id sid tid token lemma pos 35772 1 1 RELIGION religion NN 35772 1 2 AND and CC 35772 1 3 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 1 4 RELIGION religion NN 35772 1 5 AND and CC 35772 1 6 SCIENCE science NN 35772 1 7 FROM from IN 35772 1 8 GALILEO galileo NN 35772 1 9 TO to IN 35772 1 10 BERGSON BERGSON NNP 35772 1 11 BY by IN 35772 1 12 JOHN JOHN NNP 35772 1 13 CHARLTON charlton JJ 35772 1 14 HARDWICK HARDWICK NNP 35772 1 15 " " `` 35772 1 16 Philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1 17 will will MD 35772 1 18 always always RB 35772 1 19 be be VB 35772 1 20 hard hard JJ 35772 1 21 , , , 35772 1 22 and and CC 35772 1 23 what what WP 35772 1 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1 25 promises promise VBZ 35772 1 26 even even RB 35772 1 27 in in IN 35772 1 28 the the DT 35772 1 29 end end NN 35772 1 30 is be VBZ 35772 1 31 no no DT 35772 1 32 clear clear JJ 35772 1 33 theory theory NN 35772 1 34 nor nor CC 35772 1 35 any any DT 35772 1 36 complete complete JJ 35772 1 37 understanding understanding NN 35772 1 38 or or CC 35772 1 39 vision vision NN 35772 1 40 . . . 35772 2 1 But but CC 35772 2 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 2 3 certain certain JJ 35772 2 4 reward reward NN 35772 2 5 is be VBZ 35772 2 6 a a DT 35772 2 7 continual continual JJ 35772 2 8 evidence evidence NN 35772 2 9 and and CC 35772 2 10 a a DT 35772 2 11 heightened heighten VBN 35772 2 12 apprehension apprehension NN 35772 2 13 of of IN 35772 2 14 the the DT 35772 2 15 ineffable ineffable JJ 35772 2 16 mystery mystery NN 35772 2 17 of of IN 35772 2 18 life life NN 35772 2 19 , , , 35772 2 20 of of IN 35772 2 21 life life NN 35772 2 22 in in IN 35772 2 23 all all DT 35772 2 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 2 25 complexity complexity NN 35772 2 26 and and CC 35772 2 27 all all DT 35772 2 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 2 29 unity unity NN 35772 2 30 and and CC 35772 2 31 worth worth NN 35772 2 32 . . . 35772 2 33 " " '' 35772 3 1 F. F. NNP 35772 3 2 H. H. NNP 35772 3 3 BRADLEY BRADLEY NNP 35772 3 4 , , , 35772 3 5 _ _ NNP 35772 3 6 Essays Essays NNP 35772 3 7 in in IN 35772 3 8 Truth Truth NNP 35772 3 9 and and CC 35772 3 10 Reality Reality NNP 35772 3 11 _ _ NNP 35772 3 12 , , , 35772 3 13 p. p. NN 35772 3 14 106 106 CD 35772 3 15 . . . 35772 4 1 LONDON LONDON NNP 35772 4 2 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 35772 4 3 FOR for IN 35772 4 4 PROMOTING promote VBG 35772 4 5 CHRISTIAN CHRISTIAN NNP 35772 4 6 KNOWLEDGE KNOWLEDGE NNP 35772 4 7 NEW NEW NNP 35772 4 8 YORK YORK NNP 35772 4 9 : : : 35772 4 10 THE the DT 35772 4 11 MACMILLAN MACMILLAN NNP 35772 4 12 CO CO NNP 35772 4 13 . . NNP 35772 4 14 1920 1920 CD 35772 4 15 TO to IN 35772 4 16 MY my PRP$ 35772 4 17 FATHER FATHER NNP 35772 4 18 PREFACE preface VB 35772 4 19 The the DT 35772 4 20 chapters chapter NNS 35772 4 21 which which WDT 35772 4 22 follow follow VBP 35772 4 23 are be VBP 35772 4 24 not not RB 35772 4 25 intended intend VBN 35772 4 26 as as IN 35772 4 27 even even RB 35772 4 28 a a DT 35772 4 29 slight slight JJ 35772 4 30 sketch sketch NN 35772 4 31 of of IN 35772 4 32 the the DT 35772 4 33 history history NN 35772 4 34 of of IN 35772 4 35 Thought Thought NNP 35772 4 36 since since IN 35772 4 37 the the DT 35772 4 38 Renaissance Renaissance NNP 35772 4 39 . . . 35772 5 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 5 2 object object NN 35772 5 3 is be VBZ 35772 5 4 more more RBR 35772 5 5 modest modest JJ 35772 5 6 , , , 35772 5 7 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 6 1 to to TO 35772 6 2 illustrate illustrate VB 35772 6 3 the the DT 35772 6 4 thesis thesis NN 35772 6 5 that that IN 35772 6 6 mankind mankind NN 35772 6 7 , , , 35772 6 8 being be VBG 35772 6 9 " " `` 35772 6 10 incurably incurably RB 35772 6 11 religious religious JJ 35772 6 12 , , , 35772 6 13 " " '' 35772 6 14 insists insist VBZ 35772 6 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 6 16 however however RB 35772 6 17 hopeless hopeless JJ 35772 6 18 the the DT 35772 6 19 enterprise enterprise NN 35772 6 20 may may MD 35772 6 21 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 6 22 seem seem VB 35772 6 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 6 24 upon upon IN 35772 6 25 interpreting interpret VBG 35772 6 26 the the DT 35772 6 27 universe universe NN 35772 6 28 spiritually spiritually RB 35772 6 29 . . . 35772 7 1 Thus thus RB 35772 7 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 7 3 is be VBZ 35772 7 4 quite quite RB 35772 7 5 natural natural JJ 35772 7 6 that that IN 35772 7 7 only only RB 35772 7 8 a a DT 35772 7 9 few few JJ 35772 7 10 typical typical JJ 35772 7 11 names name NNS 35772 7 12 should should MD 35772 7 13 find find VB 35772 7 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 7 15 places place NNS 35772 7 16 here here RB 35772 7 17 : : : 35772 7 18 and and CC 35772 7 19 often often RB 35772 7 20 no no DT 35772 7 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 7 22 reason reason NN 35772 7 23 may may MD 35772 7 24 appear appear VB 35772 7 25 for for IN 35772 7 26 one one CD 35772 7 27 being be VBG 35772 7 28 included include VBN 35772 7 29 rather rather RB 35772 7 30 than than IN 35772 7 31 another another DT 35772 7 32 . . . 35772 8 1 For for IN 35772 8 2 instance instance NN 35772 8 3 , , , 35772 8 4 in in IN 35772 8 5 the the DT 35772 8 6 tenth tenth JJ 35772 8 7 chapter chapter NN 35772 8 8 , , , 35772 8 9 T. T. NNP 35772 8 10 H. H. NNP 35772 8 11 Green Green NNP 35772 8 12 , , , 35772 8 13 F. F. NNP 35772 8 14 H. H. NNP 35772 8 15 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 8 16 , , , 35772 8 17 and and CC 35772 8 18 A. A. NNP 35772 8 19 J. J. NNP 35772 8 20 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 8 21 are be VBP 35772 8 22 mentioned mention VBN 35772 8 23 , , , 35772 8 24 while while IN 35772 8 25 Martineau Martineau NNP 35772 8 26 and and CC 35772 8 27 the the DT 35772 8 28 Cairds Cairds NNPS 35772 8 29 are be VBP 35772 8 30 passed pass VBN 35772 8 31 over over RP 35772 8 32 . . . 35772 9 1 Needless needless JJ 35772 9 2 to to TO 35772 9 3 say say VB 35772 9 4 , , , 35772 9 5 there there EX 35772 9 6 was be VBD 35772 9 7 no no DT 35772 9 8 doctrinal doctrinal JJ 35772 9 9 prejudice prejudice NN 35772 9 10 here here RB 35772 9 11 . . . 35772 10 1 Again again RB 35772 10 2 , , , 35772 10 3 in in IN 35772 10 4 the the DT 35772 10 5 fourth fourth JJ 35772 10 6 chapter chapter NN 35772 10 7 , , , 35772 10 8 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 10 9 is be VBZ 35772 10 10 dealt deal VBN 35772 10 11 with with IN 35772 10 12 at at IN 35772 10 13 some some DT 35772 10 14 length length NN 35772 10 15 , , , 35772 10 16 but but CC 35772 10 17 Boehme Boehme NNP 35772 10 18 , , , 35772 10 19 an an DT 35772 10 20 equally equally RB 35772 10 21 important important JJ 35772 10 22 thinker thinker NN 35772 10 23 , , , 35772 10 24 is be VBZ 35772 10 25 ignored ignore VBN 35772 10 26 . . . 35772 11 1 And and CC 35772 11 2 so so RB 35772 11 3 on on RB 35772 11 4 . . . 35772 12 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 12 2 should should MD 35772 12 3 like like VB 35772 12 4 to to TO 35772 12 5 acknowledge acknowledge VB 35772 12 6 here here RB 35772 12 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 12 8 obligation obligation NN 35772 12 9 to to IN 35772 12 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 35772 12 11 Mercer Mercer NNP 35772 12 12 , , , 35772 12 13 Canon Canon NNP 35772 12 14 of of IN 35772 12 15 Chester Chester NNP 35772 12 16 , , , 35772 12 17 for for IN 35772 12 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 12 19 advice advice NN 35772 12 20 upon upon IN 35772 12 21 books book NNS 35772 12 22 , , , 35772 12 23 especially especially RB 35772 12 24 with with IN 35772 12 25 regard regard NN 35772 12 26 to to IN 35772 12 27 material material NN 35772 12 28 for for IN 35772 12 29 the the DT 35772 12 30 final final JJ 35772 12 31 chapters chapter NNS 35772 12 32 . . . 35772 13 1 Also also RB 35772 13 2 to to IN 35772 13 3 the the DT 35772 13 4 Rev. Rev. NNP 35772 14 1 H. H. NNP 35772 14 2 D. D. NNP 35772 14 3 A. A. NNP 35772 15 1 Major major JJ 35772 15 2 , , , 35772 15 3 Principal principal NN 35772 15 4 of of IN 35772 15 5 Ripon Ripon NNP 35772 15 6 Hall Hall NNP 35772 15 7 , , , 35772 15 8 for for IN 35772 15 9 suggestions suggestion NNS 35772 15 10 about about IN 35772 15 11 the the DT 35772 15 12 general general JJ 35772 15 13 plan plan NN 35772 15 14 of of IN 35772 15 15 the the DT 35772 15 16 book book NN 35772 15 17 ; ; : 35772 15 18 and and CC 35772 15 19 to to IN 35772 15 20 the the DT 35772 15 21 Rev. Rev. NNP 35772 16 1 E. E. NNP 35772 16 2 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 16 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 16 4 a a DT 35772 16 5 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 16 6 graduate graduate NN 35772 16 7 of of IN 35772 16 8 Trinity Trinity NNP 35772 16 9 College College NNP 35772 16 10 , , , 35772 16 11 Dublin Dublin NNP 35772 16 12 , , , 35772 16 13 at at IN 35772 16 14 present present JJ 35772 16 15 studying study VBG 35772 16 16 medicine medicine NN 35772 16 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 16 18 for for IN 35772 16 19 valuable valuable JJ 35772 16 20 information information NN 35772 16 21 about about IN 35772 16 22 the the DT 35772 16 23 present present JJ 35772 16 24 position position NN 35772 16 25 of of IN 35772 16 26 psychic psychic JJ 35772 16 27 research research NN 35772 16 28 . . . 35772 17 1 J. J. NNP 35772 17 2 C. C. NNP 35772 17 3 H. H. NNP 35772 17 4 ALTRINGHAM ALTRINGHAM NNP 35772 17 5 , , , 35772 17 6 _ _ NNP 35772 17 7 March March NNP 35772 17 8 23rd 23rd NN 35772 17 9 , , , 35772 17 10 1920 1920 CD 35772 17 11 _ _ NNP 35772 17 12 . . . 35772 18 1 CONTENTS content NNS 35772 18 2 CHAPTER chapter VBP 35772 18 3 I -PRON- PRP 35772 18 4 INTRODUCTORY INTRODUCTORY NNP 35772 18 5 PAGE PAGE NNP 35772 18 6 Religion Religion NNP 35772 18 7 and and CC 35772 18 8 Science Science NNP 35772 18 9 defined define VBD 35772 18 10 . . . 35772 19 1 " " `` 35772 19 2 Accurate accurate JJ 35772 19 3 and and CC 35772 19 4 systematic systematic JJ 35772 19 5 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 19 6 " " '' 35772 19 7 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 19 8 affects affect VBZ 35772 19 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 19 10 " " `` 35772 19 11 attitude attitude NN 35772 19 12 to to IN 35772 19 13 life life NN 35772 19 14 . . . 35772 19 15 " " '' 35772 20 1 Can Can MD 35772 20 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 20 3 systematised systematised JJ 35772 20 4 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 20 5 sanction sanction NN 35772 20 6 a a DT 35772 20 7 religious religious JJ 35772 20 8 attitude attitude NN 35772 20 9 ? ? . 35772 21 1 This this DT 35772 21 2 the the DT 35772 21 3 " " `` 35772 21 4 religious religious JJ 35772 21 5 problem problem NN 35772 21 6 . . . 35772 21 7 " " '' 35772 22 1 Religious religious JJ 35772 22 2 harmony harmony NN 35772 22 3 of of IN 35772 22 4 Middle Middle NNP 35772 22 5 Ages Ages NNPS 35772 22 6 . . . 35772 23 1 Will Will MD 35772 23 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 23 3 return return VB 35772 23 4 ? ? . 35772 24 1 1 1 CD 35772 24 2 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 24 3 II II NNP 35772 24 4 THE the DT 35772 24 5 DISSOLUTION dissolution NN 35772 24 6 OF of IN 35772 24 7 THE the DT 35772 24 8 OLD old JJ 35772 24 9 SYNTHESIS synthesi NNS 35772 24 10 The the DT 35772 24 11 old old JJ 35772 24 12 World World NNP 35772 24 13 - - HYPH 35772 24 14 Scheme Scheme NNP 35772 24 15 described describe VBD 35772 24 16 . . . 35772 25 1 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 25 2 and and CC 35772 25 3 Scholasticism Scholasticism NNP 35772 25 4 . . . 35772 26 1 Cusanus cusanus NN 35772 26 2 criticises criticise VBZ 35772 26 3 conventional conventional JJ 35772 26 4 ideas idea NNS 35772 26 5 of of IN 35772 26 6 space space NN 35772 26 7 . . . 35772 27 1 The the DT 35772 27 2 New New NNP 35772 27 3 Astronomy Astronomy NNP 35772 27 4 of of IN 35772 27 5 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 27 6 . . . 35772 28 1 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 28 2 and and CC 35772 28 3 an an DT 35772 28 4 infinite infinite JJ 35772 28 5 universe universe NN 35772 28 6 . . . 35772 29 1 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 29 2 's 's POS 35772 29 3 telescope telescope NN 35772 29 4 . . . 35772 30 1 The the DT 35772 30 2 New New NNP 35772 30 3 Physics Physics NNP 35772 30 4 and and CC 35772 30 5 an an DT 35772 30 6 automatic automatic JJ 35772 30 7 universe universe NN 35772 30 8 . . . 35772 31 1 The the DT 35772 31 2 New New NNP 35772 31 3 Logic Logic NNP 35772 31 4 8 8 CD 35772 31 5 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 31 6 III iii CD 35772 31 7 GROWTH GROWTH NNS 35772 31 8 OF of IN 35772 31 9 THE the DT 35772 31 10 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 31 11 THEORY THEORY VBZ 35772 31 12 The the DT 35772 31 13 New New NNP 35772 31 14 Science Science NNP 35772 31 15 creates create VBZ 35772 31 16 a a DT 35772 31 17 New New NNP 35772 31 18 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 31 19 . . . 35772 32 1 Universality Universality NNP 35772 32 2 of of IN 35772 32 3 Mechanics Mechanics NNP 35772 32 4 . . . 35772 33 1 Importance Importance NNP 35772 33 2 of of IN 35772 33 3 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 33 4 's 's POS 35772 33 5 discovery discovery NN 35772 33 6 . . . 35772 34 1 Descartes descarte NNS 35772 34 2 extends extend VBZ 35772 34 3 the the DT 35772 34 4 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 34 5 theory theory NN 35772 34 6 to to TO 35772 34 7 cover cover VB 35772 34 8 physiology physiology NN 35772 34 9 and and CC 35772 34 10 psychology psychology NN 35772 34 11 . . . 35772 35 1 Hobbes hobbe NNS 35772 35 2 and and CC 35772 35 3 a a DT 35772 35 4 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 35 5 ethic ethic NN 35772 35 6 . . . 35772 36 1 Newton Newton NNP 35772 36 2 extends extend VBZ 35772 36 3 the the DT 35772 36 4 operation operation NN 35772 36 5 of of IN 35772 36 6 law law NN 35772 36 7 from from IN 35772 36 8 the the DT 35772 36 9 earth earth NN 35772 36 10 to to IN 35772 36 11 the the DT 35772 36 12 heavens heavens NNPS 35772 36 13 . . . 35772 37 1 Religious religious JJ 35772 37 2 attitude attitude NN 35772 37 3 of of IN 35772 37 4 these these DT 35772 37 5 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 37 6 . . . 35772 38 1 Significance significance NN 35772 38 2 of of IN 35772 38 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 38 4 thought think VBN 35772 38 5 18 18 CD 35772 38 6 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 38 7 IV IV NNP 35772 38 8 SEVENTEENTH SEVENTEENTH NNP 35772 38 9 - - HYPH 35772 38 10 CENTURY CENTURY NNP 35772 38 11 REACTIONS reactions VBP 35772 38 12 A a DT 35772 38 13 Law law NN 35772 38 14 of of IN 35772 38 15 Thought Thought NNP 35772 38 16 . . . 35772 39 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 39 2 . . . 35772 40 1 A a DT 35772 40 2 Mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 40 3 Universe Universe NNP 35772 40 4 spiritually spiritually RB 35772 40 5 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 40 6 . . . 35772 41 1 _ _ NNP 35772 41 2 Natura Natura NNP 35772 41 3 Naturans Naturans NNP 35772 41 4 _ _ NNP 35772 41 5 , , , 35772 41 6 what what WP 35772 41 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 41 8 means mean VBZ 35772 41 9 . . . 35772 42 1 The the DT 35772 42 2 _ _ NNP 35772 42 3 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 42 4 _ _ NNP 35772 42 5 . . . 35772 43 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 43 2 's 's POS 35772 43 3 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 43 4 . . . 35772 44 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 44 2 personality personality NN 35772 44 3 . . . 35772 45 1 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 45 2 and and CC 35772 45 3 a a DT 35772 45 4 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 45 5 of of IN 35772 45 6 personality personality NN 35772 45 7 . . . 35772 46 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 46 2 monads monad NNS 35772 46 3 . . . 35772 47 1 Pascal pascal JJ 35772 47 2 . . . 35772 48 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 48 2 significance significance NN 35772 48 3 . . . 35772 49 1 _ _ NNP 35772 49 2 The the DT 35772 49 3 Pensées Pensées NNP 35772 49 4 . . . 35772 49 5 _ _ NNP 35772 49 6 The the DT 35772 49 7 eternal eternal JJ 35772 49 8 protest protest NN 35772 49 9 of of IN 35772 49 10 religion religion NN 35772 49 11 . . . 35772 50 1 Man man NN 35772 50 2 defies defy VBZ 35772 50 3 the the DT 35772 50 4 universe universe NN 35772 50 5 . . . 35772 51 1 Results result NNS 35772 51 2 28 28 CD 35772 51 3 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 51 4 V v NN 35772 51 5 RISE rise NN 35772 51 6 OF of IN 35772 51 7 AN an DT 35772 51 8 ANTI anti JJ 35772 51 9 - - HYPH 35772 51 10 RELIGIOUS religious JJ 35772 51 11 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 51 12 Anti Anti NNP 35772 51 13 - - NN 35772 51 14 clericalism clericalism NN 35772 51 15 in in IN 35772 51 16 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 51 17 - - HYPH 35772 51 18 century century NN 35772 51 19 France France NNP 35772 51 20 . . . 35772 52 1 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 52 2 's 's POS 35772 52 3 propaganda propaganda NN 35772 52 4 . . . 35772 53 1 Diderot Diderot NNS 35772 53 2 and and CC 35772 53 3 the the DT 35772 53 4 Encyclopædists Encyclopædists NNPS 35772 53 5 . . . 35772 54 1 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 54 2 's 's POS 35772 54 3 _ _ NNP 35772 54 4 System System NNP 35772 54 5 of of IN 35772 54 6 Nature Nature NNP 35772 54 7 _ _ NNP 35772 54 8 . . . 35772 55 1 Laplace Laplace NNP 35772 55 2 's 's POS 35772 55 3 astronomy astronomy NN 35772 55 4 . . . 35772 56 1 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 56 2 and and CC 35772 56 3 the the DT 35772 56 4 New New NNP 35772 56 5 Chemistry Chemistry NNP 35772 56 6 . . . 35772 57 1 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 57 2 's 's POS 35772 57 3 atomic atomic JJ 35772 57 4 theory theory NN 35772 57 5 . . . 35772 58 1 Results result NNS 35772 58 2 for for IN 35772 58 3 religion religion NN 35772 58 4 42 42 CD 35772 58 5 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 58 6 VI VI NNP 35772 58 7 RISE RISE NNP 35772 58 8 OF of IN 35772 58 9 GERMAN german JJ 35772 58 10 IDEALISM IDEALISM NNP 35772 58 11 Importance Importance NNP 35772 58 12 , , , 35772 58 13 for for IN 35772 58 14 the the DT 35772 58 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 58 16 view view NN 35772 58 17 , , , 35772 58 18 of of IN 35772 58 19 Locke Locke NNP 35772 58 20 's 's POS 35772 58 21 theory theory NN 35772 58 22 of of IN 35772 58 23 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 58 24 . . . 35772 59 1 Weakness weakness NN 35772 59 2 of of IN 35772 59 3 speculative speculative JJ 35772 59 4 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 59 5 . . . 35772 60 1 Rise rise NN 35772 60 2 of of IN 35772 60 3 the the DT 35772 60 4 " " `` 35772 60 5 critical critical JJ 35772 60 6 " " '' 35772 60 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 60 8 . . . 35772 61 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 61 2 . . . 35772 62 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 62 2 seeks seek VBZ 35772 62 3 to to TO 35772 62 4 solve solve VB 35772 62 5 the the DT 35772 62 6 problem problem NN 35772 62 7 : : : 35772 62 8 How how WRB 35772 62 9 is be VBZ 35772 62 10 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 62 11 possible possible JJ 35772 62 12 ? ? . 35772 63 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 63 2 's 's POS 35772 63 3 view view NN 35772 63 4 of of IN 35772 63 5 the the DT 35772 63 6 mind mind NN 35772 63 7 's 's POS 35772 63 8 function function NN 35772 63 9 in in IN 35772 63 10 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 63 11 . . . 35772 64 1 Mechanism Mechanism NNP 35772 64 2 a a DT 35772 64 3 " " `` 35772 64 4 form form NN 35772 64 5 of of IN 35772 64 6 thought thought NN 35772 64 7 , , , 35772 64 8 " " '' 35772 64 9 subjective subjective JJ 35772 64 10 not not RB 35772 64 11 objective objective JJ 35772 64 12 . . . 35772 65 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 65 2 's 's POS 35772 65 3 view view NN 35772 65 4 of of IN 35772 65 5 reality reality NN 35772 65 6 . . . 35772 66 1 Can Can MD 35772 66 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 66 3 know know VB 35772 66 4 reality reality NN 35772 66 5 ? ? . 35772 67 1 The the DT 35772 67 2 two two CD 35772 67 3 worlds world NNS 35772 67 4 52 52 CD 35772 67 5 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 67 6 VII vii NN 35772 67 7 THE the DT 35772 67 8 ROMANTIC romantic NN 35772 67 9 MOVEMENT MOVEMENT NNP 35772 67 10 Kant Kant NNP 35772 67 11 clears clear VBZ 35772 67 12 the the DT 35772 67 13 ground ground NN 35772 67 14 for for IN 35772 67 15 a a DT 35772 67 16 new new JJ 35772 67 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 67 18 . . . 35772 68 1 Significance significance NN 35772 68 2 of of IN 35772 68 3 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 68 4 . . . 35772 69 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 69 2 attitude attitude NN 35772 69 3 to to IN 35772 69 4 culture culture NN 35772 69 5 . . . 35772 70 1 The the DT 35772 70 2 new new JJ 35772 70 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 70 4 in in IN 35772 70 5 Germany Germany NNP 35772 70 6 , , , 35772 70 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 70 8 goal goal NN 35772 70 9 . . . 35772 71 1 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 71 2 . . . 35772 72 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 72 2 a a DT 35772 72 3 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 35772 72 4 - - HYPH 35772 72 5 romanticist romanticist NN 35772 72 6 . . . 35772 73 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 73 2 method method NN 35772 73 3 . . . 35772 74 1 Hegelianism Hegelianism NNP 35772 74 2 . . . 35772 75 1 Significance significance NN 35772 75 2 for for IN 35772 75 3 religious religious JJ 35772 75 4 thought thought NN 35772 75 5 of of IN 35772 75 6 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 75 7 . . . 35772 76 1 The the DT 35772 76 2 autonomy autonomy NN 35772 76 3 of of IN 35772 76 4 religion religion NN 35772 76 5 and and CC 35772 76 6 religious religious JJ 35772 76 7 experience experience NN 35772 76 8 62 62 CD 35772 76 9 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 76 10 VIII viii NN 35772 76 11 MECHANISM MECHANISM NNP 35772 76 12 AND and CC 35772 76 13 LIFE LIFE NNP 35772 76 14 Rise Rise NNP 35772 76 15 of of IN 35772 76 16 bio bio JJ 35772 76 17 - - NN 35772 76 18 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 76 19 and and CC 35772 76 20 bio bio NN 35772 76 21 - - NN 35772 76 22 physics physics NN 35772 76 23 in in IN 35772 76 24 Germany Germany NNP 35772 76 25 . . . 35772 77 1 Significance significance NN 35772 77 2 of of IN 35772 77 3 these these DT 35772 77 4 movements movement NNS 35772 77 5 . . . 35772 78 1 The the DT 35772 78 2 Origin Origin NNP 35772 78 3 of of IN 35772 78 4 Species Species NNP 35772 78 5 . . . 35772 79 1 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 79 2 . . . 35772 80 1 The the DT 35772 80 2 new new JJ 35772 80 3 geology geology NN 35772 80 4 . . . 35772 81 1 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 81 2 . . . 35772 82 1 Results result NNS 35772 82 2 of of IN 35772 82 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 82 4 theory theory NN 35772 82 5 74 74 CD 35772 82 6 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 82 7 IX IX NNP 35772 82 8 MATERIALISM MATERIALISM NNP 35772 82 9 AND and CC 35772 82 10 AGNOSTICISM AGNOSTICISM NNP 35772 82 11 Early early JJ 35772 82 12 decline decline NN 35772 82 13 of of IN 35772 82 14 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 82 15 in in IN 35772 82 16 Germany Germany NNP 35772 82 17 . . . 35772 83 1 Comte Comte NNP 35772 83 2 and and CC 35772 83 3 the the DT 35772 83 4 " " `` 35772 83 5 positive positive JJ 35772 83 6 " " '' 35772 83 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 83 8 . . . 35772 84 1 Materialism Materialism NNP 35772 84 2 in in IN 35772 84 3 Germany Germany NNP 35772 84 4 . . . 35772 85 1 Darwinism darwinism NN 35772 85 2 and and CC 35772 85 3 the the DT 35772 85 4 " " `` 35772 85 5 argument argument NN 35772 85 6 from from IN 35772 85 7 design design NN 35772 85 8 . . . 35772 85 9 " " '' 35772 86 1 Haeckel Haeckel NNP 35772 86 2 . . . 35772 87 1 Spencerian spencerian JJ 35772 87 2 evolutionism evolutionism NN 35772 87 3 . . . 35772 88 1 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 88 2 's 's POS 35772 88 3 moral moral JJ 35772 88 4 idealism idealism NN 35772 88 5 . . . 35772 89 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 89 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 89 3 of of IN 35772 89 4 religion religion NN 35772 89 5 . . . 35772 90 1 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 90 2 . . . 35772 91 1 Rise rise NN 35772 91 2 of of IN 35772 91 3 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 91 4 pessimism pessimism NN 35772 91 5 . . . 35772 92 1 Significance significance NN 35772 92 2 of of IN 35772 92 3 Nietzsche Nietzsche NNP 35772 92 4 84 84 CD 35772 92 5 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 92 6 X x NN 35772 92 7 REACTIONS reaction NNS 35772 92 8 IN in IN 35772 92 9 PHILOSOPHY philosophy JJ 35772 92 10 German german JJ 35772 92 11 idealism idealism NN 35772 92 12 naturalised naturalise VBD 35772 92 13 in in IN 35772 92 14 England England NNP 35772 92 15 by by IN 35772 92 16 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 92 17 and and CC 35772 92 18 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 92 19 . . . 35772 93 1 These these DT 35772 93 2 writers writer NNS 35772 93 3 described describe VBD 35772 93 4 . . . 35772 94 1 _ _ NNP 35772 94 2 Sartor Sartor NNP 35772 94 3 Resartus Resartus NNP 35772 94 4 . . . 35772 94 5 _ _ NNP 35772 94 6 Idealism Idealism NNP 35772 94 7 at at IN 35772 94 8 Oxford Oxford NNP 35772 94 9 , , , 35772 94 10 T. T. NNP 35772 94 11 H. H. NNP 35772 94 12 Green Green NNP 35772 94 13 . . . 35772 95 1 F. F. NNP 35772 95 2 H. H. NNP 35772 95 3 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 95 4 . . . 35772 96 1 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 96 2 's 's POS 35772 96 3 plea plea NN 35772 96 4 for for IN 35772 96 5 a a DT 35772 96 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 96 7 of of IN 35772 96 8 science science NN 35772 96 9 . . . 35772 97 1 Revival revival NN 35772 97 2 of of IN 35772 97 3 Idealism Idealism NNP 35772 97 4 in in IN 35772 97 5 Germany Germany NNP 35772 97 6 . . . 35772 98 1 Lotze Lotze NNS 35772 98 2 . . . 35772 99 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 99 2 view view NN 35772 99 3 of of IN 35772 99 4 " " `` 35772 99 5 values value NNS 35772 99 6 " " '' 35772 99 7 and and CC 35772 99 8 reality reality NN 35772 99 9 98 98 CD 35772 99 10 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 99 11 XI xi NN 35772 99 12 SOME some VBP 35772 99 13 RECENT recent JJ 35772 99 14 TENDENCIES tendency NNS 35772 99 15 IN in IN 35772 99 16 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 35772 99 17 A a DT 35772 99 18 new new JJ 35772 99 19 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 99 20 of of IN 35772 99 21 Science Science NNP 35772 99 22 . . . 35772 100 1 Mach mach JJ 35772 100 2 on on IN 35772 100 3 " " `` 35772 100 4 Economy Economy NNP 35772 100 5 of of IN 35772 100 6 Thought Thought NNP 35772 100 7 . . . 35772 100 8 " " '' 35772 101 1 " " `` 35772 101 2 Abstractness Abstractness NNP 35772 101 3 " " '' 35772 101 4 and and CC 35772 101 5 artificiality artificiality NN 35772 101 6 of of IN 35772 101 7 scientific scientific JJ 35772 101 8 method method NN 35772 101 9 . . . 35772 102 1 Boutroux boutroux NN 35772 102 2 and and CC 35772 102 3 natural natural JJ 35772 102 4 law law NN 35772 102 5 . . . 35772 103 1 James James NNP 35772 103 2 ' ' POS 35772 103 3 view view NN 35772 103 4 of of IN 35772 103 5 the the DT 35772 103 6 mind mind NN 35772 103 7 carried carry VBN 35772 103 8 further further RB 35772 103 9 by by IN 35772 103 10 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 103 11 . . . 35772 104 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 104 2 view view NN 35772 104 3 of of IN 35772 104 4 the the DT 35772 104 5 intellect intellect NN 35772 104 6 . . . 35772 105 1 What what WP 35772 105 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 105 3 can can MD 35772 105 4 , , , 35772 105 5 and and CC 35772 105 6 what what WP 35772 105 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 105 8 can can MD 35772 105 9 not not RB 35772 105 10 , , , 35772 105 11 do do VB 35772 105 12 for for IN 35772 105 13 us -PRON- PRP 35772 105 14 . . . 35772 106 1 Intuition intuition NN 35772 106 2 . . . 35772 107 1 Indeterminism Indeterminism NNP 35772 107 2 and and CC 35772 107 3 Pluralism Pluralism NNP 35772 107 4 . . . 35772 108 1 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 108 2 revived revive VBD 35772 108 3 . . . 35772 109 1 Ward Ward NNP 35772 109 2 's 's POS 35772 109 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 109 4 of of IN 35772 109 5 personality personality NN 35772 109 6 110 110 CD 35772 109 7 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 109 8 XII xii NN 35772 109 9 SOME some NN 35772 109 10 RECENT recent JJ 35772 109 11 TENDENCIES tendency NNS 35772 109 12 IN in IN 35772 109 13 SCIENCE science NN 35772 109 14 The the DT 35772 109 15 " " `` 35772 109 16 New new JJ 35772 109 17 " " '' 35772 109 18 Physics physics NN 35772 109 19 . . . 35772 110 1 New new JJ 35772 110 2 theories theory NNS 35772 110 3 of of IN 35772 110 4 matter matter NN 35772 110 5 . . . 35772 111 1 The the DT 35772 111 2 " " `` 35772 111 3 New New NNP 35772 111 4 " " '' 35772 111 5 Biology biology NN 35772 111 6 . . . 35772 112 1 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 112 2 and and CC 35772 112 3 neo neo NN 35772 112 4 - - HYPH 35772 112 5 vitalism vitalism NN 35772 112 6 . . . 35772 113 1 The the DT 35772 113 2 " " `` 35772 113 3 New New NNP 35772 113 4 " " '' 35772 113 5 Psychology psychology NN 35772 113 6 . . . 35772 114 1 " " `` 35772 114 2 Spiritualism spiritualism NN 35772 114 3 . . . 35772 114 4 " " '' 35772 115 1 The the DT 35772 115 2 outlook outlook NN 35772 115 3 for for IN 35772 115 4 the the DT 35772 115 5 future future JJ 35772 115 6 125 125 CD 35772 115 7 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 115 8 XIII xiii NN 35772 115 9 SOME some NN 35772 115 10 FINAL final JJ 35772 115 11 CONSIDERATIONS considerations NN 35772 115 12 History history NN 35772 115 13 of of IN 35772 115 14 Thought thought NN 35772 115 15 supplies supply NNS 35772 115 16 no no DT 35772 115 17 material material NN 35772 115 18 for for IN 35772 115 19 dogmatising dogmatise VBG 35772 115 20 . . . 35772 116 1 Yet yet RB 35772 116 2 a a DT 35772 116 3 progress progress NN 35772 116 4 of of IN 35772 116 5 ideas idea NNS 35772 116 6 is be VBZ 35772 116 7 evident evident JJ 35772 116 8 . . . 35772 117 1 Permanency permanency NN 35772 117 2 of of IN 35772 117 3 " " `` 35772 117 4 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 117 5 " " '' 35772 117 6 view view NN 35772 117 7 of of IN 35772 117 8 reality reality NN 35772 117 9 . . . 35772 118 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 118 2 continual continual JJ 35772 118 3 revival revival NN 35772 118 4 . . . 35772 119 1 Sabatier Sabatier NNP 35772 119 2 's 's POS 35772 119 3 saying saying NN 35772 119 4 . . . 35772 120 1 Need need NN 35772 120 2 of of IN 35772 120 3 freedom freedom NN 35772 120 4 , , , 35772 120 5 alike alike RB 35772 120 6 for for IN 35772 120 7 religion religion NN 35772 120 8 and and CC 35772 120 9 for for IN 35772 120 10 science science NN 35772 120 11 137 137 CD 35772 120 12 RELIGION RELIGION NNS 35772 120 13 AND and CC 35772 120 14 SCIENCE science NN 35772 120 15 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 120 16 I -PRON- PRP 35772 120 17 INTRODUCTORY INTRODUCTORY NNP 35772 120 18 . . . 35772 121 1 RELIGION religion NN 35772 121 2 AND and CC 35772 121 3 SCIENCE science NN 35772 121 4 Numerous numerous JJ 35772 121 5 attempts attempt NNS 35772 121 6 to to TO 35772 121 7 define define VB 35772 121 8 religion religion NN 35772 121 9 have have VBP 35772 121 10 made make VBN 35772 121 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 121 12 evident evident JJ 35772 121 13 that that IN 35772 121 14 religion religion NN 35772 121 15 is be VBZ 35772 121 16 indefinable indefinable JJ 35772 121 17 . . . 35772 122 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 122 2 may may MD 35772 122 3 , , , 35772 122 4 however however RB 35772 122 5 , , , 35772 122 6 say say VB 35772 122 7 this this DT 35772 122 8 much much JJ 35772 122 9 about about IN 35772 122 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 122 11 , , , 35772 122 12 that that IN 35772 122 13 religion religion NN 35772 122 14 is be VBZ 35772 122 15 _ _ NNP 35772 122 16 an an DT 35772 122 17 attitude attitude NN 35772 122 18 towards towards IN 35772 122 19 life life NN 35772 122 20 _ _ NN 35772 122 21 : : : 35772 122 22 a a DT 35772 122 23 way way NN 35772 122 24 of of IN 35772 122 25 looking look VBG 35772 122 26 at at IN 35772 122 27 existence existence NN 35772 122 28 . . . 35772 123 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 123 2 is be VBZ 35772 123 3 true true JJ 35772 123 4 that that IN 35772 123 5 this this DT 35772 123 6 definition definition NN 35772 123 7 is be VBZ 35772 123 8 too too RB 35772 123 9 wide wide JJ 35772 123 10 , , , 35772 123 11 and and CC 35772 123 12 includes include VBZ 35772 123 13 things thing NNS 35772 123 14 which which WDT 35772 123 15 are be VBP 35772 123 16 not not RB 35772 123 17 religion religion NN 35772 123 18 -- -- : 35772 123 19 there there EX 35772 123 20 are be VBP 35772 123 21 certain certain JJ 35772 123 22 attitudes attitude NNS 35772 123 23 to to IN 35772 123 24 life life NN 35772 123 25 which which WDT 35772 123 26 are be VBP 35772 123 27 definitely definitely RB 35772 123 28 anti anti JJ 35772 123 29 - - JJ 35772 123 30 religious religious JJ 35772 123 31 -- -- : 35772 123 32 that that DT 35772 123 33 of of IN 35772 123 34 the the DT 35772 123 35 materialist materialist NN 35772 123 36 , , , 35772 123 37 for for IN 35772 123 38 instance instance NN 35772 123 39 . . . 35772 124 1 However however RB 35772 124 2 , , , 35772 124 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 124 4 will will MD 35772 124 5 serve serve VB 35772 124 6 a a DT 35772 124 7 purpose purpose NN 35772 124 8 , , , 35772 124 9 and and CC 35772 124 10 we -PRON- PRP 35772 124 11 can can MD 35772 124 12 improve improve VB 35772 124 13 upon upon IN 35772 124 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 124 15 as as IN 35772 124 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 124 17 proceed proceed VBP 35772 124 18 . . . 35772 125 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 125 2 is be VBZ 35772 125 3 a a DT 35772 125 4 mistake mistake NN 35772 125 5 to to TO 35772 125 6 put put VB 35772 125 7 too too RB 35772 125 8 much much JJ 35772 125 9 faith faith NN 35772 125 10 in in IN 35772 125 11 definitions definition NNS 35772 125 12 : : : 35772 125 13 at at IN 35772 125 14 any any DT 35772 125 15 rate rate NN 35772 125 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 125 17 is be VBZ 35772 125 18 better well JJR 35772 125 19 to to TO 35772 125 20 have have VB 35772 125 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 125 22 definitions definition NNS 35772 125 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 125 24 if if IN 35772 125 25 have have VBP 35772 125 26 them -PRON- PRP 35772 125 27 we -PRON- PRP 35772 125 28 must must MD 35772 125 29 ) ) -RRB- 35772 125 30 too too RB 35772 125 31 wide wide JJ 35772 125 32 than than IN 35772 125 33 too too RB 35772 125 34 narrow narrow JJ 35772 125 35 . . . 35772 126 1 Science science NN 35772 126 2 is be VBZ 35772 126 3 , , , 35772 126 4 fortunately fortunately RB 35772 126 5 , , , 35772 126 6 much much RB 35772 126 7 easier easy JJR 35772 126 8 to to TO 35772 126 9 define define VB 35772 126 10 . . . 35772 127 1 _ _ NNP 35772 127 2 Accurate accurate JJ 35772 127 3 and and CC 35772 127 4 systematic systematic JJ 35772 127 5 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 127 6 _ _ NNP 35772 127 7 is be VBZ 35772 127 8 what what WP 35772 127 9 we -PRON- PRP 35772 127 10 mean mean VBP 35772 127 11 by by IN 35772 127 12 science science NN 35772 127 13 -- -- : 35772 127 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 127 15 about about IN 35772 127 16 anything anything NN 35772 127 17 , , , 35772 127 18 provided provide VBN 35772 127 19 that that IN 35772 127 20 the the DT 35772 127 21 facts fact NNS 35772 127 22 are be VBP 35772 127 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 127 24 so so RB 35772 127 25 far far RB 35772 127 26 as as IN 35772 127 27 possible possible JJ 35772 127 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 127 29 accurately accurately RB 35772 127 30 described describe VBN 35772 127 31 and and CC 35772 127 32 systematically systematically RB 35772 127 33 classified classified JJ 35772 127 34 . . . 35772 128 1 Professor Professor NNP 35772 128 2 Karl Karl NNP 35772 128 3 Pearson Pearson NNP 35772 128 4 , , , 35772 128 5 the the DT 35772 128 6 highest high JJS 35772 128 7 authority authority NN 35772 128 8 on on IN 35772 128 9 the the DT 35772 128 10 principles principle NNS 35772 128 11 of of IN 35772 128 12 scientific scientific JJ 35772 128 13 method method NN 35772 128 14 and and CC 35772 128 15 theory theory NN 35772 128 16 , , , 35772 128 17 writes write VBZ 35772 128 18 : : : 35772 128 19 " " `` 35772 128 20 The the DT 35772 128 21 man man NN 35772 128 22 who who WP 35772 128 23 classifies classify VBZ 35772 128 24 facts fact NNS 35772 128 25 of of IN 35772 128 26 any any DT 35772 128 27 kind kind NN 35772 128 28 whatever whatever WDT 35772 128 29 , , , 35772 128 30 who who WP 35772 128 31 sees see VBZ 35772 128 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 128 33 mutual mutual JJ 35772 128 34 relation relation NN 35772 128 35 and and CC 35772 128 36 describes describe VBZ 35772 128 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 128 38 sequences sequence NNS 35772 128 39 , , , 35772 128 40 is be VBZ 35772 128 41 applying apply VBG 35772 128 42 the the DT 35772 128 43 scientific scientific JJ 35772 128 44 method method NN 35772 128 45 and and CC 35772 128 46 is be VBZ 35772 128 47 a a DT 35772 128 48 man man NN 35772 128 49 of of IN 35772 128 50 science science NN 35772 128 51 . . . 35772 129 1 The the DT 35772 129 2 facts fact NNS 35772 129 3 may may MD 35772 129 4 belong belong VB 35772 129 5 to to IN 35772 129 6 the the DT 35772 129 7 past past JJ 35772 129 8 history history NN 35772 129 9 of of IN 35772 129 10 mankind mankind NN 35772 129 11 , , , 35772 129 12 to to IN 35772 129 13 the the DT 35772 129 14 social social JJ 35772 129 15 statistics statistic NNS 35772 129 16 of of IN 35772 129 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 129 18 great great JJ 35772 129 19 cities city NNS 35772 129 20 , , , 35772 129 21 to to IN 35772 129 22 the the DT 35772 129 23 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 129 24 of of IN 35772 129 25 the the DT 35772 129 26 most most RBS 35772 129 27 distant distant JJ 35772 129 28 stars star NNS 35772 129 29 , , , 35772 129 30 to to IN 35772 129 31 the the DT 35772 129 32 digestive digestive JJ 35772 129 33 organs organ NNS 35772 129 34 of of IN 35772 129 35 a a DT 35772 129 36 worm worm NN 35772 129 37 , , , 35772 129 38 or or CC 35772 129 39 to to IN 35772 129 40 the the DT 35772 129 41 life life NN 35772 129 42 of of IN 35772 129 43 a a DT 35772 129 44 scarcely scarcely RB 35772 129 45 visible visible JJ 35772 129 46 bacillus bacillus NN 35772 129 47 . . . 35772 130 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 130 2 is be VBZ 35772 130 3 not not RB 35772 130 4 facts fact NNS 35772 130 5 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 130 6 which which WDT 35772 130 7 make make VBP 35772 130 8 science science NN 35772 130 9 , , , 35772 130 10 but but CC 35772 130 11 the the DT 35772 130 12 method method NN 35772 130 13 by by IN 35772 130 14 which which WDT 35772 130 15 they -PRON- PRP 35772 130 16 are be VBP 35772 130 17 dealt deal VBN 35772 130 18 with with IN 35772 130 19 . . . 35772 131 1 The the DT 35772 131 2 material material NN 35772 131 3 of of IN 35772 131 4 science science NN 35772 131 5 is be VBZ 35772 131 6 co co JJ 35772 131 7 - - JJ 35772 131 8 extensive extensive JJ 35772 131 9 with with IN 35772 131 10 the the DT 35772 131 11 whole whole JJ 35772 131 12 physical physical JJ 35772 131 13 universe universe NN 35772 131 14 , , , 35772 131 15 not not RB 35772 131 16 only only RB 35772 131 17 that that DT 35772 131 18 universe universe NN 35772 131 19 as as IN 35772 131 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 131 21 now now RB 35772 131 22 exists exist VBZ 35772 131 23 , , , 35772 131 24 but but CC 35772 131 25 with with IN 35772 131 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 131 27 past past JJ 35772 131 28 history history NN 35772 131 29 and and CC 35772 131 30 the the DT 35772 131 31 past past JJ 35772 131 32 history history NN 35772 131 33 of of IN 35772 131 34 all all DT 35772 131 35 life life NN 35772 131 36 therein therein RB 35772 131 37 . . . 35772 132 1 When when WRB 35772 132 2 every every DT 35772 132 3 fact fact NN 35772 132 4 , , , 35772 132 5 every every DT 35772 132 6 present present JJ 35772 132 7 or or CC 35772 132 8 past past JJ 35772 132 9 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 132 10 of of IN 35772 132 11 that that DT 35772 132 12 universe universe NN 35772 132 13 , , , 35772 132 14 every every DT 35772 132 15 phase phase NN 35772 132 16 of of IN 35772 132 17 present present JJ 35772 132 18 or or CC 35772 132 19 past past JJ 35772 132 20 life life NN 35772 132 21 therein therein RB 35772 132 22 , , , 35772 132 23 has have VBZ 35772 132 24 been be VBN 35772 132 25 classified classify VBN 35772 132 26 , , , 35772 132 27 and and CC 35772 132 28 co co NNS 35772 132 29 - - VBN 35772 132 30 ordinated ordinated JJ 35772 132 31 with with IN 35772 132 32 the the DT 35772 132 33 rest rest NN 35772 132 34 , , , 35772 132 35 then then RB 35772 132 36 the the DT 35772 132 37 mission mission NN 35772 132 38 of of IN 35772 132 39 science science NN 35772 132 40 will will MD 35772 132 41 be be VB 35772 132 42 completed complete VBN 35772 132 43 . . . 35772 133 1 " " `` 35772 133 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 133 3 1 1 CD 35772 133 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 133 5 Science science NN 35772 133 6 , , , 35772 133 7 then then RB 35772 133 8 , , , 35772 133 9 is be VBZ 35772 133 10 systematic systematic JJ 35772 133 11 and and CC 35772 133 12 accurate accurate JJ 35772 133 13 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 133 14 ; ; : 35772 133 15 and and CC 35772 133 16 when when WRB 35772 133 17 we -PRON- PRP 35772 133 18 have have VBP 35772 133 19 systematic systematic JJ 35772 133 20 and and CC 35772 133 21 accurate accurate JJ 35772 133 22 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 133 23 about about IN 35772 133 24 everything everything NN 35772 133 25 there there EX 35772 133 26 is be VBZ 35772 133 27 to to TO 35772 133 28 be be VB 35772 133 29 known know VBN 35772 133 30 , , , 35772 133 31 the the DT 35772 133 32 programme programme NN 35772 133 33 of of IN 35772 133 34 science science NN 35772 133 35 will will MD 35772 133 36 be be VB 35772 133 37 complete complete JJ 35772 133 38 . . . 35772 134 1 This this DT 35772 134 2 is be VBZ 35772 134 3 only only RB 35772 134 4 to to TO 35772 134 5 say say VB 35772 134 6 that that IN 35772 134 7 the the DT 35772 134 8 task task NN 35772 134 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 134 10 has have VBZ 35772 134 11 set set VBN 35772 134 12 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 134 13 is be VBZ 35772 134 14 one one CD 35772 134 15 that that WDT 35772 134 16 will will MD 35772 134 17 never never RB 35772 134 18 end end VB 35772 134 19 . . . 35772 135 1 So so RB 35772 135 2 much much RB 35772 135 3 , , , 35772 135 4 then then RB 35772 135 5 , , , 35772 135 6 for for IN 35772 135 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 135 8 definitions definition NNS 35772 135 9 . . . 35772 136 1 Religion religion NN 35772 136 2 is be VBZ 35772 136 3 " " `` 35772 136 4 an an DT 35772 136 5 attitude attitude NN 35772 136 6 to to IN 35772 136 7 life life NN 35772 136 8 " " '' 35772 136 9 : : : 35772 136 10 science science NN 35772 136 11 is be VBZ 35772 136 12 " " `` 35772 136 13 systematic systematic JJ 35772 136 14 and and CC 35772 136 15 accurate accurate JJ 35772 136 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 136 17 . . . 35772 136 18 " " '' 35772 137 1 How how WRB 35772 137 2 does do VBZ 35772 137 3 the the DT 35772 137 4 one one CD 35772 137 5 affect affect VB 35772 137 6 the the DT 35772 137 7 other other JJ 35772 137 8 ? ? . 35772 138 1 What what WP 35772 138 2 are be VBP 35772 138 3 the the DT 35772 138 4 relations relation NNS 35772 138 5 between between IN 35772 138 6 the the DT 35772 138 7 two two CD 35772 138 8 ? ? . 35772 139 1 That that DT 35772 139 2 is be VBZ 35772 139 3 the the DT 35772 139 4 topic topic NN 35772 139 5 which which WDT 35772 139 6 will will MD 35772 139 7 occupy occupy VB 35772 139 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 139 9 attention attention NN 35772 139 10 during during IN 35772 139 11 the the DT 35772 139 12 chapters chapter NNS 35772 139 13 that that WDT 35772 139 14 follow follow VBP 35772 139 15 . . . 35772 140 1 To to TO 35772 140 2 answer answer VB 35772 140 3 the the DT 35772 140 4 question question NN 35772 140 5 properly properly RB 35772 140 6 will will MD 35772 140 7 involve involve VB 35772 140 8 a a DT 35772 140 9 certain certain JJ 35772 140 10 amount amount NN 35772 140 11 of of IN 35772 140 12 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 140 13 with with IN 35772 140 14 the the DT 35772 140 15 history history NN 35772 140 16 of of IN 35772 140 17 ideas idea NNS 35772 140 18 . . . 35772 141 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 141 2 must must MD 35772 141 3 first first RB 35772 141 4 put put VB 35772 141 5 the the DT 35772 141 6 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 141 7 question question NN 35772 141 8 : : : 35772 141 9 How how WRB 35772 141 10 , , , 35772 141 11 as as IN 35772 141 12 a a DT 35772 141 13 matter matter NN 35772 141 14 of of IN 35772 141 15 fact fact NN 35772 141 16 , , , 35772 141 17 have have VBP 35772 141 18 men man NNS 35772 141 19 's 's POS 35772 141 20 scientific scientific JJ 35772 141 21 ideas idea NNS 35772 141 22 affected affect VBD 35772 141 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 141 24 religious religious JJ 35772 141 25 ideas idea NNS 35772 141 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 141 27 or or CC 35772 141 28 _ _ NNP 35772 141 29 vice vice NN 35772 141 30 versa versa NNP 35772 141 31 _ _ NNP 35772 141 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 141 33 in in IN 35772 141 34 times time NNS 35772 141 35 past past JJ 35772 141 36 ? ? . 35772 142 1 Having have VBG 35772 142 2 tried try VBN 35772 142 3 to to TO 35772 142 4 answer answer VB 35772 142 5 this this DT 35772 142 6 question question NN 35772 142 7 , , , 35772 142 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 142 9 shall shall MD 35772 142 10 be be VB 35772 142 11 in in IN 35772 142 12 a a DT 35772 142 13 better well JJR 35772 142 14 position position NN 35772 142 15 to to TO 35772 142 16 approach approach VB 35772 142 17 the the DT 35772 142 18 religious religious JJ 35772 142 19 problem problem NN 35772 142 20 as as IN 35772 142 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 142 22 presents present VBZ 35772 142 23 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 142 24 to to IN 35772 142 25 - - HYPH 35772 142 26 day day NN 35772 142 27 . . . 35772 143 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 35772 143 2 a a DT 35772 143 3 few few JJ 35772 143 4 remarks remark NNS 35772 143 5 of of IN 35772 143 6 a a DT 35772 143 7 general general JJ 35772 143 8 character character NN 35772 143 9 will will MD 35772 143 10 not not RB 35772 143 11 be be VB 35772 143 12 out out IN 35772 143 13 of of IN 35772 143 14 place place NN 35772 143 15 . . . 35772 144 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 144 2 is be VBZ 35772 144 3 evident evident JJ 35772 144 4 that that IN 35772 144 5 " " `` 35772 144 6 science science NN 35772 144 7 " " '' 35772 144 8 can can MD 35772 144 9 hardly hardly RB 35772 144 10 fail fail VB 35772 144 11 to to TO 35772 144 12 affect affect VB 35772 144 13 " " `` 35772 144 14 religion religion NN 35772 144 15 . . . 35772 144 16 " " '' 35772 145 1 Systematised systematise VBN 35772 145 2 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 145 3 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 145 4 affects affect VBZ 35772 145 5 an an DT 35772 145 6 individual individual NN 35772 145 7 's 's POS 35772 145 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 145 9 or or CC 35772 145 10 a a DT 35772 145 11 society society NN 35772 145 12 's 's POS 35772 145 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 145 14 attitude attitude NN 35772 145 15 to to IN 35772 145 16 life life NN 35772 145 17 -- -- : 35772 145 18 either either CC 35772 145 19 by by IN 35772 145 20 broadening broaden VBG 35772 145 21 and and CC 35772 145 22 elevating elevate VBG 35772 145 23 that that DT 35772 145 24 attitude attitude NN 35772 145 25 , , , 35772 145 26 or or CC 35772 145 27 by by IN 35772 145 28 debasing debase VBG 35772 145 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 145 30 . . . 35772 146 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 146 2 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 146 3 , , , 35772 146 4 or or CC 35772 146 5 what what WP 35772 146 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 146 7 believe believe VBP 35772 146 8 to to TO 35772 146 9 be be VB 35772 146 10 such such JJ 35772 146 11 , , , 35772 146 12 tends tend VBZ 35772 146 13 to to TO 35772 146 14 create create VB 35772 146 15 certain certain JJ 35772 146 16 preconceptions preconception NNS 35772 146 17 which which WDT 35772 146 18 make make VBP 35772 146 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 146 20 minds mind NNS 35772 146 21 hostile hostile JJ 35772 146 22 to to IN 35772 146 23 certain certain JJ 35772 146 24 beliefs belief NNS 35772 146 25 or or CC 35772 146 26 ideas idea NNS 35772 146 27 . . . 35772 147 1 A a DT 35772 147 2 man man NN 35772 147 3 reared rear VBD 35772 147 4 from from IN 35772 147 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 147 6 cradle cradle NN 35772 147 7 on on IN 35772 147 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 147 9 science science NN 35772 147 10 will will MD 35772 147 11 tend tend VB 35772 147 12 to to TO 35772 147 13 regard regard VB 35772 147 14 miracles miracle NNS 35772 147 15 with with IN 35772 147 16 suspicion suspicion NN 35772 147 17 ; ; : 35772 147 18 if if IN 35772 147 19 he -PRON- PRP 35772 147 20 be be VB 35772 147 21 logical logical JJ 35772 147 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 147 23 as as IN 35772 147 24 he -PRON- PRP 35772 147 25 generally generally RB 35772 147 26 is be VBZ 35772 147 27 not not RB 35772 147 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 147 29 freedom freedom NN 35772 147 30 of of IN 35772 147 31 the the DT 35772 147 32 will will NN 35772 147 33 , , , 35772 147 34 even even RB 35772 147 35 in in IN 35772 147 36 the the DT 35772 147 37 most most RBS 35772 147 38 limited limited JJ 35772 147 39 sense sense NN 35772 147 40 , , , 35772 147 41 will will MD 35772 147 42 appear appear VB 35772 147 43 chimerical chimerical JJ 35772 147 44 . . . 35772 148 1 Nor nor CC 35772 148 2 will will MD 35772 148 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 148 4 general general JJ 35772 148 5 attitude attitude NN 35772 148 6 to to IN 35772 148 7 life life NN 35772 148 8 remain remain VBP 35772 148 9 unaffected unaffected JJ 35772 148 10 by by IN 35772 148 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 148 12 views view NNS 35772 148 13 on on IN 35772 148 14 these these DT 35772 148 15 points point NNS 35772 148 16 . . . 35772 149 1 Systematised systematise VBN 35772 149 2 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 149 3 may may MD 35772 149 4 thus thus RB 35772 149 5 conceivably conceivably RB 35772 149 6 come come VB 35772 149 7 into into IN 35772 149 8 conflict conflict NN 35772 149 9 with with IN 35772 149 10 the the DT 35772 149 11 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 149 12 or or CC 35772 149 13 the the DT 35772 149 14 ideals ideal NNS 35772 149 15 of of IN 35772 149 16 some some DT 35772 149 17 particular particular JJ 35772 149 18 religion religion NN 35772 149 19 . . . 35772 150 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 150 2 is be VBZ 35772 150 3 then then RB 35772 150 4 that that IN 35772 150 5 a a DT 35772 150 6 " " `` 35772 150 7 religious religious JJ 35772 150 8 problem problem NN 35772 150 9 " " '' 35772 150 10 arises arise VBZ 35772 150 11 . . . 35772 151 1 A a DT 35772 151 2 religion religion NN 35772 151 3 indissolubly indissolubly RB 35772 151 4 associated associate VBN 35772 151 5 with with IN 35772 151 6 a a DT 35772 151 7 geocentric geocentric JJ 35772 151 8 conception conception NN 35772 151 9 of of IN 35772 151 10 the the DT 35772 151 11 universe universe NN 35772 151 12 would would MD 35772 151 13 tend tend VB 35772 151 14 to to TO 35772 151 15 become become VB 35772 151 16 discredited discredit VBN 35772 151 17 as as RB 35772 151 18 soon soon RB 35772 151 19 as as IN 35772 151 20 that that DT 35772 151 21 conception conception NN 35772 151 22 had have VBD 35772 151 23 been be VBN 35772 151 24 disposed dispose VBN 35772 151 25 of of IN 35772 151 26 by by IN 35772 151 27 " " `` 35772 151 28 systematic systematic JJ 35772 151 29 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 151 30 . . . 35772 151 31 " " '' 35772 152 1 Science science NN 35772 152 2 may may MD 35772 152 3 even even RB 35772 152 4 tend tend VB 35772 152 5 to to TO 35772 152 6 produce produce VB 35772 152 7 an an DT 35772 152 8 attitude attitude NN 35772 152 9 to to IN 35772 152 10 life life NN 35772 152 11 hostile hostile RB 35772 152 12 not not RB 35772 152 13 only only RB 35772 152 14 to to IN 35772 152 15 a a DT 35772 152 16 particular particular JJ 35772 152 17 religion religion NN 35772 152 18 but but CC 35772 152 19 to to IN 35772 152 20 _ _ NNP 35772 152 21 all all DT 35772 152 22 _ _ NNP 35772 152 23 religion religion NN 35772 152 24 . . . 35772 153 1 If if IN 35772 153 2 materialism materialism NN 35772 153 3 should should MD 35772 153 4 ultimately ultimately RB 35772 153 5 be be VB 35772 153 6 found find VBN 35772 153 7 to to TO 35772 153 8 be be VB 35772 153 9 consistent consistent JJ 35772 153 10 with with IN 35772 153 11 systematic systematic JJ 35772 153 12 and and CC 35772 153 13 accurate accurate JJ 35772 153 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 153 15 , , , 35772 153 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 153 17 is be VBZ 35772 153 18 difficult difficult JJ 35772 153 19 to to TO 35772 153 20 see see VB 35772 153 21 how how WRB 35772 153 22 any any DT 35772 153 23 attitude attitude NN 35772 153 24 to to IN 35772 153 25 life life NN 35772 153 26 which which WDT 35772 153 27 could could MD 35772 153 28 be be VB 35772 153 29 appropriately appropriately RB 35772 153 30 described describe VBN 35772 153 31 as as IN 35772 153 32 " " `` 35772 153 33 religion religion NN 35772 153 34 " " '' 35772 153 35 could could MD 35772 153 36 survive survive VB 35772 153 37 . . . 35772 154 1 The the DT 35772 154 2 religious religious JJ 35772 154 3 problem problem NN 35772 154 4 would would MD 35772 154 5 then then RB 35772 154 6 , , , 35772 154 7 at at IN 35772 154 8 any any DT 35772 154 9 rate rate NN 35772 154 10 , , , 35772 154 11 cease cease VB 35772 154 12 to to TO 35772 154 13 trouble trouble VB 35772 154 14 us -PRON- PRP 35772 154 15 . . . 35772 155 1 The the DT 35772 155 2 religious religious JJ 35772 155 3 apologists apologist NNS 35772 155 4 would would MD 35772 155 5 be be VB 35772 155 6 free free JJ 35772 155 7 to to TO 35772 155 8 turn turn VB 35772 155 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 155 10 attention attention NN 35772 155 11 to to IN 35772 155 12 matters matter NNS 35772 155 13 of of IN 35772 155 14 more more JJR 35772 155 15 moment moment NN 35772 155 16 . . . 35772 156 1 But but CC 35772 156 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 156 3 is be VBZ 35772 156 4 not not RB 35772 156 5 only only RB 35772 156 6 with with IN 35772 156 7 the the DT 35772 156 8 cessation cessation NN 35772 156 9 of of IN 35772 156 10 religion religion NN 35772 156 11 that that IN 35772 156 12 the the DT 35772 156 13 religious religious JJ 35772 156 14 problem problem NN 35772 156 15 slumbers slumber NNS 35772 156 16 . . . 35772 157 1 There there EX 35772 157 2 are be VBP 35772 157 3 certain certain JJ 35772 157 4 happy happy JJ 35772 157 5 periods period NNS 35772 157 6 when when WRB 35772 157 7 religion religion NN 35772 157 8 flourishes flourish NNS 35772 157 9 undisturbed undisturbe VBN 35772 157 10 by by IN 35772 157 11 obstinate obstinate NN 35772 157 12 questionings questioning NNS 35772 157 13 . . . 35772 158 1 These these DT 35772 158 2 classical classical JJ 35772 158 3 ages age NNS 35772 158 4 of of IN 35772 158 5 religion religion NN 35772 158 6 exist exist VBP 35772 158 7 when when WRB 35772 158 8 systematised systematise VBN 35772 158 9 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 158 10 seems seem VBZ 35772 158 11 to to TO 35772 158 12 support support VB 35772 158 13 the the DT 35772 158 14 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 158 15 religious religious JJ 35772 158 16 outlook outlook NN 35772 158 17 -- -- : 35772 158 18 when when WRB 35772 158 19 science science NN 35772 158 20 and and CC 35772 158 21 religion religion NN 35772 158 22 speak speak VBP 35772 158 23 with with IN 35772 158 24 one one CD 35772 158 25 voice voice NN 35772 158 26 . . . 35772 159 1 Such such JJ 35772 159 2 unanimity unanimity NN 35772 159 3 seems seem VBZ 35772 159 4 to to IN 35772 159 5 us -PRON- PRP 35772 159 6 to to IN 35772 159 7 - - HYPH 35772 159 8 day day NN 35772 159 9 too too RB 35772 159 10 good good JJ 35772 159 11 to to TO 35772 159 12 be be VB 35772 159 13 possible possible JJ 35772 159 14 , , , 35772 159 15 but but CC 35772 159 16 that that DT 35772 159 17 is be VBZ 35772 159 18 only only RB 35772 159 19 because because IN 35772 159 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 159 21 own own JJ 35772 159 22 age age NN 35772 159 23 is be VBZ 35772 159 24 exceptional exceptional JJ 35772 159 25 -- -- : 35772 159 26 not not RB 35772 159 27 because because IN 35772 159 28 those those DT 35772 159 29 happier happy JJR 35772 159 30 ages age NNS 35772 159 31 were be VBD 35772 159 32 exceptional exceptional JJ 35772 159 33 ; ; : 35772 159 34 they -PRON- PRP 35772 159 35 , , , 35772 159 36 in in IN 35772 159 37 fact fact NN 35772 159 38 -- -- : 35772 159 39 if if IN 35772 159 40 we -PRON- PRP 35772 159 41 trace trace VBP 35772 159 42 history history NN 35772 159 43 backwards backwards RB 35772 159 44 -- -- : 35772 159 45 would would MD 35772 159 46 seem seem VB 35772 159 47 rather rather RB 35772 159 48 to to TO 35772 159 49 have have VB 35772 159 50 been be VBN 35772 159 51 the the DT 35772 159 52 rule rule NN 35772 159 53 . . . 35772 160 1 Primitive primitive JJ 35772 160 2 man man NN 35772 160 3 , , , 35772 160 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 160 5 would would MD 35772 160 6 seem seem VB 35772 160 7 , , , 35772 160 8 was be VBD 35772 160 9 troubled trouble VBN 35772 160 10 by by IN 35772 160 11 no no DT 35772 160 12 discords discord NNS 35772 160 13 of of IN 35772 160 14 the the DT 35772 160 15 kind kind NN 35772 160 16 which which WDT 35772 160 17 disturb disturb VBP 35772 160 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 160 19 peace peace NN 35772 160 20 . . . 35772 161 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 161 2 systematic systematic JJ 35772 161 3 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 161 4 -- -- : 35772 161 5 such such JJ 35772 161 6 as as IN 35772 161 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 161 8 was be VBD 35772 161 9 -- -- : 35772 161 10 was be VBD 35772 161 11 entirely entirely RB 35772 161 12 in in IN 35772 161 13 accord accord NN 35772 161 14 with with IN 35772 161 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 161 16 religion religion NN 35772 161 17 , , , 35772 161 18 the the DT 35772 161 19 two two CD 35772 161 20 were be VBD 35772 161 21 , , , 35772 161 22 in in IN 35772 161 23 fact fact NN 35772 161 24 , , , 35772 161 25 in in IN 35772 161 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 161 27 case case NN 35772 161 28 practically practically RB 35772 161 29 one one CD 35772 161 30 . . . 35772 162 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 162 2 science science NN 35772 162 3 _ _ NNP 35772 162 4 was be VBD 35772 162 5 _ _ NNP 35772 162 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 162 7 religion religion NN 35772 162 8 . . . 35772 163 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 163 2 may may MD 35772 163 3 not not RB 35772 163 4 have have VB 35772 163 5 been be VBN 35772 163 6 very very RB 35772 163 7 sound sound JJ 35772 163 8 science science NN 35772 163 9 , , , 35772 163 10 nor nor CC 35772 163 11 very very RB 35772 163 12 elevated elevated JJ 35772 163 13 religion religion NN 35772 163 14 , , , 35772 163 15 but but CC 35772 163 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 163 17 served serve VBD 35772 163 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 163 19 purpose purpose NN 35772 163 20 admirably admirably RB 35772 163 21 . . . 35772 164 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 164 2 was be VBD 35772 164 3 too too RB 35772 164 4 busy busy JJ 35772 164 5 with with IN 35772 164 6 the the DT 35772 164 7 struggle struggle NN 35772 164 8 for for IN 35772 164 9 survival survival NN 35772 164 10 to to TO 35772 164 11 indulge indulge VB 35772 164 12 in in IN 35772 164 13 speculation speculation NN 35772 164 14 . . . 35772 165 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 165 2 religion religion NN 35772 165 3 was be VBD 35772 165 4 severely severely RB 35772 165 5 practical practical JJ 35772 165 6 , , , 35772 165 7 and and CC 35772 165 8 he -PRON- PRP 35772 165 9 was be VBD 35772 165 10 faithful faithful JJ 35772 165 11 to to IN 35772 165 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 165 13 because because IN 35772 165 14 experience experience NN 35772 165 15 seemed seem VBD 35772 165 16 to to TO 35772 165 17 indicate indicate VB 35772 165 18 that that IN 35772 165 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 165 20 paid pay VBD 35772 165 21 . . . 35772 166 1 But but CC 35772 166 2 the the DT 35772 166 3 Stone Stone NNP 35772 166 4 Age Age NNP 35772 166 5 hardly hardly RB 35772 166 6 deserves deserve VBZ 35772 166 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 166 8 in in IN 35772 166 9 spite spite NN 35772 166 10 of of IN 35772 166 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 166 12 freedom freedom NN 35772 166 13 from from IN 35772 166 14 religious religious JJ 35772 166 15 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 166 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 166 17 to to TO 35772 166 18 be be VB 35772 166 19 described describe VBN 35772 166 20 as as IN 35772 166 21 one one CD 35772 166 22 of of IN 35772 166 23 the the DT 35772 166 24 classical classical JJ 35772 166 25 ages age NNS 35772 166 26 of of IN 35772 166 27 religion religion NN 35772 166 28 ; ; : 35772 166 29 absence absence NN 35772 166 30 of of IN 35772 166 31 struggle struggle NN 35772 166 32 does do VBZ 35772 166 33 not not RB 35772 166 34 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 166 35 mean mean VB 35772 166 36 richness richness NN 35772 166 37 of of IN 35772 166 38 life life NN 35772 166 39 . . . 35772 167 1 There there EX 35772 167 2 are be VBP 35772 167 3 ages age NNS 35772 167 4 which which WDT 35772 167 5 better better RB 35772 167 6 deserve deserve VBP 35772 167 7 that that DT 35772 167 8 appellation appellation NN 35772 167 9 . . . 35772 168 1 There there EX 35772 168 2 are be VBP 35772 168 3 times time NNS 35772 168 4 when when WRB 35772 168 5 all all DT 35772 168 6 existing exist VBG 35772 168 7 culture culture NN 35772 168 8 -- -- : 35772 168 9 even even RB 35772 168 10 of of IN 35772 168 11 a a DT 35772 168 12 high high JJ 35772 168 13 level level NN 35772 168 14 -- -- : 35772 168 15 is be VBZ 35772 168 16 closely closely RB 35772 168 17 associated associate VBN 35772 168 18 with with IN 35772 168 19 the the DT 35772 168 20 current current JJ 35772 168 21 religion religion NN 35772 168 22 , , , 35772 168 23 endorses endorse VBZ 35772 168 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 168 25 ideals ideal NNS 35772 168 26 , , , 35772 168 27 sanctions sanction VBZ 35772 168 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 168 29 hopes hope NNS 35772 168 30 , , , 35772 168 31 puts put VBZ 35772 168 32 the the DT 35772 168 33 stamp stamp NN 35772 168 34 of of IN 35772 168 35 finality finality NN 35772 168 36 upon upon IN 35772 168 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 168 38 faith faith NN 35772 168 39 . . . 35772 169 1 Such such PDT 35772 169 2 an an DT 35772 169 3 age age NN 35772 169 4 can can MD 35772 169 5 not not RB 35772 169 6 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 169 7 hope hope VB 35772 169 8 to to TO 35772 169 9 be be VB 35772 169 10 permanent permanent JJ 35772 169 11 ; ; : 35772 169 12 for for IN 35772 169 13 life life NN 35772 169 14 means mean VBZ 35772 169 15 movement movement NN 35772 169 16 , , , 35772 169 17 and and CC 35772 169 18 movement movement NN 35772 169 19 upsets upset NNS 35772 169 20 equilibrium equilibrium NN 35772 169 21 , , , 35772 169 22 and and CC 35772 169 23 human human JJ 35772 169 24 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 169 25 tends tend VBZ 35772 169 26 to to TO 35772 169 27 increase increase VB 35772 169 28 faster fast RBR 35772 169 29 than than IN 35772 169 30 the the DT 35772 169 31 human human JJ 35772 169 32 mind mind NN 35772 169 33 can can MD 35772 169 34 adapt adapt VB 35772 169 35 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 169 36 to to IN 35772 169 37 it -PRON- PRP 35772 169 38 or or CC 35772 169 39 digest digest VB 35772 169 40 it -PRON- PRP 35772 169 41 . . . 35772 170 1 But but CC 35772 170 2 such such JJ 35772 170 3 ages age NNS 35772 170 4 are be VBP 35772 170 5 looked look VBN 35772 170 6 back back RB 35772 170 7 upon upon IN 35772 170 8 with with IN 35772 170 9 regret regret NN 35772 170 10 when when WRB 35772 170 11 they -PRON- PRP 35772 170 12 are be VBP 35772 170 13 past past JJ 35772 170 14 , , , 35772 170 15 they -PRON- PRP 35772 170 16 shed shed VBD 35772 170 17 a a DT 35772 170 18 golden golden JJ 35772 170 19 radiance radiance NN 35772 170 20 over over IN 35772 170 21 history history NN 35772 170 22 , , , 35772 170 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 170 24 tradition tradition NN 35772 170 25 lingers linger VBZ 35772 170 26 , , , 35772 170 27 they -PRON- PRP 35772 170 28 even even RB 35772 170 29 leave leave VBP 35772 170 30 behind behind IN 35772 170 31 them -PRON- PRP 35772 170 32 monuments monument NNS 35772 170 33 of of IN 35772 170 34 art art NN 35772 170 35 and and CC 35772 170 36 literature literature NN 35772 170 37 which which WDT 35772 170 38 are be VBP 35772 170 39 the the DT 35772 170 40 wonder wonder NN 35772 170 41 , , , 35772 170 42 and and CC 35772 170 43 the the DT 35772 170 44 inimitable inimitable JJ 35772 170 45 models model NNS 35772 170 46 , , , 35772 170 47 of of IN 35772 170 48 succeeding succeed VBG 35772 170 49 generations generation NNS 35772 170 50 . . . 35772 171 1 Such such PDT 35772 171 2 an an DT 35772 171 3 epoch epoch NN 35772 171 4 was be VBD 35772 171 5 that that DT 35772 171 6 which which WDT 35772 171 7 left leave VBD 35772 171 8 to to IN 35772 171 9 us -PRON- PRP 35772 171 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 171 11 Gothic gothic JJ 35772 171 12 cathedrals cathedral NNS 35772 171 13 . . . 35772 172 1 These these DT 35772 172 2 are be VBP 35772 172 3 the the DT 35772 172 4 creation creation NN 35772 172 5 of of IN 35772 172 6 one one CD 35772 172 7 of of IN 35772 172 8 those those DT 35772 172 9 classic classic JJ 35772 172 10 ages age NNS 35772 172 11 " " '' 35772 172 12 when when WRB 35772 172 13 all all DT 35772 172 14 existing exist VBG 35772 172 15 culture culture NN 35772 172 16 is be VBZ 35772 172 17 cast cast VBN 35772 172 18 or or CC 35772 172 19 bent bend VBN 35772 172 20 in in IN 35772 172 21 obedience obedience NN 35772 172 22 to to IN 35772 172 23 the the DT 35772 172 24 religious religious JJ 35772 172 25 idea idea NN 35772 172 26 . . . 35772 172 27 " " '' 35772 173 1 When when WRB 35772 173 2 scientist scientist NN 35772 173 3 , , , 35772 173 4 scholar scholar NN 35772 173 5 and and CC 35772 173 6 ecclesiastic ecclesiastic NNP 35772 173 7 spoke speak VBD 35772 173 8 with with IN 35772 173 9 one one CD 35772 173 10 voice voice NN 35772 173 11 and and CC 35772 173 12 listened listen VBD 35772 173 13 to to IN 35772 173 14 one one CD 35772 173 15 message message NN 35772 173 16 ; ; : 35772 173 17 when when WRB 35772 173 18 prince prince NN 35772 173 19 and and CC 35772 173 20 peasant peasant NN 35772 173 21 worshipped worship VBD 35772 173 22 together together RB 35772 173 23 the the DT 35772 173 24 same same JJ 35772 173 25 divinities divinity NNS 35772 173 26 ; ; : 35772 173 27 when when WRB 35772 173 28 to to TO 35772 173 29 be be VB 35772 173 30 outside outside IN 35772 173 31 the the DT 35772 173 32 religious religious JJ 35772 173 33 community community NN 35772 173 34 was be VBD 35772 173 35 to to TO 35772 173 36 be be VB 35772 173 37 cut cut VBN 35772 173 38 off off RP 35772 173 39 from from IN 35772 173 40 the the DT 35772 173 41 brotherhood brotherhood NNP 35772 173 42 of of IN 35772 173 43 mankind mankind NN 35772 173 44 . . . 35772 174 1 " " `` 35772 174 2 The the DT 35772 174 3 Church Church NNP 35772 174 4 " " '' 35772 174 5 was be VBD 35772 174 6 then then RB 35772 174 7 co co JJ 35772 174 8 - - JJ 35772 174 9 extensive extensive JJ 35772 174 10 with with IN 35772 174 11 civilisation civilisation NN 35772 174 12 : : : 35772 174 13 those those DT 35772 174 14 without without IN 35772 174 15 the the DT 35772 174 16 fold fold NN 35772 174 17 were be VBD 35772 174 18 barbarians barbarian NNS 35772 174 19 , , , 35772 174 20 hardly hardly RB 35772 174 21 worthy worthy JJ 35772 174 22 of of IN 35772 174 23 the the DT 35772 174 24 name name NN 35772 174 25 of of IN 35772 174 26 man man NN 35772 174 27 . . . 35772 175 1 That that DT 35772 175 2 time time NN 35772 175 3 of of IN 35772 175 4 splendid splendid JJ 35772 175 5 harmony harmony NN 35772 175 6 , , , 35772 175 7 however however RB 35772 175 8 , , , 35772 175 9 is be VBZ 35772 175 10 now now RB 35772 175 11 past past JJ 35772 175 12 ; ; : 35772 175 13 no no DT 35772 175 14 lamentations lamentation NNS 35772 175 15 will will MD 35772 175 16 restore restore VB 35772 175 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 175 18 . . . 35772 176 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 176 2 have have VBP 35772 176 3 reached reach VBN 35772 176 4 another another DT 35772 176 5 world world NN 35772 176 6 . . . 35772 177 1 But but CC 35772 177 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 177 3 need nee MD 35772 177 4 not not RB 35772 177 5 remain remain VB 35772 177 6 only only RB 35772 177 7 a a DT 35772 177 8 memory memory NN 35772 177 9 ; ; : 35772 177 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 177 11 ought ought MD 35772 177 12 also also RB 35772 177 13 to to TO 35772 177 14 serve serve VB 35772 177 15 as as IN 35772 177 16 an an DT 35772 177 17 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 177 18 . . . 35772 178 1 The the DT 35772 178 2 conditions condition NNS 35772 178 3 of of IN 35772 178 4 affairs affair NNS 35772 178 5 during during IN 35772 178 6 the the DT 35772 178 7 classic classic JJ 35772 178 8 ages age NNS 35772 178 9 of of IN 35772 178 10 religion religion NN 35772 178 11 , , , 35772 178 12 however however RB 35772 178 13 impossible impossible JJ 35772 178 14 at at IN 35772 178 15 the the DT 35772 178 16 moment moment NN 35772 178 17 , , , 35772 178 18 must must MD 35772 178 19 remain remain VB 35772 178 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 178 21 ideal ideal NN 35772 178 22 . . . 35772 179 1 Head head NN 35772 179 2 and and CC 35772 179 3 heart heart NN 35772 179 4 must must MD 35772 179 5 some some DT 35772 179 6 day day NN 35772 179 7 speak speak VB 35772 179 8 again again RB 35772 179 9 with with IN 35772 179 10 one one CD 35772 179 11 voice voice NN 35772 179 12 , , , 35772 179 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 179 14 hopes hope NNS 35772 179 15 and and CC 35772 179 16 beliefs belief NNS 35772 179 17 must must MD 35772 179 18 be be VB 35772 179 19 consistent consistent JJ 35772 179 20 with with IN 35772 179 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 179 22 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 179 23 . . . 35772 180 1 Science science NN 35772 180 2 must must MD 35772 180 3 sanction sanction VB 35772 180 4 that that DT 35772 180 5 attitude attitude NN 35772 180 6 towards towards IN 35772 180 7 existence existence NN 35772 180 8 which which WDT 35772 180 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 180 10 highest high JJS 35772 180 11 instincts instinct NNS 35772 180 12 dictate dictate VBP 35772 180 13 . . . 35772 181 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 181 2 is be VBZ 35772 181 3 only only RB 35772 181 4 too too RB 35772 181 5 likely likely JJ 35772 181 6 that that IN 35772 181 7 this this DT 35772 181 8 consummation consummation NN 35772 181 9 is be VBZ 35772 181 10 yet yet RB 35772 181 11 distant distant JJ 35772 181 12 . . . 35772 182 1 Yet yet RB 35772 182 2 even even RB 35772 182 3 if if IN 35772 182 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 182 5 generation generation NN 35772 182 6 has have VBZ 35772 182 7 to to TO 35772 182 8 reconcile reconcile VB 35772 182 9 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 182 10 to to IN 35772 182 11 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 182 12 and and CC 35772 182 13 moral moral JJ 35772 182 14 discord discord NN 35772 182 15 , , , 35772 182 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 182 17 should should MD 35772 182 18 never never RB 35772 182 19 overlook overlook VB 35772 182 20 the the DT 35772 182 21 existence existence NN 35772 182 22 of of IN 35772 182 23 a a DT 35772 182 24 happier happy JJR 35772 182 25 ideal ideal NN 35772 182 26 , , , 35772 182 27 and and CC 35772 182 28 even even RB 35772 182 29 the the DT 35772 182 30 possibility possibility NN 35772 182 31 of of IN 35772 182 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 182 33 fulfilment fulfilment NN 35772 182 34 . . . 35772 183 1 Fortunately fortunately RB 35772 183 2 for for IN 35772 183 3 the the DT 35772 183 4 interests interest NNS 35772 183 5 of of IN 35772 183 6 religion religion NN 35772 183 7 , , , 35772 183 8 men man NNS 35772 183 9 feel feel VBP 35772 183 10 they -PRON- PRP 35772 183 11 _ _ NNP 35772 183 12 must must MD 35772 183 13 _ _ NNP 35772 183 14 effect effect VB 35772 183 15 some some DT 35772 183 16 kind kind NN 35772 183 17 of of IN 35772 183 18 a a DT 35772 183 19 reconciliation reconciliation NN 35772 183 20 between between IN 35772 183 21 the the DT 35772 183 22 opposing oppose VBG 35772 183 23 demands demand NNS 35772 183 24 which which WDT 35772 183 25 proceed proceed VBP 35772 183 26 from from IN 35772 183 27 different different JJ 35772 183 28 sides side NNS 35772 183 29 of of IN 35772 183 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 183 31 nature nature NN 35772 183 32 . . . 35772 184 1 Each each DT 35772 184 2 for for IN 35772 184 3 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 184 4 tries try VBZ 35772 184 5 to to TO 35772 184 6 approximate approximate VB 35772 184 7 science science NN 35772 184 8 and and CC 35772 184 9 religion religion NN 35772 184 10 , , , 35772 184 11 and and CC 35772 184 12 the the DT 35772 184 13 struggle struggle NN 35772 184 14 to to TO 35772 184 15 do do VB 35772 184 16 this this DT 35772 184 17 creates create VBZ 35772 184 18 in in IN 35772 184 19 each each DT 35772 184 20 individual individual JJ 35772 184 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 184 22 life life NN 35772 184 23 . . . 35772 185 1 Tension tension NN 35772 185 2 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 185 3 creates create VBZ 35772 185 4 light light JJ 35772 185 5 , , , 35772 185 6 and and CC 35772 185 7 struggle struggle VB 35772 185 8 engenders engender NNS 35772 185 9 life life NN 35772 185 10 . . . 35772 186 1 So so RB 35772 186 2 long long RB 35772 186 3 as as IN 35772 186 4 there there EX 35772 186 5 are be VBP 35772 186 6 men man NNS 35772 186 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 35772 186 8 _ _ NNP 35772 186 9 interested interested JJ 35772 186 10 _ _ NNP 35772 186 11 in in IN 35772 186 12 religion religion NN 35772 186 13 to to TO 35772 186 14 ask ask VB 35772 186 15 for for IN 35772 186 16 a a DT 35772 186 17 solution solution NN 35772 186 18 of of IN 35772 186 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 186 20 problems problem NNS 35772 186 21 , , , 35772 186 22 religion religion NN 35772 186 23 will will MD 35772 186 24 remain remain VB 35772 186 25 superior superior JJ 35772 186 26 to to IN 35772 186 27 the the DT 35772 186 28 disintegration disintegration NN 35772 186 29 towards towards IN 35772 186 30 which which WDT 35772 186 31 all all DT 35772 186 32 discord discord NN 35772 186 33 , , , 35772 186 34 if if IN 35772 186 35 unchecked unchecked JJ 35772 186 36 , , , 35772 186 37 proceeds proceed NNS 35772 186 38 . . . 35772 187 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 187 2 is be VBZ 35772 187 3 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 187 4 said say VBN 35772 187 5 that that IN 35772 187 6 the the DT 35772 187 7 religious religious JJ 35772 187 8 harmony harmony NN 35772 187 9 of of IN 35772 187 10 the the DT 35772 187 11 Middle Middle NNP 35772 187 12 Ages Ages NNP 35772 187 13 , , , 35772 187 14 of of IN 35772 187 15 which which WDT 35772 187 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 187 17 have have VBP 35772 187 18 spoken speak VBN 35772 187 19 , , , 35772 187 20 having have VBG 35772 187 21 been be VBN 35772 187 22 due due JJ 35772 187 23 to to IN 35772 187 24 imperfect imperfect JJ 35772 187 25 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 187 26 , , , 35772 187 27 is be VBZ 35772 187 28 never never RB 35772 187 29 likely likely JJ 35772 187 30 to to TO 35772 187 31 repeat repeat VB 35772 187 32 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 187 33 , , , 35772 187 34 unless unless IN 35772 187 35 we -PRON- PRP 35772 187 36 sink sink VBP 35772 187 37 back back RB 35772 187 38 into into IN 35772 187 39 the the DT 35772 187 40 ignorance ignorance NN 35772 187 41 of of IN 35772 187 42 barbarism barbarism NN 35772 187 43 : : : 35772 187 44 and and CC 35772 187 45 ( ( -LRB- 35772 187 46 it -PRON- PRP 35772 187 47 is be VBZ 35772 187 48 urged urge VBN 35772 187 49 ) ) -RRB- 35772 187 50 we -PRON- PRP 35772 187 51 know know VBP 35772 187 52 too too RB 35772 187 53 much much JJ 35772 187 54 to to TO 35772 187 55 be be VB 35772 187 56 at at IN 35772 187 57 peace peace NN 35772 187 58 . . . 35772 188 1 Having have VBG 35772 188 2 tasted taste VBN 35772 188 3 of of IN 35772 188 4 the the DT 35772 188 5 fruits fruit NNS 35772 188 6 of of IN 35772 188 7 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 188 8 , , , 35772 188 9 the the DT 35772 188 10 human human JJ 35772 188 11 race race NN 35772 188 12 is be VBZ 35772 188 13 cast cast VBN 35772 188 14 forth forth RB 35772 188 15 from from IN 35772 188 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 188 17 Paradise Paradise NNP 35772 188 18 . . . 35772 189 1 This this DT 35772 189 2 view view NN 35772 189 3 is be VBZ 35772 189 4 unduly unduly RB 35772 189 5 pessimistic pessimistic JJ 35772 189 6 . . . 35772 190 1 There there EX 35772 190 2 is be VBZ 35772 190 3 no no DT 35772 190 4 valid valid JJ 35772 190 5 reason reason NN 35772 190 6 for for IN 35772 190 7 excluding exclude VBG 35772 190 8 the the DT 35772 190 9 possibility possibility NN 35772 190 10 that that IN 35772 190 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 190 12 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 190 13 of of IN 35772 190 14 reality reality NN 35772 190 15 and and CC 35772 190 16 those those DT 35772 190 17 ideal ideal JJ 35772 190 18 hopes hope NNS 35772 190 19 which which WDT 35772 190 20 constitute constitute VBP 35772 190 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 190 22 religion religion NN 35772 190 23 may may MD 35772 190 24 actually actually RB 35772 190 25 coincide coincide VB 35772 190 26 . . . 35772 191 1 Religion religion NN 35772 191 2 and and CC 35772 191 3 science science NN 35772 191 4 , , , 35772 191 5 approaching approach VBG 35772 191 6 the the DT 35772 191 7 problem problem NN 35772 191 8 of of IN 35772 191 9 existence existence NN 35772 191 10 from from IN 35772 191 11 contrary contrary JJ 35772 191 12 directions direction NNS 35772 191 13 , , , 35772 191 14 may may MD 35772 191 15 independently independently RB 35772 191 16 arrive arrive VB 35772 191 17 at at IN 35772 191 18 an an DT 35772 191 19 identical identical JJ 35772 191 20 solution solution NN 35772 191 21 . . . 35772 192 1 That that IN 35772 192 2 the the DT 35772 192 3 two two CD 35772 192 4 actually actually RB 35772 192 5 do do VBP 35772 192 6 attack attack VB 35772 192 7 the the DT 35772 192 8 enigma enigma NN 35772 192 9 from from IN 35772 192 10 different different JJ 35772 192 11 sides side NNS 35772 192 12 has have VBZ 35772 192 13 led lead VBN 35772 192 14 many many JJ 35772 192 15 people people NNS 35772 192 16 to to TO 35772 192 17 regard regard VB 35772 192 18 the the DT 35772 192 19 two two CD 35772 192 20 as as IN 35772 192 21 hostile hostile JJ 35772 192 22 forces force NNS 35772 192 23 . . . 35772 193 1 Such such JJ 35772 193 2 is be VBZ 35772 193 3 not not RB 35772 193 4 the the DT 35772 193 5 case case NN 35772 193 6 . . . 35772 194 1 Religion religion NN 35772 194 2 and and CC 35772 194 3 science science NN 35772 194 4 regard regard NN 35772 194 5 reality reality NN 35772 194 6 from from IN 35772 194 7 different different JJ 35772 194 8 angles angle NNS 35772 194 9 , , , 35772 194 10 but but CC 35772 194 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 194 12 is be VBZ 35772 194 13 the the DT 35772 194 14 same same JJ 35772 194 15 reality reality NN 35772 194 16 that that WDT 35772 194 17 is be VBZ 35772 194 18 the the DT 35772 194 19 object object NN 35772 194 20 of of IN 35772 194 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 194 22 vision vision NN 35772 194 23 , , , 35772 194 24 and and CC 35772 194 25 the the DT 35772 194 26 goal goal NN 35772 194 27 of of IN 35772 194 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 194 29 search search NN 35772 194 30 . . . 35772 195 1 Religion religion NN 35772 195 2 looks look VBZ 35772 195 3 at at IN 35772 195 4 existence existence NN 35772 195 5 as as IN 35772 195 6 a a DT 35772 195 7 whole whole NN 35772 195 8 , , , 35772 195 9 and and CC 35772 195 10 attempts attempt NNS 35772 195 11 to to TO 35772 195 12 determine determine VB 35772 195 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 195 14 meaning meaning NN 35772 195 15 and and CC 35772 195 16 value value NN 35772 195 17 for for IN 35772 195 18 mankind mankind NN 35772 195 19 . . . 35772 196 1 Religion religion NN 35772 196 2 , , , 35772 196 3 we -PRON- PRP 35772 196 4 may may MD 35772 196 5 say say VB 35772 196 6 , , , 35772 196 7 stands stand VBZ 35772 196 8 at at IN 35772 196 9 the the DT 35772 196 10 centre centre NNP 35772 196 11 of of IN 35772 196 12 existence existence NN 35772 196 13 , , , 35772 196 14 and and CC 35772 196 15 regards regard VBZ 35772 196 16 reality reality NN 35772 196 17 from from IN 35772 196 18 a a DT 35772 196 19 central central JJ 35772 196 20 position position NN 35772 196 21 . . . 35772 197 1 The the DT 35772 197 2 province province NN 35772 197 3 of of IN 35772 197 4 science science NN 35772 197 5 , , , 35772 197 6 on on IN 35772 197 7 the the DT 35772 197 8 other other JJ 35772 197 9 hand hand NN 35772 197 10 , , , 35772 197 11 is be VBZ 35772 197 12 not not RB 35772 197 13 to to TO 35772 197 14 take take VB 35772 197 15 so so RB 35772 197 16 wide wide RB 35772 197 17 a a DT 35772 197 18 survey survey NN 35772 197 19 , , , 35772 197 20 but but CC 35772 197 21 to to TO 35772 197 22 gain gain VB 35772 197 23 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 197 24 piece piece NN 35772 197 25 - - HYPH 35772 197 26 meal meal NN 35772 197 27 : : : 35772 197 28 to to TO 35772 197 29 locate locate VB 35772 197 30 points point NNS 35772 197 31 inductively inductively RB 35772 197 32 , , , 35772 197 33 and and CC 35772 197 34 thus thus RB 35772 197 35 to to TO 35772 197 36 plot plot VB 35772 197 37 out out RP 35772 197 38 the the DT 35772 197 39 curve curve NN 35772 197 40 which which WDT 35772 197 41 we -PRON- PRP 35772 197 42 believe believe VBP 35772 197 43 existence existence NN 35772 197 44 constitutes constitute VBZ 35772 197 45 . . . 35772 198 1 If if IN 35772 198 2 the the DT 35772 198 3 _ _ NNP 35772 198 4 loci loci NN 35772 198 5 _ _ NNP 35772 198 6 , , , 35772 198 7 as as IN 35772 198 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 198 9 are be VBP 35772 198 10 successively successively RB 35772 198 11 fixed fix VBN 35772 198 12 , , , 35772 198 13 seem seem VBP 35772 198 14 to to TO 35772 198 15 indicate indicate VB 35772 198 16 that that IN 35772 198 17 the the DT 35772 198 18 curve curve NN 35772 198 19 is be VBZ 35772 198 20 identical identical JJ 35772 198 21 with with IN 35772 198 22 the the DT 35772 198 23 circle circle NN 35772 198 24 which which WDT 35772 198 25 religion religion NN 35772 198 26 has have VBZ 35772 198 27 already already RB 35772 198 28 intuitively intuitively RB 35772 198 29 postulated postulate VBN 35772 198 30 , , , 35772 198 31 the the DT 35772 198 32 problem problem NN 35772 198 33 of of IN 35772 198 34 existence existence NN 35772 198 35 would would MD 35772 198 36 have have VB 35772 198 37 been be VBN 35772 198 38 solved solve VBN 35772 198 39 . . . 35772 199 1 Science science NN 35772 199 2 and and CC 35772 199 3 religion religion NN 35772 199 4 working work VBG 35772 199 5 by by IN 35772 199 6 different different JJ 35772 199 7 methods method NNS 35772 199 8 would would MD 35772 199 9 have have VB 35772 199 10 described describe VBN 35772 199 11 the the DT 35772 199 12 same same JJ 35772 199 13 circle circle NN 35772 199 14 . . . 35772 200 1 When when WRB 35772 200 2 science science NN 35772 200 3 has have VBZ 35772 200 4 completed complete VBN 35772 200 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 200 6 circle circle NN 35772 200 7 , , , 35772 200 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 200 9 centre centre NN 35772 200 10 may may MD 35772 200 11 be be VB 35772 200 12 found find VBN 35772 200 13 to to TO 35772 200 14 stand stand VB 35772 200 15 just just RB 35772 200 16 at at IN 35772 200 17 the the DT 35772 200 18 point point NN 35772 200 19 where where WRB 35772 200 20 religion religion NN 35772 200 21 has have VBZ 35772 200 22 always always RB 35772 200 23 confidently confidently RB 35772 200 24 declared declare VBN 35772 200 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 200 26 to to TO 35772 200 27 be be VB 35772 200 28 . . . 35772 201 1 Knowledge knowledge NN 35772 201 2 and and CC 35772 201 3 faith faith NN 35772 201 4 will will MD 35772 201 5 then then RB 35772 201 6 , , , 35772 201 7 and and CC 35772 201 8 not not RB 35772 201 9 till till IN 35772 201 10 then then RB 35772 201 11 , , , 35772 201 12 be be VB 35772 201 13 one one CD 35772 201 14 . . . 35772 202 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 202 2 II II NNP 35772 202 3 THE the DT 35772 202 4 DISSOLUTION dissolution NN 35772 202 5 OF of IN 35772 202 6 THE the DT 35772 202 7 OLD old JJ 35772 202 8 SYNTHESIS synthesi NNS 35772 202 9 We -PRON- PRP 35772 202 10 have have VBP 35772 202 11 seen see VBN 35772 202 12 that that IN 35772 202 13 there there EX 35772 202 14 are be VBP 35772 202 15 classic classic JJ 35772 202 16 religious religious JJ 35772 202 17 periods period NNS 35772 202 18 when when WRB 35772 202 19 faith faith NN 35772 202 20 and and CC 35772 202 21 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 202 22 have have VBP 35772 202 23 seemed seem VBN 35772 202 24 to to TO 35772 202 25 approximate approximate VB 35772 202 26 to to IN 35772 202 27 one one CD 35772 202 28 another another DT 35772 202 29 . . . 35772 203 1 The the DT 35772 203 2 Middle Middle NNP 35772 203 3 Ages Ages NNPS 35772 203 4 in in IN 35772 203 5 Europe Europe NNP 35772 203 6 constituted constitute VBD 35772 203 7 such such PDT 35772 203 8 a a DT 35772 203 9 period period NN 35772 203 10 ; ; : 35772 203 11 no no DT 35772 203 12 " " `` 35772 203 13 Religion Religion NNP 35772 203 14 _ _ NNP 35772 203 15 v. v. IN 35772 203 16 _ _ NNP 35772 203 17 Science Science NNP 35772 203 18 " " '' 35772 203 19 controversy controversy NN 35772 203 20 could could MD 35772 203 21 then then RB 35772 203 22 be be VB 35772 203 23 said say VBN 35772 203 24 to to TO 35772 203 25 exist exist VB 35772 203 26 ; ; : 35772 203 27 the the DT 35772 203 28 best good JJS 35772 203 29 scientific scientific JJ 35772 203 30 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 203 31 of of IN 35772 203 32 the the DT 35772 203 33 time time NN 35772 203 34 seemed seem VBD 35772 203 35 to to TO 35772 203 36 sanction sanction VB 35772 203 37 the the DT 35772 203 38 popular popular JJ 35772 203 39 religious religious JJ 35772 203 40 notions notion NNS 35772 203 41 . . . 35772 204 1 Learned learn VBN 35772 204 2 and and CC 35772 204 3 lay lie VBD 35772 204 4 thought think VBN 35772 204 5 in in IN 35772 204 6 the the DT 35772 204 7 same same JJ 35772 204 8 terms term NNS 35772 204 9 ; ; : 35772 204 10 the the DT 35772 204 11 wolf wolf NN 35772 204 12 lay lie VBD 35772 204 13 down down RP 35772 204 14 with with IN 35772 204 15 the the DT 35772 204 16 lamb lamb NN 35772 204 17 . . . 35772 205 1 THE the DT 35772 205 2 OLD OLD NNP 35772 205 3 WORLD WORLD NNP 35772 205 4 - - HYPH 35772 205 5 SCHEME.--It SCHEME.--It NNP 35772 205 6 is be VBZ 35772 205 7 important important JJ 35772 205 8 to to TO 35772 205 9 grasp grasp VB 35772 205 10 the the DT 35772 205 11 main main JJ 35772 205 12 features feature NNS 35772 205 13 of of IN 35772 205 14 a a DT 35772 205 15 world world NN 35772 205 16 - - HYPH 35772 205 17 scheme scheme NN 35772 205 18 which which WDT 35772 205 19 as as RB 35772 205 20 late late RB 35772 205 21 as as IN 35772 205 22 the the DT 35772 205 23 fifteenth fifteenth JJ 35772 205 24 century century NN 35772 205 25 passed pass VBD 35772 205 26 everywhere everywhere RB 35772 205 27 without without IN 35772 205 28 criticism criticism NN 35772 205 29 . . . 35772 206 1 The the DT 35772 206 2 father father NN 35772 206 3 of of IN 35772 206 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 206 5 was be VBD 35772 206 6 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 35772 206 7 . . . 35772 207 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 207 2 conception conception NN 35772 207 3 of of IN 35772 207 4 the the DT 35772 207 5 universe universe NN 35772 207 6 rested rest VBN 35772 207 7 upon upon IN 35772 207 8 the the DT 35772 207 9 plain plain JJ 35772 207 10 contrast contrast NN 35772 207 11 , , , 35772 207 12 which which WDT 35772 207 13 strikes strike VBZ 35772 207 14 the the DT 35772 207 15 unsophisticated unsophisticated JJ 35772 207 16 observer observer NN 35772 207 17 , , , 35772 207 18 between between IN 35772 207 19 the the DT 35772 207 20 unembarrassed unembarrassed JJ 35772 207 21 and and CC 35772 207 22 regular regular JJ 35772 207 23 movements movement NNS 35772 207 24 of of IN 35772 207 25 the the DT 35772 207 26 heavenly heavenly JJ 35772 207 27 bodies body NNS 35772 207 28 and and CC 35772 207 29 the the DT 35772 207 30 disordered disorder VBN 35772 207 31 agitations agitation NNS 35772 207 32 of of IN 35772 207 33 sublunary sublunary JJ 35772 207 34 things thing NNS 35772 207 35 . . . 35772 208 1 Hence hence RB 35772 208 2 the the DT 35772 208 3 heavenly heavenly JJ 35772 208 4 region region NN 35772 208 5 was be VBD 35772 208 6 eternal eternal JJ 35772 208 7 , , , 35772 208 8 and and CC 35772 208 9 the the DT 35772 208 10 region region NN 35772 208 11 of of IN 35772 208 12 earth earth NN 35772 208 13 transitory transitory NN 35772 208 14 : : : 35772 208 15 yonder yonder NN 35772 208 16 , , , 35772 208 17 the the DT 35772 208 18 motions motion NNS 35772 208 19 that that WDT 35772 208 20 take take VBP 35772 208 21 place place NN 35772 208 22 are be VBP 35772 208 23 eternal eternal JJ 35772 208 24 and and CC 35772 208 25 regular regular JJ 35772 208 26 ; ; : 35772 208 27 here here RB 35772 208 28 , , , 35772 208 29 motion motion NN 35772 208 30 and and CC 35772 208 31 rest rest NN 35772 208 32 alternate alternate JJ 35772 208 33 , , , 35772 208 34 nothing nothing NN 35772 208 35 " " '' 35772 208 36 continueth continueth VBD 35772 208 37 in in IN 35772 208 38 one one CD 35772 208 39 stay stay NN 35772 208 40 . . . 35772 208 41 " " '' 35772 209 1 At at IN 35772 209 2 the the DT 35772 209 3 centre centre NN 35772 209 4 of of IN 35772 209 5 the the DT 35772 209 6 universe universe NN 35772 209 7 stands stand VBZ 35772 209 8 Earth Earth NNP 35772 209 9 : : : 35772 209 10 hence hence RB 35772 209 11 we -PRON- PRP 35772 209 12 mount mount VBP 35772 209 13 through through IN 35772 209 14 three three CD 35772 209 15 sublunary sublunary JJ 35772 209 16 strata strata NN 35772 209 17 to to IN 35772 209 18 the the DT 35772 209 19 region region NN 35772 209 20 of of IN 35772 209 21 the the DT 35772 209 22 celestial celestial JJ 35772 209 23 ether ether NN 35772 209 24 , , , 35772 209 25 which which WDT 35772 209 26 is be VBZ 35772 209 27 purer purer NN 35772 209 28 as as IN 35772 209 29 distance distance NN 35772 209 30 from from IN 35772 209 31 the the DT 35772 209 32 Earth Earth NNP 35772 209 33 increases increase NNS 35772 209 34 . . . 35772 210 1 These these DT 35772 210 2 strata strata NN 35772 210 3 form form NN 35772 210 4 three three CD 35772 210 5 concentric concentric JJ 35772 210 6 " " `` 35772 210 7 spheres sphere NNS 35772 210 8 " " '' 35772 210 9 which which WDT 35772 210 10 , , , 35772 210 11 solid solid JJ 35772 210 12 yet yet RB 35772 210 13 transparent transparent JJ 35772 210 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 210 15 like like IN 35772 210 16 crystal crystal NN 35772 210 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 210 18 , , , 35772 210 19 revolve revolve VB 35772 210 20 around around IN 35772 210 21 the the DT 35772 210 22 earth earth NN 35772 210 23 . . . 35772 211 1 The the DT 35772 211 2 first first JJ 35772 211 3 contains contain VBZ 35772 211 4 the the DT 35772 211 5 moon moon NN 35772 211 6 -- -- : 35772 211 7 like like IN 35772 211 8 a a DT 35772 211 9 fly fly NN 35772 211 10 in in IN 35772 211 11 amber amber NNP 35772 211 12 ; ; : 35772 211 13 the the DT 35772 211 14 second second JJ 35772 211 15 , , , 35772 211 16 the the DT 35772 211 17 sun sun NN 35772 211 18 ; ; : 35772 211 19 the the DT 35772 211 20 third third JJ 35772 211 21 , , , 35772 211 22 the the DT 35772 211 23 fixed fix VBN 35772 211 24 stars star NNS 35772 211 25 ; ; : 35772 211 26 which which WDT 35772 211 27 last last JJ 35772 211 28 sphere sphere NN 35772 211 29 is be VBZ 35772 211 30 also also RB 35772 211 31 the the DT 35772 211 32 first first JJ 35772 211 33 of of IN 35772 211 34 several several JJ 35772 211 35 successive successive JJ 35772 211 36 heavens heaven NNS 35772 211 37 , , , 35772 211 38 the the DT 35772 211 39 highest high JJS 35772 211 40 of of IN 35772 211 41 which which WDT 35772 211 42 is be VBZ 35772 211 43 the the DT 35772 211 44 seat seat NN 35772 211 45 of of IN 35772 211 46 Deity deity NN 35772 211 47 . . . 35772 212 1 This this DT 35772 212 2 Aristotelio Aristotelio NNP 35772 212 3 - - HYPH 35772 212 4 Ptolemaic Ptolemaic NNP 35772 212 5 system[2 system[2 NNP 35772 212 6 ] ] -RRB- 35772 212 7 formed form VBD 35772 212 8 a a DT 35772 212 9 coherent coherent JJ 35772 212 10 framework framework NN 35772 212 11 for for IN 35772 212 12 biblical biblical JJ 35772 212 13 world world NN 35772 212 14 - - HYPH 35772 212 15 notions notion NNS 35772 212 16 . . . 35772 213 1 Here here RB 35772 213 2 too too RB 35772 213 3 , , , 35772 213 4 earth earth NN 35772 213 5 stands stand VBZ 35772 213 6 still still RB 35772 213 7 while while IN 35772 213 8 sun sun NN 35772 213 9 and and CC 35772 213 10 stars star NNS 35772 213 11 revolve revolve VBP 35772 213 12 ; ; : 35772 213 13 here here RB 35772 213 14 , , , 35772 213 15 too too RB 35772 213 16 , , , 35772 213 17 the the DT 35772 213 18 seat seat NN 35772 213 19 of of IN 35772 213 20 Deity Deity NNP 35772 213 21 is be VBZ 35772 213 22 the the DT 35772 213 23 highest high JJS 35772 213 24 heaven heaven NNP 35772 213 25 . . . 35772 214 1 This this DT 35772 214 2 was be VBD 35772 214 3 an an DT 35772 214 4 universe universe NN 35772 214 5 where where WRB 35772 214 6 men man NNS 35772 214 7 could could MD 35772 214 8 feel feel VB 35772 214 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 214 10 feet foot NNS 35772 214 11 on on IN 35772 214 12 firm firm JJ 35772 214 13 ground ground NN 35772 214 14 ; ; : 35772 214 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 214 16 minds mind NNS 35772 214 17 found find VBD 35772 214 18 rest rest NN 35772 214 19 in in IN 35772 214 20 those those DT 35772 214 21 simple simple JJ 35772 214 22 and and CC 35772 214 23 definite definite JJ 35772 214 24 notions notion NNS 35772 214 25 which which WDT 35772 214 26 make make VBP 35772 214 27 religious religious JJ 35772 214 28 conceptions conception NNS 35772 214 29 easy easy JJ 35772 214 30 to to TO 35772 214 31 understand understand VB 35772 214 32 and and CC 35772 214 33 accept accept VB 35772 214 34 ; ; : 35772 214 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 214 36 imaginations imagination NNS 35772 214 37 were be VBD 35772 214 38 not not RB 35772 214 39 yet yet RB 35772 214 40 disturbed disturb VBN 35772 214 41 and and CC 35772 214 42 disquieted disquiet VBN 35772 214 43 by by IN 35772 214 44 thoughts thought NNS 35772 214 45 of of IN 35772 214 46 space space NN 35772 214 47 and and CC 35772 214 48 time time NN 35772 214 49 without without IN 35772 214 50 end end NN 35772 214 51 and and CC 35772 214 52 without without IN 35772 214 53 beginning begin VBG 35772 214 54 . . . 35772 215 1 AQUINAS.--Such AQUINAS.--Such NNP 35772 215 2 was be VBD 35772 215 3 the the DT 35772 215 4 " " `` 35772 215 5 world world NN 35772 215 6 of of IN 35772 215 7 nature nature NN 35772 215 8 , , , 35772 215 9 " " '' 35772 215 10 the the DT 35772 215 11 theatre theatre NN 35772 215 12 for for IN 35772 215 13 that that DT 35772 215 14 " " `` 35772 215 15 world world NN 35772 215 16 of of IN 35772 215 17 grace grace NN 35772 215 18 " " '' 35772 215 19 which which WDT 35772 215 20 Revelation Revelation NNP 35772 215 21 spoke speak VBD 35772 215 22 of of IN 35772 215 23 , , , 35772 215 24 and and CC 35772 215 25 which which WDT 35772 215 26 led lead VBD 35772 215 27 eventually eventually RB 35772 215 28 to to IN 35772 215 29 the the DT 35772 215 30 eternal eternal JJ 35772 215 31 " " `` 35772 215 32 world world NN 35772 215 33 of of IN 35772 215 34 glory glory NN 35772 215 35 " " '' 35772 215 36 in in IN 35772 215 37 which which WDT 35772 215 38 the the DT 35772 215 39 faithful faithful NN 35772 215 40 should should MD 35772 215 41 have have VB 35772 215 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 215 43 portion portion NN 35772 215 44 . . . 35772 216 1 _ _ NNP 35772 216 2 Natura Natura NNP 35772 216 3 _ _ NNP 35772 216 4 , , , 35772 216 5 _ _ NNP 35772 216 6 gratia gratia NN 35772 216 7 _ _ NNP 35772 216 8 , , , 35772 216 9 _ _ NNP 35772 216 10 gloria gloria NNP 35772 216 11 _ _ NNP 35772 216 12 was be VBD 35772 216 13 the the DT 35772 216 14 ascending ascend VBG 35772 216 15 series series NN 35772 216 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 216 17 like like IN 35772 216 18 another another DT 35772 216 19 set set NN 35772 216 20 of of IN 35772 216 21 celestial celestial JJ 35772 216 22 spheres sphere NNS 35772 216 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 216 24 , , , 35772 216 25 and and CC 35772 216 26 the the DT 35772 216 27 whole whole JJ 35772 216 28 economy economy NN 35772 216 29 was be VBD 35772 216 30 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 216 31 into into IN 35772 216 32 a a DT 35772 216 33 logical logical JJ 35772 216 34 system system NN 35772 216 35 , , , 35772 216 36 known know VBN 35772 216 37 to to IN 35772 216 38 the the DT 35772 216 39 historians historian NNS 35772 216 40 of of IN 35772 216 41 thought thought NN 35772 216 42 as as IN 35772 216 43 Scholasticism Scholasticism NNP 35772 216 44 : : : 35772 216 45 a a DT 35772 216 46 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 216 47 which which WDT 35772 216 48 found find VBD 35772 216 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 216 50 most most RBS 35772 216 51 perfect perfect JJ 35772 216 52 and and CC 35772 216 53 memorable memorable JJ 35772 216 54 expression expression NN 35772 216 55 in in IN 35772 216 56 Thomas Thomas NNP 35772 216 57 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 216 58 ( ( -LRB- 35772 216 59 1227 1227 CD 35772 216 60 - - SYM 35772 216 61 74 74 CD 35772 216 62 ) ) -RRB- 35772 216 63 , , , 35772 216 64 the the DT 35772 216 65 _ _ NNP 35772 216 66 doctor doctor NN 35772 216 67 angelicus angelicus NNP 35772 216 68 _ _ NNP 35772 216 69 of of IN 35772 216 70 Catholic Catholic NNP 35772 216 71 theology theology NN 35772 216 72 , , , 35772 216 73 canonised canonise VBD 35772 216 74 less less JJR 35772 216 75 than than IN 35772 216 76 fifty fifty CD 35772 216 77 years year NNS 35772 216 78 after after IN 35772 216 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 216 80 death death NN 35772 216 81 . . . 35772 217 1 The the DT 35772 217 2 _ _ NNP 35772 217 3 Summa Summa NNP 35772 217 4 Philosophica Philosophica NNP 35772 217 5 _ _ NNP 35772 217 6 , , , 35772 217 7 where where WRB 35772 217 8 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 217 9 deals deal NNS 35772 217 10 with with IN 35772 217 11 the the DT 35772 217 12 rational rational JJ 35772 217 13 foundations foundation NNS 35772 217 14 of of IN 35772 217 15 a a DT 35772 217 16 Christian Christian NNP 35772 217 17 Theism Theism NNP 35772 217 18 , , , 35772 217 19 and and CC 35772 217 20 the the DT 35772 217 21 _ _ NNP 35772 217 22 Summa Summa NNP 35772 217 23 Theologica Theologica NNP 35772 217 24 _ _ NNP 35772 217 25 , , , 35772 217 26 where where WRB 35772 217 27 he -PRON- PRP 35772 217 28 erects erect VBZ 35772 217 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 217 30 elaborate elaborate JJ 35772 217 31 structure structure NN 35772 217 32 of of IN 35772 217 33 theology theology NN 35772 217 34 and and CC 35772 217 35 ethics ethic NNS 35772 217 36 , , , 35772 217 37 together together RB 35772 217 38 constitute constitute VB 35772 217 39 " " '' 35772 217 40 one one CD 35772 217 41 of of IN 35772 217 42 the the DT 35772 217 43 most most RBS 35772 217 44 magnificent magnificent JJ 35772 217 45 monuments monument NNS 35772 217 46 of of IN 35772 217 47 the the DT 35772 217 48 human human JJ 35772 217 49 intellect intellect NN 35772 217 50 , , , 35772 217 51 dwarfing dwarf VBG 35772 217 52 all all DT 35772 217 53 other other JJ 35772 217 54 bodies body NNS 35772 217 55 of of IN 35772 217 56 theology theology NN 35772 217 57 into into IN 35772 217 58 insignificance insignificance NN 35772 217 59 . . . 35772 218 1 " " `` 35772 218 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 218 3 3 3 CD 35772 218 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 218 5 In in IN 35772 218 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 218 7 the the DT 35772 218 8 erudition erudition NN 35772 218 9 of of IN 35772 218 10 an an DT 35772 218 11 epoch epoch NN 35772 218 12 found find VBD 35772 218 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 218 14 spokesman spokesman NN 35772 218 15 ; ; : 35772 218 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 218 17 was be VBD 35772 218 18 the the DT 35772 218 19 personification personification NN 35772 218 20 of of IN 35772 218 21 an an DT 35772 218 22 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 218 23 ideal ideal NN 35772 218 24 . . . 35772 219 1 To to IN 35772 219 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 219 3 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 219 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 219 5 stood stand VBD 35772 219 6 beyond beyond IN 35772 219 7 the the DT 35772 219 8 range range NN 35772 219 9 of of IN 35772 219 10 criticism criticism NN 35772 219 11 . . . 35772 220 1 In in IN 35772 220 2 the the DT 35772 220 3 _ _ NNP 35772 220 4 Paradiso Paradiso NNP 35772 220 5 _ _ NNP 35772 220 6 ( ( -LRB- 35772 220 7 x.8.2 x.8.2 NFP 35772 220 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 220 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 220 10 is be VBZ 35772 220 11 St. St. NNP 35772 220 12 Thomas Thomas NNP 35772 220 13 who who WP 35772 220 14 speaks speak VBZ 35772 220 15 in in IN 35772 220 16 heaven heaven NNP 35772 220 17 . . . 35772 221 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 35772 221 2 , , , 35772 221 3 the the DT 35772 221 4 Scholastic scholastic JJ 35772 221 5 world world NN 35772 221 6 - - HYPH 35772 221 7 scheme scheme NN 35772 221 8 , , , 35772 221 9 though though IN 35772 221 10 based base VBN 35772 221 11 on on IN 35772 221 12 " " `` 35772 221 13 the the DT 35772 221 14 evidence evidence NN 35772 221 15 of of IN 35772 221 16 the the DT 35772 221 17 senses sense NNS 35772 221 18 , , , 35772 221 19 the the DT 35772 221 20 investigations investigation NNS 35772 221 21 of of IN 35772 221 22 antiquity antiquity NN 35772 221 23 , , , 35772 221 24 and and CC 35772 221 25 the the DT 35772 221 26 authority authority NN 35772 221 27 of of IN 35772 221 28 the the DT 35772 221 29 Church Church NNP 35772 221 30 , , , 35772 221 31 " " '' 35772 221 32 and and CC 35772 221 33 though though IN 35772 221 34 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 221 35 had have VBD 35772 221 36 set set VBN 35772 221 37 the the DT 35772 221 38 seal seal NN 35772 221 39 of of IN 35772 221 40 finality finality NN 35772 221 41 upon upon IN 35772 221 42 it -PRON- PRP 35772 221 43 , , , 35772 221 44 was be VBD 35772 221 45 destined destine VBN 35772 221 46 to to IN 35772 221 47 gradual gradual JJ 35772 221 48 discredit discredit NN 35772 221 49 and and CC 35772 221 50 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 221 51 extinction extinction NN 35772 221 52 . . . 35772 222 1 DISINTEGRATION DISINTEGRATION NNP 35772 222 2 BEGINS.--It BEGINS.--It NNP 35772 222 3 was be VBD 35772 222 4 open open JJ 35772 222 5 to to TO 35772 222 6 attack attack VB 35772 222 7 on on IN 35772 222 8 two two CD 35772 222 9 sides side NNS 35772 222 10 . . . 35772 223 1 _ _ NNP 35772 223 2 Either either CC 35772 223 3 _ _ NNP 35772 223 4 observations observation NNS 35772 223 5 or or CC 35772 223 6 calculations calculation NNS 35772 223 7 might may MD 35772 223 8 be be VB 35772 223 9 brought bring VBN 35772 223 10 forward forward RB 35772 223 11 , , , 35772 223 12 conflicting conflict VBG 35772 223 13 with with IN 35772 223 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 223 15 , , , 35772 223 16 or or CC 35772 223 17 making make VBG 35772 223 18 another another DT 35772 223 19 conception conception NN 35772 223 20 possible possible JJ 35772 223 21 or or CC 35772 223 22 probable probable JJ 35772 223 23 : : : 35772 223 24 _ _ NNP 35772 223 25 Or or CC 35772 223 26 _ _ NNP 35772 223 27 the the DT 35772 223 28 validity validity NN 35772 223 29 of of IN 35772 223 30 conventional conventional JJ 35772 223 31 ideas idea NNS 35772 223 32 of of IN 35772 223 33 space space NN 35772 223 34 might may MD 35772 223 35 be be VB 35772 223 36 disputed dispute VBN 35772 223 37 . . . 35772 224 1 The the DT 35772 224 2 latter latter JJ 35772 224 3 type type NN 35772 224 4 of of IN 35772 224 5 criticism criticism NN 35772 224 6 was be VBD 35772 224 7 the the DT 35772 224 8 first first JJ 35772 224 9 to to TO 35772 224 10 occur occur VB 35772 224 11 . . . 35772 225 1 Nicholas Nicholas NNP 35772 225 2 Cusanus Cusanus NNP 35772 225 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 225 4 1401 1401 CD 35772 225 5 - - SYM 35772 225 6 1464 1464 CD 35772 225 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 225 8 , , , 35772 225 9 an an DT 35772 225 10 inhabitant inhabitant NN 35772 225 11 of of IN 35772 225 12 the the DT 35772 225 13 Low Low NNP 35772 225 14 Countries Countries NNPS 35772 225 15 , , , 35772 225 16 subsequently subsequently RB 35772 225 17 bishop bishop NN 35772 225 18 and and CC 35772 225 19 cardinal cardinal NNP 35772 225 20 , , , 35772 225 21 developed develop VBD 35772 225 22 unconventional unconventional JJ 35772 225 23 notions notion NNS 35772 225 24 about about IN 35772 225 25 Space space NN 35772 225 26 . . . 35772 226 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 226 2 suggested suggest VBD 35772 226 3 that that IN 35772 226 4 wherever wherever WRB 35772 226 5 man man NN 35772 226 6 finds find VBZ 35772 226 7 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 226 8 -- -- : 35772 226 9 on on IN 35772 226 10 earth earth NN 35772 226 11 , , , 35772 226 12 sun sun NN 35772 226 13 , , , 35772 226 14 or or CC 35772 226 15 star star NN 35772 226 16 -- -- : 35772 226 17 he -PRON- PRP 35772 226 18 will will MD 35772 226 19 always always RB 35772 226 20 regard regard VB 35772 226 21 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 226 22 as as IN 35772 226 23 standing stand VBG 35772 226 24 at at IN 35772 226 25 the the DT 35772 226 26 centre centre NN 35772 226 27 of of IN 35772 226 28 existence existence NN 35772 226 29 . . . 35772 227 1 There there EX 35772 227 2 is be VBZ 35772 227 3 , , , 35772 227 4 in in IN 35772 227 5 fact fact NN 35772 227 6 , , , 35772 227 7 no no DT 35772 227 8 point point NN 35772 227 9 in in IN 35772 227 10 the the DT 35772 227 11 universe universe NN 35772 227 12 which which WDT 35772 227 13 might may MD 35772 227 14 not not RB 35772 227 15 appropriately appropriately RB 35772 227 16 be be VB 35772 227 17 called call VBN 35772 227 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 227 19 centre centre NN 35772 227 20 , , , 35772 227 21 and and CC 35772 227 22 to to TO 35772 227 23 say say VB 35772 227 24 that that IN 35772 227 25 the the DT 35772 227 26 earth earth NN 35772 227 27 stands stand VBZ 35772 227 28 at at IN 35772 227 29 the the DT 35772 227 30 centre centre NN 35772 227 31 is be VBZ 35772 227 32 only only RB 35772 227 33 ( ( -LRB- 35772 227 34 what what WP 35772 227 35 we -PRON- PRP 35772 227 36 should should MD 35772 227 37 now now RB 35772 227 38 call call VB 35772 227 39 it -PRON- PRP 35772 227 40 ) ) -RRB- 35772 227 41 an an DT 35772 227 42 anthropomorphism anthropomorphism NN 35772 227 43 . . . 35772 228 1 So so RB 35772 228 2 much much JJ 35772 228 3 for for IN 35772 228 4 _ _ NNP 35772 228 5 place place NN 35772 228 6 _ _ NNP 35772 228 7 ; ; : 35772 228 8 and and CC 35772 228 9 similarly similarly RB 35772 228 10 with with IN 35772 228 11 _ _ NNP 35772 228 12 motion motion NN 35772 228 13 _ _ NNP 35772 228 14 . . . 35772 229 1 Here here RB 35772 229 2 , , , 35772 229 3 too too RB 35772 229 4 , , , 35772 229 5 there there EX 35772 229 6 is be VBZ 35772 229 7 no no DT 35772 229 8 absolute absolute JJ 35772 229 9 standard standard NN 35772 229 10 to to TO 35772 229 11 apply apply VB 35772 229 12 : : : 35772 229 13 motion motion NN 35772 229 14 may may MD 35772 229 15 exist exist VB 35772 229 16 , , , 35772 229 17 but but CC 35772 229 18 be be VB 35772 229 19 unnoticed unnoticed JJ 35772 229 20 if if IN 35772 229 21 there there EX 35772 229 22 be be VB 35772 229 23 no no DT 35772 229 24 spot spot NN 35772 229 25 at at IN 35772 229 26 absolute absolute JJ 35772 229 27 rest rest NN 35772 229 28 from from IN 35772 229 29 which which WDT 35772 229 30 to to TO 35772 229 31 take take VB 35772 229 32 bearings bearing NNS 35772 229 33 . . . 35772 230 1 " " `` 35772 230 2 We -PRON- PRP 35772 230 3 are be VBP 35772 230 4 like like IN 35772 230 5 a a DT 35772 230 6 man man NN 35772 230 7 in in IN 35772 230 8 a a DT 35772 230 9 boat boat NN 35772 230 10 sailing sailing NN 35772 230 11 with with IN 35772 230 12 the the DT 35772 230 13 stream stream NN 35772 230 14 , , , 35772 230 15 who who WP 35772 230 16 does do VBZ 35772 230 17 not not RB 35772 230 18 know know VB 35772 230 19 that that IN 35772 230 20 the the DT 35772 230 21 water water NN 35772 230 22 is be VBZ 35772 230 23 flowing flow VBG 35772 230 24 , , , 35772 230 25 and and CC 35772 230 26 who who WP 35772 230 27 can can MD 35772 230 28 not not RB 35772 230 29 see see VB 35772 230 30 the the DT 35772 230 31 banks bank NNS 35772 230 32 : : : 35772 230 33 how how WRB 35772 230 34 is be VBZ 35772 230 35 he -PRON- PRP 35772 230 36 to to TO 35772 230 37 discover discover VB 35772 230 38 whether whether IN 35772 230 39 the the DT 35772 230 40 boat boat NN 35772 230 41 is be VBZ 35772 230 42 moving move VBG 35772 230 43 ? ? . 35772 230 44 " " '' 35772 231 1 Cusanus cusanu NNS 35772 231 2 , , , 35772 231 3 in in IN 35772 231 4 fact fact NN 35772 231 5 , , , 35772 231 6 denies deny VBZ 35772 231 7 the the DT 35772 231 8 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 231 9 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 35772 231 10 dogma dogma NN 35772 231 11 that that IN 35772 231 12 the the DT 35772 231 13 earth earth NN 35772 231 14 is be VBZ 35772 231 15 the the DT 35772 231 16 central central JJ 35772 231 17 point point NN 35772 231 18 of of IN 35772 231 19 the the DT 35772 231 20 universe universe NN 35772 231 21 , , , 35772 231 22 because because IN 35772 231 23 , , , 35772 231 24 on on IN 35772 231 25 general general JJ 35772 231 26 grounds ground NNS 35772 231 27 , , , 35772 231 28 there there RB 35772 231 29 _ _ NNP 35772 231 30 can can MD 35772 231 31 _ _ NNP 35772 231 32 be be VB 35772 231 33 no no DT 35772 231 34 absolute absolute JJ 35772 231 35 central central JJ 35772 231 36 point point NN 35772 231 37 . . . 35772 232 1 This this DT 35772 232 2 gave give VBD 35772 232 3 a a DT 35772 232 4 shock shock NN 35772 232 5 to to IN 35772 232 6 the the DT 35772 232 7 " " `` 35772 232 8 geocentric geocentric JJ 35772 232 9 theory theory NN 35772 232 10 " " '' 35772 232 11 from from IN 35772 232 12 which which WDT 35772 232 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 232 14 never never RB 35772 232 15 recovered recover VBD 35772 232 16 . . . 35772 233 1 Worse bad JJR 35772 233 2 shocks shock NNS 35772 233 3 , , , 35772 233 4 however however RB 35772 233 5 , , , 35772 233 6 were be VBD 35772 233 7 to to TO 35772 233 8 come come VB 35772 233 9 . . . 35772 234 1 The the DT 35772 234 2 name name NN 35772 234 3 of of IN 35772 234 4 the the DT 35772 234 5 man man NN 35772 234 6 who who WP 35772 234 7 actually actually RB 35772 234 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 234 9 as as IN 35772 234 10 Luther Luther NNP 35772 234 11 complained complain VBD 35772 234 12 ) ) -RRB- 35772 234 13 turned turn VBD 35772 234 14 the the DT 35772 234 15 world world NN 35772 234 16 upside upside RB 35772 234 17 down down RB 35772 234 18 , , , 35772 234 19 is be VBZ 35772 234 20 notorious notorious JJ 35772 234 21 enough enough RB 35772 234 22 . . . 35772 235 1 Poles Poles NNPS 35772 235 2 and and CC 35772 235 3 Germans Germans NNPS 35772 235 4 alike alike RB 35772 235 5 have have VBP 35772 235 6 claimed claim VBN 35772 235 7 the the DT 35772 235 8 nationality nationality NN 35772 235 9 of of IN 35772 235 10 Nicolaus Nicolaus NNP 35772 235 11 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 235 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 235 13 1473 1473 CD 35772 235 14 - - SYM 35772 235 15 1543 1543 CD 35772 235 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 235 17 ; ; : 35772 235 18 who who WP 35772 235 19 , , , 35772 235 20 having have VBG 35772 235 21 been be VBN 35772 235 22 a a DT 35772 235 23 student student NN 35772 235 24 at at IN 35772 235 25 Cracow Cracow NNP 35772 235 26 and and CC 35772 235 27 in in IN 35772 235 28 Italy Italy NNP 35772 235 29 , , , 35772 235 30 became become VBD 35772 235 31 a a DT 35772 235 32 prebendary prebendary NN 35772 235 33 in in IN 35772 235 34 Frauenburg Frauenburg NNP 35772 235 35 Cathedral Cathedral NNP 35772 235 36 . . . 35772 236 1 THE the DT 35772 236 2 NEW NEW NNP 35772 236 3 ASTRONOMY.--The astronomy.--the NN 35772 236 4 general general JJ 35772 236 5 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 236 6 of of IN 35772 236 7 Cusanus Cusanus NNP 35772 236 8 were be VBD 35772 236 9 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 236 10 by by IN 35772 236 11 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 236 12 . . . 35772 237 1 The the DT 35772 237 2 senses sense NNS 35772 237 3 can can MD 35772 237 4 not not RB 35772 237 5 inform inform VB 35772 237 6 us -PRON- PRP 35772 237 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 237 8 when when WRB 35772 237 9 any any DT 35772 237 10 motion motion NN 35772 237 11 takes take VBZ 35772 237 12 place place NN 35772 237 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 237 14 _ _ NNP 35772 237 15 what what WP 35772 237 16 _ _ IN 35772 237 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 237 18 is be VBZ 35772 237 19 that that IN 35772 237 20 moves move NNS 35772 237 21 . . . 35772 238 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 238 2 may may MD 35772 238 3 be be VB 35772 238 4 the the DT 35772 238 5 thing thing NN 35772 238 6 perceived perceive VBN 35772 238 7 that that IN 35772 238 8 moves move NNS 35772 238 9 , , , 35772 238 10 or or CC 35772 238 11 the the DT 35772 238 12 percipient percipient NN 35772 238 13 -- -- : 35772 238 14 or or CC 35772 238 15 both both DT 35772 238 16 . . . 35772 239 1 And and CC 35772 239 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 239 3 would would MD 35772 239 4 be be VB 35772 239 5 _ _ NNP 35772 239 6 possible possible JJ 35772 239 7 _ _ NNP 35772 239 8 to to TO 35772 239 9 account account VB 35772 239 10 for for IN 35772 239 11 the the DT 35772 239 12 movements movement NNS 35772 239 13 of of IN 35772 239 14 celestial celestial JJ 35772 239 15 bodies body NNS 35772 239 16 by by IN 35772 239 17 the the DT 35772 239 18 supposition supposition NN 35772 239 19 that that IN 35772 239 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 239 21 is be VBZ 35772 239 22 the the DT 35772 239 23 earth earth NN 35772 239 24 that that WDT 35772 239 25 moves move VBZ 35772 239 26 , , , 35772 239 27 and and CC 35772 239 28 not not RB 35772 239 29 they -PRON- PRP 35772 239 30 . . . 35772 240 1 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 240 2 ' ' POS 35772 240 3 whole whole JJ 35772 240 4 work work NN 35772 240 5 consisted consist VBD 35772 240 6 in in IN 35772 240 7 the the DT 35772 240 8 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 240 9 demonstration demonstration NN 35772 240 10 that that IN 35772 240 11 this this DT 35772 240 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 240 13 could could MD 35772 240 14 account account VB 35772 240 15 for for IN 35772 240 16 the the DT 35772 240 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 240 18 as as IN 35772 240 19 we -PRON- PRP 35772 240 20 observe observe VBP 35772 240 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 240 22 . . . 35772 241 1 In in IN 35772 241 2 fact fact NN 35772 241 3 , , , 35772 241 4 when when WRB 35772 241 5 these these DT 35772 241 6 demonstrations demonstration NNS 35772 241 7 were be VBD 35772 241 8 eventually eventually RB 35772 241 9 published publish VBN 35772 241 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 241 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 241 12 was be VBD 35772 241 13 only only RB 35772 241 14 on on IN 35772 241 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 241 16 death death NN 35772 241 17 - - HYPH 35772 241 18 bed bed NN 35772 241 19 that that WDT 35772 241 20 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 241 21 received receive VBD 35772 241 22 a a DT 35772 241 23 copy copy NN 35772 241 24 of of IN 35772 241 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 241 26 book book NN 35772 241 27 -- -- : 35772 241 28 and and CC 35772 241 29 he -PRON- PRP 35772 241 30 had have VBD 35772 241 31 already already RB 35772 241 32 lost lose VBN 35772 241 33 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 241 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 241 35 they -PRON- PRP 35772 241 36 were be VBD 35772 241 37 introduced introduce VBN 35772 241 38 by by IN 35772 241 39 a a DT 35772 241 40 discreet discreet NN 35772 241 41 preface preface NN 35772 241 42 , , , 35772 241 43 which which WDT 35772 241 44 intimated intimate VBD 35772 241 45 that that IN 35772 241 46 the the DT 35772 241 47 whole whole JJ 35772 241 48 thing thing NN 35772 241 49 might may MD 35772 241 50 safely safely RB 35772 241 51 be be VB 35772 241 52 regarded regard VBN 35772 241 53 as as IN 35772 241 54 a a DT 35772 241 55 _ _ NNP 35772 241 56 jeu jeu NN 35772 241 57 d'esprit d'esprit NNP 35772 241 58 _ _ NNP 35772 241 59 on on IN 35772 241 60 the the DT 35772 241 61 part part NN 35772 241 62 of of IN 35772 241 63 an an DT 35772 241 64 eccentric eccentric JJ 35772 241 65 mathematician mathematician NN 35772 241 66 . . . 35772 242 1 And and CC 35772 242 2 this this DT 35772 242 3 editorial editorial NN 35772 242 4 _ _ NNP 35772 242 5 caveto caveto NNP 35772 242 6 _ _ NNP 35772 242 7 , , , 35772 242 8 though though IN 35772 242 9 written write VBN 35772 242 10 by by IN 35772 242 11 another another DT 35772 242 12 hand hand NN 35772 242 13 , , , 35772 242 14 preserved preserve VBD 35772 242 15 the the DT 35772 242 16 Copernican copernican JJ 35772 242 17 theories theory NNS 35772 242 18 from from IN 35772 242 19 the the DT 35772 242 20 notoriety notoriety NN 35772 242 21 that that WDT 35772 242 22 might may MD 35772 242 23 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 242 24 have have VB 35772 242 25 attended attend VBN 35772 242 26 , , , 35772 242 27 and and CC 35772 242 28 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 242 29 did do VBD 35772 242 30 attend attend VB 35772 242 31 , , , 35772 242 32 them -PRON- PRP 35772 242 33 . . . 35772 243 1 Copernican copernican JJ 35772 243 2 conceptions conception NNS 35772 243 3 were be VBD 35772 243 4 semi semi JJ 35772 243 5 - - JJ 35772 243 6 traditional traditional JJ 35772 243 7 . . . 35772 244 1 The the DT 35772 244 2 sun sun NN 35772 244 3 displaces displace VBZ 35772 244 4 the the DT 35772 244 5 earth earth NN 35772 244 6 as as IN 35772 244 7 the the DT 35772 244 8 central central JJ 35772 244 9 point point NN 35772 244 10 of of IN 35772 244 11 the the DT 35772 244 12 universe universe NN 35772 244 13 : : : 35772 244 14 around around IN 35772 244 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 244 16 revolve revolve VB 35772 244 17 the the DT 35772 244 18 planets planet NNS 35772 244 19 -- -- : 35772 244 20 including include VBG 35772 244 21 the the DT 35772 244 22 earth earth NN 35772 244 23 ; ; : 35772 244 24 and and CC 35772 244 25 , , , 35772 244 26 at at IN 35772 244 27 an an DT 35772 244 28 immeasurable immeasurable JJ 35772 244 29 distance distance NN 35772 244 30 , , , 35772 244 31 is be VBZ 35772 244 32 the the DT 35772 244 33 immovable immovable JJ 35772 244 34 heaven heaven NN 35772 244 35 of of IN 35772 244 36 the the DT 35772 244 37 fixed fix VBN 35772 244 38 stars star NNS 35772 244 39 . . . 35772 245 1 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 245 2 left leave VBD 35772 245 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 245 4 an an DT 35772 245 5 open open JJ 35772 245 6 question question NN 35772 245 7 whether whether IN 35772 245 8 or or CC 35772 245 9 no no UH 35772 245 10 the the DT 35772 245 11 universe universe NN 35772 245 12 was be VBD 35772 245 13 infinite infinite JJ 35772 245 14 . . . 35772 246 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 246 2 remained remain VBD 35772 246 3 for for IN 35772 246 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 246 5 successor successor NN 35772 246 6 , , , 35772 246 7 the the DT 35772 246 8 greatest great JJS 35772 246 9 of of IN 35772 246 10 the the DT 35772 246 11 Renaissance Renaissance NNP 35772 246 12 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 246 13 , , , 35772 246 14 Giordano Giordano NNP 35772 246 15 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 246 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 246 17 1548 1548 CD 35772 246 18 - - SYM 35772 246 19 1600 1600 CD 35772 246 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 246 21 to to TO 35772 246 22 declare declare VB 35772 246 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 246 24 to to TO 35772 246 25 be be VB 35772 246 26 limitless limitless JJ 35772 246 27 , , , 35772 246 28 and and CC 35772 246 29 to to TO 35772 246 30 contain contain VB 35772 246 31 an an DT 35772 246 32 infinity infinity NN 35772 246 33 of of IN 35772 246 34 worlds world NNS 35772 246 35 like like IN 35772 246 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 246 37 own own JJ 35772 246 38 . . . 35772 247 1 The the DT 35772 247 2 fixed fixed JJ 35772 247 3 stars star NNS 35772 247 4 became become VBD 35772 247 5 , , , 35772 247 6 for for IN 35772 247 7 him -PRON- PRP 35772 247 8 , , , 35772 247 9 suns sun NNS 35772 247 10 surrounded surround VBN 35772 247 11 by by IN 35772 247 12 planets planet NNS 35772 247 13 . . . 35772 248 1 The the DT 35772 248 2 traditional traditional JJ 35772 248 3 distinction distinction NN 35772 248 4 between between IN 35772 248 5 the the DT 35772 248 6 celestial celestial JJ 35772 248 7 and and CC 35772 248 8 sublunary sublunary JJ 35772 248 9 spheres sphere NNS 35772 248 10 had have VBD 35772 248 11 vanished vanish VBN 35772 248 12 . . . 35772 249 1 The the DT 35772 249 2 bewilderment bewilderment NN 35772 249 3 and and CC 35772 249 4 indignation indignation NN 35772 249 5 excited excite VBN 35772 249 6 by by IN 35772 249 7 these these DT 35772 249 8 ideas idea NNS 35772 249 9 , , , 35772 249 10 revolting revolt VBG 35772 249 11 to to IN 35772 249 12 the the DT 35772 249 13 conscience conscience NN 35772 249 14 of of IN 35772 249 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 249 16 time time NN 35772 249 17 , , , 35772 249 18 cost cost VBP 35772 249 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 249 20 author author NN 35772 249 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 249 22 life life NN 35772 249 23 . . . 35772 250 1 GALILEO.--The galileo.--the JJ 35772 250 2 criticism criticism NN 35772 250 3 of of IN 35772 250 4 the the DT 35772 250 5 old old JJ 35772 250 6 world world NN 35772 250 7 - - HYPH 35772 250 8 conceptions conception NNS 35772 250 9 was be VBD 35772 250 10 , , , 35772 250 11 however however RB 35772 250 12 , , , 35772 250 13 to to TO 35772 250 14 be be VB 35772 250 15 based base VBN 35772 250 16 on on IN 35772 250 17 yet yet RB 35772 250 18 more more RBR 35772 250 19 sure sure JJ 35772 250 20 ground ground NN 35772 250 21 by by IN 35772 250 22 one one CD 35772 250 23 who who WP 35772 250 24 relied rely VBD 35772 250 25 , , , 35772 250 26 not not RB 35772 250 27 on on IN 35772 250 28 general general JJ 35772 250 29 considerations consideration NNS 35772 250 30 , , , 35772 250 31 but but CC 35772 250 32 on on IN 35772 250 33 observation observation NN 35772 250 34 and and CC 35772 250 35 experiment experiment NN 35772 250 36 . . . 35772 251 1 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 251 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 251 3 1564 1564 CD 35772 251 4 - - SYM 35772 251 5 1642 1642 CD 35772 251 6 ) ) -RRB- 35772 251 7 studied study VBN 35772 251 8 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 251 9 , , , 35772 251 10 physics physics NN 35772 251 11 , , , 35772 251 12 and and CC 35772 251 13 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 251 14 at at IN 35772 251 15 Pisa Pisa NNP 35772 251 16 ; ; : 35772 251 17 and and CC 35772 251 18 as as IN 35772 251 19 professor professor NNP 35772 251 20 expounded expound VBD 35772 251 21 the the DT 35772 251 22 old old JJ 35772 251 23 astronomy astronomy NN 35772 251 24 long long RB 35772 251 25 after after IN 35772 251 26 he -PRON- PRP 35772 251 27 had have VBD 35772 251 28 ceased cease VBN 35772 251 29 to to TO 35772 251 30 regard regard VB 35772 251 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 251 32 as as IN 35772 251 33 adequate adequate JJ 35772 251 34 . . . 35772 252 1 Not not RB 35772 252 2 until until IN 35772 252 3 1610 1610 CD 35772 252 4 , , , 35772 252 5 after after IN 35772 252 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 252 7 had have VBD 35772 252 8 constructed construct VBN 35772 252 9 a a DT 35772 252 10 telescope telescope NN 35772 252 11 and and CC 35772 252 12 observed observe VBD 35772 252 13 the the DT 35772 252 14 satellites satellite NNS 35772 252 15 of of IN 35772 252 16 Jupiter Jupiter NNP 35772 252 17 , , , 35772 252 18 did do VBD 35772 252 19 he -PRON- PRP 35772 252 20 openly openly RB 35772 252 21 confess confess VB 35772 252 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 252 23 adherence adherence NN 35772 252 24 to to IN 35772 252 25 the the DT 35772 252 26 system system NN 35772 252 27 of of IN 35772 252 28 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 252 29 . . . 35772 253 1 The the DT 35772 253 2 observation observation NN 35772 253 3 of of IN 35772 253 4 sun sun NN 35772 253 5 - - HYPH 35772 253 6 spots spot NNS 35772 253 7 and and CC 35772 253 8 the the DT 35772 253 9 phases phase NNS 35772 253 10 of of IN 35772 253 11 Venus Venus NNP 35772 253 12 confirmed confirm VBD 35772 253 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 253 14 opinion opinion NN 35772 253 15 . . . 35772 254 1 Aristotelian aristotelian JJ 35772 254 2 astronomers astronomer NNS 35772 254 3 declined decline VBD 35772 254 4 to to TO 35772 254 5 witness witness VB 35772 254 6 these these DT 35772 254 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 254 8 through through IN 35772 254 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 254 10 telescope telescope NN 35772 254 11 , , , 35772 254 12 and and CC 35772 254 13 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 254 14 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 254 15 was be VBD 35772 254 16 right right RB 35772 254 17 in in IN 35772 254 18 observing observe VBG 35772 254 19 with with IN 35772 254 20 a a DT 35772 254 21 sigh sigh NN 35772 254 22 that that WDT 35772 254 23 were be VBD 35772 254 24 the the DT 35772 254 25 stars star NNS 35772 254 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 254 27 to to TO 35772 254 28 descend descend VB 35772 254 29 from from IN 35772 254 30 heaven heaven NNP 35772 254 31 to to TO 35772 254 32 bear bear VB 35772 254 33 him -PRON- PRP 35772 254 34 witness witness NN 35772 254 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 254 36 critics critic NNS 35772 254 37 would would MD 35772 254 38 remain remain VB 35772 254 39 obdurate obdurate JJ 35772 254 40 . . . 35772 255 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 255 2 4 4 CD 35772 255 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 255 4 It -PRON- PRP 35772 255 5 was be VBD 35772 255 6 not not RB 35772 255 7 until until IN 35772 255 8 1632 1632 CD 35772 255 9 that that IN 35772 255 10 a a DT 35772 255 11 complete complete JJ 35772 255 12 exposition exposition NN 35772 255 13 of of IN 35772 255 14 the the DT 35772 255 15 conflict conflict NN 35772 255 16 between between IN 35772 255 17 the the DT 35772 255 18 two two CD 35772 255 19 world world NN 35772 255 20 - - HYPH 35772 255 21 systems system NNS 35772 255 22 was be VBD 35772 255 23 produced produce VBN 35772 255 24 by by IN 35772 255 25 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 255 26 . . . 35772 256 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 256 2 took take VBD 35772 256 3 the the DT 35772 256 4 form form NN 35772 256 5 of of IN 35772 256 6 a a DT 35772 256 7 dialogue dialogue NN 35772 256 8 between between IN 35772 256 9 three three CD 35772 256 10 speakers speaker NNS 35772 256 11 -- -- : 35772 256 12 conservative conservative JJ 35772 256 13 , , , 35772 256 14 mediating mediate VBG 35772 256 15 , , , 35772 256 16 and and CC 35772 256 17 extreme extreme JJ 35772 256 18 . . . 35772 257 1 The the DT 35772 257 2 views view NNS 35772 257 3 of of IN 35772 257 4 the the DT 35772 257 5 author author NN 35772 257 6 , , , 35772 257 7 however however RB 35772 257 8 , , , 35772 257 9 were be VBD 35772 257 10 not not RB 35772 257 11 sufficiently sufficiently RB 35772 257 12 concealed conceal VBN 35772 257 13 , , , 35772 257 14 the the DT 35772 257 15 book book NN 35772 257 16 was be VBD 35772 257 17 prohibited prohibit VBN 35772 257 18 , , , 35772 257 19 and and CC 35772 257 20 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 257 21 summoned summon VBD 35772 257 22 to to IN 35772 257 23 Rome Rome NNP 35772 257 24 , , , 35772 257 25 and and CC 35772 257 26 upon upon IN 35772 257 27 threat threat NN 35772 257 28 of of IN 35772 257 29 torture torture NN 35772 257 30 , , , 35772 257 31 subdued subdue VBD 35772 257 32 into into IN 35772 257 33 a a DT 35772 257 34 recantation recantation NN 35772 257 35 and and CC 35772 257 36 a a DT 35772 257 37 promise promise NN 35772 257 38 not not RB 35772 257 39 to to TO 35772 257 40 offend offend VB 35772 257 41 in in IN 35772 257 42 the the DT 35772 257 43 future future NN 35772 257 44 . . . 35772 258 1 That that IN 35772 258 2 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 258 3 perjured perjure VBD 35772 258 4 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 258 5 is be VBZ 35772 258 6 not not RB 35772 258 7 open open JJ 35772 258 8 to to IN 35772 258 9 doubt doubt VB 35772 258 10 , , , 35772 258 11 nor nor CC 35772 258 12 did do VBD 35772 258 13 he -PRON- PRP 35772 258 14 change change VB 35772 258 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 258 16 convictions conviction NNS 35772 258 17 . . . 35772 259 1 A a DT 35772 259 2 subsequent subsequent JJ 35772 259 3 work work NN 35772 259 4 , , , 35772 259 5 surreptitiously surreptitiously RB 35772 259 6 printed print VBN 35772 259 7 in in IN 35772 259 8 Holland Holland NNP 35772 259 9 , , , 35772 259 10 contained contain VBD 35772 259 11 the the DT 35772 259 12 same same JJ 35772 259 13 heresies heresy NNS 35772 259 14 expressed express VBN 35772 259 15 with with IN 35772 259 16 less less JJR 35772 259 17 reserve reserve NN 35772 259 18 . . . 35772 260 1 THE the DT 35772 260 2 NEW new JJ 35772 260 3 PHYSICS.--It physics.--it NN 35772 260 4 might may MD 35772 260 5 be be VB 35772 260 6 said say VBN 35772 260 7 , , , 35772 260 8 then then RB 35772 260 9 , , , 35772 260 10 that that IN 35772 260 11 the the DT 35772 260 12 fabric fabric NN 35772 260 13 of of IN 35772 260 14 the the DT 35772 260 15 universe universe NN 35772 260 16 had have VBD 35772 260 17 been be VBN 35772 260 18 reconstructed reconstruct VBN 35772 260 19 by by IN 35772 260 20 the the DT 35772 260 21 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 260 22 whose whose WP$ 35772 260 23 explorations exploration NNS 35772 260 24 we -PRON- PRP 35772 260 25 have have VBP 35772 260 26 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 260 27 followed follow VBN 35772 260 28 . . . 35772 261 1 This this DT 35772 261 2 achievement achievement NN 35772 261 3 , , , 35772 261 4 however however RB 35772 261 5 , , , 35772 261 6 though though IN 35772 261 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 35772 261 8 startling startling JJ 35772 261 9 in in IN 35772 261 10 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 261 11 , , , 35772 261 12 was be VBD 35772 261 13 not not RB 35772 261 14 the the DT 35772 261 15 only only JJ 35772 261 16 , , , 35772 261 17 and and CC 35772 261 18 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 261 19 not not RB 35772 261 20 the the DT 35772 261 21 most most RBS 35772 261 22 important important JJ 35772 261 23 , , , 35772 261 24 of of IN 35772 261 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 261 26 performances performance NNS 35772 261 27 . . . 35772 262 1 The the DT 35772 262 2 question question NN 35772 262 3 still still RB 35772 262 4 awaited await VBD 35772 262 5 solution solution NN 35772 262 6 : : : 35772 262 7 _ _ NNP 35772 262 8 By by IN 35772 262 9 what what WDT 35772 262 10 forces force NNS 35772 262 11 and and CC 35772 262 12 laws law NNS 35772 262 13 is be VBZ 35772 262 14 the the DT 35772 262 15 new new JJ 35772 262 16 world world NN 35772 262 17 - - HYPH 35772 262 18 system system NN 35772 262 19 maintained maintain VBD 35772 262 20 in in IN 35772 262 21 activity activity NN 35772 262 22 ? ? . 35772 262 23 _ _ NNP 35772 262 24 The the DT 35772 262 25 traditional traditional JJ 35772 262 26 reply reply NN 35772 262 27 had have VBD 35772 262 28 been be VBN 35772 262 29 that that IN 35772 262 30 the the DT 35772 262 31 universe universe NN 35772 262 32 was be VBD 35772 262 33 kept keep VBN 35772 262 34 in in IN 35772 262 35 motion motion NN 35772 262 36 by by IN 35772 262 37 the the DT 35772 262 38 operation operation NN 35772 262 39 of of IN 35772 262 40 the the DT 35772 262 41 Deity Deity NNP 35772 262 42 . . . 35772 263 1 While while IN 35772 263 2 the the DT 35772 263 3 truth truth NN 35772 263 4 of of IN 35772 263 5 this this DT 35772 263 6 reply reply NN 35772 263 7 was be VBD 35772 263 8 not not RB 35772 263 9 questioned question VBN 35772 263 10 by by IN 35772 263 11 the the DT 35772 263 12 advocates advocate NNS 35772 263 13 of of IN 35772 263 14 the the DT 35772 263 15 " " `` 35772 263 16 new new JJ 35772 263 17 " " '' 35772 263 18 science science NN 35772 263 19 , , , 35772 263 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 263 21 did do VBD 35772 263 22 not not RB 35772 263 23 seem seem VB 35772 263 24 to to IN 35772 263 25 them -PRON- PRP 35772 263 26 to to TO 35772 263 27 dispel dispel VB 35772 263 28 the the DT 35772 263 29 obscurity obscurity NN 35772 263 30 surrounding surround VBG 35772 263 31 certain certain JJ 35772 263 32 points point NNS 35772 263 33 about about IN 35772 263 34 which which WDT 35772 263 35 they -PRON- PRP 35772 263 36 required require VBD 35772 263 37 information information NN 35772 263 38 . . . 35772 264 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 264 2 was be VBD 35772 264 3 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 264 4 who who WP 35772 264 5 observed observe VBD 35772 264 6 that that IN 35772 264 7 the the DT 35772 264 8 appeal appeal NN 35772 264 9 to to IN 35772 264 10 the the DT 35772 264 11 divine divine NNP 35772 264 12 will will MD 35772 264 13 explains explain VBZ 35772 264 14 nothing nothing NN 35772 264 15 just just RB 35772 264 16 because because IN 35772 264 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 264 18 explains explain VBZ 35772 264 19 everything everything NN 35772 264 20 . . . 35772 265 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 265 2 takes take VBZ 35772 265 3 the the DT 35772 265 4 inquirer inquirer NN 35772 265 5 back back RB 35772 265 6 too too RB 35772 265 7 far far RB 35772 265 8 -- -- : 35772 265 9 behind behind IN 35772 265 10 those those DT 35772 265 11 details detail NNS 35772 265 12 of of IN 35772 265 13 method method NN 35772 265 14 which which WDT 35772 265 15 arouse arouse VBP 35772 265 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 265 17 speculative speculative JJ 35772 265 18 interest interest NN 35772 265 19 . . . 35772 266 1 This this DT 35772 266 2 desire desire NN 35772 266 3 to to TO 35772 266 4 understand understand VB 35772 266 5 those those DT 35772 266 6 methods method NNS 35772 266 7 of of IN 35772 266 8 operation operation NN 35772 266 9 which which WDT 35772 266 10 natural natural JJ 35772 266 11 objects object NNS 35772 266 12 appear appear VBP 35772 266 13 to to TO 35772 266 14 follow follow VB 35772 266 15 , , , 35772 266 16 led lead VBN 35772 266 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 266 18 to to TO 35772 266 19 enunciate enunciate VB 35772 266 20 certain certain JJ 35772 266 21 " " `` 35772 266 22 laws law NNS 35772 266 23 " " '' 35772 266 24 about about IN 35772 266 25 them -PRON- PRP 35772 266 26 . . . 35772 267 1 These these DT 35772 267 2 served serve VBD 35772 267 3 as as IN 35772 267 4 " " `` 35772 267 5 explanations explanation NNS 35772 267 6 " " '' 35772 267 7 of of IN 35772 267 8 particular particular JJ 35772 267 9 classes class NNS 35772 267 10 of of IN 35772 267 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 267 12 . . . 35772 268 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 268 2 was be VBD 35772 268 3 the the DT 35772 268 4 phenomena phenomena NN 35772 268 5 of of IN 35772 268 6 _ _ NNP 35772 268 7 motion motion NN 35772 268 8 _ _ NNP 35772 268 9 that that DT 35772 268 10 especially especially RB 35772 268 11 attracted attract VBD 35772 268 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 268 13 attention attention NN 35772 268 14 ; ; : 35772 268 15 and and CC 35772 268 16 many many JJ 35772 268 17 ingenious ingenious JJ 35772 268 18 experiments experiment NNS 35772 268 19 were be VBD 35772 268 20 performed perform VBN 35772 268 21 by by IN 35772 268 22 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 268 23 , , , 35772 268 24 in in IN 35772 268 25 particular particular JJ 35772 268 26 , , , 35772 268 27 which which WDT 35772 268 28 led lead VBD 35772 268 29 him -PRON- PRP 35772 268 30 to to IN 35772 268 31 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 268 32 which which WDT 35772 268 33 then then RB 35772 268 34 seemed seem VBD 35772 268 35 paradoxical paradoxical JJ 35772 268 36 , , , 35772 268 37 but but CC 35772 268 38 now now RB 35772 268 39 serve serve VBP 35772 268 40 as as IN 35772 268 41 axioms axiom NNS 35772 268 42 of of IN 35772 268 43 physical physical JJ 35772 268 44 science science NN 35772 268 45 ; ; : 35772 268 46 for for IN 35772 268 47 " " `` 35772 268 48 the the DT 35772 268 49 laws law NNS 35772 268 50 of of IN 35772 268 51 motion motion NN 35772 268 52 contain contain VB 35772 268 53 the the DT 35772 268 54 key key NN 35772 268 55 to to IN 35772 268 56 all all DT 35772 268 57 scientific scientific JJ 35772 268 58 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 268 59 of of IN 35772 268 60 material material JJ 35772 268 61 nature nature NN 35772 268 62 . . . 35772 268 63 " " '' 35772 269 1 When when WRB 35772 269 2 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 269 3 , , , 35772 269 4 after after IN 35772 269 5 careful careful JJ 35772 269 6 experiment experiment NN 35772 269 7 , , , 35772 269 8 established establish VBD 35772 269 9 the the DT 35772 269 10 proposition proposition NN 35772 269 11 that that IN 35772 269 12 a a DT 35772 269 13 body body NN 35772 269 14 can can MD 35772 269 15 neither neither CC 35772 269 16 change change VB 35772 269 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 269 18 motion motion NN 35772 269 19 of of IN 35772 269 20 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 269 21 , , , 35772 269 22 nor nor CC 35772 269 23 pass pass VB 35772 269 24 from from IN 35772 269 25 motion motion NN 35772 269 26 to to IN 35772 269 27 rest rest VB 35772 269 28 , , , 35772 269 29 the the DT 35772 269 30 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 269 31 " " `` 35772 269 32 law law NN 35772 269 33 of of IN 35772 269 34 inertia"--of inertia"--of NN 35772 269 35 such such JJ 35772 269 36 incalculable incalculable JJ 35772 269 37 importance importance NN 35772 269 38 to to IN 35772 269 39 the the DT 35772 269 40 development development NN 35772 269 41 of of IN 35772 269 42 modern modern JJ 35772 269 43 physics physics NN 35772 269 44 -- -- : 35772 269 45 had have VBD 35772 269 46 been be VBN 35772 269 47 established establish VBN 35772 269 48 . . . 35772 270 1 AN an DT 35772 270 2 AUTOMATIC AUTOMATIC NNP 35772 270 3 UNIVERSE.--A universe.--a XX 35772 270 4 proposition proposition NN 35772 270 5 of of IN 35772 270 6 this this DT 35772 270 7 kind kind NN 35772 270 8 may may MD 35772 270 9 not not RB 35772 270 10 at at IN 35772 270 11 first first RB 35772 270 12 seem seem VB 35772 270 13 to to TO 35772 270 14 involve involve VB 35772 270 15 important important JJ 35772 270 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 270 17 or or CC 35772 270 18 theological theological JJ 35772 270 19 consequences consequence NNS 35772 270 20 . . . 35772 271 1 But but CC 35772 271 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 271 3 only only RB 35772 271 4 have have VBP 35772 271 5 to to TO 35772 271 6 consider consider VB 35772 271 7 that that IN 35772 271 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 271 9 provided provide VBD 35772 271 10 a a DT 35772 271 11 natural natural JJ 35772 271 12 explanation explanation NN 35772 271 13 of of IN 35772 271 14 the the DT 35772 271 15 continued continued JJ 35772 271 16 and and CC 35772 271 17 untiring untire VBG 35772 271 18 motion motion NN 35772 271 19 of of IN 35772 271 20 the the DT 35772 271 21 heavenly heavenly JJ 35772 271 22 bodies body NNS 35772 271 23 . . . 35772 272 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 272 2 did do VBD 35772 272 3 not not RB 35772 272 4 , , , 35772 272 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 272 6 is be VBZ 35772 272 7 true true JJ 35772 272 8 , , , 35772 272 9 explain explain VB 35772 272 10 how how WRB 35772 272 11 that that DT 35772 272 12 motion motion NN 35772 272 13 arose arise VBD 35772 272 14 ; ; : 35772 272 15 but but CC 35772 272 16 the the DT 35772 272 17 motion motion NN 35772 272 18 being be VBG 35772 272 19 " " `` 35772 272 20 given give VBN 35772 272 21 , , , 35772 272 22 " " '' 35772 272 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 272 24 had have VBD 35772 272 25 now now RB 35772 272 26 been be VBN 35772 272 27 shown show VBN 35772 272 28 how how WRB 35772 272 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 272 30 would would MD 35772 272 31 , , , 35772 272 32 in in IN 35772 272 33 the the DT 35772 272 34 absence absence NN 35772 272 35 of of IN 35772 272 36 obstructions obstruction NNS 35772 272 37 , , , 35772 272 38 be be VB 35772 272 39 perpetual perpetual JJ 35772 272 40 . . . 35772 273 1 In in IN 35772 273 2 fact fact NN 35772 273 3 , , , 35772 273 4 speculations speculation NNS 35772 273 5 of of IN 35772 273 6 this this DT 35772 273 7 kind kind NN 35772 273 8 opened open VBD 35772 273 9 up up RP 35772 273 10 the the DT 35772 273 11 way way NN 35772 273 12 to to IN 35772 273 13 the the DT 35772 273 14 _ _ NNP 35772 273 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 273 16 _ _ NNP 35772 273 17 explanation explanation NN 35772 273 18 of of IN 35772 273 19 nature nature NN 35772 273 20 , , , 35772 273 21 a a DT 35772 273 22 theory theory NN 35772 273 23 which which WDT 35772 273 24 had have VBD 35772 273 25 been be VBN 35772 273 26 already already RB 35772 273 27 speculatively speculatively RB 35772 273 28 held hold VBN 35772 273 29 by by IN 35772 273 30 Leonardo Leonardo NNP 35772 273 31 da da NNP 35772 273 32 Vinci Vinci NNP 35772 273 33 , , , 35772 273 34 who who WP 35772 273 35 is be VBZ 35772 273 36 already already RB 35772 273 37 convinced convince VBN 35772 273 38 that that IN 35772 273 39 " " `` 35772 273 40 necessity necessity NN 35772 273 41 is be VBZ 35772 273 42 the the DT 35772 273 43 eternal eternal JJ 35772 273 44 bond bond NN 35772 273 45 , , , 35772 273 46 the the DT 35772 273 47 eternal eternal JJ 35772 273 48 rule rule NN 35772 273 49 of of IN 35772 273 50 Nature Nature NNP 35772 273 51 . . . 35772 273 52 " " '' 35772 274 1 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 274 2 AND and CC 35772 274 3 MATHEMATICS.--It MATHEMATICS.--It NNP 35772 274 4 was be VBD 35772 274 5 not not RB 35772 274 6 only only RB 35772 274 7 , , , 35772 274 8 however however RB 35772 274 9 , , , 35772 274 10 the the DT 35772 274 11 spectacle spectacle NN 35772 274 12 of of IN 35772 274 13 a a DT 35772 274 14 system system NN 35772 274 15 running run VBG 35772 274 16 automatically automatically RB 35772 274 17 that that WDT 35772 274 18 suggested suggest VBD 35772 274 19 to to IN 35772 274 20 observers observer NNS 35772 274 21 a a DT 35772 274 22 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 274 23 theory theory NN 35772 274 24 to to TO 35772 274 25 explain explain VB 35772 274 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 274 27 . . . 35772 275 1 There there EX 35772 275 2 was be VBD 35772 275 3 also also RB 35772 275 4 the the DT 35772 275 5 fact fact NN 35772 275 6 that that IN 35772 275 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 275 8 were be VBD 35772 275 9 observed observe VBN 35772 275 10 to to TO 35772 275 11 occur occur VB 35772 275 12 in in IN 35772 275 13 accordance accordance NN 35772 275 14 with with IN 35772 275 15 certain certain JJ 35772 275 16 simple simple JJ 35772 275 17 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 275 18 laws law NNS 35772 275 19 . . . 35772 276 1 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 276 2 's 's POS 35772 276 3 experiments experiment NNS 35772 276 4 with with IN 35772 276 5 falling fall VBG 35772 276 6 bodies body NNS 35772 276 7 led lead VBD 35772 276 8 him -PRON- PRP 35772 276 9 to to IN 35772 276 10 foreshadow foreshadow NNP 35772 276 11 principles principle NNS 35772 276 12 which which WDT 35772 276 13 were be VBD 35772 276 14 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 276 15 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 276 16 and and CC 35772 276 17 fully fully RB 35772 276 18 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 35772 276 19 by by IN 35772 276 20 Newton Newton NNP 35772 276 21 , , , 35772 276 22 who who WP 35772 276 23 may may MD 35772 276 24 be be VB 35772 276 25 said say VBN 35772 276 26 to to TO 35772 276 27 have have VB 35772 276 28 been be VBN 35772 276 29 the the DT 35772 276 30 first first JJ 35772 276 31 to to TO 35772 276 32 construct construct VB 35772 276 33 a a DT 35772 276 34 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 276 35 universe universe NN 35772 276 36 . . . 35772 277 1 The the DT 35772 277 2 principle principle NN 35772 277 3 had have VBD 35772 277 4 already already RB 35772 277 5 been be VBN 35772 277 6 formulated formulate VBN 35772 277 7 by by IN 35772 277 8 a a DT 35772 277 9 contemporary contemporary NN 35772 277 10 of of IN 35772 277 11 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 277 12 -- -- : 35772 277 13 Johannes Johannes NNP 35772 277 14 Kepler Kepler NNP 35772 277 15 -- -- : 35772 277 16 in in IN 35772 277 17 the the DT 35772 277 18 axiom axiom NN 35772 277 19 _ _ NNP 35772 277 20 ubi ubi NNP 35772 277 21 materia materia NNP 35772 277 22 , , , 35772 277 23 ibi ibi NNP 35772 277 24 geometria geometria NNP 35772 277 25 _ _ NNP 35772 277 26 . . . 35772 278 1 RESULTS.--The RESULTS.--The NNP 35772 278 2 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 278 3 whose whose WP$ 35772 278 4 speculations speculation NNS 35772 278 5 have have VBP 35772 278 6 engaged engage VBN 35772 278 7 us -PRON- PRP 35772 278 8 were be VBD 35772 278 9 indeed indeed RB 35772 278 10 responsible responsible JJ 35772 278 11 for for IN 35772 278 12 creating create VBG 35772 278 13 a a DT 35772 278 14 revolution revolution NN 35772 278 15 in in IN 35772 278 16 ideas idea NNS 35772 278 17 . . . 35772 279 1 For for IN 35772 279 2 a a DT 35772 279 3 finite finite JJ 35772 279 4 universe universe NN 35772 279 5 whose whose WP$ 35772 279 6 centre centre NN 35772 279 7 was be VBD 35772 279 8 the the DT 35772 279 9 earth earth NN 35772 279 10 , , , 35772 279 11 and and CC 35772 279 12 which which WDT 35772 279 13 was be VBD 35772 279 14 kept keep VBN 35772 279 15 in in IN 35772 279 16 motion motion NN 35772 279 17 by by IN 35772 279 18 the the DT 35772 279 19 operation operation NN 35772 279 20 of of IN 35772 279 21 the the DT 35772 279 22 Deity Deity NNP 35772 279 23 , , , 35772 279 24 they -PRON- PRP 35772 279 25 had have VBD 35772 279 26 substituted substitute VBN 35772 279 27 the the DT 35772 279 28 conception conception NN 35772 279 29 of of IN 35772 279 30 illimitable illimitable JJ 35772 279 31 space space NN 35772 279 32 sown sow VBN 35772 279 33 with with IN 35772 279 34 innumerable innumerable JJ 35772 279 35 systems system NNS 35772 279 36 like like IN 35772 279 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 279 38 own own JJ 35772 279 39 ; ; : 35772 279 40 and and CC 35772 279 41 had have VBD 35772 279 42 created create VBN 35772 279 43 the the DT 35772 279 44 beginning beginning NN 35772 279 45 of of IN 35772 279 46 a a DT 35772 279 47 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 279 48 conception conception NN 35772 279 49 of of IN 35772 279 50 nature nature NN 35772 279 51 . . . 35772 280 1 THE the DT 35772 280 2 NEW NEW NNP 35772 280 3 LOGIC.--But logic.--but NN 35772 280 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 280 5 was be VBD 35772 280 6 not not RB 35772 280 7 only only RB 35772 280 8 the the DT 35772 280 9 scientific scientific JJ 35772 280 10 dogmas dogmas NN 35772 280 11 of of IN 35772 280 12 the the DT 35772 280 13 old old JJ 35772 280 14 system system NN 35772 280 15 that that WDT 35772 280 16 had have VBD 35772 280 17 been be VBN 35772 280 18 so so RB 35772 280 19 rudely rudely RB 35772 280 20 overthrown overthrow VBN 35772 280 21 -- -- : 35772 280 22 the the DT 35772 280 23 very very JJ 35772 280 24 principles principle NNS 35772 280 25 upon upon IN 35772 280 26 which which WDT 35772 280 27 those those DT 35772 280 28 dogmas dogma NNS 35772 280 29 rested rest VBD 35772 280 30 had have VBD 35772 280 31 been be VBN 35772 280 32 submitted submit VBN 35772 280 33 to to IN 35772 280 34 a a DT 35772 280 35 destructive destructive JJ 35772 280 36 criticism criticism NN 35772 280 37 . . . 35772 281 1 The the DT 35772 281 2 new new JJ 35772 281 3 science science NN 35772 281 4 produced produce VBD 35772 281 5 a a DT 35772 281 6 new new JJ 35772 281 7 logic logic NN 35772 281 8 . . . 35772 282 1 This this DT 35772 282 2 order order NN 35772 282 3 of of IN 35772 282 4 events event NNS 35772 282 5 is be VBZ 35772 282 6 not not RB 35772 282 7 unusual unusual JJ 35772 282 8 : : : 35772 282 9 first first RB 35772 282 10 , , , 35772 282 11 the the DT 35772 282 12 new new JJ 35772 282 13 scientific scientific JJ 35772 282 14 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 282 15 , , , 35772 282 16 and and CC 35772 282 17 then then RB 35772 282 18 in in IN 35772 282 19 the the DT 35772 282 20 wake wake NN 35772 282 21 of of IN 35772 282 22 the the DT 35772 282 23 discoverers discoverer NNS 35772 282 24 , , , 35772 282 25 comes come VBZ 35772 282 26 the the DT 35772 282 27 innovating innovate VBG 35772 282 28 critic critic NN 35772 282 29 who who WP 35772 282 30 systematises systematise VBZ 35772 282 31 the the DT 35772 282 32 logical logical JJ 35772 282 33 or or CC 35772 282 34 scientific scientific JJ 35772 282 35 methods method NNS 35772 282 36 to to TO 35772 282 37 which which WDT 35772 282 38 the the DT 35772 282 39 new new JJ 35772 282 40 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 282 41 seems seem VBZ 35772 282 42 to to TO 35772 282 43 have have VB 35772 282 44 been be VBN 35772 282 45 due due JJ 35772 282 46 . . . 35772 283 1 First first RB 35772 283 2 , , , 35772 283 3 Kepler Kepler NNP 35772 283 4 and and CC 35772 283 5 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 283 6 , , , 35772 283 7 who who WP 35772 283 8 used use VBD 35772 283 9 the the DT 35772 283 10 " " `` 35772 283 11 inductive inductive JJ 35772 283 12 " " '' 35772 283 13 method method NN 35772 283 14 , , , 35772 283 15 and and CC 35772 283 16 then then RB 35772 283 17 Lord Lord NNP 35772 283 18 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 283 19 of of IN 35772 283 20 Verulam Verulam NNP 35772 283 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 283 22 1561 1561 CD 35772 283 23 - - SYM 35772 283 24 1626 1626 CD 35772 283 25 ) ) -RRB- 35772 283 26 , , , 35772 283 27 who who WP 35772 283 28 discovered discover VBD 35772 283 29 the the DT 35772 283 30 inductive inductive JJ 35772 283 31 logic logic NN 35772 283 32 , , , 35772 283 33 and and CC 35772 283 34 established establish VBD 35772 283 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 283 36 as as IN 35772 283 37 a a DT 35772 283 38 system system NN 35772 283 39 . . . 35772 284 1 FRANCIS FRANCIS NNP 35772 284 2 BACON.--Bacon BACON.--Bacon NNP 35772 284 3 's 's POS 35772 284 4 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 284 5 may may MD 35772 284 6 be be VB 35772 284 7 summarised summarise VBN 35772 284 8 by by IN 35772 284 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 284 10 own own JJ 35772 284 11 epigram epigram NN 35772 284 12 , , , 35772 284 13 " " `` 35772 284 14 If if IN 35772 284 15 a a DT 35772 284 16 man man NN 35772 284 17 begin begin VBP 35772 284 18 with with IN 35772 284 19 certainties certainty NNS 35772 284 20 , , , 35772 284 21 he -PRON- PRP 35772 284 22 shall shall MD 35772 284 23 end end VB 35772 284 24 in in IN 35772 284 25 doubts doubt NNS 35772 284 26 ; ; : 35772 284 27 but but CC 35772 284 28 if if IN 35772 284 29 he -PRON- PRP 35772 284 30 be be VBP 35772 284 31 content content JJ 35772 284 32 to to TO 35772 284 33 begin begin VB 35772 284 34 with with IN 35772 284 35 doubts doubt NNS 35772 284 36 , , , 35772 284 37 he -PRON- PRP 35772 284 38 shall shall MD 35772 284 39 end end VB 35772 284 40 in in IN 35772 284 41 certainties certainty NNS 35772 284 42 . . . 35772 284 43 " " '' 35772 285 1 Which which WDT 35772 285 2 is be VBZ 35772 285 3 really really RB 35772 285 4 a a DT 35772 285 5 criticism criticism NN 35772 285 6 of of IN 35772 285 7 what what WP 35772 285 8 is be VBZ 35772 285 9 known know VBN 35772 285 10 as as IN 35772 285 11 the the DT 35772 285 12 a a FW 35772 285 13 priori priori FW 35772 285 14 method method NN 35772 285 15 , , , 35772 285 16 whereby whereby WRB 35772 285 17 the the DT 35772 285 18 inquirer inquirer NN 35772 285 19 starts start VBZ 35772 285 20 with with IN 35772 285 21 certain certain JJ 35772 285 22 predefined predefined JJ 35772 285 23 theories theory NNS 35772 285 24 to to TO 35772 285 25 which which WDT 35772 285 26 all all DT 35772 285 27 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 285 28 must must MD 35772 285 29 conform conform VB 35772 285 30 , , , 35772 285 31 and and CC 35772 285 32 which which WDT 35772 285 33 all all DT 35772 285 34 experience experience NN 35772 285 35 must must MD 35772 285 36 verify verify VB 35772 285 37 . . . 35772 286 1 If if IN 35772 286 2 facts fact NNS 35772 286 3 will will MD 35772 286 4 not not RB 35772 286 5 suit suit VB 35772 286 6 the the DT 35772 286 7 particular particular JJ 35772 286 8 theory theory NN 35772 286 9 , , , 35772 286 10 so so RB 35772 286 11 much much RB 35772 286 12 the the DT 35772 286 13 worse bad JJR 35772 286 14 for for IN 35772 286 15 the the DT 35772 286 16 facts fact NNS 35772 286 17 : : : 35772 286 18 one one PRP 35772 286 19 could could MD 35772 286 20 always always RB 35772 286 21 disregard disregard VB 35772 286 22 them -PRON- PRP 35772 286 23 , , , 35772 286 24 and and CC 35772 286 25 apply apply VB 35772 286 26 a a DT 35772 286 27 blind blind JJ 35772 286 28 eye eye NN 35772 286 29 to to IN 35772 286 30 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 286 31 's 's POS 35772 286 32 telescope telescope NN 35772 286 33 . . . 35772 287 1 Such such JJ 35772 287 2 is be VBZ 35772 287 3 always always RB 35772 287 4 the the DT 35772 287 5 procedure procedure NN 35772 287 6 of of IN 35772 287 7 the the DT 35772 287 8 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 287 9 mind mind NN 35772 287 10 , , , 35772 287 11 which which WDT 35772 287 12 is be VBZ 35772 287 13 already already RB 35772 287 14 so so RB 35772 287 15 certain certain JJ 35772 287 16 of of IN 35772 287 17 the the DT 35772 287 18 truth truth NN 35772 287 19 of of IN 35772 287 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 287 21 notions notion NNS 35772 287 22 that that IN 35772 287 23 no no DT 35772 287 24 evidence evidence NN 35772 287 25 can can MD 35772 287 26 persuade persuade VB 35772 287 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 287 28 to to IN 35772 287 29 the the DT 35772 287 30 contrary contrary NN 35772 287 31 . . . 35772 288 1 But but CC 35772 288 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 288 3 is be VBZ 35772 288 4 not not RB 35772 288 5 by by IN 35772 288 6 such such JJ 35772 288 7 means mean NNS 35772 288 8 that that IN 35772 288 9 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 288 10 is be VBZ 35772 288 11 advanced advance VBN 35772 288 12 , , , 35772 288 13 and and CC 35772 288 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 288 15 was be VBD 35772 288 16 for for IN 35772 288 17 a a DT 35772 288 18 reversal reversal NN 35772 288 19 of of IN 35772 288 20 these these DT 35772 288 21 that that WDT 35772 288 22 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 288 23 pleaded plead VBD 35772 288 24 . . . 35772 289 1 Leonardo Leonardo NNP 35772 289 2 da da NNP 35772 289 3 Vinci Vinci NNP 35772 289 4 had have VBD 35772 289 5 already already RB 35772 289 6 anticipated anticipate VBN 35772 289 7 the the DT 35772 289 8 Baconian baconian JJ 35772 289 9 logic logic NN 35772 289 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 289 11 which which WDT 35772 289 12 did do VBD 35772 289 13 not not RB 35772 289 14 wait wait VB 35772 289 15 for for IN 35772 289 16 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 289 17 until until IN 35772 289 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 289 19 was be VBD 35772 289 20 applied apply VBN 35772 289 21 ) ) -RRB- 35772 289 22 when when WRB 35772 289 23 he -PRON- PRP 35772 289 24 laid lay VBD 35772 289 25 down down RP 35772 289 26 the the DT 35772 289 27 proposition proposition NN 35772 289 28 that that DT 35772 289 29 wisdom wisdom NN 35772 289 30 was be VBD 35772 289 31 the the DT 35772 289 32 daughter daughter NN 35772 289 33 of of IN 35772 289 34 experience experience NN 35772 289 35 , , , 35772 289 36 and and CC 35772 289 37 rejected reject VBD 35772 289 38 all all DT 35772 289 39 speculations speculation NNS 35772 289 40 which which WDT 35772 289 41 experience experience NN 35772 289 42 , , , 35772 289 43 the the DT 35772 289 44 common common JJ 35772 289 45 mother mother NN 35772 289 46 of of IN 35772 289 47 all all DT 35772 289 48 sciences science NNS 35772 289 49 , , , 35772 289 50 could could MD 35772 289 51 not not RB 35772 289 52 confirm confirm VB 35772 289 53 . . . 35772 290 1 Hence hence RB 35772 290 2 , , , 35772 290 3 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 290 4 was be VBD 35772 290 5 the the DT 35772 290 6 product product NN 35772 290 7 of of IN 35772 290 8 time time NN 35772 290 9 ; ; : 35772 290 10 the the DT 35772 290 11 process process NN 35772 290 12 of of IN 35772 290 13 collecting collect VBG 35772 290 14 material material NN 35772 290 15 for for IN 35772 290 16 a a DT 35772 290 17 judgment judgment NN 35772 290 18 must must MD 35772 290 19 often often RB 35772 290 20 be be VB 35772 290 21 slow slow JJ 35772 290 22 , , , 35772 290 23 but but CC 35772 290 24 the the DT 35772 290 25 results result NNS 35772 290 26 were be VBD 35772 290 27 worth worth JJ 35772 290 28 the the DT 35772 290 29 labour labour NN 35772 290 30 -- -- : 35772 290 31 these these DT 35772 290 32 would would MD 35772 290 33 not not RB 35772 290 34 be be VB 35772 290 35 speculative speculative JJ 35772 290 36 , , , 35772 290 37 but but CC 35772 290 38 true true JJ 35772 290 39 . . . 35772 291 1 Nor nor CC 35772 291 2 need need VBP 35772 291 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 291 4 be be VB 35772 291 5 supposed suppose VBN 35772 291 6 that that IN 35772 291 7 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 291 8 excluded exclude VBD 35772 291 9 imagination imagination NN 35772 291 10 from from IN 35772 291 11 playing play VBG 35772 291 12 a a DT 35772 291 13 part part NN 35772 291 14 in in IN 35772 291 15 increasing increase VBG 35772 291 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 291 17 , , , 35772 291 18 he -PRON- PRP 35772 291 19 did do VBD 35772 291 20 not not RB 35772 291 21 plead plead VB 35772 291 22 _ _ NNP 35772 291 23 only only RB 35772 291 24 _ _ NNP 35772 291 25 for for IN 35772 291 26 a a DT 35772 291 27 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 291 28 collection collection NN 35772 291 29 of of IN 35772 291 30 material material NN 35772 291 31 . . . 35772 292 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 292 2 is be VBZ 35772 292 3 imagination imagination NN 35772 292 4 which which WDT 35772 292 5 in in IN 35772 292 6 face face NN 35772 292 7 of of IN 35772 292 8 abundant abundant JJ 35772 292 9 material material NN 35772 292 10 creates create VBZ 35772 292 11 the the DT 35772 292 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 292 13 which which WDT 35772 292 14 accounts account VBZ 35772 292 15 for for IN 35772 292 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 292 17 being be VBG 35772 292 18 what what WP 35772 292 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 292 20 is be VBZ 35772 292 21 . . . 35772 293 1 And and CC 35772 293 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 293 3 was be VBD 35772 293 4 prepared prepared JJ 35772 293 5 to to TO 35772 293 6 admit admit VB 35772 293 7 the the DT 35772 293 8 value value NN 35772 293 9 of of IN 35772 293 10 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 293 11 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 35772 293 12 which which WDT 35772 293 13 might may MD 35772 293 14 be be VB 35772 293 15 replaced replace VBN 35772 293 16 as as IN 35772 293 17 further further JJ 35772 293 18 facts fact NNS 35772 293 19 were be VBD 35772 293 20 collected collect VBN 35772 293 21 , , , 35772 293 22 or or CC 35772 293 23 as as IN 35772 293 24 insight insight NN 35772 293 25 became become VBD 35772 293 26 more more RBR 35772 293 27 clear clear JJ 35772 293 28 . . . 35772 294 1 Here here RB 35772 294 2 , , , 35772 294 3 too too RB 35772 294 4 , , , 35772 294 5 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 294 6 describes describe VBZ 35772 294 7 the the DT 35772 294 8 method method NN 35772 294 9 followed follow VBN 35772 294 10 by by IN 35772 294 11 modern modern JJ 35772 294 12 science science NN 35772 294 13 . . . 35772 295 1 PRESTIGE PRESTIGE NNP 35772 295 2 OF of IN 35772 295 3 NEW NEW NNP 35772 295 4 METHODS.--And methods.--and NN 35772 295 5 so so RB 35772 295 6 , , , 35772 295 7 by by IN 35772 295 8 the the DT 35772 295 9 time time NN 35772 295 10 when when WRB 35772 295 11 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 295 12 had have VBD 35772 295 13 laid lay VBN 35772 295 14 down down RP 35772 295 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 295 16 pen pen NN 35772 295 17 after after IN 35772 295 18 writing write VBG 35772 295 19 the the DT 35772 295 20 _ _ NNP 35772 295 21 New New NNP 35772 295 22 Logic Logic NNP 35772 295 23 _ _ NNP 35772 295 24 , , , 35772 295 25 the the DT 35772 295 26 work work NN 35772 295 27 of of IN 35772 295 28 discrediting discredit VBG 35772 295 29 the the DT 35772 295 30 old old JJ 35772 295 31 system system NN 35772 295 32 , , , 35772 295 33 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 295 34 with with IN 35772 295 35 such such JJ 35772 295 36 ingenious ingenious JJ 35772 295 37 industry industry NN 35772 295 38 by by IN 35772 295 39 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 295 40 , , , 35772 295 41 was be VBD 35772 295 42 tolerably tolerably RB 35772 295 43 complete complete JJ 35772 295 44 . . . 35772 296 1 The the DT 35772 296 2 new new JJ 35772 296 3 science science NN 35772 296 4 had have VBD 35772 296 5 begun begin VBN 35772 296 6 already already RB 35772 296 7 to to TO 35772 296 8 be be VB 35772 296 9 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 296 10 in in IN 35772 296 11 results result NNS 35772 296 12 , , , 35772 296 13 both both DT 35772 296 14 practical practical JJ 35772 296 15 and and CC 35772 296 16 speculative speculative JJ 35772 296 17 . . . 35772 297 1 The the DT 35772 297 2 successors successor NNS 35772 297 3 of of IN 35772 297 4 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 297 5 and and CC 35772 297 6 of of IN 35772 297 7 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 297 8 applied apply VBD 35772 297 9 the the DT 35772 297 10 new new JJ 35772 297 11 principles principle NNS 35772 297 12 with with IN 35772 297 13 vigour vigour NN 35772 297 14 , , , 35772 297 15 and and CC 35772 297 16 reached reach VBD 35772 297 17 astonishing astonishing JJ 35772 297 18 results result NNS 35772 297 19 . . . 35772 298 1 Justified justify VBN 35772 298 2 by by IN 35772 298 3 these these DT 35772 298 4 , , , 35772 298 5 the the DT 35772 298 6 new new JJ 35772 298 7 methods method NNS 35772 298 8 secured secure VBD 35772 298 9 a a DT 35772 298 10 prestige prestige NN 35772 298 11 which which WDT 35772 298 12 has have VBZ 35772 298 13 not not RB 35772 298 14 decreased decrease VBN 35772 298 15 for for IN 35772 298 16 three three CD 35772 298 17 centuries century NNS 35772 298 18 . . . 35772 299 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 299 2 III III NNP 35772 299 3 GROWTH GROWTH NNS 35772 299 4 OF of IN 35772 299 5 THE the DT 35772 299 6 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 299 7 THEORY THEORY NNP 35772 299 8 DECLINE decline NN 35772 299 9 OF of IN 35772 299 10 SCHOLASTICISM.--By scholasticism.--by NN 35772 299 11 the the DT 35772 299 12 time time NN 35772 299 13 of of IN 35772 299 14 Lord Lord NNP 35772 299 15 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 299 16 , , , 35772 299 17 the the DT 35772 299 18 Scholastic scholastic JJ 35772 299 19 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 299 20 might may MD 35772 299 21 have have VB 35772 299 22 been be VBN 35772 299 23 described describe VBN 35772 299 24 as as IN 35772 299 25 extinct extinct JJ 35772 299 26 ; ; : 35772 299 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 299 28 no no RB 35772 299 29 longer long RBR 35772 299 30 survived survive VBD 35772 299 31 as as IN 35772 299 32 a a DT 35772 299 33 living living NN 35772 299 34 system system NN 35772 299 35 . . . 35772 300 1 The the DT 35772 300 2 loss loss NN 35772 300 3 was be VBD 35772 300 4 a a DT 35772 300 5 serious serious JJ 35772 300 6 one one NN 35772 300 7 to to IN 35772 300 8 mankind mankind NN 35772 300 9 , , , 35772 300 10 which which WDT 35772 300 11 was be VBD 35772 300 12 poorer poor JJR 35772 300 13 by by IN 35772 300 14 the the DT 35772 300 15 discrediting discrediting NN 35772 300 16 of of IN 35772 300 17 an an DT 35772 300 18 authoritative authoritative JJ 35772 300 19 body body NN 35772 300 20 of of IN 35772 300 21 thought thought NN 35772 300 22 , , , 35772 300 23 a a DT 35772 300 24 possession possession NN 35772 300 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 300 26 seems seem VBZ 35772 300 27 ill ill JJ 35772 300 28 able able JJ 35772 300 29 to to TO 35772 300 30 dispense dispense VB 35772 300 31 with with IN 35772 300 32 . . . 35772 301 1 The the DT 35772 301 2 Baconian baconian JJ 35772 301 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 301 4 was be VBD 35772 301 5 an an DT 35772 301 6 imperfect imperfect JJ 35772 301 7 substitute substitute NN 35772 301 8 ; ; : 35772 301 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 301 10 was be VBD 35772 301 11 little little RB 35772 301 12 more more JJR 35772 301 13 than than IN 35772 301 14 a a DT 35772 301 15 system system NN 35772 301 16 of of IN 35772 301 17 enquiry enquiry NN 35772 301 18 , , , 35772 301 19 a a DT 35772 301 20 manual manual NN 35772 301 21 of of IN 35772 301 22 scientific scientific JJ 35772 301 23 procedure procedure NN 35772 301 24 , , , 35772 301 25 for for IN 35772 301 26 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 301 27 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 301 28 was be VBD 35772 301 29 not not RB 35772 301 30 in in IN 35772 301 31 the the DT 35772 301 32 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 301 33 sense sense NN 35772 301 34 a a DT 35772 301 35 profound profound JJ 35772 301 36 or or CC 35772 301 37 constructive constructive JJ 35772 301 38 thinker thinker NN 35772 301 39 , , , 35772 301 40 though though IN 35772 301 41 he -PRON- PRP 35772 301 42 was be VBD 35772 301 43 one one CD 35772 301 44 of of IN 35772 301 45 those those DT 35772 301 46 men man NNS 35772 301 47 of of IN 35772 301 48 talent talent NN 35772 301 49 who who WP 35772 301 50 can can MD 35772 301 51 give give VB 35772 301 52 utterance utterance NN 35772 301 53 to to IN 35772 301 54 the the DT 35772 301 55 tendencies tendency NNS 35772 301 56 of of IN 35772 301 57 an an DT 35772 301 58 epoch epoch NN 35772 301 59 . . . 35772 302 1 THE the DT 35772 302 2 NEW NEW NNP 35772 302 3 PHILOSOPHY.--The philosophy.--the JJ 35772 302 4 task task NN 35772 302 5 , , , 35772 302 6 however however RB 35772 302 7 , , , 35772 302 8 of of IN 35772 302 9 constructing construct VBG 35772 302 10 a a DT 35772 302 11 new new JJ 35772 302 12 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 302 13 of of IN 35772 302 14 the the DT 35772 302 15 universe universe NN 35772 302 16 was be VBD 35772 302 17 courageously courageously RB 35772 302 18 taken take VBN 35772 302 19 in in IN 35772 302 20 hand hand NN 35772 302 21 by by IN 35772 302 22 a a DT 35772 302 23 succession succession NN 35772 302 24 of of IN 35772 302 25 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 302 26 , , , 35772 302 27 and and CC 35772 302 28 the the DT 35772 302 29 energy energy NN 35772 302 30 of of IN 35772 302 31 thought thought NN 35772 302 32 which which WDT 35772 302 33 the the DT 35772 302 34 great great JJ 35772 302 35 problem problem NN 35772 302 36 generated generate VBN 35772 302 37 is be VBZ 35772 302 38 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 302 39 of of IN 35772 302 40 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 302 41 the the DT 35772 302 42 most most RBS 35772 302 43 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 302 44 century century NN 35772 302 45 of of IN 35772 302 46 European european JJ 35772 302 47 history history NN 35772 302 48 -- -- : 35772 302 49 the the DT 35772 302 50 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 302 51 . . . 35772 303 1 The the DT 35772 303 2 tendency tendency NN 35772 303 3 of of IN 35772 303 4 the the DT 35772 303 5 new new JJ 35772 303 6 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 303 7 in in IN 35772 303 8 science science NN 35772 303 9 had have VBD 35772 303 10 not not RB 35772 303 11 been be VBN 35772 303 12 obscure obscure JJ 35772 303 13 , , , 35772 303 14 and and CC 35772 303 15 Modern modern JJ 35772 303 16 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 303 17 starts start VBZ 35772 303 18 with with IN 35772 303 19 an an DT 35772 303 20 attempt attempt NN 35772 303 21 to to TO 35772 303 22 represent represent VB 35772 303 23 the the DT 35772 303 24 universe universe NN 35772 303 25 as as IN 35772 303 26 a a DT 35772 303 27 self self NN 35772 303 28 - - HYPH 35772 303 29 working work VBG 35772 303 30 machine machine NN 35772 303 31 -- -- : 35772 303 32 a a DT 35772 303 33 co co JJ 35772 303 34 - - JJ 35772 303 35 ordinated ordinated JJ 35772 303 36 whole whole NN 35772 303 37 , , , 35772 303 38 throughout throughout IN 35772 303 39 which which WDT 35772 303 40 the the DT 35772 303 41 principles principle NNS 35772 303 42 of of IN 35772 303 43 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 303 44 are be VBP 35772 303 45 universally universally RB 35772 303 46 valid valid JJ 35772 303 47 . . . 35772 304 1 The the DT 35772 304 2 trend trend NN 35772 304 3 of of IN 35772 304 4 ideas idea NNS 35772 304 5 set set VBN 35772 304 6 in in IN 35772 304 7 motion motion NN 35772 304 8 by by IN 35772 304 9 the the DT 35772 304 10 new new JJ 35772 304 11 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 304 12 in in IN 35772 304 13 astronomy astronomy NNP 35772 304 14 seemed seem VBD 35772 304 15 to to TO 35772 304 16 point point VB 35772 304 17 in in IN 35772 304 18 this this DT 35772 304 19 direction direction NN 35772 304 20 . . . 35772 305 1 But but CC 35772 305 2 to to TO 35772 305 3 introduce introduce VB 35772 305 4 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 305 5 into into IN 35772 305 6 the the DT 35772 305 7 celestial celestial JJ 35772 305 8 regions region NNS 35772 305 9 , , , 35772 305 10 though though IN 35772 305 11 an an DT 35772 305 12 important important JJ 35772 305 13 step step NN 35772 305 14 , , , 35772 305 15 was be VBD 35772 305 16 but but CC 35772 305 17 a a DT 35772 305 18 beginning beginning NN 35772 305 19 . . . 35772 306 1 Mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 306 2 must must MD 35772 306 3 be be VB 35772 306 4 _ _ NNP 35772 306 5 universally universally RB 35772 306 6 _ _ NNP 35772 306 7 valid valid JJ 35772 306 8 -- -- : 35772 306 9 even even RB 35772 306 10 in in IN 35772 306 11 the the DT 35772 306 12 human human JJ 35772 306 13 body body NN 35772 306 14 -- -- : 35772 306 15 or or CC 35772 306 16 the the DT 35772 306 17 new new JJ 35772 306 18 teaching teaching NN 35772 306 19 was be VBD 35772 306 20 vain vain JJ 35772 306 21 . . . 35772 307 1 Exceptions exception NNS 35772 307 2 may may MD 35772 307 3 prove prove VB 35772 307 4 a a DT 35772 307 5 rule rule NN 35772 307 6 , , , 35772 307 7 but but CC 35772 307 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 307 9 destroy destroy VBP 35772 307 10 a a DT 35772 307 11 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 307 12 . . . 35772 308 1 THE the DT 35772 308 2 SUBJUGATION SUBJUGATION NNP 35772 308 3 OF of IN 35772 308 4 PHYSIOLOGY.--It PHYSIOLOGY.--It NNP 35772 308 5 was be VBD 35772 308 6 an an DT 35772 308 7 Englishman Englishman NNP 35772 308 8 who who WP 35772 308 9 provided provide VBD 35772 308 10 the the DT 35772 308 11 necessary necessary JJ 35772 308 12 facts fact NNS 35772 308 13 to to TO 35772 308 14 fill fill VB 35772 308 15 the the DT 35772 308 16 gravest grave JJS 35772 308 17 gap gap NN 35772 308 18 in in IN 35772 308 19 the the DT 35772 308 20 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 308 21 theory theory NN 35772 308 22 . . . 35772 309 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 309 2 was be VBD 35772 309 3 already already RB 35772 309 4 known know VBN 35772 309 5 in in IN 35772 309 6 the the DT 35772 309 7 previous previous JJ 35772 309 8 century century NN 35772 309 9 that that WDT 35772 309 10 the the DT 35772 309 11 blood blood NN 35772 309 12 of of IN 35772 309 13 animals animal NNS 35772 309 14 circulated circulate VBN 35772 309 15 throughout throughout IN 35772 309 16 the the DT 35772 309 17 body body NN 35772 309 18 ; ; : 35772 309 19 the the DT 35772 309 20 existence existence NN 35772 309 21 and and CC 35772 309 22 use use NN 35772 309 23 of of IN 35772 309 24 veins vein NNS 35772 309 25 and and CC 35772 309 26 heart heart NN 35772 309 27 - - HYPH 35772 309 28 valves valve NNS 35772 309 29 was be VBD 35772 309 30 also also RB 35772 309 31 known know VBN 35772 309 32 , , , 35772 309 33 but but CC 35772 309 34 it -PRON- PRP 35772 309 35 was be VBD 35772 309 36 William William NNP 35772 309 37 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 309 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 309 39 1578 1578 CD 35772 309 40 - - SYM 35772 309 41 1657 1657 CD 35772 309 42 ) ) -RRB- 35772 309 43 who who WP 35772 309 44 discovered discover VBD 35772 309 45 the the DT 35772 309 46 heart heart NN 35772 309 47 to to TO 35772 309 48 be be VB 35772 309 49 the the DT 35772 309 50 organ organ NN 35772 309 51 responsible responsible JJ 35772 309 52 for for IN 35772 309 53 _ _ NNP 35772 309 54 maintaining maintain VBG 35772 309 55 _ _ NNP 35772 309 56 the the DT 35772 309 57 circulation circulation NN 35772 309 58 of of IN 35772 309 59 the the DT 35772 309 60 blood blood NN 35772 309 61 , , , 35772 309 62 by by IN 35772 309 63 purely purely RB 35772 309 64 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 309 65 means mean NNS 35772 309 66 . . . 35772 310 1 This this DT 35772 310 2 was be VBD 35772 310 3 a a DT 35772 310 4 fact fact NN 35772 310 5 of of IN 35772 310 6 the the DT 35772 310 7 utmost utmost JJ 35772 310 8 significance significance NN 35772 310 9 . . . 35772 311 1 In in IN 35772 311 2 the the DT 35772 311 3 sphere sphere NN 35772 311 4 of of IN 35772 311 5 physiology physiology NN 35772 311 6 , , , 35772 311 7 where where WRB 35772 311 8 theories theory NNS 35772 311 9 about about IN 35772 311 10 mysterious mysterious JJ 35772 311 11 powers power NNS 35772 311 12 of of IN 35772 311 13 blood blood NN 35772 311 14 or or CC 35772 311 15 soul soul NN 35772 311 16 had have VBD 35772 311 17 been be VBN 35772 311 18 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 311 19 authoritative authoritative JJ 35772 311 20 , , , 35772 311 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 311 22 effected effect VBD 35772 311 23 a a DT 35772 311 24 revolution revolution NN 35772 311 25 . . . 35772 312 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 312 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 312 3 is be VBZ 35772 312 4 true true JJ 35772 312 5 to to TO 35772 312 6 say say VB 35772 312 7 that that DT 35772 312 8 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 312 9 " " '' 35772 312 10 is be VBZ 35772 312 11 to to TO 35772 312 12 physiology physiology VB 35772 312 13 what what WP 35772 312 14 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 312 15 was be VBD 35772 312 16 to to IN 35772 312 17 physics physics NN 35772 312 18 . . . 35772 312 19 " " '' 35772 313 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 313 2 proved prove VBD 35772 313 3 that that IN 35772 313 4 " " `` 35772 313 5 the the DT 35772 313 6 general general JJ 35772 313 7 laws law NNS 35772 313 8 of of IN 35772 313 9 motion motion NN 35772 313 10 are be VBP 35772 313 11 valid valid JJ 35772 313 12 within within IN 35772 313 13 as as RB 35772 313 14 well well RB 35772 313 15 as as IN 35772 313 16 without without IN 35772 313 17 the the DT 35772 313 18 organism"--an organism"--an NNP 35772 313 19 important important JJ 35772 313 20 extension extension NN 35772 313 21 of of IN 35772 313 22 the the DT 35772 313 23 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 313 24 theory theory NN 35772 313 25 . . . 35772 314 1 DESCARTES.--Among DESCARTES.--Among NNP 35772 314 2 the the DT 35772 314 3 leading lead VBG 35772 314 4 men man NNS 35772 314 5 who who WP 35772 314 6 accepted accept VBD 35772 314 7 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 314 8 's 's POS 35772 314 9 theory theory NN 35772 314 10 , , , 35772 314 11 one one CD 35772 314 12 of of IN 35772 314 13 the the DT 35772 314 14 first first JJ 35772 314 15 was be VBD 35772 314 16 René René NNP 35772 314 17 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 314 18 ( ( -LRB- 35772 314 19 1596 1596 CD 35772 314 20 - - SYM 35772 314 21 1650 1650 CD 35772 314 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 314 23 . . . 35772 315 1 Well well UH 35772 315 2 might may MD 35772 315 3 this this DT 35772 315 4 thinker thinker NN 35772 315 5 welcome welcome VB 35772 315 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 315 7 , , , 35772 315 8 for for IN 35772 315 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 315 10 was be VBD 35772 315 11 a a DT 35772 315 12 most most RBS 35772 315 13 important important JJ 35772 315 14 contribution contribution NN 35772 315 15 to to IN 35772 315 16 the the DT 35772 315 17 imposing impose VBG 35772 315 18 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 315 19 fabric fabric NN 35772 315 20 for for IN 35772 315 21 which which WDT 35772 315 22 he -PRON- PRP 35772 315 23 was be VBD 35772 315 24 industriously industriously RB 35772 315 25 collecting collect VBG 35772 315 26 materials material NNS 35772 315 27 . . . 35772 316 1 Descartes descarte NNS 35772 316 2 , , , 35772 316 3 apart apart RB 35772 316 4 from from IN 35772 316 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 316 6 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 316 7 speculations speculation NNS 35772 316 8 , , , 35772 316 9 is be VBZ 35772 316 10 an an DT 35772 316 11 interesting interesting JJ 35772 316 12 character character NN 35772 316 13 , , , 35772 316 14 being be VBG 35772 316 15 a a DT 35772 316 16 Frenchman Frenchman NNP 35772 316 17 of of IN 35772 316 18 noble noble JJ 35772 316 19 birth birth NN 35772 316 20 who who WP 35772 316 21 was be VBD 35772 316 22 educated educate VBN 35772 316 23 by by IN 35772 316 24 the the DT 35772 316 25 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 35772 316 26 , , , 35772 316 27 saw see VBD 35772 316 28 something something NN 35772 316 29 of of IN 35772 316 30 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 316 31 life life NN 35772 316 32 in in IN 35772 316 33 Paris Paris NNP 35772 316 34 , , , 35772 316 35 served serve VBD 35772 316 36 as as IN 35772 316 37 a a DT 35772 316 38 military military JJ 35772 316 39 officer officer NN 35772 316 40 in in IN 35772 316 41 Holland Holland NNP 35772 316 42 and and CC 35772 316 43 Germany Germany NNP 35772 316 44 , , , 35772 316 45 and and CC 35772 316 46 made make VBD 35772 316 47 some some DT 35772 316 48 original original JJ 35772 316 49 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 316 50 in in IN 35772 316 51 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 316 52 . . . 35772 317 1 The the DT 35772 317 2 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 317 3 mind mind NN 35772 317 4 , , , 35772 317 5 accustomed accustomed JJ 35772 317 6 as as IN 35772 317 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 317 8 is be VBZ 35772 317 9 to to TO 35772 317 10 deal deal VB 35772 317 11 with with IN 35772 317 12 highly highly RB 35772 317 13 abstract abstract JJ 35772 317 14 ideas idea NNS 35772 317 15 , , , 35772 317 16 takes take VBZ 35772 317 17 kindly kindly RB 35772 317 18 to to IN 35772 317 19 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 317 20 . . . 35772 318 1 And and CC 35772 318 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 318 3 very very RB 35772 318 4 often often RB 35772 318 5 solves solve VBZ 35772 318 6 the the DT 35772 318 7 mystery mystery NN 35772 318 8 of of IN 35772 318 9 the the DT 35772 318 10 universe universe NN 35772 318 11 by by IN 35772 318 12 expressing express VBG 35772 318 13 all all PDT 35772 318 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 318 15 contents content NNS 35772 318 16 in in IN 35772 318 17 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 318 18 terms term NNS 35772 318 19 . . . 35772 319 1 Such such JJ 35772 319 2 , , , 35772 319 3 at at RB 35772 319 4 least least JJS 35772 319 5 , , , 35772 319 6 was be VBD 35772 319 7 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 319 8 ' ' POS 35772 319 9 method method NN 35772 319 10 . . . 35772 320 1 The the DT 35772 320 2 simplest simple JJS 35772 320 3 and and CC 35772 320 4 clearest clear JJS 35772 320 5 ideas idea NNS 35772 320 6 which which WDT 35772 320 7 we -PRON- PRP 35772 320 8 can can MD 35772 320 9 have have VB 35772 320 10 of of IN 35772 320 11 anything anything NN 35772 320 12 are be VBP 35772 320 13 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 320 14 , , , 35772 320 15 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 321 1 extension extension NN 35772 321 2 and and CC 35772 321 3 mobility mobility NN 35772 321 4 . . . 35772 322 1 And and CC 35772 322 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 322 3 is be VBZ 35772 322 4 by by IN 35772 322 5 concentrating concentrate VBG 35772 322 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 322 7 attention attention NN 35772 322 8 upon upon IN 35772 322 9 this this DT 35772 322 10 simple simple JJ 35772 322 11 and and CC 35772 322 12 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 322 13 aspect aspect NN 35772 322 14 of of IN 35772 322 15 things thing NNS 35772 322 16 that that WDT 35772 322 17 we -PRON- PRP 35772 322 18 shall shall MD 35772 322 19 arrive arrive VB 35772 322 20 at at IN 35772 322 21 a a DT 35772 322 22 proper proper JJ 35772 322 23 understanding understanding NN 35772 322 24 of of IN 35772 322 25 all all DT 35772 322 26 that that WDT 35772 322 27 goes go VBZ 35772 322 28 on on RP 35772 322 29 in in IN 35772 322 30 the the DT 35772 322 31 material material NN 35772 322 32 world world NN 35772 322 33 . . . 35772 323 1 UNIVERSALITY universality NN 35772 323 2 OF of IN 35772 323 3 MATHEMATICS.--A mathematics.--a CD 35772 323 4 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 323 5 was be VBD 35772 323 6 , , , 35772 323 7 in in IN 35772 323 8 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 323 9 ' ' POS 35772 323 10 eyes eye NNS 35772 323 11 , , , 35772 323 12 " " `` 35772 323 13 explained explain VBD 35772 323 14 " " '' 35772 323 15 only only RB 35772 323 16 when when WRB 35772 323 17 a a DT 35772 323 18 " " `` 35772 323 19 cause cause NN 35772 323 20 " " '' 35772 323 21 which which WDT 35772 323 22 is be VBZ 35772 323 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 323 24 exact exact JJ 35772 323 25 _ _ NNP 35772 323 26 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 323 27 equivalent equivalent JJ 35772 323 28 _ _ NNP 35772 323 29 , , , 35772 323 30 has have VBZ 35772 323 31 been be VBN 35772 323 32 indicated indicate VBN 35772 323 33 . . . 35772 324 1 The the DT 35772 324 2 " " `` 35772 324 3 cause cause NN 35772 324 4 " " '' 35772 324 5 and and CC 35772 324 6 the the DT 35772 324 7 " " `` 35772 324 8 effect effect NN 35772 324 9 " " '' 35772 324 10 are be VBP 35772 324 11 two two CD 35772 324 12 sides side NNS 35772 324 13 of of IN 35772 324 14 a a DT 35772 324 15 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 324 16 equation equation NN 35772 324 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 324 18 _ _ NNP 35772 324 19 Causa Causa NNP 35772 324 20 aequat aequat NNP 35772 324 21 effectum effectum NNP 35772 324 22 _ _ NNP 35772 324 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 324 24 . . . 35772 325 1 Anything anything NN 35772 325 2 that that WDT 35772 325 3 happens happen VBZ 35772 325 4 in in IN 35772 325 5 the the DT 35772 325 6 material material NN 35772 325 7 world world NN 35772 325 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 325 9 the the DT 35772 325 10 fall fall NN 35772 325 11 of of IN 35772 325 12 a a DT 35772 325 13 stone stone NN 35772 325 14 , , , 35772 325 15 the the DT 35772 325 16 beat beat NN 35772 325 17 of of IN 35772 325 18 a a DT 35772 325 19 heart heart NN 35772 325 20 , , , 35772 325 21 the the DT 35772 325 22 rising rise VBG 35772 325 23 of of IN 35772 325 24 the the DT 35772 325 25 sun sun NN 35772 325 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 325 27 is be VBZ 35772 325 28 really really RB 35772 325 29 nothing nothing NN 35772 325 30 more more JJR 35772 325 31 than than IN 35772 325 32 a a DT 35772 325 33 redistribution redistribution NN 35772 325 34 of of IN 35772 325 35 portions portion NNS 35772 325 36 of of IN 35772 325 37 that that DT 35772 325 38 sum sum NN 35772 325 39 of of IN 35772 325 40 motion motion NN 35772 325 41 which which WDT 35772 325 42 , , , 35772 325 43 once once RB 35772 325 44 generated generate VBN 35772 325 45 at at IN 35772 325 46 the the DT 35772 325 47 Creation Creation NNP 35772 325 48 , , , 35772 325 49 has have VBZ 35772 325 50 remained remain VBN 35772 325 51 unaltered unaltered JJ 35772 325 52 , , , 35772 325 53 and and CC 35772 325 54 unalterable unalterable JJ 35772 325 55 , , , 35772 325 56 in in IN 35772 325 57 the the DT 35772 325 58 universe universe NN 35772 325 59 ever ever RB 35772 325 60 since since RB 35772 325 61 . . . 35772 326 1 The the DT 35772 326 2 sum sum NN 35772 326 3 of of IN 35772 326 4 motion motion NN 35772 326 5 is be VBZ 35772 326 6 constant constant JJ 35772 326 7 , , , 35772 326 8 there there EX 35772 326 9 can can MD 35772 326 10 be be VB 35772 326 11 no no DT 35772 326 12 addition addition NN 35772 326 13 to to IN 35772 326 14 or or CC 35772 326 15 subtraction subtraction NN 35772 326 16 from from IN 35772 326 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 326 18 . . . 35772 327 1 In in IN 35772 327 2 this this DT 35772 327 3 sense sense NN 35772 327 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 327 5 would would MD 35772 327 6 be be VB 35772 327 7 true true JJ 35772 327 8 that that IN 35772 327 9 " " `` 35772 327 10 there there EX 35772 327 11 is be VBZ 35772 327 12 nothing nothing NN 35772 327 13 new new JJ 35772 327 14 under under IN 35772 327 15 the the DT 35772 327 16 sun sun NN 35772 327 17 " " '' 35772 327 18 : : : 35772 327 19 only only RB 35772 327 20 ever ever RB 35772 327 21 - - HYPH 35772 327 22 new new JJ 35772 327 23 distributions distribution NNS 35772 327 24 of of IN 35772 327 25 the the DT 35772 327 26 old old JJ 35772 327 27 . . . 35772 328 1 THE the DT 35772 328 2 UNIVERSE UNIVERSE NNP 35772 328 3 A a DT 35772 328 4 MACHINE.--Once machine.--once NN 35772 328 5 assume assume VBP 35772 328 6 that that IN 35772 328 7 all all DT 35772 328 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 328 9 can can MD 35772 328 10 be be VB 35772 328 11 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 328 12 in in IN 35772 328 13 terms term NNS 35772 328 14 of of IN 35772 328 15 motion motion NN 35772 328 16 , , , 35772 328 17 and and CC 35772 328 18 add add VB 35772 328 19 the the DT 35772 328 20 proposition proposition NN 35772 328 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 328 22 already already RB 35772 328 23 enunciated enunciate VBN 35772 328 24 by by IN 35772 328 25 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 328 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 328 27 that that DT 35772 328 28 motion motion NN 35772 328 29 once once RB 35772 328 30 set set VBP 35772 328 31 going go VBG 35772 328 32 will will MD 35772 328 33 proceed proceed VB 35772 328 34 for for IN 35772 328 35 ever ever RB 35772 328 36 , , , 35772 328 37 unless unless IN 35772 328 38 some some DT 35772 328 39 impediment impediment NN 35772 328 40 from from IN 35772 328 41 outside outside JJ 35772 328 42 intervenes intervene NNS 35772 328 43 , , , 35772 328 44 and and CC 35772 328 45 the the DT 35772 328 46 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 328 47 view view NN 35772 328 48 of of IN 35772 328 49 the the DT 35772 328 50 universe universe NN 35772 328 51 is be VBZ 35772 328 52 complete complete JJ 35772 328 53 . . . 35772 329 1 The the DT 35772 329 2 universe universe NN 35772 329 3 is be VBZ 35772 329 4 a a DT 35772 329 5 machine machine NN 35772 329 6 , , , 35772 329 7 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 330 1 a a DT 35772 330 2 thing thing NN 35772 330 3 that that WDT 35772 330 4 works work VBZ 35772 330 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 330 6 1 1 LS 35772 330 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 330 8 according accord VBG 35772 330 9 to to IN 35772 330 10 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 330 11 principles principle NNS 35772 330 12 , , , 35772 330 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 330 14 2 2 LS 35772 330 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 330 16 automatically automatically RB 35772 330 17 . . . 35772 331 1 ELABORATIONS elaboration NNS 35772 331 2 OF of IN 35772 331 3 THE the DT 35772 331 4 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 331 5 THEORY.--The theory.--the NN 35772 331 6 importance importance NN 35772 331 7 of of IN 35772 331 8 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 331 9 lies lie VBZ 35772 331 10 not not RB 35772 331 11 in in IN 35772 331 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 331 13 having have VBG 35772 331 14 invented invent VBN 35772 331 15 this this DT 35772 331 16 conception conception NN 35772 331 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 331 18 we -PRON- PRP 35772 331 19 have have VBP 35772 331 20 already already RB 35772 331 21 seen see VBN 35772 331 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 331 23 in in IN 35772 331 24 the the DT 35772 331 25 hands hand NNS 35772 331 26 of of IN 35772 331 27 Leonardo Leonardo NNP 35772 331 28 da da NNP 35772 331 29 Vinci Vinci NNP 35772 331 30 , , , 35772 331 31 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 331 32 , , , 35772 331 33 and and CC 35772 331 34 others other NNS 35772 331 35 ) ) -RRB- 35772 331 36 , , , 35772 331 37 but but CC 35772 331 38 in in IN 35772 331 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 331 40 having have VBG 35772 331 41 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 331 42 it -PRON- PRP 35772 331 43 . . . 35772 332 1 This this DT 35772 332 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 332 3 did do VBD 35772 332 4 in in IN 35772 332 5 two two CD 35772 332 6 directions direction NNS 35772 332 7 : : : 35772 332 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 332 9 1 1 LS 35772 332 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 332 11 he -PRON- PRP 35772 332 12 attempted attempt VBD 35772 332 13 to to TO 35772 332 14 supply supply VB 35772 332 15 a a DT 35772 332 16 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 332 17 theory theory NN 35772 332 18 of of IN 35772 332 19 the the DT 35772 332 20 evolution evolution NN 35772 332 21 of of IN 35772 332 22 the the DT 35772 332 23 world world NN 35772 332 24 - - HYPH 35772 332 25 system system NN 35772 332 26 ; ; : 35772 332 27 _ _ NNP 35772 332 28 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 332 29 _ _ NNP 35772 332 30 to to TO 35772 332 31 show show VB 35772 332 32 how how WRB 35772 332 33 the the DT 35772 332 34 heavenly heavenly JJ 35772 332 35 bodies body NNS 35772 332 36 came come VBD 35772 332 37 into into IN 35772 332 38 being being NN 35772 332 39 by by IN 35772 332 40 natural natural JJ 35772 332 41 and and CC 35772 332 42 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 332 43 processes process NNS 35772 332 44 ; ; , 35772 332 45 ( ( -LRB- 35772 332 46 2 2 LS 35772 332 47 ) ) -RRB- 35772 332 48 he -PRON- PRP 35772 332 49 applied apply VBD 35772 332 50 the the DT 35772 332 51 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 332 52 theory theory NN 35772 332 53 to to IN 35772 332 54 organisms organism NNS 35772 332 55 ; ; : 35772 332 56 animals animal NNS 35772 332 57 and and CC 35772 332 58 men man NNS 35772 332 59 were be VBD 35772 332 60 complex complex JJ 35772 332 61 machines machine NNS 35772 332 62 . . . 35772 333 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 333 2 Here here RB 35772 333 3 , , , 35772 333 4 as as IN 35772 333 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 333 6 have have VBP 35772 333 7 seen see VBN 35772 333 8 , , , 35772 333 9 the the DT 35772 333 10 discovery discovery NN 35772 333 11 of of IN 35772 333 12 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 333 13 was be VBD 35772 333 14 of of IN 35772 333 15 prime prime JJ 35772 333 16 importance importance NN 35772 333 17 . . . 35772 333 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 334 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 334 2 is be VBZ 35772 334 3 hardly hardly RB 35772 334 4 necessary necessary JJ 35772 334 5 to to TO 35772 334 6 describe describe VB 35772 334 7 at at IN 35772 334 8 length length NN 35772 334 9 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 334 10 ' ' POS 35772 334 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 334 12 theory theory NN 35772 334 13 of of IN 35772 334 14 the the DT 35772 334 15 evolution evolution NN 35772 334 16 of of IN 35772 334 17 the the DT 35772 334 18 world world NN 35772 334 19 - - HYPH 35772 334 20 system system NN 35772 334 21 , , , 35772 334 22 though though IN 35772 334 23 an an DT 35772 334 24 interest interest NN 35772 334 25 attaches attach VBZ 35772 334 26 to to IN 35772 334 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 334 28 as as IN 35772 334 29 being be VBG 35772 334 30 the the DT 35772 334 31 ancestor ancestor NN 35772 334 32 of of IN 35772 334 33 the the DT 35772 334 34 modern modern JJ 35772 334 35 " " `` 35772 334 36 nebular nebular JJ 35772 334 37 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 334 38 . . . 35772 334 39 " " '' 35772 335 1 Matter Matter NNP 35772 335 2 in in IN 35772 335 3 whirling whirl VBG 35772 335 4 motion motion NN 35772 335 5 around around IN 35772 335 6 fixed fix VBN 35772 335 7 centres centre NNS 35772 335 8 is be VBZ 35772 335 9 the the DT 35772 335 10 original original JJ 35772 335 11 _ _ NNP 35772 335 12 datum datum NN 35772 335 13 _ _ NNP 35772 335 14 from from IN 35772 335 15 which which WDT 35772 335 16 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 335 17 evokes evoke VBZ 35772 335 18 the the DT 35772 335 19 universe universe NN 35772 335 20 . . . 35772 336 1 With with IN 35772 336 2 regard regard NN 35772 336 3 to to IN 35772 336 4 the the DT 35772 336 5 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 336 6 theory theory NN 35772 336 7 of of IN 35772 336 8 organisms organism NNS 35772 336 9 , , , 35772 336 10 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 336 11 developed develop VBD 35772 336 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 336 13 at at IN 35772 336 14 some some DT 35772 336 15 length length NN 35772 336 16 in in IN 35772 336 17 various various JJ 35772 336 18 treatises treatise NNS 35772 336 19 . . . 35772 337 1 All all PDT 35772 337 2 the the DT 35772 337 3 functions function NNS 35772 337 4 and and CC 35772 337 5 actions action NNS 35772 337 6 of of IN 35772 337 7 animals animal NNS 35772 337 8 were be VBD 35772 337 9 regarded regard VBN 35772 337 10 by by IN 35772 337 11 him -PRON- PRP 35772 337 12 as as IN 35772 337 13 entirely entirely RB 35772 337 14 involuntary involuntary JJ 35772 337 15 and and CC 35772 337 16 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 337 17 . . . 35772 338 1 " " `` 35772 338 2 That that IN 35772 338 3 the the DT 35772 338 4 lamb lamb NNP 35772 338 5 flees flee VBZ 35772 338 6 at at IN 35772 338 7 the the DT 35772 338 8 sight sight NN 35772 338 9 of of IN 35772 338 10 a a DT 35772 338 11 wolf wolf NN 35772 338 12 happens happen VBZ 35772 338 13 because because IN 35772 338 14 the the DT 35772 338 15 rays ray NNS 35772 338 16 of of IN 35772 338 17 light light NN 35772 338 18 from from IN 35772 338 19 the the DT 35772 338 20 body body NN 35772 338 21 of of IN 35772 338 22 the the DT 35772 338 23 wolf wolf NNP 35772 338 24 strike strike VB 35772 338 25 the the DT 35772 338 26 eye eye NN 35772 338 27 of of IN 35772 338 28 the the DT 35772 338 29 lamb lamb NN 35772 338 30 , , , 35772 338 31 and and CC 35772 338 32 set set VBD 35772 338 33 the the DT 35772 338 34 muscles muscle NNS 35772 338 35 in in IN 35772 338 36 motion motion NN 35772 338 37 by by IN 35772 338 38 means mean NNS 35772 338 39 of of IN 35772 338 40 the the DT 35772 338 41 ' ' `` 35772 338 42 reflex reflex NNP 35772 338 43 ' ' POS 35772 338 44 currents current NNS 35772 338 45 of of IN 35772 338 46 the the DT 35772 338 47 animal animal NN 35772 338 48 spirits spirit NNS 35772 338 49 . . . 35772 338 50 " " '' 35772 339 1 In in IN 35772 339 2 the the DT 35772 339 3 case case NN 35772 339 4 of of IN 35772 339 5 human human JJ 35772 339 6 beings being NNS 35772 339 7 , , , 35772 339 8 owing owe VBG 35772 339 9 to to IN 35772 339 10 the the DT 35772 339 11 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 339 12 of of IN 35772 339 13 " " `` 35772 339 14 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 339 15 , , , 35772 339 16 " " '' 35772 339 17 Descartes descarte NNS 35772 339 18 felt feel VBD 35772 339 19 compelled compel VBN 35772 339 20 to to TO 35772 339 21 assume assume VB 35772 339 22 a a DT 35772 339 23 " " `` 35772 339 24 soul"--a soul"--a NNP 35772 339 25 _ _ NNP 35772 339 26 thinking think VBG 35772 339 27 _ _ NNP 35772 339 28 substance substance NN 35772 339 29 in in IN 35772 339 30 reciprocal reciprocal JJ 35772 339 31 action action NN 35772 339 32 with with IN 35772 339 33 the the DT 35772 339 34 _ _ NNP 35772 339 35 material material NN 35772 339 36 _ _ NNP 35772 339 37 substance substance NN 35772 339 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 339 39 of of IN 35772 339 40 the the DT 35772 339 41 brain brain NN 35772 339 42 ) ) -RRB- 35772 339 43 . . . 35772 340 1 This this DT 35772 340 2 , , , 35772 340 3 too too RB 35772 340 4 , , , 35772 340 5 is be VBZ 35772 340 6 an an DT 35772 340 7 anticipation anticipation NN 35772 340 8 of of IN 35772 340 9 the the DT 35772 340 10 modern modern JJ 35772 340 11 theory theory NN 35772 340 12 of of IN 35772 340 13 " " `` 35772 340 14 psycho psycho NN 35772 340 15 - - HYPH 35772 340 16 physical physical JJ 35772 340 17 parallelism parallelism NN 35772 340 18 . . . 35772 340 19 " " '' 35772 341 1 CARTESIANISM.--The cartesianism.--the JJ 35772 341 2 ideas idea NNS 35772 341 3 of of IN 35772 341 4 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 341 5 had have VBD 35772 341 6 considerable considerable JJ 35772 341 7 influence influence NN 35772 341 8 among among IN 35772 341 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 341 10 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 341 11 , , , 35772 341 12 and and CC 35772 341 13 Cartesianism cartesianism NN 35772 341 14 , , , 35772 341 15 as as IN 35772 341 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 341 17 was be VBD 35772 341 18 called call VBN 35772 341 19 , , , 35772 341 20 became become VBD 35772 341 21 fashionable fashionable JJ 35772 341 22 in in IN 35772 341 23 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 341 24 circles circle NNS 35772 341 25 . . . 35772 342 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 342 2 developed develop VBD 35772 342 3 a a DT 35772 342 4 tendency tendency NN 35772 342 5 towards towards IN 35772 342 6 free free JJ 35772 342 7 enquiry enquiry NN 35772 342 8 and and CC 35772 342 9 independent independent JJ 35772 342 10 thought thought NN 35772 342 11 ; ; : 35772 342 12 and and CC 35772 342 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 342 14 was be VBD 35772 342 15 even even RB 35772 342 16 more more RBR 35772 342 17 significant significant JJ 35772 342 18 as as IN 35772 342 19 an an DT 35772 342 20 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 342 21 than than IN 35772 342 22 as as IN 35772 342 23 a a DT 35772 342 24 system system NN 35772 342 25 of of IN 35772 342 26 ideas idea NNS 35772 342 27 . . . 35772 343 1 Though though IN 35772 343 2 in in IN 35772 343 3 this this DT 35772 343 4 respect respect NN 35772 343 5 too too RB 35772 343 6 , , , 35772 343 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 343 8 was be VBD 35772 343 9 both both CC 35772 343 10 important important JJ 35772 343 11 and and CC 35772 343 12 vital vital JJ 35772 343 13 ; ; : 35772 343 14 as as IN 35772 343 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 343 16 have have VBP 35772 343 17 observed observe VBN 35772 343 18 , , , 35772 343 19 modern modern JJ 35772 343 20 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 343 21 theories theory NNS 35772 343 22 find find VBP 35772 343 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 343 24 parent parent NN 35772 343 25 in in IN 35772 343 26 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 343 27 . . . 35772 344 1 Nor nor CC 35772 344 2 was be VBD 35772 344 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 344 4 only only RB 35772 344 5 , , , 35772 344 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 344 7 may may MD 35772 344 8 remark remark VB 35772 344 9 , , , 35772 344 10 among among IN 35772 344 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 344 12 and and CC 35772 344 13 men man NNS 35772 344 14 of of IN 35772 344 15 science science NN 35772 344 16 that that WDT 35772 344 17 Cartesian cartesian JJ 35772 344 18 ideas idea NNS 35772 344 19 were be VBD 35772 344 20 popular popular JJ 35772 344 21 ; ; : 35772 344 22 they -PRON- PRP 35772 344 23 were be VBD 35772 344 24 accepted accept VBN 35772 344 25 and and CC 35772 344 26 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 344 27 by by IN 35772 344 28 the the DT 35772 344 29 religious religious JJ 35772 344 30 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 344 31 who who WP 35772 344 32 hoped hope VBD 35772 344 33 to to TO 35772 344 34 harmonise harmonise VB 35772 344 35 and and CC 35772 344 36 humanise humanise VB 35772 344 37 theology theology NN 35772 344 38 and and CC 35772 344 39 science science NN 35772 344 40 . . . 35772 345 1 Pascal pascal JJ 35772 345 2 , , , 35772 345 3 Bossuet Bossuet NNP 35772 345 4 and and CC 35772 345 5 Fénelon Fénelon NNP 35772 345 6 , , , 35772 345 7 the the DT 35772 345 8 finest fine JJS 35772 345 9 minds mind NNS 35772 345 10 in in IN 35772 345 11 the the DT 35772 345 12 French French NNP 35772 345 13 Church Church NNP 35772 345 14 , , , 35772 345 15 were be VBD 35772 345 16 eager eager JJ 35772 345 17 Cartesians Cartesians NNPS 35772 345 18 . . . 35772 346 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 346 2 5 5 CD 35772 346 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 346 4 This this DT 35772 346 5 aspect aspect NN 35772 346 6 of of IN 35772 346 7 the the DT 35772 346 8 matter matter NN 35772 346 9 , , , 35772 346 10 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 347 1 the the DT 35772 347 2 significance significance NN 35772 347 3 of of IN 35772 347 4 Cartesianism cartesianism NN 35772 347 5 for for IN 35772 347 6 religion religion NN 35772 347 7 , , , 35772 347 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 347 9 can can MD 35772 347 10 for for IN 35772 347 11 the the DT 35772 347 12 present present JJ 35772 347 13 postpone postpone NN 35772 347 14 . . . 35772 348 1 RESULTS RESULTS NNP 35772 348 2 SO SO NNP 35772 348 3 FAR.--Successive far.--successive JJ 35772 348 4 breaches breach NNS 35772 348 5 in in IN 35772 348 6 the the DT 35772 348 7 Scholastic scholastic JJ 35772 348 8 system system NN 35772 348 9 have have VBP 35772 348 10 now now RB 35772 348 11 been be VBN 35772 348 12 noted note VBN 35772 348 13 . . . 35772 349 1 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 349 2 had have VBD 35772 349 3 introduced introduce VBN 35772 349 4 a a DT 35772 349 5 new new JJ 35772 349 6 astronomy astronomy NN 35772 349 7 , , , 35772 349 8 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 349 9 a a DT 35772 349 10 new new JJ 35772 349 11 physics physics NN 35772 349 12 , , , 35772 349 13 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 349 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 349 15 with with IN 35772 349 16 the the DT 35772 349 17 help help NN 35772 349 18 of of IN 35772 349 19 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 349 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 349 21 a a DT 35772 349 22 new new JJ 35772 349 23 physiology physiology NN 35772 349 24 , , , 35772 349 25 and and CC 35772 349 26 the the DT 35772 349 27 beginnings beginning NNS 35772 349 28 of of IN 35772 349 29 a a DT 35772 349 30 new new JJ 35772 349 31 psychology psychology NN 35772 349 32 . . . 35772 350 1 CONTRIBUTIONS contribution NNS 35772 350 2 OF of IN 35772 350 3 HOBBES.--The hobbes.--the JJ 35772 350 4 step step NN 35772 350 5 that that WDT 35772 350 6 remained remain VBD 35772 350 7 was be VBD 35772 350 8 taken take VBN 35772 350 9 by by IN 35772 350 10 an an DT 35772 350 11 Englishman Englishman NNP 35772 350 12 , , , 35772 350 13 Thomas Thomas NNP 35772 350 14 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 35772 350 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 350 16 1588 1588 CD 35772 350 17 - - SYM 35772 350 18 1679 1679 CD 35772 350 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 350 20 , , , 35772 350 21 who who WP 35772 350 22 attempted attempt VBD 35772 350 23 to to TO 35772 350 24 provide provide VB 35772 350 25 a a DT 35772 350 26 system system NN 35772 350 27 of of IN 35772 350 28 ethics ethic NNS 35772 350 29 and and CC 35772 350 30 a a DT 35772 350 31 theory theory NN 35772 350 32 of of IN 35772 350 33 politics politic NNS 35772 350 34 upon upon IN 35772 350 35 a a DT 35772 350 36 purely purely RB 35772 350 37 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 350 38 basis basis NN 35772 350 39 . . . 35772 351 1 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 35772 351 2 was be VBD 35772 351 3 a a DT 35772 351 4 particularly particularly RB 35772 351 5 energetic energetic JJ 35772 351 6 thinker thinker NN 35772 351 7 . . . 35772 352 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 352 2 worked work VBD 35772 352 3 out out RP 35772 352 4 a a DT 35772 352 5 psychology psychology NN 35772 352 6 of of IN 35772 352 7 the the DT 35772 352 8 feelings feeling NNS 35772 352 9 , , , 35772 352 10 which which WDT 35772 352 11 reduced reduce VBD 35772 352 12 everything everything NN 35772 352 13 to to IN 35772 352 14 the the DT 35772 352 15 impulse impulse NN 35772 352 16 of of IN 35772 352 17 self self NN 35772 352 18 - - HYPH 35772 352 19 preservation preservation NN 35772 352 20 and and CC 35772 352 21 the the DT 35772 352 22 instinct instinct NN 35772 352 23 for for IN 35772 352 24 power power NN 35772 352 25 . . . 35772 353 1 Men man NNS 35772 353 2 were be VBD 35772 353 3 induced induce VBN 35772 353 4 by by IN 35772 353 5 these these DT 35772 353 6 instincts instinct NNS 35772 353 7 to to TO 35772 353 8 agree agree VB 35772 353 9 to to IN 35772 353 10 certain certain JJ 35772 353 11 rules rule NNS 35772 353 12 of of IN 35772 353 13 conduct conduct NN 35772 353 14 , , , 35772 353 15 for for IN 35772 353 16 the the DT 35772 353 17 sake sake NN 35772 353 18 of of IN 35772 353 19 expediency expediency NN 35772 353 20 . . . 35772 354 1 Social social JJ 35772 354 2 life life NN 35772 354 3 seems seem VBZ 35772 354 4 essential essential JJ 35772 354 5 if if IN 35772 354 6 men man NNS 35772 354 7 are be VBP 35772 354 8 to to TO 35772 354 9 live live VB 35772 354 10 together together RB 35772 354 11 -- -- : 35772 354 12 the the DT 35772 354 13 instinct instinct NN 35772 354 14 of of IN 35772 354 15 self self NN 35772 354 16 - - HYPH 35772 354 17 preservation preservation NN 35772 354 18 demands demand VBZ 35772 354 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 354 20 -- -- : 35772 354 21 and and CC 35772 354 22 social social JJ 35772 354 23 life life NN 35772 354 24 in in IN 35772 354 25 turn turn NN 35772 354 26 demands demand VBZ 35772 354 27 certain certain JJ 35772 354 28 renunciations renunciation NNS 35772 354 29 : : : 35772 354 30 thus thus RB 35772 354 31 fidelity fidelity NNP 35772 354 32 , , , 35772 354 33 gratitude gratitude NN 35772 354 34 , , , 35772 354 35 forbearance forbearance NN 35772 354 36 , , , 35772 354 37 justice justice NN 35772 354 38 , , , 35772 354 39 etc etc FW 35772 354 40 . . . 35772 354 41 , , , 35772 354 42 must must MD 35772 354 43 be be VB 35772 354 44 practised practise VBN 35772 354 45 . . . 35772 355 1 Thus thus RB 35772 355 2 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 35772 355 3 attempted attempt VBD 35772 355 4 to to TO 35772 355 5 banish banish VB 35772 355 6 all all DT 35772 355 7 mysterious mysterious JJ 35772 355 8 or or CC 35772 355 9 obscure obscure JJ 35772 355 10 forces force NNS 35772 355 11 from from IN 35772 355 12 morality morality NN 35772 355 13 , , , 35772 355 14 which which WDT 35772 355 15 was be VBD 35772 355 16 the the DT 35772 355 17 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 355 18 and and CC 35772 355 19 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 355 20 product product NN 35772 355 21 of of IN 35772 355 22 human human JJ 35772 355 23 nature nature NN 35772 355 24 and and CC 35772 355 25 human human JJ 35772 355 26 circumstances circumstance NNS 35772 355 27 . . . 35772 356 1 This this DT 35772 356 2 way way NN 35772 356 3 of of IN 35772 356 4 looking look VBG 35772 356 5 at at IN 35772 356 6 things thing NNS 35772 356 7 seemed seem VBD 35772 356 8 strange strange JJ 35772 356 9 to to IN 35772 356 10 all all DT 35772 356 11 , , , 35772 356 12 and and CC 35772 356 13 even even RB 35772 356 14 revolting revolt VBG 35772 356 15 to to IN 35772 356 16 some some DT 35772 356 17 , , , 35772 356 18 of of IN 35772 356 19 Hobbes hobbe NNS 35772 356 20 ' ' POS 35772 356 21 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 356 22 . . . 35772 357 1 As as IN 35772 357 2 the the DT 35772 357 3 mystical mystical JJ 35772 357 4 powers power NNS 35772 357 5 of of IN 35772 357 6 motion motion NN 35772 357 7 which which WDT 35772 357 8 the the DT 35772 357 9 Scholastics Scholastics NNPS 35772 357 10 had have VBD 35772 357 11 believed believe VBN 35772 357 12 in in IN 35772 357 13 were be VBD 35772 357 14 banished banish VBN 35772 357 15 by by IN 35772 357 16 the the DT 35772 357 17 new new JJ 35772 357 18 physics physics NN 35772 357 19 and and CC 35772 357 20 the the DT 35772 357 21 new new JJ 35772 357 22 physiology physiology NN 35772 357 23 , , , 35772 357 24 so so IN 35772 357 25 the the DT 35772 357 26 new new JJ 35772 357 27 psychology psychology NN 35772 357 28 could could MD 35772 357 29 allow allow VB 35772 357 30 of of IN 35772 357 31 no no DT 35772 357 32 mystical mystical JJ 35772 357 33 faculty faculty NN 35772 357 34 which which WDT 35772 357 35 can can MD 35772 357 36 decide decide VB 35772 357 37 in in IN 35772 357 38 all all DT 35772 357 39 problems problem NNS 35772 357 40 of of IN 35772 357 41 good good NN 35772 357 42 and and CC 35772 357 43 evil evil NN 35772 357 44 . . . 35772 358 1 With with IN 35772 358 2 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 358 3 , , , 35772 358 4 then then RB 35772 358 5 , , , 35772 358 6 a a DT 35772 358 7 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 358 8 view view NN 35772 358 9 of of IN 35772 358 10 the the DT 35772 358 11 universe universe NN 35772 358 12 may may MD 35772 358 13 be be VB 35772 358 14 said say VBN 35772 358 15 to to TO 35772 358 16 have have VB 35772 358 17 been be VBN 35772 358 18 tolerably tolerably RB 35772 358 19 complete complete JJ 35772 358 20 : : : 35772 358 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 358 22 embraces embrace VBZ 35772 358 23 physics physics NN 35772 358 24 , , , 35772 358 25 psychology psychology NN 35772 358 26 , , , 35772 358 27 and and CC 35772 358 28 ethics ethic NNS 35772 358 29 . . . 35772 359 1 There there EX 35772 359 2 still still RB 35772 359 3 remained remain VBD 35772 359 4 , , , 35772 359 5 of of IN 35772 359 6 course course NN 35772 359 7 , , , 35772 359 8 a a DT 35772 359 9 number number NN 35772 359 10 of of IN 35772 359 11 gaps gap NNS 35772 359 12 in in IN 35772 359 13 scientific scientific JJ 35772 359 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 359 15 , , , 35772 359 16 and and CC 35772 359 17 consequently consequently RB 35772 359 18 any any DT 35772 359 19 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 359 20 based base VBN 35772 359 21 thereupon thereupon RB 35772 359 22 could could MD 35772 359 23 not not RB 35772 359 24 yet yet RB 35772 359 25 be be VB 35772 359 26 regarded regard VBN 35772 359 27 as as IN 35772 359 28 secure secure JJ 35772 359 29 . . . 35772 360 1 These these DT 35772 360 2 gaps gap NNS 35772 360 3 , , , 35772 360 4 however however RB 35772 360 5 , , , 35772 360 6 as as IN 35772 360 7 research research NN 35772 360 8 proceeded proceed VBD 35772 360 9 and and CC 35772 360 10 successive successive JJ 35772 360 11 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 360 12 were be VBD 35772 360 13 made make VBN 35772 360 14 , , , 35772 360 15 tended tend VBD 35772 360 16 to to TO 35772 360 17 diminish diminish VB 35772 360 18 both both DT 35772 360 19 in in IN 35772 360 20 size size NN 35772 360 21 and and CC 35772 360 22 quantity quantity NN 35772 360 23 . . . 35772 361 1 NEWTON.--The newton.--the LS 35772 361 2 seventeenth seventeenth NNP 35772 361 3 and and CC 35772 361 4 the the DT 35772 361 5 early early JJ 35772 361 6 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 361 7 centuries century NNS 35772 361 8 were be VBD 35772 361 9 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 361 10 in in IN 35772 361 11 revelations revelation NNS 35772 361 12 of of IN 35772 361 13 this this DT 35772 361 14 kind kind NN 35772 361 15 , , , 35772 361 16 and and CC 35772 361 17 natural natural JJ 35772 361 18 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 361 19 steadily steadily RB 35772 361 20 and and CC 35772 361 21 even even RB 35772 361 22 rapidly rapidly RB 35772 361 23 progressed progress VBN 35772 361 24 . . . 35772 362 1 And and CC 35772 362 2 one one CD 35772 362 3 thinker thinker NN 35772 362 4 , , , 35772 362 5 who who WP 35772 362 6 may may MD 35772 362 7 be be VB 35772 362 8 regarded regard VBN 35772 362 9 as as IN 35772 362 10 a a DT 35772 362 11 link link NN 35772 362 12 between between IN 35772 362 13 the the DT 35772 362 14 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 362 15 century century NN 35772 362 16 and and CC 35772 362 17 that that IN 35772 362 18 which which WDT 35772 362 19 succeeded succeed VBD 35772 362 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 362 21 , , , 35772 362 22 may may MD 35772 362 23 now now RB 35772 362 24 claim claim VB 35772 362 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 362 26 attention attention NN 35772 362 27 . . . 35772 363 1 The the DT 35772 363 2 name name NN 35772 363 3 of of IN 35772 363 4 Newton Newton NNP 35772 363 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 363 6 1642 1642 CD 35772 363 7 - - SYM 35772 363 8 1727 1727 CD 35772 363 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 363 10 is be VBZ 35772 363 11 as as RB 35772 363 12 familiar familiar JJ 35772 363 13 to to IN 35772 363 14 Englishmen Englishmen NNP 35772 363 15 as as IN 35772 363 16 that that DT 35772 363 17 of of IN 35772 363 18 Shakespeare Shakespeare NNP 35772 363 19 , , , 35772 363 20 and and CC 35772 363 21 the the DT 35772 363 22 discovery discovery NN 35772 363 23 by by IN 35772 363 24 him -PRON- PRP 35772 363 25 of of IN 35772 363 26 the the DT 35772 363 27 " " `` 35772 363 28 law law NN 35772 363 29 of of IN 35772 363 30 gravitation gravitation NN 35772 363 31 " " '' 35772 363 32 is be VBZ 35772 363 33 one one CD 35772 363 34 of of IN 35772 363 35 those those DT 35772 363 36 scraps scrap NNS 35772 363 37 of of IN 35772 363 38 information information NN 35772 363 39 which which WDT 35772 363 40 we -PRON- PRP 35772 363 41 acquire acquire VBP 35772 363 42 , , , 35772 363 43 and and CC 35772 363 44 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 363 45 fail fail VB 35772 363 46 to to TO 35772 363 47 understand understand VB 35772 363 48 , , , 35772 363 49 in in IN 35772 363 50 early early JJ 35772 363 51 childhood childhood NN 35772 363 52 . . . 35772 364 1 Newton Newton NNP 35772 364 2 's 's POS 35772 364 3 scientific scientific JJ 35772 364 4 method method NN 35772 364 5 is be VBZ 35772 364 6 a a DT 35772 364 7 no no RB 35772 364 8 less less RBR 35772 364 9 important important JJ 35772 364 10 aspect aspect NN 35772 364 11 of of IN 35772 364 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 364 13 work work NN 35772 364 14 than than IN 35772 364 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 364 16 results result NNS 35772 364 17 . . . 35772 365 1 The the DT 35772 365 2 _ _ NNP 35772 365 3 Principia Principia NNP 35772 365 4 _ _ NNP 35772 365 5 , , , 35772 365 6 in in IN 35772 365 7 which which WDT 35772 365 8 he -PRON- PRP 35772 365 9 gave give VBD 35772 365 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 365 11 discovery discovery NN 35772 365 12 to to IN 35772 365 13 the the DT 35772 365 14 world world NN 35772 365 15 , , , 35772 365 16 is be VBZ 35772 365 17 " " `` 35772 365 18 a a DT 35772 365 19 model model NN 35772 365 20 for for IN 35772 365 21 all all DT 35772 365 22 scientific scientific JJ 35772 365 23 investigations investigation NNS 35772 365 24 which which WDT 35772 365 25 has have VBZ 35772 365 26 never never RB 35772 365 27 been be VBN 35772 365 28 surpassed surpass VBN 35772 365 29 . . . 35772 365 30 " " '' 35772 366 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 366 2 was be VBD 35772 366 3 , , , 35772 366 4 indeed indeed RB 35772 366 5 , , , 35772 366 6 a a DT 35772 366 7 brilliant brilliant JJ 35772 366 8 application application NN 35772 366 9 of of IN 35772 366 10 the the DT 35772 366 11 principle principle NN 35772 366 12 of of IN 35772 366 13 inferring infer VBG 35772 366 14 the the DT 35772 366 15 unknown unknown NN 35772 366 16 from from IN 35772 366 17 the the DT 35772 366 18 already already RB 35772 366 19 known know VBN 35772 366 20 , , , 35772 366 21 without without IN 35772 366 22 any any DT 35772 366 23 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 366 24 leaps leap NNS 35772 366 25 in in IN 35772 366 26 the the DT 35772 366 27 dark dark NN 35772 366 28 . . . 35772 367 1 The the DT 35772 367 2 principle principle NN 35772 367 3 with with IN 35772 367 4 which which WDT 35772 367 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 367 6 began begin VBD 35772 367 7 was be VBD 35772 367 8 that that IN 35772 367 9 what what WP 35772 367 10 is be VBZ 35772 367 11 true true JJ 35772 367 12 in in IN 35772 367 13 the the DT 35772 367 14 narrower narrow JJR 35772 367 15 spheres sphere NNS 35772 367 16 of of IN 35772 367 17 experience experience NN 35772 367 18 ( ( -LRB- 35772 367 19 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 368 1 in in IN 35772 368 2 the the DT 35772 368 3 case case NN 35772 368 4 of of IN 35772 368 5 an an DT 35772 368 6 apple apple NN 35772 368 7 falling fall VBG 35772 368 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 368 9 is be VBZ 35772 368 10 true true JJ 35772 368 11 also also RB 35772 368 12 in in IN 35772 368 13 the the DT 35772 368 14 wider wide JJR 35772 368 15 spheres sphere NNS 35772 368 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 368 17 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 369 1 in in IN 35772 369 2 the the DT 35772 369 3 movements movement NNS 35772 369 4 of of IN 35772 369 5 the the DT 35772 369 6 celestial celestial JJ 35772 369 7 bodies body NNS 35772 369 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 369 9 . . . 35772 370 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 370 2 then then RB 35772 370 3 made make VBD 35772 370 4 a a DT 35772 370 5 careful careful JJ 35772 370 6 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 370 7 deduction deduction NN 35772 370 8 of of IN 35772 370 9 what what WP 35772 370 10 would would MD 35772 370 11 happen happen VB 35772 370 12 in in IN 35772 370 13 the the DT 35772 370 14 case case NN 35772 370 15 of of IN 35772 370 16 the the DT 35772 370 17 planets planet NNS 35772 370 18 , , , 35772 370 19 assuming assume VBG 35772 370 20 that that IN 35772 370 21 the the DT 35772 370 22 laws law NNS 35772 370 23 of of IN 35772 370 24 falling fall VBG 35772 370 25 bodies body NNS 35772 370 26 on on IN 35772 370 27 the the DT 35772 370 28 earth earth NN 35772 370 29 were be VBD 35772 370 30 applicable applicable JJ 35772 370 31 to to IN 35772 370 32 them -PRON- PRP 35772 370 33 also also RB 35772 370 34 . . . 35772 371 1 And and CC 35772 371 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 371 3 concluded conclude VBD 35772 371 4 by by IN 35772 371 5 showing show VBG 35772 371 6 that that IN 35772 371 7 what what WP 35772 371 8 would would MD 35772 371 9 happen happen VB 35772 371 10 according accord VBG 35772 371 11 to to IN 35772 371 12 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 371 13 under under IN 35772 371 14 this this DT 35772 371 15 assumption assumption NN 35772 371 16 _ _ NNP 35772 371 17 actually actually RB 35772 371 18 does do VBZ 35772 371 19 happen happen VB 35772 371 20 _ _ NNP 35772 371 21 . . . 35772 372 1 The the DT 35772 372 2 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 372 3 follows follow VBZ 35772 372 4 that that IN 35772 372 5 the the DT 35772 372 6 same same JJ 35772 372 7 force force NN 35772 372 8 , , , 35772 372 9 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 373 1 " " `` 35772 373 2 attraction attraction NN 35772 373 3 , , , 35772 373 4 " " '' 35772 373 5 operates operate VBZ 35772 373 6 in in IN 35772 373 7 both both DT 35772 373 8 cases case NNS 35772 373 9 . . . 35772 374 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 374 2 is be VBZ 35772 374 3 no no DT 35772 374 4 wonder wonder NN 35772 374 5 that that IN 35772 374 6 this this DT 35772 374 7 final final JJ 35772 374 8 and and CC 35772 374 9 successful successful JJ 35772 374 10 operation operation NN 35772 374 11 was be VBD 35772 374 12 performed perform VBN 35772 374 13 by by IN 35772 374 14 Newton Newton NNP 35772 374 15 " " `` 35772 374 16 in in IN 35772 374 17 a a DT 35772 374 18 state state NN 35772 374 19 of of IN 35772 374 20 excitement excitement NN 35772 374 21 so so RB 35772 374 22 great great JJ 35772 374 23 that that IN 35772 374 24 he -PRON- PRP 35772 374 25 could could MD 35772 374 26 hardly hardly RB 35772 374 27 see see VB 35772 374 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 374 29 figures figure NNS 35772 374 30 . . . 35772 374 31 " " '' 35772 375 1 SIGNIFICANCE significance VB 35772 375 2 OF of IN 35772 375 3 HIS his PRP$ 35772 375 4 DISCOVERY.--The discovery.--the JJ 35772 375 5 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 375 6 importance importance NN 35772 375 7 of of IN 35772 375 8 the the DT 35772 375 9 discovery discovery NN 35772 375 10 that that IN 35772 375 11 the the DT 35772 375 12 motions motion NNS 35772 375 13 of of IN 35772 375 14 the the DT 35772 375 15 planets planet NNS 35772 375 16 may may MD 35772 375 17 be be VB 35772 375 18 explained explain VBN 35772 375 19 by by IN 35772 375 20 the the DT 35772 375 21 " " `` 35772 375 22 law law NN 35772 375 23 of of IN 35772 375 24 gravitation gravitation NN 35772 375 25 " " '' 35772 375 26 was be VBD 35772 375 27 twofold twofold JJ 35772 375 28 . . . 35772 376 1 In in IN 35772 376 2 the the DT 35772 376 3 first first JJ 35772 376 4 place place NN 35772 376 5 , , , 35772 376 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 376 7 now now RB 35772 376 8 became become VBD 35772 376 9 possible possible JJ 35772 376 10 to to TO 35772 376 11 understand understand VB 35772 376 12 how how WRB 35772 376 13 the the DT 35772 376 14 universe universe NN 35772 376 15 held hold VBN 35772 376 16 together together RB 35772 376 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 376 18 a a DT 35772 376 19 problem problem NN 35772 376 20 which which WDT 35772 376 21 the the DT 35772 376 22 new new JJ 35772 376 23 astronomy astronomy NN 35772 376 24 had have VBD 35772 376 25 not not RB 35772 376 26 solved solve VBN 35772 376 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 376 28 ; ; : 35772 376 29 and and CC 35772 376 30 in in IN 35772 376 31 the the DT 35772 376 32 second second JJ 35772 376 33 place place NN 35772 376 34 , , , 35772 376 35 the the DT 35772 376 36 theory theory NN 35772 376 37 constituted constitute VBD 35772 376 38 a a DT 35772 376 39 large large JJ 35772 376 40 extension extension NN 35772 376 41 of of IN 35772 376 42 the the DT 35772 376 43 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 376 44 view view NN 35772 376 45 . . . 35772 377 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 377 2 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 35772 377 3 that that IN 35772 377 4 " " `` 35772 377 5 the the DT 35772 377 6 physical physical JJ 35772 377 7 laws law NNS 35772 377 8 which which WDT 35772 377 9 hold hold VBP 35772 377 10 good good JJ 35772 377 11 on on IN 35772 377 12 the the DT 35772 377 13 surface surface NN 35772 377 14 of of IN 35772 377 15 the the DT 35772 377 16 earth earth NN 35772 377 17 are be VBP 35772 377 18 valid valid JJ 35772 377 19 throughout throughout IN 35772 377 20 the the DT 35772 377 21 universe universe NN 35772 377 22 , , , 35772 377 23 so so RB 35772 377 24 far far RB 35772 377 25 as as IN 35772 377 26 we -PRON- PRP 35772 377 27 can can MD 35772 377 28 know know VB 35772 377 29 anything anything NN 35772 377 30 of of IN 35772 377 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 377 32 . . . 35772 377 33 " " '' 35772 378 1 Thus thus RB 35772 378 2 the the DT 35772 378 3 area area NN 35772 378 4 of of IN 35772 378 5 existence existence NN 35772 378 6 in in IN 35772 378 7 which which WDT 35772 378 8 physical physical JJ 35772 378 9 law law NN 35772 378 10 held hold VBD 35772 378 11 good good JJ 35772 378 12 was be VBD 35772 378 13 at at IN 35772 378 14 once once RB 35772 378 15 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 378 16 widened widen VBN 35772 378 17 . . . 35772 379 1 The the DT 35772 379 2 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 379 3 theories theory NNS 35772 379 4 of of IN 35772 379 5 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 379 6 , , , 35772 379 7 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 379 8 , , , 35772 379 9 and and CC 35772 379 10 others other NNS 35772 379 11 , , , 35772 379 12 not not RB 35772 379 13 only only RB 35772 379 14 received receive VBD 35772 379 15 confirmation confirmation NN 35772 379 16 , , , 35772 379 17 but but CC 35772 379 18 became become VBD 35772 379 19 more more RBR 35772 379 20 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 35772 379 21 than than IN 35772 379 22 before before RB 35772 379 23 . . . 35772 380 1 So so RB 35772 380 2 that that IN 35772 380 3 Newton Newton NNP 35772 380 4 may may MD 35772 380 5 be be VB 35772 380 6 said say VBN 35772 380 7 to to TO 35772 380 8 have have VB 35772 380 9 put put VBN 35772 380 10 the the DT 35772 380 11 finishing finishing JJ 35772 380 12 touch touch NN 35772 380 13 upon upon IN 35772 380 14 the the DT 35772 380 15 achievements achievement NNS 35772 380 16 of of IN 35772 380 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 380 18 predecessors predecessor NNS 35772 380 19 , , , 35772 380 20 and and CC 35772 380 21 to to TO 35772 380 22 have have VB 35772 380 23 crowned crown VBN 35772 380 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 380 25 labours labour NNS 35772 380 26 with with IN 35772 380 27 success success NN 35772 380 28 . . . 35772 381 1 And and CC 35772 381 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 381 3 work work NN 35772 381 4 has have VBZ 35772 381 5 the the DT 35772 381 6 characteristic characteristic NN 35772 381 7 of of IN 35772 381 8 permanency permanency NN 35772 381 9 : : : 35772 381 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 381 11 " " `` 35772 381 12 gravitation gravitation NN 35772 381 13 formula formula NN 35772 381 14 " " '' 35772 381 15 has have VBZ 35772 381 16 stood stand VBN 35772 381 17 the the DT 35772 381 18 test test NN 35772 381 19 of of IN 35772 381 20 time time NN 35772 381 21 . . . 35772 382 1 " " `` 35772 382 2 It -PRON- PRP 35772 382 3 still still RB 35772 382 4 stands stand VBZ 35772 382 5 there there RB 35772 382 6 , , , 35772 382 7 " " '' 35772 382 8 says say VBZ 35772 382 9 a a DT 35772 382 10 careful careful JJ 35772 382 11 and and CC 35772 382 12 authoritative authoritative JJ 35772 382 13 writer writer NN 35772 382 14 , , , 35772 382 15 " " '' 35772 382 16 as as IN 35772 382 17 almost almost RB 35772 382 18 the the DT 35772 382 19 only only JJ 35772 382 20 firmly firmly RB 35772 382 21 established establish VBN 35772 382 22 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 382 23 relation relation NN 35772 382 24 , , , 35772 382 25 expressive expressive JJ 35772 382 26 of of IN 35772 382 27 a a DT 35772 382 28 property property NN 35772 382 29 of of IN 35772 382 30 all all DT 35772 382 31 matter matter NN 35772 382 32 , , , 35772 382 33 to to TO 35772 382 34 which which WDT 35772 382 35 the the DT 35772 382 36 progress progress NN 35772 382 37 of of IN 35772 382 38 more more JJR 35772 382 39 than than IN 35772 382 40 two two CD 35772 382 41 centuries century NNS 35772 382 42 has have VBZ 35772 382 43 added add VBN 35772 382 44 nothing nothing NN 35772 382 45 , , , 35772 382 46 and and CC 35772 382 47 from from IN 35772 382 48 which which WDT 35772 382 49 it -PRON- PRP 35772 382 50 has have VBZ 35772 382 51 taken take VBN 35772 382 52 nothing nothing NN 35772 382 53 away away RB 35772 382 54 . . . 35772 383 1 " " `` 35772 383 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 383 3 6 6 CD 35772 383 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 383 5 RELIGIOUS RELIGIOUS NNP 35772 383 6 COROLLARIES.--It COROLLARIES.--It NNP 35772 383 7 would would MD 35772 383 8 be be VB 35772 383 9 a a DT 35772 383 10 profound profound JJ 35772 383 11 mistake mistake NN 35772 383 12 to to TO 35772 383 13 assume assume VB 35772 383 14 that that IN 35772 383 15 the the DT 35772 383 16 creators creator NNS 35772 383 17 of of IN 35772 383 18 the the DT 35772 383 19 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 383 20 view view NN 35772 383 21 , , , 35772 383 22 as as IN 35772 383 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 383 24 has have VBZ 35772 383 25 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 383 26 met meet VBN 35772 383 27 us -PRON- PRP 35772 383 28 , , , 35772 383 29 were be VBD 35772 383 30 animated animate VBN 35772 383 31 by by IN 35772 383 32 any any DT 35772 383 33 hostility hostility NN 35772 383 34 to to IN 35772 383 35 religion religion NN 35772 383 36 . . . 35772 384 1 Nor nor CC 35772 384 2 did do VBD 35772 384 3 they -PRON- PRP 35772 384 4 believe believe VB 35772 384 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 384 6 theories theory NNS 35772 384 7 to to TO 35772 384 8 involve involve VB 35772 384 9 any any DT 35772 384 10 disastrous disastrous JJ 35772 384 11 consequences consequence NNS 35772 384 12 in in IN 35772 384 13 that that DT 35772 384 14 sphere sphere NN 35772 384 15 . . . 35772 385 1 The the DT 35772 385 2 new new JJ 35772 385 3 astronomy astronomy NN 35772 385 4 of of IN 35772 385 5 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 385 6 had have VBD 35772 385 7 actually actually RB 35772 385 8 been be VBN 35772 385 9 made make VBN 35772 385 10 the the DT 35772 385 11 basis basis NN 35772 385 12 of of IN 35772 385 13 a a DT 35772 385 14 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 385 15 view view NN 35772 385 16 of of IN 35772 385 17 the the DT 35772 385 18 universe universe NN 35772 385 19 by by IN 35772 385 20 the the DT 35772 385 21 profound profound JJ 35772 385 22 genius genius NN 35772 385 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 385 24 both both CC 35772 385 25 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 385 26 and and CC 35772 385 27 religious religious JJ 35772 385 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 385 29 of of IN 35772 385 30 Giordano Giordano NNP 35772 385 31 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 385 32 . . . 35772 386 1 And and CC 35772 386 2 the the DT 35772 386 3 fact fact NN 35772 386 4 that that IN 35772 386 5 the the DT 35772 386 6 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 35772 386 7 authorities authority NNS 35772 386 8 rejected reject VBD 35772 386 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 386 10 view view NN 35772 386 11 need nee MD 35772 386 12 not not RB 35772 386 13 divest divest VB 35772 386 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 386 15 of of IN 35772 386 16 importance importance NN 35772 386 17 or or CC 35772 386 18 of of IN 35772 386 19 value value NN 35772 386 20 in in IN 35772 386 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 386 22 eyes eye NNS 35772 386 23 . . . 35772 387 1 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 387 2 's 's POS 35772 387 3 own own JJ 35772 387 4 faith faith NN 35772 387 5 was be VBD 35772 387 6 not not RB 35772 387 7 disturbed disturb VBN 35772 387 8 by by IN 35772 387 9 the the DT 35772 387 10 infidelity infidelity NN 35772 387 11 of of IN 35772 387 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 387 13 persecutors persecutor NNS 35772 387 14 . . . 35772 388 1 " " `` 35772 388 2 Ye Ye NNP 35772 388 3 who who WP 35772 388 4 pass pass VBP 35772 388 5 judgment judgment NN 35772 388 6 upon upon IN 35772 388 7 me -PRON- PRP 35772 388 8 feel feel VBP 35772 388 9 , , , 35772 388 10 maybe maybe RB 35772 388 11 , , , 35772 388 12 greater great JJR 35772 388 13 fear fear NN 35772 388 14 than than IN 35772 388 15 I -PRON- PRP 35772 388 16 upon upon IN 35772 388 17 whom whom WP 35772 388 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 388 19 is be VBZ 35772 388 20 passed pass VBN 35772 388 21 , , , 35772 388 22 " " '' 35772 388 23 were be VBD 35772 388 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 388 25 last last JJ 35772 388 26 words word NNS 35772 388 27 to to IN 35772 388 28 them -PRON- PRP 35772 388 29 . . . 35772 389 1 Had have VBD 35772 389 2 they -PRON- PRP 35772 389 3 _ _ NNP 35772 389 4 believed believe VBD 35772 389 5 _ _ NNP 35772 389 6 , , , 35772 389 7 they -PRON- PRP 35772 389 8 need nee MD 35772 389 9 not not RB 35772 389 10 have have VB 35772 389 11 been be VBN 35772 389 12 afraid afraid JJ 35772 389 13 , , , 35772 389 14 and and CC 35772 389 15 might may MD 35772 389 16 have have VB 35772 389 17 been be VBN 35772 389 18 content content JJ 35772 389 19 with with IN 35772 389 20 the the DT 35772 389 21 policy policy NN 35772 389 22 of of IN 35772 389 23 Gamaliel Gamaliel NNP 35772 389 24 . . . 35772 390 1 As as IN 35772 390 2 for for IN 35772 390 3 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 390 4 and and CC 35772 390 5 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 390 6 , , , 35772 390 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 390 8 notions notion NNS 35772 390 9 were be VBD 35772 390 10 no no RB 35772 390 11 doubt doubt RB 35772 390 12 distasteful distasteful JJ 35772 390 13 to to IN 35772 390 14 conservative conservative JJ 35772 390 15 minds mind NNS 35772 390 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 390 17 the the DT 35772 390 18 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 35772 390 19 were be VBD 35772 390 20 no no DT 35772 390 21 friends friend NNS 35772 390 22 to to IN 35772 390 23 either either RB 35772 390 24 ) ) -RRB- 35772 390 25 , , , 35772 390 26 but but CC 35772 390 27 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 390 28 regarded regard VBD 35772 390 29 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 390 30 , , , 35772 390 31 and and CC 35772 390 32 would would MD 35772 390 33 fain fain VB 35772 390 34 have have VBP 35772 390 35 been be VBN 35772 390 36 regarded regard VBN 35772 390 37 by by IN 35772 390 38 others other NNS 35772 390 39 , , , 35772 390 40 as as IN 35772 390 41 a a DT 35772 390 42 good good JJ 35772 390 43 Catholic catholic NN 35772 390 44 ; ; : 35772 390 45 and and CC 35772 390 46 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 390 47 , , , 35772 390 48 theologically theologically RB 35772 390 49 , , , 35772 390 50 was be VBD 35772 390 51 what what WP 35772 390 52 in in IN 35772 390 53 these these DT 35772 390 54 days day NNS 35772 390 55 we -PRON- PRP 35772 390 56 might may MD 35772 390 57 call call VB 35772 390 58 a a DT 35772 390 59 Liberal Liberal NNP 35772 390 60 Protestant Protestant NNP 35772 390 61 . . . 35772 391 1 Cartesianism cartesianism NN 35772 391 2 , , , 35772 391 3 as as IN 35772 391 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 391 5 have have VBP 35772 391 6 seen see VBN 35772 391 7 , , , 35772 391 8 came come VBD 35772 391 9 to to TO 35772 391 10 be be VB 35772 391 11 a a DT 35772 391 12 name name NN 35772 391 13 for for IN 35772 391 14 a a DT 35772 391 15 type type NN 35772 391 16 of of IN 35772 391 17 thought thought NN 35772 391 18 which which WDT 35772 391 19 studied study VBD 35772 391 20 to to TO 35772 391 21 harmonise harmonise VB 35772 391 22 science science NN 35772 391 23 and and CC 35772 391 24 theology theology NN 35772 391 25 , , , 35772 391 26 and and CC 35772 391 27 one one CD 35772 391 28 of of IN 35772 391 29 the the DT 35772 391 30 most most RBS 35772 391 31 profound profound JJ 35772 391 32 religious religious JJ 35772 391 33 geniuses genius NNS 35772 391 34 of of IN 35772 391 35 any any DT 35772 391 36 age age NN 35772 391 37 -- -- : 35772 391 38 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 391 39 , , , 35772 391 40 was be VBD 35772 391 41 ( ( -LRB- 35772 391 42 as as IN 35772 391 43 we -PRON- PRP 35772 391 44 have have VBP 35772 391 45 seen see VBN 35772 391 46 ) ) -RRB- 35772 391 47 a a DT 35772 391 48 Cartesian Cartesian NNP 35772 391 49 . . . 35772 392 1 As as IN 35772 392 2 for for IN 35772 392 3 Newton Newton NNP 35772 392 4 , , , 35772 392 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 392 6 view view NN 35772 392 7 of of IN 35772 392 8 the the DT 35772 392 9 universe universe NN 35772 392 10 was be VBD 35772 392 11 essentially essentially RB 35772 392 12 a a DT 35772 392 13 religious religious JJ 35772 392 14 one one NN 35772 392 15 , , , 35772 392 16 though though IN 35772 392 17 he -PRON- PRP 35772 392 18 did do VBD 35772 392 19 not not RB 35772 392 20 allow allow VB 35772 392 21 theological theological JJ 35772 392 22 speculations speculation NNS 35772 392 23 to to TO 35772 392 24 intrude intrude VB 35772 392 25 upon upon IN 35772 392 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 392 27 strictly strictly RB 35772 392 28 scientific scientific JJ 35772 392 29 work work NN 35772 392 30 . . . 35772 393 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 393 2 attitude attitude NN 35772 393 3 is be VBZ 35772 393 4 indicated indicate VBN 35772 393 5 by by IN 35772 393 6 a a DT 35772 393 7 reply reply NN 35772 393 8 to to IN 35772 393 9 the the DT 35772 393 10 inquiry inquiry NN 35772 393 11 of of IN 35772 393 12 a a DT 35772 393 13 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 393 14 theologian theologian NN 35772 393 15 as as IN 35772 393 16 to to IN 35772 393 17 how how WRB 35772 393 18 the the DT 35772 393 19 movements movement NNS 35772 393 20 and and CC 35772 393 21 structure structure NN 35772 393 22 of of IN 35772 393 23 the the DT 35772 393 24 solar solar JJ 35772 393 25 system system NN 35772 393 26 were be VBD 35772 393 27 to to TO 35772 393 28 be be VB 35772 393 29 accounted account VBN 35772 393 30 for for IN 35772 393 31 . . . 35772 394 1 " " `` 35772 394 2 To to IN 35772 394 3 your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 394 4 query query NN 35772 394 5 I -PRON- PRP 35772 394 6 answer answer VBP 35772 394 7 that that IN 35772 394 8 the the DT 35772 394 9 motions motion NNS 35772 394 10 which which WDT 35772 394 11 the the DT 35772 394 12 planets planet NNS 35772 394 13 now now RB 35772 394 14 have have VBP 35772 394 15 could could MD 35772 394 16 not not RB 35772 394 17 spring spring VB 35772 394 18 from from IN 35772 394 19 any any DT 35772 394 20 natural natural JJ 35772 394 21 cause cause NN 35772 394 22 alone alone RB 35772 394 23 .... .... . 35772 394 24 To to TO 35772 394 25 compare compare VB 35772 394 26 and and CC 35772 394 27 adjust adjust VB 35772 394 28 all all PDT 35772 394 29 these these DT 35772 394 30 things thing NNS 35772 394 31 together together RB 35772 394 32 ( ( -LRB- 35772 394 33 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 395 1 quantities quantity NNS 35772 395 2 of of IN 35772 395 3 matter matter NN 35772 395 4 and and CC 35772 395 5 gravitating gravitate VBG 35772 395 6 powers power NNS 35772 395 7 , , , 35772 395 8 etc etc FW 35772 395 9 . . . 35772 395 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 396 1 in in IN 35772 396 2 so so RB 35772 396 3 great great JJ 35772 396 4 a a DT 35772 396 5 variety variety NN 35772 396 6 of of IN 35772 396 7 bodies body NNS 35772 396 8 , , , 35772 396 9 argues argue VBZ 35772 396 10 the the DT 35772 396 11 cause cause NN 35772 396 12 to to TO 35772 396 13 be be VB 35772 396 14 not not RB 35772 396 15 blind blind JJ 35772 396 16 and and CC 35772 396 17 fortuitous fortuitous JJ 35772 396 18 , , , 35772 396 19 but but CC 35772 396 20 very very RB 35772 396 21 well well RB 35772 396 22 skilled skilled JJ 35772 396 23 in in IN 35772 396 24 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 396 25 and and CC 35772 396 26 geometry geometry NN 35772 396 27 . . . 35772 397 1 " " `` 35772 397 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 397 3 7 7 CD 35772 397 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 397 5 Still still RB 35772 397 6 , , , 35772 397 7 the the DT 35772 397 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 397 9 view view NN 35772 397 10 contained contain VBD 35772 397 11 within within IN 35772 397 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 397 13 sinister sinister JJ 35772 397 14 possibilities possibility NNS 35772 397 15 ; ; : 35772 397 16 and and CC 35772 397 17 the the DT 35772 397 18 instincts instinct NNS 35772 397 19 of of IN 35772 397 20 conservative conservative JJ 35772 397 21 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 397 22 were be VBD 35772 397 23 not not RB 35772 397 24 altogether altogether RB 35772 397 25 at at IN 35772 397 26 fault fault NN 35772 397 27 . . . 35772 398 1 The the DT 35772 398 2 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 398 3 view view NN 35772 398 4 in in IN 35772 398 5 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 398 6 need nee MD 35772 398 7 not not RB 35772 398 8 be be VB 35772 398 9 hostile hostile JJ 35772 398 10 to to IN 35772 398 11 a a DT 35772 398 12 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 398 13 and and CC 35772 398 14 rational rational JJ 35772 398 15 religion religion NN 35772 398 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 398 17 though though IN 35772 398 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 398 19 is be VBZ 35772 398 20 fatal fatal JJ 35772 398 21 to to IN 35772 398 22 most most JJS 35772 398 23 forms form NNS 35772 398 24 of of IN 35772 398 25 superstition superstition NN 35772 398 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 398 27 ; ; : 35772 398 28 and and CC 35772 398 29 yet yet RB 35772 398 30 that that DT 35772 398 31 view view NN 35772 398 32 can can MD 35772 398 33 be be VB 35772 398 34 used use VBN 35772 398 35 in in IN 35772 398 36 the the DT 35772 398 37 interests interest NNS 35772 398 38 of of IN 35772 398 39 anti anti JJ 35772 398 40 - - JJ 35772 398 41 religious religious JJ 35772 398 42 prejudice prejudice NN 35772 398 43 -- -- : 35772 398 44 and and CC 35772 398 45 , , , 35772 398 46 as as IN 35772 398 47 we -PRON- PRP 35772 398 48 shall shall MD 35772 398 49 see see VB 35772 398 50 , , , 35772 398 51 it -PRON- PRP 35772 398 52 was be VBD 35772 398 53 so so RB 35772 398 54 used use VBN 35772 398 55 , , , 35772 398 56 and and CC 35772 398 57 with with IN 35772 398 58 considerable considerable JJ 35772 398 59 effect effect NN 35772 398 60 . . . 35772 399 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 35772 399 2 , , , 35772 399 3 however however RB 35772 399 4 , , , 35772 399 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 399 6 shall shall MD 35772 399 7 pass pass VB 35772 399 8 on on RP 35772 399 9 to to TO 35772 399 10 consider consider VB 35772 399 11 the the DT 35772 399 12 work work NN 35772 399 13 of of IN 35772 399 14 three three CD 35772 399 15 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 399 16 who who WP 35772 399 17 are be VBP 35772 399 18 typical typical JJ 35772 399 19 of of IN 35772 399 20 a a DT 35772 399 21 revolt revolt NN 35772 399 22 from from IN 35772 399 23 what what WP 35772 399 24 was be VBD 35772 399 25 in in IN 35772 399 26 danger danger NN 35772 399 27 of of IN 35772 399 28 becoming become VBG 35772 399 29 the the DT 35772 399 30 all all RB 35772 399 31 - - HYPH 35772 399 32 absorbing absorb VBG 35772 399 33 tyranny tyranny NN 35772 399 34 of of IN 35772 399 35 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 399 36 . . . 35772 400 1 This this DT 35772 400 2 reaction reaction NN 35772 400 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 400 4 for for IN 35772 400 5 so so RB 35772 400 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 400 7 may may MD 35772 400 8 be be VB 35772 400 9 termed term VBN 35772 400 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 400 11 we -PRON- PRP 35772 400 12 shall shall MD 35772 400 13 proceed proceed VB 35772 400 14 , , , 35772 400 15 in in IN 35772 400 16 the the DT 35772 400 17 following follow VBG 35772 400 18 chapter chapter NN 35772 400 19 , , , 35772 400 20 to to TO 35772 400 21 examine examine VB 35772 400 22 . . . 35772 401 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 401 2 IV IV NNP 35772 401 3 SEVENTEENTH SEVENTEENTH NNP 35772 401 4 - - HYPH 35772 401 5 CENTURY CENTURY NNP 35772 401 6 REACTIONS reactions VBP 35772 401 7 A a DT 35772 401 8 LAW law NN 35772 401 9 OF of IN 35772 401 10 THOUGHT.--Whenever THOUGHT.--Whenever `` 35772 401 11 a a DT 35772 401 12 tendency tendency NN 35772 401 13 of of IN 35772 401 14 thought thought NN 35772 401 15 has have VBZ 35772 401 16 been be VBN 35772 401 17 vigorously vigorously RB 35772 401 18 prosecuted prosecute VBN 35772 401 19 for for IN 35772 401 20 any any DT 35772 401 21 length length NN 35772 401 22 of of IN 35772 401 23 time time NN 35772 401 24 , , , 35772 401 25 a a DT 35772 401 26 reaction reaction NN 35772 401 27 invariably invariably RB 35772 401 28 displays display VBZ 35772 401 29 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 401 30 . . . 35772 402 1 This this DT 35772 402 2 rule rule NN 35772 402 3 is be VBZ 35772 402 4 illustrated illustrate VBN 35772 402 5 by by IN 35772 402 6 the the DT 35772 402 7 history history NN 35772 402 8 of of IN 35772 402 9 thought thought NN 35772 402 10 in in IN 35772 402 11 the the DT 35772 402 12 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 402 13 century century NN 35772 402 14 . . . 35772 403 1 Mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 403 2 categories category NNS 35772 403 3 , , , 35772 403 4 as as IN 35772 403 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 403 6 have have VBP 35772 403 7 seen see VBN 35772 403 8 , , , 35772 403 9 had have VBD 35772 403 10 been be VBN 35772 403 11 steadily steadily RB 35772 403 12 extending extend VBG 35772 403 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 403 14 for for IN 35772 403 15 the the DT 35772 403 16 better well JJR 35772 403 17 part part NN 35772 403 18 of of IN 35772 403 19 two two CD 35772 403 20 centuries century NNS 35772 403 21 , , , 35772 403 22 and and CC 35772 403 23 with with IN 35772 403 24 the the DT 35772 403 25 materialism materialism NN 35772 403 26 of of IN 35772 403 27 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 35772 403 28 the the DT 35772 403 29 process process NN 35772 403 30 seemed seem VBD 35772 403 31 fairly fairly RB 35772 403 32 complete complete JJ 35772 403 33 . . . 35772 404 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 35772 404 2 , , , 35772 404 3 however however RB 35772 404 4 , , , 35772 404 5 human human JJ 35772 404 6 thought thought NN 35772 404 7 began begin VBD 35772 404 8 to to TO 35772 404 9 explore explore VB 35772 404 10 other other JJ 35772 404 11 avenues avenue NNS 35772 404 12 . . . 35772 405 1 Though though IN 35772 405 2 reaction reaction NN 35772 405 3 from from IN 35772 405 4 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 405 5 ways way NNS 35772 405 6 of of IN 35772 405 7 thinking thinking NN 35772 405 8 did do VBD 35772 405 9 not not RB 35772 405 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 405 11 at at IN 35772 405 12 any any DT 35772 405 13 rate rate NN 35772 405 14 , , , 35772 405 15 in in IN 35772 405 16 the the DT 35772 405 17 circles circle NNS 35772 405 18 with with IN 35772 405 19 which which WDT 35772 405 20 we -PRON- PRP 35772 405 21 are be VBP 35772 405 22 concerned concerned JJ 35772 405 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 405 24 take take VB 35772 405 25 the the DT 35772 405 26 form form NN 35772 405 27 of of IN 35772 405 28 an an DT 35772 405 29 obscurantist obscurantist JJ 35772 405 30 retreat retreat NN 35772 405 31 into into IN 35772 405 32 prejudice prejudice NN 35772 405 33 or or CC 35772 405 34 superstition superstition NN 35772 405 35 , , , 35772 405 36 the the DT 35772 405 37 results result NNS 35772 405 38 of of IN 35772 405 39 the the DT 35772 405 40 new new JJ 35772 405 41 science science NN 35772 405 42 and and CC 35772 405 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 405 44 attendant attendant JJ 35772 405 45 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 405 46 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 405 47 served serve VBD 35772 405 48 as as IN 35772 405 49 a a DT 35772 405 50 base base NN 35772 405 51 for for IN 35772 405 52 further further JJ 35772 405 53 explorations exploration NNS 35772 405 54 . . . 35772 406 1 The the DT 35772 406 2 principles principle NNS 35772 406 3 which which WDT 35772 406 4 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 406 5 and and CC 35772 406 6 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 406 7 had have VBD 35772 406 8 laid lay VBN 35772 406 9 down down RP 35772 406 10 were be VBD 35772 406 11 criticised criticise VBN 35772 406 12 by by IN 35772 406 13 being be VBG 35772 406 14 carried carry VBN 35772 406 15 out out RP 35772 406 16 to to IN 35772 406 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 406 18 logical logical JJ 35772 406 19 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 406 20 . . . 35772 407 1 SPINOZA.--The spinoza.--the LS 35772 407 2 philosopher philosopher NNP 35772 407 3 with with IN 35772 407 4 whom whom WP 35772 407 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 407 6 shall shall MD 35772 407 7 first first RB 35772 407 8 concern concern NN 35772 407 9 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 407 10 was be VBD 35772 407 11 a a DT 35772 407 12 Jew Jew NNP 35772 407 13 of of IN 35772 407 14 Spanish spanish JJ 35772 407 15 extraction extraction NN 35772 407 16 , , , 35772 407 17 living live VBG 35772 407 18 in in IN 35772 407 19 what what WP 35772 407 20 was be VBD 35772 407 21 then then RB 35772 407 22 the the DT 35772 407 23 freest free JJS 35772 407 24 country country NN 35772 407 25 in in IN 35772 407 26 Europe Europe NNP 35772 407 27 -- -- : 35772 407 28 Holland Holland NNP 35772 407 29 . . . 35772 408 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 408 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 408 3 1632 1632 CD 35772 408 4 - - SYM 35772 408 5 1677 1677 CD 35772 408 6 ) ) -RRB- 35772 408 7 was be VBD 35772 408 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 35772 408 9 the the DT 35772 408 10 greatest great JJS 35772 408 11 thinker thinker NN 35772 408 12 of of IN 35772 408 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 408 14 own own JJ 35772 408 15 age age NN 35772 408 16 , , , 35772 408 17 which which WDT 35772 408 18 was be VBD 35772 408 19 highly highly RB 35772 408 20 fertile fertile JJ 35772 408 21 in in IN 35772 408 22 that that DT 35772 408 23 respect respect NN 35772 408 24 , , , 35772 408 25 and and CC 35772 408 26 he -PRON- PRP 35772 408 27 still still RB 35772 408 28 stands stand VBZ 35772 408 29 as as IN 35772 408 30 one one CD 35772 408 31 of of IN 35772 408 32 the the DT 35772 408 33 most most RBS 35772 408 34 notable notable JJ 35772 408 35 figures figure NNS 35772 408 36 in in IN 35772 408 37 the the DT 35772 408 38 long long JJ 35772 408 39 history history NN 35772 408 40 of of IN 35772 408 41 European european JJ 35772 408 42 thought thought NN 35772 408 43 . . . 35772 409 1 Not not RB 35772 409 2 only only RB 35772 409 3 is be VBZ 35772 409 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 409 5 outlook outlook NN 35772 409 6 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 35772 409 7 , , , 35772 409 8 and and CC 35772 409 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 409 10 thought thought NN 35772 409 11 many many JJ 35772 409 12 - - HYPH 35772 409 13 sided sided JJ 35772 409 14 , , , 35772 409 15 but but CC 35772 409 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 409 17 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 409 18 was be VBD 35772 409 19 " " `` 35772 409 20 detached detach VBN 35772 409 21 " " '' 35772 409 22 to to IN 35772 409 23 a a DT 35772 409 24 degree degree NN 35772 409 25 hitherto hitherto NNP 35772 409 26 unknown unknown JJ 35772 409 27 . . . 35772 410 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 410 2 was be VBD 35772 410 3 untainted untainted JJ 35772 410 4 , , , 35772 410 5 so so RB 35772 410 6 far far RB 35772 410 7 as as IN 35772 410 8 a a DT 35772 410 9 human human NN 35772 410 10 being be VBG 35772 410 11 ever ever RB 35772 410 12 can can MD 35772 410 13 be be VB 35772 410 14 , , , 35772 410 15 by by IN 35772 410 16 " " `` 35772 410 17 anthropomorphism anthropomorphism NN 35772 410 18 " " '' 35772 410 19 ; ; : 35772 410 20 he -PRON- PRP 35772 410 21 endeavoured endeavour VBD 35772 410 22 to to TO 35772 410 23 transcend transcend VB 35772 410 24 the the DT 35772 410 25 merely merely RB 35772 410 26 human human JJ 35772 410 27 outlook outlook NN 35772 410 28 . . . 35772 411 1 Here here RB 35772 411 2 is be VBZ 35772 411 3 always always RB 35772 411 4 the the DT 35772 411 5 dividing divide VBG 35772 411 6 line line NN 35772 411 7 between between IN 35772 411 8 the the DT 35772 411 9 great great JJ 35772 411 10 and and CC 35772 411 11 the the DT 35772 411 12 merely merely RB 35772 411 13 mediocre mediocre JJ 35772 411 14 thinker thinker NN 35772 411 15 . . . 35772 412 1 SPINOZA SPINOZA NNP 35772 412 2 'S 's POS 35772 412 3 METHOD.--Spinoza method.--spinoza NN 35772 412 4 's 's POS 35772 412 5 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 412 6 ancestry ancestry NN 35772 412 7 may may MD 35772 412 8 be be VB 35772 412 9 traced trace VBN 35772 412 10 back back RB 35772 412 11 to to IN 35772 412 12 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 412 13 , , , 35772 412 14 whose whose WP$ 35772 412 15 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 412 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 412 17 made make VBD 35772 412 18 in in IN 35772 412 19 a a DT 35772 412 20 previous previous JJ 35772 412 21 chapter chapter NN 35772 412 22 , , , 35772 412 23 but but CC 35772 412 24 in in IN 35772 412 25 whose whose WP$ 35772 412 26 company company NN 35772 412 27 we -PRON- PRP 35772 412 28 did do VBD 35772 412 29 not not RB 35772 412 30 long long RB 35772 412 31 remain remain VB 35772 412 32 . . . 35772 413 1 This this DT 35772 413 2 highly highly RB 35772 413 3 original original JJ 35772 413 4 mind mind NN 35772 413 5 had have VBD 35772 413 6 already already RB 35772 413 7 , , , 35772 413 8 by by IN 35772 413 9 the the DT 35772 413 10 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 413 11 of of IN 35772 413 12 the the DT 35772 413 13 infinitude infinitude NN 35772 413 14 and and CC 35772 413 15 the the DT 35772 413 16 divinity divinity NN 35772 413 17 of of IN 35772 413 18 nature nature NN 35772 413 19 , , , 35772 413 20 shown show VBD 35772 413 21 how how WRB 35772 413 22 the the DT 35772 413 23 concept concept NN 35772 413 24 of of IN 35772 413 25 God God NNP 35772 413 26 and and CC 35772 413 27 the the DT 35772 413 28 concept concept NN 35772 413 29 of of IN 35772 413 30 nature nature NN 35772 413 31 might may MD 35772 413 32 be be VB 35772 413 33 closely closely RB 35772 413 34 bound bind VBN 35772 413 35 up up RP 35772 413 36 together together RB 35772 413 37 . . . 35772 414 1 By by IN 35772 414 2 similar similar JJ 35772 414 3 means mean NNS 35772 414 4 , , , 35772 414 5 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 414 6 hoped hope VBD 35772 414 7 to to TO 35772 414 8 indicate indicate VB 35772 414 9 the the DT 35772 414 10 reality reality NN 35772 414 11 of of IN 35772 414 12 the the DT 35772 414 13 spiritual spiritual NN 35772 414 14 , , , 35772 414 15 without without IN 35772 414 16 disturbing disturb VBG 35772 414 17 the the DT 35772 414 18 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 414 19 world world NN 35772 414 20 - - HYPH 35772 414 21 conception conception NN 35772 414 22 which which WDT 35772 414 23 the the DT 35772 414 24 new new JJ 35772 414 25 science science NN 35772 414 26 and and CC 35772 414 27 new new JJ 35772 414 28 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 414 29 had have VBD 35772 414 30 created create VBN 35772 414 31 between between IN 35772 414 32 them -PRON- PRP 35772 414 33 . . . 35772 415 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 415 2 wished wish VBD 35772 415 3 somehow somehow RB 35772 415 4 to to TO 35772 415 5 find find VB 35772 415 6 God God NNP 35772 415 7 not not RB 35772 415 8 outside outside RB 35772 415 9 , , , 35772 415 10 but but CC 35772 415 11 _ _ NNP 35772 415 12 in in IN 35772 415 13 _ _ NNP 35772 415 14 Nature Nature NNP 35772 415 15 ; ; : 35772 415 16 not not RB 35772 415 17 in in IN 35772 415 18 disturbances disturbance NNS 35772 415 19 of of IN 35772 415 20 the the DT 35772 415 21 order order NN 35772 415 22 of of IN 35772 415 23 Nature Nature NNP 35772 415 24 , , , 35772 415 25 but but CC 35772 415 26 _ _ NNP 35772 415 27 in in IN 35772 415 28 that that DT 35772 415 29 order order NN 35772 415 30 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 415 31 _ _ NNP 35772 415 32 . . . 35772 416 1 THE the DT 35772 416 2 TERM TERM NNP 35772 416 3 NATURE.--It NATURE.--It NNP 35772 416 4 would would MD 35772 416 5 be be VB 35772 416 6 a a DT 35772 416 7 misapprehension misapprehension NN 35772 416 8 to to TO 35772 416 9 suppose suppose VB 35772 416 10 that that IN 35772 416 11 the the DT 35772 416 12 terms term NNS 35772 416 13 " " `` 35772 416 14 God God NNP 35772 416 15 " " '' 35772 416 16 and and CC 35772 416 17 " " `` 35772 416 18 Nature Nature NNP 35772 416 19 " " '' 35772 416 20 are be VBP 35772 416 21 regarded regard VBN 35772 416 22 by by IN 35772 416 23 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 416 24 as as IN 35772 416 25 interchangeable interchangeable JJ 35772 416 26 , , , 35772 416 27 though though IN 35772 416 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 416 29 numerous numerous JJ 35772 416 30 critics critic NNS 35772 416 31 were be VBD 35772 416 32 accustomed accustom VBN 35772 416 33 to to TO 35772 416 34 declare declare VB 35772 416 35 that that IN 35772 416 36 this this DT 35772 416 37 was be VBD 35772 416 38 the the DT 35772 416 39 case case NN 35772 416 40 . . . 35772 417 1 On on IN 35772 417 2 the the DT 35772 417 3 contrary contrary NN 35772 417 4 , , , 35772 417 5 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 417 6 , , , 35772 417 7 in in IN 35772 417 8 order order NN 35772 417 9 to to TO 35772 417 10 anticipate anticipate VB 35772 417 11 the the DT 35772 417 12 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 35772 417 13 which which WDT 35772 417 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 417 15 saw see VBD 35772 417 16 might may MD 35772 417 17 arise arise VB 35772 417 18 on on IN 35772 417 19 this this DT 35772 417 20 point point NN 35772 417 21 , , , 35772 417 22 reintroduced reintroduce VBN 35772 417 23 into into IN 35772 417 24 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 417 25 a a DT 35772 417 26 pair pair NN 35772 417 27 of of IN 35772 417 28 terms term NNS 35772 417 29 which which WDT 35772 417 30 the the DT 35772 417 31 Scholastics Scholastics NNPS 35772 417 32 had have VBD 35772 417 33 long long RB 35772 417 34 before before RB 35772 417 35 brought bring VBN 35772 417 36 into into IN 35772 417 37 currency currency NN 35772 417 38 , , , 35772 417 39 but but CC 35772 417 40 which which WDT 35772 417 41 had have VBD 35772 417 42 since since IN 35772 417 43 fallen fall VBN 35772 417 44 out out IN 35772 417 45 of of IN 35772 417 46 fashion--_Natura fashion--_Natura NNP 35772 417 47 naturans naturans NNP 35772 417 48 _ _ NNP 35772 417 49 and and CC 35772 417 50 _ _ NNP 35772 417 51 Natura Natura NNP 35772 417 52 naturata naturata NN 35772 417 53 _ _ NNP 35772 417 54 . . . 35772 418 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 418 2 might may MD 35772 418 3 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 418 4 translate translate VB 35772 418 5 the the DT 35772 418 6 former former JJ 35772 418 7 of of IN 35772 418 8 these these DT 35772 418 9 , , , 35772 418 10 " " `` 35772 418 11 Creative creative JJ 35772 418 12 Nature nature NN 35772 418 13 , , , 35772 418 14 " " '' 35772 418 15 and and CC 35772 418 16 the the DT 35772 418 17 latter latter JJ 35772 418 18 , , , 35772 418 19 " " `` 35772 418 20 Created created JJ 35772 418 21 Nature nature NN 35772 418 22 . . . 35772 418 23 " " '' 35772 419 1 _ _ NNP 35772 419 2 Natura Natura NNP 35772 419 3 naturans naturan NNS 35772 419 4 _ _ NNP 35772 419 5 is be VBZ 35772 419 6 equivalent equivalent JJ 35772 419 7 to to IN 35772 419 8 " " `` 35772 419 9 Nature nature NN 35772 419 10 as as IN 35772 419 11 a a DT 35772 419 12 creative creative JJ 35772 419 13 power power NN 35772 419 14 , , , 35772 419 15 " " '' 35772 419 16 or or CC 35772 419 17 " " `` 35772 419 18 The the DT 35772 419 19 creative creative JJ 35772 419 20 power power NN 35772 419 21 immanent immanent NN 35772 419 22 in in IN 35772 419 23 Nature Nature NNP 35772 419 24 . . . 35772 419 25 " " '' 35772 420 1 _ _ NNP 35772 420 2 Natura Natura NNP 35772 420 3 naturata naturata NN 35772 420 4 _ _ NNP 35772 420 5 is be VBZ 35772 420 6 equivalent equivalent JJ 35772 420 7 to to IN 35772 420 8 " " `` 35772 420 9 Nature nature NN 35772 420 10 as as IN 35772 420 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 420 12 is be VBZ 35772 420 13 when when WRB 35772 420 14 created create VBN 35772 420 15 , , , 35772 420 16 " " '' 35772 420 17 or or CC 35772 420 18 " " `` 35772 420 19 The the DT 35772 420 20 results result NNS 35772 420 21 of of IN 35772 420 22 the the DT 35772 420 23 creative creative JJ 35772 420 24 power power NN 35772 420 25 immanent immanent NN 35772 420 26 in in IN 35772 420 27 Nature Nature NNP 35772 420 28 . . . 35772 420 29 " " '' 35772 421 1 And and CC 35772 421 2 the the DT 35772 421 3 _ _ NNP 35772 421 4 Natura Natura NNP 35772 421 5 naturans naturan NNS 35772 421 6 _ _ NNP 35772 421 7 is be VBZ 35772 421 8 active active JJ 35772 421 9 in in IN 35772 421 10 the the DT 35772 421 11 _ _ NNP 35772 421 12 Natura Natura NNP 35772 421 13 naturata naturata NN 35772 421 14 _ _ NNP 35772 421 15 at at IN 35772 421 16 all all DT 35772 421 17 points point NNS 35772 421 18 : : : 35772 421 19 the the DT 35772 421 20 creative creative JJ 35772 421 21 power power NN 35772 421 22 is be VBZ 35772 421 23 immanent immanent NN 35772 421 24 in in IN 35772 421 25 creation creation NN 35772 421 26 . . . 35772 422 1 As as IN 35772 422 2 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 422 3 puts put VBZ 35772 422 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 422 5 in in IN 35772 422 6 one one CD 35772 422 7 of of IN 35772 422 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 422 9 letters letter NNS 35772 422 10 : : : 35772 422 11 " " `` 35772 422 12 I -PRON- PRP 35772 422 13 assert assert VBP 35772 422 14 that that IN 35772 422 15 God God NNP 35772 422 16 is be VBZ 35772 422 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 422 18 as as IN 35772 422 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 422 20 is be VBZ 35772 422 21 called call VBN 35772 422 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 422 23 the the DT 35772 422 24 immanent immanent NN 35772 422 25 , , , 35772 422 26 not not RB 35772 422 27 the the DT 35772 422 28 external external JJ 35772 422 29 cause cause NN 35772 422 30 of of IN 35772 422 31 all all DT 35772 422 32 things thing NNS 35772 422 33 . . . 35772 423 1 That that DT 35772 423 2 is be VBZ 35772 423 3 to to TO 35772 423 4 say say VB 35772 423 5 , , , 35772 423 6 I -PRON- PRP 35772 423 7 assert assert VBP 35772 423 8 with with IN 35772 423 9 Paul Paul NNP 35772 423 10 , , , 35772 423 11 that that IN 35772 423 12 in in IN 35772 423 13 God God NNP 35772 423 14 all all DT 35772 423 15 things thing NNS 35772 423 16 live live VBP 35772 423 17 and and CC 35772 423 18 move move VBP 35772 423 19 .... .... . 35772 424 1 But but CC 35772 424 2 if if IN 35772 424 3 any any DT 35772 424 4 one one NN 35772 424 5 thinks think VBZ 35772 424 6 that that IN 35772 424 7 the the DT 35772 424 8 _ _ NNP 35772 424 9 Theologico Theologico NNP 35772 424 10 - - HYPH 35772 424 11 Political Political NNP 35772 424 12 Treatise Treatise NNP 35772 424 13 _ _ NNP 35772 424 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 424 15 one one CD 35772 424 16 of of IN 35772 424 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 424 18 works work NNS 35772 424 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 424 20 assumes assume VBZ 35772 424 21 that that IN 35772 424 22 God God NNP 35772 424 23 and and CC 35772 424 24 Nature Nature NNP 35772 424 25 are be VBP 35772 424 26 one one CD 35772 424 27 and and CC 35772 424 28 the the DT 35772 424 29 same same JJ 35772 424 30 , , , 35772 424 31 he -PRON- PRP 35772 424 32 is be VBZ 35772 424 33 entirely entirely RB 35772 424 34 mistaken mistaken JJ 35772 424 35 . . . 35772 425 1 " " `` 35772 425 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 425 3 8 8 CD 35772 425 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 425 5 Thus thus RB 35772 425 6 , , , 35772 425 7 for for IN 35772 425 8 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 425 9 , , , 35772 425 10 the the DT 35772 425 11 order order NN 35772 425 12 of of IN 35772 425 13 nature nature NN 35772 425 14 , , , 35772 425 15 which which WDT 35772 425 16 had have VBD 35772 425 17 seemed seem VBN 35772 425 18 to to IN 35772 425 19 so so RB 35772 425 20 many many JJ 35772 425 21 of of IN 35772 425 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 425 23 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 425 24 , , , 35772 425 25 from from IN 35772 425 26 the the DT 35772 425 27 religious religious JJ 35772 425 28 point point NN 35772 425 29 of of IN 35772 425 30 view view NN 35772 425 31 , , , 35772 425 32 such such PDT 35772 425 33 a a DT 35772 425 34 devastating devastating JJ 35772 425 35 conception conception NN 35772 425 36 , , , 35772 425 37 as as IN 35772 425 38 leaving leave VBG 35772 425 39 no no DT 35772 425 40 room room NN 35772 425 41 for for IN 35772 425 42 the the DT 35772 425 43 spiritual spiritual NN 35772 425 44 , , , 35772 425 45 was be VBD 35772 425 46 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 425 47 only only RB 35772 425 48 explicable explicable JJ 35772 425 49 if if IN 35772 425 50 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 425 51 spiritually spiritually RB 35772 425 52 . . . 35772 426 1 " " `` 35772 426 2 Whatever whatever WDT 35772 426 3 is be VBZ 35772 426 4 , , , 35772 426 5 is be VBZ 35772 426 6 in in IN 35772 426 7 God God NNP 35772 426 8 , , , 35772 426 9 and and CC 35772 426 10 nothing nothing NN 35772 426 11 can can MD 35772 426 12 exist exist VB 35772 426 13 or or CC 35772 426 14 be be VB 35772 426 15 conceived conceive VBN 35772 426 16 without without IN 35772 426 17 God God NNP 35772 426 18 " " '' 35772 426 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 426 20 _ _ NNP 35772 426 21 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 426 22 _ _ NNP 35772 426 23 i. i. NNP 35772 427 1 15 15 LS 35772 427 2 ) ) -RRB- 35772 427 3 sums sum VBZ 35772 427 4 up up RP 35772 427 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 427 6 attitude attitude NN 35772 427 7 . . . 35772 428 1 All all DT 35772 428 2 things thing NNS 35772 428 3 may may MD 35772 428 4 be be VB 35772 428 5 , , , 35772 428 6 as as IN 35772 428 7 the the DT 35772 428 8 new new JJ 35772 428 9 science science NN 35772 428 10 taught teach VBD 35772 428 11 , , , 35772 428 12 ' ' '' 35772 428 13 determined determine VBN 35772 428 14 ' ' '' 35772 428 15 but but CC 35772 428 16 they -PRON- PRP 35772 428 17 are be VBP 35772 428 18 determined determine VBN 35772 428 19 " " '' 35772 428 20 by by IN 35772 428 21 the the DT 35772 428 22 necessity necessity NN 35772 428 23 of of IN 35772 428 24 the the DT 35772 428 25 divine divine JJ 35772 428 26 nature nature NN 35772 428 27 " " '' 35772 428 28 ( ( -LRB- 35772 428 29 _ _ NNP 35772 428 30 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 428 31 _ _ NNP 35772 428 32 i. i. NNP 35772 429 1 29 29 CD 35772 429 2 ) ) -RRB- 35772 429 3 . . . 35772 430 1 THE the DT 35772 430 2 " " `` 35772 430 3 ETHICS ethic NNS 35772 430 4 . . . 35772 430 5 " " '' 35772 431 1 --Spinoza --Spinoza : 35772 431 2 may may MD 35772 431 3 rightly rightly RB 35772 431 4 be be VB 35772 431 5 termed term VBN 35772 431 6 a a DT 35772 431 7 man man NN 35772 431 8 of of IN 35772 431 9 one one CD 35772 431 10 book book NN 35772 431 11 . . . 35772 432 1 In in IN 35772 432 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 432 3 _ _ NNP 35772 432 4 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 432 5 _ _ NNP 35772 432 6 is be VBZ 35772 432 7 to to TO 35772 432 8 be be VB 35772 432 9 found find VBN 35772 432 10 a a DT 35772 432 11 complete complete JJ 35772 432 12 and and CC 35772 432 13 final final JJ 35772 432 14 expression expression NN 35772 432 15 of of IN 35772 432 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 432 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 432 18 . . . 35772 433 1 " " `` 35772 433 2 How how WRB 35772 433 3 boundless boundless JJ 35772 433 4 , , , 35772 433 5 " " '' 35772 433 6 says say VBZ 35772 433 7 Goethe Goethe NNP 35772 433 8 of of IN 35772 433 9 this this DT 35772 433 10 great great JJ 35772 433 11 book book NN 35772 433 12 , , , 35772 433 13 " " '' 35772 433 14 is be VBZ 35772 433 15 the the DT 35772 433 16 disinterestedness disinterestedness JJ 35772 433 17 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 35772 433 18 in in IN 35772 433 19 every every DT 35772 433 20 sentence sentence NN 35772 433 21 , , , 35772 433 22 how how WRB 35772 433 23 exalted exalted JJ 35772 433 24 the the DT 35772 433 25 resignation resignation NN 35772 433 26 which which WDT 35772 433 27 submits submit VBZ 35772 433 28 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 433 29 once once RB 35772 433 30 for for IN 35772 433 31 all all RB 35772 433 32 to to IN 35772 433 33 the the DT 35772 433 34 great great JJ 35772 433 35 laws law NNS 35772 433 36 of of IN 35772 433 37 existence existence NN 35772 433 38 , , , 35772 433 39 instead instead RB 35772 433 40 of of IN 35772 433 41 trying try VBG 35772 433 42 to to TO 35772 433 43 get get VB 35772 433 44 through through IN 35772 433 45 life life NN 35772 433 46 with with IN 35772 433 47 the the DT 35772 433 48 help help NN 35772 433 49 of of IN 35772 433 50 trivial trivial JJ 35772 433 51 consolations consolation NNS 35772 433 52 ; ; : 35772 433 53 and and CC 35772 433 54 what what WP 35772 433 55 an an DT 35772 433 56 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 433 57 of of IN 35772 433 58 peace peace NN 35772 433 59 breathes breathe NNS 35772 433 60 through through IN 35772 433 61 the the DT 35772 433 62 whole whole NN 35772 433 63 ! ! . 35772 433 64 " " '' 35772 434 1 According accord VBG 35772 434 2 to to IN 35772 434 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 434 4 teaching teaching NN 35772 434 5 the the DT 35772 434 6 true true JJ 35772 434 7 happiness happiness NN 35772 434 8 and and CC 35772 434 9 highest high JJS 35772 434 10 activity activity NN 35772 434 11 of of IN 35772 434 12 men man NNS 35772 434 13 is be VBZ 35772 434 14 to to TO 35772 434 15 be be VB 35772 434 16 found find VBN 35772 434 17 in in IN 35772 434 18 what what WP 35772 434 19 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 434 20 terms term NNS 35772 434 21 " " `` 35772 434 22 the the DT 35772 434 23 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 434 24 love love NN 35772 434 25 of of IN 35772 434 26 God God NNP 35772 434 27 . . . 35772 434 28 " " '' 35772 435 1 The the DT 35772 435 2 phrase phrase NN 35772 435 3 seems seem VBZ 35772 435 4 to to TO 35772 435 5 have have VB 35772 435 6 been be VBN 35772 435 7 used use VBN 35772 435 8 to to TO 35772 435 9 designate designate VB 35772 435 10 that that IN 35772 435 11 full full JJ 35772 435 12 and and CC 35772 435 13 clearer clear JJR 35772 435 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 435 15 which which WDT 35772 435 16 is be VBZ 35772 435 17 aware aware JJ 35772 435 18 that that IN 35772 435 19 we -PRON- PRP 35772 435 20 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 435 21 and and CC 35772 435 22 all all PDT 35772 435 23 the the DT 35772 435 24 conditions condition NNS 35772 435 25 of of IN 35772 435 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 435 27 life life NN 35772 435 28 are be VBP 35772 435 29 determined determine VBN 35772 435 30 by by IN 35772 435 31 the the DT 35772 435 32 infinite infinite JJ 35772 435 33 Nature Nature NNP 35772 435 34 , , , 35772 435 35 by by IN 35772 435 36 God God NNP 35772 435 37 Himself Himself NNP 35772 435 38 , , , 35772 435 39 who who WP 35772 435 40 moves move VBZ 35772 435 41 in in IN 35772 435 42 us -PRON- PRP 35772 435 43 as as RB 35772 435 44 well well RB 35772 435 45 as as IN 35772 435 46 in in IN 35772 435 47 all all DT 35772 435 48 things thing NNS 35772 435 49 acting act VBG 35772 435 50 upon upon IN 35772 435 51 us -PRON- PRP 35772 435 52 . . . 35772 436 1 The the DT 35772 436 2 initiated initiate VBN 35772 436 3 no no RB 35772 436 4 longer long RBR 35772 436 5 regard regard VB 35772 436 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 436 7 as as IN 35772 436 8 single single JJ 35772 436 9 , , , 35772 436 10 isolated isolated JJ 35772 436 11 , , , 35772 436 12 impotent impotent JJ 35772 436 13 beings being NNS 35772 436 14 , , , 35772 436 15 but but CC 35772 436 16 as as IN 35772 436 17 included include VBN 35772 436 18 in in IN 35772 436 19 the the DT 35772 436 20 divine divine JJ 35772 436 21 nature nature NN 35772 436 22 . . . 35772 437 1 Themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 437 2 and and CC 35772 437 3 all all DT 35772 437 4 things thing NNS 35772 437 5 are be VBP 35772 437 6 seen see VBN 35772 437 7 under under IN 35772 437 8 the the DT 35772 437 9 form form NN 35772 437 10 of of IN 35772 437 11 eternity eternity NN 35772 437 12 . . . 35772 438 1 This this DT 35772 438 2 thought thought NN 35772 438 3 is be VBZ 35772 438 4 , , , 35772 438 5 according accord VBG 35772 438 6 to to IN 35772 438 7 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 438 8 , , , 35772 438 9 the the DT 35772 438 10 fruit fruit NN 35772 438 11 of of IN 35772 438 12 the the DT 35772 438 13 highest high JJS 35772 438 14 activity activity NN 35772 438 15 of of IN 35772 438 16 the the DT 35772 438 17 human human JJ 35772 438 18 mind mind NN 35772 438 19 ; ; : 35772 438 20 this this DT 35772 438 21 is be VBZ 35772 438 22 the the DT 35772 438 23 _ _ NNP 35772 438 24 amor amor NN 35772 438 25 intellectualis intellectualis NNP 35772 438 26 dei dei NNP 35772 438 27 _ _ NNP 35772 438 28 ; ; : 35772 438 29 and and CC 35772 438 30 the the DT 35772 438 31 supreme supreme NNP 35772 438 32 good good NNP 35772 438 33 for for IN 35772 438 34 man man NN 35772 438 35 . . . 35772 439 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 439 2 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 439 3 of of IN 35772 439 4 immortality immortality NN 35772 439 5 is be VBZ 35772 439 6 bound bind VBN 35772 439 7 up up RP 35772 439 8 with with IN 35772 439 9 this this DT 35772 439 10 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 439 11 form form NN 35772 439 12 of of IN 35772 439 13 religious religious JJ 35772 439 14 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 439 15 -- -- : 35772 439 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 439 17 of of IN 35772 439 18 God God NNP 35772 439 19 involves involve VBZ 35772 439 20 participation participation NN 35772 439 21 in in IN 35772 439 22 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 439 23 immortality immortality NN 35772 439 24 : : : 35772 439 25 " " `` 35772 439 26 Death death NN 35772 439 27 is be VBZ 35772 439 28 the the DT 35772 439 29 less less RBR 35772 439 30 harmful harmful JJ 35772 439 31 the the DT 35772 439 32 more more JJR 35772 439 33 the the DT 35772 439 34 mind mind NN 35772 439 35 's 's POS 35772 439 36 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 439 37 is be VBZ 35772 439 38 clear clear JJ 35772 439 39 and and CC 35772 439 40 distinct distinct JJ 35772 439 41 , , , 35772 439 42 and and CC 35772 439 43 the the DT 35772 439 44 more more JJR 35772 439 45 the the DT 35772 439 46 mind mind NN 35772 439 47 loves love VBZ 35772 439 48 God God NNP 35772 439 49 .... .... . 35772 440 1 The the DT 35772 440 2 human human JJ 35772 440 3 mind mind NN 35772 440 4 may may MD 35772 440 5 be be VB 35772 440 6 of of IN 35772 440 7 such such PDT 35772 440 8 a a DT 35772 440 9 nature nature NN 35772 440 10 that that WDT 35772 440 11 the the DT 35772 440 12 part part NN 35772 440 13 of of IN 35772 440 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 440 15 which which WDT 35772 440 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 440 17 showed show VBD 35772 440 18 to to TO 35772 440 19 perish perish VB 35772 440 20 with with IN 35772 440 21 the the DT 35772 440 22 body body NN 35772 440 23 may may MD 35772 440 24 be be VB 35772 440 25 of of IN 35772 440 26 no no DT 35772 440 27 moment moment NN 35772 440 28 to to IN 35772 440 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 440 30 in in IN 35772 440 31 respect respect NN 35772 440 32 to to IN 35772 440 33 what what WP 35772 440 34 remains remain VBZ 35772 440 35 . . . 35772 440 36 " " '' 35772 441 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 441 2 who who WP 35772 441 3 is be VBZ 35772 441 4 " " `` 35772 441 5 affected affect VBN 35772 441 6 with with IN 35772 441 7 love love NN 35772 441 8 towards towards IN 35772 441 9 God God NNP 35772 441 10 " " `` 35772 441 11 has have VBZ 35772 441 12 a a DT 35772 441 13 mind mind NN 35772 441 14 " " '' 35772 441 15 of of IN 35772 441 16 which which WDT 35772 441 17 the the DT 35772 441 18 greater great JJR 35772 441 19 part part NN 35772 441 20 is be VBZ 35772 441 21 eternal eternal JJ 35772 441 22 . . . 35772 441 23 " " '' 35772 442 1 Thus thus RB 35772 442 2 the the DT 35772 442 3 soul soul NN 35772 442 4 achieves achieve VBZ 35772 442 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 442 6 emancipation emancipation NN 35772 442 7 by by IN 35772 442 8 identifying identify VBG 35772 442 9 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 442 10 with with IN 35772 442 11 God God NNP 35772 442 12 -- -- : 35772 442 13 who who WP 35772 442 14 is be VBZ 35772 442 15 the the DT 35772 442 16 object object NN 35772 442 17 of of IN 35772 442 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 442 19 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 442 20 and and CC 35772 442 21 love love NN 35772 442 22 . . . 35772 443 1 The the DT 35772 443 2 path path NN 35772 443 3 is be VBZ 35772 443 4 arduous arduous JJ 35772 443 5 , , , 35772 443 6 and and CC 35772 443 7 the the DT 35772 443 8 closing closing NN 35772 443 9 passage passage NN 35772 443 10 of of IN 35772 443 11 the the DT 35772 443 12 _ _ NNP 35772 443 13 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 443 14 _ _ NNP 35772 443 15 admits admit VBZ 35772 443 16 this this DT 35772 443 17 : : : 35772 443 18 " " `` 35772 443 19 If if IN 35772 443 20 the the DT 35772 443 21 road road NN 35772 443 22 I -PRON- PRP 35772 443 23 have have VBP 35772 443 24 shown show VBN 35772 443 25 is be VBZ 35772 443 26 very very RB 35772 443 27 difficult difficult JJ 35772 443 28 , , , 35772 443 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 443 30 can can MD 35772 443 31 yet yet RB 35772 443 32 be be VB 35772 443 33 discovered discover VBN 35772 443 34 . . . 35772 444 1 And and CC 35772 444 2 clearly clearly RB 35772 444 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 444 4 must must MD 35772 444 5 be be VB 35772 444 6 very very RB 35772 444 7 hard hard JJ 35772 444 8 when when WRB 35772 444 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 444 10 is be VBZ 35772 444 11 so so RB 35772 444 12 seldom seldom RB 35772 444 13 found find VBN 35772 444 14 .... .... . 35772 445 1 But but CC 35772 445 2 all all DT 35772 445 3 excellent excellent JJ 35772 445 4 things thing NNS 35772 445 5 are be VBP 35772 445 6 as as RB 35772 445 7 difficult difficult JJ 35772 445 8 as as IN 35772 445 9 they -PRON- PRP 35772 445 10 are be VBP 35772 445 11 rare rare JJ 35772 445 12 . . . 35772 445 13 " " '' 35772 446 1 SPINOZA SPINOZA NNP 35772 446 2 AND and CC 35772 446 3 RELIGION.--It RELIGION.--It NNP 35772 446 4 is be VBZ 35772 446 5 interesting interesting JJ 35772 446 6 to to TO 35772 446 7 note note VB 35772 446 8 that that IN 35772 446 9 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 446 10 , , , 35772 446 11 though though IN 35772 446 12 a a DT 35772 446 13 " " `` 35772 446 14 free free JJ 35772 446 15 - - HYPH 35772 446 16 thinking think VBG 35772 446 17 " " '' 35772 446 18 Jew Jew NNP 35772 446 19 , , , 35772 446 20 adopts adopt VBZ 35772 446 21 towards towards IN 35772 446 22 the the DT 35772 446 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 446 24 dogma dogma NN 35772 446 25 of of IN 35772 446 26 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 446 27 an an DT 35772 446 28 attitude attitude NN 35772 446 29 which which WDT 35772 446 30 approximates approximate VBZ 35772 446 31 to to IN 35772 446 32 the the DT 35772 446 33 classical classical JJ 35772 446 34 expression expression NN 35772 446 35 of of IN 35772 446 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 446 37 in in IN 35772 446 38 the the DT 35772 446 39 Fourth Fourth NNP 35772 446 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 35772 446 41 . . . 35772 447 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 447 2 held hold VBD 35772 447 3 that that IN 35772 447 4 " " `` 35772 447 5 God God NNP 35772 447 6 's 's POS 35772 447 7 eternal eternal JJ 35772 447 8 wisdom wisdom NN 35772 447 9 , , , 35772 447 10 which which WDT 35772 447 11 reveals reveal VBZ 35772 447 12 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 447 13 in in IN 35772 447 14 all all DT 35772 447 15 things thing NNS 35772 447 16 , , , 35772 447 17 and and CC 35772 447 18 especially especially RB 35772 447 19 in in IN 35772 447 20 the the DT 35772 447 21 human human JJ 35772 447 22 mind mind NN 35772 447 23 , , , 35772 447 24 has have VBZ 35772 447 25 given give VBN 35772 447 26 a a DT 35772 447 27 special special JJ 35772 447 28 revelation revelation NN 35772 447 29 of of IN 35772 447 30 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 447 31 in in IN 35772 447 32 Christ Christ NNP 35772 447 33 . . . 35772 447 34 " " '' 35772 448 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 35772 448 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 448 3 ethic ethic NN 35772 448 4 , , , 35772 448 5 like like IN 35772 448 6 that that DT 35772 448 7 of of IN 35772 448 8 the the DT 35772 448 9 Stoics Stoics NNPS 35772 448 10 , , , 35772 448 11 with with IN 35772 448 12 whom whom WP 35772 448 13 he -PRON- PRP 35772 448 14 had have VBD 35772 448 15 so so RB 35772 448 16 much much JJ 35772 448 17 in in IN 35772 448 18 common common JJ 35772 448 19 , , , 35772 448 20 was be VBD 35772 448 21 better well RBR 35772 448 22 adapted adapt VBN 35772 448 23 to to TO 35772 448 24 satisfy satisfy VB 35772 448 25 the the DT 35772 448 26 needs need NNS 35772 448 27 of of IN 35772 448 28 the the DT 35772 448 29 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 448 30 than than IN 35772 448 31 of of IN 35772 448 32 the the DT 35772 448 33 ordinary ordinary JJ 35772 448 34 man man NN 35772 448 35 . . . 35772 449 1 But but CC 35772 449 2 , , , 35772 449 3 in in IN 35772 449 4 the the DT 35772 449 5 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 449 6 century century NN 35772 449 7 , , , 35772 449 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 449 9 was be VBD 35772 449 10 the the DT 35772 449 11 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 449 12 and and CC 35772 449 13 learned learn VBD 35772 449 14 men man NNS 35772 449 15 that that WDT 35772 449 16 were be VBD 35772 449 17 in in IN 35772 449 18 need need NN 35772 449 19 of of IN 35772 449 20 a a DT 35772 449 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 449 22 interpretation interpretation NN 35772 449 23 of of IN 35772 449 24 the the DT 35772 449 25 universe universe NN 35772 449 26 ; ; , 35772 449 27 common common JJ 35772 449 28 men man NNS 35772 449 29 had have VBD 35772 449 30 theirs -PRON- PRP 35772 449 31 already already RB 35772 449 32 , , , 35772 449 33 in in IN 35772 449 34 the the DT 35772 449 35 traditional traditional JJ 35772 449 36 pietism pietism NN 35772 449 37 which which WDT 35772 449 38 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 449 39 are be VBP 35772 449 40 often often RB 35772 449 41 too too RB 35772 449 42 ready ready JJ 35772 449 43 to to TO 35772 449 44 despise despise VB 35772 449 45 . . . 35772 450 1 To to IN 35772 450 2 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 450 3 -- -- : 35772 450 4 and and CC 35772 450 5 this this DT 35772 450 6 is be VBZ 35772 450 7 one one CD 35772 450 8 of of IN 35772 450 9 the the DT 35772 450 10 many many JJ 35772 450 11 indications indication NNS 35772 450 12 of of IN 35772 450 13 the the DT 35772 450 14 genuine genuine JJ 35772 450 15 profundity profundity NN 35772 450 16 of of IN 35772 450 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 450 18 thought thought NN 35772 450 19 -- -- : 35772 450 20 the the DT 35772 450 21 simple simple JJ 35772 450 22 believers believer NNS 35772 450 23 seemed seem VBD 35772 450 24 already already RB 35772 450 25 to to TO 35772 450 26 be be VB 35772 450 27 in in IN 35772 450 28 possession possession NN 35772 450 29 of of IN 35772 450 30 too too RB 35772 450 31 much much JJ 35772 450 32 of of IN 35772 450 33 the the DT 35772 450 34 truth truth NN 35772 450 35 for for IN 35772 450 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 450 37 to to TO 35772 450 38 be be VB 35772 450 39 desirable desirable JJ 35772 450 40 or or CC 35772 450 41 profitable profitable JJ 35772 450 42 for for IN 35772 450 43 them -PRON- PRP 35772 450 44 to to TO 35772 450 45 indulge indulge VB 35772 450 46 in in IN 35772 450 47 speculation speculation NN 35772 450 48 . . . 35772 451 1 To to IN 35772 451 2 the the DT 35772 451 3 question question NN 35772 451 4 of of IN 35772 451 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 451 6 landlady landlady NN 35772 451 7 at at IN 35772 451 8 the the DT 35772 451 9 Hague Hague NNP 35772 451 10 as as IN 35772 451 11 to to IN 35772 451 12 whether whether IN 35772 451 13 she -PRON- PRP 35772 451 14 could could MD 35772 451 15 be be VB 35772 451 16 saved save VBN 35772 451 17 by by IN 35772 451 18 the the DT 35772 451 19 religion religion NN 35772 451 20 which which WDT 35772 451 21 she -PRON- PRP 35772 451 22 professed profess VBD 35772 451 23 , , , 35772 451 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 451 25 reply reply NN 35772 451 26 was be VBD 35772 451 27 that that IN 35772 451 28 her -PRON- PRP$ 35772 451 29 religion religion NN 35772 451 30 was be VBD 35772 451 31 good good JJ 35772 451 32 , , , 35772 451 33 that that IN 35772 451 34 she -PRON- PRP 35772 451 35 should should MD 35772 451 36 seek seek VB 35772 451 37 no no DT 35772 451 38 other other JJ 35772 451 39 , , , 35772 451 40 and and CC 35772 451 41 that that IN 35772 451 42 she -PRON- PRP 35772 451 43 would would MD 35772 451 44 certainly certainly RB 35772 451 45 be be VB 35772 451 46 saved save VBN 35772 451 47 by by IN 35772 451 48 it -PRON- PRP 35772 451 49 if if IN 35772 451 50 she -PRON- PRP 35772 451 51 led lead VBD 35772 451 52 a a DT 35772 451 53 quiet quiet JJ 35772 451 54 and and CC 35772 451 55 pious pious JJ 35772 451 56 life life NN 35772 451 57 . . . 35772 452 1 SPINOZA SPINOZA NNP 35772 452 2 'S 's POS 35772 452 3 PERSONALITY.--The personality.--the JJ 35772 452 4 figure figure NN 35772 452 5 of of IN 35772 452 6 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 452 7 stands stand VBZ 35772 452 8 as as IN 35772 452 9 one one CD 35772 452 10 of of IN 35772 452 11 the the DT 35772 452 12 most most RBS 35772 452 13 imposing imposing JJ 35772 452 14 and and CC 35772 452 15 attractive attractive JJ 35772 452 16 in in IN 35772 452 17 the the DT 35772 452 18 whole whole JJ 35772 452 19 history history NN 35772 452 20 of of IN 35772 452 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 452 22 , , , 35772 452 23 and and CC 35772 452 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 452 25 was be VBD 35772 452 26 an an DT 35772 452 27 unworldliness unworldliness NN 35772 452 28 , , , 35772 452 29 a a DT 35772 452 30 simplicity simplicity NN 35772 452 31 , , , 35772 452 32 and and CC 35772 452 33 a a DT 35772 452 34 humility humility NN 35772 452 35 purely purely RB 35772 452 36 Franciscan Franciscan NNP 35772 452 37 . . . 35772 453 1 Like like IN 35772 453 2 all all DT 35772 453 3 Jews Jews NNPS 35772 453 4 then then RB 35772 453 5 , , , 35772 453 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 453 7 knew know VBD 35772 453 8 a a DT 35772 453 9 trade trade NN 35772 453 10 -- -- : 35772 453 11 that that DT 35772 453 12 of of IN 35772 453 13 lens lens NN 35772 453 14 grinding grind VBG 35772 453 15 -- -- : 35772 453 16 and and CC 35772 453 17 by by IN 35772 453 18 this this DT 35772 453 19 he -PRON- PRP 35772 453 20 was be VBD 35772 453 21 able able JJ 35772 453 22 to to TO 35772 453 23 live live VB 35772 453 24 frugally frugally RB 35772 453 25 , , , 35772 453 26 while while IN 35772 453 27 he -PRON- PRP 35772 453 28 elaborated elaborate VBD 35772 453 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 453 30 thought thought NN 35772 453 31 . . . 35772 454 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 454 2 dedicated dedicate VBD 35772 454 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 454 4 life life NN 35772 454 5 to to IN 35772 454 6 the the DT 35772 454 7 labour labour NN 35772 454 8 of of IN 35772 454 9 quiet quiet JJ 35772 454 10 contemplation contemplation NN 35772 454 11 ; ; , 35772 454 12 nor nor CC 35772 454 13 was be VBD 35772 454 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 454 15 ambitious ambitious JJ 35772 454 16 of of IN 35772 454 17 recognition recognition NN 35772 454 18 , , , 35772 454 19 which which WDT 35772 454 20 indeed indeed RB 35772 454 21 generally generally RB 35772 454 22 came come VBD 35772 454 23 to to IN 35772 454 24 him -PRON- PRP 35772 454 25 in in IN 35772 454 26 the the DT 35772 454 27 form form NN 35772 454 28 of of IN 35772 454 29 abuse abuse NN 35772 454 30 . . . 35772 455 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 455 2 did do VBD 35772 455 3 not not RB 35772 455 4 escape escape VB 35772 455 5 " " `` 35772 455 6 the the DT 35772 455 7 exquisite exquisite JJ 35772 455 8 rancour rancour NN 35772 455 9 of of IN 35772 455 10 theological theological JJ 35772 455 11 hatred hatred NN 35772 455 12 , , , 35772 455 13 " " `` 35772 455 14 but but CC 35772 455 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 455 16 was be VBD 35772 455 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 455 18 belief belief NN 35772 455 19 , , , 35772 455 20 and and CC 35772 455 21 the the DT 35772 455 22 conviction conviction NN 35772 455 23 inspired inspire VBD 35772 455 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 455 25 life life NN 35772 455 26 , , , 35772 455 27 that-- that-- NNP 35772 455 28 " " `` 35772 455 29 Neither neither DT 35772 455 30 riches rich NNS 35772 455 31 , , , 35772 455 32 nor nor CC 35772 455 33 sensuous sensuous JJ 35772 455 34 enjoyment enjoyment NN 35772 455 35 , , , 35772 455 36 nor nor CC 35772 455 37 honours honour NNS 35772 455 38 , , , 35772 455 39 can can MD 35772 455 40 be be VB 35772 455 41 a a DT 35772 455 42 true true JJ 35772 455 43 good good NN 35772 455 44 for for IN 35772 455 45 man man NN 35772 455 46 " " '' 35772 455 47 ; ; : 35772 455 48 but but CC 35772 455 49 on on IN 35772 455 50 the the DT 35772 455 51 contrary contrary NN 35772 455 52 , , , 35772 455 53 " " '' 35772 455 54 that that IN 35772 455 55 the the DT 35772 455 56 only only JJ 35772 455 57 thing thing NN 35772 455 58 which which WDT 35772 455 59 is be VBZ 35772 455 60 able able JJ 35772 455 61 to to TO 35772 455 62 fill fill VB 35772 455 63 the the DT 35772 455 64 mind mind NN 35772 455 65 with with IN 35772 455 66 ever ever RB 35772 455 67 - - HYPH 35772 455 68 new new JJ 35772 455 69 satisfaction satisfaction NN 35772 455 70 is be VBZ 35772 455 71 the the DT 35772 455 72 striving striving NN 35772 455 73 after after IN 35772 455 74 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 455 75 , , , 35772 455 76 by by IN 35772 455 77 means mean NNS 35772 455 78 of of IN 35772 455 79 which which WDT 35772 455 80 the the DT 35772 455 81 mind mind NN 35772 455 82 is be VBZ 35772 455 83 united united JJ 35772 455 84 with with IN 35772 455 85 that that DT 35772 455 86 which which WDT 35772 455 87 remains remain VBZ 35772 455 88 constant constant JJ 35772 455 89 while while IN 35772 455 90 all all DT 35772 455 91 else else RB 35772 455 92 changes change NNS 35772 455 93 . . . 35772 455 94 " " '' 35772 456 1 " " `` 35772 456 2 The the DT 35772 456 3 God God NNP 35772 456 4 - - HYPH 35772 456 5 intoxicated intoxicate VBN 35772 456 6 , , , 35772 456 7 " " '' 35772 456 8 was be VBD 35772 456 9 the the DT 35772 456 10 name name NN 35772 456 11 given give VBN 35772 456 12 to to IN 35772 456 13 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 456 14 long long RB 35772 456 15 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 456 16 in in IN 35772 456 17 Germany Germany NNP 35772 456 18 . . . 35772 457 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 457 2 died die VBD 35772 457 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 457 4 like like IN 35772 457 5 St. St. NNP 35772 457 6 Francis Francis NNP 35772 457 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 457 8 at at IN 35772 457 9 forty forty CD 35772 457 10 - - HYPH 35772 457 11 five five CD 35772 457 12 , , , 35772 457 13 worn wear VBN 35772 457 14 out out RP 35772 457 15 with with IN 35772 457 16 the the DT 35772 457 17 toil toil NN 35772 457 18 of of IN 35772 457 19 thought thought NN 35772 457 20 . . . 35772 458 1 And and CC 35772 458 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 458 3 renews renew VBZ 35772 458 4 one one NN 35772 458 5 's 's POS 35772 458 6 faith faith NN 35772 458 7 in in IN 35772 458 8 the the DT 35772 458 9 perspicacity perspicacity NN 35772 458 10 of of IN 35772 458 11 commonplace commonplace JJ 35772 458 12 people people NNS 35772 458 13 to to TO 35772 458 14 learn learn VB 35772 458 15 that that IN 35772 458 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 458 17 barber barber NN 35772 458 18 , , , 35772 458 19 sending send VBG 35772 458 20 in in IN 35772 458 21 a a DT 35772 458 22 bill bill NN 35772 458 23 after after IN 35772 458 24 the the DT 35772 458 25 death death NN 35772 458 26 of of IN 35772 458 27 the the DT 35772 458 28 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 458 29 , , , 35772 458 30 alluded allude VBD 35772 458 31 to to IN 35772 458 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 458 33 late late JJ 35772 458 34 customer customer NN 35772 458 35 as as IN 35772 458 36 " " `` 35772 458 37 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 458 38 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 458 39 of of IN 35772 458 40 blessed bless VBN 35772 458 41 memory memory NN 35772 458 42 . . . 35772 458 43 " " '' 35772 459 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 459 2 was be VBD 35772 459 3 left leave VBN 35772 459 4 to to IN 35772 459 5 a a DT 35772 459 6 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 459 7 theologian theologian NN 35772 459 8 to to TO 35772 459 9 describe describe VB 35772 459 10 him -PRON- PRP 35772 459 11 as as IN 35772 459 12 " " `` 35772 459 13 an an DT 35772 459 14 unclean unclean JJ 35772 459 15 and and CC 35772 459 16 foul foul JJ 35772 459 17 atheist atheist NN 35772 459 18 . . . 35772 459 19 " " '' 35772 460 1 LEIBNIZ.--Spinoza LEIBNIZ.--Spinoza NNP 35772 460 2 had have VBD 35772 460 3 taken take VBN 35772 460 4 over over RP 35772 460 5 from from IN 35772 460 6 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 460 7 and and CC 35772 460 8 Hobbes hobbe VBZ 35772 460 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 460 10 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 460 11 and and CC 35772 460 12 determinist determinist JJ 35772 460 13 conception conception NN 35772 460 14 of of IN 35772 460 15 nature nature NN 35772 460 16 , , , 35772 460 17 though though IN 35772 460 18 he -PRON- PRP 35772 460 19 gave give VBD 35772 460 20 to to IN 35772 460 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 460 22 , , , 35772 460 23 as as IN 35772 460 24 we -PRON- PRP 35772 460 25 have have VBP 35772 460 26 seen see VBN 35772 460 27 , , , 35772 460 28 an an DT 35772 460 29 interpretation interpretation NN 35772 460 30 of of IN 35772 460 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 460 32 own own JJ 35772 460 33 . . . 35772 461 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 461 2 attitude attitude NN 35772 461 3 was be VBD 35772 461 4 a a DT 35772 461 5 blend blend NN 35772 461 6 of of IN 35772 461 7 that that DT 35772 461 8 rationalism rationalism NN 35772 461 9 and and CC 35772 461 10 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 461 11 which which WDT 35772 461 12 were be VBD 35772 461 13 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 461 14 of of IN 35772 461 15 so so RB 35772 461 16 much much JJ 35772 461 17 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 461 18 century century NN 35772 461 19 thought thought NN 35772 461 20 . . . 35772 462 1 A a DT 35772 462 2 far far RB 35772 462 3 more more RBR 35772 462 4 complete complete JJ 35772 462 5 reaction reaction NN 35772 462 6 , , , 35772 462 7 however however RB 35772 462 8 , , , 35772 462 9 displays display VBZ 35772 462 10 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 462 11 in in IN 35772 462 12 the the DT 35772 462 13 system system NN 35772 462 14 of of IN 35772 462 15 a a DT 35772 462 16 contemporary contemporary NN 35772 462 17 of of IN 35772 462 18 Spinoza's Spinoza's NNP 35772 462 19 -- -- : 35772 462 20 Gottfried Gottfried NNP 35772 462 21 Wilhelm Wilhelm NNP 35772 462 22 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 462 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 462 24 1646 1646 CD 35772 462 25 - - SYM 35772 462 26 1716 1716 CD 35772 462 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 462 28 ; ; : 35772 462 29 who who WP 35772 462 30 , , , 35772 462 31 when when WRB 35772 462 32 already already RB 35772 462 33 a a DT 35772 462 34 youth youth NN 35772 462 35 , , , 35772 462 36 had have VBD 35772 462 37 become become VBN 35772 462 38 an an DT 35772 462 39 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 35772 462 40 devotee devotee NN 35772 462 41 of of IN 35772 462 42 the the DT 35772 462 43 new new JJ 35772 462 44 science science NN 35772 462 45 ; ; : 35772 462 46 the the DT 35772 462 47 study study NN 35772 462 48 of of IN 35772 462 49 Kepler Kepler NNP 35772 462 50 , , , 35772 462 51 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 462 52 and and CC 35772 462 53 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 462 54 caused cause VBD 35772 462 55 him -PRON- PRP 35772 462 56 to to TO 35772 462 57 feel feel VB 35772 462 58 as as IN 35772 462 59 though though RB 35772 462 60 " " `` 35772 462 61 transported transport VBN 35772 462 62 into into IN 35772 462 63 a a DT 35772 462 64 different different JJ 35772 462 65 world world NN 35772 462 66 . . . 35772 462 67 " " '' 35772 463 1 Though though IN 35772 463 2 a a DT 35772 463 3 German German NNP 35772 463 4 by by IN 35772 463 5 birth birth NN 35772 463 6 , , , 35772 463 7 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 463 8 lived live VBD 35772 463 9 continuously continuously RB 35772 463 10 in in IN 35772 463 11 France France NNP 35772 463 12 , , , 35772 463 13 and and CC 35772 463 14 wrote write VBD 35772 463 15 habitually habitually RB 35772 463 16 in in IN 35772 463 17 the the DT 35772 463 18 language language NN 35772 463 19 of of IN 35772 463 20 that that DT 35772 463 21 country country NN 35772 463 22 . . . 35772 464 1 CONTRAST contrast NN 35772 464 2 TO to IN 35772 464 3 SPINOZA.--Spinoza SPINOZA.--Spinoza NNP 35772 464 4 and and CC 35772 464 5 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 464 6 stand stand VBP 35772 464 7 as as IN 35772 464 8 examples example NNS 35772 464 9 of of IN 35772 464 10 two two CD 35772 464 11 distinct distinct JJ 35772 464 12 methods method NNS 35772 464 13 of of IN 35772 464 14 eluding elude VBG 35772 464 15 the the DT 35772 464 16 despotism despotism NN 35772 464 17 of of IN 35772 464 18 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 464 19 -- -- : 35772 464 20 methods method NNS 35772 464 21 which which WDT 35772 464 22 will will MD 35772 464 23 meet meet VB 35772 464 24 us -PRON- PRP 35772 464 25 again again RB 35772 464 26 in in IN 35772 464 27 the the DT 35772 464 28 course course NN 35772 464 29 of of IN 35772 464 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 464 31 survey survey NN 35772 464 32 . . . 35772 465 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 465 2 accepts accept VBZ 35772 465 3 the the DT 35772 465 4 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 465 5 view view NN 35772 465 6 as as IN 35772 465 7 being be VBG 35772 465 8 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 465 9 and and CC 35772 465 10 even even RB 35772 465 11 desirable desirable JJ 35772 465 12 , , , 35772 465 13 but but CC 35772 465 14 subjects subject VBZ 35772 465 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 465 16 to to IN 35772 465 17 a a DT 35772 465 18 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 465 19 interpretation interpretation NN 35772 465 20 -- -- : 35772 465 21 he -PRON- PRP 35772 465 22 regards regard VBZ 35772 465 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 465 24 as as IN 35772 465 25 the the DT 35772 465 26 way way NN 35772 465 27 in in IN 35772 465 28 which which WDT 35772 465 29 the the DT 35772 465 30 _ _ NNP 35772 465 31 Natura Natura NNP 35772 465 32 naturans naturan NNS 35772 465 33 _ _ NNP 35772 465 34 works work VBZ 35772 465 35 . . . 35772 466 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 466 2 9 9 CD 35772 466 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 466 4 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 466 5 , , , 35772 466 6 on on IN 35772 466 7 the the DT 35772 466 8 other other JJ 35772 466 9 hand hand NN 35772 466 10 , , , 35772 466 11 viewed view VBD 35772 466 12 existence existence NN 35772 466 13 from from IN 35772 466 14 an an DT 35772 466 15 entirely entirely RB 35772 466 16 different different JJ 35772 466 17 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 466 18 . . . 35772 467 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 467 2 was be VBD 35772 467 3 bold bold JJ 35772 467 4 enough enough RB 35772 467 5 to to TO 35772 467 6 reject reject VB 35772 467 7 the the DT 35772 467 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 467 9 view view NN 35772 467 10 altogether altogether RB 35772 467 11 ; ; : 35772 467 12 or or CC 35772 467 13 rather rather RB 35772 467 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 467 15 preferred prefer VBD 35772 467 16 to to TO 35772 467 17 regard regard VB 35772 467 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 467 19 as as IN 35772 467 20 a a DT 35772 467 21 convenient convenient JJ 35772 467 22 abstraction abstraction NN 35772 467 23 , , , 35772 467 24 or or CC 35772 467 25 a a DT 35772 467 26 useful useful JJ 35772 467 27 formula formula NN 35772 467 28 , , , 35772 467 29 which which WDT 35772 467 30 might may MD 35772 467 31 reflect reflect VB 35772 467 32 certain certain JJ 35772 467 33 aspects aspect NNS 35772 467 34 of of IN 35772 467 35 reality reality NN 35772 467 36 , , , 35772 467 37 but but CC 35772 467 38 could could MD 35772 467 39 not not RB 35772 467 40 do do VB 35772 467 41 justice justice NN 35772 467 42 to to IN 35772 467 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 467 44 concrete concrete JJ 35772 467 45 richness richness NN 35772 467 46 and and CC 35772 467 47 complexity complexity NN 35772 467 48 . . . 35772 468 1 A a DT 35772 468 2 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNP 35772 468 3 OF of IN 35772 468 4 INDIVIDUALS.--Leibniz INDIVIDUALS.--Leibniz NNP 35772 468 5 's 's POS 35772 468 6 criticism criticism NN 35772 468 7 of of IN 35772 468 8 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 468 9 and and CC 35772 468 10 the the DT 35772 468 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 468 12 school school NN 35772 468 13 proceeded proceed VBD 35772 468 14 along along IN 35772 468 15 different different JJ 35772 468 16 lines line NNS 35772 468 17 from from IN 35772 468 18 that that DT 35772 468 19 of of IN 35772 468 20 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 468 21 , , , 35772 468 22 who who WP 35772 468 23 , , , 35772 468 24 as as IN 35772 468 25 we -PRON- PRP 35772 468 26 have have VBP 35772 468 27 seen see VBN 35772 468 28 , , , 35772 468 29 accepted accept VBD 35772 468 30 the the DT 35772 468 31 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 468 32 view view NN 35772 468 33 as as IN 35772 468 34 the the DT 35772 468 35 basis basis NN 35772 468 36 of of IN 35772 468 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 468 38 speculation speculation NN 35772 468 39 . . . 35772 469 1 An an DT 35772 469 2 axiom axiom NN 35772 469 3 of of IN 35772 469 4 that that DT 35772 469 5 view view NN 35772 469 6 was be VBD 35772 469 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 469 8 as as IN 35772 469 9 we -PRON- PRP 35772 469 10 know know VBP 35772 469 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 469 12 the the DT 35772 469 13 conservation conservation NN 35772 469 14 of of IN 35772 469 15 motion motion NN 35772 469 16 . . . 35772 470 1 For for IN 35772 470 2 this this DT 35772 470 3 conservation conservation NN 35772 470 4 of of IN 35772 470 5 _ _ NNP 35772 470 6 motion motion NN 35772 470 7 _ _ NNP 35772 470 8 , , , 35772 470 9 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 470 10 substitutes substitute VBZ 35772 470 11 the the DT 35772 470 12 conservation conservation NN 35772 470 13 of of IN 35772 470 14 _ _ NNP 35772 470 15 force force NN 35772 470 16 _ _ NNP 35772 470 17 as as IN 35772 470 18 being be VBG 35772 470 19 logically logically RB 35772 470 20 the the DT 35772 470 21 more more RBR 35772 470 22 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 470 23 concept concept NN 35772 470 24 . . . 35772 471 1 True true JJ 35772 471 2 reality reality NN 35772 471 3 , , , 35772 471 4 according accord VBG 35772 471 5 to to IN 35772 471 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 471 7 , , , 35772 471 8 is be VBZ 35772 471 9 not not RB 35772 471 10 _ _ NNP 35772 471 11 motion motion NN 35772 471 12 _ _ NNP 35772 471 13 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 471 14 , , , 35772 471 15 but but CC 35772 471 16 the the DT 35772 471 17 _ _ NNP 35772 471 18 force force NN 35772 471 19 which which WDT 35772 471 20 is be VBZ 35772 471 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 471 22 cause cause NN 35772 471 23 _ _ NNP 35772 471 24 . . . 35772 472 1 Force force NN 35772 472 2 and and CC 35772 472 3 existence existence NN 35772 472 4 became become VBD 35772 472 5 for for IN 35772 472 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 472 7 identical identical JJ 35772 472 8 terms term NNS 35772 472 9 ; ; , 35772 472 10 to to TO 35772 472 11 work work VB 35772 472 12 and and CC 35772 472 13 to to TO 35772 472 14 exist exist VB 35772 472 15 were be VBD 35772 472 16 the the DT 35772 472 17 same same JJ 35772 472 18 . . . 35772 473 1 That that DT 35772 473 2 force force NN 35772 473 3 is be VBZ 35772 473 4 the the DT 35772 473 5 true true JJ 35772 473 6 reality reality NN 35772 473 7 , , , 35772 473 8 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 473 9 expressed express VBD 35772 473 10 in in IN 35772 473 11 the the DT 35772 473 12 language language NN 35772 473 13 of of IN 35772 473 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 473 15 time time NN 35772 473 16 by by IN 35772 473 17 saying say VBG 35772 473 18 , , , 35772 473 19 " " `` 35772 473 20 Force force NN 35772 473 21 is be VBZ 35772 473 22 substance substance NN 35772 473 23 , , , 35772 473 24 and and CC 35772 473 25 all all DT 35772 473 26 substance substance NN 35772 473 27 is be VBZ 35772 473 28 force"--a force"--a JJ 35772 473 29 proposition proposition NN 35772 473 30 which which WDT 35772 473 31 would would MD 35772 473 32 not not RB 35772 473 33 be be VB 35772 473 34 repudiated repudiate VBN 35772 473 35 by by IN 35772 473 36 modern modern JJ 35772 473 37 science science NN 35772 473 38 -- -- : 35772 473 39 and and CC 35772 473 40 upon upon IN 35772 473 41 this this DT 35772 473 42 statement statement NN 35772 473 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 473 44 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 473 45 is be VBZ 35772 473 46 built build VBN 35772 473 47 . . . 35772 474 1 But but CC 35772 474 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 474 3 was be VBD 35772 474 4 not not RB 35772 474 5 " " `` 35772 474 6 force force NN 35772 474 7 in in IN 35772 474 8 general general JJ 35772 474 9 " " '' 35772 474 10 or or CC 35772 474 11 some some DT 35772 474 12 " " `` 35772 474 13 universal universal JJ 35772 474 14 force force NN 35772 474 15 " " '' 35772 474 16 that that WDT 35772 474 17 was be VBD 35772 474 18 regarded regard VBN 35772 474 19 by by IN 35772 474 20 him -PRON- PRP 35772 474 21 as as IN 35772 474 22 the the DT 35772 474 23 final final JJ 35772 474 24 reality reality NN 35772 474 25 : : : 35772 474 26 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 474 27 was be VBD 35772 474 28 not not RB 35772 474 29 a a DT 35772 474 30 forerunner forerunner NN 35772 474 31 of of IN 35772 474 32 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 474 33 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 474 34 . . . 35772 475 1 Reality reality NN 35772 475 2 for for IN 35772 475 3 him -PRON- PRP 35772 475 4 consisted consist VBD 35772 475 5 in in IN 35772 475 6 _ _ NNP 35772 475 7 individual individual JJ 35772 475 8 centres centre NNS 35772 475 9 of of IN 35772 475 10 force_--a force_--a CD 35772 475 11 multitude multitude NN 35772 475 12 of of IN 35772 475 13 individual individual JJ 35772 475 14 and and CC 35772 475 15 independent independent JJ 35772 475 16 beings being NNS 35772 475 17 , , , 35772 475 18 each each DT 35772 475 19 with with IN 35772 475 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 475 21 own own JJ 35772 475 22 idiosyncrasy idiosyncrasy NN 35772 475 23 , , , 35772 475 24 and and CC 35772 475 25 following follow VBG 35772 475 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 475 27 own own JJ 35772 475 28 lines line NNS 35772 475 29 . . . 35772 476 1 Existence existence NN 35772 476 2 was be VBD 35772 476 3 , , , 35772 476 4 in in IN 35772 476 5 fact fact NN 35772 476 6 , , , 35772 476 7 for for IN 35772 476 8 him -PRON- PRP 35772 476 9 , , , 35772 476 10 _ _ NNP 35772 476 11 individual individual JJ 35772 476 12 _ _ NNP 35772 476 13 . . . 35772 477 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 477 2 was be VBD 35772 477 3 the the DT 35772 477 4 _ _ NNP 35772 477 5 individual individual NN 35772 477 6 _ _ NNP 35772 477 7 centres centre VBZ 35772 477 8 of of IN 35772 477 9 force force NN 35772 477 10 -- -- : 35772 477 11 not not RB 35772 477 12 _ _ NNP 35772 477 13 general general JJ 35772 477 14 _ _ NNP 35772 477 15 principles principle NNS 35772 477 16 , , , 35772 477 17 universal universal JJ 35772 477 18 substances substance NNS 35772 477 19 , , , 35772 477 20 laws law NNS 35772 477 21 or or CC 35772 477 22 forces force NNS 35772 477 23 -- -- : 35772 477 24 that that WDT 35772 477 25 make make VBP 35772 477 26 up up RP 35772 477 27 reality reality NN 35772 477 28 . . . 35772 478 1 DOCTRINE DOCTRINE NNP 35772 478 2 OF of IN 35772 478 3 MONADS.--This monads.--this DT 35772 478 4 view view NN 35772 478 5 of of IN 35772 478 6 reality reality NN 35772 478 7 was be VBD 35772 478 8 formulated formulate VBN 35772 478 9 by by IN 35772 478 10 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 478 11 in in IN 35772 478 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 478 13 famous famous JJ 35772 478 14 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 478 15 of of IN 35772 478 16 " " `` 35772 478 17 monads monad NNS 35772 478 18 . . . 35772 478 19 " " '' 35772 479 1 " " `` 35772 479 2 Monad Monad NNP 35772 479 3 " " '' 35772 479 4 was be VBD 35772 479 5 the the DT 35772 479 6 technical technical JJ 35772 479 7 name name NN 35772 479 8 applied apply VBN 35772 479 9 by by IN 35772 479 10 him -PRON- PRP 35772 479 11 to to IN 35772 479 12 those those DT 35772 479 13 absolute absolute JJ 35772 479 14 individuals individual NNS 35772 479 15 which which WDT 35772 479 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 479 17 regarded regard VBD 35772 479 18 as as IN 35772 479 19 constituting constitute VBG 35772 479 20 true true JJ 35772 479 21 reality reality NN 35772 479 22 . . . 35772 480 1 The the DT 35772 480 2 word word NN 35772 480 3 , , , 35772 480 4 meaning mean VBG 35772 480 5 " " `` 35772 480 6 unity unity NN 35772 480 7 , , , 35772 480 8 " " '' 35772 480 9 was be VBD 35772 480 10 simple simple JJ 35772 480 11 and and CC 35772 480 12 appropriate appropriate JJ 35772 480 13 . . . 35772 481 1 And and CC 35772 481 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 481 3 declared declare VBD 35772 481 4 that that IN 35772 481 5 the the DT 35772 481 6 " " `` 35772 481 7 monad monad NN 35772 481 8 , , , 35772 481 9 " " '' 35772 481 10 to to TO 35772 481 11 be be VB 35772 481 12 rightly rightly RB 35772 481 13 understood understand VBN 35772 481 14 , , , 35772 481 15 must must MD 35772 481 16 be be VB 35772 481 17 regarded regard VBN 35772 481 18 as as RB 35772 481 19 analogous analogous JJ 35772 481 20 to to IN 35772 481 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 481 22 own own JJ 35772 481 23 souls soul NNS 35772 481 24 . . . 35772 482 1 This this DT 35772 482 2 principle principle NN 35772 482 3 of of IN 35772 482 4 analogy analogy NN 35772 482 5 was be VBD 35772 482 6 described describe VBN 35772 482 7 by by IN 35772 482 8 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 482 9 as as IN 35772 482 10 _ _ NNP 35772 482 11 mon mon NNP 35772 482 12 grand grand JJ 35772 482 13 principe principe NN 35772 482 14 des des FW 35772 482 15 choses chose NNS 35772 482 16 naturelles naturelle NNS 35772 482 17 _ _ NNP 35772 482 18 . . . 35772 483 1 Thus thus RB 35772 483 2 reality reality NN 35772 483 3 was be VBD 35772 483 4 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 483 5 by by IN 35772 483 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 483 7 not not RB 35772 483 8 in in IN 35772 483 9 physical physical JJ 35772 483 10 but but CC 35772 483 11 in in IN 35772 483 12 psychical psychical JJ 35772 483 13 terms term NNS 35772 483 14 , , , 35772 483 15 or or CC 35772 483 16 if if IN 35772 483 17 the the DT 35772 483 18 expression expression NN 35772 483 19 be be VB 35772 483 20 preferred prefer VBN 35772 483 21 , , , 35772 483 22 in in IN 35772 483 23 terms term NNS 35772 483 24 of of IN 35772 483 25 personality personality NN 35772 483 26 . . . 35772 484 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 484 2 10 10 CD 35772 484 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 484 4 Of of IN 35772 484 5 these these DT 35772 484 6 " " `` 35772 484 7 monads monad NNS 35772 484 8 " " '' 35772 484 9 there there RB 35772 484 10 exist exist VBP 35772 484 11 , , , 35772 484 12 according accord VBG 35772 484 13 to to IN 35772 484 14 this this DT 35772 484 15 view view NN 35772 484 16 , , , 35772 484 17 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 484 18 many many JJ 35772 484 19 degrees degree NNS 35772 484 20 . . . 35772 485 1 In in IN 35772 485 2 fact fact NN 35772 485 3 all all DT 35772 485 4 existence existence NN 35772 485 5 differs differ VBZ 35772 485 6 only only RB 35772 485 7 in in IN 35772 485 8 degree degree NN 35772 485 9 from from IN 35772 485 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 485 11 own own JJ 35772 485 12 . . . 35772 486 1 Even even RB 35772 486 2 between between IN 35772 486 3 mind mind NN 35772 486 4 and and CC 35772 486 5 matter matter NN 35772 486 6 there there EX 35772 486 7 is be VBZ 35772 486 8 only only RB 35772 486 9 a a DT 35772 486 10 quantitative quantitative NN 35772 486 11 and and CC 35772 486 12 not not RB 35772 486 13 a a DT 35772 486 14 qualitative qualitative JJ 35772 486 15 gulf gulf NN 35772 486 16 . . . 35772 487 1 For for IN 35772 487 2 there there EX 35772 487 3 are be VBP 35772 487 4 sleeping sleep VBG 35772 487 5 , , , 35772 487 6 dreaming dream VBG 35772 487 7 , , , 35772 487 8 and and CC 35772 487 9 more more RBR 35772 487 10 or or CC 35772 487 11 less less RBR 35772 487 12 waking wake VBG 35772 487 13 monads monad NNS 35772 487 14 ; ; : 35772 487 15 and and CC 35772 487 16 matter matter NN 35772 487 17 is be VBZ 35772 487 18 a a DT 35772 487 19 form form NN 35772 487 20 of of IN 35772 487 21 unconscious unconscious JJ 35772 487 22 mind mind NN 35772 487 23 ; ; : 35772 487 24 the the DT 35772 487 25 monads monad NNS 35772 487 26 which which WDT 35772 487 27 compose compose VBP 35772 487 28 material material NN 35772 487 29 objects object NNS 35772 487 30 being be VBG 35772 487 31 " " `` 35772 487 32 minds mind NNS 35772 487 33 without without IN 35772 487 34 memory memory NN 35772 487 35 , , , 35772 487 36 " " '' 35772 487 37 " " `` 35772 487 38 momentary momentary JJ 35772 487 39 minds mind NNS 35772 487 40 . . . 35772 487 41 " " '' 35772 488 1 Let let VB 35772 488 2 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 488 3 speak speak VB 35772 488 4 for for IN 35772 488 5 himself:-- himself:-- JJ 35772 488 6 " " `` 35772 488 7 Each each DT 35772 488 8 portion portion NN 35772 488 9 of of IN 35772 488 10 matter matter NN 35772 488 11 is be VBZ 35772 488 12 not not RB 35772 488 13 only only RB 35772 488 14 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 488 15 divisible divisible JJ 35772 488 16 , , , 35772 488 17 but but CC 35772 488 18 is be VBZ 35772 488 19 also also RB 35772 488 20 actually actually RB 35772 488 21 subdivided subdivide VBN 35772 488 22 without without IN 35772 488 23 end end NN 35772 488 24 .... .... . 35772 488 25 Whence whence UH 35772 488 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 488 27 appears appear VBZ 35772 488 28 that that IN 35772 488 29 in in IN 35772 488 30 the the DT 35772 488 31 smallest small JJS 35772 488 32 particle particle NN 35772 488 33 of of IN 35772 488 34 matter matter NN 35772 488 35 there there EX 35772 488 36 is be VBZ 35772 488 37 a a DT 35772 488 38 world world NN 35772 488 39 of of IN 35772 488 40 creatures creature NNS 35772 488 41 , , , 35772 488 42 living live VBG 35772 488 43 beings being NNS 35772 488 44 , , , 35772 488 45 animals animal NNS 35772 488 46 , , , 35772 488 47 entelechies entelechy NNS 35772 488 48 , , , 35772 488 49 souls soul NNS 35772 488 50 . . . 35772 489 1 Each each DT 35772 489 2 portion portion NN 35772 489 3 of of IN 35772 489 4 matter matter NN 35772 489 5 may may MD 35772 489 6 be be VB 35772 489 7 conceived conceive VBN 35772 489 8 as as RB 35772 489 9 like like IN 35772 489 10 a a DT 35772 489 11 garden garden NN 35772 489 12 full full JJ 35772 489 13 of of IN 35772 489 14 plants plant NNS 35772 489 15 , , , 35772 489 16 or or CC 35772 489 17 like like IN 35772 489 18 a a DT 35772 489 19 pond pond NN 35772 489 20 full full JJ 35772 489 21 of of IN 35772 489 22 fishes fish NNS 35772 489 23 .... .... . 35772 490 1 Thus thus RB 35772 490 2 there there EX 35772 490 3 is be VBZ 35772 490 4 nothing nothing NN 35772 490 5 fallow fallow JJ 35772 490 6 , , , 35772 490 7 nothing nothing NN 35772 490 8 sterile sterile JJ 35772 490 9 , , , 35772 490 10 nothing nothing NN 35772 490 11 dead dead JJ 35772 490 12 in in IN 35772 490 13 the the DT 35772 490 14 universe universe NN 35772 490 15 .... .... . 35772 490 16 "[11 "[11 LS 35772 490 17 ] ] -RRB- 35772 490 18 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 490 19 may may MD 35772 490 20 indeed indeed RB 35772 490 21 be be VB 35772 490 22 said say VBN 35772 490 23 to to TO 35772 490 24 have have VB 35772 490 25 been be VBN 35772 490 26 the the DT 35772 490 27 first first JJ 35772 490 28 to to TO 35772 490 29 outline outline VB 35772 490 30 a a DT 35772 490 31 theory theory NN 35772 490 32 of of IN 35772 490 33 " " `` 35772 490 34 panpsychism panpsychism NN 35772 490 35 " " '' 35772 490 36 ( ( -LRB- 35772 490 37 as as IN 35772 490 38 it -PRON- PRP 35772 490 39 is be VBZ 35772 490 40 termed term VBN 35772 490 41 ) ) -RRB- 35772 490 42 , , , 35772 490 43 according accord VBG 35772 490 44 to to IN 35772 490 45 which which WDT 35772 490 46 there there EX 35772 490 47 is be VBZ 35772 490 48 nothing nothing NN 35772 490 49 that that WDT 35772 490 50 is be VBZ 35772 490 51 not not RB 35772 490 52 , , , 35772 490 53 in in IN 35772 490 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 490 55 degree degree NN 35772 490 56 , , , 35772 490 57 alive alive JJ 35772 490 58 . . . 35772 491 1 As as IN 35772 491 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 491 3 shall shall MD 35772 491 4 have have VB 35772 491 5 occasion occasion NN 35772 491 6 to to TO 35772 491 7 observe observe VB 35772 491 8 , , , 35772 491 9 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 491 10 was be VBD 35772 491 11 here here RB 35772 491 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 491 13 as as RB 35772 491 14 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 491 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 491 16 a a DT 35772 491 17 forerunner forerunner NN 35772 491 18 of of IN 35772 491 19 much much JJ 35772 491 20 recent recent JJ 35772 491 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 491 22 . . . 35772 492 1 The the DT 35772 492 2 significance significance NN 35772 492 3 of of IN 35772 492 4 the the DT 35772 492 5 Spinozist Spinozist NNP 35772 492 6 and and CC 35772 492 7 Leibnizian Leibnizian NNP 35772 492 8 systems system NNS 35772 492 9 of of IN 35772 492 10 thought thought NN 35772 492 11 , , , 35772 492 12 though though IN 35772 492 13 regarding regard VBG 35772 492 14 existence existence NN 35772 492 15 from from IN 35772 492 16 such such JJ 35772 492 17 diverse diverse JJ 35772 492 18 standpoints standpoint NNS 35772 492 19 , , , 35772 492 20 was be VBD 35772 492 21 , , , 35772 492 22 for for IN 35772 492 23 practical practical JJ 35772 492 24 purposes purpose NNS 35772 492 25 the the DT 35772 492 26 same same JJ 35772 492 27 . . . 35772 493 1 Both both DT 35772 493 2 alike alike RB 35772 493 3 led lead VBD 35772 493 4 out out RP 35772 493 5 , , , 35772 493 6 though though RB 35772 493 7 by by IN 35772 493 8 different different JJ 35772 493 9 paths path NNS 35772 493 10 , , , 35772 493 11 beyond beyond IN 35772 493 12 the the DT 35772 493 13 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 493 14 theory theory NN 35772 493 15 of of IN 35772 493 16 the the DT 35772 493 17 universe universe NN 35772 493 18 . . . 35772 494 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 494 2 , , , 35772 494 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 494 4 , , , 35772 494 5 represent represent VB 35772 494 6 two two CD 35772 494 7 types type NNS 35772 494 8 of of IN 35772 494 9 thought thought NN 35772 494 10 which which WDT 35772 494 11 attempt attempt VBP 35772 494 12 to to TO 35772 494 13 reach reach VB 35772 494 14 the the DT 35772 494 15 same same JJ 35772 494 16 end end NN 35772 494 17 by by IN 35772 494 18 different different JJ 35772 494 19 methods method NNS 35772 494 20 . . . 35772 495 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 495 2 counterparts counterpart NNS 35772 495 3 will will MD 35772 495 4 meet meet VB 35772 495 5 us -PRON- PRP 35772 495 6 again again RB 35772 495 7 as as IN 35772 495 8 this this DT 35772 495 9 history history NN 35772 495 10 proceeds proceed VBZ 35772 495 11 . . . 35772 496 1 PASCAL.--But PASCAL.--But NNP 35772 496 2 before before IN 35772 496 3 passing pass VBG 35772 496 4 out out RP 35772 496 5 from from IN 35772 496 6 the the DT 35772 496 7 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 496 8 century century NN 35772 496 9 , , , 35772 496 10 one one CD 35772 496 11 thinker thinker NN 35772 496 12 ought ought MD 35772 496 13 to to TO 35772 496 14 detain detain VB 35772 496 15 us -PRON- PRP 35772 496 16 ; ; : 35772 496 17 for for IN 35772 496 18 from from IN 35772 496 19 more more JJR 35772 496 20 than than IN 35772 496 21 one one CD 35772 496 22 point point NN 35772 496 23 of of IN 35772 496 24 view view NN 35772 496 25 he -PRON- PRP 35772 496 26 was be VBD 35772 496 27 a a DT 35772 496 28 notable notable JJ 35772 496 29 personality personality NN 35772 496 30 , , , 35772 496 31 and and CC 35772 496 32 of of IN 35772 496 33 first first JJ 35772 496 34 - - HYPH 35772 496 35 rate rate NN 35772 496 36 importance importance NN 35772 496 37 in in IN 35772 496 38 the the DT 35772 496 39 history history NN 35772 496 40 of of IN 35772 496 41 religious religious JJ 35772 496 42 , , , 35772 496 43 as as IN 35772 496 44 distinct distinct JJ 35772 496 45 from from IN 35772 496 46 purely purely RB 35772 496 47 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 496 48 thought thought NN 35772 496 49 . . . 35772 497 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 497 2 was be VBD 35772 497 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 497 4 one one CD 35772 497 5 of of IN 35772 497 6 those those DT 35772 497 7 figures figure NNS 35772 497 8 who who WP 35772 497 9 are be VBP 35772 497 10 distinguished distinguish VBN 35772 497 11 among among IN 35772 497 12 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 497 13 men man NNS 35772 497 14 of of IN 35772 497 15 all all DT 35772 497 16 times time NNS 35772 497 17 . . . 35772 498 1 Blaise Blaise NNP 35772 498 2 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 498 3 was be VBD 35772 498 4 born bear VBN 35772 498 5 in in IN 35772 498 6 1623 1623 CD 35772 498 7 , , , 35772 498 8 and and CC 35772 498 9 was be VBD 35772 498 10 a a DT 35772 498 11 boy boy NN 35772 498 12 of of IN 35772 498 13 precocious precocious JJ 35772 498 14 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 498 15 ability ability NN 35772 498 16 . . . 35772 499 1 By by IN 35772 499 2 the the DT 35772 499 3 age age NN 35772 499 4 of of IN 35772 499 5 twelve twelve CD 35772 499 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 499 7 is be VBZ 35772 499 8 said say VBN 35772 499 9 to to TO 35772 499 10 have have VB 35772 499 11 worked work VBN 35772 499 12 out out RP 35772 499 13 independently independently RB 35772 499 14 most most JJS 35772 499 15 of of IN 35772 499 16 the the DT 35772 499 17 first first JJ 35772 499 18 and and CC 35772 499 19 second second JJ 35772 499 20 books book NNS 35772 499 21 of of IN 35772 499 22 Euclid Euclid NNP 35772 499 23 ; ; : 35772 499 24 at at IN 35772 499 25 sixteen sixteen CD 35772 499 26 he -PRON- PRP 35772 499 27 wrote write VBD 35772 499 28 a a DT 35772 499 29 treatise treatise NN 35772 499 30 on on IN 35772 499 31 Conics conic NNS 35772 499 32 which which WDT 35772 499 33 attracted attract VBD 35772 499 34 the the DT 35772 499 35 attention attention NN 35772 499 36 of of IN 35772 499 37 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 499 38 ; ; : 35772 499 39 at at IN 35772 499 40 nineteen nineteen CD 35772 499 41 he -PRON- PRP 35772 499 42 completed complete VBD 35772 499 43 a a DT 35772 499 44 calculating calculate VBG 35772 499 45 machine machine NN 35772 499 46 -- -- : 35772 499 47 a a DT 35772 499 48 device device NN 35772 499 49 that that WDT 35772 499 50 had have VBD 35772 499 51 never never RB 35772 499 52 been be VBN 35772 499 53 dreamt dreamt NN 35772 499 54 of of IN 35772 499 55 before before RB 35772 499 56 . . . 35772 500 1 At at IN 35772 500 2 this this DT 35772 500 3 point point NN 35772 500 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 500 5 is be VBZ 35772 500 6 not not RB 35772 500 7 surprising surprising JJ 35772 500 8 to to TO 35772 500 9 learn learn VB 35772 500 10 that that IN 35772 500 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 500 12 health health NN 35772 500 13 broke break VBD 35772 500 14 down down RP 35772 500 15 . . . 35772 501 1 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 501 2 is be VBZ 35772 501 3 not not RB 35772 501 4 a a DT 35772 501 5 systematic systematic JJ 35772 501 6 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 501 7 ; ; : 35772 501 8 but but CC 35772 501 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 501 10 acute acute JJ 35772 501 11 intellect intellect NN 35772 501 12 was be VBD 35772 501 13 united united JJ 35772 501 14 to to IN 35772 501 15 an an DT 35772 501 16 inner inner JJ 35772 501 17 restlessness restlessness NN 35772 501 18 of of IN 35772 501 19 soul soul NN 35772 501 20 . . . 35772 502 1 Neither neither DT 35772 502 2 science science NN 35772 502 3 nor nor CC 35772 502 4 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 502 5 could could MD 35772 502 6 bring bring VB 35772 502 7 him -PRON- PRP 35772 502 8 peace peace NN 35772 502 9 , , , 35772 502 10 for for IN 35772 502 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 502 12 needs need NNS 35772 502 13 were be VBD 35772 502 14 far far RB 35772 502 15 deeper deep JJR 35772 502 16 than than IN 35772 502 17 any any DT 35772 502 18 merely merely RB 35772 502 19 rational rational JJ 35772 502 20 systematisation systematisation NN 35772 502 21 of of IN 35772 502 22 ideas idea NNS 35772 502 23 could could MD 35772 502 24 satisfy satisfy VB 35772 502 25 . . . 35772 503 1 Some some DT 35772 503 2 have have VBP 35772 503 3 said say VBD 35772 503 4 of of IN 35772 503 5 him -PRON- PRP 35772 503 6 that that IN 35772 503 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 503 8 was be VBD 35772 503 9 fundamentally fundamentally RB 35772 503 10 a a DT 35772 503 11 sceptic sceptic JJ 35772 503 12 , , , 35772 503 13 but but CC 35772 503 14 one one CD 35772 503 15 for for IN 35772 503 16 whom whom WP 35772 503 17 religious religious JJ 35772 503 18 faith faith NN 35772 503 19 was be VBD 35772 503 20 essential essential JJ 35772 503 21 ; ; : 35772 503 22 certainly certainly RB 35772 503 23 in in IN 35772 503 24 him -PRON- PRP 35772 503 25 were be VBD 35772 503 26 united unite VBN 35772 503 27 an an DT 35772 503 28 acute acute JJ 35772 503 29 critical critical JJ 35772 503 30 faculty faculty NN 35772 503 31 and and CC 35772 503 32 an an DT 35772 503 33 intense intense JJ 35772 503 34 religious religious JJ 35772 503 35 experience experience NN 35772 503 36 . . . 35772 504 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 35772 504 2 the the DT 35772 504 3 two two CD 35772 504 4 are be VBP 35772 504 5 not not RB 35772 504 6 so so RB 35772 504 7 incompatible incompatible JJ 35772 504 8 after after RB 35772 504 9 all all RB 35772 504 10 . . . 35772 505 1 THE the DT 35772 505 2 " " `` 35772 505 3 PENSÉES PENSÉES NNP 35772 505 4 . . . 35772 505 5 " " '' 35772 506 1 --Pascal --Pascal : 35772 506 2 is be VBZ 35772 506 3 chiefly chiefly RB 35772 506 4 famous famous JJ 35772 506 5 for for IN 35772 506 6 two two CD 35772 506 7 works work NNS 35772 506 8 , , , 35772 506 9 the the DT 35772 506 10 _ _ NNP 35772 506 11 Lettres Lettres NNPS 35772 506 12 Provinciales Provinciales NNP 35772 506 13 _ _ NNP 35772 506 14 and and CC 35772 506 15 the the DT 35772 506 16 _ _ NNP 35772 506 17 Pensées Pensées NNP 35772 506 18 _ _ NNP 35772 506 19 . . . 35772 507 1 The the DT 35772 507 2 former former JJ 35772 507 3 is be VBZ 35772 507 4 controversial controversial JJ 35772 507 5 literature literature NN 35772 507 6 , , , 35772 507 7 but but CC 35772 507 8 yet yet RB 35772 507 9 a a DT 35772 507 10 classic classic NN 35772 507 11 of of IN 35772 507 12 the the DT 35772 507 13 French french JJ 35772 507 14 language language NN 35772 507 15 : : : 35772 507 16 in in IN 35772 507 17 sum sum NN 35772 507 18 , , , 35772 507 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 507 20 is be VBZ 35772 507 21 an an DT 35772 507 22 attack attack NN 35772 507 23 on on IN 35772 507 24 the the DT 35772 507 25 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 35772 507 26 ; ; : 35772 507 27 but but CC 35772 507 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 507 29 need nee MD 35772 507 30 not not RB 35772 507 31 here here RB 35772 507 32 detain detain VB 35772 507 33 us -PRON- PRP 35772 507 34 , , , 35772 507 35 for for IN 35772 507 36 with with IN 35772 507 37 theology theology NN 35772 507 38 , , , 35772 507 39 as as IN 35772 507 40 such such JJ 35772 507 41 , , , 35772 507 42 we -PRON- PRP 35772 507 43 are be VBP 35772 507 44 not not RB 35772 507 45 concerned concerned JJ 35772 507 46 , , , 35772 507 47 and and CC 35772 507 48 still still RB 35772 507 49 less less JJR 35772 507 50 with with IN 35772 507 51 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 35772 507 52 systems system NNS 35772 507 53 . . . 35772 508 1 The the DT 35772 508 2 _ _ NNP 35772 508 3 Pensées Pensées NNP 35772 508 4 _ _ NNP 35772 508 5 is be VBZ 35772 508 6 a a DT 35772 508 7 collection collection NN 35772 508 8 of of IN 35772 508 9 fragments fragment NNS 35772 508 10 , , , 35772 508 11 the the DT 35772 508 12 material material NN 35772 508 13 for for IN 35772 508 14 an an DT 35772 508 15 Apology Apology NNP 35772 508 16 for for IN 35772 508 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 508 18 which which WDT 35772 508 19 was be VBD 35772 508 20 never never RB 35772 508 21 written write VBN 35772 508 22 . . . 35772 509 1 The the DT 35772 509 2 autograph autograph NN 35772 509 3 MS MS NNP 35772 509 4 . . . 35772 509 5 preserved preserve VBN 35772 509 6 in in IN 35772 509 7 the the DT 35772 509 8 _ _ NNP 35772 509 9 Bibliothèque Bibliothèque NNP 35772 509 10 Nationale Nationale NNP 35772 509 11 _ _ NNP 35772 509 12 at at IN 35772 509 13 Paris Paris NNP 35772 509 14 " " `` 35772 509 15 is be VBZ 35772 509 16 made make VBN 35772 509 17 up up RP 35772 509 18 of of IN 35772 509 19 scraps scrap NNS 35772 509 20 of of IN 35772 509 21 paper paper NN 35772 509 22 of of IN 35772 509 23 all all DT 35772 509 24 shapes shape NNS 35772 509 25 and and CC 35772 509 26 sizes size NNS 35772 509 27 , , , 35772 509 28 written write VBN 35772 509 29 often often RB 35772 509 30 on on IN 35772 509 31 both both DT 35772 509 32 sides side NNS 35772 509 33 ... ... : 35772 509 34 and and CC 35772 509 35 dealing deal VBG 35772 509 36 with with IN 35772 509 37 all all DT 35772 509 38 sorts sort NNS 35772 509 39 of of IN 35772 509 40 subjects subject NNS 35772 509 41 . . . 35772 509 42 " " '' 35772 510 1 One one CD 35772 510 2 is be VBZ 35772 510 3 reminded remind VBN 35772 510 4 of of IN 35772 510 5 the the DT 35772 510 6 mythical mythical JJ 35772 510 7 scraps scrap NNS 35772 510 8 of of IN 35772 510 9 manuscript manuscript NN 35772 510 10 from from IN 35772 510 11 which which WDT 35772 510 12 the the DT 35772 510 13 genius genius NN 35772 510 14 of of IN 35772 510 15 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 510 16 distilled distil VBD 35772 510 17 the the DT 35772 510 18 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 510 19 of of IN 35772 510 20 the the DT 35772 510 21 sagacious sagacious JJ 35772 510 22 Teufelsdröch Teufelsdröch NNP 35772 510 23 . . . 35772 511 1 But but CC 35772 511 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 511 3 is be VBZ 35772 511 4 in in IN 35772 511 5 these these DT 35772 511 6 detached detach VBN 35772 511 7 fragments fragment NNS 35772 511 8 that that IN 35772 511 9 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 511 10 has have VBZ 35772 511 11 expressed express VBN 35772 511 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 511 13 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 511 14 and and CC 35772 511 15 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 511 16 struggles struggle NNS 35772 511 17 ; ; : 35772 511 18 they -PRON- PRP 35772 511 19 contain contain VBP 35772 511 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 511 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 511 22 of of IN 35772 511 23 life life NN 35772 511 24 . . . 35772 512 1 And and CC 35772 512 2 , , , 35772 512 3 however however RB 35772 512 4 unsystematic unsystematic JJ 35772 512 5 in in IN 35772 512 6 arrangement arrangement NN 35772 512 7 , , , 35772 512 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 512 9 do do VBP 35772 512 10 reveal reveal VB 35772 512 11 a a DT 35772 512 12 fairly fairly RB 35772 512 13 definite definite JJ 35772 512 14 temper temper NN 35772 512 15 and and CC 35772 512 16 attitude attitude NN 35772 512 17 of of IN 35772 512 18 mind mind NN 35772 512 19 . . . 35772 513 1 PASCAL PASCAL NNP 35772 513 2 'S be VBZ 35772 513 3 PHILOSOPHY.--In philosophy.--in VBP 35772 513 4 the the DT 35772 513 5 first first JJ 35772 513 6 place place NN 35772 513 7 , , , 35772 513 8 the the DT 35772 513 9 _ _ NNP 35772 513 10 Thoughts Thoughts NNPS 35772 513 11 _ _ NNP 35772 513 12 voice voice NN 35772 513 13 a a DT 35772 513 14 reaction reaction NN 35772 513 15 against against IN 35772 513 16 the the DT 35772 513 17 " " `` 35772 513 18 Cartesian cartesian JJ 35772 513 19 intellectualism intellectualism NN 35772 513 20 " " '' 35772 513 21 which which WDT 35772 513 22 was be VBD 35772 513 23 then then RB 35772 513 24 the the DT 35772 513 25 prevalent prevalent JJ 35772 513 26 tendency tendency NN 35772 513 27 in in IN 35772 513 28 scientific scientific JJ 35772 513 29 and and CC 35772 513 30 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 513 31 circles circle NNS 35772 513 32 . . . 35772 514 1 " " `` 35772 514 2 The the DT 35772 514 3 last last JJ 35772 514 4 attainment attainment NN 35772 514 5 of of IN 35772 514 6 reason reason NN 35772 514 7 is be VBZ 35772 514 8 to to TO 35772 514 9 recognise recognise VB 35772 514 10 that that IN 35772 514 11 there there EX 35772 514 12 is be VBZ 35772 514 13 an an DT 35772 514 14 infinity infinity NN 35772 514 15 of of IN 35772 514 16 things thing NNS 35772 514 17 beyond beyond IN 35772 514 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 514 19 " " `` 35772 514 20 might may MD 35772 514 21 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 514 22 have have VB 35772 514 23 been be VBN 35772 514 24 published publish VBN 35772 514 25 by by IN 35772 514 26 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 514 27 's 's POS 35772 514 28 predecessors predecessor NNS 35772 514 29 . . . 35772 515 1 " " `` 35772 515 2 To to TO 35772 515 3 laugh laugh VB 35772 515 4 at at IN 35772 515 5 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 515 6 is be VBZ 35772 515 7 to to TO 35772 515 8 be be VB 35772 515 9 a a DT 35772 515 10 true true JJ 35772 515 11 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 515 12 " " '' 35772 515 13 would would MD 35772 515 14 have have VB 35772 515 15 seemed seem VBN 35772 515 16 like like IN 35772 515 17 blasphemy blasphemy NN 35772 515 18 or or CC 35772 515 19 nonsense nonsense NN 35772 515 20 to to IN 35772 515 21 most most JJS 35772 515 22 of of IN 35772 515 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 515 24 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 515 25 , , , 35772 515 26 but but CC 35772 515 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 515 28 was be VBD 35772 515 29 neither neither DT 35772 515 30 of of IN 35772 515 31 these these DT 35772 515 32 . . . 35772 516 1 Behind behind IN 35772 516 2 sayings saying NNS 35772 516 3 of of IN 35772 516 4 this this DT 35772 516 5 description description NN 35772 516 6 lay lie VBD 35772 516 7 the the DT 35772 516 8 strong strong JJ 35772 516 9 conviction conviction NN 35772 516 10 that that IN 35772 516 11 mere mere JJ 35772 516 12 logic logic NN 35772 516 13 was be VBD 35772 516 14 incapable incapable JJ 35772 516 15 of of IN 35772 516 16 probing probe VBG 35772 516 17 the the DT 35772 516 18 depths depth NNS 35772 516 19 of of IN 35772 516 20 existence existence NN 35772 516 21 . . . 35772 517 1 " " `` 35772 517 2 The the DT 35772 517 3 heart heart NN 35772 517 4 has have VBZ 35772 517 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 517 6 reasons reason NNS 35772 517 7 of of IN 35772 517 8 which which WDT 35772 517 9 reason reason NN 35772 517 10 knows know VBZ 35772 517 11 nothing nothing NN 35772 517 12 , , , 35772 517 13 " " `` 35772 517 14 is be VBZ 35772 517 15 sound sound JJ 35772 517 16 psychology psychology NN 35772 517 17 , , , 35772 517 18 and and CC 35772 517 19 not not RB 35772 517 20 scepticism scepticism NN 35772 517 21 or or CC 35772 517 22 obscurantism obscurantism NN 35772 517 23 . . . 35772 518 1 Of of RB 35772 518 2 course course RB 35772 518 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 518 4 all all DT 35772 518 5 depends depend VBZ 35772 518 6 what what WP 35772 518 7 one one CD 35772 518 8 means mean VBZ 35772 518 9 by by IN 35772 518 10 " " `` 35772 518 11 reason reason NN 35772 518 12 . . . 35772 518 13 " " '' 35772 519 1 Too too RB 35772 519 2 many many JJ 35772 519 3 of of IN 35772 519 4 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 519 5 's 's POS 35772 519 6 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 519 7 applied apply VBD 35772 519 8 the the DT 35772 519 9 word word NN 35772 519 10 to to IN 35772 519 11 a a DT 35772 519 12 more more RBR 35772 519 13 or or CC 35772 519 14 less less RBR 35772 519 15 shallow shallow JJ 35772 519 16 rationalism rationalism NN 35772 519 17 utterly utterly RB 35772 519 18 opposed oppose VBD 35772 519 19 to to IN 35772 519 20 a a DT 35772 519 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 519 22 view view NN 35772 519 23 of of IN 35772 519 24 things thing NNS 35772 519 25 , , , 35772 519 26 whereas whereas IN 35772 519 27 reason reason NN 35772 519 28 properly properly RB 35772 519 29 understood understand VBD 35772 519 30 is be VBZ 35772 519 31 " " `` 35772 519 32 the the DT 35772 519 33 logic logic NN 35772 519 34 of of IN 35772 519 35 the the DT 35772 519 36 whole whole JJ 35772 519 37 personality personality NN 35772 519 38 . . . 35772 520 1 " " `` 35772 520 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 520 3 12 12 CD 35772 520 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 520 5 That that IN 35772 520 6 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 520 7 was be VBD 35772 520 8 no no DT 35772 520 9 mere mere JJ 35772 520 10 narrow narrow JJ 35772 520 11 anti anti JJ 35772 520 12 - - JJ 35772 520 13 rational rational JJ 35772 520 14 obscurantist obscurantist NN 35772 520 15 is be VBZ 35772 520 16 evident evident JJ 35772 520 17 , , , 35772 520 18 not not RB 35772 520 19 only only RB 35772 520 20 from from IN 35772 520 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 520 22 own own JJ 35772 520 23 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 35772 520 24 insight insight NN 35772 520 25 , , , 35772 520 26 but but CC 35772 520 27 from from IN 35772 520 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 520 29 continual continual JJ 35772 520 30 reiteration reiteration NN 35772 520 31 of of IN 35772 520 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 520 33 idea idea NN 35772 520 34 that that IN 35772 520 35 the the DT 35772 520 36 essential essential JJ 35772 520 37 dignity dignity NN 35772 520 38 of of IN 35772 520 39 man man NN 35772 520 40 lies lie VBZ 35772 520 41 in in IN 35772 520 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 520 43 thought thought NN 35772 520 44 : : : 35772 520 45 " " `` 35772 520 46 All all DT 35772 520 47 bodies body NNS 35772 520 48 , , , 35772 520 49 the the DT 35772 520 50 firmament firmament NN 35772 520 51 , , , 35772 520 52 the the DT 35772 520 53 stars star NNS 35772 520 54 , , , 35772 520 55 the the DT 35772 520 56 earth earth NN 35772 520 57 and and CC 35772 520 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 520 59 kingdoms kingdom NNS 35772 520 60 , , , 35772 520 61 are be VBP 35772 520 62 not not RB 35772 520 63 worth worth JJ 35772 520 64 the the DT 35772 520 65 smallest small JJS 35772 520 66 mind mind NN 35772 520 67 , , , 35772 520 68 for for IN 35772 520 69 a a DT 35772 520 70 mind mind NN 35772 520 71 knows know VBZ 35772 520 72 them -PRON- PRP 35772 520 73 , , , 35772 520 74 and and CC 35772 520 75 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 520 76 , , , 35772 520 77 and and CC 35772 520 78 bodies body NNS 35772 520 79 know know VBP 35772 520 80 nothing nothing NN 35772 520 81 . . . 35772 520 82 " " '' 35772 521 1 Here here RB 35772 521 2 lies lie VBZ 35772 521 3 the the DT 35772 521 4 true true JJ 35772 521 5 greatness greatness NN 35772 521 6 of of IN 35772 521 7 man man NN 35772 521 8 . . . 35772 522 1 In in IN 35772 522 2 respect respect NN 35772 522 3 of of IN 35772 522 4 material material JJ 35772 522 5 bulk bulk NN 35772 522 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 522 7 is be VBZ 35772 522 8 nothing nothing NN 35772 522 9 , , , 35772 522 10 but but CC 35772 522 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 522 12 thought thought NN 35772 522 13 can can MD 35772 522 14 not not RB 35772 522 15 be be VB 35772 522 16 measured measure VBN 35772 522 17 . . . 35772 523 1 " " `` 35772 523 2 Man man NN 35772 523 3 is be VBZ 35772 523 4 only only RB 35772 523 5 a a DT 35772 523 6 reed reed NN 35772 523 7 , , , 35772 523 8 the the DT 35772 523 9 feeblest feeblest JJ 35772 523 10 reed reed NN 35772 523 11 in in IN 35772 523 12 nature nature NN 35772 523 13 , , , 35772 523 14 _ _ NNP 35772 523 15 but but CC 35772 523 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 523 17 is be VBZ 35772 523 18 a a DT 35772 523 19 thinking thinking NN 35772 523 20 reed reed NN 35772 523 21 _ _ NNP 35772 523 22 . . . 35772 523 23 " " '' 35772 524 1 The the DT 35772 524 2 saying saying NN 35772 524 3 has have VBZ 35772 524 4 become become VBN 35772 524 5 famous famous JJ 35772 524 6 , , , 35772 524 7 and and CC 35772 524 8 the the DT 35772 524 9 words word NNS 35772 524 10 that that WDT 35772 524 11 follow follow NN 35772 524 12 are be VBP 35772 524 13 hardly hardly RB 35772 524 14 less less RBR 35772 524 15 so so RB 35772 524 16 ; ; : 35772 524 17 they -PRON- PRP 35772 524 18 remove remove VBP 35772 524 19 the the DT 35772 524 20 overpowering overpower VBG 35772 524 21 and and CC 35772 524 22 crushing crush VBG 35772 524 23 incubus incubus NN 35772 524 24 of of IN 35772 524 25 man man NN 35772 524 26 's 's POS 35772 524 27 illimitable illimitable JJ 35772 524 28 material material NN 35772 524 29 environment environment NN 35772 524 30 , , , 35772 524 31 which which WDT 35772 524 32 , , , 35772 524 33 since since IN 35772 524 34 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 524 35 , , , 35772 524 36 had have VBD 35772 524 37 weighed weigh VBN 35772 524 38 upon upon IN 35772 524 39 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 524 40 like like IN 35772 524 41 a a DT 35772 524 42 nightmare nightmare NN 35772 524 43 : : : 35772 524 44 " " `` 35772 524 45 Were be VBD 35772 524 46 the the DT 35772 524 47 universe universe NN 35772 524 48 to to TO 35772 524 49 crush crush VB 35772 524 50 him -PRON- PRP 35772 524 51 , , , 35772 524 52 man man NN 35772 524 53 would would MD 35772 524 54 still still RB 35772 524 55 be be VB 35772 524 56 more more RBR 35772 524 57 noble noble JJ 35772 524 58 than than IN 35772 524 59 that that DT 35772 524 60 which which WDT 35772 524 61 slays slay VBZ 35772 524 62 him -PRON- PRP 35772 524 63 , , , 35772 524 64 because because IN 35772 524 65 he -PRON- PRP 35772 524 66 knows know VBZ 35772 524 67 that that IN 35772 524 68 he -PRON- PRP 35772 524 69 dies die VBZ 35772 524 70 , , , 35772 524 71 and and CC 35772 524 72 the the DT 35772 524 73 advantage advantage NN 35772 524 74 that that WDT 35772 524 75 the the DT 35772 524 76 universe universe NN 35772 524 77 has have VBZ 35772 524 78 over over IN 35772 524 79 him -PRON- PRP 35772 524 80 : : : 35772 524 81 of of IN 35772 524 82 this this DT 35772 524 83 the the DT 35772 524 84 universe universe NN 35772 524 85 knows know VBZ 35772 524 86 nothing nothing NN 35772 524 87 . . . 35772 525 1 Thus thus RB 35772 525 2 all all DT 35772 525 3 man man NN 35772 525 4 's 's POS 35772 525 5 dignity dignity NN 35772 525 6 lies lie VBZ 35772 525 7 in in IN 35772 525 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 525 9 thought thought NN 35772 525 10 . . . 35772 526 1 " " `` 35772 526 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 526 3 13 13 CD 35772 526 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 526 5 PASCAL PASCAL NNP 35772 526 6 'S 'S NNP 35772 526 7 PESSIMISM.--It PESSIMISM.--It NNP 35772 526 8 has have VBZ 35772 526 9 been be VBN 35772 526 10 said say VBN 35772 526 11 that that IN 35772 526 12 an an DT 35772 526 13 unbridgeable unbridgeable JJ 35772 526 14 gulf gulf NN 35772 526 15 lies lie VBZ 35772 526 16 between between IN 35772 526 17 those those DT 35772 526 18 who who WP 35772 526 19 believe believe VBP 35772 526 20 and and CC 35772 526 21 those those DT 35772 526 22 who who WP 35772 526 23 disbelieve disbelieve VBP 35772 526 24 in in IN 35772 526 25 mankind mankind NN 35772 526 26 . . . 35772 527 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 527 2 is be VBZ 35772 527 3 to to IN 35772 527 4 the the DT 35772 527 5 latter latter JJ 35772 527 6 category category NN 35772 527 7 that that WDT 35772 527 8 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 527 9 belongs belong VBZ 35772 527 10 . . . 35772 528 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 528 2 faith faith NN 35772 528 3 in in IN 35772 528 4 the the DT 35772 528 5 dignity dignity NN 35772 528 6 of of IN 35772 528 7 man man NN 35772 528 8 is be VBZ 35772 528 9 paradoxically paradoxically RB 35772 528 10 associated associate VBN 35772 528 11 with with IN 35772 528 12 a a DT 35772 528 13 realisation realisation NN 35772 528 14 of of IN 35772 528 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 528 16 weakness weakness NN 35772 528 17 and and CC 35772 528 18 imbecility imbecility NN 35772 528 19 : : : 35772 528 20 " " `` 35772 528 21 What what WP 35772 528 22 a a DT 35772 528 23 chimera chimera NN 35772 528 24 , , , 35772 528 25 then then RB 35772 528 26 , , , 35772 528 27 is be VBZ 35772 528 28 man man NN 35772 528 29 ! ! . 35772 529 1 What what WDT 35772 529 2 an an DT 35772 529 3 oddity oddity NN 35772 529 4 , , , 35772 529 5 what what WDT 35772 529 6 a a DT 35772 529 7 monster monster NN 35772 529 8 , , , 35772 529 9 what what WDT 35772 529 10 a a DT 35772 529 11 chaos chaos NN 35772 529 12 , , , 35772 529 13 what what WDT 35772 529 14 a a DT 35772 529 15 subject subject NN 35772 529 16 of of IN 35772 529 17 contradiction contradiction NN 35772 529 18 , , , 35772 529 19 what what WDT 35772 529 20 a a DT 35772 529 21 prodigy prodigy NN 35772 529 22 ! ! . 35772 530 1 Judge judge NN 35772 530 2 of of IN 35772 530 3 all all DT 35772 530 4 things thing NNS 35772 530 5 , , , 35772 530 6 senseless senseless JJ 35772 530 7 earth earth NN 35772 530 8 - - HYPH 35772 530 9 worm worm NN 35772 530 10 ; ; : 35772 530 11 depository depository NN 35772 530 12 of of IN 35772 530 13 truth truth NN 35772 530 14 , , , 35772 530 15 cloaca cloaca NN 35772 530 16 of of IN 35772 530 17 uncertainty uncertainty NN 35772 530 18 and and CC 35772 530 19 error error NN 35772 530 20 ; ; : 35772 530 21 the the DT 35772 530 22 glory glory NN 35772 530 23 and and CC 35772 530 24 the the DT 35772 530 25 refuse refuse NN 35772 530 26 of of IN 35772 530 27 the the DT 35772 530 28 universe universe NN 35772 530 29 . . . 35772 530 30 " " '' 35772 531 1 " " `` 35772 531 2 We -PRON- PRP 35772 531 3 desire desire VBP 35772 531 4 truth truth NN 35772 531 5 , , , 35772 531 6 and and CC 35772 531 7 find find VB 35772 531 8 in in IN 35772 531 9 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 531 10 only only RB 35772 531 11 uncertainty uncertainty NN 35772 531 12 ; ; : 35772 531 13 we -PRON- PRP 35772 531 14 seek seek VBP 35772 531 15 happiness happiness NN 35772 531 16 , , , 35772 531 17 and and CC 35772 531 18 find find VBP 35772 531 19 only only JJ 35772 531 20 misery misery NN 35772 531 21 and and CC 35772 531 22 death death NN 35772 531 23 . . . 35772 532 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 532 2 are be VBP 35772 532 3 unable unable JJ 35772 532 4 not not RB 35772 532 5 to to TO 35772 532 6 wish wish VB 35772 532 7 for for IN 35772 532 8 truth truth NN 35772 532 9 and and CC 35772 532 10 happiness happiness NN 35772 532 11 , , , 35772 532 12 and and CC 35772 532 13 incapable incapable JJ 35772 532 14 either either CC 35772 532 15 of of IN 35772 532 16 certainty certainty NN 35772 532 17 or or CC 35772 532 18 felicity felicity NN 35772 532 19 . . . 35772 532 20 " " '' 35772 533 1 In in IN 35772 533 2 fact fact NN 35772 533 3 , , , 35772 533 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 533 5 may may MD 35772 533 6 say say VB 35772 533 7 that that IN 35772 533 8 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 533 9 was be VBD 35772 533 10 the the DT 35772 533 11 first first JJ 35772 533 12 , , , 35772 533 13 in in IN 35772 533 14 an an DT 35772 533 15 age age NN 35772 533 16 of of IN 35772 533 17 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 35772 533 18 reverence reverence NN 35772 533 19 for for IN 35772 533 20 logic logic NN 35772 533 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 533 22 the the DT 35772 533 23 _ _ NNP 35772 533 24 damnosa damnosa NNP 35772 533 25 hereditas hereditas NNP 35772 533 26 _ _ NNP 35772 533 27 of of IN 35772 533 28 the the DT 35772 533 29 Scholastic scholastic JJ 35772 533 30 theologians theologian NNS 35772 533 31 ) ) -RRB- 35772 533 32 to to TO 35772 533 33 understand understand VB 35772 533 34 that that IN 35772 533 35 the the DT 35772 533 36 best good JJS 35772 533 37 arguments argument NNS 35772 533 38 for for IN 35772 533 39 religion religion NN 35772 533 40 are be VBP 35772 533 41 the the DT 35772 533 42 facts fact NNS 35772 533 43 of of IN 35772 533 44 human human JJ 35772 533 45 experience experience NN 35772 533 46 , , , 35772 533 47 and and CC 35772 533 48 the the DT 35772 533 49 conditions condition NNS 35772 533 50 of of IN 35772 533 51 human human JJ 35772 533 52 life life NN 35772 533 53 . . . 35772 534 1 " " `` 35772 534 2 In in IN 35772 534 3 vain vain JJ 35772 534 4 , , , 35772 534 5 O o UH 35772 534 6 men man NNS 35772 534 7 , , , 35772 534 8 do do VBP 35772 534 9 ye ye PRP 35772 534 10 seek seek VB 35772 534 11 within within IN 35772 534 12 yourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 534 13 the the DT 35772 534 14 cure cure NN 35772 534 15 for for IN 35772 534 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 534 17 troubles trouble NNS 35772 534 18 ! ! . 35772 535 1 All all DT 35772 535 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 535 3 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 535 4 can can MD 35772 535 5 only only RB 35772 535 6 teach teach VB 35772 535 7 you -PRON- PRP 35772 535 8 that that IN 35772 535 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 535 10 is be VBZ 35772 535 11 not not RB 35772 535 12 within within IN 35772 535 13 yourselves yourself NNS 35772 535 14 that that WDT 35772 535 15 ye ye NNP 35772 535 16 find find VBP 35772 535 17 the the DT 35772 535 18 true true JJ 35772 535 19 or or CC 35772 535 20 good good JJ 35772 535 21 ! ! . 35772 535 22 " " '' 35772 536 1 Here here RB 35772 536 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 536 3 have have VBP 35772 536 4 the the DT 35772 536 5 language language NN 35772 536 6 of of IN 35772 536 7 religious religious JJ 35772 536 8 experience experience NN 35772 536 9 . . . 35772 537 1 The the DT 35772 537 2 result result NN 35772 537 3 of of IN 35772 537 4 Augustine Augustine NNP 35772 537 5 's 's POS 35772 537 6 meditation meditation NN 35772 537 7 upon upon IN 35772 537 8 life life NN 35772 537 9 was be VBD 35772 537 10 the the DT 35772 537 11 same same JJ 35772 537 12 : : : 35772 537 13 _ _ NNP 35772 537 14 Inquietum Inquietum NNP 35772 537 15 cor cor NNP 35772 537 16 nostrum nostrum NNP 35772 537 17 dum dum NNP 35772 537 18 requiescat requiescat NNP 35772 537 19 in in IN 35772 537 20 te te NNP 35772 537 21 . . . 35772 537 22 _ _ NNP 35772 537 23 It -PRON- PRP 35772 537 24 is be VBZ 35772 537 25 a a DT 35772 537 26 tongue tongue NN 35772 537 27 that that IN 35772 537 28 the the DT 35772 537 29 " " `` 35772 537 30 psychic psychic JJ 35772 537 31 man man NN 35772 537 32 " " '' 35772 537 33 can can MD 35772 537 34 never never RB 35772 537 35 understand understand VB 35772 537 36 ; ; : 35772 537 37 it -PRON- PRP 35772 537 38 seems seem VBZ 35772 537 39 to to IN 35772 537 40 him -PRON- PRP 35772 537 41 affectation affectation NN 35772 537 42 ; ; : 35772 537 43 such such JJ 35772 537 44 language language NN 35772 537 45 is be VBZ 35772 537 46 foreign foreign JJ 35772 537 47 to to IN 35772 537 48 the the DT 35772 537 49 easy easy JJ 35772 537 50 optimism optimism NN 35772 537 51 of of IN 35772 537 52 an an DT 35772 537 53 age age NN 35772 537 54 of of IN 35772 537 55 confidence confidence NN 35772 537 56 . . . 35772 538 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 538 2 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 538 3 , , , 35772 538 4 though though IN 35772 538 5 so so RB 35772 538 6 intensely intensely RB 35772 538 7 modern modern JJ 35772 538 8 , , , 35772 538 9 is be VBZ 35772 538 10 a a DT 35772 538 11 stranger stranger NN 35772 538 12 , , , 35772 538 13 and and CC 35772 538 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 538 15 words word NNS 35772 538 16 often often RB 35772 538 17 enigmas enigmas VBP 35772 538 18 to to IN 35772 538 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 538 20 time time NN 35772 538 21 . . . 35772 539 1 _ _ NNP 35772 539 2 Vanitas Vanitas NNP 35772 539 3 vanitatum vanitatum NN 35772 539 4 _ _ NNP 35772 539 5 is be VBZ 35772 539 6 thus thus RB 35772 539 7 the the DT 35772 539 8 verdict verdict NN 35772 539 9 that that WDT 35772 539 10 he -PRON- PRP 35772 539 11 passes pass VBZ 35772 539 12 upon upon IN 35772 539 13 human human JJ 35772 539 14 experience experience NN 35772 539 15 . . . 35772 540 1 " " `` 35772 540 2 The the DT 35772 540 3 last last JJ 35772 540 4 act act NN 35772 540 5 is be VBZ 35772 540 6 tragic tragic JJ 35772 540 7 , , , 35772 540 8 however however WRB 35772 540 9 fine fine JJ 35772 540 10 the the DT 35772 540 11 comedy comedy NN 35772 540 12 of of IN 35772 540 13 all all PDT 35772 540 14 the the DT 35772 540 15 rest rest NN 35772 540 16 . . . 35772 540 17 " " '' 35772 541 1 SIGNIFICANCE SIGNIFICANCE NNP 35772 541 2 OF of IN 35772 541 3 PASCAL.--It PASCAL.--It NNP 35772 541 4 is be VBZ 35772 541 5 not not RB 35772 541 6 as as IN 35772 541 7 a a DT 35772 541 8 systematic systematic JJ 35772 541 9 thinker thinker NN 35772 541 10 that that WDT 35772 541 11 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 541 12 is be VBZ 35772 541 13 of of IN 35772 541 14 importance importance NN 35772 541 15 to to IN 35772 541 16 the the DT 35772 541 17 historian historian NN 35772 541 18 of of IN 35772 541 19 thought thought NN 35772 541 20 . . . 35772 542 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 542 2 typifies typify VBZ 35772 542 3 that that IN 35772 542 4 more more RBR 35772 542 5 or or CC 35772 542 6 less less RBR 35772 542 7 inarticulate inarticulate JJ 35772 542 8 and and CC 35772 542 9 unreasoned unreasoned JJ 35772 542 10 revolt revolt NN 35772 542 11 which which WDT 35772 542 12 the the DT 35772 542 13 arrogance arrogance NN 35772 542 14 and and CC 35772 542 15 optimism optimism NN 35772 542 16 of of IN 35772 542 17 a a DT 35772 542 18 new new JJ 35772 542 19 science science NN 35772 542 20 or or CC 35772 542 21 a a DT 35772 542 22 new new JJ 35772 542 23 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 542 24 arouse arouse VBP 35772 542 25 against against IN 35772 542 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 542 27 . . . 35772 543 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 543 2 voices voice VBZ 35772 543 3 the the DT 35772 543 4 eternal eternal JJ 35772 543 5 protest protest NN 35772 543 6 that that IN 35772 543 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 543 8 is be VBZ 35772 543 9 not not RB 35772 543 10 by by IN 35772 543 11 bread bread NN 35772 543 12 alone alone RB 35772 543 13 that that IN 35772 543 14 men man NNS 35772 543 15 live live VBP 35772 543 16 . . . 35772 544 1 As as IN 35772 544 2 is be VBZ 35772 544 3 generally generally RB 35772 544 4 the the DT 35772 544 5 case case NN 35772 544 6 with with IN 35772 544 7 such such JJ 35772 544 8 protests protest NNS 35772 544 9 , , , 35772 544 10 the the DT 35772 544 11 pessimism pessimism NN 35772 544 12 of of IN 35772 544 13 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 544 14 was be VBD 35772 544 15 no no RB 35772 544 16 doubt doubt RB 35772 544 17 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 35772 544 18 ; ; : 35772 544 19 but but CC 35772 544 20 exaggeration exaggeration NN 35772 544 21 is be VBZ 35772 544 22 necessary necessary JJ 35772 544 23 if if IN 35772 544 24 minds mind NNS 35772 544 25 are be VBP 35772 544 26 to to TO 35772 544 27 be be VB 35772 544 28 impressed impressed JJ 35772 544 29 ; ; : 35772 544 30 and and CC 35772 544 31 those those DT 35772 544 32 who who WP 35772 544 33 feel feel VBP 35772 544 34 strongly strongly RB 35772 544 35 see see VBP 35772 544 36 only only RB 35772 544 37 one one CD 35772 544 38 side side NN 35772 544 39 of of IN 35772 544 40 a a DT 35772 544 41 question question NN 35772 544 42 . . . 35772 545 1 RESULTS.--Thus RESULTS.--Thus NNP 35772 545 2 in in IN 35772 545 3 the the DT 35772 545 4 three three CD 35772 545 5 figures figure NNS 35772 545 6 that that WDT 35772 545 7 have have VBP 35772 545 8 passed pass VBN 35772 545 9 before before IN 35772 545 10 us -PRON- PRP 35772 545 11 , , , 35772 545 12 we -PRON- PRP 35772 545 13 see see VBP 35772 545 14 a a DT 35772 545 15 threefold threefold JJ 35772 545 16 protest protest NN 35772 545 17 against against IN 35772 545 18 that that DT 35772 545 19 exclusion exclusion NN 35772 545 20 of of IN 35772 545 21 the the DT 35772 545 22 spiritual spiritual NN 35772 545 23 from from IN 35772 545 24 the the DT 35772 545 25 human human JJ 35772 545 26 view view NN 35772 545 27 of of IN 35772 545 28 life life NN 35772 545 29 . . . 35772 546 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 546 2 , , , 35772 546 3 the the DT 35772 546 4 pantheist pantheist NN 35772 546 5 , , , 35772 546 6 sees see VBZ 35772 546 7 God God NNP 35772 546 8 everywhere;[14 everywhere;[14 NNP 35772 546 9 ] ] -RRB- 35772 546 10 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 546 11 finds find VBZ 35772 546 12 in in IN 35772 546 13 every every DT 35772 546 14 recess recess NN 35772 546 15 of of IN 35772 546 16 nature nature NN 35772 546 17 the the DT 35772 546 18 principle principle NN 35772 546 19 of of IN 35772 546 20 personality personality NN 35772 546 21 ; ; : 35772 546 22 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 546 23 finds find VBZ 35772 546 24 the the DT 35772 546 25 only only JJ 35772 546 26 cure cure NN 35772 546 27 for for IN 35772 546 28 human human JJ 35772 546 29 frailty frailty NN 35772 546 30 and and CC 35772 546 31 misery misery NN 35772 546 32 in in IN 35772 546 33 religion religion NN 35772 546 34 . . . 35772 547 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 547 2 V V NNP 35772 547 3 RISE RISE NNP 35772 547 4 OF of IN 35772 547 5 AN an DT 35772 547 6 ANTI anti JJ 35772 547 7 - - HYPH 35772 547 8 RELIGIOUS religious JJ 35772 547 9 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 547 10 ATMOSPHERIC atmospheric IN 35772 547 11 CONDITIONS.--As CONDITIONS.--As NNP 35772 547 12 we -PRON- PRP 35772 547 13 have have VBP 35772 547 14 seen see VBN 35772 547 15 , , , 35772 547 16 a a DT 35772 547 17 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 547 18 view view NN 35772 547 19 of of IN 35772 547 20 the the DT 35772 547 21 universe universe NN 35772 547 22 was be VBD 35772 547 23 not not RB 35772 547 24 felt feel VBN 35772 547 25 by by IN 35772 547 26 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 547 27 like like IN 35772 547 28 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 547 29 or or CC 35772 547 30 Newton Newton NNP 35772 547 31 , , , 35772 547 32 or or CC 35772 547 33 even even RB 35772 547 34 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 547 35 , , , 35772 547 36 to to TO 35772 547 37 involve involve VB 35772 547 38 any any DT 35772 547 39 consequences consequence NNS 35772 547 40 that that WDT 35772 547 41 were be VBD 35772 547 42 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 547 43 hostile hostile JJ 35772 547 44 to to IN 35772 547 45 religion religion NN 35772 547 46 . . . 35772 548 1 The the DT 35772 548 2 new new JJ 35772 548 3 science science NN 35772 548 4 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 548 5 might may MD 35772 548 6 be be VB 35772 548 7 anti anti JJ 35772 548 8 - - JJ 35772 548 9 theological theological JJ 35772 548 10 , , , 35772 548 11 because because IN 35772 548 12 the the DT 35772 548 13 current current JJ 35772 548 14 theology theology NN 35772 548 15 still still RB 35772 548 16 seemed seem VBD 35772 548 17 too too RB 35772 548 18 much much RB 35772 548 19 infected infect VBN 35772 548 20 with with IN 35772 548 21 Scholasticism Scholasticism NNP 35772 548 22 , , , 35772 548 23 but but CC 35772 548 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 548 25 was be VBD 35772 548 26 not not RB 35772 548 27 , , , 35772 548 28 in in IN 35772 548 29 the the DT 35772 548 30 hands hand NNS 35772 548 31 of of IN 35772 548 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 548 33 most most RBS 35772 548 34 notable notable JJ 35772 548 35 exponents exponent NNS 35772 548 36 , , , 35772 548 37 anti anti JJ 35772 548 38 - - JJ 35772 548 39 religious religious JJ 35772 548 40 . . . 35772 549 1 Science science NN 35772 549 2 had have VBD 35772 549 3 no no DT 35772 549 4 quarrel quarrel NN 35772 549 5 with with IN 35772 549 6 religion religion NN 35772 549 7 as as IN 35772 549 8 such such JJ 35772 549 9 , , , 35772 549 10 nor nor CC 35772 549 11 even even RB 35772 549 12 with with IN 35772 549 13 a a DT 35772 549 14 rational rational JJ 35772 549 15 type type NN 35772 549 16 of of IN 35772 549 17 theology theology NN 35772 549 18 . . . 35772 550 1 Of of RB 35772 550 2 course course RB 35772 550 3 the the DT 35772 550 4 new new JJ 35772 550 5 views view NNS 35772 550 6 aroused arouse VBD 35772 550 7 many many JJ 35772 550 8 suspicions suspicion NNS 35772 550 9 , , , 35772 550 10 and and CC 35772 550 11 did do VBD 35772 550 12 not not RB 35772 550 13 escape escape VB 35772 550 14 criticism criticism NN 35772 550 15 at at IN 35772 550 16 the the DT 35772 550 17 hands hand NNS 35772 550 18 of of IN 35772 550 19 Church Church NNP 35772 550 20 authorities authority NNS 35772 550 21 , , , 35772 550 22 both both CC 35772 550 23 Protestant Protestant NNP 35772 550 24 and and CC 35772 550 25 Catholic Catholic NNP 35772 550 26 . . . 35772 551 1 And and CC 35772 551 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 551 3 as as IN 35772 551 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 551 5 have have VBP 35772 551 6 seen see VBN 35772 551 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 551 8 some some DT 35772 551 9 early early JJ 35772 551 10 scientists scientist NNS 35772 551 11 paid pay VBD 35772 551 12 very very RB 35772 551 13 dearly dearly RB 35772 551 14 for for IN 35772 551 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 551 16 allegiance allegiance NN 35772 551 17 to to IN 35772 551 18 the the DT 35772 551 19 spirit spirit NN 35772 551 20 of of IN 35772 551 21 scientific scientific JJ 35772 551 22 enquiry enquiry NN 35772 551 23 ; ; : 35772 551 24 but but CC 35772 551 25 as as IN 35772 551 26 time time NN 35772 551 27 went go VBD 35772 551 28 on on RB 35772 551 29 , , , 35772 551 30 actual actual JJ 35772 551 31 persecution persecution NN 35772 551 32 became become VBD 35772 551 33 impossible impossible JJ 35772 551 34 , , , 35772 551 35 morally morally RB 35772 551 36 and and CC 35772 551 37 practically practically RB 35772 551 38 . . . 35772 552 1 But but CC 35772 552 2 theologians theologian NNS 35772 552 3 were be VBD 35772 552 4 never never RB 35772 552 5 , , , 35772 552 6 during during IN 35772 552 7 the the DT 35772 552 8 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 552 9 century century NN 35772 552 10 at at IN 35772 552 11 least least JJS 35772 552 12 , , , 35772 552 13 quite quite RB 35772 552 14 reconciled reconcile VBN 35772 552 15 to to IN 35772 552 16 a a DT 35772 552 17 science science NN 35772 552 18 and and CC 35772 552 19 a a DT 35772 552 20 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 552 21 which which WDT 35772 552 22 seemed seem VBD 35772 552 23 to to IN 35772 552 24 them -PRON- PRP 35772 552 25 to to TO 35772 552 26 be be VB 35772 552 27 leading lead VBG 35772 552 28 men man NNS 35772 552 29 towards towards IN 35772 552 30 areas area NNS 35772 552 31 quite quite RB 35772 552 32 uninhabitable uninhabitable JJ 35772 552 33 for for IN 35772 552 34 religion religion NN 35772 552 35 . . . 35772 553 1 But but CC 35772 553 2 in in IN 35772 553 3 spite spite NN 35772 553 4 of of IN 35772 553 5 suspicions suspicion NNS 35772 553 6 on on IN 35772 553 7 either either DT 35772 553 8 side side NN 35772 553 9 , , , 35772 553 10 and and CC 35772 553 11 the the DT 35772 553 12 prevalence prevalence NN 35772 553 13 of of IN 35772 553 14 some some DT 35772 553 15 measure measure NN 35772 553 16 of of IN 35772 553 17 intolerance intolerance NN 35772 553 18 , , , 35772 553 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 553 20 can can MD 35772 553 21 not not RB 35772 553 22 be be VB 35772 553 23 said say VBN 35772 553 24 that that IN 35772 553 25 relations relation NNS 35772 553 26 between between IN 35772 553 27 the the DT 35772 553 28 scientists scientist NNS 35772 553 29 or or CC 35772 553 30 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 553 31 and and CC 35772 553 32 the the DT 35772 553 33 theologians theologian NNS 35772 553 34 were be VBD 35772 553 35 very very RB 35772 553 36 seriously seriously RB 35772 553 37 strained strained JJ 35772 553 38 until until IN 35772 553 39 well well RB 35772 553 40 on on RB 35772 553 41 in in IN 35772 553 42 the the DT 35772 553 43 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 553 44 century century NN 35772 553 45 . . . 35772 554 1 ANTI anti JJ 35772 554 2 - - HYPH 35772 554 3 RELIGIOUS religious NN 35772 554 4 PROPAGANDA.--That PROPAGANDA.--That NNP 35772 554 5 this this DT 35772 554 6 comparatively comparatively RB 35772 554 7 pacific pacific JJ 35772 554 8 state state NN 35772 554 9 of of IN 35772 554 10 affairs affair NNS 35772 554 11 came come VBD 35772 554 12 to to IN 35772 554 13 an an DT 35772 554 14 end end NN 35772 554 15 was be VBD 35772 554 16 the the DT 35772 554 17 fault fault NN 35772 554 18 , , , 35772 554 19 primarily primarily RB 35772 554 20 , , , 35772 554 21 at at IN 35772 554 22 least least JJS 35772 554 23 , , , 35772 554 24 neither neither DT 35772 554 25 of of IN 35772 554 26 the the DT 35772 554 27 theologians theologian NNS 35772 554 28 nor nor CC 35772 554 29 of of IN 35772 554 30 the the DT 35772 554 31 scientists scientist NNS 35772 554 32 . . . 35772 555 1 A a DT 35772 555 2 different different JJ 35772 555 3 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 555 4 gradually gradually RB 35772 555 5 began begin VBD 35772 555 6 to to TO 35772 555 7 envelop envelop VB 35772 555 8 and and CC 35772 555 9 to to TO 35772 555 10 embitter embitter VB 35772 555 11 the the DT 35772 555 12 controversy controversy NN 35772 555 13 . . . 35772 556 1 Orthodox orthodox JJ 35772 556 2 religion religion NN 35772 556 3 , , , 35772 556 4 especially especially RB 35772 556 5 in in IN 35772 556 6 Catholic catholic JJ 35772 556 7 countries country NNS 35772 556 8 , , , 35772 556 9 came come VBD 35772 556 10 to to TO 35772 556 11 be be VB 35772 556 12 associated associate VBN 35772 556 13 with with IN 35772 556 14 political political JJ 35772 556 15 reaction reaction NN 35772 556 16 , , , 35772 556 17 and and CC 35772 556 18 the the DT 35772 556 19 most most RBS 35772 556 20 envenomed envenomed JJ 35772 556 21 onslaughts onslaught NNS 35772 556 22 began begin VBD 35772 556 23 to to TO 35772 556 24 be be VB 35772 556 25 made make VBN 35772 556 26 upon upon IN 35772 556 27 what what WP 35772 556 28 seemed seem VBD 35772 556 29 to to TO 35772 556 30 be be VB 35772 556 31 the the DT 35772 556 32 chief chief JJ 35772 556 33 stronghold stronghold NN 35772 556 34 of of IN 35772 556 35 a a DT 35772 556 36 discredited discredited JJ 35772 556 37 regime regime NN 35772 556 38 . . . 35772 557 1 Especially especially RB 35772 557 2 was be VBD 35772 557 3 this this DT 35772 557 4 the the DT 35772 557 5 case case NN 35772 557 6 in in IN 35772 557 7 France France NNP 35772 557 8 , , , 35772 557 9 where where WRB 35772 557 10 corrupt corrupt JJ 35772 557 11 political political JJ 35772 557 12 conditions condition NNS 35772 557 13 were be VBD 35772 557 14 aggravated aggravate VBN 35772 557 15 by by IN 35772 557 16 the the DT 35772 557 17 intense intense JJ 35772 557 18 social social JJ 35772 557 19 misery misery NN 35772 557 20 which which WDT 35772 557 21 they -PRON- PRP 35772 557 22 had have VBD 35772 557 23 created create VBN 35772 557 24 . . . 35772 558 1 Thus thus RB 35772 558 2 France France NNP 35772 558 3 became become VBD 35772 558 4 the the DT 35772 558 5 cradle cradle NN 35772 558 6 of of IN 35772 558 7 the the DT 35772 558 8 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 558 9 known know VBN 35772 558 10 as as IN 35772 558 11 anti anti JJ 35772 558 12 - - JJ 35772 558 13 clericalism clericalism JJ 35772 558 14 , , , 35772 558 15 which which WDT 35772 558 16 is be VBZ 35772 558 17 the the DT 35772 558 18 product product NN 35772 558 19 not not RB 35772 558 20 so so RB 35772 558 21 much much JJ 35772 558 22 of of IN 35772 558 23 disbelief disbelief NN 35772 558 24 in in IN 35772 558 25 a a DT 35772 558 26 creed creed NN 35772 558 27 as as IN 35772 558 28 of of IN 35772 558 29 hatred hatred NN 35772 558 30 of of IN 35772 558 31 a a DT 35772 558 32 system system NN 35772 558 33 ; ; : 35772 558 34 it -PRON- PRP 35772 558 35 was be VBD 35772 558 36 the the DT 35772 558 37 correlative correlative NN 35772 558 38 of of IN 35772 558 39 a a DT 35772 558 40 Church Church NNP 35772 558 41 in in IN 35772 558 42 which which WDT 35772 558 43 religion religion NN 35772 558 44 was be VBD 35772 558 45 extinct extinct VBN 35772 558 46 , , , 35772 558 47 for for IN 35772 558 48 genuine genuine JJ 35772 558 49 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 35772 558 50 had have VBD 35772 558 51 been be VBN 35772 558 52 rooted root VBN 35772 558 53 out out IN 35772 558 54 of of IN 35772 558 55 France France NNP 35772 558 56 early early RB 35772 558 57 in in IN 35772 558 58 the the DT 35772 558 59 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 558 60 century century NN 35772 558 61 , , , 35772 558 62 just just RB 35772 558 63 as as IN 35772 558 64 Protestantism Protestantism NNP 35772 558 65 had have VBD 35772 558 66 been be VBN 35772 558 67 drowned drown VBN 35772 558 68 in in IN 35772 558 69 blood blood NN 35772 558 70 a a DT 35772 558 71 century century NN 35772 558 72 before before RB 35772 558 73 . . . 35772 559 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 559 2 15 15 CD 35772 559 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 559 4 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 559 5 POPULARISED.--In POPULARISED.--In NNP 35772 559 6 two two CD 35772 559 7 respects respect VBZ 35772 559 8 France France NNP 35772 559 9 , , , 35772 559 10 during during IN 35772 559 11 the the DT 35772 559 12 second second JJ 35772 559 13 half half NN 35772 559 14 of of IN 35772 559 15 the the DT 35772 559 16 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 559 17 century century NN 35772 559 18 , , , 35772 559 19 was be VBD 35772 559 20 far far RB 35772 559 21 in in IN 35772 559 22 advance advance NN 35772 559 23 of of IN 35772 559 24 other other JJ 35772 559 25 countries country NNS 35772 559 26 . . . 35772 560 1 No no DT 35772 560 2 other other JJ 35772 560 3 literature literature NN 35772 560 4 of of IN 35772 560 5 that that DT 35772 560 6 age age NN 35772 560 7 can can MD 35772 560 8 be be VB 35772 560 9 compared compare VBN 35772 560 10 with with IN 35772 560 11 the the DT 35772 560 12 French French NNP 35772 560 13 for for IN 35772 560 14 the the DT 35772 560 15 skill skill NN 35772 560 16 and and CC 35772 560 17 charm charm NN 35772 560 18 with with IN 35772 560 19 which which WDT 35772 560 20 scientific scientific JJ 35772 560 21 views view NNS 35772 560 22 were be VBD 35772 560 23 expressed express VBN 35772 560 24 . . . 35772 561 1 There there EX 35772 561 2 was be VBD 35772 561 3 no no DT 35772 561 4 lack lack NN 35772 561 5 of of IN 35772 561 6 first first JJ 35772 561 7 - - HYPH 35772 561 8 rate rate NN 35772 561 9 propagandists propagandist NNS 35772 561 10 . . . 35772 562 1 And and CC 35772 562 2 not not RB 35772 562 3 only only RB 35772 562 4 in in IN 35772 562 5 the the DT 35772 562 6 popularisation popularisation NN 35772 562 7 , , , 35772 562 8 but but CC 35772 562 9 in in IN 35772 562 10 the the DT 35772 562 11 systematic systematic JJ 35772 562 12 teaching teaching NN 35772 562 13 of of IN 35772 562 14 science science NN 35772 562 15 , , , 35772 562 16 France France NNP 35772 562 17 for for IN 35772 562 18 a a DT 35772 562 19 long long JJ 35772 562 20 period period NN 35772 562 21 led lead VBD 35772 562 22 the the DT 35772 562 23 way way NN 35772 562 24 . . . 35772 563 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 563 2 16 16 CD 35772 563 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 563 4 Whereas whereas IN 35772 563 5 the the DT 35772 563 6 history history NN 35772 563 7 of of IN 35772 563 8 English english JJ 35772 563 9 or or CC 35772 563 10 German german JJ 35772 563 11 literature literature NN 35772 563 12 of of IN 35772 563 13 the the DT 35772 563 14 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 563 15 century century NN 35772 563 16 could could MD 35772 563 17 be be VB 35772 563 18 written write VBN 35772 563 19 almost almost RB 35772 563 20 without without IN 35772 563 21 reference reference NN 35772 563 22 to to IN 35772 563 23 science science NN 35772 563 24 , , , 35772 563 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 563 26 is be VBZ 35772 563 27 with with IN 35772 563 28 scientific scientific JJ 35772 563 29 problems problem NNS 35772 563 30 that that WDT 35772 563 31 the the DT 35772 563 32 names name NNS 35772 563 33 of of IN 35772 563 34 some some DT 35772 563 35 of of IN 35772 563 36 the the DT 35772 563 37 most most RBS 35772 563 38 brilliant brilliant JJ 35772 563 39 French French NNP 35772 563 40 _ _ NNP 35772 563 41 littérateurs littérateur NNS 35772 563 42 _ _ NNP 35772 563 43 are be VBP 35772 563 44 associated associate VBN 35772 563 45 . . . 35772 564 1 And and CC 35772 564 2 whereas whereas IN 35772 564 3 in in IN 35772 564 4 England England NNP 35772 564 5 , , , 35772 564 6 scientific scientific JJ 35772 564 7 men man NNS 35772 564 8 worked work VBD 35772 564 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 564 10 in in IN 35772 564 11 spite spite NN 35772 564 12 of of IN 35772 564 13 the the DT 35772 564 14 existence existence NN 35772 564 15 of of IN 35772 564 16 the the DT 35772 564 17 Royal Royal NNP 35772 564 18 Society Society NNP 35772 564 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 564 20 more more RBR 35772 564 21 or or CC 35772 564 22 less less RBR 35772 564 23 in in IN 35772 564 24 isolation isolation NN 35772 564 25 , , , 35772 564 26 in in IN 35772 564 27 France France NNP 35772 564 28 the the DT 35772 564 29 savants savant NNS 35772 564 30 have have VBP 35772 564 31 always always RB 35772 564 32 been be VBN 35772 564 33 a a DT 35772 564 34 brotherhood brotherhood NN 35772 564 35 . . . 35772 565 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 565 2 17 17 CD 35772 565 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 565 4 VOLTAIRE.--One voltaire.--one NN 35772 565 5 of of IN 35772 565 6 the the DT 35772 565 7 most most RBS 35772 565 8 notorious notorious JJ 35772 565 9 names name NNS 35772 565 10 associated associate VBN 35772 565 11 with with IN 35772 565 12 the the DT 35772 565 13 type type NN 35772 565 14 of of IN 35772 565 15 propaganda propaganda NN 35772 565 16 referred refer VBN 35772 565 17 to to IN 35772 565 18 is be VBZ 35772 565 19 that that DT 35772 565 20 of of IN 35772 565 21 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 565 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 565 23 1694 1694 CD 35772 565 24 - - SYM 35772 565 25 1778 1778 CD 35772 565 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 565 27 . . . 35772 566 1 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 566 2 's 's POS 35772 566 3 polemic polemic NN 35772 566 4 can can MD 35772 566 5 not not RB 35772 566 6 be be VB 35772 566 7 described describe VBN 35772 566 8 as as IN 35772 566 9 anti anti JJ 35772 566 10 - - JJ 35772 566 11 religious religious JJ 35772 566 12 , , , 35772 566 13 for for IN 35772 566 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 566 15 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 566 16 was be VBD 35772 566 17 a a DT 35772 566 18 theist theist NN 35772 566 19 . . . 35772 567 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 567 2 was be VBD 35772 567 3 , , , 35772 567 4 rather rather RB 35772 567 5 , , , 35772 567 6 political political JJ 35772 567 7 in in IN 35772 567 8 character character NN 35772 567 9 . . . 35772 568 1 The the DT 35772 568 2 object object NN 35772 568 3 of of IN 35772 568 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 568 5 attack attack NN 35772 568 6 was be VBD 35772 568 7 the the DT 35772 568 8 Catholic Catholic NNP 35772 568 9 Church Church NNP 35772 568 10 as as IN 35772 568 11 existing exist VBG 35772 568 12 in in IN 35772 568 13 France France NNP 35772 568 14 in in IN 35772 568 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 568 16 day day NN 35772 568 17 , , , 35772 568 18 which which WDT 35772 568 19 he -PRON- PRP 35772 568 20 regarded regard VBD 35772 568 21 as as IN 35772 568 22 the the DT 35772 568 23 chief chief JJ 35772 568 24 surviving survive VBG 35772 568 25 obstacle obstacle NN 35772 568 26 to to IN 35772 568 27 human human JJ 35772 568 28 progress progress NN 35772 568 29 . . . 35772 569 1 _ _ NNP 35772 569 2 Écrasez Écrasez NNP 35772 569 3 l'infâme l'infâme NNP 35772 569 4 _ _ NNP 35772 569 5 was be VBD 35772 569 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 569 7 motto motto NN 35772 569 8 ; ; , 35772 569 9 and and CC 35772 569 10 if if IN 35772 569 11 this this DT 35772 569 12 seems seem VBZ 35772 569 13 a a DT 35772 569 14 trifle trifle NN 35772 569 15 fanatical fanatical JJ 35772 569 16 , , , 35772 569 17 let let VB 35772 569 18 us -PRON- PRP 35772 569 19 not not RB 35772 569 20 forget forget VB 35772 569 21 , , , 35772 569 22 as as IN 35772 569 23 an an DT 35772 569 24 acute acute JJ 35772 569 25 critic critic NN 35772 569 26 has have VBZ 35772 569 27 observed observe VBN 35772 569 28 , , , 35772 569 29 " " '' 35772 569 30 that that IN 35772 569 31 what what WP 35772 569 32 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 35772 569 33 was be VBD 35772 569 34 accomplishing accomplish VBG 35772 569 35 in in IN 35772 569 36 France France NNP 35772 569 37 in in IN 35772 569 38 the the DT 35772 569 39 first first JJ 35772 569 40 half half NN 35772 569 41 of of IN 35772 569 42 the the DT 35772 569 43 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 569 44 century century NN 35772 569 45 was be VBD 35772 569 46 not not RB 35772 569 47 anything anything NN 35772 569 48 less less RBR 35772 569 49 momentous momentous JJ 35772 569 50 than than IN 35772 569 51 the the DT 35772 569 52 slow slow JJ 35772 569 53 strangling strangling NN 35772 569 54 of of IN 35772 569 55 French french JJ 35772 569 56 civilisation civilisation NN 35772 569 57 . . . 35772 570 1 " " `` 35772 570 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 570 3 18 18 CD 35772 570 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 570 5 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 570 6 was be VBD 35772 570 7 an an DT 35772 570 8 industrious industrious JJ 35772 570 9 and and CC 35772 570 10 prolific prolific JJ 35772 570 11 writer writer NN 35772 570 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 570 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 570 14 works work NNS 35772 570 15 are be VBP 35772 570 16 numbered number VBN 35772 570 17 by by IN 35772 570 18 scores score NNS 35772 570 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 570 20 , , , 35772 570 21 but but CC 35772 570 22 he -PRON- PRP 35772 570 23 was be VBD 35772 570 24 also also RB 35772 570 25 a a DT 35772 570 26 master master NN 35772 570 27 of of IN 35772 570 28 French french JJ 35772 570 29 prose prose NN 35772 570 30 , , , 35772 570 31 and and CC 35772 570 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 570 33 was be VBD 35772 570 34 universally universally RB 35772 570 35 read read VBN 35772 570 36 . . . 35772 571 1 From from IN 35772 571 2 the the DT 35772 571 3 point point NN 35772 571 4 of of IN 35772 571 5 view view NN 35772 571 6 of of IN 35772 571 7 the the DT 35772 571 8 history history NN 35772 571 9 of of IN 35772 571 10 European European NNP 35772 571 11 thought think VBD 35772 571 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 571 13 importance importance NN 35772 571 14 lies lie VBZ 35772 571 15 in in IN 35772 571 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 571 17 popularisation popularisation NN 35772 571 18 in in IN 35772 571 19 France France NNP 35772 571 20 of of IN 35772 571 21 the the DT 35772 571 22 Newtonian newtonian JJ 35772 571 23 physics physics NN 35772 571 24 . . . 35772 572 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 572 2 19 19 CD 35772 572 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 572 4 _ _ NNP 35772 572 5 Newtonisme Newtonisme NNP 35772 572 6 _ _ NNP 35772 572 7 was be VBD 35772 572 8 a a DT 35772 572 9 word word NN 35772 572 10 coined coin VBN 35772 572 11 by by IN 35772 572 12 him -PRON- PRP 35772 572 13 , , , 35772 572 14 and and CC 35772 572 15 became become VBD 35772 572 16 associated associate VBN 35772 572 17 with with IN 35772 572 18 a a DT 35772 572 19 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 572 20 view view NN 35772 572 21 of of IN 35772 572 22 nature nature NN 35772 572 23 . . . 35772 573 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 573 2 also also RB 35772 573 3 conducted conduct VBD 35772 573 4 a a DT 35772 573 5 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 573 6 polemic polemic NN 35772 573 7 against against IN 35772 573 8 certain certain JJ 35772 573 9 religious religious JJ 35772 573 10 notions notion NNS 35772 573 11 , , , 35772 573 12 then then RB 35772 573 13 current current JJ 35772 573 14 , , , 35772 573 15 but but CC 35772 573 16 now now RB 35772 573 17 out out RB 35772 573 18 - - HYPH 35772 573 19 of of IN 35772 573 20 - - HYPH 35772 573 21 date date NN 35772 573 22 , , , 35772 573 23 and and CC 35772 573 24 which which WDT 35772 573 25 need need VBP 35772 573 26 not not RB 35772 573 27 here here RB 35772 573 28 detain detain VB 35772 573 29 us -PRON- PRP 35772 573 30 . . . 35772 574 1 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 574 2 was be VBD 35772 574 3 an an DT 35772 574 4 anti anti JJ 35772 574 5 - - JJ 35772 574 6 clerical clerical JJ 35772 574 7 , , , 35772 574 8 but but CC 35772 574 9 he -PRON- PRP 35772 574 10 was be VBD 35772 574 11 not not RB 35772 574 12 hostile hostile JJ 35772 574 13 to to IN 35772 574 14 religion religion NN 35772 574 15 ; ; : 35772 574 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 574 17 was be VBD 35772 574 18 chiefly chiefly RB 35772 574 19 regarded regard VBN 35772 574 20 as as IN 35772 574 21 an an DT 35772 574 22 exponent exponent NN 35772 574 23 of of IN 35772 574 24 English English NNP 35772 574 25 ( ( -LRB- 35772 574 26 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 575 1 progressive progressive NNP 35772 575 2 ) ) -RRB- 35772 575 3 ideas idea NNS 35772 575 4 . . . 35772 576 1 LA LA NNP 35772 576 2 METTRIE.--An METTRIE.--An NNP 35772 576 3 advance advance NN 35772 576 4 in in IN 35772 576 5 the the DT 35772 576 6 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 576 7 direction direction NN 35772 576 8 was be VBD 35772 576 9 taken take VBN 35772 576 10 , , , 35772 576 11 however however RB 35772 576 12 , , , 35772 576 13 by by IN 35772 576 14 La La NNP 35772 576 15 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 576 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 576 17 1709 1709 CD 35772 576 18 - - SYM 35772 576 19 1751 1751 CD 35772 576 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 576 21 , , , 35772 576 22 who who WP 35772 576 23 approached approach VBD 35772 576 24 the the DT 35772 576 25 problem problem NN 35772 576 26 from from IN 35772 576 27 the the DT 35772 576 28 side side NN 35772 576 29 of of IN 35772 576 30 physiology physiology NN 35772 576 31 ( ( -LRB- 35772 576 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 576 33 was be VBD 35772 576 34 a a DT 35772 576 35 physician physician NN 35772 576 36 by by IN 35772 576 37 profession profession NN 35772 576 38 ) ) -RRB- 35772 576 39 . . . 35772 577 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 577 2 two two CD 35772 577 3 important important JJ 35772 577 4 contributions contribution NNS 35772 577 5 were be VBD 35772 577 6 _ _ NNP 35772 577 7 Histoire Histoire NNP 35772 577 8 naturelle naturelle NN 35772 577 9 de de NNP 35772 577 10 l'âme l'âme NNP 35772 577 11 _ _ NNP 35772 577 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 577 13 1745 1745 CD 35772 577 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 577 15 , , , 35772 577 16 and and CC 35772 577 17 _ _ NNP 35772 577 18 L'Homme L'Homme NNP 35772 577 19 Machine Machine NNP 35772 577 20 _ _ NNP 35772 577 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 577 22 1748 1748 CD 35772 577 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 577 24 . . . 35772 578 1 The the DT 35772 578 2 titles title NNS 35772 578 3 are be VBP 35772 578 4 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 578 5 to to TO 35772 578 6 indicate indicate VB 35772 578 7 the the DT 35772 578 8 scope scope NN 35772 578 9 of of IN 35772 578 10 these these DT 35772 578 11 works work NNS 35772 578 12 . . . 35772 579 1 That that DT 35772 579 2 of of IN 35772 579 3 the the DT 35772 579 4 latter latter JJ 35772 579 5 points point NNS 35772 579 6 back back RB 35772 579 7 to to IN 35772 579 8 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 579 9 , , , 35772 579 10 who who WP 35772 579 11 had have VBD 35772 579 12 applied apply VBN 35772 579 13 the the DT 35772 579 14 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 579 15 theory theory NN 35772 579 16 to to IN 35772 579 17 animals animal NNS 35772 579 18 only only RB 35772 579 19 , , , 35772 579 20 and and CC 35772 579 21 not not RB 35772 579 22 to to TO 35772 579 23 man man VB 35772 579 24 . . . 35772 580 1 La La NNP 35772 580 2 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 580 3 extended extend VBD 35772 580 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 580 5 application application NN 35772 580 6 to to TO 35772 580 7 include include VB 35772 580 8 man man NN 35772 580 9 . . . 35772 581 1 The the DT 35772 581 2 implications implication NNS 35772 581 3 of of IN 35772 581 4 this this DT 35772 581 5 theory theory NN 35772 581 6 did do VBD 35772 581 7 not not RB 35772 581 8 escape escape VB 35772 581 9 La La NNP 35772 581 10 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 581 11 's 's POS 35772 581 12 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 581 13 . . . 35772 582 1 DIDEROT diderot UH 35772 582 2 AND and CC 35772 582 3 HIS his PRP$ 35772 582 4 ENCYCLOPÆDIA.--A encyclopædia.--a CD 35772 582 5 definite definite JJ 35772 582 6 period period NN 35772 582 7 in in IN 35772 582 8 the the DT 35772 582 9 history history NN 35772 582 10 of of IN 35772 582 11 thought thought NN 35772 582 12 is be VBZ 35772 582 13 certainly certainly RB 35772 582 14 marked mark VBN 35772 582 15 by by IN 35772 582 16 the the DT 35772 582 17 successful successful JJ 35772 582 18 attempt attempt NN 35772 582 19 on on IN 35772 582 20 the the DT 35772 582 21 part part NN 35772 582 22 of of IN 35772 582 23 a a DT 35772 582 24 group group NN 35772 582 25 of of IN 35772 582 26 progressive progressive JJ 35772 582 27 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 582 28 , , , 35772 582 29 to to TO 35772 582 30 extend extend VB 35772 582 31 the the DT 35772 582 32 circle circle NN 35772 582 33 open open JJ 35772 582 34 to to IN 35772 582 35 scientific scientific JJ 35772 582 36 ideas idea NNS 35772 582 37 by by IN 35772 582 38 the the DT 35772 582 39 publication publication NN 35772 582 40 of of IN 35772 582 41 an an DT 35772 582 42 Encyclopædia Encyclopædia NNP 35772 582 43 which which WDT 35772 582 44 should should MD 35772 582 45 contain contain VB 35772 582 46 all all PDT 35772 582 47 the the DT 35772 582 48 latest late JJS 35772 582 49 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 582 50 and and CC 35772 582 51 speculation speculation NN 35772 582 52 . . . 35772 583 1 The the DT 35772 583 2 credit credit NN 35772 583 3 for for IN 35772 583 4 this this DT 35772 583 5 notable notable JJ 35772 583 6 performance performance NN 35772 583 7 was be VBD 35772 583 8 due due JJ 35772 583 9 to to IN 35772 583 10 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 583 11 , , , 35772 583 12 who who WP 35772 583 13 in in IN 35772 583 14 spite spite NN 35772 583 15 of of IN 35772 583 16 immense immense JJ 35772 583 17 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 583 18 , , , 35772 583 19 which which WDT 35772 583 20 were be VBD 35772 583 21 aggravated aggravate VBN 35772 583 22 by by IN 35772 583 23 the the DT 35772 583 24 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 35772 583 25 authorities authority NNS 35772 583 26 and and CC 35772 583 27 the the DT 35772 583 28 supporters supporter NNS 35772 583 29 of of IN 35772 583 30 reaction reaction NN 35772 583 31 in in IN 35772 583 32 general general JJ 35772 583 33 , , , 35772 583 34 carried carry VBD 35772 583 35 the the DT 35772 583 36 work work NN 35772 583 37 through through RP 35772 583 38 to to IN 35772 583 39 a a DT 35772 583 40 triumphant triumphant JJ 35772 583 41 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 583 42 . . . 35772 584 1 The the DT 35772 584 2 first first JJ 35772 584 3 volume volume NN 35772 584 4 appeared appear VBD 35772 584 5 in in IN 35772 584 6 1751 1751 CD 35772 584 7 . . . 35772 585 1 The the DT 35772 585 2 work work NN 35772 585 3 was be VBD 35772 585 4 composed compose VBN 35772 585 5 with with IN 35772 585 6 an an DT 35772 585 7 eye eye NN 35772 585 8 to to IN 35772 585 9 current current JJ 35772 585 10 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 585 11 ; ; : 35772 585 12 the the DT 35772 585 13 language language NN 35772 585 14 was be VBD 35772 585 15 guarded guard VBN 35772 585 16 , , , 35772 585 17 but but CC 35772 585 18 the the DT 35772 585 19 anti anti JJ 35772 585 20 - - JJ 35772 585 21 clerical clerical JJ 35772 585 22 tendency tendency NN 35772 585 23 of of IN 35772 585 24 the the DT 35772 585 25 whole whole NN 35772 585 26 was be VBD 35772 585 27 by by IN 35772 585 28 no no DT 35772 585 29 means means NN 35772 585 30 obscure obscure JJ 35772 585 31 . . . 35772 586 1 Diderot Diderot NNS 35772 586 2 , , , 35772 586 3 however however RB 35772 586 4 , , , 35772 586 5 did do VBD 35772 586 6 not not RB 35772 586 7 obtrude obtrude VB 35772 586 8 in in IN 35772 586 9 the the DT 35772 586 10 Encyclopædia Encyclopædia NNP 35772 586 11 the the DT 35772 586 12 definitely definitely RB 35772 586 13 anti anti JJ 35772 586 14 - - JJ 35772 586 15 religious religious JJ 35772 586 16 opinions opinion NNS 35772 586 17 which which WDT 35772 586 18 he -PRON- PRP 35772 586 19 had have VBD 35772 586 20 developed develop VBN 35772 586 21 and and CC 35772 586 22 which which WDT 35772 586 23 are be VBP 35772 586 24 revealed reveal VBN 35772 586 25 in in IN 35772 586 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 586 27 correspondence correspondence NN 35772 586 28 . . . 35772 587 1 HOLBACH.--A holbach.--a UH 35772 587 2 disciple disciple NN 35772 587 3 of of IN 35772 587 4 the the DT 35772 587 5 Encyclopædist Encyclopædist NNP 35772 587 6 -- -- : 35772 587 7 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 587 8 , , , 35772 587 9 a a DT 35772 587 10 young young JJ 35772 587 11 German German NNP 35772 587 12 settled settle VBN 35772 587 13 in in IN 35772 587 14 Paris Paris NNP 35772 587 15 -- -- : 35772 587 16 was be VBD 35772 587 17 bolder bold JJR 35772 587 18 than than IN 35772 587 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 587 20 master master NN 35772 587 21 , , , 35772 587 22 and and CC 35772 587 23 published publish VBN 35772 587 24 , , , 35772 587 25 under under IN 35772 587 26 the the DT 35772 587 27 name name NN 35772 587 28 of of IN 35772 587 29 a a DT 35772 587 30 savant savant JJ 35772 587 31 who who WP 35772 587 32 had have VBD 35772 587 33 recently recently RB 35772 587 34 died die VBN 35772 587 35 , , , 35772 587 36 a a DT 35772 587 37 book book NN 35772 587 38 which which WDT 35772 587 39 became become VBD 35772 587 40 widely widely RB 35772 587 41 notorious notorious JJ 35772 587 42 , , , 35772 587 43 and and CC 35772 587 44 has have VBZ 35772 587 45 been be VBN 35772 587 46 called call VBN 35772 587 47 the the DT 35772 587 48 Bible Bible NNP 35772 587 49 of of IN 35772 587 50 materialism materialism NN 35772 587 51 -- -- : 35772 587 52 the the DT 35772 587 53 _ _ NNP 35772 587 54 Système Système NNP 35772 587 55 de de NNP 35772 587 56 la la NNP 35772 587 57 Nature Nature NNP 35772 587 58 _ _ NNP 35772 587 59 ( ( -LRB- 35772 587 60 1770 1770 CD 35772 587 61 ) ) -RRB- 35772 587 62 . . . 35772 588 1 Like like IN 35772 588 2 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 588 3 's 's POS 35772 588 4 _ _ NNP 35772 588 5 Élémens Élémens NNP 35772 588 6 _ _ NNP 35772 588 7 , , , 35772 588 8 and and CC 35772 588 9 La La NNP 35772 588 10 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 588 11 's 's POS 35772 588 12 _ _ NNP 35772 588 13 L'Homme L'Homme NNP 35772 588 14 Machine Machine NNP 35772 588 15 _ _ NNP 35772 588 16 , , , 35772 588 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 588 18 was be VBD 35772 588 19 published publish VBN 35772 588 20 in in IN 35772 588 21 Holland Holland NNP 35772 588 22 . . . 35772 589 1 " " `` 35772 589 2 The the DT 35772 589 3 book book NN 35772 589 4 is be VBZ 35772 589 5 materialism materialism NN 35772 589 6 reduced reduce VBN 35772 589 7 to to IN 35772 589 8 a a DT 35772 589 9 system system NN 35772 589 10 . . . 35772 590 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 590 2 contains contain VBZ 35772 590 3 no no DT 35772 590 4 really really RB 35772 590 5 new new JJ 35772 590 6 thoughts thought NNS 35772 590 7 . . . 35772 591 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 591 2 significance significance NN 35772 591 3 lies lie VBZ 35772 591 4 in in IN 35772 591 5 the the DT 35772 591 6 energy energy NN 35772 591 7 and and CC 35772 591 8 indignation indignation NN 35772 591 9 with with IN 35772 591 10 which which WDT 35772 591 11 every every DT 35772 591 12 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 35772 591 13 and and CC 35772 591 14 dualistic dualistic JJ 35772 591 15 view view NN 35772 591 16 was be VBD 35772 591 17 run run VBN 35772 591 18 to to IN 35772 591 19 earth earth NN 35772 591 20 on on IN 35772 591 21 account account NN 35772 591 22 of of IN 35772 591 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 591 24 injuriousness injuriousness NN 35772 591 25 both both CC 35772 591 26 in in IN 35772 591 27 practice practice NN 35772 591 28 and and CC 35772 591 29 in in IN 35772 591 30 theory,"[20 theory,"[20 CD 35772 591 31 ] ] -RRB- 35772 591 32 is be VBZ 35772 591 33 the the DT 35772 591 34 estimate estimate NN 35772 591 35 of of IN 35772 591 36 a a DT 35772 591 37 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 591 38 and and CC 35772 591 39 impartial impartial JJ 35772 591 40 writer writer NN 35772 591 41 . . . 35772 592 1 Rumour Rumour NNP 35772 592 2 gave give VBD 35772 592 3 the the DT 35772 592 4 credit credit NN 35772 592 5 of of IN 35772 592 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 592 7 authorship authorship NN 35772 592 8 to to IN 35772 592 9 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 592 10 , , , 35772 592 11 who who WP 35772 592 12 was be VBD 35772 592 13 so so RB 35772 592 14 disturbed disturb VBN 35772 592 15 by by IN 35772 592 16 the the DT 35772 592 17 compliment compliment NN 35772 592 18 as as IN 35772 592 19 hastily hastily RB 35772 592 20 to to TO 35772 592 21 leave leave VB 35772 592 22 Paris Paris NNP 35772 592 23 for for IN 35772 592 24 the the DT 35772 592 25 frontier frontier NN 35772 592 26 . . . 35772 593 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 593 2 admiration admiration NN 35772 593 3 of of IN 35772 593 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 593 5 is be VBZ 35772 593 6 , , , 35772 593 7 however however RB 35772 593 8 , , , 35772 593 9 recorded record VBN 35772 593 10 . . . 35772 594 1 After after IN 35772 594 2 proclaiming proclaim VBG 35772 594 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 594 4 disgust disgust NN 35772 594 5 at at IN 35772 594 6 the the DT 35772 594 7 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 594 8 fashion fashion NN 35772 594 9 of of IN 35772 594 10 " " `` 35772 594 11 mixing mix VBG 35772 594 12 up up RP 35772 594 13 incredulity incredulity NN 35772 594 14 and and CC 35772 594 15 superstition superstition NN 35772 594 16 , , , 35772 594 17 " " '' 35772 594 18 he -PRON- PRP 35772 594 19 observes observe VBZ 35772 594 20 that that IN 35772 594 21 no no DT 35772 594 22 such such JJ 35772 594 23 fault fault NN 35772 594 24 is be VBZ 35772 594 25 to to TO 35772 594 26 be be VB 35772 594 27 found find VBN 35772 594 28 in in IN 35772 594 29 the the DT 35772 594 30 _ _ NNP 35772 594 31 System System NNP 35772 594 32 of of IN 35772 594 33 Nature Nature NNP 35772 594 34 _ _ NNP 35772 594 35 . . . 35772 595 1 " " `` 35772 595 2 The the DT 35772 595 3 author author NN 35772 595 4 is be VBZ 35772 595 5 not not RB 35772 595 6 an an DT 35772 595 7 atheist atheist NN 35772 595 8 in in IN 35772 595 9 one one CD 35772 595 10 page page NN 35772 595 11 , , , 35772 595 12 and and CC 35772 595 13 a a DT 35772 595 14 deist deist NN 35772 595 15 in in IN 35772 595 16 another another DT 35772 595 17 . . . 35772 596 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 596 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 596 3 is be VBZ 35772 596 4 all all DT 35772 596 5 of of IN 35772 596 6 a a DT 35772 596 7 piece piece NN 35772 596 8 . . . 35772 596 9 " " '' 35772 597 1 Certainly certainly RB 35772 597 2 to to IN 35772 597 3 those those DT 35772 597 4 with with IN 35772 597 5 an an DT 35772 597 6 appetite appetite NN 35772 597 7 for for IN 35772 597 8 negative negative JJ 35772 597 9 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 597 10 the the DT 35772 597 11 work work NN 35772 597 12 left leave VBD 35772 597 13 nothing nothing NN 35772 597 14 to to TO 35772 597 15 be be VB 35772 597 16 desired desire VBN 35772 597 17 . . . 35772 598 1 The the DT 35772 598 2 following follow VBG 35772 598 3 passage passage NN 35772 598 4 indicates indicate VBZ 35772 598 5 the the DT 35772 598 6 attitude attitude NN 35772 598 7 and and CC 35772 598 8 method method NN 35772 598 9 of of IN 35772 598 10 the the DT 35772 598 11 author author NN 35772 598 12 , , , 35772 598 13 who who WP 35772 598 14 , , , 35772 598 15 in in IN 35772 598 16 the the DT 35772 598 17 matter matter NN 35772 598 18 of of IN 35772 598 19 style style NN 35772 598 20 , , , 35772 598 21 did do VBD 35772 598 22 not not RB 35772 598 23 fall fall VB 35772 598 24 short short RB 35772 598 25 of of IN 35772 598 26 the the DT 35772 598 27 French french JJ 35772 598 28 tradition tradition NN 35772 598 29 : : : 35772 598 30 " " `` 35772 598 31 If if IN 35772 598 32 we -PRON- PRP 35772 598 33 go go VBP 35772 598 34 back back RB 35772 598 35 to to IN 35772 598 36 the the DT 35772 598 37 beginning beginning NN 35772 598 38 , , , 35772 598 39 we -PRON- PRP 35772 598 40 shall shall MD 35772 598 41 always always RB 35772 598 42 find find VB 35772 598 43 that that DT 35772 598 44 ignorance ignorance NN 35772 598 45 and and CC 35772 598 46 fear fear NN 35772 598 47 have have VBP 35772 598 48 created create VBN 35772 598 49 gods god NNS 35772 598 50 ; ; , 35772 598 51 fancy fancy JJ 35772 598 52 , , , 35772 598 53 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 35772 598 54 or or CC 35772 598 55 deceit deceit NN 35772 598 56 has have VBZ 35772 598 57 adorned adorn VBN 35772 598 58 or or CC 35772 598 59 disfigured disfigure VBN 35772 598 60 them -PRON- PRP 35772 598 61 ; ; : 35772 598 62 weakness weakness NN 35772 598 63 worships worship VBZ 35772 598 64 them -PRON- PRP 35772 598 65 ; ; : 35772 598 66 credulity credulity NN 35772 598 67 preserves preserve NNS 35772 598 68 them -PRON- PRP 35772 598 69 in in IN 35772 598 70 life life NN 35772 598 71 ; ; , 35772 598 72 custom custom NN 35772 598 73 regards regard VBZ 35772 598 74 them -PRON- PRP 35772 598 75 , , , 35772 598 76 and and CC 35772 598 77 tyranny tyranny NN 35772 598 78 supports support VBZ 35772 598 79 them -PRON- PRP 35772 598 80 in in IN 35772 598 81 order order NN 35772 598 82 to to TO 35772 598 83 make make VB 35772 598 84 the the DT 35772 598 85 blindness blindness NN 35772 598 86 of of IN 35772 598 87 men man NNS 35772 598 88 serve serve VBP 35772 598 89 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 598 90 own own JJ 35772 598 91 ends end NNS 35772 598 92 . . . 35772 598 93 " " '' 35772 599 1 The the DT 35772 599 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 599 3 of of IN 35772 599 4 religion religion NN 35772 599 5 which which WDT 35772 599 6 inspired inspire VBD 35772 599 7 these these DT 35772 599 8 sentences sentence NNS 35772 599 9 may may MD 35772 599 10 appear appear VB 35772 599 11 to to IN 35772 599 12 us -PRON- PRP 35772 599 13 sufficiently sufficiently RB 35772 599 14 crude crude JJ 35772 599 15 . . . 35772 600 1 And and CC 35772 600 2 indeed indeed RB 35772 600 3 an an DT 35772 600 4 impartial impartial JJ 35772 600 5 reader reader NN 35772 600 6 will will MD 35772 600 7 have have VB 35772 600 8 to to TO 35772 600 9 confess confess VB 35772 600 10 that that IN 35772 600 11 much much JJ 35772 600 12 of of IN 35772 600 13 this this DT 35772 600 14 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 600 15 century century NN 35772 600 16 polemic polemic NN 35772 600 17 against against IN 35772 600 18 religion religion NN 35772 600 19 , , , 35772 600 20 however however RB 35772 600 21 well well RB 35772 600 22 - - HYPH 35772 600 23 intentioned intentione VBN 35772 600 24 , , , 35772 600 25 is be VBZ 35772 600 26 singularly singularly RB 35772 600 27 wide wide JJ 35772 600 28 of of IN 35772 600 29 the the DT 35772 600 30 mark mark NN 35772 600 31 . . . 35772 601 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 601 2 is be VBZ 35772 601 3 all all RB 35772 601 4 characterised characterise VBN 35772 601 5 by by IN 35772 601 6 an an DT 35772 601 7 imperfect imperfect JJ 35772 601 8 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 601 9 of of IN 35772 601 10 the the DT 35772 601 11 psychological psychological JJ 35772 601 12 foundations foundation NNS 35772 601 13 of of IN 35772 601 14 religion religion NN 35772 601 15 , , , 35772 601 16 and and CC 35772 601 17 quite quite RB 35772 601 18 devoid devoid JJ 35772 601 19 of of IN 35772 601 20 what what WP 35772 601 21 is be VBZ 35772 601 22 now now RB 35772 601 23 termed term VBN 35772 601 24 the the DT 35772 601 25 " " `` 35772 601 26 historic historic JJ 35772 601 27 sense sense NN 35772 601 28 . . . 35772 601 29 " " '' 35772 602 1 The the DT 35772 602 2 faults fault NNS 35772 602 3 of of IN 35772 602 4 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 602 5 and and CC 35772 602 6 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 602 7 , , , 35772 602 8 however however RB 35772 602 9 , , , 35772 602 10 were be VBD 35772 602 11 those those DT 35772 602 12 of of IN 35772 602 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 602 14 age age NN 35772 602 15 , , , 35772 602 16 which which WDT 35772 602 17 was be VBD 35772 602 18 often often RB 35772 602 19 short short JJ 35772 602 20 - - HYPH 35772 602 21 sighted sighted JJ 35772 602 22 in in IN 35772 602 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 602 24 recognition recognition NN 35772 602 25 of of IN 35772 602 26 facts fact NNS 35772 602 27 , , , 35772 602 28 and and CC 35772 602 29 superficial superficial JJ 35772 602 30 in in IN 35772 602 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 602 32 reasoning reasoning NN 35772 602 33 from from IN 35772 602 34 them -PRON- PRP 35772 602 35 . . . 35772 603 1 Even even RB 35772 603 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 35772 603 3 Johnson Johnson NNP 35772 603 4 , , , 35772 603 5 who who WP 35772 603 6 found find VBD 35772 603 7 this this DT 35772 603 8 section section NN 35772 603 9 of of IN 35772 603 10 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 603 11 French french JJ 35772 603 12 literature literature NN 35772 603 13 so so RB 35772 603 14 distasteful distasteful JJ 35772 603 15 , , , 35772 603 16 never never RB 35772 603 17 laid lay VBD 35772 603 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 603 19 finger finger NN 35772 603 20 upon upon IN 35772 603 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 603 22 real real JJ 35772 603 23 weakness weakness NN 35772 603 24 ; ; : 35772 603 25 the the DT 35772 603 26 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 603 27 fallacies fallacy NNS 35772 603 28 upon upon IN 35772 603 29 which which WDT 35772 603 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 603 31 rested rest VBD 35772 603 32 escaped escape VBD 35772 603 33 him -PRON- PRP 35772 603 34 . . . 35772 604 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 604 2 , , , 35772 604 3 like like IN 35772 604 4 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 604 5 and and CC 35772 604 6 the the DT 35772 604 7 rest rest NN 35772 604 8 , , , 35772 604 9 was be VBD 35772 604 10 a a DT 35772 604 11 child child NN 35772 604 12 of of IN 35772 604 13 the the DT 35772 604 14 age age NN 35772 604 15 . . . 35772 605 1 PROPAGANDA PROPAGANDA NNP 35772 605 2 NOT NOT NNP 35772 605 3 SCIENCE.--It SCIENCE.--It NNP 35772 605 4 is be VBZ 35772 605 5 very very RB 35772 605 6 doubtful doubtful JJ 35772 605 7 whether whether IN 35772 605 8 the the DT 35772 605 9 genuine genuine JJ 35772 605 10 scientists scientist NNS 35772 605 11 , , , 35772 605 12 who who WP 35772 605 13 devoted devote VBD 35772 605 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 605 15 not not RB 35772 605 16 to to IN 35772 605 17 propaganda propaganda NN 35772 605 18 but but CC 35772 605 19 to to IN 35772 605 20 research research NN 35772 605 21 , , , 35772 605 22 could could MD 35772 605 23 have have VB 35772 605 24 been be VBN 35772 605 25 ready ready JJ 35772 605 26 to to TO 35772 605 27 sanction sanction VB 35772 605 28 the the DT 35772 605 29 uses use NNS 35772 605 30 to to TO 35772 605 31 which which WDT 35772 605 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 605 33 own own JJ 35772 605 34 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 605 35 were be VBD 35772 605 36 put put VBN 35772 605 37 . . . 35772 606 1 From from IN 35772 606 2 the the DT 35772 606 3 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 35772 606 4 references reference NNS 35772 606 5 of of IN 35772 606 6 Lange Lange NNP 35772 606 7 in in IN 35772 606 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 606 9 _ _ NNP 35772 606 10 History history NN 35772 606 11 of of IN 35772 606 12 Materialism Materialism NNP 35772 606 13 _ _ NNP 35772 606 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 606 15 Engl Engl NNP 35772 606 16 . . . 35772 607 1 Trans Trans NNP 35772 607 2 . . NNP 35772 607 3 , , , 35772 607 4 Vol Vol NNP 35772 607 5 . . . 35772 608 1 II II NNP 35772 608 2 , , , 35772 608 3 pp pp NNP 35772 608 4 . . . 35772 609 1 49 49 CD 35772 609 2 - - SYM 35772 609 3 123 123 CD 35772 609 4 ) ) -RRB- 35772 609 5 , , , 35772 609 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 609 7 is be VBZ 35772 609 8 evident evident JJ 35772 609 9 that that IN 35772 609 10 " " `` 35772 609 11 the the DT 35772 609 12 extreme extreme JJ 35772 609 13 views view NNS 35772 609 14 of of IN 35772 609 15 La La NNP 35772 609 16 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 609 17 , , , 35772 609 18 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 609 19 , , , 35772 609 20 and and CC 35772 609 21 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 609 22 can can MD 35772 609 23 not not RB 35772 609 24 be be VB 35772 609 25 fathered father VBN 35772 609 26 on on IN 35772 609 27 any any DT 35772 609 28 of of IN 35772 609 29 the the DT 35772 609 30 great great JJ 35772 609 31 scientists scientist NNS 35772 609 32 or or CC 35772 609 33 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 609 34 , , , 35772 609 35 but but CC 35772 609 36 were be VBD 35772 609 37 an an DT 35772 609 38 attempt attempt NN 35772 609 39 to to TO 35772 609 40 supply supply VB 35772 609 41 scientific scientific JJ 35772 609 42 principles principle NNS 35772 609 43 to to IN 35772 609 44 the the DT 35772 609 45 solution solution NN 35772 609 46 of of IN 35772 609 47 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 609 48 , , , 35772 609 49 ethical ethical JJ 35772 609 50 , , , 35772 609 51 or or CC 35772 609 52 religious religious JJ 35772 609 53 questions question NNS 35772 609 54 , , , 35772 609 55 frequently frequently RB 35772 609 56 for for IN 35772 609 57 practical practical JJ 35772 609 58 and and CC 35772 609 59 political political JJ 35772 609 60 purposes purpose NNS 35772 609 61 . . . 35772 610 1 " " `` 35772 610 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 610 3 21 21 CD 35772 610 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 610 5 There there EX 35772 610 6 are be VBP 35772 610 7 certainly certainly RB 35772 610 8 risks risk NNS 35772 610 9 attached attach VBN 35772 610 10 to to IN 35772 610 11 the the DT 35772 610 12 popularisation popularisation NN 35772 610 13 of of IN 35772 610 14 the the DT 35772 610 15 results result NNS 35772 610 16 of of IN 35772 610 17 scientific scientific JJ 35772 610 18 research research NN 35772 610 19 . . . 35772 611 1 Theories theory NNS 35772 611 2 have have VBP 35772 611 3 to to TO 35772 611 4 be be VB 35772 611 5 presented present VBN 35772 611 6 with with IN 35772 611 7 an an DT 35772 611 8 appearance appearance NN 35772 611 9 of of IN 35772 611 10 finality finality NN 35772 611 11 which which WDT 35772 611 12 does do VBZ 35772 611 13 not not RB 35772 611 14 legitimately legitimately RB 35772 611 15 belong belong VB 35772 611 16 to to IN 35772 611 17 them -PRON- PRP 35772 611 18 , , , 35772 611 19 and and CC 35772 611 20 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 611 21 in in IN 35772 611 22 a a DT 35772 611 23 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 611 24 startling startling JJ 35772 611 25 aspect aspect NN 35772 611 26 , , , 35772 611 27 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 611 28 the the DT 35772 611 29 reader reader NN 35772 611 30 is be VBZ 35772 611 31 left leave VBN 35772 611 32 cold cold JJ 35772 611 33 , , , 35772 611 34 for for IN 35772 611 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 611 36 is be VBZ 35772 611 37 excitement excitement NN 35772 611 38 rather rather RB 35772 611 39 than than IN 35772 611 40 genuine genuine JJ 35772 611 41 information information NN 35772 611 42 that that WDT 35772 611 43 attracts attract VBZ 35772 611 44 the the DT 35772 611 45 majority majority NN 35772 611 46 . . . 35772 612 1 As as IN 35772 612 2 a a DT 35772 612 3 judicious judicious JJ 35772 612 4 writer writer NN 35772 612 5 has have VBZ 35772 612 6 observed observe VBN 35772 612 7 : : : 35772 612 8 " " `` 35772 612 9 No no DT 35772 612 10 ideas idea NNS 35772 612 11 lend lend VBP 35772 612 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 612 13 to to IN 35772 612 14 such such JJ 35772 612 15 easy easy RB 35772 612 16 , , , 35772 612 17 but but CC 35772 612 18 likewise likewise RB 35772 612 19 to to IN 35772 612 20 such such JJ 35772 612 21 shallow shallow JJ 35772 612 22 generalisations generalisation NNS 35772 612 23 as as IN 35772 612 24 those those DT 35772 612 25 of of IN 35772 612 26 science science NN 35772 612 27 . . . 35772 613 1 Once once RB 35772 613 2 let let VB 35772 613 3 out out IN 35772 613 4 of of IN 35772 613 5 the the DT 35772 613 6 hand hand NN 35772 613 7 which which WDT 35772 613 8 uses use VBZ 35772 613 9 them -PRON- PRP 35772 613 10 in in IN 35772 613 11 the the DT 35772 613 12 strict strict JJ 35772 613 13 and and CC 35772 613 14 cautious cautious JJ 35772 613 15 manner manner NN 35772 613 16 by by IN 35772 613 17 which which WDT 35772 613 18 alone alone RB 35772 613 19 they -PRON- PRP 35772 613 20 lead lead VBP 35772 613 21 to to IN 35772 613 22 valuable valuable JJ 35772 613 23 results result NNS 35772 613 24 , , , 35772 613 25 they -PRON- PRP 35772 613 26 are be VBP 35772 613 27 apt apt JJ 35772 613 28 to to IN 35772 613 29 work work NN 35772 613 30 mischief mischief NN 35772 613 31 . . . 35772 614 1 Because because IN 35772 614 2 the the DT 35772 614 3 tool tool NN 35772 614 4 is be VBZ 35772 614 5 so so RB 35772 614 6 sharp sharp JJ 35772 614 7 , , , 35772 614 8 the the DT 35772 614 9 object object NN 35772 614 10 to to TO 35772 614 11 which which WDT 35772 614 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 614 13 is be VBZ 35772 614 14 applied apply VBN 35772 614 15 seems seem VBZ 35772 614 16 to to TO 35772 614 17 be be VB 35772 614 18 so so RB 35772 614 19 easily easily RB 35772 614 20 handled handle VBN 35772 614 21 . . . 35772 615 1 The the DT 35772 615 2 correct correct JJ 35772 615 3 use use NN 35772 615 4 of of IN 35772 615 5 scientific scientific JJ 35772 615 6 ideas idea NNS 35772 615 7 is be VBZ 35772 615 8 only only RB 35772 615 9 learnt learn VBN 35772 615 10 by by IN 35772 615 11 patient patient JJ 35772 615 12 training training NN 35772 615 13 , , , 35772 615 14 and and CC 35772 615 15 should should MD 35772 615 16 be be VB 35772 615 17 governed govern VBN 35772 615 18 by by IN 35772 615 19 the the DT 35772 615 20 not not RB 35772 615 21 easily easily RB 35772 615 22 acquired acquire VBN 35772 615 23 habit habit NN 35772 615 24 of of IN 35772 615 25 self self NN 35772 615 26 - - HYPH 35772 615 27 restraint restraint NN 35772 615 28 . . . 35772 616 1 " " `` 35772 616 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 616 3 22 22 CD 35772 616 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 616 5 SCIENTIFIC scientific JJ 35772 616 6 PROGRESS.--Alongside progress.--alongside NN 35772 616 7 of of IN 35772 616 8 this this DT 35772 616 9 rigorous rigorous JJ 35772 616 10 propaganda propaganda NN 35772 616 11 , , , 35772 616 12 which which WDT 35772 616 13 prepared prepare VBD 35772 616 14 the the DT 35772 616 15 way way NN 35772 616 16 for for IN 35772 616 17 the the DT 35772 616 18 upheaval upheaval NN 35772 616 19 of of IN 35772 616 20 1789 1789 CD 35772 616 21 , , , 35772 616 22 genuine genuine JJ 35772 616 23 scientific scientific JJ 35772 616 24 progress progress NN 35772 616 25 was be VBD 35772 616 26 being be VBG 35772 616 27 made make VBN 35772 616 28 , , , 35772 616 29 especially especially RB 35772 616 30 in in IN 35772 616 31 the the DT 35772 616 32 regions region NNS 35772 616 33 of of IN 35772 616 34 Astronomy Astronomy NNP 35772 616 35 , , , 35772 616 36 Botany Botany NNP 35772 616 37 and and CC 35772 616 38 Chemistry Chemistry NNP 35772 616 39 . . . 35772 617 1 The the DT 35772 617 2 ideas idea NNS 35772 617 3 of of IN 35772 617 4 Newton Newton NNP 35772 617 5 were be VBD 35772 617 6 taken take VBN 35772 617 7 up up RP 35772 617 8 and and CC 35772 617 9 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 617 10 by by IN 35772 617 11 means mean NNS 35772 617 12 of of IN 35772 617 13 more more RBR 35772 617 14 efficient efficient JJ 35772 617 15 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 617 16 processes process NNS 35772 617 17 -- -- : 35772 617 18 especially especially RB 35772 617 19 the the DT 35772 617 20 theory theory NN 35772 617 21 of of IN 35772 617 22 infinitesimals infinitesimal NNS 35772 617 23 -- -- : 35772 617 24 by by IN 35772 617 25 the the DT 35772 617 26 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 617 27 astronomer astronomer NN 35772 617 28 , , , 35772 617 29 Laplace Laplace NNP 35772 617 30 , , , 35772 617 31 in in IN 35772 617 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 617 33 _ _ NNP 35772 617 34 Système Système NNP 35772 617 35 du du NNP 35772 617 36 Monde Monde NNP 35772 617 37 _ _ NNP 35772 617 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 617 39 1796 1796 CD 35772 617 40 ) ) -RRB- 35772 617 41 , , , 35772 617 42 and and CC 35772 617 43 in in IN 35772 617 44 the the DT 35772 617 45 successive successive JJ 35772 617 46 volumes volume NNS 35772 617 47 of of IN 35772 617 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 617 49 _ _ NNP 35772 617 50 Méchanique Méchanique NNP 35772 617 51 Céleste Céleste NNP 35772 617 52 _ _ NNP 35772 617 53 ( ( -LRB- 35772 617 54 1799 1799 CD 35772 617 55 - - SYM 35772 617 56 1825 1825 CD 35772 617 57 ) ) -RRB- 35772 617 58 , , , 35772 617 59 which which WDT 35772 617 60 has have VBZ 35772 617 61 been be VBN 35772 617 62 called call VBN 35772 617 63 a a DT 35772 617 64 new new JJ 35772 617 65 _ _ NNP 35772 617 66 Principia Principia NNP 35772 617 67 _ _ NNP 35772 617 68 . . . 35772 618 1 Important important JJ 35772 618 2 advances advance NNS 35772 618 3 in in IN 35772 618 4 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 618 5 are be VBP 35772 618 6 associated associate VBN 35772 618 7 with with IN 35772 618 8 the the DT 35772 618 9 name name NN 35772 618 10 of of IN 35772 618 11 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 618 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 618 13 1743 1743 CD 35772 618 14 - - SYM 35772 618 15 1794 1794 CD 35772 618 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 618 17 , , , 35772 618 18 who who WP 35772 618 19 introduced introduce VBD 35772 618 20 into into IN 35772 618 21 that that DT 35772 618 22 science science NN 35772 618 23 a a DT 35772 618 24 principle principle NN 35772 618 25 which which WDT 35772 618 26 has have VBZ 35772 618 27 become become VBN 35772 618 28 axiomatic axiomatic JJ 35772 618 29 , , , 35772 618 30 and and CC 35772 618 31 which which WDT 35772 618 32 to to IN 35772 618 33 - - HYPH 35772 618 34 day day NN 35772 618 35 remains remain VBZ 35772 618 36 the the DT 35772 618 37 foundation foundation NN 35772 618 38 of of IN 35772 618 39 all all DT 35772 618 40 work work NN 35772 618 41 in in IN 35772 618 42 the the DT 35772 618 43 laboratory laboratory NN 35772 618 44 . . . 35772 619 1 To to IN 35772 619 2 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 619 3 belongs belong VBZ 35772 619 4 the the DT 35772 619 5 merit merit NN 35772 619 6 of of IN 35772 619 7 introducing introduce VBG 35772 619 8 what what WP 35772 619 9 is be VBZ 35772 619 10 known know VBN 35772 619 11 as as IN 35772 619 12 the the DT 35772 619 13 " " `` 35772 619 14 quantitative quantitative JJ 35772 619 15 method method NN 35772 619 16 " " '' 35772 619 17 into into IN 35772 619 18 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 619 19 , , , 35772 619 20 and and CC 35772 619 21 thus thus RB 35772 619 22 establishing establish VBG 35772 619 23 that that IN 35772 619 24 science science NN 35772 619 25 upon upon IN 35772 619 26 the the DT 35772 619 27 exact exact JJ 35772 619 28 -- -- : 35772 619 29 that that DT 35772 619 30 is be VBZ 35772 619 31 to to TO 35772 619 32 say say VB 35772 619 33 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 619 34 -- -- : 35772 619 35 basis basis NN 35772 619 36 , , , 35772 619 37 where where WRB 35772 619 38 it -PRON- PRP 35772 619 39 now now RB 35772 619 40 rests rest VBZ 35772 619 41 and and CC 35772 619 42 putting put VBG 35772 619 43 exact exact JJ 35772 619 44 research research NN 35772 619 45 in in IN 35772 619 46 the the DT 35772 619 47 place place NN 35772 619 48 of of IN 35772 619 49 vague vague JJ 35772 619 50 reasoning reasoning NN 35772 619 51 . . . 35772 620 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 620 2 principle principle NN 35772 620 3 was be VBD 35772 620 4 that that IN 35772 620 5 _ _ NNP 35772 620 6 in in IN 35772 620 7 all all DT 35772 620 8 chemical chemical JJ 35772 620 9 combinations combination NNS 35772 620 10 and and CC 35772 620 11 reactions reaction NNS 35772 620 12 , , , 35772 620 13 the the DT 35772 620 14 total total JJ 35772 620 15 weight weight NN 35772 620 16 of of IN 35772 620 17 the the DT 35772 620 18 various various JJ 35772 620 19 ingredients ingredient NNS 35772 620 20 remains remain VBZ 35772 620 21 unchanged unchanged JJ 35772 620 22 _ _ NNP 35772 620 23 ; ; : 35772 620 24 there there EX 35772 620 25 is be VBZ 35772 620 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 620 27 in in IN 35772 620 28 spite spite NN 35772 620 29 of of IN 35772 620 30 appearances appearance NNS 35772 620 31 ) ) -RRB- 35772 620 32 neither neither CC 35772 620 33 loss loss NN 35772 620 34 nor nor CC 35772 620 35 gain gain NN 35772 620 36 of of IN 35772 620 37 actual actual JJ 35772 620 38 matter matter NN 35772 620 39 . . . 35772 621 1 " " `` 35772 621 2 The the DT 35772 621 3 quantity quantity NN 35772 621 4 of of IN 35772 621 5 matter matter NN 35772 621 6 is be VBZ 35772 621 7 the the DT 35772 621 8 same same JJ 35772 621 9 at at IN 35772 621 10 the the DT 35772 621 11 end end NN 35772 621 12 as as IN 35772 621 13 at at IN 35772 621 14 the the DT 35772 621 15 beginning beginning NN 35772 621 16 of of IN 35772 621 17 every every DT 35772 621 18 operation operation NN 35772 621 19 . . . 35772 621 20 " " '' 35772 622 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 622 2 was be VBD 35772 622 3 Lavoisier lavoisi JJR 35772 622 4 who who WP 35772 622 5 finally finally RB 35772 622 6 established establish VBD 35772 622 7 the the DT 35772 622 8 correct correct JJ 35772 622 9 theory theory NN 35772 622 10 of of IN 35772 622 11 combustion combustion NN 35772 622 12 ; ; : 35772 622 13 that that IN 35772 622 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 622 15 consisted consist VBD 35772 622 16 in in IN 35772 622 17 the the DT 35772 622 18 combination combination NN 35772 622 19 of of IN 35772 622 20 a a DT 35772 622 21 special special JJ 35772 622 22 element element NN 35772 622 23 called call VBN 35772 622 24 oxygen oxygen NN 35772 622 25 , , , 35772 622 26 with with IN 35772 622 27 other other JJ 35772 622 28 bodies body NNS 35772 622 29 or or CC 35772 622 30 elements element NNS 35772 622 31 . . . 35772 623 1 THE the DT 35772 623 2 ATOMIC ATOMIC NNP 35772 623 3 THEORY.--Lavoisier theory.--lavoisier NN 35772 623 4 had have VBD 35772 623 5 opened open VBN 35772 623 6 a a DT 35772 623 7 door door NN 35772 623 8 to to IN 35772 623 9 researches research NNS 35772 623 10 which which WDT 35772 623 11 naturally naturally RB 35772 623 12 led lead VBD 35772 623 13 the the DT 35772 623 14 way way NN 35772 623 15 to to IN 35772 623 16 the the DT 35772 623 17 establishment establishment NN 35772 623 18 of of IN 35772 623 19 the the DT 35772 623 20 atomic atomic JJ 35772 623 21 theory theory NN 35772 623 22 of of IN 35772 623 23 matter matter NN 35772 623 24 on on IN 35772 623 25 an an DT 35772 623 26 experimental experimental NN 35772 623 27 , , , 35772 623 28 and and CC 35772 623 29 not not RB 35772 623 30 merely merely RB 35772 623 31 a a DT 35772 623 32 theoretical theoretical JJ 35772 623 33 basis basis NN 35772 623 34 . . . 35772 624 1 That that DT 35772 624 2 theory theory NN 35772 624 3 is be VBZ 35772 624 4 indeed indeed RB 35772 624 5 nothing nothing NN 35772 624 6 more more JJR 35772 624 7 than than IN 35772 624 8 the the DT 35772 624 9 elaboration elaboration NN 35772 624 10 of of IN 35772 624 11 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 624 12 's 's POS 35772 624 13 own own JJ 35772 624 14 principle principle NN 35772 624 15 . . . 35772 625 1 John John NNP 35772 625 2 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 625 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 625 4 1766 1766 CD 35772 625 5 - - SYM 35772 625 6 1844 1844 CD 35772 625 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 625 8 , , , 35772 625 9 a a DT 35772 625 10 Manchester Manchester NNP 35772 625 11 quaker quaker NN 35772 625 12 , , , 35772 625 13 published publish VBN 35772 625 14 in in IN 35772 625 15 1810 1810 CD 35772 625 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 625 17 _ _ NNP 35772 625 18 New New NNP 35772 625 19 System System NNP 35772 625 20 of of IN 35772 625 21 Chemical Chemical NNP 35772 625 22 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 625 23 _ _ NNP 35772 625 24 , , , 35772 625 25 where where WRB 35772 625 26 highly highly RB 35772 625 27 important important JJ 35772 625 28 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 625 29 are be VBP 35772 625 30 drawn draw VBN 35772 625 31 both both DT 35772 625 32 from from IN 35772 625 33 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 625 34 's 's POS 35772 625 35 facts fact NNS 35772 625 36 and and CC 35772 625 37 from from IN 35772 625 38 experimental experimental JJ 35772 625 39 results result NNS 35772 625 40 of of IN 35772 625 41 other other JJ 35772 625 42 chemists chemist NNS 35772 625 43 . . . 35772 626 1 Of of IN 35772 626 2 these these DT 35772 626 3 , , , 35772 626 4 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 626 5 gave give VBD 35772 626 6 an an DT 35772 626 7 account account NN 35772 626 8 and and CC 35772 626 9 an an DT 35772 626 10 explanation explanation NN 35772 626 11 which which WDT 35772 626 12 has have VBZ 35772 626 13 ever ever RB 35772 626 14 since since IN 35772 626 15 been be VBN 35772 626 16 the the DT 35772 626 17 soul soul NN 35772 626 18 of of IN 35772 626 19 all all DT 35772 626 20 chemical chemical NN 35772 626 21 reasoning reasoning NN 35772 626 22 . . . 35772 627 1 This this DT 35772 627 2 explanation explanation NN 35772 627 3 is be VBZ 35772 627 4 known know VBN 35772 627 5 as as IN 35772 627 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 627 7 Atomic atomic JJ 35772 627 8 theory theory NN 35772 627 9 . . . 35772 628 1 The the DT 35772 628 2 two two CD 35772 628 3 facts fact NNS 35772 628 4 of of IN 35772 628 5 which which WDT 35772 628 6 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 628 7 's 's POS 35772 628 8 theory theory NN 35772 628 9 is be VBZ 35772 628 10 an an DT 35772 628 11 explanation explanation NN 35772 628 12 are be VBP 35772 628 13 as as IN 35772 628 14 follows follow VBZ 35772 628 15 . . . 35772 629 1 _ _ NNP 35772 629 2 First First NNP 35772 629 3 _ _ NNP 35772 629 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 629 5 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 629 6 's 's POS 35772 629 7 fact fact NN 35772 629 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 629 9 , , , 35772 629 10 that that IN 35772 629 11 the the DT 35772 629 12 total total JJ 35772 629 13 weight weight NN 35772 629 14 of of IN 35772 629 15 substances substance NNS 35772 629 16 remains remain VBZ 35772 629 17 always always RB 35772 629 18 the the DT 35772 629 19 same same JJ 35772 629 20 , , , 35772 629 21 be be VB 35772 629 22 they -PRON- PRP 35772 629 23 combined combine VBN 35772 629 24 in in RP 35772 629 25 ever ever RB 35772 629 26 so so RB 35772 629 27 many many JJ 35772 629 28 different different JJ 35772 629 29 ways way NNS 35772 629 30 . . . 35772 630 1 _ _ NNP 35772 630 2 Second Second NNP 35772 630 3 _ _ NNP 35772 630 4 , , , 35772 630 5 that that IN 35772 630 6 all all DT 35772 630 7 substances substance NNS 35772 630 8 , , , 35772 630 9 be be VB 35772 630 10 they -PRON- PRP 35772 630 11 in in IN 35772 630 12 large large JJ 35772 630 13 or or CC 35772 630 14 in in IN 35772 630 15 small small JJ 35772 630 16 quantities quantity NNS 35772 630 17 , , , 35772 630 18 combine combine VB 35772 630 19 with with IN 35772 630 20 each each DT 35772 630 21 other other JJ 35772 630 22 , , , 35772 630 23 or or CC 35772 630 24 separate separate JJ 35772 630 25 from from IN 35772 630 26 each each DT 35772 630 27 other other JJ 35772 630 28 , , , 35772 630 29 in in IN 35772 630 30 definite definite JJ 35772 630 31 and and CC 35772 630 32 fixed fixed JJ 35772 630 33 proportions proportion NNS 35772 630 34 . . . 35772 631 1 The the DT 35772 631 2 theory theory NN 35772 631 3 of of IN 35772 631 4 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 631 5 was be VBD 35772 631 6 that that IN 35772 631 7 these these DT 35772 631 8 combinations combination NNS 35772 631 9 take take VBP 35772 631 10 place place NN 35772 631 11 between between IN 35772 631 12 independent independent JJ 35772 631 13 particles particle NNS 35772 631 14 of of IN 35772 631 15 matter matter NN 35772 631 16 , , , 35772 631 17 which which WDT 35772 631 18 are be VBP 35772 631 19 indestructible indestructible JJ 35772 631 20 and and CC 35772 631 21 indivisible indivisible JJ 35772 631 22 . . . 35772 632 1 These these DT 35772 632 2 " " `` 35772 632 3 atoms atom NNS 35772 632 4 " " '' 35772 632 5 of of IN 35772 632 6 the the DT 35772 632 7 various various JJ 35772 632 8 elements element NNS 35772 632 9 have have VBP 35772 632 10 definite definite JJ 35772 632 11 weights weight NNS 35772 632 12 which which WDT 35772 632 13 are be VBP 35772 632 14 responsible responsible JJ 35772 632 15 for for IN 35772 632 16 the the DT 35772 632 17 proportion proportion NN 35772 632 18 in in IN 35772 632 19 which which WDT 35772 632 20 they -PRON- PRP 35772 632 21 are be VBP 35772 632 22 found find VBN 35772 632 23 to to TO 35772 632 24 combine combine VB 35772 632 25 . . . 35772 633 1 These these DT 35772 633 2 facts fact NNS 35772 633 3 of of IN 35772 633 4 proportion proportion NN 35772 633 5 in in IN 35772 633 6 combination combination NN 35772 633 7 , , , 35772 633 8 or or CC 35772 633 9 " " `` 35772 633 10 chemical chemical JJ 35772 633 11 affinity affinity NN 35772 633 12 , , , 35772 633 13 " " `` 35772 633 14 could could MD 35772 633 15 not not RB 35772 633 16 be be VB 35772 633 17 accounted account VBN 35772 633 18 for for IN 35772 633 19 by by IN 35772 633 20 the the DT 35772 633 21 theory theory NN 35772 633 22 which which WDT 35772 633 23 regards regard VBZ 35772 633 24 matter matter NN 35772 633 25 as as IN 35772 633 26 " " `` 35772 633 27 continuous continuous JJ 35772 633 28 , , , 35772 633 29 " " '' 35772 633 30 but but CC 35772 633 31 only only RB 35772 633 32 by by IN 35772 633 33 the the DT 35772 633 34 opposite opposite JJ 35772 633 35 theory theory NN 35772 633 36 that that IN 35772 633 37 it -PRON- PRP 35772 633 38 is be VBZ 35772 633 39 " " `` 35772 633 40 discrete discrete JJ 35772 633 41 " " '' 35772 633 42 ( ( -LRB- 35772 633 43 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 634 1 divided divide VBN 35772 634 2 up up RP 35772 634 3 into into IN 35772 634 4 particles particle NNS 35772 634 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 634 6 . . . 35772 635 1 PHILOSOPHICAL philosophical NN 35772 635 2 COROLLARIES.--These COROLLARIES.--These VBZ 35772 635 3 strictly strictly RB 35772 635 4 scientific scientific JJ 35772 635 5 theories theory NNS 35772 635 6 associated associate VBN 35772 635 7 with with IN 35772 635 8 the the DT 35772 635 9 name name NN 35772 635 10 of of IN 35772 635 11 Laplace Laplace NNP 35772 635 12 , , , 35772 635 13 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 635 14 , , , 35772 635 15 and and CC 35772 635 16 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 635 17 tended tend VBD 35772 635 18 to to TO 35772 635 19 strengthen strengthen VB 35772 635 20 in in IN 35772 635 21 the the DT 35772 635 22 popular popular JJ 35772 635 23 estimation estimation NN 35772 635 24 , , , 35772 635 25 the the DT 35772 635 26 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 635 27 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 635 28 of of IN 35772 635 29 writers writer NNS 35772 635 30 like like IN 35772 635 31 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 635 32 . . . 35772 636 1 The the DT 35772 636 2 scientists scientist NNS 35772 636 3 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 636 4 remained remain VBD 35772 636 5 " " `` 35772 636 6 agnostic agnostic JJ 35772 636 7 " " '' 35772 636 8 with with IN 35772 636 9 regard regard NN 35772 636 10 to to IN 35772 636 11 questions question NNS 35772 636 12 that that WDT 35772 636 13 lay lay VBP 35772 636 14 outside outside IN 35772 636 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 636 16 scope scope NN 35772 636 17 : : : 35772 636 18 they -PRON- PRP 35772 636 19 maintained maintain VBD 35772 636 20 here here RB 35772 636 21 the the DT 35772 636 22 correct correct JJ 35772 636 23 attitude attitude NN 35772 636 24 for for IN 35772 636 25 scientific scientific JJ 35772 636 26 research research NN 35772 636 27 . . . 35772 637 1 The the DT 35772 637 2 question question NN 35772 637 3 put put VBN 35772 637 4 by by IN 35772 637 5 Napoleon Napoleon NNP 35772 637 6 to to IN 35772 637 7 Laplace Laplace NNP 35772 637 8 , , , 35772 637 9 why why WRB 35772 637 10 he -PRON- PRP 35772 637 11 had have VBD 35772 637 12 not not RB 35772 637 13 introduced introduce VBN 35772 637 14 the the DT 35772 637 15 name name NN 35772 637 16 of of IN 35772 637 17 God God NNP 35772 637 18 into into IN 35772 637 19 the the DT 35772 637 20 _ _ NNP 35772 637 21 Méchanique Méchanique NNP 35772 637 22 Céleste Céleste NNP 35772 637 23 _ _ NNP 35772 637 24 , , , 35772 637 25 was be VBD 35772 637 26 out out IN 35772 637 27 of of IN 35772 637 28 place place NN 35772 637 29 , , , 35772 637 30 and and CC 35772 637 31 deserved deserve VBD 35772 637 32 the the DT 35772 637 33 crushing crushing NN 35772 637 34 reply reply NN 35772 637 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 637 36 received receive VBD 35772 637 37 . . . 35772 638 1 Scientific scientific JJ 35772 638 2 research research NN 35772 638 3 is be VBZ 35772 638 4 not not RB 35772 638 5 concerned concerned JJ 35772 638 6 with with IN 35772 638 7 questions question NNS 35772 638 8 of of IN 35772 638 9 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 638 10 . . . 35772 639 1 Still still RB 35772 639 2 , , , 35772 639 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 639 4 did do VBD 35772 639 5 not not RB 35772 639 6 escape escape VB 35772 639 7 popular popular JJ 35772 639 8 attention attention NN 35772 639 9 that that WDT 35772 639 10 the the DT 35772 639 11 old old JJ 35772 639 12 pillar pillar NN 35772 639 13 of of IN 35772 639 14 a a DT 35772 639 15 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 639 16 view view NN 35772 639 17 of of IN 35772 639 18 the the DT 35772 639 19 universe universe NN 35772 639 20 now now RB 35772 639 21 seemed seem VBD 35772 639 22 to to TO 35772 639 23 be be VB 35772 639 24 reinforced reinforce VBN 35772 639 25 by by IN 35772 639 26 another another DT 35772 639 27 . . . 35772 640 1 The the DT 35772 640 2 theory theory NN 35772 640 3 of of IN 35772 640 4 _ _ NNP 35772 640 5 the the DT 35772 640 6 conservation conservation NN 35772 640 7 of of IN 35772 640 8 energy energy NN 35772 640 9 _ _ NNP 35772 640 10 was be VBD 35772 640 11 now now RB 35772 640 12 supplemented supplement VBN 35772 640 13 by by IN 35772 640 14 that that DT 35772 640 15 of of IN 35772 640 16 the the DT 35772 640 17 _ _ NNP 35772 640 18 indestructibility indestructibility NN 35772 640 19 of of IN 35772 640 20 matter matter NN 35772 640 21 _ _ NNP 35772 640 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 640 23 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 640 24 ) ) -RRB- 35772 640 25 . . . 35772 641 1 And and CC 35772 641 2 to to TO 35772 641 3 crown crown VB 35772 641 4 all all DT 35772 641 5 , , , 35772 641 6 the the DT 35772 641 7 old old JJ 35772 641 8 atomic atomic JJ 35772 641 9 theory theory NN 35772 641 10 , , , 35772 641 11 which which WDT 35772 641 12 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 35772 641 13 had have VBD 35772 641 14 made make VBN 35772 641 15 the the DT 35772 641 16 foundation foundation NN 35772 641 17 of of IN 35772 641 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 641 19 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 641 20 materialism materialism NN 35772 641 21 , , , 35772 641 22 was be VBD 35772 641 23 now now RB 35772 641 24 re re VBN 35772 641 25 - - VBN 35772 641 26 established establish VBN 35772 641 27 on on IN 35772 641 28 an an DT 35772 641 29 experimental experimental JJ 35772 641 30 basis basis NN 35772 641 31 . . . 35772 642 1 So so RB 35772 642 2 far far RB 35772 642 3 as as IN 35772 642 4 physical physical JJ 35772 642 5 science science NN 35772 642 6 was be VBD 35772 642 7 concerned concern VBN 35772 642 8 , , , 35772 642 9 the the DT 35772 642 10 situation situation NN 35772 642 11 seemed seem VBD 35772 642 12 menacing menacing JJ 35772 642 13 to to IN 35772 642 14 a a DT 35772 642 15 religious religious JJ 35772 642 16 view view NN 35772 642 17 of of IN 35772 642 18 life life NN 35772 642 19 . . . 35772 643 1 Men man NNS 35772 643 2 felt feel VBD 35772 643 3 that that IN 35772 643 4 they -PRON- PRP 35772 643 5 inhabited inhabit VBD 35772 643 6 a a DT 35772 643 7 world world NN 35772 643 8 of of IN 35772 643 9 indestructible indestructible JJ 35772 643 10 matter matter NN 35772 643 11 , , , 35772 643 12 moved move VBN 35772 643 13 by by IN 35772 643 14 a a DT 35772 643 15 certain certain JJ 35772 643 16 measure measure NN 35772 643 17 of of IN 35772 643 18 force force NN 35772 643 19 , , , 35772 643 20 unchangeable unchangeable JJ 35772 643 21 and and CC 35772 643 22 fixed fix VBN 35772 643 23 . . . 35772 644 1 The the DT 35772 644 2 prison prison NN 35772 644 3 of of IN 35772 644 4 determinism determinism NN 35772 644 5 and and CC 35772 644 6 matter matter NN 35772 644 7 was be VBD 35772 644 8 closing close VBG 35772 644 9 around around IN 35772 644 10 them -PRON- PRP 35772 644 11 . . . 35772 645 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 645 2 VI VI NNP 35772 645 3 RISE RISE NNP 35772 645 4 OF of IN 35772 645 5 GERMAN GERMAN NNP 35772 645 6 IDEALISM IDEALISM NNP 35772 645 7 AN an DT 35772 645 8 UNSTEMMED unstemmed NN 35772 645 9 TIDE.--In TIDE.--In NNP 35772 645 10 spite spite NN 35772 645 11 of of IN 35772 645 12 those those DT 35772 645 13 important important JJ 35772 645 14 reactions reaction NNS 35772 645 15 of of IN 35772 645 16 thought thought NN 35772 645 17 which which WDT 35772 645 18 we -PRON- PRP 35772 645 19 have have VBP 35772 645 20 associated associate VBN 35772 645 21 with with IN 35772 645 22 the the DT 35772 645 23 name name NN 35772 645 24 of of IN 35772 645 25 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 645 26 , , , 35772 645 27 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 645 28 , , , 35772 645 29 and and CC 35772 645 30 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 645 31 , , , 35772 645 32 the the DT 35772 645 33 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 645 34 view view NN 35772 645 35 had have VBD 35772 645 36 not not RB 35772 645 37 ceased cease VBN 35772 645 38 , , , 35772 645 39 as as IN 35772 645 40 the the DT 35772 645 41 last last JJ 35772 645 42 chapter chapter NN 35772 645 43 has have VBZ 35772 645 44 shown show VBN 35772 645 45 us -PRON- PRP 35772 645 46 , , , 35772 645 47 to to TO 35772 645 48 extend extend VB 35772 645 49 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 645 50 during during IN 35772 645 51 the the DT 35772 645 52 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 645 53 century century NN 35772 645 54 , , , 35772 645 55 when when WRB 35772 645 56 it -PRON- PRP 35772 645 57 became become VBD 35772 645 58 highly highly RB 35772 645 59 fashionable fashionable JJ 35772 645 60 in in IN 35772 645 61 progressive progressive JJ 35772 645 62 circles circle NNS 35772 645 63 . . . 35772 646 1 COMMON COMMON NNP 35772 646 2 - - HYPH 35772 646 3 SENSE SENSE NNP 35772 646 4 PHILOSOPHY.--The philosophy.--the JJ 35772 646 5 strength strength NN 35772 646 6 of of IN 35772 646 7 this this DT 35772 646 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 646 9 view view NN 35772 646 10 lies lie VBZ 35772 646 11 in in IN 35772 646 12 the the DT 35772 646 13 fact fact NN 35772 646 14 that that IN 35772 646 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 646 16 stands stand VBZ 35772 646 17 on on IN 35772 646 18 the the DT 35772 646 19 shoulders shoulder NNS 35772 646 20 of of IN 35772 646 21 a a DT 35772 646 22 natural natural JJ 35772 646 23 science science NN 35772 646 24 which which WDT 35772 646 25 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 646 26 has have VBZ 35772 646 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 646 28 feet foot NNS 35772 646 29 firmly firmly RB 35772 646 30 planted plant VBN 35772 646 31 on on IN 35772 646 32 the the DT 35772 646 33 irrefragible irrefragible JJ 35772 646 34 rock rock NN 35772 646 35 of of IN 35772 646 36 sense sense NN 35772 646 37 - - HYPH 35772 646 38 experience experience NN 35772 646 39 . . . 35772 647 1 The the DT 35772 647 2 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 647 3 view view NN 35772 647 4 thus thus RB 35772 647 5 rests rest VBZ 35772 647 6 , , , 35772 647 7 in in IN 35772 647 8 the the DT 35772 647 9 last last JJ 35772 647 10 resort resort NN 35772 647 11 , , , 35772 647 12 upon upon IN 35772 647 13 the the DT 35772 647 14 belief belief NN 35772 647 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 647 16 which which WDT 35772 647 17 is be VBZ 35772 647 18 held hold VBN 35772 647 19 everywhere everywhere RB 35772 647 20 with with IN 35772 647 21 confidence confidence NN 35772 647 22 by by IN 35772 647 23 plain plain JJ 35772 647 24 men man NNS 35772 647 25 ) ) -RRB- 35772 647 26 that that WDT 35772 647 27 sense sense NN 35772 647 28 - - HYPH 35772 647 29 experience experience NN 35772 647 30 is be VBZ 35772 647 31 a a DT 35772 647 32 sound sound JJ 35772 647 33 foundation foundation NN 35772 647 34 for for IN 35772 647 35 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 647 36 . . . 35772 648 1 The the DT 35772 648 2 importance importance NN 35772 648 3 of of IN 35772 648 4 this this DT 35772 648 5 belief belief NN 35772 648 6 had have VBD 35772 648 7 been be VBN 35772 648 8 recognised recognise VBN 35772 648 9 by by IN 35772 648 10 the the DT 35772 648 11 English english JJ 35772 648 12 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 648 13 , , , 35772 648 14 Locke Locke NNP 35772 648 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 648 16 1632 1632 CD 35772 648 17 - - SYM 35772 648 18 1704 1704 CD 35772 648 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 648 20 , , , 35772 648 21 who who WP 35772 648 22 in in IN 35772 648 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 648 24 _ _ NNP 35772 648 25 Essay Essay NNP 35772 648 26 concerning concern VBG 35772 648 27 Human Human NNP 35772 648 28 Understanding Understanding NNP 35772 648 29 _ _ NNP 35772 648 30 ( ( -LRB- 35772 648 31 1690 1690 CD 35772 648 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 648 33 , , , 35772 648 34 lays lay VBZ 35772 648 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 648 36 down down IN 35772 648 37 that that IN 35772 648 38 all all DT 35772 648 39 human human JJ 35772 648 40 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 648 41 is be VBZ 35772 648 42 based base VBN 35772 648 43 , , , 35772 648 44 ultimately ultimately RB 35772 648 45 , , , 35772 648 46 upon upon IN 35772 648 47 sense sense NN 35772 648 48 - - HYPH 35772 648 49 experience experience NN 35772 648 50 . . . 35772 649 1 This this DT 35772 649 2 highly highly RB 35772 649 3 important important JJ 35772 649 4 work work NN 35772 649 5 had have VBD 35772 649 6 an an DT 35772 649 7 immense immense JJ 35772 649 8 influence influence NN 35772 649 9 , , , 35772 649 10 and and CC 35772 649 11 , , , 35772 649 12 under under IN 35772 649 13 Locke Locke NNP 35772 649 14 's 's POS 35772 649 15 tutelage tutelage NN 35772 649 16 , , , 35772 649 17 many many JJ 35772 649 18 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 649 19 regarded regard VBD 35772 649 20 with with IN 35772 649 21 suspicion suspicion NN 35772 649 22 any any DT 35772 649 23 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 649 24 which which WDT 35772 649 25 might may MD 35772 649 26 seem seem VB 35772 649 27 not not RB 35772 649 28 to to TO 35772 649 29 be be VB 35772 649 30 derivable derivable JJ 35772 649 31 , , , 35772 649 32 in in IN 35772 649 33 one one CD 35772 649 34 way way NN 35772 649 35 or or CC 35772 649 36 another another DT 35772 649 37 , , , 35772 649 38 from from IN 35772 649 39 that that DT 35772 649 40 source source NN 35772 649 41 . . . 35772 650 1 As as IN 35772 650 2 the the DT 35772 650 3 strength strength NN 35772 650 4 of of IN 35772 650 5 Samson Samson NNP 35772 650 6 lay lie VBD 35772 650 7 in in IN 35772 650 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 650 9 unshorn unshorn JJ 35772 650 10 hair hair NN 35772 650 11 , , , 35772 650 12 so so CC 35772 650 13 the the DT 35772 650 14 strength strength NN 35772 650 15 of of IN 35772 650 16 the the DT 35772 650 17 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 650 18 theory theory NN 35772 650 19 lay lie VBD 35772 650 20 , , , 35772 650 21 and and CC 35772 650 22 still still RB 35772 650 23 lies lie VBZ 35772 650 24 , , , 35772 650 25 in in IN 35772 650 26 the the DT 35772 650 27 acceptance acceptance NN 35772 650 28 of of IN 35772 650 29 Locke Locke NNP 35772 650 30 's 's POS 35772 650 31 theory theory NN 35772 650 32 of of IN 35772 650 33 human human JJ 35772 650 34 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 650 35 , , , 35772 650 36 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 651 1 that that IN 35772 651 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 651 3 is be VBZ 35772 651 4 all all DT 35772 651 5 derived derive VBN 35772 651 6 from from IN 35772 651 7 the the DT 35772 651 8 senses sense NNS 35772 651 9 . . . 35772 652 1 And and CC 35772 652 2 the the DT 35772 652 3 Delilah Delilah NNP 35772 652 4 who who WP 35772 652 5 can can MD 35772 652 6 shear shear VB 35772 652 7 away away RB 35772 652 8 Locke Locke NNP 35772 652 9 's 's POS 35772 652 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 652 11 , , , 35772 652 12 leaves leave VBZ 35772 652 13 Samson Samson NNP 35772 652 14 helpless helpless NN 35772 652 15 ; ; : 35772 652 16 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 652 17 materialism materialism NN 35772 652 18 becomes become VBZ 35772 652 19 a a DT 35772 652 20 discredited discredited JJ 35772 652 21 theory theory NN 35772 652 22 . . . 35772 653 1 Hence hence RB 35772 653 2 the the DT 35772 653 3 truth truth NN 35772 653 4 of of IN 35772 653 5 the the DT 35772 653 6 saying saying NN 35772 653 7 that that IN 35772 653 8 the the DT 35772 653 9 problem problem NN 35772 653 10 of of IN 35772 653 11 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 653 12 is be VBZ 35772 653 13 the the DT 35772 653 14 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 653 15 question question NN 35772 653 16 for for IN 35772 653 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 653 18 . . . 35772 654 1 WEAKNESS weakness NN 35772 654 2 OF of IN 35772 654 3 SPECULATIVE speculative JJ 35772 654 4 PHILOSOPHY.--Spinoza philosophy.--spinoza NN 35772 654 5 and and CC 35772 654 6 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 654 7 may may MD 35772 654 8 be be VB 35772 654 9 said say VBN 35772 654 10 to to TO 35772 654 11 have have VB 35772 654 12 dispensed dispense VBN 35772 654 13 with with IN 35772 654 14 this this DT 35772 654 15 foundation foundation NN 35772 654 16 . . . 35772 655 1 Taking take VBG 35772 655 2 the the DT 35772 655 3 scientific scientific JJ 35772 655 4 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 655 5 of of IN 35772 655 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 655 7 time time NN 35772 655 8 for for IN 35772 655 9 granted grant VBN 35772 655 10 , , , 35772 655 11 they -PRON- PRP 35772 655 12 drew draw VBD 35772 655 13 certain certain JJ 35772 655 14 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 655 15 therefrom therefrom NN 35772 655 16 ; ; : 35772 655 17 but but CC 35772 655 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 655 19 results result NNS 35772 655 20 , , , 35772 655 21 however however RB 35772 655 22 imposing impose VBG 35772 655 23 , , , 35772 655 24 were be VBD 35772 655 25 felt feel VBN 35772 655 26 to to TO 35772 655 27 be be VB 35772 655 28 the the DT 35772 655 29 result result NN 35772 655 30 rather rather RB 35772 655 31 of of IN 35772 655 32 speculation speculation NN 35772 655 33 than than IN 35772 655 34 of of IN 35772 655 35 reason reason NN 35772 655 36 . . . 35772 656 1 Such such JJ 35772 656 2 was be VBD 35772 656 3 the the DT 35772 656 4 more more RBR 35772 656 5 or or CC 35772 656 6 less less RBR 35772 656 7 unexpressed unexpressed JJ 35772 656 8 estimate estimate NN 35772 656 9 of of IN 35772 656 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 656 11 work work NN 35772 656 12 . . . 35772 657 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 657 2 was be VBD 35772 657 3 undervalued undervalue VBN 35772 657 4 , , , 35772 657 5 for for IN 35772 657 6 both both DT 35772 657 7 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 657 8 and and CC 35772 657 9 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 657 10 were be VBD 35772 657 11 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 657 12 of of IN 35772 657 13 the the DT 35772 657 14 first first JJ 35772 657 15 calibre calibre NN 35772 657 16 ; ; : 35772 657 17 and and CC 35772 657 18 yet yet RB 35772 657 19 there there EX 35772 657 20 was be VBD 35772 657 21 some some DT 35772 657 22 justice justice NN 35772 657 23 in in IN 35772 657 24 the the DT 35772 657 25 charge charge NN 35772 657 26 . . . 35772 658 1 By by IN 35772 658 2 the the DT 35772 658 3 end end NN 35772 658 4 of of IN 35772 658 5 the the DT 35772 658 6 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 658 7 century century NN 35772 658 8 the the DT 35772 658 9 days day NNS 35772 658 10 of of IN 35772 658 11 merely merely RB 35772 658 12 speculative speculative JJ 35772 658 13 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 658 14 were be VBD 35772 658 15 past past JJ 35772 658 16 . . . 35772 659 1 THE the DT 35772 659 2 CRITICAL CRITICAL NNP 35772 659 3 PHILOSOPHY.--The philosophy.--the JJ 35772 659 4 time time NN 35772 659 5 was be VBD 35772 659 6 ripe ripe JJ 35772 659 7 for for IN 35772 659 8 a a DT 35772 659 9 new new JJ 35772 659 10 metaphysic metaphysic NN 35772 659 11 -- -- : 35772 659 12 for for IN 35772 659 13 a a DT 35772 659 14 fresh fresh JJ 35772 659 15 step step NN 35772 659 16 forward forward RB 35772 659 17 in in IN 35772 659 18 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 659 19 method method NN 35772 659 20 . . . 35772 660 1 That that DT 35772 660 2 step step NN 35772 660 3 was be VBD 35772 660 4 taken take VBN 35772 660 5 by by IN 35772 660 6 the the DT 35772 660 7 celebrated celebrated JJ 35772 660 8 Immanuel Immanuel NNP 35772 660 9 Kant Kant NNP 35772 660 10 , , , 35772 660 11 who who WP 35772 660 12 is be VBZ 35772 660 13 the the DT 35772 660 14 originator originator NN 35772 660 15 of of IN 35772 660 16 what what WP 35772 660 17 is be VBZ 35772 660 18 known know VBN 35772 660 19 , , , 35772 660 20 in in IN 35772 660 21 the the DT 35772 660 22 history history NN 35772 660 23 of of IN 35772 660 24 thought thought NN 35772 660 25 , , , 35772 660 26 as as IN 35772 660 27 the the DT 35772 660 28 Critical Critical NNP 35772 660 29 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 660 30 . . . 35772 661 1 The the DT 35772 661 2 word word NN 35772 661 3 _ _ NNP 35772 661 4 critical critical JJ 35772 661 5 _ _ NNP 35772 661 6 signifies signify VBZ 35772 661 7 a a DT 35772 661 8 particular particular JJ 35772 661 9 method method NN 35772 661 10 of of IN 35772 661 11 approaching approach VBG 35772 661 12 the the DT 35772 661 13 problem problem NN 35772 661 14 of of IN 35772 661 15 existence existence NN 35772 661 16 , , , 35772 661 17 a a DT 35772 661 18 method method NN 35772 661 19 which which WDT 35772 661 20 must must MD 35772 661 21 be be VB 35772 661 22 contrasted contrast VBN 35772 661 23 with with IN 35772 661 24 that that DT 35772 661 25 of of IN 35772 661 26 the the DT 35772 661 27 _ _ NNP 35772 661 28 speculative speculative JJ 35772 661 29 _ _ NNP 35772 661 30 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 661 31 , , , 35772 661 32 of of IN 35772 661 33 which which WDT 35772 661 34 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 661 35 and and CC 35772 661 36 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 661 37 are be VBP 35772 661 38 examples example NNS 35772 661 39 . . . 35772 662 1 The the DT 35772 662 2 critical critical JJ 35772 662 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 662 4 , , , 35772 662 5 before before IN 35772 662 6 attempting attempt VBG 35772 662 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 662 8 as as IN 35772 662 9 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 662 10 had have VBD 35772 662 11 done do VBN 35772 662 12 ) ) -RRB- 35772 662 13 to to TO 35772 662 14 tackle tackle VB 35772 662 15 the the DT 35772 662 16 problem problem NN 35772 662 17 of of IN 35772 662 18 _ _ NNP 35772 662 19 existence existence NN 35772 662 20 _ _ NNP 35772 662 21 , , , 35772 662 22 first first RB 35772 662 23 attacked attack VBD 35772 662 24 the the DT 35772 662 25 problem problem NN 35772 662 26 of of IN 35772 662 27 _ _ NNP 35772 662 28 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 662 29 _ _ NNP 35772 662 30 . . . 35772 663 1 Before before IN 35772 663 2 asking ask VBG 35772 663 3 _ _ NNP 35772 663 4 What what WP 35772 663 5 is be VBZ 35772 663 6 the the DT 35772 663 7 truth truth NN 35772 663 8 ? ? . 35772 663 9 _ _ NNP 35772 663 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 663 11 put put VBD 35772 663 12 the the DT 35772 663 13 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 663 14 question question NN 35772 663 15 , , , 35772 663 16 _ _ NNP 35772 663 17 What what WP 35772 663 18 are be VBP 35772 663 19 the the DT 35772 663 20 means mean NNS 35772 663 21 at at IN 35772 663 22 man man NN 35772 663 23 's 's POS 35772 663 24 disposal disposal NN 35772 663 25 for for IN 35772 663 26 reaching reach VBG 35772 663 27 the the DT 35772 663 28 truth truth NN 35772 663 29 ? ? . 35772 663 30 _ _ NNP 35772 663 31 It -PRON- PRP 35772 663 32 prefaced preface VBD 35772 663 33 all all DT 35772 663 34 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 663 35 enquiry enquiry NN 35772 663 36 by by IN 35772 663 37 an an DT 35772 663 38 examination examination NN 35772 663 39 into into IN 35772 663 40 the the DT 35772 663 41 nature nature NN 35772 663 42 and and CC 35772 663 43 scope scope NN 35772 663 44 of of IN 35772 663 45 human human JJ 35772 663 46 thought thought NN 35772 663 47 . . . 35772 664 1 Such such JJ 35772 664 2 was be VBD 35772 664 3 the the DT 35772 664 4 preparatory preparatory JJ 35772 664 5 investigation investigation NN 35772 664 6 which which WDT 35772 664 7 was be VBD 35772 664 8 to to TO 35772 664 9 place place VB 35772 664 10 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 664 11 upon upon IN 35772 664 12 a a DT 35772 664 13 secure secure JJ 35772 664 14 and and CC 35772 664 15 scientific scientific JJ 35772 664 16 foundation foundation NN 35772 664 17 . . . 35772 665 1 For for IN 35772 665 2 the the DT 35772 665 3 new new JJ 35772 665 4 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 665 5 , , , 35772 665 6 the the DT 35772 665 7 gateway gateway NN 35772 665 8 to to IN 35772 665 9 all all DT 35772 665 10 sound sound JJ 35772 665 11 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 665 12 is be VBZ 35772 665 13 the the DT 35772 665 14 reflection reflection NN 35772 665 15 of of IN 35772 665 16 the the DT 35772 665 17 human human JJ 35772 665 18 mind mind NN 35772 665 19 upon upon IN 35772 665 20 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 665 21 . . . 35772 666 1 " " `` 35772 666 2 Know know VB 35772 666 3 thyself thyself PRP 35772 666 4 , , , 35772 666 5 " " '' 35772 666 6 is be VBZ 35772 666 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 666 8 advice advice NN 35772 666 9 to to IN 35772 666 10 the the DT 35772 666 11 inquiring inquire VBG 35772 666 12 spirit spirit NN 35772 666 13 of of IN 35772 666 14 man man NN 35772 666 15 . . . 35772 667 1 Here here RB 35772 667 2 , , , 35772 667 3 if if IN 35772 667 4 anywhere anywhere RB 35772 667 5 , , , 35772 667 6 is be VBZ 35772 667 7 to to TO 35772 667 8 be be VB 35772 667 9 found find VBN 35772 667 10 the the DT 35772 667 11 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 667 12 's 's POS 35772 667 13 stone stone NN 35772 667 14 . . . 35772 668 1 IMMANUEL IMMANUEL NNP 35772 668 2 KANT.--The kant.--the FW 35772 668 3 celebrated celebrate VBD 35772 668 4 Immanuel Immanuel NNP 35772 668 5 Kant Kant NNP 35772 668 6 was be VBD 35772 668 7 born bear VBN 35772 668 8 at at IN 35772 668 9 Königsberg Königsberg NNP 35772 668 10 in in IN 35772 668 11 1724 1724 CD 35772 668 12 , , , 35772 668 13 and and CC 35772 668 14 died die VBD 35772 668 15 in in IN 35772 668 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 668 17 native native JJ 35772 668 18 town town NN 35772 668 19 in in IN 35772 668 20 1804 1804 CD 35772 668 21 . . . 35772 669 1 Between between IN 35772 669 2 those those DT 35772 669 3 dates date NNS 35772 669 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 669 5 lived live VBD 35772 669 6 the the DT 35772 669 7 industrious industrious JJ 35772 669 8 and and CC 35772 669 9 uneventful uneventful JJ 35772 669 10 life life NN 35772 669 11 of of IN 35772 669 12 a a DT 35772 669 13 university university NN 35772 669 14 professor professor NN 35772 669 15 . . . 35772 670 1 The the DT 35772 670 2 Seven Seven NNP 35772 670 3 Years Years NNPS 35772 670 4 ' ' POS 35772 670 5 War war NN 35772 670 6 and and CC 35772 670 7 the the DT 35772 670 8 French French NNP 35772 670 9 Revolution Revolution NNP 35772 670 10 left leave VBD 35772 670 11 him -PRON- PRP 35772 670 12 undisturbed undisturbed JJ 35772 670 13 , , , 35772 670 14 though though IN 35772 670 15 not not RB 35772 670 16 unmoved unmoved JJ 35772 670 17 . . . 35772 671 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 671 2 was be VBD 35772 671 3 a a DT 35772 671 4 man man NN 35772 671 5 of of IN 35772 671 6 quiet quiet JJ 35772 671 7 , , , 35772 671 8 regular regular JJ 35772 671 9 habits habit NNS 35772 671 10 , , , 35772 671 11 and and CC 35772 671 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 671 13 fellow fellow JJ 35772 671 14 - - HYPH 35772 671 15 townsmen townsman NNS 35772 671 16 would would MD 35772 671 17 set set VB 35772 671 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 671 19 clocks clock NNS 35772 671 20 by by IN 35772 671 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 671 22 daily daily JJ 35772 671 23 promenade promenade NN 35772 671 24 . . . 35772 672 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 672 2 23 23 CD 35772 672 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 672 4 But but CC 35772 672 5 the the DT 35772 672 6 adventurous adventurous JJ 35772 672 7 originality originality NN 35772 672 8 of of IN 35772 672 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 672 10 thought thought NN 35772 672 11 serves serve VBZ 35772 672 12 as as IN 35772 672 13 a a DT 35772 672 14 contrast contrast NN 35772 672 15 to to IN 35772 672 16 this this DT 35772 672 17 peaceful peaceful JJ 35772 672 18 picture picture NN 35772 672 19 . . . 35772 673 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 673 2 , , , 35772 673 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 673 4 , , , 35772 673 5 laid lay VBD 35772 673 6 the the DT 35772 673 7 foundations foundation NNS 35772 673 8 of of IN 35772 673 9 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 673 10 afresh afresh RB 35772 673 11 . . . 35772 674 1 With with IN 35772 674 2 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 674 3 insight insight NN 35772 674 4 , , , 35772 674 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 674 6 went go VBD 35772 674 7 to to IN 35772 674 8 the the DT 35772 674 9 very very JJ 35772 674 10 root root NN 35772 674 11 problem problem NN 35772 674 12 of of IN 35772 674 13 all all DT 35772 674 14 , , , 35772 674 15 and and CC 35772 674 16 challenged challenge VBN 35772 674 17 human human JJ 35772 674 18 thought thought NN 35772 674 19 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 674 20 . . . 35772 675 1 Before before IN 35772 675 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 675 3 can can MD 35772 675 4 know know VB 35772 675 5 anything anything NN 35772 675 6 , , , 35772 675 7 we -PRON- PRP 35772 675 8 must must MD 35772 675 9 first first RB 35772 675 10 of of IN 35772 675 11 all all DT 35772 675 12 demand demand VB 35772 675 13 the the DT 35772 675 14 credentials credential NNS 35772 675 15 of of IN 35772 675 16 the the DT 35772 675 17 instrument instrument NN 35772 675 18 by by IN 35772 675 19 which which WDT 35772 675 20 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 675 21 is be VBZ 35772 675 22 gained gain VBN 35772 675 23 . . . 35772 676 1 Before before IN 35772 676 2 asking ask VBG 35772 676 3 , , , 35772 676 4 _ _ NNP 35772 676 5 What what WP 35772 676 6 _ _ NNP 35772 676 7 do do VBP 35772 676 8 I -PRON- PRP 35772 676 9 know know VB 35772 676 10 ? ? . 35772 677 1 the the DT 35772 677 2 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 677 3 question question NN 35772 677 4 should should MD 35772 677 5 be be VB 35772 677 6 , , , 35772 677 7 _ _ NNP 35772 677 8 How how WRB 35772 677 9 _ _ NNP 35772 677 10 do do VBP 35772 677 11 I -PRON- PRP 35772 677 12 know know VB 35772 677 13 ? ? . 35772 678 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 35772 678 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 678 3 can can MD 35772 678 4 not not RB 35772 678 5 say say VB 35772 678 6 whether whether IN 35772 678 7 we -PRON- PRP 35772 678 8 are be VBP 35772 678 9 in in IN 35772 678 10 a a DT 35772 678 11 position position NN 35772 678 12 to to TO 35772 678 13 give give VB 35772 678 14 any any DT 35772 678 15 answer answer NN 35772 678 16 to to IN 35772 678 17 those those DT 35772 678 18 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 678 19 problems problem NNS 35772 678 20 , , , 35772 678 21 the the DT 35772 678 22 answers answer NNS 35772 678 23 to to TO 35772 678 24 which which WDT 35772 678 25 constitute constitute VBP 35772 678 26 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 678 27 . . . 35772 679 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 679 2 is be VBZ 35772 679 3 far far RB 35772 679 4 from from IN 35772 679 5 easy easy JJ 35772 679 6 to to TO 35772 679 7 present present VB 35772 679 8 Kant Kant NNP 35772 679 9 's 's POS 35772 679 10 criticism criticism NN 35772 679 11 of of IN 35772 679 12 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 679 13 at at IN 35772 679 14 once once RB 35772 679 15 simply simply RB 35772 679 16 and and CC 35772 679 17 accurately accurately RB 35772 679 18 . . . 35772 680 1 This this DT 35772 680 2 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 680 3 has have VBZ 35772 680 4 a a DT 35772 680 5 not not RB 35772 680 6 undeserved undeserved JJ 35772 680 7 reputation reputation NN 35772 680 8 for for IN 35772 680 9 obscurity obscurity NN 35772 680 10 , , , 35772 680 11 and and CC 35772 680 12 had have VBD 35772 680 13 he -PRON- PRP 35772 680 14 written write VBN 35772 680 15 in in IN 35772 680 16 any any DT 35772 680 17 other other JJ 35772 680 18 language language NN 35772 680 19 than than IN 35772 680 20 German German NNP 35772 680 21 , , , 35772 680 22 he -PRON- PRP 35772 680 23 would would MD 35772 680 24 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 680 25 have have VB 35772 680 26 found find VBN 35772 680 27 no no DT 35772 680 28 readers reader NNS 35772 680 29 . . . 35772 681 1 THE the DT 35772 681 2 PROBLEM problem NN 35772 681 3 OF of IN 35772 681 4 KNOWLEDGE.--It KNOWLEDGE.--It NNP 35772 681 5 had have VBD 35772 681 6 already already RB 35772 681 7 been be VBN 35772 681 8 realised realise VBN 35772 681 9 by by IN 35772 681 10 the the DT 35772 681 11 predecessors predecessor NNS 35772 681 12 of of IN 35772 681 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 681 14 that that IN 35772 681 15 what what WP 35772 681 16 is be VBZ 35772 681 17 called call VBN 35772 681 18 " " `` 35772 681 19 sense sense NN 35772 681 20 - - HYPH 35772 681 21 experience experience NN 35772 681 22 " " '' 35772 681 23 is be VBZ 35772 681 24 a a DT 35772 681 25 less less RBR 35772 681 26 simple simple JJ 35772 681 27 process process NN 35772 681 28 than than IN 35772 681 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 681 30 seems seem VBZ 35772 681 31 , , , 35772 681 32 and and CC 35772 681 33 that that IN 35772 681 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 681 35 senses sense NNS 35772 681 36 can can MD 35772 681 37 not not RB 35772 681 38 be be VB 35772 681 39 said say VBN 35772 681 40 to to TO 35772 681 41 reveal reveal VB 35772 681 42 to to IN 35772 681 43 us -PRON- PRP 35772 681 44 any any DT 35772 681 45 object object NN 35772 681 46 as as IN 35772 681 47 it -PRON- PRP 35772 681 48 actually actually RB 35772 681 49 _ _ NNP 35772 681 50 is be VBZ 35772 681 51 _ _ NNP 35772 681 52 . . . 35772 682 1 John John NNP 35772 682 2 Locke Locke NNP 35772 682 3 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 682 4 was be VBD 35772 682 5 not not RB 35772 682 6 the the DT 35772 682 7 first first JJ 35772 682 8 to to TO 35772 682 9 point point VB 35772 682 10 out out RP 35772 682 11 that that IN 35772 682 12 the the DT 35772 682 13 so so RB 35772 682 14 - - HYPH 35772 682 15 called call VBN 35772 682 16 " " `` 35772 682 17 secondary secondary JJ 35772 682 18 qualities quality NNS 35772 682 19 " " '' 35772 682 20 of of IN 35772 682 21 any any DT 35772 682 22 material material JJ 35772 682 23 object object NN 35772 682 24 ( ( -LRB- 35772 682 25 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 683 1 colour colour NN 35772 683 2 , , , 35772 683 3 taste taste NN 35772 683 4 , , , 35772 683 5 etc etc FW 35772 683 6 . . . 35772 683 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 684 1 are be VBP 35772 684 2 produced produce VBN 35772 684 3 just just RB 35772 684 4 as as RB 35772 684 5 much much JJ 35772 684 6 by by IN 35772 684 7 the the DT 35772 684 8 person person NN 35772 684 9 who who WP 35772 684 10 perceives perceive VBZ 35772 684 11 , , , 35772 684 12 as as IN 35772 684 13 by by IN 35772 684 14 the the DT 35772 684 15 object object NN 35772 684 16 which which WDT 35772 684 17 is be VBZ 35772 684 18 perceived perceive VBN 35772 684 19 . . . 35772 685 1 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 685 2 , , , 35772 685 3 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 685 4 , , , 35772 685 5 and and CC 35772 685 6 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 685 7 , , , 35772 685 8 besides besides IN 35772 685 9 others other NNS 35772 685 10 , , , 35772 685 11 had have VBD 35772 685 12 been be VBN 35772 685 13 aware aware JJ 35772 685 14 of of IN 35772 685 15 this this DT 35772 685 16 fact fact NN 35772 685 17 , , , 35772 685 18 which which WDT 35772 685 19 indeed indeed RB 35772 685 20 becomes become VBZ 35772 685 21 evident evident JJ 35772 685 22 to to IN 35772 685 23 the the DT 35772 685 24 most most RBS 35772 685 25 superficial superficial JJ 35772 685 26 analysis analysis NN 35772 685 27 of of IN 35772 685 28 sense sense NN 35772 685 29 - - HYPH 35772 685 30 experience experience NN 35772 685 31 . . . 35772 686 1 The the DT 35772 686 2 " " `` 35772 686 3 primary primary JJ 35772 686 4 qualities quality NNS 35772 686 5 , , , 35772 686 6 " " '' 35772 686 7 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 687 1 density density NN 35772 687 2 , , , 35772 687 3 extension extension NN 35772 687 4 , , , 35772 687 5 etc etc FW 35772 687 6 . . FW 35772 687 7 , , , 35772 687 8 continued continue VBD 35772 687 9 to to TO 35772 687 10 be be VB 35772 687 11 regarded regard VBN 35772 687 12 as as IN 35772 687 13 subsisting subsist VBG 35772 687 14 _ _ NNP 35772 687 15 in in IN 35772 687 16 _ _ NNP 35772 687 17 the the DT 35772 687 18 objects object NNS 35772 687 19 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 687 20 , , , 35772 687 21 and and CC 35772 687 22 independently independently RB 35772 687 23 of of IN 35772 687 24 any any DT 35772 687 25 perceiving perceiving NN 35772 687 26 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 687 27 . . . 35772 688 1 But but CC 35772 688 2 even even RB 35772 688 3 this this DT 35772 688 4 view view NN 35772 688 5 did do VBD 35772 688 6 not not RB 35772 688 7 prove prove VB 35772 688 8 permanent permanent JJ 35772 688 9 , , , 35772 688 10 and and CC 35772 688 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 688 12 was be VBD 35772 688 13 the the DT 35772 688 14 episcopal episcopal JJ 35772 688 15 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 688 16 , , , 35772 688 17 George George NNP 35772 688 18 Berkeley Berkeley NNP 35772 688 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 688 20 1685 1685 CD 35772 688 21 - - SYM 35772 688 22 1753 1753 CD 35772 688 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 688 24 who who WP 35772 688 25 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 35772 688 26 in in IN 35772 688 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 688 28 _ _ NNP 35772 688 29 New New NNP 35772 688 30 Theory Theory NNP 35772 688 31 of of IN 35772 688 32 Vision Vision NNP 35772 688 33 _ _ NNP 35772 688 34 that that IN 35772 688 35 not not RB 35772 688 36 even even RB 35772 688 37 _ _ IN 35772 688 38 these these DT 35772 688 39 _ _ NNP 35772 688 40 qualities quality NNS 35772 688 41 could could MD 35772 688 42 rightly rightly RB 35772 688 43 be be VB 35772 688 44 regarded regard VBN 35772 688 45 as as IN 35772 688 46 subsisting subsist VBG 35772 688 47 independently independently RB 35772 688 48 . . . 35772 689 1 Thus thus RB 35772 689 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 689 3 had have VBD 35772 689 4 already already RB 35772 689 5 been be VBN 35772 689 6 realised realise VBN 35772 689 7 , , , 35772 689 8 long long RB 35772 689 9 before before IN 35772 689 10 Kant Kant NNP 35772 689 11 wrote write VBD 35772 689 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 689 13 _ _ NNP 35772 689 14 Critique Critique NNP 35772 689 15 of of IN 35772 689 16 Pure Pure NNP 35772 689 17 Reason Reason NNP 35772 689 18 _ _ NNP 35772 689 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 689 20 published publish VBN 35772 689 21 , , , 35772 689 22 1781 1781 CD 35772 689 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 689 24 , , , 35772 689 25 that that IN 35772 689 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 689 27 senses sense NNS 35772 689 28 are be VBP 35772 689 29 far far RB 35772 689 30 from from IN 35772 689 31 revealing reveal VBG 35772 689 32 to to IN 35772 689 33 us -PRON- PRP 35772 689 34 things thing NNS 35772 689 35 as as IN 35772 689 36 they -PRON- PRP 35772 689 37 _ _ NNP 35772 689 38 are be VBP 35772 689 39 _ _ NNP 35772 689 40 ; ; : 35772 689 41 it -PRON- PRP 35772 689 42 is be VBZ 35772 689 43 only only RB 35772 689 44 the the DT 35772 689 45 _ _ NNP 35772 689 46 appearances appearance NNS 35772 689 47 _ _ NNP 35772 689 48 of of IN 35772 689 49 things thing NNS 35772 689 50 and and CC 35772 689 51 not not RB 35772 689 52 the the DT 35772 689 53 _ _ NNP 35772 689 54 things thing NNS 35772 689 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 689 56 _ _ VBP 35772 689 57 that that IN 35772 689 58 the the DT 35772 689 59 senses sense NNS 35772 689 60 present present JJ 35772 689 61 to to IN 35772 689 62 us -PRON- PRP 35772 689 63 . . . 35772 690 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 690 2 , , , 35772 690 3 as as IN 35772 690 4 is be VBZ 35772 690 5 well well RB 35772 690 6 known know VBN 35772 690 7 , , , 35772 690 8 the the DT 35772 690 9 Scotch Scotch NNP 35772 690 10 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 690 11 David David NNP 35772 690 12 Hume Hume NNP 35772 690 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 690 14 1711 1711 CD 35772 690 15 - - HYPH 35772 690 16 1776 1776 CD 35772 690 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 690 18 , , , 35772 690 19 who who WP 35772 690 20 was be VBD 35772 690 21 a a DT 35772 690 22 master master NN 35772 690 23 in in IN 35772 690 24 the the DT 35772 690 25 art art NN 35772 690 26 of of IN 35772 690 27 raising raise VBG 35772 690 28 problems problem NNS 35772 690 29 , , , 35772 690 30 extended extend VBD 35772 690 31 this this DT 35772 690 32 line line NN 35772 690 33 of of IN 35772 690 34 criticism criticism NN 35772 690 35 until until IN 35772 690 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 690 37 reached reach VBD 35772 690 38 to to TO 35772 690 39 pure pure JJ 35772 690 40 scepticism scepticism NN 35772 690 41 . . . 35772 691 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 691 2 put put VBD 35772 691 3 the the DT 35772 691 4 question question NN 35772 691 5 , , , 35772 691 6 If if IN 35772 691 7 all all DT 35772 691 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 691 9 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 691 10 is be VBZ 35772 691 11 derived derive VBN 35772 691 12 from from IN 35772 691 13 sense sense NN 35772 691 14 - - HYPH 35772 691 15 experience experience NN 35772 691 16 , , , 35772 691 17 and and CC 35772 691 18 _ _ NNP 35772 691 19 if if IN 35772 691 20 _ _ NNP 35772 691 21 sense sense NN 35772 691 22 - - HYPH 35772 691 23 experience experience NN 35772 691 24 only only RB 35772 691 25 supplies supply VBZ 35772 691 26 us -PRON- PRP 35772 691 27 with with IN 35772 691 28 appearance appearance NN 35772 691 29 and and CC 35772 691 30 not not RB 35772 691 31 reality reality NN 35772 691 32 , , , 35772 691 33 what what WP 35772 691 34 degree degree NN 35772 691 35 of of IN 35772 691 36 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 35772 691 37 can can MD 35772 691 38 there there EX 35772 691 39 be be VB 35772 691 40 in in IN 35772 691 41 human human JJ 35772 691 42 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 691 43 ? ? . 35772 692 1 And and CC 35772 692 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 692 3 was be VBD 35772 692 4 not not RB 35772 692 5 afraid afraid JJ 35772 692 6 to to TO 35772 692 7 give give VB 35772 692 8 the the DT 35772 692 9 logical logical JJ 35772 692 10 answer answer NN 35772 692 11 -- -- : 35772 692 12 None none NN 35772 692 13 . . . 35772 693 1 Hume hume NN 35772 693 2 may may MD 35772 693 3 thus thus RB 35772 693 4 be be VB 35772 693 5 said say VBN 35772 693 6 to to TO 35772 693 7 have have VB 35772 693 8 brought bring VBN 35772 693 9 things thing NNS 35772 693 10 to to IN 35772 693 11 an an DT 35772 693 12 impasse impasse NN 35772 693 13 . . . 35772 694 1 As as IN 35772 694 2 a a DT 35772 694 3 matter matter NN 35772 694 4 of of IN 35772 694 5 fact fact NN 35772 694 6 , , , 35772 694 7 what what WP 35772 694 8 he -PRON- PRP 35772 694 9 had have VBD 35772 694 10 done do VBN 35772 694 11 was be VBD 35772 694 12 to to TO 35772 694 13 refute refute VB 35772 694 14 Locke Locke NNP 35772 694 15 's 's POS 35772 694 16 theory theory NN 35772 694 17 of of IN 35772 694 18 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 694 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 694 20 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 695 1 that that IN 35772 695 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 695 3 is be VBZ 35772 695 4 derived derive VBN 35772 695 5 entirely entirely RB 35772 695 6 from from IN 35772 695 7 sense sense NN 35772 695 8 - - HYPH 35772 695 9 experience experience NN 35772 695 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 695 11 by by IN 35772 695 12 means mean NNS 35772 695 13 of of IN 35772 695 14 a a DT 35772 695 15 _ _ NNP 35772 695 16 reductio reductio NN 35772 695 17 ad ad NN 35772 695 18 absurdum absurdum NN 35772 695 19 _ _ NNP 35772 695 20 . . . 35772 696 1 THE the DT 35772 696 2 KANTIAN KANTIAN NNP 35772 696 3 CRITICISM.--Kant criticism.--kant NN 35772 696 4 says say VBZ 35772 696 5 that that IN 35772 696 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 696 7 was be VBD 35772 696 8 Hume hume NN 35772 696 9 who who WP 35772 696 10 " " `` 35772 696 11 awoke awake VBD 35772 696 12 him -PRON- PRP 35772 696 13 from from IN 35772 696 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 696 15 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 696 16 slumbers slumber NNS 35772 696 17 . . . 35772 696 18 " " '' 35772 697 1 By by IN 35772 697 2 this this DT 35772 697 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 697 4 meant mean VBD 35772 697 5 that that IN 35772 697 6 Hume Hume NNP 35772 697 7 made make VBD 35772 697 8 him -PRON- PRP 35772 697 9 realise realise VB 35772 697 10 that that IN 35772 697 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 697 12 was be VBD 35772 697 13 no no DT 35772 697 14 use use NN 35772 697 15 indulging indulging NN 35772 697 16 in in IN 35772 697 17 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 697 18 speculation speculation NN 35772 697 19 generally generally RB 35772 697 20 , , , 35772 697 21 or or CC 35772 697 22 listening listen VBG 35772 697 23 to to IN 35772 697 24 the the DT 35772 697 25 speculations speculation NNS 35772 697 26 of of IN 35772 697 27 others other NNS 35772 697 28 , , , 35772 697 29 until until IN 35772 697 30 " " `` 35772 697 31 the the DT 35772 697 32 Problem Problem NNP 35772 697 33 of of IN 35772 697 34 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 35772 697 35 " " '' 35772 697 36 was be VBD 35772 697 37 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 35772 697 38 solved solve VBN 35772 697 39 . . . 35772 698 1 To to IN 35772 698 2 this this DT 35772 698 3 problem problem NN 35772 698 4 Kant Kant NNP 35772 698 5 applied apply VBD 35772 698 6 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 698 7 . . . 35772 699 1 And and CC 35772 699 2 recognising recognise VBG 35772 699 3 Locke Locke NNP 35772 699 4 to to TO 35772 699 5 be be VB 35772 699 6 the the DT 35772 699 7 _ _ NNP 35772 699 8 fons fon NNS 35772 699 9 et et NNP 35772 699 10 origo origo NNP 35772 699 11 malorum malorum NNP 35772 699 12 _ _ NNP 35772 699 13 , , , 35772 699 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 699 15 subjected subject VBD 35772 699 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 699 17 theory theory NN 35772 699 18 of of IN 35772 699 19 human human JJ 35772 699 20 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 699 21 to to IN 35772 699 22 a a DT 35772 699 23 close close JJ 35772 699 24 analysis analysis NN 35772 699 25 , , , 35772 699 26 and and CC 35772 699 27 exposed expose VBD 35772 699 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 699 29 as as IN 35772 699 30 being be VBG 35772 699 31 fallacious fallacious JJ 35772 699 32 . . . 35772 700 1 Far far RB 35772 700 2 from from IN 35772 700 3 sense sense NN 35772 700 4 - - HYPH 35772 700 5 experience experience NN 35772 700 6 being be VBG 35772 700 7 responsible responsible JJ 35772 700 8 for for IN 35772 700 9 all all DT 35772 700 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 700 11 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 700 12 , , , 35772 700 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 700 14 proved prove VBD 35772 700 15 that that IN 35772 700 16 important important JJ 35772 700 17 elements element NNS 35772 700 18 of of IN 35772 700 19 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 700 20 are be VBP 35772 700 21 quite quite RB 35772 700 22 independent independent JJ 35772 700 23 of of IN 35772 700 24 sense sense NN 35772 700 25 - - HYPH 35772 700 26 experience experience NN 35772 700 27 ; ; : 35772 700 28 especially especially RB 35772 700 29 was be VBD 35772 700 30 this this DT 35772 700 31 so so RB 35772 700 32 in in IN 35772 700 33 the the DT 35772 700 34 case case NN 35772 700 35 of of IN 35772 700 36 certain certain JJ 35772 700 37 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 700 38 propositions proposition NNS 35772 700 39 . . . 35772 701 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 701 2 Hence hence RB 35772 701 3 the the DT 35772 701 4 question question NN 35772 701 5 , , , 35772 701 6 How how WRB 35772 701 7 is be VBZ 35772 701 8 pure pure JJ 35772 701 9 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 701 10 possible possible JJ 35772 701 11 ? ? . 35772 702 1 was be VBD 35772 702 2 put put VBN 35772 702 3 by by IN 35772 702 4 Kant Kant NNP 35772 702 5 at at IN 35772 702 6 the the DT 35772 702 7 beginning beginning NN 35772 702 8 of of IN 35772 702 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 702 10 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 702 11 . . . 35772 702 12 ) ) -RRB- 35772 703 1 But but CC 35772 703 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 703 3 is be VBZ 35772 703 4 neither neither CC 35772 703 5 necessary necessary JJ 35772 703 6 nor nor CC 35772 703 7 desirable desirable JJ 35772 703 8 to to TO 35772 703 9 enter enter VB 35772 703 10 into into IN 35772 703 11 the the DT 35772 703 12 arguments argument NNS 35772 703 13 by by IN 35772 703 14 means mean NNS 35772 703 15 of of IN 35772 703 16 which which WDT 35772 703 17 Kant Kant NNP 35772 703 18 proved prove VBD 35772 703 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 703 20 thesis thesis NN 35772 703 21 , , , 35772 703 22 which which WDT 35772 703 23 was be VBD 35772 703 24 that that IN 35772 703 25 the the DT 35772 703 26 human human JJ 35772 703 27 mind mind NN 35772 703 28 contains contain VBZ 35772 703 29 in in IN 35772 703 30 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 703 31 certain certain JJ 35772 703 32 principles principle NNS 35772 703 33 of of IN 35772 703 34 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 703 35 ( ( -LRB- 35772 703 36 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 704 1 the the DT 35772 704 2 idea idea NN 35772 704 3 of of IN 35772 704 4 cause cause NN 35772 704 5 and and CC 35772 704 6 effect effect NN 35772 704 7 , , , 35772 704 8 the the DT 35772 704 9 ideas idea NNS 35772 704 10 of of IN 35772 704 11 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 704 12 , , , 35772 704 13 and and CC 35772 704 14 so so RB 35772 704 15 on on RB 35772 704 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 704 17 which which WDT 35772 704 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 704 19 does do VBZ 35772 704 20 not not RB 35772 704 21 owe owe VB 35772 704 22 to to TO 35772 704 23 sense sense NN 35772 704 24 - - HYPH 35772 704 25 experience experience NN 35772 704 26 . . . 35772 705 1 KANT KANT NNP 35772 705 2 'S 's POS 35772 705 3 COPERNICAN COPERNICAN NNP 35772 705 4 HYPOTHESIS.--Kant HYPOTHESIS.--Kant NNP 35772 705 5 called call VBN 35772 705 6 these these DT 35772 705 7 principles principle NNS 35772 705 8 of of IN 35772 705 9 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 705 10 , , , 35772 705 11 _ _ NNP 35772 705 12 forms form NNS 35772 705 13 of of IN 35772 705 14 thought thought NN 35772 705 15 _ _ NNP 35772 705 16 or or CC 35772 705 17 _ _ NNP 35772 705 18 categories category NNS 35772 705 19 _ _ NNP 35772 705 20 . . . 35772 706 1 The the DT 35772 706 2 name name NN 35772 706 3 , , , 35772 706 4 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 706 5 , , , 35772 706 6 is be VBZ 35772 706 7 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 706 8 to to IN 35772 706 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 706 10 purpose purpose NN 35772 706 11 ; ; : 35772 706 12 all all DT 35772 706 13 that that WDT 35772 706 14 we -PRON- PRP 35772 706 15 need need VBP 35772 706 16 to to TO 35772 706 17 understand understand VB 35772 706 18 is be VBZ 35772 706 19 that that IN 35772 706 20 Kant Kant NNP 35772 706 21 turned turn VBD 35772 706 22 the the DT 35772 706 23 tables table NNS 35772 706 24 upon upon IN 35772 706 25 Locke Locke NNP 35772 706 26 . . . 35772 707 1 Locke Locke NNP 35772 707 2 said say VBD 35772 707 3 that that IN 35772 707 4 the the DT 35772 707 5 mind mind NN 35772 707 6 was be VBD 35772 707 7 a a DT 35772 707 8 _ _ NNP 35772 707 9 tabula tabula NN 35772 707 10 rasa rasa NNP 35772 707 11 _ _ NNP 35772 707 12 which which WDT 35772 707 13 passively passively RB 35772 707 14 received receive VBD 35772 707 15 impressions impression NNS 35772 707 16 from from IN 35772 707 17 outside outside RB 35772 707 18 . . . 35772 708 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 708 2 said say VBD 35772 708 3 that that IN 35772 708 4 the the DT 35772 708 5 mind mind NN 35772 708 6 is be VBZ 35772 708 7 nothing nothing NN 35772 708 8 of of IN 35772 708 9 the the DT 35772 708 10 kind kind NN 35772 708 11 ; ; : 35772 708 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 708 13 is be VBZ 35772 708 14 not not RB 35772 708 15 passive passive JJ 35772 708 16 , , , 35772 708 17 but but CC 35772 708 18 active active JJ 35772 708 19 ; ; : 35772 708 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 708 21 does do VBZ 35772 708 22 not not RB 35772 708 23 " " `` 35772 708 24 receive receive VB 35772 708 25 " " '' 35772 708 26 whatever whatever WDT 35772 708 27 is be VBZ 35772 708 28 offered offer VBN 35772 708 29 , , , 35772 708 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 708 31 " " `` 35772 708 32 selects select VBZ 35772 708 33 " " '' 35772 708 34 what what WP 35772 708 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 708 36 wants want VBZ 35772 708 37 ; ; : 35772 708 38 and and CC 35772 708 39 _ _ NNP 35772 708 40 it -PRON- PRP 35772 708 41 imposes impose VBZ 35772 708 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 708 43 own own JJ 35772 708 44 " " '' 35772 708 45 forms form NNS 35772 708 46 of of IN 35772 708 47 thought thought NN 35772 708 48 " " '' 35772 708 49 upon upon IN 35772 708 50 the the DT 35772 708 51 outside outside JJ 35772 708 52 world world NN 35772 708 53 _ _ NNP 35772 708 54 . . . 35772 709 1 Photography Photography NNP 35772 709 2 had have VBD 35772 709 3 not not RB 35772 709 4 been be VBN 35772 709 5 invented invent VBN 35772 709 6 at at IN 35772 709 7 the the DT 35772 709 8 time time NN 35772 709 9 of of IN 35772 709 10 this this DT 35772 709 11 controversy controversy NN 35772 709 12 , , , 35772 709 13 but but CC 35772 709 14 Kant Kant NNP 35772 709 15 might may MD 35772 709 16 have have VB 35772 709 17 said say VBD 35772 709 18 : : : 35772 709 19 The the DT 35772 709 20 mind mind NN 35772 709 21 is be VBZ 35772 709 22 not not RB 35772 709 23 a a DT 35772 709 24 photographic photographic JJ 35772 709 25 plate plate NN 35772 709 26 receiving receive VBG 35772 709 27 impressions impression NNS 35772 709 28 from from IN 35772 709 29 without without IN 35772 709 30 , , , 35772 709 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 709 32 rather rather RB 35772 709 33 resembles resemble VBZ 35772 709 34 the the DT 35772 709 35 lens lens NN 35772 709 36 which which WDT 35772 709 37 impressions impression NNS 35772 709 38 must must MD 35772 709 39 pass pass VB 35772 709 40 through through RB 35772 709 41 , , , 35772 709 42 and and CC 35772 709 43 be be VB 35772 709 44 transformed transform VBN 35772 709 45 by by RB 35772 709 46 , , , 35772 709 47 before before IN 35772 709 48 they -PRON- PRP 35772 709 49 can can MD 35772 709 50 create create VB 35772 709 51 a a DT 35772 709 52 picture picture NN 35772 709 53 . . . 35772 710 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 710 2 had have VBD 35772 710 3 , , , 35772 710 4 in in IN 35772 710 5 fact fact NN 35772 710 6 , , , 35772 710 7 by by IN 35772 710 8 this this DT 35772 710 9 theory theory NN 35772 710 10 , , , 35772 710 11 instituted institute VBD 35772 710 12 a a DT 35772 710 13 revolution revolution NN 35772 710 14 . . . 35772 711 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 711 2 new new JJ 35772 711 3 dogma dogma NN 35772 711 4 was be VBD 35772 711 5 : : : 35772 711 6 _ _ NNP 35772 711 7 The the DT 35772 711 8 mind mind NN 35772 711 9 is be VBZ 35772 711 10 the the DT 35772 711 11 mould mould NN 35772 711 12 into into IN 35772 711 13 which which WDT 35772 711 14 all all DT 35772 711 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 711 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 711 17 must must MD 35772 711 18 be be VB 35772 711 19 cast cast VBN 35772 711 20 ; ; , 35772 711 21 and and CC 35772 711 22 the the DT 35772 711 23 constitution constitution NN 35772 711 24 of of IN 35772 711 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 711 26 mind mind NN 35772 711 27 predetermines predetermine VBZ 35772 711 28 the the DT 35772 711 29 shape shape NN 35772 711 30 that that WDT 35772 711 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 711 32 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 711 33 takes take VBZ 35772 711 34 . . . 35772 711 35 _ _ NNP 35772 711 36 Thus Thus NNP 35772 711 37 Kant Kant NNP 35772 711 38 had have VBD 35772 711 39 discovered discover VBN 35772 711 40 that that IN 35772 711 41 not not RB 35772 711 42 only only RB 35772 711 43 sensuous sensuous JJ 35772 711 44 perception perception NN 35772 711 45 , , , 35772 711 46 but but CC 35772 711 47 rational rational JJ 35772 711 48 understanding understanding NN 35772 711 49 also also RB 35772 711 50 , , , 35772 711 51 has have VBZ 35772 711 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 711 53 forms form NNS 35772 711 54 and and CC 35772 711 55 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 711 56 . . . 35772 712 1 Just just RB 35772 712 2 as as IN 35772 712 3 we -PRON- PRP 35772 712 4 become become VBP 35772 712 5 aware aware JJ 35772 712 6 of of IN 35772 712 7 objects object NNS 35772 712 8 only only RB 35772 712 9 by by IN 35772 712 10 means mean NNS 35772 712 11 of of IN 35772 712 12 senses sense NNS 35772 712 13 which which WDT 35772 712 14 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 712 15 hide hide VBP 35772 712 16 or or CC 35772 712 17 distort distort VB 35772 712 18 as as RB 35772 712 19 much much RB 35772 712 20 as as IN 35772 712 21 they -PRON- PRP 35772 712 22 reveal reveal VBP 35772 712 23 ; ; : 35772 712 24 so so RB 35772 712 25 also also RB 35772 712 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 712 27 rational rational JJ 35772 712 28 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 712 29 is be VBZ 35772 712 30 conditioned condition VBN 35772 712 31 by by IN 35772 712 32 the the DT 35772 712 33 nature nature NN 35772 712 34 of of IN 35772 712 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 712 36 understanding understanding NN 35772 712 37 , , , 35772 712 38 which which WDT 35772 712 39 dictates dictate VBZ 35772 712 40 to to TO 35772 712 41 reality reality VB 35772 712 42 the the DT 35772 712 43 " " `` 35772 712 44 forms form NNS 35772 712 45 " " '' 35772 712 46 under under IN 35772 712 47 which which WDT 35772 712 48 it -PRON- PRP 35772 712 49 can can MD 35772 712 50 be be VB 35772 712 51 understood understand VBN 35772 712 52 and and CC 35772 712 53 known know VBN 35772 712 54 . . . 35772 713 1 MECHANISM MECHANISM NNP 35772 713 2 UNDERMINED.--How UNDERMINED.--How NNP 35772 713 3 did do VBD 35772 713 4 this this DT 35772 713 5 affect affect VB 35772 713 6 the the DT 35772 713 7 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 713 8 theory theory NN 35772 713 9 ? ? . 35772 714 1 The the DT 35772 714 2 connection connection NN 35772 714 3 is be VBZ 35772 714 4 obvious obvious JJ 35772 714 5 . . . 35772 715 1 Mechanism mechanism NN 35772 715 2 is be VBZ 35772 715 3 nothing nothing NN 35772 715 4 but but IN 35772 715 5 one one CD 35772 715 6 of of IN 35772 715 7 the the DT 35772 715 8 forms form NNS 35772 715 9 of of IN 35772 715 10 thought thought NN 35772 715 11 that that IN 35772 715 12 the the DT 35772 715 13 mind mind NN 35772 715 14 imposes impose VBZ 35772 715 15 on on IN 35772 715 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 715 17 . . . 35772 716 1 Just just RB 35772 716 2 as as IN 35772 716 3 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 716 4 had have VBD 35772 716 5 discovered discover VBN 35772 716 6 that that IN 35772 716 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 716 8 is be VBZ 35772 716 9 due due JJ 35772 716 10 to to IN 35772 716 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 716 12 position position NN 35772 716 13 on on IN 35772 716 14 the the DT 35772 716 15 earth earth NN 35772 716 16 that that WDT 35772 716 17 the the DT 35772 716 18 heavenly heavenly JJ 35772 716 19 bodies body NNS 35772 716 20 _ _ NNP 35772 716 21 appear appear VBP 35772 716 22 _ _ NNP 35772 716 23 to to TO 35772 716 24 move move VB 35772 716 25 round round IN 35772 716 26 us -PRON- PRP 35772 716 27 , , , 35772 716 28 so so RB 35772 716 29 Kant Kant NNP 35772 716 30 had have VBD 35772 716 31 discovered discover VBN 35772 716 32 that that IN 35772 716 33 it -PRON- PRP 35772 716 34 is be VBZ 35772 716 35 due due JJ 35772 716 36 to to IN 35772 716 37 the the DT 35772 716 38 nature nature NN 35772 716 39 of of IN 35772 716 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 716 41 senses sense NNS 35772 716 42 and and CC 35772 716 43 understanding understanding NN 35772 716 44 that that WDT 35772 716 45 we -PRON- PRP 35772 716 46 perceive perceive VBP 35772 716 47 things thing NNS 35772 716 48 in in IN 35772 716 49 space space NN 35772 716 50 and and CC 35772 716 51 time time NN 35772 716 52 , , , 35772 716 53 and and CC 35772 716 54 understand understand VB 35772 716 55 them -PRON- PRP 35772 716 56 as as IN 35772 716 57 being be VBG 35772 716 58 mechanically mechanically RB 35772 716 59 determined determined JJ 35772 716 60 . . . 35772 717 1 The the DT 35772 717 2 space space NN 35772 717 3 and and CC 35772 717 4 time time NN 35772 717 5 , , , 35772 717 6 and and CC 35772 717 7 the the DT 35772 717 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 717 9 determinism determinism NN 35772 717 10 are be VBP 35772 717 11 not not RB 35772 717 12 in in IN 35772 717 13 the the DT 35772 717 14 things thing NNS 35772 717 15 , , , 35772 717 16 _ _ NNP 35772 717 17 but but CC 35772 717 18 in in IN 35772 717 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 717 20 minds mind NNS 35772 717 21 _ _ NNP 35772 717 22 . . . 35772 718 1 The the DT 35772 718 2 fact fact NN 35772 718 3 is be VBZ 35772 718 4 that that IN 35772 718 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 718 6 can can MD 35772 718 7 only only RB 35772 718 8 grasp grasp VB 35772 718 9 things thing NNS 35772 718 10 under under IN 35772 718 11 these these DT 35772 718 12 forms form NNS 35772 718 13 . . . 35772 719 1 Space space NN 35772 719 2 , , , 35772 719 3 time time NN 35772 719 4 , , , 35772 719 5 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 719 6 causation causation NN 35772 719 7 are be VBP 35772 719 8 forms form NNS 35772 719 9 and and CC 35772 719 10 laws law NNS 35772 719 11 , , , 35772 719 12 _ _ NNP 35772 719 13 not not RB 35772 719 14 _ _ NNP 35772 719 15 of of IN 35772 719 16 nature nature NN 35772 719 17 , , , 35772 719 18 _ _ NNP 35772 719 19 but but CC 35772 719 20 of of IN 35772 719 21 the the DT 35772 719 22 human human JJ 35772 719 23 intellect intellect NN 35772 719 24 _ _ NNP 35772 719 25 , , , 35772 719 26 which which WDT 35772 719 27 is be VBZ 35772 719 28 so so RB 35772 719 29 constituted constituted JJ 35772 719 30 as as IN 35772 719 31 to to TO 35772 719 32 see see VB 35772 719 33 things thing NNS 35772 719 34 in in IN 35772 719 35 this this DT 35772 719 36 way way NN 35772 719 37 . . . 35772 720 1 Thus thus RB 35772 720 2 those those DT 35772 720 3 axioms axiom NNS 35772 720 4 of of IN 35772 720 5 science science NN 35772 720 6 and and CC 35772 720 7 of of IN 35772 720 8 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 720 9 which which WDT 35772 720 10 lie lie VBP 35772 720 11 at at IN 35772 720 12 the the DT 35772 720 13 base base NN 35772 720 14 of of IN 35772 720 15 all all DT 35772 720 16 exact exact JJ 35772 720 17 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 720 18 , , , 35772 720 19 and and CC 35772 720 20 which which WDT 35772 720 21 had have VBD 35772 720 22 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 720 23 been be VBN 35772 720 24 regarded regard VBN 35772 720 25 as as IN 35772 720 26 _ _ NNP 35772 720 27 objective objective NN 35772 720 28 _ _ NNP 35772 720 29 , , , 35772 720 30 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 721 1 as as RB 35772 721 2 inherent inherent JJ 35772 721 3 in in IN 35772 721 4 the the DT 35772 721 5 nature nature NN 35772 721 6 of of IN 35772 721 7 things thing NNS 35772 721 8 , , , 35772 721 9 were be VBD 35772 721 10 shewn shew VBN 35772 721 11 by by IN 35772 721 12 Kant Kant NNP 35772 721 13 to to TO 35772 721 14 be be VB 35772 721 15 , , , 35772 721 16 as as IN 35772 721 17 a a DT 35772 721 18 matter matter NN 35772 721 19 of of IN 35772 721 20 fact fact NN 35772 721 21 , , , 35772 721 22 _ _ NNP 35772 721 23 subjective subjective JJ 35772 721 24 _ _ NNP 35772 721 25 , , , 35772 721 26 that that RB 35772 721 27 is is RB 35772 721 28 ( ( -LRB- 35772 721 29 in in IN 35772 721 30 Kant Kant NNP 35772 721 31 's 's POS 35772 721 32 own own JJ 35772 721 33 phrase phrase NN 35772 721 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 721 35 " " `` 35772 721 36 they -PRON- PRP 35772 721 37 express express VBP 35772 721 38 the the DT 35772 721 39 conditions condition NNS 35772 721 40 under under IN 35772 721 41 which which WDT 35772 721 42 alone alone JJ 35772 721 43 we -PRON- PRP 35772 721 44 are be VBP 35772 721 45 able able JJ 35772 721 46 to to TO 35772 721 47 apprehend apprehend VB 35772 721 48 or or CC 35772 721 49 understand understand VB 35772 721 50 the the DT 35772 721 51 object object NN 35772 721 52 . . . 35772 721 53 " " '' 35772 722 1 Thus thus RB 35772 722 2 all all DT 35772 722 3 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 722 4 is be VBZ 35772 722 5 conditioned condition VBN 35772 722 6 by by IN 35772 722 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 722 8 nature nature NN 35772 722 9 , , , 35772 722 10 by by IN 35772 722 11 the the DT 35772 722 12 framework framework NN 35772 722 13 , , , 35772 722 14 so so RB 35772 722 15 to to TO 35772 722 16 speak speak VB 35772 722 17 , , , 35772 722 18 not not RB 35772 722 19 only only RB 35772 722 20 of of IN 35772 722 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 722 22 senses sense NNS 35772 722 23 but but IN 35772 722 24 of of IN 35772 722 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 722 26 minds mind NNS 35772 722 27 . . . 35772 723 1 In in IN 35772 723 2 this this DT 35772 723 3 way way NN 35772 723 4 the the DT 35772 723 5 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 723 6 view view NN 35772 723 7 was be VBD 35772 723 8 outflanked outflank VBN 35772 723 9 ; ; : 35772 723 10 that that DT 35772 723 11 view view NN 35772 723 12 certainly certainly RB 35772 723 13 seems seem VBZ 35772 723 14 to to IN 35772 723 15 us -PRON- PRP 35772 723 16 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 723 17 and and CC 35772 723 18 certain certain JJ 35772 723 19 , , , 35772 723 20 but but CC 35772 723 21 this this DT 35772 723 22 is be VBZ 35772 723 23 due due JJ 35772 723 24 to to IN 35772 723 25 the the DT 35772 723 26 constitution constitution NN 35772 723 27 of of IN 35772 723 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 723 29 minds mind NNS 35772 723 30 ; ; : 35772 723 31 the the DT 35772 723 32 world world NN 35772 723 33 seems seem VBZ 35772 723 34 to to IN 35772 723 35 us -PRON- PRP 35772 723 36 to to TO 35772 723 37 be be VB 35772 723 38 determined determine VBN 35772 723 39 , , , 35772 723 40 just just RB 35772 723 41 as as IN 35772 723 42 it -PRON- PRP 35772 723 43 seems seem VBZ 35772 723 44 blue blue JJ 35772 723 45 to to IN 35772 723 46 a a DT 35772 723 47 person person NN 35772 723 48 wearing wear VBG 35772 723 49 blue blue JJ 35772 723 50 spectacles spectacle NNS 35772 723 51 . . . 35772 724 1 But but CC 35772 724 2 there there EX 35772 724 3 is be VBZ 35772 724 4 no no DT 35772 724 5 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 724 6 reason reason NN 35772 724 7 for for IN 35772 724 8 supposing suppose VBG 35772 724 9 that that IN 35772 724 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 724 11 _ _ NNP 35772 724 12 is be VBZ 35772 724 13 _ _ NNP 35772 724 14 either either CC 35772 724 15 determined determined JJ 35772 724 16 or or CC 35772 724 17 blue blue JJ 35772 724 18 . . . 35772 725 1 The the DT 35772 725 2 law law NN 35772 725 3 of of IN 35772 725 4 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 725 5 causation causation NN 35772 725 6 is be VBZ 35772 725 7 an an DT 35772 725 8 axiom axiom NN 35772 725 9 , , , 35772 725 10 but but CC 35772 725 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 725 12 is be VBZ 35772 725 13 a a DT 35772 725 14 subjective subjective JJ 35772 725 15 axiom axiom NN 35772 725 16 . . . 35772 726 1 APPEARANCE APPEARANCE NNS 35772 726 2 AND and CC 35772 726 3 REALITY.--This reality.--this NN 35772 726 4 may may MD 35772 726 5 not not RB 35772 726 6 seem seem VB 35772 726 7 much much JJ 35772 726 8 of of IN 35772 726 9 an an DT 35772 726 10 advance advance NN 35772 726 11 on on IN 35772 726 12 Hume Hume NNP 35772 726 13 's 's POS 35772 726 14 position position NN 35772 726 15 . . . 35772 727 1 Human human JJ 35772 727 2 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 727 3 still still RB 35772 727 4 seems seem VBZ 35772 727 5 precarious precarious JJ 35772 727 6 , , , 35772 727 7 if if IN 35772 727 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 727 9 assume assume VBP 35772 727 10 the the DT 35772 727 11 mind mind NN 35772 727 12 to to TO 35772 727 13 be be VB 35772 727 14 a a DT 35772 727 15 kind kind NN 35772 727 16 of of IN 35772 727 17 dictator dictator NN 35772 727 18 which which WDT 35772 727 19 imposes impose VBZ 35772 727 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 727 21 own own JJ 35772 727 22 laws law NNS 35772 727 23 upon upon IN 35772 727 24 nature nature NN 35772 727 25 . . . 35772 728 1 And and CC 35772 728 2 Kant Kant NNP 35772 728 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 728 4 frankly frankly RB 35772 728 5 admitted admit VBD 35772 728 6 that that IN 35772 728 7 neither neither CC 35772 728 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 728 9 senses sense NNS 35772 728 10 nor nor CC 35772 728 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 728 12 reason reason NN 35772 728 13 were be VBD 35772 728 14 able able JJ 35772 728 15 to to TO 35772 728 16 reveal reveal VB 35772 728 17 to to IN 35772 728 18 us -PRON- PRP 35772 728 19 things thing NNS 35772 728 20 as as IN 35772 728 21 they -PRON- PRP 35772 728 22 _ _ NNP 35772 728 23 are be VBP 35772 728 24 _ _ NNP 35772 728 25 , , , 35772 728 26 but but CC 35772 728 27 only only RB 35772 728 28 things thing NNS 35772 728 29 as as IN 35772 728 30 they -PRON- PRP 35772 728 31 _ _ NNP 35772 728 32 seem seem VBP 35772 728 33 _ _ NNP 35772 728 34 ; ; : 35772 728 35 we -PRON- PRP 35772 728 36 grasp grasp VBP 35772 728 37 _ _ NNP 35772 728 38 appearance appearance NN 35772 728 39 _ _ NNP 35772 728 40 , , , 35772 728 41 not not RB 35772 728 42 _ _ NNP 35772 728 43 reality reality NN 35772 728 44 _ _ NNP 35772 728 45 , , , 35772 728 46 and and CC 35772 728 47 ( ( -LRB- 35772 728 48 to to TO 35772 728 49 use use VB 35772 728 50 Kant Kant NNP 35772 728 51 's 's POS 35772 728 52 phraseology phraseology NN 35772 728 53 ) ) -RRB- 35772 728 54 _ _ NNP 35772 728 55 phenomena phenomena NNP 35772 728 56 _ _ NNP 35772 728 57 not not RB 35772 728 58 _ _ NNP 35772 728 59 noumena noumena NNP 35772 728 60 _ _ NNP 35772 728 61 . . . 35772 729 1 Thus thus RB 35772 729 2 Kant Kant NNP 35772 729 3 cut cut VBD 35772 729 4 away away RB 35772 729 5 the the DT 35772 729 6 ground ground NN 35772 729 7 from from IN 35772 729 8 under under IN 35772 729 9 all all RB 35772 729 10 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 35772 729 11 _ _ NNP 35772 729 12 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 729 13 _ _ NNP 35772 729 14 ; ; : 35772 729 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 729 16 shewed shew VBD 35772 729 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 729 18 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 35772 729 19 futility futility NN 35772 729 20 . . . 35772 730 1 THE the DT 35772 730 2 PATHWAY PATHWAY NNP 35772 730 3 TO to IN 35772 730 4 REALITY.--Kant reality.--kant NN 35772 730 5 , , , 35772 730 6 however however RB 35772 730 7 , , , 35772 730 8 did do VBD 35772 730 9 not not RB 35772 730 10 remain remain VB 35772 730 11 satisfied satisfied JJ 35772 730 12 with with IN 35772 730 13 the the DT 35772 730 14 negative negative JJ 35772 730 15 results result NNS 35772 730 16 of of IN 35772 730 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 730 18 critical critical JJ 35772 730 19 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 730 20 , , , 35772 730 21 valuable valuable JJ 35772 730 22 as as IN 35772 730 23 these these DT 35772 730 24 were be VBD 35772 730 25 . . . 35772 731 1 Reality reality NN 35772 731 2 , , , 35772 731 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 731 4 is be VBZ 35772 731 5 true true JJ 35772 731 6 , , , 35772 731 7 lies lie VBZ 35772 731 8 out out IN 35772 731 9 of of IN 35772 731 10 range range NN 35772 731 11 of of IN 35772 731 12 the the DT 35772 731 13 human human JJ 35772 731 14 reason reason NN 35772 731 15 , , , 35772 731 16 but but CC 35772 731 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 731 18 is be VBZ 35772 731 19 not not RB 35772 731 20 entirely entirely RB 35772 731 21 inaccessible inaccessible JJ 35772 731 22 to to IN 35772 731 23 us -PRON- PRP 35772 731 24 , , , 35772 731 25 and and CC 35772 731 26 scepticism scepticism NN 35772 731 27 about about IN 35772 731 28 the the DT 35772 731 29 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 731 30 nature nature NN 35772 731 31 of of IN 35772 731 32 things thing NNS 35772 731 33 is be VBZ 35772 731 34 not not RB 35772 731 35 the the DT 35772 731 36 necessary necessary JJ 35772 731 37 corollary corollary NN 35772 731 38 of of IN 35772 731 39 Kant Kant NNP 35772 731 40 's 's POS 35772 731 41 , , , 35772 731 42 as as IN 35772 731 43 it -PRON- PRP 35772 731 44 was be VBD 35772 731 45 of of IN 35772 731 46 Hume Hume NNP 35772 731 47 's 's POS 35772 731 48 , , , 35772 731 49 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 731 50 . . . 35772 732 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 732 2 drew draw VBD 35772 732 3 a a DT 35772 732 4 distinction distinction NN 35772 732 5 between between IN 35772 732 6 the the DT 35772 732 7 " " `` 35772 732 8 Theoretical Theoretical NNP 35772 732 9 Reason reason NN 35772 732 10 , , , 35772 732 11 " " '' 35772 732 12 which which WDT 35772 732 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 732 14 _ _ NNP 35772 732 15 Critique Critique NNP 35772 732 16 of of IN 35772 732 17 Pure Pure NNP 35772 732 18 Reason Reason NNP 35772 732 19 _ _ NNP 35772 732 20 had have VBD 35772 732 21 dealt deal VBN 35772 732 22 with with IN 35772 732 23 , , , 35772 732 24 and and CC 35772 732 25 the the DT 35772 732 26 " " `` 35772 732 27 Practical Practical NNP 35772 732 28 Reason Reason NNP 35772 732 29 , , , 35772 732 30 " " '' 35772 732 31 which which WDT 35772 732 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 732 33 discusses discuss VBZ 35772 732 34 in in IN 35772 732 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 732 36 _ _ NNP 35772 732 37 Critique Critique NNP 35772 732 38 of of IN 35772 732 39 Practical Practical NNP 35772 732 40 Reason Reason NNP 35772 732 41 _ _ NNP 35772 732 42 ( ( -LRB- 35772 732 43 1788 1788 CD 35772 732 44 ) ) -RRB- 35772 732 45 . . . 35772 733 1 THE the DT 35772 733 2 " " `` 35772 733 3 PRACTICAL PRACTICAL NNP 35772 733 4 REASON REASON NNP 35772 733 5 . . . 35772 733 6 " " '' 35772 734 1 --By --By : 35772 734 2 the the DT 35772 734 3 " " `` 35772 734 4 practical practical JJ 35772 734 5 reason reason NN 35772 734 6 " " `` 35772 734 7 Kant Kant NNP 35772 734 8 meant mean VBD 35772 734 9 the the DT 35772 734 10 moral moral JJ 35772 734 11 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 734 12 , , , 35772 734 13 and and CC 35772 734 14 the the DT 35772 734 15 law law NN 35772 734 16 of of IN 35772 734 17 the the DT 35772 734 18 " " `` 35772 734 19 practical practical JJ 35772 734 20 reason reason NN 35772 734 21 " " '' 35772 734 22 is be VBZ 35772 734 23 the the DT 35772 734 24 moral moral JJ 35772 734 25 law law NN 35772 734 26 , , , 35772 734 27 the the DT 35772 734 28 fulfilment fulfilment NN 35772 734 29 of of IN 35772 734 30 which which WDT 35772 734 31 constitutes constitute VBZ 35772 734 32 duty duty NN 35772 734 33 . . . 35772 735 1 This this DT 35772 735 2 law law NN 35772 735 3 springs spring NNS 35772 735 4 neither neither CC 35772 735 5 from from IN 35772 735 6 outside outside JJ 35772 735 7 authority authority NN 35772 735 8 nor nor CC 35772 735 9 from from IN 35772 735 10 experience experience NN 35772 735 11 ; ; : 35772 735 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 735 13 is be VBZ 35772 735 14 autonomous autonomous JJ 35772 735 15 . . . 35772 736 1 And and CC 35772 736 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 736 3 is be VBZ 35772 736 4 upon upon IN 35772 736 5 the the DT 35772 736 6 existence existence NN 35772 736 7 of of IN 35772 736 8 this this DT 35772 736 9 autonomous autonomous JJ 35772 736 10 moral moral JJ 35772 736 11 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 736 12 that that WDT 35772 736 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 736 14 plants plant VBZ 35772 736 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 736 16 foothold foothold NN 35772 736 17 in in IN 35772 736 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 736 19 endeavour endeavour NN 35772 736 20 to to TO 35772 736 21 find find VB 35772 736 22 a a DT 35772 736 23 refuge refuge NN 35772 736 24 from from IN 35772 736 25 the the DT 35772 736 26 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 736 27 agnosticism agnosticism NN 35772 736 28 to to TO 35772 736 29 which which WDT 35772 736 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 736 31 analysis analysis NN 35772 736 32 of of IN 35772 736 33 the the DT 35772 736 34 " " `` 35772 736 35 theoretical theoretical JJ 35772 736 36 reason reason NN 35772 736 37 " " '' 35772 736 38 had have VBD 35772 736 39 led lead VBN 35772 736 40 ; ; : 35772 736 41 and and CC 35772 736 42 upon upon IN 35772 736 43 this this DT 35772 736 44 rock rock NN 35772 736 45 he -PRON- PRP 35772 736 46 founded found VBD 35772 736 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 736 48 belief belief NN 35772 736 49 in in IN 35772 736 50 " " `` 35772 736 51 God God NNP 35772 736 52 , , , 35772 736 53 Freedom Freedom NNP 35772 736 54 , , , 35772 736 55 and and CC 35772 736 56 Immortality immortality NN 35772 736 57 . . . 35772 736 58 " " '' 35772 737 1 By by IN 35772 737 2 means mean NNS 35772 737 3 of of IN 35772 737 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 737 5 " " `` 35772 737 6 practical practical JJ 35772 737 7 reason reason NN 35772 737 8 , , , 35772 737 9 " " '' 35772 737 10 man man NN 35772 737 11 gets get VBZ 35772 737 12 into into IN 35772 737 13 touch touch NN 35772 737 14 with with IN 35772 737 15 that that DT 35772 737 16 real real JJ 35772 737 17 world world NN 35772 737 18 , , , 35772 737 19 which which WDT 35772 737 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 737 21 " " `` 35772 737 22 theoretical theoretical JJ 35772 737 23 reason reason NN 35772 737 24 " " '' 35772 737 25 is be VBZ 35772 737 26 unable unable JJ 35772 737 27 to to TO 35772 737 28 reach reach VB 35772 737 29 . . . 35772 738 1 In in IN 35772 738 2 fact fact NN 35772 738 3 , , , 35772 738 4 the the DT 35772 738 5 " " `` 35772 738 6 practical practical JJ 35772 738 7 reason reason NN 35772 738 8 " " '' 35772 738 9 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 738 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 738 11 or or CC 35772 738 12 moral moral JJ 35772 738 13 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 738 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 738 15 is be VBZ 35772 738 16 an an DT 35772 738 17 element element NN 35772 738 18 in in IN 35772 738 19 man man NN 35772 738 20 's 's POS 35772 738 21 nature nature NN 35772 738 22 which which WDT 35772 738 23 belongs belong VBZ 35772 738 24 to to IN 35772 738 25 the the DT 35772 738 26 _ _ NNP 35772 738 27 real real JJ 35772 738 28 _ _ NNP 35772 738 29 , , , 35772 738 30 as as IN 35772 738 31 opposed oppose VBN 35772 738 32 to to IN 35772 738 33 the the DT 35772 738 34 _ _ NNP 35772 738 35 phenomenal phenomenal NN 35772 738 36 _ _ NNP 35772 738 37 world world NN 35772 738 38 . . . 35772 739 1 For for IN 35772 739 2 man man NN 35772 739 3 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 739 4 is be VBZ 35772 739 5 a a DT 35772 739 6 citizen citizen NN 35772 739 7 of of IN 35772 739 8 both both DT 35772 739 9 worlds world NNS 35772 739 10 , , , 35772 739 11 and and CC 35772 739 12 has have VBZ 35772 739 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 739 14 so so RB 35772 739 15 to to TO 35772 739 16 speak speak VB 35772 739 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 739 18 a a DT 35772 739 19 dual dual JJ 35772 739 20 nature nature NN 35772 739 21 , , , 35772 739 22 a a DT 35772 739 23 foot foot NN 35772 739 24 on on IN 35772 739 25 either either DT 35772 739 26 shore shore NN 35772 739 27 . . . 35772 740 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 740 2 is be VBZ 35772 740 3 an an DT 35772 740 4 inhabitant inhabitant NN 35772 740 5 both both DT 35772 740 6 of of IN 35772 740 7 the the DT 35772 740 8 world world NN 35772 740 9 of of IN 35772 740 10 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 740 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 740 12 , , , 35772 740 13 and and CC 35772 740 14 of of IN 35772 740 15 the the DT 35772 740 16 " " `` 35772 740 17 timeless timeless NN 35772 740 18 world world NN 35772 740 19 of of IN 35772 740 20 freedom freedom NN 35772 740 21 , , , 35772 740 22 " " '' 35772 740 23 which which WDT 35772 740 24 lies lie VBZ 35772 740 25 altogether altogether RB 35772 740 26 outside outside IN 35772 740 27 of of IN 35772 740 28 all all DT 35772 740 29 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 740 30 conceptions conception NNS 35772 740 31 . . . 35772 741 1 KANT KANT NNP 35772 741 2 AND and CC 35772 741 3 RELIGION.--"Religion religion.--"religion NN 35772 741 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 741 5 must must MD 35772 741 6 seek seek VB 35772 741 7 in in IN 35772 741 8 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 741 9 , , , 35772 741 10 not not RB 35772 741 11 outside outside IN 35772 741 12 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 741 13 , , , 35772 741 14 " " `` 35772 741 15 is be VBZ 35772 741 16 a a DT 35772 741 17 saying saying NN 35772 741 18 of of IN 35772 741 19 Kant Kant NNP 35772 741 20 's 's POS 35772 741 21 that that WDT 35772 741 22 gives give VBZ 35772 741 23 the the DT 35772 741 24 clue clue NN 35772 741 25 to to IN 35772 741 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 741 27 general general JJ 35772 741 28 attitude attitude NN 35772 741 29 . . . 35772 742 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 742 2 is be VBZ 35772 742 3 only only RB 35772 742 4 in in IN 35772 742 5 that that DT 35772 742 6 world world NN 35772 742 7 which which WDT 35772 742 8 can can MD 35772 742 9 not not RB 35772 742 10 be be VB 35772 742 11 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 742 12 mechanically mechanically RB 35772 742 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 742 14 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 743 1 the the DT 35772 743 2 inner inner JJ 35772 743 3 world world NN 35772 743 4 of of IN 35772 743 5 freedom freedom NN 35772 743 6 of of IN 35772 743 7 which which WDT 35772 743 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 743 9 never never RB 35772 743 10 cease cease VBP 35772 743 11 to to TO 35772 743 12 be be VB 35772 743 13 conscious conscious JJ 35772 743 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 743 15 that that IN 35772 743 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 743 17 may may MD 35772 743 18 seek seek VB 35772 743 19 , , , 35772 743 20 or or CC 35772 743 21 can can MD 35772 743 22 hope hope VB 35772 743 23 to to TO 35772 743 24 find find VB 35772 743 25 the the DT 35772 743 26 source source NN 35772 743 27 of of IN 35772 743 28 religion religion NN 35772 743 29 . . . 35772 744 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 744 2 is be VBZ 35772 744 3 not not RB 35772 744 4 the the DT 35772 744 5 spectacle spectacle NN 35772 744 6 of of IN 35772 744 7 the the DT 35772 744 8 mechanically mechanically RB 35772 744 9 determined determine VBN 35772 744 10 world world NN 35772 744 11 of of IN 35772 744 12 nature nature NN 35772 744 13 , , , 35772 744 14 but but CC 35772 744 15 the the DT 35772 744 16 demands demand NNS 35772 744 17 of of IN 35772 744 18 the the DT 35772 744 19 moral moral JJ 35772 744 20 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 744 21 that that WDT 35772 744 22 create create VBP 35772 744 23 religion religion NN 35772 744 24 . . . 35772 745 1 For for IN 35772 745 2 instance instance NN 35772 745 3 , , , 35772 745 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 745 5 is be VBZ 35772 745 6 the the DT 35772 745 7 gulf gulf NN 35772 745 8 that that WDT 35772 745 9 yawns yawn NNS 35772 745 10 between between IN 35772 745 11 the the DT 35772 745 12 ideal ideal JJ 35772 745 13 commands command NNS 35772 745 14 of of IN 35772 745 15 the the DT 35772 745 16 moral moral JJ 35772 745 17 law law NN 35772 745 18 , , , 35772 745 19 and and CC 35772 745 20 the the DT 35772 745 21 actual actual JJ 35772 745 22 possibilities possibility NNS 35772 745 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 745 24 so so RB 35772 745 25 poor poor JJ 35772 745 26 and and CC 35772 745 27 meagre meagre JJ 35772 745 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 745 29 of of IN 35772 745 30 fulfilling fulfil VBG 35772 745 31 and and CC 35772 745 32 satisfying satisfy VBG 35772 745 33 them -PRON- PRP 35772 745 34 , , , 35772 745 35 that that DT 35772 745 36 creates create VBZ 35772 745 37 , , , 35772 745 38 in in IN 35772 745 39 the the DT 35772 745 40 view view NN 35772 745 41 of of IN 35772 745 42 Kant Kant NNP 35772 745 43 , , , 35772 745 44 the the DT 35772 745 45 need need NN 35772 745 46 of of IN 35772 745 47 God God NNP 35772 745 48 and and CC 35772 745 49 immortality immortality NN 35772 745 50 . . . 35772 746 1 These these DT 35772 746 2 alone alone RB 35772 746 3 can can MD 35772 746 4 guarantee guarantee VB 35772 746 5 the the DT 35772 746 6 realisation realisation NN 35772 746 7 of of IN 35772 746 8 the the DT 35772 746 9 ideal ideal JJ 35772 746 10 claims claim NNS 35772 746 11 of of IN 35772 746 12 the the DT 35772 746 13 moral moral JJ 35772 746 14 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 746 15 . . . 35772 747 1 RELIGIOUS RELIGIOUS NNP 35772 747 2 FAITH.--Thus faith.--thu VBZ 35772 747 3 the the DT 35772 747 4 " " `` 35772 747 5 practical practical JJ 35772 747 6 reason reason NN 35772 747 7 " " '' 35772 747 8 leads lead VBZ 35772 747 9 on on RP 35772 747 10 to to IN 35772 747 11 convictions conviction NNS 35772 747 12 concerning concern VBG 35772 747 13 what what WP 35772 747 14 lies lie VBZ 35772 747 15 beyond beyond IN 35772 747 16 the the DT 35772 747 17 limits limit NNS 35772 747 18 defined define VBN 35772 747 19 by by IN 35772 747 20 the the DT 35772 747 21 " " `` 35772 747 22 theoretical theoretical JJ 35772 747 23 reason reason NN 35772 747 24 . . . 35772 747 25 " " '' 35772 748 1 The the DT 35772 748 2 nature nature NN 35772 748 3 of of IN 35772 748 4 the the DT 35772 748 5 demands demand NNS 35772 748 6 of of IN 35772 748 7 the the DT 35772 748 8 moral moral JJ 35772 748 9 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 748 10 give give VB 35772 748 11 us -PRON- PRP 35772 748 12 an an DT 35772 748 13 insight insight NN 35772 748 14 into into IN 35772 748 15 the the DT 35772 748 16 nature nature NN 35772 748 17 of of IN 35772 748 18 the the DT 35772 748 19 super super JJ 35772 748 20 - - JJ 35772 748 21 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 35772 748 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 748 23 transcendental transcendental JJ 35772 748 24 , , , 35772 748 25 noumenal noumenal JJ 35772 748 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 748 27 world world NN 35772 748 28 . . . 35772 749 1 That that DT 35772 749 2 world world NN 35772 749 3 must must MD 35772 749 4 be be VB 35772 749 5 of of IN 35772 749 6 such such PDT 35772 749 7 a a DT 35772 749 8 kind kind NN 35772 749 9 as as IN 35772 749 10 to to IN 35772 749 11 sanction sanction NN 35772 749 12 and and CC 35772 749 13 guarantee guarantee VB 35772 749 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 749 15 moral moral JJ 35772 749 16 ideals ideal NNS 35772 749 17 ; ; : 35772 749 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 749 19 must must MD 35772 749 20 be be VB 35772 749 21 friendly friendly JJ 35772 749 22 and and CC 35772 749 23 not not RB 35772 749 24 hostile hostile JJ 35772 749 25 or or CC 35772 749 26 indifferent indifferent JJ 35772 749 27 to to IN 35772 749 28 those those DT 35772 749 29 ideals ideal NNS 35772 749 30 which which WDT 35772 749 31 man man NN 35772 749 32 cherishes cherish VBZ 35772 749 33 , , , 35772 749 34 but but CC 35772 749 35 which which WDT 35772 749 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 749 37 " " `` 35772 749 38 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 35772 749 39 " " '' 35772 749 40 experience experience NN 35772 749 41 seems seem VBZ 35772 749 42 to to TO 35772 749 43 contradict contradict VB 35772 749 44 . . . 35772 750 1 Thus thus RB 35772 750 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 750 3 see see VBP 35772 750 4 the the DT 35772 750 5 truth truth NN 35772 750 6 of of IN 35772 750 7 the the DT 35772 750 8 saying saying NN 35772 750 9 that that IN 35772 750 10 " " `` 35772 750 11 The the DT 35772 750 12 universe universe NN 35772 750 13 as as IN 35772 750 14 a a DT 35772 750 15 moral moral JJ 35772 750 16 system system NN 35772 750 17 is be VBZ 35772 750 18 the the DT 35772 750 19 last last JJ 35772 750 20 word word NN 35772 750 21 of of IN 35772 750 22 the the DT 35772 750 23 Kantian kantian JJ 35772 750 24 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 750 25 . . . 35772 751 1 " " `` 35772 751 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 751 3 24 24 CD 35772 751 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 751 5 KANT KANT NNP 35772 751 6 'S 's POS 35772 751 7 INFLUENCE.--Kant influence.--kant NN 35772 751 8 was be VBD 35772 751 9 one one CD 35772 751 10 of of IN 35772 751 11 those those DT 35772 751 12 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 751 13 who who WP 35772 751 14 are be VBP 35772 751 15 responsible responsible JJ 35772 751 16 for for IN 35772 751 17 turning turn VBG 35772 751 18 the the DT 35772 751 19 stream stream NN 35772 751 20 of of IN 35772 751 21 thought thought NN 35772 751 22 into into IN 35772 751 23 fresh fresh JJ 35772 751 24 channels channel NNS 35772 751 25 . . . 35772 752 1 Through through IN 35772 752 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 752 3 researches research NNS 35772 752 4 into into IN 35772 752 5 the the DT 35772 752 6 nature nature NN 35772 752 7 of of IN 35772 752 8 human human JJ 35772 752 9 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 752 10 , , , 35772 752 11 he -PRON- PRP 35772 752 12 discovered discover VBD 35772 752 13 the the DT 35772 752 14 conditions condition NNS 35772 752 15 upon upon IN 35772 752 16 which which WDT 35772 752 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 752 18 rests rest VBZ 35772 752 19 , , , 35772 752 20 and and CC 35772 752 21 defined define VBD 35772 752 22 the the DT 35772 752 23 limits limit NNS 35772 752 24 beyond beyond IN 35772 752 25 which which WDT 35772 752 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 752 27 can can MD 35772 752 28 not not RB 35772 752 29 pass pass VB 35772 752 30 . . . 35772 753 1 Thus thus RB 35772 753 2 , , , 35772 753 3 once once RB 35772 753 4 for for IN 35772 753 5 all all DT 35772 753 6 , , , 35772 753 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 753 8 put put VBD 35772 753 9 an an DT 35772 753 10 end end NN 35772 753 11 to to IN 35772 753 12 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 753 13 . . . 35772 754 1 And and CC 35772 754 2 to to IN 35772 754 3 Kant Kant NNP 35772 754 4 also also RB 35772 754 5 belongs belong VBZ 35772 754 6 the the DT 35772 754 7 credit credit NN 35772 754 8 of of IN 35772 754 9 having have VBG 35772 754 10 established establish VBN 35772 754 11 the the DT 35772 754 12 reality reality NN 35772 754 13 and and CC 35772 754 14 validity validity NN 35772 754 15 of of IN 35772 754 16 _ _ NNP 35772 754 17 inner inner JJ 35772 754 18 _ _ NNP 35772 754 19 experience experience NN 35772 754 20 . . . 35772 755 1 The the DT 35772 755 2 rock rock NN 35772 755 3 upon upon IN 35772 755 4 which which WDT 35772 755 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 755 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 755 7 is be VBZ 35772 755 8 built build VBN 35772 755 9 is be VBZ 35772 755 10 no no DT 35772 755 11 external external JJ 35772 755 12 fact fact NN 35772 755 13 or or CC 35772 755 14 event event NN 35772 755 15 -- -- : 35772 755 16 nothing nothing NN 35772 755 17 in in IN 35772 755 18 time time NN 35772 755 19 or or CC 35772 755 20 space space NN 35772 755 21 -- -- : 35772 755 22 but but CC 35772 755 23 the the DT 35772 755 24 moral moral JJ 35772 755 25 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 755 26 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 755 27 . . . 35772 756 1 And and CC 35772 756 2 thus thus RB 35772 756 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 756 4 restores restore VBZ 35772 756 5 , , , 35772 756 6 as as IN 35772 756 7 the the DT 35772 756 8 central central JJ 35772 756 9 interest interest NN 35772 756 10 of of IN 35772 756 11 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 756 12 , , , 35772 756 13 the the DT 35772 756 14 human human JJ 35772 756 15 individual individual NN 35772 756 16 , , , 35772 756 17 with with IN 35772 756 18 all all PDT 35772 756 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 756 20 experiences experience NNS 35772 756 21 of of IN 35772 756 22 need need NN 35772 756 23 , , , 35772 756 24 of of IN 35772 756 25 hope hope NN 35772 756 26 , , , 35772 756 27 and and CC 35772 756 28 of of IN 35772 756 29 insight insight NN 35772 756 30 . . . 35772 757 1 Personality personality NN 35772 757 2 is be VBZ 35772 757 3 the the DT 35772 757 4 principle principle NN 35772 757 5 of of IN 35772 757 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 757 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 757 8 . . . 35772 758 1 In in IN 35772 758 2 this this DT 35772 758 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 758 4 is be VBZ 35772 758 5 the the DT 35772 758 6 true true JJ 35772 758 7 successor successor NN 35772 758 8 of of IN 35772 758 9 the the DT 35772 758 10 Reformation Reformation NNP 35772 758 11 . . . 35772 759 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 759 2 VII VII NNP 35772 759 3 THE the DT 35772 759 4 ROMANTIC romantic NN 35772 759 5 MOVEMENT MOVEMENT NNP 35772 759 6 KANT KANT NNP 35772 759 7 AND and CC 35772 759 8 AFTER.--With AFTER.--With NNP 35772 759 9 Kant Kant NNP 35772 759 10 the the DT 35772 759 11 hey hey NN 35772 759 12 - - HYPH 35772 759 13 day day NN 35772 759 14 of of IN 35772 759 15 rationalism rationalism NN 35772 759 16 terminated terminate VBN 35772 759 17 . . . 35772 760 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 760 2 had have VBD 35772 760 3 put put VBN 35772 760 4 an an DT 35772 760 5 end end NN 35772 760 6 to to IN 35772 760 7 the the DT 35772 760 8 superficial superficial JJ 35772 760 9 psychology psychology NN 35772 760 10 upon upon IN 35772 760 11 which which WDT 35772 760 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 760 13 rested rest VBD 35772 760 14 . . . 35772 761 1 For for IN 35772 761 2 the the DT 35772 761 3 rationalists rationalist NNS 35772 761 4 , , , 35772 761 5 the the DT 35772 761 6 life life NN 35772 761 7 of of IN 35772 761 8 the the DT 35772 761 9 mind mind NN 35772 761 10 had have VBD 35772 761 11 consisted consist VBN 35772 761 12 in in IN 35772 761 13 _ _ NNP 35772 761 14 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 761 15 ideas idea NNS 35772 761 16 _ _ NNP 35772 761 17 ; ; : 35772 761 18 but but CC 35772 761 19 a a DT 35772 761 20 more more RBR 35772 761 21 careful careful JJ 35772 761 22 analysis analysis NN 35772 761 23 indicated indicate VBD 35772 761 24 the the DT 35772 761 25 presence presence NN 35772 761 26 of of IN 35772 761 27 deeper deeply RBR 35772 761 28 - - HYPH 35772 761 29 lying lie VBG 35772 761 30 elements element NNS 35772 761 31 , , , 35772 761 32 which which WDT 35772 761 33 had have VBD 35772 761 34 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 761 35 been be VBN 35772 761 36 disregarded disregard VBN 35772 761 37 ; ; : 35772 761 38 there there EX 35772 761 39 existed exist VBD 35772 761 40 other other JJ 35772 761 41 important important JJ 35772 761 42 constituents constituent NNS 35772 761 43 besides besides IN 35772 761 44 the the DT 35772 761 45 intellectual intellectual NN 35772 761 46 . . . 35772 762 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 762 2 's 's POS 35772 762 3 criticism criticism NN 35772 762 4 of of IN 35772 762 5 " " `` 35772 762 6 pure pure JJ 35772 762 7 reason reason NN 35772 762 8 " " '' 35772 762 9 did do VBD 35772 762 10 much much JJ 35772 762 11 to to TO 35772 762 12 discredit discredit VB 35772 762 13 the the DT 35772 762 14 old old JJ 35772 762 15 view view NN 35772 762 16 ; ; : 35772 762 17 and and CC 35772 762 18 by by IN 35772 762 19 founding found VBG 35772 762 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 762 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 762 22 upon upon IN 35772 762 23 the the DT 35772 762 24 non non JJ 35772 762 25 - - JJ 35772 762 26 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 762 27 " " '' 35772 762 28 moral moral JJ 35772 762 29 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 762 30 , , , 35772 762 31 " " '' 35772 762 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 762 33 heightened heighten VBD 35772 762 34 the the DT 35772 762 35 prestige prestige NN 35772 762 36 of of IN 35772 762 37 feeling feeling NN 35772 762 38 as as IN 35772 762 39 against against IN 35772 762 40 reason reason NN 35772 762 41 ( ( -LRB- 35772 762 42 in in IN 35772 762 43 the the DT 35772 762 44 narrow narrow JJ 35772 762 45 and and CC 35772 762 46 limited limited JJ 35772 762 47 sense sense NN 35772 762 48 of of IN 35772 762 49 that that DT 35772 762 50 word word NN 35772 762 51 ) ) -RRB- 35772 762 52 . . . 35772 763 1 Thus thus RB 35772 763 2 Kant Kant NNP 35772 763 3 is be VBZ 35772 763 4 not not RB 35772 763 5 undeservedly undeservedly RB 35772 763 6 called call VBN 35772 763 7 the the DT 35772 763 8 father father NN 35772 763 9 of of IN 35772 763 10 a a DT 35772 763 11 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 763 12 which which WDT 35772 763 13 succeeded succeed VBD 35772 763 14 him -PRON- PRP 35772 763 15 , , , 35772 763 16 and and CC 35772 763 17 which which WDT 35772 763 18 was be VBD 35772 763 19 based base VBN 35772 763 20 upon upon IN 35772 763 21 the the DT 35772 763 22 idea idea NN 35772 763 23 of of IN 35772 763 24 the the DT 35772 763 25 supremacy supremacy NN 35772 763 26 of of IN 35772 763 27 feeling feeling NN 35772 763 28 . . . 35772 764 1 But but CC 35772 764 2 , , , 35772 764 3 at at IN 35772 764 4 the the DT 35772 764 5 same same JJ 35772 764 6 time time NN 35772 764 7 , , , 35772 764 8 that that DT 35772 764 9 title title NN 35772 764 10 is be VBZ 35772 764 11 more more RBR 35772 764 12 accurate accurate JJ 35772 764 13 as as IN 35772 764 14 an an DT 35772 764 15 estimate estimate NN 35772 764 16 of of IN 35772 764 17 another another DT 35772 764 18 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 764 19 of of IN 35772 764 20 rather rather RB 35772 764 21 different different JJ 35772 764 22 characteristics characteristic NNS 35772 764 23 . . . 35772 765 1 ROUSSEAU.--Jean ROUSSEAU.--Jean NNP 35772 765 2 Jacques Jacques NNP 35772 765 3 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 765 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 765 5 1712 1712 CD 35772 765 6 - - SYM 35772 765 7 1778 1778 CD 35772 765 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 765 9 was be VBD 35772 765 10 a a DT 35772 765 11 man man NN 35772 765 12 of of IN 35772 765 13 unique unique JJ 35772 765 14 genius genius NN 35772 765 15 whose whose WP$ 35772 765 16 figure figure NN 35772 765 17 occupies occupy VBZ 35772 765 18 a a DT 35772 765 19 prominent prominent JJ 35772 765 20 position position NN 35772 765 21 not not RB 35772 765 22 only only RB 35772 765 23 in in IN 35772 765 24 the the DT 35772 765 25 annals annal NNS 35772 765 26 of of IN 35772 765 27 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 765 28 , , , 35772 765 29 but but CC 35772 765 30 in in IN 35772 765 31 social social JJ 35772 765 32 , , , 35772 765 33 political political JJ 35772 765 34 , , , 35772 765 35 and and CC 35772 765 36 literary literary JJ 35772 765 37 history history NN 35772 765 38 . . . 35772 766 1 Even even RB 35772 766 2 more more JJR 35772 766 3 than than IN 35772 766 4 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 766 5 was be VBD 35772 766 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 766 7 responsible responsible JJ 35772 766 8 for for IN 35772 766 9 sowing sow VBG 35772 766 10 seeds seed NNS 35772 766 11 of of IN 35772 766 12 thought thought NN 35772 766 13 which which WDT 35772 766 14 bore bear VBD 35772 766 15 fruit fruit NN 35772 766 16 in in IN 35772 766 17 the the DT 35772 766 18 events event NNS 35772 766 19 of of IN 35772 766 20 the the DT 35772 766 21 Revolution Revolution NNP 35772 766 22 . . . 35772 767 1 And and CC 35772 767 2 indeed indeed RB 35772 767 3 , , , 35772 767 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 767 5 is be VBZ 35772 767 6 as as IN 35772 767 7 the the DT 35772 767 8 author author NN 35772 767 9 of of IN 35772 767 10 the the DT 35772 767 11 notorious notorious JJ 35772 767 12 _ _ NNP 35772 767 13 Contrat Contrat NNP 35772 767 14 Social Social NNP 35772 767 15 _ _ NNP 35772 767 16 that that IN 35772 767 17 he -PRON- PRP 35772 767 18 is be VBZ 35772 767 19 most most RBS 35772 767 20 widely widely RB 35772 767 21 known know VBN 35772 767 22 . . . 35772 768 1 ROUSSEAU ROUSSEAU NNP 35772 768 2 'S 'S NNP 35772 768 3 " " `` 35772 768 4 SENSIBILITY SENSIBILITY NNP 35772 768 5 . . . 35772 768 6 " " '' 35772 769 1 --Rousseau --Rousseau : 35772 769 2 was be VBD 35772 769 3 one one CD 35772 769 4 of of IN 35772 769 5 those those DT 35772 769 6 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 769 7 whose whose WP$ 35772 769 8 character character NN 35772 769 9 is be VBZ 35772 769 10 the the DT 35772 769 11 formative formative JJ 35772 769 12 element element NN 35772 769 13 which which WDT 35772 769 14 gives give VBZ 35772 769 15 shape shape NN 35772 769 16 to to IN 35772 769 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 769 18 doctrines doctrine NNS 35772 769 19 . . . 35772 770 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 770 2 was be VBD 35772 770 3 a a DT 35772 770 4 profoundly profoundly RB 35772 770 5 emotional emotional JJ 35772 770 6 temperament temperament NN 35772 770 7 . . . 35772 771 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 771 2 left leave VBD 35772 771 3 behind behind IN 35772 771 4 him -PRON- PRP 35772 771 5 an an DT 35772 771 6 invaluable invaluable JJ 35772 771 7 document document NN 35772 771 8 which which WDT 35772 771 9 lays lay VBZ 35772 771 10 bare bare VBP 35772 771 11 all all PDT 35772 771 12 the the DT 35772 771 13 psychological psychological JJ 35772 771 14 sources source NNS 35772 771 15 of of IN 35772 771 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 771 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 771 18 . . . 35772 772 1 The the DT 35772 772 2 _ _ NNP 35772 772 3 Confessions Confessions NNPS 35772 772 4 _ _ NNP 35772 772 5 reveal reveal VBP 35772 772 6 to to IN 35772 772 7 us -PRON- PRP 35772 772 8 a a DT 35772 772 9 man man NN 35772 772 10 highly highly RB 35772 772 11 sensitive sensitive JJ 35772 772 12 and and CC 35772 772 13 morbidly morbidly RB 35772 772 14 introspective introspective JJ 35772 772 15 , , , 35772 772 16 the the DT 35772 772 17 slave slave NN 35772 772 18 of of IN 35772 772 19 unreasoning unreasone VBG 35772 772 20 impulses impulse NNS 35772 772 21 and and CC 35772 772 22 passions passion NNS 35772 772 23 . . . 35772 773 1 In in IN 35772 773 2 the the DT 35772 773 3 eyes eye NNS 35772 773 4 of of IN 35772 773 5 some some DT 35772 773 6 short short JJ 35772 773 7 - - HYPH 35772 773 8 sighted sighted JJ 35772 773 9 persons person NNS 35772 773 10 , , , 35772 773 11 these these DT 35772 773 12 first first JJ 35772 773 13 - - HYPH 35772 773 14 hand hand NN 35772 773 15 revelations revelation NNS 35772 773 16 will will MD 35772 773 17 obscure obscure VB 35772 773 18 or or CC 35772 773 19 cast cast VBN 35772 773 20 doubt doubt NN 35772 773 21 upon upon IN 35772 773 22 the the DT 35772 773 23 capacity capacity NN 35772 773 24 and and CC 35772 773 25 genius genius NN 35772 773 26 of of IN 35772 773 27 the the DT 35772 773 28 man man NN 35772 773 29 , , , 35772 773 30 for for IN 35772 773 31 they -PRON- PRP 35772 773 32 do do VBP 35772 773 33 little little JJ 35772 773 34 to to TO 35772 773 35 prejudice prejudice VB 35772 773 36 opinion opinion NN 35772 773 37 in in IN 35772 773 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 773 39 favour favour NN 35772 773 40 . . . 35772 774 1 HE he PRP 35772 774 2 DEFIES defy VBZ 35772 774 3 THE the DT 35772 774 4 ZEITGEIST.--Rousseau zeitgeist.--rousseau NN 35772 774 5 's 's POS 35772 774 6 profound profound JJ 35772 774 7 originality originality NN 35772 774 8 lies lie VBZ 35772 774 9 in in IN 35772 774 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 774 11 having have VBG 35772 774 12 dared dare VBN 35772 774 13 to to TO 35772 774 14 dispute dispute VB 35772 774 15 a a DT 35772 774 16 dogma dogma NN 35772 774 17 to to TO 35772 774 18 which which WDT 35772 774 19 the the DT 35772 774 20 prestige prestige NN 35772 774 21 of of IN 35772 774 22 an an DT 35772 774 23 axiom axiom NN 35772 774 24 then then RB 35772 774 25 attached attach VBD 35772 774 26 . . . 35772 775 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 775 2 endeavoured endeavour VBD 35772 775 3 to to TO 35772 775 4 undermine undermine VB 35772 775 5 the the DT 35772 775 6 popular popular JJ 35772 775 7 faith faith NN 35772 775 8 in in IN 35772 775 9 scientific scientific JJ 35772 775 10 and and CC 35772 775 11 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 775 12 culture culture NN 35772 775 13 . . . 35772 776 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 776 2 went go VBD 35772 776 3 right right RB 35772 776 4 back back RB 35772 776 5 to to IN 35772 776 6 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 776 7 , , , 35772 776 8 who who WP 35772 776 9 , , , 35772 776 10 a a DT 35772 776 11 century century NN 35772 776 12 before before RB 35772 776 13 , , , 35772 776 14 had have VBD 35772 776 15 raised raise VBN 35772 776 16 the the DT 35772 776 17 question question NN 35772 776 18 as as IN 35772 776 19 to to IN 35772 776 20 the the DT 35772 776 21 value value NN 35772 776 22 of of IN 35772 776 23 scientific scientific JJ 35772 776 24 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 776 25 for for IN 35772 776 26 personal personal JJ 35772 776 27 life life NN 35772 776 28 , , , 35772 776 29 by by IN 35772 776 30 proclaiming proclaim VBG 35772 776 31 " " `` 35772 776 32 The the DT 35772 776 33 whole whole NN 35772 776 34 of of IN 35772 776 35 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 776 36 is be VBZ 35772 776 37 not not RB 35772 776 38 worth worth JJ 35772 776 39 an an DT 35772 776 40 hour hour NN 35772 776 41 's 's POS 35772 776 42 study study NN 35772 776 43 . . . 35772 776 44 " " '' 35772 777 1 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 777 2 's 's POS 35772 777 3 first first JJ 35772 777 4 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 777 5 work work NN 35772 777 6 was be VBD 35772 777 7 occasioned occasion VBN 35772 777 8 by by IN 35772 777 9 the the DT 35772 777 10 offer offer NN 35772 777 11 of of IN 35772 777 12 a a DT 35772 777 13 prize prize NN 35772 777 14 on on IN 35772 777 15 the the DT 35772 777 16 part part NN 35772 777 17 of of IN 35772 777 18 a a DT 35772 777 19 provincial provincial JJ 35772 777 20 academy academy NN 35772 777 21 for for IN 35772 777 22 a a DT 35772 777 23 thesis thesis NN 35772 777 24 on on IN 35772 777 25 the the DT 35772 777 26 problem problem NN 35772 777 27 " " '' 35772 777 28 Whether whether IN 35772 777 29 the the DT 35772 777 30 restoration restoration NN 35772 777 31 of of IN 35772 777 32 the the DT 35772 777 33 sciences science NNS 35772 777 34 and and CC 35772 777 35 arts art NNS 35772 777 36 has have VBZ 35772 777 37 contributed contribute VBN 35772 777 38 to to TO 35772 777 39 purify purify VB 35772 777 40 manners manner NNS 35772 777 41 ? ? . 35772 777 42 " " '' 35772 778 1 " " `` 35772 778 2 The the DT 35772 778 3 question question NN 35772 778 4 pierced pierce VBD 35772 778 5 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 778 6 's 's POS 35772 778 7 soul soul NN 35772 778 8 like like IN 35772 778 9 a a DT 35772 778 10 flash flash NN 35772 778 11 of of IN 35772 778 12 lightning lightning NN 35772 778 13 . . . 35772 778 14 " " '' 35772 779 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 779 2 felt feel VBD 35772 779 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 779 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 779 5 tells tell VBZ 35772 779 6 us -PRON- PRP 35772 779 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 779 8 that that IN 35772 779 9 he -PRON- PRP 35772 779 10 saw see VBD 35772 779 11 a a DT 35772 779 12 new new JJ 35772 779 13 world world NN 35772 779 14 , , , 35772 779 15 and and CC 35772 779 16 felt feel VBD 35772 779 17 a a DT 35772 779 18 new new JJ 35772 779 19 man man NN 35772 779 20 ; ; : 35772 779 21 he -PRON- PRP 35772 779 22 saw see VBD 35772 779 23 no no RB 35772 779 24 longer long RBR 35772 779 25 the the DT 35772 779 26 world world NN 35772 779 27 of of IN 35772 779 28 culture culture NN 35772 779 29 , , , 35772 779 30 of of IN 35772 779 31 science science NN 35772 779 32 , , , 35772 779 33 of of IN 35772 779 34 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 779 35 ( ( -LRB- 35772 779 36 which which WDT 35772 779 37 he -PRON- PRP 35772 779 38 felt feel VBD 35772 779 39 to to TO 35772 779 40 be be VB 35772 779 41 as as RB 35772 779 42 artificial artificial JJ 35772 779 43 as as IN 35772 779 44 it -PRON- PRP 35772 779 45 was be VBD 35772 779 46 ineffective ineffective JJ 35772 779 47 and and CC 35772 779 48 vain vain JJ 35772 779 49 ) ) -RRB- 35772 779 50 , , , 35772 779 51 but but CC 35772 779 52 the the DT 35772 779 53 _ _ NNP 35772 779 54 real real JJ 35772 779 55 _ _ NNP 35772 779 56 world world NN 35772 779 57 of of IN 35772 779 58 personality personality NN 35772 779 59 , , , 35772 779 60 of of IN 35772 779 61 living live VBG 35772 779 62 feeling feeling NN 35772 779 63 , , , 35772 779 64 of of IN 35772 779 65 the the DT 35772 779 66 inner inner JJ 35772 779 67 life life NN 35772 779 68 . . . 35772 780 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 780 2 flashed flash VBD 35772 780 3 upon upon IN 35772 780 4 him -PRON- PRP 35772 780 5 that that IN 35772 780 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 780 7 was be VBD 35772 780 8 the the DT 35772 780 9 primitive primitive JJ 35772 780 10 and and CC 35772 780 11 elementary elementary JJ 35772 780 12 feelings feeling NNS 35772 780 13 , , , 35772 780 14 the the DT 35772 780 15 great great JJ 35772 780 16 and and CC 35772 780 17 simple simple JJ 35772 780 18 relations relation NNS 35772 780 19 of of IN 35772 780 20 life life NN 35772 780 21 , , , 35772 780 22 which which WDT 35772 780 23 gave give VBD 35772 780 24 to to TO 35772 780 25 existence existence VB 35772 780 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 780 27 value value NN 35772 780 28 . . . 35772 781 1 The the DT 35772 781 2 rest rest NN 35772 781 3 was be VBD 35772 781 4 superficial superficial JJ 35772 781 5 and and CC 35772 781 6 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 781 7 . . . 35772 782 1 ROUSSEAU ROUSSEAU NNS 35772 782 2 AND and CC 35772 782 3 RELIGION.--The religion.--the UH 35772 782 4 intellectualist intellectualist JJ 35772 782 5 is be VBZ 35772 782 6 ever ever RB 35772 782 7 the the DT 35772 782 8 aristocrat aristocrat NN 35772 782 9 . . . 35772 783 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 783 2 25 25 CD 35772 783 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 783 4 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 783 5 and and CC 35772 783 6 the the DT 35772 783 7 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 783 8 of of IN 35772 783 9 the the DT 35772 783 10 " " `` 35772 783 11 enlightenment enlightenment NN 35772 783 12 " " '' 35772 783 13 spoke speak VBD 35772 783 14 of of IN 35772 783 15 the the DT 35772 783 16 unenlightened unenlightened JJ 35772 783 17 multitude multitude NN 35772 783 18 as as IN 35772 783 19 _ _ NNP 35772 783 20 la la NNP 35772 783 21 canaille canaille NNP 35772 783 22 _ _ NNP 35772 783 23 . . . 35772 784 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 784 2 beliefs belief NNS 35772 784 3 were be VBD 35772 784 4 superstitions superstition NNS 35772 784 5 . . . 35772 785 1 Rousseau rousseau NN 35772 785 2 knew know VBD 35772 785 3 that that IN 35772 785 4 the the DT 35772 785 5 things thing NNS 35772 785 6 which which WDT 35772 785 7 men man NNS 35772 785 8 have have VBP 35772 785 9 in in IN 35772 785 10 common common JJ 35772 785 11 are be VBP 35772 785 12 more more RBR 35772 785 13 vital vital JJ 35772 785 14 than than IN 35772 785 15 those those DT 35772 785 16 in in IN 35772 785 17 which which WDT 35772 785 18 they -PRON- PRP 35772 785 19 differ differ VBP 35772 785 20 , , , 35772 785 21 and and CC 35772 785 22 the the DT 35772 785 23 primitive primitive JJ 35772 785 24 instincts instinct NNS 35772 785 25 of of IN 35772 785 26 the the DT 35772 785 27 race race NN 35772 785 28 which which WDT 35772 785 29 we -PRON- PRP 35772 785 30 all all DT 35772 785 31 share share VBP 35772 785 32 , , , 35772 785 33 are be VBP 35772 785 34 the the DT 35772 785 35 most most RBS 35772 785 36 important important JJ 35772 785 37 part part NN 35772 785 38 of of IN 35772 785 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 785 40 nature nature NN 35772 785 41 . . . 35772 786 1 Among among IN 35772 786 2 these these DT 35772 786 3 primitive primitive JJ 35772 786 4 instincts instinct NNS 35772 786 5 , , , 35772 786 6 indomitable indomitable JJ 35772 786 7 and and CC 35772 786 8 irrepressible irrepressible JJ 35772 786 9 , , , 35772 786 10 is be VBZ 35772 786 11 the the DT 35772 786 12 instinct instinct NN 35772 786 13 of of IN 35772 786 14 religion religion NN 35772 786 15 . . . 35772 787 1 Thus thus RB 35772 787 2 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 787 3 transferred transfer VBD 35772 787 4 the the DT 35772 787 5 religious religious JJ 35772 787 6 problem problem NN 35772 787 7 from from IN 35772 787 8 the the DT 35772 787 9 sphere sphere NN 35772 787 10 of of IN 35772 787 11 external external JJ 35772 787 12 observation observation NN 35772 787 13 and and CC 35772 787 14 explanation explanation NN 35772 787 15 of of IN 35772 787 16 the the DT 35772 787 17 world world NN 35772 787 18 ( ( -LRB- 35772 787 19 to to TO 35772 787 20 which which WDT 35772 787 21 the the DT 35772 787 22 rationalists rationalist NNS 35772 787 23 had have VBD 35772 787 24 promoted promote VBN 35772 787 25 or or CC 35772 787 26 degraded degrade VBN 35772 787 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 787 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 787 29 , , , 35772 787 30 back back RB 35772 787 31 to to IN 35772 787 32 inner inner JJ 35772 787 33 personal personal JJ 35772 787 34 feeling feeling NN 35772 787 35 . . . 35772 788 1 This this DT 35772 788 2 marked mark VBD 35772 788 3 an an DT 35772 788 4 epoch epoch NN 35772 788 5 in in IN 35772 788 6 the the DT 35772 788 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 788 8 of of IN 35772 788 9 religion religion NN 35772 788 10 . . . 35772 789 1 Moreover moreover RB 35772 789 2 , , , 35772 789 3 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 789 4 was be VBD 35772 789 5 able able JJ 35772 789 6 to to TO 35772 789 7 write write VB 35772 789 8 in in IN 35772 789 9 a a DT 35772 789 10 convincing convincing JJ 35772 789 11 fashion fashion NN 35772 789 12 of of IN 35772 789 13 religion religion NN 35772 789 14 , , , 35772 789 15 because because IN 35772 789 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 789 17 and and CC 35772 789 18 here here RB 35772 789 19 he -PRON- PRP 35772 789 20 differed differ VBD 35772 789 21 from from IN 35772 789 22 the the DT 35772 789 23 intellectuals intellectual NNS 35772 789 24 of of IN 35772 789 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 789 26 day day NN 35772 789 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 789 28 he -PRON- PRP 35772 789 29 had have VBD 35772 789 30 personal personal JJ 35772 789 31 experience experience NN 35772 789 32 of of IN 35772 789 33 what what WP 35772 789 34 it -PRON- PRP 35772 789 35 meant mean VBD 35772 789 36 . . . 35772 790 1 Hence hence RB 35772 790 2 wherever wherever WRB 35772 790 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 790 4 alludes allude VBZ 35772 790 5 to to TO 35772 790 6 religion religion VB 35772 790 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 790 8 language language NN 35772 790 9 has have VBZ 35772 790 10 the the DT 35772 790 11 ring ring NN 35772 790 12 of of IN 35772 790 13 sincerity sincerity NN 35772 790 14 ; ; : 35772 790 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 790 16 is be VBZ 35772 790 17 always always RB 35772 790 18 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 35772 790 19 , , , 35772 790 20 and and CC 35772 790 21 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 790 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 790 23 is be VBZ 35772 790 24 passionate passionate JJ 35772 790 25 and and CC 35772 790 26 poetic poetic JJ 35772 790 27 . . . 35772 791 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 791 2 religious religious JJ 35772 791 3 experience experience NN 35772 791 4 took take VBD 35772 791 5 the the DT 35772 791 6 form form NN 35772 791 7 of of IN 35772 791 8 nature nature NN 35772 791 9 - - HYPH 35772 791 10 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 791 11 , , , 35772 791 12 undogmatic undogmatic JJ 35772 791 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 791 14 because because IN 35772 791 15 non non JJ 35772 791 16 - - JJ 35772 791 17 intellectualist intellectualist JJ 35772 791 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 791 19 , , , 35772 791 20 but but CC 35772 791 21 rich rich JJ 35772 791 22 and and CC 35772 791 23 deep deep JJ 35772 791 24 : : : 35772 791 25 " " `` 35772 791 26 I -PRON- PRP 35772 791 27 can can MD 35772 791 28 find find VB 35772 791 29 no no DT 35772 791 30 more more RBR 35772 791 31 worthy worthy JJ 35772 791 32 adoration adoration NN 35772 791 33 of of IN 35772 791 34 God God NNP 35772 791 35 than than IN 35772 791 36 the the DT 35772 791 37 silent silent JJ 35772 791 38 admiration admiration NN 35772 791 39 which which WDT 35772 791 40 the the DT 35772 791 41 contemplation contemplation NN 35772 791 42 of of IN 35772 791 43 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 791 44 works work NNS 35772 791 45 begets beget NNS 35772 791 46 in in IN 35772 791 47 us -PRON- PRP 35772 791 48 , , , 35772 791 49 and and CC 35772 791 50 which which WDT 35772 791 51 can can MD 35772 791 52 not not RB 35772 791 53 be be VB 35772 791 54 expressed express VBN 35772 791 55 by by IN 35772 791 56 any any DT 35772 791 57 prescribed prescribe VBN 35772 791 58 acts act NNS 35772 791 59 .... .... . 35772 792 1 In in IN 35772 792 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 792 3 room room NN 35772 792 4 I -PRON- PRP 35772 792 5 pray pray VBP 35772 792 6 seldomer seldomer NN 35772 792 7 and and CC 35772 792 8 more more RBR 35772 792 9 coldly coldly RB 35772 792 10 ; ; : 35772 792 11 but but CC 35772 792 12 the the DT 35772 792 13 sight sight NN 35772 792 14 of of IN 35772 792 15 a a DT 35772 792 16 beautiful beautiful JJ 35772 792 17 landscape landscape NN 35772 792 18 moves move VBZ 35772 792 19 me -PRON- PRP 35772 792 20 , , , 35772 792 21 I -PRON- PRP 35772 792 22 can can MD 35772 792 23 not not RB 35772 792 24 tell tell VB 35772 792 25 why why WRB 35772 792 26 . . . 35772 793 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 793 2 once once RB 35772 793 3 read read VBP 35772 793 4 of of IN 35772 793 5 a a DT 35772 793 6 certain certain JJ 35772 793 7 bishop bishop NN 35772 793 8 , , , 35772 793 9 who who WP 35772 793 10 , , , 35772 793 11 when when WRB 35772 793 12 visiting visit VBG 35772 793 13 in in IN 35772 793 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 793 15 diocese diocese NN 35772 793 16 , , , 35772 793 17 encountered encounter VBD 35772 793 18 an an DT 35772 793 19 old old JJ 35772 793 20 woman woman NN 35772 793 21 whose whose WP$ 35772 793 22 only only JJ 35772 793 23 prayers prayer NNS 35772 793 24 consisted consist VBD 35772 793 25 in in IN 35772 793 26 a a DT 35772 793 27 sigh sigh NN 35772 793 28 ' ' `` 35772 793 29 Oh oh UH 35772 793 30 ! ! . 35772 793 31 ' ' '' 35772 794 1 The the DT 35772 794 2 bishop bishop NN 35772 794 3 said say VBD 35772 794 4 to to IN 35772 794 5 her -PRON- PRP 35772 794 6 , , , 35772 794 7 ' ' '' 35772 794 8 Good good JJ 35772 794 9 mother mother NN 35772 794 10 , , , 35772 794 11 always always RB 35772 794 12 pray pray VB 35772 794 13 like like IN 35772 794 14 that that DT 35772 794 15 ; ; : 35772 794 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 794 17 prayer prayer NN 35772 794 18 is be VBZ 35772 794 19 worth worth JJ 35772 794 20 more more JJR 35772 794 21 than than IN 35772 794 22 ours ours PRP$ 35772 794 23 . . . 35772 794 24 ' ' '' 35772 795 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 35772 795 2 prayer prayer NN 35772 795 3 is be VBZ 35772 795 4 of of IN 35772 795 5 that that DT 35772 795 6 kind kind NN 35772 795 7 . . . 35772 796 1 " " `` 35772 796 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 796 3 26 26 CD 35772 796 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 796 5 Here here RB 35772 796 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 796 7 have have VBP 35772 796 8 one one CD 35772 796 9 form form NN 35772 796 10 of of IN 35772 796 11 the the DT 35772 796 12 religious religious JJ 35772 796 13 spirit spirit NN 35772 796 14 ; ; : 35772 796 15 for for IN 35772 796 16 the the DT 35772 796 17 mystic mystic NN 35772 796 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 796 19 is be VBZ 35772 796 20 always always RB 35772 796 21 true true JJ 35772 796 22 that that IN 35772 796 23 " " `` 35772 796 24 there there EX 35772 796 25 is be VBZ 35772 796 26 neither neither CC 35772 796 27 speech speech NN 35772 796 28 nor nor CC 35772 796 29 language language NN 35772 796 30 . . . 35772 796 31 " " '' 35772 797 1 The the DT 35772 797 2 mystic mystic NN 35772 797 3 and and CC 35772 797 4 the the DT 35772 797 5 dogmatist dogmatist NN 35772 797 6 stand stand NN 35772 797 7 at at IN 35772 797 8 opposite opposite JJ 35772 797 9 poles pole NNS 35772 797 10 , , , 35772 797 11 for for IN 35772 797 12 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 797 13 is be VBZ 35772 797 14 always always RB 35772 797 15 an an DT 35772 797 16 attempt attempt NN 35772 797 17 at at IN 35772 797 18 definition definition NN 35772 797 19 even even RB 35772 797 20 when when WRB 35772 797 21 that that DT 35772 797 22 which which WDT 35772 797 23 is be VBZ 35772 797 24 to to TO 35772 797 25 be be VB 35772 797 26 defined define VBN 35772 797 27 is be VBZ 35772 797 28 indefinable indefinable JJ 35772 797 29 ; ; : 35772 797 30 and and CC 35772 797 31 here here RB 35772 797 32 is be VBZ 35772 797 33 to to TO 35772 797 34 be be VB 35772 797 35 found find VBN 35772 797 36 the the DT 35772 797 37 common common JJ 35772 797 38 denominator denominator NN 35772 797 39 between between IN 35772 797 40 Kant Kant NNP 35772 797 41 and and CC 35772 797 42 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 797 43 . . . 35772 798 1 The the DT 35772 798 2 former former JJ 35772 798 3 , , , 35772 798 4 by by IN 35772 798 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 798 6 analysis analysis NN 35772 798 7 of of IN 35772 798 8 reason reason NN 35772 798 9 , , , 35772 798 10 discredited discredited JJ 35772 798 11 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 798 12 : : : 35772 798 13 the the DT 35772 798 14 latter latter JJ 35772 798 15 , , , 35772 798 16 by by IN 35772 798 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 798 18 apotheosis apotheosis NN 35772 798 19 of of IN 35772 798 20 feeling feeling NN 35772 798 21 , , , 35772 798 22 contributed contribute VBD 35772 798 23 towards towards IN 35772 798 24 the the DT 35772 798 25 same same JJ 35772 798 26 result result NN 35772 798 27 . . . 35772 799 1 ROMANTICISM ROMANTICISM NNP 35772 799 2 IN IN NNP 35772 799 3 GERMANY.--This GERMANY.--This NNP 35772 799 4 strong strong JJ 35772 799 5 movement movement NN 35772 799 6 of of IN 35772 799 7 feeling feeling NN 35772 799 8 , , , 35772 799 9 created create VBN 35772 799 10 on on IN 35772 799 11 the the DT 35772 799 12 one one CD 35772 799 13 hand hand NN 35772 799 14 by by IN 35772 799 15 Kant Kant NNP 35772 799 16 's 's POS 35772 799 17 _ _ NNP 35772 799 18 Critique Critique NNP 35772 799 19 _ _ NNP 35772 799 20 , , , 35772 799 21 and and CC 35772 799 22 by by IN 35772 799 23 the the DT 35772 799 24 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 799 25 of of IN 35772 799 26 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 799 27 , , , 35772 799 28 took take VBD 35772 799 29 different different JJ 35772 799 30 forms form NNS 35772 799 31 in in IN 35772 799 32 the the DT 35772 799 33 two two CD 35772 799 34 countries country NNS 35772 799 35 to to TO 35772 799 36 which which WDT 35772 799 37 these these DT 35772 799 38 two two CD 35772 799 39 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 799 40 belonged belong VBD 35772 799 41 . . . 35772 800 1 In in IN 35772 800 2 France France NNP 35772 800 3 the the DT 35772 800 4 new new JJ 35772 800 5 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 800 6 became become VBD 35772 800 7 the the DT 35772 800 8 hot hot JJ 35772 800 9 - - HYPH 35772 800 10 bed bed NN 35772 800 11 of of IN 35772 800 12 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 35772 800 13 ideas idea NNS 35772 800 14 ; ; : 35772 800 15 whereas whereas IN 35772 800 16 in in IN 35772 800 17 Germany Germany NNP 35772 800 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 800 19 found find VBD 35772 800 20 vent vent NN 35772 800 21 in in IN 35772 800 22 a a DT 35772 800 23 ferment ferment NN 35772 800 24 of of IN 35772 800 25 speculative speculative JJ 35772 800 26 systems system NNS 35772 800 27 , , , 35772 800 28 and and CC 35772 800 29 in in IN 35772 800 30 an an DT 35772 800 31 outcrop outcrop NN 35772 800 32 of of IN 35772 800 33 artistic artistic JJ 35772 800 34 production production NN 35772 800 35 . . . 35772 801 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 801 2 produced produce VBD 35772 801 3 the the DT 35772 801 4 philosophies philosophy NNS 35772 801 5 of of IN 35772 801 6 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 801 7 , , , 35772 801 8 Schelling Schelling NNP 35772 801 9 , , , 35772 801 10 and and CC 35772 801 11 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 801 12 , , , 35772 801 13 and and CC 35772 801 14 the the DT 35772 801 15 prose prose NN 35772 801 16 and and CC 35772 801 17 poetry poetry NN 35772 801 18 of of IN 35772 801 19 Goethe Goethe NNP 35772 801 20 and and CC 35772 801 21 Schiller Schiller NNP 35772 801 22 . . . 35772 802 1 " " `` 35772 802 2 It -PRON- PRP 35772 802 3 was be VBD 35772 802 4 the the DT 35772 802 5 age age NN 35772 802 6 of of IN 35772 802 7 ' ' `` 35772 802 8 beautiful beautiful JJ 35772 802 9 souls soul NNS 35772 802 10 ' ' '' 35772 802 11 and and CC 35772 802 12 of of IN 35772 802 13 ' ' `` 35772 802 14 noble noble JJ 35772 802 15 hearts heart NNS 35772 802 16 ' ' '' 35772 802 17 ; ; : 35772 802 18 men man NNS 35772 802 19 believed believe VBD 35772 802 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 802 21 capable capable JJ 35772 802 22 of of IN 35772 802 23 the the DT 35772 802 24 highest high JJS 35772 802 25 things thing NNS 35772 802 26 ; ; : 35772 802 27 the the DT 35772 802 28 immediate immediate JJ 35772 802 29 needs need NNS 35772 802 30 of of IN 35772 802 31 the the DT 35772 802 32 heart heart NN 35772 802 33 were be VBD 35772 802 34 set set VBN 35772 802 35 over over RP 35772 802 36 against against IN 35772 802 37 reason reason NN 35772 802 38 ... ... : 35772 802 39 under under IN 35772 802 40 many many JJ 35772 802 41 successive successive JJ 35772 802 42 forms form NNS 35772 802 43 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 802 44 prevailed prevail VBD 35772 802 45 in in IN 35772 802 46 literature literature NN 35772 802 47 , , , 35772 802 48 effecting effect VBG 35772 802 49 the the DT 35772 802 50 re re NN 35772 802 51 - - NN 35772 802 52 birth birth NN 35772 802 53 of of IN 35772 802 54 human human NN 35772 802 55 fancy fancy NN 35772 802 56 after after IN 35772 802 57 the the DT 35772 802 58 long long JJ 35772 802 59 labour labour NN 35772 802 60 of of IN 35772 802 61 intellect intellect NN 35772 802 62 . . . 35772 803 1 " " `` 35772 803 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 803 3 27 27 CD 35772 803 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 803 5 THE the DT 35772 803 6 GOAL goal NN 35772 803 7 OF of IN 35772 803 8 PHILOSOPHY.--Philosophic philosophy.--philosophic JJ 35772 803 9 young young JJ 35772 803 10 Germany Germany NNP 35772 803 11 had have VBD 35772 803 12 set set VBN 35772 803 13 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 803 14 an an DT 35772 803 15 ambitious ambitious JJ 35772 803 16 programme programme NN 35772 803 17 . . . 35772 804 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 804 2 , , , 35772 804 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 804 4 , , , 35772 804 5 had have VBD 35772 804 6 cleared clear VBN 35772 804 7 the the DT 35772 804 8 ground ground NN 35772 804 9 for for IN 35772 804 10 them -PRON- PRP 35772 804 11 , , , 35772 804 12 but but CC 35772 804 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 804 14 warnings warning NNS 35772 804 15 that that IN 35772 804 16 an an DT 35772 804 17 eagle eagle NN 35772 804 18 can can MD 35772 804 19 not not RB 35772 804 20 soar soar VB 35772 804 21 beyond beyond IN 35772 804 22 the the DT 35772 804 23 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 804 24 which which WDT 35772 804 25 supports support VBZ 35772 804 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 804 27 , , , 35772 804 28 were be VBD 35772 804 29 disregarded disregard VBN 35772 804 30 . . . 35772 805 1 The the DT 35772 805 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 805 3 of of IN 35772 805 4 Kant Kant NNP 35772 805 5 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 805 6 was be VBD 35772 805 7 felt feel VBN 35772 805 8 by by IN 35772 805 9 the the DT 35772 805 10 successors successor NNS 35772 805 11 to to TO 35772 805 12 be be VB 35772 805 13 lacking lack VBG 35772 805 14 in in IN 35772 805 15 the the DT 35772 805 16 _ _ NNP 35772 805 17 idea idea NN 35772 805 18 of of IN 35772 805 19 totality_--in totality_--in NNP 35772 805 20 the the DT 35772 805 21 conception conception NN 35772 805 22 of of IN 35772 805 23 a a DT 35772 805 24 whole whole NN 35772 805 25 . . . 35772 806 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 806 2 division division NN 35772 806 3 of of IN 35772 806 4 existence existence NN 35772 806 5 into into IN 35772 806 6 Appearance Appearance NNP 35772 806 7 and and CC 35772 806 8 Reality Reality NNP 35772 806 9 seemed seem VBD 35772 806 10 to to TO 35772 806 11 indicate indicate VB 35772 806 12 a a DT 35772 806 13 certain certain JJ 35772 806 14 lack lack NN 35772 806 15 of of IN 35772 806 16 finish finish NN 35772 806 17 in in IN 35772 806 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 806 19 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 806 20 ; ; : 35772 806 21 and and CC 35772 806 22 they -PRON- PRP 35772 806 23 set set VBD 35772 806 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 806 25 to to TO 35772 806 26 explore explore VB 35772 806 27 the the DT 35772 806 28 root root NN 35772 806 29 of of IN 35772 806 30 reality reality NN 35772 806 31 which which WDT 35772 806 32 to to IN 35772 806 33 Kant Kant NNP 35772 806 34 seemed seem VBD 35772 806 35 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 35772 806 36 , , , 35772 806 37 but but CC 35772 806 38 in in IN 35772 806 39 which which WDT 35772 806 40 the the DT 35772 806 41 sensuous sensuous JJ 35772 806 42 and and CC 35772 806 43 super super JJ 35772 806 44 - - JJ 35772 806 45 sensuous sensuous JJ 35772 806 46 worlds world NNS 35772 806 47 are be VBP 35772 806 48 united united JJ 35772 806 49 , , , 35772 806 50 and and CC 35772 806 51 from from IN 35772 806 52 which which WDT 35772 806 53 they -PRON- PRP 35772 806 54 have have VBP 35772 806 55 emerged emerge VBN 35772 806 56 . . . 35772 807 1 This this DT 35772 807 2 task task NN 35772 807 3 became become VBD 35772 807 4 and and CC 35772 807 5 remained remain VBD 35772 807 6 the the DT 35772 807 7 grand grand JJ 35772 807 8 problem problem NN 35772 807 9 of of IN 35772 807 10 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 807 11 for for IN 35772 807 12 a a DT 35772 807 13 whole whole JJ 35772 807 14 generation generation NN 35772 807 15 of of IN 35772 807 16 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 807 17 . . . 35772 808 1 All all DT 35772 808 2 externality externality NN 35772 808 3 , , , 35772 808 4 isolation isolation NN 35772 808 5 , , , 35772 808 6 and and CC 35772 808 7 division division NN 35772 808 8 were be VBD 35772 808 9 to to TO 35772 808 10 disappear disappear VB 35772 808 11 , , , 35772 808 12 all all DT 35772 808 13 existence existence NN 35772 808 14 must must MD 35772 808 15 be be VB 35772 808 16 shown show VBN 35772 808 17 to to TO 35772 808 18 be be VB 35772 808 19 but but CC 35772 808 20 degrees degree NNS 35772 808 21 and and CC 35772 808 22 phases phase NNS 35772 808 23 of of IN 35772 808 24 the the DT 35772 808 25 one one CD 35772 808 26 infinite infinite JJ 35772 808 27 reality reality NN 35772 808 28 . . . 35772 809 1 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 809 2 's 's POS 35772 809 3 work work NN 35772 809 4 had have VBD 35772 809 5 to to TO 35772 809 6 be be VB 35772 809 7 done do VBN 35772 809 8 again again RB 35772 809 9 in in IN 35772 809 10 the the DT 35772 809 11 light light NN 35772 809 12 of of IN 35772 809 13 increased increase VBN 35772 809 14 psychological psychological JJ 35772 809 15 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 809 16 . . . 35772 810 1 FICHTE.--Of FICHTE.--Of NNP 35772 810 2 the the DT 35772 810 3 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 810 4 who who WP 35772 810 5 addressed address VBD 35772 810 6 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 810 7 to to IN 35772 810 8 this this DT 35772 810 9 ambitious ambitious JJ 35772 810 10 task task NN 35772 810 11 , , , 35772 810 12 only only RB 35772 810 13 two two CD 35772 810 14 need nee MD 35772 810 15 be be VB 35772 810 16 considered consider VBN 35772 810 17 here here RB 35772 810 18 ; ; : 35772 810 19 and and CC 35772 810 20 these these DT 35772 810 21 are be VBP 35772 810 22 chosen choose VBN 35772 810 23 because because IN 35772 810 24 they -PRON- PRP 35772 810 25 attacked attack VBD 35772 810 26 the the DT 35772 810 27 problem problem NN 35772 810 28 from from IN 35772 810 29 different different JJ 35772 810 30 directions direction NNS 35772 810 31 . . . 35772 811 1 In in IN 35772 811 2 the the DT 35772 811 3 first first JJ 35772 811 4 place place NN 35772 811 5 , , , 35772 811 6 Johann Johann NNP 35772 811 7 Gottlieb Gottlieb NNP 35772 811 8 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 811 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 811 10 1762 1762 CD 35772 811 11 - - SYM 35772 811 12 1814 1814 CD 35772 811 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 811 14 , , , 35772 811 15 who who WP 35772 811 16 had have VBD 35772 811 17 been be VBN 35772 811 18 the the DT 35772 811 19 first first JJ 35772 811 20 to to TO 35772 811 21 lay lay VB 35772 811 22 down down RP 35772 811 23 the the DT 35772 811 24 programme programme NN 35772 811 25 of of IN 35772 811 26 thought thought NN 35772 811 27 with with IN 35772 811 28 explicitness explicitness NN 35772 811 29 , , , 35772 811 30 realised realise VBN 35772 811 31 and and CC 35772 811 32 admitted admit VBD 35772 811 33 that that IN 35772 811 34 the the DT 35772 811 35 task task NN 35772 811 36 which which WDT 35772 811 37 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 811 38 had have VBD 35772 811 39 set set VBN 35772 811 40 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 811 41 was be VBD 35772 811 42 beyond beyond IN 35772 811 43 the the DT 35772 811 44 powers power NNS 35772 811 45 of of IN 35772 811 46 any any DT 35772 811 47 logical logical JJ 35772 811 48 train train NN 35772 811 49 of of IN 35772 811 50 thought thought NN 35772 811 51 . . . 35772 812 1 The the DT 35772 812 2 " " `` 35772 812 3 higher high JJR 35772 812 4 unity unity NN 35772 812 5 " " '' 35772 812 6 of of IN 35772 812 7 existence existence NN 35772 812 8 , , , 35772 812 9 the the DT 35772 812 10 demonstration demonstration NN 35772 812 11 of of IN 35772 812 12 which which WDT 35772 812 13 was be VBD 35772 812 14 the the DT 35772 812 15 goal goal NN 35772 812 16 of of IN 35772 812 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 812 18 , , , 35772 812 19 could could MD 35772 812 20 be be VB 35772 812 21 reached reach VBN 35772 812 22 only only RB 35772 812 23 by by IN 35772 812 24 a a DT 35772 812 25 process process NN 35772 812 26 of of IN 35772 812 27 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 812 28 intuition,[28 intuition,[28 NN 35772 812 29 ] ] -RRB- 35772 812 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 812 31 must must MD 35772 812 32 be be VB 35772 812 33 guessed guess VBN 35772 812 34 or or CC 35772 812 35 divined divine VBN 35772 812 36 ; ; : 35772 812 37 for for IN 35772 812 38 it -PRON- PRP 35772 812 39 presents present VBZ 35772 812 40 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 812 41 ( ( -LRB- 35772 812 42 and and CC 35772 812 43 this this DT 35772 812 44 is be VBZ 35772 812 45 a a DT 35772 812 46 characteristically characteristically RB 35772 812 47 " " `` 35772 812 48 Romanticist Romanticist NNP 35772 812 49 " " '' 35772 812 50 idea idea NN 35772 812 51 ) ) -RRB- 35772 812 52 to to IN 35772 812 53 the the DT 35772 812 54 human human JJ 35772 812 55 mind mind NN 35772 812 56 in in IN 35772 812 57 the the DT 35772 812 58 immediacy immediacy NN 35772 812 59 of of IN 35772 812 60 feeling feeling NN 35772 812 61 , , , 35772 812 62 and and CC 35772 812 63 not not RB 35772 812 64 by by IN 35772 812 65 discursive discursive JJ 35772 812 66 thought thought NN 35772 812 67 . . . 35772 813 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 813 2 was be VBD 35772 813 3 of of IN 35772 813 4 the the DT 35772 813 5 essence essence NN 35772 813 6 of of IN 35772 813 7 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 813 8 's 's POS 35772 813 9 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 813 10 , , , 35772 813 11 as as IN 35772 813 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 813 13 had have VBD 35772 813 14 been be VBN 35772 813 15 of of IN 35772 813 16 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 813 17 's 's POS 35772 813 18 , , , 35772 813 19 that that IN 35772 813 20 a a DT 35772 813 21 point point NN 35772 813 22 may may MD 35772 813 23 be be VB 35772 813 24 attained attain VBN 35772 813 25 where where WRB 35772 813 26 the the DT 35772 813 27 mind mind NN 35772 813 28 feels feel VBZ 35772 813 29 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 813 30 to to TO 35772 813 31 be be VB 35772 813 32 at at IN 35772 813 33 one one CD 35772 813 34 with with IN 35772 813 35 the the DT 35772 813 36 truly truly RB 35772 813 37 real real JJ 35772 813 38 , , , 35772 813 39 and and CC 35772 813 40 only only RB 35772 813 41 when when WRB 35772 813 42 this this DT 35772 813 43 point point NN 35772 813 44 is be VBZ 35772 813 45 reached reach VBN 35772 813 46 -- -- : 35772 813 47 i.e i.e NNP 35772 813 48 . . . 35772 814 1 _ _ NNP 35772 814 2 sub sub NN 35772 814 3 specie specie JJ 35772 814 4 aeternitatis aeternitatis JJ 35772 814 5 _ _ NNP 35772 814 6 , , , 35772 814 7 will will MD 35772 814 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 814 9 arrive arrive VB 35772 814 10 at at IN 35772 814 11 and and CC 35772 814 12 retain retain VB 35772 814 13 the the DT 35772 814 14 conviction conviction NN 35772 814 15 of of IN 35772 814 16 the the DT 35772 814 17 universal universal JJ 35772 814 18 order order NN 35772 814 19 and and CC 35772 814 20 unity unity NN 35772 814 21 of of IN 35772 814 22 existence existence NN 35772 814 23 . . . 35772 815 1 From from IN 35772 815 2 this this DT 35772 815 3 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 815 4 , , , 35772 815 5 and and CC 35772 815 6 from from IN 35772 815 7 this this DT 35772 815 8 alone alone JJ 35772 815 9 , , , 35772 815 10 does do VBZ 35772 815 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 815 12 become become VB 35772 815 13 possible possible JJ 35772 815 14 to to TO 35772 815 15 grasp grasp VB 35772 815 16 " " `` 35772 815 17 the the DT 35772 815 18 meaning meaning NN 35772 815 19 of of IN 35772 815 20 those those DT 35772 815 21 dualities duality NNS 35772 815 22 and and CC 35772 815 23 contrasts contrast NNS 35772 815 24 which which WDT 35772 815 25 we -PRON- PRP 35772 815 26 find find VBP 35772 815 27 around around RB 35772 815 28 and and CC 35772 815 29 in in IN 35772 815 30 us -PRON- PRP 35772 815 31 , , , 35772 815 32 the the DT 35772 815 33 differences difference NNS 35772 815 34 of of IN 35772 815 35 self self NN 35772 815 36 and and CC 35772 815 37 not not RB 35772 815 38 - - HYPH 35772 815 39 self self NN 35772 815 40 , , , 35772 815 41 of of IN 35772 815 42 mind mind NN 35772 815 43 and and CC 35772 815 44 matter matter NN 35772 815 45 , , , 35772 815 46 of of IN 35772 815 47 subject subject NN 35772 815 48 and and CC 35772 815 49 object object NN 35772 815 50 , , , 35772 815 51 of of IN 35772 815 52 appearance appearance NN 35772 815 53 and and CC 35772 815 54 reality reality NN 35772 815 55 , , , 35772 815 56 of of IN 35772 815 57 truth truth NN 35772 815 58 and and CC 35772 815 59 semblance semblance NN 35772 815 60 . . . 35772 815 61 " " '' 35772 816 1 HEGEL.--It HEGEL.--It NNP 35772 816 2 has have VBZ 35772 816 3 been be VBN 35772 816 4 said say VBN 35772 816 5 , , , 35772 816 6 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 816 7 with with IN 35772 816 8 justice justice NN 35772 816 9 , , , 35772 816 10 that that IN 35772 816 11 " " `` 35772 816 12 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 816 13 is be VBZ 35772 816 14 the the DT 35772 816 15 finding finding NN 35772 816 16 of of IN 35772 816 17 bad bad JJ 35772 816 18 reasons reason NNS 35772 816 19 for for IN 35772 816 20 what what WP 35772 816 21 we -PRON- PRP 35772 816 22 believe believe VBP 35772 816 23 upon upon IN 35772 816 24 instinct instinct NN 35772 816 25 . . . 35772 816 26 " " '' 35772 817 1 The the DT 35772 817 2 remark remark NN 35772 817 3 might may MD 35772 817 4 seem seem VB 35772 817 5 , , , 35772 817 6 at at IN 35772 817 7 least least JJS 35772 817 8 in in IN 35772 817 9 the the DT 35772 817 10 eyes eye NNS 35772 817 11 of of IN 35772 817 12 some some DT 35772 817 13 , , , 35772 817 14 to to TO 35772 817 15 be be VB 35772 817 16 particularly particularly RB 35772 817 17 applicable applicable JJ 35772 817 18 to to IN 35772 817 19 the the DT 35772 817 20 work work NN 35772 817 21 of of IN 35772 817 22 Georg Georg NNP 35772 817 23 Wilhelm Wilhelm NNP 35772 817 24 Friedrich Friedrich NNP 35772 817 25 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 817 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 817 27 1770 1770 CD 35772 817 28 - - SYM 35772 817 29 1831 1831 CD 35772 817 30 ) ) -RRB- 35772 817 31 . . . 35772 818 1 Not not RB 35772 818 2 because because IN 35772 818 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 818 4 arguments argument NNS 35772 818 5 are be VBP 35772 818 6 bad bad JJ 35772 818 7 , , , 35772 818 8 but but CC 35772 818 9 because because IN 35772 818 10 he -PRON- PRP 35772 818 11 attempted attempt VBD 35772 818 12 to to TO 35772 818 13 establish establish VB 35772 818 14 by by IN 35772 818 15 strict strict JJ 35772 818 16 logic logic NN 35772 818 17 the the DT 35772 818 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 818 19 which which WDT 35772 818 20 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 818 21 sought seek VBD 35772 818 22 to to TO 35772 818 23 reach reach VB 35772 818 24 by by IN 35772 818 25 means mean NNS 35772 818 26 of of IN 35772 818 27 intuition intuition NN 35772 818 28 , , , 35772 818 29 and and CC 35772 818 30 which which WDT 35772 818 31 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 818 32 are be VBP 35772 818 33 only only RB 35772 818 34 attainable attainable JJ 35772 818 35 by by IN 35772 818 36 that that DT 35772 818 37 method method NN 35772 818 38 . . . 35772 819 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 819 2 attempted attempt VBD 35772 819 3 to to TO 35772 819 4 climb climb VB 35772 819 5 , , , 35772 819 6 by by IN 35772 819 7 a a DT 35772 819 8 strict strict JJ 35772 819 9 process process NN 35772 819 10 of of IN 35772 819 11 reasoning reasoning NN 35772 819 12 , , , 35772 819 13 to to IN 35772 819 14 the the DT 35772 819 15 position position NN 35772 819 16 from from IN 35772 819 17 which which WDT 35772 819 18 the the DT 35772 819 19 Fichtean Fichtean NNP 35772 819 20 landscape landscape NN 35772 819 21 might may MD 35772 819 22 spread spread VB 35772 819 23 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 819 24 below below RB 35772 819 25 as as IN 35772 819 26 a a DT 35772 819 27 logical logical JJ 35772 819 28 whole whole NN 35772 819 29 : : : 35772 819 30 he -PRON- PRP 35772 819 31 claimed claim VBD 35772 819 32 to to TO 35772 819 33 be be VB 35772 819 34 a a DT 35772 819 35 reasoner reasoner NN 35772 819 36 as as RB 35772 819 37 well well RB 35772 819 38 as as IN 35772 819 39 a a DT 35772 819 40 seer seer NN 35772 819 41 . . . 35772 820 1 And and CC 35772 820 2 thereby thereby RB 35772 820 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 820 4 may may MD 35772 820 5 be be VB 35772 820 6 said say VBN 35772 820 7 to to TO 35772 820 8 have have VB 35772 820 9 furnished furnish VBN 35772 820 10 " " '' 35772 820 11 the the DT 35772 820 12 programme programme NN 35772 820 13 of of IN 35772 820 14 thought thought NN 35772 820 15 for for IN 35772 820 16 a a DT 35772 820 17 certain certain JJ 35772 820 18 class class NN 35772 820 19 of of IN 35772 820 20 intellects intellect NNS 35772 820 21 which which WDT 35772 820 22 will will MD 35772 820 23 never never RB 35772 820 24 die die VB 35772 820 25 out out RP 35772 820 26 . . . 35772 820 27 " " '' 35772 821 1 Thus thus RB 35772 821 2 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 821 3 was be VBD 35772 821 4 something something NN 35772 821 5 of of IN 35772 821 6 a a DT 35772 821 7 hybrid hybrid NN 35772 821 8 , , , 35772 821 9 and and CC 35772 821 10 may may MD 35772 821 11 be be VB 35772 821 12 described describe VBN 35772 821 13 as as IN 35772 821 14 a a DT 35772 821 15 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 35772 821 16 - - HYPH 35772 821 17 romanticist romanticist NN 35772 821 18 . . . 35772 822 1 Nor nor CC 35772 822 2 are be VBP 35772 822 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 822 4 arguments argument NNS 35772 822 5 the the DT 35772 822 6 easiest easy JJS 35772 822 7 to to TO 35772 822 8 understand understand VB 35772 822 9 . . . 35772 823 1 " " `` 35772 823 2 The the DT 35772 823 3 only only JJ 35772 823 4 thing thing NN 35772 823 5 that that WDT 35772 823 6 is be VBZ 35772 823 7 certain certain JJ 35772 823 8 , , , 35772 823 9 " " '' 35772 823 10 writes write VBZ 35772 823 11 a a DT 35772 823 12 commentator commentator NN 35772 823 13 who who WP 35772 823 14 stands stand VBZ 35772 823 15 at at IN 35772 823 16 an an DT 35772 823 17 opposite opposite JJ 35772 823 18 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 823 19 pole pole NN 35772 823 20 , , , 35772 823 21 " " '' 35772 823 22 is be VBZ 35772 823 23 that that IN 35772 823 24 whatever whatever WDT 35772 823 25 you -PRON- PRP 35772 823 26 may may MD 35772 823 27 say say VB 35772 823 28 of of IN 35772 823 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 823 30 procedure procedure NN 35772 823 31 , , , 35772 823 32 some some DT 35772 823 33 one one NN 35772 823 34 will will MD 35772 823 35 accuse accuse VB 35772 823 36 you -PRON- PRP 35772 823 37 of of IN 35772 823 38 misunderstanding misunderstand VBG 35772 823 39 it -PRON- PRP 35772 823 40 . . . 35772 824 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 824 2 make make VBP 35772 824 3 no no DT 35772 824 4 claim claim NN 35772 824 5 to to IN 35772 824 6 understanding understand VBG 35772 824 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 824 8 ; ; : 35772 824 9 I -PRON- PRP 35772 824 10 treat treat VBP 35772 824 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 824 12 merely merely RB 35772 824 13 impressionistically impressionistically RB 35772 824 14 . . . 35772 825 1 " " `` 35772 825 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 825 3 29 29 CD 35772 825 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 825 5 And and CC 35772 825 6 this this DT 35772 825 7 is be VBZ 35772 825 8 all all DT 35772 825 9 we -PRON- PRP 35772 825 10 can can MD 35772 825 11 do do VB 35772 825 12 here here RB 35772 825 13 . . . 35772 826 1 HEGEL HEGEL NNP 35772 826 2 'S 'S NNP 35772 826 3 METHOD.--Hegel METHOD.--Hegel NNP 35772 826 4 proceeds proceed VBZ 35772 826 5 by by IN 35772 826 6 means mean NNS 35772 826 7 of of IN 35772 826 8 what what WP 35772 826 9 he -PRON- PRP 35772 826 10 calls call VBZ 35772 826 11 the the DT 35772 826 12 _ _ NNP 35772 826 13 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 35772 826 14 Method Method NNP 35772 826 15 _ _ NNP 35772 826 16 . . . 35772 827 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 827 2 understands understand VBZ 35772 827 3 by by IN 35772 827 4 " " `` 35772 827 5 dialectic dialectic NN 35772 827 6 " " '' 35772 827 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 827 8 1 1 LS 35772 827 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 827 10 a a DT 35772 827 11 property property NN 35772 827 12 of of IN 35772 827 13 all all DT 35772 827 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 827 15 _ _ NNP 35772 827 16 thoughts thought NNS 35772 827 17 _ _ NNP 35772 827 18 in in IN 35772 827 19 virtue virtue NN 35772 827 20 of of IN 35772 827 21 which which WDT 35772 827 22 , , , 35772 827 23 each each DT 35772 827 24 particular particular JJ 35772 827 25 thought thought NN 35772 827 26 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 827 27 passes pass VBZ 35772 827 28 over over RP 35772 827 29 into into IN 35772 827 30 another another DT 35772 827 31 ; ; : 35772 827 32 and and CC 35772 827 33 also also RB 35772 827 34 ( ( -LRB- 35772 827 35 2 2 LS 35772 827 36 ) ) -RRB- 35772 827 37 a a DT 35772 827 38 property property NN 35772 827 39 of of IN 35772 827 40 _ _ NNP 35772 827 41 things thing NNS 35772 827 42 _ _ NNP 35772 827 43 , , , 35772 827 44 in in IN 35772 827 45 virtue virtue NN 35772 827 46 of of IN 35772 827 47 which which WDT 35772 827 48 every every DT 35772 827 49 particular particular JJ 35772 827 50 thing thing NN 35772 827 51 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 827 52 belongs belong VBZ 35772 827 53 to to TO 35772 827 54 , , , 35772 827 55 or or CC 35772 827 56 is be VBZ 35772 827 57 related relate VBN 35772 827 58 to to IN 35772 827 59 , , , 35772 827 60 all all DT 35772 827 61 other other JJ 35772 827 62 things thing NNS 35772 827 63 . . . 35772 828 1 A a DT 35772 828 2 thing thing NN 35772 828 3 " " '' 35772 828 4 by by IN 35772 828 5 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 828 6 " " '' 35772 828 7 is be VBZ 35772 828 8 nothing nothing NN 35772 828 9 . . . 35772 829 1 Hence hence RB 35772 829 2 a a DT 35772 829 3 similarity similarity NN 35772 829 4 or or CC 35772 829 5 parallelism parallelism NN 35772 829 6 between between IN 35772 829 7 the the DT 35772 829 8 _ _ NNP 35772 829 9 method method NN 35772 829 10 of of IN 35772 829 11 thought thought NN 35772 829 12 _ _ NNP 35772 829 13 and and CC 35772 829 14 the the DT 35772 829 15 _ _ NNP 35772 829 16 nature nature NN 35772 829 17 of of IN 35772 829 18 things thing NNS 35772 829 19 _ _ NNP 35772 829 20 . . . 35772 830 1 Logic logic NN 35772 830 2 is be VBZ 35772 830 3 of of IN 35772 830 4 the the DT 35772 830 5 nature nature NN 35772 830 6 of of IN 35772 830 7 things thing NNS 35772 830 8 . . . 35772 831 1 The the DT 35772 831 2 way way NN 35772 831 3 in in IN 35772 831 4 which which WDT 35772 831 5 thought think VBD 35772 831 6 reaches reach VBZ 35772 831 7 truth truth NN 35772 831 8 is be VBZ 35772 831 9 also also RB 35772 831 10 the the DT 35772 831 11 way way NN 35772 831 12 in in IN 35772 831 13 which which WDT 35772 831 14 things thing NNS 35772 831 15 exist exist VBP 35772 831 16 . . . 35772 832 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 832 2 expressed express VBD 35772 832 3 this this DT 35772 832 4 in in IN 35772 832 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 832 6 well well RB 35772 832 7 - - HYPH 35772 832 8 known know VBN 35772 832 9 saying say VBG 35772 832 10 " " `` 35772 832 11 the the DT 35772 832 12 real real JJ 35772 832 13 is be VBZ 35772 832 14 the the DT 35772 832 15 rational rational JJ 35772 832 16 , , , 35772 832 17 and and CC 35772 832 18 the the DT 35772 832 19 rational rational JJ 35772 832 20 is be VBZ 35772 832 21 the the DT 35772 832 22 real real JJ 35772 832 23 . . . 35772 832 24 " " '' 35772 833 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 35772 833 2 more more RBR 35772 833 3 poetically poetically RB 35772 833 4 or or CC 35772 833 5 obscurely obscurely RB 35772 833 6 the the DT 35772 833 7 same same JJ 35772 833 8 proposition proposition NN 35772 833 9 is be VBZ 35772 833 10 expressed express VBN 35772 833 11 by by IN 35772 833 12 declaring declare VBG 35772 833 13 : : : 35772 833 14 " " `` 35772 833 15 When when WRB 35772 833 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 833 17 think think VBP 35772 833 18 existence existence NN 35772 833 19 , , , 35772 833 20 existence existence NN 35772 833 21 thinks think VBZ 35772 833 22 in in IN 35772 833 23 us -PRON- PRP 35772 833 24 , , , 35772 833 25 " " '' 35772 833 26 and and CC 35772 833 27 " " `` 35772 833 28 The the DT 35772 833 29 pulse pulse NN 35772 833 30 of of IN 35772 833 31 existence existence NN 35772 833 32 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 833 33 beats beat VBZ 35772 833 34 in in IN 35772 833 35 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 833 36 thinking thinking NN 35772 833 37 . . . 35772 833 38 " " '' 35772 834 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 834 2 's 's POS 35772 834 3 logic logic NN 35772 834 4 may may MD 35772 834 5 , , , 35772 834 6 in in IN 35772 834 7 fact fact NN 35772 834 8 , , , 35772 834 9 be be VB 35772 834 10 described describe VBN 35772 834 11 as as IN 35772 834 12 an an DT 35772 834 13 attempt attempt NN 35772 834 14 to to TO 35772 834 15 conceive conceive VB 35772 834 16 the the DT 35772 834 17 movement movement NN 35772 834 18 of of IN 35772 834 19 thought thought NN 35772 834 20 as as IN 35772 834 21 being be VBG 35772 834 22 at at IN 35772 834 23 the the DT 35772 834 24 same same JJ 35772 834 25 time time NN 35772 834 26 the the DT 35772 834 27 law law NN 35772 834 28 of of IN 35772 834 29 the the DT 35772 834 30 universe universe NN 35772 834 31 . . . 35772 835 1 Logic logic NN 35772 835 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 835 3 to to TO 35772 835 4 repeat repeat VB 35772 835 5 what what WP 35772 835 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 835 7 said say VBD 35772 835 8 before before RB 35772 835 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 835 10 is be VBZ 35772 835 11 of of IN 35772 835 12 the the DT 35772 835 13 nature nature NN 35772 835 14 of of IN 35772 835 15 things thing NNS 35772 835 16 : : : 35772 835 17 reality reality NN 35772 835 18 is be VBZ 35772 835 19 rational rational JJ 35772 835 20 , , , 35772 835 21 and and CC 35772 835 22 what what WP 35772 835 23 is be VBZ 35772 835 24 rational rational JJ 35772 835 25 is be VBZ 35772 835 26 real real JJ 35772 835 27 . . . 35772 836 1 Thus thus RB 35772 836 2 logic logic NN 35772 836 3 for for IN 35772 836 4 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 836 5 did do VBD 35772 836 6 not not RB 35772 836 7 mean mean VB 35772 836 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 836 9 as as IN 35772 836 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 836 11 meant mean VBD 35772 836 12 for for IN 35772 836 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 836 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 836 15 the the DT 35772 836 16 forms form NNS 35772 836 17 or or CC 35772 836 18 laws law NNS 35772 836 19 of of IN 35772 836 20 thought thought NN 35772 836 21 : : : 35772 836 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 836 23 signified signify VBD 35772 836 24 the the DT 35772 836 25 very very JJ 35772 836 26 core core NN 35772 836 27 of of IN 35772 836 28 reality reality NN 35772 836 29 . . . 35772 837 1 For for IN 35772 837 2 all all DT 35772 837 3 that that WDT 35772 837 4 Kant Kant NNP 35772 837 5 knew know VBD 35772 837 6 , , , 35772 837 7 reality reality NN 35772 837 8 might may MD 35772 837 9 or or CC 35772 837 10 might may MD 35772 837 11 not not RB 35772 837 12 be be VB 35772 837 13 rational rational JJ 35772 837 14 : : : 35772 837 15 all all DT 35772 837 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 837 17 asserted assert VBD 35772 837 18 was be VBD 35772 837 19 that that IN 35772 837 20 the the DT 35772 837 21 human human JJ 35772 837 22 mind mind NN 35772 837 23 rationalised rationalise VBD 35772 837 24 reality reality NN 35772 837 25 ( ( -LRB- 35772 837 26 or or CC 35772 837 27 parts part NNS 35772 837 28 of of IN 35772 837 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 837 30 ) ) -RRB- 35772 837 31 . . . 35772 838 1 For for IN 35772 838 2 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 838 3 , , , 35772 838 4 logic logic NN 35772 838 5 or or CC 35772 838 6 reason reason NN 35772 838 7 was be VBD 35772 838 8 the the DT 35772 838 9 living live VBG 35772 838 10 and and CC 35772 838 11 moving move VBG 35772 838 12 spirit spirit NN 35772 838 13 of of IN 35772 838 14 the the DT 35772 838 15 world world NN 35772 838 16 . . . 35772 839 1 The the DT 35772 839 2 essence essence NN 35772 839 3 of of IN 35772 839 4 reality reality NN 35772 839 5 and and CC 35772 839 6 the the DT 35772 839 7 essence essence NN 35772 839 8 of of IN 35772 839 9 thought thought NN 35772 839 10 were be VBD 35772 839 11 one one CD 35772 839 12 . . . 35772 840 1 The the DT 35772 840 2 absolute absolute JJ 35772 840 3 reality reality NN 35772 840 4 was be VBD 35772 840 5 spirit spirit NN 35772 840 6 . . . 35772 841 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 841 2 30 30 CD 35772 841 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 841 4 HEGELIANISM.--Hegel HEGELIANISM.--Hegel NNP 35772 841 5 's 's POS 35772 841 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 841 7 may may MD 35772 841 8 be be VB 35772 841 9 described describe VBN 35772 841 10 as as IN 35772 841 11 an an DT 35772 841 12 attempt attempt NN 35772 841 13 to to TO 35772 841 14 reach reach VB 35772 841 15 the the DT 35772 841 16 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 841 17 of of IN 35772 841 18 religious religious JJ 35772 841 19 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 841 20 by by IN 35772 841 21 means mean NNS 35772 841 22 of of IN 35772 841 23 purely purely RB 35772 841 24 rational rational JJ 35772 841 25 processes process NNS 35772 841 26 . . . 35772 842 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 842 2 is be VBZ 35772 842 3 the the DT 35772 842 4 finding finding NN 35772 842 5 of of IN 35772 842 6 rational rational JJ 35772 842 7 grounds ground NNS 35772 842 8 for for IN 35772 842 9 supra supra NNP 35772 842 10 - - HYPH 35772 842 11 rational rational JJ 35772 842 12 intuitions intuition NNS 35772 842 13 . . . 35772 843 1 The the DT 35772 843 2 attempt attempt NN 35772 843 3 is be VBZ 35772 843 4 laudable laudable JJ 35772 843 5 , , , 35772 843 6 and and CC 35772 843 7 , , , 35772 843 8 in in IN 35772 843 9 the the DT 35772 843 10 eyes eye NNS 35772 843 11 of of IN 35772 843 12 many many JJ 35772 843 13 , , , 35772 843 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 843 15 was be VBD 35772 843 16 successful successful JJ 35772 843 17 . . . 35772 844 1 And and CC 35772 844 2 , , , 35772 844 3 as as IN 35772 844 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 844 5 shall shall MD 35772 844 6 see see VB 35772 844 7 , , , 35772 844 8 Hegelianism Hegelianism NNP 35772 844 9 had have VBD 35772 844 10 an an DT 35772 844 11 important important JJ 35772 844 12 future future NN 35772 844 13 , , , 35772 844 14 especially especially RB 35772 844 15 in in IN 35772 844 16 England England NNP 35772 844 17 ; ; : 35772 844 18 nor nor CC 35772 844 19 , , , 35772 844 20 as as IN 35772 844 21 a a DT 35772 844 22 system system NN 35772 844 23 of of IN 35772 844 24 thought thought NN 35772 844 25 , , , 35772 844 26 is be VBZ 35772 844 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 844 28 yet yet RB 35772 844 29 extinct extinct JJ 35772 844 30 . . . 35772 845 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 845 2 central central JJ 35772 845 3 conception conception NN 35772 845 4 is be VBZ 35772 845 5 that that DT 35772 845 6 which which WDT 35772 845 7 , , , 35772 845 8 in in IN 35772 845 9 one one CD 35772 845 10 shape shape NN 35772 845 11 or or CC 35772 845 12 another another DT 35772 845 13 , , , 35772 845 14 will will MD 35772 845 15 never never RB 35772 845 16 cease cease VB 35772 845 17 to to TO 35772 845 18 appeal appeal VB 35772 845 19 to to IN 35772 845 20 mankind mankind NN 35772 845 21 -- -- : 35772 845 22 that that IN 35772 845 23 existence existence NN 35772 845 24 is be VBZ 35772 845 25 , , , 35772 845 26 at at IN 35772 845 27 bottom bottom NN 35772 845 28 , , , 35772 845 29 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 845 30 in in IN 35772 845 31 character character NN 35772 845 32 -- -- : 35772 845 33 that that DT 35772 845 34 spirit spirit NNP 35772 845 35 is be VBZ 35772 845 36 the the DT 35772 845 37 only only JJ 35772 845 38 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 845 39 reality reality NN 35772 845 40 . . . 35772 846 1 That that IN 35772 846 2 Hegelianism Hegelianism NNP 35772 846 3 provides provide VBZ 35772 846 4 a a DT 35772 846 5 rational rational JJ 35772 846 6 basis basis NN 35772 846 7 for for IN 35772 846 8 a a DT 35772 846 9 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 846 10 religion religion NN 35772 846 11 is be VBZ 35772 846 12 obvious obvious JJ 35772 846 13 enough enough RB 35772 846 14 ; ; , 35772 846 15 nor nor CC 35772 846 16 is be VBZ 35772 846 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 846 18 necessary necessary JJ 35772 846 19 to to TO 35772 846 20 indicate indicate VB 35772 846 21 the the DT 35772 846 22 possibilities possibility NNS 35772 846 23 of of IN 35772 846 24 linking link VBG 35772 846 25 up up RP 35772 846 26 the the DT 35772 846 27 Christian christian JJ 35772 846 28 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 846 29 of of IN 35772 846 30 the the DT 35772 846 31 Logos Logos NNP 35772 846 32 with with IN 35772 846 33 a a DT 35772 846 34 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 846 35 for for IN 35772 846 36 which which WDT 35772 846 37 Reason reason NN 35772 846 38 was be VBD 35772 846 39 the the DT 35772 846 40 very very JJ 35772 846 41 core core NN 35772 846 42 and and CC 35772 846 43 ground ground NN 35772 846 44 of of IN 35772 846 45 existence existence NN 35772 846 46 . . . 35772 847 1 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 847 2 may may MD 35772 847 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 847 4 be be VB 35772 847 5 said say VBN 35772 847 6 to to TO 35772 847 7 have have VB 35772 847 8 laid lay VBN 35772 847 9 the the DT 35772 847 10 foundation foundation NN 35772 847 11 of of IN 35772 847 12 Christian christian JJ 35772 847 13 theology theology NN 35772 847 14 afresh afresh RB 35772 847 15 ; ; : 35772 847 16 or or CC 35772 847 17 rather rather RB 35772 847 18 to to TO 35772 847 19 have have VB 35772 847 20 restored restore VBN 35772 847 21 what what WP 35772 847 22 was be VBD 35772 847 23 best good JJS 35772 847 24 in in IN 35772 847 25 the the DT 35772 847 26 old old JJ 35772 847 27 theology theology NN 35772 847 28 , , , 35772 847 29 and and CC 35772 847 30 given give VBN 35772 847 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 847 32 the the DT 35772 847 33 prestige prestige NN 35772 847 34 of of IN 35772 847 35 modernity modernity NN 35772 847 36 . . . 35772 848 1 RELIGION religion NN 35772 848 2 AND and CC 35772 848 3 PHILOSOPHY.--In PHILOSOPHY.--In NNP 35772 848 4 fact fact NN 35772 848 5 , , , 35772 848 6 for for IN 35772 848 7 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 848 8 as as IN 35772 848 9 for for IN 35772 848 10 all all DT 35772 848 11 rationalists rationalist NNS 35772 848 12 whose whose WP$ 35772 848 13 attitude attitude NN 35772 848 14 is be VBZ 35772 848 15 also also RB 35772 848 16 religious religious JJ 35772 848 17 , , , 35772 848 18 religion religion NN 35772 848 19 and and CC 35772 848 20 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 848 21 were be VBD 35772 848 22 two two CD 35772 848 23 forms form NNS 35772 848 24 of of IN 35772 848 25 the the DT 35772 848 26 same same JJ 35772 848 27 thing thing NN 35772 848 28 . . . 35772 849 1 Religion religion NN 35772 849 2 contains contain VBZ 35772 849 3 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 849 4 truths truth NNS 35772 849 5 under under IN 35772 849 6 the the DT 35772 849 7 form form NN 35772 849 8 of of IN 35772 849 9 imagination imagination NN 35772 849 10 : : : 35772 849 11 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 849 12 contains contain VBZ 35772 849 13 religious religious JJ 35772 849 14 truth truth NN 35772 849 15 under under IN 35772 849 16 the the DT 35772 849 17 form form NN 35772 849 18 of of IN 35772 849 19 reason reason NN 35772 849 20 . . . 35772 850 1 The the DT 35772 850 2 difference difference NN 35772 850 3 is be VBZ 35772 850 4 one one CD 35772 850 5 of of IN 35772 850 6 form form NN 35772 850 7 only only RB 35772 850 8 , , , 35772 850 9 not not RB 35772 850 10 of of IN 35772 850 11 content content NN 35772 850 12 . . . 35772 851 1 This this DT 35772 851 2 had have VBD 35772 851 3 not not RB 35772 851 4 been be VBN 35772 851 5 the the DT 35772 851 6 view view NN 35772 851 7 of of IN 35772 851 8 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 851 9 , , , 35772 851 10 nor nor CC 35772 851 11 is be VBZ 35772 851 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 851 13 the the DT 35772 851 14 deepest deep JJS 35772 851 15 view view NN 35772 851 16 ; ; : 35772 851 17 and and CC 35772 851 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 851 19 was be VBD 35772 851 20 not not RB 35772 851 21 the the DT 35772 851 22 view view NN 35772 851 23 of of IN 35772 851 24 a a DT 35772 851 25 thinker thinker NN 35772 851 26 of of IN 35772 851 27 the the DT 35772 851 28 Romantic romantic JJ 35772 851 29 school school NN 35772 851 30 who who WP 35772 851 31 did do VBD 35772 851 32 more more JJR 35772 851 33 than than IN 35772 851 34 any any DT 35772 851 35 individual individual NN 35772 851 36 among among IN 35772 851 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 851 38 predecessors predecessor NNS 35772 851 39 to to TO 35772 851 40 bring bring VB 35772 851 41 the the DT 35772 851 42 religious religious JJ 35772 851 43 problem problem NN 35772 851 44 to to IN 35772 851 45 the the DT 35772 851 46 point point NN 35772 851 47 where where WRB 35772 851 48 it -PRON- PRP 35772 851 49 now now RB 35772 851 50 stands stand VBZ 35772 851 51 . . . 35772 852 1 SCHLEIERMACHER.--While schleiermacher.--while VB 35772 852 2 the the DT 35772 852 3 sun sun NN 35772 852 4 of of IN 35772 852 5 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 852 6 was be VBD 35772 852 7 at at IN 35772 852 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 852 9 zenith zenith NN 35772 852 10 , , , 35772 852 11 the the DT 35772 852 12 spirit spirit NN 35772 852 13 of of IN 35772 852 14 Kant Kant NNP 35772 852 15 's 's POS 35772 852 16 critical critical JJ 35772 852 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 852 18 was be VBD 35772 852 19 kept keep VBN 35772 852 20 alive alive JJ 35772 852 21 by by IN 35772 852 22 a a DT 35772 852 23 thinker thinker NN 35772 852 24 of of IN 35772 852 25 as as IN 35772 852 26 deep deep JJ 35772 852 27 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 852 28 and and CC 35772 852 29 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 852 30 insight insight NN 35772 852 31 as as IN 35772 852 32 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 852 33 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 852 34 . . . 35772 853 1 Friedrich Friedrich NNP 35772 853 2 Ernst Ernst NNP 35772 853 3 Daniel Daniel NNP 35772 853 4 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 853 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 853 6 1768 1768 CD 35772 853 7 - - SYM 35772 853 8 1834 1834 CD 35772 853 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 853 10 brought bring VBD 35772 853 11 the the DT 35772 853 12 religious religious JJ 35772 853 13 problem problem NN 35772 853 14 down down RP 35772 853 15 from from IN 35772 853 16 those those DT 35772 853 17 altitudes altitude NNS 35772 853 18 to to TO 35772 853 19 which which WDT 35772 853 20 Romanticist Romanticist NNP 35772 853 21 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 853 22 had have VBD 35772 853 23 raised raise VBN 35772 853 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 853 25 , , , 35772 853 26 to to IN 35772 853 27 what what WP 35772 853 28 Kant Kant NNP 35772 853 29 had have VBD 35772 853 30 called call VBN 35772 853 31 " " `` 35772 853 32 the the DT 35772 853 33 fertile fertile JJ 35772 853 34 bathos bathos NN 35772 853 35 of of IN 35772 853 36 experience experience NN 35772 853 37 . . . 35772 853 38 " " '' 35772 854 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 854 2 approached approach VBD 35772 854 3 religion religion NN 35772 854 4 from from IN 35772 854 5 the the DT 35772 854 6 side side NN 35772 854 7 of of IN 35772 854 8 inner inner JJ 35772 854 9 experience experience NN 35772 854 10 , , , 35772 854 11 the the DT 35772 854 12 point point NN 35772 854 13 of of IN 35772 854 14 view view NN 35772 854 15 of of IN 35772 854 16 psychology psychology NN 35772 854 17 . . . 35772 855 1 The the DT 35772 855 2 profound profound JJ 35772 855 3 insight insight NN 35772 855 4 of of IN 35772 855 5 Kant Kant NNP 35772 855 6 had have VBD 35772 855 7 already already RB 35772 855 8 shown show VBN 35772 855 9 that that IN 35772 855 10 this this DT 35772 855 11 was be VBD 35772 855 12 the the DT 35772 855 13 direction direction NN 35772 855 14 on on IN 35772 855 15 which which WDT 35772 855 16 future future JJ 35772 855 17 thought thought NN 35772 855 18 would would MD 35772 855 19 travel travel VB 35772 855 20 , , , 35772 855 21 by by IN 35772 855 22 tracing trace VBG 35772 855 23 back back RP 35772 855 24 the the DT 35772 855 25 religious religious JJ 35772 855 26 problem problem NN 35772 855 27 to to IN 35772 855 28 a a DT 35772 855 29 _ _ NNP 35772 855 30 personal personal JJ 35772 855 31 need need NN 35772 855 32 _ _ NNP 35772 855 33 more more RBR 35772 855 34 clearly clearly RB 35772 855 35 and and CC 35772 855 36 penetratingly penetratingly RB 35772 855 37 than than IN 35772 855 38 ever ever RB 35772 855 39 before before RB 35772 855 40 -- -- : 35772 855 41 a a DT 35772 855 42 need need NN 35772 855 43 set set VBN 35772 855 44 up up RP 35772 855 45 by by IN 35772 855 46 the the DT 35772 855 47 incongruity incongruity NN 35772 855 48 of of IN 35772 855 49 the the DT 35772 855 50 real real JJ 35772 855 51 and and CC 35772 855 52 the the DT 35772 855 53 ideal ideal NN 35772 855 54 . . . 35772 856 1 HIS his PRP$ 35772 856 2 VIEW view NN 35772 856 3 OF of IN 35772 856 4 RELIGIOUS RELIGIOUS NNP 35772 856 5 IDEAS.--Just ideas.--just JJ 35772 856 6 as as IN 35772 856 7 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 856 8 , , , 35772 856 9 owing owe VBG 35772 856 10 to to IN 35772 856 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 856 12 own own JJ 35772 856 13 religious religious JJ 35772 856 14 experience experience NN 35772 856 15 , , , 35772 856 16 was be VBD 35772 856 17 in in IN 35772 856 18 a a DT 35772 856 19 better well JJR 35772 856 20 position position NN 35772 856 21 to to TO 35772 856 22 attack attack VB 35772 856 23 the the DT 35772 856 24 religious religious JJ 35772 856 25 problem problem NN 35772 856 26 than than IN 35772 856 27 the the DT 35772 856 28 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 856 29 of of IN 35772 856 30 the the DT 35772 856 31 " " `` 35772 856 32 enlightenment enlightenment NN 35772 856 33 , , , 35772 856 34 " " '' 35772 856 35 so so RB 35772 856 36 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 856 37 had have VBD 35772 856 38 the the DT 35772 856 39 advantage advantage NN 35772 856 40 of of IN 35772 856 41 some some DT 35772 856 42 Romanticists Romanticists NNPS 35772 856 43 . . . 35772 857 1 As as IN 35772 857 2 a a DT 35772 857 3 boy boy NN 35772 857 4 , , , 35772 857 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 857 6 had have VBD 35772 857 7 been be VBN 35772 857 8 put put VBN 35772 857 9 to to IN 35772 857 10 school school NN 35772 857 11 with with IN 35772 857 12 the the DT 35772 857 13 Moravians Moravians NNPS 35772 857 14 , , , 35772 857 15 and and CC 35772 857 16 throughout throughout IN 35772 857 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 857 18 own own JJ 35772 857 19 life life NN 35772 857 20 he -PRON- PRP 35772 857 21 never never RB 35772 857 22 ceased cease VBD 35772 857 23 to to TO 35772 857 24 declare declare VB 35772 857 25 that that IN 35772 857 26 the the DT 35772 857 27 years year NNS 35772 857 28 spent spend VBN 35772 857 29 among among IN 35772 857 30 them -PRON- PRP 35772 857 31 had have VBD 35772 857 32 been be VBN 35772 857 33 of of IN 35772 857 34 vital vital JJ 35772 857 35 importance importance NN 35772 857 36 to to IN 35772 857 37 the the DT 35772 857 38 development development NN 35772 857 39 of of IN 35772 857 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 857 41 views view NNS 35772 857 42 . . . 35772 858 1 In in IN 35772 858 2 1801 1801 CD 35772 858 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 858 4 writes write VBZ 35772 858 5 : : : 35772 858 6 " " `` 35772 858 7 My -PRON- PRP$ 35772 858 8 way way NN 35772 858 9 of of IN 35772 858 10 thinking thinking NN 35772 858 11 has have VBZ 35772 858 12 indeed indeed RB 35772 858 13 no no DT 35772 858 14 other other JJ 35772 858 15 foundation foundation NN 35772 858 16 than than IN 35772 858 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 858 18 own own JJ 35772 858 19 peculiar peculiar JJ 35772 858 20 character character NN 35772 858 21 , , , 35772 858 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 858 23 inborn inborn NN 35772 858 24 mysticism mysticism NN 35772 858 25 , , , 35772 858 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 858 27 education education NN 35772 858 28 as as IN 35772 858 29 it -PRON- PRP 35772 858 30 has have VBZ 35772 858 31 been be VBN 35772 858 32 determined determine VBN 35772 858 33 from from IN 35772 858 34 within within IN 35772 858 35 . . . 35772 858 36 " " '' 35772 859 1 And and CC 35772 859 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 859 3 own own JJ 35772 859 4 experience experience NN 35772 859 5 of of IN 35772 859 6 religion religion NN 35772 859 7 established establish VBN 35772 859 8 in in IN 35772 859 9 him -PRON- PRP 35772 859 10 the the DT 35772 859 11 conviction conviction NN 35772 859 12 that that IN 35772 859 13 the the DT 35772 859 14 innermost innermost JJS 35772 859 15 life life NN 35772 859 16 of of IN 35772 859 17 men man NNS 35772 859 18 must must MD 35772 859 19 be be VB 35772 859 20 lived live VBN 35772 859 21 in in IN 35772 859 22 feeling feeling NN 35772 859 23 , , , 35772 859 24 and and CC 35772 859 25 that that IN 35772 859 26 this this DT 35772 859 27 alone alone RB 35772 859 28 can can MD 35772 859 29 bring bring VB 35772 859 30 man man NN 35772 859 31 into into IN 35772 859 32 immediate immediate JJ 35772 859 33 relation relation NN 35772 859 34 to to IN 35772 859 35 the the DT 35772 859 36 highest high JJS 35772 859 37 . . . 35772 860 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 860 2 acceptance acceptance NN 35772 860 3 of of IN 35772 860 4 Kant Kant NNP 35772 860 5 's 's POS 35772 860 6 criticism criticism NN 35772 860 7 of of IN 35772 860 8 reason reason NN 35772 860 9 led lead VBD 35772 860 10 him -PRON- PRP 35772 860 11 to to TO 35772 860 12 understand understand VB 35772 860 13 that that IN 35772 860 14 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 860 15 concepts concept NNS 35772 860 16 , , , 35772 860 17 in in IN 35772 860 18 the the DT 35772 860 19 religious religious JJ 35772 860 20 sphere sphere NN 35772 860 21 , , , 35772 860 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 860 23 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 861 1 dogmas dogmas NNP 35772 861 2 ) ) -RRB- 35772 861 3 must must MD 35772 861 4 always always RB 35772 861 5 be be VB 35772 861 6 of of IN 35772 861 7 secondary secondary JJ 35772 861 8 importance importance NN 35772 861 9 : : : 35772 861 10 _ _ NNP 35772 861 11 experience experience NN 35772 861 12 _ _ NNP 35772 861 13 comes come VBZ 35772 861 14 first first RB 35772 861 15 . . . 35772 862 1 And and CC 35772 862 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 862 3 profound profound JJ 35772 862 4 originality originality NN 35772 862 5 lies lie VBZ 35772 862 6 just just RB 35772 862 7 here here RB 35772 862 8 , , , 35772 862 9 and and CC 35772 862 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 862 11 is be VBZ 35772 862 12 just just RB 35772 862 13 here here RB 35772 862 14 that that IN 35772 862 15 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 862 16 stands stand VBZ 35772 862 17 out out RP 35772 862 18 as as IN 35772 862 19 the the DT 35772 862 20 forerunner forerunner NN 35772 862 21 of of IN 35772 862 22 the the DT 35772 862 23 modern modern JJ 35772 862 24 view view NN 35772 862 25 . . . 35772 863 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 863 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 863 3 was be VBD 35772 863 4 who who WP 35772 863 5 first first RB 35772 863 6 made make VBD 35772 863 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 863 8 evident evident JJ 35772 863 9 that that IN 35772 863 10 religious religious JJ 35772 863 11 ideas idea NNS 35772 863 12 derive derive VBP 35772 863 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 863 14 validity validity NN 35772 863 15 from from IN 35772 863 16 that that DT 35772 863 17 inner inner JJ 35772 863 18 experience experience NN 35772 863 19 which which WDT 35772 863 20 they -PRON- PRP 35772 863 21 are be VBP 35772 863 22 an an DT 35772 863 23 attempt attempt NN 35772 863 24 to to TO 35772 863 25 describe describe VB 35772 863 26 . . . 35772 864 1 If if IN 35772 864 2 a a DT 35772 864 3 dogma dogma NN 35772 864 4 is be VBZ 35772 864 5 an an DT 35772 864 6 expression expression NN 35772 864 7 of of IN 35772 864 8 an an DT 35772 864 9 experience experience NN 35772 864 10 felt feel VBN 35772 864 11 by by IN 35772 864 12 man man NN 35772 864 13 in in IN 35772 864 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 864 15 innermost innermost JJS 35772 864 16 life life NN 35772 864 17 , , , 35772 864 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 864 19 is be VBZ 35772 864 20 a a DT 35772 864 21 _ _ NNP 35772 864 22 valid valid JJ 35772 864 23 _ _ NNP 35772 864 24 dogma dogma NN 35772 864 25 , , , 35772 864 26 even even RB 35772 864 27 if if IN 35772 864 28 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 864 29 criticism criticism NN 35772 864 30 hesitates hesitate VBZ 35772 864 31 to to TO 35772 864 32 sanction sanction VB 35772 864 33 it -PRON- PRP 35772 864 34 . . . 35772 865 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 865 2 31 31 CD 35772 865 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 865 4 WHAT what WP 35772 865 5 IS be VBZ 35772 865 6 RELIGION?--The religion?--the DT 35772 865 7 distance distance NN 35772 865 8 of of IN 35772 865 9 this this DT 35772 865 10 position position NN 35772 865 11 from from IN 35772 865 12 that that DT 35772 865 13 of of IN 35772 865 14 the the DT 35772 865 15 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 865 16 century century NN 35772 865 17 intellectualism intellectualism NN 35772 865 18 which which WDT 35772 865 19 regarded regard VBD 35772 865 20 religion religion NN 35772 865 21 either either CC 35772 865 22 as as IN 35772 865 23 a a DT 35772 865 24 form form NN 35772 865 25 of of IN 35772 865 26 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 865 27 or or CC 35772 865 28 of of IN 35772 865 29 superstition superstition NN 35772 865 30 , , , 35772 865 31 is be VBZ 35772 865 32 obvious obvious JJ 35772 865 33 . . . 35772 866 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 866 2 attacks attack VBZ 35772 866 3 two two CD 35772 866 4 intellectualist intellectualist JJ 35772 866 5 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 866 6 in in IN 35772 866 7 particular particular JJ 35772 866 8 : : : 35772 866 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 866 10 1 1 LS 35772 866 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 866 12 That that IN 35772 866 13 according accord VBG 35772 866 14 to to IN 35772 866 15 which which WDT 35772 866 16 religion religion NN 35772 866 17 is be VBZ 35772 866 18 conceived conceive VBN 35772 866 19 of of RB 35772 866 20 primarily primarily RB 35772 866 21 as as IN 35772 866 22 a a DT 35772 866 23 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 866 24 ( ( -LRB- 35772 866 25 either either CC 35772 866 26 revealed reveal VBN 35772 866 27 , , , 35772 866 28 or or CC 35772 866 29 grounded ground VBN 35772 866 30 on on IN 35772 866 31 reason reason NN 35772 866 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 866 33 , , , 35772 866 34 and and CC 35772 866 35 ( ( -LRB- 35772 866 36 2 2 LS 35772 866 37 ) ) -RRB- 35772 866 38 That that WDT 35772 866 39 which which WDT 35772 866 40 regards regard VBZ 35772 866 41 religion religion NN 35772 866 42 as as IN 35772 866 43 merely merely RB 35772 866 44 a a DT 35772 866 45 means means NN 35772 866 46 towards towards IN 35772 866 47 morality morality NN 35772 866 48 . . . 35772 867 1 Religion religion NN 35772 867 2 , , , 35772 867 3 according accord VBG 35772 867 4 to to IN 35772 867 5 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 867 6 , , , 35772 867 7 has have VBZ 35772 867 8 an an DT 35772 867 9 existence existence NN 35772 867 10 independent independent JJ 35772 867 11 of of IN 35772 867 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 867 13 though though RB 35772 867 14 , , , 35772 867 15 no no RB 35772 867 16 doubt doubt RB 35772 867 17 , , , 35772 867 18 associated associate VBN 35772 867 19 with with IN 35772 867 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 867 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 867 22 , , , 35772 867 23 superstition superstition NN 35772 867 24 , , , 35772 867 25 or or CC 35772 867 26 morality morality NN 35772 867 27 . . . 35772 868 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 868 2 essence essence NN 35772 868 3 consists consist VBZ 35772 868 4 neither neither CC 35772 868 5 in in IN 35772 868 6 speculation speculation NN 35772 868 7 nor nor CC 35772 868 8 in in IN 35772 868 9 action action NN 35772 868 10 , , , 35772 868 11 but but CC 35772 868 12 in in IN 35772 868 13 a a DT 35772 868 14 certain certain JJ 35772 868 15 type type NN 35772 868 16 of of IN 35772 868 17 feeling feeling NN 35772 868 18 , , , 35772 868 19 of of IN 35772 868 20 inner inner JJ 35772 868 21 experience experience NN 35772 868 22 . . . 35772 869 1 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 869 2 characterised characterise VBD 35772 869 3 this this DT 35772 869 4 particular particular JJ 35772 869 5 type type NN 35772 869 6 of of IN 35772 869 7 feeling feeling NN 35772 869 8 as as IN 35772 869 9 _ _ NNP 35772 869 10 a a DT 35772 869 11 feeling feeling NN 35772 869 12 of of IN 35772 869 13 dependence dependence NN 35772 869 14 _ _ NNP 35772 869 15 : : : 35772 869 16 the the DT 35772 869 17 immediate immediate JJ 35772 869 18 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 869 19 that that IN 35772 869 20 everything everything NN 35772 869 21 finite finite NNP 35772 869 22 exists exist VBZ 35772 869 23 in in IN 35772 869 24 and and CC 35772 869 25 through through IN 35772 869 26 the the DT 35772 869 27 infinite infinite NN 35772 869 28 , , , 35772 869 29 everything everything NN 35772 869 30 temporal temporal JJ 35772 869 31 in in IN 35772 869 32 and and CC 35772 869 33 through through IN 35772 869 34 the the DT 35772 869 35 eternal eternal NN 35772 869 36 . . . 35772 870 1 That that IN 35772 870 2 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 870 3 should should MD 35772 870 4 have have VB 35772 870 5 described describe VBN 35772 870 6 the the DT 35772 870 7 specifically specifically RB 35772 870 8 religious religious JJ 35772 870 9 feeling feeling NN 35772 870 10 in in IN 35772 870 11 this this DT 35772 870 12 particular particular JJ 35772 870 13 way way NN 35772 870 14 is be VBZ 35772 870 15 comparatively comparatively RB 35772 870 16 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 870 17 so so RB 35772 870 18 far far RB 35772 870 19 as as IN 35772 870 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 870 21 present present JJ 35772 870 22 purpose purpose NN 35772 870 23 is be VBZ 35772 870 24 concerned concern VBN 35772 870 25 . . . 35772 871 1 The the DT 35772 871 2 point point NN 35772 871 3 of of IN 35772 871 4 importance importance NN 35772 871 5 is be VBZ 35772 871 6 that that IN 35772 871 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 871 8 was be VBD 35772 871 9 the the DT 35772 871 10 first first JJ 35772 871 11 to to TO 35772 871 12 recognise recognise VB 35772 871 13 the the DT 35772 871 14 _ _ NNP 35772 871 15 independence independence NN 35772 871 16 _ _ NNP 35772 871 17 of of IN 35772 871 18 religion religion NN 35772 871 19 , , , 35772 871 20 to to TO 35772 871 21 see see VB 35772 871 22 in in IN 35772 871 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 871 24 a a DT 35772 871 25 legitimate legitimate JJ 35772 871 26 and and CC 35772 871 27 natural natural JJ 35772 871 28 form form NN 35772 871 29 of of IN 35772 871 30 human human JJ 35772 871 31 activity activity NN 35772 871 32 , , , 35772 871 33 which which WDT 35772 871 34 exists exist VBZ 35772 871 35 , , , 35772 871 36 not not RB 35772 871 37 for for IN 35772 871 38 the the DT 35772 871 39 sake sake NN 35772 871 40 of of IN 35772 871 41 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 871 42 or or CC 35772 871 43 of of IN 35772 871 44 morality morality NN 35772 871 45 , , , 35772 871 46 but but CC 35772 871 47 for for IN 35772 871 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 871 49 own own JJ 35772 871 50 sake sake NN 35772 871 51 , , , 35772 871 52 and and CC 35772 871 53 on on IN 35772 871 54 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 871 55 own own JJ 35772 871 56 account account NN 35772 871 57 . . . 35772 872 1 Here here RB 35772 872 2 , , , 35772 872 3 though though IN 35772 872 4 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 872 5 took take VBD 35772 872 6 a a DT 35772 872 7 different different JJ 35772 872 8 view view NN 35772 872 9 , , , 35772 872 10 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 872 11 is be VBZ 35772 872 12 one one CD 35772 872 13 in in IN 35772 872 14 spirit spirit NN 35772 872 15 with with IN 35772 872 16 the the DT 35772 872 17 Romantic romantic JJ 35772 872 18 school school NN 35772 872 19 ; ; : 35772 872 20 indeed indeed RB 35772 872 21 , , , 35772 872 22 he -PRON- PRP 35772 872 23 may may MD 35772 872 24 be be VB 35772 872 25 said say VBN 35772 872 26 to to TO 35772 872 27 have have VB 35772 872 28 drawn draw VBN 35772 872 29 the the DT 35772 872 30 logical logical JJ 35772 872 31 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 872 32 of of IN 35772 872 33 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 872 34 . . . 35772 873 1 The the DT 35772 873 2 independence independence NN 35772 873 3 and and CC 35772 873 4 originality originality NN 35772 873 5 of of IN 35772 873 6 religion religion NN 35772 873 7 is be VBZ 35772 873 8 the the DT 35772 873 9 necessary necessary JJ 35772 873 10 consequence consequence NN 35772 873 11 of of IN 35772 873 12 a a DT 35772 873 13 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 873 14 which which WDT 35772 873 15 set set VBD 35772 873 16 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 873 17 against against IN 35772 873 18 the the DT 35772 873 19 unbalanced unbalanced JJ 35772 873 20 intellectualism intellectualism NN 35772 873 21 of of IN 35772 873 22 the the DT 35772 873 23 " " `` 35772 873 24 enlightenment enlightenment NN 35772 873 25 . . . 35772 873 26 " " '' 35772 874 1 The the DT 35772 874 2 permanent permanent JJ 35772 874 3 significance significance NN 35772 874 4 of of IN 35772 874 5 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 874 6 lies lie VBZ 35772 874 7 here here RB 35772 874 8 : : : 35772 874 9 That that IN 35772 874 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 874 11 discredited discredit VBD 35772 874 12 once once RB 35772 874 13 for for IN 35772 874 14 all all PDT 35772 874 15 the the DT 35772 874 16 notion notion NN 35772 874 17 that that IN 35772 874 18 there there EX 35772 874 19 is be VBZ 35772 874 20 only only RB 35772 874 21 one one CD 35772 874 22 road road NN 35772 874 23 to to IN 35772 874 24 reality reality NN 35772 874 25 -- -- : 35772 874 26 that that DT 35772 874 27 of of IN 35772 874 28 logic logic NN 35772 874 29 . . . 35772 875 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 875 2 is be VBZ 35772 875 3 not not RB 35772 875 4 only only RB 35772 875 5 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 875 6 , , , 35772 875 7 but but CC 35772 875 8 religion religion NN 35772 875 9 and and CC 35772 875 10 art art NN 35772 875 11 that that WDT 35772 875 12 remove remove VBP 35772 875 13 the the DT 35772 875 14 veil veil NN 35772 875 15 which which WDT 35772 875 16 hides hide VBZ 35772 875 17 the the DT 35772 875 18 supra supra NNP 35772 875 19 - - HYPH 35772 875 20 sensible sensible JJ 35772 875 21 world world NN 35772 875 22 from from IN 35772 875 23 us -PRON- PRP 35772 875 24 . . . 35772 876 1 And and CC 35772 876 2 to to TO 35772 876 3 close close VB 35772 876 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 876 5 eyes eye NNS 35772 876 6 to to IN 35772 876 7 the the DT 35772 876 8 facts fact NNS 35772 876 9 of of IN 35772 876 10 religious religious JJ 35772 876 11 experience experience NN 35772 876 12 , , , 35772 876 13 or or CC 35772 876 14 to to TO 35772 876 15 attempt attempt VB 35772 876 16 to to TO 35772 876 17 discredit discredit VB 35772 876 18 them -PRON- PRP 35772 876 19 by by IN 35772 876 20 the the DT 35772 876 21 application application NN 35772 876 22 of of IN 35772 876 23 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 876 24 terms term NNS 35772 876 25 such such JJ 35772 876 26 as as IN 35772 876 27 " " `` 35772 876 28 superstition superstition NN 35772 876 29 , , , 35772 876 30 " " '' 35772 876 31 is be VBZ 35772 876 32 not not RB 35772 876 33 only only JJ 35772 876 34 to to TO 35772 876 35 display display VB 35772 876 36 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 876 37 as as IN 35772 876 38 philistines philistines NNP 35772 876 39 , , , 35772 876 40 but but CC 35772 876 41 also also RB 35772 876 42 to to TO 35772 876 43 forsake forsake VB 35772 876 44 the the DT 35772 876 45 highest high JJS 35772 876 46 traditions tradition NNS 35772 876 47 of of IN 35772 876 48 science science NN 35772 876 49 -- -- : 35772 876 50 veneration veneration NN 35772 876 51 for for IN 35772 876 52 experience experience NN 35772 876 53 , , , 35772 876 54 and and CC 35772 876 55 the the DT 35772 876 56 realms realm NNS 35772 876 57 of of IN 35772 876 58 fact fact NN 35772 876 59 . . . 35772 877 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 877 2 VIII viii NN 35772 877 3 MECHANISM MECHANISM NNP 35772 877 4 AND and CC 35772 877 5 LIFE life NN 35772 877 6 RECAPITULATORY.--We RECAPITULATORY.--We NNS 35772 877 7 have have VBP 35772 877 8 already already RB 35772 877 9 observed observe VBN 35772 877 10 the the DT 35772 877 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 877 12 theory theory NN 35772 877 13 , , , 35772 877 14 in in IN 35772 877 15 the the DT 35772 877 16 hands hand NNS 35772 877 17 of of IN 35772 877 18 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 877 19 , , , 35772 877 20 expanding expand VBG 35772 877 21 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 877 22 to to TO 35772 877 23 cover cover VB 35772 877 24 organisms organism NNS 35772 877 25 and and CC 35772 877 26 the the DT 35772 877 27 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 877 28 of of IN 35772 877 29 life life NN 35772 877 30 , , , 35772 877 31 and and CC 35772 877 32 in in IN 35772 877 33 La La NNP 35772 877 34 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 877 35 's 's POS 35772 877 36 _ _ NNP 35772 877 37 L'Homme L'Homme NNP 35772 877 38 Machine Machine NNP 35772 877 39 _ _ NNP 35772 877 40 , , , 35772 877 41 reducing reduce VBG 35772 877 42 even even RB 35772 877 43 human human JJ 35772 877 44 beings being NNS 35772 877 45 to to IN 35772 877 46 the the DT 35772 877 47 status status NN 35772 877 48 of of IN 35772 877 49 automata automata NN 35772 877 50 . . . 35772 878 1 These these DT 35772 878 2 theories theory NNS 35772 878 3 were be VBD 35772 878 4 , , , 35772 878 5 however however RB 35772 878 6 , , , 35772 878 7 known know VBN 35772 878 8 to to TO 35772 878 9 be be VB 35772 878 10 insecurely insecurely RB 35772 878 11 based base VBN 35772 878 12 upon upon IN 35772 878 13 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 878 14 hasty hasty JJ 35772 878 15 generalisations generalisation NNS 35772 878 16 , , , 35772 878 17 for for IN 35772 878 18 , , , 35772 878 19 in in IN 35772 878 20 point point NN 35772 878 21 of of IN 35772 878 22 fact fact NN 35772 878 23 , , , 35772 878 24 the the DT 35772 878 25 science science NN 35772 878 26 of of IN 35772 878 27 biology biology NN 35772 878 28 was be VBD 35772 878 29 as as RB 35772 878 30 yet yet RB 35772 878 31 in in IN 35772 878 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 878 33 infancy infancy NN 35772 878 34 ; ; : 35772 878 35 the the DT 35772 878 36 _ _ NNP 35772 878 37 data datum NNS 35772 878 38 _ _ NNP 35772 878 39 for for IN 35772 878 40 a a DT 35772 878 41 complete complete JJ 35772 878 42 vindication vindication NN 35772 878 43 of of IN 35772 878 44 the the DT 35772 878 45 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 878 46 position position NN 35772 878 47 were be VBD 35772 878 48 as as RB 35772 878 49 yet yet RB 35772 878 50 wanting want VBG 35772 878 51 . . . 35772 879 1 ADVANCE advance RB 35772 879 2 OF of IN 35772 879 3 BIOLOGY.--Biological biology.--biological NN 35772 879 4 science science NN 35772 879 5 , , , 35772 879 6 however however RB 35772 879 7 , , , 35772 879 8 during during IN 35772 879 9 the the DT 35772 879 10 first first JJ 35772 879 11 half half NN 35772 879 12 of of IN 35772 879 13 the the DT 35772 879 14 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 879 15 century century NN 35772 879 16 made make VBD 35772 879 17 considerable considerable JJ 35772 879 18 advances advance NNS 35772 879 19 , , , 35772 879 20 and and CC 35772 879 21 research research NN 35772 879 22 continually continually RB 35772 879 23 kept keep VBD 35772 879 24 bringing bring VBG 35772 879 25 to to IN 35772 879 26 light light JJ 35772 879 27 facts fact NNS 35772 879 28 which which WDT 35772 879 29 seemed seem VBD 35772 879 30 to to TO 35772 879 31 substantiate substantiate VB 35772 879 32 the the DT 35772 879 33 brilliant brilliant JJ 35772 879 34 , , , 35772 879 35 if if IN 35772 879 36 premature premature JJ 35772 879 37 , , , 35772 879 38 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 879 39 of of IN 35772 879 40 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 879 41 . . . 35772 880 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 880 2 will will MD 35772 880 3 not not RB 35772 880 4 be be VB 35772 880 5 necessary necessary JJ 35772 880 6 for for IN 35772 880 7 us -PRON- PRP 35772 880 8 to to TO 35772 880 9 do do VB 35772 880 10 more more JJR 35772 880 11 than than IN 35772 880 12 take take VB 35772 880 13 hasty hasty JJ 35772 880 14 note note NN 35772 880 15 of of IN 35772 880 16 certain certain JJ 35772 880 17 important important JJ 35772 880 18 developments development NNS 35772 880 19 . . . 35772 881 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 881 2 was be VBD 35772 881 3 in in IN 35772 881 4 1828 1828 CD 35772 881 5 that that IN 35772 881 6 the the DT 35772 881 7 German german JJ 35772 881 8 chemist chemist NN 35772 881 9 Whöler Whöler NNP 35772 881 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 881 11 1800 1800 CD 35772 881 12 - - SYM 35772 881 13 1882 1882 CD 35772 881 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 881 15 for for IN 35772 881 16 the the DT 35772 881 17 first first JJ 35772 881 18 time time NN 35772 881 19 in in IN 35772 881 20 biological biological JJ 35772 881 21 history history NN 35772 881 22 prepared prepare VBD 35772 881 23 an an DT 35772 881 24 organic organic JJ 35772 881 25 compound compound NN 35772 881 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 881 27 urea urea NNP 35772 881 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 881 29 from from IN 35772 881 30 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 881 31 materials material NNS 35772 881 32 -- -- : 35772 881 33 an an DT 35772 881 34 achievement achievement NN 35772 881 35 universally universally RB 35772 881 36 recognised recognise VBN 35772 881 37 to to TO 35772 881 38 be be VB 35772 881 39 of of IN 35772 881 40 the the DT 35772 881 41 utmost utmost JJ 35772 881 42 significance significance NN 35772 881 43 . . . 35772 882 1 As as IN 35772 882 2 a a DT 35772 882 3 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 882 4 historian historian NN 35772 882 5 of of IN 35772 882 6 the the DT 35772 882 7 science science NN 35772 882 8 of of IN 35772 882 9 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 882 10 puts put VBZ 35772 882 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 882 12 : : : 35772 882 13 " " `` 35772 882 14 This this DT 35772 882 15 discovery discovery NN 35772 882 16 destroyed destroy VBD 35772 882 17 the the DT 35772 882 18 difference difference NN 35772 882 19 which which WDT 35772 882 20 was be VBD 35772 882 21 then then RB 35772 882 22 considered consider VBN 35772 882 23 to to TO 35772 882 24 exist exist VB 35772 882 25 between between IN 35772 882 26 organic organic JJ 35772 882 27 and and CC 35772 882 28 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 882 29 bodies body NNS 35772 882 30 , , , 35772 882 31 viz viz NN 35772 882 32 . . . 35772 883 1 that that IN 35772 883 2 the the DT 35772 883 3 former former JJ 35772 883 4 could could MD 35772 883 5 only only RB 35772 883 6 be be VB 35772 883 7 formed form VBN 35772 883 8 under under IN 35772 883 9 the the DT 35772 883 10 influence influence NN 35772 883 11 of of IN 35772 883 12 vegetable vegetable NN 35772 883 13 or or CC 35772 883 14 animal animal NN 35772 883 15 vital vital JJ 35772 883 16 forces force NNS 35772 883 17 , , , 35772 883 18 whereas whereas IN 35772 883 19 the the DT 35772 883 20 latter latter JJ 35772 883 21 could could MD 35772 883 22 be be VB 35772 883 23 artificially artificially RB 35772 883 24 produced produce VBN 35772 883 25 . . . 35772 884 1 " " `` 35772 884 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 884 3 32 32 CD 35772 884 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 884 5 Ten ten CD 35772 884 6 years year NNS 35772 884 7 later later RB 35772 884 8 another another DT 35772 884 9 German German NNP 35772 884 10 , , , 35772 884 11 Schleider Schleider NNP 35772 884 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 884 13 1804 1804 CD 35772 884 14 - - SYM 35772 884 15 1881 1881 CD 35772 884 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 884 17 propounded propound VBD 35772 884 18 the the DT 35772 884 19 cellular cellular JJ 35772 884 20 theory theory NN 35772 884 21 of of IN 35772 884 22 the the DT 35772 884 23 structure structure NN 35772 884 24 and and CC 35772 884 25 growth growth NN 35772 884 26 of of IN 35772 884 27 plants plant NNS 35772 884 28 , , , 35772 884 29 a a DT 35772 884 30 theory theory NN 35772 884 31 which which WDT 35772 884 32 was be VBD 35772 884 33 soon soon RB 35772 884 34 extended extend VBN 35772 884 35 to to TO 35772 884 36 animal animal VB 35772 884 37 organisms organism NNS 35772 884 38 by by IN 35772 884 39 Schwann Schwann NNP 35772 884 40 ( ( -LRB- 35772 884 41 1810 1810 CD 35772 884 42 - - SYM 35772 884 43 1882 1882 CD 35772 884 44 ) ) -RRB- 35772 884 45 . . . 35772 885 1 The the DT 35772 885 2 publication publication NN 35772 885 3 of of IN 35772 885 4 this this DT 35772 885 5 famous famous JJ 35772 885 6 theory theory NN 35772 885 7 was be VBD 35772 885 8 described describe VBN 35772 885 9 by by IN 35772 885 10 a a DT 35772 885 11 contemporary contemporary NN 35772 885 12 as as IN 35772 885 13 " " `` 35772 885 14 a a DT 35772 885 15 burst burst NN 35772 885 16 of of IN 35772 885 17 daylight daylight NN 35772 885 18 " " '' 35772 885 19 ; ; : 35772 885 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 885 21 indeed indeed RB 35772 885 22 illuminated illuminate VBD 35772 885 23 what what WP 35772 885 24 had have VBD 35772 885 25 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 885 26 been be VBN 35772 885 27 buried bury VBN 35772 885 28 in in IN 35772 885 29 mystery mystery NN 35772 885 30 and and CC 35772 885 31 mythology mythology NN 35772 885 32 -- -- : 35772 885 33 the the DT 35772 885 34 structure structure NN 35772 885 35 and and CC 35772 885 36 method method NN 35772 885 37 of of IN 35772 885 38 growth growth NN 35772 885 39 of of IN 35772 885 40 plants plant NNS 35772 885 41 and and CC 35772 885 42 animals animal NNS 35772 885 43 . . . 35772 886 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 886 2 seemed seem VBD 35772 886 3 to to TO 35772 886 4 render render VB 35772 886 5 superfluous superfluous JJ 35772 886 6 any any DT 35772 886 7 form form NN 35772 886 8 of of IN 35772 886 9 the the DT 35772 886 10 old old JJ 35772 886 11 conception conception NN 35772 886 12 of of IN 35772 886 13 a a DT 35772 886 14 " " `` 35772 886 15 vital vital JJ 35772 886 16 force force NN 35772 886 17 " " '' 35772 886 18 to to TO 35772 886 19 explain explain VB 35772 886 20 the the DT 35772 886 21 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 886 22 of of IN 35772 886 23 growth growth NN 35772 886 24 , , , 35772 886 25 if if IN 35772 886 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 886 27 could could MD 35772 886 28 now now RB 35772 886 29 be be VB 35772 886 30 assumed assume VBN 35772 886 31 that that IN 35772 886 32 the the DT 35772 886 33 cells cell NNS 35772 886 34 automatically automatically RB 35772 886 35 absorbed absorb VBN 35772 886 36 outside outside JJ 35772 886 37 material material NN 35772 886 38 , , , 35772 886 39 increased increase VBD 35772 886 40 in in IN 35772 886 41 number number NN 35772 886 42 by by IN 35772 886 43 the the DT 35772 886 44 division division NN 35772 886 45 of of IN 35772 886 46 individuals individual NNS 35772 886 47 , , , 35772 886 48 and and CC 35772 886 49 built build VBD 35772 886 50 up up RP 35772 886 51 the the DT 35772 886 52 organism organism NN 35772 886 53 by by IN 35772 886 54 continual continual JJ 35772 886 55 repetition repetition NN 35772 886 56 of of IN 35772 886 57 this this DT 35772 886 58 process process NN 35772 886 59 . . . 35772 887 1 Schwann Schwann NNP 35772 887 2 was be VBD 35772 887 3 also also RB 35772 887 4 responsible responsible JJ 35772 887 5 for for IN 35772 887 6 initiating initiate VBG 35772 887 7 a a DT 35772 887 8 number number NN 35772 887 9 of of IN 35772 887 10 minute minute NN 35772 887 11 physiological physiological JJ 35772 887 12 investigations investigation NNS 35772 887 13 which which WDT 35772 887 14 led lead VBD 35772 887 15 to to IN 35772 887 16 a a DT 35772 887 17 far far RB 35772 887 18 more more RBR 35772 887 19 intimate intimate JJ 35772 887 20 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 887 21 of of IN 35772 887 22 the the DT 35772 887 23 action action NN 35772 887 24 of of IN 35772 887 25 nerves nerve NNS 35772 887 26 and and CC 35772 887 27 muscles muscle NNS 35772 887 28 , , , 35772 887 29 and and CC 35772 887 30 interpreted interpret VBD 35772 887 31 these these DT 35772 887 32 in in IN 35772 887 33 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 887 34 terms term NNS 35772 887 35 . . . 35772 888 1 " " `` 35772 888 2 Investigations investigation NNS 35772 888 3 which which WDT 35772 888 4 were be VBD 35772 888 5 carried carry VBN 35772 888 6 on on RP 35772 888 7 with with IN 35772 888 8 all all PDT 35772 888 9 the the DT 35772 888 10 resources resource NNS 35772 888 11 of of IN 35772 888 12 modern modern JJ 35772 888 13 physics physics NN 35772 888 14 regarding regard VBG 35772 888 15 the the DT 35772 888 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 888 17 of of IN 35772 888 18 animal animal NN 35772 888 19 movements movement NNS 35772 888 20 , , , 35772 888 21 gradually gradually RB 35772 888 22 substituted substitute VBN 35772 888 23 for for IN 35772 888 24 the the DT 35772 888 25 miracles miracle NNS 35772 888 26 of of IN 35772 888 27 the the DT 35772 888 28 ' ' `` 35772 888 29 vital vital JJ 35772 888 30 forces force NNS 35772 888 31 ' ' POS 35772 888 32 a a DT 35772 888 33 molecular molecular JJ 35772 888 34 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 888 35 , , , 35772 888 36 complicated complicate VBN 35772 888 37 , , , 35772 888 38 indeed indeed RB 35772 888 39 , , , 35772 888 40 and and CC 35772 888 41 likely likely JJ 35772 888 42 to to TO 35772 888 43 baffle baffle VB 35772 888 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 888 45 efforts effort NNS 35772 888 46 for for IN 35772 888 47 a a DT 35772 888 48 long long JJ 35772 888 49 time time NN 35772 888 50 to to TO 35772 888 51 come come VB 35772 888 52 , , , 35772 888 53 but but CC 35772 888 54 intelligible intelligible JJ 35772 888 55 , , , 35772 888 56 nevertheless nevertheless RB 35772 888 57 , , , 35772 888 58 as as IN 35772 888 59 a a DT 35772 888 60 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 888 61 . . . 35772 889 1 " " `` 35772 889 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 889 3 33 33 CD 35772 889 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 889 5 Subsequent subsequent JJ 35772 889 6 researches research NNS 35772 889 7 , , , 35772 889 8 notably notably RB 35772 889 9 of of IN 35772 889 10 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 35772 889 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 889 12 1821 1821 CD 35772 889 13 - - SYM 35772 889 14 1895 1895 CD 35772 889 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 889 16 and and CC 35772 889 17 Meyer Meyer NNP 35772 889 18 , , , 35772 889 19 lent lend VBD 35772 889 20 strong strong JJ 35772 889 21 support support NN 35772 889 22 to to IN 35772 889 23 this this DT 35772 889 24 interpretation interpretation NN 35772 889 25 . . . 35772 890 1 The the DT 35772 890 2 conception conception NN 35772 890 3 of of IN 35772 890 4 the the DT 35772 890 5 conservation conservation NN 35772 890 6 of of IN 35772 890 7 energy energy NN 35772 890 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 890 9 an an DT 35772 890 10 important important JJ 35772 890 11 axiom axiom NN 35772 890 12 of of IN 35772 890 13 the the DT 35772 890 14 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 890 15 theory theory NN 35772 890 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 890 17 was be VBD 35772 890 18 successfully successfully RB 35772 890 19 applied apply VBN 35772 890 20 by by IN 35772 890 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 890 22 to to IN 35772 890 23 the the DT 35772 890 24 economy economy NN 35772 890 25 of of IN 35772 890 26 organisms organism NNS 35772 890 27 . . . 35772 891 1 The the DT 35772 891 2 organism organism NN 35772 891 3 was be VBD 35772 891 4 found find VBN 35772 891 5 not not RB 35772 891 6 to to IN 35772 891 7 _ _ NNP 35772 891 8 create create VB 35772 891 9 _ _ NNP 35772 891 10 energy energy NN 35772 891 11 , , , 35772 891 12 but but CC 35772 891 13 only only RB 35772 891 14 to to TO 35772 891 15 contain contain VB 35772 891 16 remarkably remarkably RB 35772 891 17 efficient efficient JJ 35772 891 18 means mean NNS 35772 891 19 of of IN 35772 891 20 deriving derive VBG 35772 891 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 891 22 from from IN 35772 891 23 materials material NNS 35772 891 24 absorbed absorb VBN 35772 891 25 as as IN 35772 891 26 food food NN 35772 891 27 . . . 35772 892 1 Thus thus RB 35772 892 2 animal animal NN 35772 892 3 warmth warmth NN 35772 892 4 and and CC 35772 892 5 the the DT 35772 892 6 power power NN 35772 892 7 of of IN 35772 892 8 motion motion NN 35772 892 9 are be VBP 35772 892 10 originally originally RB 35772 892 11 " " `` 35772 892 12 sunlight sunlight NN 35772 892 13 transformed transform VBN 35772 892 14 in in IN 35772 892 15 the the DT 35772 892 16 organism organism NN 35772 892 17 of of IN 35772 892 18 the the DT 35772 892 19 plant plant NN 35772 892 20 , , , 35772 892 21 " " '' 35772 892 22 and and CC 35772 892 23 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 892 24 appropriated appropriate VBN 35772 892 25 by by IN 35772 892 26 the the DT 35772 892 27 animal animal NN 35772 892 28 . . . 35772 893 1 The the DT 35772 893 2 power power NN 35772 893 3 with with IN 35772 893 4 which which WDT 35772 893 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 893 6 move move VBP 35772 893 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 893 8 limbs limb NNS 35772 893 9 is be VBZ 35772 893 10 as as RB 35772 893 11 much much JJ 35772 893 12 the the DT 35772 893 13 product product NN 35772 893 14 of of IN 35772 893 15 combustion combustion NN 35772 893 16 as as IN 35772 893 17 is be VBZ 35772 893 18 the the DT 35772 893 19 power power NN 35772 893 20 of of IN 35772 893 21 a a DT 35772 893 22 steam steam NN 35772 893 23 engine engine NN 35772 893 24 , , , 35772 893 25 the the DT 35772 893 26 only only JJ 35772 893 27 difference difference NN 35772 893 28 being be VBG 35772 893 29 that that IN 35772 893 30 the the DT 35772 893 31 organism organism NN 35772 893 32 is be VBZ 35772 893 33 , , , 35772 893 34 of of IN 35772 893 35 the the DT 35772 893 36 two two CD 35772 893 37 , , , 35772 893 38 the the DT 35772 893 39 more more RBR 35772 893 40 efficient efficient JJ 35772 893 41 converter converter NN 35772 893 42 of of IN 35772 893 43 energy energy NN 35772 893 44 . . . 35772 894 1 THE the DT 35772 894 2 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 894 3 THEORY THEORY NNP 35772 894 4 SUBSTANTIATED.--Thus SUBSTANTIATED.--Thus NNPS 35772 894 5 , , , 35772 894 6 whether whether IN 35772 894 7 biologists biologist NNS 35772 894 8 were be VBD 35772 894 9 considering consider VBG 35772 894 10 the the DT 35772 894 11 _ _ NNP 35772 894 12 structure structure NN 35772 894 13 _ _ NNP 35772 894 14 or or CC 35772 894 15 the the DT 35772 894 16 _ _ NNP 35772 894 17 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 894 18 _ _ NNP 35772 894 19 of of IN 35772 894 20 organisms organism NNS 35772 894 21 , , , 35772 894 22 they -PRON- PRP 35772 894 23 were be VBD 35772 894 24 arriving arrive VBG 35772 894 25 at at IN 35772 894 26 the the DT 35772 894 27 same same JJ 35772 894 28 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 894 29 . . . 35772 895 1 The the DT 35772 895 2 structure structure NN 35772 895 3 was be VBD 35772 895 4 revealed reveal VBN 35772 895 5 as as IN 35772 895 6 physical physical JJ 35772 895 7 and and CC 35772 895 8 chemical chemical NN 35772 895 9 structure structure NN 35772 895 10 , , , 35772 895 11 and and CC 35772 895 12 the the DT 35772 895 13 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 895 14 as as IN 35772 895 15 the the DT 35772 895 16 resultant resultant NN 35772 895 17 of of IN 35772 895 18 familiar familiar JJ 35772 895 19 physical physical JJ 35772 895 20 and and CC 35772 895 21 chemical chemical NN 35772 895 22 processes process NNS 35772 895 23 . . . 35772 896 1 Hence hence RB 35772 896 2 biology biology NN 35772 896 3 came come VBD 35772 896 4 to to TO 35772 896 5 be be VB 35772 896 6 regarded regard VBN 35772 896 7 as as IN 35772 896 8 a a DT 35772 896 9 compartment compartment NN 35772 896 10 of of IN 35772 896 11 physics physics NN 35772 896 12 and and CC 35772 896 13 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 896 14 , , , 35772 896 15 for for IN 35772 896 16 life life NN 35772 896 17 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 896 18 was be VBD 35772 896 19 nothing nothing NN 35772 896 20 but but IN 35772 896 21 a a DT 35772 896 22 complex complex JJ 35772 896 23 physical physical JJ 35772 896 24 or or CC 35772 896 25 chemical chemical NN 35772 896 26 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 896 27 . . . 35772 897 1 Life life NN 35772 897 2 could could MD 35772 897 3 thus thus RB 35772 897 4 be be VB 35772 897 5 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 35772 897 6 expressed express VBN 35772 897 7 in in IN 35772 897 8 terms term NNS 35772 897 9 of of IN 35772 897 10 matter matter NN 35772 897 11 and and CC 35772 897 12 energy energy NN 35772 897 13 . . . 35772 898 1 The the DT 35772 898 2 speculations speculation NNS 35772 898 3 of of IN 35772 898 4 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 898 5 seemed seem VBD 35772 898 6 to to TO 35772 898 7 be be VB 35772 898 8 established establish VBN 35772 898 9 by by IN 35772 898 10 experimental experimental JJ 35772 898 11 science science NN 35772 898 12 . . . 35772 899 1 THE the DT 35772 899 2 FINAL FINAL NNP 35772 899 3 OBSTACLE.--The obstacle.--the JJ 35772 899 4 situation situation NN 35772 899 5 , , , 35772 899 6 already already RB 35772 899 7 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 35772 899 8 to to IN 35772 899 9 those those DT 35772 899 10 whose whose WP$ 35772 899 11 hope hope NN 35772 899 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 899 13 was be VBD 35772 899 14 to to TO 35772 899 15 see see VB 35772 899 16 the the DT 35772 899 17 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 899 18 theory theory NN 35772 899 19 impregnably impregnably RB 35772 899 20 established establish VBN 35772 899 21 , , , 35772 899 22 was be VBD 35772 899 23 marred mar VBN 35772 899 24 , , , 35772 899 25 however however RB 35772 899 26 , , , 35772 899 27 by by IN 35772 899 28 one one CD 35772 899 29 untoward untoward JJ 35772 899 30 circumstance circumstance NN 35772 899 31 . . . 35772 900 1 The the DT 35772 900 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 900 3 of of IN 35772 900 4 organic organic JJ 35772 900 5 structure structure NN 35772 900 6 , , , 35772 900 7 growth growth NN 35772 900 8 , , , 35772 900 9 and and CC 35772 900 10 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 900 11 having have VBG 35772 900 12 been be VBN 35772 900 13 reduced reduce VBN 35772 900 14 to to TO 35772 900 15 order order VB 35772 900 16 , , , 35772 900 17 and and CC 35772 900 18 expressed express VBN 35772 900 19 in in IN 35772 900 20 terms term NNS 35772 900 21 of of IN 35772 900 22 physics physics NN 35772 900 23 and and CC 35772 900 24 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 900 25 , , , 35772 900 26 certain certain JJ 35772 900 27 important important JJ 35772 900 28 facts fact NNS 35772 900 29 still still RB 35772 900 30 resisted resist VBD 35772 900 31 explanation explanation NN 35772 900 32 , , , 35772 900 33 and and CC 35772 900 34 stood stand VBD 35772 900 35 out out RP 35772 900 36 as as IN 35772 900 37 a a DT 35772 900 38 last last JJ 35772 900 39 stronghold stronghold NN 35772 900 40 of of IN 35772 900 41 the the DT 35772 900 42 older old JJR 35772 900 43 view view NN 35772 900 44 . . . 35772 901 1 THE the DT 35772 901 2 ORIGIN ORIGIN NNP 35772 901 3 OF of IN 35772 901 4 SPECIES.--The species.--the JJ 35772 901 5 existence existence NN 35772 901 6 of of IN 35772 901 7 definite definite JJ 35772 901 8 forms form NNS 35772 901 9 of of IN 35772 901 10 animal animal NN 35772 901 11 and and CC 35772 901 12 vegetable vegetable JJ 35772 901 13 life life NN 35772 901 14 , , , 35772 901 15 whose whose WP$ 35772 901 16 infinite infinite JJ 35772 901 17 variety variety NN 35772 901 18 and and CC 35772 901 19 complexity complexity NN 35772 901 20 was be VBD 35772 901 21 continually continually RB 35772 901 22 being be VBG 35772 901 23 increased increase VBN 35772 901 24 by by IN 35772 901 25 research[34]--still research[34]--still NNP 35772 901 26 remained remain VBD 35772 901 27 a a DT 35772 901 28 mystery mystery NN 35772 901 29 . . . 35772 902 1 How how WRB 35772 902 2 did do VBD 35772 902 3 these these DT 35772 902 4 innumerable innumerable JJ 35772 902 5 species specie NNS 35772 902 6 naturally naturally RB 35772 902 7 and and CC 35772 902 8 automatically automatically RB 35772 902 9 come come VB 35772 902 10 into into IN 35772 902 11 being being NN 35772 902 12 ? ? . 35772 903 1 was be VBD 35772 903 2 the the DT 35772 903 3 question question NN 35772 903 4 that that WDT 35772 903 5 must must MD 35772 903 6 be be VB 35772 903 7 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 35772 903 8 answered answer VBN 35772 903 9 before before IN 35772 903 10 the the DT 35772 903 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 903 12 view view NN 35772 903 13 could could MD 35772 903 14 be be VB 35772 903 15 held hold VBN 35772 903 16 to to TO 35772 903 17 cover cover VB 35772 903 18 all all PDT 35772 903 19 the the DT 35772 903 20 facts fact NNS 35772 903 21 . . . 35772 904 1 The the DT 35772 904 2 direction direction NN 35772 904 3 in in IN 35772 904 4 which which WDT 35772 904 5 to to TO 35772 904 6 look look VB 35772 904 7 for for IN 35772 904 8 a a DT 35772 904 9 reply reply NN 35772 904 10 had have VBD 35772 904 11 been be VBN 35772 904 12 indicated indicate VBN 35772 904 13 by by IN 35772 904 14 a a DT 35772 904 15 number number NN 35772 904 16 of of IN 35772 904 17 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 904 18 . . . 35772 905 1 The the DT 35772 905 2 French french JJ 35772 905 3 naturalist naturalist NN 35772 905 4 Buffon Buffon NNP 35772 905 5 , , , 35772 905 6 the the DT 35772 905 7 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 905 8 Kant Kant NNP 35772 905 9 , , , 35772 905 10 and and CC 35772 905 11 the the DT 35772 905 12 poet poet NN 35772 905 13 Goethe Goethe NNP 35772 905 14 -- -- : 35772 905 15 besides besides IN 35772 905 16 other other JJ 35772 905 17 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 905 18 -- -- : 35772 905 19 had have VBD 35772 905 20 already already RB 35772 905 21 in in IN 35772 905 22 the the DT 35772 905 23 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 905 24 century century NN 35772 905 25 familiarised familiarise VBD 35772 905 26 the the DT 35772 905 27 idea idea NN 35772 905 28 that that IN 35772 905 29 species specie NNS 35772 905 30 are be VBP 35772 905 31 not not RB 35772 905 32 immutable immutable JJ 35772 905 33 , , , 35772 905 34 but but CC 35772 905 35 that that IN 35772 905 36 , , , 35772 905 37 by by IN 35772 905 38 some some DT 35772 905 39 means mean NNS 35772 905 40 or or CC 35772 905 41 other other JJ 35772 905 42 , , , 35772 905 43 new new JJ 35772 905 44 forms form NNS 35772 905 45 of of IN 35772 905 46 life life NN 35772 905 47 are be VBP 35772 905 48 derived derive VBN 35772 905 49 from from IN 35772 905 50 pre pre JJ 35772 905 51 - - JJ 35772 905 52 existing existing JJ 35772 905 53 ones one NNS 35772 905 54 . . . 35772 906 1 The the DT 35772 906 2 conception conception NN 35772 906 3 had have VBD 35772 906 4 gained gain VBN 35772 906 5 a a DT 35772 906 6 firm firm JJ 35772 906 7 foothold foothold NN 35772 906 8 in in IN 35772 906 9 England England NNP 35772 906 10 , , , 35772 906 11 where where WRB 35772 906 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 906 13 was be VBD 35772 906 14 hospitably hospitably RB 35772 906 15 entertained entertain VBN 35772 906 16 by by IN 35772 906 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 906 18 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 906 19 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 906 20 , , , 35772 906 21 and and CC 35772 906 22 where where WRB 35772 906 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 906 24 formed form VBD 35772 906 25 the the DT 35772 906 26 staple staple NN 35772 906 27 of of IN 35772 906 28 a a DT 35772 906 29 book book NN 35772 906 30 which which WDT 35772 906 31 caused cause VBD 35772 906 32 a a DT 35772 906 33 good good JJ 35772 906 34 deal deal NN 35772 906 35 of of IN 35772 906 36 controversy controversy NN 35772 906 37 in in IN 35772 906 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 906 39 day day NN 35772 906 40 , , , 35772 906 41 and and CC 35772 906 42 which which WDT 35772 906 43 is be VBZ 35772 906 44 not not RB 35772 906 45 yet yet RB 35772 906 46 forgotten forget VBN 35772 906 47 . . . 35772 907 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 907 2 35 35 CD 35772 907 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 907 4 LAMARCK.--The lamarck.--the DT 35772 907 5 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 907 6 idea idea NN 35772 907 7 , , , 35772 907 8 however however RB 35772 907 9 , , , 35772 907 10 though though IN 35772 907 11 attractive attractive JJ 35772 907 12 to to IN 35772 907 13 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 907 14 , , , 35772 907 15 and and CC 35772 907 16 even even RB 35772 907 17 to to IN 35772 907 18 men man NNS 35772 907 19 of of IN 35772 907 20 science science NN 35772 907 21 , , , 35772 907 22 was be VBD 35772 907 23 insufficient insufficient JJ 35772 907 24 as as IN 35772 907 25 an an DT 35772 907 26 explanation explanation NN 35772 907 27 of of IN 35772 907 28 the the DT 35772 907 29 origin origin NN 35772 907 30 of of IN 35772 907 31 species specie NNS 35772 907 32 so so RB 35772 907 33 long long RB 35772 907 34 as as IN 35772 907 35 the the DT 35772 907 36 processes process NNS 35772 907 37 of of IN 35772 907 38 transformation transformation NN 35772 907 39 remained remain VBD 35772 907 40 obscure obscure JJ 35772 907 41 . . . 35772 908 1 Naturalists naturalist NNS 35772 908 2 could could MD 35772 908 3 not not RB 35772 908 4 accept accept VB 35772 908 5 an an DT 35772 908 6 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 908 7 for for IN 35772 908 8 which which WDT 35772 908 9 there there EX 35772 908 10 seemed seem VBD 35772 908 11 to to TO 35772 908 12 be be VB 35772 908 13 such such JJ 35772 908 14 imperfect imperfect JJ 35772 908 15 evidence evidence NN 35772 908 16 . . . 35772 909 1 An an DT 35772 909 2 ingenious ingenious JJ 35772 909 3 French french JJ 35772 909 4 scientist scientist NN 35772 909 5 , , , 35772 909 6 J. J. NNP 35772 909 7 Baptiste Baptiste NNP 35772 909 8 de de IN 35772 909 9 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 909 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 909 11 1744 1744 CD 35772 909 12 - - SYM 35772 909 13 1829 1829 CD 35772 909 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 909 15 had have VBD 35772 909 16 indeed indeed RB 35772 909 17 , , , 35772 909 18 in in IN 35772 909 19 1809 1809 CD 35772 909 20 , , , 35772 909 21 propounded propound VBD 35772 909 22 the the DT 35772 909 23 theory theory NN 35772 909 24 -- -- : 35772 909 25 ever ever RB 35772 909 26 since since IN 35772 909 27 known know VBN 35772 909 28 by by IN 35772 909 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 909 30 name name NN 35772 909 31 -- -- : 35772 909 32 that that IN 35772 909 33 the the DT 35772 909 34 use use NN 35772 909 35 or or CC 35772 909 36 disuse disuse NN 35772 909 37 of of IN 35772 909 38 particular particular JJ 35772 909 39 organs organ NNS 35772 909 40 might may MD 35772 909 41 , , , 35772 909 42 after after IN 35772 909 43 a a DT 35772 909 44 long long JJ 35772 909 45 series series NN 35772 909 46 of of IN 35772 909 47 generations generation NNS 35772 909 48 , , , 35772 909 49 result result VBP 35772 909 50 in in IN 35772 909 51 the the DT 35772 909 52 formation formation NN 35772 909 53 of of IN 35772 909 54 new new JJ 35772 909 55 species specie NNS 35772 909 56 . . . 35772 910 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 910 2 The the DT 35772 910 3 ideas idea NNS 35772 910 4 denoted denote VBN 35772 910 5 by by IN 35772 910 6 the the DT 35772 910 7 words word NNS 35772 910 8 " " `` 35772 910 9 environment environment NN 35772 910 10 , , , 35772 910 11 " " '' 35772 910 12 " " `` 35772 910 13 adaptation adaptation NN 35772 910 14 , , , 35772 910 15 " " '' 35772 910 16 " " `` 35772 910 17 acquired acquire VBD 35772 910 18 habits"--now habits"--now NNP 35772 910 19 so so RB 35772 910 20 familiar familiar JJ 35772 910 21 -- -- : 35772 910 22 may may MD 35772 910 23 be be VB 35772 910 24 said say VBN 35772 910 25 to to TO 35772 910 26 have have VB 35772 910 27 been be VBN 35772 910 28 introduced introduce VBN 35772 910 29 by by IN 35772 910 30 him -PRON- PRP 35772 910 31 ) ) -RRB- 35772 910 32 . . . 35772 911 1 But but CC 35772 911 2 the the DT 35772 911 3 scientific scientific JJ 35772 911 4 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 911 5 of of IN 35772 911 6 the the DT 35772 911 7 time time NN 35772 911 8 were be VBD 35772 911 9 against against IN 35772 911 10 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 911 11 's 's POS 35772 911 12 theories theory NNS 35772 911 13 , , , 35772 911 14 and and CC 35772 911 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 911 16 had have VBD 35772 911 17 to to TO 35772 911 18 lament lament VB 35772 911 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 911 20 inhospitable inhospitable JJ 35772 911 21 reception reception NN 35772 911 22 . . . 35772 912 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 912 2 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 912 3 's 's POS 35772 912 4 critics critic NNS 35772 912 5 did do VBD 35772 912 6 not not RB 35772 912 7 hesitate hesitate VB 35772 912 8 to to TO 35772 912 9 exercise exercise VB 35772 912 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 912 11 powers power NNS 35772 912 12 of of IN 35772 912 13 ridicule ridicule NN 35772 912 14 , , , 35772 912 15 or or CC 35772 912 16 to to TO 35772 912 17 make make VB 35772 912 18 fun fun NN 35772 912 19 of of IN 35772 912 20 the the DT 35772 912 21 giraffe giraffe NN 35772 912 22 who who WP 35772 912 23 derived derive VBD 35772 912 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 912 25 long long JJ 35772 912 26 neck neck NN 35772 912 27 from from IN 35772 912 28 the the DT 35772 912 29 attempts attempt NNS 35772 912 30 of of IN 35772 912 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 912 32 ancestors ancestor NNS 35772 912 33 to to TO 35772 912 34 browse browse VB 35772 912 35 on on IN 35772 912 36 high high JJ 35772 912 37 trees tree NNS 35772 912 38 . . . 35772 913 1 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 913 2 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 913 3 talks talk VBZ 35772 913 4 of of IN 35772 913 5 " " `` 35772 913 6 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 913 7 's 's POS 35772 913 8 nonsense nonsense NN 35772 913 9 , , , 35772 913 10 " " '' 35772 913 11 and and CC 35772 913 12 of of IN 35772 913 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 913 14 " " `` 35772 913 15 veritable veritable JJ 35772 913 16 rubbish"--language rubbish"--language NN 35772 913 17 , , , 35772 913 18 however however RB 35772 913 19 , , , 35772 913 20 which which WDT 35772 913 21 he -PRON- PRP 35772 913 22 was be VBD 35772 913 23 subsequently subsequently RB 35772 913 24 able able JJ 35772 913 25 to to TO 35772 913 26 retract retract VB 35772 913 27 . . . 35772 914 1 THE the DT 35772 914 2 NEW NEW NNP 35772 914 3 GEOLOGY.--Perhaps geology.--perhap VBZ 35772 914 4 the the DT 35772 914 5 most most RBS 35772 914 6 stubborn stubborn JJ 35772 914 7 obstacle obstacle NN 35772 914 8 which which WDT 35772 914 9 Lamarckian lamarckian JJ 35772 914 10 theories theory NNS 35772 914 11 had have VBD 35772 914 12 to to TO 35772 914 13 meet meet VB 35772 914 14 was be VBD 35772 914 15 the the DT 35772 914 16 current current JJ 35772 914 17 prejudice prejudice NN 35772 914 18 as as IN 35772 914 19 to to IN 35772 914 20 the the DT 35772 914 21 age age NN 35772 914 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 914 23 or or CC 35772 914 24 youth youth NN 35772 914 25 ) ) -RRB- 35772 914 26 of of IN 35772 914 27 the the DT 35772 914 28 earth earth NN 35772 914 29 . . . 35772 915 1 Contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 915 2 geologists geologist NNS 35772 915 3 were be VBD 35772 915 4 by by IN 35772 915 5 no no DT 35772 915 6 means means NN 35772 915 7 prepared prepared JJ 35772 915 8 to to TO 35772 915 9 grant grant VB 35772 915 10 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 915 11 the the DT 35772 915 12 illimitable illimitable JJ 35772 915 13 periods period NNS 35772 915 14 of of IN 35772 915 15 time time NN 35772 915 16 which which WDT 35772 915 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 915 18 transformation transformation NN 35772 915 19 processes process NNS 35772 915 20 seemed seem VBD 35772 915 21 to to TO 35772 915 22 require require VB 35772 915 23 . . . 35772 916 1 Consequently consequently RB 35772 916 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 916 3 is be VBZ 35772 916 4 not not RB 35772 916 5 surprising surprising JJ 35772 916 6 that that IN 35772 916 7 the the DT 35772 916 8 new new JJ 35772 916 9 theories theory NNS 35772 916 10 , , , 35772 916 11 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 916 12 for for IN 35772 916 13 the the DT 35772 916 14 first first JJ 35772 916 15 time time NN 35772 916 16 , , , 35772 916 17 received receive VBD 35772 916 18 a a DT 35772 916 19 measure measure NN 35772 916 20 of of IN 35772 916 21 justice justice NN 35772 916 22 at at IN 35772 916 23 the the DT 35772 916 24 hands hand NNS 35772 916 25 of of IN 35772 916 26 one one CD 35772 916 27 who who WP 35772 916 28 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 916 29 became become VBD 35772 916 30 responsible responsible JJ 35772 916 31 for for IN 35772 916 32 a a DT 35772 916 33 revolution revolution NN 35772 916 34 in in IN 35772 916 35 the the DT 35772 916 36 science science NN 35772 916 37 of of IN 35772 916 38 geology geology NN 35772 916 39 . . . 35772 917 1 " " `` 35772 917 2 I -PRON- PRP 35772 917 3 devoured devour VBD 35772 917 4 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 917 5 _ _ NNP 35772 917 6 en en IN 35772 917 7 voyage voyage NN 35772 917 8 _ _ NNP 35772 917 9 , , , 35772 917 10 " " '' 35772 917 11 writes write VBZ 35772 917 12 Charles Charles NNP 35772 917 13 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 917 14 , , , 35772 917 15 describing describe VBG 35772 917 16 a a DT 35772 917 17 journey journey NN 35772 917 18 from from IN 35772 917 19 Oxford Oxford NNP 35772 917 20 in in IN 35772 917 21 1827 1827 CD 35772 917 22 . . . 35772 918 1 " " `` 35772 918 2 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 918 3 theories theory NNS 35772 918 4 delighted delight VBD 35772 918 5 me -PRON- PRP 35772 918 6 more more RBR 35772 918 7 than than IN 35772 918 8 any any DT 35772 918 9 novel novel NN 35772 918 10 I -PRON- PRP 35772 918 11 ever ever RB 35772 918 12 read read VBP 35772 918 13 , , , 35772 918 14 and and CC 35772 918 15 much much RB 35772 918 16 in in IN 35772 918 17 the the DT 35772 918 18 same same JJ 35772 918 19 way way NN 35772 918 20 , , , 35772 918 21 for for IN 35772 918 22 they -PRON- PRP 35772 918 23 address address VBP 35772 918 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 918 25 to to IN 35772 918 26 the the DT 35772 918 27 imagination imagination NN 35772 918 28 .... .... . 35772 918 29 That that IN 35772 918 30 the the DT 35772 918 31 earth earth NN 35772 918 32 is be VBZ 35772 918 33 quite quite RB 35772 918 34 as as RB 35772 918 35 old old JJ 35772 918 36 as as IN 35772 918 37 he -PRON- PRP 35772 918 38 supposes suppose VBZ 35772 918 39 , , , 35772 918 40 has have VBZ 35772 918 41 long long RB 35772 918 42 been be VBN 35772 918 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 35772 918 44 creed creed NN 35772 918 45 . . . 35772 919 1 " " `` 35772 919 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 919 3 36 36 CD 35772 919 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 919 5 In in IN 35772 919 6 spite spite NN 35772 919 7 of of IN 35772 919 8 the the DT 35772 919 9 fascination fascination NN 35772 919 10 of of IN 35772 919 11 these these DT 35772 919 12 theories theory NNS 35772 919 13 , , , 35772 919 14 however however RB 35772 919 15 , , , 35772 919 16 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 919 17 was be VBD 35772 919 18 not not RB 35772 919 19 carried carry VBN 35772 919 20 away away RP 35772 919 21 by by IN 35772 919 22 them -PRON- PRP 35772 919 23 , , , 35772 919 24 and and CC 35772 919 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 919 26 was be VBD 35772 919 27 not not RB 35772 919 28 for for IN 35772 919 29 some some DT 35772 919 30 years year NNS 35772 919 31 that that WRB 35772 919 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 919 33 estimated estimate VBD 35772 919 34 them -PRON- PRP 35772 919 35 at at IN 35772 919 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 919 37 true true JJ 35772 919 38 value value NN 35772 919 39 . . . 35772 920 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 35772 920 2 the the DT 35772 920 3 new new JJ 35772 920 4 geology geology NN 35772 920 5 made make VBD 35772 920 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 920 7 appearance appearance NN 35772 920 8 with with IN 35772 920 9 the the DT 35772 920 10 publication publication NN 35772 920 11 of of IN 35772 920 12 the the DT 35772 920 13 three three CD 35772 920 14 volumes volume NNS 35772 920 15 of of IN 35772 920 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 920 17 own own JJ 35772 920 18 _ _ NNP 35772 920 19 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 920 20 of of IN 35772 920 21 Geology Geology NNP 35772 920 22 _ _ NNP 35772 920 23 , , , 35772 920 24 between between IN 35772 920 25 1829 1829 CD 35772 920 26 and and CC 35772 920 27 1833 1833 CD 35772 920 28 . . . 35772 921 1 The the DT 35772 921 2 significance significance NN 35772 921 3 of of IN 35772 921 4 the the DT 35772 921 5 book book NN 35772 921 6 for for IN 35772 921 7 biological biological JJ 35772 921 8 speculation speculation NN 35772 921 9 -- -- : 35772 921 10 for for IN 35772 921 11 theories theory NNS 35772 921 12 of of IN 35772 921 13 the the DT 35772 921 14 origin origin NN 35772 921 15 of of IN 35772 921 16 species specie NNS 35772 921 17 -- -- : 35772 921 18 lay lie VBD 35772 921 19 in in IN 35772 921 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 921 21 thesis thesis NN 35772 921 22 that that IN 35772 921 23 the the DT 35772 921 24 present present JJ 35772 921 25 condition condition NN 35772 921 26 of of IN 35772 921 27 the the DT 35772 921 28 earth earth NN 35772 921 29 is be VBZ 35772 921 30 the the DT 35772 921 31 product product NN 35772 921 32 of of IN 35772 921 33 geological geological JJ 35772 921 34 processes process NNS 35772 921 35 incalculably incalculably RB 35772 921 36 long long RB 35772 921 37 . . . 35772 922 1 Hitherto Hitherto NNP 35772 922 2 the the DT 35772 922 3 " " `` 35772 922 4 catastrophic catastrophic JJ 35772 922 5 theory theory NN 35772 922 6 " " '' 35772 922 7 had have VBD 35772 922 8 been be VBN 35772 922 9 dominant dominant JJ 35772 922 10 -- -- : 35772 922 11 the the DT 35772 922 12 notion notion NN 35772 922 13 that that IN 35772 922 14 a a DT 35772 922 15 series series NN 35772 922 16 of of IN 35772 922 17 immense immense JJ 35772 922 18 catastrophic catastrophic JJ 35772 922 19 events event NNS 35772 922 20 ( ( -LRB- 35772 922 21 like like IN 35772 922 22 the the DT 35772 922 23 Deluge Deluge NNP 35772 922 24 ) ) -RRB- 35772 922 25 had have VBD 35772 922 26 been be VBN 35772 922 27 responsible responsible JJ 35772 922 28 for for IN 35772 922 29 the the DT 35772 922 30 present present JJ 35772 922 31 condition condition NN 35772 922 32 of of IN 35772 922 33 the the DT 35772 922 34 earth earth NN 35772 922 35 's 's POS 35772 922 36 surface surface NN 35772 922 37 . . . 35772 923 1 For for IN 35772 923 2 this this DT 35772 923 3 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 923 4 substituted substitute VBD 35772 923 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 923 6 " " `` 35772 923 7 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP 35772 923 8 Theory Theory NNP 35772 923 9 , , , 35772 923 10 " " '' 35772 923 11 according accord VBG 35772 923 12 to to IN 35772 923 13 which which WDT 35772 923 14 the the DT 35772 923 15 almost almost RB 35772 923 16 invisibly invisibly RB 35772 923 17 slow slow JJ 35772 923 18 geological geological JJ 35772 923 19 processes process NNS 35772 923 20 which which WDT 35772 923 21 we -PRON- PRP 35772 923 22 may may MD 35772 923 23 now now RB 35772 923 24 see see VB 35772 923 25 operating operate VBG 35772 923 26 around around IN 35772 923 27 us -PRON- PRP 35772 923 28 , , , 35772 923 29 are be VBP 35772 923 30 typical typical JJ 35772 923 31 of of IN 35772 923 32 the the DT 35772 923 33 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 923 34 of of IN 35772 923 35 the the DT 35772 923 36 crust crust NN 35772 923 37 of of IN 35772 923 38 this this DT 35772 923 39 planet planet NN 35772 923 40 for for IN 35772 923 41 incalculable incalculable JJ 35772 923 42 periods period NNS 35772 923 43 of of IN 35772 923 44 time time NN 35772 923 45 ; ; : 35772 923 46 for for IN 35772 923 47 even even RB 35772 923 48 the the DT 35772 923 49 slowest slow JJS 35772 923 50 changes change NNS 35772 923 51 , , , 35772 923 52 if if IN 35772 923 53 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 923 54 time time NN 35772 923 55 is be VBZ 35772 923 56 allowed allow VBN 35772 923 57 them -PRON- PRP 35772 923 58 , , , 35772 923 59 are be VBP 35772 923 60 capable capable JJ 35772 923 61 of of IN 35772 923 62 producing produce VBG 35772 923 63 the the DT 35772 923 64 most most RBS 35772 923 65 stupendous stupendous JJ 35772 923 66 results result NNS 35772 923 67 . . . 35772 924 1 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 924 2 may may MD 35772 924 3 be be VB 35772 924 4 said say VBN 35772 924 5 to to TO 35772 924 6 have have VB 35772 924 7 extended extend VBN 35772 924 8 the the DT 35772 924 9 age age NN 35772 924 10 of of IN 35772 924 11 the the DT 35772 924 12 earth earth NN 35772 924 13 _ _ NNP 35772 924 14 ad ad NN 35772 924 15 infinitum infinitum IN 35772 924 16 _ _ NNP 35772 924 17 . . . 35772 925 1 Just just RB 35772 925 2 as as IN 35772 925 3 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 925 4 removed remove VBD 35772 925 5 all all DT 35772 925 6 barriers barrier NNS 35772 925 7 of of IN 35772 925 8 space space NN 35772 925 9 , , , 35772 925 10 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 925 11 removed remove VBD 35772 925 12 those those DT 35772 925 13 of of IN 35772 925 14 time time NN 35772 925 15 . . . 35772 926 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 926 2 joint joint JJ 35772 926 3 achievement achievement NN 35772 926 4 was be VBD 35772 926 5 to to TO 35772 926 6 present present VB 35772 926 7 to to IN 35772 926 8 humanity humanity VB 35772 926 9 a a DT 35772 926 10 universe universe NN 35772 926 11 infinite infinite NN 35772 926 12 both both CC 35772 926 13 in in IN 35772 926 14 space space NN 35772 926 15 and and CC 35772 926 16 time time NN 35772 926 17 -- -- : 35772 926 18 a a DT 35772 926 19 staggering staggering JJ 35772 926 20 conception conception NN 35772 926 21 . . . 35772 927 1 RESULTS RESULTS NNP 35772 927 2 OF of IN 35772 927 3 LYELL LYELL NNP 35772 927 4 'S 's POS 35772 927 5 THEORY.--Though theory.--though NN 35772 927 6 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 927 7 's 's POS 35772 927 8 boldness boldness NN 35772 927 9 disturbed disturb VBD 35772 927 10 a a DT 35772 927 11 good good JJ 35772 927 12 many many JJ 35772 927 13 of of IN 35772 927 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 927 15 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 927 16 , , , 35772 927 17 those those DT 35772 927 18 biologists biologist NNS 35772 927 19 who who WP 35772 927 20 were be VBD 35772 927 21 engaged engage VBN 35772 927 22 upon upon IN 35772 927 23 seeking seek VBG 35772 927 24 the the DT 35772 927 25 origin origin NN 35772 927 26 of of IN 35772 927 27 species specie NNS 35772 927 28 were be VBD 35772 927 29 thankful thankful JJ 35772 927 30 to to IN 35772 927 31 one one CD 35772 927 32 who who WP 35772 927 33 had have VBD 35772 927 34 removed remove VBN 35772 927 35 the the DT 35772 927 36 chief chief JJ 35772 927 37 obstacle obstacle NN 35772 927 38 to to IN 35772 927 39 the the DT 35772 927 40 solution solution NN 35772 927 41 of of IN 35772 927 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 927 43 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 927 44 . . . 35772 928 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 928 2 were be VBD 35772 928 3 now now RB 35772 928 4 relieved relieve VBN 35772 928 5 of of IN 35772 928 6 one one CD 35772 928 7 embarrassment embarrassment NN 35772 928 8 : : : 35772 928 9 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 928 10 gave give VBD 35772 928 11 them -PRON- PRP 35772 928 12 the the DT 35772 928 13 power power NN 35772 928 14 to to TO 35772 928 15 draw draw VB 35772 928 16 on on IN 35772 928 17 the the DT 35772 928 18 Bank Bank NNP 35772 928 19 of of IN 35772 928 20 Time Time NNP 35772 928 21 to to IN 35772 928 22 any any DT 35772 928 23 extent extent NN 35772 928 24 ; ; : 35772 928 25 bankruptcy bankruptcy NN 35772 928 26 was be VBD 35772 928 27 no no RB 35772 928 28 longer long RBR 35772 928 29 possible possible JJ 35772 928 30 . . . 35772 929 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 929 2 37 37 CD 35772 929 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 929 4 Indeed indeed RB 35772 929 5 , , , 35772 929 6 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 929 7 seems seem VBZ 35772 929 8 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 929 9 to to TO 35772 929 10 have have VB 35772 929 11 been be VBN 35772 929 12 convinced convince VBN 35772 929 13 of of IN 35772 929 14 the the DT 35772 929 15 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 929 16 origin origin NN 35772 929 17 of of IN 35772 929 18 species specie NNS 35772 929 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 929 20 though though IN 35772 929 21 the the DT 35772 929 22 mode mode NN 35772 929 23 of of IN 35772 929 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 929 25 operation operation NN 35772 929 26 still still RB 35772 929 27 remained remain VBD 35772 929 28 a a DT 35772 929 29 mystery mystery NN 35772 929 30 for for IN 35772 929 31 him -PRON- PRP 35772 929 32 no no RB 35772 929 33 less less JJR 35772 929 34 than than IN 35772 929 35 for for IN 35772 929 36 the the DT 35772 929 37 biologists biologist NNS 35772 929 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 929 39 ) ) -RRB- 35772 929 40 . . . 35772 930 1 In in IN 35772 930 2 fact fact NN 35772 930 3 , , , 35772 930 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 930 5 became become VBD 35772 930 6 quite quite RB 35772 930 7 evident evident JJ 35772 930 8 that that IN 35772 930 9 the the DT 35772 930 10 idea idea NN 35772 930 11 of of IN 35772 930 12 " " `` 35772 930 13 continuity continuity NN 35772 930 14 " " '' 35772 930 15 which which WDT 35772 930 16 the the DT 35772 930 17 _ _ NNP 35772 930 18 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 930 19 of of IN 35772 930 20 Geology Geology NNP 35772 930 21 _ _ NNP 35772 930 22 had have VBD 35772 930 23 established establish VBN 35772 930 24 in in IN 35772 930 25 the the DT 35772 930 26 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 930 27 world world NN 35772 930 28 , , , 35772 930 29 must must MD 35772 930 30 be be VB 35772 930 31 equally equally RB 35772 930 32 applicable applicable JJ 35772 930 33 to to IN 35772 930 34 the the DT 35772 930 35 organic organic JJ 35772 930 36 world world NN 35772 930 37 . . . 35772 931 1 DARWIN.--The darwin.--the JJ 35772 931 2 theory theory NN 35772 931 3 of of IN 35772 931 4 a a DT 35772 931 5 common common JJ 35772 931 6 descent descent NN 35772 931 7 of of IN 35772 931 8 species specie NNS 35772 931 9 had have VBD 35772 931 10 occurred occur VBN 35772 931 11 , , , 35772 931 12 as as RB 35772 931 13 early early RB 35772 931 14 as as IN 35772 931 15 1837 1837 CD 35772 931 16 , , , 35772 931 17 to to IN 35772 931 18 an an DT 35772 931 19 enthusiastic enthusiastic JJ 35772 931 20 student student NN 35772 931 21 of of IN 35772 931 22 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 931 23 's 's POS 35772 931 24 writings writing NNS 35772 931 25 , , , 35772 931 26 who who WP 35772 931 27 was be VBD 35772 931 28 also also RB 35772 931 29 a a DT 35772 931 30 personal personal JJ 35772 931 31 friend friend NN 35772 931 32 . . . 35772 932 1 Charles Charles NNP 35772 932 2 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 932 3 had have VBD 35772 932 4 collected collect VBN 35772 932 5 much much JJ 35772 932 6 geological geological JJ 35772 932 7 , , , 35772 932 8 botanical botanical JJ 35772 932 9 , , , 35772 932 10 and and CC 35772 932 11 zoological zoological JJ 35772 932 12 matter matter NN 35772 932 13 on on IN 35772 932 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 932 15 voyage voyage NN 35772 932 16 with with IN 35772 932 17 the the DT 35772 932 18 _ _ NNP 35772 932 19 Beagle Beagle NNP 35772 932 20 _ _ NNP 35772 932 21 round round IN 35772 932 22 the the DT 35772 932 23 world world NN 35772 932 24 , , , 35772 932 25 and and CC 35772 932 26 continued continue VBD 35772 932 27 for for IN 35772 932 28 twenty twenty CD 35772 932 29 years year NNS 35772 932 30 to to TO 35772 932 31 accumulate accumulate VB 35772 932 32 an an DT 35772 932 33 immense immense JJ 35772 932 34 volume volume NN 35772 932 35 of of IN 35772 932 36 _ _ NNP 35772 932 37 data datum NNS 35772 932 38 _ _ NNP 35772 932 39 to to TO 35772 932 40 substantiate substantiate VB 35772 932 41 a a DT 35772 932 42 theory theory NN 35772 932 43 which which WDT 35772 932 44 had have VBD 35772 932 45 first first RB 35772 932 46 suddenly suddenly RB 35772 932 47 suggested suggest VBN 35772 932 48 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 932 49 to to IN 35772 932 50 him -PRON- PRP 35772 932 51 in in IN 35772 932 52 1838 1838 CD 35772 932 53 as as IN 35772 932 54 the the DT 35772 932 55 result result NN 35772 932 56 of of IN 35772 932 57 reading read VBG 35772 932 58 for for IN 35772 932 59 amusement amusement NN 35772 932 60 Malthus Malthus NNP 35772 932 61 ' ' POS 35772 932 62 _ _ NNP 35772 932 63 Essay Essay NNP 35772 932 64 on on IN 35772 932 65 the the DT 35772 932 66 Principle Principle NNP 35772 932 67 of of IN 35772 932 68 Population Population NNP 35772 932 69 _ _ NNP 35772 932 70 . . . 35772 933 1 This this DT 35772 933 2 celebrated celebrated JJ 35772 933 3 book book NN 35772 933 4 , , , 35772 933 5 first first RB 35772 933 6 published publish VBN 35772 933 7 in in IN 35772 933 8 1798 1798 CD 35772 933 9 , , , 35772 933 10 had have VBD 35772 933 11 attempted attempt VBN 35772 933 12 to to TO 35772 933 13 describe describe VB 35772 933 14 the the DT 35772 933 15 forces force NNS 35772 933 16 which which WDT 35772 933 17 ensure ensure VBP 35772 933 18 the the DT 35772 933 19 multiplication multiplication NN 35772 933 20 , , , 35772 933 21 or or CC 35772 933 22 check check VB 35772 933 23 the the DT 35772 933 24 increase increase NN 35772 933 25 of of IN 35772 933 26 population population NN 35772 933 27 . . . 35772 934 1 The the DT 35772 934 2 proposition proposition NN 35772 934 3 laid lay VBD 35772 934 4 down down RP 35772 934 5 by by IN 35772 934 6 Malthus Malthus NNP 35772 934 7 was be VBD 35772 934 8 that that IN 35772 934 9 population population NN 35772 934 10 tends tend VBZ 35772 934 11 to to TO 35772 934 12 vary vary VB 35772 934 13 with with IN 35772 934 14 the the DT 35772 934 15 means mean NNS 35772 934 16 of of IN 35772 934 17 subsistence subsistence NN 35772 934 18 . . . 35772 935 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 935 2 had have VBD 35772 935 3 studied study VBN 35772 935 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 935 5 problem problem NN 35772 935 6 from from IN 35772 935 7 a a DT 35772 935 8 social social JJ 35772 935 9 or or CC 35772 935 10 political political JJ 35772 935 11 point point NN 35772 935 12 of of IN 35772 935 13 view view NN 35772 935 14 , , , 35772 935 15 but but CC 35772 935 16 the the DT 35772 935 17 same same JJ 35772 935 18 principle principle NN 35772 935 19 was be VBD 35772 935 20 seen see VBN 35772 935 21 by by IN 35772 935 22 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 935 23 to to TO 35772 935 24 apply apply VB 35772 935 25 to to IN 35772 935 26 all all DT 35772 935 27 living living NN 35772 935 28 creatures creature NNS 35772 935 29 . . . 35772 936 1 Two two CD 35772 936 2 forces force NNS 35772 936 3 are be VBP 35772 936 4 seen see VBN 35772 936 5 everywhere everywhere RB 35772 936 6 in in IN 35772 936 7 conflict conflict NN 35772 936 8 : : : 35772 936 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 936 10 a a LS 35772 936 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 936 12 the the DT 35772 936 13 luxuriant luxuriant JJ 35772 936 14 powers power NNS 35772 936 15 of of IN 35772 936 16 reproduction reproduction NN 35772 936 17 possessed possess VBN 35772 936 18 by by RP 35772 936 19 and and CC 35772 936 20 exercised exercise VBN 35772 936 21 by by IN 35772 936 22 each each DT 35772 936 23 species specie NNS 35772 936 24 ; ; , 35772 936 25 ( ( -LRB- 35772 936 26 b b LS 35772 936 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 936 28 the the DT 35772 936 29 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 936 30 and and CC 35772 936 31 obstacles obstacle NNS 35772 936 32 by by IN 35772 936 33 which which WDT 35772 936 34 the the DT 35772 936 35 species specie NNS 35772 936 36 tend tend VBP 35772 936 37 to to TO 35772 936 38 be be VB 35772 936 39 eliminated eliminate VBN 35772 936 40 . . . 35772 937 1 The the DT 35772 937 2 contest contest NN 35772 937 3 between between IN 35772 937 4 the the DT 35772 937 5 powers power NNS 35772 937 6 of of IN 35772 937 7 reproduction reproduction NN 35772 937 8 and and CC 35772 937 9 those those DT 35772 937 10 of of IN 35772 937 11 elimination elimination NN 35772 937 12 -- -- : 35772 937 13 this this DT 35772 937 14 " " `` 35772 937 15 over over IN 35772 937 16 - - HYPH 35772 937 17 production production NN 35772 937 18 " " '' 35772 937 19 and and CC 35772 937 20 " " `` 35772 937 21 crowding crowd VBG 35772 937 22 - - : 35772 937 23 out"--is out"--is CD 35772 937 24 what what WP 35772 937 25 was be VBD 35772 937 26 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 937 27 termed term VBN 35772 937 28 the the DT 35772 937 29 " " `` 35772 937 30 struggle struggle NN 35772 937 31 for for IN 35772 937 32 existence existence NN 35772 937 33 . . . 35772 937 34 " " '' 35772 938 1 " " `` 35772 938 2 NATURAL NATURAL NNP 35772 938 3 SELECTION SELECTION NNP 35772 938 4 . . . 35772 938 5 " " '' 35772 939 1 --Darwin --Darwin NNP 35772 939 2 's 's POS 35772 939 3 momentous momentous JJ 35772 939 4 theory theory NN 35772 939 5 was be VBD 35772 939 6 that that IN 35772 939 7 this this DT 35772 939 8 struggle struggle NN 35772 939 9 , , , 35772 939 10 proceeding proceed VBG 35772 939 11 for for IN 35772 939 12 untold untold JJ 35772 939 13 ages age NNS 35772 939 14 , , , 35772 939 15 had have VBD 35772 939 16 resulted result VBN 35772 939 17 in in IN 35772 939 18 the the DT 35772 939 19 continual continual JJ 35772 939 20 formation formation NN 35772 939 21 of of IN 35772 939 22 new new JJ 35772 939 23 species specie NNS 35772 939 24 . . . 35772 940 1 Granted grant VBN 35772 940 2 that that IN 35772 940 3 the the DT 35772 940 4 numerous numerous JJ 35772 940 5 offspring offspring NN 35772 940 6 of of IN 35772 940 7 any any DT 35772 940 8 individual individual JJ 35772 940 9 member member NN 35772 940 10 of of IN 35772 940 11 a a DT 35772 940 12 species species NN 35772 940 13 tend tend VBP 35772 940 14 to to TO 35772 940 15 vary vary VB 35772 940 16 , , , 35772 940 17 those those DT 35772 940 18 variations variation NNS 35772 940 19 survive survive VBP 35772 940 20 which which WDT 35772 940 21 happen happen VBP 35772 940 22 to to TO 35772 940 23 be be VB 35772 940 24 best well RBS 35772 940 25 fitted fit VBN 35772 940 26 to to TO 35772 940 27 cope cope VB 35772 940 28 with with IN 35772 940 29 the the DT 35772 940 30 environment environment NN 35772 940 31 . . . 35772 941 1 These these DT 35772 941 2 in in IN 35772 941 3 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 941 4 turn turn NN 35772 941 5 leave leave NN 35772 941 6 offspring offspring NN 35772 941 7 , , , 35772 941 8 the the DT 35772 941 9 variations variation NNS 35772 941 10 and and CC 35772 941 11 the the DT 35772 941 12 selections selection NNS 35772 941 13 are be VBP 35772 941 14 repeated repeat VBN 35772 941 15 , , , 35772 941 16 and and CC 35772 941 17 so so RB 35772 941 18 on on IN 35772 941 19 _ _ NNP 35772 941 20 ad ad NN 35772 941 21 infinitum infinitum IN 35772 941 22 _ _ NNP 35772 941 23 ; ; : 35772 941 24 and and CC 35772 941 25 the the DT 35772 941 26 result result NN 35772 941 27 is be VBZ 35772 941 28 that that IN 35772 941 29 entirely entirely RB 35772 941 30 new new JJ 35772 941 31 species specie NNS 35772 941 32 are be VBP 35772 941 33 formed form VBN 35772 941 34 by by IN 35772 941 35 a a DT 35772 941 36 long long JJ 35772 941 37 process process NN 35772 941 38 of of IN 35772 941 39 insignificant insignificant JJ 35772 941 40 changes change NNS 35772 941 41 . . . 35772 942 1 This this DT 35772 942 2 , , , 35772 942 3 briefly briefly RB 35772 942 4 put put VBD 35772 942 5 , , , 35772 942 6 is be VBZ 35772 942 7 the the DT 35772 942 8 celebrated celebrated JJ 35772 942 9 theory theory NN 35772 942 10 of of IN 35772 942 11 " " `` 35772 942 12 Natural Natural NNP 35772 942 13 Selection Selection NNP 35772 942 14 . . . 35772 942 15 " " '' 35772 943 1 The the DT 35772 943 2 habit habit NN 35772 943 3 of of IN 35772 943 4 scientific scientific JJ 35772 943 5 caution caution NN 35772 943 6 was be VBD 35772 943 7 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 943 8 of of IN 35772 943 9 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 943 10 , , , 35772 943 11 who who WP 35772 943 12 at at IN 35772 943 13 first first RB 35772 943 14 would would MD 35772 943 15 not not RB 35772 943 16 write write VB 35772 943 17 down down RP 35772 943 18 " " '' 35772 943 19 even even RB 35772 943 20 the the DT 35772 943 21 briefest brief JJS 35772 943 22 sketch sketch NN 35772 943 23 " " '' 35772 943 24 of of IN 35772 943 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 943 26 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 943 27 , , , 35772 943 28 but but CC 35772 943 29 devoted devote VBD 35772 943 30 nearly nearly RB 35772 943 31 twenty twenty CD 35772 943 32 years year NNS 35772 943 33 to to IN 35772 943 34 the the DT 35772 943 35 accumulation accumulation NN 35772 943 36 of of IN 35772 943 37 evidential evidential JJ 35772 943 38 _ _ NNP 35772 943 39 data datum NNS 35772 943 40 _ _ NNP 35772 943 41 . . . 35772 944 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 944 2 friends friend NNS 35772 944 3 continually continually RB 35772 944 4 warned warn VBD 35772 944 5 him -PRON- PRP 35772 944 6 that that IN 35772 944 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 944 8 would would MD 35772 944 9 be be VB 35772 944 10 forestalled forestalled JJ 35772 944 11 , , , 35772 944 12 and and CC 35772 944 13 this this DT 35772 944 14 actually actually RB 35772 944 15 occurred occur VBD 35772 944 16 , , , 35772 944 17 as as IN 35772 944 18 is be VBZ 35772 944 19 well well RB 35772 944 20 known know VBN 35772 944 21 , , , 35772 944 22 in in IN 35772 944 23 1858 1858 CD 35772 944 24 , , , 35772 944 25 when when WRB 35772 944 26 the the DT 35772 944 27 book book NN 35772 944 28 which which WDT 35772 944 29 was be VBD 35772 944 30 to to TO 35772 944 31 give give VB 35772 944 32 the the DT 35772 944 33 new new JJ 35772 944 34 theory theory NN 35772 944 35 to to IN 35772 944 36 the the DT 35772 944 37 world world NN 35772 944 38 was be VBD 35772 944 39 already already RB 35772 944 40 half half RB 35772 944 41 written write VBN 35772 944 42 . . . 35772 945 1 The the DT 35772 945 2 naturalist naturalist NN 35772 945 3 , , , 35772 945 4 Alfred Alfred NNP 35772 945 5 Russell Russell NNP 35772 945 6 Wallace Wallace NNP 35772 945 7 , , , 35772 945 8 on on IN 35772 945 9 a a DT 35772 945 10 collecting collect VBG 35772 945 11 expedition expedition NN 35772 945 12 in in IN 35772 945 13 the the DT 35772 945 14 East East NNP 35772 945 15 Indies Indies NNPS 35772 945 16 , , , 35772 945 17 " " '' 35772 945 18 in in IN 35772 945 19 a a DT 35772 945 20 flash flash NN 35772 945 21 of of IN 35772 945 22 insight insight NN 35772 945 23 " " '' 35772 945 24 while while IN 35772 945 25 sick sick JJ 35772 945 26 with with IN 35772 945 27 fever fever NN 35772 945 28 , , , 35772 945 29 found find VBD 35772 945 30 the the DT 35772 945 31 same same JJ 35772 945 32 solution solution NN 35772 945 33 of of IN 35772 945 34 the the DT 35772 945 35 mystery mystery NN 35772 945 36 that that WDT 35772 945 37 had have VBD 35772 945 38 puzzled puzzle VBN 35772 945 39 biologists biologist NNS 35772 945 40 so so RB 35772 945 41 long long RB 35772 945 42 . . . 35772 946 1 Wallace Wallace NNP 35772 946 2 's 's POS 35772 946 3 letter letter NN 35772 946 4 to to IN 35772 946 5 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 946 6 , , , 35772 946 7 containing contain VBG 35772 946 8 the the DT 35772 946 9 abstract abstract NN 35772 946 10 of of IN 35772 946 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 946 12 theory theory NN 35772 946 13 , , , 35772 946 14 came come VBD 35772 946 15 " " `` 35772 946 16 like like IN 35772 946 17 a a DT 35772 946 18 bolt bolt NN 35772 946 19 from from IN 35772 946 20 the the DT 35772 946 21 blue blue NN 35772 946 22 . . . 35772 946 23 " " '' 35772 947 1 The the DT 35772 947 2 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 947 3 of of IN 35772 947 4 the the DT 35772 947 5 two two CD 35772 947 6 men man NNS 35772 947 7 was be VBD 35772 947 8 worthy worthy JJ 35772 947 9 of of IN 35772 947 10 the the DT 35772 947 11 highest high JJS 35772 947 12 traditions tradition NNS 35772 947 13 of of IN 35772 947 14 scientific scientific JJ 35772 947 15 research research NN 35772 947 16 . . . 35772 948 1 The the DT 35772 948 2 matter matter NN 35772 948 3 was be VBD 35772 948 4 put put VBN 35772 948 5 into into IN 35772 948 6 the the DT 35772 948 7 hands hand NNS 35772 948 8 of of IN 35772 948 9 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 948 10 , , , 35772 948 11 and and CC 35772 948 12 Wallace Wallace NNP 35772 948 13 's 's POS 35772 948 14 paper paper NN 35772 948 15 , , , 35772 948 16 together together RB 35772 948 17 with with IN 35772 948 18 certain certain JJ 35772 948 19 extracts extract NNS 35772 948 20 from from IN 35772 948 21 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 948 22 's 's POS 35772 948 23 unpublished unpublished JJ 35772 948 24 notes note NNS 35772 948 25 , , , 35772 948 26 were be VBD 35772 948 27 read read VBN 35772 948 28 before before IN 35772 948 29 the the DT 35772 948 30 Linnean Linnean NNP 35772 948 31 Society Society NNP 35772 948 32 , , , 35772 948 33 and and CC 35772 948 34 the the DT 35772 948 35 preparation preparation NN 35772 948 36 of of IN 35772 948 37 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 948 38 's 's POS 35772 948 39 book book NN 35772 948 40 was be VBD 35772 948 41 hurried hurry VBN 35772 948 42 on on IN 35772 948 43 . . . 35772 949 1 In in IN 35772 949 2 November November NNP 35772 949 3 , , , 35772 949 4 1859 1859 CD 35772 949 5 , , , 35772 949 6 _ _ NNP 35772 949 7 The the DT 35772 949 8 Origin Origin NNP 35772 949 9 of of IN 35772 949 10 Species Species NNP 35772 949 11 _ _ NNP 35772 949 12 was be VBD 35772 949 13 published publish VBN 35772 949 14 . . . 35772 950 1 RESULTS result NNS 35772 950 2 OF of IN 35772 950 3 DARWIN DARWIN NNP 35772 950 4 'S 'S NNP 35772 950 5 THEORY.--The theory.--the NN 35772 950 6 importance importance NN 35772 950 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 950 8 for for IN 35772 950 9 the the DT 35772 950 10 general general JJ 35772 950 11 trend trend NN 35772 950 12 of of IN 35772 950 13 thought thought NN 35772 950 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 950 15 of of IN 35772 950 16 this this DT 35772 950 17 joint joint JJ 35772 950 18 achievement achievement NN 35772 950 19 of of IN 35772 950 20 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 950 21 and and CC 35772 950 22 Wallace Wallace NNP 35772 950 23 was be VBD 35772 950 24 considerable considerable JJ 35772 950 25 , , , 35772 950 26 and and CC 35772 950 27 could could MD 35772 950 28 not not RB 35772 950 29 but but CC 35772 950 30 be be VB 35772 950 31 regarded regard VBN 35772 950 32 as as IN 35772 950 33 an an DT 35772 950 34 extension extension NN 35772 950 35 of of IN 35772 950 36 the the DT 35772 950 37 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 950 38 theory theory NN 35772 950 39 . . . 35772 951 1 The the DT 35772 951 2 origin origin NN 35772 951 3 of of IN 35772 951 4 species specie NNS 35772 951 5 might may MD 35772 951 6 still still RB 35772 951 7 to to IN 35772 951 8 some some DT 35772 951 9 extent extent NN 35772 951 10 remain remain VBP 35772 951 11 mysterious mysterious JJ 35772 951 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 951 13 for for IN 35772 951 14 " " `` 35772 951 15 natural natural JJ 35772 951 16 selection selection NN 35772 951 17 " " '' 35772 951 18 was be VBD 35772 951 19 soon soon RB 35772 951 20 realised realise VBN 35772 951 21 to to TO 35772 951 22 be be VB 35772 951 23 only only RB 35772 951 24 one one CD 35772 951 25 of of IN 35772 951 26 many many JJ 35772 951 27 factors factor NNS 35772 951 28 at at IN 35772 951 29 work work NN 35772 951 30 in in IN 35772 951 31 evolution evolution NN 35772 951 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 951 33 , , , 35772 951 34 yet yet CC 35772 951 35 the the DT 35772 951 36 area area NN 35772 951 37 of of IN 35772 951 38 mystery mystery NN 35772 951 39 was be VBD 35772 951 40 patently patently RB 35772 951 41 reduced reduce VBN 35772 951 42 , , , 35772 951 43 and and CC 35772 951 44 the the DT 35772 951 45 " " `` 35772 951 46 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 35772 951 47 " " '' 35772 951 48 driven drive VBN 35772 951 49 further further RB 35772 951 50 back back RB 35772 951 51 . . . 35772 952 1 A a DT 35772 952 2 formula formula NN 35772 952 3 had have VBD 35772 952 4 been be VBN 35772 952 5 provided provide VBN 35772 952 6 , , , 35772 952 7 which which WDT 35772 952 8 seemed seem VBD 35772 952 9 to to TO 35772 952 10 be be VB 35772 952 11 as as RB 35772 952 12 valid valid JJ 35772 952 13 , , , 35772 952 14 and and CC 35772 952 15 likely likely JJ 35772 952 16 to to TO 35772 952 17 prove prove VB 35772 952 18 as as RB 35772 952 19 permanent permanent JJ 35772 952 20 and and CC 35772 952 21 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 952 22 in in IN 35772 952 23 biological biological JJ 35772 952 24 research research NN 35772 952 25 as as IN 35772 952 26 Newton Newton NNP 35772 952 27 's 's POS 35772 952 28 law law NN 35772 952 29 of of IN 35772 952 30 gravity gravity NN 35772 952 31 had have VBD 35772 952 32 been be VBN 35772 952 33 in in IN 35772 952 34 the the DT 35772 952 35 realm realm NN 35772 952 36 of of IN 35772 952 37 physics physics NN 35772 952 38 . . . 35772 953 1 In in IN 35772 953 2 point point NN 35772 953 3 of of IN 35772 953 4 fact fact NN 35772 953 5 , , , 35772 953 6 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 953 7 had have VBD 35772 953 8 only only RB 35772 953 9 substituted substitute VBN 35772 953 10 new new JJ 35772 953 11 problems problem NNS 35772 953 12 of of IN 35772 953 13 " " `` 35772 953 14 variation variation NN 35772 953 15 " " '' 35772 953 16 and and CC 35772 953 17 " " `` 35772 953 18 heredity heredity NN 35772 953 19 " " '' 35772 953 20 for for IN 35772 953 21 the the DT 35772 953 22 old old JJ 35772 953 23 one one CD 35772 953 24 of of IN 35772 953 25 the the DT 35772 953 26 diversity diversity NN 35772 953 27 of of IN 35772 953 28 species specie NNS 35772 953 29 ; ; : 35772 953 30 but but CC 35772 953 31 an an DT 35772 953 32 impression impression NN 35772 953 33 was be VBD 35772 953 34 created create VBN 35772 953 35 by by IN 35772 953 36 the the DT 35772 953 37 new new JJ 35772 953 38 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 953 39 that that WDT 35772 953 40 a a DT 35772 953 41 purely purely RB 35772 953 42 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 953 43 explanation explanation NN 35772 953 44 of of IN 35772 953 45 the the DT 35772 953 46 origin origin NN 35772 953 47 of of IN 35772 953 48 life life NN 35772 953 49 and and CC 35772 953 50 even even RB 35772 953 51 of of IN 35772 953 52 mind mind NN 35772 953 53 was be VBD 35772 953 54 within within IN 35772 953 55 reach reach NN 35772 953 56 . . . 35772 954 1 THE the DT 35772 954 2 DESCENT DESCENT NNP 35772 954 3 OF of IN 35772 954 4 MAN.--With man.--with CD 35772 954 5 regard regard NN 35772 954 6 to to IN 35772 954 7 " " `` 35772 954 8 mind mind NN 35772 954 9 , , , 35772 954 10 " " '' 35772 954 11 the the DT 35772 954 12 impression impression NN 35772 954 13 was be VBD 35772 954 14 re re VBN 35772 954 15 - - VBN 35772 954 16 inforced inforce VBN 35772 954 17 by by IN 35772 954 18 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 954 19 's 's POS 35772 954 20 next next JJ 35772 954 21 book book NN 35772 954 22 -- -- : 35772 954 23 the the DT 35772 954 24 _ _ NNP 35772 954 25 Descent Descent NNP 35772 954 26 of of IN 35772 954 27 Man Man NNP 35772 954 28 _ _ NNP 35772 954 29 , , , 35772 954 30 where where WRB 35772 954 31 the the DT 35772 954 32 gap gap NN 35772 954 33 between between IN 35772 954 34 man man NN 35772 954 35 and and CC 35772 954 36 the the DT 35772 954 37 animals animal NNS 35772 954 38 was be VBD 35772 954 39 finally finally RB 35772 954 40 bridged bridge VBN 35772 954 41 . . . 35772 955 1 The the DT 35772 955 2 work work NN 35772 955 3 was be VBD 35772 955 4 merely merely RB 35772 955 5 an an DT 35772 955 6 extension extension NN 35772 955 7 of of IN 35772 955 8 the the DT 35772 955 9 principles principle NNS 35772 955 10 previously previously RB 35772 955 11 applied apply VBD 35772 955 12 by by IN 35772 955 13 him -PRON- PRP 35772 955 14 , , , 35772 955 15 and and CC 35772 955 16 as as IN 35772 955 17 a a DT 35772 955 18 theory theory NN 35772 955 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 955 20 had have VBD 35772 955 21 been be VBN 35772 955 22 present present JJ 35772 955 23 to to IN 35772 955 24 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 955 25 's 's POS 35772 955 26 mind mind NN 35772 955 27 as as RB 35772 955 28 far far RB 35772 955 29 back back RB 35772 955 30 as as IN 35772 955 31 1837 1837 CD 35772 955 32 . . . 35772 956 1 As as RB 35772 956 2 soon soon RB 35772 956 3 as as IN 35772 956 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 956 5 had have VBD 35772 956 6 become become VBN 35772 956 7 " " `` 35772 956 8 convinced convinced JJ 35772 956 9 that that IN 35772 956 10 species specie NNS 35772 956 11 were be VBD 35772 956 12 mutable mutable JJ 35772 956 13 productions production NNS 35772 956 14 , , , 35772 956 15 " " '' 35772 956 16 he -PRON- PRP 35772 956 17 could could MD 35772 956 18 not not RB 35772 956 19 " " `` 35772 956 20 avoid avoid VB 35772 956 21 the the DT 35772 956 22 belief belief NN 35772 956 23 that that DT 35772 956 24 man man NN 35772 956 25 must must MD 35772 956 26 come come VB 35772 956 27 under under IN 35772 956 28 the the DT 35772 956 29 same same JJ 35772 956 30 law law NN 35772 956 31 . . . 35772 957 1 " " `` 35772 957 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 957 3 38 38 CD 35772 957 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 957 5 Indeed indeed RB 35772 957 6 the the DT 35772 957 7 Descent Descent NNP 35772 957 8 was be VBD 35772 957 9 nothing nothing NN 35772 957 10 more more JJR 35772 957 11 than than IN 35772 957 12 a a DT 35772 957 13 corollary corollary NN 35772 957 14 to to IN 35772 957 15 the the DT 35772 957 16 _ _ NNP 35772 957 17 Origin Origin NNP 35772 957 18 of of IN 35772 957 19 Species Species NNP 35772 957 20 _ _ NNP 35772 957 21 . . . 35772 958 1 The the DT 35772 958 2 earlier early JJR 35772 958 3 work work NN 35772 958 4 contains contain VBZ 35772 958 5 the the DT 35772 958 6 whole whole NN 35772 958 7 of of IN 35772 958 8 Darwinism Darwinism NNP 35772 958 9 . . . 35772 959 1 THE the DT 35772 959 2 POSITION POSITION NNP 35772 959 3 REACHED.--And REACHED.--And `` 35772 959 4 with with IN 35772 959 5 the the DT 35772 959 6 full full JJ 35772 959 7 publication publication NN 35772 959 8 of of IN 35772 959 9 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 959 10 's 's POS 35772 959 11 theories theory NNS 35772 959 12 a a DT 35772 959 13 point point NN 35772 959 14 was be VBD 35772 959 15 reached reach VBN 35772 959 16 when when WRB 35772 959 17 a a DT 35772 959 18 more more RBR 35772 959 19 or or CC 35772 959 20 less less RBR 35772 959 21 consistently consistently RB 35772 959 22 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 959 23 position position NN 35772 959 24 seemed seem VBD 35772 959 25 possible possible JJ 35772 959 26 . . . 35772 960 1 The the DT 35772 960 2 foundations foundation NNS 35772 960 3 of of IN 35772 960 4 such such PDT 35772 960 5 a a DT 35772 960 6 position position NN 35772 960 7 had have VBD 35772 960 8 been be VBN 35772 960 9 strengthened strengthen VBN 35772 960 10 by by IN 35772 960 11 the the DT 35772 960 12 scientific scientific JJ 35772 960 13 atomism atomism NN 35772 960 14 of of IN 35772 960 15 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 960 16 , , , 35772 960 17 and and CC 35772 960 18 the the DT 35772 960 19 results result NNS 35772 960 20 of of IN 35772 960 21 German german JJ 35772 960 22 research research NN 35772 960 23 in in IN 35772 960 24 the the DT 35772 960 25 field field NN 35772 960 26 of of IN 35772 960 27 _ _ NNP 35772 960 28 organic organic JJ 35772 960 29 _ _ NNP 35772 960 30 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 960 31 seemed seem VBD 35772 960 32 to to TO 35772 960 33 open open VB 35772 960 34 up up RP 35772 960 35 possibilities possibility NNS 35772 960 36 of of IN 35772 960 37 expressing express VBG 35772 960 38 even even RB 35772 960 39 life life NN 35772 960 40 in in IN 35772 960 41 terms term NNS 35772 960 42 of of IN 35772 960 43 matter matter NN 35772 960 44 . . . 35772 961 1 And and CC 35772 961 2 , , , 35772 961 3 finally finally RB 35772 961 4 , , , 35772 961 5 the the DT 35772 961 6 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 961 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 961 8 had have VBD 35772 961 9 reduced reduce VBN 35772 961 10 some some DT 35772 961 11 of of IN 35772 961 12 the the DT 35772 961 13 most most RBS 35772 961 14 obscure obscure JJ 35772 961 15 biological biological JJ 35772 961 16 problems problem NNS 35772 961 17 to to IN 35772 961 18 manageable manageable JJ 35772 961 19 proportions proportion NNS 35772 961 20 . . . 35772 962 1 The the DT 35772 962 2 prospects prospect NNS 35772 962 3 for for IN 35772 962 4 a a DT 35772 962 5 purely purely RB 35772 962 6 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 962 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 962 8 were be VBD 35772 962 9 phenomenally phenomenally RB 35772 962 10 bright bright JJ 35772 962 11 . . . 35772 963 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 35772 963 2 IX IX NNP 35772 963 3 MATERIALISM MATERIALISM NNP 35772 963 4 AND and CC 35772 963 5 AGNOSTICISM AGNOSTICISM NNP 35772 963 6 FROM from IN 35772 963 7 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 35772 963 8 TO to IN 35772 963 9 PHILOSOPHY.--The philosophy.--the JJ 35772 963 10 record record NN 35772 963 11 of of IN 35772 963 12 certain certain JJ 35772 963 13 important important JJ 35772 963 14 scientific scientific JJ 35772 963 15 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 963 16 has have VBZ 35772 963 17 occupied occupy VBN 35772 963 18 us -PRON- PRP 35772 963 19 in in IN 35772 963 20 two two CD 35772 963 21 recent recent JJ 35772 963 22 chapters chapter NNS 35772 963 23 , , , 35772 963 24 and and CC 35772 963 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 963 26 is be VBZ 35772 963 27 now now RB 35772 963 28 time time NN 35772 963 29 to to TO 35772 963 30 examine examine VB 35772 963 31 the the DT 35772 963 32 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 963 33 results result NNS 35772 963 34 that that WDT 35772 963 35 were be VBD 35772 963 36 drawn draw VBN 35772 963 37 from from IN 35772 963 38 them -PRON- PRP 35772 963 39 . . . 35772 964 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 964 2 is be VBZ 35772 964 3 true true JJ 35772 964 4 that that IN 35772 964 5 the the DT 35772 964 6 generalisations generalisation NNS 35772 964 7 drawn draw VBN 35772 964 8 from from IN 35772 964 9 the the DT 35772 964 10 results result NNS 35772 964 11 of of IN 35772 964 12 scientific scientific JJ 35772 964 13 research research NN 35772 964 14 were be VBD 35772 964 15 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 964 16 hasty hasty JJ 35772 964 17 , , , 35772 964 18 and and CC 35772 964 19 not not RB 35772 964 20 always always RB 35772 964 21 sanctioned sanction VBN 35772 964 22 by by IN 35772 964 23 the the DT 35772 964 24 gifted gift VBN 35772 964 25 minds mind NNS 35772 964 26 to to TO 35772 964 27 whom whom WP 35772 964 28 these these DT 35772 964 29 results result NNS 35772 964 30 were be VBD 35772 964 31 due due JJ 35772 964 32 ; ; : 35772 964 33 yet yet CC 35772 964 34 they -PRON- PRP 35772 964 35 were be VBD 35772 964 36 assured assure VBN 35772 964 37 a a DT 35772 964 38 popular popular JJ 35772 964 39 reception reception NN 35772 964 40 , , , 35772 964 41 and and CC 35772 964 42 exercised exercise VBD 35772 964 43 an an DT 35772 964 44 immense immense JJ 35772 964 45 influence influence NN 35772 964 46 . . . 35772 965 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 965 2 is be VBZ 35772 965 3 not not RB 35772 965 4 always always RB 35772 965 5 the the DT 35772 965 6 most most RBS 35772 965 7 accurate accurate JJ 35772 965 8 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 965 9 whose whose WP$ 35772 965 10 ideas idea NNS 35772 965 11 gain gain VBP 35772 965 12 the the DT 35772 965 13 widest wide JJS 35772 965 14 currency currency NN 35772 965 15 . . . 35772 966 1 DISCREDIT DISCREDIT NNP 35772 966 2 OF of IN 35772 966 3 ROMANTICISM.--The ROMANTICISM.--The `` 35772 966 4 Idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 966 5 movement movement NN 35772 966 6 in in IN 35772 966 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 966 8 which which WDT 35772 966 9 we -PRON- PRP 35772 966 10 have have VBP 35772 966 11 seen see VBN 35772 966 12 flourishing flourish VBG 35772 966 13 in in IN 35772 966 14 Germany Germany NNP 35772 966 15 at at IN 35772 966 16 the the DT 35772 966 17 beginning beginning NN 35772 966 18 of of IN 35772 966 19 the the DT 35772 966 20 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 966 21 century century NN 35772 966 22 , , , 35772 966 23 had have VBD 35772 966 24 begun begin VBN 35772 966 25 , , , 35772 966 26 after after IN 35772 966 27 the the DT 35772 966 28 lapse lapse NN 35772 966 29 of of IN 35772 966 30 a a DT 35772 966 31 generation generation NN 35772 966 32 , , , 35772 966 33 to to TO 35772 966 34 decline decline VB 35772 966 35 . . . 35772 967 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 967 2 39 39 CD 35772 967 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 967 4 The the DT 35772 967 5 causes cause NNS 35772 967 6 of of IN 35772 967 7 decline decline NN 35772 967 8 , , , 35772 967 9 as as RB 35772 967 10 often often RB 35772 967 11 happens happen VBZ 35772 967 12 , , , 35772 967 13 were be VBD 35772 967 14 in in IN 35772 967 15 part part NN 35772 967 16 , , , 35772 967 17 at at IN 35772 967 18 least least JJS 35772 967 19 , , , 35772 967 20 other other JJ 35772 967 21 than than IN 35772 967 22 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 967 23 . . . 35772 968 1 Hegelianism Hegelianism NNP 35772 968 2 had have VBD 35772 968 3 become become VBN 35772 968 4 associated associate VBN 35772 968 5 with with IN 35772 968 6 political political JJ 35772 968 7 reaction reaction NN 35772 968 8 , , , 35772 968 9 and and CC 35772 968 10 " " `` 35772 968 11 a a DT 35772 968 12 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 968 13 has have VBZ 35772 968 14 lost lose VBN 35772 968 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 968 16 charm charm NN 35772 968 17 when when WRB 35772 968 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 968 19 enters enter VBZ 35772 968 20 the the DT 35772 968 21 service service NN 35772 968 22 of of IN 35772 968 23 absolutism absolutism NN 35772 968 24 . . . 35772 968 25 " " '' 35772 969 1 And and CC 35772 969 2 a a DT 35772 969 3 rising rise VBG 35772 969 4 spirit spirit NN 35772 969 5 of of IN 35772 969 6 enterprise enterprise NN 35772 969 7 in in IN 35772 969 8 commerce commerce NN 35772 969 9 and and CC 35772 969 10 industry industry NN 35772 969 11 also also RB 35772 969 12 contributed contribute VBD 35772 969 13 to to IN 35772 969 14 a a DT 35772 969 15 change change NN 35772 969 16 of of IN 35772 969 17 attitude attitude NN 35772 969 18 , , , 35772 969 19 for for IN 35772 969 20 as as IN 35772 969 21 material material JJ 35772 969 22 interests interest NNS 35772 969 23 develop develop VBP 35772 969 24 , , , 35772 969 25 men man NNS 35772 969 26 have have VBP 35772 969 27 less less JJR 35772 969 28 leisure leisure NN 35772 969 29 for for IN 35772 969 30 speculation speculation NN 35772 969 31 , , , 35772 969 32 and and CC 35772 969 33 often often RB 35772 969 34 lose lose VBP 35772 969 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 969 36 taste taste NN 35772 969 37 for for IN 35772 969 38 ideals ideal NNS 35772 969 39 . . . 35772 970 1 Probably probably RB 35772 970 2 there there EX 35772 970 3 should should MD 35772 970 4 also also RB 35772 970 5 be be VB 35772 970 6 taken take VBN 35772 970 7 into into IN 35772 970 8 account account NN 35772 970 9 the the DT 35772 970 10 sentimentality sentimentality NN 35772 970 11 that that WDT 35772 970 12 had have VBD 35772 970 13 attached attach VBN 35772 970 14 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 970 15 to to IN 35772 970 16 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 970 17 and and CC 35772 970 18 with with IN 35772 970 19 which which WDT 35772 970 20 men man NNS 35772 970 21 were be VBD 35772 970 22 sated sate VBN 35772 970 23 . . . 35772 971 1 This this DT 35772 971 2 revolt revolt NN 35772 971 3 has have VBZ 35772 971 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 971 5 most most RBS 35772 971 6 pointed pointed JJ 35772 971 7 expression expression NN 35772 971 8 in in IN 35772 971 9 the the DT 35772 971 10 prose prose JJ 35772 971 11 writings writing NNS 35772 971 12 of of IN 35772 971 13 the the DT 35772 971 14 poet poet NN 35772 971 15 Heine Heine NNP 35772 971 16 , , , 35772 971 17 who who WP 35772 971 18 attacks attack VBZ 35772 971 19 with with IN 35772 971 20 satiric satiric JJ 35772 971 21 bitterness bitterness NNP 35772 971 22 " " '' 35772 971 23 the the DT 35772 971 24 new new JJ 35772 971 25 troubadours troubadour NNS 35772 971 26 , , , 35772 971 27 so so CC 35772 971 28 morbid morbid NN 35772 971 29 and and CC 35772 971 30 somnambulistic somnambulistic JJ 35772 971 31 , , , 35772 971 32 so so RB 35772 971 33 high high RB 35772 971 34 - - HYPH 35772 971 35 flown fly VBN 35772 971 36 and and CC 35772 971 37 aristocratic aristocratic JJ 35772 971 38 , , , 35772 971 39 and and CC 35772 971 40 altogether altogether RB 35772 971 41 so so RB 35772 971 42 unnatural unnatural JJ 35772 971 43 . . . 35772 971 44 " " '' 35772 972 1 METAPHYSICS metaphysic NNS 35772 972 2 REJECTED.--The rejected.--the NN 35772 972 3 reaction reaction NN 35772 972 4 against against IN 35772 972 5 the the DT 35772 972 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 972 7 of of IN 35772 972 8 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 972 9 took take VBD 35772 972 10 the the DT 35772 972 11 form form NN 35772 972 12 of of IN 35772 972 13 a a DT 35772 972 14 complete complete JJ 35772 972 15 revolt revolt NN 35772 972 16 against against IN 35772 972 17 speculative speculative JJ 35772 972 18 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 972 19 . . . 35772 973 1 But but CC 35772 973 2 instead instead RB 35772 973 3 of of IN 35772 973 4 going go VBG 35772 973 5 back back RB 35772 973 6 to to IN 35772 973 7 Kant Kant NNP 35772 973 8 , , , 35772 973 9 and and CC 35772 973 10 taking take VBG 35772 973 11 up up RP 35772 973 12 a a DT 35772 973 13 vigorously vigorously RB 35772 973 14 critical critical JJ 35772 973 15 attitude attitude NN 35772 973 16 , , , 35772 973 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 973 18 took take VBD 35772 973 19 refuge refuge NN 35772 973 20 in in IN 35772 973 21 the the DT 35772 973 22 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 973 23 of of IN 35772 973 24 " " `` 35772 973 25 common common JJ 35772 973 26 sense sense NN 35772 973 27 . . . 35772 973 28 " " '' 35772 974 1 The the DT 35772 974 2 new new JJ 35772 974 3 movement movement NN 35772 974 4 must must MD 35772 974 5 be be VB 35772 974 6 associated associate VBN 35772 974 7 in in IN 35772 974 8 the the DT 35772 974 9 first first JJ 35772 974 10 place place NN 35772 974 11 with with IN 35772 974 12 a a DT 35772 974 13 French french JJ 35772 974 14 thinker thinker NN 35772 974 15 , , , 35772 974 16 Auguste Auguste NNP 35772 974 17 Comte Comte NNP 35772 974 18 ( ( -LRB- 35772 974 19 1798 1798 CD 35772 974 20 - - SYM 35772 974 21 1857 1857 CD 35772 974 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 974 23 , , , 35772 974 24 who who WP 35772 974 25 made make VBD 35772 974 26 the the DT 35772 974 27 attempt attempt NN 35772 974 28 to to TO 35772 974 29 substitute substitute VB 35772 974 30 scientific scientific JJ 35772 974 31 and and CC 35772 974 32 _ _ NNP 35772 974 33 positive positive JJ 35772 974 34 _ _ NNP 35772 974 35 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 974 36 for for IN 35772 974 37 the the DT 35772 974 38 vague vague JJ 35772 974 39 speculations speculation NNS 35772 974 40 which which WDT 35772 974 41 had have VBD 35772 974 42 hitherto hitherto VBN 35772 974 43 passed pass VBN 35772 974 44 for for IN 35772 974 45 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 974 46 . . . 35772 975 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 975 2 was be VBD 35772 975 3 , , , 35772 975 4 in in IN 35772 975 5 fact fact NN 35772 975 6 , , , 35772 975 7 the the DT 35772 975 8 founder founder NN 35772 975 9 of of IN 35772 975 10 that that DT 35772 975 11 system system NN 35772 975 12 of of IN 35772 975 13 ideas idea NNS 35772 975 14 known know VBN 35772 975 15 as as IN 35772 975 16 Positivism Positivism NNP 35772 975 17 , , , 35772 975 18 which which WDT 35772 975 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 975 20 as as IN 35772 975 21 we -PRON- PRP 35772 975 22 shall shall MD 35772 975 23 see see VB 35772 975 24 ) ) -RRB- 35772 975 25 gained gain VBN 35772 975 26 great great JJ 35772 975 27 vogue vogue NN 35772 975 28 later later RB 35772 975 29 , , , 35772 975 30 especially especially RB 35772 975 31 in in IN 35772 975 32 England England NNP 35772 975 33 . . . 35772 976 1 Comte Comte NNP 35772 976 2 's 's POS 35772 976 3 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 976 4 was be VBD 35772 976 5 that that IN 35772 976 6 , , , 35772 976 7 all all DT 35772 976 8 spheres sphere NNS 35772 976 9 of of IN 35772 976 10 Nature nature NN 35772 976 11 now now RB 35772 976 12 being be VBG 35772 976 13 brought bring VBN 35772 976 14 under under IN 35772 976 15 the the DT 35772 976 16 sway sway NN 35772 976 17 of of IN 35772 976 18 positive positive JJ 35772 976 19 science science NN 35772 976 20 , , , 35772 976 21 the the DT 35772 976 22 time time NN 35772 976 23 had have VBD 35772 976 24 arrived arrive VBN 35772 976 25 for for IN 35772 976 26 men man NNS 35772 976 27 , , , 35772 976 28 when when WRB 35772 976 29 constructing construct VBG 35772 976 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 976 31 conceptions conception NNS 35772 976 32 of of IN 35772 976 33 life life NN 35772 976 34 and and CC 35772 976 35 the the DT 35772 976 36 world world NN 35772 976 37 , , , 35772 976 38 to to TO 35772 976 39 reject reject VB 35772 976 40 all all DT 35772 976 41 but but CC 35772 976 42 such such JJ 35772 976 43 ideas idea NNS 35772 976 44 as as IN 35772 976 45 positive positive JJ 35772 976 46 science science NN 35772 976 47 can can MD 35772 976 48 accept accept VB 35772 976 49 . . . 35772 977 1 The the DT 35772 977 2 age age NN 35772 977 3 of of IN 35772 977 4 theology theology NN 35772 977 5 and and CC 35772 977 6 speculation speculation NN 35772 977 7 was be VBD 35772 977 8 past past JJ 35772 977 9 ; ; : 35772 977 10 the the DT 35772 977 11 new new JJ 35772 977 12 age age NN 35772 977 13 of of IN 35772 977 14 positive positive JJ 35772 977 15 science science NN 35772 977 16 , , , 35772 977 17 where where WRB 35772 977 18 both both DT 35772 977 19 imagination imagination NN 35772 977 20 and and CC 35772 977 21 argumentation argumentation NN 35772 977 22 should should MD 35772 977 23 be be VB 35772 977 24 subordinate subordinate JJ 35772 977 25 to to IN 35772 977 26 observation observation NN 35772 977 27 , , , 35772 977 28 was be VBD 35772 977 29 at at IN 35772 977 30 hand hand NN 35772 977 31 . . . 35772 978 1 Comte Comte NNP 35772 978 2 , , , 35772 978 3 as as IN 35772 978 4 is be VBZ 35772 978 5 well well RB 35772 978 6 known known JJ 35772 978 7 , , , 35772 978 8 became become VBD 35772 978 9 the the DT 35772 978 10 founder founder NN 35772 978 11 of of IN 35772 978 12 what what WP 35772 978 13 he -PRON- PRP 35772 978 14 hoped hope VBD 35772 978 15 might may MD 35772 978 16 develop develop VB 35772 978 17 into into IN 35772 978 18 a a DT 35772 978 19 new new JJ 35772 978 20 Catholicism Catholicism NNP 35772 978 21 -- -- : 35772 978 22 the the DT 35772 978 23 " " `` 35772 978 24 Religion Religion NNP 35772 978 25 of of IN 35772 978 26 Humanity Humanity NNP 35772 978 27 , , , 35772 978 28 " " '' 35772 978 29 and and CC 35772 978 30 an an DT 35772 978 31 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 978 32 of of IN 35772 978 33 moral moral JJ 35772 978 34 idealism idealism NN 35772 978 35 permeates permeate VBZ 35772 978 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 978 37 thought thought NN 35772 978 38 . . . 35772 979 1 GERMAN GERMAN NNP 35772 979 2 EXTREMISTS.--In EXTREMISTS.--In NNP 35772 979 3 Germany Germany NNP 35772 979 4 , , , 35772 979 5 the the DT 35772 979 6 home home NN 35772 979 7 of of IN 35772 979 8 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 979 9 , , , 35772 979 10 the the DT 35772 979 11 revolt revolt NN 35772 979 12 took take VBD 35772 979 13 a a DT 35772 979 14 radical radical JJ 35772 979 15 shape shape NN 35772 979 16 in in IN 35772 979 17 the the DT 35772 979 18 hands hand NNS 35772 979 19 of of IN 35772 979 20 writers writer NNS 35772 979 21 like like IN 35772 979 22 Ludwig Ludwig NNP 35772 979 23 Feuerbach Feuerbach NNP 35772 979 24 ( ( -LRB- 35772 979 25 1804 1804 CD 35772 979 26 - - SYM 35772 979 27 72 72 CD 35772 979 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 979 29 and and CC 35772 979 30 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 979 31 . . . 35772 980 1 " " `` 35772 980 2 I -PRON- PRP 35772 980 3 unconditionally unconditionally RB 35772 980 4 repudiate repudiate VBP 35772 980 5 absolute absolute JJ 35772 980 6 , , , 35772 980 7 self self NN 35772 980 8 - - HYPH 35772 980 9 sufficing suffice VBG 35772 980 10 speculation speculation NN 35772 980 11 -- -- : 35772 980 12 speculation speculation NN 35772 980 13 which which WDT 35772 980 14 draws draw VBZ 35772 980 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 980 16 material material NN 35772 980 17 from from IN 35772 980 18 within within IN 35772 980 19 , , , 35772 980 20 " " '' 35772 980 21 says say VBZ 35772 980 22 the the DT 35772 980 23 former former JJ 35772 980 24 , , , 35772 980 25 in in IN 35772 980 26 the the DT 35772 980 27 Introduction introduction NN 35772 980 28 to to IN 35772 980 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 980 30 _ _ NNP 35772 980 31 Essence Essence NNP 35772 980 32 of of IN 35772 980 33 Christianity_[40 Christianity_[40 NNP 35772 980 34 ] ] -RRB- 35772 980 35 ( ( -LRB- 35772 980 36 1841 1841 CD 35772 980 37 ) ) -RRB- 35772 980 38 and and CC 35772 980 39 asserts assert VBZ 35772 980 40 that that IN 35772 980 41 he -PRON- PRP 35772 980 42 " " `` 35772 980 43 places place VBZ 35772 980 44 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 980 45 in in IN 35772 980 46 the the DT 35772 980 47 negation negation NN 35772 980 48 of of IN 35772 980 49 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 980 50 . . . 35772 980 51 " " '' 35772 981 1 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 981 2 , , , 35772 981 3 a a DT 35772 981 4 far far RB 35772 981 5 less less RBR 35772 981 6 acute acute JJ 35772 981 7 thinker thinker NN 35772 981 8 than than IN 35772 981 9 Feuerbach Feuerbach NNP 35772 981 10 , , , 35772 981 11 adopts adopt VBZ 35772 981 12 a a DT 35772 981 13 similar similar JJ 35772 981 14 attitude attitude NN 35772 981 15 , , , 35772 981 16 protests protest NNS 35772 981 17 against against IN 35772 981 18 pedantry pedantry NNP 35772 981 19 , , , 35772 981 20 and and CC 35772 981 21 appeals appeal NNS 35772 981 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 981 23 the the DT 35772 981 24 appeal appeal NN 35772 981 25 is be VBZ 35772 981 26 always always RB 35772 981 27 dangerous dangerous JJ 35772 981 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 981 29 to to IN 35772 981 30 common common JJ 35772 981 31 sense sense NN 35772 981 32 : : : 35772 981 33 " " `` 35772 981 34 Expositions exposition NNS 35772 981 35 which which WDT 35772 981 36 are be VBP 35772 981 37 not not RB 35772 981 38 intelligible intelligible JJ 35772 981 39 to to IN 35772 981 40 an an DT 35772 981 41 educated educated JJ 35772 981 42 man man NN 35772 981 43 are be VBP 35772 981 44 scarcely scarcely RB 35772 981 45 worth worth JJ 35772 981 46 the the DT 35772 981 47 ink ink NN 35772 981 48 they -PRON- PRP 35772 981 49 are be VBP 35772 981 50 printed print VBN 35772 981 51 with with IN 35772 981 52 . . . 35772 982 1 Whatever whatever WDT 35772 982 2 is be VBZ 35772 982 3 clearly clearly RB 35772 982 4 conceived conceive VBN 35772 982 5 can can MD 35772 982 6 be be VB 35772 982 7 clearly clearly RB 35772 982 8 expressed express VBN 35772 982 9 . . . 35772 982 10 " " '' 35772 983 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 983 2 is be VBZ 35772 983 3 not not RB 35772 983 4 surprising surprising JJ 35772 983 5 that that IN 35772 983 6 the the DT 35772 983 7 book book NN 35772 983 8 _ _ NNP 35772 983 9 Force Force NNP 35772 983 10 and and CC 35772 983 11 Matter Matter NNP 35772 983 12 _ _ NNP 35772 983 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 983 14 1855)--in 1855)--in CD 35772 983 15 the the DT 35772 983 16 preface preface NN 35772 983 17 to to TO 35772 983 18 which which WDT 35772 983 19 these these DT 35772 983 20 sentiments sentiment NNS 35772 983 21 are be VBP 35772 983 22 expressed express VBN 35772 983 23 -- -- : 35772 983 24 went go VBD 35772 983 25 through through IN 35772 983 26 sixteen sixteen CD 35772 983 27 editions edition NNS 35772 983 28 in in IN 35772 983 29 thirty thirty CD 35772 983 30 years year NNS 35772 983 31 and and CC 35772 983 32 was be VBD 35772 983 33 translated translate VBN 35772 983 34 into into IN 35772 983 35 most most JJS 35772 983 36 European european JJ 35772 983 37 languages language NNS 35772 983 38 . . . 35772 984 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 984 2 is be VBZ 35772 984 3 an an DT 35772 984 4 extreme extreme JJ 35772 984 5 expression expression NN 35772 984 6 of of IN 35772 984 7 the the DT 35772 984 8 most most RBS 35772 984 9 thorough thorough JJ 35772 984 10 - - HYPH 35772 984 11 going go VBG 35772 984 12 materialism materialism NN 35772 984 13 , , , 35772 984 14 and and CC 35772 984 15 the the DT 35772 984 16 circumstance circumstance NN 35772 984 17 that that WDT 35772 984 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 984 19 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 984 20 were be VBD 35772 984 21 acceptable acceptable JJ 35772 984 22 neither neither CC 35772 984 23 to to IN 35772 984 24 cautious cautious JJ 35772 984 25 scientists scientist NNS 35772 984 26 nor nor CC 35772 984 27 to to IN 35772 984 28 critical critical JJ 35772 984 29 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 984 30 , , , 35772 984 31 did do VBD 35772 984 32 not not RB 35772 984 33 compromise compromise VB 35772 984 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 984 35 authority authority NN 35772 984 36 with with IN 35772 984 37 the the DT 35772 984 38 general general JJ 35772 984 39 public public NN 35772 984 40 . . . 35772 985 1 As as IN 35772 985 2 was be VBD 35772 985 3 only only RB 35772 985 4 natural natural JJ 35772 985 5 , , , 35772 985 6 for for IN 35772 985 7 materialism materialism NN 35772 985 8 is be VBZ 35772 985 9 a a DT 35772 985 10 creed creed NN 35772 985 11 for for IN 35772 985 12 which which WDT 35772 985 13 the the DT 35772 985 14 evidence evidence NN 35772 985 15 is be VBZ 35772 985 16 all all RB 35772 985 17 on on IN 35772 985 18 the the DT 35772 985 19 surface surface NN 35772 985 20 , , , 35772 985 21 and and CC 35772 985 22 to to TO 35772 985 23 which which WDT 35772 985 24 the the DT 35772 985 25 objections objection NNS 35772 985 26 , , , 35772 985 27 being be VBG 35772 985 28 less less RBR 35772 985 29 obvious obvious JJ 35772 985 30 , , , 35772 985 31 escape escape NN 35772 985 32 notice notice NN 35772 985 33 . . . 35772 986 1 And and CC 35772 986 2 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 986 3 's 's POS 35772 986 4 pleas plea NNS 35772 986 5 for for IN 35772 986 6 intelligibility intelligibility NN 35772 986 7 and and CC 35772 986 8 clearness clearness NN 35772 986 9 , , , 35772 986 10 though though IN 35772 986 11 in in IN 35772 986 12 some some DT 35772 986 13 sense sense NN 35772 986 14 justified justify VBN 35772 986 15 by by IN 35772 986 16 the the DT 35772 986 17 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 35772 986 18 pedantry pedantry NN 35772 986 19 of of IN 35772 986 20 much much JJ 35772 986 21 German german JJ 35772 986 22 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 986 23 , , , 35772 986 24 was be VBD 35772 986 25 , , , 35772 986 26 in in IN 35772 986 27 point point NN 35772 986 28 of of IN 35772 986 29 fact fact NN 35772 986 30 , , , 35772 986 31 only only RB 35772 986 32 a a DT 35772 986 33 form form NN 35772 986 34 of of IN 35772 986 35 ca can MD 35772 986 36 nt not RB 35772 986 37 ; ; : 35772 986 38 for for IN 35772 986 39 " " `` 35772 986 40 there there EX 35772 986 41 are be VBP 35772 986 42 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 986 43 lying lie VBG 35772 986 44 in in IN 35772 986 45 the the DT 35772 986 46 subject subject NN 35772 986 47 - - HYPH 35772 986 48 matter matter NN 35772 986 49 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 986 50 which which WDT 35772 986 51 can can MD 35772 986 52 not not RB 35772 986 53 be be VB 35772 986 54 banished banish VBN 35772 986 55 from from IN 35772 986 56 the the DT 35772 986 57 sphere sphere NN 35772 986 58 of of IN 35772 986 59 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 986 60 . . . 35772 986 61 " " '' 35772 987 1 Appeals appeal NNS 35772 987 2 to to IN 35772 987 3 popular popular JJ 35772 987 4 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 987 5 are be VBP 35772 987 6 not not RB 35772 987 7 a a DT 35772 987 8 more more RBR 35772 987 9 legitimate legitimate JJ 35772 987 10 form form NN 35772 987 11 of of IN 35772 987 12 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 987 13 , , , 35772 987 14 than than IN 35772 987 15 of of IN 35772 987 16 scientific scientific JJ 35772 987 17 controversy controversy NN 35772 987 18 ; ; , 35772 987 19 serious serious JJ 35772 987 20 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 987 21 do do VBP 35772 987 22 not not RB 35772 987 23 thus thus RB 35772 987 24 stoop stoop VB 35772 987 25 to to IN 35772 987 26 the the DT 35772 987 27 expedients expedient NNS 35772 987 28 of of IN 35772 987 29 the the DT 35772 987 30 politician politician NN 35772 987 31 . . . 35772 988 1 EFFECTS effect NNS 35772 988 2 OF of IN 35772 988 3 DARWIN DARWIN NNP 35772 988 4 'S 's POS 35772 988 5 THEORY.--It THEORY.--It NNP 35772 988 6 would would MD 35772 988 7 be be VB 35772 988 8 a a DT 35772 988 9 serious serious JJ 35772 988 10 mistake mistake NN 35772 988 11 , , , 35772 988 12 then then RB 35772 988 13 , , , 35772 988 14 to to TO 35772 988 15 imagine imagine VB 35772 988 16 that that IN 35772 988 17 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 988 18 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 988 19 had have VBD 35772 988 20 to to TO 35772 988 21 wait wait VB 35772 988 22 for for IN 35772 988 23 the the DT 35772 988 24 publication publication NN 35772 988 25 of of IN 35772 988 26 the the DT 35772 988 27 _ _ NNP 35772 988 28 Origin Origin NNP 35772 988 29 of of IN 35772 988 30 Species Species NNP 35772 988 31 _ _ NNP 35772 988 32 ( ( -LRB- 35772 988 33 1859 1859 CD 35772 988 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 988 35 before before IN 35772 988 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 988 37 could could MD 35772 988 38 become become VB 35772 988 39 a a DT 35772 988 40 formidable formidable JJ 35772 988 41 theory theory NN 35772 988 42 . . . 35772 989 1 And and CC 35772 989 2 yet yet RB 35772 989 3 the the DT 35772 989 4 appearance appearance NN 35772 989 5 of of IN 35772 989 6 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 989 7 's 's POS 35772 989 8 book book NN 35772 989 9 had have VBD 35772 989 10 important important JJ 35772 989 11 effects effect NNS 35772 989 12 , , , 35772 989 13 and and CC 35772 989 14 among among IN 35772 989 15 these these DT 35772 989 16 is be VBZ 35772 989 17 to to TO 35772 989 18 be be VB 35772 989 19 reckoned reckon VBN 35772 989 20 a a DT 35772 989 21 certain certain JJ 35772 989 22 weakening weakening NN 35772 989 23 of of IN 35772 989 24 the the DT 35772 989 25 old old JJ 35772 989 26 " " `` 35772 989 27 Argument argument NN 35772 989 28 from from IN 35772 989 29 Design Design NNP 35772 989 30 , , , 35772 989 31 " " '' 35772 989 32 according accord VBG 35772 989 33 to to IN 35772 989 34 which which WDT 35772 989 35 the the DT 35772 989 36 complexity complexity NN 35772 989 37 and and CC 35772 989 38 delicacy delicacy NN 35772 989 39 evident evident JJ 35772 989 40 everywhere everywhere RB 35772 989 41 in in IN 35772 989 42 the the DT 35772 989 43 world world NN 35772 989 44 of of IN 35772 989 45 nature nature NN 35772 989 46 , , , 35772 989 47 could could MD 35772 989 48 not not RB 35772 989 49 be be VB 35772 989 50 attributed attribute VBN 35772 989 51 to to IN 35772 989 52 chance chance NN 35772 989 53 , , , 35772 989 54 but but CC 35772 989 55 pointed point VBD 35772 989 56 to to IN 35772 989 57 the the DT 35772 989 58 existence existence NN 35772 989 59 and and CC 35772 989 60 activity activity NN 35772 989 61 of of IN 35772 989 62 a a DT 35772 989 63 divine divine JJ 35772 989 64 Designer designer NN 35772 989 65 . . . 35772 990 1 Paley Paley NNP 35772 990 2 , , , 35772 990 3 during during IN 35772 990 4 the the DT 35772 990 5 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 990 6 century century NN 35772 990 7 , , , 35772 990 8 had have VBD 35772 990 9 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 990 10 the the DT 35772 990 11 argument argument NN 35772 990 12 with with IN 35772 990 13 a a DT 35772 990 14 wealth wealth NN 35772 990 15 of of IN 35772 990 16 detailed detailed JJ 35772 990 17 instances instance NNS 35772 990 18 of of IN 35772 990 19 " " `` 35772 990 20 contrivance contrivance NN 35772 990 21 " " '' 35772 990 22 : : : 35772 990 23 " " `` 35772 990 24 The the DT 35772 990 25 pivot pivot NN 35772 990 26 upon upon IN 35772 990 27 which which WDT 35772 990 28 the the DT 35772 990 29 head head NN 35772 990 30 turns turn VBZ 35772 990 31 , , , 35772 990 32 the the DT 35772 990 33 ligament ligament NN 35772 990 34 within within IN 35772 990 35 the the DT 35772 990 36 socket socket NN 35772 990 37 of of IN 35772 990 38 the the DT 35772 990 39 hip hip NN 35772 990 40 - - HYPH 35772 990 41 joint joint NN 35772 990 42 , , , 35772 990 43 the the DT 35772 990 44 pulley pulley NN 35772 990 45 or or CC 35772 990 46 trochlear trochlear JJ 35772 990 47 muscles muscle NNS 35772 990 48 of of IN 35772 990 49 the the DT 35772 990 50 eye eye NN 35772 990 51 ; ; : 35772 990 52 the the DT 35772 990 53 epiglottis epiglottis NN 35772 990 54 , , , 35772 990 55 the the DT 35772 990 56 bandages bandage NNS 35772 990 57 which which WDT 35772 990 58 tie tie VBP 35772 990 59 down down RP 35772 990 60 the the DT 35772 990 61 tendons tendon NNS 35772 990 62 of of IN 35772 990 63 the the DT 35772 990 64 wrist wrist NN 35772 990 65 and and CC 35772 990 66 instep instep NN 35772 990 67 , , , 35772 990 68 " " '' 35772 990 69 and and CC 35772 990 70 so so RB 35772 990 71 on on RB 35772 990 72 . . . 35772 991 1 And and CC 35772 991 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 991 3 was be VBD 35772 991 4 not not RB 35772 991 5 so so RB 35772 991 6 much much RB 35772 991 7 the the DT 35772 991 8 doubt doubt NN 35772 991 9 cast cast VBN 35772 991 10 by by IN 35772 991 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 991 12 upon upon IN 35772 991 13 the the DT 35772 991 14 separate separate JJ 35772 991 15 creation creation NN 35772 991 16 of of IN 35772 991 17 particular particular JJ 35772 991 18 species specie NNS 35772 991 19 that that WDT 35772 991 20 was be VBD 35772 991 21 the the DT 35772 991 22 disturbing disturbing JJ 35772 991 23 element element NN 35772 991 24 in in IN 35772 991 25 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 991 26 's 's POS 35772 991 27 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 991 28 ( ( -LRB- 35772 991 29 few few JJ 35772 991 30 men man NNS 35772 991 31 now now RB 35772 991 32 regarded regard VBD 35772 991 33 the the DT 35772 991 34 book book NN 35772 991 35 of of IN 35772 991 36 _ _ NNP 35772 991 37 Genesis Genesis NNP 35772 991 38 _ _ NNP 35772 991 39 as as IN 35772 991 40 a a DT 35772 991 41 manual manual NN 35772 991 42 of of IN 35772 991 43 natural natural JJ 35772 991 44 science science NN 35772 991 45 , , , 35772 991 46 or or CC 35772 991 47 faith faith NN 35772 991 48 in in IN 35772 991 49 it -PRON- PRP 35772 991 50 , , , 35772 991 51 as as IN 35772 991 52 such such JJ 35772 991 53 , , , 35772 991 54 as as IN 35772 991 55 a a DT 35772 991 56 matter matter NN 35772 991 57 of of IN 35772 991 58 religious religious JJ 35772 991 59 obligation obligation NN 35772 991 60 ) ) -RRB- 35772 991 61 ; ; : 35772 991 62 it -PRON- PRP 35772 991 63 was be VBD 35772 991 64 rather rather RB 35772 991 65 that that IN 35772 991 66 the the DT 35772 991 67 new new JJ 35772 991 68 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 991 69 of of IN 35772 991 70 " " `` 35772 991 71 natural natural JJ 35772 991 72 selection selection NN 35772 991 73 " " '' 35772 991 74 seemed seem VBD 35772 991 75 to to TO 35772 991 76 invalidate invalidate VB 35772 991 77 the the DT 35772 991 78 " " `` 35772 991 79 argument argument NN 35772 991 80 from from IN 35772 991 81 design design NN 35772 991 82 . . . 35772 991 83 " " '' 35772 992 1 Design design NN 35772 992 2 or or CC 35772 992 3 chance chance NN 35772 992 4 had have VBD 35772 992 5 been be VBN 35772 992 6 the the DT 35772 992 7 alternatives alternative NNS 35772 992 8 offered offer VBN 35772 992 9 by by IN 35772 992 10 Paley Paley NNP 35772 992 11 , , , 35772 992 12 and and CC 35772 992 13 chance chance NN 35772 992 14 only only RB 35772 992 15 had have VBD 35772 992 16 to to TO 35772 992 17 be be VB 35772 992 18 mentioned mention VBN 35772 992 19 to to TO 35772 992 20 be be VB 35772 992 21 rejected reject VBN 35772 992 22 ; ; : 35772 992 23 but but CC 35772 992 24 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 992 25 made make VBD 35772 992 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 992 27 possible possible JJ 35772 992 28 to to TO 35772 992 29 escape escape VB 35772 992 30 from from IN 35772 992 31 the the DT 35772 992 32 dilemma dilemma NN 35772 992 33 . . . 35772 993 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 993 2 showed show VBD 35772 993 3 how how WRB 35772 993 4 , , , 35772 993 5 if if IN 35772 993 6 certain certain JJ 35772 993 7 conditions condition NNS 35772 993 8 were be VBD 35772 993 9 granted grant VBN 35772 993 10 , , , 35772 993 11 the the DT 35772 993 12 whole whole JJ 35772 993 13 process process NN 35772 993 14 of of IN 35772 993 15 the the DT 35772 993 16 manufacture manufacture NN 35772 993 17 of of IN 35772 993 18 species specie NNS 35772 993 19 would would MD 35772 993 20 naturally naturally RB 35772 993 21 and and CC 35772 993 22 inevitably inevitably RB 35772 993 23 follow follow VB 35772 993 24 . . . 35772 994 1 Neither neither DT 35772 994 2 design design NN 35772 994 3 nor nor CC 35772 994 4 chance chance NN 35772 994 5 was be VBD 35772 994 6 the the DT 35772 994 7 explanation explanation NN 35772 994 8 : : : 35772 994 9 there there EX 35772 994 10 was be VBD 35772 994 11 another another DT 35772 994 12 alternative alternative NN 35772 994 13 , , , 35772 994 14 _ _ NNP 35772 994 15 the the DT 35772 994 16 influence influence NN 35772 994 17 of of IN 35772 994 18 environment environment NN 35772 994 19 _ _ NNP 35772 994 20 . . . 35772 995 1 Thus thus RB 35772 995 2 Paley Paley NNP 35772 995 3 's 's POS 35772 995 4 instances instance NNS 35772 995 5 of of IN 35772 995 6 elaborate elaborate JJ 35772 995 7 " " `` 35772 995 8 contrivance contrivance NN 35772 995 9 " " '' 35772 995 10 were be VBD 35772 995 11 explained explain VBN 35772 995 12 by by IN 35772 995 13 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 995 14 as as IN 35772 995 15 instances instance NNS 35772 995 16 of of IN 35772 995 17 adaptation adaptation NN 35772 995 18 . . . 35772 996 1 The the DT 35772 996 2 environment environment NN 35772 996 3 under under IN 35772 996 4 which which WDT 35772 996 5 these these DT 35772 996 6 organs organ NNS 35772 996 7 had have VBD 35772 996 8 developed develop VBN 35772 996 9 had have VBD 35772 996 10 made make VBN 35772 996 11 them -PRON- PRP 35772 996 12 what what WP 35772 996 13 they -PRON- PRP 35772 996 14 were be VBD 35772 996 15 ; ; : 35772 996 16 they -PRON- PRP 35772 996 17 could could MD 35772 996 18 not not RB 35772 996 19 , , , 35772 996 20 under under IN 35772 996 21 the the DT 35772 996 22 given give VBN 35772 996 23 circumstances circumstance NNS 35772 996 24 , , , 35772 996 25 have have VBP 35772 996 26 been be VBN 35772 996 27 different different JJ 35772 996 28 . . . 35772 997 1 As as IN 35772 997 2 a a DT 35772 997 3 very very RB 35772 997 4 lucid lucid JJ 35772 997 5 writer writer NN 35772 997 6 puts put VBZ 35772 997 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 997 8 : : : 35772 997 9 " " `` 35772 997 10 Before before IN 35772 997 11 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 997 12 's 's POS 35772 997 13 great great JJ 35772 997 14 discovery discovery NN 35772 997 15 , , , 35772 997 16 those those DT 35772 997 17 who who WP 35772 997 18 denied deny VBD 35772 997 19 the the DT 35772 997 20 existence existence NN 35772 997 21 of of IN 35772 997 22 a a DT 35772 997 23 Contriver Contriver NNP 35772 997 24 were be VBD 35772 997 25 hard hard JJ 35772 997 26 put put VBN 35772 997 27 to to IN 35772 997 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 997 29 to to TO 35772 997 30 explain explain VB 35772 997 31 the the DT 35772 997 32 appearance appearance NN 35772 997 33 of of IN 35772 997 34 contrivance contrivance NN 35772 997 35 . . . 35772 998 1 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 998 2 , , , 35772 998 3 within within IN 35772 998 4 certain certain JJ 35772 998 5 limits limit NNS 35772 998 6 and and CC 35772 998 7 on on IN 35772 998 8 certain certain JJ 35772 998 9 suppositions supposition NNS 35772 998 10 , , , 35772 998 11 provided provide VBD 35772 998 12 an an DT 35772 998 13 explanation explanation NN 35772 998 14 . . . 35772 999 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 999 2 showed show VBD 35772 999 3 how how WRB 35772 999 4 the the DT 35772 999 5 most most RBS 35772 999 6 complicated complicated JJ 35772 999 7 and and CC 35772 999 8 purposeful purposeful JJ 35772 999 9 organs organ NNS 35772 999 10 , , , 35772 999 11 if if IN 35772 999 12 only only RB 35772 999 13 they -PRON- PRP 35772 999 14 were be VBD 35772 999 15 useful useful JJ 35772 999 16 to to IN 35772 999 17 the the DT 35772 999 18 species specie NNS 35772 999 19 , , , 35772 999 20 might may MD 35772 999 21 gradually gradually RB 35772 999 22 arise arise VB 35772 999 23 out out IN 35772 999 24 of of IN 35772 999 25 random random JJ 35772 999 26 variations variation NNS 35772 999 27 , , , 35772 999 28 continuously continuously RB 35772 999 29 weeded weed VBN 35772 999 30 by by IN 35772 999 31 an an DT 35772 999 32 unthinking unthinking JJ 35772 999 33 process process NN 35772 999 34 of of IN 35772 999 35 elimination elimination NN 35772 999 36 . . . 35772 1000 1 " " `` 35772 1000 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1000 3 41 41 CD 35772 1000 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1000 5 DARWINISM DARWINISM NNP 35772 1000 6 EXPLOITED.--In EXPLOITED.--In NNP 35772 1000 7 fact fact NN 35772 1000 8 , , , 35772 1000 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1000 10 became become VBD 35772 1000 11 evident evident JJ 35772 1000 12 that that IN 35772 1000 13 popular popular JJ 35772 1000 14 materialism materialism NN 35772 1000 15 had have VBD 35772 1000 16 been be VBN 35772 1000 17 strongly strongly RB 35772 1000 18 reinforced reinforce VBN 35772 1000 19 by by IN 35772 1000 20 the the DT 35772 1000 21 new new JJ 35772 1000 22 biology biology NN 35772 1000 23 ; ; : 35772 1000 24 and and CC 35772 1000 25 though though IN 35772 1000 26 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1000 27 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1000 28 was be VBD 35772 1000 29 cautious cautious JJ 35772 1000 30 in in IN 35772 1000 31 adding add VBG 35772 1000 32 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1000 33 or or CC 35772 1000 34 religious religious JJ 35772 1000 35 corollaries corollary NNS 35772 1000 36 to to IN 35772 1000 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1000 38 own own JJ 35772 1000 39 propositions proposition NNS 35772 1000 40 , , , 35772 1000 41 some some DT 35772 1000 42 of of IN 35772 1000 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1000 44 more more RBR 35772 1000 45 eager eager JJ 35772 1000 46 disciples disciple NNS 35772 1000 47 did do VBD 35772 1000 48 not not RB 35772 1000 49 hesitate hesitate VB 35772 1000 50 to to TO 35772 1000 51 fill fill VB 35772 1000 52 in in RP 35772 1000 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1000 54 blanks blank NNS 35772 1000 55 , , , 35772 1000 56 and and CC 35772 1000 57 to to TO 35772 1000 58 draw draw VB 35772 1000 59 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1000 60 which which WDT 35772 1000 61 the the DT 35772 1000 62 master master NN 35772 1000 63 was be VBD 35772 1000 64 too too RB 35772 1000 65 conservative conservative JJ 35772 1000 66 , , , 35772 1000 67 too too RB 35772 1000 68 blind blind JJ 35772 1000 69 , , , 35772 1000 70 or or CC 35772 1000 71 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1000 72 too too RB 35772 1000 73 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1000 74 to to IN 35772 1000 75 sanction sanction NN 35772 1000 76 . . . 35772 1001 1 The the DT 35772 1001 2 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 1001 3 zoologist zoologist NN 35772 1001 4 Haeckel Haeckel NNP 35772 1001 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1001 6 1834 1834 CD 35772 1001 7 - - SYM 35772 1001 8 1919 1919 CD 35772 1001 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1001 10 may may MD 35772 1001 11 be be VB 35772 1001 12 reckoned reckon VBN 35772 1001 13 the the DT 35772 1001 14 most most RBS 35772 1001 15 notable notable JJ 35772 1001 16 amongst amongst IN 35772 1001 17 these these DT 35772 1001 18 . . . 35772 1002 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1002 2 was be VBD 35772 1002 3 one one CD 35772 1002 4 of of IN 35772 1002 5 the the DT 35772 1002 6 first first JJ 35772 1002 7 German german JJ 35772 1002 8 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1002 9 to to TO 35772 1002 10 give give VB 35772 1002 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1002 12 adherence adherence NN 35772 1002 13 to to IN 35772 1002 14 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1002 15 , , , 35772 1002 16 who who WP 35772 1002 17 seems seem VBZ 35772 1002 18 to to TO 35772 1002 19 have have VB 35772 1002 20 considered consider VBN 35772 1002 21 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1002 22 too too RB 35772 1002 23 zealous zealous JJ 35772 1002 24 a a DT 35772 1002 25 disciple disciple NN 35772 1002 26 . . . 35772 1003 1 " " `` 35772 1003 2 Your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1003 3 boldness boldness NN 35772 1003 4 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 1003 5 makes make VBZ 35772 1003 6 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1003 7 tremble tremble JJ 35772 1003 8 , , , 35772 1003 9 " " '' 35772 1003 10 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1003 11 wrote write VBD 35772 1003 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1003 13 November November NNP 35772 1003 14 19 19 CD 35772 1003 15 , , , 35772 1003 16 1868 1868 CD 35772 1003 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1003 18 . . . 35772 1004 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1004 2 is be VBZ 35772 1004 3 not not RB 35772 1004 4 every every DT 35772 1004 5 scientist scientist NN 35772 1004 6 who who WP 35772 1004 7 can can MD 35772 1004 8 perceive perceive VB 35772 1004 9 the the DT 35772 1004 10 limits limit NNS 35772 1004 11 of of IN 35772 1004 12 an an DT 35772 1004 13 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 1004 14 , , , 35772 1004 15 or or CC 35772 1004 16 who who WP 35772 1004 17 insists insist VBZ 35772 1004 18 so so RB 35772 1004 19 conscientiously conscientiously RB 35772 1004 20 as as IN 35772 1004 21 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1004 22 did do VBD 35772 1004 23 , , , 35772 1004 24 upon upon IN 35772 1004 25 the the DT 35772 1004 26 necessity necessity NN 35772 1004 27 for for IN 35772 1004 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1004 29 verification verification NN 35772 1004 30 . . . 35772 1005 1 HERBERT herbert VB 35772 1005 2 SPENCER.--Though spencer.--though IN 35772 1005 3 there there EX 35772 1005 4 were be VBD 35772 1005 5 not not RB 35772 1005 6 wanting want VBG 35772 1005 7 in in IN 35772 1005 8 England England NNP 35772 1005 9 writers writer NNS 35772 1005 10 to to TO 35772 1005 11 exploit exploit VB 35772 1005 12 Darwinian darwinian JJ 35772 1005 13 theories theory NNS 35772 1005 14 in in IN 35772 1005 15 the the DT 35772 1005 16 interests interest NNS 35772 1005 17 of of IN 35772 1005 18 a a DT 35772 1005 19 narrow narrow JJ 35772 1005 20 secularism secularism NN 35772 1005 21 , , , 35772 1005 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1005 23 work work NN 35772 1005 24 was be VBD 35772 1005 25 not not RB 35772 1005 26 of of IN 35772 1005 27 first first JJ 35772 1005 28 - - HYPH 35772 1005 29 rate rate NN 35772 1005 30 importance importance NN 35772 1005 31 , , , 35772 1005 32 and and CC 35772 1005 33 need nee MD 35772 1005 34 not not RB 35772 1005 35 detain detain VB 35772 1005 36 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1005 37 . . . 35772 1006 1 A a DT 35772 1006 2 new new JJ 35772 1006 3 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 1006 4 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1006 5 was be VBD 35772 1006 6 , , , 35772 1006 7 however however RB 35772 1006 8 , , , 35772 1006 9 worked work VBD 35772 1006 10 out out RP 35772 1006 11 by by IN 35772 1006 12 a a DT 35772 1006 13 conscientious conscientious JJ 35772 1006 14 thinker thinker NN 35772 1006 15 of of IN 35772 1006 16 a a DT 35772 1006 17 different different JJ 35772 1006 18 calibre calibre NN 35772 1006 19 -- -- : 35772 1006 20 Mr Mr NNP 35772 1006 21 . . NNP 35772 1006 22 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1006 23 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1006 24 . . . 35772 1007 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1007 2 indeed indeed RB 35772 1007 3 may may MD 35772 1007 4 be be VB 35772 1007 5 described describe VBN 35772 1007 6 as as IN 35772 1007 7 the the DT 35772 1007 8 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 35772 1007 9 of of IN 35772 1007 10 a a DT 35772 1007 11 new new JJ 35772 1007 12 world world NN 35772 1007 13 - - HYPH 35772 1007 14 view view NN 35772 1007 15 . . . 35772 1008 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1008 2 attempted attempt VBD 35772 1008 3 to to TO 35772 1008 4 co co VB 35772 1008 5 - - VB 35772 1008 6 ordinate ordinate VB 35772 1008 7 and and CC 35772 1008 8 unify unify VB 35772 1008 9 all all DT 35772 1008 10 human human JJ 35772 1008 11 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1008 12 , , , 35772 1008 13 and and CC 35772 1008 14 to to TO 35772 1008 15 present present VB 35772 1008 16 the the DT 35772 1008 17 world world NN 35772 1008 18 with with IN 35772 1008 19 a a DT 35772 1008 20 final final JJ 35772 1008 21 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1008 22 based base VBN 35772 1008 23 upon upon IN 35772 1008 24 the the DT 35772 1008 25 _ _ NNP 35772 1008 26 data datum NNS 35772 1008 27 _ _ NNP 35772 1008 28 supplied supply VBN 35772 1008 29 by by IN 35772 1008 30 natural natural JJ 35772 1008 31 science science NN 35772 1008 32 . . . 35772 1009 1 To to IN 35772 1009 2 this this DT 35772 1009 3 ambitious ambitious JJ 35772 1009 4 task task NN 35772 1009 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1009 6 devoted devote VBD 35772 1009 7 a a DT 35772 1009 8 lifetime lifetime NN 35772 1009 9 of of IN 35772 1009 10 patient patient NN 35772 1009 11 work work NN 35772 1009 12 , , , 35772 1009 13 broken break VBN 35772 1009 14 by by IN 35772 1009 15 intervals interval NNS 35772 1009 16 of of IN 35772 1009 17 ill ill JJ 35772 1009 18 - - HYPH 35772 1009 19 health health NN 35772 1009 20 . . . 35772 1010 1 In in IN 35772 1010 2 1850 1850 CD 35772 1010 3 the the DT 35772 1010 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1010 5 System System NNP 35772 1010 6 of of IN 35772 1010 7 Synthetic Synthetic NNP 35772 1010 8 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1010 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1010 10 was be VBD 35772 1010 11 projected project VBN 35772 1010 12 ; ; : 35772 1010 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1010 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1010 15 First First NNP 35772 1010 16 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 1010 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1010 18 were be VBD 35772 1010 19 published publish VBN 35772 1010 20 in in IN 35772 1010 21 1862 1862 CD 35772 1010 22 , , , 35772 1010 23 but but CC 35772 1010 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1010 25 was be VBD 35772 1010 26 not not RB 35772 1010 27 until until IN 35772 1010 28 1896 1896 CD 35772 1010 29 that that IN 35772 1010 30 the the DT 35772 1010 31 gigantic gigantic JJ 35772 1010 32 enterprise enterprise NN 35772 1010 33 was be VBD 35772 1010 34 complete complete JJ 35772 1010 35 . . . 35772 1011 1 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1011 2 was be VBD 35772 1011 3 inspired inspire VBN 35772 1011 4 neither neither CC 35772 1011 5 by by IN 35772 1011 6 hostility hostility NN 35772 1011 7 to to IN 35772 1011 8 religion religion NN 35772 1011 9 in in IN 35772 1011 10 general general JJ 35772 1011 11 , , , 35772 1011 12 nor nor CC 35772 1011 13 to to IN 35772 1011 14 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 1011 15 in in IN 35772 1011 16 particular particular JJ 35772 1011 17 . . . 35772 1012 1 The the DT 35772 1012 2 motive motive NN 35772 1012 3 of of IN 35772 1012 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1012 5 work work NN 35772 1012 6 was be VBD 35772 1012 7 a a DT 35772 1012 8 more more RBR 35772 1012 9 honourable honourable JJ 35772 1012 10 one one NN 35772 1012 11 . . . 35772 1013 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1013 2 felt feel VBD 35772 1013 3 , , , 35772 1013 4 with with IN 35772 1013 5 many many JJ 35772 1013 6 of of IN 35772 1013 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1013 8 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 1013 9 , , , 35772 1013 10 that that IN 35772 1013 11 the the DT 35772 1013 12 foundations foundation NNS 35772 1013 13 of of IN 35772 1013 14 the the DT 35772 1013 15 old old JJ 35772 1013 16 religion religion NN 35772 1013 17 were be VBD 35772 1013 18 no no RB 35772 1013 19 longer long RBR 35772 1013 20 secure secure JJ 35772 1013 21 , , , 35772 1013 22 and and CC 35772 1013 23 that that IN 35772 1013 24 the the DT 35772 1013 25 old old JJ 35772 1013 26 sanctions sanction NNS 35772 1013 27 of of IN 35772 1013 28 morality morality NN 35772 1013 29 were be VBD 35772 1013 30 already already RB 35772 1013 31 gravely gravely RB 35772 1013 32 compromised compromise VBN 35772 1013 33 ; ; : 35772 1013 34 and and CC 35772 1013 35 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1013 36 wished wish VBD 35772 1013 37 to to TO 35772 1013 38 supply supply VB 35772 1013 39 a a DT 35772 1013 40 new new JJ 35772 1013 41 creed creed NN 35772 1013 42 and and CC 35772 1013 43 a a DT 35772 1013 44 new new JJ 35772 1013 45 discipline discipline NN 35772 1013 46 in in IN 35772 1013 47 the the DT 35772 1013 48 place place NN 35772 1013 49 of of IN 35772 1013 50 these these DT 35772 1013 51 . . . 35772 1014 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1014 2 principal principal JJ 35772 1014 3 objects object NNS 35772 1014 4 were be VBD 35772 1014 5 social social JJ 35772 1014 6 and and CC 35772 1014 7 ethical ethical JJ 35772 1014 8 . . . 35772 1015 1 And and CC 35772 1015 2 in in IN 35772 1015 3 this this DT 35772 1015 4 important important JJ 35772 1015 5 respect respect NN 35772 1015 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1015 7 may may MD 35772 1015 8 be be VB 35772 1015 9 associated associate VBN 35772 1015 10 with with IN 35772 1015 11 Comte Comte NNP 35772 1015 12 . . . 35772 1016 1 Both both DT 35772 1016 2 were be VBD 35772 1016 3 sociologists sociologist NNS 35772 1016 4 and and CC 35772 1016 5 moralists moralist NNS 35772 1016 6 before before IN 35772 1016 7 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1016 8 were be VBD 35772 1016 9 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1016 10 , , , 35772 1016 11 which which WDT 35772 1016 12 accounts account VBZ 35772 1016 13 for for IN 35772 1016 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1016 15 overlooking overlook VBG 35772 1016 16 and and CC 35772 1016 17 underestimating underestimate VBG 35772 1016 18 various various JJ 35772 1016 19 important important JJ 35772 1016 20 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1016 21 difficulties difficulty NNS 35772 1016 22 . . . 35772 1017 1 A a DT 35772 1017 2 few few JJ 35772 1017 3 remarks remark NNS 35772 1017 4 about about IN 35772 1017 5 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1017 6 's 's POS 35772 1017 7 system system NN 35772 1017 8 are be VBP 35772 1017 9 here here RB 35772 1017 10 not not RB 35772 1017 11 out out IN 35772 1017 12 of of IN 35772 1017 13 place place NN 35772 1017 14 . . . 35772 1018 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1018 2 attempted attempt VBD 35772 1018 3 to to TO 35772 1018 4 reduce reduce VB 35772 1018 5 experience experience NN 35772 1018 6 to to IN 35772 1018 7 a a DT 35772 1018 8 unity unity NN 35772 1018 9 by by IN 35772 1018 10 seeking seek VBG 35772 1018 11 evidence evidence NN 35772 1018 12 for for IN 35772 1018 13 the the DT 35772 1018 14 existence existence NN 35772 1018 15 of of IN 35772 1018 16 a a DT 35772 1018 17 single single JJ 35772 1018 18 and and CC 35772 1018 19 universal universal JJ 35772 1018 20 _ _ NNP 35772 1018 21 law law NN 35772 1018 22 _ _ NNP 35772 1018 23 . . . 35772 1019 1 This this DT 35772 1019 2 unifying unifying JJ 35772 1019 3 principle principle NN 35772 1019 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1019 5 found find VBD 35772 1019 6 in in IN 35772 1019 7 a a DT 35772 1019 8 general general JJ 35772 1019 9 law law NN 35772 1019 10 of of IN 35772 1019 11 evolution evolution NN 35772 1019 12 . . . 35772 1020 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1020 2 formulated formulate VBD 35772 1020 3 this this DT 35772 1020 4 law law NN 35772 1020 5 in in IN 35772 1020 6 language language NN 35772 1020 7 which which WDT 35772 1020 8 is be VBZ 35772 1020 9 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1020 10 less less RBR 35772 1020 11 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1020 12 than than IN 35772 1020 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1020 14 seems seem VBZ 35772 1020 15 , , , 35772 1020 16 and and CC 35772 1020 17 which which WDT 35772 1020 18 practically practically RB 35772 1020 19 amounts amount VBZ 35772 1020 20 to to IN 35772 1020 21 this this DT 35772 1020 22 , , , 35772 1020 23 that that IN 35772 1020 24 there there EX 35772 1020 25 is be VBZ 35772 1020 26 a a DT 35772 1020 27 perpetual perpetual JJ 35772 1020 28 process process NN 35772 1020 29 going go VBG 35772 1020 30 on on RP 35772 1020 31 which which WDT 35772 1020 32 reduces reduce VBZ 35772 1020 33 disorder disorder NN 35772 1020 34 to to TO 35772 1020 35 order order NN 35772 1020 36 , , , 35772 1020 37 undifferentiated undifferentiated JJ 35772 1020 38 sameness sameness RB 35772 1020 39 to to IN 35772 1020 40 specialised specialise VBN 35772 1020 41 variety variety NN 35772 1020 42 . . . 35772 1021 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1021 2 42 42 CD 35772 1021 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1021 4 The the DT 35772 1021 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1021 6 First First NNP 35772 1021 7 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 1021 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1021 9 was be VBD 35772 1021 10 published publish VBN 35772 1021 11 before before IN 35772 1021 12 the the DT 35772 1021 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1021 14 Origin Origin NNP 35772 1021 15 of of IN 35772 1021 16 Species Species NNP 35772 1021 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1021 18 , , , 35772 1021 19 and and CC 35772 1021 20 the the DT 35772 1021 21 confirmation confirmation NN 35772 1021 22 which which WDT 35772 1021 23 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1021 24 's 's POS 35772 1021 25 work work NN 35772 1021 26 supplied supply VBD 35772 1021 27 to to IN 35772 1021 28 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1021 29 's 's POS 35772 1021 30 theory theory NN 35772 1021 31 must must MD 35772 1021 32 have have VB 35772 1021 33 recommended recommend VBN 35772 1021 34 the the DT 35772 1021 35 latter latter JJ 35772 1021 36 to to IN 35772 1021 37 the the DT 35772 1021 38 minds mind NNS 35772 1021 39 of of IN 35772 1021 40 scientifically scientifically RB 35772 1021 41 trained train VBN 35772 1021 42 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1021 43 . . . 35772 1022 1 Moreover moreover RB 35772 1022 2 , , , 35772 1022 3 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1022 4 sanctioned sanction VBD 35772 1022 5 a a DT 35772 1022 6 hopeful hopeful JJ 35772 1022 7 outlook outlook NN 35772 1022 8 ; ; , 35772 1022 9 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 1022 10 optimism optimism NN 35772 1022 11 was be VBD 35772 1022 12 an an DT 35772 1022 13 attractive attractive JJ 35772 1022 14 and and CC 35772 1022 15 an an DT 35772 1022 16 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1022 17 , , , 35772 1022 18 as as RB 35772 1022 19 well well RB 35772 1022 20 as as IN 35772 1022 21 a a DT 35772 1022 22 reasonable reasonable JJ 35772 1022 23 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1022 24 . . . 35772 1023 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1023 2 demanded demand VBD 35772 1023 3 the the DT 35772 1023 4 subordination subordination NN 35772 1023 5 of of IN 35772 1023 6 the the DT 35772 1023 7 individual individual NN 35772 1023 8 to to IN 35772 1023 9 society society NN 35772 1023 10 , , , 35772 1023 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1023 12 urged urge VBD 35772 1023 13 the the DT 35772 1023 14 necessity necessity NN 35772 1023 15 of of IN 35772 1023 16 self self NN 35772 1023 17 - - HYPH 35772 1023 18 discipline discipline NN 35772 1023 19 and and CC 35772 1023 20 of of IN 35772 1023 21 industry industry NN 35772 1023 22 , , , 35772 1023 23 and and CC 35772 1023 24 pointed point VBD 35772 1023 25 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1023 26 if if IN 35772 1023 27 these these DT 35772 1023 28 conditions condition NNS 35772 1023 29 were be VBD 35772 1023 30 fulfilled fulfil VBN 35772 1023 31 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1023 32 to to IN 35772 1023 33 a a DT 35772 1023 34 brighter bright JJR 35772 1023 35 future future NN 35772 1023 36 , , , 35772 1023 37 and and CC 35772 1023 38 to to IN 35772 1023 39 a a DT 35772 1023 40 new new JJ 35772 1023 41 humanity humanity NN 35772 1023 42 . . . 35772 1024 1 The the DT 35772 1024 2 generous generous JJ 35772 1024 3 idealism idealism NN 35772 1024 4 of of IN 35772 1024 5 the the DT 35772 1024 6 following follow VBG 35772 1024 7 passage passage NN 35772 1024 8 is be VBZ 35772 1024 9 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 1024 10 of of IN 35772 1024 11 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1024 12 's 's POS 35772 1024 13 outlook outlook NN 35772 1024 14 , , , 35772 1024 15 and and CC 35772 1024 16 of of IN 35772 1024 17 those those DT 35772 1024 18 who who WP 35772 1024 19 thought think VBD 35772 1024 20 -- -- : 35772 1024 21 and and CC 35772 1024 22 hoped hope VBD 35772 1024 23 -- -- : 35772 1024 24 with with IN 35772 1024 25 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1024 26 ; ; : 35772 1024 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1024 28 occurs occur VBZ 35772 1024 29 at at IN 35772 1024 30 the the DT 35772 1024 31 end end NN 35772 1024 32 of of IN 35772 1024 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1024 34 _ _ NNP 35772 1024 35 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 1024 36 of of IN 35772 1024 37 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 1024 38 _ _ NNP 35772 1024 39 : : : 35772 1024 40 " " `` 35772 1024 41 The the DT 35772 1024 42 highest high JJS 35772 1024 43 ambition ambition NN 35772 1024 44 of of IN 35772 1024 45 the the DT 35772 1024 46 beneficent beneficent NN 35772 1024 47 will will MD 35772 1024 48 be be VB 35772 1024 49 to to TO 35772 1024 50 have have VB 35772 1024 51 a a DT 35772 1024 52 share share NN 35772 1024 53 -- -- : 35772 1024 54 even even RB 35772 1024 55 though though IN 35772 1024 56 an an DT 35772 1024 57 utterly utterly RB 35772 1024 58 inappreciable inappreciable JJ 35772 1024 59 and and CC 35772 1024 60 unknown unknown JJ 35772 1024 61 share share NN 35772 1024 62 -- -- : 35772 1024 63 in in IN 35772 1024 64 ' ' '' 35772 1024 65 the the DT 35772 1024 66 making making NN 35772 1024 67 of of IN 35772 1024 68 Man Man NNP 35772 1024 69 . . . 35772 1024 70 ' ' '' 35772 1024 71 ... ... . 35772 1025 1 As as IN 35772 1025 2 time time NN 35772 1025 3 goes go VBZ 35772 1025 4 on on RP 35772 1025 5 , , , 35772 1025 6 there there EX 35772 1025 7 will will MD 35772 1025 8 be be VB 35772 1025 9 more more RBR 35772 1025 10 and and CC 35772 1025 11 more more JJR 35772 1025 12 of of IN 35772 1025 13 those those DT 35772 1025 14 whose whose WP$ 35772 1025 15 unselfish unselfish JJ 35772 1025 16 end end NN 35772 1025 17 will will MD 35772 1025 18 be be VB 35772 1025 19 the the DT 35772 1025 20 further further JJ 35772 1025 21 evolution evolution NN 35772 1025 22 of of IN 35772 1025 23 Humanity Humanity NNP 35772 1025 24 . . . 35772 1026 1 While while IN 35772 1026 2 contemplating contemplate VBG 35772 1026 3 from from IN 35772 1026 4 the the DT 35772 1026 5 heights height NNS 35772 1026 6 of of IN 35772 1026 7 thought thought NN 35772 1026 8 that that IN 35772 1026 9 far far RB 35772 1026 10 - - HYPH 35772 1026 11 off off RP 35772 1026 12 life life NN 35772 1026 13 of of IN 35772 1026 14 the the DT 35772 1026 15 race race NN 35772 1026 16 never never RB 35772 1026 17 to to TO 35772 1026 18 be be VB 35772 1026 19 enjoyed enjoy VBN 35772 1026 20 by by IN 35772 1026 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1026 22 , , , 35772 1026 23 but but CC 35772 1026 24 only only RB 35772 1026 25 by by IN 35772 1026 26 a a DT 35772 1026 27 remote remote JJ 35772 1026 28 posterity posterity NN 35772 1026 29 , , , 35772 1026 30 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1026 31 will will MD 35772 1026 32 feel feel VB 35772 1026 33 a a DT 35772 1026 34 calm calm JJ 35772 1026 35 pleasure pleasure NN 35772 1026 36 in in IN 35772 1026 37 the the DT 35772 1026 38 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1026 39 of of IN 35772 1026 40 having have VBG 35772 1026 41 aided aid VBN 35772 1026 42 the the DT 35772 1026 43 advance advance NN 35772 1026 44 towards towards IN 35772 1026 45 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1026 46 . . . 35772 1026 47 " " '' 35772 1027 1 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1027 2 , , , 35772 1027 3 then then RB 35772 1027 4 , , , 35772 1027 5 evidently evidently RB 35772 1027 6 deserves deserve VBZ 35772 1027 7 the the DT 35772 1027 8 important important JJ 35772 1027 9 place place NN 35772 1027 10 that that WDT 35772 1027 11 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1027 12 occupies occupy VBZ 35772 1027 13 in in IN 35772 1027 14 the the DT 35772 1027 15 history history NN 35772 1027 16 of of IN 35772 1027 17 thought thought NN 35772 1027 18 . . . 35772 1028 1 For for IN 35772 1028 2 though though IN 35772 1028 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1028 4 was be VBD 35772 1028 5 forced force VBN 35772 1028 6 , , , 35772 1028 7 for for IN 35772 1028 8 lack lack NN 35772 1028 9 of of IN 35772 1028 10 those those DT 35772 1028 11 final final JJ 35772 1028 12 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1028 13 results result NNS 35772 1028 14 which which WDT 35772 1028 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1028 16 vainly vainly RB 35772 1028 17 hoped hope VBD 35772 1028 18 might may MD 35772 1028 19 soon soon RB 35772 1028 20 be be VB 35772 1028 21 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 35772 1028 22 , , , 35772 1028 23 to to TO 35772 1028 24 leave leave VB 35772 1028 25 some some DT 35772 1028 26 vital vital JJ 35772 1028 27 gaps gap NNS 35772 1028 28 in in IN 35772 1028 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1028 30 scheme,[43 scheme,[43 NN 35772 1028 31 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1028 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1028 33 had have VBD 35772 1028 34 made make VBN 35772 1028 35 an an DT 35772 1028 36 imposing imposing JJ 35772 1028 37 attempt attempt NN 35772 1028 38 to to TO 35772 1028 39 systematise systematise VB 35772 1028 40 and and CC 35772 1028 41 unify unify VB 35772 1028 42 all all DT 35772 1028 43 human human JJ 35772 1028 44 experience experience NN 35772 1028 45 . . . 35772 1029 1 And and CC 35772 1029 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1029 3 attempt attempt NN 35772 1029 4 to to TO 35772 1029 5 base base VB 35772 1029 6 an an DT 35772 1029 7 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1029 8 morality morality NN 35772 1029 9 upon upon IN 35772 1029 10 sure sure JJ 35772 1029 11 grounds ground NNS 35772 1029 12 of of IN 35772 1029 13 natural natural JJ 35772 1029 14 science science NN 35772 1029 15 was be VBD 35772 1029 16 valuable valuable JJ 35772 1029 17 and and CC 35772 1029 18 important important JJ 35772 1029 19 . . . 35772 1030 1 SPENCER SPENCER NNP 35772 1030 2 'S 's POS 35772 1030 3 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 35772 1030 4 OF of IN 35772 1030 5 RELIGION.--At RELIGION.--At NNP 35772 1030 6 the the DT 35772 1030 7 same same JJ 35772 1030 8 time time NN 35772 1030 9 , , , 35772 1030 10 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1030 11 could could MD 35772 1030 12 not not RB 35772 1030 13 remain remain VB 35772 1030 14 satisfied satisfied JJ 35772 1030 15 with with IN 35772 1030 16 a a DT 35772 1030 17 mere mere JJ 35772 1030 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1030 19 description description NN 35772 1030 20 _ _ NNP 35772 1030 21 of of IN 35772 1030 22 natural natural JJ 35772 1030 23 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1030 24 , , , 35772 1030 25 however however RB 35772 1030 26 complete complete JJ 35772 1030 27 and and CC 35772 1030 28 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 35772 1030 29 such such JJ 35772 1030 30 description description NN 35772 1030 31 might may MD 35772 1030 32 seem seem VB 35772 1030 33 ; ; : 35772 1030 34 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1030 35 desired desire VBD 35772 1030 36 to to TO 35772 1030 37 offer offer VB 35772 1030 38 , , , 35772 1030 39 besides besides IN 35772 1030 40 this this DT 35772 1030 41 , , , 35772 1030 42 an an DT 35772 1030 43 _ _ NNP 35772 1030 44 explanation explanation NN 35772 1030 45 _ _ XX 35772 1030 46 of of IN 35772 1030 47 these these DT 35772 1030 48 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1030 49 -- -- : 35772 1030 50 how how WRB 35772 1030 51 did do VBD 35772 1030 52 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1030 53 come come VB 35772 1030 54 to to TO 35772 1030 55 be be VB 35772 1030 56 , , , 35772 1030 57 and and CC 35772 1030 58 how how WRB 35772 1030 59 do do VBP 35772 1030 60 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1030 61 continue continue VB 35772 1030 62 to to TO 35772 1030 63 exist exist VB 35772 1030 64 ? ? . 35772 1031 1 To to TO 35772 1031 2 provide provide VB 35772 1031 3 this this DT 35772 1031 4 explanation explanation NN 35772 1031 5 , , , 35772 1031 6 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1031 7 postulated postulate VBD 35772 1031 8 the the DT 35772 1031 9 existence existence NN 35772 1031 10 of of IN 35772 1031 11 an an DT 35772 1031 12 Unknown Unknown NNP 35772 1031 13 Power Power NNP 35772 1031 14 which which WDT 35772 1031 15 is be VBZ 35772 1031 16 at at IN 35772 1031 17 once once RB 35772 1031 18 the the DT 35772 1031 19 origin origin NN 35772 1031 20 and and CC 35772 1031 21 the the DT 35772 1031 22 sustaining sustain VBG 35772 1031 23 ground ground NN 35772 1031 24 of of IN 35772 1031 25 everything everything NN 35772 1031 26 . . . 35772 1032 1 This this DT 35772 1032 2 power power NN 35772 1032 3 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1032 4 regarded regard VBD 35772 1032 5 as as IN 35772 1032 6 lying lie VBG 35772 1032 7 quite quite RB 35772 1032 8 out out IN 35772 1032 9 of of IN 35772 1032 10 range range NN 35772 1032 11 not not RB 35772 1032 12 only only RB 35772 1032 13 of of IN 35772 1032 14 the the DT 35772 1032 15 human human JJ 35772 1032 16 senses sense NNS 35772 1032 17 , , , 35772 1032 18 but but CC 35772 1032 19 of of IN 35772 1032 20 the the DT 35772 1032 21 human human JJ 35772 1032 22 intellect intellect NN 35772 1032 23 . . . 35772 1033 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1033 2 was be VBD 35772 1033 3 not not RB 35772 1033 4 only only RB 35772 1033 5 unknown unknown JJ 35772 1033 6 but but CC 35772 1033 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1033 8 unknowable unknowable JJ 35772 1033 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1033 10 . . . 35772 1034 1 This this DT 35772 1034 2 celebrated celebrated JJ 35772 1034 3 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 1034 4 of of IN 35772 1034 5 the the DT 35772 1034 6 Unknowable Unknowable NNP 35772 1034 7 is be VBZ 35772 1034 8 not not RB 35772 1034 9 the the DT 35772 1034 10 least least RBS 35772 1034 11 interesting interesting JJ 35772 1034 12 or or CC 35772 1034 13 important important JJ 35772 1034 14 part part NN 35772 1034 15 of of IN 35772 1034 16 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1034 17 's 's POS 35772 1034 18 system system NN 35772 1034 19 , , , 35772 1034 20 and and CC 35772 1034 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1034 22 is be VBZ 35772 1034 23 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1034 24 more more JJR 35772 1034 25 germane germane NN 35772 1034 26 than than IN 35772 1034 27 any any DT 35772 1034 28 other other JJ 35772 1034 29 speculation speculation NN 35772 1034 30 of of IN 35772 1034 31 his -PRON- PRP 35772 1034 32 to to IN 35772 1034 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1034 34 present present JJ 35772 1034 35 subject subject NN 35772 1034 36 , , , 35772 1034 37 as as IN 35772 1034 38 this this DT 35772 1034 39 _ _ NNP 35772 1034 40 terra terra NNP 35772 1034 41 incognita incognita NNP 35772 1034 42 _ _ NNP 35772 1034 43 was be VBD 35772 1034 44 allotted allot VBN 35772 1034 45 by by IN 35772 1034 46 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1034 47 to to IN 35772 1034 48 religion religion NN 35772 1034 49 as as IN 35772 1034 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1034 51 peculiar peculiar JJ 35772 1034 52 province province NN 35772 1034 53 . . . 35772 1035 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1035 2 hoped hope VBD 35772 1035 3 that that IN 35772 1035 4 the the DT 35772 1035 5 undisputed undisputed JJ 35772 1035 6 possession possession NN 35772 1035 7 and and CC 35772 1035 8 occupation occupation NN 35772 1035 9 by by IN 35772 1035 10 religion religion NN 35772 1035 11 of of IN 35772 1035 12 this this DT 35772 1035 13 territory territory NN 35772 1035 14 might may MD 35772 1035 15 put put VB 35772 1035 16 an an DT 35772 1035 17 end end NN 35772 1035 18 to to IN 35772 1035 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1035 20 perpetual perpetual JJ 35772 1035 21 conflict conflict NN 35772 1035 22 with with IN 35772 1035 23 science science NN 35772 1035 24 , , , 35772 1035 25 and and CC 35772 1035 26 substitute substitute VB 35772 1035 27 for for IN 35772 1035 28 this this DT 35772 1035 29 a a DT 35772 1035 30 reasonable reasonable JJ 35772 1035 31 , , , 35772 1035 32 if if IN 35772 1035 33 not not RB 35772 1035 34 cordial cordial JJ 35772 1035 35 , , , 35772 1035 36 understanding understanding NN 35772 1035 37 . . . 35772 1036 1 Science science NN 35772 1036 2 might may MD 35772 1036 3 contentedly contentedly RB 35772 1036 4 appropriate appropriate VB 35772 1036 5 the the DT 35772 1036 6 sphere sphere NN 35772 1036 7 of of IN 35772 1036 8 the the DT 35772 1036 9 knowable knowable NN 35772 1036 10 , , , 35772 1036 11 and and CC 35772 1036 12 leave leave VB 35772 1036 13 to to TO 35772 1036 14 religion religion VB 35772 1036 15 the the DT 35772 1036 16 undefined undefined JJ 35772 1036 17 and and CC 35772 1036 18 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1036 19 infinite infinite JJ 35772 1036 20 area area NN 35772 1036 21 of of IN 35772 1036 22 the the DT 35772 1036 23 unknowable unknowable JJ 35772 1036 24 ; ; : 35772 1036 25 and and CC 35772 1036 26 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1036 27 hoped hope VBD 35772 1036 28 this this DT 35772 1036 29 division division NN 35772 1036 30 of of IN 35772 1036 31 labour labour NN 35772 1036 32 would would MD 35772 1036 33 be be VB 35772 1036 34 both both CC 35772 1036 35 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 1036 36 and and CC 35772 1036 37 permanent permanent JJ 35772 1036 38 . . . 35772 1037 1 THE the DT 35772 1037 2 VICTORIAN VICTORIAN NNP 35772 1037 3 AGNOSTICS.--Through agnostics.--through NN 35772 1037 4 this this DT 35772 1037 5 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 1037 6 of of IN 35772 1037 7 the the DT 35772 1037 8 Unknowable Unknowable NNP 35772 1037 9 , , , 35772 1037 10 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1037 11 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1037 12 was be VBD 35772 1037 13 the the DT 35772 1037 14 father father NN 35772 1037 15 of of IN 35772 1037 16 that that DT 35772 1037 17 form form NN 35772 1037 18 of of IN 35772 1037 19 belief belief NN 35772 1037 20 or or CC 35772 1037 21 disbelief disbelief NN 35772 1037 22 which which WDT 35772 1037 23 was be VBD 35772 1037 24 pertinently pertinently RB 35772 1037 25 named name VBN 35772 1037 26 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 1037 27 by by IN 35772 1037 28 the the DT 35772 1037 29 most most RBS 35772 1037 30 celebrated celebrated JJ 35772 1037 31 of of IN 35772 1037 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1037 33 exponents exponent NNS 35772 1037 34 -- -- : 35772 1037 35 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1037 36 . . . 35772 1038 1 This this DT 35772 1038 2 combination combination NN 35772 1038 3 of of IN 35772 1038 4 Positivism positivism NN 35772 1038 5 in in IN 35772 1038 6 science science NN 35772 1038 7 with with IN 35772 1038 8 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 1038 9 in in IN 35772 1038 10 religion religion NN 35772 1038 11 and and CC 35772 1038 12 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1038 13 , , , 35772 1038 14 became become VBD 35772 1038 15 highly highly RB 35772 1038 16 popular popular JJ 35772 1038 17 in in IN 35772 1038 18 a a DT 35772 1038 19 wide wide JJ 35772 1038 20 circle circle NN 35772 1038 21 in in IN 35772 1038 22 England England NNP 35772 1038 23 during during IN 35772 1038 24 the the DT 35772 1038 25 last last JJ 35772 1038 26 third third NN 35772 1038 27 of of IN 35772 1038 28 the the DT 35772 1038 29 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1038 30 century century NN 35772 1038 31 , , , 35772 1038 32 especially especially RB 35772 1038 33 among among IN 35772 1038 34 the the DT 35772 1038 35 scientifically scientifically RB 35772 1038 36 educated educate VBN 35772 1038 37 . . . 35772 1039 1 Leslie Leslie NNP 35772 1039 2 Stephen Stephen NNP 35772 1039 3 , , , 35772 1039 4 with with IN 35772 1039 5 the the DT 35772 1039 6 pride pride NN 35772 1039 7 of of IN 35772 1039 8 a a DT 35772 1039 9 disciple disciple NN 35772 1039 10 and and CC 35772 1039 11 the the DT 35772 1039 12 pardonable pardonable JJ 35772 1039 13 zeal zeal NN 35772 1039 14 of of IN 35772 1039 15 a a DT 35772 1039 16 propagandist propagandist NN 35772 1039 17 , , , 35772 1039 18 claimed claim VBD 35772 1039 19 for for IN 35772 1039 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1039 21 the the DT 35772 1039 22 distinction distinction NN 35772 1039 23 of of IN 35772 1039 24 being be VBG 35772 1039 25 " " `` 35772 1039 26 the the DT 35772 1039 27 religion religion NN 35772 1039 28 of of IN 35772 1039 29 all all DT 35772 1039 30 sensible sensible JJ 35772 1039 31 men man NNS 35772 1039 32 . . . 35772 1039 33 " " '' 35772 1040 1 This this DT 35772 1040 2 austere austere JJ 35772 1040 3 faith faith NN 35772 1040 4 owed owe VBD 35772 1040 5 much much JJ 35772 1040 6 to to IN 35772 1040 7 the the DT 35772 1040 8 qualities quality NNS 35772 1040 9 of of IN 35772 1040 10 those those DT 35772 1040 11 who who WP 35772 1040 12 preached preach VBD 35772 1040 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1040 14 . . . 35772 1041 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1041 2 wide wide JJ 35772 1041 3 culture culture NN 35772 1041 4 , , , 35772 1041 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1041 6 power power NN 35772 1041 7 of of IN 35772 1041 8 literary literary JJ 35772 1041 9 expression,[44 expression,[44 CD 35772 1041 10 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1041 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1041 12 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1041 13 vigour vigour NN 35772 1041 14 , , , 35772 1041 15 and and CC 35772 1041 16 above above IN 35772 1041 17 all all DT 35772 1041 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1041 19 moral moral JJ 35772 1041 20 earnestness earnestness NN 35772 1041 21 and and CC 35772 1041 22 social social JJ 35772 1041 23 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 35772 1041 24 recommended recommend VBD 35772 1041 25 what what WP 35772 1041 26 had have VBD 35772 1041 27 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 1041 28 seemed seem VBN 35772 1041 29 a a DT 35772 1041 30 barren barren JJ 35772 1041 31 and and CC 35772 1041 32 unpromising unpromising JJ 35772 1041 33 creed creed NN 35772 1041 34 . . . 35772 1042 1 The the DT 35772 1042 2 generous generous JJ 35772 1042 3 humanitarian humanitarian JJ 35772 1042 4 sympathies sympathy NNS 35772 1042 5 of of IN 35772 1042 6 Comte Comte NNP 35772 1042 7 supplied supply VBD 35772 1042 8 the the DT 35772 1042 9 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1042 10 elements element NNS 35772 1042 11 without without IN 35772 1042 12 which which WDT 35772 1042 13 no no DT 35772 1042 14 faith faith NN 35772 1042 15 can can MD 35772 1042 16 become become VB 35772 1042 17 popular popular JJ 35772 1042 18 , , , 35772 1042 19 and and CC 35772 1042 20 the the DT 35772 1042 21 apparent apparent JJ 35772 1042 22 stability stability NN 35772 1042 23 of of IN 35772 1042 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1042 25 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1042 26 basis basis NN 35772 1042 27 seemed seem VBD 35772 1042 28 to to IN 35772 1042 29 those those DT 35772 1042 30 impatient impatient NN 35772 1042 31 of of IN 35772 1042 32 speculative speculative JJ 35772 1042 33 doubt doubt NN 35772 1042 34 , , , 35772 1042 35 a a DT 35772 1042 36 great great JJ 35772 1042 37 rock rock NN 35772 1042 38 in in IN 35772 1042 39 a a DT 35772 1042 40 desert desert NN 35772 1042 41 of of IN 35772 1042 42 shifting shift VBG 35772 1042 43 sand sand NN 35772 1042 44 . . . 35772 1043 1 This this DT 35772 1043 2 new new JJ 35772 1043 3 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1043 4 Humanism Humanism NNP 35772 1043 5 had have VBD 35772 1043 6 an an DT 35772 1043 7 immense immense JJ 35772 1043 8 vogue vogue NN 35772 1043 9 , , , 35772 1043 10 and and CC 35772 1043 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1043 12 effects effect NNS 35772 1043 13 upon upon IN 35772 1043 14 national national JJ 35772 1043 15 life life NN 35772 1043 16 were be VBD 35772 1043 17 , , , 35772 1043 18 on on IN 35772 1043 19 the the DT 35772 1043 20 whole whole NN 35772 1043 21 , , , 35772 1043 22 of of IN 35772 1043 23 a a DT 35772 1043 24 quite quite RB 35772 1043 25 healthy healthy JJ 35772 1043 26 character character NN 35772 1043 27 . . . 35772 1044 1 Occasional occasional JJ 35772 1044 2 lapses lapse NNS 35772 1044 3 into into IN 35772 1044 4 intolerance intolerance NN 35772 1044 5 , , , 35772 1044 6 no no RB 35772 1044 7 doubt doubt RB 35772 1044 8 , , , 35772 1044 9 occurred occur VBD 35772 1044 10 ; ; : 35772 1044 11 but but CC 35772 1044 12 much much JJ 35772 1044 13 may may MD 35772 1044 14 be be VB 35772 1044 15 excused excuse VBN 35772 1044 16 in in IN 35772 1044 17 the the DT 35772 1044 18 self self NN 35772 1044 19 - - HYPH 35772 1044 20 confidence confidence NN 35772 1044 21 of of IN 35772 1044 22 a a DT 35772 1044 23 new new JJ 35772 1044 24 faith faith NN 35772 1044 25 , , , 35772 1044 26 not not RB 35772 1044 27 yet yet RB 35772 1044 28 tested test VBN 35772 1044 29 by by IN 35772 1044 30 the the DT 35772 1044 31 experiences experience NNS 35772 1044 32 and and CC 35772 1044 33 the the DT 35772 1044 34 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 1044 35 of of IN 35772 1044 36 years year NNS 35772 1044 37 . . . 35772 1045 1 THEOLOGICAL THEOLOGICAL NNP 35772 1045 2 POLEMICS.--The POLEMICS.--The . 35772 1045 3 attacks attack NNS 35772 1045 4 of of IN 35772 1045 5 orthodox orthodox JJ 35772 1045 6 apologists apologist NNS 35772 1045 7 upon upon IN 35772 1045 8 this this DT 35772 1045 9 new new JJ 35772 1045 10 orientation orientation NN 35772 1045 11 , , , 35772 1045 12 though though IN 35772 1045 13 carried carry VBN 35772 1045 14 through through RB 35772 1045 15 with with IN 35772 1045 16 the the DT 35772 1045 17 best good JJS 35772 1045 18 intentions intention NNS 35772 1045 19 , , , 35772 1045 20 were be VBD 35772 1045 21 too too RB 35772 1045 22 often often RB 35772 1045 23 conducted conduct VBN 35772 1045 24 on on IN 35772 1045 25 mistaken mistaken JJ 35772 1045 26 lines line NNS 35772 1045 27 and and CC 35772 1045 28 certainly certainly RB 35772 1045 29 on on RB 35772 1045 30 too too RB 35772 1045 31 narrow narrow JJ 35772 1045 32 a a DT 35772 1045 33 front front NN 35772 1045 34 . . . 35772 1046 1 A a DT 35772 1046 2 particular particular JJ 35772 1046 3 theory theory NN 35772 1046 4 of of IN 35772 1046 5 scriptural scriptural JJ 35772 1046 6 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 1046 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1046 8 now now RB 35772 1046 9 widely widely RB 35772 1046 10 abandoned abandon VBN 35772 1046 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1046 12 , , , 35772 1046 13 and and CC 35772 1046 14 of of IN 35772 1046 15 the the DT 35772 1046 16 miraculous miraculous JJ 35772 1046 17 , , , 35772 1046 18 seemed seem VBD 35772 1046 19 to to TO 35772 1046 20 obsess obsess VB 35772 1046 21 the the DT 35772 1046 22 controversialists controversialist NNS 35772 1046 23 . . . 35772 1047 1 Nor nor CC 35772 1047 2 were be VBD 35772 1047 3 the the DT 35772 1047 4 Agnostics Agnostics NNPS 35772 1047 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1047 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1047 7 must must MD 35772 1047 8 be be VB 35772 1047 9 confessed confess VBN 35772 1047 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1047 11 any any DT 35772 1047 12 more more RBR 35772 1047 13 alive alive JJ 35772 1047 14 to to IN 35772 1047 15 the the DT 35772 1047 16 real real JJ 35772 1047 17 issues issue NNS 35772 1047 18 . . . 35772 1048 1 Hence hence RB 35772 1048 2 , , , 35772 1048 3 to to IN 35772 1048 4 the the DT 35772 1048 5 modern modern JJ 35772 1048 6 student student NN 35772 1048 7 , , , 35772 1048 8 an an DT 35772 1048 9 oppressive oppressive JJ 35772 1048 10 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 1048 11 of of IN 35772 1048 12 deadness deadness NN 35772 1048 13 and and CC 35772 1048 14 sterility sterility NN 35772 1048 15 seems seem VBZ 35772 1048 16 to to TO 35772 1048 17 brood brood VB 35772 1048 18 over over RP 35772 1048 19 these these DT 35772 1048 20 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 1048 21 but but CC 35772 1048 22 superannuated superannuated JJ 35772 1048 23 polemics polemic NNS 35772 1048 24 ; ; : 35772 1048 25 and and CC 35772 1048 26 hence hence RB 35772 1048 27 the the DT 35772 1048 28 complete complete JJ 35772 1048 29 oblivion oblivion NN 35772 1048 30 into into IN 35772 1048 31 which which WDT 35772 1048 32 this this DT 35772 1048 33 literature literature NN 35772 1048 34 has have VBZ 35772 1048 35 fallen fall VBN 35772 1048 36 . . . 35772 1049 1 The the DT 35772 1049 2 saying saying NN 35772 1049 3 is be VBZ 35772 1049 4 profoundly profoundly RB 35772 1049 5 true true JJ 35772 1049 6 that that IN 35772 1049 7 " " `` 35772 1049 8 nothing nothing NN 35772 1049 9 so so RB 35772 1049 10 quickly quickly RB 35772 1049 11 waxes wax VBZ 35772 1049 12 old old JJ 35772 1049 13 as as IN 35772 1049 14 apologetics apologetic NNS 35772 1049 15 . . . 35772 1049 16 " " '' 35772 1050 1 Even even RB 35772 1050 2 the the DT 35772 1050 3 contributions contribution NNS 35772 1050 4 to to IN 35772 1050 5 the the DT 35772 1050 6 subject subject NN 35772 1050 7 by by IN 35772 1050 8 so so RB 35772 1050 9 accomplished accomplish VBN 35772 1050 10 a a DT 35772 1050 11 journalist journalist NN 35772 1050 12 as as IN 35772 1050 13 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1050 14 -- -- : 35772 1050 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1050 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1050 17 Essays Essays NNP 35772 1050 18 on on IN 35772 1050 19 Science Science NNP 35772 1050 20 and and CC 35772 1050 21 Christian christian JJ 35772 1050 22 Tradition_--can Tradition_--can NNP 35772 1050 23 only only RB 35772 1050 24 be be VB 35772 1050 25 read read VBN 35772 1050 26 by by IN 35772 1050 27 those those DT 35772 1050 28 whom whom WP 35772 1050 29 an an DT 35772 1050 30 almost almost RB 35772 1050 31 Teutonic teutonic JJ 35772 1050 32 industry industry NN 35772 1050 33 characterises characterise NNS 35772 1050 34 . . . 35772 1051 1 Once once RB 35772 1051 2 so so RB 35772 1051 3 eagerly eagerly RB 35772 1051 4 perused peruse VBN 35772 1051 5 and and CC 35772 1051 6 earnestly earnestly RB 35772 1051 7 pondered ponder VBN 35772 1051 8 , , , 35772 1051 9 the the DT 35772 1051 10 controversial controversial JJ 35772 1051 11 literature literature NN 35772 1051 12 of of IN 35772 1051 13 this this DT 35772 1051 14 interesting interesting JJ 35772 1051 15 epoch epoch NN 35772 1051 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1051 17 which which WDT 35772 1051 18 now now RB 35772 1051 19 seems seem VBZ 35772 1051 20 so so RB 35772 1051 21 remote remote JJ 35772 1051 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1051 23 reposes repose VBZ 35772 1051 24 on on IN 35772 1051 25 the the DT 35772 1051 26 higher high JJR 35772 1051 27 shelves shelf NNS 35772 1051 28 of of IN 35772 1051 29 libraries library NNS 35772 1051 30 , , , 35772 1051 31 accumulating accumulate VBG 35772 1051 32 the the DT 35772 1051 33 peaceful peaceful JJ 35772 1051 34 dust dust NN 35772 1051 35 of of IN 35772 1051 36 oblivion oblivion NN 35772 1051 37 . . . 35772 1052 1 These these DT 35772 1052 2 projectiles projectile NNS 35772 1052 3 have have VBP 35772 1052 4 , , , 35772 1052 5 in in IN 35772 1052 6 fact fact NN 35772 1052 7 , , , 35772 1052 8 done do VBN 35772 1052 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1052 10 work work NN 35772 1052 11 , , , 35772 1052 12 and and CC 35772 1052 13 if if IN 35772 1052 14 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1052 15 have have VBP 35772 1052 16 proved prove VBN 35772 1052 17 less less RBR 35772 1052 18 fatal fatal JJ 35772 1052 19 than than IN 35772 1052 20 was be VBD 35772 1052 21 hoped hope VBN 35772 1052 22 by by IN 35772 1052 23 those those DT 35772 1052 24 who who WP 35772 1052 25 launched launch VBD 35772 1052 26 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1052 27 , , , 35772 1052 28 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1052 29 were be VBD 35772 1052 30 dispatched dispatch VBN 35772 1052 31 with with IN 35772 1052 32 good good JJ 35772 1052 33 intentions intention NNS 35772 1052 34 , , , 35772 1052 35 and and CC 35772 1052 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1052 37 explosion explosion NN 35772 1052 38 cleared clear VBD 35772 1052 39 the the DT 35772 1052 40 air air NN 35772 1052 41 . . . 35772 1053 1 The the DT 35772 1053 2 most most RBS 35772 1053 3 effective effective JJ 35772 1053 4 method method NN 35772 1053 5 of of IN 35772 1053 6 attack attack NN 35772 1053 7 would would MD 35772 1053 8 have have VB 35772 1053 9 been be VBN 35772 1053 10 to to TO 35772 1053 11 suggest suggest VB 35772 1053 12 that that IN 35772 1053 13 what what WP 35772 1053 14 was be VBD 35772 1053 15 good good JJ 35772 1053 16 in in IN 35772 1053 17 the the DT 35772 1053 18 new new JJ 35772 1053 19 system system NN 35772 1053 20 was be VBD 35772 1053 21 as as RB 35772 1053 22 old old JJ 35772 1053 23 as as IN 35772 1053 24 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 1053 25 , , , 35772 1053 26 and and CC 35772 1053 27 that that IN 35772 1053 28 the the DT 35772 1053 29 rest rest NN 35772 1053 30 was be VBD 35772 1053 31 disputable disputable JJ 35772 1053 32 science science NN 35772 1053 33 and and CC 35772 1053 34 still still RB 35772 1053 35 more more RBR 35772 1053 36 disputable disputable JJ 35772 1053 37 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1053 38 . . . 35772 1054 1 The the DT 35772 1054 2 latter latter JJ 35772 1054 3 half half NN 35772 1054 4 of of IN 35772 1054 5 this this DT 35772 1054 6 task task NN 35772 1054 7 was be VBD 35772 1054 8 , , , 35772 1054 9 as as IN 35772 1054 10 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1054 11 shall shall MD 35772 1054 12 subsequently subsequently RB 35772 1054 13 find find VB 35772 1054 14 , , , 35772 1054 15 creditably creditably RB 35772 1054 16 performed perform VBN 35772 1054 17 by by IN 35772 1054 18 an an DT 35772 1054 19 important important JJ 35772 1054 20 school school NN 35772 1054 21 of of IN 35772 1054 22 critical critical JJ 35772 1054 23 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1054 24 . . . 35772 1055 1 But but CC 35772 1055 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1055 3 former former JJ 35772 1055 4 half half NN 35772 1055 5 , , , 35772 1055 6 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1056 1 the the DT 35772 1056 2 task task NN 35772 1056 3 of of IN 35772 1056 4 proving prove VBG 35772 1056 5 that that IN 35772 1056 6 what what WP 35772 1056 7 was be VBD 35772 1056 8 valuable valuable JJ 35772 1056 9 in in IN 35772 1056 10 the the DT 35772 1056 11 new new JJ 35772 1056 12 Humanism Humanism NNP 35772 1056 13 , , , 35772 1056 14 was be VBD 35772 1056 15 Christian Christian NNP 35772 1056 16 -- -- : 35772 1056 17 might may MD 35772 1056 18 , , , 35772 1056 19 one one PRP 35772 1056 20 would would MD 35772 1056 21 suppose suppose VB 35772 1056 22 , , , 35772 1056 23 have have VBP 35772 1056 24 been be VBN 35772 1056 25 more more RBR 35772 1056 26 successfully successfully RB 35772 1056 27 performed perform VBN 35772 1056 28 by by IN 35772 1056 29 the the DT 35772 1056 30 official official JJ 35772 1056 31 champions champion NNS 35772 1056 32 of of IN 35772 1056 33 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 35772 1056 34 . . . 35772 1057 1 These these DT 35772 1057 2 might may MD 35772 1057 3 have have VB 35772 1057 4 left leave VBN 35772 1057 5 science science NN 35772 1057 6 to to IN 35772 1057 7 the the DT 35772 1057 8 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1057 9 , , , 35772 1057 10 to to TO 35772 1057 11 have have VB 35772 1057 12 left leave VBN 35772 1057 13 off off RP 35772 1057 14 advertising advertise VBG 35772 1057 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1057 16 own own JJ 35772 1057 17 incompetence incompetence NN 35772 1057 18 in in IN 35772 1057 19 that that DT 35772 1057 20 sphere sphere NN 35772 1057 21 by by IN 35772 1057 22 passages passage NNS 35772 1057 23 of of IN 35772 1057 24 arms arm NNS 35772 1057 25 such such JJ 35772 1057 26 as as IN 35772 1057 27 took take VBD 35772 1057 28 place place NN 35772 1057 29 between between IN 35772 1057 30 Bishop Bishop NNP 35772 1057 31 Wilberforce Wilberforce NNP 35772 1057 32 and and CC 35772 1057 33 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1057 34 at at IN 35772 1057 35 the the DT 35772 1057 36 Oxford Oxford NNP 35772 1057 37 meeting meeting NN 35772 1057 38 of of IN 35772 1057 39 the the DT 35772 1057 40 British British NNP 35772 1057 41 Association Association NNP 35772 1057 42 in in IN 35772 1057 43 1860 1860 CD 35772 1057 44 , , , 35772 1057 45 which which WDT 35772 1057 46 are be VBP 35772 1057 47 never never RB 35772 1057 48 very very RB 35772 1057 49 desirable desirable JJ 35772 1057 50 , , , 35772 1057 51 and and CC 35772 1057 52 always always RB 35772 1057 53 discreditable discreditable JJ 35772 1057 54 to to IN 35772 1057 55 the the DT 35772 1057 56 discomfited discomfited JJ 35772 1057 57 party party NN 35772 1057 58 . . . 35772 1058 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1058 2 45 45 CD 35772 1058 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1058 4 ILLOGICALITY ILLOGICALITY NNP 35772 1058 5 OF of IN 35772 1058 6 NATURALISTIC naturalistic NN 35772 1058 7 IDEALISM.--In IDEALISM.--In NNP 35772 1058 8 point point NN 35772 1058 9 of of IN 35772 1058 10 fact fact NN 35772 1058 11 , , , 35772 1058 12 " " '' 35772 1058 13 the the DT 35772 1058 14 religion religion NN 35772 1058 15 of of IN 35772 1058 16 all all DT 35772 1058 17 sensible sensible JJ 35772 1058 18 men man NNS 35772 1058 19 " " '' 35772 1058 20 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1058 21 in in IN 35772 1058 22 spite spite NN 35772 1058 23 of of IN 35772 1058 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1058 25 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1058 26 weakness weakness NN 35772 1058 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1058 28 was be VBD 35772 1058 29 equivalent equivalent JJ 35772 1058 30 to to IN 35772 1058 31 Christian christian JJ 35772 1058 32 stoicism stoicism NN 35772 1058 33 ; ; : 35772 1058 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1058 35 social social JJ 35772 1058 36 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 35772 1058 37 , , , 35772 1058 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1058 39 humanitarianism humanitarianism NN 35772 1058 40 , , , 35772 1058 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1058 42 conscientious conscientious JJ 35772 1058 43 truthfulness truthfulness NN 35772 1058 44 , , , 35772 1058 45 were be VBD 35772 1058 46 the the DT 35772 1058 47 fruit fruit NN 35772 1058 48 of of IN 35772 1058 49 a a DT 35772 1058 50 stock stock NN 35772 1058 51 grown grow VBN 35772 1058 52 on on IN 35772 1058 53 Christian christian JJ 35772 1058 54 soil soil NN 35772 1058 55 . . . 35772 1059 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1059 2 ethical ethical JJ 35772 1059 3 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 1059 4 were be VBD 35772 1059 5 entirely entirely RB 35772 1059 6 Christian christian JJ 35772 1059 7 , , , 35772 1059 8 nor nor CC 35772 1059 9 were be VBD 35772 1059 10 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1059 11 sanctioned sanction VBN 35772 1059 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1059 13 in in IN 35772 1059 14 spite spite NN 35772 1059 15 of of IN 35772 1059 16 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1059 17 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1059 18 's 's POS 35772 1059 19 elaborate elaborate JJ 35772 1059 20 apologetic apologetic NN 35772 1059 21 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1059 22 by by IN 35772 1059 23 the the DT 35772 1059 24 new new JJ 35772 1059 25 biology biology NN 35772 1059 26 . . . 35772 1060 1 Nietzsche Nietzsche NNP 35772 1060 2 was be VBD 35772 1060 3 a a DT 35772 1060 4 far far RB 35772 1060 5 more more RBR 35772 1060 6 legitimate legitimate JJ 35772 1060 7 child child NN 35772 1060 8 of of IN 35772 1060 9 Darwinism darwinism NN 35772 1060 10 than than IN 35772 1060 11 was be VBD 35772 1060 12 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1060 13 . . . 35772 1061 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 1061 2 , , , 35772 1061 3 towards towards IN 35772 1061 4 the the DT 35772 1061 5 close close NN 35772 1061 6 of of IN 35772 1061 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1061 8 life life NN 35772 1061 9 , , , 35772 1061 10 some some DT 35772 1061 11 doubts doubt NNS 35772 1061 12 invaded invade VBD 35772 1061 13 the the DT 35772 1061 14 mind mind NN 35772 1061 15 of of IN 35772 1061 16 the the DT 35772 1061 17 latter latter JJ 35772 1061 18 , , , 35772 1061 19 and and CC 35772 1061 20 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1061 21 was be VBD 35772 1061 22 constrained constrain VBN 35772 1061 23 by by IN 35772 1061 24 an an DT 35772 1061 25 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1061 26 sincerity sincerity NN 35772 1061 27 which which WDT 35772 1061 28 does do VBZ 35772 1061 29 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1061 30 and and CC 35772 1061 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1061 32 school school NN 35772 1061 33 the the DT 35772 1061 34 highest high JJS 35772 1061 35 credit credit NN 35772 1061 36 , , , 35772 1061 37 to to TO 35772 1061 38 utter utter VB 35772 1061 39 a a DT 35772 1061 40 word word NN 35772 1061 41 of of IN 35772 1061 42 warning warning NN 35772 1061 43 . . . 35772 1062 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1062 2 refer refer VBP 35772 1062 3 to to IN 35772 1062 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1062 5 famous famous JJ 35772 1062 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1062 7 Romanes Romanes NNP 35772 1062 8 Lecture Lecture NNP 35772 1062 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1062 10 of of IN 35772 1062 11 1894 1894 CD 35772 1062 12 . . . 35772 1063 1 The the DT 35772 1063 2 thesis thesis NN 35772 1063 3 of of IN 35772 1063 4 this this DT 35772 1063 5 important important JJ 35772 1063 6 utterance utterance NN 35772 1063 7 was be VBD 35772 1063 8 that that IN 35772 1063 9 the the DT 35772 1063 10 field field NN 35772 1063 11 of of IN 35772 1063 12 human human JJ 35772 1063 13 interests interest NNS 35772 1063 14 is be VBZ 35772 1063 15 a a DT 35772 1063 16 narrow narrow JJ 35772 1063 17 heritage heritage NN 35772 1063 18 carved carve VBN 35772 1063 19 out out RP 35772 1063 20 from from IN 35772 1063 21 a a DT 35772 1063 22 hostile hostile JJ 35772 1063 23 environment environment NN 35772 1063 24 into into IN 35772 1063 25 which which WDT 35772 1063 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1063 27 is be VBZ 35772 1063 28 destined destine VBN 35772 1063 29 one one CD 35772 1063 30 day day NN 35772 1063 31 to to TO 35772 1063 32 relapse relapse VB 35772 1063 33 . . . 35772 1064 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1064 2 is be VBZ 35772 1064 3 a a DT 35772 1064 4 cultivated cultivate VBN 35772 1064 5 garden garden NN 35772 1064 6 with with IN 35772 1064 7 the the DT 35772 1064 8 wilderness wilderness NN 35772 1064 9 all all RB 35772 1064 10 around around RB 35772 1064 11 ; ; : 35772 1064 12 created create VBN 35772 1064 13 only only RB 35772 1064 14 at at IN 35772 1064 15 the the DT 35772 1064 16 cost cost NN 35772 1064 17 of of IN 35772 1064 18 infinite infinite JJ 35772 1064 19 sacrifice sacrifice NN 35772 1064 20 and and CC 35772 1064 21 perpetual perpetual JJ 35772 1064 22 toil toil NN 35772 1064 23 , , , 35772 1064 24 and and CC 35772 1064 25 preserved preserve VBD 35772 1064 26 only only RB 35772 1064 27 with with IN 35772 1064 28 difficulty difficulty NN 35772 1064 29 . . . 35772 1065 1 The the DT 35772 1065 2 implacable implacable JJ 35772 1065 3 jungle jungle NN 35772 1065 4 seeks seek VBZ 35772 1065 5 everywhere everywhere RB 35772 1065 6 to to TO 35772 1065 7 encroach encroach VB 35772 1065 8 on on IN 35772 1065 9 the the DT 35772 1065 10 borders border NNS 35772 1065 11 of of IN 35772 1065 12 the the DT 35772 1065 13 clearing clearing NN 35772 1065 14 , , , 35772 1065 15 whose whose WP$ 35772 1065 16 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 1065 17 engulfment engulfment NN 35772 1065 18 can can MD 35772 1065 19 only only RB 35772 1065 20 be be VB 35772 1065 21 postponed postpone VBN 35772 1065 22 , , , 35772 1065 23 not not RB 35772 1065 24 prevented prevent VBN 35772 1065 25 . . . 35772 1066 1 Two two CD 35772 1066 2 quotations quotation NNS 35772 1066 3 may may MD 35772 1066 4 suffice suffice VB 35772 1066 5 : : : 35772 1066 6 " " `` 35772 1066 7 Let let VB 35772 1066 8 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1066 9 understand understand VB 35772 1066 10 , , , 35772 1066 11 once once RB 35772 1066 12 for for IN 35772 1066 13 all all DT 35772 1066 14 , , , 35772 1066 15 that that IN 35772 1066 16 the the DT 35772 1066 17 ethical ethical JJ 35772 1066 18 progress progress NN 35772 1066 19 of of IN 35772 1066 20 society society NN 35772 1066 21 depends depend VBZ 35772 1066 22 , , , 35772 1066 23 not not RB 35772 1066 24 on on IN 35772 1066 25 imitating imitate VBG 35772 1066 26 the the DT 35772 1066 27 cosmic cosmic JJ 35772 1066 28 process process NN 35772 1066 29 , , , 35772 1066 30 still still RB 35772 1066 31 less less RBR 35772 1066 32 in in IN 35772 1066 33 running run VBG 35772 1066 34 away away RB 35772 1066 35 from from IN 35772 1066 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1066 37 , , , 35772 1066 38 but but CC 35772 1066 39 in in IN 35772 1066 40 combating combat VBG 35772 1066 41 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1066 42 . . . 35772 1066 43 " " '' 35772 1067 1 " " `` 35772 1067 2 The the DT 35772 1067 3 theory theory NN 35772 1067 4 of of IN 35772 1067 5 evolution evolution NN 35772 1067 6 encourages encourage VBZ 35772 1067 7 no no DT 35772 1067 8 millennial millennial JJ 35772 1067 9 expectations expectation NNS 35772 1067 10 . . . 35772 1068 1 If if IN 35772 1068 2 , , , 35772 1068 3 for for IN 35772 1068 4 millions million NNS 35772 1068 5 of of IN 35772 1068 6 years year NNS 35772 1068 7 , , , 35772 1068 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1068 9 globe globe NN 35772 1068 10 has have VBZ 35772 1068 11 taken take VBN 35772 1068 12 the the DT 35772 1068 13 upward upward JJ 35772 1068 14 road road NN 35772 1068 15 , , , 35772 1068 16 yet yet RB 35772 1068 17 , , , 35772 1068 18 sometime sometime RB 35772 1068 19 , , , 35772 1068 20 the the DT 35772 1068 21 summit summit NN 35772 1068 22 will will MD 35772 1068 23 be be VB 35772 1068 24 reached reach VBN 35772 1068 25 , , , 35772 1068 26 and and CC 35772 1068 27 the the DT 35772 1068 28 downward downward JJ 35772 1068 29 route route NN 35772 1068 30 will will MD 35772 1068 31 be be VB 35772 1068 32 commenced commence VBN 35772 1068 33 . . . 35772 1069 1 The the DT 35772 1069 2 most most RBS 35772 1069 3 daring daring JJ 35772 1069 4 imagination imagination NN 35772 1069 5 will will MD 35772 1069 6 hardly hardly RB 35772 1069 7 venture venture VB 35772 1069 8 upon upon IN 35772 1069 9 the the DT 35772 1069 10 suggestion suggestion NN 35772 1069 11 that that IN 35772 1069 12 the the DT 35772 1069 13 power power NN 35772 1069 14 and and CC 35772 1069 15 intelligence intelligence NN 35772 1069 16 of of IN 35772 1069 17 man man NN 35772 1069 18 can can MD 35772 1069 19 ever ever RB 35772 1069 20 arrest arrest VB 35772 1069 21 the the DT 35772 1069 22 procession procession NN 35772 1069 23 of of IN 35772 1069 24 the the DT 35772 1069 25 great great JJ 35772 1069 26 year year NN 35772 1069 27 . . . 35772 1070 1 " " `` 35772 1070 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1070 3 46 46 CD 35772 1070 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1070 5 PESSIMISM.--Coming pessimism.--coming NN 35772 1070 6 , , , 35772 1070 7 as as IN 35772 1070 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1070 9 did do VBD 35772 1070 10 , , , 35772 1070 11 at at IN 35772 1070 12 the the DT 35772 1070 13 end end NN 35772 1070 14 of of IN 35772 1070 15 a a DT 35772 1070 16 generation generation NN 35772 1070 17 of of IN 35772 1070 18 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1070 19 optimism optimism NN 35772 1070 20 , , , 35772 1070 21 this this DT 35772 1070 22 pronouncement pronouncement NN 35772 1070 23 is be VBZ 35772 1070 24 symptomatic symptomatic JJ 35772 1070 25 of of IN 35772 1070 26 a a DT 35772 1070 27 certain certain JJ 35772 1070 28 disillusionment disillusionment NN 35772 1070 29 which which WDT 35772 1070 30 had have VBD 35772 1070 31 already already RB 35772 1070 32 begun begin VBN 35772 1070 33 to to TO 35772 1070 34 mar mar VB 35772 1070 35 the the DT 35772 1070 36 fair fair JJ 35772 1070 37 picture picture NN 35772 1070 38 of of IN 35772 1070 39 Positivist positivist JJ 35772 1070 40 prophecy prophecy NN 35772 1070 41 . . . 35772 1071 1 The the DT 35772 1071 2 human human JJ 35772 1071 3 race race NN 35772 1071 4 seemed seem VBD 35772 1071 5 destined destine VBN 35772 1071 6 to to IN 35772 1071 7 an an DT 35772 1071 8 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 35772 1071 9 future future NN 35772 1071 10 ; ; : 35772 1071 11 the the DT 35772 1071 12 parabola parabola NN 35772 1071 13 of of IN 35772 1071 14 progress progress NN 35772 1071 15 would would MD 35772 1071 16 one one CD 35772 1071 17 day day NN 35772 1071 18 reach reach VB 35772 1071 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1071 20 summit summit NN 35772 1071 21 , , , 35772 1071 22 and and CC 35772 1071 23 the the DT 35772 1071 24 fall fall NN 35772 1071 25 begin begin VB 35772 1071 26 . . . 35772 1072 1 At at IN 35772 1072 2 last last JJ 35772 1072 3 upon upon IN 35772 1072 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1072 5 planet planet NN 35772 1072 6 the the DT 35772 1072 7 episode episode NN 35772 1072 8 of of IN 35772 1072 9 Life Life NNP 35772 1072 10 would would MD 35772 1072 11 pass pass VB 35772 1072 12 , , , 35772 1072 13 and and CC 35772 1072 14 be be VB 35772 1072 15 neither neither CC 35772 1072 16 forgotten forget VBN 35772 1072 17 nor nor CC 35772 1072 18 remembered remember VBN 35772 1072 19 ; ; : 35772 1072 20 the the DT 35772 1072 21 world world NN 35772 1072 22 would would MD 35772 1072 23 sink sink VB 35772 1072 24 into into IN 35772 1072 25 the the DT 35772 1072 26 eternal eternal JJ 35772 1072 27 silence silence NN 35772 1072 28 , , , 35772 1072 29 from from IN 35772 1072 30 which which WDT 35772 1072 31 for for IN 35772 1072 32 one one CD 35772 1072 33 transitory transitory NN 35772 1072 34 and and CC 35772 1072 35 insignificant insignificant JJ 35772 1072 36 moment moment NN 35772 1072 37 , , , 35772 1072 38 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1072 39 had have VBD 35772 1072 40 awakened awaken VBN 35772 1072 41 . . . 35772 1073 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1073 2 47 47 CD 35772 1073 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1073 4 NIETZSCHE.--As NIETZSCHE.--As NNP 35772 1073 5 might may MD 35772 1073 6 have have VB 35772 1073 7 been be VBN 35772 1073 8 expected expect VBN 35772 1073 9 , , , 35772 1073 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1073 11 was be VBD 35772 1073 12 in in IN 35772 1073 13 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1073 14 that that IN 35772 1073 15 the the DT 35772 1073 16 logical logical JJ 35772 1073 17 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1073 18 of of IN 35772 1073 19 a a DT 35772 1073 20 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1073 21 outlook outlook NN 35772 1073 22 were be VBD 35772 1073 23 drawn draw VBN 35772 1073 24 . . . 35772 1074 1 Here here RB 35772 1074 2 , , , 35772 1074 3 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1074 4 pessimism pessimism NN 35772 1074 5 had have VBD 35772 1074 6 already already RB 35772 1074 7 been be VBN 35772 1074 8 introduced introduce VBN 35772 1074 9 by by IN 35772 1074 10 Schopenhauer Schopenhauer NNP 35772 1074 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1074 12 1788 1788 CD 35772 1074 13 - - SYM 35772 1074 14 1860 1860 CD 35772 1074 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1074 16 , , , 35772 1074 17 and and CC 35772 1074 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1074 19 disciple disciple JJ 35772 1074 20 Nietzsche Nietzsche NNP 35772 1074 21 was be VBD 35772 1074 22 not not RB 35772 1074 23 afraid afraid JJ 35772 1074 24 to to TO 35772 1074 25 formulate formulate VB 35772 1074 26 a a DT 35772 1074 27 scheme scheme NN 35772 1074 28 of of IN 35772 1074 29 ethics ethic NNS 35772 1074 30 based base VBN 35772 1074 31 on on IN 35772 1074 32 the the DT 35772 1074 33 conception conception NN 35772 1074 34 of of IN 35772 1074 35 " " `` 35772 1074 36 the the DT 35772 1074 37 survival survival NN 35772 1074 38 of of IN 35772 1074 39 the the DT 35772 1074 40 fittest fit JJS 35772 1074 41 , , , 35772 1074 42 " " '' 35772 1074 43 and and CC 35772 1074 44 equivalent equivalent JJ 35772 1074 45 to to IN 35772 1074 46 an an DT 35772 1074 47 apotheosis apotheosis NN 35772 1074 48 of of IN 35772 1074 49 barbarism barbarism NN 35772 1074 50 . . . 35772 1075 1 The the DT 35772 1075 2 virtues virtue NNS 35772 1075 3 of of IN 35772 1075 4 self self NN 35772 1075 5 - - HYPH 35772 1075 6 assertion assertion NN 35772 1075 7 , , , 35772 1075 8 ruthlessness ruthlessness NN 35772 1075 9 , , , 35772 1075 10 and and CC 35772 1075 11 pride pride NN 35772 1075 12 were be VBD 35772 1075 13 to to TO 35772 1075 14 eradicate eradicate VB 35772 1075 15 the the DT 35772 1075 16 vices vice NNS 35772 1075 17 of of IN 35772 1075 18 abnegation abnegation NN 35772 1075 19 , , , 35772 1075 20 pity pity NN 35772 1075 21 , , , 35772 1075 22 and and CC 35772 1075 23 humility humility NN 35772 1075 24 . . . 35772 1076 1 Christian christian JJ 35772 1076 2 morality morality NN 35772 1076 3 was be VBD 35772 1076 4 a a DT 35772 1076 5 disease disease NN 35772 1076 6 ; ; : 35772 1076 7 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 1076 8 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1076 9 was be VBD 35772 1076 10 the the DT 35772 1076 11 appropriate appropriate JJ 35772 1076 12 product product NN 35772 1076 13 of of IN 35772 1076 14 the the DT 35772 1076 15 degenerate degenerate NN 35772 1076 16 epoch epoch NN 35772 1076 17 , , , 35772 1076 18 and and CC 35772 1076 19 of of IN 35772 1076 20 the the DT 35772 1076 21 loathsome loathsome JJ 35772 1076 22 environment environment NN 35772 1076 23 that that WDT 35772 1076 24 gave give VBD 35772 1076 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1076 26 birth birth NN 35772 1076 27 . . . 35772 1077 1 This this DT 35772 1077 2 radical radical JJ 35772 1077 3 thinker thinker NN 35772 1077 4 , , , 35772 1077 5 free free JJ 35772 1077 6 from from IN 35772 1077 7 English English NNP 35772 1077 8 " " '' 35772 1077 9 compromise compromise NN 35772 1077 10 , , , 35772 1077 11 " " '' 35772 1077 12 could could MD 35772 1077 13 be be VB 35772 1077 14 satisfied satisfied JJ 35772 1077 15 with with IN 35772 1077 16 no no DT 35772 1077 17 morality morality NN 35772 1077 18 which which WDT 35772 1077 19 was be VBD 35772 1077 20 parasitic parasitic JJ 35772 1077 21 upon upon IN 35772 1077 22 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 1077 23 . . . 35772 1078 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1078 2 had have VBD 35772 1078 3 clearness clearness NN 35772 1078 4 of of IN 35772 1078 5 vision vision NN 35772 1078 6 to to TO 35772 1078 7 see see VB 35772 1078 8 whither whither CC 35772 1078 9 the the DT 35772 1078 10 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1078 11 road road NN 35772 1078 12 would would MD 35772 1078 13 carry carry VB 35772 1078 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1078 15 pious pious JJ 35772 1078 16 wayfarers wayfarer NNS 35772 1078 17 . . . 35772 1079 1 To to IN 35772 1079 2 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1079 3 the the DT 35772 1079 4 moral moral JJ 35772 1079 5 idealism idealism NN 35772 1079 6 of of IN 35772 1079 7 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1079 8 was be VBD 35772 1079 9 moonshine moonshine NN 35772 1079 10 or or CC 35772 1079 11 stupidity--"the stupidity--"the DT 35772 1079 12 milk milk NN 35772 1079 13 of of IN 35772 1079 14 pious pious JJ 35772 1079 15 sentiment sentiment NN 35772 1079 16 . . . 35772 1079 17 " " '' 35772 1080 1 SIGNIFICANCE significance NN 35772 1080 2 OF of IN 35772 1080 3 NIETZSCHE.--Nietzsche NIETZSCHE.--Nietzsche NNP 35772 1080 4 has have VBZ 35772 1080 5 come come VBN 35772 1080 6 in in RP 35772 1080 7 for for IN 35772 1080 8 a a DT 35772 1080 9 fair fair JJ 35772 1080 10 share share NN 35772 1080 11 of of IN 35772 1080 12 abuse abuse NN 35772 1080 13 , , , 35772 1080 14 but but CC 35772 1080 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1080 16 is be VBZ 35772 1080 17 only only RB 35772 1080 18 just just RB 35772 1080 19 to to TO 35772 1080 20 say say VB 35772 1080 21 that that DT 35772 1080 22 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1080 23 stands stand VBZ 35772 1080 24 heavily heavily RB 35772 1080 25 endebted endebted JJ 35772 1080 26 to to IN 35772 1080 27 this this DT 35772 1080 28 thinker thinker NN 35772 1080 29 . . . 35772 1081 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1081 2 was be VBD 35772 1081 3 not not RB 35772 1081 4 afraid afraid JJ 35772 1081 5 to to TO 35772 1081 6 draw draw VB 35772 1081 7 logical logical JJ 35772 1081 8 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1081 9 , , , 35772 1081 10 and and CC 35772 1081 11 to to TO 35772 1081 12 put put VB 35772 1081 13 questions question NNS 35772 1081 14 which which WDT 35772 1081 15 more more JJR 35772 1081 16 conventional conventional JJ 35772 1081 17 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1081 18 had have VBD 35772 1081 19 preferred prefer VBN 35772 1081 20 should should MD 35772 1081 21 remain remain VB 35772 1081 22 in in IN 35772 1081 23 the the DT 35772 1081 24 background background NN 35772 1081 25 . . . 35772 1082 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1082 2 is be VBZ 35772 1082 3 well well RB 35772 1082 4 for for IN 35772 1082 5 a a DT 35772 1082 6 moralist moralist NN 35772 1082 7 to to TO 35772 1082 8 arise arise VB 35772 1082 9 , , , 35772 1082 10 once once RB 35772 1082 11 in in IN 35772 1082 12 a a DT 35772 1082 13 generation generation NN 35772 1082 14 , , , 35772 1082 15 who who WP 35772 1082 16 will will MD 35772 1082 17 clear clear VB 35772 1082 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1082 19 own own JJ 35772 1082 20 mind mind NN 35772 1082 21 of of IN 35772 1082 22 ca can MD 35772 1082 23 nt not RB 35772 1082 24 and and CC 35772 1082 25 , , , 35772 1082 26 without without IN 35772 1082 27 undue undue JJ 35772 1082 28 respect respect NN 35772 1082 29 for for IN 35772 1082 30 the the DT 35772 1082 31 conventions convention NNS 35772 1082 32 , , , 35772 1082 33 approach approach VB 35772 1082 34 the the DT 35772 1082 35 really really RB 35772 1082 36 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1082 37 questions question NNS 35772 1082 38 in in IN 35772 1082 39 a a DT 35772 1082 40 spirit spirit NN 35772 1082 41 of of IN 35772 1082 42 sincerity sincerity NN 35772 1082 43 . . . 35772 1083 1 The the DT 35772 1083 2 extravagant extravagant JJ 35772 1083 3 impieties impiety NNS 35772 1083 4 of of IN 35772 1083 5 Nietzsche Nietzsche NNP 35772 1083 6 may may MD 35772 1083 7 have have VB 35772 1083 8 shocked shock VBN 35772 1083 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1083 10 hearers hearer NNS 35772 1083 11 , , , 35772 1083 12 but but CC 35772 1083 13 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1083 14 have have VBP 35772 1083 15 cleared clear VBN 35772 1083 16 the the DT 35772 1083 17 air air NN 35772 1083 18 . . . 35772 1084 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1084 2 exposed expose VBD 35772 1084 3 , , , 35772 1084 4 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1084 5 with with IN 35772 1084 6 too too RB 35772 1084 7 little little JJ 35772 1084 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1084 9 finesse finesse NN 35772 1084 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1084 11 , , , 35772 1084 12 the the DT 35772 1084 13 nakedness nakedness NN 35772 1084 14 of of IN 35772 1084 15 Naturalism Naturalism NNP 35772 1084 16 , , , 35772 1084 17 and and CC 35772 1084 18 tore tear VBD 35772 1084 19 off off RP 35772 1084 20 that that DT 35772 1084 21 mantle mantle NN 35772 1084 22 of of IN 35772 1084 23 idealism idealism NN 35772 1084 24 under under IN 35772 1084 25 which which WDT 35772 1084 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1084 27 had have VBD 35772 1084 28 been be VBN 35772 1084 29 masquerading masquerade VBG 35772 1084 30 . . . 35772 1085 1 And and CC 35772 1085 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1085 3 may may MD 35772 1085 4 be be VB 35772 1085 5 said say VBN 35772 1085 6 , , , 35772 1085 7 by by IN 35772 1085 8 so so RB 35772 1085 9 doing do VBG 35772 1085 10 , , , 35772 1085 11 to to TO 35772 1085 12 have have VB 35772 1085 13 written write VBN 35772 1085 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1085 15 finis finis NNP 35772 1085 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1085 17 at at IN 35772 1085 18 the the DT 35772 1085 19 foot foot NN 35772 1085 20 of of IN 35772 1085 21 a a DT 35772 1085 22 chapter chapter NN 35772 1085 23 in in IN 35772 1085 24 the the DT 35772 1085 25 history history NN 35772 1085 26 of of IN 35772 1085 27 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1085 28 . . . 35772 1086 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 1086 2 X X NNP 35772 1086 3 REACTIONS reaction NNS 35772 1086 4 IN in IN 35772 1086 5 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 35772 1086 6 VICISSITUDES vicissitudes NN 35772 1086 7 OF of IN 35772 1086 8 IDEALISM.--At idealism.--at NN 35772 1086 9 the the DT 35772 1086 10 beginning beginning NN 35772 1086 11 of of IN 35772 1086 12 the the DT 35772 1086 13 last last JJ 35772 1086 14 chapter chapter NN 35772 1086 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1086 16 noticed notice VBD 35772 1086 17 the the DT 35772 1086 18 early early JJ 35772 1086 19 collapse collapse NN 35772 1086 20 of of IN 35772 1086 21 idealism idealism NN 35772 1086 22 in in IN 35772 1086 23 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1086 24 . . . 35772 1087 1 But but CC 35772 1087 2 the the DT 35772 1087 3 prophets prophet NNS 35772 1087 4 of of IN 35772 1087 5 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 1087 6 , , , 35772 1087 7 when when WRB 35772 1087 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1087 9 were be VBD 35772 1087 10 no no RB 35772 1087 11 longer long RBR 35772 1087 12 honoured honour VBN 35772 1087 13 at at IN 35772 1087 14 home home NN 35772 1087 15 , , , 35772 1087 16 found find VBD 35772 1087 17 an an DT 35772 1087 18 hospitable hospitable JJ 35772 1087 19 reception reception NN 35772 1087 20 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1087 21 , , , 35772 1087 22 and and CC 35772 1087 23 especially especially RB 35772 1087 24 in in IN 35772 1087 25 England England NNP 35772 1087 26 . . . 35772 1088 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 1088 2 , , , 35772 1088 3 even even RB 35772 1088 4 before before IN 35772 1088 5 the the DT 35772 1088 6 prestige prestige NN 35772 1088 7 of of IN 35772 1088 8 idealism idealism NN 35772 1088 9 had have VBD 35772 1088 10 begun begin VBN 35772 1088 11 to to TO 35772 1088 12 decline decline VB 35772 1088 13 in in IN 35772 1088 14 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1088 15 , , , 35772 1088 16 Englishmen Englishmen NNP 35772 1088 17 had have VBD 35772 1088 18 been be VBN 35772 1088 19 introduced introduce VBN 35772 1088 20 to to IN 35772 1088 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1088 22 by by IN 35772 1088 23 the the DT 35772 1088 24 writings writing NNS 35772 1088 25 and and CC 35772 1088 26 translations translation NNS 35772 1088 27 of of IN 35772 1088 28 S. S. NNP 35772 1088 29 T. T. NNP 35772 1088 30 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1088 31 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1088 32 1772 1772 CD 35772 1088 33 - - SYM 35772 1088 34 1834 1834 CD 35772 1088 35 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1088 36 and and CC 35772 1088 37 Thomas Thomas NNP 35772 1088 38 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1088 39 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1088 40 1795 1795 CD 35772 1088 41 - - SYM 35772 1088 42 1881 1881 CD 35772 1088 43 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1088 44 . . . 35772 1089 1 These these DT 35772 1089 2 two two CD 35772 1089 3 popularisers populariser NNS 35772 1089 4 of of IN 35772 1089 5 German german JJ 35772 1089 6 ideas idea NNS 35772 1089 7 were be VBD 35772 1089 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1089 9 littérateurs littérateur NNS 35772 1089 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1089 11 rather rather RB 35772 1089 12 than than IN 35772 1089 13 professional professional JJ 35772 1089 14 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1089 15 , , , 35772 1089 16 but but CC 35772 1089 17 for for IN 35772 1089 18 that that DT 35772 1089 19 very very JJ 35772 1089 20 reason reason NN 35772 1089 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1089 22 vogue vogue NN 35772 1089 23 and and CC 35772 1089 24 influence influence NN 35772 1089 25 were be VBD 35772 1089 26 the the DT 35772 1089 27 wider wide JJR 35772 1089 28 . . . 35772 1090 1 COLERIDGE.--Coleridge COLERIDGE.--Coleridge NNP 35772 1090 2 was be VBD 35772 1090 3 in in IN 35772 1090 4 spirit spirit NN 35772 1090 5 a a DT 35772 1090 6 genuine genuine JJ 35772 1090 7 Romanticist Romanticist NNP 35772 1090 8 ; ; : 35772 1090 9 being be VBG 35772 1090 10 , , , 35772 1090 11 as as IN 35772 1090 12 were be VBD 35772 1090 13 some some DT 35772 1090 14 of of IN 35772 1090 15 the the DT 35772 1090 16 most most RBS 35772 1090 17 notable notable JJ 35772 1090 18 of of IN 35772 1090 19 the the DT 35772 1090 20 German german JJ 35772 1090 21 school school NN 35772 1090 22 -- -- : 35772 1090 23 e.g e.g NNP 35772 1090 24 . . NNP 35772 1090 25 , , , 35772 1090 26 Goethe Goethe NNP 35772 1090 27 and and CC 35772 1090 28 Schiller Schiller NNP 35772 1090 29 -- -- : 35772 1090 30 a a DT 35772 1090 31 poet poet NN 35772 1090 32 as as RB 35772 1090 33 well well RB 35772 1090 34 as as IN 35772 1090 35 a a DT 35772 1090 36 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 1090 37 . . . 35772 1091 1 In in IN 35772 1091 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1091 3 _ _ NNP 35772 1091 4 Biographia Biographia NNP 35772 1091 5 Literaria Literaria NNP 35772 1091 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1091 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1091 8 has have VBZ 35772 1091 9 left leave VBN 35772 1091 10 behind behind IN 35772 1091 11 the the DT 35772 1091 12 story story NN 35772 1091 13 of of IN 35772 1091 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1091 15 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1091 16 and and CC 35772 1091 17 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1091 18 development development NN 35772 1091 19 . . . 35772 1092 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1092 2 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 35772 1092 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1092 4 debt debt NN 35772 1092 5 to to IN 35772 1092 6 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1092 7 , , , 35772 1092 8 to to IN 35772 1092 9 the the DT 35772 1092 10 Romanticists Romanticists NNPS 35772 1092 11 , , , 35772 1092 12 and and CC 35772 1092 13 in in IN 35772 1092 14 particular particular JJ 35772 1092 15 to to IN 35772 1092 16 Schelling Schelling NNP 35772 1092 17 , , , 35772 1092 18 whose whose WP$ 35772 1092 19 " " `` 35772 1092 20 intuitionism intuitionism NN 35772 1092 21 " " '' 35772 1092 22 was be VBD 35772 1092 23 naturally naturally RB 35772 1092 24 congenial congenial JJ 35772 1092 25 to to IN 35772 1092 26 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1092 27 . . . 35772 1093 1 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1093 2 was be VBD 35772 1093 3 never never RB 35772 1093 4 able able JJ 35772 1093 5 to to TO 35772 1093 6 embody embody VB 35772 1093 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1093 8 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1093 9 creed creed NN 35772 1093 10 in in IN 35772 1093 11 any any DT 35772 1093 12 single single JJ 35772 1093 13 work work NN 35772 1093 14 ; ; : 35772 1093 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1093 16 does do VBZ 35772 1093 17 not not RB 35772 1093 18 seem seem VB 35772 1093 19 to to TO 35772 1093 20 have have VB 35772 1093 21 possessed possess VBN 35772 1093 22 the the DT 35772 1093 23 necessary necessary JJ 35772 1093 24 power power NN 35772 1093 25 of of IN 35772 1093 26 application application NN 35772 1093 27 . . . 35772 1094 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1094 2 was be VBD 35772 1094 3 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 35772 1094 4 in in IN 35772 1094 5 being be VBG 35772 1094 6 a a DT 35772 1094 7 man man NN 35772 1094 8 of of IN 35772 1094 9 weak weak JJ 35772 1094 10 character character NN 35772 1094 11 , , , 35772 1094 12 and and CC 35772 1094 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1094 14 ineffectiveness ineffectiveness NN 35772 1094 15 struck strike VBD 35772 1094 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1094 17 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 1094 18 . . . 35772 1095 1 But but CC 35772 1095 2 in in IN 35772 1095 3 spite spite NN 35772 1095 4 of of IN 35772 1095 5 these these DT 35772 1095 6 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 35772 1095 7 -- -- : 35772 1095 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1095 9 sentimentality sentimentality NN 35772 1095 10 , , , 35772 1095 11 the the DT 35772 1095 12 lack lack NN 35772 1095 13 of of IN 35772 1095 14 clearness clearness NN 35772 1095 15 of of IN 35772 1095 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1095 17 thought thought NN 35772 1095 18 , , , 35772 1095 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1095 20 weakness weakness NN 35772 1095 21 for for IN 35772 1095 22 opium opium NN 35772 1095 23 -- -- : 35772 1095 24 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1095 25 certainly certainly RB 35772 1095 26 exercised exercise VBD 35772 1095 27 an an DT 35772 1095 28 important important JJ 35772 1095 29 influence influence NN 35772 1095 30 , , , 35772 1095 31 especially especially RB 35772 1095 32 in in IN 35772 1095 33 the the DT 35772 1095 34 realm realm NN 35772 1095 35 of of IN 35772 1095 36 theology theology NN 35772 1095 37 . . . 35772 1096 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1096 2 ideas idea NNS 35772 1096 3 , , , 35772 1096 4 though though IN 35772 1096 5 vague vague JJ 35772 1096 6 , , , 35772 1096 7 were be VBD 35772 1096 8 calculated calculate VBN 35772 1096 9 to to TO 35772 1096 10 awaken awaken VB 35772 1096 11 the the DT 35772 1096 12 speculative speculative JJ 35772 1096 13 habit habit NN 35772 1096 14 , , , 35772 1096 15 and and CC 35772 1096 16 , , , 35772 1096 17 introduced introduce VBN 35772 1096 18 as as IN 35772 1096 19 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1096 20 were be VBD 35772 1096 21 , , , 35772 1096 22 to to IN 35772 1096 23 a a DT 35772 1096 24 wide wide JJ 35772 1096 25 circle circle NN 35772 1096 26 , , , 35772 1096 27 were be VBD 35772 1096 28 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 1096 29 and and CC 35772 1096 30 stimulating stimulating JJ 35772 1096 31 . . . 35772 1097 1 English English NNP 35772 1097 2 theology theology NN 35772 1097 3 had have VBD 35772 1097 4 been be VBN 35772 1097 5 , , , 35772 1097 6 in in IN 35772 1097 7 the the DT 35772 1097 8 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 1097 9 century century NN 35772 1097 10 , , , 35772 1097 11 of of IN 35772 1097 12 an an DT 35772 1097 13 arid arid NN 35772 1097 14 kind kind NN 35772 1097 15 , , , 35772 1097 16 and and CC 35772 1097 17 the the DT 35772 1097 18 English english JJ 35772 1097 19 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1097 20 tradition tradition NN 35772 1097 21 lacked lack VBD 35772 1097 22 , , , 35772 1097 23 for for IN 35772 1097 24 the the DT 35772 1097 25 most most JJS 35772 1097 26 part part NN 35772 1097 27 , , , 35772 1097 28 appreciation appreciation NN 35772 1097 29 of of IN 35772 1097 30 those those DT 35772 1097 31 deeper deep JJR 35772 1097 32 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1097 33 of of IN 35772 1097 34 reality reality NN 35772 1097 35 which which WDT 35772 1097 36 had have VBD 35772 1097 37 appealed appeal VBN 35772 1097 38 to to IN 35772 1097 39 German german JJ 35772 1097 40 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1097 41 . . . 35772 1098 1 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1098 2 , , , 35772 1098 3 by by IN 35772 1098 4 introducing introduce VBG 35772 1098 5 German german JJ 35772 1098 6 speculation speculation NN 35772 1098 7 to to IN 35772 1098 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1098 9 countrymen countryman NNS 35772 1098 10 , , , 35772 1098 11 was be VBD 35772 1098 12 able able JJ 35772 1098 13 " " '' 35772 1098 14 to to TO 35772 1098 15 free free JJ 35772 1098 16 theology theology NN 35772 1098 17 of of IN 35772 1098 18 some some DT 35772 1098 19 of of IN 35772 1098 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1098 21 narrowness narrowness NN 35772 1098 22 , , , 35772 1098 23 and and CC 35772 1098 24 to to TO 35772 1098 25 deepen deepen VB 35772 1098 26 and and CC 35772 1098 27 enlarge enlarge VB 35772 1098 28 the the DT 35772 1098 29 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1098 30 outlook outlook NN 35772 1098 31 of of IN 35772 1098 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1098 33 age age NN 35772 1098 34 . . . 35772 1099 1 " " `` 35772 1099 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1099 3 48 48 CD 35772 1099 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1099 5 THOMAS THOMAS NNP 35772 1099 6 CARLYLE.--Carlyle CARLYLE.--Carlyle NNP 35772 1099 7 was be VBD 35772 1099 8 a a DT 35772 1099 9 man man NN 35772 1099 10 of of IN 35772 1099 11 a a DT 35772 1099 12 very very RB 35772 1099 13 different different JJ 35772 1099 14 temper temper NN 35772 1099 15 , , , 35772 1099 16 whose whose WP$ 35772 1099 17 attitude attitude NN 35772 1099 18 towards towards IN 35772 1099 19 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1099 20 was be VBD 35772 1099 21 " " `` 35772 1099 22 half half RB 35772 1099 23 contemptuous contemptuous JJ 35772 1099 24 , , , 35772 1099 25 half half RB 35772 1099 26 compassionate compassionate JJ 35772 1099 27 . . . 35772 1099 28 " " '' 35772 1100 1 A a DT 35772 1100 2 typically typically RB 35772 1100 3 Carlylean carlylean JJ 35772 1100 4 characterisation characterisation NN 35772 1100 5 of of IN 35772 1100 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1100 7 may may MD 35772 1100 8 be be VB 35772 1100 9 found find VBN 35772 1100 10 in in IN 35772 1100 11 the the DT 35772 1100 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1100 13 Life Life NNP 35772 1100 14 of of IN 35772 1100 15 Sterling Sterling NNP 35772 1100 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1100 17 : : : 35772 1100 18 " " `` 35772 1100 19 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1100 20 was be VBD 35772 1100 21 thought think VBN 35772 1100 22 to to TO 35772 1100 23 hold hold VB 35772 1100 24 -- -- : 35772 1100 25 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1100 26 alone alone RB 35772 1100 27 in in IN 35772 1100 28 England England NNP 35772 1100 29 -- -- : 35772 1100 30 the the DT 35772 1100 31 key key NN 35772 1100 32 of of IN 35772 1100 33 German german JJ 35772 1100 34 and and CC 35772 1100 35 other other JJ 35772 1100 36 Transcendentalisms transcendentalism NNS 35772 1100 37 .... .... . 35772 1100 38 A a DT 35772 1100 39 sublime sublime JJ 35772 1100 40 man man NN 35772 1100 41 , , , 35772 1100 42 who who WP 35772 1100 43 alone alone RB 35772 1100 44 in in IN 35772 1100 45 those those DT 35772 1100 46 dark dark JJ 35772 1100 47 days day NNS 35772 1100 48 escaped escape VBN 35772 1100 49 from from IN 35772 1100 50 black black JJ 35772 1100 51 materialisms materialism NNS 35772 1100 52 and and CC 35772 1100 53 revolutionary revolutionary JJ 35772 1100 54 deluges deluge NNS 35772 1100 55 with with IN 35772 1100 56 God God NNP 35772 1100 57 , , , 35772 1100 58 Freedom Freedom NNP 35772 1100 59 , , , 35772 1100 60 Immortality Immortality NNP 35772 1100 61 , , , 35772 1100 62 still still RB 35772 1100 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1100 64 . . . 35772 1101 1 The the DT 35772 1101 2 practical practical JJ 35772 1101 3 intellects intellect NNS 35772 1101 4 of of IN 35772 1101 5 the the DT 35772 1101 6 world world NN 35772 1101 7 did do VBD 35772 1101 8 not not RB 35772 1101 9 much much RB 35772 1101 10 heed heed VB 35772 1101 11 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1101 12 , , , 35772 1101 13 or or CC 35772 1101 14 carelessly carelessly RB 35772 1101 15 reckoned reckon VBD 35772 1101 16 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1101 17 a a DT 35772 1101 18 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 35772 1101 19 dreamer dreamer NN 35772 1101 20 ; ; : 35772 1101 21 but but CC 35772 1101 22 to to IN 35772 1101 23 the the DT 35772 1101 24 rising rise VBG 35772 1101 25 spirits spirit NNS 35772 1101 26 of of IN 35772 1101 27 the the DT 35772 1101 28 young young JJ 35772 1101 29 generation generation NN 35772 1101 30 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1101 31 sat sit VBD 35772 1101 32 there there RB 35772 1101 33 as as IN 35772 1101 34 a a DT 35772 1101 35 kind kind NN 35772 1101 36 of of IN 35772 1101 37 Magus Magus NNP 35772 1101 38 , , , 35772 1101 39 girt girt NN 35772 1101 40 in in IN 35772 1101 41 mystery mystery NN 35772 1101 42 and and CC 35772 1101 43 enigma enigma NNP 35772 1101 44 .... .... NFP 35772 1101 45 " " '' 35772 1101 46 " " `` 35772 1101 47 The the DT 35772 1101 48 good good JJ 35772 1101 49 man man NN 35772 1101 50 ... ... NFP 35772 1101 51 gave give VBD 35772 1101 52 you -PRON- PRP 35772 1101 53 the the DT 35772 1101 54 idea idea NN 35772 1101 55 of of IN 35772 1101 56 a a DT 35772 1101 57 life life NN 35772 1101 58 that that WDT 35772 1101 59 had have VBD 35772 1101 60 been be VBN 35772 1101 61 full full JJ 35772 1101 62 of of IN 35772 1101 63 sufferings suffering NNS 35772 1101 64 ... ... NFP 35772 1101 65 the the DT 35772 1101 66 deep deep JJ 35772 1101 67 eyes eye NNS 35772 1101 68 , , , 35772 1101 69 of of IN 35772 1101 70 a a DT 35772 1101 71 light light JJ 35772 1101 72 hazel hazel NN 35772 1101 73 , , , 35772 1101 74 were be VBD 35772 1101 75 as as RB 35772 1101 76 full full JJ 35772 1101 77 of of IN 35772 1101 78 sorrow sorrow NN 35772 1101 79 as as IN 35772 1101 80 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 1101 81 ; ; , 35772 1101 82 confused confused JJ 35772 1101 83 pain pain NN 35772 1101 84 looked look VBD 35772 1101 85 mildly mildly RB 35772 1101 86 from from IN 35772 1101 87 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1101 88 , , , 35772 1101 89 as as IN 35772 1101 90 in in IN 35772 1101 91 a a DT 35772 1101 92 kind kind NN 35772 1101 93 of of IN 35772 1101 94 mild mild JJ 35772 1101 95 astonishment astonishment NN 35772 1101 96 . . . 35772 1102 1 The the DT 35772 1102 2 whole whole JJ 35772 1102 3 figure figure NN 35772 1102 4 and and CC 35772 1102 5 air air NN 35772 1102 6 , , , 35772 1102 7 good good JJ 35772 1102 8 and and CC 35772 1102 9 amiable amiable JJ 35772 1102 10 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 1102 11 , , , 35772 1102 12 might may MD 35772 1102 13 be be VB 35772 1102 14 called call VBN 35772 1102 15 flabby flabby NN 35772 1102 16 and and CC 35772 1102 17 irresolute irresolute NN 35772 1102 18 ; ; : 35772 1102 19 expressive expressive JJ 35772 1102 20 of of IN 35772 1102 21 weakness weakness NN 35772 1102 22 under under IN 35772 1102 23 possibility possibility NN 35772 1102 24 of of IN 35772 1102 25 strength strength NN 35772 1102 26 .... .... . 35772 1103 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1103 2 spoke speak VBD 35772 1103 3 as as IN 35772 1103 4 if if IN 35772 1103 5 preaching preaching NN 35772 1103 6 -- -- : 35772 1103 7 preaching preach VBG 35772 1103 8 earnestly earnestly RB 35772 1103 9 and and CC 35772 1103 10 hopelessly hopelessly RB 35772 1103 11 the the DT 35772 1103 12 weightiest weighty JJS 35772 1103 13 things thing NNS 35772 1103 14 . . . 35772 1103 15 " " '' 35772 1104 1 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1104 2 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1104 3 had have VBD 35772 1104 4 all all PDT 35772 1104 5 the the DT 35772 1104 6 character character NN 35772 1104 7 and and CC 35772 1104 8 industry industry NN 35772 1104 9 that that WDT 35772 1104 10 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1104 11 lacked lack VBD 35772 1104 12 , , , 35772 1104 13 and and CC 35772 1104 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1104 15 was be VBD 35772 1104 16 another another DT 35772 1104 17 side side NN 35772 1104 18 of of IN 35772 1104 19 German german JJ 35772 1104 20 idealism idealism NN 35772 1104 21 that that WDT 35772 1104 22 had have VBD 35772 1104 23 appealed appeal VBN 35772 1104 24 to to IN 35772 1104 25 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1104 26 . . . 35772 1105 1 The the DT 35772 1105 2 Scotchman Scotchman NNP 35772 1105 3 was be VBD 35772 1105 4 of of IN 35772 1105 5 the the DT 35772 1105 6 same same JJ 35772 1105 7 fibre fibre NN 35772 1105 8 and and CC 35772 1105 9 stock stock NN 35772 1105 10 as as IN 35772 1105 11 that that DT 35772 1105 12 other other JJ 35772 1105 13 half half JJ 35772 1105 14 - - HYPH 35772 1105 15 Scotchman Scotchman NNP 35772 1105 16 , , , 35772 1105 17 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1105 18 . . . 35772 1106 1 Here here RB 35772 1106 2 was be VBD 35772 1106 3 the the DT 35772 1106 4 source source NN 35772 1106 5 from from IN 35772 1106 6 which which WDT 35772 1106 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1106 8 had have VBD 35772 1106 9 drawn draw VBN 35772 1106 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1106 11 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 1106 12 . . . 35772 1107 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1107 2 see see VBP 35772 1107 3 in in IN 35772 1107 4 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1107 5 the the DT 35772 1107 6 same same JJ 35772 1107 7 moral moral JJ 35772 1107 8 earnestness earnestness NN 35772 1107 9 , , , 35772 1107 10 the the DT 35772 1107 11 same same JJ 35772 1107 12 " " `` 35772 1107 13 toughness toughness NN 35772 1107 14 " " '' 35772 1107 15 of of IN 35772 1107 16 thought thought NN 35772 1107 17 , , , 35772 1107 18 the the DT 35772 1107 19 same same JJ 35772 1107 20 absence absence NN 35772 1107 21 of of IN 35772 1107 22 " " `` 35772 1107 23 sentimental sentimental JJ 35772 1107 24 moonshine moonshine NN 35772 1107 25 . . . 35772 1107 26 " " '' 35772 1108 1 From from IN 35772 1108 2 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1108 3 , , , 35772 1108 4 too too RB 35772 1108 5 , , , 35772 1108 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1108 7 derives derive VBZ 35772 1108 8 a a DT 35772 1108 9 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 1108 10 independence independence NN 35772 1108 11 of of IN 35772 1108 12 thought thought NN 35772 1108 13 , , , 35772 1108 14 a a DT 35772 1108 15 religious religious JJ 35772 1108 16 respect respect NN 35772 1108 17 for for IN 35772 1108 18 individuality individuality NN 35772 1108 19 , , , 35772 1108 20 a a DT 35772 1108 21 horror horror NN 35772 1108 22 of of IN 35772 1108 23 shams sham NNS 35772 1108 24 and and CC 35772 1108 25 affectation affectation NN 35772 1108 26 . . . 35772 1109 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1109 2 was be VBD 35772 1109 3 a a DT 35772 1109 4 true true JJ 35772 1109 5 child child NN 35772 1109 6 of of IN 35772 1109 7 the the DT 35772 1109 8 Reformation Reformation NNP 35772 1109 9 , , , 35772 1109 10 and and CC 35772 1109 11 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1109 12 is be VBZ 35772 1109 13 a a DT 35772 1109 14 genuine genuine JJ 35772 1109 15 disciple disciple NN 35772 1109 16 . . . 35772 1110 1 In in IN 35772 1110 2 a a DT 35772 1110 3 single single JJ 35772 1110 4 important important JJ 35772 1110 5 respect respect NN 35772 1110 6 , , , 35772 1110 7 however however RB 35772 1110 8 , , , 35772 1110 9 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1110 10 differed differ VBD 35772 1110 11 from from IN 35772 1110 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1110 13 and and CC 35772 1110 14 improved improve VBN 35772 1110 15 upon upon IN 35772 1110 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1110 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1110 18 master master NN 35772 1110 19 . . . 35772 1111 1 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1111 2 lacked lack VBD 35772 1111 3 , , , 35772 1111 4 or or CC 35772 1111 5 at at IN 35772 1111 6 least least JJS 35772 1111 7 did do VBD 35772 1111 8 not not RB 35772 1111 9 display display VB 35772 1111 10 , , , 35772 1111 11 the the DT 35772 1111 12 saving save VBG 35772 1111 13 grace grace NN 35772 1111 14 of of IN 35772 1111 15 humour humour NN 35772 1111 16 ; ; : 35772 1111 17 in in IN 35772 1111 18 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1111 19 this this DT 35772 1111 20 quality quality NN 35772 1111 21 looks look VBZ 35772 1111 22 out out RP 35772 1111 23 from from IN 35772 1111 24 every every DT 35772 1111 25 page page NN 35772 1111 26 -- -- : 35772 1111 27 keen keen JJ 35772 1111 28 , , , 35772 1111 29 satirical satirical JJ 35772 1111 30 , , , 35772 1111 31 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 1111 32 bitter bitter JJ 35772 1111 33 , , , 35772 1111 34 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 1111 35 grotesque grotesque JJ 35772 1111 36 ; ; : 35772 1111 37 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1111 38 ridiculed ridicule VBD 35772 1111 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1111 40 own own JJ 35772 1111 41 generation generation NN 35772 1111 42 , , , 35772 1111 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1111 44 vices vice NNS 35772 1111 45 , , , 35772 1111 46 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1111 47 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 1111 48 , , , 35772 1111 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1111 50 superstitions superstition NNS 35772 1111 51 . . . 35772 1112 1 SARTOR SARTOR NNP 35772 1112 2 RESARTUS.--For resartus.--for VB 35772 1112 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1112 4 purpose purpose NN 35772 1112 5 , , , 35772 1112 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1112 7 Sartor Sartor NNP 35772 1112 8 Resartus_--that resartus_--that VB 35772 1112 9 profound profound JJ 35772 1112 10 and and CC 35772 1112 11 humorous humorous JJ 35772 1112 12 book book NN 35772 1112 13 -- -- : 35772 1112 14 is be VBZ 35772 1112 15 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1112 16 's 's POS 35772 1112 17 masterpiece masterpiece NN 35772 1112 18 : : : 35772 1112 19 here here RB 35772 1112 20 all all PDT 35772 1112 21 the the DT 35772 1112 22 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 1112 23 Kantian kantian JJ 35772 1112 24 doctrines doctrine NNS 35772 1112 25 may may MD 35772 1112 26 be be VB 35772 1112 27 found find VBN 35772 1112 28 . . . 35772 1113 1 The the DT 35772 1113 2 " " `` 35772 1113 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1113 4 of of IN 35772 1113 5 clothes"--which clothes"--which NNP 35772 1113 6 is be VBZ 35772 1113 7 the the DT 35772 1113 8 quaint quaint NN 35772 1113 9 title title NN 35772 1113 10 behind behind IN 35772 1113 11 which which WDT 35772 1113 12 Kantian kantian JJ 35772 1113 13 idealism idealism NN 35772 1113 14 is be VBZ 35772 1113 15 made make VBN 35772 1113 16 to to TO 35772 1113 17 masquerade masquerade VB 35772 1113 18 -- -- : 35772 1113 19 starts start VBZ 35772 1113 20 from from IN 35772 1113 21 the the DT 35772 1113 22 thought thought NN 35772 1113 23 that that WDT 35772 1113 24 just just RB 35772 1113 25 as as IN 35772 1113 26 an an DT 35772 1113 27 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 1113 28 with with IN 35772 1113 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1113 30 clothes clothe NNS 35772 1113 31 will will MD 35772 1113 32 not not RB 35772 1113 33 reveal reveal VB 35772 1113 34 to to IN 35772 1113 35 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1113 36 the the DT 35772 1113 37 man man NN 35772 1113 38 , , , 35772 1113 39 so so IN 35772 1113 40 an an DT 35772 1113 41 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 1113 42 with with IN 35772 1113 43 _ _ NNP 35772 1113 44 phenomena phenomena NNP 35772 1113 45 _ _ NNP 35772 1113 46 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1113 47 which which WDT 35772 1113 48 is be VBZ 35772 1113 49 all all DT 35772 1113 50 that that DT 35772 1113 51 science science NN 35772 1113 52 can can MD 35772 1113 53 claim claim VB 35772 1113 54 to to TO 35772 1113 55 give give VB 35772 1113 56 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1113 57 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1113 58 can can MD 35772 1113 59 not not RB 35772 1113 60 reveal reveal VB 35772 1113 61 to to IN 35772 1113 62 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1113 63 the the DT 35772 1113 64 real real JJ 35772 1113 65 ground ground NN 35772 1113 66 of of IN 35772 1113 67 existence existence NN 35772 1113 68 , , , 35772 1113 69 which which WDT 35772 1113 70 remains remain VBZ 35772 1113 71 an an DT 35772 1113 72 inscrutable inscrutable JJ 35772 1113 73 mystery mystery NN 35772 1113 74 . . . 35772 1114 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1114 2 must must MD 35772 1114 3 " " `` 35772 1114 4 look look VB 35772 1114 5 on on IN 35772 1114 6 clothes clothe NNS 35772 1114 7 till till IN 35772 1114 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1114 9 become become VBP 35772 1114 10 transparent transparent JJ 35772 1114 11 , , , 35772 1114 12 " " '' 35772 1114 13 if if IN 35772 1114 14 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1114 15 could could MD 35772 1114 16 understand understand VB 35772 1114 17 reality reality NN 35772 1114 18 . . . 35772 1115 1 " " `` 35772 1115 2 To to IN 35772 1115 3 the the DT 35772 1115 4 eye eye NN 35772 1115 5 of of IN 35772 1115 6 vulgar vulgar NNP 35772 1115 7 Logic Logic NNP 35772 1115 8 what what WP 35772 1115 9 is be VBZ 35772 1115 10 man man NN 35772 1115 11 ? ? . 35772 1116 1 An an DT 35772 1116 2 omnivorous omnivorous JJ 35772 1116 3 biped biped NN 35772 1116 4 that that WDT 35772 1116 5 wears wear VBZ 35772 1116 6 breeches breech NNS 35772 1116 7 . . . 35772 1117 1 To to IN 35772 1117 2 the the DT 35772 1117 3 eye eye NN 35772 1117 4 of of IN 35772 1117 5 pure pure JJ 35772 1117 6 Reason reason NN 35772 1117 7 what what WP 35772 1117 8 is be VBZ 35772 1117 9 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1117 10 ? ? . 35772 1118 1 A a DT 35772 1118 2 Soul Soul NNP 35772 1118 3 , , , 35772 1118 4 a a DT 35772 1118 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 35772 1118 6 , , , 35772 1118 7 and and CC 35772 1118 8 divine divine JJ 35772 1118 9 Apparition apparition NN 35772 1118 10 . . . 35772 1118 11 " " '' 35772 1119 1 And and CC 35772 1119 2 so so RB 35772 1119 3 with with IN 35772 1119 4 Nature nature NN 35772 1119 5 ; ; : 35772 1119 6 to to TO 35772 1119 7 science science VB 35772 1119 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1119 9 is be VBZ 35772 1119 10 a a DT 35772 1119 11 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1119 12 , , , 35772 1119 13 to to IN 35772 1119 14 the the DT 35772 1119 15 understanding understand VBG 35772 1119 16 heart heart NN 35772 1119 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1119 18 is be VBZ 35772 1119 19 " " `` 35772 1119 20 the the DT 35772 1119 21 living live VBG 35772 1119 22 garment garment NN 35772 1119 23 of of IN 35772 1119 24 God God NNP 35772 1119 25 . . . 35772 1119 26 " " '' 35772 1120 1 " " `` 35772 1120 2 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1120 3 is be VBZ 35772 1120 4 written write VBN 35772 1120 5 , , , 35772 1120 6 the the DT 35772 1120 7 Heavens Heavens NNPS 35772 1120 8 and and CC 35772 1120 9 the the DT 35772 1120 10 Earth Earth NNP 35772 1120 11 shall shall MD 35772 1120 12 fade fade VB 35772 1120 13 away away RB 35772 1120 14 like like IN 35772 1120 15 a a DT 35772 1120 16 Vesture vesture NN 35772 1120 17 ; ; : 35772 1120 18 which which WDT 35772 1120 19 indeed indeed RB 35772 1120 20 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1120 21 are be VBP 35772 1120 22 : : : 35772 1120 23 the the DT 35772 1120 24 Time Time NNP 35772 1120 25 - - HYPH 35772 1120 26 Vesture Vesture NNP 35772 1120 27 of of IN 35772 1120 28 the the DT 35772 1120 29 Eternal Eternal NNP 35772 1120 30 .... .... . 35772 1121 1 The the DT 35772 1121 2 whole whole JJ 35772 1121 3 External External NNP 35772 1121 4 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1121 5 and and CC 35772 1121 6 what what WP 35772 1121 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1121 8 holds hold VBZ 35772 1121 9 is be VBZ 35772 1121 10 but but CC 35772 1121 11 Clothing clothing NN 35772 1121 12 .... .... . 35772 1121 13 " " '' 35772 1121 14 The the DT 35772 1121 15 visible visible JJ 35772 1121 16 world world NN 35772 1121 17 is be VBZ 35772 1121 18 but but CC 35772 1121 19 a a DT 35772 1121 20 symbol symbol NN 35772 1121 21 of of IN 35772 1121 22 a a DT 35772 1121 23 profound profound JJ 35772 1121 24 and and CC 35772 1121 25 awful awful JJ 35772 1121 26 reality reality NN 35772 1121 27 ; ; : 35772 1121 28 and and CC 35772 1121 29 all all DT 35772 1121 30 Nature Nature NNP 35772 1121 31 's 's POS 35772 1121 32 products product NNS 35772 1121 33 , , , 35772 1121 34 in in IN 35772 1121 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1121 36 degree degree NN 35772 1121 37 , , , 35772 1121 38 symbols symbol NNS 35772 1121 39 as as RB 35772 1121 40 well well RB 35772 1121 41 : : : 35772 1121 42 but but CC 35772 1121 43 of of IN 35772 1121 44 these these DT 35772 1121 45 , , , 35772 1121 46 man man NN 35772 1121 47 is be VBZ 35772 1121 48 the the DT 35772 1121 49 highest high JJS 35772 1121 50 . . . 35772 1122 1 " " `` 35772 1122 2 The the DT 35772 1122 3 true true JJ 35772 1122 4 SHEKINAH SHEKINAH NNP 35772 1122 5 is be VBZ 35772 1122 6 Man man NN 35772 1122 7 : : : 35772 1122 8 where where WRB 35772 1122 9 else else RB 35772 1122 10 is be VBZ 35772 1122 11 the the DT 35772 1122 12 GOD GOD NNP 35772 1122 13 'S 's POS 35772 1122 14 PRESENCE PRESENCE NNP 35772 1122 15 manifested manifest VBN 35772 1122 16 , , , 35772 1122 17 not not RB 35772 1122 18 to to IN 35772 1122 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1122 20 eyes eye NNS 35772 1122 21 only only RB 35772 1122 22 , , , 35772 1122 23 but but CC 35772 1122 24 to to IN 35772 1122 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1122 26 hearts heart NNS 35772 1122 27 , , , 35772 1122 28 as as IN 35772 1122 29 in in IN 35772 1122 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1122 31 fellow fellow JJ 35772 1122 32 - - HYPH 35772 1122 33 man man NN 35772 1122 34 ? ? . 35772 1122 35 " " '' 35772 1123 1 This this DT 35772 1123 2 leads lead VBZ 35772 1123 3 up up RP 35772 1123 4 to to IN 35772 1123 5 the the DT 35772 1123 6 essential essential JJ 35772 1123 7 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 1123 8 of of IN 35772 1123 9 the the DT 35772 1123 10 Kantian kantian JJ 35772 1123 11 system system NN 35772 1123 12 : : : 35772 1123 13 that that DT 35772 1123 14 man man NN 35772 1123 15 is be VBZ 35772 1123 16 a a DT 35772 1123 17 creature creature NN 35772 1123 18 of of IN 35772 1123 19 two two CD 35772 1123 20 worlds world NNS 35772 1123 21 , , , 35772 1123 22 who who WP 35772 1123 23 has have VBZ 35772 1123 24 a a DT 35772 1123 25 foot foot NN 35772 1123 26 in in IN 35772 1123 27 either either RB 35772 1123 28 ; ; : 35772 1123 29 hence hence RB 35772 1123 30 in in IN 35772 1123 31 the the DT 35772 1123 32 phenomenal phenomenal JJ 35772 1123 33 world world NN 35772 1123 34 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1123 35 can can MD 35772 1123 36 never never RB 35772 1123 37 find find VB 35772 1123 38 satisfaction satisfaction NN 35772 1123 39 . . . 35772 1124 1 " " `` 35772 1124 2 Man Man NNP 35772 1124 3 's 's POS 35772 1124 4 Unhappiness Unhappiness NNP 35772 1124 5 , , , 35772 1124 6 as as IN 35772 1124 7 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1124 8 construe construe VBP 35772 1124 9 , , , 35772 1124 10 comes come VBZ 35772 1124 11 of of IN 35772 1124 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1124 13 Greatness Greatness NNP 35772 1124 14 ; ; : 35772 1124 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1124 16 is be VBZ 35772 1124 17 because because IN 35772 1124 18 there there EX 35772 1124 19 is be VBZ 35772 1124 20 an an DT 35772 1124 21 infinite infinite NN 35772 1124 22 in in IN 35772 1124 23 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1124 24 , , , 35772 1124 25 which which WDT 35772 1124 26 , , , 35772 1124 27 with with IN 35772 1124 28 all all PDT 35772 1124 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1124 30 cunning cunning NN 35772 1124 31 , , , 35772 1124 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1124 33 can can MD 35772 1124 34 not not RB 35772 1124 35 quite quite RB 35772 1124 36 bury bury VB 35772 1124 37 under under IN 35772 1124 38 the the DT 35772 1124 39 Finite Finite NNP 35772 1124 40 . . . 35772 1125 1 Will Will MD 35772 1125 2 the the DT 35772 1125 3 whole whole JJ 35772 1125 4 Finance Finance NNP 35772 1125 5 Ministers Ministers NNPS 35772 1125 6 and and CC 35772 1125 7 Upholsterers Upholsterers NNPS 35772 1125 8 and and CC 35772 1125 9 Confectioners Confectioners NNP 35772 1125 10 of of IN 35772 1125 11 modern modern JJ 35772 1125 12 Europe Europe NNP 35772 1125 13 undertake undertake VBP 35772 1125 14 , , , 35772 1125 15 in in IN 35772 1125 16 jointstock jointstock NNP 35772 1125 17 company company NN 35772 1125 18 , , , 35772 1125 19 to to TO 35772 1125 20 make make VB 35772 1125 21 one one CD 35772 1125 22 Shoeblack shoeblack RB 35772 1125 23 Happy happy JJ 35772 1125 24 ? ? . 35772 1126 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1126 2 can can MD 35772 1126 3 not not RB 35772 1126 4 accomplish accomplish VB 35772 1126 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1126 6 , , , 35772 1126 7 above above IN 35772 1126 8 an an DT 35772 1126 9 hour hour NN 35772 1126 10 or or CC 35772 1126 11 two two CD 35772 1126 12 , , , 35772 1126 13 for for IN 35772 1126 14 the the DT 35772 1126 15 Shoeblack Shoeblack NNP 35772 1126 16 also also RB 35772 1126 17 has have VBZ 35772 1126 18 a a DT 35772 1126 19 Soul soul NN 35772 1126 20 quite quite RB 35772 1126 21 other other JJ 35772 1126 22 than than IN 35772 1126 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1126 24 Stomach stomach NN 35772 1126 25 .... .... NFP 35772 1126 26 " " '' 35772 1126 27 " " `` 35772 1126 28 There there EX 35772 1126 29 is be VBZ 35772 1126 30 in in IN 35772 1126 31 man man NN 35772 1126 32 a a DT 35772 1126 33 HIGHER high JJR 35772 1126 34 than than IN 35772 1126 35 Love love NN 35772 1126 36 of of IN 35772 1126 37 happiness happiness NN 35772 1126 38 : : : 35772 1126 39 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1126 40 can can MD 35772 1126 41 do do VB 35772 1126 42 without without IN 35772 1126 43 happiness happiness NN 35772 1126 44 and and CC 35772 1126 45 instead instead RB 35772 1126 46 thereof thereof RB 35772 1126 47 find find VBP 35772 1126 48 Blessedness Blessedness NNP 35772 1126 49 ! ! . 35772 1127 1 has have VBZ 35772 1127 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1127 3 not not RB 35772 1127 4 been be VBN 35772 1127 5 to to TO 35772 1127 6 preach preach VB 35772 1127 7 forth forth RB 35772 1127 8 this this DT 35772 1127 9 same same JJ 35772 1127 10 HIGHER HIGHER NNP 35772 1127 11 that that WDT 35772 1127 12 sages sag VBZ 35772 1127 13 and and CC 35772 1127 14 martyrs martyr NNS 35772 1127 15 ... ... NFP 35772 1127 16 have have VBP 35772 1127 17 spoken speak VBN 35772 1127 18 and and CC 35772 1127 19 suffered suffer VBN 35772 1127 20 ; ; : 35772 1127 21 bearing bear VBG 35772 1127 22 testimony testimony NN 35772 1127 23 to to IN 35772 1127 24 the the DT 35772 1127 25 God God NNP 35772 1127 26 - - : 35772 1127 27 like like UH 35772 1127 28 that that DT 35772 1127 29 is be VBZ 35772 1127 30 in in IN 35772 1127 31 man man NN 35772 1127 32 ? ? . 35772 1127 33 " " '' 35772 1128 1 CARLYLE CARLYLE NNP 35772 1128 2 'S 's POS 35772 1128 3 INFLUENCE.--In INFLUENCE.--In NNP 35772 1128 4 spite spite NN 35772 1128 5 of of IN 35772 1128 6 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1128 7 's 's POS 35772 1128 8 strange strange JJ 35772 1128 9 literary literary JJ 35772 1128 10 mannerisms mannerism NNS 35772 1128 11 and and CC 35772 1128 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1128 13 grotesquely grotesquely RB 35772 1128 14 Germanic germanic JJ 35772 1128 15 phrases phrase NNS 35772 1128 16 , , , 35772 1128 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1128 18 writings writing NNS 35772 1128 19 had have VBD 35772 1128 20 great great JJ 35772 1128 21 attractiveness attractiveness NN 35772 1128 22 for for IN 35772 1128 23 those those DT 35772 1128 24 of of IN 35772 1128 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1128 26 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 1128 27 who who WP 35772 1128 28 felt feel VBD 35772 1128 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1128 30 smothered smother VBN 35772 1128 31 by by IN 35772 1128 32 the the DT 35772 1128 33 materialism materialism NN 35772 1128 34 and and CC 35772 1128 35 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN 35772 1128 36 of of IN 35772 1128 37 early early JJ 35772 1128 38 Victorian Victorian NNP 35772 1128 39 England England NNP 35772 1128 40 . . . 35772 1129 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1129 2 was be VBD 35772 1129 3 able able JJ 35772 1129 4 to to TO 35772 1129 5 re re VB 35772 1129 6 - - VB 35772 1129 7 vitalise vitalise JJ 35772 1129 8 idealism idealism NN 35772 1129 9 amongst amongst IN 35772 1129 10 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1129 11 . . . 35772 1130 1 Moreover moreover RB 35772 1130 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1130 3 appealed appeal VBD 35772 1130 4 strongly strongly RB 35772 1130 5 to to IN 35772 1130 6 those those DT 35772 1130 7 to to IN 35772 1130 8 whom whom WP 35772 1130 9 the the DT 35772 1130 10 Coleridgean Coleridgean NNP 35772 1130 11 speculations speculation NNS 35772 1130 12 were be VBD 35772 1130 13 uncongenial uncongenial JJ 35772 1130 14 . . . 35772 1131 1 The the DT 35772 1131 2 strongly strongly RB 35772 1131 3 developed develop VBN 35772 1131 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1131 5 moral moral JJ 35772 1131 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1131 7 element element NN 35772 1131 8 , , , 35772 1131 9 both both CC 35772 1131 10 in in IN 35772 1131 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1131 12 writings writing NNS 35772 1131 13 and and CC 35772 1131 14 in in IN 35772 1131 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1131 16 own own JJ 35772 1131 17 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 1131 18 stern stern JJ 35772 1131 19 and and CC 35772 1131 20 austere austere JJ 35772 1131 21 personality personality NN 35772 1131 22 -- -- : 35772 1131 23 what what WP 35772 1131 24 Taine Taine NNP 35772 1131 25 called call VBD 35772 1131 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1131 27 " " `` 35772 1131 28 puritanism"--appealed puritanism"--appeale VBN 35772 1131 29 strongly strongly RB 35772 1131 30 to to IN 35772 1131 31 a a DT 35772 1131 32 certain certain JJ 35772 1131 33 side side NN 35772 1131 34 of of IN 35772 1131 35 English english JJ 35772 1131 36 feeling feeling NN 35772 1131 37 . . . 35772 1132 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1132 2 countrymen countryman NNS 35772 1132 3 felt feel VBD 35772 1132 4 that that IN 35772 1132 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1132 6 was be VBD 35772 1132 7 a a DT 35772 1132 8 native native JJ 35772 1132 9 genius genius NN 35772 1132 10 that that IN 35772 1132 11 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1132 12 could could MD 35772 1132 13 understand understand VB 35772 1132 14 . . . 35772 1133 1 In in IN 35772 1133 2 fact fact NN 35772 1133 3 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1133 4 may may MD 35772 1133 5 say say VB 35772 1133 6 that that IN 35772 1133 7 the the DT 35772 1133 8 influence influence NN 35772 1133 9 of of IN 35772 1133 10 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1133 11 , , , 35772 1133 12 especially especially RB 35772 1133 13 among among IN 35772 1133 14 the the DT 35772 1133 15 young young JJ 35772 1133 16 and and CC 35772 1133 17 generous generous JJ 35772 1133 18 minded minded JJ 35772 1133 19 , , , 35772 1133 20 has have VBZ 35772 1133 21 been be VBN 35772 1133 22 incalculable incalculable JJ 35772 1133 23 in in IN 35772 1133 24 extent extent NN 35772 1133 25 and and CC 35772 1133 26 invaluable invaluable JJ 35772 1133 27 in in IN 35772 1133 28 quality quality NN 35772 1133 29 . . . 35772 1134 1 Spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1134 2 life life NN 35772 1134 3 in in IN 35772 1134 4 England England NNP 35772 1134 5 stands stand VBZ 35772 1134 6 under under IN 35772 1134 7 a a DT 35772 1134 8 deep deep JJ 35772 1134 9 obligation obligation NN 35772 1134 10 to to IN 35772 1134 11 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1134 12 . . . 35772 1135 1 ROMANTICISM ROMANTICISM NNP 35772 1135 2 AT AT NNP 35772 1135 3 OXFORD.--Englishmen OXFORD.--Englishmen NNP 35772 1135 4 were be VBD 35772 1135 5 thus thus RB 35772 1135 6 not not RB 35772 1135 7 entire entire JJ 35772 1135 8 strangers stranger NNS 35772 1135 9 to to IN 35772 1135 10 German german JJ 35772 1135 11 idealism idealism NN 35772 1135 12 , , , 35772 1135 13 which which WDT 35772 1135 14 had have VBD 35772 1135 15 possessed possess VBN 35772 1135 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1135 17 interpreters interpreter NNS 35772 1135 18 in in IN 35772 1135 19 the the DT 35772 1135 20 earlier early JJR 35772 1135 21 half half NN 35772 1135 22 of of IN 35772 1135 23 the the DT 35772 1135 24 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1135 25 century century NN 35772 1135 26 . . . 35772 1136 1 Not not RB 35772 1136 2 , , , 35772 1136 3 however however RB 35772 1136 4 , , , 35772 1136 5 until until IN 35772 1136 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1136 7 had have VBD 35772 1136 8 experienced experience VBN 35772 1136 9 a a DT 35772 1136 10 decline decline NN 35772 1136 11 in in IN 35772 1136 12 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1136 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1136 14 a a DT 35772 1136 15 reaction reaction NN 35772 1136 16 which which WDT 35772 1136 17 occupied occupy VBD 35772 1136 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1136 19 attention attention NN 35772 1136 20 in in IN 35772 1136 21 the the DT 35772 1136 22 last last JJ 35772 1136 23 chapter chapter NN 35772 1136 24 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1136 25 , , , 35772 1136 26 did do VBD 35772 1136 27 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 1136 28 become become VB 35772 1136 29 naturalised naturalise VBN 35772 1136 30 in in IN 35772 1136 31 England England NNP 35772 1136 32 by by IN 35772 1136 33 being be VBG 35772 1136 34 adopted adopt VBN 35772 1136 35 in in IN 35772 1136 36 academic academic JJ 35772 1136 37 circles circle NNS 35772 1136 38 . . . 35772 1137 1 Among among IN 35772 1137 2 the the DT 35772 1137 3 most most RBS 35772 1137 4 notable notable JJ 35772 1137 5 of of IN 35772 1137 6 English english JJ 35772 1137 7 idealists idealist NNS 35772 1137 8 was be VBD 35772 1137 9 T. t. NN 35772 1137 10 H. H. NNP 35772 1137 11 Green Green NNP 35772 1137 12 -- -- : 35772 1137 13 fellow fellow NN 35772 1137 14 and and CC 35772 1137 15 tutor tutor NN 35772 1137 16 of of IN 35772 1137 17 Balliol Balliol NNP 35772 1137 18 College College NNP 35772 1137 19 , , , 35772 1137 20 Oxford Oxford NNP 35772 1137 21 . . . 35772 1138 1 In in IN 35772 1138 2 this this DT 35772 1138 3 thinker thinker NN 35772 1138 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1138 5 have have VBP 35772 1138 6 a a DT 35772 1138 7 widely widely RB 35772 1138 8 different different JJ 35772 1138 9 type type NN 35772 1138 10 of of IN 35772 1138 11 mind mind NN 35772 1138 12 from from IN 35772 1138 13 that that DT 35772 1138 14 of of IN 35772 1138 15 either either DT 35772 1138 16 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1138 17 or or CC 35772 1138 18 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1138 19 . . . 35772 1139 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1139 2 was be VBD 35772 1139 3 a a DT 35772 1139 4 thinker thinker NN 35772 1139 5 rather rather RB 35772 1139 6 than than IN 35772 1139 7 a a DT 35772 1139 8 poet poet NN 35772 1139 9 or or CC 35772 1139 10 a a DT 35772 1139 11 prophet prophet NN 35772 1139 12 , , , 35772 1139 13 and and CC 35772 1139 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1139 15 belonged belong VBD 35772 1139 16 to to IN 35772 1139 17 what what WP 35772 1139 18 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1139 19 have have VBP 35772 1139 20 noticed notice VBN 35772 1139 21 as as IN 35772 1139 22 the the DT 35772 1139 23 intellectualist intellectualist NN 35772 1139 24 -- -- : 35772 1139 25 i.e i.e NNP 35772 1139 26 . . . 35772 1140 1 Hegelian hegelian JJ 35772 1140 2 -- -- : 35772 1140 3 wing wing NN 35772 1140 4 of of IN 35772 1140 5 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 1140 6 . . . 35772 1141 1 Green Green NNP 35772 1141 2 's 's POS 35772 1141 3 chief chief NN 35772 1141 4 work work NN 35772 1141 5 was be VBD 35772 1141 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1141 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1141 8 Prolegomena Prolegomena NNP 35772 1141 9 to to IN 35772 1141 10 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 1141 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1141 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1141 13 published publish VBN 35772 1141 14 posthumously posthumously RB 35772 1141 15 in in IN 35772 1141 16 1883 1883 CD 35772 1141 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1141 18 , , , 35772 1141 19 where where WRB 35772 1141 20 arguments argument NNS 35772 1141 21 , , , 35772 1141 22 which which WDT 35772 1141 23 were be VBD 35772 1141 24 familiar familiar JJ 35772 1141 25 to to IN 35772 1141 26 those those DT 35772 1141 27 acquainted acquaint VBN 35772 1141 28 with with IN 35772 1141 29 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 1141 30 , , , 35772 1141 31 presented present VBD 35772 1141 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1141 33 . . . 35772 1142 1 Green Green NNP 35772 1142 2 begins begin VBZ 35772 1142 3 with with IN 35772 1142 4 an an DT 35772 1142 5 analysis analysis NN 35772 1142 6 of of IN 35772 1142 7 experience experience NN 35772 1142 8 , , , 35772 1142 9 and and CC 35772 1142 10 leads lead VBZ 35772 1142 11 to to IN 35772 1142 12 the the DT 35772 1142 13 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 1142 14 that that IN 35772 1142 15 Nature Nature NNP 35772 1142 16 -- -- : 35772 1142 17 if if IN 35772 1142 18 by by IN 35772 1142 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1142 20 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1142 21 mean mean VBP 35772 1142 22 " " '' 35772 1142 23 the the DT 35772 1142 24 connected connected JJ 35772 1142 25 order order NN 35772 1142 26 of of IN 35772 1142 27 experience"--implies experience"--implie NNS 35772 1142 28 " " '' 35772 1142 29 something something NN 35772 1142 30 other other JJ 35772 1142 31 than than IN 35772 1142 32 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1142 33 , , , 35772 1142 34 as as IN 35772 1142 35 the the DT 35772 1142 36 condition condition NN 35772 1142 37 of of IN 35772 1142 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1142 39 being be VBG 35772 1142 40 what what WP 35772 1142 41 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1142 42 is be VBZ 35772 1142 43 . . . 35772 1142 44 " " '' 35772 1143 1 And and CC 35772 1143 2 " " `` 35772 1143 3 of of IN 35772 1143 4 that that DT 35772 1143 5 ' ' `` 35772 1143 6 something something NN 35772 1143 7 ' ' '' 35772 1143 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1143 9 are be VBP 35772 1143 10 entitled entitle VBN 35772 1143 11 to to TO 35772 1143 12 say say VB 35772 1143 13 , , , 35772 1143 14 positively positively RB 35772 1143 15 , , , 35772 1143 16 that that IN 35772 1143 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1143 18 is be VBZ 35772 1143 19 a a DT 35772 1143 20 self self NN 35772 1143 21 - - HYPH 35772 1143 22 distinguishing distinguish VBG 35772 1143 23 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1143 24 " " '' 35772 1143 25 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1143 26 section section NN 35772 1143 27 52 52 CD 35772 1143 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1143 29 . . . 35772 1144 1 If if IN 35772 1144 2 these these DT 35772 1144 3 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1144 4 be be VBP 35772 1144 5 valid valid JJ 35772 1144 6 , , , 35772 1144 7 the the DT 35772 1144 8 bottom bottom NN 35772 1144 9 falls fall VBZ 35772 1144 10 out out IN 35772 1144 11 of of IN 35772 1144 12 Naturalism Naturalism NNP 35772 1144 13 , , , 35772 1144 14 for for IN 35772 1144 15 if if IN 35772 1144 16 nature nature NN 35772 1144 17 " " '' 35772 1144 18 implies imply VBZ 35772 1144 19 something something NN 35772 1144 20 other other JJ 35772 1144 21 than than IN 35772 1144 22 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1144 23 , , , 35772 1144 24 " " `` 35772 1144 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1144 26 does do VBZ 35772 1144 27 not not RB 35772 1144 28 stand stand VB 35772 1144 29 alone alone RB 35772 1144 30 ; ; : 35772 1144 31 and and CC 35772 1144 32 that that IN 35772 1144 33 nature nature NN 35772 1144 34 _ _ NNP 35772 1144 35 does do VBZ 35772 1144 36 _ _ NNP 35772 1144 37 stand stand VB 35772 1144 38 alone alone JJ 35772 1144 39 is be VBZ 35772 1144 40 the the DT 35772 1144 41 beginning beginning NN 35772 1144 42 and and CC 35772 1144 43 end end NN 35772 1144 44 of of IN 35772 1144 45 all all DT 35772 1144 46 naturalist naturalist JJ 35772 1144 47 theory theory NN 35772 1144 48 . . . 35772 1145 1 And and CC 35772 1145 2 , , , 35772 1145 3 furthermore furthermore RB 35772 1145 4 , , , 35772 1145 5 this this DT 35772 1145 6 " " `` 35772 1145 7 something something NN 35772 1145 8 other other JJ 35772 1145 9 than than IN 35772 1145 10 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1145 11 , , , 35772 1145 12 " " '' 35772 1145 13 which which WDT 35772 1145 14 Nature Nature NNP 35772 1145 15 involves involve VBZ 35772 1145 16 , , , 35772 1145 17 is be VBZ 35772 1145 18 " " `` 35772 1145 19 a a DT 35772 1145 20 self self NN 35772 1145 21 - - HYPH 35772 1145 22 distinguishing distinguish VBG 35772 1145 23 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1145 24 " " '' 35772 1145 25 ; ; , 35772 1145 26 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1146 1 something something NN 35772 1146 2 to to TO 35772 1146 3 which which WDT 35772 1146 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1146 5 can can MD 35772 1146 6 attribute attribute VB 35772 1146 7 personality personality NN 35772 1146 8 . . . 35772 1147 1 GREEN green JJ 35772 1147 2 AND and CC 35772 1147 3 SPENCER spencer JJ 35772 1147 4 CONTRASTED.--This contrasted.--this NN 35772 1147 5 theory theory NN 35772 1147 6 has have VBZ 35772 1147 7 only only RB 35772 1147 8 to to TO 35772 1147 9 be be VB 35772 1147 10 compared compare VBN 35772 1147 11 with with IN 35772 1147 12 that that DT 35772 1147 13 of of IN 35772 1147 14 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1147 15 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1147 16 for for IN 35772 1147 17 a a DT 35772 1147 18 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1147 19 difference difference NN 35772 1147 20 to to TO 35772 1147 21 declare declare VB 35772 1147 22 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1147 23 . . . 35772 1148 1 The the DT 35772 1148 2 two two CD 35772 1148 3 systems system NNS 35772 1148 4 do do VBP 35772 1148 5 indeed indeed RB 35772 1148 6 adopt adopt VB 35772 1148 7 as as RB 35772 1148 8 axiomatic axiomatic JJ 35772 1148 9 the the DT 35772 1148 10 conception conception NN 35772 1148 11 of of IN 35772 1148 12 the the DT 35772 1148 13 uniformity uniformity NN 35772 1148 14 and and CC 35772 1148 15 unity unity NN 35772 1148 16 of of IN 35772 1148 17 nature nature NN 35772 1148 18 , , , 35772 1148 19 which which WDT 35772 1148 20 works work VBZ 35772 1148 21 in in IN 35772 1148 22 accordance accordance NN 35772 1148 23 with with IN 35772 1148 24 a a DT 35772 1148 25 single single JJ 35772 1148 26 law law NN 35772 1148 27 . . . 35772 1149 1 But but CC 35772 1149 2 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1149 3 saw see VBD 35772 1149 4 in in IN 35772 1149 5 that that DT 35772 1149 6 law law NN 35772 1149 7 the the DT 35772 1149 8 expression expression NN 35772 1149 9 of of IN 35772 1149 10 a a DT 35772 1149 11 blind blind JJ 35772 1149 12 force force NN 35772 1149 13 , , , 35772 1149 14 an an DT 35772 1149 15 unknowable unknowable JJ 35772 1149 16 power power NN 35772 1149 17 , , , 35772 1149 18 of of IN 35772 1149 19 which which WDT 35772 1149 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1149 21 would would MD 35772 1149 22 be be VB 35772 1149 23 no no DT 35772 1149 24 more more JJR 35772 1149 25 and and CC 35772 1149 26 no no DT 35772 1149 27 less less RBR 35772 1149 28 true true JJ 35772 1149 29 to to TO 35772 1149 30 say say VB 35772 1149 31 that that IN 35772 1149 32 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1149 33 was be VBD 35772 1149 34 " " `` 35772 1149 35 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1149 36 " " '' 35772 1149 37 than than IN 35772 1149 38 that that IN 35772 1149 39 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1149 40 was be VBD 35772 1149 41 " " `` 35772 1149 42 material material JJ 35772 1149 43 . . . 35772 1149 44 " " '' 35772 1150 1 But but CC 35772 1150 2 for for IN 35772 1150 3 Green Green NNP 35772 1150 4 the the DT 35772 1150 5 law law NN 35772 1150 6 was be VBD 35772 1150 7 the the DT 35772 1150 8 expression expression NN 35772 1150 9 of of IN 35772 1150 10 a a DT 35772 1150 11 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1150 12 principal principal NN 35772 1150 13 analogous analogous JJ 35772 1150 14 to to IN 35772 1150 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1150 16 own own JJ 35772 1150 17 intelligence intelligence NN 35772 1150 18 -- -- : 35772 1150 19 a a DT 35772 1150 20 manifestation manifestation NN 35772 1150 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1150 22 to to TO 35772 1150 23 use use VB 35772 1150 24 theological theological JJ 35772 1150 25 language language NN 35772 1150 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1150 27 of of IN 35772 1150 28 God God NNP 35772 1150 29 . . . 35772 1151 1 F. F. NNP 35772 1151 2 H. H. NNP 35772 1152 1 BRADLEY.--Undoubtedly bradley.--undoubtedly RB 35772 1152 2 the the DT 35772 1152 3 most most RBS 35772 1152 4 notable notable JJ 35772 1152 5 of of IN 35772 1152 6 English English NNP 35772 1152 7 Hegelians Hegelians NNPS 35772 1152 8 is be VBZ 35772 1152 9 F. F. NNP 35772 1152 10 H. H. NNP 35772 1152 11 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1152 12 , , , 35772 1152 13 whose whose WP$ 35772 1152 14 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 35772 1152 15 essay essay NN 35772 1152 16 , , , 35772 1152 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1152 18 Appearance Appearance NNP 35772 1152 19 and and CC 35772 1152 20 Reality Reality NNP 35772 1152 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1152 22 , , , 35772 1152 23 was be VBD 35772 1152 24 a a DT 35772 1152 25 work work NN 35772 1152 26 of of IN 35772 1152 27 genuine genuine JJ 35772 1152 28 originality originality NN 35772 1152 29 . . . 35772 1153 1 The the DT 35772 1153 2 book book NN 35772 1153 3 is be VBZ 35772 1153 4 not not RB 35772 1153 5 of of IN 35772 1153 6 a a DT 35772 1153 7 type type NN 35772 1153 8 to to TO 35772 1153 9 make make VB 35772 1153 10 much much JJ 35772 1153 11 appeal appeal NN 35772 1153 12 outside outside IN 35772 1153 13 academic academic JJ 35772 1153 14 circles circle NNS 35772 1153 15 , , , 35772 1153 16 though though IN 35772 1153 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1153 18 is be VBZ 35772 1153 19 written write VBN 35772 1153 20 in in IN 35772 1153 21 an an DT 35772 1153 22 easy easy JJ 35772 1153 23 and and CC 35772 1153 24 attractive attractive JJ 35772 1153 25 style style NN 35772 1153 26 : : : 35772 1153 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1153 28 results result NNS 35772 1153 29 may may MD 35772 1153 30 seem seem VB 35772 1153 31 , , , 35772 1153 32 to to IN 35772 1153 33 the the DT 35772 1153 34 unsophisticated unsophisticated JJ 35772 1153 35 reader reader NN 35772 1153 36 , , , 35772 1153 37 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 1153 38 too too RB 35772 1153 39 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 35772 1153 40 . . . 35772 1154 1 " " `` 35772 1154 2 Ultimate Ultimate NNP 35772 1154 3 Doubts Doubts NNP 35772 1154 4 " " '' 35772 1154 5 is be VBZ 35772 1154 6 the the DT 35772 1154 7 title title NN 35772 1154 8 of of IN 35772 1154 9 the the DT 35772 1154 10 last last JJ 35772 1154 11 chapter chapter NN 35772 1154 12 , , , 35772 1154 13 and and CC 35772 1154 14 " " `` 35772 1154 15 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1154 16 costs cost VBZ 35772 1154 17 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1154 18 little little JJ 35772 1154 19 to to TO 35772 1154 20 find find VB 35772 1154 21 that that IN 35772 1154 22 in in IN 35772 1154 23 the the DT 35772 1154 24 end end NN 35772 1154 25 Reality reality NN 35772 1154 26 is be VBZ 35772 1154 27 inscrutable inscrutable JJ 35772 1154 28 , , , 35772 1154 29 " " '' 35772 1154 30 is be VBZ 35772 1154 31 a a DT 35772 1154 32 remark remark NN 35772 1154 33 not not RB 35772 1154 34 uncharacteristic uncharacteristic JJ 35772 1154 35 of of IN 35772 1154 36 the the DT 35772 1154 37 author author NN 35772 1154 38 . . . 35772 1155 1 Yet yet CC 35772 1155 2 this this DT 35772 1155 3 really really RB 35772 1155 4 profound profound JJ 35772 1155 5 thinker thinker NN 35772 1155 6 and and CC 35772 1155 7 acute acute JJ 35772 1155 8 reasoner reasoner NN 35772 1155 9 played play VBD 35772 1155 10 an an DT 35772 1155 11 important important JJ 35772 1155 12 part part NN 35772 1155 13 in in IN 35772 1155 14 helping help VBG 35772 1155 15 to to TO 35772 1155 16 discredit discredit VB 35772 1155 17 that that IN 35772 1155 18 negative negative JJ 35772 1155 19 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1155 20 which which WDT 35772 1155 21 was be VBD 35772 1155 22 so so RB 35772 1155 23 much much JJ 35772 1155 24 in in IN 35772 1155 25 vogue vogue NN 35772 1155 26 during during IN 35772 1155 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1155 28 own own JJ 35772 1155 29 lifetime lifetime NN 35772 1155 30 . . . 35772 1156 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1156 2 pointed point VBD 35772 1156 3 out out RP 35772 1156 4 the the DT 35772 1156 5 limits limit NNS 35772 1156 6 beyond beyond IN 35772 1156 7 which which WDT 35772 1156 8 natural natural JJ 35772 1156 9 science science NN 35772 1156 10 could could MD 35772 1156 11 not not RB 35772 1156 12 transgress transgress VB 35772 1156 13 without without IN 35772 1156 14 lapsing lapse VBG 35772 1156 15 into into IN 35772 1156 16 " " `` 35772 1156 17 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1156 18 superstition superstition NN 35772 1156 19 . . . 35772 1156 20 " " '' 35772 1157 1 " " `` 35772 1157 2 Too too RB 35772 1157 3 often often RB 35772 1157 4 the the DT 35772 1157 5 science science NN 35772 1157 6 of of IN 35772 1157 7 mere mere JJ 35772 1157 8 Nature Nature NNP 35772 1157 9 , , , 35772 1157 10 forgetting forget VBG 35772 1157 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1157 12 own own JJ 35772 1157 13 limits limit NNS 35772 1157 14 and and CC 35772 1157 15 false false JJ 35772 1157 16 to to IN 35772 1157 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1157 18 true true JJ 35772 1157 19 aims aim NNS 35772 1157 20 , , , 35772 1157 21 attempts attempt VBZ 35772 1157 22 to to TO 35772 1157 23 speak speak VB 35772 1157 24 about about IN 35772 1157 25 first first JJ 35772 1157 26 principles principle NNS 35772 1157 27 . . . 35772 1158 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1158 2 becomes become VBZ 35772 1158 3 transcendent transcendent NN 35772 1158 4 , , , 35772 1158 5 and and CC 35772 1158 6 offers offer VBZ 35772 1158 7 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1158 8 a a DT 35772 1158 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1158 10 and and CC 35772 1158 11 uncritical uncritical JJ 35772 1158 12 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 1158 13 " " '' 35772 1158 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1158 15 p. p. NN 35772 1158 16 284 284 CD 35772 1158 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1158 18 . . . 35772 1159 1 Though though IN 35772 1159 2 the the DT 35772 1159 3 fault fault NN 35772 1159 4 has have VBZ 35772 1159 5 not not RB 35772 1159 6 always always RB 35772 1159 7 been be VBN 35772 1159 8 on on IN 35772 1159 9 the the DT 35772 1159 10 side side NN 35772 1159 11 of of IN 35772 1159 12 the the DT 35772 1159 13 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1159 14 : : : 35772 1159 15 " " `` 35772 1159 16 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP 35772 1159 17 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1159 18 , , , 35772 1159 19 by by IN 35772 1159 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1159 21 interference interference NN 35772 1159 22 with with IN 35772 1159 23 physical physical JJ 35772 1159 24 science science NN 35772 1159 25 , , , 35772 1159 26 has have VBZ 35772 1159 27 induced induce VBN 35772 1159 28 that that DT 35772 1159 29 to to TO 35772 1159 30 act act VB 35772 1159 31 , , , 35772 1159 32 as as IN 35772 1159 33 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1159 34 thinks think VBZ 35772 1159 35 , , , 35772 1159 36 in in IN 35772 1159 37 self self NN 35772 1159 38 - - HYPH 35772 1159 39 defence defence NN 35772 1159 40 , , , 35772 1159 41 and and CC 35772 1159 42 has have VBZ 35772 1159 43 led lead VBN 35772 1159 44 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1159 45 , , , 35772 1159 46 in in IN 35772 1159 47 so so RB 35772 1159 48 doing do VBG 35772 1159 49 , , , 35772 1159 50 to to TO 35772 1159 51 become become VB 35772 1159 52 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 35772 1159 53 . . . 35772 1160 1 And and CC 35772 1160 2 this this DT 35772 1160 3 interference interference NN 35772 1160 4 of of IN 35772 1160 5 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 1160 6 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1160 7 would would MD 35772 1160 8 admit admit VB 35772 1160 9 and and CC 35772 1160 10 deplore deplore RB 35772 1160 11 , , , 35772 1160 12 as as IN 35772 1160 13 the the DT 35772 1160 14 result result NN 35772 1160 15 and and CC 35772 1160 16 the the DT 35772 1160 17 parent parent NN 35772 1160 18 of of IN 35772 1160 19 most most JJS 35772 1160 20 injurious injurious JJ 35772 1160 21 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 35772 1160 22 .... .... . 35772 1161 1 So so RB 35772 1161 2 long long RB 35772 1161 3 as as IN 35772 1161 4 natural natural JJ 35772 1161 5 science science NN 35772 1161 6 keeps keep VBZ 35772 1161 7 merely merely RB 35772 1161 8 to to IN 35772 1161 9 the the DT 35772 1161 10 sphere sphere NN 35772 1161 11 of of IN 35772 1161 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1161 13 and and CC 35772 1161 14 the the DT 35772 1161 15 laws law NNS 35772 1161 16 of of IN 35772 1161 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1161 18 occurrence occurrence NN 35772 1161 19 , , , 35772 1161 20 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 1161 21 has have VBZ 35772 1161 22 no no DT 35772 1161 23 right right NN 35772 1161 24 to to IN 35772 1161 25 a a DT 35772 1161 26 single single JJ 35772 1161 27 word word NN 35772 1161 28 of of IN 35772 1161 29 criticism criticism NN 35772 1161 30 " " '' 35772 1161 31 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1161 32 p. p. NN 35772 1161 33 285 285 CD 35772 1161 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1161 35 . . . 35772 1162 1 This this DT 35772 1162 2 critical critical JJ 35772 1162 3 handling handling NN 35772 1162 4 of of IN 35772 1162 5 the the DT 35772 1162 6 problem problem NN 35772 1162 7 of of IN 35772 1162 8 the the DT 35772 1162 9 relations relation NNS 35772 1162 10 of of IN 35772 1162 11 science science NN 35772 1162 12 and and CC 35772 1162 13 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1162 14 did do VBD 35772 1162 15 much much JJ 35772 1162 16 to to TO 35772 1162 17 draw draw VB 35772 1162 18 attention attention NN 35772 1162 19 to to IN 35772 1162 20 the the DT 35772 1162 21 confusion confusion NN 35772 1162 22 of of IN 35772 1162 23 thought thought NN 35772 1162 24 lying lie VBG 35772 1162 25 at at IN 35772 1162 26 the the DT 35772 1162 27 base base NN 35772 1162 28 of of IN 35772 1162 29 much much JJ 35772 1162 30 popular popular JJ 35772 1162 31 materialism materialism NN 35772 1162 32 . . . 35772 1163 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1163 2 began begin VBD 35772 1163 3 to to TO 35772 1163 4 be be VB 35772 1163 5 realised realise VBN 35772 1163 6 that that IN 35772 1163 7 the the DT 35772 1163 8 principles principle NNS 35772 1163 9 of of IN 35772 1163 10 physical physical JJ 35772 1163 11 science science NN 35772 1163 12 are be VBP 35772 1163 13 only only RB 35772 1163 14 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 1163 15 of of IN 35772 1163 16 good good JJ 35772 1163 17 results result NNS 35772 1163 18 in in IN 35772 1163 19 the the DT 35772 1163 20 sphere sphere NN 35772 1163 21 properly properly RB 35772 1163 22 belonging belong VBG 35772 1163 23 to to IN 35772 1163 24 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1163 25 ; ; : 35772 1163 26 and and CC 35772 1163 27 that that IN 35772 1163 28 the the DT 35772 1163 29 uncritical uncritical JJ 35772 1163 30 use use NN 35772 1163 31 of of IN 35772 1163 32 these these DT 35772 1163 33 principles principle NNS 35772 1163 34 results result VBZ 35772 1163 35 in in IN 35772 1163 36 a a DT 35772 1163 37 hybrid hybrid JJ 35772 1163 38 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1163 39 , , , 35772 1163 40 which which WDT 35772 1163 41 is be VBZ 35772 1163 42 neither neither CC 35772 1163 43 sound sound JJ 35772 1163 44 science science NN 35772 1163 45 nor nor CC 35772 1163 46 rational rational JJ 35772 1163 47 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 1163 48 . . . 35772 1164 1 A. A. NNP 35772 1164 2 J. J. NNP 35772 1165 1 BALFOUR.--Before BALFOUR.--Before NNP 35772 1165 2 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1165 3 's 's POS 35772 1165 4 essay essay NN 35772 1165 5 was be VBD 35772 1165 6 published publish VBN 35772 1165 7 , , , 35772 1165 8 a a DT 35772 1165 9 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 1165 10 similar similar JJ 35772 1165 11 line line NN 35772 1165 12 of of IN 35772 1165 13 criticism criticism NN 35772 1165 14 had have VBD 35772 1165 15 been be VBN 35772 1165 16 developed develop VBN 35772 1165 17 by by IN 35772 1165 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 1165 19 A. A. NNP 35772 1165 20 J. J. NNP 35772 1165 21 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1165 22 in in IN 35772 1165 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1165 24 _ _ NNP 35772 1165 25 Defence Defence NNP 35772 1165 26 of of IN 35772 1165 27 Philosophic Philosophic NNP 35772 1165 28 Doubt Doubt NNP 35772 1165 29 _ _ NNP 35772 1165 30 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1165 31 1879 1879 CD 35772 1165 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1165 33 . . . 35772 1166 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1166 2 title title NN 35772 1166 3 sounds sound VBZ 35772 1166 4 unpromising unpromising NN 35772 1166 5 , , , 35772 1166 6 but but CC 35772 1166 7 the the DT 35772 1166 8 book book NN 35772 1166 9 voiced voice VBD 35772 1166 10 a a DT 35772 1166 11 demand demand NN 35772 1166 12 for for IN 35772 1166 13 a a DT 35772 1166 14 rational rational JJ 35772 1166 15 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1166 16 of of IN 35772 1166 17 science science NN 35772 1166 18 which which WDT 35772 1166 19 was be VBD 35772 1166 20 practically practically RB 35772 1166 21 non non JJ 35772 1166 22 - - JJ 35772 1166 23 existent existent NN 35772 1166 24 at at IN 35772 1166 25 that that DT 35772 1166 26 time time NN 35772 1166 27 ; ; : 35772 1166 28 and and CC 35772 1166 29 consequently consequently RB 35772 1166 30 , , , 35772 1166 31 in in IN 35772 1166 32 the the DT 35772 1166 33 absence absence NN 35772 1166 34 of of IN 35772 1166 35 any any DT 35772 1166 36 adequate adequate JJ 35772 1166 37 examination examination NN 35772 1166 38 of of IN 35772 1166 39 the the DT 35772 1166 40 principles principle NNS 35772 1166 41 of of IN 35772 1166 42 science science NN 35772 1166 43 , , , 35772 1166 44 uncritical uncritical JJ 35772 1166 45 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1166 46 flourished flourish VBD 35772 1166 47 quite quite RB 35772 1166 48 unchallenged unchallenged JJ 35772 1166 49 . . . 35772 1167 1 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1167 2 , , , 35772 1167 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1167 4 , , , 35772 1167 5 indicates indicate VBZ 35772 1167 6 the the DT 35772 1167 7 objects object NNS 35772 1167 8 with with IN 35772 1167 9 which which WDT 35772 1167 10 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1167 11 wrote write VBD 35772 1167 12 the the DT 35772 1167 13 book book NN 35772 1167 14 -- -- : 35772 1167 15 to to TO 35772 1167 16 elicit elicit VB 35772 1167 17 from from IN 35772 1167 18 the the DT 35772 1167 19 disciples disciple NNS 35772 1167 20 of of IN 35772 1167 21 natural natural JJ 35772 1167 22 science science NN 35772 1167 23 a a DT 35772 1167 24 _ _ NNP 35772 1167 25 rationale rationale NN 35772 1167 26 _ _ NNP 35772 1167 27 of of IN 35772 1167 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1167 29 method method NN 35772 1167 30 : : : 35772 1167 31 " " `` 35772 1167 32 A a DT 35772 1167 33 full full JJ 35772 1167 34 and and CC 35772 1167 35 systematic systematic JJ 35772 1167 36 attempt attempt NN 35772 1167 37 , , , 35772 1167 38 first first RB 35772 1167 39 to to TO 35772 1167 40 enumerate enumerate VB 35772 1167 41 , , , 35772 1167 42 and and CC 35772 1167 43 then then RB 35772 1167 44 to to TO 35772 1167 45 justify justify VB 35772 1167 46 , , , 35772 1167 47 the the DT 35772 1167 48 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 1167 49 on on IN 35772 1167 50 which which WDT 35772 1167 51 all all DT 35772 1167 52 science science NN 35772 1167 53 finally finally RB 35772 1167 54 rests rest VBZ 35772 1167 55 , , , 35772 1167 56 has have VBZ 35772 1167 57 , , , 35772 1167 58 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1167 59 seems seem VBZ 35772 1167 60 to to IN 35772 1167 61 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1167 62 , , , 35772 1167 63 still still RB 35772 1167 64 to to TO 35772 1167 65 be be VB 35772 1167 66 made make VBN 35772 1167 67 . . . 35772 1168 1 After after IN 35772 1168 2 the the DT 35772 1168 3 critical critical JJ 35772 1168 4 examination examination NN 35772 1168 5 which which WDT 35772 1168 6 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1168 7 desiderate desiderate VBP 35772 1168 8 has have VBZ 35772 1168 9 been be VBN 35772 1168 10 thoroughly thoroughly RB 35772 1168 11 carried carry VBN 35772 1168 12 out out RP 35772 1168 13 , , , 35772 1168 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1168 15 may may MD 35772 1168 16 appear appear VB 35772 1168 17 that that IN 35772 1168 18 at at IN 35772 1168 19 the the DT 35772 1168 20 very very JJ 35772 1168 21 root root NN 35772 1168 22 of of IN 35772 1168 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1168 24 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1168 25 system system NN 35772 1168 26 of of IN 35772 1168 27 belief belief NN 35772 1168 28 lie lie NN 35772 1168 29 problems problem NNS 35772 1168 30 of of IN 35772 1168 31 which which WDT 35772 1168 32 no no DT 35772 1168 33 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 35772 1168 34 solution solution NN 35772 1168 35 has have VBZ 35772 1168 36 yet yet RB 35772 1168 37 been be VBN 35772 1168 38 devised devise VBN 35772 1168 39 . . . 35772 1169 1 " " `` 35772 1169 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1169 3 49 49 CD 35772 1169 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1169 5 Thus thus RB 35772 1169 6 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1169 7 drew draw VBD 35772 1169 8 attention attention NN 35772 1169 9 to to IN 35772 1169 10 the the DT 35772 1169 11 fact fact NN 35772 1169 12 that that IN 35772 1169 13 the the DT 35772 1169 14 common common JJ 35772 1169 15 - - HYPH 35772 1169 16 sense sense NN 35772 1169 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1169 18 of of IN 35772 1169 19 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1169 20 rested rest VBN 35772 1169 21 upon upon IN 35772 1169 22 a a DT 35772 1169 23 tacit tacit JJ 35772 1169 24 agreement agreement NN 35772 1169 25 to to TO 35772 1169 26 overlook overlook VB 35772 1169 27 certain certain JJ 35772 1169 28 important important JJ 35772 1169 29 problems problem NNS 35772 1169 30 which which WDT 35772 1169 31 are be VBP 35772 1169 32 the the DT 35772 1169 33 indispensable indispensable JJ 35772 1169 34 preliminaries preliminary NNS 35772 1169 35 to to IN 35772 1169 36 any any DT 35772 1169 37 thinking thinking NN 35772 1169 38 which which WDT 35772 1169 39 can can MD 35772 1169 40 be be VB 35772 1169 41 called call VBN 35772 1169 42 critical critical JJ 35772 1169 43 , , , 35772 1169 44 or or CC 35772 1169 45 lay lie VBD 35772 1169 46 claim claim NN 35772 1169 47 to to TO 35772 1169 48 be be VB 35772 1169 49 regarded regard VBN 35772 1169 50 as as IN 35772 1169 51 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1169 52 in in IN 35772 1169 53 the the DT 35772 1169 54 strict strict JJ 35772 1169 55 sense sense NN 35772 1169 56 . . . 35772 1170 1 That that IN 35772 1170 2 some some DT 35772 1170 3 of of IN 35772 1170 4 these these DT 35772 1170 5 problems problem NNS 35772 1170 6 seem seem VBP 35772 1170 7 artificial artificial JJ 35772 1170 8 , , , 35772 1170 9 and and CC 35772 1170 10 the the DT 35772 1170 11 questions question NNS 35772 1170 12 raised raise VBN 35772 1170 13 by by IN 35772 1170 14 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1170 15 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 35772 1170 16 , , , 35772 1170 17 to to IN 35772 1170 18 the the DT 35772 1170 19 eye eye NN 35772 1170 20 of of IN 35772 1170 21 " " `` 35772 1170 22 common common JJ 35772 1170 23 sense sense NN 35772 1170 24 " " '' 35772 1170 25 is be VBZ 35772 1170 26 an an DT 35772 1170 27 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 1170 28 consideration consideration NN 35772 1170 29 , , , 35772 1170 30 for for IN 35772 1170 31 " " `` 35772 1170 32 nothing nothing NN 35772 1170 33 stands stand VBZ 35772 1170 34 more more RBR 35772 1170 35 in in IN 35772 1170 36 need need NN 35772 1170 37 of of IN 35772 1170 38 demonstration demonstration NN 35772 1170 39 than than IN 35772 1170 40 the the DT 35772 1170 41 obvious obvious JJ 35772 1170 42 . . . 35772 1170 43 " " '' 35772 1171 1 NATURALISM NATURALISM NNP 35772 1171 2 CHECKED.--Thus CHECKED.--Thus NNP 35772 1171 3 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1171 4 and and CC 35772 1171 5 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1171 6 between between IN 35772 1171 7 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1171 8 , , , 35772 1171 9 merely merely RB 35772 1171 10 by by IN 35772 1171 11 adopting adopt VBG 35772 1171 12 a a DT 35772 1171 13 critical critical JJ 35772 1171 14 attitude attitude NN 35772 1171 15 , , , 35772 1171 16 created create VBD 35772 1171 17 an an DT 35772 1171 18 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 35772 1171 19 situation situation NN 35772 1171 20 for for IN 35772 1171 21 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1171 22 . . . 35772 1172 1 Between between IN 35772 1172 2 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1172 3 these these DT 35772 1172 4 writers writer NNS 35772 1172 5 administered administer VBD 35772 1172 6 a a DT 35772 1172 7 serious serious JJ 35772 1172 8 check check NN 35772 1172 9 to to IN 35772 1172 10 that that DT 35772 1172 11 naively naively RB 35772 1172 12 uncritical uncritical JJ 35772 1172 13 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1172 14 which which WDT 35772 1172 15 , , , 35772 1172 16 backed back VBN 35772 1172 17 by by IN 35772 1172 18 the the DT 35772 1172 19 prestige prestige NN 35772 1172 20 of of IN 35772 1172 21 natural natural JJ 35772 1172 22 science science NN 35772 1172 23 , , , 35772 1172 24 had have VBD 35772 1172 25 sought seek VBN 35772 1172 26 to to TO 35772 1172 27 impose impose VB 35772 1172 28 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1172 29 on on IN 35772 1172 30 the the DT 35772 1172 31 world world NN 35772 1172 32 as as IN 35772 1172 33 a a DT 35772 1172 34 new new JJ 35772 1172 35 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 35772 1172 36 less less RBR 35772 1172 37 liberal liberal JJ 35772 1172 38 , , , 35772 1172 39 in in IN 35772 1172 40 some some DT 35772 1172 41 ways way NNS 35772 1172 42 , , , 35772 1172 43 than than IN 35772 1172 44 the the DT 35772 1172 45 old old JJ 35772 1172 46 . . . 35772 1173 1 Nor nor CC 35772 1173 2 did do VBD 35772 1173 3 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1173 4 stop stop VB 35772 1173 5 short short RB 35772 1173 6 at at IN 35772 1173 7 negative negative JJ 35772 1173 8 criticism criticism NN 35772 1173 9 , , , 35772 1173 10 but but CC 35772 1173 11 substituted substitute VBN 35772 1173 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1173 13 according accord VBG 35772 1173 14 to to IN 35772 1173 15 the the DT 35772 1173 16 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1173 17 tradition tradition NN 35772 1173 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1173 19 a a DT 35772 1173 20 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1173 21 view view NN 35772 1173 22 of of IN 35772 1173 23 reality reality NN 35772 1173 24 for for IN 35772 1173 25 the the DT 35772 1173 26 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1173 27 materialism materialism NN 35772 1173 28 that that WDT 35772 1173 29 had have VBD 35772 1173 30 become become VBN 35772 1173 31 so so RB 35772 1173 32 popular popular JJ 35772 1173 33 . . . 35772 1174 1 _ _ NNP 35772 1174 2 Appearance Appearance NNP 35772 1174 3 and and CC 35772 1174 4 Reality Reality NNP 35772 1174 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1174 6 is be VBZ 35772 1174 7 a a DT 35772 1174 8 book book NN 35772 1174 9 of of IN 35772 1174 10 which which WDT 35772 1174 11 the the DT 35772 1174 12 trend trend NN 35772 1174 13 might may MD 35772 1174 14 seem seem VB 35772 1174 15 too too RB 35772 1174 16 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1174 17 , , , 35772 1174 18 but but CC 35772 1174 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1174 20 ends end VBZ 35772 1174 21 with with IN 35772 1174 22 a a DT 35772 1174 23 note note NN 35772 1174 24 that that WDT 35772 1174 25 is be VBZ 35772 1174 26 definite definite JJ 35772 1174 27 enough enough RB 35772 1174 28 : : : 35772 1174 29 " " `` 35772 1174 30 Outside outside NN 35772 1174 31 of of IN 35772 1174 32 spirit spirit NN 35772 1174 33 there there EX 35772 1174 34 is be VBZ 35772 1174 35 not not RB 35772 1174 36 , , , 35772 1174 37 and and CC 35772 1174 38 there there EX 35772 1174 39 can can MD 35772 1174 40 not not RB 35772 1174 41 be be VB 35772 1174 42 , , , 35772 1174 43 any any DT 35772 1174 44 reality reality NN 35772 1174 45 ; ; : 35772 1174 46 and and CC 35772 1174 47 , , , 35772 1174 48 the the DT 35772 1174 49 more more RBR 35772 1174 50 that that IN 35772 1174 51 anything anything NN 35772 1174 52 is be VBZ 35772 1174 53 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1174 54 , , , 35772 1174 55 so so RB 35772 1174 56 much much RB 35772 1174 57 the the DT 35772 1174 58 more more RBR 35772 1174 59 is be VBZ 35772 1174 60 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1174 61 veritably veritably RB 35772 1174 62 real real JJ 35772 1174 63 , , , 35772 1174 64 " " '' 35772 1174 65 are be VBP 35772 1174 66 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1174 67 's 's POS 35772 1174 68 closing closing NN 35772 1174 69 words word NNS 35772 1174 70 . . . 35772 1175 1 As as IN 35772 1175 2 for for IN 35772 1175 3 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1175 4 , , , 35772 1175 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1175 6 leads lead VBZ 35772 1175 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1175 8 readers reader NNS 35772 1175 9 up up IN 35772 1175 10 to to IN 35772 1175 11 a a DT 35772 1175 12 point point NN 35772 1175 13 which which WDT 35772 1175 14 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1175 15 describes describe VBZ 35772 1175 16 as as IN 35772 1175 17 " " `` 35772 1175 18 the the DT 35772 1175 19 threshold threshold NN 35772 1175 20 of of IN 35772 1175 21 Christian Christian NNP 35772 1175 22 Theology Theology NNP 35772 1175 23 . . . 35772 1175 24 " " '' 35772 1176 1 And and CC 35772 1176 2 having have VBG 35772 1176 3 propounded propound VBN 35772 1176 4 the the DT 35772 1176 5 perplexities perplexity NNS 35772 1176 6 in in IN 35772 1176 7 which which WDT 35772 1176 8 the the DT 35772 1176 9 " " `` 35772 1176 10 common common JJ 35772 1176 11 sense sense NN 35772 1176 12 " " '' 35772 1176 13 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1176 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1176 15 on on IN 35772 1176 16 which which WDT 35772 1176 17 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1176 18 depends depend VBZ 35772 1176 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1176 20 is be VBZ 35772 1176 21 involved involve VBN 35772 1176 22 , , , 35772 1176 23 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 24 says say VBZ 35772 1176 25 : : : 35772 1176 26 " " `` 35772 1176 27 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 28 do do VBP 35772 1176 29 not not RB 35772 1176 30 believe believe VB 35772 1176 31 that that IN 35772 1176 32 any any DT 35772 1176 33 escape escape NN 35772 1176 34 from from IN 35772 1176 35 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 36 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1176 37 the the DT 35772 1176 38 perplexities perplexity NNS 35772 1176 39 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1176 40 is be VBZ 35772 1176 41 possible possible JJ 35772 1176 42 , , , 35772 1176 43 unless unless IN 35772 1176 44 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 45 are be VBP 35772 1176 46 prepared prepared JJ 35772 1176 47 to to TO 35772 1176 48 bring bring VB 35772 1176 49 to to IN 35772 1176 50 the the DT 35772 1176 51 study study NN 35772 1176 52 of of IN 35772 1176 53 the the DT 35772 1176 54 world world NN 35772 1176 55 the the DT 35772 1176 56 presupposition presupposition NN 35772 1176 57 that that IN 35772 1176 58 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 59 was be VBD 35772 1176 60 the the DT 35772 1176 61 work work NN 35772 1176 62 of of IN 35772 1176 63 a a DT 35772 1176 64 rational rational JJ 35772 1176 65 Being Being NNP 35772 1176 66 , , , 35772 1176 67 who who WP 35772 1176 68 made make VBD 35772 1176 69 _ _ NNP 35772 1176 70 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 71 _ _ NNP 35772 1176 72 intelligible intelligible JJ 35772 1176 73 , , , 35772 1176 74 and and CC 35772 1176 75 at at IN 35772 1176 76 the the DT 35772 1176 77 same same JJ 35772 1176 78 time time NN 35772 1176 79 made make VBD 35772 1176 80 _ _ NNP 35772 1176 81 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 82 _ _ NNP 35772 1176 83 , , , 35772 1176 84 in in IN 35772 1176 85 however however RB 35772 1176 86 feeble feeble JJ 35772 1176 87 a a DT 35772 1176 88 fashion fashion NN 35772 1176 89 , , , 35772 1176 90 able able JJ 35772 1176 91 to to TO 35772 1176 92 understand understand VB 35772 1176 93 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1176 94 . . . 35772 1177 1 " " `` 35772 1177 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1177 3 50 50 CD 35772 1177 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1177 5 REVIVAL revival NN 35772 1177 6 OF of IN 35772 1177 7 IDEALISM IDEALISM NNP 35772 1177 8 IN in IN 35772 1177 9 GERMANY GERMANY NNP 35772 1177 10 . . . 35772 1178 1 LOTZE.--We LOTZE.--We NNP 35772 1178 2 have have VBP 35772 1178 3 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1178 4 dwelt dwell VBN 35772 1178 5 at at IN 35772 1178 6 too too RB 35772 1178 7 great great JJ 35772 1178 8 length length NN 35772 1178 9 upon upon IN 35772 1178 10 the the DT 35772 1178 11 backwash backwash NN 35772 1178 12 of of IN 35772 1178 13 the the DT 35772 1178 14 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1178 15 wave wave NN 35772 1178 16 in in IN 35772 1178 17 England England NNP 35772 1178 18 , , , 35772 1178 19 for for IN 35772 1178 20 idealism idealism NN 35772 1178 21 is be VBZ 35772 1178 22 not not RB 35772 1178 23 a a DT 35772 1178 24 native native JJ 35772 1178 25 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1178 26 amongst amongst IN 35772 1178 27 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1178 28 ; ; : 35772 1178 29 possibly possibly RB 35772 1178 30 , , , 35772 1178 31 because because IN 35772 1178 32 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1178 33 are be VBP 35772 1178 34 not not RB 35772 1178 35 metaphysically metaphysically RB 35772 1178 36 - - HYPH 35772 1178 37 minded minded JJ 35772 1178 38 in in IN 35772 1178 39 the the DT 35772 1178 40 same same JJ 35772 1178 41 sense sense NN 35772 1178 42 as as IN 35772 1178 43 are be VBP 35772 1178 44 the the DT 35772 1178 45 purer purer NN 35772 1178 46 Teutonic Teutonic NNP 35772 1178 47 breed breed NN 35772 1178 48 . . . 35772 1179 1 And and CC 35772 1179 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1179 3 is be VBZ 35772 1179 4 time time NN 35772 1179 5 to to TO 35772 1179 6 pass pass VB 35772 1179 7 on on RP 35772 1179 8 to to TO 35772 1179 9 pay pay VB 35772 1179 10 a a DT 35772 1179 11 brief brief JJ 35772 1179 12 tribute tribute NN 35772 1179 13 to to IN 35772 1179 14 the the DT 35772 1179 15 work work NN 35772 1179 16 of of IN 35772 1179 17 a a DT 35772 1179 18 German german JJ 35772 1179 19 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 1179 20 who who WP 35772 1179 21 accepted accept VBD 35772 1179 22 the the DT 35772 1179 23 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1179 24 theory theory NN 35772 1179 25 in in IN 35772 1179 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1179 27 totality totality NN 35772 1179 28 , , , 35772 1179 29 without without IN 35772 1179 30 sacrificing sacrifice VBG 35772 1179 31 what what WP 35772 1179 32 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1179 33 may may MD 35772 1179 34 call call VB 35772 1179 35 the the DT 35772 1179 36 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1179 37 values value NNS 35772 1179 38 of of IN 35772 1179 39 existence existence NN 35772 1179 40 . . . 35772 1180 1 Hermann Hermann NNP 35772 1180 2 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1180 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1180 4 1817 1817 CD 35772 1180 5 - - SYM 35772 1180 6 1881 1881 CD 35772 1180 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1180 8 was be VBD 35772 1180 9 inclined incline VBN 35772 1180 10 to to TO 35772 1180 11 feel feel VB 35772 1180 12 that that IN 35772 1180 13 the the DT 35772 1180 14 weakness weakness NN 35772 1180 15 of of IN 35772 1180 16 Romanticism Romanticism NNP 35772 1180 17 lay lie VBD 35772 1180 18 in in IN 35772 1180 19 a a DT 35772 1180 20 tendency tendency NN 35772 1180 21 to to TO 35772 1180 22 despise despise VB 35772 1180 23 or or CC 35772 1180 24 overlook overlook VB 35772 1180 25 what what WP 35772 1180 26 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1180 27 had have VBD 35772 1180 28 called call VBN 35772 1180 29 " " `` 35772 1180 30 the the DT 35772 1180 31 fertile fertile JJ 35772 1180 32 bathos bathos NN 35772 1180 33 of of IN 35772 1180 34 experience experience NN 35772 1180 35 . . . 35772 1180 36 " " '' 35772 1181 1 The the DT 35772 1181 2 Romanticists Romanticists NNPS 35772 1181 3 had have VBD 35772 1181 4 too too RB 35772 1181 5 often often RB 35772 1181 6 neglected neglect VBN 35772 1181 7 natural natural JJ 35772 1181 8 science science NN 35772 1181 9 , , , 35772 1181 10 which which WDT 35772 1181 11 , , , 35772 1181 12 in in IN 35772 1181 13 the the DT 35772 1181 14 shape shape NN 35772 1181 15 of of IN 35772 1181 16 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1181 17 materialism materialism NN 35772 1181 18 , , , 35772 1181 19 had have VBD 35772 1181 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1181 21 revenge revenge NN 35772 1181 22 by by IN 35772 1181 23 destroying destroy VBG 35772 1181 24 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1181 25 . . . 35772 1182 1 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 1182 2 was be VBD 35772 1182 3 the the DT 35772 1182 4 Nemesis Nemesis NNP 35772 1182 5 of of IN 35772 1182 6 an an DT 35772 1182 7 idealism idealism NN 35772 1182 8 which which WDT 35772 1182 9 was be VBD 35772 1182 10 at at IN 35772 1182 11 once once RB 35772 1182 12 vague vague JJ 35772 1182 13 and and CC 35772 1182 14 sentimental sentimental JJ 35772 1182 15 . . . 35772 1183 1 LOTZE LOTZE NNP 35772 1183 2 'S 's POS 35772 1183 3 " " `` 35772 1183 4 MICROCOSMOS MICROCOSMOS NNP 35772 1183 5 . . . 35772 1183 6 " " '' 35772 1184 1 --Lotze --Lotze : 35772 1184 2 's 's POS 35772 1184 3 attitude attitude NN 35772 1184 4 and and CC 35772 1184 5 method method NN 35772 1184 6 are be VBP 35772 1184 7 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 35772 1184 8 in in IN 35772 1184 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1184 10 well well RB 35772 1184 11 - - HYPH 35772 1184 12 known know VBN 35772 1184 13 work work NN 35772 1184 14 , , , 35772 1184 15 which which WDT 35772 1184 16 took take VBD 35772 1184 17 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1184 18 eight eight CD 35772 1184 19 years year NNS 35772 1184 20 to to TO 35772 1184 21 complete complete VB 35772 1184 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1184 23 1856 1856 CD 35772 1184 24 - - SYM 35772 1184 25 1864)--the 1864)--the NNP 35772 1184 26 _ _ NNP 35772 1184 27 Microcosmos Microcosmos NNP 35772 1184 28 _ _ NNP 35772 1184 29 . . . 35772 1185 1 After after IN 35772 1185 2 guiding guide VBG 35772 1185 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1185 4 readers reader NNS 35772 1185 5 " " '' 35772 1185 6 through through IN 35772 1185 7 the the DT 35772 1185 8 realms realm NNS 35772 1185 9 of of IN 35772 1185 10 natural natural JJ 35772 1185 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1185 12 and and CC 35772 1185 13 historical historical JJ 35772 1185 14 evolution evolution NN 35772 1185 15 , , , 35772 1185 16 " " '' 35772 1185 17 thus thus RB 35772 1185 18 constructing construct VBG 35772 1185 19 a a DT 35772 1185 20 sufficiently sufficiently RB 35772 1185 21 stable stable JJ 35772 1185 22 basis basis NN 35772 1185 23 out out IN 35772 1185 24 of of IN 35772 1185 25 _ _ NNP 35772 1185 26 facts_--he facts_--he NNP 35772 1185 27 leads lead VBZ 35772 1185 28 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1185 29 on on RP 35772 1185 30 to to IN 35772 1185 31 an an DT 35772 1185 32 ideal ideal JJ 35772 1185 33 world world NN 35772 1185 34 composed compose VBN 35772 1185 35 of of IN 35772 1185 36 what what WP 35772 1185 37 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1185 38 calls call VBZ 35772 1185 39 " " `` 35772 1185 40 values value NNS 35772 1185 41 . . . 35772 1185 42 " " '' 35772 1186 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1186 2 position position NN 35772 1186 3 may may MD 35772 1186 4 thus thus RB 35772 1186 5 be be VB 35772 1186 6 summarised summarise VBN 35772 1186 7 : : : 35772 1186 8 The the DT 35772 1186 9 world world NN 35772 1186 10 presents present VBZ 35772 1186 11 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1186 12 to to IN 35772 1186 13 the the DT 35772 1186 14 observer observer NN 35772 1186 15 in in IN 35772 1186 16 three three CD 35772 1186 17 aspects--(1 aspects--(1 NNS 35772 1186 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1186 19 The the DT 35772 1186 20 world world NN 35772 1186 21 of of IN 35772 1186 22 individual individual JJ 35772 1186 23 " " `` 35772 1186 24 things thing NNS 35772 1186 25 , , , 35772 1186 26 " " '' 35772 1186 27 which which WDT 35772 1186 28 are be VBP 35772 1186 29 bewildering bewilder VBG 35772 1186 30 and and CC 35772 1186 31 intricate intricate JJ 35772 1186 32 ; ; : 35772 1186 33 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1186 34 2 2 LS 35772 1186 35 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1186 36 the the DT 35772 1186 37 laws law NNS 35772 1186 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1186 39 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1186 40 , , , 35772 1186 41 " " `` 35772 1186 42 laws law NNS 35772 1186 43 of of IN 35772 1186 44 nature nature NN 35772 1186 45 " " '' 35772 1186 46 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1186 47 which which WDT 35772 1186 48 the the DT 35772 1186 49 human human JJ 35772 1186 50 intellect intellect NN 35772 1186 51 has have VBZ 35772 1186 52 discovered discover VBN 35772 1186 53 among among IN 35772 1186 54 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1186 55 , , , 35772 1186 56 thus thus RB 35772 1186 57 finding find VBG 35772 1186 58 regularity regularity NN 35772 1186 59 and and CC 35772 1186 60 order order NN 35772 1186 61 ; ; : 35772 1186 62 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1186 63 3 3 LS 35772 1186 64 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1186 65 the the DT 35772 1186 66 " " `` 35772 1186 67 values value NNS 35772 1186 68 " " '' 35772 1186 69 which which WDT 35772 1186 70 the the DT 35772 1186 71 human human JJ 35772 1186 72 soul soul NN 35772 1186 73 applies apply VBZ 35772 1186 74 to to IN 35772 1186 75 things thing NNS 35772 1186 76 , , , 35772 1186 77 and and CC 35772 1186 78 which which WDT 35772 1186 79 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1186 80 is be VBZ 35772 1186 81 the the DT 35772 1186 82 human human JJ 35772 1186 83 task task NN 35772 1186 84 to to TO 35772 1186 85 cultivate cultivate VB 35772 1186 86 . . . 35772 1187 1 This this DT 35772 1187 2 world world NN 35772 1187 3 of of IN 35772 1187 4 ideals ideal NNS 35772 1187 5 or or CC 35772 1187 6 values value NNS 35772 1187 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1187 8 3 3 CD 35772 1187 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1187 10 is be VBZ 35772 1187 11 that that DT 35772 1187 12 for for IN 35772 1187 13 the the DT 35772 1187 14 sake sake NN 35772 1187 15 of of IN 35772 1187 16 which which WDT 35772 1187 17 the the DT 35772 1187 18 worlds world NNS 35772 1187 19 of of IN 35772 1187 20 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1187 21 and and CC 35772 1187 22 law law NN 35772 1187 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1187 24 1 1 CD 35772 1187 25 and and CC 35772 1187 26 2 2 CD 35772 1187 27 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1187 28 exist exist VBP 35772 1187 29 . . . 35772 1188 1 These these DT 35772 1188 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1188 3 1 1 CD 35772 1188 4 and and CC 35772 1188 5 2 2 CD 35772 1188 6 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1188 7 constitute constitute VBP 35772 1188 8 respectively respectively RB 35772 1188 9 the the DT 35772 1188 10 material material NN 35772 1188 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1188 12 in in IN 35772 1188 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1188 14 which which WDT 35772 1188 15 , , , 35772 1188 16 and and CC 35772 1188 17 the the DT 35772 1188 18 forms form NNS 35772 1188 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1188 20 through through IN 35772 1188 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1188 22 which which WDT 35772 1188 23 , , , 35772 1188 24 the the DT 35772 1188 25 world world NN 35772 1188 26 of of IN 35772 1188 27 " " `` 35772 1188 28 values value NNS 35772 1188 29 " " '' 35772 1188 30 is be VBZ 35772 1188 31 to to TO 35772 1188 32 be be VB 35772 1188 33 realised realise VBN 35772 1188 34 . . . 35772 1189 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1189 2 51 51 CD 35772 1189 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1189 4 Thus thus RB 35772 1189 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1189 6 and and CC 35772 1189 7 law law NN 35772 1189 8 are be VBP 35772 1189 9 the the DT 35772 1189 10 raw raw JJ 35772 1189 11 material material NN 35772 1189 12 out out IN 35772 1189 13 of of IN 35772 1189 14 which which WDT 35772 1189 15 " " `` 35772 1189 16 values value NNS 35772 1189 17 " " '' 35772 1189 18 are be VBP 35772 1189 19 created create VBN 35772 1189 20 ; ; : 35772 1189 21 and and CC 35772 1189 22 these these DT 35772 1189 23 " " `` 35772 1189 24 values value NNS 35772 1189 25 " " '' 35772 1189 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1189 27 constitute constitute VBP 35772 1189 28 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1189 29 in in IN 35772 1189 30 the the DT 35772 1189 31 eyes eye NNS 35772 1189 32 of of IN 35772 1189 33 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1189 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1189 35 a a DT 35772 1189 36 higher high JJR 35772 1189 37 reality reality NN 35772 1189 38 . . . 35772 1190 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1190 2 the the DT 35772 1190 3 central central JJ 35772 1190 4 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 1190 5 of of IN 35772 1190 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1190 7 system system NN 35772 1190 8 is be VBZ 35772 1190 9 that that IN 35772 1190 10 the the DT 35772 1190 11 truly truly RB 35772 1190 12 Real real JJ 35772 1190 13 is be VBZ 35772 1190 14 what what WP 35772 1190 15 has have VBZ 35772 1190 16 supreme supreme NNP 35772 1190 17 worth worth NNP 35772 1190 18 : : : 35772 1190 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1190 20 is be VBZ 35772 1190 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1190 22 worth worth JJ 35772 1190 23 _ _ NNP 35772 1190 24 that that WDT 35772 1190 25 creates create VBZ 35772 1190 26 reality reality NN 35772 1190 27 . . . 35772 1191 1 The the DT 35772 1191 2 paradoxicality paradoxicality NN 35772 1191 3 of of IN 35772 1191 4 this this DT 35772 1191 5 may may MD 35772 1191 6 make make VB 35772 1191 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1191 8 difficult difficult JJ 35772 1191 9 to to TO 35772 1191 10 accept accept VB 35772 1191 11 ; ; : 35772 1191 12 but but CC 35772 1191 13 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1191 14 is be VBZ 35772 1191 15 only only RB 35772 1191 16 expressing express VBG 35772 1191 17 in in IN 35772 1191 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1191 19 own own JJ 35772 1191 20 way way NN 35772 1191 21 the the DT 35772 1191 22 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1191 23 thesis thesis NN 35772 1191 24 of of IN 35772 1191 25 all all DT 35772 1191 26 forms form NNS 35772 1191 27 of of IN 35772 1191 28 idealism idealism NN 35772 1191 29 , , , 35772 1191 30 that that IN 35772 1191 31 " " `` 35772 1191 32 the the DT 35772 1191 33 ideal ideal NN 35772 1191 34 is be VBZ 35772 1191 35 the the DT 35772 1191 36 real real JJ 35772 1191 37 " " '' 35772 1191 38 ; ; : 35772 1191 39 that that IN 35772 1191 40 the the DT 35772 1191 41 world world NN 35772 1191 42 of of IN 35772 1191 43 phenomena phenomena NNP 35772 1191 44 is be VBZ 35772 1191 45 secondary secondary JJ 35772 1191 46 to to IN 35772 1191 47 and and CC 35772 1191 48 dependent dependent JJ 35772 1191 49 upon upon IN 35772 1191 50 a a DT 35772 1191 51 " " `` 35772 1191 52 world world NN 35772 1191 53 of of IN 35772 1191 54 spirit spirit NN 35772 1191 55 , , , 35772 1191 56 " " '' 35772 1191 57 or or CC 35772 1191 58 an an DT 35772 1191 59 " " `` 35772 1191 60 ideal ideal JJ 35772 1191 61 world world NN 35772 1191 62 . . . 35772 1191 63 " " '' 35772 1192 1 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1192 2 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1192 3 in in IN 35772 1192 4 the the DT 35772 1192 5 introduction introduction NN 35772 1192 6 to to IN 35772 1192 7 the the DT 35772 1192 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 9 Microcosmos Microcosmos NNP 35772 1192 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 11 , , , 35772 1192 12 expresses express VBZ 35772 1192 13 what what WP 35772 1192 14 is be VBZ 35772 1192 15 at at IN 35772 1192 16 once once RB 35772 1192 17 the the DT 35772 1192 18 foundation foundation NN 35772 1192 19 and and CC 35772 1192 20 the the DT 35772 1192 21 kernel kernel NN 35772 1192 22 of of IN 35772 1192 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1192 24 system system NN 35772 1192 25 : : : 35772 1192 26 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1192 27 says say VBZ 35772 1192 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1192 29 is be VBZ 35772 1192 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1192 31 purpose purpose NN 35772 1192 32 to to TO 35772 1192 33 show show VB 35772 1192 34 " " `` 35772 1192 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 36 how how WRB 35772 1192 37 absolutely absolutely RB 35772 1192 38 universal universal JJ 35772 1192 39 is be VBZ 35772 1192 40 the the DT 35772 1192 41 extent extent NN 35772 1192 42 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 43 , , , 35772 1192 44 and and CC 35772 1192 45 at at IN 35772 1192 46 the the DT 35772 1192 47 same same JJ 35772 1192 48 time time NN 35772 1192 49 how how WRB 35772 1192 50 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 51 completely completely RB 35772 1192 52 subordinate subordinate VBP 35772 1192 53 the the DT 35772 1192 54 significance significance NN 35772 1192 55 , , , 35772 1192 56 of of IN 35772 1192 57 the the DT 35772 1192 58 mission mission NN 35772 1192 59 which which WDT 35772 1192 60 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1192 61 has have VBZ 35772 1192 62 to to TO 35772 1192 63 fulfil fulfil VB 35772 1192 64 in in IN 35772 1192 65 the the DT 35772 1192 66 structure structure NN 35772 1192 67 of of IN 35772 1192 68 the the DT 35772 1192 69 world world NN 35772 1192 70 _ _ NNP 35772 1192 71 . . . 35772 1192 72 " " '' 35772 1193 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1193 2 E.T. E.T. NNP 35772 1193 3 , , , 35772 1193 4 p. p. NN 35772 1194 1 xvi xvi NNP 35772 1194 2 . . . 35772 1194 3 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1195 1 Mechanism Mechanism NNP 35772 1195 2 is be VBZ 35772 1195 3 universal universal JJ 35772 1195 4 , , , 35772 1195 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1195 6 because because IN 35772 1195 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1195 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1195 9 is be VBZ 35772 1195 10 the the DT 35772 1195 11 raw raw JJ 35772 1195 12 material material NN 35772 1195 13 , , , 35772 1195 14 so so RB 35772 1195 15 to to TO 35772 1195 16 speak speak VB 35772 1195 17 , , , 35772 1195 18 out out IN 35772 1195 19 of of IN 35772 1195 20 which which WDT 35772 1195 21 reality reality NN 35772 1195 22 is be VBZ 35772 1195 23 to to TO 35772 1195 24 be be VB 35772 1195 25 made make VBN 35772 1195 26 . . . 35772 1196 1 That that DT 35772 1196 2 reality reality NN 35772 1196 3 can can MD 35772 1196 4 be be VB 35772 1196 5 expressed express VBN 35772 1196 6 in in IN 35772 1196 7 terms term NNS 35772 1196 8 of of IN 35772 1196 9 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1196 10 is be VBZ 35772 1196 11 true true JJ 35772 1196 12 , , , 35772 1196 13 just just RB 35772 1196 14 as as IN 35772 1196 15 a a DT 35772 1196 16 poem poem NN 35772 1196 17 can can MD 35772 1196 18 be be VB 35772 1196 19 described describe VBN 35772 1196 20 as as IN 35772 1196 21 a a DT 35772 1196 22 scrap scrap NN 35772 1196 23 of of IN 35772 1196 24 paper paper NN 35772 1196 25 scratched scratch VBN 35772 1196 26 upon upon IN 35772 1196 27 with with IN 35772 1196 28 a a DT 35772 1196 29 pen pen NN 35772 1196 30 ; ; : 35772 1196 31 but but CC 35772 1196 32 this this DT 35772 1196 33 reduction reduction NN 35772 1196 34 of of IN 35772 1196 35 reality reality NN 35772 1196 36 to to IN 35772 1196 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1196 38 lowest low JJS 35772 1196 39 terms term NNS 35772 1196 40 , , , 35772 1196 41 ends end VBZ 35772 1196 42 by by IN 35772 1196 43 emptying empty VBG 35772 1196 44 reality reality NN 35772 1196 45 of of IN 35772 1196 46 content content NN 35772 1196 47 . . . 35772 1197 1 Mechanism Mechanism NNP 35772 1197 2 is be VBZ 35772 1197 3 a a DT 35772 1197 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1197 5 universal universal JJ 35772 1197 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1197 7 feature feature NN 35772 1197 8 , , , 35772 1197 9 but but CC 35772 1197 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1197 11 is be VBZ 35772 1197 12 a a DT 35772 1197 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1197 14 subordinate subordinate JJ 35772 1197 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1197 16 feature feature NN 35772 1197 17 , , , 35772 1197 18 of of IN 35772 1197 19 reality reality NN 35772 1197 20 . . . 35772 1198 1 Nature nature NN 35772 1198 2 requires require VBZ 35772 1198 3 , , , 35772 1198 4 if if IN 35772 1198 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1198 6 are be VBP 35772 1198 7 to to TO 35772 1198 8 arrive arrive VB 35772 1198 9 at at IN 35772 1198 10 the the DT 35772 1198 11 truth truth NN 35772 1198 12 about about IN 35772 1198 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1198 14 , , , 35772 1198 15 not not RB 35772 1198 16 only only RB 35772 1198 17 to to TO 35772 1198 18 be be VB 35772 1198 19 described describe VBN 35772 1198 20 and and CC 35772 1198 21 analysed analyse VBN 35772 1198 22 , , , 35772 1198 23 but but CC 35772 1198 24 also also RB 35772 1198 25 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 1198 26 in in IN 35772 1198 27 the the DT 35772 1198 28 light light NN 35772 1198 29 of of IN 35772 1198 30 the the DT 35772 1198 31 idea idea NN 35772 1198 32 of of IN 35772 1198 33 _ _ NNP 35772 1198 34 value value NN 35772 1198 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1198 36 or or CC 35772 1198 37 _ _ NNP 35772 1198 38 worth worth JJ 35772 1198 39 _ _ NNP 35772 1198 40 . . . 35772 1199 1 LOTZE LOTZE NNP 35772 1199 2 AND and CC 35772 1199 3 THEOLOGY.--Lotze THEOLOGY.--Lotze NNP 35772 1199 4 's 's POS 35772 1199 5 theories theory NNS 35772 1199 6 exercised exercise VBD 35772 1199 7 an an DT 35772 1199 8 important important JJ 35772 1199 9 influence influence NN 35772 1199 10 upon upon IN 35772 1199 11 the the DT 35772 1199 12 development development NN 35772 1199 13 in in IN 35772 1199 14 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1199 15 and and CC 35772 1199 16 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1199 17 of of IN 35772 1199 18 a a DT 35772 1199 19 type type NN 35772 1199 20 of of IN 35772 1199 21 theology theology NN 35772 1199 22 known know VBN 35772 1199 23 as as IN 35772 1199 24 Ritschlianism Ritschlianism NNP 35772 1199 25 . . . 35772 1200 1 Albrecht Albrecht NNP 35772 1200 2 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 35772 1200 3 , , , 35772 1200 4 a a DT 35772 1200 5 disciple disciple NN 35772 1200 6 of of IN 35772 1200 7 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1200 8 , , , 35772 1200 9 attempted attempt VBD 35772 1200 10 to to TO 35772 1200 11 dissociate dissociate VB 35772 1200 12 religion religion NN 35772 1200 13 from from IN 35772 1200 14 metaphysics metaphysic NNS 35772 1200 15 , , , 35772 1200 16 and and CC 35772 1200 17 to to TO 35772 1200 18 base base VB 35772 1200 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1200 20 upon upon IN 35772 1200 21 " " `` 35772 1200 22 judgments judgment NNS 35772 1200 23 of of IN 35772 1200 24 value value NN 35772 1200 25 . . . 35772 1200 26 " " '' 35772 1201 1 Christian christian JJ 35772 1201 2 dogma dogma NN 35772 1201 3 , , , 35772 1201 4 for for IN 35772 1201 5 instance instance NN 35772 1201 6 , , , 35772 1201 7 is be VBZ 35772 1201 8 an an DT 35772 1201 9 attempt attempt NN 35772 1201 10 to to TO 35772 1201 11 express express VB 35772 1201 12 , , , 35772 1201 13 in in IN 35772 1201 14 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1201 15 terms term NNS 35772 1201 16 , , , 35772 1201 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1201 18 the the DT 35772 1201 19 unique unique JJ 35772 1201 20 value value NN 35772 1201 21 to to IN 35772 1201 22 humanity humanity NN 35772 1201 23 of of IN 35772 1201 24 the the DT 35772 1201 25 moral moral JJ 35772 1201 26 and and CC 35772 1201 27 religious religious JJ 35772 1201 28 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1201 29 of of IN 35772 1201 30 Christ Christ NNP 35772 1201 31 _ _ NNP 35772 1201 32 . . . 35772 1202 1 So so RB 35772 1202 2 far far RB 35772 1202 3 as as IN 35772 1202 4 a a DT 35772 1202 5 dogma dogma NN 35772 1202 6 is be VBZ 35772 1202 7 faithful faithful JJ 35772 1202 8 to to IN 35772 1202 9 that that DT 35772 1202 10 central central JJ 35772 1202 11 idea idea NN 35772 1202 12 , , , 35772 1202 13 and and CC 35772 1202 14 makes make VBZ 35772 1202 15 a a DT 35772 1202 16 genuine genuine JJ 35772 1202 17 attempt attempt NN 35772 1202 18 to to TO 35772 1202 19 express express VB 35772 1202 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1202 21 , , , 35772 1202 22 so so RB 35772 1202 23 far far RB 35772 1202 24 -- -- : 35772 1202 25 and and CC 35772 1202 26 so so RB 35772 1202 27 far far RB 35772 1202 28 only only RB 35772 1202 29 -- -- : 35772 1202 30 is be VBZ 35772 1202 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1202 32 true true JJ 35772 1202 33 . . . 35772 1203 1 This this DT 35772 1203 2 type type NN 35772 1203 3 of of IN 35772 1203 4 theology theology NN 35772 1203 5 , , , 35772 1203 6 uniting unite VBG 35772 1203 7 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1203 8 with with IN 35772 1203 9 certain certain JJ 35772 1203 10 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1203 11 tendencies tendency NNS 35772 1203 12 which which WDT 35772 1203 13 will will MD 35772 1203 14 engage engage VB 35772 1203 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1203 16 attention attention NN 35772 1203 17 later later RB 35772 1203 18 , , , 35772 1203 19 became become VBD 35772 1203 20 the the DT 35772 1203 21 basis basis NN 35772 1203 22 of of IN 35772 1203 23 what what WP 35772 1203 24 was be VBD 35772 1203 25 known know VBN 35772 1203 26 as as IN 35772 1203 27 the the DT 35772 1203 28 Modernist Modernist NNP 35772 1203 29 movement movement NN 35772 1203 30 in in IN 35772 1203 31 the the DT 35772 1203 32 Roman Roman NNP 35772 1203 33 Catholic Catholic NNP 35772 1203 34 Church Church NNP 35772 1203 35 . . . 35772 1204 1 CONCLUSIONS.--Thus CONCLUSIONS.--Thus NNP 35772 1204 2 in in IN 35772 1204 3 the the DT 35772 1204 4 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1204 5 century century NN 35772 1204 6 , , , 35772 1204 7 in in IN 35772 1204 8 England England NNP 35772 1204 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1204 10 and and CC 35772 1204 11 indeed indeed RB 35772 1204 12 on on IN 35772 1204 13 the the DT 35772 1204 14 continent continent NN 35772 1204 15 also also RB 35772 1204 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1204 17 the the DT 35772 1204 18 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1204 19 attitude attitude NN 35772 1204 20 , , , 35772 1204 21 though though IN 35772 1204 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1204 23 sometimes sometimes RB 35772 1204 24 might may MD 35772 1204 25 seem seem VB 35772 1204 26 compromised compromise VBN 35772 1204 27 , , , 35772 1204 28 was be VBD 35772 1204 29 never never RB 35772 1204 30 submerged submerge VBN 35772 1204 31 ; ; : 35772 1204 32 in in IN 35772 1204 33 spite spite NN 35772 1204 34 of of IN 35772 1204 35 the the DT 35772 1204 36 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 1204 37 outlook outlook NN 35772 1204 38 of of IN 35772 1204 39 an an DT 35772 1204 40 age age NN 35772 1204 41 only only RB 35772 1204 42 too too RB 35772 1204 43 preoccupied preoccupied JJ 35772 1204 44 with with IN 35772 1204 45 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1204 46 discovery discovery NN 35772 1204 47 and and CC 35772 1204 48 commercial commercial JJ 35772 1204 49 expansion expansion NN 35772 1204 50 . . . 35772 1205 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 1205 2 XI XI NNP 35772 1205 3 SOME some VBP 35772 1205 4 RECENT recent JJ 35772 1205 5 TENDENCIES tendency NNS 35772 1205 6 IN in IN 35772 1205 7 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 35772 1205 8 THE the DT 35772 1205 9 PHILOSOPHY PHILOSOPHY NNS 35772 1205 10 OF of IN 35772 1205 11 SCIENCE.--In science.--in NN 35772 1205 12 the the DT 35772 1205 13 last last JJ 35772 1205 14 chapter chapter NN 35772 1205 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1205 16 heard hear VBD 35772 1205 17 A. a. NN 35772 1205 18 J. J. NNP 35772 1205 19 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1205 20 complaining complain VBG 35772 1205 21 of of IN 35772 1205 22 the the DT 35772 1205 23 absence absence NN 35772 1205 24 of of IN 35772 1205 25 " " `` 35772 1205 26 a a DT 35772 1205 27 full full JJ 35772 1205 28 and and CC 35772 1205 29 systematic systematic JJ 35772 1205 30 attempt attempt NN 35772 1205 31 , , , 35772 1205 32 first first RB 35772 1205 33 to to TO 35772 1205 34 enumerate enumerate VB 35772 1205 35 , , , 35772 1205 36 and and CC 35772 1205 37 then then RB 35772 1205 38 to to TO 35772 1205 39 justify justify VB 35772 1205 40 , , , 35772 1205 41 the the DT 35772 1205 42 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 1205 43 on on IN 35772 1205 44 which which WDT 35772 1205 45 all all DT 35772 1205 46 science science NN 35772 1205 47 finally finally RB 35772 1205 48 rests rest VBZ 35772 1205 49 . . . 35772 1205 50 " " '' 35772 1206 1 And and CC 35772 1206 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 1206 3 F. F. NNP 35772 1206 4 H. H. NNP 35772 1206 5 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1206 6 also also RB 35772 1206 7 drew draw VBD 35772 1206 8 attention attention NN 35772 1206 9 to to IN 35772 1206 10 the the DT 35772 1206 11 absence absence NN 35772 1206 12 of of IN 35772 1206 13 any any DT 35772 1206 14 critical critical JJ 35772 1206 15 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1206 16 of of IN 35772 1206 17 science science NN 35772 1206 18 in in IN 35772 1206 19 England England NNP 35772 1206 20 . . . 35772 1207 1 The the DT 35772 1207 2 need need NN 35772 1207 3 was be VBD 35772 1207 4 for for IN 35772 1207 5 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1207 6 standpoints standpoint NNS 35772 1207 7 to to TO 35772 1207 8 be be VB 35772 1207 9 investigated investigate VBN 35772 1207 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1207 11 de de NNP 35772 1207 12 novo novo NNP 35772 1207 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1207 14 ; ; : 35772 1207 15 and and CC 35772 1207 16 the the DT 35772 1207 17 process process NN 35772 1207 18 had have VBD 35772 1207 19 , , , 35772 1207 20 as as IN 35772 1207 21 a a DT 35772 1207 22 matter matter NN 35772 1207 23 of of IN 35772 1207 24 fact fact NN 35772 1207 25 , , , 35772 1207 26 already already RB 35772 1207 27 been be VBN 35772 1207 28 begun begin VBN 35772 1207 29 on on IN 35772 1207 30 the the DT 35772 1207 31 Continent continent NN 35772 1207 32 . . . 35772 1208 1 MACH.--Ernst MACH.--Ernst NNP 35772 1208 2 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1208 3 , , , 35772 1208 4 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1208 5 of of IN 35772 1208 6 Physics Physics NNP 35772 1208 7 at at IN 35772 1208 8 Prague Prague NNP 35772 1208 9 , , , 35772 1208 10 and and CC 35772 1208 11 subsequently subsequently RB 35772 1208 12 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1208 13 of of IN 35772 1208 14 Physics Physics NNP 35772 1208 15 at at IN 35772 1208 16 Vienna Vienna NNP 35772 1208 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1208 18 thus thus RB 35772 1208 19 combining combine VBG 35772 1208 20 the the DT 35772 1208 21 roles role NNS 35772 1208 22 of of IN 35772 1208 23 scientist scientist NN 35772 1208 24 and and CC 35772 1208 25 metaphysician metaphysician NN 35772 1208 26 -- -- : 35772 1208 27 always always RB 35772 1208 28 a a DT 35772 1208 29 highly highly RB 35772 1208 30 instructive instructive JJ 35772 1208 31 and and CC 35772 1208 32 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 1208 33 combination combination NN 35772 1208 34 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1208 35 had have VBD 35772 1208 36 as as RB 35772 1208 37 early early JJ 35772 1208 38 as as IN 35772 1208 39 1863 1863 CD 35772 1208 40 laid lay VBD 35772 1208 41 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1208 42 down down RP 35772 1208 43 as as IN 35772 1208 44 the the DT 35772 1208 45 task task NN 35772 1208 46 of of IN 35772 1208 47 science science NN 35772 1208 48 to to TO 35772 1208 49 give give VB 35772 1208 50 " " `` 35772 1208 51 an an DT 35772 1208 52 economic economic JJ 35772 1208 53 presentation presentation NN 35772 1208 54 of of IN 35772 1208 55 the the DT 35772 1208 56 facts fact NNS 35772 1208 57 . . . 35772 1208 58 " " '' 35772 1209 1 By by IN 35772 1209 2 which which WDT 35772 1209 3 phrase phrase NN 35772 1209 4 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1209 5 meant mean VBD 35772 1209 6 that that IN 35772 1209 7 science science NN 35772 1209 8 takes take VBZ 35772 1209 9 account account NN 35772 1209 10 only only RB 35772 1209 11 of of IN 35772 1209 12 the the DT 35772 1209 13 salient salient NN 35772 1209 14 features feature NNS 35772 1209 15 of of IN 35772 1209 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1209 17 , , , 35772 1209 18 selecting select VBG 35772 1209 19 only only RB 35772 1209 20 those those DT 35772 1209 21 which which WDT 35772 1209 22 seem seem VBP 35772 1209 23 strictly strictly RB 35772 1209 24 serviceable serviceable JJ 35772 1209 25 to to IN 35772 1209 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1209 27 own own JJ 35772 1209 28 purpose purpose NN 35772 1209 29 . . . 35772 1210 1 SCIENCE science NN 35772 1210 2 " " `` 35772 1210 3 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT NNP 35772 1210 4 " " '' 35772 1210 5 OR or CC 35772 1210 6 " " '' 35772 1210 7 SELECTIVE selective RB 35772 1210 8 . . . 35772 1210 9 " " '' 35772 1211 1 --Mathematical --Mathematical : 35772 1211 2 science science NN 35772 1211 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1211 4 which which WDT 35772 1211 5 is be VBZ 35772 1211 6 the the DT 35772 1211 7 " " `` 35772 1211 8 pure pure JJ 35772 1211 9 " " '' 35772 1211 10 science science NN 35772 1211 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1211 12 par par NN 35772 1211 13 excellence excellence NN 35772 1211 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1211 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1211 16 deals deal NNS 35772 1211 17 not not RB 35772 1211 18 -- -- : 35772 1211 19 as as IN 35772 1211 20 is be VBZ 35772 1211 21 generally generally RB 35772 1211 22 supposed suppose VBN 35772 1211 23 -- -- : 35772 1211 24 with with IN 35772 1211 25 " " `` 35772 1211 26 things thing NNS 35772 1211 27 , , , 35772 1211 28 " " '' 35772 1211 29 but but CC 35772 1211 30 with with IN 35772 1211 31 _ _ NNP 35772 1211 32 certain certain JJ 35772 1211 33 selected select VBN 35772 1211 34 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1211 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1211 36 of of IN 35772 1211 37 things thing NNS 35772 1211 38 . . . 35772 1212 1 For for IN 35772 1212 2 example example NN 35772 1212 3 , , , 35772 1212 4 for for IN 35772 1212 5 purposes purpose NNS 35772 1212 6 of of IN 35772 1212 7 arithmetic arithmetic JJ 35772 1212 8 , , , 35772 1212 9 every every DT 35772 1212 10 leaf leaf NN 35772 1212 11 on on IN 35772 1212 12 a a DT 35772 1212 13 tree tree NN 35772 1212 14 is be VBZ 35772 1212 15 an an DT 35772 1212 16 " " `` 35772 1212 17 unit unit NN 35772 1212 18 " " '' 35772 1212 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1212 20 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1213 1 all all DT 35772 1213 2 are be VBP 35772 1213 3 " " `` 35772 1213 4 identical identical JJ 35772 1213 5 " " '' 35772 1213 6 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1213 7 ; ; : 35772 1213 8 but but CC 35772 1213 9 , , , 35772 1213 10 in in IN 35772 1213 11 point point NN 35772 1213 12 of of IN 35772 1213 13 fact fact NN 35772 1213 14 , , , 35772 1213 15 there there EX 35772 1213 16 exist exist VBP 35772 1213 17 no no DT 35772 1213 18 two two CD 35772 1213 19 leaves leave NNS 35772 1213 20 that that WDT 35772 1213 21 are be VBP 35772 1213 22 alike alike RB 35772 1213 23 , , , 35772 1213 24 as as IN 35772 1213 25 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 1213 26 , , , 35772 1213 27 long long RB 35772 1213 28 ago ago RB 35772 1213 29 , , , 35772 1213 30 pointed point VBD 35772 1213 31 out out RP 35772 1213 32 . . . 35772 1214 1 Again again RB 35772 1214 2 , , , 35772 1214 3 for for IN 35772 1214 4 geometrical geometrical JJ 35772 1214 5 purposes purpose NNS 35772 1214 6 two two CD 35772 1214 7 fields field NNS 35772 1214 8 may may MD 35772 1214 9 be be VB 35772 1214 10 regarded regard VBN 35772 1214 11 as as IN 35772 1214 12 of of IN 35772 1214 13 like like IN 35772 1214 14 area area NN 35772 1214 15 ; ; : 35772 1214 16 but but CC 35772 1214 17 no no DT 35772 1214 18 two two CD 35772 1214 19 fields field NNS 35772 1214 20 are be VBP 35772 1214 21 , , , 35772 1214 22 or or CC 35772 1214 23 ever ever RB 35772 1214 24 have have VBP 35772 1214 25 been be VBN 35772 1214 26 , , , 35772 1214 27 so so RB 35772 1214 28 . . . 35772 1215 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1215 2 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 1215 3 -- -- : 35772 1215 4 where where WRB 35772 1215 5 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1215 6 method method NN 35772 1215 7 is be VBZ 35772 1215 8 seen see VBN 35772 1215 9 at at IN 35772 1215 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1215 11 purest pure JJS 35772 1215 12 -- -- : 35772 1215 13 proceeds proceed NNS 35772 1215 14 by by IN 35772 1215 15 deliberately deliberately RB 35772 1215 16 disregarding disregard VBG 35772 1215 17 individuality individuality NN 35772 1215 18 ; ; : 35772 1215 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1215 20 regards regard VBZ 35772 1215 21 the the DT 35772 1215 22 differences difference NNS 35772 1215 23 between between IN 35772 1215 24 individuals individual NNS 35772 1215 25 as as IN 35772 1215 26 non non JJ 35772 1215 27 - - JJ 35772 1215 28 essential essential JJ 35772 1215 29 , , , 35772 1215 30 and and CC 35772 1215 31 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 1215 32 to to IN 35772 1215 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1215 34 purpose purpose NN 35772 1215 35 . . . 35772 1216 1 ECONOMY ECONOMY NNS 35772 1216 2 OF of IN 35772 1216 3 THOUGHT.--And thought.--and JJ 35772 1216 4 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 1216 5 science science NN 35772 1216 6 is be VBZ 35772 1216 7 justified justify VBN 35772 1216 8 in in IN 35772 1216 9 acting act VBG 35772 1216 10 in in IN 35772 1216 11 this this DT 35772 1216 12 way way NN 35772 1216 13 . . . 35772 1217 1 This this DT 35772 1217 2 method method NN 35772 1217 3 , , , 35772 1217 4 highly highly RB 35772 1217 5 abstract abstract JJ 35772 1217 6 as as IN 35772 1217 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1217 8 is be VBZ 35772 1217 9 -- -- : 35772 1217 10 in in IN 35772 1217 11 fact fact NN 35772 1217 12 , , , 35772 1217 13 just just RB 35772 1217 14 because because IN 35772 1217 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1217 16 is be VBZ 35772 1217 17 highly highly RB 35772 1217 18 abstract abstract JJ 35772 1217 19 -- -- : 35772 1217 20 leads lead VBZ 35772 1217 21 to to IN 35772 1217 22 invaluable invaluable JJ 35772 1217 23 results result NNS 35772 1217 24 . . . 35772 1218 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1218 2 's be VBZ 35772 1218 3 justification justification NN 35772 1218 4 is be VBZ 35772 1218 5 that that IN 35772 1218 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1218 7 is be VBZ 35772 1218 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1218 9 economical economical JJ 35772 1218 10 of of IN 35772 1218 11 thought thought NN 35772 1218 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1218 13 ; ; : 35772 1218 14 disregarding disregard VBG 35772 1218 15 all all DT 35772 1218 16 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 35772 1218 17 considerations consideration NNS 35772 1218 18 , , , 35772 1218 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1218 20 is be VBZ 35772 1218 21 able able JJ 35772 1218 22 , , , 35772 1218 23 by by IN 35772 1218 24 using use VBG 35772 1218 25 a a DT 35772 1218 26 short short RB 35772 1218 27 - - HYPH 35772 1218 28 cut cut NN 35772 1218 29 , , , 35772 1218 30 to to TO 35772 1218 31 reach reach VB 35772 1218 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1218 33 goal goal NN 35772 1218 34 . . . 35772 1219 1 Did do VBD 35772 1219 2 the the DT 35772 1219 3 mathematician mathematician NN 35772 1219 4 have have VB 35772 1219 5 to to TO 35772 1219 6 take take VB 35772 1219 7 into into IN 35772 1219 8 consideration consideration NN 35772 1219 9 all all PDT 35772 1219 10 the the DT 35772 1219 11 manifold manifold JJ 35772 1219 12 and and CC 35772 1219 13 complex complex JJ 35772 1219 14 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1219 15 of of IN 35772 1219 16 each each DT 35772 1219 17 concrete concrete JJ 35772 1219 18 " " `` 35772 1219 19 thing thing NN 35772 1219 20 " " '' 35772 1219 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1219 22 whether whether IN 35772 1219 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1219 24 be be VBP 35772 1219 25 leaf leaf NN 35772 1219 26 , , , 35772 1219 27 or or CC 35772 1219 28 field field NN 35772 1219 29 , , , 35772 1219 30 or or CC 35772 1219 31 lever lever NN 35772 1219 32 , , , 35772 1219 33 or or CC 35772 1219 34 what what WP 35772 1219 35 not not RB 35772 1219 36 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1219 37 with with IN 35772 1219 38 which which WDT 35772 1219 39 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1219 40 deals deal VBZ 35772 1219 41 , , , 35772 1219 42 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1219 43 would would MD 35772 1219 44 never never RB 35772 1219 45 be be VB 35772 1219 46 able able JJ 35772 1219 47 to to TO 35772 1219 48 cut cut VB 35772 1219 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1219 50 way way NN 35772 1219 51 through through IN 35772 1219 52 the the DT 35772 1219 53 jungle jungle NN 35772 1219 54 . . . 35772 1220 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1220 2 method method NN 35772 1220 3 of of IN 35772 1220 4 abstraction abstraction NN 35772 1220 5 carries carry VBZ 35772 1220 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1220 7 at at IN 35772 1220 8 once once RB 35772 1220 9 to to IN 35772 1220 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1220 11 goal goal NN 35772 1220 12 . . . 35772 1221 1 MACH MACH NNP 35772 1221 2 ON on IN 35772 1221 3 THE the DT 35772 1221 4 " " `` 35772 1221 5 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 1221 6 VIEW VIEW NNP 35772 1221 7 . . . 35772 1221 8 " " '' 35772 1222 1 --Mach --Mach NNP 35772 1222 2 's 's POS 35772 1222 3 criticism criticism NN 35772 1222 4 of of IN 35772 1222 5 the the DT 35772 1222 6 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1222 7 view view NN 35772 1222 8 of of IN 35772 1222 9 nature nature NN 35772 1222 10 proceeded proceed VBN 35772 1222 11 upon upon IN 35772 1222 12 similar similar JJ 35772 1222 13 lines line NNS 35772 1222 14 . . . 35772 1223 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1223 2 termed term VBD 35772 1223 3 that that DT 35772 1223 4 view view NN 35772 1223 5 " " `` 35772 1223 6 analogical analogical JJ 35772 1223 7 , , , 35772 1223 8 " " '' 35772 1223 9 by by IN 35772 1223 10 which which WDT 35772 1223 11 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1223 12 meant mean VBD 35772 1223 13 that that IN 35772 1223 14 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1223 15 " " `` 35772 1223 16 laws law NNS 35772 1223 17 of of IN 35772 1223 18 nature nature NN 35772 1223 19 " " `` 35772 1223 20 serve serve VBP 35772 1223 21 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1223 22 as as IN 35772 1223 23 formal formal JJ 35772 1223 24 patterns pattern NNS 35772 1223 25 to to TO 35772 1223 26 which which WDT 35772 1223 27 the the DT 35772 1223 28 processes process NNS 35772 1223 29 of of IN 35772 1223 30 nature nature NN 35772 1223 31 may may MD 35772 1223 32 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1223 33 for for IN 35772 1223 34 convenience convenience NN 35772 1223 35 sake sake NN 35772 1223 36 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1223 37 be be VB 35772 1223 38 represented represent VBN 35772 1223 39 as as IN 35772 1223 40 conforming conform VBG 35772 1223 41 . . . 35772 1224 1 A a DT 35772 1224 2 clear clear JJ 35772 1224 3 account account NN 35772 1224 4 , , , 35772 1224 5 though though IN 35772 1224 6 not not RB 35772 1224 7 a a DT 35772 1224 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1224 9 complete complete JJ 35772 1224 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1224 11 account account NN 35772 1224 12 , , , 35772 1224 13 of of IN 35772 1224 14 all all DT 35772 1224 15 physical physical JJ 35772 1224 16 processes process NNS 35772 1224 17 may may MD 35772 1224 18 be be VB 35772 1224 19 given give VBN 35772 1224 20 in in IN 35772 1224 21 terms term NNS 35772 1224 22 of of IN 35772 1224 23 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1224 24 " " `` 35772 1224 25 law law NN 35772 1224 26 . . . 35772 1224 27 " " '' 35772 1225 1 And and CC 35772 1225 2 in in IN 35772 1225 3 fact fact NN 35772 1225 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1225 5 remains remain VBZ 35772 1225 6 a a DT 35772 1225 7 question question NN 35772 1225 8 , , , 35772 1225 9 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1225 10 observed observe VBD 35772 1225 11 , , , 35772 1225 12 " " `` 35772 1225 13 whether whether IN 35772 1225 14 the the DT 35772 1225 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1225 16 view view NN 35772 1225 17 of of IN 35772 1225 18 things thing NNS 35772 1225 19 , , , 35772 1225 20 instead instead RB 35772 1225 21 of of IN 35772 1225 22 being be VBG 35772 1225 23 the the DT 35772 1225 24 profoundest profoundest NN 35772 1225 25 , , , 35772 1225 26 is be VBZ 35772 1225 27 not not RB 35772 1225 28 in in IN 35772 1225 29 point point NN 35772 1225 30 of of IN 35772 1225 31 fact fact NN 35772 1225 32 , , , 35772 1225 33 the the DT 35772 1225 34 shallowest shallow JJS 35772 1225 35 of of IN 35772 1225 36 all all DT 35772 1225 37 . . . 35772 1226 1 " " `` 35772 1226 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1226 3 52 52 CD 35772 1226 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1226 5 SCIENCE science NN 35772 1226 6 NOT not RB 35772 1226 7 INVALID invalid JJ 35772 1226 8 BUT but CC 35772 1226 9 INCOMPLETE.--This incomplete.--this DT 35772 1226 10 line line NN 35772 1226 11 of of IN 35772 1226 12 criticism criticism NN 35772 1226 13 of of IN 35772 1226 14 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1226 15 method method NN 35772 1226 16 -- -- : 35772 1226 17 i.e i.e XX 35772 1226 18 . . . 35772 1227 1 that that IN 35772 1227 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1227 3 deals deal VBZ 35772 1227 4 with with IN 35772 1227 5 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1227 6 and and CC 35772 1227 7 analogies analogy NNS 35772 1227 8 rather rather RB 35772 1227 9 than than IN 35772 1227 10 with with IN 35772 1227 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1227 12 things thing NNS 35772 1227 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1227 14 , , , 35772 1227 15 for for IN 35772 1227 16 the the DT 35772 1227 17 sake sake NN 35772 1227 18 of of IN 35772 1227 19 economy economy NN 35772 1227 20 and and CC 35772 1227 21 convenience convenience NN 35772 1227 22 of of IN 35772 1227 23 thought thought NN 35772 1227 24 -- -- : 35772 1227 25 does do VBZ 35772 1227 26 not not RB 35772 1227 27 deprive deprive VB 35772 1227 28 science science NN 35772 1227 29 of of IN 35772 1227 30 validity validity NN 35772 1227 31 , , , 35772 1227 32 but but CC 35772 1227 33 only only RB 35772 1227 34 invalidates invalidate VBZ 35772 1227 35 that that IN 35772 1227 36 superficial superficial JJ 35772 1227 37 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1227 38 which which WDT 35772 1227 39 had have VBD 35772 1227 40 crept creep VBN 35772 1227 41 into into IN 35772 1227 42 so so RB 35772 1227 43 many many JJ 35772 1227 44 investigations investigation NNS 35772 1227 45 . . . 35772 1228 1 A a DT 35772 1228 2 critical critical JJ 35772 1228 3 estimate estimate NN 35772 1228 4 of of IN 35772 1228 5 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1228 6 methods method NNS 35772 1228 7 makes make VBZ 35772 1228 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1228 9 evident evident JJ 35772 1228 10 how how WRB 35772 1228 11 much much JJ 35772 1228 12 and and CC 35772 1228 13 how how WRB 35772 1228 14 little little JJ 35772 1228 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1228 16 have have VBP 35772 1228 17 the the DT 35772 1228 18 right right NN 35772 1228 19 to to TO 35772 1228 20 expect expect VB 35772 1228 21 from from IN 35772 1228 22 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1228 23 . . . 35772 1229 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1229 2 will will MD 35772 1229 3 enable enable VB 35772 1229 4 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1229 5 to to TO 35772 1229 6 give give VB 35772 1229 7 a a DT 35772 1229 8 simple simple JJ 35772 1229 9 description description NN 35772 1229 10 of of IN 35772 1229 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1229 12 phenomena phenomena NN 35772 1229 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1229 14 as as IN 35772 1229 15 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1229 16 are be VBP 35772 1229 17 seen see VBN 35772 1229 18 when when WRB 35772 1229 19 reduced reduce VBN 35772 1229 20 to to IN 35772 1229 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1229 22 simplest simple JJS 35772 1229 23 terms term NNS 35772 1229 24 of of IN 35772 1229 25 matter matter NN 35772 1229 26 and and CC 35772 1229 27 motion motion NN 35772 1229 28 ; ; : 35772 1229 29 but but CC 35772 1229 30 of of IN 35772 1229 31 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 1229 32 and and CC 35772 1229 33 final final JJ 35772 1229 34 causes cause NNS 35772 1229 35 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1229 36 will will MD 35772 1229 37 tell tell VB 35772 1229 38 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1229 39 nothing nothing NN 35772 1229 40 . . . 35772 1230 1 " " `` 35772 1230 2 The the DT 35772 1230 3 system system NN 35772 1230 4 of of IN 35772 1230 5 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1230 6 by by IN 35772 1230 7 which which WDT 35772 1230 8 the the DT 35772 1230 9 exact exact JJ 35772 1230 10 sciences science NNS 35772 1230 11 try try VBP 35772 1230 12 to to TO 35772 1230 13 describe describe VB 35772 1230 14 the the DT 35772 1230 15 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1230 16 of of IN 35772 1230 17 nature nature NN 35772 1230 18 ... ... : 35772 1230 19 is be VBZ 35772 1230 20 symbolic symbolic JJ 35772 1230 21 , , , 35772 1230 22 a a DT 35772 1230 23 kind kind NN 35772 1230 24 of of IN 35772 1230 25 shorthand shorthand NN 35772 1230 26 , , , 35772 1230 27 unconsciously unconsciously RB 35772 1230 28 invented invent VBN 35772 1230 29 and and CC 35772 1230 30 perfected perfect VBN 35772 1230 31 for for IN 35772 1230 32 the the DT 35772 1230 33 sake sake NN 35772 1230 34 of of IN 35772 1230 35 convenience convenience NN 35772 1230 36 and and CC 35772 1230 37 for for IN 35772 1230 38 practical practical JJ 35772 1230 39 use use NN 35772 1230 40 ... ... : 35772 1230 41 the the DT 35772 1230 42 leading lead VBG 35772 1230 43 principle principle NN 35772 1230 44 is be VBZ 35772 1230 45 that that DT 35772 1230 46 of of IN 35772 1230 47 Economy economy NN 35772 1230 48 of of IN 35772 1230 49 Thought Thought NNP 35772 1230 50 " " '' 35772 1230 51 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1230 52 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1230 53 , , , 35772 1230 54 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1230 55 . . . 35772 1231 1 III III NNP 35772 1231 2 , , , 35772 1231 3 p. p. NN 35772 1231 4 579 579 CD 35772 1231 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1231 6 . . . 35772 1232 1 BOUTROUX.--This boutroux.--this NN 35772 1232 2 criticism criticism NN 35772 1232 3 of of IN 35772 1232 4 the the DT 35772 1232 5 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1232 6 method method NN 35772 1232 7 of of IN 35772 1232 8 dealing deal VBG 35772 1232 9 with with IN 35772 1232 10 reality reality NN 35772 1232 11 was be VBD 35772 1232 12 seconded second VBN 35772 1232 13 by by IN 35772 1232 14 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1232 15 's 's POS 35772 1232 16 criticism criticism NN 35772 1232 17 of of IN 35772 1232 18 the the DT 35772 1232 19 principle principle NN 35772 1232 20 of of IN 35772 1232 21 Natural Natural NNP 35772 1232 22 Law Law NNP 35772 1232 23 . . . 35772 1233 1 Émile émile NN 35772 1233 2 Boutroux boutroux NN 35772 1233 3 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1233 4 1845 1845 CD 35772 1233 5 - - SYM 35772 1233 6 1918)--Professor 1918)--professor CD 35772 1233 7 at at IN 35772 1233 8 the the DT 35772 1233 9 Sorbonne Sorbonne NNP 35772 1233 10 -- -- : 35772 1233 11 in in IN 35772 1233 12 two two CD 35772 1233 13 important important JJ 35772 1233 14 treatises treatise NNS 35772 1233 15 , , , 35772 1233 16 examines examine VBZ 35772 1233 17 with with IN 35772 1233 18 great great JJ 35772 1233 19 minuteness minuteness NN 35772 1233 20 this this DT 35772 1233 21 aspect aspect NN 35772 1233 22 of of IN 35772 1233 23 the the DT 35772 1233 24 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1233 25 method method NN 35772 1233 26 . . . 35772 1234 1 In in IN 35772 1234 2 the the DT 35772 1234 3 earlier early JJR 35772 1234 4 of of IN 35772 1234 5 these these DT 35772 1234 6 works work NNS 35772 1234 7 , , , 35772 1234 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1234 9 The the DT 35772 1234 10 Contingency Contingency NNP 35772 1234 11 of of IN 35772 1234 12 the the DT 35772 1234 13 Laws Laws NNPS 35772 1234 14 of of IN 35772 1234 15 Nature Nature NNP 35772 1234 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1234 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1234 18 1879 1879 CD 35772 1234 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1234 20 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1234 21 suggests suggest VBZ 35772 1234 22 that that IN 35772 1234 23 these these DT 35772 1234 24 laws law NNS 35772 1234 25 only only RB 35772 1234 26 give give VBP 35772 1234 27 , , , 35772 1234 28 so so RB 35772 1234 29 to to TO 35772 1234 30 speak speak VB 35772 1234 31 , , , 35772 1234 32 the the DT 35772 1234 33 _ _ NNP 35772 1234 34 habits habit NNS 35772 1234 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1234 36 which which WDT 35772 1234 37 things thing NNS 35772 1234 38 display display VBP 35772 1234 39 . . . 35772 1235 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1235 2 constitute constitute VBP 35772 1235 3 , , , 35772 1235 4 as as IN 35772 1235 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1235 6 were be VBD 35772 1235 7 , , , 35772 1235 8 " " '' 35772 1235 9 the the DT 35772 1235 10 bed bed NN 35772 1235 11 in in IN 35772 1235 12 which which WDT 35772 1235 13 the the DT 35772 1235 14 stream stream NN 35772 1235 15 of of IN 35772 1235 16 occurrence occurrence NN 35772 1235 17 flows flow VBZ 35772 1235 18 , , , 35772 1235 19 which which WDT 35772 1235 20 the the DT 35772 1235 21 stream stream NN 35772 1235 22 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1235 23 had have VBD 35772 1235 24 hollowed hollow VBN 35772 1235 25 out out RP 35772 1235 26 , , , 35772 1235 27 although although IN 35772 1235 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1235 29 course course NN 35772 1235 30 has have VBZ 35772 1235 31 come come VBN 35772 1235 32 to to TO 35772 1235 33 be be VB 35772 1235 34 determined determine VBN 35772 1235 35 by by IN 35772 1235 36 this this DT 35772 1235 37 bed bed NN 35772 1235 38 " " '' 35772 1235 39 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1235 40 Höffding höffding NN 35772 1235 41 , , , 35772 1235 42 _ _ NNP 35772 1235 43 Modern Modern NNP 35772 1235 44 Philosophers Philosophers NNPS 35772 1235 45 _ _ NNP 35772 1235 46 , , , 35772 1235 47 p. p. NN 35772 1235 48 101 101 CD 35772 1235 49 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1235 50 . . . 35772 1236 1 In in IN 35772 1236 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1236 3 _ _ NNP 35772 1236 4 Natural Natural NNP 35772 1236 5 Law Law NNP 35772 1236 6 in in IN 35772 1236 7 Science Science NNP 35772 1236 8 and and CC 35772 1236 9 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1236 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1236 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1236 12 1895 1895 CD 35772 1236 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1236 14 , , , 35772 1236 15 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1236 16 lays lay VBZ 35772 1236 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1236 18 down down RP 35772 1236 19 that that IN 35772 1236 20 the the DT 35772 1236 21 laws law NNS 35772 1236 22 of of IN 35772 1236 23 nature nature NN 35772 1236 24 , , , 35772 1236 25 as as IN 35772 1236 26 science science NN 35772 1236 27 describes describe VBZ 35772 1236 28 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1236 29 , , , 35772 1236 30 may may MD 35772 1236 31 indeed indeed RB 35772 1236 32 represent represent VB 35772 1236 33 , , , 35772 1236 34 but but CC 35772 1236 35 are be VBP 35772 1236 36 by by IN 35772 1236 37 no no DT 35772 1236 38 means means NN 35772 1236 39 identical identical JJ 35772 1236 40 with with IN 35772 1236 41 , , , 35772 1236 42 the the DT 35772 1236 43 laws law NNS 35772 1236 44 of of IN 35772 1236 45 nature nature NN 35772 1236 46 as as IN 35772 1236 47 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1236 48 really really RB 35772 1236 49 are be VBP 35772 1236 50 . . . 35772 1237 1 The the DT 35772 1237 2 laws law NNS 35772 1237 3 of of IN 35772 1237 4 science science NN 35772 1237 5 are be VBP 35772 1237 6 true true JJ 35772 1237 7 , , , 35772 1237 8 not not RB 35772 1237 9 absolutely absolutely RB 35772 1237 10 but but CC 35772 1237 11 relatively relatively RB 35772 1237 12 , , , 35772 1237 13 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1238 1 are be VBP 35772 1238 2 not not RB 35772 1238 3 elements element NNS 35772 1238 4 in in RB 35772 1238 5 , , , 35772 1238 6 but but CC 35772 1238 7 symbols symbol NNS 35772 1238 8 of of IN 35772 1238 9 , , , 35772 1238 10 reality reality NN 35772 1238 11 . . . 35772 1239 1 The the DT 35772 1239 2 notion notion NN 35772 1239 3 that that IN 35772 1239 4 everything everything NN 35772 1239 5 is be VBZ 35772 1239 6 " " `` 35772 1239 7 determined determine VBN 35772 1239 8 " " '' 35772 1239 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1239 10 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1240 1 the the DT 35772 1240 2 opposite opposite NN 35772 1240 3 of of IN 35772 1240 4 " " `` 35772 1240 5 contingent contingent JJ 35772 1240 6 " " '' 35772 1240 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1240 8 , , , 35772 1240 9 though though IN 35772 1240 10 absolutely absolutely RB 35772 1240 11 indispensable indispensable JJ 35772 1240 12 to to IN 35772 1240 13 the the DT 35772 1240 14 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1240 15 theory theory NN 35772 1240 16 , , , 35772 1240 17 is be VBZ 35772 1240 18 nevertheless nevertheless RB 35772 1240 19 a a DT 35772 1240 20 way way NN 35772 1240 21 of of IN 35772 1240 22 looking look VBG 35772 1240 23 at at IN 35772 1240 24 things thing NNS 35772 1240 25 rather rather RB 35772 1240 26 than than IN 35772 1240 27 a a DT 35772 1240 28 faithful faithful JJ 35772 1240 29 picture picture NN 35772 1240 30 of of IN 35772 1240 31 reality reality NN 35772 1240 32 -- -- : 35772 1240 33 a a DT 35772 1240 34 way way NN 35772 1240 35 in in IN 35772 1240 36 which which WDT 35772 1240 37 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1240 38 see see VBP 35772 1240 39 things thing NNS 35772 1240 40 rather rather RB 35772 1240 41 than than IN 35772 1240 42 the the DT 35772 1240 43 way way NN 35772 1240 44 things thing NNS 35772 1240 45 exist exist VBP 35772 1240 46 in in IN 35772 1240 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1240 48 . . . 35772 1241 1 As as IN 35772 1241 2 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1241 3 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1241 4 puts put VBZ 35772 1241 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1241 6 in in IN 35772 1241 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1241 8 final final JJ 35772 1241 9 chapter chapter NN 35772 1241 10 : : : 35772 1241 11 " " `` 35772 1241 12 That that IN 35772 1241 13 which which WDT 35772 1241 14 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1241 15 call call VBP 35772 1241 16 the the DT 35772 1241 17 ' ' `` 35772 1241 18 laws law NNS 35772 1241 19 of of IN 35772 1241 20 nature nature NN 35772 1241 21 ' ' '' 35772 1241 22 is be VBZ 35772 1241 23 the the DT 35772 1241 24 sum sum NN 35772 1241 25 total total NN 35772 1241 26 of of IN 35772 1241 27 the the DT 35772 1241 28 methods method NNS 35772 1241 29 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1241 30 have have VBP 35772 1241 31 discovered discover VBN 35772 1241 32 for for IN 35772 1241 33 adapting adapt VBG 35772 1241 34 things thing NNS 35772 1241 35 to to IN 35772 1241 36 the the DT 35772 1241 37 mind mind NN 35772 1241 38 , , , 35772 1241 39 and and CC 35772 1241 40 subjecting subject VBG 35772 1241 41 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1241 42 to to TO 35772 1241 43 be be VB 35772 1241 44 moulded mould VBN 35772 1241 45 by by IN 35772 1241 46 the the DT 35772 1241 47 will will NN 35772 1241 48 . . . 35772 1241 49 " " '' 35772 1242 1 RESULTS.--Here results.--here IN 35772 1242 2 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1242 3 have have VBP 35772 1242 4 Boutroux boutroux NN 35772 1242 5 approaching approach VBG 35772 1242 6 very very RB 35772 1242 7 closely closely RB 35772 1242 8 to to IN 35772 1242 9 the the DT 35772 1242 10 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 1242 11 of of IN 35772 1242 12 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1242 13 ; ; : 35772 1242 14 indeed indeed RB 35772 1242 15 the the DT 35772 1242 16 theories theory NNS 35772 1242 17 of of IN 35772 1242 18 the the DT 35772 1242 19 two two CD 35772 1242 20 men man NNS 35772 1242 21 are be VBP 35772 1242 22 complementary complementary JJ 35772 1242 23 to to IN 35772 1242 24 one one CD 35772 1242 25 another another DT 35772 1242 26 . . . 35772 1243 1 For for IN 35772 1243 2 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1243 3 , , , 35772 1243 4 the the DT 35772 1243 5 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1243 6 view view NN 35772 1243 7 is be VBZ 35772 1243 8 a a DT 35772 1243 9 way way NN 35772 1243 10 of of IN 35772 1243 11 looking look VBG 35772 1243 12 at at IN 35772 1243 13 things thing NNS 35772 1243 14 , , , 35772 1243 15 distinctly distinctly RB 35772 1243 16 useful useful JJ 35772 1243 17 for for IN 35772 1243 18 understanding understanding NN 35772 1243 19 and and CC 35772 1243 20 using use VBG 35772 1243 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1243 22 -- -- : 35772 1243 23 an an DT 35772 1243 24 " " `` 35772 1243 25 economy economy NN 35772 1243 26 of of IN 35772 1243 27 thought thought NN 35772 1243 28 . . . 35772 1243 29 " " '' 35772 1244 1 For for IN 35772 1244 2 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1244 3 , , , 35772 1244 4 the the DT 35772 1244 5 determinist determinist JJ 35772 1244 6 view view NN 35772 1244 7 is be VBZ 35772 1244 8 also also RB 35772 1244 9 a a DT 35772 1244 10 way way NN 35772 1244 11 of of IN 35772 1244 12 looking look VBG 35772 1244 13 at at IN 35772 1244 14 things thing NNS 35772 1244 15 that that WDT 35772 1244 16 is be VBZ 35772 1244 17 useful useful JJ 35772 1244 18 for for IN 35772 1244 19 the the DT 35772 1244 20 same same JJ 35772 1244 21 purposes purpose NNS 35772 1244 22 . . . 35772 1245 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1245 2 the the DT 35772 1245 3 interpretation interpretation NN 35772 1245 4 of of IN 35772 1245 5 reality reality NN 35772 1245 6 in in IN 35772 1245 7 terms term NNS 35772 1245 8 of of IN 35772 1245 9 mathematics mathematic NNS 35772 1245 10 and and CC 35772 1245 11 " " `` 35772 1245 12 unalterable unalterable JJ 35772 1245 13 law law NN 35772 1245 14 , , , 35772 1245 15 " " '' 35772 1245 16 is be VBZ 35772 1245 17 artificial artificial JJ 35772 1245 18 ; ; : 35772 1245 19 an an DT 35772 1245 20 abstract abstract JJ 35772 1245 21 way way NN 35772 1245 22 of of IN 35772 1245 23 thinking thinking NN 35772 1245 24 which which WDT 35772 1245 25 deals deal VBZ 35772 1245 26 not not RB 35772 1245 27 with with IN 35772 1245 28 reality reality NN 35772 1245 29 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1245 30 but but CC 35772 1245 31 with with IN 35772 1245 32 certain certain JJ 35772 1245 33 deliberately deliberately RB 35772 1245 34 selected select VBN 35772 1245 35 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1245 36 of of IN 35772 1245 37 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1245 38 . . . 35772 1246 1 RISE RISE NNS 35772 1246 2 OF of IN 35772 1246 3 A a DT 35772 1246 4 NEW new JJ 35772 1246 5 PHILOSOPHY.--This philosophy.--this NN 35772 1246 6 examination examination NN 35772 1246 7 of of IN 35772 1246 8 the the DT 35772 1246 9 principles principle NNS 35772 1246 10 of of IN 35772 1246 11 natural natural JJ 35772 1246 12 science science NN 35772 1246 13 was be VBD 35772 1246 14 the the DT 35772 1246 15 beginning beginning NN 35772 1246 16 of of IN 35772 1246 17 what what WP 35772 1246 18 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 1246 19 proved prove VBD 35772 1246 20 to to TO 35772 1246 21 be be VB 35772 1246 22 a a DT 35772 1246 23 revolution revolution NN 35772 1246 24 in in IN 35772 1246 25 thought thought NN 35772 1246 26 . . . 35772 1247 1 What what WP 35772 1247 2 had have VBD 35772 1247 3 been be VBN 35772 1247 4 more more RBR 35772 1247 5 or or CC 35772 1247 6 less less RBR 35772 1247 7 negative negative JJ 35772 1247 8 criticism criticism NN 35772 1247 9 in in IN 35772 1247 10 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1247 11 and and CC 35772 1247 12 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1247 13 , , , 35772 1247 14 became become VBD 35772 1247 15 the the DT 35772 1247 16 basis basis NN 35772 1247 17 of of IN 35772 1247 18 a a DT 35772 1247 19 new new JJ 35772 1247 20 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1247 21 in in IN 35772 1247 22 the the DT 35772 1247 23 hands hand NNS 35772 1247 24 of of IN 35772 1247 25 William William NNP 35772 1247 26 James James NNP 35772 1247 27 and and CC 35772 1247 28 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1247 29 . . . 35772 1248 1 The the DT 35772 1248 2 names name NNS 35772 1248 3 , , , 35772 1248 4 and and CC 35772 1248 5 even even RB 35772 1248 6 the the DT 35772 1248 7 ideas idea NNS 35772 1248 8 , , , 35772 1248 9 of of IN 35772 1248 10 these these DT 35772 1248 11 two two CD 35772 1248 12 original original JJ 35772 1248 13 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1248 14 are be VBP 35772 1248 15 familiar familiar JJ 35772 1248 16 far far RB 35772 1248 17 outside outside IN 35772 1248 18 strictly strictly RB 35772 1248 19 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1248 20 circles circle NNS 35772 1248 21 , , , 35772 1248 22 and and CC 35772 1248 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1248 24 will will MD 35772 1248 25 almost almost RB 35772 1248 26 be be VB 35772 1248 27 possible possible JJ 35772 1248 28 to to TO 35772 1248 29 presume presume VB 35772 1248 30 upon upon IN 35772 1248 31 a a DT 35772 1248 32 certain certain JJ 35772 1248 33 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 1248 34 with with IN 35772 1248 35 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1248 36 on on IN 35772 1248 37 the the DT 35772 1248 38 part part NN 35772 1248 39 of of IN 35772 1248 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1248 41 readers reader NNS 35772 1248 42 . . . 35772 1249 1 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNP 35772 1249 2 JAMES.--James JAMES.--James NNP 35772 1249 3 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1249 4 , , , 35772 1249 5 like like IN 35772 1249 6 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1249 7 , , , 35772 1249 8 was be VBD 35772 1249 9 led lead VBN 35772 1249 10 to to IN 35772 1249 11 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1249 12 by by IN 35772 1249 13 the the DT 35772 1249 14 road road NN 35772 1249 15 of of IN 35772 1249 16 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1249 17 investigation investigation NN 35772 1249 18 . . . 35772 1250 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1250 2 was be VBD 35772 1250 3 a a DT 35772 1250 4 psychologist psychologist NN 35772 1250 5 , , , 35772 1250 6 and and CC 35772 1250 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1250 8 is be VBZ 35772 1250 9 as as IN 35772 1250 10 the the DT 35772 1250 11 author author NN 35772 1250 12 of of IN 35772 1250 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1250 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1250 15 Principles Principles NNPS 35772 1250 16 of of IN 35772 1250 17 Psychology Psychology NNP 35772 1250 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1250 19 that that IN 35772 1250 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1250 21 name name NN 35772 1250 22 will will MD 35772 1250 23 be be VB 35772 1250 24 remembered remember VBN 35772 1250 25 . . . 35772 1251 1 This this DT 35772 1251 2 work work NN 35772 1251 3 is be VBZ 35772 1251 4 notable notable JJ 35772 1251 5 as as IN 35772 1251 6 containing contain VBG 35772 1251 7 the the DT 35772 1251 8 first first JJ 35772 1251 9 complete complete JJ 35772 1251 10 application application NN 35772 1251 11 of of IN 35772 1251 12 the the DT 35772 1251 13 Darwinian darwinian JJ 35772 1251 14 theory theory NN 35772 1251 15 to to IN 35772 1251 16 the the DT 35772 1251 17 evolution evolution NN 35772 1251 18 of of IN 35772 1251 19 mind mind NN 35772 1251 20 . . . 35772 1252 1 Mental mental JJ 35772 1252 2 action action NN 35772 1252 3 is be VBZ 35772 1252 4 there there RB 35772 1252 5 represented represent VBN 35772 1252 6 as as IN 35772 1252 7 a a DT 35772 1252 8 capacity capacity NN 35772 1252 9 developed develop VBN 35772 1252 10 by by IN 35772 1252 11 the the DT 35772 1252 12 organism organism NN 35772 1252 13 to to TO 35772 1252 14 enable enable VB 35772 1252 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1252 16 to to TO 35772 1252 17 deal deal VB 35772 1252 18 with with IN 35772 1252 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1252 20 environment environment NN 35772 1252 21 . . . 35772 1253 1 As as IN 35772 1253 2 an an DT 35772 1253 3 exponent exponent NN 35772 1253 4 of of IN 35772 1253 5 James James NNP 35772 1253 6 puts put VBZ 35772 1253 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1253 8 : : : 35772 1253 9 " " `` 35772 1253 10 The the DT 35772 1253 11 mind mind NN 35772 1253 12 , , , 35772 1253 13 like like IN 35772 1253 14 an an DT 35772 1253 15 antenna antenna NN 35772 1253 16 , , , 35772 1253 17 feels feel VBZ 35772 1253 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1253 19 way way NN 35772 1253 20 for for IN 35772 1253 21 the the DT 35772 1253 22 organism organism NN 35772 1253 23 . . . 35772 1254 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1254 2 gropes grope VBZ 35772 1254 3 about about IN 35772 1254 4 , , , 35772 1254 5 advances advance NNS 35772 1254 6 and and CC 35772 1254 7 recoils recoil NNS 35772 1254 8 , , , 35772 1254 9 making make VBG 35772 1254 10 many many JJ 35772 1254 11 random random JJ 35772 1254 12 efforts effort NNS 35772 1254 13 and and CC 35772 1254 14 many many JJ 35772 1254 15 failures failure NNS 35772 1254 16 ; ; : 35772 1254 17 always always RB 35772 1254 18 urged urge VBD 35772 1254 19 into into IN 35772 1254 20 taking take VBG 35772 1254 21 the the DT 35772 1254 22 initiative initiative NN 35772 1254 23 and and CC 35772 1254 24 doomed doom VBN 35772 1254 25 to to IN 35772 1254 26 success success NN 35772 1254 27 or or CC 35772 1254 28 failure failure NN 35772 1254 29 in in IN 35772 1254 30 some some DT 35772 1254 31 hour hour NN 35772 1254 32 of of IN 35772 1254 33 trial trial NN 35772 1254 34 . . . 35772 1255 1 " " `` 35772 1255 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1255 3 53 53 CD 35772 1255 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1255 5 The the DT 35772 1255 6 corollary corollary JJ 35772 1255 7 which which WDT 35772 1255 8 attaches attach VBZ 35772 1255 9 to to IN 35772 1255 10 propositions proposition NNS 35772 1255 11 of of IN 35772 1255 12 this this DT 35772 1255 13 kind kind NN 35772 1255 14 is be VBZ 35772 1255 15 that that IN 35772 1255 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1255 17 in in IN 35772 1255 18 all all DT 35772 1255 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1255 20 varieties variety NNS 35772 1255 21 and and CC 35772 1255 22 developments development NNS 35772 1255 23 arises arise VBZ 35772 1255 24 from from IN 35772 1255 25 _ _ NNP 35772 1255 26 practical practical JJ 35772 1255 27 needs need NNS 35772 1255 28 _ _ NNP 35772 1255 29 . . . 35772 1256 1 And and CC 35772 1256 2 the the DT 35772 1256 3 mind mind NN 35772 1256 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1256 5 here here RB 35772 1256 6 is be VBZ 35772 1256 7 an an DT 35772 1256 8 echo echo NN 35772 1256 9 of of IN 35772 1256 10 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1256 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1256 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1256 13 selects select NNS 35772 1256 14 _ _ IN 35772 1256 15 those those DT 35772 1256 16 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1256 17 of of IN 35772 1256 18 reality reality NN 35772 1256 19 which which WDT 35772 1256 20 concern concern VBP 35772 1256 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1256 22 , , , 35772 1256 23 and and CC 35772 1256 24 out out IN 35772 1256 25 of of IN 35772 1256 26 that that DT 35772 1256 27 selected select VBN 35772 1256 28 material material NN 35772 1256 29 makes make VBZ 35772 1256 30 up up RP 35772 1256 31 a a DT 35772 1256 32 new new JJ 35772 1256 33 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1256 34 mental mental JJ 35772 1256 35 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1256 36 world world NN 35772 1256 37 of of IN 35772 1256 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1256 39 own own JJ 35772 1256 40 . . . 35772 1257 1 Which which WDT 35772 1257 2 world world NN 35772 1257 3 is be VBZ 35772 1257 4 far far RB 35772 1257 5 from from IN 35772 1257 6 being be VBG 35772 1257 7 a a DT 35772 1257 8 " " `` 35772 1257 9 picture picture NN 35772 1257 10 " " '' 35772 1257 11 of of IN 35772 1257 12 reality reality NN 35772 1257 13 , , , 35772 1257 14 but but CC 35772 1257 15 which which WDT 35772 1257 16 is be VBZ 35772 1257 17 " " `` 35772 1257 18 symbolic symbolic JJ 35772 1257 19 " " '' 35772 1257 20 of of IN 35772 1257 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1257 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1257 23 here here RB 35772 1257 24 is be VBZ 35772 1257 25 another another DT 35772 1257 26 memory memory NN 35772 1257 27 of of IN 35772 1257 28 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1257 29 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1257 30 . . . 35772 1258 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1258 2 54 54 CD 35772 1258 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1258 4 This this DT 35772 1258 5 view view NN 35772 1258 6 obviously obviously RB 35772 1258 7 cuts cut VBZ 35772 1258 8 the the DT 35772 1258 9 ground ground NN 35772 1258 10 from from IN 35772 1258 11 under under IN 35772 1258 12 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1258 13 materialism materialism NN 35772 1258 14 . . . 35772 1259 1 The the DT 35772 1259 2 world world NN 35772 1259 3 which which WDT 35772 1259 4 that that DT 35772 1259 5 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1259 6 regards regard VBZ 35772 1259 7 as as IN 35772 1259 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1259 9 reality reality NN 35772 1259 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1259 11 , , , 35772 1259 12 is be VBZ 35772 1259 13 , , , 35772 1259 14 to to IN 35772 1259 15 the the DT 35772 1259 16 critical critical JJ 35772 1259 17 eye eye NN 35772 1259 18 , , , 35772 1259 19 a a DT 35772 1259 20 collection collection NN 35772 1259 21 of of IN 35772 1259 22 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1259 23 , , , 35772 1259 24 a a DT 35772 1259 25 mental mental JJ 35772 1259 26 creation creation NN 35772 1259 27 arising arise VBG 35772 1259 28 out out IN 35772 1259 29 of of IN 35772 1259 30 the the DT 35772 1259 31 practical practical JJ 35772 1259 32 needs need NNS 35772 1259 33 of of IN 35772 1259 34 life life NN 35772 1259 35 . . . 35772 1260 1 HENRI HENRI NNP 35772 1260 2 BERGSON.--This bergson.--this PRP$ 35772 1260 3 line line NN 35772 1260 4 of of IN 35772 1260 5 criticism criticism NN 35772 1260 6 , , , 35772 1260 7 that that DT 35772 1260 8 of of IN 35772 1260 9 the the DT 35772 1260 10 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 1260 11 psychologist psychologist NN 35772 1260 12 , , , 35772 1260 13 opened open VBN 35772 1260 14 up up RP 35772 1260 15 by by IN 35772 1260 16 James James NNP 35772 1260 17 , , , 35772 1260 18 has have VBZ 35772 1260 19 been be VBN 35772 1260 20 carried carry VBN 35772 1260 21 to to IN 35772 1260 22 extreme extreme JJ 35772 1260 23 lengths length NNS 35772 1260 24 by by IN 35772 1260 25 the the DT 35772 1260 26 French french JJ 35772 1260 27 philosopher philosopher NN 35772 1260 28 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1260 29 . . . 35772 1261 1 " " `` 35772 1261 2 Dig dig VB 35772 1261 3 to to IN 35772 1261 4 the the DT 35772 1261 5 very very JJ 35772 1261 6 roots root NNS 35772 1261 7 of of IN 35772 1261 8 nature nature NN 35772 1261 9 and and CC 35772 1261 10 of of IN 35772 1261 11 mind mind NN 35772 1261 12 " " '' 35772 1261 13 is be VBZ 35772 1261 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1261 15 advice advice NN 35772 1261 16 . . . 35772 1262 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1262 2 begins begin VBZ 35772 1262 3 by by IN 35772 1262 4 asking ask VBG 35772 1262 5 , , , 35772 1262 6 How how WRB 35772 1262 7 , , , 35772 1262 8 as as IN 35772 1262 9 a a DT 35772 1262 10 matter matter NN 35772 1262 11 of of IN 35772 1262 12 history history NN 35772 1262 13 , , , 35772 1262 14 has have VBZ 35772 1262 15 human human JJ 35772 1262 16 intellect intellect NN 35772 1262 17 developed develop VBN 35772 1262 18 ? ? . 35772 1263 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1263 2 then then RB 35772 1263 3 , , , 35772 1263 4 and and CC 35772 1263 5 then then RB 35772 1263 6 only only RB 35772 1263 7 , , , 35772 1263 8 proceeds proceed VBZ 35772 1263 9 to to TO 35772 1263 10 put put VB 35772 1263 11 the the DT 35772 1263 12 question question NN 35772 1263 13 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1263 14 which which WDT 35772 1263 15 uncritical uncritical JJ 35772 1263 16 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1263 17 always always RB 35772 1263 18 put put VBD 35772 1263 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1263 20 first first JJ 35772 1263 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1263 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1263 23 , , , 35772 1263 24 What what WP 35772 1263 25 can can MD 35772 1263 26 the the DT 35772 1263 27 intellect intellect NN 35772 1263 28 do do VB 35772 1263 29 for for IN 35772 1263 30 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1263 31 ? ? . 35772 1264 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1264 2 theory theory NN 35772 1264 3 of of IN 35772 1264 4 the the DT 35772 1264 5 origin origin NN 35772 1264 6 of of IN 35772 1264 7 intellect intellect NN 35772 1264 8 is be VBZ 35772 1264 9 the the DT 35772 1264 10 same same JJ 35772 1264 11 as as IN 35772 1264 12 that that DT 35772 1264 13 of of IN 35772 1264 14 William William NNP 35772 1264 15 James James NNP 35772 1264 16 . . . 35772 1265 1 Life life NN 35772 1265 2 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1265 3 through through IN 35772 1265 4 the the DT 35772 1265 5 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 1265 6 process process NN 35772 1265 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1265 8 has have VBZ 35772 1265 9 produced produce VBN 35772 1265 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1265 11 . . . 35772 1266 1 But but CC 35772 1266 2 the the DT 35772 1266 3 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 1266 4 that that IN 35772 1266 5 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1266 6 draws draw VBZ 35772 1266 7 from from IN 35772 1266 8 this this DT 35772 1266 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 1266 10 is be VBZ 35772 1266 11 that that IN 35772 1266 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1266 13 the the DT 35772 1266 14 intellect intellect NN 35772 1266 15 , , , 35772 1266 16 being be VBG 35772 1266 17 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1266 18 a a DT 35772 1266 19 product product NN 35772 1266 20 of of IN 35772 1266 21 life life NN 35772 1266 22 , , , 35772 1266 23 or or CC 35772 1266 24 a a DT 35772 1266 25 form form NN 35772 1266 26 of of IN 35772 1266 27 life life NN 35772 1266 28 , , , 35772 1266 29 can can MD 35772 1266 30 not not RB 35772 1266 31 understand understand VB 35772 1266 32 the the DT 35772 1266 33 whole whole NN 35772 1266 34 of of IN 35772 1266 35 life life NN 35772 1266 36 _ _ NNP 35772 1266 37 . . . 35772 1267 1 This this DT 35772 1267 2 thesis thesis NN 35772 1267 3 is be VBZ 35772 1267 4 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 1267 5 with with IN 35772 1267 6 a a DT 35772 1267 7 wealth wealth NN 35772 1267 8 of of IN 35772 1267 9 illustration illustration NN 35772 1267 10 and and CC 35772 1267 11 erudition erudition NN 35772 1267 12 , , , 35772 1267 13 both both CC 35772 1267 14 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1267 15 and and CC 35772 1267 16 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1267 17 , , , 35772 1267 18 and and CC 35772 1267 19 with with IN 35772 1267 20 a a DT 35772 1267 21 literary literary JJ 35772 1267 22 grace grace NN 35772 1267 23 and and CC 35772 1267 24 charm charm NN 35772 1267 25 possible possible JJ 35772 1267 26 only only RB 35772 1267 27 for for IN 35772 1267 28 a a DT 35772 1267 29 Frenchman Frenchman NNP 35772 1267 30 , , , 35772 1267 31 in in IN 35772 1267 32 the the DT 35772 1267 33 famous famous JJ 35772 1267 34 work work NN 35772 1267 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1267 36 Évolution Évolution NNP 35772 1267 37 Créatrice Créatrice NNP 35772 1267 38 _ _ NNP 35772 1267 39 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1267 40 1907 1907 CD 35772 1267 41 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1267 42 . . . 35772 1268 1 BERGSON BERGSON NNP 35772 1268 2 'S 's POS 35772 1268 3 ADVANCE advance NN 35772 1268 4 ON on IN 35772 1268 5 MACH MACH NNP 35772 1268 6 AND and CC 35772 1268 7 JAMES.--Those JAMES.--Those NNP 35772 1268 8 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1268 9 who who WP 35772 1268 10 had have VBD 35772 1268 11 made make VBN 35772 1268 12 a a DT 35772 1268 13 serious serious JJ 35772 1268 14 attempt attempt NN 35772 1268 15 at at IN 35772 1268 16 a a DT 35772 1268 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1268 18 of of IN 35772 1268 19 science science NN 35772 1268 20 , , , 35772 1268 21 had have VBD 35772 1268 22 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 35772 1268 23 that that IN 35772 1268 24 the the DT 35772 1268 25 " " `` 35772 1268 26 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1268 27 view view NN 35772 1268 28 " " '' 35772 1268 29 of of IN 35772 1268 30 nature nature NN 35772 1268 31 was be VBD 35772 1268 32 a a DT 35772 1268 33 mental mental JJ 35772 1268 34 abstraction abstraction NN 35772 1268 35 , , , 35772 1268 36 and and CC 35772 1268 37 not not RB 35772 1268 38 a a DT 35772 1268 39 complete complete JJ 35772 1268 40 representation representation NN 35772 1268 41 of of IN 35772 1268 42 reality reality NN 35772 1268 43 . . . 35772 1269 1 Such such JJ 35772 1269 2 is be VBZ 35772 1269 3 the the DT 35772 1269 4 debt debt NN 35772 1269 5 of of IN 35772 1269 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1269 7 to to IN 35772 1269 8 the the DT 35772 1269 9 researches research NNS 35772 1269 10 of of IN 35772 1269 11 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1269 12 , , , 35772 1269 13 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1269 14 , , , 35772 1269 15 James James NNP 35772 1269 16 , , , 35772 1269 17 and and CC 35772 1269 18 others other NNS 35772 1269 19 who who WP 35772 1269 20 worked work VBD 35772 1269 21 along along IN 35772 1269 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1269 23 lines line NNS 35772 1269 24 . . . 35772 1270 1 But but CC 35772 1270 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1270 3 remained remain VBD 35772 1270 4 for for IN 35772 1270 5 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1270 6 to to TO 35772 1270 7 demonstrate demonstrate VB 35772 1270 8 that that IN 35772 1270 9 the the DT 35772 1270 10 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1270 11 view view NN 35772 1270 12 was be VBD 35772 1270 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1270 14 the the DT 35772 1270 15 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 1270 16 product product NN 35772 1270 17 of of IN 35772 1270 18 the the DT 35772 1270 19 mental mental JJ 35772 1270 20 processes process NNS 35772 1270 21 which which WDT 35772 1270 22 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1270 23 describe describe VBP 35772 1270 24 by by IN 35772 1270 25 the the DT 35772 1270 26 word word NN 35772 1270 27 " " `` 35772 1270 28 intellect intellect NN 35772 1270 29 . . . 35772 1271 1 " " `` 35772 1271 2 _ _ NNP 35772 1271 3 The the DT 35772 1271 4 path path NN 35772 1271 5 which which WDT 35772 1271 6 led lead VBD 35772 1271 7 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1271 8 to to IN 35772 1271 9 this this DT 35772 1271 10 goal goal NN 35772 1271 11 will will MD 35772 1271 12 have have VB 35772 1271 13 to to TO 35772 1271 14 be be VB 35772 1271 15 briefly briefly RB 35772 1271 16 indicated indicate VBN 35772 1271 17 by by IN 35772 1271 18 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1271 19 . . . 35772 1272 1 CHARACTERISTICS characteristic NNS 35772 1272 2 OF of IN 35772 1272 3 THE the DT 35772 1272 4 INTELLECT.--What intellect.--what NN 35772 1272 5 is be VBZ 35772 1272 6 the the DT 35772 1272 7 " " `` 35772 1272 8 intellect intellect NN 35772 1272 9 , , , 35772 1272 10 " " '' 35772 1272 11 to to TO 35772 1272 12 which which WDT 35772 1272 13 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1272 14 look look VBP 35772 1272 15 in in IN 35772 1272 16 vain vain NN 35772 1272 17 for for IN 35772 1272 18 any any DT 35772 1272 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1272 20 complete complete JJ 35772 1272 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1272 22 explanation explanation NN 35772 1272 23 of of IN 35772 1272 24 existence existence NN 35772 1272 25 ? ? . 35772 1273 1 This this DT 35772 1273 2 is be VBZ 35772 1273 3 the the DT 35772 1273 4 preliminary preliminary JJ 35772 1273 5 question question NN 35772 1273 6 . . . 35772 1274 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1274 2 intellect intellect NN 35772 1274 3 is be VBZ 35772 1274 4 , , , 35772 1274 5 as as IN 35772 1274 6 James James NNP 35772 1274 7 had have VBD 35772 1274 8 taught teach VBN 35772 1274 9 , , , 35772 1274 10 a a DT 35772 1274 11 faculty faculty NN 35772 1274 12 developed develop VBN 35772 1274 13 by by IN 35772 1274 14 the the DT 35772 1274 15 evolutionary evolutionary JJ 35772 1274 16 process process NN 35772 1274 17 in in IN 35772 1274 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1274 19 species specie NNS 35772 1274 20 to to TO 35772 1274 21 enable enable VB 35772 1274 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1274 23 to to TO 35772 1274 24 deal deal VB 35772 1274 25 with with IN 35772 1274 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1274 27 _ _ NNP 35772 1274 28 material material NN 35772 1274 29 _ _ NNP 35772 1274 30 environment environment NN 35772 1274 31 . . . 35772 1275 1 And and CC 35772 1275 2 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1275 3 was be VBD 35772 1275 4 the the DT 35772 1275 5 first first JJ 35772 1275 6 to to TO 35772 1275 7 point point VB 35772 1275 8 out out RP 35772 1275 9 that that IN 35772 1275 10 as as IN 35772 1275 11 a a DT 35772 1275 12 consequence consequence NN 35772 1275 13 of of IN 35772 1275 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1275 15 having have VBG 35772 1275 16 been be VBN 35772 1275 17 developed develop VBN 35772 1275 18 for for IN 35772 1275 19 this this DT 35772 1275 20 particular particular JJ 35772 1275 21 purpose purpose NN 35772 1275 22 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1275 23 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1275 24 , , , 35772 1275 25 dealing deal VBG 35772 1275 26 with with IN 35772 1275 27 a a DT 35772 1275 28 _ _ NNP 35772 1275 29 material material NN 35772 1275 30 _ _ NNP 35772 1275 31 environment environment NN 35772 1275 32 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1275 33 , , , 35772 1275 34 intellect intellect NN 35772 1275 35 is be VBZ 35772 1275 36 " " `` 35772 1275 37 never never RB 35772 1275 38 quite quite RB 35772 1275 39 at at IN 35772 1275 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1275 41 ease ease NN 35772 1275 42 , , , 35772 1275 43 never never RB 35772 1275 44 entirely entirely RB 35772 1275 45 at at IN 35772 1275 46 home home NN 35772 1275 47 , , , 35772 1275 48 except except IN 35772 1275 49 when when WRB 35772 1275 50 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1275 51 is be VBZ 35772 1275 52 working work VBG 35772 1275 53 upon upon IN 35772 1275 54 inert inert JJ 35772 1275 55 matter matter NN 35772 1275 56 . . . 35772 1275 57 " " '' 35772 1276 1 If if IN 35772 1276 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1276 3 has have VBZ 35772 1276 4 to to TO 35772 1276 5 deal deal VB 35772 1276 6 with with IN 35772 1276 7 " " `` 35772 1276 8 living live VBG 35772 1276 9 " " '' 35772 1276 10 matter matter NN 35772 1276 11 , , , 35772 1276 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1276 13 " " `` 35772 1276 14 treats treat VBZ 35772 1276 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1276 16 as as IN 35772 1276 17 inert inert RB 35772 1276 18 , , , 35772 1276 19 without without IN 35772 1276 20 troubling trouble VBG 35772 1276 21 about about IN 35772 1276 22 the the DT 35772 1276 23 life life NN 35772 1276 24 that that WDT 35772 1276 25 animated animate VBD 35772 1276 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1276 27 . . . 35772 1276 28 " " '' 35772 1277 1 Such such JJ 35772 1277 2 is be VBZ 35772 1277 3 the the DT 35772 1277 4 first first JJ 35772 1277 5 characteristic characteristic NN 35772 1277 6 of of IN 35772 1277 7 the the DT 35772 1277 8 intellect intellect NN 35772 1277 9 : : : 35772 1277 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1277 11 feels feel VBZ 35772 1277 12 at at IN 35772 1277 13 home home NN 35772 1277 14 in in IN 35772 1277 15 dealing deal VBG 35772 1277 16 with with IN 35772 1277 17 dead dead JJ 35772 1277 18 matter matter NN 35772 1277 19 , , , 35772 1277 20 and and CC 35772 1277 21 living live VBG 35772 1277 22 matter matter NN 35772 1277 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1277 24 prefers prefer VBZ 35772 1277 25 to to TO 35772 1277 26 treat treat VB 35772 1277 27 " " '' 35772 1277 28 as as IN 35772 1277 29 inert inert JJ 35772 1277 30 . . . 35772 1277 31 " " '' 35772 1278 1 Another another DT 35772 1278 2 characteristic characteristic NN 35772 1278 3 of of IN 35772 1278 4 intellect intellect NN 35772 1278 5 is be VBZ 35772 1278 6 that that IN 35772 1278 7 , , , 35772 1278 8 just just RB 35772 1278 9 as as IN 35772 1278 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1278 11 treats treat VBZ 35772 1278 12 the the DT 35772 1278 13 living living NN 35772 1278 14 as as IN 35772 1278 15 if if IN 35772 1278 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1278 17 were be VBD 35772 1278 18 non non JJ 35772 1278 19 - - JJ 35772 1278 20 living living JJ 35772 1278 21 , , , 35772 1278 22 so so CC 35772 1278 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1278 24 prefers prefer VBZ 35772 1278 25 to to TO 35772 1278 26 treat treat VB 35772 1278 27 the the DT 35772 1278 28 mobile mobile NN 35772 1278 29 as as IN 35772 1278 30 though though IN 35772 1278 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1278 32 were be VBD 35772 1278 33 motionless motionless JJ 35772 1278 34 . . . 35772 1279 1 Motion motion NN 35772 1279 2 is be VBZ 35772 1279 3 a a DT 35772 1279 4 thing thing NN 35772 1279 5 which which WDT 35772 1279 6 the the DT 35772 1279 7 intellect intellect NN 35772 1279 8 simply simply RB 35772 1279 9 can can MD 35772 1279 10 not not RB 35772 1279 11 grasp grasp VB 35772 1279 12 ; ; : 35772 1279 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1279 14 has have VBZ 35772 1279 15 to to TO 35772 1279 16 treat treat VB 35772 1279 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1279 18 artificially artificially RB 35772 1279 19 , , , 35772 1279 20 and and CC 35772 1279 21 represent represent VB 35772 1279 22 a a DT 35772 1279 23 process process NN 35772 1279 24 which which WDT 35772 1279 25 in in IN 35772 1279 26 reality reality NN 35772 1279 27 is be VBZ 35772 1279 28 continuous continuous JJ 35772 1279 29 and and CC 35772 1279 30 indivisible indivisible JJ 35772 1279 31 , , , 35772 1279 32 as as IN 35772 1279 33 discontinuous discontinuous JJ 35772 1279 34 and and CC 35772 1279 35 divisible divisible JJ 35772 1279 36 -- -- : 35772 1279 37 a a DT 35772 1279 38 succession succession NN 35772 1279 39 of of IN 35772 1279 40 points point NNS 35772 1279 41 , , , 35772 1279 42 out out IN 35772 1279 43 of of IN 35772 1279 44 which which WDT 35772 1279 45 no no DT 35772 1279 46 magic magic NN 35772 1279 47 can can MD 35772 1279 48 conjure conjure VB 35772 1279 49 motion motion NN 35772 1279 50 . . . 35772 1280 1 Philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1280 2 became become VBD 35772 1280 3 aware aware JJ 35772 1280 4 of of IN 35772 1280 5 this this DT 35772 1280 6 as as RB 35772 1280 7 soon soon RB 35772 1280 8 as as IN 35772 1280 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1280 10 opened open VBD 35772 1280 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1280 12 eyes eye NNS 35772 1280 13 . . . 35772 1281 1 Hence hence RB 35772 1281 2 the the DT 35772 1281 3 paradox paradox NN 35772 1281 4 of of IN 35772 1281 5 Zeno Zeno NNP 35772 1281 6 , , , 35772 1281 7 that that IN 35772 1281 8 Achilles Achilles NNP 35772 1281 9 will will MD 35772 1281 10 never never RB 35772 1281 11 overtake overtake VB 35772 1281 12 the the DT 35772 1281 13 tortoise tortoise NN 35772 1281 14 , , , 35772 1281 15 if if IN 35772 1281 16 the the DT 35772 1281 17 latter latter JJ 35772 1281 18 once once RB 35772 1281 19 gets get VBZ 35772 1281 20 a a DT 35772 1281 21 start start NN 35772 1281 22 . . . 35772 1282 1 For for IN 35772 1282 2 if if IN 35772 1282 3 space space NN 35772 1282 4 and and CC 35772 1282 5 time time NN 35772 1282 6 are be VBP 35772 1282 7 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 1282 8 divisible divisible JJ 35772 1282 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1282 10 as as IN 35772 1282 11 intellect intellect NN 35772 1282 12 holds hold VBZ 35772 1282 13 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1282 14 to to TO 35772 1282 15 be be VB 35772 1282 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1282 17 , , , 35772 1282 18 by by IN 35772 1282 19 the the DT 35772 1282 20 time time NN 35772 1282 21 Achilles Achilles NNP 35772 1282 22 has have VBZ 35772 1282 23 reached reach VBN 35772 1282 24 the the DT 35772 1282 25 tortoise tortoise NN 35772 1282 26 's 's POS 35772 1282 27 starting starting NN 35772 1282 28 point point NN 35772 1282 29 , , , 35772 1282 30 the the DT 35772 1282 31 tortoise tortoise NN 35772 1282 32 has have VBZ 35772 1282 33 already already RB 35772 1282 34 got get VBN 35772 1282 35 ahead ahead RB 35772 1282 36 of of IN 35772 1282 37 _ _ NNP 35772 1282 38 that that IN 35772 1282 39 _ _ NNP 35772 1282 40 starting starting NN 35772 1282 41 point point NN 35772 1282 42 , , , 35772 1282 43 and and CC 35772 1282 44 so so RB 35772 1282 45 on on IN 35772 1282 46 _ _ NNP 35772 1282 47 ad ad NN 35772 1282 48 infinitum infinitum IN 35772 1282 49 _ _ NNP 35772 1282 50 ; ; : 35772 1282 51 the the DT 35772 1282 52 interval interval NN 35772 1282 53 between between IN 35772 1282 54 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1282 55 being be VBG 35772 1282 56 endlessly endlessly RB 35772 1282 57 diminished diminish VBN 35772 1282 58 , , , 35772 1282 59 but but CC 35772 1282 60 never never RB 35772 1282 61 disappearing disappear VBG 35772 1282 62 . . . 35772 1283 1 Zeno Zeno NNP 35772 1283 2 's 's POS 35772 1283 3 paradox paradox NN 35772 1283 4 arises arise VBZ 35772 1283 5 because because IN 35772 1283 6 of of IN 35772 1283 7 an an DT 35772 1283 8 innate innate JJ 35772 1283 9 fault fault NN 35772 1283 10 in in IN 35772 1283 11 the the DT 35772 1283 12 " " `` 35772 1283 13 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1283 14 " " '' 35772 1283 15 method method NN 35772 1283 16 of of IN 35772 1283 17 dealing deal VBG 35772 1283 18 with with IN 35772 1283 19 motion motion NN 35772 1283 20 ; ; : 35772 1283 21 a a DT 35772 1283 22 method method NN 35772 1283 23 which which WDT 35772 1283 24 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1283 25 calls call VBZ 35772 1283 26 " " `` 35772 1283 27 cinematographical cinematographical JJ 35772 1283 28 , , , 35772 1283 29 " " '' 35772 1283 30 because because IN 35772 1283 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1283 32 regards regard VBZ 35772 1283 33 a a DT 35772 1283 34 single single JJ 35772 1283 35 movement movement NN 35772 1283 36 as as IN 35772 1283 37 a a DT 35772 1283 38 succession succession NN 35772 1283 39 of of IN 35772 1283 40 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 1283 41 small small JJ 35772 1283 42 motions motion NNS 35772 1283 43 . . . 35772 1284 1 That that DT 35772 1284 2 method method NN 35772 1284 3 is be VBZ 35772 1284 4 hopeless hopeless JJ 35772 1284 5 ; ; : 35772 1284 6 and and CC 35772 1284 7 if if IN 35772 1284 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1284 9 expect expect VBP 35772 1284 10 to to TO 35772 1284 11 understand understand VB 35772 1284 12 motion motion NN 35772 1284 13 by by IN 35772 1284 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1284 15 means mean NNS 35772 1284 16 , , , 35772 1284 17 " " `` 35772 1284 18 You -PRON- PRP 35772 1284 19 will will MD 35772 1284 20 always always RB 35772 1284 21 experience experience VB 35772 1284 22 the the DT 35772 1284 23 disappointment disappointment NN 35772 1284 24 of of IN 35772 1284 25 the the DT 35772 1284 26 child child NN 35772 1284 27 , , , 35772 1284 28 who who WP 35772 1284 29 tries try VBZ 35772 1284 30 , , , 35772 1284 31 by by IN 35772 1284 32 clapping clap VBG 35772 1284 33 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1284 34 hands hand NNS 35772 1284 35 together together RB 35772 1284 36 to to TO 35772 1284 37 crush crush VB 35772 1284 38 the the DT 35772 1284 39 smoke smoke NN 35772 1284 40 . . . 35772 1285 1 The the DT 35772 1285 2 movement movement NN 35772 1285 3 slips slip VBZ 35772 1285 4 through through IN 35772 1285 5 the the DT 35772 1285 6 interval interval NN 35772 1285 7 , , , 35772 1285 8 because because IN 35772 1285 9 every every DT 35772 1285 10 attempt attempt NN 35772 1285 11 to to TO 35772 1285 12 reconstitute reconstitute VB 35772 1285 13 change change NN 35772 1285 14 out out IN 35772 1285 15 of of IN 35772 1285 16 states state NNS 35772 1285 17 implies imply VBZ 35772 1285 18 the the DT 35772 1285 19 absurd absurd JJ 35772 1285 20 proposition proposition NN 35772 1285 21 that that DT 35772 1285 22 movement movement NN 35772 1285 23 is be VBZ 35772 1285 24 made make VBN 35772 1285 25 up up RP 35772 1285 26 of of IN 35772 1285 27 immobilities immobility NNS 35772 1285 28 . . . 35772 1286 1 " " `` 35772 1286 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1286 3 55 55 CD 35772 1286 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1286 5 So so IN 35772 1286 6 that that IN 35772 1286 7 the the DT 35772 1286 8 intellect intellect NN 35772 1286 9 is be VBZ 35772 1286 10 best well RBS 35772 1286 11 fitted fit VBN 35772 1286 12 to to TO 35772 1286 13 deal deal VB 35772 1286 14 , , , 35772 1286 15 not not RB 35772 1286 16 with with IN 35772 1286 17 living living NN 35772 1286 18 and and CC 35772 1286 19 moving move VBG 35772 1286 20 , , , 35772 1286 21 but but CC 35772 1286 22 with with IN 35772 1286 23 dead dead JJ 35772 1286 24 and and CC 35772 1286 25 motionless motionless JJ 35772 1286 26 matter matter NN 35772 1286 27 . . . 35772 1287 1 Of of IN 35772 1287 2 the the DT 35772 1287 3 latter latter JJ 35772 1287 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 5 can can MD 35772 1287 6 form form VB 35772 1287 7 a a DT 35772 1287 8 clear clear JJ 35772 1287 9 idea idea NN 35772 1287 10 ; ; : 35772 1287 11 but but CC 35772 1287 12 in in IN 35772 1287 13 dealing deal VBG 35772 1287 14 with with IN 35772 1287 15 the the DT 35772 1287 16 former former JJ 35772 1287 17 , , , 35772 1287 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 19 finds find VBZ 35772 1287 20 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 21 at at IN 35772 1287 22 a a DT 35772 1287 23 loss loss NN 35772 1287 24 ; ; : 35772 1287 25 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 26 has have VBZ 35772 1287 27 to to TO 35772 1287 28 abstract abstract VB 35772 1287 29 the the DT 35772 1287 30 life life NN 35772 1287 31 and and CC 35772 1287 32 the the DT 35772 1287 33 motion motion NN 35772 1287 34 from from IN 35772 1287 35 what what WP 35772 1287 36 lives live VBZ 35772 1287 37 or or CC 35772 1287 38 moves move NNS 35772 1287 39 , , , 35772 1287 40 and and CC 35772 1287 41 what what WP 35772 1287 42 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 43 can can MD 35772 1287 44 not not RB 35772 1287 45 grasp grasp VB 35772 1287 46 , , , 35772 1287 47 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1287 48 must must MD 35772 1287 49 treat treat VB 35772 1287 50 as as IN 35772 1287 51 non non JJ 35772 1287 52 - - JJ 35772 1287 53 existent existent NN 35772 1287 54 . . . 35772 1288 1 BERGSON BERGSON NNP 35772 1288 2 'S 's POS 35772 1288 3 ANTI anti JJ 35772 1288 4 - - HYPH 35772 1288 5 INTELLECTUALISM.--A intellectualism.--a JJ 35772 1288 6 penetrating penetrating NN 35772 1288 7 remark remark NN 35772 1288 8 of of IN 35772 1288 9 James James NNP 35772 1288 10 ' ' '' 35772 1288 11 will will MD 35772 1288 12 help help VB 35772 1288 13 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1288 14 , , , 35772 1288 15 at at IN 35772 1288 16 this this DT 35772 1288 17 point point NN 35772 1288 18 , , , 35772 1288 19 to to TO 35772 1288 20 understand understand VB 35772 1288 21 the the DT 35772 1288 22 significance significance NN 35772 1288 23 for for IN 35772 1288 24 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1288 25 of of IN 35772 1288 26 these these DT 35772 1288 27 new new JJ 35772 1288 28 theories theory NNS 35772 1288 29 . . . 35772 1289 1 " " `` 35772 1289 2 In in IN 35772 1289 3 spite spite NN 35772 1289 4 of of IN 35772 1289 5 sceptics sceptic NNS 35772 1289 6 and and CC 35772 1289 7 empiricists empiricist NNS 35772 1289 8 , , , 35772 1289 9 in in IN 35772 1289 10 spite spite NN 35772 1289 11 of of IN 35772 1289 12 Protagoras Protagoras NNP 35772 1289 13 , , , 35772 1289 14 Hume Hume NNP 35772 1289 15 , , , 35772 1289 16 and and CC 35772 1289 17 James James NNP 35772 1289 18 Mill Mill NNP 35772 1289 19 , , , 35772 1289 20 rationalism rationalism NN 35772 1289 21 has have VBZ 35772 1289 22 never never RB 35772 1289 23 been be VBN 35772 1289 24 seriously seriously RB 35772 1289 25 questioned question VBN 35772 1289 26 , , , 35772 1289 27 for for IN 35772 1289 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1289 29 sharpest sharp JJS 35772 1289 30 critics critic NNS 35772 1289 31 have have VBP 35772 1289 32 always always RB 35772 1289 33 had have VBN 35772 1289 34 a a DT 35772 1289 35 tender tender JJ 35772 1289 36 place place NN 35772 1289 37 for for IN 35772 1289 38 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1289 39 in in IN 35772 1289 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1289 41 hearts heart NNS 35772 1289 42 , , , 35772 1289 43 and and CC 35772 1289 44 have have VBP 35772 1289 45 obeyed obey VBN 35772 1289 46 some some DT 35772 1289 47 of of IN 35772 1289 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1289 49 mandates mandate NNS 35772 1289 50 . . . 35772 1290 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1290 2 have have VBP 35772 1290 3 not not RB 35772 1290 4 been be VBN 35772 1290 5 consistent consistent JJ 35772 1290 6 , , , 35772 1290 7 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1290 8 have have VBP 35772 1290 9 played play VBN 35772 1290 10 fast fast RB 35772 1290 11 and and CC 35772 1290 12 loose loose JJ 35772 1290 13 with with IN 35772 1290 14 the the DT 35772 1290 15 enemy enemy NN 35772 1290 16 , , , 35772 1290 17 and and CC 35772 1290 18 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1290 19 alone alone RB 35772 1290 20 has have VBZ 35772 1290 21 been be VBN 35772 1290 22 radical radical JJ 35772 1290 23 . . . 35772 1291 1 " " `` 35772 1291 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1291 3 56 56 CD 35772 1291 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1291 5 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1291 6 's 's POS 35772 1291 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1291 8 is be VBZ 35772 1291 9 , , , 35772 1291 10 in in IN 35772 1291 11 fact fact NN 35772 1291 12 , , , 35772 1291 13 a a DT 35772 1291 14 reaction reaction NN 35772 1291 15 against against IN 35772 1291 16 intellectualism intellectualism NN 35772 1291 17 or or CC 35772 1291 18 rationalism rationalism NN 35772 1291 19 ; ; : 35772 1291 20 by by IN 35772 1291 21 which which WDT 35772 1291 22 is be VBZ 35772 1291 23 meant mean VBN 35772 1291 24 the the DT 35772 1291 25 theory theory NN 35772 1291 26 that that IN 35772 1291 27 pure pure JJ 35772 1291 28 reason reason NN 35772 1291 29 is be VBZ 35772 1291 30 competent competent JJ 35772 1291 31 by by IN 35772 1291 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1291 33 nature nature NN 35772 1291 34 to to TO 35772 1291 35 give give VB 35772 1291 36 a a DT 35772 1291 37 complete complete JJ 35772 1291 38 and and CC 35772 1291 39 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 35772 1291 40 account account NN 35772 1291 41 of of IN 35772 1291 42 reality reality NN 35772 1291 43 . . . 35772 1292 1 But but CC 35772 1292 2 according accord VBG 35772 1292 3 to to IN 35772 1292 4 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1292 5 , , , 35772 1292 6 intellect intellect NN 35772 1292 7 , , , 35772 1292 8 which which WDT 35772 1292 9 is be VBZ 35772 1292 10 a a DT 35772 1292 11 faculty faculty NN 35772 1292 12 developed develop VBN 35772 1292 13 to to TO 35772 1292 14 enable enable VB 35772 1292 15 men man NNS 35772 1292 16 to to TO 35772 1292 17 subdue subdue VB 35772 1292 18 and and CC 35772 1292 19 turn turn VB 35772 1292 20 to to TO 35772 1292 21 advantage advantage VB 35772 1292 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1292 23 material material NN 35772 1292 24 environment environment NN 35772 1292 25 , , , 35772 1292 26 and and CC 35772 1292 27 which which WDT 35772 1292 28 is be VBZ 35772 1292 29 , , , 35772 1292 30 as as IN 35772 1292 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1292 32 were be VBD 35772 1292 33 , , , 35772 1292 34 " " '' 35772 1292 35 fascinated fascinate VBN 35772 1292 36 by by IN 35772 1292 37 the the DT 35772 1292 38 contemplation contemplation NN 35772 1292 39 of of IN 35772 1292 40 inert inert JJ 35772 1292 41 matter matter NN 35772 1292 42 , , , 35772 1292 43 " " `` 35772 1292 44 will will MD 35772 1292 45 not not RB 35772 1292 46 reveal reveal VB 35772 1292 47 the the DT 35772 1292 48 true true JJ 35772 1292 49 meaning meaning NN 35772 1292 50 and and CC 35772 1292 51 nature nature NN 35772 1292 52 of of IN 35772 1292 53 existence existence NN 35772 1292 54 ; ; : 35772 1292 55 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1292 56 gives give VBZ 35772 1292 57 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1292 58 " " `` 35772 1292 59 a a DT 35772 1292 60 translation translation NN 35772 1292 61 of of IN 35772 1292 62 life life NN 35772 1292 63 in in IN 35772 1292 64 terms term NNS 35772 1292 65 of of IN 35772 1292 66 inertia inertia NN 35772 1292 67 , , , 35772 1292 68 " " '' 35772 1292 69 and and CC 35772 1292 70 can can MD 35772 1292 71 do do VB 35772 1292 72 no no DT 35772 1292 73 more more JJR 35772 1292 74 . . . 35772 1293 1 This this DT 35772 1293 2 criticism criticism NN 35772 1293 3 of of IN 35772 1293 4 the the DT 35772 1293 5 intellect intellect NN 35772 1293 6 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1293 7 if if IN 35772 1293 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1293 9 be be VBP 35772 1293 10 sound sound JJ 35772 1293 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1293 12 , , , 35772 1293 13 though though IN 35772 1293 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1293 15 does do VBZ 35772 1293 16 not not RB 35772 1293 17 invalidate invalidate VB 35772 1293 18 the the DT 35772 1293 19 work work NN 35772 1293 20 of of IN 35772 1293 21 that that DT 35772 1293 22 faculty faculty NN 35772 1293 23 in in IN 35772 1293 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1293 25 own own JJ 35772 1293 26 proper proper JJ 35772 1293 27 sphere sphere NN 35772 1293 28 , , , 35772 1293 29 necessarily necessarily RB 35772 1293 30 involves involve VBZ 35772 1293 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1293 32 discredit discredit NN 35772 1293 33 as as IN 35772 1293 34 a a DT 35772 1293 35 key key NN 35772 1293 36 to to IN 35772 1293 37 the the DT 35772 1293 38 unlocking unlocking NN 35772 1293 39 of of IN 35772 1293 40 the the DT 35772 1293 41 final final JJ 35772 1293 42 mysteries mystery NNS 35772 1293 43 of of IN 35772 1293 44 life life NN 35772 1293 45 and and CC 35772 1293 46 of of IN 35772 1293 47 being be VBG 35772 1293 48 . . . 35772 1294 1 These these DT 35772 1294 2 things thing NNS 35772 1294 3 lie lie VBP 35772 1294 4 outside outside IN 35772 1294 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1294 6 province province NN 35772 1294 7 . . . 35772 1295 1 " " `` 35772 1295 2 Whether whether IN 35772 1295 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1295 4 wants want VBZ 35772 1295 5 to to TO 35772 1295 6 treat treat VB 35772 1295 7 of of IN 35772 1295 8 the the DT 35772 1295 9 life life NN 35772 1295 10 of of IN 35772 1295 11 the the DT 35772 1295 12 body body NN 35772 1295 13 , , , 35772 1295 14 or or CC 35772 1295 15 the the DT 35772 1295 16 life life NN 35772 1295 17 of of IN 35772 1295 18 the the DT 35772 1295 19 mind mind NN 35772 1295 20 , , , 35772 1295 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1295 22 proceeds proceed VBZ 35772 1295 23 with with IN 35772 1295 24 the the DT 35772 1295 25 rigour rigour NN 35772 1295 26 , , , 35772 1295 27 the the DT 35772 1295 28 stiffness stiffness NN 35772 1295 29 , , , 35772 1295 30 and and CC 35772 1295 31 the the DT 35772 1295 32 brutality brutality NN 35772 1295 33 of of IN 35772 1295 34 an an DT 35772 1295 35 instrument instrument NN 35772 1295 36 not not RB 35772 1295 37 designed design VBN 35772 1295 38 for for IN 35772 1295 39 such such JJ 35772 1295 40 use use NN 35772 1295 41 . . . 35772 1296 1 " " `` 35772 1296 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1296 3 57 57 CD 35772 1296 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1296 5 INTELLECT INTELLECT NNS 35772 1296 6 AND and CC 35772 1296 7 INSTINCT.--Since instinct.--since NN 35772 1296 8 intellect intellect NN 35772 1296 9 , , , 35772 1296 10 by by IN 35772 1296 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1296 12 methods method NNS 35772 1296 13 , , , 35772 1296 14 has have VBZ 35772 1296 15 induced induce VBN 35772 1296 16 men man NNS 35772 1296 17 to to TO 35772 1296 18 turn turn VB 35772 1296 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1296 20 backs back NNS 35772 1296 21 on on IN 35772 1296 22 reality reality NN 35772 1296 23 , , , 35772 1296 24 and and CC 35772 1296 25 to to TO 35772 1296 26 look look VB 35772 1296 27 on on IN 35772 1296 28 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1296 29 instead instead RB 35772 1296 30 , , , 35772 1296 31 the the DT 35772 1296 32 only only JJ 35772 1296 33 hope hope NN 35772 1296 34 of of IN 35772 1296 35 reaching reach VBG 35772 1296 36 reality reality NN 35772 1296 37 is be VBZ 35772 1296 38 through through IN 35772 1296 39 an an DT 35772 1296 40 entire entire JJ 35772 1296 41 change change NN 35772 1296 42 of of IN 35772 1296 43 method method NN 35772 1296 44 and and CC 35772 1296 45 direction direction NN 35772 1296 46 . . . 35772 1297 1 There there EX 35772 1297 2 is be VBZ 35772 1297 3 , , , 35772 1297 4 according accord VBG 35772 1297 5 to to IN 35772 1297 6 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1297 7 , , , 35772 1297 8 a a DT 35772 1297 9 non non JJ 35772 1297 10 - - JJ 35772 1297 11 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1297 12 variety variety NN 35772 1297 13 of of IN 35772 1297 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1297 15 , , , 35772 1297 16 which which WDT 35772 1297 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1297 18 from from IN 35772 1297 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1297 20 point point NN 35772 1297 21 of of IN 35772 1297 22 view view NN 35772 1297 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1297 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1297 25 was be VBD 35772 1297 26 a a DT 35772 1297 27 kind kind NN 35772 1297 28 of of IN 35772 1297 29 original original JJ 35772 1297 30 sin sin NN 35772 1297 31 ever ever RB 35772 1297 32 to to TO 35772 1297 33 depart depart VB 35772 1297 34 from from IN 35772 1297 35 ; ; : 35772 1297 36 an an DT 35772 1297 37 original original JJ 35772 1297 38 sin sin NN 35772 1297 39 which which WDT 35772 1297 40 has have VBZ 35772 1297 41 vitiated vitiate VBN 35772 1297 42 all all PDT 35772 1297 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1297 44 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1297 45 thinking thinking NN 35772 1297 46 from from IN 35772 1297 47 the the DT 35772 1297 48 days day NNS 35772 1297 49 of of IN 35772 1297 50 Plato Plato NNP 35772 1297 51 . . . 35772 1298 1 This this DT 35772 1298 2 variety variety NN 35772 1298 3 of of IN 35772 1298 4 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1298 5 is be VBZ 35772 1298 6 more more RBR 35772 1298 7 original original JJ 35772 1298 8 and and CC 35772 1298 9 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1298 10 than than IN 35772 1298 11 any any DT 35772 1298 12 which which WDT 35772 1298 13 the the DT 35772 1298 14 processes process NNS 35772 1298 15 of of IN 35772 1298 16 the the DT 35772 1298 17 intellect intellect NN 35772 1298 18 , , , 35772 1298 19 vitiated vitiate VBN 35772 1298 20 as as IN 35772 1298 21 these these DT 35772 1298 22 are be VBP 35772 1298 23 by by IN 35772 1298 24 certain certain JJ 35772 1298 25 inherent inherent JJ 35772 1298 26 perversions perversion NNS 35772 1298 27 , , , 35772 1298 28 can can MD 35772 1298 29 give give VB 35772 1298 30 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1298 31 . . . 35772 1299 1 Intellect intellect NN 35772 1299 2 can can MD 35772 1299 3 not not RB 35772 1299 4 correct correct VB 35772 1299 5 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1299 6 ; ; : 35772 1299 7 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1299 8 must must MD 35772 1299 9 call call VB 35772 1299 10 in in IN 35772 1299 11 the the DT 35772 1299 12 aid aid NN 35772 1299 13 of of IN 35772 1299 14 some some DT 35772 1299 15 other other JJ 35772 1299 16 faculty faculty NN 35772 1299 17 if if IN 35772 1299 18 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1299 19 would would MD 35772 1299 20 understand understand VB 35772 1299 21 reality reality NN 35772 1299 22 . . . 35772 1300 1 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1300 2 finds find VBZ 35772 1300 3 this this DT 35772 1300 4 faculty faculty NN 35772 1300 5 in in IN 35772 1300 6 what what WP 35772 1300 7 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1300 8 calls call VBZ 35772 1300 9 " " `` 35772 1300 10 instinct instinct NN 35772 1300 11 . . . 35772 1300 12 " " '' 35772 1301 1 According accord VBG 35772 1301 2 to to IN 35772 1301 3 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1301 4 , , , 35772 1301 5 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1301 6 has have VBZ 35772 1301 7 developed develop VBN 35772 1301 8 in in IN 35772 1301 9 two two CD 35772 1301 10 divergent divergent JJ 35772 1301 11 directions direction NNS 35772 1301 12 -- -- : 35772 1301 13 instinct instinct NN 35772 1301 14 and and CC 35772 1301 15 intellect intellect NN 35772 1301 16 ; ; : 35772 1301 17 and and CC 35772 1301 18 the the DT 35772 1301 19 difference difference NN 35772 1301 20 between between IN 35772 1301 21 these these DT 35772 1301 22 is be VBZ 35772 1301 23 not not RB 35772 1301 24 one one CD 35772 1301 25 of of IN 35772 1301 26 intensity intensity NN 35772 1301 27 or or CC 35772 1301 28 degree degree NN 35772 1301 29 , , , 35772 1301 30 but but CC 35772 1301 31 of of IN 35772 1301 32 _ _ NNP 35772 1301 33 kind kind NN 35772 1301 34 _ _ NNP 35772 1301 35 . . . 35772 1302 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1302 2 58 58 CD 35772 1302 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1302 4 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1302 5 are be VBP 35772 1302 6 two two CD 35772 1302 7 divergent divergent JJ 35772 1302 8 developments development NNS 35772 1302 9 of of IN 35772 1302 10 the the DT 35772 1302 11 same same JJ 35772 1302 12 original original JJ 35772 1302 13 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1302 14 , , , 35772 1302 15 of of IN 35772 1302 16 which which WDT 35772 1302 17 common common JJ 35772 1302 18 origin origin NN 35772 1302 19 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1302 20 both both DT 35772 1302 21 retain retain VBP 35772 1302 22 traces trace NNS 35772 1302 23 , , , 35772 1302 24 for for IN 35772 1302 25 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1302 26 are be VBP 35772 1302 27 not not RB 35772 1302 28 entirely entirely RB 35772 1302 29 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 35772 1302 30 , , , 35772 1302 31 nor nor CC 35772 1302 32 is be VBZ 35772 1302 33 either either DT 35772 1302 34 of of IN 35772 1302 35 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1302 36 ever ever RB 35772 1302 37 found find VBD 35772 1302 38 in in IN 35772 1302 39 a a DT 35772 1302 40 pure pure JJ 35772 1302 41 state state NN 35772 1302 42 . . . 35772 1303 1 Intellect intellect NN 35772 1303 2 is be VBZ 35772 1303 3 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 1303 4 of of IN 35772 1303 5 man man NN 35772 1303 6 . . . 35772 1304 1 Instinct Instinct NNP 35772 1304 2 is be VBZ 35772 1304 3 most most RBS 35772 1304 4 highly highly RB 35772 1304 5 developed develop VBN 35772 1304 6 among among IN 35772 1304 7 certain certain JJ 35772 1304 8 insects insect NNS 35772 1304 9 , , , 35772 1304 10 notably notably RB 35772 1304 11 the the DT 35772 1304 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1304 13 hymenopterae hymenopterae NNP 35772 1304 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1304 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1304 16 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1304 17 , , , 35772 1304 18 bees bee NNS 35772 1304 19 and and CC 35772 1304 20 ants ant NNS 35772 1304 21 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1304 22 . . . 35772 1305 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1305 2 59 59 CD 35772 1305 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1305 4 BLINDNESS BLINDNESS NNP 35772 1305 5 OF of IN 35772 1305 6 INTELLECT.--And intellect.--and RB 35772 1305 7 the the DT 35772 1305 8 difficulty difficulty NN 35772 1305 9 of of IN 35772 1305 10 the the DT 35772 1305 11 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1305 12 problem problem NN 35772 1305 13 for for IN 35772 1305 14 man man NN 35772 1305 15 arises arise VBZ 35772 1305 16 from from IN 35772 1305 17 the the DT 35772 1305 18 anomalies anomaly NNS 35772 1305 19 of of IN 35772 1305 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1305 21 own own JJ 35772 1305 22 constitution constitution NN 35772 1305 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1305 24 as as IN 35772 1305 25 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 1305 26 by by IN 35772 1305 27 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1305 28 in in IN 35772 1305 29 the the DT 35772 1305 30 light light NN 35772 1305 31 of of IN 35772 1305 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1305 33 theory theory NN 35772 1305 34 of of IN 35772 1305 35 instinct instinct NN 35772 1305 36 and and CC 35772 1305 37 intellect intellect NN 35772 1305 38 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1305 39 . . . 35772 1306 1 As as IN 35772 1306 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1306 3 puts put VBZ 35772 1306 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1306 5 : : : 35772 1306 6 " " `` 35772 1306 7 There there EX 35772 1306 8 are be VBP 35772 1306 9 things thing NNS 35772 1306 10 that that WDT 35772 1306 11 Intelligence Intelligence NNP 35772 1306 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1306 13 or or CC 35772 1306 14 intellect intellect VB 35772 1306 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1306 16 alone alone RB 35772 1306 17 is be VBZ 35772 1306 18 able able JJ 35772 1306 19 to to TO 35772 1306 20 seek seek VB 35772 1306 21 , , , 35772 1306 22 but but CC 35772 1306 23 which which WDT 35772 1306 24 , , , 35772 1306 25 by by IN 35772 1306 26 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1306 27 , , , 35772 1306 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1306 29 will will MD 35772 1306 30 never never RB 35772 1306 31 find find VB 35772 1306 32 . . . 35772 1307 1 These these DT 35772 1307 2 things thing NNS 35772 1307 3 instinct instinct VBP 35772 1307 4 alone alone RB 35772 1307 5 could could MD 35772 1307 6 find find VB 35772 1307 7 ; ; : 35772 1307 8 but but CC 35772 1307 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1307 10 will will MD 35772 1307 11 never never RB 35772 1307 12 seek seek VB 35772 1307 13 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1307 14 . . . 35772 1307 15 " " '' 35772 1308 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1308 2 _ _ NNP 35772 1308 3 Creative Creative NNP 35772 1308 4 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1308 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1308 6 , , , 35772 1308 7 p. p. NN 35772 1308 8 159 159 CD 35772 1308 9 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1308 10 . . . 35772 1309 1 " " `` 35772 1309 2 If if IN 35772 1309 3 the the DT 35772 1309 4 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1309 5 which which WDT 35772 1309 6 slumbers slumber VBZ 35772 1309 7 in in IN 35772 1309 8 instinct instinct NN 35772 1309 9 were be VBD 35772 1309 10 to to TO 35772 1309 11 wake wake VB 35772 1309 12 up up RP 35772 1309 13 ... ... NFP 35772 1309 14 if if IN 35772 1309 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1309 16 knew know VBD 35772 1309 17 how how WRB 35772 1309 18 to to TO 35772 1309 19 question question VB 35772 1309 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1309 21 , , , 35772 1309 22 and and CC 35772 1309 23 if if IN 35772 1309 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1309 25 knew know VBD 35772 1309 26 how how WRB 35772 1309 27 to to TO 35772 1309 28 reply reply VB 35772 1309 29 , , , 35772 1309 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1309 31 would would MD 35772 1309 32 deliver deliver VB 35772 1309 33 to to IN 35772 1309 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1309 35 keeping keeping NN 35772 1309 36 the the DT 35772 1309 37 most most RBS 35772 1309 38 intimate intimate JJ 35772 1309 39 secrets secret NNS 35772 1309 40 of of IN 35772 1309 41 life life NN 35772 1309 42 . . . 35772 1309 43 " " '' 35772 1310 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1310 2 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1310 3 regards regard VBZ 35772 1310 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1310 5 as as RB 35772 1310 6 impossible impossible JJ 35772 1310 7 that that IN 35772 1310 8 intellect intellect NN 35772 1310 9 should should MD 35772 1310 10 ever ever RB 35772 1310 11 supply supply VB 35772 1310 12 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1310 13 with with IN 35772 1310 14 the the DT 35772 1310 15 complete complete JJ 35772 1310 16 truth truth NN 35772 1310 17 about about IN 35772 1310 18 reality reality NN 35772 1310 19 ; ; : 35772 1310 20 there there EX 35772 1310 21 are be VBP 35772 1310 22 things thing NNS 35772 1310 23 , , , 35772 1310 24 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 1311 1 life life NN 35772 1311 2 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1311 3 -- -- : 35772 1311 4 which which WDT 35772 1311 5 altogether altogether RB 35772 1311 6 elude elude VBP 35772 1311 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1311 8 grasp grasp NN 35772 1311 9 . . . 35772 1312 1 INTUITION.--The intuition.--the UH 35772 1312 2 situation situation NN 35772 1312 3 , , , 35772 1312 4 however however RB 35772 1312 5 , , , 35772 1312 6 is be VBZ 35772 1312 7 not not RB 35772 1312 8 entirely entirely RB 35772 1312 9 hopeless hopeless JJ 35772 1312 10 . . . 35772 1313 1 Man man NN 35772 1313 2 possesses possess VBZ 35772 1313 3 some some DT 35772 1313 4 measure measure NN 35772 1313 5 of of IN 35772 1313 6 instinct instinct NN 35772 1313 7 , , , 35772 1313 8 which which WDT 35772 1313 9 , , , 35772 1313 10 when when WRB 35772 1313 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1313 12 has have VBZ 35772 1313 13 " " `` 35772 1313 14 become become VBN 35772 1313 15 disinterested disinterested JJ 35772 1313 16 , , , 35772 1313 17 self self NN 35772 1313 18 - - HYPH 35772 1313 19 conscious conscious JJ 35772 1313 20 , , , 35772 1313 21 and and CC 35772 1313 22 capable capable JJ 35772 1313 23 of of IN 35772 1313 24 reflecting reflect VBG 35772 1313 25 upon upon IN 35772 1313 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1313 27 object object NN 35772 1313 28 , , , 35772 1313 29 " " '' 35772 1313 30 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1313 31 calls call VBZ 35772 1313 32 intuition intuition NN 35772 1313 33 . . . 35772 1314 1 By by IN 35772 1314 2 means mean NNS 35772 1314 3 of of IN 35772 1314 4 this this DT 35772 1314 5 faculty faculty NN 35772 1314 6 , , , 35772 1314 7 man man NN 35772 1314 8 is be VBZ 35772 1314 9 able able JJ 35772 1314 10 , , , 35772 1314 11 darkly darkly RB 35772 1314 12 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1314 13 but but CC 35772 1314 14 not not RB 35772 1314 15 ineffectually ineffectually RB 35772 1314 16 , , , 35772 1314 17 to to TO 35772 1314 18 grope grope VB 35772 1314 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1314 20 way way NN 35772 1314 21 towards towards IN 35772 1314 22 an an DT 35772 1314 23 understanding understanding NN 35772 1314 24 of of IN 35772 1314 25 reality reality NN 35772 1314 26 . . . 35772 1315 1 CHARACTERISTICS CHARACTERISTICS NNP 35772 1315 2 OF of IN 35772 1315 3 THE the DT 35772 1315 4 NEW NEW NNP 35772 1315 5 PHILOSOPHY.--Just philosophy.--just NN 35772 1315 6 as as IN 35772 1315 7 the the DT 35772 1315 8 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 1315 9 of of IN 35772 1315 10 Cusanus Cusanus NNP 35772 1315 11 and and CC 35772 1315 12 others other NNS 35772 1315 13 freed free VBD 35772 1315 14 thought think VBD 35772 1315 15 from from IN 35772 1315 16 an an DT 35772 1315 17 incubus incubus NN 35772 1315 18 which which WDT 35772 1315 19 seemed seem VBD 35772 1315 20 likely likely JJ 35772 1315 21 to to TO 35772 1315 22 prevent prevent VB 35772 1315 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1315 24 further further JJ 35772 1315 25 development development NN 35772 1315 26 , , , 35772 1315 27 so so RB 35772 1315 28 the the DT 35772 1315 29 movement movement NN 35772 1315 30 initiated initiate VBN 35772 1315 31 by by IN 35772 1315 32 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1315 33 and and CC 35772 1315 34 culminating culminate VBG 35772 1315 35 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1315 36 for for IN 35772 1315 37 the the DT 35772 1315 38 present present NN 35772 1315 39 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1315 40 in in IN 35772 1315 41 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1315 42 , , , 35772 1315 43 has have VBZ 35772 1315 44 done do VBN 35772 1315 45 much much JJ 35772 1315 46 to to TO 35772 1315 47 discredit discredit VB 35772 1315 48 " " `` 35772 1315 49 a a DT 35772 1315 50 certain certain JJ 35772 1315 51 new new JJ 35772 1315 52 scholasticism scholasticism NN 35772 1315 53 that that WDT 35772 1315 54 has have VBZ 35772 1315 55 grown grow VBN 35772 1315 56 up up RP 35772 1315 57 during during IN 35772 1315 58 the the DT 35772 1315 59 latter latter JJ 35772 1315 60 half half NN 35772 1315 61 of of IN 35772 1315 62 the the DT 35772 1315 63 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1315 64 century century NN 35772 1315 65 around around IN 35772 1315 66 the the DT 35772 1315 67 physics physics NN 35772 1315 68 of of IN 35772 1315 69 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 1315 70 , , , 35772 1315 71 as as IN 35772 1315 72 the the DT 35772 1315 73 old old JJ 35772 1315 74 scholasticism scholasticism NN 35772 1315 75 grew grow VBD 35772 1315 76 up up RP 35772 1315 77 around around IN 35772 1315 78 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 35772 1315 79 . . . 35772 1316 1 " " `` 35772 1316 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1316 3 60 60 CD 35772 1316 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1316 5 Mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1316 6 determinism determinism NN 35772 1316 7 was be VBD 35772 1316 8 characteristic characteristic JJ 35772 1316 9 of of IN 35772 1316 10 much much JJ 35772 1316 11 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1316 12 - - HYPH 35772 1316 13 century century NN 35772 1316 14 thought thought NN 35772 1316 15 in in IN 35772 1316 16 Europe Europe NNP 35772 1316 17 , , , 35772 1316 18 not not RB 35772 1316 19 only only RB 35772 1316 20 amongst amongst IN 35772 1316 21 materialists materialist NNS 35772 1316 22 , , , 35772 1316 23 but but CC 35772 1316 24 also also RB 35772 1316 25 , , , 35772 1316 26 in in IN 35772 1316 27 certain certain JJ 35772 1316 28 cases case NNS 35772 1316 29 , , , 35772 1316 30 amongst amongst IN 35772 1316 31 idealists idealist NNS 35772 1316 32 as as RB 35772 1316 33 well well RB 35772 1316 34 . . . 35772 1317 1 Against against IN 35772 1317 2 this this DT 35772 1317 3 aspect aspect NN 35772 1317 4 of of IN 35772 1317 5 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 1317 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1317 7 , , , 35772 1317 8 the the DT 35772 1317 9 work work NN 35772 1317 10 of of IN 35772 1317 11 James James NNP 35772 1317 12 and and CC 35772 1317 13 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1317 14 has have VBZ 35772 1317 15 been be VBN 35772 1317 16 a a DT 35772 1317 17 revolt revolt NN 35772 1317 18 . . . 35772 1318 1 " " `` 35772 1318 2 Indeterminism indeterminism NN 35772 1318 3 , , , 35772 1318 4 " " '' 35772 1318 5 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1319 1 a a DT 35772 1319 2 belief belief NN 35772 1319 3 in in IN 35772 1319 4 the the DT 35772 1319 5 reality reality NN 35772 1319 6 of of IN 35772 1319 7 freedom freedom NN 35772 1319 8 and and CC 35772 1319 9 spontaneity spontaneity NN 35772 1319 10 , , , 35772 1319 11 is be VBZ 35772 1319 12 an an DT 35772 1319 13 essential essential JJ 35772 1319 14 part part NN 35772 1319 15 of of IN 35772 1319 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1319 17 system system NN 35772 1319 18 . . . 35772 1320 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1320 2 indeterminism indeterminism NN 35772 1320 3 is be VBZ 35772 1320 4 indeed indeed RB 35772 1320 5 the the DT 35772 1320 6 necessary necessary JJ 35772 1320 7 and and CC 35772 1320 8 logical logical JJ 35772 1320 9 accompaniment accompaniment NN 35772 1320 10 of of IN 35772 1320 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1320 12 anti anti NN 35772 1320 13 - - NN 35772 1320 14 intellectualism intellectualism NN 35772 1320 15 . . . 35772 1321 1 For for IN 35772 1321 2 determinism determinism NN 35772 1321 3 is be VBZ 35772 1321 4 " " `` 35772 1321 5 a a DT 35772 1321 6 fabrication fabrication NN 35772 1321 7 of of IN 35772 1321 8 the the DT 35772 1321 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1321 10 intellect intellect NN 35772 1321 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1321 12 , , , 35772 1321 13 " " '' 35772 1321 14 a a DT 35772 1321 15 device device NN 35772 1321 16 which which WDT 35772 1321 17 makes make VBZ 35772 1321 18 reality reality NN 35772 1321 19 more more RBR 35772 1321 20 manageable manageable JJ 35772 1321 21 , , , 35772 1321 22 more more RBR 35772 1321 23 amenable amenable JJ 35772 1321 24 to to IN 35772 1321 25 logic logic NN 35772 1321 26 , , , 35772 1321 27 more more RBR 35772 1321 28 easily easily RB 35772 1321 29 systematised systematise VBN 35772 1321 30 . . . 35772 1322 1 Freedom freedom NN 35772 1322 2 , , , 35772 1322 3 like like IN 35772 1322 4 life life NN 35772 1322 5 and and CC 35772 1322 6 motion motion NN 35772 1322 7 , , , 35772 1322 8 eludes elude VBZ 35772 1322 9 the the DT 35772 1322 10 categories category NNS 35772 1322 11 of of IN 35772 1322 12 the the DT 35772 1322 13 intellect intellect NN 35772 1322 14 . . . 35772 1323 1 THE the DT 35772 1323 2 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 1323 3 VIEW view NN 35772 1323 4 ASSAILED.--Such ASSAILED.--Such NNP 35772 1323 5 are be VBP 35772 1323 6 the the DT 35772 1323 7 lines line NNS 35772 1323 8 upon upon IN 35772 1323 9 which which WDT 35772 1323 10 the the DT 35772 1323 11 new new JJ 35772 1323 12 criticism criticism NN 35772 1323 13 of of IN 35772 1323 14 the the DT 35772 1323 15 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1323 16 view view NN 35772 1323 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1323 18 the the DT 35772 1323 19 most most RBS 35772 1323 20 radical radical JJ 35772 1323 21 criticism criticism NN 35772 1323 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1323 23 has have VBZ 35772 1323 24 had have VBN 35772 1323 25 to to TO 35772 1323 26 meet meet VB 35772 1323 27 since since IN 35772 1323 28 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1323 29 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1323 30 proceeds proceed VBZ 35772 1323 31 . . . 35772 1324 1 That that DT 35772 1324 2 view view NN 35772 1324 3 , , , 35772 1324 4 and and CC 35772 1324 5 the the DT 35772 1324 6 idea idea NN 35772 1324 7 of of IN 35772 1324 8 predetermined predetermine VBN 35772 1324 9 human human JJ 35772 1324 10 action action NN 35772 1324 11 which which WDT 35772 1324 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1324 13 involves involve VBZ 35772 1324 14 , , , 35772 1324 15 is be VBZ 35772 1324 16 an an DT 35772 1324 17 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 1324 18 product product NN 35772 1324 19 of of IN 35772 1324 20 an an DT 35772 1324 21 intellect intellect NN 35772 1324 22 naturally naturally RB 35772 1324 23 incapable incapable JJ 35772 1324 24 of of IN 35772 1324 25 understanding understand VBG 35772 1324 26 freedom freedom NN 35772 1324 27 and and CC 35772 1324 28 spontaneity spontaneity NN 35772 1324 29 . . . 35772 1325 1 These these DT 35772 1325 2 , , , 35772 1325 3 as as IN 35772 1325 4 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1325 5 destroy destroy VBP 35772 1325 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1325 7 scheme scheme NN 35772 1325 8 of of IN 35772 1325 9 thought thought NN 35772 1325 10 , , , 35772 1325 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1325 12 casts cast VBZ 35772 1325 13 out out RP 35772 1325 14 as as IN 35772 1325 15 an an DT 35772 1325 16 illusion illusion NN 35772 1325 17 . . . 35772 1326 1 " " `` 35772 1326 2 Incorrigibly incorrigibly RB 35772 1326 3 presumptuous presumptuous JJ 35772 1326 4 , , , 35772 1326 5 " " '' 35772 1326 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1326 7 insists insist VBZ 35772 1326 8 on on IN 35772 1326 9 interpreting interpret VBG 35772 1326 10 freedom freedom NN 35772 1326 11 by by IN 35772 1326 12 means mean NNS 35772 1326 13 of of IN 35772 1326 14 those those DT 35772 1326 15 notions notion NNS 35772 1326 16 which which WDT 35772 1326 17 suit suit VBP 35772 1326 18 inert inert JJ 35772 1326 19 matter matter RB 35772 1326 20 alone alone RB 35772 1326 21 , , , 35772 1326 22 and and CC 35772 1326 23 therefore therefore RB 35772 1326 24 always always RB 35772 1326 25 perceives perceive VBZ 35772 1326 26 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1326 27 as as IN 35772 1326 28 necessity necessity NN 35772 1326 29 . . . 35772 1327 1 So so RB 35772 1327 2 that that IN 35772 1327 3 all all DT 35772 1327 4 life life NN 35772 1327 5 , , , 35772 1327 6 far far RB 35772 1327 7 from from IN 35772 1327 8 being be VBG 35772 1327 9 subjected subject VBN 35772 1327 10 to to IN 35772 1327 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1327 12 necessity necessity NN 35772 1327 13 , , , 35772 1327 14 as as IN 35772 1327 15 had have VBD 35772 1327 16 seemed seem VBN 35772 1327 17 the the DT 35772 1327 18 inevitable inevitable JJ 35772 1327 19 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 1327 20 of of IN 35772 1327 21 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1327 22 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1327 23 , , , 35772 1327 24 was be VBD 35772 1327 25 spontaneity spontaneity NN 35772 1327 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1327 27 so so RB 35772 1327 28 to to TO 35772 1327 29 speak speak VB 35772 1327 30 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1327 31 materialised materialise VBN 35772 1327 32 and and CC 35772 1327 33 embodied embody VBN 35772 1327 34 : : : 35772 1327 35 " " `` 35772 1327 36 All all PDT 35772 1327 37 the the DT 35772 1327 38 living living NN 35772 1327 39 hold hold NN 35772 1327 40 together together RB 35772 1327 41 , , , 35772 1327 42 and and CC 35772 1327 43 all all DT 35772 1327 44 yield yield VBP 35772 1327 45 to to IN 35772 1327 46 the the DT 35772 1327 47 same same JJ 35772 1327 48 tremendous tremendous JJ 35772 1327 49 push push NN 35772 1327 50 . . . 35772 1328 1 The the DT 35772 1328 2 animal animal NN 35772 1328 3 takes take VBZ 35772 1328 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1328 5 stand stand NN 35772 1328 6 on on IN 35772 1328 7 the the DT 35772 1328 8 plant plant NN 35772 1328 9 , , , 35772 1328 10 man man NN 35772 1328 11 bestrides bestride VBZ 35772 1328 12 animality animality NN 35772 1328 13 , , , 35772 1328 14 and and CC 35772 1328 15 the the DT 35772 1328 16 whole whole NN 35772 1328 17 of of IN 35772 1328 18 humanity humanity NN 35772 1328 19 ... ... : 35772 1328 20 is be VBZ 35772 1328 21 one one CD 35772 1328 22 immense immense JJ 35772 1328 23 army army NN 35772 1328 24 galloping gallop VBG 35772 1328 25 beside beside RB 35772 1328 26 and and CC 35772 1328 27 before before IN 35772 1328 28 and and CC 35772 1328 29 behind behind IN 35772 1328 30 each each DT 35772 1328 31 of of IN 35772 1328 32 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1328 33 in in IN 35772 1328 34 an an DT 35772 1328 35 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 35772 1328 36 charge charge NN 35772 1328 37 , , , 35772 1328 38 able able JJ 35772 1328 39 to to TO 35772 1328 40 beat beat VB 35772 1328 41 down down RP 35772 1328 42 every every DT 35772 1328 43 resistance resistance NN 35772 1328 44 and and CC 35772 1328 45 clear clear VB 35772 1328 46 the the DT 35772 1328 47 most most RBS 35772 1328 48 formidable formidable JJ 35772 1328 49 obstacles obstacle NNS 35772 1328 50 , , , 35772 1328 51 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1328 52 even even RB 35772 1328 53 death death NN 35772 1328 54 . . . 35772 1329 1 " " `` 35772 1329 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1329 3 61 61 CD 35772 1329 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1329 5 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1329 6 have have VBP 35772 1329 7 indeed indeed RB 35772 1329 8 travelled travel VBN 35772 1329 9 a a DT 35772 1329 10 long long JJ 35772 1329 11 way way NN 35772 1329 12 from from IN 35772 1329 13 the the DT 35772 1329 14 austere austere JJ 35772 1329 15 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1329 16 of of IN 35772 1329 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 1329 18 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1329 19 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1329 20 . . . 35772 1330 1 The the DT 35772 1330 2 new new JJ 35772 1330 3 evolutionism evolutionism NN 35772 1330 4 is be VBZ 35772 1330 5 very very RB 35772 1330 6 different different JJ 35772 1330 7 from from IN 35772 1330 8 the the DT 35772 1330 9 old old JJ 35772 1330 10 . . . 35772 1331 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1331 2 substitutes substitute VBZ 35772 1331 3 for for IN 35772 1331 4 " " `` 35772 1331 5 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1331 6 " " '' 35772 1331 7 another another DT 35772 1331 8 conception conception NN 35772 1331 9 -- -- : 35772 1331 10 that that DT 35772 1331 11 of of IN 35772 1331 12 " " `` 35772 1331 13 dynamism dynamism NN 35772 1331 14 , , , 35772 1331 15 " " '' 35772 1331 16 according accord VBG 35772 1331 17 to to IN 35772 1331 18 which which WDT 35772 1331 19 the the DT 35772 1331 20 process process NN 35772 1331 21 of of IN 35772 1331 22 evolution evolution NN 35772 1331 23 is be VBZ 35772 1331 24 something something NN 35772 1331 25 undetermined undetermined JJ 35772 1331 26 and and CC 35772 1331 27 impredictable--"creative impredictable--"creative JJ 35772 1331 28 , , , 35772 1331 29 " " '' 35772 1331 30 in in IN 35772 1331 31 fact fact NN 35772 1331 32 . . . 35772 1332 1 The the DT 35772 1332 2 world world NN 35772 1332 3 of of IN 35772 1332 4 organic organic JJ 35772 1332 5 life life NN 35772 1332 6 is be VBZ 35772 1332 7 embodied embody VBN 35772 1332 8 " " `` 35772 1332 9 creative creative JJ 35772 1332 10 activity activity NN 35772 1332 11 , , , 35772 1332 12 " " '' 35772 1332 13 and and CC 35772 1332 14 what what WP 35772 1332 15 this this DT 35772 1332 16 " " `` 35772 1332 17 creative creative JJ 35772 1332 18 activity activity NN 35772 1332 19 " " '' 35772 1332 20 is be VBZ 35772 1332 21 , , , 35772 1332 22 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1332 23 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1332 24 experience experience VBP 35772 1332 25 every every DT 35772 1332 26 time time NN 35772 1332 27 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1332 28 act act VBP 35772 1332 29 freely freely RB 35772 1332 30 . . . 35772 1333 1 PLURALISM.--The pluralism.--the JJ 35772 1333 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1333 3 of of IN 35772 1333 4 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1333 5 is be VBZ 35772 1333 6 a a DT 35772 1333 7 reaction reaction NN 35772 1333 8 against against IN 35772 1333 9 the the DT 35772 1333 10 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1333 11 evolutionism evolutionism NN 35772 1333 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1333 13 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1334 1 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1334 2 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1334 3 of of IN 35772 1334 4 the the DT 35772 1334 5 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1334 6 century century NN 35772 1334 7 . . . 35772 1335 1 Closely closely RB 35772 1335 2 allied ally VBN 35772 1335 3 with with IN 35772 1335 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1335 5 is be VBZ 35772 1335 6 another another DT 35772 1335 7 movement movement NN 35772 1335 8 of of IN 35772 1335 9 thought thought NN 35772 1335 10 , , , 35772 1335 11 known know VBN 35772 1335 12 as as IN 35772 1335 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1335 14 pluralism pluralism NN 35772 1335 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1335 16 . . . 35772 1336 1 This this DT 35772 1336 2 , , , 35772 1336 3 too too RB 35772 1336 4 , , , 35772 1336 5 is be VBZ 35772 1336 6 a a DT 35772 1336 7 reaction reaction NN 35772 1336 8 , , , 35772 1336 9 not not RB 35772 1336 10 so so RB 35772 1336 11 much much JJ 35772 1336 12 against against IN 35772 1336 13 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1336 14 , , , 35772 1336 15 as as IN 35772 1336 16 against against IN 35772 1336 17 certain certain JJ 35772 1336 18 forms form NNS 35772 1336 19 of of IN 35772 1336 20 idealism idealism NN 35772 1336 21 . . . 35772 1337 1 Idealism idealism NN 35772 1337 2 , , , 35772 1337 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1337 4 will will MD 35772 1337 5 be be VB 35772 1337 6 remembered remember VBN 35772 1337 7 , , , 35772 1337 8 seeks seek VBZ 35772 1337 9 to to TO 35772 1337 10 interpret interpret VB 35772 1337 11 reality reality NN 35772 1337 12 in in IN 35772 1337 13 terms term NNS 35772 1337 14 of of IN 35772 1337 15 mind mind NN 35772 1337 16 or or CC 35772 1337 17 spirit spirit NN 35772 1337 18 . . . 35772 1338 1 And and CC 35772 1338 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1338 3 does do VBZ 35772 1338 4 this this DT 35772 1338 5 in in IN 35772 1338 6 certain certain JJ 35772 1338 7 cases case NNS 35772 1338 8 -- -- : 35772 1338 9 notably notably RB 35772 1338 10 in in IN 35772 1338 11 the the DT 35772 1338 12 case case NN 35772 1338 13 of of IN 35772 1338 14 F. F. NNP 35772 1338 15 H. H. NNP 35772 1338 16 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1338 17 -- -- : 35772 1338 18 by by IN 35772 1338 19 regarding regard VBG 35772 1338 20 all all DT 35772 1338 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1338 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1338 23 _ _ NNP 35772 1338 24 as as IN 35772 1338 25 forms form NNS 35772 1338 26 or or CC 35772 1338 27 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1338 28 of of IN 35772 1338 29 the the DT 35772 1338 30 one one CD 35772 1338 31 absolute absolute JJ 35772 1338 32 mind mind NN 35772 1338 33 or or CC 35772 1338 34 spirit spirit NN 35772 1338 35 . . . 35772 1339 1 This this DT 35772 1339 2 has have VBZ 35772 1339 3 seemed seem VBN 35772 1339 4 to to IN 35772 1339 5 many many JJ 35772 1339 6 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1339 7 a a DT 35772 1339 8 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1339 9 too too RB 35772 1339 10 abstract abstract JJ 35772 1339 11 and and CC 35772 1339 12 too too RB 35772 1339 13 remote remote JJ 35772 1339 14 from from IN 35772 1339 15 the the DT 35772 1339 16 world world NN 35772 1339 17 of of IN 35772 1339 18 experience experience NN 35772 1339 19 . . . 35772 1340 1 Hence hence RB 35772 1340 2 the the DT 35772 1340 3 question question NN 35772 1340 4 arose arise VBD 35772 1340 5 whether whether IN 35772 1340 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1340 7 might may MD 35772 1340 8 not not RB 35772 1340 9 be be VB 35772 1340 10 possible possible JJ 35772 1340 11 to to TO 35772 1340 12 interpret interpret VB 35772 1340 13 nature nature NN 35772 1340 14 in in IN 35772 1340 15 terms term NNS 35772 1340 16 of of IN 35772 1340 17 mind mind NN 35772 1340 18 without without IN 35772 1340 19 being be VBG 35772 1340 20 compelled compel VBN 35772 1340 21 to to TO 35772 1340 22 take take VB 35772 1340 23 refuge refuge NN 35772 1340 24 in in IN 35772 1340 25 the the DT 35772 1340 26 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1340 27 of of IN 35772 1340 28 " " `` 35772 1340 29 absolutism absolutism NN 35772 1340 30 . . . 35772 1340 31 " " '' 35772 1341 1 And and CC 35772 1341 2 pluralism pluralism NN 35772 1341 3 is be VBZ 35772 1341 4 an an DT 35772 1341 5 attempt attempt NN 35772 1341 6 to to TO 35772 1341 7 solve solve VB 35772 1341 8 the the DT 35772 1341 9 problem problem NN 35772 1341 10 . . . 35772 1342 1 LEIBNIZ LEIBNIZ NNP 35772 1342 2 REVIVED.--Leibniz REVIVED.--Leibniz NNP 35772 1342 3 ' ' POS 35772 1342 4 system system NN 35772 1342 5 of of IN 35772 1342 6 " " `` 35772 1342 7 monads monad NNS 35772 1342 8 , , , 35772 1342 9 " " '' 35772 1342 10 the the DT 35772 1342 11 nature nature NN 35772 1342 12 of of IN 35772 1342 13 which which WDT 35772 1342 14 will will MD 35772 1342 15 hardly hardly RB 35772 1342 16 have have VB 35772 1342 17 been be VBN 35772 1342 18 forgotten forget VBN 35772 1342 19 , , , 35772 1342 20 has have VBZ 35772 1342 21 been be VBN 35772 1342 22 the the DT 35772 1342 23 model model NN 35772 1342 24 to to IN 35772 1342 25 which which WDT 35772 1342 26 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1342 27 have have VBP 35772 1342 28 looked look VBN 35772 1342 29 in in IN 35772 1342 30 constructing construct VBG 35772 1342 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1342 32 new new JJ 35772 1342 33 system system NN 35772 1342 34 . . . 35772 1343 1 And and CC 35772 1343 2 the the DT 35772 1343 3 " " `` 35772 1343 4 Monadology Monadology NNP 35772 1343 5 " " '' 35772 1343 6 may may MD 35772 1343 7 be be VB 35772 1343 8 taken take VBN 35772 1343 9 as as IN 35772 1343 10 the the DT 35772 1343 11 type type NN 35772 1343 12 to to TO 35772 1343 13 which which WDT 35772 1343 14 all all DT 35772 1343 15 modern modern JJ 35772 1343 16 attempts attempt NNS 35772 1343 17 to to TO 35772 1343 18 construct construct VB 35772 1343 19 a a DT 35772 1343 20 " " `` 35772 1343 21 pluralistic pluralistic JJ 35772 1343 22 " " '' 35772 1343 23 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1343 24 more more RBR 35772 1343 25 or or CC 35772 1343 26 less less JJR 35772 1343 27 conform conform VB 35772 1343 28 . . . 35772 1344 1 The the DT 35772 1344 2 essence essence NN 35772 1344 3 of of IN 35772 1344 4 " " `` 35772 1344 5 pluralism"--whether pluralism"--whether NNP 35772 1344 6 Leibnizian Leibnizian NNP 35772 1344 7 or or CC 35772 1344 8 other other JJ 35772 1344 9 -- -- : 35772 1344 10 lies lie NNS 35772 1344 11 in in IN 35772 1344 12 the the DT 35772 1344 13 proposition proposition NN 35772 1344 14 that that IN 35772 1344 15 there there EX 35772 1344 16 exists exist VBZ 35772 1344 17 an an DT 35772 1344 18 indefinite indefinite JJ 35772 1344 19 variety variety NN 35772 1344 20 of of IN 35772 1344 21 beings being NNS 35772 1344 22 , , , 35772 1344 23 some some DT 35772 1344 24 higher high JJR 35772 1344 25 , , , 35772 1344 26 some some DT 35772 1344 27 lower low JJR 35772 1344 28 than than IN 35772 1344 29 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1344 30 . . . 35772 1345 1 The the DT 35772 1345 2 pluralist pluralist NN 35772 1345 3 agrees agree VBZ 35772 1345 4 with with IN 35772 1345 5 the the DT 35772 1345 6 idealist idealist NN 35772 1345 7 in in IN 35772 1345 8 declaring declare VBG 35772 1345 9 that that IN 35772 1345 10 the the DT 35772 1345 11 essence essence NN 35772 1345 12 of of IN 35772 1345 13 reality reality NN 35772 1345 14 is be VBZ 35772 1345 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1345 16 spirit spirit NNP 35772 1345 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1345 18 , , , 35772 1345 19 but but CC 35772 1345 20 differs differ VBZ 35772 1345 21 from from IN 35772 1345 22 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1345 23 in in IN 35772 1345 24 declining decline VBG 35772 1345 25 to to TO 35772 1345 26 allow allow VB 35772 1345 27 independent independent JJ 35772 1345 28 spirits spirit NNS 35772 1345 29 to to TO 35772 1345 30 be be VB 35772 1345 31 absorbed absorb VBN 35772 1345 32 by by IN 35772 1345 33 an an DT 35772 1345 34 " " `` 35772 1345 35 all all RB 35772 1345 36 - - HYPH 35772 1345 37 devouring devour VBG 35772 1345 38 Absolute Absolute NNP 35772 1345 39 . . . 35772 1345 40 " " '' 35772 1346 1 PLURALISM PLURALISM NNP 35772 1346 2 AND and CC 35772 1346 3 THEISM.--William THEISM.--William NNP 35772 1346 4 James James NNP 35772 1346 5 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1346 6 , , , 35772 1346 7 in in IN 35772 1346 8 a a DT 35772 1346 9 work work NN 35772 1346 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1346 11 A a DT 35772 1346 12 Pluralistic Pluralistic NNP 35772 1346 13 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1346 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1346 15 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1346 16 1909 1909 CD 35772 1346 17 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1346 18 outlined outline VBD 35772 1346 19 a a DT 35772 1346 20 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1346 21 of of IN 35772 1346 22 spirit spirit NN 35772 1346 23 radically radically RB 35772 1346 24 opposed oppose VBD 35772 1346 25 to to IN 35772 1346 26 " " `` 35772 1346 27 Absolute Absolute NNP 35772 1346 28 Idealism Idealism NNP 35772 1346 29 , , , 35772 1346 30 " " '' 35772 1346 31 which which WDT 35772 1346 32 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1346 33 subjects subject VBZ 35772 1346 34 to to IN 35772 1346 35 a a DT 35772 1346 36 good good JJ 35772 1346 37 deal deal NN 35772 1346 38 of of IN 35772 1346 39 criticism criticism NN 35772 1346 40 . . . 35772 1347 1 Another another DT 35772 1347 2 important important JJ 35772 1347 3 work work NN 35772 1347 4 , , , 35772 1347 5 written write VBN 35772 1347 6 from from IN 35772 1347 7 a a DT 35772 1347 8 similar similar JJ 35772 1347 9 point point NN 35772 1347 10 of of IN 35772 1347 11 view view NN 35772 1347 12 , , , 35772 1347 13 is be VBZ 35772 1347 14 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1347 15 James James NNP 35772 1347 16 Ward Ward NNP 35772 1347 17 's 's POS 35772 1347 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1347 19 Pluralism Pluralism NNP 35772 1347 20 and and CC 35772 1347 21 Theism Theism NNP 35772 1347 22 _ _ NNP 35772 1347 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1347 24 1911 1911 CD 35772 1347 25 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1347 26 . . . 35772 1348 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1348 2 62 62 CD 35772 1348 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1348 4 With with IN 35772 1348 5 regard regard NN 35772 1348 6 to to IN 35772 1348 7 modern modern JJ 35772 1348 8 pluralism pluralism NN 35772 1348 9 , , , 35772 1348 10 the the DT 35772 1348 11 notable notable JJ 35772 1348 12 features feature NNS 35772 1348 13 are be VBP 35772 1348 14 two two CD 35772 1348 15 . . . 35772 1349 1 In in IN 35772 1349 2 the the DT 35772 1349 3 first first JJ 35772 1349 4 place place NN 35772 1349 5 , , , 35772 1349 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1349 7 is be VBZ 35772 1349 8 a a DT 35772 1349 9 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1349 10 of of IN 35772 1349 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1349 12 personality personality NN 35772 1349 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1349 14 , , , 35772 1349 15 which which WDT 35772 1349 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1349 17 regards regard VBZ 35772 1349 18 as as IN 35772 1349 19 the the DT 35772 1349 20 most most RBS 35772 1349 21 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1349 22 form form NN 35772 1349 23 of of IN 35772 1349 24 reality reality NN 35772 1349 25 ; ; , 35772 1349 26 and and CC 35772 1349 27 also also RB 35772 1349 28 , , , 35772 1349 29 that that IN 35772 1349 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1349 31 is be VBZ 35772 1349 32 _ _ NNP 35772 1349 33 theistic theistic NN 35772 1349 34 _ _ NNP 35772 1349 35 in in IN 35772 1349 36 a a DT 35772 1349 37 sense sense NN 35772 1349 38 peculiar peculiar JJ 35772 1349 39 to to IN 35772 1349 40 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1349 41 . . . 35772 1350 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1350 2 believes believe VBZ 35772 1350 3 in in IN 35772 1350 4 a a DT 35772 1350 5 God God NNP 35772 1350 6 who who WP 35772 1350 7 may may MD 35772 1350 8 be be VB 35772 1350 9 termed term VBN 35772 1350 10 the the DT 35772 1350 11 supreme supreme NNP 35772 1350 12 monad monad NNP 35772 1350 13 , , , 35772 1350 14 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1351 1 the the DT 35772 1351 2 head head NN 35772 1351 3 of of IN 35772 1351 4 a a DT 35772 1351 5 system system NN 35772 1351 6 of of IN 35772 1351 7 monads monad NNS 35772 1351 8 ; ; : 35772 1351 9 but but CC 35772 1351 10 whose whose WP$ 35772 1351 11 power power NN 35772 1351 12 may may MD 35772 1351 13 be be VB 35772 1351 14 said say VBN 35772 1351 15 , , , 35772 1351 16 in in IN 35772 1351 17 certain certain JJ 35772 1351 18 respects respect NNS 35772 1351 19 , , , 35772 1351 20 to to TO 35772 1351 21 be be VB 35772 1351 22 limited limit VBN 35772 1351 23 . . . 35772 1352 1 And and CC 35772 1352 2 indeed indeed RB 35772 1352 3 some some DT 35772 1352 4 such such JJ 35772 1352 5 position position NN 35772 1352 6 seems seem VBZ 35772 1352 7 to to TO 35772 1352 8 be be VB 35772 1352 9 the the DT 35772 1352 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1352 11 logical logical JJ 35772 1352 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1352 13 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 1352 14 that that WDT 35772 1352 15 follows follow VBZ 35772 1352 16 from from IN 35772 1352 17 the the DT 35772 1352 18 premises premise NNS 35772 1352 19 with with IN 35772 1352 20 which which WDT 35772 1352 21 pluralists pluralist NNS 35772 1352 22 start start VBP 35772 1352 23 , , , 35772 1352 24 and and CC 35772 1352 25 also also RB 35772 1352 26 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1352 27 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1352 28 may may MD 35772 1352 29 add add VB 35772 1352 30 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1352 31 from from IN 35772 1352 32 the the DT 35772 1352 33 facts fact NNS 35772 1352 34 of of IN 35772 1352 35 experience experience NN 35772 1352 36 . . . 35772 1353 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1353 2 63 63 CD 35772 1353 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1353 4 Pluralists pluralist NNS 35772 1353 5 unite unite VB 35772 1353 6 in in IN 35772 1353 7 affirming affirming NN 35772 1353 8 that that IN 35772 1353 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1353 10 God God NNP 35772 1353 11 is be VBZ 35772 1353 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1353 13 what what WP 35772 1353 14 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1353 15 deny deny VBP 35772 1353 16 the the DT 35772 1353 17 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1353 18 Absolute Absolute NNP 35772 1353 19 to to TO 35772 1353 20 be be VB 35772 1353 21 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1353 22 the the DT 35772 1353 23 God God NNP 35772 1353 24 of of IN 35772 1353 25 the the DT 35772 1353 26 religious religious JJ 35772 1353 27 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1353 28 . . . 35772 1354 1 James James NNP 35772 1354 2 elaborates elaborate VBZ 35772 1354 3 this this DT 35772 1354 4 thesis thesis NN 35772 1354 5 with with IN 35772 1354 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1354 7 usual usual JJ 35772 1354 8 resourcefulness resourcefulness NN 35772 1354 9 and and CC 35772 1354 10 skill skill NN 35772 1354 11 . . . 35772 1355 1 The the DT 35772 1355 2 controversy controversy NN 35772 1355 3 , , , 35772 1355 4 however however RB 35772 1355 5 , , , 35772 1355 6 is be VBZ 35772 1355 7 one one CD 35772 1355 8 into into IN 35772 1355 9 which which WDT 35772 1355 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1355 11 does do VBZ 35772 1355 12 not not RB 35772 1355 13 seem seem VB 35772 1355 14 necessary necessary JJ 35772 1355 15 for for IN 35772 1355 16 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1355 17 to to TO 35772 1355 18 enter enter VB 35772 1355 19 . . . 35772 1356 1 Pluralism pluralism NN 35772 1356 2 and and CC 35772 1356 3 idealism idealism NN 35772 1356 4 are be VBP 35772 1356 5 or or CC 35772 1356 6 may may MD 35772 1356 7 be be VB 35772 1356 8 both both DT 35772 1356 9 definitely definitely RB 35772 1356 10 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1356 11 philosophies philosophy NNS 35772 1356 12 , , , 35772 1356 13 and and CC 35772 1356 14 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1356 15 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1356 16 appeal appeal VBP 35772 1356 17 to to IN 35772 1356 18 different different JJ 35772 1356 19 types type NNS 35772 1356 20 of of IN 35772 1356 21 mind mind NN 35772 1356 22 . . . 35772 1357 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1357 2 , , , 35772 1357 3 at at IN 35772 1357 4 any any DT 35772 1357 5 rate rate NN 35772 1357 6 , , , 35772 1357 7 shall shall MD 35772 1357 8 not not RB 35772 1357 9 undertake undertake VB 35772 1357 10 to to TO 35772 1357 11 judge judge VB 35772 1357 12 between between IN 35772 1357 13 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1357 14 . . . 35772 1358 1 Both both DT 35772 1358 2 alike alike RB 35772 1358 3 are be VBP 35772 1358 4 preferable preferable JJ 35772 1358 5 to to IN 35772 1358 6 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1358 7 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1358 8 . . . 35772 1359 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 1359 2 XII XII NNP 35772 1359 3 SOME some VBP 35772 1359 4 RECENT recent JJ 35772 1359 5 TENDENCIES tendency NNS 35772 1359 6 IN in IN 35772 1359 7 SCIENCE science NN 35772 1359 8 SCIENTIFIC scientific VBP 35772 1359 9 METHOD.--In METHOD.--In VBZ 35772 1359 10 the the DT 35772 1359 11 last last JJ 35772 1359 12 chapter chapter NN 35772 1359 13 , , , 35772 1359 14 attention attention NN 35772 1359 15 was be VBD 35772 1359 16 drawn draw VBN 35772 1359 17 to to IN 35772 1359 18 some some DT 35772 1359 19 important important JJ 35772 1359 20 attempts attempt NNS 35772 1359 21 to to TO 35772 1359 22 supply supply VB 35772 1359 23 science science NN 35772 1359 24 with with IN 35772 1359 25 a a DT 35772 1359 26 sound sound JJ 35772 1359 27 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1359 28 of of IN 35772 1359 29 method method NN 35772 1359 30 , , , 35772 1359 31 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1360 1 to to TO 35772 1360 2 give give VB 35772 1360 3 a a DT 35772 1360 4 critical critical JJ 35772 1360 5 account account NN 35772 1360 6 of of IN 35772 1360 7 those those DT 35772 1360 8 processes process NNS 35772 1360 9 , , , 35772 1360 10 logical logical JJ 35772 1360 11 and and CC 35772 1360 12 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 1360 13 , , , 35772 1360 14 which which WDT 35772 1360 15 issue issue VBP 35772 1360 16 in in IN 35772 1360 17 what what WP 35772 1360 18 is be VBZ 35772 1360 19 called call VBN 35772 1360 20 " " `` 35772 1360 21 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1360 22 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1360 23 . . . 35772 1360 24 " " '' 35772 1361 1 The the DT 35772 1361 2 general general JJ 35772 1361 3 results result NNS 35772 1361 4 of of IN 35772 1361 5 these these DT 35772 1361 6 attempts attempt NNS 35772 1361 7 was be VBD 35772 1361 8 to to TO 35772 1361 9 re re VB 35772 1361 10 - - VB 35772 1361 11 enforce enforce VB 35772 1361 12 the the DT 35772 1361 13 validity validity NN 35772 1361 14 of of IN 35772 1361 15 sound sound JJ 35772 1361 16 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1361 17 method method NN 35772 1361 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1361 19 within within IN 35772 1361 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1361 21 own own JJ 35772 1361 22 sphere sphere NN 35772 1361 23 _ _ NNP 35772 1361 24 . . . 35772 1362 1 But but CC 35772 1362 2 , , , 35772 1362 3 at at IN 35772 1362 4 the the DT 35772 1362 5 same same JJ 35772 1362 6 time time NN 35772 1362 7 , , , 35772 1362 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1362 9 was be VBD 35772 1362 10 felt feel VBN 35772 1362 11 likely likely JJ 35772 1362 12 to to TO 35772 1362 13 prove prove VB 35772 1362 14 an an DT 35772 1362 15 unreliable unreliable JJ 35772 1362 16 guide guide NN 35772 1362 17 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1362 18 . . . 35772 1363 1 THE the DT 35772 1363 2 NEW new JJ 35772 1363 3 PHYSICS.--Meanwhile physics.--meanwhile NN 35772 1363 4 , , , 35772 1363 5 while while IN 35772 1363 6 the the DT 35772 1363 7 logic logic NN 35772 1363 8 of of IN 35772 1363 9 science science NN 35772 1363 10 was be VBD 35772 1363 11 being be VBG 35772 1363 12 scrutinised scrutinise VBN 35772 1363 13 by by IN 35772 1363 14 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1363 15 , , , 35772 1363 16 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1363 17 research research NN 35772 1363 18 was be VBD 35772 1363 19 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1363 20 going go VBG 35772 1363 21 steadily steadily RB 35772 1363 22 forward forward RB 35772 1363 23 , , , 35772 1363 24 and and CC 35772 1363 25 fresh fresh JJ 35772 1363 26 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 1363 27 of of IN 35772 1363 28 a a DT 35772 1363 29 highly highly RB 35772 1363 30 important important JJ 35772 1363 31 nature nature NN 35772 1363 32 were be VBD 35772 1363 33 coming come VBG 35772 1363 34 to to IN 35772 1363 35 light light NN 35772 1363 36 . . . 35772 1364 1 In in IN 35772 1364 2 the the DT 35772 1364 3 sphere sphere NN 35772 1364 4 of of IN 35772 1364 5 physical physical JJ 35772 1364 6 science science NN 35772 1364 7 , , , 35772 1364 8 more more RBR 35772 1364 9 especially especially RB 35772 1364 10 , , , 35772 1364 11 revolutions revolution NNS 35772 1364 12 of of IN 35772 1364 13 Copernican copernican JJ 35772 1364 14 proportions proportion NNS 35772 1364 15 quietly quietly RB 35772 1364 16 took take VBD 35772 1364 17 place place NN 35772 1364 18 . . . 35772 1365 1 The the DT 35772 1365 2 whole whole JJ 35772 1365 3 subject subject NN 35772 1365 4 of of IN 35772 1365 5 physics physics NN 35772 1365 6 is be VBZ 35772 1365 7 of of IN 35772 1365 8 a a DT 35772 1365 9 highly highly RB 35772 1365 10 technical technical JJ 35772 1365 11 nature nature NN 35772 1365 12 , , , 35772 1365 13 quite quite RB 35772 1365 14 unsuitable unsuitable JJ 35772 1365 15 for for IN 35772 1365 16 discussion discussion NN 35772 1365 17 here here RB 35772 1365 18 , , , 35772 1365 19 and and CC 35772 1365 20 , , , 35772 1365 21 indeed indeed RB 35772 1365 22 , , , 35772 1365 23 entirely entirely RB 35772 1365 24 beyond beyond IN 35772 1365 25 the the DT 35772 1365 26 range range NN 35772 1365 27 of of IN 35772 1365 28 the the DT 35772 1365 29 present present JJ 35772 1365 30 writer writer NN 35772 1365 31 . . . 35772 1366 1 To to TO 35772 1366 2 indicate indicate VB 35772 1366 3 the the DT 35772 1366 4 nature nature NN 35772 1366 5 of of IN 35772 1366 6 the the DT 35772 1366 7 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 1366 8 which which WDT 35772 1366 9 were be VBD 35772 1366 10 made make VBN 35772 1366 11 , , , 35772 1366 12 however however RB 35772 1366 13 , , , 35772 1366 14 involves involve VBZ 35772 1366 15 few few JJ 35772 1366 16 technicalities technicality NNS 35772 1366 17 : : : 35772 1366 18 though though IN 35772 1366 19 the the DT 35772 1366 20 method method NN 35772 1366 21 by by IN 35772 1366 22 which which WDT 35772 1366 23 these these DT 35772 1366 24 were be VBD 35772 1366 25 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 35772 1366 26 and and CC 35772 1366 27 established establish VBN 35772 1366 28 must must MD 35772 1366 29 remain remain VB 35772 1366 30 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1366 31 to to IN 35772 1366 32 all all DT 35772 1366 33 but but CC 35772 1366 34 mathematical mathematical JJ 35772 1366 35 specialists specialist NNS 35772 1366 36 . . . 35772 1367 1 COLLAPSE COLLAPSE NNS 35772 1367 2 OF of IN 35772 1367 3 THE the DT 35772 1367 4 ATOMIC ATOMIC NNP 35772 1367 5 THEORY.--Dalton THEORY.--Dalton NNP 35772 1367 6 's 's POS 35772 1367 7 theory theory NN 35772 1367 8 of of IN 35772 1367 9 atoms atom NNS 35772 1367 10 was be VBD 35772 1367 11 described describe VBN 35772 1367 12 in in IN 35772 1367 13 a a DT 35772 1367 14 previous previous JJ 35772 1367 15 chapter chapter NN 35772 1367 16 . . . 35772 1368 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1368 2 is be VBZ 35772 1368 3 hardly hardly RB 35772 1368 4 possible possible JJ 35772 1368 5 to to TO 35772 1368 6 exaggerate exaggerate VB 35772 1368 7 the the DT 35772 1368 8 importance importance NN 35772 1368 9 attached attach VBN 35772 1368 10 by by IN 35772 1368 11 materialists materialist NNS 35772 1368 12 , , , 35772 1368 13 ever ever RB 35772 1368 14 since since IN 35772 1368 15 Lucretius Lucretius NNP 35772 1368 16 , , , 35772 1368 17 to to IN 35772 1368 18 the the DT 35772 1368 19 conception conception NN 35772 1368 20 of of IN 35772 1368 21 indivisible indivisible JJ 35772 1368 22 and and CC 35772 1368 23 indestructible indestructible JJ 35772 1368 24 atoms atom NNS 35772 1368 25 . . . 35772 1369 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1369 2 was be VBD 35772 1369 3 regarded regard VBN 35772 1369 4 as as IN 35772 1369 5 integral integral JJ 35772 1369 6 to to IN 35772 1369 7 materialism materialism NN 35772 1369 8 , , , 35772 1369 9 and and CC 35772 1369 10 never never RB 35772 1369 11 was be VBD 35772 1369 12 the the DT 35772 1369 13 prestige prestige NN 35772 1369 14 of of IN 35772 1369 15 this this DT 35772 1369 16 theory theory NN 35772 1369 17 higher high JJR 35772 1369 18 than than IN 35772 1369 19 during during IN 35772 1369 20 the the DT 35772 1369 21 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1369 22 century century NN 35772 1369 23 , , , 35772 1369 24 which which WDT 35772 1369 25 " " `` 35772 1369 26 will will MD 35772 1369 27 go go VB 35772 1369 28 down down RB 35772 1369 29 in in IN 35772 1369 30 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1369 31 history history NN 35772 1369 32 as as IN 35772 1369 33 the the DT 35772 1369 34 era era NN 35772 1369 35 of of IN 35772 1369 36 the the DT 35772 1369 37 atomic atomic JJ 35772 1369 38 theory theory NN 35772 1369 39 of of IN 35772 1369 40 matter matter NN 35772 1369 41 . . . 35772 1369 42 " " '' 35772 1370 1 Towards towards IN 35772 1370 2 the the DT 35772 1370 3 close close NN 35772 1370 4 of of IN 35772 1370 5 the the DT 35772 1370 6 century century NN 35772 1370 7 , , , 35772 1370 8 the the DT 35772 1370 9 theory theory NN 35772 1370 10 collapsed collapse VBD 35772 1370 11 . . . 35772 1371 1 Atoms atom NNS 35772 1371 2 were be VBD 35772 1371 3 found find VBN 35772 1371 4 to to TO 35772 1371 5 be be VB 35772 1371 6 neither neither CC 35772 1371 7 indivisible indivisible JJ 35772 1371 8 nor nor CC 35772 1371 9 indestructible indestructible JJ 35772 1371 10 ; ; : 35772 1371 11 and and CC 35772 1371 12 the the DT 35772 1371 13 process process NN 35772 1371 14 of of IN 35772 1371 15 the the DT 35772 1371 16 breaking breaking NN 35772 1371 17 up up RP 35772 1371 18 of of IN 35772 1371 19 the the DT 35772 1371 20 atom atom NN 35772 1371 21 has have VBZ 35772 1371 22 actually actually RB 35772 1371 23 been be VBN 35772 1371 24 observed observe VBN 35772 1371 25 . . . 35772 1372 1 As as IN 35772 1372 2 is be VBZ 35772 1372 3 very very RB 35772 1372 4 generally generally RB 35772 1372 5 known know VBN 35772 1372 6 , , , 35772 1372 7 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1372 8 is be VBZ 35772 1372 9 in in IN 35772 1372 10 the the DT 35772 1372 11 case case NN 35772 1372 12 of of IN 35772 1372 13 a a DT 35772 1372 14 particular particular JJ 35772 1372 15 element element NN 35772 1372 16 , , , 35772 1372 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1372 18 radium radium NN 35772 1372 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1372 20 , , , 35772 1372 21 that that IN 35772 1372 22 this this DT 35772 1372 23 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 1372 24 occurs occur VBZ 35772 1372 25 . . . 35772 1373 1 That that DT 35772 1373 2 substance substance NN 35772 1373 3 , , , 35772 1373 4 wherever wherever WRB 35772 1373 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1373 6 occurs occur VBZ 35772 1373 7 , , , 35772 1373 8 is be VBZ 35772 1373 9 undergoing undergo VBG 35772 1373 10 a a DT 35772 1373 11 continual continual JJ 35772 1373 12 process process NN 35772 1373 13 of of IN 35772 1373 14 disintegration disintegration NN 35772 1373 15 ; ; : 35772 1373 16 radium radium NN 35772 1373 17 atoms atom NNS 35772 1373 18 are be VBP 35772 1373 19 continually continually RB 35772 1373 20 breaking break VBG 35772 1373 21 up up RP 35772 1373 22 into into IN 35772 1373 23 more more JJR 35772 1373 24 elementary elementary JJ 35772 1373 25 bodies body NNS 35772 1373 26 . . . 35772 1374 1 Were be VBD 35772 1374 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1374 3 not not RB 35772 1374 4 for for IN 35772 1374 5 the the DT 35772 1374 6 fact fact NN 35772 1374 7 that that IN 35772 1374 8 radium radium NN 35772 1374 9 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1374 10 is be VBZ 35772 1374 11 the the DT 35772 1374 12 product product NN 35772 1374 13 of of IN 35772 1374 14 the the DT 35772 1374 15 disintegration disintegration NN 35772 1374 16 of of IN 35772 1374 17 another another DT 35772 1374 18 element element NN 35772 1374 19 , , , 35772 1374 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1374 21 would would MD 35772 1374 22 be be VB 35772 1374 23 impossible impossible JJ 35772 1374 24 to to TO 35772 1374 25 account account VB 35772 1374 26 for for IN 35772 1374 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1374 28 survival survival NN 35772 1374 29 . . . 35772 1375 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1375 2 continually continually RB 35772 1375 3 evaporates evaporate VBZ 35772 1375 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1375 5 the the DT 35772 1375 6 life life NN 35772 1375 7 of of IN 35772 1375 8 radium radium NN 35772 1375 9 is be VBZ 35772 1375 10 only only RB 35772 1375 11 2500 2500 CD 35772 1375 12 years year NNS 35772 1375 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1375 14 but but CC 35772 1375 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1375 16 is be VBZ 35772 1375 17 as as RB 35772 1375 18 continually continually RB 35772 1375 19 renewed renew VBN 35772 1375 20 by by IN 35772 1375 21 the the DT 35772 1375 22 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 1375 23 slower slow JJR 35772 1375 24 disintegration disintegration NN 35772 1375 25 of of IN 35772 1375 26 uranium uranium NN 35772 1375 27 . . . 35772 1376 1 ELECTRONS.--The electrons.--the JJ 35772 1376 2 particles particle NNS 35772 1376 3 into into IN 35772 1376 4 which which WDT 35772 1376 5 the the DT 35772 1376 6 radium radium NN 35772 1376 7 atom atom NN 35772 1376 8 disintegrates disintegrate NNS 35772 1376 9 are be VBP 35772 1376 10 known know VBN 35772 1376 11 as as IN 35772 1376 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1376 13 electrons electron NNS 35772 1376 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1376 15 . . . 35772 1377 1 And and CC 35772 1377 2 according accord VBG 35772 1377 3 to to IN 35772 1377 4 the the DT 35772 1377 5 new new JJ 35772 1377 6 theory theory NN 35772 1377 7 of of IN 35772 1377 8 matter matter NN 35772 1377 9 , , , 35772 1377 10 not not RB 35772 1377 11 only only RB 35772 1377 12 radium radium NN 35772 1377 13 atoms atom NNS 35772 1377 14 , , , 35772 1377 15 but but CC 35772 1377 16 the the DT 35772 1377 17 atoms atom NNS 35772 1377 18 of of IN 35772 1377 19 all all PDT 35772 1377 20 the the DT 35772 1377 21 other other JJ 35772 1377 22 elements element NNS 35772 1377 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1377 24 hitherto hitherto NNP 35772 1377 25 regarded regard VBN 35772 1377 26 as as IN 35772 1377 27 irreducible irreducible JJ 35772 1377 28 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1377 29 are be VBP 35772 1377 30 composed compose VBN 35772 1377 31 of of IN 35772 1377 32 electrons electron NNS 35772 1377 33 , , , 35772 1377 34 differently differently RB 35772 1377 35 grouped group VBN 35772 1377 36 . . . 35772 1378 1 The the DT 35772 1378 2 radium radium NN 35772 1378 3 atom atom NN 35772 1378 4 is be VBZ 35772 1378 5 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 1378 6 more more RBR 35772 1378 7 unstable unstable JJ 35772 1378 8 than than IN 35772 1378 9 the the DT 35772 1378 10 atoms atom NNS 35772 1378 11 of of IN 35772 1378 12 the the DT 35772 1378 13 other other JJ 35772 1378 14 elements element NNS 35772 1378 15 ; ; : 35772 1378 16 but but CC 35772 1378 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1378 18 is be VBZ 35772 1378 19 possible possible JJ 35772 1378 20 to to TO 35772 1378 21 conceive conceive VB 35772 1378 22 of of IN 35772 1378 23 the the DT 35772 1378 24 disintegration disintegration NN 35772 1378 25 of of IN 35772 1378 26 these these DT 35772 1378 27 also also RB 35772 1378 28 . . . 35772 1379 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1379 2 are be VBP 35772 1379 3 all all RB 35772 1379 4 alike alike RB 35772 1379 5 composed compose VBN 35772 1379 6 of of IN 35772 1379 7 the the DT 35772 1379 8 same same JJ 35772 1379 9 elementary elementary JJ 35772 1379 10 particles particle NNS 35772 1379 11 -- -- : 35772 1379 12 different different JJ 35772 1379 13 compounds compound NNS 35772 1379 14 of of IN 35772 1379 15 the the DT 35772 1379 16 same same JJ 35772 1379 17 primitive primitive JJ 35772 1379 18 substance substance NN 35772 1379 19 . . . 35772 1380 1 MATTER MATTER NNP 35772 1380 2 A a DT 35772 1380 3 FORM form NN 35772 1380 4 OF of IN 35772 1380 5 ELECTRICITY.--And electricity.--and NN 35772 1380 6 the the DT 35772 1380 7 most most RBS 35772 1380 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 35772 1380 9 part part NN 35772 1380 10 of of IN 35772 1380 11 the the DT 35772 1380 12 new new JJ 35772 1380 13 theory theory NN 35772 1380 14 is be VBZ 35772 1380 15 that that IN 35772 1380 16 these these DT 35772 1380 17 primitive primitive JJ 35772 1380 18 particles particle NNS 35772 1380 19 of of IN 35772 1380 20 which which WDT 35772 1380 21 material material NN 35772 1380 22 atoms atom NNS 35772 1380 23 are be VBP 35772 1380 24 composed compose VBN 35772 1380 25 , , , 35772 1380 26 are be VBP 35772 1380 27 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1380 28 the the DT 35772 1380 29 units unit NNS 35772 1380 30 which which WDT 35772 1380 31 constitute constitute VBP 35772 1380 32 what what WP 35772 1380 33 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1380 34 call call VBP 35772 1380 35 " " `` 35772 1380 36 electricity electricity NN 35772 1380 37 . . . 35772 1380 38 " " '' 35772 1381 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1381 2 matter matter NN 35772 1381 3 and and CC 35772 1381 4 electricity electricity NN 35772 1381 5 are be VBP 35772 1381 6 now now RB 35772 1381 7 expressed express VBN 35772 1381 8 in in IN 35772 1381 9 common common JJ 35772 1381 10 terms term NNS 35772 1381 11 -- -- : 35772 1381 12 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1381 13 are be VBP 35772 1381 14 regarded regard VBN 35772 1381 15 as as IN 35772 1381 16 different different JJ 35772 1381 17 manifestations manifestation NNS 35772 1381 18 of of IN 35772 1381 19 the the DT 35772 1381 20 same same JJ 35772 1381 21 substance substance NN 35772 1381 22 . . . 35772 1382 1 And and CC 35772 1382 2 of of IN 35772 1382 3 the the DT 35772 1382 4 two two CD 35772 1382 5 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1382 6 -- -- : 35772 1382 7 matter matter NN 35772 1382 8 and and CC 35772 1382 9 electricity electricity NN 35772 1382 10 -- -- : 35772 1382 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1382 12 is be VBZ 35772 1382 13 the the DT 35772 1382 14 latter latter JJ 35772 1382 15 that that WDT 35772 1382 16 is be VBZ 35772 1382 17 the the DT 35772 1382 18 more more RBR 35772 1382 19 simple simple JJ 35772 1382 20 and and CC 35772 1382 21 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1382 22 . . . 35772 1383 1 As as IN 35772 1383 2 a a DT 35772 1383 3 high high JJ 35772 1383 4 authority authority NN 35772 1383 5 puts put VBZ 35772 1383 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1383 7 : : : 35772 1383 8 " " `` 35772 1383 9 Whereas whereas IN 35772 1383 10 through through IN 35772 1383 11 the the DT 35772 1383 12 greater great JJR 35772 1383 13 part part NN 35772 1383 14 of of IN 35772 1383 15 the the DT 35772 1383 16 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1383 17 century century NN 35772 1383 18 , , , 35772 1383 19 ' ' `` 35772 1383 20 matter matter NN 35772 1383 21 ' ' '' 35772 1383 22 was be VBD 35772 1383 23 the the DT 35772 1383 24 concept concept NN 35772 1383 25 which which WDT 35772 1383 26 was be VBD 35772 1383 27 looked look VBN 35772 1383 28 upon upon IN 35772 1383 29 as as RB 35772 1383 30 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1383 31 in in IN 35772 1383 32 physical physical JJ 35772 1383 33 science science NN 35772 1383 34 , , , 35772 1383 35 and and CC 35772 1383 36 of of IN 35772 1383 37 which which WDT 35772 1383 38 there there EX 35772 1383 39 was be VBD 35772 1383 40 a a DT 35772 1383 41 curious curious JJ 35772 1383 42 accidental accidental JJ 35772 1383 43 property property NN 35772 1383 44 called call VBN 35772 1383 45 electricity electricity NN 35772 1383 46 , , , 35772 1383 47 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1383 48 now now RB 35772 1383 49 appears appear VBZ 35772 1383 50 that that IN 35772 1383 51 electricity electricity NN 35772 1383 52 must must MD 35772 1383 53 be be VB 35772 1383 54 more more RBR 35772 1383 55 fundamental fundamental JJ 35772 1383 56 than than IN 35772 1383 57 matter matter NN 35772 1383 58 , , , 35772 1383 59 in in IN 35772 1383 60 the the DT 35772 1383 61 sense sense NN 35772 1383 62 that that IN 35772 1383 63 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1383 64 more more JJR 35772 1383 65 elementary elementary JJ 35772 1383 66 matter matter NN 35772 1383 67 must must MD 35772 1383 68 now now RB 35772 1383 69 be be VB 35772 1383 70 conceived conceive VBN 35772 1383 71 as as IN 35772 1383 72 a a DT 35772 1383 73 manifestation manifestation NN 35772 1383 74 of of IN 35772 1383 75 extremely extremely RB 35772 1383 76 complex complex JJ 35772 1383 77 electrical electrical JJ 35772 1383 78 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1383 79 . . . 35772 1384 1 " " `` 35772 1384 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1384 3 64 64 CD 35772 1384 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1384 5 As as IN 35772 1384 6 to to IN 35772 1384 7 whether whether IN 35772 1384 8 the the DT 35772 1384 9 electrons electron NNS 35772 1384 10 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1384 11 , , , 35772 1384 12 in in IN 35772 1384 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1384 14 turn turn NN 35772 1384 15 , , , 35772 1384 16 are be VBP 35772 1384 17 irreducible irreducible JJ 35772 1384 18 units unit NNS 35772 1384 19 , , , 35772 1384 20 there there EX 35772 1384 21 may may MD 35772 1384 22 be be VB 35772 1384 23 room room NN 35772 1384 24 for for IN 35772 1384 25 doubt doubt NN 35772 1384 26 . . . 35772 1385 1 According accord VBG 35772 1385 2 to to IN 35772 1385 3 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1385 4 J. J. NNP 35772 1385 5 Larmor Larmor NNP 35772 1385 6 the the DT 35772 1385 7 electron electron NN 35772 1385 8 is be VBZ 35772 1385 9 " " `` 35772 1385 10 a a DT 35772 1385 11 nucleus nucleus NN 35772 1385 12 of of IN 35772 1385 13 intrinsic intrinsic JJ 35772 1385 14 strain strain NN 35772 1385 15 in in IN 35772 1385 16 the the DT 35772 1385 17 ether ether NN 35772 1385 18 . . . 35772 1386 1 " " `` 35772 1386 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1386 3 65 65 CD 35772 1386 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1386 5 If if IN 35772 1386 6 this this DT 35772 1386 7 view view NN 35772 1386 8 be be VB 35772 1386 9 sound sound JJ 35772 1386 10 , , , 35772 1386 11 matter matter NN 35772 1386 12 may may MD 35772 1386 13 be be VB 35772 1386 14 regarded regard VBN 35772 1386 15 as as IN 35772 1386 16 a a DT 35772 1386 17 manifestation manifestation NN 35772 1386 18 of of IN 35772 1386 19 the the DT 35772 1386 20 ether ether NN 35772 1386 21 ; ; : 35772 1386 22 " " `` 35772 1386 23 a a DT 35772 1386 24 persistent persistent JJ 35772 1386 25 strain strain NN 35772 1386 26 - - HYPH 35772 1386 27 form form NN 35772 1386 28 flitting flitting NN 35772 1386 29 through through IN 35772 1386 30 an an DT 35772 1386 31 universal universal JJ 35772 1386 32 sea sea NN 35772 1386 33 of of IN 35772 1386 34 ether ether NN 35772 1386 35 . . . 35772 1386 36 " " '' 35772 1387 1 As as IN 35772 1387 2 to to IN 35772 1387 3 the the DT 35772 1387 4 nature nature NN 35772 1387 5 of of IN 35772 1387 6 the the DT 35772 1387 7 ether ether NN 35772 1387 8 , , , 35772 1387 9 that that DT 35772 1387 10 is be VBZ 35772 1387 11 a a DT 35772 1387 12 subject subject NN 35772 1387 13 of of IN 35772 1387 14 speculation speculation NN 35772 1387 15 among among IN 35772 1387 16 physicists physicist NNS 35772 1387 17 . . . 35772 1388 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1388 2 is be VBZ 35772 1388 3 variously variously RB 35772 1388 4 described describe VBN 35772 1388 5 as as IN 35772 1388 6 an an DT 35772 1388 7 " " `` 35772 1388 8 elastic elastic JJ 35772 1388 9 fluid fluid NN 35772 1388 10 , , , 35772 1388 11 " " '' 35772 1388 12 and and CC 35772 1388 13 as as IN 35772 1388 14 " " `` 35772 1388 15 a a DT 35772 1388 16 fairly fairly RB 35772 1388 17 close close JJ 35772 1388 18 packed pack VBN 35772 1388 19 conglomerate conglomerate NN 35772 1388 20 of of IN 35772 1388 21 minute minute NN 35772 1388 22 grains grain NNS 35772 1388 23 in in IN 35772 1388 24 continual continual JJ 35772 1388 25 oscillation oscillation NN 35772 1388 26 . . . 35772 1389 1 " " `` 35772 1389 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1389 3 66 66 CD 35772 1389 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1389 5 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1389 6 may may MD 35772 1389 7 indeed indeed RB 35772 1389 8 be be VB 35772 1389 9 said say VBN 35772 1389 10 that that IN 35772 1389 11 modern modern JJ 35772 1389 12 physical physical JJ 35772 1389 13 theories theory NNS 35772 1389 14 have have VBP 35772 1389 15 succeeded succeed VBN 35772 1389 16 in in IN 35772 1389 17 reducing reduce VBG 35772 1389 18 matter matter NN 35772 1389 19 , , , 35772 1389 20 which which WDT 35772 1389 21 seems seem VBZ 35772 1389 22 comparatively comparatively RB 35772 1389 23 knowable knowable JJ 35772 1389 24 , , , 35772 1389 25 to to IN 35772 1389 26 a a DT 35772 1389 27 substance substance NN 35772 1389 28 of of IN 35772 1389 29 which which WDT 35772 1389 30 little little JJ 35772 1389 31 is be VBZ 35772 1389 32 known know VBN 35772 1389 33 and and CC 35772 1389 34 , , , 35772 1389 35 therefore therefore RB 35772 1389 36 , , , 35772 1389 37 of of IN 35772 1389 38 which which WDT 35772 1389 39 much much JJ 35772 1389 40 can can MD 35772 1389 41 be be VB 35772 1389 42 postulated postulate VBN 35772 1389 43 ; ; : 35772 1389 44 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1389 45 can can MD 35772 1389 46 be be VB 35772 1389 47 called call VBN 35772 1389 48 sub sub JJ 35772 1389 49 - - JJ 35772 1389 50 natural natural JJ 35772 1389 51 , , , 35772 1389 52 or or CC 35772 1389 53 super super JJ 35772 1389 54 - - JJ 35772 1389 55 natural natural JJ 35772 1389 56 , , , 35772 1389 57 according accord VBG 35772 1389 58 to to IN 35772 1389 59 taste taste NN 35772 1389 60 . . . 35772 1390 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1390 2 may may MD 35772 1390 3 , , , 35772 1390 4 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1390 5 , , , 35772 1390 6 satisfy satisfy VB 35772 1390 7 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1390 8 with with IN 35772 1390 9 the the DT 35772 1390 10 words word NNS 35772 1390 11 of of IN 35772 1390 12 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1390 13 Tait Tait NNP 35772 1390 14 : : : 35772 1390 15 " " `` 35772 1390 16 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1390 17 do do VBP 35772 1390 18 not not RB 35772 1390 19 know know VB 35772 1390 20 , , , 35772 1390 21 and and CC 35772 1390 22 are be VBP 35772 1390 23 probably probably RB 35772 1390 24 incapable incapable JJ 35772 1390 25 of of IN 35772 1390 26 discovering discover VBG 35772 1390 27 , , , 35772 1390 28 _ _ NNP 35772 1390 29 what what WP 35772 1390 30 _ _ NNP 35772 1390 31 matter matter NN 35772 1390 32 is be VBZ 35772 1390 33 " " `` 35772 1390 34 ; ; : 35772 1390 35 and and CC 35772 1390 36 " " `` 35772 1390 37 The the DT 35772 1390 38 discovery discovery NN 35772 1390 39 of of IN 35772 1390 40 the the DT 35772 1390 41 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 1390 42 nature nature NN 35772 1390 43 of of IN 35772 1390 44 matter matter NN 35772 1390 45 is be VBZ 35772 1390 46 probably probably RB 35772 1390 47 beyond beyond IN 35772 1390 48 the the DT 35772 1390 49 range range NN 35772 1390 50 of of IN 35772 1390 51 human human JJ 35772 1390 52 intelligence intelligence NN 35772 1390 53 . . . 35772 1391 1 " " `` 35772 1391 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1391 3 67 67 CD 35772 1391 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1391 5 And and CC 35772 1391 6 yet yet RB 35772 1391 7 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1391 8 can can MD 35772 1391 9 agree agree VB 35772 1391 10 with with IN 35772 1391 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 35772 1391 12 Arthur Arthur NNP 35772 1391 13 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1391 14 when when WRB 35772 1391 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1391 16 says[68 says[68 VBD 35772 1391 17 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1391 18 " " `` 35772 1391 19 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1391 20 know know VBP 35772 1391 21 too too RB 35772 1391 22 much much JJ 35772 1391 23 about about IN 35772 1391 24 matter matter NN 35772 1391 25 to to TO 35772 1391 26 be be VB 35772 1391 27 materialists materialist NNS 35772 1391 28 . . . 35772 1391 29 " " '' 35772 1392 1 That that IN 35772 1392 2 , , , 35772 1392 3 in in IN 35772 1392 4 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1392 5 , , , 35772 1392 6 a a DT 35772 1392 7 generation generation NN 35772 1392 8 ago ago RB 35772 1392 9 would would MD 35772 1392 10 have have VB 35772 1392 11 been be VBN 35772 1392 12 regarded regard VBN 35772 1392 13 as as IN 35772 1392 14 a a DT 35772 1392 15 large large JJ 35772 1392 16 admission admission NN 35772 1392 17 from from IN 35772 1392 18 the the DT 35772 1392 19 standpoint standpoint NN 35772 1392 20 of of IN 35772 1392 21 physical physical JJ 35772 1392 22 science science NN 35772 1392 23 . . . 35772 1393 1 RESULTS result NNS 35772 1393 2 OF of IN 35772 1393 3 THE the DT 35772 1393 4 NEW new JJ 35772 1393 5 PHYSICS.--The physics.--the JJ 35772 1393 6 reduction reduction NN 35772 1393 7 of of IN 35772 1393 8 knowable knowable JJ 35772 1393 9 and and CC 35772 1393 10 tangible tangible JJ 35772 1393 11 matter matter NN 35772 1393 12 to to IN 35772 1393 13 intangible intangible JJ 35772 1393 14 electricity electricity NN 35772 1393 15 or or CC 35772 1393 16 unknowable unknowable JJ 35772 1393 17 ether ether NN 35772 1393 18 may may MD 35772 1393 19 not not RB 35772 1393 20 seem seem VB 35772 1393 21 to to TO 35772 1393 22 be be VB 35772 1393 23 much much JJ 35772 1393 24 of of IN 35772 1393 25 an an DT 35772 1393 26 advance advance NN 35772 1393 27 from from IN 35772 1393 28 the the DT 35772 1393 29 point point NN 35772 1393 30 of of IN 35772 1393 31 view view NN 35772 1393 32 of of IN 35772 1393 33 those those DT 35772 1393 34 who who WP 35772 1393 35 are be VBP 35772 1393 36 interested interested JJ 35772 1393 37 in in IN 35772 1393 38 establishing establish VBG 35772 1393 39 a a DT 35772 1393 40 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1393 41 theory theory NN 35772 1393 42 of of IN 35772 1393 43 the the DT 35772 1393 44 universe universe NN 35772 1393 45 . . . 35772 1394 1 But but CC 35772 1394 2 electricity electricity NN 35772 1394 3 is be VBZ 35772 1394 4 a a DT 35772 1394 5 species species NN 35772 1394 6 of of IN 35772 1394 7 energy energy NN 35772 1394 8 which which WDT 35772 1394 9 can can MD 35772 1394 10 be be VB 35772 1394 11 expressed express VBN 35772 1394 12 in in IN 35772 1394 13 terms term NNS 35772 1394 14 of of IN 35772 1394 15 will will NN 35772 1394 16 -- -- : 35772 1394 17 which which WDT 35772 1394 18 is be VBZ 35772 1394 19 the the DT 35772 1394 20 only only JJ 35772 1394 21 kind kind NN 35772 1394 22 of of IN 35772 1394 23 energy energy NN 35772 1394 24 that that WDT 35772 1394 25 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1394 26 are be VBP 35772 1394 27 acquainted acquaint VBN 35772 1394 28 with with IN 35772 1394 29 at at IN 35772 1394 30 first first JJ 35772 1394 31 hand hand NN 35772 1394 32 . . . 35772 1395 1 " " `` 35772 1395 2 What what WP 35772 1395 3 is be VBZ 35772 1395 4 objectively objectively RB 35772 1395 5 energy energy NN 35772 1395 6 is be VBZ 35772 1395 7 subjectively subjectively RB 35772 1395 8 will will MD 35772 1395 9 ; ; : 35772 1395 10 or or CC 35772 1395 11 , , , 35772 1395 12 in in IN 35772 1395 13 other other JJ 35772 1395 14 words word NNS 35772 1395 15 , , , 35772 1395 16 manifested manifest VBD 35772 1395 17 energy energy NN 35772 1395 18 is be VBZ 35772 1395 19 the the DT 35772 1395 20 visibility visibility NN 35772 1395 21 of of IN 35772 1395 22 will will NN 35772 1395 23 . . . 35772 1396 1 " " `` 35772 1396 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1396 3 69 69 CD 35772 1396 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1396 5 And and CC 35772 1396 6 so so RB 35772 1396 7 far far RB 35772 1396 8 as as IN 35772 1396 9 the the DT 35772 1396 10 " " `` 35772 1396 11 unknowable unknowable JJ 35772 1396 12 " " '' 35772 1396 13 ether ether NN 35772 1396 14 is be VBZ 35772 1396 15 concerned concern VBN 35772 1396 16 , , , 35772 1396 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1396 18 gives give VBZ 35772 1396 19 less less JJR 35772 1396 20 scope scope NN 35772 1396 21 to to IN 35772 1396 22 those those DT 35772 1396 23 powers power NNS 35772 1396 24 of of IN 35772 1396 25 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1396 26 , , , 35772 1396 27 the the DT 35772 1396 28 exercise exercise NN 35772 1396 29 of of IN 35772 1396 30 which which WDT 35772 1396 31 characterised characterise VBD 35772 1396 32 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1396 33 of of IN 35772 1396 34 the the DT 35772 1396 35 old old JJ 35772 1396 36 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 1396 37 school school NN 35772 1396 38 ; ; : 35772 1396 39 and and CC 35772 1396 40 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1396 41 is be VBZ 35772 1396 42 the the DT 35772 1396 43 habit habit NN 35772 1396 44 of of IN 35772 1396 45 oracular oracular JJ 35772 1396 46 pronouncements pronouncement NNS 35772 1396 47 which which WDT 35772 1396 48 does do VBZ 35772 1396 49 the the DT 35772 1396 50 harm harm NN 35772 1396 51 , , , 35772 1396 52 by by IN 35772 1396 53 rendering render VBG 35772 1396 54 any any DT 35772 1396 55 intellectual intellectual JJ 35772 1396 56 or or CC 35772 1396 57 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1396 58 progress progress NN 35772 1396 59 impossible impossible JJ 35772 1396 60 . . . 35772 1397 1 In in IN 35772 1397 2 any any DT 35772 1397 3 case case NN 35772 1397 4 , , , 35772 1397 5 whatever whatever WDT 35772 1397 6 be be VB 35772 1397 7 the the DT 35772 1397 8 substitute substitute NN 35772 1397 9 which which WDT 35772 1397 10 is be VBZ 35772 1397 11 to to TO 35772 1397 12 replace replace VB 35772 1397 13 the the DT 35772 1397 14 old old JJ 35772 1397 15 theory theory NN 35772 1397 16 , , , 35772 1397 17 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1397 18 may may MD 35772 1397 19 congratulate congratulate VB 35772 1397 20 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1397 21 , , , 35772 1397 22 with with IN 35772 1397 23 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1397 24 J. J. NNP 35772 1397 25 S. S. NNP 35772 1397 26 Haldane Haldane NNP 35772 1397 27 , , , 35772 1397 28 that that IN 35772 1397 29 " " `` 35772 1397 30 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1397 31 have have VBP 35772 1397 32 parted part VBN 35772 1397 33 once once RB 35772 1397 34 for for IN 35772 1397 35 all all DT 35772 1397 36 with with IN 35772 1397 37 the the DT 35772 1397 38 notion notion NN 35772 1397 39 of of IN 35772 1397 40 a a DT 35772 1397 41 real real JJ 35772 1397 42 and and CC 35772 1397 43 self self NN 35772 1397 44 - - HYPH 35772 1397 45 existent existent NN 35772 1397 46 Material material JJ 35772 1397 47 universe universe NN 35772 1397 48 ; ; , 35772 1397 49 and and CC 35772 1397 50 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1397 51 must must MD 35772 1397 52 remember remember VB 35772 1397 53 where where WRB 35772 1397 54 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1397 55 now now RB 35772 1397 56 are be VBP 35772 1397 57 . . . 35772 1398 1 " " `` 35772 1398 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1398 3 70 70 CD 35772 1398 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1398 5 THE the DT 35772 1398 6 NEW NEW NNP 35772 1398 7 BIOLOGY.--But biology.--but NN 35772 1398 8 if if IN 35772 1398 9 the the DT 35772 1398 10 results result NNS 35772 1398 11 of of IN 35772 1398 12 the the DT 35772 1398 13 new new JJ 35772 1398 14 physics physics NN 35772 1398 15 have have VBP 35772 1398 16 been be VBN 35772 1398 17 disturbing disturbing JJ 35772 1398 18 to to IN 35772 1398 19 those those DT 35772 1398 20 who who WP 35772 1398 21 had have VBD 35772 1398 22 hoped hope VBN 35772 1398 23 that that IN 35772 1398 24 materialism materialism NN 35772 1398 25 was be VBD 35772 1398 26 a a DT 35772 1398 27 finally finally RB 35772 1398 28 established establish VBN 35772 1398 29 theory theory NN 35772 1398 30 , , , 35772 1398 31 the the DT 35772 1398 32 results result NNS 35772 1398 33 of of IN 35772 1398 34 recent recent JJ 35772 1398 35 biological biological JJ 35772 1398 36 research research NN 35772 1398 37 have have VBP 35772 1398 38 been be VBN 35772 1398 39 equally equally RB 35772 1398 40 embarrassing embarrassing JJ 35772 1398 41 to to IN 35772 1398 42 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1398 43 . . . 35772 1399 1 The the DT 35772 1399 2 anti anti JJ 35772 1399 3 - - JJ 35772 1399 4 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1399 5 trend trend NN 35772 1399 6 of of IN 35772 1399 7 recent recent JJ 35772 1399 8 biological biological JJ 35772 1399 9 theory theory NN 35772 1399 10 is be VBZ 35772 1399 11 only only RB 35772 1399 12 too too RB 35772 1399 13 evident evident JJ 35772 1399 14 . . . 35772 1400 1 The the DT 35772 1400 2 organism organism NN 35772 1400 3 is be VBZ 35772 1400 4 regarded regard VBN 35772 1400 5 no no RB 35772 1400 6 longer longer RB 35772 1400 7 by by IN 35772 1400 8 the the DT 35772 1400 9 majority majority NN 35772 1400 10 of of IN 35772 1400 11 biologists biologist NNS 35772 1400 12 as as IN 35772 1400 13 fully fully RB 35772 1400 14 explicable explicable JJ 35772 1400 15 in in IN 35772 1400 16 terms term NNS 35772 1400 17 of of IN 35772 1400 18 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 1400 19 and and CC 35772 1400 20 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 1400 21 . . . 35772 1401 1 To to TO 35772 1401 2 quote quote VB 35772 1401 3 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1401 4 Haldane Haldane NNP 35772 1401 5 again again RB 35772 1401 6 , , , 35772 1401 7 " " `` 35772 1401 8 The the DT 35772 1401 9 main main JJ 35772 1401 10 outstanding outstanding JJ 35772 1401 11 fact fact NN 35772 1401 12 is be VBZ 35772 1401 13 that that IN 35772 1401 14 the the DT 35772 1401 15 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1401 16 account account NN 35772 1401 17 of of IN 35772 1401 18 the the DT 35772 1401 19 universe universe NN 35772 1401 20 breaks break VBZ 35772 1401 21 down down RP 35772 1401 22 completely completely RB 35772 1401 23 in in IN 35772 1401 24 connection connection NN 35772 1401 25 with with IN 35772 1401 26 the the DT 35772 1401 27 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1401 28 of of IN 35772 1401 29 life life NN 35772 1401 30 .... .... . 35772 1402 1 In in IN 35772 1402 2 the the DT 35772 1402 3 case case NN 35772 1402 4 of of IN 35772 1402 5 life life NN 35772 1402 6 , , , 35772 1402 7 the the DT 35772 1402 8 facts fact NNS 35772 1402 9 are be VBP 35772 1402 10 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 35772 1402 11 with with IN 35772 1402 12 the the DT 35772 1402 13 physical physical JJ 35772 1402 14 and and CC 35772 1402 15 chemical chemical NN 35772 1402 16 account account NN 35772 1402 17 of of IN 35772 1402 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1402 19 . . . 35772 1403 1 " " `` 35772 1403 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1403 3 71 71 CD 35772 1403 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1403 5 The the DT 35772 1403 6 organism organism NN 35772 1403 7 can can MD 35772 1403 8 no no RB 35772 1403 9 longer longer RB 35772 1403 10 be be VB 35772 1403 11 regarded regard VBN 35772 1403 12 as as IN 35772 1403 13 even even RB 35772 1403 14 an an DT 35772 1403 15 extremely extremely RB 35772 1403 16 complex complex JJ 35772 1403 17 kind kind NN 35772 1403 18 of of IN 35772 1403 19 machine machine NN 35772 1403 20 ; ; : 35772 1403 21 that that DT 35772 1403 22 word word NN 35772 1403 23 will will MD 35772 1403 24 not not RB 35772 1403 25 cover cover VB 35772 1403 26 the the DT 35772 1403 27 facts fact NNS 35772 1403 28 , , , 35772 1403 29 and and CC 35772 1403 30 biologists biologist NNS 35772 1403 31 are be VBP 35772 1403 32 compelled compel VBN 35772 1403 33 to to TO 35772 1403 34 look look VB 35772 1403 35 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1403 36 for for IN 35772 1403 37 a a DT 35772 1403 38 less less RBR 35772 1403 39 misleading misleading JJ 35772 1403 40 terminology terminology NN 35772 1403 41 . . . 35772 1404 1 To to TO 35772 1404 2 describe describe VB 35772 1404 3 the the DT 35772 1404 4 organism organism NN 35772 1404 5 as as IN 35772 1404 6 a a DT 35772 1404 7 machine machine NN 35772 1404 8 , , , 35772 1404 9 is be VBZ 35772 1404 10 to to TO 35772 1404 11 give give VB 35772 1404 12 to to IN 35772 1404 13 that that DT 35772 1404 14 word word NN 35772 1404 15 a a DT 35772 1404 16 very very RB 35772 1404 17 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 35772 1404 18 connotation connotation NN 35772 1404 19 . . . 35772 1405 1 For for IN 35772 1405 2 the the DT 35772 1405 3 organism organism NN 35772 1405 4 is be VBZ 35772 1405 5 a a DT 35772 1405 6 machine machine NN 35772 1405 7 different different JJ 35772 1405 8 in in IN 35772 1405 9 kind kind NN 35772 1405 10 from from IN 35772 1405 11 any any DT 35772 1405 12 that that WDT 35772 1405 13 has have VBZ 35772 1405 14 been be VBN 35772 1405 15 constructed construct VBN 35772 1405 16 by by IN 35772 1405 17 man man NN 35772 1405 18 ; ; : 35772 1405 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1405 20 is be VBZ 35772 1405 21 " " `` 35772 1405 22 a a DT 35772 1405 23 self self NN 35772 1405 24 - - HYPH 35772 1405 25 stoking stoke VBG 35772 1405 26 , , , 35772 1405 27 self self NN 35772 1405 28 - - HYPH 35772 1405 29 repairing repair VBG 35772 1405 30 , , , 35772 1405 31 self self NN 35772 1405 32 - - HYPH 35772 1405 33 preservative preservative JJ 35772 1405 34 , , , 35772 1405 35 self self NN 35772 1405 36 - - HYPH 35772 1405 37 adjusting adjust VBG 35772 1405 38 , , , 35772 1405 39 self self NN 35772 1405 40 - - HYPH 35772 1405 41 increasing increase VBG 35772 1405 42 , , , 35772 1405 43 self self NN 35772 1405 44 - - HYPH 35772 1405 45 producing produce VBG 35772 1405 46 engine engine NN 35772 1405 47 . . . 35772 1406 1 " " `` 35772 1406 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1406 3 72 72 CD 35772 1406 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1406 5 THE the DT 35772 1406 6 RESEARCHES researches NN 35772 1406 7 OF of IN 35772 1406 8 DRIESCH.--Just driesch.--just NN 35772 1406 9 as as IN 35772 1406 10 modern modern JJ 35772 1406 11 physics physics NN 35772 1406 12 is be VBZ 35772 1406 13 concerned concern VBN 35772 1406 14 with with IN 35772 1406 15 the the DT 35772 1406 16 infinitely infinitely RB 35772 1406 17 small small JJ 35772 1406 18 -- -- : 35772 1406 19 the the DT 35772 1406 20 ultra ultra JJ 35772 1406 21 - - JJ 35772 1406 22 microscopic microscopic JJ 35772 1406 23 , , , 35772 1406 24 in in IN 35772 1406 25 fact fact NN 35772 1406 26 -- -- : 35772 1406 27 so so RB 35772 1406 28 modern modern JJ 35772 1406 29 biologists biologist NNS 35772 1406 30 are be VBP 35772 1406 31 concentrating concentrate VBG 35772 1406 32 attention attention NN 35772 1406 33 upon upon IN 35772 1406 34 microscopic microscopic JJ 35772 1406 35 organisms organism NNS 35772 1406 36 , , , 35772 1406 37 where where WRB 35772 1406 38 life life NN 35772 1406 39 is be VBZ 35772 1406 40 seen see VBN 35772 1406 41 at at IN 35772 1406 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1406 43 lowest low JJS 35772 1406 44 terms term NNS 35772 1406 45 , , , 35772 1406 46 and and CC 35772 1406 47 where where WRB 35772 1406 48 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1406 49 if if IN 35772 1406 50 anywhere anywhere RB 35772 1406 51 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1406 52 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1406 53 may may MD 35772 1406 54 expect expect VB 35772 1406 55 to to TO 35772 1406 56 discover discover VB 35772 1406 57 what what WP 35772 1406 58 are be VBP 35772 1406 59 the the DT 35772 1406 60 _ _ NNP 35772 1406 61 differentia differentia NNP 35772 1406 62 _ _ NNP 35772 1406 63 of of IN 35772 1406 64 life life NN 35772 1406 65 , , , 35772 1406 66 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1407 1 what what WP 35772 1407 2 are be VBP 35772 1407 3 the the DT 35772 1407 4 qualities quality NNS 35772 1407 5 that that WDT 35772 1407 6 distinguish distinguish VBP 35772 1407 7 living live VBG 35772 1407 8 organic organic JJ 35772 1407 9 from from IN 35772 1407 10 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 1407 11 matter matter NN 35772 1407 12 . . . 35772 1408 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1408 2 the the DT 35772 1408 3 most most RBS 35772 1408 4 notable notable JJ 35772 1408 5 of of IN 35772 1408 6 the the DT 35772 1408 7 researches research NNS 35772 1408 8 conducted conduct VBN 35772 1408 9 in in IN 35772 1408 10 this this DT 35772 1408 11 sphere sphere NN 35772 1408 12 , , , 35772 1408 13 of of IN 35772 1408 14 recent recent JJ 35772 1408 15 years year NNS 35772 1408 16 , , , 35772 1408 17 have have VBP 35772 1408 18 been be VBN 35772 1408 19 those those DT 35772 1408 20 of of IN 35772 1408 21 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1408 22 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1408 23 , , , 35772 1408 24 who who WP 35772 1408 25 expounded expound VBD 35772 1408 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1408 27 results result NNS 35772 1408 28 in in IN 35772 1408 29 the the DT 35772 1408 30 _ _ NNP 35772 1408 31 Gifford Gifford NNP 35772 1408 32 Lectures Lectures NNP 35772 1408 33 _ _ NNP 35772 1408 34 for for IN 35772 1408 35 1907 1907 CD 35772 1408 36 - - SYM 35772 1408 37 1908 1908 CD 35772 1408 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1408 39 _ _ NNP 35772 1408 40 The The NNP 35772 1408 41 Science Science NNP 35772 1408 42 and and CC 35772 1408 43 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1408 44 of of IN 35772 1408 45 the the DT 35772 1408 46 Organism Organism NNP 35772 1408 47 _ _ NNP 35772 1408 48 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1408 49 . . . 35772 1409 1 The the DT 35772 1409 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1409 3 upon upon IN 35772 1409 4 which which WDT 35772 1409 5 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1409 6 lays lay VBZ 35772 1409 7 considerable considerable JJ 35772 1409 8 stress stress NN 35772 1409 9 are be VBP 35772 1409 10 those those DT 35772 1409 11 which which WDT 35772 1409 12 occur occur VBP 35772 1409 13 upon upon IN 35772 1409 14 a a DT 35772 1409 15 division division NN 35772 1409 16 of of IN 35772 1409 17 certain certain JJ 35772 1409 18 living live VBG 35772 1409 19 embryos embryo NNS 35772 1409 20 . . . 35772 1410 1 An an DT 35772 1410 2 embryo embryo NN 35772 1410 3 , , , 35772 1410 4 when when WRB 35772 1410 5 cut cut VBN 35772 1410 6 in in IN 35772 1410 7 half half NN 35772 1410 8 , , , 35772 1410 9 displays display NNS 35772 1410 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 35772 1410 11 powers power NNS 35772 1410 12 of of IN 35772 1410 13 self self NN 35772 1410 14 - - HYPH 35772 1410 15 adjustment adjustment NN 35772 1410 16 and and CC 35772 1410 17 continued continued JJ 35772 1410 18 development development NN 35772 1410 19 . . . 35772 1411 1 Each each DT 35772 1411 2 half half NN 35772 1411 3 can can MD 35772 1411 4 , , , 35772 1411 5 as as IN 35772 1411 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1411 7 were be VBD 35772 1411 8 , , , 35772 1411 9 regulate regulate VB 35772 1411 10 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1411 11 , , , 35772 1411 12 and and CC 35772 1411 13 make make VB 35772 1411 14 a a DT 35772 1411 15 fresh fresh JJ 35772 1411 16 start start NN 35772 1411 17 ; ; : 35772 1411 18 a a DT 35772 1411 19 process process NN 35772 1411 20 which which WDT 35772 1411 21 results result VBZ 35772 1411 22 in in IN 35772 1411 23 two two CD 35772 1411 24 self self NN 35772 1411 25 - - HYPH 35772 1411 26 contained contain VBN 35772 1411 27 organisms organism NNS 35772 1411 28 , , , 35772 1411 29 though though IN 35772 1411 30 of of IN 35772 1411 31 smaller small JJR 35772 1411 32 size size NN 35772 1411 33 than than IN 35772 1411 34 would would MD 35772 1411 35 have have VB 35772 1411 36 resulted result VBN 35772 1411 37 from from IN 35772 1411 38 a a DT 35772 1411 39 single single JJ 35772 1411 40 undivided undivided JJ 35772 1411 41 organism organism NN 35772 1411 42 . . . 35772 1412 1 The the DT 35772 1412 2 cells cell NNS 35772 1412 3 which which WDT 35772 1412 4 compose compose VBD 35772 1412 5 the the DT 35772 1412 6 organism organism NN 35772 1412 7 seem seem VB 35772 1412 8 able able JJ 35772 1412 9 to to TO 35772 1412 10 adapt adapt VB 35772 1412 11 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1412 12 to to IN 35772 1412 13 whatever whatever WDT 35772 1412 14 demands demand NNS 35772 1412 15 are be VBP 35772 1412 16 made make VBN 35772 1412 17 upon upon IN 35772 1412 18 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1412 19 . . . 35772 1413 1 Like like IN 35772 1413 2 workmen workman NNS 35772 1413 3 building build VBG 35772 1413 4 a a DT 35772 1413 5 bridge bridge NN 35772 1413 6 , , , 35772 1413 7 all all DT 35772 1413 8 of of IN 35772 1413 9 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1413 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1413 11 can can MD 35772 1413 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1413 13 do do VB 35772 1413 14 every every DT 35772 1413 15 single single JJ 35772 1413 16 act act NN 35772 1413 17 -- -- : 35772 1413 18 if if IN 35772 1413 19 need need NN 35772 1413 20 arise arise NN 35772 1413 21 -- -- : 35772 1413 22 and and CC 35772 1413 23 the the DT 35772 1413 24 result result NN 35772 1413 25 of of IN 35772 1413 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1413 27 labours labour NNS 35772 1413 28 is be VBZ 35772 1413 29 a a DT 35772 1413 30 perfect perfect JJ 35772 1413 31 bridge bridge NN 35772 1413 32 , , , 35772 1413 33 even even RB 35772 1413 34 if if IN 35772 1413 35 some some DT 35772 1413 36 of of IN 35772 1413 37 the the DT 35772 1413 38 workmen workman NNS 35772 1413 39 fall fall VBP 35772 1413 40 sick sick JJ 35772 1413 41 or or CC 35772 1413 42 are be VBP 35772 1413 43 killed kill VBN 35772 1413 44 or or CC 35772 1413 45 injured injure VBN 35772 1413 46 in in IN 35772 1413 47 an an DT 35772 1413 48 accident accident NN 35772 1413 49 . . . 35772 1414 1 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1414 2 sums sum VBZ 35772 1414 3 up up RP 35772 1414 4 the the DT 35772 1414 5 results result NNS 35772 1414 6 of of IN 35772 1414 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1414 8 researches research NNS 35772 1414 9 by by IN 35772 1414 10 saying say VBG 35772 1414 11 : : : 35772 1414 12 " " `` 35772 1414 13 There there EX 35772 1414 14 is be VBZ 35772 1414 15 something something NN 35772 1414 16 in in IN 35772 1414 17 the the DT 35772 1414 18 organism organism NN 35772 1414 19 's 's POS 35772 1414 20 behaviour behaviour NN 35772 1414 21 -- -- : 35772 1414 22 in in IN 35772 1414 23 the the DT 35772 1414 24 widest wide JJS 35772 1414 25 sense sense NN 35772 1414 26 of of IN 35772 1414 27 the the DT 35772 1414 28 word word NN 35772 1414 29 -- -- : 35772 1414 30 which which WDT 35772 1414 31 is be VBZ 35772 1414 32 opposed opposed JJ 35772 1414 33 to to IN 35772 1414 34 an an DT 35772 1414 35 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 1414 36 resolution resolution NN 35772 1414 37 of of IN 35772 1414 38 the the DT 35772 1414 39 same same JJ 35772 1414 40 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1414 41 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1415 1 to to IN 35772 1415 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1415 3 complete complete JJ 35772 1415 4 expression expression NN 35772 1415 5 in in IN 35772 1415 6 terms term NNS 35772 1415 7 of of IN 35772 1415 8 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 1415 9 and and CC 35772 1415 10 physics physics NN 35772 1415 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1415 12 , , , 35772 1415 13 and and CC 35772 1415 14 which which WDT 35772 1415 15 shows show VBZ 35772 1415 16 that that IN 35772 1415 17 the the DT 35772 1415 18 living live VBG 35772 1415 19 organism organism NN 35772 1415 20 is be VBZ 35772 1415 21 more more JJR 35772 1415 22 than than IN 35772 1415 23 a a DT 35772 1415 24 sum sum NN 35772 1415 25 or or CC 35772 1415 26 aggregate aggregate NN 35772 1415 27 of of IN 35772 1415 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1415 29 parts part NNS 35772 1415 30 ; ; : 35772 1415 31 that that IN 35772 1415 32 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1415 33 is be VBZ 35772 1415 34 insufficient insufficient JJ 35772 1415 35 to to TO 35772 1415 36 call call VB 35772 1415 37 the the DT 35772 1415 38 organism organism NN 35772 1415 39 ' ' '' 35772 1415 40 a a DT 35772 1415 41 typically typically RB 35772 1415 42 combined combine VBN 35772 1415 43 body body NN 35772 1415 44 ' ' '' 35772 1415 45 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1415 46 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1415 47 , , , 35772 1415 48 a a DT 35772 1415 49 machine machine NN 35772 1415 50 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1415 51 , , , 35772 1415 52 without without IN 35772 1415 53 further further JJ 35772 1415 54 explanation explanation NN 35772 1415 55 . . . 35772 1416 1 " " `` 35772 1416 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1416 3 73 73 CD 35772 1416 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1416 5 THE the DT 35772 1416 6 PROBLEM problem NN 35772 1416 7 OF of IN 35772 1416 8 LIFE.--The life.--the NN 35772 1416 9 problem problem NN 35772 1416 10 is be VBZ 35772 1416 11 : : : 35772 1416 12 What what WP 35772 1416 13 is be VBZ 35772 1416 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1416 15 in in IN 35772 1416 16 an an DT 35772 1416 17 organism organism NN 35772 1416 18 which which WDT 35772 1416 19 causes cause VBZ 35772 1416 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1416 21 to to TO 35772 1416 22 behave behave VB 35772 1416 23 in in IN 35772 1416 24 a a DT 35772 1416 25 fashion fashion NN 35772 1416 26 so so RB 35772 1416 27 impossible impossible JJ 35772 1416 28 for for IN 35772 1416 29 any any DT 35772 1416 30 machine machine NN 35772 1416 31 ? ? . 35772 1417 1 To to TO 35772 1417 2 answer answer VB 35772 1417 3 this this DT 35772 1417 4 question question NN 35772 1417 5 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 35772 1417 6 would would MD 35772 1417 7 be be VB 35772 1417 8 to to TO 35772 1417 9 have have VB 35772 1417 10 solved solve VBN 35772 1417 11 the the DT 35772 1417 12 mystery mystery NN 35772 1417 13 of of IN 35772 1417 14 life life NN 35772 1417 15 . . . 35772 1418 1 Biologists biologist NNS 35772 1418 2 do do VBP 35772 1418 3 not not RB 35772 1418 4 answer answer VB 35772 1418 5 the the DT 35772 1418 6 question question NN 35772 1418 7 ; ; : 35772 1418 8 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1418 9 do do VBP 35772 1418 10 not not RB 35772 1418 11 say say VB 35772 1418 12 what what WP 35772 1418 13 this this DT 35772 1418 14 peculiar peculiar JJ 35772 1418 15 potency potency NN 35772 1418 16 is be VBZ 35772 1418 17 , , , 35772 1418 18 but but CC 35772 1418 19 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1418 20 give give VBP 35772 1418 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1418 22 a a DT 35772 1418 23 name name NN 35772 1418 24 . . . 35772 1419 1 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1419 2 calls call VBZ 35772 1419 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1419 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1419 5 entelechy entelechy JJ 35772 1419 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1419 7 , , , 35772 1419 8 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1420 1 " " `` 35772 1420 2 purposiveness purposiveness NN 35772 1420 3 , , , 35772 1420 4 " " '' 35772 1420 5 and and CC 35772 1420 6 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1420 7 also also RB 35772 1420 8 speaks speak VBZ 35772 1420 9 of of IN 35772 1420 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1420 11 psychoids psychoid NNS 35772 1420 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1420 13 , , , 35772 1420 14 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1421 1 " " `` 35772 1421 2 primitive primitive JJ 35772 1421 3 minds mind NNS 35772 1421 4 . . . 35772 1421 5 " " '' 35772 1422 1 Names name NNS 35772 1422 2 do do VBP 35772 1422 3 not not RB 35772 1422 4 carry carry VB 35772 1422 5 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1422 6 very very RB 35772 1422 7 far far RB 35772 1422 8 ; ; : 35772 1422 9 but but CC 35772 1422 10 the the DT 35772 1422 11 mere mere JJ 35772 1422 12 fact fact NN 35772 1422 13 that that IN 35772 1422 14 biologists biologist NNS 35772 1422 15 have have VBP 35772 1422 16 gone go VBN 35772 1422 17 to to IN 35772 1422 18 the the DT 35772 1422 19 trouble trouble NN 35772 1422 20 of of IN 35772 1422 21 providing provide VBG 35772 1422 22 a a DT 35772 1422 23 name name NN 35772 1422 24 , , , 35772 1422 25 is be VBZ 35772 1422 26 important important JJ 35772 1422 27 . . . 35772 1423 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1423 2 constitutes constitute VBZ 35772 1423 3 an an DT 35772 1423 4 admission admission NN 35772 1423 5 on on IN 35772 1423 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1423 7 part part NN 35772 1423 8 that that IN 35772 1423 9 there there EX 35772 1423 10 is be VBZ 35772 1423 11 something something NN 35772 1423 12 mysterious mysterious JJ 35772 1423 13 about about IN 35772 1423 14 the the DT 35772 1423 15 organism organism NN 35772 1423 16 ; ; : 35772 1423 17 for for IN 35772 1423 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1423 19 has have VBZ 35772 1423 20 been be VBN 35772 1423 21 a a DT 35772 1423 22 principle principle NN 35772 1423 23 of of IN 35772 1423 24 modern modern JJ 35772 1423 25 science science NN 35772 1423 26 since since IN 35772 1423 27 the the DT 35772 1423 28 days day NNS 35772 1423 29 of of IN 35772 1423 30 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 1423 31 never never RB 35772 1423 32 to to TO 35772 1423 33 appeal appeal VB 35772 1423 34 to to IN 35772 1423 35 mysterious mysterious JJ 35772 1423 36 causes cause NNS 35772 1423 37 if if IN 35772 1423 38 known know VBN 35772 1423 39 ones one NNS 35772 1423 40 can can MD 35772 1423 41 be be VB 35772 1423 42 found find VBN 35772 1423 43 . . . 35772 1424 1 The the DT 35772 1424 2 _ _ NNP 35772 1424 3 deus deu VBZ 35772 1424 4 ex ex NNP 35772 1424 5 machina machina NNP 35772 1424 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1424 7 method method NN 35772 1424 8 seems seem VBZ 35772 1424 9 to to IN 35772 1424 10 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1424 11 fundamentally fundamentally RB 35772 1424 12 unsound unsound JJ 35772 1424 13 , , , 35772 1424 14 and and CC 35772 1424 15 so so RB 35772 1424 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1424 17 is be VBZ 35772 1424 18 . . . 35772 1425 1 If if IN 35772 1425 2 every every DT 35772 1425 3 difficulty difficulty NN 35772 1425 4 were be VBD 35772 1425 5 considered consider VBN 35772 1425 6 solved solve VBN 35772 1425 7 merely merely RB 35772 1425 8 by by IN 35772 1425 9 the the DT 35772 1425 10 word word NN 35772 1425 11 " " '' 35772 1425 12 mystery mystery NN 35772 1425 13 , , , 35772 1425 14 " " '' 35772 1425 15 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1425 16 would would MD 35772 1425 17 never never RB 35772 1425 18 advance advance VB 35772 1425 19 . . . 35772 1426 1 Labelled label VBN 35772 1426 2 ignorance ignorance NN 35772 1426 3 is be VBZ 35772 1426 4 still still RB 35772 1426 5 ignorance ignorance NN 35772 1426 6 . . . 35772 1427 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1427 2 is be VBZ 35772 1427 3 not not RB 35772 1427 4 names name NNS 35772 1427 5 , , , 35772 1427 6 but but CC 35772 1427 7 things thing NNS 35772 1427 8 that that WDT 35772 1427 9 are be VBP 35772 1427 10 important important JJ 35772 1427 11 . . . 35772 1428 1 But but CC 35772 1428 2 in in IN 35772 1428 3 this this DT 35772 1428 4 particular particular JJ 35772 1428 5 instance instance NN 35772 1428 6 the the DT 35772 1428 7 application application NN 35772 1428 8 of of IN 35772 1428 9 the the DT 35772 1428 10 name name NN 35772 1428 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1428 12 entelechy entelechy JJ 35772 1428 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1428 14 indicates indicate VBZ 35772 1428 15 that that IN 35772 1428 16 , , , 35772 1428 17 in in IN 35772 1428 18 the the DT 35772 1428 19 opinion opinion NN 35772 1428 20 of of IN 35772 1428 21 such such PDT 35772 1428 22 an an DT 35772 1428 23 authority authority NN 35772 1428 24 as as IN 35772 1428 25 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1428 26 , , , 35772 1428 27 at at IN 35772 1428 28 any any DT 35772 1428 29 rate rate NN 35772 1428 30 , , , 35772 1428 31 something something NN 35772 1428 32 exists exist VBZ 35772 1428 33 which which WDT 35772 1428 34 no no DT 35772 1428 35 merely merely RB 35772 1428 36 physical physical JJ 35772 1428 37 or or CC 35772 1428 38 chemical chemical JJ 35772 1428 39 term term NN 35772 1428 40 can can MD 35772 1428 41 completely completely RB 35772 1428 42 describe describe VB 35772 1428 43 . . . 35772 1429 1 And and CC 35772 1429 2 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1429 3 is be VBZ 35772 1429 4 typical typical JJ 35772 1429 5 of of IN 35772 1429 6 the the DT 35772 1429 7 trend trend NN 35772 1429 8 of of IN 35772 1429 9 much much JJ 35772 1429 10 modern modern JJ 35772 1429 11 biology biology NN 35772 1429 12 . . . 35772 1430 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1430 2 is be VBZ 35772 1430 3 only only RB 35772 1430 4 the the DT 35772 1430 5 very very RB 35772 1430 6 extreme extreme JJ 35772 1430 7 optimists optimist NNS 35772 1430 8 who who WP 35772 1430 9 now now RB 35772 1430 10 look look VBP 35772 1430 11 for for IN 35772 1430 12 a a DT 35772 1430 13 final final JJ 35772 1430 14 explanation explanation NN 35772 1430 15 of of IN 35772 1430 16 the the DT 35772 1430 17 living live VBG 35772 1430 18 organism organism NN 35772 1430 19 in in IN 35772 1430 20 terms term NNS 35772 1430 21 of of IN 35772 1430 22 physics physics NN 35772 1430 23 and and CC 35772 1430 24 chemistry chemistry NN 35772 1430 25 . . . 35772 1431 1 RESULTS result NNS 35772 1431 2 OF of IN 35772 1431 3 THE the DT 35772 1431 4 NEW NEW NNP 35772 1431 5 BIOLOGY.--But biology.--but NN 35772 1431 6 if if IN 35772 1431 7 life life NN 35772 1431 8 resists resist VBZ 35772 1431 9 all all DT 35772 1431 10 attempts attempt NNS 35772 1431 11 to to TO 35772 1431 12 reduce reduce VB 35772 1431 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1431 14 to to IN 35772 1431 15 matter matter NN 35772 1431 16 and and CC 35772 1431 17 motion motion NN 35772 1431 18 , , , 35772 1431 19 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1431 20 are be VBP 35772 1431 21 confronted confront VBN 35772 1431 22 with with IN 35772 1431 23 the the DT 35772 1431 24 breakdown breakdown NN 35772 1431 25 of of IN 35772 1431 26 the the DT 35772 1431 27 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1431 28 theory theory NN 35772 1431 29 of of IN 35772 1431 30 the the DT 35772 1431 31 universe universe NN 35772 1431 32 , , , 35772 1431 33 which which WDT 35772 1431 34 has have VBZ 35772 1431 35 been be VBN 35772 1431 36 slowly slowly RB 35772 1431 37 but but CC 35772 1431 38 progressively progressively RB 35772 1431 39 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 1431 40 since since IN 35772 1431 41 the the DT 35772 1431 42 days day NNS 35772 1431 43 of of IN 35772 1431 44 Leonardo Leonardo NNP 35772 1431 45 da da NNP 35772 1431 46 Vinci Vinci NNP 35772 1431 47 , , , 35772 1431 48 and and CC 35772 1431 49 applied apply VBD 35772 1431 50 impartially impartially RB 35772 1431 51 to to IN 35772 1431 52 the the DT 35772 1431 53 organic organic JJ 35772 1431 54 and and CC 35772 1431 55 the the DT 35772 1431 56 inorganic inorganic JJ 35772 1431 57 spheres sphere NNS 35772 1431 58 . . . 35772 1432 1 But but CC 35772 1432 2 this this DT 35772 1432 3 ultra ultra JJ 35772 1432 4 - - JJ 35772 1432 5 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1432 6 theory theory NN 35772 1432 7 now now RB 35772 1432 8 seems seem VBZ 35772 1432 9 too too RB 35772 1432 10 cramped cramp VBN 35772 1432 11 to to TO 35772 1432 12 contain contain VB 35772 1432 13 the the DT 35772 1432 14 facts fact NNS 35772 1432 15 ; ; : 35772 1432 16 even even RB 35772 1432 17 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1432 18 resent resent VBP 35772 1432 19 the the DT 35772 1432 20 claims claim NNS 35772 1432 21 of of IN 35772 1432 22 materialist materialist NN 35772 1432 23 - - HYPH 35772 1432 24 mechanical mechanical NNP 35772 1432 25 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 35772 1432 26 . . . 35772 1433 1 Some some DT 35772 1433 2 indeed indeed RB 35772 1433 3 adopt adopt VBP 35772 1433 4 not not RB 35772 1433 5 merely merely RB 35772 1433 6 a a DT 35772 1433 7 critical critical JJ 35772 1433 8 , , , 35772 1433 9 but but CC 35772 1433 10 a a DT 35772 1433 11 provocative provocative JJ 35772 1433 12 attitude attitude NN 35772 1433 13 , , , 35772 1433 14 and and CC 35772 1433 15 seek seek VB 35772 1433 16 to to TO 35772 1433 17 discredit discredit VB 35772 1433 18 the the DT 35772 1433 19 prestige prestige NN 35772 1433 20 of of IN 35772 1433 21 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 1433 22 . . . 35772 1434 1 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1434 2 J. J. NNP 35772 1434 3 S. S. NNP 35772 1434 4 Haldane Haldane NNP 35772 1434 5 not not RB 35772 1434 6 only only RB 35772 1434 7 vindicates vindicate VBZ 35772 1434 8 the the DT 35772 1434 9 freedom freedom NN 35772 1434 10 , , , 35772 1434 11 but but CC 35772 1434 12 prophesies prophesy VBZ 35772 1434 13 the the DT 35772 1434 14 speedy speedy JJ 35772 1434 15 advance advance NN 35772 1434 16 of of IN 35772 1434 17 biology biology NN 35772 1434 18 to to IN 35772 1434 19 a a DT 35772 1434 20 position position NN 35772 1434 21 of of IN 35772 1434 22 pre pre NN 35772 1434 23 - - NN 35772 1434 24 eminence eminence NN 35772 1434 25 . . . 35772 1435 1 Not not RB 35772 1435 2 only only RB 35772 1435 3 are be VBP 35772 1435 4 biological biological JJ 35772 1435 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1435 6 irreducible irreducible JJ 35772 1435 7 to to IN 35772 1435 8 terms term NNS 35772 1435 9 of of IN 35772 1435 10 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 1435 11 , , , 35772 1435 12 but but CC 35772 1435 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1435 14 is be VBZ 35772 1435 15 mechanics mechanic NNS 35772 1435 16 that that WDT 35772 1435 17 will will MD 35772 1435 18 have have VB 35772 1435 19 to to TO 35772 1435 20 be be VB 35772 1435 21 re re VBN 35772 1435 22 - - VBN 35772 1435 23 interpreted interpret VBN 35772 1435 24 in in IN 35772 1435 25 terms term NNS 35772 1435 26 of of IN 35772 1435 27 biology biology NN 35772 1435 28 . . . 35772 1436 1 " " `` 35772 1436 2 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1436 3 is be VBZ 35772 1436 4 at at IN 35772 1436 5 least least JJS 35772 1436 6 evident evident JJ 35772 1436 7 that that IN 35772 1436 8 the the DT 35772 1436 9 extension extension NN 35772 1436 10 of of IN 35772 1436 11 biological biological JJ 35772 1436 12 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1436 13 to to IN 35772 1436 14 the the DT 35772 1436 15 whole whole NN 35772 1436 16 of of IN 35772 1436 17 nature nature NN 35772 1436 18 may may MD 35772 1436 19 be be VB 35772 1436 20 much much RB 35772 1436 21 nearer near JJR 35772 1436 22 than than IN 35772 1436 23 seemed seem VBN 35772 1436 24 conceivable conceivable JJ 35772 1436 25 even even RB 35772 1436 26 a a DT 35772 1436 27 few few JJ 35772 1436 28 years year NNS 35772 1436 29 ago ago RB 35772 1436 30 . . . 35772 1437 1 When when WRB 35772 1437 2 the the DT 35772 1437 3 day day NN 35772 1437 4 of of IN 35772 1437 5 that that DT 35772 1437 6 extension extension NN 35772 1437 7 comes come VBZ 35772 1437 8 , , , 35772 1437 9 the the DT 35772 1437 10 physical physical JJ 35772 1437 11 and and CC 35772 1437 12 chemical chemical JJ 35772 1437 13 world world NN 35772 1437 14 as as IN 35772 1437 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1437 16 now now RB 35772 1437 17 conceive conceive VBP 35772 1437 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1437 19 -- -- : 35772 1437 20 the the DT 35772 1437 21 world world NN 35772 1437 22 of of IN 35772 1437 23 atoms atom NNS 35772 1437 24 and and CC 35772 1437 25 energy energy NN 35772 1437 26 -- -- : 35772 1437 27 will will MD 35772 1437 28 be be VB 35772 1437 29 recognised recognise VBN 35772 1437 30 as as IN 35772 1437 31 nothing nothing NN 35772 1437 32 but but IN 35772 1437 33 an an DT 35772 1437 34 appearance appearance NN 35772 1437 35 ... ... : 35772 1437 36 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1437 37 will will MD 35772 1437 38 stand stand VB 35772 1437 39 confessed confessed JJ 35772 1437 40 as as IN 35772 1437 41 a a DT 35772 1437 42 world world NN 35772 1437 43 of of IN 35772 1437 44 abstractions abstraction NNS 35772 1437 45 like like IN 35772 1437 46 that that DT 35772 1437 47 of of IN 35772 1437 48 the the DT 35772 1437 49 pure pure JJ 35772 1437 50 mathematicians mathematician NNS 35772 1437 51 . . . 35772 1438 1 " " `` 35772 1438 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1438 3 74 74 CD 35772 1438 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1438 5 THE the DT 35772 1438 6 NEW NEW NNP 35772 1438 7 PSYCHOLOGY.--Not psychology.--not VBP 35772 1438 8 only only RB 35772 1438 9 physical physical JJ 35772 1438 10 and and CC 35772 1438 11 biological biological JJ 35772 1438 12 , , , 35772 1438 13 but but CC 35772 1438 14 psychological psychological JJ 35772 1438 15 science science NN 35772 1438 16 will will MD 35772 1438 17 contribute contribute VB 35772 1438 18 very very RB 35772 1438 19 largely largely RB 35772 1438 20 to to IN 35772 1438 21 the the DT 35772 1438 22 reconstruction reconstruction NN 35772 1438 23 of of IN 35772 1438 24 view view NN 35772 1438 25 which which WDT 35772 1438 26 is be VBZ 35772 1438 27 now now RB 35772 1438 28 taking take VBG 35772 1438 29 place place NN 35772 1438 30 . . . 35772 1439 1 Particular particular JJ 35772 1439 2 attention attention NN 35772 1439 3 is be VBZ 35772 1439 4 due due JJ 35772 1439 5 to to IN 35772 1439 6 those those DT 35772 1439 7 branches branch NNS 35772 1439 8 of of IN 35772 1439 9 psychology psychology NN 35772 1439 10 which which WDT 35772 1439 11 deal deal VBP 35772 1439 12 experimentally experimentally RB 35772 1439 13 with with IN 35772 1439 14 the the DT 35772 1439 15 subconscious subconscious JJ 35772 1439 16 , , , 35772 1439 17 with with IN 35772 1439 18 instincts instinct NNS 35772 1439 19 , , , 35772 1439 20 with with IN 35772 1439 21 the the DT 35772 1439 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1439 23 of of IN 35772 1439 24 thought thought NN 35772 1439 25 transference transference NN 35772 1439 26 , , , 35772 1439 27 psychotherapy psychotherapy NN 35772 1439 28 , , , 35772 1439 29 and and CC 35772 1439 30 of of IN 35772 1439 31 so so RB 35772 1439 32 - - HYPH 35772 1439 33 called call VBN 35772 1439 34 " " `` 35772 1439 35 spiritualism spiritualism NN 35772 1439 36 . . . 35772 1439 37 " " '' 35772 1440 1 In in IN 35772 1440 2 none none NN 35772 1440 3 of of IN 35772 1440 4 these these DT 35772 1440 5 spheres sphere NNS 35772 1440 6 can can MD 35772 1440 7 research research VB 35772 1440 8 yet yet RB 35772 1440 9 be be VB 35772 1440 10 said say VBN 35772 1440 11 to to TO 35772 1440 12 have have VB 35772 1440 13 proceeded proceed VBN 35772 1440 14 far far RB 35772 1440 15 enough enough RB 35772 1440 16 to to TO 35772 1440 17 justify justify VB 35772 1440 18 the the DT 35772 1440 19 luxury luxury NN 35772 1440 20 of of IN 35772 1440 21 dogmatising dogmatise VBG 35772 1440 22 over over RP 35772 1440 23 results result NNS 35772 1440 24 . . . 35772 1441 1 Considerable considerable JJ 35772 1441 2 confusion confusion NN 35772 1441 3 of of IN 35772 1441 4 opinion opinion NN 35772 1441 5 may may MD 35772 1441 6 still still RB 35772 1441 7 exist exist VB 35772 1441 8 , , , 35772 1441 9 but but CC 35772 1441 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1441 11 is be VBZ 35772 1441 12 now now RB 35772 1441 13 generally generally RB 35772 1441 14 recognised recognise VBN 35772 1441 15 that that IN 35772 1441 16 there there EX 35772 1441 17 is be VBZ 35772 1441 18 a a DT 35772 1441 19 wide wide JJ 35772 1441 20 sphere sphere NN 35772 1441 21 of of IN 35772 1441 22 research research NN 35772 1441 23 in in IN 35772 1441 24 psychical psychical JJ 35772 1441 25 regions region NNS 35772 1441 26 which which WDT 35772 1441 27 is be VBZ 35772 1441 28 practically practically RB 35772 1441 29 a a DT 35772 1441 30 _ _ NNP 35772 1441 31 terra terra NN 35772 1441 32 incognita incognita NNP 35772 1441 33 _ _ NNP 35772 1441 34 . . . 35772 1442 1 And and CC 35772 1442 2 those those DT 35772 1442 3 most most RBS 35772 1442 4 competent competent JJ 35772 1442 5 to to TO 35772 1442 6 judge judge NN 35772 1442 7 of of IN 35772 1442 8 results result NNS 35772 1442 9 seem seem VBP 35772 1442 10 to to TO 35772 1442 11 be be VB 35772 1442 12 most most RBS 35772 1442 13 cautious cautious JJ 35772 1442 14 in in IN 35772 1442 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1442 16 statements statement NNS 35772 1442 17 . . . 35772 1443 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1443 2 are be VBP 35772 1443 3 in in IN 35772 1443 4 the the DT 35772 1443 5 position position NN 35772 1443 6 of of IN 35772 1443 7 not not RB 35772 1443 8 knowing know VBG 35772 1443 9 what what WP 35772 1443 10 a a DT 35772 1443 11 day day NN 35772 1443 12 may may MD 35772 1443 13 bring bring VB 35772 1443 14 forth forth RB 35772 1443 15 ; ; : 35772 1443 16 and and CC 35772 1443 17 an an DT 35772 1443 18 expectant expectant JJ 35772 1443 19 agnosticism agnosticism NN 35772 1443 20 with with IN 35772 1443 21 regard regard NN 35772 1443 22 to to IN 35772 1443 23 many many JJ 35772 1443 24 problems problem NNS 35772 1443 25 is be VBZ 35772 1443 26 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1443 27 the the DT 35772 1443 28 right right JJ 35772 1443 29 attitude attitude NN 35772 1443 30 to to TO 35772 1443 31 adopt adopt VB 35772 1443 32 . . . 35772 1444 1 The the DT 35772 1444 2 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 1444 3 arrogant arrogant JJ 35772 1444 4 negations negation NNS 35772 1444 5 of of IN 35772 1444 6 the the DT 35772 1444 7 last last JJ 35772 1444 8 generation generation NN 35772 1444 9 are be VBP 35772 1444 10 now now RB 35772 1444 11 out out IN 35772 1444 12 of of IN 35772 1444 13 place place NN 35772 1444 14 ; ; : 35772 1444 15 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1444 16 were be VBD 35772 1444 17 never never RB 35772 1444 18 , , , 35772 1444 19 in in IN 35772 1444 20 the the DT 35772 1444 21 strict strict JJ 35772 1444 22 sense sense NN 35772 1444 23 , , , 35772 1444 24 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1444 25 , , , 35772 1444 26 and and CC 35772 1444 27 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1444 28 are be VBP 35772 1444 29 now now RB 35772 1444 30 demodés demodé NNS 35772 1444 31 . . . 35772 1445 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1445 2 is be VBZ 35772 1445 3 extremely extremely RB 35772 1445 4 difficult difficult JJ 35772 1445 5 to to TO 35772 1445 6 imagine imagine VB 35772 1445 7 a a DT 35772 1445 8 return return NN 35772 1445 9 to to IN 35772 1445 10 the the DT 35772 1445 11 view view NN 35772 1445 12 which which WDT 35772 1445 13 dismisses dismiss VBZ 35772 1445 14 " " `` 35772 1445 15 mind mind NN 35772 1445 16 " " '' 35772 1445 17 from from IN 35772 1445 18 the the DT 35772 1445 19 universe universe NN 35772 1445 20 as as IN 35772 1445 21 being be VBG 35772 1445 22 an an DT 35772 1445 23 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1445 24 by by IN 35772 1445 25 - - HYPH 35772 1445 26 product product NN 35772 1445 27 of of IN 35772 1445 28 matter matter NN 35772 1445 29 , , , 35772 1445 30 or or CC 35772 1445 31 a a DT 35772 1445 32 comparatively comparatively RB 35772 1445 33 insignificant insignificant JJ 35772 1445 34 " " `` 35772 1445 35 epiphenomenon epiphenomenon JJ 35772 1445 36 " " '' 35772 1445 37 accompanying accompany VBG 35772 1445 38 certain certain JJ 35772 1445 39 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1445 40 chemical chemical NN 35772 1445 41 or or CC 35772 1445 42 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1445 43 processes process NNS 35772 1445 44 . . . 35772 1446 1 The the DT 35772 1446 2 old old JJ 35772 1446 3 theories theory NNS 35772 1446 4 , , , 35772 1446 5 gratifying gratify VBG 35772 1446 6 in in IN 35772 1446 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1446 8 simplicity simplicity NN 35772 1446 9 , , , 35772 1446 10 will will MD 35772 1446 11 no no RB 35772 1446 12 longer longer RB 35772 1446 13 cover cover VB 35772 1446 14 the the DT 35772 1446 15 facts fact NNS 35772 1446 16 . . . 35772 1447 1 PSYCHICAL PSYCHICAL NNP 35772 1447 2 RESEARCH.--One RESEARCH.--One VBZ 35772 1447 3 particular particular JJ 35772 1447 4 branch branch NN 35772 1447 5 of of IN 35772 1447 6 experimental experimental JJ 35772 1447 7 psychology psychology NN 35772 1447 8 , , , 35772 1447 9 which which WDT 35772 1447 10 has have VBZ 35772 1447 11 attracted attract VBN 35772 1447 12 a a DT 35772 1447 13 large large JJ 35772 1447 14 measure measure NN 35772 1447 15 of of IN 35772 1447 16 public public JJ 35772 1447 17 attention attention NN 35772 1447 18 , , , 35772 1447 19 calls call VBZ 35772 1447 20 for for IN 35772 1447 21 a a DT 35772 1447 22 few few JJ 35772 1447 23 remarks remark NNS 35772 1447 24 . . . 35772 1448 1 The the DT 35772 1448 2 attempt attempt NN 35772 1448 3 has have VBZ 35772 1448 4 been be VBN 35772 1448 5 made make VBN 35772 1448 6 to to TO 35772 1448 7 give give VB 35772 1448 8 experimental experimental JJ 35772 1448 9 proof proof NN 35772 1448 10 of of IN 35772 1448 11 the the DT 35772 1448 12 existence existence NN 35772 1448 13 of of IN 35772 1448 14 " " `` 35772 1448 15 disembodied disembody VBN 35772 1448 16 spirits spirit NNS 35772 1448 17 , , , 35772 1448 18 " " `` 35772 1448 19 human human JJ 35772 1448 20 or or CC 35772 1448 21 otherwise otherwise RB 35772 1448 22 . . . 35772 1449 1 The the DT 35772 1449 2 whole whole JJ 35772 1449 3 subject subject NN 35772 1449 4 , , , 35772 1449 5 exceptionally exceptionally RB 35772 1449 6 exposed expose VBN 35772 1449 7 as as IN 35772 1449 8 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1449 9 is be VBZ 35772 1449 10 to to IN 35772 1449 11 the the DT 35772 1449 12 influence influence NN 35772 1449 13 of of IN 35772 1449 14 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 1449 15 of of IN 35772 1449 16 various various JJ 35772 1449 17 kinds kind NNS 35772 1449 18 , , , 35772 1449 19 requires require VBZ 35772 1449 20 to to TO 35772 1449 21 be be VB 35772 1449 22 treated treat VBN 35772 1449 23 with with IN 35772 1449 24 great great JJ 35772 1449 25 caution caution NN 35772 1449 26 , , , 35772 1449 27 and and CC 35772 1449 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1449 29 is be VBZ 35772 1449 30 inadvisable inadvisable JJ 35772 1449 31 , , , 35772 1449 32 in in IN 35772 1449 33 the the DT 35772 1449 34 present present JJ 35772 1449 35 condition condition NN 35772 1449 36 of of IN 35772 1449 37 the the DT 35772 1449 38 problem problem NN 35772 1449 39 , , , 35772 1449 40 to to TO 35772 1449 41 make make VB 35772 1449 42 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1449 43 statements statement NNS 35772 1449 44 in in IN 35772 1449 45 any any DT 35772 1449 46 direction direction NN 35772 1449 47 . . . 35772 1450 1 What what WP 35772 1450 2 appears appear VBZ 35772 1450 3 to to TO 35772 1450 4 be be VB 35772 1450 5 certain certain JJ 35772 1450 6 is be VBZ 35772 1450 7 that that IN 35772 1450 8 the the DT 35772 1450 9 occurrence occurrence NN 35772 1450 10 is be VBZ 35772 1450 11 well well RB 35772 1450 12 established establish VBN 35772 1450 13 of of IN 35772 1450 14 various various JJ 35772 1450 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1450 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1450 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1450 18 which which WDT 35772 1450 19 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1450 20 is be VBZ 35772 1450 21 extremely extremely RB 35772 1450 22 difficult difficult JJ 35772 1450 23 to to TO 35772 1450 24 explain explain VB 35772 1450 25 in in IN 35772 1450 26 accordance accordance NN 35772 1450 27 with with IN 35772 1450 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1450 29 present present JJ 35772 1450 30 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1450 31 of of IN 35772 1450 32 matter matter NN 35772 1450 33 , , , 35772 1450 34 of of IN 35772 1450 35 space space NN 35772 1450 36 , , , 35772 1450 37 or or CC 35772 1450 38 of of IN 35772 1450 39 mental mental JJ 35772 1450 40 action action NN 35772 1450 41 . . . 35772 1451 1 The the DT 35772 1451 2 occurrence occurrence NN 35772 1451 3 of of IN 35772 1451 4 such such JJ 35772 1451 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1451 6 is be VBZ 35772 1451 7 no no RB 35772 1451 8 longer long RBR 35772 1451 9 disputed dispute VBN 35772 1451 10 ; ; : 35772 1451 11 but but CC 35772 1451 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1451 13 is be VBZ 35772 1451 14 over over IN 35772 1451 15 the the DT 35772 1451 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1451 17 explanation explanation NN 35772 1451 18 _ _ XX 35772 1451 19 of of IN 35772 1451 20 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1451 21 that that WDT 35772 1451 22 controversy controversy NN 35772 1451 23 is be VBZ 35772 1451 24 active active JJ 35772 1451 25 . . . 35772 1452 1 And and CC 35772 1452 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1452 3 seems seem VBZ 35772 1452 4 quite quite RB 35772 1452 5 certain certain JJ 35772 1452 6 that that IN 35772 1452 7 the the DT 35772 1452 8 very very RB 35772 1452 9 least least JJS 35772 1452 10 in in IN 35772 1452 11 the the DT 35772 1452 12 way way NN 35772 1452 13 of of IN 35772 1452 14 concessions concession NNS 35772 1452 15 that that WDT 35772 1452 16 these these DT 35772 1452 17 new new JJ 35772 1452 18 facts fact NNS 35772 1452 19 will will MD 35772 1452 20 force force VB 35772 1452 21 from from IN 35772 1452 22 conservative conservative JJ 35772 1452 23 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1452 24 is be VBZ 35772 1452 25 _ _ NNP 35772 1452 26 a a DT 35772 1452 27 radical radical JJ 35772 1452 28 revision revision NN 35772 1452 29 of of IN 35772 1452 30 current current JJ 35772 1452 31 notions notion NNS 35772 1452 32 of of IN 35772 1452 33 the the DT 35772 1452 34 range range NN 35772 1452 35 of of IN 35772 1452 36 human human JJ 35772 1452 37 mental mental JJ 35772 1452 38 action action NN 35772 1452 39 _ _ NNP 35772 1452 40 . . . 35772 1453 1 The the DT 35772 1453 2 mind mind NN 35772 1453 3 is be VBZ 35772 1453 4 evidently evidently RB 35772 1453 5 capable capable JJ 35772 1453 6 of of IN 35772 1453 7 producing produce VBG 35772 1453 8 certain certain JJ 35772 1453 9 effects effect NNS 35772 1453 10 -- -- : 35772 1453 11 even even RB 35772 1453 12 upon upon IN 35772 1453 13 matter matter NN 35772 1453 14 -- -- : 35772 1453 15 which which WDT 35772 1453 16 would would MD 35772 1453 17 have have VB 35772 1453 18 seemed seem VBN 35772 1453 19 incredible incredible JJ 35772 1453 20 a a DT 35772 1453 21 short short JJ 35772 1453 22 while while NN 35772 1453 23 ago ago RB 35772 1453 24 . . . 35772 1454 1 So so RB 35772 1454 2 much much JJ 35772 1454 3 is be VBZ 35772 1454 4 the the DT 35772 1454 5 least least JJS 35772 1454 6 that that WDT 35772 1454 7 may may MD 35772 1454 8 be be VB 35772 1454 9 expected expect VBN 35772 1454 10 . . . 35772 1455 1 But but CC 35772 1455 2 in in IN 35772 1455 3 the the DT 35772 1455 4 view view NN 35772 1455 5 of of IN 35772 1455 6 many many JJ 35772 1455 7 competent competent JJ 35772 1455 8 and and CC 35772 1455 9 highly highly RB 35772 1455 10 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1455 11 observers observer NNS 35772 1455 12 , , , 35772 1455 13 some some DT 35772 1455 14 far far RB 35772 1455 15 more more RBR 35772 1455 16 radical radical JJ 35772 1455 17 revision revision NN 35772 1455 18 of of IN 35772 1455 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1455 20 notions notion NNS 35772 1455 21 may may MD 35772 1455 22 be be VB 35772 1455 23 necessary necessary JJ 35772 1455 24 . . . 35772 1456 1 Some some DT 35772 1456 2 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1456 3 of of IN 35772 1456 4 good good JJ 35772 1456 5 repute repute NN 35772 1456 6 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1456 7 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 1457 1 Sir Sir NNP 35772 1457 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 35772 1457 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 35772 1457 4 , , , 35772 1457 5 in in IN 35772 1457 6 England England NNP 35772 1457 7 , , , 35772 1457 8 and and CC 35772 1457 9 Flammarion Flammarion NNP 35772 1457 10 and and CC 35772 1457 11 others other NNS 35772 1457 12 on on IN 35772 1457 13 the the DT 35772 1457 14 Continent continent NN 35772 1457 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1457 16 are be VBP 35772 1457 17 convinced convince VBN 35772 1457 18 that that IN 35772 1457 19 the the DT 35772 1457 20 facts fact NNS 35772 1457 21 can can MD 35772 1457 22 only only RB 35772 1457 23 adequately adequately RB 35772 1457 24 be be VB 35772 1457 25 explained explain VBN 35772 1457 26 by by IN 35772 1457 27 reference reference NN 35772 1457 28 to to IN 35772 1457 29 another another DT 35772 1457 30 world world NN 35772 1457 31 -- -- : 35772 1457 32 interlocked interlock VBN 35772 1457 33 , , , 35772 1457 34 as as IN 35772 1457 35 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1457 36 were be VBD 35772 1457 37 , , , 35772 1457 38 with with IN 35772 1457 39 this this DT 35772 1457 40 . . . 35772 1458 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1458 2 75 75 CD 35772 1458 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1458 4 And and CC 35772 1458 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1458 6 has have VBZ 35772 1458 7 to to TO 35772 1458 8 be be VB 35772 1458 9 admitted admit VBN 35772 1458 10 that that IN 35772 1458 11 this this DT 35772 1458 12 , , , 35772 1458 13 what what WP 35772 1458 14 may may MD 35772 1458 15 be be VB 35772 1458 16 called call VBN 35772 1458 17 more more RBR 35772 1458 18 " " `` 35772 1458 19 advanced advanced JJ 35772 1458 20 " " '' 35772 1458 21 explanation explanation NN 35772 1458 22 , , , 35772 1458 23 is be VBZ 35772 1458 24 more more JJR 35772 1458 25 in in IN 35772 1458 26 accordance accordance NN 35772 1458 27 than than IN 35772 1458 28 the the DT 35772 1458 29 other other JJ 35772 1458 30 with with IN 35772 1458 31 a a DT 35772 1458 32 rather rather RB 35772 1458 33 universal universal JJ 35772 1458 34 tradition tradition NN 35772 1458 35 or or CC 35772 1458 36 assumption assumption NN 35772 1458 37 of of IN 35772 1458 38 mankind mankind NN 35772 1458 39 in in IN 35772 1458 40 all all DT 35772 1458 41 ages age NNS 35772 1458 42 . . . 35772 1459 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1459 2 will will MD 35772 1459 3 be be VB 35772 1459 4 easily easily RB 35772 1459 5 seen see VBN 35772 1459 6 that that IN 35772 1459 7 the the DT 35772 1459 8 whole whole JJ 35772 1459 9 subject subject NN 35772 1459 10 is be VBZ 35772 1459 11 one one CD 35772 1459 12 of of IN 35772 1459 13 the the DT 35772 1459 14 most most RBS 35772 1459 15 extreme extreme JJ 35772 1459 16 difficulty difficulty NN 35772 1459 17 . . . 35772 1460 1 There there EX 35772 1460 2 is be VBZ 35772 1460 3 a a DT 35772 1460 4 general general JJ 35772 1460 5 hesitancy hesitancy NN 35772 1460 6 in in IN 35772 1460 7 accepting accept VBG 35772 1460 8 what what WP 35772 1460 9 is be VBZ 35772 1460 10 called call VBN 35772 1460 11 the the DT 35772 1460 12 " " `` 35772 1460 13 spirit spirit NN 35772 1460 14 hypothesis hypothesis NN 35772 1460 15 , , , 35772 1460 16 " " '' 35772 1460 17 so so RB 35772 1460 18 long long RB 35772 1460 19 as as IN 35772 1460 20 any any DT 35772 1460 21 other other JJ 35772 1460 22 can can MD 35772 1460 23 be be VB 35772 1460 24 found find VBN 35772 1460 25 ; ; : 35772 1460 26 a a DT 35772 1460 27 hesitancy hesitancy NN 35772 1460 28 justified justify VBN 35772 1460 29 in in IN 35772 1460 30 view view NN 35772 1460 31 of of IN 35772 1460 32 the the DT 35772 1460 33 extreme extreme JJ 35772 1460 34 complexity complexity NN 35772 1460 35 of of IN 35772 1460 36 the the DT 35772 1460 37 world world NN 35772 1460 38 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1460 39 live live VBP 35772 1460 40 in in IN 35772 1460 41 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1460 42 where where WRB 35772 1460 43 so so RB 35772 1460 44 much much JJ 35772 1460 45 is be VBZ 35772 1460 46 even even RB 35772 1460 47 yet yet RB 35772 1460 48 unknown unknown JJ 35772 1460 49 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1460 50 , , , 35772 1460 51 and and CC 35772 1460 52 in in IN 35772 1460 53 view view NN 35772 1460 54 of of IN 35772 1460 55 the the DT 35772 1460 56 great great JJ 35772 1460 57 difficulty difficulty NN 35772 1460 58 which which WDT 35772 1460 59 there there EX 35772 1460 60 seems seem VBZ 35772 1460 61 to to TO 35772 1460 62 be be VB 35772 1460 63 in in IN 35772 1460 64 adducing adduce VBG 35772 1460 65 _ _ NNP 35772 1460 66 exact exact JJ 35772 1460 67 _ _ NNP 35772 1460 68 proofs proof NNS 35772 1460 69 of of IN 35772 1460 70 the the DT 35772 1460 71 " " `` 35772 1460 72 spirit spirit NN 35772 1460 73 theory theory NN 35772 1460 74 . . . 35772 1460 75 " " '' 35772 1461 1 A a DT 35772 1461 2 REASONABLE REASONABLE NNP 35772 1461 3 ATTITUDE.--We ATTITUDE.--We NNP 35772 1461 4 shall shall NN 35772 1461 5 , , , 35772 1461 6 no no RB 35772 1461 7 doubt doubt RB 35772 1461 8 , , , 35772 1461 9 be be VB 35772 1461 10 wise wise JJ 35772 1461 11 at at IN 35772 1461 12 present present NN 35772 1461 13 to to TO 35772 1461 14 refuse refuse VB 35772 1461 15 to to TO 35772 1461 16 cry cry VB 35772 1461 17 " " `` 35772 1461 18 Proven prove VBN 35772 1461 19 , , , 35772 1461 20 " " '' 35772 1461 21 and and CC 35772 1461 22 whilst whilst IN 35772 1461 23 admitting admit VBG 35772 1461 24 that that IN 35772 1461 25 all all DT 35772 1461 26 things thing NNS 35772 1461 27 are be VBP 35772 1461 28 possible possible JJ 35772 1461 29 -- -- : 35772 1461 30 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1461 31 even even RB 35772 1461 32 probable probable JJ 35772 1461 33 -- -- : 35772 1461 34 to to TO 35772 1461 35 await await VB 35772 1461 36 with with IN 35772 1461 37 patience patience NN 35772 1461 38 the the DT 35772 1461 39 results result NNS 35772 1461 40 of of IN 35772 1461 41 further further JJ 35772 1461 42 investigation investigation NN 35772 1461 43 . . . 35772 1462 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1462 2 has have VBZ 35772 1462 3 to to TO 35772 1462 4 be be VB 35772 1462 5 admitted admit VBN 35772 1462 6 that that IN 35772 1462 7 , , , 35772 1462 8 while while IN 35772 1462 9 many many JJ 35772 1462 10 people people NNS 35772 1462 11 are be VBP 35772 1462 12 superstitious superstitious JJ 35772 1462 13 and and CC 35772 1462 14 easily easily RB 35772 1462 15 attracted attract VBN 35772 1462 16 by by IN 35772 1462 17 picturesque picturesque NN 35772 1462 18 theories theory NNS 35772 1462 19 , , , 35772 1462 20 there there EX 35772 1462 21 are be VBP 35772 1462 22 others other NNS 35772 1462 23 who who WP 35772 1462 24 are be VBP 35772 1462 25 as as RB 35772 1462 26 prejudiced prejudiced JJ 35772 1462 27 , , , 35772 1462 28 in in IN 35772 1462 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1462 30 way way NN 35772 1462 31 , , , 35772 1462 32 against against IN 35772 1462 33 new new JJ 35772 1462 34 ideas idea NNS 35772 1462 35 , , , 35772 1462 36 as as IN 35772 1462 37 were be VBD 35772 1462 38 those those DT 35772 1462 39 astronomers astronomer NNS 35772 1462 40 who who WP 35772 1462 41 , , , 35772 1462 42 being be VBG 35772 1462 43 committed commit VBN 35772 1462 44 to to IN 35772 1462 45 Ptolemaic Ptolemaic NNP 35772 1462 46 views view NNS 35772 1462 47 , , , 35772 1462 48 refused refuse VBD 35772 1462 49 to to TO 35772 1462 50 look look VB 35772 1462 51 through through IN 35772 1462 52 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 1462 53 's 's POS 35772 1462 54 telescope telescope NN 35772 1462 55 . . . 35772 1463 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1463 2 is be VBZ 35772 1463 3 not not RB 35772 1463 4 only only RB 35772 1463 5 theologians theologian NNS 35772 1463 6 who who WP 35772 1463 7 have have VBP 35772 1463 8 , , , 35772 1463 9 in in IN 35772 1463 10 the the DT 35772 1463 11 history history NN 35772 1463 12 of of IN 35772 1463 13 thought thought NN 35772 1463 14 , , , 35772 1463 15 been be VBN 35772 1463 16 guilty guilty JJ 35772 1463 17 of of IN 35772 1463 18 obscurantism obscurantism NN 35772 1463 19 . . . 35772 1464 1 In in IN 35772 1464 2 the the DT 35772 1464 3 early early JJ 35772 1464 4 days day NNS 35772 1464 5 of of IN 35772 1464 6 hypnotic hypnotic JJ 35772 1464 7 experiments experiment NNS 35772 1464 8 the the DT 35772 1464 9 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1464 10 world world NN 35772 1464 11 in in IN 35772 1464 12 general general JJ 35772 1464 13 " " `` 35772 1464 14 pooh pooh NNP 35772 1464 15 - - HYPH 35772 1464 16 poohed poohe VBN 35772 1464 17 " " `` 35772 1464 18 the the DT 35772 1464 19 idea idea NN 35772 1464 20 of of IN 35772 1464 21 hypnotism hypnotism NN 35772 1464 22 ; ; : 35772 1464 23 and and CC 35772 1464 24 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1464 25 took take VBD 35772 1464 26 a a DT 35772 1464 27 considerable considerable JJ 35772 1464 28 time time NN 35772 1464 29 before before IN 35772 1464 30 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1464 31 would would MD 35772 1464 32 allow allow VB 35772 1464 33 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1464 34 to to TO 35772 1464 35 be be VB 35772 1464 36 convinced convince VBN 35772 1464 37 that that IN 35772 1464 38 such such PDT 35772 1464 39 a a DT 35772 1464 40 thing thing NN 35772 1464 41 was be VBD 35772 1464 42 possible possible JJ 35772 1464 43 . . . 35772 1465 1 Facts fact NNS 35772 1465 2 , , , 35772 1465 3 in in IN 35772 1465 4 the the DT 35772 1465 5 end end NN 35772 1465 6 , , , 35772 1465 7 were be VBD 35772 1465 8 too too RB 35772 1465 9 strong strong JJ 35772 1465 10 even even RB 35772 1465 11 for for IN 35772 1465 12 prejudice prejudice NN 35772 1465 13 . . . 35772 1466 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1466 2 is be VBZ 35772 1466 3 facts fact NNS 35772 1466 4 , , , 35772 1466 5 eventually eventually RB 35772 1466 6 , , , 35772 1466 7 that that WDT 35772 1466 8 decide decide VB 35772 1466 9 matters matter NNS 35772 1466 10 ; ; : 35772 1466 11 and and CC 35772 1466 12 , , , 35772 1466 13 no no RB 35772 1466 14 doubt doubt RB 35772 1466 15 , , , 35772 1466 16 before before IN 35772 1466 17 a a DT 35772 1466 18 very very RB 35772 1466 19 long long JJ 35772 1466 20 period period NN 35772 1466 21 has have VBZ 35772 1466 22 elapsed elapse VBN 35772 1466 23 , , , 35772 1466 24 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 1466 25 facts fact NNS 35772 1466 26 will will MD 35772 1466 27 have have VB 35772 1466 28 accumulated accumulate VBN 35772 1466 29 to to TO 35772 1466 30 allow allow VB 35772 1466 31 the the DT 35772 1466 32 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1466 33 world world NN 35772 1466 34 to to TO 35772 1466 35 form form VB 35772 1466 36 more more RBR 35772 1466 37 definite definite JJ 35772 1466 38 and and CC 35772 1466 39 better well JJR 35772 1466 40 - - HYPH 35772 1466 41 grounded ground VBN 35772 1466 42 opinions opinion NNS 35772 1466 43 than than IN 35772 1466 44 are be VBP 35772 1466 45 possible possible JJ 35772 1466 46 to to IN 35772 1466 47 - - HYPH 35772 1466 48 day day NN 35772 1466 49 . . . 35772 1467 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 35772 1467 2 , , , 35772 1467 3 the the DT 35772 1467 4 ordinary ordinary JJ 35772 1467 5 man man NN 35772 1467 6 will will MD 35772 1467 7 do do VB 35772 1467 8 well well RB 35772 1467 9 to to TO 35772 1467 10 remember remember VB 35772 1467 11 that that IN 35772 1467 12 the the DT 35772 1467 13 universe universe NN 35772 1467 14 is be VBZ 35772 1467 15 really really RB 35772 1467 16 a a DT 35772 1467 17 very very RB 35772 1467 18 wonderful wonderful JJ 35772 1467 19 place place NN 35772 1467 20 , , , 35772 1467 21 and and CC 35772 1467 22 that that IN 35772 1467 23 the the DT 35772 1467 24 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1467 25 of of IN 35772 1467 26 the the DT 35772 1467 27 wisest wise JJS 35772 1467 28 of of IN 35772 1467 29 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1467 30 about about IN 35772 1467 31 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1467 32 can can MD 35772 1467 33 only only RB 35772 1467 34 be be VB 35772 1467 35 described describe VBN 35772 1467 36 as as IN 35772 1467 37 infinitesimal infinitesimal JJ 35772 1467 38 . . . 35772 1468 1 The the DT 35772 1468 2 traditions tradition NNS 35772 1468 3 of of IN 35772 1468 4 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1468 5 - - HYPH 35772 1468 6 century century NN 35772 1468 7 materialism materialism NN 35772 1468 8 are be VBP 35772 1468 9 still still RB 35772 1468 10 strong strong JJ 35772 1468 11 amongst amongst IN 35772 1468 12 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1468 13 , , , 35772 1468 14 even even RB 35772 1468 15 with with IN 35772 1468 16 those those DT 35772 1468 17 who who WP 35772 1468 18 are be VBP 35772 1468 19 least least JJS 35772 1468 20 conscious conscious JJ 35772 1468 21 of of IN 35772 1468 22 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1468 23 . . . 35772 1469 1 But but CC 35772 1469 2 there there EX 35772 1469 3 are be VBP 35772 1469 4 more more JJR 35772 1469 5 things thing NNS 35772 1469 6 in in IN 35772 1469 7 heaven heaven NNP 35772 1469 8 and and CC 35772 1469 9 earth earth NN 35772 1469 10 than than IN 35772 1469 11 are be VBP 35772 1469 12 dreamt dreamt NN 35772 1469 13 of of IN 35772 1469 14 in in IN 35772 1469 15 that that DT 35772 1469 16 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1469 17 . . . 35772 1470 1 RESULTS.--These results.--these JJ 35772 1470 2 new new JJ 35772 1470 3 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1470 4 of of IN 35772 1470 5 matter matter NN 35772 1470 6 , , , 35772 1470 7 of of IN 35772 1470 8 life life NN 35772 1470 9 , , , 35772 1470 10 and and CC 35772 1470 11 of of IN 35772 1470 12 mind mind NN 35772 1470 13 , , , 35772 1470 14 which which WDT 35772 1470 15 are be VBP 35772 1470 16 the the DT 35772 1470 17 products product NNS 35772 1470 18 of of IN 35772 1470 19 the the DT 35772 1470 20 new new JJ 35772 1470 21 physics physics NN 35772 1470 22 , , , 35772 1470 23 the the DT 35772 1470 24 new new JJ 35772 1470 25 biology biology NN 35772 1470 26 , , , 35772 1470 27 and and CC 35772 1470 28 the the DT 35772 1470 29 new new JJ 35772 1470 30 psychology psychology NN 35772 1470 31 respectively respectively RB 35772 1470 32 , , , 35772 1470 33 may may MD 35772 1470 34 be be VB 35772 1470 35 confidently confidently RB 35772 1470 36 left leave VBN 35772 1470 37 to to IN 35772 1470 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1470 39 to to TO 35772 1470 40 work work VB 35772 1470 41 out out RP 35772 1470 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1470 43 own own JJ 35772 1470 44 salvation salvation NN 35772 1470 45 . . . 35772 1471 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1471 2 have have VBP 35772 1471 3 the the DT 35772 1471 4 strength strength NN 35772 1471 5 of of IN 35772 1471 6 youth youth NN 35772 1471 7 . . . 35772 1472 1 What what WP 35772 1472 2 is be VBZ 35772 1472 3 evident evident JJ 35772 1472 4 is be VBZ 35772 1472 5 that that IN 35772 1472 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1472 7 have have VBP 35772 1472 8 crossed cross VBN 35772 1472 9 the the DT 35772 1472 10 threshold threshold NN 35772 1472 11 of of IN 35772 1472 12 a a DT 35772 1472 13 new new JJ 35772 1472 14 era era NN 35772 1472 15 in in IN 35772 1472 16 the the DT 35772 1472 17 history history NN 35772 1472 18 of of IN 35772 1472 19 science science NN 35772 1472 20 . . . 35772 1473 1 The the DT 35772 1473 2 outlook outlook NN 35772 1473 3 of of IN 35772 1473 4 the the DT 35772 1473 5 future future NN 35772 1473 6 will will MD 35772 1473 7 be be VB 35772 1473 8 as as RB 35772 1473 9 different different JJ 35772 1473 10 from from IN 35772 1473 11 that that DT 35772 1473 12 of of IN 35772 1473 13 the the DT 35772 1473 14 recent recent JJ 35772 1473 15 past past NN 35772 1473 16 as as IN 35772 1473 17 was be VBD 35772 1473 18 the the DT 35772 1473 19 new new JJ 35772 1473 20 science science NN 35772 1473 21 of of IN 35772 1473 22 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 1473 23 , , , 35772 1473 24 Descartes Descartes NNPS 35772 1473 25 , , , 35772 1473 26 and and CC 35772 1473 27 Newton Newton NNP 35772 1473 28 from from IN 35772 1473 29 the the DT 35772 1473 30 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 35772 1473 31 but but CC 35772 1473 32 fanciful fanciful JJ 35772 1473 33 notions notion NNS 35772 1473 34 which which WDT 35772 1473 35 the the DT 35772 1473 36 Scholastic scholastic JJ 35772 1473 37 theologians theologian NNS 35772 1473 38 had have VBD 35772 1473 39 borrowed borrow VBN 35772 1473 40 from from IN 35772 1473 41 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 35772 1473 42 , , , 35772 1473 43 and and CC 35772 1473 44 sought seek VBD 35772 1473 45 to to TO 35772 1473 46 impose impose VB 35772 1473 47 as as IN 35772 1473 48 a a DT 35772 1473 49 permanent permanent JJ 35772 1473 50 revelation revelation NN 35772 1473 51 . . . 35772 1474 1 The the DT 35772 1474 2 current current NN 35772 1474 3 of of IN 35772 1474 4 thought thought NN 35772 1474 5 is be VBZ 35772 1474 6 never never RB 35772 1474 7 stayed stay VBN 35772 1474 8 . . . 35772 1475 1 The the DT 35772 1475 2 future future NN 35772 1475 3 is be VBZ 35772 1475 4 obscure obscure JJ 35772 1475 5 , , , 35772 1475 6 but but CC 35772 1475 7 one one CD 35772 1475 8 thing thing NN 35772 1475 9 is be VBZ 35772 1475 10 certain certain JJ 35772 1475 11 , , , 35772 1475 12 that that IN 35772 1475 13 the the DT 35772 1475 14 coming come VBG 35772 1475 15 generations generation NNS 35772 1475 16 will will MD 35772 1475 17 see see VB 35772 1475 18 catastrophic catastrophic JJ 35772 1475 19 changes change NNS 35772 1475 20 in in IN 35772 1475 21 the the DT 35772 1475 22 outlook outlook NN 35772 1475 23 of of IN 35772 1475 24 science science NN 35772 1475 25 ; ; : 35772 1475 26 and and CC 35772 1475 27 the the DT 35772 1475 28 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 1475 29 and and CC 35772 1475 30 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1475 31 _ _ NNP 35772 1475 32 weltanschauung weltanschauung VBD 35772 1475 33 _ _ NNP 35772 1475 34 , , , 35772 1475 35 which which WDT 35772 1475 36 lately lately RB 35772 1475 37 seemed seem VBD 35772 1475 38 so so RB 35772 1475 39 formidable formidable JJ 35772 1475 40 , , , 35772 1475 41 may may MD 35772 1475 42 soon soon RB 35772 1475 43 become become VB 35772 1475 44 as as RB 35772 1475 45 superannuated superannuated JJ 35772 1475 46 as as IN 35772 1475 47 astrology astrology NN 35772 1475 48 . . . 35772 1476 1 The the DT 35772 1476 2 theory theory NN 35772 1476 3 which which WDT 35772 1476 4 overshadowed overshadow VBD 35772 1476 5 the the DT 35772 1476 6 religious religious JJ 35772 1476 7 life life NN 35772 1476 8 of of IN 35772 1476 9 a a DT 35772 1476 10 century century NN 35772 1476 11 , , , 35772 1476 12 and and CC 35772 1476 13 which which WDT 35772 1476 14 had have VBD 35772 1476 15 become become VBN 35772 1476 16 more more RBR 35772 1476 17 and and CC 35772 1476 18 more more RBR 35772 1476 19 menacing menacing JJ 35772 1476 20 as as IN 35772 1476 21 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1476 22 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1476 23 increased increase VBD 35772 1476 24 in in IN 35772 1476 25 extent extent NN 35772 1476 26 and and CC 35772 1476 27 popularity popularity NN 35772 1476 28 , , , 35772 1476 29 has have VBZ 35772 1476 30 fallen fall VBN 35772 1476 31 into into IN 35772 1476 32 discredit discredit NN 35772 1476 33 . . . 35772 1477 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1477 2 prestige prestige NN 35772 1477 3 will will MD 35772 1477 4 not not RB 35772 1477 5 revive revive VB 35772 1477 6 . . . 35772 1478 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 35772 1478 2 XIII XIII NNP 35772 1478 3 SOME some NN 35772 1478 4 FINAL final JJ 35772 1478 5 CONSIDERATIONS considerations NN 35772 1478 6 VALUE value NN 35772 1478 7 OF of IN 35772 1478 8 THE the DT 35772 1478 9 HISTORY HISTORY NNP 35772 1478 10 OF of IN 35772 1478 11 PHILOSOPHY.--It PHILOSOPHY.--It NNP 35772 1478 12 may may MD 35772 1478 13 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1478 14 be be VB 35772 1478 15 felt feel VBN 35772 1478 16 that that IN 35772 1478 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1478 18 protracted protract VBN 35772 1478 19 excursion excursion NN 35772 1478 20 has have VBZ 35772 1478 21 not not RB 35772 1478 22 advanced advance VBN 35772 1478 23 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1478 24 far far RB 35772 1478 25 beyond beyond IN 35772 1478 26 the the DT 35772 1478 27 position position NN 35772 1478 28 at at IN 35772 1478 29 which which WDT 35772 1478 30 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1478 31 stood stand VBD 35772 1478 32 in in IN 35772 1478 33 the the DT 35772 1478 34 opening opening NN 35772 1478 35 chapter chapter NN 35772 1478 36 . . . 35772 1479 1 Indeed indeed RB 35772 1479 2 , , , 35772 1479 3 the the DT 35772 1479 4 history history NN 35772 1479 5 of of IN 35772 1479 6 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1479 7 may may MD 35772 1479 8 seem seem VB 35772 1479 9 not not RB 35772 1479 10 to to TO 35772 1479 11 establish establish VB 35772 1479 12 any any DT 35772 1479 13 very very RB 35772 1479 14 definite definite JJ 35772 1479 15 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1479 16 ; ; : 35772 1479 17 and and CC 35772 1479 18 those those DT 35772 1479 19 who who WP 35772 1479 20 study study VBP 35772 1479 21 the the DT 35772 1479 22 subject subject NN 35772 1479 23 in in IN 35772 1479 24 the the DT 35772 1479 25 hope hope NN 35772 1479 26 that that IN 35772 1479 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1479 28 will will MD 35772 1479 29 supply supply VB 35772 1479 30 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1479 31 with with IN 35772 1479 32 material material NN 35772 1479 33 for for IN 35772 1479 34 dogmatising dogmatising NN 35772 1479 35 are be VBP 35772 1479 36 likely likely JJ 35772 1479 37 to to TO 35772 1479 38 be be VB 35772 1479 39 disappointed disappoint VBN 35772 1479 40 . . . 35772 1480 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1480 2 have have VBP 35772 1480 3 to to TO 35772 1480 4 reconcile reconcile VB 35772 1480 5 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1480 6 to to IN 35772 1480 7 the the DT 35772 1480 8 fact fact NN 35772 1480 9 that that IN 35772 1480 10 the the DT 35772 1480 11 riddle riddle NN 35772 1480 12 of of IN 35772 1480 13 the the DT 35772 1480 14 universe universe NN 35772 1480 15 has have VBZ 35772 1480 16 as as RB 35772 1480 17 yet yet RB 35772 1480 18 received receive VBN 35772 1480 19 no no DT 35772 1480 20 final final JJ 35772 1480 21 solution solution NN 35772 1480 22 at at IN 35772 1480 23 the the DT 35772 1480 24 hands hand NNS 35772 1480 25 of of IN 35772 1480 26 the the DT 35772 1480 27 metaphysicians metaphysicians NNPS 35772 1480 28 . . . 35772 1481 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1481 2 is be VBZ 35772 1481 3 only only RB 35772 1481 4 too too RB 35772 1481 5 evident evident JJ 35772 1481 6 that that IN 35772 1481 7 , , , 35772 1481 8 as as IN 35772 1481 9 the the DT 35772 1481 10 poet poet NN 35772 1481 11 says say VBZ 35772 1481 12 : : : 35772 1481 13 " " `` 35772 1481 14 Our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1481 15 little little JJ 35772 1481 16 systems system NNS 35772 1481 17 have have VBP 35772 1481 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1481 19 day day NN 35772 1481 20 , , , 35772 1481 21 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1481 22 have have VBP 35772 1481 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1481 24 day day NN 35772 1481 25 , , , 35772 1481 26 and and CC 35772 1481 27 cease cease VB 35772 1481 28 to to TO 35772 1481 29 be be VB 35772 1481 30 . . . 35772 1481 31 " " '' 35772 1482 1 And and CC 35772 1482 2 yet yet RB 35772 1482 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1482 4 would would MD 35772 1482 5 be be VB 35772 1482 6 an an DT 35772 1482 7 error error NN 35772 1482 8 to to TO 35772 1482 9 suppose suppose VB 35772 1482 10 that that IN 35772 1482 11 this this DT 35772 1482 12 lack lack NN 35772 1482 13 of of IN 35772 1482 14 finality finality NN 35772 1482 15 about about IN 35772 1482 16 philosophical philosophical JJ 35772 1482 17 opinion opinion NN 35772 1482 18 , , , 35772 1482 19 or or CC 35772 1482 20 the the DT 35772 1482 21 want want NN 35772 1482 22 of of IN 35772 1482 23 unanimity unanimity NN 35772 1482 24 among among IN 35772 1482 25 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1482 26 , , , 35772 1482 27 indicates indicate VBZ 35772 1482 28 that that IN 35772 1482 29 no no DT 35772 1482 30 progress progress NN 35772 1482 31 has have VBZ 35772 1482 32 been be VBN 35772 1482 33 made make VBN 35772 1482 34 . . . 35772 1483 1 There there EX 35772 1483 2 are be VBP 35772 1483 3 certain certain JJ 35772 1483 4 landmarks landmark NNS 35772 1483 5 in in IN 35772 1483 6 the the DT 35772 1483 7 history history NN 35772 1483 8 of of IN 35772 1483 9 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1483 10 -- -- : 35772 1483 11 such such JJ 35772 1483 12 as as IN 35772 1483 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1483 14 's 's POS 35772 1483 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1483 16 Critique Critique NNP 35772 1483 17 of of IN 35772 1483 18 Pure Pure NNP 35772 1483 19 Reason_--which reason_--which NN 35772 1483 20 mark mark VBP 35772 1483 21 a a DT 35772 1483 22 point point NN 35772 1483 23 behind behind IN 35772 1483 24 which which WDT 35772 1483 25 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1483 26 shall shall MD 35772 1483 27 not not RB 35772 1483 28 again again RB 35772 1483 29 regress regress JJ 35772 1483 30 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1483 31 assuming assume VBG 35772 1483 32 that that IN 35772 1483 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1483 34 culture culture NN 35772 1483 35 and and CC 35772 1483 36 civilisation civilisation NN 35772 1483 37 is be VBZ 35772 1483 38 preserved preserve VBN 35772 1483 39 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1483 40 . . . 35772 1484 1 Even even RB 35772 1484 2 if if IN 35772 1484 3 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1484 4 have have VBP 35772 1484 5 not not RB 35772 1484 6 grasped grasp VBN 35772 1484 7 the the DT 35772 1484 8 whole whole JJ 35772 1484 9 truth truth NN 35772 1484 10 about about IN 35772 1484 11 things thing NNS 35772 1484 12 yet yet RB 35772 1484 13 , , , 35772 1484 14 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1484 15 are be VBP 35772 1484 16 still still RB 35772 1484 17 justified justify VBN 35772 1484 18 in in IN 35772 1484 19 assuming assume VBG 35772 1484 20 that that IN 35772 1484 21 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1484 22 are be VBP 35772 1484 23 gradually gradually RB 35772 1484 24 , , , 35772 1484 25 if if IN 35772 1484 26 painfully painfully RB 35772 1484 27 , , , 35772 1484 28 getting get VBG 35772 1484 29 nearer nearer NN 35772 1484 30 to to IN 35772 1484 31 the the DT 35772 1484 32 goal goal NN 35772 1484 33 . . . 35772 1485 1 But but CC 35772 1485 2 surely surely RB 35772 1485 3 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1485 4 are be VBP 35772 1485 5 entitled entitle VBN 35772 1485 6 to to TO 35772 1485 7 believe believe VB 35772 1485 8 that that IN 35772 1485 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1485 10 is be VBZ 35772 1485 11 not not RB 35772 1485 12 the the DT 35772 1485 13 crude crude JJ 35772 1485 14 appetite appetite NN 35772 1485 15 for for IN 35772 1485 16 metaphysical metaphysical JJ 35772 1485 17 dogma dogma NN 35772 1485 18 that that WDT 35772 1485 19 attracts attract VBZ 35772 1485 20 men man NNS 35772 1485 21 to to IN 35772 1485 22 the the DT 35772 1485 23 history history NN 35772 1485 24 of of IN 35772 1485 25 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1485 26 . . . 35772 1486 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1486 2 fascination fascination NN 35772 1486 3 rather rather RB 35772 1486 4 resembles resemble VBZ 35772 1486 5 that that DT 35772 1486 6 of of IN 35772 1486 7 the the DT 35772 1486 8 history history NN 35772 1486 9 of of IN 35772 1486 10 religion religion NN 35772 1486 11 : : : 35772 1486 12 both both DT 35772 1486 13 are be VBP 35772 1486 14 , , , 35772 1486 15 as as IN 35772 1486 16 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1486 17 were be VBD 35772 1486 18 , , , 35772 1486 19 Odysseys Odysseys NNP 35772 1486 20 of of IN 35772 1486 21 the the DT 35772 1486 22 human human JJ 35772 1486 23 spirit spirit NN 35772 1486 24 ; ; : 35772 1486 25 nor nor CC 35772 1486 26 is be VBZ 35772 1486 27 there there EX 35772 1486 28 any any DT 35772 1486 29 activity activity NN 35772 1486 30 of of IN 35772 1486 31 man man NN 35772 1486 32 that that WDT 35772 1486 33 has have VBZ 35772 1486 34 not not RB 35772 1486 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1486 36 appeal appeal NN 35772 1486 37 to to IN 35772 1486 38 the the DT 35772 1486 39 human human JJ 35772 1486 40 heart heart NN 35772 1486 41 : : : 35772 1486 42 for for IN 35772 1486 43 _ _ NNP 35772 1486 44 cor cor NNP 35772 1486 45 ad ad NNP 35772 1486 46 cor cor NNP 35772 1486 47 loquitur loquitur NNP 35772 1486 48 _ _ NNP 35772 1486 49 . . . 35772 1487 1 And and CC 35772 1487 2 , , , 35772 1487 3 again again RB 35772 1487 4 , , , 35772 1487 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1487 6 should should MD 35772 1487 7 reflect reflect VB 35772 1487 8 that that IN 35772 1487 9 those those DT 35772 1487 10 who who WP 35772 1487 11 ask ask VBP 35772 1487 12 for for IN 35772 1487 13 final final JJ 35772 1487 14 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1487 15 , , , 35772 1487 16 forget forget VB 35772 1487 17 that that IN 35772 1487 18 the the DT 35772 1487 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1487 20 search search NN 35772 1487 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1487 22 for for IN 35772 1487 23 truth truth NN 35772 1487 24 may may MD 35772 1487 25 be be VB 35772 1487 26 , , , 35772 1487 27 in in RB 35772 1487 28 and and CC 35772 1487 29 for for IN 35772 1487 30 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1487 31 , , , 35772 1487 32 of of IN 35772 1487 33 the the DT 35772 1487 34 highest high JJS 35772 1487 35 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1487 36 value value NN 35772 1487 37 . . . 35772 1488 1 The the DT 35772 1488 2 best good JJS 35772 1488 3 starting starting NN 35772 1488 4 - - HYPH 35772 1488 5 point point NN 35772 1488 6 for for IN 35772 1488 7 the the DT 35772 1488 8 history history NN 35772 1488 9 of of IN 35772 1488 10 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1488 11 is be VBZ 35772 1488 12 a a DT 35772 1488 13 famous famous JJ 35772 1488 14 passage passage NN 35772 1488 15 from from IN 35772 1488 16 Lessing lessing NN 35772 1488 17 . . . 35772 1489 1 " " `` 35772 1489 2 Not not RB 35772 1489 3 the the DT 35772 1489 4 truth truth NN 35772 1489 5 which which WDT 35772 1489 6 is be VBZ 35772 1489 7 at at IN 35772 1489 8 the the DT 35772 1489 9 disposal disposal NN 35772 1489 10 of of IN 35772 1489 11 every every DT 35772 1489 12 man man NN 35772 1489 13 , , , 35772 1489 14 but but CC 35772 1489 15 the the DT 35772 1489 16 honest honest JJ 35772 1489 17 pains pain NNS 35772 1489 18 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1489 19 has have VBZ 35772 1489 20 taken take VBN 35772 1489 21 to to TO 35772 1489 22 come come VB 35772 1489 23 at at IN 35772 1489 24 the the DT 35772 1489 25 truth truth NN 35772 1489 26 make make VBP 35772 1489 27 the the DT 35772 1489 28 worth worth NN 35772 1489 29 of of IN 35772 1489 30 a a DT 35772 1489 31 man man NN 35772 1489 32 . . . 35772 1490 1 For for IN 35772 1490 2 not not RB 35772 1490 3 through through IN 35772 1490 4 the the DT 35772 1490 5 possession possession NN 35772 1490 6 , , , 35772 1490 7 but but CC 35772 1490 8 through through IN 35772 1490 9 the the DT 35772 1490 10 pursuit pursuit NN 35772 1490 11 of of IN 35772 1490 12 truth truth NN 35772 1490 13 do do VBP 35772 1490 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1490 15 powers power NNS 35772 1490 16 increase increase VB 35772 1490 17 , , , 35772 1490 18 and and CC 35772 1490 19 in in IN 35772 1490 20 this this DT 35772 1490 21 alone alone RB 35772 1490 22 consists consist VBZ 35772 1490 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1490 24 ever ever RB 35772 1490 25 - - HYPH 35772 1490 26 increasing increase VBG 35772 1490 27 perfection perfection NN 35772 1490 28 . . . 35772 1491 1 Possession possession NN 35772 1491 2 makes make VBZ 35772 1491 3 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1491 4 quiet quiet JJ 35772 1491 5 , , , 35772 1491 6 indolent indolent JJ 35772 1491 7 , , , 35772 1491 8 proud proud JJ 35772 1491 9 .... .... . 35772 1492 1 If if IN 35772 1492 2 God God NNP 35772 1492 3 with with IN 35772 1492 4 all all DT 35772 1492 5 truth truth NN 35772 1492 6 in in IN 35772 1492 7 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1492 8 right right JJ 35772 1492 9 hand hand NN 35772 1492 10 , , , 35772 1492 11 and and CC 35772 1492 12 in in IN 35772 1492 13 His -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1492 14 left leave VBN 35772 1492 15 the the DT 35772 1492 16 single single JJ 35772 1492 17 , , , 35772 1492 18 unceasing uncease VBG 35772 1492 19 striving strive VBG 35772 1492 20 after after IN 35772 1492 21 truth truth NN 35772 1492 22 , , , 35772 1492 23 even even RB 35772 1492 24 though though IN 35772 1492 25 coupled couple VBN 35772 1492 26 with with IN 35772 1492 27 the the DT 35772 1492 28 condition condition NN 35772 1492 29 that that WDT 35772 1492 30 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1492 31 should should MD 35772 1492 32 ever ever RB 35772 1492 33 and and CC 35772 1492 34 always always RB 35772 1492 35 err err VB 35772 1492 36 , , , 35772 1492 37 came come VBD 35772 1492 38 to to IN 35772 1492 39 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1492 40 and and CC 35772 1492 41 said say VBD 35772 1492 42 , , , 35772 1492 43 ' ' `` 35772 1492 44 Choose choose VB 35772 1492 45 ! ! . 35772 1492 46 ' ' '' 35772 1493 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1493 2 would would MD 35772 1493 3 in in IN 35772 1493 4 all all DT 35772 1493 5 humility humility NN 35772 1493 6 clasp clasp NN 35772 1493 7 this this DT 35772 1493 8 left leave VBD 35772 1493 9 hand hand NN 35772 1493 10 and and CC 35772 1493 11 say say VB 35772 1493 12 , , , 35772 1493 13 ' ' '' 35772 1493 14 Father Father NNP 35772 1493 15 , , , 35772 1493 16 give give VB 35772 1493 17 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1493 18 this this DT 35772 1493 19 ! ! . 35772 1494 1 Is be VBZ 35772 1494 2 not not RB 35772 1494 3 pure pure JJ 35772 1494 4 truth truth NN 35772 1494 5 for for IN 35772 1494 6 Thee Thee NNP 35772 1494 7 alone alone RB 35772 1494 8 ? ? . 35772 1495 1 ' ' `` 35772 1495 2 " " '' 35772 1495 3 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1495 4 76 76 CD 35772 1495 5 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1495 6 But but CC 35772 1495 7 there there EX 35772 1495 8 is be VBZ 35772 1495 9 another another DT 35772 1495 10 respect respect NN 35772 1495 11 in in IN 35772 1495 12 which which WDT 35772 1495 13 some some DT 35772 1495 14 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1495 15 of of IN 35772 1495 16 the the DT 35772 1495 17 history history NN 35772 1495 18 of of IN 35772 1495 19 thought thought NN 35772 1495 20 may may MD 35772 1495 21 be be VB 35772 1495 22 an an DT 35772 1495 23 important important JJ 35772 1495 24 advantage advantage NN 35772 1495 25 . . . 35772 1496 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1496 2 may may MD 35772 1496 3 not not RB 35772 1496 4 bestow bestow VB 35772 1496 5 upon upon IN 35772 1496 6 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1496 7 the the DT 35772 1496 8 liberty liberty NN 35772 1496 9 of of IN 35772 1496 10 dogmatising dogmatise VBG 35772 1496 11 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1496 12 , , , 35772 1496 13 but but CC 35772 1496 14 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1496 15 does do VBZ 35772 1496 16 bestow bestow VB 35772 1496 17 upon upon IN 35772 1496 18 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1496 19 a a DT 35772 1496 20 certain certain JJ 35772 1496 21 imperturbability imperturbability NN 35772 1496 22 in in IN 35772 1496 23 the the DT 35772 1496 24 face face NN 35772 1496 25 of of IN 35772 1496 26 the the DT 35772 1496 27 dogmatisms dogmatism NNS 35772 1496 28 of of IN 35772 1496 29 others other NNS 35772 1496 30 . . . 35772 1497 1 Airs air NNS 35772 1497 2 of of IN 35772 1497 3 systematic systematic JJ 35772 1497 4 omniscience omniscience NN 35772 1497 5 , , , 35772 1497 6 " " '' 35772 1497 7 the the DT 35772 1497 8 pride pride NN 35772 1497 9 of of IN 35772 1497 10 a a DT 35772 1497 11 pretended pretend VBN 35772 1497 12 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1497 13 , , , 35772 1497 14 " " `` 35772 1497 15 will will MD 35772 1497 16 leave leave VB 35772 1497 17 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1497 18 unimpressed unimpressed JJ 35772 1497 19 and and CC 35772 1497 20 undismayed undismayed JJ 35772 1497 21 . . . 35772 1498 1 The the DT 35772 1498 2 latest late JJS 35772 1498 3 pretentious pretentious JJ 35772 1498 4 product product NN 35772 1498 5 of of IN 35772 1498 6 popular popular JJ 35772 1498 7 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1498 8 will will MD 35772 1498 9 , , , 35772 1498 10 in in IN 35772 1498 11 the the DT 35772 1498 12 majority majority NN 35772 1498 13 of of IN 35772 1498 14 cases case NNS 35772 1498 15 , , , 35772 1498 16 be be VB 35772 1498 17 recognised recognise VBN 35772 1498 18 as as IN 35772 1498 19 an an DT 35772 1498 20 old old JJ 35772 1498 21 heresy heresy NN 35772 1498 22 in in IN 35772 1498 23 a a DT 35772 1498 24 new new JJ 35772 1498 25 garb garb NN 35772 1498 26 ; ; : 35772 1498 27 " " `` 35772 1498 28 new new JJ 35772 1498 29 " " '' 35772 1498 30 thought thought NN 35772 1498 31 will will MD 35772 1498 32 not not RB 35772 1498 33 impress impress VB 35772 1498 34 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1498 35 at at IN 35772 1498 36 least least JJS 35772 1498 37 , , , 35772 1498 38 by by IN 35772 1498 39 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1498 40 novelty novelty NN 35772 1498 41 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1498 42 those those DT 35772 1498 43 who who WP 35772 1498 44 know know VBP 35772 1498 45 that that IN 35772 1498 46 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1498 47 is be VBZ 35772 1498 48 old old JJ 35772 1498 49 . . . 35772 1499 1 But but CC 35772 1499 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1499 3 is be VBZ 35772 1499 4 against against IN 35772 1499 5 the the DT 35772 1499 6 crudities crudity NNS 35772 1499 7 of of IN 35772 1499 8 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 1499 9 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1499 10 that that IN 35772 1499 11 even even RB 35772 1499 12 a a DT 35772 1499 13 slight slight JJ 35772 1499 14 acquaintance acquaintance NN 35772 1499 15 with with IN 35772 1499 16 the the DT 35772 1499 17 history history NN 35772 1499 18 of of IN 35772 1499 19 ideas idea NNS 35772 1499 20 will will MD 35772 1499 21 form form VB 35772 1499 22 an an DT 35772 1499 23 antidote antidote NN 35772 1499 24 . . . 35772 1500 1 The the DT 35772 1500 2 various various JJ 35772 1500 3 exposures exposure NNS 35772 1500 4 of of IN 35772 1500 5 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1500 6 , , , 35772 1500 7 from from IN 35772 1500 8 Hume Hume NNP 35772 1500 9 and and CC 35772 1500 10 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1500 11 to to IN 35772 1500 12 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1500 13 , , , 35772 1500 14 will will MD 35772 1500 15 be be VB 35772 1500 16 to to IN 35772 1500 17 some some DT 35772 1500 18 extent extent NN 35772 1500 19 familiar familiar JJ 35772 1500 20 ; ; : 35772 1500 21 and and CC 35772 1500 22 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1500 23 will will MD 35772 1500 24 be be VB 35772 1500 25 a a DT 35772 1500 26 recognised recognise VBN 35772 1500 27 fact fact NN 35772 1500 28 that that IN 35772 1500 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1500 30 chief chief JJ 35772 1500 31 popular popular JJ 35772 1500 32 attraction attraction NN 35772 1500 33 is be VBZ 35772 1500 34 at at IN 35772 1500 35 the the DT 35772 1500 36 same same JJ 35772 1500 37 time time NN 35772 1500 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1500 39 chief chief JJ 35772 1500 40 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1500 41 weakness weakness NN 35772 1500 42 ; ; : 35772 1500 43 and and CC 35772 1500 44 this this DT 35772 1500 45 is be VBZ 35772 1500 46 that that IN 35772 1500 47 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1500 48 is be VBZ 35772 1500 49 nothing nothing NN 35772 1500 50 more more JJR 35772 1500 51 or or CC 35772 1500 52 less less JJR 35772 1500 53 than than IN 35772 1500 54 a a DT 35772 1500 55 systematisation systematisation NN 35772 1500 56 of of IN 35772 1500 57 the the DT 35772 1500 58 prejudices prejudice NNS 35772 1500 59 of of IN 35772 1500 60 common common JJ 35772 1500 61 sense sense NN 35772 1500 62 . . . 35772 1501 1 " " `` 35772 1501 2 As as IN 35772 1501 3 a a DT 35772 1501 4 theory theory NN 35772 1501 5 of of IN 35772 1501 6 first first JJ 35772 1501 7 principles principle NNS 35772 1501 8 , , , 35772 1501 9 the the DT 35772 1501 10 best good JJS 35772 1501 11 that that WDT 35772 1501 12 can can MD 35772 1501 13 be be VB 35772 1501 14 said say VBN 35772 1501 15 of of IN 35772 1501 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1501 17 pretensions pretension NNS 35772 1501 18 is be VBZ 35772 1501 19 that that IN 35772 1501 20 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1501 21 are be VBP 35772 1501 22 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 35772 1501 23 . . . 35772 1502 1 " " `` 35772 1502 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1502 3 77 77 CD 35772 1502 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1502 5 SOME some NN 35772 1502 6 DEDUCTIONS deduction NNS 35772 1502 7 FROM from IN 35772 1502 8 HISTORY.--But HISTORY.--But NNS 35772 1502 9 , , , 35772 1502 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1502 11 may may MD 35772 1502 12 be be VB 35772 1502 13 asked ask VBN 35772 1502 14 , , , 35772 1502 15 what what WP 35772 1502 16 definite definite JJ 35772 1502 17 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1502 18 have have VBP 35772 1502 19 the the DT 35772 1502 20 foregoing foregoing JJ 35772 1502 21 chapters chapter NNS 35772 1502 22 to to TO 35772 1502 23 offer offer VB 35772 1502 24 ? ? . 35772 1503 1 Some some DT 35772 1503 2 , , , 35772 1503 3 if if IN 35772 1503 4 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1503 5 are be VBP 35772 1503 6 not not RB 35772 1503 7 mistaken mistaken JJ 35772 1503 8 , , , 35772 1503 9 of of IN 35772 1503 10 a a DT 35772 1503 11 genuinely genuinely RB 35772 1503 12 positive positive JJ 35772 1503 13 character character NN 35772 1503 14 . . . 35772 1504 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1504 2 will will MD 35772 1504 3 be be VB 35772 1504 4 necessary necessary JJ 35772 1504 5 to to TO 35772 1504 6 recall recall VB 35772 1504 7 certain certain JJ 35772 1504 8 facts fact NNS 35772 1504 9 and and CC 35772 1504 10 reflections reflection NNS 35772 1504 11 to to IN 35772 1504 12 the the DT 35772 1504 13 minds mind NNS 35772 1504 14 of of IN 35772 1504 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1504 16 readers reader NNS 35772 1504 17 . . . 35772 1505 1 In in IN 35772 1505 2 the the DT 35772 1505 3 early early JJ 35772 1505 4 chapters chapter NNS 35772 1505 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1505 6 noted note VBD 35772 1505 7 the the DT 35772 1505 8 rise rise NN 35772 1505 9 of of IN 35772 1505 10 an an DT 35772 1505 11 independent independent JJ 35772 1505 12 science science NN 35772 1505 13 , , , 35772 1505 14 and and CC 35772 1505 15 the the DT 35772 1505 16 collapse collapse NN 35772 1505 17 of of IN 35772 1505 18 the the DT 35772 1505 19 medieval medieval JJ 35772 1505 20 world world NN 35772 1505 21 view view NN 35772 1505 22 with with IN 35772 1505 23 which which WDT 35772 1505 24 popular popular JJ 35772 1505 25 religious religious JJ 35772 1505 26 notions notion NNS 35772 1505 27 were be VBD 35772 1505 28 associated associate VBN 35772 1505 29 so so RB 35772 1505 30 closely closely RB 35772 1505 31 , , , 35772 1505 32 that that IN 35772 1505 33 many many JJ 35772 1505 34 conservative conservative JJ 35772 1505 35 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1505 36 expected expect VBN 35772 1505 37 to to TO 35772 1505 38 see see VB 35772 1505 39 both both DT 35772 1505 40 involved involve VBN 35772 1505 41 in in IN 35772 1505 42 a a DT 35772 1505 43 common common JJ 35772 1505 44 ruin ruin NN 35772 1505 45 . . . 35772 1506 1 Science science NN 35772 1506 2 seemed seem VBD 35772 1506 3 to to TO 35772 1506 4 threaten threaten VB 35772 1506 5 the the DT 35772 1506 6 existence existence NN 35772 1506 7 of of IN 35772 1506 8 a a DT 35772 1506 9 religion religion NN 35772 1506 10 bound bind VBN 35772 1506 11 up up RP 35772 1506 12 with with IN 35772 1506 13 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1506 14 of of IN 35772 1506 15 space space NN 35772 1506 16 and and CC 35772 1506 17 of of IN 35772 1506 18 force force NN 35772 1506 19 which which WDT 35772 1506 20 were be VBD 35772 1506 21 being be VBG 35772 1506 22 brought bring VBN 35772 1506 23 into into IN 35772 1506 24 discredit discredit NN 35772 1506 25 . . . 35772 1507 1 These these DT 35772 1507 2 misgivings misgiving NNS 35772 1507 3 turned turn VBD 35772 1507 4 out out RP 35772 1507 5 , , , 35772 1507 6 however however RB 35772 1507 7 , , , 35772 1507 8 to to TO 35772 1507 9 be be VB 35772 1507 10 ill ill RB 35772 1507 11 - - HYPH 35772 1507 12 founded found VBN 35772 1507 13 . . . 35772 1508 1 Certain certain JJ 35772 1508 2 advantages advantage NNS 35772 1508 3 , , , 35772 1508 4 no no RB 35772 1508 5 doubt doubt RB 35772 1508 6 , , , 35772 1508 7 of of IN 35772 1508 8 simplicity simplicity NN 35772 1508 9 and and CC 35772 1508 10 definiteness definiteness NN 35772 1508 11 , , , 35772 1508 12 which which WDT 35772 1508 13 had have VBD 35772 1508 14 belonged belong VBN 35772 1508 15 to to IN 35772 1508 16 the the DT 35772 1508 17 old old JJ 35772 1508 18 notions notion NNS 35772 1508 19 , , , 35772 1508 20 had have VBD 35772 1508 21 been be VBN 35772 1508 22 irrecoverably irrecoverably RB 35772 1508 23 lost lose VBN 35772 1508 24 ; ; : 35772 1508 25 but but CC 35772 1508 26 thinkers thinker NNS 35772 1508 27 like like IN 35772 1508 28 Giordano Giordano NNP 35772 1508 29 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 1508 30 showed show VBD 35772 1508 31 that that IN 35772 1508 32 the the DT 35772 1508 33 conception conception NN 35772 1508 34 of of IN 35772 1508 35 an an DT 35772 1508 36 infinite infinite JJ 35772 1508 37 universe universe NN 35772 1508 38 was be VBD 35772 1508 39 by by IN 35772 1508 40 no no DT 35772 1508 41 means mean NNS 35772 1508 42 hostile hostile JJ 35772 1508 43 to to IN 35772 1508 44 religion religion NN 35772 1508 45 ; ; : 35772 1508 46 but but CC 35772 1508 47 that that IN 35772 1508 48 , , , 35772 1508 49 on on IN 35772 1508 50 the the DT 35772 1508 51 contrary contrary NN 35772 1508 52 , , , 35772 1508 53 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1508 54 might may MD 35772 1508 55 be be VB 35772 1508 56 a a DT 35772 1508 57 conception conception NN 35772 1508 58 of of IN 35772 1508 59 the the DT 35772 1508 60 highest high JJS 35772 1508 61 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1508 62 value value NN 35772 1508 63 . . . 35772 1509 1 Such such JJ 35772 1509 2 are be VBP 35772 1509 3 the the DT 35772 1509 4 sentiments sentiment NNS 35772 1509 5 expressed express VBN 35772 1509 6 in in IN 35772 1509 7 some some DT 35772 1509 8 sonnets sonnet NNS 35772 1509 9 which which WDT 35772 1509 10 precede precede VBP 35772 1509 11 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 1509 12 's 's POS 35772 1509 13 dialogue dialogue NN 35772 1509 14 " " `` 35772 1509 15 On on IN 35772 1509 16 the the DT 35772 1509 17 Infinite Infinite NNP 35772 1509 18 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1509 19 . . . 35772 1509 20 " " '' 35772 1510 1 " " `` 35772 1510 2 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1510 3 seemed seem VBD 35772 1510 4 to to IN 35772 1510 5 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 1510 6 as as IN 35772 1510 7 if if IN 35772 1510 8 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1510 9 had have VBD 35772 1510 10 never never RB 35772 1510 11 breathed breathe VBN 35772 1510 12 freely freely RB 35772 1510 13 until until IN 35772 1510 14 the the DT 35772 1510 15 limits limit NNS 35772 1510 16 of of IN 35772 1510 17 the the DT 35772 1510 18 universe universe NN 35772 1510 19 had have VBD 35772 1510 20 been be VBN 35772 1510 21 extended extend VBN 35772 1510 22 to to IN 35772 1510 23 infinity infinity NN 35772 1510 24 , , , 35772 1510 25 and and CC 35772 1510 26 the the DT 35772 1510 27 fixed fix VBN 35772 1510 28 spheres sphere NNS 35772 1510 29 had have VBD 35772 1510 30 disappeared disappear VBN 35772 1510 31 . . . 35772 1511 1 No no RB 35772 1511 2 longer long RBR 35772 1511 3 now now RB 35772 1511 4 was be VBD 35772 1511 5 there there EX 35772 1511 6 a a DT 35772 1511 7 limit limit NN 35772 1511 8 to to IN 35772 1511 9 the the DT 35772 1511 10 flight flight NN 35772 1511 11 of of IN 35772 1511 12 the the DT 35772 1511 13 spirit spirit NN 35772 1511 14 , , , 35772 1511 15 no no UH 35772 1511 16 ' ' '' 35772 1511 17 so so RB 35772 1511 18 far far RB 35772 1511 19 and and CC 35772 1511 20 no no RB 35772 1511 21 further further RB 35772 1511 22 ' ' '' 35772 1511 23 ; ; : 35772 1511 24 the the DT 35772 1511 25 narrow narrow JJ 35772 1511 26 prison prison NN 35772 1511 27 in in IN 35772 1511 28 which which WDT 35772 1511 29 the the DT 35772 1511 30 old old JJ 35772 1511 31 beliefs belief NNS 35772 1511 32 had have VBD 35772 1511 33 confined confine VBN 35772 1511 34 men man NNS 35772 1511 35 's 's POS 35772 1511 36 spirits spirit NNS 35772 1511 37 had have VBD 35772 1511 38 now now RB 35772 1511 39 to to TO 35772 1511 40 open open VB 35772 1511 41 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1511 42 gates gate NNS 35772 1511 43 and and CC 35772 1511 44 let let VBD 35772 1511 45 in in IN 35772 1511 46 the the DT 35772 1511 47 pure pure JJ 35772 1511 48 air air NN 35772 1511 49 of of IN 35772 1511 50 a a DT 35772 1511 51 new new JJ 35772 1511 52 life life NN 35772 1511 53 . . . 35772 1512 1 " " `` 35772 1512 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1512 3 78 78 CD 35772 1512 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1512 5 The the DT 35772 1512 6 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1512 7 did do VBD 35772 1512 8 not not RB 35772 1512 9 seem seem VB 35772 1512 10 to to IN 35772 1512 11 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1512 12 incompatible incompatible JJ 35772 1512 13 with with IN 35772 1512 14 a a DT 35772 1512 15 fundamentally fundamentally RB 35772 1512 16 religious religious JJ 35772 1512 17 conception conception NN 35772 1512 18 of of IN 35772 1512 19 the the DT 35772 1512 20 world world NN 35772 1512 21 , , , 35772 1512 22 at at IN 35772 1512 23 least least JJS 35772 1512 24 for for IN 35772 1512 25 those those DT 35772 1512 26 who who WP 35772 1512 27 were be VBD 35772 1512 28 not not RB 35772 1512 29 afraid afraid JJ 35772 1512 30 " " '' 35772 1512 31 to to TO 35772 1512 32 take take VB 35772 1512 33 ship ship NN 35772 1512 34 upon upon IN 35772 1512 35 the the DT 35772 1512 36 seas sea NNS 35772 1512 37 of of IN 35772 1512 38 the the DT 35772 1512 39 infinite infinite NN 35772 1512 40 . . . 35772 1512 41 " " '' 35772 1513 1 DANGERS danger NNS 35772 1513 2 OF of IN 35772 1513 3 THE the DT 35772 1513 4 " " `` 35772 1513 5 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 1513 6 VIEW VIEW NNP 35772 1513 7 . . . 35772 1513 8 " " '' 35772 1514 1 --Thus --thus VB 35772 1514 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1514 3 was be VBD 35772 1514 4 not not RB 35772 1514 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1514 6 science science NN 35772 1514 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1514 8 that that WDT 35772 1514 9 was be VBD 35772 1514 10 hostile hostile JJ 35772 1514 11 to to IN 35772 1514 12 religion religion NN 35772 1514 13 . . . 35772 1515 1 This this DT 35772 1515 2 was be VBD 35772 1515 3 not not RB 35772 1515 4 the the DT 35772 1515 5 case case NN 35772 1515 6 until until IN 35772 1515 7 science science NN 35772 1515 8 began begin VBD 35772 1515 9 to to TO 35772 1515 10 be be VB 35772 1515 11 associated associate VBN 35772 1515 12 with with IN 35772 1515 13 a a DT 35772 1515 14 certain certain JJ 35772 1515 15 fairly fairly RB 35772 1515 16 definite definite JJ 35772 1515 17 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1515 18 of of IN 35772 1515 19 a a DT 35772 1515 20 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1515 21 , , , 35772 1515 22 and and CC 35772 1515 23 later later RB 35772 1515 24 of of IN 35772 1515 25 a a DT 35772 1515 26 materialist materialist NN 35772 1515 27 , , , 35772 1515 28 description description NN 35772 1515 29 . . . 35772 1516 1 Religion religion NN 35772 1516 2 could could MD 35772 1516 3 not not RB 35772 1516 4 have have VB 35772 1516 5 survived survive VBN 35772 1516 6 the the DT 35772 1516 7 final final JJ 35772 1516 8 establishment establishment NN 35772 1516 9 of of IN 35772 1516 10 such such PDT 35772 1516 11 a a DT 35772 1516 12 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1516 13 as as IN 35772 1516 14 this this DT 35772 1516 15 , , , 35772 1516 16 for for IN 35772 1516 17 the the DT 35772 1516 18 indispensable indispensable JJ 35772 1516 19 element element NN 35772 1516 20 in in IN 35772 1516 21 a a DT 35772 1516 22 religious religious JJ 35772 1516 23 attitude attitude NN 35772 1516 24 of of IN 35772 1516 25 life life NN 35772 1516 26 is be VBZ 35772 1516 27 the the DT 35772 1516 28 idea idea NN 35772 1516 29 that that WDT 35772 1516 30 _ _ NNP 35772 1516 31 somehow somehow RB 35772 1516 32 there there EX 35772 1516 33 lies lie VBZ 35772 1516 34 behind behind IN 35772 1516 35 things thing NNS 35772 1516 36 a a DT 35772 1516 37 power power NN 35772 1516 38 or or CC 35772 1516 39 essence essence NN 35772 1516 40 that that WDT 35772 1516 41 has have VBZ 35772 1516 42 something something NN 35772 1516 43 in in IN 35772 1516 44 common common JJ 35772 1516 45 with with IN 35772 1516 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1516 47 own own JJ 35772 1516 48 natures_--something natures_--something NN 35772 1516 49 that that WDT 35772 1516 50 can can MD 35772 1516 51 , , , 35772 1516 52 without without IN 35772 1516 53 an an DT 35772 1516 54 abuse abuse NN 35772 1516 55 of of IN 35772 1516 56 language language NN 35772 1516 57 , , , 35772 1516 58 be be VB 35772 1516 59 called call VBN 35772 1516 60 personal personal JJ 35772 1516 61 . . . 35772 1517 1 Any any DT 35772 1517 2 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1517 3 that that WDT 35772 1517 4 rules rule VBZ 35772 1517 5 out out RP 35772 1517 6 this this DT 35772 1517 7 idea idea NN 35772 1517 8 creates create VBZ 35772 1517 9 an an DT 35772 1517 10 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 1517 11 in in IN 35772 1517 12 which which WDT 35772 1517 13 religion religion NN 35772 1517 14 can can MD 35772 1517 15 not not RB 35772 1517 16 breathe breathe VB 35772 1517 17 . . . 35772 1518 1 And and CC 35772 1518 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1518 3 was be VBD 35772 1518 4 just just RB 35772 1518 5 this this DT 35772 1518 6 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 1518 7 that that IN 35772 1518 8 the the DT 35772 1518 9 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1518 10 view view NN 35772 1518 11 , , , 35772 1518 12 unless unless IN 35772 1518 13 amplified amplify VBN 35772 1518 14 by by IN 35772 1518 15 considerations consideration NNS 35772 1518 16 of of IN 35772 1518 17 another another DT 35772 1518 18 kind kind NN 35772 1518 19 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1518 20 as as IN 35772 1518 21 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1518 22 was be VBD 35772 1518 23 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 1519 1 in in IN 35772 1519 2 the the DT 35772 1519 3 case case NN 35772 1519 4 of of IN 35772 1519 5 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 1519 6 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1519 7 tended tend VBD 35772 1519 8 to to TO 35772 1519 9 create create VB 35772 1519 10 . . . 35772 1520 1 THE the DT 35772 1520 2 " " `` 35772 1520 3 MECHANICAL MECHANICAL NNP 35772 1520 4 VIEW view NN 35772 1520 5 " " '' 35772 1520 6 NEVER never RB 35772 1520 7 UNCHALLENGED.--And unchallenged.--and CC 35772 1520 8 with with IN 35772 1520 9 regard regard NN 35772 1520 10 to to IN 35772 1520 11 this this DT 35772 1520 12 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1520 13 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1520 14 , , , 35772 1520 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1520 16 have have VBP 35772 1520 17 to to TO 35772 1520 18 observe observe VB 35772 1520 19 that that IN 35772 1520 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1520 21 never never RB 35772 1520 22 seems seem VBZ 35772 1520 23 to to TO 35772 1520 24 have have VB 35772 1520 25 commended commend VBN 35772 1520 26 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1520 27 , , , 35772 1520 28 as as IN 35772 1520 29 a a DT 35772 1520 30 final final JJ 35772 1520 31 and and CC 35772 1520 32 complete complete JJ 35772 1520 33 solution solution NN 35772 1520 34 , , , 35772 1520 35 to to IN 35772 1520 36 the the DT 35772 1520 37 best good JJS 35772 1520 38 minds mind NNS 35772 1520 39 . . . 35772 1521 1 In in IN 35772 1521 2 the the DT 35772 1521 3 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 35772 1521 4 century century NN 35772 1521 5 , , , 35772 1521 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1521 7 will will MD 35772 1521 8 be be VB 35772 1521 9 remembered remember VBN 35772 1521 10 , , , 35772 1521 11 the the DT 35772 1521 12 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1521 13 conception conception NN 35772 1521 14 was be VBD 35772 1521 15 transcended transcend VBN 35772 1521 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1521 17 though though RB 35772 1521 18 in in IN 35772 1521 19 entirely entirely RB 35772 1521 20 different different JJ 35772 1521 21 ways way NNS 35772 1521 22 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1521 23 by by IN 35772 1521 24 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 1521 25 and and CC 35772 1521 26 by by IN 35772 1521 27 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 1521 28 , , , 35772 1521 29 and and CC 35772 1521 30 the the DT 35772 1521 31 religious religious JJ 35772 1521 32 consciousness consciousness NN 35772 1521 33 of of IN 35772 1521 34 the the DT 35772 1521 35 age age NN 35772 1521 36 , , , 35772 1521 37 in in IN 35772 1521 38 the the DT 35772 1521 39 person person NN 35772 1521 40 of of IN 35772 1521 41 Pascal Pascal NNP 35772 1521 42 , , , 35772 1521 43 protested protest VBD 35772 1521 44 against against IN 35772 1521 45 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1521 46 . . . 35772 1522 1 And and CC 35772 1522 2 although although IN 35772 1522 3 , , , 35772 1522 4 during during IN 35772 1522 5 the the DT 35772 1522 6 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 1522 7 century century NN 35772 1522 8 , , , 35772 1522 9 this this DT 35772 1522 10 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1522 11 persisted persist VBD 35772 1522 12 , , , 35772 1522 13 and and CC 35772 1522 14 was be VBD 35772 1522 15 considerably considerably RB 35772 1522 16 reinforced reinforce VBN 35772 1522 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1522 18 with with IN 35772 1522 19 the the DT 35772 1522 20 help help NN 35772 1522 21 of of IN 35772 1522 22 further further JJ 35772 1522 23 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 1522 24 in in IN 35772 1522 25 the the DT 35772 1522 26 realm realm NN 35772 1522 27 of of IN 35772 1522 28 physics physics NN 35772 1522 29 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1522 30 by by IN 35772 1522 31 the the DT 35772 1522 32 school school NN 35772 1522 33 of of IN 35772 1522 34 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 1522 35 and and CC 35772 1522 36 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 1522 37 , , , 35772 1522 38 yet yet CC 35772 1522 39 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1522 40 had have VBD 35772 1522 41 still still RB 35772 1522 42 to to TO 35772 1522 43 face face VB 35772 1522 44 the the DT 35772 1522 45 radical radical JJ 35772 1522 46 criticism criticism NN 35772 1522 47 of of IN 35772 1522 48 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1522 49 . . . 35772 1523 1 This this DT 35772 1523 2 criticism criticism NN 35772 1523 3 , , , 35772 1523 4 as as IN 35772 1523 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1523 6 shall shall MD 35772 1523 7 remember remember VB 35772 1523 8 , , , 35772 1523 9 indicated indicate VBD 35772 1523 10 that that IN 35772 1523 11 the the DT 35772 1523 12 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1523 13 view view NN 35772 1523 14 is be VBZ 35772 1523 15 a a DT 35772 1523 16 way way NN 35772 1523 17 in in IN 35772 1523 18 which which WDT 35772 1523 19 the the DT 35772 1523 20 human human JJ 35772 1523 21 mind mind NN 35772 1523 22 -- -- : 35772 1523 23 owing owe VBG 35772 1523 24 to to IN 35772 1523 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1523 26 constitution constitution NN 35772 1523 27 -- -- : 35772 1523 28 regards regard VBZ 35772 1523 29 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1523 30 . . . 35772 1524 1 If if IN 35772 1524 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1524 3 is be VBZ 35772 1524 4 to to TO 35772 1524 5 understand understand VB 35772 1524 6 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1524 7 , , , 35772 1524 8 the the DT 35772 1524 9 human human JJ 35772 1524 10 mind mind NN 35772 1524 11 can can MD 35772 1524 12 not not RB 35772 1524 13 help help VB 35772 1524 14 viewing view VBG 35772 1524 15 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1524 16 in in IN 35772 1524 17 that that DT 35772 1524 18 fashion fashion NN 35772 1524 19 ; ; : 35772 1524 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1524 21 must must MD 35772 1524 22 subject subject VB 35772 1524 23 things thing NNS 35772 1524 24 to to IN 35772 1524 25 the the DT 35772 1524 26 mould mould NN 35772 1524 27 in in IN 35772 1524 28 which which WDT 35772 1524 29 all all DT 35772 1524 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1524 31 thought thought NN 35772 1524 32 is be VBZ 35772 1524 33 cast cast VBN 35772 1524 34 . . . 35772 1525 1 Mechanism Mechanism NNP 35772 1525 2 is be VBZ 35772 1525 3 the the DT 35772 1525 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1525 5 medium medium NN 35772 1525 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1525 7 through through IN 35772 1525 8 which which WDT 35772 1525 9 the the DT 35772 1525 10 mind mind NN 35772 1525 11 understands understand VBZ 35772 1525 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1525 13 . . . 35772 1526 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1526 2 belongs belong VBZ 35772 1526 3 not not RB 35772 1526 4 to to IN 35772 1526 5 the the DT 35772 1526 6 things thing NNS 35772 1526 7 in in IN 35772 1526 8 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1526 9 , , , 35772 1526 10 but but CC 35772 1526 11 to to IN 35772 1526 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1526 13 way way NN 35772 1526 14 of of IN 35772 1526 15 understanding understand VBG 35772 1526 16 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1526 17 . . . 35772 1527 1 And and CC 35772 1527 2 attached attach VBN 35772 1527 3 to to IN 35772 1527 4 this this DT 35772 1527 5 radical radical JJ 35772 1527 6 criticism criticism NN 35772 1527 7 of of IN 35772 1527 8 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1527 9 notions notion NNS 35772 1527 10 , , , 35772 1527 11 was be VBD 35772 1527 12 an an DT 35772 1527 13 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1527 14 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1527 15 of of IN 35772 1527 16 the the DT 35772 1527 17 most most RBS 35772 1527 18 genuinely genuinely RB 35772 1527 19 religious religious JJ 35772 1527 20 and and CC 35772 1527 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1527 22 character character NN 35772 1527 23 . . . 35772 1528 1 Kantian kantian JJ 35772 1528 2 idealism idealism NN 35772 1528 3 is be VBZ 35772 1528 4 one one CD 35772 1528 5 of of IN 35772 1528 6 those those DT 35772 1528 7 contributions contribution NNS 35772 1528 8 to to IN 35772 1528 9 human human JJ 35772 1528 10 thought thought NN 35772 1528 11 behind behind IN 35772 1528 12 which which WDT 35772 1528 13 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1528 14 shall shall MD 35772 1528 15 not not RB 35772 1528 16 again again RB 35772 1528 17 regress regress JJ 35772 1528 18 . . . 35772 1529 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1529 2 is be VBZ 35772 1529 3 a a DT 35772 1529 4 phenomenon phenomenon NN 35772 1529 5 of of IN 35772 1529 6 incalculable incalculable JJ 35772 1529 7 value value NN 35772 1529 8 and and CC 35772 1529 9 importance importance NN 35772 1529 10 . . . 35772 1530 1 The the DT 35772 1530 2 immediate immediate JJ 35772 1530 3 results result NNS 35772 1530 4 of of IN 35772 1530 5 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1530 6 's 's POS 35772 1530 7 critical critical JJ 35772 1530 8 idealism idealism NN 35772 1530 9 was be VBD 35772 1530 10 a a DT 35772 1530 11 luxuriant luxuriant JJ 35772 1530 12 growth growth NN 35772 1530 13 of of IN 35772 1530 14 a a DT 35772 1530 15 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1530 16 type type NN 35772 1530 17 of of IN 35772 1530 18 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1530 19 upon upon IN 35772 1530 20 the the DT 35772 1530 21 ground ground NN 35772 1530 22 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1530 23 had have VBD 35772 1530 24 cleared clear VBN 35772 1530 25 and and CC 35772 1530 26 prepared prepare VBN 35772 1530 27 . . . 35772 1531 1 Romanticism romanticism NN 35772 1531 2 may may MD 35772 1531 3 be be VB 35772 1531 4 regarded regard VBN 35772 1531 5 as as IN 35772 1531 6 a a DT 35772 1531 7 revolt revolt NN 35772 1531 8 of of IN 35772 1531 9 those those DT 35772 1531 10 sides side NNS 35772 1531 11 of of IN 35772 1531 12 human human JJ 35772 1531 13 nature nature NN 35772 1531 14 upon upon IN 35772 1531 15 which which WDT 35772 1531 16 the the DT 35772 1531 17 tyranny tyranny NN 35772 1531 18 of of IN 35772 1531 19 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1531 20 pressed press VBN 35772 1531 21 hardest hard RBS 35772 1531 22 -- -- : 35772 1531 23 religion religion NN 35772 1531 24 , , , 35772 1531 25 speculation speculation NN 35772 1531 26 , , , 35772 1531 27 poetry poetry NN 35772 1531 28 , , , 35772 1531 29 music music NN 35772 1531 30 , , , 35772 1531 31 art art NN 35772 1531 32 . . . 35772 1532 1 " " `` 35772 1532 2 You -PRON- PRP 35772 1532 3 may may MD 35772 1532 4 expel expel VB 35772 1532 5 nature nature NN 35772 1532 6 with with IN 35772 1532 7 a a DT 35772 1532 8 pitchfork pitchfork NN 35772 1532 9 , , , 35772 1532 10 but but CC 35772 1532 11 she -PRON- PRP 35772 1532 12 persists persist VBZ 35772 1532 13 in in IN 35772 1532 14 returning return VBG 35772 1532 15 . . . 35772 1532 16 " " '' 35772 1533 1 The the DT 35772 1533 2 Horatian horatian JJ 35772 1533 3 remark remark NN 35772 1533 4 is be VBZ 35772 1533 5 true true JJ 35772 1533 6 also also RB 35772 1533 7 of of IN 35772 1533 8 the the DT 35772 1533 9 human human JJ 35772 1533 10 mind mind NN 35772 1533 11 ; ; : 35772 1533 12 you -PRON- PRP 35772 1533 13 may may MD 35772 1533 14 try try VB 35772 1533 15 to to TO 35772 1533 16 weed weed VB 35772 1533 17 out out RP 35772 1533 18 religion religion NN 35772 1533 19 and and CC 35772 1533 20 poetry poetry NN 35772 1533 21 , , , 35772 1533 22 but but CC 35772 1533 23 your -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1533 24 success success NN 35772 1533 25 will will MD 35772 1533 26 only only RB 35772 1533 27 be be VB 35772 1533 28 temporary temporary JJ 35772 1533 29 ; ; : 35772 1533 30 for for IN 35772 1533 31 nature nature NN 35772 1533 32 herself -PRON- PRP 35772 1533 33 is be VBZ 35772 1533 34 more more RBR 35772 1533 35 persistent persistent JJ 35772 1533 36 than than IN 35772 1533 37 the the DT 35772 1533 38 most most RBS 35772 1533 39 earnest earnest JJ 35772 1533 40 of of IN 35772 1533 41 materialists materialist NNS 35772 1533 42 and and CC 35772 1533 43 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1533 44 what what WP 35772 1533 45 is be VBZ 35772 1533 46 more more JJR 35772 1533 47 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1533 48 she -PRON- PRP 35772 1533 49 outlives outlive VBZ 35772 1533 50 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1533 51 . . . 35772 1534 1 And and CC 35772 1534 2 with with IN 35772 1534 3 regard regard NN 35772 1534 4 to to IN 35772 1534 5 the the DT 35772 1534 6 materialist materialist NN 35772 1534 7 or or CC 35772 1534 8 mechanistic mechanistic JJ 35772 1534 9 view view NN 35772 1534 10 , , , 35772 1534 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1534 12 is be VBZ 35772 1534 13 highly highly RB 35772 1534 14 interesting interesting JJ 35772 1534 15 to to TO 35772 1534 16 note note VB 35772 1534 17 that that IN 35772 1534 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1534 19 greatest great JJS 35772 1534 20 attraction attraction NN 35772 1534 21 has have VBZ 35772 1534 22 consisted consist VBN 35772 1534 23 in in IN 35772 1534 24 something something NN 35772 1534 25 which which WDT 35772 1534 26 , , , 35772 1534 27 strictly strictly RB 35772 1534 28 speaking speak VBG 35772 1534 29 , , , 35772 1534 30 is be VBZ 35772 1534 31 not not RB 35772 1534 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1534 33 own own JJ 35772 1534 34 property property NN 35772 1534 35 . . . 35772 1535 1 In in IN 35772 1535 2 the the DT 35772 1535 3 eighteenth eighteenth JJ 35772 1535 4 century century NN 35772 1535 5 in in IN 35772 1535 6 France France NNP 35772 1535 7 , , , 35772 1535 8 and and CC 35772 1535 9 in in IN 35772 1535 10 the the DT 35772 1535 11 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1535 12 century century NN 35772 1535 13 in in IN 35772 1535 14 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1535 15 and and CC 35772 1535 16 England England NNP 35772 1535 17 , , , 35772 1535 18 the the DT 35772 1535 19 popularity popularity NN 35772 1535 20 of of IN 35772 1535 21 this this DT 35772 1535 22 view view NN 35772 1535 23 was be VBD 35772 1535 24 derived derive VBN 35772 1535 25 from from IN 35772 1535 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1535 27 altogether altogether RB 35772 1535 28 illegitimate illegitimate NNP 35772 1535 29 association association NN 35772 1535 30 with with IN 35772 1535 31 a a DT 35772 1535 32 high high JJ 35772 1535 33 moral moral JJ 35772 1535 34 and and CC 35772 1535 35 social social JJ 35772 1535 36 idealism idealism NN 35772 1535 37 , , , 35772 1535 38 which which WDT 35772 1535 39 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1535 40 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1535 41 is be VBZ 35772 1535 42 only only RB 35772 1535 43 too too RB 35772 1535 44 evident evident JJ 35772 1535 45 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1535 46 had have VBD 35772 1535 47 been be VBN 35772 1535 48 borrowed borrow VBN 35772 1535 49 -- -- : 35772 1535 50 without without IN 35772 1535 51 sufficient sufficient JJ 35772 1535 52 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 35772 1535 53 -- -- : 35772 1535 54 from from IN 35772 1535 55 the the DT 35772 1535 56 Christian christian JJ 35772 1535 57 tradition tradition NN 35772 1535 58 . . . 35772 1536 1 The the DT 35772 1536 2 rather rather RB 35772 1536 3 self self NN 35772 1536 4 - - HYPH 35772 1536 5 conscious conscious JJ 35772 1536 6 atheism atheism NN 35772 1536 7 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1536 8 for for IN 35772 1536 9 instance instance NN 35772 1536 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1536 11 of of IN 35772 1536 12 Shelley Shelley NNP 35772 1536 13 or or CC 35772 1536 14 Byron Byron NNP 35772 1536 15 -- -- : 35772 1536 16 which which WDT 35772 1536 17 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1536 18 had have VBD 35772 1536 19 presumably presumably RB 35772 1536 20 derived derive VBN 35772 1536 21 from from IN 35772 1536 22 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 1536 23 and and CC 35772 1536 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1536 25 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 1536 26 -- -- : 35772 1536 27 was be VBD 35772 1536 28 less less RBR 35772 1536 29 a a DT 35772 1536 30 denial denial NN 35772 1536 31 of of IN 35772 1536 32 God God NNP 35772 1536 33 than than IN 35772 1536 34 an an DT 35772 1536 35 affirmation affirmation NN 35772 1536 36 of of IN 35772 1536 37 the the DT 35772 1536 38 rights right NNS 35772 1536 39 of of IN 35772 1536 40 humanity humanity NN 35772 1536 41 . . . 35772 1537 1 This this DT 35772 1537 2 generous generous JJ 35772 1537 3 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1537 4 of of IN 35772 1537 5 revolt revolt NN 35772 1537 6 from from IN 35772 1537 7 contemporary contemporary JJ 35772 1537 8 tyranny tyranny NN 35772 1537 9 and and CC 35772 1537 10 pharisaism pharisaism NN 35772 1537 11 is be VBZ 35772 1537 12 atheistic atheistic JJ 35772 1537 13 only only RB 35772 1537 14 in in IN 35772 1537 15 name name NN 35772 1537 16 . . . 35772 1538 1 The the DT 35772 1538 2 callous callous JJ 35772 1538 3 and and CC 35772 1538 4 cynical cynical JJ 35772 1538 5 powers power NNS 35772 1538 6 , , , 35772 1538 7 both both CC 35772 1538 8 political political JJ 35772 1538 9 and and CC 35772 1538 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 35772 1538 11 , , , 35772 1538 12 that that WDT 35772 1538 13 were be VBD 35772 1538 14 the the DT 35772 1538 15 object object NN 35772 1538 16 of of IN 35772 1538 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1538 18 bitter bitter JJ 35772 1538 19 attacks attack NNS 35772 1538 20 were be VBD 35772 1538 21 the the DT 35772 1538 22 embodiments embodiment NNS 35772 1538 23 of of IN 35772 1538 24 atheism atheism NN 35772 1538 25 , , , 35772 1538 26 for for IN 35772 1538 27 " " `` 35772 1538 28 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1538 29 alone alone RB 35772 1538 30 is be VBZ 35772 1538 31 the the DT 35772 1538 32 true true JJ 35772 1538 33 atheist atheist NN 35772 1538 34 to to IN 35772 1538 35 whom whom WP 35772 1538 36 the the DT 35772 1538 37 predicates predicate NNS 35772 1538 38 of of IN 35772 1538 39 the the DT 35772 1538 40 Divine Divine NNP 35772 1538 41 Being Being NNP 35772 1538 42 , , , 35772 1538 43 e.g. e.g. RB 35772 1539 1 love love NN 35772 1539 2 , , , 35772 1539 3 wisdom wisdom NN 35772 1539 4 , , , 35772 1539 5 justice justice NN 35772 1539 6 , , , 35772 1539 7 are be VBP 35772 1539 8 nothing nothing NN 35772 1539 9 . . . 35772 1540 1 " " `` 35772 1540 2 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1540 3 79 79 CD 35772 1540 4 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1540 5 THE the DT 35772 1540 6 PRESENT PRESENT NNP 35772 1540 7 SITUATION.--During situation.--dure VBG 35772 1540 8 the the DT 35772 1540 9 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 35772 1540 10 century century NN 35772 1540 11 the the DT 35772 1540 12 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1540 13 view view NN 35772 1540 14 received receive VBD 35772 1540 15 some some DT 35772 1540 16 accession accession NN 35772 1540 17 of of IN 35772 1540 18 strength strength NN 35772 1540 19 owing owe VBG 35772 1540 20 to to IN 35772 1540 21 the the DT 35772 1540 22 reduction reduction NN 35772 1540 23 of of IN 35772 1540 24 biology biology NN 35772 1540 25 to to IN 35772 1540 26 what what WP 35772 1540 27 seemed seem VBD 35772 1540 28 like like IN 35772 1540 29 subjection subjection NN 35772 1540 30 . . . 35772 1541 1 But but CC 35772 1541 2 , , , 35772 1541 3 at at IN 35772 1541 4 the the DT 35772 1541 5 same same JJ 35772 1541 6 time time NN 35772 1541 7 , , , 35772 1541 8 an an DT 35772 1541 9 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1541 10 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1541 11 had have VBD 35772 1541 12 taken take VBN 35772 1541 13 a a DT 35772 1541 14 strong strong JJ 35772 1541 15 hold hold NN 35772 1541 16 in in IN 35772 1541 17 England England NNP 35772 1541 18 , , , 35772 1541 19 and and CC 35772 1541 20 towards towards IN 35772 1541 21 the the DT 35772 1541 22 end end NN 35772 1541 23 of of IN 35772 1541 24 the the DT 35772 1541 25 century century NN 35772 1541 26 critical critical JJ 35772 1541 27 students student NNS 35772 1541 28 of of IN 35772 1541 29 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1541 30 method method NN 35772 1541 31 cast cast VBN 35772 1541 32 doubt doubt NN 35772 1541 33 upon upon IN 35772 1541 34 the the DT 35772 1541 35 _ _ NNP 35772 1541 36 finality finality NN 35772 1541 37 _ _ NNP 35772 1541 38 of of IN 35772 1541 39 the the DT 35772 1541 40 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1541 41 view view NN 35772 1541 42 . . . 35772 1542 1 They -PRON- PRP 35772 1542 2 regarded regard VBD 35772 1542 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1542 4 as as IN 35772 1542 5 artificial artificial JJ 35772 1542 6 , , , 35772 1542 7 abstract abstract JJ 35772 1542 8 , , , 35772 1542 9 and and CC 35772 1542 10 symbolic symbolic JJ 35772 1542 11 only only RB 35772 1542 12 of of IN 35772 1542 13 reality reality NN 35772 1542 14 . . . 35772 1543 1 This this DT 35772 1543 2 critical critical JJ 35772 1543 3 movement movement NN 35772 1543 4 may may MD 35772 1543 5 be be VB 35772 1543 6 associated associate VBN 35772 1543 7 with with IN 35772 1543 8 the the DT 35772 1543 9 names name NNS 35772 1543 10 of of IN 35772 1543 11 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1543 12 , , , 35772 1543 13 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1543 14 , , , 35772 1543 15 and and CC 35772 1543 16 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1543 17 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1543 18 above above IN 35772 1543 19 all all DT 35772 1543 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1543 21 of of IN 35772 1543 22 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1543 23 . . . 35772 1544 1 Moreover moreover RB 35772 1544 2 , , , 35772 1544 3 towards towards IN 35772 1544 4 the the DT 35772 1544 5 end end NN 35772 1544 6 of of IN 35772 1544 7 the the DT 35772 1544 8 century century NN 35772 1544 9 , , , 35772 1544 10 a a DT 35772 1544 11 number number NN 35772 1544 12 of of IN 35772 1544 13 new new JJ 35772 1544 14 facts fact NNS 35772 1544 15 in in IN 35772 1544 16 physics physics NN 35772 1544 17 , , , 35772 1544 18 biology biology NN 35772 1544 19 , , , 35772 1544 20 and and CC 35772 1544 21 psychology psychology NN 35772 1544 22 came come VBD 35772 1544 23 to to IN 35772 1544 24 light light NN 35772 1544 25 and and CC 35772 1544 26 tended tend VBD 35772 1544 27 to to TO 35772 1544 28 discredit discredit VB 35772 1544 29 the the DT 35772 1544 30 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1544 31 view view NN 35772 1544 32 as as IN 35772 1544 33 a a DT 35772 1544 34 final final JJ 35772 1544 35 explanation explanation NN 35772 1544 36 of of IN 35772 1544 37 reality reality NN 35772 1544 38 . . . 35772 1545 1 The the DT 35772 1545 2 indestructibility indestructibility NN 35772 1545 3 of of IN 35772 1545 4 matter matter NN 35772 1545 5 , , , 35772 1545 6 even even RB 35772 1545 7 the the DT 35772 1545 8 conservation conservation NN 35772 1545 9 of of IN 35772 1545 10 energy energy NN 35772 1545 11 and and CC 35772 1545 12 of of IN 35772 1545 13 mass mass NNP 35772 1545 14 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1545 15 corner corner NN 35772 1545 16 stones stone NNS 35772 1545 17 of of IN 35772 1545 18 the the DT 35772 1545 19 mechanico mechanico NNP 35772 1545 20 - - HYPH 35772 1545 21 materialist materialist NNP 35772 1545 22 view view NN 35772 1545 23 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1545 24 began begin VBD 35772 1545 25 openly openly RB 35772 1545 26 to to TO 35772 1545 27 be be VB 35772 1545 28 questioned question VBN 35772 1545 29 , , , 35772 1545 30 not not RB 35772 1545 31 by by IN 35772 1545 32 metaphysicians metaphysician NNS 35772 1545 33 , , , 35772 1545 34 but but CC 35772 1545 35 by by IN 35772 1545 36 men man NNS 35772 1545 37 of of IN 35772 1545 38 science science NN 35772 1545 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1545 40 . . . 35772 1546 1 The the DT 35772 1546 2 foes foe NNS 35772 1546 3 of of IN 35772 1546 4 materialism materialism NN 35772 1546 5 were be VBD 35772 1546 6 those those DT 35772 1546 7 of of IN 35772 1546 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1546 9 own own JJ 35772 1546 10 household household NN 35772 1546 11 . . . 35772 1547 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1547 2 80 80 CD 35772 1547 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1547 4 Thus thus RB 35772 1547 5 assailed assail VBN 35772 1547 6 from from IN 35772 1547 7 without without IN 35772 1547 8 by by IN 35772 1547 9 the the DT 35772 1547 10 philosophers philosopher NNS 35772 1547 11 , , , 35772 1547 12 and and CC 35772 1547 13 from from IN 35772 1547 14 within within IN 35772 1547 15 by by IN 35772 1547 16 the the DT 35772 1547 17 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1547 18 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1547 19 , , , 35772 1547 20 the the DT 35772 1547 21 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1547 22 view view NN 35772 1547 23 , , , 35772 1547 24 after after IN 35772 1547 25 a a DT 35772 1547 26 reign reign NN 35772 1547 27 of of IN 35772 1547 28 three three CD 35772 1547 29 centuries century NNS 35772 1547 30 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1547 31 disturbed disturb VBN 35772 1547 32 though though IN 35772 1547 33 these these DT 35772 1547 34 may may MD 35772 1547 35 have have VB 35772 1547 36 been be VBN 35772 1547 37 by by IN 35772 1547 38 successive successive JJ 35772 1547 39 rebellions rebellion NNS 35772 1547 40 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1547 41 seems seem VBZ 35772 1547 42 destined destine VBN 35772 1547 43 to to TO 35772 1547 44 disappear disappear VB 35772 1547 45 . . . 35772 1548 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1548 2 may may MD 35772 1548 3 indeed indeed RB 35772 1548 4 subsist subsist VB 35772 1548 5 as as IN 35772 1548 6 an an DT 35772 1548 7 approximate approximate JJ 35772 1548 8 and and CC 35772 1548 9 convenient convenient JJ 35772 1548 10 way way NN 35772 1548 11 of of IN 35772 1548 12 regarding regard VBG 35772 1548 13 reality reality NN 35772 1548 14 , , , 35772 1548 15 of of IN 35772 1548 16 which which WDT 35772 1548 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1548 18 will will MD 35772 1548 19 no no RB 35772 1548 20 longer longer RB 35772 1548 21 pretend pretend VB 35772 1548 22 to to TO 35772 1548 23 give give VB 35772 1548 24 an an DT 35772 1548 25 absolute absolute JJ 35772 1548 26 and and CC 35772 1548 27 complete complete JJ 35772 1548 28 account account NN 35772 1548 29 . . . 35772 1549 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1549 2 will will MD 35772 1549 3 continue continue VB 35772 1549 4 to to TO 35772 1549 5 reign reign VB 35772 1549 6 as as IN 35772 1549 7 a a DT 35772 1549 8 constitutional constitutional JJ 35772 1549 9 monarch monarch NN 35772 1549 10 , , , 35772 1549 11 but but CC 35772 1549 12 the the DT 35772 1549 13 days day NNS 35772 1549 14 of of IN 35772 1549 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1549 16 tyranny tyranny NN 35772 1549 17 are be VBP 35772 1549 18 at at IN 35772 1549 19 an an DT 35772 1549 20 end end NN 35772 1549 21 . . . 35772 1550 1 And and CC 35772 1550 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1550 3 is be VBZ 35772 1550 4 not not RB 35772 1550 5 unlikely unlikely JJ 35772 1550 6 that that IN 35772 1550 7 future future JJ 35772 1550 8 generations generation NNS 35772 1550 9 will will MD 35772 1550 10 look look VB 35772 1550 11 with with IN 35772 1550 12 surprise surprise NN 35772 1550 13 upon upon IN 35772 1550 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1550 15 respect respect NN 35772 1550 16 for for IN 35772 1550 17 a a DT 35772 1550 18 theory theory NN 35772 1550 19 which which WDT 35772 1550 20 to to IN 35772 1550 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1550 22 will will MD 35772 1550 23 wear wear VB 35772 1550 24 something something NN 35772 1550 25 of of IN 35772 1550 26 the the DT 35772 1550 27 same same JJ 35772 1550 28 aspect aspect NN 35772 1550 29 as as IN 35772 1550 30 medieval medieval JJ 35772 1550 31 astrology astrology NN 35772 1550 32 now now RB 35772 1550 33 presents present VBZ 35772 1550 34 to to IN 35772 1550 35 ourselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1550 36 . . . 35772 1551 1 SOME SOME NNP 35772 1551 2 DEDUCTIONS.--If DEDUCTIONS.--If NNP 35772 1551 3 the the DT 35772 1551 4 history history NN 35772 1551 5 of of IN 35772 1551 6 thought thought NN 35772 1551 7 showed show VBD 35772 1551 8 no no DT 35772 1551 9 other other JJ 35772 1551 10 results result NNS 35772 1551 11 than than IN 35772 1551 12 the the DT 35772 1551 13 impaired impaired JJ 35772 1551 14 prestige prestige NN 35772 1551 15 of of IN 35772 1551 16 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1551 17 , , , 35772 1551 18 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1551 19 would would MD 35772 1551 20 be be VB 35772 1551 21 worth worth JJ 35772 1551 22 attention attention NN 35772 1551 23 and and CC 35772 1551 24 study study NN 35772 1551 25 . . . 35772 1552 1 The the DT 35772 1552 2 facts fact NNS 35772 1552 3 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 35772 1552 4 compromise compromise VBP 35772 1552 5 that that DT 35772 1552 6 prestige prestige NN 35772 1552 7 , , , 35772 1552 8 for for IN 35772 1552 9 history history NN 35772 1552 10 indicates indicate VBZ 35772 1552 11 that that IN 35772 1552 12 at at IN 35772 1552 13 no no DT 35772 1552 14 period period NN 35772 1552 15 has have VBZ 35772 1552 16 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1552 17 been be VBN 35772 1552 18 able able JJ 35772 1552 19 to to TO 35772 1552 20 impose impose VB 35772 1552 21 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1552 22 permanently permanently RB 35772 1552 23 . . . 35772 1553 1 If if IN 35772 1553 2 there there EX 35772 1553 3 has have VBZ 35772 1553 4 been be VBN 35772 1553 5 a a DT 35772 1553 6 movement movement NN 35772 1553 7 in in IN 35772 1553 8 that that DT 35772 1553 9 direction direction NN 35772 1553 10 , , , 35772 1553 11 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1553 12 has have VBZ 35772 1553 13 elicited elicit VBN 35772 1553 14 a a DT 35772 1553 15 corresponding corresponding JJ 35772 1553 16 reaction reaction NN 35772 1553 17 . . . 35772 1554 1 The the DT 35772 1554 2 human human JJ 35772 1554 3 mind mind NN 35772 1554 4 seems seem VBZ 35772 1554 5 unable unable JJ 35772 1554 6 to to TO 35772 1554 7 remain remain VB 35772 1554 8 satisfied satisfied JJ 35772 1554 9 with with IN 35772 1554 10 the the DT 35772 1554 11 negations negation NNS 35772 1554 12 which which WDT 35772 1554 13 systematised systematise VBD 35772 1554 14 common common JJ 35772 1554 15 sense sense NN 35772 1554 16 seeks seek VBZ 35772 1554 17 to to TO 35772 1554 18 impose impose VB 35772 1554 19 upon upon IN 35772 1554 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1554 21 . . . 35772 1555 1 There there EX 35772 1555 2 is be VBZ 35772 1555 3 an an DT 35772 1555 4 instinctive instinctive JJ 35772 1555 5 appetite appetite NN 35772 1555 6 in in IN 35772 1555 7 humanity humanity NN 35772 1555 8 for for IN 35772 1555 9 a a DT 35772 1555 10 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1555 11 view view NN 35772 1555 12 of of IN 35772 1555 13 things thing NNS 35772 1555 14 , , , 35772 1555 15 and and CC 35772 1555 16 Sabatier Sabatier NNP 35772 1555 17 was be VBD 35772 1555 18 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 35772 1555 19 right right JJ 35772 1555 20 in in IN 35772 1555 21 observing observe VBG 35772 1555 22 that that DT 35772 1555 23 mankind mankind NN 35772 1555 24 is be VBZ 35772 1555 25 " " `` 35772 1555 26 incurably incurably RB 35772 1555 27 religious religious JJ 35772 1555 28 . . . 35772 1555 29 " " '' 35772 1556 1 Neither neither DT 35772 1556 2 Hobbes Hobbes NNP 35772 1556 3 , , , 35772 1556 4 nor nor CC 35772 1556 5 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 1556 6 , , , 35772 1556 7 nor nor CC 35772 1556 8 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 1556 9 , , , 35772 1556 10 with with IN 35772 1556 11 the the DT 35772 1556 12 best good JJS 35772 1556 13 will will NN 35772 1556 14 in in IN 35772 1556 15 the the DT 35772 1556 16 world world NN 35772 1556 17 , , , 35772 1556 18 can can MD 35772 1556 19 exorcise exorcise VB 35772 1556 20 from from IN 35772 1556 21 the the DT 35772 1556 22 human human JJ 35772 1556 23 heart heart NN 35772 1556 24 that that DT 35772 1556 25 instinct instinct NN 35772 1556 26 which which WDT 35772 1556 27 seeks seek VBZ 35772 1556 28 for for IN 35772 1556 29 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1556 30 personal personal JJ 35772 1556 31 relations relation NNS 35772 1556 32 with with IN 35772 1556 33 the the DT 35772 1556 34 universe universe NN 35772 1556 35 -- -- : 35772 1556 36 which which WDT 35772 1556 37 sees see VBZ 35772 1556 38 a a DT 35772 1556 39 mind mind NN 35772 1556 40 behind behind IN 35772 1556 41 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1556 42 . . . 35772 1557 1 This this DT 35772 1557 2 is be VBZ 35772 1557 3 one one CD 35772 1557 4 of of IN 35772 1557 5 those those DT 35772 1557 6 instincts instinct NNS 35772 1557 7 of of IN 35772 1557 8 which which WDT 35772 1557 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1557 10 is be VBZ 35772 1557 11 true true JJ 35772 1557 12 that that IN 35772 1557 13 the the DT 35772 1557 14 more more RBR 35772 1557 15 you -PRON- PRP 35772 1557 16 repress repress VB 35772 1557 17 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1557 18 the the DT 35772 1557 19 more more JJR 35772 1557 20 insurgent insurgent NN 35772 1557 21 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1557 22 become become VBP 35772 1557 23 -- -- : 35772 1557 24 they -PRON- PRP 35772 1557 25 will will MD 35772 1557 26 have have VB 35772 1557 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1557 28 way way NN 35772 1557 29 in in IN 35772 1557 30 the the DT 35772 1557 31 end end NN 35772 1557 32 . . . 35772 1558 1 Thus thus RB 35772 1558 2 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1558 3 , , , 35772 1558 4 blind blind JJ 35772 1558 5 to to IN 35772 1558 6 the the DT 35772 1558 7 mutilation mutilation NN 35772 1558 8 of of IN 35772 1558 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1558 10 nature nature NN 35772 1558 11 of of IN 35772 1558 12 which which WDT 35772 1558 13 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1558 14 is be VBZ 35772 1558 15 guilty guilty JJ 35772 1558 16 , , , 35772 1558 17 is be VBZ 35772 1558 18 psychologically psychologically RB 35772 1558 19 unsound unsound JJ 35772 1558 20 . . . 35772 1559 1 And and CC 35772 1559 2 yet yet RB 35772 1559 3 , , , 35772 1559 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1559 5 nature nature NN 35772 1559 6 is be VBZ 35772 1559 7 not not RB 35772 1559 8 so so RB 35772 1559 9 easily easily RB 35772 1559 10 mutilated mutilate VBN 35772 1559 11 after after RB 35772 1559 12 all all RB 35772 1559 13 . . . 35772 1560 1 Naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1560 2 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1560 3 has have VBZ 35772 1560 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1560 5 in in IN 35772 1560 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1560 7 power power NN 35772 1560 8 to to TO 35772 1560 9 create create VB 35772 1560 10 an an DT 35772 1560 11 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 1560 12 which which WDT 35772 1560 13 is be VBZ 35772 1560 14 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 35772 1560 15 for for IN 35772 1560 16 religion religion NN 35772 1560 17 , , , 35772 1560 18 but but CC 35772 1560 19 that that IN 35772 1560 20 growth growth NN 35772 1560 21 has have VBZ 35772 1560 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1560 23 roots root NNS 35772 1560 24 too too RB 35772 1560 25 deep deep RB 35772 1560 26 for for IN 35772 1560 27 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1560 28 to to TO 35772 1560 29 be be VB 35772 1560 30 easily easily RB 35772 1560 31 destroyed destroy VBN 35772 1560 32 . . . 35772 1561 1 Springing springing NN 35772 1561 2 as as IN 35772 1561 3 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1561 4 does do VBZ 35772 1561 5 from from IN 35772 1561 6 the the DT 35772 1561 7 depths depth NNS 35772 1561 8 of of IN 35772 1561 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1561 10 nature nature NN 35772 1561 11 , , , 35772 1561 12 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1561 13 will will MD 35772 1561 14 prove prove VB 35772 1561 15 as as RB 35772 1561 16 permanent permanent JJ 35772 1561 17 as as IN 35772 1561 18 humanity humanity NN 35772 1561 19 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1561 20 . . . 35772 1562 1 This this DT 35772 1562 2 is be VBZ 35772 1562 3 not not RB 35772 1562 4 to to TO 35772 1562 5 deny deny VB 35772 1562 6 that that IN 35772 1562 7 this this DT 35772 1562 8 type type NN 35772 1562 9 of of IN 35772 1562 10 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1562 11 may may MD 35772 1562 12 do do VB 35772 1562 13 , , , 35772 1562 14 as as IN 35772 1562 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1562 16 actually actually RB 35772 1562 17 has have VBZ 35772 1562 18 done do VBN 35772 1562 19 , , , 35772 1562 20 a a DT 35772 1562 21 great great JJ 35772 1562 22 deal deal NN 35772 1562 23 of of IN 35772 1562 24 harm harm NN 35772 1562 25 . . . 35772 1563 1 A a DT 35772 1563 2 plant plant NN 35772 1563 3 may may MD 35772 1563 4 be be VB 35772 1563 5 strong strong JJ 35772 1563 6 and and CC 35772 1563 7 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 1563 8 , , , 35772 1563 9 but but CC 35772 1563 10 under under IN 35772 1563 11 unceasing uncease VBG 35772 1563 12 bitter bitter JJ 35772 1563 13 weather weather NN 35772 1563 14 , , , 35772 1563 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1563 16 will will MD 35772 1563 17 tend tend VB 35772 1563 18 to to TO 35772 1563 19 become become VB 35772 1563 20 discouraged discouraged JJ 35772 1563 21 . . . 35772 1564 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 35772 1564 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1564 3 would would MD 35772 1564 4 not not RB 35772 1564 5 be be VB 35772 1564 6 worth worth JJ 35772 1564 7 while while IN 35772 1564 8 to to TO 35772 1564 9 write write VB 35772 1564 10 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 1564 11 of of IN 35772 1564 12 naturalism naturalism NN 35772 1564 13 . . . 35772 1565 1 FREEDOM.--Perhaps freedom.--perhaps IN 35772 1565 2 the the DT 35772 1565 3 best good JJS 35772 1565 4 service service NN 35772 1565 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1565 6 can can MD 35772 1565 7 do do VB 35772 1565 8 is be VBZ 35772 1565 9 to to TO 35772 1565 10 protest protest VB 35772 1565 11 against against IN 35772 1565 12 indulging indulge VBG 35772 1565 13 an an DT 35772 1565 14 appetite appetite NN 35772 1565 15 for for IN 35772 1565 16 negative negative JJ 35772 1565 17 dogmatism dogmatism NN 35772 1565 18 . . . 35772 1566 1 Such such PDT 35772 1566 2 an an DT 35772 1566 3 attitude attitude NN 35772 1566 4 is be VBZ 35772 1566 5 a a DT 35772 1566 6 negation negation NN 35772 1566 7 of of IN 35772 1566 8 the the DT 35772 1566 9 freedom freedom NN 35772 1566 10 of of IN 35772 1566 11 thought thought NN 35772 1566 12 . . . 35772 1567 1 And and CC 35772 1567 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1567 3 is be VBZ 35772 1567 4 in in IN 35772 1567 5 an an DT 35772 1567 6 atmosphere atmosphere NN 35772 1567 7 of of IN 35772 1567 8 freedom freedom NN 35772 1567 9 that that IN 35772 1567 10 both both DT 35772 1567 11 religion religion NN 35772 1567 12 and and CC 35772 1567 13 science science NN 35772 1567 14 flourish flourish VBP 35772 1567 15 best best RB 35772 1567 16 . . . 35772 1568 1 A a DT 35772 1568 2 hard hard JJ 35772 1568 3 and and CC 35772 1568 4 fast fast JJ 35772 1568 5 naturalistic naturalistic JJ 35772 1568 6 outlook outlook NN 35772 1568 7 may may MD 35772 1568 8 prove prove VB 35772 1568 9 , , , 35772 1568 10 and and CC 35772 1568 11 actually actually RB 35772 1568 12 has have VBZ 35772 1568 13 proved prove VBN 35772 1568 14 , , , 35772 1568 15 an an DT 35772 1568 16 incubus incubus NN 35772 1568 17 from from IN 35772 1568 18 which which WDT 35772 1568 19 even even RB 35772 1568 20 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1568 21 themselves -PRON- PRP 35772 1568 22 may may MD 35772 1568 23 pray pray VB 35772 1568 24 to to TO 35772 1568 25 be be VB 35772 1568 26 delivered deliver VBN 35772 1568 27 . . . 35772 1569 1 Nor nor CC 35772 1569 2 has have VBZ 35772 1569 3 religion religion NN 35772 1569 4 always always RB 35772 1569 5 enjoyed enjoy VBN 35772 1569 6 that that IN 35772 1569 7 full full JJ 35772 1569 8 measure measure NN 35772 1569 9 of of IN 35772 1569 10 freedom freedom NN 35772 1569 11 which which WDT 35772 1569 12 is be VBZ 35772 1569 13 indispensable indispensable JJ 35772 1569 14 to to IN 35772 1569 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1569 16 vigorous vigorous JJ 35772 1569 17 life life NN 35772 1569 18 . . . 35772 1570 1 The the DT 35772 1570 2 curious curious JJ 35772 1570 3 and and CC 35772 1570 4 sad sad JJ 35772 1570 5 fact fact NN 35772 1570 6 is be VBZ 35772 1570 7 that that IN 35772 1570 8 the the DT 35772 1570 9 human human JJ 35772 1570 10 mind mind NN 35772 1570 11 seems seem VBZ 35772 1570 12 to to TO 35772 1570 13 delight delight VB 35772 1570 14 in in IN 35772 1570 15 creating create VBG 35772 1570 16 prisons prison NNS 35772 1570 17 for for IN 35772 1570 18 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1570 19 . . . 35772 1571 1 The the DT 35772 1571 2 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1571 3 spirit spirit NN 35772 1571 4 created create VBD 35772 1571 5 a a DT 35772 1571 6 mechanico mechanico NN 35772 1571 7 - - HYPH 35772 1571 8 materialistic materialistic JJ 35772 1571 9 scheme scheme NN 35772 1571 10 which which WDT 35772 1571 11 has have VBZ 35772 1571 12 ended end VBN 35772 1571 13 by by IN 35772 1571 14 becoming become VBG 35772 1571 15 the the DT 35772 1571 16 enemy enemy NN 35772 1571 17 of of IN 35772 1571 18 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1571 19 research research NN 35772 1571 20 , , , 35772 1571 21 and and CC 35772 1571 22 which which WDT 35772 1571 23 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1571 24 besides besides IN 35772 1571 25 this this DT 35772 1571 26 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1571 27 asks ask VBZ 35772 1571 28 , , , 35772 1571 29 as as IN 35772 1571 30 a a DT 35772 1571 31 sacrifice sacrifice NN 35772 1571 32 , , , 35772 1571 33 the the DT 35772 1571 34 mutilation mutilation NN 35772 1571 35 of of IN 35772 1571 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1571 37 spiritual spiritual JJ 35772 1571 38 instincts instinct NNS 35772 1571 39 . . . 35772 1572 1 And and CC 35772 1572 2 so so RB 35772 1572 3 with with IN 35772 1572 4 religion religion NN 35772 1572 5 . . . 35772 1573 1 The the DT 35772 1573 2 religious religious JJ 35772 1573 3 instinct instinct NN 35772 1573 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1573 5 like like IN 35772 1573 6 the the DT 35772 1573 7 scientific scientific NN 35772 1573 8 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1573 9 tends tend VBZ 35772 1573 10 to to TO 35772 1573 11 create create VB 35772 1573 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1573 13 prisons prison NNS 35772 1573 14 . . . 35772 1574 1 The the DT 35772 1574 2 pride pride NN 35772 1574 3 of of IN 35772 1574 4 , , , 35772 1574 5 a a DT 35772 1574 6 pretended pretend VBN 35772 1574 7 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1574 8 reduces reduce NNS 35772 1574 9 to to IN 35772 1574 10 a a DT 35772 1574 11 mechanical mechanical JJ 35772 1574 12 scheme scheme NN 35772 1574 13 the the DT 35772 1574 14 mysteries mystery NNS 35772 1574 15 of of IN 35772 1574 16 life life NN 35772 1574 17 and and CC 35772 1574 18 death death NN 35772 1574 19 ; ; : 35772 1574 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1574 21 provides provide VBZ 35772 1574 22 superficial superficial JJ 35772 1574 23 standardised standardised JJ 35772 1574 24 solutions solution NNS 35772 1574 25 for for IN 35772 1574 26 the the DT 35772 1574 27 problems problem NNS 35772 1574 28 of of IN 35772 1574 29 existence existence NN 35772 1574 30 . . . 35772 1575 1 Of of RB 35772 1575 2 course course RB 35772 1575 3 , , , 35772 1575 4 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1575 5 is be VBZ 35772 1575 6 clear clear JJ 35772 1575 7 enough enough RB 35772 1575 8 , , , 35772 1575 9 that that IN 35772 1575 10 in in IN 35772 1575 11 religion religion NN 35772 1575 12 as as IN 35772 1575 13 in in IN 35772 1575 14 science science NN 35772 1575 15 , , , 35772 1575 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1575 17 can can MD 35772 1575 18 not not RB 35772 1575 19 , , , 35772 1575 20 even even RB 35772 1575 21 if if IN 35772 1575 22 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1575 23 would would MD 35772 1575 24 , , , 35772 1575 25 start start VB 35772 1575 26 each each DT 35772 1575 27 of of IN 35772 1575 28 us -PRON- PRP 35772 1575 29 from from IN 35772 1575 30 the the DT 35772 1575 31 beginning beginning NN 35772 1575 32 . . . 35772 1576 1 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1576 2 have have VBP 35772 1576 3 to to TO 35772 1576 4 accept accept VB 35772 1576 5 and and CC 35772 1576 6 to to TO 35772 1576 7 revere revere VB 35772 1576 8 the the DT 35772 1576 9 riches rich NNS 35772 1576 10 of of IN 35772 1576 11 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1576 12 and and CC 35772 1576 13 experience experience NN 35772 1576 14 accumulated accumulate VBN 35772 1576 15 by by IN 35772 1576 16 those those DT 35772 1576 17 who who WP 35772 1576 18 have have VBP 35772 1576 19 gone go VBN 35772 1576 20 before before RB 35772 1576 21 . . . 35772 1577 1 And and CC 35772 1577 2 yet yet RB 35772 1577 3 , , , 35772 1577 4 in in IN 35772 1577 5 religion religion NN 35772 1577 6 as as IN 35772 1577 7 in in IN 35772 1577 8 science science NN 35772 1577 9 , , , 35772 1577 10 life life NN 35772 1577 11 consists consist VBZ 35772 1577 12 in in IN 35772 1577 13 movement movement NN 35772 1577 14 ; ; : 35772 1577 15 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1577 16 must must MD 35772 1577 17 go go VB 35772 1577 18 forward forward RB 35772 1577 19 . . . 35772 1578 1 The the DT 35772 1578 2 past past NN 35772 1578 3 may may MD 35772 1578 4 be be VB 35772 1578 5 an an DT 35772 1578 6 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 1578 7 , , , 35772 1578 8 but but CC 35772 1578 9 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1578 10 must must MD 35772 1578 11 not not RB 35772 1578 12 be be VB 35772 1578 13 the the DT 35772 1578 14 limit limit NN 35772 1578 15 of of IN 35772 1578 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1578 17 thought thought NN 35772 1578 18 , , , 35772 1578 19 or or CC 35772 1578 20 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1578 21 becomes become VBZ 35772 1578 22 an an DT 35772 1578 23 incubus incubus NN 35772 1578 24 . . . 35772 1579 1 The the DT 35772 1579 2 glance glance NN 35772 1579 3 must must MD 35772 1579 4 be be VB 35772 1579 5 forward forward RB 35772 1579 6 not not RB 35772 1579 7 backward backward JJ 35772 1579 8 ; ; : 35772 1579 9 the the DT 35772 1579 10 stream stream NN 35772 1579 11 flows flow VBZ 35772 1579 12 , , , 35772 1579 13 and and CC 35772 1579 14 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1579 15 are be VBP 35772 1579 16 borne bear VBN 35772 1579 17 on on IN 35772 1579 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1579 19 bosom bosom NN 35772 1579 20 . . . 35772 1580 1 Humanity humanity NN 35772 1580 2 , , , 35772 1580 3 like like IN 35772 1580 4 an an DT 35772 1580 5 explorer explorer NN 35772 1580 6 , , , 35772 1580 7 has have VBZ 35772 1580 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1580 9 face face NN 35772 1580 10 set set VBN 35772 1580 11 towards towards IN 35772 1580 12 the the DT 35772 1580 13 unknown unknown NN 35772 1580 14 . . . 35772 1581 1 Both both DT 35772 1581 2 science science NN 35772 1581 3 and and CC 35772 1581 4 religion religion NN 35772 1581 5 are be VBP 35772 1581 6 children child NNS 35772 1581 7 of of IN 35772 1581 8 freedom freedom NN 35772 1581 9 , , , 35772 1581 10 without without IN 35772 1581 11 which which WDT 35772 1581 12 the the DT 35772 1581 13 creative creative JJ 35772 1581 14 spirit spirit NN 35772 1581 15 in in IN 35772 1581 16 man man NN 35772 1581 17 is be VBZ 35772 1581 18 crushed crush VBN 35772 1581 19 . . . 35772 1582 1 And and CC 35772 1582 2 here here RB 35772 1582 3 , , , 35772 1582 4 with with IN 35772 1582 5 this this DT 35772 1582 6 note note NN 35772 1582 7 of of IN 35772 1582 8 warning warning NN 35772 1582 9 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1582 10 though though IN 35772 1582 11 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1582 12 rather rather RB 35772 1582 13 of of IN 35772 1582 14 encouragement encouragement NN 35772 1582 15 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1582 16 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1582 17 may may MD 35772 1582 18 close close VB 35772 1582 19 . . . 35772 1583 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 35772 1583 2 : : : 35772 1583 3 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1583 4 1 1 CD 35772 1583 5 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1583 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1583 7 The the DT 35772 1583 8 Grammar Grammar NNP 35772 1583 9 of of IN 35772 1583 10 Science Science NNP 35772 1583 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1583 12 , , , 35772 1583 13 pp pp NNP 35772 1583 14 . . . 35772 1584 1 12 12 CD 35772 1584 2 , , , 35772 1584 3 13 13 CD 35772 1584 4 . . . 35772 1585 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1585 2 2 2 LS 35772 1585 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1585 4 Ptolemy Ptolemy NNP 35772 1585 5 of of IN 35772 1585 6 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 35772 1585 7 : : : 35772 1585 8 127 127 CD 35772 1585 9 - - SYM 35772 1585 10 151 151 CD 35772 1585 11 A.D. A.D. NNP 35772 1585 12 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1585 13 3 3 CD 35772 1585 14 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1585 15 J. J. NNP 35772 1585 16 M. M. NNP 35772 1585 17 Heald Heald NNP 35772 1585 18 in in IN 35772 1585 19 art art NN 35772 1585 20 . . . 35772 1586 1 " " `` 35772 1586 2 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 1586 3 " " '' 35772 1586 4 in in IN 35772 1586 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1586 6 Encyclopædia Encyclopædia NNP 35772 1586 7 of of IN 35772 1586 8 Religion Religion NNP 35772 1586 9 and and CC 35772 1586 10 Ethics Ethics NNP 35772 1586 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1586 12 . . . 35772 1587 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1587 2 4 4 CD 35772 1587 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1587 4 Monks monk NNS 35772 1587 5 and and CC 35772 1587 6 theologians theologian NNS 35772 1587 7 were be VBD 35772 1587 8 betrayed betray VBN 35772 1587 9 into into IN 35772 1587 10 some some DT 35772 1587 11 controversial controversial JJ 35772 1587 12 asperities asperity NNS 35772 1587 13 . . . 35772 1588 1 " " `` 35772 1588 2 Ye Ye NNP 35772 1588 3 men man NNS 35772 1588 4 of of IN 35772 1588 5 Galilee Galilee NNP 35772 1588 6 , , , 35772 1588 7 why why WRB 35772 1588 8 stand stand VB 35772 1588 9 ye ye NNP 35772 1588 10 gazing gaze VBG 35772 1588 11 up up RP 35772 1588 12 into into IN 35772 1588 13 heaven heaven NN 35772 1588 14 " " '' 35772 1588 15 formed form VBD 35772 1588 16 the the DT 35772 1588 17 appropriate appropriate JJ 35772 1588 18 text text NN 35772 1588 19 for for IN 35772 1588 20 a a DT 35772 1588 21 sermon sermon NN 35772 1588 22 by by IN 35772 1588 23 a a DT 35772 1588 24 Dominican Dominican NNP 35772 1588 25 . . . 35772 1589 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1589 2 5 5 CD 35772 1589 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1589 4 In in IN 35772 1589 5 spite spite NN 35772 1589 6 of of IN 35772 1589 7 this this DT 35772 1589 8 , , , 35772 1589 9 however however RB 35772 1589 10 , , , 35772 1589 11 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 1589 12 ' ' POS 35772 1589 13 works work NNS 35772 1589 14 , , , 35772 1589 15 in in IN 35772 1589 16 1663 1663 CD 35772 1589 17 , , , 35772 1589 18 appeared appear VBD 35772 1589 19 in in IN 35772 1589 20 the the DT 35772 1589 21 Index Index NNP 35772 1589 22 of of IN 35772 1589 23 forbidden forbid VBN 35772 1589 24 books book NNS 35772 1589 25 : : : 35772 1589 26 and and CC 35772 1589 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1589 28 doctrines doctrine NNS 35772 1589 29 were be VBD 35772 1589 30 banned ban VBN 35772 1589 31 by by IN 35772 1589 32 Royal Royal NNP 35772 1589 33 decree decree NN 35772 1589 34 from from IN 35772 1589 35 the the DT 35772 1589 36 French french JJ 35772 1589 37 universities university NNS 35772 1589 38 . . . 35772 1590 1 Jesuit jesuit NN 35772 1590 2 influences influence NNS 35772 1590 3 , , , 35772 1590 4 which which WDT 35772 1590 5 were be VBD 35772 1590 6 not not RB 35772 1590 7 at at RB 35772 1590 8 all all RB 35772 1590 9 favourable favourable JJ 35772 1590 10 to to IN 35772 1590 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1590 12 native native JJ 35772 1590 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1590 14 religion religion NN 35772 1590 15 in in IN 35772 1590 16 France France NNP 35772 1590 17 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1590 18 or or CC 35772 1590 19 elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1590 20 ! ! . 35772 1591 1 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1591 2 , , , 35772 1591 3 may may MD 35772 1591 4 have have VB 35772 1591 5 been be VBN 35772 1591 6 responsible responsible JJ 35772 1591 7 for for IN 35772 1591 8 this this DT 35772 1591 9 obscurantist obscurantist JJ 35772 1591 10 policy policy NN 35772 1591 11 . . . 35772 1592 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1592 2 6 6 CD 35772 1592 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1592 4 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1592 5 , , , 35772 1592 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1592 7 History history NN 35772 1592 8 of of IN 35772 1592 9 European European NNP 35772 1592 10 Thought Thought NNP 35772 1592 11 in in IN 35772 1592 12 the the DT 35772 1592 13 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 35772 1592 14 Century Century NNP 35772 1592 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1592 16 , , , 35772 1592 17 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1592 18 . . . 35772 1593 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1593 2 , , , 35772 1593 3 p. p. NN 35772 1593 4 384 384 CD 35772 1593 5 . . . 35772 1594 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1594 2 7 7 CD 35772 1594 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1594 4 Quoted quote VBN 35772 1594 5 by by IN 35772 1594 6 Ward Ward NNP 35772 1594 7 , , , 35772 1594 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1594 9 Naturalism Naturalism NNP 35772 1594 10 and and CC 35772 1594 11 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 1594 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1594 13 , , , 35772 1594 14 p. p. NN 35772 1594 15 4 4 CD 35772 1594 16 . . . 35772 1595 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1595 2 8 8 CD 35772 1595 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1595 4 Höffding höffding NN 35772 1595 5 , , , 35772 1595 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1595 7 History history NN 35772 1595 8 of of IN 35772 1595 9 Modern Modern NNP 35772 1595 10 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1595 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1595 12 , , , 35772 1595 13 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1595 14 . . . 35772 1596 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1596 2 , , , 35772 1596 3 p. p. NN 35772 1596 4 315 315 CD 35772 1596 5 . . . 35772 1597 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1597 2 may may MD 35772 1597 3 set set VB 35772 1597 4 the the DT 35772 1597 5 scruples scruple NNS 35772 1597 6 of of IN 35772 1597 7 some some DT 35772 1597 8 at at IN 35772 1597 9 rest rest NN 35772 1597 10 to to TO 35772 1597 11 be be VB 35772 1597 12 reminded remind VBN 35772 1597 13 that that IN 35772 1597 14 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 1597 15 himself -PRON- PRP 35772 1597 16 applied apply VBD 35772 1597 17 the the DT 35772 1597 18 term term NN 35772 1597 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1597 20 Natura Natura NNP 35772 1597 21 Naturans Naturans NNPS 35772 1597 22 _ _ NNP 35772 1597 23 to to IN 35772 1597 24 God God NNP 35772 1597 25 as as IN 35772 1597 26 the the DT 35772 1597 27 cause cause NN 35772 1597 28 of of IN 35772 1597 29 all all DT 35772 1597 30 existence existence NN 35772 1597 31 . . . 35772 1598 1 Eckhart eckhart NN 35772 1598 2 and and CC 35772 1598 3 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 1598 4 had have VBD 35772 1598 5 made make VBN 35772 1598 6 a a DT 35772 1598 7 similar similar JJ 35772 1598 8 application application NN 35772 1598 9 of of IN 35772 1598 10 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1598 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1598 12 cf cf UH 35772 1598 13 . . . 35772 1599 1 Martineau Martineau NNP 35772 1599 2 , , , 35772 1599 3 _ _ NNP 35772 1599 4 Study Study NNP 35772 1599 5 of of IN 35772 1599 6 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 1599 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1599 8 , , , 35772 1599 9 p. p. NN 35772 1599 10 226 226 CD 35772 1599 11 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1599 12 . . . 35772 1600 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1600 2 9 9 CD 35772 1600 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1600 4 Here here RB 35772 1600 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1600 6 may may MD 35772 1600 7 note note VB 35772 1600 8 , , , 35772 1600 9 by by IN 35772 1600 10 way way NN 35772 1600 11 of of IN 35772 1600 12 an an DT 35772 1600 13 anticipation anticipation NN 35772 1600 14 , , , 35772 1600 15 a a DT 35772 1600 16 truth truth NN 35772 1600 17 that that WDT 35772 1600 18 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1600 19 afterwards afterwards RB 35772 1600 20 was be VBD 35772 1600 21 the the DT 35772 1600 22 first first JJ 35772 1600 23 to to TO 35772 1600 24 grasp grasp VB 35772 1600 25 clearly clearly RB 35772 1600 26 : : : 35772 1600 27 that that IN 35772 1600 28 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1600 29 is be VBZ 35772 1600 30 only only RB 35772 1600 31 when when WRB 35772 1600 32 the the DT 35772 1600 33 mechanism mechanism NN 35772 1600 34 of of IN 35772 1600 35 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1600 36 is be VBZ 35772 1600 37 proved prove VBN 35772 1600 38 , , , 35772 1600 39 that that IN 35772 1600 40 religion religion NN 35772 1600 41 can can MD 35772 1600 42 be be VB 35772 1600 43 purged purge VBN 35772 1600 44 of of IN 35772 1600 45 materialism materialism NN 35772 1600 46 . . . 35772 1601 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1601 2 10 10 CD 35772 1601 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1601 4 Cf cf NN 35772 1601 5 . . . 35772 1602 1 letter letter NN 35772 1602 2 to to IN 35772 1602 3 Arnauld Arnauld NNP 35772 1602 4 , , , 35772 1602 5 quoted quote VBN 35772 1602 6 by by IN 35772 1602 7 Höffding Höffding NNP 35772 1602 8 , , , 35772 1602 9 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1602 10 , , , 35772 1602 11 p. p. NN 35772 1602 12 347 347 CD 35772 1602 13 : : : 35772 1602 14 " " `` 35772 1602 15 The the DT 35772 1602 16 substantial substantial JJ 35772 1602 17 unity unity NN 35772 1602 18 presupposes presuppose VBZ 35772 1602 19 a a DT 35772 1602 20 complete complete JJ 35772 1602 21 , , , 35772 1602 22 indivisible indivisible JJ 35772 1602 23 being being NN 35772 1602 24 . . . 35772 1603 1 Nothing nothing NN 35772 1603 2 of of IN 35772 1603 3 this this DT 35772 1603 4 kind kind NN 35772 1603 5 is be VBZ 35772 1603 6 to to TO 35772 1603 7 be be VB 35772 1603 8 found find VBN 35772 1603 9 in in IN 35772 1603 10 figure figure NN 35772 1603 11 or or CC 35772 1603 12 motion motion NN 35772 1603 13 ... ... NFP 35772 1603 14 but but CC 35772 1603 15 only only RB 35772 1603 16 in in IN 35772 1603 17 a a DT 35772 1603 18 soul soul NN 35772 1603 19 or or CC 35772 1603 20 a a DT 35772 1603 21 substantial substantial JJ 35772 1603 22 form form NN 35772 1603 23 similar similar JJ 35772 1603 24 to to IN 35772 1603 25 that that DT 35772 1603 26 which which WDT 35772 1603 27 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1603 28 call call VBP 35772 1603 29 an an DT 35772 1603 30 ' ' `` 35772 1603 31 I. i. NN 35772 1603 32 ' ' '' 35772 1603 33 " " '' 35772 1604 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1604 2 11 11 CD 35772 1604 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1604 4 The the DT 35772 1604 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1604 6 Monadology Monadology NNP 35772 1604 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1604 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1604 9 quoted quote VBN 35772 1604 10 by by IN 35772 1604 11 Pattison Pattison NNP 35772 1604 12 , , , 35772 1604 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1604 14 Idea Idea NNP 35772 1604 15 of of IN 35772 1604 16 God God NNP 35772 1604 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1604 18 , , , 35772 1604 19 p. p. NN 35772 1604 20 180 180 CD 35772 1604 21 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1604 22 . . . 35772 1605 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1605 2 12 12 CD 35772 1605 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1605 4 Inge Inge NNP 35772 1605 5 , , , 35772 1605 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1605 7 Christian Christian NNP 35772 1605 8 Mysticism Mysticism NNP 35772 1605 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1605 10 , , , 35772 1605 11 p. p. NN 35772 1605 12 19 19 CD 35772 1605 13 . . . 35772 1606 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1606 2 13 13 CD 35772 1606 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1606 4 Cf Cf NNP 35772 1606 5 . . . 35772 1607 1 " " `` 35772 1607 2 With with IN 35772 1607 3 space space NN 35772 1607 4 the the DT 35772 1607 5 universe universe NN 35772 1607 6 encloses enclose VBZ 35772 1607 7 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1607 8 and and CC 35772 1607 9 engulfs engulf VBZ 35772 1607 10 me -PRON- PRP 35772 1607 11 like like IN 35772 1607 12 an an DT 35772 1607 13 atom atom NN 35772 1607 14 , , , 35772 1607 15 but but CC 35772 1607 16 with with IN 35772 1607 17 thought thought NN 35772 1607 18 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1607 19 enclose enclose VBP 35772 1607 20 the the DT 35772 1607 21 universe universe NN 35772 1607 22 . . . 35772 1607 23 " " '' 35772 1608 1 A a DT 35772 1608 2 great great JJ 35772 1608 3 saying saying NN 35772 1608 4 . . . 35772 1609 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1609 2 14 14 CD 35772 1609 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1609 4 Novalis Novalis NNP 35772 1609 5 called call VBD 35772 1609 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1609 7 " " `` 35772 1609 8 the the DT 35772 1609 9 God God NNP 35772 1609 10 - - HYPH 35772 1609 11 intoxicated intoxicate VBN 35772 1609 12 " " '' 35772 1609 13 : : : 35772 1609 14 a a DT 35772 1609 15 bold bold JJ 35772 1609 16 phrase phrase NN 35772 1609 17 . . . 35772 1610 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1610 2 15 15 CD 35772 1610 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1610 4 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1610 5 refer refer VBP 35772 1610 6 , , , 35772 1610 7 of of IN 35772 1610 8 course course NN 35772 1610 9 , , , 35772 1610 10 to to IN 35772 1610 11 the the DT 35772 1610 12 promulgation promulgation NN 35772 1610 13 of of IN 35772 1610 14 the the DT 35772 1610 15 Bull Bull NNP 35772 1610 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1610 17 Unigenitus Unigenitus NNP 35772 1610 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1610 19 , , , 35772 1610 20 procured procure VBN 35772 1610 21 from from IN 35772 1610 22 Pope Pope NNP 35772 1610 23 Clement Clement NNP 35772 1610 24 XI XI NNP 35772 1610 25 by by IN 35772 1610 26 the the DT 35772 1610 27 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 35772 1610 28 ; ; : 35772 1610 29 when when WRB 35772 1610 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1610 31 opponents opponent NNS 35772 1610 32 , , , 35772 1610 33 the the DT 35772 1610 34 Jansenists Jansenists NNPS 35772 1610 35 " " '' 35772 1610 36 of of IN 35772 1610 37 all all DT 35772 1610 38 professions profession NNS 35772 1610 39 and and CC 35772 1610 40 classes class NNS 35772 1610 41 , , , 35772 1610 42 were be VBD 35772 1610 43 subjected subject VBN 35772 1610 44 to to IN 35772 1610 45 imprisonment imprisonment NN 35772 1610 46 , , , 35772 1610 47 confiscation confiscation NN 35772 1610 48 , , , 35772 1610 49 and and CC 35772 1610 50 every every DT 35772 1610 51 species species NN 35772 1610 52 of of IN 35772 1610 53 oppression oppression NN 35772 1610 54 " " '' 35772 1610 55 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1610 56 Jervis Jervis NNP 35772 1610 57 , , , 35772 1610 58 _ _ NNP 35772 1610 59 Student Student NNP 35772 1610 60 's 's POS 35772 1610 61 History history NN 35772 1610 62 of of IN 35772 1610 63 France France NNP 35772 1610 64 _ _ NNP 35772 1610 65 , , , 35772 1610 66 p. p. NN 35772 1610 67 415 415 CD 35772 1610 68 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1610 69 . . . 35772 1611 1 The the DT 35772 1611 2 manoeuvre manoeuvre NN 35772 1611 3 is be VBZ 35772 1611 4 characterised characterise VBN 35772 1611 5 by by IN 35772 1611 6 another another DT 35772 1611 7 historian historian NN 35772 1611 8 as as IN 35772 1611 9 a a DT 35772 1611 10 " " `` 35772 1611 11 struggle struggle NN 35772 1611 12 of of IN 35772 1611 13 narrow narrow JJ 35772 1611 14 - - HYPH 35772 1611 15 minded minded JJ 35772 1611 16 fanaticism fanaticism NN 35772 1611 17 , , , 35772 1611 18 allied ally VBN 35772 1611 19 to to IN 35772 1611 20 absolutely absolutely RB 35772 1611 21 unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ 35772 1611 22 political political JJ 35772 1611 23 ambition ambition NN 35772 1611 24 , , , 35772 1611 25 against against IN 35772 1611 26 all all PDT 35772 1611 27 the the DT 35772 1611 28 learning learning NN 35772 1611 29 and and CC 35772 1611 30 virtue virtue NN 35772 1611 31 which which WDT 35772 1611 32 the the DT 35772 1611 33 French french JJ 35772 1611 34 clergy clergy NNS 35772 1611 35 still still RB 35772 1611 36 possessed possess VBD 35772 1611 37 " " '' 35772 1611 38 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1611 39 Chamberlain Chamberlain NNP 35772 1611 40 , , , 35772 1611 41 _ _ NNP 35772 1611 42 Foundations Foundations NNPS 35772 1611 43 of of IN 35772 1611 44 the the DT 35772 1611 45 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 35772 1611 46 Century Century NNP 35772 1611 47 _ _ NNP 35772 1611 48 , , , 35772 1611 49 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1611 50 . . . 35772 1612 1 II II NNP 35772 1612 2 , , , 35772 1612 3 p. p. NN 35772 1612 4 379 379 CD 35772 1612 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1612 6 . . . 35772 1613 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1613 2 16 16 CD 35772 1613 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1613 4 Even even RB 35772 1613 5 before before IN 35772 1613 6 the the DT 35772 1613 7 age age NN 35772 1613 8 of of IN 35772 1613 9 the the DT 35772 1613 10 Revolution Revolution NNP 35772 1613 11 , , , 35772 1613 12 Paris Paris NNP 35772 1613 13 possessed possess VBD 35772 1613 14 many many JJ 35772 1613 15 great great JJ 35772 1613 16 schools school NNS 35772 1613 17 . . . 35772 1614 1 The the DT 35772 1614 2 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 3 Collège Collège NNP 35772 1614 4 de de IN 35772 1614 5 France France NNP 35772 1614 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 7 was be VBD 35772 1614 8 founded found VBN 35772 1614 9 in in IN 35772 1614 10 1530 1530 CD 35772 1614 11 ; ; : 35772 1614 12 there there EX 35772 1614 13 was be VBD 35772 1614 14 the the DT 35772 1614 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 16 College College NNP 35772 1614 17 et et NNP 35772 1614 18 École École NNP 35772 1614 19 de de NNP 35772 1614 20 Chirurgie Chirurgie NNP 35772 1614 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 22 , , , 35772 1614 23 the the DT 35772 1614 24 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 25 Jardin Jardin NNP 35772 1614 26 des des NNP 35772 1614 27 Plantes Plantes NNP 35772 1614 28 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 29 , , , 35772 1614 30 the the DT 35772 1614 31 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 32 École École NNP 35772 1614 33 royale royale NNP 35772 1614 34 des des NNP 35772 1614 35 Mines Mines NNP 35772 1614 36 _ _ NNP 35772 1614 37 , , , 35772 1614 38 etc etc FW 35772 1614 39 . . . 35772 1615 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1615 2 cf cf NN 35772 1615 3 . . . 35772 1616 1 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1616 2 , , , 35772 1616 3 _ _ NNP 35772 1616 4 History history NN 35772 1616 5 of of IN 35772 1616 6 European European NNP 35772 1616 7 Thought Thought NNP 35772 1616 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1616 9 , , , 35772 1616 10 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1616 11 . . . 35772 1617 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1617 2 , , , 35772 1617 3 p. p. NN 35772 1617 4 107 107 CD 35772 1617 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1617 6 . . . 35772 1618 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1618 2 17 17 CD 35772 1618 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1618 4 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1618 5 says say VBZ 35772 1618 6 of of IN 35772 1618 7 Newton Newton NNP 35772 1618 8 : : : 35772 1618 9 " " `` 35772 1618 10 In in IN 35772 1618 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1618 12 own own JJ 35772 1618 13 country country NN 35772 1618 14 that that WDT 35772 1618 15 fruitful fruitful JJ 35772 1618 16 co co NN 35772 1618 17 - - NN 35772 1618 18 operation operation NN 35772 1618 19 which which WDT 35772 1618 20 can can MD 35772 1618 21 only only RB 35772 1618 22 be be VB 35772 1618 23 secured secure VBN 35772 1618 24 by by IN 35772 1618 25 an an DT 35772 1618 26 academic academic JJ 35772 1618 27 organisation organisation NN 35772 1618 28 and and CC 35772 1618 29 by by IN 35772 1618 30 endowment endowment NN 35772 1618 31 of of IN 35772 1618 32 research research NN 35772 1618 33 was be VBD 35772 1618 34 wanting want VBG 35772 1618 35 " " `` 35772 1618 36 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1618 37 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1618 38 , , , 35772 1618 39 p. p. NN 35772 1618 40 99 99 CD 35772 1618 41 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1618 42 . . . 35772 1619 1 As as RB 35772 1619 2 late late RB 35772 1619 3 as as IN 35772 1619 4 1740 1740 CD 35772 1619 5 the the DT 35772 1619 6 whole whole JJ 35772 1619 7 revenue revenue NN 35772 1619 8 of of IN 35772 1619 9 the the DT 35772 1619 10 Royal Royal NNP 35772 1619 11 Society Society NNP 35772 1619 12 was be VBD 35772 1619 13 only only RB 35772 1619 14 £ £ $ 35772 1619 15 232 232 CD 35772 1619 16 _ _ NN 35772 1619 17 per per IN 35772 1619 18 annum annum FW 35772 1619 19 _ _ NNP 35772 1619 20 . . . 35772 1620 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1620 2 18 18 CD 35772 1620 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1620 4 Morley Morley NNP 35772 1620 5 , , , 35772 1620 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1620 7 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 1620 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1620 9 , , , 35772 1620 10 p. p. NN 35772 1620 11 41 41 CD 35772 1620 12 . . . 35772 1621 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1621 2 19 19 CD 35772 1621 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1621 4 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1621 5 published publish VBD 35772 1621 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1621 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1621 8 Élémens Élémens NNP 35772 1621 9 de de NNP 35772 1621 10 la la NNP 35772 1621 11 Philosophie Philosophie NNP 35772 1621 12 de de NNP 35772 1621 13 Newton Newton NNP 35772 1621 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1621 15 in in IN 35772 1621 16 1738 1738 CD 35772 1621 17 . . . 35772 1622 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1622 2 20 20 CD 35772 1622 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1622 4 Höffding Höffding NNP 35772 1622 5 , , , 35772 1622 6 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1622 7 . . . 35772 1623 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1623 2 , , , 35772 1623 3 p. p. NN 35772 1623 4 481 481 CD 35772 1623 5 . . . 35772 1624 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1624 2 21 21 CD 35772 1624 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1624 4 See see VB 35772 1624 5 note note NN 35772 1624 6 in in IN 35772 1624 7 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1624 8 , , , 35772 1624 9 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1624 10 . . . 35772 1625 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1625 2 , , , 35772 1625 3 p. p. NN 35772 1625 4 145 145 CD 35772 1625 5 . . . 35772 1626 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1626 2 22 22 CD 35772 1626 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1626 4 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1626 5 , , , 35772 1626 6 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1626 7 . . . 35772 1627 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1627 2 , , , 35772 1627 3 p. p. NN 35772 1627 4 143 143 CD 35772 1627 5 . . . 35772 1628 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1628 2 23 23 CD 35772 1628 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1628 4 The the DT 35772 1628 5 receipt receipt NN 35772 1628 6 and and CC 35772 1628 7 perusal perusal NN 35772 1628 8 of of IN 35772 1628 9 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 1628 10 's 's POS 35772 1628 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1628 12 Emile Emile NNP 35772 1628 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1628 14 , , , 35772 1628 15 are be VBP 35772 1628 16 said say VBN 35772 1628 17 to to TO 35772 1628 18 have have VB 35772 1628 19 interrupted interrupt VBN 35772 1628 20 the the DT 35772 1628 21 walk walk NN 35772 1628 22 on on IN 35772 1628 23 one one CD 35772 1628 24 occasion occasion NN 35772 1628 25 , , , 35772 1628 26 to to IN 35772 1628 27 the the DT 35772 1628 28 great great JJ 35772 1628 29 astonishment astonishment NN 35772 1628 30 of of IN 35772 1628 31 the the DT 35772 1628 32 Königsbergers Königsbergers NNPS 35772 1628 33 . . . 35772 1629 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1629 2 24 24 CD 35772 1629 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1629 4 Pringle Pringle NNP 35772 1629 5 Pattison Pattison NNP 35772 1629 6 , , , 35772 1629 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1629 8 Idea Idea NNP 35772 1629 9 of of IN 35772 1629 10 God God NNP 35772 1629 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1629 12 , , , 35772 1629 13 p. p. NN 35772 1629 14 26 26 CD 35772 1629 15 . . . 35772 1630 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1630 2 25 25 CD 35772 1630 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1630 4 " " `` 35772 1630 5 Atheism atheism NN 35772 1630 6 is be VBZ 35772 1630 7 aristocratic aristocratic JJ 35772 1630 8 , , , 35772 1630 9 " " '' 35772 1630 10 was be VBD 35772 1630 11 the the DT 35772 1630 12 reply reply NN 35772 1630 13 of of IN 35772 1630 14 Robespierre Robespierre NNP 35772 1630 15 to to IN 35772 1630 16 one one CD 35772 1630 17 who who WP 35772 1630 18 mocked mock VBD 35772 1630 19 at at IN 35772 1630 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1630 21 _ _ NNP 35772 1630 22 Être Être NNP 35772 1630 23 Suprême Suprême NNP 35772 1630 24 _ _ NNP 35772 1630 25 . . . 35772 1631 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1631 2 26 26 CD 35772 1631 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1631 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1631 5 Confessions Confessions NNPS 35772 1631 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1631 7 , , , 35772 1631 8 Book Book NNP 35772 1631 9 XII XII NNP 35772 1631 10 . . . 35772 1632 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1632 2 27 27 CD 35772 1632 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1632 4 Höffding Höffding NNP 35772 1632 5 , , , 35772 1632 6 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1632 7 . . . 35772 1633 1 II II NNP 35772 1633 2 , , , 35772 1633 3 p. p. NN 35772 1633 4 9 9 CD 35772 1633 5 . . . 35772 1634 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1634 2 28 28 CD 35772 1634 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1634 4 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 1634 5 's 's POS 35772 1634 6 word word NN 35772 1634 7 is be VBZ 35772 1634 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1634 9 Anschauung Anschauung NNP 35772 1634 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1634 11 , , , 35772 1634 12 for for IN 35772 1634 13 which which WDT 35772 1634 14 the the DT 35772 1634 15 English english JJ 35772 1634 16 language language NN 35772 1634 17 possesses possess VBZ 35772 1634 18 no no DT 35772 1634 19 exact exact JJ 35772 1634 20 equivalent equivalent NN 35772 1634 21 . . . 35772 1635 1 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1635 2 " " `` 35772 1635 3 implies imply VBZ 35772 1635 4 something something NN 35772 1635 5 akin akin JJ 35772 1635 6 , , , 35772 1635 7 though though IN 35772 1635 8 perhaps perhaps RB 35772 1635 9 superior superior JJ 35772 1635 10 to to IN 35772 1635 11 , , , 35772 1635 12 seeing seeing NN 35772 1635 13 or or CC 35772 1635 14 perceiving perceiving NN 35772 1635 15 by by IN 35772 1635 16 means mean NNS 35772 1635 17 of of IN 35772 1635 18 the the DT 35772 1635 19 senses sense NNS 35772 1635 20 , , , 35772 1635 21 " " '' 35772 1635 22 and and CC 35772 1635 23 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1635 24 approaches approach VBZ 35772 1635 25 less less RBR 35772 1635 26 closely closely RB 35772 1635 27 to to TO 35772 1635 28 " " `` 35772 1635 29 inspiration inspiration NN 35772 1635 30 " " '' 35772 1635 31 than than IN 35772 1635 32 does do VBZ 35772 1635 33 the the DT 35772 1635 34 English english JJ 35772 1635 35 word word NN 35772 1635 36 " " '' 35772 1635 37 intuition intuition NN 35772 1635 38 . . . 35772 1635 39 " " '' 35772 1636 1 The the DT 35772 1636 2 term term NN 35772 1636 3 acquired acquire VBD 35772 1636 4 a a DT 35772 1636 5 meaning meaning NN 35772 1636 6 somewhat somewhat RB 35772 1636 7 akin akin JJ 35772 1636 8 to to IN 35772 1636 9 the the DT 35772 1636 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1636 11 amor amor NN 35772 1636 12 intellectualis intellectualis NNP 35772 1636 13 Dei Dei NNP 35772 1636 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1636 15 of of IN 35772 1636 16 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 1636 17 , , , 35772 1636 18 which which WDT 35772 1636 19 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1636 20 have have VBP 35772 1636 21 met meet VBN 35772 1636 22 before before RB 35772 1636 23 . . . 35772 1637 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1637 2 See see VB 35772 1637 3 note note NN 35772 1637 4 in in IN 35772 1637 5 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1637 6 , , , 35772 1637 7 III III NNP 35772 1637 8 , , , 35772 1637 9 p. p. NN 35772 1638 1 445 445 CD 35772 1638 2 . . . 35772 1638 3 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1639 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1639 2 29 29 CD 35772 1639 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1639 4 William William NNP 35772 1639 5 James James NNP 35772 1639 6 , , , 35772 1639 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1639 8 A a DT 35772 1639 9 Pluralistic Pluralistic NNP 35772 1639 10 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1639 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1639 12 , , , 35772 1639 13 p. p. NN 35772 1639 14 92 92 CD 35772 1639 15 . . . 35772 1640 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1640 2 30 30 CD 35772 1640 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1640 4 Here here RB 35772 1640 5 again again RB 35772 1640 6 a a DT 35772 1640 7 certain certain JJ 35772 1640 8 ambiguity ambiguity NN 35772 1640 9 surrounds surround VBZ 35772 1640 10 the the DT 35772 1640 11 German german JJ 35772 1640 12 word word NN 35772 1640 13 . . . 35772 1641 1 _ _ NNP 35772 1641 2 Geist Geist NNP 35772 1641 3 _ _ NNP 35772 1641 4 is be VBZ 35772 1641 5 inadequately inadequately RB 35772 1641 6 translated translate VBN 35772 1641 7 by by IN 35772 1641 8 either either DT 35772 1641 9 " " `` 35772 1641 10 mind mind NN 35772 1641 11 " " '' 35772 1641 12 or or CC 35772 1641 13 " " `` 35772 1641 14 spirit spirit NN 35772 1641 15 " " '' 35772 1641 16 : : : 35772 1641 17 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1641 18 comprises comprise VBZ 35772 1641 19 the the DT 35772 1641 20 meaning meaning NN 35772 1641 21 of of IN 35772 1641 22 both both DT 35772 1641 23 words word NNS 35772 1641 24 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1641 25 cf cf NN 35772 1641 26 . . . 35772 1642 1 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1642 2 , , , 35772 1642 3 III III NNP 35772 1642 4 , , , 35772 1642 5 p. p. NN 35772 1642 6 466 466 CD 35772 1642 7 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1642 8 . . . 35772 1643 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1643 2 31 31 CD 35772 1643 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1643 4 This this DT 35772 1643 5 does do VBZ 35772 1643 6 not not RB 35772 1643 7 mean mean VB 35772 1643 8 that that IN 35772 1643 9 what what WP 35772 1643 10 is be VBZ 35772 1643 11 not not RB 35772 1643 12 good good JJ 35772 1643 13 enough enough RB 35772 1643 14 for for IN 35772 1643 15 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1643 16 is be VBZ 35772 1643 17 good good JJ 35772 1643 18 enough enough RB 35772 1643 19 for for IN 35772 1643 20 religion religion NN 35772 1643 21 . . . 35772 1644 1 The the DT 35772 1644 2 idea idea NN 35772 1644 3 behind behind IN 35772 1644 4 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 1644 5 is be VBZ 35772 1644 6 that that IN 35772 1644 7 what what WDT 35772 1644 8 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1644 9 can can MD 35772 1644 10 not not RB 35772 1644 11 sanction sanction VB 35772 1644 12 , , , 35772 1644 13 religious religious JJ 35772 1644 14 experience experience NN 35772 1644 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1644 16 can can MD 35772 1644 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1644 18 sanction sanction NN 35772 1644 19 . . . 35772 1645 1 And and CC 35772 1645 2 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1645 3 has have VBZ 35772 1645 4 to to TO 35772 1645 5 be be VB 35772 1645 6 remembered remember VBN 35772 1645 7 that that IN 35772 1645 8 , , , 35772 1645 9 as as IN 35772 1645 10 a a DT 35772 1645 11 follower follower NN 35772 1645 12 of of IN 35772 1645 13 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1645 14 , , , 35772 1645 15 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1645 16 assigned assign VBD 35772 1645 17 very very RB 35772 1645 18 definite definite JJ 35772 1645 19 limits limit NNS 35772 1645 20 to to IN 35772 1645 21 the the DT 35772 1645 22 powers power NNS 35772 1645 23 of of IN 35772 1645 24 philosophy philosophy NN 35772 1645 25 . . . 35772 1646 1 He -PRON- PRP 35772 1646 2 was be VBD 35772 1646 3 not not RB 35772 1646 4 an an DT 35772 1646 5 Hegelian hegelian JJ 35772 1646 6 -- -- : 35772 1646 7 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 1646 8 's 's POS 35772 1646 9 and and CC 35772 1646 10 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 1646 11 's 's POS 35772 1646 12 views view NNS 35772 1646 13 of of IN 35772 1646 14 the the DT 35772 1646 15 religious religious JJ 35772 1646 16 problem problem NN 35772 1646 17 are be VBP 35772 1646 18 quite quite RB 35772 1646 19 incompatible incompatible JJ 35772 1646 20 -- -- : 35772 1646 21 the the DT 35772 1646 22 one one CD 35772 1646 23 believed believe VBD 35772 1646 24 , , , 35772 1646 25 the the DT 35772 1646 26 other other JJ 35772 1646 27 did do VBD 35772 1646 28 not not RB 35772 1646 29 believe believe VB 35772 1646 30 , , , 35772 1646 31 that that DT 35772 1646 32 reason reason NN 35772 1646 33 could could MD 35772 1646 34 solve solve VB 35772 1646 35 that that DT 35772 1646 36 problem problem NN 35772 1646 37 . . . 35772 1647 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1647 2 32 32 CD 35772 1647 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1647 4 Kopp Kopp NNP 35772 1647 5 , , , 35772 1647 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1647 7 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 35772 1647 8 der der VBD 35772 1647 9 Chemie Chemie NNP 35772 1647 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1647 11 , , , 35772 1647 12 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1647 13 . . . 35772 1648 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1648 2 , , , 35772 1648 3 p. p. NN 35772 1648 4 442 442 CD 35772 1648 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1648 6 quoted quote VBN 35772 1648 7 by by IN 35772 1648 8 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1648 9 , , , 35772 1648 10 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1648 11 . . . 35772 1649 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1649 2 , , , 35772 1649 3 p. p. NN 35772 1649 4 191 191 CD 35772 1649 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1649 6 . . . 35772 1650 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1650 2 33 33 CD 35772 1650 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1650 4 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1650 5 , , , 35772 1650 6 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1650 7 . . . 35772 1651 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1651 2 , , , 35772 1651 3 p. p. NN 35772 1651 4 218 218 CD 35772 1651 5 . . . 35772 1652 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1652 2 34 34 CD 35772 1652 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1652 4 According accord VBG 35772 1652 5 to to IN 35772 1652 6 one one CD 35772 1652 7 authority authority NN 35772 1652 8 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1652 9 Judd Judd NNP 35772 1652 10 , , , 35772 1652 11 in in IN 35772 1652 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1652 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1652 14 Coming Coming NNP 35772 1652 15 of of IN 35772 1652 16 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1652 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1652 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1652 19 the the DT 35772 1652 20 number number NN 35772 1652 21 of of IN 35772 1652 22 known know VBN 35772 1652 23 species specie NNS 35772 1652 24 of of IN 35772 1652 25 plants plant NNS 35772 1652 26 and and CC 35772 1652 27 animals animal NNS 35772 1652 28 must must MD 35772 1652 29 be be VB 35772 1652 30 placed place VBN 35772 1652 31 at at IN 35772 1652 32 600,000 600,000 CD 35772 1652 33 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1652 34 p. p. NN 35772 1652 35 10 10 CD 35772 1652 36 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1652 37 . . . 35772 1653 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1653 2 35 35 CD 35772 1653 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1653 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1653 5 Vestiges Vestiges NNP 35772 1653 6 of of IN 35772 1653 7 Creation Creation NNP 35772 1653 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1653 9 , , , 35772 1653 10 published publish VBN 35772 1653 11 anonymously anonymously RB 35772 1653 12 in in IN 35772 1653 13 1844 1844 CD 35772 1653 14 , , , 35772 1653 15 passed pass VBD 35772 1653 16 through through IN 35772 1653 17 nine nine CD 35772 1653 18 large large JJ 35772 1653 19 editions edition NNS 35772 1653 20 by by IN 35772 1653 21 1853 1853 CD 35772 1653 22 . . . 35772 1654 1 The the DT 35772 1654 2 author author NN 35772 1654 3 was be VBD 35772 1654 4 Robert Robert NNP 35772 1654 5 Chambers Chambers NNP 35772 1654 6 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1654 7 1802 1802 CD 35772 1654 8 - - SYM 35772 1654 9 71 71 CD 35772 1654 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1654 11 , , , 35772 1654 12 a a DT 35772 1654 13 geologist geologist NN 35772 1654 14 . . . 35772 1655 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1655 2 36 36 CD 35772 1655 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1655 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1655 5 Life Life NNP 35772 1655 6 and and CC 35772 1655 7 Letters Letters NNPS 35772 1655 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1655 9 , , , 35772 1655 10 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1655 11 . . . 35772 1656 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1656 2 , , , 35772 1656 3 p. p. NN 35772 1656 4 168 168 CD 35772 1656 5 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1656 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1656 7 vide vide NN 35772 1656 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1656 9 Judd Judd NNP 35772 1656 10 , , , 35772 1656 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1656 12 Coming Coming NNP 35772 1656 13 of of IN 35772 1656 14 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1656 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1656 16 , , , 35772 1656 17 p. p. NN 35772 1656 18 89 89 CD 35772 1656 19 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1656 20 . . . 35772 1657 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1657 2 37 37 CD 35772 1657 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1657 4 As as IN 35772 1657 5 a a DT 35772 1657 6 matter matter NN 35772 1657 7 of of IN 35772 1657 8 fact fact NN 35772 1657 9 , , , 35772 1657 10 biologists biologist NNS 35772 1657 11 soon soon RB 35772 1657 12 demanded demand VBD 35772 1657 13 more more JJR 35772 1657 14 than than IN 35772 1657 15 even even RB 35772 1657 16 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 1657 17 's 's POS 35772 1657 18 geology geology NN 35772 1657 19 could could MD 35772 1657 20 give give VB 35772 1657 21 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1657 22 . . . 35772 1658 1 Recent recent JJ 35772 1658 2 discoveries discovery NNS 35772 1658 3 about about IN 35772 1658 4 the the DT 35772 1658 5 nature nature NN 35772 1658 6 of of IN 35772 1658 7 matter matter NN 35772 1658 8 have have VBP 35772 1658 9 , , , 35772 1658 10 however however RB 35772 1658 11 , , , 35772 1658 12 further further RB 35772 1658 13 extended extend VBD 35772 1658 14 the the DT 35772 1658 15 possible possible JJ 35772 1658 16 age age NN 35772 1658 17 of of IN 35772 1658 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1658 19 planet planet NN 35772 1658 20 . . . 35772 1659 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1659 2 38 38 CD 35772 1659 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1659 4 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1659 5 , , , 35772 1659 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1659 7 Life Life NNP 35772 1659 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1659 9 , , , 35772 1659 10 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1659 11 . . . 35772 1660 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1660 2 , , , 35772 1660 3 p. p. NN 35772 1660 4 93 93 CD 35772 1660 5 . . . 35772 1661 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1661 2 39 39 CD 35772 1661 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1661 4 " " `` 35772 1661 5 If if IN 35772 1661 6 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1661 7 wish wish VBP 35772 1661 8 to to TO 35772 1661 9 fix fix VB 35772 1661 10 a a DT 35772 1661 11 definite definite JJ 35772 1661 12 point point NN 35772 1661 13 to to TO 35772 1661 14 describe describe VB 35772 1661 15 as as IN 35772 1661 16 the the DT 35772 1661 17 end end NN 35772 1661 18 of of IN 35772 1661 19 the the DT 35772 1661 20 idealistic idealistic JJ 35772 1661 21 period period NN 35772 1661 22 in in IN 35772 1661 23 Germany Germany NNP 35772 1661 24 , , , 35772 1661 25 no no DT 35772 1661 26 such such JJ 35772 1661 27 distinctive distinctive JJ 35772 1661 28 event event NN 35772 1661 29 offers offer VBZ 35772 1661 30 itself -PRON- PRP 35772 1661 31 as as IN 35772 1661 32 the the DT 35772 1661 33 French French NNP 35772 1661 34 Revolution Revolution NNP 35772 1661 35 of of IN 35772 1661 36 July July NNP 35772 1661 37 , , , 35772 1661 38 1830 1830 CD 35772 1661 39 " " '' 35772 1661 40 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1661 41 Lange lange NN 35772 1661 42 , , , 35772 1661 43 _ _ NNP 35772 1661 44 History history NN 35772 1661 45 of of IN 35772 1661 46 Materialism Materialism NNP 35772 1661 47 _ _ NNP 35772 1661 48 , , , 35772 1661 49 E.T. E.T. NNP 35772 1661 50 , , , 35772 1661 51 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1661 52 . . . 35772 1662 1 II II NNP 35772 1662 2 , , , 35772 1662 3 p. p. NN 35772 1662 4 245 245 CD 35772 1662 5 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1662 6 . . . 35772 1663 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1663 2 40 40 CD 35772 1663 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1663 4 A a DT 35772 1663 5 famous famous JJ 35772 1663 6 book book NN 35772 1663 7 which which WDT 35772 1663 8 , , , 35772 1663 9 though though IN 35772 1663 10 negative negative JJ 35772 1663 11 in in IN 35772 1663 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1663 13 conclusions conclusion NNS 35772 1663 14 , , , 35772 1663 15 places place VBZ 35772 1663 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1663 17 author author NN 35772 1663 18 alongside alongside IN 35772 1663 19 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 1663 20 as as IN 35772 1663 21 one one CD 35772 1663 22 of of IN 35772 1663 23 the the DT 35772 1663 24 founders founder NNS 35772 1663 25 of of IN 35772 1663 26 the the DT 35772 1663 27 modern modern JJ 35772 1663 28 science science NN 35772 1663 29 of of IN 35772 1663 30 Religious Religious NNP 35772 1663 31 Psychology Psychology NNP 35772 1663 32 . . . 35772 1664 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1664 2 41 41 CD 35772 1664 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1664 4 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1664 5 , , , 35772 1664 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1664 7 Theism Theism NNP 35772 1664 8 and and CC 35772 1664 9 Humanism Humanism NNP 35772 1664 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1664 11 , , , 35772 1664 12 p. p. NN 35772 1664 13 36 36 CD 35772 1664 14 . . . 35772 1665 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1665 2 42 42 CD 35772 1665 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1665 4 " " `` 35772 1665 5 Evolution evolution NN 35772 1665 6 is be VBZ 35772 1665 7 an an DT 35772 1665 8 integration integration NN 35772 1665 9 of of IN 35772 1665 10 matter matter NN 35772 1665 11 and and CC 35772 1665 12 concomitant concomitant JJ 35772 1665 13 dissipation dissipation NN 35772 1665 14 of of IN 35772 1665 15 motion motion NN 35772 1665 16 , , , 35772 1665 17 during during IN 35772 1665 18 which which WDT 35772 1665 19 the the DT 35772 1665 20 matter matter NN 35772 1665 21 passes pass VBZ 35772 1665 22 from from IN 35772 1665 23 an an DT 35772 1665 24 indefinite indefinite JJ 35772 1665 25 incoherent incoherent JJ 35772 1665 26 homogeneity homogeneity NN 35772 1665 27 to to IN 35772 1665 28 a a DT 35772 1665 29 definite definite JJ 35772 1665 30 coherent coherent JJ 35772 1665 31 heterogeneity heterogeneity NN 35772 1665 32 , , , 35772 1665 33 and and CC 35772 1665 34 during during IN 35772 1665 35 which which WDT 35772 1665 36 the the DT 35772 1665 37 retained retained JJ 35772 1665 38 motion motion NN 35772 1665 39 undergoes undergo VBZ 35772 1665 40 a a DT 35772 1665 41 parallel parallel JJ 35772 1665 42 transformation transformation NN 35772 1665 43 . . . 35772 1665 44 " " '' 35772 1666 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1666 2 43 43 CD 35772 1666 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1666 4 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1666 5 confessed confess VBD 35772 1666 6 that that DT 35772 1666 7 of of IN 35772 1666 8 the the DT 35772 1666 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1666 10 Synthetic Synthetic NNP 35772 1666 11 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1666 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1666 13 " " '' 35772 1666 14 two two CD 35772 1666 15 volumes volume NNS 35772 1666 16 are be VBP 35772 1666 17 missing miss VBG 35772 1666 18 , , , 35772 1666 19 " " '' 35772 1666 20 the the DT 35772 1666 21 two two CD 35772 1666 22 important important JJ 35772 1666 23 volumes volume NNS 35772 1666 24 on on IN 35772 1666 25 Inorganic Inorganic NNP 35772 1666 26 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1666 27 , , , 35772 1666 28 leading lead VBG 35772 1666 29 to to IN 35772 1666 30 the the DT 35772 1666 31 evolution evolution NN 35772 1666 32 of of IN 35772 1666 33 the the DT 35772 1666 34 living living NN 35772 1666 35 and and CC 35772 1666 36 of of IN 35772 1666 37 the the DT 35772 1666 38 non non JJ 35772 1666 39 - - JJ 35772 1666 40 living living JJ 35772 1666 41 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1666 42 cf cf NN 35772 1666 43 . . . 35772 1667 1 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 1667 2 by by IN 35772 1667 3 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1667 4 James James NNP 35772 1667 5 Ward Ward NNP 35772 1667 6 in in IN 35772 1667 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1667 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1667 9 Naturalism Naturalism NNP 35772 1667 10 and and CC 35772 1667 11 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 1667 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1667 13 , , , 35772 1667 14 Lecture Lecture NNP 35772 1667 15 IX IX NNP 35772 1667 16 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1667 17 . . . 35772 1668 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1668 2 44 44 CD 35772 1668 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1668 4 For for IN 35772 1668 5 an an DT 35772 1668 6 instance instance NN 35772 1668 7 of of IN 35772 1668 8 the the DT 35772 1668 9 masterly masterly JJ 35772 1668 10 work work NN 35772 1668 11 turned turn VBD 35772 1668 12 out out RP 35772 1668 13 by by IN 35772 1668 14 this this DT 35772 1668 15 school school NN 35772 1668 16 and and CC 35772 1668 17 of of IN 35772 1668 18 the the DT 35772 1668 19 attractiveness attractiveness NN 35772 1668 20 of of IN 35772 1668 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1668 22 propaganda propaganda NN 35772 1668 23 , , , 35772 1668 24 read read VBD 35772 1668 25 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1668 26 's 's POS 35772 1668 27 lecture lecture NN 35772 1668 28 , , , 35772 1668 29 " " '' 35772 1668 30 On on IN 35772 1668 31 a a DT 35772 1668 32 Piece Piece NNP 35772 1668 33 of of IN 35772 1668 34 Chalk Chalk NNP 35772 1668 35 , , , 35772 1668 36 " " '' 35772 1668 37 delivered deliver VBN 35772 1668 38 to to IN 35772 1668 39 the the DT 35772 1668 40 working work VBG 35772 1668 41 men man NNS 35772 1668 42 of of IN 35772 1668 43 Norwich Norwich NNP 35772 1668 44 during during IN 35772 1668 45 the the DT 35772 1668 46 meeting meeting NN 35772 1668 47 of of IN 35772 1668 48 the the DT 35772 1668 49 British British NNP 35772 1668 50 Association Association NNP 35772 1668 51 in in IN 35772 1668 52 1868 1868 CD 35772 1668 53 . . . 35772 1669 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1669 2 45 45 CD 35772 1669 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1669 4 For for IN 35772 1669 5 this this DT 35772 1669 6 famous famous JJ 35772 1669 7 encounter encounter NN 35772 1669 8 , , , 35772 1669 9 see see VB 35772 1669 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1669 11 Life Life NNP 35772 1669 12 of of IN 35772 1669 13 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1669 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1669 15 , , , 35772 1669 16 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1669 17 . . . 35772 1670 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1670 2 , , , 35772 1670 3 pp pp NNP 35772 1670 4 . . . 35772 1671 1 179 179 CD 35772 1671 2 - - SYM 35772 1671 3 89 89 CD 35772 1671 4 , , , 35772 1671 5 and and CC 35772 1671 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1671 7 Life Life NNP 35772 1671 8 of of IN 35772 1671 9 J. J. NNP 35772 1671 10 R. R. NNP 35772 1671 11 Green Green NNP 35772 1671 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1671 13 , , , 35772 1671 14 pp pp NNP 35772 1671 15 . . . 35772 1672 1 44 44 CD 35772 1672 2 , , , 35772 1672 3 45 45 CD 35772 1672 4 . . . 35772 1673 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1673 2 46 46 CD 35772 1673 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1673 4 As as IN 35772 1673 5 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1673 6 shall shall MD 35772 1673 7 subsequently subsequently RB 35772 1673 8 find find VB 35772 1673 9 , , , 35772 1673 10 this this DT 35772 1673 11 cosmic cosmic JJ 35772 1673 12 pessimism pessimism NN 35772 1673 13 is be VBZ 35772 1673 14 less less RBR 35772 1673 15 well well RB 35772 1673 16 grounded ground VBN 35772 1673 17 than than IN 35772 1673 18 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1673 19 believed believe VBD 35772 1673 20 . . . 35772 1674 1 Still still RB 35772 1674 2 , , , 35772 1674 3 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1674 4 's 's POS 35772 1674 5 own own JJ 35772 1674 6 scientific scientific JJ 35772 1674 7 presuppositions presupposition NNS 35772 1674 8 were be VBD 35772 1674 9 the the DT 35772 1674 10 same same JJ 35772 1674 11 as as IN 35772 1674 12 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1674 13 's 's POS 35772 1674 14 , , , 35772 1674 15 so so IN 35772 1674 16 that that IN 35772 1674 17 the the DT 35772 1674 18 passage passage NN 35772 1674 19 remains remain VBZ 35772 1674 20 a a DT 35772 1674 21 pertinent pertinent JJ 35772 1674 22 criticism criticism NN 35772 1674 23 of of IN 35772 1674 24 the the DT 35772 1674 25 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP 35772 1674 26 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1674 27 as as IN 35772 1674 28 elaborated elaborate VBN 35772 1674 29 by by IN 35772 1674 30 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1674 31 . . . 35772 1675 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1675 2 47 47 CD 35772 1675 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1675 4 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1675 5 is be VBZ 35772 1675 6 instructive instructive JJ 35772 1675 7 to to TO 35772 1675 8 observe observe VB 35772 1675 9 that that IN 35772 1675 10 a a DT 35772 1675 11 similar similar JJ 35772 1675 12 note note NN 35772 1675 13 of of IN 35772 1675 14 latent latent NN 35772 1675 15 pessimism pessimism NN 35772 1675 16 is be VBZ 35772 1675 17 struck strike VBN 35772 1675 18 by by IN 35772 1675 19 the the DT 35772 1675 20 last last JJ 35772 1675 21 notable notable JJ 35772 1675 22 survivor survivor NN 35772 1675 23 of of IN 35772 1675 24 the the DT 35772 1675 25 School School NNP 35772 1675 26 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1675 27 have have VBP 35772 1675 28 endeavoured endeavour VBN 35772 1675 29 to to TO 35772 1675 30 describe describe VB 35772 1675 31 . . . 35772 1676 1 Viscount Viscount NNP 35772 1676 2 Morley Morley NNP 35772 1676 3 at at IN 35772 1676 4 the the DT 35772 1676 5 end end NN 35772 1676 6 of of IN 35772 1676 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1676 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1676 9 Recollections Recollections NNPS 35772 1676 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1676 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1676 12 1917 1917 CD 35772 1676 13 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1676 14 , , , 35772 1676 15 questioned question VBD 35772 1676 16 as as IN 35772 1676 17 to to IN 35772 1676 18 the the DT 35772 1676 19 outcome outcome NN 35772 1676 20 of of IN 35772 1676 21 those those DT 35772 1676 22 generous generous JJ 35772 1676 23 hopes hope NNS 35772 1676 24 entertained entertain VBN 35772 1676 25 with with IN 35772 1676 26 such such JJ 35772 1676 27 confidence confidence NN 35772 1676 28 by by IN 35772 1676 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1676 30 contemporaries contemporary NNS 35772 1676 31 , , , 35772 1676 32 is be VBZ 35772 1676 33 compelled compel VBN 35772 1676 34 to to TO 35772 1676 35 ejaculate ejaculate VB 35772 1676 36 with with IN 35772 1676 37 philosophic philosophic JJ 35772 1676 38 brevity brevity NN 35772 1676 39 , , , 35772 1676 40 _ _ NNP 35772 1676 41 circumspice circumspice NN 35772 1676 42 _ _ NNP 35772 1676 43 , , , 35772 1676 44 as as IN 35772 1676 45 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1676 46 contemplates contemplate VBZ 35772 1676 47 a a DT 35772 1676 48 spectacle spectacle NN 35772 1676 49 of of IN 35772 1676 50 unparalleled unparalleled JJ 35772 1676 51 horror horror NN 35772 1676 52 . . . 35772 1677 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1677 2 48 48 CD 35772 1677 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1677 4 Storr Storr NNP 35772 1677 5 , , , 35772 1677 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1677 7 Development Development NNP 35772 1677 8 of of IN 35772 1677 9 English English NNP 35772 1677 10 Theology Theology NNP 35772 1677 11 in in IN 35772 1677 12 the the DT 35772 1677 13 Nineteenth Nineteenth NNP 35772 1677 14 Century Century NNP 35772 1677 15 _ _ NNP 35772 1677 16 , , , 35772 1677 17 p. p. NN 35772 1677 18 329 329 CD 35772 1677 19 . . . 35772 1678 1 See see VB 35772 1678 2 which which WDT 35772 1678 3 book book NN 35772 1678 4 for for IN 35772 1678 5 a a DT 35772 1678 6 valuable valuable JJ 35772 1678 7 chapter chapter NN 35772 1678 8 upon upon IN 35772 1678 9 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1678 10 . . . 35772 1679 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1679 2 49 49 CD 35772 1679 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1679 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1679 5 Foundations Foundations NNPS 35772 1679 6 of of IN 35772 1679 7 Belief Belief NNP 35772 1679 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1679 9 , , , 35772 1679 10 p. p. NN 35772 1679 11 98 98 CD 35772 1679 12 . . . 35772 1680 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1680 2 50 50 CD 35772 1680 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1680 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1680 5 Foundations Foundations NNPS 35772 1680 6 of of IN 35772 1680 7 Belief Belief NNP 35772 1680 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1680 9 , , , 35772 1680 10 p. p. NN 35772 1680 11 309 309 CD 35772 1680 12 . . . 35772 1681 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1681 2 51 51 CD 35772 1681 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1681 4 For for IN 35772 1681 5 this this DT 35772 1681 6 summary summary NN 35772 1681 7 of of IN 35772 1681 8 Lotze Lotze NNP 35772 1681 9 's 's POS 35772 1681 10 doctrine doctrine NN 35772 1681 11 , , , 35772 1681 12 see see VBP 35772 1681 13 Merz Merz NNP 35772 1681 14 , , , 35772 1681 15 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1681 16 . . . 35772 1682 1 III III NNP 35772 1682 2 , , , 35772 1682 3 p. p. NN 35772 1682 4 615 615 CD 35772 1682 5 and and CC 35772 1682 6 ff ff NNP 35772 1682 7 . . . 35772 1683 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1683 2 52 52 CD 35772 1683 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1683 4 Quoted quote VBN 35772 1683 5 by by IN 35772 1683 6 Ward Ward NNP 35772 1683 7 in in IN 35772 1683 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1683 9 Pluralism Pluralism NNP 35772 1683 10 and and CC 35772 1683 11 Theism Theism NNP 35772 1683 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1683 13 , , , 35772 1683 14 p. p. NN 35772 1683 15 103 103 CD 35772 1683 16 . . . 35772 1684 1 For for IN 35772 1684 2 a a DT 35772 1684 3 brief brief NN 35772 1684 4 yet yet CC 35772 1684 5 adequate adequate JJ 35772 1684 6 treatment treatment NN 35772 1684 7 of of IN 35772 1684 8 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1684 9 's 's POS 35772 1684 10 criticisms criticism NNS 35772 1684 11 see see VBP 35772 1684 12 Höffding Höffding NNP 35772 1684 13 's 's POS 35772 1684 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1684 15 Modern Modern NNP 35772 1684 16 Philosophers Philosophers NNPS 35772 1684 17 _ _ NNP 35772 1684 18 , , , 35772 1684 19 pp pp NNP 35772 1684 20 . . . 35772 1685 1 115 115 CD 35772 1685 2 - - SYM 35772 1685 3 21 21 CD 35772 1685 4 . . . 35772 1686 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1686 2 53 53 CD 35772 1686 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1686 4 R. R. NNP 35772 1686 5 B. B. NNP 35772 1686 6 Perry Perry NNP 35772 1686 7 , , , 35772 1686 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1686 9 Present Present NNP 35772 1686 10 Philosophical Philosophical NNP 35772 1686 11 Tendencies Tendencies NNPS 35772 1686 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1686 13 , , , 35772 1686 14 p. p. NN 35772 1686 15 351 351 CD 35772 1686 16 . . . 35772 1687 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1687 2 54 54 CD 35772 1687 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1687 4 It -PRON- PRP 35772 1687 5 is be VBZ 35772 1687 6 impossible impossible JJ 35772 1687 7 to to TO 35772 1687 8 go go VB 35772 1687 9 deeper deep JJR 35772 1687 10 into into IN 35772 1687 11 James James NNP 35772 1687 12 ' ' POS 35772 1687 13 " " `` 35772 1687 14 theory theory NN 35772 1687 15 of of IN 35772 1687 16 knowledge knowledge NN 35772 1687 17 " " '' 35772 1687 18 without without IN 35772 1687 19 using use VBG 35772 1687 20 technical technical JJ 35772 1687 21 language language NN 35772 1687 22 . . . 35772 1688 1 A a DT 35772 1688 2 few few JJ 35772 1688 3 of of IN 35772 1688 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1688 5 own own JJ 35772 1688 6 phrases phrase NNS 35772 1688 7 , , , 35772 1688 8 however however RB 35772 1688 9 , , , 35772 1688 10 may may MD 35772 1688 11 help help VB 35772 1688 12 to to TO 35772 1688 13 elucidate elucidate VB 35772 1688 14 things thing NNS 35772 1688 15 . . . 35772 1689 1 " " `` 35772 1689 2 Abstract abstract JJ 35772 1689 3 concepts concept NNS 35772 1689 4 ... ... : 35772 1689 5 are be VBP 35772 1689 6 salient salient NN 35772 1689 7 aspects aspect NNS 35772 1689 8 of of IN 35772 1689 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1689 10 concrete concrete JJ 35772 1689 11 experiences experience NNS 35772 1689 12 which which WDT 35772 1689 13 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1689 14 find find VBP 35772 1689 15 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1689 16 useful useful JJ 35772 1689 17 to to TO 35772 1689 18 single single VB 35772 1689 19 out out RP 35772 1689 20 " " '' 35772 1689 21 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1689 22 _ _ NNP 35772 1689 23 Meaning Meaning NNP 35772 1689 24 of of IN 35772 1689 25 Truth Truth NNP 35772 1689 26 _ _ NNP 35772 1689 27 , , , 35772 1689 28 p. p. NN 35772 1689 29 246 246 CD 35772 1689 30 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1689 31 . . . 35772 1690 1 Elsewhere elsewhere RB 35772 1690 2 he -PRON- PRP 35772 1690 3 speaks speak VBZ 35772 1690 4 of of IN 35772 1690 5 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1690 6 as as IN 35772 1690 7 things thing NNS 35772 1690 8 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1690 9 have have VBP 35772 1690 10 learned learn VBN 35772 1690 11 to to TO 35772 1690 12 " " `` 35772 1690 13 cut cut VB 35772 1690 14 out out RP 35772 1690 15 " " '' 35772 1690 16 from from IN 35772 1690 17 experience experience NN 35772 1690 18 , , , 35772 1690 19 as as IN 35772 1690 20 " " `` 35772 1690 21 flowers flower NNS 35772 1690 22 gathered gather VBD 35772 1690 23 , , , 35772 1690 24 " " '' 35772 1690 25 and and CC 35772 1690 26 as as IN 35772 1690 27 " " `` 35772 1690 28 moments moment NNS 35772 1690 29 dipped dip VBD 35772 1690 30 out out RP 35772 1690 31 from from IN 35772 1690 32 the the DT 35772 1690 33 stream stream NN 35772 1690 34 of of IN 35772 1690 35 time time NN 35772 1690 36 " " '' 35772 1690 37 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1690 38 _ _ NNP 35772 1690 39 A a DT 35772 1690 40 Pluralistic Pluralistic NNP 35772 1690 41 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1690 42 _ _ NNP 35772 1690 43 , , , 35772 1690 44 p. p. NN 35772 1690 45 235 235 CD 35772 1690 46 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1690 47 . . . 35772 1691 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1691 2 owe owe VBP 35772 1691 3 these these DT 35772 1691 4 quotations quotation NNS 35772 1691 5 to to IN 35772 1691 6 Perry Perry NNP 35772 1691 7 , , , 35772 1691 8 op op NN 35772 1691 9 . . . 35772 1692 1 cit cit NNP 35772 1692 2 . . . 35772 1693 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1693 2 55 55 CD 35772 1693 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1693 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1693 5 Creative Creative NNP 35772 1693 6 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1693 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1693 8 , , , 35772 1693 9 p. p. NN 35772 1693 10 325 325 CD 35772 1693 11 . . . 35772 1694 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1694 2 56 56 CD 35772 1694 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1694 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1694 5 A a DT 35772 1694 6 Pluralistic Pluralistic NNP 35772 1694 7 Universe Universe NNP 35772 1694 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1694 9 , , , 35772 1694 10 p. p. NN 35772 1694 11 237 237 CD 35772 1694 12 . . . 35772 1695 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1695 2 57 57 CD 35772 1695 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1695 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1695 5 Creative Creative NNP 35772 1695 6 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1695 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1695 8 , , , 35772 1695 9 p. p. NN 35772 1695 10 174 174 CD 35772 1695 11 . . . 35772 1696 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1696 2 58 58 CD 35772 1696 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1696 4 i.e. i.e. FW 35772 1697 1 Intellect intellect NN 35772 1697 2 is be VBZ 35772 1697 3 not not RB 35772 1697 4 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1697 5 as as IN 35772 1697 6 it -PRON- PRP 35772 1697 7 is be VBZ 35772 1697 8 generally generally RB 35772 1697 9 represented represent VBN 35772 1697 10 to to TO 35772 1697 11 be be VB 35772 1697 12 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1697 13 a a DT 35772 1697 14 developed develop VBN 35772 1697 15 form form NN 35772 1697 16 of of IN 35772 1697 17 instinct instinct NN 35772 1697 18 , , , 35772 1697 19 nor nor CC 35772 1697 20 instinct instinct VB 35772 1697 21 an an DT 35772 1697 22 embryonic embryonic JJ 35772 1697 23 form form NN 35772 1697 24 of of IN 35772 1697 25 intellect intellect NN 35772 1697 26 . . . 35772 1698 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1698 2 59 59 LS 35772 1698 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1698 4 The the DT 35772 1698 5 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 35772 1698 6 and and CC 35772 1698 7 miraculous miraculous JJ 35772 1698 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 35772 1698 9 of of IN 35772 1698 10 instinct instinct NN 35772 1698 11 -- -- : 35772 1698 12 especially especially RB 35772 1698 13 as as IN 35772 1698 14 celebrated celebrate VBN 35772 1698 15 by by IN 35772 1698 16 the the DT 35772 1698 17 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 1698 18 French french JJ 35772 1698 19 scientist scientist NN 35772 1698 20 Fabre Fabre NNP 35772 1698 21 -- -- : 35772 1698 22 cannot cannot NNP 35772 1698 23 be be VB 35772 1698 24 rightly rightly RB 35772 1698 25 understood understand VBN 35772 1698 26 by by IN 35772 1698 27 trying try VBG 35772 1698 28 to to TO 35772 1698 29 interpret interpret VB 35772 1698 30 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1698 31 in in IN 35772 1698 32 terms term NNS 35772 1698 33 of of IN 35772 1698 34 intellect intellect NN 35772 1698 35 . . . 35772 1699 1 This this DT 35772 1699 2 is be VBZ 35772 1699 3 to to TO 35772 1699 4 misread misread VB 35772 1699 5 them -PRON- PRP 35772 1699 6 completely completely RB 35772 1699 7 . . . 35772 1700 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1700 2 60 60 CD 35772 1700 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1700 4 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1700 5 's 's POS 35772 1700 6 characterisation characterisation NN 35772 1700 7 of of IN 35772 1700 8 Spencerian Spencerian NNP 35772 1700 9 Evolutionism Evolutionism NNP 35772 1700 10 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1700 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1700 12 Creative Creative NNP 35772 1700 13 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1700 14 _ _ NNP 35772 1700 15 , , , 35772 1700 16 p. p. NN 35772 1700 17 391 391 CD 35772 1700 18 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1700 19 . . . 35772 1701 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1701 2 61 61 CD 35772 1701 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1701 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1701 5 Creative Creative NNP 35772 1701 6 Evolution Evolution NNP 35772 1701 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1701 8 , , , 35772 1701 9 p. p. NN 35772 1701 10 286 286 CD 35772 1701 11 . . . 35772 1702 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1702 2 62 62 CD 35772 1702 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1702 4 Other other JJ 35772 1702 5 notable notable JJ 35772 1702 6 pluralists pluralist NNS 35772 1702 7 in in IN 35772 1702 8 England England NNP 35772 1702 9 are be VBP 35772 1702 10 F. F. NNP 35772 1702 11 C. C. NNP 35772 1702 12 S. S. NNP 35772 1702 13 Schiller Schiller NNP 35772 1702 14 and and CC 35772 1702 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 35772 1702 16 MacTaggart MacTaggart NNP 35772 1702 17 . . . 35772 1703 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1703 2 63 63 CD 35772 1703 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1703 4 The the DT 35772 1703 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1703 6 logical logical JJ 35772 1703 7 _ _ NNP 35772 1703 8 conclusion conclusion NN 35772 1703 9 , , , 35772 1703 10 we -PRON- PRP 35772 1703 11 say say VBP 35772 1703 12 , , , 35772 1703 13 though though IN 35772 1703 14 this this DT 35772 1703 15 may may MD 35772 1703 16 not not RB 35772 1703 17 be be VB 35772 1703 18 the the DT 35772 1703 19 ultimate ultimate JJ 35772 1703 20 truth truth NN 35772 1703 21 about about IN 35772 1703 22 the the DT 35772 1703 23 matter matter NN 35772 1703 24 . . . 35772 1704 1 The the DT 35772 1704 2 most most RBS 35772 1704 3 attractive attractive JJ 35772 1704 4 theories theory NNS 35772 1704 5 are be VBP 35772 1704 6 often often RB 35772 1704 7 the the DT 35772 1704 8 most most RBS 35772 1704 9 superficial superficial JJ 35772 1704 10 . . . 35772 1705 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1705 2 64 64 CD 35772 1705 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1705 4 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1705 5 Cunningham Cunningham NNP 35772 1705 6 in in IN 35772 1705 7 Pearson Pearson NNP 35772 1705 8 's 's POS 35772 1705 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1705 10 Grammar Grammar NNP 35772 1705 11 of of IN 35772 1705 12 Science Science NNP 35772 1705 13 _ _ NNP 35772 1705 14 , , , 35772 1705 15 Part Part NNP 35772 1705 16 I I NNP 35772 1705 17 , , , 35772 1705 18 p. p. NN 35772 1705 19 356 356 CD 35772 1705 20 . . . 35772 1706 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1706 2 65 65 CD 35772 1706 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1706 4 Quoted quote VBN 35772 1706 5 by by IN 35772 1706 6 W. W. NNP 35772 1706 7 C. C. NNP 35772 1706 8 D. D. NNP 35772 1706 9 Whetham Whetham NNP 35772 1706 10 in in IN 35772 1706 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1706 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1706 13 Recent Recent NNP 35772 1706 14 Development Development NNP 35772 1706 15 of of IN 35772 1706 16 Physical Physical NNP 35772 1706 17 Science Science NNP 35772 1706 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1706 19 , , , 35772 1706 20 p. p. NN 35772 1706 21 280 280 CD 35772 1706 22 . . . 35772 1707 1 No no DT 35772 1707 2 reference reference NN 35772 1707 3 is be VBZ 35772 1707 4 given give VBN 35772 1707 5 by by IN 35772 1707 6 him -PRON- PRP 35772 1707 7 . . . 35772 1708 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1708 2 66 66 CD 35772 1708 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1708 4 One one CD 35772 1708 5 theory theory NN 35772 1708 6 attributes attribute VBZ 35772 1708 7 the the DT 35772 1708 8 existence existence NN 35772 1708 9 of of IN 35772 1708 10 matter matter NN 35772 1708 11 to to IN 35772 1708 12 occasional occasional JJ 35772 1708 13 misfits misfit NNS 35772 1708 14 among among IN 35772 1708 15 these these DT 35772 1708 16 grains grain NNS 35772 1708 17 . . . 35772 1709 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1709 2 67 67 CD 35772 1709 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1709 4 Quoted quote VBN 35772 1709 5 by by IN 35772 1709 6 Bishop Bishop NNP 35772 1709 7 Mercer Mercer NNP 35772 1709 8 . . . 35772 1710 1 _ _ NNP 35772 1710 2 Problem Problem NNP 35772 1710 3 of of IN 35772 1710 4 Creation Creation NNP 35772 1710 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1710 6 , , , 35772 1710 7 Appendix Appendix NNP 35772 1710 8 B. B. NNP 35772 1711 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1711 2 68 68 CD 35772 1711 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1711 4 In in IN 35772 1711 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1711 6 Theism Theism NNP 35772 1711 7 and and CC 35772 1711 8 Humanism Humanism NNP 35772 1711 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1711 10 . . . 35772 1712 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1712 2 69 69 CD 35772 1712 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1712 4 Mercer Mercer NNP 35772 1712 5 , , , 35772 1712 6 op op NN 35772 1712 7 . . . 35772 1713 1 cit cit NNP 35772 1713 2 . . NNP 35772 1713 3 , , , 35772 1713 4 p. p. NN 35772 1713 5 106 106 CD 35772 1713 6 . . . 35772 1714 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1714 2 70 70 CD 35772 1714 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1714 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1714 5 Mechanism Mechanism NNP 35772 1714 6 , , , 35772 1714 7 Life Life NNP 35772 1714 8 , , , 35772 1714 9 and and CC 35772 1714 10 Personality Personality NNP 35772 1714 11 _ _ NNP 35772 1714 12 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1714 13 1913 1913 CD 35772 1714 14 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1714 15 , , , 35772 1714 16 p. p. NN 35772 1714 17 81 81 CD 35772 1714 18 . . . 35772 1715 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1715 2 71 71 CD 35772 1715 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1715 4 Op Op NNP 35772 1715 5 . . . 35772 1716 1 cit cit NNP 35772 1716 2 . . . 35772 1717 1 pp pp NNP 35772 1717 2 . . . 35772 1718 1 64 64 CD 35772 1718 2 , , , 35772 1718 3 66 66 CD 35772 1718 4 . . . 35772 1719 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1719 2 72 72 CD 35772 1719 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1719 4 Professor Professor NNP 35772 1719 5 J. J. NNP 35772 1719 6 Arthur Arthur NNP 35772 1719 7 Thomson Thomson NNP 35772 1719 8 , , , 35772 1719 9 in in IN 35772 1719 10 an an DT 35772 1719 11 article article NN 35772 1719 12 entitled entitle VBN 35772 1719 13 , , , 35772 1719 14 " " `` 35772 1719 15 Is be VBZ 35772 1719 16 there there EX 35772 1719 17 one one CD 35772 1719 18 Science Science NNP 35772 1719 19 of of IN 35772 1719 20 Nature nature NN 35772 1719 21 ? ? . 35772 1719 22 " " '' 35772 1720 1 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1720 2 _ _ NNP 35772 1720 3 Hibbert Hibbert NNP 35772 1720 4 Journal Journal NNP 35772 1720 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1720 6 , , , 35772 1720 7 Oct. October NNP 35772 1720 8 , , , 35772 1720 9 1911 1911 CD 35772 1720 10 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1720 11 . . . 35772 1721 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1721 2 73 73 CD 35772 1721 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1721 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1721 5 The The NNP 35772 1721 6 Science Science NNP 35772 1721 7 and and CC 35772 1721 8 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1721 9 of of IN 35772 1721 10 the the DT 35772 1721 11 Organism Organism NNP 35772 1721 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1721 13 , , , 35772 1721 14 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1721 15 . . . 35772 1722 1 II II NNP 35772 1722 2 , , , 35772 1722 3 p. p. NN 35772 1722 4 338 338 CD 35772 1722 5 . . . 35772 1723 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1723 2 74 74 CD 35772 1723 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1723 4 Op Op NNP 35772 1723 5 . . . 35772 1724 1 cit cit NNP 35772 1724 2 . . . 35772 1725 1 p. p. NN 35772 1725 2 101 101 CD 35772 1725 3 . . . 35772 1726 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1726 2 75 75 CD 35772 1726 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1726 4 Other other JJ 35772 1726 5 names name NNS 35772 1726 6 of of IN 35772 1726 7 distinguished distinguished JJ 35772 1726 8 scientists scientist NNS 35772 1726 9 holding hold VBG 35772 1726 10 this this DT 35772 1726 11 view view NN 35772 1726 12 are be VBP 35772 1726 13 : : : 35772 1726 14 Sir Sir NNP 35772 1726 15 W. W. NNP 35772 1726 16 Crookes Crookes NNP 35772 1726 17 the the DT 35772 1726 18 Physicist Physicist NNP 35772 1726 19 and and CC 35772 1726 20 Sir Sir NNP 35772 1726 21 W. W. NNP 35772 1726 22 F. F. NNP 35772 1726 23 Barrett Barrett NNP 35772 1726 24 , , , 35772 1726 25 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 35772 1726 26 , , , 35772 1726 27 in in IN 35772 1726 28 England England NNP 35772 1726 29 , , , 35772 1726 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 35772 1726 31 Hodgson Hodgson NNP 35772 1726 32 and and CC 35772 1726 33 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1726 34 James James NNP 35772 1726 35 Hyslop Hyslop NNP 35772 1726 36 in in IN 35772 1726 37 America America NNP 35772 1726 38 , , , 35772 1726 39 Lombroso Lombroso NNP 35772 1726 40 in in IN 35772 1726 41 Italy Italy NNP 35772 1726 42 , , , 35772 1726 43 Richet Richet NNP 35772 1726 44 in in IN 35772 1726 45 France France NNP 35772 1726 46 . . . 35772 1727 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1727 2 76 76 CD 35772 1727 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1727 4 From from IN 35772 1727 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 35772 1727 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1727 7 Duplik Duplik NNP 35772 1727 8 _ _ NNP 35772 1727 9 . . . 35772 1728 1 Quoted quote VBN 35772 1728 2 by by IN 35772 1728 3 Höffding Höffding NNP 35772 1728 4 , , , 35772 1728 5 _ _ NNP 35772 1728 6 History history NN 35772 1728 7 of of IN 35772 1728 8 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 35772 1728 9 _ _ NNP 35772 1728 10 , , , 35772 1728 11 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1728 12 . . . 35772 1729 1 II II NNP 35772 1729 2 , , , 35772 1729 3 p. p. NN 35772 1729 4 21 21 CD 35772 1729 5 . . . 35772 1730 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1730 2 77 77 CD 35772 1730 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1730 4 F. F. NNP 35772 1730 5 H. H. NNP 35772 1730 6 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1730 7 on on IN 35772 1730 8 " " `` 35772 1730 9 Phenomenalism Phenomenalism NNP 35772 1730 10 " " '' 35772 1730 11 ( ( -LRB- 35772 1730 12 _ _ NNP 35772 1730 13 Appearance Appearance NNP 35772 1730 14 and and CC 35772 1730 15 Reality Reality NNP 35772 1730 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1730 17 , , , 35772 1730 18 p. p. NN 35772 1730 19 126 126 CD 35772 1730 20 ) ) -RRB- 35772 1730 21 . . . 35772 1731 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1731 2 78 78 CD 35772 1731 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1731 4 Höffding höffding NN 35772 1731 5 , , , 35772 1731 6 op op NN 35772 1731 7 . . . 35772 1732 1 cit cit NNP 35772 1732 2 . . . 35772 1732 3 , , , 35772 1732 4 Vol Vol NNP 35772 1732 5 . . . 35772 1733 1 I -PRON- PRP 35772 1733 2 , , , 35772 1733 3 p. p. NN 35772 1733 4 129 129 CD 35772 1733 5 . . . 35772 1734 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1734 2 79 79 CD 35772 1734 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1734 4 Feuerbach Feuerbach NNP 35772 1734 5 , , , 35772 1734 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1734 7 Essence Essence NNP 35772 1734 8 of of IN 35772 1734 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 35772 1734 10 _ _ NNP 35772 1734 11 , , , 35772 1734 12 p. p. NN 35772 1734 13 21 21 CD 35772 1734 14 . . . 35772 1735 1 [ [ -LRB- 35772 1735 2 80 80 CD 35772 1735 3 ] ] -RRB- 35772 1735 4 We -PRON- PRP 35772 1735 5 now now RB 35772 1735 6 learn learn VBP 35772 1735 7 that that IN 35772 1735 8 conceptions conception NNS 35772 1735 9 of of IN 35772 1735 10 space space NN 35772 1735 11 of of IN 35772 1735 12 a a DT 35772 1735 13 highly highly RB 35772 1735 14 unorthodox unorthodox JJ 35772 1735 15 character character NN 35772 1735 16 are be VBP 35772 1735 17 entertained entertain VBN 35772 1735 18 by by IN 35772 1735 19 physicists physicist NNS 35772 1735 20 and and CC 35772 1735 21 mathematicians mathematician NNS 35772 1735 22 , , , 35772 1735 23 as as IN 35772 1735 24 the the DT 35772 1735 25 result result NN 35772 1735 26 of of IN 35772 1735 27 recent recent JJ 35772 1735 28 researches research NNS 35772 1735 29 in in IN 35772 1735 30 the the DT 35772 1735 31 sphere sphere NN 35772 1735 32 of of IN 35772 1735 33 the the DT 35772 1735 34 gravitation gravitation NN 35772 1735 35 of of IN 35772 1735 36 light light NN 35772 1735 37 . . . 35772 1736 1 INDEX INDEX NNP 35772 1736 2 Agnosticism Agnosticism NNP 35772 1736 3 , , , 35772 1736 4 92 92 CD 35772 1736 5 Anti anti JJ 35772 1736 6 - - NN 35772 1736 7 clericalism clericalism NNP 35772 1736 8 , , , 35772 1736 9 43 43 CD 35772 1736 10 Aquinas Aquinas NNP 35772 1736 11 , , , 35772 1736 12 9 9 CD 35772 1736 13 f. f. NN 35772 1736 14 , , , 35772 1736 15 30 30 CD 35772 1736 16 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 17 n. n. NN 35772 1736 18 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 19 Aristotle Aristotle NNP 35772 1736 20 , , , 35772 1736 21 8 8 CD 35772 1736 22 , , , 35772 1736 23 136 136 CD 35772 1736 24 Atomic atomic JJ 35772 1736 25 theory theory NN 35772 1736 26 , , , 35772 1736 27 the the DT 35772 1736 28 , , , 35772 1736 29 49 49 CD 35772 1736 30 collapse collapse NN 35772 1736 31 of of IN 35772 1736 32 , , , 35772 1736 33 126 126 CD 35772 1736 34 Bacon Bacon NNP 35772 1736 35 , , , 35772 1736 36 Lord Lord NNP 35772 1736 37 , , , 35772 1736 38 16 16 CD 35772 1736 39 f. f. NN 35772 1736 40 Balfour Balfour NNP 35772 1736 41 , , , 35772 1736 42 A. a. NN 35772 1736 43 J. J. NNP 35772 1736 44 , , , 35772 1736 45 105 105 CD 35772 1736 46 f. f. NN 35772 1736 47 , , , 35772 1736 48 110 110 CD 35772 1736 49 , , , 35772 1736 50 128 128 CD 35772 1736 51 Bergson Bergson NNP 35772 1736 52 , , , 35772 1736 53 115 115 CD 35772 1736 54 - - SYM 35772 1736 55 121 121 CD 35772 1736 56 , , , 35772 1736 57 143 143 CD 35772 1736 58 Berkeley Berkeley NNP 35772 1736 59 , , , 35772 1736 60 55 55 CD 35772 1736 61 Boutroux Boutroux NNP 35772 1736 62 , , , 35772 1736 63 112 112 CD 35772 1736 64 f. f. NN 35772 1736 65 , , , 35772 1736 66 143 143 CD 35772 1736 67 Bradley Bradley NNP 35772 1736 68 , , , 35772 1736 69 F. F. NNP 35772 1736 70 H. H. NNP 35772 1736 71 , , , 35772 1736 72 104 104 CD 35772 1736 73 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 74 , , , 35772 1736 75 110 110 CD 35772 1736 76 , , , 35772 1736 77 122 122 CD 35772 1736 78 , , , 35772 1736 79 139 139 CD 35772 1736 80 Bruno Bruno NNP 35772 1736 81 , , , 35772 1736 82 12 12 CD 35772 1736 83 , , , 35772 1736 84 25 25 CD 35772 1736 85 , , , 35772 1736 86 29 29 CD 35772 1736 87 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 88 , , , 35772 1736 89 140 140 CD 35772 1736 90 Büchner Büchner NNP 35772 1736 91 , , , 35772 1736 92 86 86 CD 35772 1736 93 , , , 35772 1736 94 144 144 CD 35772 1736 95 Buffon Buffon NNP 35772 1736 96 , , , 35772 1736 97 77 77 CD 35772 1736 98 Carlyle Carlyle NNP 35772 1736 99 , , , 35772 1736 100 Thomas Thomas NNP 35772 1736 101 , , , 35772 1736 102 38 38 CD 35772 1736 103 , , , 35772 1736 104 99 99 CD 35772 1736 105 - - SYM 35772 1736 106 102 102 CD 35772 1736 107 Coleridge Coleridge NNP 35772 1736 108 , , , 35772 1736 109 S. S. NNP 35772 1736 110 T. T. NNP 35772 1736 111 , , , 35772 1736 112 98 98 CD 35772 1736 113 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 114 Comte Comte NNP 35772 1736 115 , , , 35772 1736 116 85 85 CD 35772 1736 117 , , , 35772 1736 118 89 89 CD 35772 1736 119 , , , 35772 1736 120 92 92 CD 35772 1736 121 Copernicus Copernicus NNP 35772 1736 122 , , , 35772 1736 123 11 11 CD 35772 1736 124 , , , 35772 1736 125 22 22 CD 35772 1736 126 , , , 35772 1736 127 25 25 CD 35772 1736 128 , , , 35772 1736 129 58 58 CD 35772 1736 130 Cunningham Cunningham NNP 35772 1736 131 , , , 35772 1736 132 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 133 , , , 35772 1736 134 127 127 CD 35772 1736 135 Cusanus cusanu NNS 35772 1736 136 , , , 35772 1736 137 10 10 CD 35772 1736 138 Dalton Dalton NNP 35772 1736 139 , , , 35772 1736 140 49 49 CD 35772 1736 141 , , , 35772 1736 142 83 83 CD 35772 1736 143 , , , 35772 1736 144 126 126 CD 35772 1736 145 Darwin Darwin NNP 35772 1736 146 , , , 35772 1736 147 80 80 CD 35772 1736 148 - - SYM 35772 1736 149 83 83 CD 35772 1736 150 , , , 35772 1736 151 87 87 CD 35772 1736 152 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 153 Descartes Descartes NNP 35772 1736 154 , , , 35772 1736 155 19 19 CD 35772 1736 156 - - SYM 35772 1736 157 22 22 CD 35772 1736 158 , , , 35772 1736 159 26 26 CD 35772 1736 160 , , , 35772 1736 161 37 37 CD 35772 1736 162 , , , 35772 1736 163 43 43 CD 35772 1736 164 , , , 35772 1736 165 55 55 CD 35772 1736 166 , , , 35772 1736 167 74 74 CD 35772 1736 168 , , , 35772 1736 169 136 136 CD 35772 1736 170 Design Design NNP 35772 1736 171 , , , 35772 1736 172 Argument argument NN 35772 1736 173 from from IN 35772 1736 174 , , , 35772 1736 175 87 87 CD 35772 1736 176 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 177 Diderot Diderot NNP 35772 1736 178 , , , 35772 1736 179 45 45 CD 35772 1736 180 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 181 , , , 35772 1736 182 48 48 CD 35772 1736 183 , , , 35772 1736 184 141 141 CD 35772 1736 185 , , , 35772 1736 186 144 144 CD 35772 1736 187 Driesch Driesch NNP 35772 1736 188 , , , 35772 1736 189 130 130 CD 35772 1736 190 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 191 Eckhart Eckhart NNP 35772 1736 192 , , , 35772 1736 193 30 30 CD 35772 1736 194 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 195 n. n. NN 35772 1736 196 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 197 Encyclopædia Encyclopædia NNP 35772 1736 198 , , , 35772 1736 199 The the DT 35772 1736 200 , , , 35772 1736 201 45 45 CD 35772 1736 202 Electrons Electrons NNPS 35772 1736 203 , , , 35772 1736 204 126 126 CD 35772 1736 205 Feuerbach Feuerbach NNP 35772 1736 206 , , , 35772 1736 207 85 85 CD 35772 1736 208 , , , 35772 1736 209 95 95 CD 35772 1736 210 Fichte Fichte NNP 35772 1736 211 , , , 35772 1736 212 65 65 CD 35772 1736 213 - - SYM 35772 1736 214 67 67 CD 35772 1736 215 Galileo Galileo NNP 35772 1736 216 , , , 35772 1736 217 12 12 CD 35772 1736 218 - - SYM 35772 1736 219 15 15 CD 35772 1736 220 , , , 35772 1736 221 22 22 CD 35772 1736 222 , , , 35772 1736 223 55 55 CD 35772 1736 224 , , , 35772 1736 225 79 79 CD 35772 1736 226 , , , 35772 1736 227 136 136 CD 35772 1736 228 Goethe goethe CD 35772 1736 229 , , , 35772 1736 230 30 30 CD 35772 1736 231 , , , 35772 1736 232 65 65 CD 35772 1736 233 Green Green NNP 35772 1736 234 , , , 35772 1736 235 T. T. NNP 35772 1736 236 H. H. NNP 35772 1736 237 , , , 35772 1736 238 103 103 CD 35772 1736 239 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 240 Haeckel Haeckel NNP 35772 1736 241 , , , 35772 1736 242 88 88 CD 35772 1736 243 Haldane Haldane NNP 35772 1736 244 , , , 35772 1736 245 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 246 J. J. NNP 35772 1736 247 S. S. NNP 35772 1736 248 , , , 35772 1736 249 129 129 CD 35772 1736 250 , , , 35772 1736 251 132 132 CD 35772 1736 252 Harvey Harvey NNP 35772 1736 253 , , , 35772 1736 254 William William NNP 35772 1736 255 , , , 35772 1736 256 19 19 CD 35772 1736 257 , , , 35772 1736 258 22 22 CD 35772 1736 259 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 1736 260 , , , 35772 1736 261 67 67 CD 35772 1736 262 - - SYM 35772 1736 263 70 70 CD 35772 1736 264 Heine Heine NNP 35772 1736 265 , , , 35772 1736 266 85 85 CD 35772 1736 267 Helmholtz Helmholtz NNP 35772 1736 268 , , , 35772 1736 269 75 75 CD 35772 1736 270 Hobbes Hobbes NNPS 35772 1736 271 , , , 35772 1736 272 22 22 CD 35772 1736 273 , , , 35772 1736 274 26 26 CD 35772 1736 275 , , , 35772 1736 276 43 43 CD 35772 1736 277 , , , 35772 1736 278 55 55 CD 35772 1736 279 , , , 35772 1736 280 144 144 CD 35772 1736 281 Holbach Holbach NNP 35772 1736 282 , , , 35772 1736 283 46 46 CD 35772 1736 284 - - SYM 35772 1736 285 48 48 CD 35772 1736 286 , , , 35772 1736 287 141 141 CD 35772 1736 288 , , , 35772 1736 289 144 144 CD 35772 1736 290 Hume Hume NNP 35772 1736 291 , , , 35772 1736 292 55 55 CD 35772 1736 293 f. f. NN 35772 1736 294 , , , 35772 1736 295 58 58 CD 35772 1736 296 Huxley Huxley NNP 35772 1736 297 , , , 35772 1736 298 92 92 CD 35772 1736 299 f. f. NN 35772 1736 300 , , , 35772 1736 301 95 95 CD 35772 1736 302 Inge Inge NNP 35772 1736 303 , , , 35772 1736 304 38 38 CD 35772 1736 305 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 306 n. n. NN 35772 1736 307 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 308 James James NNP 35772 1736 309 , , , 35772 1736 310 William William NNP 35772 1736 311 , , , 35772 1736 312 114 114 CD 35772 1736 313 f. f. NN 35772 1736 314 , , , 35772 1736 315 123 123 CD 35772 1736 316 Jansenists Jansenists NNPS 35772 1736 317 , , , 35772 1736 318 the the DT 35772 1736 319 , , , 35772 1736 320 43 43 CD 35772 1736 321 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 322 n. n. NN 35772 1736 323 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 324 Jesuits Jesuits NNP 35772 1736 325 , , , 35772 1736 326 the the DT 35772 1736 327 , , , 35772 1736 328 22 22 CD 35772 1736 329 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 330 n. n. NN 35772 1736 331 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 332 , , , 35772 1736 333 26 26 CD 35772 1736 334 , , , 35772 1736 335 37 37 CD 35772 1736 336 , , , 35772 1736 337 43 43 CD 35772 1736 338 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 339 n. n. NN 35772 1736 340 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 341 Johnson Johnson NNP 35772 1736 342 , , , 35772 1736 343 Dr. Dr. NNP 35772 1736 344 , , , 35772 1736 345 47 47 CD 35772 1736 346 Kant Kant NNP 35772 1736 347 , , , 35772 1736 348 53 53 CD 35772 1736 349 - - SYM 35772 1736 350 61 61 CD 35772 1736 351 , , , 35772 1736 352 66 66 CD 35772 1736 353 , , , 35772 1736 354 70 70 CD 35772 1736 355 , , , 35772 1736 356 77 77 CD 35772 1736 357 , , , 35772 1736 358 85 85 CD 35772 1736 359 , , , 35772 1736 360 137 137 CD 35772 1736 361 , , , 35772 1736 362 141 141 CD 35772 1736 363 and and CC 35772 1736 364 Hegel Hegel NNP 35772 1736 365 compared compare VBN 35772 1736 366 , , , 35772 1736 367 69 69 CD 35772 1736 368 and and CC 35772 1736 369 Locke Locke NNP 35772 1736 370 compared compare VBN 35772 1736 371 , , , 35772 1736 372 57 57 CD 35772 1736 373 and and CC 35772 1736 374 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 1736 375 compared compare VBD 35772 1736 376 , , , 35772 1736 377 65 65 CD 35772 1736 378 Kepler Kepler NNP 35772 1736 379 , , , 35772 1736 380 15 15 CD 35772 1736 381 Lamarck Lamarck NNP 35772 1736 382 , , , 35772 1736 383 77 77 CD 35772 1736 384 La La NNP 35772 1736 385 Mettrie Mettrie NNP 35772 1736 386 , , , 35772 1736 387 45 45 CD 35772 1736 388 , , , 35772 1736 389 48 48 CD 35772 1736 390 , , , 35772 1736 391 74 74 CD 35772 1736 392 Lange Lange NNP 35772 1736 393 , , , 35772 1736 394 47 47 CD 35772 1736 395 , , , 35772 1736 396 84 84 CD 35772 1736 397 Laplace Laplace NNP 35772 1736 398 , , , 35772 1736 399 48 48 CD 35772 1736 400 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 401 Larmor Larmor NNP 35772 1736 402 , , , 35772 1736 403 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 404 J. J. NNP 35772 1736 405 , , , 35772 1736 406 127 127 CD 35772 1736 407 Lavoisier Lavoisier NNP 35772 1736 408 , , , 35772 1736 409 49 49 CD 35772 1736 410 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 411 Leibniz Leibniz NNP 35772 1736 412 , , , 35772 1736 413 33 33 CD 35772 1736 414 - - SYM 35772 1736 415 36 36 CD 35772 1736 416 , , , 35772 1736 417 41 41 CD 35772 1736 418 , , , 35772 1736 419 52 52 CD 35772 1736 420 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 421 , , , 35772 1736 422 122 122 CD 35772 1736 423 , , , 35772 1736 424 141 141 CD 35772 1736 425 Leonardo Leonardo NNP 35772 1736 426 da da NNP 35772 1736 427 Vinci Vinci NNP 35772 1736 428 , , , 35772 1736 429 14 14 CD 35772 1736 430 , , , 35772 1736 431 16 16 CD 35772 1736 432 , , , 35772 1736 433 132 132 CD 35772 1736 434 Lessing lessing NN 35772 1736 435 , , , 35772 1736 436 138 138 CD 35772 1736 437 Locke Locke NNP 35772 1736 438 , , , 35772 1736 439 52 52 CD 35772 1736 440 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 441 , , , 35772 1736 442 55 55 CD 35772 1736 443 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 444 Lodge Lodge NNP 35772 1736 445 , , , 35772 1736 446 Sir Sir NNP 35772 1736 447 O. O. NNP 35772 1736 448 , , , 35772 1736 449 134 134 CD 35772 1736 450 Lotze Lotze NNPS 35772 1736 451 , , , 35772 1736 452 107 107 CD 35772 1736 453 - - HYPH 35772 1736 454 109 109 CD 35772 1736 455 Lyell Lyell NNP 35772 1736 456 , , , 35772 1736 457 78 78 CD 35772 1736 458 - - SYM 35772 1736 459 80 80 CD 35772 1736 460 Mach Mach NNP 35772 1736 461 , , , 35772 1736 462 110 110 CD 35772 1736 463 - - SYM 35772 1736 464 114 114 CD 35772 1736 465 , , , 35772 1736 466 143 143 CD 35772 1736 467 Malthus Malthus NNP 35772 1736 468 ' ' POS 35772 1736 469 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 470 Essay Essay NNP 35772 1736 471 on on IN 35772 1736 472 Population Population NNP 35772 1736 473 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 474 , , , 35772 1736 475 80 80 CD 35772 1736 476 Meyer Meyer NNP 35772 1736 477 , , , 35772 1736 478 75 75 CD 35772 1736 479 McTaggart McTaggart NNP 35772 1736 480 , , , 35772 1736 481 123 123 CD 35772 1736 482 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 483 n. n. NN 35772 1736 484 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 485 Modernism Modernism NNP 35772 1736 486 , , , 35772 1736 487 109 109 CD 35772 1736 488 Monads monad NNS 35772 1736 489 , , , 35772 1736 490 35 35 CD 35772 1736 491 f. f. NN 35772 1736 492 , , , 35772 1736 493 122 122 CD 35772 1736 494 " " `` 35772 1736 495 Natural Natural NNP 35772 1736 496 Selection Selection NNP 35772 1736 497 , , , 35772 1736 498 " " '' 35772 1736 499 81 81 CD 35772 1736 500 , , , 35772 1736 501 87 87 CD 35772 1736 502 Newton Newton NNP 35772 1736 503 , , , 35772 1736 504 23 23 CD 35772 1736 505 - - SYM 35772 1736 506 26 26 CD 35772 1736 507 , , , 35772 1736 508 43 43 CD 35772 1736 509 , , , 35772 1736 510 44 44 CD 35772 1736 511 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 512 n. n. NN 35772 1736 513 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 514 , , , 35772 1736 515 48 48 CD 35772 1736 516 , , , 35772 1736 517 82 82 CD 35772 1736 518 , , , 35772 1736 519 136 136 CD 35772 1736 520 Nietzsche nietzsche NN 35772 1736 521 , , , 35772 1736 522 94 94 CD 35772 1736 523 , , , 35772 1736 524 96 96 CD 35772 1736 525 f. f. NNP 35772 1736 526 Paley Paley NNP 35772 1736 527 , , , 35772 1736 528 87 87 CD 35772 1736 529 Pascal pascal JJ 35772 1736 530 , , , 35772 1736 531 22 22 CD 35772 1736 532 , , , 35772 1736 533 36 36 CD 35772 1736 534 - - SYM 35772 1736 535 41 41 CD 35772 1736 536 Pearson Pearson NNP 35772 1736 537 , , , 35772 1736 538 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 539 Karl Karl NNP 35772 1736 540 , , , 35772 1736 541 1 1 CD 35772 1736 542 Pessimism Pessimism NNP 35772 1736 543 , , , 35772 1736 544 95 95 CD 35772 1736 545 Positivism positivism NN 35772 1736 546 , , , 35772 1736 547 85 85 CD 35772 1736 548 , , , 35772 1736 549 95 95 CD 35772 1736 550 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 35772 1736 551 , , , 35772 1736 552 109 109 CD 35772 1736 553 Rousseau Rousseau NNP 35772 1736 554 , , , 35772 1736 555 54 54 CD 35772 1736 556 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 557 n. n. NN 35772 1736 558 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 559 , , , 35772 1736 560 62 62 CD 35772 1736 561 - - SYM 35772 1736 562 65 65 CD 35772 1736 563 , , , 35772 1736 564 80 80 CD 35772 1736 565 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 566 Sartor Sartor NNP 35772 1736 567 Resartus Resartus NNP 35772 1736 568 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 569 , , , 35772 1736 570 100 100 CD 35772 1736 571 Schelling schelle VBG 35772 1736 572 , , , 35772 1736 573 65 65 CD 35772 1736 574 Schiller schiller NN 35772 1736 575 , , , 35772 1736 576 65 65 CD 35772 1736 577 Schiller Schiller NNP 35772 1736 578 , , , 35772 1736 579 F. F. NNP 35772 1736 580 C. C. NNP 35772 1736 581 S. S. NNP 35772 1736 582 , , , 35772 1736 583 123 123 CD 35772 1736 584 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 585 n. n. NN 35772 1736 586 _ _ NNP 35772 1736 587 Schleider Schleider NNP 35772 1736 588 , , , 35772 1736 589 75 75 CD 35772 1736 590 Schleiermacher Schleiermacher NNP 35772 1736 591 , , , 35772 1736 592 70 70 CD 35772 1736 593 - - SYM 35772 1736 594 72 72 CD 35772 1736 595 Spencer Spencer NNP 35772 1736 596 , , , 35772 1736 597 Herbert Herbert NNP 35772 1736 598 , , , 35772 1736 599 35 35 CD 35772 1736 600 , , , 35772 1736 601 77 77 CD 35772 1736 602 , , , 35772 1736 603 89 89 CD 35772 1736 604 - - SYM 35772 1736 605 92 92 CD 35772 1736 606 , , , 35772 1736 607 122 122 CD 35772 1736 608 Spinoza Spinoza NNP 35772 1736 609 , , , 35772 1736 610 28 28 CD 35772 1736 611 - - SYM 35772 1736 612 33 33 CD 35772 1736 613 , , , 35772 1736 614 41 41 CD 35772 1736 615 , , , 35772 1736 616 52 52 CD 35772 1736 617 f. f. NNS 35772 1736 618 , , , 35772 1736 619 67 67 CD 35772 1736 620 , , , 35772 1736 621 141 141 CD 35772 1736 622 " " `` 35772 1736 623 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 35772 1736 624 , , , 35772 1736 625 " " '' 35772 1736 626 133 133 CD 35772 1736 627 - - SYM 35772 1736 628 136 136 CD 35772 1736 629 Stephen Stephen NNP 35772 1736 630 , , , 35772 1736 631 Leslie Leslie NNP 35772 1736 632 , , , 35772 1736 633 92 92 CD 35772 1736 634 Tait Tait NNP 35772 1736 635 , , , 35772 1736 636 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 637 , , , 35772 1736 638 128 128 CD 35772 1736 639 Thomson Thomson NNP 35772 1736 640 , , , 35772 1736 641 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1736 642 J. J. NNP 35772 1737 1 A. A. NNP 35772 1737 2 , , , 35772 1737 3 130 130 CD 35772 1737 4 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 5 n. n. NN 35772 1737 6 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 7 Voltaire Voltaire NNP 35772 1737 8 , , , 35772 1737 9 44 44 CD 35772 1737 10 f. f. NNP 35772 1737 11 Wallace Wallace NNP 35772 1737 12 , , , 35772 1737 13 Alfred Alfred NNP 35772 1737 14 Russell Russell NNP 35772 1737 15 , , , 35772 1737 16 81 81 CD 35772 1737 17 f. f. NN 35772 1737 18 Ward Ward NNP 35772 1737 19 , , , 35772 1737 20 Prof. Prof. NNP 35772 1737 21 James James NNP 35772 1737 22 , , , 35772 1737 23 26 26 CD 35772 1737 24 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 25 n. n. NN 35772 1737 26 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 27 , , , 35772 1737 28 91 91 CD 35772 1737 29 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 30 n. n. NN 35772 1737 31 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 32 , , , 35772 1737 33 123 123 CD 35772 1737 34 Whöler Whöler NNP 35772 1737 35 , , , 35772 1737 36 74 74 CD 35772 1737 37 Zeno Zeno NNP 35772 1737 38 's 's POS 35772 1737 39 paradox paradox NN 35772 1737 40 , , , 35772 1737 41 117 117 CD 35772 1737 42 Printed Printed NNP 35772 1737 43 in in IN 35772 1737 44 Great Great NNP 35772 1737 45 Britain Britain NNP 35772 1737 46 at at IN 35772 1737 47 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 48 The the DT 35772 1737 49 Mayflower Mayflower NNP 35772 1737 50 Press Press NNP 35772 1737 51 , , , 35772 1737 52 Plymouth Plymouth NNP 35772 1737 53 . . . 35772 1737 54 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 55 William William NNP 35772 1737 56 Brandon Brandon NNP 35772 1737 57 & & CC 35772 1737 58 Son Son NNP 35772 1737 59 , , , 35772 1737 60 Ltd. Ltd. NNP 35772 1737 61 TRANSCRIBER TRANSCRIBER NNP 35772 1737 62 'S be VBZ 35772 1737 63 NOTES note NNS 35772 1737 64 : : : 35772 1737 65 Passages passage NNS 35772 1737 66 in in IN 35772 1737 67 italics italic NNS 35772 1737 68 are be VBP 35772 1737 69 indicated indicate VBN 35772 1737 70 by by IN 35772 1737 71 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 72 italics italics NNPS 35772 1737 73 _ _ NNP 35772 1737 74 . . . 35772 1738 1 Punctuation punctuation NN 35772 1738 2 has have VBZ 35772 1738 3 been be VBN 35772 1738 4 corrected correct VBN 35772 1738 5 without without IN 35772 1738 6 note note NN 35772 1738 7 . . . 35772 1739 1 Spelling spelling NN 35772 1739 2 , , , 35772 1739 3 grammatical grammatical JJ 35772 1739 4 and and CC 35772 1739 5 typographical typographical JJ 35772 1739 6 errors error NNS 35772 1739 7 have have VBP 35772 1739 8 been be VBN 35772 1739 9 corrected correct VBN 35772 1739 10 in in IN 35772 1739 11 the the DT 35772 1739 12 text text NN 35772 1739 13 : : : 35772 1739 14 Page page NN 35772 1739 15 68 68 CD 35772 1739 16 : : : 35772 1739 17 " " `` 35772 1739 18 understand understand VB 35772 1739 19 " " '' 35772 1739 20 changed change VBN 35772 1739 21 to to IN 35772 1739 22 " " `` 35772 1739 23 understands understand NNS 35772 1739 24 " " `` 35772 1739 25 Page page NN 35772 1739 26 70 70 CD 35772 1739 27 : : : 35772 1739 28 " " `` 35772 1739 29 fom fom NNP 35772 1739 30 " " '' 35772 1739 31 changed change VBN 35772 1739 32 to to IN 35772 1739 33 " " `` 35772 1739 34 from from IN 35772 1739 35 " " `` 35772 1739 36 Page page NN 35772 1739 37 128 128 CD 35772 1739 38 : : : 35772 1739 39 " " `` 35772 1739 40 subjectly subjectly RB 35772 1739 41 " " '' 35772 1739 42 changed change VBN 35772 1739 43 to to TO 35772 1739 44 " " `` 35772 1739 45 subjectively subjectively RB 35772 1739 46 " " '' 35772 1739 47 Page page NN 35772 1739 48 138 138 CD 35772 1739 49 : : : 35772 1739 50 " " `` 35772 1739 51 Odyssies odyssie NNS 35772 1739 52 " " '' 35772 1739 53 changed change VBD 35772 1739 54 to to IN 35772 1739 55 " " `` 35772 1739 56 Odysseys Odysseys NNP 35772 1739 57 " " '' 35772 1739 58 Inconsistencies Inconsistencies NNPS 35772 1739 59 in in IN 35772 1739 60 spelling spelling NN 35772 1739 61 and and CC 35772 1739 62 hyphenation hyphenation NN 35772 1739 63 have have VBP 35772 1739 64 been be VBN 35772 1739 65 retained retain VBN 35772 1739 66 from from IN 35772 1739 67 the the DT 35772 1739 68 original original NN 35772 1739 69 . . .