id sid tid token lemma pos 13433 1 1 Archives archive NNS 13433 1 2 < < XX 13433 1 3 freethought@despammed.com freethought@despammed.com ADD 13433 1 4 > > XX 13433 1 5 PRODUCTION production NN 13433 1 6 NOTES note NNS 13433 1 7 : : : 13433 1 8 A A NNP 13433 1 9 Reply Reply NNP 13433 1 10 to to IN 13433 1 11 Dr Dr NNP 13433 1 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1 13 's 's POS 13433 1 14 Essays essay NNS 13433 1 15 by by IN 13433 1 16 Walter Walter NNP 13433 1 17 R. R. NNP 13433 1 18 Cassels Cassels NNP 13433 1 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1 20 4-Sep-1826 4-sep-1826 CD 13433 1 21 to to IN 13433 1 22 10-Jun-1907 10-Jun-1907 NNP 13433 1 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1 24 Originally originally RB 13433 1 25 published publish VBN 13433 1 26 anonymously anonymously RB 13433 1 27 in in IN 13433 1 28 1889 1889 CD 13433 1 29 . . . 13433 2 1 Transcribed transcribe VBN 13433 2 2 by by IN 13433 2 3 the the DT 13433 2 4 Freethought Freethought NNP 13433 2 5 Archives Archives NNPS 13433 2 6 < < XX 13433 2 7 freethought@despammed.com freethought@despammed.com ADD 13433 2 8 > > XX 13433 2 9 A a DT 13433 2 10 REPLY reply NN 13433 2 11 TO to IN 13433 2 12 DR DR NNP 13433 2 13 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 2 14 'S 's POS 13433 2 15 ESSAYS essay NNS 13433 2 16 BY by IN 13433 2 17 THE the DT 13433 2 18 AUTHOR author NN 13433 2 19 OF of IN 13433 2 20 " " `` 13433 2 21 SUPERNATURAL supernatural JJ 13433 2 22 RELIGION religion NN 13433 2 23 " " '' 13433 2 24 LONDON LONDON NNP 13433 2 25 1889 1889 CD 13433 2 26 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 13433 2 27 . . . 13433 3 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 3 2 sincerely sincerely RB 13433 3 3 rejoice rejoice VBP 13433 3 4 that that IN 13433 3 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 3 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 3 7 has have VBZ 13433 3 8 recovered recover VBN 13433 3 9 from from IN 13433 3 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 3 11 recent recent JJ 13433 3 12 illness illness NN 13433 3 13 . . . 13433 4 1 Of of IN 13433 4 2 this this DT 13433 4 3 restoration restoration NN 13433 4 4 the the DT 13433 4 5 vigorous vigorous JJ 13433 4 6 energy energy NN 13433 4 7 of of IN 13433 4 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 4 9 preface preface NN 13433 4 10 to to IN 13433 4 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 4 12 republication republication NN 13433 4 13 of of IN 13433 4 14 the the DT 13433 4 15 Essays essay NNS 13433 4 16 on on IN 13433 4 17 _ _ NNP 13433 4 18 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 4 19 Religion Religion NNP 13433 4 20 _ _ NNP 13433 4 21 affords afford VBZ 13433 4 22 decided decide VBD 13433 4 23 evidence evidence NN 13433 4 24 , , , 13433 4 25 and and CC 13433 4 26 I -PRON- PRP 13433 4 27 hope hope VBP 13433 4 28 that that IN 13433 4 29 no no DT 13433 4 30 refutation refutation NN 13433 4 31 of of IN 13433 4 32 this this DT 13433 4 33 inference inference NN 13433 4 34 at at IN 13433 4 35 least least JJS 13433 4 36 may may MD 13433 4 37 be be VB 13433 4 38 possible possible JJ 13433 4 39 , , , 13433 4 40 however however RB 13433 4 41 little little JJ 13433 4 42 we -PRON- PRP 13433 4 43 may may MD 13433 4 44 agree agree VB 13433 4 45 on on IN 13433 4 46 other other JJ 13433 4 47 points point NNS 13433 4 48 . . . 13433 5 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 5 2 was be VBD 13433 5 3 natural natural JJ 13433 5 4 that that IN 13433 5 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 5 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 5 7 should should MD 13433 5 8 not not RB 13433 5 9 be be VB 13433 5 10 averse averse JJ 13433 5 11 to to IN 13433 5 12 preserving preserve VBG 13433 5 13 the the DT 13433 5 14 more more RBR 13433 5 15 serious serious JJ 13433 5 16 part part NN 13433 5 17 of of IN 13433 5 18 these these DT 13433 5 19 Essays essay NNS 13433 5 20 , , , 13433 5 21 the the DT 13433 5 22 preparation preparation NN 13433 5 23 of of IN 13433 5 24 which which WDT 13433 5 25 cost cost VBD 13433 5 26 him -PRON- PRP 13433 5 27 so so RB 13433 5 28 much much JJ 13433 5 29 time time NN 13433 5 30 and and CC 13433 5 31 trouble trouble NN 13433 5 32 ; ; : 13433 5 33 and and CC 13433 5 34 the the DT 13433 5 35 republication republication NN 13433 5 36 of of IN 13433 5 37 this this DT 13433 5 38 portion portion NN 13433 5 39 of of IN 13433 5 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 5 41 reply reply NN 13433 5 42 to to IN 13433 5 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 5 44 volumes volume NNS 13433 5 45 , , , 13433 5 46 giving give VBG 13433 5 47 as as IN 13433 5 48 it -PRON- PRP 13433 5 49 does do VBZ 13433 5 50 the the DT 13433 5 51 most most RBS 13433 5 52 eloquent eloquent JJ 13433 5 53 and and CC 13433 5 54 attractive attractive JJ 13433 5 55 statement statement NN 13433 5 56 of of IN 13433 5 57 the the DT 13433 5 58 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 5 59 case case NN 13433 5 60 , , , 13433 5 61 must must MD 13433 5 62 be be VB 13433 5 63 welcome welcome JJ 13433 5 64 to to IN 13433 5 65 many many JJ 13433 5 66 . . . 13433 6 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 6 2 can can MD 13433 6 3 not not RB 13433 6 4 but but RB 13433 6 5 think think VB 13433 6 6 that that IN 13433 6 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 6 8 has have VBZ 13433 6 9 been be VBN 13433 6 10 an an DT 13433 6 11 error error NN 13433 6 12 of of IN 13433 6 13 judgment judgment NN 13433 6 14 and and CC 13433 6 15 of of IN 13433 6 16 temper temper NN 13433 6 17 , , , 13433 6 18 however however RB 13433 6 19 , , , 13433 6 20 to to TO 13433 6 21 have have VB 13433 6 22 rescued rescue VBN 13433 6 23 from from IN 13433 6 24 an an DT 13433 6 25 ephemeral ephemeral JJ 13433 6 26 state state NN 13433 6 27 of of IN 13433 6 28 existence existence NN 13433 6 29 and and CC 13433 6 30 conferred confer VBD 13433 6 31 literary literary JJ 13433 6 32 permanence permanence NN 13433 6 33 on on IN 13433 6 34 much much JJ 13433 6 35 in in IN 13433 6 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 6 37 present present JJ 13433 6 38 volume volume NN 13433 6 39 , , , 13433 6 40 which which WDT 13433 6 41 is be VBZ 13433 6 42 mere mere JJ 13433 6 43 personal personal JJ 13433 6 44 attack attack NN 13433 6 45 on on IN 13433 6 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 6 47 adversary adversary NN 13433 6 48 and and CC 13433 6 49 a a DT 13433 6 50 deliberate deliberate JJ 13433 6 51 attempt attempt NN 13433 6 52 to to TO 13433 6 53 discredit discredit VB 13433 6 54 a a DT 13433 6 55 writer writer NN 13433 6 56 with with IN 13433 6 57 whom whom WP 13433 6 58 he -PRON- PRP 13433 6 59 pretends pretend VBZ 13433 6 60 to to TO 13433 6 61 enter enter VB 13433 6 62 into into IN 13433 6 63 serious serious JJ 13433 6 64 argument argument NN 13433 6 65 . . . 13433 7 1 A a DT 13433 7 2 material material JJ 13433 7 3 part part NN 13433 7 4 of of IN 13433 7 5 the the DT 13433 7 6 volume volume NN 13433 7 7 is be VBZ 13433 7 8 composed compose VBN 13433 7 9 of of IN 13433 7 10 such such JJ 13433 7 11 matter matter NN 13433 7 12 . . . 13433 8 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 8 2 can can MD 13433 8 3 not not RB 13433 8 4 congratulate congratulate VB 13433 8 5 him -PRON- PRP 13433 8 6 on on IN 13433 8 7 the the DT 13433 8 8 spirit spirit NN 13433 8 9 which which WDT 13433 8 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 8 11 has have VBZ 13433 8 12 displayed display VBN 13433 8 13 . . . 13433 9 1 Personally personally RB 13433 9 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 9 3 am be VBP 13433 9 4 profoundly profoundly RB 13433 9 5 indifferent indifferent JJ 13433 9 6 to to IN 13433 9 7 such such JJ 13433 9 8 attempts attempt NNS 13433 9 9 at at IN 13433 9 10 detraction detraction NN 13433 9 11 , , , 13433 9 12 and and CC 13433 9 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 9 14 is be VBZ 13433 9 15 with with IN 13433 9 16 heretical heretical JJ 13433 9 17 amusement amusement NN 13433 9 18 that that WDT 13433 9 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 9 20 contemplate contemplate VBP 13433 9 21 the the DT 13433 9 22 large large JJ 13433 9 23 part part NN 13433 9 24 which which WDT 13433 9 25 purely purely RB 13433 9 26 individual individual JJ 13433 9 27 and and CC 13433 9 28 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 13433 9 29 criticism criticism NN 13433 9 30 is be VBZ 13433 9 31 made make VBN 13433 9 32 to to TO 13433 9 33 play play VB 13433 9 34 in in IN 13433 9 35 stuffing stuff VBG 13433 9 36 out out RP 13433 9 37 the the DT 13433 9 38 proportions proportion NNS 13433 9 39 of of IN 13433 9 40 orthodox orthodox NNP 13433 9 41 argument argument NN 13433 9 42 . . . 13433 10 1 In in IN 13433 10 2 the the DT 13433 10 3 first first JJ 13433 10 4 moment moment NN 13433 10 5 of of IN 13433 10 6 irritation irritation NN 13433 10 7 , , , 13433 10 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 10 9 can can MD 13433 10 10 well well RB 13433 10 11 understand understand VB 13433 10 12 that that IN 13433 10 13 hard hard RB 13433 10 14 hitting hit VBG 13433 10 15 , , , 13433 10 16 even even RB 13433 10 17 below below IN 13433 10 18 the the DT 13433 10 19 belt belt NN 13433 10 20 , , , 13433 10 21 might may MD 13433 10 22 be be VB 13433 10 23 indulged indulge VBN 13433 10 24 in in RP 13433 10 25 against against IN 13433 10 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 10 27 work work NN 13433 10 28 by by IN 13433 10 29 an an DT 13433 10 30 exasperated exasperate VBN 13433 10 31 theologian theologian NN 13433 10 32 -- -- : 13433 10 33 for for IN 13433 10 34 even even RB 13433 10 35 a a DT 13433 10 36 bishop bishop NN 13433 10 37 is be VBZ 13433 10 38 a a DT 13433 10 39 man,--but man,--but NNP 13433 10 40 that that IN 13433 10 41 such such JJ 13433 10 42 attacks attack NNS 13433 10 43 should should MD 13433 10 44 not not RB 13433 10 45 only only RB 13433 10 46 be be VB 13433 10 47 perpetuated perpetuate VBN 13433 10 48 , , , 13433 10 49 but but CC 13433 10 50 repeated repeat VBN 13433 10 51 after after IN 13433 10 52 years year NNS 13433 10 53 of of IN 13433 10 54 calm calm JJ 13433 10 55 reflection reflection NN 13433 10 56 , , , 13433 10 57 is be VBZ 13433 10 58 at at IN 13433 10 59 once once RB 13433 10 60 an an DT 13433 10 61 error error NN 13433 10 62 and and CC 13433 10 63 a a DT 13433 10 64 compliment compliment NN 13433 10 65 for for IN 13433 10 66 which which WDT 13433 10 67 I -PRON- PRP 13433 10 68 was be VBD 13433 10 69 not not RB 13433 10 70 prepared prepared JJ 13433 10 71 . . . 13433 11 1 Anything anything NN 13433 11 2 to to TO 13433 11 3 prevent prevent VB 13433 11 4 readers reader NNS 13433 11 5 from from IN 13433 11 6 taking take VBG 13433 11 7 up up RP 13433 11 8 _ _ NNP 13433 11 9 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 11 10 Religion Religion NNP 13433 11 11 _ _ NNP 13433 11 12 : : : 13433 11 13 any any DT 13433 11 14 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 11 15 to to TO 13433 11 16 prejudice prejudice VB 13433 11 17 them -PRON- PRP 13433 11 18 against against IN 13433 11 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 11 20 statements statement NNS 13433 11 21 . . . 13433 12 1 Elaborate elaborate VB 13433 12 2 literary literary JJ 13433 12 3 abuse abuse NN 13433 12 4 against against IN 13433 12 5 the the DT 13433 12 6 author author NN 13433 12 7 is be VBZ 13433 12 8 substituted substitute VBN 13433 12 9 for for IN 13433 12 10 the the DT 13433 12 11 effective effective JJ 13433 12 12 arguments argument NNS 13433 12 13 against against IN 13433 12 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 12 15 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 12 16 which which WDT 13433 12 17 are be VBP 13433 12 18 unhappily unhappily RB 13433 12 19 wanting want VBG 13433 12 20 . . . 13433 13 1 In in IN 13433 13 2 the the DT 13433 13 3 later later JJ 13433 13 4 editions edition NNS 13433 13 5 of of IN 13433 13 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 13 7 work work NN 13433 13 8 , , , 13433 13 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 13 10 removed remove VBD 13433 13 11 everything everything NN 13433 13 12 that that WDT 13433 13 13 seemed seem VBD 13433 13 14 likely likely JJ 13433 13 15 to to TO 13433 13 16 irritate irritate VB 13433 13 17 or or CC 13433 13 18 to to TO 13433 13 19 afford afford VB 13433 13 20 openings opening NNS 13433 13 21 for for IN 13433 13 22 the the DT 13433 13 23 discussion discussion NN 13433 13 24 of of IN 13433 13 25 minor minor JJ 13433 13 26 questions question NNS 13433 13 27 , , , 13433 13 28 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 13433 13 29 to to IN 13433 13 30 the the DT 13433 13 31 main main JJ 13433 13 32 subject subject NN 13433 13 33 under under IN 13433 13 34 treatment treatment NN 13433 13 35 . . . 13433 14 1 Whilst whilst IN 13433 14 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 14 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 14 4 in in IN 13433 14 5 many many JJ 13433 14 6 cases case NNS 13433 14 7 points point VBZ 13433 14 8 out out RP 13433 14 9 such such JJ 13433 14 10 alterations alteration NNS 13433 14 11 , , , 13433 14 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 14 13 republishes republish VBZ 13433 14 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 14 15 original original JJ 13433 14 16 attacks attack NNS 13433 14 17 and and CC 13433 14 18 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 14 19 the the DT 13433 14 20 disparaging disparage VBG 13433 14 21 purpose purpose NN 13433 14 22 of of IN 13433 14 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 14 24 Essays essay NNS 13433 14 25 by by IN 13433 14 26 the the DT 13433 14 27 reiterated reiterate VBN 13433 14 28 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 14 29 of of IN 13433 14 30 passages passage NNS 13433 14 31 which which WDT 13433 14 32 had have VBD 13433 14 33 so so RB 13433 14 34 little little JJ 13433 14 35 to to TO 13433 14 36 do do VB 13433 14 37 with with IN 13433 14 38 the the DT 13433 14 39 argument argument NN 13433 14 40 that that IN 13433 14 41 they -PRON- PRP 13433 14 42 no no RB 13433 14 43 longer longer RB 13433 14 44 exist exist VBP 13433 14 45 in in IN 13433 14 46 the the DT 13433 14 47 complete complete JJ 13433 14 48 edition edition NN 13433 14 49 of of IN 13433 14 50 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 14 51 Religion Religion NNP 13433 14 52 . . . 13433 15 1 Could Could MD 13433 15 2 there there EX 13433 15 3 be be VB 13433 15 4 more more RBR 13433 15 5 palpable palpable JJ 13433 15 6 evidence evidence NN 13433 15 7 of of IN 13433 15 8 the the DT 13433 15 9 frivolous frivolous JJ 13433 15 10 and and CC 13433 15 11 superficial superficial JJ 13433 15 12 character character NN 13433 15 13 of of IN 13433 15 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 15 15 objections objection NNS 13433 15 16 ? ? . 13433 16 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 16 2 is be VBZ 13433 16 3 not not RB 13433 16 4 too too RB 13433 16 5 much much JJ 13433 16 6 to to TO 13433 16 7 say say VB 13433 16 8 that that IN 13433 16 9 in in IN 13433 16 10 no no DT 13433 16 11 part part NN 13433 16 12 of of IN 13433 16 13 these these DT 13433 16 14 Essays essay NNS 13433 16 15 has have VBZ 13433 16 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 16 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 16 18 at at RB 13433 16 19 all all RB 13433 16 20 seriously seriously RB 13433 16 21 entered enter VBN 13433 16 22 upon upon IN 13433 16 23 the the DT 13433 16 24 fundamental fundamental JJ 13433 16 25 proposition proposition NN 13433 16 26 of of IN 13433 16 27 _ _ NNP 13433 16 28 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 16 29 Religion Religion NNP 13433 16 30 _ _ NNP 13433 16 31 . . . 13433 17 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 17 2 has have VBZ 13433 17 3 elaborately elaborately RB 13433 17 4 criticised criticise VBN 13433 17 5 notes note NNS 13433 17 6 and and CC 13433 17 7 references reference NNS 13433 17 8 : : : 13433 17 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 17 10 has have VBZ 13433 17 11 discussed discuss VBN 13433 17 12 dates date NNS 13433 17 13 and and CC 13433 17 14 unimportant unimportant JJ 13433 17 15 details detail NNS 13433 17 16 : : : 13433 17 17 but but CC 13433 17 18 as as IN 13433 17 19 to to IN 13433 17 20 the the DT 13433 17 21 question question NN 13433 17 22 whether whether IN 13433 17 23 there there EX 13433 17 24 is be VBZ 13433 17 25 any any DT 13433 17 26 evidence evidence NN 13433 17 27 for for IN 13433 17 28 miracles miracle NNS 13433 17 29 and and CC 13433 17 30 the the DT 13433 17 31 reality reality NN 13433 17 32 of of IN 13433 17 33 alleged alleged JJ 13433 17 34 Divine Divine NNP 13433 17 35 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 17 36 , , , 13433 17 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 17 38 volume volume NN 13433 17 39 is be VBZ 13433 17 40 an an DT 13433 17 41 absolute absolute JJ 13433 17 42 blank blank NN 13433 17 43 . . . 13433 18 1 Bampton Bampton NNP 13433 18 2 Lecturers Lecturers NNPS 13433 18 3 and and CC 13433 18 4 distinguished distinguish VBD 13433 18 5 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 18 6 writers writer NNS 13433 18 7 have have VBP 13433 18 8 frankly frankly RB 13433 18 9 admitted admit VBN 13433 18 10 that that IN 13433 18 11 the the DT 13433 18 12 Christian christian JJ 13433 18 13 argument argument NN 13433 18 14 must must MD 13433 18 15 be be VB 13433 18 16 reconstructed reconstruct VBN 13433 18 17 . . . 13433 19 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 19 2 have have VBP 13433 19 3 felt feel VBN 13433 19 4 the the DT 13433 19 5 positions position NNS 13433 19 6 , , , 13433 19 7 formerly formerly RB 13433 19 8 considered consider VBN 13433 19 9 to to TO 13433 19 10 be be VB 13433 19 11 impregnable impregnable JJ 13433 19 12 , , , 13433 19 13 crumbling crumble VBG 13433 19 14 away away RP 13433 19 15 under under IN 13433 19 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 19 17 feet foot NNS 13433 19 18 , , , 13433 19 19 but but CC 13433 19 20 nothing nothing NN 13433 19 21 could could MD 13433 19 22 more more RBR 13433 19 23 forcibly forcibly RB 13433 19 24 expose expose VB 13433 19 25 the the DT 13433 19 26 feebleness feebleness NN 13433 19 27 of of IN 13433 19 28 the the DT 13433 19 29 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 19 30 case case NN 13433 19 31 than than IN 13433 19 32 this this DT 13433 19 33 volume volume NN 13433 19 34 of of IN 13433 19 35 Dr Dr NNP 13433 19 36 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 19 37 's 's POS 13433 19 38 Essays essay NNS 13433 19 39 . . . 13433 20 1 The the DT 13433 20 2 substantial substantial JJ 13433 20 3 correctness correctness NN 13433 20 4 of of IN 13433 20 5 the the DT 13433 20 6 main main JJ 13433 20 7 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 20 8 of of IN 13433 20 9 _ _ NNP 13433 20 10 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 20 11 Religion Religion NNP 13433 20 12 _ _ NNP 13433 20 13 is be VBZ 13433 20 14 rendered render VBN 13433 20 15 all all PDT 13433 20 16 the the DT 13433 20 17 more more RBR 13433 20 18 apparent apparent JJ 13433 20 19 by by IN 13433 20 20 the the DT 13433 20 21 reply reply NN 13433 20 22 to to IN 13433 20 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 20 24 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 20 25 . . . 13433 21 1 The the DT 13433 21 2 eagerness eagerness NN 13433 21 3 with with IN 13433 21 4 which which WDT 13433 21 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 21 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 21 7 and and CC 13433 21 8 others other NNS 13433 21 9 rush rush VBP 13433 21 10 up up RP 13433 21 11 all all PDT 13433 21 12 the the DT 13433 21 13 side side NN 13433 21 14 issues issue NNS 13433 21 15 and and CC 13433 21 16 turn turn VB 13433 21 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 21 18 backs back NNS 13433 21 19 upon upon IN 13433 21 20 the the DT 13433 21 21 more more RBR 13433 21 22 important important JJ 13433 21 23 central central JJ 13433 21 24 proposition proposition NN 13433 21 25 is be VBZ 13433 21 26 in in IN 13433 21 27 the the DT 13433 21 28 highest high JJS 13433 21 29 degree degree NN 13433 21 30 remarkable remarkable JJ 13433 21 31 . . . 13433 22 1 Those those DT 13433 22 2 who who WP 13433 22 3 are be VBP 13433 22 4 in in IN 13433 22 5 doubt doubt NN 13433 22 6 and and CC 13433 22 7 who who WP 13433 22 8 have have VBP 13433 22 9 understood understand VBN 13433 22 10 what what WP 13433 22 11 the the DT 13433 22 12 problem problem NN 13433 22 13 to to TO 13433 22 14 be be VB 13433 22 15 solved solve VBN 13433 22 16 really really RB 13433 22 17 is be VBZ 13433 22 18 will will MD 13433 22 19 not not RB 13433 22 20 get get VB 13433 22 21 any any DT 13433 22 22 help help NN 13433 22 23 from from IN 13433 22 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 22 25 volume volume NN 13433 22 26 . . . 13433 23 1 The the DT 13433 23 2 republication republication NN 13433 23 3 of of IN 13433 23 4 these these DT 13433 23 5 Essays essay NNS 13433 23 6 , , , 13433 23 7 however however RB 13433 23 8 , , , 13433 23 9 has have VBZ 13433 23 10 almost almost RB 13433 23 11 forced force VBN 13433 23 12 upon upon IN 13433 23 13 me -PRON- PRP 13433 23 14 the the DT 13433 23 15 necessity necessity NN 13433 23 16 of of IN 13433 23 17 likewise likewise RB 13433 23 18 republishing republish VBG 13433 23 19 the the DT 13433 23 20 reply reply NN 13433 23 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 23 22 gave give VBD 13433 23 23 at at IN 13433 23 24 the the DT 13433 23 25 time time NN 13433 23 26 of of IN 13433 23 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 23 28 appearance appearance NN 13433 23 29 . . . 13433 24 1 The the DT 13433 24 2 first first JJ 13433 24 3 Essay Essay NNP 13433 24 4 appeared appear VBD 13433 24 5 in in IN 13433 24 6 the the DT 13433 24 7 _ _ NNP 13433 24 8 Fortnightly Fortnightly NNP 13433 24 9 Review Review NNP 13433 24 10 _ _ NNP 13433 24 11 , , , 13433 24 12 and and CC 13433 24 13 others other NNS 13433 24 14 followed follow VBD 13433 24 15 in in IN 13433 24 16 the the DT 13433 24 17 preface preface NN 13433 24 18 to to IN 13433 24 19 the the DT 13433 24 20 sixth sixth JJ 13433 24 21 edition edition NN 13433 24 22 of of IN 13433 24 23 _ _ NNP 13433 24 24 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 24 25 Religion Religion NNP 13433 24 26 _ _ NNP 13433 24 27 , , , 13433 24 28 and and CC 13433 24 29 in in IN 13433 24 30 that that DT 13433 24 31 and and CC 13433 24 32 the the DT 13433 24 33 complete complete JJ 13433 24 34 edition edition NN 13433 24 35 , , , 13433 24 36 in in IN 13433 24 37 notes note NNS 13433 24 38 to to IN 13433 24 39 the the DT 13433 24 40 portions portion NNS 13433 24 41 attacked attack VBD 13433 24 42 , , , 13433 24 43 where where WRB 13433 24 44 reply reply NN 13433 24 45 seemed seem VBD 13433 24 46 necessary necessary JJ 13433 24 47 . . . 13433 25 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 25 2 can can MD 13433 25 3 not not RB 13433 25 4 hope hope VB 13433 25 5 that that IN 13433 25 6 readers reader NNS 13433 25 7 will will MD 13433 25 8 refer refer VB 13433 25 9 to to IN 13433 25 10 these these DT 13433 25 11 scattered scatter VBN 13433 25 12 arguments argument NNS 13433 25 13 , , , 13433 25 14 and and CC 13433 25 15 this this DT 13433 25 16 volume volume NN 13433 25 17 is be VBZ 13433 25 18 published publish VBN 13433 25 19 with with IN 13433 25 20 the the DT 13433 25 21 view view NN 13433 25 22 of of IN 13433 25 23 affording afford VBG 13433 25 24 a a DT 13433 25 25 convenient convenient JJ 13433 25 26 form form NN 13433 25 27 of of IN 13433 25 28 reference reference NN 13433 25 29 for for IN 13433 25 30 those those DT 13433 25 31 interested interested JJ 13433 25 32 in in IN 13433 25 33 the the DT 13433 25 34 discussion discussion NN 13433 25 35 . . . 13433 26 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 26 2 add add VBP 13433 26 3 brief brief JJ 13433 26 4 notes note NNS 13433 26 5 upon upon IN 13433 26 6 those those DT 13433 26 7 Essays essay NNS 13433 26 8 which which WDT 13433 26 9 did do VBD 13433 26 10 not not RB 13433 26 11 require require VB 13433 26 12 separate separate JJ 13433 26 13 treatment treatment NN 13433 26 14 at at IN 13433 26 15 the the DT 13433 26 16 time time NN 13433 26 17 , , , 13433 26 18 and and CC 13433 26 19 such such JJ 13433 26 20 further further JJ 13433 26 21 explanations explanation NNS 13433 26 22 as as IN 13433 26 23 seem seem VBP 13433 26 24 to to IN 13433 26 25 me -PRON- PRP 13433 26 26 desirable desirable JJ 13433 26 27 for for IN 13433 26 28 the the DT 13433 26 29 elucidation elucidation NN 13433 26 30 of of IN 13433 26 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 26 32 statements statement NNS 13433 26 33 . . . 13433 27 1 Of of RB 13433 27 2 course course RB 13433 27 3 , , , 13433 27 4 the the DT 13433 27 5 full full JJ 13433 27 6 discussion discussion NN 13433 27 7 of of IN 13433 27 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 27 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 27 10 's 's POS 13433 27 11 arguments argument NNS 13433 27 12 must must MD 13433 27 13 still still RB 13433 27 14 be be VB 13433 27 15 sought seek VBN 13433 27 16 in in IN 13433 27 17 the the DT 13433 27 18 volumes volume NNS 13433 27 19 of of IN 13433 27 20 _ _ NNP 13433 27 21 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 27 22 Religion Religion NNP 13433 27 23 _ _ NNP 13433 27 24 , , , 13433 27 25 but but CC 13433 27 26 I -PRON- PRP 13433 27 27 trust trust VBP 13433 27 28 that that IN 13433 27 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 27 30 may may MD 13433 27 31 have have VB 13433 27 32 said say VBN 13433 27 33 enough enough JJ 13433 27 34 here here RB 13433 27 35 to to TO 13433 27 36 indicate indicate VB 13433 27 37 the the DT 13433 27 38 nature nature NN 13433 27 39 of of IN 13433 27 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 27 41 allegations allegation NNS 13433 27 42 and and CC 13433 27 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 27 44 bearing bearing NN 13433 27 45 on on IN 13433 27 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 27 47 argument argument NN 13433 27 48 . . . 13433 28 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 28 2 have have VBP 13433 28 3 likewise likewise RB 13433 28 4 thought think VBN 13433 28 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 28 6 right right JJ 13433 28 7 to to TO 13433 28 8 add add VB 13433 28 9 the the DT 13433 28 10 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 13433 28 11 , , , 13433 28 12 without without IN 13433 28 13 any any DT 13433 28 14 alteration alteration NN 13433 28 15 , , , 13433 28 16 which which WDT 13433 28 17 were be VBD 13433 28 18 written write VBN 13433 28 19 for for IN 13433 28 20 the the DT 13433 28 21 complete complete JJ 13433 28 22 edition edition NN 13433 28 23 , , , 13433 28 24 when when WRB 13433 28 25 , , , 13433 28 26 for for IN 13433 28 27 the the DT 13433 28 28 first first JJ 13433 28 29 time time NN 13433 28 30 , , , 13433 28 31 having have VBG 13433 28 32 examined examine VBN 13433 28 33 all all PDT 13433 28 34 the the DT 13433 28 35 evidence evidence NN 13433 28 36 , , , 13433 28 37 I -PRON- PRP 13433 28 38 was be VBD 13433 28 39 in in IN 13433 28 40 a a DT 13433 28 41 position position NN 13433 28 42 to to TO 13433 28 43 wind wind VB 13433 28 44 up up RP 13433 28 45 the the DT 13433 28 46 case case NN 13433 28 47 . . . 13433 29 1 This this DT 13433 29 2 is be VBZ 13433 29 3 all all PDT 13433 29 4 the the DT 13433 29 5 more more RBR 13433 29 6 necessary necessary JJ 13433 29 7 as as IN 13433 29 8 they -PRON- PRP 13433 29 9 finally finally RB 13433 29 10 show show VBP 13433 29 11 the the DT 13433 29 12 inadequacy inadequacy NN 13433 29 13 of of IN 13433 29 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 29 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 29 16 's 's POS 13433 29 17 treatment treatment NN 13433 29 18 . . . 13433 30 1 But but CC 13433 30 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 30 3 have have VBP 13433 30 4 still still RB 13433 30 5 more more RBR 13433 30 6 been be VBN 13433 30 7 moved move VBN 13433 30 8 to to TO 13433 30 9 append append VB 13433 30 10 these these DT 13433 30 11 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 13433 30 12 in in IN 13433 30 13 order order NN 13433 30 14 to to TO 13433 30 15 put put VB 13433 30 16 them -PRON- PRP 13433 30 17 within within IN 13433 30 18 easier easy JJR 13433 30 19 reach reach NN 13433 30 20 of of IN 13433 30 21 those those DT 13433 30 22 who who WP 13433 30 23 only only RB 13433 30 24 possess possess VBP 13433 30 25 the the DT 13433 30 26 earlier early JJR 13433 30 27 editions edition NNS 13433 30 28 , , , 13433 30 29 which which WDT 13433 30 30 do do VBP 13433 30 31 not not RB 13433 30 32 contain contain VB 13433 30 33 them -PRON- PRP 13433 30 34 . . . 13433 31 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 31 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 31 3 again again RB 13433 31 4 reproaches reproach VBZ 13433 31 5 me -PRON- PRP 13433 31 6 with with IN 13433 31 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 31 8 anonymity anonymity NN 13433 31 9 . . . 13433 32 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 32 2 do do VBP 13433 32 3 not not RB 13433 32 4 think think VB 13433 32 5 that that IN 13433 32 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 32 7 am be VBP 13433 32 8 open open JJ 13433 32 9 to to IN 13433 32 10 much much JJ 13433 32 11 rebuke rebuke NN 13433 32 12 for for IN 13433 32 13 not not RB 13433 32 14 having have VBG 13433 32 15 the the DT 13433 32 16 courage courage NN 13433 32 17 of of IN 13433 32 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 32 19 opinions opinion NNS 13433 32 20 ; ; : 13433 32 21 but but CC 13433 32 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 32 23 may may MD 13433 32 24 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 32 25 say say VB 13433 32 26 that that IN 13433 32 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 32 28 have have VBP 13433 32 29 always always RB 13433 32 30 held hold VBN 13433 32 31 that that IN 13433 32 32 arguments argument NNS 13433 32 33 upon upon IN 13433 32 34 very very RB 13433 32 35 serious serious JJ 13433 32 36 subjects subject NNS 13433 32 37 should should MD 13433 32 38 be be VB 13433 32 39 impersonal impersonal JJ 13433 32 40 , , , 13433 32 41 and and CC 13433 32 42 neither neither CC 13433 32 43 gain gain VB 13433 32 44 weight weight NN 13433 32 45 by by IN 13433 32 46 the the DT 13433 32 47 possession possession NN 13433 32 48 of of IN 13433 32 49 a a DT 13433 32 50 distinguished distinguished JJ 13433 32 51 name name NN 13433 32 52 nor nor CC 13433 32 53 lose lose VB 13433 32 54 by by IN 13433 32 55 the the DT 13433 32 56 want want NN 13433 32 57 of of IN 13433 32 58 it -PRON- PRP 13433 32 59 . . . 13433 33 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 33 2 leave leave VBP 13433 33 3 the the DT 13433 33 4 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 33 5 any any DT 13433 33 6 advantage advantage NN 13433 33 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 33 8 has have VBZ 13433 33 9 in in IN 13433 33 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 33 11 throne throne NN 13433 33 12 , , , 13433 33 13 and and CC 13433 33 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 33 15 take take VBP 13433 33 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 33 17 stand stand NN 13433 33 18 upon upon IN 13433 33 19 the the DT 13433 33 20 basis basis NN 13433 33 21 of of IN 13433 33 22 reason reason NN 13433 33 23 and and CC 13433 33 24 not not RB 13433 33 25 of of IN 13433 33 26 reputation reputation NN 13433 33 27 . . . 13433 34 1 CONTENTS content NNS 13433 34 2 I. i. NN 13433 35 1 A a DT 13433 35 2 REPLY reply NN 13433 35 3 TO to IN 13433 35 4 DR DR NNP 13433 35 5 . . . 13433 35 6 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 35 7 'S 's POS 13433 35 8 FIRST FIRST NNP 13433 35 9 ESSAY ESSAY NNP 13433 35 10 ON on IN 13433 35 11 " " `` 13433 35 12 SUPERNATURAL supernatural JJ 13433 35 13 RELIGION religion NN 13433 35 14 " " '' 13433 35 15 II ii CD 13433 35 16 . . . 13433 36 1 THE the DT 13433 36 2 SILENCE SILENCE NNP 13433 36 3 OF of IN 13433 36 4 EUSEBIUS eusebius NN 13433 36 5 -- -- : 13433 36 6 THE the DT 13433 36 7 IGNATIAN ignatian JJ 13433 36 8 EPISTLES epistle NNS 13433 36 9 III iii CD 13433 36 10 . . . 13433 37 1 POLYCARP POLYCARP NNP 13433 37 2 OF of IN 13433 37 3 SMYRNA SMYRNA NNP 13433 37 4 IV IV NNP 13433 37 5 . . . 13433 38 1 PAPIAS PAPIAS NNP 13433 38 2 OF of IN 13433 38 3 HIERAPOLIS HIERAPOLIS NNP 13433 38 4 V. V. NNP 13433 38 5 MELITO MELITO NNP 13433 38 6 OF of IN 13433 38 7 SARDIS SARDIS NNP 13433 38 8 -- -- : 13433 38 9 CLAUDIUS claudiu NNS 13433 38 10 APOLLINARIS apollinari NNS 13433 38 11 -- -- : 13433 38 12 POLYCRATES polycrate NNS 13433 38 13 VI VI NNP 13433 38 14 . . . 13433 39 1 THE the DT 13433 39 2 CHURCHES CHURCHES NNP 13433 39 3 OF of IN 13433 39 4 GAUL GAUL NNP 13433 39 5 VII VII NNP 13433 39 6 . . . 13433 40 1 TATIAN TATIAN NNP 13433 40 2 'S 's POS 13433 40 3 " " `` 13433 40 4 DIATESSARON DIATESSARON NNP 13433 40 5 " " '' 13433 40 6 VIII VIII NNP 13433 40 7 . . . 13433 41 1 CONCLUSIONS conclusion NNS 13433 41 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 41 3 ENDNOTES ENDNOTES NNP 13433 41 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 41 5 INDEX INDEX NNP 13433 41 6 . . . 13433 42 1 I. I. NNP 13433 43 1 _ _ NNP 13433 43 2 A a DT 13433 43 3 REPLY REPLY NNP 13433 43 4 TO to IN 13433 43 5 DR DR NNP 13433 43 6 . . . 13433 43 7 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 43 8 'S 's POS 13433 43 9 FIRST FIRST NNP 13433 43 10 ESSAY ESSAY NNP 13433 43 11 ON on IN 13433 43 12 " " `` 13433 43 13 SUPERNATURAL supernatural JJ 13433 43 14 RELIGION religion NN 13433 43 15 . . . 13433 44 1 " " `` 13433 44 2 _ _ NNP 13433 44 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 44 4 Endnote Endnote NNP 13433 44 5 1:1 1:1 CD 13433 44 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 44 7 The the DT 13433 44 8 function function NN 13433 44 9 of of IN 13433 44 10 the the DT 13433 44 11 critic critic NN 13433 44 12 , , , 13433 44 13 when when WRB 13433 44 14 rightly rightly RB 13433 44 15 exercised exercise VBN 13433 44 16 , , , 13433 44 17 is be VBZ 13433 44 18 so so RB 13433 44 19 important important JJ 13433 44 20 , , , 13433 44 21 that that IN 13433 44 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 44 23 is be VBZ 13433 44 24 fitting fitting JJ 13433 44 25 that that IN 13433 44 26 a a DT 13433 44 27 reviewer reviewer NN 13433 44 28 seriously seriously RB 13433 44 29 examining examine VBG 13433 44 30 serious serious JJ 13433 44 31 work work NN 13433 44 32 should should MD 13433 44 33 receive receive VB 13433 44 34 serious serious JJ 13433 44 35 and and CC 13433 44 36 respectful respectful JJ 13433 44 37 consideration consideration NN 13433 44 38 , , , 13433 44 39 however however RB 13433 44 40 severe severe JJ 13433 44 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 44 42 remarks remark NNS 13433 44 43 and and CC 13433 44 44 however however RB 13433 44 45 unpleasant unpleasant JJ 13433 44 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 44 47 strictures stricture NNS 13433 44 48 . . . 13433 45 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 45 2 is be VBZ 13433 45 3 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 45 4 possible possible JJ 13433 45 5 that that IN 13433 45 6 a a DT 13433 45 7 man man NN 13433 45 8 can can MD 13433 45 9 so so RB 13433 45 10 fully fully RB 13433 45 11 separate separate VB 13433 45 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 45 13 from from IN 13433 45 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 45 15 work work NN 13433 45 16 as as IN 13433 45 17 to to TO 13433 45 18 judge judge VB 13433 45 19 fairly fairly RB 13433 45 20 either either DT 13433 45 21 of of IN 13433 45 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 45 23 effect effect NN 13433 45 24 as as IN 13433 45 25 a a DT 13433 45 26 whole whole NN 13433 45 27 or or CC 13433 45 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 45 29 treatment treatment NN 13433 45 30 in in IN 13433 45 31 detail detail NN 13433 45 32 ; ; : 13433 45 33 and and CC 13433 45 34 in in IN 13433 45 35 every every DT 13433 45 36 undertaking undertaking NN 13433 45 37 of of IN 13433 45 38 any any DT 13433 45 39 magnitude magnitude NN 13433 45 40 it -PRON- PRP 13433 45 41 is be VBZ 13433 45 42 almost almost RB 13433 45 43 certain certain JJ 13433 45 44 that that IN 13433 45 45 flaws flaw NNS 13433 45 46 and and CC 13433 45 47 mistakes mistake NNS 13433 45 48 must must MD 13433 45 49 occur occur VB 13433 45 50 , , , 13433 45 51 which which WDT 13433 45 52 can can MD 13433 45 53 best best RB 13433 45 54 be be VB 13433 45 55 detected detect VBN 13433 45 56 by by IN 13433 45 57 those those DT 13433 45 58 whose whose WP$ 13433 45 59 perception perception NN 13433 45 60 has have VBZ 13433 45 61 not not RB 13433 45 62 been be VBN 13433 45 63 dulled dull VBN 13433 45 64 by by IN 13433 45 65 continuous continuous JJ 13433 45 66 and and CC 13433 45 67 over over RB 13433 45 68 - - HYPH 13433 45 69 strained strained JJ 13433 45 70 application application NN 13433 45 71 . . . 13433 46 1 No no DT 13433 46 2 honest honest JJ 13433 46 3 writer writer NN 13433 46 4 , , , 13433 46 5 however however RB 13433 46 6 much much RB 13433 46 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 46 8 may may MD 13433 46 9 wince wince VB 13433 46 10 , , , 13433 46 11 can can MD 13433 46 12 feel feel VB 13433 46 13 otherwise otherwise RB 13433 46 14 than than IN 13433 46 15 thankful thankful JJ 13433 46 16 to to IN 13433 46 17 anyone anyone NN 13433 46 18 who who WP 13433 46 19 points point VBZ 13433 46 20 out out RP 13433 46 21 errors error NNS 13433 46 22 or or CC 13433 46 23 mistakes mistake NNS 13433 46 24 which which WDT 13433 46 25 can can MD 13433 46 26 be be VB 13433 46 27 rectified rectified JJ 13433 46 28 ; ; : 13433 46 29 and and CC 13433 46 30 , , , 13433 46 31 for for IN 13433 46 32 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 46 33 , , , 13433 46 34 I -PRON- PRP 13433 46 35 may may MD 13433 46 36 say say VB 13433 46 37 that that IN 13433 46 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 46 39 desire desire VBP 13433 46 40 nothing nothing NN 13433 46 41 more more JJR 13433 46 42 than than IN 13433 46 43 such such JJ 13433 46 44 frankness frankness NN 13433 46 45 , , , 13433 46 46 and and CC 13433 46 47 the the DT 13433 46 48 fair fair JJ 13433 46 49 refutation refutation NN 13433 46 50 of of IN 13433 46 51 any any DT 13433 46 52 arguments argument NNS 13433 46 53 which which WDT 13433 46 54 may may MD 13433 46 55 be be VB 13433 46 56 fallacious fallacious JJ 13433 46 57 . . . 13433 47 1 Reluctant reluctant JJ 13433 47 2 as as IN 13433 47 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 47 4 must must MD 13433 47 5 ever ever RB 13433 47 6 be be VB 13433 47 7 , , , 13433 47 8 therefore therefore RB 13433 47 9 , , , 13433 47 10 to to TO 13433 47 11 depart depart VB 13433 47 12 from from IN 13433 47 13 the the DT 13433 47 14 attitude attitude NN 13433 47 15 of of IN 13433 47 16 silent silent JJ 13433 47 17 attention attention NN 13433 47 18 which which WDT 13433 47 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 47 20 think think VBP 13433 47 21 should should MD 13433 47 22 be be VB 13433 47 23 maintained maintain VBN 13433 47 24 by by IN 13433 47 25 writers writer NNS 13433 47 26 in in IN 13433 47 27 the the DT 13433 47 28 face face NN 13433 47 29 of of IN 13433 47 30 criticism criticism NN 13433 47 31 , , , 13433 47 32 or or CC 13433 47 33 to to TO 13433 47 34 interrupt interrupt VB 13433 47 35 the the DT 13433 47 36 fair fair JJ 13433 47 37 reply reply NN 13433 47 38 of of IN 13433 47 39 an an DT 13433 47 40 opponent opponent NN 13433 47 41 , , , 13433 47 42 the the DT 13433 47 43 case case NN 13433 47 44 is be VBZ 13433 47 45 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 47 46 different different JJ 13433 47 47 when when WRB 13433 47 48 criticism criticism NN 13433 47 49 assumes assume VBZ 13433 47 50 the the DT 13433 47 51 vicious vicious JJ 13433 47 52 tone tone NN 13433 47 53 of of IN 13433 47 54 the the DT 13433 47 55 Rev. Rev. NNP 13433 48 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 48 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 48 3 's 's POS 13433 48 4 article article NN 13433 48 5 upon upon IN 13433 48 6 _ _ NNP 13433 48 7 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 48 8 Religion Religion NNP 13433 48 9 _ _ NNP 13433 48 10 in in IN 13433 48 11 the the DT 13433 48 12 December December NNP 13433 48 13 number number NN 13433 48 14 of of IN 13433 48 15 the the DT 13433 48 16 " " `` 13433 48 17 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 48 18 Review Review NNP 13433 48 19 . . . 13433 48 20 " " '' 13433 49 1 Whilst whilst IN 13433 49 2 delivering deliver VBG 13433 49 3 severe severe JJ 13433 49 4 lectures lecture NNS 13433 49 5 upon upon IN 13433 49 6 want want NN 13433 49 7 of of IN 13433 49 8 candour candour NN 13433 49 9 and and CC 13433 49 10 impartiality impartiality NN 13433 49 11 , , , 13433 49 12 and and CC 13433 49 13 preaching preach VBG 13433 49 14 temperance temperance NN 13433 49 15 and and CC 13433 49 16 moderation moderation NN 13433 49 17 , , , 13433 49 18 the the DT 13433 49 19 practice practice NN 13433 49 20 of of IN 13433 49 21 the the DT 13433 49 22 preacher preacher NN 13433 49 23 , , , 13433 49 24 as as IN 13433 49 25 sometimes sometimes RB 13433 49 26 happens happen VBZ 13433 49 27 , , , 13433 49 28 falls fall VBZ 13433 49 29 very very RB 13433 49 30 short short JJ 13433 49 31 of of IN 13433 49 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 49 33 precept precept NN 13433 49 34 . . . 13433 50 1 The the DT 13433 50 2 example example NN 13433 50 3 of of IN 13433 50 4 moderation moderation NN 13433 50 5 presented present VBN 13433 50 6 to to IN 13433 50 7 me -PRON- PRP 13433 50 8 by by IN 13433 50 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 50 10 clerical clerical JJ 13433 50 11 critic critic NN 13433 50 12 does do VBZ 13433 50 13 not not RB 13433 50 14 seem seem VB 13433 50 15 to to IN 13433 50 16 me -PRON- PRP 13433 50 17 very very RB 13433 50 18 edifying edifying NN 13433 50 19 , , , 13433 50 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 50 21 impartiality impartiality NN 13433 50 22 does do VBZ 13433 50 23 not not RB 13433 50 24 appear appear VB 13433 50 25 to to TO 13433 50 26 be be VB 13433 50 27 beyond beyond IN 13433 50 28 reproach reproach NN 13433 50 29 , , , 13433 50 30 and and CC 13433 50 31 in in IN 13433 50 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 50 33 tone tone NN 13433 50 34 I -PRON- PRP 13433 50 35 fail fail VBP 13433 50 36 to to TO 13433 50 37 recognise recognise VB 13433 50 38 any any DT 13433 50 39 of of IN 13433 50 40 the the DT 13433 50 41 [ [ -LRB- 13433 50 42 Greek Greek NNP 13433 50 43 : : : 13433 50 44 epieikeia epieikeia NNP 13433 50 45 ] ] -RRB- 13433 50 46 which which WDT 13433 50 47 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 50 48 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 50 49 Arnold Arnold NNP 13433 50 50 so so RB 13433 50 51 justly justly RB 13433 50 52 admires admire VBZ 13433 50 53 . . . 13433 51 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 2 shall shall MD 13433 51 3 not not RB 13433 51 4 emulate emulate VB 13433 51 5 the the DT 13433 51 6 spirit spirit NN 13433 51 7 of of IN 13433 51 8 that that DT 13433 51 9 article article NN 13433 51 10 , , , 13433 51 11 and and CC 13433 51 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 13 trust trust VBP 13433 51 14 that that IN 13433 51 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 16 shall shall MD 13433 51 17 not not RB 13433 51 18 scant scant VB 13433 51 19 the the DT 13433 51 20 courtesy courtesy NN 13433 51 21 with with IN 13433 51 22 which which WDT 13433 51 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 24 desire desire VBP 13433 51 25 to to TO 13433 51 26 treat treat VB 13433 51 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 51 28 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 51 29 , , , 13433 51 30 whose whose WP$ 13433 51 31 ability ability NN 13433 51 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 33 admire admire VBP 13433 51 34 and and CC 13433 51 35 whose whose WP$ 13433 51 36 position position NN 13433 51 37 I -PRON- PRP 13433 51 38 understand understand VBP 13433 51 39 . . . 13433 52 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 52 2 should should MD 13433 52 3 not not RB 13433 52 4 , , , 13433 52 5 indeed indeed RB 13433 52 6 , , , 13433 52 7 consider consider VB 13433 52 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 52 9 necessary necessary JJ 13433 52 10 at at IN 13433 52 11 present present JJ 13433 52 12 to to TO 13433 52 13 notice notice VB 13433 52 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 52 15 attack attack NN 13433 52 16 at at RB 13433 52 17 all all RB 13433 52 18 , , , 13433 52 19 but but CC 13433 52 20 that that IN 13433 52 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 52 22 perceive perceive VBP 13433 52 23 the the DT 13433 52 24 attempt attempt NN 13433 52 25 to to TO 13433 52 26 prejudice prejudice VB 13433 52 27 an an DT 13433 52 28 audience audience NN 13433 52 29 and and CC 13433 52 30 divert divert VB 13433 52 31 attention attention NN 13433 52 32 from from IN 13433 52 33 the the DT 13433 52 34 issues issue NNS 13433 52 35 of of IN 13433 52 36 a a DT 13433 52 37 serious serious JJ 13433 52 38 argument argument NN 13433 52 39 by by IN 13433 52 40 general general JJ 13433 52 41 detraction detraction NN 13433 52 42 . . . 13433 53 1 The the DT 13433 53 2 device device NN 13433 53 3 is be VBZ 13433 53 4 far far RB 13433 53 5 from from IN 13433 53 6 new new JJ 13433 53 7 , , , 13433 53 8 and and CC 13433 53 9 the the DT 13433 53 10 tactics tactic NNS 13433 53 11 can can MD 13433 53 12 not not RB 13433 53 13 be be VB 13433 53 14 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 53 15 original original JJ 13433 53 16 . . . 13433 54 1 In in IN 13433 54 2 religious religious JJ 13433 54 3 as as RB 13433 54 4 well well RB 13433 54 5 as as IN 13433 54 6 legal legal JJ 13433 54 7 controversy controversy NN 13433 54 8 , , , 13433 54 9 the the DT 13433 54 10 threadbare threadbare NN 13433 54 11 maxim maxim NN 13433 54 12 : : : 13433 54 13 " " `` 13433 54 14 A a DT 13433 54 15 bad bad JJ 13433 54 16 case case NN 13433 54 17 -- -- : 13433 54 18 abuse abuse VB 13433 54 19 the the DT 13433 54 20 plaintiff plaintiff NN 13433 54 21 's 's POS 13433 54 22 attorney attorney NN 13433 54 23 , , , 13433 54 24 " " `` 13433 54 25 remains remain VBZ 13433 54 26 in in IN 13433 54 27 force force NN 13433 54 28 ; ; : 13433 54 29 and and CC 13433 54 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 54 31 is be VBZ 13433 54 32 surprising surprising JJ 13433 54 33 how how WRB 13433 54 34 effectual effectual JJ 13433 54 35 the the DT 13433 54 36 simple simple JJ 13433 54 37 practice practice NN 13433 54 38 still still RB 13433 54 39 is be VBZ 13433 54 40 . . . 13433 55 1 If if IN 13433 55 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 55 3 were be VBD 13433 55 4 granted grant VBN 13433 55 5 , , , 13433 55 6 for for IN 13433 55 7 the the DT 13433 55 8 sake sake NN 13433 55 9 of of IN 13433 55 10 argument argument NN 13433 55 11 , , , 13433 55 12 that that IN 13433 55 13 each each DT 13433 55 14 slip slip NN 13433 55 15 in in IN 13433 55 16 translation translation NN 13433 55 17 , , , 13433 55 18 each each DT 13433 55 19 error error NN 13433 55 20 in in IN 13433 55 21 detail detail NN 13433 55 22 and and CC 13433 55 23 each each DT 13433 55 24 oversight oversight NN 13433 55 25 in in IN 13433 55 26 statement statement NN 13433 55 27 , , , 13433 55 28 with with IN 13433 55 29 which which WDT 13433 55 30 Canon Canon NNP 13433 55 31 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 55 32 reproaches reproach VBZ 13433 55 33 _ _ NNP 13433 55 34 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 55 35 Religion Religion NNP 13433 55 36 _ _ NNP 13433 55 37 were be VBD 13433 55 38 well well RB 13433 55 39 founded found VBN 13433 55 40 , , , 13433 55 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 55 42 must must MD 13433 55 43 be be VB 13433 55 44 evident evident JJ 13433 55 45 to to IN 13433 55 46 any any DT 13433 55 47 intelligent intelligent JJ 13433 55 48 mind mind NN 13433 55 49 that that IN 13433 55 50 the the DT 13433 55 51 mass mass NN 13433 55 52 of of IN 13433 55 53 such such PDT 13433 55 54 a a DT 13433 55 55 work work NN 13433 55 56 would would MD 13433 55 57 not not RB 13433 55 58 really really RB 13433 55 59 be be VB 13433 55 60 affected affect VBN 13433 55 61 ; ; : 13433 55 62 such such JJ 13433 55 63 flaws flaw NNS 13433 55 64 -- -- : 13433 55 65 and and CC 13433 55 66 what what WP 13433 55 67 book book NN 13433 55 68 of of IN 13433 55 69 the the DT 13433 55 70 kind kind NN 13433 55 71 escapes escape VBZ 13433 55 72 them -PRON- PRP 13433 55 73 -- -- : 13433 55 74 which which WDT 13433 55 75 can can MD 13433 55 76 most most RBS 13433 55 77 easily easily RB 13433 55 78 be be VB 13433 55 79 removed remove VBN 13433 55 80 , , , 13433 55 81 would would MD 13433 55 82 not not RB 13433 55 83 weaken weaken VB 13433 55 84 the the DT 13433 55 85 central central JJ 13433 55 86 argument argument NN 13433 55 87 , , , 13433 55 88 and and CC 13433 55 89 after after IN 13433 55 90 the the DT 13433 55 91 Apologist Apologist NNP 13433 55 92 's 's POS 13433 55 93 ingenuity ingenuity NN 13433 55 94 has have VBZ 13433 55 95 been be VBN 13433 55 96 exerted exert VBN 13433 55 97 to to IN 13433 55 98 the the DT 13433 55 99 utmost utmost NN 13433 55 100 to to TO 13433 55 101 blacken blacken VB 13433 55 102 every every DT 13433 55 103 blot blot NN 13433 55 104 , , , 13433 55 105 the the DT 13433 55 106 basis basis NN 13433 55 107 of of IN 13433 55 108 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 55 109 Religion Religion NNP 13433 55 110 would would MD 13433 55 111 not not RB 13433 55 112 be be VB 13433 55 113 made make VBN 13433 55 114 one one CD 13433 55 115 whit whit NN 13433 55 116 more more RBR 13433 55 117 secure secure JJ 13433 55 118 . . . 13433 56 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 56 2 is be VBZ 13433 56 3 , , , 13433 56 4 however however RB 13433 56 5 , , , 13433 56 6 because because IN 13433 56 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 56 8 recognise recognise VBP 13433 56 9 that that IN 13433 56 10 , , , 13433 56 11 behind behind IN 13433 56 12 this this DT 13433 56 13 skirmishing skirmishing NN 13433 56 14 attack attack NN 13433 56 15 , , , 13433 56 16 there there EX 13433 56 17 is be VBZ 13433 56 18 the the DT 13433 56 19 constant constant JJ 13433 56 20 insinuation insinuation NN 13433 56 21 that that IN 13433 56 22 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 56 23 have have VBP 13433 56 24 been be VBN 13433 56 25 detected detect VBN 13433 56 26 which which WDT 13433 56 27 have have VBP 13433 56 28 " " `` 13433 56 29 a a DT 13433 56 30 vital vital JJ 13433 56 31 bearing bearing NN 13433 56 32 " " '' 13433 56 33 upon upon IN 13433 56 34 the the DT 13433 56 35 question question NN 13433 56 36 at at IN 13433 56 37 issue issue NN 13433 56 38 , , , 13433 56 39 arguments argument NNS 13433 56 40 " " `` 13433 56 41 wrecked wreck VBD 13433 56 42 " " '' 13433 56 43 which which WDT 13433 56 44 are be VBP 13433 56 45 of of IN 13433 56 46 serious serious JJ 13433 56 47 importance importance NN 13433 56 48 , , , 13433 56 49 and and CC 13433 56 50 omissions omission NNS 13433 56 51 indicated indicate VBD 13433 56 52 which which WDT 13433 56 53 change change VBP 13433 56 54 the the DT 13433 56 55 aspect aspect NN 13433 56 56 of of IN 13433 56 57 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 56 58 , , , 13433 56 59 that that IN 13433 56 60 I -PRON- PRP 13433 56 61 have have VBP 13433 56 62 thought think VBN 13433 56 63 it -PRON- PRP 13433 56 64 worth worth JJ 13433 56 65 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 56 66 while while NN 13433 56 67 at at IN 13433 56 68 once once RB 13433 56 69 to to TO 13433 56 70 reply reply VB 13433 56 71 . . . 13433 57 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 57 2 shall shall MD 13433 57 3 endeavour endeavour VB 13433 57 4 briefly briefly RB 13433 57 5 to to TO 13433 57 6 show show VB 13433 57 7 that that IN 13433 57 8 , , , 13433 57 9 in in IN 13433 57 10 thus thus RB 13433 57 11 attempting attempt VBG 13433 57 12 to to TO 13433 57 13 sap sap VB 13433 57 14 the the DT 13433 57 15 strength strength NN 13433 57 16 of of IN 13433 57 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 57 18 position position NN 13433 57 19 , , , 13433 57 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 57 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 57 22 has have VBZ 13433 57 23 only only RB 13433 57 24 exposed expose VBN 13433 57 25 the the DT 13433 57 26 weakness weakness NN 13433 57 27 of of IN 13433 57 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 57 29 own own JJ 13433 57 30 . . . 13433 58 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 58 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 58 3 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 58 4 scornfully scornfully RB 13433 58 5 says say VBZ 13433 58 6 that that IN 13433 58 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 58 8 has have VBZ 13433 58 9 the the DT 13433 58 10 " " `` 13433 58 11 misfortune misfortune NN 13433 58 12 " " '' 13433 58 13 " " '' 13433 58 14 to to TO 13433 58 15 dispute dispute VB 13433 58 16 not not RB 13433 58 17 a a DT 13433 58 18 few few JJ 13433 58 19 propositions proposition NNS 13433 58 20 which which WDT 13433 58 21 ' ' `` 13433 58 22 most most JJS 13433 58 23 critics critic NNS 13433 58 24 ' ' POS 13433 58 25 are be VBP 13433 58 26 agreed agree VBN 13433 58 27 in in IN 13433 58 28 maintaining maintain VBG 13433 58 29 . . . 13433 58 30 " " '' 13433 59 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 59 2 will will MD 13433 59 3 probably probably RB 13433 59 4 find find VB 13433 59 5 that that IN 13433 59 6 " " `` 13433 59 7 most most JJS 13433 59 8 critics critic NNS 13433 59 9 , , , 13433 59 10 " " '' 13433 59 11 for for IN 13433 59 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 59 13 part part NN 13433 59 14 , , , 13433 59 15 will will MD 13433 59 16 not not RB 13433 59 17 consider consider VB 13433 59 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 59 19 a a DT 13433 59 20 very very RB 13433 59 21 great great JJ 13433 59 22 misfortune misfortune NN 13433 59 23 to to TO 13433 59 24 differ differ VB 13433 59 25 from from IN 13433 59 26 a a DT 13433 59 27 divine divine NN 13433 59 28 who who WP 13433 59 29 has have VBZ 13433 59 30 the the DT 13433 59 31 misfortune misfortune NN 13433 59 32 of of IN 13433 59 33 differing differ VBG 13433 59 34 on on IN 13433 59 35 so so RB 13433 59 36 many many JJ 13433 59 37 points point NNS 13433 59 38 , , , 13433 59 39 from from IN 13433 59 40 most most JJS 13433 59 41 critics critic NNS 13433 59 42 . . . 13433 60 1 The the DT 13433 60 2 first first JJ 13433 60 3 and and CC 13433 60 4 most most RBS 13433 60 5 vehement vehement JJ 13433 60 6 attack attack NN 13433 60 7 made make VBN 13433 60 8 upon upon IN 13433 60 9 me -PRON- PRP 13433 60 10 by by IN 13433 60 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 60 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 60 13 is be VBZ 13433 60 14 regarding regard VBG 13433 60 15 " " `` 13433 60 16 a a DT 13433 60 17 highly highly RB 13433 60 18 important important JJ 13433 60 19 passage passage NN 13433 60 20 of of IN 13433 60 21 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 60 22 , , , 13433 60 23 " " '' 13433 60 24 containing contain VBG 13433 60 25 a a DT 13433 60 26 reference reference NN 13433 60 27 to to IN 13433 60 28 some some DT 13433 60 29 other other JJ 13433 60 30 and and CC 13433 60 31 unnamed unnamed JJ 13433 60 32 authority authority NN 13433 60 33 , , , 13433 60 34 in in IN 13433 60 35 which which WDT 13433 60 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 60 37 considers consider VBZ 13433 60 38 that that IN 13433 60 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 60 40 am be VBP 13433 60 41 " " `` 13433 60 42 quite quite RB 13433 60 43 unconscious unconscious JJ 13433 60 44 of of IN 13433 60 45 the the DT 13433 60 46 distinction distinction NN 13433 60 47 between between IN 13433 60 48 the the DT 13433 60 49 infinitive infinitive JJ 13433 60 50 and and CC 13433 60 51 indicative indicative JJ 13433 60 52 ; ; : 13433 60 53 " " `` 13433 60 54 a a DT 13433 60 55 point point NN 13433 60 56 upon upon IN 13433 60 57 which which WDT 13433 60 58 " " `` 13433 60 59 any any DT 13433 60 60 fairly fairly RB 13433 60 61 trained train VBN 13433 60 62 schoolboy schoolboy NN 13433 60 63 " " '' 13433 60 64 would would MD 13433 60 65 decide decide VB 13433 60 66 against against IN 13433 60 67 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 60 68 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 60 69 . . . 13433 61 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 61 2 had have VBD 13433 61 3 found find VBN 13433 61 4 fault fault NN 13433 61 5 with with IN 13433 61 6 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 61 7 in in IN 13433 61 8 the the DT 13433 61 9 text text NN 13433 61 10 , , , 13433 61 11 and and CC 13433 61 12 with with IN 13433 61 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 61 14 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 61 15 in in IN 13433 61 16 a a DT 13433 61 17 note note NN 13433 61 18 , , , 13433 61 19 for for IN 13433 61 20 inserting insert VBG 13433 61 21 the the DT 13433 61 22 words word NNS 13433 61 23 " " `` 13433 61 24 say say VBP 13433 61 25 they -PRON- PRP 13433 61 26 , , , 13433 61 27 " " '' 13433 61 28 and and CC 13433 61 29 " " `` 13433 61 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 61 31 taught teach VBD 13433 61 32 , , , 13433 61 33 " " '' 13433 61 34 in in IN 13433 61 35 rendering render VBG 13433 61 36 the the DT 13433 61 37 oblique oblique JJ 13433 61 38 construction construction NN 13433 61 39 of of IN 13433 61 40 a a DT 13433 61 41 passage passage NN 13433 61 42 whose whose WP$ 13433 61 43 source source NN 13433 61 44 is be VBZ 13433 61 45 in in IN 13433 61 46 dispute dispute NN 13433 61 47 , , , 13433 61 48 without without IN 13433 61 49 some some DT 13433 61 50 mark mark NN 13433 61 51 or or CC 13433 61 52 explanation explanation NN 13433 61 53 , , , 13433 61 54 in in IN 13433 61 55 the the DT 13433 61 56 total total JJ 13433 61 57 absence absence NN 13433 61 58 of of IN 13433 61 59 the the DT 13433 61 60 original original JJ 13433 61 61 , , , 13433 61 62 that that IN 13433 61 63 these these DT 13433 61 64 special special JJ 13433 61 65 words word NNS 13433 61 66 were be VBD 13433 61 67 supplementary supplementary JJ 13433 61 68 and and CC 13433 61 69 introduced introduce VBN 13433 61 70 by by IN 13433 61 71 the the DT 13433 61 72 translator translator NN 13433 61 73 . . . 13433 62 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 62 2 shall shall MD 13433 62 3 speak speak VB 13433 62 4 of of IN 13433 62 5 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 62 6 presently presently RB 13433 62 7 , , , 13433 62 8 and and CC 13433 62 9 for for IN 13433 62 10 the the DT 13433 62 11 moment moment NN 13433 62 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 62 13 confine confine VBP 13433 62 14 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 62 15 to to IN 13433 62 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 62 17 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 62 18 . . . 13433 63 1 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 63 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 63 3 _ _ NNP 13433 63 4 Adv Adv NNP 13433 63 5 . . . 13433 64 1 Haer Haer NNP 13433 64 2 . . . 13433 64 3 _ _ NNP 13433 64 4 v. v. IN 13433 64 5 36 36 CD 13433 64 6 , , , 13433 64 7 1 1 CD 13433 64 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 64 9 makes make VBZ 13433 64 10 a a DT 13433 64 11 statement statement NN 13433 64 12 as as IN 13433 64 13 to to IN 13433 64 14 what what WP 13433 64 15 " " `` 13433 64 16 the the DT 13433 64 17 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 64 18 say say VBP 13433 64 19 " " `` 13433 64 20 regarding regard VBG 13433 64 21 the the DT 13433 64 22 joys joy NNS 13433 64 23 of of IN 13433 64 24 the the DT 13433 64 25 Millennial Millennial NNP 13433 64 26 kingdom kingdom NN 13433 64 27 , , , 13433 64 28 and and CC 13433 64 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 64 30 then then RB 13433 64 31 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 64 32 ( ( -LRB- 13433 64 33 § § CD 13433 64 34 2 2 CD 13433 64 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 64 36 with with IN 13433 64 37 indirect indirect JJ 13433 64 38 construction construction NN 13433 64 39 , , , 13433 64 40 indicating indicate VBG 13433 64 41 a a DT 13433 64 42 reference reference NN 13433 64 43 to to IN 13433 64 44 some some DT 13433 64 45 other other JJ 13433 64 46 authority authority NN 13433 64 47 than than IN 13433 64 48 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 64 49 , , , 13433 64 50 to to IN 13433 64 51 the the DT 13433 64 52 passage passage NN 13433 64 53 in in IN 13433 64 54 question question NN 13433 64 55 , , , 13433 64 56 in in IN 13433 64 57 which which WDT 13433 64 58 a a DT 13433 64 59 saying say VBG 13433 64 60 similar similar JJ 13433 64 61 to to IN 13433 64 62 John John NNP 13433 64 63 xiv xiv NNP 13433 64 64 . . . 13433 65 1 2 2 CD 13433 65 2 is be VBZ 13433 65 3 introduced introduce VBN 13433 65 4 . . . 13433 66 1 This this DT 13433 66 2 passage passage NN 13433 66 3 is be VBZ 13433 66 4 claimed claim VBN 13433 66 5 by by IN 13433 66 6 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 66 7 as as IN 13433 66 8 a a DT 13433 66 9 quotation quotation NN 13433 66 10 from from IN 13433 66 11 the the DT 13433 66 12 work work NN 13433 66 13 of of IN 13433 66 14 Papias Papias NNP 13433 66 15 , , , 13433 66 16 and and CC 13433 66 17 is be VBZ 13433 66 18 advanced advanced JJ 13433 66 19 in in IN 13433 66 20 discussing discuss VBG 13433 66 21 the the DT 13433 66 22 evidence evidence NN 13433 66 23 of of IN 13433 66 24 the the DT 13433 66 25 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 66 26 of of IN 13433 66 27 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 13433 66 28 . . . 13433 67 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 67 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 67 3 , , , 13433 67 4 without without IN 13433 67 5 any any DT 13433 67 6 explanation explanation NN 13433 67 7 , , , 13433 67 8 states state NNS 13433 67 9 in in IN 13433 67 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 67 11 text text NN 13433 67 12 : : : 13433 67 13 " " `` 13433 67 14 In in IN 13433 67 15 addition addition NN 13433 67 16 to to IN 13433 67 17 the the DT 13433 67 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 67 19 of of IN 13433 67 20 St. St. NNP 13433 67 21 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 67 22 and and CC 13433 67 23 St. St. NNP 13433 67 24 Mark Mark NNP 13433 67 25 , , , 13433 67 26 Papias Papias NNP 13433 67 27 appears appear VBZ 13433 67 28 to to TO 13433 67 29 have have VB 13433 67 30 been be VBN 13433 67 31 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 67 32 with with IN 13433 67 33 the the DT 13433 67 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 67 35 of of IN 13433 67 36 St. St. NNP 13433 67 37 John John NNP 13433 67 38 ; ; : 13433 67 39 " " `` 13433 67 40 [ [ -LRB- 13433 67 41 4:1 4:1 CD 13433 67 42 ] ] -RRB- 13433 67 43 and and CC 13433 67 44 in in IN 13433 67 45 a a DT 13433 67 46 note note NN 13433 67 47 on on IN 13433 67 48 an an DT 13433 67 49 earlier early JJR 13433 67 50 page page NN 13433 67 51 : : : 13433 67 52 " " `` 13433 67 53 The the DT 13433 67 54 passage passage NN 13433 67 55 quoted quote VBN 13433 67 56 by by IN 13433 67 57 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 67 58 from from IN 13433 67 59 ' ' '' 13433 67 60 the the DT 13433 67 61 Elders Elders NNPS 13433 67 62 ' ' POS 13433 67 63 may may MD 13433 67 64 probably probably RB 13433 67 65 be be VB 13433 67 66 taken take VBN 13433 67 67 as as IN 13433 67 68 a a DT 13433 67 69 specimen speciman NNS 13433 67 70 of of IN 13433 67 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 67 72 style style NN 13433 67 73 of of IN 13433 67 74 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 67 75 ; ; : 13433 67 76 " " '' 13433 67 77 [ [ -LRB- 13433 67 78 4:2 4:2 CD 13433 67 79 ] ] -RRB- 13433 67 80 and and CC 13433 67 81 then then RB 13433 67 82 follows follow VBZ 13433 67 83 the the DT 13433 67 84 passage passage NN 13433 67 85 in in IN 13433 67 86 which which WDT 13433 67 87 the the DT 13433 67 88 indirect indirect JJ 13433 67 89 construction construction NN 13433 67 90 receives receive VBZ 13433 67 91 a a DT 13433 67 92 specific specific JJ 13433 67 93 direction direction NN 13433 67 94 by by IN 13433 67 95 the the DT 13433 67 96 insertion insertion NN 13433 67 97 of of IN 13433 67 98 " " `` 13433 67 99 they -PRON- PRP 13433 67 100 taught teach VBD 13433 67 101 . . . 13433 67 102 " " '' 13433 68 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 68 2 4:3 4:3 LS 13433 68 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 68 4 Neither neither CC 13433 68 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 68 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 68 7 nor nor CC 13433 68 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 68 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 68 10 makes make VBZ 13433 68 11 the the DT 13433 68 12 slightest slight JJS 13433 68 13 allusion allusion NN 13433 68 14 to to IN 13433 68 15 the the DT 13433 68 16 fact fact NN 13433 68 17 that that IN 13433 68 18 they -PRON- PRP 13433 68 19 are be VBP 13433 68 20 almost almost RB 13433 68 21 alone alone JJ 13433 68 22 in in IN 13433 68 23 advancing advance VBG 13433 68 24 this this DT 13433 68 25 testimony testimony NN 13433 68 26 , , , 13433 68 27 which which WDT 13433 68 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 68 29 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 68 30 describes describe VBZ 13433 68 31 as as IN 13433 68 32 having have VBG 13433 68 33 " " `` 13433 68 34 a a DT 13433 68 35 vital vital JJ 13433 68 36 bearing bearing NN 13433 68 37 on on IN 13433 68 38 the the DT 13433 68 39 main main JJ 13433 68 40 question question NN 13433 68 41 at at IN 13433 68 42 issue issue NN 13433 68 43 , , , 13433 68 44 the the DT 13433 68 45 date date NN 13433 68 46 of of IN 13433 68 47 the the DT 13433 68 48 fourth fourth JJ 13433 68 49 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 68 50 . . . 13433 68 51 " " '' 13433 69 1 The the DT 13433 69 2 reader reader NN 13433 69 3 who who WP 13433 69 4 had have VBD 13433 69 5 not not RB 13433 69 6 the the DT 13433 69 7 work work NN 13433 69 8 of of IN 13433 69 9 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 69 10 before before IN 13433 69 11 him -PRON- PRP 13433 69 12 to to TO 13433 69 13 estimate estimate VB 13433 69 14 the the DT 13433 69 15 justness justness NN 13433 69 16 of of IN 13433 69 17 the the DT 13433 69 18 ascription ascription NN 13433 69 19 of of IN 13433 69 20 this this DT 13433 69 21 passage passage NN 13433 69 22 to to IN 13433 69 23 Papias Papias NNP 13433 69 24 , , , 13433 69 25 and and CC 13433 69 26 who who WP 13433 69 27 was be VBD 13433 69 28 not not RB 13433 69 29 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 69 30 with with IN 13433 69 31 all all PDT 13433 69 32 the the DT 13433 69 33 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 69 34 , , , 13433 69 35 and and CC 13433 69 36 with with IN 13433 69 37 the the DT 13433 69 38 state state NN 13433 69 39 of of IN 13433 69 40 critical critical JJ 13433 69 41 opinion opinion NN 13433 69 42 on on IN 13433 69 43 the the DT 13433 69 44 point point NN 13433 69 45 , , , 13433 69 46 could could MD 13433 69 47 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 69 48 , , , 13433 69 49 on on IN 13433 69 50 reading read VBG 13433 69 51 such such JJ 13433 69 52 statements statement NNS 13433 69 53 , , , 13433 69 54 understand understand VB 13433 69 55 the the DT 13433 69 56 real real JJ 13433 69 57 position position NN 13433 69 58 of of IN 13433 69 59 the the DT 13433 69 60 case case NN 13433 69 61 . . . 13433 70 1 Now now RB 13433 70 2 the the DT 13433 70 3 facts fact NNS 13433 70 4 are be VBP 13433 70 5 as as IN 13433 70 6 follows follow VBZ 13433 70 7 : : : 13433 70 8 Routh Routh NNP 13433 70 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 70 10 4:4 4:4 CD 13433 70 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 70 12 conjectured conjecture VBN 13433 70 13 that that IN 13433 70 14 the the DT 13433 70 15 whole whole JJ 13433 70 16 passage passage NN 13433 70 17 in in IN 13433 70 18 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 70 19 was be VBD 13433 70 20 derived derive VBN 13433 70 21 from from IN 13433 70 22 the the DT 13433 70 23 work work NN 13433 70 24 of of IN 13433 70 25 Papias Papias NNP 13433 70 26 , , , 13433 70 27 and and CC 13433 70 28 in in IN 13433 70 29 this this DT 13433 70 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 70 31 was be VBD 13433 70 32 followed follow VBN 13433 70 33 by by IN 13433 70 34 Dorner Dorner NNP 13433 70 35 , , , 13433 70 36 [ [ -LRB- 13433 70 37 4:5 4:5 CD 13433 70 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 70 39 who who WP 13433 70 40 practically practically RB 13433 70 41 introduced introduce VBD 13433 70 42 the the DT 13433 70 43 suggestion suggestion NN 13433 70 44 to to IN 13433 70 45 the the DT 13433 70 46 critics critic NNS 13433 70 47 of of IN 13433 70 48 Germany Germany NNP 13433 70 49 , , , 13433 70 50 with with IN 13433 70 51 whom whom WP 13433 70 52 it -PRON- PRP 13433 70 53 found find VBD 13433 70 54 no no DT 13433 70 55 favour favour NN 13433 70 56 , , , 13433 70 57 and and CC 13433 70 58 no no DT 13433 70 59 one one NN 13433 70 60 whom whom WP 13433 70 61 I -PRON- PRP 13433 70 62 remember remember VBP 13433 70 63 , , , 13433 70 64 except except IN 13433 70 65 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 70 66 and and CC 13433 70 67 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 70 68 Professor Professor NNP 13433 70 69 Hofstede Hofstede NNP 13433 70 70 de de NNP 13433 70 71 Groot Groot NNP 13433 70 72 , , , 13433 70 73 now now RB 13433 70 74 seriously seriously RB 13433 70 75 supports support VBZ 13433 70 76 this this DT 13433 70 77 view view NN 13433 70 78 . . . 13433 71 1 Zeller Zeller NNP 13433 71 2 , , , 13433 71 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 71 4 5:1 5:1 CD 13433 71 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 71 6 in in IN 13433 71 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 71 8 celebrated celebrated JJ 13433 71 9 treatise treatise NN 13433 71 10 on on IN 13433 71 11 the the DT 13433 71 12 external external JJ 13433 71 13 testimony testimony NN 13433 71 14 for for IN 13433 71 15 the the DT 13433 71 16 fourth fourth JJ 13433 71 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 71 18 , , , 13433 71 19 argued argue VBD 13433 71 20 against against IN 13433 71 21 Dorner Dorner NNP 13433 71 22 that that IN 13433 71 23 , , , 13433 71 24 in in IN 13433 71 25 spite spite NN 13433 71 26 of of IN 13433 71 27 the the DT 13433 71 28 indirect indirect JJ 13433 71 29 construction construction NN 13433 71 30 of of IN 13433 71 31 the the DT 13433 71 32 passage passage NN 13433 71 33 , , , 13433 71 34 there there EX 13433 71 35 is be VBZ 13433 71 36 not not RB 13433 71 37 the the DT 13433 71 38 slightest slight JJS 13433 71 39 certainty certainty NN 13433 71 40 that that IN 13433 71 41 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 71 42 did do VBD 13433 71 43 not not RB 13433 71 44 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 71 45 interpolate interpolate VB 13433 71 46 the the DT 13433 71 47 words word NNS 13433 71 48 from from IN 13433 71 49 the the DT 13433 71 50 fourth fourth JJ 13433 71 51 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 71 52 , , , 13433 71 53 and and CC 13433 71 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 71 55 affirmed affirm VBD 13433 71 56 the the DT 13433 71 57 fact fact NN 13433 71 58 that that IN 13433 71 59 there there EX 13433 71 60 is be VBZ 13433 71 61 no no DT 13433 71 62 evidence evidence NN 13433 71 63 whatever whatever WDT 13433 71 64 that that IN 13433 71 65 Papias Papias NNP 13433 71 66 knew know VBD 13433 71 67 that that DT 13433 71 68 work work NN 13433 71 69 . . . 13433 72 1 Anger anger NN 13433 72 2 , , , 13433 72 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 72 4 5:2 5:2 LS 13433 72 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 72 6 discussing discuss VBG 13433 72 7 the the DT 13433 72 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 72 9 of of IN 13433 72 10 the the DT 13433 72 11 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 72 12 quoted quote VBN 13433 72 13 by by IN 13433 72 14 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 72 15 in in IN 13433 72 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 72 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 72 18 , , , 13433 72 19 refers refer VBZ 13433 72 20 to to IN 13433 72 21 this this DT 13433 72 22 passage passage NN 13433 72 23 in in IN 13433 72 24 a a DT 13433 72 25 note note NN 13433 72 26 with with IN 13433 72 27 marked marked JJ 13433 72 28 doubt doubt NN 13433 72 29 , , , 13433 72 30 saying say VBG 13433 72 31 , , , 13433 72 32 that that IN 13433 72 33 _ _ NNP 13433 72 34 fortasse fortasse NN 13433 72 35 _ _ NNP 13433 72 36 ( ( -LRB- 13433 72 37 in in IN 13433 72 38 italics italic NNS 13433 72 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 72 40 , , , 13433 72 41 on on IN 13433 72 42 account account NN 13433 72 43 the the DT 13433 72 44 chiliastic chiliastic JJ 13433 72 45 tone tone NN 13433 72 46 of of IN 13433 72 47 the the DT 13433 72 48 passage passage NN 13433 72 49 , , , 13433 72 50 it -PRON- PRP 13433 72 51 may may MD 13433 72 52 , , , 13433 72 53 as as IN 13433 72 54 Routh Routh NNP 13433 72 55 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 72 56 , , , 13433 72 57 be be VB 13433 72 58 from from IN 13433 72 59 the the DT 13433 72 60 work work NN 13433 72 61 of of IN 13433 72 62 Papias Papias NNP 13433 72 63 ; ; : 13433 72 64 but but CC 13433 72 65 in in IN 13433 72 66 the the DT 13433 72 67 text text NN 13433 72 68 he -PRON- PRP 13433 72 69 points point VBZ 13433 72 70 out out RP 13433 72 71 the the DT 13433 72 72 great great JJ 13433 72 73 caution caution NN 13433 72 74 with with IN 13433 72 75 which which WDT 13433 72 76 these these DT 13433 72 77 quotations quotation NNS 13433 72 78 from from IN 13433 72 79 " " `` 13433 72 80 the the DT 13433 72 81 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 72 82 " " `` 13433 72 83 should should MD 13433 72 84 be be VB 13433 72 85 used use VBN 13433 72 86 . . . 13433 73 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 73 2 says say VBZ 13433 73 3 , , , 13433 73 4 " " `` 13433 73 5 Sed Sed NNP 13433 73 6 in in IN 13433 73 7 usu usu NNP 13433 73 8 horum horum NNP 13433 73 9 testimoniorum testimoniorum NNP 13433 73 10 faciendo faciendo NNP 13433 73 11 cautissime cautissime NN 13433 73 12 versandum versandum NNP 13433 73 13 est est NNP 13433 73 14 , , , 13433 73 15 tum tum NN 13433 73 16 quod quod NN 13433 73 17 , , , 13433 73 18 nisi nisi NNP 13433 73 19 omnia omnia NNP 13433 73 20 , , , 13433 73 21 certe certe NNP 13433 73 22 pleraque pleraque NNP 13433 73 23 ab ab NNP 13433 73 24 Irenaeo Irenaeo NNP 13433 73 25 _ _ NNP 13433 73 26 memoriter memoriter NN 13433 73 27 _ _ NNP 13433 73 28 repetuntur repetuntur NN 13433 73 29 , , , 13433 73 30 tum tum NN 13433 73 31 quia quia NN 13433 73 32 hic hic JJ 13433 73 33 illic illic JJ 13433 73 34 incertissimum incertissimum JJ 13433 73 35 est est NNP 13433 73 36 , , , 13433 73 37 utrum utrum NNP 13433 73 38 ipse ipse NNP 13433 73 39 loquatur loquatur NN 13433 73 40 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 73 41 an an DT 13433 73 42 presbyterorum presbyterorum NN 13433 73 43 verba verba NN 13433 73 44 recitet recitet NN 13433 73 45 . . . 13433 73 46 " " '' 13433 74 1 Meyer Meyer NNP 13433 74 2 , , , 13433 74 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 74 4 5:3 5:3 NN 13433 74 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 74 6 who who WP 13433 74 7 refers refer VBZ 13433 74 8 to to IN 13433 74 9 the the DT 13433 74 10 passage passage NN 13433 74 11 , , , 13433 74 12 remarks remark VBZ 13433 74 13 that that IN 13433 74 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 74 15 is be VBZ 13433 74 16 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 74 17 whether whether IN 13433 74 18 these these DT 13433 74 19 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 74 20 , , , 13433 74 21 whom whom WP 13433 74 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 74 23 does do VBZ 13433 74 24 not not RB 13433 74 25 connect connect VB 13433 74 26 with with IN 13433 74 27 Papias Papias NNP 13433 74 28 , , , 13433 74 29 derived derive VBD 13433 74 30 the the DT 13433 74 31 saying saying NN 13433 74 32 from from IN 13433 74 33 the the DT 13433 74 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 74 35 or or CC 13433 74 36 from from IN 13433 74 37 tradition tradition NN 13433 74 38 . . . 13433 75 1 Riggenbach Riggenbach NNP 13433 75 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 75 3 5:4 5:4 CD 13433 75 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 75 5 alludes allude NNS 13433 75 6 to to IN 13433 75 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 75 8 merely merely RB 13433 75 9 to to TO 13433 75 10 abandon abandon VB 13433 75 11 the the DT 13433 75 12 passage passage NN 13433 75 13 as as IN 13433 75 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 75 15 connected connect VBN 13433 75 16 with with IN 13433 75 17 Papias Papias NNP 13433 75 18 , , , 13433 75 19 and and CC 13433 75 20 only only RB 13433 75 21 claims claim VBZ 13433 75 22 the the DT 13433 75 23 quotation quotation NN 13433 75 24 , , , 13433 75 25 in in IN 13433 75 26 an an DT 13433 75 27 arbitrary arbitrary JJ 13433 75 28 way way NN 13433 75 29 , , , 13433 75 30 as as IN 13433 75 31 emanating emanate VBG 13433 75 32 from from IN 13433 75 33 the the DT 13433 75 34 first first JJ 13433 75 35 half half NN 13433 75 36 of of IN 13433 75 37 the the DT 13433 75 38 second second JJ 13433 75 39 century century NN 13433 75 40 . . . 13433 76 1 Professor Professor NNP 13433 76 2 Hofstede Hofstede NNP 13433 76 3 de de NNP 13433 76 4 Groot Groot NNP 13433 76 5 , , , 13433 76 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 76 7 5:5 5:5 CD 13433 76 8 ] ] -RRB- 13433 76 9 the the DT 13433 76 10 translator translator NN 13433 76 11 of of IN 13433 76 12 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 76 13 's 's POS 13433 76 14 work work NN 13433 76 15 into into IN 13433 76 16 Dutch Dutch NNP 13433 76 17 , , , 13433 76 18 and and CC 13433 76 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 76 20 warm warm JJ 13433 76 21 admirer admirer NN 13433 76 22 , , , 13433 76 23 brings bring VBZ 13433 76 24 forward forward RP 13433 76 25 the the DT 13433 76 26 quotation quotation NN 13433 76 27 , , , 13433 76 28 after after IN 13433 76 29 him -PRON- PRP 13433 76 30 , , , 13433 76 31 as as IN 13433 76 32 either either DT 13433 76 33 belonging belong VBG 13433 76 34 to to IN 13433 76 35 the the DT 13433 76 36 circle circle NN 13433 76 37 of of IN 13433 76 38 Papias Papias NNP 13433 76 39 or or CC 13433 76 40 to to IN 13433 76 41 that that DT 13433 76 42 Father Father NNP 13433 76 43 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 76 44 . . . 13433 77 1 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 77 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 77 3 5:6 5:6 LS 13433 77 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 77 5 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 77 6 separates separate VBZ 13433 77 7 the the DT 13433 77 8 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 77 9 of of IN 13433 77 10 this this DT 13433 77 11 passage passage NN 13433 77 12 from from IN 13433 77 13 Papias Papias NNP 13433 77 14 , , , 13433 77 15 and and CC 13433 77 16 asserts assert VBZ 13433 77 17 that that IN 13433 77 18 they -PRON- PRP 13433 77 19 may may MD 13433 77 20 have have VB 13433 77 21 lived live VBN 13433 77 22 in in IN 13433 77 23 the the DT 13433 77 24 second second JJ 13433 77 25 half half NN 13433 77 26 of of IN 13433 77 27 the the DT 13433 77 28 second second JJ 13433 77 29 century century NN 13433 77 30 . . . 13433 78 1 Luthardt luthardt NN 13433 78 2 , , , 13433 78 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 78 4 6:1 6:1 CD 13433 78 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 78 6 in in IN 13433 78 7 the the DT 13433 78 8 new new JJ 13433 78 9 issue issue NN 13433 78 10 of of IN 13433 78 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 78 12 youthful youthful JJ 13433 78 13 work work NN 13433 78 14 on on IN 13433 78 15 the the DT 13433 78 16 fourth fourth JJ 13433 78 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 78 18 , , , 13433 78 19 does do VBZ 13433 78 20 not not RB 13433 78 21 attempt attempt VB 13433 78 22 to to TO 13433 78 23 associate associate VB 13433 78 24 the the DT 13433 78 25 quotation quotation NN 13433 78 26 with with IN 13433 78 27 the the DT 13433 78 28 book book NN 13433 78 29 of of IN 13433 78 30 Papias Papias NNP 13433 78 31 , , , 13433 78 32 but but CC 13433 78 33 merely merely RB 13433 78 34 argues argue VBZ 13433 78 35 that that IN 13433 78 36 the the DT 13433 78 37 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 78 38 to to TO 13433 78 39 whom whom WP 13433 78 40 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 78 41 was be VBD 13433 78 42 indebted indebte VBN 13433 78 43 for for IN 13433 78 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 78 45 formed form VBD 13433 78 46 a a DT 13433 78 47 circle circle NN 13433 78 48 to to TO 13433 78 49 which which WDT 13433 78 50 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 78 51 and and CC 13433 78 52 Papias Papias NNP 13433 78 53 belonged belong VBD 13433 78 54 . . . 13433 79 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 79 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 79 3 6:2 6:2 CD 13433 79 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 79 5 does do VBZ 13433 79 6 not not RB 13433 79 7 go go VB 13433 79 8 beyond beyond IN 13433 79 9 him -PRON- PRP 13433 79 10 in in IN 13433 79 11 this this DT 13433 79 12 . . . 13433 80 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 80 2 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 80 3 , , , 13433 80 4 while while IN 13433 80 5 arguing argue VBG 13433 80 6 that that IN 13433 80 7 " " `` 13433 80 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 80 9 is be VBZ 13433 80 10 impossible impossible JJ 13433 80 11 to to TO 13433 80 12 show show VB 13433 80 13 that that IN 13433 80 14 the the DT 13433 80 15 four four CD 13433 80 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 80 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 80 18 ) ) -RRB- 13433 80 19 were be VBD 13433 80 20 current current JJ 13433 80 21 as as RB 13433 80 22 early early RB 13433 80 23 as as IN 13433 80 24 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 80 25 150 150 CD 13433 80 26 , , , 13433 80 27 " " `` 13433 80 28 refers refer VBZ 13433 80 29 to to IN 13433 80 30 this this DT 13433 80 31 passage passage NN 13433 80 32 , , , 13433 80 33 and and CC 13433 80 34 says say VBZ 13433 80 35 : : : 13433 80 36 " " `` 13433 80 37 It -PRON- PRP 13433 80 38 is be VBZ 13433 80 39 precarious precarious JJ 13433 80 40 to to TO 13433 80 41 infer infer VB 13433 80 42 with with IN 13433 80 43 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 80 44 either either CC 13433 80 45 that that IN 13433 80 46 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 80 47 derived derive VBD 13433 80 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 80 49 account account NN 13433 80 50 of of IN 13433 80 51 the the DT 13433 80 52 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 80 53 from from IN 13433 80 54 Papias Papias NNP 13433 80 55 's 's POS 13433 80 56 book book NN 13433 80 57 , , , 13433 80 58 or or CC 13433 80 59 that that IN 13433 80 60 the the DT 13433 80 61 authority authority NN 13433 80 62 of of IN 13433 80 63 the the DT 13433 80 64 elders elder NNS 13433 80 65 carries carry VBZ 13433 80 66 us -PRON- PRP 13433 80 67 back back RB 13433 80 68 to to IN 13433 80 69 the the DT 13433 80 70 termination termination NN 13433 80 71 of of IN 13433 80 72 the the DT 13433 80 73 apostolic apostolic NNP 13433 80 74 times times NNP 13433 80 75 ; ; : 13433 80 76 " " `` 13433 80 77 and and CC 13433 80 78 he -PRON- PRP 13433 80 79 concludes conclude VBZ 13433 80 80 : : : 13433 80 81 " " `` 13433 80 82 Is be VBZ 13433 80 83 it -PRON- PRP 13433 80 84 not not RB 13433 80 85 evident evident JJ 13433 80 86 that that IN 13433 80 87 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 80 88 employed employ VBD 13433 80 89 it -PRON- PRP 13433 80 90 ( ( -LRB- 13433 80 91 the the DT 13433 80 92 word word NN 13433 80 93 ' ' `` 13433 80 94 elders elder NNS 13433 80 95 ' ' '' 13433 80 96 ) ) -RRB- 13433 80 97 loosely loosely RB 13433 80 98 , , , 13433 80 99 without without IN 13433 80 100 an an DT 13433 80 101 exact exact JJ 13433 80 102 idea idea NN 13433 80 103 of of IN 13433 80 104 the the DT 13433 80 105 persons person NNS 13433 80 106 he -PRON- PRP 13433 80 107 meant mean VBD 13433 80 108 ? ? . 13433 80 109 " " '' 13433 81 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 81 2 6:3 6:3 CD 13433 81 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 81 4 In in IN 13433 81 5 another another DT 13433 81 6 place place NN 13433 81 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 81 8 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 81 9 still still RB 13433 81 10 more more RBR 13433 81 11 directly directly RB 13433 81 12 says say VBZ 13433 81 13 : : : 13433 81 14 " " `` 13433 81 15 The the DT 13433 81 16 second second JJ 13433 81 17 proof proof NN 13433 81 18 is be VBZ 13433 81 19 founded found VBN 13433 81 20 on on IN 13433 81 21 a a DT 13433 81 22 passage passage NN 13433 81 23 in in IN 13433 81 24 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 81 25 where where WRB 13433 81 26 the the DT 13433 81 27 Father Father NNP 13433 81 28 , , , 13433 81 29 professing profess VBG 13433 81 30 to to TO 13433 81 31 give give VB 13433 81 32 an an DT 13433 81 33 account account NN 13433 81 34 of of IN 13433 81 35 the the DT 13433 81 36 eschatological eschatological JJ 13433 81 37 tradition tradition NN 13433 81 38 of of IN 13433 81 39 ' ' '' 13433 81 40 the the DT 13433 81 41 presbyter presbyter NN 13433 81 42 , , , 13433 81 43 a a DT 13433 81 44 disciple disciple NN 13433 81 45 of of IN 13433 81 46 the the DT 13433 81 47 Apostles Apostles NNPS 13433 81 48 , , , 13433 81 49 ' ' '' 13433 81 50 introduces introduce VBZ 13433 81 51 the the DT 13433 81 52 words word NNS 13433 81 53 , , , 13433 81 54 ' ' '' 13433 81 55 and and CC 13433 81 56 that that IN 13433 81 57 therefore therefore RB 13433 81 58 the the DT 13433 81 59 Lord Lord NNP 13433 81 60 said say VBD 13433 81 61 , , , 13433 81 62 " " `` 13433 81 63 In in IN 13433 81 64 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 81 65 Father Father NNP 13433 81 66 's 's POS 13433 81 67 house house NN 13433 81 68 are be VBP 13433 81 69 many many JJ 13433 81 70 mansions mansion NNS 13433 81 71 . . . 13433 81 72 " " '' 13433 81 73 ' ' '' 13433 82 1 Here here RB 13433 82 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 82 3 is be VBZ 13433 82 4 equally equally RB 13433 82 5 uncertain uncertain JJ 13433 82 6 whether whether IN 13433 82 7 a a DT 13433 82 8 work work NN 13433 82 9 of of IN 13433 82 10 Papias Papias NNP 13433 82 11 be be VB 13433 82 12 meant mean VBN 13433 82 13 as as IN 13433 82 14 the the DT 13433 82 15 source source NN 13433 82 16 of of IN 13433 82 17 the the DT 13433 82 18 quotation quotation NN 13433 82 19 , , , 13433 82 20 and and CC 13433 82 21 whether whether IN 13433 82 22 that that DT 13433 82 23 Father Father NNP 13433 82 24 did do VBD 13433 82 25 not not RB 13433 82 26 insert insert VB 13433 82 27 something something NN 13433 82 28 of of IN 13433 82 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 82 30 own own JJ 13433 82 31 , , , 13433 82 32 or or CC 13433 82 33 something something NN 13433 82 34 borrowed borrow VBN 13433 82 35 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 82 36 , , , 13433 82 37 and and CC 13433 82 38 altered alter VBD 13433 82 39 according accord VBG 13433 82 40 to to IN 13433 82 41 the the DT 13433 82 42 text text NN 13433 82 43 of of IN 13433 82 44 the the DT 13433 82 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 82 46 . . . 13433 82 47 " " '' 13433 83 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 83 2 6:4 6:4 CD 13433 83 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 83 4 With with IN 13433 83 5 these these DT 13433 83 6 exceptions exception NNS 13433 83 7 , , , 13433 83 8 no no DT 13433 83 9 critic critic NN 13433 83 10 seems seem VBZ 13433 83 11 to to TO 13433 83 12 have have VB 13433 83 13 considered consider VBN 13433 83 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 83 15 worth worth JJ 13433 83 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 83 17 while while NN 13433 83 18 to to TO 13433 83 19 refer refer VB 13433 83 20 to to IN 13433 83 21 this this DT 13433 83 22 passage passage NN 13433 83 23 at at RB 13433 83 24 all all RB 13433 83 25 . . . 13433 84 1 Neither neither CC 13433 84 2 in in IN 13433 84 3 considering consider VBG 13433 84 4 the the DT 13433 84 5 external external JJ 13433 84 6 evidences evidence NNS 13433 84 7 for for IN 13433 84 8 the the DT 13433 84 9 antiquity antiquity NN 13433 84 10 of of IN 13433 84 11 the the DT 13433 84 12 fourth fourth JJ 13433 84 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 84 14 , , , 13433 84 15 nor nor CC 13433 84 16 in in IN 13433 84 17 discussing discuss VBG 13433 84 18 the the DT 13433 84 19 question question NN 13433 84 20 whether whether IN 13433 84 21 Papias Papias NNP 13433 84 22 was be VBD 13433 84 23 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 84 24 with with IN 13433 84 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 84 26 , , , 13433 84 27 do do VBP 13433 84 28 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 84 29 writers writer NNS 13433 84 30 like like IN 13433 84 31 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 84 32 , , , 13433 84 33 Ebrard Ebrard NNP 13433 84 34 , , , 13433 84 35 Olshausen Olshausen NNP 13433 84 36 , , , 13433 84 37 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 84 38 , , , 13433 84 39 Kirchhofer Kirchhofer NNP 13433 84 40 , , , 13433 84 41 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 84 42 , , , 13433 84 43 or or CC 13433 84 44 Tholuck Tholuck NNP 13433 84 45 , , , 13433 84 46 or or CC 13433 84 47 impartial impartial JJ 13433 84 48 writers writer NNS 13433 84 49 like like IN 13433 84 50 Credner Credner NNP 13433 84 51 , , , 13433 84 52 De De NNP 13433 84 53 Wette Wette NNP 13433 84 54 , , , 13433 84 55 Gfrörer Gfrörer NNP 13433 84 56 , , , 13433 84 57 Lücke Lücke NNP 13433 84 58 , , , 13433 84 59 and and CC 13433 84 60 others other NNS 13433 84 61 commit commit VBP 13433 84 62 the the DT 13433 84 63 mistake mistake NN 13433 84 64 of of IN 13433 84 65 even even RB 13433 84 66 alluding allude VBG 13433 84 67 to to IN 13433 84 68 it -PRON- PRP 13433 84 69 , , , 13433 84 70 although although IN 13433 84 71 many many JJ 13433 84 72 of of IN 13433 84 73 them -PRON- PRP 13433 84 74 directly directly RB 13433 84 75 endeavour endeavour VBP 13433 84 76 to to TO 13433 84 77 refute refute VB 13433 84 78 the the DT 13433 84 79 article article NN 13433 84 80 of of IN 13433 84 81 Zeller Zeller NNP 13433 84 82 , , , 13433 84 83 in in IN 13433 84 84 which which WDT 13433 84 85 it -PRON- PRP 13433 84 86 is be VBZ 13433 84 87 cited cite VBN 13433 84 88 and and CC 13433 84 89 rejected reject VBN 13433 84 90 , , , 13433 84 91 and and CC 13433 84 92 all all DT 13433 84 93 of of IN 13433 84 94 them -PRON- PRP 13433 84 95 point point VBP 13433 84 96 out out RP 13433 84 97 so so RB 13433 84 98 indirect indirect VBP 13433 84 99 an an DT 13433 84 100 argument argument NN 13433 84 101 for for IN 13433 84 102 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 84 103 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 84 104 of of IN 13433 84 105 the the DT 13433 84 106 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 84 107 as as IN 13433 84 108 the the DT 13433 84 109 statement statement NN 13433 84 110 of of IN 13433 84 111 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 84 112 that that IN 13433 84 113 Papias Papias NNP 13433 84 114 made make VBD 13433 84 115 use use NN 13433 84 116 of of IN 13433 84 117 the the DT 13433 84 118 first first JJ 13433 84 119 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 84 120 of of IN 13433 84 121 John John NNP 13433 84 122 . . . 13433 85 1 Indeed indeed RB 13433 85 2 , , , 13433 85 3 on on IN 13433 85 4 neither neither DT 13433 85 5 side side NN 13433 85 6 is be VBZ 13433 85 7 the the DT 13433 85 8 passage passage NN 13433 85 9 introduced introduce VBN 13433 85 10 into into IN 13433 85 11 the the DT 13433 85 12 controversy controversy NN 13433 85 13 at at RB 13433 85 14 all all RB 13433 85 15 ; ; : 13433 85 16 and and CC 13433 85 17 whilst whilst IN 13433 85 18 so so RB 13433 85 19 many many JJ 13433 85 20 conclude conclude VBP 13433 85 21 positively positively RB 13433 85 22 that that IN 13433 85 23 Papias Papias NNP 13433 85 24 was be VBD 13433 85 25 not not RB 13433 85 26 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 85 27 with with IN 13433 85 28 the the DT 13433 85 29 fourth fourth JJ 13433 85 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 85 31 , , , 13433 85 32 the the DT 13433 85 33 utmost utmost JJ 13433 85 34 that that WDT 13433 85 35 is be VBZ 13433 85 36 argued argue VBN 13433 85 37 by by IN 13433 85 38 the the DT 13433 85 39 majority majority NN 13433 85 40 of of IN 13433 85 41 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 85 42 critics critic NNS 13433 85 43 is be VBZ 13433 85 44 , , , 13433 85 45 that that IN 13433 85 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 85 47 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 85 48 of of IN 13433 85 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 85 50 is be VBZ 13433 85 51 not not RB 13433 85 52 actually actually RB 13433 85 53 proved prove VBN 13433 85 54 . . . 13433 86 1 Those those DT 13433 86 2 who who WP 13433 86 3 go go VBP 13433 86 4 further far RBR 13433 86 5 and and CC 13433 86 6 urge urge VB 13433 86 7 the the DT 13433 86 8 supposed suppose VBN 13433 86 9 use use NN 13433 86 10 of of IN 13433 86 11 the the DT 13433 86 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 86 13 as as IN 13433 86 14 testimony testimony NN 13433 86 15 in in IN 13433 86 16 favour favour NN 13433 86 17 of of IN 13433 86 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 86 19 also also RB 13433 86 20 knowing know VBG 13433 86 21 the the DT 13433 86 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 86 23 would would MD 13433 86 24 only only RB 13433 86 25 too too RB 13433 86 26 gladly gladly RB 13433 86 27 have have VBP 13433 86 28 produced produce VBN 13433 86 29 this this DT 13433 86 30 passage passage NN 13433 86 31 , , , 13433 86 32 if if IN 13433 86 33 they -PRON- PRP 13433 86 34 could could MD 13433 86 35 have have VB 13433 86 36 maintained maintain VBN 13433 86 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 86 38 as as IN 13433 86 39 taken take VBN 13433 86 40 from from IN 13433 86 41 the the DT 13433 86 42 work work NN 13433 86 43 of of IN 13433 86 44 Papias Papias NNP 13433 86 45 . . . 13433 87 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 87 2 would would MD 13433 87 3 not not RB 13433 87 4 be be VB 13433 87 5 permissible permissible JJ 13433 87 6 to to TO 13433 87 7 assume assume VB 13433 87 8 that that IN 13433 87 9 any any DT 13433 87 10 of of IN 13433 87 11 the the DT 13433 87 12 writers writer NNS 13433 87 13 to to TO 13433 87 14 whom whom WP 13433 87 15 we -PRON- PRP 13433 87 16 refer refer VBP 13433 87 17 were be VBD 13433 87 18 ignorant ignorant JJ 13433 87 19 of of IN 13433 87 20 the the DT 13433 87 21 existence existence NN 13433 87 22 of of IN 13433 87 23 the the DT 13433 87 24 passage passage NN 13433 87 25 , , , 13433 87 26 because because IN 13433 87 27 they -PRON- PRP 13433 87 28 are be VBP 13433 87 29 men man NNS 13433 87 30 thoroughly thoroughly RB 13433 87 31 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 87 32 with with IN 13433 87 33 the the DT 13433 87 34 subject subject NN 13433 87 35 generally generally RB 13433 87 36 , , , 13433 87 37 and and CC 13433 87 38 most most JJS 13433 87 39 of of IN 13433 87 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 87 41 directly directly RB 13433 87 42 refer refer VBP 13433 87 43 to to IN 13433 87 44 the the DT 13433 87 45 article article NN 13433 87 46 of of IN 13433 87 47 Zeller Zeller NNP 13433 87 48 in in IN 13433 87 49 which which WDT 13433 87 50 the the DT 13433 87 51 quotation quotation NN 13433 87 52 is be VBZ 13433 87 53 discussed discuss VBN 13433 87 54 . . . 13433 88 1 This this DT 13433 88 2 is be VBZ 13433 88 3 an an DT 13433 88 4 instance instance NN 13433 88 5 in in IN 13433 88 6 which which WDT 13433 88 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 88 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 88 9 has have VBZ 13433 88 10 the the DT 13433 88 11 " " `` 13433 88 12 misfortune misfortune NN 13433 88 13 to to TO 13433 88 14 dispute dispute VB 13433 88 15 not not RB 13433 88 16 a a DT 13433 88 17 few few JJ 13433 88 18 propositions proposition NNS 13433 88 19 , , , 13433 88 20 which which WDT 13433 88 21 most most JJS 13433 88 22 critics critic NNS 13433 88 23 are be VBP 13433 88 24 agreed agree VBN 13433 88 25 in in IN 13433 88 26 maintaining maintain VBG 13433 88 27 . . . 13433 88 28 " " '' 13433 89 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 89 2 have have VBP 13433 89 3 no no DT 13433 89 4 objection objection NN 13433 89 5 to to IN 13433 89 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 89 7 disputing dispute VBG 13433 89 8 anything anything NN 13433 89 9 . . . 13433 90 1 All all DT 13433 90 2 that that WDT 13433 90 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 90 4 suggest suggest VBP 13433 90 5 desirable desirable JJ 13433 90 6 in in IN 13433 90 7 such such PDT 13433 90 8 a a DT 13433 90 9 case case NN 13433 90 10 is be VBZ 13433 90 11 some some DT 13433 90 12 indication indication NN 13433 90 13 that that IN 13433 90 14 there there EX 13433 90 15 is be VBZ 13433 90 16 anything anything NN 13433 90 17 in in IN 13433 90 18 dispute dispute NN 13433 90 19 , , , 13433 90 20 which which WDT 13433 90 21 , , , 13433 90 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 90 23 submit submit VBP 13433 90 24 , , , 13433 90 25 general general JJ 13433 90 26 readers reader NNS 13433 90 27 could could MD 13433 90 28 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 90 29 discover discover VB 13433 90 30 from from IN 13433 90 31 the the DT 13433 90 32 statements statement NNS 13433 90 33 of of IN 13433 90 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 90 35 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 90 36 or or CC 13433 90 37 the the DT 13433 90 38 remarks remark NNS 13433 90 39 of of IN 13433 90 40 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 90 41 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 90 42 . . . 13433 91 1 Now now RB 13433 91 2 in in IN 13433 91 3 regard regard NN 13433 91 4 to to IN 13433 91 5 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 91 6 , , , 13433 91 7 in in IN 13433 91 8 desiring desire VBG 13433 91 9 to to TO 13433 91 10 avoid avoid VB 13433 91 11 what what WP 13433 91 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 91 13 objected object VBD 13433 91 14 to to IN 13433 91 15 in in IN 13433 91 16 others other NNS 13433 91 17 , , , 13433 91 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 91 19 may may MD 13433 91 20 have have VB 13433 91 21 gone go VBN 13433 91 22 to to IN 13433 91 23 the the DT 13433 91 24 other other JJ 13433 91 25 extreme extreme NN 13433 91 26 . . . 13433 92 1 But but CC 13433 92 2 although although IN 13433 92 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 92 4 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 92 5 too too RB 13433 92 6 carefully carefully RB 13433 92 7 avoided avoid VBD 13433 92 8 any any DT 13433 92 9 indication indication NN 13433 92 10 as as IN 13433 92 11 to to IN 13433 92 12 who who WP 13433 92 13 says say VBZ 13433 92 14 " " `` 13433 92 15 that that IN 13433 92 16 there there EX 13433 92 17 is be VBZ 13433 92 18 this this DT 13433 92 19 distinction distinction NN 13433 92 20 of of IN 13433 92 21 dwelling dwelling NN 13433 92 22 , , , 13433 92 23 " " '' 13433 92 24 & & CC 13433 92 25 c. c. NNP 13433 92 26 , , , 13433 92 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 92 28 did do VBD 13433 92 29 what what WP 13433 92 30 was be VBD 13433 92 31 possible possible JJ 13433 92 32 to to TO 13433 92 33 attract attract VB 13433 92 34 attention attention NN 13433 92 35 to to IN 13433 92 36 the the DT 13433 92 37 actual actual JJ 13433 92 38 indirect indirect JJ 13433 92 39 construction construction NN 13433 92 40 , , , 13433 92 41 a a DT 13433 92 42 fact fact NN 13433 92 43 which which WDT 13433 92 44 must must MD 13433 92 45 have have VB 13433 92 46 been be VBN 13433 92 47 patent patent NN 13433 92 48 , , , 13433 92 49 as as IN 13433 92 50 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 92 51 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 92 52 says say VBZ 13433 92 53 , , , 13433 92 54 to to IN 13433 92 55 a a DT 13433 92 56 " " `` 13433 92 57 fairly fairly RB 13433 92 58 trained train VBN 13433 92 59 schoolboy schoolboy NN 13433 92 60 . . . 13433 92 61 " " '' 13433 93 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 93 2 doubly doubly RB 13433 93 3 indicated indicate VBD 13433 93 4 , , , 13433 93 5 by by IN 13433 93 6 a a DT 13433 93 7 mark mark NN 13433 93 8 and and CC 13433 93 9 by by IN 13433 93 10 adding add VBG 13433 93 11 a a DT 13433 93 12 note note NN 13433 93 13 , , , 13433 93 14 the the DT 13433 93 15 commencement commencement NN 13433 93 16 of of IN 13433 93 17 the the DT 13433 93 18 sentence sentence NN 13433 93 19 , , , 13433 93 20 and and CC 13433 93 21 not not RB 13433 93 22 only only RB 13433 93 23 gave give VBD 13433 93 24 the the DT 13433 93 25 original original NN 13433 93 26 below below RB 13433 93 27 , , , 13433 93 28 but but CC 13433 93 29 actually actually RB 13433 93 30 inserted insert VBN 13433 93 31 in in IN 13433 93 32 the the DT 13433 93 33 text text NN 13433 93 34 the the DT 13433 93 35 opening opening NN 13433 93 36 words word NNS 13433 93 37 , , , 13433 93 38 [ [ -LRB- 13433 93 39 Greek Greek NNP 13433 93 40 : : : 13433 93 41 einai einai NNP 13433 93 42 de de NNP 13433 93 43 tên tên NNP 13433 93 44 diastolên diastolên NNP 13433 93 45 tautên tautên NNP 13433 93 46 tês tês NNP 13433 93 47 oikêseôs oikêseôs NNP 13433 93 48 ] ] -RRB- 13433 93 49 , , , 13433 93 50 for for IN 13433 93 51 the the DT 13433 93 52 express express JJ 13433 93 53 purpose purpose NN 13433 93 54 of of IN 13433 93 55 showing show VBG 13433 93 56 the the DT 13433 93 57 construction construction NN 13433 93 58 . . . 13433 94 1 That that IN 13433 94 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 94 3 did do VBD 13433 94 4 not not RB 13433 94 5 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 94 6 mistake mistake VB 13433 94 7 the the DT 13433 94 8 point point NN 13433 94 9 is be VBZ 13433 94 10 evident evident JJ 13433 94 11 , , , 13433 94 12 not not RB 13433 94 13 only only RB 13433 94 14 from from IN 13433 94 15 this this DT 13433 94 16 , , , 13433 94 17 but but CC 13433 94 18 from from IN 13433 94 19 the the DT 13433 94 20 fact fact NN 13433 94 21 that that IN 13433 94 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 94 23 do do VBP 13433 94 24 not not RB 13433 94 25 make make VB 13433 94 26 any any DT 13433 94 27 objection objection NN 13433 94 28 to to IN 13433 94 29 the the DT 13433 94 30 translations translation NNS 13433 94 31 of of IN 13433 94 32 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 94 33 and and CC 13433 94 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 94 35 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 94 36 , , , 13433 94 37 beyond beyond IN 13433 94 38 condemning condemn VBG 13433 94 39 the the DT 13433 94 40 _ _ NNP 13433 94 41 unmarked unmarked JJ 13433 94 42 _ _ NNP 13433 94 43 introduction introduction NN 13433 94 44 of of IN 13433 94 45 precise precise JJ 13433 94 46 words word NNS 13433 94 47 , , , 13433 94 48 and and CC 13433 94 49 that that IN 13433 94 50 I -PRON- PRP 13433 94 51 proceed proceed VBP 13433 94 52 to to TO 13433 94 53 argue argue VB 13433 94 54 that that IN 13433 94 55 " " `` 13433 94 56 the the DT 13433 94 57 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 94 58 , , , 13433 94 59 " " '' 13433 94 60 to to TO 13433 94 61 whom whom WP 13433 94 62 the the DT 13433 94 63 passage passage NN 13433 94 64 is be VBZ 13433 94 65 referred refer VBN 13433 94 66 , , , 13433 94 67 are be VBP 13433 94 68 in in IN 13433 94 69 no no DT 13433 94 70 case case NN 13433 94 71 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 94 72 to to TO 13433 94 73 be be VB 13433 94 74 associated associate VBN 13433 94 75 with with IN 13433 94 76 the the DT 13433 94 77 work work NN 13433 94 78 of of IN 13433 94 79 Papias Papias NNP 13433 94 80 , , , 13433 94 81 which which WDT 13433 94 82 would would MD 13433 94 83 have have VB 13433 94 84 been be VBN 13433 94 85 mere mere JJ 13433 94 86 waste waste NN 13433 94 87 of of IN 13433 94 88 time time NN 13433 94 89 had have VBD 13433 94 90 I -PRON- PRP 13433 94 91 intended intend VBN 13433 94 92 to to TO 13433 94 93 maintain maintain VB 13433 94 94 that that IN 13433 94 95 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 94 96 quoted quote VBD 13433 94 97 direct direct RB 13433 94 98 from from IN 13433 94 99 the the DT 13433 94 100 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 94 101 . . . 13433 95 1 An an DT 13433 95 2 observation observation NN 13433 95 3 made make VBD 13433 95 4 to to IN 13433 95 5 me -PRON- PRP 13433 95 6 regarding regard VBG 13433 95 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 95 8 note note NN 13433 95 9 on on IN 13433 95 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 95 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 95 12 , , , 13433 95 13 showed show VBD 13433 95 14 me -PRON- PRP 13433 95 15 that that IN 13433 95 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 95 17 had have VBD 13433 95 18 been be VBN 13433 95 19 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 13433 95 20 , , , 13433 95 21 and and CC 13433 95 22 led lead VBD 13433 95 23 me -PRON- PRP 13433 95 24 to to TO 13433 95 25 refer refer VB 13433 95 26 to to IN 13433 95 27 the the DT 13433 95 28 place place NN 13433 95 29 again again RB 13433 95 30 . . . 13433 96 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 96 2 immediately immediately RB 13433 96 3 withdrew withdraw VBD 13433 96 4 the the DT 13433 96 5 note note NN 13433 96 6 which which WDT 13433 96 7 had have VBD 13433 96 8 been be VBN 13433 96 9 interpreted interpret VBN 13433 96 10 in in IN 13433 96 11 a a DT 13433 96 12 way way NN 13433 96 13 very very RB 13433 96 14 different different JJ 13433 96 15 from from IN 13433 96 16 what what WP 13433 96 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 96 18 had have VBD 13433 96 19 intended intend VBN 13433 96 20 , , , 13433 96 21 and and CC 13433 96 22 at at IN 13433 96 23 the the DT 13433 96 24 same same JJ 13433 96 25 time time NN 13433 96 26 perceiving perceiving NN 13433 96 27 that that WDT 13433 96 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 96 29 argument argument NN 13433 96 30 was be VBD 13433 96 31 obscure obscure JJ 13433 96 32 and and CC 13433 96 33 liable liable JJ 13433 96 34 to to IN 13433 96 35 the the DT 13433 96 36 misinterpretation misinterpretation NN 13433 96 37 of of IN 13433 96 38 which which WDT 13433 96 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 96 40 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 96 41 has have VBZ 13433 96 42 made make VBN 13433 96 43 such such JJ 13433 96 44 eager eager JJ 13433 96 45 use use NN 13433 96 46 , , , 13433 96 47 I -PRON- PRP 13433 96 48 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 96 49 at at IN 13433 96 50 once once RB 13433 96 51 recast recast VB 13433 96 52 it -PRON- PRP 13433 96 53 as as RB 13433 96 54 well well RB 13433 96 55 as as IN 13433 96 56 I -PRON- PRP 13433 96 57 could could MD 13433 96 58 within within IN 13433 96 59 the the DT 13433 96 60 limits limit NNS 13433 96 61 at at IN 13433 96 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 96 63 command command NN 13433 96 64 , , , 13433 96 65 [ [ -LRB- 13433 96 66 8:1 8:1 NN 13433 96 67 ] ] -RRB- 13433 96 68 and and CC 13433 96 69 this this DT 13433 96 70 was be VBD 13433 96 71 already already RB 13433 96 72 published publish VBN 13433 96 73 before before IN 13433 96 74 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 96 75 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 96 76 's 's POS 13433 96 77 criticism criticism NN 13433 96 78 appeared appear VBD 13433 96 79 , , , 13433 96 80 and and CC 13433 96 81 before before IN 13433 96 82 I -PRON- PRP 13433 96 83 had have VBD 13433 96 84 any any DT 13433 96 85 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 96 86 of of IN 13433 96 87 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 96 88 articles article NNS 13433 96 89 . . . 13433 97 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 97 2 8:2 8:2 CD 13433 97 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 97 4 With with IN 13433 97 5 regard regard NN 13433 97 6 to to IN 13433 97 7 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 97 8 , , , 13433 97 9 however however RB 13433 97 10 , , , 13433 97 11 the the DT 13433 97 12 validity validity NN 13433 97 13 of of IN 13433 97 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 97 15 objection objection NN 13433 97 16 is be VBZ 13433 97 17 practically practically RB 13433 97 18 admitted admit VBN 13433 97 19 in in IN 13433 97 20 the the DT 13433 97 21 fullest full JJS 13433 97 22 way way NN 13433 97 23 by by IN 13433 97 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 97 25 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 97 26 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 97 27 . . . 13433 98 1 " " `` 13433 98 2 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 98 3 's 's POS 13433 98 4 words word NNS 13433 98 5 , , , 13433 98 6 " " '' 13433 98 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 98 8 says say VBZ 13433 98 9 , , , 13433 98 10 " " `` 13433 98 11 are be VBP 13433 98 12 ' ' `` 13433 98 13 und und JJ 13433 98 14 deshalb deshalb NN 13433 98 15 , , , 13433 98 16 sagen sagen NNP 13433 98 17 sie sie NNP 13433 98 18 , , , 13433 98 19 habe habe NNP 13433 98 20 der der NNP 13433 98 21 Herr Herr NNP 13433 98 22 den den NN 13433 98 23 Ausspruch Ausspruch NNP 13433 98 24 gethan gethan NN 13433 98 25 . . . 13433 98 26 ' ' '' 13433 99 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 99 2 might may MD 13433 99 3 have have VB 13433 99 4 spared spare VBN 13433 99 5 the the DT 13433 99 6 ' ' `` 13433 99 7 sagen sagen NN 13433 99 8 sie sie NN 13433 99 9 , , , 13433 99 10 ' ' '' 13433 99 11 because because IN 13433 99 12 the the DT 13433 99 13 German german JJ 13433 99 14 idiom idiom NN 13433 99 15 ' ' `` 13433 99 16 habe habe NN 13433 99 17 ' ' POS 13433 99 18 enables enable VBZ 13433 99 19 him -PRON- PRP 13433 99 20 to to TO 13433 99 21 express express VB 13433 99 22 the the DT 13433 99 23 main main JJ 13433 99 24 fact fact NN 13433 99 25 that that IN 13433 99 26 the the DT 13433 99 27 words word NNS 13433 99 28 were be VBD 13433 99 29 not not RB 13433 99 30 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 99 31 's 's POS 13433 99 32 own own JJ 13433 99 33 without without IN 13433 99 34 this this DT 13433 99 35 addition addition NN 13433 99 36 . . . 13433 99 37 " " '' 13433 100 1 Writing write VBG 13433 100 2 of of IN 13433 100 3 a a DT 13433 100 4 brother brother NN 13433 100 5 apologist apologist NN 13433 100 6 of of IN 13433 100 7 course course NN 13433 100 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 100 9 apologetically apologetically RB 13433 100 10 adds add VBZ 13433 100 11 : : : 13433 100 12 " " `` 13433 100 13 But but CC 13433 100 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 100 15 has have VBZ 13433 100 16 not not RB 13433 100 17 altered alter VBN 13433 100 18 any any DT 13433 100 19 idea idea NN 13433 100 20 which which WDT 13433 100 21 the the DT 13433 100 22 original original JJ 13433 100 23 contains contain NNS 13433 100 24 . . . 13433 100 25 " " '' 13433 101 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 101 2 9:1 9:1 CD 13433 101 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 101 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 101 5 affirm affirm VBP 13433 101 6 , , , 13433 101 7 on on IN 13433 101 8 the the DT 13433 101 9 contrary contrary NN 13433 101 10 , , , 13433 101 11 that that IN 13433 101 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 101 13 has have VBZ 13433 101 14 very very RB 13433 101 15 materially materially RB 13433 101 16 altered alter VBN 13433 101 17 an an DT 13433 101 18 idea idea NN 13433 101 19 -- -- : 13433 101 20 that that IN 13433 101 21 , , , 13433 101 22 in in IN 13433 101 23 fact fact NN 13433 101 24 , , , 13433 101 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 101 26 has have VBZ 13433 101 27 warped warp VBN 13433 101 28 the the DT 13433 101 29 whole whole JJ 13433 101 30 argument argument NN 13433 101 31 , , , 13433 101 32 for for IN 13433 101 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 101 34 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 101 35 has have VBZ 13433 101 36 mercifully mercifully RB 13433 101 37 omitted omit VBN 13433 101 38 to to TO 13433 101 39 point point VB 13433 101 40 out out RP 13433 101 41 that that IN 13433 101 42 the the DT 13433 101 43 words word NNS 13433 101 44 just just RB 13433 101 45 quoted quote VBN 13433 101 46 are be VBP 13433 101 47 introduced introduce VBN 13433 101 48 by by IN 13433 101 49 the the DT 13433 101 50 distinct distinct JJ 13433 101 51 assertion assertion NN 13433 101 52 " " '' 13433 101 53 that that WDT 13433 101 54 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 101 55 quotes quote VBZ 13433 101 56 even even RB 13433 101 57 out out IN 13433 101 58 of of IN 13433 101 59 the the DT 13433 101 60 mouth mouth NN 13433 101 61 of of IN 13433 101 62 the the DT 13433 101 63 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 101 64 , , , 13433 101 65 those those DT 13433 101 66 high high JJ 13433 101 67 authorities authority NNS 13433 101 68 of of IN 13433 101 69 Papias Papias NNP 13433 101 70 . . . 13433 101 71 " " '' 13433 102 1 The the DT 13433 102 2 German german JJ 13433 102 3 apologist apologist NN 13433 102 4 , , , 13433 102 5 therefore therefore RB 13433 102 6 , , , 13433 102 7 not not RB 13433 102 8 giving give VBG 13433 102 9 the the DT 13433 102 10 original original JJ 13433 102 11 text text NN 13433 102 12 , , , 13433 102 13 not not RB 13433 102 14 saying say VBG 13433 102 15 a a DT 13433 102 16 word word NN 13433 102 17 of of IN 13433 102 18 the the DT 13433 102 19 adverse adverse JJ 13433 102 20 judgment judgment NN 13433 102 21 of of IN 13433 102 22 most most JJS 13433 102 23 critics critic NNS 13433 102 24 , , , 13433 102 25 after after IN 13433 102 26 fully fully RB 13433 102 27 rendering render VBG 13433 102 28 the the DT 13433 102 29 construction construction NN 13433 102 30 of of IN 13433 102 31 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 102 32 by by IN 13433 102 33 the the DT 13433 102 34 " " `` 13433 102 35 habe habe NN 13433 102 36 , , , 13433 102 37 " " '' 13433 102 38 quietly quietly RB 13433 102 39 inserts insert VBZ 13433 102 40 " " '' 13433 102 41 say say VBP 13433 102 42 they -PRON- PRP 13433 102 43 , , , 13433 102 44 " " '' 13433 102 45 in in IN 13433 102 46 reference reference NN 13433 102 47 to to IN 13433 102 48 these these DT 13433 102 49 " " `` 13433 102 50 high high JJ 13433 102 51 authorities authority NNS 13433 102 52 of of IN 13433 102 53 Papias Papias NNP 13433 102 54 , , , 13433 102 55 " " '' 13433 102 56 without without IN 13433 102 57 a a DT 13433 102 58 hint hint NN 13433 102 59 that that IN 13433 102 60 these these DT 13433 102 61 words word NNS 13433 102 62 are be VBP 13433 102 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 102 64 own own JJ 13433 102 65 . . . 13433 103 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 103 2 9:2 9:2 LS 13433 103 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 103 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 103 5 argument argument NN 13433 103 6 briefly briefly RB 13433 103 7 is be VBZ 13433 103 8 , , , 13433 103 9 that that IN 13433 103 10 there there EX 13433 103 11 is be VBZ 13433 103 12 no no DT 13433 103 13 ground ground NN 13433 103 14 for for IN 13433 103 15 asserting assert VBG 13433 103 16 that that IN 13433 103 17 the the DT 13433 103 18 passage passage NN 13433 103 19 in in IN 13433 103 20 question question NN 13433 103 21 , , , 13433 103 22 with with IN 13433 103 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 103 24 reference reference NN 13433 103 25 to to IN 13433 103 26 " " `` 13433 103 27 many many JJ 13433 103 28 mansions mansion NNS 13433 103 29 , , , 13433 103 30 " " '' 13433 103 31 was be VBD 13433 103 32 derived derive VBN 13433 103 33 from from IN 13433 103 34 the the DT 13433 103 35 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 103 36 of of IN 13433 103 37 Papias Papias NNP 13433 103 38 , , , 13433 103 39 or or CC 13433 103 40 from from IN 13433 103 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 103 42 book book NN 13433 103 43 , , , 13433 103 44 and and CC 13433 103 45 that that IN 13433 103 46 it -PRON- PRP 13433 103 47 is be VBZ 13433 103 48 not not RB 13433 103 49 a a DT 13433 103 50 quotation quotation NN 13433 103 51 from from IN 13433 103 52 a a DT 13433 103 53 work work NN 13433 103 54 which which WDT 13433 103 55 quotes quote VBZ 13433 103 56 the the DT 13433 103 57 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 103 58 as as IN 13433 103 59 quoting quote VBG 13433 103 60 these these DT 13433 103 61 words word NNS 13433 103 62 , , , 13433 103 63 but but CC 13433 103 64 one one CD 13433 103 65 made make VBD 13433 103 66 more more RBR 13433 103 67 directly directly RB 13433 103 68 by by IN 13433 103 69 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 103 70 -- -- : 13433 103 71 not not RB 13433 103 72 directly directly RB 13433 103 73 from from IN 13433 103 74 the the DT 13433 103 75 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 103 76 , , , 13433 103 77 but but CC 13433 103 78 probably probably RB 13433 103 79 from from IN 13433 103 80 some some DT 13433 103 81 contemporary contemporary NN 13433 103 82 , , , 13433 103 83 and and CC 13433 103 84 representing represent VBG 13433 103 85 nothing nothing NN 13433 103 86 more more JJR 13433 103 87 than than IN 13433 103 88 the the DT 13433 103 89 exegesis exegesis NN 13433 103 90 of of IN 13433 103 91 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 103 92 own own JJ 13433 103 93 day day NN 13433 103 94 . . . 13433 104 1 The the DT 13433 104 2 second second JJ 13433 104 3 point point NN 13433 104 4 of of IN 13433 104 5 Canon Canon NNP 13433 104 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 104 7 's 's POS 13433 104 8 attack attack NN 13433 104 9 is be VBZ 13433 104 10 in in IN 13433 104 11 connection connection NN 13433 104 12 with with IN 13433 104 13 a a DT 13433 104 14 discussion discussion NN 13433 104 15 of of IN 13433 104 16 the the DT 13433 104 17 date date NN 13433 104 18 of of IN 13433 104 19 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 104 20 . . . 13433 105 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 105 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 105 3 quotes quote VBZ 13433 105 4 a a DT 13433 105 5 passage passage NN 13433 105 6 from from IN 13433 105 7 Origen Origen NNP 13433 105 8 given give VBN 13433 105 9 in in IN 13433 105 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 105 11 work work NN 13433 105 12 , , , 13433 105 13 [ [ -LRB- 13433 105 14 10:1 10:1 CD 13433 105 15 ] ] -RRB- 13433 105 16 upon upon IN 13433 105 17 which which WDT 13433 105 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 105 19 comments comment VBZ 13433 105 20 as as IN 13433 105 21 follows follow VBZ 13433 105 22 : : : 13433 105 23 " " `` 13433 105 24 On on IN 13433 105 25 the the DT 13433 105 26 strength strength NN 13433 105 27 of of IN 13433 105 28 the the DT 13433 105 29 passage passage NN 13433 105 30 so so RB 13433 105 31 translated translate VBD 13433 105 32 , , , 13433 105 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 105 34 author author NN 13433 105 35 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 105 36 that that IN 13433 105 37 Origen Origen NNP 13433 105 38 's 's POS 13433 105 39 impression impression NN 13433 105 40 concerning concern VBG 13433 105 41 the the DT 13433 105 42 date date NN 13433 105 43 of of IN 13433 105 44 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 105 45 had have VBD 13433 105 46 meanwhile meanwhile RB 13433 105 47 been be VBN 13433 105 48 ' ' `` 13433 105 49 considerably considerably RB 13433 105 50 modified modify VBN 13433 105 51 , , , 13433 105 52 ' ' '' 13433 105 53 and and CC 13433 105 54 remarks remark VBZ 13433 105 55 that that IN 13433 105 56 he -PRON- PRP 13433 105 57 now now RB 13433 105 58 ' ' `` 13433 105 59 treats treat VBZ 13433 105 60 him -PRON- PRP 13433 105 61 as as IN 13433 105 62 a a DT 13433 105 63 contemporary contemporary NN 13433 105 64 . . . 13433 105 65 ' ' '' 13433 106 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 13433 106 2 , , , 13433 106 3 however however RB 13433 106 4 , , , 13433 106 5 the the DT 13433 106 6 tenses tense NNS 13433 106 7 , , , 13433 106 8 on on IN 13433 106 9 which which WDT 13433 106 10 everything everything NN 13433 106 11 depends depend VBZ 13433 106 12 , , , 13433 106 13 are be VBP 13433 106 14 freely freely RB 13433 106 15 handled handle VBN 13433 106 16 in in IN 13433 106 17 this this DT 13433 106 18 translation translation NN 13433 106 19 . . . 13433 107 1 Origen Origen NNP 13433 107 2 does do VBZ 13433 107 3 not not RB 13433 107 4 say say VB 13433 107 5 ' ' '' 13433 107 6 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 107 7 _ _ NNP 13433 107 8 has have VBZ 13433 107 9 promised promise VBN 13433 107 10 _ _ NNP 13433 107 11 , , , 13433 107 12 ' ' '' 13433 107 13 but but CC 13433 107 14 ' ' '' 13433 107 15 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 107 16 _ _ NNP 13433 107 17 promises promise VBZ 13433 107 18 _ _ NNP 13433 107 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 107 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 107 21 Greek Greek NNP 13433 107 22 : : : 13433 107 23 epangellomenon])--_i.e epangellomenon])--_i.e NNP 13433 107 24 . . . 13433 107 25 _ _ NNP 13433 107 26 , , , 13433 107 27 in in IN 13433 107 28 the the DT 13433 107 29 treatise treatise NN 13433 107 30 before before IN 13433 107 31 him -PRON- PRP 13433 107 32 , , , 13433 107 33 Origen Origen NNP 13433 107 34 's 's POS 13433 107 35 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 107 36 was be VBD 13433 107 37 plainly plainly RB 13433 107 38 derived derive VBN 13433 107 39 from from IN 13433 107 40 the the DT 13433 107 41 book book NN 13433 107 42 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 107 43 . . . 13433 108 1 And and CC 13433 108 2 , , , 13433 108 3 again again RB 13433 108 4 , , , 13433 108 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 6 does do VBZ 13433 108 7 not not RB 13433 108 8 say say VB 13433 108 9 ' ' '' 13433 108 10 If if IN 13433 108 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 12 _ _ NNP 13433 108 13 has have VBZ 13433 108 14 not not RB 13433 108 15 fulfilled fulfil VBN 13433 108 16 _ _ NNP 13433 108 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 108 18 promise promise NN 13433 108 19 to to TO 13433 108 20 write write VB 13433 108 21 , , , 13433 108 22 ' ' '' 13433 108 23 but but CC 13433 108 24 ' ' '' 13433 108 25 If if IN 13433 108 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 27 _ _ NNP 13433 108 28 did do VBD 13433 108 29 not not RB 13433 108 30 write write VB 13433 108 31 _ _ NNP 13433 108 32 as as IN 13433 108 33 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 34 undertook undertake VBD 13433 108 35 to to TO 13433 108 36 do do VB 13433 108 37 ' ' '' 13433 108 38 ( ( -LRB- 13433 108 39 [ [ -LRB- 13433 108 40 Greek Greek NNP 13433 108 41 : : : 13433 108 42 _ _ NNP 13433 108 43 egrapsen egrapsen VBD 13433 108 44 huposchomenos huposchomenos NNP 13433 108 45 _ _ NNP 13433 108 46 ] ] -RRB- 13433 108 47 ) ) -RRB- 13433 108 48 ; ; : 13433 108 49 nor nor CC 13433 108 50 ' ' `` 13433 108 51 If if IN 13433 108 52 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 53 _ _ NNP 13433 108 54 has have VBZ 13433 108 55 commenced commence VBN 13433 108 56 and and CC 13433 108 57 finished finish VBN 13433 108 58 _ _ NNP 13433 108 59 , , , 13433 108 60 ' ' '' 13433 108 61 but but CC 13433 108 62 ' ' '' 13433 108 63 If if IN 13433 108 64 he -PRON- PRP 13433 108 65 _ _ NNP 13433 108 66 commenced commence VBD 13433 108 67 and and CC 13433 108 68 finished finish VBD 13433 108 69 _ _ NNP 13433 108 70 ' ' '' 13433 108 71 ( ( -LRB- 13433 108 72 [ [ -LRB- 13433 108 73 Greek Greek NNP 13433 108 74 : : : 13433 108 75 _ _ NNP 13433 108 76 arxamenos arxamenos NN 13433 108 77 sunetelese sunetelese NNP 13433 108 78 _ _ NNP 13433 108 79 ] ] -RRB- 13433 108 80 ) ) -RRB- 13433 108 81 . . . 13433 109 1 Thus thus RB 13433 109 2 Origen Origen NNP 13433 109 3 's 's POS 13433 109 4 language language NN 13433 109 5 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 109 6 here here RB 13433 109 7 points point VBZ 13433 109 8 to to IN 13433 109 9 a a DT 13433 109 10 past past JJ 13433 109 11 epoch epoch NN 13433 109 12 , , , 13433 109 13 and and CC 13433 109 14 is be VBZ 13433 109 15 in in IN 13433 109 16 strict strict JJ 13433 109 17 accordance accordance NN 13433 109 18 with with IN 13433 109 19 the the DT 13433 109 20 earlier early JJR 13433 109 21 passages passage NNS 13433 109 22 in in IN 13433 109 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 109 24 work work NN 13433 109 25 . . . 13433 109 26 " " '' 13433 110 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 110 2 10:2 10:2 CD 13433 110 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 110 4 These these DT 13433 110 5 remarks remark NNS 13433 110 6 , , , 13433 110 7 and and CC 13433 110 8 the the DT 13433 110 9 triumphant triumphant NN 13433 110 10 exclamation exclamation NN 13433 110 11 of of IN 13433 110 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 110 13 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 110 14 at at IN 13433 110 15 the the DT 13433 110 16 close close NN 13433 110 17 that that WDT 13433 110 18 here here RB 13433 110 19 " " `` 13433 110 20 an an DT 13433 110 21 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 110 22 argument argument NN 13433 110 23 is be VBZ 13433 110 24 wrecked wreck VBN 13433 110 25 on on IN 13433 110 26 this this DT 13433 110 27 rock rock NN 13433 110 28 of of IN 13433 110 29 grammar grammar NN 13433 110 30 , , , 13433 110 31 " " '' 13433 110 32 convey convey VB 13433 110 33 a a DT 13433 110 34 totally totally RB 13433 110 35 wrong wrong JJ 13433 110 36 impression impression NN 13433 110 37 of of IN 13433 110 38 the the DT 13433 110 39 case case NN 13433 110 40 . . . 13433 111 1 The the DT 13433 111 2 argument argument NN 13433 111 3 regarding regard VBG 13433 111 4 this this DT 13433 111 5 passage passage NN 13433 111 6 in in IN 13433 111 7 Origen Origen NNP 13433 111 8 occurs occur VBZ 13433 111 9 in in IN 13433 111 10 a a DT 13433 111 11 controversy controversy NN 13433 111 12 between between IN 13433 111 13 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 111 14 and and CC 13433 111 15 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 111 16 , , , 13433 111 17 the the DT 13433 111 18 particulars particular NNS 13433 111 19 of of IN 13433 111 20 which which WDT 13433 111 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 111 22 report report VBP 13433 111 23 ; ; : 13433 111 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 111 25 10:3 10:3 CD 13433 111 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 111 27 and and CC 13433 111 28 to to TO 13433 111 29 avoid avoid VB 13433 111 30 anticipation anticipation NN 13433 111 31 of of IN 13433 111 32 the the DT 13433 111 33 point point NN 13433 111 34 , , , 13433 111 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 111 36 promise promise VBP 13433 111 37 to to TO 13433 111 38 give give VB 13433 111 39 the the DT 13433 111 40 passage passage NN 13433 111 41 in in IN 13433 111 42 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 111 43 place place NN 13433 111 44 , , , 13433 111 45 which which WDT 13433 111 46 I -PRON- PRP 13433 111 47 subsequently subsequently RB 13433 111 48 do do VBP 13433 111 49 . . . 13433 112 1 All all PDT 13433 112 2 the the DT 13433 112 3 complimentary complimentary JJ 13433 112 4 observations observation NNS 13433 112 5 which which WDT 13433 112 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 112 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 112 8 makes make VBZ 13433 112 9 upon upon IN 13433 112 10 the the DT 13433 112 11 translation translation NN 13433 112 12 actually actually RB 13433 112 13 fall fall VBP 13433 112 14 upon upon IN 13433 112 15 the the DT 13433 112 16 head head NN 13433 112 17 of of IN 13433 112 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 112 19 brother brother NN 13433 112 20 apologist apologist NN 13433 112 21 , , , 13433 112 22 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 112 23 , , , 13433 112 24 whose whose WP$ 13433 112 25 rendering rendering NN 13433 112 26 , , , 13433 112 27 as as IN 13433 112 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 112 29 so so RB 13433 112 30 much much JJ 13433 112 31 insists insist VBZ 13433 112 32 upon upon IN 13433 112 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 112 34 , , , 13433 112 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 112 36 merely merely RB 13433 112 37 reproduce reproduce VBP 13433 112 38 . . . 13433 113 1 The the DT 13433 113 2 manner manner NN 13433 113 3 in in IN 13433 113 4 which which WDT 13433 113 5 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 113 6 attacks attack VBZ 13433 113 7 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 113 8 in in IN 13433 113 9 connection connection NN 13433 113 10 with with IN 13433 113 11 this this DT 13433 113 12 passage passage NN 13433 113 13 forcibly forcibly RB 13433 113 14 reminds remind VBZ 13433 113 15 me -PRON- PRP 13433 113 16 of of IN 13433 113 17 the the DT 13433 113 18 amenities amenity NNS 13433 113 19 addressed address VBD 13433 113 20 to to IN 13433 113 21 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 113 22 by by IN 13433 113 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 113 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 113 25 , , , 13433 113 26 who who WP 13433 113 27 seems seem VBZ 13433 113 28 unconsciously unconsciously RB 13433 113 29 to to TO 13433 113 30 have have VB 13433 113 31 caught catch VBN 13433 113 32 the the DT 13433 113 33 trick trick NN 13433 113 34 of of IN 13433 113 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 113 36 precursor precursor NN 13433 113 37 's 's POS 13433 113 38 scolding scolding NN 13433 113 39 . . . 13433 114 1 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 114 2 had have VBD 13433 114 3 paraphrased paraphrase VBN 13433 114 4 Origen Origen NNP 13433 114 5 's 's POS 13433 114 6 words word NNS 13433 114 7 in in IN 13433 114 8 a a DT 13433 114 9 way way NN 13433 114 10 of of IN 13433 114 11 which which WDT 13433 114 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 114 13 critic critic NN 13433 114 14 disapproved disapprove VBD 13433 114 15 , , , 13433 114 16 and and CC 13433 114 17 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 114 18 comments comment NNS 13433 114 19 as as IN 13433 114 20 follows follow VBZ 13433 114 21 : : : 13433 114 22 " " `` 13433 114 23 But but CC 13433 114 24 here here RB 13433 114 25 again again RB 13433 114 26 we -PRON- PRP 13433 114 27 have have VBP 13433 114 28 to to TO 13433 114 29 do do VB 13433 114 30 with with IN 13433 114 31 nothing nothing NN 13433 114 32 else else RB 13433 114 33 than than IN 13433 114 34 a a DT 13433 114 35 completely completely RB 13433 114 36 abortive abortive JJ 13433 114 37 fabrication fabrication NN 13433 114 38 , , , 13433 114 39 a a DT 13433 114 40 certificate certificate NN 13433 114 41 of of IN 13433 114 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 114 43 said say VBN 13433 114 44 critic critic NN 13433 114 45 's 's POS 13433 114 46 poverty poverty NN 13433 114 47 . . . 13433 115 1 For for IN 13433 115 2 the the DT 13433 115 3 assertion assertion NN 13433 115 4 derived derive VBN 13433 115 5 from from IN 13433 115 6 the the DT 13433 115 7 close close NN 13433 115 8 of of IN 13433 115 9 the the DT 13433 115 10 work work NN 13433 115 11 of of IN 13433 115 12 Origen Origen NNP 13433 115 13 rests rest VBZ 13433 115 14 upon upon IN 13433 115 15 gross gross JJ 13433 115 16 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 115 17 or or CC 13433 115 18 upon upon IN 13433 115 19 intentional intentional JJ 13433 115 20 deception deception NN 13433 115 21 . . . 13433 116 1 The the DT 13433 116 2 words word NNS 13433 116 3 of of IN 13433 116 4 Origen Origen NNP 13433 116 5 to to IN 13433 116 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 116 7 patron patron NN 13433 116 8 Ambrosius Ambrosius NNP 13433 116 9 , , , 13433 116 10 who who WP 13433 116 11 had have VBD 13433 116 12 prompted prompt VBN 13433 116 13 him -PRON- PRP 13433 116 14 to to IN 13433 116 15 the the DT 13433 116 16 composition composition NN 13433 116 17 of of IN 13433 116 18 the the DT 13433 116 19 whole whole JJ 13433 116 20 apology apology NN 13433 116 21 , , , 13433 116 22 run run VB 13433 116 23 as as IN 13433 116 24 follows follow VBZ 13433 116 25 " " `` 13433 116 26 [ [ -LRB- 13433 116 27 and and CC 13433 116 28 here here RB 13433 116 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 116 30 must must MD 13433 116 31 give give VB 13433 116 32 the the DT 13433 116 33 German German NNP 13433 116 34 ] ] -RRB- 13433 116 35 : : : 13433 116 36 " " `` 13433 116 37 ' ' `` 13433 116 38 Wenn Wenn NNP 13433 116 39 dass dass NN 13433 116 40 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 116 41 versprochen versprochen VBZ 13433 116 42 hat hat NN 13433 116 43 ' ' '' 13433 116 44 [ [ -LRB- 13433 116 45 _ _ NNP 13433 116 46 has have VBZ 13433 116 47 promised promise VBN 13433 116 48 _ _ NNP 13433 116 49 ] ] -RRB- 13433 116 50 ' ' POS 13433 116 51 jedenfalls jedenfall NNS 13433 116 52 in in IN 13433 116 53 seinem seinem NNP 13433 116 54 gegen gegen NNP 13433 116 55 das das NNP 13433 116 56 Christenthum Christenthum NNP 13433 116 57 gerichteten gerichteten VBD 13433 116 58 und und RP 13433 116 59 von von NNP 13433 116 60 Origenes Origenes NNPS 13433 116 61 widerlegten widerlegten VBD 13433 116 62 Buche Buche NNP 13433 116 63 ) ) -RRB- 13433 116 64 noch noch NNP 13433 116 65 eine eine NN 13433 116 66 andere andere RB 13433 116 67 Schrift schrift JJ 13433 116 68 nach nach NN 13433 116 69 dieser dieser NN 13433 116 70 zu zu NNP 13433 116 71 verfassen verfassen NNP 13433 116 72 , , , 13433 116 73 worin worin NNP 13433 116 74 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 116 75 . . . 13433 116 76 ' ' '' 13433 117 1 ' ' `` 13433 117 2 Wenn wenn VB 13433 117 3 er er UH 13433 117 4 nun nun UH 13433 117 5 diese diese JJ 13433 117 6 zweite zweite VBP 13433 117 7 Schrift schrift JJ 13433 117 8 trotz trotz NN 13433 117 9 seines seine NNS 13433 117 10 Versprechens Versprechens NNP 13433 117 11 nicht nicht NNP 13433 117 12 geschrieben geschrieben NNP 13433 117 13 hat hat NN 13433 117 14 ' ' '' 13433 117 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 117 16 _ _ NNP 13433 117 17 has have VBZ 13433 117 18 not not RB 13433 117 19 written write VBN 13433 117 20 _ _ NNP 13433 117 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 117 22 , , , 13433 117 23 ' ' '' 13433 117 24 so so RB 13433 117 25 genügt genügt NNP 13433 117 26 es es NNP 13433 117 27 uns uns NNP 13433 117 28 mit mit NNP 13433 117 29 diesen diesen NNP 13433 117 30 acht acht NNP 13433 117 31 Büchern Büchern NNP 13433 117 32 auf auf NN 13433 117 33 seine seine NN 13433 117 34 Schrift Schrift NNP 13433 117 35 geantwortet geantwortet NN 13433 117 36 zu zu NNP 13433 117 37 haben haben NN 13433 117 38 . . . 13433 118 1 Wenn Wenn NNP 13433 118 2 er er UH 13433 118 3 aber aber NN 13433 118 4 auch auch NN 13433 118 5 jene jene NNP 13433 118 6 unternommen unternommen NNP 13433 118 7 und und NNP 13433 118 8 vollendet vollendet NN 13433 118 9 hat hat NN 13433 118 10 ' ' '' 13433 118 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 118 12 _ _ NNP 13433 118 13 has have VBZ 13433 118 14 undertaken undertake VBN 13433 118 15 and and CC 13433 118 16 completed complete VBN 13433 118 17 _ _ NNP 13433 118 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 118 19 , , , 13433 118 20 ' ' '' 13433 118 21 so so RB 13433 118 22 treib treib VB 13433 118 23 das das NNP 13433 118 24 Buch Buch NNP 13433 118 25 auf auf NN 13433 118 26 und und NN 13433 118 27 schicke schicke NNP 13433 118 28 es es UH 13433 118 29 , , , 13433 118 30 damit damit VB 13433 118 31 wir wir NNP 13433 118 32 auch auch JJ 13433 118 33 darauf darauf NN 13433 118 34 antworten antworten VBP 13433 118 35 , , , 13433 118 36 ' ' '' 13433 118 37 " " '' 13433 118 38 & & CC 13433 118 39 c. c. NNP 13433 118 40 [ [ -LRB- 13433 118 41 11:1 11:1 CD 13433 118 42 ] ] -RRB- 13433 118 43 Now now RB 13433 118 44 this this DT 13433 118 45 translation translation NN 13433 118 46 of of IN 13433 118 47 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 118 48 is be VBZ 13433 118 49 not not RB 13433 118 50 made make VBN 13433 118 51 carelessly carelessly RB 13433 118 52 , , , 13433 118 53 but but CC 13433 118 54 deliberately deliberately RB 13433 118 55 , , , 13433 118 56 for for IN 13433 118 57 the the DT 13433 118 58 express express JJ 13433 118 59 purpose purpose NN 13433 118 60 of of IN 13433 118 61 showing show VBG 13433 118 62 the the DT 13433 118 63 actual actual JJ 13433 118 64 words word NNS 13433 118 65 of of IN 13433 118 66 Origen Origen NNP 13433 118 67 , , , 13433 118 68 and and CC 13433 118 69 correcting correct VBG 13433 118 70 the the DT 13433 118 71 version version NN 13433 118 72 of of IN 13433 118 73 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 118 74 ; ; : 13433 118 75 and and CC 13433 118 76 he -PRON- PRP 13433 118 77 insists insist VBZ 13433 118 78 upon upon IN 13433 118 79 these these DT 13433 118 80 tenses tense NNS 13433 118 81 not not RB 13433 118 82 only only RB 13433 118 83 by by IN 13433 118 84 referring refer VBG 13433 118 85 to to IN 13433 118 86 the the DT 13433 118 87 Greek Greek NNP 13433 118 88 of of IN 13433 118 89 these these DT 13433 118 90 special special JJ 13433 118 91 phrases phrase NNS 13433 118 92 , , , 13433 118 93 but but CC 13433 118 94 by by IN 13433 118 95 again again RB 13433 118 96 contrasting contrast VBG 13433 118 97 with with IN 13433 118 98 them -PRON- PRP 13433 118 99 the the DT 13433 118 100 paraphrase paraphrase NN 13433 118 101 of of IN 13433 118 102 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 118 103 . . . 13433 119 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 119 2 11:2 11:2 CD 13433 119 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 119 4 Whatever whatever WDT 13433 119 5 disregard disregard NN 13433 119 6 of of IN 13433 119 7 tenses tense NNS 13433 119 8 and and CC 13433 119 9 " " `` 13433 119 10 free free JJ 13433 119 11 handling handling NN 13433 119 12 " " '' 13433 119 13 of of IN 13433 119 14 Origen Origen NNP 13433 119 15 there there EX 13433 119 16 may may MD 13433 119 17 be be VB 13433 119 18 here here RB 13433 119 19 , , , 13433 119 20 therefore therefore RB 13433 119 21 , , , 13433 119 22 are be VBP 13433 119 23 due due JJ 13433 119 24 to to IN 13433 119 25 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 119 26 , , , 13433 119 27 who who WP 13433 119 28 may may MD 13433 119 29 be be VB 13433 119 30 considered consider VBN 13433 119 31 as as RB 13433 119 32 good good JJ 13433 119 33 a a DT 13433 119 34 scholar scholar NN 13433 119 35 as as IN 13433 119 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 119 37 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 119 38 , , , 13433 119 39 and and CC 13433 119 40 not not RB 13433 119 41 a a DT 13433 119 42 less less RBR 13433 119 43 zealous zealous JJ 13433 119 44 apologist apologist NN 13433 119 45 . . . 13433 120 1 Instead instead RB 13433 120 2 of of IN 13433 120 3 depending depend VBG 13433 120 4 on on IN 13433 120 5 the the DT 13433 120 6 " " `` 13433 120 7 strength strength NN 13433 120 8 of of IN 13433 120 9 the the DT 13433 120 10 passage passage NN 13433 120 11 so so RB 13433 120 12 translated translate VBD 13433 120 13 , , , 13433 120 14 " " '' 13433 120 15 however however RB 13433 120 16 , , , 13433 120 17 as as IN 13433 120 18 Canon Canon NNP 13433 120 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 120 20 represents represent VBZ 13433 120 21 , , , 13433 120 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 120 23 argument argument NN 13433 120 24 is be VBZ 13433 120 25 independent independent JJ 13433 120 26 of of IN 13433 120 27 this this DT 13433 120 28 or or CC 13433 120 29 any any DT 13433 120 30 other other JJ 13433 120 31 version version NN 13433 120 32 of of IN 13433 120 33 Origen Origen NNP 13433 120 34 's 's POS 13433 120 35 words word NNS 13433 120 36 ; ; : 13433 120 37 and and CC 13433 120 38 , , , 13433 120 39 in in IN 13433 120 40 fact fact NN 13433 120 41 , , , 13433 120 42 the the DT 13433 120 43 point point NN 13433 120 44 is be VBZ 13433 120 45 only only RB 13433 120 46 incidentally incidentally RB 13433 120 47 introduced introduce VBN 13433 120 48 , , , 13433 120 49 and and CC 13433 120 50 more more JJR 13433 120 51 as as IN 13433 120 52 the the DT 13433 120 53 view view NN 13433 120 54 of of IN 13433 120 55 others other NNS 13433 120 56 than than IN 13433 120 57 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 120 58 own own JJ 13433 120 59 . . . 13433 121 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 121 2 point point VBP 13433 121 3 out out RP 13433 121 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 121 5 12:1 12:1 CD 13433 121 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 121 7 that that IN 13433 121 8 Origen Origen NNP 13433 121 9 evidently evidently RB 13433 121 10 knows know VBZ 13433 121 11 nothing nothing NN 13433 121 12 of of IN 13433 121 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 121 14 adversary adversary NN 13433 121 15 : : : 13433 121 16 and and CC 13433 121 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 121 18 add add VBP 13433 121 19 that that IN 13433 121 20 " " `` 13433 121 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 121 22 is be VBZ 13433 121 23 almost almost RB 13433 121 24 impossible impossible JJ 13433 121 25 to to TO 13433 121 26 avoid avoid VB 13433 121 27 the the DT 13433 121 28 conviction conviction NN 13433 121 29 that that IN 13433 121 30 , , , 13433 121 31 during during IN 13433 121 32 the the DT 13433 121 33 time time NN 13433 121 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 121 35 was be VBD 13433 121 36 composing compose VBG 13433 121 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 121 38 work work NN 13433 121 39 , , , 13433 121 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 121 41 impressions impression NNS 13433 121 42 concerning concern VBG 13433 121 43 the the DT 13433 121 44 date date NN 13433 121 45 and and CC 13433 121 46 identity identity NN 13433 121 47 of of IN 13433 121 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 121 49 opponent opponent NN 13433 121 50 became become VBD 13433 121 51 considerably considerably RB 13433 121 52 modified modify VBN 13433 121 53 . . . 13433 121 54 " " '' 13433 122 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 122 2 then then RB 13433 122 3 proceed proceed VBP 13433 122 4 to to TO 13433 122 5 enumerate enumerate VB 13433 122 6 some some DT 13433 122 7 of of IN 13433 122 8 the the DT 13433 122 9 reasons reason NNS 13433 122 10 . . . 13433 123 1 In in IN 13433 123 2 the the DT 13433 123 3 earlier early JJR 13433 123 4 portion portion NN 13433 123 5 of of IN 13433 123 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 123 7 first first JJ 13433 123 8 book book NN 13433 123 9 ( ( -LRB- 13433 123 10 i. i. NNP 13433 124 1 8) 8) CD 13433 124 2 , , , 13433 124 3 Origen Origen NNP 13433 124 4 has have VBZ 13433 124 5 heard hear VBN 13433 124 6 that that IN 13433 124 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 124 8 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 124 9 is be VBZ 13433 124 10 the the DT 13433 124 11 Epicurean Epicurean NNP 13433 124 12 of of IN 13433 124 13 the the DT 13433 124 14 reign reign NN 13433 124 15 of of IN 13433 124 16 Hadrian Hadrian NNP 13433 124 17 and and CC 13433 124 18 later later RBR 13433 124 19 , , , 13433 124 20 but but CC 13433 124 21 a a DT 13433 124 22 little little JJ 13433 124 23 further far RBR 13433 124 24 on on IN 13433 124 25 ( ( -LRB- 13433 124 26 i. i. NN 13433 125 1 68 68 CD 13433 125 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 125 3 , , , 13433 125 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 125 5 confesses confess VBZ 13433 125 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 125 7 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 125 8 as as IN 13433 125 9 to to IN 13433 125 10 whether whether IN 13433 125 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 125 12 is be VBZ 13433 125 13 the the DT 13433 125 14 same same JJ 13433 125 15 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 125 16 who who WP 13433 125 17 wrote write VBD 13433 125 18 against against IN 13433 125 19 magic magic NN 13433 125 20 , , , 13433 125 21 which which WDT 13433 125 22 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 125 23 the the DT 13433 125 24 Epicurean Epicurean NNP 13433 125 25 actually actually RB 13433 125 26 did do VBD 13433 125 27 . . . 13433 126 1 In in IN 13433 126 2 the the DT 13433 126 3 fourth fourth JJ 13433 126 4 book book NN 13433 126 5 ( ( -LRB- 13433 126 6 iv iv UH 13433 126 7 . . . 13433 127 1 36 36 LS 13433 127 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 127 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 127 4 expresses express VBZ 13433 127 5 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 127 6 as as IN 13433 127 7 to to IN 13433 127 8 whether whether IN 13433 127 9 the the DT 13433 127 10 Epicurean Epicurean NNP 13433 127 11 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 127 12 had have VBD 13433 127 13 composed compose VBN 13433 127 14 the the DT 13433 127 15 work work NN 13433 127 16 against against IN 13433 127 17 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 127 18 which which WDT 13433 127 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 127 20 is be VBZ 13433 127 21 refuting refute VBG 13433 127 22 , , , 13433 127 23 and and CC 13433 127 24 at at IN 13433 127 25 the the DT 13433 127 26 close close NN 13433 127 27 of of IN 13433 127 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 127 29 treatise treatise NN 13433 127 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 127 31 treats treat VBZ 13433 127 32 him -PRON- PRP 13433 127 33 as as IN 13433 127 34 a a DT 13433 127 35 contemporary contemporary NN 13433 127 36 , , , 13433 127 37 for for IN 13433 127 38 , , , 13433 127 39 as as IN 13433 127 40 I -PRON- PRP 13433 127 41 again again RB 13433 127 42 mention mention VBP 13433 127 43 , , , 13433 127 44 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 127 45 and and CC 13433 127 46 others other NNS 13433 127 47 assert assert VBP 13433 127 48 , , , 13433 127 49 on on IN 13433 127 50 the the DT 13433 127 51 strength strength NN 13433 127 52 of of IN 13433 127 53 the the DT 13433 127 54 passage passage NN 13433 127 55 in in IN 13433 127 56 the the DT 13433 127 57 eighth eighth JJ 13433 127 58 book book NN 13433 127 59 and and CC 13433 127 60 from from IN 13433 127 61 other other JJ 13433 127 62 considerations consideration NNS 13433 127 63 , , , 13433 127 64 that that IN 13433 127 65 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 127 66 really really RB 13433 127 67 was be VBD 13433 127 68 a a DT 13433 127 69 contemporary contemporary NN 13433 127 70 of of IN 13433 127 71 Origen Origen NNP 13433 127 72 . . . 13433 128 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 128 2 proceed proceed VBP 13433 128 3 to to TO 13433 128 4 argue argue VB 13433 128 5 that that IN 13433 128 6 , , , 13433 128 7 even even RB 13433 128 8 if if IN 13433 128 9 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 128 10 were be VBD 13433 128 11 the the DT 13433 128 12 Epicurean epicurean JJ 13433 128 13 friend friend NN 13433 128 14 of of IN 13433 128 15 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 128 16 , , , 13433 128 17 there there EX 13433 128 18 could could MD 13433 128 19 be be VB 13433 128 20 no no DT 13433 128 21 ground ground NN 13433 128 22 for for IN 13433 128 23 assigning assigning NN 13433 128 24 to to IN 13433 128 25 him -PRON- PRP 13433 128 26 an an DT 13433 128 27 early early JJ 13433 128 28 date date NN 13433 128 29 ; ; : 13433 128 30 but but CC 13433 128 31 , , , 13433 128 32 on on IN 13433 128 33 the the DT 13433 128 34 contrary contrary NN 13433 128 35 , , , 13433 128 36 that that IN 13433 128 37 so so RB 13433 128 38 far far RB 13433 128 39 from from IN 13433 128 40 being be VBG 13433 128 41 an an DT 13433 128 42 Epicurean Epicurean NNP 13433 128 43 , , , 13433 128 44 the the DT 13433 128 45 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 128 46 attacked attack VBN 13433 128 47 by by IN 13433 128 48 Origen Origen NNP 13433 128 49 evidently evidently RB 13433 128 50 was be VBD 13433 128 51 a a DT 13433 128 52 Neo Neo NNP 13433 128 53 - - HYPH 13433 128 54 Platonist Platonist NNP 13433 128 55 . . . 13433 129 1 This this DT 13433 129 2 , , , 13433 129 3 and and CC 13433 129 4 the the DT 13433 129 5 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 129 6 that that WDT 13433 129 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 129 8 work work NN 13433 129 9 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 129 10 a a DT 13433 129 11 period period NN 13433 129 12 of of IN 13433 129 13 persecution persecution NN 13433 129 14 against against IN 13433 129 15 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 129 16 , , , 13433 129 17 leads lead VBZ 13433 129 18 to to IN 13433 129 19 the the DT 13433 129 20 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 129 21 , , , 13433 129 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 129 23 point point VBP 13433 129 24 out out RP 13433 129 25 , , , 13433 129 26 that that IN 13433 129 27 he -PRON- PRP 13433 129 28 must must MD 13433 129 29 be be VB 13433 129 30 dated date VBN 13433 129 31 about about IN 13433 129 32 the the DT 13433 129 33 beginning beginning NN 13433 129 34 of of IN 13433 129 35 the the DT 13433 129 36 third third JJ 13433 129 37 century century NN 13433 129 38 . . . 13433 130 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 130 2 argument argument NN 13433 130 3 , , , 13433 130 4 in in IN 13433 130 5 short short JJ 13433 130 6 , , , 13433 130 7 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 130 8 turns turn VBZ 13433 130 9 upon upon IN 13433 130 10 the the DT 13433 130 11 passage passage NN 13433 130 12 in in IN 13433 130 13 Origen Origen NNP 13433 130 14 at at RB 13433 130 15 all all RB 13433 130 16 , , , 13433 130 17 and and CC 13433 130 18 that that IN 13433 130 19 which which WDT 13433 130 20 renders render VBZ 13433 130 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 130 22 incapable incapable JJ 13433 130 23 of of IN 13433 130 24 being be VBG 13433 130 25 wrecked wreck VBN 13433 130 26 is be VBZ 13433 130 27 the the DT 13433 130 28 fact fact NN 13433 130 29 that that IN 13433 130 30 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 130 31 never never RB 13433 130 32 mentions mention VBZ 13433 130 33 the the DT 13433 130 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 130 35 , , , 13433 130 36 and and CC 13433 130 37 much much RB 13433 130 38 less less RBR 13433 130 39 adds add VBZ 13433 130 40 anything anything NN 13433 130 41 to to IN 13433 130 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 130 43 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 130 44 of of IN 13433 130 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 130 46 authors author NNS 13433 130 47 , , , 13433 130 48 which which WDT 13433 130 49 can can MD 13433 130 50 entitle entitle VB 13433 130 51 them -PRON- PRP 13433 130 52 to to IN 13433 130 53 greater great JJR 13433 130 54 credit credit NN 13433 130 55 as as IN 13433 130 56 witnesses witness NNS 13433 130 57 for for IN 13433 130 58 the the DT 13433 130 59 reality reality NN 13433 130 60 of of IN 13433 130 61 Divine Divine NNP 13433 130 62 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 130 63 . . . 13433 131 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 131 2 do do VBP 13433 131 3 not not RB 13433 131 4 intend intend VB 13433 131 5 to to TO 13433 131 6 bandy bandy VB 13433 131 7 many many JJ 13433 131 8 words word NNS 13433 131 9 with with IN 13433 131 10 Canon Canon NNP 13433 131 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 131 12 regarding regard VBG 13433 131 13 translations translation NNS 13433 131 14 . . . 13433 132 1 Nothing nothing NN 13433 132 2 is be VBZ 13433 132 3 so so RB 13433 132 4 easy easy JJ 13433 132 5 as as IN 13433 132 6 to to TO 13433 132 7 find find VB 13433 132 8 fault fault NN 13433 132 9 with with IN 13433 132 10 the the DT 13433 132 11 rendering rendering NN 13433 132 12 of of IN 13433 132 13 passages passage NNS 13433 132 14 from from IN 13433 132 15 another another DT 13433 132 16 language language NN 13433 132 17 , , , 13433 132 18 or or CC 13433 132 19 to to TO 13433 132 20 point point VB 13433 132 21 out out RP 13433 132 22 variations variation NNS 13433 132 23 in in IN 13433 132 24 tenses tense NNS 13433 132 25 and and CC 13433 132 26 expressions expression NNS 13433 132 27 , , , 13433 132 28 not not RB 13433 132 29 in in IN 13433 132 30 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 132 31 of of IN 13433 132 32 the the DT 13433 132 33 slightest slight JJS 13433 132 34 importance importance NN 13433 132 35 to to IN 13433 132 36 the the DT 13433 132 37 main main JJ 13433 132 38 issue issue NN 13433 132 39 , , , 13433 132 40 in in IN 13433 132 41 freely freely RB 13433 132 42 transferring transfer VBG 13433 132 43 the the DT 13433 132 44 spirit spirit NN 13433 132 45 of of IN 13433 132 46 sentences sentence NNS 13433 132 47 from from IN 13433 132 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 132 49 natural natural JJ 13433 132 50 context context NN 13433 132 51 to to IN 13433 132 52 an an DT 13433 132 53 isolated isolated JJ 13433 132 54 position position NN 13433 132 55 in in IN 13433 132 56 quotation quotation NN 13433 132 57 . . . 13433 133 1 Such such PDT 13433 133 2 a a DT 13433 133 3 personal personal JJ 13433 133 4 matter matter NN 13433 133 5 as as IN 13433 133 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 133 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 133 8 's 's POS 13433 133 9 general general JJ 13433 133 10 strictures stricture NNS 13433 133 11 , , , 13433 133 12 in in IN 13433 133 13 this this DT 13433 133 14 respect respect NN 13433 133 15 , , , 13433 133 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 133 17 feel feel VBP 13433 133 18 can can MD 13433 133 19 not not RB 13433 133 20 interest interest VB 13433 133 21 the the DT 13433 133 22 readers reader NNS 13433 133 23 of of IN 13433 133 24 this this DT 13433 133 25 Review Review NNP 13433 133 26 . . . 13433 134 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 134 2 am be VBP 13433 134 3 quite quite RB 13433 134 4 ready ready JJ 13433 134 5 to to TO 13433 134 6 accept accept VB 13433 134 7 correction correction NN 13433 134 8 even even RB 13433 134 9 from from IN 13433 134 10 an an DT 13433 134 11 opponent opponent NN 13433 134 12 where where WRB 13433 134 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 134 14 am be VBP 13433 134 15 wrong wrong JJ 13433 134 16 , , , 13433 134 17 but but CC 13433 134 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 134 19 am be VBP 13433 134 20 quite quite RB 13433 134 21 content content JJ 13433 134 22 to to TO 13433 134 23 leave leave VB 13433 134 24 to to IN 13433 134 25 the the DT 13433 134 26 judgment judgment NN 13433 134 27 of of IN 13433 134 28 all all DT 13433 134 29 who who WP 13433 134 30 will will MD 13433 134 31 examine examine VB 13433 134 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 134 33 in in IN 13433 134 34 a a DT 13433 134 35 fair fair JJ 13433 134 36 spirit spirit NN 13433 134 37 the the DT 13433 134 38 voluminous voluminous JJ 13433 134 39 quotations quotation NNS 13433 134 40 in in IN 13433 134 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 134 42 work work NN 13433 134 43 . . . 13433 135 1 The the DT 13433 135 2 ' ' `` 13433 135 3 higher high JJR 13433 135 4 criticism criticism NN 13433 135 5 , , , 13433 135 6 ' ' '' 13433 135 7 in in IN 13433 135 8 which which WDT 13433 135 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 135 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 135 11 seems seem VBZ 13433 135 12 to to TO 13433 135 13 have have VB 13433 135 14 indulged indulge VBN 13433 135 15 in in IN 13433 135 16 this this DT 13433 135 17 article article NN 13433 135 18 , , , 13433 135 19 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 135 20 rises rise VBZ 13433 135 21 above above IN 13433 135 22 the the DT 13433 135 23 correction correction NN 13433 135 24 of of IN 13433 135 25 an an DT 13433 135 26 exercise exercise NN 13433 135 27 or or CC 13433 135 28 the the DT 13433 135 29 conjugation conjugation NN 13433 135 30 of of IN 13433 135 31 a a DT 13433 135 32 verb verb NN 13433 135 33 . . . 13433 136 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 136 2 13:1 13:1 CD 13433 136 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 136 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 136 5 am be VBP 13433 136 6 extremely extremely RB 13433 136 7 obliged oblige VBN 13433 136 8 to to IN 13433 136 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 136 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 136 11 for for IN 13433 136 12 pointing point VBG 13433 136 13 out out RP 13433 136 14 two two CD 13433 136 15 clerical clerical JJ 13433 136 16 errors error NNS 13433 136 17 which which WDT 13433 136 18 had have VBD 13433 136 19 escaped escape VBN 13433 136 20 me -PRON- PRP 13433 136 21 , , , 13433 136 22 but but CC 13433 136 23 which which WDT 13433 136 24 have have VBP 13433 136 25 been be VBN 13433 136 26 discovered discover VBN 13433 136 27 and and CC 13433 136 28 magnified magnify VBN 13433 136 29 by by IN 13433 136 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 136 31 microscopic microscopic JJ 13433 136 32 criticism criticism NN 13433 136 33 , , , 13433 136 34 and and CC 13433 136 35 thrown throw VBN 13433 136 36 at at IN 13433 136 37 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 136 38 head head NN 13433 136 39 by by IN 13433 136 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 136 41 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 136 42 zeal zeal NN 13433 136 43 . . . 13433 137 1 The the DT 13433 137 2 first first JJ 13433 137 3 is be VBZ 13433 137 4 in in IN 13433 137 5 reference reference NN 13433 137 6 to to IN 13433 137 7 what what WP 13433 137 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 137 9 describes describe VBZ 13433 137 10 as as IN 13433 137 11 " " `` 13433 137 12 a a DT 13433 137 13 highly highly RB 13433 137 14 important important JJ 13433 137 15 question question NN 13433 137 16 of of IN 13433 137 17 Biblical biblical JJ 13433 137 18 criticism criticism NN 13433 137 19 . . . 13433 137 20 " " '' 13433 138 1 In in IN 13433 138 2 speaking speak VBG 13433 138 3 , , , 13433 138 4 _ _ NNP 13433 138 5 en en NNP 13433 138 6 passant passant NN 13433 138 7 _ _ NNP 13433 138 8 , , , 13433 138 9 of of IN 13433 138 10 a a DT 13433 138 11 passage passage NN 13433 138 12 in in IN 13433 138 13 John John NNP 13433 138 14 v. v. CC 13433 138 15 3 3 CD 13433 138 16 , , , 13433 138 17 4 4 CD 13433 138 18 , , , 13433 138 19 in in IN 13433 138 20 connection connection NN 13433 138 21 with with IN 13433 138 22 the the DT 13433 138 23 " " `` 13433 138 24 Age Age NNP 13433 138 25 of of IN 13433 138 26 Miracles Miracles NNPS 13433 138 27 , , , 13433 138 28 " " '' 13433 138 29 the the DT 13433 138 30 words word NNS 13433 138 31 " " `` 13433 138 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 138 33 is be VBZ 13433 138 34 argued argue VBN 13433 138 35 that that IN 13433 138 36 " " `` 13433 138 37 were be VBD 13433 138 38 accidentally accidentally RB 13433 138 39 omitted omit VBN 13433 138 40 from from IN 13433 138 41 vol vol NNP 13433 138 42 . . . 13433 139 1 i. i. NNP 13433 139 2 p. p. NN 13433 139 3 113 113 CD 13433 139 4 , , , 13433 139 5 line line NN 13433 139 6 19 19 CD 13433 139 7 , , , 13433 139 8 and and CC 13433 139 9 the the DT 13433 139 10 sentence sentence NN 13433 139 11 should should MD 13433 139 12 read read VB 13433 139 13 , , , 13433 139 14 " " `` 13433 139 15 and and CC 13433 139 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 139 17 is be VBZ 13433 139 18 argued argue VBN 13433 139 19 that that IN 13433 139 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 139 21 was be VBD 13433 139 22 probably probably RB 13433 139 23 a a DT 13433 139 24 later later JJ 13433 139 25 interpolation interpolation NN 13433 139 26 . . . 13433 139 27 " " '' 13433 140 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 140 2 14:1 14:1 CD 13433 140 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 140 4 In in IN 13433 140 5 vol vol NNP 13433 140 6 . . . 13433 141 1 ii ii LS 13433 141 2 . . . 13433 142 1 p. p. NN 13433 142 2 420 420 CD 13433 142 3 , , , 13433 142 4 after after IN 13433 142 5 again again RB 13433 142 6 mentioning mention VBG 13433 142 7 the the DT 13433 142 8 rejection rejection NN 13433 142 9 of of IN 13433 142 10 the the DT 13433 142 11 passage passage NN 13433 142 12 , , , 13433 142 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 142 14 proceed proceed VBP 13433 142 15 to to TO 13433 142 16 state state VB 13433 142 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 142 18 own own JJ 13433 142 19 personal personal JJ 13433 142 20 belief belief NN 13433 142 21 that that IN 13433 142 22 the the DT 13433 142 23 words word NNS 13433 142 24 must must MD 13433 142 25 have have VB 13433 142 26 Originally originally RB 13433 142 27 stood stand VBN 13433 142 28 in in IN 13433 142 29 the the DT 13433 142 30 text text NN 13433 142 31 , , , 13433 142 32 because because IN 13433 142 33 v. v. IN 13433 142 34 7 7 CD 13433 142 35 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 142 36 the the DT 13433 142 37 existence existence NN 13433 142 38 of of IN 13433 142 39 such such PDT 13433 142 40 a a DT 13433 142 41 context context NN 13433 142 42 . . . 13433 143 1 The the DT 13433 143 2 second second JJ 13433 143 3 error error NN 13433 143 4 is be VBZ 13433 143 5 in in IN 13433 143 6 vol vol NNP 13433 143 7 . . . 13433 144 1 ii ii LS 13433 144 2 . . . 13433 145 1 p. p. NN 13433 145 2 423 423 CD 13433 145 3 , , , 13433 145 4 line line NN 13433 145 5 24 24 CD 13433 145 6 , , , 13433 145 7 in in IN 13433 145 8 which which WDT 13433 145 9 " " `` 13433 145 10 only only RB 13433 145 11 " " '' 13433 145 12 has have VBZ 13433 145 13 been be VBN 13433 145 14 substituted substitute VBN 13433 145 15 for for IN 13433 145 16 " " `` 13433 145 17 never never RB 13433 145 18 " " '' 13433 145 19 in in IN 13433 145 20 deciphering decipher VBG 13433 145 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 145 22 MS MS NNP 13433 145 23 . . . 13433 146 1 Since since IN 13433 146 2 this this DT 13433 146 3 is be VBZ 13433 146 4 such such PDT 13433 146 5 a a DT 13433 146 6 _ _ NNP 13433 146 7 common common JJ 13433 146 8 - - HYPH 13433 146 9 place place NN 13433 146 10 _ _ NNP 13433 146 11 of of IN 13433 146 12 " " `` 13433 146 13 apologists apologist NNS 13433 146 14 , , , 13433 146 15 " " '' 13433 146 16 as as IN 13433 146 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 146 18 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 146 19 points point VBZ 13433 146 20 out out RP 13433 146 21 , , , 13433 146 22 surely surely RB 13433 146 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 146 24 might may MD 13433 146 25 have have VB 13433 146 26 put put VBN 13433 146 27 a a DT 13433 146 28 courteous courteous JJ 13433 146 29 construction construction NN 13433 146 30 upon upon IN 13433 146 31 the the DT 13433 146 32 error error NN 13433 146 33 , , , 13433 146 34 instead instead RB 13433 146 35 of of IN 13433 146 36 venting vent VBG 13433 146 37 upon upon IN 13433 146 38 me -PRON- PRP 13433 146 39 so so RB 13433 146 40 much much JJ 13433 146 41 righteous righteous JJ 13433 146 42 indignation indignation NN 13433 146 43 . . . 13433 147 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 147 2 can can MD 13433 147 3 assure assure VB 13433 147 4 him -PRON- PRP 13433 147 5 that that IN 13433 147 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 147 7 do do VBP 13433 147 8 not not RB 13433 147 9 in in IN 13433 147 10 the the DT 13433 147 11 slightest slight JJS 13433 147 12 degree degree NN 13433 147 13 grudge grudge NN 13433 147 14 him -PRON- PRP 13433 147 15 the the DT 13433 147 16 full full JJ 13433 147 17 benefit benefit NN 13433 147 18 of of IN 13433 147 19 the the DT 13433 147 20 argument argument NN 13433 147 21 that that IN 13433 147 22 the the DT 13433 147 23 fourth fourth JJ 13433 147 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 147 25 never never RB 13433 147 26 once once RB 13433 147 27 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 13433 147 28 John John NNP 13433 147 29 the the DT 13433 147 30 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 147 31 from from IN 13433 147 32 the the DT 13433 147 33 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 147 34 John John NNP 13433 147 35 by by IN 13433 147 36 the the DT 13433 147 37 addition addition NN 13433 147 38 [ [ -LRB- 13433 147 39 Greek Greek NNP 13433 147 40 : : : 13433 147 41 ho ho NNP 13433 147 42 Baptistês Baptistês NNP 13433 147 43 ] ] -RRB- 13433 147 44 . . . 13433 148 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 148 2 15:1 15:1 CD 13433 148 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 148 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 148 5 turn turn VBP 13433 148 6 , , , 13433 148 7 however however RB 13433 148 8 , , , 13433 148 9 to to IN 13433 148 10 a a DT 13433 148 11 more more RBR 13433 148 12 important important JJ 13433 148 13 matter matter NN 13433 148 14 . . . 13433 149 1 Canon Canon NNP 13433 149 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 149 3 attacks attack VBZ 13433 149 4 me -PRON- PRP 13433 149 5 in in IN 13433 149 6 no no DT 13433 149 7 measured measured JJ 13433 149 8 terms term NNS 13433 149 9 for for IN 13433 149 10 a a DT 13433 149 11 criticism criticism NN 13433 149 12 upon upon IN 13433 149 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 149 14 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 149 15 's 's POS 13433 149 16 mode mode NN 13433 149 17 of of IN 13433 149 18 dealing deal VBG 13433 149 19 with with IN 13433 149 20 a a DT 13433 149 21 piece piece NN 13433 149 22 of of IN 13433 149 23 information information NN 13433 149 24 regarding regard VBG 13433 149 25 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 149 26 . . . 13433 150 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 150 2 says-- says-- VBP 13433 150 3 " " `` 13433 150 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 150 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 150 6 writes write VBZ 13433 150 7 of of IN 13433 150 8 Basilides basilide NNS 13433 150 9 as as IN 13433 150 10 follows:-- follows:-- `` 13433 150 11 " " `` 13433 150 12 ' ' `` 13433 150 13 At at IN 13433 150 14 the the DT 13433 150 15 same same JJ 13433 150 16 time time NN 13433 150 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 150 18 appealed appeal VBD 13433 150 19 to to IN 13433 150 20 the the DT 13433 150 21 authority authority NN 13433 150 22 of of IN 13433 150 23 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 150 24 , , , 13433 150 25 who who WP 13433 150 26 , , , 13433 150 27 as as RB 13433 150 28 well well RB 13433 150 29 as as IN 13433 150 30 St. St. NNP 13433 150 31 Mark Mark NNP 13433 150 32 , , , 13433 150 33 was be VBD 13433 150 34 " " `` 13433 150 35 an an DT 13433 150 36 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 150 37 of of IN 13433 150 38 St. St. NNP 13433 151 1 Peter Peter NNP 13433 151 2 . . . 13433 151 3 " " `` 13433 151 4 ' ' '' 13433 152 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 152 2 ' ' `` 13433 152 3 Canon Canon NNP 13433 152 4 , , , 13433 152 5 ' ' '' 13433 152 6 p. p. NN 13433 152 7 264 264 CD 13433 152 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 152 9 " " `` 13433 152 10 The the DT 13433 152 11 inverted invert VBN 13433 152 12 commas comma NNS 13433 152 13 are be VBP 13433 152 14 given give VBN 13433 152 15 here here RB 13433 152 16 as as IN 13433 152 17 they -PRON- PRP 13433 152 18 appear appear VBP 13433 152 19 in in IN 13433 152 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 152 21 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 152 22 's 's POS 13433 152 23 book book NN 13433 152 24 . . . 13433 153 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 153 2 need nee MD 13433 153 3 hardly hardly RB 13433 153 4 be be VB 13433 153 5 said say VBN 13433 153 6 that that IN 13433 153 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 153 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 153 9 is be VBZ 13433 153 10 simply simply RB 13433 153 11 illustrating illustrate VBG 13433 153 12 the the DT 13433 153 13 statement statement NN 13433 153 14 of of IN 13433 153 15 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 153 16 that that IN 13433 153 17 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 153 18 was be VBD 13433 153 19 an an DT 13433 153 20 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 153 21 of of IN 13433 153 22 St. St. NNP 13433 153 23 Peter Peter NNP 13433 153 24 by by IN 13433 153 25 the the DT 13433 153 26 similar similar JJ 13433 153 27 statement statement NN 13433 153 28 of of IN 13433 153 29 Papias Papias NNP 13433 153 30 and and CC 13433 153 31 others other NNS 13433 153 32 that that IN 13433 153 33 St. St. NNP 13433 153 34 Mark Mark NNP 13433 153 35 was be VBD 13433 153 36 an an DT 13433 153 37 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 153 38 of of IN 13433 153 39 the the DT 13433 153 40 same same JJ 13433 153 41 apostle apostle NN 13433 153 42 -- -- : 13433 153 43 a a DT 13433 153 44 very very RB 13433 153 45 innocent innocent JJ 13433 153 46 piece piece NN 13433 153 47 of of IN 13433 153 48 information information NN 13433 153 49 , , , 13433 153 50 one one PRP 13433 153 51 would would MD 13433 153 52 suppose suppose VB 13433 153 53 . . . 13433 154 1 On on IN 13433 154 2 this this DT 13433 154 3 passage passage NN 13433 154 4 , , , 13433 154 5 however however RB 13433 154 6 , , , 13433 154 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 154 8 author author NN 13433 154 9 remarks-- remarks-- CD 13433 154 10 " " '' 13433 154 11 ' ' `` 13433 154 12 Now now RB 13433 154 13 we -PRON- PRP 13433 154 14 have have VBP 13433 154 15 here here RB 13433 154 16 again again RB 13433 154 17 an an DT 13433 154 18 illustration illustration NN 13433 154 19 of of IN 13433 154 20 the the DT 13433 154 21 same same JJ 13433 154 22 misleading misleading JJ 13433 154 23 system system NN 13433 154 24 which which WDT 13433 154 25 we -PRON- PRP 13433 154 26 have have VBP 13433 154 27 already already RB 13433 154 28 condemned condemn VBN 13433 154 29 , , , 13433 154 30 and and CC 13433 154 31 shall shall MD 13433 154 32 further further RB 13433 154 33 refer refer VB 13433 154 34 to to IN 13433 154 35 , , , 13433 154 36 in in IN 13433 154 37 the the DT 13433 154 38 introduction introduction NN 13433 154 39 after after IN 13433 154 40 " " `` 13433 154 41 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 154 42 " " '' 13433 154 43 of of IN 13433 154 44 the the DT 13433 154 45 words word NNS 13433 154 46 " " `` 13433 154 47 _ _ NNP 13433 154 48 who who WP 13433 154 49 , , , 13433 154 50 as as RB 13433 154 51 well well RB 13433 154 52 as as IN 13433 154 53 St. St. NNP 13433 154 54 Mark Mark NNP 13433 154 55 , , , 13433 154 56 was be VBD 13433 154 57 _ _ NNP 13433 154 58 an an DT 13433 154 59 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 154 60 of of IN 13433 154 61 St. St. NNP 13433 155 1 Peter Peter NNP 13433 155 2 . . . 13433 155 3 " " '' 13433 156 1 The the DT 13433 156 2 words word NNS 13433 156 3 in in IN 13433 156 4 italics italic NNS 13433 156 5 are be VBP 13433 156 6 the the DT 13433 156 7 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 13433 156 8 addition addition NN 13433 156 9 of of IN 13433 156 10 Canon Canon NNP 13433 156 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 156 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 156 13 , , , 13433 156 14 and and CC 13433 156 15 can can MD 13433 156 16 only only RB 13433 156 17 have have VB 13433 156 18 been be VBN 13433 156 19 inserted insert VBN 13433 156 20 for for IN 13433 156 21 one one CD 13433 156 22 of of IN 13433 156 23 two two CD 13433 156 24 purposes--(1 purposes--(1 NNS 13433 156 25 ) ) -RRB- 13433 156 26 to to TO 13433 156 27 assert assert VB 13433 156 28 the the DT 13433 156 29 fact fact NN 13433 156 30 that that IN 13433 156 31 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 156 32 was be VBD 13433 156 33 actually actually RB 13433 156 34 an an DT 13433 156 35 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 156 36 of of IN 13433 156 37 Peter Peter NNP 13433 156 38 , , , 13433 156 39 as as IN 13433 156 40 tradition tradition NN 13433 156 41 represented represent VBD 13433 156 42 Mark Mark NNP 13433 156 43 to to TO 13433 156 44 be be VB 13433 156 45 ; ; , 13433 156 46 or or CC 13433 156 47 ( ( -LRB- 13433 156 48 2 2 LS 13433 156 49 ) ) -RRB- 13433 156 50 to to TO 13433 156 51 insinuate insinuate VB 13433 156 52 to to IN 13433 156 53 unlearned unlearned JJ 13433 156 54 readers reader NNS 13433 156 55 that that IN 13433 156 56 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 156 57 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 156 58 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 13433 156 59 Mark Mark NNP 13433 156 60 as as RB 13433 156 61 well well RB 13433 156 62 as as IN 13433 156 63 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 156 64 as as IN 13433 156 65 the the DT 13433 156 66 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 156 67 of of IN 13433 156 68 Peter Peter NNP 13433 156 69 . . . 13433 157 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 157 2 can can MD 13433 157 3 hardly hardly RB 13433 157 4 suppose suppose VB 13433 157 5 the the DT 13433 157 6 first first JJ 13433 157 7 to to TO 13433 157 8 have have VB 13433 157 9 been be VBN 13433 157 10 the the DT 13433 157 11 intention intention NN 13433 157 12 , , , 13433 157 13 and and CC 13433 157 14 we -PRON- PRP 13433 157 15 regret regret VBP 13433 157 16 to to TO 13433 157 17 be be VB 13433 157 18 forced force VBN 13433 157 19 back back RB 13433 157 20 upon upon IN 13433 157 21 the the DT 13433 157 22 second second JJ 13433 157 23 , , , 13433 157 24 and and CC 13433 157 25 infer infer VB 13433 157 26 that that IN 13433 157 27 the the DT 13433 157 28 temptation temptation NN 13433 157 29 to to TO 13433 157 30 weaken weaken VB 13433 157 31 the the DT 13433 157 32 inferences inference NNS 13433 157 33 from from IN 13433 157 34 the the DT 13433 157 35 appeal appeal NN 13433 157 36 of of IN 13433 157 37 Basilides basilide NNS 13433 157 38 to to IN 13433 157 39 the the DT 13433 157 40 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 13433 157 41 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 157 42 , , , 13433 157 43 by by IN 13433 157 44 coupling couple VBG 13433 157 45 with with IN 13433 157 46 it -PRON- PRP 13433 157 47 the the DT 13433 157 48 allusion allusion NN 13433 157 49 to to IN 13433 157 50 Mark Mark NNP 13433 157 51 , , , 13433 157 52 was be VBD 13433 157 53 , , , 13433 157 54 unconsciously unconsciously RB 13433 157 55 , , , 13433 157 56 no no RB 13433 157 57 doubt doubt RB 13433 157 58 , , , 13433 157 59 too too RB 13433 157 60 strong strong JJ 13433 157 61 for for IN 13433 157 62 the the DT 13433 157 63 apologist apologist NN 13433 157 64 . . . 13433 157 65 ' ' '' 13433 158 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 158 2 ' ' `` 13433 158 3 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 158 4 ' ' '' 13433 159 1 i. i. NNP 13433 159 2 p. p. NN 13433 159 3 459 459 CD 13433 159 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 159 5 " " `` 13433 159 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 159 7 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 159 8 's 's POS 13433 159 9 honour honour NN 13433 159 10 may may MD 13433 159 11 safely safely RB 13433 159 12 be be VB 13433 159 13 left leave VBN 13433 159 14 to to TO 13433 159 15 take take VB 13433 159 16 care care NN 13433 159 17 of of IN 13433 159 18 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 159 19 . . . 13433 160 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 160 2 stands stand VBZ 13433 160 3 far far RB 13433 160 4 too too RB 13433 160 5 high high JJ 13433 160 6 to to TO 13433 160 7 be be VB 13433 160 8 touched touch VBN 13433 160 9 by by IN 13433 160 10 insinuations insinuation NNS 13433 160 11 like like IN 13433 160 12 these these DT 13433 160 13 . . . 13433 161 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 161 2 only only RB 13433 161 3 call call VBP 13433 161 4 attention attention NN 13433 161 5 to to IN 13433 161 6 the the DT 13433 161 7 fact fact NN 13433 161 8 that that IN 13433 161 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 161 10 author author NN 13433 161 11 has have VBZ 13433 161 12 removed remove VBN 13433 161 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 161 14 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 161 15 's 's POS 13433 161 16 inverted invert VBN 13433 161 17 commas comma NNS 13433 161 18 , , , 13433 161 19 and and CC 13433 161 20 then then RB 13433 161 21 founded found VBD 13433 161 22 on on IN 13433 161 23 the the DT 13433 161 24 passage passage NN 13433 161 25 so so RB 13433 161 26 manipulated manipulate VBD 13433 161 27 a a DT 13433 161 28 charge charge NN 13433 161 29 of of IN 13433 161 30 unfair unfair JJ 13433 161 31 dealing dealing NN 13433 161 32 , , , 13433 161 33 which which WDT 13433 161 34 could could MD 13433 161 35 only only RB 13433 161 36 be be VB 13433 161 37 sustained sustain VBN 13433 161 38 in in IN 13433 161 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 161 40 absence absence NN 13433 161 41 , , , 13433 161 42 and and CC 13433 161 43 which which WDT 13433 161 44 even even RB 13433 161 45 then then RB 13433 161 46 no no DT 13433 161 47 one one NN 13433 161 48 but but IN 13433 161 49 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 161 50 would would MD 13433 161 51 have have VB 13433 161 52 thought think VBD 13433 161 53 of of IN 13433 161 54 . . . 13433 161 55 " " '' 13433 162 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 162 2 16:1 16:1 CD 13433 162 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 162 4 In in IN 13433 162 5 order order NN 13433 162 6 to to TO 13433 162 7 make make VB 13433 162 8 this this DT 13433 162 9 matter matter NN 13433 162 10 clear clear JJ 13433 162 11 , , , 13433 162 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 162 13 must must MD 13433 162 14 venture venture VB 13433 162 15 more more RBR 13433 162 16 fully fully RB 13433 162 17 to to TO 13433 162 18 quote quote VB 13433 162 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 162 20 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 162 21 's 's POS 13433 162 22 statements statement NNS 13433 162 23 regarding regard VBG 13433 162 24 Basilides basilide NNS 13433 162 25 . . . 13433 163 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 163 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 163 3 says say VBZ 13433 163 4 : : : 13433 163 5 " " `` 13433 163 6 Since since IN 13433 163 7 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 163 8 lived live VBD 13433 163 9 on on IN 13433 163 10 the the DT 13433 163 11 verge verge NN 13433 163 12 of of IN 13433 163 13 the the DT 13433 163 14 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 163 15 times time NNS 13433 163 16 , , , 13433 163 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 163 18 is be VBZ 13433 163 19 not not RB 13433 163 20 surprising surprising JJ 13433 163 21 that that IN 13433 163 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 163 23 made make VBD 13433 163 24 use use NN 13433 163 25 of of IN 13433 163 26 other other JJ 13433 163 27 sources source NNS 13433 163 28 of of IN 13433 163 29 Christian christian JJ 13433 163 30 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 163 31 besides besides IN 13433 163 32 the the DT 13433 163 33 canonical canonical JJ 13433 163 34 books book NNS 13433 163 35 . . . 13433 164 1 The the DT 13433 164 2 belief belief NN 13433 164 3 in in IN 13433 164 4 Divine Divine NNP 13433 164 5 Inspiration Inspiration NNP 13433 164 6 was be VBD 13433 164 7 still still RB 13433 164 8 fresh fresh JJ 13433 164 9 and and CC 13433 164 10 real real JJ 13433 164 11 ; ; : 13433 164 12 and and CC 13433 164 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 164 14 relates relate VBZ 13433 164 15 that that IN 13433 164 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 164 17 set set VBD 13433 164 18 up up RP 13433 164 19 imaginary imaginary JJ 13433 164 20 prophets prophet NNS 13433 164 21 , , , 13433 164 22 Barcabbas Barcabbas NNP 13433 164 23 and and CC 13433 164 24 Barcoph Barcoph NNP 13433 164 25 ( ( -LRB- 13433 164 26 Parchor)--'names parchor)--'name NNS 13433 164 27 to to TO 13433 164 28 strike strike VB 13433 164 29 terror terror NN 13433 164 30 into into IN 13433 164 31 the the DT 13433 164 32 superstitious'--by superstitious'--by NNP 13433 164 33 whose whose WP$ 13433 164 34 writings writing NNS 13433 164 35 he -PRON- PRP 13433 164 36 supported support VBD 13433 164 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 164 38 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 164 39 views view NNS 13433 164 40 . . . 13433 165 1 At at IN 13433 165 2 the the DT 13433 165 3 same same JJ 13433 165 4 time time NN 13433 165 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 165 6 appealed appeal VBD 13433 165 7 to to IN 13433 165 8 the the DT 13433 165 9 authority authority NN 13433 165 10 of of IN 13433 165 11 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 165 12 , , , 13433 165 13 who who WP 13433 165 14 , , , 13433 165 15 as as RB 13433 165 16 well well RB 13433 165 17 as as IN 13433 165 18 St. St. NNP 13433 165 19 Mark Mark NNP 13433 165 20 , , , 13433 165 21 was be VBD 13433 165 22 ' ' '' 13433 165 23 an an DT 13433 165 24 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 165 25 of of IN 13433 165 26 St. St. NNP 13433 165 27 Peter Peter NNP 13433 165 28 ; ; : 13433 165 29 ' ' '' 13433 165 30 [ [ -LRB- 13433 165 31 16:2 16:2 CD 13433 165 32 ] ] -RRB- 13433 165 33 and and CC 13433 165 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 165 35 also also RB 13433 165 36 made make VBD 13433 165 37 use use NN 13433 165 38 of of IN 13433 165 39 certain certain JJ 13433 165 40 ' ' '' 13433 165 41 Traditions Traditions NNPS 13433 165 42 of of IN 13433 165 43 Matthias Matthias NNP 13433 165 44 , , , 13433 165 45 ' ' '' 13433 165 46 which which WDT 13433 165 47 claimed claim VBD 13433 165 48 to to TO 13433 165 49 be be VB 13433 165 50 grounded ground VBN 13433 165 51 on on IN 13433 165 52 ' ' `` 13433 165 53 private private JJ 13433 165 54 intercourse intercourse NN 13433 165 55 with with IN 13433 165 56 the the DT 13433 165 57 Saviour Saviour NNP 13433 165 58 . . . 13433 165 59 ' ' '' 13433 166 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 166 2 16:3 16:3 CD 13433 166 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 166 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 166 5 appears appear VBZ 13433 166 6 , , , 13433 166 7 moreover moreover RB 13433 166 8 , , , 13433 166 9 that that IN 13433 166 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 166 11 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 166 12 published publish VBD 13433 166 13 a a DT 13433 166 14 gospel gospel NN 13433 166 15 -- -- : 13433 166 16 a a DT 13433 166 17 ' ' `` 13433 166 18 Life Life NNP 13433 166 19 of of IN 13433 166 20 Christ Christ NNP 13433 166 21 , , , 13433 166 22 ' ' '' 13433 166 23 as as IN 13433 166 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 166 25 would would MD 13433 166 26 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 166 27 be be VB 13433 166 28 called call VBN 13433 166 29 in in IN 13433 166 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 166 31 days day NNS 13433 166 32 , , , 13433 166 33 or or CC 13433 166 34 ' ' `` 13433 166 35 The the DT 13433 166 36 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 13433 166 37 of of IN 13433 166 38 Christianity'--but Christianity'--but NNP 13433 166 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 166 40 admitted admit VBD 13433 166 41 the the DT 13433 166 42 historic historic JJ 13433 166 43 truth truth NN 13433 166 44 of of IN 13433 166 45 all all PDT 13433 166 46 the the DT 13433 166 47 facts fact NNS 13433 166 48 contained contain VBN 13433 166 49 in in IN 13433 166 50 the the DT 13433 166 51 canonical canonical JJ 13433 166 52 gospels gospel NNS 13433 166 53 , , , 13433 166 54 and and CC 13433 166 55 used use VBD 13433 166 56 them -PRON- PRP 13433 166 57 as as IN 13433 166 58 Scripture scripture NN 13433 166 59 . . . 13433 167 1 For for IN 13433 167 2 , , , 13433 167 3 in in IN 13433 167 4 spite spite NN 13433 167 5 of of IN 13433 167 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 167 7 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 167 8 opinions opinion NNS 13433 167 9 , , , 13433 167 10 the the DT 13433 167 11 testimony testimony NN 13433 167 12 of of IN 13433 167 13 Basilides basilide NNS 13433 167 14 to to IN 13433 167 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 167 16 ' ' `` 13433 167 17 acknowledged acknowledged JJ 13433 167 18 ' ' '' 13433 167 19 books book NNS 13433 167 20 is be VBZ 13433 167 21 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 13433 167 22 and and CC 13433 167 23 clear clear JJ 13433 167 24 . . . 13433 168 1 In in IN 13433 168 2 the the DT 13433 168 3 few few JJ 13433 168 4 pages page NNS 13433 168 5 of of IN 13433 168 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 168 7 writings writing NNS 13433 168 8 which which WDT 13433 168 9 remain remain VBP 13433 168 10 , , , 13433 168 11 there there EX 13433 168 12 are be VBP 13433 168 13 certain certain JJ 13433 168 14 references reference NNS 13433 168 15 to to IN 13433 168 16 the the DT 13433 168 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 168 18 of of IN 13433 168 19 St. St. NNP 13433 168 20 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 168 21 , , , 13433 168 22 St. St. NNP 13433 168 23 Luke Luke NNP 13433 168 24 , , , 13433 168 25 and and CC 13433 168 26 St. St. NNP 13433 168 27 John John NNP 13433 168 28 , , , 13433 168 29 & & CC 13433 168 30 c. c. NNP 13433 168 31 " " '' 13433 168 32 And and CC 13433 168 33 in in IN 13433 168 34 a a DT 13433 168 35 note note NN 13433 168 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 168 37 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 168 38 adds add VBZ 13433 168 39 , , , 13433 168 40 " " `` 13433 168 41 The the DT 13433 168 42 following follow VBG 13433 168 43 examples example NNS 13433 168 44 will will MD 13433 168 45 be be VB 13433 168 46 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 168 47 to to TO 13433 168 48 show show VB 13433 168 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 168 50 mode mode NN 13433 168 51 of of IN 13433 168 52 quotation quotation NN 13433 168 53 , , , 13433 168 54 & & CC 13433 168 55 c. c. NNP 13433 168 56 " " '' 13433 168 57 [ [ -LRB- 13433 168 58 17:1 17:1 CD 13433 168 59 ] ] -RRB- 13433 168 60 Not not RB 13433 168 61 a a DT 13433 168 62 word word NN 13433 168 63 of of IN 13433 168 64 qualification qualification NN 13433 168 65 or or CC 13433 168 66 doubt doubt NN 13433 168 67 is be VBZ 13433 168 68 added add VBN 13433 168 69 to to IN 13433 168 70 these these DT 13433 168 71 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 168 72 statements statement NNS 13433 168 73 , , , 13433 168 74 for for IN 13433 168 75 a a DT 13433 168 76 full full JJ 13433 168 77 criticism criticism NN 13433 168 78 of of IN 13433 168 79 which which WDT 13433 168 80 I -PRON- PRP 13433 168 81 must must MD 13433 168 82 beg beg VB 13433 168 83 the the DT 13433 168 84 reader reader NN 13433 168 85 to to TO 13433 168 86 be be VB 13433 168 87 good good JJ 13433 168 88 enough enough RB 13433 168 89 to to TO 13433 168 90 refer refer VB 13433 168 91 to to IN 13433 168 92 _ _ NNP 13433 168 93 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 168 94 Religion Religion NNP 13433 168 95 _ _ NNP 13433 168 96 , , , 13433 168 97 ii ii NNP 13433 168 98 . . . 13433 169 1 pp pp NNP 13433 169 2 . . . 13433 170 1 41 41 CD 13433 170 2 - - SYM 13433 170 3 54 54 CD 13433 170 4 . . . 13433 171 1 Setting set VBG 13433 171 2 aside aside RB 13433 171 3 here here RB 13433 171 4 the the DT 13433 171 5 important important JJ 13433 171 6 question question NN 13433 171 7 as as IN 13433 171 8 to to IN 13433 171 9 what what WP 13433 171 10 the the DT 13433 171 11 " " `` 13433 171 12 gospel gospel NN 13433 171 13 " " '' 13433 171 14 of of IN 13433 171 15 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 171 16 -- -- : 13433 171 17 to to TO 13433 171 18 which which WDT 13433 171 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 171 20 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 171 21 gives give VBZ 13433 171 22 the the DT 13433 171 23 fanciful fanciful JJ 13433 171 24 names name NNS 13433 171 25 of of IN 13433 171 26 a a DT 13433 171 27 " " `` 13433 171 28 Life Life NNP 13433 171 29 of of IN 13433 171 30 Christ Christ NNP 13433 171 31 , , , 13433 171 32 " " '' 13433 171 33 or or CC 13433 171 34 " " `` 13433 171 35 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 13433 171 36 of of IN 13433 171 37 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 171 38 , , , 13433 171 39 " " '' 13433 171 40 without without IN 13433 171 41 a a DT 13433 171 42 shadow shadow NN 13433 171 43 of of IN 13433 171 44 evidence evidence NN 13433 171 45 -- -- : 13433 171 46 really really RB 13433 171 47 was be VBD 13433 171 48 , , , 13433 171 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 171 50 could could MD 13433 171 51 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 171 52 be be VB 13433 171 53 divined divine VBN 13433 171 54 , , , 13433 171 55 for for IN 13433 171 56 instance instance NN 13433 171 57 , , , 13433 171 58 that that IN 13433 171 59 the the DT 13433 171 60 statement statement NN 13433 171 61 that that IN 13433 171 62 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 171 63 " " `` 13433 171 64 admitted admit VBD 13433 171 65 the the DT 13433 171 66 historic historic JJ 13433 171 67 truth truth NN 13433 171 68 of of IN 13433 171 69 all all PDT 13433 171 70 the the DT 13433 171 71 facts fact NNS 13433 171 72 contained contain VBN 13433 171 73 in in IN 13433 171 74 the the DT 13433 171 75 canonical canonical JJ 13433 171 76 gospels gospel NNS 13433 171 77 " " '' 13433 171 78 rests rest VBZ 13433 171 79 solely solely RB 13433 171 80 upon upon IN 13433 171 81 a a DT 13433 171 82 sentence sentence NN 13433 171 83 in in IN 13433 171 84 the the DT 13433 171 85 work work NN 13433 171 86 attributed attribute VBN 13433 171 87 to to IN 13433 171 88 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 171 89 , , , 13433 171 90 to to IN 13433 171 91 the the DT 13433 171 92 effect effect NN 13433 171 93 that that IN 13433 171 94 , , , 13433 171 95 after after IN 13433 171 96 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 171 97 generation generation NN 13433 171 98 , , , 13433 171 99 all all DT 13433 171 100 things thing NNS 13433 171 101 regarding regard VBG 13433 171 102 the the DT 13433 171 103 Saviour Saviour NNP 13433 171 104 -- -- : 13433 171 105 according accord VBG 13433 171 106 to to IN 13433 171 107 the the DT 13433 171 108 _ _ NNP 13433 171 109 followers follower NNS 13433 171 110 _ _ NNP 13433 171 111 of of IN 13433 171 112 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 171 113 -- -- : 13433 171 114 occurred occur VBD 13433 171 115 in in IN 13433 171 116 the the DT 13433 171 117 same same JJ 13433 171 118 way way NN 13433 171 119 as as IN 13433 171 120 they -PRON- PRP 13433 171 121 are be VBP 13433 171 122 written write VBN 13433 171 123 in in IN 13433 171 124 the the DT 13433 171 125 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 171 126 . . . 13433 172 1 Again again RB 13433 172 2 , , , 13433 172 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 172 4 could could MD 13433 172 5 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 172 6 be be VB 13433 172 7 supposed suppose VBN 13433 172 8 by by IN 13433 172 9 an an DT 13433 172 10 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 172 11 reader reader NN 13433 172 12 that that IN 13433 172 13 the the DT 13433 172 14 assertion assertion NN 13433 172 15 that that IN 13433 172 16 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 172 17 used use VBD 13433 172 18 the the DT 13433 172 19 " " `` 13433 172 20 canonical canonical JJ 13433 172 21 gospels"--there gospels"--there NNP 13433 172 22 certainly certainly RB 13433 172 23 were be VBD 13433 172 24 no no DT 13433 172 25 " " `` 13433 172 26 canonical canonical JJ 13433 172 27 " " '' 13433 172 28 gospels gospel NNS 13433 172 29 in in IN 13433 172 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 31 day--"as day--"as NN 13433 172 32 Scripture Scripture NNP 13433 172 33 , , , 13433 172 34 " " '' 13433 172 35 that that IN 13433 172 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 37 testimony testimony NN 13433 172 38 to to IN 13433 172 39 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 40 ' ' `` 13433 172 41 acknowledged acknowledged JJ 13433 172 42 ' ' '' 13433 172 43 books book NNS 13433 172 44 is be VBZ 13433 172 45 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 13433 172 46 and and CC 13433 172 47 clear clear JJ 13433 172 48 , , , 13433 172 49 and and CC 13433 172 50 that that IN 13433 172 51 " " `` 13433 172 52 in in IN 13433 172 53 the the DT 13433 172 54 few few JJ 13433 172 55 pages page NNS 13433 172 56 of of IN 13433 172 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 58 writings writing NNS 13433 172 59 which which WDT 13433 172 60 remain remain VBP 13433 172 61 there there EX 13433 172 62 are be VBP 13433 172 63 certain certain JJ 13433 172 64 references reference NNS 13433 172 65 " " '' 13433 172 66 to to IN 13433 172 67 those those DT 13433 172 68 gospels gospel NNS 13433 172 69 , , , 13433 172 70 which which WDT 13433 172 71 show show VBP 13433 172 72 " " `` 13433 172 73 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 74 method method NN 13433 172 75 of of IN 13433 172 76 quotation quotation NN 13433 172 77 , , , 13433 172 78 " " '' 13433 172 79 is be VBZ 13433 172 80 not not RB 13433 172 81 based base VBN 13433 172 82 upon upon IN 13433 172 83 any any DT 13433 172 84 direct direct JJ 13433 172 85 extracts extract NNS 13433 172 86 from from IN 13433 172 87 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 172 88 writings writing NNS 13433 172 89 , , , 13433 172 90 but but CC 13433 172 91 solely solely RB 13433 172 92 upon upon IN 13433 172 93 passages passage NNS 13433 172 94 in in IN 13433 172 95 an an DT 13433 172 96 epitome epitome NN 13433 172 97 by by IN 13433 172 98 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 172 99 of of IN 13433 172 100 the the DT 13433 172 101 views view NNS 13433 172 102 of of IN 13433 172 103 the the DT 13433 172 104 school school NN 13433 172 105 of of IN 13433 172 106 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 172 107 , , , 13433 172 108 not not RB 13433 172 109 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 172 110 directly directly RB 13433 172 111 to to IN 13433 172 112 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 172 113 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 172 114 , , , 13433 172 115 but but CC 13433 172 116 introduced introduce VBN 13433 172 117 by by IN 13433 172 118 a a DT 13433 172 119 mere mere JJ 13433 172 120 indefinite indefinite NN 13433 172 121 [ [ -LRB- 13433 172 122 Greek greek JJ 13433 172 123 : : : 13433 172 124 phêsi phêsi NN 13433 172 125 ] ] -RRB- 13433 172 126 . . . 13433 173 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 173 2 17:2 17:2 CD 13433 173 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 173 4 Why why WRB 13433 173 5 , , , 13433 173 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 173 7 might may MD 13433 173 8 enquire enquire VB 13433 173 9 in in IN 13433 173 10 the the DT 13433 173 11 vein vein NN 13433 173 12 of of IN 13433 173 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 173 14 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 173 15 , , , 13433 173 16 is be VBZ 13433 173 17 not not RB 13433 173 18 a a DT 13433 173 19 syllable syllable NN 13433 173 20 said say VBN 13433 173 21 of of IN 13433 173 22 all all PDT 13433 173 23 this this DT 13433 173 24 , , , 13433 173 25 or or CC 13433 173 26 of of IN 13433 173 27 the the DT 13433 173 28 fact fact NN 13433 173 29 , , , 13433 173 30 which which WDT 13433 173 31 completes complete VBZ 13433 173 32 the the DT 13433 173 33 separation separation NN 13433 173 34 of of IN 13433 173 35 these these DT 13433 173 36 passages passage NNS 13433 173 37 from from IN 13433 173 38 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 173 39 , , , 13433 173 40 that that IN 13433 173 41 the the DT 13433 173 42 Gnosticism Gnosticism NNP 13433 173 43 described describe VBN 13433 173 44 by by IN 13433 173 45 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 173 46 is be VBZ 13433 173 47 not not RB 13433 173 48 that that DT 13433 173 49 of of IN 13433 173 50 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 173 51 , , , 13433 173 52 but but CC 13433 173 53 clearly clearly RB 13433 173 54 of of IN 13433 173 55 a a DT 13433 173 56 later later JJ 13433 173 57 type type NN 13433 173 58 ; ; : 13433 173 59 and and CC 13433 173 60 that that IN 13433 173 61 writers writer NNS 13433 173 62 of of IN 13433 173 63 that that DT 13433 173 64 period period NN 13433 173 65 , , , 13433 173 66 and and CC 13433 173 67 notably notably RB 13433 173 68 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 173 69 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 173 70 , , , 13433 173 71 were be VBD 13433 173 72 in in IN 13433 173 73 the the DT 13433 173 74 habit habit NN 13433 173 75 of of IN 13433 173 76 putting putting NN 13433 173 77 , , , 13433 173 78 as as IN 13433 173 79 it -PRON- PRP 13433 173 80 might may MD 13433 173 81 seem seem VB 13433 173 82 , , , 13433 173 83 by by IN 13433 173 84 the the DT 13433 173 85 use use NN 13433 173 86 of of IN 13433 173 87 an an DT 13433 173 88 indefinite indefinite NN 13433 173 89 " " '' 13433 173 90 he -PRON- PRP 13433 173 91 says say VBZ 13433 173 92 , , , 13433 173 93 " " `` 13433 173 94 sentiments sentiment NNS 13433 173 95 into into IN 13433 173 96 the the DT 13433 173 97 mouth mouth NN 13433 173 98 of of IN 13433 173 99 the the DT 13433 173 100 founder founder NN 13433 173 101 of of IN 13433 173 102 a a DT 13433 173 103 sect sect NN 13433 173 104 which which WDT 13433 173 105 were be VBD 13433 173 106 only only RB 13433 173 107 expressed express VBN 13433 173 108 by by IN 13433 173 109 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 173 110 later later JJ 13433 173 111 followers follower NNS 13433 173 112 ? ? . 13433 174 1 As as IN 13433 174 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 174 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 174 4 evidently evidently RB 13433 174 5 highly highly RB 13433 174 6 values value VBZ 13433 174 7 the the DT 13433 174 8 testimony testimony NN 13433 174 9 of of IN 13433 174 10 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 174 11 , , , 13433 174 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 174 13 will will MD 13433 174 14 quote quote VB 13433 174 15 the the DT 13433 174 16 words word NNS 13433 174 17 of of IN 13433 174 18 that that DT 13433 174 19 staunch staunch JJ 13433 174 20 apologist apologist NN 13433 174 21 to to TO 13433 174 22 show show VB 13433 174 23 that that IN 13433 174 24 , , , 13433 174 25 in in IN 13433 174 26 this this DT 13433 174 27 , , , 13433 174 28 I -PRON- PRP 13433 174 29 do do VBP 13433 174 30 not not RB 13433 174 31 merely merely RB 13433 174 32 represent represent VB 13433 174 33 the the DT 13433 174 34 views view NNS 13433 174 35 of of IN 13433 174 36 a a DT 13433 174 37 heterodox heterodox NN 13433 174 38 school school NN 13433 174 39 . . . 13433 175 1 In in IN 13433 175 2 discussing discuss VBG 13433 175 3 the the DT 13433 175 4 supposed suppose VBN 13433 175 5 quotations quotation NNS 13433 175 6 from from IN 13433 175 7 the the DT 13433 175 8 fourth fourth JJ 13433 175 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 175 10 , , , 13433 175 11 which which WDT 13433 175 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 175 13 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 175 14 represents represent VBZ 13433 175 15 as as IN 13433 175 16 " " `` 13433 175 17 certain certain JJ 13433 175 18 references reference NNS 13433 175 19 " " '' 13433 175 20 to to IN 13433 175 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 175 22 by by IN 13433 175 23 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 175 24 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 175 25 , , , 13433 175 26 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 175 27 says say VBZ 13433 175 28 : : : 13433 175 29 " " `` 13433 175 30 But but CC 13433 175 31 to to IN 13433 175 32 this this DT 13433 175 33 is be VBZ 13433 175 34 opposed oppose VBN 13433 175 35 the the DT 13433 175 36 consideration consideration NN 13433 175 37 that that IN 13433 175 38 , , , 13433 175 39 as as IN 13433 175 40 we -PRON- PRP 13433 175 41 know know VBP 13433 175 42 from from IN 13433 175 43 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 175 44 , , , 13433 175 45 & & CC 13433 175 46 c. c. NNP 13433 175 47 , , , 13433 175 48 the the DT 13433 175 49 original original JJ 13433 175 50 system system NN 13433 175 51 of of IN 13433 175 52 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 175 53 had have VBD 13433 175 54 a a DT 13433 175 55 dualistic dualistic JJ 13433 175 56 character character NN 13433 175 57 , , , 13433 175 58 whilst whilst IN 13433 175 59 that that DT 13433 175 60 of of IN 13433 175 61 the the DT 13433 175 62 ' ' `` 13433 175 63 Philosophumena Philosophumena NNP 13433 175 64 ' ' '' 13433 175 65 is be VBZ 13433 175 66 pantheistic pantheistic JJ 13433 175 67 . . . 13433 176 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 176 2 must must MD 13433 176 3 recognise recognise VB 13433 176 4 that that IN 13433 176 5 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 176 6 , , , 13433 176 7 in in IN 13433 176 8 the the DT 13433 176 9 ' ' `` 13433 176 10 Philosophumena Philosophumena NNP 13433 176 11 , , , 13433 176 12 ' ' '' 13433 176 13 not not RB 13433 176 14 unfrequently unfrequently RB 13433 176 15 makes make VBZ 13433 176 16 the the DT 13433 176 17 founder founder NN 13433 176 18 of of IN 13433 176 19 a a DT 13433 176 20 sect sect NN 13433 176 21 responsible responsible JJ 13433 176 22 for for IN 13433 176 23 that that DT 13433 176 24 which which WDT 13433 176 25 in in IN 13433 176 26 the the DT 13433 176 27 first first JJ 13433 176 28 place place NN 13433 176 29 concerns concern VBZ 13433 176 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 176 31 disciples disciple NNS 13433 176 32 , , , 13433 176 33 so so IN 13433 176 34 that that IN 13433 176 35 from from IN 13433 176 36 these these DT 13433 176 37 quotations quotation NNS 13433 176 38 only only RB 13433 176 39 the the DT 13433 176 40 use use NN 13433 176 41 of of IN 13433 176 42 the the DT 13433 176 43 Johannine Johannine NNP 13433 176 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 176 45 in in IN 13433 176 46 the the DT 13433 176 47 school school NN 13433 176 48 of of IN 13433 176 49 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 176 50 is be VBZ 13433 176 51 undoubtedly undoubtedly RB 13433 176 52 proved prove VBN 13433 176 53 , , , 13433 176 54 but but CC 13433 176 55 not not RB 13433 176 56 on on IN 13433 176 57 the the DT 13433 176 58 part part NN 13433 176 59 of of IN 13433 176 60 the the DT 13433 176 61 founder founder NN 13433 176 62 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 176 63 . . . 13433 176 64 " " '' 13433 177 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 177 2 18:1 18:1 CD 13433 177 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 177 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 177 5 is be VBZ 13433 177 6 difficult difficult JJ 13433 177 7 to to TO 13433 177 8 recognise recognise VB 13433 177 9 in in IN 13433 177 10 this this DT 13433 177 11 fancy fancy JJ 13433 177 12 portrait portrait NN 13433 177 13 the the DT 13433 177 14 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 177 15 regarding regard VBG 13433 177 16 whom whom WP 13433 177 17 a a DT 13433 177 18 large large JJ 13433 177 19 body body NN 13433 177 20 of of IN 13433 177 21 eminent eminent JJ 13433 177 22 critics critic NNS 13433 177 23 conclude conclude VBP 13433 177 24 that that IN 13433 177 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 177 26 did do VBD 13433 177 27 not not RB 13433 177 28 know know VB 13433 177 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 177 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 177 31 at at RB 13433 177 32 all all RB 13433 177 33 , , , 13433 177 34 but but CC 13433 177 35 made make VBD 13433 177 36 use use NN 13433 177 37 of of IN 13433 177 38 an an DT 13433 177 39 uncanonical uncanonical JJ 13433 177 40 work work NN 13433 177 41 , , , 13433 177 42 supplemented supplement VBN 13433 177 43 by by IN 13433 177 44 traditions tradition NNS 13433 177 45 from from IN 13433 177 46 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 177 47 and and CC 13433 177 48 Matthias Matthias NNP 13433 177 49 ; ; : 13433 177 50 but but CC 13433 177 51 , , , 13433 177 52 as as IN 13433 177 53 if if IN 13433 177 54 the the DT 13433 177 55 heretic heretic NN 13433 177 56 had have VBD 13433 177 57 not not RB 13433 177 58 been be VBN 13433 177 59 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 177 60 restored restore VBN 13433 177 61 to to IN 13433 177 62 the the DT 13433 177 63 odour odour NN 13433 177 64 of of IN 13433 177 65 sanctity sanctity NN 13433 177 66 , , , 13433 177 67 the the DT 13433 177 68 additional additional JJ 13433 177 69 touch touch NN 13433 177 70 is be VBZ 13433 177 71 given give VBN 13433 177 72 in in IN 13433 177 73 the the DT 13433 177 74 passage passage NN 13433 177 75 more more RBR 13433 177 76 immediately immediately RB 13433 177 77 before before IN 13433 177 78 us -PRON- PRP 13433 177 79 . . . 13433 178 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 178 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 178 3 conveys convey VBZ 13433 178 4 the the DT 13433 178 5 information information NN 13433 178 6 contained contain VBN 13433 178 7 in in IN 13433 178 8 the the DT 13433 178 9 single single JJ 13433 178 10 sentence sentence NN 13433 178 11 of of IN 13433 178 12 Clement Clement NNP 13433 178 13 of of IN 13433 178 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 178 15 , , , 13433 178 16 [ [ -LRB- 13433 178 17 Greek Greek NNP 13433 178 18 : : : 13433 178 19 kathaper kathaper NNP 13433 178 20 ho ho NNP 13433 178 21 Basileidês Basileidês NNP 13433 178 22 kan kan VBD 13433 178 23 Glaukian glaukian JJ 13433 178 24 epigraphêtai epigraphêtai NNP 13433 178 25 didaskalon didaskalon NNP 13433 178 26 , , , 13433 178 27 hôs hôs NNP 13433 178 28 auchousin auchousin NNP 13433 178 29 autoi autoi NNP 13433 178 30 , , , 13433 178 31 ton ton NN 13433 178 32 Petrou Petrou NNP 13433 178 33 hermênea hermênea NNP 13433 178 34 ] ] -RRB- 13433 178 35 , , , 13433 178 36 [ [ -LRB- 13433 178 37 19:1 19:1 CD 13433 178 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 178 39 in in IN 13433 178 40 the the DT 13433 178 41 following follow VBG 13433 178 42 words word NNS 13433 178 43 ; ; : 13433 178 44 and and CC 13433 178 45 I -PRON- PRP 13433 178 46 quote quote VBP 13433 178 47 the the DT 13433 178 48 statement statement NN 13433 178 49 exactly exactly RB 13433 178 50 as as IN 13433 178 51 it -PRON- PRP 13433 178 52 has have VBZ 13433 178 53 stood stand VBN 13433 178 54 in in IN 13433 178 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 178 56 text text NN 13433 178 57 from from IN 13433 178 58 the the DT 13433 178 59 very very RB 13433 178 60 first first JJ 13433 178 61 , , , 13433 178 62 in in IN 13433 178 63 order order NN 13433 178 64 to to TO 13433 178 65 show show VB 13433 178 66 the the DT 13433 178 67 inverted invert VBN 13433 178 68 commas comma NNS 13433 178 69 upon upon IN 13433 178 70 which which WDT 13433 178 71 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 178 72 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 178 73 lays lay VBZ 13433 178 74 so so RB 13433 178 75 much much JJ 13433 178 76 stress stress NN 13433 178 77 as as IN 13433 178 78 having have VBG 13433 178 79 been be VBN 13433 178 80 removed remove VBN 13433 178 81 . . . 13433 179 1 In in IN 13433 179 2 mentioning mention VBG 13433 179 3 this this DT 13433 179 4 fact fact NN 13433 179 5 Canon Canon NNP 13433 179 6 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 179 7 says say VBZ 13433 179 8 : : : 13433 179 9 " " `` 13433 179 10 At at IN 13433 179 11 the the DT 13433 179 12 same same JJ 13433 179 13 time time NN 13433 179 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 179 15 appealed appeal VBD 13433 179 16 to to IN 13433 179 17 the the DT 13433 179 18 authority authority NN 13433 179 19 of of IN 13433 179 20 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 179 21 , , , 13433 179 22 who who WP 13433 179 23 , , , 13433 179 24 as as RB 13433 179 25 well well RB 13433 179 26 as as IN 13433 179 27 St. St. NNP 13433 179 28 Mark Mark NNP 13433 179 29 , , , 13433 179 30 was be VBD 13433 179 31 ' ' '' 13433 179 32 an an DT 13433 179 33 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 179 34 of of IN 13433 179 35 St. St. NNP 13433 180 1 Peter Peter NNP 13433 180 2 . . . 13433 180 3 ' ' '' 13433 181 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 181 2 19:2 19:2 CD 13433 181 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 181 4 Now now RB 13433 181 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 181 6 have have VBP 13433 181 7 here here RB 13433 181 8 , , , 13433 181 9 again again RB 13433 181 10 , , , 13433 181 11 an an DT 13433 181 12 illustration illustration NN 13433 181 13 , , , 13433 181 14 " " '' 13433 181 15 & & CC 13433 181 16 c. c. NNP 13433 181 17 ; ; : 13433 181 18 and and CC 13433 181 19 then then RB 13433 181 20 follows follow VBZ 13433 181 21 the the DT 13433 181 22 passage passage NN 13433 181 23 quoted quote VBN 13433 181 24 by by IN 13433 181 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 181 26 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 181 27 . . . 13433 182 1 The the DT 13433 182 2 positive positive JJ 13433 182 3 form form NN 13433 182 4 given give VBN 13433 182 5 to to IN 13433 182 6 the the DT 13433 182 7 words word NNS 13433 182 8 of of IN 13433 182 9 Clement Clement NNP 13433 182 10 , , , 13433 182 11 and and CC 13433 182 12 the the DT 13433 182 13 introduction introduction NN 13433 182 14 of of IN 13433 182 15 the the DT 13433 182 16 words word NNS 13433 182 17 " " `` 13433 182 18 as as RB 13433 182 19 well well RB 13433 182 20 as as IN 13433 182 21 St. St. NNP 13433 182 22 Mark Mark NNP 13433 182 23 , , , 13433 182 24 " " '' 13433 182 25 seem seem VBP 13433 182 26 at at IN 13433 182 27 once once RB 13433 182 28 to to TO 13433 182 29 impart impart VB 13433 182 30 a a DT 13433 182 31 full full JJ 13433 182 32 flavour flavour NN 13433 182 33 of of IN 13433 182 34 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 13433 182 35 to to IN 13433 182 36 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 182 37 which which WDT 13433 182 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 182 39 do do VBP 13433 182 40 not not RB 13433 182 41 find find VB 13433 182 42 in in IN 13433 182 43 the the DT 13433 182 44 original original NN 13433 182 45 . . . 13433 183 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 183 2 confess confess VBP 13433 183 3 that that IN 13433 183 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 183 5 fail fail VBP 13433 183 6 to to TO 13433 183 7 see see VB 13433 183 8 any any DT 13433 183 9 special special JJ 13433 183 10 virtue virtue NN 13433 183 11 in in IN 13433 183 12 the the DT 13433 183 13 inverted inverted JJ 13433 183 14 commas comma NNS 13433 183 15 ; ; : 13433 183 16 but but CC 13433 183 17 as as IN 13433 183 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 183 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 183 20 does do VBZ 13433 183 21 , , , 13433 183 22 let let VB 13433 183 23 me -PRON- PRP 13433 183 24 point point VB 13433 183 25 out out RP 13433 183 26 to to IN 13433 183 27 him -PRON- PRP 13433 183 28 that that IN 13433 183 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 183 30 commences commence VBZ 13433 183 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 183 32 quotation quotation NN 13433 183 33 -- -- : 13433 183 34 upon upon IN 13433 183 35 the the DT 13433 183 36 strength strength NN 13433 183 37 of of IN 13433 183 38 which which WDT 13433 183 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 183 40 accuses accuse VBZ 13433 183 41 me -PRON- PRP 13433 183 42 of of IN 13433 183 43 " " `` 13433 183 44 manipulating manipulate VBG 13433 183 45 " " '' 13433 183 46 a a DT 13433 183 47 passage passage NN 13433 183 48 , , , 13433 183 49 and and CC 13433 183 50 then then RB 13433 183 51 founding found VBG 13433 183 52 upon upon IN 13433 183 53 it -PRON- PRP 13433 183 54 a a DT 13433 183 55 charge charge NN 13433 183 56 of of IN 13433 183 57 unfair unfair JJ 13433 183 58 dealing dealing NN 13433 183 59 -- -- : 13433 183 60 immediately immediately RB 13433 183 61 after after IN 13433 183 62 the the DT 13433 183 63 direct direct JJ 13433 183 64 citation citation NN 13433 183 65 from from IN 13433 183 66 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 183 67 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 183 68 's 's POS 13433 183 69 work work NN 13433 183 70 , , , 13433 183 71 in in IN 13433 183 72 which which WDT 13433 183 73 those those DT 13433 183 74 inverted invert VBN 13433 183 75 commas comma NNS 13433 183 76 are be VBP 13433 183 77 given give VBN 13433 183 78 . . . 13433 184 1 The the DT 13433 184 2 words word NNS 13433 184 3 they -PRON- PRP 13433 184 4 mark mark VBP 13433 184 5 are be VBP 13433 184 6 a a DT 13433 184 7 quotation quotation NN 13433 184 8 from from IN 13433 184 9 Clement Clement NNP 13433 184 10 , , , 13433 184 11 and and CC 13433 184 12 in in IN 13433 184 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 184 14 re re NN 13433 184 15 - - NN 13433 184 16 quotation quotation NN 13433 184 17 a a DT 13433 184 18 few few JJ 13433 184 19 lines line NNS 13433 184 20 lower lower RBR 13433 184 21 down down RB 13433 184 22 they -PRON- PRP 13433 184 23 are be VBP 13433 184 24 equally equally RB 13433 184 25 well well RB 13433 184 26 indicated indicate VBN 13433 184 27 by by IN 13433 184 28 being be VBG 13433 184 29 the the DT 13433 184 30 only only JJ 13433 184 31 words word NNS 13433 184 32 not not RB 13433 184 33 put put VBN 13433 184 34 in in IN 13433 184 35 italics italic NNS 13433 184 36 . . . 13433 185 1 The the DT 13433 185 2 fact fact NN 13433 185 3 is be VBZ 13433 185 4 , , , 13433 185 5 that that IN 13433 185 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 185 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 185 8 has have VBZ 13433 185 9 mistaken mistake VBN 13433 185 10 and and CC 13433 185 11 misstated misstate VBN 13433 185 12 the the DT 13433 185 13 whole whole JJ 13433 185 14 case case NN 13433 185 15 . . . 13433 186 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 186 2 has have VBZ 13433 186 3 been be VBN 13433 186 4 so so RB 13433 186 5 eagerly eagerly RB 13433 186 6 looking look VBG 13433 186 7 for for IN 13433 186 8 the the DT 13433 186 9 mote mote NN 13433 186 10 in in IN 13433 186 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 186 12 eye eye NN 13433 186 13 that that IN 13433 186 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 186 15 has have VBZ 13433 186 16 failed fail VBN 13433 186 17 to to TO 13433 186 18 perceive perceive VB 13433 186 19 the the DT 13433 186 20 beam beam NN 13433 186 21 which which WDT 13433 186 22 is be VBZ 13433 186 23 in in IN 13433 186 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 186 25 own own JJ 13433 186 26 eye eye NN 13433 186 27 . . . 13433 187 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 187 2 is be VBZ 13433 187 3 by by IN 13433 187 4 this this DT 13433 187 5 wonderful wonderful JJ 13433 187 6 illustration illustration NN 13433 187 7 that that IN 13433 187 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 187 9 " " `` 13433 187 10 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 13433 187 11 the the DT 13433 187 12 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 187 13 looseness looseness NN 13433 187 14 which which WDT 13433 187 15 pervades pervade VBZ 13433 187 16 the the DT 13433 187 17 critical critical JJ 13433 187 18 portion portion NN 13433 187 19 of of IN 13433 187 20 this this DT 13433 187 21 ( ( -LRB- 13433 187 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 187 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 187 24 book book NN 13433 187 25 . . . 13433 187 26 " " '' 13433 188 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 188 2 19:3 19:3 CD 13433 188 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 188 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 188 5 rather rather RB 13433 188 6 exemplifies exemplify VBZ 13433 188 7 the the DT 13433 188 8 uncritical uncritical JJ 13433 188 9 looseness looseness NN 13433 188 10 which which WDT 13433 188 11 pervades pervade VBZ 13433 188 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 188 13 own own JJ 13433 188 14 article article NN 13433 188 15 . . . 13433 189 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 189 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 189 3 says say VBZ 13433 189 4 , , , 13433 189 5 and and CC 13433 189 6 says say VBZ 13433 189 7 rightly rightly RB 13433 189 8 , , , 13433 189 9 that that IN 13433 189 10 " " `` 13433 189 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 189 12 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 189 13 's 's POS 13433 189 14 honour honour NN 13433 189 15 may may MD 13433 189 16 safely safely RB 13433 189 17 be be VB 13433 189 18 left leave VBN 13433 189 19 to to TO 13433 189 20 take take VB 13433 189 21 care care NN 13433 189 22 of of IN 13433 189 23 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 189 24 . . . 13433 189 25 " " '' 13433 190 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 190 2 would would MD 13433 190 3 have have VB 13433 190 4 been be VBN 13433 190 5 much much RB 13433 190 6 better well JJR 13433 190 7 to to TO 13433 190 8 have have VB 13433 190 9 left leave VBN 13433 190 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 190 11 to to TO 13433 190 12 take take VB 13433 190 13 care care NN 13433 190 14 of of IN 13433 190 15 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 190 16 , , , 13433 190 17 indeed indeed RB 13433 190 18 , , , 13433 190 19 than than IN 13433 190 20 trouble trouble NN 13433 190 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 190 22 by by IN 13433 190 23 such such JJ 13433 190 24 advocacy advocacy NN 13433 190 25 . . . 13433 191 1 If if IN 13433 191 2 anything anything NN 13433 191 3 could could MD 13433 191 4 check check VB 13433 191 5 just just RB 13433 191 6 or or CC 13433 191 7 generous generous JJ 13433 191 8 expression expression NN 13433 191 9 , , , 13433 191 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 191 11 would would MD 13433 191 12 be be VB 13433 191 13 the the DT 13433 191 14 tone tone NN 13433 191 15 adopted adopt VBN 13433 191 16 by by IN 13433 191 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 191 18 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 191 19 ; ; : 13433 191 20 but but CC 13433 191 21 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 191 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 191 23 again again RB 13433 191 24 say say VBP 13433 191 25 , , , 13433 191 26 in in IN 13433 191 27 the the DT 13433 191 28 most most RBS 13433 191 29 unreserved unreserved JJ 13433 191 30 manner manner NN 13433 191 31 , , , 13433 191 32 that that IN 13433 191 33 neither neither CC 13433 191 34 in in IN 13433 191 35 this this DT 13433 191 36 instance instance NN 13433 191 37 nor nor CC 13433 191 38 in in IN 13433 191 39 any any DT 13433 191 40 other other JJ 13433 191 41 have have VBP 13433 191 42 I -PRON- PRP 13433 191 43 had have VBN 13433 191 44 the the DT 13433 191 45 most most RBS 13433 191 46 distant distant JJ 13433 191 47 intention intention NN 13433 191 48 of of IN 13433 191 49 attributing attribute VBG 13433 191 50 " " `` 13433 191 51 corrupt corrupt JJ 13433 191 52 motives motive NNS 13433 191 53 " " '' 13433 191 54 to to IN 13433 191 55 a a DT 13433 191 56 man man NN 13433 191 57 like like IN 13433 191 58 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 191 59 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 191 60 , , , 13433 191 61 whose whose WP$ 13433 191 62 single single JJ 13433 191 63 - - HYPH 13433 191 64 mindedness mindedness NN 13433 191 65 I -PRON- PRP 13433 191 66 recognise recognise VBP 13433 191 67 , , , 13433 191 68 and and CC 13433 191 69 for for IN 13433 191 70 whose whose WP$ 13433 191 71 earnest earnest JJ 13433 191 72 character character NN 13433 191 73 I -PRON- PRP 13433 191 74 feel feel VBP 13433 191 75 genuine genuine JJ 13433 191 76 respect respect NN 13433 191 77 . . . 13433 192 1 The the DT 13433 192 2 utmost utmost JJ 13433 192 3 that that WDT 13433 192 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 192 5 have have VBP 13433 192 6 at at IN 13433 192 7 any any DT 13433 192 8 time time NN 13433 192 9 intended intend VBN 13433 192 10 to to TO 13433 192 11 point point VB 13433 192 12 out out RP 13433 192 13 is be VBZ 13433 192 14 that that IN 13433 192 15 , , , 13433 192 16 utterly utterly RB 13433 192 17 possessed possess VBD 13433 192 18 as as IN 13433 192 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 192 20 is be VBZ 13433 192 21 by by IN 13433 192 22 orthodox orthodox JJ 13433 192 23 views view NNS 13433 192 24 in in IN 13433 192 25 general general JJ 13433 192 26 , , , 13433 192 27 and and CC 13433 192 28 of of IN 13433 192 29 the the DT 13433 192 30 canon canon NN 13433 192 31 in in IN 13433 192 32 particular particular JJ 13433 192 33 , , , 13433 192 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 192 35 sees see VBZ 13433 192 36 facts fact NNS 13433 192 37 , , , 13433 192 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 192 39 consider consider VBP 13433 192 40 , , , 13433 192 41 through through IN 13433 192 42 a a DT 13433 192 43 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 13433 192 44 medium medium NN 13433 192 45 , , , 13433 192 46 and and CC 13433 192 47 unconsciously unconsciously RB 13433 192 48 imparts impart VBZ 13433 192 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 192 50 own own JJ 13433 192 51 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 192 52 colouring colouring NN 13433 192 53 to to IN 13433 192 54 statements statement NNS 13433 192 55 which which WDT 13433 192 56 should should MD 13433 192 57 be be VB 13433 192 58 more more RBR 13433 192 59 impartially impartially RB 13433 192 60 made make VBN 13433 192 61 . . . 13433 193 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 193 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 193 3 will will MD 13433 193 4 not not RB 13433 193 5 even even RB 13433 193 6 give give VB 13433 193 7 me -PRON- PRP 13433 193 8 credit credit NN 13433 193 9 for for IN 13433 193 10 fairly fairly RB 13433 193 11 stating state VBG 13433 193 12 the the DT 13433 193 13 arguments argument NNS 13433 193 14 of of IN 13433 193 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 193 16 adversaries adversary NNS 13433 193 17 . . . 13433 194 1 " " `` 13433 194 2 The the DT 13433 194 3 author author NN 13433 194 4 , , , 13433 194 5 " " '' 13433 194 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 194 7 says say VBZ 13433 194 8 , , , 13433 194 9 " " `` 13433 194 10 does do VBZ 13433 194 11 indeed indeed RB 13433 194 12 single single VB 13433 194 13 out out RP 13433 194 14 from from IN 13433 194 15 time time NN 13433 194 16 to to IN 13433 194 17 time time NN 13433 194 18 the the DT 13433 194 19 weaker weak JJR 13433 194 20 arguments argument NNS 13433 194 21 of of IN 13433 194 22 ' ' `` 13433 194 23 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 194 24 ' ' '' 13433 194 25 writers writer NNS 13433 194 26 , , , 13433 194 27 and and CC 13433 194 28 on on IN 13433 194 29 these these DT 13433 194 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 194 31 dwells dwell VBZ 13433 194 32 at at IN 13433 194 33 great great JJ 13433 194 34 length length NN 13433 194 35 ; ; : 13433 194 36 but but CC 13433 194 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 194 38 weightier weighty JJR 13433 194 39 facts fact NNS 13433 194 40 and and CC 13433 194 41 lines line NNS 13433 194 42 of of IN 13433 194 43 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 194 44 are be VBP 13433 194 45 altogether altogether RB 13433 194 46 ignored ignore VBN 13433 194 47 by by IN 13433 194 48 him -PRON- PRP 13433 194 49 , , , 13433 194 50 though though IN 13433 194 51 they -PRON- PRP 13433 194 52 often often RB 13433 194 53 occur occur VBP 13433 194 54 in in IN 13433 194 55 the the DT 13433 194 56 same same JJ 13433 194 57 books book NNS 13433 194 58 , , , 13433 194 59 and and CC 13433 194 60 even even RB 13433 194 61 in in IN 13433 194 62 the the DT 13433 194 63 same same JJ 13433 194 64 contexts contexts NN 13433 194 65 which which WDT 13433 194 66 he -PRON- PRP 13433 194 67 quotes quote VBZ 13433 194 68 . . . 13433 194 69 " " '' 13433 195 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 195 2 20:1 20:1 CD 13433 195 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 195 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 195 5 am be VBP 13433 195 6 exceedingly exceedingly RB 13433 195 7 indebted indebted JJ 13433 195 8 to to IN 13433 195 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 195 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 195 11 for for IN 13433 195 12 having have VBG 13433 195 13 had have VBD 13433 195 14 compassion compassion NN 13433 195 15 upon upon IN 13433 195 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 195 17 incapacity incapacity NN 13433 195 18 to to TO 13433 195 19 distinguish distinguish VB 13433 195 20 these these DT 13433 195 21 arguments argument NNS 13433 195 22 , , , 13433 195 23 and and CC 13433 195 24 for for IN 13433 195 25 giving give VBG 13433 195 26 me -PRON- PRP 13433 195 27 " " `` 13433 195 28 samples sample NNS 13433 195 29 " " '' 13433 195 30 of of IN 13433 195 31 the the DT 13433 195 32 " " `` 13433 195 33 weightier weighty JJR 13433 195 34 facts fact NNS 13433 195 35 and and CC 13433 195 36 lines line NNS 13433 195 37 of of IN 13433 195 38 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 195 39 " " '' 13433 195 40 of of IN 13433 195 41 apologists apologist NNS 13433 195 42 which which WDT 13433 195 43 I -PRON- PRP 13433 195 44 have have VBP 13433 195 45 ignored ignore VBN 13433 195 46 . . . 13433 196 1 The the DT 13433 196 2 first first JJ 13433 196 3 of of IN 13433 196 4 these these DT 13433 196 5 with with IN 13433 196 6 which which WDT 13433 196 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 196 8 favours favour VBZ 13433 196 9 me -PRON- PRP 13433 196 10 is be VBZ 13433 196 11 in in IN 13433 196 12 connection connection NN 13433 196 13 with with IN 13433 196 14 an an DT 13433 196 15 anachronism anachronism NN 13433 196 16 in in IN 13433 196 17 the the DT 13433 196 18 epistle epistle NN 13433 196 19 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 196 20 to to IN 13433 196 21 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 196 22 , , , 13433 196 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 196 24 being be VBG 13433 196 25 spoken speak VBN 13433 196 26 of of IN 13433 196 27 in in IN 13433 196 28 chapter chapter NN 13433 196 29 thirteen thirteen CD 13433 196 30 as as IN 13433 196 31 living living NN 13433 196 32 , , , 13433 196 33 and and CC 13433 196 34 information information NN 13433 196 35 requested request VBD 13433 196 36 regarding regard VBG 13433 196 37 him -PRON- PRP 13433 196 38 " " '' 13433 196 39 and and CC 13433 196 40 those those DT 13433 196 41 who who WP 13433 196 42 are be VBP 13433 196 43 with with IN 13433 196 44 him -PRON- PRP 13433 196 45 ; ; : 13433 196 46 " " `` 13433 196 47 whereas whereas IN 13433 196 48 in in IN 13433 196 49 an an DT 13433 196 50 earlier early JJR 13433 196 51 passage passage NN 13433 196 52 he -PRON- PRP 13433 196 53 is be VBZ 13433 196 54 represented represent VBN 13433 196 55 as as IN 13433 196 56 dead dead JJ 13433 196 57 . . . 13433 197 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 197 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 197 3 reproaches reproach VBZ 13433 197 4 me:-- me:-- ADD 13433 197 5 " " `` 13433 197 6 Why why WRB 13433 197 7 , , , 13433 197 8 then then RB 13433 197 9 , , , 13433 197 10 does do VBZ 13433 197 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 197 12 not not RB 13433 197 13 notice notice VB 13433 197 14 the the DT 13433 197 15 answer answer NN 13433 197 16 which which WDT 13433 197 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 197 18 might may MD 13433 197 19 have have VB 13433 197 20 found find VBN 13433 197 21 in in IN 13433 197 22 any any DT 13433 197 23 common common JJ 13433 197 24 source source NN 13433 197 25 of of IN 13433 197 26 information information NN 13433 197 27 , , , 13433 197 28 that that IN 13433 197 29 when when WRB 13433 197 30 the the DT 13433 197 31 Latin latin JJ 13433 197 32 version version NN 13433 197 33 ( ( -LRB- 13433 197 34 the the DT 13433 197 35 Greek Greek NNP 13433 197 36 is be VBZ 13433 197 37 wanting want VBG 13433 197 38 here here RB 13433 197 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 197 40 ' ' '' 13433 197 41 de de VB 13433 197 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 197 43 qui qui NNP 13433 197 44 cum cum NNP 13433 197 45 eo eo NNP 13433 197 46 sunt sunt NNP 13433 197 47 ' ' '' 13433 197 48 is be VBZ 13433 197 49 re re JJ 13433 197 50 - - VBN 13433 197 51 translated translate VBN 13433 197 52 into into IN 13433 197 53 the the DT 13433 197 54 original original JJ 13433 197 55 language language NN 13433 197 56 , , , 13433 197 57 [ [ -LRB- 13433 197 58 Greek Greek NNP 13433 197 59 : : : 13433 197 60 tois tois NNP 13433 197 61 sun sun NNP 13433 197 62 autô autô NNP 13433 197 63 ] ] -RRB- 13433 197 64 , , , 13433 197 65 the the DT 13433 197 66 ' ' `` 13433 197 67 anachronism anachronism NN 13433 197 68 ' ' '' 13433 197 69 altogether altogether RB 13433 197 70 disappears disappear VBZ 13433 197 71 ? ? . 13433 197 72 " " '' 13433 198 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 198 2 21:1 21:1 CD 13433 198 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 198 4 As as IN 13433 198 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 198 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 198 7 does do VBZ 13433 198 8 not not RB 13433 198 9 apparently apparently RB 13433 198 10 attach attach VB 13433 198 11 much much JJ 13433 198 12 weight weight NN 13433 198 13 to to IN 13433 198 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 198 15 replies reply NNS 13433 198 16 , , , 13433 198 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 198 18 venture venture VBP 13433 198 19 to to TO 13433 198 20 give give VB 13433 198 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 198 22 reasons reason NNS 13433 198 23 for for IN 13433 198 24 not not RB 13433 198 25 troubling trouble VBG 13433 198 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 198 27 readers reader NNS 13433 198 28 with with IN 13433 198 29 this this DT 13433 198 30 argument argument NN 13433 198 31 in in IN 13433 198 32 words word NNS 13433 198 33 which which WDT 13433 198 34 , , , 13433 198 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 198 36 hope hope VBP 13433 198 37 , , , 13433 198 38 may may MD 13433 198 39 find find VB 13433 198 40 more more JJR 13433 198 41 favour favour NN 13433 198 42 with with IN 13433 198 43 him -PRON- PRP 13433 198 44 . . . 13433 199 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 199 2 Donaldson Donaldson NNP 13433 199 3 , , , 13433 199 4 in in IN 13433 199 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 199 6 able able JJ 13433 199 7 work work NN 13433 199 8 on on IN 13433 199 9 " " `` 13433 199 10 Christian Christian NNP 13433 199 11 Literature Literature NNP 13433 199 12 and and CC 13433 199 13 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 199 14 , , , 13433 199 15 " " '' 13433 199 16 says say VBZ 13433 199 17 : : : 13433 199 18 " " `` 13433 199 19 In in IN 13433 199 20 the the DT 13433 199 21 ninth ninth JJ 13433 199 22 chapter chapter NN 13433 199 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 199 24 is be VBZ 13433 199 25 spoken speak VBN 13433 199 26 of of IN 13433 199 27 as as IN 13433 199 28 a a DT 13433 199 29 martyr martyr NN 13433 199 30 , , , 13433 199 31 an an DT 13433 199 32 example example NN 13433 199 33 to to IN 13433 199 34 the the DT 13433 199 35 Philippians Philippians NNPS 13433 199 36 of of IN 13433 199 37 patience patience NN 13433 199 38 ... ... . 13433 200 1 In in IN 13433 200 2 the the DT 13433 200 3 thirteenth thirteenth JJ 13433 200 4 chapter chapter NN 13433 200 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 200 6 requests request VBZ 13433 200 7 information information NN 13433 200 8 with with IN 13433 200 9 regard regard NN 13433 200 10 to to IN 13433 200 11 ' ' `` 13433 200 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 200 13 and and CC 13433 200 14 those those DT 13433 200 15 with with IN 13433 200 16 him -PRON- PRP 13433 200 17 . . . 13433 200 18 ' ' '' 13433 201 1 These these DT 13433 201 2 words word NNS 13433 201 3 occur occur VBP 13433 201 4 only only RB 13433 201 5 in in IN 13433 201 6 the the DT 13433 201 7 Latin latin JJ 13433 201 8 translation translation NN 13433 201 9 of of IN 13433 201 10 the the DT 13433 201 11 epistle epistle NN 13433 201 12 . . . 13433 202 1 To to TO 13433 202 2 get get VB 13433 202 3 rid rid VBN 13433 202 4 of of IN 13433 202 5 the the DT 13433 202 6 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 202 7 which which WDT 13433 202 8 they -PRON- PRP 13433 202 9 present present VBP 13433 202 10 , , , 13433 202 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 202 12 has have VBZ 13433 202 13 been be VBN 13433 202 14 supposed suppose VBN 13433 202 15 that that IN 13433 202 16 the the DT 13433 202 17 words word NNS 13433 202 18 ' ' `` 13433 202 19 de de IN 13433 202 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 202 21 qui qui NNP 13433 202 22 cum cum NNP 13433 202 23 eo eo NNP 13433 202 24 sunt sunt NNP 13433 202 25 ' ' `` 13433 202 26 are be VBP 13433 202 27 a a DT 13433 202 28 wrong wrong JJ 13433 202 29 rendering rendering NN 13433 202 30 of of IN 13433 202 31 the the DT 13433 202 32 Greek Greek NNP 13433 202 33 [ [ -LRB- 13433 202 34 Greek Greek NNP 13433 202 35 : : : 13433 202 36 peri peri NN 13433 202 37 ton ton NN 13433 202 38 met meet VBD 13433 202 39 ' ' '' 13433 202 40 autou autou NNP 13433 202 41 ] ] -RRB- 13433 202 42 . . . 13433 203 1 And and CC 13433 203 2 then then RB 13433 203 3 the the DT 13433 203 4 words word NNS 13433 203 5 are be VBP 13433 203 6 supposed suppose VBN 13433 203 7 to to TO 13433 203 8 mean mean VB 13433 203 9 , , , 13433 203 10 ' ' '' 13433 203 11 concerning concern VBG 13433 203 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 203 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 203 14 of of IN 13433 203 15 whose whose WP$ 13433 203 16 death death NN 13433 203 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 203 18 heard hear VBD 13433 203 19 , , , 13433 203 20 but but CC 13433 203 21 of of IN 13433 203 22 which which WDT 13433 203 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 203 24 wish wish VBP 13433 203 25 particulars particular NNS 13433 203 26 ) ) -RRB- 13433 203 27 and and CC 13433 203 28 those those DT 13433 203 29 who who WP 13433 203 30 _ _ NNP 13433 203 31 were be VBD 13433 203 32 _ _ NNP 13433 203 33 with with IN 13433 203 34 him -PRON- PRP 13433 203 35 . . . 13433 203 36 ' ' '' 13433 204 1 But but CC 13433 204 2 even even RB 13433 204 3 the the DT 13433 204 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 204 5 could could MD 13433 204 6 not not RB 13433 204 7 be be VB 13433 204 8 forced force VBN 13433 204 9 into into IN 13433 204 10 such such PDT 13433 204 11 a a DT 13433 204 12 meaning meaning NN 13433 204 13 as as IN 13433 204 14 this this DT 13433 204 15 ; ; : 13433 204 16 and and CC 13433 204 17 , , , 13433 204 18 moreover moreover RB 13433 204 19 , , , 13433 204 20 there there EX 13433 204 21 is be VBZ 13433 204 22 no no DT 13433 204 23 reason reason NN 13433 204 24 to to TO 13433 204 25 impugn impugn VB 13433 204 26 the the DT 13433 204 27 Latin latin JJ 13433 204 28 translation translation NN 13433 204 29 , , , 13433 204 30 except except IN 13433 204 31 the the DT 13433 204 32 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 204 33 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 204 34 presented present VBN 13433 204 35 by by IN 13433 204 36 a a DT 13433 204 37 comparison comparison NN 13433 204 38 with with IN 13433 204 39 the the DT 13433 204 40 ninth ninth JJ 13433 204 41 chapter chapter NN 13433 204 42 . . . 13433 204 43 " " '' 13433 205 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 205 2 21:2 21:2 CD 13433 205 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 205 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 205 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 205 6 , , , 13433 205 7 however however RB 13433 205 8 , , , 13433 205 9 does do VBZ 13433 205 10 impugn impugn VB 13433 205 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 205 12 . . . 13433 206 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 206 2 is be VBZ 13433 206 3 apparently apparently RB 13433 206 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 206 5 habit habit NN 13433 206 6 to to IN 13433 206 7 impugn impugn NNP 13433 206 8 translations translation NNS 13433 206 9 . . . 13433 207 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 207 2 accuses accuse VBZ 13433 207 3 the the DT 13433 207 4 ancient ancient JJ 13433 207 5 Latin latin JJ 13433 207 6 translator translator NN 13433 207 7 of of IN 13433 207 8 freely freely RB 13433 207 9 handling handle VBG 13433 207 10 the the DT 13433 207 11 tenses tense NNS 13433 207 12 of of IN 13433 207 13 a a DT 13433 207 14 Greek greek JJ 13433 207 15 text text NN 13433 207 16 which which WDT 13433 207 17 the the DT 13433 207 18 critic critic NN 13433 207 19 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 207 20 has have VBZ 13433 207 21 never never RB 13433 207 22 seen see VBN 13433 207 23 . . . 13433 208 1 Here here RB 13433 208 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 208 3 is be VBZ 13433 208 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 208 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 208 6 's 's POS 13433 208 7 argument argument NN 13433 208 8 which which WDT 13433 208 9 is be VBZ 13433 208 10 " " `` 13433 208 11 wrecked wreck VBN 13433 208 12 upon upon IN 13433 208 13 this this DT 13433 208 14 rock rock NN 13433 208 15 of of IN 13433 208 16 grammar grammar NN 13433 208 17 . . . 13433 208 18 " " '' 13433 209 1 The the DT 13433 209 2 next next JJ 13433 209 3 example example NN 13433 209 4 of of IN 13433 209 5 the the DT 13433 209 6 " " `` 13433 209 7 weightier weighty JJR 13433 209 8 facts fact NNS 13433 209 9 and and CC 13433 209 10 lines line NNS 13433 209 11 of of IN 13433 209 12 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 209 13 " " '' 13433 209 14 of of IN 13433 209 15 apologists apologist NNS 13433 209 16 which which WDT 13433 209 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 209 18 have have VBP 13433 209 19 ignored ignore VBN 13433 209 20 is be VBZ 13433 209 21 as as IN 13433 209 22 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 13433 209 23 " " `` 13433 209 24 Again again RB 13433 209 25 , , , 13433 209 26 when when WRB 13433 209 27 he -PRON- PRP 13433 209 28 devotes devote VBZ 13433 209 29 more more JJR 13433 209 30 than than IN 13433 209 31 forty forty CD 13433 209 32 pages page NNS 13433 209 33 to to IN 13433 209 34 the the DT 13433 209 35 discussion discussion NN 13433 209 36 of of IN 13433 209 37 Papias Papias NNP 13433 209 38 , , , 13433 209 39 why why WRB 13433 209 40 does do VBZ 13433 209 41 he -PRON- PRP 13433 209 42 not not RB 13433 209 43 even even RB 13433 209 44 mention mention VB 13433 209 45 the the DT 13433 209 46 view view NN 13433 209 47 maintained maintain VBN 13433 209 48 by by IN 13433 209 49 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 209 50 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 209 51 and and CC 13433 209 52 others other NNS 13433 209 53 ( ( -LRB- 13433 209 54 and and CC 13433 209 55 certainly certainly RB 13433 209 56 suggested suggest VBN 13433 209 57 by by IN 13433 209 58 a a DT 13433 209 59 strict strict JJ 13433 209 60 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 209 61 of of IN 13433 209 62 Papias Papias NNP 13433 209 63 ' ' POS 13433 209 64 own own JJ 13433 209 65 words word NNS 13433 209 66 ) ) -RRB- 13433 209 67 , , , 13433 209 68 that that IN 13433 209 69 this this DT 13433 209 70 father father NN 13433 209 71 's 's POS 13433 209 72 object object NN 13433 209 73 , , , 13433 209 74 in in IN 13433 209 75 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 209 76 ' ' `` 13433 209 77 Exposition exposition NN 13433 209 78 , , , 13433 209 79 ' ' '' 13433 209 80 was be VBD 13433 209 81 not not RB 13433 209 82 to to TO 13433 209 83 construct construct VB 13433 209 84 a a DT 13433 209 85 new new JJ 13433 209 86 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 209 87 narrative narrative NN 13433 209 88 , , , 13433 209 89 but but CC 13433 209 90 to to TO 13433 209 91 interpret interpret VB 13433 209 92 and and CC 13433 209 93 to to TO 13433 209 94 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 209 95 by by IN 13433 209 96 oral oral JJ 13433 209 97 tradition tradition NN 13433 209 98 one one CD 13433 209 99 already already RB 13433 209 100 lying lie VBG 13433 209 101 before before IN 13433 209 102 him -PRON- PRP 13433 209 103 in in IN 13433 209 104 written write VBN 13433 209 105 documents document NNS 13433 209 106 ? ? . 13433 210 1 This this DT 13433 210 2 view view NN 13433 210 3 , , , 13433 210 4 if if IN 13433 210 5 correct correct JJ 13433 210 6 , , , 13433 210 7 entirely entirely RB 13433 210 8 alters alter VBZ 13433 210 9 the the DT 13433 210 10 relation relation NN 13433 210 11 of of IN 13433 210 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 210 13 to to IN 13433 210 14 the the DT 13433 210 15 written write VBN 13433 210 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 210 17 ; ; : 13433 210 18 and and CC 13433 210 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 210 20 discussion discussion NN 13433 210 21 was be VBD 13433 210 22 a a DT 13433 210 23 matter matter NN 13433 210 24 of of IN 13433 210 25 essential essential JJ 13433 210 26 importance importance NN 13433 210 27 to to IN 13433 210 28 the the DT 13433 210 29 main main JJ 13433 210 30 question question NN 13433 210 31 at at IN 13433 210 32 issue issue NN 13433 210 33 . . . 13433 210 34 " " '' 13433 211 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 211 2 22:1 22:1 CD 13433 211 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 211 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 211 5 reply reply VBP 13433 211 6 that that IN 13433 211 7 the the DT 13433 211 8 object object NN 13433 211 9 of of IN 13433 211 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 211 11 work work NN 13433 211 12 was be VBD 13433 211 13 not not RB 13433 211 14 to to TO 13433 211 15 discuss discuss VB 13433 211 16 views view NNS 13433 211 17 advanced advanced JJ 13433 211 18 without without IN 13433 211 19 a a DT 13433 211 20 shadow shadow NN 13433 211 21 of of IN 13433 211 22 evidence evidence NN 13433 211 23 , , , 13433 211 24 contradicted contradict VBN 13433 211 25 by by IN 13433 211 26 the the DT 13433 211 27 words word NNS 13433 211 28 of of IN 13433 211 29 Papias Papias NNP 13433 211 30 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 211 31 , , , 13433 211 32 and and CC 13433 211 33 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 211 34 incapable incapable JJ 13433 211 35 of of IN 13433 211 36 proof proof NN 13433 211 37 . . . 13433 212 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 212 2 object object NN 13433 212 3 was be VBD 13433 212 4 the the DT 13433 212 5 much much RB 13433 212 6 more more RBR 13433 212 7 practical practical JJ 13433 212 8 and and CC 13433 212 9 direct direct JJ 13433 212 10 one one CD 13433 212 11 of of IN 13433 212 12 ascertaining ascertaining NN 13433 212 13 whether whether IN 13433 212 14 Papias Papias NNP 13433 212 15 affords afford VBZ 13433 212 16 any any DT 13433 212 17 evidence evidence NN 13433 212 18 with with IN 13433 212 19 regard regard NN 13433 212 20 to to IN 13433 212 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 212 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 212 23 which which WDT 13433 212 24 could could MD 13433 212 25 warrant warrant VB 13433 212 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 212 27 believing believe VBG 13433 212 28 in in IN 13433 212 29 the the DT 13433 212 30 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 212 31 of of IN 13433 212 32 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 212 33 events event NNS 13433 212 34 for for IN 13433 212 35 which which WDT 13433 212 36 they -PRON- PRP 13433 212 37 are be VBP 13433 212 38 the the DT 13433 212 39 principal principal JJ 13433 212 40 testimony testimony NN 13433 212 41 . . . 13433 213 1 Even even RB 13433 213 2 if if IN 13433 213 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 213 4 could could MD 13433 213 5 be be VB 13433 213 6 proved prove VBN 13433 213 7 , , , 13433 213 8 which which WDT 13433 213 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 213 10 can can MD 13433 213 11 not not RB 13433 213 12 be be VB 13433 213 13 , , , 13433 213 14 that that IN 13433 213 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 213 16 actually actually RB 13433 213 17 had have VBD 13433 213 18 " " `` 13433 213 19 written write VBN 13433 213 20 documents document NNS 13433 213 21 " " '' 13433 213 22 before before IN 13433 213 23 him -PRON- PRP 13433 213 24 , , , 13433 213 25 the the DT 13433 213 26 cause cause NN 13433 213 27 of of IN 13433 213 28 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 213 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 213 30 would would MD 13433 213 31 not not RB 13433 213 32 be be VB 13433 213 33 one one CD 13433 213 34 jot jot NNP 13433 213 35 advanced advance VBN 13433 213 36 , , , 13433 213 37 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 13433 213 38 as as IN 13433 213 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 213 40 could could MD 13433 213 41 not not RB 13433 213 42 be be VB 13433 213 43 shown show VBN 13433 213 44 that that IN 13433 213 45 these these DT 13433 213 46 documents document NNS 13433 213 47 were be VBD 13433 213 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 213 49 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 213 50 ; ; : 13433 213 51 and and CC 13433 213 52 the the DT 13433 213 53 avowed avowed JJ 13433 213 54 preference preference NN 13433 213 55 of of IN 13433 213 56 Papias Papias NNP 13433 213 57 for for IN 13433 213 58 tradition tradition NN 13433 213 59 over over IN 13433 213 60 books book NNS 13433 213 61 , , , 13433 213 62 so so RB 13433 213 63 clearly clearly RB 13433 213 64 expressed express VBN 13433 213 65 , , , 13433 213 66 implies imply VBZ 13433 213 67 anything anything NN 13433 213 68 but but IN 13433 213 69 respect respect NN 13433 213 70 for for IN 13433 213 71 any any DT 13433 213 72 written write VBN 13433 213 73 documents document NNS 13433 213 74 with with IN 13433 213 75 which which WDT 13433 213 76 he -PRON- PRP 13433 213 77 was be VBD 13433 213 78 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 213 79 . . . 13433 214 1 However however WRB 13433 214 2 important important JJ 13433 214 3 such such PDT 13433 214 4 a a DT 13433 214 5 discussion discussion NN 13433 214 6 may may MD 13433 214 7 appear appear VB 13433 214 8 to to IN 13433 214 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 214 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 214 11 in in IN 13433 214 12 the the DT 13433 214 13 absence absence NN 13433 214 14 of of IN 13433 214 15 other other JJ 13433 214 16 evidence evidence NN 13433 214 17 , , , 13433 214 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 214 19 is be VBZ 13433 214 20 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 214 21 devoid devoid JJ 13433 214 22 of of IN 13433 214 23 value value NN 13433 214 24 in in IN 13433 214 25 an an DT 13433 214 26 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 214 27 into into IN 13433 214 28 the the DT 13433 214 29 reality reality NN 13433 214 30 of of IN 13433 214 31 Divine Divine NNP 13433 214 32 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 214 33 . . . 13433 215 1 The the DT 13433 215 2 next next JJ 13433 215 3 " " `` 13433 215 4 sample sample NN 13433 215 5 " " '' 13433 215 6 of of IN 13433 215 7 these these DT 13433 215 8 ignored ignore VBN 13433 215 9 " " `` 13433 215 10 weightier weighty JJR 13433 215 11 facts fact NNS 13433 215 12 and and CC 13433 215 13 lines line NNS 13433 215 14 of of IN 13433 215 15 reasoning reason VBG 13433 215 16 " " `` 13433 215 17 given give VBN 13433 215 18 by by IN 13433 215 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 215 20 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 215 21 is be VBZ 13433 215 22 the the DT 13433 215 23 following follow VBG 13433 215 24 : : : 13433 215 25 " " `` 13433 215 26 Again again RB 13433 215 27 , , , 13433 215 28 when when WRB 13433 215 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 215 30 reproduces reproduce VBZ 13433 215 31 the the DT 13433 215 32 Tübingen Tübingen NNP 13433 215 33 fallacy fallacy NN 13433 215 34 respecting respect VBG 13433 215 35 ' ' '' 13433 215 36 the the DT 13433 215 37 strong strong JJ 13433 215 38 prejudice prejudice NN 13433 215 39 ' ' '' 13433 215 40 of of IN 13433 215 41 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 215 42 against against IN 13433 215 43 St. St. NNP 13433 215 44 Paul Paul NNP 13433 215 45 , , , 13433 215 46 and and CC 13433 215 47 quotes quote VBZ 13433 215 48 the the DT 13433 215 49 often often RB 13433 215 50 - - HYPH 13433 215 51 quoted quote VBN 13433 215 52 passage passage NN 13433 215 53 from from IN 13433 215 54 Stephanus Stephanus NNP 13433 215 55 Gobarus Gobarus NNP 13433 215 56 , , , 13433 215 57 in in IN 13433 215 58 which which WDT 13433 215 59 this this DT 13433 215 60 writer writer NN 13433 215 61 refers refer VBZ 13433 215 62 to to IN 13433 215 63 the the DT 13433 215 64 language language NN 13433 215 65 of of IN 13433 215 66 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 215 67 condemning condemn VBG 13433 215 68 the the DT 13433 215 69 use use NN 13433 215 70 of of IN 13433 215 71 the the DT 13433 215 72 words word NNS 13433 215 73 , , , 13433 215 74 ' ' '' 13433 215 75 Eye eye NN 13433 215 76 hath hath NN 13433 215 77 not not RB 13433 215 78 seen see VBN 13433 215 79 , , , 13433 215 80 ' ' '' 13433 215 81 & & CC 13433 215 82 c. c. NNP 13433 215 83 , , , 13433 215 84 why why WRB 13433 215 85 does do VBZ 13433 215 86 he -PRON- PRP 13433 215 87 not not RB 13433 215 88 state state VB 13433 215 89 that that IN 13433 215 90 these these DT 13433 215 91 words word NNS 13433 215 92 were be VBD 13433 215 93 employed employ VBN 13433 215 94 by by IN 13433 215 95 heretical heretical JJ 13433 215 96 teachers teacher NNS 13433 215 97 to to TO 13433 215 98 justify justify VB 13433 215 99 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 215 100 rites rite NNS 13433 215 101 of of IN 13433 215 102 initiation initiation NN 13433 215 103 , , , 13433 215 104 and and CC 13433 215 105 consequently consequently RB 13433 215 106 ' ' `` 13433 215 107 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 215 108 ' ' '' 13433 215 109 writers writer NNS 13433 215 110 contend contend VBP 13433 215 111 that that IN 13433 215 112 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 215 113 refers refer VBZ 13433 215 114 to to IN 13433 215 115 the the DT 13433 215 116 words word NNS 13433 215 117 , , , 13433 215 118 not not RB 13433 215 119 as as IN 13433 215 120 used use VBN 13433 215 121 by by IN 13433 215 122 St. St. NNP 13433 215 123 Paul Paul NNP 13433 215 124 , , , 13433 215 125 but but CC 13433 215 126 as as IN 13433 215 127 misapplied misapply VBN 13433 215 128 by by IN 13433 215 129 these these DT 13433 215 130 heretics heretic NNS 13433 215 131 ? ? . 13433 216 1 Since since IN 13433 216 2 , , , 13433 216 3 according accord VBG 13433 216 4 to to IN 13433 216 5 the the DT 13433 216 6 Tübingen Tübingen NNP 13433 216 7 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 216 8 , , , 13433 216 9 this this DT 13433 216 10 single single JJ 13433 216 11 notice notice NN 13433 216 12 contradicts contradict VBZ 13433 216 13 everything everything NN 13433 216 14 else else RB 13433 216 15 which which WDT 13433 216 16 we -PRON- PRP 13433 216 17 now now RB 13433 216 18 of of IN 13433 216 19 the the DT 13433 216 20 opinions opinion NNS 13433 216 21 of of IN 13433 216 22 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 216 23 , , , 13433 216 24 the the DT 13433 216 25 view view NN 13433 216 26 of of IN 13433 216 27 ' ' `` 13433 216 28 apologists apologist NNS 13433 216 29 ' ' '' 13433 216 30 might might NN 13433 216 31 , , , 13433 216 32 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 216 33 , , , 13433 216 34 have have VBP 13433 216 35 been be VBN 13433 216 36 worth worth JJ 13433 216 37 a a DT 13433 216 38 moment moment NN 13433 216 39 's 's POS 13433 216 40 consideration consideration NN 13433 216 41 . . . 13433 216 42 " " '' 13433 217 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 217 2 23:1 23:1 CD 13433 217 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 217 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 217 5 reply reply VBP 13433 217 6 , , , 13433 217 7 why why WRB 13433 217 8 does do VBZ 13433 217 9 this this DT 13433 217 10 punctilious punctilious JJ 13433 217 11 objector objector NN 13433 217 12 omit omit NN 13433 217 13 to to TO 13433 217 14 point point VB 13433 217 15 out out RP 13433 217 16 that that IN 13433 217 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 217 18 merely merely RB 13433 217 19 mention mention VBP 13433 217 20 the the DT 13433 217 21 anti anti JJ 13433 217 22 - - JJ 13433 217 23 Pauline pauline JJ 13433 217 24 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 217 25 incidentally incidentally RB 13433 217 26 in in IN 13433 217 27 a a DT 13433 217 28 single single JJ 13433 217 29 sentence sentence NN 13433 217 30 , , , 13433 217 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 217 32 23:2 23:2 CD 13433 217 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 217 34 and and CC 13433 217 35 after after IN 13433 217 36 a a DT 13433 217 37 few few JJ 13433 217 38 words word NNS 13433 217 39 as as IN 13433 217 40 to to IN 13433 217 41 the the DT 13433 217 42 source source NN 13433 217 43 of of IN 13433 217 44 the the DT 13433 217 45 quotation quotation NN 13433 217 46 in in IN 13433 217 47 Cor Cor NNP 13433 217 48 . . . 13433 218 1 ii ii LS 13433 218 2 . . . 13433 219 1 9 9 LS 13433 219 2 , , , 13433 219 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 219 4 proceed proceed VBP 13433 219 5 : : : 13433 219 6 " " `` 13433 219 7 This this DT 13433 219 8 , , , 13433 219 9 however however RB 13433 219 10 , , , 13433 219 11 does do VBZ 13433 219 12 not not RB 13433 219 13 concern concern VB 13433 219 14 us -PRON- PRP 13433 219 15 here here RB 13433 219 16 , , , 13433 219 17 and and CC 13433 219 18 we -PRON- PRP 13433 219 19 have have VBP 13433 219 20 merely merely RB 13433 219 21 to to TO 13433 219 22 examine examine VB 13433 219 23 ' ' '' 13433 219 24 the the DT 13433 219 25 saying saying NN 13433 219 26 of of IN 13433 219 27 the the DT 13433 219 28 Lord Lord NNP 13433 219 29 , , , 13433 219 30 ' ' '' 13433 219 31 which which WDT 13433 219 32 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 219 33 opposes oppose VBZ 13433 219 34 to to IN 13433 219 35 the the DT 13433 219 36 passage passage NN 13433 219 37 , , , 13433 219 38 ' ' '' 13433 219 39 Blessed bless VBN 13433 219 40 are be VBP 13433 219 41 your -PRON- PRP$ 13433 219 42 eyes eye NNS 13433 219 43 , , , 13433 219 44 ' ' '' 13433 219 45 " " '' 13433 219 46 & & CC 13433 219 47 c. c. NNP 13433 219 48 , , , 13433 219 49 this this DT 13433 219 50 being being NN 13433 219 51 , , , 13433 219 52 in in IN 13433 219 53 fact fact NN 13433 219 54 , , , 13433 219 55 the the DT 13433 219 56 sole sole JJ 13433 219 57 object object NN 13433 219 58 of of IN 13433 219 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 219 60 quotation quotation NN 13433 219 61 from from IN 13433 219 62 Stephanus Stephanus NNP 13433 219 63 Gobarus Gobarus NNP 13433 219 64 ? ? . 13433 220 1 Why why WRB 13433 220 2 does do VBZ 13433 220 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 220 4 not not RB 13433 220 5 also also RB 13433 220 6 state state VBP 13433 220 7 that that IN 13433 220 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 220 9 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 220 10 refer refer VBP 13433 220 11 to to IN 13433 220 12 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 220 13 's 's POS 13433 220 14 denial denial NN 13433 220 15 that that IN 13433 220 16 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 220 17 was be VBD 13433 220 18 opposed opposed JJ 13433 220 19 to to IN 13433 220 20 Paul Paul NNP 13433 220 21 ? ? . 13433 221 1 And and CC 13433 221 2 why why WRB 13433 221 3 does do VBZ 13433 221 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 221 5 not not RB 13433 221 6 further further JJ 13433 221 7 state state NN 13433 221 8 that that IN 13433 221 9 , , , 13433 221 10 instead instead RB 13433 221 11 of of IN 13433 221 12 being be VBG 13433 221 13 the the DT 13433 221 14 " " `` 13433 221 15 single single JJ 13433 221 16 notice notice NN 13433 221 17 " " '' 13433 221 18 from from IN 13433 221 19 which which WDT 13433 221 20 the the DT 13433 221 21 view view NN 13433 221 22 of of IN 13433 221 23 the the DT 13433 221 24 anti anti JJ 13433 221 25 - - JJ 13433 221 26 Pauline pauline JJ 13433 221 27 feelings feeling NNS 13433 221 28 of of IN 13433 221 29 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 221 30 is be VBZ 13433 221 31 derived derive VBN 13433 221 32 , , , 13433 221 33 that that DT 13433 221 34 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 221 35 is be VBZ 13433 221 36 based base VBN 13433 221 37 upon upon IN 13433 221 38 the the DT 13433 221 39 whole whole JJ 13433 221 40 tendency tendency NN 13433 221 41 of of IN 13433 221 42 the the DT 13433 221 43 fragments fragment NNS 13433 221 44 of of IN 13433 221 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 221 46 writings writing NNS 13433 221 47 which which WDT 13433 221 48 remain remain VBP 13433 221 49 ? ? . 13433 222 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 222 2 was be VBD 13433 222 3 not not RB 13433 222 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 222 5 purpose purpose NN 13433 222 6 to to TO 13433 222 7 enter enter VB 13433 222 8 into into IN 13433 222 9 any any DT 13433 222 10 discussion discussion NN 13433 222 11 of of IN 13433 222 12 the the DT 13433 222 13 feeling feeling NN 13433 222 14 against against IN 13433 222 15 Paul Paul NNP 13433 222 16 entertained entertain VBN 13433 222 17 by by IN 13433 222 18 a a DT 13433 222 19 large large JJ 13433 222 20 section section NN 13433 222 21 of of IN 13433 222 22 the the DT 13433 222 23 early early JJ 13433 222 24 Church Church NNP 13433 222 25 . . . 13433 223 1 What what WP 13433 223 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 223 3 have have VBP 13433 223 4 to to TO 13433 223 5 say say VB 13433 223 6 upon upon IN 13433 223 7 that that DT 13433 223 8 subject subject NN 13433 223 9 will will MD 13433 223 10 appear appear VB 13433 223 11 in in IN 13433 223 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 223 13 examination examination NN 13433 223 14 of of IN 13433 223 15 the the DT 13433 223 16 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 223 17 of of IN 13433 223 18 the the DT 13433 223 19 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 223 20 . . . 13433 224 1 " " `` 13433 224 2 And and CC 13433 224 3 again again RB 13433 224 4 , , , 13433 224 5 " " '' 13433 224 6 says say VBZ 13433 224 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 224 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 224 9 , , , 13433 224 10 proceeding proceed VBG 13433 224 11 with with IN 13433 224 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 224 13 samples sample NNS 13433 224 14 of of IN 13433 224 15 ignored ignore VBN 13433 224 16 weightier weighty JJR 13433 224 17 lines line NNS 13433 224 18 of of IN 13433 224 19 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 224 20 , , , 13433 224 21 " " '' 13433 224 22 in in IN 13433 224 23 the the DT 13433 224 24 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 224 25 examination examination NN 13433 224 26 of of IN 13433 224 27 Justin Justin NNP 13433 224 28 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 224 29 's 's POS 13433 224 30 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 224 31 quotations quotation NNS 13433 224 32 ... ... NFP 13433 224 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 224 34 author author NN 13433 224 35 frequently frequently RB 13433 224 36 refers refer VBZ 13433 224 37 to to IN 13433 224 38 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 224 39 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 224 40 's 's POS 13433 224 41 book book NN 13433 224 42 to to TO 13433 224 43 censure censure VB 13433 224 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 224 45 , , , 13433 224 46 and and CC 13433 224 47 many many JJ 13433 224 48 comparatively comparatively JJ 13433 224 49 insignificant insignificant JJ 13433 224 50 points point NNS 13433 224 51 are be VBP 13433 224 52 discussed discuss VBN 13433 224 53 at at IN 13433 224 54 great great JJ 13433 224 55 length length NN 13433 224 56 . . . 13433 225 1 Why why WRB 13433 225 2 , , , 13433 225 3 then then RB 13433 225 4 , , , 13433 225 5 does do VBZ 13433 225 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 225 7 not not RB 13433 225 8 once once RB 13433 225 9 mention mention VB 13433 225 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 225 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 225 12 's 's POS 13433 225 13 argument argument NN 13433 225 14 founded found VBD 13433 225 15 on on IN 13433 225 16 the the DT 13433 225 17 looseness looseness NN 13433 225 18 of of IN 13433 225 19 Justin Justin NNP 13433 225 20 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 225 21 's 's POS 13433 225 22 quotations quotation NNS 13433 225 23 from from IN 13433 225 24 the the DT 13433 225 25 Old Old NNP 13433 225 26 Testament Testament NNP 13433 225 27 as as IN 13433 225 28 throwing throw VBG 13433 225 29 some some DT 13433 225 30 light light NN 13433 225 31 on on IN 13433 225 32 the the DT 13433 225 33 degree degree NN 13433 225 34 of of IN 13433 225 35 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 225 36 which which WDT 13433 225 37 he -PRON- PRP 13433 225 38 might may MD 13433 225 39 be be VB 13433 225 40 expected expect VBN 13433 225 41 to to TO 13433 225 42 show show VB 13433 225 43 in in IN 13433 225 44 quoting quote VBG 13433 225 45 the the DT 13433 225 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 225 47 ? ? . 13433 226 1 A a DT 13433 226 2 reader reader NN 13433 226 3 fresh fresh JJ 13433 226 4 from from IN 13433 226 5 the the DT 13433 226 6 perusal perusal NN 13433 226 7 of of IN 13433 226 8 _ _ NNP 13433 226 9 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 226 10 Religion Religion NNP 13433 226 11 _ _ NNP 13433 226 12 will will MD 13433 226 13 have have VB 13433 226 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 226 15 eyes eye NNS 13433 226 16 opened open VBN 13433 226 17 as as IN 13433 226 18 to to IN 13433 226 19 the the DT 13433 226 20 character character NN 13433 226 21 of of IN 13433 226 22 Justin Justin NNP 13433 226 23 's 's POS 13433 226 24 mind mind NN 13433 226 25 when when WRB 13433 226 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 226 27 turns turn VBZ 13433 226 28 to to IN 13433 226 29 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 226 30 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 226 31 's 's POS 13433 226 32 book book NN 13433 226 33 , , , 13433 226 34 and and CC 13433 226 35 finds find VBZ 13433 226 36 how how WRB 13433 226 37 Justin Justin NNP 13433 226 38 interweaves interweave NNS 13433 226 39 , , , 13433 226 40 misnames misname NNS 13433 226 41 , , , 13433 226 42 and and CC 13433 226 43 misquotes misquote VBZ 13433 226 44 passages passage NNS 13433 226 45 from from IN 13433 226 46 the the DT 13433 226 47 Old Old NNP 13433 226 48 Testament Testament NNP 13433 226 49 . . . 13433 227 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 227 2 can can MD 13433 227 3 not not RB 13433 227 4 be be VB 13433 227 5 said say VBN 13433 227 6 that that IN 13433 227 7 these these DT 13433 227 8 are be VBP 13433 227 9 unimportant unimportant JJ 13433 227 10 points point NNS 13433 227 11 . . . 13433 227 12 " " '' 13433 228 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 228 2 24:1 24:1 CD 13433 228 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 228 4 Now now RB 13433 228 5 the the DT 13433 228 6 fact fact NN 13433 228 7 is be VBZ 13433 228 8 , , , 13433 228 9 that that IN 13433 228 10 in in IN 13433 228 11 the the DT 13433 228 12 first first JJ 13433 228 13 105 105 CD 13433 228 14 pages page NNS 13433 228 15 of of IN 13433 228 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 228 17 examination examination NN 13433 228 18 of of IN 13433 228 19 Justin Justin NNP 13433 228 20 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 228 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 228 22 do do VBP 13433 228 23 not not RB 13433 228 24 once once RB 13433 228 25 refer refer VB 13433 228 26 in in IN 13433 228 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 228 28 text text NN 13433 228 29 to to IN 13433 228 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 228 31 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 228 32 's 's POS 13433 228 33 work work NN 13433 228 34 ; ; : 13433 228 35 and and CC 13433 228 36 when when WRB 13433 228 37 I -PRON- PRP 13433 228 38 finally finally RB 13433 228 39 do do VBP 13433 228 40 so so RB 13433 228 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 228 42 is be VBZ 13433 228 43 for for IN 13433 228 44 the the DT 13433 228 45 purposes purpose NNS 13433 228 46 of of IN 13433 228 47 discussing discuss VBG 13433 228 48 what what WP 13433 228 49 seemed seem VBD 13433 228 50 to to IN 13433 228 51 me -PRON- PRP 13433 228 52 a a DT 13433 228 53 singular singular JJ 13433 228 54 argument argument NN 13433 228 55 , , , 13433 228 56 demanding demand VBG 13433 228 57 a a DT 13433 228 58 moment moment NN 13433 228 59 's 's POS 13433 228 60 attention attention NN 13433 228 61 . . . 13433 229 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 229 2 24:2 24:2 CD 13433 229 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 229 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 229 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 229 6 , , , 13433 229 7 whilst whilst IN 13433 229 8 maintaining maintain VBG 13433 229 9 that that IN 13433 229 10 Justin Justin NNP 13433 229 11 's 's POS 13433 229 12 quotations quotation NNS 13433 229 13 are be VBP 13433 229 14 derived derive VBN 13433 229 15 from from IN 13433 229 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 229 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 229 18 , , , 13433 229 19 argues argue VBZ 13433 229 20 that that IN 13433 229 21 only only RB 13433 229 22 in in IN 13433 229 23 seven seven CD 13433 229 24 passages passage NNS 13433 229 25 out out IN 13433 229 26 of of IN 13433 229 27 the the DT 13433 229 28 very very RB 13433 229 29 numerous numerous JJ 13433 229 30 citations citation NNS 13433 229 31 in in IN 13433 229 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 229 33 writings writing NNS 13433 229 34 " " '' 13433 229 35 does do VBZ 13433 229 36 Justin Justin NNP 13433 229 37 profess profess NN 13433 229 38 to to TO 13433 229 39 give give VB 13433 229 40 the the DT 13433 229 41 exact exact JJ 13433 229 42 words word NNS 13433 229 43 recorded record VBN 13433 229 44 in in IN 13433 229 45 the the DT 13433 229 46 ' ' `` 13433 229 47 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 13433 229 48 . . . 13433 229 49 ' ' '' 13433 229 50 " " '' 13433 230 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 230 2 24:3 24:3 CD 13433 230 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 230 4 The the DT 13433 230 5 reason reason NN 13433 230 6 why why WRB 13433 230 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 230 8 do do VBP 13433 230 9 not not RB 13433 230 10 feel feel VB 13433 230 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 230 12 at at RB 13433 230 13 all all RB 13433 230 14 necessary necessary JJ 13433 230 15 to to TO 13433 230 16 discuss discuss VB 13433 230 17 the the DT 13433 230 18 other other JJ 13433 230 19 views view NNS 13433 230 20 of of IN 13433 230 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 230 22 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 230 23 here here RB 13433 230 24 mentioned mention VBN 13433 230 25 is be VBZ 13433 230 26 practically practically RB 13433 230 27 given give VBN 13433 230 28 in in IN 13433 230 29 the the DT 13433 230 30 final final JJ 13433 230 31 sentence sentence NN 13433 230 32 of of IN 13433 230 33 a a DT 13433 230 34 note note NN 13433 230 35 quoted quote VBN 13433 230 36 by by IN 13433 230 37 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 230 38 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 230 39 , , , 13433 230 40 [ [ -LRB- 13433 230 41 24:4 24:4 CD 13433 230 42 ] ] -RRB- 13433 230 43 which which WDT 13433 230 44 sentence sentence NN 13433 230 45 he -PRON- PRP 13433 230 46 has have VBZ 13433 230 47 thought think VBN 13433 230 48 it -PRON- PRP 13433 230 49 right right JJ 13433 230 50 to to TO 13433 230 51 omit omit VB 13433 230 52 . . . 13433 231 1 The the DT 13433 231 2 note note NN 13433 231 3 is be VBZ 13433 231 4 as as IN 13433 231 5 follows follow VBZ 13433 231 6 , , , 13433 231 7 and and CC 13433 231 8 the the DT 13433 231 9 sentence sentence NN 13433 231 10 to to TO 13433 231 11 which which WDT 13433 231 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 231 13 refer refer VBP 13433 231 14 is be VBZ 13433 231 15 put put VBN 13433 231 16 in in IN 13433 231 17 italics italic NNS 13433 231 18 : : : 13433 231 19 " " `` 13433 231 20 For for IN 13433 231 21 the the DT 13433 231 22 arguments argument NNS 13433 231 23 of of IN 13433 231 24 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 231 25 criticism criticism NN 13433 231 26 , , , 13433 231 27 the the DT 13433 231 28 reader reader NN 13433 231 29 may may MD 13433 231 30 be be VB 13433 231 31 referred refer VBN 13433 231 32 to to IN 13433 231 33 Canon Canon NNP 13433 231 34 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 231 35 's 's POS 13433 231 36 work work NN 13433 231 37 ' ' '' 13433 231 38 On on IN 13433 231 39 the the DT 13433 231 40 Canon Canon NNP 13433 231 41 , , , 13433 231 42 ' ' '' 13433 231 43 pp pp NN 13433 231 44 . . . 13433 232 1 112 112 CD 13433 232 2 - - SYM 13433 232 3 139 139 CD 13433 232 4 . . . 13433 233 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 233 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 233 3 does do VBZ 13433 233 4 not not RB 13433 233 5 attempt attempt VB 13433 233 6 to to TO 13433 233 7 deny deny VB 13433 233 8 the the DT 13433 233 9 fact fact NN 13433 233 10 that that IN 13433 233 11 Justin Justin NNP 13433 233 12 's 's POS 13433 233 13 quotations quotation NNS 13433 233 14 are be VBP 13433 233 15 different different JJ 13433 233 16 from from IN 13433 233 17 the the DT 13433 233 18 text text NN 13433 233 19 of of IN 13433 233 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 233 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 233 22 , , , 13433 233 23 but but CC 13433 233 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 233 25 accounts account VBZ 13433 233 26 for for IN 13433 233 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 233 28 variations variation NNS 13433 233 29 on on IN 13433 233 30 grounds ground NNS 13433 233 31 which which WDT 13433 233 32 are be VBP 13433 233 33 purely purely RB 13433 233 34 imaginary imaginary JJ 13433 233 35 . . . 13433 234 1 _ _ NNP 13433 234 2 It -PRON- PRP 13433 234 3 is be VBZ 13433 234 4 evident evident JJ 13433 234 5 that that IN 13433 234 6 so so RB 13433 234 7 long long RB 13433 234 8 as as IN 13433 234 9 there there EX 13433 234 10 are be VBP 13433 234 11 such such JJ 13433 234 12 variations variation NNS 13433 234 13 to to TO 13433 234 14 be be VB 13433 234 15 explained explain VBN 13433 234 16 away away RP 13433 234 17 , , , 13433 234 18 at at IN 13433 234 19 least least JJS 13433 234 20 no no DT 13433 234 21 proof proof NN 13433 234 22 of of IN 13433 234 23 identity identity NN 13433 234 24 is be VBZ 13433 234 25 possible possible JJ 13433 234 26 _ _ NNP 13433 234 27 . . . 13433 234 28 " " '' 13433 235 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 235 2 24:5 24:5 CD 13433 235 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 235 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 235 5 will will MD 13433 235 6 be be VB 13433 235 7 observed observe VBN 13433 235 8 that that IN 13433 235 9 although although IN 13433 235 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 235 11 do do VBP 13433 235 12 not not RB 13433 235 13 discuss discuss VB 13433 235 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 235 15 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 235 16 's 's POS 13433 235 17 views view NNS 13433 235 18 , , , 13433 235 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 235 20 pointedly pointedly RB 13433 235 21 refer refer VBP 13433 235 22 those those DT 13433 235 23 who who WP 13433 235 24 desire desire VBP 13433 235 25 to to TO 13433 235 26 know know VB 13433 235 27 what what WP 13433 235 28 the the DT 13433 235 29 arguments argument NNS 13433 235 30 on on IN 13433 235 31 the the DT 13433 235 32 other other JJ 13433 235 33 side side NN 13433 235 34 are be VBP 13433 235 35 to to IN 13433 235 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 235 37 work work NN 13433 235 38 . . . 13433 236 1 Let let VB 13433 236 2 me -PRON- PRP 13433 236 3 repeat repeat VB 13433 236 4 , , , 13433 236 5 once once RB 13433 236 6 for for IN 13433 236 7 all all DT 13433 236 8 , , , 13433 236 9 that that IN 13433 236 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 236 11 object object NN 13433 236 12 in in IN 13433 236 13 examining examine VBG 13433 236 14 the the DT 13433 236 15 writings writing NNS 13433 236 16 of of IN 13433 236 17 the the DT 13433 236 18 Fathers father NNS 13433 236 19 is be VBZ 13433 236 20 not not RB 13433 236 21 to to TO 13433 236 22 form form VB 13433 236 23 theories theory NNS 13433 236 24 and and CC 13433 236 25 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 236 26 as as IN 13433 236 27 to to IN 13433 236 28 what what WDT 13433 236 29 documents document NNS 13433 236 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 236 31 may may MD 13433 236 32 possibly possibly RB 13433 236 33 have have VB 13433 236 34 used use VBN 13433 236 35 , , , 13433 236 36 but but CC 13433 236 37 to to TO 13433 236 38 ascertain ascertain VB 13433 236 39 whether whether IN 13433 236 40 they -PRON- PRP 13433 236 41 afford afford VBP 13433 236 42 any any DT 13433 236 43 positive positive JJ 13433 236 44 evidence evidence NN 13433 236 45 regarding regard VBG 13433 236 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 236 47 existing exist VBG 13433 236 48 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 236 49 , , , 13433 236 50 which which WDT 13433 236 51 can can MD 13433 236 52 warrant warrant VB 13433 236 53 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 236 54 believing believing NN 13433 236 55 , , , 13433 236 56 upon upon IN 13433 236 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 236 58 authority authority NN 13433 236 59 , , , 13433 236 60 the the DT 13433 236 61 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 236 62 contents content NNS 13433 236 63 of of IN 13433 236 64 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 236 65 . . . 13433 237 1 Any any DT 13433 237 2 argument argument NN 13433 237 3 that that IN 13433 237 4 , , , 13433 237 5 although although IN 13433 237 6 Justin Justin NNP 13433 237 7 , , , 13433 237 8 for for IN 13433 237 9 instance instance NN 13433 237 10 , , , 13433 237 11 never never RB 13433 237 12 once once RB 13433 237 13 names name NNS 13433 237 14 any any DT 13433 237 15 of of IN 13433 237 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 237 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 237 18 , , , 13433 237 19 and and CC 13433 237 20 out out IN 13433 237 21 of of IN 13433 237 22 very very RB 13433 237 23 numerous numerous JJ 13433 237 24 quotations quotation NNS 13433 237 25 of of IN 13433 237 26 sayings saying NNS 13433 237 27 of of IN 13433 237 28 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 237 29 very very RB 13433 237 30 rarely rarely RB 13433 237 31 indeed indeed RB 13433 237 32 quotes quote VBZ 13433 237 33 anything anything NN 13433 237 34 which which WDT 13433 237 35 has have VBZ 13433 237 36 an an DT 13433 237 37 exact exact JJ 13433 237 38 parallel parallel NN 13433 237 39 in in IN 13433 237 40 those those DT 13433 237 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 237 42 , , , 13433 237 43 yet yet CC 13433 237 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 237 45 may may MD 13433 237 46 have have VB 13433 237 47 made make VBN 13433 237 48 use use NN 13433 237 49 of of IN 13433 237 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 237 51 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 237 52 , , , 13433 237 53 because because IN 13433 237 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 237 55 also also RB 13433 237 56 frequently frequently RB 13433 237 57 misquotes misquote VBZ 13433 237 58 passages passage NNS 13433 237 59 from from IN 13433 237 60 the the DT 13433 237 61 Old Old NNP 13433 237 62 Testament Testament NNP 13433 237 63 , , , 13433 237 64 is be VBZ 13433 237 65 worthless worthless JJ 13433 237 66 for for IN 13433 237 67 the the DT 13433 237 68 purpose purpose NN 13433 237 69 of of IN 13433 237 70 establishing establish VBG 13433 237 71 the the DT 13433 237 72 reality reality NN 13433 237 73 of of IN 13433 237 74 Divine Divine NNP 13433 237 75 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 237 76 . . . 13433 238 1 From from IN 13433 238 2 the the DT 13433 238 3 point point NN 13433 238 4 of of IN 13433 238 5 view view NN 13433 238 6 of of IN 13433 238 7 such such PDT 13433 238 8 an an DT 13433 238 9 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 238 10 , , , 13433 238 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 238 12 probably probably RB 13433 238 13 go go VBP 13433 238 14 much much RB 13433 238 15 further further RB 13433 238 16 into into IN 13433 238 17 the the DT 13433 238 18 examination examination NN 13433 238 19 of of IN 13433 238 20 Justin Justin NNP 13433 238 21 's 's POS 13433 238 22 " " `` 13433 238 23 Memoirs Memoirs NNPS 13433 238 24 " " '' 13433 238 25 than than IN 13433 238 26 was be VBD 13433 238 27 at at RB 13433 238 28 all all RB 13433 238 29 necessary necessary JJ 13433 238 30 . . . 13433 239 1 Space space NN 13433 239 2 , , , 13433 239 3 however however RB 13433 239 4 , , , 13433 239 5 forbids forbid NNS 13433 239 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 239 7 further further JJ 13433 239 8 dwelling dwelling NN 13433 239 9 on on IN 13433 239 10 these these DT 13433 239 11 instances instance NNS 13433 239 12 , , , 13433 239 13 regarding regard VBG 13433 239 14 which which WDT 13433 239 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 239 16 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 239 17 says say VBZ 13433 239 18 : : : 13433 239 19 " " `` 13433 239 20 In in IN 13433 239 21 every every DT 13433 239 22 instance instance NN 13433 239 23 which which WDT 13433 239 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 239 25 have have VBP 13433 239 26 selected"--and selected"--and CD 13433 239 27 to to TO 13433 239 28 which which WDT 13433 239 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 239 30 have have VBP 13433 239 31 replied--"these replied--"these : 13433 239 32 omitted omit VBN 13433 239 33 considerations consideration NNS 13433 239 34 vitally vitally RB 13433 239 35 affect affect VBP 13433 239 36 the the DT 13433 239 37 main main JJ 13433 239 38 question question NN 13433 239 39 at at IN 13433 239 40 issue issue NN 13433 239 41 . . . 13433 239 42 " " '' 13433 240 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 240 2 25:1 25:1 CD 13433 240 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 240 4 If if IN 13433 240 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 240 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 240 7 had have VBD 13433 240 8 devoted devote VBN 13433 240 9 half half PDT 13433 240 10 the the DT 13433 240 11 time time NN 13433 240 12 to to IN 13433 240 13 mastering master VBG 13433 240 14 what what WP 13433 240 15 " " `` 13433 240 16 the the DT 13433 240 17 main main JJ 13433 240 18 question question NN 13433 240 19 at at IN 13433 240 20 issue issue NN 13433 240 21 " " `` 13433 240 22 really really RB 13433 240 23 is be VBZ 13433 240 24 , , , 13433 240 25 which which WDT 13433 240 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 240 27 has have VBZ 13433 240 28 wasted waste VBN 13433 240 29 in in IN 13433 240 30 finding find VBG 13433 240 31 minute minute NN 13433 240 32 faults fault NNS 13433 240 33 in in IN 13433 240 34 me -PRON- PRP 13433 240 35 , , , 13433 240 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 240 37 might may MD 13433 240 38 have have VB 13433 240 39 spared spare VBN 13433 240 40 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 240 41 the the DT 13433 240 42 trouble trouble NN 13433 240 43 of of IN 13433 240 44 giving give VBG 13433 240 45 these these DT 13433 240 46 instances instance NNS 13433 240 47 at at RB 13433 240 48 all all RB 13433 240 49 . . . 13433 241 1 If if IN 13433 241 2 such such JJ 13433 241 3 considerations consideration NNS 13433 241 4 have have VBP 13433 241 5 vital vital JJ 13433 241 6 importance importance NN 13433 241 7 , , , 13433 241 8 the the DT 13433 241 9 position position NN 13433 241 10 of of IN 13433 241 11 the the DT 13433 241 12 question question NN 13433 241 13 may may MD 13433 241 14 easily easily RB 13433 241 15 be be VB 13433 241 16 understood understand VBN 13433 241 17 . . . 13433 242 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 242 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 242 3 , , , 13433 242 4 however however RB 13433 242 5 , , , 13433 242 6 evidently evidently RB 13433 242 7 seems seem VBZ 13433 242 8 to to TO 13433 242 9 suppose suppose VB 13433 242 10 that that IN 13433 242 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 242 12 can can MD 13433 242 13 be be VB 13433 242 14 charged charge VBN 13433 242 15 with with IN 13433 242 16 want want NN 13433 242 17 of of IN 13433 242 18 candour candour NN 13433 242 19 and and CC 13433 242 20 of of IN 13433 242 21 fulness fulness NN 13433 242 22 , , , 13433 242 23 because because IN 13433 242 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 242 25 do do VBP 13433 242 26 not not RB 13433 242 27 reproduce reproduce VB 13433 242 28 every every DT 13433 242 29 shred shre VBN 13433 242 30 and and CC 13433 242 31 tatter tatter NN 13433 242 32 of of IN 13433 242 33 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 242 34 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 242 35 which which WDT 13433 242 36 divines divine NNS 13433 242 37 continue continue VBP 13433 242 38 to to TO 13433 242 39 flaunt flaunt VB 13433 242 40 about about IN 13433 242 41 after after IN 13433 242 42 others other NNS 13433 242 43 have have VBP 13433 242 44 rejected reject VBN 13433 242 45 them -PRON- PRP 13433 242 46 as as IN 13433 242 47 useless useless JJ 13433 242 48 . . . 13433 243 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 243 2 again again RB 13433 243 3 accuses accuse VBZ 13433 243 4 me -PRON- PRP 13433 243 5 , , , 13433 243 6 in in IN 13433 243 7 connection connection NN 13433 243 8 with with IN 13433 243 9 the the DT 13433 243 10 fourth fourth JJ 13433 243 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 243 12 , , , 13433 243 13 of of IN 13433 243 14 systematically systematically RB 13433 243 15 ignoring ignore VBG 13433 243 16 the the DT 13433 243 17 arguments argument NNS 13433 243 18 of of IN 13433 243 19 " " `` 13433 243 20 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 243 21 " " '' 13433 243 22 writers writer NNS 13433 243 23 , , , 13433 243 24 and and CC 13433 243 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 243 26 represents represent VBZ 13433 243 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 243 28 work work NN 13433 243 29 as as IN 13433 243 30 " " `` 13433 243 31 the the DT 13433 243 32 very very RB 13433 243 33 reverse reverse NN 13433 243 34 of of IN 13433 243 35 full full JJ 13433 243 36 and and CC 13433 243 37 impartial impartial JJ 13433 243 38 . . . 13433 243 39 " " '' 13433 244 1 " " `` 13433 244 2 Once once RB 13433 244 3 or or CC 13433 244 4 twice twice RB 13433 244 5 , , , 13433 244 6 indeed indeed RB 13433 244 7 , , , 13433 244 8 " " '' 13433 244 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 244 10 says say VBZ 13433 244 11 , , , 13433 244 12 " " `` 13433 244 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 244 14 fastens fasten VBZ 13433 244 15 on on IN 13433 244 16 passages passage NNS 13433 244 17 from from IN 13433 244 18 such such JJ 13433 244 19 writers writer NNS 13433 244 20 , , , 13433 244 21 that that IN 13433 244 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 244 23 may may MD 13433 244 24 make make VB 13433 244 25 capital capital NN 13433 244 26 of of IN 13433 244 27 them -PRON- PRP 13433 244 28 ; ; : 13433 244 29 but but CC 13433 244 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 244 31 main main JJ 13433 244 32 arguments argument NNS 13433 244 33 remain remain VBP 13433 244 34 wholly wholly RB 13433 244 35 unnoticed unnoticed JJ 13433 244 36 . . . 13433 244 37 " " '' 13433 245 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 245 2 26:1 26:1 CD 13433 245 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 245 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 245 5 confess confess VBP 13433 245 6 that that IN 13433 245 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 245 8 find find VBP 13433 245 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 245 10 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 245 11 difficult difficult JJ 13433 245 12 to to TO 13433 245 13 distinguish distinguish VB 13433 245 14 between between IN 13433 245 15 those those DT 13433 245 16 out out IN 13433 245 17 of of IN 13433 245 18 which which WDT 13433 245 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 245 20 am be VBP 13433 245 21 said say VBN 13433 245 22 to to TO 13433 245 23 " " `` 13433 245 24 make make VB 13433 245 25 capital capital NN 13433 245 26 " " '' 13433 245 27 and and CC 13433 245 28 those those DT 13433 245 29 which which WDT 13433 245 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 245 31 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 245 32 characterises characterise VBZ 13433 245 33 as as IN 13433 245 34 " " `` 13433 245 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 245 36 main main JJ 13433 245 37 arguments argument NNS 13433 245 38 , , , 13433 245 39 " " `` 13433 245 40 if if IN 13433 245 41 I -PRON- PRP 13433 245 42 am be VBP 13433 245 43 to to TO 13433 245 44 judge judge VB 13433 245 45 by by IN 13433 245 46 the the DT 13433 245 47 " " `` 13433 245 48 samples sample NNS 13433 245 49 " " '' 13433 245 50 of of IN 13433 245 51 them -PRON- PRP 13433 245 52 which which WDT 13433 245 53 he -PRON- PRP 13433 245 54 gives give VBZ 13433 245 55 me -PRON- PRP 13433 245 56 . . . 13433 246 1 For for IN 13433 246 2 instance instance NN 13433 246 3 , , , 13433 246 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 246 5 26:2 26:2 CD 13433 246 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 246 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 246 8 asks ask VBZ 13433 246 9 why why WRB 13433 246 10 , , , 13433 246 11 when when WRB 13433 246 12 asserting assert VBG 13433 246 13 that that IN 13433 246 14 the the DT 13433 246 15 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 246 16 clearly clearly RB 13433 246 17 represent represent VBP 13433 246 18 the the DT 13433 246 19 ministry ministry NN 13433 246 20 of of IN 13433 246 21 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 246 22 as as IN 13433 246 23 having have VBG 13433 246 24 been be VBN 13433 246 25 limited limit VBN 13433 246 26 to to IN 13433 246 27 a a DT 13433 246 28 single single JJ 13433 246 29 year year NN 13433 246 30 , , , 13433 246 31 and and CC 13433 246 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 246 33 preaching preaching NN 13433 246 34 as as IN 13433 246 35 confined confine VBN 13433 246 36 to to IN 13433 246 37 Galilee Galilee NNP 13433 246 38 and and CC 13433 246 39 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 246 40 , , , 13433 246 41 whilst whilst IN 13433 246 42 the the DT 13433 246 43 fourth fourth JJ 13433 246 44 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 246 45 distributes distribute VBZ 13433 246 46 the the DT 13433 246 47 teaching teaching NN 13433 246 48 of of IN 13433 246 49 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 246 50 between between IN 13433 246 51 Galilee Galilee NNP 13433 246 52 , , , 13433 246 53 Samaria Samaria NNP 13433 246 54 , , , 13433 246 55 and and CC 13433 246 56 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 246 57 , , , 13433 246 58 makes make VBZ 13433 246 59 it -PRON- PRP 13433 246 60 extend extend VB 13433 246 61 over over IN 13433 246 62 three three CD 13433 246 63 years year NNS 13433 246 64 , , , 13433 246 65 and and CC 13433 246 66 refers refer VBZ 13433 246 67 to to IN 13433 246 68 three three CD 13433 246 69 passovers passover NNS 13433 246 70 spent spend VBN 13433 246 71 by by IN 13433 246 72 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 246 73 at at IN 13433 246 74 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 246 75 : : : 13433 246 76 " " `` 13433 246 77 Why why WRB 13433 246 78 then then RB 13433 246 79 , , , 13433 246 80 " " '' 13433 246 81 he -PRON- PRP 13433 246 82 asks ask VBZ 13433 246 83 , , , 13433 246 84 " " `` 13433 246 85 does do VBZ 13433 246 86 he -PRON- PRP 13433 246 87 not not RB 13433 246 88 add add VB 13433 246 89 that that IN 13433 246 90 ' ' `` 13433 246 91 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 246 92 ' ' '' 13433 246 93 writers writer NNS 13433 246 94 refer refer VBP 13433 246 95 to to IN 13433 246 96 such such JJ 13433 246 97 passages passage NNS 13433 246 98 as as IN 13433 246 99 Matt Matt NNP 13433 246 100 . . . 13433 247 1 xiii xiii NNP 13433 247 2 . . . 13433 248 1 37 37 CD 13433 248 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 248 3 comp comp NNP 13433 248 4 . . . 13433 249 1 Luke Luke NNP 13433 249 2 xiii xiii NNP 13433 249 3 . . . 13433 250 1 34 34 CD 13433 250 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 250 3 , , , 13433 250 4 ' ' '' 13433 250 5 O o UH 13433 250 6 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 250 7 , , , 13433 250 8 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 250 9 ... ... : 13433 250 10 _ _ NNP 13433 250 11 how how WRB 13433 250 12 often often RB 13433 250 13 _ _ NNP 13433 250 14 would would MD 13433 250 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 250 16 have have VB 13433 250 17 gathered gather VBN 13433 250 18 thy thy PRP$ 13433 250 19 children child NNS 13433 250 20 together together RB 13433 250 21 ' ' '' 13433 250 22 ? ? . 13433 251 1 Here here RB 13433 251 2 the the DT 13433 251 3 expression expression NN 13433 251 4 ' ' `` 13433 251 5 how how WRB 13433 251 6 often often RB 13433 251 7 , , , 13433 251 8 ' ' '' 13433 251 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 251 10 is be VBZ 13433 251 11 contended contend VBN 13433 251 12 , , , 13433 251 13 obliges oblige VBZ 13433 251 14 us -PRON- PRP 13433 251 15 to to TO 13433 251 16 postulate postulate VB 13433 251 17 other other JJ 13433 251 18 visits visit NNS 13433 251 19 , , , 13433 251 20 probably probably RB 13433 251 21 several several JJ 13433 251 22 visits visit NNS 13433 251 23 , , , 13433 251 24 to to IN 13433 251 25 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 251 26 , , , 13433 251 27 which which WDT 13433 251 28 are be VBP 13433 251 29 not not RB 13433 251 30 recorded record VBN 13433 251 31 in in IN 13433 251 32 the the DT 13433 251 33 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 13433 251 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 251 35 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 251 36 . . . 13433 252 1 And and CC 13433 252 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 252 3 may may MD 13433 252 4 be be VB 13433 252 5 suggested suggest VBN 13433 252 6 also also RB 13433 252 7 that that IN 13433 252 8 the the DT 13433 252 9 twice twice RB 13433 252 10 - - HYPH 13433 252 11 repeated repeat VBN 13433 252 12 notice notice NN 13433 252 13 of of IN 13433 252 14 time time NN 13433 252 15 in in IN 13433 252 16 the the DT 13433 252 17 context context NN 13433 252 18 of of IN 13433 252 19 St. St. NNP 13433 252 20 Luke Luke NNP 13433 252 21 , , , 13433 252 22 ' ' '' 13433 252 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 252 24 do do VBP 13433 252 25 cures cure NNS 13433 252 26 _ _ NNP 13433 252 27 to to IN 13433 252 28 - - HYPH 13433 252 29 day day NN 13433 252 30 and and CC 13433 252 31 to to NN 13433 252 32 - - HYPH 13433 252 33 morrow morrow NN 13433 252 34 , , , 13433 252 35 and and CC 13433 252 36 the the DT 13433 252 37 third third JJ 13433 252 38 day day NN 13433 252 39 _ _ RB 13433 252 40 I -PRON- PRP 13433 252 41 shall shall MD 13433 252 42 be be VB 13433 252 43 perfected perfect VBN 13433 252 44 , , , 13433 252 45 ' ' '' 13433 252 46 ' ' '' 13433 252 47 I -PRON- PRP 13433 252 48 must must MD 13433 252 49 walk walk VB 13433 252 50 _ _ NNP 13433 252 51 to to IN 13433 252 52 - - HYPH 13433 252 53 day day NN 13433 252 54 and and CC 13433 252 55 to to IN 13433 252 56 - - HYPH 13433 252 57 morrow morrow NNP 13433 252 58 and and CC 13433 252 59 the the DT 13433 252 60 day day NN 13433 252 61 following follow VBG 13433 252 62 _ _ NNP 13433 252 63 , , , 13433 252 64 ' ' '' 13433 252 65 points point NNS 13433 252 66 to to IN 13433 252 67 the the DT 13433 252 68 very very JJ 13433 252 69 duration duration NN 13433 252 70 of of IN 13433 252 71 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 252 72 Lord Lord NNP 13433 252 73 's 's POS 13433 252 74 ministry ministry NN 13433 252 75 , , , 13433 252 76 as as IN 13433 252 77 indicated indicate VBN 13433 252 78 by by IN 13433 252 79 the the DT 13433 252 80 fourth fourth JJ 13433 252 81 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 252 82 . . . 13433 253 1 If if IN 13433 253 2 so so RB 13433 253 3 , , , 13433 253 4 the the DT 13433 253 5 coincidence coincidence NN 13433 253 6 is be VBZ 13433 253 7 the the DT 13433 253 8 more more RBR 13433 253 9 remarkable remarkable JJ 13433 253 10 because because IN 13433 253 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 253 12 does do VBZ 13433 253 13 not not RB 13433 253 14 appear appear VB 13433 253 15 that that IN 13433 253 16 St. St. NNP 13433 253 17 Luke Luke NNP 13433 253 18 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 253 19 , , , 13433 253 20 while while IN 13433 253 21 wording word VBG 13433 253 22 these these DT 13433 253 23 prophetic prophetic JJ 13433 253 24 words word NNS 13433 253 25 , , , 13433 253 26 was be VBD 13433 253 27 aware aware JJ 13433 253 28 of of IN 13433 253 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 253 30 full full JJ 13433 253 31 historical historical JJ 13433 253 32 import import NN 13433 253 33 . . . 13433 253 34 " " '' 13433 254 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 254 2 27:1 27:1 CD 13433 254 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 254 4 Now now RB 13433 254 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 254 6 might may MD 13433 254 7 have have VB 13433 254 8 struck strike VBN 13433 254 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 254 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 254 11 that that IN 13433 254 12 if if IN 13433 254 13 anyone anyone NN 13433 254 14 making make VBG 13433 254 15 an an DT 13433 254 16 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 254 17 into into IN 13433 254 18 the the DT 13433 254 19 reality reality NN 13433 254 20 of of IN 13433 254 21 Divine Divine NNP 13433 254 22 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 254 23 were be VBD 13433 254 24 obliged oblige VBN 13433 254 25 , , , 13433 254 26 in in IN 13433 254 27 order order NN 13433 254 28 to to TO 13433 254 29 escape escape VB 13433 254 30 charges charge NNS 13433 254 31 of of IN 13433 254 32 want want NN 13433 254 33 of of IN 13433 254 34 candour candour NN 13433 254 35 , , , 13433 254 36 fulness fulness NN 13433 254 37 , , , 13433 254 38 and and CC 13433 254 39 impartiality impartiality NN 13433 254 40 , , , 13433 254 41 or or CC 13433 254 42 insinuations insinuation NNS 13433 254 43 of of IN 13433 254 44 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 254 45 , , , 13433 254 46 to to TO 13433 254 47 reproduce reproduce VB 13433 254 48 and and CC 13433 254 49 refute refute VB 13433 254 50 all all DT 13433 254 51 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 254 52 arguments argument NNS 13433 254 53 like like IN 13433 254 54 this this DT 13433 254 55 , , , 13433 254 56 the the DT 13433 254 57 duration duration NN 13433 254 58 of of IN 13433 254 59 modern modern JJ 13433 254 60 life life NN 13433 254 61 would would MD 13433 254 62 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 254 63 suffice suffice VB 13433 254 64 for for IN 13433 254 65 the the DT 13433 254 66 task task NN 13433 254 67 ; ; : 13433 254 68 and and CC 13433 254 69 " " `` 13433 254 70 if if IN 13433 254 71 they -PRON- PRP 13433 254 72 should should MD 13433 254 73 be be VB 13433 254 74 written write VBN 13433 254 75 every every DT 13433 254 76 one one NN 13433 254 77 , , , 13433 254 78 I -PRON- PRP 13433 254 79 suppose suppose VBP 13433 254 80 that that IN 13433 254 81 even even RB 13433 254 82 the the DT 13433 254 83 world world NN 13433 254 84 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 254 85 could could MD 13433 254 86 not not RB 13433 254 87 contain contain VB 13433 254 88 all all PDT 13433 254 89 the the DT 13433 254 90 books book NNS 13433 254 91 that that WDT 13433 254 92 should should MD 13433 254 93 be be VB 13433 254 94 written write VBN 13433 254 95 . . . 13433 254 96 " " '' 13433 255 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 255 2 is be VBZ 13433 255 3 very very RB 13433 255 4 right right JJ 13433 255 5 that that IN 13433 255 6 anyone anyone NN 13433 255 7 believing believe VBG 13433 255 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 255 9 valid valid RB 13433 255 10 should should MD 13433 255 11 advance advance VB 13433 255 12 this this DT 13433 255 13 or or CC 13433 255 14 any any DT 13433 255 15 other other JJ 13433 255 16 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 255 17 in in IN 13433 255 18 reply reply NN 13433 255 19 to to IN 13433 255 20 objections objection NNS 13433 255 21 , , , 13433 255 22 or or CC 13433 255 23 in in IN 13433 255 24 support support NN 13433 255 25 of of IN 13433 255 26 opinions opinion NNS 13433 255 27 ; ; : 13433 255 28 but but CC 13433 255 29 is be VBZ 13433 255 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 255 31 not not RB 13433 255 32 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 255 33 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 13433 255 34 vehemently vehemently RB 13433 255 35 to to TO 13433 255 36 condemn condemn VB 13433 255 37 a a DT 13433 255 38 writer writer NN 13433 255 39 for for IN 13433 255 40 not not RB 13433 255 41 exhausting exhaust VBG 13433 255 42 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 255 43 , , , 13433 255 44 and and CC 13433 255 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 255 46 readers reader NNS 13433 255 47 , , , 13433 255 48 by by IN 13433 255 49 discussing discuss VBG 13433 255 50 pleas plea NNS 13433 255 51 which which WDT 13433 255 52 are be VBP 13433 255 53 not not RB 13433 255 54 only only RB 13433 255 55 unsound unsound JJ 13433 255 56 in in IN 13433 255 57 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 255 58 , , , 13433 255 59 but but CC 13433 255 60 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 13433 255 61 to to IN 13433 255 62 the the DT 13433 255 63 direct direct JJ 13433 255 64 purpose purpose NN 13433 255 65 of of IN 13433 255 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 255 67 work work NN 13433 255 68 ? ? . 13433 256 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 256 2 have have VBP 13433 256 3 only only RB 13433 256 4 advanced advanced JJ 13433 256 5 objections objection NNS 13433 256 6 against against IN 13433 256 7 the the DT 13433 256 8 Johannine Johannine NNP 13433 256 9 authorship authorship NN 13433 256 10 of of IN 13433 256 11 the the DT 13433 256 12 fourth fourth JJ 13433 256 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 256 14 , , , 13433 256 15 which which WDT 13433 256 16 seem seem VBP 13433 256 17 to to IN 13433 256 18 me -PRON- PRP 13433 256 19 unrefuted unrefuted JJ 13433 256 20 by by IN 13433 256 21 any any DT 13433 256 22 of of IN 13433 256 23 the the DT 13433 256 24 explanations explanation NNS 13433 256 25 offered offer VBN 13433 256 26 . . . 13433 257 1 Let let VB 13433 257 2 me -PRON- PRP 13433 257 3 now now RB 13433 257 4 turn turn VB 13433 257 5 to to IN 13433 257 6 more more RBR 13433 257 7 important important JJ 13433 257 8 instances instance NNS 13433 257 9 . . . 13433 258 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 258 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 258 3 asks ask VBZ 13433 258 4 : : : 13433 258 5 " " `` 13433 258 6 Why why WRB 13433 258 7 , , , 13433 258 8 when when WRB 13433 258 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 258 10 is be VBZ 13433 258 11 endeavouring endeavour VBG 13433 258 12 to to TO 13433 258 13 minimise minimise VB 13433 258 14 , , , 13433 258 15 if if IN 13433 258 16 not not RB 13433 258 17 deny deny VB 13433 258 18 , , , 13433 258 19 the the DT 13433 258 20 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 258 21 character character NN 13433 258 22 of of IN 13433 258 23 the the DT 13433 258 24 fourth fourth JJ 13433 258 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 258 26 , , , 13433 258 27 does do VBZ 13433 258 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 258 29 wholly wholly RB 13433 258 30 ignore ignore VB 13433 258 31 the the DT 13433 258 32 investigations investigation NNS 13433 258 33 of of IN 13433 258 34 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 258 35 and and CC 13433 258 36 others other NNS 13433 258 37 , , , 13433 258 38 which which WDT 13433 258 39 ( ( -LRB- 13433 258 40 as as IN 13433 258 41 ' ' `` 13433 258 42 apologists apologist NNS 13433 258 43 ' ' POS 13433 258 44 venture venture NN 13433 258 45 to to TO 13433 258 46 think think VB 13433 258 47 ) ) -RRB- 13433 258 48 show show VBP 13433 258 49 that that IN 13433 258 50 the the DT 13433 258 51 whole whole JJ 13433 258 52 texture texture NN 13433 258 53 of of IN 13433 258 54 the the DT 13433 258 55 language language NN 13433 258 56 the the DT 13433 258 57 fourth fourth JJ 13433 258 58 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 258 59 is be VBZ 13433 258 60 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 258 61 ? ? . 13433 258 62 " " '' 13433 259 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 259 2 27:2 27:2 CD 13433 259 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 259 4 Now now RB 13433 259 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 259 6 statements statement NNS 13433 259 7 with with IN 13433 259 8 regard regard NN 13433 259 9 to to IN 13433 259 10 the the DT 13433 259 11 language language NN 13433 259 12 of of IN 13433 259 13 the the DT 13433 259 14 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 259 15 and and CC 13433 259 16 fourth fourth JJ 13433 259 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 259 18 are be VBP 13433 259 19 as as IN 13433 259 20 follows follow VBZ 13433 259 21 . . . 13433 260 1 Of of IN 13433 260 2 the the DT 13433 260 3 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 260 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 260 5 say say VBP 13433 260 6 : : : 13433 260 7 " " `` 13433 260 8 The the DT 13433 260 9 language language NN 13433 260 10 in in IN 13433 260 11 which which WDT 13433 260 12 the the DT 13433 260 13 book book NN 13433 260 14 is be VBZ 13433 260 15 written write VBN 13433 260 16 is be VBZ 13433 260 17 the the DT 13433 260 18 most most RBS 13433 260 19 Hebraistic Hebraistic NNP 13433 260 20 Greek Greek NNP 13433 260 21 of of IN 13433 260 22 the the DT 13433 260 23 New New NNP 13433 260 24 Testament Testament NNP 13433 260 25 ; ; : 13433 260 26 " " `` 13433 260 27 [ [ -LRB- 13433 260 28 28:1 28:1 CD 13433 260 29 ] ] -RRB- 13433 260 30 and and CC 13433 260 31 further far RBR 13433 260 32 on on RB 13433 260 33 : : : 13433 260 34 " " `` 13433 260 35 The the DT 13433 260 36 barbarous barbarous JJ 13433 260 37 Hebraistic Hebraistic NNP 13433 260 38 Greek Greek NNP 13433 260 39 and and CC 13433 260 40 abrupt abrupt JJ 13433 260 41 , , , 13433 260 42 inelegant inelegant JJ 13433 260 43 diction diction NN 13433 260 44 are be VBP 13433 260 45 natural natural JJ 13433 260 46 to to IN 13433 260 47 the the DT 13433 260 48 unlettered unlettered JJ 13433 260 49 fisherman fisherman NN 13433 260 50 of of IN 13433 260 51 Galilee Galilee NNP 13433 260 52 . . . 13433 260 53 " " '' 13433 261 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 261 2 28:2 28:2 CD 13433 261 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 261 4 Of of IN 13433 261 5 the the DT 13433 261 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 261 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 261 8 say say VBP 13433 261 9 : : : 13433 261 10 " " `` 13433 261 11 Instead instead RB 13433 261 12 of of IN 13433 261 13 the the DT 13433 261 14 Hebraistic Hebraistic NNP 13433 261 15 Greek Greek NNP 13433 261 16 and and CC 13433 261 17 harsh harsh JJ 13433 261 18 diction diction NN 13433 261 19 which which WDT 13433 261 20 might may MD 13433 261 21 be be VB 13433 261 22 expected expect VBN 13433 261 23 from from IN 13433 261 24 the the DT 13433 261 25 unlettered unlettered JJ 13433 261 26 and and CC 13433 261 27 ignorant ignorant JJ 13433 261 28 [ [ -LRB- 13433 261 29 28:3 28:3 CD 13433 261 30 ] ] -RRB- 13433 261 31 fisherman fisherman NN 13433 261 32 of of IN 13433 261 33 Galilee Galilee NNP 13433 261 34 , , , 13433 261 35 we -PRON- PRP 13433 261 36 find find VBP 13433 261 37 , , , 13433 261 38 in in IN 13433 261 39 the the DT 13433 261 40 fourth fourth JJ 13433 261 41 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 261 42 , , , 13433 261 43 the the DT 13433 261 44 purest pure JJS 13433 261 45 and and CC 13433 261 46 least least JJS 13433 261 47 Hebraistic Hebraistic NNP 13433 261 48 Greek Greek NNP 13433 261 49 of of IN 13433 261 50 any any DT 13433 261 51 of of IN 13433 261 52 the the DT 13433 261 53 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 261 54 ( ( -LRB- 13433 261 55 some some DT 13433 261 56 parts part NNS 13433 261 57 of of IN 13433 261 58 the the DT 13433 261 59 third third JJ 13433 261 60 synoptic synoptic NNP 13433 261 61 , , , 13433 261 62 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 261 63 , , , 13433 261 64 alone alone RB 13433 261 65 excepted except VBN 13433 261 66 ) ) -RRB- 13433 261 67 , , , 13433 261 68 and and CC 13433 261 69 a a DT 13433 261 70 refinement refinement NN 13433 261 71 and and CC 13433 261 72 beauty beauty NN 13433 261 73 of of IN 13433 261 74 composition composition NN 13433 261 75 whose whose WP$ 13433 261 76 charm charm NN 13433 261 77 has have VBZ 13433 261 78 captivated captivate VBN 13433 261 79 the the DT 13433 261 80 world world NN 13433 261 81 , , , 13433 261 82 " " '' 13433 261 83 & & CC 13433 261 84 c. c. NNP 13433 261 85 [ [ -LRB- 13433 261 86 28:4 28:4 CD 13433 261 87 ] ] -RRB- 13433 261 88 In in IN 13433 261 89 another another DT 13433 261 90 place place NN 13433 261 91 I -PRON- PRP 13433 261 92 say say VBP 13433 261 93 : : : 13433 261 94 " " `` 13433 261 95 The the DT 13433 261 96 language language NN 13433 261 97 in in IN 13433 261 98 which which WDT 13433 261 99 the the DT 13433 261 100 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 261 101 is be VBZ 13433 261 102 written write VBN 13433 261 103 , , , 13433 261 104 as as IN 13433 261 105 we -PRON- PRP 13433 261 106 have have VBP 13433 261 107 already already RB 13433 261 108 mentioned mention VBN 13433 261 109 , , , 13433 261 110 is be VBZ 13433 261 111 much much RB 13433 261 112 less less JJR 13433 261 113 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 261 114 than than IN 13433 261 115 that that DT 13433 261 116 of of IN 13433 261 117 the the DT 13433 261 118 other other JJ 13433 261 119 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 261 120 , , , 13433 261 121 with with IN 13433 261 122 the the DT 13433 261 123 exception exception NN 13433 261 124 , , , 13433 261 125 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 261 126 , , , 13433 261 127 of of IN 13433 261 128 parts part NNS 13433 261 129 of of IN 13433 261 130 the the DT 13433 261 131 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 261 132 according accord VBG 13433 261 133 to to IN 13433 261 134 Luke Luke NNP 13433 261 135 , , , 13433 261 136 and and CC 13433 261 137 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 261 138 Hebraisms Hebraisms NNPS 13433 261 139 are be VBP 13433 261 140 not not RB 13433 261 141 on on IN 13433 261 142 the the DT 13433 261 143 whole whole JJ 13433 261 144 greater great JJR 13433 261 145 than than IN 13433 261 146 was be VBD 13433 261 147 almost almost RB 13433 261 148 invariably invariably RB 13433 261 149 the the DT 13433 261 150 case case NN 13433 261 151 with with IN 13433 261 152 Hellenistic Hellenistic NNP 13433 261 153 Greek Greek NNP 13433 261 154 ; ; : 13433 261 155 but but CC 13433 261 156 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 261 157 composition composition NN 13433 261 158 is be VBZ 13433 261 159 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 261 160 by by IN 13433 261 161 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 261 162 smoothness smoothness NN 13433 261 163 , , , 13433 261 164 grace grace NN 13433 261 165 , , , 13433 261 166 and and CC 13433 261 167 beauty beauty NN 13433 261 168 , , , 13433 261 169 and and CC 13433 261 170 in in IN 13433 261 171 this this DT 13433 261 172 respect respect NN 13433 261 173 it -PRON- PRP 13433 261 174 is be VBZ 13433 261 175 assigned assign VBN 13433 261 176 the the DT 13433 261 177 first first JJ 13433 261 178 rank rank NN 13433 261 179 amongst amongst IN 13433 261 180 the the DT 13433 261 181 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 261 182 . . . 13433 261 183 " " '' 13433 262 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 262 2 28:5 28:5 CD 13433 262 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 262 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 262 5 believe believe VBP 13433 262 6 that that IN 13433 262 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 262 8 do do VBP 13433 262 9 not not RB 13433 262 10 say say VB 13433 262 11 another another DT 13433 262 12 word word NN 13433 262 13 as as IN 13433 262 14 to to IN 13433 262 15 the the DT 13433 262 16 texture texture NN 13433 262 17 of of IN 13433 262 18 the the DT 13433 262 19 language language NN 13433 262 20 of of IN 13433 262 21 the the DT 13433 262 22 fourth fourth JJ 13433 262 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 262 24 , , , 13433 262 25 and and CC 13433 262 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 262 27 will will MD 13433 262 28 be be VB 13433 262 29 observed observe VBN 13433 262 30 that that IN 13433 262 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 262 32 remarks remark NNS 13433 262 33 are be VBP 13433 262 34 almost almost RB 13433 262 35 wholly wholly RB 13433 262 36 limited limited JJ 13433 262 37 to to IN 13433 262 38 the the DT 13433 262 39 comparative comparative JJ 13433 262 40 quality quality NN 13433 262 41 of of IN 13433 262 42 the the DT 13433 262 43 Greek Greek NNP 13433 262 44 of of IN 13433 262 45 the the DT 13433 262 46 fourth fourth JJ 13433 262 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 262 48 , , , 13433 262 49 on on IN 13433 262 50 the the DT 13433 262 51 one one CD 13433 262 52 hand hand NN 13433 262 53 , , , 13433 262 54 and and CC 13433 262 55 the the DT 13433 262 56 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 262 57 and and CC 13433 262 58 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 262 59 on on IN 13433 262 60 the the DT 13433 262 61 other other JJ 13433 262 62 , , , 13433 262 63 and and CC 13433 262 64 that that IN 13433 262 65 they -PRON- PRP 13433 262 66 do do VBP 13433 262 67 not not RB 13433 262 68 exclude exclude VB 13433 262 69 Hebraisms Hebraisms NNP 13433 262 70 . . . 13433 263 1 The the DT 13433 263 2 views view NNS 13433 263 3 expressed express VBN 13433 263 4 might may MD 13433 263 5 be be VB 13433 263 6 supported support VBN 13433 263 7 by by IN 13433 263 8 numberless numberless JJ 13433 263 9 authorities authority NNS 13433 263 10 . . . 13433 264 1 As as IN 13433 264 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 264 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 264 4 accuses accuse VBZ 13433 264 5 me -PRON- PRP 13433 264 6 of of IN 13433 264 7 " " `` 13433 264 8 wholly wholly RB 13433 264 9 ignoring ignore VBG 13433 264 10 " " '' 13433 264 11 the the DT 13433 264 12 results result NNS 13433 264 13 at at IN 13433 264 14 which which WDT 13433 264 15 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 264 16 and and CC 13433 264 17 others other NNS 13433 264 18 have have VBP 13433 264 19 arrived arrive VBN 13433 264 20 , , , 13433 264 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 264 22 will will MD 13433 264 23 quote quote VB 13433 264 24 what what WP 13433 264 25 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 264 26 says say VBZ 13433 264 27 of of IN 13433 264 28 the the DT 13433 264 29 two two CD 13433 264 30 works work NNS 13433 264 31 : : : 13433 264 32 " " `` 13433 264 33 The the DT 13433 264 34 difference difference NN 13433 264 35 of of IN 13433 264 36 the the DT 13433 264 37 _ _ NNP 13433 264 38 language language NN 13433 264 39 _ _ NNP 13433 264 40 , , , 13433 264 41 as as RB 13433 264 42 well well RB 13433 264 43 in in IN 13433 264 44 regard regard NN 13433 264 45 to to IN 13433 264 46 grammar grammar NN 13433 264 47 and and CC 13433 264 48 style style NN 13433 264 49 as as IN 13433 264 50 to to TO 13433 264 51 doctrine doctrine VB 13433 264 52 , , , 13433 264 53 is be VBZ 13433 264 54 , , , 13433 264 55 of of IN 13433 264 56 course course NN 13433 264 57 , , , 13433 264 58 in in IN 13433 264 59 a a DT 13433 264 60 high high JJ 13433 264 61 degree degree NN 13433 264 62 remarkable remarkable JJ 13433 264 63 ... ... : 13433 264 64 As as IN 13433 264 65 regards regard NNS 13433 264 66 _ _ NNP 13433 264 67 grammar grammar NNP 13433 264 68 _ _ NNP 13433 264 69 , , , 13433 264 70 the the DT 13433 264 71 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 264 72 is be VBZ 13433 264 73 written write VBN 13433 264 74 in in IN 13433 264 75 correct correct JJ 13433 264 76 , , , 13433 264 77 the the DT 13433 264 78 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 264 79 in in IN 13433 264 80 incorrect incorrect JJ 13433 264 81 Greek Greek NNP 13433 264 82 . . . 13433 264 83 " " '' 13433 265 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 265 2 argues argue VBZ 13433 265 3 that that IN 13433 265 4 this this DT 13433 265 5 is be VBZ 13433 265 6 a a DT 13433 265 7 consequence consequence NN 13433 265 8 of of IN 13433 265 9 sovereign sovereign JJ 13433 265 10 freedom freedom NN 13433 265 11 in in IN 13433 265 12 the the DT 13433 265 13 latter latter JJ 13433 265 14 , , , 13433 265 15 and and CC 13433 265 16 that that IN 13433 265 17 from from IN 13433 265 18 the the DT 13433 265 19 nature nature NN 13433 265 20 of of IN 13433 265 21 the the DT 13433 265 22 composition composition NN 13433 265 23 the the DT 13433 265 24 author author NN 13433 265 25 of of IN 13433 265 26 the the DT 13433 265 27 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 265 28 wrote write VBD 13433 265 29 in in IN 13433 265 30 an an DT 13433 265 31 artificial artificial JJ 13433 265 32 style style NN 13433 265 33 , , , 13433 265 34 and and CC 13433 265 35 could could MD 13433 265 36 both both DT 13433 265 37 have have VB 13433 265 38 spoken speak VBN 13433 265 39 and and CC 13433 265 40 written write VBN 13433 265 41 otherwise otherwise RB 13433 265 42 . . . 13433 266 1 " " `` 13433 266 2 The the DT 13433 266 3 errors error NNS 13433 266 4 are be VBP 13433 266 5 not not RB 13433 266 6 errors error NNS 13433 266 7 of of IN 13433 266 8 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 266 9 , , , 13433 266 10 but but CC 13433 266 11 intentional intentional JJ 13433 266 12 emancipations emancipation NNS 13433 266 13 from from IN 13433 266 14 the the DT 13433 266 15 rules rule NNS 13433 266 16 of of IN 13433 266 17 grammar grammar NN 13433 266 18 " " '' 13433 266 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 266 20 ! ! . 13433 267 1 ) ) -RRB- 13433 267 2 , , , 13433 267 3 in in IN 13433 267 4 imitation imitation NN 13433 267 5 of of IN 13433 267 6 ancient ancient JJ 13433 267 7 prophetic prophetic JJ 13433 267 8 style style NN 13433 267 9 . . . 13433 268 1 Presently presently RB 13433 268 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 268 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 268 4 : : : 13433 268 5 " " `` 13433 268 6 If if IN 13433 268 7 , , , 13433 268 8 then then RB 13433 268 9 , , , 13433 268 10 on on IN 13433 268 11 the the DT 13433 268 12 one one CD 13433 268 13 hand hand NN 13433 268 14 , , , 13433 268 15 the the DT 13433 268 16 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 268 17 is be VBZ 13433 268 18 written write VBN 13433 268 19 in in IN 13433 268 20 worse bad JJR 13433 268 21 Greek Greek NNP 13433 268 22 and and CC 13433 268 23 less less RBR 13433 268 24 correctly correctly RB 13433 268 25 than than IN 13433 268 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 268 27 author author NN 13433 268 28 was be VBD 13433 268 29 able able JJ 13433 268 30 to to TO 13433 268 31 speak speak VB 13433 268 32 and and CC 13433 268 33 write write VB 13433 268 34 , , , 13433 268 35 the the DT 13433 268 36 question question NN 13433 268 37 , , , 13433 268 38 on on IN 13433 268 39 the the DT 13433 268 40 hand hand NN 13433 268 41 , , , 13433 268 42 is be VBZ 13433 268 43 , , , 13433 268 44 whether whether IN 13433 268 45 the the DT 13433 268 46 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 268 47 is be VBZ 13433 268 48 not not RB 13433 268 49 in in IN 13433 268 50 too too RB 13433 268 51 good good JJ 13433 268 52 Greek Greek NNP 13433 268 53 to to TO 13433 268 54 be be VB 13433 268 55 credited credit VBN 13433 268 56 to to IN 13433 268 57 a a DT 13433 268 58 born bear VBN 13433 268 59 Jew Jew NNP 13433 268 60 and and CC 13433 268 61 Palestinian Palestinian NNP 13433 268 62 . . . 13433 268 63 " " '' 13433 269 1 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 269 2 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 269 3 " " `` 13433 269 4 that that IN 13433 269 5 the the DT 13433 269 6 style style NN 13433 269 7 of of IN 13433 269 8 the the DT 13433 269 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 269 10 betrays betray VBZ 13433 269 11 the the DT 13433 269 12 born bear VBN 13433 269 13 Jew Jew NNP 13433 269 14 , , , 13433 269 15 and and CC 13433 269 16 certainly certainly RB 13433 269 17 not not RB 13433 269 18 the the DT 13433 269 19 Greek Greek NNP 13433 269 20 , , , 13433 269 21 " " '' 13433 269 22 but but CC 13433 269 23 the the DT 13433 269 24 force force NN 13433 269 25 which which WDT 13433 269 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 269 27 intends intend VBZ 13433 269 28 to to TO 13433 269 29 give give VB 13433 269 30 to to IN 13433 269 31 all all PDT 13433 269 32 this this DT 13433 269 33 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 269 34 is be VBZ 13433 269 35 clearly clearly RB 13433 269 36 indicated indicate VBN 13433 269 37 by by IN 13433 269 38 the the DT 13433 269 39 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 269 40 at at IN 13433 269 41 which which WDT 13433 269 42 he -PRON- PRP 13433 269 43 finally finally RB 13433 269 44 arrives arrive VBZ 13433 269 45 , , , 13433 269 46 that that IN 13433 269 47 " " `` 13433 269 48 the the DT 13433 269 49 linguistic linguistic NNP 13433 269 50 gulf gulf NNP 13433 269 51 between between IN 13433 269 52 the the DT 13433 269 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 269 54 and and CC 13433 269 55 the the DT 13433 269 56 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 269 57 is be VBZ 13433 269 58 not not RB 13433 269 59 impassable impassable JJ 13433 269 60 . . . 13433 269 61 " " '' 13433 270 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 270 2 29:1 29:1 CD 13433 270 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 270 4 This this DT 13433 270 5 result result NN 13433 270 6 from from IN 13433 270 7 so so RB 13433 270 8 staunch staunch JJ 13433 270 9 an an DT 13433 270 10 apologist apologist NN 13433 270 11 , , , 13433 270 12 obviously obviously RB 13433 270 13 to to TO 13433 270 14 minimise minimise VB 13433 270 15 the the DT 13433 270 16 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 270 17 character character NN 13433 270 18 of of IN 13433 270 19 the the DT 13433 270 20 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 270 21 , , , 13433 270 22 is be VBZ 13433 270 23 not not RB 13433 270 24 after after RB 13433 270 25 all all RB 13433 270 26 so so RB 13433 270 27 strikingly strikingly RB 13433 270 28 different different JJ 13433 270 29 from from IN 13433 270 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 270 31 representation representation NN 13433 270 32 . . . 13433 271 1 Take take VB 13433 271 2 again again RB 13433 271 3 the the DT 13433 271 4 opinion opinion NN 13433 271 5 of of IN 13433 271 6 so so RB 13433 271 7 eminent eminent JJ 13433 271 8 an an DT 13433 271 9 apologist apologist NN 13433 271 10 as as IN 13433 271 11 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 271 12 : : : 13433 271 13 " " `` 13433 271 14 The the DT 13433 271 15 language language NN 13433 271 16 of of IN 13433 271 17 the the DT 13433 271 18 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 271 19 in in IN 13433 271 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 271 21 whole whole JJ 13433 271 22 character character NN 13433 271 23 is be VBZ 13433 271 24 beyond beyond IN 13433 271 25 comparison comparison NN 13433 271 26 harsher harsher NNP 13433 271 27 , , , 13433 271 28 rougher rougher NNP 13433 271 29 , , , 13433 271 30 looser loose JJR 13433 271 31 , , , 13433 271 32 and and CC 13433 271 33 presents present VBZ 13433 271 34 grosser gross JJR 13433 271 35 incorrectness incorrectness NN 13433 271 36 than than IN 13433 271 37 any any DT 13433 271 38 other other JJ 13433 271 39 book book NN 13433 271 40 of of IN 13433 271 41 the the DT 13433 271 42 New New NNP 13433 271 43 Testament Testament NNP 13433 271 44 , , , 13433 271 45 whilst whilst IN 13433 271 46 the the DT 13433 271 47 language language NN 13433 271 48 of of IN 13433 271 49 the the DT 13433 271 50 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 271 51 is be VBZ 13433 271 52 certainly certainly RB 13433 271 53 not not RB 13433 271 54 pure pure JJ 13433 271 55 Greek Greek NNP 13433 271 56 , , , 13433 271 57 but but CC 13433 271 58 is be VBZ 13433 271 59 beyond beyond IN 13433 271 60 comparison comparison NN 13433 271 61 more more RBR 13433 271 62 grammatically grammatically RB 13433 271 63 correct correct JJ 13433 271 64 . . . 13433 271 65 " " '' 13433 272 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 272 2 29:2 29:2 CD 13433 272 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 272 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 272 5 am be VBP 13433 272 6 merely merely RB 13433 272 7 replying reply VBG 13433 272 8 , , , 13433 272 9 to to IN 13433 272 10 the the DT 13433 272 11 statements statement NNS 13433 272 12 of of IN 13433 272 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 272 14 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 272 15 , , , 13433 272 16 and and CC 13433 272 17 not not RB 13433 272 18 arguing argue VBG 13433 272 19 afresh afresh RB 13433 272 20 regarding regard VBG 13433 272 21 the the DT 13433 272 22 language language NN 13433 272 23 of of IN 13433 272 24 the the DT 13433 272 25 fourth fourth JJ 13433 272 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 272 27 , , , 13433 272 28 or or CC 13433 272 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 272 30 might may MD 13433 272 31 produce produce VB 13433 272 32 very very RB 13433 272 33 different different JJ 13433 272 34 arguments argument NNS 13433 272 35 and and CC 13433 272 36 authorities authority NNS 13433 272 37 , , , 13433 272 38 but but CC 13433 272 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 272 40 may may MD 13433 272 41 remark remark VB 13433 272 42 that that IN 13433 272 43 the the DT 13433 272 44 critical critical JJ 13433 272 45 dilemma dilemma NN 13433 272 46 which which WDT 13433 272 47 I -PRON- PRP 13433 272 48 have have VBP 13433 272 49 represented represent VBN 13433 272 50 , , , 13433 272 51 in in IN 13433 272 52 reviewing review VBG 13433 272 53 the the DT 13433 272 54 fourth fourth JJ 13433 272 55 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 272 56 , , , 13433 272 57 is be VBZ 13433 272 58 not not RB 13433 272 59 merely merely RB 13433 272 60 dependent dependent JJ 13433 272 61 upon upon IN 13433 272 62 linguistic linguistic JJ 13433 272 63 considerations consideration NNS 13433 272 64 , , , 13433 272 65 but but CC 13433 272 66 arises arise VBZ 13433 272 67 out out IN 13433 272 68 of of IN 13433 272 69 the the DT 13433 272 70 aggregate aggregate NN 13433 272 71 and and CC 13433 272 72 conflicting conflicting JJ 13433 272 73 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 272 74 presented present VBN 13433 272 75 by by IN 13433 272 76 the the DT 13433 272 77 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 272 78 on on IN 13433 272 79 the the DT 13433 272 80 one one CD 13433 272 81 hand hand NN 13433 272 82 and and CC 13433 272 83 the the DT 13433 272 84 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 272 85 on on IN 13433 272 86 the the DT 13433 272 87 other other JJ 13433 272 88 . . . 13433 273 1 Space space NN 13433 273 2 only only RB 13433 273 3 allows allow VBZ 13433 273 4 of of IN 13433 273 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 273 6 referring referring NN 13433 273 7 to to IN 13433 273 8 one one CD 13433 273 9 other other JJ 13433 273 10 instance instance NN 13433 273 11 . . . 13433 274 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 274 2 30:1 30:1 CD 13433 274 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 274 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 274 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 274 6 says-- says-- NN 13433 274 7 " " `` 13433 274 8 If if IN 13433 274 9 by by IN 13433 274 10 any any DT 13433 274 11 chance chance NN 13433 274 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 274 13 condescends condescend VBZ 13433 274 14 to to TO 13433 274 15 discuss discuss VB 13433 274 16 a a DT 13433 274 17 question question NN 13433 274 18 , , , 13433 274 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 274 20 takes take VBZ 13433 274 21 care care NN 13433 274 22 to to TO 13433 274 23 fasten fasten VB 13433 274 24 on on IN 13433 274 25 the the DT 13433 274 26 least least JJS 13433 274 27 likely likely JJ 13433 274 28 solution solution NN 13433 274 29 of of IN 13433 274 30 ' ' `` 13433 274 31 apologists apologist NNS 13433 274 32 ' ' '' 13433 274 33 ( ( -LRB- 13433 274 34 _ _ NNP 13433 274 35 e.g. e.g. RB 13433 274 36 _ _ NNP 13433 274 37 the the DT 13433 274 38 identification identification NN 13433 274 39 of of IN 13433 274 40 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 274 41 and and CC 13433 274 42 Shechem Shechem NNP 13433 274 43 ) ) -RRB- 13433 274 44 , , , 13433 274 45 [ [ -LRB- 13433 274 46 30:2 30:2 CD 13433 274 47 ] ] -RRB- 13433 274 48 omitting omit VBG 13433 274 49 altogether altogether RB 13433 274 50 to to TO 13433 274 51 notice notice VB 13433 274 52 others other NNS 13433 274 53 . . . 13433 274 54 " " '' 13433 275 1 In in IN 13433 275 2 a a DT 13433 275 3 note note NN 13433 275 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 275 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 275 6 adds:-- adds:-- CC 13433 275 7 " " `` 13433 275 8 Travellers traveller NNS 13433 275 9 and and CC 13433 275 10 ' ' `` 13433 275 11 apologists apologist NNS 13433 275 12 ' ' '' 13433 275 13 alike alike RB 13433 275 14 now now RB 13433 275 15 more more RBR 13433 275 16 commonly commonly RB 13433 275 17 identify identify VB 13433 275 18 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 275 19 with with IN 13433 275 20 the the DT 13433 275 21 village village NN 13433 275 22 bearing bear VBG 13433 275 23 the the DT 13433 275 24 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 275 25 name name NN 13433 275 26 Askar Askar NNP 13433 275 27 . . . 13433 276 1 This this DT 13433 276 2 fact fact NN 13433 276 3 is be VBZ 13433 276 4 not not RB 13433 276 5 mentioned mention VBN 13433 276 6 by by IN 13433 276 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 276 8 author author NN 13433 276 9 . . . 13433 277 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 277 2 says say VBZ 13433 277 3 moreover moreover RB 13433 277 4 , , , 13433 277 5 ' ' '' 13433 277 6 It -PRON- PRP 13433 277 7 is be VBZ 13433 277 8 admitted admit VBN 13433 277 9 that that IN 13433 277 10 there there EX 13433 277 11 was be VBD 13433 277 12 no no DT 13433 277 13 such such JJ 13433 277 14 place place NN 13433 277 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 277 16 as as IN 13433 277 17 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 277 18 , , , 13433 277 19 [ [ -LRB- 13433 277 20 Greek greek JJ 13433 277 21 : : : 13433 277 22 Suchár Suchár NNS 13433 277 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 277 24 ) ) -RRB- 13433 277 25 , , , 13433 277 26 and and CC 13433 277 27 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 277 28 ingenuity ingenuity NN 13433 277 29 is be VBZ 13433 277 30 severely severely RB 13433 277 31 taxed tax VBN 13433 277 32 to to TO 13433 277 33 explain explain VB 13433 277 34 the the DT 13433 277 35 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 277 36 . . . 13433 277 37 ' ' '' 13433 278 1 _ _ NNP 13433 278 2 This this DT 13433 278 3 is be VBZ 13433 278 4 altogether altogether RB 13433 278 5 untrue untrue JJ 13433 278 6 _ _ NNP 13433 278 7 . . . 13433 279 1 Others other NNS 13433 279 2 besides besides IN 13433 279 3 ' ' `` 13433 279 4 apologists apologist NNS 13433 279 5 ' ' POS 13433 279 6 point point NN 13433 279 7 to to IN 13433 279 8 passages passage NNS 13433 279 9 in in IN 13433 279 10 the the DT 13433 279 11 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 279 12 which which WDT 13433 279 13 speak speak VBP 13433 279 14 of of IN 13433 279 15 ' ' '' 13433 279 16 the the DT 13433 279 17 well well NN 13433 279 18 of of IN 13433 279 19 Suchar Suchar NNP 13433 279 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 279 21 or or CC 13433 279 22 Sochar Sochar NNP 13433 279 23 or or CC 13433 279 24 Sichar Sichar NNP 13433 279 25 ) ) -RRB- 13433 279 26 ; ; : 13433 279 27 ' ' '' 13433 279 28 see see VB 13433 279 29 Neubauer Neubauer NNP 13433 279 30 , , , 13433 279 31 ' ' '' 13433 279 32 La La NNP 13433 279 33 Géographie Géographie NNP 13433 279 34 du du NNP 13433 279 35 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 279 36 , , , 13433 279 37 ' ' '' 13433 279 38 p. p. NN 13433 279 39 169 169 CD 13433 279 40 f. f. NN 13433 279 41 Our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 279 42 author author NN 13433 279 43 refers refer VBZ 13433 279 44 in in IN 13433 279 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 279 46 note note NN 13433 279 47 to to IN 13433 279 48 an an DT 13433 279 49 article article NN 13433 279 50 by by IN 13433 279 51 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 279 52 , , , 13433 279 53 ( ( -LRB- 13433 279 54 ' ' `` 13433 279 55 _ _ NNP 13433 279 56 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 279 57 . . . 13433 280 1 J. J. NNP 13433 280 2 Luth Luth NNP 13433 280 3 . . . 13433 281 1 Theol Theol NNP 13433 281 2 . . . 13433 281 3 _ _ NNP 13433 281 4 , , , 13433 281 5 ' ' '' 13433 281 6 1856 1856 CD 13433 281 7 , , , 13433 281 8 p. p. NN 13433 281 9 240 240 CD 13433 281 10 f. f. NN 13433 281 11 ) ) -RRB- 13433 281 12 _ _ NNP 13433 281 13 He -PRON- PRP 13433 281 14 can can MD 13433 281 15 not not RB 13433 281 16 have have VB 13433 281 17 read read VBN 13433 281 18 the the DT 13433 281 19 article article NN 13433 281 20 , , , 13433 281 21 for for IN 13433 281 22 these these DT 13433 281 23 Talmudic talmudic JJ 13433 281 24 references reference NNS 13433 281 25 are be VBP 13433 281 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 281 27 main main JJ 13433 281 28 purport purport NN 13433 281 29 _ _ NNP 13433 281 30 . . . 13433 281 31 " " '' 13433 282 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 282 2 30:3 30:3 CD 13433 282 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 282 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 282 5 may may MD 13433 282 6 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 282 7 be be VB 13433 282 8 allowed allow VBN 13433 282 9 to to TO 13433 282 10 refer refer VB 13433 282 11 , , , 13433 282 12 first first RB 13433 282 13 , , , 13433 282 14 to to IN 13433 282 15 the the DT 13433 282 16 two two CD 13433 282 17 sentences sentence NNS 13433 282 18 which which WDT 13433 282 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 282 20 have have VBP 13433 282 21 taken take VBN 13433 282 22 the the DT 13433 282 23 liberty liberty NN 13433 282 24 of of IN 13433 282 25 putting put VBG 13433 282 26 in in RP 13433 282 27 italics italic NNS 13433 282 28 . . . 13433 283 1 If if IN 13433 283 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 283 3 be be VB 13433 283 4 possible possible JJ 13433 283 5 for for IN 13433 283 6 an an DT 13433 283 7 apologist apologist NN 13433 283 8 to to TO 13433 283 9 apologise apologise VB 13433 283 10 , , , 13433 283 11 an an DT 13433 283 12 apology apology NN 13433 283 13 is be VBZ 13433 283 14 surely surely RB 13433 283 15 due due JJ 13433 283 16 to to IN 13433 283 17 the the DT 13433 283 18 readers reader NNS 13433 283 19 of of IN 13433 283 20 the the DT 13433 283 21 " " `` 13433 283 22 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 283 23 Review Review NNP 13433 283 24 , , , 13433 283 25 " " '' 13433 283 26 at at IN 13433 283 27 least least JJS 13433 283 28 , , , 13433 283 29 for for IN 13433 283 30 this this DT 13433 283 31 style style NN 13433 283 32 of of IN 13433 283 33 criticism criticism NN 13433 283 34 , , , 13433 283 35 to to IN 13433 283 36 which which WDT 13433 283 37 , , , 13433 283 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 283 39 doubt doubt VBP 13433 283 40 not not RB 13433 283 41 , , , 13433 283 42 they -PRON- PRP 13433 283 43 are be VBP 13433 283 44 as as RB 13433 283 45 little little JJ 13433 283 46 accustomed accustomed JJ 13433 283 47 as as IN 13433 283 48 I -PRON- PRP 13433 283 49 am be VBP 13433 283 50 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 283 51 . . . 13433 284 1 There there EX 13433 284 2 is be VBZ 13433 284 3 no no DT 13433 284 4 satisfying satisfy VBG 13433 284 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 284 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 284 7 . . . 13433 285 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 285 2 give give VBP 13433 285 3 him -PRON- PRP 13433 285 4 references reference NNS 13433 285 5 , , , 13433 285 6 and and CC 13433 285 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 285 8 accuses accuse VBZ 13433 285 9 me -PRON- PRP 13433 285 10 of of IN 13433 285 11 " " `` 13433 285 12 literary literary JJ 13433 285 13 browbeating browbeating NN 13433 285 14 " " '' 13433 285 15 and and CC 13433 285 16 " " `` 13433 285 17 subtle subtle JJ 13433 285 18 intimidation intimidation NN 13433 285 19 ; ; : 13433 285 20 " " `` 13433 285 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 285 22 do do VBP 13433 285 23 not not RB 13433 285 24 give give VB 13433 285 25 references reference NNS 13433 285 26 , , , 13433 285 27 and and CC 13433 285 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 285 29 gives give VBZ 13433 285 30 me -PRON- PRP 13433 285 31 the the DT 13433 285 32 lie lie NN 13433 285 33 . . . 13433 286 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 286 2 refer refer VBP 13433 286 3 to to IN 13433 286 4 the the DT 13433 286 5 article article NN 13433 286 6 of of IN 13433 286 7 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 286 8 in in IN 13433 286 9 support support NN 13433 286 10 of of IN 13433 286 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 286 12 specific specific JJ 13433 286 13 statement statement NN 13433 286 14 that that WDT 13433 286 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 286 16 rejects reject VBZ 13433 286 17 the the DT 13433 286 18 identification identification NN 13433 286 19 of of IN 13433 286 20 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 286 21 with with IN 13433 286 22 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 286 23 , , , 13433 286 24 and and CC 13433 286 25 apparently apparently RB 13433 286 26 because because IN 13433 286 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 286 28 do do VBP 13433 286 29 not not RB 13433 286 30 quote quote VB 13433 286 31 the the DT 13433 286 32 whole whole JJ 13433 286 33 study study NN 13433 286 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 286 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 286 36 courteously courteously RB 13433 286 37 asserts assert VBZ 13433 286 38 that that IN 13433 286 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 286 40 can can MD 13433 286 41 not not RB 13433 286 42 have have VB 13433 286 43 read read VBN 13433 286 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 286 45 . . . 13433 287 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 287 2 31:1 31:1 CD 13433 287 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 287 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 287 5 statement statement NN 13433 287 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 287 7 31:2 31:2 CD 13433 287 8 ] ] -RRB- 13433 287 9 is be VBZ 13433 287 10 , , , 13433 287 11 that that IN 13433 287 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 287 13 is be VBZ 13433 287 14 admitted admit VBN 13433 287 15 that that IN 13433 287 16 there there EX 13433 287 17 was be VBD 13433 287 18 no no DT 13433 287 19 such such JJ 13433 287 20 place place NN 13433 287 21 as as IN 13433 287 22 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 287 23 -- -- : 13433 287 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 287 25 ought ought MD 13433 287 26 to to TO 13433 287 27 have have VB 13433 287 28 added add VBN 13433 287 29 , , , 13433 287 30 " " `` 13433 287 31 except except IN 13433 287 32 by by IN 13433 287 33 apologists apologist NNS 13433 287 34 who who WP 13433 287 35 never never RB 13433 287 36 admit admit VBP 13433 287 37 anything"--but anything"--but NNP 13433 287 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 287 39 thought think VBD 13433 287 40 that that IN 13433 287 41 in in IN 13433 287 42 saying say VBG 13433 287 43 : : : 13433 287 44 " " `` 13433 287 45 and and CC 13433 287 46 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 287 47 ingenuity ingenuity NN 13433 287 48 is be VBZ 13433 287 49 severely severely RB 13433 287 50 taxed tax VBN 13433 287 51 to to TO 13433 287 52 explain explain VB 13433 287 53 the the DT 13433 287 54 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 287 55 , , , 13433 287 56 " " `` 13433 287 57 I -PRON- PRP 13433 287 58 had have VBD 13433 287 59 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 287 60 excepted except VBN 13433 287 61 apologists apologist NNS 13433 287 62 , , , 13433 287 63 and and CC 13433 287 64 indicated indicate VBD 13433 287 65 that that IN 13433 287 66 many many JJ 13433 287 67 assertions assertion NNS 13433 287 68 and and CC 13433 287 69 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 287 70 are be VBP 13433 287 71 advanced advance VBN 13433 287 72 by by IN 13433 287 73 them -PRON- PRP 13433 287 74 for for IN 13433 287 75 that that DT 13433 287 76 purpose purpose NN 13433 287 77 . . . 13433 288 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 288 2 mention mention VBP 13433 288 3 that that IN 13433 288 4 the the DT 13433 288 5 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 288 6 which which WDT 13433 288 7 identifies identify VBZ 13433 288 8 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 288 9 and and CC 13433 288 10 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 288 11 is be VBZ 13433 288 12 rejected reject VBN 13433 288 13 by by IN 13433 288 14 some some DT 13433 288 15 , , , 13433 288 16 refer refer VBP 13433 288 17 to to IN 13433 288 18 Credner Credner NNP 13433 288 19 's 's POS 13433 288 20 supposition supposition NN 13433 288 21 that that IN 13433 288 22 the the DT 13433 288 23 alteration alteration NN 13433 288 24 may may MD 13433 288 25 be be VB 13433 288 26 due due IN 13433 288 27 to to IN 13433 288 28 some some DT 13433 288 29 error error NN 13433 288 30 committed commit VBN 13433 288 31 by by IN 13433 288 32 a a DT 13433 288 33 secretary secretary NN 13433 288 34 in in IN 13433 288 35 writing write VBG 13433 288 36 down down RP 13433 288 37 the the DT 13433 288 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 288 39 from from IN 13433 288 40 the the DT 13433 288 41 dictation dictation NN 13433 288 42 of of IN 13433 288 43 the the DT 13433 288 44 Apostle apostle NN 13433 288 45 , , , 13433 288 46 and and CC 13433 288 47 that that IN 13433 288 48 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 288 49 is be VBZ 13433 288 50 meant mean VBN 13433 288 51 , , , 13433 288 52 and and CC 13433 288 53 I -PRON- PRP 13433 288 54 state state VBP 13433 288 55 the the DT 13433 288 56 " " `` 13433 288 57 nickname nickname NN 13433 288 58 " " '' 13433 288 59 hypothesis hypothesis NN 13433 288 60 of of IN 13433 288 61 Hengstenberg Hengstenberg NNP 13433 288 62 and and CC 13433 288 63 others other NNS 13433 288 64 . . . 13433 289 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 289 2 is be VBZ 13433 289 3 undeniable undeniable JJ 13433 289 4 that that IN 13433 289 5 , , , 13433 289 6 with with IN 13433 289 7 the the DT 13433 289 8 exception exception NN 13433 289 9 of of IN 13433 289 10 some some DT 13433 289 11 vague vague JJ 13433 289 12 references reference NNS 13433 289 13 in in IN 13433 289 14 the the DT 13433 289 15 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 289 16 to to IN 13433 289 17 a a DT 13433 289 18 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 289 19 similar similar JJ 13433 289 20 , , , 13433 289 21 but but CC 13433 289 22 not not RB 13433 289 23 identical identical JJ 13433 289 24 , , , 13433 289 25 name name NN 13433 289 26 , , , 13433 289 27 the the DT 13433 289 28 locality locality NN 13433 289 29 of of IN 13433 289 30 which which WDT 13433 289 31 is be VBZ 13433 289 32 quite quite RB 13433 289 33 uncertain uncertain JJ 13433 289 34 , , , 13433 289 35 no no DT 13433 289 36 place place NN 13433 289 37 bearing bearing NN 13433 289 38 , , , 13433 289 39 or or CC 13433 289 40 having have VBG 13433 289 41 borne bear VBN 13433 289 42 , , , 13433 289 43 the the DT 13433 289 44 designation designation NN 13433 289 45 of of IN 13433 289 46 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 289 47 is be VBZ 13433 289 48 known know VBN 13433 289 49 . . . 13433 290 1 The the DT 13433 290 2 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 290 3 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 290 4 theory theory NN 13433 290 5 , , , 13433 290 6 as as IN 13433 290 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 290 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 290 9 may may MD 13433 290 10 find find VB 13433 290 11 " " `` 13433 290 12 in in IN 13433 290 13 any any DT 13433 290 14 common common JJ 13433 290 15 source source NN 13433 290 16 of of IN 13433 290 17 information,"--Dr information,"--Dr NNP 13433 290 18 . . . 13433 290 19 Smith Smith NNP 13433 290 20 's 's POS 13433 290 21 " " `` 13433 290 22 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 13433 290 23 of of IN 13433 290 24 the the DT 13433 290 25 Bible Bible NNP 13433 290 26 , , , 13433 290 27 " " `` 13433 290 28 for for IN 13433 290 29 instance instance NN 13433 290 30 -- -- : 13433 290 31 is be VBZ 13433 290 32 the the DT 13433 290 33 delightfully delightfully RB 13433 290 34 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 13433 290 35 one one NN 13433 290 36 : : : 13433 290 37 " " `` 13433 290 38 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 290 39 was be VBD 13433 290 40 either either CC 13433 290 41 a a DT 13433 290 42 name name NN 13433 290 43 applied apply VBN 13433 290 44 to to IN 13433 290 45 the the DT 13433 290 46 town town NN 13433 290 47 of of IN 13433 290 48 Shechem Shechem NNP 13433 290 49 , , , 13433 290 50 or or CC 13433 290 51 it -PRON- PRP 13433 290 52 was be VBD 13433 290 53 an an DT 13433 290 54 independent independent JJ 13433 290 55 place place NN 13433 290 56 . . . 13433 290 57 " " '' 13433 291 1 This this DT 13433 291 2 authority authority NN 13433 291 3 , , , 13433 291 4 however however RB 13433 291 5 , , , 13433 291 6 goes go VBZ 13433 291 7 clean clean JJ 13433 291 8 against against IN 13433 291 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 291 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 291 11 's 's POS 13433 291 12 assertion assertion NN 13433 291 13 , , , 13433 291 14 for for IN 13433 291 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 291 16 continues continue VBZ 13433 291 17 : : : 13433 291 18 " " `` 13433 291 19 The the DT 13433 291 20 first first JJ 13433 291 21 of of IN 13433 291 22 these these DT 13433 291 23 alternatives alternative NNS 13433 291 24 is be VBZ 13433 291 25 now now RB 13433 291 26 almost almost RB 13433 291 27 universally universally RB 13433 291 28 accepted accept VBN 13433 291 29 . . . 13433 291 30 " " '' 13433 292 1 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 292 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 292 3 32:1 32:1 CD 13433 292 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 292 5 considered consider VBN 13433 292 6 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 292 7 a a DT 13433 292 8 mere mere JJ 13433 292 9 alteration alteration NN 13433 292 10 of of IN 13433 292 11 the the DT 13433 292 12 name name NN 13433 292 13 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 292 14 , , , 13433 292 15 both both DT 13433 292 16 representing represent VBG 13433 292 17 the the DT 13433 292 18 same same JJ 13433 292 19 place place NN 13433 292 20 . . . 13433 293 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 293 2 found find VBD 13433 293 3 a a DT 13433 293 4 reference reference NN 13433 293 5 in in IN 13433 293 6 the the DT 13433 293 7 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 293 8 to to TO 13433 293 9 " " `` 13433 293 10 _ _ NNP 13433 293 11 Ain Ain NNP 13433 293 12 Socar Socar NNP 13433 293 13 _ _ NNP 13433 293 14 , , , 13433 293 15 " " '' 13433 293 16 and and CC 13433 293 17 with with IN 13433 293 18 great great JJ 13433 293 19 hesitation hesitation NN 13433 293 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 293 21 associated associate VBD 13433 293 22 the the DT 13433 293 23 name name NN 13433 293 24 with with IN 13433 293 25 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 293 26 . . . 13433 294 1 " " `` 13433 294 2 May May MD 13433 294 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 294 4 not not RB 13433 294 5 venture venture VB 13433 294 6 " " '' 13433 294 7 to to TO 13433 294 8 render render VB 13433 294 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 294 10 " " `` 13433 294 11 the the DT 13433 294 12 well well NN 13433 294 13 of of IN 13433 294 14 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 294 15 " " '' 13433 294 16 ? ? . 13433 295 1 And and CC 13433 295 2 after after IN 13433 295 3 detailed detailed JJ 13433 295 4 extracts extract NNS 13433 295 5 and and CC 13433 295 6 explanations explanation NNS 13433 295 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 295 8 says say VBZ 13433 295 9 : : : 13433 295 10 " " `` 13433 295 11 And and CC 13433 295 12 now now RB 13433 295 13 let let VB 13433 295 14 the the DT 13433 295 15 reader reader NN 13433 295 16 give give VB 13433 295 17 us -PRON- PRP 13433 295 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 295 19 judgment judgment NN 13433 295 20 as as IN 13433 295 21 to to IN 13433 295 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 295 23 name name NN 13433 295 24 and and CC 13433 295 25 place place NN 13433 295 26 , , , 13433 295 27 whether whether IN 13433 295 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 295 29 doth doth JJ 13433 295 30 not not RB 13433 295 31 seem seem VBP 13433 295 32 to to TO 13433 295 33 have have VB 13433 295 34 some some DT 13433 295 35 relation relation NN 13433 295 36 with with IN 13433 295 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 295 38 ' ' '' 13433 295 39 well well NN 13433 295 40 of of IN 13433 295 41 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 295 42 . . . 13433 295 43 ' ' '' 13433 296 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 296 2 may may MD 13433 296 3 be be VB 13433 296 4 disputed dispute VBN 13433 296 5 on on IN 13433 296 6 either either DT 13433 296 7 side side NN 13433 296 8 . . . 13433 296 9 " " '' 13433 297 1 Wieseler Wieseler NNP 13433 297 2 , , , 13433 297 3 who who WP 13433 297 4 first first RB 13433 297 5 , , , 13433 297 6 in in IN 13433 297 7 more more JJR 13433 297 8 recent recent JJ 13433 297 9 times time NNS 13433 297 10 , , , 13433 297 11 developed develop VBD 13433 297 12 the the DT 13433 297 13 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 297 14 of of IN 13433 297 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 297 16 , , , 13433 297 17 argues argue VBZ 13433 297 18 : : : 13433 297 19 " " `` 13433 297 20 In in IN 13433 297 21 the the DT 13433 297 22 first first JJ 13433 297 23 place place NN 13433 297 24 , , , 13433 297 25 there there EX 13433 297 26 can can MD 13433 297 27 be be VB 13433 297 28 no no DT 13433 297 29 doubt doubt NN 13433 297 30 that that IN 13433 297 31 by by IN 13433 297 32 [ [ -LRB- 13433 297 33 Greek Greek NNP 13433 297 34 : : : 13433 297 35 Suchar Suchar NNP 13433 297 36 ] ] -RRB- 13433 297 37 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 297 38 is be VBZ 13433 297 39 meant mean VBN 13433 297 40 , , , 13433 297 41 " " '' 13433 297 42 and and CC 13433 297 43 he -PRON- PRP 13433 297 44 adds add VBZ 13433 297 45 , , , 13433 297 46 a a DT 13433 297 47 few few JJ 13433 297 48 lines line NNS 13433 297 49 after after IN 13433 297 50 : : : 13433 297 51 " " `` 13433 297 52 Regarding regard VBG 13433 297 53 this this DT 13433 297 54 there there EX 13433 297 55 is be VBZ 13433 297 56 no no DT 13433 297 57 controversy controversy NN 13433 297 58 amongst amongst IN 13433 297 59 interpreters interpreter NNS 13433 297 60 . . . 13433 297 61 " " '' 13433 298 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 298 2 totally totally RB 13433 298 3 rejects reject VBZ 13433 298 4 the the DT 13433 298 5 idea idea NN 13433 298 6 of of IN 13433 298 7 such such JJ 13433 298 8 in in IN 13433 298 9 alteration alteration NN 13433 298 10 of of IN 13433 298 11 the the DT 13433 298 12 name name NN 13433 298 13 occurring occur VBG 13433 298 14 in in IN 13433 298 15 translation translation NN 13433 298 16 , , , 13433 298 17 which which WDT 13433 298 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 298 19 says say VBZ 13433 298 20 is be VBZ 13433 298 21 " " `` 13433 298 22 unprecedented unprecedented JJ 13433 298 23 . . . 13433 298 24 " " '' 13433 299 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 299 2 therefore therefore RB 13433 299 3 concludes conclude VBZ 13433 299 4 that that IN 13433 299 5 in in IN 13433 299 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 299 7 Greek greek JJ 13433 299 8 : : : 13433 299 9 Suchar suchar NN 13433 299 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 299 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 299 12 have have VBP 13433 299 13 _ _ NNP 13433 299 14 another another DT 13433 299 15 _ _ NNP 13433 299 16 name name NN 13433 299 17 for for IN 13433 299 18 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 299 19 . . . 13433 300 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 300 2 merely merely RB 13433 300 3 submits submit VBZ 13433 300 4 this this DT 13433 300 5 , , , 13433 300 6 however however RB 13433 300 7 , , , 13433 300 8 as as IN 13433 300 9 " " `` 13433 300 10 a a DT 13433 300 11 new new JJ 13433 300 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 13433 300 13 to to IN 13433 300 14 the the DT 13433 300 15 judgment judgment NN 13433 300 16 of of IN 13433 300 17 the the DT 13433 300 18 reader reader NN 13433 300 19 , , , 13433 300 20 " " '' 13433 300 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 300 22 32:2 32:2 CD 13433 300 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 300 24 which which WDT 13433 300 25 alone alone RB 13433 300 26 shows show VBZ 13433 300 27 the the DT 13433 300 28 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 300 29 of of IN 13433 300 30 the the DT 13433 300 31 suggestion suggestion NN 13433 300 32 . . . 13433 301 1 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 301 2 and and CC 13433 301 3 Wieseler Wieseler NNP 13433 301 4 are be VBP 13433 301 5 substantially substantially RB 13433 301 6 followed follow VBN 13433 301 7 by by IN 13433 301 8 Olshausen Olshausen NNP 13433 301 9 , , , 13433 301 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 11 32:3 32:3 CD 13433 301 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 13 De De NNP 13433 301 14 Wette Wette NNP 13433 301 15 , , , 13433 301 16 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 17 32:4 32:4 CD 13433 301 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 19 Hug Hug NNP 13433 301 20 , , , 13433 301 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 22 32:5 32:5 CD 13433 301 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 24 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 301 25 , , , 13433 301 26 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 27 32:6 32:6 CD 13433 301 28 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 29 Riggenbach Riggenbach NNP 13433 301 30 , , , 13433 301 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 32 32:7 32:7 CD 13433 301 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 34 Godet Godet NNP 13433 301 35 , , , 13433 301 36 [ [ -LRB- 13433 301 37 32:8 32:8 CD 13433 301 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 301 39 and and CC 13433 301 40 others other NNS 13433 301 41 . . . 13433 302 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 302 2 , , , 13433 302 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 302 4 32:9 32:9 CD 13433 302 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 302 6 in in IN 13433 302 7 spite spite NN 13433 302 8 of of IN 13433 302 9 the the DT 13433 302 10 arguments argument NNS 13433 302 11 of of IN 13433 302 12 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 302 13 and and CC 13433 302 14 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 302 15 , , , 13433 302 16 and and CC 13433 302 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 302 18 Talmudic talmudic JJ 13433 302 19 researches research NNS 13433 302 20 , , , 13433 302 21 considers consider VBZ 13433 302 22 that that IN 13433 302 23 the the DT 13433 302 24 old old JJ 13433 302 25 town town NN 13433 302 26 of of IN 13433 302 27 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 302 28 is be VBZ 13433 302 29 meant mean VBN 13433 302 30 . . . 13433 303 1 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 303 2 , , , 13433 303 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 303 4 32:10 32:10 CD 13433 303 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 303 6 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 303 7 , , , 13433 303 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 303 9 32:11 32:11 CD 13433 303 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 303 11 Lange lange NN 13433 303 12 , , , 13433 303 13 [ [ -LRB- 13433 303 14 32:12 32:12 CD 13433 303 15 ] ] -RRB- 13433 303 16 Meyer Meyer NNP 13433 303 17 , , , 13433 303 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 303 19 32:13 32:13 CD 13433 303 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 303 21 and and CC 13433 303 22 others other NNS 13433 303 23 think think VBP 13433 303 24 that that IN 13433 303 25 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 303 26 was be VBD 13433 303 27 near near JJ 13433 303 28 to to IN 13433 303 29 , , , 13433 303 30 but but CC 13433 303 31 distinct distinct JJ 13433 303 32 from from IN 13433 303 33 , , , 13433 303 34 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 303 35 . . . 13433 304 1 Lücke lücke VB 13433 304 2 [ [ -LRB- 13433 304 3 33:1 33:1 CD 13433 304 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 304 5 is be VBZ 13433 304 6 very very RB 13433 304 7 undecided undecided JJ 13433 304 8 . . . 13433 305 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 305 2 recognises recognise VBZ 13433 305 3 the the DT 13433 305 4 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 305 5 difference difference NN 13433 305 6 in in IN 13433 305 7 the the DT 13433 305 8 name name NN 13433 305 9 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 305 10 . . . 13433 306 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 306 2 does do VBZ 13433 306 3 not not RB 13433 306 4 favourably favourably RB 13433 306 5 receive receive VB 13433 306 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 306 7 's 's POS 13433 306 8 arguments argument NNS 13433 306 9 regarding regard VBG 13433 306 10 an an DT 13433 306 11 alteration alteration NN 13433 306 12 of of IN 13433 306 13 the the DT 13433 306 14 name name NN 13433 306 15 of of IN 13433 306 16 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 306 17 , , , 13433 306 18 nor nor CC 13433 306 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 306 20 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 306 21 as as IN 13433 306 22 to to IN 13433 306 23 the the DT 13433 306 24 relation relation NN 13433 306 25 of of IN 13433 306 26 the the DT 13433 306 27 place place NN 13433 306 28 mentioned mention VBN 13433 306 29 in in IN 13433 306 30 the the DT 13433 306 31 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 306 32 to to IN 13433 306 33 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 306 34 , , , 13433 306 35 which which WDT 13433 306 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 306 37 thinks think VBZ 13433 306 38 is be VBZ 13433 306 39 " " `` 13433 306 40 very very RB 13433 306 41 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 306 42 , , , 13433 306 43 " " '' 13433 306 44 and and CC 13433 306 45 he -PRON- PRP 13433 306 46 seems seem VBZ 13433 306 47 to to TO 13433 306 48 incline incline VB 13433 306 49 rather rather RB 13433 306 50 to to IN 13433 306 51 an an DT 13433 306 52 accidental accidental JJ 13433 306 53 corruption corruption NN 13433 306 54 of of IN 13433 306 55 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 306 56 into into IN 13433 306 57 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 306 58 , , , 13433 306 59 although although IN 13433 306 60 he -PRON- PRP 13433 306 61 feels feel VBZ 13433 306 62 the the DT 13433 306 63 great great JJ 13433 306 64 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 306 65 in in IN 13433 306 66 the the DT 13433 306 67 way way NN 13433 306 68 of of IN 13433 306 69 such such PDT 13433 306 70 an an DT 13433 306 71 explanation explanation NN 13433 306 72 . . . 13433 307 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 307 2 condemns condemn VBZ 13433 307 3 the the DT 13433 307 4 " " `` 13433 307 5 Talmudische Talmudische NNP 13433 307 6 Studien Studien NNP 13433 307 7 " " '' 13433 307 8 of of IN 13433 307 9 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 307 10 as as IN 13433 307 11 generally generally RB 13433 307 12 more more JJR 13433 307 13 complicating complicate VBG 13433 307 14 than than IN 13433 307 15 clearing clear VBG 13433 307 16 up up RP 13433 307 17 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 307 18 , , , 13433 307 19 and and CC 13433 307 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 307 21 views view NNS 13433 307 22 as as IN 13433 307 23 commonly commonly RB 13433 307 24 incorrect incorrect JJ 13433 307 25 , , , 13433 307 26 and and CC 13433 307 27 , , , 13433 307 28 whilst whilst IN 13433 307 29 agreeing agree VBG 13433 307 30 with with IN 13433 307 31 him -PRON- PRP 13433 307 32 that that IN 13433 307 33 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 307 34 can can MD 13433 307 35 not not RB 13433 307 36 be be VB 13433 307 37 the the DT 13433 307 38 same same JJ 13433 307 39 place place NN 13433 307 40 as as IN 13433 307 41 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 307 42 , , , 13433 307 43 he -PRON- PRP 13433 307 44 points point VBZ 13433 307 45 out out RP 13433 307 46 that that IN 13433 307 47 the the DT 13433 307 48 site site NN 13433 307 49 of of IN 13433 307 50 the the DT 13433 307 51 _ _ NNP 13433 307 52 valley valley NN 13433 307 53 of of IN 13433 307 54 the the DT 13433 307 55 _ _ NNP 13433 307 56 well well NN 13433 307 57 of of IN 13433 307 58 the the DT 13433 307 59 Talmud Talmud NNP 13433 307 60 is be VBZ 13433 307 61 certainly certainly RB 13433 307 62 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 307 63 . . . 13433 308 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 308 2 33:2 33:2 CD 13433 308 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 308 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 308 5 explains explain VBZ 13433 308 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 308 7 own own JJ 13433 308 8 views view NNS 13433 308 9 , , , 13433 308 10 however however RB 13433 308 11 , , , 13433 308 12 more more RBR 13433 308 13 clearly clearly RB 13433 308 14 in in IN 13433 308 15 another another DT 13433 308 16 place:-- place:-- NN 13433 308 17 " " `` 13433 308 18 That that IN 13433 308 19 this this DT 13433 308 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 308 21 Sychar sychar NN 13433 308 22 ) ) -RRB- 13433 308 23 can can MD 13433 308 24 not not RB 13433 308 25 be be VB 13433 308 26 the the DT 13433 308 27 large large JJ 13433 308 28 , , , 13433 308 29 ancient ancient JJ 13433 308 30 Sikhem Sikhem NNP 13433 308 31 , , , 13433 308 32 which which WDT 13433 308 33 , , , 13433 308 34 at at IN 13433 308 35 the the DT 13433 308 36 time time NN 13433 308 37 when when WRB 13433 308 38 the the DT 13433 308 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 308 40 was be VBD 13433 308 41 written write VBN 13433 308 42 , , , 13433 308 43 was be VBD 13433 308 44 probably probably RB 13433 308 45 already already RB 13433 308 46 generally generally RB 13433 308 47 called call VBN 13433 308 48 _ _ NNP 13433 308 49 Neapolis Neapolis NNP 13433 308 50 _ _ NNP 13433 308 51 in in IN 13433 308 52 Greek greek JJ 13433 308 53 writings writing NNS 13433 308 54 , , , 13433 308 55 has have VBZ 13433 308 56 been be VBN 13433 308 57 already already RB 13433 308 58 stated state VBN 13433 308 59 ; ; : 13433 308 60 it -PRON- PRP 13433 308 61 is be VBZ 13433 308 62 the the DT 13433 308 63 place place NN 13433 308 64 still still RB 13433 308 65 called call VBD 13433 308 66 with with IN 13433 308 67 an an DT 13433 308 68 altered alter VBN 13433 308 69 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 308 70 name name NN 13433 308 71 _ _ NNP 13433 308 72 Al Al NNP 13433 308 73 ' ' POS 13433 308 74 Askar Askar NNP 13433 308 75 _ _ NNP 13433 308 76 , , , 13433 308 77 east east NN 13433 308 78 of of IN 13433 308 79 Naplûs Naplûs NNP 13433 308 80 . . . 13433 309 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 309 2 is be VBZ 13433 309 3 indeed indeed RB 13433 309 4 difficult difficult JJ 13433 309 5 to to TO 13433 309 6 prove prove VB 13433 309 7 that that IN 13433 309 8 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 309 9 could could MD 13433 309 10 stand stand VB 13433 309 11 for for IN 13433 309 12 Sikhem Sikhem NNP 13433 309 13 , , , 13433 309 14 either either CC 13433 309 15 through through IN 13433 309 16 change change NN 13433 309 17 of of IN 13433 309 18 pronunciation pronunciation NN 13433 309 19 , , , 13433 309 20 or or CC 13433 309 21 for for IN 13433 309 22 any any DT 13433 309 23 other other JJ 13433 309 24 reason reason NN 13433 309 25 , , , 13433 309 26 and and CC 13433 309 27 the the DT 13433 309 28 addition addition NN 13433 309 29 [ [ -LRB- 13433 309 30 Greek Greek NNP 13433 309 31 : : : 13433 309 32 legomenê legomenê NN 13433 309 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 309 34 does do VBZ 13433 309 35 not not RB 13433 309 36 indicate indicate VB 13433 309 37 , , , 13433 309 38 here here RB 13433 309 39 any any DT 13433 309 40 more more RBR 13433 309 41 than than IN 13433 309 42 in in IN 13433 309 43 xi xi NNP 13433 309 44 . . . 13433 310 1 54 54 CD 13433 310 2 , , , 13433 310 3 so so RB 13433 310 4 large large JJ 13433 310 5 and and CC 13433 310 6 generally generally RB 13433 310 7 known know VBN 13433 310 8 a a DT 13433 310 9 town town NN 13433 310 10 as as IN 13433 310 11 Sikhem Sikhem NNP 13433 310 12 . . . 13433 311 1 or or CC 13433 311 2 Flavia Flavia NNP 13433 311 3 Neapolis Neapolis NNP 13433 311 4 . . . 13433 311 5 " " '' 13433 312 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 312 2 33:3 33:3 CD 13433 312 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 312 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 312 5 Sanday Sanday NNP 13433 312 6 , , , 13433 312 7 [ [ -LRB- 13433 312 8 33:4 33:4 CD 13433 312 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 312 10 of of IN 13433 312 11 whose whose WP$ 13433 312 12 able able JJ 13433 312 13 work work NN 13433 312 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 312 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 312 16 directly directly RB 13433 312 17 speaks speak VBZ 13433 312 18 , , , 13433 312 19 says:-- says:-- '' 13433 312 20 " " `` 13433 312 21 The the DT 13433 312 22 name name NN 13433 312 23 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 312 24 is be VBZ 13433 312 25 not not RB 13433 312 26 the the DT 13433 312 27 common common JJ 13433 312 28 one one NN 13433 312 29 , , , 13433 312 30 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 312 31 , , , 13433 312 32 but but CC 13433 312 33 is be VBZ 13433 312 34 a a DT 13433 312 35 mock mock JJ 13433 312 36 title title NN 13433 312 37 ( ( -LRB- 13433 312 38 = = SYM 13433 312 39 ' ' `` 13433 312 40 liar liar NN 13433 312 41 ' ' '' 13433 312 42 or or CC 13433 312 43 ' ' `` 13433 312 44 drunkard drunkard NN 13433 312 45 ' ' '' 13433 312 46 ) ) -RRB- 13433 312 47 that that WDT 13433 312 48 was be VBD 13433 312 49 given give VBN 13433 312 50 to to IN 13433 312 51 the the DT 13433 312 52 town town NN 13433 312 53 by by IN 13433 312 54 the the DT 13433 312 55 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 312 56 . . . 13433 313 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 313 2 33:5 33:5 CD 13433 313 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 313 4 This this DT 13433 313 5 is be VBZ 13433 313 6 a a DT 13433 313 7 clear clear JJ 13433 313 8 reminiscence reminiscence NN 13433 313 9 of of IN 13433 313 10 the the DT 13433 313 11 vernacular vernacular JJ 13433 313 12 that that IN 13433 313 13 the the DT 13433 313 14 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 313 15 spoke speak VBD 13433 313 16 in in IN 13433 313 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 313 18 youth youth NN 13433 313 19 , , , 13433 313 20 and and CC 13433 313 21 is be VBZ 13433 313 22 a a DT 13433 313 23 strong strong JJ 13433 313 24 touch touch NN 13433 313 25 of of IN 13433 313 26 nature nature NN 13433 313 27 . . . 13433 314 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 314 2 is be VBZ 13433 314 3 not not RB 13433 314 4 quite quite RB 13433 314 5 certain certain JJ 13433 314 6 that that IN 13433 314 7 the the DT 13433 314 8 name name NN 13433 314 9 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 314 10 has have VBZ 13433 314 11 this this DT 13433 314 12 force force NN 13433 314 13 , , , 13433 314 14 but but CC 13433 314 15 the the DT 13433 314 16 hypothesis hypothesis NN 13433 314 17 is be VBZ 13433 314 18 in in IN 13433 314 19 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 314 20 more more RBR 13433 314 21 likely likely JJ 13433 314 22 than than IN 13433 314 23 , , , 13433 314 24 & & CC 13433 314 25 c c NNP 13433 314 26 .... .... . 13433 315 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 315 2 is be VBZ 13433 315 3 not not RB 13433 315 4 , , , 13433 315 5 however however RB 13433 315 6 , , , 13433 315 7 by by IN 13433 315 8 any any DT 13433 315 9 means mean NNS 13433 315 10 improbable improbable JJ 13433 315 11 that that IN 13433 315 12 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 315 13 may may MD 13433 315 14 represent represent VB 13433 315 15 , , , 13433 315 16 not not RB 13433 315 17 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 315 18 , , , 13433 315 19 but but CC 13433 315 20 the the DT 13433 315 21 modern modern JJ 13433 315 22 village village NN 13433 315 23 Askar Askar NNP 13433 315 24 , , , 13433 315 25 which which WDT 13433 315 26 is be VBZ 13433 315 27 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 315 28 nearer nearer JJ 13433 315 29 to to IN 13433 315 30 Jacob Jacob NNP 13433 315 31 's 's POS 13433 315 32 Well well UH 13433 315 33 . . . 13433 315 34 " " '' 13433 316 1 To to TO 13433 316 2 quote quote VB 13433 316 3 one one CD 13433 316 4 of of IN 13433 316 5 the the DT 13433 316 6 latest late JJS 13433 316 7 " " `` 13433 316 8 travellers traveller NNS 13433 316 9 and and CC 13433 316 10 apologists apologist NNS 13433 316 11 , , , 13433 316 12 " " '' 13433 316 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 316 14 Farrar Farrar NNP 13433 316 15 says say VBZ 13433 316 16 : : : 13433 316 17 " " `` 13433 316 18 From from IN 13433 316 19 what what WP 13433 316 20 the the DT 13433 316 21 name name NN 13433 316 22 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 316 23 is be VBZ 13433 316 24 derived derive VBN 13433 316 25 is be VBZ 13433 316 26 uncertain uncertain JJ 13433 316 27 . . . 13433 317 1 The the DT 13433 317 2 word word NN 13433 317 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 317 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 317 5 : : : 13433 317 6 legomenos legomenos NNPS 13433 317 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 317 8 in in IN 13433 317 9 St. St. NNP 13433 317 10 John John NNP 13433 317 11 seems seem VBZ 13433 317 12 to to TO 13433 317 13 imply imply VB 13433 317 14 a a DT 13433 317 15 sobriquet sobriquet NN 13433 317 16 . . . 13433 318 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 318 2 may may MD 13433 318 3 be be VB 13433 318 4 ' ' `` 13433 318 5 a a DT 13433 318 6 lie lie NN 13433 318 7 , , , 13433 318 8 ' ' '' 13433 318 9 ' ' '' 13433 318 10 drunken drunken NN 13433 318 11 , , , 13433 318 12 ' ' '' 13433 318 13 or or CC 13433 318 14 ' ' '' 13433 318 15 a a DT 13433 318 16 sepulchre sepulchre NN 13433 318 17 . . . 13433 318 18 ' ' '' 13433 319 1 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 319 2 may may MD 13433 319 3 possibly possibly RB 13433 319 4 have have VB 13433 319 5 been be VBN 13433 319 6 a a DT 13433 319 7 village village NN 13433 319 8 nearer nearer IN 13433 319 9 the the DT 13433 319 10 well well NN 13433 319 11 than than IN 13433 319 12 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 319 13 , , , 13433 319 14 on on IN 13433 319 15 the the DT 13433 319 16 site site NN 13433 319 17 of of IN 13433 319 18 the the DT 13433 319 19 village village NN 13433 319 20 now now RB 13433 319 21 called call VBN 13433 319 22 El El NNP 13433 319 23 Askar Askar NNP 13433 319 24 . . . 13433 319 25 " " '' 13433 320 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 320 2 34:1 34:1 CD 13433 320 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 320 4 As as IN 13433 320 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 320 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 320 7 specially specially RB 13433 320 8 mentions mention VBZ 13433 320 9 Neubauer Neubauer NNP 13433 320 10 , , , 13433 320 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 320 12 opinion opinion NN 13433 320 13 may may MD 13433 320 14 be be VB 13433 320 15 substantially substantially RB 13433 320 16 given give VBN 13433 320 17 in in IN 13433 320 18 a a DT 13433 320 19 single single JJ 13433 320 20 sentence sentence NN 13433 320 21 : : : 13433 320 22 " " `` 13433 320 23 La La NNP 13433 320 24 Mischna Mischna NNP 13433 320 25 mentionne mentionne NN 13433 320 26 un un NNP 13433 320 27 endroit endroit NNP 13433 320 28 appelé appelé NNP 13433 320 29 ' ' '' 13433 320 30 la la NNP 13433 320 31 plaine plaine JJ 13433 320 32 d'En d'En NNP 13433 320 33 - - HYPH 13433 320 34 Sokher Sokher NNP 13433 320 35 , , , 13433 320 36 ' ' '' 13433 320 37 qui qui RB 13433 320 38 est est NNP 13433 320 39 peut peut NN 13433 320 40 - - HYPH 13433 320 41 être être NNP 13433 320 42 le le IN 13433 320 43 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 320 44 de de NNP 13433 320 45 l'Evangile l'Evangile NNP 13433 320 46 . . . 13433 320 47 " " '' 13433 321 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 321 2 had have VBD 13433 321 3 a a DT 13433 321 4 few few JJ 13433 321 5 lines line NNS 13433 321 6 before before IN 13433 321 7 said say VBD 13433 321 8 : : : 13433 321 9 " " `` 13433 321 10 Il il FW 13433 321 11 est est NNP 13433 321 12 donc donc NNS 13433 321 13 plus plus CC 13433 321 14 logique logique NNP 13433 321 15 de de NNP 13433 321 16 ne ne NNP 13433 321 17 pas pas NNP 13433 321 18 identifier identifier NNP 13433 321 19 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 321 20 avec avec FW 13433 321 21 Sichem Sichem NNP 13433 321 22 . . . 13433 321 23 " " '' 13433 322 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 322 2 34:2 34:2 CD 13433 322 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 322 4 Now now RB 13433 322 5 , , , 13433 322 6 with with IN 13433 322 7 regard regard NN 13433 322 8 to to IN 13433 322 9 all all PDT 13433 322 10 these these DT 13433 322 11 theories theory NNS 13433 322 12 , , , 13433 322 13 and and CC 13433 322 14 especially especially RB 13433 322 15 in in IN 13433 322 16 so so RB 13433 322 17 far far RB 13433 322 18 as as IN 13433 322 19 they -PRON- PRP 13433 322 20 connect connect VBP 13433 322 21 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 322 22 with with IN 13433 322 23 El El NNP 13433 322 24 Askar Askar NNP 13433 322 25 , , , 13433 322 26 let let VB 13433 322 27 me -PRON- PRP 13433 322 28 quote quote VB 13433 322 29 a a DT 13433 322 30 few few JJ 13433 322 31 more more JJR 13433 322 32 words word NNS 13433 322 33 in in IN 13433 322 34 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 322 35 , , , 13433 322 36 from from IN 13433 322 37 a a DT 13433 322 38 " " `` 13433 322 39 common common JJ 13433 322 40 source source NN 13433 322 41 of of IN 13433 322 42 information:"-- information:"-- NN 13433 322 43 " " '' 13433 322 44 On on IN 13433 322 45 the the DT 13433 322 46 other other JJ 13433 322 47 hand hand NN 13433 322 48 there there EX 13433 322 49 is be VBZ 13433 322 50 an an DT 13433 322 51 etymological etymological JJ 13433 322 52 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 322 53 in in IN 13433 322 54 the the DT 13433 322 55 way way NN 13433 322 56 of of IN 13433 322 57 this this DT 13433 322 58 identification identification NN 13433 322 59 . . . 13433 323 1 _ _ NNP 13433 323 2 ' ' `` 13433 323 3 Askar Askar NNP 13433 323 4 _ _ NNP 13433 323 5 begins begin VBZ 13433 323 6 with with IN 13433 323 7 the the DT 13433 323 8 letter letter NN 13433 323 9 ' ' `` 13433 323 10 Ain Ain NNP 13433 323 11 , , , 13433 323 12 which which WDT 13433 323 13 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 323 14 does do VBZ 13433 323 15 not not RB 13433 323 16 appear appear VB 13433 323 17 to to TO 13433 323 18 have have VB 13433 323 19 contained contain VBN 13433 323 20 ; ; : 13433 323 21 a a DT 13433 323 22 letter letter NN 13433 323 23 too too RB 13433 323 24 stubborn stubborn JJ 13433 323 25 and and CC 13433 323 26 enduring enduring JJ 13433 323 27 to to TO 13433 323 28 be be VB 13433 323 29 easily easily RB 13433 323 30 either either CC 13433 323 31 dropped drop VBN 13433 323 32 or or CC 13433 323 33 assumed assume VBN 13433 323 34 in in IN 13433 323 35 a a DT 13433 323 36 name name NN 13433 323 37 ... ... . 13433 324 1 These these DT 13433 324 2 considerations consideration NNS 13433 324 3 have have VBP 13433 324 4 been be VBN 13433 324 5 stated state VBN 13433 324 6 not not RB 13433 324 7 so so RB 13433 324 8 much much JJ 13433 324 9 with with IN 13433 324 10 the the DT 13433 324 11 hope hope NN 13433 324 12 of of IN 13433 324 13 leading lead VBG 13433 324 14 to to IN 13433 324 15 any any DT 13433 324 16 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 324 17 on on IN 13433 324 18 the the DT 13433 324 19 identity identity NN 13433 324 20 of of IN 13433 324 21 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 324 22 , , , 13433 324 23 which which WDT 13433 324 24 seems seem VBZ 13433 324 25 hopeless hopeless JJ 13433 324 26 , , , 13433 324 27 as as IN 13433 324 28 with with IN 13433 324 29 the the DT 13433 324 30 desire desire NN 13433 324 31 to to TO 13433 324 32 show show VB 13433 324 33 that that IN 13433 324 34 the the DT 13433 324 35 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 324 36 explanation explanation NN 13433 324 37 is be VBZ 13433 324 38 not not RB 13433 324 39 nearly nearly RB 13433 324 40 so so RB 13433 324 41 obvious obvious JJ 13433 324 42 as as IN 13433 324 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 324 44 is be VBZ 13433 324 45 usually usually RB 13433 324 46 assumed assume VBN 13433 324 47 to to TO 13433 324 48 be be VB 13433 324 49 . . . 13433 324 50 " " '' 13433 325 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 325 2 34:3 34:3 CD 13433 325 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 325 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 325 5 Grove Grove NNP 13433 325 6 is be VBZ 13433 325 7 very very RB 13433 325 8 right right JJ 13433 325 9 . . . 13433 326 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 326 2 have have VBP 13433 326 3 been be VBN 13433 326 4 careful careful JJ 13433 326 5 only only RB 13433 326 6 to to TO 13433 326 7 quote quote VB 13433 326 8 from from IN 13433 326 9 writers writer NNS 13433 326 10 who who WP 13433 326 11 are be VBP 13433 326 12 either either RB 13433 326 13 " " `` 13433 326 14 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 326 15 , , , 13433 326 16 " " '' 13433 326 17 or or CC 13433 326 18 far far RB 13433 326 19 from from IN 13433 326 20 belonging belong VBG 13433 326 21 to to IN 13433 326 22 heterodox heterodox NNP 13433 326 23 schools school NNS 13433 326 24 . . . 13433 327 1 Is be VBZ 13433 327 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 327 3 not not RB 13433 327 4 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 327 5 clear clear JJ 13433 327 6 that that IN 13433 327 7 no no DT 13433 327 8 place place NN 13433 327 9 of of IN 13433 327 10 the the DT 13433 327 11 name name NN 13433 327 12 of of IN 13433 327 13 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 327 14 can can MD 13433 327 15 be be VB 13433 327 16 reasonably reasonably RB 13433 327 17 identified identify VBN 13433 327 18 ? ? . 13433 328 1 The the DT 13433 328 2 case case NN 13433 328 3 , , , 13433 328 4 in in IN 13433 328 5 fact fact NN 13433 328 6 , , , 13433 328 7 simply simply RB 13433 328 8 stands stand VBZ 13433 328 9 thus:--As thus:--as ADD 13433 328 10 the the DT 13433 328 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 328 12 mentions mention VBZ 13433 328 13 a a DT 13433 328 14 town town NN 13433 328 15 called call VBN 13433 328 16 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 328 17 , , , 13433 328 18 apologists apologist NNS 13433 328 19 maintain maintain VBP 13433 328 20 that that IN 13433 328 21 there there EX 13433 328 22 must must MD 13433 328 23 have have VB 13433 328 24 been be VBN 13433 328 25 such such PDT 13433 328 26 a a DT 13433 328 27 place place NN 13433 328 28 , , , 13433 328 29 and and CC 13433 328 30 attempt attempt VB 13433 328 31 by by IN 13433 328 32 various various JJ 13433 328 33 theories theory NNS 13433 328 34 to to TO 13433 328 35 find find VB 13433 328 36 a a DT 13433 328 37 site site NN 13433 328 38 for for IN 13433 328 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 328 40 . . . 13433 329 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 329 2 is be VBZ 13433 329 3 certain certain JJ 13433 329 4 , , , 13433 329 5 however however RB 13433 329 6 , , , 13433 329 7 that that IN 13433 329 8 even even RB 13433 329 9 in in IN 13433 329 10 the the DT 13433 329 11 days day NNS 13433 329 12 of of IN 13433 329 13 St. St. NNP 13433 329 14 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 329 15 there there EX 13433 329 16 was be VBD 13433 329 17 no no DT 13433 329 18 real real JJ 13433 329 19 trace trace NN 13433 329 20 of of IN 13433 329 21 such such PDT 13433 329 22 a a DT 13433 329 23 town town NN 13433 329 24 , , , 13433 329 25 and and CC 13433 329 26 apologists apologist NNS 13433 329 27 and and CC 13433 329 28 travellers traveller NNS 13433 329 29 have have VBP 13433 329 30 not not RB 13433 329 31 since since RB 13433 329 32 been be VBN 13433 329 33 able able JJ 13433 329 34 to to TO 13433 329 35 discover discover VB 13433 329 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 329 37 , , , 13433 329 38 except except IN 13433 329 39 in in IN 13433 329 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 329 41 own own JJ 13433 329 42 imaginations imagination NNS 13433 329 43 . . . 13433 330 1 With with IN 13433 330 2 regard regard NN 13433 330 3 to to IN 13433 330 4 the the DT 13433 330 5 insinuation insinuation NN 13433 330 6 that that IN 13433 330 7 the the DT 13433 330 8 references reference NNS 13433 330 9 given give VBN 13433 330 10 in in IN 13433 330 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 330 12 notes note NNS 13433 330 13 constitute constitute VBP 13433 330 14 a a DT 13433 330 15 " " `` 13433 330 16 subtle subtle JJ 13433 330 17 mode mode NN 13433 330 18 of of IN 13433 330 19 intimidation intimidation NN 13433 330 20 " " '' 13433 330 21 and and CC 13433 330 22 " " `` 13433 330 23 literary literary JJ 13433 330 24 browbeating browbeating NN 13433 330 25 , , , 13433 330 26 " " '' 13433 330 27 Canon Canon NNP 13433 330 28 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 330 29 omits omit VBZ 13433 330 30 to to TO 13433 330 31 say say VB 13433 330 32 that that IN 13433 330 33 I -PRON- PRP 13433 330 34 as as RB 13433 330 35 fully fully RB 13433 330 36 and and CC 13433 330 37 candidly candidly RB 13433 330 38 refer refer VB 13433 330 39 to to IN 13433 330 40 those those DT 13433 330 41 who who WP 13433 330 42 maintain maintain VBP 13433 330 43 views view NNS 13433 330 44 wholly wholly RB 13433 330 45 different different JJ 13433 330 46 from from IN 13433 330 47 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 330 48 own own JJ 13433 330 49 , , , 13433 330 50 as as IN 13433 330 51 to to IN 13433 330 52 those those DT 13433 330 53 who who WP 13433 330 54 support support VBP 13433 330 55 me -PRON- PRP 13433 330 56 . . . 13433 331 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 331 2 is be VBZ 13433 331 3 very very RB 13433 331 4 possible possible JJ 13433 331 5 , , , 13433 331 6 considering consider VBG 13433 331 7 the the DT 13433 331 8 number number NN 13433 331 9 of of IN 13433 331 10 these these DT 13433 331 11 references reference NNS 13433 331 12 , , , 13433 331 13 that that IN 13433 331 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 331 15 may may MD 13433 331 16 have have VB 13433 331 17 committed commit VBN 13433 331 18 some some DT 13433 331 19 errors error NNS 13433 331 20 , , , 13433 331 21 and and CC 13433 331 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 331 23 can can MD 13433 331 24 only only RB 13433 331 25 say say VB 13433 331 26 that that IN 13433 331 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 331 28 shall shall MD 13433 331 29 very very RB 13433 331 30 thankfully thankfully RB 13433 331 31 receive receive VB 13433 331 32 from from IN 13433 331 33 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 331 34 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 331 35 any any DT 13433 331 36 corrections correction NNS 13433 331 37 which which WDT 13433 331 38 he -PRON- PRP 13433 331 39 may may MD 13433 331 40 be be VB 13433 331 41 good good JJ 13433 331 42 enough enough RB 13433 331 43 to to TO 13433 331 44 point point VB 13433 331 45 out out RP 13433 331 46 . . . 13433 332 1 Instead instead RB 13433 332 2 of of IN 13433 332 3 intimidation intimidation NN 13433 332 4 and and CC 13433 332 5 browbeating browbeating NN 13433 332 6 , , , 13433 332 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 332 8 sole sole JJ 13433 332 9 desire desire NN 13433 332 10 has have VBZ 13433 332 11 been be VBN 13433 332 12 to to TO 13433 332 13 indicate indicate VB 13433 332 14 to to IN 13433 332 15 all all DT 13433 332 16 who who WP 13433 332 17 may may MD 13433 332 18 be be VB 13433 332 19 anxious anxious JJ 13433 332 20 further further RB 13433 332 21 to to TO 13433 332 22 examine examine VB 13433 332 23 questions question NNS 13433 332 24 in in IN 13433 332 25 debate debate NN 13433 332 26 , , , 13433 332 27 works work VBZ 13433 332 28 in in IN 13433 332 29 which which WDT 13433 332 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 332 31 may may MD 13433 332 32 find find VB 13433 332 33 them -PRON- PRP 13433 332 34 discussed discuss VBN 13433 332 35 . . . 13433 333 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 333 2 is be VBZ 13433 333 3 time time NN 13433 333 4 that that IN 13433 333 5 the the DT 13433 333 6 system system NN 13433 333 7 of of IN 13433 333 8 advancing advance VBG 13433 333 9 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 333 10 opinions opinion NNS 13433 333 11 with with IN 13433 333 12 perfect perfect JJ 13433 333 13 assurance assurance NN 13433 333 14 , , , 13433 333 15 and and CC 13433 333 16 without without IN 13433 333 17 a a DT 13433 333 18 hint hint NN 13433 333 19 that that IN 13433 333 20 they -PRON- PRP 13433 333 21 are be VBP 13433 333 22 disputed dispute VBN 13433 333 23 by by IN 13433 333 24 anyone anyone NN 13433 333 25 , , , 13433 333 26 should should MD 13433 333 27 come come VB 13433 333 28 to to IN 13433 333 29 an an DT 13433 333 30 end end NN 13433 333 31 , , , 13433 333 32 and and CC 13433 333 33 that that IN 13433 333 34 earnest earnest JJ 13433 333 35 men man NNS 13433 333 36 should should MD 13433 333 37 be be VB 13433 333 38 made make VBN 13433 333 39 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 333 40 with with IN 13433 333 41 the the DT 13433 333 42 true true JJ 13433 333 43 state state NN 13433 333 44 of of IN 13433 333 45 the the DT 13433 333 46 case case NN 13433 333 47 . . . 13433 334 1 As as IN 13433 334 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 334 3 Mozley Mozley NNP 13433 334 4 rightly rightly RB 13433 334 5 and and CC 13433 334 6 honestly honestly RB 13433 334 7 says say VBZ 13433 334 8 : : : 13433 334 9 " " `` 13433 334 10 The the DT 13433 334 11 majority majority NN 13433 334 12 of of IN 13433 334 13 mankind mankind NN 13433 334 14 , , , 13433 334 15 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 334 16 , , , 13433 334 17 owe owe VBP 13433 334 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 334 19 belief belief NN 13433 334 20 rather rather RB 13433 334 21 to to IN 13433 334 22 the the DT 13433 334 23 outward outward JJ 13433 334 24 influence influence NN 13433 334 25 of of IN 13433 334 26 custom custom NN 13433 334 27 and and CC 13433 334 28 education education NN 13433 334 29 than than IN 13433 334 30 to to IN 13433 334 31 any any DT 13433 334 32 strong strong JJ 13433 334 33 principle principle NN 13433 334 34 of of IN 13433 334 35 faith faith NN 13433 334 36 within within IN 13433 334 37 ; ; : 13433 334 38 and and CC 13433 334 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 334 40 is be VBZ 13433 334 41 to to TO 13433 334 42 be be VB 13433 334 43 feared fear VBN 13433 334 44 that that IN 13433 334 45 many many JJ 13433 334 46 , , , 13433 334 47 if if IN 13433 334 48 they -PRON- PRP 13433 334 49 came come VBD 13433 334 50 to to TO 13433 334 51 perceive perceive VB 13433 334 52 how how WRB 13433 334 53 wonderful wonderful JJ 13433 334 54 what what WP 13433 334 55 they -PRON- PRP 13433 334 56 believed believe VBD 13433 334 57 was be VBD 13433 334 58 , , , 13433 334 59 would would MD 13433 334 60 not not RB 13433 334 61 find find VB 13433 334 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 334 63 belief belief NN 13433 334 64 so so RB 13433 334 65 easy easy JJ 13433 334 66 and and CC 13433 334 67 so so RB 13433 334 68 matter matter RB 13433 334 69 - - HYPH 13433 334 70 of of IN 13433 334 71 - - HYPH 13433 334 72 course course NN 13433 334 73 a a DT 13433 334 74 thing thing NN 13433 334 75 as as IN 13433 334 76 they -PRON- PRP 13433 334 77 appear appear VBP 13433 334 78 to to TO 13433 334 79 find find VB 13433 334 80 it -PRON- PRP 13433 334 81 . . . 13433 334 82 " " '' 13433 335 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 335 2 36:1 36:1 CD 13433 335 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 335 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 335 5 shall shall MD 13433 335 6 not not RB 13433 335 7 here here RB 13433 335 8 follow follow VB 13433 335 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 335 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 335 11 into into IN 13433 335 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 335 13 general general JJ 13433 335 14 remarks remark NNS 13433 335 15 regarding regard VBG 13433 335 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 335 17 ' ' `` 13433 335 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 335 19 , , , 13433 335 20 ' ' '' 13433 335 21 nor nor CC 13433 335 22 shall shall MD 13433 335 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 335 24 proceed proceed VB 13433 335 25 , , , 13433 335 26 in in IN 13433 335 27 this this DT 13433 335 28 article article NN 13433 335 29 , , , 13433 335 30 to to TO 13433 335 31 discuss discuss VB 13433 335 32 the the DT 13433 335 33 dilemma dilemma NN 13433 335 34 in in IN 13433 335 35 which which WDT 13433 335 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 335 37 attempts attempt VBZ 13433 335 38 to to TO 13433 335 39 involve involve VB 13433 335 40 me -PRON- PRP 13433 335 41 through through IN 13433 335 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 335 43 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN 13433 335 44 and and CC 13433 335 45 consequent consequent JJ 13433 335 46 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 335 47 , , , 13433 335 48 of of IN 13433 335 49 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 335 50 views view NNS 13433 335 51 regarding regard VBG 13433 335 52 the the DT 13433 335 53 Supreme Supreme NNP 13433 335 54 Being Being NNP 13433 335 55 . . . 13433 336 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 336 2 am be VBP 13433 336 3 almost almost RB 13433 336 4 inclined inclined JJ 13433 336 5 to to TO 13433 336 6 think think VB 13433 336 7 that that IN 13433 336 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 336 9 can can MD 13433 336 10 have have VB 13433 336 11 the the DT 13433 336 12 pleasure pleasure NN 13433 336 13 of of IN 13433 336 14 agreeing agree VBG 13433 336 15 with with IN 13433 336 16 him -PRON- PRP 13433 336 17 in in IN 13433 336 18 one one CD 13433 336 19 important important JJ 13433 336 20 point point NN 13433 336 21 , , , 13433 336 22 at at IN 13433 336 23 least least JJS 13433 336 24 , , , 13433 336 25 before before IN 13433 336 26 coming come VBG 13433 336 27 to to IN 13433 336 28 a a DT 13433 336 29 close close NN 13433 336 30 . . . 13433 337 1 When when WRB 13433 337 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 337 3 read read VBP 13433 337 4 the the DT 13433 337 5 curiously curiously RB 13433 337 6 modified modify VBN 13433 337 7 statement statement NN 13433 337 8 that that WDT 13433 337 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 337 10 have have VBP 13433 337 11 " " `` 13433 337 12 studiously studiously RB 13433 337 13 avoided avoid VBN 13433 337 14 committing commit VBG 13433 337 15 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 337 16 to to IN 13433 337 17 a a DT 13433 337 18 belief belief NN 13433 337 19 in in IN 13433 337 20 a a DT 13433 337 21 universal universal JJ 13433 337 22 Father Father NNP 13433 337 23 , , , 13433 337 24 or or CC 13433 337 25 a a DT 13433 337 26 moral moral JJ 13433 337 27 Governor governor NN 13433 337 28 , , , 13433 337 29 or or CC 13433 337 30 even even RB 13433 337 31 in in IN 13433 337 32 a a DT 13433 337 33 Personal personal JJ 13433 337 34 God God NNP 13433 337 35 , , , 13433 337 36 " " '' 13433 337 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 337 38 seems seem VBZ 13433 337 39 clear clear JJ 13433 337 40 to to IN 13433 337 41 me -PRON- PRP 13433 337 42 that that IN 13433 337 43 the the DT 13433 337 44 _ _ NNP 13433 337 45 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 337 46 Religion Religion NNP 13433 337 47 _ _ NNP 13433 337 48 about about IN 13433 337 49 which which WDT 13433 337 50 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 337 51 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 337 52 has have VBZ 13433 337 53 been be VBN 13433 337 54 writing write VBG 13433 337 55 can can MD 13433 337 56 not not RB 13433 337 57 be be VB 13433 337 58 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 337 59 work work NN 13433 337 60 , , , 13433 337 61 but but CC 13433 337 62 is be VBZ 13433 337 63 simply simply RB 13433 337 64 a a DT 13433 337 65 work work NN 13433 337 66 of of IN 13433 337 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 337 68 own own JJ 13433 337 69 imagination imagination NN 13433 337 70 . . . 13433 338 1 That that DT 13433 338 2 work work NN 13433 338 3 can can MD 13433 338 4 not not RB 13433 338 5 possibly possibly RB 13433 338 6 have have VB 13433 338 7 contained contain VBN 13433 338 8 , , , 13433 338 9 for for IN 13433 338 10 instance instance NN 13433 338 11 , , , 13433 338 12 the the DT 13433 338 13 chapter chapter NN 13433 338 14 on on IN 13433 338 15 " " `` 13433 338 16 Anthropomorphic Anthropomorphic NNP 13433 338 17 Divinity Divinity NNP 13433 338 18 , , , 13433 338 19 " " '' 13433 338 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 338 21 36:2 36:2 CD 13433 338 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 338 23 in in IN 13433 338 24 which which WDT 13433 338 25 , , , 13433 338 26 on on IN 13433 338 27 the the DT 13433 338 28 contrary contrary NN 13433 338 29 , , , 13433 338 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 338 31 studiously studiously RB 13433 338 32 commit commit VBP 13433 338 33 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 338 34 to to IN 13433 338 35 very very RB 13433 338 36 decided decided JJ 13433 338 37 disbelief disbelief NN 13433 338 38 in in IN 13433 338 39 such such PDT 13433 338 40 a a DT 13433 338 41 " " `` 13433 338 42 Personal personal JJ 13433 338 43 God God NNP 13433 338 44 " " '' 13433 338 45 as as IN 13433 338 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 338 47 means mean VBZ 13433 338 48 . . . 13433 339 1 In in IN 13433 339 2 no no DT 13433 339 3 way way NN 13433 339 4 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 13433 339 5 with with IN 13433 339 6 that that DT 13433 339 7 chapter chapter NN 13433 339 8 are be VBP 13433 339 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 339 10 concluding conclude VBG 13433 339 11 remarks remark NNS 13433 339 12 , , , 13433 339 13 contrasting contrast VBG 13433 339 14 with with IN 13433 339 15 the the DT 13433 339 16 spasmodic spasmodic JJ 13433 339 17 Jewish jewish JJ 13433 339 18 Divinity Divinity NNP 13433 339 19 a a DT 13433 339 20 Supreme Supreme NNP 13433 339 21 Being Being NNP 13433 339 22 manifested manifest VBN 13433 339 23 in in IN 13433 339 24 the the DT 13433 339 25 operation operation NN 13433 339 26 of of IN 13433 339 27 invariable invariable JJ 13433 339 28 laws law NNS 13433 339 29 -- -- : 13433 339 30 whose whose WP$ 13433 339 31 very very JJ 13433 339 32 invariability invariability NN 13433 339 33 is be VBZ 13433 339 34 the the DT 13433 339 35 guarantee guarantee NN 13433 339 36 of of IN 13433 339 37 beneficence beneficence NN 13433 339 38 and and CC 13433 339 39 security security NN 13433 339 40 . . . 13433 340 1 If if IN 13433 340 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 340 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 340 4 , , , 13433 340 5 however however RB 13433 340 6 , , , 13433 340 7 succeeded succeed VBD 13433 340 8 in in IN 13433 340 9 convicting convict VBG 13433 340 10 me -PRON- PRP 13433 340 11 of of IN 13433 340 12 inconsistency inconsistency NN 13433 340 13 in in IN 13433 340 14 those those DT 13433 340 15 final final JJ 13433 340 16 expressions expression NNS 13433 340 17 , , , 13433 340 18 there there EX 13433 340 19 could could MD 13433 340 20 be be VB 13433 340 21 no no RB 13433 340 22 doubt doubt RB 13433 340 23 which which WDT 13433 340 24 view view NN 13433 340 25 must must MD 13433 340 26 logically logically RB 13433 340 27 be be VB 13433 340 28 abandoned abandon VBN 13433 340 29 , , , 13433 340 30 and and CC 13433 340 31 it -PRON- PRP 13433 340 32 would would MD 13433 340 33 be be VB 13433 340 34 a a DT 13433 340 35 new new JJ 13433 340 36 sensation sensation NN 13433 340 37 to to TO 13433 340 38 secure secure VB 13433 340 39 the the DT 13433 340 40 approval approval NN 13433 340 41 of of IN 13433 340 42 a a DT 13433 340 43 divine divine JJ 13433 340 44 by by IN 13433 340 45 the the DT 13433 340 46 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 13433 340 47 destruction destruction NN 13433 340 48 of of IN 13433 340 49 the the DT 13433 340 50 last last JJ 13433 340 51 page page NN 13433 340 52 of of IN 13433 340 53 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 340 54 work work NN 13433 340 55 . . . 13433 341 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 341 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 341 3 , , , 13433 341 4 again again RB 13433 341 5 , , , 13433 341 6 refers refer VBZ 13433 341 7 to to IN 13433 341 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 341 9 Mill Mill NNP 13433 341 10 's 's POS 13433 341 11 " " `` 13433 341 12 Three three CD 13433 341 13 Essays essay NNS 13433 341 14 on on IN 13433 341 15 Religion religion NN 13433 341 16 , , , 13433 341 17 " " '' 13433 341 18 but but CC 13433 341 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 341 20 does do VBZ 13433 341 21 not not RB 13433 341 22 appear appear VB 13433 341 23 to to TO 13433 341 24 have have VB 13433 341 25 very very RB 13433 341 26 deeply deeply RB 13433 341 27 studied study VBN 13433 341 28 that that DT 13433 341 29 work work NN 13433 341 30 . . . 13433 342 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 342 2 confess confess VBP 13433 342 3 that that IN 13433 342 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 342 5 do do VBP 13433 342 6 not not RB 13433 342 7 entirely entirely RB 13433 342 8 agree agree VB 13433 342 9 with with IN 13433 342 10 some some DT 13433 342 11 views view NNS 13433 342 12 therein therein RB 13433 342 13 expressed express VBN 13433 342 14 , , , 13433 342 15 and and CC 13433 342 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 342 17 hope hope VBP 13433 342 18 that that IN 13433 342 19 , , , 13433 342 20 hereafter hereafter RB 13433 342 21 , , , 13433 342 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 342 23 may may MD 13433 342 24 have have VB 13433 342 25 an an DT 13433 342 26 opportunity opportunity NN 13433 342 27 of of IN 13433 342 28 explaining explain VBG 13433 342 29 what what WP 13433 342 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 342 31 are be VBP 13433 342 32 ; ; : 13433 342 33 but but CC 13433 342 34 I -PRON- PRP 13433 342 35 am be VBP 13433 342 36 surprised surprised JJ 13433 342 37 that that IN 13433 342 38 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 342 39 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 342 40 has have VBZ 13433 342 41 failed fail VBN 13433 342 42 to to TO 13433 342 43 observe observe VB 13433 342 44 how how WRB 13433 342 45 singularly singularly RB 13433 342 46 that that DT 13433 342 47 great great JJ 13433 342 48 Thinker Thinker NNP 13433 342 49 supports support VBZ 13433 342 50 the the DT 13433 342 51 general general JJ 13433 342 52 results result NNS 13433 342 53 of of IN 13433 342 54 _ _ NNP 13433 342 55 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 342 56 Religion Religion NNP 13433 342 57 _ _ NNP 13433 342 58 , , , 13433 342 59 to to IN 13433 342 60 the the DT 13433 342 61 point point NN 13433 342 62 even even RB 13433 342 63 of of IN 13433 342 64 a a DT 13433 342 65 frequent frequent JJ 13433 342 66 agreement agreement NN 13433 342 67 almost almost RB 13433 342 68 in in IN 13433 342 69 words word NNS 13433 342 70 . . . 13433 343 1 If if IN 13433 343 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 343 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 343 4 had have VBD 13433 343 5 studied study VBN 13433 343 6 Mill Mill NNP 13433 343 7 a a DT 13433 343 8 little little JJ 13433 343 9 more more RBR 13433 343 10 closely closely RB 13433 343 11 , , , 13433 343 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 343 13 would would MD 13433 343 14 not not RB 13433 343 15 have have VB 13433 343 16 committed commit VBN 13433 343 17 the the DT 13433 343 18 serious serious JJ 13433 343 19 error error NN 13433 343 20 of of IN 13433 343 21 arguing argue VBG 13433 343 22 : : : 13433 343 23 " " `` 13433 343 24 Obviously obviously RB 13433 343 25 , , , 13433 343 26 if if IN 13433 343 27 the the DT 13433 343 28 author author NN 13433 343 29 has have VBZ 13433 343 30 established establish VBN 13433 343 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 343 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 343 33 in in IN 13433 343 34 the the DT 13433 343 35 first first JJ 13433 343 36 part part NN 13433 343 37 , , , 13433 343 38 the the DT 13433 343 39 second second JJ 13433 343 40 and and CC 13433 343 41 third third JJ 13433 343 42 are be VBP 13433 343 43 altogether altogether RB 13433 343 44 superfluous superfluous JJ 13433 343 45 . . . 13433 344 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 344 2 is be VBZ 13433 344 3 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 344 4 strange strange JJ 13433 344 5 , , , 13433 344 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 344 7 , , , 13433 344 8 that that IN 13433 344 9 more more JJR 13433 344 10 than than IN 13433 344 11 three three CD 13433 344 12 - - HYPH 13433 344 13 fourths fourth NNS 13433 344 14 of of IN 13433 344 15 the the DT 13433 344 16 whole whole JJ 13433 344 17 work work NN 13433 344 18 should should MD 13433 344 19 be be VB 13433 344 20 devoted devoted JJ 13433 344 21 to to IN 13433 344 22 this this DT 13433 344 23 needless needless JJ 13433 344 24 task task NN 13433 344 25 . . . 13433 344 26 " " '' 13433 345 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 345 2 37:1 37:1 CD 13433 345 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 345 4 Now now RB 13433 345 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 345 6 argument argument NN 13433 345 7 in in IN 13433 345 8 the the DT 13433 345 9 first first JJ 13433 345 10 part part NN 13433 345 11 is be VBZ 13433 345 12 not not RB 13433 345 13 that that IN 13433 345 14 miracles miracle NNS 13433 345 15 are be VBP 13433 345 16 impossible impossible JJ 13433 345 17 -- -- : 13433 345 18 a a DT 13433 345 19 thesis thesis NN 13433 345 20 which which WDT 13433 345 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 345 22 is be VBZ 13433 345 23 quite quite RB 13433 345 24 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 345 25 to to TO 13433 345 26 maintain maintain VB 13433 345 27 -- -- : 13433 345 28 but but CC 13433 345 29 the the DT 13433 345 30 much much RB 13433 345 31 more more RBR 13433 345 32 simple simple JJ 13433 345 33 one one NN 13433 345 34 that that WDT 13433 345 35 miracles miracle NNS 13433 345 36 are be VBP 13433 345 37 _ _ NNP 13433 345 38 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 345 39 _ _ NNP 13433 345 40 incredible incredible JJ 13433 345 41 . . . 13433 346 1 Having have VBG 13433 346 2 shown show VBN 13433 346 3 that that IN 13433 346 4 they -PRON- PRP 13433 346 5 are be VBP 13433 346 6 so so RB 13433 346 7 , , , 13433 346 8 and and CC 13433 346 9 appreciated appreciate VBD 13433 346 10 the the DT 13433 346 11 true true JJ 13433 346 12 nature nature NN 13433 346 13 of of IN 13433 346 14 the the DT 13433 346 15 allegation allegation NN 13433 346 16 of of IN 13433 346 17 miracles miracle NNS 13433 346 18 , , , 13433 346 19 and and CC 13433 346 20 the the DT 13433 346 21 amount amount NN 13433 346 22 of of IN 13433 346 23 evidence evidence NN 13433 346 24 requisite requisite JJ 13433 346 25 to to TO 13433 346 26 establish establish VB 13433 346 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 346 28 , , , 13433 346 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 346 30 proceed proceed VBP 13433 346 31 to to TO 13433 346 32 examine examine VB 13433 346 33 the the DT 13433 346 34 evidence evidence NN 13433 346 35 which which WDT 13433 346 36 is be VBZ 13433 346 37 actually actually RB 13433 346 38 produced produce VBN 13433 346 39 in in IN 13433 346 40 support support NN 13433 346 41 of of IN 13433 346 42 the the DT 13433 346 43 assertion assertion NN 13433 346 44 that that IN 13433 346 45 , , , 13433 346 46 although although IN 13433 346 47 miracles miracle NNS 13433 346 48 are be VBP 13433 346 49 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 346 50 incredible incredible JJ 13433 346 51 , , , 13433 346 52 they -PRON- PRP 13433 346 53 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 346 54 took take VBD 13433 346 55 place place NN 13433 346 56 . . . 13433 347 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 347 2 Mill Mill NNP 13433 347 3 clearly clearly RB 13433 347 4 supports support VBZ 13433 347 5 me -PRON- PRP 13433 347 6 in in IN 13433 347 7 this this DT 13433 347 8 course course NN 13433 347 9 . . . 13433 348 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 348 2 states state VBZ 13433 348 3 the the DT 13433 348 4 main main JJ 13433 348 5 principle principle NN 13433 348 6 of of IN 13433 348 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 348 8 argument argument NN 13433 348 9 thus thus RB 13433 348 10 : : : 13433 348 11 " " `` 13433 348 12 A a DT 13433 348 13 revelation revelation NN 13433 348 14 , , , 13433 348 15 therefore therefore RB 13433 348 16 , , , 13433 348 17 can can MD 13433 348 18 not not RB 13433 348 19 be be VB 13433 348 20 proved prove VBN 13433 348 21 divine divine JJ 13433 348 22 unless unless IN 13433 348 23 by by IN 13433 348 24 external external JJ 13433 348 25 evidence evidence NN 13433 348 26 ; ; : 13433 348 27 that that RB 13433 348 28 is is RB 13433 348 29 , , , 13433 348 30 by by IN 13433 348 31 the the DT 13433 348 32 exhibition exhibition NN 13433 348 33 of of IN 13433 348 34 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 348 35 facts fact NNS 13433 348 36 . . . 13433 349 1 And and CC 13433 349 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 349 3 have have VBP 13433 349 4 to to TO 13433 349 5 consider consider VB 13433 349 6 , , , 13433 349 7 whether whether IN 13433 349 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 349 9 is be VBZ 13433 349 10 possible possible JJ 13433 349 11 to to TO 13433 349 12 prove prove VB 13433 349 13 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 349 14 facts fact NNS 13433 349 15 , , , 13433 349 16 and and CC 13433 349 17 if if IN 13433 349 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 349 19 is be VBZ 13433 349 20 , , , 13433 349 21 what what WDT 13433 349 22 evidence evidence NN 13433 349 23 is be VBZ 13433 349 24 required require VBN 13433 349 25 to to TO 13433 349 26 prove prove VB 13433 349 27 them -PRON- PRP 13433 349 28 . . . 13433 349 29 " " '' 13433 350 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 350 2 37:2 37:2 CD 13433 350 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 350 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 350 5 Mill Mill NNP 13433 350 6 decides decide VBZ 13433 350 7 that that IN 13433 350 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 350 9 is be VBZ 13433 350 10 possible possible JJ 13433 350 11 to to TO 13433 350 12 prove prove VB 13433 350 13 the the DT 13433 350 14 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 350 15 of of IN 13433 350 16 a a DT 13433 350 17 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 350 18 fact fact NN 13433 350 19 , , , 13433 350 20 if if IN 13433 350 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 350 22 actually actually RB 13433 350 23 occurred occur VBD 13433 350 24 , , , 13433 350 25 and and CC 13433 350 26 after after IN 13433 350 27 showing show VBG 13433 350 28 the the DT 13433 350 29 great great JJ 13433 350 30 preponderance preponderance NN 13433 350 31 of of IN 13433 350 32 evidence evidence NN 13433 350 33 against against IN 13433 350 34 miracles miracle NNS 13433 350 35 , , , 13433 350 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 350 37 says say VBZ 13433 350 38 : : : 13433 350 39 " " `` 13433 350 40 Against against IN 13433 350 41 this this DT 13433 350 42 weight weight NN 13433 350 43 of of IN 13433 350 44 negative negative JJ 13433 350 45 evidence evidence NN 13433 350 46 we -PRON- PRP 13433 350 47 have have VBP 13433 350 48 to to TO 13433 350 49 set set VB 13433 350 50 such such JJ 13433 350 51 positive positive JJ 13433 350 52 evidence evidence NN 13433 350 53 as as IN 13433 350 54 is be VBZ 13433 350 55 produced produce VBN 13433 350 56 in in IN 13433 350 57 attestation attestation NN 13433 350 58 of of IN 13433 350 59 exceptions exception NNS 13433 350 60 ; ; : 13433 350 61 in in IN 13433 350 62 other other JJ 13433 350 63 words word NNS 13433 350 64 , , , 13433 350 65 the the DT 13433 350 66 positive positive JJ 13433 350 67 evidences evidence NNS 13433 350 68 of of IN 13433 350 69 miracles miracle NNS 13433 350 70 . . . 13433 351 1 And and CC 13433 351 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 351 3 have have VBP 13433 351 4 already already RB 13433 351 5 admitted admit VBN 13433 351 6 that that IN 13433 351 7 this this DT 13433 351 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 351 9 might may MD 13433 351 10 conceivably conceivably RB 13433 351 11 have have VB 13433 351 12 been be VBN 13433 351 13 such such JJ 13433 351 14 as as IN 13433 351 15 to to TO 13433 351 16 make make VB 13433 351 17 the the DT 13433 351 18 exception exception NN 13433 351 19 equally equally RB 13433 351 20 certain certain JJ 13433 351 21 with with IN 13433 351 22 the the DT 13433 351 23 rule rule NN 13433 351 24 . . . 13433 351 25 " " '' 13433 352 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 352 2 38:1 38:1 CD 13433 352 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 352 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 352 5 Mill Mill NNP 13433 352 6 's 's POS 13433 352 7 opinion opinion NN 13433 352 8 of of IN 13433 352 9 the the DT 13433 352 10 evidence evidence NN 13433 352 11 actually actually RB 13433 352 12 produced produce VBN 13433 352 13 is be VBZ 13433 352 14 not not RB 13433 352 15 flattering flattering JJ 13433 352 16 , , , 13433 352 17 and and CC 13433 352 18 may may MD 13433 352 19 be be VB 13433 352 20 compared compare VBN 13433 352 21 with with IN 13433 352 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 352 23 results result NNS 13433 352 24 : : : 13433 352 25 " " `` 13433 352 26 But but CC 13433 352 27 the the DT 13433 352 28 evidence evidence NN 13433 352 29 of of IN 13433 352 30 miracles miracle NNS 13433 352 31 , , , 13433 352 32 at at IN 13433 352 33 least least JJS 13433 352 34 to to IN 13433 352 35 Protestant Protestant NNP 13433 352 36 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 352 37 , , , 13433 352 38 is be VBZ 13433 352 39 not not RB 13433 352 40 , , , 13433 352 41 in in IN 13433 352 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 352 43 day day NN 13433 352 44 , , , 13433 352 45 of of IN 13433 352 46 this this DT 13433 352 47 cogent cogent JJ 13433 352 48 description description NN 13433 352 49 . . . 13433 353 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 353 2 is be VBZ 13433 353 3 not not RB 13433 353 4 the the DT 13433 353 5 evidence evidence NN 13433 353 6 of of IN 13433 353 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 353 8 senses sense NNS 13433 353 9 , , , 13433 353 10 but but CC 13433 353 11 of of IN 13433 353 12 witnesses witness NNS 13433 353 13 , , , 13433 353 14 and and CC 13433 353 15 even even RB 13433 353 16 this this DT 13433 353 17 not not RB 13433 353 18 at at IN 13433 353 19 first first JJ 13433 353 20 hand hand NN 13433 353 21 , , , 13433 353 22 but but CC 13433 353 23 resting rest VBG 13433 353 24 on on IN 13433 353 25 the the DT 13433 353 26 attestation attestation NN 13433 353 27 of of IN 13433 353 28 books book NNS 13433 353 29 and and CC 13433 353 30 traditions tradition NNS 13433 353 31 . . . 13433 354 1 And and CC 13433 354 2 even even RB 13433 354 3 in in IN 13433 354 4 the the DT 13433 354 5 case case NN 13433 354 6 of of IN 13433 354 7 the the DT 13433 354 8 original original JJ 13433 354 9 eye eye NN 13433 354 10 - - HYPH 13433 354 11 witnesses witness NNS 13433 354 12 , , , 13433 354 13 the the DT 13433 354 14 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 354 15 facts fact NNS 13433 354 16 asserted assert VBD 13433 354 17 on on IN 13433 354 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 354 19 alleged allege VBN 13433 354 20 testimony testimony NN 13433 354 21 are be VBP 13433 354 22 not not RB 13433 354 23 of of IN 13433 354 24 the the DT 13433 354 25 transcendent transcendent NN 13433 354 26 character character NN 13433 354 27 supposed suppose VBN 13433 354 28 in in IN 13433 354 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 354 30 example example NN 13433 354 31 , , , 13433 354 32 about about IN 13433 354 33 the the DT 13433 354 34 nature nature NN 13433 354 35 of of IN 13433 354 36 which which WDT 13433 354 37 , , , 13433 354 38 or or CC 13433 354 39 the the DT 13433 354 40 impossibility impossibility NN 13433 354 41 of of IN 13433 354 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 354 43 having have VBG 13433 354 44 had have VBN 13433 354 45 a a DT 13433 354 46 natural natural JJ 13433 354 47 origin origin NN 13433 354 48 , , , 13433 354 49 there there EX 13433 354 50 could could MD 13433 354 51 be be VB 13433 354 52 little little JJ 13433 354 53 room room NN 13433 354 54 for for IN 13433 354 55 doubt doubt NN 13433 354 56 . . . 13433 355 1 On on IN 13433 355 2 the the DT 13433 355 3 contrary contrary NN 13433 355 4 , , , 13433 355 5 the the DT 13433 355 6 recorded record VBN 13433 355 7 miracles miracle NNS 13433 355 8 are be VBP 13433 355 9 , , , 13433 355 10 in in IN 13433 355 11 the the DT 13433 355 12 first first JJ 13433 355 13 place place NN 13433 355 14 , , , 13433 355 15 generally generally RB 13433 355 16 such such JJ 13433 355 17 as as IN 13433 355 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 355 19 would would MD 13433 355 20 have have VB 13433 355 21 been be VBN 13433 355 22 extremely extremely RB 13433 355 23 difficult difficult JJ 13433 355 24 to to TO 13433 355 25 verify verify VB 13433 355 26 as as IN 13433 355 27 matters matter NNS 13433 355 28 of of IN 13433 355 29 fact fact NN 13433 355 30 , , , 13433 355 31 and and CC 13433 355 32 in in IN 13433 355 33 the the DT 13433 355 34 next next JJ 13433 355 35 place place NN 13433 355 36 , , , 13433 355 37 are be VBP 13433 355 38 hardly hardly RB 13433 355 39 ever ever RB 13433 355 40 beyond beyond IN 13433 355 41 the the DT 13433 355 42 possibility possibility NN 13433 355 43 of of IN 13433 355 44 having have VBG 13433 355 45 been be VBN 13433 355 46 brought bring VBN 13433 355 47 about about RP 13433 355 48 by by IN 13433 355 49 human human JJ 13433 355 50 means mean NNS 13433 355 51 or or CC 13433 355 52 by by IN 13433 355 53 the the DT 13433 355 54 spontaneous spontaneous JJ 13433 355 55 agencies agency NNS 13433 355 56 of of IN 13433 355 57 nature nature NN 13433 355 58 . . . 13433 355 59 " " '' 13433 356 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 356 2 38:2 38:2 CD 13433 356 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 356 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 356 5 is be VBZ 13433 356 6 to to TO 13433 356 7 substantiate substantiate VB 13433 356 8 the the DT 13433 356 9 statements statement NNS 13433 356 10 made make VBN 13433 356 11 here here RB 13433 356 12 , , , 13433 356 13 and and CC 13433 356 14 , , , 13433 356 15 in in IN 13433 356 16 fact fact NN 13433 356 17 , , , 13433 356 18 to to TO 13433 356 19 confirm confirm VB 13433 356 20 the the DT 13433 356 21 philosophical philosophical JJ 13433 356 22 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 356 23 by by IN 13433 356 24 the the DT 13433 356 25 historical historical JJ 13433 356 26 proof proof NN 13433 356 27 , , , 13433 356 28 that that IN 13433 356 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 356 30 enter enter VBP 13433 356 31 into into IN 13433 356 32 an an DT 13433 356 33 examination examination NN 13433 356 34 of of IN 13433 356 35 the the DT 13433 356 36 four four CD 13433 356 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 356 38 , , , 13433 356 39 as as IN 13433 356 40 the the DT 13433 356 41 chief chief JJ 13433 356 42 witnesses witness NNS 13433 356 43 for for IN 13433 356 44 miracles miracle NNS 13433 356 45 . . . 13433 357 1 To to IN 13433 357 2 those those DT 13433 357 3 who who WP 13433 357 4 have have VBP 13433 357 5 already already RB 13433 357 6 ascertained ascertain VBN 13433 357 7 the the DT 13433 357 8 frivolous frivolous JJ 13433 357 9 nature nature NN 13433 357 10 of of IN 13433 357 11 that that DT 13433 357 12 testimony testimony NN 13433 357 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 357 14 may may MD 13433 357 15 , , , 13433 357 16 no no RB 13433 357 17 doubt doubt RB 13433 357 18 , , , 13433 357 19 seem seem VBP 13433 357 20 useless useless JJ 13433 357 21 labour labour NN 13433 357 22 to to TO 13433 357 23 examine examine VB 13433 357 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 357 25 in in IN 13433 357 26 detail detail NN 13433 357 27 ; ; : 13433 357 28 but but CC 13433 357 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 357 30 is be VBZ 13433 357 31 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 357 32 conceivable conceivable JJ 13433 357 33 that that IN 13433 357 34 an an DT 13433 357 35 ecclesiastic ecclesiastic NN 13433 357 36 who who WP 13433 357 37 professes profess VBZ 13433 357 38 to to TO 13433 357 39 base base VB 13433 357 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 357 41 faith faith NN 13433 357 42 upon upon IN 13433 357 43 those those DT 13433 357 44 records record NNS 13433 357 45 should should MD 13433 357 46 represent represent VB 13433 357 47 such such PDT 13433 357 48 a a DT 13433 357 49 process process NN 13433 357 50 as as IN 13433 357 51 useless useless JJ 13433 357 52 . . . 13433 358 1 In in IN 13433 358 2 endeavouring endeavour VBG 13433 358 3 to to TO 13433 358 4 place place VB 13433 358 5 me -PRON- PRP 13433 358 6 on on IN 13433 358 7 the the DT 13433 358 8 forks fork NNS 13433 358 9 of of IN 13433 358 10 a a DT 13433 358 11 dilemma dilemma NN 13433 358 12 , , , 13433 358 13 in in IN 13433 358 14 fact fact NN 13433 358 15 , , , 13433 358 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 358 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 358 18 has have VBZ 13433 358 19 betrayed betray VBN 13433 358 20 that that IN 13433 358 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 358 22 altogether altogether RB 13433 358 23 fails fail VBZ 13433 358 24 to to TO 13433 358 25 appreciate appreciate VB 13433 358 26 the the DT 13433 358 27 question question NN 13433 358 28 at at IN 13433 358 29 issue issue NN 13433 358 30 , , , 13433 358 31 or or CC 13433 358 32 to to TO 13433 358 33 comprehend comprehend VB 13433 358 34 the the DT 13433 358 35 position position NN 13433 358 36 of of IN 13433 358 37 miracles miracle NNS 13433 358 38 in in IN 13433 358 39 relation relation NN 13433 358 40 to to IN 13433 358 41 philosophical philosophical JJ 13433 358 42 and and CC 13433 358 43 historical historical JJ 13433 358 44 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 358 45 . . . 13433 359 1 Instead instead RB 13433 359 2 of of IN 13433 359 3 being be VBG 13433 359 4 " " `` 13433 359 5 altogether altogether RB 13433 359 6 superfluous superfluous JJ 13433 359 7 , , , 13433 359 8 " " '' 13433 359 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 359 10 examination examination NN 13433 359 11 of of IN 13433 359 12 witnesses witness NNS 13433 359 13 , , , 13433 359 14 in in IN 13433 359 15 the the DT 13433 359 16 second second JJ 13433 359 17 and and CC 13433 359 18 third third JJ 13433 359 19 parts part NNS 13433 359 20 , , , 13433 359 21 has have VBZ 13433 359 22 more more RBR 13433 359 23 correctly correctly RB 13433 359 24 been be VBN 13433 359 25 represented represent VBN 13433 359 26 by by IN 13433 359 27 able able JJ 13433 359 28 critics critic NNS 13433 359 29 as as IN 13433 359 30 incomplete incomplete JJ 13433 359 31 , , , 13433 359 32 from from IN 13433 359 33 the the DT 13433 359 34 omission omission NN 13433 359 35 of of IN 13433 359 36 the the DT 13433 359 37 remaining remain VBG 13433 359 38 documents document NNS 13433 359 39 of of IN 13433 359 40 the the DT 13433 359 41 New New NNP 13433 359 42 Testament Testament NNP 13433 359 43 . . . 13433 360 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 360 2 foresaw foresaw VBP 13433 360 3 , , , 13433 360 4 and and CC 13433 360 5 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 360 6 to to IN 13433 360 7 some some DT 13433 360 8 degree degree NN 13433 360 9 admitted admit VBN 13433 360 10 , , , 13433 360 11 the the DT 13433 360 12 justice justice NN 13433 360 13 of of IN 13433 360 14 this this DT 13433 360 15 argument argument NN 13433 360 16 ; ; : 13433 360 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 360 18 39:1 39:1 CD 13433 360 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 360 20 but but CC 13433 360 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 360 22 work work NN 13433 360 23 being be VBG 13433 360 24 already already RB 13433 360 25 bulky bulky VBN 13433 360 26 enough enough RB 13433 360 27 , , , 13433 360 28 I -PRON- PRP 13433 360 29 reserved reserve VBD 13433 360 30 to to IN 13433 360 31 another another DT 13433 360 32 volume volume NN 13433 360 33 the the DT 13433 360 34 completion completion NN 13433 360 35 of of IN 13433 360 36 the the DT 13433 360 37 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 360 38 . . . 13433 361 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 361 2 can can MD 13433 361 3 not not RB 13433 361 4 close close VB 13433 361 5 this this DT 13433 361 6 article article NN 13433 361 7 without without IN 13433 361 8 expressing express VBG 13433 361 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 361 10 regret regret NN 13433 361 11 that that IN 13433 361 12 so so RB 13433 361 13 much much JJ 13433 361 14 which which WDT 13433 361 15 is be VBZ 13433 361 16 personal personal JJ 13433 361 17 and and CC 13433 361 18 unworthy unworthy JJ 13433 361 19 has have VBZ 13433 361 20 been be VBN 13433 361 21 introduced introduce VBN 13433 361 22 into into IN 13433 361 23 the the DT 13433 361 24 discussion discussion NN 13433 361 25 of of IN 13433 361 26 a a DT 13433 361 27 great great JJ 13433 361 28 and and CC 13433 361 29 profoundly profoundly RB 13433 361 30 important important JJ 13433 361 31 subject subject NN 13433 361 32 . . . 13433 362 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 362 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 362 3 is be VBZ 13433 362 4 too too RB 13433 362 5 able able JJ 13433 362 6 and and CC 13433 362 7 too too RB 13433 362 8 earnest earnest JJ 13433 362 9 a a DT 13433 362 10 man man NN 13433 362 11 not not RB 13433 362 12 to to TO 13433 362 13 recognise recognise VB 13433 362 14 that that IN 13433 362 15 no no DT 13433 362 16 occasional occasional JJ 13433 362 17 errors error NNS 13433 362 18 or or CC 13433 362 19 faults fault NNS 13433 362 20 in in IN 13433 362 21 a a DT 13433 362 22 writer writer NN 13433 362 23 can can MD 13433 362 24 really really RB 13433 362 25 affect affect VB 13433 362 26 the the DT 13433 362 27 validity validity NN 13433 362 28 of of IN 13433 362 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 362 30 argument argument NN 13433 362 31 , , , 13433 362 32 and and CC 13433 362 33 instead instead RB 13433 362 34 of of IN 13433 362 35 mere mere JJ 13433 362 36 general general JJ 13433 362 37 and and CC 13433 362 38 desultory desultory JJ 13433 362 39 efforts effort NNS 13433 362 40 to to TO 13433 362 41 do do VB 13433 362 42 some some DT 13433 362 43 damage damage NN 13433 362 44 to to IN 13433 362 45 me -PRON- PRP 13433 362 46 , , , 13433 362 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 362 48 would would MD 13433 362 49 be be VB 13433 362 50 much much RB 13433 362 51 more more JJR 13433 362 52 to to IN 13433 362 53 the the DT 13433 362 54 purpose purpose NN 13433 362 55 were be VBD 13433 362 56 he -PRON- PRP 13433 362 57 seriously seriously RB 13433 362 58 to to TO 13433 362 59 endeavour endeavour VB 13433 362 60 to to TO 13433 362 61 refute refute VB 13433 362 62 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 362 63 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 362 64 . . . 13433 363 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 363 2 have have VBP 13433 363 3 no no DT 13433 363 4 desire desire NN 13433 363 5 to to TO 13433 363 6 escape escape VB 13433 363 7 hard hard JJ 13433 363 8 hitting hitting NN 13433 363 9 or or CC 13433 363 10 to to TO 13433 363 11 avoid avoid VB 13433 363 12 fair fair JJ 13433 363 13 fight fight NN 13433 363 14 , , , 13433 363 15 and and CC 13433 363 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 363 17 feel feel VBP 13433 363 18 unfeigned unfeigned JJ 13433 363 19 respect respect NN 13433 363 20 for for IN 13433 363 21 many many JJ 13433 363 22 of of IN 13433 363 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 363 24 critics critic NNS 13433 363 25 who who WP 13433 363 26 , , , 13433 363 27 differing differ VBG 13433 363 28 _ _ NNP 13433 363 29 toto toto NN 13433 363 30 coelo coelo NNP 13433 363 31 _ _ NNP 13433 363 32 from from IN 13433 363 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 363 34 views view NNS 13433 363 35 , , , 13433 363 36 have have VBP 13433 363 37 with with IN 13433 363 38 vigorous vigorous JJ 13433 363 39 ability ability NN 13433 363 40 attacked attack VBD 13433 363 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 363 42 arguments argument NNS 13433 363 43 without without IN 13433 363 44 altogether altogether RB 13433 363 45 forgetting forget VBG 13433 363 46 the the DT 13433 363 47 courtesy courtesy NN 13433 363 48 due due JJ 13433 363 49 even even RB 13433 363 50 to to IN 13433 363 51 an an DT 13433 363 52 enemy enemy NN 13433 363 53 . . . 13433 364 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 364 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 364 3 will will MD 13433 364 4 not not RB 13433 364 5 find find VB 13433 364 6 me -PRON- PRP 13433 364 7 inattentive inattentive JJ 13433 364 8 to to IN 13433 364 9 courteous courteous JJ 13433 364 10 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 364 11 , , , 13433 364 12 nor nor CC 13433 364 13 indifferent indifferent JJ 13433 364 14 to to IN 13433 364 15 earnest earnest JJ 13433 364 16 criticism criticism NN 13433 364 17 , , , 13433 364 18 and and CC 13433 364 19 , , , 13433 364 20 whatever whatever WDT 13433 364 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 364 22 may may MD 13433 364 23 think think VB 13433 364 24 , , , 13433 364 25 I -PRON- PRP 13433 364 26 promise promise VBP 13433 364 27 him -PRON- PRP 13433 364 28 that that IN 13433 364 29 no no DT 13433 364 30 one one NN 13433 364 31 will will MD 13433 364 32 be be VB 13433 364 33 more more RBR 13433 364 34 ready ready JJ 13433 364 35 respectfully respectfully RB 13433 364 36 to to TO 13433 364 37 follow follow VB 13433 364 38 every every DT 13433 364 39 serious serious JJ 13433 364 40 line line NN 13433 364 41 of of IN 13433 364 42 argument argument NN 13433 364 43 than than IN 13433 364 44 the the DT 13433 364 45 author author NN 13433 364 46 of of IN 13433 364 47 _ _ NNP 13433 364 48 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 364 49 Religion Religion NNP 13433 364 50 _ _ NNP 13433 364 51 . . . 13433 365 1 II ii CD 13433 365 2 . . . 13433 366 1 _ _ NNP 13433 366 2 THE the DT 13433 366 3 SILENCE SILENCE NNP 13433 366 4 OF of IN 13433 366 5 EUSEBIUS eusebius NN 13433 366 6 -- -- : 13433 366 7 THE the DT 13433 366 8 IGNATIAN ignatian JJ 13433 366 9 EPISTLES epistle NNS 13433 366 10 . . . 13433 366 11 _ _ NNP 13433 366 12 [ [ -LRB- 13433 366 13 Endnote Endnote NNP 13433 366 14 40:1 40:1 CD 13433 366 15 ] ] -RRB- 13433 366 16 This this DT 13433 366 17 work work NN 13433 366 18 has have VBZ 13433 366 19 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 366 20 yet yet RB 13433 366 21 been be VBN 13433 366 22 twelve twelve CD 13433 366 23 months month NNS 13433 366 24 before before IN 13433 366 25 the the DT 13433 366 26 public public NN 13433 366 27 , , , 13433 366 28 but but CC 13433 366 29 both both DT 13433 366 30 in in IN 13433 366 31 this this DT 13433 366 32 country country NN 13433 366 33 and and CC 13433 366 34 in in IN 13433 366 35 America America NNP 13433 366 36 and and CC 13433 366 37 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 366 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 366 39 has have VBZ 13433 366 40 been be VBN 13433 366 41 subjected subject VBN 13433 366 42 to to IN 13433 366 43 such such JJ 13433 366 44 wide wide JJ 13433 366 45 and and CC 13433 366 46 searching search VBG 13433 366 47 criticism criticism NN 13433 366 48 by by IN 13433 366 49 writers writer NNS 13433 366 50 of of IN 13433 366 51 all all DT 13433 366 52 shades shade NNS 13433 366 53 of of IN 13433 366 54 opinion opinion NN 13433 366 55 , , , 13433 366 56 that that IN 13433 366 57 I -PRON- PRP 13433 366 58 may may MD 13433 366 59 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 366 60 be be VB 13433 366 61 permitted permit VBN 13433 366 62 to to TO 13433 366 63 make make VB 13433 366 64 a a DT 13433 366 65 few few JJ 13433 366 66 remarks remark NNS 13433 366 67 , , , 13433 366 68 and and CC 13433 366 69 to to TO 13433 366 70 review review VB 13433 366 71 some some DT 13433 366 72 of of IN 13433 366 73 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 366 74 Reviewers Reviewers NNPS 13433 366 75 . . . 13433 367 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 367 2 must must MD 13433 367 3 first first RB 13433 367 4 , , , 13433 367 5 however however RB 13433 367 6 , , , 13433 367 7 beg beg NNP 13433 367 8 leave leave VB 13433 367 9 to to TO 13433 367 10 express express VB 13433 367 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 367 12 gratitude gratitude NN 13433 367 13 to to IN 13433 367 14 that that DT 13433 367 15 large large JJ 13433 367 16 majority majority NN 13433 367 17 of of IN 13433 367 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 367 19 critics critic NNS 13433 367 20 who who WP 13433 367 21 have have VBP 13433 367 22 bestowed bestow VBN 13433 367 23 generous generous JJ 13433 367 24 commendation commendation NN 13433 367 25 upon upon IN 13433 367 26 the the DT 13433 367 27 work work NN 13433 367 28 , , , 13433 367 29 and and CC 13433 367 30 liberally liberally RB 13433 367 31 encouraged encourage VBD 13433 367 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 367 33 completion completion NN 13433 367 34 . . . 13433 368 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 368 2 have have VBP 13433 368 3 to to TO 13433 368 4 thank thank VB 13433 368 5 others other NNS 13433 368 6 , , , 13433 368 7 who who WP 13433 368 8 , , , 13433 368 9 differing differ VBG 13433 368 10 totally totally RB 13433 368 11 from from IN 13433 368 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 368 13 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 368 14 , , , 13433 368 15 have have VBP 13433 368 16 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 368 17 temperately temperately RB 13433 368 18 argued argue VBN 13433 368 19 against against IN 13433 368 20 them -PRON- PRP 13433 368 21 , , , 13433 368 22 for for IN 13433 368 23 the the DT 13433 368 24 courtesy courtesy NN 13433 368 25 with with IN 13433 368 26 which which WDT 13433 368 27 they -PRON- PRP 13433 368 28 have have VBP 13433 368 29 treated treat VBN 13433 368 30 an an DT 13433 368 31 opponent opponent NN 13433 368 32 whose whose WP$ 13433 368 33 views view NNS 13433 368 34 must must MD 13433 368 35 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 368 36 have have VB 13433 368 37 offended offend VBN 13433 368 38 them -PRON- PRP 13433 368 39 , , , 13433 368 40 and and CC 13433 368 41 I -PRON- PRP 13433 368 42 can can MD 13433 368 43 only only RB 13433 368 44 say say VB 13433 368 45 that that IN 13433 368 46 , , , 13433 368 47 whilst whilst IN 13433 368 48 such such PDT 13433 368 49 a a DT 13433 368 50 course course NN 13433 368 51 has have VBZ 13433 368 52 commanded command VBN 13433 368 53 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 368 54 unfeigned unfeigned JJ 13433 368 55 respect respect NN 13433 368 56 , , , 13433 368 57 it -PRON- PRP 13433 368 58 has have VBZ 13433 368 59 certainly certainly RB 13433 368 60 not not RB 13433 368 61 diminished diminish VBN 13433 368 62 the the DT 13433 368 63 attention attention NN 13433 368 64 with with IN 13433 368 65 which which WDT 13433 368 66 I -PRON- PRP 13433 368 67 have have VBP 13433 368 68 followed follow VBN 13433 368 69 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 368 70 arguments argument NNS 13433 368 71 . . . 13433 369 1 There there EX 13433 369 2 are be VBP 13433 369 3 two two CD 13433 369 4 serious serious JJ 13433 369 5 misapprehensions misapprehension NNS 13433 369 6 of of IN 13433 369 7 the the DT 13433 369 8 purpose purpose NN 13433 369 9 and and CC 13433 369 10 line line NN 13433 369 11 of of IN 13433 369 12 argument argument NN 13433 369 13 of of IN 13433 369 14 this this DT 13433 369 15 work work NN 13433 369 16 which which WDT 13433 369 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 369 18 desire desire VBP 13433 369 19 to to TO 13433 369 20 correct correct VB 13433 369 21 . . . 13433 370 1 Some some DT 13433 370 2 critics critic NNS 13433 370 3 have have VBP 13433 370 4 objected object VBN 13433 370 5 that that IN 13433 370 6 , , , 13433 370 7 if if IN 13433 370 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 370 9 had have VBD 13433 370 10 succeeded succeed VBN 13433 370 11 in in IN 13433 370 12 establishing establish VBG 13433 370 13 the the DT 13433 370 14 proposition proposition NN 13433 370 15 advanced advance VBN 13433 370 16 in in IN 13433 370 17 the the DT 13433 370 18 first first JJ 13433 370 19 part part NN 13433 370 20 , , , 13433 370 21 the the DT 13433 370 22 second second JJ 13433 370 23 and and CC 13433 370 24 third third JJ 13433 370 25 parts part NNS 13433 370 26 need need VBP 13433 370 27 not not RB 13433 370 28 have have VB 13433 370 29 been be VBN 13433 370 30 written write VBN 13433 370 31 : : : 13433 370 32 in in IN 13433 370 33 fact fact NN 13433 370 34 , , , 13433 370 35 that that IN 13433 370 36 the the DT 13433 370 37 historical historical JJ 13433 370 38 argument argument NN 13433 370 39 against against IN 13433 370 40 miracles miracle NNS 13433 370 41 is be VBZ 13433 370 42 only only RB 13433 370 43 necessary necessary JJ 13433 370 44 in in IN 13433 370 45 consequence consequence NN 13433 370 46 of of IN 13433 370 47 the the DT 13433 370 48 failure failure NN 13433 370 49 of of IN 13433 370 50 the the DT 13433 370 51 philosophical philosophical JJ 13433 370 52 . . . 13433 371 1 Now now RB 13433 371 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 371 3 contend contend VBP 13433 371 4 that that IN 13433 371 5 the the DT 13433 371 6 historical historical JJ 13433 371 7 is be VBZ 13433 371 8 the the DT 13433 371 9 necessary necessary JJ 13433 371 10 complement complement NN 13433 371 11 of of IN 13433 371 12 the the DT 13433 371 13 philosophical philosophical JJ 13433 371 14 argument argument NN 13433 371 15 , , , 13433 371 16 and and CC 13433 371 17 that that IN 13433 371 18 both both DT 13433 371 19 are be VBP 13433 371 20 equally equally RB 13433 371 21 requisite requisite JJ 13433 371 22 to to TO 13433 371 23 completeness completeness VB 13433 371 24 in in IN 13433 371 25 dealing deal VBG 13433 371 26 with with IN 13433 371 27 the the DT 13433 371 28 subject subject NN 13433 371 29 . . . 13433 372 1 The the DT 13433 372 2 preliminary preliminary JJ 13433 372 3 affirmation affirmation NN 13433 372 4 is be VBZ 13433 372 5 not not RB 13433 372 6 that that IN 13433 372 7 miracles miracle NNS 13433 372 8 are be VBP 13433 372 9 impossible impossible JJ 13433 372 10 , , , 13433 372 11 but but CC 13433 372 12 that that IN 13433 372 13 they -PRON- PRP 13433 372 14 are be VBP 13433 372 15 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 372 16 incredible incredible JJ 13433 372 17 . . . 13433 373 1 The the DT 13433 373 2 counter counter NN 13433 373 3 - - NN 13433 373 4 allegation allegation NN 13433 373 5 is be VBZ 13433 373 6 that that IN 13433 373 7 , , , 13433 373 8 although although IN 13433 373 9 miracles miracle NNS 13433 373 10 may may MD 13433 373 11 be be VB 13433 373 12 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 373 13 incredible incredible JJ 13433 373 14 , , , 13433 373 15 they -PRON- PRP 13433 373 16 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 373 17 actually actually RB 13433 373 18 took take VBD 13433 373 19 place place NN 13433 373 20 . . . 13433 374 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 374 2 is be VBZ 13433 374 3 , , , 13433 374 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 374 5 , , , 13433 374 6 necessary necessary JJ 13433 374 7 , , , 13433 374 8 not not RB 13433 374 9 only only RB 13433 374 10 to to TO 13433 374 11 establish establish VB 13433 374 12 the the DT 13433 374 13 antecedent antecedent NN 13433 374 14 incredibility incredibility NN 13433 374 15 , , , 13433 374 16 but but CC 13433 374 17 to to TO 13433 374 18 examine examine VB 13433 374 19 the the DT 13433 374 20 validity validity NN 13433 374 21 of of IN 13433 374 22 the the DT 13433 374 23 allegation allegation NN 13433 374 24 that that IN 13433 374 25 certain certain JJ 13433 374 26 miracles miracle NNS 13433 374 27 occurred occur VBD 13433 374 28 , , , 13433 374 29 and and CC 13433 374 30 this this DT 13433 374 31 involves involve VBZ 13433 374 32 the the DT 13433 374 33 historical historical JJ 13433 374 34 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 374 35 into into IN 13433 374 36 the the DT 13433 374 37 evidence evidence NN 13433 374 38 for for IN 13433 374 39 the the DT 13433 374 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 374 41 which which WDT 13433 374 42 occupies occupy VBZ 13433 374 43 the the DT 13433 374 44 second second JJ 13433 374 45 and and CC 13433 374 46 third third JJ 13433 374 47 parts part NNS 13433 374 48 . . . 13433 375 1 Indeed indeed RB 13433 375 2 , , , 13433 375 3 many many JJ 13433 375 4 will will MD 13433 375 5 not not RB 13433 375 6 acknowledge acknowledge VB 13433 375 7 the the DT 13433 375 8 case case NN 13433 375 9 to to TO 13433 375 10 be be VB 13433 375 11 complete complete JJ 13433 375 12 until until IN 13433 375 13 other other JJ 13433 375 14 witnesses witness NNS 13433 375 15 are be VBP 13433 375 16 questioned question VBN 13433 375 17 in in IN 13433 375 18 a a DT 13433 375 19 succeeding succeed VBG 13433 375 20 volume volume NN 13433 375 21 . . . 13433 376 1 ... ... NFP 13433 377 1 The the DT 13433 377 2 second second JJ 13433 377 3 point point NN 13433 377 4 to to TO 13433 377 5 which which WDT 13433 377 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 377 7 desire desire VBP 13433 377 8 to to TO 13433 377 9 refer refer VB 13433 377 10 is be VBZ 13433 377 11 a a DT 13433 377 12 statement statement NN 13433 377 13 which which WDT 13433 377 14 has have VBZ 13433 377 15 frequently frequently RB 13433 377 16 been be VBN 13433 377 17 made make VBN 13433 377 18 that that IN 13433 377 19 , , , 13433 377 20 in in IN 13433 377 21 the the DT 13433 377 22 second second JJ 13433 377 23 and and CC 13433 377 24 third third JJ 13433 377 25 parts part NNS 13433 377 26 , , , 13433 377 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 377 28 endeavour endeavour VBP 13433 377 29 to to TO 13433 377 30 prove prove VB 13433 377 31 that that IN 13433 377 32 the the DT 13433 377 33 four four CD 13433 377 34 canonical canonical JJ 13433 377 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 377 36 were be VBD 13433 377 37 not not RB 13433 377 38 written write VBN 13433 377 39 until until IN 13433 377 40 the the DT 13433 377 41 end end NN 13433 377 42 of of IN 13433 377 43 the the DT 13433 377 44 second second JJ 13433 377 45 century century NN 13433 377 46 . . . 13433 378 1 This this DT 13433 378 2 error error NN 13433 378 3 is be VBZ 13433 378 4 of of IN 13433 378 5 course course NN 13433 378 6 closely closely RB 13433 378 7 connected connect VBN 13433 378 8 with with IN 13433 378 9 that that DT 13433 378 10 which which WDT 13433 378 11 has have VBZ 13433 378 12 just just RB 13433 378 13 been be VBN 13433 378 14 discussed discuss VBN 13433 378 15 , , , 13433 378 16 but but CC 13433 378 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 378 18 is be VBZ 13433 378 19 difficult difficult JJ 13433 378 20 to to TO 13433 378 21 understand understand VB 13433 378 22 how how WRB 13433 378 23 anyone anyone NN 13433 378 24 who who WP 13433 378 25 had have VBD 13433 378 26 taken take VBN 13433 378 27 the the DT 13433 378 28 slightest slight JJS 13433 378 29 trouble trouble NN 13433 378 30 to to TO 13433 378 31 ascertain ascertain VB 13433 378 32 the the DT 13433 378 33 nature nature NN 13433 378 34 of of IN 13433 378 35 the the DT 13433 378 36 argument argument NN 13433 378 37 , , , 13433 378 38 and and CC 13433 378 39 to to TO 13433 378 40 state state VB 13433 378 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 378 42 fairly fairly RB 13433 378 43 , , , 13433 378 44 could could MD 13433 378 45 have have VB 13433 378 46 fallen fall VBN 13433 378 47 into into IN 13433 378 48 it -PRON- PRP 13433 378 49 . . . 13433 379 1 The the DT 13433 379 2 fact fact NN 13433 379 3 is be VBZ 13433 379 4 that that IN 13433 379 5 no no DT 13433 379 6 attempt attempt NN 13433 379 7 is be VBZ 13433 379 8 made make VBN 13433 379 9 to to TO 13433 379 10 prove prove VB 13433 379 11 anything anything NN 13433 379 12 with with IN 13433 379 13 regard regard NN 13433 379 14 to to IN 13433 379 15 the the DT 13433 379 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 379 17 . . . 13433 380 1 The the DT 13433 380 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 380 3 for for IN 13433 380 4 them -PRON- PRP 13433 380 5 is be VBZ 13433 380 6 merely merely RB 13433 380 7 examined examine VBN 13433 380 8 , , , 13433 380 9 and and CC 13433 380 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 380 11 is be VBZ 13433 380 12 found find VBN 13433 380 13 that that IN 13433 380 14 , , , 13433 380 15 so so RB 13433 380 16 far far RB 13433 380 17 from from IN 13433 380 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 380 19 affording afford VBG 13433 380 20 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 380 21 testimony testimony NN 13433 380 22 to to IN 13433 380 23 warrant warrant VB 13433 380 24 belief belief NN 13433 380 25 in in IN 13433 380 26 the the DT 13433 380 27 actual actual JJ 13433 380 28 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 380 29 of of IN 13433 380 30 miracles miracle NNS 13433 380 31 declared declare VBD 13433 380 32 to to TO 13433 380 33 be be VB 13433 380 34 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 380 35 incredible incredible JJ 13433 380 36 , , , 13433 380 37 there there EX 13433 380 38 is be VBZ 13433 380 39 not not RB 13433 380 40 a a DT 13433 380 41 certain certain JJ 13433 380 42 trace trace NN 13433 380 43 even even RB 13433 380 44 of of IN 13433 380 45 the the DT 13433 380 46 existence existence NN 13433 380 47 of of IN 13433 380 48 the the DT 13433 380 49 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 380 50 for for IN 13433 380 51 a a DT 13433 380 52 century century NN 13433 380 53 and and CC 13433 380 54 a a DT 13433 380 55 half half NN 13433 380 56 after after IN 13433 380 57 those those DT 13433 380 58 miracles miracle NNS 13433 380 59 are be VBP 13433 380 60 alleged allege VBN 13433 380 61 to to TO 13433 380 62 have have VB 13433 380 63 occurred occur VBN 13433 380 64 , , , 13433 380 65 and and CC 13433 380 66 nothing nothing NN 13433 380 67 whatever whatever WDT 13433 380 68 to to TO 13433 380 69 attest attest VB 13433 380 70 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 380 71 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 380 72 and and CC 13433 380 73 truth truth NN 13433 380 74 . . . 13433 381 1 This this DT 13433 381 2 is be VBZ 13433 381 3 a a DT 13433 381 4 very very RB 13433 381 5 different different JJ 13433 381 6 thing thing NN 13433 381 7 from from IN 13433 381 8 an an DT 13433 381 9 endeavour endeavour NN 13433 381 10 to to TO 13433 381 11 establish establish VB 13433 381 12 some some DT 13433 381 13 special special JJ 13433 381 14 theory theory NN 13433 381 15 of of IN 13433 381 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 381 17 own own JJ 13433 381 18 , , , 13433 381 19 and and CC 13433 381 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 381 21 is be VBZ 13433 381 22 because because IN 13433 381 23 this this DT 13433 381 24 line line NN 13433 381 25 of of IN 13433 381 26 argument argument NN 13433 381 27 has have VBZ 13433 381 28 not not RB 13433 381 29 been be VBN 13433 381 30 understood understand VBN 13433 381 31 , , , 13433 381 32 that that IN 13433 381 33 some some DT 13433 381 34 critics critic NNS 13433 381 35 have have VBP 13433 381 36 expressed express VBN 13433 381 37 surprise surprise NN 13433 381 38 at at IN 13433 381 39 the the DT 13433 381 40 decisive decisive JJ 13433 381 41 rejection rejection NN 13433 381 42 of of IN 13433 381 43 mere mere JJ 13433 381 44 conjectures conjecture NNS 13433 381 45 and and CC 13433 381 46 possibilities possibility NNS 13433 381 47 as as IN 13433 381 48 evidence evidence NN 13433 381 49 . . . 13433 382 1 In in IN 13433 382 2 a a DT 13433 382 3 case case NN 13433 382 4 of of IN 13433 382 5 such such JJ 13433 382 6 importance importance NN 13433 382 7 , , , 13433 382 8 no no DT 13433 382 9 testimony testimony NN 13433 382 10 which which WDT 13433 382 11 is be VBZ 13433 382 12 not not RB 13433 382 13 clear clear JJ 13433 382 14 and and CC 13433 382 15 indubitable indubitable JJ 13433 382 16 could could MD 13433 382 17 be be VB 13433 382 18 of of IN 13433 382 19 any any DT 13433 382 20 value value NN 13433 382 21 , , , 13433 382 22 but but CC 13433 382 23 the the DT 13433 382 24 evidence evidence NN 13433 382 25 producible producible JJ 13433 382 26 for for IN 13433 382 27 the the DT 13433 382 28 canonical canonical JJ 13433 382 29 Gospels Gospels NNP 13433 382 30 falls fall VBZ 13433 382 31 very very RB 13433 382 32 far far RB 13433 382 33 short short JJ 13433 382 34 even even RB 13433 382 35 of of IN 13433 382 36 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 382 37 requirements requirement NNS 13433 382 38 , , , 13433 382 39 and and CC 13433 382 40 in in IN 13433 382 41 relation relation NN 13433 382 42 to to IN 13433 382 43 miracles miracle NNS 13433 382 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 382 45 is be VBZ 13433 382 46 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 382 47 deserving deserve VBG 13433 382 48 of of IN 13433 382 49 serious serious JJ 13433 382 50 consideration consideration NN 13433 382 51 . . . 13433 383 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 383 2 has have VBZ 13433 383 3 been be VBN 13433 383 4 argued argue VBN 13433 383 5 that that IN 13433 383 6 , , , 13433 383 7 even even RB 13433 383 8 if if IN 13433 383 9 there there EX 13433 383 10 be be VBP 13433 383 11 no no DT 13433 383 12 evidence evidence NN 13433 383 13 for for IN 13433 383 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 383 15 special special JJ 13433 383 16 gospels gospel NNS 13433 383 17 , , , 13433 383 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 383 19 admit admit VBP 13433 383 20 that that IN 13433 383 21 gospels gospel NNS 13433 383 22 very very RB 13433 383 23 similar similar JJ 13433 383 24 must must MD 13433 383 25 early early RB 13433 383 26 have have VB 13433 383 27 been be VBN 13433 383 28 in in IN 13433 383 29 existence existence NN 13433 383 30 , , , 13433 383 31 and and CC 13433 383 32 that that IN 13433 383 33 these these DT 13433 383 34 equally equally RB 13433 383 35 represent represent VBP 13433 383 36 the the DT 13433 383 37 same same JJ 13433 383 38 prevailing prevailing JJ 13433 383 39 belief belief NN 13433 383 40 as as IN 13433 383 41 the the DT 13433 383 42 canonical canonical JJ 13433 383 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 383 44 : : : 13433 383 45 consequently consequently RB 13433 383 46 that that IN 13433 383 47 I -PRON- PRP 13433 383 48 merely merely RB 13433 383 49 change change VBP 13433 383 50 , , , 13433 383 51 without without IN 13433 383 52 shaking shake VBG 13433 383 53 , , , 13433 383 54 the the DT 13433 383 55 witnesses witness NNS 13433 383 56 . . . 13433 384 1 Those those DT 13433 384 2 who who WP 13433 384 3 advance advance VBP 13433 384 4 this this DT 13433 384 5 argument argument NN 13433 384 6 , , , 13433 384 7 however however RB 13433 384 8 , , , 13433 384 9 totally totally RB 13433 384 10 overlook overlook VBP 13433 384 11 the the DT 13433 384 12 fact fact NN 13433 384 13 that that IN 13433 384 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 384 15 is be VBZ 13433 384 16 not not RB 13433 384 17 the the DT 13433 384 18 reality reality NN 13433 384 19 of of IN 13433 384 20 the the DT 13433 384 21 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 384 22 belief belief NN 13433 384 23 which which WDT 13433 384 24 is be VBZ 13433 384 25 in in IN 13433 384 26 question question NN 13433 384 27 , , , 13433 384 28 but but CC 13433 384 29 the the DT 13433 384 30 reality reality NN 13433 384 31 of of IN 13433 384 32 the the DT 13433 384 33 miracles miracle NNS 13433 384 34 , , , 13433 384 35 and and CC 13433 384 36 the the DT 13433 384 37 sufficiency sufficiency NN 13433 384 38 of of IN 13433 384 39 the the DT 13433 384 40 witnesses witness NNS 13433 384 41 to to TO 13433 384 42 establish establish VB 13433 384 43 them -PRON- PRP 13433 384 44 . . . 13433 385 1 What what WP 13433 385 2 such such JJ 13433 385 3 objectors objector NNS 13433 385 4 urge urge VBP 13433 385 5 practically practically RB 13433 385 6 amounts amount VBZ 13433 385 7 to to IN 13433 385 8 this this DT 13433 385 9 : : : 13433 385 10 that that IN 13433 385 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 385 12 should should MD 13433 385 13 believe believe VB 13433 385 14 in in IN 13433 385 15 the the DT 13433 385 16 actual actual JJ 13433 385 17 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 385 18 of of IN 13433 385 19 certain certain JJ 13433 385 20 miracles miracle NNS 13433 385 21 contradictory contradictory JJ 13433 385 22 to to IN 13433 385 23 all all DT 13433 385 24 experience experience NN 13433 385 25 , , , 13433 385 26 out out IN 13433 385 27 of of IN 13433 385 28 a a DT 13433 385 29 mass mass NN 13433 385 30 of of IN 13433 385 31 false false JJ 13433 385 32 miracles miracle NNS 13433 385 33 which which WDT 13433 385 34 are be VBP 13433 385 35 reported report VBN 13433 385 36 but but CC 13433 385 37 never never RB 13433 385 38 really really RB 13433 385 39 took take VBD 13433 385 40 place place NN 13433 385 41 , , , 13433 385 42 because because IN 13433 385 43 some some DT 13433 385 44 unknown unknown JJ 13433 385 45 persons person NNS 13433 385 46 in in IN 13433 385 47 an an DT 13433 385 48 ignorant ignorant JJ 13433 385 49 and and CC 13433 385 50 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 385 51 age age NN 13433 385 52 , , , 13433 385 53 who who WP 13433 385 54 give give VBP 13433 385 55 no no DT 13433 385 56 evidence evidence NN 13433 385 57 of of IN 13433 385 58 personal personal JJ 13433 385 59 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 385 60 , , , 13433 385 61 or or CC 13433 385 62 of of IN 13433 385 63 careful careful JJ 13433 385 64 investigation investigation NN 13433 385 65 , , , 13433 385 66 have have VBP 13433 385 67 written write VBN 13433 385 68 an an DT 13433 385 69 account account NN 13433 385 70 of of IN 13433 385 71 them -PRON- PRP 13433 385 72 , , , 13433 385 73 and and CC 13433 385 74 other other JJ 13433 385 75 persons person NNS 13433 385 76 , , , 13433 385 77 equally equally RB 13433 385 78 ignorant ignorant JJ 13433 385 79 and and CC 13433 385 80 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 385 81 , , , 13433 385 82 have have VBP 13433 385 83 believed believe VBN 13433 385 84 them -PRON- PRP 13433 385 85 . . . 13433 386 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 386 2 venture venture VBP 13433 386 3 to to TO 13433 386 4 say say VB 13433 386 5 that that IN 13433 386 6 no no DT 13433 386 7 one one NN 13433 386 8 who who WP 13433 386 9 advances advance VBZ 13433 386 10 the the DT 13433 386 11 argument argument NN 13433 386 12 to to TO 13433 386 13 which which WDT 13433 386 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 386 15 am be VBP 13433 386 16 referring refer VBG 13433 386 17 can can MD 13433 386 18 have have VB 13433 386 19 realised realise VBN 13433 386 20 the the DT 13433 386 21 nature nature NN 13433 386 22 of of IN 13433 386 23 the the DT 13433 386 24 question question NN 13433 386 25 at at IN 13433 386 26 issue issue NN 13433 386 27 , , , 13433 386 28 and and CC 13433 386 29 the the DT 13433 386 30 relation relation NN 13433 386 31 of of IN 13433 386 32 miracles miracle NNS 13433 386 33 to to IN 13433 386 34 the the DT 13433 386 35 order order NN 13433 386 36 of of IN 13433 386 37 nature nature NN 13433 386 38 . . . 13433 387 1 The the DT 13433 387 2 last last JJ 13433 387 3 of of IN 13433 387 4 these these DT 13433 387 5 general general JJ 13433 387 6 objections objection NNS 13433 387 7 to to TO 13433 387 8 which which WDT 13433 387 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 387 10 need need VBP 13433 387 11 now now RB 13433 387 12 refer refer VB 13433 387 13 is be VBZ 13433 387 14 the the DT 13433 387 15 statement statement NN 13433 387 16 , , , 13433 387 17 that that IN 13433 387 18 the the DT 13433 387 19 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 387 20 with with IN 13433 387 21 regard regard NN 13433 387 22 to to IN 13433 387 23 the the DT 13433 387 24 Gospels Gospels NNP 13433 387 25 commences commence NNS 13433 387 26 precisely precisely RB 13433 387 27 where where WRB 13433 387 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 387 29 examination examination NN 13433 387 30 ends end VBZ 13433 387 31 , , , 13433 387 32 and and CC 13433 387 33 that that IN 13433 387 34 I -PRON- PRP 13433 387 35 am be VBP 13433 387 36 bound bind VBN 13433 387 37 to to TO 13433 387 38 explain explain VB 13433 387 39 how how WRB 13433 387 40 , , , 13433 387 41 if if IN 13433 387 42 no no DT 13433 387 43 trace trace NN 13433 387 44 of of IN 13433 387 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 387 46 existence existence NN 13433 387 47 is be VBZ 13433 387 48 previously previously RB 13433 387 49 discoverable discoverable JJ 13433 387 50 , , , 13433 387 51 the the DT 13433 387 52 four four CD 13433 387 53 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 387 54 are be VBP 13433 387 55 suddenly suddenly RB 13433 387 56 found find VBN 13433 387 57 in in IN 13433 387 58 general general JJ 13433 387 59 circulation circulation NN 13433 387 60 at at IN 13433 387 61 the the DT 13433 387 62 end end NN 13433 387 63 of of IN 13433 387 64 the the DT 13433 387 65 second second JJ 13433 387 66 century century NN 13433 387 67 , , , 13433 387 68 and and CC 13433 387 69 quoted quote VBN 13433 387 70 as as IN 13433 387 71 authoritative authoritative JJ 13433 387 72 documents document NNS 13433 387 73 by by IN 13433 387 74 such such JJ 13433 387 75 writers writer NNS 13433 387 76 as as IN 13433 387 77 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 387 78 . . . 13433 388 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 388 2 reply reply NN 13433 388 3 is be VBZ 13433 388 4 that that IN 13433 388 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 388 6 is be VBZ 13433 388 7 totally totally RB 13433 388 8 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 388 9 for for IN 13433 388 10 me -PRON- PRP 13433 388 11 to to TO 13433 388 12 account account VB 13433 388 13 for for IN 13433 388 14 this this DT 13433 388 15 . . . 13433 389 1 No no DT 13433 389 2 one one NN 13433 389 3 acquainted acquaint VBD 13433 389 4 with with IN 13433 389 5 the the DT 13433 389 6 history history NN 13433 389 7 of of IN 13433 389 8 pseudonymic pseudonymic JJ 13433 389 9 literature literature NN 13433 389 10 in in IN 13433 389 11 the the DT 13433 389 12 second second JJ 13433 389 13 century century NN 13433 389 14 , , , 13433 389 15 and and CC 13433 389 16 with with IN 13433 389 17 the the DT 13433 389 18 rapid rapid JJ 13433 389 19 circulation circulation NN 13433 389 20 and and CC 13433 389 21 ready ready JJ 13433 389 22 acceptance acceptance NN 13433 389 23 of of IN 13433 389 24 spurious spurious JJ 13433 389 25 works work NNS 13433 389 26 tending tend VBG 13433 389 27 to to IN 13433 389 28 edification edification NN 13433 389 29 , , , 13433 389 30 could could MD 13433 389 31 for for IN 13433 389 32 a a DT 13433 389 33 moment moment NN 13433 389 34 regard regard VB 13433 389 35 the the DT 13433 389 36 canonical canonical JJ 13433 389 37 position position NN 13433 389 38 of of IN 13433 389 39 any any DT 13433 389 40 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 389 41 at at IN 13433 389 42 the the DT 13433 389 43 end end NN 13433 389 44 of of IN 13433 389 45 that that DT 13433 389 46 century century NN 13433 389 47 either either CC 13433 389 48 as as IN 13433 389 49 evidence evidence NN 13433 389 50 of of IN 13433 389 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 389 52 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 389 53 or or CC 13433 389 54 early early JJ 13433 389 55 origin origin NN 13433 389 56 . . . 13433 390 1 That that DT 13433 390 2 which which WDT 13433 390 3 concerns concern VBZ 13433 390 4 us -PRON- PRP 13433 390 5 chiefly chiefly RB 13433 390 6 is be VBZ 13433 390 7 not not RB 13433 390 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 390 9 regarding regard VBG 13433 390 10 the the DT 13433 390 11 end end NN 13433 390 12 of of IN 13433 390 13 the the DT 13433 390 14 second second JJ 13433 390 15 but but CC 13433 390 16 the the DT 13433 390 17 beginning beginning NN 13433 390 18 of of IN 13433 390 19 the the DT 13433 390 20 first first JJ 13433 390 21 century century NN 13433 390 22 . . . 13433 391 1 Even even RB 13433 391 2 if if IN 13433 391 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 391 4 took take VBD 13433 391 5 the the DT 13433 391 6 statements statement NNS 13433 391 7 of of IN 13433 391 8 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 391 9 and and CC 13433 391 10 later late JJR 13433 391 11 Fathers father NNS 13433 391 12 , , , 13433 391 13 like like IN 13433 391 14 the the DT 13433 391 15 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 13433 391 16 Clement Clement NNP 13433 391 17 , , , 13433 391 18 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 13433 391 19 and and CC 13433 391 20 Origen Origen NNP 13433 391 21 , , , 13433 391 22 about about IN 13433 391 23 the the DT 13433 391 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 391 25 , , , 13433 391 26 they -PRON- PRP 13433 391 27 are be VBP 13433 391 28 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 391 29 without without IN 13433 391 30 value value NN 13433 391 31 except except IN 13433 391 32 as as IN 13433 391 33 personal personal JJ 13433 391 34 opinion opinion NN 13433 391 35 at at IN 13433 391 36 a a DT 13433 391 37 late late JJ 13433 391 38 date date NN 13433 391 39 , , , 13433 391 40 for for IN 13433 391 41 which which WDT 13433 391 42 no no DT 13433 391 43 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 391 44 grounds ground NNS 13433 391 45 are be VBP 13433 391 46 shown show VBN 13433 391 47 . . . 13433 392 1 Of of IN 13433 392 2 the the DT 13433 392 3 earlier early JJR 13433 392 4 history history NN 13433 392 5 of of IN 13433 392 6 those those DT 13433 392 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 392 8 there there EX 13433 392 9 is be VBZ 13433 392 10 not not RB 13433 392 11 a a DT 13433 392 12 distinct distinct JJ 13433 392 13 trace trace NN 13433 392 14 , , , 13433 392 15 except except IN 13433 392 16 of of IN 13433 392 17 a a DT 13433 392 18 nature nature NN 13433 392 19 which which WDT 13433 392 20 altogether altogether RB 13433 392 21 discredits discredit VBZ 13433 392 22 them -PRON- PRP 13433 392 23 as as IN 13433 392 24 witnesses witness NNS 13433 392 25 for for IN 13433 392 26 miracles miracle NNS 13433 392 27 . . . 13433 393 1 After after IN 13433 393 2 having have VBG 13433 393 3 carefully carefully RB 13433 393 4 weighed weigh VBN 13433 393 5 the the DT 13433 393 6 arguments argument NNS 13433 393 7 which which WDT 13433 393 8 have have VBP 13433 393 9 been be VBN 13433 393 10 advanced advance VBN 13433 393 11 against against IN 13433 393 12 this this DT 13433 393 13 work work NN 13433 393 14 , , , 13433 393 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 393 16 venture venture VBP 13433 393 17 to to TO 13433 393 18 express express VB 13433 393 19 strengthened strengthened JJ 13433 393 20 conviction conviction NN 13433 393 21 of of IN 13433 393 22 the the DT 13433 393 23 truth truth NN 13433 393 24 of of IN 13433 393 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 393 26 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 393 27 . . . 13433 394 1 The the DT 13433 394 2 best good JJS 13433 394 3 and and CC 13433 394 4 most most RBS 13433 394 5 powerful powerful JJ 13433 394 6 reasons reason NNS 13433 394 7 which which WDT 13433 394 8 able able JJ 13433 394 9 divines divine NNS 13433 394 10 and and CC 13433 394 11 apologists apologist NNS 13433 394 12 have have VBP 13433 394 13 been be VBN 13433 394 14 able able JJ 13433 394 15 to to TO 13433 394 16 bring bring VB 13433 394 17 forward forward RB 13433 394 18 against against IN 13433 394 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 394 20 main main JJ 13433 394 21 argument argument NN 13433 394 22 have have VBP 13433 394 23 , , , 13433 394 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 394 25 submit submit VBP 13433 394 26 , , , 13433 394 27 not not RB 13433 394 28 only only RB 13433 394 29 failed fail VBD 13433 394 30 to to TO 13433 394 31 shake shake VB 13433 394 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 394 33 , , , 13433 394 34 but but CC 13433 394 35 have have VBP 13433 394 36 , , , 13433 394 37 by by IN 13433 394 38 inference inference NN 13433 394 39 , , , 13433 394 40 shown show VBD 13433 394 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 394 42 to to TO 13433 394 43 be be VB 13433 394 44 unassailable unassailable JJ 13433 394 45 . . . 13433 395 1 Very very RB 13433 395 2 many many JJ 13433 395 3 of of IN 13433 395 4 those those DT 13433 395 5 who who WP 13433 395 6 have have VBP 13433 395 7 professedly professedly RB 13433 395 8 advanced advance VBN 13433 395 9 against against IN 13433 395 10 the the DT 13433 395 11 citadel citadel NN 13433 395 12 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 395 13 have have VBP 13433 395 14 practically practically RB 13433 395 15 attacked attack VBN 13433 395 16 nothing nothing NN 13433 395 17 but but IN 13433 395 18 some some DT 13433 395 19 outlying outlying JJ 13433 395 20 fort fort NN 13433 395 21 , , , 13433 395 22 which which WDT 13433 395 23 was be VBD 13433 395 24 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 395 25 worth worth JJ 13433 395 26 defence defence NN 13433 395 27 , , , 13433 395 28 whilst whilst IN 13433 395 29 others other NNS 13433 395 30 , , , 13433 395 31 who who WP 13433 395 32 have have VBP 13433 395 33 seriously seriously RB 13433 395 34 attempted attempt VBN 13433 395 35 an an DT 13433 395 36 assault assault NN 13433 395 37 , , , 13433 395 38 have have VBP 13433 395 39 shown show VBN 13433 395 40 that that IN 13433 395 41 the the DT 13433 395 42 Church Church NNP 13433 395 43 has have VBZ 13433 395 44 no no DT 13433 395 45 artillery artillery NN 13433 395 46 capable capable JJ 13433 395 47 of of IN 13433 395 48 making make VBG 13433 395 49 a a DT 13433 395 50 practicable practicable JJ 13433 395 51 breach breach NN 13433 395 52 in in IN 13433 395 53 the the DT 13433 395 54 rationalistic rationalistic JJ 13433 395 55 stronghold stronghold NN 13433 395 56 . . . 13433 396 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 396 2 say say VBP 13433 396 3 this this DT 13433 396 4 solely solely RB 13433 396 5 in in IN 13433 396 6 reference reference NN 13433 396 7 to to IN 13433 396 8 the the DT 13433 396 9 argument argument NN 13433 396 10 which which WDT 13433 396 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 396 12 have have VBP 13433 396 13 taken take VBN 13433 396 14 upon upon IN 13433 396 15 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 396 16 to to TO 13433 396 17 represent represent VB 13433 396 18 , , , 13433 396 19 and and CC 13433 396 20 in in IN 13433 396 21 no no DT 13433 396 22 sense sense NN 13433 396 23 of of IN 13433 396 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 396 25 own own JJ 13433 396 26 individual individual JJ 13433 396 27 share share NN 13433 396 28 in in IN 13433 396 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 396 30 maintenance maintenance NN 13433 396 31 . . . 13433 397 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 397 2 must must MD 13433 397 3 now now RB 13433 397 4 address address VB 13433 397 5 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 397 6 more more RBR 13433 397 7 particularly particularly RB 13433 397 8 to to IN 13433 397 9 two two CD 13433 397 10 of of IN 13433 397 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 397 12 critics critic NNS 13433 397 13 who who WP 13433 397 14 , , , 13433 397 15 with with IN 13433 397 16 great great JJ 13433 397 17 ability ability NN 13433 397 18 and and CC 13433 397 19 learning learning NN 13433 397 20 , , , 13433 397 21 have have VBP 13433 397 22 subjected subject VBN 13433 397 23 this this DT 13433 397 24 work work NN 13433 397 25 to to IN 13433 397 26 the the DT 13433 397 27 most most RBS 13433 397 28 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 397 29 and and CC 13433 397 30 microscopic microscopic JJ 13433 397 31 criticism criticism NN 13433 397 32 of of IN 13433 397 33 which which WDT 13433 397 34 personal personal JJ 13433 397 35 earnestness earnestness NN 13433 397 36 and and CC 13433 397 37 official official JJ 13433 397 38 zeal zeal NN 13433 397 39 are be VBP 13433 397 40 capable capable JJ 13433 397 41 . . . 13433 398 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 398 2 am be VBP 13433 398 3 sincerely sincerely RB 13433 398 4 obliged oblige VBN 13433 398 5 to to IN 13433 398 6 Professor Professor NNP 13433 398 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 398 8 and and CC 13433 398 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 398 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 398 11 for for IN 13433 398 12 the the DT 13433 398 13 minute minute JJ 13433 398 14 attention attention NN 13433 398 15 they -PRON- PRP 13433 398 16 have have VBP 13433 398 17 bestowed bestow VBN 13433 398 18 upon upon IN 13433 398 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 398 20 book book NN 13433 398 21 . . . 13433 399 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 399 2 had have VBD 13433 399 3 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 399 4 directly directly RB 13433 399 5 attacked attack VBN 13433 399 6 the the DT 13433 399 7 views view NNS 13433 399 8 of of IN 13433 399 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 399 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 399 11 , , , 13433 399 12 and and CC 13433 399 13 of of IN 13433 399 14 course course NN 13433 399 15 could could MD 13433 399 16 only only RB 13433 399 17 expect expect VB 13433 399 18 him -PRON- PRP 13433 399 19 to to TO 13433 399 20 do do VB 13433 399 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 399 22 best good JJS 13433 399 23 or or CC 13433 399 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 399 25 worst bad JJS 13433 399 26 against against IN 13433 399 27 me -PRON- PRP 13433 399 28 in in IN 13433 399 29 reply reply NN 13433 399 30 ; ; : 13433 399 31 and and CC 13433 399 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 399 33 am be VBP 13433 399 34 not not RB 13433 399 35 surprised surprised JJ 13433 399 36 at at IN 13433 399 37 the the DT 13433 399 38 vigour vigour NN 13433 399 39 with with IN 13433 399 40 which which WDT 13433 399 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 399 42 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 399 43 has have VBZ 13433 399 44 assailed assail VBN 13433 399 45 a a DT 13433 399 46 work work NN 13433 399 47 so so RB 13433 399 48 opposed oppose VBN 13433 399 49 to to IN 13433 399 50 principles principle NNS 13433 399 51 which which WDT 13433 399 52 he -PRON- PRP 13433 399 53 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 399 54 holds hold VBZ 13433 399 55 sacred sacred JJ 13433 399 56 , , , 13433 399 57 although although IN 13433 399 58 I -PRON- PRP 13433 399 59 may may MD 13433 399 60 be be VB 13433 399 61 permitted permit VBN 13433 399 62 to to TO 13433 399 63 express express VB 13433 399 64 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 399 65 regret regret NN 13433 399 66 that that IN 13433 399 67 he -PRON- PRP 13433 399 68 has have VBZ 13433 399 69 not not RB 13433 399 70 done do VBN 13433 399 71 so so RB 13433 399 72 in in IN 13433 399 73 a a DT 13433 399 74 spirit spirit NN 13433 399 75 more more RBR 13433 399 76 worthy worthy JJ 13433 399 77 of of IN 13433 399 78 the the DT 13433 399 79 cause cause NN 13433 399 80 which which WDT 13433 399 81 he -PRON- PRP 13433 399 82 defends defend VBZ 13433 399 83 . . . 13433 400 1 In in IN 13433 400 2 spite spite NN 13433 400 3 of of IN 13433 400 4 hostile hostile JJ 13433 400 5 criticism criticism NN 13433 400 6 of of IN 13433 400 7 very very RB 13433 400 8 unusual unusual JJ 13433 400 9 minuteness minuteness NN 13433 400 10 and and CC 13433 400 11 ability ability NN 13433 400 12 , , , 13433 400 13 no no DT 13433 400 14 flaw flaw NN 13433 400 15 or or CC 13433 400 16 error error NN 13433 400 17 has have VBZ 13433 400 18 been be VBN 13433 400 19 pointed point VBN 13433 400 20 out out RP 13433 400 21 which which WDT 13433 400 22 in in IN 13433 400 23 the the DT 13433 400 24 slightest slight JJS 13433 400 25 degree degree NN 13433 400 26 affects affect VBZ 13433 400 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 400 28 main main JJ 13433 400 29 argument argument NN 13433 400 30 , , , 13433 400 31 and and CC 13433 400 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 400 33 consider consider VBP 13433 400 34 that that IN 13433 400 35 every every DT 13433 400 36 point point NN 13433 400 37 yet yet RB 13433 400 38 objected object VBN 13433 400 39 to to IN 13433 400 40 by by IN 13433 400 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 400 42 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 400 43 , , , 13433 400 44 or or CC 13433 400 45 indicated indicate VBN 13433 400 46 by by IN 13433 400 47 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 400 48 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 400 49 , , , 13433 400 50 might may MD 13433 400 51 be be VB 13433 400 52 withdrawn withdraw VBN 13433 400 53 without without IN 13433 400 54 at at RB 13433 400 55 all all RB 13433 400 56 weakening weaken VBG 13433 400 57 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 400 58 position position NN 13433 400 59 . . . 13433 401 1 These these DT 13433 401 2 objections objection NNS 13433 401 3 , , , 13433 401 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 401 5 may may MD 13433 401 6 say say VB 13433 401 7 , , , 13433 401 8 refer refer VBP 13433 401 9 solely solely RB 13433 401 10 to to IN 13433 401 11 details detail NNS 13433 401 12 , , , 13433 401 13 and and CC 13433 401 14 only only RB 13433 401 15 follow follow VBP 13433 401 16 side side NN 13433 401 17 issues issue NNS 13433 401 18 , , , 13433 401 19 but but CC 13433 401 20 the the DT 13433 401 21 attack attack NN 13433 401 22 , , , 13433 401 23 if if IN 13433 401 24 impotent impotent NN 13433 401 25 against against IN 13433 401 26 the the DT 13433 401 27 main main JJ 13433 401 28 position position NN 13433 401 29 , , , 13433 401 30 has have VBZ 13433 401 31 in in IN 13433 401 32 many many JJ 13433 401 33 cases case NNS 13433 401 34 been be VBN 13433 401 35 insidiously insidiously RB 13433 401 36 directed direct VBN 13433 401 37 against against IN 13433 401 38 notes note NNS 13433 401 39 and and CC 13433 401 40 passing pass VBG 13433 401 41 references reference NNS 13433 401 42 , , , 13433 401 43 and and CC 13433 401 44 a a DT 13433 401 45 plentiful plentiful JJ 13433 401 46 sprinkling sprinkling NN 13433 401 47 of of IN 13433 401 48 such such JJ 13433 401 49 words word NNS 13433 401 50 as as IN 13433 401 51 " " `` 13433 401 52 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 401 53 " " '' 13433 401 54 and and CC 13433 401 55 " " `` 13433 401 56 misrepresentations misrepresentation NNS 13433 401 57 " " '' 13433 401 58 along along IN 13433 401 59 the the DT 13433 401 60 line line NN 13433 401 61 may may MD 13433 401 62 have have VB 13433 401 63 given give VBN 13433 401 64 it -PRON- PRP 13433 401 65 a a DT 13433 401 66 formidable formidable JJ 13433 401 67 appearance appearance NN 13433 401 68 and and CC 13433 401 69 malicious malicious JJ 13433 401 70 effect effect NN 13433 401 71 , , , 13433 401 72 which which WDT 13433 401 73 render render VBP 13433 401 74 it -PRON- PRP 13433 401 75 worth worth JJ 13433 401 76 while while IN 13433 401 77 once once RB 13433 401 78 for for IN 13433 401 79 all all DT 13433 401 80 to to TO 13433 401 81 meet meet VB 13433 401 82 it -PRON- PRP 13433 401 83 in in IN 13433 401 84 detail detail NN 13433 401 85 . . . 13433 402 1 The the DT 13433 402 2 first first JJ 13433 402 3 point point NN 13433 402 4 to to TO 13433 402 5 which which WDT 13433 402 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 402 7 shall shall MD 13433 402 8 refer refer VB 13433 402 9 is be VBZ 13433 402 10 an an DT 13433 402 11 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 402 12 argument argument NN 13433 402 13 by by IN 13433 402 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 402 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 402 16 regarding regard VBG 13433 402 17 the the DT 13433 402 18 " " `` 13433 402 19 SILENCE SILENCE NNP 13433 402 20 OF of IN 13433 402 21 EUSEBIUS EUSEBIUS NNP 13433 402 22 . . . 13433 402 23 " " '' 13433 403 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 403 2 45:1 45:1 CD 13433 403 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 403 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 403 5 had have VBD 13433 403 6 called call VBN 13433 403 7 attention attention NN 13433 403 8 to to IN 13433 403 9 the the DT 13433 403 10 importance importance NN 13433 403 11 of of IN 13433 403 12 considering consider VBG 13433 403 13 the the DT 13433 403 14 silence silence NN 13433 403 15 of of IN 13433 403 16 the the DT 13433 403 17 Fathers Fathers NNPS 13433 403 18 , , , 13433 403 19 under under IN 13433 403 20 certain certain JJ 13433 403 21 conditions condition NNS 13433 403 22 ; ; : 13433 403 23 [ [ -LRB- 13433 403 24 45:2 45:2 CD 13433 403 25 ] ] -RRB- 13433 403 26 and and CC 13433 403 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 403 28 might may MD 13433 403 29 , , , 13433 403 30 omitting omit VBG 13433 403 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 403 32 curious curious JJ 13433 403 33 limitation limitation NN 13433 403 34 , , , 13433 403 35 adopt adopt VB 13433 403 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 403 37 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 403 38 's 's POS 13433 403 39 opening opening NN 13433 403 40 comment comment NN 13433 403 41 upon upon IN 13433 403 42 this this DT 13433 403 43 as as IN 13433 403 44 singularly singularly RB 13433 403 45 descriptive descriptive JJ 13433 403 46 of of IN 13433 403 47 the the DT 13433 403 48 state state NN 13433 403 49 of of IN 13433 403 50 the the DT 13433 403 51 case case NN 13433 403 52 : : : 13433 403 53 " " `` 13433 403 54 In in IN 13433 403 55 one one CD 13433 403 56 province province NN 13433 403 57 more more RBR 13433 403 58 especially especially RB 13433 403 59 , , , 13433 403 60 relating relate VBG 13433 403 61 to to IN 13433 403 62 the the DT 13433 403 63 external external JJ 13433 403 64 evidences evidence NNS 13433 403 65 for for IN 13433 403 66 the the DT 13433 403 67 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 403 68 , , , 13433 403 69 silence silence VB 13433 403 70 occupies occupy VBZ 13433 403 71 a a DT 13433 403 72 prominent prominent JJ 13433 403 73 place place NN 13433 403 74 . . . 13433 403 75 " " '' 13433 404 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 404 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 404 3 proposes propose VBZ 13433 404 4 to to TO 13433 404 5 interrogate interrogate VB 13433 404 6 this this DT 13433 404 7 " " `` 13433 404 8 mysterious mysterious JJ 13433 404 9 oracle oracle NN 13433 404 10 , , , 13433 404 11 " " '' 13433 404 12 and and CC 13433 404 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 404 14 considers consider VBZ 13433 404 15 that that IN 13433 404 16 " " `` 13433 404 17 the the DT 13433 404 18 response response NN 13433 404 19 elicited elicit VBD 13433 404 20 will will MD 13433 404 21 not not RB 13433 404 22 be be VB 13433 404 23 at at RB 13433 404 24 all all RB 13433 404 25 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 13433 404 26 . . . 13433 404 27 " " '' 13433 405 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 405 2 might may MD 13433 405 3 again again RB 13433 405 4 agree agree VB 13433 405 5 with with IN 13433 405 6 him -PRON- PRP 13433 405 7 , , , 13433 405 8 but but CC 13433 405 9 that that IN 13433 405 10 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 13433 405 11 response response NN 13433 405 12 can can MD 13433 405 13 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 405 14 be be VB 13433 405 15 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 405 16 very very RB 13433 405 17 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 13433 405 18 for for IN 13433 405 19 the the DT 13433 405 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 405 21 . . . 13433 406 1 Such such JJ 13433 406 2 silence silence NN 13433 406 3 may may MD 13433 406 4 be be VB 13433 406 5 very very RB 13433 406 6 eloquent eloquent JJ 13433 406 7 , , , 13433 406 8 but but CC 13433 406 9 after after IN 13433 406 10 all all DT 13433 406 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 406 12 is be VBZ 13433 406 13 only only RB 13433 406 14 the the DT 13433 406 15 eloquence eloquence NN 13433 406 16 of of IN 13433 406 17 -- -- : 13433 406 18 silence silence NN 13433 406 19 . . . 13433 407 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 407 2 have have VBP 13433 407 3 not not RB 13433 407 4 yet yet RB 13433 407 5 met meet VBN 13433 407 6 with with IN 13433 407 7 the the DT 13433 407 8 argument argument NN 13433 407 9 anywhere anywhere RB 13433 407 10 that that IN 13433 407 11 , , , 13433 407 12 because because IN 13433 407 13 none none NN 13433 407 14 of of IN 13433 407 15 the the DT 13433 407 16 early early JJ 13433 407 17 Fathers father NNS 13433 407 18 quote quote VBP 13433 407 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 407 20 Canonical Canonical NNP 13433 407 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 407 22 , , , 13433 407 23 or or CC 13433 407 24 say say VB 13433 407 25 anything anything NN 13433 407 26 with with IN 13433 407 27 regard regard NN 13433 407 28 to to IN 13433 407 29 them -PRON- PRP 13433 407 30 , , , 13433 407 31 the the DT 13433 407 32 fact fact NN 13433 407 33 is be VBZ 13433 407 34 unambiguous unambiguous JJ 13433 407 35 evidence evidence NN 13433 407 36 that that IN 13433 407 37 they -PRON- PRP 13433 407 38 were be VBD 13433 407 39 well well RB 13433 407 40 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 407 41 with with IN 13433 407 42 them -PRON- PRP 13433 407 43 , , , 13433 407 44 and and CC 13433 407 45 considered consider VBD 13433 407 46 them -PRON- PRP 13433 407 47 apostolic apostolic NNP 13433 407 48 and and CC 13433 407 49 authoritative authoritative JJ 13433 407 50 . . . 13433 408 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 408 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 408 3 's 's POS 13433 408 4 argument argument NN 13433 408 5 from from IN 13433 408 6 Silence Silence NNP 13433 408 7 is be VBZ 13433 408 8 , , , 13433 408 9 for for IN 13433 408 10 the the DT 13433 408 11 present present NN 13433 408 12 at at IN 13433 408 13 least least JJS 13433 408 14 , , , 13433 408 15 limited limit VBN 13433 408 16 to to IN 13433 408 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 408 18 . . . 13433 409 1 The the DT 13433 409 2 point point NN 13433 409 3 on on IN 13433 409 4 which which WDT 13433 409 5 the the DT 13433 409 6 argument argument NN 13433 409 7 turns turn VBZ 13433 409 8 is be VBZ 13433 409 9 this this DT 13433 409 10 : : : 13433 409 11 After after IN 13433 409 12 examining examine VBG 13433 409 13 the the DT 13433 409 14 whole whole NN 13433 409 15 of of IN 13433 409 16 the the DT 13433 409 17 extant extant JJ 13433 409 18 writings writing NNS 13433 409 19 of of IN 13433 409 20 the the DT 13433 409 21 early early JJ 13433 409 22 Fathers father NNS 13433 409 23 , , , 13433 409 24 and and CC 13433 409 25 finding find VBG 13433 409 26 them -PRON- PRP 13433 409 27 a a DT 13433 409 28 complete complete JJ 13433 409 29 blank blank NN 13433 409 30 as as IN 13433 409 31 regards regard VBZ 13433 409 32 the the DT 13433 409 33 canonical canonical JJ 13433 409 34 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 409 35 , , , 13433 409 36 if if IN 13433 409 37 , , , 13433 409 38 by by IN 13433 409 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 409 40 use use NN 13433 409 41 of of IN 13433 409 42 apocryphal apocryphal NN 13433 409 43 works work NNS 13433 409 44 and and CC 13433 409 45 other other JJ 13433 409 46 indications indication NNS 13433 409 47 , , , 13433 409 48 they -PRON- PRP 13433 409 49 are be VBP 13433 409 50 not not RB 13433 409 51 evidence evidence NN 13433 409 52 against against IN 13433 409 53 them -PRON- PRP 13433 409 54 , , , 13433 409 55 I -PRON- PRP 13433 409 56 supplement supplement VBD 13433 409 57 this this DT 13433 409 58 , , , 13433 409 59 in in IN 13433 409 60 the the DT 13433 409 61 case case NN 13433 409 62 of of IN 13433 409 63 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 409 64 , , , 13433 409 65 Papias Papias NNP 13433 409 66 , , , 13433 409 67 and and CC 13433 409 68 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 409 69 of of IN 13433 409 70 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 409 71 , , , 13433 409 72 by by IN 13433 409 73 the the DT 13433 409 74 inference inference NN 13433 409 75 that that IN 13433 409 76 , , , 13433 409 77 as as IN 13433 409 78 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 409 79 does do VBZ 13433 409 80 not not RB 13433 409 81 state state VB 13433 409 82 that that IN 13433 409 83 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 409 84 lost lose VBN 13433 409 85 works work NNS 13433 409 86 contained contain VBD 13433 409 87 any any DT 13433 409 88 evidence evidence NN 13433 409 89 for for IN 13433 409 90 the the DT 13433 409 91 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 409 92 , , , 13433 409 93 they -PRON- PRP 13433 409 94 actually actually RB 13433 409 95 did do VBD 13433 409 96 not not RB 13433 409 97 contain contain VB 13433 409 98 any any DT 13433 409 99 . . . 13433 410 1 But but CC 13433 410 2 before before IN 13433 410 3 proceeding proceed VBG 13433 410 4 to to TO 13433 410 5 discuss discuss VB 13433 410 6 the the DT 13433 410 7 point point NN 13433 410 8 , , , 13433 410 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 410 10 is be VBZ 13433 410 11 necessary necessary JJ 13433 410 12 that that IN 13433 410 13 a a DT 13433 410 14 proper proper JJ 13433 410 15 estimate estimate NN 13433 410 16 should should MD 13433 410 17 be be VB 13433 410 18 formed form VBN 13433 410 19 of of IN 13433 410 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 410 21 importance importance NN 13433 410 22 to to IN 13433 410 23 the the DT 13433 410 24 main main JJ 13433 410 25 argument argument NN 13433 410 26 of of IN 13433 410 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 410 28 work work NN 13433 410 29 . . . 13433 411 1 The the DT 13433 411 2 evident evident JJ 13433 411 3 labour labour NN 13433 411 4 which which WDT 13433 411 5 Professor Professor NNP 13433 411 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 411 7 has have VBZ 13433 411 8 expended expend VBN 13433 411 9 upon upon IN 13433 411 10 the the DT 13433 411 11 preparation preparation NN 13433 411 12 of of IN 13433 411 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 411 14 attack attack NN 13433 411 15 , , , 13433 411 16 the the DT 13433 411 17 space space NN 13433 411 18 devoted devote VBN 13433 411 19 to to IN 13433 411 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 411 21 , , , 13433 411 22 and and CC 13433 411 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 411 24 own own JJ 13433 411 25 express express JJ 13433 411 26 words word NNS 13433 411 27 , , , 13433 411 28 would would MD 13433 411 29 naturally naturally RB 13433 411 30 lead lead VB 13433 411 31 most most JJS 13433 411 32 readers reader NNS 13433 411 33 to to TO 13433 411 34 suppose suppose VB 13433 411 35 that that IN 13433 411 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 411 37 has have VBZ 13433 411 38 almost almost RB 13433 411 39 a a DT 13433 411 40 vital vital JJ 13433 411 41 bearing bearing NN 13433 411 42 upon upon IN 13433 411 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 411 44 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 411 45 . . . 13433 412 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 412 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 412 3 says say VBZ 13433 412 4 , , , 13433 412 5 after after IN 13433 412 6 quoting quote VBG 13433 412 7 the the DT 13433 412 8 passages passage NNS 13433 412 9 in in IN 13433 412 10 which which WDT 13433 412 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 412 12 appeal appeal VBP 13433 412 13 to to IN 13433 412 14 the the DT 13433 412 15 silence silence NN 13433 412 16 of of IN 13433 412 17 Eusebius:-- eusebius:-- NN 13433 412 18 " " `` 13433 412 19 This this DT 13433 412 20 indeed indeed RB 13433 412 21 is be VBZ 13433 412 22 the the DT 13433 412 23 fundamental fundamental JJ 13433 412 24 assumption assumption NN 13433 412 25 which which WDT 13433 412 26 lies lie VBZ 13433 412 27 at at IN 13433 412 28 the the DT 13433 412 29 basis basis NN 13433 412 30 of of IN 13433 412 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 412 32 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 412 33 ; ; : 13433 412 34 and and CC 13433 412 35 the the DT 13433 412 36 reader reader NN 13433 412 37 will will MD 13433 412 38 not not RB 13433 412 39 need need VB 13433 412 40 to to TO 13433 412 41 be be VB 13433 412 42 reminded remind VBN 13433 412 43 how how WRB 13433 412 44 much much JJ 13433 412 45 of of IN 13433 412 46 the the DT 13433 412 47 argument argument NN 13433 412 48 falls fall VBZ 13433 412 49 to to IN 13433 412 50 pieces piece NNS 13433 412 51 if if IN 13433 412 52 this this DT 13433 412 53 basis basis NN 13433 412 54 should should MD 13433 412 55 prove prove VB 13433 412 56 to to TO 13433 412 57 be be VB 13433 412 58 unsound unsound JJ 13433 412 59 . . . 13433 413 1 A a DT 13433 413 2 wise wise JJ 13433 413 3 master master NN 13433 413 4 - - HYPH 13433 413 5 builder builder NN 13433 413 6 would would MD 13433 413 7 therefore therefore RB 13433 413 8 have have VB 13433 413 9 looked look VBN 13433 413 10 to to IN 13433 413 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 413 12 foundations foundation NNS 13433 413 13 first first RB 13433 413 14 , , , 13433 413 15 and and CC 13433 413 16 assured assure VBD 13433 413 17 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 413 18 of of IN 13433 413 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 413 20 strength strength NN 13433 413 21 , , , 13433 413 22 before before IN 13433 413 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 413 24 piled pile VBD 13433 413 25 up up RP 13433 413 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 413 27 fabric fabric NN 13433 413 28 to to IN 13433 413 29 this this DT 13433 413 30 height height NN 13433 413 31 . . . 13433 414 1 This this DT 13433 414 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 414 3 author author NN 13433 414 4 has have VBZ 13433 414 5 altogether altogether RB 13433 414 6 neglected neglect VBN 13433 414 7 to to TO 13433 414 8 do do VB 13433 414 9 . . . 13433 414 10 " " '' 13433 415 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 415 2 46:1 46:1 CD 13433 415 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 415 4 Towards towards IN 13433 415 5 the the DT 13433 415 6 close close NN 13433 415 7 of of IN 13433 415 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 415 9 article article NN 13433 415 10 , , , 13433 415 11 after after IN 13433 415 12 triumphantly triumphantly RB 13433 415 13 expressing express VBG 13433 415 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 415 15 belief belief NN 13433 415 16 that that IN 13433 415 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 415 18 " " `` 13433 415 19 main main JJ 13433 415 20 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 415 21 are be VBP 13433 415 22 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 13433 415 23 , , , 13433 415 24 " " '' 13433 415 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 415 26 further further RB 13433 415 27 says:-- says:-- '' 13433 415 28 " " `` 13433 415 29 If if IN 13433 415 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 415 31 are be VBP 13433 415 32 , , , 13433 415 33 then then RB 13433 415 34 the the DT 13433 415 35 reader reader NN 13433 415 36 will will MD 13433 415 37 not not RB 13433 415 38 fail fail VB 13433 415 39 to to TO 13433 415 40 see see VB 13433 415 41 how how WRB 13433 415 42 large large JJ 13433 415 43 a a DT 13433 415 44 part part NN 13433 415 45 of of IN 13433 415 46 the the DT 13433 415 47 argument argument NN 13433 415 48 in in IN 13433 415 49 _ _ NNP 13433 415 50 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 415 51 Religion Religion NNP 13433 415 52 _ _ NNP 13433 415 53 has have VBZ 13433 415 54 crumbled crumble VBN 13433 415 55 to to IN 13433 415 56 pieces piece NNS 13433 415 57 . . . 13433 415 58 " " '' 13433 416 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 416 2 46:2 46:2 CD 13433 416 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 416 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 416 5 do do VBP 13433 416 6 not not RB 13433 416 7 doubt doubt VB 13433 416 8 that that IN 13433 416 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 416 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 416 11 sincerely sincerely RB 13433 416 12 believes believe VBZ 13433 416 13 this this DT 13433 416 14 , , , 13433 416 15 but but CC 13433 416 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 416 17 must must MD 13433 416 18 allow allow VB 13433 416 19 me -PRON- PRP 13433 416 20 to to TO 13433 416 21 say say VB 13433 416 22 that that IN 13433 416 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 416 24 is be VBZ 13433 416 25 thoroughly thoroughly RB 13433 416 26 mistaken mistaken JJ 13433 416 27 in in IN 13433 416 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 416 29 estimate estimate NN 13433 416 30 of of IN 13433 416 31 the the DT 13433 416 32 importance importance NN 13433 416 33 of of IN 13433 416 34 the the DT 13433 416 35 point point NN 13433 416 36 , , , 13433 416 37 and and CC 13433 416 38 that that IN 13433 416 39 , , , 13433 416 40 as as IN 13433 416 41 regards regard VBZ 13433 416 42 this this DT 13433 416 43 work work NN 13433 416 44 , , , 13433 416 45 the the DT 13433 416 46 representations representation NNS 13433 416 47 made make VBN 13433 416 48 in in IN 13433 416 49 the the DT 13433 416 50 above above JJ 13433 416 51 passages passage NNS 13433 416 52 are be VBP 13433 416 53 a a DT 13433 416 54 very very RB 13433 416 55 strange strange JJ 13433 416 56 exaggeration exaggeration NN 13433 416 57 . . . 13433 417 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 417 2 am be VBP 13433 417 3 unfortunately unfortunately RB 13433 417 4 too too RB 13433 417 5 familiar familiar JJ 13433 417 6 , , , 13433 417 7 in in IN 13433 417 8 connection connection NN 13433 417 9 with with IN 13433 417 10 criticism criticism NN 13433 417 11 on on IN 13433 417 12 this this DT 13433 417 13 book book NN 13433 417 14 , , , 13433 417 15 with with IN 13433 417 16 instances instance NNS 13433 417 17 of of IN 13433 417 18 vast vast JJ 13433 417 19 expenditure expenditure NN 13433 417 20 of of IN 13433 417 21 time time NN 13433 417 22 and and CC 13433 417 23 strength strength NN 13433 417 24 in in IN 13433 417 25 attacking attack VBG 13433 417 26 points point NNS 13433 417 27 to to TO 13433 417 28 which which WDT 13433 417 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 417 30 attach attach VBP 13433 417 31 no no DT 13433 417 32 importance importance NN 13433 417 33 whatever whatever WDT 13433 417 34 , , , 13433 417 35 and and CC 13433 417 36 which which WDT 13433 417 37 in in IN 13433 417 38 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 417 39 have have VBP 13433 417 40 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 417 41 any any DT 13433 417 42 value value NN 13433 417 43 . . . 13433 418 1 When when WRB 13433 418 2 writers writer NNS 13433 418 3 , , , 13433 418 4 after after IN 13433 418 5 an an DT 13433 418 6 amount amount NN 13433 418 7 of of IN 13433 418 8 demonstration demonstration NN 13433 418 9 which which WDT 13433 418 10 must must MD 13433 418 11 have have VB 13433 418 12 conveyed convey VBN 13433 418 13 the the DT 13433 418 14 impression impression NN 13433 418 15 that that IN 13433 418 16 vital vital JJ 13433 418 17 interests interest NNS 13433 418 18 were be VBD 13433 418 19 at at IN 13433 418 20 stake stake NN 13433 418 21 , , , 13433 418 22 have have VBP 13433 418 23 , , , 13433 418 24 at at IN 13433 418 25 least least JJS 13433 418 26 in in IN 13433 418 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 418 28 own own JJ 13433 418 29 opinion opinion NN 13433 418 30 , , , 13433 418 31 proved prove VBD 13433 418 32 that that IN 13433 418 33 I -PRON- PRP 13433 418 34 have have VBP 13433 418 35 omitted omit VBN 13433 418 36 to to TO 13433 418 37 dot dot VB 13433 418 38 an an DT 13433 418 39 " " `` 13433 418 40 i i PRP 13433 418 41 , , , 13433 418 42 " " '' 13433 418 43 cross cross VB 13433 418 44 a a DT 13433 418 45 " " `` 13433 418 46 t t NN 13433 418 47 , , , 13433 418 48 " " '' 13433 418 49 or or CC 13433 418 50 insert insert VB 13433 418 51 an an DT 13433 418 52 inverted invert VBN 13433 418 53 comma comma NN 13433 418 54 , , , 13433 418 55 they -PRON- PRP 13433 418 56 have have VBP 13433 418 57 really really RB 13433 418 58 left leave VBN 13433 418 59 the the DT 13433 418 60 question question NN 13433 418 61 precisely precisely RB 13433 418 62 where where WRB 13433 418 63 it -PRON- PRP 13433 418 64 was be VBD 13433 418 65 . . . 13433 419 1 Now now RB 13433 419 2 , , , 13433 419 3 in in IN 13433 419 4 the the DT 13433 419 5 present present JJ 13433 419 6 instance instance NN 13433 419 7 , , , 13433 419 8 the the DT 13433 419 9 whole whole JJ 13433 419 10 extent extent NN 13433 419 11 of of IN 13433 419 12 the the DT 13433 419 13 argument argument NN 13433 419 14 which which WDT 13433 419 15 is be VBZ 13433 419 16 based base VBN 13433 419 17 upon upon IN 13433 419 18 the the DT 13433 419 19 silence silence NN 13433 419 20 of of IN 13433 419 21 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 419 22 is be VBZ 13433 419 23 an an DT 13433 419 24 inference inference NN 13433 419 25 regarding regard VBG 13433 419 26 some some DT 13433 419 27 lost lose VBN 13433 419 28 works work NNS 13433 419 29 of of IN 13433 419 30 three three CD 13433 419 31 writers writer NNS 13433 419 32 only only RB 13433 419 33 , , , 13433 419 34 which which WDT 13433 419 35 might may MD 13433 419 36 altogether altogether RB 13433 419 37 be be VB 13433 419 38 withdrawn withdraw VBN 13433 419 39 without without IN 13433 419 40 affecting affect VBG 13433 419 41 the the DT 13433 419 42 case case NN 13433 419 43 . . . 13433 420 1 The the DT 13433 420 2 object object NN 13433 420 3 of of IN 13433 420 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 420 5 investigation investigation NN 13433 420 6 is be VBZ 13433 420 7 to to TO 13433 420 8 discover discover VB 13433 420 9 what what WP 13433 420 10 evidence evidence NN 13433 420 11 actually actually RB 13433 420 12 exists exist VBZ 13433 420 13 in in IN 13433 420 14 the the DT 13433 420 15 works work NNS 13433 420 16 of of IN 13433 420 17 early early JJ 13433 420 18 writers writer NNS 13433 420 19 regarding regard VBG 13433 420 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 420 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 420 22 . . . 13433 421 1 In in IN 13433 421 2 the the DT 13433 421 3 fragments fragment NNS 13433 421 4 which which WDT 13433 421 5 remain remain VBP 13433 421 6 of of IN 13433 421 7 the the DT 13433 421 8 works work NNS 13433 421 9 of of IN 13433 421 10 three three CD 13433 421 11 writers writer NNS 13433 421 12 , , , 13433 421 13 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 421 14 , , , 13433 421 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 421 16 , , , 13433 421 17 and and CC 13433 421 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 421 19 of of IN 13433 421 20 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 421 21 , , , 13433 421 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 421 23 do do VBP 13433 421 24 not not RB 13433 421 25 find find VB 13433 421 26 any any DT 13433 421 27 evidence evidence NN 13433 421 28 of of IN 13433 421 29 acquaintance acquaintance NN 13433 421 30 with with IN 13433 421 31 these these DT 13433 421 32 Gospels,--the gospels,--the PRP$ 13433 421 33 works work NNS 13433 421 34 mentioned mention VBN 13433 421 35 by by IN 13433 421 36 Papias Papias NNP 13433 421 37 being be VBG 13433 421 38 , , , 13433 421 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 421 40 contend contend VBP 13433 421 41 , , , 13433 421 42 different different JJ 13433 421 43 from from IN 13433 421 44 the the DT 13433 421 45 existing exist VBG 13433 421 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 421 47 attributed attribute VBD 13433 421 48 to to IN 13433 421 49 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 421 50 and and CC 13433 421 51 Mark Mark NNP 13433 421 52 . . . 13433 422 1 Whether whether IN 13433 422 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 422 3 am be VBP 13433 422 4 right right JJ 13433 422 5 or or CC 13433 422 6 not not RB 13433 422 7 in in IN 13433 422 8 this this DT 13433 422 9 does do VBZ 13433 422 10 not not RB 13433 422 11 affect affect VB 13433 422 12 the the DT 13433 422 13 present present JJ 13433 422 14 discussion discussion NN 13433 422 15 . . . 13433 423 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 423 2 is be VBZ 13433 423 3 an an DT 13433 423 4 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 13433 423 5 fact fact NN 13433 423 6 that that IN 13433 423 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 423 8 does do VBZ 13433 423 9 not not RB 13433 423 10 mention mention VB 13433 423 11 that that IN 13433 423 12 the the DT 13433 423 13 lost lost JJ 13433 423 14 works work NNS 13433 423 15 of of IN 13433 423 16 these these DT 13433 423 17 writers writer NNS 13433 423 18 contained contain VBD 13433 423 19 any any DT 13433 423 20 reference reference NN 13433 423 21 to to IN 13433 423 22 , , , 13433 423 23 or or CC 13433 423 24 information information NN 13433 423 25 about about IN 13433 423 26 , , , 13433 423 27 the the DT 13433 423 28 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 423 29 , , , 13433 423 30 nor nor CC 13433 423 31 have have VBP 13433 423 32 we -PRON- PRP 13433 423 33 any any DT 13433 423 34 statement statement NN 13433 423 35 from from IN 13433 423 36 any any DT 13433 423 37 other other JJ 13433 423 38 author author NN 13433 423 39 to to IN 13433 423 40 that that DT 13433 423 41 effect effect NN 13433 423 42 . . . 13433 424 1 The the DT 13433 424 2 objection objection NN 13433 424 3 of of IN 13433 424 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 424 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 424 6 is be VBZ 13433 424 7 limited limit VBN 13433 424 8 to to IN 13433 424 9 a a DT 13433 424 10 denial denial NN 13433 424 11 that that IN 13433 424 12 the the DT 13433 424 13 silence silence NN 13433 424 14 of of IN 13433 424 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 424 16 warrants warrant VBZ 13433 424 17 the the DT 13433 424 18 inference inference NN 13433 424 19 that that IN 13433 424 20 , , , 13433 424 21 because because IN 13433 424 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 424 23 does do VBZ 13433 424 24 not not RB 13433 424 25 state state VB 13433 424 26 that that IN 13433 424 27 these these DT 13433 424 28 writers writer NNS 13433 424 29 made make VBD 13433 424 30 quotations quotation NNS 13433 424 31 from from IN 13433 424 32 or or CC 13433 424 33 references reference NNS 13433 424 34 to to IN 13433 424 35 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 424 36 canonical canonical JJ 13433 424 37 books book NNS 13433 424 38 , , , 13433 424 39 the the DT 13433 424 40 lost lost JJ 13433 424 41 works work NNS 13433 424 42 did do VBD 13433 424 43 not not RB 13433 424 44 contain contain VB 13433 424 45 any any DT 13433 424 46 ; ; : 13433 424 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 424 48 does do VBZ 13433 424 49 not not RB 13433 424 50 , , , 13433 424 51 however however RB 13433 424 52 , , , 13433 424 53 extend extend VBP 13433 424 54 to to IN 13433 424 55 interesting interesting JJ 13433 424 56 information information NN 13433 424 57 regarding regard VBG 13433 424 58 those those DT 13433 424 59 books book NNS 13433 424 60 , , , 13433 424 61 which which WDT 13433 424 62 he -PRON- PRP 13433 424 63 admits admit VBZ 13433 424 64 it -PRON- PRP 13433 424 65 was be VBD 13433 424 66 the the DT 13433 424 67 purpose purpose NN 13433 424 68 of of IN 13433 424 69 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 424 70 to to TO 13433 424 71 record record VB 13433 424 72 . . . 13433 425 1 To to TO 13433 425 2 give give VB 13433 425 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 425 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 425 5 's 's POS 13433 425 6 statements statement NNS 13433 425 7 , , , 13433 425 8 which which WDT 13433 425 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 425 10 am be VBP 13433 425 11 examining examine VBG 13433 425 12 , , , 13433 425 13 the the DT 13433 425 14 fullest full JJS 13433 425 15 possible possible JJ 13433 425 16 support support NN 13433 425 17 , , , 13433 425 18 however however RB 13433 425 19 , , , 13433 425 20 suppose suppose VB 13433 425 21 that that IN 13433 425 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 425 23 abandon abandon VBP 13433 425 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 425 25 altogether altogether RB 13433 425 26 , , , 13433 425 27 and and CC 13433 425 28 do do VBP 13433 425 29 not not RB 13433 425 30 draw draw VB 13433 425 31 any any DT 13433 425 32 inference inference NN 13433 425 33 of of IN 13433 425 34 any any DT 13433 425 35 kind kind NN 13433 425 36 from from IN 13433 425 37 him -PRON- PRP 13433 425 38 beyond beyond IN 13433 425 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 425 40 positive positive JJ 13433 425 41 statements statement NNS 13433 425 42 , , , 13433 425 43 how how WRB 13433 425 44 would would MD 13433 425 45 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 425 46 case case NN 13433 425 47 stand stand VB 13433 425 48 ? ? . 13433 426 1 Simply simply RB 13433 426 2 as as RB 13433 426 3 complete complete JJ 13433 426 4 as as IN 13433 426 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 426 6 well well RB 13433 426 7 could could MD 13433 426 8 be be VB 13433 426 9 : : : 13433 426 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 426 11 , , , 13433 426 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 426 13 , , , 13433 426 14 and and CC 13433 426 15 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 426 16 do do VBP 13433 426 17 not not RB 13433 426 18 furnish furnish VB 13433 426 19 any any DT 13433 426 20 evidence evidence NN 13433 426 21 in in IN 13433 426 22 favour favour NN 13433 426 23 of of IN 13433 426 24 the the DT 13433 426 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 426 26 . . . 13433 427 1 The the DT 13433 427 2 reader reader NN 13433 427 3 , , , 13433 427 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 427 5 , , , 13433 427 6 will will MD 13433 427 7 not not RB 13433 427 8 fail fail VB 13433 427 9 to to TO 13433 427 10 see see VB 13433 427 11 how how WRB 13433 427 12 serious serious JJ 13433 427 13 a a DT 13433 427 14 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 427 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 427 16 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 427 17 has have VBZ 13433 427 18 made make VBN 13433 427 19 , , , 13433 427 20 and and CC 13433 427 21 how how WRB 13433 427 22 little little JJ 13433 427 23 the the DT 13433 427 24 argument argument NN 13433 427 25 of of IN 13433 427 26 _ _ NNP 13433 427 27 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 427 28 Religion Religion NNP 13433 427 29 _ _ NNP 13433 427 30 would would MD 13433 427 31 be be VB 13433 427 32 affected affect VBN 13433 427 33 even even RB 13433 427 34 if if IN 13433 427 35 he -PRON- PRP 13433 427 36 established establish VBD 13433 427 37 much much RB 13433 427 38 more more JJR 13433 427 39 than than IN 13433 427 40 he -PRON- PRP 13433 427 41 has have VBZ 13433 427 42 asserted assert VBN 13433 427 43 . . . 13433 428 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 428 2 may may MD 13433 428 3 now now RB 13433 428 4 proceed proceed VB 13433 428 5 to to TO 13433 428 6 consider consider VB 13433 428 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 428 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 428 9 's 's POS 13433 428 10 argument argument NN 13433 428 11 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 428 12 . . . 13433 429 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 429 2 carefully carefully RB 13433 429 3 and and CC 13433 429 4 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 429 5 defines define VBZ 13433 429 6 what what WP 13433 429 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 429 8 understands understand VBZ 13433 429 9 to to TO 13433 429 10 be be VB 13433 429 11 the the DT 13433 429 12 declared declare VBN 13433 429 13 intention intention NN 13433 429 14 of of IN 13433 429 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 429 16 in in IN 13433 429 17 composing compose VBG 13433 429 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 429 19 history history NN 13433 429 20 , , , 13433 429 21 as as IN 13433 429 22 regards regard VBZ 13433 429 23 the the DT 13433 429 24 mention mention NN 13433 429 25 or or CC 13433 429 26 use use NN 13433 429 27 of of IN 13433 429 28 the the DT 13433 429 29 disputed disputed JJ 13433 429 30 and and CC 13433 429 31 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 429 32 canonical canonical JJ 13433 429 33 books book NNS 13433 429 34 in in IN 13433 429 35 the the DT 13433 429 36 writings writing NNS 13433 429 37 of of IN 13433 429 38 the the DT 13433 429 39 Fathers Fathers NNPS 13433 429 40 , , , 13433 429 41 and and CC 13433 429 42 in in IN 13433 429 43 order order NN 13433 429 44 to to TO 13433 429 45 do do VB 13433 429 46 him -PRON- PRP 13433 429 47 full full JJ 13433 429 48 justice justice NN 13433 429 49 I -PRON- PRP 13433 429 50 will will MD 13433 429 51 quote quote VB 13433 429 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 429 53 words word NNS 13433 429 54 , , , 13433 429 55 merely merely RB 13433 429 56 taking take VBG 13433 429 57 the the DT 13433 429 58 liberty liberty NN 13433 429 59 , , , 13433 429 60 for for IN 13433 429 61 facility facility NN 13433 429 62 of of IN 13433 429 63 reference reference NN 13433 429 64 , , , 13433 429 65 of of IN 13433 429 66 dividing divide VBG 13433 429 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 429 68 statement statement NN 13433 429 69 into into IN 13433 429 70 three three CD 13433 429 71 paragraphs paragraph NNS 13433 429 72 . . . 13433 430 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 430 2 says say VBZ 13433 430 3 : : : 13433 430 4 " " `` 13433 430 5 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 430 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 430 7 proposes propose VBZ 13433 430 8 to to TO 13433 430 9 treat treat VB 13433 430 10 these these DT 13433 430 11 two two CD 13433 430 12 classes class NNS 13433 430 13 of of IN 13433 430 14 writings writing NNS 13433 430 15 in in IN 13433 430 16 two two CD 13433 430 17 different different JJ 13433 430 18 ways way NNS 13433 430 19 . . . 13433 431 1 This this DT 13433 431 2 is be VBZ 13433 431 3 the the DT 13433 431 4 cardinal cardinal JJ 13433 431 5 point point NN 13433 431 6 of of IN 13433 431 7 the the DT 13433 431 8 passage passage NN 13433 431 9 . . . 13433 432 1 " " `` 13433 432 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 432 3 1 1 CD 13433 432 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 432 5 Of of IN 13433 432 6 the the DT 13433 432 7 Antilegomena Antilegomena NNP 13433 432 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 432 9 pledges pledge VBZ 13433 432 10 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 432 11 to to TO 13433 432 12 record record VB 13433 432 13 when when WRB 13433 432 14 any any DT 13433 432 15 ancient ancient JJ 13433 432 16 writer writer NN 13433 432 17 _ _ NNP 13433 432 18 employs employ VBZ 13433 432 19 _ _ NNP 13433 432 20 any any DT 13433 432 21 book book NN 13433 432 22 belonging belong VBG 13433 432 23 to to IN 13433 432 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 432 25 class class NN 13433 432 26 ( ( -LRB- 13433 432 27 [ [ -LRB- 13433 432 28 Greek Greek NNP 13433 432 29 : : : 13433 432 30 tines tine NNS 13433 432 31 hopoiais hopoiais NNP 13433 432 32 kechrêntai kechrêntai NNP 13433 432 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 432 34 ) ) -RRB- 13433 432 35 ; ; : 13433 432 36 " " `` 13433 432 37 ( ( -LRB- 13433 432 38 2 2 CD 13433 432 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 432 40 but but CC 13433 432 41 as as IN 13433 432 42 regards regard VBZ 13433 432 43 the the DT 13433 432 44 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 432 45 Canonical canonical JJ 13433 432 46 books book NNS 13433 432 47 , , , 13433 432 48 he -PRON- PRP 13433 432 49 only only RB 13433 432 50 professes profess VBZ 13433 432 51 to to TO 13433 432 52 mention mention VB 13433 432 53 them -PRON- PRP 13433 432 54 when when WRB 13433 432 55 such such PDT 13433 432 56 a a DT 13433 432 57 writer writer NN 13433 432 58 has have VBZ 13433 432 59 something something NN 13433 432 60 to to TO 13433 432 61 _ _ NNP 13433 432 62 tell tell VB 13433 432 63 about about IN 13433 432 64 them -PRON- PRP 13433 432 65 _ _ VBP 13433 432 66 ( ( -LRB- 13433 432 67 [ [ -LRB- 13433 432 68 Greek Greek NNP 13433 432 69 : : : 13433 432 70 tina tina NNP 13433 432 71 peri peri NNP 13433 432 72 tôn tôn NNP 13433 432 73 endiathêkon endiathêkon NNP 13433 432 74 eirêtai eirêtai NNP 13433 432 75 ] ] -RRB- 13433 432 76 ) ) -RRB- 13433 432 77 . . . 13433 433 1 Any any DT 13433 433 2 _ _ NNP 13433 433 3 anecdote anecdote NN 13433 433 4 _ _ NNP 13433 433 5 of of IN 13433 433 6 interest interest NN 13433 433 7 respecting respect VBG 13433 433 8 them -PRON- PRP 13433 433 9 , , , 13433 433 10 as as IN 13433 433 11 also also RB 13433 433 12 respecting respect VBG 13433 433 13 the the DT 13433 433 14 others other NNS 13433 433 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 433 16 [ [ -LRB- 13433 433 17 Greek Greek NNP 13433 433 18 : : : 13433 433 19 tôn tôn NNP 13433 433 20 mê mê NNP 13433 433 21 toioutôn toioutôn NNP 13433 433 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 433 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 433 24 , , , 13433 433 25 will will MD 13433 433 26 be be VB 13433 433 27 recorded record VBN 13433 433 28 . . . 13433 434 1 " " `` 13433 434 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 434 3 3 3 LS 13433 434 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 434 5 But but CC 13433 434 6 in in IN 13433 434 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 434 8 case case NN 13433 434 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 434 10 nowhere nowhere RB 13433 434 11 leads lead VBZ 13433 434 12 us -PRON- PRP 13433 434 13 to to TO 13433 434 14 expect expect VB 13433 434 15 that that IN 13433 434 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 434 17 will will MD 13433 434 18 allude allude VB 13433 434 19 to to IN 13433 434 20 mere mere JJ 13433 434 21 _ _ NNP 13433 434 22 quotations quotation NNS 13433 434 23 _ _ NNP 13433 434 24 , , , 13433 434 25 however however RB 13433 434 26 numerous numerous JJ 13433 434 27 and and CC 13433 434 28 however however RB 13433 434 29 precise precise JJ 13433 434 30 . . . 13433 434 31 " " '' 13433 435 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 435 2 48:1 48:1 CD 13433 435 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 435 4 In in IN 13433 435 5 order order NN 13433 435 6 to to TO 13433 435 7 dispose dispose VB 13433 435 8 of of IN 13433 435 9 the the DT 13433 435 10 only only JJ 13433 435 11 one one CD 13433 435 12 of of IN 13433 435 13 these these DT 13433 435 14 points point NNS 13433 435 15 upon upon IN 13433 435 16 which which WDT 13433 435 17 we -PRON- PRP 13433 435 18 can can MD 13433 435 19 differ differ VB 13433 435 20 , , , 13433 435 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 435 22 will will MD 13433 435 23 first first RB 13433 435 24 refer refer VB 13433 435 25 to to IN 13433 435 26 the the DT 13433 435 27 third third JJ 13433 435 28 . . . 13433 436 1 Did do VBD 13433 436 2 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 436 3 intend intend VB 13433 436 4 to to TO 13433 436 5 point point VB 13433 436 6 out out RP 13433 436 7 mere mere JJ 13433 436 8 quotations quotation NNS 13433 436 9 of of IN 13433 436 10 the the DT 13433 436 11 books book NNS 13433 436 12 which which WDT 13433 436 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 436 14 considered consider VBD 13433 436 15 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 436 16 ? ? . 13433 437 1 As as IN 13433 437 2 a a DT 13433 437 3 matter matter NN 13433 437 4 of of IN 13433 437 5 fact fact NN 13433 437 6 , , , 13433 437 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 437 8 actually actually RB 13433 437 9 did do VBD 13433 437 10 point point VB 13433 437 11 such such JJ 13433 437 12 out out IN 13433 437 13 in in IN 13433 437 14 the the DT 13433 437 15 case case NN 13433 437 16 of of IN 13433 437 17 the the DT 13433 437 18 1st 1st JJ 13433 437 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 437 20 of of IN 13433 437 21 Peter Peter NNP 13433 437 22 and and CC 13433 437 23 the the DT 13433 437 24 1st 1st NNP 13433 437 25 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 437 26 of of IN 13433 437 27 John John NNP 13433 437 28 , , , 13433 437 29 which which WDT 13433 437 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 437 31 repeatedly repeatedly RB 13433 437 32 and and CC 13433 437 33 in in IN 13433 437 34 the the DT 13433 437 35 most most RBS 13433 437 36 emphatic emphatic JJ 13433 437 37 manner manner NN 13433 437 38 declared declare VBD 13433 437 39 to to TO 13433 437 40 be be VB 13433 437 41 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 437 42 . . . 13433 438 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 438 2 49:1 49:1 CD 13433 438 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 438 4 This this DT 13433 438 5 is be VBZ 13433 438 6 admitted admit VBN 13433 438 7 by by IN 13433 438 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 438 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 438 10 . . . 13433 439 1 That that IN 13433 439 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 439 3 omitted omit VBD 13433 439 4 to to TO 13433 439 5 mention mention VB 13433 439 6 a a DT 13433 439 7 reference reference NN 13433 439 8 to to IN 13433 439 9 the the DT 13433 439 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 439 11 to to IN 13433 439 12 the the DT 13433 439 13 Corinthians Corinthians NNPS 13433 439 14 in in IN 13433 439 15 the the DT 13433 439 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 439 17 of of IN 13433 439 18 Clement Clement NNP 13433 439 19 of of IN 13433 439 20 Rome Rome NNP 13433 439 21 , , , 13433 439 22 or or CC 13433 439 23 the the DT 13433 439 24 reference reference NN 13433 439 25 by by IN 13433 439 26 Theophilus Theophilus NNP 13433 439 27 to to IN 13433 439 28 the the DT 13433 439 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 439 30 of of IN 13433 439 31 John John NNP 13433 439 32 , , , 13433 439 33 and and CC 13433 439 34 other other JJ 13433 439 35 supposed suppose VBN 13433 439 36 quotations quotation NNS 13433 439 37 , , , 13433 439 38 might may MD 13433 439 39 be be VB 13433 439 40 set set VBN 13433 439 41 down down RP 13433 439 42 as as RB 13433 439 43 much much JJ 13433 439 44 to to IN 13433 439 45 oversight oversight NN 13433 439 46 as as IN 13433 439 47 intention intention NN 13433 439 48 . . . 13433 440 1 On on IN 13433 440 2 the the DT 13433 440 3 other other JJ 13433 440 4 hand hand NN 13433 440 5 , , , 13433 440 6 that that IN 13433 440 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 440 8 did do VBD 13433 440 9 mention mention VB 13433 440 10 disputed dispute VBN 13433 440 11 books book NNS 13433 440 12 is be VBZ 13433 440 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 440 14 only only RB 13433 440 15 that that IN 13433 440 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 440 17 not not RB 13433 440 18 only only RB 13433 440 19 pledged pledge VBD 13433 440 20 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 440 21 to to TO 13433 440 22 do do VB 13433 440 23 so so RB 13433 440 24 , , , 13433 440 25 but but CC 13433 440 26 actually actually RB 13433 440 27 fulfilled fulfil VBD 13433 440 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 440 29 promise promise NN 13433 440 30 . . . 13433 441 1 Although although IN 13433 441 2 much much JJ 13433 441 3 might may MD 13433 441 4 be be VB 13433 441 5 said say VBN 13433 441 6 upon upon IN 13433 441 7 this this DT 13433 441 8 point point NN 13433 441 9 , , , 13433 441 10 therefore therefore RB 13433 441 11 , , , 13433 441 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 441 13 consider consider VBP 13433 441 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 441 15 of of IN 13433 441 16 so so RB 13433 441 17 little little JJ 13433 441 18 importance importance NN 13433 441 19 that that WDT 13433 441 20 I -PRON- PRP 13433 441 21 do do VBP 13433 441 22 not not RB 13433 441 23 intend intend VB 13433 441 24 to to TO 13433 441 25 waste waste VB 13433 441 26 time time NN 13433 441 27 in in IN 13433 441 28 minutely minutely RB 13433 441 29 discussing discuss VBG 13433 441 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 441 31 . . . 13433 442 1 If if IN 13433 442 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 442 3 assertions assertion NNS 13433 442 4 with with IN 13433 442 5 regard regard NN 13433 442 6 to to IN 13433 442 7 the the DT 13433 442 8 silence silence NN 13433 442 9 of of IN 13433 442 10 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 442 11 likewise likewise RB 13433 442 12 include include VBP 13433 442 13 the the DT 13433 442 14 supposition supposition NN 13433 442 15 that that IN 13433 442 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 442 17 proposed propose VBD 13433 442 18 to to TO 13433 442 19 mention mention VB 13433 442 20 mere mere JJ 13433 442 21 quotations quotation NNS 13433 442 22 of of IN 13433 442 23 the the DT 13433 442 24 " " `` 13433 442 25 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 442 26 " " '' 13433 442 27 books book NNS 13433 442 28 , , , 13433 442 29 they -PRON- PRP 13433 442 30 are be VBP 13433 442 31 so so RB 13433 442 32 far far RB 13433 442 33 from from IN 13433 442 34 limited limited JJ 13433 442 35 to to IN 13433 442 36 this this DT 13433 442 37 very very RB 13433 442 38 subsidiary subsidiary JJ 13433 442 39 testimony testimony NN 13433 442 40 that that WDT 13433 442 41 I -PRON- PRP 13433 442 42 should should MD 13433 442 43 have have VB 13433 442 44 no no DT 13433 442 45 reluctance reluctance NN 13433 442 46 in in IN 13433 442 47 waiving waive VBG 13433 442 48 it -PRON- PRP 13433 442 49 altogether altogether RB 13433 442 50 . . . 13433 443 1 Even even RB 13433 443 2 if if IN 13433 443 3 the the DT 13433 443 4 most most RBS 13433 443 5 distinct distinct JJ 13433 443 6 quotations quotation NNS 13433 443 7 of of IN 13433 443 8 this this DT 13433 443 9 kind kind NN 13433 443 10 had have VBD 13433 443 11 occurred occur VBN 13433 443 12 in in IN 13433 443 13 the the DT 13433 443 14 lost lost JJ 13433 443 15 works work NNS 13433 443 16 of of IN 13433 443 17 the the DT 13433 443 18 three three CD 13433 443 19 writers writer NNS 13433 443 20 in in IN 13433 443 21 question question NN 13433 443 22 , , , 13433 443 23 they -PRON- PRP 13433 443 24 could could MD 13433 443 25 have have VB 13433 443 26 proved prove VBN 13433 443 27 nothing nothing NN 13433 443 28 beyond beyond IN 13433 443 29 the the DT 13433 443 30 mere mere JJ 13433 443 31 existence existence NN 13433 443 32 of of IN 13433 443 33 the the DT 13433 443 34 book book NN 13433 443 35 quoted quote VBN 13433 443 36 , , , 13433 443 37 at at IN 13433 443 38 the the DT 13433 443 39 time time NN 13433 443 40 that that WDT 13433 443 41 work work NN 13433 443 42 was be VBD 13433 443 43 written write VBN 13433 443 44 , , , 13433 443 45 but but CC 13433 443 46 would would MD 13433 443 47 have have VB 13433 443 48 done do VBN 13433 443 49 nothing nothing NN 13433 443 50 to to TO 13433 443 51 establish establish VB 13433 443 52 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 443 53 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 443 54 and and CC 13433 443 55 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 13433 443 56 . . . 13433 444 1 In in IN 13433 444 2 the the DT 13433 444 3 evidential evidential JJ 13433 444 4 destitution destitution NN 13433 444 5 of of IN 13433 444 6 the the DT 13433 444 7 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 444 8 , , , 13433 444 9 apologists apologist NNS 13433 444 10 would would MD 13433 444 11 thankfully thankfully RB 13433 444 12 have have VB 13433 444 13 received receive VBN 13433 444 14 even even RB 13433 444 15 such such JJ 13433 444 16 vague vague JJ 13433 444 17 indications indication NNS 13433 444 18 ; ; : 13433 444 19 indeed indeed RB 13433 444 20 there there EX 13433 444 21 is be VBZ 13433 444 22 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 444 23 any any DT 13433 444 24 other other JJ 13433 444 25 evidence evidence NN 13433 444 26 , , , 13433 444 27 but but CC 13433 444 28 something something NN 13433 444 29 much much RB 13433 444 30 more more RBR 13433 444 31 definite definite JJ 13433 444 32 is be VBZ 13433 444 33 required require VBN 13433 444 34 to to TO 13433 444 35 establish establish VB 13433 444 36 the the DT 13433 444 37 reality reality NN 13433 444 38 of of IN 13433 444 39 miracles miracle NNS 13433 444 40 and and CC 13433 444 41 Divine Divine NNP 13433 444 42 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 444 43 . . . 13433 445 1 If if IN 13433 445 2 this this DT 13433 445 3 point point NN 13433 445 4 be be VB 13433 445 5 , , , 13433 445 6 for for IN 13433 445 7 the the DT 13433 445 8 sake sake NN 13433 445 9 of of IN 13433 445 10 argument argument NN 13433 445 11 , , , 13433 445 12 set set VBN 13433 445 13 aside aside RB 13433 445 14 , , , 13433 445 15 what what WP 13433 445 16 is be VBZ 13433 445 17 the the DT 13433 445 18 position position NN 13433 445 19 ? ? . 13433 446 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 446 2 are be VBP 13433 446 3 not not RB 13433 446 4 entitled entitle VBN 13433 446 5 to to TO 13433 446 6 infer infer VB 13433 446 7 that that IN 13433 446 8 there there EX 13433 446 9 were be VBD 13433 446 10 no no DT 13433 446 11 quotations quotation NNS 13433 446 12 from from IN 13433 446 13 the the DT 13433 446 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 446 15 in in IN 13433 446 16 the the DT 13433 446 17 works work NNS 13433 446 18 of of IN 13433 446 19 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 446 20 , , , 13433 446 21 Papias Papias NNP 13433 446 22 , , , 13433 446 23 and and CC 13433 446 24 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 446 25 of of IN 13433 446 26 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 446 27 , , , 13433 446 28 because because IN 13433 446 29 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 446 30 does do VBZ 13433 446 31 not not RB 13433 446 32 record record VB 13433 446 33 them -PRON- PRP 13433 446 34 ; ; : 13433 446 35 but but CC 13433 446 36 , , , 13433 446 37 on on IN 13433 446 38 the the DT 13433 446 39 other other JJ 13433 446 40 hand hand NN 13433 446 41 , , , 13433 446 42 we -PRON- PRP 13433 446 43 are be VBP 13433 446 44 still still RB 13433 446 45 less less RBR 13433 446 46 entitled entitled JJ 13433 446 47 to to TO 13433 446 48 infer infer VB 13433 446 49 that that IN 13433 446 50 there there EX 13433 446 51 were be VBD 13433 446 52 any any DT 13433 446 53 . . . 13433 447 1 The the DT 13433 447 2 only only JJ 13433 447 3 inference inference NN 13433 447 4 which which WDT 13433 447 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 447 6 care care VBP 13433 447 7 to to TO 13433 447 8 draw draw VB 13433 447 9 from from IN 13433 447 10 the the DT 13433 447 11 silence silence NN 13433 447 12 of of IN 13433 447 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 447 14 is be VBZ 13433 447 15 precisely precisely RB 13433 447 16 that that IN 13433 447 17 which which WDT 13433 447 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 447 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 447 20 admits admit VBZ 13433 447 21 that that IN 13433 447 22 , , , 13433 447 23 both both DT 13433 447 24 from from IN 13433 447 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 447 26 promise promise NN 13433 447 27 and and CC 13433 447 28 practice practice NN 13433 447 29 , , , 13433 447 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 447 31 am be VBP 13433 447 32 entitled entitle VBN 13433 447 33 to to TO 13433 447 34 deduce deduce VB 13433 447 35 : : : 13433 447 36 when when WRB 13433 447 37 any any DT 13433 447 38 ancient ancient JJ 13433 447 39 writer writer NN 13433 447 40 " " '' 13433 447 41 has have VBZ 13433 447 42 something something NN 13433 447 43 to to TO 13433 447 44 _ _ NNP 13433 447 45 tell tell VB 13433 447 46 about about IN 13433 447 47 _ _ NNP 13433 447 48 " " `` 13433 447 49 the the DT 13433 447 50 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 447 51 , , , 13433 447 52 " " '' 13433 447 53 any any DT 13433 447 54 _ _ NNP 13433 447 55 anecdote anecdote NN 13433 447 56 _ _ NNP 13433 447 57 of of IN 13433 447 58 interest interest NN 13433 447 59 respecting respect VBG 13433 447 60 them -PRON- PRP 13433 447 61 , , , 13433 447 62 " " `` 13433 447 63 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 447 64 will will MD 13433 447 65 record record VB 13433 447 66 it -PRON- PRP 13433 447 67 . . . 13433 448 1 This this DT 13433 448 2 is be VBZ 13433 448 3 the the DT 13433 448 4 only only JJ 13433 448 5 information information NN 13433 448 6 of of IN 13433 448 7 the the DT 13433 448 8 slightest slight JJS 13433 448 9 value value NN 13433 448 10 to to IN 13433 448 11 this this DT 13433 448 12 work work NN 13433 448 13 which which WDT 13433 448 14 could could MD 13433 448 15 be be VB 13433 448 16 looked look VBN 13433 448 17 for for IN 13433 448 18 in in IN 13433 448 19 these these DT 13433 448 20 writers writer NNS 13433 448 21 . . . 13433 449 1 So so RB 13433 449 2 far far RB 13433 449 3 , , , 13433 449 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 449 5 , , , 13433 449 6 from from IN 13433 449 7 producing produce VBG 13433 449 8 the the DT 13433 449 9 destructive destructive JJ 13433 449 10 effect effect NN 13433 449 11 upon upon IN 13433 449 12 some some DT 13433 449 13 of of IN 13433 449 14 the the DT 13433 449 15 arguments argument NNS 13433 449 16 of of IN 13433 449 17 _ _ NNP 13433 449 18 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 449 19 Religion Religion NNP 13433 449 20 _ _ NNP 13433 449 21 , , , 13433 449 22 upon upon IN 13433 449 23 which which WDT 13433 449 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 449 25 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 449 26 prematurely prematurely RB 13433 449 27 congratulates congratulate VBZ 13433 449 28 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 449 29 , , , 13433 449 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 449 31 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 449 32 's 's POS 13433 449 33 elaborate elaborate NN 13433 449 34 and and CC 13433 449 35 learned learn VBD 13433 449 36 article article NN 13433 449 37 on on IN 13433 449 38 the the DT 13433 449 39 silence silence NN 13433 449 40 of of IN 13433 449 41 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 449 42 supports support VBZ 13433 449 43 them -PRON- PRP 13433 449 44 in in IN 13433 449 45 the the DT 13433 449 46 most most RBS 13433 449 47 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 449 48 manner manner NN 13433 449 49 . . . 13433 450 1 Before before IN 13433 450 2 proceeding proceed VBG 13433 450 3 to to TO 13433 450 4 speak speak VB 13433 450 5 more more RBR 13433 450 6 directly directly RB 13433 450 7 of of IN 13433 450 8 the the DT 13433 450 9 three three CD 13433 450 10 writers writer NNS 13433 450 11 under under IN 13433 450 12 discussion discussion NN 13433 450 13 , , , 13433 450 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 450 15 may may MD 13433 450 16 be be VB 13433 450 17 well well JJ 13433 450 18 to to TO 13433 450 19 glance glance VB 13433 450 20 a a DT 13433 450 21 little little JJ 13433 450 22 at at IN 13433 450 23 the the DT 13433 450 24 procedure procedure NN 13433 450 25 of of IN 13433 450 26 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 450 27 , , , 13433 450 28 and and CC 13433 450 29 note note VB 13433 450 30 , , , 13433 450 31 for for IN 13433 450 32 those those DT 13433 450 33 who who WP 13433 450 34 care care VBP 13433 450 35 to to TO 13433 450 36 go go VB 13433 450 37 more more RBR 13433 450 38 closely closely RB 13433 450 39 into into IN 13433 450 40 the the DT 13433 450 41 matter matter NN 13433 450 42 , , , 13433 450 43 how how WRB 13433 450 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 450 45 fulfils fulfil VBZ 13433 450 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 450 47 promise promise NN 13433 450 48 to to TO 13433 450 49 record record VB 13433 450 50 what what WP 13433 450 51 the the DT 13433 450 52 Fathers father NNS 13433 450 53 have have VBP 13433 450 54 to to TO 13433 450 55 tell tell VB 13433 450 56 about about IN 13433 450 57 the the DT 13433 450 58 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 450 59 . . . 13433 451 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 451 2 may may MD 13433 451 3 mention mention VB 13433 451 4 , , , 13433 451 5 in in IN 13433 451 6 the the DT 13433 451 7 first first JJ 13433 451 8 place place NN 13433 451 9 , , , 13433 451 10 that that IN 13433 451 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 451 12 states state VBZ 13433 451 13 what what WP 13433 451 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 451 15 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 451 16 knows know VBZ 13433 451 17 of of IN 13433 451 18 the the DT 13433 451 19 composition composition NN 13433 451 20 of of IN 13433 451 21 the the DT 13433 451 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 451 23 and and CC 13433 451 24 other other JJ 13433 451 25 canonical canonical JJ 13433 451 26 works work NNS 13433 451 27 . . . 13433 452 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 452 2 50:1 50:1 CD 13433 452 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 452 4 Upon upon IN 13433 452 5 two two CD 13433 452 6 occasions occasion NNS 13433 452 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 452 8 quotes quote VBZ 13433 452 9 the the DT 13433 452 10 account account NN 13433 452 11 which which WDT 13433 452 12 Clement Clement NNP 13433 452 13 of of IN 13433 452 14 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 452 15 gives give VBZ 13433 452 16 of of IN 13433 452 17 the the DT 13433 452 18 composition composition NN 13433 452 19 of of IN 13433 452 20 Mark Mark NNP 13433 452 21 's 's POS 13433 452 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 452 23 , , , 13433 452 24 and and CC 13433 452 25 also also RB 13433 452 26 cites cite VBZ 13433 452 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 452 28 statements statement NNS 13433 452 29 regarding regard VBG 13433 452 30 the the DT 13433 452 31 other other JJ 13433 452 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 452 33 . . . 13433 453 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 453 2 50:2 50:2 CD 13433 453 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 453 4 In in IN 13433 453 5 like like JJ 13433 453 6 manner manner NN 13433 453 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 453 8 records record VBZ 13433 453 9 the the DT 13433 453 10 information information NN 13433 453 11 , , , 13433 453 12 such such JJ 13433 453 13 as as IN 13433 453 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 453 15 is be VBZ 13433 453 16 , , , 13433 453 17 which which WDT 13433 453 18 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 453 19 has have VBZ 13433 453 20 to to TO 13433 453 21 impart impart VB 13433 453 22 about about IN 13433 453 23 the the DT 13433 453 24 four four CD 13433 453 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 453 26 and and CC 13433 453 27 other other JJ 13433 453 28 works work NNS 13433 453 29 , , , 13433 453 30 [ [ -LRB- 13433 453 31 50:3 50:3 CD 13433 453 32 ] ] -RRB- 13433 453 33 and and CC 13433 453 34 what what WP 13433 453 35 Origen Origen NNP 13433 453 36 has have VBZ 13433 453 37 to to TO 13433 453 38 say say VB 13433 453 39 concerning concern VBG 13433 453 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 453 41 . . . 13433 454 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 454 2 50:4 50:4 CD 13433 454 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 454 4 Interrogating interrogate VBG 13433 454 5 extant extant JJ 13433 454 6 works work NNS 13433 454 7 , , , 13433 454 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 454 9 find find VBP 13433 454 10 in in IN 13433 454 11 fact fact NN 13433 454 12 that that IN 13433 454 13 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 454 14 does do VBZ 13433 454 15 not not RB 13433 454 16 neglect neglect VB 13433 454 17 to to TO 13433 454 18 quote quote VB 13433 454 19 anything anything NN 13433 454 20 useful useful JJ 13433 454 21 or or CC 13433 454 22 interesting interesting JJ 13433 454 23 regarding regard VBG 13433 454 24 these these DT 13433 454 25 books book NNS 13433 454 26 from from IN 13433 454 27 early early JJ 13433 454 28 writers writer NNS 13433 454 29 . . . 13433 455 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 455 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 455 3 says say VBZ 13433 455 4 that that IN 13433 455 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 455 6 " " `` 13433 455 7 restricts restrict VBZ 13433 455 8 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 455 9 to to IN 13433 455 10 the the DT 13433 455 11 narrowest narrow JJS 13433 455 12 limits limit NNS 13433 455 13 which which WDT 13433 455 14 justice justice NN 13433 455 15 to to IN 13433 455 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 455 17 subject subject NN 13433 455 18 will will MD 13433 455 19 allow allow VB 13433 455 20 , , , 13433 455 21 " " '' 13433 455 22 and and CC 13433 455 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 455 24 illustrates illustrate VBZ 13433 455 25 this this DT 13433 455 26 by by IN 13433 455 27 the the DT 13433 455 28 case case NN 13433 455 29 of of IN 13433 455 30 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 455 31 . . . 13433 456 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 456 2 says say VBZ 13433 456 3 : : : 13433 456 4 " " `` 13433 456 5 Though though IN 13433 456 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 456 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 456 8 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 456 9 ) ) -RRB- 13433 456 10 gives give VBZ 13433 456 11 the the DT 13433 456 12 principal principal JJ 13433 456 13 passage passage NN 13433 456 14 in in IN 13433 456 15 this this DT 13433 456 16 author author NN 13433 456 17 relating relate VBG 13433 456 18 to to IN 13433 456 19 the the DT 13433 456 20 Four Four NNP 13433 456 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 456 22 ( ( -LRB- 13433 456 23 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 456 24 , , , 13433 456 25 _ _ NNP 13433 456 26 Adv Adv NNP 13433 456 27 . . . 13433 457 1 Haer Haer NNP 13433 457 2 . . . 13433 457 3 _ _ NNP 13433 457 4 iii iii NNP 13433 457 5 . . . 13433 458 1 1 1 CD 13433 458 2 , , , 13433 458 3 1 1 CD 13433 458 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 458 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 458 6 omits omit VBZ 13433 458 7 to to TO 13433 458 8 mention mention VB 13433 458 9 others other NNS 13433 458 10 which which WDT 13433 458 11 contain contain VBP 13433 458 12 interesting interesting JJ 13433 458 13 statements statement NNS 13433 458 14 directly directly RB 13433 458 15 or or CC 13433 458 16 indirectly indirectly RB 13433 458 17 affecting affect VBG 13433 458 18 the the DT 13433 458 19 question question NN 13433 458 20 , , , 13433 458 21 _ _ NNP 13433 458 22 e.g. e.g. RB 13433 458 23 _ _ NNP 13433 458 24 that that IN 13433 458 25 St. St. NNP 13433 458 26 John John NNP 13433 458 27 wrote write VBD 13433 458 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 458 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 458 30 to to TO 13433 458 31 counteract counteract VB 13433 458 32 the the DT 13433 458 33 errors error NNS 13433 458 34 of of IN 13433 458 35 Cerinthus Cerinthus NNP 13433 458 36 and and CC 13433 458 37 the the DT 13433 458 38 Nicolaitans Nicolaitans NNPS 13433 458 39 ( ( -LRB- 13433 458 40 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 458 41 , , , 13433 458 42 _ _ NNP 13433 458 43 Adv Adv NNP 13433 458 44 . . . 13433 459 1 Haer Haer NNP 13433 459 2 . . . 13433 459 3 _ _ NNP 13433 459 4 iii iii NNP 13433 459 5 . . . 13433 460 1 11 11 CD 13433 460 2 , , , 13433 460 3 1 1 CD 13433 460 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 460 5 . . . 13433 460 6 " " '' 13433 461 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 461 2 51:1 51:1 CD 13433 461 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 461 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 461 5 must must MD 13433 461 6 explain explain VB 13433 461 7 , , , 13433 461 8 however however RB 13433 461 9 , , , 13433 461 10 that that IN 13433 461 11 the the DT 13433 461 12 " " `` 13433 461 13 interesting interesting JJ 13433 461 14 statement statement NN 13433 461 15 " " '' 13433 461 16 omitted omit VBN 13433 461 17 , , , 13433 461 18 which which WDT 13433 461 19 is be VBZ 13433 461 20 not not RB 13433 461 21 in in IN 13433 461 22 the the DT 13433 461 23 context context NN 13433 461 24 of of IN 13433 461 25 the the DT 13433 461 26 part part NN 13433 461 27 quoted quote VBN 13433 461 28 , , , 13433 461 29 is be VBZ 13433 461 30 not not RB 13433 461 31 advanced advance VBN 13433 461 32 as as IN 13433 461 33 information information NN 13433 461 34 derived derive VBN 13433 461 35 from from IN 13433 461 36 any any DT 13433 461 37 authority authority NN 13433 461 38 , , , 13433 461 39 but but CC 13433 461 40 only only RB 13433 461 41 in in IN 13433 461 42 the the DT 13433 461 43 course course NN 13433 461 44 of of IN 13433 461 45 argument argument NN 13433 461 46 , , , 13433 461 47 and and CC 13433 461 48 there there EX 13433 461 49 is be VBZ 13433 461 50 nothing nothing NN 13433 461 51 to to TO 13433 461 52 distinguish distinguish VB 13433 461 53 it -PRON- PRP 13433 461 54 from from IN 13433 461 55 mere mere JJ 13433 461 56 personal personal JJ 13433 461 57 opinion opinion NN 13433 461 58 , , , 13433 461 59 so so IN 13433 461 60 that that IN 13433 461 61 on on IN 13433 461 62 this this DT 13433 461 63 ground ground NN 13433 461 64 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 461 65 may may MD 13433 461 66 well well RB 13433 461 67 have have VB 13433 461 68 passed pass VBN 13433 461 69 it -PRON- PRP 13433 461 70 over over RP 13433 461 71 . . . 13433 462 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 462 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 462 3 further further RB 13433 462 4 says say VBZ 13433 462 5 : : : 13433 462 6 " " `` 13433 462 7 Thus thus RB 13433 462 8 too too RB 13433 462 9 when when WRB 13433 462 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 462 11 quotes quote VBZ 13433 462 12 a a DT 13433 462 13 few few JJ 13433 462 14 lines line NNS 13433 462 15 alluding allude VBG 13433 462 16 to to IN 13433 462 17 the the DT 13433 462 18 unanimous unanimous JJ 13433 462 19 tradition tradition NN 13433 462 20 of of IN 13433 462 21 the the DT 13433 462 22 Asiatic asiatic JJ 13433 462 23 Elders Elders NNPS 13433 462 24 who who WP 13433 462 25 were be VBD 13433 462 26 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 462 27 with with IN 13433 462 28 St. St. NNP 13433 462 29 John John NNP 13433 462 30 , , , 13433 462 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 462 32 51:2 51:2 CD 13433 462 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 462 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 462 35 omits omit VBZ 13433 462 36 the the DT 13433 462 37 context context NN 13433 462 38 , , , 13433 462 39 from from IN 13433 462 40 which which WDT 13433 462 41 we -PRON- PRP 13433 462 42 find find VBP 13433 462 43 that that IN 13433 462 44 this this DT 13433 462 45 tradition tradition NN 13433 462 46 had have VBD 13433 462 47 an an DT 13433 462 48 important important JJ 13433 462 49 bearing bearing NN 13433 462 50 on on IN 13433 462 51 the the DT 13433 462 52 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 462 53 of of IN 13433 462 54 the the DT 13433 462 55 fourth fourth JJ 13433 462 56 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 462 57 , , , 13433 462 58 for for IN 13433 462 59 it -PRON- PRP 13433 462 60 declared declare VBD 13433 462 61 that that IN 13433 462 62 Christ Christ NNP 13433 462 63 's 's POS 13433 462 64 ministry ministry NN 13433 462 65 extended extend VBD 13433 462 66 much much RB 13433 462 67 beyond beyond IN 13433 462 68 a a DT 13433 462 69 single single JJ 13433 462 70 year year NN 13433 462 71 , , , 13433 462 72 thus thus RB 13433 462 73 confirming confirm VBG 13433 462 74 the the DT 13433 462 75 obvious obvious JJ 13433 462 76 chronology chronology NN 13433 462 77 of of IN 13433 462 78 the the DT 13433 462 79 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 462 80 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 462 81 against against IN 13433 462 82 the the DT 13433 462 83 apparent apparent JJ 13433 462 84 chronology chronology NN 13433 462 85 of of IN 13433 462 86 the the DT 13433 462 87 Synoptists Synoptists NNPS 13433 462 88 . . . 13433 462 89 " " '' 13433 463 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 463 2 51:3 51:3 CD 13433 463 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 463 4 Nothing nothing NN 13433 463 5 , , , 13433 463 6 however however RB 13433 463 7 , , , 13433 463 8 could could MD 13433 463 9 be be VB 13433 463 10 further further JJ 13433 463 11 from from IN 13433 463 12 the the DT 13433 463 13 desire desire NN 13433 463 14 or or CC 13433 463 15 intention intention NN 13433 463 16 of of IN 13433 463 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 463 18 than than IN 13433 463 19 to to TO 13433 463 20 represent represent VB 13433 463 21 any any DT 13433 463 22 discordance discordance NN 13433 463 23 between between IN 13433 463 24 the the DT 13433 463 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 463 26 , , , 13433 463 27 or or CC 13433 463 28 to to TO 13433 463 29 support support VB 13433 463 30 the the DT 13433 463 31 one one NN 13433 463 32 at at IN 13433 463 33 the the DT 13433 463 34 expense expense NN 13433 463 35 of of IN 13433 463 36 the the DT 13433 463 37 others other NNS 13433 463 38 . . . 13433 464 1 On on IN 13433 464 2 the the DT 13433 464 3 contrary contrary NN 13433 464 4 , , , 13433 464 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 464 6 enters enter VBZ 13433 464 7 into into IN 13433 464 8 an an DT 13433 464 9 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 464 10 explanation explanation NN 13433 464 11 in in IN 13433 464 12 order order NN 13433 464 13 to to TO 13433 464 14 show show VB 13433 464 15 that that IN 13433 464 16 there there EX 13433 464 17 is be VBZ 13433 464 18 no no DT 13433 464 19 discrepancy discrepancy NN 13433 464 20 between between IN 13433 464 21 them -PRON- PRP 13433 464 22 , , , 13433 464 23 affirming affirm VBG 13433 464 24 , , , 13433 464 25 and and CC 13433 464 26 supporting support VBG 13433 464 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 464 28 view view NN 13433 464 29 by by IN 13433 464 30 singular singular JJ 13433 464 31 quotations quotation NNS 13433 464 32 , , , 13433 464 33 that that IN 13433 464 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 464 35 was be VBD 13433 464 36 evidently evidently RB 13433 464 37 the the DT 13433 464 38 intention intention NN 13433 464 39 of of IN 13433 464 40 the the DT 13433 464 41 three three CD 13433 464 42 Synoptists Synoptists NNPS 13433 464 43 only only RB 13433 464 44 to to TO 13433 464 45 write write VB 13433 464 46 the the DT 13433 464 47 doings doing NNS 13433 464 48 of of IN 13433 464 49 the the DT 13433 464 50 Lord Lord NNP 13433 464 51 for for IN 13433 464 52 one one CD 13433 464 53 year year NN 13433 464 54 after after IN 13433 464 55 the the DT 13433 464 56 imprisonment imprisonment NN 13433 464 57 of of IN 13433 464 58 John John NNP 13433 464 59 the the DT 13433 464 60 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 464 61 , , , 13433 464 62 and and CC 13433 464 63 that that IN 13433 464 64 John John NNP 13433 464 65 , , , 13433 464 66 having have VBG 13433 464 67 the the DT 13433 464 68 other other JJ 13433 464 69 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 464 70 before before IN 13433 464 71 him -PRON- PRP 13433 464 72 , , , 13433 464 73 wrote write VBD 13433 464 74 an an DT 13433 464 75 account account NN 13433 464 76 of of IN 13433 464 77 the the DT 13433 464 78 period period NN 13433 464 79 not not RB 13433 464 80 embraced embrace VBN 13433 464 81 by by IN 13433 464 82 the the DT 13433 464 83 other other JJ 13433 464 84 evangelists evangelist NNS 13433 464 85 . . . 13433 465 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 465 2 51:4 51:4 CD 13433 465 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 465 4 Moreover moreover RB 13433 465 5 , , , 13433 465 6 the the DT 13433 465 7 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 465 8 assertions assertion NNS 13433 465 9 of of IN 13433 465 10 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 465 11 not not RB 13433 465 12 only only RB 13433 465 13 contradict contradict VBP 13433 465 14 the the DT 13433 465 15 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 465 16 , , , 13433 465 17 but but CC 13433 465 18 also also RB 13433 465 19 the the DT 13433 465 20 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 465 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 465 22 , , , 13433 465 23 and and CC 13433 465 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 465 25 certainly certainly RB 13433 465 26 could could MD 13433 465 27 not not RB 13433 465 28 have have VB 13433 465 29 felt feel VBN 13433 465 30 much much JJ 13433 465 31 inclination inclination NN 13433 465 32 to to TO 13433 465 33 quote quote VB 13433 465 34 such such JJ 13433 465 35 opinions opinion NNS 13433 465 36 , , , 13433 465 37 even even RB 13433 465 38 although although IN 13433 465 39 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 465 40 seemed seem VBD 13433 465 41 to to TO 13433 465 42 base base VB 13433 465 43 them -PRON- PRP 13433 465 44 upon upon IN 13433 465 45 traditions tradition NNS 13433 465 46 handed hand VBN 13433 465 47 down down RP 13433 465 48 by by IN 13433 465 49 the the DT 13433 465 50 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 465 51 who who WP 13433 465 52 were be VBD 13433 465 53 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 465 54 with with IN 13433 465 55 John John NNP 13433 465 56 . . . 13433 466 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 466 2 being be VBG 13433 466 3 , , , 13433 466 4 then then RB 13433 466 5 , , , 13433 466 6 admitted admit VBD 13433 466 7 that that IN 13433 466 8 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 466 9 not not RB 13433 466 10 only only RB 13433 466 11 pledges pledge VBZ 13433 466 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 466 13 to to TO 13433 466 14 record record VB 13433 466 15 when when WRB 13433 466 16 any any DT 13433 466 17 ancient ancient JJ 13433 466 18 writer writer NN 13433 466 19 has have VBZ 13433 466 20 something something NN 13433 466 21 to to TO 13433 466 22 " " `` 13433 466 23 tell tell VB 13433 466 24 about about IN 13433 466 25 " " `` 13433 466 26 the the DT 13433 466 27 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 466 28 canonical canonical JJ 13433 466 29 books book NNS 13433 466 30 , , , 13433 466 31 but but CC 13433 466 32 that that IN 13433 466 33 , , , 13433 466 34 judged judge VBN 13433 466 35 by by IN 13433 466 36 the the DT 13433 466 37 test test NN 13433 466 38 of of IN 13433 466 39 extant extant JJ 13433 466 40 writings writing NNS 13433 466 41 which which WDT 13433 466 42 we -PRON- PRP 13433 466 43 can can MD 13433 466 44 examine examine VB 13433 466 45 , , , 13433 466 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 466 47 actually actually RB 13433 466 48 does do VBZ 13433 466 49 so so RB 13433 466 50 , , , 13433 466 51 let let VB 13433 466 52 us -PRON- PRP 13433 466 53 see see VB 13433 466 54 the the DT 13433 466 55 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 466 56 which which WDT 13433 466 57 we -PRON- PRP 13433 466 58 are be VBP 13433 466 59 entitled entitle VBN 13433 466 60 to to TO 13433 466 61 draw draw VB 13433 466 62 in in IN 13433 466 63 the the DT 13433 466 64 case case NN 13433 466 65 of of IN 13433 466 66 the the DT 13433 466 67 only only JJ 13433 466 68 three three CD 13433 466 69 writers writer NNS 13433 466 70 with with IN 13433 466 71 regard regard NN 13433 466 72 to to IN 13433 466 73 whom whom WP 13433 466 74 I -PRON- PRP 13433 466 75 have have VBP 13433 466 76 inferred infer VBN 13433 466 77 anything anything NN 13433 466 78 from from IN 13433 466 79 the the DT 13433 466 80 " " `` 13433 466 81 silence silence NN 13433 466 82 of of IN 13433 466 83 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 466 84 . . . 13433 466 85 " " '' 13433 467 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 467 2 need need VBP 13433 467 3 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 467 4 repeat repeat VB 13433 467 5 that that IN 13433 467 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 467 7 held hold VBD 13433 467 8 HEGESIPPUS HEGESIPPUS NNP 13433 467 9 in in IN 13433 467 10 very very RB 13433 467 11 high high JJ 13433 467 12 estimation estimation NN 13433 467 13 . . . 13433 468 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 468 2 refers refer VBZ 13433 468 3 to to IN 13433 468 4 him -PRON- PRP 13433 468 5 very very RB 13433 468 6 frequently frequently RB 13433 468 7 , , , 13433 468 8 and and CC 13433 468 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 468 10 clearly clearly RB 13433 468 11 shows show VBZ 13433 468 12 that that IN 13433 468 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 468 14 not not RB 13433 468 15 only only RB 13433 468 16 valued value VBN 13433 468 17 , , , 13433 468 18 but but CC 13433 468 19 was be VBD 13433 468 20 intimately intimately RB 13433 468 21 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 468 22 with with IN 13433 468 23 , , , 13433 468 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 468 25 writings writing NNS 13433 468 26 . . . 13433 469 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 469 2 quotes quote VBZ 13433 469 3 from from IN 13433 469 4 the the DT 13433 469 5 work work NN 13433 469 6 of of IN 13433 469 7 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 8 a a DT 13433 469 9 very very RB 13433 469 10 long long JJ 13433 469 11 account account NN 13433 469 12 of of IN 13433 469 13 the the DT 13433 469 14 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 469 15 of of IN 13433 469 16 James James NNP 13433 469 17 ; ; : 13433 469 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 19 52:1 52:1 CD 13433 469 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 22 refers refer VBZ 13433 469 23 to to IN 13433 469 24 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 25 as as IN 13433 469 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 27 authority authority NN 13433 469 28 for for IN 13433 469 29 the the DT 13433 469 30 statement statement NN 13433 469 31 that that IN 13433 469 32 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 469 33 was be VBD 13433 469 34 a a DT 13433 469 35 cousin cousin NN 13433 469 36 ( ( -LRB- 13433 469 37 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 38 Greek Greek NNP 13433 469 39 : : : 13433 469 40 anepsios anepsio NNS 13433 469 41 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 42 ) ) -RRB- 13433 469 43 of of IN 13433 469 44 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 469 45 , , , 13433 469 46 Cleophas Cleophas NNP 13433 469 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 48 father father NN 13433 469 49 being be VBG 13433 469 50 , , , 13433 469 51 according accord VBG 13433 469 52 to to IN 13433 469 53 that that DT 13433 469 54 author author NN 13433 469 55 , , , 13433 469 56 the the DT 13433 469 57 brother brother NN 13433 469 58 of of IN 13433 469 59 Joseph Joseph NNP 13433 469 60 ; ; : 13433 469 61 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 62 52:2 52:2 CD 13433 469 63 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 64 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 65 confirms confirm VBZ 13433 469 66 a a DT 13433 469 67 passage passage NN 13433 469 68 in in IN 13433 469 69 the the DT 13433 469 70 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 469 71 of of IN 13433 469 72 Clement Clement NNP 13433 469 73 by by IN 13433 469 74 reference reference NN 13433 469 75 to to IN 13433 469 76 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 77 ; ; : 13433 469 78 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 79 52:3 52:3 CD 13433 469 80 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 81 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 82 quotes quote VBZ 13433 469 83 from from IN 13433 469 84 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 85 a a DT 13433 469 86 story story NN 13433 469 87 regarding regard VBG 13433 469 88 some some DT 13433 469 89 members member NNS 13433 469 90 of of IN 13433 469 91 the the DT 13433 469 92 family family NN 13433 469 93 of of IN 13433 469 94 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 469 95 , , , 13433 469 96 of of IN 13433 469 97 the the DT 13433 469 98 race race NN 13433 469 99 of of IN 13433 469 100 David David NNP 13433 469 101 , , , 13433 469 102 who who WP 13433 469 103 were be VBD 13433 469 104 brought bring VBN 13433 469 105 before before RB 13433 469 106 Domitian Domitian NNP 13433 469 107 ; ; : 13433 469 108 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 109 52:4 52:4 CD 13433 469 110 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 111 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 112 cites cite VBZ 13433 469 113 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 114 narrative narrative NN 13433 469 115 of of IN 13433 469 116 the the DT 13433 469 117 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 469 118 of of IN 13433 469 119 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 469 120 , , , 13433 469 121 together together RB 13433 469 122 with with IN 13433 469 123 other other JJ 13433 469 124 matters matter NNS 13433 469 125 concerning concern VBG 13433 469 126 the the DT 13433 469 127 early early JJ 13433 469 128 Church church NN 13433 469 129 ; ; : 13433 469 130 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 131 52:5 52:5 CD 13433 469 132 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 133 in in IN 13433 469 134 another another DT 13433 469 135 place place NN 13433 469 136 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 137 gives give VBZ 13433 469 138 a a DT 13433 469 139 laudatory laudatory JJ 13433 469 140 account account NN 13433 469 141 of of IN 13433 469 142 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 143 and and CC 13433 469 144 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 145 writings writing NNS 13433 469 146 ; ; , 13433 469 147 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 148 52:6 52:6 CD 13433 469 149 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 150 shortly shortly RB 13433 469 151 after after IN 13433 469 152 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 153 refers refer VBZ 13433 469 154 to to IN 13433 469 155 the the DT 13433 469 156 statement statement NN 13433 469 157 of of IN 13433 469 158 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 469 159 that that IN 13433 469 160 he -PRON- PRP 13433 469 161 was be VBD 13433 469 162 in in IN 13433 469 163 Rome Rome NNP 13433 469 164 until until IN 13433 469 165 the the DT 13433 469 166 episcopate episcopate NN 13433 469 167 of of IN 13433 469 168 Eleutherus Eleutherus NNP 13433 469 169 , , , 13433 469 170 [ [ -LRB- 13433 469 171 52:7 52:7 CD 13433 469 172 ] ] -RRB- 13433 469 173 and and CC 13433 469 174 further further JJ 13433 469 175 speaks speak VBZ 13433 469 176 in in IN 13433 469 177 praise praise NN 13433 469 178 of of IN 13433 469 179 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 180 work work NN 13433 469 181 , , , 13433 469 182 mentions mention VBZ 13433 469 183 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 184 observation observation NN 13433 469 185 on on IN 13433 469 186 the the DT 13433 469 187 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 469 188 of of IN 13433 469 189 Clement Clement NNP 13433 469 190 , , , 13433 469 191 and and CC 13433 469 192 quotes quote VBZ 13433 469 193 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 469 194 remarks remark NNS 13433 469 195 about about IN 13433 469 196 the the DT 13433 469 197 Church Church NNP 13433 469 198 in in IN 13433 469 199 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 469 200 , , , 13433 469 201 the the DT 13433 469 202 succession succession NN 13433 469 203 of of IN 13433 469 204 Roman roman JJ 13433 469 205 bishops bishop NNS 13433 469 206 , , , 13433 469 207 the the DT 13433 469 208 general general JJ 13433 469 209 state state NN 13433 469 210 of of IN 13433 469 211 the the DT 13433 469 212 Church Church NNP 13433 469 213 , , , 13433 469 214 the the DT 13433 469 215 rise rise NN 13433 469 216 of of IN 13433 469 217 heresies heresy NNS 13433 469 218 , , , 13433 469 219 and and CC 13433 469 220 other other JJ 13433 469 221 matters matter NNS 13433 469 222 . . . 13433 470 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 470 2 52:8 52:8 CD 13433 470 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 470 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 470 5 mention mention VBP 13433 470 6 these these DT 13433 470 7 numerous numerous JJ 13433 470 8 references reference NNS 13433 470 9 to to IN 13433 470 10 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 470 11 as as IN 13433 470 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 470 13 have have VBP 13433 470 14 noticed notice VBN 13433 470 15 them -PRON- PRP 13433 470 16 in in IN 13433 470 17 turning turn VBG 13433 470 18 over over RP 13433 470 19 the the DT 13433 470 20 pages page NNS 13433 470 21 of of IN 13433 470 22 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 470 23 , , , 13433 470 24 but but CC 13433 470 25 others other NNS 13433 470 26 may may MD 13433 470 27 very very RB 13433 470 28 probably probably RB 13433 470 29 have have VB 13433 470 30 escaped escape VBN 13433 470 31 me -PRON- PRP 13433 470 32 . . . 13433 471 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 471 2 fulfils fulfil VBZ 13433 471 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 471 4 pledge pledge NN 13433 471 5 , , , 13433 471 6 and and CC 13433 471 7 states state NNS 13433 471 8 what what WP 13433 471 9 disputed dispute VBD 13433 471 10 works work NNS 13433 471 11 were be VBD 13433 471 12 used use VBN 13433 471 13 by by IN 13433 471 14 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 471 15 and and CC 13433 471 16 what what WP 13433 471 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 471 18 said say VBD 13433 471 19 about about IN 13433 471 20 them -PRON- PRP 13433 471 21 , , , 13433 471 22 and and CC 13433 471 23 one one CD 13433 471 24 of of IN 13433 471 25 these these DT 13433 471 26 was be VBD 13433 471 27 the the DT 13433 471 28 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 471 29 according accord VBG 13433 471 30 to to IN 13433 471 31 the the DT 13433 471 32 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 471 33 . . . 13433 472 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 472 2 does do VBZ 13433 472 3 not not RB 13433 472 4 , , , 13433 472 5 however however RB 13433 472 6 , , , 13433 472 7 record record VB 13433 472 8 a a DT 13433 472 9 single single JJ 13433 472 10 remark remark NN 13433 472 11 of of IN 13433 472 12 any any DT 13433 472 13 kind kind NN 13433 472 14 regarding regard VBG 13433 472 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 472 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 472 17 , , , 13433 472 18 and and CC 13433 472 19 the the DT 13433 472 20 legitimate legitimate JJ 13433 472 21 inference inference NN 13433 472 22 , , , 13433 472 23 and and CC 13433 472 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 472 25 is be VBZ 13433 472 26 the the DT 13433 472 27 only only JJ 13433 472 28 one one CD 13433 472 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 472 30 care care VBP 13433 472 31 to to TO 13433 472 32 draw draw VB 13433 472 33 , , , 13433 472 34 is be VBZ 13433 472 35 , , , 13433 472 36 that that IN 13433 472 37 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 472 38 did do VBD 13433 472 39 not not RB 13433 472 40 say say VB 13433 472 41 anything anything NN 13433 472 42 about about IN 13433 472 43 them -PRON- PRP 13433 472 44 . . . 13433 473 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 473 2 may may MD 13433 473 3 simply simply RB 13433 473 4 add add VB 13433 473 5 that that DT 13433 473 6 , , , 13433 473 7 as as IN 13433 473 8 that that DT 13433 473 9 , , , 13433 473 10 as as IN 13433 473 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 473 12 quotes quote VBZ 13433 473 13 the the DT 13433 473 14 account account NN 13433 473 15 of of IN 13433 473 16 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 473 17 and and CC 13433 473 18 Mark Mark NNP 13433 473 19 from from IN 13433 473 20 Papias Papias NNP 13433 473 21 , , , 13433 473 22 a a DT 13433 473 23 man man NN 13433 473 24 of of IN 13433 473 25 whom whom WP 13433 473 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 473 27 expresses express VBZ 13433 473 28 something something NN 13433 473 29 like like IN 13433 473 30 contempt contempt NN 13433 473 31 , , , 13433 473 32 and and CC 13433 473 33 again again RB 13433 473 34 refers refer VBZ 13433 473 35 to to IN 13433 473 36 him -PRON- PRP 13433 473 37 in in IN 13433 473 38 confirmation confirmation NN 13433 473 39 of of IN 13433 473 40 the the DT 13433 473 41 statement statement NN 13433 473 42 of of IN 13433 473 43 the the DT 13433 473 44 Alexandrian Alexandrian NNP 13433 473 45 Clement Clement NNP 13433 473 46 regarding regard VBG 13433 473 47 the the DT 13433 473 48 composition composition NN 13433 473 49 of of IN 13433 473 50 Mark Mark NNP 13433 473 51 's 's POS 13433 473 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 473 53 , , , 13433 473 54 [ [ -LRB- 13433 473 55 53:1 53:1 CD 13433 473 56 ] ] -RRB- 13433 473 57 it -PRON- PRP 13433 473 58 would would MD 13433 473 59 be be VB 13433 473 60 against against IN 13433 473 61 all all DT 13433 473 62 reason reason NN 13433 473 63 , , , 13433 473 64 as as RB 13433 473 65 well well RB 13433 473 66 as as IN 13433 473 67 opposed oppose VBN 13433 473 68 to to IN 13433 473 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 473 70 pledge pledge NN 13433 473 71 and and CC 13433 473 72 general general JJ 13433 473 73 practice practice NN 13433 473 74 , , , 13433 473 75 to to TO 13433 473 76 suppose suppose VB 13433 473 77 that that IN 13433 473 78 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 473 79 would would MD 13433 473 80 have have VB 13433 473 81 omitted omit VBN 13433 473 82 to to TO 13433 473 83 record record VB 13433 473 84 any any DT 13433 473 85 information information NN 13433 473 86 given give VBN 13433 473 87 by by IN 13433 473 88 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 473 89 , , , 13433 473 90 a a DT 13433 473 91 writer writer NN 13433 473 92 with with IN 13433 473 93 whom whom WP 13433 473 94 he -PRON- PRP 13433 473 95 was be VBD 13433 473 96 so so RB 13433 473 97 well well RB 13433 473 98 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 473 99 and and CC 13433 473 100 of of IN 13433 473 101 whom whom WP 13433 473 102 he -PRON- PRP 13433 473 103 speaks speak VBZ 13433 473 104 with with IN 13433 473 105 so so RB 13433 473 106 much much JJ 13433 473 107 respect respect NN 13433 473 108 . . . 13433 474 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 474 2 have have VBP 13433 474 3 said say VBN 13433 474 4 that that IN 13433 474 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 474 6 would would MD 13433 474 7 more more RBR 13433 474 8 particularly particularly RB 13433 474 9 have have VBP 13433 474 10 quoted quote VBN 13433 474 11 anything anything NN 13433 474 12 with with IN 13433 474 13 regard regard NN 13433 474 14 to to IN 13433 474 15 the the DT 13433 474 16 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 474 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 474 18 , , , 13433 474 19 and and CC 13433 474 20 for for IN 13433 474 21 those those DT 13433 474 22 who who WP 13433 474 23 care care VBP 13433 474 24 to to TO 13433 474 25 go go VB 13433 474 26 more more RBR 13433 474 27 closely closely RB 13433 474 28 into into IN 13433 474 29 the the DT 13433 474 30 point point NN 13433 474 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 474 32 reasons reason NNS 13433 474 33 may may MD 13433 474 34 be be VB 13433 474 35 briefly briefly RB 13433 474 36 given give VBN 13433 474 37 . . . 13433 475 1 No no DT 13433 475 2 one one NN 13433 475 3 can can MD 13433 475 4 read read VB 13433 475 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 475 6 attentively attentively RB 13433 475 7 without without IN 13433 475 8 noting note VBG 13433 475 9 the the DT 13433 475 10 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 475 11 care care NN 13433 475 12 with with IN 13433 475 13 which which WDT 13433 475 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 475 15 speaks speak VBZ 13433 475 16 of of IN 13433 475 17 John John NNP 13433 475 18 and and CC 13433 475 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 475 20 writings writing NNS 13433 475 21 , , , 13433 475 22 and and CC 13433 475 23 the the DT 13433 475 24 substantially substantially RB 13433 475 25 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 475 26 tone tone NN 13433 475 27 which which WDT 13433 475 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 475 29 adopts adopt VBZ 13433 475 30 in in IN 13433 475 31 regard regard NN 13433 475 32 to to IN 13433 475 33 them -PRON- PRP 13433 475 34 . . . 13433 476 1 Apart apart RB 13433 476 2 from from IN 13433 476 3 any any DT 13433 476 4 doubts doubt NNS 13433 476 5 expressed express VBN 13433 476 6 regarding regard VBG 13433 476 7 the the DT 13433 476 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 476 9 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 476 10 , , , 13433 476 11 the the DT 13433 476 12 controversy controversy NN 13433 476 13 as as IN 13433 476 14 to to IN 13433 476 15 the the DT 13433 476 16 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 476 17 of of IN 13433 476 18 the the DT 13433 476 19 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 476 20 and and CC 13433 476 21 second second JJ 13433 476 22 and and CC 13433 476 23 third third JJ 13433 476 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 476 25 called call VBN 13433 476 26 by by IN 13433 476 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 476 28 name name NN 13433 476 29 , , , 13433 476 30 with with IN 13433 476 31 which which WDT 13433 476 32 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 476 33 was be VBD 13433 476 34 so so RB 13433 476 35 well well RB 13433 476 36 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 476 37 , , , 13433 476 38 and and CC 13433 476 39 the the DT 13433 476 40 critical critical JJ 13433 476 41 dilemma dilemma NN 13433 476 42 as as IN 13433 476 43 to to IN 13433 476 44 the the DT 13433 476 45 impossibility impossibility NN 13433 476 46 of of IN 13433 476 47 the the DT 13433 476 48 same same JJ 13433 476 49 John John NNP 13433 476 50 having have VBG 13433 476 51 written write VBN 13433 476 52 both both DT 13433 476 53 the the DT 13433 476 54 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 476 55 and and CC 13433 476 56 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 476 57 , , , 13433 476 58 regarding regard VBG 13433 476 59 which which WDT 13433 476 60 he -PRON- PRP 13433 476 61 so so RB 13433 476 62 fully fully RB 13433 476 63 quotes quote VBZ 13433 476 64 the the DT 13433 476 65 argument argument NN 13433 476 66 of of IN 13433 476 67 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 476 68 of of IN 13433 476 69 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 476 70 , , , 13433 476 71 [ [ -LRB- 13433 476 72 53:2 53:2 CD 13433 476 73 ] ] -RRB- 13433 476 74 evidently evidently RB 13433 476 75 made make VBD 13433 476 76 him -PRON- PRP 13433 476 77 peculiarly peculiarly RB 13433 476 78 interested interested JJ 13433 476 79 in in IN 13433 476 80 the the DT 13433 476 81 subject subject NN 13433 476 82 , , , 13433 476 83 and and CC 13433 476 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 476 85 attention attention NN 13433 476 86 to to IN 13433 476 87 the the DT 13433 476 88 fourth fourth JJ 13433 476 89 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 476 90 was be VBD 13433 476 91 certainly certainly RB 13433 476 92 not not RB 13433 476 93 diminished diminish VBN 13433 476 94 by by IN 13433 476 95 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 476 96 recognition recognition NN 13433 476 97 of of IN 13433 476 98 the the DT 13433 476 99 essential essential JJ 13433 476 100 difference difference NN 13433 476 101 between between IN 13433 476 102 that that DT 13433 476 103 work work NN 13433 476 104 and and CC 13433 476 105 the the DT 13433 476 106 three three CD 13433 476 107 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 476 108 . . . 13433 477 1 The the DT 13433 477 2 first first JJ 13433 477 3 occasion occasion NN 13433 477 4 on on IN 13433 477 5 which which WDT 13433 477 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 477 7 speaks speak VBZ 13433 477 8 of of IN 13433 477 9 John John NNP 13433 477 10 , , , 13433 477 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 477 12 records record VBZ 13433 477 13 the the DT 13433 477 14 tradition tradition NN 13433 477 15 that that WDT 13433 477 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 477 17 was be VBD 13433 477 18 banished banish VBN 13433 477 19 to to IN 13433 477 20 Patmos Patmos NNP 13433 477 21 during during IN 13433 477 22 the the DT 13433 477 23 persecution persecution NN 13433 477 24 under under IN 13433 477 25 Domitian domitian JJ 13433 477 26 , , , 13433 477 27 and and CC 13433 477 28 refers refer VBZ 13433 477 29 to to IN 13433 477 30 the the DT 13433 477 31 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 477 32 . . . 13433 478 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 478 2 quotes quote VBZ 13433 478 3 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 478 4 in in IN 13433 478 5 support support NN 13433 478 6 of of IN 13433 478 7 this this DT 13433 478 8 tradition tradition NN 13433 478 9 , , , 13433 478 10 and and CC 13433 478 11 the the DT 13433 478 12 composition composition NN 13433 478 13 of of IN 13433 478 14 the the DT 13433 478 15 work work NN 13433 478 16 at at IN 13433 478 17 the the DT 13433 478 18 close close NN 13433 478 19 of of IN 13433 478 20 Domitian Domitian NNP 13433 478 21 's 's POS 13433 478 22 reign reign NN 13433 478 23 . . . 13433 479 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 479 2 54:1 54:1 CD 13433 479 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 479 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 479 5 goes go VBZ 13433 479 6 on on RP 13433 479 7 to to TO 13433 479 8 speak speak VB 13433 479 9 of of IN 13433 479 10 the the DT 13433 479 11 persecution persecution NN 13433 479 12 under under IN 13433 479 13 Domitian domitian JJ 13433 479 14 , , , 13433 479 15 and and CC 13433 479 16 quotes quote VBZ 13433 479 17 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 479 18 as as IN 13433 479 19 to to IN 13433 479 20 a a DT 13433 479 21 command command NN 13433 479 22 given give VBN 13433 479 23 by by IN 13433 479 24 that that DT 13433 479 25 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 479 26 to to TO 13433 479 27 slay slay VB 13433 479 28 all all PDT 13433 479 29 the the DT 13433 479 30 posterity posterity NN 13433 479 31 of of IN 13433 479 32 David David NNP 13433 479 33 , , , 13433 479 34 [ [ -LRB- 13433 479 35 54:2 54:2 CD 13433 479 36 ] ] -RRB- 13433 479 37 as as IN 13433 479 38 also also RB 13433 479 39 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 13433 479 40 's 's POS 13433 479 41 account account NN 13433 479 42 , , , 13433 479 43 [ [ -LRB- 13433 479 44 54:3 54:3 CD 13433 479 45 ] ] -RRB- 13433 479 46 winding wind VBG 13433 479 47 up up RP 13433 479 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 479 49 extracts extract NNS 13433 479 50 from from IN 13433 479 51 the the DT 13433 479 52 historians historian NNS 13433 479 53 of of IN 13433 479 54 the the DT 13433 479 55 time time NN 13433 479 56 by by IN 13433 479 57 the the DT 13433 479 58 statement statement NN 13433 479 59 that that IN 13433 479 60 , , , 13433 479 61 after after IN 13433 479 62 Nerva Nerva NNP 13433 479 63 succeeded succeed VBD 13433 479 64 Domitian Domitian NNP 13433 479 65 , , , 13433 479 66 and and CC 13433 479 67 the the DT 13433 479 68 Senate Senate NNP 13433 479 69 had have VBD 13433 479 70 revoked revoke VBN 13433 479 71 the the DT 13433 479 72 cruel cruel JJ 13433 479 73 decrees decree NNS 13433 479 74 of of IN 13433 479 75 the the DT 13433 479 76 latter latter JJ 13433 479 77 , , , 13433 479 78 the the DT 13433 479 79 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 479 80 John John NNP 13433 479 81 returned return VBD 13433 479 82 from from IN 13433 479 83 exile exile NN 13433 479 84 in in IN 13433 479 85 Patmos Patmos NNP 13433 479 86 and and CC 13433 479 87 , , , 13433 479 88 according accord VBG 13433 479 89 to to IN 13433 479 90 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 479 91 tradition tradition NN 13433 479 92 , , , 13433 479 93 settled settle VBN 13433 479 94 at at IN 13433 479 95 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 479 96 . . . 13433 480 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 480 2 54:4 54:4 CD 13433 480 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 480 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 480 5 states state VBZ 13433 480 6 that that IN 13433 480 7 John John NNP 13433 480 8 , , , 13433 480 9 the the DT 13433 480 10 beloved beloved JJ 13433 480 11 disciple disciple NN 13433 480 12 , , , 13433 480 13 apostle apostle NN 13433 480 14 and and CC 13433 480 15 evangelist evangelist NN 13433 480 16 , , , 13433 480 17 governed govern VBD 13433 480 18 the the DT 13433 480 19 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 480 20 of of IN 13433 480 21 Asia Asia NNP 13433 480 22 after after IN 13433 480 23 the the DT 13433 480 24 death death NN 13433 480 25 of of IN 13433 480 26 Domitian Domitian NNP 13433 480 27 and and CC 13433 480 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 480 29 return return NN 13433 480 30 from from IN 13433 480 31 Patmos Patmos NNP 13433 480 32 , , , 13433 480 33 and and CC 13433 480 34 that that IN 13433 480 35 he -PRON- PRP 13433 480 36 was be VBD 13433 480 37 still still RB 13433 480 38 living live VBG 13433 480 39 when when WRB 13433 480 40 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 480 41 succeeded succeed VBD 13433 480 42 Nerva Nerva NNP 13433 480 43 , , , 13433 480 44 and and CC 13433 480 45 for for IN 13433 480 46 the the DT 13433 480 47 truth truth NN 13433 480 48 of of IN 13433 480 49 this this DT 13433 480 50 he -PRON- PRP 13433 480 51 quotes quote VBZ 13433 480 52 passages passage NNS 13433 480 53 from from IN 13433 480 54 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 480 55 and and CC 13433 480 56 Clement Clement NNP 13433 480 57 of of IN 13433 480 58 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 480 59 . . . 13433 481 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 481 2 54:5 54:5 CD 13433 481 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 481 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 481 5 then then RB 13433 481 6 gives give VBZ 13433 481 7 an an DT 13433 481 8 account account NN 13433 481 9 of of IN 13433 481 10 the the DT 13433 481 11 writings writing NNS 13433 481 12 of of IN 13433 481 13 John John NNP 13433 481 14 , , , 13433 481 15 and and CC 13433 481 16 whilst whilst IN 13433 481 17 asserting assert VBG 13433 481 18 that that IN 13433 481 19 the the DT 13433 481 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 481 21 must must MD 13433 481 22 be be VB 13433 481 23 universally universally RB 13433 481 24 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 13433 481 25 as as IN 13433 481 26 genuine genuine JJ 13433 481 27 , , , 13433 481 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 481 29 says say VBZ 13433 481 30 that that IN 13433 481 31 it -PRON- PRP 13433 481 32 is be VBZ 13433 481 33 rightly rightly RB 13433 481 34 put put VBN 13433 481 35 last last RB 13433 481 36 in in IN 13433 481 37 order order NN 13433 481 38 amongst amongst IN 13433 481 39 the the DT 13433 481 40 four four CD 13433 481 41 , , , 13433 481 42 of of IN 13433 481 43 the the DT 13433 481 44 composition composition NN 13433 481 45 of of IN 13433 481 46 which which WDT 13433 481 47 he -PRON- PRP 13433 481 48 gives give VBZ 13433 481 49 an an DT 13433 481 50 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 481 51 description description NN 13433 481 52 . . . 13433 482 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 482 2 is be VBZ 13433 482 3 not not RB 13433 482 4 necessary necessary JJ 13433 482 5 to to TO 13433 482 6 quote quote VB 13433 482 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 482 8 account account NN 13433 482 9 of of IN 13433 482 10 the the DT 13433 482 11 fourth fourth JJ 13433 482 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 482 13 and and CC 13433 482 14 of of IN 13433 482 15 the the DT 13433 482 16 occasion occasion NN 13433 482 17 of of IN 13433 482 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 482 19 composition composition NN 13433 482 20 , , , 13433 482 21 which which WDT 13433 482 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 482 23 states state VBZ 13433 482 24 to to TO 13433 482 25 have have VB 13433 482 26 been be VBN 13433 482 27 John John NNP 13433 482 28 's 's POS 13433 482 29 receiving receive VBG 13433 482 30 the the DT 13433 482 31 other other JJ 13433 482 32 three three CD 13433 482 33 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 482 34 , , , 13433 482 35 and and CC 13433 482 36 , , , 13433 482 37 whilst whilst IN 13433 482 38 admitting admit VBG 13433 482 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 482 40 truth truth NN 13433 482 41 , , , 13433 482 42 perceiving perceive VBG 13433 482 43 that that IN 13433 482 44 they -PRON- PRP 13433 482 45 did do VBD 13433 482 46 not not RB 13433 482 47 contain contain VB 13433 482 48 a a DT 13433 482 49 narrative narrative NN 13433 482 50 of of IN 13433 482 51 the the DT 13433 482 52 earlier early JJR 13433 482 53 history history NN 13433 482 54 of of IN 13433 482 55 Christ Christ NNP 13433 482 56 . . . 13433 483 1 For for IN 13433 483 2 this this DT 13433 483 3 reason reason NN 13433 483 4 , , , 13433 483 5 being be VBG 13433 483 6 entreated entreat VBN 13433 483 7 to to TO 13433 483 8 do do VB 13433 483 9 so so RB 13433 483 10 , , , 13433 483 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 483 12 wrote write VBD 13433 483 13 an an DT 13433 483 14 account account NN 13433 483 15 of of IN 13433 483 16 the the DT 13433 483 17 doings doing NNS 13433 483 18 of of IN 13433 483 19 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 483 20 before before IN 13433 483 21 the the DT 13433 483 22 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 483 23 was be VBD 13433 483 24 cast cast VBN 13433 483 25 into into IN 13433 483 26 prison prison NN 13433 483 27 . . . 13433 484 1 After after IN 13433 484 2 some some DT 13433 484 3 very very RB 13433 484 4 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 484 5 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 484 6 , , , 13433 484 7 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 484 8 says say VBZ 13433 484 9 that that IN 13433 484 10 no no DT 13433 484 11 one one NN 13433 484 12 who who WP 13433 484 13 carefully carefully RB 13433 484 14 considers consider VBZ 13433 484 15 the the DT 13433 484 16 points point NNS 13433 484 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 484 18 mentions mention VBZ 13433 484 19 can can MD 13433 484 20 think think VB 13433 484 21 that that IN 13433 484 22 the the DT 13433 484 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 484 24 are be VBP 13433 484 25 at at IN 13433 484 26 variance variance NN 13433 484 27 with with IN 13433 484 28 each each DT 13433 484 29 other other JJ 13433 484 30 , , , 13433 484 31 and and CC 13433 484 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 484 33 conjectures conjecture VBZ 13433 484 34 that that IN 13433 484 35 John John NNP 13433 484 36 probably probably RB 13433 484 37 omitted omit VBD 13433 484 38 the the DT 13433 484 39 genealogies genealogy NNS 13433 484 40 because because IN 13433 484 41 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 484 42 and and CC 13433 484 43 Luke Luke NNP 13433 484 44 had have VBD 13433 484 45 given give VBN 13433 484 46 them -PRON- PRP 13433 484 47 . . . 13433 485 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 485 2 54:6 54:6 CD 13433 485 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 485 4 Without without IN 13433 485 5 further further RB 13433 485 6 anticipating anticipate VBG 13433 485 7 what what WP 13433 485 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 485 9 have have VBP 13433 485 10 to to TO 13433 485 11 say say VB 13433 485 12 when when WRB 13433 485 13 speaking speak VBG 13433 485 14 of of IN 13433 485 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 485 16 , , , 13433 485 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 485 18 is be VBZ 13433 485 19 clear clear JJ 13433 485 20 , , , 13433 485 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 485 22 think think VBP 13433 485 23 , , , 13433 485 24 that that IN 13433 485 25 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 485 26 , , , 13433 485 27 being be VBG 13433 485 28 aware aware JJ 13433 485 29 of of IN 13433 485 30 , , , 13433 485 31 and and CC 13433 485 32 interested interested JJ 13433 485 33 in in IN 13433 485 34 , , , 13433 485 35 the the DT 13433 485 36 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 485 37 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 485 38 connected connect VBN 13433 485 39 with with IN 13433 485 40 the the DT 13433 485 41 writings writing NNS 13433 485 42 attributed attribute VBN 13433 485 43 to to IN 13433 485 44 John John NNP 13433 485 45 , , , 13433 485 46 not not RB 13433 485 47 to to TO 13433 485 48 put put VB 13433 485 49 a a DT 13433 485 50 still still RB 13433 485 51 stronger strong JJR 13433 485 52 case case NN 13433 485 53 , , , 13433 485 54 and and CC 13433 485 55 quoting quote VBG 13433 485 56 traditions tradition NNS 13433 485 57 from from IN 13433 485 58 later later RB 13433 485 59 and and CC 13433 485 60 consequently consequently RB 13433 485 61 less less RBR 13433 485 62 weighty weighty JJ 13433 485 63 authorities authority NNS 13433 485 64 , , , 13433 485 65 would would MD 13433 485 66 certainly certainly RB 13433 485 67 have have VB 13433 485 68 recorded record VBN 13433 485 69 with with IN 13433 485 70 more more RBR 13433 485 71 special special JJ 13433 485 72 readiness readiness NN 13433 485 73 any any DT 13433 485 74 information information NN 13433 485 75 on on IN 13433 485 76 the the DT 13433 485 77 subject subject NN 13433 485 78 given give VBN 13433 485 79 by by IN 13433 485 80 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 485 81 , , , 13433 485 82 whom whom WP 13433 485 83 he -PRON- PRP 13433 485 84 so so RB 13433 485 85 frequently frequently RB 13433 485 86 lays lay VBZ 13433 485 87 under under IN 13433 485 88 contribution contribution NN 13433 485 89 , , , 13433 485 90 had have VBD 13433 485 91 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 485 92 writings writing NNS 13433 485 93 contained contain VBN 13433 485 94 any any DT 13433 485 95 . . . 13433 486 1 In in IN 13433 486 2 regard regard NN 13433 486 3 to to IN 13433 486 4 PAPIAS PAPIAS NNP 13433 486 5 the the DT 13433 486 6 case case NN 13433 486 7 is be VBZ 13433 486 8 still still RB 13433 486 9 clearer clear JJR 13433 486 10 . . . 13433 487 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 487 2 find find VBP 13433 487 3 that that IN 13433 487 4 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 487 5 quotes quote VBZ 13433 487 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 487 7 account account NN 13433 487 8 of of IN 13433 487 9 the the DT 13433 487 10 composition composition NN 13433 487 11 of of IN 13433 487 12 Gospels Gospels NNP 13433 487 13 by by IN 13433 487 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 487 15 and and CC 13433 487 16 Mark Mark NNP 13433 487 17 , , , 13433 487 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 487 19 55:1 55:1 CD 13433 487 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 487 21 although although IN 13433 487 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 487 23 had have VBD 13433 487 24 already already RB 13433 487 25 given give VBN 13433 487 26 a a DT 13433 487 27 closely closely RB 13433 487 28 similar similar JJ 13433 487 29 narrative narrative NN 13433 487 30 regarding regard VBG 13433 487 31 Mark Mark NNP 13433 487 32 from from IN 13433 487 33 Clement Clement NNP 13433 487 34 of of IN 13433 487 35 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 487 36 , , , 13433 487 37 and and CC 13433 487 38 appealed appeal VBD 13433 487 39 to to IN 13433 487 40 Papias Papias NNP 13433 487 41 in in IN 13433 487 42 confirmation confirmation NN 13433 487 43 of of IN 13433 487 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 487 45 . . . 13433 488 1 Is be VBZ 13433 488 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 488 3 either either CC 13433 488 4 possible possible JJ 13433 488 5 or or CC 13433 488 6 permissible permissible JJ 13433 488 7 to to TO 13433 488 8 suppose suppose VB 13433 488 9 that that DT 13433 488 10 , , , 13433 488 11 had have VBD 13433 488 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 488 13 known know VBN 13433 488 14 anything anything NN 13433 488 15 of of IN 13433 488 16 the the DT 13433 488 17 other other JJ 13433 488 18 two two CD 13433 488 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 488 20 , , , 13433 488 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 488 22 would would MD 13433 488 23 not not RB 13433 488 24 have have VB 13433 488 25 enquired enquire VBN 13433 488 26 about about IN 13433 488 27 them -PRON- PRP 13433 488 28 from from IN 13433 488 29 the the DT 13433 488 30 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 488 31 and and CC 13433 488 32 recorded record VBD 13433 488 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 488 34 information information NN 13433 488 35 ? ? . 13433 489 1 And and CC 13433 489 2 is be VBZ 13433 489 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 489 4 either either CC 13433 489 5 possible possible JJ 13433 489 6 or or CC 13433 489 7 permissible permissible JJ 13433 489 8 to to TO 13433 489 9 suppose suppose VB 13433 489 10 that that IN 13433 489 11 if if IN 13433 489 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 489 13 had have VBD 13433 489 14 recorded record VBN 13433 489 15 any any DT 13433 489 16 similar similar JJ 13433 489 17 information information NN 13433 489 18 regarding regard VBG 13433 489 19 the the DT 13433 489 20 composition composition NN 13433 489 21 of of IN 13433 489 22 the the DT 13433 489 23 third third JJ 13433 489 24 and and CC 13433 489 25 fourth fourth JJ 13433 489 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 489 27 , , , 13433 489 28 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 489 29 would would MD 13433 489 30 have have VB 13433 489 31 omitted omit VBN 13433 489 32 to to TO 13433 489 33 quote quote VB 13433 489 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 489 35 ? ? . 13433 490 1 Certainly certainly RB 13433 490 2 not not RB 13433 490 3 ; ; : 13433 490 4 and and CC 13433 490 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 490 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 490 7 's 's POS 13433 490 8 article article NN 13433 490 9 proves prove VBZ 13433 490 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 490 11 . . . 13433 491 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 491 2 had have VBD 13433 491 3 not not RB 13433 491 4 only only RB 13433 491 5 pledged pledge VBN 13433 491 6 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 491 7 to to TO 13433 491 8 give give VB 13433 491 9 such such JJ 13433 491 10 information information NN 13433 491 11 , , , 13433 491 12 and and CC 13433 491 13 does do VBZ 13433 491 14 so so RB 13433 491 15 in in IN 13433 491 16 every every DT 13433 491 17 case case NN 13433 491 18 which which WDT 13433 491 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 491 20 can can MD 13433 491 21 test test VB 13433 491 22 , , , 13433 491 23 but but CC 13433 491 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 491 25 fulfil fulfil VBP 13433 491 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 491 27 by by IN 13433 491 28 actually actually RB 13433 491 29 quoting quote VBG 13433 491 30 what what WP 13433 491 31 Papias Papias NNP 13433 491 32 had have VBD 13433 491 33 to to TO 13433 491 34 say say VB 13433 491 35 about about IN 13433 491 36 the the DT 13433 491 37 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 491 38 . . . 13433 492 1 Even even RB 13433 492 2 if if IN 13433 492 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 492 4 had have VBD 13433 492 5 been be VBN 13433 492 6 careless careless JJ 13433 492 7 , , , 13433 492 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 492 9 very very JJ 13433 492 10 reference reference NN 13433 492 11 to to IN 13433 492 12 the the DT 13433 492 13 first first JJ 13433 492 14 two two CD 13433 492 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 492 16 must must MD 13433 492 17 have have VB 13433 492 18 reminded remind VBN 13433 492 19 him -PRON- PRP 13433 492 20 of of IN 13433 492 21 the the DT 13433 492 22 claims claim NNS 13433 492 23 of of IN 13433 492 24 the the DT 13433 492 25 rest rest NN 13433 492 26 . . . 13433 493 1 There there EX 13433 493 2 are be VBP 13433 493 3 , , , 13433 493 4 however however RB 13433 493 5 , , , 13433 493 6 special special JJ 13433 493 7 reasons reason NNS 13433 493 8 which which WDT 13433 493 9 render render VBP 13433 493 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 493 11 still still RB 13433 493 12 more more RBR 13433 493 13 certain certain JJ 13433 493 14 that that WDT 13433 493 15 had have VBD 13433 493 16 Papias Papias NNP 13433 493 17 had have VBD 13433 493 18 anything anything NN 13433 493 19 to to TO 13433 493 20 tell tell VB 13433 493 21 about about IN 13433 493 22 the the DT 13433 493 23 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 493 24 Gospel,--and Gospel,--and NNP 13433 493 25 if if IN 13433 493 26 there there EX 13433 493 27 was be VBD 13433 493 28 a a DT 13433 493 29 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 493 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 493 31 in in IN 13433 493 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 493 33 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 493 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 493 35 must must MD 13433 493 36 have have VB 13433 493 37 had have VBN 13433 493 38 something something NN 13433 493 39 , , , 13433 493 40 to to TO 13433 493 41 tell tell VB 13433 493 42 about about IN 13433 493 43 it,--Eusebius it,--Eusebius NNP 13433 493 44 would would MD 13433 493 45 have have VB 13433 493 46 recorded record VBN 13433 493 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 493 48 . . . 13433 494 1 The the DT 13433 494 2 first first JJ 13433 494 3 quotation quotation NN 13433 494 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 494 5 makes make VBZ 13433 494 6 from from IN 13433 494 7 Papias Papias NNP 13433 494 8 is be VBZ 13433 494 9 the the DT 13433 494 10 passage passage NN 13433 494 11 in in IN 13433 494 12 which which WDT 13433 494 13 the the DT 13433 494 14 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 494 15 of of IN 13433 494 16 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 13433 494 17 states state VBZ 13433 494 18 the the DT 13433 494 19 interest interest NN 13433 494 20 with with IN 13433 494 21 which which WDT 13433 494 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 494 23 had have VBD 13433 494 24 enquired enquire VBN 13433 494 25 about about IN 13433 494 26 the the DT 13433 494 27 words word NNS 13433 494 28 of of IN 13433 494 29 the the DT 13433 494 30 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 494 31 , , , 13433 494 32 " " '' 13433 494 33 what what WP 13433 494 34 John John NNP 13433 494 35 or or CC 13433 494 36 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 494 37 or or CC 13433 494 38 what what WP 13433 494 39 any any DT 13433 494 40 other other JJ 13433 494 41 of of IN 13433 494 42 the the DT 13433 494 43 disciples disciple NNS 13433 494 44 of of IN 13433 494 45 the the DT 13433 494 46 Lord Lord NNP 13433 494 47 said say VBD 13433 494 48 , , , 13433 494 49 and and CC 13433 494 50 what what WP 13433 494 51 Aristion Aristion NNP 13433 494 52 and and CC 13433 494 53 the the DT 13433 494 54 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 494 55 John John NNP 13433 494 56 , , , 13433 494 57 disciples disciple NNS 13433 494 58 of of IN 13433 494 59 the the DT 13433 494 60 Lord Lord NNP 13433 494 61 , , , 13433 494 62 say say VBP 13433 494 63 . . . 13433 494 64 " " '' 13433 495 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 495 2 55:2 55:2 CD 13433 495 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 495 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 495 5 observes observe VBZ 13433 495 6 , , , 13433 495 7 and and CC 13433 495 8 particularly particularly RB 13433 495 9 points point VBZ 13433 495 10 out out RP 13433 495 11 , , , 13433 495 12 that that IN 13433 495 13 the the DT 13433 495 14 name name NN 13433 495 15 of of IN 13433 495 16 John John NNP 13433 495 17 is be VBZ 13433 495 18 twice twice RB 13433 495 19 mentioned mention VBN 13433 495 20 in in IN 13433 495 21 the the DT 13433 495 22 passage passage NN 13433 495 23 , , , 13433 495 24 the the DT 13433 495 25 former former JJ 13433 495 26 , , , 13433 495 27 mentioned mention VBN 13433 495 28 with with IN 13433 495 29 Peter Peter NNP 13433 495 30 , , , 13433 495 31 James James NNP 13433 495 32 , , , 13433 495 33 and and CC 13433 495 34 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 495 35 , , , 13433 495 36 and and CC 13433 495 37 other other JJ 13433 495 38 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 495 39 , , , 13433 495 40 evidently evidently RB 13433 495 41 being be VBG 13433 495 42 , , , 13433 495 43 he -PRON- PRP 13433 495 44 thinks think VBZ 13433 495 45 , , , 13433 495 46 the the DT 13433 495 47 Evangelist Evangelist NNP 13433 495 48 , , , 13433 495 49 and and CC 13433 495 50 the the DT 13433 495 51 latter latter JJ 13433 495 52 being be VBG 13433 495 53 clearly clearly RB 13433 495 54 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 495 55 by by IN 13433 495 56 the the DT 13433 495 57 designation designation NN 13433 495 58 of of IN 13433 495 59 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 495 60 . . . 13433 496 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 496 2 states state VBZ 13433 496 3 that that IN 13433 496 4 this this DT 13433 496 5 proves prove VBZ 13433 496 6 the the DT 13433 496 7 truth truth NN 13433 496 8 of of IN 13433 496 9 the the DT 13433 496 10 assertion assertion NN 13433 496 11 that that IN 13433 496 12 there there EX 13433 496 13 were be VBD 13433 496 14 two two CD 13433 496 15 men man NNS 13433 496 16 of of IN 13433 496 17 the the DT 13433 496 18 name name NN 13433 496 19 of of IN 13433 496 20 John John NNP 13433 496 21 in in IN 13433 496 22 Asia Asia NNP 13433 496 23 , , , 13433 496 24 and and CC 13433 496 25 that that IN 13433 496 26 two two CD 13433 496 27 tombs tomb NNS 13433 496 28 were be VBD 13433 496 29 still still RB 13433 496 30 shown show VBN 13433 496 31 at at IN 13433 496 32 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 496 33 bearing bear VBG 13433 496 34 the the DT 13433 496 35 name name NN 13433 496 36 of of IN 13433 496 37 John John NNP 13433 496 38 . . . 13433 497 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 497 2 then then RB 13433 497 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 497 4 to to TO 13433 497 5 argue argue VB 13433 497 6 that that IN 13433 497 7 probably probably RB 13433 497 8 the the DT 13433 497 9 second second JJ 13433 497 10 of of IN 13433 497 11 the the DT 13433 497 12 two two CD 13433 497 13 Johns Johns NNP 13433 497 14 , , , 13433 497 15 if if IN 13433 497 16 not not RB 13433 497 17 the the DT 13433 497 18 first first JJ 13433 497 19 , , , 13433 497 20 was be VBD 13433 497 21 the the DT 13433 497 22 man man NN 13433 497 23 who who WP 13433 497 24 saw see VBD 13433 497 25 the the DT 13433 497 26 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 497 27 . . . 13433 498 1 What what WDT 13433 498 2 an an DT 13433 498 3 occasion occasion NN 13433 498 4 for for IN 13433 498 5 quoting quote VBG 13433 498 6 any any DT 13433 498 7 information information NN 13433 498 8 bearing bear VBG 13433 498 9 at at RB 13433 498 10 all all RB 13433 498 11 on on IN 13433 498 12 the the DT 13433 498 13 subject subject NN 13433 498 14 from from IN 13433 498 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 498 16 , , , 13433 498 17 who who WP 13433 498 18 had have VBD 13433 498 19 questioned question VBN 13433 498 20 those those DT 13433 498 21 who who WP 13433 498 22 had have VBD 13433 498 23 been be VBN 13433 498 24 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 498 25 with with IN 13433 498 26 both both DT 13433 498 27 ! ! . 13433 499 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 499 2 attention attention NN 13433 499 3 is be VBZ 13433 499 4 so so RB 13433 499 5 pointedly pointedly RB 13433 499 6 turned turn VBN 13433 499 7 to to IN 13433 499 8 John John NNP 13433 499 9 at at IN 13433 499 10 the the DT 13433 499 11 very very JJ 13433 499 12 moment moment NN 13433 499 13 when when WRB 13433 499 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 499 15 makes make VBZ 13433 499 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 499 17 quotations quotation NNS 13433 499 18 regarding regard VBG 13433 499 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 499 20 and and CC 13433 499 21 Mark Mark NNP 13433 499 22 , , , 13433 499 23 that that IN 13433 499 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 499 25 am be VBP 13433 499 26 fully fully RB 13433 499 27 warranted warrant VBN 13433 499 28 , , , 13433 499 29 both both CC 13433 499 30 by by IN 13433 499 31 the the DT 13433 499 32 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 499 33 of of IN 13433 499 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 499 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 499 36 and and CC 13433 499 37 the the DT 13433 499 38 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 499 39 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 499 40 of of IN 13433 499 41 the the DT 13433 499 42 case case NN 13433 499 43 , , , 13433 499 44 in in IN 13433 499 45 affirming affirm VBG 13433 499 46 that that IN 13433 499 47 the the DT 13433 499 48 silence silence NN 13433 499 49 of of IN 13433 499 50 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 499 51 proves prove VBZ 13433 499 52 that that IN 13433 499 53 Papias Papias NNP 13433 499 54 said say VBD 13433 499 55 nothing nothing NN 13433 499 56 about about IN 13433 499 57 either either CC 13433 499 58 the the DT 13433 499 59 third third JJ 13433 499 60 or or CC 13433 499 61 fourth fourth JJ 13433 499 62 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 499 63 . . . 13433 500 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 500 2 need need VBP 13433 500 3 not not RB 13433 500 4 go go VB 13433 500 5 on on RP 13433 500 6 to to TO 13433 500 7 discuss discuss VB 13433 500 8 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 500 9 of of IN 13433 500 10 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 500 11 , , , 13433 500 12 for for IN 13433 500 13 the the DT 13433 500 14 same same JJ 13433 500 15 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 500 16 equally equally RB 13433 500 17 applies apply VBZ 13433 500 18 to to IN 13433 500 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 500 20 case case NN 13433 500 21 . . . 13433 501 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 501 2 have have VBP 13433 501 3 , , , 13433 501 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 501 5 , , , 13433 501 6 only only RB 13433 501 7 a a DT 13433 501 8 few few JJ 13433 501 9 more more JJR 13433 501 10 words word NNS 13433 501 11 to to TO 13433 501 12 say say VB 13433 501 13 on on IN 13433 501 14 the the DT 13433 501 15 subject subject NN 13433 501 16 of of IN 13433 501 17 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 501 18 . . . 13433 502 1 Not not RB 13433 502 2 content content JJ 13433 502 3 with with IN 13433 502 4 what what WP 13433 502 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 502 6 intended intend VBD 13433 502 7 to to TO 13433 502 8 be be VB 13433 502 9 destructive destructive JJ 13433 502 10 criticism criticism NN 13433 502 11 , , , 13433 502 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 502 13 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 502 14 valiantly valiantly RB 13433 502 15 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 502 16 to to IN 13433 502 17 the the DT 13433 502 18 constructive constructive JJ 13433 502 19 and and CC 13433 502 20 , , , 13433 502 21 " " '' 13433 502 22 as as IN 13433 502 23 a a DT 13433 502 24 sober sober JJ 13433 502 25 deduction deduction NN 13433 502 26 from from IN 13433 502 27 facts fact NNS 13433 502 28 , , , 13433 502 29 " " '' 13433 502 30 makes make VBZ 13433 502 31 the the DT 13433 502 32 following follow VBG 13433 502 33 statement statement NN 13433 502 34 , , , 13433 502 35 which which WDT 13433 502 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 502 37 prints print VBZ 13433 502 38 in in IN 13433 502 39 italics italic NNS 13433 502 40 : : : 13433 502 41 " " `` 13433 502 42 _ _ NNP 13433 502 43 The the DT 13433 502 44 silence silence NN 13433 502 45 of of IN 13433 502 46 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 502 47 respecting respect VBG 13433 502 48 early early JJ 13433 502 49 witnesses witness NNS 13433 502 50 to to IN 13433 502 51 the the DT 13433 502 52 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 502 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 502 54 is be VBZ 13433 502 55 an an DT 13433 502 56 evidence evidence NN 13433 502 57 in in IN 13433 502 58 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 502 59 favour favour NN 13433 502 60 _ _ NNP 13433 502 61 . . . 13433 502 62 " " '' 13433 503 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 503 2 56:1 56:1 CD 13433 503 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 503 4 Now now RB 13433 503 5 , , , 13433 503 6 interpreted interpret VBN 13433 503 7 even even RB 13433 503 8 by by IN 13433 503 9 the the DT 13433 503 10 rules rule NNS 13433 503 11 laid lay VBN 13433 503 12 down down RP 13433 503 13 by by IN 13433 503 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 503 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 503 16 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 503 17 , , , 13433 503 18 what what WP 13433 503 19 does do VBZ 13433 503 20 this this DT 13433 503 21 silence silence NN 13433 503 22 really really RB 13433 503 23 mean mean VB 13433 503 24 ? ? . 13433 504 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 504 2 means mean VBZ 13433 504 3 , , , 13433 504 4 not not RB 13433 504 5 that that IN 13433 504 6 the the DT 13433 504 7 early early JJ 13433 504 8 writers writer NNS 13433 504 9 about about IN 13433 504 10 whom whom WP 13433 504 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 504 12 is be VBZ 13433 504 13 supposed suppose VBN 13433 504 14 to to TO 13433 504 15 be be VB 13433 504 16 silent silent JJ 13433 504 17 are be VBP 13433 504 18 witnesses witness NNS 13433 504 19 about about IN 13433 504 20 anything anything NN 13433 504 21 connected connect VBN 13433 504 22 with with IN 13433 504 23 the the DT 13433 504 24 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 504 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 504 26 , , , 13433 504 27 but but CC 13433 504 28 simply simply RB 13433 504 29 that that IN 13433 504 30 if if IN 13433 504 31 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 504 32 noticed notice VBD 13433 504 33 and and CC 13433 504 34 did do VBD 13433 504 35 not not RB 13433 504 36 record record VB 13433 504 37 the the DT 13433 504 38 mere mere JJ 13433 504 39 use use NN 13433 504 40 of of IN 13433 504 41 that that DT 13433 504 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 504 43 by by IN 13433 504 44 anyone anyone NN 13433 504 45 , , , 13433 504 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 504 47 thereby thereby RB 13433 504 48 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 504 49 that that IN 13433 504 50 he -PRON- PRP 13433 504 51 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 504 52 , , , 13433 504 53 in in IN 13433 504 54 the the DT 13433 504 55 fourth fourth JJ 13433 504 56 century century NN 13433 504 57 , , , 13433 504 58 classed class VBD 13433 504 59 it -PRON- PRP 13433 504 60 amongst amongst IN 13433 504 61 the the DT 13433 504 62 undisputed undisputed JJ 13433 504 63 books book NNS 13433 504 64 , , , 13433 504 65 the the DT 13433 504 66 mere mere JJ 13433 504 67 use use NN 13433 504 68 of of IN 13433 504 69 which which WDT 13433 504 70 he -PRON- PRP 13433 504 71 does do VBZ 13433 504 72 not not RB 13433 504 73 undertake undertake VB 13433 504 74 to to TO 13433 504 75 mention mention VB 13433 504 76 . . . 13433 505 1 The the DT 13433 505 2 value value NN 13433 505 3 of of IN 13433 505 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 505 5 opinion opinion NN 13433 505 6 at at IN 13433 505 7 so so RB 13433 505 8 late late RB 13433 505 9 a a DT 13433 505 10 date date NN 13433 505 11 is be VBZ 13433 505 12 very very RB 13433 505 13 small small JJ 13433 505 14 . . . 13433 506 1 Professor Professor NNP 13433 506 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 506 3 next next RB 13433 506 4 makes make VBZ 13433 506 5 a a DT 13433 506 6 vehement vehement JJ 13433 506 7 attack attack NN 13433 506 8 upon upon IN 13433 506 9 me -PRON- PRP 13433 506 10 in in IN 13433 506 11 connection connection NN 13433 506 12 with with IN 13433 506 13 " " `` 13433 506 14 THE the DT 13433 506 15 IGNATIAN ignatian JJ 13433 506 16 EPISTLES epistle NNS 13433 506 17 , , , 13433 506 18 " " '' 13433 506 19 [ [ -LRB- 13433 506 20 57:1 57:1 CD 13433 506 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 506 22 which which WDT 13433 506 23 is be VBZ 13433 506 24 equally equally RB 13433 506 25 abortive abortive JJ 13433 506 26 and and CC 13433 506 27 limited limited JJ 13433 506 28 to to IN 13433 506 29 details detail NNS 13433 506 30 . . . 13433 507 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 507 2 do do VBP 13433 507 3 not not RB 13433 507 4 intend intend VB 13433 507 5 to to TO 13433 507 6 complain complain VB 13433 507 7 of of IN 13433 507 8 the the DT 13433 507 9 spirit spirit NN 13433 507 10 in in IN 13433 507 11 which which WDT 13433 507 12 the the DT 13433 507 13 article article NN 13433 507 14 is be VBZ 13433 507 15 written write VBN 13433 507 16 , , , 13433 507 17 nor nor CC 13433 507 18 of of IN 13433 507 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 507 20 unfairness unfairness NN 13433 507 21 . . . 13433 508 1 On on IN 13433 508 2 the the DT 13433 508 3 whole whole NN 13433 508 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 508 5 think think VBP 13433 508 6 that that IN 13433 508 7 readers reader NNS 13433 508 8 may may MD 13433 508 9 safely safely RB 13433 508 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 508 11 left leave VBD 13433 508 12 to to TO 13433 508 13 judge judge VB 13433 508 14 of of IN 13433 508 15 the the DT 13433 508 16 tone tone NN 13433 508 17 in in IN 13433 508 18 which which WDT 13433 508 19 a a DT 13433 508 20 controversy controversy NN 13433 508 21 is be VBZ 13433 508 22 carried carry VBN 13433 508 23 on on RP 13433 508 24 . . . 13433 509 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 13433 509 2 , , , 13433 509 3 however however RB 13433 509 4 , , , 13433 509 5 the the DT 13433 509 6 perpetual perpetual JJ 13433 509 7 accusation accusation NN 13433 509 8 of of IN 13433 509 9 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 509 10 brought bring VBN 13433 509 11 against against IN 13433 509 12 me -PRON- PRP 13433 509 13 in in IN 13433 509 14 this this DT 13433 509 15 article article NN 13433 509 16 , , , 13433 509 17 and and CC 13433 509 18 based base VBN 13433 509 19 upon upon IN 13433 509 20 minute minute JJ 13433 509 21 criticism criticism NN 13433 509 22 into into IN 13433 509 23 which which WDT 13433 509 24 few few JJ 13433 509 25 care care NN 13433 509 26 to to TO 13433 509 27 follow follow VB 13433 509 28 , , , 13433 509 29 is be VBZ 13433 509 30 apt apt JJ 13433 509 31 to to TO 13433 509 32 leave leave VB 13433 509 33 the the DT 13433 509 34 impression impression NN 13433 509 35 that that IN 13433 509 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 509 37 is be VBZ 13433 509 38 well well RB 13433 509 39 - - HYPH 13433 509 40 founded found VBN 13433 509 41 , , , 13433 509 42 for for IN 13433 509 43 there there EX 13433 509 44 is be VBZ 13433 509 45 the the DT 13433 509 46 very very RB 13433 509 47 natural natural JJ 13433 509 48 feeling feeling NN 13433 509 49 in in IN 13433 509 50 most most JJS 13433 509 51 right right JJ 13433 509 52 minds mind NNS 13433 509 53 that that WDT 13433 509 54 no no DT 13433 509 55 one one NN 13433 509 56 would would MD 13433 509 57 recklessly recklessly RB 13433 509 58 scatter scatter VB 13433 509 59 such such JJ 13433 509 60 insinuations insinuation NNS 13433 509 61 . . . 13433 510 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 510 2 is be VBZ 13433 510 3 this this DT 13433 510 4 which which WDT 13433 510 5 alone alone RB 13433 510 6 makes make VBZ 13433 510 7 such such PDT 13433 510 8 an an DT 13433 510 9 attack attack NN 13433 510 10 dangerous dangerous JJ 13433 510 11 . . . 13433 511 1 Now now RB 13433 511 2 in in IN 13433 511 3 a a DT 13433 511 4 work work NN 13433 511 5 like like IN 13433 511 6 this this DT 13433 511 7 , , , 13433 511 8 dealing deal VBG 13433 511 9 with with IN 13433 511 10 so so RB 13433 511 11 many many JJ 13433 511 12 details detail NNS 13433 511 13 , , , 13433 511 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 511 15 must must MD 13433 511 16 be be VB 13433 511 17 obvious obvious JJ 13433 511 18 that that IN 13433 511 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 511 20 not not RB 13433 511 21 possible possible JJ 13433 511 22 altogether altogether RB 13433 511 23 to to TO 13433 511 24 escape escape VB 13433 511 25 errors error NNS 13433 511 26 . . . 13433 512 1 A a DT 13433 512 2 critic critic NN 13433 512 3 or or CC 13433 512 4 opponent opponent NN 13433 512 5 is be VBZ 13433 512 6 of of IN 13433 512 7 course course NN 13433 512 8 entitled entitle VBN 13433 512 9 to to TO 13433 512 10 point point VB 13433 512 11 these these DT 13433 512 12 out out RP 13433 512 13 , , , 13433 512 14 although although IN 13433 512 15 , , , 13433 512 16 if if IN 13433 512 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 512 18 be be VB 13433 512 19 high high RB 13433 512 20 - - HYPH 13433 512 21 minded minded JJ 13433 512 22 or or CC 13433 512 23 even even RB 13433 512 24 alive alive JJ 13433 512 25 to to IN 13433 512 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 512 27 own own JJ 13433 512 28 interests interest NNS 13433 512 29 , , , 13433 512 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 512 31 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 512 32 think think VBP 13433 512 33 that that IN 13433 512 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 512 35 will will MD 13433 512 36 do do VB 13433 512 37 so so RB 13433 512 38 in in IN 13433 512 39 a a DT 13433 512 40 spirit spirit NN 13433 512 41 of of IN 13433 512 42 unfair unfair JJ 13433 512 43 detraction detraction NN 13433 512 44 . . . 13433 513 1 But but CC 13433 513 2 in in IN 13433 513 3 doing do VBG 13433 513 4 this this DT 13433 513 5 a a DT 13433 513 6 writer writer NN 13433 513 7 is be VBZ 13433 513 8 bound bind VBN 13433 513 9 to to TO 13433 513 10 be be VB 13433 513 11 accurate accurate JJ 13433 513 12 , , , 13433 513 13 for for CC 13433 513 14 if if IN 13433 513 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 513 16 be be VB 13433 513 17 liberal liberal JJ 13433 513 18 of of IN 13433 513 19 such such JJ 13433 513 20 accusations accusation NNS 13433 513 21 and and CC 13433 513 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 513 23 can can MD 13433 513 24 be be VB 13433 513 25 shown show VBN 13433 513 26 that that IN 13433 513 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 513 28 charges charge NNS 13433 513 29 are be VBP 13433 513 30 unfounded unfounded JJ 13433 513 31 , , , 13433 513 32 they -PRON- PRP 13433 513 33 recoil recoil VBP 13433 513 34 with with IN 13433 513 35 double double JJ 13433 513 36 force force NN 13433 513 37 upon upon IN 13433 513 38 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 513 39 . . . 13433 514 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 514 2 propose propose VBP 13433 514 3 , , , 13433 514 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 514 5 , , , 13433 514 6 as as IN 13433 514 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 514 8 is be VBZ 13433 514 9 impossible impossible JJ 13433 514 10 for for IN 13433 514 11 me -PRON- PRP 13433 514 12 to to TO 13433 514 13 reply reply VB 13433 514 14 to to IN 13433 514 15 all all DT 13433 514 16 such such JJ 13433 514 17 attacks attack NNS 13433 514 18 , , , 13433 514 19 to to TO 13433 514 20 follow follow VB 13433 514 21 Professor Professor NNP 13433 514 22 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 514 23 and and CC 13433 514 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 514 25 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 514 26 , , , 13433 514 27 with with IN 13433 514 28 some some DT 13433 514 29 minuteness minuteness NN 13433 514 30 in in IN 13433 514 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 514 32 discussion discussion NN 13433 514 33 of of IN 13433 514 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 514 35 treatment treatment NN 13433 514 36 of of IN 13433 514 37 the the DT 13433 514 38 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 514 39 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 514 40 , , , 13433 514 41 and and CC 13433 514 42 once once RB 13433 514 43 for for IN 13433 514 44 all all DT 13433 514 45 to to TO 13433 514 46 show show VB 13433 514 47 the the DT 13433 514 48 grave grave JJ 13433 514 49 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 514 50 to to TO 13433 514 51 which which WDT 13433 514 52 they -PRON- PRP 13433 514 53 commit commit VBP 13433 514 54 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 514 55 . . . 13433 515 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 515 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 515 3 does do VBZ 13433 515 4 not not RB 13433 515 5 ignore ignore VB 13433 515 6 the the DT 13433 515 7 character character NN 13433 515 8 of of IN 13433 515 9 the the DT 13433 515 10 discussion discussion NN 13433 515 11 upon upon IN 13433 515 12 which which WDT 13433 515 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 515 14 enters enter VBZ 13433 515 15 , , , 13433 515 16 but but CC 13433 515 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 515 18 will will MD 13433 515 19 be be VB 13433 515 20 seen see VBN 13433 515 21 that that IN 13433 515 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 515 23 appreciation appreciation NN 13433 515 24 of of IN 13433 515 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 515 26 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 515 27 by by IN 13433 515 28 no no DT 13433 515 29 means means NN 13433 515 30 inspires inspire VBZ 13433 515 31 him -PRON- PRP 13433 515 32 with with IN 13433 515 33 charitable charitable JJ 13433 515 34 emotions emotion NNS 13433 515 35 . . . 13433 516 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 516 2 says say VBZ 13433 516 3 : : : 13433 516 4 " " `` 13433 516 5 The the DT 13433 516 6 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 516 7 question question NN 13433 516 8 is be VBZ 13433 516 9 the the DT 13433 516 10 most most RBS 13433 516 11 perplexing perplexing JJ 13433 516 12 which which WDT 13433 516 13 confronts confront VBZ 13433 516 14 the the DT 13433 516 15 student student NN 13433 516 16 of of IN 13433 516 17 earlier early JJR 13433 516 18 Christian christian JJ 13433 516 19 history history NN 13433 516 20 . . . 13433 517 1 The the DT 13433 517 2 literature literature NN 13433 517 3 is be VBZ 13433 517 4 voluminous voluminous JJ 13433 517 5 ; ; : 13433 517 6 the the DT 13433 517 7 considerations consideration NNS 13433 517 8 involved involve VBN 13433 517 9 are be VBP 13433 517 10 very very RB 13433 517 11 wide wide JJ 13433 517 12 , , , 13433 517 13 very very RB 13433 517 14 varied varied JJ 13433 517 15 , , , 13433 517 16 and and CC 13433 517 17 very very RB 13433 517 18 intricate intricate JJ 13433 517 19 . . . 13433 518 1 A a DT 13433 518 2 writer writer NN 13433 518 3 , , , 13433 518 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 518 5 , , , 13433 518 6 may may MD 13433 518 7 well well RB 13433 518 8 be be VB 13433 518 9 pardoned pardon VBN 13433 518 10 if if IN 13433 518 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 518 12 betrays betray VBZ 13433 518 13 a a DT 13433 518 14 want want NN 13433 518 15 of of IN 13433 518 16 familiarity familiarity NN 13433 518 17 with with IN 13433 518 18 this this DT 13433 518 19 subject subject NN 13433 518 20 . . . 13433 519 1 But but CC 13433 519 2 in in IN 13433 519 3 this this DT 13433 519 4 case case NN 13433 519 5 the the DT 13433 519 6 reader reader NN 13433 519 7 naturally naturally RB 13433 519 8 expects expect VBZ 13433 519 9 that that IN 13433 519 10 the the DT 13433 519 11 opinions opinion NNS 13433 519 12 at at IN 13433 519 13 which which WDT 13433 519 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 519 15 has have VBZ 13433 519 16 arrived arrive VBN 13433 519 17 will will MD 13433 519 18 be be VB 13433 519 19 stated state VBN 13433 519 20 with with IN 13433 519 21 some some DT 13433 519 22 diffidence diffidence NN 13433 519 23 . . . 13433 519 24 " " '' 13433 520 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 520 2 58:1 58:1 CD 13433 520 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 520 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 520 5 critic critic NN 13433 520 6 objects object VBZ 13433 520 7 that that WDT 13433 520 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 520 9 express express VBP 13433 520 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 520 11 opinions opinion NNS 13433 520 12 with with IN 13433 520 13 decision decision NN 13433 520 14 . . . 13433 521 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 521 2 shall shall MD 13433 521 3 hereafter hereafter RB 13433 521 4 justify justify VB 13433 521 5 this this DT 13433 521 6 decision decision NN 13433 521 7 , , , 13433 521 8 but but CC 13433 521 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 521 10 would would MD 13433 521 11 here here RB 13433 521 12 point point VB 13433 521 13 out out RP 13433 521 14 that that IN 13433 521 15 the the DT 13433 521 16 very very JJ 13433 521 17 reasons reason NNS 13433 521 18 which which WDT 13433 521 19 render render VBP 13433 521 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 521 21 difficult difficult JJ 13433 521 22 for for IN 13433 521 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 521 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 521 25 to to TO 13433 521 26 form form VB 13433 521 27 a a DT 13433 521 28 final final JJ 13433 521 29 and and CC 13433 521 30 decisive decisive JJ 13433 521 31 judgment judgment NN 13433 521 32 on on IN 13433 521 33 the the DT 13433 521 34 question question NN 13433 521 35 make make VBP 13433 521 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 521 37 easy easy JJ 13433 521 38 for for IN 13433 521 39 me -PRON- PRP 13433 521 40 . . . 13433 522 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 522 2 requires require VBZ 13433 522 3 but but CC 13433 522 4 little little JJ 13433 522 5 logical logical JJ 13433 522 6 perception perception NN 13433 522 7 to to TO 13433 522 8 recognize recognize VB 13433 522 9 that that IN 13433 522 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 522 11 , , , 13433 522 12 the the DT 13433 522 13 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 522 14 of of IN 13433 522 15 which which WDT 13433 522 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 522 17 is be VBZ 13433 522 18 so so RB 13433 522 19 difficult difficult JJ 13433 522 20 to to TO 13433 522 21 establish establish VB 13433 522 22 , , , 13433 522 23 can can MD 13433 522 24 not not RB 13433 522 25 have have VB 13433 522 26 much much JJ 13433 522 27 influence influence NN 13433 522 28 as as IN 13433 522 29 testimony testimony NN 13433 522 30 for for IN 13433 522 31 the the DT 13433 522 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 522 33 . . . 13433 523 1 The the DT 13433 523 2 statement statement NN 13433 523 3 just just RB 13433 523 4 quoted quote VBD 13433 523 5 , , , 13433 523 6 however however RB 13433 523 7 , , , 13433 523 8 is be VBZ 13433 523 9 made make VBN 13433 523 10 the the DT 13433 523 11 base base NN 13433 523 12 of of IN 13433 523 13 the the DT 13433 523 14 attack attack NN 13433 523 15 , , , 13433 523 16 and and CC 13433 523 17 war war NN 13433 523 18 is be VBZ 13433 523 19 declared declare VBN 13433 523 20 in in IN 13433 523 21 the the DT 13433 523 22 following following JJ 13433 523 23 terms term NNS 13433 523 24 : : : 13433 523 25 " " `` 13433 523 26 The the DT 13433 523 27 reader reader NN 13433 523 28 is be VBZ 13433 523 29 naturally naturally RB 13433 523 30 led lead VBN 13433 523 31 to to TO 13433 523 32 think think VB 13433 523 33 that that IN 13433 523 34 a a DT 13433 523 35 writer writer NN 13433 523 36 would would MD 13433 523 37 not not RB 13433 523 38 use use VB 13433 523 39 such such JJ 13433 523 40 very very RB 13433 523 41 decided decided JJ 13433 523 42 language language NN 13433 523 43 unless unless IN 13433 523 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 523 45 had have VBD 13433 523 46 obtained obtain VBN 13433 523 47 a a DT 13433 523 48 thorough thorough JJ 13433 523 49 mastery mastery NN 13433 523 50 of of IN 13433 523 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 523 52 subject subject NN 13433 523 53 ; ; : 13433 523 54 and and CC 13433 523 55 when when WRB 13433 523 56 he -PRON- PRP 13433 523 57 finds find VBZ 13433 523 58 the the DT 13433 523 59 notes note NNS 13433 523 60 thronged throng VBD 13433 523 61 with with IN 13433 523 62 references reference NNS 13433 523 63 to to IN 13433 523 64 the the DT 13433 523 65 most most RBS 13433 523 66 recondite recondite JJ 13433 523 67 sources source NNS 13433 523 68 of of IN 13433 523 69 information information NN 13433 523 70 , , , 13433 523 71 he -PRON- PRP 13433 523 72 at at IN 13433 523 73 once once RB 13433 523 74 credits credit VBZ 13433 523 75 the the DT 13433 523 76 author author NN 13433 523 77 with with IN 13433 523 78 an an DT 13433 523 79 ' ' `` 13433 523 80 exhaustive exhaustive JJ 13433 523 81 ' ' '' 13433 523 82 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 523 83 of of IN 13433 523 84 the the DT 13433 523 85 literature literature NN 13433 523 86 bearing bear VBG 13433 523 87 upon upon IN 13433 523 88 it -PRON- PRP 13433 523 89 . . . 13433 524 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 524 2 becomes become VBZ 13433 524 3 important important JJ 13433 524 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 524 5 to to TO 13433 524 6 enquire enquire VB 13433 524 7 whether whether IN 13433 524 8 the the DT 13433 524 9 writer writer NN 13433 524 10 shows show VBZ 13433 524 11 that that IN 13433 524 12 accurate accurate JJ 13433 524 13 acquaintance acquaintance NN 13433 524 14 with with IN 13433 524 15 the the DT 13433 524 16 subject subject NN 13433 524 17 , , , 13433 524 18 which which WDT 13433 524 19 justifies justify VBZ 13433 524 20 us -PRON- PRP 13433 524 21 in in IN 13433 524 22 attaching attach VBG 13433 524 23 weight weight NN 13433 524 24 to to IN 13433 524 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 524 26 dicta dicta NN 13433 524 27 as as IN 13433 524 28 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 524 29 from from IN 13433 524 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 524 31 arguments argument NNS 13433 524 32 . . . 13433 524 33 " " '' 13433 525 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 525 2 59:1 59:1 CD 13433 525 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 525 4 This this DT 13433 525 5 sentence sentence NN 13433 525 6 shows show VBZ 13433 525 7 the the DT 13433 525 8 scope scope NN 13433 525 9 of of IN 13433 525 10 the the DT 13433 525 11 discussion discussion NN 13433 525 12 . . . 13433 526 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 526 2 dicta dicta NN 13433 526 3 , , , 13433 526 4 however however RB 13433 526 5 , , , 13433 526 6 play play VB 13433 526 7 a a DT 13433 526 8 very very RB 13433 526 9 subordinate subordinate JJ 13433 526 10 part part NN 13433 526 11 throughout throughout IN 13433 526 12 , , , 13433 526 13 and and CC 13433 526 14 even even RB 13433 526 15 if if IN 13433 526 16 no no DT 13433 526 17 weight weight NN 13433 526 18 be be VB 13433 526 19 attached attach VBN 13433 526 20 to to IN 13433 526 21 them -PRON- PRP 13433 526 22 -- -- : 13433 526 23 and and CC 13433 526 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 526 25 have have VBP 13433 526 26 never never RB 13433 526 27 desired desire VBN 13433 526 28 that that IN 13433 526 29 any any DT 13433 526 30 should should MD 13433 526 31 be be VB 13433 526 32 -- -- . 13433 526 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 526 34 argument argument NN 13433 526 35 would would MD 13433 526 36 not not RB 13433 526 37 be be VB 13433 526 38 in in IN 13433 526 39 the the DT 13433 526 40 least least JJS 13433 526 41 degree degree NN 13433 526 42 affected affect VBN 13433 526 43 . . . 13433 527 1 The the DT 13433 527 2 first first JJ 13433 527 3 point point NN 13433 527 4 attacked attack VBD 13433 527 5 , , , 13433 527 6 like like IN 13433 527 7 most most JJS 13433 527 8 of of IN 13433 527 9 those those DT 13433 527 10 subsequently subsequently RB 13433 527 11 assailed assail VBN 13433 527 12 , , , 13433 527 13 is be VBZ 13433 527 14 one one CD 13433 527 15 of of IN 13433 527 16 mere mere JJ 13433 527 17 critical critical JJ 13433 527 18 history history NN 13433 527 19 . . . 13433 528 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 528 2 wrote write VBD 13433 528 3 : : : 13433 528 4 " " `` 13433 528 5 The the DT 13433 528 6 strongest strong JJS 13433 528 7 internal internal JJ 13433 528 8 , , , 13433 528 9 as as RB 13433 528 10 well well RB 13433 528 11 as as IN 13433 528 12 other other JJ 13433 528 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 528 14 , , , 13433 528 15 into into IN 13433 528 16 which which WDT 13433 528 17 space space NN 13433 528 18 forbids forbid NNS 13433 528 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 528 20 going go VBG 13433 528 21 in in IN 13433 528 22 detail detail NN 13433 528 23 , , , 13433 528 24 has have VBZ 13433 528 25 led lead VBN 13433 528 26 ( ( -LRB- 13433 528 27 1 1 LS 13433 528 28 ) ) -RRB- 13433 528 29 the the DT 13433 528 30 majority majority NN 13433 528 31 of of IN 13433 528 32 critics critic NNS 13433 528 33 to to TO 13433 528 34 recognize recognize VB 13433 528 35 the the DT 13433 528 36 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 528 37 version version NN 13433 528 38 as as IN 13433 528 39 the the DT 13433 528 40 most most RBS 13433 528 41 genuine genuine JJ 13433 528 42 form form NN 13433 528 43 of of IN 13433 528 44 the the DT 13433 528 45 letters letter NNS 13433 528 46 of of IN 13433 528 47 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 528 48 extant extant JJ 13433 528 49 , , , 13433 528 50 and and CC 13433 528 51 ( ( -LRB- 13433 528 52 2 2 LS 13433 528 53 ) ) -RRB- 13433 528 54 this this DT 13433 528 55 is be VBZ 13433 528 56 admitted admit VBN 13433 528 57 by by IN 13433 528 58 most most JJS 13433 528 59 of of IN 13433 528 60 those those DT 13433 528 61 who who WP 13433 528 62 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 528 63 deny deny VBP 13433 528 64 the the DT 13433 528 65 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 528 66 of of IN 13433 528 67 any any DT 13433 528 68 of of IN 13433 528 69 the the DT 13433 528 70 epistles epistle NNS 13433 528 71 . . . 13433 528 72 " " '' 13433 529 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 529 2 59:2 59:2 CD 13433 529 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 529 4 Upon upon IN 13433 529 5 this this DT 13433 529 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 529 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 529 8 remarks:-- remarks:-- VBZ 13433 529 9 " " `` 13433 529 10 No no DT 13433 529 11 statement statement NN 13433 529 12 could could MD 13433 529 13 be be VB 13433 529 14 more more RBR 13433 529 15 erroneous erroneous JJ 13433 529 16 as as IN 13433 529 17 a a DT 13433 529 18 summary summary NN 13433 529 19 of of IN 13433 529 20 the the DT 13433 529 21 results result NNS 13433 529 22 of of IN 13433 529 23 the the DT 13433 529 24 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 529 25 controversy controversy NN 13433 529 26 since since IN 13433 529 27 the the DT 13433 529 28 publication publication NN 13433 529 29 of of IN 13433 529 30 the the DT 13433 529 31 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 529 32 epistles epistle NNS 13433 529 33 than than IN 13433 529 34 this this DT 13433 529 35 . . . 13433 529 36 " " '' 13433 530 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 530 2 59:1 59:1 CD 13433 530 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 530 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 530 5 will will MD 13433 530 6 be be VB 13433 530 7 admitted admit VBN 13433 530 8 that that IN 13433 530 9 this this DT 13433 530 10 is be VBZ 13433 530 11 pretty pretty RB 13433 530 12 " " `` 13433 530 13 decided decided JJ 13433 530 14 language language NN 13433 530 15 " " '' 13433 530 16 for for IN 13433 530 17 one one CD 13433 530 18 who who WP 13433 530 19 is be VBZ 13433 530 20 preaching preach VBG 13433 530 21 " " `` 13433 530 22 diffidence diffidence NN 13433 530 23 . . . 13433 530 24 " " '' 13433 531 1 When when WRB 13433 531 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 531 3 come come VBP 13433 531 4 to to IN 13433 531 5 details detail NNS 13433 531 6 , , , 13433 531 7 however however RB 13433 531 8 , , , 13433 531 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 531 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 531 11 admits admit VBZ 13433 531 12 : : : 13433 531 13 " " `` 13433 531 14 Those those DT 13433 531 15 who who WP 13433 531 16 maintain maintain VBP 13433 531 17 the the DT 13433 531 18 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 531 19 of of IN 13433 531 20 the the DT 13433 531 21 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 531 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 531 23 in in IN 13433 531 24 one one CD 13433 531 25 or or CC 13433 531 26 other other JJ 13433 531 27 of of IN 13433 531 28 the the DT 13433 531 29 two two CD 13433 531 30 forms form NNS 13433 531 31 , , , 13433 531 32 may may MD 13433 531 33 be be VB 13433 531 34 said say VBN 13433 531 35 to to TO 13433 531 36 be be VB 13433 531 37 almost almost RB 13433 531 38 evenly evenly RB 13433 531 39 divided divide VBN 13433 531 40 on on IN 13433 531 41 this this DT 13433 531 42 question question NN 13433 531 43 of of IN 13433 531 44 priority priority NN 13433 531 45 . . . 13433 531 46 " " '' 13433 532 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 532 2 seems seem VBZ 13433 532 3 to to TO 13433 532 4 consider consider VB 13433 532 5 that that IN 13433 532 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 532 7 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 532 8 shows show VBZ 13433 532 9 this this DT 13433 532 10 when when WRB 13433 532 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 532 12 mentions mention VBZ 13433 532 13 five five CD 13433 532 14 or or CC 13433 532 15 six six CD 13433 532 16 critics critic NNS 13433 532 17 on on IN 13433 532 18 either either DT 13433 532 19 side side NN 13433 532 20 ; ; : 13433 532 21 but but CC 13433 532 22 even even RB 13433 532 23 on on IN 13433 532 24 this this DT 13433 532 25 modified modify VBN 13433 532 26 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 532 27 of of IN 13433 532 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 532 29 statement statement NN 13433 532 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 532 31 correctness correctness NN 13433 532 32 may may MD 13433 532 33 be be VB 13433 532 34 literally literally RB 13433 532 35 maintained maintain VBN 13433 532 36 . . . 13433 533 1 To to IN 13433 533 2 the the DT 13433 533 3 five five CD 13433 533 4 names name NNS 13433 533 5 quoted quote VBN 13433 533 6 as as IN 13433 533 7 recognising recognise VBG 13433 533 8 the the DT 13433 533 9 priority priority NN 13433 533 10 of of IN 13433 533 11 the the DT 13433 533 12 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 533 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 533 14 may may MD 13433 533 15 be be VB 13433 533 16 added add VBN 13433 533 17 those those DT 13433 533 18 of of IN 13433 533 19 Milman Milman NNP 13433 533 20 , , , 13433 533 21 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 13433 533 22 , , , 13433 533 23 de de NNP 13433 533 24 Pressensé Pressensé NNP 13433 533 25 , , , 13433 533 26 and and CC 13433 533 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 533 28 Tregelles Tregelles NNP 13433 533 29 , , , 13433 533 30 which which WDT 13433 533 31 immediately immediately RB 13433 533 32 occur occur VBP 13433 533 33 to to IN 13433 533 34 me -PRON- PRP 13433 533 35 . . . 13433 534 1 But but CC 13433 534 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 534 3 must must MD 13433 534 4 ask ask VB 13433 534 5 upon upon IN 13433 534 6 what what WP 13433 534 7 ground ground NN 13433 534 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 534 9 limits limit VBZ 13433 534 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 534 11 remark remark NN 13433 534 12 to to IN 13433 534 13 those those DT 13433 534 14 who who WP 13433 534 15 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 534 16 admit admit VBP 13433 534 17 the the DT 13433 534 18 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 534 19 ? ? . 13433 535 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 535 2 certainly certainly RB 13433 535 3 do do VBP 13433 535 4 not not RB 13433 535 5 so so RB 13433 535 6 limit limit VB 13433 535 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 535 8 , , , 13433 535 9 but but CC 13433 535 10 affirm affirm VB 13433 535 11 that that IN 13433 535 12 a a DT 13433 535 13 majority majority NN 13433 535 14 prefer prefer VBP 13433 535 15 the the DT 13433 535 16 three three CD 13433 535 17 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 535 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 535 19 , , , 13433 535 20 and and CC 13433 535 21 that that IN 13433 535 22 this this DT 13433 535 23 majority majority NN 13433 535 24 is be VBZ 13433 535 25 made make VBN 13433 535 26 up up RP 13433 535 27 partly partly RB 13433 535 28 of of IN 13433 535 29 those those DT 13433 535 30 who who WP 13433 535 31 , , , 13433 535 32 denying deny VBG 13433 535 33 the the DT 13433 535 34 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 535 35 of of IN 13433 535 36 any any DT 13433 535 37 of of IN 13433 535 38 the the DT 13433 535 39 letters letter NNS 13433 535 40 , , , 13433 535 41 still still RB 13433 535 42 consider consider VB 13433 535 43 the the DT 13433 535 44 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 535 45 the the DT 13433 535 46 purest pure JJS 13433 535 47 and and CC 13433 535 48 least least JJS 13433 535 49 adulterated adulterate VBN 13433 535 50 form form NN 13433 535 51 of of IN 13433 535 52 the the DT 13433 535 53 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 535 54 . . . 13433 536 1 This this DT 13433 536 2 will will MD 13433 536 3 be be VB 13433 536 4 evident evident JJ 13433 536 5 to to IN 13433 536 6 anyone anyone NN 13433 536 7 who who WP 13433 536 8 reads read VBZ 13433 536 9 the the DT 13433 536 10 context context NN 13433 536 11 . . . 13433 537 1 With with IN 13433 537 2 regard regard NN 13433 537 3 to to IN 13433 537 4 the the DT 13433 537 5 latter latter JJ 13433 537 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 537 7 2 2 LS 13433 537 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 537 9 part part NN 13433 537 10 of of IN 13433 537 11 the the DT 13433 537 12 sentence sentence NN 13433 537 13 , , , 13433 537 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 537 15 will will MD 13433 537 16 at at IN 13433 537 17 once once RB 13433 537 18 say say VB 13433 537 19 that that IN 13433 537 20 " " `` 13433 537 21 most most JJS 13433 537 22 " " '' 13433 537 23 is be VBZ 13433 537 24 a a DT 13433 537 25 slip slip NN 13433 537 26 of of IN 13433 537 27 the the DT 13433 537 28 pen pen NN 13433 537 29 for for IN 13433 537 30 " " `` 13433 537 31 many many JJ 13433 537 32 , , , 13433 537 33 " " '' 13433 537 34 which which WDT 13433 537 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 537 36 correct correct VBP 13433 537 37 in in IN 13433 537 38 this this DT 13433 537 39 edition edition NN 13433 537 40 . . . 13433 538 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 538 2 60:1 60:1 CD 13433 538 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 538 4 Many many JJ 13433 538 5 of of IN 13433 538 6 those those DT 13433 538 7 who who WP 13433 538 8 deny deny VBP 13433 538 9 or or CC 13433 538 10 do do VBP 13433 538 11 not not RB 13433 538 12 admit admit VB 13433 538 13 the the DT 13433 538 14 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 538 15 prefer prefer VB 13433 538 16 the the DT 13433 538 17 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 538 18 version version NN 13433 538 19 . . . 13433 539 1 The the DT 13433 539 2 Tübingen Tübingen NNP 13433 539 3 school school NN 13433 539 4 are be VBP 13433 539 5 not not RB 13433 539 6 unanimous unanimous JJ 13433 539 7 on on IN 13433 539 8 the the DT 13433 539 9 point point NN 13433 539 10 , , , 13433 539 11 and and CC 13433 539 12 there there EX 13433 539 13 are be VBP 13433 539 14 critics critic NNS 13433 539 15 who who WP 13433 539 16 do do VBP 13433 539 17 not not RB 13433 539 18 belong belong VB 13433 539 19 to to IN 13433 539 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 539 21 . . . 13433 540 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 540 2 , , , 13433 540 3 for for IN 13433 540 4 instance instance NN 13433 540 5 , , , 13433 540 6 who who WP 13433 540 7 does do VBZ 13433 540 8 not not RB 13433 540 9 commit commit VB 13433 540 10 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 540 11 to to IN 13433 540 12 belief belief NN 13433 540 13 , , , 13433 540 14 considers consider VBZ 13433 540 15 the the DT 13433 540 16 priority priority NN 13433 540 17 of of IN 13433 540 18 the the DT 13433 540 19 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 540 20 " " `` 13433 540 21 i -PRON- PRP 13433 540 22 m be VBP 13433 540 23 höchsten höchsten VBD 13433 540 24 Grade Grade NNP 13433 540 25 wahrscheinlich wahrscheinlich RB 13433 540 26 . . . 13433 540 27 " " '' 13433 541 1 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 541 2 , , , 13433 541 3 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 541 4 , , , 13433 541 5 and and CC 13433 541 6 Rumpf Rumpf NNP 13433 541 7 prefer prefer VBP 13433 541 8 them -PRON- PRP 13433 541 9 . . . 13433 542 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 542 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 542 3 says say VBZ 13433 542 4 : : : 13433 542 5 " " `` 13433 542 6 The the DT 13433 542 7 case case NN 13433 542 8 of of IN 13433 542 9 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 542 10 is be VBZ 13433 542 11 especially especially RB 13433 542 12 instructive instructive JJ 13433 542 13 , , , 13433 542 14 as as IN 13433 542 15 illustrating illustrate VBG 13433 542 16 this this DT 13433 542 17 point point NN 13433 542 18 . . . 13433 543 1 Having have VBG 13433 543 2 at at IN 13433 543 3 one one CD 13433 543 4 time time NN 13433 543 5 maintained maintain VBD 13433 543 6 the the DT 13433 543 7 priority priority NN 13433 543 8 and and CC 13433 543 9 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 543 10 of of IN 13433 543 11 the the DT 13433 543 12 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 543 13 letters letter NNS 13433 543 14 , , , 13433 543 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 543 16 has have VBZ 13433 543 17 lately lately RB 13433 543 18 , , , 13433 543 19 if if IN 13433 543 20 I -PRON- PRP 13433 543 21 rightly rightly RB 13433 543 22 understand understand VBP 13433 543 23 him -PRON- PRP 13433 543 24 , , , 13433 543 25 retracted retract VBD 13433 543 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 543 27 former former JJ 13433 543 28 opinion opinion NN 13433 543 29 on on IN 13433 543 30 both both DT 13433 543 31 questions question NNS 13433 543 32 alike alike RB 13433 543 33 . . . 13433 543 34 " " '' 13433 544 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 544 2 60:2 60:2 CD 13433 544 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 544 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 544 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 544 6 , , , 13433 544 7 however however RB 13433 544 8 , , , 13433 544 9 has have VBZ 13433 544 10 not not RB 13433 544 11 , , , 13433 544 12 rightly rightly RB 13433 544 13 understood understand VBD 13433 544 14 him -PRON- PRP 13433 544 15 . . . 13433 545 1 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 545 2 has have VBZ 13433 545 3 only only RB 13433 545 4 withdrawn withdraw VBN 13433 545 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 545 6 opinion opinion NN 13433 545 7 that that IN 13433 545 8 the the DT 13433 545 9 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 545 10 letters letter NNS 13433 545 11 are be VBP 13433 545 12 authentic authentic JJ 13433 545 13 , , , 13433 545 14 but but CC 13433 545 15 , , , 13433 545 16 whilst whilst IN 13433 545 17 now now RB 13433 545 18 asserting assert VBG 13433 545 19 that that IN 13433 545 20 in in IN 13433 545 21 all all DT 13433 545 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 545 23 forms form NNS 13433 545 24 the the DT 13433 545 25 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 545 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 545 27 are be VBP 13433 545 28 spurious spurious JJ 13433 545 29 , , , 13433 545 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 545 31 still still RB 13433 545 32 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 545 33 the the DT 13433 545 34 priority priority NN 13433 545 35 of of IN 13433 545 36 the the DT 13433 545 37 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 545 38 version version NN 13433 545 39 . . . 13433 546 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 546 2 first first RB 13433 546 3 announced announce VBD 13433 546 4 this this DT 13433 546 5 change change NN 13433 546 6 of of IN 13433 546 7 view view NN 13433 546 8 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 546 9 in in IN 13433 546 10 1873 1873 CD 13433 546 11 , , , 13433 546 12 when when WRB 13433 546 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 546 14 added add VBD 13433 546 15 : : : 13433 546 16 " " `` 13433 546 17 An an DT 13433 546 18 dem dem JJ 13433 546 19 relativ relativ NN 13433 546 20 grössern grössern NNP 13433 546 21 Alter Alter NNP 13433 546 22 der der NNP 13433 546 23 syrischen syrischen NNP 13433 546 24 Textgestalt Textgestalt NNP 13433 546 25 gegenüber gegenüber NNP 13433 546 26 der der IN 13433 546 27 kürzeren kürzeren NNP 13433 546 28 griechischen griechischen NNP 13433 546 29 halte halte NNP 13433 546 30 ich ich NNP 13433 546 31 übrigens übrigens NNP 13433 546 32 nach nach NNP 13433 546 33 wie wie NNP 13433 546 34 vor vor NNP 13433 546 35 fest f JJS 13433 546 36 . . . 13433 546 37 " " '' 13433 547 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 547 2 61:1 61:1 CD 13433 547 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 547 4 In in IN 13433 547 5 the the DT 13433 547 6 very very JJ 13433 547 7 paper paper NN 13433 547 8 to to TO 13433 547 9 which which WDT 13433 547 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 547 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 547 12 refers refer VBZ 13433 547 13 , , , 13433 547 14 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 547 15 also also RB 13433 547 16 again again RB 13433 547 17 says say VBZ 13433 547 18 quite quite RB 13433 547 19 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 547 20 : : : 13433 547 21 " " `` 13433 547 22 Ich Ich NNP 13433 547 23 bin bin NNP 13433 547 24 noch noch NNP 13433 547 25 jetzt jetzt NNP 13433 547 26 überzeugt überzeugt NNP 13433 547 27 , , , 13433 547 28 dass dass NNP 13433 547 29 der der NNP 13433 547 30 Syrer Syrer NNP 13433 547 31 in in IN 13433 547 32 zahlreichen zahlreichen NNP 13433 547 33 Fällen Fällen NNP 13433 547 34 den den NN 13433 547 35 relativ relativ NN 13433 547 36 ursprünglichsten ursprünglichsten VBP 13433 547 37 Text Text NNP 13433 547 38 bewahrt bewahrt NN 13433 547 39 hat hat NN 13433 547 40 ( ( -LRB- 13433 547 41 vgl vgl NNP 13433 547 42 . . . 13433 548 1 meine meine NNP 13433 548 2 Nachweise Nachweise NNP 13433 548 3 in in IN 13433 548 4 ' ' '' 13433 548 5 Niedner Niedner NNP 13433 548 6 's 's POS 13433 548 7 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 548 8 . . . 13433 548 9 ' ' '' 13433 549 1 S. S. NNP 13433 550 1 15ff 15ff NNP 13433 550 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 550 3 . . . 13433 550 4 " " '' 13433 551 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 551 2 61:2 61:2 CD 13433 551 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 551 4 With with IN 13433 551 5 regard regard NN 13433 551 6 to to IN 13433 551 7 the the DT 13433 551 8 whole whole NN 13433 551 9 of of IN 13433 551 10 this this DT 13433 551 11 ( ( -LRB- 13433 551 12 2 2 LS 13433 551 13 ) ) -RRB- 13433 551 14 point point NN 13433 551 15 , , , 13433 551 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 551 17 must must MD 13433 551 18 be be VB 13433 551 19 remembered remember VBN 13433 551 20 that that IN 13433 551 21 the the DT 13433 551 22 only only JJ 13433 551 23 matter matter NN 13433 551 24 in in IN 13433 551 25 question question NN 13433 551 26 is be VBZ 13433 551 27 simply simply RB 13433 551 28 a a DT 13433 551 29 shade shade NN 13433 551 30 of of IN 13433 551 31 opinion opinion NN 13433 551 32 amongst amongst IN 13433 551 33 critics critic NNS 13433 551 34 who who WP 13433 551 35 deny deny VBP 13433 551 36 the the DT 13433 551 37 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 551 38 of of IN 13433 551 39 the the DT 13433 551 40 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 551 41 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 551 42 in in IN 13433 551 43 all all DT 13433 551 44 forms form NNS 13433 551 45 . . . 13433 552 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 552 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 552 3 , , , 13433 552 4 however however RB 13433 552 5 , , , 13433 552 6 goes go VBZ 13433 552 7 on on IN 13433 552 8 " " `` 13433 552 9 to to TO 13433 552 10 throw throw VB 13433 552 11 some some DT 13433 552 12 light light NN 13433 552 13 upon upon IN 13433 552 14 this this DT 13433 552 15 point point NN 13433 552 16 " " '' 13433 552 17 by by IN 13433 552 18 analysing analyse VBG 13433 552 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 552 20 " " `` 13433 552 21 general general JJ 13433 552 22 statement statement NN 13433 552 23 of of IN 13433 552 24 the the DT 13433 552 25 course course NN 13433 552 26 of of IN 13433 552 27 opinion opinion NN 13433 552 28 on on IN 13433 552 29 this this DT 13433 552 30 subject subject NN 13433 552 31 given give VBN 13433 552 32 in in IN 13433 552 33 an an DT 13433 552 34 earlier early JJR 13433 552 35 passage passage NN 13433 552 36 . . . 13433 552 37 " " '' 13433 553 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 553 2 61:3 61:3 CD 13433 553 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 553 4 The the DT 13433 553 5 " " `` 13433 553 6 light light NN 13433 553 7 " " '' 13433 553 8 which which WDT 13433 553 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 553 10 throws throw VBZ 13433 553 11 seems seem VBZ 13433 553 12 to to TO 13433 553 13 pass pass VB 13433 553 14 through through RP 13433 553 15 so so RB 13433 553 16 peculiar peculiar RB 13433 553 17 a a DT 13433 553 18 medium medium NN 13433 553 19 , , , 13433 553 20 that that IN 13433 553 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 553 22 should should MD 13433 553 23 be be VB 13433 553 24 much much RB 13433 553 25 rather rather RB 13433 553 26 tempted tempt VBN 13433 553 27 to to TO 13433 553 28 call call VB 13433 553 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 553 30 darkness darkness NN 13433 553 31 . . . 13433 554 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 554 2 beg beg VBP 13433 554 3 the the DT 13433 554 4 reader reader NN 13433 554 5 to to TO 13433 554 6 favour favour VB 13433 554 7 me -PRON- PRP 13433 554 8 with with IN 13433 554 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 554 10 attention attention NN 13433 554 11 to to IN 13433 554 12 this this DT 13433 554 13 matter matter NN 13433 554 14 , , , 13433 554 15 for for IN 13433 554 16 here here RB 13433 554 17 commences commence VBZ 13433 554 18 a a DT 13433 554 19 serious serious JJ 13433 554 20 attack attack NN 13433 554 21 upon upon IN 13433 554 22 the the DT 13433 554 23 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 554 24 of of IN 13433 554 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 554 26 notes note NNS 13433 554 27 and and CC 13433 554 28 statements statement NNS 13433 554 29 , , , 13433 554 30 which which WDT 13433 554 31 is be VBZ 13433 554 32 singularly singularly RB 13433 554 33 full full JJ 13433 554 34 of of IN 13433 554 35 error error NN 13433 554 36 and and CC 13433 554 37 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 554 38 . . . 13433 555 1 The the DT 13433 555 2 general general JJ 13433 555 3 statement statement NN 13433 555 4 referred refer VBD 13433 555 5 to to IN 13433 555 6 and and CC 13433 555 7 quoted quote VBN 13433 555 8 is be VBZ 13433 555 9 as as IN 13433 555 10 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 13433 555 11 " " `` 13433 555 12 These these DT 13433 555 13 three three CD 13433 555 14 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 555 15 epistles epistle NNS 13433 555 16 have have VBP 13433 555 17 been be VBN 13433 555 18 subjected subject VBN 13433 555 19 to to IN 13433 555 20 the the DT 13433 555 21 severest severe JJS 13433 555 22 scrutiny scrutiny NN 13433 555 23 , , , 13433 555 24 and and CC 13433 555 25 many many JJ 13433 555 26 of of IN 13433 555 27 the the DT 13433 555 28 ablest able JJS 13433 555 29 critics critic NNS 13433 555 30 have have VBP 13433 555 31 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 555 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 555 33 to to TO 13433 555 34 be be VB 13433 555 35 the the DT 13433 555 36 only only JJ 13433 555 37 authentic authentic JJ 13433 555 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 555 39 of of IN 13433 555 40 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 555 41 , , , 13433 555 42 whilst whilst IN 13433 555 43 others other NNS 13433 555 44 , , , 13433 555 45 who who WP 13433 555 46 do do VBP 13433 555 47 not not RB 13433 555 48 admit admit VB 13433 555 49 that that IN 13433 555 50 even even RB 13433 555 51 these these DT 13433 555 52 are be VBP 13433 555 53 genuine genuine JJ 13433 555 54 letters letter NNS 13433 555 55 emanating emanate VBG 13433 555 56 from from IN 13433 555 57 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 555 58 , , , 13433 555 59 prefer prefer VB 13433 555 60 them -PRON- PRP 13433 555 61 to to IN 13433 555 62 the the DT 13433 555 63 version version NN 13433 555 64 of of IN 13433 555 65 seven seven CD 13433 555 66 Greek greek JJ 13433 555 67 epistles epistle NNS 13433 555 68 , , , 13433 555 69 and and CC 13433 555 70 consider consider VB 13433 555 71 them -PRON- PRP 13433 555 72 the the DT 13433 555 73 most most RBS 13433 555 74 ancient ancient JJ 13433 555 75 form form NN 13433 555 76 of of IN 13433 555 77 the the DT 13433 555 78 letters letter NNS 13433 555 79 which which WDT 13433 555 80 we -PRON- PRP 13433 555 81 possess possess VBP 13433 555 82 . . . 13433 556 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 556 2 1 1 LS 13433 556 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 556 4 As as RB 13433 556 5 early early RB 13433 556 6 as as IN 13433 556 7 the the DT 13433 556 8 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 13433 556 9 century century NN 13433 556 10 , , , 13433 556 11 however however RB 13433 556 12 , , , 13433 556 13 the the DT 13433 556 14 strongest strong JJS 13433 556 15 doubts doubt NNS 13433 556 16 were be VBD 13433 556 17 expressed express VBN 13433 556 18 regarding regard VBG 13433 556 19 the the DT 13433 556 20 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 556 21 of of IN 13433 556 22 any any DT 13433 556 23 of of IN 13433 556 24 the the DT 13433 556 25 epistles epistle NNS 13433 556 26 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 556 27 to to IN 13433 556 28 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 556 29 . . . 13433 557 1 The the DT 13433 557 2 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 13433 557 3 Centuriators Centuriators NNP 13433 557 4 first first RB 13433 557 5 attacked attack VBD 13433 557 6 them -PRON- PRP 13433 557 7 , , , 13433 557 8 and and CC 13433 557 9 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 557 10 declared declare VBD 13433 557 11 ( ( -LRB- 13433 557 12 p. p. NN 13433 557 13 260 260 CD 13433 557 14 ) ) -RRB- 13433 557 15 them -PRON- PRP 13433 557 16 to to TO 13433 557 17 be be VB 13433 557 18 spurious,[^1 spurious,[^1 CD 13433 557 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 557 20 an an DT 13433 557 21 opinion opinion NN 13433 557 22 fully fully RB 13433 557 23 shared share VBN 13433 557 24 by by IN 13433 557 25 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 557 26 , , , 13433 557 27 Dallaeus Dallaeus NNP 13433 557 28 , , , 13433 557 29 and and CC 13433 557 30 others other NNS 13433 557 31 ; ; : 13433 557 32 and and CC 13433 557 33 similar similar JJ 13433 557 34 doubts doubt NNS 13433 557 35 , , , 13433 557 36 more more RBR 13433 557 37 or or CC 13433 557 38 less less RBR 13433 557 39 definite definite JJ 13433 557 40 , , , 13433 557 41 were be VBD 13433 557 42 expressed express VBN 13433 557 43 throughout throughout IN 13433 557 44 the the DT 13433 557 45 seventeenth seventeenth JJ 13433 557 46 century,(2 century,(2 NNS 13433 557 47 ) ) -RRB- 13433 557 48 and and CC 13433 557 49 onward onward RB 13433 557 50 to to IN 13433 557 51 comparatively comparatively RB 13433 557 52 recent recent JJ 13433 557 53 times,(3 times,(3 NN 13433 557 54 ) ) -RRB- 13433 557 55 although although IN 13433 557 56 the the DT 13433 557 57 means mean NNS 13433 557 58 of of IN 13433 557 59 forming form VBG 13433 557 60 a a DT 13433 557 61 judgment judgment NN 13433 557 62 were be VBD 13433 557 63 not not RB 13433 557 64 then then RB 13433 557 65 so so RB 13433 557 66 complete complete JJ 13433 557 67 as as IN 13433 557 68 now now RB 13433 557 69 . . . 13433 558 1 That that IN 13433 558 2 the the DT 13433 558 3 epistles epistle NNS 13433 558 4 were be VBD 13433 558 5 interpolated interpolate VBN 13433 558 6 there there EX 13433 558 7 was be VBD 13433 558 8 no no DT 13433 558 9 doubt doubt NN 13433 558 10 . . . 13433 559 1 Fuller full JJR 13433 559 2 examination examination NN 13433 559 3 and and CC 13433 559 4 more more RBR 13433 559 5 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 13433 559 6 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 559 7 of of IN 13433 559 8 the the DT 13433 559 9 subject subject NN 13433 559 10 have have VBP 13433 559 11 confirmed confirm VBN 13433 559 12 earlier early JJR 13433 559 13 doubts doubt NNS 13433 559 14 , , , 13433 559 15 and and CC 13433 559 16 a a DT 13433 559 17 large large JJ 13433 559 18 mass mass NN 13433 559 19 of of IN 13433 559 20 critics critic NNS 13433 559 21 recognise recognise VBP 13433 559 22 that that IN 13433 559 23 the the DT 13433 559 24 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 559 25 of of IN 13433 559 26 none none NN 13433 559 27 of of IN 13433 559 28 these these DT 13433 559 29 epistles epistle NNS 13433 559 30 can can MD 13433 559 31 be be VB 13433 559 32 established establish VBN 13433 559 33 , , , 13433 559 34 and and CC 13433 559 35 that that IN 13433 559 36 they -PRON- PRP 13433 559 37 can can MD 13433 559 38 only only RB 13433 559 39 be be VB 13433 559 40 considered consider VBN 13433 559 41 later later RB 13433 559 42 and and CC 13433 559 43 spurious spurious JJ 13433 559 44 compositions composition NNS 13433 559 45 . . . 13433 560 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 560 2 4 4 LS 13433 560 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 560 4 " " '' 13433 560 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 560 6 62:1 62:1 CD 13433 560 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 560 8 In in IN 13433 560 9 the the DT 13433 560 10 first first JJ 13433 560 11 note note NN 13433 560 12 ( ( -LRB- 13433 560 13 1 1 CD 13433 560 14 ) ) -RRB- 13433 560 15 on on IN 13433 560 16 p. p. NN 13433 560 17 259 259 CD 13433 560 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 560 19 referred refer VBD 13433 560 20 to to IN 13433 560 21 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 560 22 , , , 13433 560 23 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 560 24 , , , 13433 560 25 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 13433 560 26 , , , 13433 560 27 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 560 28 , , , 13433 560 29 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 560 30 , , , 13433 560 31 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 560 32 , , , 13433 560 33 Milman Milman NNP 13433 560 34 , , , 13433 560 35 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 13433 560 36 , , , 13433 560 37 and and CC 13433 560 38 Weiss Weiss NNP 13433 560 39 , , , 13433 560 40 and and CC 13433 560 41 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 560 42 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 560 43 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 560 44 to to TO 13433 560 45 analyse analyse VB 13433 560 46 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 560 47 statements statement NNS 13433 560 48 as as IN 13433 560 49 follows follow VBZ 13433 560 50 : : : 13433 560 51 and and CC 13433 560 52 I -PRON- PRP 13433 560 53 at at IN 13433 560 54 once once RB 13433 560 55 put put VBD 13433 560 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 560 57 explanation explanation NN 13433 560 58 and and CC 13433 560 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 560 60 text text NN 13433 560 61 in in IN 13433 560 62 parallel parallel JJ 13433 560 63 columns column NNS 13433 560 64 , , , 13433 560 65 italicising italicise VBG 13433 560 66 parts part NNS 13433 560 67 of of IN 13433 560 68 both both DT 13433 560 69 to to TO 13433 560 70 call call VB 13433 560 71 more more RBR 13433 560 72 immediate immediate JJ 13433 560 73 attention attention NN 13433 560 74 to to IN 13433 560 75 the the DT 13433 560 76 point point NN 13433 560 77 : : : 13433 560 78 THE the DT 13433 560 79 TRUTH truth NN 13433 560 80 . . . 13433 561 1 | | NNP 13433 561 2 DR DR NNP 13433 561 3 . . . 13433 561 4 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 561 5 'S 's POS 13433 561 6 STATEMENT statement NN 13433 561 7 . . . 13433 562 1 | | NNP 13433 562 2 _ _ NNP 13433 562 3 Many many JJ 13433 562 4 of of IN 13433 562 5 the the DT 13433 562 6 ablest able JJS 13433 562 7 critics critic NNS 13433 562 8 have have VBP 13433 562 9 | | CD 13433 562 10 " " `` 13433 562 11 These these DT 13433 562 12 references reference NNS 13433 562 13 , , , 13433 562 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 562 15 will will MD 13433 562 16 be be VB 13433 562 17 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 562 18 them -PRON- PRP 13433 562 19 to to TO 13433 562 20 be be VB 13433 562 21 the the DT 13433 562 22 only only JJ 13433 562 23 | | CD 13433 562 24 observed observe VBN 13433 562 25 , , , 13433 562 26 are be VBP 13433 562 27 given give VBN 13433 562 28 to to TO 13433 562 29 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 562 30 authentic authentic JJ 13433 562 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 562 32 of of IN 13433 562 33 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 562 34 , , , 13433 562 35 | | NNP 13433 562 36 _ _ NNP 13433 562 37 more more RBR 13433 562 38 immediately immediately RB 13433 562 39 _ _ NNP 13433 562 40 , , , 13433 562 41 though though IN 13433 562 42 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 562 43 whilst whilst IN 13433 562 44 others other NNS 13433 562 45 _ _ IN 13433 562 46 who who WP 13433 562 47 do do VBP 13433 562 48 not not RB 13433 562 49 admit admit VB 13433 562 50 | | NNP 13433 562 51 not not RB 13433 562 52 solely solely RB 13433 562 53 , , , 13433 562 54 the the DT 13433 562 55 statement statement NN 13433 562 56 that that IN 13433 562 57 that that IN 13433 562 58 even even RB 13433 562 59 these these DT 13433 562 60 are be VBP 13433 562 61 genuine genuine JJ 13433 562 62 letters letter NNS 13433 562 63 | | NNS 13433 562 64 writers writer NNS 13433 562 65 ' ' '' 13433 562 66 _ _ NN 13433 562 67 who who WP 13433 562 68 do do VBP 13433 562 69 not not RB 13433 562 70 admit admit VB 13433 562 71 that that IN 13433 562 72 emanating emanate VBG 13433 562 73 from from IN 13433 562 74 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 562 75 , , , 13433 562 76 _ _ NNP 13433 562 77 still still RB 13433 562 78 | | : 13433 562 79 even even RB 13433 562 80 these these DT 13433 562 81 _ _ NNP 13433 562 82 ( ( -LRB- 13433 562 83 the the DT 13433 562 84 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 562 85 prefer prefer VBP 13433 562 86 them -PRON- PRP 13433 562 87 _ _ RP 13433 562 88 to to IN 13433 562 89 the the DT 13433 562 90 version version NN 13433 562 91 of of IN 13433 562 92 | | NNP 13433 562 93 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 562 94 ) ) -RRB- 13433 562 95 _ _ NNP 13433 562 96 are be VBP 13433 562 97 genuine genuine JJ 13433 562 98 letters letter NNS 13433 562 99 seven seven CD 13433 562 100 Greek Greek NNP 13433 562 101 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 562 102 , , , 13433 562 103 _ _ NNP 13433 562 104 and and CC 13433 562 105 consider consider VB 13433 562 106 | | NNP 13433 562 107 emanating emanate VBG 13433 562 108 from from IN 13433 562 109 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 562 110 , , , 13433 562 111 still still RB 13433 562 112 them -PRON- PRP 13433 562 113 the the DT 13433 562 114 most most RBS 13433 562 115 ancient ancient JJ 13433 562 116 form form NN 13433 562 117 of of IN 13433 562 118 the the DT 13433 562 119 | | NNS 13433 562 120 prefer prefer VBP 13433 562 121 them -PRON- PRP 13433 562 122 _ _ RP 13433 562 123 to to IN 13433 562 124 the the DT 13433 562 125 version version NN 13433 562 126 of of IN 13433 562 127 letters letter NNS 13433 562 128 _ _ IN 13433 562 129 which which WDT 13433 562 130 we -PRON- PRP 13433 562 131 possess possess VBP 13433 562 132 . . . 13433 563 1 | | CD 13433 563 2 seven seven CD 13433 563 3 Greek Greek NNP 13433 563 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 563 5 , , , 13433 563 6 and and CC 13433 563 7 consider consider VB 13433 563 8 | | NNP 13433 563 9 them -PRON- PRP 13433 563 10 the the DT 13433 563 11 most most RBS 13433 563 12 ancient ancient JJ 13433 563 13 form form NN 13433 563 14 of of IN 13433 563 15 the the DT 13433 563 16 | | CD 13433 563 17 letters letter NNS 13433 563 18 which which WDT 13433 563 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 563 20 possess possess VBP 13433 563 21 . . . 13433 563 22 ' ' '' 13433 563 23 " " '' 13433 564 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 564 2 62:2 62:2 CD 13433 564 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 564 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 564 5 must must MD 13433 564 6 be be VB 13433 564 7 evident evident JJ 13433 564 8 to to IN 13433 564 9 anyone anyone NN 13433 564 10 who who WP 13433 564 11 reads read VBZ 13433 564 12 the the DT 13433 564 13 context context NN 13433 564 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 564 15 62:3 62:3 CD 13433 564 16 ] ] -RRB- 13433 564 17 that that IN 13433 564 18 in in IN 13433 564 19 this this DT 13433 564 20 sentence sentence NN 13433 564 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 564 22 am be VBP 13433 564 23 stating state VBG 13433 564 24 opinions opinion NNS 13433 564 25 expressed express VBN 13433 564 26 in in IN 13433 564 27 favour favour NN 13433 564 28 of of IN 13433 564 29 the the DT 13433 564 30 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 564 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 564 32 , , , 13433 564 33 and and CC 13433 564 34 that that IN 13433 564 35 the the DT 13433 564 36 note note NN 13433 564 37 , , , 13433 564 38 which which WDT 13433 564 39 is be VBZ 13433 564 40 naturally naturally RB 13433 564 41 put put VBN 13433 564 42 at at IN 13433 564 43 the the DT 13433 564 44 end end NN 13433 564 45 of of IN 13433 564 46 that that DT 13433 564 47 sentence sentence NN 13433 564 48 , , , 13433 564 49 must must MD 13433 564 50 be be VB 13433 564 51 intended intend VBN 13433 564 52 to to TO 13433 564 53 represent represent VB 13433 564 54 this this DT 13433 564 55 favourable favourable JJ 13433 564 56 opinion opinion NN 13433 564 57 , , , 13433 564 58 whether whether IN 13433 564 59 of of IN 13433 564 60 those those DT 13433 564 61 who who WP 13433 564 62 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 564 63 maintain maintain VBP 13433 564 64 the the DT 13433 564 65 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 564 66 or or CC 13433 564 67 merely merely RB 13433 564 68 the the DT 13433 564 69 relative relative JJ 13433 564 70 priority priority NN 13433 564 71 . . . 13433 565 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 565 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 565 3 quietly quietly RB 13433 565 4 suppresses suppress VBZ 13433 565 5 , , , 13433 565 6 in in IN 13433 565 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 565 8 comments comment NNS 13433 565 9 , , , 13433 565 10 the the DT 13433 565 11 main main JJ 13433 565 12 statement statement NN 13433 565 13 of of IN 13433 565 14 the the DT 13433 565 15 text text NN 13433 565 16 which which WDT 13433 565 17 the the DT 13433 565 18 note note NN 13433 565 19 illustrates illustrate VBZ 13433 565 20 , , , 13433 565 21 and and CC 13433 565 22 then then RB 13433 565 23 " " `` 13433 565 24 throws throw VBZ 13433 565 25 light light NN 13433 565 26 " " '' 13433 565 27 upon upon IN 13433 565 28 the the DT 13433 565 29 point point NN 13433 565 30 by by IN 13433 565 31 the the DT 13433 565 32 following follow VBG 13433 565 33 remarks:-- remarks:-- `` 13433 565 34 THE the DT 13433 565 35 TRUTH truth NN 13433 565 36 . . . 13433 566 1 | | NNP 13433 566 2 DR DR NNP 13433 566 3 . . . 13433 566 4 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 566 5 'S 's POS 13433 566 6 STATEMENT statement NN 13433 566 7 . . . 13433 567 1 | | NNP 13433 567 2 _ _ NNP 13433 567 3 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 567 4 , , , 13433 567 5 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 567 6 , , , 13433 567 7 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 13433 567 8 , , , 13433 567 9 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 567 10 , , , 13433 567 11 | | NNP 13433 567 12 " " `` 13433 567 13 The the DT 13433 567 14 reader reader NN 13433 567 15 , , , 13433 567 16 therefore therefore RB 13433 567 17 , , , 13433 567 18 will will MD 13433 567 19 Milman Milman NNP 13433 567 20 , , , 13433 567 21 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 13433 567 22 _ _ NNP 13433 567 23 , , , 13433 567 24 and and CC 13433 567 25 _ _ NNP 13433 567 26 Weiss Weiss NNP 13433 567 27 _ _ NNP 13433 567 28 | | NNP 13433 567 29 hardly hardly RB 13433 567 30 be be VB 13433 567 31 prepared prepared JJ 13433 567 32 to to TO 13433 567 33 hear hear VB 13433 567 34 that that DT 13433 567 35 maintain maintain VB 13433 567 36 both both DT 13433 567 37 the the DT 13433 567 38 priority priority NN 13433 567 39 and and CC 13433 567 40 | | CD 13433 567 41 not not RB 13433 567 42 one one CD 13433 567 43 of of IN 13433 567 44 these these DT 13433 567 45 nine nine CD 13433 567 46 writers writer NNS 13433 567 47 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 567 48 of of IN 13433 567 49 the the DT 13433 567 50 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 567 51 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 567 52 . . . 13433 568 1 | | NNS 13433 568 2 condemns condemn VBZ 13433 568 3 the the DT 13433 568 4 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 568 5 letters letter NNS 13433 568 6 _ _ NNP 13433 568 7 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 568 8 _ _ NNP 13433 568 9 will will MD 13433 568 10 not not RB 13433 568 11 commit commit VB 13433 568 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 568 13 to to IN 13433 568 14 a a DT 13433 568 15 | | NNP 13433 568 16 as as RB 13433 568 17 spurious spurious JJ 13433 568 18 . . . 13433 569 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 569 2 alone alone RB 13433 569 3 leaves leave VBZ 13433 569 4 distinct distinct JJ 13433 569 5 recognition recognition NN 13433 569 6 of of IN 13433 569 7 the the DT 13433 569 8 letters letter NNS 13433 569 9 | | CD 13433 569 10 leaves leave VBZ 13433 569 11 the the DT 13433 569 12 matter matter NN 13433 569 13 in in IN 13433 569 14 some some DT 13433 569 15 in in IN 13433 569 16 any any DT 13433 569 17 form form NN 13433 569 18 . . . 13433 570 1 Of of IN 13433 570 2 the the DT 13433 570 3 Vossian vossian JJ 13433 570 4 | | NNP 13433 570 5 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 570 6 while while IN 13433 570 7 inclining incline VBG 13433 570 8 to to IN 13433 570 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 570 10 , , , 13433 570 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 570 12 says say VBZ 13433 570 13 : : : 13433 570 14 " " `` 13433 570 15 Aber aber NN 13433 570 16 auch auch NN 13433 570 17 die die NN 13433 570 18 | | NNP 13433 570 19 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 570 20 's 's POS 13433 570 21 view view NN 13433 570 22 ; ; : 13433 570 23 the the DT 13433 570 24 other other JJ 13433 570 25 eight eight CD 13433 570 26 Echtheit Echtheit NNP 13433 570 27 dieser dieser NN 13433 570 28 Recension recension NN 13433 570 29 ist ist NN 13433 570 30 | | NNP 13433 570 31 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 570 32 maintain maintain VBP 13433 570 33 the the DT 13433 570 34 keineswegs keineswegs NNP 13433 570 35 sicher sicher NN 13433 570 36 . . . 13433 570 37 " " '' 13433 571 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 571 2 considers consider VBZ 13433 571 3 the the DT 13433 571 4 | | CD 13433 571 5 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 571 6 of of IN 13433 571 7 the the DT 13433 571 8 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 571 9 priority priority NN 13433 571 10 of of IN 13433 571 11 the the DT 13433 571 12 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 571 13 " " '' 13433 571 14 in in IN 13433 571 15 the the DT 13433 571 16 | | CD 13433 571 17 letters letter NNS 13433 571 18 . . . 13433 571 19 " " '' 13433 572 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 572 2 63:1 63:1 CD 13433 572 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 572 4 highest high JJS 13433 572 5 degree degree NN 13433 572 6 probable probable JJ 13433 572 7 . . . 13433 572 8 " " '' 13433 573 1 | | NNP 13433 573 2 | | NNP 13433 573 3 _ _ NNP 13433 573 4 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 573 5 _ _ NNP 13433 573 6 rejects reject VBZ 13433 573 7 all all PDT 13433 573 8 the the DT 13433 573 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 573 10 , , , 13433 573 11 | | NNP 13433 573 12 as as IN 13433 573 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 573 14 have have VBP 13433 573 15 already already RB 13433 573 16 said say VBN 13433 573 17 , , , 13433 573 18 but but CC 13433 573 19 | | NNP 13433 573 20 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 573 21 the the DT 13433 573 22 priority priority NN 13433 573 23 of of IN 13433 573 24 the the DT 13433 573 25 | | NNP 13433 573 26 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 573 27 . . . 13433 574 1 | | NNP 13433 574 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 574 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 574 4 's 's POS 13433 574 5 statement statement NN 13433 574 6 , , , 13433 574 7 therefore therefore RB 13433 574 8 , , , 13433 574 9 is be VBZ 13433 574 10 a a DT 13433 574 11 total total JJ 13433 574 12 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 574 13 of of IN 13433 574 14 the the DT 13433 574 15 facts fact NNS 13433 574 16 , , , 13433 574 17 and and CC 13433 574 18 of of IN 13433 574 19 that that DT 13433 574 20 mischievous mischievous JJ 13433 574 21 kind kind NN 13433 574 22 which which WDT 13433 574 23 does do VBZ 13433 574 24 most most RBS 13433 574 25 subtle subtle JJ 13433 574 26 injury injury NN 13433 574 27 . . . 13433 575 1 Not not RB 13433 575 2 one one CD 13433 575 3 reader reader NN 13433 575 4 in in IN 13433 575 5 twenty twenty CD 13433 575 6 would would MD 13433 575 7 take take VB 13433 575 8 the the DT 13433 575 9 trouble trouble NN 13433 575 10 to to TO 13433 575 11 investigate investigate VB 13433 575 12 , , , 13433 575 13 but but CC 13433 575 14 would would MD 13433 575 15 receive receive VB 13433 575 16 from from IN 13433 575 17 such such JJ 13433 575 18 positive positive JJ 13433 575 19 assertions assertion NNS 13433 575 20 an an DT 13433 575 21 impression impression NN 13433 575 22 that that IN 13433 575 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 575 24 note note NN 13433 575 25 was be VBD 13433 575 26 totally totally RB 13433 575 27 wrong wrong JJ 13433 575 28 , , , 13433 575 29 when when WRB 13433 575 30 in in IN 13433 575 31 fact fact NN 13433 575 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 575 33 is be VBZ 13433 575 34 literally literally RB 13433 575 35 correct correct JJ 13433 575 36 . . . 13433 576 1 Continuing continue VBG 13433 576 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 576 3 analysis analysis NN 13433 576 4 , , , 13433 576 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 576 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 576 7 fights fight VBZ 13433 576 8 almost almost RB 13433 576 9 every every DT 13433 576 10 inch inch NN 13433 576 11 of of IN 13433 576 12 the the DT 13433 576 13 ground ground NN 13433 576 14 in in IN 13433 576 15 the the DT 13433 576 16 very very RB 13433 576 17 same same JJ 13433 576 18 style style NN 13433 576 19 . . . 13433 577 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 577 2 can can MD 13433 577 3 not not RB 13433 577 4 contradict contradict VB 13433 577 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 577 6 statement statement NN 13433 577 7 that that WDT 13433 577 8 so so RB 13433 577 9 early early RB 13433 577 10 as as IN 13433 577 11 the the DT 13433 577 12 sixteenth sixteenth JJ 13433 577 13 century century NN 13433 577 14 the the DT 13433 577 15 strongest strong JJS 13433 577 16 doubts doubt NNS 13433 577 17 were be VBD 13433 577 18 expressed express VBN 13433 577 19 regarding regard VBG 13433 577 20 the the DT 13433 577 21 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 577 22 of of IN 13433 577 23 any any DT 13433 577 24 of of IN 13433 577 25 the the DT 13433 577 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 577 27 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 577 28 to to IN 13433 577 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 577 30 , , , 13433 577 31 and and CC 13433 577 32 that that IN 13433 577 33 the the DT 13433 577 34 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 13433 577 35 Centuriators Centuriators NNPS 13433 577 36 attacked attack VBD 13433 577 37 them -PRON- PRP 13433 577 38 , , , 13433 577 39 and and CC 13433 577 40 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 577 41 declared declare VBD 13433 577 42 them -PRON- PRP 13433 577 43 to to TO 13433 577 44 be be VB 13433 577 45 spurious spurious JJ 13433 577 46 , , , 13433 577 47 [ [ -LRB- 13433 577 48 64:1 64:1 CD 13433 577 49 ] ] -RRB- 13433 577 50 but but CC 13433 577 51 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 577 52 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 577 53 says say VBZ 13433 577 54 : : : 13433 577 55 " " `` 13433 577 56 The the DT 13433 577 57 criticisms criticism NNS 13433 577 58 of of IN 13433 577 59 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 577 60 more more RBR 13433 577 61 especially especially RB 13433 577 62 refer refer VBP 13433 577 63 to to IN 13433 577 64 those those DT 13433 577 65 passages passage NNS 13433 577 66 which which WDT 13433 577 67 were be VBD 13433 577 68 found find VBN 13433 577 69 in in IN 13433 577 70 the the DT 13433 577 71 Long Long NNP 13433 577 72 Recension Recension NNP 13433 577 73 alone alone RB 13433 577 74 . . . 13433 577 75 " " '' 13433 578 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 578 2 64:2 64:2 CD 13433 578 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 578 4 Of of RB 13433 578 5 course course RB 13433 578 6 only only RB 13433 578 7 the the DT 13433 578 8 Long Long NNP 13433 578 9 Recension Recension NNP 13433 578 10 was be VBD 13433 578 11 at at IN 13433 578 12 that that DT 13433 578 13 time time NN 13433 578 14 known know VBN 13433 578 15 . . . 13433 579 1 Rivet Rivet NNS 13433 579 2 replies reply VBZ 13433 579 3 to to IN 13433 579 4 Campianus Campianus NNP 13433 579 5 that that IN 13433 579 6 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 579 7 's 's POS 13433 579 8 objections objection NNS 13433 579 9 were be VBD 13433 579 10 not not RB 13433 579 11 against against IN 13433 579 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 579 13 but but CC 13433 579 14 the the DT 13433 579 15 Jesuits Jesuits NNPS 13433 579 16 who who WP 13433 579 17 had have VBD 13433 579 18 corrupted corrupt VBN 13433 579 19 him -PRON- PRP 13433 579 20 . . . 13433 580 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 580 2 64:3 64:3 CD 13433 580 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 580 4 This this DT 13433 580 5 is be VBZ 13433 580 6 the the DT 13433 580 7 usual usual JJ 13433 580 8 retort retort NN 13433 580 9 theological theological NN 13433 580 10 , , , 13433 580 11 but but CC 13433 580 12 as as IN 13433 580 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 580 14 have have VBP 13433 580 15 quoted quote VBN 13433 580 16 the the DT 13433 580 17 words word NNS 13433 580 18 of of IN 13433 580 19 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 580 20 the the DT 13433 580 21 reader reader NN 13433 580 22 may may MD 13433 580 23 judge judge VB 13433 580 24 for for IN 13433 580 25 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 580 26 . . . 13433 581 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 581 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 581 3 then then RB 13433 581 4 says say VBZ 13433 581 5 : : : 13433 581 6 " " `` 13433 581 7 The the DT 13433 581 8 clause clause NN 13433 581 9 which which WDT 13433 581 10 follows follow VBZ 13433 581 11 contains contain VBZ 13433 581 12 a a DT 13433 581 13 direct direct JJ 13433 581 14 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 581 15 . . . 13433 582 1 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 582 2 did do VBD 13433 582 3 not not RB 13433 582 4 fully fully RB 13433 582 5 share share VB 13433 582 6 the the DT 13433 582 7 opinion opinion NN 13433 582 8 that that IN 13433 582 9 they -PRON- PRP 13433 582 10 were be VBD 13433 582 11 spurious spurious JJ 13433 582 12 ; ; : 13433 582 13 on on IN 13433 582 14 the the DT 13433 582 15 contrary contrary NN 13433 582 16 , , , 13433 582 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 582 18 quotes quote VBZ 13433 582 19 them -PRON- PRP 13433 582 20 several several JJ 13433 582 21 times time NNS 13433 582 22 as as IN 13433 582 23 authoritative authoritative JJ 13433 582 24 ; ; : 13433 582 25 but but CC 13433 582 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 582 27 says say VBZ 13433 582 28 that that IN 13433 582 29 they -PRON- PRP 13433 582 30 ' ' `` 13433 582 31 seem seem VBP 13433 582 32 to to TO 13433 582 33 have have VB 13433 582 34 been be VBN 13433 582 35 altered alter VBN 13433 582 36 in in IN 13433 582 37 many many JJ 13433 582 38 places place NNS 13433 582 39 to to TO 13433 582 40 strengthen strengthen VB 13433 582 41 the the DT 13433 582 42 position position NN 13433 582 43 of of IN 13433 582 44 the the DT 13433 582 45 Papal Papal NNP 13433 582 46 power power NN 13433 582 47 , , , 13433 582 48 & & CC 13433 582 49 c. c. NNP 13433 582 50 ' ' '' 13433 582 51 " " '' 13433 582 52 [ [ -LRB- 13433 582 53 64:4 64:4 NN 13433 582 54 ] ] -RRB- 13433 582 55 Pearson Pearson NNP 13433 582 56 's 's POS 13433 582 57 statement statement NN 13433 582 58 here here RB 13433 582 59 quoted quote VBN 13433 582 60 must must MD 13433 582 61 be be VB 13433 582 62 received receive VBN 13433 582 63 with with IN 13433 582 64 reserve reserve NN 13433 582 65 , , , 13433 582 66 for for IN 13433 582 67 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 582 68 rather rather RB 13433 582 69 speaks speak VBZ 13433 582 70 sarcastically sarcastically RB 13433 582 71 of of IN 13433 582 72 those those DT 13433 582 73 who who WP 13433 582 74 quote quote VBP 13433 582 75 these these DT 13433 582 76 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 582 77 as as IN 13433 582 78 evidence evidence NN 13433 582 79 . . . 13433 583 1 In in IN 13433 583 2 treating treat VBG 13433 583 3 them -PRON- PRP 13433 583 4 as as IN 13433 583 5 ancient ancient JJ 13433 583 6 documents document NNS 13433 583 7 or or CC 13433 583 8 speaking speaking NN 13433 583 9 of of IN 13433 583 10 parts part NNS 13433 583 11 of of IN 13433 583 12 them -PRON- PRP 13433 583 13 with with IN 13433 583 14 respect respect NN 13433 583 15 , , , 13433 583 16 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 583 17 does do VBZ 13433 583 18 nothing nothing NN 13433 583 19 more more JJR 13433 583 20 than than IN 13433 583 21 the the DT 13433 583 22 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 13433 583 23 Centuriators Centuriators NNP 13433 583 24 , , , 13433 583 25 but but CC 13433 583 26 this this DT 13433 583 27 is be VBZ 13433 583 28 a a DT 13433 583 29 very very RB 13433 583 30 different different JJ 13433 583 31 thing thing NN 13433 583 32 from from IN 13433 583 33 directly directly RB 13433 583 34 ascribing ascribe VBG 13433 583 35 them -PRON- PRP 13433 583 36 to to IN 13433 583 37 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 583 38 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 583 39 . . . 13433 584 1 The the DT 13433 584 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 584 3 in in IN 13433 584 4 the the DT 13433 584 5 " " `` 13433 584 6 Long long JJ 13433 584 7 Recension recension NN 13433 584 8 were be VBD 13433 584 9 before before IN 13433 584 10 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 584 11 both both DT 13433 584 12 in in IN 13433 584 13 the the DT 13433 584 14 Latin latin JJ 13433 584 15 and and CC 13433 584 16 Greek greek JJ 13433 584 17 forms form NNS 13433 584 18 . . . 13433 585 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 585 2 says say VBZ 13433 585 3 of of IN 13433 585 4 them -PRON- PRP 13433 585 5 : : : 13433 585 6 " " `` 13433 585 7 ... ... : 13433 585 8 multas multas NNP 13433 585 9 habent habent VBP 13433 585 10 non non JJ 13433 585 11 contemnendas contemnendas NNP 13433 585 12 sententias sententias NNP 13433 585 13 , , , 13433 585 14 praesertim praesertim NN 13433 585 15 sicut sicut NN 13433 585 16 Graece Graece NNP 13433 585 17 leguntur leguntur NN 13433 585 18 . . . 13433 586 1 Admixta admixta JJ 13433 586 2 vero vero NN 13433 586 3 sunt sunt NN 13433 586 4 et et NNP 13433 586 5 alia alia NNP 13433 586 6 non non NNP 13433 586 7 pauca pauca NNP 13433 586 8 , , , 13433 586 9 quae quae NNP 13433 586 10 profecto profecto NNP 13433 586 11 non non AFX 13433 586 12 referunt referunt NN 13433 586 13 gravitatem gravitatem NN 13433 586 14 Apostolicam Apostolicam NNP 13433 586 15 . . . 13433 587 1 Adulteratas Adulteratas NNP 13433 587 2 enim enim NNP 13433 587 3 jam jam NNP 13433 587 4 esse esse NNP 13433 587 5 illas illas NNP 13433 587 6 epistolas epistolas NNP 13433 587 7 , , , 13433 587 8 vel vel NNP 13433 587 9 inde inde NNP 13433 587 10 colligitur colligitur NNP 13433 587 11 . . . 13433 587 12 " " '' 13433 588 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 588 2 then then RB 13433 588 3 shows show VBZ 13433 588 4 that that IN 13433 588 5 quotations quotation NNS 13433 588 6 in in IN 13433 588 7 ancient ancient JJ 13433 588 8 writers writer NNS 13433 588 9 purporting purport VBG 13433 588 10 to to TO 13433 588 11 be be VB 13433 588 12 taken take VBN 13433 588 13 from from IN 13433 588 14 the the DT 13433 588 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 588 16 of of IN 13433 588 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 588 18 are be VBP 13433 588 19 not not RB 13433 588 20 found find VBN 13433 588 21 in in IN 13433 588 22 these these DT 13433 588 23 extant extant JJ 13433 588 24 Epistles epistle NNS 13433 588 25 at at RB 13433 588 26 all all RB 13433 588 27 , , , 13433 588 28 and and CC 13433 588 29 says say VBZ 13433 588 30 : : : 13433 588 31 " " `` 13433 588 32 De De NNP 13433 588 33 Epistolis Epistolis NNP 13433 588 34 igitur igitur NN 13433 588 35 illis illis NNP 13433 588 36 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 13433 588 37 , , , 13433 588 38 quae quae RB 13433 588 39 nunc nunc NNP 13433 588 40 ejus ejus NNP 13433 588 41 titulo titulo NNP 13433 588 42 feruntur feruntur NNP 13433 588 43 , , , 13433 588 44 merito merito NNP 13433 588 45 dubitamus dubitamus NNP 13433 588 46 : : : 13433 588 47 transformatae transformatae NNP 13433 588 48 enim enim NNP 13433 588 49 videntur videntur NNP 13433 588 50 in in IN 13433 588 51 multis multis NNP 13433 588 52 locis locis NN 13433 588 53 , , , 13433 588 54 ad ad NN 13433 588 55 stabiliendum stabiliendum NN 13433 588 56 statum statum NN 13433 588 57 regni regni NNP 13433 588 58 Pontificii Pontificii NNP 13433 588 59 . . . 13433 588 60 " " '' 13433 589 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 589 2 65:1 65:1 CD 13433 589 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 589 4 Even even RB 13433 589 5 when when WRB 13433 589 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 589 7 speaks speak VBZ 13433 589 8 in in IN 13433 589 9 favour favour NN 13433 589 10 of of IN 13433 589 11 them -PRON- PRP 13433 589 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 589 13 " " `` 13433 589 14 damns damn VBZ 13433 589 15 them -PRON- PRP 13433 589 16 with with IN 13433 589 17 faint faint JJ 13433 589 18 praise praise NN 13433 589 19 . . . 13433 589 20 " " '' 13433 590 1 The the DT 13433 590 2 whole whole NN 13433 590 3 of of IN 13433 590 4 the the DT 13433 590 5 discussion discussion NN 13433 590 6 turns turn VBZ 13433 590 7 upon upon IN 13433 590 8 the the DT 13433 590 9 word word NN 13433 590 10 " " `` 13433 590 11 fully fully RB 13433 590 12 , , , 13433 590 13 " " '' 13433 590 14 and and CC 13433 590 15 is be VBZ 13433 590 16 an an DT 13433 590 17 instance instance NN 13433 590 18 of of IN 13433 590 19 the the DT 13433 590 20 minute minute JJ 13433 590 21 criticism criticism NN 13433 590 22 of of IN 13433 590 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 590 24 critic critic NN 13433 590 25 , , , 13433 590 26 who who WP 13433 590 27 evidently evidently RB 13433 590 28 is be VBZ 13433 590 29 not not RB 13433 590 30 directly directly RB 13433 590 31 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 590 32 with with IN 13433 590 33 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 590 34 . . . 13433 591 1 A a DT 13433 591 2 shade shade NN 13433 591 3 more more RBR 13433 591 4 or or CC 13433 591 5 less less RBR 13433 591 6 of of IN 13433 591 7 doubt doubt NN 13433 591 8 or or CC 13433 591 9 certainty certainty NN 13433 591 10 in in IN 13433 591 11 conveying convey VBG 13433 591 12 the the DT 13433 591 13 impression impression NN 13433 591 14 received receive VBN 13433 591 15 from from IN 13433 591 16 the the DT 13433 591 17 words word NNS 13433 591 18 of of IN 13433 591 19 a a DT 13433 591 20 writer writer NN 13433 591 21 is be VBZ 13433 591 22 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 591 23 worth worth JJ 13433 591 24 much much JJ 13433 591 25 indignation indignation NN 13433 591 26 . . . 13433 592 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 592 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 592 3 makes make VBZ 13433 592 4 a a DT 13433 592 5 very very RB 13433 592 6 detailed detailed JJ 13433 592 7 attack attack NN 13433 592 8 upon upon IN 13433 592 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 592 10 next next JJ 13433 592 11 two two CD 13433 592 12 notes note NNS 13433 592 13 , , , 13433 592 14 and and CC 13433 592 15 here here RB 13433 592 16 again again RB 13433 592 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 592 18 must must MD 13433 592 19 closely closely RB 13433 592 20 follow follow VB 13433 592 21 him -PRON- PRP 13433 592 22 . . . 13433 593 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 593 2 note note NN 13433 593 3 ( ( -LRB- 13433 593 4 2 2 LS 13433 593 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 593 6 p. p. NN 13433 593 7 260 260 CD 13433 593 8 reads read NNS 13433 593 9 as as IN 13433 593 10 follows follow VBZ 13433 593 11 : : : 13433 593 12 " " `` 13433 593 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 593 14 2 2 LS 13433 593 15 ) ) -RRB- 13433 593 16 By by IN 13433 593 17 Bochartus Bochartus NNP 13433 593 18 , , , 13433 593 19 Aubertin Aubertin NNP 13433 593 20 , , , 13433 593 21 Blondel Blondel NNP 13433 593 22 , , , 13433 593 23 Basnage Basnage NNP 13433 593 24 , , , 13433 593 25 Casaubon Casaubon NNP 13433 593 26 , , , 13433 593 27 Cocus Cocus NNP 13433 593 28 , , , 13433 593 29 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 13433 593 30 , , , 13433 593 31 Rivetus Rivetus NNP 13433 593 32 , , , 13433 593 33 Salmasius Salmasius NNP 13433 593 34 , , , 13433 593 35 Socinus Socinus NNP 13433 593 36 ( ( -LRB- 13433 593 37 Faustus Faustus NNP 13433 593 38 ) ) -RRB- 13433 593 39 , , , 13433 593 40 Parker Parker NNP 13433 593 41 , , , 13433 593 42 Petau Petau NNP 13433 593 43 , , , 13433 593 44 & & CC 13433 593 45 c. c. NNP 13433 593 46 & & CC 13433 593 47 c. c. NNP 13433 593 48 ; ; : 13433 593 49 cf cf NNP 13433 593 50 . . . 13433 594 1 Jacobson Jacobson NNP 13433 594 2 , , , 13433 594 3 ' ' '' 13433 594 4 Patr Patr NNP 13433 594 5 . . . 13433 595 1 Apost apost UH 13433 595 2 . . . 13433 595 3 ' ' '' 13433 596 1 i. i. NNP 13433 596 2 p. p. NNP 13433 596 3 xxv xxv NNP 13433 596 4 ; ; : 13433 596 5 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 596 6 , , , 13433 596 7 ' ' '' 13433 596 8 Vindiciae Vindiciae NNS 13433 596 9 Ignatianae ignatianae IN 13433 596 10 , , , 13433 596 11 ' ' '' 13433 596 12 1846 1846 CD 13433 596 13 , , , 13433 596 14 appendix appendix NNP 13433 596 15 . . . 13433 596 16 " " '' 13433 597 1 Upon upon IN 13433 597 2 this this DT 13433 597 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 597 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 597 5 makes make VBZ 13433 597 6 the the DT 13433 597 7 following follow VBG 13433 597 8 preliminary preliminary JJ 13433 597 9 remarks:-- remarks:-- NN 13433 597 10 " " `` 13433 597 11 But but CC 13433 597 12 the the DT 13433 597 13 most most RBS 13433 597 14 important important JJ 13433 597 15 point point NN 13433 597 16 of of IN 13433 597 17 all all DT 13433 597 18 is be VBZ 13433 597 19 the the DT 13433 597 20 purpose purpose NN 13433 597 21 for for IN 13433 597 22 which which WDT 13433 597 23 they -PRON- PRP 13433 597 24 are be VBP 13433 597 25 quoted quote VBN 13433 597 26 . . . 13433 598 1 ' ' `` 13433 598 2 Similar similar JJ 13433 598 3 doubts doubt NNS 13433 598 4 ' ' '' 13433 598 5 could could MD 13433 598 6 only only RB 13433 598 7 , , , 13433 598 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 598 9 think think VBP 13433 598 10 , , , 13433 598 11 be be VB 13433 598 12 interpreted interpret VBN 13433 598 13 from from IN 13433 598 14 the the DT 13433 598 15 context context NN 13433 598 16 as as IN 13433 598 17 doubts doubt NNS 13433 598 18 ' ' `` 13433 598 19 regarding regard VBG 13433 598 20 the the DT 13433 598 21 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 598 22 of of IN 13433 598 23 any any DT 13433 598 24 of of IN 13433 598 25 the the DT 13433 598 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 598 27 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 598 28 to to IN 13433 598 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 598 30 . . . 13433 598 31 ' ' '' 13433 598 32 " " '' 13433 599 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 599 2 65:2 65:2 CD 13433 599 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 599 4 As as IN 13433 599 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 599 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 599 7 , , , 13433 599 8 in in IN 13433 599 9 the the DT 13433 599 10 first first JJ 13433 599 11 sentence sentence NN 13433 599 12 just just RB 13433 599 13 quoted quote VBN 13433 599 14 , , , 13433 599 15 recognises recognise VBZ 13433 599 16 what what WP 13433 599 17 is be VBZ 13433 599 18 " " `` 13433 599 19 the the DT 13433 599 20 most most RBS 13433 599 21 important important JJ 13433 599 22 point point NN 13433 599 23 of of IN 13433 599 24 all all DT 13433 599 25 , , , 13433 599 26 " " `` 13433 599 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 599 28 is be VBZ 13433 599 29 a a DT 13433 599 30 pity pity NN 13433 599 31 that that WDT 13433 599 32 , , , 13433 599 33 throughout throughout IN 13433 599 34 the the DT 13433 599 35 whole whole NN 13433 599 36 of of IN 13433 599 37 the the DT 13433 599 38 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 599 39 analysis analysis NN 13433 599 40 of of IN 13433 599 41 the the DT 13433 599 42 references reference NNS 13433 599 43 in in IN 13433 599 44 question question NN 13433 599 45 , , , 13433 599 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 599 47 persistently persistently RB 13433 599 48 ignores ignore VBZ 13433 599 49 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 599 50 very very RB 13433 599 51 careful careful JJ 13433 599 52 definition definition NN 13433 599 53 of of IN 13433 599 54 " " `` 13433 599 55 the the DT 13433 599 56 purpose purpose NN 13433 599 57 for for IN 13433 599 58 which which WDT 13433 599 59 they -PRON- PRP 13433 599 60 are be VBP 13433 599 61 quoted quote VBN 13433 599 62 . . . 13433 599 63 " " '' 13433 600 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 600 2 is be VBZ 13433 600 3 difficult difficult JJ 13433 600 4 , , , 13433 600 5 without without IN 13433 600 6 entering enter VBG 13433 600 7 into into IN 13433 600 8 minute minute NN 13433 600 9 classifications classification NNS 13433 600 10 , , , 13433 600 11 accurately accurately RB 13433 600 12 to to TO 13433 600 13 represent represent VB 13433 600 14 in in IN 13433 600 15 a a DT 13433 600 16 few few JJ 13433 600 17 words word NNS 13433 600 18 the the DT 13433 600 19 opinions opinion NNS 13433 600 20 of of IN 13433 600 21 a a DT 13433 600 22 great great JJ 13433 600 23 number number NN 13433 600 24 of of IN 13433 600 25 writers writer NNS 13433 600 26 , , , 13433 600 27 and and CC 13433 600 28 briefly briefly RB 13433 600 29 convey convey VB 13433 600 30 a a DT 13433 600 31 fair fair JJ 13433 600 32 idea idea NN 13433 600 33 of of IN 13433 600 34 the the DT 13433 600 35 course course NN 13433 600 36 of of IN 13433 600 37 critical critical JJ 13433 600 38 judgment judgment NN 13433 600 39 . . . 13433 601 1 Desirous desirous JJ 13433 601 2 , , , 13433 601 3 therefore therefore RB 13433 601 4 , , , 13433 601 5 of of IN 13433 601 6 embracing embrace VBG 13433 601 7 a a DT 13433 601 8 large large JJ 13433 601 9 class class NN 13433 601 10 -- -- : 13433 601 11 for for IN 13433 601 12 both both CC 13433 601 13 this this DT 13433 601 14 note note NN 13433 601 15 and and CC 13433 601 16 the the DT 13433 601 17 next next JJ 13433 601 18 , , , 13433 601 19 with with IN 13433 601 20 mere mere JJ 13433 601 21 difference difference NN 13433 601 22 of of IN 13433 601 23 epoch epoch NNP 13433 601 24 , , , 13433 601 25 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 601 26 the the DT 13433 601 27 same same JJ 13433 601 28 statement statement NN 13433 601 29 in in IN 13433 601 30 the the DT 13433 601 31 text text NN 13433 601 32 -- -- : 13433 601 33 and and CC 13433 601 34 not not RB 13433 601 35 to to TO 13433 601 36 overstate overstate VB 13433 601 37 the the DT 13433 601 38 case case NN 13433 601 39 on on IN 13433 601 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 601 41 own own JJ 13433 601 42 side side NN 13433 601 43 , , , 13433 601 44 I -PRON- PRP 13433 601 45 used use VBD 13433 601 46 what what WP 13433 601 47 seemed seem VBD 13433 601 48 to to IN 13433 601 49 me -PRON- PRP 13433 601 50 a a DT 13433 601 51 very very RB 13433 601 52 moderate moderate JJ 13433 601 53 phrase phrase NN 13433 601 54 , , , 13433 601 55 decreasing decrease VBG 13433 601 56 the the DT 13433 601 57 force force NN 13433 601 58 of of IN 13433 601 59 the the DT 13433 601 60 opinion opinion NN 13433 601 61 of of IN 13433 601 62 those those DT 13433 601 63 who who WP 13433 601 64 positively positively RB 13433 601 65 rejected reject VBD 13433 601 66 the the DT 13433 601 67 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 601 68 , , , 13433 601 69 and and CC 13433 601 70 not not RB 13433 601 71 unfairly unfairly RB 13433 601 72 representing represent VBG 13433 601 73 the the DT 13433 601 74 hesitation hesitation NN 13433 601 75 of of IN 13433 601 76 those those DT 13433 601 77 who who WP 13433 601 78 did do VBD 13433 601 79 not not RB 13433 601 80 fully fully RB 13433 601 81 accept accept VB 13433 601 82 them -PRON- PRP 13433 601 83 . . . 13433 602 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 602 2 said say VBD 13433 602 3 , , , 13433 602 4 then then RB 13433 602 5 , , , 13433 602 6 in in IN 13433 602 7 guarded guard VBN 13433 602 8 terms term NNS 13433 602 9 -- -- : 13433 602 10 and and CC 13433 602 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 602 12 italicise italicise VBP 13433 602 13 the the DT 13433 602 14 part part NN 13433 602 15 which which WDT 13433 602 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 602 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 602 18 chooses choose VBZ 13433 602 19 to to TO 13433 602 20 suppress suppress VB 13433 602 21 -- -- : 13433 602 22 that that IN 13433 602 23 " " `` 13433 602 24 similar similar JJ 13433 602 25 _ _ NNP 13433 602 26 doubts doubt NNS 13433 602 27 , , , 13433 602 28 more more RBR 13433 602 29 or or CC 13433 602 30 less less RBR 13433 602 31 definite definite JJ 13433 602 32 _ _ NNP 13433 602 33 , , , 13433 602 34 " " '' 13433 602 35 were be VBD 13433 602 36 expressed express VBN 13433 602 37 by by IN 13433 602 38 the the DT 13433 602 39 writers writer NNS 13433 602 40 referred refer VBD 13433 602 41 to to IN 13433 602 42 . . . 13433 603 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 603 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 603 3 admits admit VBZ 13433 603 4 that that IN 13433 603 5 Bochart Bochart NNP 13433 603 6 directly directly RB 13433 603 7 condemns condemn VBZ 13433 603 8 one one CD 13433 603 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 603 10 , , , 13433 603 11 and and CC 13433 603 12 would would MD 13433 603 13 probably probably RB 13433 603 14 have have VB 13433 603 15 condemned condemn VBN 13433 603 16 the the DT 13433 603 17 rest rest NN 13433 603 18 also also RB 13433 603 19 ; ; : 13433 603 20 that that IN 13433 603 21 Aubertin Aubertin NNP 13433 603 22 , , , 13433 603 23 Blondel Blondel NNP 13433 603 24 , , , 13433 603 25 Basnage Basnage NNP 13433 603 26 , , , 13433 603 27 R. R. NNP 13433 603 28 Parker Parker NNP 13433 603 29 , , , 13433 603 30 and and CC 13433 603 31 Saumaise Saumaise NNP 13433 603 32 actually actually RB 13433 603 33 rejected reject VBD 13433 603 34 all all DT 13433 603 35 ; ; : 13433 603 36 and and CC 13433 603 37 that that IN 13433 603 38 Cook Cook NNP 13433 603 39 pronounces pronounce VBZ 13433 603 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 603 41 " " `` 13433 603 42 either either CC 13433 603 43 supposititious supposititious JJ 13433 603 44 or or CC 13433 603 45 shamefully shamefully RB 13433 603 46 corrupted corrupt VBN 13433 603 47 . . . 13433 603 48 " " '' 13433 604 1 So so RB 13433 604 2 far far RB 13433 604 3 , , , 13433 604 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 604 5 , , , 13433 604 6 there there EX 13433 604 7 can can MD 13433 604 8 be be VB 13433 604 9 no no DT 13433 604 10 dispute dispute NN 13433 604 11 . . . 13433 605 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 605 2 will will MD 13433 605 3 now now RB 13433 605 4 take take VB 13433 605 5 the the DT 13433 605 6 rest rest NN 13433 605 7 in in IN 13433 605 8 succession succession NN 13433 605 9 . . . 13433 606 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 606 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 606 3 says say VBZ 13433 606 4 that that IN 13433 606 5 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 13433 606 6 " " `` 13433 606 7 considers consider VBZ 13433 606 8 that that IN 13433 606 9 they -PRON- PRP 13433 606 10 have have VBP 13433 606 11 been be VBN 13433 606 12 interpolated interpolate VBN 13433 606 13 and and CC 13433 606 14 mutilated mutilate VBN 13433 606 15 , , , 13433 606 16 but but CC 13433 606 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 606 18 believes believe VBZ 13433 606 19 them -PRON- PRP 13433 606 20 genuine genuine RB 13433 606 21 in in IN 13433 606 22 the the DT 13433 606 23 main main NN 13433 606 24 . . . 13433 606 25 " " '' 13433 607 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 607 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 607 3 has have VBZ 13433 607 4 so so RB 13433 607 5 completely completely RB 13433 607 6 warped warp VBN 13433 607 7 the the DT 13433 607 8 statement statement NN 13433 607 9 in in IN 13433 607 10 the the DT 13433 607 11 text text NN 13433 607 12 , , , 13433 607 13 that that IN 13433 607 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 607 15 seems seem VBZ 13433 607 16 to to TO 13433 607 17 demand demand VB 13433 607 18 nothing nothing NN 13433 607 19 short short JJ 13433 607 20 of of IN 13433 607 21 a a DT 13433 607 22 total total JJ 13433 607 23 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 607 24 of of IN 13433 607 25 the the DT 13433 607 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 607 27 in in IN 13433 607 28 the the DT 13433 607 29 note note NN 13433 607 30 , , , 13433 607 31 but but CC 13433 607 32 had have VBD 13433 607 33 I -PRON- PRP 13433 607 34 intended intend VBN 13433 607 35 to to TO 13433 607 36 say say VB 13433 607 37 that that IN 13433 607 38 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 13433 607 39 and and CC 13433 607 40 all all DT 13433 607 41 of of IN 13433 607 42 these these DT 13433 607 43 writers writer NNS 13433 607 44 definitely definitely RB 13433 607 45 rejected reject VBD 13433 607 46 the the DT 13433 607 47 whole whole NN 13433 607 48 of of IN 13433 607 49 the the DT 13433 607 50 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 607 51 I -PRON- PRP 13433 607 52 should should MD 13433 607 53 not not RB 13433 607 54 have have VB 13433 607 55 limited limit VBN 13433 607 56 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 607 57 to to IN 13433 607 58 merely merely RB 13433 607 59 saying say VBG 13433 607 60 that that IN 13433 607 61 they -PRON- PRP 13433 607 62 expressed express VBD 13433 607 63 " " `` 13433 607 64 _ _ NNP 13433 607 65 doubts doubt NNS 13433 607 66 _ _ NNP 13433 607 67 more more RBR 13433 607 68 or or CC 13433 607 69 less less RBR 13433 607 70 definite definite JJ 13433 607 71 , , , 13433 607 72 " " '' 13433 607 73 which which WDT 13433 607 74 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 13433 607 75 does do VBZ 13433 607 76 . . . 13433 608 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 608 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 608 3 says say VBZ 13433 608 4 that that IN 13433 608 5 Socinus Socinus NNP 13433 608 6 " " `` 13433 608 7 denounces denounce VBZ 13433 608 8 corruptions corruption NNS 13433 608 9 and and CC 13433 608 10 anachronisms anachronism NNS 13433 608 11 , , , 13433 608 12 but but CC 13433 608 13 so so RB 13433 608 14 far far RB 13433 608 15 as as IN 13433 608 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 608 17 can can MD 13433 608 18 see see VB 13433 608 19 does do VBZ 13433 608 20 not not RB 13433 608 21 question question VB 13433 608 22 a a DT 13433 608 23 nucleus nucleus NN 13433 608 24 of of IN 13433 608 25 genuine genuine JJ 13433 608 26 matter matter NN 13433 608 27 . . . 13433 608 28 " " '' 13433 609 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 609 2 very very JJ 13433 609 3 denunciations denunciation NNS 13433 609 4 , , , 13433 609 5 however however RB 13433 609 6 , , , 13433 609 7 are be VBP 13433 609 8 certainly certainly RB 13433 609 9 the the DT 13433 609 10 expression expression NN 13433 609 11 of of IN 13433 609 12 " " `` 13433 609 13 doubts doubt NNS 13433 609 14 , , , 13433 609 15 more more RBR 13433 609 16 or or CC 13433 609 17 less less RBR 13433 609 18 definite definite JJ 13433 609 19 . . . 13433 609 20 " " '' 13433 610 1 " " `` 13433 610 2 Casaubon casaubon NN 13433 610 3 , , , 13433 610 4 far far RB 13433 610 5 from from IN 13433 610 6 rejecting reject VBG 13433 610 7 them -PRON- PRP 13433 610 8 altogether altogether RB 13433 610 9 , , , 13433 610 10 " " '' 13433 610 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 610 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 610 13 says say VBZ 13433 610 14 , , , 13433 610 15 " " `` 13433 610 16 promises promise VBZ 13433 610 17 to to TO 13433 610 18 defend defend VB 13433 610 19 the the DT 13433 610 20 antiquity antiquity NN 13433 610 21 of of IN 13433 610 22 some some DT 13433 610 23 of of IN 13433 610 24 the the DT 13433 610 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 610 26 with with IN 13433 610 27 new new JJ 13433 610 28 arguments argument NNS 13433 610 29 . . . 13433 610 30 " " '' 13433 611 1 But but CC 13433 611 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 611 3 have have VBP 13433 611 4 never never RB 13433 611 5 affirmed affirm VBN 13433 611 6 that that IN 13433 611 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 611 8 " " `` 13433 611 9 rejected reject VBD 13433 611 10 them -PRON- PRP 13433 611 11 altogether altogether RB 13433 611 12 . . . 13433 611 13 " " '' 13433 612 1 Casaubon casaubon NN 13433 612 2 died die VBD 13433 612 3 before before IN 13433 612 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 612 5 fulfilled fulfil VBD 13433 612 6 the the DT 13433 612 7 promise promise NN 13433 612 8 referred refer VBN 13433 612 9 to to IN 13433 612 10 , , , 13433 612 11 so so IN 13433 612 12 that that IN 13433 612 13 we -PRON- PRP 13433 612 14 can can MD 13433 612 15 not not RB 13433 612 16 determine determine VB 13433 612 17 what what WP 13433 612 18 arguments argument NNS 13433 612 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 612 20 might may MD 13433 612 21 have have VB 13433 612 22 used use VBN 13433 612 23 . . . 13433 613 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 613 2 must must MD 13433 613 3 point point VB 13433 613 4 out out RP 13433 613 5 , , , 13433 613 6 however however RB 13433 613 7 , , , 13433 613 8 that that IN 13433 613 9 the the DT 13433 613 10 antiquity antiquity NN 13433 613 11 does do VBZ 13433 613 12 not not RB 13433 613 13 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 613 14 involve involve VB 13433 613 15 the the DT 13433 613 16 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 613 17 of of IN 13433 613 18 a a DT 13433 613 19 document document NN 13433 613 20 . . . 13433 614 1 With with IN 13433 614 2 regard regard NN 13433 614 3 to to IN 13433 614 4 Rivet Rivet NNP 13433 614 5 the the DT 13433 614 6 case case NN 13433 614 7 is be VBZ 13433 614 8 different different JJ 13433 614 9 . . . 13433 615 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 615 2 had have VBD 13433 615 3 overlooked overlook VBN 13433 615 4 the the DT 13433 615 5 fact fact NN 13433 615 6 that that IN 13433 615 7 in in IN 13433 615 8 a a DT 13433 615 9 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 615 10 edition edition NN 13433 615 11 of of IN 13433 615 12 the the DT 13433 615 13 work work NN 13433 615 14 referred refer VBD 13433 615 15 to to IN 13433 615 16 , , , 13433 615 17 after after IN 13433 615 18 receiving receive VBG 13433 615 19 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 13433 615 20 Usher Usher NNP 13433 615 21 's 's POS 13433 615 22 edition edition NN 13433 615 23 on on IN 13433 615 24 of of IN 13433 615 25 the the DT 13433 615 26 Short Short NNP 13433 615 27 Recension Recension NNP 13433 615 28 , , , 13433 615 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 615 30 had have VBD 13433 615 31 given give VBN 13433 615 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 615 33 adhesion adhesion NN 13433 615 34 to to IN 13433 615 35 " " `` 13433 615 36 that that DT 13433 615 37 form form NN 13433 615 38 of of IN 13433 615 39 the the DT 13433 615 40 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 615 41 . . . 13433 615 42 " " '' 13433 616 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 616 2 67:1 67:1 CD 13433 616 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 616 4 This this DT 13433 616 5 fact fact NN 13433 616 6 is be VBZ 13433 616 7 also also RB 13433 616 8 mentioned mention VBN 13433 616 9 by by IN 13433 616 10 Pearson Pearson NNP 13433 616 11 , , , 13433 616 12 and and CC 13433 616 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 616 14 ought ought MD 13433 616 15 to to TO 13433 616 16 have have VB 13433 616 17 observed observe VBN 13433 616 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 616 19 . . . 13433 617 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 617 2 67:2 67:2 CD 13433 617 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 617 4 Petau Petau NNP 13433 617 5 , , , 13433 617 6 the the DT 13433 617 7 last last JJ 13433 617 8 of of IN 13433 617 9 the the DT 13433 617 10 writers writer NNS 13433 617 11 referred refer VBD 13433 617 12 to to IN 13433 617 13 , , , 13433 617 14 says say VBZ 13433 617 15 : : : 13433 617 16 " " `` 13433 617 17 Equidem Equidem NNP 13433 617 18 haud haud VBP 13433 617 19 abnuerim abnuerim JJ 13433 617 20 epistolas epistolas NNP 13433 617 21 illius illius NNP 13433 617 22 varie varie NNP 13433 617 23 interpolatas interpolatas NNP 13433 617 24 et et NNP 13433 617 25 quibusdam quibusdam NNP 13433 617 26 additis additis NNP 13433 617 27 mutatas mutatas NNP 13433 617 28 , , , 13433 617 29 ac ac NNP 13433 617 30 depravatas depravatas NNP 13433 617 31 fuisse fuisse NNP 13433 617 32 : : : 13433 617 33 tum tum NNP 13433 617 34 aliquas aliqua VBD 13433 617 35 esse esse NNP 13433 617 36 supposititias supposititias NNP 13433 617 37 : : : 13433 617 38 verum verum NNP 13433 617 39 nullas nullas NNP 13433 617 40 omnino omnino NNP 13433 617 41 ab ab NNP 13433 617 42 Ignatio Ignatio NNP 13433 617 43 Epistolas Epistolas NNP 13433 617 44 esse esse VBP 13433 617 45 scriptas scripta NNS 13433 617 46 , , , 13433 617 47 i -PRON- PRP 13433 617 48 d d VBD 13433 617 49 vero vero NNP 13433 617 50 nimium nimium NN 13433 617 51 temere temere RB 13433 617 52 affirmari affirmari NNP 13433 617 53 sentio sentio VBP 13433 617 54 . . . 13433 617 55 " " '' 13433 618 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 618 2 then then RB 13433 618 3 goes go VBZ 13433 618 4 on on RP 13433 618 5 to to TO 13433 618 6 mention mention VB 13433 618 7 the the DT 13433 618 8 recent recent JJ 13433 618 9 publication publication NN 13433 618 10 of of IN 13433 618 11 the the DT 13433 618 12 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 618 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 618 14 and and CC 13433 618 15 the the DT 13433 618 16 version version NN 13433 618 17 of of IN 13433 618 18 Usher Usher NNP 13433 618 19 , , , 13433 618 20 and and CC 13433 618 21 the the DT 13433 618 22 learned learn VBN 13433 618 23 Jesuit Jesuit NNP 13433 618 24 Father Father NNP 13433 618 25 has have VBZ 13433 618 26 no no DT 13433 618 27 more more RBR 13433 618 28 decided decide VBN 13433 618 29 opinion opinion NN 13433 618 30 to to TO 13433 618 31 express express VB 13433 618 32 than than IN 13433 618 33 : : : 13433 618 34 " " `` 13433 618 35 ut ut NNP 13433 618 36 haec haec NNP 13433 618 37 prudens pruden NNS 13433 618 38 , , , 13433 618 39 ac ac NNP 13433 618 40 justa justa NNP 13433 618 41 suspicio suspicio NNP 13433 618 42 sit sit NNP 13433 618 43 , , , 13433 618 44 illas illa NNS 13433 618 45 esse esse NNP 13433 618 46 genuinas genuinas NNP 13433 618 47 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 13433 618 48 epistolas epistola NNS 13433 618 49 , , , 13433 618 50 quas quas NNP 13433 618 51 antiquorum antiquorum NNP 13433 618 52 consensus consensus NNP 13433 618 53 illustribus illustribus NNP 13433 618 54 testimoniis testimoniis NNP 13433 618 55 commendatas commendatas NNP 13433 618 56 ac ac NNP 13433 618 57 approbatas approbatas NNP 13433 618 58 reliquit reliquit NNP 13433 618 59 . . . 13433 618 60 " " '' 13433 619 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 619 2 67:3 67:3 CD 13433 619 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 619 4 The the DT 13433 619 5 next next JJ 13433 619 6 note note NN 13433 619 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 619 8 3 3 CD 13433 619 9 ) ) -RRB- 13433 619 10 , , , 13433 619 11 p. p. NN 13433 619 12 260 260 CD 13433 619 13 , , , 13433 619 14 was be VBD 13433 619 15 only only RB 13433 619 16 separated separate VBN 13433 619 17 from from IN 13433 619 18 the the DT 13433 619 19 preceding precede VBG 13433 619 20 for for IN 13433 619 21 convenience convenience NN 13433 619 22 of of IN 13433 619 23 reference reference NN 13433 619 24 , , , 13433 619 25 and and CC 13433 619 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 619 27 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 619 28 quotes quote VBZ 13433 619 29 and and CC 13433 619 30 comments comment NNS 13433 619 31 upon upon IN 13433 619 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 619 33 as as IN 13433 619 34 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 13433 619 35 " " `` 13433 619 36 The the DT 13433 619 37 next next JJ 13433 619 38 note note NN 13433 619 39 ( ( -LRB- 13433 619 40 3 3 CD 13433 619 41 ) ) -RRB- 13433 619 42 , , , 13433 619 43 p. p. NN 13433 619 44 260 260 CD 13433 619 45 , , , 13433 619 46 is be VBZ 13433 619 47 as as IN 13433 619 48 follows:--"'[Wotton follows:--"'[wotton NN 13433 619 49 , , , 13433 619 50 _ _ NNP 13433 619 51 Praef Praef NNP 13433 619 52 . . . 13433 620 1 Clem Clem NNP 13433 620 2 . . . 13433 621 1 R. R. NNP 13433 621 2 Epp Epp NNP 13433 621 3 . . . 13433 621 4 _ _ NNP 13433 621 5 1718 1718 CD 13433 621 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 621 7 ; ; : 13433 621 8 J. J. NNP 13433 621 9 Owen Owen NNP 13433 621 10 , , , 13433 621 11 _ _ NNP 13433 621 12 Enquiry Enquiry NNP 13433 621 13 into into IN 13433 621 14 Original Original NNP 13433 621 15 Nature Nature NNP 13433 621 16 , , , 13433 621 17 & & CC 13433 621 18 c. c. NNP 13433 621 19 , , , 13433 621 20 Evang Evang NNP 13433 621 21 . . . 13433 622 1 Church church NN 13433 622 2 , , , 13433 622 3 Works Works NNP 13433 622 4 _ _ NNP 13433 622 5 , , , 13433 622 6 ed ed NNP 13433 622 7 . . . 13433 623 1 Russel Russel NNP 13433 623 2 , , , 13433 623 3 1826 1826 CD 13433 623 4 , , , 13433 623 5 vol vol NNP 13433 623 6 . . . 13433 624 1 xx xx NNP 13433 624 2 . . . 13433 625 1 p. p. NN 13433 625 2 147 147 CD 13433 625 3 ; ; : 13433 625 4 Oudin Oudin NNP 13433 625 5 , , , 13433 625 6 _ _ NNP 13433 625 7 Comm Comm NNP 13433 625 8 . . . 13433 626 1 de de NNP 13433 626 2 Script Script NNP 13433 626 3 . . . 13433 627 1 Eccles Eccles NNP 13433 627 2 . . . 13433 627 3 _ _ NNP 13433 627 4 & & CC 13433 627 5 c. c. NNP 13433 627 6 1722 1722 CD 13433 627 7 , , , 13433 627 8 p. p. NN 13433 627 9 88 88 CD 13433 627 10 ; ; : 13433 627 11 Lampe Lampe NNP 13433 627 12 , , , 13433 627 13 _ _ NNP 13433 627 14 Comm Comm NNP 13433 627 15 . . . 13433 628 1 analyt analyt NNP 13433 628 2 . . . 13433 629 1 ex ex NNP 13433 629 2 Evang Evang NNP 13433 629 3 . . . 13433 630 1 Joan Joan NNP 13433 630 2 . . . 13433 630 3 _ _ NNP 13433 630 4 1724 1724 CD 13433 630 5 , , , 13433 630 6 i. i. NNP 13433 630 7 p. p. NN 13433 630 8 184 184 CD 13433 630 9 ; ; : 13433 630 10 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 630 11 , , , 13433 630 12 _ _ NNP 13433 630 13 Credibility Credibility NNP 13433 630 14 _ _ NNP 13433 630 15 , , , 13433 630 16 & & CC 13433 630 17 c. c. NNP 13433 630 18 , , , 13433 630 19 _ _ NNP 13433 630 20 Works Works NNP 13433 630 21 _ _ NNP 13433 630 22 , , , 13433 630 23 ii ii NNP 13433 630 24 . . . 13433 631 1 p. p. NN 13433 631 2 68 68 CD 13433 631 3 f. f. NNS 13433 631 4 ; ; : 13433 631 5 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 13433 631 6 , , , 13433 631 7 _ _ NNP 13433 631 8 Hist Hist NNP 13433 631 9 . . . 13433 632 1 Crit Crit NNP 13433 632 2 . . . 13433 633 1 de de NNP 13433 633 2 Manichée Manichée NNP 13433 633 3 _ _ NNP 13433 633 4 , , , 13433 633 5 & & CC 13433 633 6 c. c. NNP 13433 633 7 1734 1734 CD 13433 633 8 , , , 13433 633 9 i. i. NNP 13433 633 10 p. p. NN 13433 633 11 378 378 CD 13433 633 12 , , , 13433 633 13 note note VBP 13433 633 14 3 3 CD 13433 633 15 ; ; : 13433 633 16 Ernesti Ernesti NNP 13433 633 17 , , , 13433 633 18 _ _ NNP 13433 633 19 N. N. NNP 13433 634 1 Theol Theol NNP 13433 634 2 . . . 13433 635 1 Biblioth biblioth NN 13433 635 2 . . . 13433 635 3 _ _ NNP 13433 635 4 1761 1761 CD 13433 635 5 , , , 13433 635 6 ii ii NNP 13433 635 7 . . . 13433 636 1 p. p. NN 13433 636 2 489 489 CD 13433 636 3 ; ; : 13433 636 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 636 5 Mosheim Mosheim NNP 13433 636 6 , , , 13433 636 7 _ _ NNP 13433 636 8 De De NNP 13433 636 9 Rebus Rebus NNP 13433 636 10 Christ Christ NNP 13433 636 11 . . . 13433 636 12 _ _ NNP 13433 636 13 p. p. NN 13433 636 14 159 159 CD 13433 636 15 f. f. NN 13433 636 16 ] ] -RRB- 13433 636 17 ; ; : 13433 636 18 Weismann Weismann NNP 13433 636 19 , , , 13433 636 20 _ _ NNP 13433 636 21 Introd Introd NNP 13433 636 22 . . . 13433 637 1 in in IN 13433 637 2 Memorab Memorab NNP 13433 637 3 . . . 13433 638 1 Eccles Eccles NNP 13433 638 2 . . . 13433 638 3 _ _ NNP 13433 638 4 1745 1745 CD 13433 638 5 , , , 13433 638 6 i. i. NNP 13433 638 7 p. p. NN 13433 638 8 137 137 CD 13433 638 9 ; ; : 13433 638 10 Heumann Heumann NNP 13433 638 11 , , , 13433 638 12 _ _ NNP 13433 638 13 Conspect Conspect NNP 13433 638 14 . . . 13433 639 1 Reipub Reipub NNP 13433 639 2 . . . 13433 640 1 Lit Lit NNP 13433 640 2 . . . 13433 640 3 _ _ NNP 13433 640 4 1763 1763 CD 13433 640 5 , , , 13433 640 6 p. p. NN 13433 640 7 492 492 CD 13433 640 8 ; ; : 13433 640 9 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 13433 640 10 , , , 13433 640 11 _ _ NNP 13433 640 12 Chr Chr NNP 13433 640 13 . . . 13433 641 1 Kirchengesch Kirchengesch NNP 13433 641 2 . . . 13433 641 3 _ _ NNP 13433 641 4 1775 1775 CD 13433 641 5 , , , 13433 641 6 ii ii NNP 13433 641 7 . . . 13433 642 1 p. p. NN 13433 642 2 341 341 CD 13433 642 3 ; ; : 13433 642 4 Griesbach Griesbach NNP 13433 642 5 , , , 13433 642 6 _ _ NNP 13433 642 7 Opuscula Opuscula NNP 13433 642 8 Academ Academ NNP 13433 642 9 . . . 13433 642 10 _ _ NNP 13433 642 11 1824 1824 CD 13433 642 12 , , , 13433 642 13 i. i. NNP 13433 642 14 p. p. NN 13433 642 15 26 26 CD 13433 642 16 ; ; : 13433 642 17 Rosenmüller Rosenmüller NNP 13433 642 18 , , , 13433 642 19 _ _ NNP 13433 642 20 Hist Hist NNP 13433 642 21 . . . 13433 643 1 Interpr interpr VB 13433 643 2 . . . 13433 644 1 Libr libr JJ 13433 644 2 . . . 13433 645 1 Sacr Sacr NNP 13433 645 2 . . . 13433 646 1 in in IN 13433 646 2 Eccles Eccles NNP 13433 646 3 . . . 13433 646 4 _ _ NNP 13433 646 5 1795 1795 CD 13433 646 6 , , , 13433 646 7 i. i. NNP 13433 646 8 p. p. NN 13433 646 9 116 116 CD 13433 646 10 ; ; : 13433 646 11 Semler Semler NNP 13433 646 12 , , , 13433 646 13 _ _ NNP 13433 646 14 Paraphr Paraphr NNP 13433 646 15 . . . 13433 647 1 in in IN 13433 647 2 Epist Epist NNP 13433 647 3 II II NNP 13433 647 4 . . . 13433 648 1 Petri Petri NNP 13433 648 2 . . . 13433 648 3 _ _ NNP 13433 648 4 1784 1784 CD 13433 648 5 , , , 13433 648 6 _ _ NNP 13433 648 7 Praef Praef NNP 13433 648 8 . . . 13433 648 9 _ _ NNP 13433 648 10 ; ; : 13433 648 11 Kestner Kestner NNP 13433 648 12 , , , 13433 648 13 _ _ NNP 13433 648 14 Comm Comm NNP 13433 648 15 . . . 13433 649 1 de de NNP 13433 649 2 Eusebii Eusebii NNP 13433 649 3 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 650 1 condit condit NNP 13433 650 2 . . . 13433 650 3 _ _ NNP 13433 650 4 1816 1816 CD 13433 650 5 , , , 13433 650 6 p. p. NN 13433 650 7 63 63 CD 13433 650 8 ; ; : 13433 650 9 Henke Henke NNP 13433 650 10 , , , 13433 650 11 _ _ NNP 13433 650 12 Allg Allg NNP 13433 650 13 . . . 13433 651 1 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 651 2 . . . 13433 652 1 chr chr NNP 13433 652 2 . . . 13433 653 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 653 2 _ _ NNP 13433 653 3 , , , 13433 653 4 1818 1818 CD 13433 653 5 , , , 13433 653 6 i. i. NNP 13433 653 7 p. p. NN 13433 653 8 96 96 CD 13433 653 9 ; ; : 13433 653 10 Neander Neander NNP 13433 653 11 , , , 13433 653 12 _ _ NNP 13433 653 13 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 653 14 _ _ NNP 13433 653 15 1843 1843 CD 13433 653 16 , , , 13433 653 17 ii ii NNP 13433 653 18 . . . 13433 654 1 p. p. NN 13433 654 2 1140 1140 CD 13433 654 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 654 4 cf cf NN 13433 654 5 . . . 13433 655 1 i. i. NNP 13433 655 2 p. p. NNP 13433 655 3 327 327 CD 13433 655 4 , , , 13433 655 5 Anm anm CC 13433 655 6 . . . 13433 656 1 11 11 CD 13433 656 2 ; ; : 13433 656 3 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 13433 656 4 - - HYPH 13433 656 5 Crusius Crusius NNP 13433 656 6 , , , 13433 656 7 _ _ NNP 13433 656 8 Lehrb Lehrb NNP 13433 656 9 . . . 13433 657 1 chr chr NNP 13433 657 2 . . . 13433 658 1 Dogmengesch Dogmengesch NNP 13433 658 2 . . . 13433 658 3 _ _ NNP 13433 658 4 1832 1832 CD 13433 658 5 , , , 13433 658 6 p. p. NN 13433 658 7 83 83 CD 13433 658 8 ; ; : 13433 658 9 cf cf NN 13433 658 10 . . . 13433 659 1 _ _ NNP 13433 659 2 Comp Comp NNP 13433 659 3 . . . 13433 660 1 chr chr NNP 13433 660 2 . . . 13433 661 1 Dogmengesch Dogmengesch NNP 13433 661 2 . . . 13433 661 3 _ _ NNP 13433 661 4 1840 1840 CD 13433 661 5 , , , 13433 661 6 p. p. NN 13433 661 7 79 79 CD 13433 661 8 ; ; : 13433 661 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 661 10 Niedner Niedner NNP 13433 661 11 , , , 13433 661 12 _ _ NNP 13433 661 13 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 661 14 . . . 13433 662 1 chr chr NNP 13433 662 2 . . . 13433 663 1 K. K. NNP 13433 663 2 _ _ NNP 13433 663 3 p. p. NN 13433 663 4 196 196 CD 13433 663 5 ; ; : 13433 663 6 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 663 7 , , , 13433 663 8 _ _ NNP 13433 663 9 Die Die NNP 13433 663 10 K. K. NNP 13433 663 11 i -PRON- PRP 13433 663 12 m be VBP 13433 663 13 ap ap NNP 13433 663 14 . . . 13433 664 1 Zeit Zeit NNP 13433 664 2 . . . 13433 664 3 _ _ NNP 13433 664 4 p. p. NN 13433 664 5 322 322 CD 13433 664 6 ; ; : 13433 664 7 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 664 8 , , , 13433 664 9 _ _ NNP 13433 664 10 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 664 11 _ _ NNP 13433 664 12 i. i. NNP 13433 664 13 p. p. NN 13433 664 14 115 115 CD 13433 664 15 f. f. NNP 13433 664 16 ] ] -RRB- 13433 664 17 ; ; : 13433 664 18 cf cf NN 13433 664 19 . . . 13433 665 1 _ _ NNP 13433 665 2 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 665 3 , , , 13433 665 4 Vind Vind NNP 13433 665 5 . . . 13433 666 1 Ign Ign NNP 13433 666 2 . . . 13433 667 1 Append append NN 13433 667 2 . . . 13433 667 3 _ _ NNP 13433 667 4 ; ; : 13433 667 5 Ziegler Ziegler NNP 13433 667 6 , , , 13433 667 7 _ _ NNP 13433 667 8 Versuch Versuch NNP 13433 667 9 eine eine NN 13433 667 10 prag prag NN 13433 667 11 . . . 13433 668 1 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 668 2 . . . 13433 669 1 d. d. NNP 13433 669 2 kirchl kirchl NNP 13433 669 3 . . . 13433 670 1 Verfassungsformen verfassungsforman NNS 13433 670 2 , , , 13433 670 3 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 670 4 . . . 13433 670 5 _ _ NNP 13433 670 6 1798 1798 CD 13433 670 7 , , , 13433 670 8 p. p. NN 13433 670 9 16 16 CD 13433 670 10 ; ; : 13433 670 11 J.E.C. J.E.C. NNP 13433 671 1 Schmidt Schmidt NNP 13433 671 2 , , , 13433 671 3 _ _ NNP 13433 671 4 Versuch Versuch NNP 13433 671 5 üb üb NNP 13433 671 6 . . . 13433 672 1 d. d. NNP 13433 672 2 gedopp gedopp NNP 13433 672 3 . . . 13433 673 1 Recens Recens NNP 13433 673 2 . . . 13433 674 1 d. d. NNP 13433 674 2 Br Br NNP 13433 674 3 . . . 13433 675 1 S. S. NNP 13433 675 2 Ignat Ignat NNP 13433 675 3 . . . 13433 675 4 _ _ NNP 13433 675 5 , , , 13433 675 6 in in IN 13433 675 7 Henke Henke NNP 13433 675 8 's 's POS 13433 675 9 _ _ NNP 13433 675 10 Mag Mag NNP 13433 675 11 . . . 13433 676 1 f. f. NNP 13433 676 2 Rel Rel NNP 13433 676 3 . . . 13433 677 1 Phil Phil NNP 13433 677 2 . . . 13433 678 1 u.s.w u.s.w UH 13433 678 2 . . . 13433 678 3 _ _ NNP 13433 678 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 678 5 1795 1795 CD 13433 678 6 ; ; : 13433 678 7 cf cf NN 13433 678 8 . . . 13433 679 1 _ _ NNP 13433 679 2 Biblioth Biblioth NNP 13433 679 3 . . . 13433 680 1 f. f. NNP 13433 680 2 Krit Krit NNP 13433 680 3 . . . 13433 681 1 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 681 2 . . NNP 13433 681 3 , , , 13433 681 4 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 681 5 _ _ NNP 13433 681 6 i. i. NNP 13433 681 7 p p NNP 13433 681 8 463 463 CD 13433 681 9 ff ff NNS 13433 681 10 . . . 13433 682 1 _ _ NNP 13433 682 2 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 682 3 . . . 13433 683 1 kath kath NNP 13433 683 2 . . . 13433 684 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 684 2 _ _ NNP 13433 684 3 , , , 13433 684 4 II II NNP 13433 684 5 . . . 13433 685 1 i. i. NNP 13433 685 2 p. p. NNP 13433 685 3 1 1 CD 13433 685 4 f. f. NNP 13433 685 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 685 6 ; ; : 13433 685 7 _ _ NNP 13433 685 8 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 685 9 Chr Chr NNP 13433 685 10 . . . 13433 686 1 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 686 2 _ _ NNP 13433 686 3 i. i. NNP 13433 686 4 p. p. NN 13433 687 1 200 200 CD 13433 687 2 . . . 13433 687 3 ' ' '' 13433 688 1 " " `` 13433 688 2 The the DT 13433 688 3 brackets bracket NNS 13433 688 4 are be VBP 13433 688 5 not not RB 13433 688 6 the the DT 13433 688 7 author author NN 13433 688 8 's 's POS 13433 688 9 , , , 13433 688 10 but but CC 13433 688 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 688 12 own own JJ 13433 688 13 . . . 13433 689 1 " " `` 13433 689 2 This this DT 13433 689 3 is be VBZ 13433 689 4 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 689 5 one one CD 13433 689 6 of of IN 13433 689 7 those those DT 13433 689 8 exhibitions exhibition NNS 13433 689 9 of of IN 13433 689 10 learning learning NN 13433 689 11 which which WDT 13433 689 12 have have VBP 13433 689 13 made make VBN 13433 689 14 such such PDT 13433 689 15 a a DT 13433 689 16 deep deep JJ 13433 689 17 impression impression NN 13433 689 18 on on IN 13433 689 19 the the DT 13433 689 20 reviewers reviewer NNS 13433 689 21 . . . 13433 690 1 Certainly certainly RB 13433 690 2 , , , 13433 690 3 as as IN 13433 690 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 690 5 stands stand VBZ 13433 690 6 , , , 13433 690 7 this this DT 13433 690 8 note note NN 13433 690 9 suggests suggest VBZ 13433 690 10 a a DT 13433 690 11 thorough thorough JJ 13433 690 12 acquaintance acquaintance NN 13433 690 13 with with IN 13433 690 14 all all PDT 13433 690 15 the the DT 13433 690 16 by by NN 13433 690 17 - - HYPH 13433 690 18 paths path NNS 13433 690 19 of of IN 13433 690 20 the the DT 13433 690 21 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 690 22 literature literature NN 13433 690 23 , , , 13433 690 24 and and CC 13433 690 25 seems seem VBZ 13433 690 26 to to TO 13433 690 27 represent represent VB 13433 690 28 the the DT 13433 690 29 gleanings gleaning NNS 13433 690 30 of of IN 13433 690 31 many many JJ 13433 690 32 years year NNS 13433 690 33 ' ' POS 13433 690 34 reading reading NN 13433 690 35 . . . 13433 691 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 691 2 is be VBZ 13433 691 3 important important JJ 13433 691 4 to to TO 13433 691 5 observe observe VB 13433 691 6 , , , 13433 691 7 however however RB 13433 691 8 , , , 13433 691 9 that that IN 13433 691 10 every every DT 13433 691 11 one one CD 13433 691 12 of of IN 13433 691 13 these these DT 13433 691 14 references reference NNS 13433 691 15 , , , 13433 691 16 except except IN 13433 691 17 those those DT 13433 691 18 which which WDT 13433 691 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 691 20 have have VBP 13433 691 21 included include VBN 13433 691 22 in in IN 13433 691 23 brackets bracket NNS 13433 691 24 , , , 13433 691 25 is be VBZ 13433 691 26 given give VBN 13433 691 27 in in IN 13433 691 28 the the DT 13433 691 29 appendix appendix NNP 13433 691 30 to to IN 13433 691 31 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 691 32 's 's POS 13433 691 33 ' ' `` 13433 691 34 Vindiciae Vindiciae NNS 13433 691 35 Ignatianae ignatianae RB 13433 691 36 , , , 13433 691 37 ' ' '' 13433 691 38 where where WRB 13433 691 39 the the DT 13433 691 40 passages passage NNS 13433 691 41 are be VBP 13433 691 42 quoted quote VBN 13433 691 43 in in IN 13433 691 44 full full JJ 13433 691 45 . . . 13433 692 1 Thus thus RB 13433 692 2 two two CD 13433 692 3 - - HYPH 13433 692 4 thirds third NNS 13433 692 5 of of IN 13433 692 6 this this DT 13433 692 7 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 692 8 note note NN 13433 692 9 might may MD 13433 692 10 have have VB 13433 692 11 been be VBN 13433 692 12 compiled compile VBN 13433 692 13 in in IN 13433 692 14 ten ten CD 13433 692 15 minutes minute NNS 13433 692 16 . . . 13433 693 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 693 2 author author NN 13433 693 3 has have VBZ 13433 693 4 here here RB 13433 693 5 and and CC 13433 693 6 there there EX 13433 693 7 transposed transpose VBD 13433 693 8 the the DT 13433 693 9 order order NN 13433 693 10 of of IN 13433 693 11 the the DT 13433 693 12 quotations quotation NNS 13433 693 13 , , , 13433 693 14 and and CC 13433 693 15 confused confuse VBD 13433 693 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 693 17 by by IN 13433 693 18 so so RB 13433 693 19 doing do VBG 13433 693 20 , , , 13433 693 21 for for IN 13433 693 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 693 23 is be VBZ 13433 693 24 chronological chronological JJ 13433 693 25 in in IN 13433 693 26 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 693 27 . . . 13433 694 1 But but CC 13433 694 2 what what WP 13433 694 3 purpose purpose NN 13433 694 4 was be VBD 13433 694 5 served serve VBN 13433 694 6 by by IN 13433 694 7 thus thus RB 13433 694 8 importing import VBG 13433 694 9 into into IN 13433 694 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 694 11 notes note NNS 13433 694 12 a a DT 13433 694 13 mass mass NN 13433 694 14 of of IN 13433 694 15 borrowed borrow VBN 13433 694 16 and and CC 13433 694 17 unsorted unsorted JJ 13433 694 18 references reference NNS 13433 694 19 ? ? . 13433 695 1 And and CC 13433 695 2 , , , 13433 695 3 if if IN 13433 695 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 695 5 thought think VBD 13433 695 6 fit fit JJ 13433 695 7 to to TO 13433 695 8 do do VB 13433 695 9 so so RB 13433 695 10 , , , 13433 695 11 why why WRB 13433 695 12 was be VBD 13433 695 13 the the DT 13433 695 14 key key JJ 13433 695 15 - - HYPH 13433 695 16 reference reference NN 13433 695 17 to to IN 13433 695 18 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 695 19 buried bury VBN 13433 695 20 among among IN 13433 695 21 the the DT 13433 695 22 rest rest NN 13433 695 23 , , , 13433 695 24 so so IN 13433 695 25 that that IN 13433 695 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 695 27 stands stand VBZ 13433 695 28 in in IN 13433 695 29 immediate immediate JJ 13433 695 30 connection connection NN 13433 695 31 with with IN 13433 695 32 some some DT 13433 695 33 additional additional JJ 13433 695 34 references reference NNS 13433 695 35 on on IN 13433 695 36 which which WDT 13433 695 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 695 38 has have VBZ 13433 695 39 no no DT 13433 695 40 bearing bearing NN 13433 695 41 ? ? . 13433 695 42 " " '' 13433 696 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 696 2 68:1 68:1 CD 13433 696 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 696 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 696 5 do do VBP 13433 696 6 not not RB 13433 696 7 see see VB 13433 696 8 any any DT 13433 696 9 special special JJ 13433 696 10 virtue virtue NN 13433 696 11 in in IN 13433 696 12 the the DT 13433 696 13 amount amount NN 13433 696 14 of of IN 13433 696 15 time time NN 13433 696 16 which which WDT 13433 696 17 might may MD 13433 696 18 suffice suffice VB 13433 696 19 , , , 13433 696 20 under under IN 13433 696 21 some some DT 13433 696 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 696 23 , , , 13433 696 24 to to TO 13433 696 25 compile compile VB 13433 696 26 a a DT 13433 696 27 note note NN 13433 696 28 , , , 13433 696 29 although although IN 13433 696 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 696 31 is be VBZ 13433 696 32 here here RB 13433 696 33 advanced advanced JJ 13433 696 34 as as IN 13433 696 35 an an DT 13433 696 36 important important JJ 13433 696 37 point point NN 13433 696 38 to to TO 13433 696 39 observe observe VB 13433 696 40 , , , 13433 696 41 but but CC 13433 696 42 I -PRON- PRP 13433 696 43 call call VBP 13433 696 44 attention attention NN 13433 696 45 to to IN 13433 696 46 the the DT 13433 696 47 unfair unfair JJ 13433 696 48 spirit spirit NN 13433 696 49 in in IN 13433 696 50 which which WDT 13433 696 51 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 696 52 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 696 53 's 's POS 13433 696 54 criticisms criticism NNS 13433 696 55 are be VBP 13433 696 56 made make VBN 13433 696 57 . . . 13433 697 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 697 2 ask ask VBP 13433 697 3 every every DT 13433 697 4 just just RB 13433 697 5 - - HYPH 13433 697 6 minded minded JJ 13433 697 7 reader reader NN 13433 697 8 to to TO 13433 697 9 consider consider VB 13433 697 10 what what WP 13433 697 11 right right UH 13433 697 12 any any DT 13433 697 13 critic critic NN 13433 697 14 has have VBZ 13433 697 15 to to TO 13433 697 16 insinuate insinuate VB 13433 697 17 , , , 13433 697 18 if if IN 13433 697 19 not not RB 13433 697 20 directly directly RB 13433 697 21 to to TO 13433 697 22 say say VB 13433 697 23 , , , 13433 697 24 that that IN 13433 697 25 , , , 13433 697 26 because because IN 13433 697 27 some some DT 13433 697 28 of of IN 13433 697 29 the the DT 13433 697 30 references reference NNS 13433 697 31 in in IN 13433 697 32 a a DT 13433 697 33 note note NN 13433 697 34 are be VBP 13433 697 35 also also RB 13433 697 36 given give VBN 13433 697 37 by by IN 13433 697 38 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 697 39 , , , 13433 697 40 I -PRON- PRP 13433 697 41 simply simply RB 13433 697 42 took take VBD 13433 697 43 them -PRON- PRP 13433 697 44 from from IN 13433 697 45 him -PRON- PRP 13433 697 46 , , , 13433 697 47 and and CC 13433 697 48 thus thus RB 13433 697 49 " " `` 13433 697 50 imported import VBN 13433 697 51 into into IN 13433 697 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 697 53 notes note NNS 13433 697 54 a a DT 13433 697 55 mass mass NN 13433 697 56 of of IN 13433 697 57 borrowed borrow VBN 13433 697 58 and and CC 13433 697 59 unsorted unsorted JJ 13433 697 60 references reference NNS 13433 697 61 , , , 13433 697 62 " " '' 13433 697 63 and and CC 13433 697 64 further far RBR 13433 697 65 to to TO 13433 697 66 insinuate insinuate VB 13433 697 67 that that IN 13433 697 68 I -PRON- PRP 13433 697 69 " " `` 13433 697 70 here here RB 13433 697 71 and and CC 13433 697 72 there there EX 13433 697 73 transposed transpose VBD 13433 697 74 the the DT 13433 697 75 order order NN 13433 697 76 " " `` 13433 697 77 apparently apparently RB 13433 697 78 to to TO 13433 697 79 conceal conceal VB 13433 697 80 the the DT 13433 697 81 source source NN 13433 697 82 ? ? . 13433 698 1 This this DT 13433 698 2 is be VBZ 13433 698 3 a a DT 13433 698 4 kind kind NN 13433 698 5 of of IN 13433 698 6 criticism criticism NN 13433 698 7 which which WDT 13433 698 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 698 9 very very RB 13433 698 10 gladly gladly RB 13433 698 11 relinquish relinquish VBP 13433 698 12 entirely entirely RB 13433 698 13 to to IN 13433 698 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 698 15 high high JJ 13433 698 16 - - HYPH 13433 698 17 minded minded JJ 13433 698 18 and and CC 13433 698 19 reverend reverend JJ 13433 698 20 opponent opponent NN 13433 698 21 . . . 13433 699 1 Now now RB 13433 699 2 , , , 13433 699 3 as as IN 13433 699 4 full full JJ 13433 699 5 quotations quotation NNS 13433 699 6 are be VBP 13433 699 7 given give VBN 13433 699 8 in in IN 13433 699 9 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 699 10 's 's POS 13433 699 11 appendix appendix NNP 13433 699 12 , , , 13433 699 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 699 14 should should MD 13433 699 15 have have VB 13433 699 16 been be VBN 13433 699 17 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 699 18 entitled entitle VBN 13433 699 19 to to TO 13433 699 20 take take VB 13433 699 21 references reference NNS 13433 699 22 from from IN 13433 699 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 699 24 , , , 13433 699 25 had have VBD 13433 699 26 I -PRON- PRP 13433 699 27 pleased pleased JJ 13433 699 28 , , , 13433 699 29 and and CC 13433 699 30 for for IN 13433 699 31 the the DT 13433 699 32 convenience convenience NN 13433 699 33 of of IN 13433 699 34 many many JJ 13433 699 35 readers reader NNS 13433 699 36 I -PRON- PRP 13433 699 37 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 699 38 indicate indicate VBP 13433 699 39 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 699 40 's 's POS 13433 699 41 work work NN 13433 699 42 , , , 13433 699 43 in in IN 13433 699 44 the the DT 13433 699 45 note note NN 13433 699 46 , , , 13433 699 47 as as IN 13433 699 48 a a DT 13433 699 49 source source NN 13433 699 50 to to TO 13433 699 51 be be VB 13433 699 52 compared compare VBN 13433 699 53 . . . 13433 700 1 The the DT 13433 700 2 fact fact NN 13433 700 3 is be VBZ 13433 700 4 , , , 13433 700 5 however however RB 13433 700 6 , , , 13433 700 7 that that IN 13433 700 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 700 9 did do VBD 13433 700 10 not not RB 13433 700 11 take take VB 13433 700 12 the the DT 13433 700 13 references reference NNS 13433 700 14 from from IN 13433 700 15 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 700 16 , , , 13433 700 17 but but CC 13433 700 18 in in IN 13433 700 19 every every DT 13433 700 20 case case NN 13433 700 21 derived derive VBD 13433 700 22 them -PRON- PRP 13433 700 23 from from IN 13433 700 24 the the DT 13433 700 25 works work NNS 13433 700 26 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 700 27 , , , 13433 700 28 and and CC 13433 700 29 if if IN 13433 700 30 the the DT 13433 700 31 note note NN 13433 700 32 " " `` 13433 700 33 seems seem VBZ 13433 700 34 to to TO 13433 700 35 represent represent VB 13433 700 36 the the DT 13433 700 37 gleanings gleaning NNS 13433 700 38 of of IN 13433 700 39 many many JJ 13433 700 40 years year NNS 13433 700 41 ' ' POS 13433 700 42 reading reading NN 13433 700 43 , , , 13433 700 44 " " `` 13433 700 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 700 46 certainly certainly RB 13433 700 47 does do VBZ 13433 700 48 not not RB 13433 700 49 misrepresent misrepresent VB 13433 700 50 the the DT 13433 700 51 fact fact NN 13433 700 52 , , , 13433 700 53 for for CC 13433 700 54 I -PRON- PRP 13433 700 55 took take VBD 13433 700 56 the the DT 13433 700 57 trouble trouble NN 13433 700 58 to to TO 13433 700 59 make make VB 13433 700 60 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 700 61 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 700 62 with with IN 13433 700 63 the the DT 13433 700 64 " " `` 13433 700 65 by by IN 13433 700 66 - - HYPH 13433 700 67 paths path NNS 13433 700 68 of of IN 13433 700 69 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 700 70 literature literature NN 13433 700 71 . . . 13433 700 72 " " '' 13433 701 1 Now now RB 13433 701 2 in in IN 13433 701 3 analysing analyse VBG 13433 701 4 the the DT 13433 701 5 references reference NNS 13433 701 6 in in IN 13433 701 7 this this DT 13433 701 8 note note NN 13433 701 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 701 10 must must MD 13433 701 11 be be VB 13433 701 12 borne bear VBN 13433 701 13 in in IN 13433 701 14 mind mind NN 13433 701 15 that that IN 13433 701 16 they -PRON- PRP 13433 701 17 illustrate illustrate VBP 13433 701 18 the the DT 13433 701 19 statement statement NN 13433 701 20 that that IN 13433 701 21 " " `` 13433 701 22 _ _ NNP 13433 701 23 doubts doubt NNS 13433 701 24 , , , 13433 701 25 more more RBR 13433 701 26 or or CC 13433 701 27 less less RBR 13433 701 28 definite definite JJ 13433 701 29 _ _ NNP 13433 701 30 , , , 13433 701 31 " " `` 13433 701 32 continued continue VBD 13433 701 33 to to TO 13433 701 34 be be VB 13433 701 35 expressed express VBN 13433 701 36 regarding regard VBG 13433 701 37 the the DT 13433 701 38 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 701 39 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 701 40 . . . 13433 702 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 702 2 am be VBP 13433 702 3 much much RB 13433 702 4 obliged oblige VBN 13433 702 5 to to IN 13433 702 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 702 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 702 8 for for IN 13433 702 9 drawing draw VBG 13433 702 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 702 11 attention attention NN 13433 702 12 to to IN 13433 702 13 Wotton Wotton NNP 13433 702 14 . . . 13433 703 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 703 2 name name NN 13433 703 3 is be VBZ 13433 703 4 the the DT 13433 703 5 first first JJ 13433 703 6 in in IN 13433 703 7 the the DT 13433 703 8 note note NN 13433 703 9 , , , 13433 703 10 and and CC 13433 703 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 703 12 unfortunately unfortunately RB 13433 703 13 was be VBD 13433 703 14 the the DT 13433 703 15 last last JJ 13433 703 16 in in IN 13433 703 17 a a DT 13433 703 18 list list NN 13433 703 19 on on IN 13433 703 20 another another DT 13433 703 21 point point NN 13433 703 22 in in IN 13433 703 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 703 24 note note NN 13433 703 25 - - HYPH 13433 703 26 book book NN 13433 703 27 , , , 13433 703 28 immediately immediately RB 13433 703 29 preceding precede VBG 13433 703 30 this this DT 13433 703 31 one one NN 13433 703 32 , , , 13433 703 33 and and CC 13433 703 34 was be VBD 13433 703 35 by by IN 13433 703 36 mistake mistake NN 13433 703 37 included include VBN 13433 703 38 in in IN 13433 703 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 703 40 . . . 13433 704 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 704 2 also also RB 13433 704 3 frankly frankly RB 13433 704 4 give give VBP 13433 704 5 up up RP 13433 704 6 Weismann Weismann NNP 13433 704 7 , , , 13433 704 8 whose whose WP$ 13433 704 9 doubts doubt NNS 13433 704 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 704 11 find find VBP 13433 704 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 704 13 had have VBD 13433 704 14 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 13433 704 15 , , , 13433 704 16 and and CC 13433 704 17 proceed proceed VB 13433 704 18 to to TO 13433 704 19 examine examine VB 13433 704 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 704 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 704 22 's 's POS 13433 704 23 further further JJ 13433 704 24 statements statement NNS 13433 704 25 . . . 13433 705 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 705 2 says say VBZ 13433 705 3 that that IN 13433 705 4 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 705 5 uses use VBZ 13433 705 6 the the DT 13433 705 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 705 8 as as IN 13433 705 9 genuine genuine JJ 13433 705 10 , , , 13433 705 11 and and CC 13433 705 12 that that IN 13433 705 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 705 14 only only JJ 13433 705 15 doubt doubt NN 13433 705 16 is be VBZ 13433 705 17 whether whether IN 13433 705 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 705 19 ought ought MD 13433 705 20 not not RB 13433 705 21 to to TO 13433 705 22 accept accept VB 13433 705 23 the the DT 13433 705 24 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 705 25 . . . 13433 706 1 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 706 2 , , , 13433 706 3 however however RB 13433 706 4 , , , 13433 706 5 admits admit VBZ 13433 706 6 that that IN 13433 706 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 706 8 can can MD 13433 706 9 not not RB 13433 706 10 quote quote VB 13433 706 11 either either CC 13433 706 12 the the DT 13433 706 13 seven seven CD 13433 706 14 or or CC 13433 706 15 the the DT 13433 706 16 three three CD 13433 706 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 706 18 as as IN 13433 706 19 genuine genuine JJ 13433 706 20 . . . 13433 707 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 707 2 says say VBZ 13433 707 3 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 707 4 : : : 13433 707 5 " " `` 13433 707 6 These these DT 13433 707 7 three three CD 13433 707 8 Syriac Syriac NNPS 13433 707 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 707 10 lie lie VBP 13433 707 11 under under IN 13433 707 12 the the DT 13433 707 13 suspicion suspicion NN 13433 707 14 that that IN 13433 707 15 they -PRON- PRP 13433 707 16 are be VBP 13433 707 17 not not RB 13433 707 18 an an DT 13433 707 19 older old JJR 13433 707 20 text text NN 13433 707 21 , , , 13433 707 22 but but CC 13433 707 23 merely merely RB 13433 707 24 an an DT 13433 707 25 epitome epitome NN 13433 707 26 of of IN 13433 707 27 the the DT 13433 707 28 seven seven CD 13433 707 29 , , , 13433 707 30 for for IN 13433 707 31 the the DT 13433 707 32 other other JJ 13433 707 33 notes note NNS 13433 707 34 found find VBN 13433 707 35 in in IN 13433 707 36 the the DT 13433 707 37 same same JJ 13433 707 38 MS MS NNP 13433 707 39 . . . 13433 707 40 seem seem VBP 13433 707 41 to to TO 13433 707 42 be be VB 13433 707 43 excerpts excerpt NNS 13433 707 44 . . . 13433 708 1 But but CC 13433 708 2 on on IN 13433 708 3 the the DT 13433 708 4 other other JJ 13433 708 5 hand hand NN 13433 708 6 , , , 13433 708 7 the the DT 13433 708 8 doubts doubt NNS 13433 708 9 regarding regard VBG 13433 708 10 the the DT 13433 708 11 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 708 12 of of IN 13433 708 13 the the DT 13433 708 14 seven seven CD 13433 708 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 708 16 , , , 13433 708 17 in in IN 13433 708 18 the the DT 13433 708 19 form form NN 13433 708 20 in in IN 13433 708 21 which which WDT 13433 708 22 they -PRON- PRP 13433 708 23 are be VBP 13433 708 24 known know VBN 13433 708 25 since since IN 13433 708 26 Usher Usher NNP 13433 708 27 's 's POS 13433 708 28 time time NN 13433 708 29 , , , 13433 708 30 are be VBP 13433 708 31 not not RB 13433 708 32 yet yet RB 13433 708 33 entirely entirely RB 13433 708 34 removed remove VBN 13433 708 35 . . . 13433 709 1 For for IN 13433 709 2 no no DT 13433 709 3 MS MS NNP 13433 709 4 . . . 13433 709 5 has have VBZ 13433 709 6 yet yet RB 13433 709 7 been be VBN 13433 709 8 found find VBN 13433 709 9 which which WDT 13433 709 10 contains contain VBZ 13433 709 11 _ _ NNP 13433 709 12 only only RB 13433 709 13 _ _ NNP 13433 709 14 the the DT 13433 709 15 seven seven CD 13433 709 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 709 17 attested attest VBN 13433 709 18 by by IN 13433 709 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 709 20 , , , 13433 709 21 a a DT 13433 709 22 MS MS NNP 13433 709 23 . . . 13433 709 24 such such JJ 13433 709 25 as as IN 13433 709 26 lay lie VBN 13433 709 27 before before IN 13433 709 28 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 709 29 . . . 13433 709 30 " " '' 13433 710 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 710 2 70:1 70:1 CD 13433 710 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 710 4 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 710 5 , , , 13433 710 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 710 7 , , , 13433 710 8 does do VBZ 13433 710 9 express express VB 13433 710 10 " " `` 13433 710 11 doubts doubt NNS 13433 710 12 , , , 13433 710 13 more more RBR 13433 710 14 or or CC 13433 710 15 less less RBR 13433 710 16 definite definite JJ 13433 710 17 . . . 13433 710 18 " " '' 13433 711 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 711 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 711 3 then then RB 13433 711 4 continues continue VBZ 13433 711 5 : : : 13433 711 6 " " `` 13433 711 7 Of of IN 13433 711 8 the the DT 13433 711 9 rest rest NN 13433 711 10 a a DT 13433 711 11 considerable considerable JJ 13433 711 12 number number NN 13433 711 13 , , , 13433 711 14 as as IN 13433 711 15 , , , 13433 711 16 for for IN 13433 711 17 instance instance NN 13433 711 18 , , , 13433 711 19 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 711 20 , , , 13433 711 21 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 13433 711 22 , , , 13433 711 23 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 13433 711 24 , , , 13433 711 25 Griesbach Griesbach NNP 13433 711 26 , , , 13433 711 27 Kestner Kestner NNP 13433 711 28 , , , 13433 711 29 Neander Neander NNP 13433 711 30 , , , 13433 711 31 and and CC 13433 711 32 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 13433 711 33 - - HYPH 13433 711 34 Crusius Crusius NNP 13433 711 35 , , , 13433 711 36 _ _ NNP 13433 711 37 with with IN 13433 711 38 different different JJ 13433 711 39 degrees degree NNS 13433 711 40 of of IN 13433 711 41 certainty certainty NN 13433 711 42 or or CC 13433 711 43 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 711 44 _ _ NNP 13433 711 45 , , , 13433 711 46 pronounce pronounce VBP 13433 711 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 711 48 in in IN 13433 711 49 favour favour NN 13433 711 50 of of IN 13433 711 51 a a DT 13433 711 52 genuine genuine JJ 13433 711 53 nucleus nucleus NN 13433 711 54 . . . 13433 711 55 " " '' 13433 712 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 712 2 70:2 70:2 CD 13433 712 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 712 4 The the DT 13433 712 5 words word NNS 13433 712 6 which which WDT 13433 712 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 712 8 have have VBP 13433 712 9 italicised italicise VBN 13433 712 10 are be VBP 13433 712 11 a a DT 13433 712 12 mere mere JJ 13433 712 13 paraphrase paraphrase NN 13433 712 14 of of IN 13433 712 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 712 16 words word NNS 13433 712 17 descriptive descriptive JJ 13433 712 18 of of IN 13433 712 19 the the DT 13433 712 20 doubts doubt NNS 13433 712 21 entertained entertain VBN 13433 712 22 . . . 13433 713 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 713 2 must must MD 13433 713 3 point point VB 13433 713 4 out out RP 13433 713 5 that that IN 13433 713 6 a a DT 13433 713 7 leaning lean VBG 13433 713 8 towards towards IN 13433 713 9 belief belief NN 13433 713 10 in in IN 13433 713 11 a a DT 13433 713 12 genuine genuine JJ 13433 713 13 " " `` 13433 713 14 nucleus nucleus NN 13433 713 15 " " '' 13433 713 16 on on IN 13433 713 17 the the DT 13433 713 18 part part NN 13433 713 19 of of IN 13433 713 20 some some DT 13433 713 21 of of IN 13433 713 22 these these DT 13433 713 23 writers writer NNS 13433 713 24 , , , 13433 713 25 by by IN 13433 713 26 no no DT 13433 713 27 means means NN 13433 713 28 excludes exclude VBZ 13433 713 29 the the DT 13433 713 30 expression expression NN 13433 713 31 of of IN 13433 713 32 " " `` 13433 713 33 _ _ NNP 13433 713 34 doubts doubt NNS 13433 713 35 , , , 13433 713 36 more more RBR 13433 713 37 or or CC 13433 713 38 less less RBR 13433 713 39 definite definite JJ 13433 713 40 _ _ NNP 13433 713 41 , , , 13433 713 42 " " '' 13433 713 43 which which WDT 13433 713 44 is be VBZ 13433 713 45 all all DT 13433 713 46 I -PRON- PRP 13433 713 47 quote quote VBP 13433 713 48 them -PRON- PRP 13433 713 49 for for IN 13433 713 50 . . . 13433 714 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 714 2 will will MD 13433 714 3 take take VB 13433 714 4 each each DT 13433 714 5 name name NN 13433 714 6 in in IN 13433 714 7 order order NN 13433 714 8 . . . 13433 715 1 _ _ NNP 13433 715 2 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 715 3 _ _ NNP 13433 715 4 says say VBZ 13433 715 5 : : : 13433 715 6 " " `` 13433 715 7 But but CC 13433 715 8 whether whether IN 13433 715 9 the the DT 13433 715 10 smaller small JJR 13433 715 11 ( ( -LRB- 13433 715 12 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 715 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 715 14 ) ) -RRB- 13433 715 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 715 16 are be VBP 13433 715 17 the the DT 13433 715 18 genuine genuine JJ 13433 715 19 writings writing NNS 13433 715 20 of of IN 13433 715 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 715 22 , , , 13433 715 23 bishop bishop NN 13433 715 24 of of IN 13433 715 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 715 26 , , , 13433 715 27 is be VBZ 13433 715 28 a a DT 13433 715 29 question question NN 13433 715 30 that that WDT 13433 715 31 has have VBZ 13433 715 32 been be VBN 13433 715 33 much much RB 13433 715 34 disputed dispute VBN 13433 715 35 , , , 13433 715 36 and and CC 13433 715 37 has have VBZ 13433 715 38 employed employ VBN 13433 715 39 the the DT 13433 715 40 pens pen NNS 13433 715 41 of of IN 13433 715 42 the the DT 13433 715 43 ablest able JJS 13433 715 44 critics critic NNS 13433 715 45 . . . 13433 716 1 And and CC 13433 716 2 whatever whatever WDT 13433 716 3 positiveness positiveness NN 13433 716 4 some some DT 13433 716 5 may may MD 13433 716 6 have have VB 13433 716 7 shown show VBN 13433 716 8 on on IN 13433 716 9 either either DT 13433 716 10 side side NN 13433 716 11 , , , 13433 716 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 716 13 must must MD 13433 716 14 own own VB 13433 716 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 716 16 have have VBP 13433 716 17 found find VBN 13433 716 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 716 19 a a DT 13433 716 20 very very RB 13433 716 21 difficult difficult JJ 13433 716 22 question question NN 13433 716 23 . . . 13433 716 24 " " '' 13433 717 1 The the DT 13433 717 2 opinion opinion NN 13433 717 3 which which WDT 13433 717 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 717 5 expresses express VBZ 13433 717 6 finally finally RB 13433 717 7 is be VBZ 13433 717 8 merely merely RB 13433 717 9 : : : 13433 717 10 " " `` 13433 717 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 717 12 appears appear VBZ 13433 717 13 to to IN 13433 717 14 me -PRON- PRP 13433 717 15 _ _ NNP 13433 717 16 probable probable JJ 13433 717 17 _ _ NNP 13433 717 18 , , , 13433 717 19 that that IN 13433 717 20 they -PRON- PRP 13433 717 21 are be VBP 13433 717 22 _ _ NNP 13433 717 23 for for IN 13433 717 24 the the DT 13433 717 25 main main JJ 13433 717 26 part part NN 13433 717 27 _ _ IN 13433 717 28 the the DT 13433 717 29 genuine genuine JJ 13433 717 30 epistles epistle NNS 13433 717 31 of of IN 13433 717 32 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 717 33 . . . 13433 717 34 " " '' 13433 718 1 _ _ NNP 13433 718 2 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 13433 718 3 _ _ NNP 13433 718 4 says say VBZ 13433 718 5 : : : 13433 718 6 " " `` 13433 718 7 Je Je NNP 13433 718 8 ne ne NNP 13433 718 9 veux veux NN 13433 718 10 , , , 13433 718 11 ni ni NNP 13433 718 12 défendre défendre NNP 13433 718 13 , , , 13433 718 14 ni ni NNP 13433 718 15 combattre combattre NNP 13433 718 16 l'authenticité l'authenticité NNP 13433 718 17 des des NNP 13433 718 18 _ _ NNP 13433 718 19 Lettres Lettres NNP 13433 718 20 de de NNP 13433 718 21 St. St. NNP 13433 718 22 Ignace Ignace NNP 13433 718 23 _ _ NNP 13433 718 24 . . . 13433 719 1 Si Si NNP 13433 719 2 elles elles NNP 13433 719 3 ne ne NNP 13433 719 4 sont sont NNP 13433 719 5 pas pas NNP 13433 719 6 véritables véritables NNP 13433 719 7 , , , 13433 719 8 elles elles NNP 13433 719 9 ne ne NNP 13433 719 10 laissent laissent NNP 13433 719 11 pas pas NNP 13433 719 12 d'être d'être NNP 13433 719 13 fort fort NNP 13433 719 14 anciennes anciennes NNPS 13433 719 15 ; ; : 13433 719 16 et et NN 13433 719 17 l'opinion l'opinion NN 13433 719 18 , , , 13433 719 19 qui qui VBD 13433 719 20 me -PRON- PRP 13433 719 21 paroit paroit NNP 13433 719 22 la la NNP 13433 719 23 plus plus CC 13433 719 24 raisonnable raisonnable JJ 13433 719 25 , , , 13433 719 26 est est NNP 13433 719 27 que que NNP 13433 719 28 les les NNP 13433 719 29 plus plus NNP 13433 719 30 pures pures NNP 13433 719 31 ont ont CC 13433 719 32 été été NNP 13433 719 33 interpolées interpolées NNP 13433 719 34 . . . 13433 719 35 " " '' 13433 720 1 _ _ NNP 13433 720 2 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 13433 720 3 _ _ NNP 13433 720 4 says say VBZ 13433 720 5 that that IN 13433 720 6 along along IN 13433 720 7 with with IN 13433 720 8 the the DT 13433 720 9 favourable favourable JJ 13433 720 10 considerations consideration NNS 13433 720 11 for for IN 13433 720 12 the the DT 13433 720 13 shorter short JJR 13433 720 14 ( ( -LRB- 13433 720 15 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 720 16 ) ) -RRB- 13433 720 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 720 18 , , , 13433 720 19 " " '' 13433 720 20 many many JJ 13433 720 21 doubts doubt NNS 13433 720 22 arise arise VBP 13433 720 23 which which WDT 13433 720 24 make make VBP 13433 720 25 them -PRON- PRP 13433 720 26 suspicious suspicious JJ 13433 720 27 . . . 13433 720 28 " " '' 13433 721 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 721 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 721 3 to to TO 13433 721 4 point point VB 13433 721 5 out out RP 13433 721 6 many many JJ 13433 721 7 grave grave JJ 13433 721 8 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 721 9 , , , 13433 721 10 and and CC 13433 721 11 anachronisms anachronism NNS 13433 721 12 which which WDT 13433 721 13 cast cast VBD 13433 721 14 doubt doubt NN 13433 721 15 both both DT 13433 721 16 on on IN 13433 721 17 individual individual JJ 13433 721 18 epistles epistle NNS 13433 721 19 and and CC 13433 721 20 upon upon IN 13433 721 21 the the DT 13433 721 22 whole whole NN 13433 721 23 , , , 13433 721 24 and and CC 13433 721 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 721 26 remarks remark VBZ 13433 721 27 that that IN 13433 721 28 a a DT 13433 721 29 very very RB 13433 721 30 common common JJ 13433 721 31 way way NN 13433 721 32 of of IN 13433 721 33 evading evade VBG 13433 721 34 these these DT 13433 721 35 and and CC 13433 721 36 other other JJ 13433 721 37 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 721 38 is be VBZ 13433 721 39 to to TO 13433 721 40 affirm affirm VB 13433 721 41 that that IN 13433 721 42 all all PDT 13433 721 43 the the DT 13433 721 44 passages passage NNS 13433 721 45 which which WDT 13433 721 46 can can MD 13433 721 47 not not RB 13433 721 48 be be VB 13433 721 49 reconciled reconcile VBN 13433 721 50 with with IN 13433 721 51 the the DT 13433 721 52 mode mode NN 13433 721 53 of of IN 13433 721 54 thought thought NN 13433 721 55 of of IN 13433 721 56 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 721 57 are be VBP 13433 721 58 interpolations interpolation NNS 13433 721 59 of of IN 13433 721 60 a a DT 13433 721 61 later later JJ 13433 721 62 time time NN 13433 721 63 . . . 13433 722 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 722 2 concludes conclude VBZ 13433 722 3 with with IN 13433 722 4 the the DT 13433 722 5 pertinent pertinent JJ 13433 722 6 observation observation NN 13433 722 7 : : : 13433 722 8 " " `` 13433 722 9 However however RB 13433 722 10 probable probable JJ 13433 722 11 this this DT 13433 722 12 is be VBZ 13433 722 13 , , , 13433 722 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 722 15 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 722 16 remains remain VBZ 13433 722 17 as as RB 13433 722 18 difficult difficult JJ 13433 722 19 to to TO 13433 722 20 prove prove VB 13433 722 21 which which WDT 13433 722 22 are be VBP 13433 722 23 the the DT 13433 722 24 interpolated interpolated JJ 13433 722 25 passages passage NNS 13433 722 26 . . . 13433 722 27 " " '' 13433 723 1 In in IN 13433 723 2 fact fact NN 13433 723 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 723 4 would would MD 13433 723 5 be be VB 13433 723 6 difficult difficult JJ 13433 723 7 to to TO 13433 723 8 point point VB 13433 723 9 out out RP 13433 723 10 any any DT 13433 723 11 writer writer NN 13433 723 12 who who WP 13433 723 13 more more RBR 13433 723 14 thoroughly thoroughly RB 13433 723 15 doubts doubt NNS 13433 723 16 , , , 13433 723 17 without without IN 13433 723 18 definitely definitely RB 13433 723 19 rejecting reject VBG 13433 723 20 , , , 13433 723 21 all all PDT 13433 723 22 the the DT 13433 723 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 723 24 . . . 13433 724 1 _ _ NNP 13433 724 2 Griesbach Griesbach NNP 13433 724 3 _ _ NNP 13433 724 4 and and CC 13433 724 5 _ _ NNP 13433 724 6 Kestner Kestner NNP 13433 724 7 _ _ NNP 13433 724 8 both both CC 13433 724 9 express express VBP 13433 724 10 " " `` 13433 724 11 doubts doubt NNS 13433 724 12 more more RBR 13433 724 13 or or CC 13433 724 14 less less RBR 13433 724 15 definite definite JJ 13433 724 16 , , , 13433 724 17 " " '' 13433 724 18 but but CC 13433 724 19 to to TO 13433 724 20 make make VB 13433 724 21 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 724 22 extracts extract NNS 13433 724 23 to to TO 13433 724 24 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 724 25 this this DT 13433 724 26 would would MD 13433 724 27 occupy occupy VB 13433 724 28 too too RB 13433 724 29 much much JJ 13433 724 30 space space NN 13433 724 31 . . . 13433 725 1 _ _ NNP 13433 725 2 Neander._--Dr neander._--dr NN 13433 725 3 . . . 13433 725 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 725 5 has have VBZ 13433 725 6 been be VBN 13433 725 7 misled mislead VBN 13433 725 8 by by IN 13433 725 9 the the DT 13433 725 10 short short JJ 13433 725 11 extract extract NN 13433 725 12 from from IN 13433 725 13 the the DT 13433 725 14 English english JJ 13433 725 15 translation translation NN 13433 725 16 of of IN 13433 725 17 the the DT 13433 725 18 first first JJ 13433 725 19 edition edition NN 13433 725 20 of of IN 13433 725 21 Neander Neander NNP 13433 725 22 's 's POS 13433 725 23 History history NN 13433 725 24 given give VBN 13433 725 25 by by IN 13433 725 26 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 725 27 in in IN 13433 725 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 725 29 Appendix Appendix NNP 13433 725 30 , , , 13433 725 31 has have VBZ 13433 725 32 not not RB 13433 725 33 attended attend VBN 13433 725 34 to to IN 13433 725 35 the the DT 13433 725 36 brief brief JJ 13433 725 37 German german JJ 13433 725 38 quotation quotation NN 13433 725 39 from from IN 13433 725 40 the the DT 13433 725 41 second second JJ 13433 725 42 edition edition NN 13433 725 43 , , , 13433 725 44 and and CC 13433 725 45 has have VBZ 13433 725 46 not not RB 13433 725 47 examined examine VBN 13433 725 48 the the DT 13433 725 49 original original NN 13433 725 50 at at RB 13433 725 51 all all RB 13433 725 52 , , , 13433 725 53 or or CC 13433 725 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 725 55 would would MD 13433 725 56 have have VB 13433 725 57 seen see VBN 13433 725 58 that that DT 13433 725 59 , , , 13433 725 60 so so RB 13433 725 61 far far RB 13433 725 62 from from IN 13433 725 63 pronouncing pronounce VBG 13433 725 64 " " '' 13433 725 65 in in IN 13433 725 66 favour favour NN 13433 725 67 of of IN 13433 725 68 a a DT 13433 725 69 genuine genuine JJ 13433 725 70 nucleus nucleus NN 13433 725 71 , , , 13433 725 72 " " `` 13433 725 73 Neander Neander NNP 13433 725 74 might may MD 13433 725 75 well well RB 13433 725 76 have have VB 13433 725 77 been be VBN 13433 725 78 classed class VBN 13433 725 79 by by IN 13433 725 80 me -PRON- PRP 13433 725 81 amongst amongst IN 13433 725 82 those those DT 13433 725 83 who who WP 13433 725 84 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 725 85 reject reject VBP 13433 725 86 the the DT 13433 725 87 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 725 88 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 725 89 , , , 13433 725 90 instead instead RB 13433 725 91 of of IN 13433 725 92 being be VBG 13433 725 93 moderately moderately RB 13433 725 94 quoted quote VBN 13433 725 95 amongst amongst IN 13433 725 96 those those DT 13433 725 97 who who WP 13433 725 98 merely merely RB 13433 725 99 express express VBP 13433 725 100 doubt doubt NN 13433 725 101 . . . 13433 726 1 Neander Neander NNP 13433 726 2 says say VBZ 13433 726 3 : : : 13433 726 4 " " `` 13433 726 5 As as IN 13433 726 6 the the DT 13433 726 7 account account NN 13433 726 8 of of IN 13433 726 9 the the DT 13433 726 10 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 726 11 of of IN 13433 726 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 726 13 is be VBZ 13433 726 14 very very RB 13433 726 15 suspicious suspicious JJ 13433 726 16 , , , 13433 726 17 so so RB 13433 726 18 also also RB 13433 726 19 the the DT 13433 726 20 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 726 21 which which WDT 13433 726 22 suppose suppose VBP 13433 726 23 the the DT 13433 726 24 correctness correctness NN 13433 726 25 of of IN 13433 726 26 this this DT 13433 726 27 suspicious suspicious JJ 13433 726 28 legend legend NN 13433 726 29 do do VBP 13433 726 30 not not RB 13433 726 31 bear bear VB 13433 726 32 throughout throughout IN 13433 726 33 the the DT 13433 726 34 impress impress NN 13433 726 35 of of IN 13433 726 36 a a DT 13433 726 37 distinct distinct JJ 13433 726 38 individuality individuality NN 13433 726 39 , , , 13433 726 40 and and CC 13433 726 41 of of IN 13433 726 42 a a DT 13433 726 43 man man NN 13433 726 44 of of IN 13433 726 45 that that DT 13433 726 46 time time NN 13433 726 47 who who WP 13433 726 48 is be VBZ 13433 726 49 addressing address VBG 13433 726 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 726 51 last last JJ 13433 726 52 words word NNS 13433 726 53 to to IN 13433 726 54 the the DT 13433 726 55 communities community NNS 13433 726 56 . . . 13433 727 1 A a DT 13433 727 2 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 13433 727 3 purpose purpose NN 13433 727 4 is be VBZ 13433 727 5 not not RB 13433 727 6 to to TO 13433 727 7 be be VB 13433 727 8 mistaken mistaken JJ 13433 727 9 . . . 13433 727 10 " " '' 13433 728 1 In in IN 13433 728 2 an an DT 13433 728 3 earlier early JJR 13433 728 4 part part NN 13433 728 5 of of IN 13433 728 6 the the DT 13433 728 7 work work NN 13433 728 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 728 9 still still RB 13433 728 10 more more RBR 13433 728 11 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 728 12 says say VBZ 13433 728 13 that that IN 13433 728 14 , , , 13433 728 15 " " `` 13433 728 16 in in IN 13433 728 17 the the DT 13433 728 18 so so RB 13433 728 19 - - HYPH 13433 728 20 called call VBN 13433 728 21 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 728 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 728 23 , , , 13433 728 24 " " '' 13433 728 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 728 26 recognises recognise VBZ 13433 728 27 a a DT 13433 728 28 decided decided JJ 13433 728 29 " " `` 13433 728 30 design design NN 13433 728 31 " " '' 13433 728 32 ( ( -LRB- 13433 728 33 _ _ NNP 13433 728 34 Absichtlichkeit Absichtlichkeit NNP 13433 728 35 _ _ NNP 13433 728 36 ) ) -RRB- 13433 728 37 , , , 13433 728 38 and and CC 13433 728 39 then then RB 13433 728 40 he -PRON- PRP 13433 728 41 continues continue VBZ 13433 728 42 : : : 13433 728 43 " " `` 13433 728 44 As as IN 13433 728 45 the the DT 13433 728 46 tradition tradition NN 13433 728 47 regarding regard VBG 13433 728 48 the the DT 13433 728 49 journey journey NN 13433 728 50 of of IN 13433 728 51 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 728 52 to to IN 13433 728 53 Rome Rome NNP 13433 728 54 , , , 13433 728 55 there there RB 13433 728 56 to to TO 13433 728 57 be be VB 13433 728 58 cast cast VBN 13433 728 59 to to IN 13433 728 60 the the DT 13433 728 61 wild wild JJ 13433 728 62 beasts beast NNS 13433 728 63 , , , 13433 728 64 seems seem VBZ 13433 728 65 to to IN 13433 728 66 me -PRON- PRP 13433 728 67 for for IN 13433 728 68 the the DT 13433 728 69 above above RB 13433 728 70 - - HYPH 13433 728 71 mentioned mention VBN 13433 728 72 reasons reason NNS 13433 728 73 very very RB 13433 728 74 suspicious suspicious JJ 13433 728 75 , , , 13433 728 76 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 728 77 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 728 78 , , , 13433 728 79 which which WDT 13433 728 80 presuppose presuppose VBP 13433 728 81 the the DT 13433 728 82 truth truth NN 13433 728 83 of of IN 13433 728 84 this this DT 13433 728 85 tradition tradition NN 13433 728 86 , , , 13433 728 87 can can MD 13433 728 88 no no RB 13433 728 89 longer long RBR 13433 728 90 inspire inspire VB 13433 728 91 me -PRON- PRP 13433 728 92 with with IN 13433 728 93 faith faith NN 13433 728 94 in in IN 13433 728 95 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 728 96 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 728 97 . . . 13433 728 98 " " '' 13433 729 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 729 2 72:1 72:1 CD 13433 729 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 729 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 729 5 goes go VBZ 13433 729 6 on on IN 13433 729 7 to to IN 13433 729 8 state state VB 13433 729 9 additional additional JJ 13433 729 10 grounds ground NNS 13433 729 11 for for IN 13433 729 12 disbelief disbelief NN 13433 729 13 . . . 13433 730 1 _ _ NNP 13433 730 2 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 13433 730 3 - - HYPH 13433 730 4 Crusius Crusius NNP 13433 730 5 _ _ NNP 13433 730 6 stated state VBD 13433 730 7 in in IN 13433 730 8 one one CD 13433 730 9 place place NN 13433 730 10 , , , 13433 730 11 in in IN 13433 730 12 regard regard NN 13433 730 13 to to IN 13433 730 14 the the DT 13433 730 15 seven seven CD 13433 730 16 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 730 17 , , , 13433 730 18 that that IN 13433 730 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 730 20 is be VBZ 13433 730 21 no no RB 13433 730 22 longer long RBR 13433 730 23 possible possible JJ 13433 730 24 to to TO 13433 730 25 ascertain ascertain VB 13433 730 26 how how WRB 13433 730 27 much much JJ 13433 730 28 of of IN 13433 730 29 the the DT 13433 730 30 extant extant JJ 13433 730 31 may may MD 13433 730 32 have have VB 13433 730 33 formed form VBN 13433 730 34 part part NN 13433 730 35 of of IN 13433 730 36 the the DT 13433 730 37 original original JJ 13433 730 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 730 39 , , , 13433 730 40 and and CC 13433 730 41 in in IN 13433 730 42 a a DT 13433 730 43 note note NN 13433 730 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 730 45 excepts except VBZ 13433 730 46 only only RB 13433 730 47 the the DT 13433 730 48 passages passage NNS 13433 730 49 quoted quote VBN 13433 730 50 by by IN 13433 730 51 the the DT 13433 730 52 Fathers father NNS 13433 730 53 . . . 13433 731 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 731 2 seems seem VBZ 13433 731 3 to to TO 13433 731 4 agree agree VB 13433 731 5 with with IN 13433 731 6 Semler Semler NNP 13433 731 7 and and CC 13433 731 8 others other NNS 13433 731 9 that that IN 13433 731 10 the the DT 13433 731 11 two two CD 13433 731 12 Recensions recension NNS 13433 731 13 are be VBP 13433 731 14 probably probably RB 13433 731 15 the the DT 13433 731 16 result result NN 13433 731 17 of of IN 13433 731 18 manipulations manipulation NNS 13433 731 19 of of IN 13433 731 20 the the DT 13433 731 21 original original JJ 13433 731 22 , , , 13433 731 23 the the DT 13433 731 24 shorter short JJR 13433 731 25 form form NN 13433 731 26 being be VBG 13433 731 27 more more RBR 13433 731 28 in in IN 13433 731 29 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 731 30 , , , 13433 731 31 the the DT 13433 731 32 longer long JJR 13433 731 33 in in IN 13433 731 34 dogmatic dogmatic NN 13433 731 35 , , , 13433 731 36 interest interest NN 13433 731 37 . . . 13433 732 1 Some some DT 13433 732 2 years year NNS 13433 732 3 later later RBR 13433 732 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 732 5 remarked remark VBD 13433 732 6 that that IN 13433 732 7 enquiries enquiry NNS 13433 732 8 into into IN 13433 732 9 the the DT 13433 732 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 732 11 , , , 13433 732 12 although although IN 13433 732 13 not not RB 13433 732 14 yet yet RB 13433 732 15 concluded conclude VBN 13433 732 16 , , , 13433 732 17 had have VBD 13433 732 18 rather rather RB 13433 732 19 tended tend VBN 13433 732 20 towards towards IN 13433 732 21 the the DT 13433 732 22 earlier early JJR 13433 732 23 view view NN 13433 732 24 that that IN 13433 732 25 the the DT 13433 732 26 Shorter Shorter NNP 13433 732 27 Recension recension NN 13433 732 28 was be VBD 13433 732 29 more more RBR 13433 732 30 original original JJ 13433 732 31 than than IN 13433 732 32 the the DT 13433 732 33 Long long JJ 13433 732 34 , , , 13433 732 35 but but CC 13433 732 36 that that IN 13433 732 37 even even RB 13433 732 38 the the DT 13433 732 39 shorter short JJR 13433 732 40 may may MD 13433 732 41 have have VB 13433 732 42 suffered suffer VBN 13433 732 43 , , , 13433 732 44 if if IN 13433 732 45 not not RB 13433 732 46 from from IN 13433 732 47 manipulations manipulation NNS 13433 732 48 ( ( -LRB- 13433 732 49 _ _ NNP 13433 732 50 Ueberarbeitungen Ueberarbeitungen NNP 13433 732 51 _ _ NNP 13433 732 52 ) ) -RRB- 13433 732 53 , , , 13433 732 54 from from IN 13433 732 55 interpolations interpolation NNS 13433 732 56 . . . 13433 733 1 This this DT 13433 733 2 very very RB 13433 733 3 cautious cautious JJ 13433 733 4 statement statement NN 13433 733 5 , , , 13433 733 6 it -PRON- PRP 13433 733 7 will will MD 13433 733 8 be be VB 13433 733 9 observed observe VBN 13433 733 10 , , , 13433 733 11 is be VBZ 13433 733 12 wholly wholly RB 13433 733 13 relative relative JJ 13433 733 14 , , , 13433 733 15 and and CC 13433 733 16 does do VBZ 13433 733 17 not not RB 13433 733 18 in in IN 13433 733 19 the the DT 13433 733 20 least least JJS 13433 733 21 modify modify VB 13433 733 22 the the DT 13433 733 23 previous previous JJ 13433 733 24 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 733 25 that that IN 13433 733 26 the the DT 13433 733 27 original original JJ 13433 733 28 material material NN 13433 733 29 of of IN 13433 733 30 the the DT 13433 733 31 letters letter NNS 13433 733 32 can can MD 13433 733 33 not not RB 13433 733 34 be be VB 13433 733 35 ascertained ascertain VBN 13433 733 36 . . . 13433 734 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 734 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 734 3 's 's POS 13433 734 4 objections objection NNS 13433 734 5 regarding regard VBG 13433 734 6 these these DT 13433 734 7 seven seven CD 13433 734 8 writers writer NNS 13433 734 9 are be VBP 13433 734 10 thoroughly thoroughly RB 13433 734 11 unfounded unfounded JJ 13433 734 12 , , , 13433 734 13 and and CC 13433 734 14 in in IN 13433 734 15 most most JJS 13433 734 16 cases case NNS 13433 734 17 glaringly glaringly RB 13433 734 18 erroneous erroneous JJ 13433 734 19 . . . 13433 735 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 735 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 735 3 to to IN 13433 735 4 the the DT 13433 735 5 next next JJ 13433 735 6 " " `` 13433 735 7 note note NN 13433 735 8 ( ( -LRB- 13433 735 9 4 4 CD 13433 735 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 735 11 " " '' 13433 735 12 with with IN 13433 735 13 the the DT 13433 735 14 same same JJ 13433 735 15 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 13433 735 16 vigour vigour NN 13433 735 17 , , , 13433 735 18 and and CC 13433 735 19 characterises characterise VBZ 13433 735 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 735 21 as as IN 13433 735 22 " " `` 13433 735 23 equally equally RB 13433 735 24 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 13433 735 25 . . . 13433 735 26 " " '' 13433 736 1 Wherever wherever WRB 13433 736 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 736 3 has have VBZ 13433 736 4 been be VBN 13433 736 5 possible possible JJ 13433 736 6 , , , 13433 736 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 736 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 736 9 has have VBZ 13433 736 10 succeeded succeed VBN 13433 736 11 in in IN 13433 736 12 misrepresenting misrepresent VBG 13433 736 13 the the DT 13433 736 14 " " `` 13433 736 15 purpose purpose NN 13433 736 16 " " '' 13433 736 17 of of IN 13433 736 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 736 19 notes note NNS 13433 736 20 , , , 13433 736 21 although although IN 13433 736 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 736 23 has have VBZ 13433 736 24 recognised recognise VBN 13433 736 25 how how WRB 13433 736 26 important important JJ 13433 736 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 736 28 is be VBZ 13433 736 29 to to TO 13433 736 30 ascertain ascertain VB 13433 736 31 this this DT 13433 736 32 correctly correctly RB 13433 736 33 , , , 13433 736 34 and and CC 13433 736 35 in in IN 13433 736 36 this this DT 13433 736 37 instance instance NN 13433 736 38 he -PRON- PRP 13433 736 39 has have VBZ 13433 736 40 done do VBN 13433 736 41 so so RB 13433 736 42 again again RB 13433 736 43 . . . 13433 737 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 737 2 will will MD 13433 737 3 put put VB 13433 737 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 737 5 text text NN 13433 737 6 and and CC 13433 737 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 737 8 explanation explanation NN 13433 737 9 , , , 13433 737 10 upon upon IN 13433 737 11 the the DT 13433 737 12 basis basis NN 13433 737 13 of of IN 13433 737 14 which which WDT 13433 737 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 737 16 analyses analyse VBZ 13433 737 17 the the DT 13433 737 18 note note NN 13433 737 19 , , , 13433 737 20 in in IN 13433 737 21 juxtaposition juxtaposition NN 13433 737 22 , , , 13433 737 23 italicising italicise VBG 13433 737 24 part part NN 13433 737 25 of of IN 13433 737 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 737 27 own own JJ 13433 737 28 statement statement NN 13433 737 29 which which WDT 13433 737 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 737 31 altogether altogether RB 13433 737 32 disregards:-- disregards:-- NNP 13433 737 33 | | NNP 13433 737 34 DR DR NNP 13433 737 35 . . . 13433 737 36 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 737 37 . . . 13433 738 1 | | NNP 13433 738 2 " " `` 13433 738 3 Further further JJ 13433 738 4 examination examination NN 13433 738 5 and and CC 13433 738 6 more more JJR 13433 738 7 | | NNS 13433 738 8 " " `` 13433 738 9 References reference NNS 13433 738 10 to to TO 13433 738 11 twenty twenty CD 13433 738 12 authorities authority NNS 13433 738 13 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 13433 738 14 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 738 15 of of IN 13433 738 16 the the DT 13433 738 17 | | NNS 13433 738 18 are be VBP 13433 738 19 then then RB 13433 738 20 given give VBN 13433 738 21 , , , 13433 738 22 as as IN 13433 738 23 belonging belong VBG 13433 738 24 to to IN 13433 738 25 subject subject JJ 13433 738 26 have have VBP 13433 738 27 confirmed confirm VBN 13433 738 28 earlier early RBR 13433 738 29 | | CD 13433 738 30 the the DT 13433 738 31 ' ' `` 13433 738 32 large large JJ 13433 738 33 mass mass NN 13433 738 34 of of IN 13433 738 35 critics critic NNS 13433 738 36 ' ' '' 13433 738 37 who who WP 13433 738 38 doubts doubt VBZ 13433 738 39 , , , 13433 738 40 and and CC 13433 738 41 a a DT 13433 738 42 large large JJ 13433 738 43 mass mass NN 13433 738 44 of of IN 13433 738 45 critics critic NNS 13433 738 46 | | CD 13433 738 47 recognise recognise VBP 13433 738 48 that that IN 13433 738 49 the the DT 13433 738 50 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 738 51 recognise recognise NN 13433 738 52 _ _ NNP 13433 738 53 that that IN 13433 738 54 the the DT 13433 738 55 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 738 56 of of IN 13433 738 57 | | NNP 13433 738 58 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 738 59 ' ' '' 13433 738 60 can can MD 13433 738 61 only only RB 13433 738 62 be be VB 13433 738 63 considered consider VBN 13433 738 64 none none NN 13433 738 65 _ _ NNP 13433 738 66 of of IN 13433 738 67 these these DT 13433 738 68 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 738 69 _ _ NNP 13433 738 70 can can MD 13433 738 71 be be VB 13433 738 72 | | CD 13433 738 73 later later RB 13433 738 74 and and CC 13433 738 75 spurious spurious JJ 13433 738 76 compositions composition NNS 13433 738 77 . . . 13433 738 78 ' ' '' 13433 738 79 " " '' 13433 739 1 established establish VBN 13433 739 2 _ _ NNP 13433 739 3 , , , 13433 739 4 and and CC 13433 739 5 that that IN 13433 739 6 they -PRON- PRP 13433 739 7 can can MD 13433 739 8 | | VB 13433 739 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 739 10 73:1 73:1 CD 13433 739 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 739 12 only only RB 13433 739 13 be be VB 13433 739 14 considered consider VBN 13433 739 15 later later RB 13433 739 16 and and CC 13433 739 17 | | HYPH 13433 739 18 spurious spurious JJ 13433 739 19 compositions composition NNS 13433 739 20 . . . 13433 739 21 " " '' 13433 740 1 | | NNS 13433 740 2 There there EX 13433 740 3 are be VBP 13433 740 4 here here RB 13433 740 5 , , , 13433 740 6 in in IN 13433 740 7 order order NN 13433 740 8 to to TO 13433 740 9 embrace embrace VB 13433 740 10 a a DT 13433 740 11 number number NN 13433 740 12 of of IN 13433 740 13 references reference NNS 13433 740 14 , , , 13433 740 15 two two CD 13433 740 16 approximate approximate JJ 13433 740 17 states state NNS 13433 740 18 of of IN 13433 740 19 opinion opinion NN 13433 740 20 represented represent VBD 13433 740 21 : : : 13433 740 22 the the DT 13433 740 23 first first JJ 13433 740 24 , , , 13433 740 25 which which WDT 13433 740 26 leaves leave VBZ 13433 740 27 the the DT 13433 740 28 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 740 29 in in IN 13433 740 30 permanent permanent JJ 13433 740 31 doubt doubt NN 13433 740 32 , , , 13433 740 33 as as IN 13433 740 34 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 740 35 evidence evidence NN 13433 740 36 is be VBZ 13433 740 37 not not RB 13433 740 38 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 13433 740 39 to to TO 13433 740 40 establish establish VB 13433 740 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 740 42 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 740 43 ; ; : 13433 740 44 and and CC 13433 740 45 the the DT 13433 740 46 second second JJ 13433 740 47 , , , 13433 740 48 which which WDT 13433 740 49 positively positively RB 13433 740 50 pronounces pronounce VBZ 13433 740 51 them -PRON- PRP 13433 740 52 to to TO 13433 740 53 be be VB 13433 740 54 spurious spurious JJ 13433 740 55 . . . 13433 741 1 Out out IN 13433 741 2 of of IN 13433 741 3 the the DT 13433 741 4 twenty twenty CD 13433 741 5 authorities authority NNS 13433 741 6 referred refer VBD 13433 741 7 to to IN 13433 741 8 , , , 13433 741 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 741 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 741 11 objects object VBZ 13433 741 12 to to IN 13433 741 13 six six CD 13433 741 14 as as RB 13433 741 15 contradictory contradictory JJ 13433 741 16 or or CC 13433 741 17 not not RB 13433 741 18 confirming confirm VBG 13433 741 19 what what WP 13433 741 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 741 21 states state VBZ 13433 741 22 to to TO 13433 741 23 be be VB 13433 741 24 the the DT 13433 741 25 purpose purpose NN 13433 741 26 of of IN 13433 741 27 the the DT 13433 741 28 note note NN 13433 741 29 . . . 13433 742 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 742 2 seems seem VBZ 13433 742 3 to to TO 13433 742 4 consider consider VB 13433 742 5 that that IN 13433 742 6 a a DT 13433 742 7 reservation reservation NN 13433 742 8 for for IN 13433 742 9 the the DT 13433 742 10 possibility possibility NN 13433 742 11 of of IN 13433 742 12 a a DT 13433 742 13 genuine genuine JJ 13433 742 14 substratum substratum NN 13433 742 15 which which WDT 13433 742 16 can can MD 13433 742 17 not not RB 13433 742 18 be be VB 13433 742 19 defined define VBN 13433 742 20 invalidates invalidate VBZ 13433 742 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 742 22 reference reference NN 13433 742 23 . . . 13433 743 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 743 2 maintain maintain VBP 13433 743 3 , , , 13433 743 4 however however RB 13433 743 5 , , , 13433 743 6 that that IN 13433 743 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 743 8 does do VBZ 13433 743 9 not not RB 13433 743 10 . . . 13433 744 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 744 2 is be VBZ 13433 744 3 quite quite RB 13433 744 4 possible possible JJ 13433 744 5 to to TO 13433 744 6 consider consider VB 13433 744 7 that that IN 13433 744 8 the the DT 13433 744 9 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 744 10 of of IN 13433 744 11 the the DT 13433 744 12 extant extant JJ 13433 744 13 letters letter NNS 13433 744 14 can can MD 13433 744 15 not not RB 13433 744 16 be be VB 13433 744 17 established establish VBN 13433 744 18 without without IN 13433 744 19 denying deny VBG 13433 744 20 that that IN 13433 744 21 there there EX 13433 744 22 may may MD 13433 744 23 have have VB 13433 744 24 been be VBN 13433 744 25 some some DT 13433 744 26 original original JJ 13433 744 27 nucleus nucleus NN 13433 744 28 upon upon IN 13433 744 29 which which WDT 13433 744 30 these these DT 13433 744 31 actual actual JJ 13433 744 32 documents document NNS 13433 744 33 may may MD 13433 744 34 have have VB 13433 744 35 been be VBN 13433 744 36 based base VBN 13433 744 37 . . . 13433 745 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 745 2 will will MD 13433 745 3 analyse analyse VB 13433 745 4 the the DT 13433 745 5 six six CD 13433 745 6 references reference NNS 13433 745 7 . . . 13433 746 1 _ _ NNP 13433 746 2 Bleek._--Dr bleek._--dr NN 13433 746 3 . . . 13433 746 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 746 5 says say VBZ 13433 746 6 : : : 13433 746 7 " " `` 13433 746 8 Of of IN 13433 746 9 these these DT 13433 746 10 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 746 11 ( ( -LRB- 13433 746 12 already already RB 13433 746 13 cited cite VBN 13433 746 14 in in IN 13433 746 15 a a DT 13433 746 16 previous previous JJ 13433 746 17 note note NN 13433 746 18 ) ) -RRB- 13433 746 19 expresses express VBZ 13433 746 20 no no DT 13433 746 21 definite definite JJ 13433 746 22 opinion opinion NN 13433 746 23 . . . 13433 746 24 " " '' 13433 747 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 747 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 747 3 omits omit VBZ 13433 747 4 to to TO 13433 747 5 mention mention VB 13433 747 6 that that IN 13433 747 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 747 8 do do VBP 13433 747 9 not not RB 13433 747 10 refer refer VB 13433 747 11 to to IN 13433 747 12 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 747 13 directly directly RB 13433 747 14 , , , 13433 747 15 but but CC 13433 747 16 by by IN 13433 747 17 " " `` 13433 747 18 Cf Cf NNP 13433 747 19 . . . 13433 747 20 " " '' 13433 748 1 merely merely RB 13433 748 2 request request VBP 13433 748 3 consideration consideration NN 13433 748 4 of of IN 13433 748 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 748 6 opinions opinion NNS 13433 748 7 . . . 13433 749 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 749 2 have have VBP 13433 749 3 already already RB 13433 749 4 partly partly RB 13433 749 5 stated state VBN 13433 749 6 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 749 7 's 's POS 13433 749 8 view view NN 13433 749 9 . . . 13433 750 1 After after IN 13433 750 2 pointing point VBG 13433 750 3 out out RP 13433 750 4 some some DT 13433 750 5 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 750 6 , , , 13433 750 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 750 8 says say VBZ 13433 750 9 generally generally RB 13433 750 10 : : : 13433 750 11 " " `` 13433 750 12 It -PRON- PRP 13433 750 13 comes come VBZ 13433 750 14 to to IN 13433 750 15 this this DT 13433 750 16 , , , 13433 750 17 that that IN 13433 750 18 the the DT 13433 750 19 origin origin NN 13433 750 20 of of IN 13433 750 21 the the DT 13433 750 22 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 750 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 750 24 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 750 25 is be VBZ 13433 750 26 still still RB 13433 750 27 very very RB 13433 750 28 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 750 29 . . . 13433 750 30 " " '' 13433 751 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 751 2 refuses refuse VBZ 13433 751 3 to to TO 13433 751 4 make make VB 13433 751 5 use use NN 13433 751 6 of of IN 13433 751 7 a a DT 13433 751 8 passage passage NN 13433 751 9 because because IN 13433 751 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 751 11 is be VBZ 13433 751 12 only only RB 13433 751 13 found find VBN 13433 751 14 in in IN 13433 751 15 the the DT 13433 751 16 Long Long NNP 13433 751 17 Recension Recension NNP 13433 751 18 , , , 13433 751 19 and and CC 13433 751 20 another another DT 13433 751 21 which which WDT 13433 751 22 occurs occur VBZ 13433 751 23 in in IN 13433 751 24 the the DT 13433 751 25 Shorter Shorter NNP 13433 751 26 Recension Recension NNP 13433 751 27 he -PRON- PRP 13433 751 28 does do VBZ 13433 751 29 not not RB 13433 751 30 consider consider VB 13433 751 31 evidence evidence NN 13433 751 32 , , , 13433 751 33 because because IN 13433 751 34 , , , 13433 751 35 first first RB 13433 751 36 , , , 13433 751 37 he -PRON- PRP 13433 751 38 says say VBZ 13433 751 39 , , , 13433 751 40 " " `` 13433 751 41 The the DT 13433 751 42 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 751 43 of of IN 13433 751 44 this this DT 13433 751 45 Recension Recension NNP 13433 751 46 also also RB 13433 751 47 is be VBZ 13433 751 48 by by IN 13433 751 49 no no DT 13433 751 50 means mean NNS 13433 751 51 certain certain JJ 13433 751 52 , , , 13433 751 53 " " '' 13433 751 54 and and CC 13433 751 55 , , , 13433 751 56 next next RB 13433 751 57 , , , 13433 751 58 the the DT 13433 751 59 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 751 60 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 751 61 discredit discredit VBP 13433 751 62 the the DT 13433 751 63 others other NNS 13433 751 64 . . . 13433 752 1 " " `` 13433 752 2 Whether whether IN 13433 752 3 this this DT 13433 752 4 Recension recension NN 13433 752 5 ( ( -LRB- 13433 752 6 the the DT 13433 752 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 752 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 752 9 is be VBZ 13433 752 10 more more RBR 13433 752 11 original original JJ 13433 752 12 than than IN 13433 752 13 the the DT 13433 752 14 shorter short JJR 13433 752 15 Greek Greek NNP 13433 752 16 is be VBZ 13433 752 17 certainly certainly RB 13433 752 18 not not RB 13433 752 19 altogether altogether RB 13433 752 20 certain certain JJ 13433 752 21 , , , 13433 752 22 but but CC 13433 752 23 ... ... NFP 13433 752 24 in in IN 13433 752 25 the the DT 13433 752 26 highest high JJS 13433 752 27 degree degree NN 13433 752 28 probable probable JJ 13433 752 29 . . . 13433 752 30 " " '' 13433 753 1 In in IN 13433 753 2 another another DT 13433 753 3 place place NN 13433 753 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 753 5 refuses refuse VBZ 13433 753 6 to to TO 13433 753 7 make make VB 13433 753 8 use use NN 13433 753 9 of of IN 13433 753 10 reminiscences reminiscence NNS 13433 753 11 in in IN 13433 753 12 the the DT 13433 753 13 " " `` 13433 753 14 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 753 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 753 16 , , , 13433 753 17 " " '' 13433 753 18 " " `` 13433 753 19 because because IN 13433 753 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 753 21 is be VBZ 13433 753 22 still still RB 13433 753 23 very very RB 13433 753 24 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 753 25 how how WRB 13433 753 26 the the DT 13433 753 27 case case NN 13433 753 28 stands stand VBZ 13433 753 29 as as IN 13433 753 30 regards regard VBZ 13433 753 31 the the DT 13433 753 32 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 753 33 and and CC 13433 753 34 integrity integrity NN 13433 753 35 of of IN 13433 753 36 these these DT 13433 753 37 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 753 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 753 39 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 753 40 , , , 13433 753 41 in in IN 13433 753 42 the the DT 13433 753 43 different different JJ 13433 753 44 Recensions recension NNS 13433 753 45 in in IN 13433 753 46 which which WDT 13433 753 47 we -PRON- PRP 13433 753 48 possess possess VBP 13433 753 49 them -PRON- PRP 13433 753 50 . . . 13433 753 51 " " '' 13433 754 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 754 2 75:1 75:1 CD 13433 754 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 754 4 In in IN 13433 754 5 fact fact NN 13433 754 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 754 7 did do VBD 13433 754 8 not not RB 13433 754 9 consider consider VB 13433 754 10 that that IN 13433 754 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 754 12 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 754 13 could could MD 13433 754 14 be be VB 13433 754 15 established establish VBN 13433 754 16 . . . 13433 755 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 755 2 do do VBP 13433 755 3 not not RB 13433 755 4 , , , 13433 755 5 however however RB 13433 755 6 , , , 13433 755 7 include include VBP 13433 755 8 him -PRON- PRP 13433 755 9 here here RB 13433 755 10 at at RB 13433 755 11 all all RB 13433 755 12 . . . 13433 756 1 _ _ NNP 13433 756 2 Gfrörer._--Dr gfrörer._--dr NN 13433 756 3 . . . 13433 756 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 756 5 , , , 13433 756 6 again again RB 13433 756 7 , , , 13433 756 8 omits omit VBZ 13433 756 9 to to IN 13433 756 10 state state NN 13433 756 11 that that IN 13433 756 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 756 13 do do VBP 13433 756 14 not not RB 13433 756 15 cite cite VB 13433 756 16 this this DT 13433 756 17 writer writer NN 13433 756 18 like like IN 13433 756 19 the the DT 13433 756 20 others other NNS 13433 756 21 , , , 13433 756 22 but but CC 13433 756 23 by by IN 13433 756 24 a a DT 13433 756 25 " " `` 13433 756 26 Cf Cf NNP 13433 756 27 . . . 13433 756 28 " " '' 13433 757 1 merely merely RB 13433 757 2 suggest suggest VBP 13433 757 3 a a DT 13433 757 4 reference reference NN 13433 757 5 to to IN 13433 757 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 757 7 remarks remark NNS 13433 757 8 . . . 13433 758 1 _ _ NNP 13433 758 2 Harless Harless NNP 13433 758 3 _ _ NNP 13433 758 4 , , , 13433 758 5 according accord VBG 13433 758 6 to to IN 13433 758 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 758 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 758 9 , , , 13433 758 10 " " '' 13433 758 11 avows avow VBZ 13433 758 12 that that IN 13433 758 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 758 14 must must MD 13433 758 15 ' ' `` 13433 758 16 decidedly decidedly RB 13433 758 17 reject reject VB 13433 758 18 with with IN 13433 758 19 the the DT 13433 758 20 most most RBS 13433 758 21 considerable considerable JJ 13433 758 22 critics critic NNS 13433 758 23 of of IN 13433 758 24 older old JJR 13433 758 25 and and CC 13433 758 26 more more JJR 13433 758 27 recent recent JJ 13433 758 28 times time NNS 13433 758 29 ' ' POS 13433 758 30 the the DT 13433 758 31 opinion opinion NN 13433 758 32 maintained maintain VBN 13433 758 33 by by IN 13433 758 34 certain certain JJ 13433 758 35 persons person NNS 13433 758 36 that that WDT 13433 758 37 the the DT 13433 758 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 758 39 are be VBP 13433 758 40 ' ' `` 13433 758 41 altogether altogether RB 13433 758 42 spurious spurious JJ 13433 758 43 , , , 13433 758 44 ' ' '' 13433 758 45 and and CC 13433 758 46 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 758 47 to to TO 13433 758 48 treat treat VB 13433 758 49 a a DT 13433 758 50 passage passage NN 13433 758 51 as as RB 13433 758 52 genuine genuine JJ 13433 758 53 because because IN 13433 758 54 it -PRON- PRP 13433 758 55 stands stand VBZ 13433 758 56 in in IN 13433 758 57 the the DT 13433 758 58 Vossian vossian JJ 13433 758 59 letters letter NNS 13433 758 60 as as RB 13433 758 61 well well RB 13433 758 62 as as IN 13433 758 63 in in IN 13433 758 64 the the DT 13433 758 65 Long Long NNP 13433 758 66 Recension Recension NNP 13433 758 67 . . . 13433 758 68 " " '' 13433 759 1 This this DT 13433 759 2 is be VBZ 13433 759 3 a a DT 13433 759 4 mistake mistake NN 13433 759 5 . . . 13433 760 1 Harless Harless NNP 13433 760 2 quotes quote VBZ 13433 760 3 a a DT 13433 760 4 passage passage NN 13433 760 5 in in IN 13433 760 6 connection connection NN 13433 760 7 with with IN 13433 760 8 Paul Paul NNP 13433 760 9 's 's POS 13433 760 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 760 11 to to IN 13433 760 12 the the DT 13433 760 13 Ephesians Ephesians NNPS 13433 760 14 with with IN 13433 760 15 the the DT 13433 760 16 distinct distinct JJ 13433 760 17 remark remark NN 13433 760 18 : : : 13433 760 19 " " `` 13433 760 20 In in IN 13433 760 21 this this DT 13433 760 22 case case NN 13433 760 23 the the DT 13433 760 24 disadvantage disadvantage NN 13433 760 25 of of IN 13433 760 26 the the DT 13433 760 27 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 760 28 regarding regard VBG 13433 760 29 the the DT 13433 760 30 Recensions Recensions NNPS 13433 760 31 is be VBZ 13433 760 32 _ _ NNP 13433 760 33 in in IN 13433 760 34 part part NN 13433 760 35 _ _ NNP 13433 760 36 removed remove VBD 13433 760 37 through through IN 13433 760 38 the the DT 13433 760 39 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 760 40 that that WDT 13433 760 41 both both DT 13433 760 42 Recensions recension NNS 13433 760 43 have have VBP 13433 760 44 the the DT 13433 760 45 passage passage NN 13433 760 46 . . . 13433 760 47 " " '' 13433 761 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 761 2 recognises recognise VBZ 13433 761 3 that that IN 13433 761 4 the the DT 13433 761 5 completeness completeness NN 13433 761 6 of of IN 13433 761 7 the the DT 13433 761 8 proof proof NN 13433 761 9 that that IN 13433 761 10 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 761 11 tradition tradition NN 13433 761 12 goes go VBZ 13433 761 13 back back RB 13433 761 14 beyond beyond IN 13433 761 15 the the DT 13433 761 16 time time NN 13433 761 17 of of IN 13433 761 18 Marcion Marcion NNP 13433 761 19 is be VBZ 13433 761 20 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 761 21 wanting want VBG 13433 761 22 from from IN 13433 761 23 the the DT 13433 761 24 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 761 25 regarding regard VBG 13433 761 26 the the DT 13433 761 27 text text NN 13433 761 28 of of IN 13433 761 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 761 30 . . . 13433 762 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 762 2 did do VBD 13433 762 3 not not RB 13433 762 4 , , , 13433 762 5 in in IN 13433 762 6 fact fact NN 13433 762 7 , , , 13433 762 8 venture venture NN 13433 762 9 to to TO 13433 762 10 consider consider VB 13433 762 11 the the DT 13433 762 12 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 762 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 762 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 762 15 even even RB 13433 762 16 for for IN 13433 762 17 the the DT 13433 762 18 first first JJ 13433 762 19 half half NN 13433 762 20 of of IN 13433 762 21 the the DT 13433 762 22 second second JJ 13433 762 23 century century NN 13433 762 24 . . . 13433 763 1 _ _ NNP 13433 763 2 Schliemann Schliemann NNP 13433 763 3 _ _ NNP 13433 763 4 , , , 13433 763 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 763 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 763 7 states state VBZ 13433 763 8 , , , 13433 763 9 " " '' 13433 763 10 says say VBZ 13433 763 11 that that IN 13433 763 12 ' ' '' 13433 763 13 the the DT 13433 763 14 external external JJ 13433 763 15 testimonies testimony NNS 13433 763 16 oblige oblige VBP 13433 763 17 him -PRON- PRP 13433 763 18 to to TO 13433 763 19 recognise recognise VB 13433 763 20 a a DT 13433 763 21 genuine genuine JJ 13433 763 22 substratum substratum NN 13433 763 23 , , , 13433 763 24 ' ' '' 13433 763 25 though though IN 13433 763 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 763 27 is be VBZ 13433 763 28 not not RB 13433 763 29 satisfied satisfied JJ 13433 763 30 with with IN 13433 763 31 either either CC 13433 763 32 existing exist VBG 13433 763 33 recension recension NN 13433 763 34 . . . 13433 763 35 " " '' 13433 764 1 Now now RB 13433 764 2 what what WP 13433 764 3 Schliemann Schliemann NNP 13433 764 4 says say VBZ 13433 764 5 is be VBZ 13433 764 6 this this DT 13433 764 7 : : : 13433 764 8 " " `` 13433 764 9 Certainly certainly RB 13433 764 10 neither neither CC 13433 764 11 the the DT 13433 764 12 Shorter Shorter NNP 13433 764 13 and and CC 13433 764 14 still still RB 13433 764 15 less less RBR 13433 764 16 the the DT 13433 764 17 Longer long JJR 13433 764 18 Recension recension NN 13433 764 19 in in IN 13433 764 20 which which WDT 13433 764 21 we -PRON- PRP 13433 764 22 possess possess VBP 13433 764 23 these these DT 13433 764 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 764 25 can can MD 13433 764 26 lay lay VB 13433 764 27 claim claim NN 13433 764 28 to to IN 13433 764 29 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 764 30 . . . 13433 765 1 Only only RB 13433 765 2 if if IN 13433 765 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 765 4 must must MD 13433 765 5 , , , 13433 765 6 nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 765 7 , , , 13433 765 8 without without IN 13433 765 9 doubt doubt NN 13433 765 10 suppose suppose VBP 13433 765 11 a a DT 13433 765 12 genuine genuine JJ 13433 765 13 substratum substratum NN 13433 765 14 , , , 13433 765 15 " " '' 13433 765 16 & & CC 13433 765 17 c. c. NNP 13433 765 18 In in IN 13433 765 19 a a DT 13433 765 20 note note NN 13433 765 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 765 22 adds add VBZ 13433 765 23 : : : 13433 765 24 " " `` 13433 765 25 The the DT 13433 765 26 external external JJ 13433 765 27 testimonies testimony NNS 13433 765 28 oblige oblige VBP 13433 765 29 me -PRON- PRP 13433 765 30 to to TO 13433 765 31 recognise recognise VB 13433 765 32 a a DT 13433 765 33 genuine genuine JJ 13433 765 34 substratum substratum NN 13433 765 35 -- -- : 13433 765 36 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 765 37 already already RB 13433 765 38 speaks speak VBZ 13433 765 39 of of IN 13433 765 40 the the DT 13433 765 41 same same JJ 13433 765 42 in in IN 13433 765 43 Ch Ch NNP 13433 765 44 . . . 13433 766 1 xiii xiii NNP 13433 766 2 . . . 13433 767 1 of of IN 13433 767 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 767 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 767 4 . . . 13433 768 1 But but CC 13433 768 2 that that IN 13433 768 3 in in IN 13433 768 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 768 5 present present JJ 13433 768 6 form form NN 13433 768 7 they -PRON- PRP 13433 768 8 do do VBP 13433 768 9 not not RB 13433 768 10 proceed proceed VB 13433 768 11 from from IN 13433 768 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 768 13 the the DT 13433 768 14 contents content NNS 13433 768 15 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 768 16 show show VBP 13433 768 17 . . . 13433 768 18 " " '' 13433 769 1 _ _ NNP 13433 769 2 Hase Hase NNP 13433 769 3 _ _ NNP 13433 769 4 , , , 13433 769 5 according accord VBG 13433 769 6 to to IN 13433 769 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 769 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 769 9 , , , 13433 769 10 " " '' 13433 769 11 commits commit VBZ 13433 769 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 769 13 to to IN 13433 769 14 no no DT 13433 769 15 opinion opinion NN 13433 769 16 . . . 13433 769 17 " " '' 13433 770 1 If if IN 13433 770 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 770 3 does do VBZ 13433 770 4 not not RB 13433 770 5 deliberately deliberately RB 13433 770 6 and and CC 13433 770 7 directly directly RB 13433 770 8 do do VBP 13433 770 9 so so RB 13433 770 10 , , , 13433 770 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 770 12 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 770 13 what what WP 13433 770 14 that that DT 13433 770 15 opinion opinion NN 13433 770 16 is be VBZ 13433 770 17 with with IN 13433 770 18 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 770 19 clearness clearness NN 13433 770 20 . . . 13433 771 1 The the DT 13433 771 2 Long Long NNP 13433 771 3 Recension Recension NNP 13433 771 4 , , , 13433 771 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 771 6 says say VBZ 13433 771 7 , , , 13433 771 8 bears bear VBZ 13433 771 9 the the DT 13433 771 10 marks mark NNS 13433 771 11 of of IN 13433 771 12 later late JJR 13433 771 13 manipulation manipulation NN 13433 771 14 , , , 13433 771 15 and and CC 13433 771 16 excites excite VBZ 13433 771 17 suspicion suspicion NN 13433 771 18 of of IN 13433 771 19 an an DT 13433 771 20 invention invention NN 13433 771 21 in in IN 13433 771 22 favour favour NN 13433 771 23 of of IN 13433 771 24 Episcopacy Episcopacy NNP 13433 771 25 , , , 13433 771 26 and and CC 13433 771 27 the the DT 13433 771 28 shorter short JJR 13433 771 29 text text NN 13433 771 30 is be VBZ 13433 771 31 not not RB 13433 771 32 fully fully RB 13433 771 33 attested attest VBN 13433 771 34 either either RB 13433 771 35 . . . 13433 772 1 The the DT 13433 772 2 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 772 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 772 4 with with IN 13433 772 5 the the DT 13433 772 6 shortest short JJS 13433 772 7 and and CC 13433 772 8 least least JJS 13433 772 9 hierarchical hierarchical JJ 13433 772 10 text text NN 13433 772 11 give give VB 13433 772 12 the the DT 13433 772 13 impression impression NN 13433 772 14 of of IN 13433 772 15 an an DT 13433 772 16 epitome epitome NN 13433 772 17 . . . 13433 773 1 " " `` 13433 773 2 But but CC 13433 773 3 even even RB 13433 773 4 if if IN 13433 773 5 no no DT 13433 773 6 authentic authentic JJ 13433 773 7 kernel kernel NN 13433 773 8 lay lie VBD 13433 773 9 at at IN 13433 773 10 the the DT 13433 773 11 basis basis NN 13433 773 12 of of IN 13433 773 13 these these DT 13433 773 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 773 15 , , , 13433 773 16 yet yet CC 13433 773 17 they -PRON- PRP 13433 773 18 would would MD 13433 773 19 be be VB 13433 773 20 a a DT 13433 773 21 significant significant JJ 13433 773 22 document document NN 13433 773 23 at at IN 13433 773 24 latest late JJS 13433 773 25 out out IN 13433 773 26 of of IN 13433 773 27 the the DT 13433 773 28 middle middle NN 13433 773 29 of of IN 13433 773 30 the the DT 13433 773 31 second second JJ 13433 773 32 century century NN 13433 773 33 . . . 13433 773 34 " " '' 13433 774 1 These these DT 13433 774 2 last last JJ 13433 774 3 words word NNS 13433 774 4 are be VBP 13433 774 5 a a DT 13433 774 6 clear clear JJ 13433 774 7 admission admission NN 13433 774 8 of of IN 13433 774 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 774 10 opinion opinion NN 13433 774 11 that that IN 13433 774 12 the the DT 13433 774 13 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 774 14 can can MD 13433 774 15 not not RB 13433 774 16 be be VB 13433 774 17 established establish VBN 13433 774 18 . . . 13433 775 1 _ _ NNP 13433 775 2 Lechler Lechler NNP 13433 775 3 _ _ NNP 13433 775 4 candidly candidly RB 13433 775 5 confesses confess VBZ 13433 775 6 that that IN 13433 775 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 775 8 commenced commence VBD 13433 775 9 with with IN 13433 775 10 a a DT 13433 775 11 prejudice prejudice NN 13433 775 12 in in IN 13433 775 13 favour favour NN 13433 775 14 of of IN 13433 775 15 the the DT 13433 775 16 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 775 17 of of IN 13433 775 18 the the DT 13433 775 19 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 775 20 in in IN 13433 775 21 the the DT 13433 775 22 Shorter Shorter NNP 13433 775 23 Recension Recension NNP 13433 775 24 , , , 13433 775 25 but but CC 13433 775 26 on on IN 13433 775 27 reading read VBG 13433 775 28 them -PRON- PRP 13433 775 29 through through RP 13433 775 30 , , , 13433 775 31 he -PRON- PRP 13433 775 32 says say VBZ 13433 775 33 that that IN 13433 775 34 an an DT 13433 775 35 impression impression NN 13433 775 36 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 13433 775 37 to to IN 13433 775 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 775 39 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 775 40 was be VBD 13433 775 41 produced produce VBN 13433 775 42 upon upon IN 13433 775 43 him -PRON- PRP 13433 775 44 which which WDT 13433 775 45 he -PRON- PRP 13433 775 46 had have VBD 13433 775 47 not not RB 13433 775 48 been be VBN 13433 775 49 able able JJ 13433 775 50 to to TO 13433 775 51 shake shake VB 13433 775 52 off off RP 13433 775 53 . . . 13433 776 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 776 2 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 776 3 to to TO 13433 776 4 point point VB 13433 776 5 out out RP 13433 776 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 776 7 internal internal JJ 13433 776 8 improbability improbability NN 13433 776 9 , , , 13433 776 10 and and CC 13433 776 11 other other JJ 13433 776 12 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 776 13 connected connect VBN 13433 776 14 with with IN 13433 776 15 the the DT 13433 776 16 supposed suppose VBN 13433 776 17 journey journey NN 13433 776 18 , , , 13433 776 19 which which WDT 13433 776 20 make make VBP 13433 776 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 776 22 " " `` 13433 776 23 still still RB 13433 776 24 more more RBR 13433 776 25 improbable improbable JJ 13433 776 26 that that IN 13433 776 27 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 776 28 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 776 29 can can MD 13433 776 30 really really RB 13433 776 31 have have VB 13433 776 32 written write VBN 13433 776 33 these these DT 13433 776 34 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 776 35 in in IN 13433 776 36 this this DT 13433 776 37 situation situation NN 13433 776 38 . . . 13433 776 39 " " '' 13433 777 1 Lechler lechler NN 13433 777 2 does do VBZ 13433 777 3 not not RB 13433 777 4 consider consider VB 13433 777 5 that that IN 13433 777 6 the the DT 13433 777 7 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 777 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 777 9 strengthen strengthen VB 13433 777 10 the the DT 13433 777 11 case case NN 13433 777 12 ; ; , 13433 777 13 and and CC 13433 777 14 although although IN 13433 777 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 777 16 admits admit VBZ 13433 777 17 that that IN 13433 777 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 777 19 can can MD 13433 777 20 not not RB 13433 777 21 congratulate congratulate VB 13433 777 22 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 777 23 on on IN 13433 777 24 the the DT 13433 777 25 possession possession NN 13433 777 26 of of IN 13433 777 27 " " `` 13433 777 28 certainty certainty NNP 13433 777 29 and and CC 13433 777 30 cheerfulness cheerfulness NN 13433 777 31 of of IN 13433 777 32 conviction conviction NN 13433 777 33 " " '' 13433 777 34 of of IN 13433 777 35 the the DT 13433 777 36 inauthenticity inauthenticity NN 13433 777 37 of of IN 13433 777 38 the the DT 13433 777 39 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 777 40 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 777 41 , , , 13433 777 42 he -PRON- PRP 13433 777 43 at at RB 13433 777 44 least least JJS 13433 777 45 very very RB 13433 777 46 clearly clearly RB 13433 777 47 justifies justify VBZ 13433 777 48 the the DT 13433 777 49 affirmation affirmation NN 13433 777 50 that that IN 13433 777 51 the the DT 13433 777 52 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 777 53 can can MD 13433 777 54 not not RB 13433 777 55 be be VB 13433 777 56 established establish VBN 13433 777 57 . . . 13433 778 1 Now now RB 13433 778 2 what what WP 13433 778 3 has have VBZ 13433 778 4 been be VBN 13433 778 5 the the DT 13433 778 6 result result NN 13433 778 7 of of IN 13433 778 8 this this DT 13433 778 9 minute minute NN 13433 778 10 and and CC 13433 778 11 prejudiced prejudiced JJ 13433 778 12 attack attack NN 13433 778 13 upon upon IN 13433 778 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 778 15 notes note NNS 13433 778 16 ? ? . 13433 779 1 Out out IN 13433 779 2 of of IN 13433 779 3 nearly nearly RB 13433 779 4 seventy seventy CD 13433 779 5 critics critic NNS 13433 779 6 and and CC 13433 779 7 writers writer NNS 13433 779 8 in in IN 13433 779 9 connection connection NN 13433 779 10 with with IN 13433 779 11 what what WP 13433 779 12 is be VBZ 13433 779 13 admitted admit VBN 13433 779 14 to to TO 13433 779 15 be be VB 13433 779 16 one one CD 13433 779 17 of of IN 13433 779 18 the the DT 13433 779 19 most most RBS 13433 779 20 intricate intricate JJ 13433 779 21 questions question NNS 13433 779 22 of of IN 13433 779 23 Christian christian JJ 13433 779 24 literature literature NN 13433 779 25 , , , 13433 779 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 779 27 appears appear VBZ 13433 779 28 that that DT 13433 779 29 -- -- : 13433 779 30 much much RB 13433 779 31 to to IN 13433 779 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 779 33 regret regret NN 13433 779 34 -- -- : 13433 779 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 779 36 have have VBP 13433 779 37 inserted insert VBN 13433 779 38 one one CD 13433 779 39 name name NN 13433 779 40 totally totally RB 13433 779 41 by by IN 13433 779 42 accident accident NN 13433 779 43 , , , 13433 779 44 overlooked overlook VBD 13433 779 45 that that IN 13433 779 46 the the DT 13433 779 47 doubts doubt NNS 13433 779 48 of of IN 13433 779 49 another another DT 13433 779 50 had have VBD 13433 779 51 been be VBN 13433 779 52 removed remove VBN 13433 779 53 by by IN 13433 779 54 the the DT 13433 779 55 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 779 56 publication publication NN 13433 779 57 of of IN 13433 779 58 the the DT 13433 779 59 Short Short NNP 13433 779 60 Recension Recension NNP 13433 779 61 and and CC 13433 779 62 consequently consequently RB 13433 779 63 erroneously erroneously RB 13433 779 64 classed class VBD 13433 779 65 him -PRON- PRP 13433 779 66 , , , 13433 779 67 and and CC 13433 779 68 I -PRON- PRP 13433 779 69 withdraw withdraw VBP 13433 779 70 a a DT 13433 779 71 third third NN 13433 779 72 whose whose WP$ 13433 779 73 doubts doubt NNS 13433 779 74 I -PRON- PRP 13433 779 75 consider consider VBP 13433 779 76 that that IN 13433 779 77 I -PRON- PRP 13433 779 78 have have VBP 13433 779 79 overrated overrate VBN 13433 779 80 . . . 13433 780 1 Mistakes mistake NNS 13433 780 2 to to IN 13433 780 3 this this DT 13433 780 4 extent extent NN 13433 780 5 in in IN 13433 780 6 dealing deal VBG 13433 780 7 with with IN 13433 780 8 such such PDT 13433 780 9 a a DT 13433 780 10 mass mass NN 13433 780 11 of of IN 13433 780 12 references reference NNS 13433 780 13 , , , 13433 780 14 or or CC 13433 780 15 a a DT 13433 780 16 difference difference NN 13433 780 17 of of IN 13433 780 18 a a DT 13433 780 19 shade shade NN 13433 780 20 more more RBR 13433 780 21 or or CC 13433 780 22 less less RBR 13433 780 23 in in IN 13433 780 24 the the DT 13433 780 25 representation representation NN 13433 780 26 of of IN 13433 780 27 critical critical JJ 13433 780 28 opinions opinion NNS 13433 780 29 , , , 13433 780 30 not not RB 13433 780 31 always always RB 13433 780 32 clearly clearly RB 13433 780 33 expressed express VBN 13433 780 34 , , , 13433 780 35 may may MD 13433 780 36 , , , 13433 780 37 I -PRON- PRP 13433 780 38 hope hope VBP 13433 780 39 , , , 13433 780 40 be be VB 13433 780 41 excusable excusable JJ 13433 780 42 , , , 13433 780 43 and and CC 13433 780 44 I -PRON- PRP 13433 780 45 can can MD 13433 780 46 truly truly RB 13433 780 47 say say VB 13433 780 48 that that IN 13433 780 49 I -PRON- PRP 13433 780 50 am be VBP 13433 780 51 only only RB 13433 780 52 too too RB 13433 780 53 glad glad JJ 13433 780 54 to to TO 13433 780 55 correct correct VB 13433 780 56 such such JJ 13433 780 57 errors error NNS 13433 780 58 . . . 13433 781 1 On on IN 13433 781 2 the the DT 13433 781 3 other other JJ 13433 781 4 hand hand NN 13433 781 5 , , , 13433 781 6 a a DT 13433 781 7 critic critic NN 13433 781 8 who who WP 13433 781 9 attacks attack VBZ 13433 781 10 such such JJ 13433 781 11 references reference NNS 13433 781 12 , , , 13433 781 13 in in IN 13433 781 14 such such PDT 13433 781 15 a a DT 13433 781 16 tone tone NN 13433 781 17 , , , 13433 781 18 and and CC 13433 781 19 with with IN 13433 781 20 such such JJ 13433 781 21 wholesale wholesale JJ 13433 781 22 accusations accusation NNS 13433 781 23 of of IN 13433 781 24 " " `` 13433 781 25 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 781 26 " " '' 13433 781 27 and and CC 13433 781 28 " " `` 13433 781 29 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 781 30 , , , 13433 781 31 " " '' 13433 781 32 was be VBD 13433 781 33 bound bind VBN 13433 781 34 to to TO 13433 781 35 be be VB 13433 781 36 accurate accurate JJ 13433 781 37 , , , 13433 781 38 and and CC 13433 781 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 781 40 have have VBP 13433 781 41 shown show VBN 13433 781 42 that that IN 13433 781 43 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 781 44 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 781 45 is be VBZ 13433 781 46 not not RB 13433 781 47 only only RB 13433 781 48 inaccurate inaccurate JJ 13433 781 49 in in IN 13433 781 50 matters matter NNS 13433 781 51 of of IN 13433 781 52 fact fact NN 13433 781 53 , , , 13433 781 54 but but CC 13433 781 55 unfair unfair JJ 13433 781 56 in in IN 13433 781 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 781 58 statements statement NNS 13433 781 59 of of IN 13433 781 60 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 781 61 purpose purpose NN 13433 781 62 . . . 13433 782 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 782 2 am be VBP 13433 782 3 happy happy JJ 13433 782 4 , , , 13433 782 5 however however RB 13433 782 6 , , , 13433 782 7 to to TO 13433 782 8 be be VB 13433 782 9 able able JJ 13433 782 10 to to TO 13433 782 11 make make VB 13433 782 12 use use NN 13433 782 13 of of IN 13433 782 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 782 15 own own JJ 13433 782 16 words word NNS 13433 782 17 and and CC 13433 782 18 say say VB 13433 782 19 : : : 13433 782 20 " " `` 13433 782 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 782 22 may may MD 13433 782 23 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 782 24 have have VB 13433 782 25 fallen fall VBN 13433 782 26 into into IN 13433 782 27 some some DT 13433 782 28 errors error NNS 13433 782 29 of of IN 13433 782 30 detail detail NN 13433 782 31 , , , 13433 782 32 though though IN 13433 782 33 I -PRON- PRP 13433 782 34 have have VBP 13433 782 35 endeavoured endeavour VBN 13433 782 36 to to TO 13433 782 37 avoid avoid VB 13433 782 38 them -PRON- PRP 13433 782 39 , , , 13433 782 40 but but CC 13433 782 41 the the DT 13433 782 42 main main JJ 13433 782 43 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 782 44 are be VBP 13433 782 45 , , , 13433 782 46 I -PRON- PRP 13433 782 47 believe believe VBP 13433 782 48 , , , 13433 782 49 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 13433 782 50 . . . 13433 782 51 " " '' 13433 783 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 783 2 78:1 78:1 CD 13433 783 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 783 4 There there EX 13433 783 5 are be VBP 13433 783 6 further further JJ 13433 783 7 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 783 8 made make VBN 13433 783 9 by by IN 13433 783 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 783 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 783 12 to to TO 13433 783 13 which which WDT 13433 783 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 783 15 must must MD 13433 783 16 briefly briefly RB 13433 783 17 refer refer VB 13433 783 18 before before IN 13433 783 19 turning turn VBG 13433 783 20 to to IN 13433 783 21 other other JJ 13433 783 22 matters matter NNS 13433 783 23 . . . 13433 784 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 784 2 says say VBZ 13433 784 3 , , , 13433 784 4 with with IN 13433 784 5 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 13433 784 6 boldness boldness NN 13433 784 7 : : : 13433 784 8 " " `` 13433 784 9 One one CD 13433 784 10 highly highly RB 13433 784 11 important important JJ 13433 784 12 omission omission NN 13433 784 13 is be VBZ 13433 784 14 significant significant JJ 13433 784 15 . . . 13433 785 1 There there EX 13433 785 2 is be VBZ 13433 785 3 no no DT 13433 785 4 mention mention NN 13433 785 5 , , , 13433 785 6 from from IN 13433 785 7 first first RB 13433 785 8 to to IN 13433 785 9 last last JJ 13433 785 10 , , , 13433 785 11 of of IN 13433 785 12 the the DT 13433 785 13 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 785 14 version version NN 13433 785 15 . . . 13433 786 1 Now now RB 13433 786 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 786 3 happens happen VBZ 13433 786 4 that that IN 13433 786 5 this this DT 13433 786 6 version version NN 13433 786 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 786 8 so so RB 13433 786 9 far far RB 13433 786 10 as as IN 13433 786 11 regards regard VBZ 13433 786 12 the the DT 13433 786 13 documentary documentary JJ 13433 786 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 786 15 ) ) -RRB- 13433 786 16 _ _ NNP 13433 786 17 has have VBZ 13433 786 18 been be VBN 13433 786 19 felt feel VBN 13433 786 20 to to TO 13433 786 21 be be VB 13433 786 22 the the DT 13433 786 23 key key NN 13433 786 24 to to IN 13433 786 25 the the DT 13433 786 26 position position NN 13433 786 27 , , , 13433 786 28 and and CC 13433 786 29 around around IN 13433 786 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 786 31 the the DT 13433 786 32 battle battle NN 13433 786 33 has have VBZ 13433 786 34 raged rage VBN 13433 786 35 fiercely fiercely RB 13433 786 36 since since IN 13433 786 37 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 786 38 publication publication NN 13433 786 39 _ _ NNP 13433 786 40 . . . 13433 787 1 One one CD 13433 787 2 who who WP 13433 787 3 ( ( -LRB- 13433 787 4 like like IN 13433 787 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 787 6 author author NN 13433 787 7 ) ) -RRB- 13433 787 8 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 787 9 the the DT 13433 787 10 priority priority NN 13433 787 11 of of IN 13433 787 12 the the DT 13433 787 13 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 787 14 letters letter NNS 13433 787 15 , , , 13433 787 16 was be VBD 13433 787 17 especially especially RB 13433 787 18 bound bind VBN 13433 787 19 to to TO 13433 787 20 give give VB 13433 787 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 787 22 some some DT 13433 787 23 consideration consideration NN 13433 787 24 , , , 13433 787 25 for for IN 13433 787 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 787 27 furnishes furnish VBZ 13433 787 28 the the DT 13433 787 29 most most RBS 13433 787 30 formidable formidable JJ 13433 787 31 argument argument NN 13433 787 32 to to IN 13433 787 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 787 34 opponents opponent NNS 13433 787 35 . . . 13433 788 1 This this DT 13433 788 2 version version NN 13433 788 3 was be VBD 13433 788 4 given give VBN 13433 788 5 to to IN 13433 788 6 the the DT 13433 788 7 world world NN 13433 788 8 by by IN 13433 788 9 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 788 10 in in IN 13433 788 11 1849 1849 CD 13433 788 12 , , , 13433 788 13 the the DT 13433 788 14 same same JJ 13433 788 15 year year NN 13433 788 16 in in IN 13433 788 17 which which WDT 13433 788 18 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 788 19 's 's POS 13433 788 20 later later JJ 13433 788 21 work work NN 13433 788 22 , , , 13433 788 23 the the DT 13433 788 24 _ _ NNP 13433 788 25 Corpus Corpus NNP 13433 788 26 Ignatianum Ignatianum NNP 13433 788 27 _ _ NNP 13433 788 28 , , , 13433 788 29 appeared appear VBD 13433 788 30 , , , 13433 788 31 and and CC 13433 788 32 therefore therefore RB 13433 788 33 was be VBD 13433 788 34 unknown unknown JJ 13433 788 35 to to IN 13433 788 36 him -PRON- PRP 13433 788 37 . . . 13433 789 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 789 2 _ _ NNP 13433 789 3 bearing bearing NN 13433 789 4 occupies occupy VBZ 13433 789 5 a a DT 13433 789 6 more more RBR 13433 789 7 or or CC 13433 789 8 less less RBR 13433 789 9 prominent prominent JJ 13433 789 10 place place NN 13433 789 11 in in IN 13433 789 12 all all DT 13433 789 13 , , , 13433 789 14 or or CC 13433 789 15 nearly nearly RB 13433 789 16 all all DT 13433 789 17 , , , 13433 789 18 the the DT 13433 789 19 writers writer NNS 13433 789 20 who who WP 13433 789 21 have have VBP 13433 789 22 specially specially RB 13433 789 23 discussed discuss VBN 13433 789 24 the the DT 13433 789 25 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 789 26 question question NN 13433 789 27 during during IN 13433 789 28 the the DT 13433 789 29 last last JJ 13433 789 30 quarter quarter NN 13433 789 31 of of IN 13433 789 32 a a DT 13433 789 33 century century NN 13433 789 34 . . . 13433 790 1 This this DT 13433 790 2 is be VBZ 13433 790 3 true true JJ 13433 790 4 of of IN 13433 790 5 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 790 6 and and CC 13433 790 7 Weiss Weiss NNP 13433 790 8 and and CC 13433 790 9 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 790 10 and and CC 13433 790 11 Uhlhorn Uhlhorn NNP 13433 790 12 , , , 13433 790 13 whom whom WP 13433 790 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 790 15 cites cite VBZ 13433 790 16 , , , 13433 790 17 not not RB 13433 790 18 less less JJR 13433 790 19 than than IN 13433 790 20 of of IN 13433 790 21 Merx Merx NNP 13433 790 22 and and CC 13433 790 23 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 13433 790 24 and and CC 13433 790 25 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 790 26 , , , 13433 790 27 whom whom WP 13433 790 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 790 29 neglects neglect VBZ 13433 790 30 to to TO 13433 790 31 cite cite VB 13433 790 32 _ _ NNP 13433 790 33 . . . 13433 790 34 " " '' 13433 791 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 791 2 78:2 78:2 CD 13433 791 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 791 4 Now now RB 13433 791 5 first first RB 13433 791 6 as as IN 13433 791 7 regards regard VBZ 13433 791 8 the the DT 13433 791 9 facts fact NNS 13433 791 10 . . . 13433 792 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 792 2 do do VBP 13433 792 3 not not RB 13433 792 4 maintain maintain VB 13433 792 5 the the DT 13433 792 6 priority priority NN 13433 792 7 of of IN 13433 792 8 the the DT 13433 792 9 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 792 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 792 11 in in IN 13433 792 12 this this DT 13433 792 13 book book NN 13433 792 14 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 792 15 ; ; : 13433 792 16 indeed indeed RB 13433 792 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 792 18 express express VBP 13433 792 19 no no DT 13433 792 20 personal personal JJ 13433 792 21 opinion opinion NN 13433 792 22 whatever whatever WDT 13433 792 23 regarding regard VBG 13433 792 24 them -PRON- PRP 13433 792 25 which which WDT 13433 792 26 is be VBZ 13433 792 27 not not RB 13433 792 28 contained contain VBN 13433 792 29 in in IN 13433 792 30 that that DT 13433 792 31 general general JJ 13433 792 32 declaration declaration NNP 13433 792 33 of of IN 13433 792 34 belief belief NNP 13433 792 35 , , , 13433 792 36 the the DT 13433 792 37 decision decision NN 13433 792 38 of of IN 13433 792 39 which which WDT 13433 792 40 excites excite VBZ 13433 792 41 the the DT 13433 792 42 wrath wrath NN 13433 792 43 of of IN 13433 792 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 792 45 diffident diffident NN 13433 792 46 critic critic NN 13433 792 47 , , , 13433 792 48 that that IN 13433 792 49 the the DT 13433 792 50 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 792 51 in in IN 13433 792 52 no no DT 13433 792 53 form form NN 13433 792 54 have have VBP 13433 792 55 " " `` 13433 792 56 any any DT 13433 792 57 value value NN 13433 792 58 as as IN 13433 792 59 evidence evidence NN 13433 792 60 for for IN 13433 792 61 an an DT 13433 792 62 earlier early JJR 13433 792 63 period period NN 13433 792 64 than than IN 13433 792 65 the the DT 13433 792 66 end end NN 13433 792 67 of of IN 13433 792 68 the the DT 13433 792 69 second second JJ 13433 792 70 or or CC 13433 792 71 beginning beginning NN 13433 792 72 of of IN 13433 792 73 the the DT 13433 792 74 third third JJ 13433 792 75 century century NN 13433 792 76 , , , 13433 792 77 even even RB 13433 792 78 if if IN 13433 792 79 they -PRON- PRP 13433 792 80 have have VBP 13433 792 81 any any DT 13433 792 82 value value NN 13433 792 83 at at RB 13433 792 84 all all RB 13433 792 85 . . . 13433 792 86 " " '' 13433 793 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 793 2 merely merely RB 13433 793 3 represent represent VBP 13433 793 4 the the DT 13433 793 5 opinion opinion NN 13433 793 6 of of IN 13433 793 7 others other NNS 13433 793 8 regarding regard VBG 13433 793 9 those those DT 13433 793 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 793 11 . . . 13433 794 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 794 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 794 3 very very RB 13433 794 4 greatly greatly RB 13433 794 5 exaggerates exaggerate VBZ 13433 794 6 the the DT 13433 794 7 importance importance NN 13433 794 8 attached attach VBN 13433 794 9 to to IN 13433 794 10 the the DT 13433 794 11 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 794 12 version version NN 13433 794 13 , , , 13433 794 14 and and CC 13433 794 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 794 16 call call VBP 13433 794 17 special special JJ 13433 794 18 attention attention NN 13433 794 19 to to IN 13433 794 20 the the DT 13433 794 21 passages passage NNS 13433 794 22 in in IN 13433 794 23 the the DT 13433 794 24 above above JJ 13433 794 25 quotation quotation NN 13433 794 26 which which WDT 13433 794 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 794 28 have have VBP 13433 794 29 taken take VBN 13433 794 30 the the DT 13433 794 31 liberty liberty NN 13433 794 32 of of IN 13433 794 33 italicising italicising NN 13433 794 34 . . . 13433 795 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 795 2 venture venture VBP 13433 795 3 to to TO 13433 795 4 say say VB 13433 795 5 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 795 6 that that DT 13433 795 7 , , , 13433 795 8 so so RB 13433 795 9 far far RB 13433 795 10 from from IN 13433 795 11 being be VBG 13433 795 12 considered consider VBN 13433 795 13 the the DT 13433 795 14 " " `` 13433 795 15 key key NN 13433 795 16 of of IN 13433 795 17 the the DT 13433 795 18 position position NN 13433 795 19 , , , 13433 795 20 " " '' 13433 795 21 this this DT 13433 795 22 version version NN 13433 795 23 has have VBZ 13433 795 24 , , , 13433 795 25 with with IN 13433 795 26 some some DT 13433 795 27 exceptions exception NNS 13433 795 28 , , , 13433 795 29 played play VBD 13433 795 30 a a DT 13433 795 31 most most RBS 13433 795 32 subordinate subordinate JJ 13433 795 33 and and CC 13433 795 34 insignificant insignificant JJ 13433 795 35 part part NN 13433 795 36 in in IN 13433 795 37 the the DT 13433 795 38 controversy controversy NN 13433 795 39 , , , 13433 795 40 and and CC 13433 795 41 as as IN 13433 795 42 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 795 43 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 795 44 has have VBZ 13433 795 45 expressly expressly RB 13433 795 46 mentioned mention VBN 13433 795 47 certain certain JJ 13433 795 48 writers writer NNS 13433 795 49 , , , 13433 795 50 I -PRON- PRP 13433 795 51 will will MD 13433 795 52 state state VB 13433 795 53 how how WRB 13433 795 54 the the DT 13433 795 55 case case NN 13433 795 56 stands stand VBZ 13433 795 57 with with IN 13433 795 58 regard regard NN 13433 795 59 to to IN 13433 795 60 them -PRON- PRP 13433 795 61 . . . 13433 796 1 Weiss Weiss NNP 13433 796 2 , , , 13433 796 3 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 796 4 , , , 13433 796 5 Uhlhorn Uhlhorn NNP 13433 796 6 , , , 13433 796 7 Merx Merx NNP 13433 796 8 , , , 13433 796 9 and and CC 13433 796 10 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 796 11 certainly certainly RB 13433 796 12 " " `` 13433 796 13 more more RBR 13433 796 14 or or CC 13433 796 15 less less RBR 13433 796 16 prominently prominently RB 13433 796 17 " " `` 13433 796 18 deal deal NN 13433 796 19 with with IN 13433 796 20 them -PRON- PRP 13433 796 21 . . . 13433 797 1 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 13433 797 2 , , , 13433 797 3 however however RB 13433 797 4 , , , 13433 797 5 only only RB 13433 797 6 refers refer VBZ 13433 797 7 to to IN 13433 797 8 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 797 9 's 's POS 13433 797 10 publication publication NN 13433 797 11 , , , 13433 797 12 which which WDT 13433 797 13 appeared appear VBD 13433 797 14 while while IN 13433 797 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 797 16 own own JJ 13433 797 17 _ _ NNP 13433 797 18 brochure brochure NN 13433 797 19 _ _ NNP 13433 797 20 was be VBD 13433 797 21 passing pass VBG 13433 797 22 through through IN 13433 797 23 the the DT 13433 797 24 press press NN 13433 797 25 , , , 13433 797 26 in in IN 13433 797 27 a a DT 13433 797 28 short short JJ 13433 797 29 note note NN 13433 797 30 at at IN 13433 797 31 the the DT 13433 797 32 end end NN 13433 797 33 , , , 13433 797 34 and and CC 13433 797 35 in in IN 13433 797 36 again again RB 13433 797 37 writing write VBG 13433 797 38 on on IN 13433 797 39 the the DT 13433 797 40 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 797 41 question question NN 13433 797 42 , , , 13433 797 43 two two CD 13433 797 44 years year NNS 13433 797 45 after after IN 13433 797 46 , , , 13433 797 47 [ [ -LRB- 13433 797 48 79:1 79:1 CD 13433 797 49 ] ] -RRB- 13433 797 50 he -PRON- PRP 13433 797 51 does do VBZ 13433 797 52 not not RB 13433 797 53 even even RB 13433 797 54 allude allude VB 13433 797 55 to to IN 13433 797 56 the the DT 13433 797 57 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 797 58 version version NN 13433 797 59 . . . 13433 798 1 Beyond beyond IN 13433 798 2 the the DT 13433 798 3 barest bare JJS 13433 798 4 historical historical JJ 13433 798 5 reference reference NN 13433 798 6 to to IN 13433 798 7 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 798 8 's 's POS 13433 798 9 work work NN 13433 798 10 , , , 13433 798 11 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 798 12 does do VBZ 13433 798 13 not not RB 13433 798 14 discuss discuss VB 13433 798 15 the the DT 13433 798 16 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 798 17 version version NN 13433 798 18 at at RB 13433 798 19 all all RB 13433 798 20 . . . 13433 799 1 So so RB 13433 799 2 much much JJ 13433 799 3 for for IN 13433 799 4 the the DT 13433 799 5 writers writer NNS 13433 799 6 actually actually RB 13433 799 7 mentioned mention VBN 13433 799 8 by by IN 13433 799 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 799 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 799 11 . . . 13433 800 1 As as IN 13433 800 2 for for IN 13433 800 3 " " `` 13433 800 4 the the DT 13433 800 5 writers writer NNS 13433 800 6 who who WP 13433 800 7 have have VBP 13433 800 8 specially specially RB 13433 800 9 discussed discuss VBN 13433 800 10 the the DT 13433 800 11 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 800 12 question question NN 13433 800 13 during during IN 13433 800 14 the the DT 13433 800 15 last last JJ 13433 800 16 quarter quarter NN 13433 800 17 of of IN 13433 800 18 a a DT 13433 800 19 century century NN 13433 800 20 : : : 13433 800 21 " " `` 13433 800 22 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 800 23 apparently apparently RB 13433 800 24 did do VBD 13433 800 25 not not RB 13433 800 26 think think VB 13433 800 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 800 28 worth worth JJ 13433 800 29 while while IN 13433 800 30 to to TO 13433 800 31 add add VB 13433 800 32 anything anything NN 13433 800 33 regarding regard VBG 13433 800 34 the the DT 13433 800 35 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 800 36 version version NN 13433 800 37 of of IN 13433 800 38 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 800 39 after after IN 13433 800 40 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 800 41 appearance appearance NN 13433 800 42 ; ; : 13433 800 43 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 800 44 refutes refute VBZ 13433 800 45 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 800 46 's 's POS 13433 800 47 arguments argument NNS 13433 800 48 in in IN 13433 800 49 a a DT 13433 800 50 few few JJ 13433 800 51 pages page NNS 13433 800 52 of of IN 13433 800 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 800 54 " " `` 13433 800 55 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 800 56 ; ; : 13433 800 57 " " '' 13433 800 58 [ [ -LRB- 13433 800 59 79:2 79:2 CD 13433 800 60 ] ] -RRB- 13433 800 61 Baur Baur NNP 13433 800 62 , , , 13433 800 63 who who WP 13433 800 64 wrote write VBD 13433 800 65 against against IN 13433 800 66 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 800 67 and and CC 13433 800 68 the the DT 13433 800 69 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 800 70 letters letter NNS 13433 800 71 , , , 13433 800 72 and and CC 13433 800 73 , , , 13433 800 74 according accord VBG 13433 800 75 to to IN 13433 800 76 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 800 77 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 800 78 's 's POS 13433 800 79 representation representation NN 13433 800 80 , , , 13433 800 81 should should MD 13433 800 82 have have VB 13433 800 83 found find VBN 13433 800 84 this this DT 13433 800 85 " " `` 13433 800 86 the the DT 13433 800 87 most most RBS 13433 800 88 formidable formidable JJ 13433 800 89 argument argument NN 13433 800 90 " " '' 13433 800 91 against against IN 13433 800 92 them -PRON- PRP 13433 800 93 , , , 13433 800 94 does do VBZ 13433 800 95 not not RB 13433 800 96 anywhere anywhere RB 13433 800 97 , , , 13433 800 98 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 800 99 to to IN 13433 800 100 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 800 101 publication publication NN 13433 800 102 , , , 13433 800 103 even even RB 13433 800 104 allude allude VB 13433 800 105 to to IN 13433 800 106 the the DT 13433 800 107 Armenian Armenian NNP 13433 800 108 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 800 109 ; ; : 13433 800 110 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 800 111 , , , 13433 800 112 in in IN 13433 800 113 a a DT 13433 800 114 note note NN 13433 800 115 of of IN 13433 800 116 a a DT 13433 800 117 couple couple NN 13433 800 118 of of IN 13433 800 119 lines line NNS 13433 800 120 , , , 13433 800 121 [ [ -LRB- 13433 800 122 79:3 79:3 CD 13433 800 123 ] ] -RRB- 13433 800 124 refers refer VBZ 13433 800 125 to to IN 13433 800 126 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 800 127 's 's POS 13433 800 128 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 800 129 as as RB 13433 800 130 identical identical JJ 13433 800 131 with with IN 13433 800 132 a a DT 13433 800 133 post post JJ 13433 800 134 - - JJ 13433 800 135 Eusebian eusebian JJ 13433 800 136 manipulated manipulate VBN 13433 800 137 form form NN 13433 800 138 of of IN 13433 800 139 the the DT 13433 800 140 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 800 141 which which WDT 13433 800 142 he -PRON- PRP 13433 800 143 mentions mention VBZ 13433 800 144 in in IN 13433 800 145 a a DT 13433 800 146 sentence sentence NN 13433 800 147 in in IN 13433 800 148 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 800 149 text text NN 13433 800 150 ; ; : 13433 800 151 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 800 152 devotes devote VBZ 13433 800 153 a a DT 13433 800 154 few few JJ 13433 800 155 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 13433 800 156 lines line NNS 13433 800 157 to to IN 13433 800 158 them -PRON- PRP 13433 800 159 ; ; : 13433 800 160 [ [ -LRB- 13433 800 161 80:1 80:1 CD 13433 800 162 ] ] -RRB- 13433 800 163 Hefele Hefele NNP 13433 800 164 [ [ -LRB- 13433 800 165 80:2 80:2 CD 13433 800 166 ] ] -RRB- 13433 800 167 supports support VBZ 13433 800 168 them -PRON- PRP 13433 800 169 at at IN 13433 800 170 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 800 171 greater great JJR 13433 800 172 length length NN 13433 800 173 ; ; : 13433 800 174 but but CC 13433 800 175 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 800 176 , , , 13433 800 177 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 800 178 , , , 13433 800 179 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 800 180 , , , 13433 800 181 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 13433 800 182 , , , 13433 800 183 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 800 184 , , , 13433 800 185 and and CC 13433 800 186 others other NNS 13433 800 187 have have VBP 13433 800 188 not not RB 13433 800 189 thought think VBN 13433 800 190 them -PRON- PRP 13433 800 191 worthy worthy JJ 13433 800 192 of of IN 13433 800 193 special special JJ 13433 800 194 notice notice NN 13433 800 195 ; ; : 13433 800 196 at at IN 13433 800 197 any any DT 13433 800 198 rate rate NN 13433 800 199 none none NN 13433 800 200 of of IN 13433 800 201 these these DT 13433 800 202 nor nor CC 13433 800 203 any any DT 13433 800 204 other other JJ 13433 800 205 writers writer NNS 13433 800 206 of of IN 13433 800 207 any any DT 13433 800 208 weight weight NN 13433 800 209 have have VBP 13433 800 210 , , , 13433 800 211 so so RB 13433 800 212 far far RB 13433 800 213 as as IN 13433 800 214 I -PRON- PRP 13433 800 215 am be VBP 13433 800 216 aware aware JJ 13433 800 217 , , , 13433 800 218 introduced introduce VBD 13433 800 219 them -PRON- PRP 13433 800 220 into into IN 13433 800 221 the the DT 13433 800 222 controversy controversy NN 13433 800 223 at at RB 13433 800 224 all all RB 13433 800 225 . . . 13433 801 1 The the DT 13433 801 2 argument argument NN 13433 801 3 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 801 4 did do VBD 13433 801 5 not not RB 13433 801 6 seem seem VB 13433 801 7 to to IN 13433 801 8 me -PRON- PRP 13433 801 9 of of IN 13433 801 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 801 11 importance importance NN 13433 801 12 to to TO 13433 801 13 drag drag VB 13433 801 14 into into IN 13433 801 15 a a DT 13433 801 16 discussion discussion NN 13433 801 17 already already RB 13433 801 18 too too RB 13433 801 19 long long JJ 13433 801 20 and and CC 13433 801 21 complicated complicated JJ 13433 801 22 , , , 13433 801 23 and and CC 13433 801 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 801 25 refer refer VBP 13433 801 26 the the DT 13433 801 27 reader reader NN 13433 801 28 to to IN 13433 801 29 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 801 30 's 's POS 13433 801 31 reply reply NN 13433 801 32 to to IN 13433 801 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 801 34 , , , 13433 801 35 from from IN 13433 801 36 which which WDT 13433 801 37 , , , 13433 801 38 however however RB 13433 801 39 , , , 13433 801 40 I -PRON- PRP 13433 801 41 may may MD 13433 801 42 quote quote VB 13433 801 43 the the DT 13433 801 44 following follow VBG 13433 801 45 lines line NNS 13433 801 46 : : : 13433 801 47 " " `` 13433 801 48 But but CC 13433 801 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 801 50 appears appear VBZ 13433 801 51 to to IN 13433 801 52 me -PRON- PRP 13433 801 53 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 801 54 serious serious JJ 13433 801 55 to to TO 13433 801 56 say say VB 13433 801 57 : : : 13433 801 58 there there EX 13433 801 59 are be VBP 13433 801 60 the the DT 13433 801 61 Seven Seven NNP 13433 801 62 Letters Letters NNPS 13433 801 63 in in IN 13433 801 64 Armenian Armenian NNP 13433 801 65 , , , 13433 801 66 and and CC 13433 801 67 I -PRON- PRP 13433 801 68 maintain maintain VBP 13433 801 69 , , , 13433 801 70 they -PRON- PRP 13433 801 71 prove prove VBP 13433 801 72 that that IN 13433 801 73 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 801 74 's 's POS 13433 801 75 text text NN 13433 801 76 is be VBZ 13433 801 77 an an DT 13433 801 78 incomplete incomplete JJ 13433 801 79 extract extract NN 13433 801 80 , , , 13433 801 81 because because IN 13433 801 82 , , , 13433 801 83 I -PRON- PRP 13433 801 84 think think VBP 13433 801 85 , , , 13433 801 86 I -PRON- PRP 13433 801 87 have have VBP 13433 801 88 found find VBN 13433 801 89 some some DT 13433 801 90 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 801 91 idioms idiom NNS 13433 801 92 in in IN 13433 801 93 the the DT 13433 801 94 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 801 95 text text NN 13433 801 96 ! ! . 13433 802 1 Well well UH 13433 802 2 , , , 13433 802 3 if if IN 13433 802 4 that that DT 13433 802 5 is be VBZ 13433 802 6 not not RB 13433 802 7 a a DT 13433 802 8 joke joke NN 13433 802 9 , , , 13433 802 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 802 11 simply simply RB 13433 802 12 proves prove VBZ 13433 802 13 , , , 13433 802 14 according accord VBG 13433 802 15 to to IN 13433 802 16 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 802 17 logic logic NN 13433 802 18 , , , 13433 802 19 that that IN 13433 802 20 the the DT 13433 802 21 Seven Seven NNP 13433 802 22 Letters Letters NNPS 13433 802 23 must must MD 13433 802 24 have have VB 13433 802 25 once once RB 13433 802 26 been be VBN 13433 802 27 translated translate VBN 13433 802 28 into into IN 13433 802 29 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 802 30 . . . 13433 803 1 But but CC 13433 803 2 how how WRB 13433 803 3 can can MD 13433 803 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 803 5 prove prove VB 13433 803 6 that that IN 13433 803 7 the the DT 13433 803 8 Greek greek JJ 13433 803 9 original original NN 13433 803 10 of of IN 13433 803 11 this this DT 13433 803 12 supposed suppose VBN 13433 803 13 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 803 14 version version NN 13433 803 15 is be VBZ 13433 803 16 the the DT 13433 803 17 genuine genuine JJ 13433 803 18 text text NN 13433 803 19 , , , 13433 803 20 and and CC 13433 803 21 not not RB 13433 803 22 an an DT 13433 803 23 interpolated interpolate VBN 13433 803 24 and and CC 13433 803 25 partially partially RB 13433 803 26 forged forge VBD 13433 803 27 one one NN 13433 803 28 ? ? . 13433 803 29 " " '' 13433 804 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 804 2 80:3 80:3 CD 13433 804 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 804 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 804 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 804 6 blames blame VBZ 13433 804 7 me -PRON- PRP 13433 804 8 for for IN 13433 804 9 omitting omit VBG 13433 804 10 to to TO 13433 804 11 mention mention VB 13433 804 12 this this DT 13433 804 13 argument argument NN 13433 804 14 , , , 13433 804 15 on on IN 13433 804 16 the the DT 13433 804 17 ground ground NN 13433 804 18 that that IN 13433 804 19 " " `` 13433 804 20 a a DT 13433 804 21 discussion discussion NN 13433 804 22 which which WDT 13433 804 23 , , , 13433 804 24 while while IN 13433 804 25 assuming assume VBG 13433 804 26 the the DT 13433 804 27 priority priority NN 13433 804 28 of of IN 13433 804 29 the the DT 13433 804 30 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 804 31 letters letter NNS 13433 804 32 , , , 13433 804 33 ignores ignore VBZ 13433 804 34 this this DT 13433 804 35 version version NN 13433 804 36 altogether altogether RB 13433 804 37 , , , 13433 804 38 has have VBZ 13433 804 39 omitted omit VBN 13433 804 40 a a DT 13433 804 41 vital vital JJ 13433 804 42 problem problem NN 13433 804 43 of of IN 13433 804 44 which which WDT 13433 804 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 804 46 was be VBD 13433 804 47 bound bind VBN 13433 804 48 to to TO 13433 804 49 give give VB 13433 804 50 an an DT 13433 804 51 account account NN 13433 804 52 . . . 13433 804 53 " " '' 13433 805 1 Now now RB 13433 805 2 all all PDT 13433 805 3 this this DT 13433 805 4 is be VBZ 13433 805 5 sheer sheer JJ 13433 805 6 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 805 7 . . . 13433 806 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 806 2 do do VBP 13433 806 3 not not RB 13433 806 4 assume assume VB 13433 806 5 the the DT 13433 806 6 priority priority NN 13433 806 7 of of IN 13433 806 8 the the DT 13433 806 9 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 806 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 806 11 , , , 13433 806 12 and and CC 13433 806 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 806 14 examine examine VBP 13433 806 15 all all PDT 13433 806 16 the the DT 13433 806 17 passages passage NNS 13433 806 18 contained contain VBN 13433 806 19 in in IN 13433 806 20 the the DT 13433 806 21 seven seven CD 13433 806 22 Greek Greek NNP 13433 806 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 806 24 which which WDT 13433 806 25 have have VBP 13433 806 26 any any DT 13433 806 27 bearing bearing NN 13433 806 28 upon upon IN 13433 806 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 806 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 806 31 . . . 13433 807 1 Passing pass VBG 13433 807 2 on on RP 13433 807 3 to to IN 13433 807 4 another another DT 13433 807 5 point point NN 13433 807 6 , , , 13433 807 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 807 8 say say VBP 13433 807 9 : : : 13433 807 10 " " `` 13433 807 11 Seven Seven NNP 13433 807 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 807 13 have have VBP 13433 807 14 been be VBN 13433 807 15 selected select VBN 13433 807 16 out out IN 13433 807 17 of of IN 13433 807 18 fifteen fifteen CD 13433 807 19 extant extant JJ 13433 807 20 , , , 13433 807 21 all all DT 13433 807 22 equally equally RB 13433 807 23 purporting purport VBG 13433 807 24 to to TO 13433 807 25 be be VB 13433 807 26 by by IN 13433 807 27 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 807 28 , , , 13433 807 29 simply simply RB 13433 807 30 because because IN 13433 807 31 only only RB 13433 807 32 that that DT 13433 807 33 number number NN 13433 807 34 were be VBD 13433 807 35 mentioned mention VBN 13433 807 36 by by IN 13433 807 37 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 807 38 . . . 13433 807 39 " " '' 13433 808 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 808 2 81:1 81:1 CD 13433 808 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 808 4 Another another DT 13433 808 5 passage passage NN 13433 808 6 is be VBZ 13433 808 7 also also RB 13433 808 8 quoted quote VBN 13433 808 9 by by IN 13433 808 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 808 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 808 12 , , , 13433 808 13 which which WDT 13433 808 14 will will MD 13433 808 15 be be VB 13433 808 16 found find VBN 13433 808 17 a a DT 13433 808 18 little little JJ 13433 808 19 further further RB 13433 808 20 on on RB 13433 808 21 , , , 13433 808 22 where where WRB 13433 808 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 808 24 is be VBZ 13433 808 25 taken take VBN 13433 808 26 for for IN 13433 808 27 facility facility NN 13433 808 28 of of IN 13433 808 29 reference reference NN 13433 808 30 . . . 13433 809 1 Upon upon IN 13433 809 2 this this DT 13433 809 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 809 4 writes write VBZ 13433 809 5 as as IN 13433 809 6 follows:-- follows:-- `` 13433 809 7 " " `` 13433 809 8 This this DT 13433 809 9 attempt attempt NN 13433 809 10 to to TO 13433 809 11 confound confound VB 13433 809 12 the the DT 13433 809 13 seven seven CD 13433 809 14 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 809 15 mentioned mention VBN 13433 809 16 by by IN 13433 809 17 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 809 18 with with IN 13433 809 19 the the DT 13433 809 20 other other JJ 13433 809 21 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 809 22 spurious spurious JJ 13433 809 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 809 24 , , , 13433 809 25 as as IN 13433 809 26 if if IN 13433 809 27 they -PRON- PRP 13433 809 28 presented present VBD 13433 809 29 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 809 30 to to IN 13433 809 31 us -PRON- PRP 13433 809 32 with with IN 13433 809 33 the the DT 13433 809 34 same same JJ 13433 809 35 credentials credential NNS 13433 809 36 , , , 13433 809 37 ignores ignore VBZ 13433 809 38 all all PDT 13433 809 39 the the DT 13433 809 40 important important JJ 13433 809 41 facts fact NNS 13433 809 42 bearing bear VBG 13433 809 43 on on IN 13433 809 44 the the DT 13433 809 45 question question NN 13433 809 46 . . . 13433 810 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 810 2 1 1 LS 13433 810 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 810 4 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 810 5 , , , 13433 810 6 a a DT 13433 810 7 century century NN 13433 810 8 after after IN 13433 810 9 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 810 10 , , , 13433 810 11 betrays betray VBZ 13433 810 12 no no DT 13433 810 13 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 810 14 of of IN 13433 810 15 any any DT 13433 810 16 other other JJ 13433 810 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 810 18 , , , 13433 810 19 and and CC 13433 810 20 there there EX 13433 810 21 is be VBZ 13433 810 22 no no DT 13433 810 23 distinct distinct JJ 13433 810 24 trace trace NN 13433 810 25 of of IN 13433 810 26 the the DT 13433 810 27 use use NN 13433 810 28 of of IN 13433 810 29 the the DT 13433 810 30 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 810 31 spurious spurious JJ 13433 810 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 810 33 till till IN 13433 810 34 late late RB 13433 810 35 in in IN 13433 810 36 the the DT 13433 810 37 sixth sixth JJ 13433 810 38 century century NN 13433 810 39 at at IN 13433 810 40 the the DT 13433 810 41 earliest early JJS 13433 810 42 . . . 13433 811 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 811 2 2 2 LS 13433 811 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 811 4 The the DT 13433 811 5 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 811 6 spurious spurious JJ 13433 811 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 811 8 differ differ VBP 13433 811 9 widely widely RB 13433 811 10 in in IN 13433 811 11 style style NN 13433 811 12 from from IN 13433 811 13 the the DT 13433 811 14 seven seven CD 13433 811 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 811 16 , , , 13433 811 17 and and CC 13433 811 18 betray betray VB 13433 811 19 the the DT 13433 811 20 same same JJ 13433 811 21 hand hand NN 13433 811 22 which which WDT 13433 811 23 interpolated interpolate VBD 13433 811 24 the the DT 13433 811 25 seven seven CD 13433 811 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 811 27 . . . 13433 812 1 In in IN 13433 812 2 other other JJ 13433 812 3 words word NNS 13433 812 4 , , , 13433 812 5 they -PRON- PRP 13433 812 6 clearly clearly RB 13433 812 7 formed form VBD 13433 812 8 part part NN 13433 812 9 of of IN 13433 812 10 the the DT 13433 812 11 Long Long NNP 13433 812 12 Recension Recension NNP 13433 812 13 in in IN 13433 812 14 the the DT 13433 812 15 first first JJ 13433 812 16 instance instance NN 13433 812 17 . . . 13433 813 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 813 2 3 3 LS 13433 813 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 813 4 They -PRON- PRP 13433 813 5 abound abound VBP 13433 813 6 in in IN 13433 813 7 anachronisms anachronism NNS 13433 813 8 which which WDT 13433 813 9 point point VBP 13433 813 10 to to IN 13433 813 11 an an DT 13433 813 12 age age NN 13433 813 13 later later RB 13433 813 14 than than IN 13433 813 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 813 16 , , , 13433 813 17 as as IN 13433 813 18 the the DT 13433 813 19 date date NN 13433 813 20 of of IN 13433 813 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 813 22 composition composition NN 13433 813 23 . . . 13433 813 24 " " '' 13433 814 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 814 2 81:2 81:2 CD 13433 814 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 814 4 Although although IN 13433 814 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 814 6 do do VBP 13433 814 7 not not RB 13433 814 8 really really RB 13433 814 9 say say VB 13433 814 10 in in IN 13433 814 11 the the DT 13433 814 12 above above JJ 13433 814 13 that that IN 13433 814 14 no no DT 13433 814 15 other other JJ 13433 814 16 pleas plea NNS 13433 814 17 are be VBP 13433 814 18 advanced advanced JJ 13433 814 19 in in IN 13433 814 20 favour favour NN 13433 814 21 of of IN 13433 814 22 the the DT 13433 814 23 seven seven CD 13433 814 24 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 814 25 , , , 13433 814 26 I -PRON- PRP 13433 814 27 contend contend VBP 13433 814 28 that that IN 13433 814 29 , , , 13433 814 30 reduced reduce VBN 13433 814 31 to to IN 13433 814 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 814 33 simplest simple JJS 13433 814 34 form form NN 13433 814 35 , , , 13433 814 36 the the DT 13433 814 37 argument argument NN 13433 814 38 for for IN 13433 814 39 that that DT 13433 814 40 special special JJ 13433 814 41 number number NN 13433 814 42 rests rest NNS 13433 814 43 mainly mainly RB 13433 814 44 , , , 13433 814 45 if if IN 13433 814 46 not not RB 13433 814 47 altogether altogether RB 13433 814 48 , , , 13433 814 49 upon upon IN 13433 814 50 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 814 51 mention mention NN 13433 814 52 by by IN 13433 814 53 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 814 54 . . . 13433 815 1 The the DT 13433 815 2 very very RB 13433 815 3 first first JJ 13433 815 4 reason reason NN 13433 815 5 ( ( -LRB- 13433 815 6 1 1 CD 13433 815 7 ) ) -RRB- 13433 815 8 advanced advance VBN 13433 815 9 by by IN 13433 815 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 815 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 815 12 to to TO 13433 815 13 refute refute VB 13433 815 14 me -PRON- PRP 13433 815 15 is be VBZ 13433 815 16 a a DT 13433 815 17 practical practical JJ 13433 815 18 admission admission NN 13433 815 19 of of IN 13433 815 20 the the DT 13433 815 21 correctness correctness NN 13433 815 22 of of IN 13433 815 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 815 24 statement statement NN 13433 815 25 , , , 13433 815 26 for for IN 13433 815 27 the the DT 13433 815 28 eight eight CD 13433 815 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 815 30 are be VBP 13433 815 31 put put VBN 13433 815 32 out out IN 13433 815 33 of of IN 13433 815 34 court court NN 13433 815 35 because because IN 13433 815 36 even even RB 13433 815 37 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 815 38 , , , 13433 815 39 a a DT 13433 815 40 century century NN 13433 815 41 after after IN 13433 815 42 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 815 43 , , , 13433 815 44 does do VBZ 13433 815 45 not not RB 13433 815 46 betray betray VB 13433 815 47 any any DT 13433 815 48 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 815 49 of of IN 13433 815 50 them -PRON- PRP 13433 815 51 , , , 13433 815 52 but but CC 13433 815 53 the the DT 13433 815 54 " " `` 13433 815 55 silence silence NN 13433 815 56 of of IN 13433 815 57 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 815 58 , , , 13433 815 59 " " '' 13433 815 60 the the DT 13433 815 61 earlier early JJR 13433 815 62 witness witness NN 13433 815 63 , , , 13433 815 64 is be VBZ 13433 815 65 infinitely infinitely RB 13433 815 66 more more RBR 13433 815 67 important important JJ 13433 815 68 , , , 13433 815 69 and and CC 13433 815 70 it -PRON- PRP 13433 815 71 merely merely RB 13433 815 72 receives receive VBZ 13433 815 73 some some DT 13433 815 74 increase increase NN 13433 815 75 of of IN 13433 815 76 significance significance NN 13433 815 77 from from IN 13433 815 78 the the DT 13433 815 79 silence silence NN 13433 815 80 of of IN 13433 815 81 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 815 82 . . . 13433 816 1 Suppose suppose VB 13433 816 2 , , , 13433 816 3 however however RB 13433 816 4 , , , 13433 816 5 that that IN 13433 816 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 816 7 had have VBD 13433 816 8 referred refer VBN 13433 816 9 to to IN 13433 816 10 any any DT 13433 816 11 of of IN 13433 816 12 them -PRON- PRP 13433 816 13 , , , 13433 816 14 how how WRB 13433 816 15 changed change VBD 13433 816 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 816 17 position position NN 13433 816 18 would would MD 13433 816 19 have have VB 13433 816 20 been be VBN 13433 816 21 ! ! . 13433 817 1 The the DT 13433 817 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 817 3 referred refer VBD 13433 817 4 to to TO 13433 817 5 would would MD 13433 817 6 have have VB 13433 817 7 attained attain VBN 13433 817 8 the the DT 13433 817 9 exceptional exceptional JJ 13433 817 10 distinction distinction NN 13433 817 11 which which WDT 13433 817 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 817 13 mention mention NN 13433 817 14 has have VBZ 13433 817 15 conferred confer VBN 13433 817 16 upon upon IN 13433 817 17 the the DT 13433 817 18 rest rest NN 13433 817 19 .. .. . 13433 818 1 The the DT 13433 818 2 fact fact NN 13433 818 3 is be VBZ 13433 818 4 , , , 13433 818 5 moreover moreover RB 13433 818 6 , , , 13433 818 7 that that IN 13433 818 8 , , , 13433 818 9 throughout throughout IN 13433 818 10 the the DT 13433 818 11 controversy controversy NN 13433 818 12 , , , 13433 818 13 the the DT 13433 818 14 two two CD 13433 818 15 divisions division NNS 13433 818 16 of of IN 13433 818 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 818 18 are be VBP 13433 818 19 commonly commonly RB 13433 818 20 designated designate VBN 13433 818 21 the the DT 13433 818 22 " " `` 13433 818 23 prae- prae- JJ 13433 818 24 " " '' 13433 818 25 and and CC 13433 818 26 " " `` 13433 818 27 post post JJ 13433 818 28 - - JJ 13433 818 29 Eusebian eusebian JJ 13433 818 30 , , , 13433 818 31 " " '' 13433 818 32 making make VBG 13433 818 33 him -PRON- PRP 13433 818 34 the the DT 13433 818 35 turning turning NN 13433 818 36 - - HYPH 13433 818 37 point point NN 13433 818 38 of of IN 13433 818 39 the the DT 13433 818 40 controversy controversy NN 13433 818 41 . . . 13433 819 1 Indeed indeed RB 13433 819 2 , , , 13433 819 3 further further RB 13433 819 4 on on RB 13433 819 5 , , , 13433 819 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 819 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 819 8 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 819 9 admits admit VBZ 13433 819 10 : : : 13433 819 11 " " `` 13433 819 12 The the DT 13433 819 13 testimony testimony NN 13433 819 14 of of IN 13433 819 15 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 819 16 first first RB 13433 819 17 differentiates differentiate VBZ 13433 819 18 them -PRON- PRP 13433 819 19 . . . 13433 819 20 " " '' 13433 820 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 820 2 82:1 82:1 CD 13433 820 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 820 4 The the DT 13433 820 5 argument argument NN 13433 820 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 820 7 2 2 CD 13433 820 8 and and CC 13433 820 9 3 3 CD 13433 820 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 820 11 that that IN 13433 820 12 the the DT 13433 820 13 eight eight CD 13433 820 14 rejected reject VBN 13433 820 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 820 16 betray betray NN 13433 820 17 anachronisms anachronism NNS 13433 820 18 and and CC 13433 820 19 interpolations interpolation NNS 13433 820 20 , , , 13433 820 21 is be VBZ 13433 820 22 no no DT 13433 820 23 refutation refutation NN 13433 820 24 of of IN 13433 820 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 820 26 statement statement NN 13433 820 27 , , , 13433 820 28 for for IN 13433 820 29 the the DT 13433 820 30 same same JJ 13433 820 31 accusation accusation NN 13433 820 32 is be VBZ 13433 820 33 brought bring VBN 13433 820 34 by by IN 13433 820 35 the the DT 13433 820 36 majority majority NN 13433 820 37 of of IN 13433 820 38 critics critic NNS 13433 820 39 against against IN 13433 820 40 the the DT 13433 820 41 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 820 42 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 820 43 . . . 13433 821 1 The the DT 13433 821 2 fourth fourth JJ 13433 821 3 and and CC 13433 821 4 last last JJ 13433 821 5 argument argument NN 13433 821 6 seems seem VBZ 13433 821 7 more more RBR 13433 821 8 directly directly RB 13433 821 9 addressed address VBN 13433 821 10 to to IN 13433 821 11 a a DT 13433 821 12 second second JJ 13433 821 13 paragraph paragraph NN 13433 821 14 quoted quote VBN 13433 821 15 by by IN 13433 821 16 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 821 17 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 821 18 , , , 13433 821 19 to to TO 13433 821 20 which which WDT 13433 821 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 821 22 refer refer VBP 13433 821 23 above above IN 13433 821 24 , , , 13433 821 25 and and CC 13433 821 26 which which WDT 13433 821 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 821 28 have have VBP 13433 821 29 reserved reserve VBN 13433 821 30 till till IN 13433 821 31 now now RB 13433 821 32 , , , 13433 821 33 as as IN 13433 821 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 821 35 requires require VBZ 13433 821 36 more more RBR 13433 821 37 detailed detailed JJ 13433 821 38 notice notice NN 13433 821 39 . . . 13433 822 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 822 2 is be VBZ 13433 822 3 this:-- this:-- LS 13433 822 4 " " `` 13433 822 5 It -PRON- PRP 13433 822 6 is be VBZ 13433 822 7 a a DT 13433 822 8 total total JJ 13433 822 9 mistake mistake NN 13433 822 10 to to TO 13433 822 11 suppose suppose VB 13433 822 12 that that IN 13433 822 13 the the DT 13433 822 14 seven seven CD 13433 822 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 822 16 mentioned mention VBN 13433 822 17 by by IN 13433 822 18 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 822 19 have have VBP 13433 822 20 been be VBN 13433 822 21 transmitted transmit VBN 13433 822 22 to to IN 13433 822 23 us -PRON- PRP 13433 822 24 in in IN 13433 822 25 any any DT 13433 822 26 special special JJ 13433 822 27 way way NN 13433 822 28 . . . 13433 823 1 These these DT 13433 823 2 Epistles epistle NNS 13433 823 3 are be VBP 13433 823 4 mixed mix VBN 13433 823 5 up up RP 13433 823 6 in in IN 13433 823 7 the the DT 13433 823 8 Medicean Medicean NNP 13433 823 9 and and CC 13433 823 10 corresponding corresponding JJ 13433 823 11 ancient ancient JJ 13433 823 12 Latin Latin NNP 13433 823 13 MSS MSS NNP 13433 823 14 . . . 13433 824 1 with with IN 13433 824 2 the the DT 13433 824 3 other other JJ 13433 824 4 eight eight CD 13433 824 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 824 6 , , , 13433 824 7 universally universally RB 13433 824 8 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 824 9 to to TO 13433 824 10 be be VB 13433 824 11 spurious spurious JJ 13433 824 12 , , , 13433 824 13 without without IN 13433 824 14 distinction distinction NN 13433 824 15 of of IN 13433 824 16 any any DT 13433 824 17 kind kind NN 13433 824 18 , , , 13433 824 19 and and CC 13433 824 20 all all DT 13433 824 21 have have VBP 13433 824 22 equal equal JJ 13433 824 23 honour honour NN 13433 824 24 . . . 13433 824 25 " " '' 13433 825 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 825 2 82:2 82:2 CD 13433 825 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 825 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 825 5 will will MD 13433 825 6 at at IN 13433 825 7 once once RB 13433 825 8 give give VB 13433 825 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 825 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 825 11 's 's POS 13433 825 12 comment comment NN 13433 825 13 on on IN 13433 825 14 this this DT 13433 825 15 , , , 13433 825 16 in in IN 13433 825 17 contrast contrast NN 13433 825 18 with with IN 13433 825 19 the the DT 13433 825 20 statement statement NN 13433 825 21 of of IN 13433 825 22 a a DT 13433 825 23 writer writer NN 13433 825 24 equally equally RB 13433 825 25 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 825 26 for for IN 13433 825 27 learning learning NN 13433 825 28 and and CC 13433 825 29 orthodoxy orthodoxy NN 13433 825 30 -- -- . 13433 825 31 Dr Dr NNP 13433 825 32 . . NNP 13433 825 33 Tregelles:-- Tregelles:-- NNP 13433 825 34 DR DR NNP 13433 825 35 . . . 13433 825 36 LIGHTFOOT LIGHTFOOT NNP 13433 825 37 . . . 13433 826 1 | | NNP 13433 826 2 DR DR NNP 13433 826 3 . . . 13433 826 4 TREGELLES tregelles FW 13433 826 5 . . . 13433 827 1 | | NNP 13433 827 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 827 3 4 4 CD 13433 827 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 827 5 " " `` 13433 827 6 It -PRON- PRP 13433 827 7 is be VBZ 13433 827 8 not not RB 13433 827 9 strictly strictly RB 13433 827 10 true true JJ 13433 827 11 that that IN 13433 827 12 | | NNP 13433 827 13 " " `` 13433 827 14 It -PRON- PRP 13433 827 15 is be VBZ 13433 827 16 a a DT 13433 827 17 mistake mistake NN 13433 827 18 to to TO 13433 827 19 think think VB 13433 827 20 of of IN 13433 827 21 _ _ NNP 13433 827 22 seven seven CD 13433 827 23 _ _ NNP 13433 827 24 the the DT 13433 827 25 seven seven CD 13433 827 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 827 27 are be VBP 13433 827 28 mixed mix VBN 13433 827 29 up up RP 13433 827 30 | | JJ 13433 827 31 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 827 32 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 827 33 in in IN 13433 827 34 Greek Greek NNP 13433 827 35 having have VBG 13433 827 36 with with IN 13433 827 37 the the DT 13433 827 38 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 827 39 spurious spurious JJ 13433 827 40 | | NNS 13433 827 41 been be VBN 13433 827 42 _ _ NNP 13433 827 43 transmitted transmit VBN 13433 827 44 _ _ NNP 13433 827 45 to to IN 13433 827 46 us -PRON- PRP 13433 827 47 , , , 13433 827 48 for for IN 13433 827 49 no no DT 13433 827 50 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 827 51 . . . 13433 828 1 In in IN 13433 828 2 the the DT 13433 828 3 Greek Greek NNP 13433 828 4 and and CC 13433 828 5 Latin latin JJ 13433 828 6 | | CD 13433 828 7 such such JJ 13433 828 8 seven seven CD 13433 828 9 exist exist NN 13433 828 10 , , , 13433 828 11 except except IN 13433 828 12 through through IN 13433 828 13 MSS MSS NNP 13433 828 14 . . . 13433 828 15 , , , 13433 828 16 as as RB 13433 828 17 also also RB 13433 828 18 in in IN 13433 828 19 the the DT 13433 828 20 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 828 21 | | NNP 13433 828 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 828 23 having have VBG 13433 828 24 been be VBN 13433 828 25 selected select VBN 13433 828 26 by by IN 13433 828 27 version version NN 13433 828 28 , , , 13433 828 29 the the DT 13433 828 30 spurious spurious JJ 13433 828 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 828 32 | | NNP 13433 828 33 _ _ NNP 13433 828 34 editors editor NNS 13433 828 35 _ _ NNP 13433 828 36 from from IN 13433 828 37 the the DT 13433 828 38 Medicean Medicean NNP 13433 828 39 MS MS NNP 13433 828 40 . . . 13433 828 41 come come VB 13433 828 42 after after IN 13433 828 43 the the DT 13433 828 44 others other NNS 13433 828 45 ; ; : 13433 828 46 and and CC 13433 828 47 the the DT 13433 828 48 | | NNS 13433 828 49 which which WDT 13433 828 50 contains contain VBZ 13433 828 51 so so RB 13433 828 52 much much RB 13433 828 53 that that DT 13433 828 54 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 828 55 , , , 13433 828 56 combined combine VBN 13433 828 57 with with IN 13433 828 58 the the DT 13433 828 59 | | NNP 13433 828 60 is be VBZ 13433 828 61 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 828 62 spurious;--a spurious;--a JJ 13433 828 63 fact fact NN 13433 828 64 facts fact NNS 13433 828 65 already already RB 13433 828 66 mentioned mention VBN 13433 828 67 , , , 13433 828 68 plainly plainly RB 13433 828 69 | | CD 13433 828 70 which which WDT 13433 828 71 some some DT 13433 828 72 who who WP 13433 828 73 imagine imagine VBP 13433 828 74 a a DT 13433 828 75 shows show NNS 13433 828 76 that that IN 13433 828 77 they -PRON- PRP 13433 828 78 were be VBD 13433 828 79 a a DT 13433 828 80 later later RB 13433 828 81 | | HYPH 13433 828 82 diplomatic diplomatic JJ 13433 828 83 transmission transmission NN 13433 828 84 of of IN 13433 828 85 addition addition NN 13433 828 86 , , , 13433 828 87 borrowed borrow VBN 13433 828 88 from from IN 13433 828 89 the the DT 13433 828 90 Long Long NNP 13433 828 91 | | NNP 13433 828 92 _ _ NNP 13433 828 93 seven seven CD 13433 828 94 _ _ NNP 13433 828 95 have have VBP 13433 828 96 overlooked overlook VBN 13433 828 97 . . . 13433 828 98 " " '' 13433 829 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 829 2 83:2 83:2 CD 13433 829 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 829 4 Recension recension NN 13433 829 5 to to TO 13433 829 6 complete complete VB 13433 829 7 the the DT 13433 829 8 body body NN 13433 829 9 | | NNS 13433 829 10 of of IN 13433 829 11 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 829 12 letters letter NNS 13433 829 13 . . . 13433 829 14 " " '' 13433 830 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 830 2 83:1 83:1 CD 13433 830 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 830 4 | | NNS 13433 830 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 830 6 will will MD 13433 830 7 further further RB 13433 830 8 quote quote VB 13433 830 9 the the DT 13433 830 10 words word NNS 13433 830 11 of of IN 13433 830 12 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 830 13 , , , 13433 830 14 for for IN 13433 830 15 , , , 13433 830 16 as as IN 13433 830 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 830 18 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 830 19 advances advance VBZ 13433 830 20 nothing nothing NN 13433 830 21 but but IN 13433 830 22 assertions assertion NNS 13433 830 23 , , , 13433 830 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 830 25 is be VBZ 13433 830 26 well well JJ 13433 830 27 to to TO 13433 830 28 meet meet VB 13433 830 29 him -PRON- PRP 13433 830 30 with with IN 13433 830 31 the the DT 13433 830 32 testimony testimony NN 13433 830 33 of of IN 13433 830 34 others other NNS 13433 830 35 rather rather RB 13433 830 36 than than IN 13433 830 37 the the DT 13433 830 38 mere mere JJ 13433 830 39 reiteration reiteration NN 13433 830 40 of of IN 13433 830 41 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 830 42 own own JJ 13433 830 43 statement statement NN 13433 830 44 . . . 13433 831 1 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 831 2 says say VBZ 13433 831 3 : : : 13433 831 4 " " `` 13433 831 5 Again again RB 13433 831 6 , , , 13433 831 7 there there EX 13433 831 8 is be VBZ 13433 831 9 another another DT 13433 831 10 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 831 11 which which WDT 13433 831 12 will will MD 13433 831 13 naturally naturally RB 13433 831 14 lead lead VB 13433 831 15 us -PRON- PRP 13433 831 16 to to TO 13433 831 17 look look VB 13433 831 18 with with IN 13433 831 19 some some DT 13433 831 20 suspicion suspicion NN 13433 831 21 upon upon IN 13433 831 22 the the DT 13433 831 23 recension recension NN 13433 831 24 of of IN 13433 831 25 the the DT 13433 831 26 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 831 27 of of IN 13433 831 28 St. St. NNP 13433 831 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 831 30 , , , 13433 831 31 as as IN 13433 831 32 exhibited exhibit VBN 13433 831 33 in in IN 13433 831 34 the the DT 13433 831 35 Medicean Medicean NNP 13433 831 36 MS MS NNP 13433 831 37 . . NNP 13433 831 38 , , , 13433 831 39 and and CC 13433 831 40 in in IN 13433 831 41 the the DT 13433 831 42 ancient ancient JJ 13433 831 43 Latin Latin NNP 13433 831 44 version version NN 13433 831 45 corresponding correspond VBG 13433 831 46 with with IN 13433 831 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 831 48 , , , 13433 831 49 which which WDT 13433 831 50 is be VBZ 13433 831 51 , , , 13433 831 52 that that IN 13433 831 53 the the DT 13433 831 54 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 831 55 presumed presume VBN 13433 831 56 to to TO 13433 831 57 be be VB 13433 831 58 the the DT 13433 831 59 genuine genuine JJ 13433 831 60 production production NN 13433 831 61 of of IN 13433 831 62 that that DT 13433 831 63 holy holy NNP 13433 831 64 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 831 65 are be VBP 13433 831 66 mixed mix VBN 13433 831 67 up up RP 13433 831 68 with with IN 13433 831 69 others other NNS 13433 831 70 , , , 13433 831 71 which which WDT 13433 831 72 are be VBP 13433 831 73 almost almost RB 13433 831 74 universally universally RB 13433 831 75 allowed allow VBN 13433 831 76 to to TO 13433 831 77 be be VB 13433 831 78 spurious spurious JJ 13433 831 79 . . . 13433 832 1 Both both DT 13433 832 2 in in IN 13433 832 3 the the DT 13433 832 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 832 5 and and CC 13433 832 6 Latin Latin NNP 13433 832 7 MSS MSS NNP 13433 832 8 . . . 13433 833 1 all all PDT 13433 833 2 these these DT 13433 833 3 are be VBP 13433 833 4 placed place VBN 13433 833 5 upon upon IN 13433 833 6 the the DT 13433 833 7 same same JJ 13433 833 8 footing footing NN 13433 833 9 , , , 13433 833 10 and and CC 13433 833 11 no no DT 13433 833 12 distinction distinction NN 13433 833 13 is be VBZ 13433 833 14 drawn draw VBN 13433 833 15 between between IN 13433 833 16 them -PRON- PRP 13433 833 17 ; ; : 13433 833 18 and and CC 13433 833 19 the the DT 13433 833 20 only only JJ 13433 833 21 ground ground NN 13433 833 22 which which WDT 13433 833 23 has have VBZ 13433 833 24 hitherto hitherto VBN 13433 833 25 been be VBN 13433 833 26 assumed assume VBN 13433 833 27 for for IN 13433 833 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 833 29 separation separation NN 13433 833 30 has have VBZ 13433 833 31 been be VBN 13433 833 32 the the DT 13433 833 33 specification specification NN 13433 833 34 of of IN 13433 833 35 some some DT 13433 833 36 of of IN 13433 833 37 them -PRON- PRP 13433 833 38 by by IN 13433 833 39 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 833 40 and and CC 13433 833 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 833 42 omission omission NN 13433 833 43 of of IN 13433 833 44 any any DT 13433 833 45 mention mention NN 13433 833 46 of of IN 13433 833 47 the the DT 13433 833 48 others other NNS 13433 833 49 . . . 13433 833 50 " " '' 13433 834 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 834 2 83:3 83:3 CD 13433 834 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 834 4 " " `` 13433 834 5 The the DT 13433 834 6 external external JJ 13433 834 7 evidence evidence NN 13433 834 8 from from IN 13433 834 9 the the DT 13433 834 10 testimony testimony NN 13433 834 11 of of IN 13433 834 12 manuscripts manuscript NNS 13433 834 13 in in IN 13433 834 14 favour favour NN 13433 834 15 of of IN 13433 834 16 the the DT 13433 834 17 rejected reject VBN 13433 834 18 Greek Greek NNP 13433 834 19 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 834 20 , , , 13433 834 21 with with IN 13433 834 22 the the DT 13433 834 23 exception exception NN 13433 834 24 of of IN 13433 834 25 that that DT 13433 834 26 to to IN 13433 834 27 the the DT 13433 834 28 Philippians Philippians NNPS 13433 834 29 , , , 13433 834 30 is be VBZ 13433 834 31 certainly certainly RB 13433 834 32 greater great JJR 13433 834 33 than than IN 13433 834 34 that that DT 13433 834 35 in in IN 13433 834 36 favour favour NN 13433 834 37 of of IN 13433 834 38 those those DT 13433 834 39 which which WDT 13433 834 40 have have VBP 13433 834 41 been be VBN 13433 834 42 received receive VBN 13433 834 43 . . . 13433 835 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 835 2 are be VBP 13433 835 3 found find VBN 13433 835 4 in in IN 13433 835 5 all all PDT 13433 835 6 the the DT 13433 835 7 manuscripts manuscript NNS 13433 835 8 , , , 13433 835 9 both both DT 13433 835 10 Greek Greek NNP 13433 835 11 and and CC 13433 835 12 Latin Latin NNP 13433 835 13 , , , 13433 835 14 in in IN 13433 835 15 the the DT 13433 835 16 same same JJ 13433 835 17 form form NN 13433 835 18 ; ; : 13433 835 19 while while IN 13433 835 20 the the DT 13433 835 21 others other NNS 13433 835 22 exhibit exhibit VBP 13433 835 23 two two CD 13433 835 24 distinct distinct JJ 13433 835 25 and and CC 13433 835 26 very very RB 13433 835 27 different different JJ 13433 835 28 recensions recension NNS 13433 835 29 , , , 13433 835 30 if if IN 13433 835 31 we -PRON- PRP 13433 835 32 except except IN 13433 835 33 the the DT 13433 835 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 835 35 to to IN 13433 835 36 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 835 37 , , , 13433 835 38 in in IN 13433 835 39 which which WDT 13433 835 40 the the DT 13433 835 41 variations variation NNS 13433 835 42 are be VBP 13433 835 43 very very RB 13433 835 44 few few JJ 13433 835 45 . . . 13433 836 1 Of of IN 13433 836 2 these these DT 13433 836 3 two two CD 13433 836 4 recensions recension NNS 13433 836 5 the the DT 13433 836 6 shorter short JJR 13433 836 7 has have VBZ 13433 836 8 been be VBN 13433 836 9 most most RBS 13433 836 10 generally generally RB 13433 836 11 received receive VBN 13433 836 12 : : : 13433 836 13 the the DT 13433 836 14 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 836 15 of of IN 13433 836 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 836 17 being be VBG 13433 836 18 shorter short JJR 13433 836 19 seems seem VBZ 13433 836 20 much much JJ 13433 836 21 to to TO 13433 836 22 have have VB 13433 836 23 influenced influence VBN 13433 836 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 836 25 reception reception NN 13433 836 26 ; ; : 13433 836 27 and and CC 13433 836 28 the the DT 13433 836 29 text text NN 13433 836 30 of of IN 13433 836 31 the the DT 13433 836 32 Medicean Medicean NNP 13433 836 33 Codex Codex NNP 13433 836 34 and and CC 13433 836 35 of of IN 13433 836 36 the the DT 13433 836 37 two two CD 13433 836 38 copies copy NNS 13433 836 39 of of IN 13433 836 40 the the DT 13433 836 41 corresponding correspond VBG 13433 836 42 Latin latin JJ 13433 836 43 version version NN 13433 836 44 belonging belong VBG 13433 836 45 to to IN 13433 836 46 Caius Caius NNP 13433 836 47 College College NNP 13433 836 48 , , , 13433 836 49 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 13433 836 50 , , , 13433 836 51 and and CC 13433 836 52 Corpus Corpus NNP 13433 836 53 Christi Christi NNP 13433 836 54 College College NNP 13433 836 55 , , , 13433 836 56 Oxford Oxford NNP 13433 836 57 , , , 13433 836 58 has have VBZ 13433 836 59 been be VBN 13433 836 60 adopted adopt VBN 13433 836 61 ... ... . 13433 837 1 In in IN 13433 837 2 all all PDT 13433 837 3 these these DT 13433 837 4 there there EX 13433 837 5 is be VBZ 13433 837 6 no no DT 13433 837 7 distinction distinction NN 13433 837 8 whatever whatever WDT 13433 837 9 drawn draw VBN 13433 837 10 between between IN 13433 837 11 the the DT 13433 837 12 former former JJ 13433 837 13 and and CC 13433 837 14 latter latter JJ 13433 837 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 837 16 : : : 13433 837 17 all all DT 13433 837 18 are be VBP 13433 837 19 placed place VBN 13433 837 20 upon upon IN 13433 837 21 the the DT 13433 837 22 same same JJ 13433 837 23 basis basis NN 13433 837 24 ; ; : 13433 837 25 and and CC 13433 837 26 there there EX 13433 837 27 is be VBZ 13433 837 28 no no DT 13433 837 29 ground ground NN 13433 837 30 whatever whatever WDT 13433 837 31 to to TO 13433 837 32 conclude conclude VB 13433 837 33 either either CC 13433 837 34 that that IN 13433 837 35 the the DT 13433 837 36 arranger arranger NN 13433 837 37 of of IN 13433 837 38 the the DT 13433 837 39 Greek greek JJ 13433 837 40 recension recension NN 13433 837 41 or or CC 13433 837 42 the the DT 13433 837 43 translator translator NN 13433 837 44 of of IN 13433 837 45 the the DT 13433 837 46 Latin Latin NNP 13433 837 47 version version NN 13433 837 48 esteemed esteem VBD 13433 837 49 one one CD 13433 837 50 to to TO 13433 837 51 be be VB 13433 837 52 better well JJR 13433 837 53 or or CC 13433 837 54 more more RBR 13433 837 55 genuine genuine JJ 13433 837 56 than than IN 13433 837 57 another another DT 13433 837 58 . . . 13433 838 1 Nor nor CC 13433 838 2 can can MD 13433 838 3 any any DT 13433 838 4 prejudice prejudice NN 13433 838 5 result result VB 13433 838 6 to to IN 13433 838 7 the the DT 13433 838 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 838 9 to to IN 13433 838 10 the the DT 13433 838 11 Tarsians Tarsians NNPS 13433 838 12 , , , 13433 838 13 to to IN 13433 838 14 the the DT 13433 838 15 Antiochians Antiochians NNPS 13433 838 16 , , , 13433 838 17 and and CC 13433 838 18 to to IN 13433 838 19 Hero Hero NNP 13433 838 20 , , , 13433 838 21 from from IN 13433 838 22 the the DT 13433 838 23 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 838 24 of of IN 13433 838 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 838 26 being be VBG 13433 838 27 placed place VBN 13433 838 28 after after IN 13433 838 29 the the DT 13433 838 30 others other NNS 13433 838 31 in in IN 13433 838 32 the the DT 13433 838 33 collection collection NN 13433 838 34 ; ; : 13433 838 35 for for CC 13433 838 36 they -PRON- PRP 13433 838 37 are be VBP 13433 838 38 evidently evidently RB 13433 838 39 arranged arrange VBN 13433 838 40 in in IN 13433 838 41 chronological chronological JJ 13433 838 42 order order NN 13433 838 43 , , , 13433 838 44 and and CC 13433 838 45 rank rank NN 13433 838 46 after after IN 13433 838 47 the the DT 13433 838 48 rest rest NN 13433 838 49 as as IN 13433 838 50 having have VBG 13433 838 51 been be VBN 13433 838 52 written write VBN 13433 838 53 from from IN 13433 838 54 Philippi Philippi NNP 13433 838 55 , , , 13433 838 56 at at IN 13433 838 57 which which WDT 13433 838 58 place place NN 13433 838 59 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 838 60 is be VBZ 13433 838 61 said say VBN 13433 838 62 to to TO 13433 838 63 have have VB 13433 838 64 arrived arrive VBN 13433 838 65 after after IN 13433 838 66 he -PRON- PRP 13433 838 67 had have VBD 13433 838 68 despatched despatch VBN 13433 838 69 the the DT 13433 838 70 previous previous JJ 13433 838 71 Letters letter NNS 13433 838 72 . . . 13433 839 1 So so RB 13433 839 2 far far RB 13433 839 3 , , , 13433 839 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 839 5 , , , 13433 839 6 as as IN 13433 839 7 the the DT 13433 839 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 839 9 of of IN 13433 839 10 all all PDT 13433 839 11 the the DT 13433 839 12 existing exist VBG 13433 839 13 copies copy NNS 13433 839 14 , , , 13433 839 15 Latin Latin NNP 13433 839 16 as as RB 13433 839 17 well well RB 13433 839 18 as as IN 13433 839 19 Greek Greek NNP 13433 839 20 , , , 13433 839 21 of of IN 13433 839 22 both both PDT 13433 839 23 the the DT 13433 839 24 recensions recension NNS 13433 839 25 is be VBZ 13433 839 26 to to TO 13433 839 27 be be VB 13433 839 28 considered consider VBN 13433 839 29 , , , 13433 839 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 839 31 is be VBZ 13433 839 32 certainly certainly RB 13433 839 33 in in IN 13433 839 34 favour favour NN 13433 839 35 of of IN 13433 839 36 the the DT 13433 839 37 rejected reject VBN 13433 839 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 839 39 , , , 13433 839 40 rather rather RB 13433 839 41 than than IN 13433 839 42 of of IN 13433 839 43 those those DT 13433 839 44 which which WDT 13433 839 45 have have VBP 13433 839 46 been be VBN 13433 839 47 retained retain VBN 13433 839 48 . . . 13433 839 49 " " '' 13433 840 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 840 2 84:1 84:1 CD 13433 840 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 840 4 Proceeding proceed VBG 13433 840 5 from from IN 13433 840 6 counter counter NN 13433 840 7 - - NNS 13433 840 8 statements statement NNS 13433 840 9 to to IN 13433 840 10 actual actual JJ 13433 840 11 facts fact NNS 13433 840 12 , , , 13433 840 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 840 14 will will MD 13433 840 15 very very RB 13433 840 16 briefly briefly RB 13433 840 17 show show VB 13433 840 18 the the DT 13433 840 19 order order NN 13433 840 20 in in IN 13433 840 21 which which WDT 13433 840 22 these these DT 13433 840 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 840 24 have have VBP 13433 840 25 been be VBN 13433 840 26 found find VBN 13433 840 27 in in IN 13433 840 28 some some DT 13433 840 29 of of IN 13433 840 30 the the DT 13433 840 31 principal principal JJ 13433 840 32 MSS MSS NNP 13433 840 33 . . . 13433 841 1 One one CD 13433 841 2 of of IN 13433 841 3 the the DT 13433 841 4 earliest early JJS 13433 841 5 published publish VBN 13433 841 6 was be VBD 13433 841 7 the the DT 13433 841 8 ancient ancient JJ 13433 841 9 Latin Latin NNP 13433 841 10 version version NN 13433 841 11 of of IN 13433 841 12 eleven eleven CD 13433 841 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 841 14 edited edit VBN 13433 841 15 by by IN 13433 841 16 J. J. NNP 13433 841 17 Faber Faber NNP 13433 841 18 Stapulensis Stapulensis NNP 13433 841 19 in in IN 13433 841 20 1498 1498 CD 13433 841 21 , , , 13433 841 22 which which WDT 13433 841 23 was be VBD 13433 841 24 at at RB 13433 841 25 least least RBS 13433 841 26 quoted quote VBN 13433 841 27 in in IN 13433 841 28 the the DT 13433 841 29 ninth ninth JJ 13433 841 30 century century NN 13433 841 31 , , , 13433 841 32 and and CC 13433 841 33 which which WDT 13433 841 34 in in IN 13433 841 35 the the DT 13433 841 36 subjoined subjoin VBN 13433 841 37 table table NN 13433 841 38 I -PRON- PRP 13433 841 39 shall shall MD 13433 841 40 mark mark VB 13433 841 41 A a NN 13433 841 42 , , , 13433 841 43 [ [ -LRB- 13433 841 44 84:2 84:2 CD 13433 841 45 ] ] -RRB- 13433 841 46 and and CC 13433 841 47 which which WDT 13433 841 48 also also RB 13433 841 49 exhibits exhibit VBZ 13433 841 50 the the DT 13433 841 51 order order NN 13433 841 52 of of IN 13433 841 53 Cod cod NN 13433 841 54 . . . 13433 842 1 Vat Vat NNP 13433 842 2 . . . 13433 843 1 859 859 CD 13433 843 2 , , , 13433 843 3 assigned assign VBN 13433 843 4 to to IN 13433 843 5 the the DT 13433 843 6 eleventh eleventh JJ 13433 843 7 century century NN 13433 843 8 . . . 13433 844 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 844 2 84:3 84:3 CD 13433 844 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 844 4 The the DT 13433 844 5 next next JJ 13433 844 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 844 7 B b NN 13433 844 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 844 9 is be VBZ 13433 844 10 a a DT 13433 844 11 Greek Greek NNP 13433 844 12 MS MS NNP 13433 844 13 . . . 13433 844 14 edited edit VBN 13433 844 15 by by IN 13433 844 16 Valentinus Valentinus NNP 13433 844 17 Pacaeus Pacaeus NNP 13433 844 18 in in IN 13433 844 19 1557 1557 CD 13433 844 20 , , , 13433 844 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 844 22 84:4 84:4 CD 13433 844 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 844 24 and and CC 13433 844 25 the the DT 13433 844 26 order order NN 13433 844 27 at at IN 13433 844 28 the the DT 13433 844 29 same same JJ 13433 844 30 time time NN 13433 844 31 represents represent VBZ 13433 844 32 that that DT 13433 844 33 of of IN 13433 844 34 the the DT 13433 844 35 Cod cod NN 13433 844 36 . . . 13433 845 1 Pal Pal NNP 13433 845 2 . . . 13433 846 1 150 150 CD 13433 846 2 . . . 13433 847 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 847 2 84:5 84:5 CD 13433 847 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 847 4 The the DT 13433 847 5 third third JJ 13433 847 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 847 7 C c NN 13433 847 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 847 9 is be VBZ 13433 847 10 the the DT 13433 847 11 ancient ancient JJ 13433 847 12 Latin latin JJ 13433 847 13 translation translation NN 13433 847 14 , , , 13433 847 15 referred refer VBD 13433 847 16 to to IN 13433 847 17 above above RB 13433 847 18 , , , 13433 847 19 published publish VBN 13433 847 20 by by IN 13433 847 21 Archbishop Archbishop NNP 13433 847 22 Usher Usher NNP 13433 847 23 . . . 13433 848 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 848 2 84:6 84:6 CD 13433 848 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 848 4 The the DT 13433 848 5 fourth fourth JJ 13433 848 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 848 7 D d NN 13433 848 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 848 9 is be VBZ 13433 848 10 the the DT 13433 848 11 celebrated celebrated JJ 13433 848 12 Medicean Medicean NNP 13433 848 13 MS MS NNP 13433 848 14 . . NNP 13433 848 15 assigned assign VBN 13433 848 16 to to IN 13433 848 17 the the DT 13433 848 18 eleventh eleventh JJ 13433 848 19 century century NN 13433 848 20 , , , 13433 848 21 and and CC 13433 848 22 published publish VBN 13433 848 23 by by IN 13433 848 24 Vossius Vossius NNP 13433 848 25 in in IN 13433 848 26 1646 1646 CD 13433 848 27 . . . 13433 849 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 849 2 84:7 84:7 CD 13433 849 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 849 4 This this DT 13433 849 5 also also RB 13433 849 6 represents represent VBZ 13433 849 7 the the DT 13433 849 8 order order NN 13433 849 9 of of IN 13433 849 10 the the DT 13433 849 11 Cod cod NN 13433 849 12 . . . 13433 850 1 Casanatensis Casanatensis NNP 13433 850 2 G.V. G.V. NNP 13433 851 1 14 14 CD 13433 851 2 . . . 13433 852 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 852 2 84:8 84:8 CD 13433 852 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 852 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 852 5 italicise italicise VBP 13433 852 6 the the DT 13433 852 7 rejected reject VBN 13433 852 8 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 852 9 : : : 13433 852 10 A. a. NN 13433 853 1 | | NNP 13433 853 2 B. B. NNP 13433 854 1 | | NNP 13433 854 2 C. C. NNP 13433 854 3 | | NNP 13433 854 4 D. D. NNP 13433 854 5 | | NNP 13433 854 6 FABER FABER NNP 13433 854 7 STAP STAP NNP 13433 854 8 . . . 13433 855 1 | | JJ 13433 855 2 VAL VAL NNP 13433 855 3 . . . 13433 856 1 PACAEUS PACAEUS NNP 13433 856 2 . . . 13433 857 1 | | NNP 13433 857 2 USHER usher JJ 13433 857 3 | | NN 13433 857 4 VOSSIUS vossiu NNS 13433 857 5 . . . 13433 858 1 | | NNP 13433 858 2 | | NNP 13433 858 3 | | CD 13433 858 4 | | CD 13433 858 5 | | CD 13433 858 6 1 1 CD 13433 858 7 . . . 13433 859 1 Trallians Trallians NNPS 13433 859 2 | | NNP 13433 859 3 _ _ NNP 13433 859 4 Mar. March NNP 13433 860 1 Cass Cass NNP 13433 860 2 . . . 13433 860 3 _ _ NNP 13433 860 4 | | NNP 13433 860 5 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 13433 860 6 . . . 13433 861 1 | | NNP 13433 861 2 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 13433 861 3 . . . 13433 862 1 | | NNP 13433 862 2 2 2 CD 13433 862 3 . . . 13433 863 1 Magn magn NN 13433 863 2 . . . 13433 864 1 | | NNP 13433 864 2 Trallians Trallians NNP 13433 864 3 | | NNP 13433 864 4 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 864 5 | | NNP 13433 864 6 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 864 7 | | NNP 13433 864 8 3 3 CD 13433 864 9 . . . 13433 865 1 _ _ NNP 13433 865 2 Tarsians Tarsians NNP 13433 865 3 _ _ NNP 13433 865 4 | | NNP 13433 865 5 Magnes Magnes NNP 13433 865 6 . . . 13433 866 1 | | NNP 13433 866 2 Ephes ephe NNS 13433 866 3 . . . 13433 867 1 | | NNP 13433 867 2 Ephes ephe NNS 13433 867 3 . . . 13433 868 1 | | NNP 13433 868 2 4 4 CD 13433 868 3 . . . 13433 869 1 _ _ NNP 13433 869 2 Philip Philip NNP 13433 869 3 . . . 13433 869 4 _ _ NNP 13433 869 5 | | NNP 13433 869 6 _ _ NNP 13433 869 7 Tarsians Tarsians NNP 13433 869 8 _ _ NNP 13433 869 9 | | NNP 13433 869 10 Magnes Magnes NNP 13433 869 11 . . . 13433 870 1 | | NNP 13433 870 2 Magnes Magnes NNP 13433 870 3 . . . 13433 871 1 | | NNP 13433 871 2 5 5 CD 13433 871 3 . . . 13433 872 1 Philad Philad NNP 13433 872 2 . . . 13433 873 1 | | NNP 13433 873 2 _ _ NNP 13433 873 3 Philip Philip NNP 13433 873 4 . . . 13433 874 1 | | NNP 13433 874 2 Philad Philad NNP 13433 874 3 . . . 13433 875 1 | | NNP 13433 875 2 Philad Philad NNP 13433 875 3 . . . 13433 876 1 | | NNP 13433 876 2 6 6 CD 13433 876 3 . . . 13433 877 1 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 13433 877 2 . . . 13433 878 1 | | NNP 13433 878 2 Philad Philad NNP 13433 878 3 . . . 13433 879 1 | | NNP 13433 879 2 Trallians Trallians NNP 13433 879 3 | | NNP 13433 879 4 Trallians Trallians NNP 13433 879 5 | | NNP 13433 879 6 7 7 CD 13433 879 7 . . . 13433 880 1 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 880 2 | | NNP 13433 880 3 Smyrn Smyrn NNP 13433 880 4 . . . 13433 881 1 | | NNP 13433 881 2 _ _ NNP 13433 881 3 Mar. March NNP 13433 882 1 ad ad NN 13433 882 2 . . . 13433 883 1 Ign Ign NNP 13433 883 2 . . . 13433 883 3 _ _ NNP 13433 883 4 | | NNP 13433 883 5 _ _ NNP 13433 883 6 Mar. March NNP 13433 884 1 ad ad NN 13433 884 2 . . . 13433 885 1 Ign Ign NNP 13433 885 2 . . . 13433 885 3 _ _ NNP 13433 885 4 | | NNP 13433 885 5 8 8 CD 13433 885 6 . . . 13433 886 1 _ _ NNP 13433 886 2 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 886 3 . . . 13433 886 4 _ _ NNP 13433 886 5 | | NNP 13433 886 6 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 886 7 | | NNP 13433 886 8 _ _ NNP 13433 886 9 Ign Ign NNP 13433 886 10 . . . 13433 887 1 ad ad NN 13433 887 2 . . . 13433 888 1 Mar. March NNP 13433 888 2 _ _ NNP 13433 888 3 | | NNP 13433 888 4 _ _ NNP 13433 888 5 Ign Ign NNP 13433 888 6 . . . 13433 889 1 ad ad NN 13433 889 2 . . . 13433 890 1 Mar. March NNP 13433 890 2 _ _ NNP 13433 890 3 | | NNP 13433 890 4 9 9 CD 13433 890 5 . . . 13433 891 1 _ _ NNP 13433 891 2 Hero Hero NNP 13433 891 3 _ _ NNP 13433 891 4 | | NNP 13433 891 5 _ _ NNP 13433 891 6 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 891 7 . . . 13433 892 1 | | NNP 13433 892 2 _ _ NNP 13433 892 3 Tarsians Tarsians NNP 13433 892 4 _ _ NNP 13433 892 5 | | NNP 13433 892 6 _ _ NNP 13433 892 7 Tarsians Tarsians NNP 13433 892 8 _ _ NNP 13433 892 9 | | NNP 13433 892 10 10 10 CD 13433 892 11 . . . 13433 893 1 Ephes ephe NNS 13433 893 2 . . . 13433 894 1 | | NNP 13433 894 2 _ _ NNP 13433 894 3 Hero Hero NNP 13433 894 4 _ _ NNP 13433 894 5 | | NNP 13433 894 6 _ _ NNP 13433 894 7 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 894 8 . . . 13433 894 9 _ _ NNP 13433 894 10 | | NNP 13433 894 11 | | CD 13433 894 12 11 11 CD 13433 894 13 . . . 13433 895 1 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 895 2 | | NNP 13433 895 3 Ephes ephe NNS 13433 895 4 . . . 13433 896 1 | | NNP 13433 896 2 _ _ NNP 13433 896 3 Hero Hero NNP 13433 896 4 _ _ NNP 13433 896 5 | | NNP 13433 896 6 | | NNP 13433 896 7 12 12 CD 13433 896 8 . . . 13433 897 1 | | NNP 13433 897 2 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 897 3 | | NNP 13433 897 4 _ _ NNP 13433 897 5 Mart Mart NNP 13433 897 6 . . . 13433 898 1 Ign Ign NNP 13433 898 2 . . . 13433 898 3 _ _ NNP 13433 898 4 | | NNP 13433 898 5 | | NNP 13433 898 6 13 13 CD 13433 898 7 . . . 13433 899 1 | | NNP 13433 899 2 | | NNP 13433 899 3 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 899 4 | | NNP 13433 899 5 | | NNS 13433 899 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 899 7 have have VBP 13433 899 8 given give VBN 13433 899 9 the the DT 13433 899 10 order order NN 13433 899 11 in in IN 13433 899 12 MSS MSS NNP 13433 899 13 . . . 13433 900 1 containing contain VBG 13433 900 2 the the DT 13433 900 3 " " `` 13433 900 4 Long long JJ 13433 900 5 Recension Recension NNP 13433 900 6 " " '' 13433 900 7 as as RB 13433 900 8 well well RB 13433 900 9 as as IN 13433 900 10 the the DT 13433 900 11 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 900 12 , , , 13433 900 13 because because IN 13433 900 14 , , , 13433 900 15 however however RB 13433 900 16 much much RB 13433 900 17 some some DT 13433 900 18 may may MD 13433 900 19 desire desire VB 13433 900 20 to to TO 13433 900 21 exclude exclude VB 13433 900 22 them -PRON- PRP 13433 900 23 , , , 13433 900 24 the the DT 13433 900 25 variety variety NN 13433 900 26 of of IN 13433 900 27 arrangement arrangement NN 13433 900 28 is be VBZ 13433 900 29 notable notable JJ 13433 900 30 , , , 13433 900 31 and and CC 13433 900 32 presents present NNS 13433 900 33 features feature NNS 13433 900 34 which which WDT 13433 900 35 have have VBP 13433 900 36 an an DT 13433 900 37 undeniable undeniable JJ 13433 900 38 bearing bearing NN 13433 900 39 upon upon IN 13433 900 40 this this DT 13433 900 41 question question NN 13433 900 42 . . . 13433 901 1 Taking take VBG 13433 901 2 the the DT 13433 901 3 Vossian vossian JJ 13433 901 4 MS MS NNP 13433 901 5 . . NNP 13433 901 6 , , , 13433 901 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 901 8 is be VBZ 13433 901 9 obvious obvious JJ 13433 901 10 that that IN 13433 901 11 , , , 13433 901 12 without without IN 13433 901 13 any any DT 13433 901 14 distinction distinction NN 13433 901 15 whatever whatever WDT 13433 901 16 between between IN 13433 901 17 the the DT 13433 901 18 genuine genuine NN 13433 901 19 and and CC 13433 901 20 the the DT 13433 901 21 spurious spurious JJ 13433 901 22 , , , 13433 901 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 901 24 contains contain VBZ 13433 901 25 three three CD 13433 901 26 of of IN 13433 901 27 the the DT 13433 901 28 false false JJ 13433 901 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 901 30 , , , 13433 901 31 and and CC 13433 901 32 _ _ NNP 13433 901 33 does do VBZ 13433 901 34 not not RB 13433 901 35 contain contain VB 13433 901 36 the the DT 13433 901 37 so so RB 13433 901 38 - - HYPH 13433 901 39 called call VBN 13433 901 40 genuine genuine JJ 13433 901 41 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 901 42 to to IN 13433 901 43 the the DT 13433 901 44 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 901 45 at at RB 13433 901 46 all all RB 13433 901 47 _ _ NNP 13433 901 48 . . . 13433 902 1 The the DT 13433 902 2 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 902 3 to to IN 13433 902 4 the the DT 13433 902 5 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 902 6 , , , 13433 902 7 in in IN 13433 902 8 fact fact NN 13433 902 9 , , , 13433 902 10 is be VBZ 13433 902 11 , , , 13433 902 12 to to TO 13433 902 13 use use VB 13433 902 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 902 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 902 16 's 's POS 13433 902 17 own own JJ 13433 902 18 expression expression NN 13433 902 19 , , , 13433 902 20 " " '' 13433 902 21 embedded embed VBN 13433 902 22 in in IN 13433 902 23 the the DT 13433 902 24 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 13433 902 25 , , , 13433 902 26 " " '' 13433 902 27 which which WDT 13433 902 28 is be VBZ 13433 902 29 as as RB 13433 902 30 spurious spurious JJ 13433 902 31 as as IN 13433 902 32 any any DT 13433 902 33 of of IN 13433 902 34 the the DT 13433 902 35 epistles epistle NNS 13433 902 36 . . . 13433 903 1 This this DT 13433 903 2 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 903 3 alone alone RB 13433 903 4 would would MD 13433 903 5 justify justify VB 13433 903 6 the the DT 13433 903 7 assertion assertion NN 13433 903 8 which which WDT 13433 903 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 903 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 903 11 contradicts contradict VBZ 13433 903 12 . . . 13433 904 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 904 2 must must MD 13433 904 3 now now RB 13433 904 4 , , , 13433 904 5 in in IN 13433 904 6 order order NN 13433 904 7 finally finally RB 13433 904 8 to to TO 13433 904 9 dispose dispose VB 13433 904 10 of of IN 13433 904 11 this this DT 13433 904 12 matter matter NN 13433 904 13 of of IN 13433 904 14 notes note NNS 13433 904 15 , , , 13433 904 16 turn turn VBP 13433 904 17 for for IN 13433 904 18 a a DT 13433 904 19 short short JJ 13433 904 20 time time NN 13433 904 21 to to TO 13433 904 22 consider consider VB 13433 904 23 objections objection NNS 13433 904 24 raised raise VBN 13433 904 25 by by IN 13433 904 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 904 27 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 904 28 . . . 13433 905 1 Whilst whilst IN 13433 905 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 905 3 have have VBP 13433 905 4 to to TO 13433 905 5 thank thank VB 13433 905 6 him -PRON- PRP 13433 905 7 for for IN 13433 905 8 greater great JJR 13433 905 9 courtesy courtesy NN 13433 905 10 , , , 13433 905 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 905 12 regret regret VBP 13433 905 13 that that IN 13433 905 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 905 15 must must MD 13433 905 16 point point VB 13433 905 17 out out RP 13433 905 18 serious serious JJ 13433 905 19 errors error NNS 13433 905 20 into into IN 13433 905 21 which which WDT 13433 905 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 905 23 has have VBZ 13433 905 24 fallen fall VBN 13433 905 25 in in IN 13433 905 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 905 27 statements statement NNS 13433 905 28 regarding regard VBG 13433 905 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 905 30 references reference NNS 13433 905 31 , , , 13433 905 32 which which WDT 13433 905 33 , , , 13433 905 34 as as IN 13433 905 35 matters matter NNS 13433 905 36 of of IN 13433 905 37 fact fact NN 13433 905 38 , , , 13433 905 39 admit admit VBP 13433 905 40 of of IN 13433 905 41 practical practical JJ 13433 905 42 test test NN 13433 905 43 . . . 13433 906 1 Before before IN 13433 906 2 proceeding proceed VBG 13433 906 3 to to IN 13433 906 4 them -PRON- PRP 13433 906 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 906 6 may may MD 13433 906 7 make make VB 13433 906 8 one one CD 13433 906 9 or or CC 13433 906 10 two two CD 13433 906 11 general general JJ 13433 906 12 observations observation NNS 13433 906 13 . . . 13433 907 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 907 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 907 3 says:-- says:-- : 13433 907 4 " " `` 13433 907 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 907 6 may may MD 13433 907 7 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 907 8 express express VB 13433 907 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 907 10 surprise surprise NN 13433 907 11 that that IN 13433 907 12 a a DT 13433 907 13 writer writer NN 13433 907 14 who who WP 13433 907 15 is be VBZ 13433 907 16 quite quite RB 13433 907 17 capable capable JJ 13433 907 18 of of IN 13433 907 19 thinking think VBG 13433 907 20 for for IN 13433 907 21 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 907 22 should should MD 13433 907 23 have have VB 13433 907 24 considered consider VBN 13433 907 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 907 26 worth worth JJ 13433 907 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 907 28 while while NN 13433 907 29 to to TO 13433 907 30 burden burden VB 13433 907 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 907 32 pages page NNS 13433 907 33 with with IN 13433 907 34 lists list NNS 13433 907 35 of of IN 13433 907 36 names name NNS 13433 907 37 and and CC 13433 907 38 writings writing NNS 13433 907 39 , , , 13433 907 40 arranged arrange VBD 13433 907 41 , , , 13433 907 42 for for IN 13433 907 43 the the DT 13433 907 44 most most JJS 13433 907 45 part part NN 13433 907 46 , , , 13433 907 47 alphabetically alphabetically RB 13433 907 48 , , , 13433 907 49 which which WDT 13433 907 50 have have VBP 13433 907 51 in in IN 13433 907 52 very very RB 13433 907 53 many many JJ 13433 907 54 cases case NNS 13433 907 55 no no DT 13433 907 56 value value NN 13433 907 57 whatever whatever WDT 13433 907 58 for for IN 13433 907 59 a a DT 13433 907 60 scholar scholar NN 13433 907 61 , , , 13433 907 62 while while IN 13433 907 63 they -PRON- PRP 13433 907 64 can can MD 13433 907 65 only only RB 13433 907 66 oppress oppress VB 13433 907 67 the the DT 13433 907 68 general general JJ 13433 907 69 reader reader NN 13433 907 70 with with IN 13433 907 71 a a DT 13433 907 72 vague vague JJ 13433 907 73 feeling feeling NN 13433 907 74 that that IN 13433 907 75 all all DT 13433 907 76 ' ' `` 13433 907 77 profound profound JJ 13433 907 78 ' ' '' 13433 907 79 critics critic NNS 13433 907 80 are be VBP 13433 907 81 on on IN 13433 907 82 one one CD 13433 907 83 side side NN 13433 907 84 . . . 13433 908 1 The the DT 13433 908 2 questions question NNS 13433 908 3 to to TO 13433 908 4 be be VB 13433 908 5 discussed discuss VBN 13433 908 6 must must MD 13433 908 7 be be VB 13433 908 8 decided decide VBN 13433 908 9 by by IN 13433 908 10 evidence evidence NN 13433 908 11 and and CC 13433 908 12 by by IN 13433 908 13 argument argument NN 13433 908 14 and and CC 13433 908 15 not not RB 13433 908 16 by by IN 13433 908 17 authority authority NN 13433 908 18 . . . 13433 908 19 " " '' 13433 909 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 909 2 86:1 86:1 CD 13433 909 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 909 4 Now now RB 13433 909 5 the the DT 13433 909 6 fact fact NN 13433 909 7 is be VBZ 13433 909 8 that that DT 13433 909 9 hitherto hitherto NNP 13433 909 10 , , , 13433 909 11 in in IN 13433 909 12 England England NNP 13433 909 13 , , , 13433 909 14 argument argument NN 13433 909 15 and and CC 13433 909 16 evidence evidence NN 13433 909 17 have have VBP 13433 909 18 almost almost RB 13433 909 19 been be VBN 13433 909 20 ignored ignore VBN 13433 909 21 in in IN 13433 909 22 connection connection NN 13433 909 23 with with IN 13433 909 24 the the DT 13433 909 25 great great JJ 13433 909 26 question question NN 13433 909 27 discussed discuss VBN 13433 909 28 in in IN 13433 909 29 this this DT 13433 909 30 work work NN 13433 909 31 , , , 13433 909 32 and and CC 13433 909 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 909 34 has have VBZ 13433 909 35 practically practically RB 13433 909 36 been be VBN 13433 909 37 decided decide VBN 13433 909 38 by by IN 13433 909 39 the the DT 13433 909 40 authority authority NN 13433 909 41 of of IN 13433 909 42 the the DT 13433 909 43 Church Church NNP 13433 909 44 , , , 13433 909 45 rendered render VBN 13433 909 46 doubly doubly RB 13433 909 47 potent potent JJ 13433 909 48 by by IN 13433 909 49 force force NN 13433 909 50 of of IN 13433 909 51 habit habit NN 13433 909 52 and and CC 13433 909 53 transmitted transmit VBN 13433 909 54 reverence reverence NN 13433 909 55 . . . 13433 910 1 The the DT 13433 910 2 orthodox orthodox JJ 13433 910 3 works work VBZ 13433 910 4 usually usually RB 13433 910 5 written write VBN 13433 910 6 on on IN 13433 910 7 the the DT 13433 910 8 subject subject NN 13433 910 9 have have VBP 13433 910 10 , , , 13433 910 11 to to IN 13433 910 12 a a DT 13433 910 13 very very RB 13433 910 14 great great JJ 13433 910 15 extent extent NN 13433 910 16 , , , 13433 910 17 suppressed suppress VBD 13433 910 18 the the DT 13433 910 19 objections objection NNS 13433 910 20 raised raise VBN 13433 910 21 by by IN 13433 910 22 a a DT 13433 910 23 mass mass NN 13433 910 24 of of IN 13433 910 25 learned learned JJ 13433 910 26 and and CC 13433 910 27 independent independent JJ 13433 910 28 critics critic NNS 13433 910 29 , , , 13433 910 30 or or CC 13433 910 31 treated treat VBD 13433 910 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 910 33 as as IN 13433 910 34 insignificant insignificant JJ 13433 910 35 , , , 13433 910 36 and and CC 13433 910 37 worthy worthy JJ 13433 910 38 of of IN 13433 910 39 little little JJ 13433 910 40 more more JJR 13433 910 41 than than IN 13433 910 42 a a DT 13433 910 43 passing pass VBG 13433 910 44 word word NN 13433 910 45 of of IN 13433 910 46 pious pious JJ 13433 910 47 indignation indignation NN 13433 910 48 . . . 13433 911 1 At at IN 13433 911 2 the the DT 13433 911 3 same same JJ 13433 911 4 time time NN 13433 911 5 , , , 13433 911 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 911 7 , , , 13433 911 8 that that IN 13433 911 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 911 10 endeavour endeavour VBP 13433 911 11 , , , 13433 911 12 to to IN 13433 911 13 the the DT 13433 911 14 best good JJS 13433 911 15 of of IN 13433 911 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 911 17 ability ability NN 13433 911 18 , , , 13433 911 19 to to TO 13433 911 20 decide decide VB 13433 911 21 these these DT 13433 911 22 questions question NNS 13433 911 23 by by IN 13433 911 24 evidence evidence NN 13433 911 25 and and CC 13433 911 26 argument argument NN 13433 911 27 , , , 13433 911 28 in in IN 13433 911 29 opposition opposition NN 13433 911 30 to to IN 13433 911 31 mere mere JJ 13433 911 32 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 911 33 authority authority NN 13433 911 34 , , , 13433 911 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 911 36 refer refer VBP 13433 911 37 readers reader NNS 13433 911 38 desirous desirous JJ 13433 911 39 of of IN 13433 911 40 further further RB 13433 911 41 pursuing pursue VBG 13433 911 42 the the DT 13433 911 43 subject subject NN 13433 911 44 to to IN 13433 911 45 works work NNS 13433 911 46 where where WRB 13433 911 47 they -PRON- PRP 13433 911 48 may may MD 13433 911 49 find find VB 13433 911 50 them -PRON- PRP 13433 911 51 discussed discuss VBN 13433 911 52 . . . 13433 912 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 912 2 must must MD 13433 912 3 be be VB 13433 912 4 permitted permit VBN 13433 912 5 to to TO 13433 912 6 add add VB 13433 912 7 , , , 13433 912 8 that that IN 13433 912 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 912 10 do do VBP 13433 912 11 not not RB 13433 912 12 consider consider VB 13433 912 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 912 14 uselessly uselessly RB 13433 912 15 burden burden VBP 13433 912 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 912 17 pages page NNS 13433 912 18 by by IN 13433 912 19 references reference NNS 13433 912 20 to to IN 13433 912 21 critics critic NNS 13433 912 22 who who WP 13433 912 23 confirm confirm VBP 13433 912 24 the the DT 13433 912 25 views view NNS 13433 912 26 in in IN 13433 912 27 the the DT 13433 912 28 text text NN 13433 912 29 or or CC 13433 912 30 discuss discuss VB 13433 912 31 them -PRON- PRP 13433 912 32 , , , 13433 912 33 for for IN 13433 912 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 912 35 is be VBZ 13433 912 36 right right JJ 13433 912 37 that that IN 13433 912 38 earnest earnest JJ 13433 912 39 thinkers thinker NNS 13433 912 40 should should MD 13433 912 41 be be VB 13433 912 42 told tell VBN 13433 912 43 the the DT 13433 912 44 state state NN 13433 912 45 of of IN 13433 912 46 opinion opinion NN 13433 912 47 , , , 13433 912 48 and and CC 13433 912 49 recognise recognise VB 13433 912 50 that that DT 13433 912 51 belief belief NN 13433 912 52 is be VBZ 13433 912 53 not not RB 13433 912 54 so so RB 13433 912 55 easy easy JJ 13433 912 56 and and CC 13433 912 57 matter matter JJ 13433 912 58 - - HYPH 13433 912 59 of of IN 13433 912 60 - - HYPH 13433 912 61 course course NN 13433 912 62 a a DT 13433 912 63 thing thing NN 13433 912 64 as as IN 13433 912 65 they -PRON- PRP 13433 912 66 have have VBP 13433 912 67 been be VBN 13433 912 68 led lead VBN 13433 912 69 to to TO 13433 912 70 suppose suppose VB 13433 912 71 , , , 13433 912 72 or or CC 13433 912 73 the the DT 13433 912 74 unanimity unanimity NN 13433 912 75 quite quite RB 13433 912 76 so so RB 13433 912 77 complete complete JJ 13433 912 78 as as IN 13433 912 79 English english JJ 13433 912 80 divines divine NNS 13433 912 81 have have VBP 13433 912 82 often often RB 13433 912 83 seemed seem VBN 13433 912 84 to to TO 13433 912 85 represent represent VB 13433 912 86 it -PRON- PRP 13433 912 87 . . . 13433 913 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 913 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 913 3 , , , 13433 913 4 however however RB 13433 913 5 , , , 13433 913 6 omits omit VBZ 13433 913 7 to to IN 13433 913 8 state state NN 13433 913 9 that that IN 13433 913 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 913 11 as as IN 13433 913 12 persistently persistently RB 13433 913 13 refer refer VBP 13433 913 14 to to IN 13433 913 15 writers writer NNS 13433 913 16 who who WP 13433 913 17 oppose oppose VBP 13433 913 18 , , , 13433 913 19 as as IN 13433 913 20 to to IN 13433 913 21 those those DT 13433 913 22 who who WP 13433 913 23 favour favour VBP 13433 913 24 , , , 13433 913 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 913 26 own own JJ 13433 913 27 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 913 28 . . . 13433 914 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 914 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 914 3 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 914 4 to to TO 13433 914 5 make make VB 13433 914 6 the the DT 13433 914 7 accusation accusation NN 13433 914 8 which which WDT 13433 914 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 914 10 now now RB 13433 914 11 desire desire VBP 13433 914 12 to to TO 13433 914 13 investigate investigate VB 13433 914 14 . . . 13433 915 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 915 2 says say VBZ 13433 915 3 : : : 13433 915 4 " " `` 13433 915 5 Writers writer NNS 13433 915 6 are be VBP 13433 915 7 quoted quote VBN 13433 915 8 as as IN 13433 915 9 holding hold VBG 13433 915 10 on on IN 13433 915 11 independent independent JJ 13433 915 12 grounds ground NNS 13433 915 13 an an DT 13433 915 14 opinion opinion NN 13433 915 15 which which WDT 13433 915 16 is be VBZ 13433 915 17 involved involve VBN 13433 915 18 in in IN 13433 915 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 915 20 characteristic characteristic JJ 13433 915 21 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 915 22 . . . 13433 916 1 And and CC 13433 916 2 more more JJR 13433 916 3 than than IN 13433 916 4 this this DT 13433 916 5 , , , 13433 916 6 the the DT 13433 916 7 references reference NNS 13433 916 8 are be VBP 13433 916 9 not not RB 13433 916 10 unfrequently unfrequently RB 13433 916 11 actually actually RB 13433 916 12 misleading misleading JJ 13433 916 13 . . . 13433 917 1 One one CD 13433 917 2 example example NN 13433 917 3 will will MD 13433 917 4 show show VB 13433 917 5 that that IN 13433 917 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 917 7 do do VBP 13433 917 8 not not RB 13433 917 9 speak speak VB 13433 917 10 too too RB 13433 917 11 strongly strongly RB 13433 917 12 . . . 13433 917 13 " " '' 13433 918 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 918 2 87:1 87:1 CD 13433 918 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 918 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 918 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 918 6 has have VBZ 13433 918 7 scrutinised scrutinise VBN 13433 918 8 this this DT 13433 918 9 work work NN 13433 918 10 with with IN 13433 918 11 great great JJ 13433 918 12 minuteness minuteness NN 13433 918 13 , , , 13433 918 14 and and CC 13433 918 15 , , , 13433 918 16 as as IN 13433 918 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 918 18 shall shall MD 13433 918 19 presently presently RB 13433 918 20 explain explain VB 13433 918 21 , , , 13433 918 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 918 23 has have VBZ 13433 918 24 selected select VBN 13433 918 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 918 26 example example NN 13433 918 27 with with IN 13433 918 28 evident evident JJ 13433 918 29 care care NN 13433 918 30 . . . 13433 919 1 The the DT 13433 919 2 idea idea NN 13433 919 3 of of IN 13433 919 4 illustrating illustrate VBG 13433 919 5 the the DT 13433 919 6 vast vast JJ 13433 919 7 mass mass NN 13433 919 8 of of IN 13433 919 9 references reference NNS 13433 919 10 in in IN 13433 919 11 these these DT 13433 919 12 volumes volume NNS 13433 919 13 by by IN 13433 919 14 a a DT 13433 919 15 single single JJ 13433 919 16 instance instance NN 13433 919 17 is be VBZ 13433 919 18 somewhat somewhat RB 13433 919 19 startling startling JJ 13433 919 20 but but CC 13433 919 21 to to TO 13433 919 22 insinuate insinuate VB 13433 919 23 that that IN 13433 919 24 a a DT 13433 919 25 supposed suppose VBN 13433 919 26 contradiction contradiction NN 13433 919 27 pointed point VBD 13433 919 28 out out RP 13433 919 29 in in IN 13433 919 30 one one CD 13433 919 31 note note NN 13433 919 32 runs run VBZ 13433 919 33 through through IN 13433 919 34 the the DT 13433 919 35 whole whole JJ 13433 919 36 work work NN 13433 919 37 , , , 13433 919 38 as as IN 13433 919 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 919 40 does do VBZ 13433 919 41 , , , 13433 919 42 if if IN 13433 919 43 I -PRON- PRP 13433 919 44 rightly rightly RB 13433 919 45 understand understand VBP 13433 919 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 919 47 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 919 48 expressions expression NNS 13433 919 49 , , , 13433 919 50 is be VBZ 13433 919 51 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 919 52 worthy worthy JJ 13433 919 53 of of IN 13433 919 54 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 919 55 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 919 56 , , , 13433 919 57 although although IN 13433 919 58 I -PRON- PRP 13433 919 59 am be VBP 13433 919 60 sure sure JJ 13433 919 61 he -PRON- PRP 13433 919 62 does do VBZ 13433 919 63 not not RB 13433 919 64 mean mean VB 13433 919 65 to to TO 13433 919 66 be be VB 13433 919 67 unfair unfair JJ 13433 919 68 . . . 13433 920 1 The the DT 13433 920 2 example example NN 13433 920 3 selected select VBN 13433 920 4 is be VBZ 13433 920 5 as as IN 13433 920 6 follows follow VBZ 13433 920 7 : : : 13433 920 8 " " `` 13433 920 9 ' ' `` 13433 920 10 It -PRON- PRP 13433 920 11 has have VBZ 13433 920 12 been be VBN 13433 920 13 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 13433 920 14 that that IN 13433 920 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 920 16 was be VBD 13433 920 17 not not RB 13433 920 18 sent send VBN 13433 920 19 to to IN 13433 920 20 Rome Rome NNP 13433 920 21 at at RB 13433 920 22 all all RB 13433 920 23 , , , 13433 920 24 but but CC 13433 920 25 suffered suffer VBN 13433 920 26 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 920 27 in in IN 13433 920 28 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 920 29 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 920 30 on on IN 13433 920 31 the the DT 13433 920 32 20th 20th JJ 13433 920 33 December December NNP 13433 920 34 , , , 13433 920 35 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 920 36 115,(3 115,(3 NN 13433 920 37 ) ) -RRB- 13433 920 38 when when WRB 13433 920 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 920 40 was be VBD 13433 920 41 condemned condemn VBN 13433 920 42 to to TO 13433 920 43 be be VB 13433 920 44 cast cast VBN 13433 920 45 to to IN 13433 920 46 wild wild JJ 13433 920 47 beasts beast NNS 13433 920 48 in in IN 13433 920 49 the the DT 13433 920 50 amphitheatre amphitheatre NNP 13433 920 51 , , , 13433 920 52 in in IN 13433 920 53 consequence consequence NN 13433 920 54 of of IN 13433 920 55 the the DT 13433 920 56 fanatical fanatical JJ 13433 920 57 excitement excitement NN 13433 920 58 produced produce VBN 13433 920 59 by by IN 13433 920 60 the the DT 13433 920 61 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 920 62 which which WDT 13433 920 63 took take VBD 13433 920 64 place place NN 13433 920 65 on on IN 13433 920 66 the the DT 13433 920 67 13th 13th NN 13433 920 68 of of IN 13433 920 69 that that DT 13433 920 70 month month NN 13433 920 71 . . . 13433 921 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 921 2 4 4 LS 13433 921 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 921 4 " " '' 13433 921 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 921 6 87:2 87:2 CD 13433 921 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 921 8 " " `` 13433 921 9 ' ' `` 13433 921 10 The the DT 13433 921 11 references reference NNS 13433 921 12 in in IN 13433 921 13 support support NN 13433 921 14 of of IN 13433 921 15 these these DT 13433 921 16 statements statement NNS 13433 921 17 are be VBP 13433 921 18 the the DT 13433 921 19 following:-- following:-- : 13433 921 20 " " '' 13433 921 21 ' ' '' 13433 921 22 ( ( -LRB- 13433 921 23 3 3 LS 13433 921 24 ) ) -RRB- 13433 921 25 Baur Baur NNP 13433 921 26 , , , 13433 921 27 _ _ NNP 13433 921 28 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 921 29 . . . 13433 922 1 d. d. NNP 13433 923 1 Episc Episc NNP 13433 923 2 . . . 13433 923 3 , , , 13433 923 4 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 923 5 . . . 13433 924 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 924 2 . . . 13433 925 1 f. f. NNP 13433 925 2 Theol Theol NNP 13433 925 3 . . . 13433 925 4 _ _ NNP 13433 925 5 1838 1838 CD 13433 925 6 , , , 13433 925 7 H.3 H.3 NNP 13433 925 8 , , , 13433 925 9 p. p. NN 13433 925 10 155 155 CD 13433 925 11 , , , 13433 925 12 Anm anm CC 13433 925 13 . . . 13433 926 1 ; ; : 13433 926 2 Bretschneider Bretschneider NNP 13433 926 3 , , , 13433 926 4 _ _ NNP 13433 926 5 Probabilia Probabilia NNP 13433 926 6 _ _ NNP 13433 926 7 , , , 13433 926 8 & & CC 13433 926 9 c. c. NNP 13433 926 10 p. p. NNP 13433 926 11 185 185 CD 13433 926 12 ; ; : 13433 926 13 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 926 14 , , , 13433 926 15 _ _ NNP 13433 926 16 Einl Einl NNP 13433 926 17 . . . 13433 927 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 927 2 _ _ NNP 13433 927 3 p. p. NN 13433 927 4 144 144 CD 13433 927 5 ; ; : 13433 927 6 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 927 7 , , , 13433 927 8 _ _ NNP 13433 927 9 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 927 10 , , , 13433 927 11 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 927 12 _ _ NNP 13433 927 13 i. i. NNP 13433 927 14 p. p. NN 13433 927 15 148 148 CD 13433 927 16 ; ; : 13433 927 17 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 927 18 , , , 13433 927 19 _ _ NNP 13433 927 20 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 927 21 _ _ NNP 13433 927 22 i. i. NNP 13433 927 23 p. p. NN 13433 927 24 113 113 CD 13433 927 25 f. f. NNP 13433 927 26 ; ; : 13433 927 27 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 927 28 , , , 13433 927 29 _ _ NNP 13433 927 30 Introd Introd NNP 13433 927 31 . . . 13433 928 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 928 2 _ _ NNP 13433 928 3 i. i. NNP 13433 928 4 p. p. NN 13433 928 5 19 19 CD 13433 928 6 ; ; : 13433 928 7 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 13433 928 8 , , , 13433 928 9 _ _ NNP 13433 928 10 Einl Einl NNP 13433 928 11 . . . 13433 929 1 petr petr NN 13433 929 2 . . . 13433 930 1 Schr Schr NNP 13433 930 2 . . . 13433 930 3 _ _ NNP 13433 930 4 p. p. NN 13433 930 5 79 79 CD 13433 930 6 ; ; : 13433 930 7 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 930 8 , , , 13433 930 9 _ _ NNP 13433 930 10 Die Die NNP 13433 930 11 ält ält NNP 13433 930 12 . . . 13433 931 1 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 931 2 _ _ NNP 13433 931 3 , , , 13433 931 4 pp pp NNP 13433 931 5 . . . 13433 932 1 40 40 CD 13433 932 2 , , , 13433 932 3 50 50 CD 13433 932 4 f. f. NNS 13433 932 5 ; ; : 13433 932 6 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 932 7 , , , 13433 932 8 _ _ NNP 13433 932 9 Der Der NNP 13433 932 10 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 932 11 _ _ NNP 13433 932 12 , , , 13433 932 13 p. p. NN 13433 932 14 52 52 CD 13433 932 15 ; ; : 13433 932 16 _ _ NNP 13433 932 17 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 932 18 Einl Einl NNP 13433 932 19 . . . 13433 933 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 13433 933 2 . . . 13433 933 3 _ _ NNP 13433 933 4 i. i. NNP 13433 933 5 pp pp NNP 13433 933 6 . . . 13433 934 1 121 121 CD 13433 934 2 f. f. NNP 13433 934 3 , , , 13433 934 4 136 136 CD 13433 934 5 . . . 13433 935 1 " " `` 13433 935 2 ' ' `` 13433 935 3 ( ( -LRB- 13433 935 4 4 4 LS 13433 935 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 935 6 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 935 7 , , , 13433 935 8 _ _ NNP 13433 935 9 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 935 10 Einl Einl NNP 13433 935 11 . . . 13433 936 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 13433 936 2 . . . 13433 936 3 _ _ NNP 13433 936 4 i. i. NNP 13433 936 5 pp pp NNP 13433 936 6 . . . 13433 937 1 121 121 CD 13433 937 2 ff ff NNP 13433 937 3 . . NNP 13433 937 4 , , , 13433 937 5 136 136 CD 13433 937 6 f. f. NNS 13433 937 7 ; ; : 13433 937 8 _ _ NNP 13433 937 9 Der Der NNP 13433 937 10 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 937 11 _ _ NNP 13433 937 12 , , , 13433 937 13 p. p. NN 13433 937 14 52 52 CD 13433 937 15 ff ff NN 13433 937 16 . . . 13433 938 1 ; ; : 13433 938 2 Baur Baur NNP 13433 938 3 , , , 13433 938 4 _ _ NNP 13433 938 5 Ursp Ursp NNP 13433 938 6 . . . 13433 939 1 d. d. NNP 13433 939 2 Episc Episc NNP 13433 939 3 . . . 13433 940 1 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 940 2 . . . 13433 941 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 941 2 . . . 13433 942 1 f. f. NNP 13433 942 2 Theol Theol NNP 13433 942 3 . . . 13433 942 4 _ _ NNP 13433 942 5 1838 1838 CD 13433 942 6 , , , 13433 942 7 H. H. NNP 13433 942 8 3 3 CD 13433 942 9 , , , 13433 942 10 p. p. NN 13433 942 11 149 149 CD 13433 942 12 f. f. NNS 13433 942 13 ; ; : 13433 942 14 _ _ NNP 13433 942 15 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 942 16 . . . 13433 943 1 chr chr NNP 13433 943 2 . . . 13433 944 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 944 2 , , , 13433 944 3 _ _ NNP 13433 944 4 1863 1863 CD 13433 944 5 , , , 13433 944 6 i. i. NNP 13433 944 7 p. p. NN 13433 944 8 440 440 CD 13433 944 9 , , , 13433 944 10 Amn Amn NNP 13433 944 11 . . . 13433 945 1 1 1 LS 13433 945 2 ; ; : 13433 945 3 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 945 4 , , , 13433 945 5 _ _ NNP 13433 945 6 Introd Introd NNP 13433 945 7 . . . 13433 946 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 946 2 _ _ NNP 13433 946 3 i i PRP 13433 946 4 , , , 13433 946 5 p. p. NN 13433 946 6 19 19 CD 13433 946 7 ; ; : 13433 946 8 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 946 9 , , , 13433 946 10 _ _ NNP 13433 946 11 Die Die NNP 13433 946 12 ält ält NNP 13433 946 13 . . . 13433 947 1 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 947 2 _ _ NNP 13433 947 3 , , , 13433 947 4 p. p. NN 13433 947 5 51 51 CD 13433 947 6 f. f. NNP 13433 947 7 ; ; : 13433 947 8 cf cf NNP 13433 947 9 . . . 13433 948 1 Francke Francke NNP 13433 948 2 , , , 13433 948 3 _ _ NNP 13433 948 4 Zur Zur NNP 13433 948 5 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 948 6 . . . 13433 949 1 Trajans trajan NNS 13433 949 2 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 949 3 . . . 13433 949 4 _ _ NNP 13433 949 5 1840 1840 CD 13433 949 6 , , , 13433 949 7 p. p. NN 13433 949 8 253 253 CD 13433 949 9 f. f. NNS 13433 949 10 ; ; : 13433 949 11 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 949 12 , , , 13433 949 13 _ _ NNP 13433 949 14 Die Die NNP 13433 949 15 ap ap NNP 13433 949 16 . . . 13433 950 1 Väter Väter NNP 13433 950 2 _ _ NNP 13433 950 3 , , , 13433 950 4 p p NNP 13433 950 5 , , , 13433 950 6 214 214 CD 13433 950 7 . . . 13433 950 8 ' ' '' 13433 950 9 " " '' 13433 951 1 Upon upon IN 13433 951 2 this this DT 13433 951 3 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 951 4 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 951 5 remarks remark VBZ 13433 951 6 : : : 13433 951 7 Such such PDT 13433 951 8 an an DT 13433 951 9 array array NN 13433 951 10 of of IN 13433 951 11 authorities authority NNS 13433 951 12 , , , 13433 951 13 drawn draw VBN 13433 951 14 from from IN 13433 951 15 different different JJ 13433 951 16 schools school NNS 13433 951 17 , , , 13433 951 18 can can MD 13433 951 19 not not RB 13433 951 20 but but CC 13433 951 21 appear appear VB 13433 951 22 overwhelming overwhelming JJ 13433 951 23 ; ; : 13433 951 24 and and CC 13433 951 25 the the DT 13433 951 26 fact fact NN 13433 951 27 that that IN 13433 951 28 about about IN 13433 951 29 half half NN 13433 951 30 of of IN 13433 951 31 them -PRON- PRP 13433 951 32 are be VBP 13433 951 33 quoted quote VBN 13433 951 34 twice twice RB 13433 951 35 over over IN 13433 951 36 emphasises emphasis NNS 13433 951 37 the the DT 13433 951 38 implied implied JJ 13433 951 39 precision precision NN 13433 951 40 of of IN 13433 951 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 951 42 testimony testimony NN 13433 951 43 as as IN 13433 951 44 to to IN 13433 951 45 the the DT 13433 951 46 two two CD 13433 951 47 points point NNS 13433 951 48 affirmed affirm VBD 13433 951 49 . . . 13433 951 50 " " '' 13433 952 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 952 2 88:1 88:1 CD 13433 952 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 952 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 952 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 952 6 however however RB 13433 952 7 , , , 13433 952 8 has have VBZ 13433 952 9 either either CC 13433 952 10 overlooked overlook VBN 13433 952 11 or or CC 13433 952 12 omitted omit VBN 13433 952 13 to to TO 13433 952 14 state state VB 13433 952 15 the the DT 13433 952 16 fact fact NN 13433 952 17 that that IN 13433 952 18 , , , 13433 952 19 although although IN 13433 952 20 some some DT 13433 952 21 of of IN 13433 952 22 the the DT 13433 952 23 writers writer NNS 13433 952 24 are be VBP 13433 952 25 quoted quote VBN 13433 952 26 twice twice RB 13433 952 27 , , , 13433 952 28 the the DT 13433 952 29 two two CD 13433 952 30 notes note NNS 13433 952 31 differ differ VBP 13433 952 32 in in IN 13433 952 33 almost almost RB 13433 952 34 every every DT 13433 952 35 particular particular JJ 13433 952 36 , , , 13433 952 37 many many JJ 13433 952 38 of of IN 13433 952 39 the the DT 13433 952 40 names name NNS 13433 952 41 in in IN 13433 952 42 note note NN 13433 952 43 3 3 CD 13433 952 44 being be VBG 13433 952 45 absent absent JJ 13433 952 46 from from IN 13433 952 47 note note NN 13433 952 48 4 4 CD 13433 952 49 , , , 13433 952 50 other other JJ 13433 952 51 names name NNS 13433 952 52 being be VBG 13433 952 53 inserted insert VBN 13433 952 54 in in IN 13433 952 55 the the DT 13433 952 56 latter latter JJ 13433 952 57 which which WDT 13433 952 58 do do VBP 13433 952 59 not not RB 13433 952 60 appear appear VB 13433 952 61 in in IN 13433 952 62 the the DT 13433 952 63 former former JJ 13433 952 64 , , , 13433 952 65 an an DT 13433 952 66 alteration alteration NN 13433 952 67 being be VBG 13433 952 68 in in IN 13433 952 69 most most JJS 13433 952 70 cases case NNS 13433 952 71 made make VBN 13433 952 72 in in IN 13433 952 73 the the DT 13433 952 74 place place NN 13433 952 75 referred refer VBN 13433 952 76 to to IN 13433 952 77 , , , 13433 952 78 and and CC 13433 952 79 the the DT 13433 952 80 order order NN 13433 952 81 in in IN 13433 952 82 which which WDT 13433 952 83 the the DT 13433 952 84 authorities authority NNS 13433 952 85 are be VBP 13433 952 86 placed place VBN 13433 952 87 being be VBG 13433 952 88 significantly significantly RB 13433 952 89 varied varied JJ 13433 952 90 . . . 13433 953 1 For for IN 13433 953 2 instance instance NN 13433 953 3 , , , 13433 953 4 in in IN 13433 953 5 note note NN 13433 953 6 3 3 CD 13433 953 7 , , , 13433 953 8 the the DT 13433 953 9 reference reference NN 13433 953 10 to to IN 13433 953 11 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 953 12 is be VBZ 13433 953 13 the the DT 13433 953 14 last last JJ 13433 953 15 , , , 13433 953 16 but but CC 13433 953 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 953 18 is be VBZ 13433 953 19 the the DT 13433 953 20 first first JJ 13433 953 21 in in IN 13433 953 22 note note NN 13433 953 23 4 4 CD 13433 953 24 ; ; : 13433 953 25 whilst whilst IN 13433 953 26 a a DT 13433 953 27 similar similar JJ 13433 953 28 transposition transposition NN 13433 953 29 of of IN 13433 953 30 order order NN 13433 953 31 takes take VBZ 13433 953 32 place place NN 13433 953 33 in in IN 13433 953 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 953 35 works work NNS 13433 953 36 , , , 13433 953 37 and and CC 13433 953 38 alterations alteration NNS 13433 953 39 are be VBP 13433 953 40 made make VBN 13433 953 41 in in IN 13433 953 42 the the DT 13433 953 43 pages page NNS 13433 953 44 . . . 13433 954 1 The the DT 13433 954 2 references reference NNS 13433 954 3 in in IN 13433 954 4 note note NN 13433 954 5 3 3 CD 13433 954 6 , , , 13433 954 7 in in IN 13433 954 8 fact fact NN 13433 954 9 , , , 13433 954 10 are be VBP 13433 954 11 given give VBN 13433 954 12 for for IN 13433 954 13 the the DT 13433 954 14 date date NN 13433 954 15 occurring occur VBG 13433 954 16 in in IN 13433 954 17 the the DT 13433 954 18 course course NN 13433 954 19 of of IN 13433 954 20 the the DT 13433 954 21 sentence sentence NN 13433 954 22 , , , 13433 954 23 whilst whilst IN 13433 954 24 those those DT 13433 954 25 in in IN 13433 954 26 note note NN 13433 954 27 4 4 CD 13433 954 28 , , , 13433 954 29 placed place VBN 13433 954 30 at at IN 13433 954 31 the the DT 13433 954 32 end end NN 13433 954 33 , , , 13433 954 34 are be VBP 13433 954 35 intended intend VBN 13433 954 36 to to TO 13433 954 37 support support VB 13433 954 38 the the DT 13433 954 39 whole whole JJ 13433 954 40 statement statement NN 13433 954 41 which which WDT 13433 954 42 is be VBZ 13433 954 43 made make VBN 13433 954 44 . . . 13433 955 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 955 2 must must MD 13433 955 3 , , , 13433 955 4 however however RB 13433 955 5 , , , 13433 955 6 explain explain VB 13433 955 7 an an DT 13433 955 8 omission omission NN 13433 955 9 , , , 13433 955 10 which which WDT 13433 955 11 is be VBZ 13433 955 12 pretty pretty RB 13433 955 13 obvious obvious JJ 13433 955 14 , , , 13433 955 15 but but CC 13433 955 16 which which WDT 13433 955 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 955 18 regret regret VBP 13433 955 19 may may MD 13433 955 20 have have VB 13433 955 21 misled mislead VBN 13433 955 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 955 23 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 955 24 in in IN 13433 955 25 regard regard NN 13433 955 26 to to TO 13433 955 27 note note VB 13433 955 28 3 3 CD 13433 955 29 , , , 13433 955 30 although although IN 13433 955 31 it -PRON- PRP 13433 955 32 does do VBZ 13433 955 33 not not RB 13433 955 34 affect affect VB 13433 955 35 note note NN 13433 955 36 4 4 CD 13433 955 37 . . . 13433 956 1 Readers reader NNS 13433 956 2 are be VBP 13433 956 3 probably probably RB 13433 956 4 aware aware JJ 13433 956 5 that that IN 13433 956 6 there there EX 13433 956 7 has have VBZ 13433 956 8 been be VBN 13433 956 9 , , , 13433 956 10 amongst amongst IN 13433 956 11 other other JJ 13433 956 12 points point NNS 13433 956 13 , , , 13433 956 14 a a DT 13433 956 15 difference difference NN 13433 956 16 of of IN 13433 956 17 opinion opinion NN 13433 956 18 not not RB 13433 956 19 only only RB 13433 956 20 as as IN 13433 956 21 to to IN 13433 956 22 the the DT 13433 956 23 place place NN 13433 956 24 , , , 13433 956 25 but but CC 13433 956 26 also also RB 13433 956 27 the the DT 13433 956 28 date date NN 13433 956 29 of of IN 13433 956 30 the the DT 13433 956 31 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 956 32 of of IN 13433 956 33 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 956 34 . . . 13433 957 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 957 2 have have VBP 13433 957 3 in in IN 13433 957 4 every every DT 13433 957 5 other other JJ 13433 957 6 case case NN 13433 957 7 carefully carefully RB 13433 957 8 stated state VBD 13433 957 9 the the DT 13433 957 10 question question NN 13433 957 11 of of IN 13433 957 12 date date NN 13433 957 13 , , , 13433 957 14 and and CC 13433 957 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 957 16 omission omission NN 13433 957 17 in in IN 13433 957 18 this this DT 13433 957 19 instance instance NN 13433 957 20 is be VBZ 13433 957 21 , , , 13433 957 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 957 23 think think VBP 13433 957 24 , , , 13433 957 25 the the DT 13433 957 26 only only JJ 13433 957 27 exception exception NN 13433 957 28 in in IN 13433 957 29 the the DT 13433 957 30 book book NN 13433 957 31 . . . 13433 958 1 The the DT 13433 958 2 fact fact NN 13433 958 3 is be VBZ 13433 958 4 , , , 13433 958 5 that that IN 13433 958 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 958 7 had have VBD 13433 958 8 originally originally RB 13433 958 9 in in IN 13433 958 10 the the DT 13433 958 11 text text NN 13433 958 12 the the DT 13433 958 13 words word NNS 13433 958 14 which which WDT 13433 958 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 958 16 now now RB 13433 958 17 add add VBP 13433 958 18 to to IN 13433 958 19 the the DT 13433 958 20 note note NN 13433 958 21 : : : 13433 958 22 " " `` 13433 958 23 The the DT 13433 958 24 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 958 25 has have VBZ 13433 958 26 been be VBN 13433 958 27 variously variously RB 13433 958 28 dated date VBN 13433 958 29 about about IN 13433 958 30 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 958 31 107 107 CD 13433 958 32 , , , 13433 958 33 or or CC 13433 958 34 115 115 CD 13433 958 35 - - SYM 13433 958 36 116 116 CD 13433 958 37 . . . 13433 958 38 but but CC 13433 958 39 whether whether IN 13433 958 40 assigning assign VBG 13433 958 41 the the DT 13433 958 42 event event NN 13433 958 43 to to IN 13433 958 44 Rome Rome NNP 13433 958 45 or or CC 13433 958 46 to to IN 13433 958 47 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 958 48 a a DT 13433 958 49 majority majority NN 13433 958 50 of of IN 13433 958 51 critics critic NNS 13433 958 52 of of IN 13433 958 53 all all DT 13433 958 54 shades shade NNS 13433 958 55 of of IN 13433 958 56 opinion opinion NN 13433 958 57 have have VBP 13433 958 58 adopted adopt VBN 13433 958 59 the the DT 13433 958 60 later later JJ 13433 958 61 date date NN 13433 958 62 . . . 13433 958 63 " " '' 13433 959 1 Thinking think VBG 13433 959 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 959 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 959 4 , , , 13433 959 5 under under IN 13433 959 6 the the DT 13433 959 7 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 959 8 , , , 13433 959 9 to to TO 13433 959 10 burden burden VB 13433 959 11 the the DT 13433 959 12 text text NN 13433 959 13 with with IN 13433 959 14 this this DT 13433 959 15 , , , 13433 959 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 959 17 removed remove VBD 13433 959 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 959 19 with with IN 13433 959 20 the the DT 13433 959 21 design design NN 13433 959 22 of of IN 13433 959 23 putting put VBG 13433 959 24 the the DT 13433 959 25 statement statement NN 13433 959 26 at at IN 13433 959 27 the the DT 13433 959 28 head head NN 13433 959 29 of of IN 13433 959 30 note note NN 13433 959 31 3 3 CD 13433 959 32 , , , 13433 959 33 with with IN 13433 959 34 reference reference NN 13433 959 35 to to IN 13433 959 36 " " `` 13433 959 37 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 959 38 115 115 CD 13433 959 39 " " '' 13433 959 40 in in IN 13433 959 41 the the DT 13433 959 42 text text NN 13433 959 43 , , , 13433 959 44 but but CC 13433 959 45 unfortunately unfortunately RB 13433 959 46 an an DT 13433 959 47 interruption interruption NN 13433 959 48 at at IN 13433 959 49 the the DT 13433 959 50 time time NN 13433 959 51 prevented prevent VBD 13433 959 52 the the DT 13433 959 53 completion completion NN 13433 959 54 of of IN 13433 959 55 this this DT 13433 959 56 intention intention NN 13433 959 57 , , , 13433 959 58 as as RB 13433 959 59 well well RB 13433 959 60 as as IN 13433 959 61 the the DT 13433 959 62 addition addition NN 13433 959 63 of of IN 13433 959 64 some some DT 13433 959 65 fuller full JJR 13433 959 66 references reference NNS 13433 959 67 to to IN 13433 959 68 the the DT 13433 959 69 writers writer NNS 13433 959 70 quoted quote VBN 13433 959 71 , , , 13433 959 72 which which WDT 13433 959 73 had have VBD 13433 959 74 been be VBN 13433 959 75 omitted omit VBN 13433 959 76 , , , 13433 959 77 and and CC 13433 959 78 the the DT 13433 959 79 point point NN 13433 959 80 , , , 13433 959 81 to to IN 13433 959 82 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 959 83 infinite infinite JJ 13433 959 84 regret regret NN 13433 959 85 , , , 13433 959 86 was be VBD 13433 959 87 overlooked overlook VBN 13433 959 88 . . . 13433 960 1 The the DT 13433 960 2 whole whole NN 13433 960 3 of of IN 13433 960 4 the the DT 13433 960 5 authorities authority NNS 13433 960 6 in in IN 13433 960 7 note note NN 13433 960 8 3 3 CD 13433 960 9 , , , 13433 960 10 therefore therefore RB 13433 960 11 , , , 13433 960 12 do do VBP 13433 960 13 not not RB 13433 960 14 support support VB 13433 960 15 the the DT 13433 960 16 apparent apparent JJ 13433 960 17 statement statement NN 13433 960 18 of of IN 13433 960 19 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 960 20 in in IN 13433 960 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 960 22 , , , 13433 960 23 although although IN 13433 960 24 they -PRON- PRP 13433 960 25 all all DT 13433 960 26 confirm confirm VBP 13433 960 27 the the DT 13433 960 28 date date NN 13433 960 29 , , , 13433 960 30 for for IN 13433 960 31 which which WDT 13433 960 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 960 33 really really RB 13433 960 34 referred refer VBD 13433 960 35 to to IN 13433 960 36 them -PRON- PRP 13433 960 37 . . . 13433 961 1 With with IN 13433 961 2 this this DT 13433 961 3 explanation explanation NN 13433 961 4 , , , 13433 961 5 and and CC 13433 961 6 marking mark VBG 13433 961 7 the the DT 13433 961 8 omitted omitted JJ 13433 961 9 references reference NNS 13433 961 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 961 11 89:1 89:1 CD 13433 961 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 961 13 by by IN 13433 961 14 placing place VBG 13433 961 15 them -PRON- PRP 13433 961 16 within within IN 13433 961 17 brackets bracket NNS 13433 961 18 , , , 13433 961 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 961 20 proceed proceed VBP 13433 961 21 to to TO 13433 961 22 analyse analyse VB 13433 961 23 the the DT 13433 961 24 two two CD 13433 961 25 notes note NNS 13433 961 26 in in IN 13433 961 27 contrast contrast NN 13433 961 28 with with IN 13433 961 29 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 961 30 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 961 31 's 's POS 13433 961 32 statements statement NNS 13433 961 33 . . . 13433 962 1 NOTE NOTE NNP 13433 962 2 3 3 CD 13433 962 3 , , , 13433 962 4 FOR for IN 13433 962 5 THE the DT 13433 962 6 DATE DATE NNP 13433 962 7 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 962 8 115 115 CD 13433 962 9 - - SYM 13433 962 10 116 116 CD 13433 962 11 . . . 13433 963 1 DR DR NNP 13433 963 2 . . . 13433 963 3 WESTCOTT westcott NN 13433 963 4 'S 's NN 13433 963 5 STATEMENTS statement NNS 13433 963 6 . . . 13433 964 1 | | CD 13433 964 2 THE the DT 13433 964 3 TRUTH truth NN 13433 964 4 . . . 13433 965 1 | | NNP 13433 965 2 | | NNP 13433 965 3 Baur Baur NNP 13433 965 4 , , , 13433 965 5 _ _ NNP 13433 965 6 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 965 7 . . . 13433 966 1 d. d. NNP 13433 967 1 Episc Episc NNP 13433 967 2 . . . 13433 967 3 , , , 13433 967 4 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 967 5 . . . 13433 968 1 | | NNP 13433 968 2 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 968 3 . . . 13433 968 4 _ _ NNP 13433 968 5 1838 1838 CD 13433 968 6 , , , 13433 968 7 H.3 H.3 NNP 13433 968 8 ( ( -LRB- 13433 968 9 p. p. NN 13433 968 10 149 149 CD 13433 968 11 , , , 13433 968 12 | | NNP 13433 968 13 Anm Anm NNP 13433 968 14 . . . 13433 968 15 ) ) -RRB- 13433 969 1 Baur baur JJ 13433 969 2 states state NNS 13433 969 3 as as IN 13433 969 4 the the DT 13433 969 5 date date NN 13433 969 6 of of IN 13433 969 7 | | CD 13433 969 8 the the DT 13433 969 9 Parthian parthian JJ 13433 969 10 war war NN 13433 969 11 , , , 13433 969 12 and and CC 13433 969 13 of of IN 13433 969 14 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 969 15 's 's POS 13433 969 16 | | CD 13433 969 17 visit visit NN 13433 969 18 to to IN 13433 969 19 Rome Rome NNP 13433 969 20 , , , 13433 969 21 " " '' 13433 969 22 during during IN 13433 969 23 which which WDT 13433 969 24 the the DT 13433 969 25 | | CD 13433 969 26 above above IN 13433 969 27 order order NN 13433 969 28 " " '' 13433 969 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 969 30 the the DT 13433 969 31 sentence sentence NN 13433 969 32 against against IN 13433 969 33 | | NNP 13433 969 34 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 969 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 969 36 is be VBZ 13433 969 37 said say VBN 13433 969 38 to to TO 13433 969 39 have have VB 13433 969 40 been be VBN 13433 969 41 | | CD 13433 969 42 given give VBN 13433 969 43 , , , 13433 969 44 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 969 45 115 115 CD 13433 969 46 and and CC 13433 969 47 not not RB 13433 969 48 107 107 CD 13433 969 49 . . . 13433 970 1 | | NNP 13433 970 2 " " `` 13433 970 3 1 1 CD 13433 970 4 . . . 13433 971 1 Baur Baur NNP 13433 971 2 , , , 13433 971 3 _ _ NNP 13433 971 4 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 971 5 . . . 13433 972 1 d. d. NNP 13433 973 1 Episc Episc NNP 13433 973 2 . . . 13433 973 3 , , , 13433 973 4 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 973 5 . . . 13433 974 1 | | NNP 13433 974 2 _ _ NNP 13433 974 3 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 974 4 . . . 13433 974 5 _ _ NNP 13433 974 6 p. p. NN 13433 974 7 155 155 CD 13433 974 8 , , , 13433 974 9 Anm anm CC 13433 974 10 . . . 13433 975 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 975 2 . . . 13433 975 3 _ _ NNP 13433 975 4 1838 1838 CD 13433 975 5 , , , 13433 975 6 ii ii NNP 13433 975 7 . . . 13433 976 1 3 3 LS 13433 976 2 . . . 13433 976 3 p. p. NN 13433 976 4 155 155 CD 13433 976 5 , , , 13433 976 6 | | NNP 13433 976 7 Anm Anm NNP 13433 976 8 . . . 13433 977 1 In in IN 13433 977 2 this this DT 13433 977 3 note note NN 13433 977 4 , , , 13433 977 5 which which WDT 13433 977 6 is be VBZ 13433 977 7 too too RB 13433 977 8 | | JJ 13433 977 9 After after IN 13433 977 10 showing show VBG 13433 977 11 the the DT 13433 977 12 extreme extreme NN 13433 977 13 long long RB 13433 977 14 to to TO 13433 977 15 quote quote VB 13433 977 16 , , , 13433 977 17 _ _ NNP 13433 977 18 there there EX 13433 977 19 is be VBZ 13433 977 20 nothing nothing NN 13433 977 21 _ _ NNP 13433 977 22 , , , 13433 977 23 | | CD 13433 977 24 improbability improbability NN 13433 977 25 of of IN 13433 977 26 the the DT 13433 977 27 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 977 28 so so RB 13433 977 29 far far RB 13433 977 30 as as IN 13433 977 31 I -PRON- PRP 13433 977 32 see see VBP 13433 977 33 , , , 13433 977 34 _ _ NNP 13433 977 35 in in IN 13433 977 36 any any DT 13433 977 37 way way NN 13433 977 38 | | CD 13433 977 39 under under IN 13433 977 40 which which WDT 13433 977 41 the the DT 13433 977 42 letters letter NNS 13433 977 43 to to IN 13433 977 44 the the DT 13433 977 45 bearing bearing NN 13433 977 46 _ _ NNP 13433 977 47 upon upon IN 13433 977 48 the the DT 13433 977 49 history history NN 13433 977 50 [ [ -LRB- 13433 977 51 90:1 90:1 NN 13433 977 52 ] ] -RRB- 13433 977 53 | | NNS 13433 977 54 Smyrnaeans Smyrnaeans NNPS 13433 977 55 and and CC 13433 977 56 to to IN 13433 977 57 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 977 58 are be VBP 13433 977 59 said say VBN 13433 977 60 except except IN 13433 977 61 a a DT 13433 977 62 passing pass VBG 13433 977 63 supposition supposition NN 13433 977 64 ' ' `` 13433 977 65 wenn wenn NN 13433 977 66 | | NNP 13433 977 67 to to TO 13433 977 68 have have VB 13433 977 69 been be VBN 13433 977 70 written write VBN 13433 977 71 , , , 13433 977 72 Baur baur JJ 13433 977 73 points point NNS 13433 977 74 ... ... : 13433 977 75 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 977 76 i -PRON- PRP 13433 977 77 m be VBP 13433 977 78 J. J. NNP 13433 978 1 116 116 CD 13433 978 2 an an DT 13433 978 3 ihn ihn NN 13433 978 4 | | VBN 13433 978 5 out out RP 13433 978 6 the the DT 13433 978 7 additional additional JJ 13433 978 8 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 978 9 in in IN 13433 978 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 978 11 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 978 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 978 13 ... ... . 13433 978 14 schrieb schrieb UH 13433 978 15 ... ... : 13433 978 16 ' ' '' 13433 978 17 | | CD 13433 978 18 regard regard NN 13433 978 19 to to IN 13433 978 20 the the DT 13433 978 21 latter latter JJ 13433 978 22 that that IN 13433 978 23 , , , 13433 978 24 if if IN 13433 978 25 | | CD 13433 978 26 [ [ -LRB- 13433 978 27 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 978 28 ] ] -RRB- 13433 978 29 died die VBD 13433 978 30 in in IN 13433 978 31 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 978 32 167 167 CD 13433 978 33 in in IN 13433 978 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 978 35 | | CD 13433 978 36 86th 86th NN 13433 978 37 year year NN 13433 978 38 , , , 13433 978 39 and and CC 13433 978 40 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 978 41 wrote write VBD 13433 978 42 to to IN 13433 978 43 him -PRON- PRP 13433 978 44 | | VBD 13433 978 45 as as RB 13433 978 46 already already RB 13433 978 47 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 978 48 of of IN 13433 978 49 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 13433 978 50 in in IN 13433 978 51 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 978 52 | | NNP 13433 978 53 116 116 CD 13433 978 54 , , , 13433 978 55 he -PRON- PRP 13433 978 56 must must MD 13433 978 57 have have VB 13433 978 58 become become VBN 13433 978 59 bishop bishop NN 13433 978 60 at at IN 13433 978 61 | | CD 13433 978 62 least least JJS 13433 978 63 in in IN 13433 978 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 978 65 35th 35th JJ 13433 978 66 year year NN 13433 978 67 , , , 13433 978 68 and and CC 13433 978 69 | | NNP 13433 978 70 continued continue VBD 13433 978 71 so so RB 13433 978 72 for for IN 13433 978 73 upwards upward NNS 13433 978 74 of of IN 13433 978 75 half half NN 13433 978 76 | | NNS 13433 978 77 a a DT 13433 978 78 century century NN 13433 978 79 . . . 13433 979 1 The the DT 13433 979 2 inference inference NN 13433 979 3 is be VBZ 13433 979 4 clear clear JJ 13433 979 5 | | NNS 13433 979 6 that that IN 13433 979 7 if if IN 13433 979 8 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 979 9 died die VBD 13433 979 10 so so RB 13433 979 11 much much JJ 13433 979 12 | | NNS 13433 979 13 earlier early RBR 13433 979 14 as as IN 13433 979 15 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 979 16 107 107 CD 13433 979 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 979 18 involves involve VBZ 13433 979 19 | | CD 13433 979 20 the the DT 13433 979 21 still still RB 13433 979 22 greater great JJR 13433 979 23 improbability improbability NN 13433 979 24 | | NNS 13433 979 25 that that IN 13433 979 26 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 979 27 must must MD 13433 979 28 have have VB 13433 979 29 become become VBN 13433 979 30 | | NNP 13433 979 31 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 979 32 of of IN 13433 979 33 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 13433 979 34 at at IN 13433 979 35 latest late JJS 13433 979 36 in in IN 13433 979 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 979 38 | | CD 13433 979 39 26th 26th JJ 13433 979 40 year year NN 13433 979 41 , , , 13433 979 42 which which WDT 13433 979 43 is be VBZ 13433 979 44 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 979 45 to to TO 13433 979 46 be be VB 13433 979 47 | | VBN 13433 979 48 maintained maintain VBD 13433 979 49 , , , 13433 979 50 and and CC 13433 979 51 the the DT 13433 979 52 later later JJ 13433 979 53 date date NN 13433 979 54 is be VBZ 13433 979 55 | | CD 13433 979 56 thus thus RB 13433 979 57 obviously obviously RB 13433 979 58 supported support VBN 13433 979 59 . . . 13433 980 1 | | NNS 13433 980 2 | | NNP 13433 980 3 ( ( -LRB- 13433 980 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 980 5 . . . 13433 981 1 _ _ NNP 13433 981 2 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 981 3 . . . 13433 982 1 christl christl NNP 13433 982 2 . . . 13433 983 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 983 2 _ _ NNP 13433 983 3 , , , 13433 983 4 | | NNP 13433 983 5 i. i. NNP 13433 983 6 p. p. NN 13433 983 7 440 440 CD 13433 983 8 , , , 13433 983 9 Anm anm CC 13433 983 10 . . . 13433 984 1 1 1 LS 13433 984 2 . . . 13433 984 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 985 1 | | CD 13433 985 2 | | NNP 13433 985 3 Baur Baur NNP 13433 985 4 supports support VBZ 13433 985 5 the the DT 13433 985 6 assertion assertion NN 13433 985 7 that that IN 13433 985 8 | | NNP 13433 985 9 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 985 10 suffered suffer VBD 13433 985 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 985 12 in in IN 13433 985 13 | | NNP 13433 985 14 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 985 15 , , , 13433 985 16 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 985 17 115 115 CD 13433 985 18 . . . 13433 986 1 | | NNP 13433 986 2 " " `` 13433 986 3 2 2 CD 13433 986 4 . . . 13433 987 1 Bretschneider bretschneider NN 13433 987 2 , , , 13433 987 3 _ _ NNP 13433 987 4 Probabilia Probabilia NNP 13433 987 5 _ _ NNP 13433 987 6 , , , 13433 987 7 x. x. NNP 13433 988 1 | | NNP 13433 988 2 The the DT 13433 988 3 same same JJ 13433 988 4 . . . 13433 989 1 p. p. NN 13433 989 2 185 185 CD 13433 989 3 . . . 13433 990 1 ' ' `` 13433 990 2 Pergamus Pergamus NNP 13433 990 3 ad ad NN 13433 990 4 Ignatium Ignatium NNP 13433 990 5 ' ' POS 13433 990 6 _ _ NNP 13433 990 7 qui qui NNP 13433 990 8 | | NNP 13433 990 9 circa circa NN 13433 990 10 annum annum NN 13433 990 11 cxvi cxvi NN 13433 990 12 obiisse obiisse NNP 13433 990 13 dicitur dicitur NNP 13433 990 14 _ _ NNP 13433 990 15 . . . 13433 990 16 ' ' '' 13433 991 1 | | NNP 13433 991 2 | | NNP 13433 991 3 " " '' 13433 991 4 3 3 CD 13433 991 5 . . . 13433 992 1 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 992 2 , , , 13433 992 3 _ _ NNP 13433 992 4 Einl Einl NNP 13433 992 5 . . . 13433 993 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 993 2 _ _ NNP 13433 993 3 p. p. NN 13433 993 4 144 144 CD 13433 993 5 | | NNP 13433 993 6 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 993 7 , , , 13433 993 8 _ _ NNP 13433 993 9 Einl Einl NNP 13433 993 10 . . . 13433 994 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 994 2 _ _ NNP 13433 994 3 p. p. NN 13433 994 4 144 144 CD 13433 994 5 . . . 13433 995 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 995 2 p. p. NN 13433 995 3 142 142 CD 13433 995 4 ed ed NN 13433 995 5 . . . 13433 996 1 1862 1862 LS 13433 996 2 ] ] -RRB- 13433 996 3 ' ' '' 13433 996 4 ... ... . 13433 997 1 In in IN 13433 997 2 den den NNP 13433 997 3 | | NNP 13433 997 4 Briefen Briefen NNP 13433 997 5 des des FW 13433 997 6 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 997 7 Bischofes Bischofes NNP 13433 997 8 von von NNP 13433 997 9 | | NNP 13433 997 10 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 997 11 suffered suffer VBD 13433 997 12 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 997 13 at at IN 13433 997 14 Rome Rome NNP 13433 997 15 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 13433 997 16 , , , 13433 997 17 der der XX 13433 997 18 unter unter NN 13433 997 19 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 997 20 gegen gegen NNP 13433 997 21 | | NNP 13433 997 22 under under IN 13433 997 23 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 997 24 , , , 13433 997 25 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 997 26 115 115 CD 13433 997 27 . . . 13433 998 1 115 115 CD 13433 998 2 _ _ NNP 13433 998 3 zu zu NNP 13433 998 4 Rom Rom NNP 13433 998 5 _ _ NNP 13433 998 6 als als NNP 13433 998 7 Märtyrer märtyrer NN 13433 998 8 starb starb NN 13433 998 9 . . . 13433 998 10 ' ' '' 13433 999 1 | | NNP 13433 999 2 | | NNP 13433 999 3 " " '' 13433 999 4 4 4 CD 13433 999 5 . . . 13433 1000 1 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 1000 2 , , , 13433 1000 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1000 4 Handb Handb NNP 13433 1000 5 . . . 13433 1001 1 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 1001 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1001 3 i. i. NNP 13433 1002 1 | | NNP 13433 1002 2 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 1002 3 , , , 13433 1002 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1002 5 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 1002 6 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 1002 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1002 8 i. i. NNP 13433 1002 9 p. p. NNP 13433 1002 10 148 148 CD 13433 1002 11 . . . 13433 1002 12 p. p. NN 13433 1002 13 148 148 CD 13433 1002 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1002 15 p. p. NN 13433 1002 16 177 177 CD 13433 1002 17 ed ed NN 13433 1002 18 . . . 13433 1003 1 3 3 CD 13433 1003 2 , , , 13433 1003 3 1838 1838 CD 13433 1003 4 , , , 13433 1003 5 the the DT 13433 1003 6 | | NNP 13433 1003 7 edition edition NN 13433 1003 8 which which WDT 13433 1003 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1003 10 have have VBP 13433 1003 11 used use VBN 13433 1003 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1003 13 . . . 13433 1004 1 | | NNP 13433 1004 2 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1004 3 was be VBD 13433 1004 4 sent send VBN 13433 1004 5 to to IN 13433 1004 6 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1004 7 , , , 13433 1004 8 under under IN 13433 1004 9 ' ' `` 13433 1004 10 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1004 11 , , , 13433 1004 12 Bischoff Bischoff NNP 13433 1004 13 von von NNP 13433 1004 14 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 13433 1004 15 | | NNP 13433 1004 16 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1004 17 , , , 13433 1004 18 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1004 19 115 115 CD 13433 1004 20 , , , 13433 1004 21 and and CC 13433 1004 22 was be VBD 13433 1004 23 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 1004 24 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1004 25 Euseb Euseb NNP 13433 1004 26 . . . 13433 1005 1 " " `` 13433 1005 2 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 1005 3 " " '' 13433 1006 1 iii iii NNP 13433 1006 2 . . . 13433 1007 1 36 36 CD 13433 1007 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1007 3 , , , 13433 1007 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1007 5 welcher welcher NN 13433 1007 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1007 7 | | NNP 13433 1007 8 by by IN 13433 1007 9 lions lion NNS 13433 1007 10 in in IN 13433 1007 11 the the DT 13433 1007 12 Coliseum Coliseum NNP 13433 1007 13 , , , 13433 1007 14 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1007 15 116 116 CD 13433 1007 16 . . . 13433 1007 17 wegen wegen NN 13433 1007 18 seines seine NNS 13433 1007 19 standhaften standhaften VBD 13433 1007 20 | | NNP 13433 1007 21 Bekenntnisses Bekenntnisses NNP 13433 1007 22 Christi Christi NNP 13433 1007 23 _ _ NNP 13433 1007 24 unter unter NN 13433 1007 25 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1007 26 | | NNP 13433 1007 27 115 115 CD 13433 1007 28 _ _ NNP 13433 1007 29 nach nach RB 13433 1007 30 Rom Rom NNP 13433 1007 31 geführt geführt NN 13433 1007 32 , , , 13433 1007 33 und und RB 13433 1007 34 hier hi JJR 13433 1007 35 116 116 CD 13433 1007 36 | | NNS 13433 1007 37 i -PRON- PRP 13433 1007 38 m be VBP 13433 1007 39 Colosseum Colosseum NNP 13433 1007 40 von von NNP 13433 1007 41 Löwen Löwen NNP 13433 1007 42 zerrissen zerrissen NNP 13433 1007 43 | | NNP 13433 1007 44 wurde wurde NNP 13433 1007 45 _ _ NNP 13433 1007 46 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1007 47 vgl vgl NNP 13433 1007 48 . . . 13433 1008 1 § § CD 13433 1008 2 23 23 CD 13433 1008 3 , , , 13433 1008 4 i. i. NNP 13433 1008 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1008 6 ' ' '' 13433 1009 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1009 2 where where WRB 13433 1009 3 the the DT 13433 1009 4 | | CD 13433 1009 5 same same JJ 13433 1009 6 statement statement NN 13433 1009 7 is be VBZ 13433 1009 8 repeated repeat VBN 13433 1009 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1009 10 . . . 13433 1010 1 | | NNP 13433 1010 2 | | NNP 13433 1010 3 " " '' 13433 1010 4 5 5 CD 13433 1010 5 . . . 13433 1011 1 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 1011 2 , , , 13433 1011 3 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 1012 1 i. i. NNP 13433 1013 1 113 113 CD 13433 1013 2 f. f. NNP 13433 1013 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1013 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1013 5 | | NNP 13433 1013 6 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 1013 7 , , , 13433 1013 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1013 9 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 1013 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1013 11 1869 1869 CD 13433 1013 12 , , , 13433 1013 13 p. p. NN 13433 1013 14 113 113 CD 13433 1013 15 . . . 13433 1013 16 f. f. NNP 13433 1013 17 have have VBP 13433 1013 18 not not RB 13433 1013 19 been be VBN 13433 1013 20 able able JJ 13433 1013 21 to to TO 13433 1013 22 see see VB 13433 1013 23 the the DT 13433 1013 24 book book NN 13433 1013 25 | | CD 13433 1013 26 referred refer VBD 13433 1013 27 to to IN 13433 1013 28 , , , 13433 1013 29 but but CC 13433 1013 30 in in IN 13433 1013 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1013 32 Lectures Lectures NNP 13433 1013 33 | | CD 13433 1013 34 " " `` 13433 1013 35 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1013 36 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1013 37 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1013 38 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1013 39 may may MD 13433 1013 40 have have VB 13433 1013 41 filled fill VBN 13433 1013 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1013 43 ' ' `` 13433 1013 44 Die Die NNP 13433 1013 45 christliche christliche NNP 13433 1013 46 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 1013 47 der der NNP 13433 1013 48 drei drei NNP 13433 1013 49 | | HYPH 13433 1013 50 office office NN 13433 1013 51 about about RB 13433 1013 52 40 40 CD 13433 1013 53 years year NNS 13433 1013 54 when when WRB 13433 1013 55 the the DT 13433 1013 56 ersten ersten JJ 13433 1013 57 Jahrhunderte Jahrhunderte NNP 13433 1013 58 , , , 13433 1013 59 " " '' 13433 1013 60 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1013 61 91:1 91:1 CD 13433 1013 62 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1013 63 1853 1853 CD 13433 1013 64 | | NNP 13433 1013 65 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1013 66 , , , 13433 1013 67 in in IN 13433 1013 68 the the DT 13433 1013 69 year year NN 13433 1013 70 115 115 CD 13433 1013 71 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1013 72 according accord VBG 13433 1013 73 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1013 74 pp pp NNP 13433 1013 75 . . . 13433 1014 1 122 122 CD 13433 1014 2 ff ff NN 13433 1014 3 . . . 13433 1015 1 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1015 2 , , , 13433 1015 3 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 1015 4 mentions mention NNS 13433 1015 5 | | CD 13433 1015 6 to to IN 13433 1015 7 others other NNS 13433 1015 8 still still RB 13433 1015 9 earlier early RBR 13433 1015 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1015 11 , , , 13433 1015 12 came come VBD 13433 1015 13 to to IN 13433 1015 14 the the DT 13433 1015 15 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 1015 16 which which WDT 13433 1015 17 has have VBZ 13433 1015 18 been be VBN 13433 1015 19 felt feel VBN 13433 1015 20 | | CD 13433 1015 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1015 22 . . . 13433 1016 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1016 2 was be VBD 13433 1016 3 during during IN 13433 1016 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1016 5 war war NN 13433 1016 6 as as IN 13433 1016 7 to to IN 13433 1016 8 the the DT 13433 1016 9 execution execution NN 13433 1016 10 at at IN 13433 1016 11 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1016 12 , , , 13433 1016 13 while while IN 13433 1016 14 | | NNS 13433 1016 15 against against IN 13433 1016 16 the the DT 13433 1016 17 Parthians Parthians NNPS 13433 1016 18 . . . 13433 1016 19 " " '' 13433 1017 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1017 2 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 1017 3 an an DT 13433 1017 4 execution execution NN 13433 1017 5 at at IN 13433 1017 6 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1017 7 might may MD 13433 1017 8 have have VB 13433 1017 9 | | CD 13433 1017 10 states state NNS 13433 1017 11 some some DT 13433 1017 12 of of IN 13433 1017 13 the the DT 13433 1017 14 arguments argument NNS 13433 1017 15 for for IN 13433 1017 16 and and CC 13433 1017 17 been be VBN 13433 1017 18 simpler simple JJR 13433 1017 19 and and CC 13433 1017 20 more more RBR 13433 1017 21 impressive impressive JJ 13433 1017 22 , , , 13433 1017 23 | | VBN 13433 1017 24 against against IN 13433 1017 25 the the DT 13433 1017 26 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1017 27 in in IN 13433 1017 28 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1017 29 , , , 13433 1017 30 and and CC 13433 1017 31 then then RB 13433 1017 32 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1017 33 Gieseler Gieseler NNP 13433 1017 34 's 's POS 13433 1017 35 solution,| solution,| NNS 13433 1017 36 and and CC 13433 1017 37 the the DT 13433 1017 38 journey journey NN 13433 1017 39 to to IN 13433 1017 40 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1017 41 , , , 13433 1017 42 the the DT 13433 1017 43 former former JJ 13433 1017 44 and and CC 13433 1017 45 passes pass VBZ 13433 1017 46 on on RP 13433 1017 47 with with IN 13433 1017 48 ' ' `` 13433 1017 49 Wie Wie NNP 13433 1017 50 dem dem VBP 13433 1017 51 such such JJ 13433 1017 52 | | NNS 13433 1017 53 of of IN 13433 1017 54 which which WDT 13433 1017 55 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1017 56 seems seem VBZ 13433 1017 57 to to TO 13433 1017 58 consider consider VB 13433 1017 59 more more JJR 13433 1017 60 sei sei NN 13433 1017 61 . . . 13433 1017 62 ' ' '' 13433 1017 63 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1018 1 | | JJ 13433 1018 2 probable probable JJ 13433 1018 3 . . . 13433 1018 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1019 1 | | NNP 13433 1019 2 " " `` 13433 1019 3 6 6 CD 13433 1019 4 . . . 13433 1020 1 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 1020 2 , , , 13433 1020 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1020 4 Introd Introd NNP 13433 1020 5 . . . 13433 1021 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1021 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1021 3 i. i. NN 13433 1022 1 | | NNP 13433 1022 2 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 1022 3 , , , 13433 1022 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1022 5 Introd Introd NNP 13433 1022 6 . . . 13433 1023 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1023 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1023 3 i. i. NNP 13433 1023 4 p. p. NN 13433 1023 5 19 19 CD 13433 1023 6 . . . 13433 1023 7 p. p. NN 13433 1023 8 19 19 CD 13433 1023 9 . . . 13433 1024 1 ' ' `` 13433 1024 2 All all DT 13433 1024 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1024 4 the the DT 13433 1024 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1024 6 of of IN 13433 1024 7 | | NNP 13433 1024 8 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1024 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1024 10 are be VBP 13433 1024 11 posterior posterior JJ 13433 1024 12 to to IN 13433 1024 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1024 14 | | NNP 13433 1024 15 The the DT 13433 1024 16 same same JJ 13433 1024 17 as as IN 13433 1024 18 opposite opposite JJ 13433 1024 19 . . . 13433 1025 1 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1025 2 , , , 13433 1025 3 who who WP 13433 1025 4 was be VBD 13433 1025 5 not not RB 13433 1025 6 thrown throw VBN 13433 1025 7 to to IN 13433 1025 8 the the DT 13433 1025 9 | | JJ 13433 1025 10 wild wild JJ 13433 1025 11 beasts beast NNS 13433 1025 12 in in IN 13433 1025 13 the the DT 13433 1025 14 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1025 15 at at IN 13433 1025 16 | | NNP 13433 1025 17 These these DT 13433 1025 18 " " `` 13433 1025 19 peremptory peremptory JJ 13433 1025 20 statements statement NNS 13433 1025 21 " " '' 13433 1025 22 are be VBP 13433 1025 23 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1025 24 by by IN 13433 1025 25 command command NN 13433 1025 26 of of IN 13433 1025 27 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1025 28 , , , 13433 1025 29 but but CC 13433 1025 30 at at IN 13433 1025 31 | | CD 13433 1025 32 of of IN 13433 1025 33 course course NN 13433 1025 34 based base VBN 13433 1025 35 upon upon IN 13433 1025 36 what what WP 13433 1025 37 is be VBZ 13433 1025 38 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1025 39 on on IN 13433 1025 40 December December NNP 13433 1025 41 20 20 CD 13433 1025 42 , , , 13433 1025 43 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1025 44 115 115 CD 13433 1025 45 . . . 13433 1026 1 | | NNP 13433 1026 2 considered consider VBD 13433 1026 3 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 13433 1026 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 1026 5 , , , 13433 1026 6 The the DT 13433 1026 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1026 8 were be VBD 13433 1026 9 written write VBN 13433 1026 10 after after IN 13433 1026 11 | | CD 13433 1026 12 though though IN 13433 1026 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1026 14 may may MD 13433 1026 15 not not RB 13433 1026 16 be be VB 13433 1026 17 adduced adduce VBN 13433 1026 18 here here RB 13433 1026 19 . . . 13433 1027 1 150 150 CD 13433 1027 2 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1027 3 ' ' '' 13433 1027 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1027 5 For for IN 13433 1027 6 these these DT 13433 1027 7 peremptory peremptory JJ 13433 1027 8 | | NNS 13433 1027 9 statements statement VBZ 13433 1027 10 no no DT 13433 1027 11 authority authority NN 13433 1027 12 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1027 13 is be VBZ 13433 1027 14 | | NNP 13433 1027 15 adduced adduce VBN 13433 1027 16 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1027 17 . . . 13433 1028 1 | | NNP 13433 1028 2 | | NNP 13433 1028 3 " " '' 13433 1028 4 7 7 CD 13433 1028 5 . . . 13433 1029 1 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 13433 1029 2 , , , 13433 1029 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1029 4 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1029 5 . . . 13433 1030 1 petr petr NN 13433 1030 2 . . . 13433 1031 1 Schr Schr NNP 13433 1031 2 . . . 13433 1031 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1031 4 | | NNP 13433 1031 5 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 13433 1031 6 , , , 13433 1031 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1031 8 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1031 9 . . . 13433 1032 1 petr petr NN 13433 1032 2 . . . 13433 1033 1 Schr Schr NNP 13433 1033 2 . . . 13433 1033 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1033 4 p. p. NN 13433 1033 5 79 79 CD 13433 1033 6 . . . 13433 1034 1 ' ' `` 13433 1034 2 ... ... : 13433 1034 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1034 4 , , , 13433 1034 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1034 6 der der NNP 13433 1034 7 | | NNP 13433 1034 8 p. p. NN 13433 1034 9 79 79 CD 13433 1034 10 . . . 13433 1034 11 spätestens spätesten NNS 13433 1034 12 117 117 CD 13433 1034 13 zu zu NN 13433 1034 14 Rom rom JJ 13433 1034 15 den den NN 13433 1034 16 | | NNP 13433 1034 17 Märtyrertod märtyrertod JJ 13433 1034 18 litt litt NN 13433 1034 19 ... ... : 13433 1034 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1034 21 ' ' POS 13433 1034 22 | | NNP 13433 1034 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1034 24 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1034 25 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1034 26 in in IN 13433 1034 27 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1034 28 | | NNP 13433 1034 29 at at IN 13433 1034 30 latest late JJS 13433 1034 31 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1034 32 117 117 CD 13433 1034 33 . . . 13433 1035 1 | | NNP 13433 1035 2 " " `` 13433 1035 3 8 8 CD 13433 1035 4 . . . 13433 1036 1 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1036 2 , , , 13433 1036 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1036 4 Die Die NNP 13433 1036 5 ält ält NNP 13433 1036 6 . . . 13433 1037 1 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 1037 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1037 3 , , , 13433 1037 4 | | NNP 13433 1037 5 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1037 6 , , , 13433 1037 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1037 8 Die Die NNP 13433 1037 9 ält ält NNP 13433 1037 10 . . . 13433 1038 1 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 1038 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1038 3 , , , 13433 1038 4 p. p. NN 13433 1038 5 40 40 CD 13433 1038 6 , , , 13433 1038 7 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1038 8 115 115 CD 13433 1038 9 as as IN 13433 1038 10 the the DT 13433 1038 11 year year NN 13433 1038 12 of of IN 13433 1038 13 | | NNP 13433 1038 14 p. p. NN 13433 1038 15 40 40 CD 13433 1038 16 , , , 13433 1038 17 states state VBZ 13433 1038 18 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1038 19 115 115 CD 13433 1038 20 as as IN 13433 1038 21 the the DT 13433 1038 22 date date NN 13433 1038 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1038 24 ' ' POS 13433 1038 25 death death NN 13433 1038 26 : : : 13433 1038 27 p. p. NN 13433 1038 28 50 50 CD 13433 1038 29 f. f. NN 13433 1038 30 The the DT 13433 1038 31 | | NNP 13433 1038 32 of of IN 13433 1038 33 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1038 34 ' ' POS 13433 1038 35 death death NN 13433 1038 36 . . . 13433 1039 1 At at IN 13433 1039 2 p. p. NN 13433 1039 3 50 50 CD 13433 1039 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1039 5 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1039 6 letters letter NNS 13433 1039 7 are be VBP 13433 1039 8 rejected reject VBN 13433 1039 9 | | CD 13433 1039 10 repeats repeat NNS 13433 1039 11 this this DT 13433 1039 12 statement statement NN 13433 1039 13 , , , 13433 1039 14 and and CC 13433 1039 15 gives give VBZ 13433 1039 16 partly partly RB 13433 1039 17 ' ' `` 13433 1039 18 weil weil NNP 13433 1039 19 sie sie JJ 13433 1039 20 eine eine NN 13433 1039 21 Märtyrerreise Märtyrerreise NNP 13433 1039 22 | | CD 13433 1039 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1039 24 support support NN 13433 1039 25 to to IN 13433 1039 26 the the DT 13433 1039 27 view view NN 13433 1039 28 that that IN 13433 1039 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1039 30 des des FW 13433 1039 31 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1039 32 nach nach RB 13433 1039 33 Rom Rom NNP 13433 1039 34 melden melden NN 13433 1039 35 , , , 13433 1039 36 deren deren NN 13433 1039 37 | | NNP 13433 1039 38 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1039 39 took take VBD 13433 1039 40 place place NN 13433 1039 41 in in IN 13433 1039 42 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1039 43 on on IN 13433 1039 44 schon schon NNP 13433 1039 45 früher früher NNP 13433 1039 46 erkanntes erkannte VBZ 13433 1039 47 | | NNP 13433 1039 48 the the DT 13433 1039 49 20th 20th JJ 13433 1039 50 December December NNP 13433 1039 51 , , , 13433 1039 52 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1039 53 115 115 CD 13433 1039 54 . . . 13433 1039 55 ungeschichtliches ungeschichtliches NNP 13433 1039 56 Wesen Wesen NNP 13433 1039 57 durch durch NN 13433 1039 58 | | NNP 13433 1039 59 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1039 60 's 's POS 13433 1039 61 nicht nicht NN 13433 1039 62 ungegründete ungegründete NNP 13433 1039 63 | | NNP 13433 1039 64 Vermuthung Vermuthung NNP 13433 1039 65 um um UH 13433 1039 66 so so RB 13433 1039 67 wahrscheinlicher wahrscheinlicher NN 13433 1039 68 | | NNP 13433 1039 69 wird wird NN 13433 1039 70 . . . 13433 1040 1 Darnach Darnach NNP 13433 1040 2 scheint scheint NNP 13433 1040 3 nämlich nämlich NNP 13433 1040 4 | | NNP 13433 1040 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1040 6 nicht nicht NN 13433 1040 7 zu zu NFP 13433 1040 8 Rom Rom NNP 13433 1040 9 auf auf NN 13433 1040 10 Befehl Befehl NNP 13433 1040 11 | | NNP 13433 1040 12 des des NNP 13433 1040 13 sanftmüthigen sanftmüthigen NNP 13433 1040 14 Trajans trajan NNS 13433 1040 15 , , , 13433 1040 16 sondern sondern JJ 13433 1040 17 | | CD 13433 1040 18 zu zu NNP 13433 1040 19 Antiochia Antiochia NNP 13433 1040 20 selbst selbst NN 13433 1040 21 , , , 13433 1040 22 in in IN 13433 1040 23 Folge Folge NNP 13433 1040 24 eines eine NNS 13433 1040 25 | | CD 13433 1040 26 am be VBP 13433 1040 27 dreizehnten dreizehnten JJ 13433 1040 28 December December NNP 13433 1040 29 115 115 CD 13433 1040 30 | | CD 13433 1040 31 eingetretenen eingetretenen NN 13433 1040 32 Erdbebens Erdbebens NNP 13433 1040 33 , , , 13433 1040 34 als als NNP 13433 1040 35 Opfer Opfer NNP 13433 1040 36 | | NNP 13433 1040 37 eines eine VBZ 13433 1040 38 abergläubischen abergläubischen VBP 13433 1040 39 Volkswahns Volkswahns NNP 13433 1040 40 am be VBP 13433 1040 41 | | NNS 13433 1040 42 zwanzigsten zwanzigsten VBN 13433 1040 43 December December NNP 13433 1040 44 dieses diese VBZ 13433 1040 45 Jahres Jahres NNP 13433 1040 46 | | NNP 13433 1040 47 i -PRON- PRP 13433 1040 48 m be VBP 13433 1040 49 Amphitheater Amphitheater NNP 13433 1040 50 den den NN 13433 1040 51 wilden wilden JJ 13433 1040 52 Thieren Thieren NNP 13433 1040 53 | | NNP 13433 1040 54 zur zur NNP 13433 1040 55 Beute Beute NNP 13433 1040 56 überliefert überliefert NN 13433 1040 57 worden worden JJ 13433 1040 58 zu zu NNP 13433 1040 59 | | NNP 13433 1040 60 sein sein NNP 13433 1040 61 . . . 13433 1040 62 ' ' '' 13433 1041 1 | | NNP 13433 1041 2 | | NNP 13433 1041 3 " " '' 13433 1041 4 9 9 CD 13433 1041 5 . . . 13433 1042 1 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1042 2 , , , 13433 1042 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1042 4 Der Der NNP 13433 1042 5 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 1042 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1042 7 , , , 13433 1042 8 p. p. NN 13433 1042 9 52 52 CD 13433 1042 10 | | NNP 13433 1042 11 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1042 12 , , , 13433 1042 13 _ _ NNP 13433 1042 14 Der Der NNP 13433 1042 15 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 1042 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1042 17 , , , 13433 1042 18 p. p. NN 13433 1042 19 52 52 CD 13433 1042 20 , , , 13433 1042 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1042 22 p. p. NN 13433 1042 23 52 52 CD 13433 1042 24 ff ff NN 13433 1042 25 . . . 13433 1042 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1043 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1043 2 92:1 92:1 CD 13433 1043 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1043 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1043 5 This this DT 13433 1043 6 book book NN 13433 1043 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1043 8 | | VBD 13433 1043 9 affirms affirm VBZ 13433 1043 10 the the DT 13433 1043 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1043 12 at at IN 13433 1043 13 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1043 14 , , , 13433 1043 15 have have VBP 13433 1043 16 not not RB 13433 1043 17 been be VBN 13433 1043 18 able able JJ 13433 1043 19 to to TO 13433 1043 20 consult consult VB 13433 1043 21 , , , 13433 1043 22 but but CC 13433 1043 23 | | NNP 13433 1043 24 20th 20th NN 13433 1043 25 December December NNP 13433 1043 26 , , , 13433 1043 27 115 115 CD 13433 1043 28 . . . 13433 1043 29 from from IN 13433 1043 30 secondary secondary JJ 13433 1043 31 references reference NNS 13433 1043 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1043 33 gather gather VBP 13433 1043 34 | | NNS 13433 1043 35 that that IN 13433 1043 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1043 37 repeats repeat VBZ 13433 1043 38 the the DT 13433 1043 39 arguments argument NNS 13433 1043 40 given give VBN 13433 1043 41 | | CD 13433 1043 42 under under IN 13433 1043 43 the the DT 13433 1043 44 next next JJ 13433 1043 45 reference reference NN 13433 1043 46 . . . 13433 1043 47 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1044 1 | | NNP 13433 1044 2 | | NNP 13433 1044 3 " " '' 13433 1044 4 10 10 CD 13433 1044 5 . . . 13433 1045 1 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1045 2 , , , 13433 1045 3 Haindb Haindb NNP 13433 1045 4 . . . 13433 1046 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1046 2 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1046 3 . . . 13433 1047 1 Apocr._| Apocr._| NNP 13433 1047 2 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1047 3 . . . 13433 1048 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1048 2 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 1048 3 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1048 4 . . . 13433 1049 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 13433 1049 2 . . . 13433 1049 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1049 4 pp pp NNP 13433 1049 5 . . . 13433 1050 1 121 121 CD 13433 1050 2 f. f. NNP 13433 1050 3 , , , 13433 1050 4 136 136 CD 13433 1050 5 . . . 13433 1051 1 ' ' `` 13433 1051 2 Ein Ein NNP 13433 1051 3 Haupt Haupt NNP 13433 1051 4 der der NN 13433 1051 5 | | NNP 13433 1051 6 p. p. NN 13433 1051 7 121 121 CD 13433 1051 8 f. f. NNS 13433 1051 9 , , , 13433 1051 10 affirms affirm VBZ 13433 1051 11 the the DT 13433 1051 12 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1051 13 Gemeinde Gemeinde NNP 13433 1051 14 zu zu NNP 13433 1051 15 Antiochia Antiochia NNP 13433 1051 16 , , , 13433 1051 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1051 18 , , , 13433 1051 19 | | NNP 13433 1051 20 at at IN 13433 1051 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1051 22 , , , 13433 1051 23 20th 20th JJ 13433 1051 24 December December NNP 13433 1051 25 , , , 13433 1051 26 115 115 CD 13433 1051 27 . . . 13433 1051 28 wurde wurde NNP 13433 1051 29 , , , 13433 1051 30 während während VB 13433 1051 31 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1051 32 dortselbst dortselbst NN 13433 1051 33 | | NNP 13433 1051 34 überwinterte überwinterte NN 13433 1051 35 , , , 13433 1051 36 am be VBP 13433 1051 37 20 20 CD 13433 1051 38 . . . 13433 1052 1 December December NNP 13433 1052 2 den den NN 13433 1052 3 | | NNP 13433 1052 4 Thieren Thieren NNP 13433 1052 5 vorgeworfen vorgeworfen NN 13433 1052 6 , , , 13433 1052 7 in in IN 13433 1052 8 Folge Folge NNP 13433 1052 9 der der IN 13433 1052 10 | | CD 13433 1052 11 durch durch VBP 13433 1052 12 das das NNP 13433 1052 13 Erdbeben Erdbeben NNP 13433 1052 14 vom vom VBZ 13433 1052 15 13 13 CD 13433 1052 16 . . . 13433 1053 1 December December NNP 13433 1053 2 | | NNP 13433 1053 3 115 115 CD 13433 1053 4 gegen gegen NN 13433 1053 5 die die NN 13433 1053 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1053 7 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1053 8 : : : 13433 1053 9 atheoi atheoi NN 13433 1053 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1053 11 | | CD 13433 1053 12 erweckten erweckten VBD 13433 1053 13 Volkswuth Volkswuth NNP 13433 1053 14 , , , 13433 1053 15 ein ein NNP 13433 1053 16 Opfer Opfer NNP 13433 1053 17 | | NNP 13433 1053 18 zugleich zugleich NNP 13433 1053 19 der der NN 13433 1053 20 Siegesfeste Siegesfeste NNP 13433 1053 21 des des NNP 13433 1053 22 | | NNP 13433 1053 23 Parthicus Parthicus NNP 13433 1053 24 , , , 13433 1053 25 welche welche NN 13433 1053 26 die die NN 13433 1053 27 Judith- Judith- NNP 13433 1053 28 | | NNP 13433 1053 29 Erzählung Erzählung NNP 13433 1053 30 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1053 31 i. i. NNP 13433 1054 1 16 16 LS 13433 1054 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1054 3 andeutet andeutet NN 13433 1054 4 , , , 13433 1054 5 Dio Dio NNP 13433 1054 6 | | NNP 13433 1054 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1054 8 c. c. NNP 13433 1054 9 24 24 CD 13433 1054 10 f. f. NNP 13433 1054 11 ; ; : 13433 1054 12 vgl vgl NNP 13433 1054 13 . . . 13433 1055 1 c. c. NNP 13433 1055 2 10 10 CD 13433 1055 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1055 4 voraussetzt voraussetzt VBD 13433 1055 5 | | CD 13433 1055 6 ... ... : 13433 1055 7 ' ' '' 13433 1055 8 | | CD 13433 1055 9 | | NNP 13433 1055 10 " " '' 13433 1055 11 P. P. NNP 13433 1055 12 136 136 CD 13433 1055 13 . . . 13433 1056 1 The the DT 13433 1056 2 same same JJ 13433 1056 3 statement statement NN 13433 1056 4 is be VBZ 13433 1056 5 | | JJ 13433 1056 6 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1056 7 . . . 13433 1057 1 p. p. NN 13433 1057 2 136 136 CD 13433 1057 3 . . . 13433 1058 1 The the DT 13433 1058 2 same same JJ 13433 1058 3 repeated repeat VBN 13433 1058 4 briefly briefly NN 13433 1058 5 . . . 13433 1058 6 " " '' 13433 1059 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1059 2 93:1 93:1 CD 13433 1059 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1059 4 | | CD 13433 1059 5 statement statement NN 13433 1059 6 , , , 13433 1059 7 with with IN 13433 1059 8 fuller full JJR 13433 1059 9 | | HYPH 13433 1059 10 chronological chronological JJ 13433 1059 11 evidence evidence NN 13433 1059 12 . . . 13433 1060 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1060 2 will will MD 13433 1060 3 thus thus RB 13433 1060 4 be be VB 13433 1060 5 seen see VBN 13433 1060 6 that that IN 13433 1060 7 the the DT 13433 1060 8 whole whole NN 13433 1060 9 of of IN 13433 1060 10 these these DT 13433 1060 11 authorities authority NNS 13433 1060 12 confirm confirm VBP 13433 1060 13 the the DT 13433 1060 14 later later JJ 13433 1060 15 date date NN 13433 1060 16 assigned assign VBN 13433 1060 17 to to IN 13433 1060 18 the the DT 13433 1060 19 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1060 20 , , , 13433 1060 21 and and CC 13433 1060 22 that that IN 13433 1060 23 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1060 24 , , , 13433 1060 25 in in IN 13433 1060 26 the the DT 13433 1060 27 note note NN 13433 1060 28 in in IN 13433 1060 29 which which WDT 13433 1060 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1060 31 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1060 32 finds find VBZ 13433 1060 33 " " `` 13433 1060 34 nothing nothing NN 13433 1060 35 in in IN 13433 1060 36 any any DT 13433 1060 37 way way NN 13433 1060 38 bearing bear VBG 13433 1060 39 upon upon IN 13433 1060 40 the the DT 13433 1060 41 history history NN 13433 1060 42 except except IN 13433 1060 43 a a DT 13433 1060 44 passing pass VBG 13433 1060 45 supposition supposition NN 13433 1060 46 , , , 13433 1060 47 " " '' 13433 1060 48 really really RB 13433 1060 49 advances advance VBZ 13433 1060 50 a a DT 13433 1060 51 weighty weighty JJ 13433 1060 52 argument argument NN 13433 1060 53 for for IN 13433 1060 54 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1060 55 and and CC 13433 1060 56 against against IN 13433 1060 57 the the DT 13433 1060 58 earlier early JJR 13433 1060 59 date date NN 13433 1060 60 , , , 13433 1060 61 and and CC 13433 1060 62 as as IN 13433 1060 63 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1060 64 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1060 65 considers consider VBZ 13433 1060 66 , , , 13433 1060 67 rightly rightly RB 13433 1060 68 , , , 13433 1060 69 that that DT 13433 1060 70 argument argument NN 13433 1060 71 should should MD 13433 1060 72 decide decide VB 13433 1060 73 everything everything NN 13433 1060 74 , , , 13433 1060 75 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1060 76 am be VBP 13433 1060 77 surprised surprised JJ 13433 1060 78 that that IN 13433 1060 79 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1060 80 has have VBZ 13433 1060 81 not not RB 13433 1060 82 perceived perceive VBN 13433 1060 83 the the DT 13433 1060 84 propriety propriety NN 13433 1060 85 of of IN 13433 1060 86 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1060 87 referring referring NN 13433 1060 88 to to IN 13433 1060 89 arguments argument NNS 13433 1060 90 as as RB 13433 1060 91 well well RB 13433 1060 92 as as IN 13433 1060 93 statements statement NNS 13433 1060 94 of of IN 13433 1060 95 evidence evidence NN 13433 1060 96 . . . 13433 1061 1 To to TO 13433 1061 2 sum sum VB 13433 1061 3 up up RP 13433 1061 4 the the DT 13433 1061 5 opinions opinion NNS 13433 1061 6 expressed express VBN 13433 1061 7 , , , 13433 1061 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1061 9 may may MD 13433 1061 10 state state VB 13433 1061 11 that that IN 13433 1061 12 whilst whilst IN 13433 1061 13 all all PDT 13433 1061 14 the the DT 13433 1061 15 nine nine CD 13433 1061 16 writers writer NNS 13433 1061 17 support support VBP 13433 1061 18 the the DT 13433 1061 19 later later JJ 13433 1061 20 date date NN 13433 1061 21 , , , 13433 1061 22 for for IN 13433 1061 23 which which WDT 13433 1061 24 purpose purpose NN 13433 1061 25 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1061 26 were be VBD 13433 1061 27 quoted quote VBN 13433 1061 28 , , , 13433 1061 29 three three CD 13433 1061 30 of of IN 13433 1061 31 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1061 32 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1061 33 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 1061 34 , , , 13433 1061 35 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 1061 36 , , , 13433 1061 37 and and CC 13433 1061 38 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 13433 1061 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1061 40 ascribe ascribe VBP 13433 1061 41 the the DT 13433 1061 42 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1061 43 to to IN 13433 1061 44 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1061 45 , , , 13433 1061 46 one one CD 13433 1061 47 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1061 48 Bretschneider bretschneider NN 13433 1061 49 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1061 50 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1061 51 no no DT 13433 1061 52 place place NN 13433 1061 53 , , , 13433 1061 54 one one CD 13433 1061 55 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1061 56 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 1061 57 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1061 58 is be VBZ 13433 1061 59 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1061 60 , , , 13433 1061 61 but but CC 13433 1061 62 leans lean VBZ 13433 1061 63 to to IN 13433 1061 64 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1061 65 , , , 13433 1061 66 and and CC 13433 1061 67 the the DT 13433 1061 68 other other JJ 13433 1061 69 four four CD 13433 1061 70 declare declare NN 13433 1061 71 for for IN 13433 1061 72 the the DT 13433 1061 73 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1061 74 in in IN 13433 1061 75 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1061 76 . . . 13433 1062 1 Nothing nothing NN 13433 1062 2 , , , 13433 1062 3 however however RB 13433 1062 4 , , , 13433 1062 5 could could MD 13433 1062 6 show show VB 13433 1062 7 more more RBR 13433 1062 8 conclusively conclusively RB 13433 1062 9 the the DT 13433 1062 10 purpose purpose NN 13433 1062 11 of of IN 13433 1062 12 note note NN 13433 1062 13 3 3 CD 13433 1062 14 , , , 13433 1062 15 which which WDT 13433 1062 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1062 17 have have VBP 13433 1062 18 explained explain VBN 13433 1062 19 , , , 13433 1062 20 than than IN 13433 1062 21 this this DT 13433 1062 22 very very JJ 13433 1062 23 contradiction contradiction NN 13433 1062 24 , , , 13433 1062 25 and and CC 13433 1062 26 the the DT 13433 1062 27 fact fact NN 13433 1062 28 that that IN 13433 1062 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1062 30 claim claim VBP 13433 1062 31 for for IN 13433 1062 32 the the DT 13433 1062 33 general general JJ 13433 1062 34 statement statement NN 13433 1062 35 in in IN 13433 1062 36 the the DT 13433 1062 37 text text NN 13433 1062 38 , , , 13433 1062 39 regarding regard VBG 13433 1062 40 the the DT 13433 1062 41 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1062 42 in in IN 13433 1062 43 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1062 44 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1062 45 in in IN 13433 1062 46 opposition opposition NN 13433 1062 47 to to IN 13433 1062 48 the the DT 13433 1062 49 legend legend NN 13433 1062 50 of of IN 13433 1062 51 the the DT 13433 1062 52 journey journey NN 13433 1062 53 to to IN 13433 1062 54 and and CC 13433 1062 55 death death NN 13433 1062 56 in in IN 13433 1062 57 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1062 58 , , , 13433 1062 59 only only RB 13433 1062 60 the the DT 13433 1062 61 authorities authority NNS 13433 1062 62 in in IN 13433 1062 63 note note NN 13433 1062 64 4 4 CD 13433 1062 65 , , , 13433 1062 66 which which WDT 13433 1062 67 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1062 68 shall shall MD 13433 1062 69 now now RB 13433 1062 70 proceed proceed VB 13433 1062 71 to to TO 13433 1062 72 analyse analyse VB 13433 1062 73 in in IN 13433 1062 74 contrast contrast NN 13433 1062 75 with with IN 13433 1062 76 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1062 77 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1062 78 's 's POS 13433 1062 79 statements statement NNS 13433 1062 80 , , , 13433 1062 81 and and CC 13433 1062 82 here here RB 13433 1062 83 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1062 84 beg beg VBP 13433 1062 85 the the DT 13433 1062 86 favour favour NN 13433 1062 87 of of IN 13433 1062 88 the the DT 13433 1062 89 reader reader NN 13433 1062 90 's 's POS 13433 1062 91 attention attention NN 13433 1062 92 . . . 13433 1063 1 NOTE NOTE NNP 13433 1063 2 4 4 CD 13433 1063 3 . . . 13433 1064 1 DR DR NNP 13433 1064 2 . . . 13433 1064 3 WESTCOTT westcott NN 13433 1064 4 'S 's NN 13433 1064 5 STATEMENTS statement NNS 13433 1064 6 . . . 13433 1065 1 | | CD 13433 1065 2 THE the DT 13433 1065 3 TRUTH truth NN 13433 1065 4 . . . 13433 1066 1 | | NNP 13433 1066 2 1 1 CD 13433 1066 3 . . . 13433 1067 1 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1067 2 : : : 13433 1067 3 see see VB 13433 1067 4 above above RB 13433 1067 5 . . . 13433 1068 1 | | NNP 13433 1068 2 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1068 3 , , , 13433 1068 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1068 5 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 1068 6 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1068 7 . . . 13433 1069 1 Apocr Apocr NNP 13433 1069 2 . . . 13433 1069 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1069 4 | | NNP 13433 1069 5 i. i. NNP 13433 1069 6 pp pp NNP 13433 1069 7 . . . 13433 1070 1 121 121 CD 13433 1070 2 ff ff NNP 13433 1070 3 . . NNP 13433 1070 4 , , , 13433 1070 5 136 136 CD 13433 1070 6 f. f. NN 13433 1070 7 | | CD 13433 1070 8 | | NNS 13433 1070 9 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1070 10 will will MD 13433 1070 11 be be VB 13433 1070 12 observed observe VBN 13433 1070 13 on on IN 13433 1070 14 turning turn VBG 13433 1070 15 to to IN 13433 1070 16 | | CD 13433 1070 17 the the DT 13433 1070 18 passage passage NN 13433 1070 19 " " `` 13433 1070 20 above above RB 13433 1070 21 " " '' 13433 1070 22 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1070 23 10 10 CD 13433 1070 24 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1070 25 , , , 13433 1070 26 to to TO 13433 1070 27 which which WDT 13433 1070 28 | | NNP 13433 1070 29 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1070 30 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1070 31 refers refer VBZ 13433 1070 32 , , , 13433 1070 33 that that IN 13433 1070 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1070 35 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1070 36 | | NNP 13433 1070 37 a a DT 13433 1070 38 single single JJ 13433 1070 39 sentence sentence NN 13433 1070 40 containing contain VBG 13433 1070 41 merely merely RB 13433 1070 42 | | VBZ 13433 1070 43 a a DT 13433 1070 44 concise concise JJ 13433 1070 45 statement statement NN 13433 1070 46 of of IN 13433 1070 47 facts fact NNS 13433 1070 48 , , , 13433 1070 49 and and CC 13433 1070 50 | | CD 13433 1070 51 that that IN 13433 1070 52 no no DT 13433 1070 53 indication indication NN 13433 1070 54 is be VBZ 13433 1070 55 given give VBN 13433 1070 56 to to IN 13433 1070 57 the the DT 13433 1070 58 | | CD 13433 1070 59 reader reader NN 13433 1070 60 that that IN 13433 1070 61 there there EX 13433 1070 62 is be VBZ 13433 1070 63 anything anything NN 13433 1070 64 beyond beyond IN 13433 1070 65 | | NNP 13433 1070 66 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1070 67 . . . 13433 1071 1 At at IN 13433 1071 2 p. p. NN 13433 1071 3 136 136 CD 13433 1071 4 " " `` 13433 1071 5 the the DT 13433 1071 6 same same JJ 13433 1071 7 statement statement NN 13433 1071 8 | | NNP 13433 1071 9 is be VBZ 13433 1071 10 repeated repeat VBN 13433 1071 11 briefly briefly RB 13433 1071 12 . . . 13433 1071 13 " " '' 13433 1072 1 Now now RB 13433 1072 2 either either DT 13433 1072 3 | | NNP 13433 1072 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1072 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1072 6 , , , 13433 1072 7 whilst whilst IN 13433 1072 8 bringing bring VBG 13433 1072 9 a a DT 13433 1072 10 most most RBS 13433 1072 11 | | JJ 13433 1072 12 serious serious JJ 13433 1072 13 charge charge NN 13433 1072 14 against against IN 13433 1072 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1072 16 work work NN 13433 1072 17 , , , 13433 1072 18 based base VBN 13433 1072 19 | | CD 13433 1072 20 upon upon IN 13433 1072 21 this this DT 13433 1072 22 " " `` 13433 1072 23 one one CD 13433 1072 24 example example NN 13433 1072 25 , , , 13433 1072 26 " " '' 13433 1072 27 has have VBZ 13433 1072 28 actually actually RB 13433 1072 29 | | CD 13433 1072 30 not not RB 13433 1072 31 taken take VBN 13433 1072 32 the the DT 13433 1072 33 trouble trouble NN 13433 1072 34 to to TO 13433 1072 35 examine examine VB 13433 1072 36 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1072 37 | | NN 13433 1072 38 reference reference NN 13433 1072 39 to to IN 13433 1072 40 " " `` 13433 1072 41 pp pp NNP 13433 1072 42 . . . 13433 1073 1 121 121 CD 13433 1073 2 ff ff NNP 13433 1073 3 . . NNP 13433 1073 4 , , , 13433 1073 5 136 136 CD 13433 1073 6 f. f. NNS 13433 1073 7 , , , 13433 1073 8 " " '' 13433 1073 9 | | NNP 13433 1073 10 and and CC 13433 1073 11 p. p. NN 13433 1073 12 50 50 CD 13433 1073 13 ff ff NNP 13433 1073 14 . . NNP 13433 1073 15 , , , 13433 1073 16 to to TO 13433 1073 17 which which WDT 13433 1073 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 19 would would MD 13433 1073 20 | | VB 13433 1073 21 have have VB 13433 1073 22 found find VBN 13433 1073 23 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 24 there there RB 13433 1073 25 directed direct VBN 13433 1073 26 , , , 13433 1073 27 | | CD 13433 1073 28 or or CC 13433 1073 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 30 has have VBZ 13433 1073 31 acted act VBN 13433 1073 32 towards towards IN 13433 1073 33 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 34 with with IN 13433 1073 35 a a DT 13433 1073 36 | | CD 13433 1073 37 want want NN 13433 1073 38 of of IN 13433 1073 39 fairness fairness NN 13433 1073 40 which which WDT 13433 1073 41 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 42 venture venture VBP 13433 1073 43 to to IN 13433 1073 44 | | CD 13433 1073 45 say say VB 13433 1073 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 47 will will MD 13433 1073 48 be be VB 13433 1073 49 the the DT 13433 1073 50 first first JJ 13433 1073 51 to to TO 13433 1073 52 regret regret VB 13433 1073 53 , , , 13433 1073 54 | | CD 13433 1073 55 when when WRB 13433 1073 56 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1073 57 considers consider VBZ 13433 1073 58 the the DT 13433 1073 59 facts fact NNS 13433 1073 60 . . . 13433 1074 1 | | NNS 13433 1074 2 | | NNP 13433 1074 3 Would Would MD 13433 1074 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1074 5 be be VB 13433 1074 6 divined divine VBN 13433 1074 7 from from IN 13433 1074 8 the the DT 13433 1074 9 words word NNS 13433 1074 10 | | CD 13433 1074 11 opposite opposite NN 13433 1074 12 , , , 13433 1074 13 and and CC 13433 1074 14 the the DT 13433 1074 15 sentence sentence NN 13433 1074 16 " " '' 13433 1074 17 above above RB 13433 1074 18 , , , 13433 1074 19 " " '' 13433 1074 20 | | VBD 13433 1074 21 that that WDT 13433 1074 22 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1074 23 enters enter VBZ 13433 1074 24 into into IN 13433 1074 25 an an DT 13433 1074 26 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1074 27 | | NNP 13433 1074 28 argument argument NN 13433 1074 29 , , , 13433 1074 30 extending extend VBG 13433 1074 31 over over IN 13433 1074 32 a a DT 13433 1074 33 dozen dozen NN 13433 1074 34 | | CD 13433 1074 35 closely closely RB 13433 1074 36 printed print VBN 13433 1074 37 pages page NNS 13433 1074 38 , , , 13433 1074 39 to to TO 13433 1074 40 prove prove VB 13433 1074 41 that that IN 13433 1074 42 | | NNP 13433 1074 43 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1074 44 was be VBD 13433 1074 45 not not RB 13433 1074 46 sent send VBN 13433 1074 47 to to IN 13433 1074 48 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1074 49 at at RB 13433 1074 50 all all RB 13433 1074 51 , , , 13433 1074 52 | | NNP 13433 1074 53 but but CC 13433 1074 54 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1074 55 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1074 56 in in IN 13433 1074 57 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1074 58 | | NNP 13433 1074 59 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1074 60 on on IN 13433 1074 61 the the DT 13433 1074 62 20th 20th JJ 13433 1074 63 December December NNP 13433 1074 64 , , , 13433 1074 65 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1074 66 115 115 CD 13433 1074 67 , , , 13433 1074 68 | | NNP 13433 1074 69 probably probably RB 13433 1074 70 as as IN 13433 1074 71 a a DT 13433 1074 72 sacrifice sacrifice NN 13433 1074 73 to to IN 13433 1074 74 the the DT 13433 1074 75 | | JJ 13433 1074 76 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1074 77 fury fury NN 13433 1074 78 of of IN 13433 1074 79 the the DT 13433 1074 80 people people NNS 13433 1074 81 | | CD 13433 1074 82 against against IN 13433 1074 83 the the DT 13433 1074 84 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1074 85 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1074 86 : : : 13433 1074 87 atheoi atheoi NN 13433 1074 88 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1074 89 , , , 13433 1074 90 excited excite VBN 13433 1074 91 | | NNP 13433 1074 92 by by IN 13433 1074 93 the the DT 13433 1074 94 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1074 95 which which WDT 13433 1074 96 occurred occur VBD 13433 1074 97 on on IN 13433 1074 98 | | CD 13433 1074 99 the the DT 13433 1074 100 thirteenth thirteenth NN 13433 1074 101 of of IN 13433 1074 102 that that DT 13433 1074 103 month month NN 13433 1074 104 ? ? . 13433 1075 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1075 2 shall shall MD 13433 1075 3 | | VB 13433 1075 4 not not RB 13433 1075 5 here here RB 13433 1075 6 attempt attempt VB 13433 1075 7 to to TO 13433 1075 8 give give VB 13433 1075 9 even even RB 13433 1075 10 an an DT 13433 1075 11 | | CD 13433 1075 12 epitome epitome NN 13433 1075 13 of of IN 13433 1075 14 the the DT 13433 1075 15 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1075 16 , , , 13433 1075 17 as as IN 13433 1075 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1075 19 shall shall MD 13433 1075 20 | | NNP 13433 1075 21 presently presently RB 13433 1075 22 reproduce reproduce VB 13433 1075 23 some some DT 13433 1075 24 of of IN 13433 1075 25 the the DT 13433 1075 26 | | CD 13433 1075 27 arguments argument NNS 13433 1075 28 of of IN 13433 1075 29 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1075 30 and and CC 13433 1075 31 others other NNS 13433 1075 32 in in IN 13433 1075 33 a a DT 13433 1075 34 | | CD 13433 1075 35 more more RBR 13433 1075 36 condensed condensed JJ 13433 1075 37 and and CC 13433 1075 38 consecutive consecutive JJ 13433 1075 39 form form NN 13433 1075 40 . . . 13433 1076 1 | | NNS 13433 1076 2 | | NNP 13433 1076 3 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1076 4 . . . 13433 1077 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1077 2 Der Der NNP 13433 1077 3 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 1077 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1077 5 , , , 13433 1077 6 p. p. NN 13433 1077 7 52 52 CD 13433 1077 8 ff ff NN 13433 1077 9 . . . 13433 1078 1 | | NNP 13433 1078 2 | | NNP 13433 1078 3 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1078 4 repeats repeat VBZ 13433 1078 5 the the DT 13433 1078 6 affirmations affirmation NNS 13433 1078 7 which which WDT 13433 1078 8 | | VBZ 13433 1078 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1078 10 had have VBD 13433 1078 11 fully fully RB 13433 1078 12 argued argue VBN 13433 1078 13 in in IN 13433 1078 14 the the DT 13433 1078 15 above above JJ 13433 1078 16 | | CD 13433 1078 17 work work NN 13433 1078 18 and and CC 13433 1078 19 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 1078 20 . . . 13433 1079 1 | | NNP 13433 1079 2 2 2 CD 13433 1079 3 . . . 13433 1080 1 " " `` 13433 1080 2 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1080 3 , , , 13433 1080 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1080 5 Ursprung Ursprung NNP 13433 1080 6 d. d. NN 13433 1081 1 Episc Episc NNP 13433 1081 2 . . NNP 13433 1081 3 , , , 13433 1081 4 | | NNP 13433 1081 5 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1081 6 , , , 13433 1081 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1081 8 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 1081 9 . . . 13433 1082 1 d. d. NNP 13433 1083 1 Episc Episc NNP 13433 1083 2 . . . 13433 1083 3 , , , 13433 1083 4 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 1083 5 . . . 13433 1084 1 Tüb Tüb NNP 13433 1084 2 . . . 13433 1085 1 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 1085 2 . . . 13433 1085 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1085 4 1838 1838 CD 13433 1085 5 , , , 13433 1085 6 ii ii NNP 13433 1085 7 . . . 13433 1086 1 H. H. NNP 13433 1086 2 3 3 CD 13433 1086 3 , , , 13433 1086 4 | | NNP 13433 1086 5 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 1086 6 . . . 13433 1086 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1086 8 1838 1838 CD 13433 1086 9 , , , 13433 1086 10 H. H. NNP 13433 1086 11 3 3 CD 13433 1086 12 , , , 13433 1086 13 p. p. NN 13433 1086 14 149 149 CD 13433 1086 15 f. f. NNP 13433 1086 16 p. p. NNP 13433 1086 17 149 149 CD 13433 1086 18 f. f. NNP 13433 1086 19 | | NNP 13433 1086 20 | | NNP 13433 1086 21 " " '' 13433 1086 22 In in IN 13433 1086 23 this this DT 13433 1086 24 passage passage NN 13433 1086 25 Baur baur JJ 13433 1086 26 discusses discusse NNS 13433 1086 27 | | NNP 13433 1086 28 Baur baur JJ 13433 1086 29 enters enter NNS 13433 1086 30 into into IN 13433 1086 31 a a DT 13433 1086 32 long long JJ 13433 1086 33 and and CC 13433 1086 34 minute minute NN 13433 1086 35 generally generally RB 13433 1086 36 the the DT 13433 1086 37 historical historical JJ 13433 1086 38 | | CD 13433 1086 39 examination examination NN 13433 1086 40 of of IN 13433 1086 41 the the DT 13433 1086 42 historical historical JJ 13433 1086 43 character character NN 13433 1086 44 of of IN 13433 1086 45 the the DT 13433 1086 46 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1086 47 , , , 13433 1086 48 which which WDT 13433 1086 49 | | VBZ 13433 1086 50 character character NN 13433 1086 51 of of IN 13433 1086 52 the the DT 13433 1086 53 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1086 54 of of IN 13433 1086 55 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1086 56 considers consider VBZ 13433 1086 57 , , , 13433 1086 58 as as IN 13433 1086 59 a a DT 13433 1086 60 whole whole NN 13433 1086 61 , , , 13433 1086 62 to to TO 13433 1086 63 be be VB 13433 1086 64 | | NNP 13433 1086 65 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1086 66 , , , 13433 1086 67 and and CC 13433 1086 68 of of IN 13433 1086 69 the the DT 13433 1086 70 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1086 71 ' ' POS 13433 1086 72 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1086 73 and and CC 13433 1086 74 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1086 75 . . . 13433 1086 76 ' ' '' 13433 1087 1 To to IN 13433 1087 2 | | NNP 13433 1087 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1087 4 , , , 13433 1087 5 and and CC 13433 1087 6 pronounces pronounce VBZ 13433 1087 7 the the DT 13433 1087 8 whole whole JJ 13433 1087 9 establish establish VB 13433 1087 10 this this DT 13433 1087 11 result result NN 13433 1087 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1087 13 notices notice VBZ 13433 1087 14 | | NNPS 13433 1087 15 to to TO 13433 1087 16 be be VB 13433 1087 17 fabulous fabulous JJ 13433 1087 18 , , , 13433 1087 19 and and CC 13433 1087 20 more more RBR 13433 1087 21 especially especially RB 13433 1087 22 the the DT 13433 1087 23 relation relation NN 13433 1087 24 of of IN 13433 1087 25 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1087 26 to to IN 13433 1087 27 | | VB 13433 1087 28 the the DT 13433 1087 29 representation representation NN 13433 1087 30 of of IN 13433 1087 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1087 32 sentence sentence NN 13433 1087 33 the the DT 13433 1087 34 Empire empire NN 13433 1087 35 in in IN 13433 1087 36 the the DT 13433 1087 37 time time NN 13433 1087 38 of of IN 13433 1087 39 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1087 40 , , , 13433 1087 41 | | NNP 13433 1087 42 and and CC 13433 1087 43 martyr martyr NN 13433 1087 44 - - HYPH 13433 1087 45 journey journey NN 13433 1087 46 to to IN 13433 1087 47 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1087 48 . . . 13433 1088 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1088 2 which which WDT 13433 1088 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1088 4 regards regard VBZ 13433 1088 5 as as IN 13433 1088 6 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 13433 1088 7 | | NNP 13433 1088 8 shows show VBZ 13433 1088 9 that that IN 13433 1088 10 , , , 13433 1088 11 while while IN 13433 1088 12 isolated isolated JJ 13433 1088 13 cases case NNS 13433 1088 14 of of IN 13433 1088 15 with with IN 13433 1088 16 the the DT 13433 1088 17 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1088 18 of of IN 13433 1088 19 Ignatius;| Ignatius;| NNP 13433 1088 20 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1088 21 to to IN 13433 1088 22 death death NN 13433 1088 23 , , , 13433 1088 24 under under IN 13433 1088 25 and and CC 13433 1088 26 the the DT 13433 1088 27 improbable improbable JJ 13433 1088 28 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1088 29 | | CD 13433 1088 30 occurred occur VBD 13433 1088 31 during during IN 13433 1088 32 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1088 33 's 's POS 13433 1088 34 reign reign NN 13433 1088 35 may may NN 13433 1088 36 of of IN 13433 1088 37 the the DT 13433 1088 38 journey journey NN 13433 1088 39 . . . 13433 1089 1 The the DT 13433 1089 2 personal personal JJ 13433 1089 3 | | CD 13433 1089 4 justify justify VBP 13433 1089 5 the the DT 13433 1089 6 mere mere JJ 13433 1089 7 tradition tradition NN 13433 1089 8 that that WDT 13433 1089 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1089 10 characteristics characteristic VBZ 13433 1089 11 , , , 13433 1089 12 the the DT 13433 1089 13 letters letter NNS 13433 1089 14 , , , 13433 1089 15 the the DT 13433 1089 16 | | CD 13433 1089 17 suffered suffer VBN 13433 1089 18 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1089 19 , , , 13433 1089 20 there there EX 13433 1089 21 is be VBZ 13433 1089 22 no no DT 13433 1089 23 history history NN 13433 1089 24 of of IN 13433 1089 25 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1089 26 , , , 13433 1089 27 are be VBP 13433 1089 28 , , , 13433 1089 29 in in IN 13433 1089 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1089 31 | | CD 13433 1089 32 instance instance NN 13433 1089 33 recorded record VBN 13433 1089 34 in in IN 13433 1089 35 which which WDT 13433 1089 36 a a DT 13433 1089 37 opinion opinion NN 13433 1089 38 , , , 13433 1089 39 all all PDT 13433 1089 40 a a DT 13433 1089 41 mere mere JJ 13433 1089 42 creation creation NN 13433 1089 43 of of IN 13433 1089 44 | | JJ 13433 1089 45 Christian Christian NNP 13433 1089 46 was be VBD 13433 1089 47 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1089 48 to to TO 13433 1089 49 be be VB 13433 1089 50 sent send VBN 13433 1089 51 the the DT 13433 1089 52 imagination imagination NN 13433 1089 53 . . . 13433 1090 1 The the DT 13433 1090 2 utmost utmost NN 13433 1090 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1090 4 | | VBD 13433 1090 5 to to IN 13433 1090 6 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1090 7 to to TO 13433 1090 8 be be VB 13433 1090 9 cast cast VBN 13433 1090 10 to to IN 13433 1090 11 the the DT 13433 1090 12 beasts beast NNS 13433 1090 13 ; ; : 13433 1090 14 allows allows NNP 13433 1090 15 is be VBZ 13433 1090 16 that that IN 13433 1090 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1090 18 may may MD 13433 1090 19 have have VB 13433 1090 20 | | CD 13433 1090 21 that that IN 13433 1090 22 such such PDT 13433 1090 23 a a DT 13433 1090 24 sentence sentence NN 13433 1090 25 is be VBZ 13433 1090 26 opposed oppose VBN 13433 1090 27 to to IN 13433 1090 28 suffered suffer VBN 13433 1090 29 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1090 30 . . . 13433 1090 31 " " '' 13433 1091 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1091 2 P. P. NNP 13433 1092 1 169 169 CD 13433 1092 2 . . . 13433 1092 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1093 1 | | VB 13433 1093 2 all all DT 13433 1093 3 historical historical JJ 13433 1093 4 data datum NNS 13433 1093 5 of of IN 13433 1093 6 the the DT 13433 1093 7 reign reign NN 13433 1093 8 of of IN 13433 1093 9 | | NNP 13433 1093 10 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1093 11 , , , 13433 1093 12 and and CC 13433 1093 13 to to IN 13433 1093 14 all all DT 13433 1093 15 that that WDT 13433 1093 16 is be VBZ 13433 1093 17 known know VBN 13433 1093 18 of of IN 13433 1093 19 | | CD 13433 1093 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1093 21 character character NN 13433 1093 22 and and CC 13433 1093 23 principles principle NNS 13433 1093 24 ; ; : 13433 1093 25 and and CC 13433 1093 26 | | CD 13433 1093 27 that that IN 13433 1093 28 the the DT 13433 1093 29 whole whole NN 13433 1093 30 of of IN 13433 1093 31 the the DT 13433 1093 32 statements statement NNS 13433 1093 33 | | CD 13433 1093 34 regarding regard VBG 13433 1093 35 the the DT 13433 1093 36 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1093 37 journey journey NN 13433 1093 38 | | NNP 13433 1093 39 directly directly RB 13433 1093 40 discredit discredit VBP 13433 1093 41 the the DT 13433 1093 42 story story NN 13433 1093 43 . . . 13433 1094 1 The the DT 13433 1094 2 | | CD 13433 1094 3 argument argument NN 13433 1094 4 is be VBZ 13433 1094 5 much much RB 13433 1094 6 too too RB 13433 1094 7 long long JJ 13433 1094 8 and and CC 13433 1094 9 | | CD 13433 1094 10 elaborate elaborate VBP 13433 1094 11 to to TO 13433 1094 12 reproduce reproduce VB 13433 1094 13 here here RB 13433 1094 14 , , , 13433 1094 15 but but CC 13433 1094 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1094 17 | | VBD 13433 1094 18 shall shall MD 13433 1094 19 presently presently RB 13433 1094 20 make make VB 13433 1094 21 use use NN 13433 1094 22 of of IN 13433 1094 23 some some DT 13433 1094 24 | | JJ 13433 1094 25 parts part NNS 13433 1094 26 of of IN 13433 1094 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1094 28 . . . 13433 1095 1 | | NNP 13433 1095 2 " " `` 13433 1095 3 3 3 CD 13433 1095 4 . . . 13433 1096 1 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1096 2 , , , 13433 1096 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1096 4 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 1096 5 . . . 13433 1097 1 chr chr NNP 13433 1097 2 . . . 13433 1098 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 1098 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1098 3 , , , 13433 1098 4 | | NNP 13433 1098 5 " " `` 13433 1098 6 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1098 7 . . . 13433 1098 8 , , , 13433 1098 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1098 10 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 1098 11 . . . 13433 1099 1 chr chr NNP 13433 1099 2 . . . 13433 1100 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 1100 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1100 3 , , , 13433 1100 4 1863 1863 CD 13433 1100 5 , , , 13433 1100 6 1863 1863 CD 13433 1100 7 , , , 13433 1100 8 i. i. NNP 13433 1100 9 p. p. NN 13433 1100 10 440 440 CD 13433 1100 11 , , , 13433 1100 12 Anm anm CC 13433 1100 13 . . . 13433 1101 1 1 1 LS 13433 1101 2 . . . 13433 1102 1 | | NNP 13433 1102 2 i. i. NNP 13433 1102 3 p. p. NN 13433 1102 4 440 440 CD 13433 1102 5 , , , 13433 1102 6 Anm anm CC 13433 1102 7 . . . 13433 1103 1 1 1 LS 13433 1103 2 . . . 13433 1104 1 | | LS 13433 1104 2 " " `` 13433 1104 3 ' ' `` 13433 1104 4 Die Die NNP 13433 1104 5 Verurtheilung Verurtheilung NNP 13433 1104 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1104 7 ad ad NN 13433 1104 8 bestias bestia NNS 13433 1104 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1104 10 | | NNP 13433 1104 11 " " `` 13433 1104 12 The the DT 13433 1104 13 reality reality NN 13433 1104 14 is be VBZ 13433 1104 15 ' ' `` 13433 1104 16 wohl wohl NN 13433 1104 17 nur nur NN 13433 1104 18 ' ' '' 13433 1104 19 that that IN 13433 1104 20 in in IN 13433 1104 21 und und JJ 13433 1104 22 die die NN 13433 1104 23 Abführung Abführung NNP 13433 1104 24 dazu dazu VBZ 13433 1104 25 nach nach RB 13433 1104 26 Rom Rom NNP 13433 1104 27 | | NNP 13433 1104 28 the the DT 13433 1104 29 year year NN 13433 1104 30 115 115 CD 13433 1104 31 , , , 13433 1104 32 when when WRB 13433 1104 33 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1104 34 wintered winter VBD 13433 1104 35 ... ... : 13433 1104 36 mag mag JJ 13433 1104 37 auch auch NN 13433 1104 38 unter unter NN 13433 1104 39 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1104 40 nichts nicht NNS 13433 1104 41 | | NNP 13433 1104 42 in in IN 13433 1104 43 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1104 44 , , , 13433 1104 45 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1104 46 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1104 47 zu zu NNP 13433 1104 48 ungewöhnliches ungewöhnliche NNS 13433 1104 49 gewesen gewesen NNP 13433 1104 50 sein sein NNP 13433 1104 51 , , , 13433 1104 52 | | NNP 13433 1104 53 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1104 54 in in IN 13433 1104 55 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1104 56 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1104 57 , , , 13433 1104 58 as as IN 13433 1104 59 a a DT 13433 1104 60 aber aber NN 13433 1104 61 ... ... : 13433 1104 62 bleibt bleibt NN 13433 1104 63 ie ie NNP 13433 1104 64 Geschichte Geschichte NNP 13433 1104 65 | | NNP 13433 1104 66 sacrifice sacrifice NN 13433 1104 67 to to IN 13433 1104 68 popular popular JJ 13433 1104 69 fury fury NN 13433 1104 70 seines seine NNS 13433 1104 71 Märtyrerthums Märtyrerthums NNPS 13433 1104 72 auch auch VBP 13433 1104 73 nach nach NN 13433 1104 74 | | HYPH 13433 1104 75 consequent consequent NN 13433 1104 76 on on IN 13433 1104 77 the the DT 13433 1104 78 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1104 79 of of IN 13433 1104 80 der der NNP 13433 1104 81 Vertheidigung Vertheidigung NNP 13433 1104 82 derselben derselben NN 13433 1104 83 von von NNP 13433 1104 84 | | NNP 13433 1104 85 that that DT 13433 1104 86 year year NN 13433 1104 87 . . . 13433 1105 1 The the DT 13433 1105 2 rest rest NN 13433 1105 3 was be VBD 13433 1105 4 developed develop VBN 13433 1105 5 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 1105 6 ... ... : 13433 1105 7 höchst höchst NNP 13433 1105 8 | | NNP 13433 1105 9 out out IN 13433 1105 10 of of IN 13433 1105 11 the the DT 13433 1105 12 reference reference NN 13433 1105 13 to to IN 13433 1105 14 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1105 15 for for IN 13433 1105 16 unwahrscheinlich unwahrscheinlich NN 13433 1105 17 . . . 13433 1106 1 Das Das NNP 13433 1106 2 Factische Factische NNP 13433 1106 3 | | VBD 13433 1106 4 the the DT 13433 1106 5 glorification glorification NN 13433 1106 6 of of IN 13433 1106 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1106 8 . . . 13433 1106 9 " " '' 13433 1107 1 ist ist NNP 13433 1107 2 wohl wohl NNP 13433 1107 3 nur nur NNP 13433 1107 4 dass dass NNP 13433 1107 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1107 6 i -PRON- PRP 13433 1107 7 m be VBP 13433 1107 8 J. J. NNP 13433 1108 1 | | NNP 13433 1108 2 115 115 CD 13433 1108 3 , , , 13433 1108 4 als als NNP 13433 1108 5 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1108 6 in in IN 13433 1108 7 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 13433 1108 8 | | NNP 13433 1108 9 überwinterte überwinterte NNP 13433 1108 10 , , , 13433 1108 11 in in IN 13433 1108 12 Folge Folge NNP 13433 1108 13 des des FW 13433 1108 14 | | NNP 13433 1108 15 Erdbebens Erdbebens NNP 13433 1108 16 in in IN 13433 1108 17 diesem diesem JJ 13433 1108 18 Jahr Jahr NNPS 13433 1108 19 , , , 13433 1108 20 in in IN 13433 1108 21 | | CD 13433 1108 22 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 13433 1108 23 selbst selbst NN 13433 1108 24 als als NN 13433 1108 25 ein ein NNP 13433 1108 26 Opfer Opfer NNP 13433 1108 27 | | NNP 13433 1108 28 der der NN 13433 1108 29 Volkswuth Volkswuth NNP 13433 1108 30 zum zum NNP 13433 1108 31 Märtyrer Märtyrer NNP 13433 1108 32 | | NNP 13433 1108 33 wurde wurde NNP 13433 1108 34 . . . 13433 1108 35 ' ' '' 13433 1109 1 | | CD 13433 1109 2 | | CD 13433 1109 3 4 4 CD 13433 1109 4 . . . 13433 1110 1 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 1110 2 : : : 13433 1110 3 see see VB 13433 1110 4 above above RB 13433 1110 5 . . . 13433 1111 1 | | NNP 13433 1111 2 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 1111 3 , , , 13433 1111 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1111 5 Introd Introd NNP 13433 1111 6 . . . 13433 1112 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1112 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1112 3 , , , 13433 1112 4 p. p. NN 13433 1112 5 19 19 CD 13433 1112 6 . . . 13433 1113 1 | | CD 13433 1113 2 | | NNP 13433 1113 3 " " '' 13433 1113 4 All all DT 13433 1113 5 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1113 6 the the DT 13433 1113 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1113 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1113 9 are be VBP 13433 1113 10 posterior posterior RB 13433 1113 11 | | CD 13433 1113 12 to to IN 13433 1113 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1113 14 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1113 15 , , , 13433 1113 16 who who WP 13433 1113 17 was be VBD 13433 1113 18 not not RB 13433 1113 19 | | VBN 13433 1113 20 thrown throw VBN 13433 1113 21 to to IN 13433 1113 22 the the DT 13433 1113 23 wild wild JJ 13433 1113 24 beasts beast NNS 13433 1113 25 in in IN 13433 1113 26 the the DT 13433 1113 27 | | NNP 13433 1113 28 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1113 29 at at IN 13433 1113 30 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1113 31 by by IN 13433 1113 32 command command NN 13433 1113 33 of of IN 13433 1113 34 | | NNP 13433 1113 35 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1113 36 , , , 13433 1113 37 but but CC 13433 1113 38 at at IN 13433 1113 39 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1113 40 , , , 13433 1113 41 on on IN 13433 1113 42 December December NNP 13433 1113 43 | | NNP 13433 1113 44 20th 20th NN 13433 1113 45 , , , 13433 1113 46 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1114 1 115 115 CD 13433 1114 2 . . . 13433 1114 3 " " '' 13433 1115 1 | | NNP 13433 1115 2 5 5 CD 13433 1115 3 . . . 13433 1116 1 Scholten scholten NN 13433 1116 2 : : : 13433 1116 3 see see VB 13433 1116 4 above above RB 13433 1116 5 . . . 13433 1117 1 | | NNP 13433 1117 2 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1117 3 , , , 13433 1117 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1117 5 Die Die NNP 13433 1117 6 ält ält NNP 13433 1117 7 . . . 13433 1118 1 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 1118 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1118 3 , , , 13433 1118 4 | | NNP 13433 1118 5 p. p. NN 13433 1118 6 51 51 CD 13433 1118 7 f. f. NNS 13433 1118 8 The the DT 13433 1118 9 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1118 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1118 11 are be VBP 13433 1118 12 | | VBN 13433 1118 13 declared declare VBN 13433 1118 14 to to TO 13433 1118 15 be be VB 13433 1118 16 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1118 17 for for IN 13433 1118 18 various various JJ 13433 1118 19 | | NNP 13433 1118 20 reasons reason NNS 13433 1118 21 , , , 13433 1118 22 but but CC 13433 1118 23 partly partly RB 13433 1118 24 " " '' 13433 1118 25 because because IN 13433 1118 26 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1118 27 | | MD 13433 1118 28 mention mention VBP 13433 1118 29 a a DT 13433 1118 30 martyr martyr NN 13433 1118 31 - - HYPH 13433 1118 32 journey journey NN 13433 1118 33 of of IN 13433 1118 34 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1118 35 | | NNP 13433 1118 36 to to IN 13433 1118 37 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1118 38 , , , 13433 1118 39 the the DT 13433 1118 40 unhistorical unhistorical JJ 13433 1118 41 character character NN 13433 1118 42 | | NNP 13433 1118 43 of of IN 13433 1118 44 which which WDT 13433 1118 45 , , , 13433 1118 46 already already RB 13433 1118 47 earlier early RBR 13433 1118 48 recognised recognise VBN 13433 1118 49 | | CD 13433 1118 50 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1118 51 see see VB 13433 1118 52 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1118 53 , , , 13433 1118 54 _ _ NNP 13433 1118 55 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 1118 56 . . . 13433 1119 1 des des NNP 13433 1119 2 Episc Episc NNP 13433 1119 3 . . . 13433 1119 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1119 5 1838 1838 CD 13433 1119 6 , , , 13433 1119 7 | | NNP 13433 1119 8 p. p. NN 13433 1119 9 147 147 CD 13433 1119 10 ff ff NNP 13433 1119 11 . . NNP 13433 1119 12 , , , 13433 1119 13 _ _ NNP 13433 1119 14 Die Die NNP 13433 1119 15 Ign Ign NNP 13433 1119 16 . . . 13433 1120 1 Briefe Briefe NNP 13433 1120 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1120 3 , , , 13433 1120 4 1848 1848 CD 13433 1120 5 ; ; : 13433 1120 6 | | NNP 13433 1120 7 Schwegler Schwegler NNP 13433 1120 8 , , , 13433 1120 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1120 10 Nachap Nachap NNP 13433 1120 11 . . . 13433 1121 1 Zeitalt Zeitalt NNP 13433 1121 2 . . . 13433 1121 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1121 4 ii ii NNP 13433 1121 5 . . . 13433 1122 1 | | NNP 13433 1122 2 p. p. NN 13433 1122 3 159 159 CD 13433 1122 4 ff ff NN 13433 1122 5 . . . 13433 1123 1 ; ; : 13433 1123 2 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1123 3 , , , 13433 1123 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1123 5 Apost Apost NNP 13433 1123 6 . . . 13433 1124 1 | | NNP 13433 1124 2 Väter Väter NNP 13433 1124 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1124 4 , , , 13433 1124 5 p. p. NN 13433 1124 6 210 210 CD 13433 1124 7 ff ff NN 13433 1124 8 . . . 13433 1125 1 ; ; : 13433 1125 2 Réville Réville NNP 13433 1125 3 , , , 13433 1125 4 | | NNP 13433 1125 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1125 6 Le Le NNP 13433 1125 7 Lien Lien NNP 13433 1125 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1125 9 , , , 13433 1125 10 1856 1856 CD 13433 1125 11 , , , 13433 1125 12 Nos Nos NNP 13433 1125 13 . . . 13433 1126 1 18 18 CD 13433 1126 2 - - SYM 13433 1126 3 22 22 CD 13433 1126 4 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1126 5 , , , 13433 1126 6 is be VBZ 13433 1126 7 | | CD 13433 1126 8 made make VBD 13433 1126 9 all all PDT 13433 1126 10 the the DT 13433 1126 11 more more RBR 13433 1126 12 probable probable JJ 13433 1126 13 by by IN 13433 1126 14 | | NNP 13433 1126 15 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1126 16 's 's POS 13433 1126 17 not not RB 13433 1126 18 groundless groundless JJ 13433 1126 19 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1126 20 . . . 13433 1127 1 | | NNP 13433 1127 2 According accord VBG 13433 1127 3 to to IN 13433 1127 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1127 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1127 6 is be VBZ 13433 1127 7 reported report VBN 13433 1127 8 | | CD 13433 1127 9 to to TO 13433 1127 10 have have VB 13433 1127 11 become become VBN 13433 1127 12 the the DT 13433 1127 13 prey prey NN 13433 1127 14 of of IN 13433 1127 15 wild wild JJ 13433 1127 16 beasts beast NNS 13433 1127 17 | | NNP 13433 1127 18 on on IN 13433 1127 19 the the DT 13433 1127 20 20th 20th JJ 13433 1127 21 December December NNP 13433 1127 22 , , , 13433 1127 23 115 115 CD 13433 1127 24 , , , 13433 1127 25 not not RB 13433 1127 26 in in IN 13433 1127 27 the the DT 13433 1127 28 | | NNP 13433 1127 29 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1127 30 in in IN 13433 1127 31 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1127 32 by by IN 13433 1127 33 the the DT 13433 1127 34 order order NN 13433 1127 35 of of IN 13433 1127 36 | | CD 13433 1127 37 the the DT 13433 1127 38 mild mild JJ 13433 1127 39 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1127 40 , , , 13433 1127 41 but but CC 13433 1127 42 in in IN 13433 1127 43 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1127 44 | | NNP 13433 1127 45 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1127 46 , , , 13433 1127 47 as as IN 13433 1127 48 the the DT 13433 1127 49 victim victim NN 13433 1127 50 of of IN 13433 1127 51 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1127 52 | | JJ 13433 1127 53 popular popular JJ 13433 1127 54 fury fury NN 13433 1127 55 consequent consequent NN 13433 1127 56 on on IN 13433 1127 57 an an DT 13433 1127 58 | | NNP 13433 1127 59 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1127 60 which which WDT 13433 1127 61 occurred occur VBD 13433 1127 62 on on IN 13433 1127 63 the the DT 13433 1127 64 | | NNP 13433 1127 65 13th 13th NN 13433 1127 66 December December NNP 13433 1127 67 of of IN 13433 1127 68 that that DT 13433 1127 69 year year NN 13433 1127 70 . . . 13433 1127 71 " " '' 13433 1128 1 | | NNP 13433 1128 2 6 6 CD 13433 1128 3 . . . 13433 1129 1 " " `` 13433 1129 2 Francke Francke NNP 13433 1129 3 , , , 13433 1129 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1129 5 Zur Zur NNP 13433 1129 6 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 1129 7 . . . 13433 1130 1 | | NNP 13433 1130 2 " " `` 13433 1130 3 Cf Cf NNP 13433 1130 4 . . . 13433 1131 1 Francke Francke NNP 13433 1131 2 , , , 13433 1131 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1131 4 Zur Zur NNP 13433 1131 5 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 1131 6 . . . 13433 1132 1 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1132 2 's 's POS 13433 1132 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1132 4 , , , 13433 1132 5 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1132 6 's 's POS 13433 1132 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1132 8 , , , 13433 1132 9 1840 1840 CD 13433 1132 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1132 11 1837 1837 CD 13433 1132 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1132 13 , , , 13433 1132 14 p. p. NN 13433 1132 15 253 253 CD 13433 1132 16 f. f. NNP 13433 1132 17 | | NNP 13433 1132 18 1840 1840 CD 13433 1132 19 . . . 13433 1133 1 This this DT 13433 1133 2 is be VBZ 13433 1133 3 a a DT 13433 1133 4 mere mere JJ 13433 1133 5 comparative comparative NN 13433 1133 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1133 7 A a DT 13433 1133 8 discussion discussion NN 13433 1133 9 of of IN 13433 1133 10 the the DT 13433 1133 11 date date NN 13433 1133 12 of of IN 13433 1133 13 the the DT 13433 1133 14 | | JJ 13433 1133 15 reference reference NN 13433 1133 16 to to TO 13433 1133 17 establish establish VB 13433 1133 18 the the DT 13433 1133 19 important important JJ 13433 1133 20 beginning beginning NN 13433 1133 21 of of IN 13433 1133 22 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1133 23 's 's POS 13433 1133 24 Parthian parthian JJ 13433 1133 25 | | CD 13433 1133 26 point point NN 13433 1133 27 of of IN 13433 1133 28 the the DT 13433 1133 29 date date NN 13433 1133 30 of of IN 13433 1133 31 the the DT 13433 1133 32 Parthian parthian JJ 13433 1133 33 war war NN 13433 1133 34 , , , 13433 1133 35 which which WDT 13433 1133 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1133 37 fixes fix VBZ 13433 1133 38 in in IN 13433 1133 39 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1133 40 115 115 CD 13433 1133 41 , , , 13433 1133 42 | | CD 13433 1133 43 war war NN 13433 1133 44 and and CC 13433 1133 45 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1133 46 's 's POS 13433 1133 47 visit visit NN 13433 1133 48 to to IN 13433 1133 49 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1133 50 . . . 13433 1134 1 but but CC 13433 1134 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1134 3 decides decide VBZ 13433 1134 4 nothing nothing NN 13433 1134 5 directly directly RB 13433 1134 6 | | VBZ 13433 1134 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1134 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1134 9 omits omit VBZ 13433 1134 10 the the DT 13433 1134 11 " " `` 13433 1134 12 Cf Cf NNP 13433 1134 13 . . . 13433 1134 14 " " '' 13433 1135 1 as as IN 13433 1135 2 to to IN 13433 1135 3 the the DT 13433 1135 4 time time NN 13433 1135 5 of of IN 13433 1135 6 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1135 7 ' ' POS 13433 1135 8 | | NNP 13433 1135 9 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1135 10 . . . 13433 1135 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1136 1 | | NNP 13433 1136 2 | | CD 13433 1136 3 7 7 CD 13433 1136 4 . . . 13433 1137 1 " " `` 13433 1137 2 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1137 3 , , , 13433 1137 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1137 5 Die Die NNP 13433 1137 6 ap ap NNP 13433 1137 7 . . . 13433 1138 1 Väter Väter NNP 13433 1138 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1138 3 , , , 13433 1138 4 | | NNP 13433 1138 5 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1138 6 , , , 13433 1138 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1138 8 Die Die NNP 13433 1138 9 ap ap NNP 13433 1138 10 . . . 13433 1139 1 Väter Väter NNP 13433 1139 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1139 3 , , , 13433 1139 4 p. p. NN 13433 1139 5 214 214 CD 13433 1139 6 ff ff NNP 13433 1139 7 . . . 13433 1140 1 p. p. NN 13433 1140 2 214 214 CD 13433 1140 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1140 4 pp pp NNP 13433 1140 5 . . . 13433 1141 1 210 210 CD 13433 1141 2 ff ff NNP 13433 1141 3 . . . 13433 1141 4 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1142 1 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1142 2 | | NNP 13433 1142 3 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1142 4 strongly strongly RB 13433 1142 5 supports support VBZ 13433 1142 6 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1142 7 's 's POS 13433 1142 8 points point NNS 13433 1142 9 out out RP 13433 1142 10 the the DT 13433 1142 11 objections objection NNS 13433 1142 12 to to IN 13433 1142 13 the the DT 13433 1142 14 | | NNP 13433 1142 15 argument argument NN 13433 1142 16 which which WDT 13433 1142 17 is be VBZ 13433 1142 18 referred refer VBN 13433 1142 19 to to IN 13433 1142 20 narrative narrative NN 13433 1142 21 in in IN 13433 1142 22 the the DT 13433 1142 23 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1142 24 of of IN 13433 1142 25 the the DT 13433 1142 26 | | NNP 13433 1142 27 above above RB 13433 1142 28 , , , 13433 1142 29 and and CC 13433 1142 30 while while IN 13433 1142 31 declaring declare VBG 13433 1142 32 the the DT 13433 1142 33 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 1142 34 , , , 13433 1142 35 the the DT 13433 1142 36 origin origin NN 13433 1142 37 of of IN 13433 1142 38 which which WDT 13433 1142 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1142 40 | | VBD 13433 1142 41 whole whole JJ 13433 1142 42 story story NN 13433 1142 43 of of IN 13433 1142 44 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1142 45 , , , 13433 1142 46 and and CC 13433 1142 47 more more JJR 13433 1142 48 refers refer NNS 13433 1142 49 to to IN 13433 1142 50 the the DT 13433 1142 51 period period NN 13433 1142 52 between between IN 13433 1142 53 | | CD 13433 1142 54 especially especially RB 13433 1142 55 the the DT 13433 1142 56 journey journey NN 13433 1142 57 to to IN 13433 1142 58 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1142 59 , , , 13433 1142 60 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1142 61 and and CC 13433 1142 62 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 1142 63 : : : 13433 1142 64 setting set VBG 13433 1142 65 | | JJ 13433 1142 66 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1142 67 , , , 13433 1142 68 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1142 69 considers consider VBZ 13433 1142 70 the the DT 13433 1142 71 mere mere JJ 13433 1142 72 aside aside RB 13433 1142 73 this this DT 13433 1142 74 detailed detailed JJ 13433 1142 75 narrative narrative NN 13433 1142 76 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1142 77 | | CD 13433 1142 78 fact fact NN 13433 1142 79 that that IN 13433 1142 80 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1142 81 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1142 82 considers consider VBZ 13433 1142 83 the the DT 13433 1142 84 historical historical JJ 13433 1142 85 character| character| NNP 13433 1142 86 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1142 87 the the DT 13433 1142 88 only only JJ 13433 1142 89 point point NN 13433 1142 90 regarding regard VBG 13433 1142 91 of of IN 13433 1142 92 the the DT 13433 1142 93 general general JJ 13433 1142 94 statements statement NNS 13433 1142 95 in in IN 13433 1142 96 the the DT 13433 1142 97 | | NNP 13433 1142 98 which which WDT 13433 1142 99 the the DT 13433 1142 100 possibility possibility NN 13433 1142 101 has have VBZ 13433 1142 102 been be VBN 13433 1142 103 made make VBN 13433 1142 104 letters letter NNS 13433 1142 105 . . . 13433 1143 1 The the DT 13433 1143 2 mode mode NN 13433 1143 3 of of IN 13433 1143 4 punishment punishment NN 13433 1143 5 | | VBN 13433 1143 6 out out RP 13433 1143 7 . . . 13433 1144 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1144 2 shows show VBZ 13433 1144 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1144 4 97:1 97:1 CD 13433 1144 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1144 6 that that IN 13433 1144 7 the the DT 13433 1144 8 by by IN 13433 1144 9 a a DT 13433 1144 10 provincial provincial JJ 13433 1144 11 governor governor NN 13433 1144 12 causes cause VBZ 13433 1144 13 | | NNP 13433 1144 14 martyrology martyrology NN 13433 1144 15 states state VBZ 13433 1144 16 the the DT 13433 1144 17 20th 20th NN 13433 1144 18 some some DT 13433 1144 19 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 1144 20 : : : 13433 1144 21 ' ' '' 13433 1144 22 bedenklicher bedenklicher NN 13433 1144 23 , , , 13433 1144 24 ' ' '' 13433 1144 25 | | NNP 13433 1144 26 December December NNP 13433 1144 27 as as IN 13433 1144 28 the the DT 13433 1144 29 day day NN 13433 1144 30 of of IN 13433 1144 31 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1144 32 ' ' '' 13433 1144 33 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1144 34 continues continue VBZ 13433 1144 35 , , , 13433 1144 36 ' ' '' 13433 1144 37 ist ist NNP 13433 1144 38 jedenfalls jedenfall NNS 13433 1144 39 der der NNP 13433 1144 40 | | CD 13433 1144 41 death death NN 13433 1144 42 , , , 13433 1144 43 and and CC 13433 1144 44 that that IN 13433 1144 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1144 46 remains remain NNS 13433 1144 47 were be VBD 13433 1144 48 andre andre VBG 13433 1144 49 Punct Punct NNP 13433 1144 50 , , , 13433 1144 51 die die VBP 13433 1144 52 Versendung Versendung NNP 13433 1144 53 nach nach RB 13433 1144 54 | | VBN 13433 1144 55 buried bury VBN 13433 1144 56 at at IN 13433 1144 57 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1144 58 , , , 13433 1144 59 where where WRB 13433 1144 60 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1144 61 still still RB 13433 1144 62 Rom rom VBP 13433 1144 63 . . . 13433 1144 64 ' ' '' 13433 1145 1 Why why WRB 13433 1145 2 was be VBD 13433 1145 3 the the DT 13433 1145 4 punishment punishment NN 13433 1145 5 not not RB 13433 1145 6 | | NNS 13433 1145 7 were be VBD 13433 1145 8 in in IN 13433 1145 9 the the DT 13433 1145 10 days day NNS 13433 1145 11 of of IN 13433 1145 12 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 1145 13 and and CC 13433 1145 14 carried carry VBD 13433 1145 15 out out RP 13433 1145 16 at at IN 13433 1145 17 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1145 18 ? ? . 13433 1146 1 Would Would MD 13433 1146 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1146 3 | | VB 13433 1146 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 1146 5 . . . 13433 1147 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1147 2 argues argue VBZ 13433 1147 3 from from IN 13433 1147 4 all all DT 13433 1147 5 that that WDT 13433 1147 6 is be VBZ 13433 1147 7 be be VB 13433 1147 8 likely likely JJ 13433 1147 9 that that IN 13433 1147 10 under under IN 13433 1147 11 an an DT 13433 1147 12 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1147 13 | | CD 13433 1147 14 known know VBN 13433 1147 15 of of IN 13433 1147 16 the the DT 13433 1147 17 reign reign NN 13433 1147 18 and and CC 13433 1147 19 character character NN 13433 1147 20 of of IN 13433 1147 21 like like IN 13433 1147 22 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1147 23 a a DT 13433 1147 24 prisoner prisoner NN 13433 1147 25 like like IN 13433 1147 26 | | NNP 13433 1147 27 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1147 28 , , , 13433 1147 29 that that IN 13433 1147 30 such such PDT 13433 1147 31 a a DT 13433 1147 32 sentence sentence NN 13433 1147 33 from from IN 13433 1147 34 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1147 35 would would MD 13433 1147 36 be be VB 13433 1147 37 sent send VBN 13433 1147 38 to to IN 13433 1147 39 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1147 40 to to IN 13433 1147 41 | | CD 13433 1147 42 the the DT 13433 1147 43 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1147 44 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1147 45 is be VBZ 13433 1147 46 quite quite RB 13433 1147 47 fight fight JJ 13433 1147 48 in in IN 13433 1147 49 the the DT 13433 1147 50 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1147 51 ? ? . 13433 1148 1 The the DT 13433 1148 2 | | CD 13433 1148 3 unsupported unsupported JJ 13433 1148 4 and and CC 13433 1148 5 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 13433 1148 6 . . . 13433 1149 1 A a DT 13433 1149 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1149 3 of of IN 13433 1149 4 the the DT 13433 1149 5 journey journey NN 13433 1149 6 as as IN 13433 1149 7 | | CD 13433 1149 8 provincial provincial JJ 13433 1149 9 Governor Governor NNP 13433 1149 10 might may MD 13433 1149 11 have have VB 13433 1149 12 described describe VBN 13433 1149 13 are be VBP 13433 1149 14 most most RBS 13433 1149 15 improbable improbable JJ 13433 1149 16 . . . 13433 1150 1 | | NNP 13433 1150 2 condemned condemn VBD 13433 1150 3 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1150 4 ad ad NN 13433 1150 5 bestias bestia NNS 13433 1150 6 , , , 13433 1150 7 but but CC 13433 1150 8 in in IN 13433 1150 9 The the DT 13433 1150 10 account account NN 13433 1150 11 of of IN 13433 1150 12 the the DT 13433 1150 13 persecution persecution NN 13433 1150 14 | | CD 13433 1150 15 any any DT 13433 1150 16 case case NN 13433 1150 17 the the DT 13433 1150 18 transmission transmission NN 13433 1150 19 to to IN 13433 1150 20 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1150 21 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1150 22 is be VBZ 13433 1150 23 beset beset NN 13433 1150 24 by by IN 13433 1150 25 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 1150 26 . . . 13433 1151 1 | | NNP 13433 1151 2 is be VBZ 13433 1151 3 more more RBR 13433 1151 4 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1151 5 . . . 13433 1152 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1152 2 shows show VBZ 13433 1152 3 , , , 13433 1152 4 Having have VBG 13433 1152 5 set set VBN 13433 1152 6 out out RP 13433 1152 7 these these DT 13433 1152 8 objections objection NNS 13433 1152 9 | | CD 13433 1152 10 however however RB 13433 1152 11 , , , 13433 1152 12 that that IN 13433 1152 13 the the DT 13433 1152 14 whole whole JJ 13433 1152 15 story story NN 13433 1152 16 is be VBZ 13433 1152 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1152 18 leaves leave VBZ 13433 1152 19 the the DT 13433 1152 20 question question NN 13433 1152 21 , , , 13433 1152 22 casting cast VBG 13433 1152 23 | | CD 13433 1152 24 inconsistent inconsistent NN 13433 1152 25 with with IN 13433 1152 26 historical historical JJ 13433 1152 27 facts fact NNS 13433 1152 28 , , , 13433 1152 29 doubt doubt NN 13433 1152 30 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1152 31 like like IN 13433 1152 32 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1152 33 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1152 34 upon upon IN 13433 1152 35 the the DT 13433 1152 36 whole whole JJ 13433 1152 37 | | CD 13433 1152 38 and and CC 13433 1152 39 the the DT 13433 1152 40 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1152 41 of of IN 13433 1152 42 the the DT 13433 1152 43 history history NN 13433 1152 44 , , , 13433 1152 45 and and CC 13433 1152 46 gives give VBZ 13433 1152 47 no no DT 13433 1152 48 support support NN 13433 1152 49 to to IN 13433 1152 50 | | CD 13433 1152 51 journey journey NN 13433 1152 52 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1152 53 . . . 13433 1153 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1153 2 is be VBZ 13433 1153 3 the the DT 13433 1153 4 bold bold JJ 13433 1153 5 affirmation affirmation NN 13433 1153 6 of of IN 13433 1153 7 a a DT 13433 1153 8 | | NNP 13433 1153 9 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1153 10 to to TO 13433 1153 11 give give VB 13433 1153 12 even even RB 13433 1153 13 a a DT 13433 1153 14 sketch sketch NN 13433 1153 15 of of IN 13433 1153 16 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1153 17 ' ' '' 13433 1153 18 at at IN 13433 1153 19 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1153 20 on on IN 13433 1153 21 the the DT 13433 1153 22 20th 20th JJ 13433 1153 23 | | NN 13433 1153 24 this this DT 13433 1153 25 argument argument NN 13433 1153 26 , , , 13433 1153 27 which which WDT 13433 1153 28 extends extend VBZ 13433 1153 29 over over IN 13433 1153 30 December December NNP 13433 1153 31 , , , 13433 1153 32 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1154 1 115 115 CD 13433 1154 2 . . . 13433 1154 3 ' ' '' 13433 1154 4 " " '' 13433 1155 1 | | CD 13433 1155 2 five five CD 13433 1155 3 long long JJ 13433 1155 4 pages page NNS 13433 1155 5 , , , 13433 1155 6 but but CC 13433 1155 7 although although IN 13433 1155 8 | | NNP 13433 1155 9 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1155 10 does do VBZ 13433 1155 11 not not RB 13433 1155 12 directly directly RB 13433 1155 13 refer refer VB 13433 1155 14 | | NNP 13433 1155 15 to to IN 13433 1155 16 the the DT 13433 1155 17 theory theory NN 13433 1155 18 of of IN 13433 1155 19 the the DT 13433 1155 20 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1155 21 in in IN 13433 1155 22 | | NNP 13433 1155 23 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1155 24 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1155 25 , , , 13433 1155 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1155 27 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1155 28 | | NNP 13433 1155 29 forcibly forcibly RB 13433 1155 30 points point VBZ 13433 1155 31 to to IN 13433 1155 32 that that DT 13433 1155 33 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1155 34 , , , 13433 1155 35 | | NNP 13433 1155 36 and and CC 13433 1155 37 forms form VBZ 13433 1155 38 part part NN 13433 1155 39 of of IN 13433 1155 40 the the DT 13433 1155 41 converging converge VBG 13433 1155 42 | | NNS 13433 1155 43 trains train NNS 13433 1155 44 of of IN 13433 1155 45 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1155 46 which which WDT 13433 1155 47 result result VBP 13433 1155 48 in in IN 13433 1155 49 | | NNP 13433 1155 50 that that IN 13433 1155 51 " " `` 13433 1155 52 demonstration demonstration NN 13433 1155 53 " " '' 13433 1155 54 which which WDT 13433 1155 55 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1155 56 | | MD 13433 1155 57 assert assert VBP 13433 1155 58 . . . 13433 1156 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1156 2 will will MD 13433 1156 3 presently presently RB 13433 1156 4 make make VB 13433 1156 5 use use NN 13433 1156 6 | | NNS 13433 1156 7 of of IN 13433 1156 8 some some DT 13433 1156 9 of of IN 13433 1156 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1156 11 arguments argument NNS 13433 1156 12 . . . 13433 1157 1 At at IN 13433 1157 2 the the DT 13433 1157 3 close close NN 13433 1157 4 of of IN 13433 1157 5 this this DT 13433 1157 6 analysis analysis NN 13433 1157 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1157 8 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1157 9 sums sum VBZ 13433 1157 10 up up RP 13433 1157 11 the the DT 13433 1157 12 result result NN 13433 1157 13 as as IN 13433 1157 14 follows follow VBZ 13433 1157 15 : : : 13433 1157 16 " " `` 13433 1157 17 In in IN 13433 1157 18 this this DT 13433 1157 19 case case NN 13433 1157 20 , , , 13433 1157 21 therefore therefore RB 13433 1157 22 , , , 13433 1157 23 again again RB 13433 1157 24 , , , 13433 1157 25 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1157 26 alone alone RB 13433 1157 27 offers offer VBZ 13433 1157 28 any any DT 13433 1157 29 arguments argument NNS 13433 1157 30 in in IN 13433 1157 31 support support NN 13433 1157 32 of of IN 13433 1157 33 the the DT 13433 1157 34 statement statement NN 13433 1157 35 in in IN 13433 1157 36 the the DT 13433 1157 37 text text NN 13433 1157 38 ; ; : 13433 1157 39 and and CC 13433 1157 40 the the DT 13433 1157 41 final final JJ 13433 1157 42 result result NN 13433 1157 43 of of IN 13433 1157 44 the the DT 13433 1157 45 references reference NNS 13433 1157 46 is be VBZ 13433 1157 47 , , , 13433 1157 48 that that IN 13433 1157 49 the the DT 13433 1157 50 alleged allege VBN 13433 1157 51 ' ' `` 13433 1157 52 demonstration demonstration NN 13433 1157 53 ' ' '' 13433 1157 54 is be VBZ 13433 1157 55 , , , 13433 1157 56 at at IN 13433 1157 57 the the DT 13433 1157 58 most most JJS 13433 1157 59 , , , 13433 1157 60 what what WP 13433 1157 61 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1157 62 calls call VBZ 13433 1157 63 ' ' '' 13433 1157 64 a a DT 13433 1157 65 not not RB 13433 1157 66 groundless groundless JJ 13433 1157 67 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1157 68 . . . 13433 1157 69 ' ' '' 13433 1157 70 " " '' 13433 1158 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1158 2 98:1 98:1 CD 13433 1158 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1158 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1158 5 is be VBZ 13433 1158 6 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 1158 7 possible possible JJ 13433 1158 8 to to TO 13433 1158 9 imagine imagine VB 13433 1158 10 a a DT 13433 1158 11 more more RBR 13433 1158 12 complete complete JJ 13433 1158 13 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 1158 14 of of IN 13433 1158 15 the the DT 13433 1158 16 fact fact NN 13433 1158 17 than than IN 13433 1158 18 the the DT 13433 1158 19 assertion assertion NN 13433 1158 20 that that IN 13433 1158 21 " " `` 13433 1158 22 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1158 23 alone alone RB 13433 1158 24 offers offer VBZ 13433 1158 25 any any DT 13433 1158 26 arguments argument NNS 13433 1158 27 in in IN 13433 1158 28 support support NN 13433 1158 29 of of IN 13433 1158 30 the the DT 13433 1158 31 statement statement NN 13433 1158 32 in in IN 13433 1158 33 the the DT 13433 1158 34 text text NN 13433 1158 35 , , , 13433 1158 36 " " '' 13433 1158 37 and and CC 13433 1158 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1158 39 is be VBZ 13433 1158 40 incomprehensible incomprehensible JJ 13433 1158 41 upon upon IN 13433 1158 42 any any DT 13433 1158 43 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 1158 44 theory theory NN 13433 1158 45 . . . 13433 1159 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1159 2 mere mere JJ 13433 1159 3 sketch sketch NN 13433 1159 4 can can MD 13433 1159 5 not not RB 13433 1159 6 possibly possibly RB 13433 1159 7 convey convey VB 13433 1159 8 an an DT 13433 1159 9 adequate adequate JJ 13433 1159 10 idea idea NN 13433 1159 11 of of IN 13433 1159 12 the the DT 13433 1159 13 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1159 14 arguments argument NNS 13433 1159 15 of of IN 13433 1159 16 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1159 17 , , , 13433 1159 18 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1159 19 , , , 13433 1159 20 and and CC 13433 1159 21 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1159 22 , , , 13433 1159 23 but but CC 13433 1159 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1159 25 hope hope VBP 13433 1159 26 to to TO 13433 1159 27 state state VB 13433 1159 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1159 29 main main JJ 13433 1159 30 features feature NNS 13433 1159 31 , , , 13433 1159 32 a a DT 13433 1159 33 few few JJ 13433 1159 34 pages page NNS 13433 1159 35 on on IN 13433 1159 36 . . . 13433 1160 1 With with IN 13433 1160 2 regard regard NN 13433 1160 3 to to IN 13433 1160 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1160 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1160 6 's 's POS 13433 1160 7 remark remark NN 13433 1160 8 on on IN 13433 1160 9 the the DT 13433 1160 10 " " `` 13433 1160 11 alleged allege VBN 13433 1160 12 ' ' '' 13433 1160 13 demonstration demonstration NN 13433 1160 14 , , , 13433 1160 15 ' ' '' 13433 1160 16 " " `` 13433 1160 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1160 18 must must MD 13433 1160 19 be be VB 13433 1160 20 evident evident JJ 13433 1160 21 that that IN 13433 1160 22 when when WRB 13433 1160 23 a a DT 13433 1160 24 writer writer NN 13433 1160 25 states state VBZ 13433 1160 26 anything anything NN 13433 1160 27 to to TO 13433 1160 28 be be VB 13433 1160 29 " " `` 13433 1160 30 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 13433 1160 31 " " '' 13433 1160 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1160 33 expresses express VBZ 13433 1160 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1160 35 own own JJ 13433 1160 36 belief belief NN 13433 1160 37 . . . 13433 1161 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1161 2 is be VBZ 13433 1161 3 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1161 4 to to TO 13433 1161 5 secure secure VB 13433 1161 6 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1161 7 unanimity unanimity NN 13433 1161 8 of of IN 13433 1161 9 opinion opinion NN 13433 1161 10 , , , 13433 1161 11 and and CC 13433 1161 12 the the DT 13433 1161 13 only only JJ 13433 1161 14 question question NN 13433 1161 15 in in IN 13433 1161 16 such such PDT 13433 1161 17 a a DT 13433 1161 18 case case NN 13433 1161 19 is be VBZ 13433 1161 20 whether whether IN 13433 1161 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1161 22 refer refer VBP 13433 1161 23 to to IN 13433 1161 24 writers writer NNS 13433 1161 25 , , , 13433 1161 26 in in IN 13433 1161 27 connection connection NN 13433 1161 28 with with IN 13433 1161 29 the the DT 13433 1161 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1161 31 which which WDT 13433 1161 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1161 33 affirm affirm VBP 13433 1161 34 to to TO 13433 1161 35 be be VB 13433 1161 36 demonstrated demonstrate VBN 13433 1161 37 , , , 13433 1161 38 who who WP 13433 1161 39 advance advance VBP 13433 1161 40 arguments argument NNS 13433 1161 41 and and CC 13433 1161 42 evidence evidence NN 13433 1161 43 bearing bear VBG 13433 1161 44 upon upon IN 13433 1161 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1161 46 . . . 13433 1162 1 A a DT 13433 1162 2 critic critic NN 13433 1162 3 is be VBZ 13433 1162 4 quite quite RB 13433 1162 5 at at IN 13433 1162 6 liberty liberty NN 13433 1162 7 to to TO 13433 1162 8 say say VB 13433 1162 9 that that IN 13433 1162 10 the the DT 13433 1162 11 arguments argument NNS 13433 1162 12 are be VBP 13433 1162 13 insufficient insufficient JJ 13433 1162 14 , , , 13433 1162 15 but but CC 13433 1162 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1162 17 is be VBZ 13433 1162 18 not not RB 13433 1162 19 at at IN 13433 1162 20 liberty liberty NN 13433 1162 21 to to TO 13433 1162 22 deny deny VB 13433 1162 23 that that IN 13433 1162 24 there there EX 13433 1162 25 are be VBP 13433 1162 26 any any DT 13433 1162 27 arguments argument NNS 13433 1162 28 at at RB 13433 1162 29 all all RB 13433 1162 30 when when WRB 13433 1162 31 the the DT 13433 1162 32 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1162 33 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1162 34 of of IN 13433 1162 35 men man NNS 13433 1162 36 like like IN 13433 1162 37 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1162 38 , , , 13433 1162 39 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1162 40 , , , 13433 1162 41 and and CC 13433 1162 42 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1162 43 is be VBZ 13433 1162 44 referred refer VBN 13433 1162 45 to to IN 13433 1162 46 . . . 13433 1163 1 Therefore therefore RB 13433 1163 2 , , , 13433 1163 3 when when WRB 13433 1163 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1163 5 goes go VBZ 13433 1163 6 on on RP 13433 1163 7 to to TO 13433 1163 8 say say VB 13433 1163 9 : : : 13433 1163 10 " " `` 13433 1163 11 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1163 12 seems seem VBZ 13433 1163 13 quite quite RB 13433 1163 14 needless needless JJ 13433 1163 15 to to TO 13433 1163 16 multiply multiply VB 13433 1163 17 comments comment NNS 13433 1163 18 on on IN 13433 1163 19 these these DT 13433 1163 20 results result NNS 13433 1163 21 . . . 13433 1164 1 Anyone anyone NN 13433 1164 2 who who WP 13433 1164 3 will will MD 13433 1164 4 candidly candidly RB 13433 1164 5 consider consider VB 13433 1164 6 this this DT 13433 1164 7 analysis analysis NN 13433 1164 8 will will MD 13433 1164 9 , , , 13433 1164 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1164 11 believe believe VBP 13433 1164 12 , , , 13433 1164 13 agree agree VBP 13433 1164 14 with with IN 13433 1164 15 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1164 16 in in IN 13433 1164 17 thinking think VBG 13433 1164 18 that that IN 13433 1164 19 such such PDT 13433 1164 20 a a DT 13433 1164 21 style style NN 13433 1164 22 of of IN 13433 1164 23 annotation annotation NN 13433 1164 24 , , , 13433 1164 25 which which WDT 13433 1164 26 runs run VBZ 13433 1164 27 through through IN 13433 1164 28 the the DT 13433 1164 29 whole whole JJ 13433 1164 30 work work NN 13433 1164 31 , , , 13433 1164 32 is be VBZ 13433 1164 33 justly justly RB 13433 1164 34 characterised characterise VBN 13433 1164 35 as as IN 13433 1164 36 frivolous frivolous JJ 13433 1164 37 and and CC 13433 1164 38 misleading"--[99:1 misleading"--[99:1 JJ 13433 1164 39 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1164 40 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1164 41 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1164 42 must must MD 13433 1164 43 excuse excuse VB 13433 1164 44 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1164 45 retorting retorting NN 13433 1164 46 that that IN 13433 1164 47 , , , 13433 1164 48 not not RB 13433 1164 49 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1164 50 annotation annotation NN 13433 1164 51 , , , 13433 1164 52 but but CC 13433 1164 53 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1164 54 own own JJ 13433 1164 55 criticism criticism NN 13433 1164 56 of of IN 13433 1164 57 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1164 58 , , , 13433 1164 59 endorsed endorse VBN 13433 1164 60 by by IN 13433 1164 61 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1164 62 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1164 63 , , , 13433 1164 64 is be VBZ 13433 1164 65 " " `` 13433 1164 66 frivolous frivolous JJ 13433 1164 67 and and CC 13433 1164 68 misleading misleading JJ 13433 1164 69 , , , 13433 1164 70 " " '' 13433 1164 71 and and CC 13433 1164 72 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1164 73 venture venture VBP 13433 1164 74 to to TO 13433 1164 75 hope hope VB 13433 1164 76 that that IN 13433 1164 77 this this DT 13433 1164 78 analysis analysis NN 13433 1164 79 , , , 13433 1164 80 tedious tedious JJ 13433 1164 81 as as IN 13433 1164 82 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1164 83 has have VBZ 13433 1164 84 been be VBN 13433 1164 85 , , , 13433 1164 86 may may MD 13433 1164 87 once once RB 13433 1164 88 for for IN 13433 1164 89 all all DT 13433 1164 90 establish establish VB 13433 1164 91 the the DT 13433 1164 92 propriety propriety JJ 13433 1164 93 and and CC 13433 1164 94 substantial substantial JJ 13433 1164 95 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1164 96 of of IN 13433 1164 97 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1164 98 references reference NNS 13433 1164 99 . . . 13433 1165 1 As as IN 13433 1165 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1165 3 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1165 4 does do VBZ 13433 1165 5 not not RB 13433 1165 6 advance advance VB 13433 1165 7 any any DT 13433 1165 8 further further JJ 13433 1165 9 arguments argument NNS 13433 1165 10 of of IN 13433 1165 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1165 12 own own JJ 13433 1165 13 in in IN 13433 1165 14 regard regard NN 13433 1165 15 to to IN 13433 1165 16 the the DT 13433 1165 17 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1165 18 controversy controversy NN 13433 1165 19 , , , 13433 1165 20 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1165 21 may may MD 13433 1165 22 now now RB 13433 1165 23 return return VB 13433 1165 24 to to IN 13433 1165 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1165 26 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1165 27 , , , 13433 1165 28 and and CC 13433 1165 29 complete complete VB 13433 1165 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1165 31 reply reply NN 13433 1165 32 to to IN 13433 1165 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1165 34 objections objection NNS 13433 1165 35 ; ; : 13433 1165 36 but but CC 13433 1165 37 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1165 38 must must MD 13433 1165 39 do do VB 13433 1165 40 so so RB 13433 1165 41 with with IN 13433 1165 42 extreme extreme JJ 13433 1165 43 brevity brevity NN 13433 1165 44 , , , 13433 1165 45 as as IN 13433 1165 46 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1165 47 have have VBP 13433 1165 48 already already RB 13433 1165 49 devoted devote VBN 13433 1165 50 too too RB 13433 1165 51 much much JJ 13433 1165 52 space space NN 13433 1165 53 to to IN 13433 1165 54 this this DT 13433 1165 55 subject subject NN 13433 1165 56 , , , 13433 1165 57 and and CC 13433 1165 58 must must MD 13433 1165 59 now now RB 13433 1165 60 come come VB 13433 1165 61 to to IN 13433 1165 62 a a DT 13433 1165 63 close close NN 13433 1165 64 . . . 13433 1166 1 To to IN 13433 1166 2 the the DT 13433 1166 3 argument argument NN 13433 1166 4 that that IN 13433 1166 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1166 6 is be VBZ 13433 1166 7 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1166 8 to to TO 13433 1166 9 suppose suppose VB 13433 1166 10 that that IN 13433 1166 11 soldiers soldier NNS 13433 1166 12 such such JJ 13433 1166 13 as as IN 13433 1166 14 the the DT 13433 1166 15 " " `` 13433 1166 16 ten ten CD 13433 1166 17 leopards leopard NNS 13433 1166 18 " " '' 13433 1166 19 described describe VBN 13433 1166 20 in in IN 13433 1166 21 the the DT 13433 1166 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1166 23 would would MD 13433 1166 24 allow allow VB 13433 1166 25 a a DT 13433 1166 26 prisoner prisoner NN 13433 1166 27 , , , 13433 1166 28 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1166 29 to to IN 13433 1166 30 wild wild JJ 13433 1166 31 beasts beast NNS 13433 1166 32 for for IN 13433 1166 33 professing profess VBG 13433 1166 34 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1166 35 , , , 13433 1166 36 deliberately deliberately RB 13433 1166 37 to to TO 13433 1166 38 write write VB 13433 1166 39 long long JJ 13433 1166 40 epistles epistle NNS 13433 1166 41 at at IN 13433 1166 42 every every DT 13433 1166 43 stage stage NN 13433 1166 44 of of IN 13433 1166 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1166 46 journey journey NN 13433 1166 47 , , , 13433 1166 48 promulgating promulgate VBG 13433 1166 49 the the DT 13433 1166 50 very very JJ 13433 1166 51 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1166 52 for for IN 13433 1166 53 which which WDT 13433 1166 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1166 55 was be VBD 13433 1166 56 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1166 57 , , , 13433 1166 58 as as RB 13433 1166 59 well well RB 13433 1166 60 as as IN 13433 1166 61 to to TO 13433 1166 62 hold hold VB 13433 1166 63 the the DT 13433 1166 64 freest free JJS 13433 1166 65 intercourse intercourse NN 13433 1166 66 with with IN 13433 1166 67 deputations deputation NNS 13433 1166 68 from from IN 13433 1166 69 the the DT 13433 1166 70 various various JJ 13433 1166 71 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1166 72 , , , 13433 1166 73 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1166 74 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1166 75 advances advance VBZ 13433 1166 76 arguments argument NNS 13433 1166 77 , , , 13433 1166 78 derived derive VBN 13433 1166 79 from from IN 13433 1166 80 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1166 81 , , , 13433 1166 82 regarding regard VBG 13433 1166 83 the the DT 13433 1166 84 Roman roman JJ 13433 1166 85 procedure procedure NN 13433 1166 86 in in IN 13433 1166 87 cases case NNS 13433 1166 88 that that WDT 13433 1166 89 are be VBP 13433 1166 90 said say VBN 13433 1166 91 to to TO 13433 1166 92 be be VB 13433 1166 93 " " `` 13433 1166 94 known know VBN 13433 1166 95 . . . 13433 1166 96 " " '' 13433 1167 1 These these DT 13433 1167 2 cases case NNS 13433 1167 3 , , , 13433 1167 4 however however RB 13433 1167 5 , , , 13433 1167 6 are be VBP 13433 1167 7 neither neither RB 13433 1167 8 analogous analogous JJ 13433 1167 9 , , , 13433 1167 10 nor nor CC 13433 1167 11 have have VBP 13433 1167 12 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1167 13 the the DT 13433 1167 14 force force NN 13433 1167 15 which which WDT 13433 1167 16 is be VBZ 13433 1167 17 assumed assume VBN 13433 1167 18 . . . 13433 1168 1 That that IN 13433 1168 2 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1168 3 imprisoned imprison VBD 13433 1168 4 for for IN 13433 1168 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1168 6 religious religious JJ 13433 1168 7 belief belief NN 13433 1168 8 should should MD 13433 1168 9 receive receive VB 13433 1168 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1168 11 nourishment nourishment NN 13433 1168 12 , , , 13433 1168 13 while while IN 13433 1168 14 in in IN 13433 1168 15 prison prison NN 13433 1168 16 , , , 13433 1168 17 from from IN 13433 1168 18 friends friend NNS 13433 1168 19 , , , 13433 1168 20 is be VBZ 13433 1168 21 anything anything NN 13433 1168 22 but but IN 13433 1168 23 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 1168 24 , , , 13433 1168 25 and and CC 13433 1168 26 that that IN 13433 1168 27 bribes bribe NNS 13433 1168 28 should should MD 13433 1168 29 secure secure VB 13433 1168 30 access access NN 13433 1168 31 to to IN 13433 1168 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1168 33 in in IN 13433 1168 34 many many JJ 13433 1168 35 cases case NNS 13433 1168 36 , , , 13433 1168 37 and and CC 13433 1168 38 some some DT 13433 1168 39 mitigation mitigation NN 13433 1168 40 of of IN 13433 1168 41 suffering suffering NN 13433 1168 42 , , , 13433 1168 43 is be VBZ 13433 1168 44 possible possible JJ 13433 1168 45 . . . 13433 1169 1 The the DT 13433 1169 2 case case NN 13433 1169 3 of of IN 13433 1169 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1169 5 , , , 13433 1169 6 however however RB 13433 1169 7 , , , 13433 1169 8 is be VBZ 13433 1169 9 very very RB 13433 1169 10 different different JJ 13433 1169 11 . . . 13433 1170 1 If if IN 13433 1170 2 the the DT 13433 1170 3 meaning meaning NN 13433 1170 4 of of IN 13433 1170 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1170 6 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1170 7 : : : 13433 1170 8 oi oi NNP 13433 1170 9 kai kai NNP 13433 1170 10 euergetoumenoi euergetoumenoi NNP 13433 1170 11 cheirous cheirous JJ 13433 1170 12 ginontai ginontai NN 13433 1170 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1170 14 be be VB 13433 1170 15 that that IN 13433 1170 16 , , , 13433 1170 17 although although IN 13433 1170 18 receiving receive VBG 13433 1170 19 bribes bribe NNS 13433 1170 20 , , , 13433 1170 21 the the DT 13433 1170 22 " " `` 13433 1170 23 ten ten CD 13433 1170 24 leopards leopard NNS 13433 1170 25 " " '' 13433 1170 26 only only RB 13433 1170 27 became become VBD 13433 1170 28 more more RBR 13433 1170 29 cruel cruel JJ 13433 1170 30 , , , 13433 1170 31 the the DT 13433 1170 32 very very RB 13433 1170 33 reverse reverse NN 13433 1170 34 of of IN 13433 1170 35 the the DT 13433 1170 36 leniency leniency NN 13433 1170 37 and and CC 13433 1170 38 mild mild JJ 13433 1170 39 treatment treatment NN 13433 1170 40 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1170 41 to to IN 13433 1170 42 the the DT 13433 1170 43 Roman roman JJ 13433 1170 44 procedure procedure NN 13433 1170 45 is be VBZ 13433 1170 46 described describe VBN 13433 1170 47 by by IN 13433 1170 48 the the DT 13433 1170 49 writer writer NN 13433 1170 50 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1170 51 as as IN 13433 1170 52 actually actually RB 13433 1170 53 taking take VBG 13433 1170 54 place place NN 13433 1170 55 , , , 13433 1170 56 and and CC 13433 1170 57 certainly certainly RB 13433 1170 58 nothing nothing NN 13433 1170 59 approaching approach VBG 13433 1170 60 a a DT 13433 1170 61 parallel parallel NN 13433 1170 62 to to IN 13433 1170 63 the the DT 13433 1170 64 correspondence correspondence NN 13433 1170 65 of of IN 13433 1170 66 pseudo pseudo NNP 13433 1170 67 - - NNP 13433 1170 68 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1170 69 can can MD 13433 1170 70 be be VB 13433 1170 71 pointed point VBN 13433 1170 72 out out RP 13433 1170 73 in in IN 13433 1170 74 any any DT 13433 1170 75 known know VBN 13433 1170 76 instance instance NN 13433 1170 77 . . . 13433 1171 1 The the DT 13433 1171 2 case case NN 13433 1171 3 of of IN 13433 1171 4 Saturus Saturus NNP 13433 1171 5 and and CC 13433 1171 6 Perpetua Perpetua NNP 13433 1171 7 , , , 13433 1171 8 even even RB 13433 1171 9 if if IN 13433 1171 10 true true JJ 13433 1171 11 , , , 13433 1171 12 is be VBZ 13433 1171 13 no no DT 13433 1171 14 confirmation confirmation NN 13433 1171 15 , , , 13433 1171 16 the the DT 13433 1171 17 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1171 18 being be VBG 13433 1171 19 very very RB 13433 1171 20 different different JJ 13433 1171 21 ; ; : 13433 1171 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1171 23 100:1 100:1 CD 13433 1171 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1171 25 but but CC 13433 1171 26 in in IN 13433 1171 27 fact fact NN 13433 1171 28 there there EX 13433 1171 29 is be VBZ 13433 1171 30 no no DT 13433 1171 31 evidence evidence NN 13433 1171 32 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1171 33 that that IN 13433 1171 34 the the DT 13433 1171 35 extant extant JJ 13433 1171 36 history history NN 13433 1171 37 was be VBD 13433 1171 38 written write VBN 13433 1171 39 by by IN 13433 1171 40 either either DT 13433 1171 41 of of IN 13433 1171 42 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1171 43 , , , 13433 1171 44 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1171 45 100:2 100:2 CD 13433 1171 46 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1171 47 but but CC 13433 1171 48 on on IN 13433 1171 49 the the DT 13433 1171 50 contrary contrary NN 13433 1171 51 , , , 13433 1171 52 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1171 53 maintain maintain VBP 13433 1171 54 , , , 13433 1171 55 every every DT 13433 1171 56 reason reason NN 13433 1171 57 to to TO 13433 1171 58 believe believe VB 13433 1171 59 that that IN 13433 1171 60 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1171 61 was be VBD 13433 1171 62 not not RB 13433 1171 63 . . . 13433 1172 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1172 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1172 3 advances advance VBZ 13433 1172 4 the the DT 13433 1172 5 instance instance NN 13433 1172 6 of of IN 13433 1172 7 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1172 8 as as IN 13433 1172 9 a a DT 13433 1172 10 case case NN 13433 1172 11 in in IN 13433 1172 12 point point NN 13433 1172 13 of of IN 13433 1172 14 a a DT 13433 1172 15 Christian christian JJ 13433 1172 16 prisoner prisoner NN 13433 1172 17 treated treat VBN 13433 1172 18 with with IN 13433 1172 19 great great JJ 13433 1172 20 consideration consideration NN 13433 1172 21 , , , 13433 1172 22 and and CC 13433 1172 23 who who WP 13433 1172 24 " " `` 13433 1172 25 writes write VBZ 13433 1172 26 letters letter NNS 13433 1172 27 freely freely RB 13433 1172 28 , , , 13433 1172 29 receives receive VBZ 13433 1172 30 visits visit NNS 13433 1172 31 from from IN 13433 1172 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1172 33 friends friend NNS 13433 1172 34 , , , 13433 1172 35 communicates communicate VBZ 13433 1172 36 with with IN 13433 1172 37 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1172 38 and and CC 13433 1172 39 individuals individual NNS 13433 1172 40 as as IN 13433 1172 41 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1172 42 desires desire VBZ 13433 1172 43 . . . 13433 1172 44 " " '' 13433 1173 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1173 2 101:1 101:1 CD 13433 1173 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1173 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1173 5 is be VBZ 13433 1173 6 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 1173 7 possible possible JJ 13433 1173 8 to to TO 13433 1173 9 imagine imagine VB 13433 1173 10 two two CD 13433 1173 11 cases case NNS 13433 1173 12 more more RBR 13433 1173 13 dissimilar dissimilar JJ 13433 1173 14 than than IN 13433 1173 15 those those DT 13433 1173 16 of of IN 13433 1173 17 pseudo pseudo NNP 13433 1173 18 - - HYPH 13433 1173 19 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1173 20 and and CC 13433 1173 21 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1173 22 , , , 13433 1173 23 as as IN 13433 1173 24 narrated narrate VBN 13433 1173 25 in in IN 13433 1173 26 the the DT 13433 1173 27 " " `` 13433 1173 28 Acts act NNS 13433 1173 29 of of IN 13433 1173 30 the the DT 13433 1173 31 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1173 32 , , , 13433 1173 33 " " '' 13433 1173 34 although although IN 13433 1173 35 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 1173 36 the the DT 13433 1173 37 story story NN 13433 1173 38 of of IN 13433 1173 39 the the DT 13433 1173 40 former former JJ 13433 1173 41 has have VBZ 13433 1173 42 been be VBN 13433 1173 43 framed frame VBN 13433 1173 44 upon upon IN 13433 1173 45 some some DT 13433 1173 46 of of IN 13433 1173 47 the the DT 13433 1173 48 lines line NNS 13433 1173 49 of of IN 13433 1173 50 the the DT 13433 1173 51 latter latter JJ 13433 1173 52 . . . 13433 1174 1 Whilst whilst IN 13433 1174 2 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1174 3 is be VBZ 13433 1174 4 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1174 5 to to TO 13433 1174 6 be be VB 13433 1174 7 cast cast VBN 13433 1174 8 to to IN 13433 1174 9 the the DT 13433 1174 10 wild wild JJ 13433 1174 11 beasts beast NNS 13433 1174 12 as as IN 13433 1174 13 a a DT 13433 1174 14 Christian Christian NNP 13433 1174 15 , , , 13433 1174 16 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1174 17 is be VBZ 13433 1174 18 not not RB 13433 1174 19 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1174 20 at at RB 13433 1174 21 all all RB 13433 1174 22 , , , 13433 1174 23 but but CC 13433 1174 24 stands stand VBZ 13433 1174 25 in in IN 13433 1174 26 the the DT 13433 1174 27 position position NN 13433 1174 28 of of IN 13433 1174 29 a a DT 13433 1174 30 Roman roman JJ 13433 1174 31 citizen citizen NN 13433 1174 32 , , , 13433 1174 33 rescued rescue VBN 13433 1174 34 from from IN 13433 1174 35 infuriated infuriate VBN 13433 1174 36 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 1174 37 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1174 38 xxiii xxiii NN 13433 1174 39 . . . 13433 1175 1 27 27 CD 13433 1175 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1175 3 , , , 13433 1175 4 repeatedly repeatedly RB 13433 1175 5 declared declare VBN 13433 1175 6 by by IN 13433 1175 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1175 8 judges judge NNS 13433 1175 9 to to TO 13433 1175 10 have have VB 13433 1175 11 done do VBN 13433 1175 12 nothing nothing NN 13433 1175 13 worthy worthy JJ 13433 1175 14 of of IN 13433 1175 15 death death NN 13433 1175 16 or or CC 13433 1175 17 of of IN 13433 1175 18 bonds bond NNS 13433 1175 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1175 20 xxv xxv NNP 13433 1175 21 . . . 13433 1176 1 25 25 CD 13433 1176 2 , , , 13433 1176 3 xxvi xxvi NNP 13433 1176 4 . . . 13433 1177 1 31 31 CD 13433 1177 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1177 3 , , , 13433 1177 4 and and CC 13433 1177 5 who who WP 13433 1177 6 might may MD 13433 1177 7 have have VB 13433 1177 8 been be VBN 13433 1177 9 set set VBN 13433 1177 10 at at IN 13433 1177 11 liberty liberty NN 13433 1177 12 but but CC 13433 1177 13 that that IN 13433 1177 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1177 15 had have VBD 13433 1177 16 appealed appeal VBN 13433 1177 17 to to IN 13433 1177 18 Caesar Caesar NNP 13433 1177 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1177 20 xxv xxv NNP 13433 1177 21 . . . 13433 1178 1 11 11 CD 13433 1178 2 f. f. NNP 13433 1178 3 , , , 13433 1178 4 xxvi xxvi NNP 13433 1178 5 . . . 13433 1179 1 32 32 CD 13433 1179 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1179 3 . . . 13433 1180 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1180 2 position position NN 13433 1180 3 was be VBD 13433 1180 4 one one CD 13433 1180 5 which which WDT 13433 1180 6 secured secure VBD 13433 1180 7 the the DT 13433 1180 8 sympathy sympathy NN 13433 1180 9 of of IN 13433 1180 10 the the DT 13433 1180 11 Roman roman JJ 13433 1180 12 soldiers soldier NNS 13433 1180 13 . . . 13433 1181 1 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1181 2 " " `` 13433 1181 3 fights fight VBZ 13433 1181 4 with with IN 13433 1181 5 beasts beast NNS 13433 1181 6 from from IN 13433 1181 7 Syria Syria NNP 13433 1181 8 even even RB 13433 1181 9 unto unto IN 13433 1181 10 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1181 11 , , , 13433 1181 12 " " '' 13433 1181 13 and and CC 13433 1181 14 is be VBZ 13433 1181 15 cruelly cruelly RB 13433 1181 16 treated treat VBN 13433 1181 17 by by IN 13433 1181 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1181 19 " " `` 13433 1181 20 ten ten CD 13433 1181 21 leopards leopard NNS 13433 1181 22 , , , 13433 1181 23 " " '' 13433 1181 24 but but CC 13433 1181 25 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1181 26 is be VBZ 13433 1181 27 represented represent VBN 13433 1181 28 as as IN 13433 1181 29 receiving receive VBG 13433 1181 30 very very RB 13433 1181 31 different different JJ 13433 1181 32 treatment treatment NN 13433 1181 33 . . . 13433 1182 1 Felix Felix NNP 13433 1182 2 commands command VBZ 13433 1182 3 that that WDT 13433 1182 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1182 5 own own JJ 13433 1182 6 people people NNS 13433 1182 7 should should MD 13433 1182 8 be be VB 13433 1182 9 allowed allow VBN 13433 1182 10 to to TO 13433 1182 11 come come VB 13433 1182 12 and and CC 13433 1182 13 minister minister VB 13433 1182 14 to to IN 13433 1182 15 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1182 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1182 17 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 1182 18 . . . 13433 1183 1 23 23 CD 13433 1183 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1183 3 , , , 13433 1183 4 and and CC 13433 1183 5 when when WRB 13433 1183 6 the the DT 13433 1183 7 voyage voyage NN 13433 1183 8 is be VBZ 13433 1183 9 commenced commence VBN 13433 1183 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1183 11 is be VBZ 13433 1183 12 said say VBN 13433 1183 13 that that IN 13433 1183 14 Julius Julius NNP 13433 1183 15 , , , 13433 1183 16 who who WP 13433 1183 17 had have VBD 13433 1183 18 charge charge NN 13433 1183 19 of of IN 13433 1183 20 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1183 21 , , , 13433 1183 22 treated treat VBD 13433 1183 23 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1183 24 courteously courteously RB 13433 1183 25 , , , 13433 1183 26 and and CC 13433 1183 27 , , , 13433 1183 28 gave give VBD 13433 1183 29 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1183 30 liberty liberty NN 13433 1183 31 to to TO 13433 1183 32 go go VB 13433 1183 33 to to TO 13433 1183 34 see see VB 13433 1183 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1183 36 friends friend NNS 13433 1183 37 at at IN 13433 1183 38 Sidon Sidon NNP 13433 1183 39 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1183 40 xxvii xxvii NN 13433 1183 41 . . . 13433 1184 1 3 3 LS 13433 1184 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1184 3 . . . 13433 1185 1 At at IN 13433 1185 2 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1185 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1185 4 was be VBD 13433 1185 5 allowed allow VBN 13433 1185 6 to to TO 13433 1185 7 live live VB 13433 1185 8 by by IN 13433 1185 9 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1185 10 with with IN 13433 1185 11 a a DT 13433 1185 12 single single JJ 13433 1185 13 soldier soldier NN 13433 1185 14 to to TO 13433 1185 15 guard guard VB 13433 1185 16 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1185 17 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1185 18 xxviii xxviii NNP 13433 1185 19 . . . 13433 1186 1 16 16 CD 13433 1186 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1186 3 , , , 13433 1186 4 and and CC 13433 1186 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1186 6 continued continue VBD 13433 1186 7 for for IN 13433 1186 8 two two CD 13433 1186 9 years year NNS 13433 1186 10 in in IN 13433 1186 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1186 12 own own JJ 13433 1186 13 hired hire VBN 13433 1186 14 house house NN 13433 1186 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1186 16 xxviii xxviii NNP 13433 1186 17 . . . 13433 1187 1 28 28 CD 13433 1187 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1187 3 . . . 13433 1188 1 These these DT 13433 1188 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1188 3 are be VBP 13433 1188 4 totally totally RB 13433 1188 5 different different JJ 13433 1188 6 from from IN 13433 1188 7 those those DT 13433 1188 8 under under IN 13433 1188 9 which which WDT 13433 1188 10 the the DT 13433 1188 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1188 12 of of IN 13433 1188 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1188 14 are be VBP 13433 1188 15 said say VBN 13433 1188 16 to to TO 13433 1188 17 have have VB 13433 1188 18 been be VBN 13433 1188 19 written write VBN 13433 1188 20 . . . 13433 1189 1 " " `` 13433 1189 2 But but CC 13433 1189 3 the the DT 13433 1189 4 most most RBS 13433 1189 5 powerful powerful JJ 13433 1189 6 testimony testimony NN 13433 1189 7 , , , 13433 1189 8 " " '' 13433 1189 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1189 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1189 11 goes go VBZ 13433 1189 12 on on RP 13433 1189 13 to to TO 13433 1189 14 say say VB 13433 1189 15 , , , 13433 1189 16 " " '' 13433 1189 17 is be VBZ 13433 1189 18 derived derive VBN 13433 1189 19 from from IN 13433 1189 20 the the DT 13433 1189 21 representations representation NNS 13433 1189 22 of of IN 13433 1189 23 a a DT 13433 1189 24 heathen heathen NNP 13433 1189 25 writer writer NN 13433 1189 26 . . . 13433 1189 27 " " '' 13433 1190 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1190 2 101:2 101:2 LS 13433 1190 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1190 4 The the DT 13433 1190 5 case case NN 13433 1190 6 of of IN 13433 1190 7 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1190 8 , , , 13433 1190 9 to to TO 13433 1190 10 which which WDT 13433 1190 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1190 12 refers refer VBZ 13433 1190 13 , , , 13433 1190 14 seems seem VBZ 13433 1190 15 to to IN 13433 1190 16 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1190 17 even even RB 13433 1190 18 more more RBR 13433 1190 19 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 13433 1190 20 than than IN 13433 1190 21 that that DT 13433 1190 22 of of IN 13433 1190 23 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1190 24 . . . 13433 1191 1 Of of IN 13433 1191 2 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1191 3 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1191 4 , , , 13433 1191 5 historically historically RB 13433 1191 6 , , , 13433 1191 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1191 8 really really RB 13433 1191 9 know know VBP 13433 1191 10 little little JJ 13433 1191 11 or or CC 13433 1191 12 nothing nothing NN 13433 1191 13 , , , 13433 1191 14 for for IN 13433 1191 15 the the DT 13433 1191 16 account account NN 13433 1191 17 of of IN 13433 1191 18 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1191 19 is be VBZ 13433 1191 20 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 1191 21 received receive VBN 13433 1191 22 as as RB 13433 1191 23 serious serious JJ 13433 1191 24 by by IN 13433 1191 25 anyone anyone NN 13433 1191 26 . . . 13433 1192 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1192 2 102:1 102:1 CD 13433 1192 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1192 4 Lucian lucian JJ 13433 1192 5 narrates narrate NNS 13433 1192 6 that that IN 13433 1192 7 this this DT 13433 1192 8 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1192 9 Proteus Proteus NNP 13433 1192 10 , , , 13433 1192 11 a a DT 13433 1192 12 cynic cynic JJ 13433 1192 13 philosopher philosopher NN 13433 1192 14 , , , 13433 1192 15 having have VBG 13433 1192 16 been be VBN 13433 1192 17 guilty guilty JJ 13433 1192 18 of of IN 13433 1192 19 parricide parricide JJ 13433 1192 20 and and CC 13433 1192 21 other other JJ 13433 1192 22 crimes crime NNS 13433 1192 23 , , , 13433 1192 24 found find VBD 13433 1192 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1192 26 convenient convenient JJ 13433 1192 27 to to TO 13433 1192 28 leave leave VB 13433 1192 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1192 30 own own JJ 13433 1192 31 country country NN 13433 1192 32 . . . 13433 1193 1 In in IN 13433 1193 2 the the DT 13433 1193 3 course course NN 13433 1193 4 of of IN 13433 1193 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1193 6 travels travel NNS 13433 1193 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 8 fell fall VBD 13433 1193 9 in in RP 13433 1193 10 with with IN 13433 1193 11 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1193 12 and and CC 13433 1193 13 learnt learn VBD 13433 1193 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1193 15 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1193 16 , , , 13433 1193 17 and and CC 13433 1193 18 , , , 13433 1193 19 according accord VBG 13433 1193 20 to to IN 13433 1193 21 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1193 22 , , , 13433 1193 23 the the DT 13433 1193 24 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1193 25 soon soon RB 13433 1193 26 were be VBD 13433 1193 27 mere mere JJ 13433 1193 28 children child NNS 13433 1193 29 in in IN 13433 1193 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1193 31 hands hand NNS 13433 1193 32 , , , 13433 1193 33 so so IN 13433 1193 34 that that IN 13433 1193 35 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 36 became become VBD 13433 1193 37 in in IN 13433 1193 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1193 39 own own JJ 13433 1193 40 person person NN 13433 1193 41 " " '' 13433 1193 42 prophet prophet NN 13433 1193 43 , , , 13433 1193 44 high high JJ 13433 1193 45 - - HYPH 13433 1193 46 priest priest NN 13433 1193 47 , , , 13433 1193 48 and and CC 13433 1193 49 ruler ruler NN 13433 1193 50 of of IN 13433 1193 51 a a DT 13433 1193 52 synagogue synagogue NN 13433 1193 53 , , , 13433 1193 54 " " `` 13433 1193 55 and and CC 13433 1193 56 further far RBR 13433 1193 57 " " '' 13433 1193 58 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 59 spoke speak VBD 13433 1193 60 of of IN 13433 1193 61 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 62 as as IN 13433 1193 63 a a DT 13433 1193 64 god god NNP 13433 1193 65 , , , 13433 1193 66 used use VBD 13433 1193 67 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 68 as as IN 13433 1193 69 a a DT 13433 1193 70 lawgiver lawgiver NN 13433 1193 71 , , , 13433 1193 72 and and CC 13433 1193 73 elected elect VBD 13433 1193 74 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1193 75 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1193 76 chief chief JJ 13433 1193 77 man man NN 13433 1193 78 . . . 13433 1193 79 " " '' 13433 1194 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1194 2 102:2 102:2 LS 13433 1194 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1194 4 After after IN 13433 1194 5 a a DT 13433 1194 6 time time NN 13433 1194 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1194 8 was be VBD 13433 1194 9 put put VBN 13433 1194 10 in in IN 13433 1194 11 prison prison NN 13433 1194 12 for for IN 13433 1194 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1194 14 new new JJ 13433 1194 15 faith faith NN 13433 1194 16 , , , 13433 1194 17 which which WDT 13433 1194 18 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1194 19 says say VBZ 13433 1194 20 was be VBD 13433 1194 21 a a DT 13433 1194 22 real real JJ 13433 1194 23 service service NN 13433 1194 24 to to IN 13433 1194 25 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1194 26 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1194 27 in in IN 13433 1194 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1194 29 impostures imposture NNS 13433 1194 30 . . . 13433 1195 1 During during IN 13433 1195 2 the the DT 13433 1195 3 time time NN 13433 1195 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1195 5 was be VBD 13433 1195 6 in in IN 13433 1195 7 prison prison NN 13433 1195 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1195 9 is be VBZ 13433 1195 10 said say VBN 13433 1195 11 to to TO 13433 1195 12 have have VB 13433 1195 13 received receive VBN 13433 1195 14 those those DT 13433 1195 15 services service NNS 13433 1195 16 from from IN 13433 1195 17 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1195 18 which which WDT 13433 1195 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1195 20 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1195 21 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1195 22 . . . 13433 1196 1 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1196 2 was be VBD 13433 1196 3 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1196 4 set set VBN 13433 1196 5 at at IN 13433 1196 6 liberty liberty NN 13433 1196 7 by by IN 13433 1196 8 the the DT 13433 1196 9 Governor Governor NNP 13433 1196 10 of of IN 13433 1196 11 Syria Syria NNP 13433 1196 12 , , , 13433 1196 13 who who WP 13433 1196 14 loved love VBD 13433 1196 15 philosophy philosophy NN 13433 1196 16 , , , 13433 1196 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1196 18 102:3 102:3 CD 13433 1196 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1196 20 and and CC 13433 1196 21 travelled travel VBD 13433 1196 22 about about IN 13433 1196 23 , , , 13433 1196 24 living live VBG 13433 1196 25 in in IN 13433 1196 26 great great JJ 13433 1196 27 comfort comfort NN 13433 1196 28 at at IN 13433 1196 29 the the DT 13433 1196 30 expense expense NN 13433 1196 31 of of IN 13433 1196 32 the the DT 13433 1196 33 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1196 34 , , , 13433 1196 35 until until IN 13433 1196 36 at at IN 13433 1196 37 last last RB 13433 1196 38 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1196 39 quarrelled quarrel VBD 13433 1196 40 in in IN 13433 1196 41 consequence consequence NN 13433 1196 42 , , , 13433 1196 43 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1196 44 thinks think VBZ 13433 1196 45 , , , 13433 1196 46 of of IN 13433 1196 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1196 48 eating eat VBG 13433 1196 49 some some DT 13433 1196 50 forbidden forbid VBN 13433 1196 51 food food NN 13433 1196 52 . . . 13433 1197 1 Finally finally RB 13433 1197 2 , , , 13433 1197 3 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1197 4 ended end VBD 13433 1197 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1197 6 career career NN 13433 1197 7 by by IN 13433 1197 8 throwing throw VBG 13433 1197 9 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1197 10 into into IN 13433 1197 11 the the DT 13433 1197 12 flames flame NNS 13433 1197 13 of of IN 13433 1197 14 a a DT 13433 1197 15 funeral funeral NN 13433 1197 16 pile pile NN 13433 1197 17 during during IN 13433 1197 18 the the DT 13433 1197 19 Olympian olympian JJ 13433 1197 20 games game NNS 13433 1197 21 . . . 13433 1198 1 An an DT 13433 1198 2 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1198 3 is be VBZ 13433 1198 4 said say VBN 13433 1198 5 to to TO 13433 1198 6 have have VB 13433 1198 7 taken take VBN 13433 1198 8 place place NN 13433 1198 9 at at IN 13433 1198 10 the the DT 13433 1198 11 time time NN 13433 1198 12 ; ; : 13433 1198 13 a a DT 13433 1198 14 vulture vulture NN 13433 1198 15 flew fly VBD 13433 1198 16 out out RP 13433 1198 17 from from IN 13433 1198 18 the the DT 13433 1198 19 pile pile NN 13433 1198 20 crying cry VBG 13433 1198 21 out out RP 13433 1198 22 with with IN 13433 1198 23 a a DT 13433 1198 24 human human JJ 13433 1198 25 voice voice NN 13433 1198 26 ; ; : 13433 1198 27 and and CC 13433 1198 28 , , , 13433 1198 29 shortly shortly RB 13433 1198 30 after after IN 13433 1198 31 , , , 13433 1198 32 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1198 33 rose rise VBD 13433 1198 34 again again RB 13433 1198 35 and and CC 13433 1198 36 appeared appear VBD 13433 1198 37 clothed clothe VBN 13433 1198 38 in in IN 13433 1198 39 white white JJ 13433 1198 40 raiment raiment NN 13433 1198 41 , , , 13433 1198 42 unhurt unhurt JJ 13433 1198 43 by by IN 13433 1198 44 the the DT 13433 1198 45 fire fire NN 13433 1198 46 . . . 13433 1199 1 Now now RB 13433 1199 2 this this DT 13433 1199 3 writing writing NN 13433 1199 4 , , , 13433 1199 5 of of IN 13433 1199 6 which which WDT 13433 1199 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1199 8 have have VBP 13433 1199 9 given give VBN 13433 1199 10 the the DT 13433 1199 11 barest bare JJS 13433 1199 12 sketch sketch NN 13433 1199 13 , , , 13433 1199 14 is be VBZ 13433 1199 15 a a DT 13433 1199 16 direct direct JJ 13433 1199 17 satire satire NN 13433 1199 18 upon upon IN 13433 1199 19 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1199 20 , , , 13433 1199 21 or or CC 13433 1199 22 even even RB 13433 1199 23 , , , 13433 1199 24 as as IN 13433 1199 25 Baur baur JJ 13433 1199 26 affirms affirm NNS 13433 1199 27 , , , 13433 1199 28 " " '' 13433 1199 29 a a DT 13433 1199 30 parody parody NN 13433 1199 31 of of IN 13433 1199 32 the the DT 13433 1199 33 history history NN 13433 1199 34 of of IN 13433 1199 35 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1199 36 . . . 13433 1199 37 " " '' 13433 1200 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1200 2 102:4 102:4 LS 13433 1200 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1200 4 There there EX 13433 1200 5 are be VBP 13433 1200 6 no no DT 13433 1200 7 means means NN 13433 1200 8 of of IN 13433 1200 9 ascertaining ascertaining NN 13433 1200 10 that that IN 13433 1200 11 any any DT 13433 1200 12 of of IN 13433 1200 13 the the DT 13433 1200 14 events event NNS 13433 1200 15 of of IN 13433 1200 16 the the DT 13433 1200 17 Christian christian JJ 13433 1200 18 career career NN 13433 1200 19 of of IN 13433 1200 20 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1200 21 were be VBD 13433 1200 22 true true JJ 13433 1200 23 , , , 13433 1200 24 but but CC 13433 1200 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1200 26 is be VBZ 13433 1200 27 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1200 28 that that IN 13433 1200 29 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1200 30 's 's POS 13433 1200 31 policy policy NN 13433 1200 32 was be VBD 13433 1200 33 to to TO 13433 1200 34 exaggerate exaggerate VB 13433 1200 35 the the DT 13433 1200 36 facility facility NN 13433 1200 37 of of IN 13433 1200 38 access access NN 13433 1200 39 to to IN 13433 1200 40 prisoners prisoner NNS 13433 1200 41 , , , 13433 1200 42 as as RB 13433 1200 43 well well RB 13433 1200 44 as as IN 13433 1200 45 the the DT 13433 1200 46 assiduity assiduity NN 13433 1200 47 and and CC 13433 1200 48 attention attention NN 13433 1200 49 of of IN 13433 1200 50 the the DT 13433 1200 51 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1200 52 to to IN 13433 1200 53 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1200 54 , , , 13433 1200 55 the the DT 13433 1200 56 ease ease NN 13433 1200 57 with with IN 13433 1200 58 which which WDT 13433 1200 59 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1200 60 were be VBD 13433 1200 61 duped dupe VBN 13433 1200 62 being be VBG 13433 1200 63 the the DT 13433 1200 64 chief chief JJ 13433 1200 65 point point NN 13433 1200 66 of of IN 13433 1200 67 the the DT 13433 1200 68 satire satire NN 13433 1200 69 . . . 13433 1201 1 There there EX 13433 1201 2 is be VBZ 13433 1201 3 another another DT 13433 1201 4 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 1201 5 which which WDT 13433 1201 6 must must MD 13433 1201 7 be be VB 13433 1201 8 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1201 9 . . . 13433 1202 1 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1202 2 's 's POS 13433 1202 3 account account NN 13433 1202 4 of of IN 13433 1202 5 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1202 6 is be VBZ 13433 1202 7 claimed claim VBN 13433 1202 8 by by IN 13433 1202 9 supporters supporter NNS 13433 1202 10 of of IN 13433 1202 11 the the DT 13433 1202 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1202 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1202 14 as as IN 13433 1202 15 evidence evidence NN 13433 1202 16 for for IN 13433 1202 17 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1202 18 . . . 13433 1203 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1203 2 103:1 103:1 CD 13433 1203 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1203 4 " " `` 13433 1203 5 The the DT 13433 1203 6 singular singular JJ 13433 1203 7 correspondence correspondence NN 13433 1203 8 in in IN 13433 1203 9 this this DT 13433 1203 10 narrative narrative NN 13433 1203 11 with with IN 13433 1203 12 the the DT 13433 1203 13 account account NN 13433 1203 14 of of IN 13433 1203 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1203 16 , , , 13433 1203 17 combined combine VBN 13433 1203 18 with with IN 13433 1203 19 some some DT 13433 1203 20 striking strike VBG 13433 1203 21 coincidences coincidence NNS 13433 1203 22 of of IN 13433 1203 23 expression expression NN 13433 1203 24 , , , 13433 1203 25 " " '' 13433 1203 26 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1203 27 argue argue VBP 13433 1203 28 , , , 13433 1203 29 show show VBP 13433 1203 30 " " '' 13433 1203 31 that that IN 13433 1203 32 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 1203 33 was be VBD 13433 1203 34 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1203 35 with with IN 13433 1203 36 the the DT 13433 1203 37 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1203 38 history history NN 13433 1203 39 , , , 13433 1203 40 if if IN 13433 1203 41 not not RB 13433 1203 42 with with IN 13433 1203 43 the the DT 13433 1203 44 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1203 45 letters letter NNS 13433 1203 46 . . . 13433 1203 47 " " '' 13433 1204 1 These these DT 13433 1204 2 are be VBP 13433 1204 3 the the DT 13433 1204 4 words word NNS 13433 1204 5 of of IN 13433 1204 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1204 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1204 8 , , , 13433 1204 9 although although IN 13433 1204 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1204 11 guards guard VBZ 13433 1204 12 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1204 13 , , , 13433 1204 14 in in IN 13433 1204 15 referring refer VBG 13433 1204 16 to to IN 13433 1204 17 this this DT 13433 1204 18 argument argument NN 13433 1204 19 , , , 13433 1204 20 by by IN 13433 1204 21 the the DT 13433 1204 22 words word NNS 13433 1204 23 " " `` 13433 1204 24 if if IN 13433 1204 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1204 26 be be VBP 13433 1204 27 true true JJ 13433 1204 28 , , , 13433 1204 29 " " '' 13433 1204 30 and and CC 13433 1204 31 does do VBZ 13433 1204 32 not not RB 13433 1204 33 express express VB 13433 1204 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1204 35 own own JJ 13433 1204 36 opinion opinion NN 13433 1204 37 ; ; : 13433 1204 38 but but CC 13433 1204 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1204 40 goes go VBZ 13433 1204 41 on on RP 13433 1204 42 to to TO 13433 1204 43 say say VB 13433 1204 44 : : : 13433 1204 45 " " `` 13433 1204 46 At at IN 13433 1204 47 all all DT 13433 1204 48 events event NNS 13433 1204 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1204 50 is be VBZ 13433 1204 51 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 1204 52 for for IN 13433 1204 53 the the DT 13433 1204 54 matter matter NN 13433 1204 55 in in IN 13433 1204 56 hand hand NN 13433 1204 57 , , , 13433 1204 58 as as IN 13433 1204 59 showing show VBG 13433 1204 60 that that IN 13433 1204 61 Christian christian JJ 13433 1204 62 prisoners prisoner NNS 13433 1204 63 were be VBD 13433 1204 64 treated treat VBN 13433 1204 65 in in IN 13433 1204 66 the the DT 13433 1204 67 very very JJ 13433 1204 68 way way NN 13433 1204 69 described describe VBN 13433 1204 70 in in IN 13433 1204 71 these these DT 13433 1204 72 epistles epistle NNS 13433 1204 73 . . . 13433 1204 74 " " '' 13433 1205 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1205 2 103:2 103:2 LS 13433 1205 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1205 4 On on IN 13433 1205 5 the the DT 13433 1205 6 contrary contrary NN 13433 1205 7 , , , 13433 1205 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1205 9 is be VBZ 13433 1205 10 in in IN 13433 1205 11 no no DT 13433 1205 12 case case NN 13433 1205 13 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 1205 14 of of IN 13433 1205 15 anything anything NN 13433 1205 16 . . . 13433 1206 1 If if IN 13433 1206 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1206 3 were be VBD 13433 1206 4 true true JJ 13433 1206 5 that that IN 13433 1206 6 Lucian lucian JJ 13433 1206 7 employed employ VBN 13433 1206 8 , , , 13433 1206 9 as as IN 13433 1206 10 the the DT 13433 1206 11 basis basis NN 13433 1206 12 of of IN 13433 1206 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1206 14 satire satire NN 13433 1206 15 , , , 13433 1206 16 the the DT 13433 1206 17 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1206 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1206 19 and and CC 13433 1206 20 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 13433 1206 21 , , , 13433 1206 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1206 23 is be VBZ 13433 1206 24 clear clear JJ 13433 1206 25 that that IN 13433 1206 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1206 27 narrative narrative NN 13433 1206 28 can can MD 13433 1206 29 not not RB 13433 1206 30 be be VB 13433 1206 31 used use VBN 13433 1206 32 as as IN 13433 1206 33 independent independent JJ 13433 1206 34 testimony testimony NN 13433 1206 35 for for IN 13433 1206 36 the the DT 13433 1206 37 truth truth NN 13433 1206 38 of of IN 13433 1206 39 the the DT 13433 1206 40 statements statement NNS 13433 1206 41 regarding regard VBG 13433 1206 42 the the DT 13433 1206 43 treatment treatment NN 13433 1206 44 of of IN 13433 1206 45 Christian christian JJ 13433 1206 46 prisoners prisoner NNS 13433 1206 47 . . . 13433 1207 1 On on IN 13433 1207 2 the the DT 13433 1207 3 other other JJ 13433 1207 4 hand hand NN 13433 1207 5 , , , 13433 1207 6 as as IN 13433 1207 7 this this DT 13433 1207 8 can can MD 13433 1207 9 not not RB 13433 1207 10 be be VB 13433 1207 11 shown show VBN 13433 1207 12 , , , 13433 1207 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1207 14 story story NN 13433 1207 15 remains remain VBZ 13433 1207 16 a a DT 13433 1207 17 mere mere JJ 13433 1207 18 satire satire NN 13433 1207 19 with with IN 13433 1207 20 very very RB 13433 1207 21 little little JJ 13433 1207 22 historical historical JJ 13433 1207 23 value value NN 13433 1207 24 . . . 13433 1208 1 Apart apart RB 13433 1208 2 from from IN 13433 1208 3 all all PDT 13433 1208 4 this this DT 13433 1208 5 , , , 13433 1208 6 however however RB 13433 1208 7 , , , 13433 1208 8 the the DT 13433 1208 9 case case NN 13433 1208 10 of of IN 13433 1208 11 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1208 12 , , , 13433 1208 13 a a DT 13433 1208 14 man man NN 13433 1208 15 confined confine VBN 13433 1208 16 in in IN 13433 1208 17 prison prison NN 13433 1208 18 for for IN 13433 1208 19 a a DT 13433 1208 20 short short JJ 13433 1208 21 time time NN 13433 1208 22 , , , 13433 1208 23 under under IN 13433 1208 24 a a DT 13433 1208 25 favourable favourable JJ 13433 1208 26 governor governor NN 13433 1208 27 , , , 13433 1208 28 and and CC 13433 1208 29 not not RB 13433 1208 30 pursued pursue VBN 13433 1208 31 with with IN 13433 1208 32 any any DT 13433 1208 33 severity severity NN 13433 1208 34 , , , 13433 1208 35 is be VBZ 13433 1208 36 no no DT 13433 1208 37 parallel parallel NN 13433 1208 38 to to IN 13433 1208 39 that that DT 13433 1208 40 of of IN 13433 1208 41 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1208 42 condemned condemn VBD 13433 1208 43 _ _ NNP 13433 1208 44 ad ad NN 13433 1208 45 bestias bestia NNS 13433 1208 46 _ _ NNP 13433 1208 47 and and CC 13433 1208 48 , , , 13433 1208 49 according accord VBG 13433 1208 50 to to IN 13433 1208 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1208 52 own own JJ 13433 1208 53 express express JJ 13433 1208 54 statement statement NN 13433 1208 55 , , , 13433 1208 56 cruelly cruelly RB 13433 1208 57 treated treat VBN 13433 1208 58 by by IN 13433 1208 59 the the DT 13433 1208 60 " " `` 13433 1208 61 ten ten CD 13433 1208 62 leopards leopard NNS 13433 1208 63 ; ; : 13433 1208 64 " " '' 13433 1208 65 and and CC 13433 1208 66 further further RB 13433 1208 67 the the DT 13433 1208 68 liberty liberty NN 13433 1208 69 of of IN 13433 1208 70 pseudo pseudo NNP 13433 1208 71 - - NNP 13433 1208 72 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1208 73 must must MD 13433 1208 74 greatly greatly RB 13433 1208 75 have have VB 13433 1208 76 exceeded exceed VBN 13433 1208 77 all all PDT 13433 1208 78 that that WDT 13433 1208 79 is be VBZ 13433 1208 80 said say VBN 13433 1208 81 of of IN 13433 1208 82 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 1208 83 , , , 13433 1208 84 if if IN 13433 1208 85 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1208 86 was be VBD 13433 1208 87 able able JJ 13433 1208 88 to to TO 13433 1208 89 write write VB 13433 1208 90 such such JJ 13433 1208 91 epistles epistle NNS 13433 1208 92 , , , 13433 1208 93 and and CC 13433 1208 94 hold hold VB 13433 1208 95 such such JJ 13433 1208 96 free free JJ 13433 1208 97 intercourse intercourse NN 13433 1208 98 as as IN 13433 1208 99 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1208 100 represent represent VBP 13433 1208 101 . . . 13433 1209 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1209 2 will will MD 13433 1209 3 now now RB 13433 1209 4 , , , 13433 1209 5 in in IN 13433 1209 6 the the DT 13433 1209 7 briefest brief JJS 13433 1209 8 manner manner NN 13433 1209 9 possible possible JJ 13433 1209 10 , , , 13433 1209 11 indicate indicate VBP 13433 1209 12 the the DT 13433 1209 13 arguments argument NNS 13433 1209 14 of of IN 13433 1209 15 the the DT 13433 1209 16 writers writer NNS 13433 1209 17 referred refer VBD 13433 1209 18 to to IN 13433 1209 19 in in IN 13433 1209 20 the the DT 13433 1209 21 note note NN 13433 1209 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1209 23 104:1 104:1 CD 13433 1209 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1209 25 attacked attack VBN 13433 1209 26 by by IN 13433 1209 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1209 28 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1209 29 , , , 13433 1209 30 in in IN 13433 1209 31 which which WDT 13433 1209 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1209 33 can can MD 13433 1209 34 not not RB 13433 1209 35 find find VB 13433 1209 36 any any DT 13433 1209 37 relevancy relevancy NN 13433 1209 38 , , , 13433 1209 39 but but CC 13433 1209 40 which which WDT 13433 1209 41 , , , 13433 1209 42 in in IN 13433 1209 43 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1209 44 opinion opinion NN 13433 1209 45 , , , 13433 1209 46 demonstrate demonstrate VBP 13433 1209 47 that that IN 13433 1209 48 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1209 49 was be VBD 13433 1209 50 not not RB 13433 1209 51 sent send VBN 13433 1209 52 to to IN 13433 1209 53 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1209 54 at at RB 13433 1209 55 all all RB 13433 1209 56 , , , 13433 1209 57 but but CC 13433 1209 58 suffered suffer VBN 13433 1209 59 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1209 60 in in IN 13433 1209 61 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1209 62 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1209 63 . . . 13433 1210 1 The the DT 13433 1210 2 reader reader NN 13433 1210 3 who who WP 13433 1210 4 wishes wish VBZ 13433 1210 5 to to TO 13433 1210 6 go go VB 13433 1210 7 minutely minutely RB 13433 1210 8 into into IN 13433 1210 9 the the DT 13433 1210 10 matter matter NN 13433 1210 11 must must MD 13433 1210 12 be be VB 13433 1210 13 good good JJ 13433 1210 14 enough enough RB 13433 1210 15 to to TO 13433 1210 16 consult consult VB 13433 1210 17 the the DT 13433 1210 18 writers writer NNS 13433 1210 19 there there RB 13433 1210 20 cited cite VBD 13433 1210 21 , , , 13433 1210 22 and and CC 13433 1210 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1210 24 will will MD 13433 1210 25 only only RB 13433 1210 26 sketch sketch VB 13433 1210 27 the the DT 13433 1210 28 case case NN 13433 1210 29 here here RB 13433 1210 30 , , , 13433 1210 31 without without IN 13433 1210 32 specifically specifically RB 13433 1210 33 indicating indicate VBG 13433 1210 34 the the DT 13433 1210 35 source source NN 13433 1210 36 of of IN 13433 1210 37 each each DT 13433 1210 38 argument argument NN 13433 1210 39 . . . 13433 1211 1 Where where WRB 13433 1211 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1211 3 add add VBP 13433 1211 4 any any DT 13433 1211 5 particulars particular NNS 13433 1211 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1211 7 will will MD 13433 1211 8 , , , 13433 1211 9 when when WRB 13433 1211 10 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1211 11 , , , 13433 1211 12 give give VB 13433 1211 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1211 14 authorities authority NNS 13433 1211 15 . . . 13433 1212 1 The the DT 13433 1212 2 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1212 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1212 4 and and CC 13433 1212 5 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 13433 1212 6 set set VBP 13433 1212 7 forth forth RP 13433 1212 8 that that IN 13433 1212 9 , , , 13433 1212 10 during during IN 13433 1212 11 a a DT 13433 1212 12 general general JJ 13433 1212 13 persecution persecution NN 13433 1212 14 of of IN 13433 1212 15 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1212 16 , , , 13433 1212 17 in in IN 13433 1212 18 Syria Syria NNP 13433 1212 19 at at IN 13433 1212 20 least least JJS 13433 1212 21 , , , 13433 1212 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1212 23 was be VBD 13433 1212 24 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1212 25 by by IN 13433 1212 26 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1212 27 , , , 13433 1212 28 when when WRB 13433 1212 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1212 30 wintered winter VBD 13433 1212 31 in in IN 13433 1212 32 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1212 33 during during IN 13433 1212 34 the the DT 13433 1212 35 Parthian Parthian NNP 13433 1212 36 War War NNP 13433 1212 37 , , , 13433 1212 38 to to TO 13433 1212 39 be be VB 13433 1212 40 taken take VBN 13433 1212 41 to to IN 13433 1212 42 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1212 43 and and CC 13433 1212 44 cast cast VBD 13433 1212 45 to to IN 13433 1212 46 wild wild JJ 13433 1212 47 beasts beast NNS 13433 1212 48 in in IN 13433 1212 49 the the DT 13433 1212 50 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1212 51 . . . 13433 1213 1 Instead instead RB 13433 1213 2 of of IN 13433 1213 3 being be VBG 13433 1213 4 sent send VBN 13433 1213 5 to to IN 13433 1213 6 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1213 7 by by IN 13433 1213 8 the the DT 13433 1213 9 short short NNP 13433 1213 10 sea sea NN 13433 1213 11 voyage voyage NN 13433 1213 12 , , , 13433 1213 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1213 14 is be VBZ 13433 1213 15 represented represent VBN 13433 1213 16 as as IN 13433 1213 17 taken take VBN 13433 1213 18 thither thither NN 13433 1213 19 by by IN 13433 1213 20 the the DT 13433 1213 21 long long JJ 13433 1213 22 and and CC 13433 1213 23 incomparably incomparably RB 13433 1213 24 more more RBR 13433 1213 25 difficult difficult JJ 13433 1213 26 land land NN 13433 1213 27 route route NN 13433 1213 28 . . . 13433 1214 1 The the DT 13433 1214 2 ten ten CD 13433 1214 3 soldiers soldier NNS 13433 1214 4 who who WP 13433 1214 5 guard guard VBP 13433 1214 6 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1214 7 are be VBP 13433 1214 8 described describe VBN 13433 1214 9 by by IN 13433 1214 10 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1214 11 as as IN 13433 1214 12 only only RB 13433 1214 13 rendered render VBN 13433 1214 14 more more RBR 13433 1214 15 cruel cruel JJ 13433 1214 16 by by IN 13433 1214 17 the the DT 13433 1214 18 presents present NNS 13433 1214 19 made make VBN 13433 1214 20 to to IN 13433 1214 21 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1214 22 to to TO 13433 1214 23 secure secure VB 13433 1214 24 kind kind JJ 13433 1214 25 treatment treatment NN 13433 1214 26 for for IN 13433 1214 27 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1214 28 , , , 13433 1214 29 so so IN 13433 1214 30 that that IN 13433 1214 31 not not RB 13433 1214 32 in in IN 13433 1214 33 the the DT 13433 1214 34 amphitheatre amphitheatre NN 13433 1214 35 only only RB 13433 1214 36 , , , 13433 1214 37 but but CC 13433 1214 38 all all PDT 13433 1214 39 the the DT 13433 1214 40 way way NN 13433 1214 41 from from IN 13433 1214 42 Syria Syria NNP 13433 1214 43 to to IN 13433 1214 44 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1214 45 , , , 13433 1214 46 by by IN 13433 1214 47 night night NN 13433 1214 48 and and CC 13433 1214 49 day day NN 13433 1214 50 , , , 13433 1214 51 by by IN 13433 1214 52 sea sea NN 13433 1214 53 and and CC 13433 1214 54 land land NN 13433 1214 55 , , , 13433 1214 56 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1214 57 " " `` 13433 1214 58 fights fight VBZ 13433 1214 59 with with IN 13433 1214 60 beasts beast NNS 13433 1214 61 . . . 13433 1214 62 " " '' 13433 1215 1 Notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 13433 1215 2 this this DT 13433 1215 3 severity severity NN 13433 1215 4 , , , 13433 1215 5 the the DT 13433 1215 6 martyr martyr NN 13433 1215 7 freely freely RB 13433 1215 8 receives receive VBZ 13433 1215 9 deputations deputation NNS 13433 1215 10 from from IN 13433 1215 11 the the DT 13433 1215 12 various various JJ 13433 1215 13 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1215 14 , , , 13433 1215 15 who who WP 13433 1215 16 , , , 13433 1215 17 far far RB 13433 1215 18 from from IN 13433 1215 19 being be VBG 13433 1215 20 molested molest VBN 13433 1215 21 , , , 13433 1215 22 are be VBP 13433 1215 23 able able JJ 13433 1215 24 to to TO 13433 1215 25 have have VB 13433 1215 26 constant constant JJ 13433 1215 27 intercourse intercourse NN 13433 1215 28 with with IN 13433 1215 29 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1215 30 , , , 13433 1215 31 and and CC 13433 1215 32 even even RB 13433 1215 33 to to TO 13433 1215 34 accompany accompany VB 13433 1215 35 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1215 36 on on IN 13433 1215 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1215 38 journey journey NN 13433 1215 39 . . . 13433 1216 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1216 2 not not RB 13433 1216 3 only only RB 13433 1216 4 converses converse VBZ 13433 1216 5 with with IN 13433 1216 6 these these DT 13433 1216 7 freely freely RB 13433 1216 8 , , , 13433 1216 9 but but CC 13433 1216 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1216 11 is be VBZ 13433 1216 12 represented represent VBN 13433 1216 13 as as IN 13433 1216 14 writing write VBG 13433 1216 15 long long RB 13433 1216 16 epistles epistle NNS 13433 1216 17 to to IN 13433 1216 18 the the DT 13433 1216 19 various various JJ 13433 1216 20 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1216 21 , , , 13433 1216 22 which which WDT 13433 1216 23 , , , 13433 1216 24 instead instead RB 13433 1216 25 of of IN 13433 1216 26 containing contain VBG 13433 1216 27 the the DT 13433 1216 28 last last JJ 13433 1216 29 exhortations exhortation NNS 13433 1216 30 and and CC 13433 1216 31 farewell farewell JJ 13433 1216 32 words word NNS 13433 1216 33 which which WDT 13433 1216 34 might may MD 13433 1216 35 be be VB 13433 1216 36 considered consider VBN 13433 1216 37 natural natural JJ 13433 1216 38 from from IN 13433 1216 39 the the DT 13433 1216 40 expectant expectant JJ 13433 1216 41 martyr martyr NN 13433 1216 42 , , , 13433 1216 43 are be VBP 13433 1216 44 filled fill VBN 13433 1216 45 with with IN 13433 1216 46 advanced advanced JJ 13433 1216 47 views view NNS 13433 1216 48 of of IN 13433 1216 49 Church Church NNP 13433 1216 50 government government NN 13433 1216 51 , , , 13433 1216 52 and and CC 13433 1216 53 the the DT 13433 1216 54 dignity dignity NN 13433 1216 55 of of IN 13433 1216 56 the the DT 13433 1216 57 episcopate episcopate NN 13433 1216 58 . . . 13433 1217 1 These these DT 13433 1217 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1217 3 , , , 13433 1217 4 at at IN 13433 1217 5 the the DT 13433 1217 6 outset outset NN 13433 1217 7 , , , 13433 1217 8 excite excite VB 13433 1217 9 grave grave JJ 13433 1217 10 suspicions suspicion NNS 13433 1217 11 of of IN 13433 1217 12 the the DT 13433 1217 13 truth truth NN 13433 1217 14 of of IN 13433 1217 15 the the DT 13433 1217 16 documents document NNS 13433 1217 17 and and CC 13433 1217 18 of of IN 13433 1217 19 the the DT 13433 1217 20 story story NN 13433 1217 21 which which WDT 13433 1217 22 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1217 23 set set VBD 13433 1217 24 forth forth RB 13433 1217 25 . . . 13433 1218 1 When when WRB 13433 1218 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1218 3 enquire enquire VBP 13433 1218 4 whether whether IN 13433 1218 5 the the DT 13433 1218 6 alleged allege VBN 13433 1218 7 facts fact NNS 13433 1218 8 of of IN 13433 1218 9 the the DT 13433 1218 10 case case NN 13433 1218 11 are be VBP 13433 1218 12 supported support VBN 13433 1218 13 by by IN 13433 1218 14 historical historical JJ 13433 1218 15 data datum NNS 13433 1218 16 , , , 13433 1218 17 the the DT 13433 1218 18 reply reply NN 13433 1218 19 is be VBZ 13433 1218 20 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 1218 21 adverse adverse JJ 13433 1218 22 . . . 13433 1219 1 All all DT 13433 1219 2 that that WDT 13433 1219 3 is be VBZ 13433 1219 4 known know VBN 13433 1219 5 of of IN 13433 1219 6 the the DT 13433 1219 7 treatment treatment NN 13433 1219 8 of of IN 13433 1219 9 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1219 10 during during IN 13433 1219 11 the the DT 13433 1219 12 reign reign NN 13433 1219 13 of of IN 13433 1219 14 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1219 15 , , , 13433 1219 16 as as RB 13433 1219 17 well well RB 13433 1219 18 as as IN 13433 1219 19 of of IN 13433 1219 20 the the DT 13433 1219 21 character character NN 13433 1219 22 of of IN 13433 1219 23 the the DT 13433 1219 24 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1219 25 , , , 13433 1219 26 is be VBZ 13433 1219 27 opposed oppose VBN 13433 1219 28 to to IN 13433 1219 29 the the DT 13433 1219 30 supposition supposition NN 13433 1219 31 that that IN 13433 1219 32 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1219 33 could could MD 13433 1219 34 have have VB 13433 1219 35 been be VBN 13433 1219 36 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1219 37 by by IN 13433 1219 38 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1219 39 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1219 40 , , , 13433 1219 41 or or CC 13433 1219 42 even even RB 13433 1219 43 by by IN 13433 1219 44 a a DT 13433 1219 45 provincial provincial JJ 13433 1219 46 governor governor NN 13433 1219 47 , , , 13433 1219 48 to to TO 13433 1219 49 be be VB 13433 1219 50 taken take VBN 13433 1219 51 to to IN 13433 1219 52 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1219 53 and and CC 13433 1219 54 there there RB 13433 1219 55 cast cast VBD 13433 1219 56 to to IN 13433 1219 57 the the DT 13433 1219 58 beasts beast NNS 13433 1219 59 . . . 13433 1220 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1220 2 is be VBZ 13433 1220 3 well well RB 13433 1220 4 known know VBN 13433 1220 5 that that IN 13433 1220 6 under under IN 13433 1220 7 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1220 8 there there EX 13433 1220 9 was be VBD 13433 1220 10 no no DT 13433 1220 11 general general JJ 13433 1220 12 persecution persecution NN 13433 1220 13 of of IN 13433 1220 14 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1220 15 , , , 13433 1220 16 although although IN 13433 1220 17 there there EX 13433 1220 18 may may MD 13433 1220 19 have have VB 13433 1220 20 been be VBN 13433 1220 21 instances instance NNS 13433 1220 22 in in IN 13433 1220 23 which which WDT 13433 1220 24 prominent prominent JJ 13433 1220 25 members member NNS 13433 1220 26 of of IN 13433 1220 27 the the DT 13433 1220 28 body body NN 13433 1220 29 were be VBD 13433 1220 30 either either CC 13433 1220 31 punished punish VBN 13433 1220 32 or or CC 13433 1220 33 fell fall VBD 13433 1220 34 victims victim NNS 13433 1220 35 to to IN 13433 1220 36 popular popular JJ 13433 1220 37 fury fury NN 13433 1220 38 and and CC 13433 1220 39 superstition superstition NN 13433 1220 40 . . . 13433 1221 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1221 2 105:1 105:1 LS 13433 1221 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1221 4 An an DT 13433 1221 5 instance instance NN 13433 1221 6 of of IN 13433 1221 7 this this DT 13433 1221 8 kind kind NN 13433 1221 9 was be VBD 13433 1221 10 the the DT 13433 1221 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1221 12 of of IN 13433 1221 13 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 1221 14 , , , 13433 1221 15 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 1221 16 of of IN 13433 1221 17 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 1221 18 , , , 13433 1221 19 reported report VBN 13433 1221 20 by by IN 13433 1221 21 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 1221 22 . . . 13433 1222 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1222 2 was be VBD 13433 1222 3 not not RB 13433 1222 4 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1222 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1222 6 ad ad NN 13433 1222 7 bestias bestia NNS 13433 1222 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1222 9 , , , 13433 1222 10 however however RB 13433 1222 11 , , , 13433 1222 12 and and CC 13433 1222 13 much much RB 13433 1222 14 less less RBR 13433 1222 15 deported deported JJ 13433 1222 16 to to IN 13433 1222 17 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1222 18 for for IN 13433 1222 19 the the DT 13433 1222 20 purpose purpose NN 13433 1222 21 . . . 13433 1223 1 Why why WRB 13433 1223 2 should should MD 13433 1223 3 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1223 4 have have VB 13433 1223 5 been be VBN 13433 1223 6 so so RB 13433 1223 7 exceptionally exceptionally RB 13433 1223 8 treated treat VBN 13433 1223 9 ? ? . 13433 1224 1 In in IN 13433 1224 2 fact fact NN 13433 1224 3 , , , 13433 1224 4 even even RB 13433 1224 5 during during IN 13433 1224 6 the the DT 13433 1224 7 persecutions persecution NNS 13433 1224 8 under under IN 13433 1224 9 Marcus Marcus NNP 13433 1224 10 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 13433 1224 11 , , , 13433 1224 12 although although IN 13433 1224 13 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1224 14 in in IN 13433 1224 15 Syria Syria NNP 13433 1224 16 were be VBD 13433 1224 17 frequently frequently RB 13433 1224 18 enough enough RB 13433 1224 19 cast cast VBN 13433 1224 20 to to IN 13433 1224 21 the the DT 13433 1224 22 beasts beast NNS 13433 1224 23 , , , 13433 1224 24 there there EX 13433 1224 25 is be VBZ 13433 1224 26 no no DT 13433 1224 27 instance instance NN 13433 1224 28 recorded record VBN 13433 1224 29 in in IN 13433 1224 30 which which WDT 13433 1224 31 anyone anyone NN 13433 1224 32 condemned condemn VBD 13433 1224 33 to to IN 13433 1224 34 this this DT 13433 1224 35 fate fate NN 13433 1224 36 was be VBD 13433 1224 37 sent send VBN 13433 1224 38 to to IN 13433 1224 39 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1224 40 . . . 13433 1225 1 Such such PDT 13433 1225 2 a a DT 13433 1225 3 sentence sentence NN 13433 1225 4 is be VBZ 13433 1225 5 quite quite RB 13433 1225 6 at at IN 13433 1225 7 variance variance NN 13433 1225 8 with with IN 13433 1225 9 the the DT 13433 1225 10 clement clement JJ 13433 1225 11 character character NN 13433 1225 12 of of IN 13433 1225 13 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1225 14 and and CC 13433 1225 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1225 16 principles principle NNS 13433 1225 17 of of IN 13433 1225 18 government government NN 13433 1225 19 . . . 13433 1226 1 Neander neander NN 13433 1226 2 , , , 13433 1226 3 in in IN 13433 1226 4 a a DT 13433 1226 5 passage passage NN 13433 1226 6 quoted quote VBN 13433 1226 7 by by IN 13433 1226 8 Baur Baur NNP 13433 1226 9 , , , 13433 1226 10 says say VBZ 13433 1226 11 : : : 13433 1226 12 " " `` 13433 1226 13 As as IN 13433 1226 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1226 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1226 16 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1226 17 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1226 18 , , , 13433 1226 19 like like IN 13433 1226 20 Pliny Pliny NNP 13433 1226 21 , , , 13433 1226 22 considered consider VBN 13433 1226 23 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1226 24 mere mere JJ 13433 1226 25 fanaticism fanaticism NN 13433 1226 26 , , , 13433 1226 27 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1226 28 also also RB 13433 1226 29 probably probably RB 13433 1226 30 thought think VBD 13433 1226 31 that that IN 13433 1226 32 if if IN 13433 1226 33 severity severity NN 13433 1226 34 were be VBD 13433 1226 35 combined combine VBN 13433 1226 36 with with IN 13433 1226 37 clemency clemency NN 13433 1226 38 , , , 13433 1226 39 if if IN 13433 1226 40 too too RB 13433 1226 41 much much JJ 13433 1226 42 noise noise NN 13433 1226 43 were be VBD 13433 1226 44 not not RB 13433 1226 45 made make VBN 13433 1226 46 about about IN 13433 1226 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1226 48 , , , 13433 1226 49 the the DT 13433 1226 50 open open JJ 13433 1226 51 demonstration demonstration NN 13433 1226 52 not not RB 13433 1226 53 left leave VBN 13433 1226 54 unpunished unpunished JJ 13433 1226 55 but but CC 13433 1226 56 also also RB 13433 1226 57 minds mind NNS 13433 1226 58 not not RB 13433 1226 59 stirred stir VBN 13433 1226 60 up up RP 13433 1226 61 by by IN 13433 1226 62 persecution persecution NN 13433 1226 63 , , , 13433 1226 64 the the DT 13433 1226 65 fanatical fanatical JJ 13433 1226 66 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 13433 1226 67 would would MD 13433 1226 68 most most RBS 13433 1226 69 easily easily RB 13433 1226 70 cool cool JJ 13433 1226 71 down down RP 13433 1226 72 , , , 13433 1226 73 and and CC 13433 1226 74 the the DT 13433 1226 75 matter matter NN 13433 1226 76 by by IN 13433 1226 77 degrees degree NNS 13433 1226 78 come come VBP 13433 1226 79 to to IN 13433 1226 80 an an DT 13433 1226 81 end end NN 13433 1226 82 . . . 13433 1226 83 " " '' 13433 1227 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1227 2 106:1 106:1 LS 13433 1227 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1227 4 This this DT 13433 1227 5 was be VBD 13433 1227 6 certainly certainly RB 13433 1227 7 the the DT 13433 1227 8 policy policy NN 13433 1227 9 which which WDT 13433 1227 10 mainly mainly RB 13433 1227 11 characterised characterise VBD 13433 1227 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1227 13 reign reign NN 13433 1227 14 . . . 13433 1228 1 Now now RB 13433 1228 2 not not RB 13433 1228 3 only only RB 13433 1228 4 would would MD 13433 1228 5 this this DT 13433 1228 6 severe severe JJ 13433 1228 7 sentence sentence NN 13433 1228 8 have have VBP 13433 1228 9 been be VBN 13433 1228 10 contrary contrary JJ 13433 1228 11 to to IN 13433 1228 12 such such JJ 13433 1228 13 principles principle NNS 13433 1228 14 , , , 13433 1228 15 but but CC 13433 1228 16 the the DT 13433 1228 17 agitation agitation NN 13433 1228 18 excited excite VBN 13433 1228 19 would would MD 13433 1228 20 have have VB 13433 1228 21 been be VBN 13433 1228 22 enormously enormously RB 13433 1228 23 increased increase VBN 13433 1228 24 by by IN 13433 1228 25 sending send VBG 13433 1228 26 the the DT 13433 1228 27 martyr martyr NN 13433 1228 28 a a DT 13433 1228 29 long long JJ 13433 1228 30 journey journey NN 13433 1228 31 by by IN 13433 1228 32 land land NN 13433 1228 33 through through IN 13433 1228 34 Asia Asia NNP 13433 1228 35 , , , 13433 1228 36 and and CC 13433 1228 37 allowing allow VBG 13433 1228 38 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1228 39 to to TO 13433 1228 40 pass pass VB 13433 1228 41 through through RP 13433 1228 42 some some DT 13433 1228 43 of of IN 13433 1228 44 the the DT 13433 1228 45 principal principal JJ 13433 1228 46 cities city NNS 13433 1228 47 , , , 13433 1228 48 hold hold VB 13433 1228 49 constant constant JJ 13433 1228 50 intercourse intercourse NN 13433 1228 51 with with IN 13433 1228 52 the the DT 13433 1228 53 various various JJ 13433 1228 54 Christian christian JJ 13433 1228 55 communities community NNS 13433 1228 56 , , , 13433 1228 57 and and CC 13433 1228 58 address address NN 13433 1228 59 long long JJ 13433 1228 60 epistles epistle NNS 13433 1228 61 to to IN 13433 1228 62 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1228 63 . . . 13433 1229 1 With with IN 13433 1229 2 the the DT 13433 1229 3 fervid fervid JJ 13433 1229 4 desire desire NN 13433 1229 5 for for IN 13433 1229 6 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1229 7 then then RB 13433 1229 8 prevalent prevalent JJ 13433 1229 9 , , , 13433 1229 10 such such PDT 13433 1229 11 a a DT 13433 1229 12 journey journey NN 13433 1229 13 would would MD 13433 1229 14 have have VB 13433 1229 15 been be VBN 13433 1229 16 a a DT 13433 1229 17 triumphal triumphal NN 13433 1229 18 progress progress NN 13433 1229 19 , , , 13433 1229 20 spreading spread VBG 13433 1229 21 everywhere everywhere RB 13433 1229 22 excitement excitement NN 13433 1229 23 and and CC 13433 1229 24 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 13433 1229 25 . . . 13433 1230 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1230 2 may may MD 13433 1230 3 not not RB 13433 1230 4 be be VB 13433 1230 5 out out IN 13433 1230 6 of of IN 13433 1230 7 place place NN 13433 1230 8 , , , 13433 1230 9 as as IN 13433 1230 10 an an DT 13433 1230 11 indication indication NN 13433 1230 12 of of IN 13433 1230 13 the the DT 13433 1230 14 results result NNS 13433 1230 15 of of IN 13433 1230 16 impartial impartial JJ 13433 1230 17 examination examination NN 13433 1230 18 , , , 13433 1230 19 to to TO 13433 1230 20 point point VB 13433 1230 21 out out RP 13433 1230 22 that that IN 13433 1230 23 Neander Neander NNP 13433 1230 24 's 's POS 13433 1230 25 inability inability NN 13433 1230 26 to to TO 13433 1230 27 accept accept VB 13433 1230 28 the the DT 13433 1230 29 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1230 30 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1230 31 largely largely RB 13433 1230 32 rests rest VBZ 13433 1230 33 on on IN 13433 1230 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1230 35 disbelief disbelief NN 13433 1230 36 of of IN 13433 1230 37 the the DT 13433 1230 38 whole whole JJ 13433 1230 39 tradition tradition NN 13433 1230 40 of of IN 13433 1230 41 this this DT 13433 1230 42 sentence sentence NN 13433 1230 43 and and CC 13433 1230 44 martyr martyr NN 13433 1230 45 - - HYPH 13433 1230 46 journey journey NN 13433 1230 47 . . . 13433 1231 1 " " `` 13433 1231 2 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1231 3 do do VBP 13433 1231 4 not not RB 13433 1231 5 recognise recognise VB 13433 1231 6 the the DT 13433 1231 7 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1231 8 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1231 9 in in IN 13433 1231 10 this this DT 13433 1231 11 narrative narrative NN 13433 1231 12 " " '' 13433 1231 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1231 14 the the DT 13433 1231 15 martyrology martyrology NN 13433 1231 16 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1231 17 , , , 13433 1231 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1231 19 says say VBZ 13433 1231 20 , , , 13433 1231 21 " " `` 13433 1231 22 therefore therefore RB 13433 1231 23 can can MD 13433 1231 24 not not RB 13433 1231 25 but but CC 13433 1231 26 doubt doubt VB 13433 1231 27 everything everything NN 13433 1231 28 which which WDT 13433 1231 29 is be VBZ 13433 1231 30 related relate VBN 13433 1231 31 by by IN 13433 1231 32 this this DT 13433 1231 33 document document NN 13433 1231 34 , , , 13433 1231 35 as as RB 13433 1231 36 well well RB 13433 1231 37 as as IN 13433 1231 38 that that DT 13433 1231 39 , , , 13433 1231 40 during during IN 13433 1231 41 this this DT 13433 1231 42 reign reign NN 13433 1231 43 , , , 13433 1231 44 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1231 45 can can MD 13433 1231 46 have have VB 13433 1231 47 been be VBN 13433 1231 48 cast cast VBN 13433 1231 49 to to IN 13433 1231 50 the the DT 13433 1231 51 wild wild JJ 13433 1231 52 beasts beast NNS 13433 1231 53 . . . 13433 1231 54 " " '' 13433 1232 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1232 2 106:2 106:2 CD 13433 1232 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1232 4 If if IN 13433 1232 5 , , , 13433 1232 6 for for IN 13433 1232 7 a a DT 13433 1232 8 moment moment NN 13433 1232 9 , , , 13433 1232 10 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1232 11 suppose suppose VBP 13433 1232 12 that that IN 13433 1232 13 , , , 13433 1232 14 instead instead RB 13433 1232 15 of of IN 13433 1232 16 being be VBG 13433 1232 17 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1232 18 by by IN 13433 1232 19 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1232 20 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1232 21 , , , 13433 1232 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1232 23 received receive VBD 13433 1232 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1232 25 sentence sentence NN 13433 1232 26 from from IN 13433 1232 27 a a DT 13433 1232 28 provincial provincial JJ 13433 1232 29 governor governor NN 13433 1232 30 , , , 13433 1232 31 the the DT 13433 1232 32 story story NN 13433 1232 33 does do VBZ 13433 1232 34 not not RB 13433 1232 35 gain gain VB 13433 1232 36 greater great JJR 13433 1232 37 probability probability NN 13433 1232 38 . . . 13433 1233 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1233 2 is be VBZ 13433 1233 3 not not RB 13433 1233 4 credible credible JJ 13433 1233 5 that that IN 13433 1233 6 such such PDT 13433 1233 7 an an DT 13433 1233 8 official official NN 13433 1233 9 would would MD 13433 1233 10 have have VB 13433 1233 11 ventured venture VBN 13433 1233 12 to to TO 13433 1233 13 act act VB 13433 1233 14 so so RB 13433 1233 15 much much RB 13433 1233 16 in in IN 13433 1233 17 opposition opposition NN 13433 1233 18 to to IN 13433 1233 19 the the DT 13433 1233 20 spirit spirit NN 13433 1233 21 of of IN 13433 1233 22 the the DT 13433 1233 23 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1233 24 's 's POS 13433 1233 25 government government NN 13433 1233 26 . . . 13433 1234 1 Besides besides IN 13433 1234 2 , , , 13433 1234 3 if if IN 13433 1234 4 such such PDT 13433 1234 5 a a DT 13433 1234 6 governor governor NN 13433 1234 7 did do VBD 13433 1234 8 pronounce pronounce NN 13433 1234 9 so so RB 13433 1234 10 severe severe JJ 13433 1234 11 a a DT 13433 1234 12 sentence sentence NN 13433 1234 13 , , , 13433 1234 14 why why WRB 13433 1234 15 did do VBD 13433 1234 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1234 17 not not RB 13433 1234 18 execute execute VB 13433 1234 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1234 20 in in IN 13433 1234 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1234 22 ? ? . 13433 1235 1 Why why WRB 13433 1235 2 send send VB 13433 1235 3 the the DT 13433 1235 4 prisoner prisoner NN 13433 1235 5 to to IN 13433 1235 6 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1235 7 ? ? . 13433 1236 1 By by IN 13433 1236 2 doing do VBG 13433 1236 3 so so RB 13433 1236 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1236 5 made make VBD 13433 1236 6 all all PDT 13433 1236 7 the the DT 13433 1236 8 more more RBR 13433 1236 9 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 13433 1236 10 a a DT 13433 1236 11 severity severity NN 13433 1236 12 which which WDT 13433 1236 13 was be VBD 13433 1236 14 not not RB 13433 1236 15 likely likely JJ 13433 1236 16 to to TO 13433 1236 17 be be VB 13433 1236 18 pleasing pleasing JJ 13433 1236 19 to to IN 13433 1236 20 the the DT 13433 1236 21 clement clement JJ 13433 1236 22 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1236 23 . . . 13433 1237 1 The the DT 13433 1237 2 cruelty cruelty NN 13433 1237 3 which which WDT 13433 1237 4 dictated dictate VBD 13433 1237 5 a a DT 13433 1237 6 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1237 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1237 8 ad ad NN 13433 1237 9 bestias bestia NNS 13433 1237 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1237 11 would would MD 13433 1237 12 have have VB 13433 1237 13 been be VBN 13433 1237 14 more more RBR 13433 1237 15 gratified gratified JJ 13433 1237 16 by by IN 13433 1237 17 execution execution NN 13433 1237 18 on on IN 13433 1237 19 the the DT 13433 1237 20 spot spot NN 13433 1237 21 , , , 13433 1237 22 and and CC 13433 1237 23 there there EX 13433 1237 24 is be VBZ 13433 1237 25 besides besides IN 13433 1237 26 no no DT 13433 1237 27 instance instance NN 13433 1237 28 known know VBN 13433 1237 29 , , , 13433 1237 30 even even RB 13433 1237 31 during during IN 13433 1237 32 the the DT 13433 1237 33 following follow VBG 13433 1237 34 general general JJ 13433 1237 35 persecution persecution NN 13433 1237 36 , , , 13433 1237 37 of of IN 13433 1237 38 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1237 39 being be VBG 13433 1237 40 sent send VBN 13433 1237 41 for for IN 13433 1237 42 execution execution NN 13433 1237 43 in in IN 13433 1237 44 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1237 45 . . . 13433 1238 1 The the DT 13433 1238 2 transport transport NN 13433 1238 3 to to IN 13433 1238 4 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1238 5 is be VBZ 13433 1238 6 in in IN 13433 1238 7 no no DT 13433 1238 8 case case NN 13433 1238 9 credible credible JJ 13433 1238 10 , , , 13433 1238 11 and and CC 13433 1238 12 the the DT 13433 1238 13 utmost utmost JJ 13433 1238 14 that that WDT 13433 1238 15 can can MD 13433 1238 16 be be VB 13433 1238 17 admitted admit VBN 13433 1238 18 is be VBZ 13433 1238 19 , , , 13433 1238 20 that that IN 13433 1238 21 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1238 22 , , , 13433 1238 23 like like IN 13433 1238 24 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 1238 25 of of IN 13433 1238 26 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 1238 27 , , , 13433 1238 28 may may MD 13433 1238 29 have have VB 13433 1238 30 been be VBN 13433 1238 31 condemned condemn VBN 13433 1238 32 to to IN 13433 1238 33 death death NN 13433 1238 34 during during IN 13433 1238 35 this this DT 13433 1238 36 reign reign NN 13433 1238 37 , , , 13433 1238 38 more more RBR 13433 1238 39 especially especially RB 13433 1238 40 if if IN 13433 1238 41 the the DT 13433 1238 42 event event NN 13433 1238 43 be be VB 13433 1238 44 associated associate VBN 13433 1238 45 with with IN 13433 1238 46 some some DT 13433 1238 47 sudden sudden JJ 13433 1238 48 outbreak outbreak NN 13433 1238 49 of of IN 13433 1238 50 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1238 51 fury fury NN 13433 1238 52 against against IN 13433 1238 53 the the DT 13433 1238 54 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1238 55 , , , 13433 1238 56 to to TO 13433 1238 57 which which WDT 13433 1238 58 the the DT 13433 1238 59 martyr martyr NN 13433 1238 60 may may MD 13433 1238 61 at at IN 13433 1238 62 once once RB 13433 1238 63 have have VBP 13433 1238 64 fallen fall VBN 13433 1238 65 a a DT 13433 1238 66 victim victim NN 13433 1238 67 . . . 13433 1239 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1239 2 are be VBP 13433 1239 3 not not RB 13433 1239 4 without without IN 13433 1239 5 indications indication NNS 13433 1239 6 of of IN 13433 1239 7 such such PDT 13433 1239 8 a a DT 13433 1239 9 cause cause NN 13433 1239 10 operating operate VBG 13433 1239 11 in in IN 13433 1239 12 the the DT 13433 1239 13 case case NN 13433 1239 14 of of IN 13433 1239 15 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1239 16 . . . 13433 1240 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1240 2 is be VBZ 13433 1240 3 generally generally RB 13433 1240 4 admitted admit VBN 13433 1240 5 that that IN 13433 1240 6 the the DT 13433 1240 7 date date NN 13433 1240 8 of of IN 13433 1240 9 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1240 10 's 's POS 13433 1240 11 visit visit NN 13433 1240 12 to to IN 13433 1240 13 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1240 14 is be VBZ 13433 1240 15 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1240 16 115 115 CD 13433 1240 17 , , , 13433 1240 18 when when WRB 13433 1240 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1240 20 wintered winter VBD 13433 1240 21 there there RB 13433 1240 22 during during IN 13433 1240 23 the the DT 13433 1240 24 Parthian Parthian NNP 13433 1240 25 War War NNP 13433 1240 26 . . . 13433 1241 1 An an DT 13433 1241 2 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1241 3 occurred occur VBD 13433 1241 4 on on IN 13433 1241 5 the the DT 13433 1241 6 13th 13th JJ 13433 1241 7 December December NNP 13433 1241 8 of of IN 13433 1241 9 that that DT 13433 1241 10 year year NN 13433 1241 11 , , , 13433 1241 12 which which WDT 13433 1241 13 was be VBD 13433 1241 14 well well RB 13433 1241 15 calculated calculate VBN 13433 1241 16 to to TO 13433 1241 17 excite excite VB 13433 1241 18 popular popular JJ 13433 1241 19 superstition superstition NN 13433 1241 20 . . . 13433 1242 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1242 2 may may MD 13433 1242 3 not not RB 13433 1242 4 be be VB 13433 1242 5 out out IN 13433 1242 6 of of IN 13433 1242 7 place place NN 13433 1242 8 to to TO 13433 1242 9 quote quote VB 13433 1242 10 here here RB 13433 1242 11 the the DT 13433 1242 12 account account NN 13433 1242 13 of of IN 13433 1242 14 the the DT 13433 1242 15 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1242 16 given give VBN 13433 1242 17 by by IN 13433 1242 18 Dean Dean NNP 13433 1242 19 Milman Milman NNP 13433 1242 20 , , , 13433 1242 21 who who WP 13433 1242 22 , , , 13433 1242 23 although although IN 13433 1242 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1242 25 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1242 26 a a DT 13433 1242 27 different different JJ 13433 1242 28 date date NN 13433 1242 29 , , , 13433 1242 30 and and CC 13433 1242 31 adheres adhere VBZ 13433 1242 32 to to IN 13433 1242 33 the the DT 13433 1242 34 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1242 35 in in IN 13433 1242 36 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1242 37 , , , 13433 1242 38 still still RB 13433 1242 39 associates associate VBZ 13433 1242 40 the the DT 13433 1242 41 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1242 42 of of IN 13433 1242 43 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1242 44 with with IN 13433 1242 45 the the DT 13433 1242 46 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1242 47 . . . 13433 1243 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1243 2 says say VBZ 13433 1243 3 : : : 13433 1243 4 " " `` 13433 1243 5 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 13433 1243 6 , , , 13433 1243 7 at at IN 13433 1243 8 that that DT 13433 1243 9 time time NN 13433 1243 10 there there EX 13433 1243 11 were be VBD 13433 1243 12 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1243 13 which which WDT 13433 1243 14 account account VBP 13433 1243 15 with with IN 13433 1243 16 singular singular JJ 13433 1243 17 likelihood likelihood NN 13433 1243 18 for for IN 13433 1243 19 that that DT 13433 1243 20 sudden sudden JJ 13433 1243 21 outburst outburst NN 13433 1243 22 of of IN 13433 1243 23 persecution persecution NN 13433 1243 24 in in IN 13433 1243 25 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1243 26 ... ... . 13433 1243 27 At at IN 13433 1243 28 this this DT 13433 1243 29 very very JJ 13433 1243 30 time time NN 13433 1243 31 an an DT 13433 1243 32 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1243 33 , , , 13433 1243 34 more more JJR 13433 1243 35 than than IN 13433 1243 36 usually usually RB 13433 1243 37 terrible terrible JJ 13433 1243 38 and and CC 13433 1243 39 destructive destructive JJ 13433 1243 40 , , , 13433 1243 41 shook shake VBD 13433 1243 42 the the DT 13433 1243 43 cities city NNS 13433 1243 44 of of IN 13433 1243 45 the the DT 13433 1243 46 East East NNP 13433 1243 47 . . . 13433 1244 1 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1244 2 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1244 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1244 4 most most RBS 13433 1244 5 appalling appalling JJ 13433 1244 6 ravages ravage NNS 13433 1244 7 -- -- : 13433 1244 8 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1244 9 , , , 13433 1244 10 crowded crowd VBD 13433 1244 11 with with IN 13433 1244 12 the the DT 13433 1244 13 legionaries legionary NNS 13433 1244 14 prepared prepare VBN 13433 1244 15 for for IN 13433 1244 16 the the DT 13433 1244 17 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1244 18 's 's POS 13433 1244 19 invasion invasion NN 13433 1244 20 of of IN 13433 1244 21 the the DT 13433 1244 22 East East NNP 13433 1244 23 , , , 13433 1244 24 with with IN 13433 1244 25 ambassadors ambassador NNS 13433 1244 26 and and CC 13433 1244 27 tributary tributary JJ 13433 1244 28 kings king NNS 13433 1244 29 from from IN 13433 1244 30 all all DT 13433 1244 31 parts part NNS 13433 1244 32 of of IN 13433 1244 33 the the DT 13433 1244 34 East East NNP 13433 1244 35 . . . 13433 1245 1 The the DT 13433 1245 2 city city NN 13433 1245 3 shook shake VBD 13433 1245 4 through through IN 13433 1245 5 all all DT 13433 1245 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1245 7 streets street NNS 13433 1245 8 ; ; : 13433 1245 9 houses house NNS 13433 1245 10 , , , 13433 1245 11 palaces palace NNS 13433 1245 12 , , , 13433 1245 13 theatres theatre NNS 13433 1245 14 , , , 13433 1245 15 temples temple NNS 13433 1245 16 fell fall VBD 13433 1245 17 crashing crash VBG 13433 1245 18 down down RP 13433 1245 19 . . . 13433 1246 1 Many many JJ 13433 1246 2 were be VBD 13433 1246 3 killed kill VBN 13433 1246 4 : : : 13433 1246 5 the the DT 13433 1246 6 Consul Consul NNP 13433 1246 7 Pedo Pedo NNP 13433 1246 8 died die VBD 13433 1246 9 of of IN 13433 1246 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1246 11 hurts hurt NNS 13433 1246 12 . . . 13433 1247 1 The the DT 13433 1247 2 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1247 3 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1247 4 hardly hardly RB 13433 1247 5 escaped escape VBD 13433 1247 6 through through IN 13433 1247 7 a a DT 13433 1247 8 window window NN 13433 1247 9 , , , 13433 1247 10 and and CC 13433 1247 11 took take VBD 13433 1247 12 refuge refuge NN 13433 1247 13 in in IN 13433 1247 14 the the DT 13433 1247 15 Circus Circus NNP 13433 1247 16 , , , 13433 1247 17 where where WRB 13433 1247 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1247 19 passed pass VBD 13433 1247 20 some some DT 13433 1247 21 days day NNS 13433 1247 22 in in IN 13433 1247 23 the the DT 13433 1247 24 open open JJ 13433 1247 25 air air NN 13433 1247 26 . . . 13433 1248 1 Whence whence UH 13433 1248 2 this this DT 13433 1248 3 terrible terrible JJ 13433 1248 4 blow blow NN 13433 1248 5 but but CC 13433 1248 6 from from IN 13433 1248 7 the the DT 13433 1248 8 wrath wrath NN 13433 1248 9 of of IN 13433 1248 10 the the DT 13433 1248 11 Gods Gods NNPS 13433 1248 12 , , , 13433 1248 13 who who WP 13433 1248 14 must must MD 13433 1248 15 be be VB 13433 1248 16 appeased appease VBN 13433 1248 17 by by IN 13433 1248 18 unusual unusual JJ 13433 1248 19 sacrifices sacrifice NNS 13433 1248 20 ? ? . 13433 1249 1 This this DT 13433 1249 2 was be VBD 13433 1249 3 towards towards IN 13433 1249 4 the the DT 13433 1249 5 end end NN 13433 1249 6 of of IN 13433 1249 7 January January NNP 13433 1249 8 ; ; : 13433 1249 9 early early RB 13433 1249 10 in in IN 13433 1249 11 February February NNP 13433 1249 12 the the DT 13433 1249 13 Christian Christian NNP 13433 1249 14 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 1249 15 , , , 13433 1249 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1249 17 , , , 13433 1249 18 was be VBD 13433 1249 19 arrested arrest VBN 13433 1249 20 . . . 13433 1250 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1250 2 know know VBP 13433 1250 3 how how WRB 13433 1250 4 , , , 13433 1250 5 during during IN 13433 1250 6 this this DT 13433 1250 7 century century NN 13433 1250 8 , , , 13433 1250 9 at at IN 13433 1250 10 every every DT 13433 1250 11 period period NN 13433 1250 12 of of IN 13433 1250 13 public public JJ 13433 1250 14 calamity calamity NN 13433 1250 15 , , , 13433 1250 16 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1250 17 that that DT 13433 1250 18 calamity calamity NN 13433 1250 19 might may MD 13433 1250 20 be be VB 13433 1250 21 , , , 13433 1250 22 the the DT 13433 1250 23 cry cry NN 13433 1250 24 of of IN 13433 1250 25 the the DT 13433 1250 26 panic panic NN 13433 1250 27 - - HYPH 13433 1250 28 stricken stricken VBN 13433 1250 29 Heathens Heathens NNPS 13433 1250 30 was be VBD 13433 1250 31 , , , 13433 1250 32 ' ' '' 13433 1250 33 The the DT 13433 1250 34 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1250 35 to to IN 13433 1250 36 the the DT 13433 1250 37 lions lion NNS 13433 1250 38 ! ! . 13433 1250 39 ' ' '' 13433 1251 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1251 2 maybe maybe RB 13433 1251 3 that that IN 13433 1251 4 , , , 13433 1251 5 in in IN 13433 1251 6 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1251 7 's 's POS 13433 1251 8 humanity humanity NN 13433 1251 9 , , , 13433 1251 10 in in IN 13433 1251 11 order order NN 13433 1251 12 to to TO 13433 1251 13 prevent prevent VB 13433 1251 14 a a DT 13433 1251 15 general general JJ 13433 1251 16 massacre massacre NN 13433 1251 17 by by IN 13433 1251 18 the the DT 13433 1251 19 infuriated infuriate VBN 13433 1251 20 populace populace NN 13433 1251 21 , , , 13433 1251 22 or or CC 13433 1251 23 to to TO 13433 1251 24 give give VB 13433 1251 25 greater great JJR 13433 1251 26 solemnity solemnity NN 13433 1251 27 to to IN 13433 1251 28 the the DT 13433 1251 29 sacrifice sacrifice NN 13433 1251 30 , , , 13433 1251 31 the the DT 13433 1251 32 execution execution NN 13433 1251 33 was be VBD 13433 1251 34 ordered order VBN 13433 1251 35 to to TO 13433 1251 36 take take VB 13433 1251 37 place place NN 13433 1251 38 , , , 13433 1251 39 not not RB 13433 1251 40 in in IN 13433 1251 41 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1251 42 , , , 13433 1251 43 but but CC 13433 1251 44 in in IN 13433 1251 45 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1251 46 . . . 13433 1251 47 " " '' 13433 1252 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1252 2 108:1 108:1 CD 13433 1252 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1252 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1252 5 contend contend VBP 13433 1252 6 that that IN 13433 1252 7 these these DT 13433 1252 8 reasons reason NNS 13433 1252 9 , , , 13433 1252 10 on on IN 13433 1252 11 the the DT 13433 1252 12 contrary contrary NN 13433 1252 13 , , , 13433 1252 14 render render VB 13433 1252 15 execution execution NN 13433 1252 16 in in IN 13433 1252 17 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1252 18 infinitely infinitely RB 13433 1252 19 more more RBR 13433 1252 20 probable probable JJ 13433 1252 21 . . . 13433 1253 1 To to TO 13433 1253 2 continue continue VB 13433 1253 3 , , , 13433 1253 4 however however RB 13433 1253 5 : : : 13433 1253 6 the the DT 13433 1253 7 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1253 8 occurred occur VBD 13433 1253 9 on on IN 13433 1253 10 the the DT 13433 1253 11 13th 13th NN 13433 1253 12 , , , 13433 1253 13 and and CC 13433 1253 14 the the DT 13433 1253 15 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1253 16 of of IN 13433 1253 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1253 18 took take VBD 13433 1253 19 place place NN 13433 1253 20 on on IN 13433 1253 21 the the DT 13433 1253 22 20th 20th JJ 13433 1253 23 December December NNP 13433 1253 24 , , , 13433 1253 25 just just RB 13433 1253 26 a a DT 13433 1253 27 week week NN 13433 1253 28 after after IN 13433 1253 29 the the DT 13433 1253 30 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1253 31 . . . 13433 1254 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1254 2 remains remain NNS 13433 1254 3 , , , 13433 1254 4 as as IN 13433 1254 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1254 6 know know VBP 13433 1254 7 from from IN 13433 1254 8 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 1254 9 and and CC 13433 1254 10 others other NNS 13433 1254 11 , , , 13433 1254 12 were be VBD 13433 1254 13 , , , 13433 1254 14 as as IN 13433 1254 15 an an DT 13433 1254 16 actual actual JJ 13433 1254 17 fact fact NN 13433 1254 18 , , , 13433 1254 19 interred inter VBN 13433 1254 20 at at IN 13433 1254 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1254 22 . . . 13433 1255 1 The the DT 13433 1255 2 natural natural JJ 13433 1255 3 inference inference NN 13433 1255 4 is be VBZ 13433 1255 5 that that IN 13433 1255 6 the the DT 13433 1255 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1255 8 , , , 13433 1255 9 the the DT 13433 1255 10 only only JJ 13433 1255 11 part part NN 13433 1255 12 of of IN 13433 1255 13 the the DT 13433 1255 14 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1255 15 story story NN 13433 1255 16 which which WDT 13433 1255 17 is be VBZ 13433 1255 18 credible credible JJ 13433 1255 19 , , , 13433 1255 20 occurred occur VBD 13433 1255 21 not not RB 13433 1255 22 in in IN 13433 1255 23 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1255 24 but but CC 13433 1255 25 in in IN 13433 1255 26 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1255 27 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1255 28 , , , 13433 1255 29 in in IN 13433 1255 30 consequence consequence NN 13433 1255 31 of of IN 13433 1255 32 the the DT 13433 1255 33 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1255 34 fury fury NN 13433 1255 35 against against IN 13433 1255 36 the the DT 13433 1255 37 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1255 38 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1255 39 : : : 13433 1255 40 atheoi atheoi NN 13433 1255 41 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1255 42 aroused arouse VBN 13433 1255 43 by by IN 13433 1255 44 the the DT 13433 1255 45 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1255 46 . . . 13433 1256 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1256 2 will will MD 13433 1256 3 now now RB 13433 1256 4 go go VB 13433 1256 5 more more RBR 13433 1256 6 into into IN 13433 1256 7 the the DT 13433 1256 8 details detail NNS 13433 1256 9 of of IN 13433 1256 10 the the DT 13433 1256 11 brief brief JJ 13433 1256 12 statements statement NNS 13433 1256 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1256 14 have have VBP 13433 1256 15 just just RB 13433 1256 16 made make VBN 13433 1256 17 , , , 13433 1256 18 and and CC 13433 1256 19 here here RB 13433 1256 20 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1256 21 come come VBP 13433 1256 22 for for IN 13433 1256 23 the the DT 13433 1256 24 first first JJ 13433 1256 25 time time NN 13433 1256 26 to to IN 13433 1256 27 John John NNP 13433 1256 28 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1256 29 . . . 13433 1257 1 In in IN 13433 1257 2 the the DT 13433 1257 3 first first JJ 13433 1257 4 place place NN 13433 1257 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1257 6 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1257 7 the the DT 13433 1257 8 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 1257 9 of of IN 13433 1257 10 the the DT 13433 1257 11 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1257 12 on on IN 13433 1257 13 the the DT 13433 1257 14 13th 13th JJ 13433 1257 15 December December NNP 13433 1257 16 . . . 13433 1258 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1258 2 will will MD 13433 1258 3 quote quote VB 13433 1258 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1258 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1258 6 's 's POS 13433 1258 7 own own JJ 13433 1258 8 rendering rendering NN 13433 1258 9 of of IN 13433 1258 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1258 11 further further JJ 13433 1258 12 important important JJ 13433 1258 13 statement statement NN 13433 1258 14 . . . 13433 1259 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1259 2 says:-- says:-- : 13433 1259 3 " " `` 13433 1259 4 The the DT 13433 1259 5 words word NNS 13433 1259 6 of of IN 13433 1259 7 John John NNP 13433 1259 8 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1259 9 are be VBP 13433 1259 10 : : : 13433 1259 11 The the DT 13433 1259 12 same same JJ 13433 1259 13 king king NN 13433 1259 14 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1259 15 was be VBD 13433 1259 16 residing reside VBG 13433 1259 17 in in IN 13433 1259 18 the the DT 13433 1259 19 same same JJ 13433 1259 20 city city NN 13433 1259 21 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1259 22 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1259 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1259 24 when when WRB 13433 1259 25 the the DT 13433 1259 26 visitation visitation NN 13433 1259 27 of of IN 13433 1259 28 God God NNP 13433 1259 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1259 30 _ _ NNP 13433 1259 31 i.e. i.e. FW 13433 1259 32 _ _ NNP 13433 1259 33 the the DT 13433 1259 34 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1259 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1259 36 occurred occur VBD 13433 1259 37 . . . 13433 1260 1 And and CC 13433 1260 2 at at IN 13433 1260 3 that that DT 13433 1260 4 time time NN 13433 1260 5 the the DT 13433 1260 6 holy holy NNP 13433 1260 7 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1260 8 , , , 13433 1260 9 the the DT 13433 1260 10 bishop bishop NN 13433 1260 11 of of IN 13433 1260 12 the the DT 13433 1260 13 city city NN 13433 1260 14 of of IN 13433 1260 15 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1260 16 , , , 13433 1260 17 was be VBD 13433 1260 18 martyred martyr VBN 13433 1260 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1260 20 or or CC 13433 1260 21 bore bore NN 13433 1260 22 testimony testimony NN 13433 1260 23 , , , 13433 1260 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1260 25 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1260 26 : : : 13433 1260 27 emarturêse emarturêse NNS 13433 1260 28 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1260 29 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1260 30 before before IN 13433 1260 31 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1260 32 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1260 33 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1260 34 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1260 35 : : : 13433 1260 36 epi epi NNP 13433 1260 37 autou autou NNP 13433 1260 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1260 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1260 40 ; ; : 13433 1260 41 for for IN 13433 1260 42 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1260 43 was be VBD 13433 1260 44 exasperated exasperate VBN 13433 1260 45 against against IN 13433 1260 46 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1260 47 , , , 13433 1260 48 because because IN 13433 1260 49 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1260 50 reviled revile VBD 13433 1260 51 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1260 52 . . . 13433 1260 53 ' ' '' 13433 1260 54 " " '' 13433 1261 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1261 2 109:1 109:1 LS 13433 1261 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1261 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1261 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1261 6 endeavours endeavour VBZ 13433 1261 7 in in IN 13433 1261 8 every every DT 13433 1261 9 way way NN 13433 1261 10 to to TO 13433 1261 11 discredit discredit VB 13433 1261 12 this this DT 13433 1261 13 statement statement NN 13433 1261 14 . . . 13433 1262 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1262 2 argues argue VBZ 13433 1262 3 that that IN 13433 1262 4 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1262 5 tells tell VBZ 13433 1262 6 foolish foolish JJ 13433 1262 7 stories story NNS 13433 1262 8 about about IN 13433 1262 9 other other JJ 13433 1262 10 matters matter NNS 13433 1262 11 , , , 13433 1262 12 and and CC 13433 1262 13 , , , 13433 1262 14 therefore therefore RB 13433 1262 15 , , , 13433 1262 16 is be VBZ 13433 1262 17 not not RB 13433 1262 18 to to TO 13433 1262 19 be be VB 13433 1262 20 believed believe VBN 13433 1262 21 here here RB 13433 1262 22 ; ; : 13433 1262 23 but but CC 13433 1262 24 so so RB 13433 1262 25 simple simple JJ 13433 1262 26 a a DT 13433 1262 27 piece piece NN 13433 1262 28 of of IN 13433 1262 29 information information NN 13433 1262 30 may may MD 13433 1262 31 well well RB 13433 1262 32 be be VB 13433 1262 33 correctly correctly RB 13433 1262 34 conveyed convey VBN 13433 1262 35 by by IN 13433 1262 36 a a DT 13433 1262 37 writer writer NN 13433 1262 38 who who WP 13433 1262 39 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 1262 40 may may MD 13433 1262 41 record record VB 13433 1262 42 stupid stupid JJ 13433 1262 43 traditions tradition NNS 13433 1262 44 . . . 13433 1263 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1263 2 109:2 109:2 LS 13433 1263 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1263 4 If if IN 13433 1263 5 the the DT 13433 1263 6 narrative narrative NN 13433 1263 7 of of IN 13433 1263 8 foolish foolish JJ 13433 1263 9 stories story NNS 13433 1263 10 and and CC 13433 1263 11 fabulous fabulous JJ 13433 1263 12 traditions tradition NNS 13433 1263 13 is be VBZ 13433 1263 14 to to TO 13433 1263 15 exclude exclude VB 13433 1263 16 belief belief NN 13433 1263 17 in in IN 13433 1263 18 everything everything NN 13433 1263 19 else else RB 13433 1263 20 stated state VBN 13433 1263 21 by by IN 13433 1263 22 those those DT 13433 1263 23 who who WP 13433 1263 24 relate relate VBP 13433 1263 25 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1263 26 , , , 13433 1263 27 the the DT 13433 1263 28 whole whole NN 13433 1263 29 of of IN 13433 1263 30 the the DT 13433 1263 31 Fathers father NNS 13433 1263 32 are be VBP 13433 1263 33 disposed dispose VBN 13433 1263 34 of of IN 13433 1263 35 at at IN 13433 1263 36 one one CD 13433 1263 37 fell fell JJ 13433 1263 38 swoop swoop NN 13433 1263 39 , , , 13433 1263 40 for for IN 13433 1263 41 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1263 42 all all DT 13433 1263 43 do do VBP 13433 1263 44 so so RB 13433 1263 45 . . . 13433 1264 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1264 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1264 3 also also RB 13433 1264 4 assert assert VBP 13433 1264 5 that that IN 13433 1264 6 the the DT 13433 1264 7 theory theory NN 13433 1264 8 of of IN 13433 1264 9 the the DT 13433 1264 10 cause cause NN 13433 1264 11 of of IN 13433 1264 12 the the DT 13433 1264 13 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1264 14 advanced advance VBN 13433 1264 15 by by IN 13433 1264 16 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 1264 17 " " `` 13433 1264 18 receives receive VBZ 13433 1264 19 no no DT 13433 1264 20 countenance countenance NN 13433 1264 21 from from IN 13433 1264 22 the the DT 13433 1264 23 story story NN 13433 1264 24 of of IN 13433 1264 25 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1264 26 , , , 13433 1264 27 who who WP 13433 1264 28 gives give VBZ 13433 1264 29 a a DT 13433 1264 30 wholly wholly RB 13433 1264 31 different different JJ 13433 1264 32 reason reason NN 13433 1264 33 -- -- : 13433 1264 34 the the DT 13433 1264 35 irritating irritate VBG 13433 1264 36 language language NN 13433 1264 37 used use VBN 13433 1264 38 to to IN 13433 1264 39 the the DT 13433 1264 40 Emperor Emperor NNP 13433 1264 41 . . . 13433 1264 42 " " '' 13433 1265 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1265 2 109:3 109:3 LS 13433 1265 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1265 4 On on IN 13433 1265 5 the the DT 13433 1265 6 other other JJ 13433 1265 7 hand hand NN 13433 1265 8 , , , 13433 1265 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1265 10 in in IN 13433 1265 11 no no DT 13433 1265 12 way way NN 13433 1265 13 contradicts contradict VBZ 13433 1265 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1265 15 , , , 13433 1265 16 for for IN 13433 1265 17 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1265 18 can can MD 13433 1265 19 only only RB 13433 1265 20 have have VB 13433 1265 21 " " `` 13433 1265 22 reviled revile VBN 13433 1265 23 " " '' 13433 1265 24 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1265 25 when when WRB 13433 1265 26 brought bring VBD 13433 1265 27 before before IN 13433 1265 28 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1265 29 , , , 13433 1265 30 and and CC 13433 1265 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1265 32 being be VBG 13433 1265 33 taken take VBN 13433 1265 34 before before IN 13433 1265 35 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1265 36 may may MD 13433 1265 37 well well RB 13433 1265 38 have have VB 13433 1265 39 been be VBN 13433 1265 40 caused cause VBN 13433 1265 41 by by IN 13433 1265 42 the the DT 13433 1265 43 fury fury NN 13433 1265 44 excited excite VBN 13433 1265 45 by by IN 13433 1265 46 the the DT 13433 1265 47 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 1265 48 , , , 13433 1265 49 even even RB 13433 1265 50 if if IN 13433 1265 51 the the DT 13433 1265 52 language language NN 13433 1265 53 of of IN 13433 1265 54 the the DT 13433 1265 55 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 1265 56 influenced influence VBD 13433 1265 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1265 58 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1265 59 ; ; : 13433 1265 60 the the DT 13433 1265 61 whole whole JJ 13433 1265 62 statement statement NN 13433 1265 63 of of IN 13433 1265 64 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1265 65 is be VBZ 13433 1265 66 in in IN 13433 1265 67 perfect perfect JJ 13433 1265 68 harmony harmony NN 13433 1265 69 with with IN 13433 1265 70 the the DT 13433 1265 71 theory theory NN 13433 1265 72 in in IN 13433 1265 73 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1265 74 details detail NNS 13433 1265 75 , , , 13433 1265 76 and and CC 13433 1265 77 in in IN 13433 1265 78 the the DT 13433 1265 79 main main JJ 13433 1265 80 , , , 13433 1265 81 of of IN 13433 1265 82 course course NN 13433 1265 83 , , , 13433 1265 84 directly directly RB 13433 1265 85 supports support VBZ 13433 1265 86 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1265 87 . . . 13433 1266 1 Then then RB 13433 1266 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1266 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1266 4 actually actually RB 13433 1266 5 makes make VBZ 13433 1266 6 use use NN 13433 1266 7 of of IN 13433 1266 8 the the DT 13433 1266 9 following follow VBG 13433 1266 10 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 1266 11 argument:-- argument:-- NN 13433 1266 12 " " `` 13433 1266 13 But but CC 13433 1266 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1266 15 may may MD 13433 1266 16 be be VB 13433 1266 17 worth worth JJ 13433 1266 18 while while IN 13433 1266 19 adding add VBG 13433 1266 20 that that IN 13433 1266 21 the the DT 13433 1266 22 error error NN 13433 1266 23 of of IN 13433 1266 24 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1266 25 is be VBZ 13433 1266 26 capable capable JJ 13433 1266 27 of of IN 13433 1266 28 easy easy JJ 13433 1266 29 explanation explanation NN 13433 1266 30 . . . 13433 1267 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1267 2 has have VBZ 13433 1267 3 probably probably RB 13433 1267 4 misinterpreted misinterpret VBN 13433 1267 5 some some DT 13433 1267 6 earlier early JJR 13433 1267 7 authority authority NN 13433 1267 8 , , , 13433 1267 9 whose whose WP$ 13433 1267 10 language language NN 13433 1267 11 lent lend VBD 13433 1267 12 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1267 13 to to IN 13433 1267 14 misinterpretation misinterpretation NN 13433 1267 15 . . . 13433 1268 1 The the DT 13433 1268 2 words word NNS 13433 1268 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1268 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1268 5 : : : 13433 1268 6 marturein marturein NNP 13433 1268 7 , , , 13433 1268 8 marturia marturia NNP 13433 1268 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1268 10 , , , 13433 1268 11 which which WDT 13433 1268 12 were be VBD 13433 1268 13 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1268 14 used use VBN 13433 1268 15 especially especially RB 13433 1268 16 of of IN 13433 1268 17 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1268 18 , , , 13433 1268 19 had have VBD 13433 1268 20 in in IN 13433 1268 21 the the DT 13433 1268 22 earlier early JJR 13433 1268 23 ages age NNS 13433 1268 24 a a DT 13433 1268 25 wider wide JJR 13433 1268 26 sense sense NN 13433 1268 27 , , , 13433 1268 28 including include VBG 13433 1268 29 other other JJ 13433 1268 30 modes mode NNS 13433 1268 31 of of IN 13433 1268 32 witnessing witness VBG 13433 1268 33 to to IN 13433 1268 34 the the DT 13433 1268 35 faith faith NN 13433 1268 36 : : : 13433 1268 37 the the DT 13433 1268 38 expression expression NN 13433 1268 39 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1268 40 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1268 41 : : : 13433 1268 42 epi epi JJ 13433 1268 43 Traianou Traianou NNP 13433 1268 44 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1268 45 again again RB 13433 1268 46 is be VBZ 13433 1268 47 ambiguous ambiguous JJ 13433 1268 48 and and CC 13433 1268 49 might may MD 13433 1268 50 denote denote VB 13433 1268 51 either either CC 13433 1268 52 ' ' `` 13433 1268 53 during during IN 13433 1268 54 the the DT 13433 1268 55 reign reign NN 13433 1268 56 of of IN 13433 1268 57 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1268 58 , , , 13433 1268 59 ' ' '' 13433 1268 60 or or CC 13433 1268 61 ' ' '' 13433 1268 62 in in IN 13433 1268 63 the the DT 13433 1268 64 presence presence NN 13433 1268 65 of of IN 13433 1268 66 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1268 67 . . . 13433 1268 68 ' ' '' 13433 1269 1 A a DT 13433 1269 2 blundering blundering NN 13433 1269 3 writer writer NN 13433 1269 4 like like IN 13433 1269 5 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1269 6 might may MD 13433 1269 7 have have VB 13433 1269 8 stumbled stumble VBN 13433 1269 9 over over IN 13433 1269 10 either either DT 13433 1269 11 expression expression NN 13433 1269 12 . . . 13433 1269 13 " " '' 13433 1270 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1270 2 110:1 110:1 LS 13433 1270 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1270 4 This this DT 13433 1270 5 is be VBZ 13433 1270 6 a a DT 13433 1270 7 favourite favourite JJ 13433 1270 8 device device NN 13433 1270 9 . . . 13433 1271 1 In in IN 13433 1271 2 case case NN 13433 1271 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1271 4 abuse abuse NN 13433 1271 5 of of IN 13433 1271 6 poor poor JJ 13433 1271 7 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1271 8 should should MD 13433 1271 9 not not RB 13433 1271 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 1271 11 discredit discredit VB 13433 1271 12 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1271 13 , , , 13433 1271 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1271 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1271 16 attempts attempt VBZ 13433 1271 17 to to TO 13433 1271 18 explain explain VB 13433 1271 19 away away RB 13433 1271 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1271 21 language language NN 13433 1271 22 . . . 13433 1272 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1272 2 would would MD 13433 1272 3 be be VB 13433 1272 4 difficult difficult JJ 13433 1272 5 indeed indeed RB 13433 1272 6 to to TO 13433 1272 7 show show VB 13433 1272 8 that that IN 13433 1272 9 the the DT 13433 1272 10 words word NNS 13433 1272 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1272 12 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1272 13 : : : 13433 1272 14 marturein marturein NNP 13433 1272 15 , , , 13433 1272 16 marturia marturia NNP 13433 1272 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1272 18 , , , 13433 1272 19 already already RB 13433 1272 20 used use VBN 13433 1272 21 in in IN 13433 1272 22 that that DT 13433 1272 23 sense sense NN 13433 1272 24 in in IN 13433 1272 25 the the DT 13433 1272 26 New New NNP 13433 1272 27 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1272 28 , , , 13433 1272 29 were be VBD 13433 1272 30 not not RB 13433 1272 31 , , , 13433 1272 32 at at IN 13433 1272 33 the the DT 13433 1272 34 date date NN 13433 1272 35 at at IN 13433 1272 36 which which WDT 13433 1272 37 any any DT 13433 1272 38 record record NN 13433 1272 39 of of IN 13433 1272 40 the the DT 13433 1272 41 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1272 42 of of IN 13433 1272 43 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1272 44 which which WDT 13433 1272 45 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1272 46 could could MD 13433 1272 47 have have VB 13433 1272 48 had have VBN 13433 1272 49 before before IN 13433 1272 50 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1272 51 was be VBD 13433 1272 52 written write VBN 13433 1272 53 , , , 13433 1272 54 employed employ VBN 13433 1272 55 to to TO 13433 1272 56 express express VB 13433 1272 57 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1272 58 , , , 13433 1272 59 when when WRB 13433 1272 60 applied apply VBN 13433 1272 61 to to IN 13433 1272 62 such such PDT 13433 1272 63 a a DT 13433 1272 64 case case NN 13433 1272 65 , , , 13433 1272 66 as as IN 13433 1272 67 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1272 68 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1272 69 indeed indeed RB 13433 1272 70 has have VBZ 13433 1272 71 in in IN 13433 1272 72 the the DT 13433 1272 73 first first JJ 13433 1272 74 instance instance NN 13433 1272 75 rendered render VBD 13433 1272 76 the the DT 13433 1272 77 phrase phrase NN 13433 1272 78 . . . 13433 1273 1 Even even RB 13433 1273 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1273 3 , , , 13433 1273 4 whom whom WP 13433 1273 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1273 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1273 7 so so RB 13433 1273 8 implicitly implicitly RB 13433 1273 9 follows follow VBZ 13433 1273 10 , , , 13433 1273 11 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 1273 12 decides decide VBZ 13433 1273 13 against against IN 13433 1273 14 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1273 15 on on IN 13433 1273 16 both both DT 13433 1273 17 points point NNS 13433 1273 18 . . . 13433 1274 1 " " `` 13433 1274 2 The the DT 13433 1274 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1274 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1274 5 : : : 13433 1274 6 epi epi NNP 13433 1274 7 autou autou NNP 13433 1274 8 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1274 9 together together RB 13433 1274 10 with with IN 13433 1274 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1274 12 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1274 13 : : : 13433 1274 14 tote tote NN 13433 1274 15 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1274 16 can can MD 13433 1274 17 only only RB 13433 1274 18 signify signify VB 13433 1274 19 ' ' '' 13433 1274 20 coram coram NNP 13433 1274 21 Trajano Trajano NNP 13433 1274 22 ' ' '' 13433 1274 23 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1274 24 ' ' `` 13433 1274 25 in in IN 13433 1274 26 the the DT 13433 1274 27 presence presence NN 13433 1274 28 of of IN 13433 1274 29 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1274 30 ' ' '' 13433 1274 31 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1274 32 , , , 13433 1274 33 and and CC 13433 1274 34 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1274 35 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1274 36 : : : 13433 1274 37 emarturaese emarturaese NNS 13433 1274 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1274 39 only only RB 13433 1274 40 the the DT 13433 1274 41 execution execution NN 13433 1274 42 . . . 13433 1274 43 " " '' 13433 1275 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1275 2 110:2 110:2 LS 13433 1275 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1275 4 Let let VB 13433 1275 5 anyone anyone NN 13433 1275 6 simply simply RB 13433 1275 7 read read VB 13433 1275 8 over over IN 13433 1275 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1275 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1275 11 's 's POS 13433 1275 12 own own JJ 13433 1275 13 rendering rendering NN 13433 1275 14 , , , 13433 1275 15 which which WDT 13433 1275 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1275 17 have have VBP 13433 1275 18 quoted quote VBN 13433 1275 19 above above RB 13433 1275 20 , , , 13433 1275 21 and and CC 13433 1275 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1275 23 will will MD 13433 1275 24 see see VB 13433 1275 25 that that IN 13433 1275 26 such such JJ 13433 1275 27 quibbles quibble NNS 13433 1275 28 are be VBP 13433 1275 29 excluded exclude VBN 13433 1275 30 , , , 13433 1275 31 and and CC 13433 1275 32 that that IN 13433 1275 33 , , , 13433 1275 34 on on IN 13433 1275 35 the the DT 13433 1275 36 contrary contrary NN 13433 1275 37 , , , 13433 1275 38 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1275 39 seems seem VBZ 13433 1275 40 excellently excellently RB 13433 1275 41 well well JJ 13433 1275 42 and and CC 13433 1275 43 directly directly RB 13433 1275 44 to to TO 13433 1275 45 have have VB 13433 1275 46 interpreted interpret VBN 13433 1275 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1275 48 earlier early JJR 13433 1275 49 authority authority NN 13433 1275 50 . . . 13433 1276 1 That that IN 13433 1276 2 the the DT 13433 1276 3 statement statement NN 13433 1276 4 of of IN 13433 1276 5 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1276 6 does do VBZ 13433 1276 7 not not RB 13433 1276 8 agree agree VB 13433 1276 9 with with IN 13433 1276 10 the the DT 13433 1276 11 reports report NNS 13433 1276 12 of of IN 13433 1276 13 the the DT 13433 1276 14 Fathers father NNS 13433 1276 15 is be VBZ 13433 1276 16 no no DT 13433 1276 17 real real JJ 13433 1276 18 objection objection NN 13433 1276 19 , , , 13433 1276 20 for for IN 13433 1276 21 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1276 22 have have VBP 13433 1276 23 good good JJ 13433 1276 24 reason reason NN 13433 1276 25 to to TO 13433 1276 26 believe believe VB 13433 1276 27 that that IN 13433 1276 28 none none NN 13433 1276 29 of of IN 13433 1276 30 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1276 31 had have VBD 13433 1276 32 information information NN 13433 1276 33 from from IN 13433 1276 34 any any DT 13433 1276 35 other other JJ 13433 1276 36 source source NN 13433 1276 37 than than IN 13433 1276 38 the the DT 13433 1276 39 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1276 40 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1276 41 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1276 42 , , , 13433 1276 43 or or CC 13433 1276 44 tradition tradition NN 13433 1276 45 . . . 13433 1277 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1277 2 evidently evidently RB 13433 1277 3 had have VBD 13433 1277 4 not not RB 13433 1277 5 . . . 13433 1278 1 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 1278 2 , , , 13433 1278 3 Origen Origen NNP 13433 1278 4 , , , 13433 1278 5 and and CC 13433 1278 6 some some DT 13433 1278 7 later later JJ 13433 1278 8 Fathers father NNS 13433 1278 9 tell tell VBP 13433 1278 10 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1278 11 nothing nothing NN 13433 1278 12 about about IN 13433 1278 13 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1278 14 . . . 13433 1279 1 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 1279 2 and and CC 13433 1279 3 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 1279 4 clearly clearly RB 13433 1279 5 take take VBP 13433 1279 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1279 7 accounts account NNS 13433 1279 8 from from IN 13433 1279 9 these these DT 13433 1279 10 sources source NNS 13433 1279 11 . . . 13433 1280 1 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1280 2 is be VBZ 13433 1280 3 the the DT 13433 1280 4 first first JJ 13433 1280 5 who who WP 13433 1280 6 , , , 13433 1280 7 by by IN 13433 1280 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1280 9 variation variation NN 13433 1280 10 , , , 13433 1280 11 proves prove VBZ 13433 1280 12 that that IN 13433 1280 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1280 14 had have VBD 13433 1280 15 another another DT 13433 1280 16 and and CC 13433 1280 17 different different JJ 13433 1280 18 authority authority NN 13433 1280 19 before before IN 13433 1280 20 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1280 21 , , , 13433 1280 22 and and CC 13433 1280 23 in in IN 13433 1280 24 abandoning abandon VBG 13433 1280 25 the the DT 13433 1280 26 martyr martyr NN 13433 1280 27 - - HYPH 13433 1280 28 journey journey NN 13433 1280 29 to to IN 13433 1280 30 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1280 31 , , , 13433 1280 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1280 33 account account NN 13433 1280 34 has have VBZ 13433 1280 35 infinitely infinitely RB 13433 1280 36 greater great JJR 13433 1280 37 apparent apparent JJ 13433 1280 38 probability probability NN 13433 1280 39 . . . 13433 1281 1 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1281 2 lived live VBD 13433 1281 3 at at IN 13433 1281 4 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1281 5 , , , 13433 1281 6 which which WDT 13433 1281 7 adds add VBZ 13433 1281 8 some some DT 13433 1281 9 weight weight NN 13433 1281 10 to to IN 13433 1281 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1281 12 statement statement NN 13433 1281 13 . . . 13433 1282 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1282 2 is be VBZ 13433 1282 3 objected object VBN 13433 1282 4 that that IN 13433 1282 5 so so RB 13433 1282 6 also also RB 13433 1282 7 did do VBD 13433 1282 8 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 1282 9 , , , 13433 1282 10 and and CC 13433 1282 11 at at IN 13433 1282 12 an an DT 13433 1282 13 earlier early JJR 13433 1282 14 period period NN 13433 1282 15 , , , 13433 1282 16 and and CC 13433 1282 17 yet yet RB 13433 1282 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1282 19 repeats repeat VBZ 13433 1282 20 the the DT 13433 1282 21 Roman roman JJ 13433 1282 22 story story NN 13433 1282 23 . . . 13433 1283 1 This this DT 13433 1283 2 , , , 13433 1283 3 however however RB 13433 1283 4 , , , 13433 1283 5 is be VBZ 13433 1283 6 no no DT 13433 1283 7 valid valid JJ 13433 1283 8 argument argument NN 13433 1283 9 against against IN 13433 1283 10 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 1283 11 . . . 13433 1284 1 Chrysostom chrysostom NN 13433 1284 2 was be VBD 13433 1284 3 too too RB 13433 1284 4 good good JJ 13433 1284 5 a a DT 13433 1284 6 churchman churchman NN 13433 1284 7 to to TO 13433 1284 8 doubt doubt VB 13433 1284 9 the the DT 13433 1284 10 story story NN 13433 1284 11 of of IN 13433 1284 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1284 13 so so RB 13433 1284 14 much much RB 13433 1284 15 tending tend VBG 13433 1284 16 to to IN 13433 1284 17 edification edification NN 13433 1284 18 , , , 13433 1284 19 which which WDT 13433 1284 20 were be VBD 13433 1284 21 in in IN 13433 1284 22 wide wide JJ 13433 1284 23 circulation circulation NN 13433 1284 24 , , , 13433 1284 25 and and CC 13433 1284 26 had have VBD 13433 1284 27 been be VBN 13433 1284 28 quoted quote VBN 13433 1284 29 by by IN 13433 1284 30 earlier early JJR 13433 1284 31 Fathers father NNS 13433 1284 32 . . . 13433 1285 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1285 2 is be VBZ 13433 1285 3 in in IN 13433 1285 4 no no DT 13433 1285 5 way way NN 13433 1285 6 surprising surprising JJ 13433 1285 7 that that IN 13433 1285 8 , , , 13433 1285 9 some some DT 13433 1285 10 two two CD 13433 1285 11 centuries century NNS 13433 1285 12 and and CC 13433 1285 13 a a DT 13433 1285 14 half half NN 13433 1285 15 after after IN 13433 1285 16 the the DT 13433 1285 17 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1285 18 , , , 13433 1285 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1285 20 should should MD 13433 1285 21 quietly quietly RB 13433 1285 22 have have VB 13433 1285 23 accepted accept VBN 13433 1285 24 the the DT 13433 1285 25 representations representation NNS 13433 1285 26 of of IN 13433 1285 27 the the DT 13433 1285 28 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1285 29 purporting purport VBG 13433 1285 30 to to TO 13433 1285 31 have have VB 13433 1285 32 been be VBN 13433 1285 33 written write VBN 13433 1285 34 by by IN 13433 1285 35 the the DT 13433 1285 36 martyr martyr NN 13433 1285 37 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1285 38 , , , 13433 1285 39 and and CC 13433 1285 40 that that IN 13433 1285 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1285 42 story story NN 13433 1285 43 should should MD 13433 1285 44 have have VB 13433 1285 45 shaped shape VBN 13433 1285 46 the the DT 13433 1285 47 prevailing prevail VBG 13433 1285 48 tradition tradition NN 13433 1285 49 . . . 13433 1286 1 The the DT 13433 1286 2 remains remain NNS 13433 1286 3 of of IN 13433 1286 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1286 5 , , , 13433 1286 6 as as IN 13433 1286 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1286 8 are be VBP 13433 1286 9 informed inform VBN 13433 1286 10 by by IN 13433 1286 11 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 1286 12 and and CC 13433 1286 13 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 1286 14 , , , 13433 1286 15 long long RB 13433 1286 16 remained remain VBD 13433 1286 17 interred interred JJ 13433 1286 18 in in IN 13433 1286 19 the the DT 13433 1286 20 cemetery cemetery NN 13433 1286 21 of of IN 13433 1286 22 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1286 23 , , , 13433 1286 24 but but CC 13433 1286 25 finally finally RB 13433 1286 26 -- -- : 13433 1286 27 in in IN 13433 1286 28 the the DT 13433 1286 29 time time NN 13433 1286 30 of of IN 13433 1286 31 Theodosius Theodosius NNP 13433 1286 32 , , , 13433 1286 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1286 34 is be VBZ 13433 1286 35 said say VBN 13433 1286 36 -- -- : 13433 1286 37 were be VBD 13433 1286 38 translated translate VBN 13433 1286 39 with with IN 13433 1286 40 great great JJ 13433 1286 41 pomp pomp NN 13433 1286 42 and and CC 13433 1286 43 ceremony ceremony NN 13433 1286 44 to to IN 13433 1286 45 a a DT 13433 1286 46 building building NN 13433 1286 47 which which WDT 13433 1286 48 -- -- : 13433 1286 49 such such JJ 13433 1286 50 is be VBZ 13433 1286 51 the the DT 13433 1286 52 irony irony NN 13433 1286 53 of of IN 13433 1286 54 events event NNS 13433 1286 55 -- -- : 13433 1286 56 had have VBD 13433 1286 57 previously previously RB 13433 1286 58 been be VBN 13433 1286 59 a a DT 13433 1286 60 Temple Temple NNP 13433 1286 61 of of IN 13433 1286 62 Fortune Fortune NNP 13433 1286 63 . . . 13433 1287 1 The the DT 13433 1287 2 story story NN 13433 1287 3 told tell VBD 13433 1287 4 , , , 13433 1287 5 of of IN 13433 1287 6 course course NN 13433 1287 7 , , , 13433 1287 8 is be VBZ 13433 1287 9 that that IN 13433 1287 10 the the DT 13433 1287 11 relics relic NNS 13433 1287 12 of of IN 13433 1287 13 the the DT 13433 1287 14 martyr martyr NN 13433 1287 15 had have VBD 13433 1287 16 been be VBN 13433 1287 17 carefully carefully RB 13433 1287 18 collected collect VBN 13433 1287 19 in in IN 13433 1287 20 the the DT 13433 1287 21 Coliseum Coliseum NNP 13433 1287 22 and and CC 13433 1287 23 carried carry VBN 13433 1287 24 from from IN 13433 1287 25 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1287 26 to to IN 13433 1287 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1287 28 . . . 13433 1288 1 After after IN 13433 1288 2 reposing repose VBG 13433 1288 3 there there RB 13433 1288 4 for for IN 13433 1288 5 some some DT 13433 1288 6 centuries century NNS 13433 1288 7 , , , 13433 1288 8 the the DT 13433 1288 9 relics relic NNS 13433 1288 10 , , , 13433 1288 11 which which WDT 13433 1288 12 are be VBP 13433 1288 13 said say VBN 13433 1288 14 to to TO 13433 1288 15 have have VB 13433 1288 16 been be VBN 13433 1288 17 transported transport VBN 13433 1288 18 from from IN 13433 1288 19 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1288 20 to to IN 13433 1288 21 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1288 22 , , , 13433 1288 23 were be VBD 13433 1288 24 , , , 13433 1288 25 about about IN 13433 1288 26 the the DT 13433 1288 27 seventh seventh JJ 13433 1288 28 century century NN 13433 1288 29 , , , 13433 1288 30 carried carry VBD 13433 1288 31 back back RB 13433 1288 32 from from IN 13433 1288 33 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1288 34 to to IN 13433 1288 35 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1288 36 . . . 13433 1289 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1289 2 111:1 111:1 LS 13433 1289 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1289 4 The the DT 13433 1289 5 natural natural JJ 13433 1289 6 and and CC 13433 1289 7 more more JJR 13433 1289 8 simple simple JJ 13433 1289 9 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1289 10 is be VBZ 13433 1289 11 that that IN 13433 1289 12 , , , 13433 1289 13 instead instead RB 13433 1289 14 of of IN 13433 1289 15 this this DT 13433 1289 16 double double JJ 13433 1289 17 translation translation NN 13433 1289 18 , , , 13433 1289 19 the the DT 13433 1289 20 bones bone NNS 13433 1289 21 of of IN 13433 1289 22 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1289 23 had have VBD 13433 1289 24 always always RB 13433 1289 25 remained remain VBN 13433 1289 26 in in IN 13433 1289 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1289 28 , , , 13433 1289 29 where where WRB 13433 1289 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1289 31 had have VBD 13433 1289 32 suffered suffer VBN 13433 1289 33 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1289 34 , , , 13433 1289 35 and and CC 13433 1289 36 the the DT 13433 1289 37 tradition tradition NN 13433 1289 38 that that WDT 13433 1289 39 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1289 40 had have VBD 13433 1289 41 been be VBN 13433 1289 42 brought bring VBN 13433 1289 43 back back RB 13433 1289 44 from from IN 13433 1289 45 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1289 46 was be VBD 13433 1289 47 merely merely RB 13433 1289 48 the the DT 13433 1289 49 explanation explanation NN 13433 1289 50 which which WDT 13433 1289 51 reconciled reconcile VBD 13433 1289 52 the the DT 13433 1289 53 fact fact NN 13433 1289 54 of of IN 13433 1289 55 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1289 56 actually actually RB 13433 1289 57 being be VBG 13433 1289 58 in in IN 13433 1289 59 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1289 60 with with IN 13433 1289 61 the the DT 13433 1289 62 legend legend NN 13433 1289 63 of of IN 13433 1289 64 the the DT 13433 1289 65 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1289 66 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1289 67 . . . 13433 1290 1 The the DT 13433 1290 2 20th 20th NN 13433 1290 3 of of IN 13433 1290 4 December December NNP 13433 1290 5 is be VBZ 13433 1290 6 the the DT 13433 1290 7 date date NN 13433 1290 8 assigned assign VBN 13433 1290 9 to to IN 13433 1290 10 the the DT 13433 1290 11 death death NN 13433 1290 12 of of IN 13433 1290 13 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1290 14 in in IN 13433 1290 15 the the DT 13433 1290 16 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 13433 1290 17 , , , 13433 1290 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1290 19 112:1 112:1 CD 13433 1290 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1290 21 and and CC 13433 1290 22 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1290 23 admits admit VBZ 13433 1290 24 that that IN 13433 1290 25 this this DT 13433 1290 26 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 1290 27 is be VBZ 13433 1290 28 undeniable undeniable JJ 13433 1290 29 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1290 30 112:2 112:2 CD 13433 1290 31 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1290 32 Moreover moreover RB 13433 1290 33 , , , 13433 1290 34 the the DT 13433 1290 35 anniversary anniversary NN 13433 1290 36 of of IN 13433 1290 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1290 38 death death NN 13433 1290 39 was be VBD 13433 1290 40 celebrated celebrate VBN 13433 1290 41 on on IN 13433 1290 42 that that DT 13433 1290 43 day day NN 13433 1290 44 in in IN 13433 1290 45 the the DT 13433 1290 46 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1290 47 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1290 48 and and CC 13433 1290 49 throughout throughout IN 13433 1290 50 the the DT 13433 1290 51 East East NNP 13433 1290 52 . . . 13433 1291 1 In in IN 13433 1291 2 the the DT 13433 1291 3 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1291 4 Church Church NNP 13433 1291 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1291 6 is be VBZ 13433 1291 7 kept keep VBN 13433 1291 8 on on IN 13433 1291 9 the the DT 13433 1291 10 1st 1st NN 13433 1291 11 of of IN 13433 1291 12 February February NNP 13433 1291 13 . . . 13433 1292 1 There there EX 13433 1292 2 can can MD 13433 1292 3 be be VB 13433 1292 4 little little JJ 13433 1292 5 doubt doubt NN 13433 1292 6 that that IN 13433 1292 7 this this DT 13433 1292 8 was be VBD 13433 1292 9 the the DT 13433 1292 10 day day NN 13433 1292 11 of of IN 13433 1292 12 the the DT 13433 1292 13 translation translation NN 13433 1292 14 of of IN 13433 1292 15 the the DT 13433 1292 16 relics relic NNS 13433 1292 17 to to IN 13433 1292 18 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1292 19 , , , 13433 1292 20 and and CC 13433 1292 21 this this DT 13433 1292 22 was be VBD 13433 1292 23 evidently evidently RB 13433 1292 24 the the DT 13433 1292 25 view view NN 13433 1292 26 of of IN 13433 1292 27 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 13433 1292 28 , , , 13433 1292 29 who who WP 13433 1292 30 , , , 13433 1292 31 although although IN 13433 1292 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1292 33 could could MD 13433 1292 34 not not RB 13433 1292 35 positively positively RB 13433 1292 36 contradict contradict VB 13433 1292 37 the the DT 13433 1292 38 views view NNS 13433 1292 39 of of IN 13433 1292 40 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1292 41 own own JJ 13433 1292 42 Church Church NNP 13433 1292 43 , , , 13433 1292 44 says say VBZ 13433 1292 45 : : : 13433 1292 46 " " `` 13433 1292 47 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 13433 1292 48 festum festum JJ 13433 1292 49 Graeci Graeci NNPS 13433 1292 50 vigesima vigesima NN 13433 1292 51 die die VBP 13433 1292 52 mensis mensis NNP 13433 1292 53 Decembris Decembris NNP 13433 1292 54 celebrant celebrant NN 13433 1292 55 , , , 13433 1292 56 quo quo NNP 13433 1292 57 ipsum ipsum NNP 13433 1292 58 passum passum NNP 13433 1292 59 , , , 13433 1292 60 fuisse fuisse NNP 13433 1292 61 Acta Acta NNP 13433 1292 62 testantur testantur NN 13433 1292 63 ; ; : 13433 1292 64 Latini latini NN 13433 1292 65 vero vero NN 13433 1292 66 die die VBP 13433 1292 67 prima prima NNP 13433 1292 68 Februarii Februarii NNP 13433 1292 69 , , , 13433 1292 70 an an DT 13433 1292 71 ob ob NNP 13433 1292 72 aliquam aliquam NNP 13433 1292 73 sacrarum sacrarum NNP 13433 1292 74 ejus ejus NNP 13433 1292 75 reliquiarum reliquiarum NNP 13433 1292 76 translationem translationem NNP 13433 1292 77 ? ? . 13433 1293 1 plures plure VBZ 13433 1293 2 enim enim NNP 13433 1293 3 fuisse fuisse NNP 13433 1293 4 constat constat NNP 13433 1293 5 . . . 13433 1293 6 " " '' 13433 1294 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1294 2 112:3 112:3 CD 13433 1294 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1294 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1294 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1294 6 112:4 112:4 CD 13433 1294 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1294 8 states state VBZ 13433 1294 9 that that IN 13433 1294 10 the the DT 13433 1294 11 Feast Feast NNP 13433 1294 12 of of IN 13433 1294 13 the the DT 13433 1294 14 translation translation NN 13433 1294 15 in in IN 13433 1294 16 later later JJ 13433 1294 17 calendars calendar NNS 13433 1294 18 was be VBD 13433 1294 19 celebrated celebrate VBN 13433 1294 20 on on IN 13433 1294 21 the the DT 13433 1294 22 29th 29th JJ 13433 1294 23 January January NNP 13433 1294 24 , , , 13433 1294 25 and and CC 13433 1294 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1294 27 points point VBZ 13433 1294 28 out out RP 13433 1294 29 the the DT 13433 1294 30 evident evident JJ 13433 1294 31 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1294 32 which which WDT 13433 1294 33 prevailed prevail VBD 13433 1294 34 in in IN 13433 1294 35 the the DT 13433 1294 36 West West NNP 13433 1294 37 regarding regard VBG 13433 1294 38 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1294 39 . . . 13433 1295 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1295 2 112:5 112:5 LS 13433 1295 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1295 4 On on IN 13433 1295 5 the the DT 13433 1295 6 one one CD 13433 1295 7 hand hand NN 13433 1295 8 , , , 13433 1295 9 therefore therefore RB 13433 1295 10 , , , 13433 1295 11 all all PDT 13433 1295 12 the the DT 13433 1295 13 historical historical JJ 13433 1295 14 data datum NNS 13433 1295 15 which which WDT 13433 1295 16 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1295 17 possess possess VBP 13433 1295 18 regarding regard VBG 13433 1295 19 the the DT 13433 1295 20 reign reign NN 13433 1295 21 and and CC 13433 1295 22 character character NN 13433 1295 23 of of IN 13433 1295 24 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 1295 25 discredit discredit VB 13433 1295 26 the the DT 13433 1295 27 story story NN 13433 1295 28 that that WDT 13433 1295 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1295 30 was be VBD 13433 1295 31 sent send VBN 13433 1295 32 to to IN 13433 1295 33 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1295 34 to to TO 13433 1295 35 be be VB 13433 1295 36 exposed expose VBN 13433 1295 37 to to IN 13433 1295 38 beasts beast NNS 13433 1295 39 in in IN 13433 1295 40 the the DT 13433 1295 41 Coliseum Coliseum NNP 13433 1295 42 ; ; : 13433 1295 43 and and CC 13433 1295 44 all all PDT 13433 1295 45 the the DT 13433 1295 46 positive positive JJ 13433 1295 47 evidence evidence NN 13433 1295 48 which which WDT 13433 1295 49 exists exist VBZ 13433 1295 50 , , , 13433 1295 51 independent independent JJ 13433 1295 52 of of IN 13433 1295 53 the the DT 13433 1295 54 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1295 55 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1295 56 , , , 13433 1295 57 tends tend VBZ 13433 1295 58 to to TO 13433 1295 59 establish establish VB 13433 1295 60 the the DT 13433 1295 61 fact fact NN 13433 1295 62 that that IN 13433 1295 63 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1295 64 suffered suffer VBD 13433 1295 65 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1295 66 in in IN 13433 1295 67 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1295 68 . . . 13433 1296 1 On on IN 13433 1296 2 the the DT 13433 1296 3 other other JJ 13433 1296 4 hand hand NN 13433 1296 5 , , , 13433 1296 6 all all PDT 13433 1296 7 the the DT 13433 1296 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 1296 9 which which WDT 13433 1296 10 is be VBZ 13433 1296 11 offered offer VBN 13433 1296 12 for for IN 13433 1296 13 the the DT 13433 1296 14 statement statement NN 13433 1296 15 that that IN 13433 1296 16 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1296 17 was be VBD 13433 1296 18 sent send VBN 13433 1296 19 to to IN 13433 1296 20 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1296 21 is be VBZ 13433 1296 22 more more RBR 13433 1296 23 or or CC 13433 1296 24 less less RBR 13433 1296 25 directly directly RB 13433 1296 26 based base VBN 13433 1296 27 upon upon IN 13433 1296 28 the the DT 13433 1296 29 representations representation NNS 13433 1296 30 of of IN 13433 1296 31 the the DT 13433 1296 32 letters letter NNS 13433 1296 33 , , , 13433 1296 34 the the DT 13433 1296 35 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1296 36 of of IN 13433 1296 37 which which WDT 13433 1296 38 is be VBZ 13433 1296 39 in in IN 13433 1296 40 discussion discussion NN 13433 1296 41 , , , 13433 1296 42 and and CC 13433 1296 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1296 44 is be VBZ 13433 1296 45 surrounded surround VBN 13433 1296 46 with with IN 13433 1296 47 improbabilities improbability NNS 13433 1296 48 of of IN 13433 1296 49 every every DT 13433 1296 50 kind kind NN 13433 1296 51 . . . 13433 1297 1 And and CC 13433 1297 2 what what WP 13433 1297 3 is be VBZ 13433 1297 4 the the DT 13433 1297 5 value value NN 13433 1297 6 of of IN 13433 1297 7 any any DT 13433 1297 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 1297 9 emanating emanate VBG 13433 1297 10 from from IN 13433 1297 11 the the DT 13433 1297 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1297 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1297 14 and and CC 13433 1297 15 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 13433 1297 16 ? ? . 13433 1298 1 There there EX 13433 1298 2 are be VBP 13433 1298 3 three three CD 13433 1298 4 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 13433 1298 5 which which WDT 13433 1298 6 , , , 13433 1298 7 as as IN 13433 1298 8 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 1298 9 says say VBZ 13433 1298 10 , , , 13433 1298 11 are be VBP 13433 1298 12 " " `` 13433 1298 13 the the DT 13433 1298 14 one one CD 13433 1298 15 more more RBR 13433 1298 16 fabulous fabulous JJ 13433 1298 17 than than IN 13433 1298 18 the the DT 13433 1298 19 other other JJ 13433 1298 20 . . . 13433 1298 21 " " '' 13433 1299 1 There there EX 13433 1299 2 are be VBP 13433 1299 3 fifteen fifteen CD 13433 1299 4 Epistles epistle NNS 13433 1299 5 all all RB 13433 1299 6 equally equally RB 13433 1299 7 purporting purport VBG 13433 1299 8 to to TO 13433 1299 9 be be VB 13433 1299 10 by by IN 13433 1299 11 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1299 12 , , , 13433 1299 13 and and CC 13433 1299 14 most most JJS 13433 1299 15 of of IN 13433 1299 16 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1299 17 handed hand VBD 13433 1299 18 down down RP 13433 1299 19 together together RB 13433 1299 20 in in IN 13433 1299 21 MSS MSS NNP 13433 1299 22 . . . 13433 1299 23 , , , 13433 1299 24 without without IN 13433 1299 25 any any DT 13433 1299 26 distinction distinction NN 13433 1299 27 . . . 13433 1300 1 Three three CD 13433 1300 2 of of IN 13433 1300 3 these these DT 13433 1300 4 , , , 13433 1300 5 in in IN 13433 1300 6 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1300 7 only only RB 13433 1300 8 , , , 13433 1300 9 are be VBP 13433 1300 10 universally universally RB 13433 1300 11 rejected reject VBN 13433 1300 12 , , , 13433 1300 13 as as IN 13433 1300 14 are be VBP 13433 1300 15 also also RB 13433 1300 16 other other JJ 13433 1300 17 five five CD 13433 1300 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1300 19 , , , 13433 1300 20 of of IN 13433 1300 21 which which WDT 13433 1300 22 there there EX 13433 1300 23 are be VBP 13433 1300 24 Greek greek JJ 13433 1300 25 , , , 13433 1300 26 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1300 27 , , , 13433 1300 28 and and CC 13433 1300 29 other other JJ 13433 1300 30 versions version NNS 13433 1300 31 . . . 13433 1301 1 Of of IN 13433 1301 2 the the DT 13433 1301 3 remaining remain VBG 13433 1301 4 seven seven CD 13433 1301 5 there there EX 13433 1301 6 are be VBP 13433 1301 7 two two CD 13433 1301 8 forms form NNS 13433 1301 9 , , , 13433 1301 10 one one PRP 13433 1301 11 called call VBD 13433 1301 12 the the DT 13433 1301 13 Long Long NNP 13433 1301 14 Recension Recension NNP 13433 1301 15 and and CC 13433 1301 16 another another DT 13433 1301 17 shorter short JJR 13433 1301 18 , , , 13433 1301 19 known know VBN 13433 1301 20 as as IN 13433 1301 21 the the DT 13433 1301 22 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 1301 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1301 24 . . . 13433 1302 1 The the DT 13433 1302 2 former former JJ 13433 1302 3 is be VBZ 13433 1302 4 almost almost RB 13433 1302 5 unanimously unanimously RB 13433 1302 6 rejected reject VBN 13433 1302 7 as as IN 13433 1302 8 shamefully shamefully RB 13433 1302 9 interpolated interpolate VBN 13433 1302 10 and and CC 13433 1302 11 falsified falsify VBN 13433 1302 12 ; ; : 13433 1302 13 and and CC 13433 1302 14 a a DT 13433 1302 15 majority majority NN 13433 1302 16 of of IN 13433 1302 17 critics critic NNS 13433 1302 18 assert assert VBP 13433 1302 19 that that IN 13433 1302 20 the the DT 13433 1302 21 text text NN 13433 1302 22 of of IN 13433 1302 23 the the DT 13433 1302 24 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 1302 25 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1302 26 is be VBZ 13433 1302 27 likewise likewise RB 13433 1302 28 very very RB 13433 1302 29 impure impure NN 13433 1302 30 . . . 13433 1303 1 Besides besides IN 13433 1303 2 these these DT 13433 1303 3 there there EX 13433 1303 4 is be VBZ 13433 1303 5 a a DT 13433 1303 6 still still RB 13433 1303 7 shorter short JJR 13433 1303 8 version version NN 13433 1303 9 of of IN 13433 1303 10 three three CD 13433 1303 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1303 12 only only RB 13433 1303 13 , , , 13433 1303 14 the the DT 13433 1303 15 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 1303 16 , , , 13433 1303 17 which which WDT 13433 1303 18 many many JJ 13433 1303 19 able able JJ 13433 1303 20 critics critic NNS 13433 1303 21 declare declare VBP 13433 1303 22 to to TO 13433 1303 23 be be VB 13433 1303 24 the the DT 13433 1303 25 only only JJ 13433 1303 26 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1303 27 letters letter NNS 13433 1303 28 of of IN 13433 1303 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 1303 30 , , , 13433 1303 31 whilst whilst IN 13433 1303 32 a a DT 13433 1303 33 still still RB 13433 1303 34 greater great JJR 13433 1303 35 number number NN 13433 1303 36 , , , 13433 1303 37 both both CC 13433 1303 38 from from IN 13433 1303 39 internal internal JJ 13433 1303 40 and and CC 13433 1303 41 external external JJ 13433 1303 42 reasons reason NNS 13433 1303 43 , , , 13433 1303 44 deny deny VB 13433 1303 45 the the DT 13433 1303 46 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1303 47 of of IN 13433 1303 48 the the DT 13433 1303 49 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1303 50 in in IN 13433 1303 51 any any DT 13433 1303 52 form form NN 13433 1303 53 . . . 13433 1304 1 The the DT 13433 1304 2 second second JJ 13433 1304 3 and and CC 13433 1304 4 third third JJ 13433 1304 5 centuries century NNS 13433 1304 6 teem teem VBP 13433 1304 7 with with IN 13433 1304 8 pseudonymic pseudonymic JJ 13433 1304 9 literature literature NN 13433 1304 10 , , , 13433 1304 11 but but CC 13433 1304 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1304 13 venture venture VBP 13433 1304 14 to to TO 13433 1304 15 say say VB 13433 1304 16 that that IN 13433 1304 17 pious pious JJ 13433 1304 18 fraud fraud NN 13433 1304 19 has have VBZ 13433 1304 20 never never RB 13433 1304 21 been be VBN 13433 1304 22 more more RBR 13433 1304 23 busy busy JJ 13433 1304 24 and and CC 13433 1304 25 conspicuous conspicuous JJ 13433 1304 26 than than IN 13433 1304 27 in in IN 13433 1304 28 dealing deal VBG 13433 1304 29 with with IN 13433 1304 30 the the DT 13433 1304 31 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 1304 32 of of IN 13433 1304 33 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 1304 34 . . . 13433 1305 1 The the DT 13433 1305 2 mere mere JJ 13433 1305 3 statement statement NN 13433 1305 4 of of IN 13433 1305 5 the the DT 13433 1305 6 simple simple JJ 13433 1305 7 and and CC 13433 1305 8 acknowledged acknowledge VBD 13433 1305 9 facts fact NNS 13433 1305 10 regarding regard VBG 13433 1305 11 the the DT 13433 1305 12 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1305 13 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1305 14 is be VBZ 13433 1305 15 ample ample JJ 13433 1305 16 justification justification NN 13433 1305 17 of of IN 13433 1305 18 the the DT 13433 1305 19 assertion assertion NN 13433 1305 20 , , , 13433 1305 21 which which WDT 13433 1305 22 so so RB 13433 1305 23 mightily mightily RB 13433 1305 24 offends offend VBZ 13433 1305 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1305 26 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1305 27 , , , 13433 1305 28 that that IN 13433 1305 29 " " `` 13433 1305 30 the the DT 13433 1305 31 whole whole NN 13433 1305 32 of of IN 13433 1305 33 the the DT 13433 1305 34 Ignatian ignatian JJ 13433 1305 35 literature literature NN 13433 1305 36 is be VBZ 13433 1305 37 a a DT 13433 1305 38 mass mass NN 13433 1305 39 of of IN 13433 1305 40 falsification falsification NN 13433 1305 41 and and CC 13433 1305 42 fraud fraud NN 13433 1305 43 . . . 13433 1305 44 " " '' 13433 1306 1 Even even RB 13433 1306 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1306 3 indignant indignant JJ 13433 1306 4 critic critic NN 13433 1306 5 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1306 6 has have VBZ 13433 1306 7 not not RB 13433 1306 8 ventured venture VBN 13433 1306 9 to to TO 13433 1306 10 use use VB 13433 1306 11 as as RB 13433 1306 12 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1306 13 more more JJR 13433 1306 14 than than IN 13433 1306 15 the the DT 13433 1306 16 three three CD 13433 1306 17 short short JJ 13433 1306 18 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1306 19 letters letter NNS 13433 1306 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1306 21 114:1 114:1 CD 13433 1306 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1306 23 out out IN 13433 1306 24 of of IN 13433 1306 25 this this DT 13433 1306 26 mass mass NN 13433 1306 27 of of IN 13433 1306 28 forgery forgery NN 13433 1306 29 , , , 13433 1306 30 which which WDT 13433 1306 31 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1306 32 rebukes rebuke VBZ 13433 1306 33 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1306 34 for for IN 13433 1306 35 holding hold VBG 13433 1306 36 so so RB 13433 1306 37 cheap cheap JJ 13433 1306 38 . . . 13433 1307 1 Documents document NNS 13433 1307 2 which which WDT 13433 1307 3 lie lie VBP 13433 1307 4 under under IN 13433 1307 5 such such JJ 13433 1307 6 grave grave JJ 13433 1307 7 and and CC 13433 1307 8 permanent permanent JJ 13433 1307 9 suspicion suspicion NN 13433 1307 10 can can MD 13433 1307 11 not not RB 13433 1307 12 prove prove VB 13433 1307 13 anything anything NN 13433 1307 14 . . . 13433 1308 1 As as IN 13433 1308 2 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1308 3 have have VBP 13433 1308 4 shown show VBN 13433 1308 5 , , , 13433 1308 6 however however RB 13433 1308 7 , , , 13433 1308 8 the the DT 13433 1308 9 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 1308 10 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1308 11 , , , 13433 1308 12 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1308 13 the the DT 13433 1308 14 value value NN 13433 1308 15 of of IN 13433 1308 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1308 17 testimony testimony NN 13433 1308 18 , , , 13433 1308 19 so so RB 13433 1308 20 far far RB 13433 1308 21 from from IN 13433 1308 22 supporting support VBG 13433 1308 23 the the DT 13433 1308 24 claims claim NNS 13433 1308 25 advanced advance VBN 13433 1308 26 in in IN 13433 1308 27 favour favour NN 13433 1308 28 of of IN 13433 1308 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1308 30 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1308 31 , , , 13433 1308 32 rather rather RB 13433 1308 33 discredit discredit VB 13433 1308 34 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1308 35 . . . 13433 1309 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1309 2 have have VBP 13433 1309 3 now now RB 13433 1309 4 minutely minutely RB 13433 1309 5 followed follow VBN 13433 1309 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1309 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1309 8 and and CC 13433 1309 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1309 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1309 11 in in IN 13433 1309 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1309 13 attacks attack NNS 13433 1309 14 upon upon IN 13433 1309 15 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1309 16 in in IN 13433 1309 17 connection connection NN 13433 1309 18 with with IN 13433 1309 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1309 20 and and CC 13433 1309 21 the the DT 13433 1309 22 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 1309 23 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1309 24 , , , 13433 1309 25 and and CC 13433 1309 26 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1309 27 trust trust VBP 13433 1309 28 that that IN 13433 1309 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1309 30 have have VBP 13433 1309 31 shown show VBN 13433 1309 32 once once RB 13433 1309 33 for for IN 13433 1309 34 all all DT 13433 1309 35 that that WDT 13433 1309 36 the the DT 13433 1309 37 charges charge NNS 13433 1309 38 of of IN 13433 1309 39 " " `` 13433 1309 40 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 13433 1309 41 " " '' 13433 1309 42 and and CC 13433 1309 43 " " `` 13433 1309 44 misstatement misstatement NN 13433 1309 45 , , , 13433 1309 46 " " '' 13433 1309 47 so so RB 13433 1309 48 lightly lightly RB 13433 1309 49 and and CC 13433 1309 50 liberally liberally RB 13433 1309 51 advanced advanced JJ 13433 1309 52 , , , 13433 1309 53 far far RB 13433 1309 54 from from IN 13433 1309 55 being be VBG 13433 1309 56 well well RB 13433 1309 57 - - HYPH 13433 1309 58 founded found VBN 13433 1309 59 , , , 13433 1309 60 recoil recoil VB 13433 1309 61 upon upon IN 13433 1309 62 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1309 63 . . . 13433 1310 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1310 2 is be VBZ 13433 1310 3 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1310 4 in in IN 13433 1310 5 a a DT 13433 1310 6 work work NN 13433 1310 7 like like IN 13433 1310 8 this this DT 13433 1310 9 , , , 13433 1310 10 dealing deal VBG 13433 1310 11 with with IN 13433 1310 12 such such JJ 13433 1310 13 voluminous voluminous JJ 13433 1310 14 materials material NNS 13433 1310 15 , , , 13433 1310 16 to to TO 13433 1310 17 escape escape VB 13433 1310 18 errors error NNS 13433 1310 19 of of IN 13433 1310 20 detail detail NN 13433 1310 21 , , , 13433 1310 22 as as IN 13433 1310 23 both both DT 13433 1310 24 of of IN 13433 1310 25 these these DT 13433 1310 26 gentlemen gentleman NNS 13433 1310 27 bear bear VBP 13433 1310 28 witness witness NN 13433 1310 29 , , , 13433 1310 30 but but CC 13433 1310 31 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1310 32 have have VBP 13433 1310 33 at at IN 13433 1310 34 least least JJS 13433 1310 35 conscientiously conscientiously RB 13433 1310 36 endeavoured endeavour VBN 13433 1310 37 to to TO 13433 1310 38 be be VB 13433 1310 39 fair fair JJ 13433 1310 40 , , , 13433 1310 41 and and CC 13433 1310 42 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1310 43 venture venture VBP 13433 1310 44 to to TO 13433 1310 45 think think VB 13433 1310 46 that that IN 13433 1310 47 few few JJ 13433 1310 48 writers writer NNS 13433 1310 49 have have VBP 13433 1310 50 ever ever RB 13433 1310 51 more more RBR 13433 1310 52 fully fully RB 13433 1310 53 laid lay VBN 13433 1310 54 before before IN 13433 1310 55 readers reader NNS 13433 1310 56 the the DT 13433 1310 57 actual actual JJ 13433 1310 58 means mean NNS 13433 1310 59 of of IN 13433 1310 60 judging judging NN 13433 1310 61 of of IN 13433 1310 62 the the DT 13433 1310 63 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1310 64 of of IN 13433 1310 65 every every DT 13433 1310 66 statement statement NN 13433 1310 67 which which WDT 13433 1310 68 has have VBZ 13433 1310 69 been be VBN 13433 1310 70 made make VBN 13433 1310 71 . . . 13433 1311 1 III iii CD 13433 1311 2 . . . 13433 1312 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1312 2 POLYCARP POLYCARP NNP 13433 1312 3 OF of IN 13433 1312 4 SMYRNA SMYRNA NNP 13433 1312 5 . . . 13433 1312 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1312 7 In in IN 13433 1312 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1312 9 chapter chapter NN 13433 1312 10 on on IN 13433 1312 11 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1312 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1312 13 state state VBP 13433 1312 14 the the DT 13433 1312 15 various various JJ 13433 1312 16 opinions opinion NNS 13433 1312 17 expressed express VBN 13433 1312 18 by by IN 13433 1312 19 critics critic NNS 13433 1312 20 regarding regard VBG 13433 1312 21 the the DT 13433 1312 22 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1312 23 of of IN 13433 1312 24 the the DT 13433 1312 25 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1312 26 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1312 27 to to IN 13433 1312 28 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1312 29 , , , 13433 1312 30 and and CC 13433 1312 31 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1312 32 more more RBR 13433 1312 33 particularly particularly RB 13433 1312 34 point point VBP 13433 1312 35 out out RP 13433 1312 36 the the DT 13433 1312 37 reasons reason NNS 13433 1312 38 which which WDT 13433 1312 39 have have VBP 13433 1312 40 led lead VBN 13433 1312 41 many many JJ 13433 1312 42 to to TO 13433 1312 43 decide decide VB 13433 1312 44 that that IN 13433 1312 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1312 46 is be VBZ 13433 1312 47 either either CC 13433 1312 48 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1312 49 or or CC 13433 1312 50 interpolated interpolate VBN 13433 1312 51 . . . 13433 1313 1 That that IN 13433 1313 2 an an DT 13433 1313 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1313 4 of of IN 13433 1313 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1313 6 did do VBD 13433 1313 7 really really RB 13433 1313 8 exist exist VB 13433 1313 9 at at IN 13433 1313 10 one one CD 13433 1313 11 time time NN 13433 1313 12 no no DT 13433 1313 13 one one NN 13433 1313 14 doubts doubt VBZ 13433 1313 15 , , , 13433 1313 16 but but CC 13433 1313 17 the the DT 13433 1313 18 proof proof NN 13433 1313 19 that that IN 13433 1313 20 the the DT 13433 1313 21 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1313 22 which which WDT 13433 1313 23 is be VBZ 13433 1313 24 now now RB 13433 1313 25 extant extant JJ 13433 1313 26 was be VBD 13433 1313 27 the the DT 13433 1313 28 actual actual JJ 13433 1313 29 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1313 30 written write VBN 13433 1313 31 by by IN 13433 1313 32 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1313 33 is be VBZ 13433 1313 34 not not RB 13433 1313 35 proven prove VBN 13433 1313 36 . . . 13433 1314 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1314 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1314 3 's 's POS 13433 1314 4 essay essay NN 13433 1314 5 of of IN 13433 1314 6 course course NN 13433 1314 7 assumes assume VBZ 13433 1314 8 the the DT 13433 1314 9 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1314 10 , , , 13433 1314 11 and and CC 13433 1314 12 seeks seek VBZ 13433 1314 13 to to TO 13433 1314 14 establish establish VB 13433 1314 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1314 16 . . . 13433 1315 1 A a DT 13433 1315 2 large large JJ 13433 1315 3 part part NN 13433 1315 4 of of IN 13433 1315 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1315 6 is be VBZ 13433 1315 7 directed direct VBN 13433 1315 8 to to IN 13433 1315 9 the the DT 13433 1315 10 date date NN 13433 1315 11 which which WDT 13433 1315 12 must must MD 13433 1315 13 be be VB 13433 1315 14 assigned assign VBN 13433 1315 15 to to IN 13433 1315 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1315 17 on on IN 13433 1315 18 that that DT 13433 1315 19 supposition supposition NN 13433 1315 20 , , , 13433 1315 21 and and CC 13433 1315 22 recent recent JJ 13433 1315 23 researches research NNS 13433 1315 24 seem seem VBP 13433 1315 25 to to TO 13433 1315 26 establish establish VB 13433 1315 27 that that IN 13433 1315 28 the the DT 13433 1315 29 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1315 30 of of IN 13433 1315 31 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1315 32 must must MD 13433 1315 33 be be VB 13433 1315 34 set set VBN 13433 1315 35 some some DT 13433 1315 36 two two CD 13433 1315 37 years year NNS 13433 1315 38 earlier early RBR 13433 1315 39 than than IN 13433 1315 40 was be VBD 13433 1315 41 formerly formerly RB 13433 1315 42 believed believe VBN 13433 1315 43 . . . 13433 1316 1 The the DT 13433 1316 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1316 3 Chronicon Chronicon NNP 13433 1316 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1316 5 of of IN 13433 1316 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1316 7 dates date VBZ 13433 1316 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1316 9 death death NN 13433 1316 10 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1316 11 166 166 CD 13433 1316 12 or or CC 13433 1316 13 167 167 CD 13433 1316 14 , , , 13433 1316 15 and and CC 13433 1316 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1316 17 is be VBZ 13433 1316 18 said say VBN 13433 1316 19 to to TO 13433 1316 20 have have VB 13433 1316 21 been be VBN 13433 1316 22 martyred martyr VBN 13433 1316 23 during during IN 13433 1316 24 the the DT 13433 1316 25 proconsulship proconsulship NN 13433 1316 26 of of IN 13433 1316 27 Statius Statius NNP 13433 1316 28 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 13433 1316 29 . . . 13433 1317 1 M. M. NNP 13433 1317 2 Waddington Waddington NNP 13433 1317 3 , , , 13433 1317 4 in in IN 13433 1317 5 examining examine VBG 13433 1317 6 the the DT 13433 1317 7 proconsular proconsular JJ 13433 1317 8 annals annal NNS 13433 1317 9 of of IN 13433 1317 10 Asia Asia NNP 13433 1317 11 Minor Minor NNP 13433 1317 12 , , , 13433 1317 13 with with IN 13433 1317 14 the the DT 13433 1317 15 assistance assistance NN 13433 1317 16 of of IN 13433 1317 17 newly newly RB 13433 1317 18 - - HYPH 13433 1317 19 discovered discover VBN 13433 1317 20 inscriptions inscription NNS 13433 1317 21 , , , 13433 1317 22 has have VBZ 13433 1317 23 decided decide VBN 13433 1317 24 that that IN 13433 1317 25 Statius Statius NNP 13433 1317 26 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 13433 1317 27 was be VBD 13433 1317 28 proconsul proconsul NN 13433 1317 29 in in IN 13433 1317 30 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1317 31 154 154 CD 13433 1317 32 - - SYM 13433 1317 33 155 155 CD 13433 1317 34 , , , 13433 1317 35 and and CC 13433 1317 36 if if IN 13433 1317 37 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1317 38 was be VBD 13433 1317 39 martyred martyr VBN 13433 1317 40 during during IN 13433 1317 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1317 42 proconsulship proconsulship NN 13433 1317 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1317 44 would would MD 13433 1317 45 follow follow VB 13433 1317 46 that that IN 13433 1317 47 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1317 48 death death NN 13433 1317 49 must must MD 13433 1317 50 have have VB 13433 1317 51 taken take VBN 13433 1317 52 place place NN 13433 1317 53 in in IN 13433 1317 54 one one CD 13433 1317 55 of of IN 13433 1317 56 those those DT 13433 1317 57 years year NNS 13433 1317 58 . . . 13433 1318 1 Having have VBG 13433 1318 2 said say VBD 13433 1318 3 so so RB 13433 1318 4 much much RB 13433 1318 5 in in IN 13433 1318 6 support support NN 13433 1318 7 of of IN 13433 1318 8 the the DT 13433 1318 9 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1318 10 of of IN 13433 1318 11 the the DT 13433 1318 12 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1318 13 of of IN 13433 1318 14 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1318 15 , , , 13433 1318 16 and and CC 13433 1318 17 the the DT 13433 1318 18 earlier early JJR 13433 1318 19 date date NN 13433 1318 20 to to TO 13433 1318 21 be be VB 13433 1318 22 assigned assign VBN 13433 1318 23 to to IN 13433 1318 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1318 25 , , , 13433 1318 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1318 27 might may MD 13433 1318 28 have have VB 13433 1318 29 been be VBN 13433 1318 30 expected expect VBN 13433 1318 31 that that IN 13433 1318 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1318 33 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1318 34 would would MD 13433 1318 35 have have VB 13433 1318 36 proceeded proceed VBN 13433 1318 37 to to TO 13433 1318 38 show show VB 13433 1318 39 what what WP 13433 1318 40 bearing bear VBG 13433 1318 41 the the DT 13433 1318 42 epistle epistle NN 13433 1318 43 has have VBZ 13433 1318 44 upon upon IN 13433 1318 45 the the DT 13433 1318 46 evidence evidence NN 13433 1318 47 for for IN 13433 1318 48 the the DT 13433 1318 49 existence existence NN 13433 1318 50 of of IN 13433 1318 51 the the DT 13433 1318 52 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1318 53 and and CC 13433 1318 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1318 55 sufficiency sufficiency NN 13433 1318 56 as as IN 13433 1318 57 testimony testimony NN 13433 1318 58 for for IN 13433 1318 59 the the DT 13433 1318 60 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1318 61 which which WDT 13433 1318 62 those those DT 13433 1318 63 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1318 64 record record VBP 13433 1318 65 . . . 13433 1319 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1319 2 has have VBZ 13433 1319 3 not not RB 13433 1319 4 done do VBN 13433 1319 5 so so RB 13433 1319 6 , , , 13433 1319 7 however however RB 13433 1319 8 , , , 13433 1319 9 for for IN 13433 1319 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1319 11 is be VBZ 13433 1319 12 in in IN 13433 1319 13 such such JJ 13433 1319 14 haste haste NN 13433 1319 15 to to TO 13433 1319 16 find find VB 13433 1319 17 small small JJ 13433 1319 18 faults fault NNS 13433 1319 19 with with IN 13433 1319 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1319 21 statements statement NNS 13433 1319 22 , , , 13433 1319 23 and and CC 13433 1319 24 disparage disparage VB 13433 1319 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1319 26 work work NN 13433 1319 27 , , , 13433 1319 28 that that IN 13433 1319 29 , , , 13433 1319 30 having have VBG 13433 1319 31 arrived arrive VBN 13433 1319 32 at at IN 13433 1319 33 this this DT 13433 1319 34 point point NN 13433 1319 35 , , , 13433 1319 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1319 37 at at IN 13433 1319 38 once once RB 13433 1319 39 rushes rush VBZ 13433 1319 40 off off RP 13433 1319 41 upon upon IN 13433 1319 42 this this DT 13433 1319 43 side side NN 13433 1319 44 issue issue NN 13433 1319 45 , , , 13433 1319 46 and and CC 13433 1319 47 does do VBZ 13433 1319 48 not not RB 13433 1319 49 say say VB 13433 1319 50 one one CD 13433 1319 51 word word NN 13433 1319 52 that that WDT 13433 1319 53 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1319 54 can can MD 13433 1319 55 discover discover VB 13433 1319 56 regarding regard VBG 13433 1319 57 any any DT 13433 1319 58 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1319 59 use use NN 13433 1319 60 of of IN 13433 1319 61 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1319 62 in in IN 13433 1319 63 the the DT 13433 1319 64 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1319 65 . . . 13433 1320 1 For for IN 13433 1320 2 a a DT 13433 1320 3 complete complete JJ 13433 1320 4 discussion discussion NN 13433 1320 5 of of IN 13433 1320 6 analogies analogy NNS 13433 1320 7 which which WDT 13433 1320 8 other other JJ 13433 1320 9 apologists apologist NNS 13433 1320 10 have have VBP 13433 1320 11 pointed point VBN 13433 1320 12 out out RP 13433 1320 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1320 14 must must MD 13433 1320 15 refer refer VB 13433 1320 16 to to IN 13433 1320 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1320 18 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1320 19 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1320 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1320 21 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1320 22 ; ; : 13433 1320 23 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1320 24 116:1 116:1 LS 13433 1320 25 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1320 26 but but CC 13433 1320 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1320 28 may may MD 13433 1320 29 here here RB 13433 1320 30 state state VB 13433 1320 31 the the DT 13433 1320 32 case case NN 13433 1320 33 in in IN 13433 1320 34 the the DT 13433 1320 35 strongest strong JJS 13433 1320 36 form form NN 13433 1320 37 for for IN 13433 1320 38 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1320 39 . . . 13433 1321 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1321 2 is be VBZ 13433 1321 3 asserted assert VBN 13433 1321 4 that that IN 13433 1321 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1321 6 in in IN 13433 1321 7 this this DT 13433 1321 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1321 9 uses use VBZ 13433 1321 10 expressions expression NNS 13433 1321 11 which which WDT 13433 1321 12 correspond correspond VBP 13433 1321 13 more more RBR 13433 1321 14 or or CC 13433 1321 15 less less RBR 13433 1321 16 closely closely RB 13433 1321 17 with with IN 13433 1321 18 some some DT 13433 1321 19 of of IN 13433 1321 20 those those DT 13433 1321 21 in in IN 13433 1321 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1321 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1321 24 . . . 13433 1322 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1322 2 is be VBZ 13433 1322 3 not not RB 13433 1322 4 in in IN 13433 1322 5 the the DT 13433 1322 6 least least RBS 13433 1322 7 pretended pretend VBN 13433 1322 8 that that IN 13433 1322 9 the the DT 13433 1322 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1322 11 are be VBP 13433 1322 12 referred refer VBN 13433 1322 13 to to IN 13433 1322 14 by by IN 13433 1322 15 name name NN 13433 1322 16 , , , 13433 1322 17 or or CC 13433 1322 18 that that IN 13433 1322 19 any any DT 13433 1322 20 information information NN 13433 1322 21 is be VBZ 13433 1322 22 given give VBN 13433 1322 23 regarding regard VBG 13433 1322 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1322 25 authorship authorship NN 13433 1322 26 or or CC 13433 1322 27 composition composition NN 13433 1322 28 . . . 13433 1323 1 If if IN 13433 1323 2 , , , 13433 1323 3 therefore therefore RB 13433 1323 4 , , , 13433 1323 5 the the DT 13433 1323 6 use use NN 13433 1323 7 of of IN 13433 1323 8 the the DT 13433 1323 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1323 10 could could MD 13433 1323 11 be be VB 13433 1323 12 established establish VBN 13433 1323 13 , , , 13433 1323 14 and and CC 13433 1323 15 the the DT 13433 1323 16 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1323 17 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1323 18 of of IN 13433 1323 19 the the DT 13433 1323 20 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1323 21 , , , 13433 1323 22 what what WP 13433 1323 23 could could MD 13433 1323 24 this this DT 13433 1323 25 do do VB 13433 1323 26 towards towards IN 13433 1323 27 proving prove VBG 13433 1323 28 the the DT 13433 1323 29 actual actual JJ 13433 1323 30 performance performance NN 13433 1323 31 of of IN 13433 1323 32 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1323 33 or or CC 13433 1323 34 the the DT 13433 1323 35 reality reality NN 13433 1323 36 of of IN 13433 1323 37 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1323 38 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1323 39 ? ? . 13433 1324 1 The the DT 13433 1324 2 mere mere JJ 13433 1324 3 existence existence NN 13433 1324 4 of of IN 13433 1324 5 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1324 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1324 7 would would MD 13433 1324 8 be be VB 13433 1324 9 indicated indicate VBN 13433 1324 10 , , , 13433 1324 11 and and CC 13433 1324 12 though though IN 13433 1324 13 this this DT 13433 1324 14 might may MD 13433 1324 15 be be VB 13433 1324 16 considered consider VBN 13433 1324 17 a a DT 13433 1324 18 good good JJ 13433 1324 19 deal deal NN 13433 1324 20 in in IN 13433 1324 21 the the DT 13433 1324 22 actual actual JJ 13433 1324 23 evidential evidential JJ 13433 1324 24 destitution destitution NN 13433 1324 25 , , , 13433 1324 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1324 27 would would MD 13433 1324 28 leave leave VB 13433 1324 29 the the DT 13433 1324 30 chief chief JJ 13433 1324 31 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 1324 32 quite quite RB 13433 1324 33 untouched untouched JJ 13433 1324 34 . . . 13433 1325 1 IV IV NNP 13433 1325 2 . . . 13433 1326 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1326 2 PAPIAS PAPIAS NNP 13433 1326 3 OF of IN 13433 1326 4 HIERAPOLIS HIERAPOLIS NNP 13433 1326 5 . . . 13433 1326 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1326 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1326 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1326 9 has have VBZ 13433 1326 10 devoted devote VBN 13433 1326 11 two two CD 13433 1326 12 long long JJ 13433 1326 13 chapters chapter NNS 13433 1326 14 to to IN 13433 1326 15 the the DT 13433 1326 16 evidence evidence NN 13433 1326 17 of of IN 13433 1326 18 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1326 19 , , , 13433 1326 20 although although IN 13433 1326 21 with with IN 13433 1326 22 a a DT 13433 1326 23 good good JJ 13433 1326 24 deal deal NN 13433 1326 25 of of IN 13433 1326 26 divergence divergence NN 13433 1326 27 to to IN 13433 1326 28 other other JJ 13433 1326 29 topics topic NNS 13433 1326 30 in in IN 13433 1326 31 the the DT 13433 1326 32 second second NN 13433 1326 33 . . . 13433 1327 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1327 2 need need VBP 13433 1327 3 not not RB 13433 1327 4 follow follow VB 13433 1327 5 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1327 6 minutely minutely RB 13433 1327 7 here here RB 13433 1327 8 , , , 13433 1327 9 for for IN 13433 1327 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1327 11 have have VBP 13433 1327 12 treated treat VBN 13433 1327 13 the the DT 13433 1327 14 subject subject NN 13433 1327 15 fully fully RB 13433 1327 16 in in IN 13433 1327 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1327 18 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1327 19 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1327 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1327 21 , , , 13433 1327 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1327 23 117:1 117:1 LS 13433 1327 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1327 25 to to TO 13433 1327 26 which which WDT 13433 1327 27 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1327 28 beg beg VBP 13433 1327 29 leave leave VBP 13433 1327 30 to to TO 13433 1327 31 refer refer VB 13433 1327 32 any any DT 13433 1327 33 reader reader NN 13433 1327 34 who who WP 13433 1327 35 is be VBZ 13433 1327 36 interested interested JJ 13433 1327 37 in in IN 13433 1327 38 the the DT 13433 1327 39 discussion discussion NN 13433 1327 40 ; ; : 13433 1327 41 and and CC 13433 1327 42 this this DT 13433 1327 43 is be VBZ 13433 1327 44 merely merely RB 13433 1327 45 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1327 46 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1327 47 's 's POS 13433 1327 48 reply reply NN 13433 1327 49 . . . 13433 1328 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1328 2 will will MD 13433 1328 3 confine confine VB 13433 1328 4 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1328 5 here here RB 13433 1328 6 to to IN 13433 1328 7 a a DT 13433 1328 8 few few JJ 13433 1328 9 words word NNS 13433 1328 10 on on IN 13433 1328 11 the the DT 13433 1328 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 13433 1328 13 question question NN 13433 1328 14 at at IN 13433 1328 15 issue issue NN 13433 1328 16 . . . 13433 1329 1 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1329 2 , , , 13433 1329 3 in in IN 13433 1329 4 the the DT 13433 1329 5 absence absence NN 13433 1329 6 of of IN 13433 1329 7 other other JJ 13433 1329 8 testimony testimony NN 13433 1329 9 , , , 13433 1329 10 is be VBZ 13433 1329 11 an an DT 13433 1329 12 important important JJ 13433 1329 13 witness witness NN 13433 1329 14 of of IN 13433 1329 15 whom whom WP 13433 1329 16 theologians theologian NNS 13433 1329 17 are be VBP 13433 1329 18 naturally naturally RB 13433 1329 19 very very RB 13433 1329 20 tenacious tenacious JJ 13433 1329 21 , , , 13433 1329 22 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 13433 1329 23 as as IN 13433 1329 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1329 25 is be VBZ 13433 1329 26 the the DT 13433 1329 27 first first JJ 13433 1329 28 writer writer NN 13433 1329 29 who who WP 13433 1329 30 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1329 31 the the DT 13433 1329 32 name name NN 13433 1329 33 of of IN 13433 1329 34 anyone anyone NN 13433 1329 35 who who WP 13433 1329 36 was be VBD 13433 1329 37 believed believe VBN 13433 1329 38 to to TO 13433 1329 39 have have VB 13433 1329 40 written write VBN 13433 1329 41 a a DT 13433 1329 42 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1329 43 . . . 13433 1330 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1330 2 is be VBZ 13433 1330 3 true true JJ 13433 1330 4 that that IN 13433 1330 5 what what WP 13433 1330 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1330 7 says say VBZ 13433 1330 8 is be VBZ 13433 1330 9 of of IN 13433 1330 10 very very RB 13433 1330 11 little little JJ 13433 1330 12 weight weight NN 13433 1330 13 , , , 13433 1330 14 but but CC 13433 1330 15 , , , 13433 1330 16 since since IN 13433 1330 17 no no DT 13433 1330 18 one one NN 13433 1330 19 else else RB 13433 1330 20 had have VBD 13433 1330 21 said say VBN 13433 1330 22 anything anything NN 13433 1330 23 at at RB 13433 1330 24 all all RB 13433 1330 25 on on IN 13433 1330 26 the the DT 13433 1330 27 point point NN 13433 1330 28 , , , 13433 1330 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1330 30 remarks remark NNS 13433 1330 31 merit merit NN 13433 1330 32 attention attention NN 13433 1330 33 which which WDT 13433 1330 34 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1330 35 would would MD 13433 1330 36 not not RB 13433 1330 37 otherwise otherwise RB 13433 1330 38 receive receive VB 13433 1330 39 . . . 13433 1331 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1331 2 states state VBZ 13433 1331 3 that that IN 13433 1331 4 , , , 13433 1331 5 in in IN 13433 1331 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1331 7 last last JJ 13433 1331 8 work work NN 13433 1331 9 , , , 13433 1331 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1331 11 117:2 117:2 CD 13433 1331 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1331 13 " " `` 13433 1331 14 Exposition Exposition NNP 13433 1331 15 of of IN 13433 1331 16 the the DT 13433 1331 17 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1331 18 's 's POS 13433 1331 19 Oracles Oracles NNPS 13433 1331 20 " " '' 13433 1331 21 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1331 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1331 23 Greek greek JJ 13433 1331 24 : : : 13433 1331 25 Logiôn logiôn JJ 13433 1331 26 kuriakôn kuriakôn NNP 13433 1331 27 exêgêsis exêgêsis NN 13433 1331 28 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1331 29 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1331 30 , , , 13433 1331 31 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1331 32 wrote write VBD 13433 1331 33 as as IN 13433 1331 34 follows follow VBZ 13433 1331 35 : : : 13433 1331 36 " " `` 13433 1331 37 And and CC 13433 1331 38 the the DT 13433 1331 39 elder elder NN 13433 1331 40 said say VBD 13433 1331 41 this this DT 13433 1331 42 also also RB 13433 1331 43 : : : 13433 1331 44 ' ' '' 13433 1331 45 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1331 46 , , , 13433 1331 47 having have VBG 13433 1331 48 become become VBN 13433 1331 49 the the DT 13433 1331 50 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 1331 51 of of IN 13433 1331 52 Peter Peter NNP 13433 1331 53 , , , 13433 1331 54 wrote write VBD 13433 1331 55 down down RP 13433 1331 56 accurately accurately RB 13433 1331 57 everything everything NN 13433 1331 58 that that WDT 13433 1331 59 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1331 60 remembered remember VBD 13433 1331 61 , , , 13433 1331 62 without without IN 13433 1331 63 , , , 13433 1331 64 however however RB 13433 1331 65 , , , 13433 1331 66 recording record VBG 13433 1331 67 in in IN 13433 1331 68 order order NN 13433 1331 69 what what WP 13433 1331 70 was be VBD 13433 1331 71 either either CC 13433 1331 72 said say VBN 13433 1331 73 or or CC 13433 1331 74 done do VBN 13433 1331 75 by by IN 13433 1331 76 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1331 77 . . . 13433 1332 1 For for IN 13433 1332 2 neither neither DT 13433 1332 3 did do VBD 13433 1332 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1332 5 hear hear VB 13433 1332 6 the the DT 13433 1332 7 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1332 8 , , , 13433 1332 9 nor nor CC 13433 1332 10 did do VBD 13433 1332 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1332 12 follow follow VB 13433 1332 13 Him -PRON- PRP 13433 1332 14 ; ; : 13433 1332 15 but but CC 13433 1332 16 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1332 17 , , , 13433 1332 18 as as IN 13433 1332 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1332 20 said say VBD 13433 1332 21 , , , 13433 1332 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1332 23 attended attend VBN 13433 1332 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1332 25 Peter Peter NNP 13433 1332 26 , , , 13433 1332 27 who who WP 13433 1332 28 adapted adapt VBD 13433 1332 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1332 30 instructions instruction NNS 13433 1332 31 to to IN 13433 1332 32 the the DT 13433 1332 33 needs need NNS 13433 1332 34 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1332 35 of of IN 13433 1332 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1332 37 hearers hearer NNS 13433 1332 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1332 39 , , , 13433 1332 40 but but CC 13433 1332 41 had have VBD 13433 1332 42 no no DT 13433 1332 43 design design NN 13433 1332 44 of of IN 13433 1332 45 giving give VBG 13433 1332 46 a a DT 13433 1332 47 connected connected JJ 13433 1332 48 account account NN 13433 1332 49 of of IN 13433 1332 50 the the DT 13433 1332 51 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1332 52 's 's POS 13433 1332 53 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1332 54 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1332 55 or or CC 13433 1332 56 discourses discourse NNS 13433 1332 57 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1332 58 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1332 59 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1332 60 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1332 61 : : : 13433 1332 62 all all DT 13433 1332 63 ' ' '' 13433 1332 64 ouch ouch JJ 13433 1332 65 hôsper hôsper NNP 13433 1332 66 suntaxin suntaxin NNP 13433 1332 67 tôn tôn NNP 13433 1332 68 kuriakôn kuriakôn NNP 13433 1332 69 poioumenos poioumenos NNP 13433 1332 70 logiôn logiôn NNP 13433 1332 71 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1332 72 or or CC 13433 1332 73 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1332 74 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1332 75 : : : 13433 1332 76 logôn logôn NN 13433 1332 77 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1332 78 . . . 13433 1332 79 ' ' '' 13433 1333 1 So so RB 13433 1333 2 , , , 13433 1333 3 then then RB 13433 1333 4 , , , 13433 1333 5 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1333 6 made make VBD 13433 1333 7 no no DT 13433 1333 8 mistake mistake NN 13433 1333 9 while while IN 13433 1333 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 11 thus thus RB 13433 1333 12 wrote write VBD 13433 1333 13 down down RP 13433 1333 14 some some DT 13433 1333 15 things thing NNS 13433 1333 16 as as IN 13433 1333 17 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 18 remembered remember VBD 13433 1333 19 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 20 ; ; : 13433 1333 21 for for IN 13433 1333 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 23 made make VBD 13433 1333 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1333 26 one one CD 13433 1333 27 care care NN 13433 1333 28 not not RB 13433 1333 29 to to TO 13433 1333 30 omit omit VB 13433 1333 31 anything anything NN 13433 1333 32 that that WDT 13433 1333 33 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1333 34 heard hear VBD 13433 1333 35 , , , 13433 1333 36 or or CC 13433 1333 37 to to TO 13433 1333 38 set set VB 13433 1333 39 down down RP 13433 1333 40 any any DT 13433 1333 41 false false JJ 13433 1333 42 statement statement NN 13433 1333 43 therein therein RB 13433 1333 44 . . . 13433 1333 45 " " '' 13433 1334 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1334 2 118:1 118:1 LS 13433 1334 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1334 4 The the DT 13433 1334 5 first first JJ 13433 1334 6 question question NN 13433 1334 7 which which WDT 13433 1334 8 suggests suggest VBZ 13433 1334 9 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1334 10 is be VBZ 13433 1334 11 : : : 13433 1334 12 Does do VBZ 13433 1334 13 the the DT 13433 1334 14 description description NN 13433 1334 15 here here RB 13433 1334 16 given give VBN 13433 1334 17 correspond correspond NN 13433 1334 18 with with IN 13433 1334 19 the the DT 13433 1334 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1334 21 " " '' 13433 1334 22 according accord VBG 13433 1334 23 to to IN 13433 1334 24 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1334 25 " " '' 13433 1334 26 which which WDT 13433 1334 27 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1334 28 now now RB 13433 1334 29 possess possess VBP 13433 1334 30 ? ? . 13433 1335 1 Can Can MD 13433 1335 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1335 3 second second JJ 13433 1335 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1335 5 be be VB 13433 1335 6 considered consider VBN 13433 1335 7 a a DT 13433 1335 8 work work NN 13433 1335 9 composed compose VBN 13433 1335 10 " " '' 13433 1335 11 without without IN 13433 1335 12 recording record VBG 13433 1335 13 in in IN 13433 1335 14 order order NN 13433 1335 15 what what WP 13433 1335 16 was be VBD 13433 1335 17 either either CC 13433 1335 18 said say VBN 13433 1335 19 or or CC 13433 1335 20 done do VBN 13433 1335 21 by by IN 13433 1335 22 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1335 23 " " '' 13433 1335 24 ? ? . 13433 1336 1 A a DT 13433 1336 2 negative negative JJ 13433 1336 3 answer answer NN 13433 1336 4 has have VBZ 13433 1336 5 been be VBN 13433 1336 6 given give VBN 13433 1336 7 by by IN 13433 1336 8 many many JJ 13433 1336 9 eminent eminent JJ 13433 1336 10 critics critic NNS 13433 1336 11 to to IN 13433 1336 12 these these DT 13433 1336 13 and and CC 13433 1336 14 similar similar JJ 13433 1336 15 enquiries enquiry NNS 13433 1336 16 , , , 13433 1336 17 and and CC 13433 1336 18 the the DT 13433 1336 19 application application NN 13433 1336 20 of of IN 13433 1336 21 the the DT 13433 1336 22 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 1336 23 's 's POS 13433 1336 24 words word NNS 13433 1336 25 to to IN 13433 1336 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1336 27 has have VBZ 13433 1336 28 consequently consequently RB 13433 1336 29 been be VBN 13433 1336 30 denied deny VBN 13433 1336 31 by by IN 13433 1336 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1336 33 . . . 13433 1337 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1337 2 does do VBZ 13433 1337 3 not not RB 13433 1337 4 follow follow VB 13433 1337 5 from from IN 13433 1337 6 this this DT 13433 1337 7 that that IN 13433 1337 8 there there EX 13433 1337 9 has have VBZ 13433 1337 10 been be VBN 13433 1337 11 any any DT 13433 1337 12 refusal refusal NN 13433 1337 13 to to TO 13433 1337 14 accept accept VB 13433 1337 15 the the DT 13433 1337 16 words word NNS 13433 1337 17 of of IN 13433 1337 18 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1337 19 as as IN 13433 1337 20 referring refer VBG 13433 1337 21 to to IN 13433 1337 22 a a DT 13433 1337 23 work work NN 13433 1337 24 which which WDT 13433 1337 25 may may MD 13433 1337 26 have have VB 13433 1337 27 been be VBN 13433 1337 28 the the DT 13433 1337 29 basis basis NN 13433 1337 30 of of IN 13433 1337 31 the the DT 13433 1337 32 second second JJ 13433 1337 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1337 34 as as IN 13433 1337 35 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1337 36 have have VBP 13433 1337 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1337 38 . . . 13433 1338 1 However however RB 13433 1338 2 , , , 13433 1338 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1338 4 propose propose VBP 13433 1338 5 to to TO 13433 1338 6 waive waive VB 13433 1338 7 all all PDT 13433 1338 8 this this DT 13433 1338 9 objection objection NN 13433 1338 10 , , , 13433 1338 11 for for IN 13433 1338 12 the the DT 13433 1338 13 sake sake NN 13433 1338 14 of of IN 13433 1338 15 argument argument NN 13433 1338 16 , , , 13433 1338 17 on on IN 13433 1338 18 the the DT 13433 1338 19 present present JJ 13433 1338 20 occasion occasion NN 13433 1338 21 , , , 13433 1338 22 and and CC 13433 1338 23 to to TO 13433 1338 24 consider consider VB 13433 1338 25 what what WP 13433 1338 26 might may MD 13433 1338 27 be be VB 13433 1338 28 the the DT 13433 1338 29 value value NN 13433 1338 30 of of IN 13433 1338 31 the the DT 13433 1338 32 evidence evidence NN 13433 1338 33 before before IN 13433 1338 34 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1338 35 , , , 13433 1338 36 if if IN 13433 1338 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1338 38 be be VB 13433 1338 39 taken take VBN 13433 1338 40 as as IN 13433 1338 41 referring refer VBG 13433 1338 42 to to IN 13433 1338 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1338 44 second second JJ 13433 1338 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1338 46 . . . 13433 1339 1 In in IN 13433 1339 2 the the DT 13433 1339 3 first first JJ 13433 1339 4 place place NN 13433 1339 5 , , , 13433 1339 6 the the DT 13433 1339 7 tradition tradition NN 13433 1339 8 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 1339 9 states state VBZ 13433 1339 10 that that IN 13433 1339 11 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1339 12 , , , 13433 1339 13 who who WP 13433 1339 14 is be VBZ 13433 1339 15 said say VBN 13433 1339 16 to to TO 13433 1339 17 have have VB 13433 1339 18 been be VBN 13433 1339 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1339 20 author author NN 13433 1339 21 , , , 13433 1339 22 was be VBD 13433 1339 23 neither neither CC 13433 1339 24 an an DT 13433 1339 25 eye eye NN 13433 1339 26 - - HYPH 13433 1339 27 witness witness NN 13433 1339 28 of of IN 13433 1339 29 the the DT 13433 1339 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1339 31 recorded record VBN 13433 1339 32 , , , 13433 1339 33 nor nor CC 13433 1339 34 a a DT 13433 1339 35 hearer hearer NN 13433 1339 36 of of IN 13433 1339 37 the the DT 13433 1339 38 words word NNS 13433 1339 39 of of IN 13433 1339 40 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1339 41 , , , 13433 1339 42 but but CC 13433 1339 43 that that IN 13433 1339 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1339 45 merely merely RB 13433 1339 46 recorded record VBD 13433 1339 47 what what WP 13433 1339 48 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1339 49 remembered remember VBD 13433 1339 50 of of IN 13433 1339 51 the the DT 13433 1339 52 casual casual JJ 13433 1339 53 teaching teaching NN 13433 1339 54 of of IN 13433 1339 55 Peter Peter NNP 13433 1339 56 . . . 13433 1340 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1340 2 is be VBZ 13433 1340 3 true true JJ 13433 1340 4 that that IN 13433 1340 5 an an DT 13433 1340 6 assurance assurance NN 13433 1340 7 is be VBZ 13433 1340 8 added add VBN 13433 1340 9 as as IN 13433 1340 10 to to IN 13433 1340 11 the the DT 13433 1340 12 general general JJ 13433 1340 13 care care NN 13433 1340 14 and and CC 13433 1340 15 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1340 16 of of IN 13433 1340 17 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1340 18 in in IN 13433 1340 19 recording record VBG 13433 1340 20 all all DT 13433 1340 21 that that WDT 13433 1340 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1340 23 heard hear VBD 13433 1340 24 and and CC 13433 1340 25 not not RB 13433 1340 26 making make VBG 13433 1340 27 any any DT 13433 1340 28 false false JJ 13433 1340 29 statement statement NN 13433 1340 30 , , , 13433 1340 31 but but CC 13433 1340 32 this this DT 13433 1340 33 does do VBZ 13433 1340 34 not not RB 13433 1340 35 add add VB 13433 1340 36 much much JJ 13433 1340 37 value value NN 13433 1340 38 to to IN 13433 1340 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1340 40 record record NN 13433 1340 41 . . . 13433 1341 1 No no DT 13433 1341 2 one one NN 13433 1341 3 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 1341 4 that that IN 13433 1341 5 the the DT 13433 1341 6 writer writer NN 13433 1341 7 of of IN 13433 1341 8 the the DT 13433 1341 9 second second JJ 13433 1341 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1341 11 deliberately deliberately RB 13433 1341 12 invented invent VBD 13433 1341 13 what what WP 13433 1341 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1341 15 has have VBZ 13433 1341 16 embodied embody VBN 13433 1341 17 in in IN 13433 1341 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1341 19 work work NN 13433 1341 20 , , , 13433 1341 21 and and CC 13433 1341 22 the the DT 13433 1341 23 certificate certificate NN 13433 1341 24 of of IN 13433 1341 25 character character NN 13433 1341 26 can can MD 13433 1341 27 be be VB 13433 1341 28 received receive VBN 13433 1341 29 for for IN 13433 1341 30 nothing nothing NN 13433 1341 31 more more JJR 13433 1341 32 than than IN 13433 1341 33 a a DT 13433 1341 34 general general JJ 13433 1341 35 estimate estimate NN 13433 1341 36 of of IN 13433 1341 37 the the DT 13433 1341 38 speaker speaker NN 13433 1341 39 . . . 13433 1342 1 The the DT 13433 1342 2 testimony testimony NN 13433 1342 3 of of IN 13433 1342 4 the the DT 13433 1342 5 second second JJ 13433 1342 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1342 7 is be VBZ 13433 1342 8 , , , 13433 1342 9 according accord VBG 13433 1342 10 to to IN 13433 1342 11 this this DT 13433 1342 12 tradition tradition NN 13433 1342 13 , , , 13433 1342 14 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 1342 15 at at IN 13433 1342 16 second second JJ 13433 1342 17 hand hand NN 13433 1342 18 , , , 13433 1342 19 and and CC 13433 1342 20 consequently consequently RB 13433 1342 21 utterly utterly RB 13433 1342 22 inadequate inadequate JJ 13433 1342 23 to to TO 13433 1342 24 attest attest VB 13433 1342 25 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1342 26 pretensions pretension NNS 13433 1342 27 . . . 13433 1343 1 The the DT 13433 1343 2 tradition tradition NN 13433 1343 3 that that WDT 13433 1343 4 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1343 5 derived derive VBD 13433 1343 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1343 7 information information NN 13433 1343 8 from from IN 13433 1343 9 the the DT 13433 1343 10 preaching preaching NN 13433 1343 11 of of IN 13433 1343 12 Peter Peter NNP 13433 1343 13 is be VBZ 13433 1343 14 not not RB 13433 1343 15 supported support VBN 13433 1343 16 by by IN 13433 1343 17 internal internal JJ 13433 1343 18 evidence evidence NN 13433 1343 19 , , , 13433 1343 20 and and CC 13433 1343 21 has have VBZ 13433 1343 22 nothing nothing NN 13433 1343 23 extraneous extraneous JJ 13433 1343 24 to to TO 13433 1343 25 strengthen strengthen VB 13433 1343 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1343 27 probability probability NN 13433 1343 28 . . . 13433 1344 1 Because because IN 13433 1344 2 some some DT 13433 1344 3 person person NN 13433 1344 4 , , , 13433 1344 5 whose whose WP$ 13433 1344 6 very very JJ 13433 1344 7 identity identity NN 13433 1344 8 is be VBZ 13433 1344 9 far far RB 13433 1344 10 from from IN 13433 1344 11 established establish VBN 13433 1344 12 , , , 13433 1344 13 says say VBZ 13433 1344 14 so so CC 13433 1344 15 , , , 13433 1344 16 is be VBZ 13433 1344 17 not not RB 13433 1344 18 strong strong JJ 13433 1344 19 evidence evidence NN 13433 1344 20 of of IN 13433 1344 21 the the DT 13433 1344 22 fact fact NN 13433 1344 23 . . . 13433 1345 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1345 2 was be VBD 13433 1345 3 the the DT 13433 1345 4 earnest earnest JJ 13433 1345 5 desire desire NN 13433 1345 6 of of IN 13433 1345 7 the the DT 13433 1345 8 early early JJ 13433 1345 9 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1345 10 to to TO 13433 1345 11 connect connect VB 13433 1345 12 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1345 13 with with IN 13433 1345 14 the the DT 13433 1345 15 authorship authorship NN 13433 1345 16 of of IN 13433 1345 17 the the DT 13433 1345 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1345 19 , , , 13433 1345 20 and and CC 13433 1345 21 as as IN 13433 1345 22 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1345 23 is be VBZ 13433 1345 24 represented represent VBN 13433 1345 25 as as IN 13433 1345 26 the the DT 13433 1345 27 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 1345 28 of of IN 13433 1345 29 Peter Peter NNP 13433 1345 30 , , , 13433 1345 31 so so RB 13433 1345 32 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1345 33 , , , 13433 1345 34 or or CC 13433 1345 35 the the DT 13433 1345 36 third third JJ 13433 1345 37 evangelist evangelist NN 13433 1345 38 , , , 13433 1345 39 is be VBZ 13433 1345 40 connected connect VBN 13433 1345 41 more more RBR 13433 1345 42 or or CC 13433 1345 43 less less RBR 13433 1345 44 closely closely RB 13433 1345 45 with with IN 13433 1345 46 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1345 47 , , , 13433 1345 48 in in IN 13433 1345 49 forgetfulness forgetfulness NN 13433 1345 50 of of IN 13433 1345 51 the the DT 13433 1345 52 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 1345 53 that that WDT 13433 1345 54 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1345 55 have have VBP 13433 1345 56 no no DT 13433 1345 57 reason reason NN 13433 1345 58 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1345 59 for for IN 13433 1345 60 believing believe VBG 13433 1345 61 that that IN 13433 1345 62 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1345 63 ever ever RB 13433 1345 64 saw see VBD 13433 1345 65 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1345 66 . . . 13433 1346 1 Comparison comparison NN 13433 1346 2 of of IN 13433 1346 3 the the DT 13433 1346 4 contents content NNS 13433 1346 5 of of IN 13433 1346 6 the the DT 13433 1346 7 first first JJ 13433 1346 8 three three CD 13433 1346 9 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1346 10 , , , 13433 1346 11 moreover moreover RB 13433 1346 12 , , , 13433 1346 13 not not RB 13433 1346 14 only only RB 13433 1346 15 does do VBZ 13433 1346 16 not not RB 13433 1346 17 render render VB 13433 1346 18 more more RBR 13433 1346 19 probable probable JJ 13433 1346 20 this this DT 13433 1346 21 account account NN 13433 1346 22 of of IN 13433 1346 23 the the DT 13433 1346 24 composition composition NN 13433 1346 25 of of IN 13433 1346 26 the the DT 13433 1346 27 second second JJ 13433 1346 28 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1346 29 as as IN 13433 1346 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1346 31 lies lie VBZ 13433 1346 32 before before IN 13433 1346 33 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1346 34 , , , 13433 1346 35 but but CC 13433 1346 36 is be VBZ 13433 1346 37 really really RB 13433 1346 38 opposed opposed JJ 13433 1346 39 to to IN 13433 1346 40 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1346 41 . . . 13433 1347 1 Into into IN 13433 1347 2 this this DT 13433 1347 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1347 4 shall shall MD 13433 1347 5 not not RB 13433 1347 6 here here RB 13433 1347 7 go go VB 13433 1347 8 . . . 13433 1348 1 Setting set VBG 13433 1348 2 aside aside RB 13433 1348 3 , , , 13433 1348 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 1348 5 , , , 13433 1348 6 all all PDT 13433 1348 7 the the DT 13433 1348 8 reasons reason NNS 13433 1348 9 for for IN 13433 1348 10 doubting doubt VBG 13433 1348 11 the the DT 13433 1348 12 applicability applicability NN 13433 1348 13 of of IN 13433 1348 14 the the DT 13433 1348 15 tradition tradition NN 13433 1348 16 recorded record VBN 13433 1348 17 by by IN 13433 1348 18 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1348 19 regarding regard VBG 13433 1348 20 the the DT 13433 1348 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1348 22 said say VBD 13433 1348 23 to to TO 13433 1348 24 have have VB 13433 1348 25 been be VBN 13433 1348 26 written write VBN 13433 1348 27 by by IN 13433 1348 28 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1348 29 , , , 13433 1348 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1348 31 simply simply RB 13433 1348 32 appeal appeal VBP 13433 1348 33 to to IN 13433 1348 34 those those DT 13433 1348 35 who who WP 13433 1348 36 have have VBP 13433 1348 37 rightly rightly RB 13433 1348 38 appreciated appreciate VBN 13433 1348 39 the the DT 13433 1348 40 nature nature NN 13433 1348 41 of of IN 13433 1348 42 the the DT 13433 1348 43 allegations allegation NNS 13433 1348 44 for for IN 13433 1348 45 which which WDT 13433 1348 46 evidence evidence NN 13433 1348 47 is be VBZ 13433 1348 48 required require VBN 13433 1348 49 as as IN 13433 1348 50 to to IN 13433 1348 51 the the DT 13433 1348 52 value value NN 13433 1348 53 of of IN 13433 1348 54 such such PDT 13433 1348 55 a a DT 13433 1348 56 work work NN 13433 1348 57 , , , 13433 1348 58 compiled compile VBN 13433 1348 59 by by IN 13433 1348 60 one one CD 13433 1348 61 who who WP 13433 1348 62 had have VBD 13433 1348 63 neither neither CC 13433 1348 64 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1348 65 seen see VBN 13433 1348 66 nor nor CC 13433 1348 67 heard hear VBD 13433 1348 68 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1348 69 . . . 13433 1349 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1349 2 is be VBZ 13433 1349 3 quite quite RB 13433 1349 4 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 1349 5 to to TO 13433 1349 6 proceed proceed VB 13433 1349 7 to to IN 13433 1349 8 the the DT 13433 1349 9 closer close JJR 13433 1349 10 examination examination NN 13433 1349 11 of of IN 13433 1349 12 the the DT 13433 1349 13 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1349 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 1349 15 . . . 13433 1350 1 " " `` 13433 1350 2 But but CC 13433 1350 3 concerning concern VBG 13433 1350 4 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1350 5 the the DT 13433 1350 6 following follow VBG 13433 1350 7 statement statement NN 13433 1350 8 is be VBZ 13433 1350 9 made make VBN 13433 1350 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1350 11 by by IN 13433 1350 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1350 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1350 14 : : : 13433 1350 15 ' ' '' 13433 1350 16 So so RB 13433 1350 17 then then RB 13433 1350 18 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1350 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1350 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1350 21 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1350 22 : : : 13433 1350 23 Matthaios matthaio NNS 13433 1350 24 men man NNS 13433 1350 25 oun oun NNP 13433 1350 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1350 27 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1350 28 composed compose VBD 13433 1350 29 the the DT 13433 1350 30 Oracles Oracles NNPS 13433 1350 31 in in IN 13433 1350 32 the the DT 13433 1350 33 Hebrew hebrew JJ 13433 1350 34 language language NN 13433 1350 35 , , , 13433 1350 36 and and CC 13433 1350 37 each each DT 13433 1350 38 one one NN 13433 1350 39 interpreted interpret VBD 13433 1350 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1350 41 as as IN 13433 1350 42 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1350 43 could could MD 13433 1350 44 . . . 13433 1350 45 ' ' '' 13433 1350 46 " " '' 13433 1351 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1351 2 119:1 119:1 LS 13433 1351 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1351 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1351 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1351 6 points point VBZ 13433 1351 7 out out RP 13433 1351 8 that that IN 13433 1351 9 there there EX 13433 1351 10 is be VBZ 13433 1351 11 no no DT 13433 1351 12 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1351 13 reason reason NN 13433 1351 14 for for IN 13433 1351 15 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1351 16 that that IN 13433 1351 17 this this DT 13433 1351 18 statement statement NN 13433 1351 19 , , , 13433 1351 20 like like IN 13433 1351 21 the the DT 13433 1351 22 former former JJ 13433 1351 23 , , , 13433 1351 24 was be VBD 13433 1351 25 made make VBN 13433 1351 26 on on IN 13433 1351 27 the the DT 13433 1351 28 authority authority NN 13433 1351 29 of of IN 13433 1351 30 the the DT 13433 1351 31 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 1351 32 , , , 13433 1351 33 and and CC 13433 1351 34 , , , 13433 1351 35 although although IN 13433 1351 36 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1351 37 think think VBP 13433 1351 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1351 39 probable probable JJ 13433 1351 40 that that IN 13433 1351 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1351 42 was be VBD 13433 1351 43 , , , 13433 1351 44 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1351 45 agree agree VBP 13433 1351 46 with with IN 13433 1351 47 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1351 48 in in IN 13433 1351 49 this this DT 13433 1351 50 . . . 13433 1352 1 The the DT 13433 1352 2 doubt doubt NN 13433 1352 3 , , , 13433 1352 4 however however RB 13433 1352 5 , , , 13433 1352 6 is be VBZ 13433 1352 7 specially specially RB 13433 1352 8 advanced advanced JJ 13433 1352 9 because because IN 13433 1352 10 , , , 13433 1352 11 the the DT 13433 1352 12 statement statement NN 13433 1352 13 of of IN 13433 1352 14 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1352 15 being be VBG 13433 1352 16 particularly particularly RB 13433 1352 17 inconvenient inconvenient JJ 13433 1352 18 to to IN 13433 1352 19 apologists apologist NNS 13433 1352 20 , , , 13433 1352 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1352 22 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1352 23 is be VBZ 13433 1352 24 evidently evidently RB 13433 1352 25 anxious anxious JJ 13433 1352 26 to to TO 13433 1352 27 invalidate invalidate VB 13433 1352 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1352 29 . . . 13433 1353 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1353 2 accepts accept VBZ 13433 1353 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1353 4 in in RP 13433 1353 5 so so RB 13433 1353 6 far far RB 13433 1353 7 as as IN 13433 1353 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1353 9 seems seem VBZ 13433 1353 10 to to TO 13433 1353 11 permit permit VB 13433 1353 12 of of IN 13433 1353 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1353 14 drawing draw VBG 13433 1353 15 certain certain JJ 13433 1353 16 inferences inference NNS 13433 1353 17 from from IN 13433 1353 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1353 19 , , , 13433 1353 20 but but CC 13433 1353 21 for for IN 13433 1353 22 the the DT 13433 1353 23 rest rest NN 13433 1353 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1353 25 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 1353 26 to to TO 13433 1353 27 weaken weaken VB 13433 1353 28 the the DT 13433 1353 29 testimony testimony NN 13433 1353 30 . . . 13433 1354 1 " " `` 13433 1354 2 But but CC 13433 1354 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1354 4 does do VBZ 13433 1354 5 not not RB 13433 1354 6 follow follow VB 13433 1354 7 that that IN 13433 1354 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1354 9 account account NN 13433 1354 10 of of IN 13433 1354 11 the the DT 13433 1354 12 origin origin NN 13433 1354 13 was be VBD 13433 1354 14 correct correct JJ 13433 1354 15 . . . 13433 1355 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1355 2 may may MD 13433 1355 3 be be VB 13433 1355 4 ; ; : 13433 1355 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1355 6 may may MD 13433 1355 7 not not RB 13433 1355 8 have have VB 13433 1355 9 been be VBN 13433 1355 10 . . . 13433 1356 1 This this DT 13433 1356 2 is be VBZ 13433 1356 3 just just RB 13433 1356 4 what what WP 13433 1356 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1356 6 can can MD 13433 1356 7 not not RB 13433 1356 8 decide decide VB 13433 1356 9 , , , 13433 1356 10 because because IN 13433 1356 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1356 12 do do VBP 13433 1356 13 not not RB 13433 1356 14 know know VB 13433 1356 15 what what WP 13433 1356 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1356 17 said say VBD 13433 1356 18 . . . 13433 1356 19 " " '' 13433 1357 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1357 2 120:1 120:1 CD 13433 1357 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1357 4 What what WP 13433 1357 5 a a DT 13433 1357 6 pity pity NN 13433 1357 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1357 8 is be VBZ 13433 1357 9 that that IN 13433 1357 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1357 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1357 12 does do VBZ 13433 1357 13 not not RB 13433 1357 14 always always RB 13433 1357 15 exercise exercise VB 13433 1357 16 this this DT 13433 1357 17 rigorous rigorous JJ 13433 1357 18 logic logic NN 13433 1357 19 . . . 13433 1358 1 If if IN 13433 1358 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1358 3 did do VBD 13433 1358 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1358 5 would would MD 13433 1358 6 infallibly infallibly RB 13433 1358 7 agree agree VB 13433 1358 8 with with IN 13433 1358 9 the the DT 13433 1358 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 1358 11 of of IN 13433 1358 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1358 13 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1358 14 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1358 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1358 16 . . . 13433 1359 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1359 2 shall shall MD 13433 1359 3 presently presently RB 13433 1359 4 state state VB 13433 1359 5 what what WP 13433 1359 6 inference inference NN 13433 1359 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1359 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1359 9 wishes wish VBZ 13433 1359 10 to to TO 13433 1359 11 draw draw VB 13433 1359 12 from from IN 13433 1359 13 a a DT 13433 1359 14 statement statement NN 13433 1359 15 the the DT 13433 1359 16 general general JJ 13433 1359 17 correctness correctness NN 13433 1359 18 of of IN 13433 1359 19 which which WDT 13433 1359 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1359 21 does do VBZ 13433 1359 22 not not RB 13433 1359 23 consider consider VB 13433 1359 24 as as IN 13433 1359 25 at at RB 13433 1359 26 all all RB 13433 1359 27 certain certain JJ 13433 1359 28 . . . 13433 1360 1 If if IN 13433 1360 2 this this DT 13433 1360 3 doubt doubt NN 13433 1360 4 exist exist VBP 13433 1360 5 , , , 13433 1360 6 however however RB 13433 1360 7 , , , 13433 1360 8 of of IN 13433 1360 9 what what WDT 13433 1360 10 value value NN 13433 1360 11 can can MD 13433 1360 12 the the DT 13433 1360 13 passage passage NN 13433 1360 14 from from IN 13433 1360 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1360 16 be be VB 13433 1360 17 as as IN 13433 1360 18 evidence evidence NN 13433 1360 19 ? ? . 13433 1361 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1361 2 can can MD 13433 1361 3 not not RB 13433 1361 4 perceive perceive VB 13433 1361 5 that that IN 13433 1361 6 , , , 13433 1361 7 if if IN 13433 1361 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1361 9 do do VBP 13433 1361 10 not not RB 13433 1361 11 reject reject VB 13433 1361 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1361 13 altogether altogether RB 13433 1361 14 on on IN 13433 1361 15 the the DT 13433 1361 16 ground ground NN 13433 1361 17 of of IN 13433 1361 18 possible possible JJ 13433 1361 19 or or CC 13433 1361 20 probable probable JJ 13433 1361 21 incorrectness incorrectness NN 13433 1361 22 , , , 13433 1361 23 there there EX 13433 1361 24 can can MD 13433 1361 25 be be VB 13433 1361 26 any any DT 13433 1361 27 reasonable reasonable JJ 13433 1361 28 doubt doubt NN 13433 1361 29 as as IN 13433 1361 30 to to IN 13433 1361 31 what what WP 13433 1361 32 the the DT 13433 1361 33 actual actual JJ 13433 1361 34 statement statement NN 13433 1361 35 was be VBD 13433 1361 36 . . . 13433 1362 1 " " `` 13433 1362 2 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1362 3 composed compose VBD 13433 1362 4 the the DT 13433 1362 5 Oracles oracle NNS 13433 1362 6 in in IN 13433 1362 7 the the DT 13433 1362 8 Hebrew hebrew JJ 13433 1362 9 language language NN 13433 1362 10 , , , 13433 1362 11 " " '' 13433 1362 12 and and CC 13433 1362 13 not not RB 13433 1362 14 in in IN 13433 1362 15 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1362 16 , , , 13433 1362 17 " " '' 13433 1362 18 and and CC 13433 1362 19 each each DT 13433 1362 20 one one NN 13433 1362 21 interpreted interpret VBD 13433 1362 22 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1362 23 as as IN 13433 1362 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1362 25 could could MD 13433 1362 26 . . . 13433 1362 27 " " '' 13433 1363 1 The the DT 13433 1363 2 original original JJ 13433 1363 3 work work NN 13433 1363 4 of of IN 13433 1363 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1363 6 was be VBD 13433 1363 7 written write VBN 13433 1363 8 in in IN 13433 1363 9 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1363 10 : : : 13433 1363 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1363 12 first first JJ 13433 1363 13 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1363 14 is be VBZ 13433 1363 15 a a DT 13433 1363 16 Greek greek JJ 13433 1363 17 work work NN 13433 1363 18 : : : 13433 1363 19 therefore therefore RB 13433 1363 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1363 21 can can MD 13433 1363 22 not not RB 13433 1363 23 possibly possibly RB 13433 1363 24 be be VB 13433 1363 25 the the DT 13433 1363 26 original original JJ 13433 1363 27 composition composition NN 13433 1363 28 of of IN 13433 1363 29 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1363 30 , , , 13433 1363 31 whoever whoever WP 13433 1363 32 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1363 33 may may MD 13433 1363 34 have have VB 13433 1363 35 been be VBN 13433 1363 36 , , , 13433 1363 37 but but CC 13433 1363 38 at at IN 13433 1363 39 the the DT 13433 1363 40 best good JJS 13433 1363 41 can can MD 13433 1363 42 only only RB 13433 1363 43 be be VB 13433 1363 44 a a DT 13433 1363 45 free free JJ 13433 1363 46 translation translation NN 13433 1363 47 . . . 13433 1364 1 A a DT 13433 1364 2 free free JJ 13433 1364 3 translation translation NN 13433 1364 4 , , , 13433 1364 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1364 6 say say VBP 13433 1364 7 , , , 13433 1364 8 because because IN 13433 1364 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1364 10 does do VBZ 13433 1364 11 not not RB 13433 1364 12 bear bear VB 13433 1364 13 any any DT 13433 1364 14 of of IN 13433 1364 15 the the DT 13433 1364 16 traces trace NNS 13433 1364 17 of of IN 13433 1364 18 close close JJ 13433 1364 19 translation translation NN 13433 1364 20 . . . 13433 1365 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1365 2 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1365 3 , , , 13433 1365 4 indeed indeed RB 13433 1365 5 , , , 13433 1365 6 does do VBZ 13433 1365 7 not not RB 13433 1365 8 purport purport VB 13433 1365 9 to to TO 13433 1365 10 be be VB 13433 1365 11 a a DT 13433 1365 12 translation translation NN 13433 1365 13 at at RB 13433 1365 14 all all RB 13433 1365 15 , , , 13433 1365 16 but but CC 13433 1365 17 if if IN 13433 1365 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1365 19 be be VB 13433 1365 20 a a DT 13433 1365 21 version version NN 13433 1365 22 of of IN 13433 1365 23 the the DT 13433 1365 24 work work NN 13433 1365 25 referred refer VBD 13433 1365 26 to to IN 13433 1365 27 by by IN 13433 1365 28 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1365 29 , , , 13433 1365 30 or or CC 13433 1365 31 the the DT 13433 1365 32 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 1365 33 , , , 13433 1365 34 a a DT 13433 1365 35 translation translation NN 13433 1365 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1365 37 must must MD 13433 1365 38 be be VB 13433 1365 39 . . . 13433 1366 1 As as IN 13433 1366 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1366 3 is be VBZ 13433 1366 4 not not RB 13433 1366 5 in in IN 13433 1366 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1366 7 original original JJ 13433 1366 8 form form NN 13433 1366 9 , , , 13433 1366 10 however however RB 13433 1366 11 , , , 13433 1366 12 and and CC 13433 1366 13 no no DT 13433 1366 14 one one NN 13433 1366 15 can can MD 13433 1366 16 affirm affirm VB 13433 1366 17 what what WP 13433 1366 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1366 19 precise precise JJ 13433 1366 20 relation relation NN 13433 1366 21 to to IN 13433 1366 22 the the DT 13433 1366 23 work work NN 13433 1366 24 of of IN 13433 1366 25 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1366 26 may may MD 13433 1366 27 be be VB 13433 1366 28 , , , 13433 1366 29 the the DT 13433 1366 30 whole whole JJ 13433 1366 31 value value NN 13433 1366 32 of of IN 13433 1366 33 the the DT 13433 1366 34 statement statement NN 13433 1366 35 of of IN 13433 1366 36 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1366 37 is be VBZ 13433 1366 38 lost lose VBN 13433 1366 39 . . . 13433 1367 1 The the DT 13433 1367 2 inference inference NN 13433 1367 3 which which WDT 13433 1367 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1367 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1367 6 considers consider VBZ 13433 1367 7 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1367 8 entitled entitle VBD 13433 1367 9 to to TO 13433 1367 10 draw draw VB 13433 1367 11 from from IN 13433 1367 12 the the DT 13433 1367 13 testimony testimony NN 13433 1367 14 of of IN 13433 1367 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1367 16 is be VBZ 13433 1367 17 in in IN 13433 1367 18 most most RBS 13433 1367 19 curious curious JJ 13433 1367 20 contrast contrast NN 13433 1367 21 with with IN 13433 1367 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1367 23 severe severe JJ 13433 1367 24 handling handling NN 13433 1367 25 of of IN 13433 1367 26 that that DT 13433 1367 27 part part NN 13433 1367 28 of of IN 13433 1367 29 the the DT 13433 1367 30 testimony testimony NN 13433 1367 31 which which WDT 13433 1367 32 does do VBZ 13433 1367 33 not not RB 13433 1367 34 suit suit VB 13433 1367 35 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1367 36 . . . 13433 1368 1 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1368 2 , , , 13433 1368 3 or or CC 13433 1368 4 the the DT 13433 1368 5 Presbyter Presbyter NNP 13433 1368 6 , , , 13433 1368 7 states state NNS 13433 1368 8 regarding regard VBG 13433 1368 9 the the DT 13433 1368 10 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1368 11 Oracles Oracles NNPS 13433 1368 12 of of IN 13433 1368 13 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1368 14 that that IN 13433 1368 15 " " `` 13433 1368 16 each each DT 13433 1368 17 one one NN 13433 1368 18 interpreted interpret VBD 13433 1368 19 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1368 20 as as IN 13433 1368 21 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1368 22 could could MD 13433 1368 23 . . . 13433 1368 24 " " '' 13433 1369 1 The the DT 13433 1369 2 use use NN 13433 1369 3 of of IN 13433 1369 4 the the DT 13433 1369 5 verb verb NN 13433 1369 6 " " `` 13433 1369 7 interpreted interpret VBN 13433 1369 8 " " '' 13433 1369 9 in in IN 13433 1369 10 the the DT 13433 1369 11 past past JJ 13433 1369 12 tense tense JJ 13433 1369 13 , , , 13433 1369 14 instead instead RB 13433 1369 15 of of IN 13433 1369 16 " " `` 13433 1369 17 interprets interpret NNS 13433 1369 18 " " '' 13433 1369 19 in in IN 13433 1369 20 the the DT 13433 1369 21 present present NN 13433 1369 22 , , , 13433 1369 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1369 24 considers consider VBZ 13433 1369 25 , , , 13433 1369 26 clearly clearly RB 13433 1369 27 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 1369 28 that that IN 13433 1369 29 the the DT 13433 1369 30 time time NN 13433 1369 31 which which WDT 13433 1369 32 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1369 33 contemplates contemplate VBZ 13433 1369 34 is be VBZ 13433 1369 35 not not RB 13433 1369 36 the the DT 13433 1369 37 time time NN 13433 1369 38 when when WRB 13433 1369 39 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1369 40 writes write VBZ 13433 1369 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1369 42 book book NN 13433 1369 43 . . . 13433 1370 1 Each each DT 13433 1370 2 one one NN 13433 1370 3 interpreted interpret VBD 13433 1370 4 as as IN 13433 1370 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1370 6 could could MD 13433 1370 7 when when WRB 13433 1370 8 the the DT 13433 1370 9 Oracles Oracles NNPS 13433 1370 10 were be VBD 13433 1370 11 written write VBN 13433 1370 12 , , , 13433 1370 13 but but CC 13433 1370 14 the the DT 13433 1370 15 necessity necessity NN 13433 1370 16 of of IN 13433 1370 17 which which WDT 13433 1370 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1370 19 speaks speak VBZ 13433 1370 20 had have VBD 13433 1370 21 passed pass VBN 13433 1370 22 away away RB 13433 1370 23 ; ; : 13433 1370 24 and and CC 13433 1370 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1370 26 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1370 27 arrives arrive VBZ 13433 1370 28 at at IN 13433 1370 29 the the DT 13433 1370 30 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1370 31 : : : 13433 1370 32 " " `` 13433 1370 33 In in IN 13433 1370 34 other other JJ 13433 1370 35 words word NNS 13433 1370 36 , , , 13433 1370 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1370 38 implies imply VBZ 13433 1370 39 the the DT 13433 1370 40 existence existence NN 13433 1370 41 of of IN 13433 1370 42 a a DT 13433 1370 43 recognised recognise VBN 13433 1370 44 Greek greek JJ 13433 1370 45 translation translation NN 13433 1370 46 _ _ NNP 13433 1370 47 when when WRB 13433 1370 48 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1370 49 wrote write VBD 13433 1370 50 _ _ NNP 13433 1370 51 ... ... . 13433 1371 1 But but CC 13433 1371 2 if if IN 13433 1371 3 a a DT 13433 1371 4 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1371 5 St. St. NNP 13433 1371 6 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1371 7 existed exist VBD 13433 1371 8 in in IN 13433 1371 9 the the DT 13433 1371 10 time time NN 13433 1371 11 of of IN 13433 1371 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1371 13 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1371 14 are be VBP 13433 1371 15 forbidden forbid VBN 13433 1371 16 by by IN 13433 1371 17 all all DT 13433 1371 18 considerations consideration NNS 13433 1371 19 of of IN 13433 1371 20 historical historical JJ 13433 1371 21 probability probability NN 13433 1371 22 to to TO 13433 1371 23 suppose suppose VB 13433 1371 24 that that IN 13433 1371 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1371 26 was be VBD 13433 1371 27 any any DT 13433 1371 28 other other JJ 13433 1371 29 than than IN 13433 1371 30 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1371 31 St. St. NNP 13433 1372 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1372 2 . . . 13433 1372 3 " " '' 13433 1373 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1373 2 121:1 121:1 CD 13433 1373 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1373 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1373 5 is be VBZ 13433 1373 6 very very RB 13433 1373 7 probable probable JJ 13433 1373 8 that that IN 13433 1373 9 , , , 13433 1373 10 at at IN 13433 1373 11 the the DT 13433 1373 12 time time NN 13433 1373 13 when when WRB 13433 1373 14 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1373 15 wrote write VBD 13433 1373 16 , , , 13433 1373 17 there there EX 13433 1373 18 may may MD 13433 1373 19 have have VB 13433 1373 20 been be VBN 13433 1373 21 several several JJ 13433 1373 22 translations translation NNS 13433 1373 23 of of IN 13433 1373 24 the the DT 13433 1373 25 " " `` 13433 1373 26 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 1373 27 " " '' 13433 1373 28 and and CC 13433 1373 29 not not RB 13433 1373 30 merely merely RB 13433 1373 31 one one CD 13433 1373 32 , , , 13433 1373 33 but but CC 13433 1373 34 from from IN 13433 1373 35 this this DT 13433 1373 36 to to IN 13433 1373 37 the the DT 13433 1373 38 assertion assertion NN 13433 1373 39 that that IN 13433 1373 40 the the DT 13433 1373 41 words word NNS 13433 1373 42 imply imply VBP 13433 1373 43 a a DT 13433 1373 44 " " `` 13433 1373 45 recognised recognise VBN 13433 1373 46 " " '' 13433 1373 47 version version NN 13433 1373 48 which which WDT 13433 1373 49 was be VBD 13433 1373 50 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 1373 51 " " `` 13433 1373 52 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1373 53 St. St. NNP 13433 1373 54 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1373 55 " " '' 13433 1373 56 is be VBZ 13433 1373 57 a a DT 13433 1373 58 remarkable remarkable JJ 13433 1373 59 jump jump NN 13433 1373 60 at at IN 13433 1373 61 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 1373 62 . . . 13433 1374 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1374 2 is be VBZ 13433 1374 3 really really RB 13433 1374 4 not not RB 13433 1374 5 worth worth JJ 13433 1374 6 while while IN 13433 1374 7 again again RB 13433 1374 8 to to TO 13433 1374 9 discuss discuss VB 13433 1374 10 the the DT 13433 1374 11 point point NN 13433 1374 12 . . . 13433 1375 1 When when WRB 13433 1375 2 imagination imagination NN 13433 1375 3 is be VBZ 13433 1375 4 allowed allow VBN 13433 1375 5 to to TO 13433 1375 6 interpret interpret VB 13433 1375 7 the the DT 13433 1375 8 hidden hide VBN 13433 1375 9 meaning meaning NN 13433 1375 10 of of IN 13433 1375 11 such such PDT 13433 1375 12 a a DT 13433 1375 13 statement statement NN 13433 1375 14 the the DT 13433 1375 15 consequence consequence NN 13433 1375 16 can can MD 13433 1375 17 not not RB 13433 1375 18 well well RB 13433 1375 19 be be VB 13433 1375 20 predicated predicate VBN 13433 1375 21 . . . 13433 1376 1 This this DT 13433 1376 2 hypothesis hypothesis NN 13433 1376 3 still still RB 13433 1376 4 leaves leave VBZ 13433 1376 5 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1376 6 to to TO 13433 1376 7 account account VB 13433 1376 8 for for IN 13433 1376 9 the the DT 13433 1376 10 substitution substitution NN 13433 1376 11 of of IN 13433 1376 12 a a DT 13433 1376 13 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1376 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1376 15 for for IN 13433 1376 16 the the DT 13433 1376 17 Hebrew hebrew JJ 13433 1376 18 original original NN 13433 1376 19 of of IN 13433 1376 20 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1376 21 , , , 13433 1376 22 and and CC 13433 1376 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1376 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1376 25 does do VBZ 13433 1376 26 not not RB 13433 1376 27 assist assist VB 13433 1376 28 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1376 29 much much JJ 13433 1376 30 . . . 13433 1377 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1377 2 demurs demur VBZ 13433 1377 3 to to IN 13433 1377 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1377 5 statement statement NN 13433 1377 6 that that IN 13433 1377 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1377 8 first first JJ 13433 1377 9 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1377 10 bears bear VBZ 13433 1377 11 all all PDT 13433 1377 12 the the DT 13433 1377 13 marks mark NNS 13433 1377 14 of of IN 13433 1377 15 an an DT 13433 1377 16 original original JJ 13433 1377 17 , , , 13433 1377 18 and and CC 13433 1377 19 can can MD 13433 1377 20 not not RB 13433 1377 21 have have VB 13433 1377 22 been be VBN 13433 1377 23 translated translate VBN 13433 1377 24 from from IN 13433 1377 25 the the DT 13433 1377 26 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1377 27 at at RB 13433 1377 28 all all RB 13433 1377 29 : : : 13433 1377 30 " " `` 13433 1377 31 If if IN 13433 1377 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1377 33 had have VBD 13433 1377 34 said say VBN 13433 1377 35 that that IN 13433 1377 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1377 37 is be VBZ 13433 1377 38 not not RB 13433 1377 39 a a DT 13433 1377 40 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 13433 1377 41 Greek greek JJ 13433 1377 42 version version NN 13433 1377 43 of of IN 13433 1377 44 a a DT 13433 1377 45 homogeneous homogeneous JJ 13433 1377 46 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1377 47 original original NN 13433 1377 48 this this DT 13433 1377 49 would would MD 13433 1377 50 have have VB 13433 1377 51 been be VBN 13433 1377 52 nearer nearer IN 13433 1377 53 the the DT 13433 1377 54 truth truth NN 13433 1377 55 . . . 13433 1377 56 " " '' 13433 1378 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1378 2 122:1 122:1 LS 13433 1378 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1378 4 That that IN 13433 1378 5 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1378 6 original original NN 13433 1378 7 is be VBZ 13433 1378 8 a a DT 13433 1378 9 sad sad JJ 13433 1378 10 stumbling stumbling NN 13433 1378 11 - - HYPH 13433 1378 12 block block NN 13433 1378 13 , , , 13433 1378 14 and and CC 13433 1378 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1378 16 must must MD 13433 1378 17 be be VB 13433 1378 18 got get VBN 13433 1378 19 rid rid JJ 13433 1378 20 of of IN 13433 1378 21 at at IN 13433 1378 22 all all DT 13433 1378 23 costs cost NNS 13433 1378 24 . . . 13433 1379 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1379 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1379 3 is be VBZ 13433 1379 4 full full JJ 13433 1379 5 of of IN 13433 1379 6 resources resource NNS 13433 1379 7 . . . 13433 1380 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1380 2 have have VBP 13433 1380 3 seen see VBN 13433 1380 4 that that IN 13433 1380 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1380 6 has have VBZ 13433 1380 7 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1380 8 that that IN 13433 1380 9 the the DT 13433 1380 10 account account NN 13433 1380 11 of of IN 13433 1380 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1380 13 of of IN 13433 1380 14 the the DT 13433 1380 15 origin origin NN 13433 1380 16 may may MD 13433 1380 17 not not RB 13433 1380 18 have have VB 13433 1380 19 been be VBN 13433 1380 20 correct correct JJ 13433 1380 21 . . . 13433 1381 1 Regarding regard VBG 13433 1381 2 the the DT 13433 1381 3 translation translation NN 13433 1381 4 or or CC 13433 1381 5 the the DT 13433 1381 6 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1381 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1381 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1381 9 do do VBP 13433 1381 10 not not RB 13433 1381 11 know know VB 13433 1381 12 exactly exactly RB 13433 1381 13 what what WP 13433 1381 14 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1381 15 said say VBD 13433 1381 16 . . . 13433 1382 1 " " `` 13433 1382 2 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1382 3 may may MD 13433 1382 4 have have VB 13433 1382 5 expressed express VBN 13433 1382 6 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1382 7 in in IN 13433 1382 8 language language NN 13433 1382 9 quite quite RB 13433 1382 10 consistent consistent JJ 13433 1382 11 with with IN 13433 1382 12 the the DT 13433 1382 13 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1382 14 . . . 13433 1382 15 " " '' 13433 1383 1 How how WRB 13433 1383 2 unlimited unlimited JJ 13433 1383 3 a a DT 13433 1383 4 field field NN 13433 1383 5 for for IN 13433 1383 6 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1383 7 is be VBZ 13433 1383 8 thus thus RB 13433 1383 9 opened open VBN 13433 1383 10 out out RP 13433 1383 11 . . . 13433 1384 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1384 2 do do VBP 13433 1384 3 not not RB 13433 1384 4 know know VB 13433 1384 5 more more JJR 13433 1384 6 of of IN 13433 1384 7 what what WP 13433 1384 8 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1384 9 said say VBD 13433 1384 10 than than IN 13433 1384 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1384 12 has have VBZ 13433 1384 13 recorded record VBN 13433 1384 14 , , , 13433 1384 15 and and CC 13433 1384 16 may may MD 13433 1384 17 therefore therefore RB 13433 1384 18 suppose suppose VB 13433 1384 19 that that IN 13433 1384 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1384 21 may may MD 13433 1384 22 have have VB 13433 1384 23 said say VBN 13433 1384 24 something something NN 13433 1384 25 more more JJR 13433 1384 26 , , , 13433 1384 27 which which WDT 13433 1384 28 may may MD 13433 1384 29 have have VB 13433 1384 30 been be VBN 13433 1384 31 consistent consistent JJ 13433 1384 32 with with IN 13433 1384 33 any any DT 13433 1384 34 theory theory NN 13433 1384 35 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1384 36 may may MD 13433 1384 37 advance advance VB 13433 1384 38 . . . 13433 1385 1 " " `` 13433 1385 2 Or or CC 13433 1385 3 , , , 13433 1385 4 on on IN 13433 1385 5 the the DT 13433 1385 6 other other JJ 13433 1385 7 hand hand NN 13433 1385 8 , , , 13433 1385 9 " " '' 13433 1385 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1385 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1385 12 continues continue VBZ 13433 1385 13 , , , 13433 1385 14 " " '' 13433 1385 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1385 16 may may MD 13433 1385 17 , , , 13433 1385 18 as as IN 13433 1385 19 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1385 20 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 1385 21 , , , 13433 1385 22 have have VBP 13433 1385 23 made make VBN 13433 1385 24 the the DT 13433 1385 25 mistake mistake NN 13433 1385 26 which which WDT 13433 1385 27 some some DT 13433 1385 28 later later JJ 13433 1385 29 Fathers father NNS 13433 1385 30 made make VBD 13433 1385 31 of of IN 13433 1385 32 thinking think VBG 13433 1385 33 that that IN 13433 1385 34 the the DT 13433 1385 35 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1385 36 according accord VBG 13433 1385 37 to to IN 13433 1385 38 the the DT 13433 1385 39 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1385 40 was be VBD 13433 1385 41 the the DT 13433 1385 42 original original NN 13433 1385 43 of of IN 13433 1385 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1385 45 St. St. NNP 13433 1386 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1386 2 . . . 13433 1386 3 " " '' 13433 1387 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1387 2 122:2 122:2 CD 13433 1387 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1387 4 Who who WP 13433 1387 5 would would MD 13433 1387 6 think think VB 13433 1387 7 that that IN 13433 1387 8 this this DT 13433 1387 9 is be VBZ 13433 1387 10 the the DT 13433 1387 11 critic critic NN 13433 1387 12 who who WP 13433 1387 13 vents vent VBZ 13433 1387 14 so so RB 13433 1387 15 much much JJ 13433 1387 16 righteous righteous JJ 13433 1387 17 indignation indignation NN 13433 1387 18 upon upon IN 13433 1387 19 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1387 20 for for IN 13433 1387 21 pointing point VBG 13433 1387 22 out out RP 13433 1387 23 possible possible JJ 13433 1387 24 or or CC 13433 1387 25 probable probable JJ 13433 1387 26 alternative alternative JJ 13433 1387 27 interpretations interpretation NNS 13433 1387 28 of of IN 13433 1387 29 vague vague JJ 13433 1387 30 evidence evidence NN 13433 1387 31 extracted extract VBN 13433 1387 32 from from IN 13433 1387 33 the the DT 13433 1387 34 Fathers father NNS 13433 1387 35 ? ? . 13433 1388 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1388 2 is be VBZ 13433 1388 3 true true JJ 13433 1388 4 that that IN 13433 1388 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1388 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1388 7 continues continue VBZ 13433 1388 8 : : : 13433 1388 9 " " `` 13433 1388 10 In in IN 13433 1388 11 the the DT 13433 1388 12 absence absence NN 13433 1388 13 of of IN 13433 1388 14 adequate adequate JJ 13433 1388 15 data datum NNS 13433 1388 16 , , , 13433 1388 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1388 18 is be VBZ 13433 1388 19 quite quite RB 13433 1388 20 vain vain JJ 13433 1388 21 to to IN 13433 1388 22 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1388 23 . . . 13433 1389 1 But but CC 13433 1389 2 meanwhile meanwhile RB 13433 1389 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1389 4 are be VBP 13433 1389 5 not not RB 13433 1389 6 warranted warrant VBN 13433 1389 7 in in IN 13433 1389 8 drawing draw VBG 13433 1389 9 any any DT 13433 1389 10 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1389 11 unfavourable unfavourable JJ 13433 1389 12 either either CC 13433 1389 13 to to IN 13433 1389 14 the the DT 13433 1389 15 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1389 16 of of IN 13433 1389 17 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1389 18 or or CC 13433 1389 19 to to IN 13433 1389 20 the the DT 13433 1389 21 identity identity NN 13433 1389 22 of of IN 13433 1389 23 the the DT 13433 1389 24 document document NN 13433 1389 25 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1389 26 . . . 13433 1389 27 " " '' 13433 1390 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1390 2 122:3 122:3 LS 13433 1390 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1390 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1390 5 thus thus RB 13433 1390 6 seeks seek VBZ 13433 1390 7 to to TO 13433 1390 8 reserve reserve VB 13433 1390 9 for for IN 13433 1390 10 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1390 11 any any DT 13433 1390 12 support support NN 13433 1390 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1390 14 thinks think VBZ 13433 1390 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1390 16 can can MD 13433 1390 17 derive derive VB 13433 1390 18 from from IN 13433 1390 19 the the DT 13433 1390 20 tradition tradition NN 13433 1390 21 of of IN 13433 1390 22 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1390 23 , , , 13433 1390 24 and and CC 13433 1390 25 set set VB 13433 1390 26 aside aside RB 13433 1390 27 exactly exactly RB 13433 1390 28 as as RB 13433 1390 29 much much RB 13433 1390 30 as as IN 13433 1390 31 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1390 32 does do VBZ 13433 1390 33 not not RB 13433 1390 34 like like VB 13433 1390 35 . . . 13433 1391 1 In in IN 13433 1391 2 fact fact NN 13433 1391 3 , , , 13433 1391 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1391 5 clearly clearly RB 13433 1391 6 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 1391 7 how how WRB 13433 1391 8 exceedingly exceedingly RB 13433 1391 9 loose loose JJ 13433 1391 10 is be VBZ 13433 1391 11 all all PDT 13433 1391 12 this this DT 13433 1391 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 1391 14 from from IN 13433 1391 15 the the DT 13433 1391 16 Fathers Fathers NNP 13433 1391 17 , , , 13433 1391 18 and and CC 13433 1391 19 with with IN 13433 1391 20 what what WDT 13433 1391 21 ease ease NN 13433 1391 22 one one CD 13433 1391 23 may may MD 13433 1391 24 either either CC 13433 1391 25 base base NN 13433 1391 26 magnificent magnificent JJ 13433 1391 27 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 1391 28 upon upon IN 13433 1391 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1391 30 , , , 13433 1391 31 or or CC 13433 1391 32 drive drive VB 13433 1391 33 a a DT 13433 1391 34 coach coach NN 13433 1391 35 and and CC 13433 1391 36 four four CD 13433 1391 37 through through IN 13433 1391 38 the the DT 13433 1391 39 whole whole JJ 13433 1391 40 mass mass NN 13433 1391 41 . . . 13433 1392 1 In in IN 13433 1392 2 admitting admit VBG 13433 1392 3 for for IN 13433 1392 4 a a DT 13433 1392 5 moment moment NN 13433 1392 6 that that WDT 13433 1392 7 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1392 8 may may MD 13433 1392 9 have have VB 13433 1392 10 mistaken mistake VBN 13433 1392 11 the the DT 13433 1392 12 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1392 13 of of IN 13433 1392 14 the the DT 13433 1392 15 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1392 16 " " '' 13433 1392 17 for for IN 13433 1392 18 the the DT 13433 1392 19 original original NN 13433 1392 20 of of IN 13433 1392 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1392 22 St. St. NNP 13433 1392 23 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1392 24 , , , 13433 1392 25 " " '' 13433 1392 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1392 27 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1392 28 , , , 13433 1392 29 in in IN 13433 1392 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1392 31 attempt attempt NN 13433 1392 32 to to TO 13433 1392 33 get get VB 13433 1392 34 rid rid VBN 13433 1392 35 of of IN 13433 1392 36 that that DT 13433 1392 37 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 13433 1392 38 Hebrew hebrew JJ 13433 1392 39 work work NN 13433 1392 40 of of IN 13433 1392 41 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1392 42 , , , 13433 1392 43 has have VBZ 13433 1392 44 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 1392 45 gone go VBN 13433 1392 46 further further RB 13433 1392 47 than than IN 13433 1392 48 is be VBZ 13433 1392 49 safe safe JJ 13433 1392 50 for for IN 13433 1392 51 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1392 52 . . . 13433 1393 1 Apart apart RB 13433 1393 2 from from IN 13433 1393 3 the the DT 13433 1393 4 general general JJ 13433 1393 5 flavour flavour NN 13433 1393 6 of of IN 13433 1393 7 inaccuracy inaccuracy NN 13433 1393 8 which which WDT 13433 1393 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1393 10 imparts impart VBZ 13433 1393 11 to to IN 13433 1393 12 the the DT 13433 1393 13 testimony testimony NN 13433 1393 14 of of IN 13433 1393 15 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1393 16 , , , 13433 1393 17 the the DT 13433 1393 18 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1393 19 inference inference NN 13433 1393 20 is be VBZ 13433 1393 21 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1393 22 that that IN 13433 1393 23 , , , 13433 1393 24 if if IN 13433 1393 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1393 26 made make VBD 13433 1393 27 this this DT 13433 1393 28 mistake mistake NN 13433 1393 29 , , , 13433 1393 30 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1393 31 is be VBZ 13433 1393 32 far far RB 13433 1393 33 from from IN 13433 1393 34 being be VBG 13433 1393 35 a a DT 13433 1393 36 witness witness NN 13433 1393 37 for for IN 13433 1393 38 the the DT 13433 1393 39 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1393 40 of of IN 13433 1393 41 the the DT 13433 1393 42 translation translation NN 13433 1393 43 which which WDT 13433 1393 44 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1393 45 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1393 46 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 1393 47 to to TO 13433 1393 48 have have VB 13433 1393 49 then then RB 13433 1393 50 been be VBN 13433 1393 51 " " `` 13433 1393 52 recognised recognise VBN 13433 1393 53 , , , 13433 1393 54 " " '' 13433 1393 55 and and CC 13433 1393 56 which which WDT 13433 1393 57 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1393 58 declares declare VBZ 13433 1393 59 to to TO 13433 1393 60 have have VB 13433 1393 61 been be VBN 13433 1393 62 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1393 63 first first JJ 13433 1393 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1393 65 . . . 13433 1394 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1394 2 is be VBZ 13433 1394 3 well well RB 13433 1394 4 known know VBN 13433 1394 5 at at IN 13433 1394 6 least least JJS 13433 1394 7 that that IN 13433 1394 8 , , , 13433 1394 9 although although IN 13433 1394 10 the the DT 13433 1394 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1394 12 of of IN 13433 1394 13 the the DT 13433 1394 14 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1394 15 bore bear VBD 13433 1394 16 more more JJR 13433 1394 17 analogy analogy NN 13433 1394 18 to to IN 13433 1394 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1394 20 present present JJ 13433 1394 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1394 22 " " '' 13433 1394 23 according accord VBG 13433 1394 24 to to IN 13433 1394 25 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1394 26 " " '' 13433 1394 27 than than IN 13433 1394 28 to to IN 13433 1394 29 any any DT 13433 1394 30 of of IN 13433 1394 31 the the DT 13433 1394 32 other other JJ 13433 1394 33 three three CD 13433 1394 34 , , , 13433 1394 35 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1394 36 very very RB 13433 1394 37 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 1394 38 differed differ VBD 13433 1394 39 from from IN 13433 1394 40 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1394 41 . . . 13433 1395 1 If if IN 13433 1395 2 , , , 13433 1395 3 therefore therefore RB 13433 1395 4 , , , 13433 1395 5 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1395 6 could could MD 13433 1395 7 quietly quietly RB 13433 1395 8 accept accept VB 13433 1395 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1395 10 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1395 11 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1395 12 as as IN 13433 1395 13 an an DT 13433 1395 14 equivalent equivalent NN 13433 1395 15 for for IN 13433 1395 16 the the DT 13433 1395 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1395 18 of of IN 13433 1395 19 the the DT 13433 1395 20 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1395 21 , , , 13433 1395 22 from from IN 13433 1395 23 which which WDT 13433 1395 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1395 25 presented present VBD 13433 1395 26 considerable considerable JJ 13433 1395 27 variation variation NN 13433 1395 28 , , , 13433 1395 29 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1395 30 are be VBP 13433 1395 31 entitled entitle VBN 13433 1395 32 to to TO 13433 1395 33 reject reject VB 13433 1395 34 such such PDT 13433 1395 35 a a DT 13433 1395 36 translation translation NN 13433 1395 37 as as IN 13433 1395 38 evidence evidence NN 13433 1395 39 of of IN 13433 1395 40 the the DT 13433 1395 41 contents content NNS 13433 1395 42 of of IN 13433 1395 43 the the DT 13433 1395 44 original original NN 13433 1395 45 . . . 13433 1396 1 That that IN 13433 1396 2 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1396 3 was be VBD 13433 1396 4 actually actually RB 13433 1396 5 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1396 6 with with IN 13433 1396 7 the the DT 13433 1396 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1396 9 according accord VBG 13433 1396 10 to to IN 13433 1396 11 the the DT 13433 1396 12 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1396 13 may may MD 13433 1396 14 be be VB 13433 1396 15 inferred infer VBN 13433 1396 16 from from IN 13433 1396 17 the the DT 13433 1396 18 statement statement NN 13433 1396 19 of of IN 13433 1396 20 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1396 21 that that IN 13433 1396 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1396 23 relates relate VBZ 13433 1396 24 " " `` 13433 1396 25 a a DT 13433 1396 26 story story NN 13433 1396 27 about about IN 13433 1396 28 a a DT 13433 1396 29 woman woman NN 13433 1396 30 accused accuse VBN 13433 1396 31 of of IN 13433 1396 32 many many JJ 13433 1396 33 sins sin NNS 13433 1396 34 before before IN 13433 1396 35 the the DT 13433 1396 36 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1396 37 " " '' 13433 1396 38 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1396 39 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 1396 40 the the DT 13433 1396 41 same same JJ 13433 1396 42 which which WDT 13433 1396 43 is be VBZ 13433 1396 44 found find VBN 13433 1396 45 in in IN 13433 1396 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1396 47 copies copy NNS 13433 1396 48 of of IN 13433 1396 49 St. St. NNP 13433 1396 50 John John NNP 13433 1396 51 's 's POS 13433 1396 52 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1396 53 , , , 13433 1396 54 vii vii NN 13433 1396 55 . . . 13433 1397 1 53-viii 53-viii CD 13433 1397 2 . . . 13433 1398 1 11 11 CD 13433 1398 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1398 3 , , , 13433 1398 4 " " '' 13433 1398 5 which which WDT 13433 1398 6 the the DT 13433 1398 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1398 8 according accord VBG 13433 1398 9 to to IN 13433 1398 10 the the DT 13433 1398 11 Hebrews Hebrews NNP 13433 1398 12 contains contain NNS 13433 1398 13 . . . 13433 1398 14 " " '' 13433 1399 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1399 2 123:1 123:1 CD 13433 1399 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1399 4 If if IN 13433 1399 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1399 6 exercised exercise VBD 13433 1399 7 any any DT 13433 1399 8 critical critical JJ 13433 1399 9 power power NN 13433 1399 10 at at RB 13433 1399 11 all all RB 13433 1399 12 , , , 13433 1399 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1399 14 could could MD 13433 1399 15 not not RB 13433 1399 16 confound confound VB 13433 1399 17 the the DT 13433 1399 18 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1399 19 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1399 20 with with IN 13433 1399 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1399 22 , , , 13433 1399 23 and and CC 13433 1399 24 if if IN 13433 1399 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1399 26 did do VBD 13433 1399 27 not not RB 13433 1399 28 , , , 13433 1399 29 what what WP 13433 1399 30 becomes become VBZ 13433 1399 31 of of IN 13433 1399 32 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1399 33 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1399 34 's 's POS 13433 1399 35 argument argument NN 13433 1399 36 ? ? . 13433 1400 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1400 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1400 3 argues argue VBZ 13433 1400 4 at at IN 13433 1400 5 considerable considerable JJ 13433 1400 6 length length NN 13433 1400 7 against against IN 13433 1400 8 the the DT 13433 1400 9 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 1400 10 , , , 13433 1400 11 accepted accept VBN 13433 1400 12 by by IN 13433 1400 13 many many JJ 13433 1400 14 eminent eminent JJ 13433 1400 15 critics critic NNS 13433 1400 16 , , , 13433 1400 17 that that IN 13433 1400 18 the the DT 13433 1400 19 work work NN 13433 1400 20 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1400 21 to to IN 13433 1400 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1400 23 and and CC 13433 1400 24 called call VBD 13433 1400 25 the the DT 13433 1400 26 " " `` 13433 1400 27 Oracles oracle NNS 13433 1400 28 " " '' 13433 1400 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1400 30 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1400 31 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1400 32 : : : 13433 1400 33 logia logia NN 13433 1400 34 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1400 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1400 36 could could MD 13433 1400 37 not not RB 13433 1400 38 be be VB 13433 1400 39 the the DT 13433 1400 40 first first JJ 13433 1400 41 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1400 42 as as IN 13433 1400 43 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1400 44 now now RB 13433 1400 45 possess possess VBP 13433 1400 46 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1400 47 , , , 13433 1400 48 but but CC 13433 1400 49 must must MD 13433 1400 50 have have VB 13433 1400 51 consisted consist VBN 13433 1400 52 mainly mainly RB 13433 1400 53 or or CC 13433 1400 54 entirely entirely RB 13433 1400 55 of of IN 13433 1400 56 Discourses discourse NNS 13433 1400 57 . . . 13433 1401 1 The the DT 13433 1401 2 argument argument NN 13433 1401 3 will will MD 13433 1401 4 be be VB 13433 1401 5 found find VBN 13433 1401 6 in in IN 13433 1401 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1401 8 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1401 9 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1401 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1401 11 , , , 13433 1401 12 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1401 13 124:1 124:1 CD 13433 1401 14 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1401 15 and and CC 13433 1401 16 need nee MD 13433 1401 17 not not RB 13433 1401 18 here here RB 13433 1401 19 be be VB 13433 1401 20 repeated repeat VBN 13433 1401 21 . . . 13433 1402 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1402 2 will will MD 13433 1402 3 confine confine VB 13433 1402 4 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1402 5 to to IN 13433 1402 6 some some DT 13433 1402 7 points point NNS 13433 1402 8 of of IN 13433 1402 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1402 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1402 11 's 's POS 13433 1402 12 reply reply NN 13433 1402 13 . . . 13433 1403 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1403 2 seems seem VBZ 13433 1403 3 not not RB 13433 1403 4 to to TO 13433 1403 5 reject reject VB 13433 1403 6 the the DT 13433 1403 7 suggestion suggestion NN 13433 1403 8 with with IN 13433 1403 9 so so RB 13433 1403 10 much much JJ 13433 1403 11 vigour vigour NN 13433 1403 12 as as IN 13433 1403 13 might may MD 13433 1403 14 have have VB 13433 1403 15 been be VBN 13433 1403 16 expected expect VBN 13433 1403 17 . . . 13433 1404 1 " " `` 13433 1404 2 The the DT 13433 1404 3 theory theory NN 13433 1404 4 is be VBZ 13433 1404 5 not not RB 13433 1404 6 without without IN 13433 1404 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1404 8 attractions attraction NNS 13433 1404 9 , , , 13433 1404 10 " " '' 13433 1404 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1404 12 says say VBZ 13433 1404 13 ; ; : 13433 1404 14 " " `` 13433 1404 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1404 16 promises promise VBZ 13433 1404 17 a a DT 13433 1404 18 solution solution NN 13433 1404 19 of of IN 13433 1404 20 some some DT 13433 1404 21 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 1404 22 ; ; : 13433 1404 23 but but CC 13433 1404 24 hitherto hitherto VBD 13433 1404 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1404 26 has have VBZ 13433 1404 27 not not RB 13433 1404 28 yielded yield VBN 13433 1404 29 any any DT 13433 1404 30 results result NNS 13433 1404 31 which which WDT 13433 1404 32 would would MD 13433 1404 33 justify justify VB 13433 1404 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1404 35 acceptance acceptance NN 13433 1404 36 . . . 13433 1404 37 " " '' 13433 1405 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1405 2 124:2 124:2 LS 13433 1405 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1405 4 Indeed indeed RB 13433 1405 5 , , , 13433 1405 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1405 7 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 1405 8 to to TO 13433 1405 9 say say VB 13433 1405 10 that that IN 13433 1405 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1405 12 " " `` 13433 1405 13 is be VBZ 13433 1405 14 encumbered encumber VBN 13433 1405 15 with with IN 13433 1405 16 the the DT 13433 1405 17 most most RBS 13433 1405 18 serious serious JJ 13433 1405 19 difficulties difficulty NNS 13433 1405 20 . . . 13433 1405 21 " " '' 13433 1406 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1406 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1406 3 does do VBZ 13433 1406 4 not not RB 13433 1406 5 think think VB 13433 1406 6 that that IN 13433 1406 7 only only RB 13433 1406 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1406 9 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1406 10 : : : 13433 1406 11 logoi logoi NN 13433 1406 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1406 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1406 14 " " `` 13433 1406 15 discourses discourse NNS 13433 1406 16 " " '' 13433 1406 17 or or CC 13433 1406 18 " " `` 13433 1406 19 sayings saying NNS 13433 1406 20 " " '' 13433 1406 21 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1406 22 could could MD 13433 1406 23 be be VB 13433 1406 24 called call VBN 13433 1406 25 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1406 26 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1406 27 : : : 13433 1406 28 logia logia NN 13433 1406 29 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1406 30 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1406 31 " " `` 13433 1406 32 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1406 33 " " '' 13433 1406 34 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1406 35 , , , 13433 1406 36 and and CC 13433 1406 37 says say VBZ 13433 1406 38 that that IN 13433 1406 39 usage usage NN 13433 1406 40 does do VBZ 13433 1406 41 not not RB 13433 1406 42 warrant warrant VB 13433 1406 43 the the DT 13433 1406 44 restriction restriction NN 13433 1406 45 . . . 13433 1407 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1407 2 124:3 124:3 LS 13433 1407 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1407 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1407 5 had have VBD 13433 1407 6 contended contend VBN 13433 1407 7 that that IN 13433 1407 8 " " `` 13433 1407 9 however however RB 13433 1407 10 much much RB 13433 1407 11 the the DT 13433 1407 12 signification signification NN 13433 1407 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1407 14 of of IN 13433 1407 15 the the DT 13433 1407 16 expression expression NN 13433 1407 17 ' ' `` 13433 1407 18 the the DT 13433 1407 19 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1407 20 , , , 13433 1407 21 ' ' '' 13433 1407 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1407 23 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1407 24 : : : 13433 1407 25 ta ta NNP 13433 1407 26 logia logia NN 13433 1407 27 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1407 28 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1407 29 became become VBD 13433 1407 30 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1407 31 extended extended JJ 13433 1407 32 , , , 13433 1407 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1407 34 was be VBD 13433 1407 35 not not RB 13433 1407 36 then then RB 13433 1407 37 at at RB 13433 1407 38 all all RB 13433 1407 39 applied apply VBD 13433 1407 40 to to IN 13433 1407 41 doings doing NNS 13433 1407 42 as as RB 13433 1407 43 well well RB 13433 1407 44 as as IN 13433 1407 45 sayings saying NNS 13433 1407 46 , , , 13433 1407 47 " " '' 13433 1407 48 and and CC 13433 1407 49 that that IN 13433 1407 50 " " `` 13433 1407 51 there there EX 13433 1407 52 is be VBZ 13433 1407 53 no no DT 13433 1407 54 linguistic linguistic JJ 13433 1407 55 precedent precedent NN 13433 1407 56 for for IN 13433 1407 57 straining strain VBG 13433 1407 58 the the DT 13433 1407 59 expression expression NN 13433 1407 60 , , , 13433 1407 61 used use VBN 13433 1407 62 at at IN 13433 1407 63 that that DT 13433 1407 64 period period NN 13433 1407 65 , , , 13433 1407 66 to to TO 13433 1407 67 mean mean VB 13433 1407 68 anything anything NN 13433 1407 69 beyond beyond IN 13433 1407 70 a a DT 13433 1407 71 collection collection NN 13433 1407 72 of of IN 13433 1407 73 sayings saying NNS 13433 1407 74 of of IN 13433 1407 75 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1407 76 , , , 13433 1407 77 which which WDT 13433 1407 78 were be VBD 13433 1407 79 oracular oracular JJ 13433 1407 80 or or CC 13433 1407 81 Divine divine JJ 13433 1407 82 . . . 13433 1407 83 " " '' 13433 1408 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1408 2 124:4 124:4 CD 13433 1408 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1408 4 To to IN 13433 1408 5 this this DT 13433 1408 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1408 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1408 8 replies reply VBZ 13433 1408 9 that that IN 13433 1408 10 if if IN 13433 1408 11 the the DT 13433 1408 12 objection objection NN 13433 1408 13 has have VBZ 13433 1408 14 any any DT 13433 1408 15 force force NN 13433 1408 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1408 17 involves involve VBZ 13433 1408 18 one one CD 13433 1408 19 or or CC 13433 1408 20 both both DT 13433 1408 21 of of IN 13433 1408 22 the the DT 13433 1408 23 two two CD 13433 1408 24 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 1408 25 : : : 13433 1408 26 " " `` 13433 1408 27 _ _ NNP 13433 1408 28 first first JJ 13433 1408 29 _ _ NNP 13433 1408 30 , , , 13433 1408 31 that that IN 13433 1408 32 books book NNS 13433 1408 33 which which WDT 13433 1408 34 were be VBD 13433 1408 35 regarded regard VBN 13433 1408 36 as as IN 13433 1408 37 Scripture scripture NN 13433 1408 38 could could MD 13433 1408 39 not not RB 13433 1408 40 at at IN 13433 1408 41 this this DT 13433 1408 42 early early JJ 13433 1408 43 date date NN 13433 1408 44 be be VB 13433 1408 45 called call VBN 13433 1408 46 ' ' `` 13433 1408 47 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1408 48 , , , 13433 1408 49 ' ' '' 13433 1408 50 unless unless IN 13433 1408 51 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1408 52 were be VBD 13433 1408 53 occupied occupy VBN 13433 1408 54 entirely entirely RB 13433 1408 55 with with IN 13433 1408 56 Divine divine JJ 13433 1408 57 sayings saying NNS 13433 1408 58 ; ; : 13433 1408 59 _ _ NNP 13433 1408 60 secondly secondly RB 13433 1408 61 _ _ NNP 13433 1408 62 , , , 13433 1408 63 that that IN 13433 1408 64 the the DT 13433 1408 65 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1408 66 of of IN 13433 1408 67 St. St. NNP 13433 1408 68 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1408 69 , , , 13433 1408 70 in in IN 13433 1408 71 particular particular JJ 13433 1408 72 , , , 13433 1408 73 could could MD 13433 1408 74 not not RB 13433 1408 75 at at IN 13433 1408 76 this this DT 13433 1408 77 time time NN 13433 1408 78 be be VB 13433 1408 79 regarded regard VBN 13433 1408 80 as as IN 13433 1408 81 Scripture scripture NN 13433 1408 82 . . . 13433 1409 1 Both both DT 13433 1409 2 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 1409 3 alike alike RB 13433 1409 4 are be VBP 13433 1409 5 contradicted contradict VBN 13433 1409 6 by by IN 13433 1409 7 facts fact NNS 13433 1409 8 . . . 13433 1409 9 " " '' 13433 1410 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1410 2 125:1 125:1 LS 13433 1410 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1410 4 The the DT 13433 1410 5 second second JJ 13433 1410 6 point point NN 13433 1410 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1410 8 considers consider VBZ 13433 1410 9 proved prove VBN 13433 1410 10 by by IN 13433 1410 11 the the DT 13433 1410 12 well well RB 13433 1410 13 - - HYPH 13433 1410 14 known know VBN 13433 1410 15 passage passage NN 13433 1410 16 in in IN 13433 1410 17 the the DT 13433 1410 18 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1410 19 of of IN 13433 1410 20 Barnabas Barnabas NNP 13433 1410 21 . . . 13433 1411 1 For for IN 13433 1411 2 the the DT 13433 1411 3 discussion discussion NN 13433 1411 4 regarding regard VBG 13433 1411 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1411 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1411 7 beg beg VBP 13433 1411 8 leave leave VBP 13433 1411 9 to to TO 13433 1411 10 refer refer VB 13433 1411 11 the the DT 13433 1411 12 reader reader NN 13433 1411 13 to to IN 13433 1411 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1411 15 volumes volume NNS 13433 1411 16 . . . 13433 1412 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1412 2 125:2 125:2 LS 13433 1412 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1412 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1412 5 venture venture VBP 13433 1412 6 to to TO 13433 1412 7 say say VB 13433 1412 8 that that IN 13433 1412 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1412 10 is be VBZ 13433 1412 11 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1412 12 to to TO 13433 1412 13 prove prove VB 13433 1412 14 that that IN 13433 1412 15 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1412 16 's 's POS 13433 1412 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1412 18 was be VBD 13433 1412 19 , , , 13433 1412 20 at at IN 13433 1412 21 that that DT 13433 1412 22 time time NN 13433 1412 23 , , , 13433 1412 24 considered consider VBN 13433 1412 25 " " `` 13433 1412 26 Scripture scripture NN 13433 1412 27 , , , 13433 1412 28 " " '' 13433 1412 29 but but CC 13433 1412 30 , , , 13433 1412 31 on on IN 13433 1412 32 the the DT 13433 1412 33 contrary contrary NN 13433 1412 34 , , , 13433 1412 35 that that IN 13433 1412 36 there there EX 13433 1412 37 are be VBP 13433 1412 38 excellent excellent JJ 13433 1412 39 reasons reason NNS 13433 1412 40 for for IN 13433 1412 41 affirming affirm VBG 13433 1412 42 that that IN 13433 1412 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1412 44 was be VBD 13433 1412 45 not not RB 13433 1412 46 . . . 13433 1413 1 Regarding regard VBG 13433 1413 2 the the DT 13433 1413 3 first first JJ 13433 1413 4 point point NN 13433 1413 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1413 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1413 7 asserts assert VBZ 13433 1413 8 : : : 13433 1413 9 " " `` 13433 1413 10 The the DT 13433 1413 11 first first JJ 13433 1413 12 is be VBZ 13433 1413 13 refuted refute VBN 13433 1413 14 by by IN 13433 1413 15 a a DT 13433 1413 16 large large JJ 13433 1413 17 number number NN 13433 1413 18 of of IN 13433 1413 19 examples example NNS 13433 1413 20 . . . 13433 1414 1 St. St. NNP 13433 1414 2 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1414 3 , , , 13433 1414 4 for for IN 13433 1414 5 instance instance NN 13433 1414 6 , , , 13433 1414 7 describes describe VBZ 13433 1414 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1414 9 as as IN 13433 1414 10 the the DT 13433 1414 11 special special JJ 13433 1414 12 privilege privilege NN 13433 1414 13 of of IN 13433 1414 14 the the DT 13433 1414 15 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 1414 16 that that IN 13433 1414 17 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1414 18 had have VBD 13433 1414 19 the the DT 13433 1414 20 keeping keeping NN 13433 1414 21 of of IN 13433 1414 22 ' ' '' 13433 1414 23 the the DT 13433 1414 24 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1414 25 of of IN 13433 1414 26 God God NNP 13433 1414 27 ' ' POS 13433 1414 28 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1414 29 Rom rom NN 13433 1414 30 . . . 13433 1415 1 iii iii NNP 13433 1415 2 . . . 13433 1416 1 2 2 LS 13433 1416 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1416 3 . . . 13433 1417 1 Can Can MD 13433 1417 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1417 3 suppose suppose VB 13433 1417 4 that that IN 13433 1417 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1417 6 meant mean VBD 13433 1417 7 anything anything NN 13433 1417 8 else else RB 13433 1417 9 but but CC 13433 1417 10 the the DT 13433 1417 11 Old Old NNP 13433 1417 12 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1417 13 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 13433 1417 14 by by IN 13433 1417 15 this this DT 13433 1417 16 expression expression NN 13433 1417 17 ? ? . 13433 1418 1 Is be VBZ 13433 1418 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1418 3 possible possible JJ 13433 1418 4 that that IN 13433 1418 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1418 6 would would MD 13433 1418 7 exclude exclude VB 13433 1418 8 the the DT 13433 1418 9 books book NNS 13433 1418 10 of of IN 13433 1418 11 Genesis Genesis NNP 13433 1418 12 , , , 13433 1418 13 of of IN 13433 1418 14 Joshua Joshua NNP 13433 1418 15 , , , 13433 1418 16 of of IN 13433 1418 17 Samuel Samuel NNP 13433 1418 18 and and CC 13433 1418 19 Kings Kings NNP 13433 1418 20 , , , 13433 1418 21 or or CC 13433 1418 22 only only RB 13433 1418 23 include include VBP 13433 1418 24 such such JJ 13433 1418 25 fragments fragment NNS 13433 1418 26 of of IN 13433 1418 27 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1418 28 as as IN 13433 1418 29 professed profess VBN 13433 1418 30 to to TO 13433 1418 31 give give VB 13433 1418 32 the the DT 13433 1418 33 direct direct JJ 13433 1418 34 sayings saying NNS 13433 1418 35 of of IN 13433 1418 36 God God NNP 13433 1418 37 ? ? . 13433 1419 1 Would Would MD 13433 1419 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1419 3 , , , 13433 1419 4 or or CC 13433 1419 5 would would MD 13433 1419 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1419 7 not not RB 13433 1419 8 , , , 13433 1419 9 comprise comprise VB 13433 1419 10 under under IN 13433 1419 11 the the DT 13433 1419 12 term term NN 13433 1419 13 the the DT 13433 1419 14 account account NN 13433 1419 15 of of IN 13433 1419 16 the the DT 13433 1419 17 creation creation NN 13433 1419 18 and and CC 13433 1419 19 fall fall NN 13433 1419 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1419 21 1 1 CD 13433 1419 22 Cor Cor NNP 13433 1419 23 . . . 13433 1420 1 xi xi NNP 13433 1420 2 . . . 13433 1421 1 8 8 CD 13433 1421 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1421 3 sq sq NNP 13433 1421 4 . . NNP 13433 1421 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1421 6 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1421 7 , , , 13433 1421 8 of of IN 13433 1421 9 the the DT 13433 1421 10 wanderings wandering NNS 13433 1421 11 in in IN 13433 1421 12 the the DT 13433 1421 13 wilderness wilderness NN 13433 1421 14 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1421 15 1 1 CD 13433 1421 16 Cor Cor NNP 13433 1421 17 . . . 13433 1422 1 x. x. NNP 13433 1423 1 1 1 CD 13433 1423 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1423 3 sq sq NNP 13433 1423 4 . . NNP 13433 1423 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1423 6 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1423 7 , , , 13433 1423 8 of of IN 13433 1423 9 Sarah Sarah NNP 13433 1423 10 and and CC 13433 1423 11 Hagar Hagar NNP 13433 1423 12 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1423 13 Gal Gal NNP 13433 1423 14 . . . 13433 1424 1 iv iv XX 13433 1424 2 . . . 13433 1425 1 21 21 CD 13433 1425 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1425 3 sq sq NNP 13433 1425 4 . . NNP 13433 1425 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1425 6 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1425 7 ? ? . 13433 1426 1 Does do VBZ 13433 1426 2 not not RB 13433 1426 3 the the DT 13433 1426 4 main main JJ 13433 1426 5 part part NN 13433 1426 6 of of IN 13433 1426 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1426 8 argument argument NN 13433 1426 9 in in IN 13433 1426 10 the the DT 13433 1426 11 very very RB 13433 1426 12 next next JJ 13433 1426 13 chapter chapter NN 13433 1426 14 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1426 15 Rom Rom NNP 13433 1426 16 . . . 13433 1427 1 iv iv LS 13433 1427 2 . . . 13433 1427 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1428 1 depend depend VB 13433 1428 2 more more JJR 13433 1428 3 on on IN 13433 1428 4 the the DT 13433 1428 5 narrative narrative NN 13433 1428 6 of of IN 13433 1428 7 God God NNP 13433 1428 8 's 's POS 13433 1428 9 dealings dealing NNS 13433 1428 10 than than IN 13433 1428 11 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1428 12 words word NNS 13433 1428 13 ? ? . 13433 1429 1 Again again RB 13433 1429 2 , , , 13433 1429 3 when when WRB 13433 1429 4 the the DT 13433 1429 5 author author NN 13433 1429 6 of of IN 13433 1429 7 the the DT 13433 1429 8 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1429 9 to to IN 13433 1429 10 the the DT 13433 1429 11 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1429 12 refers refer VBZ 13433 1429 13 to to IN 13433 1429 14 ' ' '' 13433 1429 15 the the DT 13433 1429 16 first first JJ 13433 1429 17 principles principle NNS 13433 1429 18 of of IN 13433 1429 19 the the DT 13433 1429 20 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1429 21 of of IN 13433 1429 22 God God NNP 13433 1429 23 ' ' '' 13433 1429 24 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1429 25 v. v. CC 13433 1429 26 12 12 CD 13433 1429 27 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1429 28 , , , 13433 1429 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1429 30 meaning meaning NN 13433 1429 31 is be VBZ 13433 1429 32 explained explain VBN 13433 1429 33 by by IN 13433 1429 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1429 35 practice practice NN 13433 1429 36 ; ; : 13433 1429 37 for for IN 13433 1429 38 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1429 39 elicits elicit VBZ 13433 1429 40 the the DT 13433 1429 41 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1429 42 teaching teaching NN 13433 1429 43 quite quite RB 13433 1429 44 as as RB 13433 1429 45 much much RB 13433 1429 46 from from IN 13433 1429 47 the the DT 13433 1429 48 history history NN 13433 1429 49 as as IN 13433 1429 50 from from IN 13433 1429 51 the the DT 13433 1429 52 direct direct JJ 13433 1429 53 precepts precept NNS 13433 1429 54 of of IN 13433 1429 55 the the DT 13433 1429 56 Old Old NNP 13433 1429 57 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1429 58 . . . 13433 1430 1 But but CC 13433 1430 2 if if IN 13433 1430 3 the the DT 13433 1430 4 language language NN 13433 1430 5 of of IN 13433 1430 6 the the DT 13433 1430 7 New New NNP 13433 1430 8 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1430 9 writers writer NNS 13433 1430 10 leaves leave VBZ 13433 1430 11 any any DT 13433 1430 12 loophole loophole NN 13433 1430 13 for for IN 13433 1430 14 doubt doubt NN 13433 1430 15 , , , 13433 1430 16 this this DT 13433 1430 17 is be VBZ 13433 1430 18 not not RB 13433 1430 19 the the DT 13433 1430 20 case case NN 13433 1430 21 with with IN 13433 1430 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1430 23 contemporary contemporary JJ 13433 1430 24 Philo Philo NNPS 13433 1430 25 . . . 13433 1431 1 In in IN 13433 1431 2 one one CD 13433 1431 3 place place NN 13433 1431 4 , , , 13433 1431 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1431 6 speaks speak VBZ 13433 1431 7 of of IN 13433 1431 8 the the DT 13433 1431 9 words word NNS 13433 1431 10 in in IN 13433 1431 11 Deut Deut NNP 13433 1431 12 . . . 13433 1432 1 x. x. NNP 13433 1433 1 9 9 CD 13433 1433 2 , , , 13433 1433 3 ' ' '' 13433 1433 4 The the DT 13433 1433 5 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1433 6 is be VBZ 13433 1433 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1433 8 inheritance inheritance NN 13433 1433 9 , , , 13433 1433 10 ' ' '' 13433 1433 11 as as IN 13433 1433 12 an an DT 13433 1433 13 ' ' `` 13433 1433 14 oracle oracle NN 13433 1433 15 ' ' '' 13433 1433 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1433 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1433 18 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1433 19 : : : 13433 1433 20 logion logion NN 13433 1433 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1433 22 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1433 23 ; ; : 13433 1433 24 in in IN 13433 1433 25 another another DT 13433 1433 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1433 27 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1433 28 as as IN 13433 1433 29 an an DT 13433 1433 30 ' ' `` 13433 1433 31 oracle oracle NN 13433 1433 32 ' ' '' 13433 1433 33 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1433 34 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1433 35 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1433 36 : : : 13433 1433 37 logion logion NN 13433 1433 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1433 39 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1433 40 the the DT 13433 1433 41 _ _ NNP 13433 1433 42 narrative narrative NN 13433 1433 43 _ _ NNP 13433 1433 44 in in IN 13433 1433 45 Gen. Gen. NNP 13433 1433 46 iv iv NNP 13433 1433 47 . . . 13433 1434 1 15 15 CD 13433 1434 2 : : : 13433 1434 3 ' ' `` 13433 1434 4 The the DT 13433 1434 5 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1434 6 God God NNP 13433 1434 7 set set VBD 13433 1434 8 a a DT 13433 1434 9 mark mark NN 13433 1434 10 upon upon IN 13433 1434 11 Cain Cain NNP 13433 1434 12 , , , 13433 1434 13 lest l JJS 13433 1434 14 anyone anyone NN 13433 1434 15 finding find VBG 13433 1434 16 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1434 17 should should MD 13433 1434 18 kill kill VB 13433 1434 19 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1434 20 . . . 13433 1434 21 ' ' '' 13433 1435 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1435 2 125:3 125:3 LS 13433 1435 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1435 4 From from IN 13433 1435 5 this this DT 13433 1435 6 and and CC 13433 1435 7 other other JJ 13433 1435 8 passages passage NNS 13433 1435 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1435 10 is be VBZ 13433 1435 11 clear clear JJ 13433 1435 12 that that IN 13433 1435 13 with with IN 13433 1435 14 Philo Philo NNP 13433 1435 15 an an DT 13433 1435 16 ' ' `` 13433 1435 17 oracle oracle NN 13433 1435 18 ' ' '' 13433 1435 19 is be VBZ 13433 1435 20 a a DT 13433 1435 21 synonyme synonyme NNS 13433 1435 22 for for IN 13433 1435 23 a a DT 13433 1435 24 Scripture scripture NN 13433 1435 25 . . . 13433 1436 1 Similarly similarly RB 13433 1436 2 Clement Clement NNP 13433 1436 3 of of IN 13433 1436 4 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1436 5 writes write VBZ 13433 1436 6 : : : 13433 1436 7 ' ' '' 13433 1436 8 Ye Ye NNP 13433 1436 9 know know VBP 13433 1436 10 well well UH 13433 1436 11 the the DT 13433 1436 12 sacred sacred JJ 13433 1436 13 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1436 14 , , , 13433 1436 15 and and CC 13433 1436 16 have have VBP 13433 1436 17 studied study VBN 13433 1436 18 the the DT 13433 1436 19 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1436 20 of of IN 13433 1436 21 God God NNP 13433 1436 22 ; ; : 13433 1436 23 ' ' '' 13433 1436 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1436 25 125:4 125:4 CD 13433 1436 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1436 27 and and CC 13433 1436 28 immediately immediately RB 13433 1436 29 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1436 30 recalls recall VBZ 13433 1436 31 to to IN 13433 1436 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1436 33 mind mind NN 13433 1436 34 the the DT 13433 1436 35 account account NN 13433 1436 36 in in IN 13433 1436 37 Deut Deut NNP 13433 1436 38 . . . 13433 1437 1 ix ix IN 13433 1437 2 . . . 13433 1438 1 12 12 CD 13433 1438 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1438 3 sq sq NNP 13433 1438 4 . . NNP 13433 1438 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1438 6 , , , 13433 1438 7 Exod Exod NNP 13433 1438 8 . . . 13433 1439 1 xxxii xxxii NNP 13433 1439 2 . . . 13433 1440 1 7 7 CD 13433 1440 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1440 3 sq sq NNP 13433 1440 4 . . NNP 13433 1440 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1440 6 , , , 13433 1440 7 of of IN 13433 1440 8 which which WDT 13433 1440 9 the the DT 13433 1440 10 point point NN 13433 1440 11 is be VBZ 13433 1440 12 not not RB 13433 1440 13 any any DT 13433 1440 14 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1440 15 precept precept NN 13433 1440 16 or or CC 13433 1440 17 prediction prediction NN 13433 1440 18 , , , 13433 1440 19 but but CC 13433 1440 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1440 21 the the DT 13433 1440 22 example example NN 13433 1440 23 of of IN 13433 1440 24 Moses Moses NNP 13433 1440 25 _ _ NNP 13433 1440 26 . . . 13433 1441 1 A a DT 13433 1441 2 few few JJ 13433 1441 3 years year NNS 13433 1441 4 later later RBR 13433 1441 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1441 6 speaks speak VBZ 13433 1441 7 in in IN 13433 1441 8 condemnation condemnation NN 13433 1441 9 of of IN 13433 1441 10 those those DT 13433 1441 11 who who WP 13433 1441 12 ' ' '' 13433 1441 13 pervert pervert VBP 13433 1441 14 the the DT 13433 1441 15 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1441 16 of of IN 13433 1441 17 the the DT 13433 1441 18 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1441 19 . . . 13433 1441 20 " " '' 13433 1442 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1442 2 126:1 126:1 LS 13433 1442 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1442 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1442 5 then then RB 13433 1442 6 goes go VBZ 13433 1442 7 on on RP 13433 1442 8 to to TO 13433 1442 9 refer refer VB 13433 1442 10 to to IN 13433 1442 11 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 1442 12 , , , 13433 1442 13 Clement Clement NNP 13433 1442 14 of of IN 13433 1442 15 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 1442 16 , , , 13433 1442 17 Origen Origen NNP 13433 1442 18 , , , 13433 1442 19 and and CC 13433 1442 20 Basil Basil NNP 13433 1442 21 , , , 13433 1442 22 but but CC 13433 1442 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1442 24 need need VBP 13433 1442 25 not not RB 13433 1442 26 follow follow VB 13433 1442 27 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1442 28 to to IN 13433 1442 29 these these DT 13433 1442 30 later later JJ 13433 1442 31 writers writer NNS 13433 1442 32 , , , 13433 1442 33 but but CC 13433 1442 34 confine confine VB 13433 1442 35 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1442 36 to to IN 13433 1442 37 that that DT 13433 1442 38 which which WDT 13433 1442 39 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1442 40 have have VBP 13433 1442 41 quoted quote VBN 13433 1442 42 . . . 13433 1443 1 " " `` 13433 1443 2 When when WRB 13433 1443 3 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1443 4 writes write VBZ 13433 1443 5 in in IN 13433 1443 6 the the DT 13433 1443 7 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1443 8 to to IN 13433 1443 9 the the DT 13433 1443 10 Romans Romans NNPS 13433 1443 11 iii iii NNP 13433 1443 12 . . . 13433 1444 1 2 2 LS 13433 1444 2 , , , 13433 1444 3 ' ' '' 13433 1444 4 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1444 5 were be VBD 13433 1444 6 entrusted entrust VBN 13433 1444 7 with with IN 13433 1444 8 the the DT 13433 1444 9 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1444 10 of of IN 13433 1444 11 God God NNP 13433 1444 12 , , , 13433 1444 13 ' ' '' 13433 1444 14 can can MD 13433 1444 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1444 16 mean mean VB 13433 1444 17 anything anything NN 13433 1444 18 else else RB 13433 1444 19 but but CC 13433 1444 20 the the DT 13433 1444 21 Old Old NNP 13433 1444 22 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1444 23 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1444 24 , , , 13433 1444 25 including include VBG 13433 1444 26 the the DT 13433 1444 27 historical historical JJ 13433 1444 28 books book NNS 13433 1444 29 ? ? . 13433 1444 30 " " '' 13433 1445 1 argues argue VBZ 13433 1445 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1445 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1445 4 . . . 13433 1446 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1446 2 maintain maintain VBP 13433 1446 3 , , , 13433 1446 4 on on IN 13433 1446 5 the the DT 13433 1446 6 contrary contrary NN 13433 1446 7 , , , 13433 1446 8 that that IN 13433 1446 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1446 10 certainly certainly RB 13433 1446 11 does do VBZ 13433 1446 12 not not RB 13433 1446 13 refer refer VB 13433 1446 14 to to IN 13433 1446 15 a a DT 13433 1446 16 collection collection NN 13433 1446 17 of of IN 13433 1446 18 writings writing NNS 13433 1446 19 at at RB 13433 1446 20 all all RB 13433 1446 21 , , , 13433 1446 22 but but CC 13433 1446 23 to to IN 13433 1446 24 the the DT 13433 1446 25 communications communication NNS 13433 1446 26 or or CC 13433 1446 27 revelations revelation NNS 13433 1446 28 of of IN 13433 1446 29 God God NNP 13433 1446 30 , , , 13433 1446 31 and and CC 13433 1446 32 , , , 13433 1446 33 as as IN 13433 1446 34 the the DT 13433 1446 35 context context NN 13433 1446 36 shows show VBZ 13433 1446 37 , , , 13433 1446 38 probably probably RB 13433 1446 39 more more RBR 13433 1446 40 immediately immediately RB 13433 1446 41 to to IN 13433 1446 42 the the DT 13433 1446 43 Messianic Messianic NNP 13433 1446 44 prophecies prophecy NNS 13433 1446 45 . . . 13433 1447 1 The the DT 13433 1447 2 advantage advantage NN 13433 1447 3 of of IN 13433 1447 4 the the DT 13433 1447 5 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 1447 6 , , , 13433 1447 7 in in IN 13433 1447 8 fact fact NN 13433 1447 9 , , , 13433 1447 10 according accord VBG 13433 1447 11 to to IN 13433 1447 12 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1447 13 here here RB 13433 1447 14 , , , 13433 1447 15 was be VBD 13433 1447 16 that that DT 13433 1447 17 to to IN 13433 1447 18 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1447 19 were be VBD 13433 1447 20 first first RB 13433 1447 21 communicated communicate VBN 13433 1447 22 the the DT 13433 1447 23 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1447 24 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1447 25 : : : 13433 1447 26 that that IN 13433 1447 27 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1447 28 were be VBD 13433 1447 29 made make VBN 13433 1447 30 the the DT 13433 1447 31 medium medium NN 13433 1447 32 of of IN 13433 1447 33 God God NNP 13433 1447 34 's 's POS 13433 1447 35 utterances utterance NNS 13433 1447 36 to to IN 13433 1447 37 mankind mankind NN 13433 1447 38 . . . 13433 1448 1 There there EX 13433 1448 2 seems seem VBZ 13433 1448 3 almost almost RB 13433 1448 4 an an DT 13433 1448 5 echo echo NN 13433 1448 6 of of IN 13433 1448 7 the the DT 13433 1448 8 expression expression NN 13433 1448 9 in in IN 13433 1448 10 Acts Acts NNP 13433 1448 11 vii vii NN 13433 1448 12 . . . 13433 1449 1 38 38 CD 13433 1449 2 , , , 13433 1449 3 where where WRB 13433 1449 4 Stephen Stephen NNP 13433 1449 5 is be VBZ 13433 1449 6 represented represent VBN 13433 1449 7 as as IN 13433 1449 8 saying say VBG 13433 1449 9 to to IN 13433 1449 10 the the DT 13433 1449 11 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 1449 12 of of IN 13433 1449 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1449 14 fathers father NNS 13433 1449 15 on on IN 13433 1449 16 Mount Mount NNP 13433 1449 17 Sinai Sinai NNP 13433 1449 18 , , , 13433 1449 19 " " `` 13433 1449 20 who who WP 13433 1449 21 received receive VBD 13433 1449 22 living live VBG 13433 1449 23 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1449 24 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1449 25 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1449 26 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1449 27 : : : 13433 1449 28 logia logia NNP 13433 1449 29 zônta zônta NNP 13433 1449 30 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1449 31 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1449 32 to to TO 13433 1449 33 give give VB 13433 1449 34 unto unto IN 13433 1449 35 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1449 36 . . . 13433 1449 37 " " '' 13433 1450 1 Of of IN 13433 1450 2 this this DT 13433 1450 3 nature nature NN 13433 1450 4 were be VBD 13433 1450 5 the the DT 13433 1450 6 " " `` 13433 1450 7 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1450 8 of of IN 13433 1450 9 God God NNP 13433 1450 10 " " '' 13433 1450 11 which which WDT 13433 1450 12 were be VBD 13433 1450 13 entrusted entrust VBN 13433 1450 14 to to IN 13433 1450 15 the the DT 13433 1450 16 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 1450 17 . . . 13433 1451 1 Further further RB 13433 1451 2 , , , 13433 1451 3 the the DT 13433 1451 4 phrase phrase NN 13433 1451 5 : : : 13433 1451 6 " " `` 13433 1451 7 the the DT 13433 1451 8 first first JJ 13433 1451 9 principles principle NNS 13433 1451 10 of of IN 13433 1451 11 the the DT 13433 1451 12 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1451 13 of of IN 13433 1451 14 God God NNP 13433 1451 15 " " '' 13433 1451 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1451 17 Heb heb NN 13433 1451 18 . . . 13433 1452 1 v. v. CC 13433 1452 2 12 12 CD 13433 1452 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1452 4 , , , 13433 1452 5 is be VBZ 13433 1452 6 no no DT 13433 1452 7 application application NN 13433 1452 8 of of IN 13433 1452 9 the the DT 13433 1452 10 term term NN 13433 1452 11 to to IN 13433 1452 12 narrative narrative NN 13433 1452 13 , , , 13433 1452 14 as as IN 13433 1452 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1452 16 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1452 17 affirms affirm VBZ 13433 1452 18 , , , 13433 1452 19 however however RB 13433 1452 20 much much RB 13433 1452 21 the the DT 13433 1452 22 author author NN 13433 1452 23 may may MD 13433 1452 24 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 1452 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1452 26 own own JJ 13433 1452 27 teaching teaching NN 13433 1452 28 by by IN 13433 1452 29 Old Old NNP 13433 1452 30 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1452 31 history history NN 13433 1452 32 ; ; : 13433 1452 33 but but CC 13433 1452 34 the the DT 13433 1452 35 writer writer NN 13433 1452 36 of of IN 13433 1452 37 the the DT 13433 1452 38 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1452 39 clearly clearly RB 13433 1452 40 explains explain VBZ 13433 1452 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1452 42 meaning meaning NN 13433 1452 43 in in IN 13433 1452 44 the the DT 13433 1452 45 first first JJ 13433 1452 46 and and CC 13433 1452 47 second second JJ 13433 1452 48 verses verse NNS 13433 1452 49 of of IN 13433 1452 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1452 51 letter letter NN 13433 1452 52 , , , 13433 1452 53 when when WRB 13433 1452 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1452 55 says say VBZ 13433 1452 56 : : : 13433 1452 57 " " `` 13433 1452 58 God God NNP 13433 1452 59 having have VBG 13433 1452 60 spoken speak VBN 13433 1452 61 to to IN 13433 1452 62 the the DT 13433 1452 63 fathers father NNS 13433 1452 64 in in IN 13433 1452 65 time time NN 13433 1452 66 past past JJ 13433 1452 67 in in IN 13433 1452 68 the the DT 13433 1452 69 prophets prophet NNS 13433 1452 70 , , , 13433 1452 71 at at IN 13433 1452 72 the the DT 13433 1452 73 end end NN 13433 1452 74 of of IN 13433 1452 75 these these DT 13433 1452 76 days day NNS 13433 1452 77 spake spake VBP 13433 1452 78 unto unto IN 13433 1452 79 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1452 80 in in IN 13433 1452 81 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1452 82 Son Son NNP 13433 1452 83 . . . 13433 1452 84 " " '' 13433 1453 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1453 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1453 3 also also RB 13433 1453 4 urges urge VBZ 13433 1453 5 that that IN 13433 1453 6 Philo Philo NNP 13433 1453 7 applies apply VBZ 13433 1453 8 the the DT 13433 1453 9 term term NN 13433 1453 10 " " `` 13433 1453 11 oracle oracle NN 13433 1453 12 " " '' 13433 1453 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1453 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1453 15 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1453 16 : : : 13433 1453 17 logion logion NN 13433 1453 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1453 19 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1453 20 to to IN 13433 1453 21 the the DT 13433 1453 22 _ _ NNP 13433 1453 23 narrative narrative NN 13433 1453 24 _ _ NNP 13433 1453 25 in in IN 13433 1453 26 Gen. Gen. NNP 13433 1453 27 iv iv NNP 13433 1453 28 . . . 13433 1454 1 15 15 CD 13433 1454 2 , , , 13433 1454 3 & & CC 13433 1454 4 c. c. NN 13433 1454 5 The the DT 13433 1454 6 fact fact NN 13433 1454 7 is be VBZ 13433 1454 8 , , , 13433 1454 9 however however RB 13433 1454 10 , , , 13433 1454 11 that that IN 13433 1454 12 Philo Philo NNP 13433 1454 13 considered consider VBD 13433 1454 14 almost almost RB 13433 1454 15 every every DT 13433 1454 16 part part NN 13433 1454 17 of of IN 13433 1454 18 the the DT 13433 1454 19 Old Old NNP 13433 1454 20 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1454 21 as as IN 13433 1454 22 allegorical allegorical JJ 13433 1454 23 , , , 13433 1454 24 and and CC 13433 1454 25 held hold VBD 13433 1454 26 that that IN 13433 1454 27 narrative narrative NN 13433 1454 28 or or CC 13433 1454 29 descriptive descriptive JJ 13433 1454 30 phrases phrase NNS 13433 1454 31 veiled veil VBD 13433 1454 32 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1454 33 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1454 34 . . . 13433 1455 1 When when WRB 13433 1455 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1455 3 applies apply VBZ 13433 1455 4 the the DT 13433 1455 5 term term NN 13433 1455 6 " " `` 13433 1455 7 oracle oracle NN 13433 1455 8 " " '' 13433 1455 9 to to IN 13433 1455 10 any any DT 13433 1455 11 of of IN 13433 1455 12 these these DT 13433 1455 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1455 14 is be VBZ 13433 1455 15 not not RB 13433 1455 16 to to IN 13433 1455 17 the the DT 13433 1455 18 narrative narrative NN 13433 1455 19 , , , 13433 1455 20 but but CC 13433 1455 21 to to IN 13433 1455 22 the the DT 13433 1455 23 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1455 24 utterance utterance NN 13433 1455 25 which which WDT 13433 1455 26 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1455 27 believes believe VBZ 13433 1455 28 to to TO 13433 1455 29 be be VB 13433 1455 30 mystically mystically RB 13433 1455 31 contained contain VBN 13433 1455 32 in in IN 13433 1455 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1455 34 , , , 13433 1455 35 and and CC 13433 1455 36 which which WDT 13433 1455 37 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1455 38 extracts extract VBZ 13433 1455 39 and and CC 13433 1455 40 expounds expound NNS 13433 1455 41 in in IN 13433 1455 42 the the DT 13433 1455 43 usual usual JJ 13433 1455 44 extravagant extravagant JJ 13433 1455 45 manner manner NN 13433 1455 46 of of IN 13433 1455 47 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 13433 1455 48 typologists typologist NNS 13433 1455 49 . . . 13433 1456 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1456 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1456 3 does do VBZ 13433 1456 4 not not RB 13433 1456 5 refer refer VB 13433 1456 6 to to IN 13433 1456 7 the the DT 13433 1456 8 expression expression NN 13433 1456 9 of of IN 13433 1456 10 1 1 CD 13433 1456 11 Pet Pet NNP 13433 1456 12 . . . 13433 1457 1 iv iv XX 13433 1457 2 . . . 13433 1458 1 11 11 CD 13433 1458 2 , , , 13433 1458 3 " " `` 13433 1458 4 Let let VB 13433 1458 5 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1458 6 speak speak VB 13433 1458 7 as as IN 13433 1458 8 the the DT 13433 1458 9 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1458 10 of of IN 13433 1458 11 God God NNP 13433 1458 12 " " '' 13433 1458 13 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1458 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1458 15 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1458 16 : : : 13433 1458 17 hôs hôs JJ 13433 1458 18 logia logia NN 13433 1458 19 Theou Theou NNP 13433 1458 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1458 21 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1458 22 , , , 13433 1458 23 which which WDT 13433 1458 24 shows show VBZ 13433 1458 25 the the DT 13433 1458 26 use use NN 13433 1458 27 of of IN 13433 1458 28 the the DT 13433 1458 29 word word NN 13433 1458 30 in in IN 13433 1458 31 the the DT 13433 1458 32 New New NNP 13433 1458 33 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1458 34 . . . 13433 1459 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1459 2 does do VBZ 13433 1459 3 point point VB 13433 1459 4 out out RP 13433 1459 5 the the DT 13433 1459 6 passage passage NN 13433 1459 7 in in IN 13433 1459 8 the the DT 13433 1459 9 " " `` 13433 1459 10 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1459 11 of of IN 13433 1459 12 Clement Clement NNP 13433 1459 13 of of IN 13433 1459 14 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1459 15 , , , 13433 1459 16 " " '' 13433 1459 17 than than IN 13433 1459 18 which which WDT 13433 1459 19 , , , 13433 1459 20 in in IN 13433 1459 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1459 22 opinion opinion NN 13433 1459 23 , , , 13433 1459 24 nothing nothing NN 13433 1459 25 could could MD 13433 1459 26 more more RBR 13433 1459 27 directly directly RB 13433 1459 28 tell tell VB 13433 1459 29 against against IN 13433 1459 30 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1459 31 . . . 13433 1460 1 " " `` 13433 1460 2 Ye Ye NNP 13433 1460 3 know know VBP 13433 1460 4 well well UH 13433 1460 5 the the DT 13433 1460 6 sacred sacred JJ 13433 1460 7 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1460 8 and and CC 13433 1460 9 have have VBP 13433 1460 10 studied study VBN 13433 1460 11 the the DT 13433 1460 12 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1460 13 of of IN 13433 1460 14 God God NNP 13433 1460 15 . . . 13433 1460 16 " " '' 13433 1461 1 The the DT 13433 1461 2 " " `` 13433 1461 3 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1461 4 of of IN 13433 1461 5 God God NNP 13433 1461 6 " " `` 13433 1461 7 are be VBP 13433 1461 8 pointedly pointedly RB 13433 1461 9 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 1461 10 from from IN 13433 1461 11 the the DT 13433 1461 12 sacred sacred JJ 13433 1461 13 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1461 14 , , , 13433 1461 15 of of IN 13433 1461 16 which which WDT 13433 1461 17 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1461 18 form form VBP 13433 1461 19 a a DT 13433 1461 20 part part NN 13433 1461 21 . . . 13433 1462 1 These these DT 13433 1462 2 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1462 3 are be VBP 13433 1462 4 contained contain VBN 13433 1462 5 in in IN 13433 1462 6 the the DT 13433 1462 7 " " `` 13433 1462 8 sacred sacred JJ 13433 1462 9 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1462 10 , , , 13433 1462 11 " " '' 13433 1462 12 but but CC 13433 1462 13 are be VBP 13433 1462 14 not not RB 13433 1462 15 synonymous synonymous JJ 13433 1462 16 with with IN 13433 1462 17 the the DT 13433 1462 18 whole whole NN 13433 1462 19 of of IN 13433 1462 20 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1462 21 . . . 13433 1463 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1463 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1463 3 admits admit VBZ 13433 1463 4 that that IN 13433 1463 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1463 6 can can MD 13433 1463 7 not not RB 13433 1463 8 say say VB 13433 1463 9 how how WRB 13433 1463 10 much much JJ 13433 1463 11 " " `` 13433 1463 12 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1463 13 " " '' 13433 1463 14 included include VBN 13433 1463 15 in in IN 13433 1463 16 the the DT 13433 1463 17 expression expression NN 13433 1463 18 : : : 13433 1463 19 " " `` 13433 1463 20 pervert pervert VB 13433 1463 21 the the DT 13433 1463 22 oracles oracle NNS 13433 1463 23 of of IN 13433 1463 24 the the DT 13433 1463 25 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1463 26 , , , 13433 1463 27 " " '' 13433 1463 28 but but CC 13433 1463 29 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1463 30 maintain maintain VBP 13433 1463 31 that that IN 13433 1463 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1463 33 must must MD 13433 1463 34 be be VB 13433 1463 35 referred refer VBN 13433 1463 36 to to IN 13433 1463 37 the the DT 13433 1463 38 teaching teaching NN 13433 1463 39 of of IN 13433 1463 40 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1463 41 regarding regard VBG 13433 1463 42 " " `` 13433 1463 43 a a DT 13433 1463 44 resurrection resurrection NN 13433 1463 45 and and CC 13433 1463 46 a a DT 13433 1463 47 judgment judgment NN 13433 1463 48 , , , 13433 1463 49 " " '' 13433 1463 50 and and CC 13433 1463 51 not not RB 13433 1463 52 to to IN 13433 1463 53 historical historical JJ 13433 1463 54 books book NNS 13433 1463 55 . . . 13433 1464 1 In in IN 13433 1464 2 replying reply VBG 13433 1464 3 to to IN 13433 1464 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1464 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1464 6 's 's POS 13433 1464 7 chapter chapter NN 13433 1464 8 on on IN 13433 1464 9 the the DT 13433 1464 10 Silence Silence NNP 13433 1464 11 of of IN 13433 1464 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1464 13 , , , 13433 1464 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1464 15 have have VBP 13433 1464 16 said say VBD 13433 1464 17 all all PDT 13433 1464 18 that that WDT 13433 1464 19 is be VBZ 13433 1464 20 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1464 21 regarding regard VBG 13433 1464 22 the the DT 13433 1464 23 other other JJ 13433 1464 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1464 25 in in IN 13433 1464 26 connection connection NN 13433 1464 27 with with IN 13433 1464 28 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1464 29 . . . 13433 1465 1 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1465 2 is be VBZ 13433 1465 3 the the DT 13433 1465 4 most most RBS 13433 1465 5 interesting interesting JJ 13433 1465 6 witness witness NN 13433 1465 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1465 8 have have VBP 13433 1465 9 concerning concern VBG 13433 1465 10 the the DT 13433 1465 11 composition composition NN 13433 1465 12 of of IN 13433 1465 13 the the DT 13433 1465 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1465 15 . . . 13433 1466 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1466 2 has have VBZ 13433 1466 3 not not RB 13433 1466 4 told tell VBN 13433 1466 5 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1466 6 much much JJ 13433 1466 7 , , , 13433 1466 8 but but CC 13433 1466 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1466 10 has have VBZ 13433 1466 11 told tell VBN 13433 1466 12 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1466 13 more more JJR 13433 1466 14 than than IN 13433 1466 15 any any DT 13433 1466 16 previous previous JJ 13433 1466 17 writer writer NN 13433 1466 18 . . . 13433 1467 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1467 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1467 3 has have VBZ 13433 1467 4 not not RB 13433 1467 5 scrupled scruple VBN 13433 1467 6 to to TO 13433 1467 7 discredit discredit VB 13433 1467 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1467 9 own own JJ 13433 1467 10 witness witness NN 13433 1467 11 , , , 13433 1467 12 however however RB 13433 1467 13 , , , 13433 1467 14 and and CC 13433 1467 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1467 16 is be VBZ 13433 1467 17 quite quite RB 13433 1467 18 right right JJ 13433 1467 19 in in IN 13433 1467 20 suggesting suggest VBG 13433 1467 21 that that IN 13433 1467 22 no no DT 13433 1467 23 great great JJ 13433 1467 24 reliance reliance NN 13433 1467 25 can can MD 13433 1467 26 be be VB 13433 1467 27 placed place VBN 13433 1467 28 upon upon IN 13433 1467 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1467 30 testimony testimony NN 13433 1467 31 . . . 13433 1468 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1468 2 comes come VBZ 13433 1468 3 to to IN 13433 1468 4 this this DT 13433 1468 5 : : : 13433 1468 6 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1468 7 can can MD 13433 1468 8 not not RB 13433 1468 9 rely rely VB 13433 1468 10 upon upon IN 13433 1468 11 the the DT 13433 1468 12 correctness correctness NN 13433 1468 13 of of IN 13433 1468 14 the the DT 13433 1468 15 meagre meagre JJ 13433 1468 16 account account NN 13433 1468 17 of of IN 13433 1468 18 the the DT 13433 1468 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1468 20 supposed suppose VBD 13433 1468 21 to to TO 13433 1468 22 have have VB 13433 1468 23 been be VBN 13433 1468 24 written write VBN 13433 1468 25 by by IN 13433 1468 26 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1468 27 and and CC 13433 1468 28 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1468 29 , , , 13433 1468 30 and and CC 13433 1468 31 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1468 32 have have VBP 13433 1468 33 no no DT 13433 1468 34 other other JJ 13433 1468 35 upon upon IN 13433 1468 36 which which WDT 13433 1468 37 to to TO 13433 1468 38 fall fall VB 13433 1468 39 back back RB 13433 1468 40 . . . 13433 1469 1 Regarding regard VBG 13433 1469 2 the the DT 13433 1469 3 other other JJ 13433 1469 4 two two CD 13433 1469 5 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1469 6 , , , 13433 1469 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1469 8 have have VBP 13433 1469 9 no no DT 13433 1469 10 information information NN 13433 1469 11 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1469 12 from from IN 13433 1469 13 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1469 14 , , , 13433 1469 15 whether whether IN 13433 1469 16 correct correct JJ 13433 1469 17 or or CC 13433 1469 18 incorrect incorrect JJ 13433 1469 19 , , , 13433 1469 20 and and CC 13433 1469 21 altogether altogether RB 13433 1469 22 this this DT 13433 1469 23 Father Father NNP 13433 1469 24 does do VBZ 13433 1469 25 little little JJ 13433 1469 26 or or CC 13433 1469 27 nothing nothing NN 13433 1469 28 towards towards IN 13433 1469 29 establishing establish VBG 13433 1469 30 the the DT 13433 1469 31 credibility credibility NN 13433 1469 32 of of IN 13433 1469 33 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1469 34 and and CC 13433 1469 35 the the DT 13433 1469 36 reality reality NN 13433 1469 37 of of IN 13433 1469 38 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1469 39 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1469 40 . . . 13433 1470 1 V. V. NNP 13433 1470 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1470 3 MELITO MELITO NNP 13433 1470 4 OF of IN 13433 1470 5 SARDIS SARDIS NNP 13433 1470 6 -- -- : 13433 1470 7 CLAUDIUS claudiu NNS 13433 1470 8 APOLLINARIS apollinari NNS 13433 1470 9 -- -- : 13433 1470 10 POLYCRATES polycrate NNS 13433 1470 11 . . . 13433 1470 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1470 13 Throughout throughout IN 13433 1470 14 the the DT 13433 1470 15 whole whole NN 13433 1470 16 of of IN 13433 1470 17 these these DT 13433 1470 18 essays essay NNS 13433 1470 19 , , , 13433 1470 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1470 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1470 22 has have VBZ 13433 1470 23 shown show VBN 13433 1470 24 the the DT 13433 1470 25 most most RBS 13433 1470 26 complete complete JJ 13433 1470 27 misapprehension misapprehension NN 13433 1470 28 of of IN 13433 1470 29 the the DT 13433 1470 30 purpose purpose NN 13433 1470 31 for for IN 13433 1470 32 which which WDT 13433 1470 33 the the DT 13433 1470 34 examination examination NN 13433 1470 35 of of IN 13433 1470 36 the the DT 13433 1470 37 evidence evidence NN 13433 1470 38 regarding regard VBG 13433 1470 39 the the DT 13433 1470 40 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1470 41 in in IN 13433 1470 42 early early JJ 13433 1470 43 writings writing NNS 13433 1470 44 was be VBD 13433 1470 45 undertaken undertake VBN 13433 1470 46 in in IN 13433 1470 47 _ _ NNP 13433 1470 48 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1470 49 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1470 50 _ _ NNP 13433 1470 51 , , , 13433 1470 52 and and CC 13433 1470 53 consequently consequently RB 13433 1470 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1470 55 naturally naturally RB 13433 1470 56 misunderstands misunderstand VBZ 13433 1470 57 and and CC 13433 1470 58 misrepresents misrepresent VBZ 13433 1470 59 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1470 60 argument argument NN 13433 1470 61 from from IN 13433 1470 62 first first RB 13433 1470 63 to to TO 13433 1470 64 last last VB 13433 1470 65 . . . 13433 1471 1 This this DT 13433 1471 2 becomes become VBZ 13433 1471 3 increasingly increasingly RB 13433 1471 4 evident evident JJ 13433 1471 5 when when WRB 13433 1471 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1471 7 come come VBP 13433 1471 8 to to IN 13433 1471 9 writers writer NNS 13433 1471 10 , , , 13433 1471 11 whom whom WP 13433 1471 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1471 13 fancifully fancifully RB 13433 1471 14 denominates denominate VBZ 13433 1471 15 : : : 13433 1471 16 " " `` 13433 1471 17 the the DT 13433 1471 18 later later JJ 13433 1471 19 school school NN 13433 1471 20 of of IN 13433 1471 21 St. St. NNP 13433 1472 1 John John NNP 13433 1472 2 . . . 13433 1472 3 " " '' 13433 1473 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 2 evidently evidently RB 13433 1473 3 considers consider VBZ 13433 1473 4 that that IN 13433 1473 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 6 is be VBZ 13433 1473 7 producing produce VBG 13433 1473 8 a a DT 13433 1473 9 very very RB 13433 1473 10 destructive destructive JJ 13433 1473 11 effect effect NN 13433 1473 12 , , , 13433 1473 13 when when WRB 13433 1473 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 15 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 1473 16 from from IN 13433 1473 17 the the DT 13433 1473 18 writings writing NNS 13433 1473 19 , , , 13433 1473 20 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1473 21 or or CC 13433 1473 22 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1473 23 , , , 13433 1473 24 of of IN 13433 1473 25 such such JJ 13433 1473 26 men man NNS 13433 1473 27 as as IN 13433 1473 28 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1473 29 of of IN 13433 1473 30 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 1473 31 , , , 13433 1473 32 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 1473 33 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 1473 34 and and CC 13433 1473 35 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 13433 1473 36 of of IN 13433 1473 37 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 1473 38 , , , 13433 1473 39 or or CC 13433 1473 40 from from IN 13433 1473 41 much much RB 13433 1473 42 more more JJR 13433 1473 43 than than IN 13433 1473 44 suspected suspect VBN 13433 1473 45 documents document NNS 13433 1473 46 like like IN 13433 1473 47 the the DT 13433 1473 48 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 1473 49 of of IN 13433 1473 50 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1473 51 , , , 13433 1473 52 that that IN 13433 1473 53 towards towards IN 13433 1473 54 the the DT 13433 1473 55 last last JJ 13433 1473 56 quarter quarter NN 13433 1473 57 of of IN 13433 1473 58 the the DT 13433 1473 59 second second JJ 13433 1473 60 century century NN 13433 1473 61 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 62 were be VBD 13433 1473 63 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1473 64 with with IN 13433 1473 65 the the DT 13433 1473 66 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1473 67 of of IN 13433 1473 68 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1473 69 and and CC 13433 1473 70 , , , 13433 1473 71 as as IN 13433 1473 72 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 73 infers infer VBZ 13433 1473 74 , , , 13433 1473 75 derived derive VBD 13433 1473 76 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1473 77 from from IN 13433 1473 78 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1473 79 four four CD 13433 1473 80 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1473 81 . . . 13433 1474 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1474 2 really really RB 13433 1474 3 seems seem VBZ 13433 1474 4 incapable incapable JJ 13433 1474 5 of of IN 13433 1474 6 discriminating discriminate VBG 13433 1474 7 between between IN 13433 1474 8 a a DT 13433 1474 9 denial denial NN 13433 1474 10 that that IN 13433 1474 11 there there EX 13433 1474 12 is be VBZ 13433 1474 13 clear clear JJ 13433 1474 14 and and CC 13433 1474 15 palpable palpable JJ 13433 1474 16 evidence evidence NN 13433 1474 17 of of IN 13433 1474 18 the the DT 13433 1474 19 existence existence NN 13433 1474 20 and and CC 13433 1474 21 authorship authorship NN 13433 1474 22 of of IN 13433 1474 23 these these DT 13433 1474 24 particular particular JJ 13433 1474 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1474 26 , , , 13433 1474 27 and and CC 13433 1474 28 denial denial NN 13433 1474 29 that that IN 13433 1474 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1474 31 actually actually RB 13433 1474 32 existed exist VBD 13433 1474 33 at at RB 13433 1474 34 all all RB 13433 1474 35 . . . 13433 1475 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1475 2 do do VBP 13433 1475 3 not not RB 13433 1475 4 suppose suppose VB 13433 1475 5 that that IN 13433 1475 6 there there EX 13433 1475 7 is be VBZ 13433 1475 8 any any DT 13433 1475 9 critic critic NN 13433 1475 10 , , , 13433 1475 11 past past JJ 13433 1475 12 or or CC 13433 1475 13 present present JJ 13433 1475 14 , , , 13433 1475 15 who who WP 13433 1475 16 doubts doubt VBZ 13433 1475 17 that that IN 13433 1475 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1475 19 four four CD 13433 1475 20 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1475 21 had have VBD 13433 1475 22 been be VBN 13433 1475 23 composed compose VBN 13433 1475 24 and and CC 13433 1475 25 were be VBD 13433 1475 26 in in IN 13433 1475 27 wide wide JJ 13433 1475 28 circulation circulation NN 13433 1475 29 during during IN 13433 1475 30 this this DT 13433 1475 31 period period NN 13433 1475 32 of of IN 13433 1475 33 the the DT 13433 1475 34 second second JJ 13433 1475 35 century century NN 13433 1475 36 . . . 13433 1476 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1476 2 is be VBZ 13433 1476 3 a a DT 13433 1476 4 very very RB 13433 1476 5 different different JJ 13433 1476 6 matter matter NN 13433 1476 7 to to TO 13433 1476 8 examine examine VB 13433 1476 9 what what WP 13433 1476 10 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1476 11 testimony testimony NN 13433 1476 12 there there EX 13433 1476 13 is be VBZ 13433 1476 14 regarding regard VBG 13433 1476 15 the the DT 13433 1476 16 origin origin NN 13433 1476 17 , , , 13433 1476 18 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1476 19 , , , 13433 1476 20 and and CC 13433 1476 21 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 13433 1476 22 of of IN 13433 1476 23 these these DT 13433 1476 24 documents document NNS 13433 1476 25 , , , 13433 1476 26 as as IN 13433 1476 27 records record NNS 13433 1476 28 of of IN 13433 1476 29 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1476 30 and and CC 13433 1476 31 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1476 32 for for IN 13433 1476 33 the the DT 13433 1476 34 reality reality NN 13433 1476 35 of of IN 13433 1476 36 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1476 37 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1476 38 . . . 13433 1477 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 2 can can MD 13433 1477 3 not not RB 13433 1477 4 accuse accuse VB 13433 1477 5 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 6 of of IN 13433 1477 7 having have VBG 13433 1477 8 misled mislead VBN 13433 1477 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1477 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1477 11 on on IN 13433 1477 12 this this DT 13433 1477 13 point point NN 13433 1477 14 by by IN 13433 1477 15 any any DT 13433 1477 16 obscurity obscurity NN 13433 1477 17 in in IN 13433 1477 18 the the DT 13433 1477 19 statement statement NN 13433 1477 20 of of IN 13433 1477 21 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1477 22 object object NN 13433 1477 23 , , , 13433 1477 24 but but CC 13433 1477 25 , , , 13433 1477 26 as as IN 13433 1477 27 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 28 and and CC 13433 1477 29 other other JJ 13433 1477 30 apologists apologist NNS 13433 1477 31 have have VBP 13433 1477 32 carefully carefully RB 13433 1477 33 ignored ignore VBN 13433 1477 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 35 , , , 13433 1477 36 and and CC 13433 1477 37 systematically systematically RB 13433 1477 38 warped warp VBD 13433 1477 39 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1477 40 argument argument NN 13433 1477 41 , , , 13433 1477 42 either either CC 13433 1477 43 by by IN 13433 1477 44 accident accident NN 13433 1477 45 or or CC 13433 1477 46 design design NN 13433 1477 47 , , , 13433 1477 48 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 49 venture venture VBP 13433 1477 50 to to TO 13433 1477 51 quote quote VB 13433 1477 52 a a DT 13433 1477 53 few few JJ 13433 1477 54 sentences sentence NNS 13433 1477 55 from from IN 13433 1477 56 _ _ NNP 13433 1477 57 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1477 58 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1477 59 _ _ NNP 13433 1477 60 , , , 13433 1477 61 both both DT 13433 1477 62 to to TO 13433 1477 63 justify justify VB 13433 1477 64 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1477 65 and and CC 13433 1477 66 to to TO 13433 1477 67 restore restore VB 13433 1477 68 the the DT 13433 1477 69 discussion discussion NN 13433 1477 70 to to IN 13433 1477 71 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1477 72 proper proper JJ 13433 1477 73 lines line NNS 13433 1477 74 . . . 13433 1478 1 In in IN 13433 1478 2 winding wind VBG 13433 1478 3 up up RP 13433 1478 4 the the DT 13433 1478 5 first first JJ 13433 1478 6 part part NN 13433 1478 7 of of IN 13433 1478 8 the the DT 13433 1478 9 work work NN 13433 1478 10 , , , 13433 1478 11 which which WDT 13433 1478 12 was be VBD 13433 1478 13 principally principally RB 13433 1478 14 concerned concerned JJ 13433 1478 15 with with IN 13433 1478 16 the the DT 13433 1478 17 antecedent antecedent NN 13433 1478 18 credibility credibility NN 13433 1478 19 of of IN 13433 1478 20 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1478 21 , , , 13433 1478 22 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1478 23 said:-- said:-- VBP 13433 1478 24 " " `` 13433 1478 25 Now now RB 13433 1478 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1478 27 is be VBZ 13433 1478 28 apparent apparent JJ 13433 1478 29 that that IN 13433 1478 30 the the DT 13433 1478 31 evidence evidence NN 13433 1478 32 for for IN 13433 1478 33 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1478 34 requires require VBZ 13433 1478 35 to to TO 13433 1478 36 embrace embrace VB 13433 1478 37 two two CD 13433 1478 38 distinct distinct JJ 13433 1478 39 points point NNS 13433 1478 40 : : : 13433 1478 41 the the DT 13433 1478 42 reality reality NN 13433 1478 43 of of IN 13433 1478 44 the the DT 13433 1478 45 alleged allege VBN 13433 1478 46 facts fact NNS 13433 1478 47 , , , 13433 1478 48 and and CC 13433 1478 49 the the DT 13433 1478 50 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1478 51 of of IN 13433 1478 52 the the DT 13433 1478 53 inference inference NN 13433 1478 54 that that IN 13433 1478 55 the the DT 13433 1478 56 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1478 57 were be VBD 13433 1478 58 produced produce VBN 13433 1478 59 by by IN 13433 1478 60 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1478 61 agency agency NN 13433 1478 62 ... ... . 13433 1479 1 In in IN 13433 1479 2 order order NN 13433 1479 3 , , , 13433 1479 4 however however RB 13433 1479 5 , , , 13433 1479 6 to to TO 13433 1479 7 render render VB 13433 1479 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1479 9 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1479 10 complete complete JJ 13433 1479 11 , , , 13433 1479 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1479 13 remains remain VBZ 13433 1479 14 for for IN 13433 1479 15 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1479 16 to to TO 13433 1479 17 see see VB 13433 1479 18 whether whether IN 13433 1479 19 , , , 13433 1479 20 as as IN 13433 1479 21 affirmed affirm VBN 13433 1479 22 , , , 13433 1479 23 there there EX 13433 1479 24 be be VB 13433 1479 25 any any DT 13433 1479 26 special special JJ 13433 1479 27 evidence evidence NN 13433 1479 28 regarding regard VBG 13433 1479 29 the the DT 13433 1479 30 alleged allege VBN 13433 1479 31 facts fact NNS 13433 1479 32 entitling entitle VBG 13433 1479 33 the the DT 13433 1479 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1479 35 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1479 36 to to IN 13433 1479 37 exceptional exceptional JJ 13433 1479 38 attention attention NN 13433 1479 39 . . . 13433 1480 1 If if IN 13433 1480 2 , , , 13433 1480 3 instead instead RB 13433 1480 4 of of IN 13433 1480 5 being be VBG 13433 1480 6 clear clear JJ 13433 1480 7 , , , 13433 1480 8 direct direct JJ 13433 1480 9 , , , 13433 1480 10 the the DT 13433 1480 11 undoubted undoubted JJ 13433 1480 12 testimony testimony NN 13433 1480 13 of of IN 13433 1480 14 known know VBN 13433 1480 15 eye eye NN 13433 1480 16 - - HYPH 13433 1480 17 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1480 18 free free JJ 13433 1480 19 from from IN 13433 1480 20 superstition superstition NN 13433 1480 21 and and CC 13433 1480 22 capable capable JJ 13433 1480 23 , , , 13433 1480 24 through through IN 13433 1480 25 adequate adequate JJ 13433 1480 26 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1480 27 , , , 13433 1480 28 rightly rightly RB 13433 1480 29 to to TO 13433 1480 30 estimate estimate VB 13433 1480 31 the the DT 13433 1480 32 alleged alleged JJ 13433 1480 33 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1480 34 , , , 13433 1480 35 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1480 36 find find VBP 13433 1480 37 that that IN 13433 1480 38 the the DT 13433 1480 39 actual actual JJ 13433 1480 40 accounts account NNS 13433 1480 41 have have VBP 13433 1480 42 none none NN 13433 1480 43 of of IN 13433 1480 44 these these DT 13433 1480 45 qualifications qualification NNS 13433 1480 46 , , , 13433 1480 47 the the DT 13433 1480 48 final final JJ 13433 1480 49 decision decision NN 13433 1480 50 with with IN 13433 1480 51 regard regard NN 13433 1480 52 to to IN 13433 1480 53 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1480 54 and and CC 13433 1480 55 the the DT 13433 1480 56 reality reality NN 13433 1480 57 of of IN 13433 1480 58 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1480 59 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1480 60 will will MD 13433 1480 61 be be VB 13433 1480 62 easy easy JJ 13433 1480 63 and and CC 13433 1480 64 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 1480 65 . . . 13433 1480 66 " " '' 13433 1481 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1481 2 130:1 130:1 LS 13433 1481 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1481 4 Before before IN 13433 1481 5 commencing commence VBG 13433 1481 6 the the DT 13433 1481 7 examination examination NN 13433 1481 8 of of IN 13433 1481 9 the the DT 13433 1481 10 evidence evidence NN 13433 1481 11 for for IN 13433 1481 12 the the DT 13433 1481 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1481 14 , , , 13433 1481 15 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1481 16 was be VBD 13433 1481 17 careful careful JJ 13433 1481 18 to to TO 13433 1481 19 state state VB 13433 1481 20 the the DT 13433 1481 21 principles principle NNS 13433 1481 22 upon upon IN 13433 1481 23 which which WDT 13433 1481 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1481 25 considered consider VBD 13433 1481 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1481 27 right right JJ 13433 1481 28 to to TO 13433 1481 29 proceed proceed VB 13433 1481 30 . . . 13433 1482 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1482 2 said say VBD 13433 1482 3 : : : 13433 1482 4 " " `` 13433 1482 5 Before before IN 13433 1482 6 commencing commence VBG 13433 1482 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1482 8 examination examination NN 13433 1482 9 of of IN 13433 1482 10 the the DT 13433 1482 11 evidence evidence NN 13433 1482 12 as as IN 13433 1482 13 to to IN 13433 1482 14 the the DT 13433 1482 15 date date NN 13433 1482 16 , , , 13433 1482 17 authorship authorship NN 13433 1482 18 , , , 13433 1482 19 and and CC 13433 1482 20 character character NN 13433 1482 21 of of IN 13433 1482 22 the the DT 13433 1482 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1482 24 , , , 13433 1482 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1482 26 may may MD 13433 1482 27 be be VB 13433 1482 28 well well JJ 13433 1482 29 to to TO 13433 1482 30 make make VB 13433 1482 31 a a DT 13433 1482 32 few few JJ 13433 1482 33 preliminary preliminary JJ 13433 1482 34 remarks remark NNS 13433 1482 35 , , , 13433 1482 36 and and CC 13433 1482 37 clearly clearly RB 13433 1482 38 state state VB 13433 1482 39 certain certain JJ 13433 1482 40 canons canon NNS 13433 1482 41 of of IN 13433 1482 42 criticism criticism NN 13433 1482 43 . . . 13433 1483 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1483 2 shall shall MD 13433 1483 3 make make VB 13433 1483 4 no no DT 13433 1483 5 attempt attempt NN 13433 1483 6 to to TO 13433 1483 7 establish establish VB 13433 1483 8 any any DT 13433 1483 9 theory theory NN 13433 1483 10 as as IN 13433 1483 11 to to IN 13433 1483 12 the the DT 13433 1483 13 date date NN 13433 1483 14 at at IN 13433 1483 15 which which WDT 13433 1483 16 any any DT 13433 1483 17 of of IN 13433 1483 18 the the DT 13433 1483 19 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1483 20 was be VBD 13433 1483 21 actually actually RB 13433 1483 22 written write VBN 13433 1483 23 , , , 13433 1483 24 but but CC 13433 1483 25 simply simply RB 13433 1483 26 examine examine VB 13433 1483 27 all all PDT 13433 1483 28 the the DT 13433 1483 29 testimony testimony NN 13433 1483 30 which which WDT 13433 1483 31 is be VBZ 13433 1483 32 extant extant JJ 13433 1483 33 , , , 13433 1483 34 with with IN 13433 1483 35 the the DT 13433 1483 36 view view NN 13433 1483 37 of of IN 13433 1483 38 ascertaining ascertain VBG 13433 1483 39 _ _ NN 13433 1483 40 what what WP 13433 1483 41 is be VBZ 13433 1483 42 known know VBN 13433 1483 43 of of IN 13433 1483 44 these these DT 13433 1483 45 works work NNS 13433 1483 46 and and CC 13433 1483 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1483 48 authors author NNS 13433 1483 49 , , , 13433 1483 50 certainly certainly RB 13433 1483 51 and and CC 13433 1483 52 distinctly distinctly RB 13433 1483 53 , , , 13433 1483 54 as as IN 13433 1483 55 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 1483 56 from from IN 13433 1483 57 what what WP 13433 1483 58 is be VBZ 13433 1483 59 merely merely RB 13433 1483 60 conjectured conjecture VBN 13433 1483 61 or or CC 13433 1483 62 inferred infer VBN 13433 1483 63 _ _ NNP 13433 1483 64 ... ... . 13433 1483 65 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1483 66 propose propose VBP 13433 1483 67 , , , 13433 1483 68 therefore therefore RB 13433 1483 69 , , , 13433 1483 70 as as RB 13433 1483 71 exhaustively exhaustively RB 13433 1483 72 as as IN 13433 1483 73 possible possible JJ 13433 1483 74 , , , 13433 1483 75 to to TO 13433 1483 76 search search VB 13433 1483 77 all all PDT 13433 1483 78 the the DT 13433 1483 79 writings writing NNS 13433 1483 80 of of IN 13433 1483 81 the the DT 13433 1483 82 early early JJ 13433 1483 83 Church Church NNP 13433 1483 84 for for IN 13433 1483 85 information information NN 13433 1483 86 regarding regard VBG 13433 1483 87 the the DT 13433 1483 88 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1483 89 , , , 13433 1483 90 and and CC 13433 1483 91 to to TO 13433 1483 92 examine examine VB 13433 1483 93 even even RB 13433 1483 94 the the DT 13433 1483 95 alleged allege VBN 13433 1483 96 indications indication NNS 13433 1483 97 of of IN 13433 1483 98 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1483 99 use use NN 13433 1483 100 ... ... : 13433 1484 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1484 2 is be VBZ 13433 1484 3 still still RB 13433 1484 4 more more RBR 13433 1484 5 important important JJ 13433 1484 6 that that IN 13433 1484 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1484 8 should should MD 13433 1484 9 constantly constantly RB 13433 1484 10 bear bear VB 13433 1484 11 in in IN 13433 1484 12 mind mind NN 13433 1484 13 that that IN 13433 1484 14 a a DT 13433 1484 15 great great JJ 13433 1484 16 number number NN 13433 1484 17 of of IN 13433 1484 18 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1484 19 existed exist VBD 13433 1484 20 in in IN 13433 1484 21 the the DT 13433 1484 22 early early JJ 13433 1484 23 Church church NN 13433 1484 24 which which WDT 13433 1484 25 are be VBP 13433 1484 26 no no RB 13433 1484 27 longer long RBR 13433 1484 28 extant extant JJ 13433 1484 29 , , , 13433 1484 30 and and CC 13433 1484 31 of of IN 13433 1484 32 most most JJS 13433 1484 33 of of IN 13433 1484 34 which which WDT 13433 1484 35 even even RB 13433 1484 36 the the DT 13433 1484 37 names name NNS 13433 1484 38 are be VBP 13433 1484 39 lost lose VBN 13433 1484 40 . . . 13433 1485 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1485 2 need need VBP 13433 1485 3 not not RB 13433 1485 4 here here RB 13433 1485 5 do do VB 13433 1485 6 more more JJR 13433 1485 7 than than IN 13433 1485 8 refer refer VB 13433 1485 9 , , , 13433 1485 10 in in IN 13433 1485 11 corroboration corroboration NN 13433 1485 12 of of IN 13433 1485 13 this this DT 13433 1485 14 fact fact NN 13433 1485 15 , , , 13433 1485 16 to to IN 13433 1485 17 the the DT 13433 1485 18 preliminary preliminary JJ 13433 1485 19 statement statement NN 13433 1485 20 of of IN 13433 1485 21 the the DT 13433 1485 22 author author NN 13433 1485 23 of of IN 13433 1485 24 the the DT 13433 1485 25 third third JJ 13433 1485 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1485 27 : : : 13433 1485 28 ' ' '' 13433 1485 29 Forasmuch forasmuch VB 13433 1485 30 as as IN 13433 1485 31 many many JJ 13433 1485 32 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1485 33 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1485 34 Greek greek JJ 13433 1485 35 : : : 13433 1485 36 polloi polloi NN 13433 1485 37 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1485 38 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1485 39 took take VBD 13433 1485 40 in in IN 13433 1485 41 hand hand NN 13433 1485 42 to to TO 13433 1485 43 set set VB 13433 1485 44 forth forth RP 13433 1485 45 in in IN 13433 1485 46 order order NN 13433 1485 47 a a DT 13433 1485 48 declaration declaration NN 13433 1485 49 of of IN 13433 1485 50 the the DT 13433 1485 51 things thing NNS 13433 1485 52 which which WDT 13433 1485 53 have have VBP 13433 1485 54 been be VBN 13433 1485 55 accomplish accomplish JJ 13433 1485 56 among among IN 13433 1485 57 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1485 58 , , , 13433 1485 59 ' ' '' 13433 1485 60 & & CC 13433 1485 61 c. c. NNP 13433 1485 62 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1485 63 is be VBZ 13433 1485 64 , , , 13433 1485 65 therefore therefore RB 13433 1485 66 , , , 13433 1485 67 evident evident JJ 13433 1485 68 that that IN 13433 1485 69 before before IN 13433 1485 70 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1485 71 third third JJ 13433 1485 72 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1485 73 was be VBD 13433 1485 74 written write VBN 13433 1485 75 many many JJ 13433 1485 76 similar similar JJ 13433 1485 77 works work NNS 13433 1485 78 were be VBD 13433 1485 79 already already RB 13433 1485 80 in in IN 13433 1485 81 circulation circulation NN 13433 1485 82 . . . 13433 1486 1 Looking look VBG 13433 1486 2 at at IN 13433 1486 3 the the DT 13433 1486 4 close close JJ 13433 1486 5 similarity similarity NN 13433 1486 6 of of IN 13433 1486 7 large large JJ 13433 1486 8 portions portion NNS 13433 1486 9 of of IN 13433 1486 10 the the DT 13433 1486 11 three three CD 13433 1486 12 synoptics synoptic NNS 13433 1486 13 , , , 13433 1486 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1486 15 is be VBZ 13433 1486 16 almost almost RB 13433 1486 17 certain certain JJ 13433 1486 18 that that IN 13433 1486 19 many many JJ 13433 1486 20 of of IN 13433 1486 21 the the DT 13433 1486 22 writings writing NNS 13433 1486 23 here here RB 13433 1486 24 mentioned mention VBD 13433 1486 25 bore bear VBD 13433 1486 26 a a DT 13433 1486 27 close close JJ 13433 1486 28 analogy analogy NN 13433 1486 29 to to IN 13433 1486 30 each each DT 13433 1486 31 other other JJ 13433 1486 32 and and CC 13433 1486 33 to to IN 13433 1486 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1486 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1486 36 , , , 13433 1486 37 and and CC 13433 1486 38 this this DT 13433 1486 39 is be VBZ 13433 1486 40 known know VBN 13433 1486 41 to to TO 13433 1486 42 have have VB 13433 1486 43 been be VBN 13433 1486 44 the the DT 13433 1486 45 case case NN 13433 1486 46 , , , 13433 1486 47 for for IN 13433 1486 48 instance instance NN 13433 1486 49 , , , 13433 1486 50 amongst amongst IN 13433 1486 51 the the DT 13433 1486 52 various various JJ 13433 1486 53 forms form NNS 13433 1486 54 of of IN 13433 1486 55 the the DT 13433 1486 56 ' ' `` 13433 1486 57 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1486 58 according accord VBG 13433 1486 59 to to IN 13433 1486 60 the the DT 13433 1486 61 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1486 62 . . . 13433 1486 63 ' ' '' 13433 1487 1 When when WRB 13433 1487 2 , , , 13433 1487 3 therefore therefore RB 13433 1487 4 , , , 13433 1487 5 in in IN 13433 1487 6 early early JJ 13433 1487 7 writings writing NNS 13433 1487 8 , , , 13433 1487 9 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1487 10 meet meet VBP 13433 1487 11 with with IN 13433 1487 12 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1487 13 closely closely RB 13433 1487 14 resembling resemble VBG 13433 1487 15 , , , 13433 1487 16 or or CC 13433 1487 17 , , , 13433 1487 18 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1487 19 may may MD 13433 1487 20 add add VB 13433 1487 21 , , , 13433 1487 22 even even RB 13433 1487 23 identical identical JJ 13433 1487 24 , , , 13433 1487 25 with with IN 13433 1487 26 passages passage NNS 13433 1487 27 which which WDT 13433 1487 28 are be VBP 13433 1487 29 found find VBN 13433 1487 30 in in IN 13433 1487 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1487 32 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1487 33 , , , 13433 1487 34 the the DT 13433 1487 35 source source NN 13433 1487 36 of of IN 13433 1487 37 which which WDT 13433 1487 38 , , , 13433 1487 39 however however RB 13433 1487 40 , , , 13433 1487 41 is be VBZ 13433 1487 42 not not RB 13433 1487 43 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1487 44 , , , 13433 1487 45 nor nor CC 13433 1487 46 is be VBZ 13433 1487 47 any any DT 13433 1487 48 author author NN 13433 1487 49 's 's POS 13433 1487 50 name name NN 13433 1487 51 indicated indicate VBD 13433 1487 52 , , , 13433 1487 53 _ _ NNP 13433 1487 54 the the DT 13433 1487 55 similarity similarity NN 13433 1487 56 or or CC 13433 1487 57 even even RB 13433 1487 58 identity identity NN 13433 1487 59 can can MD 13433 1487 60 not not RB 13433 1487 61 by by IN 13433 1487 62 any any DT 13433 1487 63 means mean NNS 13433 1487 64 be be VB 13433 1487 65 admitted admit VBN 13433 1487 66 as as IN 13433 1487 67 proof proof NN 13433 1487 68 that that IN 13433 1487 69 the the DT 13433 1487 70 quotation quotation NN 13433 1487 71 is be VBZ 13433 1487 72 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 1487 73 from from IN 13433 1487 74 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1487 75 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1487 76 , , , 13433 1487 77 and and CC 13433 1487 78 not not RB 13433 1487 79 from from IN 13433 1487 80 some some DT 13433 1487 81 other other JJ 13433 1487 82 similar similar JJ 13433 1487 83 work work NN 13433 1487 84 now now RB 13433 1487 85 no no RB 13433 1487 86 longer long RBR 13433 1487 87 extant extant JJ 13433 1487 88 _ _ NNP 13433 1487 89 , , , 13433 1487 90 and and CC 13433 1487 91 more more RBR 13433 1487 92 especially especially RB 13433 1487 93 not not RB 13433 1487 94 when when WRB 13433 1487 95 , , , 13433 1487 96 in in IN 13433 1487 97 the the DT 13433 1487 98 same same JJ 13433 1487 99 writings writing NNS 13433 1487 100 , , , 13433 1487 101 there there EX 13433 1487 102 are be VBP 13433 1487 103 other other JJ 13433 1487 104 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1487 105 from from IN 13433 1487 106 sources source NNS 13433 1487 107 different different JJ 13433 1487 108 from from IN 13433 1487 109 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1487 110 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1487 111 .... .... . 13433 1488 1 But but CC 13433 1488 2 whilst whilst IN 13433 1488 3 similarity similarity NN 13433 1488 4 to to IN 13433 1488 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1488 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1488 7 in in IN 13433 1488 8 passages passage NNS 13433 1488 9 quoted quote VBN 13433 1488 10 by by IN 13433 1488 11 early early JJ 13433 1488 12 writers writer NNS 13433 1488 13 from from IN 13433 1488 14 unnamed unnamed JJ 13433 1488 15 sources source NNS 13433 1488 16 can can MD 13433 1488 17 not not RB 13433 1488 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1488 19 prove prove VB 13433 1488 20 _ _ IN 13433 1488 21 the the DT 13433 1488 22 use use NN 13433 1488 23 of of IN 13433 1488 24 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1488 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1488 26 , , , 13433 1488 27 variation variation NN 13433 1488 28 from from IN 13433 1488 29 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1488 30 would would MD 13433 1488 31 suggest suggest VB 13433 1488 32 or or CC 13433 1488 33 prove prove VB 13433 1488 34 a a DT 13433 1488 35 different different JJ 13433 1488 36 origin origin NN 13433 1488 37 , , , 13433 1488 38 _ _ NNP 13433 1488 39 and and CC 13433 1488 40 at at IN 13433 1488 41 least least JJS 13433 1488 42 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1488 43 is be VBZ 13433 1488 44 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1488 45 that that IN 13433 1488 46 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1488 47 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1488 48 which which WDT 13433 1488 49 do do VBP 13433 1488 50 not not RB 13433 1488 51 agree agree VB 13433 1488 52 with with IN 13433 1488 53 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1488 54 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1488 55 can can MD 13433 1488 56 not not RB 13433 1488 57 in in IN 13433 1488 58 any any DT 13433 1488 59 case case NN 13433 1488 60 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 1488 61 indicate indicate VBP 13433 1488 62 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1488 63 existence existence NN 13433 1488 64 _ _ NNP 13433 1488 65 ... ... . 13433 1489 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1489 2 is be VBZ 13433 1489 3 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 1489 4 to to TO 13433 1489 5 add add VB 13433 1489 6 that that DT 13433 1489 7 , , , 13433 1489 8 in in IN 13433 1489 9 proportion proportion NN 13433 1489 10 as as IN 13433 1489 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1489 12 remove remove VBP 13433 1489 13 from from IN 13433 1489 14 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 1489 15 times time NNS 13433 1489 16 without without IN 13433 1489 17 positive positive JJ 13433 1489 18 evidence evidence NN 13433 1489 19 of of IN 13433 1489 20 the the DT 13433 1489 21 existence existence NN 13433 1489 22 and and CC 13433 1489 23 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1489 24 of of IN 13433 1489 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1489 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1489 27 , , , 13433 1489 28 so so RB 13433 1489 29 does do VBZ 13433 1489 30 the the DT 13433 1489 31 value value NN 13433 1489 32 of of IN 13433 1489 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1489 34 testimony testimony NN 13433 1489 35 dwindle dwindle VB 13433 1489 36 away away RB 13433 1489 37 . . . 13433 1490 1 Indeed indeed RB 13433 1490 2 , , , 13433 1490 3 requiring require VBG 13433 1490 4 , , , 13433 1490 5 as as IN 13433 1490 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1490 7 do do VBP 13433 1490 8 , , , 13433 1490 9 clear clear JJ 13433 1490 10 , , , 13433 1490 11 direct direct JJ 13433 1490 12 and and CC 13433 1490 13 irrefragable irrefragable JJ 13433 1490 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 1490 15 of of IN 13433 1490 16 the the DT 13433 1490 17 integrity integrity NN 13433 1490 18 , , , 13433 1490 19 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1490 20 , , , 13433 1490 21 and and CC 13433 1490 22 historical historical JJ 13433 1490 23 character character NN 13433 1490 24 of of IN 13433 1490 25 these these DT 13433 1490 26 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1490 27 , , , 13433 1490 28 doubt doubt NN 13433 1490 29 or or CC 13433 1490 30 obscurity obscurity NN 13433 1490 31 on on IN 13433 1490 32 these these DT 13433 1490 33 points point NNS 13433 1490 34 must must MD 13433 1490 35 inevitably inevitably RB 13433 1490 36 be be VB 13433 1490 37 fatal fatal JJ 13433 1490 38 to to IN 13433 1490 39 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1490 40 as as IN 13433 1490 41 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 1490 42 testimony testimony NN 13433 1490 43 -- -- : 13433 1490 44 if if IN 13433 1490 45 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1490 46 could could MD 13433 1490 47 , , , 13433 1490 48 under under IN 13433 1490 49 any any DT 13433 1490 50 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1490 51 , , , 13433 1490 52 be be VB 13433 1490 53 considered consider VBN 13433 1490 54 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 1490 55 testimony testimony NN 13433 1490 56 -- -- : 13433 1490 57 for for IN 13433 1490 58 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1490 59 and and CC 13433 1490 60 a a DT 13433 1490 61 direct direct JJ 13433 1490 62 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1490 63 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1490 64 like like IN 13433 1490 65 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 1490 66 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1490 67 . . . 13433 1490 68 " " '' 13433 1491 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1491 2 132:1 132:1 LS 13433 1491 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1491 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1491 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1491 6 must must MD 13433 1491 7 have have VB 13433 1491 8 been be VBN 13433 1491 9 aware aware JJ 13433 1491 10 of of IN 13433 1491 11 these these DT 13433 1491 12 statements statement NNS 13433 1491 13 , , , 13433 1491 14 since since IN 13433 1491 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 16 has have VBZ 13433 1491 17 made make VBN 13433 1491 18 the the DT 13433 1491 19 paragraph paragraph NN 13433 1491 20 on on IN 13433 1491 21 the the DT 13433 1491 22 silence silence NN 13433 1491 23 of of IN 13433 1491 24 ancient ancient JJ 13433 1491 25 writers writer NNS 13433 1491 26 the the DT 13433 1491 27 basis basis NN 13433 1491 28 of of IN 13433 1491 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1491 30 essay essay NN 13433 1491 31 on on IN 13433 1491 32 the the DT 13433 1491 33 silence silence NN 13433 1491 34 of of IN 13433 1491 35 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1491 36 , , , 13433 1491 37 and and CC 13433 1491 38 has have VBZ 13433 1491 39 been be VBN 13433 1491 40 so so RB 13433 1491 41 particular particular JJ 13433 1491 42 in in IN 13433 1491 43 calling call VBG 13433 1491 44 attention attention NN 13433 1491 45 to to IN 13433 1491 46 any any DT 13433 1491 47 alteration alteration NN 13433 1491 48 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 49 have have VBP 13433 1491 50 made make VBN 13433 1491 51 in in IN 13433 1491 52 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1491 53 text text NN 13433 1491 54 ; ; : 13433 1491 55 and and CC 13433 1491 56 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 57 might may MD 13433 1491 58 have have VB 13433 1491 59 been be VBN 13433 1491 60 better well JJR 13433 1491 61 if if IN 13433 1491 62 , , , 13433 1491 63 instead instead RB 13433 1491 64 of of IN 13433 1491 65 cheap cheap JJ 13433 1491 66 sneers sneer NNS 13433 1491 67 on on IN 13433 1491 68 every every DT 13433 1491 69 occasion occasion NN 13433 1491 70 in in IN 13433 1491 71 which which WDT 13433 1491 72 these these DT 13433 1491 73 canons canon NNS 13433 1491 74 have have VBP 13433 1491 75 been be VBN 13433 1491 76 applied apply VBN 13433 1491 77 , , , 13433 1491 78 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 79 had have VBD 13433 1491 80 once once RB 13433 1491 81 for for IN 13433 1491 82 all all DT 13433 1491 83 stated state VBN 13433 1491 84 any any DT 13433 1491 85 reasons reason NNS 13433 1491 86 which which WDT 13433 1491 87 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 88 can can MD 13433 1491 89 bring bring VB 13433 1491 90 forward forward RB 13433 1491 91 against against IN 13433 1491 92 the the DT 13433 1491 93 canons canon NNS 13433 1491 94 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1491 95 . . . 13433 1492 1 The the DT 13433 1492 2 course course NN 13433 1492 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1492 4 has have VBZ 13433 1492 5 adopted adopt VBN 13433 1492 6 , , , 13433 1492 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1492 8 can can MD 13433 1492 9 well well RB 13433 1492 10 understand understand VB 13433 1492 11 , , , 13433 1492 12 is be VBZ 13433 1492 13 more more RBR 13433 1492 14 convenient convenient JJ 13433 1492 15 for for IN 13433 1492 16 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1492 17 and and CC 13433 1492 18 , , , 13433 1492 19 after after RB 13433 1492 20 all all RB 13433 1492 21 , , , 13433 1492 22 with with IN 13433 1492 23 many many JJ 13433 1492 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1492 25 is be VBZ 13433 1492 26 quite quite RB 13433 1492 27 as as RB 13433 1492 28 effective effective JJ 13433 1492 29 . . . 13433 1493 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 2 may may MD 13433 1493 3 be be VB 13433 1493 4 well well JJ 13433 1493 5 that that IN 13433 1493 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 7 should should MD 13433 1493 8 here here RB 13433 1493 9 again again RB 13433 1493 10 illustrate illustrate VB 13433 1493 11 the the DT 13433 1493 12 necessity necessity NN 13433 1493 13 for for IN 13433 1493 14 such such JJ 13433 1493 15 canons canon NNS 13433 1493 16 of of IN 13433 1493 17 criticism criticism NN 13433 1493 18 as as IN 13433 1493 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 20 have have VBP 13433 1493 21 indicated indicate VBN 13433 1493 22 above above RB 13433 1493 23 , , , 13433 1493 24 and and CC 13433 1493 25 which which WDT 13433 1493 26 can can MD 13433 1493 27 be be VB 13433 1493 28 done do VBN 13433 1493 29 very very RB 13433 1493 30 simply simply RB 13433 1493 31 from from IN 13433 1493 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1493 33 own own JJ 13433 1493 34 Gospels gospel NNS 13433 1493 35 : : : 13433 1493 36 " " `` 13433 1493 37 Not not RB 13433 1493 38 only only RB 13433 1493 39 the the DT 13433 1493 40 language language NN 13433 1493 41 but but CC 13433 1493 42 the the DT 13433 1493 43 order order NN 13433 1493 44 of of IN 13433 1493 45 a a DT 13433 1493 46 quotation quotation NN 13433 1493 47 must must MD 13433 1493 48 have have VB 13433 1493 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1493 50 due due JJ 13433 1493 51 weight weight NN 13433 1493 52 , , , 13433 1493 53 and and CC 13433 1493 54 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 55 have have VBP 13433 1493 56 no no DT 13433 1493 57 right right NN 13433 1493 58 to to TO 13433 1493 59 dismember dismember VB 13433 1493 60 a a DT 13433 1493 61 passage passage NN 13433 1493 62 and and CC 13433 1493 63 , , , 13433 1493 64 discovering discover VBG 13433 1493 65 fragmentary fragmentary JJ 13433 1493 66 parallels parallel NNS 13433 1493 67 in in IN 13433 1493 68 various various JJ 13433 1493 69 parts part NNS 13433 1493 70 of of IN 13433 1493 71 the the DT 13433 1493 72 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1493 73 , , , 13433 1493 74 to to TO 13433 1493 75 assert assert VB 13433 1493 76 that that IN 13433 1493 77 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 78 is be VBZ 13433 1493 79 compiled compile VBN 13433 1493 80 from from IN 13433 1493 81 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 82 and and CC 13433 1493 83 not not RB 13433 1493 84 derived derive VBN 13433 1493 85 , , , 13433 1493 86 as as IN 13433 1493 87 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1493 88 stands stand VBZ 13433 1493 89 , , , 13433 1493 90 from from IN 13433 1493 91 another another DT 13433 1493 92 source source NN 13433 1493 93 . . . 13433 1494 1 As as IN 13433 1494 2 an an DT 13433 1494 3 illustration illustration NN 13433 1494 4 , , , 13433 1494 5 let let VB 13433 1494 6 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1494 7 for for IN 13433 1494 8 a a DT 13433 1494 9 moment moment NN 13433 1494 10 suppose suppose VB 13433 1494 11 the the DT 13433 1494 12 ' ' `` 13433 1494 13 Gospel gospel NN 13433 1494 14 according accord VBG 13433 1494 15 to to IN 13433 1494 16 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1494 17 ' ' '' 13433 1494 18 to to TO 13433 1494 19 have have VB 13433 1494 20 been be VBN 13433 1494 21 lost lose VBN 13433 1494 22 , , , 13433 1494 23 like like IN 13433 1494 24 the the DT 13433 1494 25 ' ' `` 13433 1494 26 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1494 27 according accord VBG 13433 1494 28 to to IN 13433 1494 29 the the DT 13433 1494 30 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1494 31 ' ' '' 13433 1494 32 and and CC 13433 1494 33 so so RB 13433 1494 34 many many JJ 13433 1494 35 others other NNS 13433 1494 36 . . . 13433 1495 1 In in IN 13433 1495 2 the the DT 13433 1495 3 works work NNS 13433 1495 4 of of IN 13433 1495 5 one one CD 13433 1495 6 of of IN 13433 1495 7 the the DT 13433 1495 8 Fathers father NNS 13433 1495 9 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1495 10 discover discover VBP 13433 1495 11 the the DT 13433 1495 12 following follow VBG 13433 1495 13 quotation quotation NN 13433 1495 14 from from IN 13433 1495 15 an an DT 13433 1495 16 unnamed unnamed JJ 13433 1495 17 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 1495 18 work work NN 13433 1495 19 : : : 13433 1495 20 ' ' '' 13433 1495 21 And and CC 13433 1495 22 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1495 23 said say VBD 13433 1495 24 unto unto IN 13433 1495 25 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1495 26 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1495 27 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1495 28 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1495 29 : : : 13433 1495 30 elegen elegen NNP 13433 1495 31 de de FW 13433 1495 32 pros pro NNS 13433 1495 33 autous autous JJ 13433 1495 34 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1495 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1495 36 : : : 13433 1495 37 ' ' '' 13433 1495 38 The the DT 13433 1495 39 harvest harvest NN 13433 1495 40 truly truly RB 13433 1495 41 is be VBZ 13433 1495 42 great great JJ 13433 1495 43 , , , 13433 1495 44 but but CC 13433 1495 45 the the DT 13433 1495 46 labourers labourer NNS 13433 1495 47 are be VBP 13433 1495 48 few few JJ 13433 1495 49 ; ; : 13433 1495 50 pray pray VB 13433 1495 51 ye ye NNP 13433 1495 52 therefore therefore RB 13433 1495 53 the the DT 13433 1495 54 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1495 55 of of IN 13433 1495 56 the the DT 13433 1495 57 harvest harvest NN 13433 1495 58 that that WDT 13433 1495 59 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1495 60 would would MD 13433 1495 61 send send VB 13433 1495 62 forth forth RB 13433 1495 63 labourers labourer NNS 13433 1495 64 into into IN 13433 1495 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1495 66 harvest harvest NN 13433 1495 67 . . . 13433 1496 1 Go go VB 13433 1496 2 your -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1496 3 ways way NNS 13433 1496 4 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1496 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1496 6 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1496 7 : : : 13433 1496 8 hupagete hupagete NN 13433 1496 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1496 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1496 11 : : : 13433 1496 12 behold behold VB 13433 1496 13 , , , 13433 1496 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1496 15 send send VBP 13433 1496 16 you -PRON- PRP 13433 1496 17 forth forth RB 13433 1496 18 as as IN 13433 1496 19 lambs lamb NNS 13433 1496 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1496 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1496 22 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1496 23 : : : 13433 1496 24 arnas arnas NNP 13433 1496 25 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1496 26 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1496 27 in in IN 13433 1496 28 the the DT 13433 1496 29 midst midst NN 13433 1496 30 of of IN 13433 1496 31 wolves wolf NNS 13433 1496 32 . . . 13433 1496 33 ' ' '' 13433 1497 1 Following follow VBG 13433 1497 2 the the DT 13433 1497 3 system system NN 13433 1497 4 adopted adopt VBN 13433 1497 5 in in IN 13433 1497 6 regard regard NN 13433 1497 7 to to IN 13433 1497 8 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1497 9 and and CC 13433 1497 10 others other NNS 13433 1497 11 , , , 13433 1497 12 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 1497 13 critics critic NNS 13433 1497 14 would would MD 13433 1497 15 of of IN 13433 1497 16 course course NN 13433 1497 17 maintain maintain VB 13433 1497 18 that that IN 13433 1497 19 this this DT 13433 1497 20 was be VBD 13433 1497 21 a a DT 13433 1497 22 compilation compilation NN 13433 1497 23 from from IN 13433 1497 24 memory memory NN 13433 1497 25 of of IN 13433 1497 26 passages passage NNS 13433 1497 27 quoted quote VBN 13433 1497 28 from from IN 13433 1497 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1497 30 first first JJ 13433 1497 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1497 32 -- -- : 13433 1497 33 that that DT 13433 1497 34 is be VBZ 13433 1497 35 to to TO 13433 1497 36 say say VB 13433 1497 37 , , , 13433 1497 38 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1497 39 ix ix NNP 13433 1497 40 , , , 13433 1497 41 37 37 CD 13433 1497 42 : : : 13433 1497 43 ' ' '' 13433 1497 44 Then then RB 13433 1497 45 saith saith VBZ 13433 1497 46 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1497 47 unto unto IN 13433 1497 48 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1497 49 disciples disciple NNS 13433 1497 50 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1497 51 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1497 52 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1497 53 : : : 13433 1497 54 tote tote NNP 13433 1497 55 legei legei NNP 13433 1497 56 tois tois NNP 13433 1497 57 mathêtais mathêtais NNP 13433 1497 58 autou autou NNP 13433 1497 59 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1497 60 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1497 61 , , , 13433 1497 62 The the DT 13433 1497 63 harvest harvest NN 13433 1497 64 , , , 13433 1497 65 ' ' '' 13433 1497 66 & & CC 13433 1497 67 c. c. NNP 13433 1497 68 ; ; : 13433 1497 69 and and CC 13433 1497 70 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1497 71 . . . 13433 1498 1 x. x. NNP 13433 1499 1 16 16 CD 13433 1499 2 : : : 13433 1499 3 ' ' '' 13433 1499 4 Behold Behold NNP 13433 1499 5 , , , 13433 1499 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1499 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1499 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1499 9 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1499 10 : : : 13433 1499 11 egô egô NNP 13433 1499 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1499 13 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1499 14 send send VB 13433 1499 15 you -PRON- PRP 13433 1499 16 forth forth RB 13433 1499 17 as as IN 13433 1499 18 sheep sheep NNS 13433 1499 19 ' ' '' 13433 1499 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1499 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1499 22 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1499 23 : : : 13433 1499 24 probata probata NN 13433 1499 25 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1499 26 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1499 27 in in IN 13433 1499 28 the the DT 13433 1499 29 midst midst NN 13433 1499 30 of of IN 13433 1499 31 wolves wolf NNS 13433 1499 32 : : : 13433 1499 33 be be VB 13433 1499 34 ye ye NNP 13433 1499 35 therefore therefore RB 13433 1499 36 , , , 13433 1499 37 ' ' '' 13433 1499 38 & & CC 13433 1499 39 c. c. NNP 13433 1499 40 , , , 13433 1499 41 which which WDT 13433 1499 42 , , , 13433 1499 43 with with IN 13433 1499 44 the the DT 13433 1499 45 differences difference NNS 13433 1499 46 which which WDT 13433 1499 47 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1499 48 have have VBP 13433 1499 49 indicated indicate VBN 13433 1499 50 , , , 13433 1499 51 agree agree VBP 13433 1499 52 . . . 13433 1500 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1500 2 would would MD 13433 1500 3 probably probably RB 13433 1500 4 be be VB 13433 1500 5 in in IN 13433 1500 6 vain vain JJ 13433 1500 7 to to TO 13433 1500 8 argue argue VB 13433 1500 9 that that IN 13433 1500 10 the the DT 13433 1500 11 quotation quotation NN 13433 1500 12 indicated indicate VBD 13433 1500 13 a a DT 13433 1500 14 continuous continuous JJ 13433 1500 15 order order NN 13433 1500 16 , , , 13433 1500 17 and and CC 13433 1500 18 the the DT 13433 1500 19 variations variation NNS 13433 1500 20 combined combine VBN 13433 1500 21 to to TO 13433 1500 22 confirm confirm VB 13433 1500 23 the the DT 13433 1500 24 probability probability NN 13433 1500 25 of of IN 13433 1500 26 a a DT 13433 1500 27 different different JJ 13433 1500 28 source source NN 13433 1500 29 , , , 13433 1500 30 and and CC 13433 1500 31 still still RB 13433 1500 32 more more RBR 13433 1500 33 so so RB 13433 1500 34 to to TO 13433 1500 35 point point VB 13433 1500 36 out out RP 13433 1500 37 that that IN 13433 1500 38 , , , 13433 1500 39 although although IN 13433 1500 40 parts part NNS 13433 1500 41 of of IN 13433 1500 42 the the DT 13433 1500 43 quotation quotation NN 13433 1500 44 , , , 13433 1500 45 separated separate VBN 13433 1500 46 from from IN 13433 1500 47 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1500 48 context context NN 13433 1500 49 , , , 13433 1500 50 might may MD 13433 1500 51 , , , 13433 1500 52 to to IN 13433 1500 53 a a DT 13433 1500 54 certain certain JJ 13433 1500 55 extent extent NN 13433 1500 56 , , , 13433 1500 57 correspond correspond VB 13433 1500 58 with with IN 13433 1500 59 scattered scatter VBN 13433 1500 60 verses verse NNS 13433 1500 61 in in IN 13433 1500 62 the the DT 13433 1500 63 first first JJ 13433 1500 64 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1500 65 , , , 13433 1500 66 such such PDT 13433 1500 67 a a DT 13433 1500 68 circumstance circumstance NN 13433 1500 69 was be VBD 13433 1500 70 no no DT 13433 1500 71 proof proof NN 13433 1500 72 that that IN 13433 1500 73 the the DT 13433 1500 74 quotation quotation NN 13433 1500 75 was be VBD 13433 1500 76 taken take VBN 13433 1500 77 from from IN 13433 1500 78 that that DT 13433 1500 79 and and CC 13433 1500 80 from from IN 13433 1500 81 no no DT 13433 1500 82 other other JJ 13433 1500 83 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1500 84 . . . 13433 1501 1 The the DT 13433 1501 2 passage passage NN 13433 1501 3 , , , 13433 1501 4 however however RB 13433 1501 5 , , , 13433 1501 6 is be VBZ 13433 1501 7 a a DT 13433 1501 8 literal literal JJ 13433 1501 9 quotation quotation NN 13433 1501 10 from from IN 13433 1501 11 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1501 12 x. x. NNP 13433 1502 1 2 2 CD 13433 1502 2 - - SYM 13433 1502 3 3 3 CD 13433 1502 4 , , , 13433 1502 5 which which WDT 13433 1502 6 , , , 13433 1502 7 as as IN 13433 1502 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1502 9 have have VBP 13433 1502 10 assumed assume VBN 13433 1502 11 , , , 13433 1502 12 had have VBD 13433 1502 13 been be VBN 13433 1502 14 lost lose VBN 13433 1502 15 . . . 13433 1503 1 " " `` 13433 1503 2 Again again RB 13433 1503 3 , , , 13433 1503 4 still still RB 13433 1503 5 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1503 6 the the DT 13433 1503 7 third third JJ 13433 1503 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1503 9 no no RB 13433 1503 10 longer long RBR 13433 1503 11 extant extant JJ 13433 1503 12 , , , 13433 1503 13 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1503 14 might may MD 13433 1503 15 find find VB 13433 1503 16 the the DT 13433 1503 17 following following JJ 13433 1503 18 quotation quotation NN 13433 1503 19 in in IN 13433 1503 20 a a DT 13433 1503 21 work work NN 13433 1503 22 of of IN 13433 1503 23 the the DT 13433 1503 24 Fathers father NNS 13433 1503 25 : : : 13433 1503 26 ' ' '' 13433 1503 27 Take take VB 13433 1503 28 heed heed NN 13433 1503 29 to to IN 13433 1503 30 yourselves yourself NNS 13433 1503 31 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1503 32 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1503 33 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1503 34 : : : 13433 1503 35 eautois eautois NNP 13433 1503 36 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1503 37 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1503 38 of of IN 13433 1503 39 the the DT 13433 1503 40 leaven leaven NN 13433 1503 41 of of IN 13433 1503 42 the the DT 13433 1503 43 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 13433 1503 44 , , , 13433 1503 45 which which WDT 13433 1503 46 is be VBZ 13433 1503 47 hypocrisy hypocrisy NN 13433 1503 48 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1503 49 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1503 50 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1503 51 : : : 13433 1503 52 hêtis hêtis NNP 13433 1503 53 estin estin NNP 13433 1503 54 hupocrisis hupocrisis NNP 13433 1503 55 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1503 56 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1503 57 . . . 13433 1504 1 For for IN 13433 1504 2 there there EX 13433 1504 3 is be VBZ 13433 1504 4 nothing nothing NN 13433 1504 5 covered cover VBN 13433 1504 6 up up RP 13433 1504 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1504 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1504 9 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1504 10 : : : 13433 1504 11 sunkekalummenon sunkekalummenon NNP 13433 1504 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1504 13 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1504 14 which which WDT 13433 1504 15 shall shall MD 13433 1504 16 not not RB 13433 1504 17 be be VB 13433 1504 18 revealed reveal VBN 13433 1504 19 , , , 13433 1504 20 and and CC 13433 1504 21 hid hide VBD 13433 1504 22 , , , 13433 1504 23 which which WDT 13433 1504 24 shall shall MD 13433 1504 25 not not RB 13433 1504 26 be be VB 13433 1504 27 known know VBN 13433 1504 28 . . . 13433 1504 29 ' ' '' 13433 1505 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1505 2 would would MD 13433 1505 3 , , , 13433 1505 4 of of IN 13433 1505 5 course course NN 13433 1505 6 , , , 13433 1505 7 be be VB 13433 1505 8 affirmed affirm VBN 13433 1505 9 that that IN 13433 1505 10 this this DT 13433 1505 11 was be VBD 13433 1505 12 evidently evidently RB 13433 1505 13 a a DT 13433 1505 14 combination combination NN 13433 1505 15 of of IN 13433 1505 16 two two CD 13433 1505 17 verses verse NNS 13433 1505 18 of of IN 13433 1505 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1505 20 first first JJ 13433 1505 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1505 22 quoted quote VBD 13433 1505 23 almost almost RB 13433 1505 24 literally literally RB 13433 1505 25 , , , 13433 1505 26 with with IN 13433 1505 27 merely merely RB 13433 1505 28 a a DT 13433 1505 29 few few JJ 13433 1505 30 very very RB 13433 1505 31 immaterial immaterial JJ 13433 1505 32 slips slip NNS 13433 1505 33 of of IN 13433 1505 34 memory memory NN 13433 1505 35 in in IN 13433 1505 36 the the DT 13433 1505 37 parts part NNS 13433 1505 38 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1505 39 note note VBP 13433 1505 40 , , , 13433 1505 41 and and CC 13433 1505 42 the the DT 13433 1505 43 explanatory explanatory JJ 13433 1505 44 words word NNS 13433 1505 45 , , , 13433 1505 46 ' ' '' 13433 1505 47 which which WDT 13433 1505 48 is be VBZ 13433 1505 49 hypocrisy hypocrisy JJ 13433 1505 50 , , , 13433 1505 51 ' ' '' 13433 1505 52 introduced introduce VBN 13433 1505 53 by by IN 13433 1505 54 the the DT 13433 1505 55 Father Father NNP 13433 1505 56 , , , 13433 1505 57 and and CC 13433 1505 58 not not RB 13433 1505 59 a a DT 13433 1505 60 part part NN 13433 1505 61 of of IN 13433 1505 62 the the DT 13433 1505 63 quotation quotation NN 13433 1505 64 at at RB 13433 1505 65 all all RB 13433 1505 66 . . . 13433 1506 1 The the DT 13433 1506 2 two two CD 13433 1506 3 verses verse NNS 13433 1506 4 are be VBP 13433 1506 5 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1506 6 . . . 13433 1507 1 xvi xvi NNP 13433 1507 2 . . . 13433 1508 1 6 6 CD 13433 1508 2 , , , 13433 1508 3 ' ' `` 13433 1508 4 Beware beware VB 13433 1508 5 and and CC 13433 1508 6 take take VB 13433 1508 7 heed heed NN 13433 1508 8 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1508 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1508 10 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1508 11 : : : 13433 1508 12 hopate hopate VB 13433 1508 13 kai kai NNP 13433 1508 14 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1508 15 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1508 16 of of IN 13433 1508 17 the the DT 13433 1508 18 leaven leaven NN 13433 1508 19 of of IN 13433 1508 20 the the DT 13433 1508 21 Pharisees Pharisees NNPS 13433 1508 22 and and CC 13433 1508 23 Sadducees Sadducees NNPS 13433 1508 24 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1508 25 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1508 26 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1508 27 : : : 13433 1508 28 kai kai NNP 13433 1508 29 Saddoukaiôn Saddoukaiôn NNP 13433 1508 30 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1508 31 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1508 32 , , , 13433 1508 33 and and CC 13433 1508 34 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1508 35 . . . 13433 1509 1 x. x. NNP 13433 1510 1 26 26 CD 13433 1510 2 , , , 13433 1510 3 ' ' '' 13433 1510 4 ... ... : 13433 1510 5 for for IN 13433 1510 6 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1510 7 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1510 8 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1510 9 : : : 13433 1510 10 gar gar NNP 13433 1510 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1510 12 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1510 13 there there EX 13433 1510 14 is be VBZ 13433 1510 15 nothing nothing NN 13433 1510 16 covered cover VBN 13433 1510 17 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1510 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1510 19 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1510 20 : : : 13433 1510 21 kekalummenon kekalummenon NNP 13433 1510 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1510 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1510 24 that that WDT 13433 1510 25 shall shall MD 13433 1510 26 not not RB 13433 1510 27 be be VB 13433 1510 28 revealed reveal VBN 13433 1510 29 , , , 13433 1510 30 and and CC 13433 1510 31 hid hide VBD 13433 1510 32 , , , 13433 1510 33 that that DT 13433 1510 34 shall shall MD 13433 1510 35 not not RB 13433 1510 36 be be VB 13433 1510 37 known know VBN 13433 1510 38 . . . 13433 1510 39 ' ' '' 13433 1511 1 The the DT 13433 1511 2 sentence sentence NN 13433 1511 3 would would MD 13433 1511 4 , , , 13433 1511 5 in in IN 13433 1511 6 fact fact NN 13433 1511 7 , , , 13433 1511 8 be be VB 13433 1511 9 divided divide VBN 13433 1511 10 as as IN 13433 1511 11 in in IN 13433 1511 12 the the DT 13433 1511 13 case case NN 13433 1511 14 of of IN 13433 1511 15 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1511 16 , , , 13433 1511 17 and and CC 13433 1511 18 each each DT 13433 1511 19 part part NN 13433 1511 20 would would MD 13433 1511 21 have have VB 13433 1511 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1511 23 parallel parallel NN 13433 1511 24 pointed point VBN 13433 1511 25 out out RP 13433 1511 26 in in IN 13433 1511 27 separate separate JJ 13433 1511 28 portions portion NNS 13433 1511 29 of of IN 13433 1511 30 the the DT 13433 1511 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1511 32 . . . 13433 1512 1 How how WRB 13433 1512 2 wrong wrong JJ 13433 1512 3 such such PDT 13433 1512 4 a a DT 13433 1512 5 system system NN 13433 1512 6 is be VBZ 13433 1512 7 -- -- : 13433 1512 8 and and CC 13433 1512 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1512 10 is be VBZ 13433 1512 11 precisely precisely RB 13433 1512 12 that that IN 13433 1512 13 which which WDT 13433 1512 14 is be VBZ 13433 1512 15 adopted adopt VBN 13433 1512 16 with with IN 13433 1512 17 regard regard NN 13433 1512 18 to to IN 13433 1512 19 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1512 20 -- -- : 13433 1512 21 is be VBZ 13433 1512 22 clearly clearly RB 13433 1512 23 established establish VBN 13433 1512 24 by by IN 13433 1512 25 the the DT 13433 1512 26 fact fact NN 13433 1512 27 that that IN 13433 1512 28 the the DT 13433 1512 29 quotation quotation NN 13433 1512 30 , , , 13433 1512 31 instead instead RB 13433 1512 32 of of IN 13433 1512 33 being be VBG 13433 1512 34 such such PDT 13433 1512 35 a a DT 13433 1512 36 combination combination NN 13433 1512 37 , , , 13433 1512 38 is be VBZ 13433 1512 39 simply simply RB 13433 1512 40 taken take VBN 13433 1512 41 as as IN 13433 1512 42 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1512 43 stands stand VBZ 13433 1512 44 from from IN 13433 1512 45 the the DT 13433 1512 46 ' ' `` 13433 1512 47 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1512 48 according accord VBG 13433 1512 49 to to IN 13433 1512 50 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1512 51 , , , 13433 1512 52 ' ' '' 13433 1512 53 xii xii NNP 13433 1512 54 . . . 13433 1513 1 1 1 CD 13433 1513 2 - - SYM 13433 1513 3 2 2 CD 13433 1513 4 . . . 13433 1513 5 " " '' 13433 1514 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1514 2 133:1 133:1 LS 13433 1514 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1514 4 " " `` 13433 1514 5 If if IN 13433 1514 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1514 7 examine examine VBP 13433 1514 8 further further RB 13433 1514 9 , , , 13433 1514 10 however however RB 13433 1514 11 , , , 13433 1514 12 in in IN 13433 1514 13 the the DT 13433 1514 14 same same JJ 13433 1514 15 way way NN 13433 1514 16 , , , 13433 1514 17 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1514 18 which which WDT 13433 1514 19 differ differ VBP 13433 1514 20 merely merely RB 13433 1514 21 in in IN 13433 1514 22 language language NN 13433 1514 23 , , , 13433 1514 24 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1514 25 arrive arrive VBP 13433 1514 26 at at IN 13433 1514 27 the the DT 13433 1514 28 very very RB 13433 1514 29 same same JJ 13433 1514 30 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1514 31 . . . 13433 1515 1 Supposing suppose VBG 13433 1515 2 the the DT 13433 1515 3 third third JJ 13433 1515 4 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1515 5 to to TO 13433 1515 6 be be VB 13433 1515 7 lost lose VBN 13433 1515 8 , , , 13433 1515 9 what what WP 13433 1515 10 would would MD 13433 1515 11 be be VB 13433 1515 12 the the DT 13433 1515 13 source source NN 13433 1515 14 assigned assign VBN 13433 1515 15 to to IN 13433 1515 16 the the DT 13433 1515 17 following following JJ 13433 1515 18 quotation quotation NN 13433 1515 19 from from IN 13433 1515 20 an an DT 13433 1515 21 unnamed unnamed JJ 13433 1515 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1515 23 in in IN 13433 1515 24 the the DT 13433 1515 25 work work NN 13433 1515 26 of of IN 13433 1515 27 one one CD 13433 1515 28 of of IN 13433 1515 29 the the DT 13433 1515 30 Fathers father NNS 13433 1515 31 ? ? . 13433 1516 1 ' ' `` 13433 1516 2 No no DT 13433 1516 3 servant servant NN 13433 1516 4 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1516 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1516 6 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1516 7 : : : 13433 1516 8 oudeis oudeis NNP 13433 1516 9 oiketês oiketês NN 13433 1516 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1516 11 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1516 12 can can MD 13433 1516 13 serve serve VB 13433 1516 14 two two CD 13433 1516 15 lords lord NNS 13433 1516 16 , , , 13433 1516 17 for for IN 13433 1516 18 either either CC 13433 1516 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1516 20 will will MD 13433 1516 21 hate hate VB 13433 1516 22 the the DT 13433 1516 23 one one NN 13433 1516 24 and and CC 13433 1516 25 love love VB 13433 1516 26 the the DT 13433 1516 27 other other JJ 13433 1516 28 , , , 13433 1516 29 or or CC 13433 1516 30 else else RB 13433 1516 31 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1516 32 will will MD 13433 1516 33 hold hold VB 13433 1516 34 to to IN 13433 1516 35 the the DT 13433 1516 36 one one NN 13433 1516 37 and and CC 13433 1516 38 despise despise VB 13433 1516 39 the the DT 13433 1516 40 other other JJ 13433 1516 41 . . . 13433 1517 1 Ye Ye NNP 13433 1517 2 can can MD 13433 1517 3 not not RB 13433 1517 4 serve serve VB 13433 1517 5 God God NNP 13433 1517 6 and and CC 13433 1517 7 Mammon Mammon NNP 13433 1517 8 . . . 13433 1517 9 ' ' '' 13433 1518 1 Of of RB 13433 1518 2 course course RB 13433 1518 3 the the DT 13433 1518 4 passage passage NN 13433 1518 5 would would MD 13433 1518 6 be be VB 13433 1518 7 claimed claim VBN 13433 1518 8 as as IN 13433 1518 9 a a DT 13433 1518 10 quotation quotation NN 13433 1518 11 from from IN 13433 1518 12 memory memory NN 13433 1518 13 of of IN 13433 1518 14 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1518 15 . . . 13433 1519 1 vi vi NNP 13433 1519 2 . . . 13433 1520 1 24 24 CD 13433 1520 2 , , , 13433 1520 3 with with IN 13433 1520 4 which which WDT 13433 1520 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1520 6 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 1520 7 corresponds correspond VBZ 13433 1520 8 , , , 13433 1520 9 with with IN 13433 1520 10 the the DT 13433 1520 11 exception exception NN 13433 1520 12 of of IN 13433 1520 13 the the DT 13433 1520 14 addition addition NN 13433 1520 15 of of IN 13433 1520 16 the the DT 13433 1520 17 second second JJ 13433 1520 18 word word NN 13433 1520 19 , , , 13433 1520 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1520 21 Greek greek JJ 13433 1520 22 : : : 13433 1520 23 oiketês oiketês NN 13433 1520 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1520 25 , , , 13433 1520 26 which which WDT 13433 1520 27 , , , 13433 1520 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1520 29 would would MD 13433 1520 30 no no RB 13433 1520 31 doubt doubt RB 13433 1520 32 be be VB 13433 1520 33 argued argue VBN 13433 1520 34 , , , 13433 1520 35 is be VBZ 13433 1520 36 an an DT 13433 1520 37 evident evident JJ 13433 1520 38 and and CC 13433 1520 39 very very RB 13433 1520 40 natural natural JJ 13433 1520 41 amplification amplification NN 13433 1520 42 of of IN 13433 1520 43 the the DT 13433 1520 44 simple simple JJ 13433 1520 45 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1520 46 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1520 47 : : : 13433 1520 48 oudeis oudeis NN 13433 1520 49 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1520 50 of of IN 13433 1520 51 the the DT 13433 1520 52 first first JJ 13433 1520 53 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1520 54 . . . 13433 1521 1 Yet yet RB 13433 1521 2 this this DT 13433 1521 3 passage passage NN 13433 1521 4 , , , 13433 1521 5 only only RB 13433 1521 6 differing differ VBG 13433 1521 7 by by IN 13433 1521 8 the the DT 13433 1521 9 single single JJ 13433 1521 10 word word NN 13433 1521 11 from from IN 13433 1521 12 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1521 13 , , , 13433 1521 14 is be VBZ 13433 1521 15 a a DT 13433 1521 16 literal literal JJ 13433 1521 17 quotation quotation NN 13433 1521 18 from from IN 13433 1521 19 the the DT 13433 1521 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1521 21 according accord VBG 13433 1521 22 to to IN 13433 1521 23 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1521 24 xvi xvi NNP 13433 1521 25 . . . 13433 1522 1 13 13 CD 13433 1522 2 . . . 13433 1523 1 Or or CC 13433 1523 2 , , , 13433 1523 3 to to TO 13433 1523 4 take take VB 13433 1523 5 another another DT 13433 1523 6 instance instance NN 13433 1523 7 , , , 13433 1523 8 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1523 9 the the DT 13433 1523 10 third third JJ 13433 1523 11 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1523 12 to to TO 13433 1523 13 be be VB 13433 1523 14 lost lose VBN 13433 1523 15 , , , 13433 1523 16 and and CC 13433 1523 17 the the DT 13433 1523 18 following follow VBG 13433 1523 19 passage passage NN 13433 1523 20 quoted quote VBD 13433 1523 21 , , , 13433 1523 22 from from IN 13433 1523 23 an an DT 13433 1523 24 unnamed unnamed JJ 13433 1523 25 source source NN 13433 1523 26 , , , 13433 1523 27 by by IN 13433 1523 28 one one CD 13433 1523 29 of of IN 13433 1523 30 the the DT 13433 1523 31 Fathers father NNS 13433 1523 32 : : : 13433 1523 33 ' ' '' 13433 1523 34 Beware beware VB 13433 1523 35 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1523 36 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1523 37 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1523 38 : : : 13433 1523 39 prosechete prosechete NN 13433 1523 40 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1523 41 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1523 42 of of IN 13433 1523 43 the the DT 13433 1523 44 Scribes Scribes NNPS 13433 1523 45 , , , 13433 1523 46 which which WDT 13433 1523 47 desire desire VBP 13433 1523 48 to to TO 13433 1523 49 walk walk VB 13433 1523 50 in in IN 13433 1523 51 long long JJ 13433 1523 52 robes robe NNS 13433 1523 53 , , , 13433 1523 54 and and CC 13433 1523 55 love love NN 13433 1523 56 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1523 57 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1523 58 Greek greek JJ 13433 1523 59 : : : 13433 1523 60 philountôn philountôn NNP 13433 1523 61 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1523 62 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1523 63 greetings greeting NNS 13433 1523 64 in in IN 13433 1523 65 the the DT 13433 1523 66 markets market NNS 13433 1523 67 , , , 13433 1523 68 and and CC 13433 1523 69 chief chief JJ 13433 1523 70 seats seat NNS 13433 1523 71 in in IN 13433 1523 72 the the DT 13433 1523 73 synagogues synagogue NNS 13433 1523 74 , , , 13433 1523 75 and and CC 13433 1523 76 chief chief JJ 13433 1523 77 places place NNS 13433 1523 78 at at IN 13433 1523 79 feasts feast NNS 13433 1523 80 ; ; : 13433 1523 81 which which WDT 13433 1523 82 devour devour NN 13433 1523 83 widows widow NNS 13433 1523 84 ' ' POS 13433 1523 85 houses house NNS 13433 1523 86 , , , 13433 1523 87 and and CC 13433 1523 88 for for IN 13433 1523 89 a a DT 13433 1523 90 pretence pretence NN 13433 1523 91 make make VBP 13433 1523 92 long long JJ 13433 1523 93 prayers prayer NNS 13433 1523 94 : : : 13433 1523 95 these these DT 13433 1523 96 shall shall MD 13433 1523 97 receive receive VB 13433 1523 98 greater great JJR 13433 1523 99 damnation damnation NN 13433 1523 100 . . . 13433 1523 101 ' ' '' 13433 1524 1 This this DT 13433 1524 2 would would MD 13433 1524 3 , , , 13433 1524 4 without without IN 13433 1524 5 hesitation hesitation NN 13433 1524 6 , , , 13433 1524 7 be be VB 13433 1524 8 declared declare VBN 13433 1524 9 a a DT 13433 1524 10 quotation quotation NN 13433 1524 11 from from IN 13433 1524 12 memory memory NN 13433 1524 13 of of IN 13433 1524 14 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1524 15 xii xii NNP 13433 1524 16 . . . 13433 1525 1 38 38 CD 13433 1525 2 - - SYM 13433 1525 3 40 40 CD 13433 1525 4 , , , 13433 1525 5 from from IN 13433 1525 6 which which WDT 13433 1525 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1525 8 only only RB 13433 1525 9 differs differ VBZ 13433 1525 10 in in IN 13433 1525 11 a a DT 13433 1525 12 couple couple NN 13433 1525 13 of of IN 13433 1525 14 words word NNS 13433 1525 15 . . . 13433 1526 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1526 2 is be VBZ 13433 1526 3 , , , 13433 1526 4 however however RB 13433 1526 5 , , , 13433 1526 6 a a DT 13433 1526 7 literal literal JJ 13433 1526 8 quotation quotation NN 13433 1526 9 of of IN 13433 1526 10 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1526 11 xx xx CD 13433 1526 12 . . . 13433 1527 1 46 46 CD 13433 1527 2 - - SYM 13433 1527 3 47 47 CD 13433 1527 4 , , , 13433 1527 5 yet yet CC 13433 1527 6 probably probably RB 13433 1527 7 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1527 8 would would MD 13433 1527 9 be be VB 13433 1527 10 in in IN 13433 1527 11 vain vain JJ 13433 1527 12 to to TO 13433 1527 13 submit submit VB 13433 1527 14 to to IN 13433 1527 15 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 1527 16 critics critic NNS 13433 1527 17 that that WDT 13433 1527 18 possibly possibly RB 13433 1527 19 , , , 13433 1527 20 not not RB 13433 1527 21 to to TO 13433 1527 22 say say VB 13433 1527 23 probably probably RB 13433 1527 24 , , , 13433 1527 25 the the DT 13433 1527 26 passage passage NN 13433 1527 27 was be VBD 13433 1527 28 not not RB 13433 1527 29 derived derive VBN 13433 1527 30 from from IN 13433 1527 31 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1527 32 , , , 13433 1527 33 but but CC 13433 1527 34 from from IN 13433 1527 35 a a DT 13433 1527 36 lost lost JJ 13433 1527 37 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1527 38 . . . 13433 1528 1 To to TO 13433 1528 2 quote quote VB 13433 1528 3 one one CD 13433 1528 4 more more JJR 13433 1528 5 instance instance NN 13433 1528 6 , , , 13433 1528 7 let let VB 13433 1528 8 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1528 9 suppose suppose VB 13433 1528 10 the the DT 13433 1528 11 ' ' `` 13433 1528 12 Gospel gospel NN 13433 1528 13 according accord VBG 13433 1528 14 to to IN 13433 1528 15 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1528 16 ' ' '' 13433 1528 17 no no RB 13433 1528 18 longer long RBR 13433 1528 19 extant extant JJ 13433 1528 20 , , , 13433 1528 21 and and CC 13433 1528 22 that that IN 13433 1528 23 in in IN 13433 1528 24 some some DT 13433 1528 25 early early JJ 13433 1528 26 work work NN 13433 1528 27 there there EX 13433 1528 28 existed exist VBD 13433 1528 29 the the DT 13433 1528 30 following follow VBG 13433 1528 31 passage passage NN 13433 1528 32 : : : 13433 1528 33 ' ' `` 13433 1528 34 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1528 35 is be VBZ 13433 1528 36 easier easy JJR 13433 1528 37 for for IN 13433 1528 38 a a DT 13433 1528 39 camel camel NN 13433 1528 40 to to TO 13433 1528 41 go go VB 13433 1528 42 through through IN 13433 1528 43 the the DT 13433 1528 44 eye eye NN 13433 1528 45 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1528 46 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1528 47 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1528 48 : : : 13433 1528 49 trumalias trumalias NNP 13433 1528 50 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1528 51 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1528 52 of of IN 13433 1528 53 a a DT 13433 1528 54 needle needle NN 13433 1528 55 than than IN 13433 1528 56 for for IN 13433 1528 57 a a DT 13433 1528 58 rich rich JJ 13433 1528 59 man man NN 13433 1528 60 to to TO 13433 1528 61 enter enter VB 13433 1528 62 into into IN 13433 1528 63 the the DT 13433 1528 64 kingdom kingdom NN 13433 1528 65 of of IN 13433 1528 66 God God NNP 13433 1528 67 . . . 13433 1528 68 ' ' '' 13433 1529 1 This this DT 13433 1529 2 of of IN 13433 1529 3 course course NN 13433 1529 4 would would MD 13433 1529 5 be be VB 13433 1529 6 claimed claim VBN 13433 1529 7 as as IN 13433 1529 8 a a DT 13433 1529 9 quotation quotation NN 13433 1529 10 from from IN 13433 1529 11 memory memory NN 13433 1529 12 of of IN 13433 1529 13 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1529 14 . . . 13433 1530 1 xix xix NNP 13433 1530 2 . . . 13433 1531 1 24 24 CD 13433 1531 2 , , , 13433 1531 3 with with IN 13433 1531 4 which which WDT 13433 1531 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1531 6 agrees agree VBZ 13433 1531 7 with with IN 13433 1531 8 the the DT 13433 1531 9 exception exception NN 13433 1531 10 of of IN 13433 1531 11 the the DT 13433 1531 12 substitution substitution NN 13433 1531 13 of of IN 13433 1531 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1531 15 Greek greek JJ 13433 1531 16 : : : 13433 1531 17 trupêmatos trupêmatos NN 13433 1531 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1531 19 for for IN 13433 1531 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1531 21 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1531 22 : : : 13433 1531 23 trumalias trumalias NNP 13433 1531 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1531 25 . . . 13433 1532 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1532 2 would would MD 13433 1532 3 not not RB 13433 1532 4 the the DT 13433 1532 5 less less JJR 13433 1532 6 have have VBP 13433 1532 7 been be VBN 13433 1532 8 an an DT 13433 1532 9 exact exact JJ 13433 1532 10 quotation quotation NN 13433 1532 11 from from IN 13433 1532 12 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1532 13 x. x. NNP 13433 1533 1 25 25 CD 13433 1533 2 . . . 13433 1533 3 " " '' 13433 1534 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1534 2 134:1 134:1 LS 13433 1534 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1534 4 Illustrations illustration NNS 13433 1534 5 of of IN 13433 1534 6 this this DT 13433 1534 7 kind kind NN 13433 1534 8 could could MD 13433 1534 9 be be VB 13433 1534 10 indefinitely indefinitely RB 13433 1534 11 multiplied multiply VBN 13433 1534 12 , , , 13433 1534 13 and and CC 13433 1534 14 to to IN 13433 1534 15 anyone anyone NN 13433 1534 16 who who WP 13433 1534 17 has have VBZ 13433 1534 18 studied study VBN 13433 1534 19 the the DT 13433 1534 20 three three CD 13433 1534 21 synoptics synoptic NNS 13433 1534 22 , , , 13433 1534 23 with with IN 13433 1534 24 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1534 25 similarities similarity NNS 13433 1534 26 and and CC 13433 1534 27 variations variation NNS 13433 1534 28 , , , 13433 1534 29 and and CC 13433 1534 30 considered consider VBD 13433 1534 31 the the DT 13433 1534 32 probable probable JJ 13433 1534 33 mode mode NN 13433 1534 34 of of IN 13433 1534 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1534 36 compilation compilation NN 13433 1534 37 , , , 13433 1534 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1534 39 must must MD 13433 1534 40 be be VB 13433 1534 41 apparent apparent JJ 13433 1534 42 that that IN 13433 1534 43 , , , 13433 1534 44 with with IN 13433 1534 45 the the DT 13433 1534 46 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1534 47 that that WDT 13433 1534 48 very very RB 13433 1534 49 many many JJ 13433 1534 50 other other JJ 13433 1534 51 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1534 52 existed exist VBD 13433 1534 53 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1534 54 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1534 55 i. i. NNP 13433 1535 1 1 1 LS 13433 1535 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1535 3 , , , 13433 1535 4 which which WDT 13433 1535 5 can can MD 13433 1535 6 only only RB 13433 1535 7 very very RB 13433 1535 8 slowly slowly RB 13433 1535 9 have have VBP 13433 1535 10 disappeared disappear VBN 13433 1535 11 from from IN 13433 1535 12 circulation circulation NN 13433 1535 13 , , , 13433 1535 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1535 15 is be VBZ 13433 1535 16 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1535 17 for for IN 13433 1535 18 anyone anyone NN 13433 1535 19 with with IN 13433 1535 20 a a DT 13433 1535 21 due due JJ 13433 1535 22 appreciation appreciation NN 13433 1535 23 of of IN 13433 1535 24 the the DT 13433 1535 25 laws law NNS 13433 1535 26 of of IN 13433 1535 27 evidence evidence NN 13433 1535 28 to to TO 13433 1535 29 assert assert VB 13433 1535 30 that that IN 13433 1535 31 the the DT 13433 1535 32 use use NN 13433 1535 33 of of IN 13433 1535 34 short short JJ 13433 1535 35 passages passage NNS 13433 1535 36 similar similar JJ 13433 1535 37 to to IN 13433 1535 38 others other NNS 13433 1535 39 in in IN 13433 1535 40 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1535 41 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1535 42 actually actually RB 13433 1535 43 proves prove VBZ 13433 1535 44 that that IN 13433 1535 45 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1535 46 must must MD 13433 1535 47 have have VB 13433 1535 48 been be VBN 13433 1535 49 derived derive VBN 13433 1535 50 from from IN 13433 1535 51 these these DT 13433 1535 52 alone alone JJ 13433 1535 53 , , , 13433 1535 54 and and CC 13433 1535 55 can can MD 13433 1535 56 not not RB 13433 1535 57 have have VB 13433 1535 58 emanated emanate VBN 13433 1535 59 from from IN 13433 1535 60 any any DT 13433 1535 61 other other JJ 13433 1535 62 source source NN 13433 1535 63 . . . 13433 1536 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1536 2 is be VBZ 13433 1536 3 not not RB 13433 1536 4 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1536 5 to to TO 13433 1536 6 deny deny VB 13433 1536 7 that that IN 13433 1536 8 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1536 9 may may MD 13433 1536 10 equally equally RB 13433 1536 11 have have VB 13433 1536 12 come come VBN 13433 1536 13 from from IN 13433 1536 14 the the DT 13433 1536 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1536 16 , , , 13433 1536 17 but but CC 13433 1536 18 the the DT 13433 1536 19 inevitable inevitable JJ 13433 1536 20 decision decision NN 13433 1536 21 of of IN 13433 1536 22 a a DT 13433 1536 23 judicial judicial JJ 13433 1536 24 mind mind NN 13433 1536 25 , , , 13433 1536 26 seriously seriously RB 13433 1536 27 measuring measure VBG 13433 1536 28 evidence evidence NN 13433 1536 29 , , , 13433 1536 30 must must MD 13433 1536 31 be be VB 13433 1536 32 that that IN 13433 1536 33 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1536 34 do do VBP 13433 1536 35 not not RB 13433 1536 36 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1536 37 prove prove VB 13433 1536 38 anything anything NN 13433 1536 39 . . . 13433 1537 1 Coming come VBG 13433 1537 2 now now RB 13433 1537 3 more more RBR 13433 1537 4 directly directly RB 13433 1537 5 to to IN 13433 1537 6 the the DT 13433 1537 7 essay essay NN 13433 1537 8 on on IN 13433 1537 9 " " `` 13433 1537 10 The the DT 13433 1537 11 later later JJ 13433 1537 12 school school NN 13433 1537 13 of of IN 13433 1537 14 St. St. NNP 13433 1537 15 John John NNP 13433 1537 16 , , , 13433 1537 17 " " `` 13433 1537 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1537 19 is be VBZ 13433 1537 20 curious curious JJ 13433 1537 21 to to TO 13433 1537 22 find find VB 13433 1537 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1537 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1537 25 setting set VBG 13433 1537 26 in in IN 13433 1537 27 the the DT 13433 1537 28 very very JJ 13433 1537 29 foreground foreground NN 13433 1537 30 the the DT 13433 1537 31 account account NN 13433 1537 32 of of IN 13433 1537 33 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1537 34 's 's POS 13433 1537 35 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1537 36 , , , 13433 1537 37 without without IN 13433 1537 38 a a DT 13433 1537 39 single single JJ 13433 1537 40 word word NN 13433 1537 41 regarding regard VBG 13433 1537 42 the the DT 13433 1537 43 more more JJR 13433 1537 44 than than IN 13433 1537 45 suspicious suspicious JJ 13433 1537 46 character character NN 13433 1537 47 of of IN 13433 1537 48 the the DT 13433 1537 49 document document NN 13433 1537 50 , , , 13433 1537 51 except except IN 13433 1537 52 the the DT 13433 1537 53 remark remark NN 13433 1537 54 in in IN 13433 1537 55 a a DT 13433 1537 56 note note NN 13433 1537 57 that that IN 13433 1537 58 " " `` 13433 1537 59 the the DT 13433 1537 60 objections objection NNS 13433 1537 61 which which WDT 13433 1537 62 have have VBP 13433 1537 63 been be VBN 13433 1537 64 urged urge VBN 13433 1537 65 against against IN 13433 1537 66 this this DT 13433 1537 67 narrative narrative NN 13433 1537 68 are be VBP 13433 1537 69 not not RB 13433 1537 70 serious serious JJ 13433 1537 71 . . . 13433 1537 72 " " '' 13433 1538 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1538 2 135:1 135:1 LS 13433 1538 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1538 4 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1538 5 have have VBP 13433 1538 6 been be VBN 13433 1538 7 considered consider VBN 13433 1538 8 so so RB 13433 1538 9 by by IN 13433 1538 10 men man NNS 13433 1538 11 like like IN 13433 1538 12 Keim Keim NNP 13433 1538 13 , , , 13433 1538 14 Schürer Schürer NNP 13433 1538 15 , , , 13433 1538 16 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 1538 17 , , , 13433 1538 18 and and CC 13433 1538 19 Holtzmann Holtzmann NNP 13433 1538 20 . . . 13433 1539 1 The the DT 13433 1539 2 account account NN 13433 1539 3 has have VBZ 13433 1539 4 too too RB 13433 1539 5 much much JJ 13433 1539 6 need need NN 13433 1539 7 to to TO 13433 1539 8 be be VB 13433 1539 9 propped prop VBN 13433 1539 10 up up RP 13433 1539 11 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1539 12 to to TO 13433 1539 13 be be VB 13433 1539 14 of of IN 13433 1539 15 much much JJ 13433 1539 16 use use NN 13433 1539 17 as as IN 13433 1539 18 a a DT 13433 1539 19 prop prop NN 13433 1539 20 for for IN 13433 1539 21 the the DT 13433 1539 22 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1539 23 . . . 13433 1540 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1540 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1540 3 points point VBZ 13433 1540 4 out out RP 13433 1540 5 that that IN 13433 1540 6 an an DT 13433 1540 7 " " `` 13433 1540 8 idea idea NN 13433 1540 9 of of IN 13433 1540 10 literal literal JJ 13433 1540 11 conformity conformity NN 13433 1540 12 to to IN 13433 1540 13 the the DT 13433 1540 14 life life NN 13433 1540 15 and and CC 13433 1540 16 Passion passion NN 13433 1540 17 of of IN 13433 1540 18 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1540 19 runs run VBZ 13433 1540 20 through through IN 13433 1540 21 the the DT 13433 1540 22 document document NN 13433 1540 23 , , , 13433 1540 24 " " '' 13433 1540 25 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1540 26 135:2 135:2 CD 13433 1540 27 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1540 28 and and CC 13433 1540 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1540 30 is be VBZ 13433 1540 31 chiefly chiefly RB 13433 1540 32 on on IN 13433 1540 33 the the DT 13433 1540 34 fact fact NN 13433 1540 35 that that IN 13433 1540 36 " " `` 13433 1540 37 most most JJS 13433 1540 38 of of IN 13433 1540 39 the the DT 13433 1540 40 incidents incident NNS 13433 1540 41 have have VBP 13433 1540 42 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1540 43 counterparts counterpart NNS 13433 1540 44 in in IN 13433 1540 45 the the DT 13433 1540 46 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1540 47 of of IN 13433 1540 48 the the DT 13433 1540 49 Passion Passion NNP 13433 1540 50 , , , 13433 1540 51 as as IN 13433 1540 52 recorded record VBN 13433 1540 53 by by IN 13433 1540 54 the the DT 13433 1540 55 synoptic synoptic JJ 13433 1540 56 evangelists evangelist NNS 13433 1540 57 alone alone RB 13433 1540 58 or or CC 13433 1540 59 in in IN 13433 1540 60 common common JJ 13433 1540 61 with with IN 13433 1540 62 St. St. NNP 13433 1540 63 John John NNP 13433 1540 64 , , , 13433 1540 65 " " `` 13433 1540 66 that that IN 13433 1540 67 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1540 68 relies rely VBZ 13433 1540 69 , , , 13433 1540 70 in in IN 13433 1540 71 referring refer VBG 13433 1540 72 to to IN 13433 1540 73 the the DT 13433 1540 74 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1540 75 . . . 13433 1541 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1541 2 need need VBP 13433 1541 3 scarcely scarcely RB 13433 1541 4 reply reply VB 13433 1541 5 that that IN 13433 1541 6 not not RB 13433 1541 7 only only RB 13433 1541 8 , , , 13433 1541 9 on on IN 13433 1541 10 account account NN 13433 1541 11 of of IN 13433 1541 12 the the DT 13433 1541 13 very very RB 13433 1541 14 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1541 15 character character NN 13433 1541 16 of of IN 13433 1541 17 the the DT 13433 1541 18 document document NN 13433 1541 19 , , , 13433 1541 20 is be VBZ 13433 1541 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1541 22 useless useless JJ 13433 1541 23 to to IN 13433 1541 24 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1541 25 as as IN 13433 1541 26 evidence evidence NN 13433 1541 27 , , , 13433 1541 28 but but CC 13433 1541 29 because because IN 13433 1541 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1541 31 does do VBZ 13433 1541 32 not not RB 13433 1541 33 name name VB 13433 1541 34 a a DT 13433 1541 35 single single JJ 13433 1541 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1541 37 , , , 13433 1541 38 much much RB 13433 1541 39 less less RBR 13433 1541 40 add add VB 13433 1541 41 anything anything NN 13433 1541 42 to to IN 13433 1541 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1541 44 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1541 45 of of IN 13433 1541 46 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1541 47 authorship authorship NN 13433 1541 48 and and CC 13433 1541 49 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 13433 1541 50 . . . 13433 1542 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1542 2 shall shall MD 13433 1542 3 have have VB 13433 1542 4 more more JJR 13433 1542 5 to to TO 13433 1542 6 say say VB 13433 1542 7 regarding regard VBG 13433 1542 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1542 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1542 10 in in IN 13433 1542 11 connection connection NN 13433 1542 12 with with IN 13433 1542 13 this this DT 13433 1542 14 document document NN 13433 1542 15 further further RB 13433 1542 16 on on RB 13433 1542 17 . . . 13433 1543 1 The the DT 13433 1543 2 same same JJ 13433 1543 3 remark remark NN 13433 1543 4 applies apply VBZ 13433 1543 5 to to IN 13433 1543 6 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1543 7 of of IN 13433 1543 8 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 1543 9 . . . 13433 1544 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1544 2 have have VBP 13433 1544 3 fully fully RB 13433 1544 4 discussed discuss VBN 13433 1544 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1544 6 135:3 135:3 LS 13433 1544 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1544 8 the the DT 13433 1544 9 evidence evidence NN 13433 1544 10 which which WDT 13433 1544 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1544 12 is be VBZ 13433 1544 13 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1544 14 to to TO 13433 1544 15 contribute contribute VB 13433 1544 16 , , , 13433 1544 17 and and CC 13433 1544 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1544 19 is be VBZ 13433 1544 20 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 1544 21 for for IN 13433 1544 22 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1544 23 to to TO 13433 1544 24 enter enter VB 13433 1544 25 into into IN 13433 1544 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1544 27 at at IN 13433 1544 28 any any DT 13433 1544 29 length length NN 13433 1544 30 here here RB 13433 1544 31 , , , 13433 1544 32 more more RBR 13433 1544 33 especially especially RB 13433 1544 34 as as IN 13433 1544 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1544 36 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1544 37 does do VBZ 13433 1544 38 not not RB 13433 1544 39 advance advance VB 13433 1544 40 any any DT 13433 1544 41 new new JJ 13433 1544 42 argument argument NN 13433 1544 43 . . . 13433 1545 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1545 2 has have VBZ 13433 1545 3 said say VBN 13433 1545 4 nothing nothing NN 13433 1545 5 which which WDT 13433 1545 6 materially materially RB 13433 1545 7 alters alter VBZ 13433 1545 8 the the DT 13433 1545 9 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1545 10 position position NN 13433 1545 11 of of IN 13433 1545 12 many many JJ 13433 1545 13 of of IN 13433 1545 14 the the DT 13433 1545 15 fragments fragment NNS 13433 1545 16 attributed attribute VBN 13433 1545 17 to to IN 13433 1545 18 this this DT 13433 1545 19 Father Father NNP 13433 1545 20 . . . 13433 1546 1 In in IN 13433 1546 2 any any DT 13433 1546 3 case case NN 13433 1546 4 the the DT 13433 1546 5 use use NN 13433 1546 6 which which WDT 13433 1546 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1546 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1546 9 chiefly chiefly RB 13433 1546 10 makes make VBZ 13433 1546 11 of of IN 13433 1546 12 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1546 13 as as IN 13433 1546 14 a a DT 13433 1546 15 witness witness NN 13433 1546 16 is be VBZ 13433 1546 17 to to TO 13433 1546 18 show show VB 13433 1546 19 that that IN 13433 1546 20 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1546 21 exhibits exhibit VBZ 13433 1546 22 full full JJ 13433 1546 23 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1546 24 of of IN 13433 1546 25 the the DT 13433 1546 26 details detail NNS 13433 1546 27 of of IN 13433 1546 28 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 1546 29 history history NN 13433 1546 30 as as IN 13433 1546 31 contained contain VBN 13433 1546 32 in in IN 13433 1546 33 the the DT 13433 1546 34 four four CD 13433 1546 35 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1546 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1546 37 . . . 13433 1547 1 Waiving waive VBG 13433 1547 2 all all DT 13433 1547 3 discussion discussion NN 13433 1547 4 of of IN 13433 1547 5 the the DT 13433 1547 6 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1547 7 of of IN 13433 1547 8 the the DT 13433 1547 9 fragments fragment NNS 13433 1547 10 , , , 13433 1547 11 and and CC 13433 1547 12 accepting accept VBG 13433 1547 13 , , , 13433 1547 14 for for IN 13433 1547 15 the the DT 13433 1547 16 sake sake NN 13433 1547 17 of of IN 13433 1547 18 argument argument NN 13433 1547 19 , , , 13433 1547 20 the the DT 13433 1547 21 asserted assert VBN 13433 1547 22 acquaintance acquaintance NN 13433 1547 23 with with IN 13433 1547 24 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 1547 25 history history NN 13433 1547 26 which which WDT 13433 1547 27 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1547 28 display display VBP 13433 1547 29 , , , 13433 1547 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1547 31 simply simply RB 13433 1547 32 enquire enquire VBP 13433 1547 33 what what WP 13433 1547 34 this this DT 13433 1547 35 proves prove VBZ 13433 1547 36 ? ? . 13433 1548 1 Does do VBZ 13433 1548 2 anyone anyone NN 13433 1548 3 doubt doubt VB 13433 1548 4 that that IN 13433 1548 5 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1548 6 of of IN 13433 1548 7 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 1548 8 , , , 13433 1548 9 in in IN 13433 1548 10 the the DT 13433 1548 11 last last JJ 13433 1548 12 third third NN 13433 1548 13 of of IN 13433 1548 14 the the DT 13433 1548 15 second second JJ 13433 1548 16 century century NN 13433 1548 17 , , , 13433 1548 18 must must MD 13433 1548 19 have have VB 13433 1548 20 been be VBN 13433 1548 21 thoroughly thoroughly RB 13433 1548 22 versed verse VBN 13433 1548 23 in in IN 13433 1548 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1548 25 history history NN 13433 1548 26 , , , 13433 1548 27 or or CC 13433 1548 28 deny deny VB 13433 1548 29 that that IN 13433 1548 30 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1548 31 might may MD 13433 1548 32 have have VB 13433 1548 33 possessed possess VBN 13433 1548 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1548 35 four four CD 13433 1548 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1548 37 ? ? . 13433 1549 1 The the DT 13433 1549 2 only only JJ 13433 1549 3 thing thing NN 13433 1549 4 which which WDT 13433 1549 5 is be VBZ 13433 1549 6 lacking lack VBG 13433 1549 7 is be VBZ 13433 1549 8 actual actual JJ 13433 1549 9 proof proof NN 13433 1549 10 of of IN 13433 1549 11 the the DT 13433 1549 12 fact fact NN 13433 1549 13 . . . 13433 1550 1 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1550 2 does do VBZ 13433 1550 3 not not RB 13433 1550 4 refer refer VB 13433 1550 5 to to IN 13433 1550 6 a a DT 13433 1550 7 single single JJ 13433 1550 8 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1550 9 by by IN 13433 1550 10 name name NN 13433 1550 11 . . . 13433 1551 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1551 2 does do VBZ 13433 1551 3 not not RB 13433 1551 4 add add VB 13433 1551 5 one one CD 13433 1551 6 word word NN 13433 1551 7 or or CC 13433 1551 8 one one CD 13433 1551 9 fact fact NN 13433 1551 10 to to IN 13433 1551 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1551 12 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1551 13 of of IN 13433 1551 14 the the DT 13433 1551 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1551 16 or or CC 13433 1551 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1551 18 composers composer NNS 13433 1551 19 . . . 13433 1552 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1552 2 does do VBZ 13433 1552 3 not not RB 13433 1552 4 , , , 13433 1552 5 indeed indeed RB 13433 1552 6 , , , 13433 1552 7 mention mention VB 13433 1552 8 any any DT 13433 1552 9 writing writing NN 13433 1552 10 of of IN 13433 1552 11 the the DT 13433 1552 12 New New NNP 13433 1552 13 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1552 14 . . . 13433 1553 1 If if IN 13433 1553 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1553 3 words word NNS 13433 1553 4 regarding regard VBG 13433 1553 5 the the DT 13433 1553 6 " " `` 13433 1553 7 Books book NNS 13433 1553 8 of of IN 13433 1553 9 the the DT 13433 1553 10 Old Old NNP 13433 1553 11 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1553 12 " " `` 13433 1553 13 imply imply VBP 13433 1553 14 " " '' 13433 1553 15 a a DT 13433 1553 16 corresponding corresponding JJ 13433 1553 17 Christian christian JJ 13433 1553 18 literature literature NN 13433 1553 19 which which WDT 13433 1553 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1553 21 regarded regard VBD 13433 1553 22 as as IN 13433 1553 23 the the DT 13433 1553 24 books book NNS 13433 1553 25 of of IN 13433 1553 26 the the DT 13433 1553 27 New New NNP 13433 1553 28 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1553 29 , , , 13433 1553 30 " " '' 13433 1553 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1553 32 136:1 136:1 CD 13433 1553 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1553 34 which which WDT 13433 1553 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1553 36 deny deny VBP 13433 1553 37 , , , 13433 1553 38 what what WP 13433 1553 39 is be VBZ 13433 1553 40 gained gain VBN 13433 1553 41 ? ? . 13433 1554 1 Even even RB 13433 1554 2 in in IN 13433 1554 3 that that DT 13433 1554 4 case case NN 13433 1554 5 " " `` 13433 1554 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1554 7 can can MD 13433 1554 8 not not RB 13433 1554 9 , , , 13433 1554 10 " " '' 13433 1554 11 as as IN 13433 1554 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1554 13 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 1554 14 frankly frankly RB 13433 1554 15 states state VBZ 13433 1554 16 , , , 13433 1554 17 " " `` 13433 1554 18 infer infer VBP 13433 1554 19 the the DT 13433 1554 20 names name NNS 13433 1554 21 or or CC 13433 1554 22 the the DT 13433 1554 23 exact exact JJ 13433 1554 24 number number NN 13433 1554 25 of of IN 13433 1554 26 those those DT 13433 1554 27 books book NNS 13433 1554 28 . . . 13433 1554 29 " " '' 13433 1555 1 As as IN 13433 1555 2 for for IN 13433 1555 3 adding add VBG 13433 1555 4 anything anything NN 13433 1555 5 to to IN 13433 1555 6 the the DT 13433 1555 7 credibility credibility NN 13433 1555 8 of of IN 13433 1555 9 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1555 10 , , , 13433 1555 11 such such PDT 13433 1555 12 an an DT 13433 1555 13 idea idea NN 13433 1555 14 is be VBZ 13433 1555 15 not not RB 13433 1555 16 even even RB 13433 1555 17 broached broach VBN 13433 1555 18 by by IN 13433 1555 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1555 20 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1555 21 , , , 13433 1555 22 and and CC 13433 1555 23 yet yet RB 13433 1555 24 if if IN 13433 1555 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1555 26 can can MD 13433 1555 27 not not RB 13433 1555 28 do do VB 13433 1555 29 this this DT 13433 1555 30 the the DT 13433 1555 31 only only JJ 13433 1555 32 purpose purpose NN 13433 1555 33 for for IN 13433 1555 34 which which WDT 13433 1555 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1555 36 testimony testimony NN 13433 1555 37 is be VBZ 13433 1555 38 examined examine VBN 13433 1555 39 is be VBZ 13433 1555 40 gone go VBN 13433 1555 41 . . . 13433 1556 1 The the DT 13433 1556 2 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1556 3 display display NN 13433 1556 4 of of IN 13433 1556 5 vehemence vehemence NN 13433 1556 6 in in IN 13433 1556 7 discussing discuss VBG 13433 1556 8 the the DT 13433 1556 9 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1556 10 of of IN 13433 1556 11 fragments fragment NNS 13433 1556 12 of of IN 13433 1556 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1556 14 writings writing NNS 13433 1556 15 merely merely RB 13433 1556 16 distracts distract VBZ 13433 1556 17 the the DT 13433 1556 18 attention attention NN 13433 1556 19 of of IN 13433 1556 20 the the DT 13433 1556 21 reader reader NN 13433 1556 22 from from IN 13433 1556 23 the the DT 13433 1556 24 true true JJ 13433 1556 25 issue issue NN 13433 1556 26 if if IN 13433 1556 27 , , , 13433 1556 28 when when WRB 13433 1556 29 to to IN 13433 1556 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1556 31 own own JJ 13433 1556 32 satisfaction satisfaction NN 13433 1556 33 , , , 13433 1556 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1556 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1556 36 can can MD 13433 1556 37 not not RB 13433 1556 38 turn turn VB 13433 1556 39 the the DT 13433 1556 40 evidence evidence NN 13433 1556 41 of of IN 13433 1556 42 Melito Melito NNP 13433 1556 43 to to IN 13433 1556 44 greater great JJR 13433 1556 45 account account NN 13433 1556 46 . . . 13433 1557 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1557 2 136:2 136:2 CD 13433 1557 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1557 4 Nor nor CC 13433 1557 5 is be VBZ 13433 1557 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1557 7 much much RB 13433 1557 8 more more RBR 13433 1557 9 fortunate fortunate JJ 13433 1557 10 in in IN 13433 1557 11 the the DT 13433 1557 12 case case NN 13433 1557 13 of of IN 13433 1557 14 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 1557 15 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 1557 16 , , , 13433 1557 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1557 18 137:1 137:1 LS 13433 1557 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1557 20 whose whose WP$ 13433 1557 21 " " `` 13433 1557 22 Apology Apology NNP 13433 1557 23 " " '' 13433 1557 24 may may MD 13433 1557 25 be be VB 13433 1557 26 dated date VBN 13433 1557 27 about about IN 13433 1557 28 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1557 29 177 177 CD 13433 1557 30 - - SYM 13433 1557 31 180 180 CD 13433 1557 32 . . . 13433 1558 1 In in IN 13433 1558 2 an an DT 13433 1558 3 extract extract NN 13433 1558 4 preserved preserve VBN 13433 1558 5 in in IN 13433 1558 6 the the DT 13433 1558 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1558 8 Paschal Paschal NNP 13433 1558 9 Chronicle Chronicle NNP 13433 1558 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1558 11 , , , 13433 1558 12 regarding regard VBG 13433 1558 13 the the DT 13433 1558 14 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 1558 15 of of IN 13433 1558 16 which which WDT 13433 1558 17 all all DT 13433 1558 18 discussion discussion NN 13433 1558 19 may may MD 13433 1558 20 , , , 13433 1558 21 for for IN 13433 1558 22 the the DT 13433 1558 23 sake sake NN 13433 1558 24 of of IN 13433 1558 25 argument argument NN 13433 1558 26 , , , 13433 1558 27 be be VB 13433 1558 28 waived waive VBN 13433 1558 29 here here RB 13433 1558 30 , , , 13433 1558 31 the the DT 13433 1558 32 writer writer NN 13433 1558 33 in in IN 13433 1558 34 connection connection NN 13433 1558 35 with with IN 13433 1558 36 the the DT 13433 1558 37 Paschal Paschal NNP 13433 1558 38 Festival Festival NNP 13433 1558 39 says say VBZ 13433 1558 40 that that IN 13433 1558 41 " " `` 13433 1558 42 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1558 43 affirm affirm VBP 13433 1558 44 that that IN 13433 1558 45 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1558 46 represents represent VBZ 13433 1558 47 " " `` 13433 1558 48 one one CD 13433 1558 49 thing thing NN 13433 1558 50 " " '' 13433 1558 51 and and CC 13433 1558 52 , , , 13433 1558 53 on on IN 13433 1558 54 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1558 55 showing showing NN 13433 1558 56 , , , 13433 1558 57 the the DT 13433 1558 58 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1558 59 seem seem VBP 13433 1558 60 to to TO 13433 1558 61 be be VB 13433 1558 62 at at IN 13433 1558 63 variance variance NN 13433 1558 64 with with IN 13433 1558 65 one one CD 13433 1558 66 another another DT 13433 1558 67 . . . 13433 1558 68 " " '' 13433 1559 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1559 2 137:2 137:2 LS 13433 1559 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1559 4 If if IN 13433 1559 5 , , , 13433 1559 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 1559 7 , , , 13433 1559 8 the the DT 13433 1559 9 passage passage NN 13433 1559 10 be be VB 13433 1559 11 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1559 12 , , , 13433 1559 13 the the DT 13433 1559 14 writer writer NN 13433 1559 15 seems seem VBZ 13433 1559 16 to to TO 13433 1559 17 refer refer VB 13433 1559 18 to to IN 13433 1559 19 the the DT 13433 1559 20 first first JJ 13433 1559 21 synoptic synoptic NNP 13433 1559 22 , , , 13433 1559 23 and and CC 13433 1559 24 by by IN 13433 1559 25 inference inference NN 13433 1559 26 to to IN 13433 1559 27 the the DT 13433 1559 28 fourth fourth JJ 13433 1559 29 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1559 30 . . . 13433 1560 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1560 2 says say VBZ 13433 1560 3 nothing nothing NN 13433 1560 4 of of IN 13433 1560 5 the the DT 13433 1560 6 composition composition NN 13433 1560 7 of of IN 13433 1560 8 these these DT 13433 1560 9 works work NNS 13433 1560 10 , , , 13433 1560 11 and and CC 13433 1560 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1560 13 does do VBZ 13433 1560 14 nothing nothing NN 13433 1560 15 more more JJR 13433 1560 16 than than IN 13433 1560 17 merely merely RB 13433 1560 18 show show VB 13433 1560 19 that that IN 13433 1560 20 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1560 21 were be VBD 13433 1560 22 accepted accept VBN 13433 1560 23 in in IN 13433 1560 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1560 25 time time NN 13433 1560 26 . . . 13433 1561 1 This this DT 13433 1561 2 may may MD 13433 1561 3 seem seem VB 13433 1561 4 a a DT 13433 1561 5 good good JJ 13433 1561 6 deal deal NN 13433 1561 7 when when WRB 13433 1561 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1561 9 consider consider VBP 13433 1561 10 how how WRB 13433 1561 11 very very RB 13433 1561 12 few few JJ 13433 1561 13 of of IN 13433 1561 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1561 15 contemporaries contemporary NNS 13433 1561 16 do do VBP 13433 1561 17 as as RB 13433 1561 18 much much JJ 13433 1561 19 , , , 13433 1561 20 but but CC 13433 1561 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1561 22 really really RB 13433 1561 23 contributes contribute VBZ 13433 1561 24 nothing nothing NN 13433 1561 25 to to IN 13433 1561 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1561 27 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1561 28 of of IN 13433 1561 29 the the DT 13433 1561 30 authors author NNS 13433 1561 31 , , , 13433 1561 32 and and CC 13433 1561 33 does do VBZ 13433 1561 34 not not RB 13433 1561 35 add add VB 13433 1561 36 a a DT 13433 1561 37 jot jot NN 13433 1561 38 to to IN 13433 1561 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1561 40 credibility credibility NN 13433 1561 41 as as IN 13433 1561 42 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1561 43 for for IN 13433 1561 44 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1561 45 and and CC 13433 1561 46 the the DT 13433 1561 47 reality reality NN 13433 1561 48 of of IN 13433 1561 49 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1561 50 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1561 51 . . . 13433 1562 1 With with IN 13433 1562 2 regard regard NN 13433 1562 3 to to IN 13433 1562 4 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 13433 1562 5 of of IN 13433 1562 6 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 1562 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1562 8 need need VBP 13433 1562 9 say say VB 13433 1562 10 very very RB 13433 1562 11 little little JJ 13433 1562 12 . . . 13433 1563 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1563 2 preserves preserve VBZ 13433 1563 3 a a DT 13433 1563 4 passage passage NN 13433 1563 5 from from IN 13433 1563 6 a a DT 13433 1563 7 letter letter NN 13433 1563 8 which which WDT 13433 1563 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1563 10 wrote write VBD 13433 1563 11 " " `` 13433 1563 12 in in IN 13433 1563 13 the the DT 13433 1563 14 closing closing NN 13433 1563 15 years year NNS 13433 1563 16 of of IN 13433 1563 17 the the DT 13433 1563 18 second second JJ 13433 1563 19 century century NN 13433 1563 20 , , , 13433 1563 21 " " '' 13433 1563 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1563 23 137:3 137:3 CD 13433 1563 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1563 25 when when WRB 13433 1563 26 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1563 27 of of IN 13433 1563 28 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1563 29 attempted attempt VBD 13433 1563 30 to to TO 13433 1563 31 force force VB 13433 1563 32 the the DT 13433 1563 33 Western western JJ 13433 1563 34 usage usage NN 13433 1563 35 with with IN 13433 1563 36 respect respect NN 13433 1563 37 to to IN 13433 1563 38 Easter Easter NNP 13433 1563 39 on on IN 13433 1563 40 the the DT 13433 1563 41 Asiatic asiatic JJ 13433 1563 42 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1563 43 . . . 13433 1564 1 In in IN 13433 1564 2 this this DT 13433 1564 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1564 4 uses use VBZ 13433 1564 5 the the DT 13433 1564 6 expression expression NN 13433 1564 7 " " `` 13433 1564 8 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1564 9 that that WDT 13433 1564 10 leaned lean VBD 13433 1564 11 on on IN 13433 1564 12 the the DT 13433 1564 13 bosom bosom NN 13433 1564 14 of of IN 13433 1564 15 the the DT 13433 1564 16 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1564 17 , , , 13433 1564 18 " " '' 13433 1564 19 which which WDT 13433 1564 20 occurs occur VBZ 13433 1564 21 in in IN 13433 1564 22 the the DT 13433 1564 23 fourth fourth JJ 13433 1564 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1564 25 . . . 13433 1565 1 Nothing nothing NN 13433 1565 2 could could MD 13433 1565 3 more more RBR 13433 1565 4 forcibly forcibly RB 13433 1565 5 show show VB 13433 1565 6 the the DT 13433 1565 7 meagreness meagreness NN 13433 1565 8 of of IN 13433 1565 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1565 10 information information NN 13433 1565 11 regarding regard VBG 13433 1565 12 the the DT 13433 1565 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1565 14 than than IN 13433 1565 15 that that DT 13433 1565 16 such such PDT 13433 1565 17 a a DT 13433 1565 18 phrase phrase NN 13433 1565 19 is be VBZ 13433 1565 20 considered consider VBN 13433 1565 21 of of IN 13433 1565 22 value value NN 13433 1565 23 as as IN 13433 1565 24 evidence evidence NN 13433 1565 25 for for IN 13433 1565 26 one one CD 13433 1565 27 of of IN 13433 1565 28 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1565 29 . . . 13433 1566 1 In in IN 13433 1566 2 fact fact NN 13433 1566 3 the the DT 13433 1566 4 slightness slightness NN 13433 1566 5 of of IN 13433 1566 6 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1566 7 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1566 8 of of IN 13433 1566 9 these these DT 13433 1566 10 works work NNS 13433 1566 11 is be VBZ 13433 1566 12 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 1566 13 astounding astounding JJ 13433 1566 14 when when WRB 13433 1566 15 the the DT 13433 1566 16 importance importance NN 13433 1566 17 which which WDT 13433 1566 18 is be VBZ 13433 1566 19 attached attach VBN 13433 1566 20 to to IN 13433 1566 21 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1566 22 is be VBZ 13433 1566 23 taken take VBN 13433 1566 24 into into IN 13433 1566 25 account account NN 13433 1566 26 . . . 13433 1567 1 VI VI NNP 13433 1567 2 . . . 13433 1568 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1568 2 THE the DT 13433 1568 3 CHURCHES CHURCHES NNP 13433 1568 4 OF of IN 13433 1568 5 GAUL GAUL NNP 13433 1568 6 . . . 13433 1568 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1568 8 A a DT 13433 1568 9 severe severe JJ 13433 1568 10 persecution persecution NN 13433 1568 11 broke break VBD 13433 1568 12 out out RP 13433 1568 13 in in IN 13433 1568 14 the the DT 13433 1568 15 year year NN 13433 1568 16 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1568 17 177 177 CD 13433 1568 18 , , , 13433 1568 19 under under IN 13433 1568 20 Marcus Marcus NNP 13433 1568 21 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 13433 1568 22 , , , 13433 1568 23 in in IN 13433 1568 24 the the DT 13433 1568 25 cities city NNS 13433 1568 26 of of IN 13433 1568 27 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 1568 28 and and CC 13433 1568 29 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 1568 30 , , , 13433 1568 31 on on IN 13433 1568 32 the the DT 13433 1568 33 Rhone Rhone NNP 13433 1568 34 , , , 13433 1568 35 and and CC 13433 1568 36 an an DT 13433 1568 37 account account NN 13433 1568 38 of of IN 13433 1568 39 the the DT 13433 1568 40 martyrdoms martyrdom NNS 13433 1568 41 which which WDT 13433 1568 42 then then RB 13433 1568 43 took take VBD 13433 1568 44 place place NN 13433 1568 45 was be VBD 13433 1568 46 given give VBN 13433 1568 47 in in IN 13433 1568 48 a a DT 13433 1568 49 letter letter NN 13433 1568 50 from from IN 13433 1568 51 the the DT 13433 1568 52 persecuted persecute VBN 13433 1568 53 communities community NNS 13433 1568 54 , , , 13433 1568 55 addressed address VBD 13433 1568 56 " " `` 13433 1568 57 to to IN 13433 1568 58 the the DT 13433 1568 59 brethren brother NNS 13433 1568 60 that that WDT 13433 1568 61 are be VBP 13433 1568 62 in in IN 13433 1568 63 Asia Asia NNP 13433 1568 64 and and CC 13433 1568 65 Phrygia Phrygia NNP 13433 1568 66 . . . 13433 1568 67 " " '' 13433 1569 1 This this DT 13433 1569 2 epistle epistle NN 13433 1569 3 is be VBZ 13433 1569 4 in in IN 13433 1569 5 great great JJ 13433 1569 6 part part NN 13433 1569 7 preserved preserve VBN 13433 1569 8 to to IN 13433 1569 9 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1569 10 by by IN 13433 1569 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1569 12 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1569 13 _ _ NNP 13433 1569 14 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 1569 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1569 16 v. v. IN 13433 1569 17 1 1 CD 13433 1569 18 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1569 19 , , , 13433 1569 20 and and CC 13433 1569 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1569 22 is be VBZ 13433 1569 23 to to IN 13433 1569 24 a a DT 13433 1569 25 consideration consideration NN 13433 1569 26 of of IN 13433 1569 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1569 28 contents content NNS 13433 1569 29 that that WDT 13433 1569 30 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1569 31 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1569 32 devotes devote VBZ 13433 1569 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1569 34 essay essay NN 13433 1569 35 on on IN 13433 1569 36 the the DT 13433 1569 37 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1569 38 of of IN 13433 1569 39 Gaul Gaul NNP 13433 1569 40 . . . 13433 1570 1 But but CC 13433 1570 2 for for IN 13433 1570 3 the the DT 13433 1570 4 sake sake NN 13433 1570 5 of of IN 13433 1570 6 ascertaining ascertain VBG 13433 1570 7 clearly clearly RB 13433 1570 8 what what WDT 13433 1570 9 evidence evidence NN 13433 1570 10 actually actually RB 13433 1570 11 exists exist VBZ 13433 1570 12 of of IN 13433 1570 13 the the DT 13433 1570 14 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1570 15 , , , 13433 1570 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1570 17 would would MD 13433 1570 18 have have VB 13433 1570 19 been be VBN 13433 1570 20 of of IN 13433 1570 21 little little JJ 13433 1570 22 utility utility NN 13433 1570 23 to to TO 13433 1570 24 extend extend VB 13433 1570 25 the the DT 13433 1570 26 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 1570 27 in in IN 13433 1570 28 _ _ NNP 13433 1570 29 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1570 30 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1570 31 _ _ NNP 13433 1570 32 to to IN 13433 1570 33 this this DT 13433 1570 34 document document NN 13433 1570 35 , , , 13433 1570 36 written write VBN 13433 1570 37 nearly nearly RB 13433 1570 38 a a DT 13433 1570 39 century century NN 13433 1570 40 and and CC 13433 1570 41 a a DT 13433 1570 42 half half NN 13433 1570 43 after after IN 13433 1570 44 the the DT 13433 1570 45 death death NN 13433 1570 46 of of IN 13433 1570 47 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1570 48 , , , 13433 1570 49 but but CC 13433 1570 50 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1570 51 is be VBZ 13433 1570 52 instructive instructive JJ 13433 1570 53 to to TO 13433 1570 54 show show VB 13433 1570 55 how how WRB 13433 1570 56 exceedingly exceedingly RB 13433 1570 57 slight slight JJ 13433 1570 58 is be VBZ 13433 1570 59 the the DT 13433 1570 60 information information NN 13433 1570 61 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1570 62 possess possess VBP 13433 1570 63 regarding regard VBG 13433 1570 64 those those DT 13433 1570 65 documents document NNS 13433 1570 66 . . . 13433 1571 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1571 2 may may MD 13433 1571 3 at at IN 13433 1571 4 once once RB 13433 1571 5 say say VB 13433 1571 6 that that IN 13433 1571 7 no no DT 13433 1571 8 writing writing NN 13433 1571 9 of of IN 13433 1571 10 the the DT 13433 1571 11 New New NNP 13433 1571 12 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1571 13 is be VBZ 13433 1571 14 directly directly RB 13433 1571 15 referred refer VBN 13433 1571 16 to to IN 13433 1571 17 by by IN 13433 1571 18 name name NN 13433 1571 19 in in IN 13433 1571 20 this this DT 13433 1571 21 epistle epistle NN 13433 1571 22 , , , 13433 1571 23 and and CC 13433 1571 24 consequently consequently RB 13433 1571 25 any any DT 13433 1571 26 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1571 27 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1571 28 are be VBP 13433 1571 29 merely merely RB 13433 1571 30 inferred infer VBN 13433 1571 31 to to TO 13433 1571 32 be be VB 13433 1571 33 such such JJ 13433 1571 34 by by IN 13433 1571 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1571 36 similarity similarity NN 13433 1571 37 to to IN 13433 1571 38 passages passage NNS 13433 1571 39 found find VBN 13433 1571 40 in in IN 13433 1571 41 these these DT 13433 1571 42 writings writing NNS 13433 1571 43 . . . 13433 1572 1 With with IN 13433 1572 2 the the DT 13433 1572 3 complete complete JJ 13433 1572 4 unconsciousness unconsciousness NN 13433 1572 5 which which WDT 13433 1572 6 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1572 7 have have VBP 13433 1572 8 pointed point VBN 13433 1572 9 out out RP 13433 1572 10 that that IN 13433 1572 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1572 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1572 13 affects affect VBZ 13433 1572 14 regarding regard VBG 13433 1572 15 the the DT 13433 1572 16 object object NN 13433 1572 17 and and CC 13433 1572 18 requirements requirement NNS 13433 1572 19 of of IN 13433 1572 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1572 21 argument argument NN 13433 1572 22 , , , 13433 1572 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1572 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1572 25 is be VBZ 13433 1572 26 , , , 13433 1572 27 of of IN 13433 1572 28 course course NN 13433 1572 29 , , , 13433 1572 30 indignant indignant JJ 13433 1572 31 that that IN 13433 1572 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1572 33 will will MD 13433 1572 34 not not RB 13433 1572 35 accept accept VB 13433 1572 36 as as IN 13433 1572 37 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 1572 38 evidence evidence NN 13433 1572 39 the the DT 13433 1572 40 imperfect imperfect JJ 13433 1572 41 coincidences coincidence NNS 13433 1572 42 which which WDT 13433 1572 43 alone alone RB 13433 1572 44 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1572 45 is be VBZ 13433 1572 46 able able JJ 13433 1572 47 to to TO 13433 1572 48 bring bring VB 13433 1572 49 forward forward RB 13433 1572 50 . . . 13433 1573 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1573 2 have have VBP 13433 1573 3 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 1573 4 fully fully RB 13433 1573 5 discussed discuss VBN 13433 1573 6 these these DT 13433 1573 7 , , , 13433 1573 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1573 9 140:1 140:1 CD 13433 1573 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1573 11 and and CC 13433 1573 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1573 13 need need VBP 13433 1573 14 only only RB 13433 1573 15 refer refer VB 13433 1573 16 to to IN 13433 1573 17 some some DT 13433 1573 18 portions portion NNS 13433 1573 19 of of IN 13433 1573 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1573 21 essay essay NN 13433 1573 22 here here RB 13433 1573 23 . . . 13433 1574 1 " " `` 13433 1574 2 Of of IN 13433 1574 3 Vettius Vettius NNP 13433 1574 4 Epagathus Epagathus NNP 13433 1574 5 , , , 13433 1574 6 one one CD 13433 1574 7 of of IN 13433 1574 8 the the DT 13433 1574 9 sufferers sufferer NNS 13433 1574 10 , , , 13433 1574 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1574 12 are be VBP 13433 1574 13 told tell VBN 13433 1574 14 that that IN 13433 1574 15 , , , 13433 1574 16 though though IN 13433 1574 17 young young JJ 13433 1574 18 ; ; : 13433 1574 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1574 20 ' ' `` 13433 1574 21 rivalled rival VBD 13433 1574 22 the the DT 13433 1574 23 testimony testimony NN 13433 1574 24 borne borne VB 13433 1574 25 to to IN 13433 1574 26 the the DT 13433 1574 27 elder eld JJR 13433 1574 28 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1574 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1574 30 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1574 31 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1574 32 : : : 13433 1574 33 sunexisousthai sunexisousthai NNP 13433 1574 34 tê tê NNP 13433 1574 35 tou tou NNP 13433 1574 36 presbuterou presbuterou NNP 13433 1574 37 Zacharious Zacharious NNP 13433 1574 38 marturia marturia NNP 13433 1574 39 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1574 40 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1574 41 , , , 13433 1574 42 for for IN 13433 1574 43 verily verily RB 13433 1574 44 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1574 45 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1574 46 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1574 47 : : : 13433 1574 48 goun goun NN 13433 1574 49 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1574 50 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1574 51 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1574 52 had have VBD 13433 1574 53 _ _ NNP 13433 1574 54 walked walk VBD 13433 1574 55 in in IN 13433 1574 56 all all PDT 13433 1574 57 the the DT 13433 1574 58 commandments commandment NNS 13433 1574 59 and and CC 13433 1574 60 ordinances ordinance NNS 13433 1574 61 of of IN 13433 1574 62 the the DT 13433 1574 63 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1574 64 blameless blameless NN 13433 1574 65 _ _ NNP 13433 1574 66 . . . 13433 1574 67 ' ' '' 13433 1575 1 Here here RB 13433 1575 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1575 3 have have VBP 13433 1575 4 the the DT 13433 1575 5 same same JJ 13433 1575 6 words word NNS 13433 1575 7 , , , 13433 1575 8 and and CC 13433 1575 9 in in IN 13433 1575 10 the the DT 13433 1575 11 same same JJ 13433 1575 12 order order NN 13433 1575 13 , , , 13433 1575 14 which which WDT 13433 1575 15 are be VBP 13433 1575 16 used use VBN 13433 1575 17 of of IN 13433 1575 18 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1575 19 and and CC 13433 1575 20 Elizabeth Elizabeth NNP 13433 1575 21 in in IN 13433 1575 22 St. St. NNP 13433 1575 23 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1575 24 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1575 25 i. i. NNP 13433 1576 1 6 6 LS 13433 1576 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1576 3 : : : 13433 1576 4 ' ' '' 13433 1576 5 and and CC 13433 1576 6 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1576 7 , , , 13433 1576 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1576 9 father father NN 13433 1576 10 , , , 13433 1576 11 was be VBD 13433 1576 12 filled fill VBN 13433 1576 13 with with IN 13433 1576 14 the the DT 13433 1576 15 Holy Holy NNP 13433 1576 16 Ghost Ghost NNP 13433 1576 17 . . . 13433 1576 18 ' ' '' 13433 1576 19 " " '' 13433 1577 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1577 2 140:2 140:2 CD 13433 1577 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1577 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1577 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1577 6 very very RB 13433 1577 7 properly properly RB 13433 1577 8 dwells dwell VBZ 13433 1577 9 on on IN 13433 1577 10 the the DT 13433 1577 11 meaning meaning NN 13433 1577 12 of of IN 13433 1577 13 the the DT 13433 1577 14 expression expression NN 13433 1577 15 " " `` 13433 1577 16 the the DT 13433 1577 17 testimony testimony NN 13433 1577 18 of of IN 13433 1577 19 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1577 20 " " '' 13433 1577 21 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1577 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1577 23 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1577 24 : : : 13433 1577 25 tê tê DT 13433 1577 26 Zachariou Zachariou NNP 13433 1577 27 marturia marturia NN 13433 1577 28 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1577 29 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1577 30 , , , 13433 1577 31 which which WDT 13433 1577 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1577 33 points point VBZ 13433 1577 34 out out RP 13433 1577 35 " " `` 13433 1577 36 might may MD 13433 1577 37 signify signify VB 13433 1577 38 either either CC 13433 1577 39 ' ' `` 13433 1577 40 the the DT 13433 1577 41 testimony testimony NN 13433 1577 42 borne bear VBN 13433 1577 43 to to IN 13433 1577 44 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1577 45 , , , 13433 1577 46 ' ' '' 13433 1577 47 _ _ NNP 13433 1577 48 i.e. i.e. FW 13433 1577 49 _ _ NNP 13433 1577 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1577 51 recorded record VBN 13433 1577 52 character character NN 13433 1577 53 , , , 13433 1577 54 or or CC 13433 1577 55 ' ' `` 13433 1577 56 the the DT 13433 1577 57 testimony testimony NN 13433 1577 58 borne bear VBN 13433 1577 59 by by IN 13433 1577 60 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1577 61 , , , 13433 1577 62 ' ' '' 13433 1577 63 _ _ NNP 13433 1577 64 i.e. i.e. FW 13433 1577 65 _ _ NNP 13433 1577 66 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1577 67 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1577 68 . . . 13433 1577 69 " " '' 13433 1578 1 By by IN 13433 1578 2 a a DT 13433 1578 3 vexatious vexatious JJ 13433 1578 4 mistake mistake NN 13433 1578 5 in in IN 13433 1578 6 reprinting reprinting NN 13433 1578 7 , , , 13433 1578 8 " " '' 13433 1578 9 to to TO 13433 1578 10 " " `` 13433 1578 11 was be VBD 13433 1578 12 accidentally accidentally RB 13433 1578 13 substituted substitute VBN 13433 1578 14 for for IN 13433 1578 15 " " `` 13433 1578 16 by by IN 13433 1578 17 " " '' 13433 1578 18 in in IN 13433 1578 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1578 20 translation translation NN 13433 1578 21 of of IN 13433 1578 22 this this DT 13433 1578 23 passage passage NN 13433 1578 24 in in IN 13433 1578 25 a a DT 13433 1578 26 very very RB 13433 1578 27 few few JJ 13433 1578 28 of of IN 13433 1578 29 the the DT 13433 1578 30 earlier early JJR 13433 1578 31 copies copy NNS 13433 1578 32 of of IN 13433 1578 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1578 34 sixth sixth JJ 13433 1578 35 edition edition NN 13433 1578 36 , , , 13433 1578 37 but but CC 13433 1578 38 the the DT 13433 1578 39 error error NN 13433 1578 40 was be VBD 13433 1578 41 almost almost RB 13433 1578 42 immediately immediately RB 13433 1578 43 observed observe VBN 13433 1578 44 and and CC 13433 1578 45 corrected correct VBN 13433 1578 46 in in IN 13433 1578 47 the the DT 13433 1578 48 rest rest NN 13433 1578 49 of of IN 13433 1578 50 the the DT 13433 1578 51 edition edition NN 13433 1578 52 . . . 13433 1579 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1579 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1579 3 seizes seize VBZ 13433 1579 4 upon upon IN 13433 1579 5 the the DT 13433 1579 6 " " `` 13433 1579 7 to to TO 13433 1579 8 " " '' 13433 1579 9 in in IN 13433 1579 10 the the DT 13433 1579 11 early early JJ 13433 1579 12 copy copy NN 13433 1579 13 which which WDT 13433 1579 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1579 15 had have VBD 13433 1579 16 sent send VBN 13433 1579 17 to to IN 13433 1579 18 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1579 19 , , , 13433 1579 20 and and CC 13433 1579 21 argues argue VBZ 13433 1579 22 upon upon IN 13433 1579 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1579 24 as as IN 13433 1579 25 a a DT 13433 1579 26 deliberate deliberate JJ 13433 1579 27 adoption adoption NN 13433 1579 28 of of IN 13433 1579 29 the the DT 13433 1579 30 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 1579 31 , , , 13433 1579 32 whilst whilst IN 13433 1579 33 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1579 34 takes take VBZ 13433 1579 35 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1579 36 to to IN 13433 1579 37 task task NN 13433 1579 38 for for IN 13433 1579 39 actually actually RB 13433 1579 40 arguing argue VBG 13433 1579 41 upon upon IN 13433 1579 42 the the DT 13433 1579 43 rendering rendering NN 13433 1579 44 " " '' 13433 1579 45 by by IN 13433 1579 46 " " '' 13433 1579 47 in in IN 13433 1579 48 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1579 49 text text NN 13433 1579 50 . . . 13433 1580 1 Very very RB 13433 1580 2 naturally naturally RB 13433 1580 3 a a DT 13433 1580 4 printer printer NN 13433 1580 5 's 's POS 13433 1580 6 error error NN 13433 1580 7 could could MD 13433 1580 8 not not RB 13433 1580 9 extend extend VB 13433 1580 10 to to IN 13433 1580 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1580 12 argument argument NN 13433 1580 13 . . . 13433 1581 1 The the DT 13433 1581 2 following follow VBG 13433 1581 3 is be VBZ 13433 1581 4 what what WP 13433 1581 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1581 6 say say VBP 13433 1581 7 regarding regard VBG 13433 1581 8 the the DT 13433 1581 9 passage passage NN 13433 1581 10 in in IN 13433 1581 11 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1581 12 complete complete JJ 13433 1581 13 edition edition NN 13433 1581 14 : : : 13433 1581 15 " " `` 13433 1581 16 The the DT 13433 1581 17 epistle epistle NN 13433 1581 18 is be VBZ 13433 1581 19 an an DT 13433 1581 20 account account NN 13433 1581 21 of of IN 13433 1581 22 the the DT 13433 1581 23 persecution persecution NN 13433 1581 24 of of IN 13433 1581 25 the the DT 13433 1581 26 Christian christian JJ 13433 1581 27 community community NN 13433 1581 28 of of IN 13433 1581 29 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 1581 30 and and CC 13433 1581 31 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 1581 32 , , , 13433 1581 33 and and CC 13433 1581 34 Vettius Vettius NNP 13433 1581 35 Epagathus Epagathus NNP 13433 1581 36 is be VBZ 13433 1581 37 the the DT 13433 1581 38 first first JJ 13433 1581 39 of of IN 13433 1581 40 the the DT 13433 1581 41 martyrs martyr NNS 13433 1581 42 who who WP 13433 1581 43 is be VBZ 13433 1581 44 named name VBN 13433 1581 45 in in IN 13433 1581 46 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1581 47 : : : 13433 1581 48 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1581 49 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1581 50 : : : 13433 1581 51 marturia marturia NNP 13433 1581 52 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1581 53 was be VBD 13433 1581 54 at at IN 13433 1581 55 that that DT 13433 1581 56 time time NN 13433 1581 57 the the DT 13433 1581 58 term term NN 13433 1581 59 used use VBN 13433 1581 60 to to TO 13433 1581 61 express express VB 13433 1581 62 the the DT 13433 1581 63 supreme supreme NNP 13433 1581 64 testimony testimony NNP 13433 1581 65 of of IN 13433 1581 66 Christians-- Christians-- NNP 13433 1581 67 martyrdom martyrdom NNP 13433 1581 68 -- -- : 13433 1581 69 and and CC 13433 1581 70 the the DT 13433 1581 71 epistle epistle NN 13433 1581 72 seems seem VBZ 13433 1581 73 here here RB 13433 1581 74 simply simply RB 13433 1581 75 to to TO 13433 1581 76 refer refer VB 13433 1581 77 to to IN 13433 1581 78 the the DT 13433 1581 79 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1581 80 , , , 13433 1581 81 the the DT 13433 1581 82 honour honour NN 13433 1581 83 of of IN 13433 1581 84 which which WDT 13433 1581 85 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1581 86 shared share VBD 13433 1581 87 with with IN 13433 1581 88 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1581 89 . . . 13433 1582 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1582 2 is be VBZ 13433 1582 3 , , , 13433 1582 4 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1582 5 think think VBP 13433 1582 6 , , , 13433 1582 7 highly highly RB 13433 1582 8 improbable improbable JJ 13433 1582 9 that that IN 13433 1582 10 , , , 13433 1582 11 under under IN 13433 1582 12 such such JJ 13433 1582 13 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1582 14 , , , 13433 1582 15 the the DT 13433 1582 16 word word NN 13433 1582 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1582 18 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1582 19 : : : 13433 1582 20 marturia marturia NNP 13433 1582 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1582 22 would would MD 13433 1582 23 have have VB 13433 1582 24 been be VBN 13433 1582 25 used use VBN 13433 1582 26 to to TO 13433 1582 27 express express VB 13433 1582 28 a a DT 13433 1582 29 mere mere JJ 13433 1582 30 description description NN 13433 1582 31 of of IN 13433 1582 32 the the DT 13433 1582 33 character character NN 13433 1582 34 of of IN 13433 1582 35 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1582 36 given give VBN 13433 1582 37 by by IN 13433 1582 38 some some DT 13433 1582 39 other other JJ 13433 1582 40 writer writer NN 13433 1582 41 . . . 13433 1582 42 " " '' 13433 1583 1 This this DT 13433 1583 2 is be VBZ 13433 1583 3 the the DT 13433 1583 4 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 1583 5 which which WDT 13433 1583 6 is be VBZ 13433 1583 7 adopted adopt VBN 13433 1583 8 by by IN 13433 1583 9 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 1583 10 , , , 13433 1583 11 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1583 12 , , , 13433 1583 13 and and CC 13433 1583 14 many many JJ 13433 1583 15 eminent eminent JJ 13433 1583 16 critics critic NNS 13433 1583 17 . . . 13433 1584 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1584 2 will will MD 13433 1584 3 be be VB 13433 1584 4 observed observe VBN 13433 1584 5 that that IN 13433 1584 6 the the DT 13433 1584 7 saying saying NN 13433 1584 8 that that IN 13433 1584 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1584 10 had have VBD 13433 1584 11 " " `` 13433 1584 12 walked walk VBD 13433 1584 13 in in IN 13433 1584 14 all all PDT 13433 1584 15 the the DT 13433 1584 16 commandments commandment NNS 13433 1584 17 and and CC 13433 1584 18 ordinances ordinance NNS 13433 1584 19 of of IN 13433 1584 20 the the DT 13433 1584 21 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1584 22 blameless blameless NN 13433 1584 23 , , , 13433 1584 24 " " '' 13433 1584 25 which which WDT 13433 1584 26 is be VBZ 13433 1584 27 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1584 28 to to TO 13433 1584 29 be be VB 13433 1584 30 taken take VBN 13433 1584 31 from from IN 13433 1584 32 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1584 33 i. i. NNP 13433 1585 1 6 6 CD 13433 1585 2 , , , 13433 1585 3 is be VBZ 13433 1585 4 there there EX 13433 1585 5 applied apply VBN 13433 1585 6 to to IN 13433 1585 7 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1585 8 and and CC 13433 1585 9 Elizabeth Elizabeth NNP 13433 1585 10 , , , 13433 1585 11 the the DT 13433 1585 12 father father NN 13433 1585 13 and and CC 13433 1585 14 mother mother NN 13433 1585 15 of of IN 13433 1585 16 John John NNP 13433 1585 17 the the DT 13433 1585 18 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 1585 19 , , , 13433 1585 20 but but CC 13433 1585 21 the the DT 13433 1585 22 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1585 23 does do VBZ 13433 1585 24 not not RB 13433 1585 25 say say VB 13433 1585 26 anything anything NN 13433 1585 27 of of IN 13433 1585 28 this this DT 13433 1585 29 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1585 30 having have VBG 13433 1585 31 suffered suffer VBN 13433 1585 32 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1585 33 . . . 13433 1586 1 The the DT 13433 1586 2 allusion allusion NN 13433 1586 3 in in IN 13433 1586 4 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1586 5 xi xi NNP 13433 1586 6 . . . 13433 1587 1 51 51 CD 13433 1587 2 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1587 3 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1587 4 . . . 13433 1588 1 xxiii xxiii NNP 13433 1588 2 . . . 13433 1589 1 35 35 LS 13433 1589 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1589 3 is be VBZ 13433 1589 4 almost almost RB 13433 1589 5 universally universally RB 13433 1589 6 admitted admit VBN 13433 1589 7 to to TO 13433 1589 8 be be VB 13433 1589 9 to to IN 13433 1589 10 another another DT 13433 1589 11 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1589 12 , , , 13433 1589 13 whose whose WP$ 13433 1589 14 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1589 15 is be VBZ 13433 1589 16 related relate VBN 13433 1589 17 in in IN 13433 1589 18 2 2 CD 13433 1589 19 Chron Chron NNP 13433 1589 20 . . . 13433 1590 1 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 1590 2 . . . 13433 1591 1 21 21 CD 13433 1591 2 . . . 13433 1592 1 " " `` 13433 1592 2 Since since IN 13433 1592 3 the the DT 13433 1592 4 epistle epistle NN 13433 1592 5 , , , 13433 1592 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 1592 7 , , , 13433 1592 8 refers refer VBZ 13433 1592 9 to to IN 13433 1592 10 the the DT 13433 1592 11 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1592 12 of of IN 13433 1592 13 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1592 14 , , , 13433 1592 15 the the DT 13433 1592 16 father father NN 13433 1592 17 of of IN 13433 1592 18 John John NNP 13433 1592 19 the the DT 13433 1592 20 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 1592 21 , , , 13433 1592 22 when when WRB 13433 1592 23 using use VBG 13433 1592 24 the the DT 13433 1592 25 expressions expression NNS 13433 1592 26 which which WDT 13433 1592 27 are be VBP 13433 1592 28 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1592 29 to to TO 13433 1592 30 be be VB 13433 1592 31 taken take VBN 13433 1592 32 from from IN 13433 1592 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1592 34 third third JJ 13433 1592 35 synoptic synoptic NNP 13433 1592 36 , , , 13433 1592 37 is be VBZ 13433 1592 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1592 39 not not RB 13433 1592 40 reasonable reasonable JJ 13433 1592 41 to to TO 13433 1592 42 suppose suppose VB 13433 1592 43 that that IN 13433 1592 44 those those DT 13433 1592 45 expressions expression NNS 13433 1592 46 were be VBD 13433 1592 47 derived derive VBN 13433 1592 48 from from IN 13433 1592 49 some some DT 13433 1592 50 work work NN 13433 1592 51 which which WDT 13433 1592 52 likewise likewise RB 13433 1592 53 contained contain VBD 13433 1592 54 an an DT 13433 1592 55 account account NN 13433 1592 56 of of IN 13433 1592 57 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1592 58 death death NN 13433 1592 59 , , , 13433 1592 60 which which WDT 13433 1592 61 is be VBZ 13433 1592 62 not not RB 13433 1592 63 found find VBN 13433 1592 64 in in IN 13433 1592 65 the the DT 13433 1592 66 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1592 67 ? ? . 13433 1593 1 When when WRB 13433 1593 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1593 3 examine examine VBP 13433 1593 4 the the DT 13433 1593 5 matter matter NN 13433 1593 6 more more RBR 13433 1593 7 closely closely RB 13433 1593 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1593 9 find find VBP 13433 1593 10 that that IN 13433 1593 11 , , , 13433 1593 12 although although IN 13433 1593 13 none none NN 13433 1593 14 of of IN 13433 1593 15 the the DT 13433 1593 16 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1593 17 gospels gospel NNS 13433 1593 18 except except IN 13433 1593 19 the the DT 13433 1593 20 third third JJ 13433 1593 21 gives give VBZ 13433 1593 22 any any DT 13433 1593 23 narrative narrative NN 13433 1593 24 of of IN 13433 1593 25 the the DT 13433 1593 26 birth birth NN 13433 1593 27 of of IN 13433 1593 28 John John NNP 13433 1593 29 the the DT 13433 1593 30 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 1593 31 , , , 13433 1593 32 that that DT 13433 1593 33 portion portion NN 13433 1593 34 of of IN 13433 1593 35 the the DT 13433 1593 36 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1593 37 in in IN 13433 1593 38 which which WDT 13433 1593 39 are be VBP 13433 1593 40 the the DT 13433 1593 41 words word NNS 13433 1593 42 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1593 43 are be VBP 13433 1593 44 discussing discuss VBG 13433 1593 45 can can MD 13433 1593 46 not not RB 13433 1593 47 be be VB 13433 1593 48 considered consider VBN 13433 1593 49 an an DT 13433 1593 50 original original JJ 13433 1593 51 production production NN 13433 1593 52 by by IN 13433 1593 53 the the DT 13433 1593 54 third third JJ 13433 1593 55 Synoptist Synoptist NNP 13433 1593 56 , , , 13433 1593 57 but but CC 13433 1593 58 , , , 13433 1593 59 like like IN 13433 1593 60 the the DT 13433 1593 61 rest rest NN 13433 1593 62 of of IN 13433 1593 63 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1593 64 work work NN 13433 1593 65 , , , 13433 1593 66 is be VBZ 13433 1593 67 merely merely RB 13433 1593 68 a a DT 13433 1593 69 composition composition NN 13433 1593 70 based base VBN 13433 1593 71 upon upon IN 13433 1593 72 earlier early RBR 13433 1593 73 written write VBN 13433 1593 74 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1593 75 . . . 13433 1594 1 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 1594 2 , , , 13433 1594 3 for for IN 13433 1594 4 instance instance NN 13433 1594 5 , , , 13433 1594 6 assigns assign VBZ 13433 1594 7 the the DT 13433 1594 8 whole whole NN 13433 1594 9 of of IN 13433 1594 10 the the DT 13433 1594 11 first first JJ 13433 1594 12 chapters chapter NNS 13433 1594 13 of of IN 13433 1594 14 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1594 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1594 16 i. i. NNP 13433 1595 1 5-ii 5-ii LS 13433 1595 2 . . . 13433 1596 1 40 40 LS 13433 1596 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1596 3 to to IN 13433 1596 4 what what WP 13433 1596 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1596 6 terms term VBZ 13433 1596 7 ' ' POS 13433 1596 8 the the DT 13433 1596 9 eighth eighth JJ 13433 1596 10 recognisable recognisable JJ 13433 1596 11 book book NN 13433 1596 12 . . . 13433 1596 13 ' ' '' 13433 1596 14 " " '' 13433 1597 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1597 2 141:1 141:1 LS 13433 1597 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1597 4 No no DT 13433 1597 5 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 1597 6 critic critic NN 13433 1597 7 pretends pretend NNS 13433 1597 8 that that IN 13433 1597 9 the the DT 13433 1597 10 author author NN 13433 1597 11 of of IN 13433 1597 12 the the DT 13433 1597 13 third third JJ 13433 1597 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1597 15 can can MD 13433 1597 16 have have VB 13433 1597 17 written write VBN 13433 1597 18 this this DT 13433 1597 19 account account NN 13433 1597 20 from from IN 13433 1597 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1597 22 own own JJ 13433 1597 23 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1597 24 or or CC 13433 1597 25 observation observation NN 13433 1597 26 . . . 13433 1598 1 Where where WRB 13433 1598 2 , , , 13433 1598 3 then then RB 13433 1598 4 , , , 13433 1598 5 did do VBD 13433 1598 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1598 7 get get VB 13433 1598 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1598 9 information information NN 13433 1598 10 ? ? . 13433 1599 1 Surely surely RB 13433 1599 2 not not RB 13433 1599 3 from from IN 13433 1599 4 oral oral JJ 13433 1599 5 tradition tradition NN 13433 1599 6 limited limit VBN 13433 1599 7 to to IN 13433 1599 8 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1599 9 . . . 13433 1600 1 The the DT 13433 1600 2 whole whole JJ 13433 1600 3 character character NN 13433 1600 4 of of IN 13433 1600 5 the the DT 13433 1600 6 narrative narrative NN 13433 1600 7 , , , 13433 1600 8 even even RB 13433 1600 9 apart apart RB 13433 1600 10 from from IN 13433 1600 11 the the DT 13433 1600 12 prologue prologue NN 13433 1600 13 to to IN 13433 1600 14 the the DT 13433 1600 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1600 16 , , , 13433 1600 17 and and CC 13433 1600 18 the the DT 13433 1600 19 composition composition NN 13433 1600 20 of of IN 13433 1600 21 the the DT 13433 1600 22 rest rest NN 13433 1600 23 of of IN 13433 1600 24 the the DT 13433 1600 25 work work NN 13433 1600 26 , , , 13433 1600 27 would would MD 13433 1600 28 lead lead VB 13433 1600 29 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1600 30 to to TO 13433 1600 31 infer infer VB 13433 1600 32 a a DT 13433 1600 33 written write VBN 13433 1600 34 source source NN 13433 1600 35 . . . 13433 1601 1 " " `` 13433 1601 2 The the DT 13433 1601 3 fact fact NN 13433 1601 4 that that IN 13433 1601 5 other other JJ 13433 1601 6 works work NNS 13433 1601 7 existed exist VBD 13433 1601 8 at at IN 13433 1601 9 an an DT 13433 1601 10 earlier early JJR 13433 1601 11 period period NN 13433 1601 12 in in IN 13433 1601 13 which which WDT 13433 1601 14 the the DT 13433 1601 15 history history NN 13433 1601 16 of of IN 13433 1601 17 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1601 18 , , , 13433 1601 19 the the DT 13433 1601 20 father father NN 13433 1601 21 of of IN 13433 1601 22 the the DT 13433 1601 23 Baptist Baptist NNP 13433 1601 24 , , , 13433 1601 25 was be VBD 13433 1601 26 given give VBN 13433 1601 27 , , , 13433 1601 28 and and CC 13433 1601 29 in in IN 13433 1601 30 which which WDT 13433 1601 31 not not RB 13433 1601 32 only only RB 13433 1601 33 the the DT 13433 1601 34 words word NNS 13433 1601 35 used use VBN 13433 1601 36 in in IN 13433 1601 37 the the DT 13433 1601 38 epistle epistle NN 13433 1601 39 were be VBD 13433 1601 40 found find VBN 13433 1601 41 , , , 13433 1601 42 but but CC 13433 1601 43 also also RB 13433 1601 44 the the DT 13433 1601 45 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1601 46 , , , 13433 1601 47 is be VBZ 13433 1601 48 in in IN 13433 1601 49 the the DT 13433 1601 50 highest high JJS 13433 1601 51 degree degree NN 13433 1601 52 probable probable JJ 13433 1601 53 , , , 13433 1601 54 and and CC 13433 1601 55 , , , 13433 1601 56 so so RB 13433 1601 57 far far RB 13433 1601 58 as as IN 13433 1601 59 the the DT 13433 1601 60 history history NN 13433 1601 61 is be VBZ 13433 1601 62 concerned concern VBN 13433 1601 63 , , , 13433 1601 64 this this DT 13433 1601 65 is be VBZ 13433 1601 66 placed place VBN 13433 1601 67 almost almost RB 13433 1601 68 beyond beyond IN 13433 1601 69 doubt doubt NN 13433 1601 70 by by IN 13433 1601 71 the the DT 13433 1601 72 ' ' `` 13433 1601 73 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 13433 1601 74 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 13433 1601 75 , , , 13433 1601 76 ' ' '' 13433 1601 77 which which WDT 13433 1601 78 contains contain VBZ 13433 1601 79 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1601 80 . . . 13433 1602 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 1602 2 , , , 13433 1602 3 who who WP 13433 1602 4 does do VBZ 13433 1602 5 not not RB 13433 1602 6 make make VB 13433 1602 7 use use NN 13433 1602 8 of of IN 13433 1602 9 this this DT 13433 1602 10 epistle epistle NN 13433 1602 11 at at RB 13433 1602 12 all all RB 13433 1602 13 as as IN 13433 1602 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 1602 15 for for IN 13433 1602 16 the the DT 13433 1602 17 Scriptures scripture NNS 13433 1602 18 of of IN 13433 1602 19 the the DT 13433 1602 20 New New NNP 13433 1602 21 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1602 22 , , , 13433 1602 23 does do VBZ 13433 1602 24 refer refer VB 13433 1602 25 to to IN 13433 1602 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1602 27 , , , 13433 1602 28 and and CC 13433 1602 29 to to IN 13433 1602 30 this this DT 13433 1602 31 very very JJ 13433 1602 32 allusion allusion NN 13433 1602 33 in in IN 13433 1602 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1602 35 to to IN 13433 1602 36 the the DT 13433 1602 37 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1602 38 of of IN 13433 1602 39 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1602 40 , , , 13433 1602 41 as as IN 13433 1602 42 testimony testimony NN 13433 1602 43 to to IN 13433 1602 44 the the DT 13433 1602 45 existence existence NN 13433 1602 46 and and CC 13433 1602 47 use use NN 13433 1602 48 of of IN 13433 1602 49 the the DT 13433 1602 50 ' ' `` 13433 1602 51 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 13433 1602 52 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 13433 1602 53 , , , 13433 1602 54 ' ' '' 13433 1602 55 a a DT 13433 1602 56 work work NN 13433 1602 57 whose whose WP$ 13433 1602 58 origin origin NN 13433 1602 59 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1602 60 dates date VBZ 13433 1602 61 so so RB 13433 1602 62 far far RB 13433 1602 63 back back RB 13433 1602 64 as as IN 13433 1602 65 the the DT 13433 1602 66 first first JJ 13433 1602 67 three three CD 13433 1602 68 decades decade NNS 13433 1602 69 of of IN 13433 1602 70 the the DT 13433 1602 71 second second JJ 13433 1602 72 century century NN 13433 1602 73 , , , 13433 1602 74 and and CC 13433 1602 75 which which WDT 13433 1602 76 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1602 77 considers consider VBZ 13433 1602 78 was be VBD 13433 1602 79 also also RB 13433 1602 80 used use VBN 13433 1602 81 by by IN 13433 1602 82 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1602 83 , , , 13433 1602 84 as as IN 13433 1602 85 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1602 86 had have VBD 13433 1602 87 already already RB 13433 1602 88 observed observe VBN 13433 1602 89 . . . 13433 1603 1 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 1603 2 and and CC 13433 1603 3 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1603 4 , , , 13433 1603 5 therefore therefore RB 13433 1603 6 , , , 13433 1603 7 agree agree VBP 13433 1603 8 in in IN 13433 1603 9 affirming affirm VBG 13433 1603 10 that that IN 13433 1603 11 the the DT 13433 1603 12 reference reference NN 13433 1603 13 to to IN 13433 1603 14 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 1603 15 which which WDT 13433 1603 16 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1603 17 have have VBP 13433 1603 18 quoted quote VBN 13433 1603 19 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 1603 20 acquaintance acquaintance NN 13433 1603 21 with with IN 13433 1603 22 a a DT 13433 1603 23 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1603 24 different different JJ 13433 1603 25 from from IN 13433 1603 26 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1603 27 third third JJ 13433 1603 28 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1603 29 . . . 13433 1603 30 " " '' 13433 1604 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1604 2 142:1 142:1 LS 13433 1604 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1604 4 Such such JJ 13433 1604 5 being be VBG 13433 1604 6 the the DT 13433 1604 7 state state NN 13433 1604 8 of of IN 13433 1604 9 the the DT 13433 1604 10 case case NN 13433 1604 11 , , , 13433 1604 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1604 13 would would MD 13433 1604 14 ask ask VB 13433 1604 15 any any DT 13433 1604 16 impartial impartial JJ 13433 1604 17 reader reader NN 13433 1604 18 whether whether IN 13433 1604 19 there there EX 13433 1604 20 is be VBZ 13433 1604 21 any any DT 13433 1604 22 evidence evidence NN 13433 1604 23 here here RB 13433 1604 24 that that IN 13433 1604 25 these these DT 13433 1604 26 few few JJ 13433 1604 27 words word NNS 13433 1604 28 , , , 13433 1604 29 introduced introduce VBN 13433 1604 30 without without IN 13433 1604 31 the the DT 13433 1604 32 slightest slight JJS 13433 1604 33 indication indication NN 13433 1604 34 of of IN 13433 1604 35 the the DT 13433 1604 36 source source NN 13433 1604 37 from from IN 13433 1604 38 which which WDT 13433 1604 39 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1604 40 were be VBD 13433 1604 41 derived derive VBN 13433 1604 42 , , , 13433 1604 43 must must MD 13433 1604 44 have have VB 13433 1604 45 been be VBN 13433 1604 46 quoted quote VBN 13433 1604 47 from from IN 13433 1604 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1604 49 third third JJ 13433 1604 50 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1604 51 , , , 13433 1604 52 and and CC 13433 1604 53 can can MD 13433 1604 54 not not RB 13433 1604 55 have have VB 13433 1604 56 been be VBN 13433 1604 57 taken take VBN 13433 1604 58 from from IN 13433 1604 59 some some DT 13433 1604 60 one one CD 13433 1604 61 of of IN 13433 1604 62 the the DT 13433 1604 63 numerous numerous JJ 13433 1604 64 evangelical evangelical JJ 13433 1604 65 works work NNS 13433 1604 66 in in IN 13433 1604 67 circulation circulation NN 13433 1604 68 before before IN 13433 1604 69 that that IN 13433 1604 70 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1604 71 was be VBD 13433 1604 72 written write VBN 13433 1604 73 . . . 13433 1605 1 The the DT 13433 1605 2 reply reply NN 13433 1605 3 of of IN 13433 1605 4 everyone everyone NN 13433 1605 5 accustomed accustom VBN 13433 1605 6 to to TO 13433 1605 7 weigh weigh VB 13433 1605 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 1605 9 must must MD 13433 1605 10 be be VB 13433 1605 11 that that IN 13433 1605 12 the the DT 13433 1605 13 words word NNS 13433 1605 14 can can MD 13433 1605 15 not not RB 13433 1605 16 even even RB 13433 1605 17 prove prove VB 13433 1605 18 the the DT 13433 1605 19 existence existence NN 13433 1605 20 of of IN 13433 1605 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1605 22 synoptic synoptic NN 13433 1605 23 at at IN 13433 1605 24 the the DT 13433 1605 25 time time NN 13433 1605 26 the the DT 13433 1605 27 letter letter NN 13433 1605 28 was be VBD 13433 1605 29 written write VBN 13433 1605 30 . . . 13433 1606 1 " " `` 13433 1606 2 But but CC 13433 1606 3 , , , 13433 1606 4 if if IN 13433 1606 5 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1606 6 author author NN 13433 1606 7 disposes dispose VBZ 13433 1606 8 of of IN 13433 1606 9 the the DT 13433 1606 10 coincidences coincidence NNS 13433 1606 11 with with IN 13433 1606 12 the the DT 13433 1606 13 third third JJ 13433 1606 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1606 15 in in IN 13433 1606 16 this this DT 13433 1606 17 way way NN 13433 1606 18 " " '' 13433 1606 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1606 20 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 1606 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1606 22 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1606 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1606 24 , , , 13433 1606 25 " " `` 13433 1606 26 what what WP 13433 1606 27 will will MD 13433 1606 28 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1606 29 say say VB 13433 1606 30 to to IN 13433 1606 31 those those DT 13433 1606 32 with with IN 13433 1606 33 the the DT 13433 1606 34 Acts act NNS 13433 1606 35 ? ? . 13433 1607 1 In in IN 13433 1607 2 this this DT 13433 1607 3 same same JJ 13433 1607 4 letter letter NN 13433 1607 5 of of IN 13433 1607 6 the the DT 13433 1607 7 Gallican Gallican NNP 13433 1607 8 Churches Churches NNPS 13433 1607 9 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1607 10 are be VBP 13433 1607 11 told tell VBN 13433 1607 12 that that IN 13433 1607 13 the the DT 13433 1607 14 sufferers sufferer NNS 13433 1607 15 prayed pray VBD 13433 1607 16 for for IN 13433 1607 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1607 18 persecutors persecutor NNS 13433 1607 19 ' ' POS 13433 1607 20 like like IN 13433 1607 21 Stephen Stephen NNP 13433 1607 22 , , , 13433 1607 23 the the DT 13433 1607 24 perfect perfect JJ 13433 1607 25 martyr martyr NN 13433 1607 26 , , , 13433 1607 27 " " '' 13433 1607 28 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1607 29 , , , 13433 1607 30 lay lie VBD 13433 1607 31 not not RB 13433 1607 32 this this DT 13433 1607 33 sin sin NN 13433 1607 34 to to IN 13433 1607 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1607 36 charge charge NN 13433 1607 37 . . . 13433 1607 38 ' ' '' 13433 1607 39 " " '' 13433 1608 1 Will Will MD 13433 1608 2 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1608 3 boldly boldly RB 13433 1608 4 maintain maintain VB 13433 1608 5 that that IN 13433 1608 6 the the DT 13433 1608 7 writers writer NNS 13433 1608 8 had have VBD 13433 1608 9 before before IN 13433 1608 10 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1608 11 another another DT 13433 1608 12 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1608 13 , , , 13433 1608 14 containing contain VBG 13433 1608 15 words word NNS 13433 1608 16 identical identical JJ 13433 1608 17 with with IN 13433 1608 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1608 19 Acts act NNS 13433 1608 20 , , , 13433 1608 21 just just RB 13433 1608 22 as as IN 13433 1608 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1608 24 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 1608 25 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1608 26 to to TO 13433 1608 27 have have VB 13433 1608 28 had have VBN 13433 1608 29 another another DT 13433 1608 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1608 31 , , , 13433 1608 32 containing contain VBG 13433 1608 33 words word NNS 13433 1608 34 identical identical JJ 13433 1608 35 with with IN 13433 1608 36 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1608 37 Third third JJ 13433 1608 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1608 39 ? ? . 13433 1609 1 Or or CC 13433 1609 2 , , , 13433 1609 3 will will MD 13433 1609 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1609 5 allow allow VB 13433 1609 6 this this DT 13433 1609 7 account account NN 13433 1609 8 to to TO 13433 1609 9 have have VB 13433 1609 10 been be VBN 13433 1609 11 taken take VBN 13433 1609 12 from from IN 13433 1609 13 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1609 14 vii vii NN 13433 1609 15 . . . 13433 1610 1 60 60 CD 13433 1610 2 , , , 13433 1610 3 with with IN 13433 1610 4 which which WDT 13433 1610 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1610 6 coincides coincide VBZ 13433 1610 7 ? ? . 13433 1611 1 But but CC 13433 1611 2 in in IN 13433 1611 3 this this DT 13433 1611 4 latter latter JJ 13433 1611 5 case case NN 13433 1611 6 , , , 13433 1611 7 if if IN 13433 1611 8 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1611 9 had have VBD 13433 1611 10 the the DT 13433 1611 11 second second JJ 13433 1611 12 treatise treatise NN 13433 1611 13 , , , 13433 1611 14 which which WDT 13433 1611 15 bears bear VBZ 13433 1611 16 the the DT 13433 1611 17 name name NN 13433 1611 18 of of IN 13433 1611 19 St. St. NNP 13433 1611 20 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1611 21 , , , 13433 1611 22 in in IN 13433 1611 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1611 24 hands hand NNS 13433 1611 25 , , , 13433 1611 26 why why WRB 13433 1611 27 should should MD 13433 1611 28 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1611 29 not not RB 13433 1611 30 have have VB 13433 1611 31 had have VBN 13433 1611 32 the the DT 13433 1611 33 first first JJ 13433 1611 34 also also RB 13433 1611 35 ? ? . 13433 1611 36 " " '' 13433 1612 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1612 2 143:1 143:1 LS 13433 1612 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1612 4 My -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1612 5 reply reply NN 13433 1612 6 to to IN 13433 1612 7 this this DT 13433 1612 8 is be VBZ 13433 1612 9 : : : 13433 1612 10 " " `` 13433 1612 11 There there EX 13433 1612 12 is be VBZ 13433 1612 13 no no DT 13433 1612 14 mention mention NN 13433 1612 15 of of IN 13433 1612 16 the the DT 13433 1612 17 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1612 18 of of IN 13433 1612 19 the the DT 13433 1612 20 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1612 21 in in IN 13433 1612 22 the the DT 13433 1612 23 epistle epistle NN 13433 1612 24 , , , 13433 1612 25 and and CC 13433 1612 26 the the DT 13433 1612 27 source source NN 13433 1612 28 from from IN 13433 1612 29 which which WDT 13433 1612 30 the the DT 13433 1612 31 writers writer NNS 13433 1612 32 obtained obtain VBD 13433 1612 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1612 34 information information NN 13433 1612 35 about about IN 13433 1612 36 Stephen Stephen NNP 13433 1612 37 , , , 13433 1612 38 is be VBZ 13433 1612 39 , , , 13433 1612 40 of of IN 13433 1612 41 course course NN 13433 1612 42 , , , 13433 1612 43 not not RB 13433 1612 44 stated state VBN 13433 1612 45 . . . 13433 1613 1 If if IN 13433 1613 2 there there EX 13433 1613 3 really really RB 13433 1613 4 was be VBD 13433 1613 5 a a DT 13433 1613 6 martyr martyr NN 13433 1613 7 of of IN 13433 1613 8 the the DT 13433 1613 9 name name NN 13433 1613 10 of of IN 13433 1613 11 Stephen Stephen NNP 13433 1613 12 , , , 13433 1613 13 and and CC 13433 1613 14 if if IN 13433 1613 15 these these DT 13433 1613 16 words word NNS 13433 1613 17 were be VBD 13433 1613 18 actually actually RB 13433 1613 19 spoken speak VBN 13433 1613 20 by by IN 13433 1613 21 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1613 22 , , , 13433 1613 23 the the DT 13433 1613 24 tradition tradition NN 13433 1613 25 of of IN 13433 1613 26 the the DT 13433 1613 27 fact fact NN 13433 1613 28 , , , 13433 1613 29 and and CC 13433 1613 30 the the DT 13433 1613 31 memory memory NN 13433 1613 32 of of IN 13433 1613 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1613 34 noble noble JJ 13433 1613 35 saying saying NN 13433 1613 36 , , , 13433 1613 37 may may MD 13433 1613 38 well well RB 13433 1613 39 have have VB 13433 1613 40 remained remain VBN 13433 1613 41 in in IN 13433 1613 42 the the DT 13433 1613 43 Church Church NNP 13433 1613 44 , , , 13433 1613 45 or or CC 13433 1613 46 have have VBP 13433 1613 47 been be VBN 13433 1613 48 recorded record VBN 13433 1613 49 in in IN 13433 1613 50 writings writing NNS 13433 1613 51 then then RB 13433 1613 52 current current JJ 13433 1613 53 , , , 13433 1613 54 from from IN 13433 1613 55 one one CD 13433 1613 56 of of IN 13433 1613 57 which which WDT 13433 1613 58 , , , 13433 1613 59 indeed indeed RB 13433 1613 60 , , , 13433 1613 61 eminent eminent JJ 13433 1613 62 critics critic NNS 13433 1613 63 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1613 64 as as IN 13433 1613 65 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 1613 66 , , , 13433 1613 67 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 1613 68 , , , 13433 1613 69 Meyer Meyer NNP 13433 1613 70 , , , 13433 1613 71 Neander Neander NNP 13433 1613 72 , , , 13433 1613 73 De De NNP 13433 1613 74 Wette Wette NNP 13433 1613 75 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1613 76 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1613 77 that that WDT 13433 1613 78 the the DT 13433 1613 79 author author NN 13433 1613 80 of of IN 13433 1613 81 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1613 82 derived derive VBD 13433 1613 83 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1613 84 materials material NNS 13433 1613 85 , , , 13433 1613 86 and and CC 13433 1613 87 in in IN 13433 1613 88 this this DT 13433 1613 89 case case NN 13433 1613 90 the the DT 13433 1613 91 passage passage NN 13433 1613 92 obviously obviously RB 13433 1613 93 does do VBZ 13433 1613 94 not not RB 13433 1613 95 prove prove VB 13433 1613 96 the the DT 13433 1613 97 use use NN 13433 1613 98 of of IN 13433 1613 99 the the DT 13433 1613 100 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1613 101 . . . 13433 1614 1 If if IN 13433 1614 2 , , , 13433 1614 3 on on IN 13433 1614 4 the the DT 13433 1614 5 other other JJ 13433 1614 6 hand hand NN 13433 1614 7 , , , 13433 1614 8 there there EX 13433 1614 9 never never RB 13433 1614 10 was be VBD 13433 1614 11 such such PDT 13433 1614 12 a a DT 13433 1614 13 martyr martyr NN 13433 1614 14 by by IN 13433 1614 15 whom whom WP 13433 1614 16 the the DT 13433 1614 17 words word NNS 13433 1614 18 were be VBD 13433 1614 19 spoken speak VBN 13433 1614 20 , , , 13433 1614 21 and and CC 13433 1614 22 the the DT 13433 1614 23 whole whole JJ 13433 1614 24 story story NN 13433 1614 25 must must MD 13433 1614 26 be be VB 13433 1614 27 considered consider VBN 13433 1614 28 an an DT 13433 1614 29 original original JJ 13433 1614 30 invention invention NN 13433 1614 31 by by IN 13433 1614 32 the the DT 13433 1614 33 author author NN 13433 1614 34 of of IN 13433 1614 35 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1614 36 , , , 13433 1614 37 then then RB 13433 1614 38 , , , 13433 1614 39 in in IN 13433 1614 40 that that DT 13433 1614 41 case case NN 13433 1614 42 , , , 13433 1614 43 and and CC 13433 1614 44 in in IN 13433 1614 45 that that DT 13433 1614 46 case case NN 13433 1614 47 only only RB 13433 1614 48 , , , 13433 1614 49 the the DT 13433 1614 50 passage passage NN 13433 1614 51 does do VBZ 13433 1614 52 show show VB 13433 1614 53 the the DT 13433 1614 54 use use NN 13433 1614 55 of of IN 13433 1614 56 the the DT 13433 1614 57 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1614 58 . . . 13433 1615 1 Supposing suppose VBG 13433 1615 2 that that IN 13433 1615 3 the the DT 13433 1615 4 use use NN 13433 1615 5 of of IN 13433 1615 6 Acts act NNS 13433 1615 7 be be VB 13433 1615 8 held hold VBN 13433 1615 9 to to TO 13433 1615 10 be be VB 13433 1615 11 thus thus RB 13433 1615 12 indicated indicate VBN 13433 1615 13 , , , 13433 1615 14 what what WP 13433 1615 15 does do VBZ 13433 1615 16 this this DT 13433 1615 17 prove prove VB 13433 1615 18 ? ? . 13433 1616 1 Merely merely RB 13433 1616 2 that that IN 13433 1616 3 the the DT 13433 1616 4 ' ' `` 13433 1616 5 Acts act NNS 13433 1616 6 of of IN 13433 1616 7 the the DT 13433 1616 8 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1616 9 ' ' '' 13433 1616 10 were be VBD 13433 1616 11 in in IN 13433 1616 12 existence existence NN 13433 1616 13 in in IN 13433 1616 14 the the DT 13433 1616 15 year year NN 13433 1616 16 177 177 CD 13433 1616 17 - - SYM 13433 1616 18 178 178 CD 13433 1616 19 , , , 13433 1616 20 when when WRB 13433 1616 21 the the DT 13433 1616 22 epistle epistle NN 13433 1616 23 of of IN 13433 1616 24 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 1616 25 and and CC 13433 1616 26 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 1616 27 was be VBD 13433 1616 28 written write VBN 13433 1616 29 . . . 13433 1617 1 No no DT 13433 1617 2 light light NN 13433 1617 3 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1617 4 would would MD 13433 1617 5 thus thus RB 13433 1617 6 be be VB 13433 1617 7 thrown throw VBN 13433 1617 8 upon upon IN 13433 1617 9 the the DT 13433 1617 10 question question NN 13433 1617 11 of of IN 13433 1617 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1617 13 authorship authorship NN 13433 1617 14 ; ; : 13433 1617 15 and and CC 13433 1617 16 neither neither CC 13433 1617 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1617 18 credibility credibility NN 13433 1617 19 nor nor CC 13433 1617 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1617 21 sufficiency sufficiency NN 13433 1617 22 to to TO 13433 1617 23 prove prove VB 13433 1617 24 the the DT 13433 1617 25 reality reality NN 13433 1617 26 of of IN 13433 1617 27 a a DT 13433 1617 28 cycle cycle NN 13433 1617 29 of of IN 13433 1617 30 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1617 31 would would MD 13433 1617 32 be be VB 13433 1617 33 in in IN 13433 1617 34 the the DT 13433 1617 35 slightest slight JJS 13433 1617 36 degree degree NN 13433 1617 37 established establish VBN 13433 1617 38 . . . 13433 1617 39 " " '' 13433 1618 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1618 2 143:2 143:2 LS 13433 1618 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1618 4 Apart apart RB 13433 1618 5 from from IN 13433 1618 6 the the DT 13433 1618 7 question question NN 13433 1618 8 of of IN 13433 1618 9 the the DT 13433 1618 10 sufficiency sufficiency NN 13433 1618 11 of of IN 13433 1618 12 evidence evidence NN 13433 1618 13 actually actually RB 13433 1618 14 under under IN 13433 1618 15 examination examination NN 13433 1618 16 , , , 13433 1618 17 however however RB 13433 1618 18 , , , 13433 1618 19 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1618 20 have have VBP 13433 1618 21 never never RB 13433 1618 22 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1618 23 , , , 13433 1618 24 much much RB 13433 1618 25 less less RBR 13433 1618 26 asserted asserted JJ 13433 1618 27 , , , 13433 1618 28 that that IN 13433 1618 29 the the DT 13433 1618 30 " " `` 13433 1618 31 Acts act NNS 13433 1618 32 of of IN 13433 1618 33 the the DT 13433 1618 34 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1618 35 " " '' 13433 1618 36 was be VBD 13433 1618 37 not not RB 13433 1618 38 in in IN 13433 1618 39 existence existence NN 13433 1618 40 at at IN 13433 1618 41 this this DT 13433 1618 42 date date NN 13433 1618 43 . . . 13433 1619 1 The the DT 13433 1619 2 only only JJ 13433 1619 3 interest interest NN 13433 1619 4 attachable attachable JJ 13433 1619 5 to to IN 13433 1619 6 the the DT 13433 1619 7 question question NN 13433 1619 8 is be VBZ 13433 1619 9 , , , 13433 1619 10 as as IN 13433 1619 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1619 12 have have VBP 13433 1619 13 before before RB 13433 1619 14 said say VBN 13433 1619 15 , , , 13433 1619 16 the the DT 13433 1619 17 paucity paucity NN 13433 1619 18 of of IN 13433 1619 19 the the DT 13433 1619 20 testimony testimony NN 13433 1619 21 regarding regard VBG 13433 1619 22 the the DT 13433 1619 23 book book NN 13433 1619 24 , , , 13433 1619 25 to to TO 13433 1619 26 demonstrate demonstrate VB 13433 1619 27 which which WDT 13433 1619 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1619 29 has have VBZ 13433 1619 30 been be VBN 13433 1619 31 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1619 32 to to TO 13433 1619 33 discuss discuss VB 13433 1619 34 all all DT 13433 1619 35 such such JJ 13433 1619 36 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1619 37 allusions allusion NNS 13433 1619 38 . . . 13433 1620 1 But but CC 13433 1620 2 the the DT 13433 1620 3 apologetic apologetic JJ 13433 1620 4 argument argument NN 13433 1620 5 characteristically characteristically RB 13433 1620 6 ignores ignore VBZ 13433 1620 7 the the DT 13433 1620 8 fact fact NN 13433 1620 9 that that IN 13433 1620 10 " " `` 13433 1620 11 many many JJ 13433 1620 12 took take VBD 13433 1620 13 in in RP 13433 1620 14 hand hand NN 13433 1620 15 " " '' 13433 1620 16 at at IN 13433 1620 17 an an DT 13433 1620 18 early early JJ 13433 1620 19 date date NN 13433 1620 20 to to TO 13433 1620 21 set set VB 13433 1620 22 forth forth RP 13433 1620 23 the the DT 13433 1620 24 Christian christian JJ 13433 1620 25 story story NN 13433 1620 26 , , , 13433 1620 27 and and CC 13433 1620 28 that that IN 13433 1620 29 the the DT 13433 1620 30 books book NNS 13433 1620 31 of of IN 13433 1620 32 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1620 33 New New NNP 13433 1620 34 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1620 35 did do VBD 13433 1620 36 not not RB 13433 1620 37 constitute constitute VB 13433 1620 38 the the DT 13433 1620 39 whole whole NN 13433 1620 40 of of IN 13433 1620 41 Christian christian JJ 13433 1620 42 literature literature NN 13433 1620 43 in in IN 13433 1620 44 circulation circulation NN 13433 1620 45 in in IN 13433 1620 46 the the DT 13433 1620 47 early early JJ 13433 1620 48 days day NNS 13433 1620 49 of of IN 13433 1620 50 the the DT 13433 1620 51 Church Church NNP 13433 1620 52 . . . 13433 1621 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1621 2 need need VBP 13433 1621 3 not not RB 13433 1621 4 go go VB 13433 1621 5 with with IN 13433 1621 6 any any DT 13433 1621 7 minuteness minuteness NN 13433 1621 8 into into IN 13433 1621 9 the the DT 13433 1621 10 alleged allege VBN 13433 1621 11 quotation quotation NN 13433 1621 12 from from IN 13433 1621 13 the the DT 13433 1621 14 fourth fourth JJ 13433 1621 15 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1621 16 . . . 13433 1622 1 " " `` 13433 1622 2 There there EX 13433 1622 3 shall shall MD 13433 1622 4 come come VB 13433 1622 5 a a DT 13433 1622 6 time time NN 13433 1622 7 in in IN 13433 1622 8 which which WDT 13433 1622 9 whosoever whosoever NN 13433 1622 10 killeth killeth NNP 13433 1622 11 you -PRON- PRP 13433 1622 12 will will MD 13433 1622 13 think think VB 13433 1622 14 that that IN 13433 1622 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1622 16 doeth doeth VBP 13433 1622 17 God God NNP 13433 1622 18 service service NN 13433 1622 19 . . . 13433 1622 20 " " '' 13433 1623 1 The the DT 13433 1623 2 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1623 3 has have VBZ 13433 1623 4 : : : 13433 1623 5 " " `` 13433 1623 6 There there EX 13433 1623 7 cometh cometh VBP 13433 1623 8 an an DT 13433 1623 9 hour hour NN 13433 1623 10 when when WRB 13433 1623 11 , , , 13433 1623 12 " " '' 13433 1623 13 & & CC 13433 1623 14 c. c. NNP 13433 1623 15 , , , 13433 1623 16 and and CC 13433 1623 17 , , , 13433 1623 18 as as IN 13433 1623 19 no no DT 13433 1623 20 source source NN 13433 1623 21 is be VBZ 13433 1623 22 named name VBN 13433 1623 23 , , , 13433 1623 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1623 25 is be VBZ 13433 1623 26 useless useless JJ 13433 1623 27 to to TO 13433 1623 28 maintain maintain VB 13433 1623 29 that that IN 13433 1623 30 the the DT 13433 1623 31 use use NN 13433 1623 32 of of IN 13433 1623 33 this this DT 13433 1623 34 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1623 35 , , , 13433 1623 36 and and CC 13433 1623 37 the the DT 13433 1623 38 impossibility impossibility NN 13433 1623 39 of of IN 13433 1623 40 the the DT 13433 1623 41 use use NN 13433 1623 42 of of IN 13433 1623 43 any any DT 13433 1623 44 other other JJ 13433 1623 45 , , , 13433 1623 46 is be VBZ 13433 1623 47 proved prove VBN 13433 1623 48 . . . 13433 1624 1 If if IN 13433 1624 2 even even RB 13433 1624 3 this this DT 13433 1624 4 were be VBD 13433 1624 5 conceded concede VBN 13433 1624 6 , , , 13433 1624 7 the the DT 13433 1624 8 passage passage NN 13433 1624 9 does do VBZ 13433 1624 10 not not RB 13433 1624 11 add add VB 13433 1624 12 one one CD 13433 1624 13 iota iota NN 13433 1624 14 to to IN 13433 1624 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1624 16 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1624 17 of of IN 13433 1624 18 the the DT 13433 1624 19 authorship authorship NN 13433 1624 20 and and CC 13433 1624 21 credibility credibility NN 13433 1624 22 of of IN 13433 1624 23 the the DT 13433 1624 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1624 25 . . . 13433 1625 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1625 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1625 3 says say VBZ 13433 1625 4 " " `` 13433 1625 5 The the DT 13433 1625 6 author author NN 13433 1625 7 of of IN 13433 1625 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1625 9 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1625 10 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1625 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1625 12 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 1625 13 , , , 13433 1625 14 on on IN 13433 1625 15 the the DT 13433 1625 16 other other JJ 13433 1625 17 hand hand NN 13433 1625 18 , , , 13433 1625 19 that that IN 13433 1625 20 only only RB 13433 1625 21 twelve twelve CD 13433 1625 22 years year NNS 13433 1625 23 before before RB 13433 1625 24 , , , 13433 1625 25 at at IN 13433 1625 26 the the DT 13433 1625 27 outside outside NN 13433 1625 28 , , , 13433 1625 29 the the DT 13433 1625 30 very very JJ 13433 1625 31 Church church NN 13433 1625 32 to to TO 13433 1625 33 which which WDT 13433 1625 34 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 1625 35 belonged belong VBD 13433 1625 36 , , , 13433 1625 37 in in IN 13433 1625 38 a a DT 13433 1625 39 public public JJ 13433 1625 40 document document NN 13433 1625 41 with with IN 13433 1625 42 which which WDT 13433 1625 43 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1625 44 was be VBD 13433 1625 45 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1625 46 , , , 13433 1625 47 betrays betray VBZ 13433 1625 48 no no DT 13433 1625 49 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1625 50 of of IN 13433 1625 51 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1625 52 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1625 53 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1625 54 , , , 13433 1625 55 but but CC 13433 1625 56 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1625 57 from from IN 13433 1625 58 one one CD 13433 1625 59 or or CC 13433 1625 60 more more JJR 13433 1625 61 apocryphal apocryphal NNS 13433 1625 62 Gospels gospel NNS 13433 1625 63 instead instead RB 13433 1625 64 . . . 13433 1626 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1626 2 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 1626 3 this this DT 13433 1626 4 though though IN 13433 1626 5 the the DT 13433 1626 6 quotations quotation NNS 13433 1626 7 in in IN 13433 1626 8 question question NN 13433 1626 9 are be VBP 13433 1626 10 actually actually RB 13433 1626 11 found find VBN 13433 1626 12 in in IN 13433 1626 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1626 14 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1626 15 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1626 16 . . . 13433 1626 17 " " '' 13433 1627 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1627 2 144:1 144:1 LS 13433 1627 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1627 4 Really really RB 13433 1627 5 , , , 13433 1627 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1627 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1627 8 betrays betray VBZ 13433 1627 9 that that IN 13433 1627 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1627 11 has have VBZ 13433 1627 12 not not RB 13433 1627 13 understood understand VBN 13433 1627 14 the the DT 13433 1627 15 argument argument NN 13433 1627 16 , , , 13433 1627 17 which which WDT 13433 1627 18 merely merely RB 13433 1627 19 turns turn VBZ 13433 1627 20 upon upon IN 13433 1627 21 the the DT 13433 1627 22 insufficiency insufficiency NN 13433 1627 23 of of IN 13433 1627 24 the the DT 13433 1627 25 evidence evidence NN 13433 1627 26 to to TO 13433 1627 27 prove prove VB 13433 1627 28 the the DT 13433 1627 29 use use NN 13433 1627 30 of of IN 13433 1627 31 particular particular JJ 13433 1627 32 documents document NNS 13433 1627 33 , , , 13433 1627 34 whilst whilst IN 13433 1627 35 others other NNS 13433 1627 36 existed exist VBD 13433 1627 37 which which WDT 13433 1627 38 possibly possibly RB 13433 1627 39 , , , 13433 1627 40 or or CC 13433 1627 41 probably probably RB 13433 1627 42 , , , 13433 1627 43 did do VBD 13433 1627 44 contain contain VB 13433 1627 45 similar similar JJ 13433 1627 46 passages passage NNS 13433 1627 47 to to IN 13433 1627 48 those those DT 13433 1627 49 in in IN 13433 1627 50 debate debate NN 13433 1627 51 . . . 13433 1628 1 VII VII NNP 13433 1628 2 . . . 13433 1629 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1629 2 TATIAN TATIAN NNP 13433 1629 3 'S 'S NNP 13433 1629 4 ' ' '' 13433 1629 5 DIATESSARON DIATESSARON NNP 13433 1629 6 . . . 13433 1630 1 ' ' `` 13433 1630 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1630 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1630 4 need need VBP 13433 1630 5 not not RB 13433 1630 6 reply reply VB 13433 1630 7 at at IN 13433 1630 8 any any DT 13433 1630 9 length length NN 13433 1630 10 to to IN 13433 1630 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1630 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1630 13 's 's POS 13433 1630 14 essay essay NN 13433 1630 15 on on IN 13433 1630 16 the the DT 13433 1630 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1630 18 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1630 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1630 20 of of IN 13433 1630 21 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1630 22 , , , 13433 1630 23 and and CC 13433 1630 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1630 25 must must MD 13433 1630 26 refer refer VB 13433 1630 27 those those DT 13433 1630 28 who who WP 13433 1630 29 wish wish VBP 13433 1630 30 to to TO 13433 1630 31 see see VB 13433 1630 32 what what WP 13433 1630 33 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1630 34 had have VBD 13433 1630 35 to to TO 13433 1630 36 say say VB 13433 1630 37 on on IN 13433 1630 38 the the DT 13433 1630 39 subject subject NN 13433 1630 40 to to IN 13433 1630 41 _ _ NNP 13433 1630 42 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1630 43 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1630 44 _ _ NNP 13433 1630 45 . . . 13433 1631 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1631 2 145:1 145:1 LS 13433 1631 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1631 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1631 5 may may MD 13433 1631 6 here here RB 13433 1631 7 confine confine VB 13433 1631 8 myself -PRON- PRP 13433 1631 9 to to IN 13433 1631 10 remarks remark NNS 13433 1631 11 connected connect VBN 13433 1631 12 with with IN 13433 1631 13 fresh fresh JJ 13433 1631 14 matter matter NN 13433 1631 15 which which WDT 13433 1631 16 has have VBZ 13433 1631 17 appeared appear VBN 13433 1631 18 since since IN 13433 1631 19 the the DT 13433 1631 20 publication publication NN 13433 1631 21 of of IN 13433 1631 22 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1631 23 work work NN 13433 1631 24 . . . 13433 1632 1 An an DT 13433 1632 2 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 1632 3 translation translation NN 13433 1632 4 of of IN 13433 1632 5 what what WP 13433 1632 6 is be VBZ 13433 1632 7 alleged allege VBN 13433 1632 8 to to TO 13433 1632 9 be be VB 13433 1632 10 the the DT 13433 1632 11 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 1632 12 of of IN 13433 1632 13 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1632 14 Syrus Syrus NNP 13433 1632 15 on on IN 13433 1632 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1632 17 's 's POS 13433 1632 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1632 19 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1632 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1632 21 was be VBD 13433 1632 22 published publish VBN 13433 1632 23 as as RB 13433 1632 24 long long RB 13433 1632 25 ago ago RB 13433 1632 26 as as IN 13433 1632 27 1836 1836 CD 13433 1632 28 , , , 13433 1632 29 but but CC 13433 1632 30 failed fail VBD 13433 1632 31 to to TO 13433 1632 32 attract attract VB 13433 1632 33 critical critical JJ 13433 1632 34 attention attention NN 13433 1632 35 . . . 13433 1633 1 In in IN 13433 1633 2 1876 1876 CD 13433 1633 3 , , , 13433 1633 4 however however RB 13433 1633 5 , , , 13433 1633 6 a a DT 13433 1633 7 Latin latin JJ 13433 1633 8 translation translation NN 13433 1633 9 of of IN 13433 1633 10 this this DT 13433 1633 11 work work NN 13433 1633 12 by by IN 13433 1633 13 Aucher Aucher NNP 13433 1633 14 and and CC 13433 1633 15 Moesinger Moesinger NNP 13433 1633 16 was be VBD 13433 1633 17 issued issue VBN 13433 1633 18 , , , 13433 1633 19 and and CC 13433 1633 20 this this DT 13433 1633 21 has have VBZ 13433 1633 22 now now RB 13433 1633 23 , , , 13433 1633 24 naturally naturally RB 13433 1633 25 introduced introduce VBD 13433 1633 26 new new JJ 13433 1633 27 elements element NNS 13433 1633 28 into into IN 13433 1633 29 the the DT 13433 1633 30 argument argument NN 13433 1633 31 regarding regard VBG 13433 1633 32 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1633 33 's 's POS 13433 1633 34 use use NN 13433 1633 35 of of IN 13433 1633 36 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1633 37 . . . 13433 1634 1 Only only RB 13433 1634 2 last last JJ 13433 1634 3 year year NN 13433 1634 4 , , , 13433 1634 5 a a DT 13433 1634 6 still still RB 13433 1634 7 more more RBR 13433 1634 8 important important JJ 13433 1634 9 addition addition NN 13433 1634 10 to to IN 13433 1634 11 critical critical JJ 13433 1634 12 materials material NNS 13433 1634 13 was be VBD 13433 1634 14 made make VBN 13433 1634 15 by by IN 13433 1634 16 the the DT 13433 1634 17 publication publication NN 13433 1634 18 in in IN 13433 1634 19 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1634 20 of of IN 13433 1634 21 an an DT 13433 1634 22 alleged allege VBN 13433 1634 23 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 1634 24 version version NN 13433 1634 25 of of IN 13433 1634 26 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1634 27 's 's POS 13433 1634 28 _ _ NNP 13433 1634 29 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1634 30 _ _ NNP 13433 1634 31 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1634 32 , , , 13433 1634 33 with with IN 13433 1634 34 a a DT 13433 1634 35 Latin latin JJ 13433 1634 36 translation translation NN 13433 1634 37 by by IN 13433 1634 38 Ciasca Ciasca NNP 13433 1634 39 . . . 13433 1635 1 These these DT 13433 1635 2 works work NNS 13433 1635 3 were be VBD 13433 1635 4 not not RB 13433 1635 5 before before IN 13433 1635 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1635 7 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1635 8 when when WRB 13433 1635 9 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1635 10 wrote write VBD 13433 1635 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1635 12 Essay Essay NNP 13433 1635 13 on on IN 13433 1635 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1635 15 in in IN 13433 1635 16 1877 1877 CD 13433 1635 17 , , , 13433 1635 18 and and CC 13433 1635 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1635 20 only only RB 13433 1635 21 refers refer VBZ 13433 1635 22 to to IN 13433 1635 23 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1635 24 in in IN 13433 1635 25 a a DT 13433 1635 26 note note NN 13433 1635 27 in in IN 13433 1635 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1635 29 present present JJ 13433 1635 30 volume volume NN 13433 1635 31 . . . 13433 1636 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1636 2 entertains entertain VBZ 13433 1636 3 no no DT 13433 1636 4 doubt doubt NN 13433 1636 5 as as IN 13433 1636 6 to to IN 13433 1636 7 the the DT 13433 1636 8 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 1636 9 of of IN 13433 1636 10 these these DT 13433 1636 11 works work NNS 13433 1636 12 , , , 13433 1636 13 and and CC 13433 1636 14 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1636 15 triumphantly triumphantly RB 13433 1636 16 claims claim VBZ 13433 1636 17 that that IN 13433 1636 18 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1636 19 establish establish VBP 13433 1636 20 the the DT 13433 1636 21 truth truth NN 13433 1636 22 of of IN 13433 1636 23 the the DT 13433 1636 24 " " `` 13433 1636 25 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 1636 26 theory theory NN 13433 1636 27 " " '' 13433 1636 28 regarding regard VBG 13433 1636 29 the the DT 13433 1636 30 _ _ NNP 13433 1636 31 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1636 32 _ _ NNP 13433 1636 33 of of IN 13433 1636 34 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1636 35 . . . 13433 1637 1 In in IN 13433 1637 2 order order NN 13433 1637 3 to to TO 13433 1637 4 understand understand VB 13433 1637 5 the the DT 13433 1637 6 exact exact JJ 13433 1637 7 position position NN 13433 1637 8 of of IN 13433 1637 9 the the DT 13433 1637 10 case case NN 13433 1637 11 , , , 13433 1637 12 however however RB 13433 1637 13 , , , 13433 1637 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1637 15 will will MD 13433 1637 16 be be VB 13433 1637 17 well well JJ 13433 1637 18 to to TO 13433 1637 19 state state VB 13433 1637 20 again again RB 13433 1637 21 what what WP 13433 1637 22 is be VBZ 13433 1637 23 known know VBN 13433 1637 24 regarding regard VBG 13433 1637 25 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1637 26 's 's POS 13433 1637 27 work work NN 13433 1637 28 . . . 13433 1638 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1638 2 is be VBZ 13433 1638 3 the the DT 13433 1638 4 first first JJ 13433 1638 5 writer writer NN 13433 1638 6 who who WP 13433 1638 7 mentions mention VBZ 13433 1638 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1638 9 . . . 13433 1639 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1639 2 says say VBZ 13433 1639 3 -- -- : 13433 1639 4 and and CC 13433 1639 5 to to TO 13433 1639 6 avoid avoid VB 13433 1639 7 all all DT 13433 1639 8 dispute dispute NN 13433 1639 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1639 10 give give VBP 13433 1639 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1639 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1639 13 's 's POS 13433 1639 14 rendering:-- rendering:-- CD 13433 1639 15 " " `` 13433 1639 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1639 17 composed compose VBD 13433 1639 18 a a DT 13433 1639 19 sort sort NN 13433 1639 20 of of IN 13433 1639 21 connection connection NN 13433 1639 22 and and CC 13433 1639 23 compilation compilation NN 13433 1639 24 , , , 13433 1639 25 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1639 26 know know VBP 13433 1639 27 not not RB 13433 1639 28 how how WRB 13433 1639 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1639 30 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1639 31 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1639 32 : : : 13433 1639 33 ouk ouk NN 13433 1639 34 oid oid NNP 13433 1639 35 ' ' '' 13433 1639 36 hopôs hopôs NN 13433 1639 37 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1639 38 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1639 39 , , , 13433 1639 40 of of IN 13433 1639 41 the the DT 13433 1639 42 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1639 43 , , , 13433 1639 44 and and CC 13433 1639 45 called call VBD 13433 1639 46 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1639 47 _ _ NNP 13433 1639 48 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1639 49 _ _ NNP 13433 1639 50 . . . 13433 1640 1 This this DT 13433 1640 2 work work NN 13433 1640 3 is be VBZ 13433 1640 4 current current JJ 13433 1640 5 in in IN 13433 1640 6 some some DT 13433 1640 7 quarters quarter NNS 13433 1640 8 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1640 9 with with IN 13433 1640 10 some some DT 13433 1640 11 persons person NNS 13433 1640 12 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1640 13 even even RB 13433 1640 14 to to IN 13433 1640 15 the the DT 13433 1640 16 present present JJ 13433 1640 17 day day NN 13433 1640 18 . . . 13433 1640 19 " " '' 13433 1641 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1641 2 146:1 146:1 CD 13433 1641 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1641 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1641 5 argued argue VBD 13433 1641 6 that that IN 13433 1641 7 this this DT 13433 1641 8 statement statement NN 13433 1641 9 indicates indicate VBZ 13433 1641 10 that that IN 13433 1641 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1641 12 was be VBD 13433 1641 13 not not RB 13433 1641 14 personally personally RB 13433 1641 15 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1641 16 with with IN 13433 1641 17 the the DT 13433 1641 18 work work NN 13433 1641 19 in in IN 13433 1641 20 question question NN 13433 1641 21 , , , 13433 1641 22 but but CC 13433 1641 23 speaks speak VBZ 13433 1641 24 of of IN 13433 1641 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1641 26 from from IN 13433 1641 27 mere mere JJ 13433 1641 28 hearsay hearsay NN 13433 1641 29 . . . 13433 1642 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1642 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1642 3 replies-- replies-- NNP 13433 1642 4 " " `` 13433 1642 5 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1642 6 inference inference NN 13433 1642 7 , , , 13433 1642 8 however however RB 13433 1642 9 , , , 13433 1642 10 from from IN 13433 1642 11 the the DT 13433 1642 12 expression expression NN 13433 1642 13 ' ' '' 13433 1642 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1642 15 know know VBP 13433 1642 16 not not RB 13433 1642 17 how how WRB 13433 1642 18 ' ' '' 13433 1642 19 is be VBZ 13433 1642 20 altogether altogether RB 13433 1642 21 unwarranted unwarranted JJ 13433 1642 22 . . . 13433 1643 1 So so RB 13433 1643 2 far far RB 13433 1643 3 from from IN 13433 1643 4 implying imply VBG 13433 1643 5 that that IN 13433 1643 6 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1643 7 had have VBD 13433 1643 8 no no DT 13433 1643 9 personal personal JJ 13433 1643 10 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1643 11 of of IN 13433 1643 12 the the DT 13433 1643 13 work work NN 13433 1643 14 , , , 13433 1643 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1643 16 is be VBZ 13433 1643 17 constantly constantly RB 13433 1643 18 used use VBN 13433 1643 19 by by IN 13433 1643 20 writers writer NNS 13433 1643 21 in in IN 13433 1643 22 speaking speak VBG 13433 1643 23 of of IN 13433 1643 24 books book NNS 13433 1643 25 where where WRB 13433 1643 26 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1643 27 are be VBP 13433 1643 28 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 1643 29 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1643 30 with with IN 13433 1643 31 the the DT 13433 1643 32 contents content NNS 13433 1643 33 , , , 13433 1643 34 but but CC 13433 1643 35 do do VBP 13433 1643 36 not not RB 13433 1643 37 understand understand VB 13433 1643 38 the the DT 13433 1643 39 principles principle NNS 13433 1643 40 , , , 13433 1643 41 or or CC 13433 1643 42 do do VBP 13433 1643 43 not not RB 13433 1643 44 approve approve VB 13433 1643 45 the the DT 13433 1643 46 method method NN 13433 1643 47 . . . 13433 1644 1 In in IN 13433 1644 2 idiomatic idiomatic JJ 13433 1644 3 English English NNP 13433 1644 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1644 5 signifies signify VBZ 13433 1644 6 ' ' '' 13433 1644 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1644 8 can can MD 13433 1644 9 not not RB 13433 1644 10 think think VB 13433 1644 11 what what WP 13433 1644 12 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1644 13 was be VBD 13433 1644 14 about about IN 13433 1644 15 , , , 13433 1644 16 ' ' '' 13433 1644 17 and and CC 13433 1644 18 is be VBZ 13433 1644 19 equivalent equivalent JJ 13433 1644 20 to to IN 13433 1644 21 ' ' `` 13433 1644 22 unaccountably unaccountably RB 13433 1644 23 , , , 13433 1644 24 ' ' '' 13433 1644 25 ' ' '' 13433 1644 26 absurdly absurdly RB 13433 1644 27 , , , 13433 1644 28 ' ' '' 13433 1644 29 so so IN 13433 1644 30 that that IN 13433 1644 31 , , , 13433 1644 32 if if IN 13433 1644 33 anything anything NN 13433 1644 34 , , , 13433 1644 35 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1644 36 implies imply VBZ 13433 1644 37 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1644 38 rather rather RB 13433 1644 39 than than IN 13433 1644 40 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1644 41 of of IN 13433 1644 42 the the DT 13433 1644 43 contents content NNS 13433 1644 44 . . . 13433 1645 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 2 have have VBP 13433 1645 3 noticed notice VBN 13433 1645 4 at at IN 13433 1645 5 least least JJS 13433 1645 6 twenty twenty CD 13433 1645 7 - - HYPH 13433 1645 8 six six CD 13433 1645 9 examples example NNS 13433 1645 10 of of IN 13433 1645 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1645 12 use use NN 13433 1645 13 in in IN 13433 1645 14 the the DT 13433 1645 15 treatise treatise NN 13433 1645 16 of of IN 13433 1645 17 Origen Origen NNP 13433 1645 18 against against IN 13433 1645 19 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 1645 20 alone alone RB 13433 1645 21 , , , 13433 1645 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1645 23 146:2 146:2 CD 13433 1645 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1645 25 where where WRB 13433 1645 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 27 commonly commonly RB 13433 1645 28 refers refer VBZ 13433 1645 29 to to IN 13433 1645 30 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 1645 31 ' ' POS 13433 1645 32 work work NN 13433 1645 33 which which WDT 13433 1645 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 35 had have VBD 13433 1645 36 before before IN 13433 1645 37 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 38 , , , 13433 1645 39 and and CC 13433 1645 40 very very RB 13433 1645 41 often often RB 13433 1645 42 to to IN 13433 1645 43 passages passage NNS 13433 1645 44 which which WDT 13433 1645 45 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 46 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1645 47 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1645 48 in in IN 13433 1645 49 the the DT 13433 1645 50 context context NN 13433 1645 51 . . . 13433 1645 52 " " '' 13433 1646 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1646 2 146:3 146:3 LS 13433 1646 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1646 4 If if IN 13433 1646 5 this this DT 13433 1646 6 signification signification NN 13433 1646 7 be be VB 13433 1646 8 also also RB 13433 1646 9 attached attach VBN 13433 1646 10 to to IN 13433 1646 11 the the DT 13433 1646 12 expression expression NN 13433 1646 13 , , , 13433 1646 14 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1646 15 is be VBZ 13433 1646 16 equally equally RB 13433 1646 17 certain certain JJ 13433 1646 18 that that IN 13433 1646 19 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1646 20 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1646 21 : : : 13433 1646 22 ouk ouk NN 13433 1646 23 oid oid NNP 13433 1646 24 ' ' '' 13433 1646 25 hopôs hopôs NN 13433 1646 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1646 27 is be VBZ 13433 1646 28 used use VBN 13433 1646 29 to to TO 13433 1646 30 express express VB 13433 1646 31 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1646 32 , , , 13433 1646 33 although although IN 13433 1646 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1646 35 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1646 36 chooses choose VBZ 13433 1646 37 , , , 13433 1646 38 for for IN 13433 1646 39 the the DT 13433 1646 40 sake sake NN 13433 1646 41 of of IN 13433 1646 42 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1646 43 argument argument NN 13433 1646 44 , , , 13433 1646 45 to to TO 13433 1646 46 forget forget VB 13433 1646 47 the the DT 13433 1646 48 fact fact NN 13433 1646 49 . . . 13433 1647 1 In in IN 13433 1647 2 any any DT 13433 1647 3 case case NN 13433 1647 4 some some DT 13433 1647 5 of of IN 13433 1647 6 the the DT 13433 1647 7 best good JJS 13433 1647 8 critics critic NNS 13433 1647 9 draw draw VBP 13433 1647 10 the the DT 13433 1647 11 same same JJ 13433 1647 12 inference inference NN 13433 1647 13 from from IN 13433 1647 14 the the DT 13433 1647 15 phrase phrase NN 13433 1647 16 here here RB 13433 1647 17 that that IN 13433 1647 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1647 19 do do VBP 13433 1647 20 , , , 13433 1647 21 more more RBR 13433 1647 22 especially especially RB 13433 1647 23 as as IN 13433 1647 24 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1647 25 does do VBZ 13433 1647 26 not not RB 13433 1647 27 speak speak VB 13433 1647 28 further further RB 13433 1647 29 or or CC 13433 1647 30 more more RBR 13433 1647 31 definitely definitely RB 13433 1647 32 of of IN 13433 1647 33 the the DT 13433 1647 34 _ _ NNP 13433 1647 35 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1647 36 _ _ NNP 13433 1647 37 , , , 13433 1647 38 amongst amongst IN 13433 1647 39 whom whom WP 13433 1647 40 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1647 41 may may MD 13433 1647 42 name name VB 13433 1647 43 Credner Credner NNP 13433 1647 44 , , , 13433 1647 45 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 1647 46 , , , 13433 1647 47 Holtzmann Holtzmann NNP 13433 1647 48 , , , 13433 1647 49 Reuss Reuss NNP 13433 1647 50 and and CC 13433 1647 51 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1647 52 ; ; : 13433 1647 53 and and CC 13433 1647 54 should should MD 13433 1647 55 these these DT 13433 1647 56 not not RB 13433 1647 57 have have VB 13433 1647 58 weight weight NN 13433 1647 59 with with IN 13433 1647 60 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1647 61 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1647 62 may may MD 13433 1647 63 refer refer VB 13433 1647 64 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1647 65 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1647 66 to to IN 13433 1647 67 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1647 68 , , , 13433 1647 69 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1647 70 147:1 147:1 CD 13433 1647 71 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1647 72 and and CC 13433 1647 73 even even RB 13433 1647 74 to to IN 13433 1647 75 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1647 76 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1647 77 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1647 78 147:2 147:2 CD 13433 1647 79 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1647 80 and and CC 13433 1647 81 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1647 82 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 1647 83 . . . 13433 1648 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1648 2 147:3 147:3 CD 13433 1648 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1648 4 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1648 5 says say VBZ 13433 1648 6 nothing nothing NN 13433 1648 7 more more JJR 13433 1648 8 of of IN 13433 1648 9 the the DT 13433 1648 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1648 11 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1648 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1648 13 of of IN 13433 1648 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1648 15 and and CC 13433 1648 16 gives give VBZ 13433 1648 17 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1648 18 no no DT 13433 1648 19 further further JJ 13433 1648 20 help help NN 13433 1648 21 towards towards IN 13433 1648 22 a a DT 13433 1648 23 recognition recognition NN 13433 1648 24 of of IN 13433 1648 25 the the DT 13433 1648 26 work work NN 13433 1648 27 . . . 13433 1649 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1649 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1649 3 supposes suppose VBZ 13433 1649 4 that that IN 13433 1649 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1649 6 had have VBD 13433 1649 7 overlooked overlook VBN 13433 1649 8 the the DT 13433 1649 9 testimony testimony NN 13433 1649 10 of of IN 13433 1649 11 the the DT 13433 1649 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1649 13 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 1649 14 of of IN 13433 1649 15 Addai Addai NNP 13433 1649 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1649 17 , , , 13433 1649 18 an an DT 13433 1649 19 apocryphal apocryphal NN 13433 1649 20 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1649 21 work work NN 13433 1649 22 , , , 13433 1649 23 published publish VBN 13433 1649 24 in in IN 13433 1649 25 1876 1876 CD 13433 1649 26 by by IN 13433 1649 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1649 28 Phillips Phillips NNP 13433 1649 29 after after IN 13433 1649 30 _ _ NNP 13433 1649 31 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1649 32 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1649 33 _ _ NNP 13433 1649 34 was be VBD 13433 1649 35 written write VBN 13433 1649 36 . . . 13433 1650 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1650 2 did do VBD 13433 1650 3 not not RB 13433 1650 4 overlook overlook VB 13433 1650 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1650 6 , , , 13433 1650 7 but but CC 13433 1650 8 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1650 9 considered consider VBD 13433 1650 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1650 11 of of IN 13433 1650 12 too too RB 13433 1650 13 little little JJ 13433 1650 14 critical critical JJ 13433 1650 15 value value NN 13433 1650 16 to to TO 13433 1650 17 require require VB 13433 1650 18 much much JJ 13433 1650 19 notice notice NN 13433 1650 20 in in IN 13433 1650 21 later later JJ 13433 1650 22 editions edition NNS 13433 1650 23 of of IN 13433 1650 24 the the DT 13433 1650 25 work work NN 13433 1650 26 . . . 13433 1651 1 The the DT 13433 1651 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1651 3 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 1651 4 of of IN 13433 1651 5 Addai Addai NNP 13433 1651 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1651 7 is be VBZ 13433 1651 8 conjecturally conjecturally RB 13433 1651 9 dated date VBN 13433 1651 10 by by IN 13433 1651 11 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1651 12 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1651 13 about about IN 13433 1651 14 the the DT 13433 1651 15 middle middle NN 13433 1651 16 of of IN 13433 1651 17 the the DT 13433 1651 18 third third JJ 13433 1651 19 century century NN 13433 1651 20 , , , 13433 1651 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1651 22 147:4 147:4 CD 13433 1651 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1651 24 and and CC 13433 1651 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1651 26 might may MD 13433 1651 27 with with IN 13433 1651 28 greater great JJR 13433 1651 29 certainty certainty NN 13433 1651 30 be be VB 13433 1651 31 placed place VBN 13433 1651 32 much much RB 13433 1651 33 later later RB 13433 1651 34 . . . 13433 1652 1 The the DT 13433 1652 2 passage passage NN 13433 1652 3 to to IN 13433 1652 4 which which WDT 13433 1652 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1652 6 points point VBZ 13433 1652 7 is be VBZ 13433 1652 8 one one CD 13433 1652 9 in in IN 13433 1652 10 which which WDT 13433 1652 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1652 12 is be VBZ 13433 1652 13 said say VBN 13433 1652 14 that that IN 13433 1652 15 the the DT 13433 1652 16 new new JJ 13433 1652 17 converts convert NNS 13433 1652 18 meet meet VBP 13433 1652 19 together together RB 13433 1652 20 to to TO 13433 1652 21 hear hear VB 13433 1652 22 , , , 13433 1652 23 along along IN 13433 1652 24 with with IN 13433 1652 25 the the DT 13433 1652 26 Old Old NNP 13433 1652 27 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1652 28 , , , 13433 1652 29 " " '' 13433 1652 30 the the DT 13433 1652 31 New New NNP 13433 1652 32 of of IN 13433 1652 33 the the DT 13433 1652 34 _ _ NNP 13433 1652 35 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1652 36 _ _ NNP 13433 1652 37 . . . 13433 1652 38 " " '' 13433 1653 1 This this DT 13433 1653 2 is be VBZ 13433 1653 3 assumed assume VBN 13433 1653 4 to to TO 13433 1653 5 be be VB 13433 1653 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1653 7 's 's POS 13433 1653 8 " " `` 13433 1653 9 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1653 10 of of IN 13433 1653 11 the the DT 13433 1653 12 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1653 13 , , , 13433 1653 14 " " '' 13433 1653 15 and and CC 13433 1653 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1653 17 shall shall MD 13433 1653 18 not not RB 13433 1653 19 further further RB 13433 1653 20 argue argue VB 13433 1653 21 the the DT 13433 1653 22 point point NN 13433 1653 23 ; ; : 13433 1653 24 but but CC 13433 1653 25 does do VBZ 13433 1653 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1653 27 bring bring VB 13433 1653 28 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1653 29 any any DT 13433 1653 30 nearer nearer NN 13433 1653 31 to to IN 13433 1653 32 a a DT 13433 1653 33 certain certain JJ 13433 1653 34 understanding understanding NN 13433 1653 35 of of IN 13433 1653 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1653 37 character character NN 13433 1653 38 and and CC 13433 1653 39 contents content NNS 13433 1653 40 ? ? . 13433 1654 1 The the DT 13433 1654 2 next next JJ 13433 1654 3 witness witness NN 13433 1654 4 , , , 13433 1654 5 taking take VBG 13433 1654 6 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1654 7 in in IN 13433 1654 8 the the DT 13433 1654 9 order order NN 13433 1654 10 in in IN 13433 1654 11 which which WDT 13433 1654 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1654 13 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1654 14 cites cite VBZ 13433 1654 15 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1654 16 , , , 13433 1654 17 is be VBZ 13433 1654 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 1654 19 Bar Bar NNP 13433 1654 20 - - HYPH 13433 1654 21 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 1654 22 , , , 13433 1654 23 who who WP 13433 1654 24 flourished flourish VBD 13433 1654 25 in in IN 13433 1654 26 the the DT 13433 1654 27 last last JJ 13433 1654 28 years year NNS 13433 1654 29 of of IN 13433 1654 30 the the DT 13433 1654 31 twelfth twelfth JJ 13433 1654 32 century century NN 13433 1654 33 . . . 13433 1655 1 In in IN 13433 1655 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1655 3 commentary commentary NN 13433 1655 4 on on IN 13433 1655 5 the the DT 13433 1655 6 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1655 7 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1655 8 writes:-- writes:-- VBD 13433 1655 9 " " `` 13433 1655 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1655 11 , , , 13433 1655 12 the the DT 13433 1655 13 disciple disciple NN 13433 1655 14 of of IN 13433 1655 15 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1655 16 , , , 13433 1655 17 the the DT 13433 1655 18 philosopher philosopher NN 13433 1655 19 and and CC 13433 1655 20 martyr martyr NN 13433 1655 21 , , , 13433 1655 22 selected select VBN 13433 1655 23 and and CC 13433 1655 24 patched patch VBN 13433 1655 25 together together RB 13433 1655 26 from from IN 13433 1655 27 the the DT 13433 1655 28 four four CD 13433 1655 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1655 30 and and CC 13433 1655 31 constructed construct VBD 13433 1655 32 a a DT 13433 1655 33 gospel gospel NN 13433 1655 34 , , , 13433 1655 35 which which WDT 13433 1655 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1655 37 called call VBD 13433 1655 38 _ _ NNP 13433 1655 39 Diatessaron_--that diatessaron_--that NN 13433 1655 40 is be VBZ 13433 1655 41 , , , 13433 1655 42 _ _ NNP 13433 1655 43 Miscellanies Miscellanies NNP 13433 1655 44 _ _ NNP 13433 1655 45 . . . 13433 1656 1 On on IN 13433 1656 2 this this DT 13433 1656 3 work work NN 13433 1656 4 Mar Mar NNP 13433 1656 5 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1656 6 wrote write VBD 13433 1656 7 an an DT 13433 1656 8 exposition exposition NN 13433 1656 9 ; ; : 13433 1656 10 and and CC 13433 1656 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1656 12 commencement commencement NN 13433 1656 13 was--_In was--_In : 13433 1656 14 the the DT 13433 1656 15 beginning beginning NN 13433 1656 16 was be VBD 13433 1656 17 the the DT 13433 1656 18 Word Word NNP 13433 1656 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1656 20 . . . 13433 1657 1 Elias elia NNS 13433 1657 2 of of IN 13433 1657 3 Salamia Salamia NNP 13433 1657 4 , , , 13433 1657 5 who who WP 13433 1657 6 is be VBZ 13433 1657 7 also also RB 13433 1657 8 called call VBN 13433 1657 9 Aphthonius Aphthonius NNP 13433 1657 10 , , , 13433 1657 11 constructed construct VBD 13433 1657 12 a a DT 13433 1657 13 gospel gospel NN 13433 1657 14 after after IN 13433 1657 15 the the DT 13433 1657 16 likeness likeness NN 13433 1657 17 of of IN 13433 1657 18 the the DT 13433 1657 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1657 20 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1657 21 _ _ NNP 13433 1657 22 of of IN 13433 1657 23 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1657 24 , , , 13433 1657 25 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1657 26 by by IN 13433 1657 27 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1657 28 in in IN 13433 1657 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1657 30 prologue prologue NN 13433 1657 31 to to IN 13433 1657 32 the the DT 13433 1657 33 Canons canon NNS 13433 1657 34 which which WDT 13433 1657 35 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1657 36 made make VBD 13433 1657 37 for for IN 13433 1657 38 the the DT 13433 1657 39 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1657 40 . . . 13433 1658 1 Elias elias PRP 13433 1658 2 sought seek VBD 13433 1658 3 for for IN 13433 1658 4 that that DT 13433 1658 5 _ _ NNP 13433 1658 6 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1658 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1658 8 and and CC 13433 1658 9 could could MD 13433 1658 10 not not RB 13433 1658 11 find find VB 13433 1658 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1658 13 , , , 13433 1658 14 and and CC 13433 1658 15 in in IN 13433 1658 16 consequence consequence NN 13433 1658 17 constructed construct VBD 13433 1658 18 this this DT 13433 1658 19 after after IN 13433 1658 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1658 21 likeness likeness NN 13433 1658 22 . . . 13433 1659 1 And and CC 13433 1659 2 the the DT 13433 1659 3 said say VBN 13433 1659 4 Elias Elias NNP 13433 1659 5 finds find VBZ 13433 1659 6 fault fault NN 13433 1659 7 with with IN 13433 1659 8 several several JJ 13433 1659 9 things thing NNS 13433 1659 10 in in IN 13433 1659 11 the the DT 13433 1659 12 Canons Canons NNPS 13433 1659 13 of of IN 13433 1659 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1659 15 , , , 13433 1659 16 and and CC 13433 1659 17 points point VBZ 13433 1659 18 out out RP 13433 1659 19 errors error NNS 13433 1659 20 in in IN 13433 1659 21 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1659 22 , , , 13433 1659 23 and and CC 13433 1659 24 rightly rightly RB 13433 1659 25 . . . 13433 1660 1 But but CC 13433 1660 2 this this DT 13433 1660 3 copy copy NN 13433 1660 4 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1660 5 work work NN 13433 1660 6 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1660 7 which which WDT 13433 1660 8 Elias Elias NNP 13433 1660 9 composed compose VBN 13433 1660 10 is be VBZ 13433 1660 11 not not RB 13433 1660 12 often often RB 13433 1660 13 met meet VBN 13433 1660 14 with with IN 13433 1660 15 . . . 13433 1660 16 " " '' 13433 1661 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1661 2 148:1 148:1 LS 13433 1661 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1661 4 This this DT 13433 1661 5 information information NN 13433 1661 6 regarding regard VBG 13433 1661 7 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1661 8 -- -- : 13433 1661 9 who who WP 13433 1661 10 died die VBD 13433 1661 11 about about IN 13433 1661 12 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1661 13 373 373 CD 13433 1661 14 - - HYPH 13433 1661 15 -be -be NN 13433 1661 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1661 17 remembered remember VBD 13433 1661 18 , , , 13433 1661 19 is be VBZ 13433 1661 20 given give VBN 13433 1661 21 by by IN 13433 1661 22 a a DT 13433 1661 23 writer writer NN 13433 1661 24 of of IN 13433 1661 25 the the DT 13433 1661 26 twelfth twelfth JJ 13433 1661 27 century century NN 13433 1661 28 , , , 13433 1661 29 and and CC 13433 1661 30 but but CC 13433 1661 31 for for IN 13433 1661 32 this this DT 13433 1661 33 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1661 34 should should MD 13433 1661 35 not not RB 13433 1661 36 have have VB 13433 1661 37 known know VBN 13433 1661 38 from from IN 13433 1661 39 any any DT 13433 1661 40 ancient ancient JJ 13433 1661 41 independent independent JJ 13433 1661 42 source source NN 13433 1661 43 that that WDT 13433 1661 44 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1661 45 had have VBD 13433 1661 46 composed compose VBN 13433 1661 47 a a DT 13433 1661 48 commentary commentary NN 13433 1661 49 at at RB 13433 1661 50 all all RB 13433 1661 51 , , , 13433 1661 52 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1661 53 that that IN 13433 1661 54 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1661 55 did do VBD 13433 1661 56 so so RB 13433 1661 57 . . . 13433 1662 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1662 2 is be VBZ 13433 1662 3 important important JJ 13433 1662 4 to to TO 13433 1662 5 note note VB 13433 1662 6 , , , 13433 1662 7 however however RB 13433 1662 8 , , , 13433 1662 9 that that IN 13433 1662 10 a a DT 13433 1662 11 second second JJ 13433 1662 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1662 13 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1662 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1662 15 , , , 13433 1662 16 prepared prepare VBN 13433 1662 17 by by IN 13433 1662 18 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1662 19 , , , 13433 1662 20 is be VBZ 13433 1662 21 here here RB 13433 1662 22 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1662 23 , , , 13433 1662 24 and and CC 13433 1662 25 that that IN 13433 1662 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1662 27 was be VBD 13433 1662 28 also also RB 13433 1662 29 described describe VBN 13433 1662 30 by by IN 13433 1662 31 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1662 32 in in IN 13433 1662 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1662 34 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1662 35 to to IN 13433 1662 36 Carpianus Carpianus NNP 13433 1662 37 , , , 13433 1662 38 and and CC 13433 1662 39 further far RBR 13433 1662 40 that that IN 13433 1662 41 Bar Bar NNP 13433 1662 42 - - HYPH 13433 1662 43 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 1662 44 speaks speak VBZ 13433 1662 45 of of IN 13433 1662 46 a a DT 13433 1662 47 third third JJ 13433 1662 48 , , , 13433 1662 49 composed compose VBN 13433 1662 50 on on IN 13433 1662 51 the the DT 13433 1662 52 same same JJ 13433 1662 53 lines line NNS 13433 1662 54 by by IN 13433 1662 55 Elias elia NNS 13433 1662 56 . . . 13433 1663 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1663 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1663 3 disposes dispose VBZ 13433 1663 4 of of IN 13433 1663 5 the the DT 13433 1663 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1663 7 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1663 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1663 9 of of IN 13433 1663 10 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1663 11 in in IN 13433 1663 12 a a DT 13433 1663 13 very very RB 13433 1663 14 decided decide VBN 13433 1663 15 way way NN 13433 1663 16 . . . 13433 1664 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1664 2 says say VBZ 13433 1664 3 : : : 13433 1664 4 " " `` 13433 1664 5 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1664 6 was be VBD 13433 1664 7 quite quite RB 13433 1664 8 different different JJ 13433 1664 9 in in IN 13433 1664 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1664 11 character character NN 13433 1664 12 from from IN 13433 1664 13 the the DT 13433 1664 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1664 15 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1664 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1664 17 of of IN 13433 1664 18 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1664 19 . . . 13433 1665 1 The the DT 13433 1665 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1665 3 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1665 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1665 5 of of IN 13433 1665 6 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1665 7 was be VBD 13433 1665 8 a a DT 13433 1665 9 patchwork patchwork NN 13433 1665 10 of of IN 13433 1665 11 the the DT 13433 1665 12 four four CD 13433 1665 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1665 14 , , , 13433 1665 15 commencing commence VBG 13433 1665 16 with with IN 13433 1665 17 the the DT 13433 1665 18 preface preface NN 13433 1665 19 of of IN 13433 1665 20 St. St. NNP 13433 1665 21 John John NNP 13433 1665 22 . . . 13433 1666 1 The the DT 13433 1666 2 work work NN 13433 1666 3 of of IN 13433 1666 4 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1666 5 took take VBD 13433 1666 6 the the DT 13433 1666 7 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1666 8 of of IN 13433 1666 9 St. St. NNP 13433 1666 10 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1666 11 as as IN 13433 1666 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1666 13 standard standard NN 13433 1666 14 , , , 13433 1666 15 preserving preserve VBG 13433 1666 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1666 17 continuity continuity NN 13433 1666 18 , , , 13433 1666 19 and and CC 13433 1666 20 placed place VBN 13433 1666 21 side side NN 13433 1666 22 by by IN 13433 1666 23 side side NN 13433 1666 24 with with IN 13433 1666 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1666 26 parallel parallel VBZ 13433 1666 27 passages passage NNS 13433 1666 28 from from IN 13433 1666 29 the the DT 13433 1666 30 other other JJ 13433 1666 31 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1666 32 . . . 13433 1667 1 The the DT 13433 1667 2 principle principle NN 13433 1667 3 of of IN 13433 1667 4 the the DT 13433 1667 5 one one NN 13433 1667 6 was be VBD 13433 1667 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1667 8 amalgamation amalgamation NN 13433 1667 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1667 10 ; ; : 13433 1667 11 of of IN 13433 1667 12 the the DT 13433 1667 13 other other JJ 13433 1667 14 , , , 13433 1667 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1667 16 comparison comparison NN 13433 1667 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1667 18 . . . 13433 1668 1 No no DT 13433 1668 2 one one NN 13433 1668 3 who who WP 13433 1668 4 had have VBD 13433 1668 5 seen see VBN 13433 1668 6 the the DT 13433 1668 7 two two CD 13433 1668 8 works work NNS 13433 1668 9 could could MD 13433 1668 10 confuse confuse VB 13433 1668 11 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1668 12 , , , 13433 1668 13 though though IN 13433 1668 14 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1668 15 bore bear VBD 13433 1668 16 the the DT 13433 1668 17 same same JJ 13433 1668 18 name name NN 13433 1668 19 , , , 13433 1668 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1668 21 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1668 22 _ _ NNP 13433 1668 23 . . . 13433 1669 1 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1669 2 keeps keep VBZ 13433 1669 3 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1669 4 quite quite RB 13433 1669 5 distinct distinct JJ 13433 1669 6 . . . 13433 1670 1 So so RB 13433 1670 2 does do VBZ 13433 1670 3 Bar Bar NNP 13433 1670 4 - - HYPH 13433 1670 5 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 1670 6 . . . 13433 1671 1 Later later RB 13433 1671 2 on on RB 13433 1671 3 in in IN 13433 1671 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1671 5 commentary commentary NN 13433 1671 6 , , , 13433 1671 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1671 8 are be VBP 13433 1671 9 told tell VBN 13433 1671 10 , , , 13433 1671 11 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1671 12 quotes quote VBZ 13433 1671 13 both both DT 13433 1671 14 works work NNS 13433 1671 15 in in IN 13433 1671 16 the the DT 13433 1671 17 same same JJ 13433 1671 18 place place NN 13433 1671 19 . . . 13433 1671 20 " " '' 13433 1672 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1672 2 148:2 148:2 LS 13433 1672 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1672 4 Doubtless Doubtless NNP 13433 1672 5 , , , 13433 1672 6 no no DT 13433 1672 7 one one NN 13433 1672 8 comparing compare VBG 13433 1672 9 the the DT 13433 1672 10 two two CD 13433 1672 11 works work NNS 13433 1672 12 here here RB 13433 1672 13 described describe VBN 13433 1672 14 could could MD 13433 1672 15 confuse confuse VB 13433 1672 16 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1672 17 , , , 13433 1672 18 but but CC 13433 1672 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1672 20 is be VBZ 13433 1672 21 far far RB 13433 1672 22 from from IN 13433 1672 23 being be VBG 13433 1672 24 so so RB 13433 1672 25 clear clear JJ 13433 1672 26 that that IN 13433 1672 27 anyone anyone NN 13433 1672 28 who who WP 13433 1672 29 had have VBD 13433 1672 30 not not RB 13433 1672 31 seen see VBN 13433 1672 32 more more JJR 13433 1672 33 than than IN 13433 1672 34 one one CD 13433 1672 35 of of IN 13433 1672 36 these these DT 13433 1672 37 works work NNS 13433 1672 38 could could MD 13433 1672 39 with with IN 13433 1672 40 equal equal JJ 13433 1672 41 certainty certainty NN 13433 1672 42 distinguish distinguish VB 13433 1672 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1672 44 . . . 13433 1673 1 The the DT 13433 1673 2 statement statement NN 13433 1673 3 of of IN 13433 1673 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1673 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1673 6 quoted quote VBD 13433 1673 7 above above RB 13433 1673 8 , , , 13433 1673 9 that that IN 13433 1673 10 the the DT 13433 1673 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1673 12 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1673 13 _ _ NNP 13433 1673 14 of of IN 13433 1673 15 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1673 16 " " '' 13433 1673 17 took take VBD 13433 1673 18 the the DT 13433 1673 19 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1673 20 of of IN 13433 1673 21 St. St. NNP 13433 1673 22 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1673 23 as as IN 13433 1673 24 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1673 25 standard standard NN 13433 1673 26 , , , 13433 1673 27 preserving preserve VBG 13433 1673 28 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1673 29 continuity continuity NN 13433 1673 30 , , , 13433 1673 31 " " '' 13433 1673 32 certainly certainly RB 13433 1673 33 does do VBZ 13433 1673 34 not not RB 13433 1673 35 tend tend VB 13433 1673 36 to to TO 13433 1673 37 show show VB 13433 1673 38 that that IN 13433 1673 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1673 40 was be VBD 13433 1673 41 " " `` 13433 1673 42 quite quite RB 13433 1673 43 different different JJ 13433 1673 44 in in IN 13433 1673 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1673 46 character character NN 13433 1673 47 from from IN 13433 1673 48 the the DT 13433 1673 49 _ _ NNP 13433 1673 50 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1673 51 _ _ NNP 13433 1673 52 of of IN 13433 1673 53 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1673 54 , , , 13433 1673 55 " " '' 13433 1673 56 on on IN 13433 1673 57 the the DT 13433 1673 58 supposition supposition NN 13433 1673 59 that that IN 13433 1673 60 the the DT 13433 1673 61 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 1673 62 translation translation NN 13433 1673 63 lately lately RB 13433 1673 64 published publish VBD 13433 1673 65 represents represent VBZ 13433 1673 66 the the DT 13433 1673 67 work work NN 13433 1673 68 of of IN 13433 1673 69 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1673 70 . . . 13433 1674 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1674 2 will will MD 13433 1674 3 quote quote VB 13433 1674 4 what what WP 13433 1674 5 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1674 6 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 1674 7 says say VBZ 13433 1674 8 regarding regard VBG 13433 1674 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1674 10 , , , 13433 1674 11 in in IN 13433 1674 12 preference preference NN 13433 1674 13 to to IN 13433 1674 14 making make VBG 13433 1674 15 any any DT 13433 1674 16 statement statement NN 13433 1674 17 of of IN 13433 1674 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1674 19 own:-- own:-- NN 13433 1674 20 " " '' 13433 1674 21 On on IN 13433 1674 22 examining examine VBG 13433 1674 23 the the DT 13433 1674 24 _ _ NNP 13433 1674 25 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1674 26 _ _ NNP 13433 1674 27 as as IN 13433 1674 28 translated translate VBN 13433 1674 29 into into IN 13433 1674 30 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1674 31 from from IN 13433 1674 32 this this DT 13433 1674 33 Arabic Arabic NNP 13433 1674 34 , , , 13433 1674 35 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1674 36 find find VBP 13433 1674 37 in in RP 13433 1674 38 by by IN 13433 1674 39 far far RB 13433 1674 40 the the DT 13433 1674 41 greater great JJR 13433 1674 42 portion portion NN 13433 1674 43 of of IN 13433 1674 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1674 45 , , , 13433 1674 46 from from IN 13433 1674 47 the the DT 13433 1674 48 Sermon Sermon NNP 13433 1674 49 on on IN 13433 1674 50 the the DT 13433 1674 51 Mount Mount NNP 13433 1674 52 to to IN 13433 1674 53 the the DT 13433 1674 54 Last last JJ 13433 1674 55 Supper supper NN 13433 1674 56 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1674 57 § § ADD 13433 1674 58 § § CD 13433 1674 59 30 30 CD 13433 1674 60 - - SYM 13433 1674 61 134 134 CD 13433 1674 62 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1674 63 that that IN 13433 1674 64 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1674 65 , , , 13433 1674 66 like like IN 13433 1674 67 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1674 68 brother brother NN 13433 1674 69 harmonist harmonist NNP 13433 1674 70 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1674 71 , , , 13433 1674 72 took take VBD 13433 1674 73 St. St. NNP 13433 1674 74 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1674 75 as as IN 13433 1674 76 the the DT 13433 1674 77 basis basis NN 13433 1674 78 of of IN 13433 1674 79 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1674 80 work work NN 13433 1674 81 ... ... : 13433 1674 82 St. St. NNP 13433 1674 83 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1674 84 , , , 13433 1674 85 as as IN 13433 1674 86 might may MD 13433 1674 87 be be VB 13433 1674 88 expected expect VBN 13433 1674 89 , , , 13433 1674 90 runs run VBZ 13433 1674 91 parallel parallel JJ 13433 1674 92 with with IN 13433 1674 93 St. St. NNP 13433 1674 94 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1674 95 in in IN 13433 1674 96 the the DT 13433 1674 97 _ _ NNP 13433 1674 98 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1674 99 _ _ NNP 13433 1674 100 , , , 13433 1674 101 and and CC 13433 1674 102 is be VBZ 13433 1674 103 in in IN 13433 1674 104 a a DT 13433 1674 105 few few JJ 13433 1674 106 cases case NNS 13433 1674 107 the the DT 13433 1674 108 source source NN 13433 1674 109 out out IN 13433 1674 110 of of IN 13433 1674 111 which which WDT 13433 1674 112 incidents incident NNS 13433 1674 113 have have VBP 13433 1674 114 been be VBN 13433 1674 115 incorporated incorporate VBN 13433 1674 116 . . . 13433 1675 1 St. St. NNP 13433 1675 2 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1675 3 , , , 13433 1675 4 on on IN 13433 1675 5 the the DT 13433 1675 6 other other JJ 13433 1675 7 hand hand NN 13433 1675 8 , , , 13433 1675 9 is be VBZ 13433 1675 10 employed employ VBN 13433 1675 11 by by IN 13433 1675 12 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1675 13 , , , 13433 1675 14 as as RB 13433 1675 15 also also RB 13433 1675 16 in in IN 13433 1675 17 a a DT 13433 1675 18 lesser less JJR 13433 1675 19 degree degree NN 13433 1675 20 is be VBZ 13433 1675 21 St. St. NNP 13433 1675 22 John John NNP 13433 1675 23 , , , 13433 1675 24 in in IN 13433 1675 25 complete complete JJ 13433 1675 26 defiance defiance NN 13433 1675 27 of of IN 13433 1675 28 chronological chronological JJ 13433 1675 29 order order NN 13433 1675 30 . . . 13433 1675 31 " " '' 13433 1676 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1676 2 149:1 149:1 LS 13433 1676 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1676 4 This this DT 13433 1676 5 is be VBZ 13433 1676 6 not not RB 13433 1676 7 quite quite RB 13433 1676 8 so so RB 13433 1676 9 different different JJ 13433 1676 10 from from IN 13433 1676 11 the the DT 13433 1676 12 description description NN 13433 1676 13 of of IN 13433 1676 14 the the DT 13433 1676 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1676 16 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1676 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1676 18 of of IN 13433 1676 19 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1676 20 , , , 13433 1676 21 which which WDT 13433 1676 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1676 23 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1676 24 quotes:-- quotes:-- UH 13433 1676 25 " " `` 13433 1676 26 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1676 27 placed place VBD 13433 1676 28 side side NN 13433 1676 29 by by IN 13433 1676 30 side side NN 13433 1676 31 with with IN 13433 1676 32 the the DT 13433 1676 33 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1676 34 according accord VBG 13433 1676 35 to to IN 13433 1676 36 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1676 37 the the DT 13433 1676 38 corresponding correspond VBG 13433 1676 39 passages passage NNS 13433 1676 40 of of IN 13433 1676 41 the the DT 13433 1676 42 other other JJ 13433 1676 43 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 13433 1676 44 , , , 13433 1676 45 so so IN 13433 1676 46 that that IN 13433 1676 47 as as IN 13433 1676 48 a a DT 13433 1676 49 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1676 50 result result NN 13433 1676 51 the the DT 13433 1676 52 connection connection NN 13433 1676 53 of of IN 13433 1676 54 sequence sequence NN 13433 1676 55 in in IN 13433 1676 56 the the DT 13433 1676 57 three three CD 13433 1676 58 was be VBD 13433 1676 59 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 1676 60 so so RB 13433 1676 61 far far RB 13433 1676 62 as as IN 13433 1676 63 regards regard VBZ 13433 1676 64 the the DT 13433 1676 65 order order NN 13433 1676 66 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1676 67 texture texture NN 13433 1676 68 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1676 69 of of IN 13433 1676 70 reading reading NN 13433 1676 71 . . . 13433 1676 72 " " '' 13433 1677 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1677 2 149:2 149:2 LS 13433 1677 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1677 4 The the DT 13433 1677 5 next next JJ 13433 1677 6 witness witness NN 13433 1677 7 cited cite VBD 13433 1677 8 is be VBZ 13433 1677 9 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 1677 10 , , , 13433 1677 11 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 1677 12 of of IN 13433 1677 13 Cyrus Cyrus NNP 13433 1677 14 , , , 13433 1677 15 writing write VBG 13433 1677 16 about about IN 13433 1677 17 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1677 18 453 453 CD 13433 1677 19 , , , 13433 1677 20 and and CC 13433 1677 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1677 22 need need VBP 13433 1677 23 not not RB 13433 1677 24 quote quote VB 13433 1677 25 the the DT 13433 1677 26 well well RB 13433 1677 27 - - HYPH 13433 1677 28 known know VBN 13433 1677 29 passage passage NN 13433 1677 30 in in IN 13433 1677 31 which which WDT 13433 1677 32 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1677 33 describes describe VBZ 13433 1677 34 the the DT 13433 1677 35 suppression suppression NN 13433 1677 36 of of IN 13433 1677 37 some some DT 13433 1677 38 200 200 CD 13433 1677 39 copies copy NNS 13433 1677 40 of of IN 13433 1677 41 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1677 42 's 's POS 13433 1677 43 work work NN 13433 1677 44 in in IN 13433 1677 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1677 46 diocese diocese NN 13433 1677 47 , , , 13433 1677 48 which which WDT 13433 1677 49 were be VBD 13433 1677 50 in in IN 13433 1677 51 use use NN 13433 1677 52 " " `` 13433 1677 53 not not RB 13433 1677 54 only only RB 13433 1677 55 among among IN 13433 1677 56 persons person NNS 13433 1677 57 belonging belong VBG 13433 1677 58 to to IN 13433 1677 59 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1677 60 sect sect NN 13433 1677 61 , , , 13433 1677 62 but but CC 13433 1677 63 also also RB 13433 1677 64 among among IN 13433 1677 65 those those DT 13433 1677 66 who who WP 13433 1677 67 follow follow VBP 13433 1677 68 the the DT 13433 1677 69 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 1677 70 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 1677 71 , , , 13433 1677 72 " " `` 13433 1677 73 who who WP 13433 1677 74 did do VBD 13433 1677 75 not not RB 13433 1677 76 perceive perceive VB 13433 1677 77 the the DT 13433 1677 78 heretical heretical JJ 13433 1677 79 purpose purpose NN 13433 1677 80 of of IN 13433 1677 81 a a DT 13433 1677 82 book book NN 13433 1677 83 in in IN 13433 1677 84 which which WDT 13433 1677 85 the the DT 13433 1677 86 genealogies genealogy NNS 13433 1677 87 and and CC 13433 1677 88 other other JJ 13433 1677 89 passages passage NNS 13433 1677 90 showing show VBG 13433 1677 91 the the DT 13433 1677 92 Lord Lord NNP 13433 1677 93 to to TO 13433 1677 94 have have VB 13433 1677 95 been be VBN 13433 1677 96 born bear VBN 13433 1677 97 of of IN 13433 1677 98 the the DT 13433 1677 99 seed seed NN 13433 1677 100 of of IN 13433 1677 101 David David NNP 13433 1677 102 after after IN 13433 1677 103 the the DT 13433 1677 104 flesh flesh NN 13433 1677 105 were be VBD 13433 1677 106 suppressed suppress VBN 13433 1677 107 . . . 13433 1678 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1678 2 is be VBZ 13433 1678 3 a a DT 13433 1678 4 fact fact NN 13433 1678 5 , , , 13433 1678 6 however however RB 13433 1678 7 , , , 13433 1678 8 which which WDT 13433 1678 9 even even RB 13433 1678 10 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 1678 11 points point VBZ 13433 1678 12 out out RP 13433 1678 13 , , , 13433 1678 14 that that IN 13433 1678 15 , , , 13433 1678 16 in in IN 13433 1678 17 the the DT 13433 1678 18 alleged allege VBN 13433 1678 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1678 20 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1678 21 _ _ NNP 13433 1678 22 of of IN 13433 1678 23 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1678 24 , , , 13433 1678 25 these these DT 13433 1678 26 passages passage NNS 13433 1678 27 are be VBP 13433 1678 28 not not RB 13433 1678 29 all all RB 13433 1678 30 excised excise VBN 13433 1678 31 , , , 13433 1678 32 but but CC 13433 1678 33 still still RB 13433 1678 34 remain remain VBP 13433 1678 35 part part NN 13433 1678 36 of of IN 13433 1678 37 the the DT 13433 1678 38 text text NN 13433 1678 39 , , , 13433 1678 40 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1678 41 150:1 150:1 LS 13433 1678 42 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1678 43 as as IN 13433 1678 44 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1678 45 also also RB 13433 1678 46 do do VBP 13433 1678 47 in in IN 13433 1678 48 the the DT 13433 1678 49 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 1678 50 translation translation NN 13433 1678 51 . . . 13433 1679 1 This this DT 13433 1679 2 is be VBZ 13433 1679 3 the the DT 13433 1679 4 only only JJ 13433 1679 5 definite definite JJ 13433 1679 6 information information NN 13433 1679 7 which which WDT 13433 1679 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1679 9 possess possess VBP 13433 1679 10 of of IN 13433 1679 11 the the DT 13433 1679 12 contents content NNS 13433 1679 13 of of IN 13433 1679 14 the the DT 13433 1679 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1679 16 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1679 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1679 18 beyond beyond IN 13433 1679 19 the the DT 13433 1679 20 opening opening NN 13433 1679 21 words word NNS 13433 1679 22 , , , 13433 1679 23 and and CC 13433 1679 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1679 25 does do VBZ 13433 1679 26 not not RB 13433 1679 27 tally tally VB 13433 1679 28 with with IN 13433 1679 29 the the DT 13433 1679 30 recently recently RB 13433 1679 31 discovered discover VBN 13433 1679 32 works work NNS 13433 1679 33 . . . 13433 1680 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1680 2 need need VBP 13433 1680 3 not not RB 13433 1680 4 further further RB 13433 1680 5 discuss discuss VB 13433 1680 6 here here RB 13433 1680 7 the the DT 13433 1680 8 statement statement NN 13433 1680 9 of of IN 13433 1680 10 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 13433 1680 11 that that IN 13433 1680 12 some some DT 13433 1680 13 called call VBN 13433 1680 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1680 15 's 's POS 13433 1680 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1680 17 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1680 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1680 19 the the DT 13433 1680 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1680 21 according accord VBG 13433 1680 22 to to IN 13433 1680 23 the the DT 13433 1680 24 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 1680 25 . . . 13433 1681 1 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 13433 1681 2 had have VBD 13433 1681 3 not not RB 13433 1681 4 seen see VBN 13433 1681 5 the the DT 13433 1681 6 work work NN 13433 1681 7 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1681 8 , , , 13433 1681 9 and and CC 13433 1681 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1681 11 leaves leave VBZ 13433 1681 12 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1681 13 in in IN 13433 1681 14 the the DT 13433 1681 15 same same JJ 13433 1681 16 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1681 17 as as IN 13433 1681 18 to to IN 13433 1681 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1681 20 character character NN 13433 1681 21 . . . 13433 1682 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1682 2 is be VBZ 13433 1682 3 clear clear JJ 13433 1682 4 from from IN 13433 1682 5 all all PDT 13433 1682 6 this this DT 13433 1682 7 that that IN 13433 1682 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1682 9 have have VBP 13433 1682 10 no no DT 13433 1682 11 detailed detailed JJ 13433 1682 12 information information NN 13433 1682 13 regarding regard VBG 13433 1682 14 the the DT 13433 1682 15 _ _ NNP 13433 1682 16 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1682 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1682 18 of of IN 13433 1682 19 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1682 20 . . . 13433 1683 1 As as IN 13433 1683 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1683 3 Donaldson Donaldson NNP 13433 1683 4 said say VBD 13433 1683 5 long long RB 13433 1683 6 ago ago RB 13433 1683 7 : : : 13433 1683 8 " " `` 13433 1683 9 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 10 should should MD 13433 1683 11 not not RB 13433 1683 12 be be VB 13433 1683 13 able able JJ 13433 1683 14 to to TO 13433 1683 15 identify identify VB 13433 1683 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 17 , , , 13433 1683 18 even even RB 13433 1683 19 if if IN 13433 1683 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 21 did do VBD 13433 1683 22 come come VB 13433 1683 23 down down RP 13433 1683 24 to to IN 13433 1683 25 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 26 , , , 13433 1683 27 unless unless IN 13433 1683 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 29 told tell VBD 13433 1683 30 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 31 something something NN 13433 1683 32 reliable reliable JJ 13433 1683 33 about about IN 13433 1683 34 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1683 35 . . . 13433 1683 36 " " '' 13433 1684 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1684 2 150:2 150:2 LS 13433 1684 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1684 4 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1684 5 may may MD 13433 1684 6 now now RB 13433 1684 7 come come VB 13433 1684 8 to to IN 13433 1684 9 the the DT 13433 1684 10 documents document NNS 13433 1684 11 recently recently RB 13433 1684 12 published publish VBN 13433 1684 13 . . . 13433 1685 1 The the DT 13433 1685 2 MS MS NNP 13433 1685 3 . . NNP 13433 1685 4 of of IN 13433 1685 5 the the DT 13433 1685 6 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 1685 7 version version NN 13433 1685 8 of of IN 13433 1685 9 the the DT 13433 1685 10 commentary commentary NN 13433 1685 11 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1685 12 to to IN 13433 1685 13 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1685 14 is be VBZ 13433 1685 15 dated date VBN 13433 1685 16 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1685 17 1195 1195 CD 13433 1685 18 , , , 13433 1685 19 and and CC 13433 1685 20 Moesinger Moesinger NNP 13433 1685 21 declares declare VBZ 13433 1685 22 that that IN 13433 1685 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1685 24 is be VBZ 13433 1685 25 translated translate VBN 13433 1685 26 from from IN 13433 1685 27 the the DT 13433 1685 28 Syriac Syriac NNPS 13433 1685 29 , , , 13433 1685 30 of of IN 13433 1685 31 which which WDT 13433 1685 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1685 33 is be VBZ 13433 1685 34 said say VBN 13433 1685 35 to to TO 13433 1685 36 retain retain VB 13433 1685 37 many many JJ 13433 1685 38 traces trace NNS 13433 1685 39 . . . 13433 1686 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1686 2 150:3 150:3 LS 13433 1686 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1686 4 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1686 5 states state VBZ 13433 1686 6 that that IN 13433 1686 7 in in IN 13433 1686 8 the the DT 13433 1686 9 judgment judgment NN 13433 1686 10 of of IN 13433 1686 11 the the DT 13433 1686 12 Mechitarist Mechitarist NNP 13433 1686 13 Fathers Fathers NNP 13433 1686 14 the the DT 13433 1686 15 translation translation NN 13433 1686 16 dates date VBZ 13433 1686 17 from from IN 13433 1686 18 about about IN 13433 1686 19 the the DT 13433 1686 20 fifth fifth JJ 13433 1686 21 century century NN 13433 1686 22 , , , 13433 1686 23 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1686 24 150:4 150:4 CD 13433 1686 25 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1686 26 but but CC 13433 1686 27 an an DT 13433 1686 28 opinion opinion NN 13433 1686 29 on on IN 13433 1686 30 such such PDT 13433 1686 31 a a DT 13433 1686 32 point point NN 13433 1686 33 can can MD 13433 1686 34 only only RB 13433 1686 35 be be VB 13433 1686 36 received receive VBN 13433 1686 37 with with IN 13433 1686 38 great great JJ 13433 1686 39 caution caution NN 13433 1686 40 . . . 13433 1687 1 The the DT 13433 1687 2 name name NN 13433 1687 3 of of IN 13433 1687 4 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1687 5 is be VBZ 13433 1687 6 not not RB 13433 1687 7 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1687 8 as as IN 13433 1687 9 the the DT 13433 1687 10 author author NN 13433 1687 11 of of IN 13433 1687 12 the the DT 13433 1687 13 " " `` 13433 1687 14 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1687 15 , , , 13433 1687 16 " " '' 13433 1687 17 and and CC 13433 1687 18 the the DT 13433 1687 19 question question NN 13433 1687 20 is be VBZ 13433 1687 21 open open JJ 13433 1687 22 as as IN 13433 1687 23 to to IN 13433 1687 24 whether whether IN 13433 1687 25 the the DT 13433 1687 26 authorship authorship NN 13433 1687 27 of of IN 13433 1687 28 the the DT 13433 1687 29 commentary commentary NN 13433 1687 30 is be VBZ 13433 1687 31 rightly rightly RB 13433 1687 32 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1687 33 to to IN 13433 1687 34 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1687 35 Syrus Syrus NNP 13433 1687 36 . . . 13433 1688 1 In in IN 13433 1688 2 any any DT 13433 1688 3 case case NN 13433 1688 4 there there EX 13433 1688 5 can can MD 13433 1688 6 be be VB 13433 1688 7 no no DT 13433 1688 8 doubt doubt NN 13433 1688 9 that that IN 13433 1688 10 the the DT 13433 1688 11 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 1688 12 work work NN 13433 1688 13 is be VBZ 13433 1688 14 a a DT 13433 1688 15 translation translation NN 13433 1688 16 . . . 13433 1689 1 The the DT 13433 1689 2 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 1689 3 work work NN 13433 1689 4 published publish VBN 13433 1689 5 by by IN 13433 1689 6 Ciasca Ciasca NNP 13433 1689 7 , , , 13433 1689 8 and and CC 13433 1689 9 supposed suppose VBD 13433 1689 10 to to TO 13433 1689 11 be be VB 13433 1689 12 a a DT 13433 1689 13 version version NN 13433 1689 14 of of IN 13433 1689 15 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1689 16 's 's POS 13433 1689 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1689 18 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1689 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1689 20 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1689 21 , , , 13433 1689 22 is be VBZ 13433 1689 23 derived derive VBN 13433 1689 24 from from IN 13433 1689 25 two two CD 13433 1689 26 manuscripts manuscript NNS 13433 1689 27 , , , 13433 1689 28 one one NN 13433 1689 29 belonging belong VBG 13433 1689 30 to to IN 13433 1689 31 the the DT 13433 1689 32 Vatican Vatican NNP 13433 1689 33 Library Library NNP 13433 1689 34 and and CC 13433 1689 35 the the DT 13433 1689 36 other other JJ 13433 1689 37 forwarded forward VBD 13433 1689 38 to to IN 13433 1689 39 Rome Rome NNP 13433 1689 40 from from IN 13433 1689 41 Egypt Egypt NNP 13433 1689 42 by by IN 13433 1689 43 the the DT 13433 1689 44 Vicar Vicar NNP 13433 1689 45 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 1689 46 of of IN 13433 1689 47 the the DT 13433 1689 48 Catholic Catholic NNP 13433 1689 49 Copts Copts NNPS 13433 1689 50 . . . 13433 1690 1 The the DT 13433 1690 2 latter latter JJ 13433 1690 3 MS MS NNP 13433 1690 4 . . . 13433 1690 5 states state NNS 13433 1690 6 , , , 13433 1690 7 in in IN 13433 1690 8 notes note NNS 13433 1690 9 at at IN 13433 1690 10 the the DT 13433 1690 11 beginning beginning NN 13433 1690 12 and and CC 13433 1690 13 end end NN 13433 1690 14 , , , 13433 1690 15 that that IN 13433 1690 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1690 17 is be VBZ 13433 1690 18 an an DT 13433 1690 19 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 1690 20 translation translation NN 13433 1690 21 of of IN 13433 1690 22 the the DT 13433 1690 23 _ _ NNP 13433 1690 24 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1690 25 _ _ NNP 13433 1690 26 of of IN 13433 1690 27 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1690 28 , , , 13433 1690 29 made make VBN 13433 1690 30 from from IN 13433 1690 31 the the DT 13433 1690 32 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1690 33 by by IN 13433 1690 34 the the DT 13433 1690 35 presbyter presbyter NN 13433 1690 36 Abû Abû NNP 13433 1690 37 - - HYPH 13433 1690 38 l l NNP 13433 1690 39 - - HYPH 13433 1690 40 Pharag Pharag NNP 13433 1690 41 Abdullah Abdullah NNP 13433 1690 42 Ben Ben NNP 13433 1690 43 - - HYPH 13433 1690 44 at at IN 13433 1690 45 - - HYPH 13433 1690 46 Tib Tib NNP 13433 1690 47 , , , 13433 1690 48 who who WP 13433 1690 49 is be VBZ 13433 1690 50 believed believe VBN 13433 1690 51 to to TO 13433 1690 52 have have VB 13433 1690 53 flourished flourish VBN 13433 1690 54 in in IN 13433 1690 55 the the DT 13433 1690 56 first first JJ 13433 1690 57 half half NN 13433 1690 58 of of IN 13433 1690 59 the the DT 13433 1690 60 eleventh eleventh JJ 13433 1690 61 century century NN 13433 1690 62 , , , 13433 1690 63 and and CC 13433 1690 64 in in IN 13433 1690 65 one one CD 13433 1690 66 of of IN 13433 1690 67 these these DT 13433 1690 68 notes note VBZ 13433 1690 69 the the DT 13433 1690 70 name name NN 13433 1690 71 of of IN 13433 1690 72 the the DT 13433 1690 73 scribe scribe NN 13433 1690 74 who who WP 13433 1690 75 wrote write VBD 13433 1690 76 the the DT 13433 1690 77 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1690 78 copy copy NN 13433 1690 79 is be VBZ 13433 1690 80 given give VBN 13433 1690 81 , , , 13433 1690 82 which which WDT 13433 1690 83 leads lead VBZ 13433 1690 84 to to IN 13433 1690 85 the the DT 13433 1690 86 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1690 87 that that WDT 13433 1690 88 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1690 89 may may MD 13433 1690 90 have have VB 13433 1690 91 been be VBN 13433 1690 92 dated date VBN 13433 1690 93 about about IN 13433 1690 94 the the DT 13433 1690 95 end end NN 13433 1690 96 of of IN 13433 1690 97 the the DT 13433 1690 98 ninth ninth JJ 13433 1690 99 century century NN 13433 1690 100 . . . 13433 1691 1 A a DT 13433 1691 2 note note NN 13433 1691 3 in in IN 13433 1691 4 the the DT 13433 1691 5 Vatican Vatican NNP 13433 1691 6 MS MS NNP 13433 1691 7 . . . 13433 1691 8 also also RB 13433 1691 9 ascribes ascribe VBZ 13433 1691 10 the the DT 13433 1691 11 original original JJ 13433 1691 12 work work NN 13433 1691 13 to to IN 13433 1691 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1691 15 . . . 13433 1692 1 These these DT 13433 1692 2 notes note NNS 13433 1692 3 constitute constitute VBP 13433 1692 4 the the DT 13433 1692 5 principal principal JJ 13433 1692 6 or or CC 13433 1692 7 only only RB 13433 1692 8 ground ground NN 13433 1692 9 for for IN 13433 1692 10 connecting connect VBG 13433 1692 11 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1692 12 's 's POS 13433 1692 13 name name NN 13433 1692 14 with with IN 13433 1692 15 the the DT 13433 1692 16 " " `` 13433 1692 17 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1692 18 . . . 13433 1692 19 " " '' 13433 1693 1 So so RB 13433 1693 2 little little JJ 13433 1693 3 is be VBZ 13433 1693 4 known know VBN 13433 1693 5 regarding regard VBG 13433 1693 6 the the DT 13433 1693 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1693 8 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1693 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1693 10 of of IN 13433 1693 11 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1693 12 that that WDT 13433 1693 13 even even RB 13433 1693 14 the the DT 13433 1693 15 language language NN 13433 1693 16 in in IN 13433 1693 17 which which WDT 13433 1693 18 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1693 19 was be VBD 13433 1693 20 written write VBN 13433 1693 21 is be VBZ 13433 1693 22 matter matter NN 13433 1693 23 of of IN 13433 1693 24 vehement vehement JJ 13433 1693 25 debate debate NN 13433 1693 26 . . . 13433 1694 1 The the DT 13433 1694 2 name name NN 13433 1694 3 would would MD 13433 1694 4 , , , 13433 1694 5 of of IN 13433 1694 6 course course NN 13433 1694 7 , , , 13433 1694 8 lead lead VB 13433 1694 9 to to IN 13433 1694 10 the the DT 13433 1694 11 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1694 12 that that IN 13433 1694 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 14 was be VBD 13433 1694 15 a a DT 13433 1694 16 Greek greek JJ 13433 1694 17 composition composition NN 13433 1694 18 , , , 13433 1694 19 and and CC 13433 1694 20 many many JJ 13433 1694 21 other other JJ 13433 1694 22 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1694 23 support support VBP 13433 1694 24 this this DT 13433 1694 25 , , , 13433 1694 26 but but CC 13433 1694 27 the the DT 13433 1694 28 mere mere JJ 13433 1694 29 fact fact NN 13433 1694 30 that that IN 13433 1694 31 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 32 does do VBZ 13433 1694 33 not not RB 13433 1694 34 seem seem VB 13433 1694 35 to to TO 13433 1694 36 have have VB 13433 1694 37 been be VBN 13433 1694 38 known know VBN 13433 1694 39 to to IN 13433 1694 40 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1694 41 Fathers Fathers NNP 13433 1694 42 , , , 13433 1694 43 and and CC 13433 1694 44 that that IN 13433 1694 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 46 is be VBZ 13433 1694 47 very very RB 13433 1694 48 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1694 49 whether whether IN 13433 1694 50 any any DT 13433 1694 51 of of IN 13433 1694 52 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 53 , , , 13433 1694 54 with with IN 13433 1694 55 the the DT 13433 1694 56 exception exception NN 13433 1694 57 of of IN 13433 1694 58 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 1694 59 , , , 13433 1694 60 had have VBD 13433 1694 61 ever ever RB 13433 1694 62 seen see VBN 13433 1694 63 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 64 , , , 13433 1694 65 has have VBZ 13433 1694 66 led lead VBN 13433 1694 67 many many JJ 13433 1694 68 critics critic NNS 13433 1694 69 to to TO 13433 1694 70 maintain maintain VB 13433 1694 71 that that IN 13433 1694 72 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1694 73 was be VBD 13433 1694 74 written write VBN 13433 1694 75 in in IN 13433 1694 76 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1694 77 . . . 13433 1695 1 Nothing nothing NN 13433 1695 2 but but CC 13433 1695 3 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 13433 1695 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 1695 5 of of IN 13433 1695 6 this this DT 13433 1695 7 can can MD 13433 1695 8 be be VB 13433 1695 9 produced produce VBN 13433 1695 10 . . . 13433 1696 1 This this DT 13433 1696 2 alone alone RB 13433 1696 3 shows show VBZ 13433 1696 4 how how WRB 13433 1696 5 little little JJ 13433 1696 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1696 7 really really RB 13433 1696 8 know know VBP 13433 1696 9 of of IN 13433 1696 10 the the DT 13433 1696 11 original original NN 13433 1696 12 . . . 13433 1697 1 The the DT 13433 1697 2 recently recently RB 13433 1697 3 discovered discover VBN 13433 1697 4 works work NNS 13433 1697 5 , , , 13433 1697 6 being be VBG 13433 1697 7 in in IN 13433 1697 8 Arabic Arabic NNP 13433 1697 9 and and CC 13433 1697 10 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 1697 11 , , , 13433 1697 12 even even RB 13433 1697 13 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1697 14 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1697 15 to to TO 13433 1697 16 be be VB 13433 1697 17 translations translation NNS 13433 1697 18 from from IN 13433 1697 19 the the DT 13433 1697 20 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1697 21 and and CC 13433 1697 22 that that IN 13433 1697 23 the the DT 13433 1697 24 _ _ NNP 13433 1697 25 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1697 26 _ _ NNP 13433 1697 27 was be VBD 13433 1697 28 composed compose VBN 13433 1697 29 in in IN 13433 1697 30 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 1697 31 , , , 13433 1697 32 can can MD 13433 1697 33 only only RB 13433 1697 34 indirectly indirectly RB 13433 1697 35 represent represent VB 13433 1697 36 the the DT 13433 1697 37 original original JJ 13433 1697 38 , , , 13433 1697 39 and and CC 13433 1697 40 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1697 41 obviously obviously RB 13433 1697 42 labour labour VBP 13433 1697 43 under under IN 13433 1697 44 fatal fatal JJ 13433 1697 45 disability disability NN 13433 1697 46 in in IN 13433 1697 47 regard regard NN 13433 1697 48 to to IN 13433 1697 49 a a DT 13433 1697 50 restoration restoration NN 13433 1697 51 of of IN 13433 1697 52 the the DT 13433 1697 53 text text NN 13433 1697 54 of of IN 13433 1697 55 the the DT 13433 1697 56 documents document NNS 13433 1697 57 at at IN 13433 1697 58 the the DT 13433 1697 59 basis basis NN 13433 1697 60 of of IN 13433 1697 61 the the DT 13433 1697 62 work work NN 13433 1697 63 . . . 13433 1698 1 Between between IN 13433 1698 2 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1698 3 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 1698 4 of of IN 13433 1698 5 rendering rendering JJ 13433 1698 6 and and CC 13433 1698 7 evident evident JJ 13433 1698 8 work work NN 13433 1698 9 of of IN 13433 1698 10 revision revision NN 13433 1698 11 , , , 13433 1698 12 the the DT 13433 1698 13 original original JJ 13433 1698 14 matter matter NN 13433 1698 15 can can MD 13433 1698 16 not not RB 13433 1698 17 but but CC 13433 1698 18 be be VB 13433 1698 19 seriously seriously RB 13433 1698 20 disfigured disfigure VBN 13433 1698 21 . . . 13433 1699 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1699 2 is be VBZ 13433 1699 3 certain certain JJ 13433 1699 4 that that IN 13433 1699 5 the the DT 13433 1699 6 name name NN 13433 1699 7 of of IN 13433 1699 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1699 9 did do VBD 13433 1699 10 not not RB 13433 1699 11 appear appear VB 13433 1699 12 as as IN 13433 1699 13 the the DT 13433 1699 14 author author NN 13433 1699 15 of of IN 13433 1699 16 the the DT 13433 1699 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1699 18 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1699 19 _ _ NNP 13433 1699 20 . . . 13433 1700 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1700 2 152:1 152:1 LS 13433 1700 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1700 4 This this DT 13433 1700 5 is be VBZ 13433 1700 6 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1700 7 from from IN 13433 1700 8 the the DT 13433 1700 9 very very JJ 13433 1700 10 nature nature NN 13433 1700 11 of of IN 13433 1700 12 the the DT 13433 1700 13 composition composition NN 13433 1700 14 and and CC 13433 1700 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1700 16 object object NN 13433 1700 17 . . . 13433 1701 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1701 2 have have VBP 13433 1701 3 met meet VBN 13433 1701 4 with with IN 13433 1701 5 three three CD 13433 1701 6 works work NNS 13433 1701 7 of of IN 13433 1701 8 this this DT 13433 1701 9 description description NN 13433 1701 10 and and CC 13433 1701 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1701 12 is be VBZ 13433 1701 13 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1701 14 to to TO 13433 1701 15 say say VB 13433 1701 16 how how WRB 13433 1701 17 many many JJ 13433 1701 18 more more JJR 13433 1701 19 may may MD 13433 1701 20 not not RB 13433 1701 21 have have VB 13433 1701 22 existed exist VBN 13433 1701 23 . . . 13433 1702 1 As as IN 13433 1702 2 the the DT 13433 1702 3 most most RBS 13433 1702 4 celebrated celebrated JJ 13433 1702 5 , , , 13433 1702 6 by by IN 13433 1702 7 name name NN 13433 1702 8 at at IN 13433 1702 9 least least RBS 13433 1702 10 , , , 13433 1702 11 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1702 12 is be VBZ 13433 1702 13 almost almost RB 13433 1702 14 certain certain JJ 13433 1702 15 that that IN 13433 1702 16 , , , 13433 1702 17 as as IN 13433 1702 18 time time NN 13433 1702 19 went go VBD 13433 1702 20 on on RP 13433 1702 21 and and CC 13433 1702 22 the the DT 13433 1702 23 identity identity NN 13433 1702 24 of of IN 13433 1702 25 such such JJ 13433 1702 26 works work NNS 13433 1702 27 was be VBD 13433 1702 28 lost lose VBN 13433 1702 29 , , , 13433 1702 30 the the DT 13433 1702 31 first first JJ 13433 1702 32 idea idea NN 13433 1702 33 of of IN 13433 1702 34 anyone anyone NN 13433 1702 35 meeting meet VBG 13433 1702 36 with with IN 13433 1702 37 such such PDT 13433 1702 38 a a DT 13433 1702 39 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1702 40 must must MD 13433 1702 41 have have VB 13433 1702 42 been be VBN 13433 1702 43 that that IN 13433 1702 44 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1702 45 was be VBD 13433 1702 46 the the DT 13433 1702 47 _ _ NNP 13433 1702 48 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1702 49 _ _ NNP 13433 1702 50 of of IN 13433 1702 51 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1702 52 . . . 13433 1703 1 What what WP 13433 1703 2 means mean VBZ 13433 1703 3 could could MD 13433 1703 4 there there EX 13433 1703 5 be be VB 13433 1703 6 of of IN 13433 1703 7 correcting correct VBG 13433 1703 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1703 9 and and CC 13433 1703 10 positively positively RB 13433 1703 11 ascertaining ascertain VBG 13433 1703 12 the the DT 13433 1703 13 truth truth NN 13433 1703 14 ? ? . 13433 1704 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1704 2 is be VBZ 13433 1704 3 not not RB 13433 1704 4 as as IN 13433 1704 5 if if IN 13433 1704 6 such such PDT 13433 1704 7 a a DT 13433 1704 8 work work NN 13433 1704 9 were be VBD 13433 1704 10 a a DT 13433 1704 11 personal personal JJ 13433 1704 12 composition composition NN 13433 1704 13 , , , 13433 1704 14 showing show VBG 13433 1704 15 individuality individuality NN 13433 1704 16 of of IN 13433 1704 17 style style NN 13433 1704 18 and and CC 13433 1704 19 invention invention NN 13433 1704 20 ; ; : 13433 1704 21 but but CC 13433 1704 22 supposing suppose VBG 13433 1704 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1704 24 to to TO 13433 1704 25 be be VB 13433 1704 26 a a DT 13433 1704 27 harmony harmony NN 13433 1704 28 of of IN 13433 1704 29 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1704 30 already already RB 13433 1704 31 current current JJ 13433 1704 32 , , , 13433 1704 33 and and CC 13433 1704 34 consequently consequently RB 13433 1704 35 varying vary VBG 13433 1704 36 from from IN 13433 1704 37 similar similar JJ 13433 1704 38 harmonies harmony NNS 13433 1704 39 merely merely RB 13433 1704 40 in in IN 13433 1704 41 details detail NNS 13433 1704 42 of of IN 13433 1704 43 compilation compilation NN 13433 1704 44 and and CC 13433 1704 45 arrangement arrangement NN 13433 1704 46 , , , 13433 1704 47 how how WRB 13433 1704 48 is be VBZ 13433 1704 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1704 50 possible possible JJ 13433 1704 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1704 52 authorship authorship NN 13433 1704 53 could could MD 13433 1704 54 remain remain VB 13433 1704 55 in in IN 13433 1704 56 the the DT 13433 1704 57 least least JJS 13433 1704 58 degree degree NN 13433 1704 59 certain certain JJ 13433 1704 60 , , , 13433 1704 61 in in IN 13433 1704 62 the the DT 13433 1704 63 absence absence NN 13433 1704 64 of of IN 13433 1704 65 an an DT 13433 1704 66 arranger arranger NN 13433 1704 67 's 's POS 13433 1704 68 name name NN 13433 1704 69 ? ? . 13433 1705 1 An an DT 13433 1705 2 illustration illustration NN 13433 1705 3 of of IN 13433 1705 4 all all PDT 13433 1705 5 this this DT 13433 1705 6 is be VBZ 13433 1705 7 aptly aptly RB 13433 1705 8 supplied supply VBN 13433 1705 9 in in IN 13433 1705 10 the the DT 13433 1705 11 case case NN 13433 1705 12 of of IN 13433 1705 13 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1705 14 of of IN 13433 1705 15 Capua Capua NNP 13433 1705 16 , , , 13433 1705 17 and and CC 13433 1705 18 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1705 19 will will MD 13433 1705 20 allow allow VB 13433 1705 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1705 22 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1705 23 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1705 24 to to TO 13433 1705 25 tell tell VB 13433 1705 26 the the DT 13433 1705 27 story story NN 13433 1705 28 . . . 13433 1706 1 " " `` 13433 1706 2 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1706 3 , , , 13433 1706 4 who who WP 13433 1706 5 flourished flourish VBD 13433 1706 6 about about IN 13433 1706 7 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 1706 8 545 545 CD 13433 1706 9 , , , 13433 1706 10 happened happen VBD 13433 1706 11 to to TO 13433 1706 12 stumble stumble VB 13433 1706 13 upon upon IN 13433 1706 14 an an DT 13433 1706 15 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1706 16 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1706 17 or or CC 13433 1706 18 Digest Digest NNP 13433 1706 19 of of IN 13433 1706 20 the the DT 13433 1706 21 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1706 22 , , , 13433 1706 23 and and CC 13433 1706 24 began begin VBD 13433 1706 25 in in IN 13433 1706 26 consequence consequence NN 13433 1706 27 to to TO 13433 1706 28 investigate investigate VB 13433 1706 29 the the DT 13433 1706 30 authorship authorship NN 13433 1706 31 . . . 13433 1707 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1707 2 found find VBD 13433 1707 3 two two CD 13433 1707 4 notices notice NNS 13433 1707 5 in in IN 13433 1707 6 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 1707 7 of of IN 13433 1707 8 such such JJ 13433 1707 9 Harmonies harmony NNS 13433 1707 10 ; ; : 13433 1707 11 one one CD 13433 1707 12 in in IN 13433 1707 13 the the DT 13433 1707 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1707 15 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 1707 16 to to IN 13433 1707 17 Carpianus Carpianus NNP 13433 1707 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1707 19 prefixed prefix VBN 13433 1707 20 to to IN 13433 1707 21 the the DT 13433 1707 22 canons canon NNS 13433 1707 23 , , , 13433 1707 24 relating relate VBG 13433 1707 25 to to IN 13433 1707 26 the the DT 13433 1707 27 work work NN 13433 1707 28 of of IN 13433 1707 29 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1707 30 ; ; : 13433 1707 31 another another DT 13433 1707 32 in in IN 13433 1707 33 the the DT 13433 1707 34 _ _ NNP 13433 1707 35 Ecclesiastical Ecclesiastical NNP 13433 1707 36 History History NNP 13433 1707 37 _ _ NNP 13433 1707 38 , , , 13433 1707 39 relating relate VBG 13433 1707 40 to to IN 13433 1707 41 that that DT 13433 1707 42 of of IN 13433 1707 43 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1707 44 . . . 13433 1708 1 Assuming assume VBG 13433 1708 2 that that IN 13433 1708 3 the the DT 13433 1708 4 work work NN 13433 1708 5 which which WDT 13433 1708 6 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1708 7 had have VBD 13433 1708 8 discovered discover VBN 13433 1708 9 must must MD 13433 1708 10 be be VB 13433 1708 11 one one CD 13433 1708 12 or or CC 13433 1708 13 other other JJ 13433 1708 14 , , , 13433 1708 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1708 16 decides decide VBZ 13433 1708 17 in in IN 13433 1708 18 favour favour NN 13433 1708 19 of of IN 13433 1708 20 the the DT 13433 1708 21 latter latter JJ 13433 1708 22 , , , 13433 1708 23 because because IN 13433 1708 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1708 25 does do VBZ 13433 1708 26 not not RB 13433 1708 27 give give VB 13433 1708 28 St. St. NNP 13433 1708 29 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1708 30 continuously continuously RB 13433 1708 31 and and CC 13433 1708 32 append append VB 13433 1708 33 the the DT 13433 1708 34 passages passage NNS 13433 1708 35 of of IN 13433 1708 36 the the DT 13433 1708 37 other other JJ 13433 1708 38 evangelists evangelist NNS 13433 1708 39 , , , 13433 1708 40 as as IN 13433 1708 41 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1708 42 states state VBZ 13433 1708 43 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1708 44 to to TO 13433 1708 45 have have VB 13433 1708 46 done do VBN 13433 1708 47 . . . 13433 1709 1 All all PDT 13433 1709 2 this this DT 13433 1709 3 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1709 4 tells tell VBZ 13433 1709 5 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1709 6 in in IN 13433 1709 7 the the DT 13433 1709 8 preface preface NN 13433 1709 9 to to IN 13433 1709 10 this this DT 13433 1709 11 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1709 12 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1709 13 , , , 13433 1709 14 which which WDT 13433 1709 15 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1709 16 publishes publish VBZ 13433 1709 17 in in IN 13433 1709 18 a a DT 13433 1709 19 Latin latin JJ 13433 1709 20 dress dress NN 13433 1709 21 . . . 13433 1710 1 " " `` 13433 1710 2 There there EX 13433 1710 3 can can MD 13433 1710 4 be be VB 13433 1710 5 no no DT 13433 1710 6 doubt doubt NN 13433 1710 7 that that IN 13433 1710 8 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1710 9 was be VBD 13433 1710 10 mistaken mistake VBN 13433 1710 11 about about IN 13433 1710 12 the the DT 13433 1710 13 authorship authorship NN 13433 1710 14 ; ; : 13433 1710 15 for for IN 13433 1710 16 though though IN 13433 1710 17 the the DT 13433 1710 18 work work NN 13433 1710 19 is be VBZ 13433 1710 20 constructed construct VBN 13433 1710 21 on on IN 13433 1710 22 the the DT 13433 1710 23 same same JJ 13433 1710 24 general general JJ 13433 1710 25 plan plan NN 13433 1710 26 as as IN 13433 1710 27 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1710 28 's 's POS 13433 1710 29 , , , 13433 1710 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1710 31 does do VBZ 13433 1710 32 not not RB 13433 1710 33 begin begin VB 13433 1710 34 with with IN 13433 1710 35 John John NNP 13433 1710 36 i. i. NNP 13433 1711 1 1 1 CD 13433 1711 2 , , , 13433 1711 3 but but CC 13433 1711 4 with with IN 13433 1711 5 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1711 6 i. i. NNP 13433 1712 1 1 1 CD 13433 1712 2 , , , 13433 1712 3 and and CC 13433 1712 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1712 5 does do VBZ 13433 1712 6 contain contain VB 13433 1712 7 the the DT 13433 1712 8 genealogies genealogy NNS 13433 1712 9 . . . 13433 1713 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1713 2 belongs belong VBZ 13433 1713 3 , , , 13433 1713 4 therefore therefore RB 13433 1713 5 , , , 13433 1713 6 at at IN 13433 1713 7 least least JJS 13433 1713 8 in in IN 13433 1713 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1713 10 present present JJ 13433 1713 11 form form NN 13433 1713 12 , , , 13433 1713 13 neither neither CC 13433 1713 14 to to IN 13433 1713 15 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1713 16 nor nor CC 13433 1713 17 to to IN 13433 1713 18 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 1713 19 . . . 13433 1713 20 " " '' 13433 1714 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1714 2 153:1 153:1 LS 13433 1714 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1714 4 How how WRB 13433 1714 5 this this DT 13433 1714 6 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1714 7 would would MD 13433 1714 8 have have VB 13433 1714 9 fallen fall VBN 13433 1714 10 to to IN 13433 1714 11 the the DT 13433 1714 12 ground ground NN 13433 1714 13 had have VBD 13433 1714 14 the the DT 13433 1714 15 Harmonist Harmonist NNP 13433 1714 16 , , , 13433 1714 17 as as IN 13433 1714 18 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1714 19 might may MD 13433 1714 20 well well RB 13433 1714 21 have have VB 13433 1714 22 done do VBN 13433 1714 23 in in IN 13433 1714 24 imitation imitation NN 13433 1714 25 of of IN 13433 1714 26 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1714 27 , , , 13433 1714 28 commenced commence VBD 13433 1714 29 with with IN 13433 1714 30 the the DT 13433 1714 31 words word NNS 13433 1714 32 , , , 13433 1714 33 " " `` 13433 1714 34 In in IN 13433 1714 35 the the DT 13433 1714 36 beginning beginning NN 13433 1714 37 was be VBD 13433 1714 38 the the DT 13433 1714 39 Word Word NNP 13433 1714 40 " " '' 13433 1714 41 ! ! . 13433 1715 1 The the DT 13433 1715 2 most most RBS 13433 1715 3 instructive instructive JJ 13433 1715 4 part part NN 13433 1715 5 is be VBZ 13433 1715 6 still still RB 13433 1715 7 to to TO 13433 1715 8 come come VB 13433 1715 9 , , , 13433 1715 10 however however RB 13433 1715 11 , , , 13433 1715 12 for for IN 13433 1715 13 although although IN 13433 1715 14 in in IN 13433 1715 15 May May NNP 13433 1715 16 1887 1887 CD 13433 1715 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1715 18 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1715 19 says say VBZ 13433 1715 20 : : : 13433 1715 21 " " `` 13433 1715 22 There there EX 13433 1715 23 can can MD 13433 1715 24 be be VB 13433 1715 25 no no DT 13433 1715 26 doubt doubt NN 13433 1715 27 that that IN 13433 1715 28 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1715 29 was be VBD 13433 1715 30 mistaken mistake VBN 13433 1715 31 about about IN 13433 1715 32 the the DT 13433 1715 33 authorship authorship NN 13433 1715 34 , , , 13433 1715 35 " " '' 13433 1715 36 & & CC 13433 1715 37 c. c. NNP 13433 1715 38 , , , 13433 1715 39 in in IN 13433 1715 40 a a DT 13433 1715 41 note note NN 13433 1715 42 now now RB 13433 1715 43 inserted insert VBN 13433 1715 44 at at IN 13433 1715 45 the the DT 13433 1715 46 end end NN 13433 1715 47 of of IN 13433 1715 48 the the DT 13433 1715 49 essay essay NN 13433 1715 50 , , , 13433 1715 51 after after IN 13433 1715 52 referring refer VBG 13433 1715 53 to to IN 13433 1715 54 the the DT 13433 1715 55 newly newly RB 13433 1715 56 - - HYPH 13433 1715 57 discovered discover VBN 13433 1715 58 works work NNS 13433 1715 59 , , , 13433 1715 60 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1715 61 adds add VBZ 13433 1715 62 : : : 13433 1715 63 " " `` 13433 1715 64 On on IN 13433 1715 65 the the DT 13433 1715 66 relation relation NN 13433 1715 67 of of IN 13433 1715 68 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1715 69 's 's POS 13433 1715 70 _ _ NNP 13433 1715 71 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1715 72 , , , 13433 1715 73 which which WDT 13433 1715 74 seems seem VBZ 13433 1715 75 to to TO 13433 1715 76 be be VB 13433 1715 77 shown show VBN 13433 1715 78 after after RB 13433 1715 79 all all RB 13433 1715 80 not not RB 13433 1715 81 to to TO 13433 1715 82 be be VB 13433 1715 83 independent independent JJ 13433 1715 84 of of IN 13433 1715 85 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1715 86 _ _ NNP 13433 1715 87 ... ... . 13433 1715 88 See See NNP 13433 1715 89 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 1715 90 's 's POS 13433 1715 91 _ _ NNP 13433 1715 92 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1715 93 _ _ NNP 13433 1715 94 . . . 13433 1715 95 " " '' 13433 1716 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1716 2 153:2 153:2 LS 13433 1716 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1716 4 On on IN 13433 1716 5 turning turn VBG 13433 1716 6 to to IN 13433 1716 7 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1716 8 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 1716 9 's 's POS 13433 1716 10 work work NN 13433 1716 11 , , , 13433 1716 12 the the DT 13433 1716 13 following follow VBG 13433 1716 14 passage passage NN 13433 1716 15 on on IN 13433 1716 16 the the DT 13433 1716 17 point point NN 13433 1716 18 is be VBZ 13433 1716 19 discovered:-- discovered:-- NN 13433 1716 20 " " `` 13433 1716 21 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1716 22 will will MD 13433 1716 23 be be VB 13433 1716 24 remembered remember VBN 13433 1716 25 that that IN 13433 1716 26 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1716 27 , , , 13433 1716 28 Bishop Bishop NNP 13433 1716 29 of of IN 13433 1716 30 Capua Capua NNP 13433 1716 31 , , , 13433 1716 32 in in IN 13433 1716 33 the the DT 13433 1716 34 year year NN 13433 1716 35 543 543 CD 13433 1716 36 , , , 13433 1716 37 found find VBD 13433 1716 38 a a DT 13433 1716 39 Latin latin JJ 13433 1716 40 Harmony harmony NN 13433 1716 41 or or CC 13433 1716 42 compilation compilation NN 13433 1716 43 of of IN 13433 1716 44 the the DT 13433 1716 45 four four CD 13433 1716 46 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1716 47 without without IN 13433 1716 48 any any DT 13433 1716 49 name name NN 13433 1716 50 or or CC 13433 1716 51 title title NN 13433 1716 52 , , , 13433 1716 53 and and CC 13433 1716 54 being be VBG 13433 1716 55 a a DT 13433 1716 56 man man NN 13433 1716 57 of of IN 13433 1716 58 enquiring enquire VBG 13433 1716 59 mind mind NN 13433 1716 60 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1716 61 at at IN 13433 1716 62 once once RB 13433 1716 63 set set VBN 13433 1716 64 about about IN 13433 1716 65 the the DT 13433 1716 66 task task NN 13433 1716 67 of of IN 13433 1716 68 discovering discover VBG 13433 1716 69 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1716 70 unknown unknown JJ 13433 1716 71 author author NN 13433 1716 72 . . . 13433 1717 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1717 2 have have VBP 13433 1717 3 already already RB 13433 1717 4 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1717 5 the the DT 13433 1717 6 way way NN 13433 1717 7 in in IN 13433 1717 8 which which WDT 13433 1717 9 , , , 13433 1717 10 from from IN 13433 1717 11 the the DT 13433 1717 12 passage passage NN 13433 1717 13 of of IN 13433 1717 14 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 1717 15 , , , 13433 1717 16 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1717 17 was be VBD 13433 1717 18 led lead VBN 13433 1717 19 to to TO 13433 1717 20 ascribe ascribe VB 13433 1717 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1717 22 discovery discovery NN 13433 1717 23 to to IN 13433 1717 24 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1717 25 . . . 13433 1718 1 This this DT 13433 1718 2 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1718 3 was be VBD 13433 1718 4 generally generally RB 13433 1718 5 traversed traverse VBN 13433 1718 6 by by IN 13433 1718 7 Church church NN 13433 1718 8 writers writer NNS 13433 1718 9 , , , 13433 1718 10 and and CC 13433 1718 11 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1718 12 was be VBD 13433 1718 13 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1718 14 to to TO 13433 1718 15 have have VB 13433 1718 16 made make VBN 13433 1718 17 a a DT 13433 1718 18 mistake mistake NN 13433 1718 19 . . . 13433 1719 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1719 2 is be VBZ 13433 1719 3 now now RB 13433 1719 4 , , , 13433 1719 5 however however RB 13433 1719 6 , , , 13433 1719 7 proved prove VBD 13433 1719 8 to to TO 13433 1719 9 have have VB 13433 1719 10 been be VBN 13433 1719 11 a a DT 13433 1719 12 better well JJR 13433 1719 13 judge judge NN 13433 1719 14 than than IN 13433 1719 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1719 16 critics critic NNS 13433 1719 17 , , , 13433 1719 18 for for IN 13433 1719 19 , , , 13433 1719 20 as as IN 13433 1719 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1719 22 Wace Wace NNP 13433 1719 23 was be VBD 13433 1719 24 the the DT 13433 1719 25 first first JJ 13433 1719 26 to to TO 13433 1719 27 point point VB 13433 1719 28 out out RP 13433 1719 29 , , , 13433 1719 30 a a DT 13433 1719 31 comparison comparison NN 13433 1719 32 of of IN 13433 1719 33 this this DT 13433 1719 34 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1719 35 Harmony Harmony NNP 13433 1719 36 with with IN 13433 1719 37 the the DT 13433 1719 38 Ephraem ephraem JJ 13433 1719 39 fragments fragment NNS 13433 1719 40 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 1719 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1719 42 substantial substantial JJ 13433 1719 43 identity identity NN 13433 1719 44 , , , 13433 1719 45 as as IN 13433 1719 46 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1719 47 preserve preserve VBP 13433 1719 48 to to IN 13433 1719 49 a a DT 13433 1719 50 wonderful wonderful JJ 13433 1719 51 degree degree NN 13433 1719 52 the the DT 13433 1719 53 same same JJ 13433 1719 54 order order NN 13433 1719 55 , , , 13433 1719 56 and and CC 13433 1719 57 generally generally RB 13433 1719 58 proceed proceed VBP 13433 1719 59 _ _ NNP 13433 1719 60 pari pari JJ 13433 1719 61 passu passu NNP 13433 1719 62 _ _ NNP 13433 1719 63 . . . 13433 1719 64 " " '' 13433 1720 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1720 2 153:3 153:3 LS 13433 1720 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1720 4 But but CC 13433 1720 5 how how WRB 13433 1720 6 about about IN 13433 1720 7 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1720 8 i. i. NNP 13433 1721 1 1 1 CD 13433 1721 2 as as IN 13433 1721 3 the the DT 13433 1721 4 beginning beginning NN 13433 1721 5 ? ? . 13433 1722 1 and and CC 13433 1722 2 the the DT 13433 1722 3 genealogies genealogy NNS 13433 1722 4 ? ? . 13433 1723 1 Nothing nothing NN 13433 1723 2 could could MD 13433 1723 3 more more RBR 13433 1723 4 clearly clearly RB 13433 1723 5 show show VB 13433 1723 6 the the DT 13433 1723 7 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 1723 8 which which WDT 13433 1723 9 must must MD 13433 1723 10 always always RB 13433 1723 11 prevail prevail VB 13433 1723 12 about about IN 13433 1723 13 such such JJ 13433 1723 14 works work NNS 13433 1723 15 . . . 13433 1724 1 Shall Shall MD 13433 1724 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1724 3 one one CD 13433 1724 4 day day NN 13433 1724 5 discover discover VBP 13433 1724 6 that that IN 13433 1724 7 Victor Victor NNP 13433 1724 8 was be VBD 13433 1724 9 equally equally RB 13433 1724 10 right right JJ 13433 1724 11 about about IN 13433 1724 12 the the DT 13433 1724 13 reading reading NN 13433 1724 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1724 15 Diapente Diapente NNP 13433 1724 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1724 17 ? ? . 13433 1725 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1725 2 have have VBP 13433 1725 3 thought think VBN 13433 1725 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1725 5 worth worth JJ 13433 1725 6 while while IN 13433 1725 7 to to TO 13433 1725 8 go go VB 13433 1725 9 into into IN 13433 1725 10 all all PDT 13433 1725 11 this this DT 13433 1725 12 with with IN 13433 1725 13 a a DT 13433 1725 14 view view NN 13433 1725 15 of of IN 13433 1725 16 showing show VBG 13433 1725 17 how how WRB 13433 1725 18 little little JJ 13433 1725 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1725 20 know know VBP 13433 1725 21 of of IN 13433 1725 22 the the DT 13433 1725 23 _ _ NNP 13433 1725 24 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1725 25 _ _ NNP 13433 1725 26 of of IN 13433 1725 27 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1725 28 and and CC 13433 1725 29 , , , 13433 1725 30 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1725 31 may may MD 13433 1725 32 add add VB 13433 1725 33 , , , 13433 1725 34 of of IN 13433 1725 35 the the DT 13433 1725 36 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 1725 37 of of IN 13433 1725 38 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1725 39 Syrus Syrus NNP 13433 1725 40 and and CC 13433 1725 41 the the DT 13433 1725 42 work work NN 13433 1725 43 on on IN 13433 1725 44 which which WDT 13433 1725 45 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1725 46 is be VBZ 13433 1725 47 based base VBN 13433 1725 48 . . . 13433 1726 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1726 2 is be VBZ 13433 1726 3 not not RB 13433 1726 4 at at IN 13433 1726 5 present present JJ 13433 1726 6 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1726 7 to to TO 13433 1726 8 examine examine VB 13433 1726 9 more more RBR 13433 1726 10 closely closely RB 13433 1726 11 the the DT 13433 1726 12 text text NN 13433 1726 13 of of IN 13433 1726 14 either either DT 13433 1726 15 of of IN 13433 1726 16 the the DT 13433 1726 17 recently recently RB 13433 1726 18 published publish VBN 13433 1726 19 works work NNS 13433 1726 20 , , , 13433 1726 21 but but CC 13433 1726 22 , , , 13433 1726 23 whilst whilst IN 13433 1726 24 leaving leave VBG 13433 1726 25 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1726 26 to to TO 13433 1726 27 be be VB 13433 1726 28 tried try VBN 13433 1726 29 by by IN 13433 1726 30 time time NN 13433 1726 31 , , , 13433 1726 32 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1726 33 may may MD 13433 1726 34 clearly clearly RB 13433 1726 35 state state VB 13433 1726 36 what what WP 13433 1726 37 the the DT 13433 1726 38 effect effect NN 13433 1726 39 on on IN 13433 1726 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1726 41 argument argument NN 13433 1726 42 would would MD 13433 1726 43 be be VB 13433 1726 44 on on IN 13433 1726 45 the the DT 13433 1726 46 assumption assumption NN 13433 1726 47 made make VBN 13433 1726 48 by by IN 13433 1726 49 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1726 50 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1726 51 that that IN 13433 1726 52 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1726 53 have have VBP 13433 1726 54 actually actually RB 13433 1726 55 recovered recover VBN 13433 1726 56 the the DT 13433 1726 57 _ _ NNP 13433 1726 58 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1726 59 _ _ NNP 13433 1726 60 of of IN 13433 1726 61 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1726 62 , , , 13433 1726 63 and and CC 13433 1726 64 that that IN 13433 1726 65 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1726 66 is be VBZ 13433 1726 67 composed compose VBN 13433 1726 68 upon upon IN 13433 1726 69 a a DT 13433 1726 70 text text NN 13433 1726 71 more more RBR 13433 1726 72 or or CC 13433 1726 73 less less RBR 13433 1726 74 corresponding corresponding JJ 13433 1726 75 with with IN 13433 1726 76 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1726 77 four four CD 13433 1726 78 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1726 79 . . . 13433 1727 1 Neither neither CC 13433 1727 2 in in IN 13433 1727 3 the the DT 13433 1727 4 " " `` 13433 1727 5 Harmony harmony NN 13433 1727 6 " " '' 13433 1727 7 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1727 8 nor nor CC 13433 1727 9 in in IN 13433 1727 10 the the DT 13433 1727 11 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1727 12 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 1727 13 of of IN 13433 1727 14 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1727 15 Syrus Syrus NNP 13433 1727 16 is be VBZ 13433 1727 17 the the DT 13433 1727 18 name name NN 13433 1727 19 of of IN 13433 1727 20 any any DT 13433 1727 21 of of IN 13433 1727 22 the the DT 13433 1727 23 Evangelists Evangelists NNPS 13433 1727 24 mentioned mention VBD 13433 1727 25 , , , 13433 1727 26 and and CC 13433 1727 27 much much RB 13433 1727 28 less less JJR 13433 1727 29 is be VBZ 13433 1727 30 there there EX 13433 1727 31 any any DT 13433 1727 32 information information NN 13433 1727 33 given give VBN 13433 1727 34 as as IN 13433 1727 35 to to IN 13433 1727 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1727 37 personality personality NN 13433 1727 38 , , , 13433 1727 39 character character NN 13433 1727 40 , , , 13433 1727 41 or or CC 13433 1727 42 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 13433 1727 43 . . . 13433 1728 1 If if IN 13433 1728 2 these these DT 13433 1728 3 works work NNS 13433 1728 4 were be VBD 13433 1728 5 , , , 13433 1728 6 therefore therefore RB 13433 1728 7 , , , 13433 1728 8 the the DT 13433 1728 9 veritable veritable JJ 13433 1728 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1728 11 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 1728 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1728 13 of of IN 13433 1728 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 1728 15 and and CC 13433 1728 16 the the DT 13433 1728 17 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 1728 18 of of IN 13433 1728 19 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 1728 20 upon upon IN 13433 1728 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1728 22 , , , 13433 1728 23 the the DT 13433 1728 24 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1728 25 would would MD 13433 1728 26 not not RB 13433 1728 27 be be VB 13433 1728 28 rendered render VBN 13433 1728 29 more more RBR 13433 1728 30 credible credible JJ 13433 1728 31 as as IN 13433 1728 32 the the DT 13433 1728 33 record record NN 13433 1728 34 of of IN 13433 1728 35 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1728 36 nor nor CC 13433 1728 37 as as IN 13433 1728 38 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1728 39 for for IN 13433 1728 40 the the DT 13433 1728 41 reality reality NN 13433 1728 42 of of IN 13433 1728 43 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1728 44 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1728 45 . . . 13433 1729 1 * * NFP 13433 1729 2 * * NFP 13433 1729 3 * * NFP 13433 1729 4 * * NFP 13433 1729 5 * * NFP 13433 1729 6 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1729 7 may may MD 13433 1729 8 not not RB 13433 1729 9 be be VB 13433 1729 10 uninstructive uninstructive JJ 13433 1729 11 if if IN 13433 1729 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1729 13 take take VBP 13433 1729 14 the the DT 13433 1729 15 liberty liberty NN 13433 1729 16 of of IN 13433 1729 17 quoting quoting NN 13433 1729 18 here here RB 13433 1729 19 some some DT 13433 1729 20 arguments argument NNS 13433 1729 21 of of IN 13433 1729 22 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1729 23 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1729 24 regarding regard VBG 13433 1729 25 the the DT 13433 1729 26 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1729 27 of of IN 13433 1729 28 the the DT 13433 1729 29 " " `` 13433 1729 30 Letter Letter NNP 13433 1729 31 of of IN 13433 1729 32 the the DT 13433 1729 33 Smyrnaens Smyrnaens NNP 13433 1729 34 , , , 13433 1729 35 " " '' 13433 1729 36 giving give VBG 13433 1729 37 an an DT 13433 1729 38 account account NN 13433 1729 39 of of IN 13433 1729 40 the the DT 13433 1729 41 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1729 42 of of IN 13433 1729 43 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1729 44 . . . 13433 1730 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1730 2 154:1 154:1 LS 13433 1730 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1730 4 " " `` 13433 1730 5 The the DT 13433 1730 6 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1730 7 element element NN 13433 1730 8 has have VBZ 13433 1730 9 also also RB 13433 1730 10 been be VBN 13433 1730 11 urged urge VBN 13433 1730 12 in in IN 13433 1730 13 some some DT 13433 1730 14 quarters quarter NNS 13433 1730 15 as as IN 13433 1730 16 an an DT 13433 1730 17 objection objection NN 13433 1730 18 to to IN 13433 1730 19 the the DT 13433 1730 20 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 1730 21 of of IN 13433 1730 22 the the DT 13433 1730 23 document document NN 13433 1730 24 . . . 13433 1731 1 Yet yet RB 13433 1731 2 , , , 13433 1731 3 considering consider VBG 13433 1731 4 all all PDT 13433 1731 5 the the DT 13433 1731 6 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1731 7 of of IN 13433 1731 8 the the DT 13433 1731 9 case case NN 13433 1731 10 , , , 13433 1731 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1731 12 have have VBP 13433 1731 13 more more JJR 13433 1731 14 occasion occasion NN 13433 1731 15 to to TO 13433 1731 16 be be VB 13433 1731 17 surprised surprised JJ 13433 1731 18 at at IN 13433 1731 19 the the DT 13433 1731 20 comparative comparative JJ 13433 1731 21 absence absence NN 13433 1731 22 than than IN 13433 1731 23 at at IN 13433 1731 24 the the DT 13433 1731 25 special special JJ 13433 1731 26 prominence prominence NN 13433 1731 27 of of IN 13433 1731 28 the the DT 13433 1731 29 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1731 30 in in IN 13433 1731 31 the the DT 13433 1731 32 narrative narrative NN 13433 1731 33 . . . 13433 1732 1 Compared compare VBN 13433 1732 2 with with IN 13433 1732 3 records record NNS 13433 1732 4 of of IN 13433 1732 5 early early JJ 13433 1732 6 Christian christian JJ 13433 1732 7 martyrs martyr NNS 13433 1732 8 , , , 13433 1732 9 or or CC 13433 1732 10 with with IN 13433 1732 11 biographies biography NNS 13433 1732 12 of of IN 13433 1732 13 mediaeval mediaeval JJ 13433 1732 14 saints saint NNS 13433 1732 15 , , , 13433 1732 16 or or CC 13433 1732 17 with with IN 13433 1732 18 notices notice NNS 13433 1732 19 of of IN 13433 1732 20 religious religious JJ 13433 1732 21 heroes hero NNS 13433 1732 22 at at IN 13433 1732 23 any any DT 13433 1732 24 great great JJ 13433 1732 25 crisis crisis NN 13433 1732 26 , , , 13433 1732 27 even even RB 13433 1732 28 in in IN 13433 1732 29 the the DT 13433 1732 30 more more RBR 13433 1732 31 recent recent JJ 13433 1732 32 history history NN 13433 1732 33 of of IN 13433 1732 34 the the DT 13433 1732 35 Church Church NNP 13433 1732 36 -- -- : 13433 1732 37 as as IN 13433 1732 38 , , , 13433 1732 39 for for IN 13433 1732 40 instance instance NN 13433 1732 41 , , , 13433 1732 42 the the DT 13433 1732 43 rise rise NN 13433 1732 44 of of IN 13433 1732 45 Jesuitism Jesuitism NNP 13433 1732 46 or or CC 13433 1732 47 of of IN 13433 1732 48 Wesleyanism Wesleyanism NNP 13433 1732 49 -- -- : 13433 1732 50 this this DT 13433 1732 51 document document NN 13433 1732 52 contains contain VBZ 13433 1732 53 nothing nothing NN 13433 1732 54 which which WDT 13433 1732 55 ought ought MD 13433 1732 56 to to TO 13433 1732 57 excite excite VB 13433 1732 58 a a DT 13433 1732 59 suspicion suspicion NN 13433 1732 60 as as IN 13433 1732 61 to to IN 13433 1732 62 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1732 63 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1732 64 . . . 13433 1733 1 " " `` 13433 1733 2 The the DT 13433 1733 3 one one CD 13433 1733 4 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1733 5 incident incident NN 13433 1733 6 , , , 13433 1733 7 which which WDT 13433 1733 8 creates create VBZ 13433 1733 9 a a DT 13433 1733 10 real real JJ 13433 1733 11 difficulty difficulty NN 13433 1733 12 , , , 13433 1733 13 is be VBZ 13433 1733 14 the the DT 13433 1733 15 dove dove NN 13433 1733 16 issuing issue VBG 13433 1733 17 from from IN 13433 1733 18 the the DT 13433 1733 19 wounded wound VBN 13433 1733 20 side side NN 13433 1733 21 of of IN 13433 1733 22 the the DT 13433 1733 23 martyr martyr NN 13433 1733 24 . . . 13433 1734 1 Yet yet CC 13433 1734 2 even even RB 13433 1734 3 this this DT 13433 1734 4 might may MD 13433 1734 5 be be VB 13433 1734 6 accounted account VBN 13433 1734 7 for for IN 13433 1734 8 by by IN 13433 1734 9 an an DT 13433 1734 10 illusion illusion NN 13433 1734 11 , , , 13433 1734 12 and and CC 13433 1734 13 under under IN 13433 1734 14 any any DT 13433 1734 15 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1734 16 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1734 17 would would MD 13433 1734 18 be be VB 13433 1734 19 quite quite RB 13433 1734 20 inadequate inadequate JJ 13433 1734 21 to to TO 13433 1734 22 condemn condemn VB 13433 1734 23 the the DT 13433 1734 24 document document NN 13433 1734 25 as as IN 13433 1734 26 a a DT 13433 1734 27 forgery forgery NN 13433 1734 28 . . . 13433 1735 1 But but CC 13433 1735 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1735 3 will will MD 13433 1735 4 be be VB 13433 1735 5 shown show VBN 13433 1735 6 hereafter hereafter RB 13433 1735 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1735 8 p. p. NN 13433 1735 9 627 627 CD 13433 1735 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1735 11 that that IN 13433 1735 12 there there EX 13433 1735 13 are be VBP 13433 1735 14 excellent excellent JJ 13433 1735 15 reasons reason NNS 13433 1735 16 for for IN 13433 1735 17 regarding regard VBG 13433 1735 18 the the DT 13433 1735 19 incident incident NN 13433 1735 20 as as IN 13433 1735 21 a a DT 13433 1735 22 later later JJ 13433 1735 23 interpolation interpolation NN 13433 1735 24 , , , 13433 1735 25 which which WDT 13433 1735 26 had have VBD 13433 1735 27 no no DT 13433 1735 28 place place NN 13433 1735 29 in in IN 13433 1735 30 the the DT 13433 1735 31 original original JJ 13433 1735 32 document document NN 13433 1735 33 . . . 13433 1736 1 Beyond beyond IN 13433 1736 2 this this DT 13433 1736 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1736 4 have have VBP 13433 1736 5 the the DT 13433 1736 6 voice voice NN 13433 1736 7 from from IN 13433 1736 8 heaven heaven NNP 13433 1736 9 calling call VBG 13433 1736 10 to to IN 13433 1736 11 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1736 12 in in IN 13433 1736 13 the the DT 13433 1736 14 stadium stadium NN 13433 1736 15 to to TO 13433 1736 16 play play VB 13433 1736 17 the the DT 13433 1736 18 man man NN 13433 1736 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1736 20 § § ADD 13433 1736 21 9 9 CD 13433 1736 22 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1736 23 . . . 13433 1737 1 But but CC 13433 1737 2 the the DT 13433 1737 3 very very JJ 13433 1737 4 simplicity simplicity NN 13433 1737 5 of of IN 13433 1737 6 the the DT 13433 1737 7 narrative narrative NN 13433 1737 8 here here RB 13433 1737 9 disarms disarm VBZ 13433 1737 10 criticism criticism NN 13433 1737 11 . . . 13433 1738 1 The the DT 13433 1738 2 brethren brother NNS 13433 1738 3 present present NN 13433 1738 4 heard hear VBD 13433 1738 5 the the DT 13433 1738 6 voice voice NN 13433 1738 7 , , , 13433 1738 8 but but CC 13433 1738 9 no no DT 13433 1738 10 one one NN 13433 1738 11 saw see VBD 13433 1738 12 the the DT 13433 1738 13 speaker speaker NN 13433 1738 14 . . . 13433 1739 1 This this DT 13433 1739 2 was be VBD 13433 1739 3 the the DT 13433 1739 4 sole sole JJ 13433 1739 5 ground ground NN 13433 1739 6 for for IN 13433 1739 7 the the DT 13433 1739 8 belief belief NN 13433 1739 9 that that IN 13433 1739 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1739 11 was be VBD 13433 1739 12 not not RB 13433 1739 13 a a DT 13433 1739 14 human human JJ 13433 1739 15 utterance utterance NN 13433 1739 16 . . . 13433 1740 1 Again again RB 13433 1740 2 , , , 13433 1740 3 there there EX 13433 1740 4 is be VBZ 13433 1740 5 the the DT 13433 1740 6 arching arching NN 13433 1740 7 of of IN 13433 1740 8 the the DT 13433 1740 9 fire fire NN 13433 1740 10 round round IN 13433 1740 11 the the DT 13433 1740 12 martyr martyr NN 13433 1740 13 like like IN 13433 1740 14 a a DT 13433 1740 15 sail sail NN 13433 1740 16 swelled swell VBN 13433 1740 17 by by IN 13433 1740 18 the the DT 13433 1740 19 wind wind NN 13433 1740 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1740 21 § § CD 13433 1740 22 15 15 CD 13433 1740 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1740 24 . . . 13433 1741 1 But but CC 13433 1741 2 this this DT 13433 1741 3 may may MD 13433 1741 4 be be VB 13433 1741 5 explained explain VBN 13433 1741 6 as as IN 13433 1741 7 a a DT 13433 1741 8 strictly strictly RB 13433 1741 9 natural natural JJ 13433 1741 10 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 1741 11 , , , 13433 1741 12 and and CC 13433 1741 13 similar similar JJ 13433 1741 14 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1741 15 have have VBP 13433 1741 16 been be VBN 13433 1741 17 witnessed witness VBN 13433 1741 18 more more RBR 13433 1741 19 than than IN 13433 1741 20 once once RB 13433 1741 21 on on IN 13433 1741 22 like like JJ 13433 1741 23 occasions occasion NNS 13433 1741 24 , , , 13433 1741 25 notably notably RB 13433 1741 26 at at IN 13433 1741 27 the the DT 13433 1741 28 martyrdoms martyrdom NNS 13433 1741 29 of of IN 13433 1741 30 Savonarola Savonarola NNP 13433 1741 31 and and CC 13433 1741 32 of of IN 13433 1741 33 Hooper Hooper NNP 13433 1741 34 . . . 13433 1742 1 Again again RB 13433 1742 2 , , , 13433 1742 3 there there EX 13433 1742 4 is be VBZ 13433 1742 5 the the DT 13433 1742 6 sweet sweet JJ 13433 1742 7 scent scent NN 13433 1742 8 , , , 13433 1742 9 as as IN 13433 1742 10 of of IN 13433 1742 11 incense incense NN 13433 1742 12 , , , 13433 1742 13 issuing issue VBG 13433 1742 14 from from IN 13433 1742 15 the the DT 13433 1742 16 burning burn VBG 13433 1742 17 pyre pyre NN 13433 1742 18 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1742 19 § § ADD 13433 1742 20 15 15 CD 13433 1742 21 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1742 22 ; ; : 13433 1742 23 but but CC 13433 1742 24 this this DT 13433 1742 25 phenomenon phenomenon NN 13433 1742 26 also also RB 13433 1742 27 , , , 13433 1742 28 however however RB 13433 1742 29 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1742 30 may may MD 13433 1742 31 explain explain VB 13433 1742 32 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1742 33 , , , 13433 1742 34 whether whether IN 13433 1742 35 from from IN 13433 1742 36 the the DT 13433 1742 37 fragrance fragrance NN 13433 1742 38 of of IN 13433 1742 39 the the DT 13433 1742 40 wood wood NN 13433 1742 41 or or CC 13433 1742 42 in in IN 13433 1742 43 some some DT 13433 1742 44 other other JJ 13433 1742 45 way way NN 13433 1742 46 , , , 13433 1742 47 meets meet VBZ 13433 1742 48 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1742 49 constantly constantly RB 13433 1742 50 . . . 13433 1743 1 In in IN 13433 1743 2 another another DT 13433 1743 3 early early JJ 13433 1743 4 record record NN 13433 1743 5 of of IN 13433 1743 6 martyrdoms martyrdom NNS 13433 1743 7 , , , 13433 1743 8 the the DT 13433 1743 9 history history NN 13433 1743 10 of of IN 13433 1743 11 the the DT 13433 1743 12 persecutions persecution NNS 13433 1743 13 at at IN 13433 1743 14 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 1743 15 and and CC 13433 1743 16 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 1743 17 , , , 13433 1743 18 a a DT 13433 1743 19 little little JJ 13433 1743 20 more more JJR 13433 1743 21 than than IN 13433 1743 22 twenty twenty CD 13433 1743 23 years year NNS 13433 1743 24 later later RB 13433 1743 25 , , , 13433 1743 26 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1743 27 are be VBP 13433 1743 28 told tell VBN 13433 1743 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1743 30 Euseb Euseb NNP 13433 1743 31 . . . 13433 1744 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1744 2 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 1744 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1744 4 v. v. IN 13433 1744 5 1 1 CD 13433 1744 6 , , , 13433 1744 7 § § ADD 13433 1744 8 35 35 CD 13433 1744 9 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1744 10 that that WDT 13433 1744 11 the the DT 13433 1744 12 heroic heroic JJ 13433 1744 13 martyrs martyr NNS 13433 1744 14 , , , 13433 1744 15 as as IN 13433 1744 16 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1744 17 stepped step VBD 13433 1744 18 forward forward RB 13433 1744 19 to to TO 13433 1744 20 meet meet VB 13433 1744 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1744 22 fate fate NN 13433 1744 23 , , , 13433 1744 24 were be VBD 13433 1744 25 ' ' `` 13433 1744 26 fragrant fragrant JJ 13433 1744 27 with with IN 13433 1744 28 the the DT 13433 1744 29 sweet sweet JJ 13433 1744 30 odour odour NN 13433 1744 31 of of IN 13433 1744 32 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1744 33 , , , 13433 1744 34 so so IN 13433 1744 35 that that IN 13433 1744 36 some some DT 13433 1744 37 persons person NNS 13433 1744 38 even even RB 13433 1744 39 supposed suppose VBD 13433 1744 40 that that IN 13433 1744 41 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1744 42 had have VBD 13433 1744 43 been be VBN 13433 1744 44 anointed anoint VBN 13433 1744 45 with with IN 13433 1744 46 material material JJ 13433 1744 47 ointment ointment NN 13433 1744 48 ' ' '' 13433 1744 49 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1744 50 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1744 51 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1744 52 : : : 13433 1744 53 hôste hôste VB 13433 1744 54 enious enious JJ 13433 1744 55 doxai doxai NNP 13433 1744 56 kai kai NNP 13433 1744 57 murô murô NNP 13433 1744 58 kosmikô kosmikô NNP 13433 1744 59 kechristhai kechristhai NNP 13433 1744 60 autous autous NNP 13433 1744 61 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1744 62 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1744 63 . . . 13433 1745 1 Yet yet CC 13433 1745 2 there there EX 13433 1745 3 was be VBD 13433 1745 4 no no DT 13433 1745 5 pyre pyre NN 13433 1745 6 and and CC 13433 1745 7 no no DT 13433 1745 8 burning burn VBG 13433 1745 9 wood wood NN 13433 1745 10 here here RB 13433 1745 11 , , , 13433 1745 12 so so IN 13433 1745 13 that that IN 13433 1745 14 the the DT 13433 1745 15 imagination imagination NN 13433 1745 16 of of IN 13433 1745 17 the the DT 13433 1745 18 bystanders bystander NNS 13433 1745 19 must must MD 13433 1745 20 have have VB 13433 1745 21 supplied supply VBN 13433 1745 22 the the DT 13433 1745 23 incident incident NN 13433 1745 24 . . . 13433 1746 1 Indeed indeed RB 13433 1746 2 , , , 13433 1746 3 this this DT 13433 1746 4 account account NN 13433 1746 5 of of IN 13433 1746 6 the the DT 13433 1746 7 Gallican gallican JJ 13433 1746 8 martyrs martyr NNS 13433 1746 9 , , , 13433 1746 10 indisputably indisputably RB 13433 1746 11 written write VBN 13433 1746 12 by by IN 13433 1746 13 eye eye NN 13433 1746 14 - - HYPH 13433 1746 15 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1746 16 , , , 13433 1746 17 contains contain VBZ 13433 1746 18 many many JJ 13433 1746 19 more more RBR 13433 1746 20 startling startling JJ 13433 1746 21 occurrences occurrence NNS 13433 1746 22 than than IN 13433 1746 23 the the DT 13433 1746 24 record record NN 13433 1746 25 of of IN 13433 1746 26 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1746 27 's 's POS 13433 1746 28 fate fate NN 13433 1746 29 . . . 13433 1747 1 " " `` 13433 1747 2 More more RBR 13433 1747 3 or or CC 13433 1747 4 less less RBR 13433 1747 5 closely closely RB 13433 1747 6 connected connected JJ 13433 1747 7 with with IN 13433 1747 8 the the DT 13433 1747 9 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1747 10 element element NN 13433 1747 11 is be VBZ 13433 1747 12 the the DT 13433 1747 13 _ _ NNP 13433 1747 14 prophetic prophetic JJ 13433 1747 15 insight insight NN 13433 1747 16 _ _ NNP 13433 1747 17 attributed attribute VBD 13433 1747 18 to to IN 13433 1747 19 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 1747 20 . . . 13433 1748 1 But but CC 13433 1748 2 what what WP 13433 1748 3 does do VBZ 13433 1748 4 this this DT 13433 1748 5 amount amount NN 13433 1748 6 to to IN 13433 1748 7 ? ? . 13433 1749 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1749 2 is be VBZ 13433 1749 3 stated state VBN 13433 1749 4 indeed indeed RB 13433 1749 5 that that IN 13433 1749 6 ' ' `` 13433 1749 7 every every DT 13433 1749 8 word word NN 13433 1749 9 which which WDT 13433 1749 10 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1749 11 uttered utter VBD 13433 1749 12 was be VBD 13433 1749 13 accomplished accomplish VBN 13433 1749 14 and and CC 13433 1749 15 will will MD 13433 1749 16 be be VB 13433 1749 17 accomplished accomplish VBN 13433 1749 18 ' ' '' 13433 1749 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1749 20 § § CD 13433 1749 21 16 16 CD 13433 1749 22 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1749 23 . . . 13433 1750 1 But but CC 13433 1750 2 the the DT 13433 1750 3 future future JJ 13433 1750 4 tense tense NN 13433 1750 5 , , , 13433 1750 6 ' ' '' 13433 1750 7 will will MD 13433 1750 8 be be VB 13433 1750 9 accomplished accomplish VBN 13433 1750 10 , , , 13433 1750 11 ' ' '' 13433 1750 12 is be VBZ 13433 1750 13 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1750 14 the the DT 13433 1750 15 expression expression NN 13433 1750 16 of of IN 13433 1750 17 a a DT 13433 1750 18 belief belief NN 13433 1750 19 , , , 13433 1750 20 not not RB 13433 1750 21 the the DT 13433 1750 22 statement statement NN 13433 1750 23 of of IN 13433 1750 24 a a DT 13433 1750 25 fact fact NN 13433 1750 26 . . . 13433 1751 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1751 2 may may MD 13433 1751 3 , , , 13433 1751 4 indeed indeed RB 13433 1751 5 , , , 13433 1751 6 accept accept VB 13433 1751 7 this this DT 13433 1751 8 qualification qualification NN 13433 1751 9 as as IN 13433 1751 10 clear clear JJ 13433 1751 11 testimony testimony NN 13433 1751 12 that that WDT 13433 1751 13 , , , 13433 1751 14 when when WRB 13433 1751 15 the the DT 13433 1751 16 narrative narrative NN 13433 1751 17 was be VBD 13433 1751 18 written write VBN 13433 1751 19 , , , 13433 1751 20 many many JJ 13433 1751 21 of of IN 13433 1751 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1751 23 forebodings foreboding NNS 13433 1751 24 and and CC 13433 1751 25 predictions prediction NNS 13433 1751 26 had have VBD 13433 1751 27 not not RB 13433 1751 28 been be VBN 13433 1751 29 fulfilled fulfil VBN 13433 1751 30 . . . 13433 1752 1 The the DT 13433 1752 2 only only JJ 13433 1752 3 example example NN 13433 1752 4 of of IN 13433 1752 5 a a DT 13433 1752 6 prediction prediction NN 13433 1752 7 actually actually RB 13433 1752 8 given give VBN 13433 1752 9 in in IN 13433 1752 10 the the DT 13433 1752 11 narrative narrative NN 13433 1752 12 is be VBZ 13433 1752 13 the the DT 13433 1752 14 dream dream NN 13433 1752 15 of of IN 13433 1752 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1752 17 burning burn VBG 13433 1752 18 pillow pillow NN 13433 1752 19 , , , 13433 1752 20 which which WDT 13433 1752 21 suggested suggest VBD 13433 1752 22 to to IN 13433 1752 23 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1752 24 that that IN 13433 1752 25 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1752 26 would would MD 13433 1752 27 undergo undergo VB 13433 1752 28 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1752 29 by by IN 13433 1752 30 fire fire NN 13433 1752 31 . . . 13433 1753 1 But but CC 13433 1753 2 what what WP 13433 1753 3 more more RBR 13433 1753 4 natural natural JJ 13433 1753 5 than than IN 13433 1753 6 this this DT 13433 1753 7 presentiment presentiment NN 13433 1753 8 , , , 13433 1753 9 when when WRB 13433 1753 10 persecution persecution NN 13433 1753 11 was be VBD 13433 1753 12 raging rage VBG 13433 1753 13 around around IN 13433 1753 14 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1753 15 and and CC 13433 1753 16 fire fire NN 13433 1753 17 was be VBD 13433 1753 18 a a DT 13433 1753 19 common common JJ 13433 1753 20 instrument instrument NN 13433 1753 21 of of IN 13433 1753 22 death death NN 13433 1753 23 ? ? . 13433 1754 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1754 2 need need VBP 13433 1754 3 not not RB 13433 1754 4 stop stop VB 13433 1754 5 here here RB 13433 1754 6 to to TO 13433 1754 7 discuss discuss VB 13433 1754 8 how how WRB 13433 1754 9 far far RB 13433 1754 10 a a DT 13433 1754 11 prescience prescience NN 13433 1754 12 may may MD 13433 1754 13 be be VB 13433 1754 14 vouchsafed vouchsafe VBN 13433 1754 15 to to IN 13433 1754 16 God God NNP 13433 1754 17 's 's POS 13433 1754 18 saints saint NNS 13433 1754 19 . . . 13433 1755 1 Even even RB 13433 1755 2 ' ' `` 13433 1755 3 old old JJ 13433 1755 4 experience experience NN 13433 1755 5 ' ' '' 13433 1755 6 is be VBZ 13433 1755 7 found find VBN 13433 1755 8 to to TO 13433 1755 9 be be VB 13433 1755 10 gifted gift VBN 13433 1755 11 with with IN 13433 1755 12 ' ' `` 13433 1755 13 something something NN 13433 1755 14 like like IN 13433 1755 15 prophetic prophetic JJ 13433 1755 16 strain strain NN 13433 1755 17 . . . 13433 1755 18 ' ' '' 13433 1756 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1756 2 is be VBZ 13433 1756 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 1756 4 to to TO 13433 1756 5 say say VB 13433 1756 6 here here RB 13433 1756 7 again again RB 13433 1756 8 that that IN 13433 1756 9 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1756 10 would would MD 13433 1756 11 be be VB 13433 1756 12 difficult difficult JJ 13433 1756 13 to to TO 13433 1756 14 point point VB 13433 1756 15 to to IN 13433 1756 16 a a DT 13433 1756 17 single single JJ 13433 1756 18 authentic authentic JJ 13433 1756 19 biography biography NN 13433 1756 20 of of IN 13433 1756 21 any any DT 13433 1756 22 Christian christian JJ 13433 1756 23 hero hero NN 13433 1756 24 -- -- : 13433 1756 25 certainly certainly RB 13433 1756 26 of of IN 13433 1756 27 any any DT 13433 1756 28 Christian christian JJ 13433 1756 29 hero hero NN 13433 1756 30 of of IN 13433 1756 31 the the DT 13433 1756 32 early early JJ 13433 1756 33 centuries century NNS 13433 1756 34 -- -- : 13433 1756 35 of of IN 13433 1756 36 whom whom WP 13433 1756 37 some some DT 13433 1756 38 incident incident NN 13433 1756 39 at at IN 13433 1756 40 least least JJS 13433 1756 41 as as RB 13433 1756 42 remarkable remarkable JJ 13433 1756 43 as as IN 13433 1756 44 this this DT 13433 1756 45 prophecy prophecy NN 13433 1756 46 , , , 13433 1756 47 if if IN 13433 1756 48 prophecy prophecy NN 13433 1756 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1756 50 can can MD 13433 1756 51 be be VB 13433 1756 52 called call VBN 13433 1756 53 , , , 13433 1756 54 is be VBZ 13433 1756 55 not not RB 13433 1756 56 recorded record VBN 13433 1756 57 . . . 13433 1757 1 Pontius Pontius NNP 13433 1757 2 , , , 13433 1757 3 the the DT 13433 1757 4 disciple disciple NN 13433 1757 5 and and CC 13433 1757 6 biographer biographer NN 13433 1757 7 of of IN 13433 1757 8 Cyprian Cyprian NNP 13433 1757 9 , , , 13433 1757 10 relates relate VBZ 13433 1757 11 a a DT 13433 1757 12 similar similar JJ 13433 1757 13 intimation intimation NN 13433 1757 14 which which WDT 13433 1757 15 preceded precede VBD 13433 1757 16 the the DT 13433 1757 17 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 1757 18 of of IN 13433 1757 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1757 20 master master NN 13433 1757 21 , , , 13433 1757 22 and and CC 13433 1757 23 adds add VBZ 13433 1757 24 : : : 13433 1757 25 ' ' `` 13433 1757 26 Quid Quid NNP 13433 1757 27 hac hac NNP 13433 1757 28 revelatione revelatione NN 13433 1757 29 manifestius manifestius NNP 13433 1757 30 ? ? . 13433 1758 1 quid quid NNP 13433 1758 2 hac hac NNP 13433 1758 3 dignatione dignatione NNP 13433 1758 4 felicius felicius NNP 13433 1758 5 ? ? . 13433 1759 1 ante ante NNP 13433 1759 2 illi illi NNP 13433 1759 3 praedicta praedicta NNP 13433 1759 4 sunt sunt NNP 13433 1759 5 omnia omnia NNP 13433 1759 6 quaecunque quaecunque NNP 13433 1759 7 postmodum postmodum NNP 13433 1759 8 subsecuta subsecuta NNP 13433 1759 9 sunt sunt NNP 13433 1759 10 . . . 13433 1759 11 ' ' '' 13433 1760 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1760 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1760 3 Vit Vit NNP 13433 1760 4 . . . 13433 1761 1 et et FW 13433 1761 2 Pass Pass NNP 13433 1761 3 . . . 13433 1762 1 Cypr Cypr NNPS 13433 1762 2 . . . 13433 1762 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1762 4 12 12 CD 13433 1762 5 , , , 13433 1762 6 13 13 CD 13433 1762 7 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1762 8 " " '' 13433 1762 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1762 10 156:1 156:1 LS 13433 1762 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1762 12 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1762 13 am be VBP 13433 1762 14 the the DT 13433 1762 15 more more RBR 13433 1762 16 anxious anxious JJ 13433 1762 17 to to TO 13433 1762 18 quote quote VB 13433 1762 19 this this DT 13433 1762 20 extract extract NN 13433 1762 21 from from IN 13433 1762 22 a a DT 13433 1762 23 work work NN 13433 1762 24 , , , 13433 1762 25 written write VBN 13433 1762 26 long long RB 13433 1762 27 after after IN 13433 1762 28 the the DT 13433 1762 29 essays essay NNS 13433 1762 30 on on IN 13433 1762 31 _ _ NNP 13433 1762 32 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1762 33 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1762 34 _ _ NNP 13433 1762 35 , , , 13433 1762 36 as as IN 13433 1762 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1762 38 presents present VBZ 13433 1762 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1762 40 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1762 41 in in IN 13433 1762 42 a a DT 13433 1762 43 very very RB 13433 1762 44 different different JJ 13433 1762 45 light light NN 13433 1762 46 , , , 13433 1762 47 and and CC 13433 1762 48 gives give VBZ 13433 1762 49 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1762 50 an an DT 13433 1762 51 opportunity opportunity NN 13433 1762 52 of of IN 13433 1762 53 congratulating congratulate VBG 13433 1762 54 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1762 55 on on IN 13433 1762 56 the the DT 13433 1762 57 apparent apparent JJ 13433 1762 58 progress progress NN 13433 1762 59 of of IN 13433 1762 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1762 61 thought thought NN 13433 1762 62 towards towards IN 13433 1762 63 freedom freedom NN 13433 1762 64 which which WDT 13433 1762 65 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1762 66 exhibits exhibit VBZ 13433 1762 67 . . . 13433 1763 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1763 2 quite quite RB 13433 1763 3 agree agree VBP 13433 1763 4 with with IN 13433 1763 5 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1763 6 that that IN 13433 1763 7 the the DT 13433 1763 8 presence presence NN 13433 1763 9 of of IN 13433 1763 10 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1763 11 or or CC 13433 1763 12 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1763 13 elements element NNS 13433 1763 14 is be VBZ 13433 1763 15 no no DT 13433 1763 16 evidence evidence NN 13433 1763 17 against against IN 13433 1763 18 the the DT 13433 1763 19 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1763 20 of of IN 13433 1763 21 an an DT 13433 1763 22 early early JJ 13433 1763 23 Christian christian JJ 13433 1763 24 writing writing NN 13433 1763 25 , , , 13433 1763 26 but but CC 13433 1763 27 the the DT 13433 1763 28 promptitude promptitude NN 13433 1763 29 with with IN 13433 1763 30 which which WDT 13433 1763 31 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1763 32 sets set VBZ 13433 1763 33 these these DT 13433 1763 34 aside aside RP 13433 1763 35 as as IN 13433 1763 36 interpolations interpolation NNS 13433 1763 37 , , , 13433 1763 38 or or CC 13433 1763 39 explains explain VBZ 13433 1763 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1763 41 away away RB 13433 1763 42 into into IN 13433 1763 43 naturalism naturalism NN 13433 1763 44 , , , 13433 1763 45 is be VBZ 13433 1763 46 worthy worthy JJ 13433 1763 47 of of IN 13433 1763 48 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1763 49 Huxley Huxley NNP 13433 1763 50 . . . 13433 1764 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1764 2 now now RB 13433 1764 3 understands understand VBZ 13433 1764 4 , , , 13433 1764 5 without without IN 13433 1764 6 doubt doubt NN 13433 1764 7 , , , 13433 1764 8 the the DT 13433 1764 9 reason reason NN 13433 1764 10 why why WRB 13433 1764 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1764 12 demand demand VBP 13433 1764 13 such such JJ 13433 1764 14 clear clear JJ 13433 1764 15 and and CC 13433 1764 16 conclusive conclusive JJ 13433 1764 17 evidence evidence NN 13433 1764 18 of of IN 13433 1764 19 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1764 20 , , , 13433 1764 21 and and CC 13433 1764 22 why why WRB 13433 1764 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1764 24 refuse refuse VBP 13433 1764 25 to to TO 13433 1764 26 accept accept VB 13433 1764 27 such such JJ 13433 1764 28 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1764 29 upon upon IN 13433 1764 30 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1764 31 and and CC 13433 1764 32 insufficient insufficient JJ 13433 1764 33 testimony testimony NN 13433 1764 34 . . . 13433 1765 1 In in IN 13433 1765 2 fact fact NN 13433 1765 3 , , , 13433 1765 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1765 5 can can MD 13433 1765 6 not not RB 13433 1765 7 complain complain VB 13433 1765 8 that that IN 13433 1765 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1765 10 feel feel VBP 13433 1765 11 bound bind VBN 13433 1765 12 to to TO 13433 1765 13 explain explain VB 13433 1765 14 all all DT 13433 1765 15 alleged alleged JJ 13433 1765 16 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1765 17 occurrences occurrence NNS 13433 1765 18 precisely precisely RB 13433 1765 19 in in IN 13433 1765 20 the the DT 13433 1765 21 way way NN 13433 1765 22 of of IN 13433 1765 23 which which WDT 13433 1765 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1765 25 has have VBZ 13433 1765 26 set set VBN 13433 1765 27 me -PRON- PRP 13433 1765 28 so so RB 13433 1765 29 good good JJ 13433 1765 30 an an DT 13433 1765 31 example example NN 13433 1765 32 , , , 13433 1765 33 and and CC 13433 1765 34 that that IN 13433 1765 35 , , , 13433 1765 36 whilst whilst IN 13433 1765 37 feeling feel VBG 13433 1765 38 nothing nothing NN 13433 1765 39 but but CC 13433 1765 40 very very RB 13433 1765 41 sympathetic sympathetic JJ 13433 1765 42 appreciation appreciation NN 13433 1765 43 of of IN 13433 1765 44 the the DT 13433 1765 45 emotion emotion NN 13433 1765 46 which which WDT 13433 1765 47 stimulated stimulate VBD 13433 1765 48 the the DT 13433 1765 49 imagination imagination NN 13433 1765 50 and and CC 13433 1765 51 devout devout VB 13433 1765 52 reverence reverence NN 13433 1765 53 of of IN 13433 1765 54 early early JJ 13433 1765 55 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 1765 56 to to IN 13433 1765 57 such such JJ 13433 1765 58 mistakes mistake NNS 13433 1765 59 , , , 13433 1765 60 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1765 61 resolutely resolutely RB 13433 1765 62 refuse refuse VBP 13433 1765 63 to to TO 13433 1765 64 believe believe VB 13433 1765 65 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1765 66 pious pious JJ 13433 1765 67 aberrations aberration NNS 13433 1765 68 . . . 13433 1766 1 VIII VIII NNP 13433 1766 2 . . . 13433 1767 1 CONCLUSIONS conclusion NNS 13433 1767 2 . . . 13433 1768 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1768 2 have have VBP 13433 1768 3 seen see VBN 13433 1768 4 that that IN 13433 1768 5 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1768 6 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1768 7 could could MD 13433 1768 8 only only RB 13433 1768 9 be be VB 13433 1768 10 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1768 11 or or CC 13433 1768 12 conceivable conceivable JJ 13433 1768 13 for for IN 13433 1768 14 the the DT 13433 1768 15 purpose purpose NN 13433 1768 16 of of IN 13433 1768 17 communicating communicate VBG 13433 1768 18 to to IN 13433 1768 19 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1768 20 something something NN 13433 1768 21 which which WDT 13433 1768 22 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1768 23 could could MD 13433 1768 24 not not RB 13433 1768 25 otherwise otherwise RB 13433 1768 26 discover discover VB 13433 1768 27 , , , 13433 1768 28 and and CC 13433 1768 29 that that IN 13433 1768 30 the the DT 13433 1768 31 truth truth NN 13433 1768 32 of of IN 13433 1768 33 communications communication NNS 13433 1768 34 which which WDT 13433 1768 35 are be VBP 13433 1768 36 essentially essentially RB 13433 1768 37 beyond beyond IN 13433 1768 38 and and CC 13433 1768 39 undiscoverable undiscoverable JJ 13433 1768 40 by by IN 13433 1768 41 reason reason NN 13433 1768 42 can can MD 13433 1768 43 not not RB 13433 1768 44 be be VB 13433 1768 45 attested attest VBN 13433 1768 46 in in IN 13433 1768 47 any any DT 13433 1768 48 other other JJ 13433 1768 49 way way NN 13433 1768 50 than than IN 13433 1768 51 by by IN 13433 1768 52 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1768 53 signs sign NNS 13433 1768 54 distinguishing distinguish VBG 13433 1768 55 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1768 56 as as IN 13433 1768 57 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1768 58 . . . 13433 1769 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1769 2 is be VBZ 13433 1769 3 admitted admit VBN 13433 1769 4 that that IN 13433 1769 5 no no DT 13433 1769 6 other other JJ 13433 1769 7 testimony testimony NN 13433 1769 8 could could MD 13433 1769 9 justify justify VB 13433 1769 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1769 11 believing believe VBG 13433 1769 12 the the DT 13433 1769 13 specific specific JJ 13433 1769 14 Revelation revelation NN 13433 1769 15 which which WDT 13433 1769 16 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1769 17 are be VBP 13433 1769 18 considering consider VBG 13433 1769 19 , , , 13433 1769 20 the the DT 13433 1769 21 very very JJ 13433 1769 22 substance substance NN 13433 1769 23 of of IN 13433 1769 24 which which WDT 13433 1769 25 is be VBZ 13433 1769 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1769 27 and and CC 13433 1769 28 beyond beyond IN 13433 1769 29 the the DT 13433 1769 30 criticism criticism NN 13433 1769 31 of of IN 13433 1769 32 reason reason NN 13433 1769 33 , , , 13433 1769 34 and and CC 13433 1769 35 that that IN 13433 1769 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1769 37 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1769 38 , , , 13433 1769 39 if if IN 13433 1769 40 not not RB 13433 1769 41 proved prove VBN 13433 1769 42 to to TO 13433 1769 43 be be VB 13433 1769 44 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1769 45 truths truth NNS 13433 1769 46 , , , 13433 1769 47 must must MD 13433 1769 48 inevitably inevitably RB 13433 1769 49 be be VB 13433 1769 50 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 1769 51 " " `` 13433 1769 52 the the DT 13433 1769 53 wildest wild JJS 13433 1769 54 delusions delusion NNS 13433 1769 55 . . . 13433 1769 56 " " '' 13433 1770 1 " " `` 13433 1770 2 By by IN 13433 1770 3 no no DT 13433 1770 4 rational rational JJ 13433 1770 5 being being NN 13433 1770 6 could could MD 13433 1770 7 a a DT 13433 1770 8 just just RB 13433 1770 9 and and CC 13433 1770 10 benevolent benevolent JJ 13433 1770 11 life life NN 13433 1770 12 be be VB 13433 1770 13 accepted accept VBN 13433 1770 14 as as IN 13433 1770 15 proof proof NN 13433 1770 16 of of IN 13433 1770 17 such such JJ 13433 1770 18 astonishing astonishing JJ 13433 1770 19 announcements announcement NNS 13433 1770 20 . . . 13433 1770 21 " " '' 13433 1771 1 On on IN 13433 1771 2 examining examine VBG 13433 1771 3 the the DT 13433 1771 4 alleged allege VBN 13433 1771 5 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1771 6 evidence evidence NN 13433 1771 7 for for IN 13433 1771 8 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1771 9 as as IN 13433 1771 10 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1771 11 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1771 12 , , , 13433 1771 13 however however RB 13433 1771 14 , , , 13433 1771 15 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1771 16 find find VBP 13433 1771 17 that that IN 13433 1771 18 , , , 13433 1771 19 even even RB 13433 1771 20 if if IN 13433 1771 21 the the DT 13433 1771 22 actual actual JJ 13433 1771 23 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 1771 24 of of IN 13433 1771 25 the the DT 13433 1771 26 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1771 27 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1771 28 could could MD 13433 1771 29 be be VB 13433 1771 30 substantiated substantiate VBN 13433 1771 31 , , , 13433 1771 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1771 33 value value NN 13433 1771 34 as as IN 13433 1771 35 evidence evidence NN 13433 1771 36 would would MD 13433 1771 37 be be VB 13433 1771 38 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 1771 39 by by IN 13433 1771 40 the the DT 13433 1771 41 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1771 42 admission admission NN 13433 1771 43 that that IN 13433 1771 44 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1771 45 are be VBP 13433 1771 46 not not RB 13433 1771 47 limited limit VBN 13433 1771 48 to to IN 13433 1771 49 one one CD 13433 1771 50 source source NN 13433 1771 51 and and CC 13433 1771 52 are be VBP 13433 1771 53 not not RB 13433 1771 54 exclusively exclusively RB 13433 1771 55 associated associate VBN 13433 1771 56 with with IN 13433 1771 57 truth truth NN 13433 1771 58 , , , 13433 1771 59 but but CC 13433 1771 60 are be VBP 13433 1771 61 performed perform VBN 13433 1771 62 by by IN 13433 1771 63 various various JJ 13433 1771 64 spiritual spiritual JJ 13433 1771 65 Beings Beings NNPS 13433 1771 66 , , , 13433 1771 67 Satanic Satanic NNP 13433 1771 68 as as RB 13433 1771 69 well well RB 13433 1771 70 as as IN 13433 1771 71 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1771 72 , , , 13433 1771 73 and and CC 13433 1771 74 are be VBP 13433 1771 75 not not RB 13433 1771 76 always always RB 13433 1771 77 evidential evidential JJ 13433 1771 78 , , , 13433 1771 79 but but CC 13433 1771 80 are be VBP 13433 1771 81 sometimes sometimes RB 13433 1771 82 to to TO 13433 1771 83 be be VB 13433 1771 84 regarded regard VBN 13433 1771 85 as as IN 13433 1771 86 delusive delusive JJ 13433 1771 87 and and CC 13433 1771 88 for for IN 13433 1771 89 the the DT 13433 1771 90 trial trial NN 13433 1771 91 of of IN 13433 1771 92 faith faith NN 13433 1771 93 . . . 13433 1772 1 As as IN 13433 1772 2 the the DT 13433 1772 3 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1772 4 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1772 5 to to TO 13433 1772 6 be be VB 13433 1772 7 revealed reveal VBN 13433 1772 8 are be VBP 13433 1772 9 beyond beyond IN 13433 1772 10 Reason reason NN 13433 1772 11 , , , 13433 1772 12 and and CC 13433 1772 13 can can MD 13433 1772 14 not not RB 13433 1772 15 in in IN 13433 1772 16 any any DT 13433 1772 17 sense sense NN 13433 1772 18 be be VB 13433 1772 19 intelligently intelligently RB 13433 1772 20 approved approve VBN 13433 1772 21 by by IN 13433 1772 22 the the DT 13433 1772 23 human human JJ 13433 1772 24 intellect intellect NN 13433 1772 25 , , , 13433 1772 26 no no DT 13433 1772 27 evidence evidence NN 13433 1772 28 which which WDT 13433 1772 29 is be VBZ 13433 1772 30 of of IN 13433 1772 31 so so RB 13433 1772 32 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 1772 33 and and CC 13433 1772 34 inconclusive inconclusive VB 13433 1772 35 a a DT 13433 1772 36 nature nature NN 13433 1772 37 could could MD 13433 1772 38 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 1772 39 attest attest VB 13433 1772 40 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1772 41 . . . 13433 1773 1 This this DT 13433 1773 2 alone alone RB 13433 1773 3 would would MD 13433 1773 4 disqualify disqualify VB 13433 1773 5 the the DT 13433 1773 6 Christian christian JJ 13433 1773 7 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1773 8 for for IN 13433 1773 9 the the DT 13433 1773 10 duty duty NN 13433 1773 11 which which WDT 13433 1773 12 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1773 13 alone alone RB 13433 1773 14 are be VBP 13433 1773 15 capable capable JJ 13433 1773 16 of of IN 13433 1773 17 performing perform VBG 13433 1773 18 . . . 13433 1774 1 The the DT 13433 1774 2 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1774 3 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1774 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 1774 5 for for IN 13433 1774 6 the the DT 13433 1774 7 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1774 8 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1774 9 , , , 13433 1774 10 moreover moreover RB 13433 1774 11 , , , 13433 1774 12 is be VBZ 13433 1774 13 not not RB 13433 1774 14 only only RB 13433 1774 15 without without IN 13433 1774 16 any any DT 13433 1774 17 special special JJ 13433 1774 18 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1774 19 character character NN 13433 1774 20 , , , 13433 1774 21 being be VBG 13433 1774 22 avowedly avowedly RB 13433 1774 23 common common JJ 13433 1774 24 also also RB 13433 1774 25 to to IN 13433 1774 26 Satanic satanic JJ 13433 1774 27 agency agency NN 13433 1774 28 , , , 13433 1774 29 but but CC 13433 1774 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1774 31 is be VBZ 13433 1774 32 not not RB 13433 1774 33 original original JJ 13433 1774 34 either either CC 13433 1774 35 in in IN 13433 1774 36 conception conception NN 13433 1774 37 or or CC 13433 1774 38 details detail NNS 13433 1774 39 . . . 13433 1775 1 Similar similar JJ 13433 1775 2 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1775 3 are be VBP 13433 1775 4 reported report VBN 13433 1775 5 long long RB 13433 1775 6 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 1775 7 to to IN 13433 1775 8 the the DT 13433 1775 9 first first JJ 13433 1775 10 promulgation promulgation NN 13433 1775 11 of of IN 13433 1775 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1775 13 , , , 13433 1775 14 and and CC 13433 1775 15 continued continue VBD 13433 1775 16 to to TO 13433 1775 17 be be VB 13433 1775 18 performed perform VBN 13433 1775 19 for for IN 13433 1775 20 centuries century NNS 13433 1775 21 after after IN 13433 1775 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1775 23 . . . 13433 1776 1 A a DT 13433 1776 2 stream stream NN 13433 1776 3 of of IN 13433 1776 4 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1776 5 pretension pretension NN 13433 1776 6 , , , 13433 1776 7 in in IN 13433 1776 8 fact fact NN 13433 1776 9 , , , 13433 1776 10 has have VBZ 13433 1776 11 flowed flow VBN 13433 1776 12 through through IN 13433 1776 13 all all DT 13433 1776 14 human human JJ 13433 1776 15 history history NN 13433 1776 16 , , , 13433 1776 17 deep deep JJ 13433 1776 18 and and CC 13433 1776 19 broad broad JJ 13433 1776 20 as as IN 13433 1776 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1776 22 has have VBZ 13433 1776 23 passed pass VBN 13433 1776 24 through through IN 13433 1776 25 the the DT 13433 1776 26 darker dark JJR 13433 1776 27 ages age NNS 13433 1776 28 , , , 13433 1776 29 but but CC 13433 1776 30 dwindling dwindle VBG 13433 1776 31 down down RP 13433 1776 32 to to IN 13433 1776 33 a a DT 13433 1776 34 thread thread NN 13433 1776 35 as as IN 13433 1776 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1776 37 has have VBZ 13433 1776 38 entered enter VBN 13433 1776 39 days day NNS 13433 1776 40 of of IN 13433 1776 41 enlightenment enlightenment NN 13433 1776 42 . . . 13433 1777 1 The the DT 13433 1777 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 1777 3 was be VBD 13433 1777 4 too too RB 13433 1777 5 hackneyed hackneyed JJ 13433 1777 6 and and CC 13433 1777 7 commonplace commonplace JJ 13433 1777 8 to to TO 13433 1777 9 make make VB 13433 1777 10 any any DT 13433 1777 11 impression impression NN 13433 1777 12 upon upon IN 13433 1777 13 those those DT 13433 1777 14 before before IN 13433 1777 15 whom whom WP 13433 1777 16 the the DT 13433 1777 17 Christian christian JJ 13433 1777 18 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1777 19 are be VBP 13433 1777 20 said say VBN 13433 1777 21 to to TO 13433 1777 22 have have VB 13433 1777 23 been be VBN 13433 1777 24 performed perform VBN 13433 1777 25 , , , 13433 1777 26 and and CC 13433 1777 27 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1777 28 altogether altogether RB 13433 1777 29 failed fail VBD 13433 1777 30 to to TO 13433 1777 31 convince convince VB 13433 1777 32 the the DT 13433 1777 33 people people NNS 13433 1777 34 to to TO 13433 1777 35 whom whom WP 13433 1777 36 the the DT 13433 1777 37 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1777 38 was be VBD 13433 1777 39 primarily primarily RB 13433 1777 40 addressed address VBN 13433 1777 41 . . . 13433 1778 1 The the DT 13433 1778 2 selection selection NN 13433 1778 3 of of IN 13433 1778 4 such such JJ 13433 1778 5 evidence evidence NN 13433 1778 6 for for IN 13433 1778 7 such such PDT 13433 1778 8 a a DT 13433 1778 9 purpose purpose NN 13433 1778 10 is be VBZ 13433 1778 11 much much RB 13433 1778 12 more more RBR 13433 1778 13 characteristic characteristic JJ 13433 1778 14 of of IN 13433 1778 15 human human JJ 13433 1778 16 weakness weakness NN 13433 1778 17 than than IN 13433 1778 18 of of IN 13433 1778 19 Divine divine JJ 13433 1778 20 power power NN 13433 1778 21 . . . 13433 1779 1 The the DT 13433 1779 2 true true JJ 13433 1779 3 character character NN 13433 1779 4 of of IN 13433 1779 5 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1779 6 is be VBZ 13433 1779 7 at at IN 13433 1779 8 once once RB 13433 1779 9 betrayed betray VBN 13433 1779 10 by by IN 13433 1779 11 the the DT 13433 1779 12 fact fact NN 13433 1779 13 that that IN 13433 1779 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1779 15 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1779 16 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 1779 17 has have VBZ 13433 1779 18 thus thus RB 13433 1779 19 been be VBN 13433 1779 20 confined confine VBN 13433 1779 21 to to IN 13433 1779 22 ages age NNS 13433 1779 23 of of IN 13433 1779 24 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1779 25 and and CC 13433 1779 26 superstition superstition NN 13433 1779 27 , , , 13433 1779 28 and and CC 13433 1779 29 that that IN 13433 1779 30 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1779 31 are be VBP 13433 1779 32 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1779 33 unknown unknown JJ 13433 1779 34 in in IN 13433 1779 35 any any DT 13433 1779 36 time time NN 13433 1779 37 or or CC 13433 1779 38 place place NN 13433 1779 39 where where WRB 13433 1779 40 science science NN 13433 1779 41 has have VBZ 13433 1779 42 provided provide VBN 13433 1779 43 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1779 44 fitted fit VBN 13433 1779 45 to to TO 13433 1779 46 appreciate appreciate VB 13433 1779 47 and and CC 13433 1779 48 ascertain ascertain VB 13433 1779 49 the the DT 13433 1779 50 nature nature NN 13433 1779 51 of of IN 13433 1779 52 such such JJ 13433 1779 53 exhibitions exhibition NNS 13433 1779 54 of of IN 13433 1779 55 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1779 56 power power NN 13433 1779 57 . . . 13433 1780 1 There there EX 13433 1780 2 is be VBZ 13433 1780 3 not not RB 13433 1780 4 the the DT 13433 1780 5 slightest slight JJS 13433 1780 6 evidence evidence NN 13433 1780 7 that that IN 13433 1780 8 any any DT 13433 1780 9 attempt attempt NN 13433 1780 10 was be VBD 13433 1780 11 made make VBN 13433 1780 12 to to TO 13433 1780 13 investigate investigate VB 13433 1780 14 the the DT 13433 1780 15 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1780 16 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1780 17 occurrences occurrence NNS 13433 1780 18 , , , 13433 1780 19 or or CC 13433 1780 20 to to TO 13433 1780 21 justify justify VB 13433 1780 22 the the DT 13433 1780 23 inferences inference NNS 13433 1780 24 so so RB 13433 1780 25 freely freely RB 13433 1780 26 drawn draw VBN 13433 1780 27 from from IN 13433 1780 28 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1780 29 , , , 13433 1780 30 nor nor CC 13433 1780 31 is be VBZ 13433 1780 32 there there EX 13433 1780 33 any any DT 13433 1780 34 reason reason NN 13433 1780 35 to to TO 13433 1780 36 believe believe VB 13433 1780 37 that that IN 13433 1780 38 the the DT 13433 1780 39 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1780 40 possessed possess VBD 13433 1780 41 , , , 13433 1780 42 in in IN 13433 1780 43 any any DT 13433 1780 44 considerable considerable JJ 13433 1780 45 degree degree NN 13433 1780 46 , , , 13433 1780 47 the the DT 13433 1780 48 fulness fulness NN 13433 1780 49 of of IN 13433 1780 50 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1780 51 and and CC 13433 1780 52 sobriety sobriety NN 13433 1780 53 of of IN 13433 1780 54 judgment judgment NN 13433 1780 55 requisite requisite JJ 13433 1780 56 for for IN 13433 1780 57 the the DT 13433 1780 58 purpose purpose NN 13433 1780 59 . . . 13433 1781 1 No no DT 13433 1781 2 miracle miracle NN 13433 1781 3 has have VBZ 13433 1781 4 yet yet RB 13433 1781 5 established establish VBN 13433 1781 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1781 7 claim claim NN 13433 1781 8 to to IN 13433 1781 9 the the DT 13433 1781 10 rank rank NN 13433 1781 11 even even RB 13433 1781 12 of of IN 13433 1781 13 apparent apparent JJ 13433 1781 14 reality reality NN 13433 1781 15 , , , 13433 1781 16 and and CC 13433 1781 17 all all DT 13433 1781 18 such such JJ 13433 1781 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1781 20 must must MD 13433 1781 21 remain remain VB 13433 1781 22 in in IN 13433 1781 23 the the DT 13433 1781 24 dim dim JJ 13433 1781 25 region region NN 13433 1781 26 of of IN 13433 1781 27 imagination imagination NN 13433 1781 28 . . . 13433 1782 1 The the DT 13433 1782 2 test test NN 13433 1782 3 applied apply VBD 13433 1782 4 to to IN 13433 1782 5 the the DT 13433 1782 6 largest large JJS 13433 1782 7 class class NN 13433 1782 8 of of IN 13433 1782 9 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1782 10 , , , 13433 1782 11 connected connect VBN 13433 1782 12 with with IN 13433 1782 13 demoniacal demoniacal JJ 13433 1782 14 possession possession NN 13433 1782 15 , , , 13433 1782 16 discloses disclose VBZ 13433 1782 17 the the DT 13433 1782 18 falsity falsity NN 13433 1782 19 of of IN 13433 1782 20 all all DT 13433 1782 21 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1782 22 pretension pretension NN 13433 1782 23 . . . 13433 1783 1 There there EX 13433 1783 2 is be VBZ 13433 1783 3 no no DT 13433 1783 4 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 1783 5 as as IN 13433 1783 6 to to IN 13433 1783 7 the the DT 13433 1783 8 origin origin NN 13433 1783 9 of of IN 13433 1783 10 belief belief NN 13433 1783 11 in in IN 13433 1783 12 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1783 13 interference interference NN 13433 1783 14 with with IN 13433 1783 15 nature nature NN 13433 1783 16 . . . 13433 1784 1 The the DT 13433 1784 2 assertion assertion NN 13433 1784 3 that that IN 13433 1784 4 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1784 5 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1784 6 have have VBP 13433 1784 7 sprung spring VBN 13433 1784 8 up up RP 13433 1784 9 round round IN 13433 1784 10 a a DT 13433 1784 11 few few JJ 13433 1784 12 instances instance NNS 13433 1784 13 of of IN 13433 1784 14 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1784 15 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1784 16 power power NN 13433 1784 17 has have VBZ 13433 1784 18 not not RB 13433 1784 19 a a DT 13433 1784 20 single single JJ 13433 1784 21 valid valid JJ 13433 1784 22 argument argument NN 13433 1784 23 to to TO 13433 1784 24 support support VB 13433 1784 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1784 26 . . . 13433 1785 1 History history NN 13433 1785 2 clearly clearly RB 13433 1785 3 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 1785 4 that that IN 13433 1785 5 , , , 13433 1785 6 wherever wherever WRB 13433 1785 7 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1785 8 and and CC 13433 1785 9 superstition superstition NN 13433 1785 10 have have VBP 13433 1785 11 prevailed prevail VBN 13433 1785 12 , , , 13433 1785 13 every every DT 13433 1785 14 obscure obscure JJ 13433 1785 15 occurrence occurrence NN 13433 1785 16 has have VBZ 13433 1785 17 been be VBN 13433 1785 18 attributed attribute VBN 13433 1785 19 to to IN 13433 1785 20 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1785 21 agency agency NN 13433 1785 22 , , , 13433 1785 23 and and CC 13433 1785 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1785 25 is be VBZ 13433 1785 26 freely freely RB 13433 1785 27 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 13433 1785 28 that that IN 13433 1785 29 , , , 13433 1785 30 under under IN 13433 1785 31 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1785 32 influence influence NN 13433 1785 33 , , , 13433 1785 34 ' ' '' 13433 1785 35 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 13433 1785 36 ' ' '' 13433 1785 37 and and CC 13433 1785 38 ' ' `` 13433 1785 39 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1785 40 ' ' '' 13433 1785 41 are be VBP 13433 1785 42 convertible convertible JJ 13433 1785 43 terms term NNS 13433 1785 44 . . . 13433 1786 1 On on IN 13433 1786 2 the the DT 13433 1786 3 other other JJ 13433 1786 4 hand hand NN 13433 1786 5 , , , 13433 1786 6 in in IN 13433 1786 7 proportion proportion NN 13433 1786 8 as as IN 13433 1786 9 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1786 10 of of IN 13433 1786 11 natural natural JJ 13433 1786 12 laws law NNS 13433 1786 13 has have VBZ 13433 1786 14 increased increase VBN 13433 1786 15 , , , 13433 1786 16 the the DT 13433 1786 17 theory theory NN 13433 1786 18 of of IN 13433 1786 19 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1786 20 interference interference NN 13433 1786 21 with with IN 13433 1786 22 the the DT 13433 1786 23 order order NN 13433 1786 24 of of IN 13433 1786 25 nature nature NN 13433 1786 26 has have VBZ 13433 1786 27 been be VBN 13433 1786 28 dispelled dispel VBN 13433 1786 29 and and CC 13433 1786 30 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1786 31 have have VBP 13433 1786 32 ceased cease VBN 13433 1786 33 . . . 13433 1787 1 The the DT 13433 1787 2 effect effect NN 13433 1787 3 of of IN 13433 1787 4 science science NN 13433 1787 5 , , , 13433 1787 6 however however RB 13433 1787 7 , , , 13433 1787 8 is be VBZ 13433 1787 9 not not RB 13433 1787 10 limited limit VBN 13433 1787 11 to to IN 13433 1787 12 the the DT 13433 1787 13 present present JJ 13433 1787 14 and and CC 13433 1787 15 future future NN 13433 1787 16 , , , 13433 1787 17 but but CC 13433 1787 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1787 19 action action NN 13433 1787 20 is be VBZ 13433 1787 21 equally equally RB 13433 1787 22 retrospective retrospective JJ 13433 1787 23 , , , 13433 1787 24 and and CC 13433 1787 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1787 26 which which WDT 13433 1787 27 were be VBD 13433 1787 28 once once RB 13433 1787 29 ignorantly ignorantly RB 13433 1787 30 isolated isolate VBN 13433 1787 31 from from IN 13433 1787 32 the the DT 13433 1787 33 sequence sequence NN 13433 1787 34 of of IN 13433 1787 35 natural natural JJ 13433 1787 36 cause cause NN 13433 1787 37 and and CC 13433 1787 38 effect effect NN 13433 1787 39 are be VBP 13433 1787 40 now now RB 13433 1787 41 restored restore VBN 13433 1787 42 to to IN 13433 1787 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1787 44 place place NN 13433 1787 45 in in IN 13433 1787 46 the the DT 13433 1787 47 unbroken unbroken JJ 13433 1787 48 order order NN 13433 1787 49 . . . 13433 1788 1 Ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1788 2 and and CC 13433 1788 3 superstition superstition NN 13433 1788 4 created create VBD 13433 1788 5 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1788 6 ; ; : 13433 1788 7 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1788 8 has have VBZ 13433 1788 9 for for IN 13433 1788 10 ever ever RB 13433 1788 11 annihilated annihilate VBN 13433 1788 12 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1788 13 . . . 13433 1789 1 To to TO 13433 1789 2 justify justify VB 13433 1789 3 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1789 4 , , , 13433 1789 5 two two CD 13433 1789 6 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 1789 7 are be VBP 13433 1789 8 made make VBN 13433 1789 9 : : : 13433 1789 10 first first RB 13433 1789 11 , , , 13433 1789 12 an an DT 13433 1789 13 Infinite Infinite NNP 13433 1789 14 Personal Personal NNP 13433 1789 15 God God NNP 13433 1789 16 ; ; : 13433 1789 17 and and CC 13433 1789 18 second second RB 13433 1789 19 , , , 13433 1789 20 a a DT 13433 1789 21 Divine divine JJ 13433 1789 22 design design NN 13433 1789 23 of of IN 13433 1789 24 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1789 25 , , , 13433 1789 26 the the DT 13433 1789 27 execution execution NN 13433 1789 28 of of IN 13433 1789 29 which which WDT 13433 1789 30 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 1789 31 involves involve VBZ 13433 1789 32 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1789 33 action action NN 13433 1789 34 . . . 13433 1790 1 Miracles miracle NNS 13433 1790 2 , , , 13433 1790 3 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1790 4 is be VBZ 13433 1790 5 argued argue VBN 13433 1790 6 , , , 13433 1790 7 are be VBP 13433 1790 8 not not RB 13433 1790 9 contrary contrary JJ 13433 1790 10 to to IN 13433 1790 11 nature nature NN 13433 1790 12 , , , 13433 1790 13 or or CC 13433 1790 14 effects effect NNS 13433 1790 15 produced produce VBN 13433 1790 16 without without IN 13433 1790 17 adequate adequate JJ 13433 1790 18 causes cause NNS 13433 1790 19 , , , 13433 1790 20 but but CC 13433 1790 21 on on IN 13433 1790 22 the the DT 13433 1790 23 contrary contrary NN 13433 1790 24 are be VBP 13433 1790 25 caused cause VBN 13433 1790 26 by by IN 13433 1790 27 the the DT 13433 1790 28 intervention intervention NN 13433 1790 29 of of IN 13433 1790 30 this this DT 13433 1790 31 Infinite Infinite NNP 13433 1790 32 Personal Personal NNP 13433 1790 33 God God NNP 13433 1790 34 for for IN 13433 1790 35 the the DT 13433 1790 36 purpose purpose NN 13433 1790 37 of of IN 13433 1790 38 attesting attest VBG 13433 1790 39 and and CC 13433 1790 40 carrying carry VBG 13433 1790 41 out out RP 13433 1790 42 the the DT 13433 1790 43 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1790 44 design design NN 13433 1790 45 . . . 13433 1791 1 Neither neither DT 13433 1791 2 of of IN 13433 1791 3 the the DT 13433 1791 4 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 1791 5 , , , 13433 1791 6 however however RB 13433 1791 7 , , , 13433 1791 8 can can MD 13433 1791 9 be be VB 13433 1791 10 reasonably reasonably RB 13433 1791 11 maintained maintain VBN 13433 1791 12 . . . 13433 1792 1 The the DT 13433 1792 2 assumption assumption NN 13433 1792 3 of of IN 13433 1792 4 an an DT 13433 1792 5 Infinite Infinite NNP 13433 1792 6 Personal Personal NNP 13433 1792 7 God God NNP 13433 1792 8 : : : 13433 1792 9 a a DT 13433 1792 10 Being being NN 13433 1792 11 at at IN 13433 1792 12 once once RB 13433 1792 13 limited limited JJ 13433 1792 14 and and CC 13433 1792 15 unlimited unlimited JJ 13433 1792 16 , , , 13433 1792 17 is be VBZ 13433 1792 18 a a DT 13433 1792 19 use use NN 13433 1792 20 of of IN 13433 1792 21 language language NN 13433 1792 22 to to TO 13433 1792 23 which which WDT 13433 1792 24 no no DT 13433 1792 25 mode mode NN 13433 1792 26 of of IN 13433 1792 27 human human JJ 13433 1792 28 thought thought NN 13433 1792 29 can can MD 13433 1792 30 possibly possibly RB 13433 1792 31 attach attach VB 13433 1792 32 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1792 33 . . . 13433 1793 1 Moreover moreover RB 13433 1793 2 , , , 13433 1793 3 the the DT 13433 1793 4 assumption assumption NN 13433 1793 5 of of IN 13433 1793 6 a a DT 13433 1793 7 God God NNP 13433 1793 8 working work VBG 13433 1793 9 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1793 10 is be VBZ 13433 1793 11 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 1793 12 excluded exclude VBN 13433 1793 13 by by IN 13433 1793 14 universal universal JJ 13433 1793 15 experience experience NN 13433 1793 16 of of IN 13433 1793 17 the the DT 13433 1793 18 order order NN 13433 1793 19 of of IN 13433 1793 20 nature nature NN 13433 1793 21 . . . 13433 1794 1 The the DT 13433 1794 2 allegation allegation NN 13433 1794 3 of of IN 13433 1794 4 a a DT 13433 1794 5 specific specific JJ 13433 1794 6 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1794 7 cause cause NN 13433 1794 8 of of IN 13433 1794 9 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1794 10 is be VBZ 13433 1794 11 further further RB 13433 1794 12 inadequate inadequate JJ 13433 1794 13 from from IN 13433 1794 14 the the DT 13433 1794 15 fact fact NN 13433 1794 16 that that IN 13433 1794 17 the the DT 13433 1794 18 power power NN 13433 1794 19 of of IN 13433 1794 20 working work VBG 13433 1794 21 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1794 22 is be VBZ 13433 1794 23 avowedly avowedly RB 13433 1794 24 not not RB 13433 1794 25 limited limit VBN 13433 1794 26 to to IN 13433 1794 27 a a DT 13433 1794 28 Personal Personal NNP 13433 1794 29 God God NNP 13433 1794 30 , , , 13433 1794 31 but but CC 13433 1794 32 is be VBZ 13433 1794 33 also also RB 13433 1794 34 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1794 35 to to IN 13433 1794 36 other other JJ 13433 1794 37 spiritual spiritual JJ 13433 1794 38 Beings being NNS 13433 1794 39 , , , 13433 1794 40 and and CC 13433 1794 41 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1794 42 must must MD 13433 1794 43 , , , 13433 1794 44 consequently consequently RB 13433 1794 45 , , , 13433 1794 46 always always RB 13433 1794 47 be be VB 13433 1794 48 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1794 49 to to TO 13433 1794 50 prove prove VB 13433 1794 51 that that IN 13433 1794 52 the the DT 13433 1794 53 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1794 54 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1794 55 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1794 56 originate originate VBP 13433 1794 57 with with IN 13433 1794 58 one one CD 13433 1794 59 and and CC 13433 1794 60 not not RB 13433 1794 61 with with IN 13433 1794 62 the the DT 13433 1794 63 other other JJ 13433 1794 64 . . . 13433 1795 1 On on IN 13433 1795 2 the the DT 13433 1795 3 other other JJ 13433 1795 4 hand hand NN 13433 1795 5 , , , 13433 1795 6 the the DT 13433 1795 7 assumption assumption NN 13433 1795 8 of of IN 13433 1795 9 a a DT 13433 1795 10 Divine divine JJ 13433 1795 11 design design NN 13433 1795 12 of of IN 13433 1795 13 Revelation revelation NN 13433 1795 14 is be VBZ 13433 1795 15 not not RB 13433 1795 16 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1795 17 by by IN 13433 1795 18 antecedent antecedent NN 13433 1795 19 probability probability NN 13433 1795 20 , , , 13433 1795 21 but but CC 13433 1795 22 is be VBZ 13433 1795 23 derived derive VBN 13433 1795 24 from from IN 13433 1795 25 the the DT 13433 1795 26 very very JJ 13433 1795 27 Revelation revelation NN 13433 1795 28 which which WDT 13433 1795 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1795 30 is be VBZ 13433 1795 31 intended intend VBN 13433 1795 32 to to TO 13433 1795 33 justify justify VB 13433 1795 34 , , , 13433 1795 35 as as IN 13433 1795 36 is be VBZ 13433 1795 37 likewise likewise RB 13433 1795 38 the the DT 13433 1795 39 assumption assumption NN 13433 1795 40 of of IN 13433 1795 41 a a DT 13433 1795 42 Personal Personal NNP 13433 1795 43 God God NNP 13433 1795 44 , , , 13433 1795 45 and and CC 13433 1795 46 both both DT 13433 1795 47 are be VBP 13433 1795 48 equally equally RB 13433 1795 49 vicious vicious JJ 13433 1795 50 as as IN 13433 1795 51 arguments argument NNS 13433 1795 52 . . . 13433 1796 1 The the DT 13433 1796 2 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1796 3 which which WDT 13433 1796 4 are be VBP 13433 1796 5 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1796 6 to to TO 13433 1796 7 require require VB 13433 1796 8 this this DT 13433 1796 9 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1796 10 design design NN 13433 1796 11 , , , 13433 1796 12 and and CC 13433 1796 13 the the DT 13433 1796 14 details detail NNS 13433 1796 15 of of IN 13433 1796 16 the the DT 13433 1796 17 scheme scheme NN 13433 1796 18 , , , 13433 1796 19 are be VBP 13433 1796 20 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1796 21 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1796 22 and and CC 13433 1796 23 opposed opposed JJ 13433 1796 24 to to IN 13433 1796 25 all all PDT 13433 1796 26 the the DT 13433 1796 27 results result NNS 13433 1796 28 of of IN 13433 1796 29 science science NN 13433 1796 30 . . . 13433 1797 1 Nature nature NN 13433 1797 2 does do VBZ 13433 1797 3 not not RB 13433 1797 4 countenance countenance VB 13433 1797 5 any any DT 13433 1797 6 theory theory NN 13433 1797 7 of of IN 13433 1797 8 the the DT 13433 1797 9 original original JJ 13433 1797 10 perfection perfection NN 13433 1797 11 and and CC 13433 1797 12 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 1797 13 degradation degradation NN 13433 1797 14 of of IN 13433 1797 15 the the DT 13433 1797 16 human human JJ 13433 1797 17 race race NN 13433 1797 18 , , , 13433 1797 19 and and CC 13433 1797 20 the the DT 13433 1797 21 supposition supposition NN 13433 1797 22 of of IN 13433 1797 23 a a DT 13433 1797 24 frustrated frustrated JJ 13433 1797 25 original original JJ 13433 1797 26 plan plan NN 13433 1797 27 of of IN 13433 1797 28 creation creation NN 13433 1797 29 , , , 13433 1797 30 and and CC 13433 1797 31 of of IN 13433 1797 32 later later JJ 13433 1797 33 impotent impotent JJ 13433 1797 34 endeavours endeavour NNS 13433 1797 35 to to TO 13433 1797 36 correct correct VB 13433 1797 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1797 38 , , , 13433 1797 39 is be VBZ 13433 1797 40 as as RB 13433 1797 41 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 13433 1797 42 with with IN 13433 1797 43 Divine divine JJ 13433 1797 44 omnipotence omnipotence NN 13433 1797 45 and and CC 13433 1797 46 wisdom wisdom NN 13433 1797 47 as as IN 13433 1797 48 the the DT 13433 1797 49 proposed propose VBN 13433 1797 50 punishment punishment NN 13433 1797 51 of of IN 13433 1797 52 the the DT 13433 1797 53 human human JJ 13433 1797 54 race race NN 13433 1797 55 and and CC 13433 1797 56 the the DT 13433 1797 57 mode mode NN 13433 1797 58 devised devise VBD 13433 1797 59 to to TO 13433 1797 60 save save VB 13433 1797 61 some some DT 13433 1797 62 of of IN 13433 1797 63 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1797 64 are be VBP 13433 1797 65 opposed oppose VBN 13433 1797 66 to to IN 13433 1797 67 justice justice NN 13433 1797 68 and and CC 13433 1797 69 morality morality NN 13433 1797 70 . . . 13433 1798 1 Such such JJ 13433 1798 2 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 1798 3 are be VBP 13433 1798 4 essentially essentially RB 13433 1798 5 inadmissible inadmissible JJ 13433 1798 6 , , , 13433 1798 7 and and CC 13433 1798 8 totally totally RB 13433 1798 9 fail fail VB 13433 1798 10 to to TO 13433 1798 11 explain explain VB 13433 1798 12 and and CC 13433 1798 13 justify justify VB 13433 1798 14 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1798 15 . . . 13433 1799 1 Whatever whatever WDT 13433 1799 2 definition definition NN 13433 1799 3 be be VB 13433 1799 4 given give VBN 13433 1799 5 of of IN 13433 1799 6 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1799 7 , , , 13433 1799 8 such such JJ 13433 1799 9 exceptional exceptional JJ 13433 1799 10 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1799 11 must must MD 13433 1799 12 at at IN 13433 1799 13 least least JJS 13433 1799 14 be be VB 13433 1799 15 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 1799 16 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1799 17 . . . 13433 1800 1 In in IN 13433 1800 2 the the DT 13433 1800 3 absence absence NN 13433 1800 4 of of IN 13433 1800 5 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1800 6 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1800 7 , , , 13433 1800 8 human human JJ 13433 1800 9 belief belief NN 13433 1800 10 must must MD 13433 1800 11 be be VB 13433 1800 12 guided guide VBN 13433 1800 13 by by IN 13433 1800 14 the the DT 13433 1800 15 balance balance NN 13433 1800 16 of of IN 13433 1800 17 evidence evidence NN 13433 1800 18 , , , 13433 1800 19 and and CC 13433 1800 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1800 21 is be VBZ 13433 1800 22 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1800 23 that that IN 13433 1800 24 the the DT 13433 1800 25 evidence evidence NN 13433 1800 26 for for IN 13433 1800 27 the the DT 13433 1800 28 uniformity uniformity NN 13433 1800 29 of of IN 13433 1800 30 the the DT 13433 1800 31 order order NN 13433 1800 32 of of IN 13433 1800 33 nature nature NN 13433 1800 34 , , , 13433 1800 35 which which WDT 13433 1800 36 is be VBZ 13433 1800 37 derived derive VBN 13433 1800 38 from from IN 13433 1800 39 universal universal JJ 13433 1800 40 experience experience NN 13433 1800 41 , , , 13433 1800 42 must must MD 13433 1800 43 be be VB 13433 1800 44 enormously enormously RB 13433 1800 45 greater great JJR 13433 1800 46 than than IN 13433 1800 47 can can MD 13433 1800 48 be be VB 13433 1800 49 the the DT 13433 1800 50 testimony testimony NN 13433 1800 51 for for IN 13433 1800 52 any any DT 13433 1800 53 alleged allege VBN 13433 1800 54 exception exception NN 13433 1800 55 to to IN 13433 1800 56 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1800 57 . . . 13433 1801 1 On on IN 13433 1801 2 the the DT 13433 1801 3 other other JJ 13433 1801 4 hand hand NN 13433 1801 5 , , , 13433 1801 6 universal universal JJ 13433 1801 7 experience experience NN 13433 1801 8 prepares prepare VBZ 13433 1801 9 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1801 10 to to TO 13433 1801 11 consider consider VB 13433 1801 12 mistakes mistake NNS 13433 1801 13 of of IN 13433 1801 14 the the DT 13433 1801 15 senses sense NNS 13433 1801 16 , , , 13433 1801 17 imperfect imperfect JJ 13433 1801 18 observation observation NN 13433 1801 19 and and CC 13433 1801 20 erroneous erroneous JJ 13433 1801 21 inference inference NN 13433 1801 22 as as IN 13433 1801 23 not not RB 13433 1801 24 only only RB 13433 1801 25 possible possible JJ 13433 1801 26 , , , 13433 1801 27 but but CC 13433 1801 28 eminently eminently RB 13433 1801 29 probable probable JJ 13433 1801 30 on on IN 13433 1801 31 the the DT 13433 1801 32 part part NN 13433 1801 33 of of IN 13433 1801 34 the the DT 13433 1801 35 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1801 36 of of IN 13433 1801 37 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1801 38 , , , 13433 1801 39 even even RB 13433 1801 40 when when WRB 13433 1801 41 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1801 42 are be VBP 13433 1801 43 perfectly perfectly RB 13433 1801 44 honest honest JJ 13433 1801 45 and and CC 13433 1801 46 truthful truthful JJ 13433 1801 47 , , , 13433 1801 48 and and CC 13433 1801 49 more more RBR 13433 1801 50 especially especially RB 13433 1801 51 so so RB 13433 1801 52 when when WRB 13433 1801 53 such such JJ 13433 1801 54 disturbing disturbing JJ 13433 1801 55 causes cause NNS 13433 1801 56 as as IN 13433 1801 57 religious religious JJ 13433 1801 58 excitement excitement NN 13433 1801 59 and and CC 13433 1801 60 superstition superstition NN 13433 1801 61 are be VBP 13433 1801 62 present present JJ 13433 1801 63 . . . 13433 1802 1 When when WRB 13433 1802 2 the the DT 13433 1802 3 report report NN 13433 1802 4 of of IN 13433 1802 5 the the DT 13433 1802 6 original original JJ 13433 1802 7 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1802 8 only only RB 13433 1802 9 reaches reach VBZ 13433 1802 10 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1802 11 indirectly indirectly RB 13433 1802 12 and and CC 13433 1802 13 through through IN 13433 1802 14 the the DT 13433 1802 15 medium medium NN 13433 1802 16 of of IN 13433 1802 17 tradition tradition NN 13433 1802 18 , , , 13433 1802 19 the the DT 13433 1802 20 probability probability NN 13433 1802 21 of of IN 13433 1802 22 error error NN 13433 1802 23 is be VBZ 13433 1802 24 further further RB 13433 1802 25 increased increase VBN 13433 1802 26 . . . 13433 1803 1 Thus thus RB 13433 1803 2 the the DT 13433 1803 3 allegation allegation NN 13433 1803 4 of of IN 13433 1803 5 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1803 6 is be VBZ 13433 1803 7 discredited discredit VBN 13433 1803 8 , , , 13433 1803 9 both both DT 13433 1803 10 positively positively RB 13433 1803 11 by by IN 13433 1803 12 the the DT 13433 1803 13 invariability invariability NN 13433 1803 14 of of IN 13433 1803 15 the the DT 13433 1803 16 order order NN 13433 1803 17 of of IN 13433 1803 18 nature nature NN 13433 1803 19 , , , 13433 1803 20 and and CC 13433 1803 21 negatively negatively RB 13433 1803 22 by by IN 13433 1803 23 the the DT 13433 1803 24 fallibility fallibility NN 13433 1803 25 of of IN 13433 1803 26 human human JJ 13433 1803 27 observation observation NN 13433 1803 28 and and CC 13433 1803 29 testimony testimony NN 13433 1803 30 . . . 13433 1804 1 The the DT 13433 1804 2 history history NN 13433 1804 3 of of IN 13433 1804 4 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1804 5 pretension pretension NN 13433 1804 6 in in IN 13433 1804 7 the the DT 13433 1804 8 world world NN 13433 1804 9 and and CC 13433 1804 10 the the DT 13433 1804 11 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1804 12 attending attend VBG 13433 1804 13 the the DT 13433 1804 14 special special JJ 13433 1804 15 exhibition exhibition NN 13433 1804 16 of of IN 13433 1804 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1804 18 which which WDT 13433 1804 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1804 20 are be VBP 13433 1804 21 examining examine VBG 13433 1804 22 suggest suggest VBP 13433 1804 23 natural natural JJ 13433 1804 24 explanations explanation NNS 13433 1804 25 of of IN 13433 1804 26 the the DT 13433 1804 27 reported report VBN 13433 1804 28 facts fact NNS 13433 1804 29 which which WDT 13433 1804 30 wholly wholly RB 13433 1804 31 remove remove VBP 13433 1804 32 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1804 33 from from IN 13433 1804 34 the the DT 13433 1804 35 region region NN 13433 1804 36 of of IN 13433 1804 37 the the DT 13433 1804 38 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1804 39 . . . 13433 1805 1 When when WRB 13433 1805 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1805 3 proceed proceed VBP 13433 1805 4 to to TO 13433 1805 5 examine examine VB 13433 1805 6 the the DT 13433 1805 7 direct direct JJ 13433 1805 8 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1805 9 for for IN 13433 1805 10 the the DT 13433 1805 11 Christian christian JJ 13433 1805 12 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1805 13 , , , 13433 1805 14 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1805 15 do do VBP 13433 1805 16 not not RB 13433 1805 17 discover discover VB 13433 1805 18 any any DT 13433 1805 19 exceptional exceptional JJ 13433 1805 20 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1805 21 neutralising neutralise VBG 13433 1805 22 the the DT 13433 1805 23 preceding precede VBG 13433 1805 24 considerations consideration NNS 13433 1805 25 . . . 13433 1806 1 On on IN 13433 1806 2 the the DT 13433 1806 3 contrary contrary NN 13433 1806 4 , , , 13433 1806 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1806 6 find find VBP 13433 1806 7 that that IN 13433 1806 8 the the DT 13433 1806 9 case case NN 13433 1806 10 turns turn VBZ 13433 1806 11 not not RB 13433 1806 12 upon upon IN 13433 1806 13 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1806 14 substantially substantially RB 13433 1806 15 before before IN 13433 1806 16 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1806 17 , , , 13433 1806 18 but but CC 13433 1806 19 upon upon IN 13433 1806 20 the the DT 13433 1806 21 mere mere JJ 13433 1806 22 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1806 23 of of IN 13433 1806 24 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1806 25 said say VBD 13433 1806 26 to to TO 13433 1806 27 have have VB 13433 1806 28 occurred occur VBN 13433 1806 29 over over IN 13433 1806 30 eighteen eighteen CD 13433 1806 31 hundred hundred CD 13433 1806 32 years year NNS 13433 1806 33 ago ago RB 13433 1806 34 . . . 13433 1807 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1807 2 is be VBZ 13433 1807 3 obvious obvious JJ 13433 1807 4 that that IN 13433 1807 5 , , , 13433 1807 6 for for IN 13433 1807 7 such such JJ 13433 1807 8 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1807 9 to to TO 13433 1807 10 possess possess VB 13433 1807 11 any any DT 13433 1807 12 real real JJ 13433 1807 13 force force NN 13433 1807 14 and and CC 13433 1807 15 validity validity NN 13433 1807 16 , , , 13433 1807 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1807 18 is be VBZ 13433 1807 19 essential essential JJ 13433 1807 20 that that IN 13433 1807 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1807 22 character character NN 13433 1807 23 and and CC 13433 1807 24 authorship authorship NN 13433 1807 25 should should MD 13433 1807 26 be be VB 13433 1807 27 placed place VBN 13433 1807 28 beyond beyond IN 13433 1807 29 all all DT 13433 1807 30 doubt doubt NN 13433 1807 31 . . . 13433 1808 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1808 2 must must MD 13433 1808 3 proceed proceed VB 13433 1808 4 from from IN 13433 1808 5 eye eye NN 13433 1808 6 - - HYPH 13433 1808 7 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1808 8 capable capable JJ 13433 1808 9 of of IN 13433 1808 10 estimating estimate VBG 13433 1808 11 aright aright NN 13433 1808 12 the the DT 13433 1808 13 nature nature NN 13433 1808 14 of of IN 13433 1808 15 the the DT 13433 1808 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1808 17 . . . 13433 1809 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1809 2 four four CD 13433 1809 3 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1809 4 , , , 13433 1809 5 however however RB 13433 1809 6 , , , 13433 1809 7 are be VBP 13433 1809 8 strictly strictly RB 13433 1809 9 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1809 10 works work NNS 13433 1809 11 . . . 13433 1810 1 The the DT 13433 1810 2 superscriptions superscription NNS 13433 1810 3 which which WDT 13433 1810 4 now now RB 13433 1810 5 distinguish distinguish VBP 13433 1810 6 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1810 7 are be VBP 13433 1810 8 undeniably undeniably RB 13433 1810 9 of of IN 13433 1810 10 later later JJ 13433 1810 11 origin origin NN 13433 1810 12 than than IN 13433 1810 13 the the DT 13433 1810 14 works work NNS 13433 1810 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1810 16 and and CC 13433 1810 17 do do VBP 13433 1810 18 not not RB 13433 1810 19 proceed proceed VB 13433 1810 20 from from IN 13433 1810 21 the the DT 13433 1810 22 composers composer NNS 13433 1810 23 of of IN 13433 1810 24 the the DT 13433 1810 25 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1810 26 . . . 13433 1811 1 Of of IN 13433 1811 2 the the DT 13433 1811 3 writers writer NNS 13433 1811 4 to to TO 13433 1811 5 whom whom WP 13433 1811 6 these these DT 13433 1811 7 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1811 8 are be VBP 13433 1811 9 traditionally traditionally RB 13433 1811 10 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 1811 11 only only RB 13433 1811 12 two two CD 13433 1811 13 are be VBP 13433 1811 14 even even RB 13433 1811 15 said say VBN 13433 1811 16 to to TO 13433 1811 17 have have VB 13433 1811 18 been be VBN 13433 1811 19 apostles apostle NNS 13433 1811 20 , , , 13433 1811 21 the the DT 13433 1811 22 alleged allege VBN 13433 1811 23 authors author NNS 13433 1811 24 of of IN 13433 1811 25 the the DT 13433 1811 26 second second JJ 13433 1811 27 and and CC 13433 1811 28 third third JJ 13433 1811 29 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 1811 30 neither neither CC 13433 1811 31 having have VBG 13433 1811 32 been be VBN 13433 1811 33 personal personal JJ 13433 1811 34 followers follower NNS 13433 1811 35 of of IN 13433 1811 36 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1811 37 nor nor CC 13433 1811 38 eye eye NN 13433 1811 39 - - HYPH 13433 1811 40 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1811 41 of of IN 13433 1811 42 the the DT 13433 1811 43 events event NNS 13433 1811 44 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1811 45 describe describe VBP 13433 1811 46 . . . 13433 1812 1 Under under IN 13433 1812 2 these these DT 13433 1812 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 13433 1812 4 , , , 13433 1812 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1812 6 are be VBP 13433 1812 7 wholly wholly RB 13433 1812 8 dependent dependent JJ 13433 1812 9 upon upon IN 13433 1812 10 external external JJ 13433 1812 11 evidence evidence NN 13433 1812 12 for for IN 13433 1812 13 information information NN 13433 1812 14 regarding regard VBG 13433 1812 15 the the DT 13433 1812 16 authorship authorship NN 13433 1812 17 and and CC 13433 1812 18 trustworthiness trustworthiness NN 13433 1812 19 of of IN 13433 1812 20 the the DT 13433 1812 21 four four CD 13433 1812 22 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1812 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1812 24 . . . 13433 1813 1 In in IN 13433 1813 2 examining examine VBG 13433 1813 3 this this DT 13433 1813 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 1813 5 , , , 13433 1813 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1813 7 proceeded proceed VBD 13433 1813 8 upon upon IN 13433 1813 9 clear clear JJ 13433 1813 10 and and CC 13433 1813 11 definite definite JJ 13433 1813 12 principles principle NNS 13433 1813 13 . . . 13433 1814 1 Without without IN 13433 1814 2 forming form VBG 13433 1814 3 or or CC 13433 1814 4 adopting adopt VBG 13433 1814 5 any any DT 13433 1814 6 theory theory NN 13433 1814 7 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1814 8 as as IN 13433 1814 9 to to IN 13433 1814 10 the the DT 13433 1814 11 date date NN 13433 1814 12 or or CC 13433 1814 13 origin origin NN 13433 1814 14 of of IN 13433 1814 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1814 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1814 17 , , , 13433 1814 18 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1814 19 simply simply RB 13433 1814 20 searched search VBD 13433 1814 21 the the DT 13433 1814 22 writings writing NNS 13433 1814 23 of of IN 13433 1814 24 the the DT 13433 1814 25 Fathers Fathers NNPS 13433 1814 26 , , , 13433 1814 27 during during IN 13433 1814 28 a a DT 13433 1814 29 century century NN 13433 1814 30 and and CC 13433 1814 31 a a DT 13433 1814 32 half half NN 13433 1814 33 after after IN 13433 1814 34 the the DT 13433 1814 35 events event NNS 13433 1814 36 in in IN 13433 1814 37 question question NN 13433 1814 38 , , , 13433 1814 39 for for IN 13433 1814 40 information information NN 13433 1814 41 regarding regard VBG 13433 1814 42 the the DT 13433 1814 43 composition composition NN 13433 1814 44 and and CC 13433 1814 45 character character NN 13433 1814 46 of of IN 13433 1814 47 these these DT 13433 1814 48 works work NNS 13433 1814 49 and and CC 13433 1814 50 even even RB 13433 1814 51 for for IN 13433 1814 52 any any DT 13433 1814 53 certain certain JJ 13433 1814 54 traces trace NNS 13433 1814 55 of of IN 13433 1814 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1814 57 use use NN 13433 1814 58 , , , 13433 1814 59 although although IN 13433 1814 60 , , , 13433 1814 61 if if IN 13433 1814 62 discovered discover VBN 13433 1814 63 , , , 13433 1814 64 these these DT 13433 1814 65 could could MD 13433 1814 66 prove prove VB 13433 1814 67 little little JJ 13433 1814 68 beyond beyond IN 13433 1814 69 the the DT 13433 1814 70 mere mere JJ 13433 1814 71 existence existence NN 13433 1814 72 of of IN 13433 1814 73 the the DT 13433 1814 74 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1814 75 used use VBN 13433 1814 76 at at IN 13433 1814 77 the the DT 13433 1814 78 date date NN 13433 1814 79 of of IN 13433 1814 80 the the DT 13433 1814 81 writer writer NN 13433 1814 82 . . . 13433 1815 1 In in IN 13433 1815 2 the the DT 13433 1815 3 latter latter JJ 13433 1815 4 and and CC 13433 1815 5 minor minor JJ 13433 1815 6 investigation investigation NN 13433 1815 7 , , , 13433 1815 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1815 9 were be VBD 13433 1815 10 guided guide VBN 13433 1815 11 by by IN 13433 1815 12 canons canon NNS 13433 1815 13 of of IN 13433 1815 14 criticism criticism NN 13433 1815 15 , , , 13433 1815 16 previously previously RB 13433 1815 17 laid lay VBN 13433 1815 18 down down RP 13433 1815 19 , , , 13433 1815 20 which which WDT 13433 1815 21 are be VBP 13433 1815 22 based base VBN 13433 1815 23 upon upon IN 13433 1815 24 the the DT 13433 1815 25 simplest simple JJS 13433 1815 26 laws law NNS 13433 1815 27 of of IN 13433 1815 28 evidence evidence NN 13433 1815 29 . . . 13433 1816 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1816 2 found find VBD 13433 1816 3 that that IN 13433 1816 4 the the DT 13433 1816 5 writings writing NNS 13433 1816 6 of of IN 13433 1816 7 the the DT 13433 1816 8 Fathers Fathers NNPS 13433 1816 9 , , , 13433 1816 10 during during IN 13433 1816 11 a a DT 13433 1816 12 century century NN 13433 1816 13 and and CC 13433 1816 14 a a DT 13433 1816 15 half half NN 13433 1816 16 after after IN 13433 1816 17 the the DT 13433 1816 18 death death NN 13433 1816 19 of of IN 13433 1816 20 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1816 21 , , , 13433 1816 22 are be VBP 13433 1816 23 a a DT 13433 1816 24 complete complete JJ 13433 1816 25 blank blank NN 13433 1816 26 so so RB 13433 1816 27 far far RB 13433 1816 28 as as IN 13433 1816 29 any any DT 13433 1816 30 evidence evidence NN 13433 1816 31 regarding regard VBG 13433 1816 32 the the DT 13433 1816 33 composition composition NN 13433 1816 34 and and CC 13433 1816 35 character character NN 13433 1816 36 of of IN 13433 1816 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1816 38 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1816 39 is be VBZ 13433 1816 40 concerned concern VBN 13433 1816 41 , , , 13433 1816 42 unless unless IN 13433 1816 43 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1816 44 except except IN 13433 1816 45 the the DT 13433 1816 46 tradition tradition NN 13433 1816 47 preserved preserve VBN 13433 1816 48 by by IN 13433 1816 49 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1816 50 , , , 13433 1816 51 after after IN 13433 1816 52 the the DT 13433 1816 53 middle middle NN 13433 1816 54 of of IN 13433 1816 55 the the DT 13433 1816 56 second second JJ 13433 1816 57 century century NN 13433 1816 58 , , , 13433 1816 59 the the DT 13433 1816 60 details detail NNS 13433 1816 61 of of IN 13433 1816 62 which which WDT 13433 1816 63 fully fully RB 13433 1816 64 justify justify VBP 13433 1816 65 the the DT 13433 1816 66 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1816 67 that that IN 13433 1816 68 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1816 69 first first JJ 13433 1816 70 and and CC 13433 1816 71 second second JJ 13433 1816 72 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 1816 73 , , , 13433 1816 74 in in IN 13433 1816 75 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1816 76 present present JJ 13433 1816 77 form form NN 13433 1816 78 , , , 13433 1816 79 can can MD 13433 1816 80 not not RB 13433 1816 81 be be VB 13433 1816 82 the the DT 13433 1816 83 works work NNS 13433 1816 84 said say VBD 13433 1816 85 to to TO 13433 1816 86 have have VB 13433 1816 87 been be VBN 13433 1816 88 composed compose VBN 13433 1816 89 by by IN 13433 1816 90 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 1816 91 and and CC 13433 1816 92 Mark Mark NNP 13433 1816 93 . . . 13433 1817 1 There there EX 13433 1817 2 is be VBZ 13433 1817 3 thus thus RB 13433 1817 4 no no DT 13433 1817 5 evidence evidence NN 13433 1817 6 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1817 7 directly directly RB 13433 1817 8 connecting connect VBG 13433 1817 9 any any DT 13433 1817 10 of of IN 13433 1817 11 the the DT 13433 1817 12 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1817 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1817 14 with with IN 13433 1817 15 the the DT 13433 1817 16 writers writer NNS 13433 1817 17 to to IN 13433 1817 18 whom whom WP 13433 1817 19 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1817 20 are be VBP 13433 1817 21 popularly popularly RB 13433 1817 22 attributed attribute VBN 13433 1817 23 , , , 13433 1817 24 and and CC 13433 1817 25 later later JJ 13433 1817 26 tradition tradition NN 13433 1817 27 , , , 13433 1817 28 of of IN 13433 1817 29 little little JJ 13433 1817 30 or or CC 13433 1817 31 no no DT 13433 1817 32 value value NN 13433 1817 33 in in IN 13433 1817 34 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1817 35 , , , 13433 1817 36 is be VBZ 13433 1817 37 separated separate VBN 13433 1817 38 by by IN 13433 1817 39 a a DT 13433 1817 40 long long JJ 13433 1817 41 interval interval NN 13433 1817 42 of of IN 13433 1817 43 profound profound JJ 13433 1817 44 silence silence NN 13433 1817 45 from from IN 13433 1817 46 the the DT 13433 1817 47 epoch epoch NN 13433 1817 48 at at IN 13433 1817 49 which which WDT 13433 1817 50 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1817 51 are be VBP 13433 1817 52 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1817 53 to to TO 13433 1817 54 have have VB 13433 1817 55 been be VBN 13433 1817 56 composed compose VBN 13433 1817 57 . . . 13433 1818 1 With with IN 13433 1818 2 one one CD 13433 1818 3 exception exception NN 13433 1818 4 , , , 13433 1818 5 moreover moreover RB 13433 1818 6 , , , 13433 1818 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1818 8 found find VBD 13433 1818 9 that that IN 13433 1818 10 , , , 13433 1818 11 during during IN 13433 1818 12 the the DT 13433 1818 13 same same JJ 13433 1818 14 century century NN 13433 1818 15 and and CC 13433 1818 16 a a DT 13433 1818 17 half half NN 13433 1818 18 , , , 13433 1818 19 there there EX 13433 1818 20 is be VBZ 13433 1818 21 no no DT 13433 1818 22 certain certain JJ 13433 1818 23 and and CC 13433 1818 24 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 13433 1818 25 trace trace NN 13433 1818 26 even even RB 13433 1818 27 of of IN 13433 1818 28 the the DT 13433 1818 29 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1818 30 use use NN 13433 1818 31 of of IN 13433 1818 32 any any DT 13433 1818 33 of of IN 13433 1818 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1818 35 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1818 36 in in IN 13433 1818 37 the the DT 13433 1818 38 early early JJ 13433 1818 39 Church church NN 13433 1818 40 . . . 13433 1819 1 This this DT 13433 1819 2 fact fact NN 13433 1819 3 , , , 13433 1819 4 of of IN 13433 1819 5 course course NN 13433 1819 6 , , , 13433 1819 7 does do VBZ 13433 1819 8 not not RB 13433 1819 9 justify justify VB 13433 1819 10 the the DT 13433 1819 11 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1819 12 that that IN 13433 1819 13 none none NN 13433 1819 14 of of IN 13433 1819 15 these these DT 13433 1819 16 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1819 17 was be VBD 13433 1819 18 actually actually RB 13433 1819 19 in in IN 13433 1819 20 existence existence NN 13433 1819 21 during during IN 13433 1819 22 any any DT 13433 1819 23 part part NN 13433 1819 24 of of IN 13433 1819 25 that that DT 13433 1819 26 time time NN 13433 1819 27 , , , 13433 1819 28 nor nor CC 13433 1819 29 have have VBP 13433 1819 30 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1819 31 anywhere anywhere RB 13433 1819 32 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1819 33 such such PDT 13433 1819 34 an an DT 13433 1819 35 inference inference NN 13433 1819 36 , , , 13433 1819 37 but but CC 13433 1819 38 strict strict JJ 13433 1819 39 examination examination NN 13433 1819 40 of of IN 13433 1819 41 the the DT 13433 1819 42 evidence evidence NN 13433 1819 43 shows show VBZ 13433 1819 44 that that IN 13433 1819 45 there there EX 13433 1819 46 is be VBZ 13433 1819 47 no no DT 13433 1819 48 positive positive JJ 13433 1819 49 proof proof NN 13433 1819 50 that that IN 13433 1819 51 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1819 52 were be VBD 13433 1819 53 . . . 13433 1820 1 The the DT 13433 1820 2 exception exception NN 13433 1820 3 to to TO 13433 1820 4 which which WDT 13433 1820 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1820 6 refer refer VBP 13433 1820 7 is be VBZ 13433 1820 8 Marcion Marcion NNP 13433 1820 9 's 's POS 13433 1820 10 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1820 11 , , , 13433 1820 12 which which WDT 13433 1820 13 was be VBD 13433 1820 14 , , , 13433 1820 15 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1820 16 think think VBP 13433 1820 17 , , , 13433 1820 18 based base VBN 13433 1820 19 upon upon IN 13433 1820 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1820 21 third third JJ 13433 1820 22 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 13433 1820 23 , , , 13433 1820 24 and and CC 13433 1820 25 consequently consequently RB 13433 1820 26 must must MD 13433 1820 27 be be VB 13433 1820 28 accepted accept VBN 13433 1820 29 as as IN 13433 1820 30 evidence evidence NN 13433 1820 31 of of IN 13433 1820 32 the the DT 13433 1820 33 existence existence NN 13433 1820 34 of of IN 13433 1820 35 that that DT 13433 1820 36 work work NN 13433 1820 37 . . . 13433 1821 1 Marcion marcion NN 13433 1821 2 , , , 13433 1821 3 however however RB 13433 1821 4 , , , 13433 1821 5 does do VBZ 13433 1821 6 not not RB 13433 1821 7 give give VB 13433 1821 8 the the DT 13433 1821 9 slightest slight JJS 13433 1821 10 information information NN 13433 1821 11 as as IN 13433 1821 12 to to IN 13433 1821 13 the the DT 13433 1821 14 authorship authorship NN 13433 1821 15 of of IN 13433 1821 16 the the DT 13433 1821 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1821 18 , , , 13433 1821 19 and and CC 13433 1821 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1821 21 charges charge NNS 13433 1821 22 against against IN 13433 1821 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1821 24 of of IN 13433 1821 25 adulteration adulteration NN 13433 1821 26 can can MD 13433 1821 27 not not RB 13433 1821 28 be be VB 13433 1821 29 considered consider VBN 13433 1821 30 very very RB 13433 1821 31 favourable favourable JJ 13433 1821 32 testimony testimony NN 13433 1821 33 as as IN 13433 1821 34 to to IN 13433 1821 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1821 36 infallible infallible JJ 13433 1821 37 character character NN 13433 1821 38 . . . 13433 1822 1 The the DT 13433 1822 2 canonical canonical JJ 13433 1822 3 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1822 4 continue continue VBP 13433 1822 5 to to IN 13433 1822 6 the the DT 13433 1822 7 end end JJ 13433 1822 8 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 1822 9 documents document NNS 13433 1822 10 of of IN 13433 1822 11 no no DT 13433 1822 12 evidential evidential JJ 13433 1822 13 value value NN 13433 1822 14 for for IN 13433 1822 15 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1822 16 . . . 13433 1823 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1823 2 do do VBP 13433 1823 3 not not RB 13433 1823 4 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1823 5 pretend pretend VB 13433 1823 6 to to TO 13433 1823 7 be be VB 13433 1823 8 inspired inspire VBN 13433 1823 9 histories history NNS 13433 1823 10 , , , 13433 1823 11 and and CC 13433 1823 12 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1823 13 can can MD 13433 1823 14 not not RB 13433 1823 15 escape escape VB 13433 1823 16 from from IN 13433 1823 17 the the DT 13433 1823 18 ordinary ordinary JJ 13433 1823 19 rules rule NNS 13433 1823 20 of of IN 13433 1823 21 criticism criticism NN 13433 1823 22 . . . 13433 1824 1 Internal internal JJ 13433 1824 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 1824 3 does do VBZ 13433 1824 4 not not RB 13433 1824 5 modify modify VB 13433 1824 6 the the DT 13433 1824 7 inferences inference NNS 13433 1824 8 from from IN 13433 1824 9 external external JJ 13433 1824 10 testimony testimony NN 13433 1824 11 . . . 13433 1825 1 Apart apart RB 13433 1825 2 from from IN 13433 1825 3 continual continual JJ 13433 1825 4 minor minor JJ 13433 1825 5 contradictions contradiction NNS 13433 1825 6 throughout throughout IN 13433 1825 7 the the DT 13433 1825 8 first first JJ 13433 1825 9 three three CD 13433 1825 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1825 11 , , , 13433 1825 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1825 13 is be VBZ 13433 1825 14 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1825 15 to to TO 13433 1825 16 reconcile reconcile VB 13433 1825 17 the the DT 13433 1825 18 representations representation NNS 13433 1825 19 of of IN 13433 1825 20 the the DT 13433 1825 21 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 1825 22 with with IN 13433 1825 23 those those DT 13433 1825 24 of of IN 13433 1825 25 the the DT 13433 1825 26 fourth fourth JJ 13433 1825 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1825 28 . . . 13433 1826 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1826 2 mutually mutually RB 13433 1826 3 destroy destroy VBP 13433 1826 4 each each DT 13433 1826 5 other other JJ 13433 1826 6 as as IN 13433 1826 7 evidence evidence NN 13433 1826 8 . . . 13433 1827 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1827 2 must must MD 13433 1827 3 be be VB 13433 1827 4 pronounced pronounce VBN 13433 1827 5 mere mere JJ 13433 1827 6 narratives narrative NNS 13433 1827 7 compiled compile VBD 13433 1827 8 long long RB 13433 1827 9 after after IN 13433 1827 10 the the DT 13433 1827 11 events event NNS 13433 1827 12 recorded record VBD 13433 1827 13 , , , 13433 1827 14 by by IN 13433 1827 15 unknown unknown JJ 13433 1827 16 persons person NNS 13433 1827 17 who who WP 13433 1827 18 were be VBD 13433 1827 19 neither neither CC 13433 1827 20 eye eye NN 13433 1827 21 - - HYPH 13433 1827 22 witnesses witness NNS 13433 1827 23 of of IN 13433 1827 24 the the DT 13433 1827 25 alleged allege VBN 13433 1827 26 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1827 27 occurrences occurrence NNS 13433 1827 28 nor nor CC 13433 1827 29 hearers hearer NNS 13433 1827 30 of of IN 13433 1827 31 the the DT 13433 1827 32 statements statement NNS 13433 1827 33 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1827 34 profess profess VBP 13433 1827 35 to to TO 13433 1827 36 report report VB 13433 1827 37 . . . 13433 1828 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1828 2 can can MD 13433 1828 3 not not RB 13433 1828 4 be be VB 13433 1828 5 accepted accept VBN 13433 1828 6 as as IN 13433 1828 7 adequate adequate JJ 13433 1828 8 testimony testimony NN 13433 1828 9 for for IN 13433 1828 10 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1828 11 and and CC 13433 1828 12 the the DT 13433 1828 13 reality reality NN 13433 1828 14 of of IN 13433 1828 15 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1828 16 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1828 17 . . . 13433 1829 1 Applying apply VBG 13433 1829 2 similar similar JJ 13433 1829 3 tests test NNS 13433 1829 4 to to IN 13433 1829 5 the the DT 13433 1829 6 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1829 7 of of IN 13433 1829 8 the the DT 13433 1829 9 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1829 10 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1829 11 arrived arrive VBD 13433 1829 12 at at IN 13433 1829 13 similar similar JJ 13433 1829 14 results result NNS 13433 1829 15 . . . 13433 1830 1 Acknowledged acknowledge VBN 13433 1830 2 to to TO 13433 1830 3 be be VB 13433 1830 4 composed compose VBN 13433 1830 5 by by IN 13433 1830 6 the the DT 13433 1830 7 same same JJ 13433 1830 8 author author NN 13433 1830 9 who who WP 13433 1830 10 produced produce VBD 13433 1830 11 the the DT 13433 1830 12 third third JJ 13433 1830 13 Synoptic Synoptic NNP 13433 1830 14 , , , 13433 1830 15 that that DT 13433 1830 16 author author NN 13433 1830 17 's 's POS 13433 1830 18 identity identity NN 13433 1830 19 is be VBZ 13433 1830 20 not not RB 13433 1830 21 thereby thereby RB 13433 1830 22 made make VBN 13433 1830 23 more more RBR 13433 1830 24 clear clear JJ 13433 1830 25 . . . 13433 1831 1 There there EX 13433 1831 2 is be VBZ 13433 1831 3 no no DT 13433 1831 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 1831 5 of of IN 13433 1831 6 the the DT 13433 1831 7 slightest slight JJS 13433 1831 8 value value NN 13433 1831 9 regarding regard VBG 13433 1831 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1831 11 character character NN 13433 1831 12 , , , 13433 1831 13 but but CC 13433 1831 14 , , , 13433 1831 15 on on IN 13433 1831 16 the the DT 13433 1831 17 other other JJ 13433 1831 18 hand hand NN 13433 1831 19 , , , 13433 1831 20 the the DT 13433 1831 21 work work NN 13433 1831 22 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1831 23 teems teem VBZ 13433 1831 24 to to IN 13433 1831 25 such such PDT 13433 1831 26 an an DT 13433 1831 27 extent extent NN 13433 1831 28 with with IN 13433 1831 29 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1831 30 incidents incident NNS 13433 1831 31 and and CC 13433 1831 32 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1831 33 agency agency NN 13433 1831 34 that that IN 13433 1831 35 the the DT 13433 1831 36 credibility credibility NN 13433 1831 37 of of IN 13433 1831 38 the the DT 13433 1831 39 narrative narrative NN 13433 1831 40 requires require VBZ 13433 1831 41 an an DT 13433 1831 42 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 13433 1831 43 amount amount NN 13433 1831 44 of of IN 13433 1831 45 attestation attestation NN 13433 1831 46 to to TO 13433 1831 47 secure secure VB 13433 1831 48 for for IN 13433 1831 49 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1831 50 any any DT 13433 1831 51 serious serious JJ 13433 1831 52 consideration consideration NN 13433 1831 53 . . . 13433 1832 1 When when WRB 13433 1832 2 the the DT 13433 1832 3 statements statement NNS 13433 1832 4 of of IN 13433 1832 5 the the DT 13433 1832 6 author author NN 13433 1832 7 are be VBP 13433 1832 8 compared compare VBN 13433 1832 9 with with IN 13433 1832 10 the the DT 13433 1832 11 emphatic emphatic JJ 13433 1832 12 declarations declaration NNS 13433 1832 13 of of IN 13433 1832 14 the the DT 13433 1832 15 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 1832 16 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1832 17 and and CC 13433 1832 18 with with IN 13433 1832 19 authentic authentic JJ 13433 1832 20 accounts account NNS 13433 1832 21 of of IN 13433 1832 22 the the DT 13433 1832 23 development development NN 13433 1832 24 of of IN 13433 1832 25 the the DT 13433 1832 26 early early JJ 13433 1832 27 Christian Christian NNP 13433 1832 28 Church Church NNP 13433 1832 29 , , , 13433 1832 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1832 31 becomes become VBZ 13433 1832 32 evident evident JJ 13433 1832 33 that that IN 13433 1832 34 the the DT 13433 1832 35 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 1832 36 of of IN 13433 1832 37 the the DT 13433 1832 38 Apostles Apostles NNPS 13433 1832 39 , , , 13433 1832 40 as as IN 13433 1832 41 might may MD 13433 1832 42 have have VB 13433 1832 43 been be VBN 13433 1832 44 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1832 45 , , , 13433 1832 46 is be VBZ 13433 1832 47 a a DT 13433 1832 48 legendary legendary JJ 13433 1832 49 composition composition NN 13433 1832 50 of of IN 13433 1832 51 a a DT 13433 1832 52 later later JJ 13433 1832 53 day day NN 13433 1832 54 , , , 13433 1832 55 which which WDT 13433 1832 56 can can MD 13433 1832 57 not not RB 13433 1832 58 be be VB 13433 1832 59 regarded regard VBN 13433 1832 60 as as IN 13433 1832 61 sober sober JJ 13433 1832 62 and and CC 13433 1832 63 credible credible JJ 13433 1832 64 history history NN 13433 1832 65 , , , 13433 1832 66 and and CC 13433 1832 67 rather rather RB 13433 1832 68 discredits discredit NNS 13433 1832 69 than than IN 13433 1832 70 tends tend VBZ 13433 1832 71 to to TO 13433 1832 72 establish establish VB 13433 1832 73 the the DT 13433 1832 74 reality reality NN 13433 1832 75 of of IN 13433 1832 76 the the DT 13433 1832 77 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1832 78 with with IN 13433 1832 79 which which WDT 13433 1832 80 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1832 81 pages page NNS 13433 1832 82 so so RB 13433 1832 83 suspiciously suspiciously RB 13433 1832 84 abound abound JJ 13433 1832 85 . . . 13433 1833 1 The the DT 13433 1833 2 remaining remain VBG 13433 1833 3 books book NNS 13433 1833 4 of of IN 13433 1833 5 the the DT 13433 1833 6 New New NNP 13433 1833 7 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1833 8 Canon Canon NNP 13433 1833 9 required require VBD 13433 1833 10 no no DT 13433 1833 11 separate separate JJ 13433 1833 12 examination examination NN 13433 1833 13 , , , 13433 1833 14 because because IN 13433 1833 15 , , , 13433 1833 16 even even RB 13433 1833 17 if if IN 13433 1833 18 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1833 19 , , , 13433 1833 20 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1833 21 contain contain VBP 13433 1833 22 no no DT 13433 1833 23 additional additional JJ 13433 1833 24 testimony testimony NN 13433 1833 25 to to IN 13433 1833 26 the the DT 13433 1833 27 reality reality NN 13433 1833 28 of of IN 13433 1833 29 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1833 30 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1833 31 , , , 13433 1833 32 beyond beyond IN 13433 1833 33 the the DT 13433 1833 34 implied implied JJ 13433 1833 35 belief belief NN 13433 1833 36 in in IN 13433 1833 37 such such JJ 13433 1833 38 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1833 39 as as IN 13433 1833 40 the the DT 13433 1833 41 Incarnation Incarnation NNP 13433 1833 42 and and CC 13433 1833 43 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1833 44 . . . 13433 1834 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1834 2 is be VBZ 13433 1834 3 unquestionable unquestionable JJ 13433 1834 4 , , , 13433 1834 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1834 6 suppose suppose VBP 13433 1834 7 , , , 13433 1834 8 that that IN 13433 1834 9 in in IN 13433 1834 10 some some DT 13433 1834 11 form form NN 13433 1834 12 or or CC 13433 1834 13 other other JJ 13433 1834 14 the the DT 13433 1834 15 Apostles Apostles NNPS 13433 1834 16 believed believe VBD 13433 1834 17 in in IN 13433 1834 18 these these DT 13433 1834 19 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1834 20 , , , 13433 1834 21 and and CC 13433 1834 22 the the DT 13433 1834 23 assumption assumption NN 13433 1834 24 that that IN 13433 1834 25 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1834 26 did do VBD 13433 1834 27 so so RB 13433 1834 28 supersedes supersede NNS 13433 1834 29 the the DT 13433 1834 30 necessity necessity NN 13433 1834 31 for for IN 13433 1834 32 examining examine VBG 13433 1834 33 the the DT 13433 1834 34 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1834 35 of of IN 13433 1834 36 the the DT 13433 1834 37 Catholic Catholic NNP 13433 1834 38 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1834 39 and and CC 13433 1834 40 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 1834 41 . . . 13433 1835 1 In in IN 13433 1835 2 like like JJ 13433 1835 3 manner manner NN 13433 1835 4 , , , 13433 1835 5 the the DT 13433 1835 6 recognition recognition NN 13433 1835 7 as as IN 13433 1835 8 genuine genuine JJ 13433 1835 9 of of IN 13433 1835 10 four four CD 13433 1835 11 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1835 12 of of IN 13433 1835 13 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1835 14 , , , 13433 1835 15 which which WDT 13433 1835 16 contain contain VBP 13433 1835 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1835 18 testimony testimony NN 13433 1835 19 to to IN 13433 1835 20 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1835 21 , , , 13433 1835 22 renders render VBZ 13433 1835 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1835 24 superfluous superfluous JJ 13433 1835 25 to to TO 13433 1835 26 discuss discuss VB 13433 1835 27 the the DT 13433 1835 28 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 1835 29 of of IN 13433 1835 30 the the DT 13433 1835 31 other other JJ 13433 1835 32 letters letter NNS 13433 1835 33 attributed attribute VBN 13433 1835 34 to to IN 13433 1835 35 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1835 36 . . . 13433 1836 1 The the DT 13433 1836 2 general general JJ 13433 1836 3 belief belief NN 13433 1836 4 in in IN 13433 1836 5 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1836 6 power power NN 13433 1836 7 and and CC 13433 1836 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1836 9 possession possession NN 13433 1836 10 by by IN 13433 1836 11 the the DT 13433 1836 12 Church Church NNP 13433 1836 13 is be VBZ 13433 1836 14 brought bring VBN 13433 1836 15 to to IN 13433 1836 16 a a DT 13433 1836 17 practical practical JJ 13433 1836 18 test test NN 13433 1836 19 in in IN 13433 1836 20 the the DT 13433 1836 21 case case NN 13433 1836 22 of of IN 13433 1836 23 the the DT 13433 1836 24 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 1836 25 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1836 26 . . . 13433 1837 1 After after IN 13433 1837 2 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1837 3 consideration consideration NN 13433 1837 4 of of IN 13433 1837 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1837 6 letters letter NNS 13433 1837 7 , , , 13433 1837 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1837 9 came come VBD 13433 1837 10 to to IN 13433 1837 11 the the DT 13433 1837 12 unhesitating unhesitating JJ 13433 1837 13 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1837 14 that that IN 13433 1837 15 , , , 13433 1837 16 instead instead RB 13433 1837 17 of of IN 13433 1837 18 establishing establish VBG 13433 1837 19 the the DT 13433 1837 20 reality reality NN 13433 1837 21 of of IN 13433 1837 22 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1837 23 , , , 13433 1837 24 the the DT 13433 1837 25 unconscious unconscious JJ 13433 1837 26 testimony testimony NN 13433 1837 27 of of IN 13433 1837 28 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1837 29 clearly clearly RB 13433 1837 30 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 13433 1837 31 the the DT 13433 1837 32 facility facility NN 13433 1837 33 with with IN 13433 1837 34 which which WDT 13433 1837 35 erroneous erroneous JJ 13433 1837 36 inferences inference NNS 13433 1837 37 convert convert VBP 13433 1837 38 the the DT 13433 1837 39 most most RBS 13433 1837 40 natural natural JJ 13433 1837 41 phenomena phenomenon NNS 13433 1837 42 into into IN 13433 1837 43 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1837 44 occurrences occurrence NNS 13433 1837 45 . . . 13433 1838 1 As as IN 13433 1838 2 a a DT 13433 1838 3 final final JJ 13433 1838 4 test test NN 13433 1838 5 , , , 13433 1838 6 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1838 7 carefully carefully RB 13433 1838 8 examined examine VBD 13433 1838 9 the the DT 13433 1838 10 whole whole NN 13433 1838 11 of of IN 13433 1838 12 the the DT 13433 1838 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 1838 14 for for IN 13433 1838 15 the the DT 13433 1838 16 cardinal cardinal JJ 13433 1838 17 dogmas dogmas NN 13433 1838 18 of of IN 13433 1838 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1838 20 , , , 13433 1838 21 the the DT 13433 1838 22 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1838 23 and and CC 13433 1838 24 Ascension Ascension NNP 13433 1838 25 of of IN 13433 1838 26 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1838 27 . . . 13433 1839 1 First first RB 13433 1839 2 taking take VBG 13433 1839 3 the the DT 13433 1839 4 four four CD 13433 1839 5 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1839 6 , , , 13433 1839 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1839 8 found find VBD 13433 1839 9 that that IN 13433 1839 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1839 11 accounts account NNS 13433 1839 12 of of IN 13433 1839 13 these these DT 13433 1839 14 events event NNS 13433 1839 15 are be VBP 13433 1839 16 not not RB 13433 1839 17 only only RB 13433 1839 18 full full JJ 13433 1839 19 of of IN 13433 1839 20 legendary legendary JJ 13433 1839 21 matter matter NN 13433 1839 22 , , , 13433 1839 23 but but CC 13433 1839 24 even even RB 13433 1839 25 contradict contradict VB 13433 1839 26 and and CC 13433 1839 27 exclude exclude VB 13433 1839 28 each each DT 13433 1839 29 other other JJ 13433 1839 30 and and CC 13433 1839 31 , , , 13433 1839 32 so so RB 13433 1839 33 far far RB 13433 1839 34 from from IN 13433 1839 35 establishing establish VBG 13433 1839 36 the the DT 13433 1839 37 reality reality NN 13433 1839 38 of of IN 13433 1839 39 such such JJ 13433 1839 40 stupendous stupendous JJ 13433 1839 41 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1839 42 , , , 13433 1839 43 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1839 44 show show VBP 13433 1839 45 that that IN 13433 1839 46 no no DT 13433 1839 47 reliance reliance NN 13433 1839 48 is be VBZ 13433 1839 49 to to TO 13433 1839 50 be be VB 13433 1839 51 placed place VBN 13433 1839 52 on on IN 13433 1839 53 the the DT 13433 1839 54 statements statement NNS 13433 1839 55 of of IN 13433 1839 56 the the DT 13433 1839 57 unknown unknown JJ 13433 1839 58 authors author NNS 13433 1839 59 . . . 13433 1840 1 Taking take VBG 13433 1840 2 next next JJ 13433 1840 3 the the DT 13433 1840 4 testimony testimony NN 13433 1840 5 of of IN 13433 1840 6 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1840 7 , , , 13433 1840 8 which which WDT 13433 1840 9 is be VBZ 13433 1840 10 more more RBR 13433 1840 11 important important JJ 13433 1840 12 as as IN 13433 1840 13 at at IN 13433 1840 14 least least JJS 13433 1840 15 authentic authentic JJ 13433 1840 16 and and CC 13433 1840 17 proceeding proceed VBG 13433 1840 18 from from IN 13433 1840 19 an an DT 13433 1840 20 Apostle apostle NN 13433 1840 21 of of IN 13433 1840 22 whom whom WP 13433 1840 23 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1840 24 know know VBP 13433 1840 25 more more JJR 13433 1840 26 than than IN 13433 1840 27 of of IN 13433 1840 28 any any DT 13433 1840 29 other other JJ 13433 1840 30 of of IN 13433 1840 31 the the DT 13433 1840 32 early early JJ 13433 1840 33 missionaries missionary NNS 13433 1840 34 of of IN 13433 1840 35 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1840 36 , , , 13433 1840 37 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1840 38 saw see VBD 13433 1840 39 that that IN 13433 1840 40 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1840 41 was be VBD 13433 1840 42 indefinite indefinite JJ 13433 1840 43 and and CC 13433 1840 44 utterly utterly RB 13433 1840 45 insufficient insufficient JJ 13433 1840 46 . . . 13433 1841 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1841 2 so so RB 13433 1841 3 - - HYPH 13433 1841 4 called call VBN 13433 1841 5 " " `` 13433 1841 6 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 13433 1841 7 account account NN 13433 1841 8 of of IN 13433 1841 9 the the DT 13433 1841 10 testimony testimony NN 13433 1841 11 upon upon IN 13433 1841 12 which which WDT 13433 1841 13 the the DT 13433 1841 14 belief belief NN 13433 1841 15 in in IN 13433 1841 16 the the DT 13433 1841 17 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1841 18 rested rest VBD 13433 1841 19 " " `` 13433 1841 20 consists consist VBZ 13433 1841 21 merely merely RB 13433 1841 22 of of IN 13433 1841 23 vague vague JJ 13433 1841 24 and and CC 13433 1841 25 undetailed undetailed JJ 13433 1841 26 hearsay hearsay NN 13433 1841 27 , , , 13433 1841 28 differing differ VBG 13433 1841 29 , , , 13433 1841 30 so so RB 13433 1841 31 far far RB 13433 1841 32 as as IN 13433 1841 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 34 can can MD 13433 1841 35 be be VB 13433 1841 36 compared compare VBN 13433 1841 37 , , , 13433 1841 38 from from IN 13433 1841 39 the the DT 13433 1841 40 statements statement NNS 13433 1841 41 in in IN 13433 1841 42 the the DT 13433 1841 43 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1841 44 , , , 13433 1841 45 and and CC 13433 1841 46 without without IN 13433 1841 47 other other JJ 13433 1841 48 attestation attestation NN 13433 1841 49 than than IN 13433 1841 50 the the DT 13433 1841 51 bare bare JJ 13433 1841 52 fact fact NN 13433 1841 53 that that IN 13433 1841 54 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 55 is be VBZ 13433 1841 56 repeated repeat VBN 13433 1841 57 by by IN 13433 1841 58 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1841 59 , , , 13433 1841 60 who who WP 13433 1841 61 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 1841 62 believed believe VBD 13433 1841 63 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 64 , , , 13433 1841 65 although although IN 13433 1841 66 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 67 had have VBD 13433 1841 68 not not RB 13433 1841 69 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 70 been be VBN 13433 1841 71 a a DT 13433 1841 72 witness witness NN 13433 1841 73 of of IN 13433 1841 74 any any DT 13433 1841 75 of of IN 13433 1841 76 the the DT 13433 1841 77 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1841 78 appearances appearance NNS 13433 1841 79 of of IN 13433 1841 80 the the DT 13433 1841 81 risen rise VBN 13433 1841 82 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1841 83 which which WDT 13433 1841 84 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1841 85 so so RB 13433 1841 86 briefly briefly RB 13433 1841 87 catalogues catalogue VBZ 13433 1841 88 . . . 13433 1842 1 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1842 2 's 's POS 13433 1842 3 own own JJ 13433 1842 4 personal personal JJ 13433 1842 5 testimony testimony NN 13433 1842 6 to to IN 13433 1842 7 the the DT 13433 1842 8 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1842 9 is be VBZ 13433 1842 10 limited limit VBN 13433 1842 11 to to IN 13433 1842 12 a a DT 13433 1842 13 vision vision NN 13433 1842 14 of of IN 13433 1842 15 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1842 16 , , , 13433 1842 17 of of IN 13433 1842 18 which which WDT 13433 1842 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1842 20 have have VBP 13433 1842 21 no no DT 13433 1842 22 authentic authentic JJ 13433 1842 23 details detail NNS 13433 1842 24 , , , 13433 1842 25 seen see VBN 13433 1842 26 many many JJ 13433 1842 27 years year NNS 13433 1842 28 after after IN 13433 1842 29 the the DT 13433 1842 30 alleged alleged JJ 13433 1842 31 miracle miracle NN 13433 1842 32 . . . 13433 1843 1 Considering consider VBG 13433 1843 2 the the DT 13433 1843 3 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 1843 4 and and CC 13433 1843 5 highly highly RB 13433 1843 6 nervous nervous JJ 13433 1843 7 temperament temperament NN 13433 1843 8 of of IN 13433 1843 9 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1843 10 , , , 13433 1843 11 of of IN 13433 1843 12 which which WDT 13433 1843 13 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1843 14 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1843 15 supplies supply VBZ 13433 1843 16 abundant abundant JJ 13433 1843 17 evidence evidence NN 13433 1843 18 , , , 13433 1843 19 there there EX 13433 1843 20 can can MD 13433 1843 21 be be VB 13433 1843 22 no no DT 13433 1843 23 hesitation hesitation NN 13433 1843 24 in in IN 13433 1843 25 deciding decide VBG 13433 1843 26 that that IN 13433 1843 27 this this DT 13433 1843 28 vision vision NN 13433 1843 29 was be VBD 13433 1843 30 purely purely RB 13433 1843 31 subjective subjective JJ 13433 1843 32 , , , 13433 1843 33 as as IN 13433 1843 34 were be VBD 13433 1843 35 likewise likewise RB 13433 1843 36 , , , 13433 1843 37 in in IN 13433 1843 38 all all DT 13433 1843 39 probability probability NN 13433 1843 40 , , , 13433 1843 41 the the DT 13433 1843 42 appearances appearance NNS 13433 1843 43 to to IN 13433 1843 44 the the DT 13433 1843 45 excited excited JJ 13433 1843 46 disciples disciple NNS 13433 1843 47 of of IN 13433 1843 48 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1843 49 . . . 13433 1844 1 The the DT 13433 1844 2 testimony testimony NN 13433 1844 3 of of IN 13433 1844 4 Paul Paul NNP 13433 1844 5 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1844 6 , , , 13433 1844 7 before before IN 13433 1844 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1844 9 imagination imagination NN 13433 1844 10 was be VBD 13433 1844 11 stimulated stimulate VBN 13433 1844 12 to to IN 13433 1844 13 ecstatic ecstatic JJ 13433 1844 14 fervour fervour NN 13433 1844 15 by by IN 13433 1844 16 the the DT 13433 1844 17 beauty beauty NN 13433 1844 18 of of IN 13433 1844 19 a a DT 13433 1844 20 spiritualised spiritualise VBN 13433 1844 21 religion religion NN 13433 1844 22 , , , 13433 1844 23 was be VBD 13433 1844 24 an an DT 13433 1844 25 earnest earnest JJ 13433 1844 26 denial denial NN 13433 1844 27 of of IN 13433 1844 28 the the DT 13433 1844 29 great great JJ 13433 1844 30 Christian christian JJ 13433 1844 31 dogma dogma NN 13433 1844 32 , , , 13433 1844 33 emphasised emphasise VBN 13433 1844 34 by by IN 13433 1844 35 the the DT 13433 1844 36 active active JJ 13433 1844 37 persecution persecution NN 13433 1844 38 of of IN 13433 1844 39 those those DT 13433 1844 40 who who WP 13433 1844 41 affirmed affirm VBD 13433 1844 42 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1844 43 ; ; : 13433 1844 44 and and CC 13433 1844 45 a a DT 13433 1844 46 vision vision NN 13433 1844 47 , , , 13433 1844 48 especially especially RB 13433 1844 49 in in IN 13433 1844 50 the the DT 13433 1844 51 case case NN 13433 1844 52 of of IN 13433 1844 53 one one CD 13433 1844 54 so so RB 13433 1844 55 constituted constituted JJ 13433 1844 56 , , , 13433 1844 57 supposed suppose VBN 13433 1844 58 to to TO 13433 1844 59 be be VB 13433 1844 60 seen see VBN 13433 1844 61 many many JJ 13433 1844 62 years year NNS 13433 1844 63 after after IN 13433 1844 64 the the DT 13433 1844 65 fact fact NN 13433 1844 66 of of IN 13433 1844 67 the the DT 13433 1844 68 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1844 69 had have VBD 13433 1844 70 ceased cease VBN 13433 1844 71 to to TO 13433 1844 72 be be VB 13433 1844 73 capable capable JJ 13433 1844 74 of of IN 13433 1844 75 verification verification NN 13433 1844 76 , , , 13433 1844 77 is be VBZ 13433 1844 78 not not RB 13433 1844 79 an an DT 13433 1844 80 argument argument NN 13433 1844 81 of of IN 13433 1844 82 convincing convince VBG 13433 1844 83 force force NN 13433 1844 84 . . . 13433 1845 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1845 2 were be VBD 13433 1845 3 compelled compel VBN 13433 1845 4 to to TO 13433 1845 5 pronounce pronounce VB 13433 1845 6 the the DT 13433 1845 7 evidence evidence NN 13433 1845 8 for for IN 13433 1845 9 the the DT 13433 1845 10 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 1845 11 and and CC 13433 1845 12 Ascension Ascension NNP 13433 1845 13 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1845 14 and and CC 13433 1845 15 hopelessly hopelessly RB 13433 1845 16 inadequate inadequate JJ 13433 1845 17 to to TO 13433 1845 18 prove prove VB 13433 1845 19 the the DT 13433 1845 20 reality reality NN 13433 1845 21 of of IN 13433 1845 22 such such JJ 13433 1845 23 stupendous stupendous JJ 13433 1845 24 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1845 25 , , , 13433 1845 26 which which WDT 13433 1845 27 must must MD 13433 1845 28 consequently consequently RB 13433 1845 29 be be VB 13433 1845 30 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 13433 1845 31 rejected reject VBN 13433 1845 32 . . . 13433 1846 1 There there EX 13433 1846 2 is be VBZ 13433 1846 3 no no DT 13433 1846 4 reason reason NN 13433 1846 5 given give VBN 13433 1846 6 , , , 13433 1846 7 or or CC 13433 1846 8 even even RB 13433 1846 9 conceivable conceivable JJ 13433 1846 10 , , , 13433 1846 11 why why WRB 13433 1846 12 allegations allegation NNS 13433 1846 13 such such JJ 13433 1846 14 as as IN 13433 1846 15 these these DT 13433 1846 16 , , , 13433 1846 17 and and CC 13433 1846 18 dogmas dogma VBZ 13433 1846 19 affecting affect VBG 13433 1846 20 the the DT 13433 1846 21 religion religion NN 13433 1846 22 and and CC 13433 1846 23 even even RB 13433 1846 24 the the DT 13433 1846 25 salvation salvation NN 13433 1846 26 of of IN 13433 1846 27 the the DT 13433 1846 28 human human JJ 13433 1846 29 race race NN 13433 1846 30 , , , 13433 1846 31 should should MD 13433 1846 32 be be VB 13433 1846 33 accepted accept VBN 13433 1846 34 upon upon IN 13433 1846 35 evidence evidence NN 13433 1846 36 which which WDT 13433 1846 37 would would MD 13433 1846 38 be be VB 13433 1846 39 declared declare VBN 13433 1846 40 totally totally RB 13433 1846 41 insufficient insufficient JJ 13433 1846 42 in in IN 13433 1846 43 the the DT 13433 1846 44 case case NN 13433 1846 45 of of IN 13433 1846 46 any any DT 13433 1846 47 common common JJ 13433 1846 48 question question NN 13433 1846 49 of of IN 13433 1846 50 property property NN 13433 1846 51 or or CC 13433 1846 52 title title NN 13433 1846 53 before before IN 13433 1846 54 a a DT 13433 1846 55 legal legal JJ 13433 1846 56 tribunal tribunal NN 13433 1846 57 . . . 13433 1847 1 On on IN 13433 1847 2 the the DT 13433 1847 3 contrary contrary NN 13433 1847 4 , , , 13433 1847 5 the the DT 13433 1847 6 more more RBR 13433 1847 7 momentous momentous JJ 13433 1847 8 the the DT 13433 1847 9 point point NN 13433 1847 10 to to TO 13433 1847 11 be be VB 13433 1847 12 established establish VBN 13433 1847 13 , , , 13433 1847 14 the the DT 13433 1847 15 more more RBR 13433 1847 16 complete complete JJ 13433 1847 17 must must MD 13433 1847 18 be be VB 13433 1847 19 the the DT 13433 1847 20 proof proof NN 13433 1847 21 required require VBN 13433 1847 22 . . . 13433 1848 1 If if IN 13433 1848 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1848 3 test test VBP 13433 1848 4 the the DT 13433 1848 5 results result NNS 13433 1848 6 at at IN 13433 1848 7 which which WDT 13433 1848 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1848 9 have have VBP 13433 1848 10 arrived arrive VBN 13433 1848 11 by by IN 13433 1848 12 general general JJ 13433 1848 13 considerations consideration NNS 13433 1848 14 , , , 13433 1848 15 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1848 16 find find VBP 13433 1848 17 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1848 18 everywhere everywhere RB 13433 1848 19 confirmed confirm VBN 13433 1848 20 and and CC 13433 1848 21 established establish VBN 13433 1848 22 . . . 13433 1849 1 There there EX 13433 1849 2 is be VBZ 13433 1849 3 nothing nothing NN 13433 1849 4 original original JJ 13433 1849 5 in in IN 13433 1849 6 the the DT 13433 1849 7 claim claim NN 13433 1849 8 of of IN 13433 1849 9 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1849 10 to to TO 13433 1849 11 be be VB 13433 1849 12 regarded regard VBN 13433 1849 13 as as IN 13433 1849 14 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1849 15 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1849 16 , , , 13433 1849 17 and and CC 13433 1849 18 nothing nothing NN 13433 1849 19 new new JJ 13433 1849 20 either either CC 13433 1849 21 in in IN 13433 1849 22 the the DT 13433 1849 23 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1849 24 said say VBD 13433 1849 25 to to TO 13433 1849 26 have have VB 13433 1849 27 been be VBN 13433 1849 28 revealed reveal VBN 13433 1849 29 , , , 13433 1849 30 or or CC 13433 1849 31 in in IN 13433 1849 32 the the DT 13433 1849 33 miracles miracle NNS 13433 1849 34 by by IN 13433 1849 35 which which WDT 13433 1849 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1849 37 is be VBZ 13433 1849 38 alleged allege VBN 13433 1849 39 to to TO 13433 1849 40 have have VB 13433 1849 41 been be VBN 13433 1849 42 distinguished distinguish VBN 13433 1849 43 . . . 13433 1850 1 There there EX 13433 1850 2 has have VBZ 13433 1850 3 not not RB 13433 1850 4 been be VBN 13433 1850 5 a a DT 13433 1850 6 single single JJ 13433 1850 7 historical historical JJ 13433 1850 8 religion religion NN 13433 1850 9 largely largely RB 13433 1850 10 held hold VBN 13433 1850 11 amongst amongst IN 13433 1850 12 men man NNS 13433 1850 13 which which WDT 13433 1850 14 has have VBZ 13433 1850 15 not not RB 13433 1850 16 pretended pretend VBN 13433 1850 17 to to TO 13433 1850 18 be be VB 13433 1850 19 divinely divinely RB 13433 1850 20 revealed reveal VBN 13433 1850 21 , , , 13433 1850 22 and and CC 13433 1850 23 the the DT 13433 1850 24 written write VBN 13433 1850 25 books book NNS 13433 1850 26 of of IN 13433 1850 27 which which WDT 13433 1850 28 have have VBP 13433 1850 29 not not RB 13433 1850 30 been be VBN 13433 1850 31 represented represent VBN 13433 1850 32 as as IN 13433 1850 33 directly directly RB 13433 1850 34 inspired inspire VBN 13433 1850 35 . . . 13433 1851 1 There there EX 13433 1851 2 is be VBZ 13433 1851 3 not not RB 13433 1851 4 a a DT 13433 1851 5 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 1851 6 , , , 13433 1851 7 sacrament sacrament NN 13433 1851 8 , , , 13433 1851 9 or or CC 13433 1851 10 rite rite NN 13433 1851 11 of of IN 13433 1851 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1851 13 which which WDT 13433 1851 14 has have VBZ 13433 1851 15 not not RB 13433 1851 16 substantially substantially RB 13433 1851 17 formed form VBN 13433 1851 18 part part NN 13433 1851 19 of of IN 13433 1851 20 earlier early JJR 13433 1851 21 religions religion NNS 13433 1851 22 ; ; : 13433 1851 23 and and CC 13433 1851 24 not not RB 13433 1851 25 a a DT 13433 1851 26 single single JJ 13433 1851 27 phase phase NN 13433 1851 28 of of IN 13433 1851 29 the the DT 13433 1851 30 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1851 31 history history NN 13433 1851 32 of of IN 13433 1851 33 the the DT 13433 1851 34 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1851 35 , , , 13433 1851 36 from from IN 13433 1851 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1851 38 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 1851 39 conception conception NN 13433 1851 40 , , , 13433 1851 41 birth birth NN 13433 1851 42 and and CC 13433 1851 43 incarnation incarnation NN 13433 1851 44 to to IN 13433 1851 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1851 46 death death NN 13433 1851 47 , , , 13433 1851 48 resurrection resurrection NN 13433 1851 49 , , , 13433 1851 50 and and CC 13433 1851 51 ascension ascension NN 13433 1851 52 , , , 13433 1851 53 which which WDT 13433 1851 54 has have VBZ 13433 1851 55 not not RB 13433 1851 56 had have VBN 13433 1851 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1851 58 counterpart counterpart NN 13433 1851 59 in in IN 13433 1851 60 earlier early JJR 13433 1851 61 mythologies mythology NNS 13433 1851 62 . . . 13433 1852 1 Heaven Heaven NNP 13433 1852 2 and and CC 13433 1852 3 hell hell NNP 13433 1852 4 , , , 13433 1852 5 with with IN 13433 1852 6 characteristic characteristic JJ 13433 1852 7 variation variation NN 13433 1852 8 of of IN 13433 1852 9 details detail NNS 13433 1852 10 , , , 13433 1852 11 have have VBP 13433 1852 12 held hold VBN 13433 1852 13 an an DT 13433 1852 14 important important JJ 13433 1852 15 place place NN 13433 1852 16 in in IN 13433 1852 17 the the DT 13433 1852 18 eschatology eschatology NN 13433 1852 19 of of IN 13433 1852 20 many many JJ 13433 1852 21 creeds creed NNS 13433 1852 22 and and CC 13433 1852 23 races race NNS 13433 1852 24 . . . 13433 1853 1 The the DT 13433 1853 2 same same JJ 13433 1853 3 may may MD 13433 1853 4 be be VB 13433 1853 5 said say VBN 13433 1853 6 even even RB 13433 1853 7 of of IN 13433 1853 8 the the DT 13433 1853 9 moral moral JJ 13433 1853 10 teaching teaching NN 13433 1853 11 of of IN 13433 1853 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1853 13 , , , 13433 1853 14 the the DT 13433 1853 15 elevated elevated JJ 13433 1853 16 precepts precept NNS 13433 1853 17 of of IN 13433 1853 18 which which WDT 13433 1853 19 , , , 13433 1853 20 although although IN 13433 1853 21 in in IN 13433 1853 22 a a DT 13433 1853 23 less less RBR 13433 1853 24 perfect perfect JJ 13433 1853 25 and and CC 13433 1853 26 connected connected JJ 13433 1853 27 form form NN 13433 1853 28 , , , 13433 1853 29 had have VBD 13433 1853 30 already already RB 13433 1853 31 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1853 32 themselves -PRON- PRP 13433 1853 33 to to IN 13433 1853 34 many many JJ 13433 1853 35 noble noble JJ 13433 1853 36 minds mind NNS 13433 1853 37 and and CC 13433 1853 38 been be VBN 13433 1853 39 promulgated promulgate VBN 13433 1853 40 by by IN 13433 1853 41 ancient ancient JJ 13433 1853 42 sages sage NNS 13433 1853 43 and and CC 13433 1853 44 philosophers philosopher NNS 13433 1853 45 . . . 13433 1854 1 That that IN 13433 1854 2 this this DT 13433 1854 3 Enquiry enquiry NN 13433 1854 4 into into IN 13433 1854 5 the the DT 13433 1854 6 reality reality NN 13433 1854 7 of of IN 13433 1854 8 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1854 9 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1854 10 has have VBZ 13433 1854 11 been be VBN 13433 1854 12 limited limit VBN 13433 1854 13 to to IN 13433 1854 14 the the DT 13433 1854 15 claim claim NN 13433 1854 16 of of IN 13433 1854 17 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1854 18 has have VBZ 13433 1854 19 arisen arise VBN 13433 1854 20 solely solely RB 13433 1854 21 from from IN 13433 1854 22 a a DT 13433 1854 23 desire desire NN 13433 1854 24 to to TO 13433 1854 25 condense condense VB 13433 1854 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1854 27 within within IN 13433 1854 28 reasonable reasonable JJ 13433 1854 29 bounds bound NNS 13433 1854 30 , , , 13433 1854 31 and and CC 13433 1854 32 confine confine VB 13433 1854 33 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1854 34 to to IN 13433 1854 35 the the DT 13433 1854 36 only only JJ 13433 1854 37 Religion religion NN 13433 1854 38 in in IN 13433 1854 39 connection connection NN 13433 1854 40 with with IN 13433 1854 41 which which WDT 13433 1854 42 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1854 43 could could MD 13433 1854 44 practically practically RB 13433 1854 45 interest interest VB 13433 1854 46 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1854 47 now now RB 13433 1854 48 . . . 13433 1855 1 There there EX 13433 1855 2 is be VBZ 13433 1855 3 nothing nothing NN 13433 1855 4 in in IN 13433 1855 5 the the DT 13433 1855 6 history history NN 13433 1855 7 and and CC 13433 1855 8 achievements achievement NNS 13433 1855 9 of of IN 13433 1855 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1855 11 which which WDT 13433 1855 12 can can MD 13433 1855 13 be be VB 13433 1855 14 considered consider VBN 13433 1855 15 characteristic characteristic JJ 13433 1855 16 of of IN 13433 1855 17 a a DT 13433 1855 18 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1855 19 Divinely divinely RB 13433 1855 20 revealed reveal VBD 13433 1855 21 for for IN 13433 1855 22 the the DT 13433 1855 23 salvation salvation NN 13433 1855 24 of of IN 13433 1855 25 mankind mankind NN 13433 1855 26 . . . 13433 1856 1 Originally originally RB 13433 1856 2 said say VBD 13433 1856 3 to to TO 13433 1856 4 have have VB 13433 1856 5 been be VBN 13433 1856 6 communicated communicate VBN 13433 1856 7 to to IN 13433 1856 8 a a DT 13433 1856 9 single single JJ 13433 1856 10 nation nation NN 13433 1856 11 , , , 13433 1856 12 specially specially RB 13433 1856 13 selected select VBN 13433 1856 14 as as IN 13433 1856 15 the the DT 13433 1856 16 peculiar peculiar JJ 13433 1856 17 people people NNS 13433 1856 18 of of IN 13433 1856 19 God God NNP 13433 1856 20 , , , 13433 1856 21 for for IN 13433 1856 22 whom whom WP 13433 1856 23 distinguished distinguished JJ 13433 1856 24 privileges privilege NNS 13433 1856 25 were be VBD 13433 1856 26 said say VBN 13433 1856 27 to to TO 13433 1856 28 be be VB 13433 1856 29 reserved reserve VBN 13433 1856 30 , , , 13433 1856 31 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1856 32 was be VBD 13433 1856 33 almost almost RB 13433 1856 34 unanimously unanimously RB 13433 1856 35 rejected reject VBN 13433 1856 36 by by IN 13433 1856 37 that that DT 13433 1856 38 nation nation NN 13433 1856 39 at at IN 13433 1856 40 the the DT 13433 1856 41 time time NN 13433 1856 42 and and CC 13433 1856 43 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1856 44 has have VBZ 13433 1856 45 continued continue VBN 13433 1856 46 to to TO 13433 1856 47 be be VB 13433 1856 48 repudiated repudiate VBN 13433 1856 49 by by IN 13433 1856 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1856 51 descendants descendant NNS 13433 1856 52 , , , 13433 1856 53 with with IN 13433 1856 54 singular singular JJ 13433 1856 55 unanimity unanimity NN 13433 1856 56 , , , 13433 1856 57 to to IN 13433 1856 58 the the DT 13433 1856 59 present present JJ 13433 1856 60 day day NN 13433 1856 61 . . . 13433 1857 1 After after IN 13433 1857 2 more more JJR 13433 1857 3 than than IN 13433 1857 4 eighteen eighteen CD 13433 1857 5 centuries century NNS 13433 1857 6 , , , 13433 1857 7 this this DT 13433 1857 8 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1857 9 scheme scheme NN 13433 1857 10 of of IN 13433 1857 11 salvation salvation NN 13433 1857 12 has have VBZ 13433 1857 13 not not RB 13433 1857 14 obtained obtain VBN 13433 1857 15 even even RB 13433 1857 16 the the DT 13433 1857 17 nominal nominal JJ 13433 1857 18 adhesion adhesion NN 13433 1857 19 of of IN 13433 1857 20 more more JJR 13433 1857 21 than than IN 13433 1857 22 a a DT 13433 1857 23 third third NN 13433 1857 24 of of IN 13433 1857 25 the the DT 13433 1857 26 human human JJ 13433 1857 27 race race NN 13433 1857 28 , , , 13433 1857 29 and and CC 13433 1857 30 if if IN 13433 1857 31 , , , 13433 1857 32 in in IN 13433 1857 33 a a DT 13433 1857 34 census census NN 13433 1857 35 of of IN 13433 1857 36 Christendom Christendom NNP 13433 1857 37 , , , 13433 1857 38 distinction distinction NN 13433 1857 39 could could MD 13433 1857 40 now now RB 13433 1857 41 be be VB 13433 1857 42 made make VBN 13433 1857 43 of of IN 13433 1857 44 those those DT 13433 1857 45 who who WP 13433 1857 46 no no RB 13433 1857 47 longer long RBR 13433 1857 48 seriously seriously RB 13433 1857 49 believe believe VBP 13433 1857 50 in in IN 13433 1857 51 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1857 52 as as IN 13433 1857 53 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 1857 54 Religion Religion NNP 13433 1857 55 , , , 13433 1857 56 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1857 57 would would MD 13433 1857 58 take take VB 13433 1857 59 a a DT 13433 1857 60 much much RB 13433 1857 61 lower low JJR 13433 1857 62 numerical numerical JJ 13433 1857 63 position position NN 13433 1857 64 . . . 13433 1858 1 Sâkya Sâkya NNP 13433 1858 2 Muni Muni NNP 13433 1858 3 , , , 13433 1858 4 a a DT 13433 1858 5 teacher teacher NN 13433 1858 6 only only RB 13433 1858 7 second second JJ 13433 1858 8 in in IN 13433 1858 9 nobility nobility NN 13433 1858 10 of of IN 13433 1858 11 character character NN 13433 1858 12 to to IN 13433 1858 13 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1858 14 , , , 13433 1858 15 who who WP 13433 1858 16 , , , 13433 1858 17 like like IN 13433 1858 18 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1858 19 , , , 13433 1858 20 proclaimed proclaim VBD 13433 1858 21 a a DT 13433 1858 22 system system NN 13433 1858 23 of of IN 13433 1858 24 elevated elevated JJ 13433 1858 25 morality morality NN 13433 1858 26 , , , 13433 1858 27 has have VBZ 13433 1858 28 even even RB 13433 1858 29 now now RB 13433 1858 30 almost almost RB 13433 1858 31 twice twice PDT 13433 1858 32 the the DT 13433 1858 33 number number NN 13433 1858 34 of of IN 13433 1858 35 followers follower NNS 13433 1858 36 , , , 13433 1858 37 although although IN 13433 1858 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1858 39 missionaries missionary NNS 13433 1858 40 never never RB 13433 1858 41 sought seek VBD 13433 1858 42 converts convert NNS 13433 1858 43 in in IN 13433 1858 44 the the DT 13433 1858 45 West West NNP 13433 1858 46 . . . 13433 1859 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1859 2 168:1 168:1 CD 13433 1859 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1859 4 Considered consider VBN 13433 1859 5 as as IN 13433 1859 6 a a DT 13433 1859 7 scheme scheme NN 13433 1859 8 Divinely divinely RB 13433 1859 9 devised devise VBD 13433 1859 10 as as IN 13433 1859 11 the the DT 13433 1859 12 best good JJS 13433 1859 13 , , , 13433 1859 14 if if IN 13433 1859 15 not not RB 13433 1859 16 only only RB 13433 1859 17 , , , 13433 1859 18 mode mode NN 13433 1859 19 of of IN 13433 1859 20 redeeming redeem VBG 13433 1859 21 the the DT 13433 1859 22 human human JJ 13433 1859 23 race race NN 13433 1859 24 and and CC 13433 1859 25 saving save VBG 13433 1859 26 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1859 27 from from IN 13433 1859 28 eternal eternal JJ 13433 1859 29 damnation damnation NN 13433 1859 30 , , , 13433 1859 31 promulgated promulgate VBN 13433 1859 32 by by IN 13433 1859 33 God God NNP 13433 1859 34 himself -PRON- PRP 13433 1859 35 incarnate incarnate JJ 13433 1859 36 in in IN 13433 1859 37 human human JJ 13433 1859 38 form form NN 13433 1859 39 , , , 13433 1859 40 and and CC 13433 1859 41 completed complete VBN 13433 1859 42 by by IN 13433 1859 43 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1859 44 own own JJ 13433 1859 45 actual actual JJ 13433 1859 46 death death NN 13433 1859 47 upon upon IN 13433 1859 48 the the DT 13433 1859 49 cross cross NN 13433 1859 50 for for IN 13433 1859 51 the the DT 13433 1859 52 sins sin NNS 13433 1859 53 of of IN 13433 1859 54 the the DT 13433 1859 55 world world NN 13433 1859 56 , , , 13433 1859 57 such such JJ 13433 1859 58 results result NNS 13433 1859 59 as as IN 13433 1859 60 these these DT 13433 1859 61 can can MD 13433 1859 62 only only RB 13433 1859 63 be be VB 13433 1859 64 regarded regard VBN 13433 1859 65 as as IN 13433 1859 66 practical practical JJ 13433 1859 67 failure failure NN 13433 1859 68 , , , 13433 1859 69 although although IN 13433 1859 70 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1859 71 may may MD 13433 1859 72 not not RB 13433 1859 73 be be VB 13433 1859 74 disproportionate disproportionate JJ 13433 1859 75 for for IN 13433 1859 76 a a DT 13433 1859 77 system system NN 13433 1859 78 of of IN 13433 1859 79 elevated elevated JJ 13433 1859 80 morality morality NN 13433 1859 81 . . . 13433 1860 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1860 2 shall shall MD 13433 1860 3 probably probably RB 13433 1860 4 never never RB 13433 1860 5 be be VB 13433 1860 6 able able JJ 13433 1860 7 to to TO 13433 1860 8 determine determine VB 13433 1860 9 how how WRB 13433 1860 10 far far RB 13433 1860 11 the the DT 13433 1860 12 great great JJ 13433 1860 13 Teacher teacher NN 13433 1860 14 may may MD 13433 1860 15 through through IN 13433 1860 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1860 17 own own JJ 13433 1860 18 speculations speculation NNS 13433 1860 19 or or CC 13433 1860 20 misunderstood misunderstood NN 13433 1860 21 spiritual spiritual JJ 13433 1860 22 utterances utterance NNS 13433 1860 23 have have VBP 13433 1860 24 suggested suggest VBN 13433 1860 25 the the DT 13433 1860 26 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1860 27 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1860 28 subsequently subsequently RB 13433 1860 29 attributed attribute VBN 13433 1860 30 to to IN 13433 1860 31 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1860 32 , , , 13433 1860 33 and and CC 13433 1860 34 by by IN 13433 1860 35 which which WDT 13433 1860 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1860 37 whole whole JJ 13433 1860 38 history history NN 13433 1860 39 and and CC 13433 1860 40 system system NN 13433 1860 41 soon soon RB 13433 1860 42 became become VBD 13433 1860 43 transformed transformed JJ 13433 1860 44 ; ; : 13433 1860 45 but but CC 13433 1860 46 no no DT 13433 1860 47 one one NN 13433 1860 48 who who WP 13433 1860 49 attentively attentively RB 13433 1860 50 studies study VBZ 13433 1860 51 the the DT 13433 1860 52 subject subject NN 13433 1860 53 can can MD 13433 1860 54 fail fail VB 13433 1860 55 to to TO 13433 1860 56 be be VB 13433 1860 57 struck strike VBN 13433 1860 58 by by IN 13433 1860 59 the the DT 13433 1860 60 absence absence NN 13433 1860 61 of of IN 13433 1860 62 such such JJ 13433 1860 63 dogmas dogma NNS 13433 1860 64 from from IN 13433 1860 65 the the DT 13433 1860 66 earlier early JJR 13433 1860 67 records record NNS 13433 1860 68 of of IN 13433 1860 69 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1860 70 teaching teaching NN 13433 1860 71 . . . 13433 1861 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1861 2 is be VBZ 13433 1861 3 to to IN 13433 1861 4 the the DT 13433 1861 5 excited excited JJ 13433 1861 6 veneration veneration NN 13433 1861 7 of of IN 13433 1861 8 the the DT 13433 1861 9 followers follower NNS 13433 1861 10 of of IN 13433 1861 11 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1861 12 , , , 13433 1861 13 however however RB 13433 1861 14 , , , 13433 1861 15 that that IN 13433 1861 16 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1861 17 owe owe VBP 13433 1861 18 most most JJS 13433 1861 19 of of IN 13433 1861 20 the the DT 13433 1861 21 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1861 22 elements element NNS 13433 1861 23 so so RB 13433 1861 24 characteristic characteristic JJ 13433 1861 25 of of IN 13433 1861 26 the the DT 13433 1861 27 age age NN 13433 1861 28 and and CC 13433 1861 29 people people NNS 13433 1861 30 . . . 13433 1862 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1862 2 may may MD 13433 1862 3 look look VB 13433 1862 4 in in IN 13433 1862 5 vain vain NN 13433 1862 6 even even RB 13433 1862 7 in in IN 13433 1862 8 the the DT 13433 1862 9 synoptic synoptic JJ 13433 1862 10 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 1862 11 for for IN 13433 1862 12 the the DT 13433 1862 13 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1862 14 elaborated elaborate VBN 13433 1862 15 in in IN 13433 1862 16 the the DT 13433 1862 17 Pauline Pauline NNP 13433 1862 18 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 1862 19 and and CC 13433 1862 20 the the DT 13433 1862 21 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1862 22 of of IN 13433 1862 23 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 1862 24 . . . 13433 1863 1 The the DT 13433 1863 2 great great JJ 13433 1863 3 transformation transformation NN 13433 1863 4 of of IN 13433 1863 5 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1863 6 was be VBD 13433 1863 7 effected effect VBN 13433 1863 8 by by IN 13433 1863 9 men man NNS 13433 1863 10 who who WP 13433 1863 11 had have VBD 13433 1863 12 never never RB 13433 1863 13 seen see VBN 13433 1863 14 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1863 15 , , , 13433 1863 16 and and CC 13433 1863 17 who who WP 13433 1863 18 were be VBD 13433 1863 19 only only RB 13433 1863 20 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 1863 21 with with IN 13433 1863 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1863 23 teaching teaching NN 13433 1863 24 after after IN 13433 1863 25 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1863 26 had have VBD 13433 1863 27 become become VBN 13433 1863 28 transmuted transmute VBN 13433 1863 29 by by IN 13433 1863 30 tradition tradition NN 13433 1863 31 . . . 13433 1864 1 The the DT 13433 1864 2 fervid fervid JJ 13433 1864 3 imagination imagination NN 13433 1864 4 of of IN 13433 1864 5 the the DT 13433 1864 6 East East NNP 13433 1864 7 constructed construct VBN 13433 1864 8 Christian christian JJ 13433 1864 9 theology theology NN 13433 1864 10 . . . 13433 1865 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1865 2 is be VBZ 13433 1865 3 not not RB 13433 1865 4 difficult difficult JJ 13433 1865 5 to to TO 13433 1865 6 follow follow VB 13433 1865 7 the the DT 13433 1865 8 development development NN 13433 1865 9 of of IN 13433 1865 10 the the DT 13433 1865 11 creeds creed NNS 13433 1865 12 of of IN 13433 1865 13 the the DT 13433 1865 14 Church Church NNP 13433 1865 15 , , , 13433 1865 16 and and CC 13433 1865 17 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1865 18 is be VBZ 13433 1865 19 certainly certainly RB 13433 1865 20 most most RBS 13433 1865 21 instructive instructive JJ 13433 1865 22 to to TO 13433 1865 23 observe observe VB 13433 1865 24 the the DT 13433 1865 25 progressive progressive JJ 13433 1865 26 boldness boldness NN 13433 1865 27 with with IN 13433 1865 28 which which WDT 13433 1865 29 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1865 30 dogmas dogma NNS 13433 1865 31 were be VBD 13433 1865 32 expanded expand VBN 13433 1865 33 by by IN 13433 1865 34 pious pious JJ 13433 1865 35 enthusiasm enthusiasm NN 13433 1865 36 . . . 13433 1866 1 The the DT 13433 1866 2 New New NNP 13433 1866 3 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1866 4 alone alone RB 13433 1866 5 represents represent VBZ 13433 1866 6 several several JJ 13433 1866 7 stages stage NNS 13433 1866 8 of of IN 13433 1866 9 dogmatic dogmatic JJ 13433 1866 10 evolution evolution NN 13433 1866 11 . . . 13433 1867 1 Before before IN 13433 1867 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1867 3 first first JJ 13433 1867 4 followers follower NNS 13433 1867 5 had have VBD 13433 1867 6 passed pass VBN 13433 1867 7 away away RP 13433 1867 8 the the DT 13433 1867 9 process process NN 13433 1867 10 of of IN 13433 1867 11 transformation transformation NN 13433 1867 12 had have VBD 13433 1867 13 commenced commence VBN 13433 1867 14 . . . 13433 1868 1 The the DT 13433 1868 2 disciples disciple NNS 13433 1868 3 , , , 13433 1868 4 who who WP 13433 1868 5 had have VBD 13433 1868 6 so so RB 13433 1868 7 often often RB 13433 1868 8 misunderstood misunderstand VBN 13433 1868 9 the the DT 13433 1868 10 teaching teaching NN 13433 1868 11 of of IN 13433 1868 12 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1868 13 during during IN 13433 1868 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1868 15 life life NN 13433 1868 16 , , , 13433 1868 17 piously piously RB 13433 1868 18 distorted distort VBD 13433 1868 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1868 20 after after IN 13433 1868 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1868 22 death death NN 13433 1868 23 . . . 13433 1869 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1869 2 simple simple JJ 13433 1869 3 lessons lesson NNS 13433 1869 4 of of IN 13433 1869 5 meekness meekness NN 13433 1869 6 and and CC 13433 1869 7 humility humility NN 13433 1869 8 were be VBD 13433 1869 9 soon soon RB 13433 1869 10 forgotten forget VBN 13433 1869 11 . . . 13433 1870 1 With with IN 13433 1870 2 lamentable lamentable JJ 13433 1870 3 rapidity rapidity NN 13433 1870 4 , , , 13433 1870 5 the the DT 13433 1870 6 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 1870 7 structure structure NN 13433 1870 8 of of IN 13433 1870 9 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 1870 10 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1870 11 , , , 13433 1870 12 following follow VBG 13433 1870 13 stereotyped stereotyped JJ 13433 1870 14 lines line NNS 13433 1870 15 of of IN 13433 1870 16 human human JJ 13433 1870 17 superstition superstition NN 13433 1870 18 and and CC 13433 1870 19 deeply deeply RB 13433 1870 20 coloured colour VBN 13433 1870 21 by by IN 13433 1870 22 Alexandrian alexandrian JJ 13433 1870 23 philosophy philosophy NN 13433 1870 24 , , , 13433 1870 25 displaced displace VBD 13433 1870 26 the the DT 13433 1870 27 sublime sublime JJ 13433 1870 28 morality morality NN 13433 1870 29 of of IN 13433 1870 30 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 1870 31 . . . 13433 1871 1 Doctrinal doctrinal JJ 13433 1871 2 controversy controversy NN 13433 1871 3 , , , 13433 1871 4 which which WDT 13433 1871 5 commenced commence VBD 13433 1871 6 amongst amongst IN 13433 1871 7 the the DT 13433 1871 8 very very JJ 13433 1871 9 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 1871 10 , , , 13433 1871 11 has have VBZ 13433 1871 12 ever ever RB 13433 1871 13 since since IN 13433 1871 14 divided divide VBN 13433 1871 15 the the DT 13433 1871 16 unity unity NN 13433 1871 17 of of IN 13433 1871 18 the the DT 13433 1871 19 Christian christian JJ 13433 1871 20 body body NN 13433 1871 21 . . . 13433 1872 1 The the DT 13433 1872 2 perverted perverted JJ 13433 1872 3 ingenuity ingenuity NN 13433 1872 4 of of IN 13433 1872 5 successive successive JJ 13433 1872 6 generations generation NNS 13433 1872 7 of of IN 13433 1872 8 churchmen churchman NNS 13433 1872 9 has have VBZ 13433 1872 10 filled fill VBN 13433 1872 11 the the DT 13433 1872 12 world world NN 13433 1872 13 with with IN 13433 1872 14 theological theological JJ 13433 1872 15 quibbles quibble NNS 13433 1872 16 , , , 13433 1872 17 which which WDT 13433 1872 18 have have VBP 13433 1872 19 naturally naturally RB 13433 1872 20 enough enough RB 13433 1872 21 culminated culminate VBN 13433 1872 22 of of IN 13433 1872 23 late late JJ 13433 1872 24 in in IN 13433 1872 25 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1872 26 of of IN 13433 1872 27 Immaculate Immaculate NNP 13433 1872 28 Conception Conception NNP 13433 1872 29 and and CC 13433 1872 30 Papal Papal NNP 13433 1872 31 Infallibility Infallibility NNP 13433 1872 32 . . . 13433 1873 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1873 2 is be VBZ 13433 1873 3 sometimes sometimes RB 13433 1873 4 affirmed affirm VBN 13433 1873 5 , , , 13433 1873 6 however however RB 13433 1873 7 , , , 13433 1873 8 that that IN 13433 1873 9 those those DT 13433 1873 10 who who WP 13433 1873 11 proclaim proclaim VBP 13433 1873 12 such such JJ 13433 1873 13 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 1873 14 not not RB 13433 1873 15 only only RB 13433 1873 16 wantonly wantonly RB 13433 1873 17 destroy destroy VB 13433 1873 18 the the DT 13433 1873 19 dearest dear JJS 13433 1873 20 hopes hope NNS 13433 1873 21 of of IN 13433 1873 22 humanity humanity NN 13433 1873 23 , , , 13433 1873 24 but but CC 13433 1873 25 remove remove VB 13433 1873 26 the the DT 13433 1873 27 only only JJ 13433 1873 28 solid solid JJ 13433 1873 29 basis basis NN 13433 1873 30 of of IN 13433 1873 31 morality morality NN 13433 1873 32 ; ; : 13433 1873 33 and and CC 13433 1873 34 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1873 35 is be VBZ 13433 1873 36 alleged allege VBN 13433 1873 37 that that IN 13433 1873 38 , , , 13433 1873 39 before before IN 13433 1873 40 existing exist VBG 13433 1873 41 belief belief NN 13433 1873 42 is be VBZ 13433 1873 43 disturbed disturb VBN 13433 1873 44 , , , 13433 1873 45 the the DT 13433 1873 46 iconoclast iconoclast NN 13433 1873 47 is be VBZ 13433 1873 48 bound bind VBN 13433 1873 49 to to TO 13433 1873 50 provide provide VB 13433 1873 51 a a DT 13433 1873 52 substitute substitute NN 13433 1873 53 for for IN 13433 1873 54 the the DT 13433 1873 55 shattered shattered JJ 13433 1873 56 idol idol NN 13433 1873 57 . . . 13433 1874 1 To to IN 13433 1874 2 this this DT 13433 1874 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1874 4 may may MD 13433 1874 5 reply reply VB 13433 1874 6 that that DT 13433 1874 7 speech speech NN 13433 1874 8 or or CC 13433 1874 9 silence silence NN 13433 1874 10 does do VBZ 13433 1874 11 not not RB 13433 1874 12 alter alter VB 13433 1874 13 the the DT 13433 1874 14 reality reality NN 13433 1874 15 of of IN 13433 1874 16 things thing NNS 13433 1874 17 . . . 13433 1875 1 The the DT 13433 1875 2 recognition recognition NN 13433 1875 3 of of IN 13433 1875 4 Truth truth NN 13433 1875 5 can can MD 13433 1875 6 not not RB 13433 1875 7 be be VB 13433 1875 8 made make VBN 13433 1875 9 dependent dependent JJ 13433 1875 10 on on IN 13433 1875 11 consequences consequence NNS 13433 1875 12 , , , 13433 1875 13 or or CC 13433 1875 14 be be VB 13433 1875 15 trammelled trammelle VBN 13433 1875 16 by by IN 13433 1875 17 considerations consideration NNS 13433 1875 18 of of IN 13433 1875 19 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1875 20 expediency expediency NN 13433 1875 21 . . . 13433 1876 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1876 2 declaration declaration NN 13433 1876 3 in in IN 13433 1876 4 a a DT 13433 1876 5 serious serious JJ 13433 1876 6 and and CC 13433 1876 7 suitable suitable JJ 13433 1876 8 manner manner NN 13433 1876 9 to to IN 13433 1876 10 those those DT 13433 1876 11 who who WP 13433 1876 12 are be VBP 13433 1876 13 capable capable JJ 13433 1876 14 of of IN 13433 1876 15 judging judging NN 13433 1876 16 can can MD 13433 1876 17 never never RB 13433 1876 18 be be VB 13433 1876 19 premature premature JJ 13433 1876 20 . . . 13433 1877 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1877 2 suppression suppression NN 13433 1877 3 can can MD 13433 1877 4 not not RB 13433 1877 5 be be VB 13433 1877 6 effectual effectual JJ 13433 1877 7 , , , 13433 1877 8 and and CC 13433 1877 9 is be VBZ 13433 1877 10 only only RB 13433 1877 11 a a DT 13433 1877 12 humiliating humiliating JJ 13433 1877 13 compromise compromise NN 13433 1877 14 with with IN 13433 1877 15 conscious conscious JJ 13433 1877 16 imposture imposture NN 13433 1877 17 . . . 13433 1878 1 In in IN 13433 1878 2 so so RB 13433 1878 3 far far RB 13433 1878 4 as as IN 13433 1878 5 morality morality NN 13433 1878 6 is be VBZ 13433 1878 7 concerned concern VBN 13433 1878 8 , , , 13433 1878 9 belief belief NN 13433 1878 10 in in IN 13433 1878 11 a a DT 13433 1878 12 system system NN 13433 1878 13 of of IN 13433 1878 14 future future JJ 13433 1878 15 rewards reward NNS 13433 1878 16 and and CC 13433 1878 17 punishments punishment NNS 13433 1878 18 , , , 13433 1878 19 although although IN 13433 1878 20 of of IN 13433 1878 21 an an DT 13433 1878 22 intensely intensely RB 13433 1878 23 degraded degrade VBN 13433 1878 24 character character NN 13433 1878 25 , , , 13433 1878 26 may may MD 13433 1878 27 , , , 13433 1878 28 to to IN 13433 1878 29 a a DT 13433 1878 30 certain certain JJ 13433 1878 31 extent extent NN 13433 1878 32 , , , 13433 1878 33 have have VBP 13433 1878 34 promoted promote VBN 13433 1878 35 observance observance NN 13433 1878 36 of of IN 13433 1878 37 the the DT 13433 1878 38 letter letter NN 13433 1878 39 of of IN 13433 1878 40 the the DT 13433 1878 41 law law NN 13433 1878 42 in in IN 13433 1878 43 darker dark JJR 13433 1878 44 ages age NNS 13433 1878 45 and and CC 13433 1878 46 even even RB 13433 1878 47 in in IN 13433 1878 48 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1878 49 own own JJ 13433 1878 50 ; ; : 13433 1878 51 but but CC 13433 1878 52 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1878 53 may may MD 13433 1878 54 , , , 13433 1878 55 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1878 56 think think VBP 13433 1878 57 , , , 13433 1878 58 be be VB 13433 1878 59 shown show VBN 13433 1878 60 that that IN 13433 1878 61 education education NN 13433 1878 62 and and CC 13433 1878 63 civilisation civilisation NN 13433 1878 64 have have VBP 13433 1878 65 done do VBN 13433 1878 66 infinitely infinitely RB 13433 1878 67 more more JJR 13433 1878 68 to to TO 13433 1878 69 enforce enforce VB 13433 1878 70 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1878 71 spirit spirit NN 13433 1878 72 . . . 13433 1879 1 How how WRB 13433 1879 2 far far RB 13433 1879 3 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1879 4 has have VBZ 13433 1879 5 promoted promote VBN 13433 1879 6 education education NN 13433 1879 7 and and CC 13433 1879 8 civilisation civilisation NN 13433 1879 9 , , , 13433 1879 10 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1879 11 shall shall MD 13433 1879 12 not not RB 13433 1879 13 here here RB 13433 1879 14 venture venture VB 13433 1879 15 adequately adequately RB 13433 1879 16 to to TO 13433 1879 17 discuss discuss VB 13433 1879 18 . . . 13433 1880 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1880 2 may may MD 13433 1880 3 emphatically emphatically RB 13433 1880 4 assert assert VB 13433 1880 5 , , , 13433 1880 6 however however RB 13433 1880 7 , , , 13433 1880 8 that that IN 13433 1880 9 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1880 10 beneficial beneficial JJ 13433 1880 11 effect effect NN 13433 1880 12 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1880 13 has have VBZ 13433 1880 14 produced produce VBN 13433 1880 15 has have VBZ 13433 1880 16 been be VBN 13433 1880 17 due due JJ 13433 1880 18 , , , 13433 1880 19 not not RB 13433 1880 20 to to IN 13433 1880 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1880 22 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1880 23 dogmas dogmas NN 13433 1880 24 , , , 13433 1880 25 but but CC 13433 1880 26 to to IN 13433 1880 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1880 28 simple simple JJ 13433 1880 29 morality morality NN 13433 1880 30 . . . 13433 1881 1 Dogmatic Dogmatic NNP 13433 1881 2 Theology Theology NNP 13433 1881 3 , , , 13433 1881 4 on on IN 13433 1881 5 the the DT 13433 1881 6 contrary contrary NN 13433 1881 7 , , , 13433 1881 8 has have VBZ 13433 1881 9 retarded retard VBN 13433 1881 10 education education NN 13433 1881 11 and and CC 13433 1881 12 impeded impede VBD 13433 1881 13 science science NN 13433 1881 14 . . . 13433 1882 1 Wherever wherever WRB 13433 1882 2 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1882 3 has have VBZ 13433 1882 4 been be VBN 13433 1882 5 dominant dominant JJ 13433 1882 6 , , , 13433 1882 7 civilisation civilisation NN 13433 1882 8 has have VBZ 13433 1882 9 stood stand VBN 13433 1882 10 still still RB 13433 1882 11 . . . 13433 1883 1 Science science NN 13433 1883 2 has have VBZ 13433 1883 3 been be VBN 13433 1883 4 judged judge VBN 13433 1883 5 and and CC 13433 1883 6 suppressed suppress VBN 13433 1883 7 by by IN 13433 1883 8 the the DT 13433 1883 9 light light NN 13433 1883 10 of of IN 13433 1883 11 a a DT 13433 1883 12 text text NN 13433 1883 13 or or CC 13433 1883 14 a a DT 13433 1883 15 chapter chapter NN 13433 1883 16 of of IN 13433 1883 17 Genesis Genesis NNP 13433 1883 18 . . . 13433 1884 1 Almost almost RB 13433 1884 2 every every DT 13433 1884 3 great great JJ 13433 1884 4 advance advance NN 13433 1884 5 which which WDT 13433 1884 6 has have VBZ 13433 1884 7 been be VBN 13433 1884 8 made make VBN 13433 1884 9 towards towards IN 13433 1884 10 enlightenment enlightenment NN 13433 1884 11 has have VBZ 13433 1884 12 been be VBN 13433 1884 13 achieved achieve VBN 13433 1884 14 in in IN 13433 1884 15 spite spite NN 13433 1884 16 of of IN 13433 1884 17 the the DT 13433 1884 18 protest protest NN 13433 1884 19 or or CC 13433 1884 20 the the DT 13433 1884 21 anathema anathema NN 13433 1884 22 of of IN 13433 1884 23 the the DT 13433 1884 24 Church Church NNP 13433 1884 25 . . . 13433 1885 1 Submissive submissive JJ 13433 1885 2 ignorance ignorance NN 13433 1885 3 , , , 13433 1885 4 absolute absolute JJ 13433 1885 5 or or CC 13433 1885 6 comparative comparative JJ 13433 1885 7 , , , 13433 1885 8 has have VBZ 13433 1885 9 been be VBN 13433 1885 10 tacitly tacitly RB 13433 1885 11 fostered foster VBN 13433 1885 12 as as IN 13433 1885 13 the the DT 13433 1885 14 most most RBS 13433 1885 15 desirable desirable JJ 13433 1885 16 condition condition NN 13433 1885 17 of of IN 13433 1885 18 the the DT 13433 1885 19 popular popular JJ 13433 1885 20 mind mind NN 13433 1885 21 . . . 13433 1886 1 " " `` 13433 1886 2 Except except IN 13433 1886 3 ye ye NNP 13433 1886 4 be be VBP 13433 1886 5 converted convert VBN 13433 1886 6 , , , 13433 1886 7 and and CC 13433 1886 8 become become VB 13433 1886 9 as as IN 13433 1886 10 little little JJ 13433 1886 11 children child NNS 13433 1886 12 , , , 13433 1886 13 ye ye NNP 13433 1886 14 shall shall MD 13433 1886 15 not not RB 13433 1886 16 enter enter VB 13433 1886 17 into into IN 13433 1886 18 the the DT 13433 1886 19 kingdom kingdom NN 13433 1886 20 of of IN 13433 1886 21 heaven heaven NNP 13433 1886 22 , , , 13433 1886 23 " " '' 13433 1886 24 has have VBZ 13433 1886 25 been be VBN 13433 1886 26 the the DT 13433 1886 27 favourite favourite JJ 13433 1886 28 text text NN 13433 1886 29 of of IN 13433 1886 30 Doctors Doctors NNPS 13433 1886 31 of of IN 13433 1886 32 Divinity Divinity NNP 13433 1886 33 with with IN 13433 1886 34 a a DT 13433 1886 35 stock stock NN 13433 1886 36 of of IN 13433 1886 37 incredible incredible JJ 13433 1886 38 dogmas dogmas NN 13433 1886 39 difficult difficult JJ 13433 1886 40 of of IN 13433 1886 41 assimilation assimilation NN 13433 1886 42 by by IN 13433 1886 43 the the DT 13433 1886 44 virile virile JJ 13433 1886 45 mind mind NN 13433 1886 46 . . . 13433 1887 1 Even even RB 13433 1887 2 now now RB 13433 1887 3 , , , 13433 1887 4 the the DT 13433 1887 5 friction friction NN 13433 1887 6 of of IN 13433 1887 7 theological theological JJ 13433 1887 8 resistance resistance NN 13433 1887 9 is be VBZ 13433 1887 10 a a DT 13433 1887 11 constant constant JJ 13433 1887 12 waste waste NN 13433 1887 13 of of IN 13433 1887 14 intellectual intellectual JJ 13433 1887 15 power power NN 13433 1887 16 . . . 13433 1888 1 The the DT 13433 1888 2 early early JJ 13433 1888 3 enunciation enunciation NN 13433 1888 4 of of IN 13433 1888 5 so so RB 13433 1888 6 pure pure JJ 13433 1888 7 a a DT 13433 1888 8 system system NN 13433 1888 9 of of IN 13433 1888 10 morality morality NN 13433 1888 11 , , , 13433 1888 12 and and CC 13433 1888 13 one one CD 13433 1888 14 so so RB 13433 1888 15 intelligible intelligible JJ 13433 1888 16 to to IN 13433 1888 17 the the DT 13433 1888 18 simple simple JJ 13433 1888 19 as as RB 13433 1888 20 well well RB 13433 1888 21 as as IN 13433 1888 22 profound profound JJ 13433 1888 23 to to IN 13433 1888 24 the the DT 13433 1888 25 wise wise JJ 13433 1888 26 , , , 13433 1888 27 was be VBD 13433 1888 28 of of IN 13433 1888 29 great great JJ 13433 1888 30 value value NN 13433 1888 31 to to IN 13433 1888 32 the the DT 13433 1888 33 world world NN 13433 1888 34 ; ; : 13433 1888 35 but but CC 13433 1888 36 , , , 13433 1888 37 experience experience NN 13433 1888 38 being be VBG 13433 1888 39 once once RB 13433 1888 40 systematised systematise VBN 13433 1888 41 and and CC 13433 1888 42 codified codify VBD 13433 1888 43 , , , 13433 1888 44 if if IN 13433 1888 45 higher high JJR 13433 1888 46 principles principle NNS 13433 1888 47 do do VBP 13433 1888 48 not not RB 13433 1888 49 constrain constrain VB 13433 1888 50 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1888 51 , , , 13433 1888 52 society society NN 13433 1888 53 may may MD 13433 1888 54 safely safely RB 13433 1888 55 be be VB 13433 1888 56 left leave VBN 13433 1888 57 to to TO 13433 1888 58 see see VB 13433 1888 59 morals moral NNS 13433 1888 60 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 1888 61 observed observe VBN 13433 1888 62 . . . 13433 1889 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1889 2 is be VBZ 13433 1889 3 true true JJ 13433 1889 4 that that IN 13433 1889 5 , , , 13433 1889 6 notwithstanding notwithstanding IN 13433 1889 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1889 8 fluctuating fluctuate VBG 13433 1889 9 rules rule NNS 13433 1889 10 , , , 13433 1889 11 morality morality NN 13433 1889 12 has have VBZ 13433 1889 13 hitherto hitherto VBN 13433 1889 14 assumed assume VBN 13433 1889 15 the the DT 13433 1889 16 character character NN 13433 1889 17 of of IN 13433 1889 18 a a DT 13433 1889 19 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1889 20 institution institution NN 13433 1889 21 , , , 13433 1889 22 but but CC 13433 1889 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1889 24 sway sway NN 13433 1889 25 has have VBZ 13433 1889 26 not not RB 13433 1889 27 , , , 13433 1889 28 in in IN 13433 1889 29 consequence consequence NN 13433 1889 30 , , , 13433 1889 31 been be VBN 13433 1889 32 more more RBR 13433 1889 33 real real JJ 13433 1889 34 than than IN 13433 1889 35 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1889 36 must must MD 13433 1889 37 be be VB 13433 1889 38 as as IN 13433 1889 39 the the DT 13433 1889 40 simple simple JJ 13433 1889 41 result result NN 13433 1889 42 of of IN 13433 1889 43 human human JJ 13433 1889 44 wisdom wisdom NN 13433 1889 45 and and CC 13433 1889 46 the the DT 13433 1889 47 outcome outcome NN 13433 1889 48 of of IN 13433 1889 49 social social JJ 13433 1889 50 experience experience NN 13433 1889 51 . . . 13433 1890 1 The the DT 13433 1890 2 choice choice NN 13433 1890 3 of of IN 13433 1890 4 a a DT 13433 1890 5 noble noble JJ 13433 1890 6 life life NN 13433 1890 7 is be VBZ 13433 1890 8 no no RB 13433 1890 9 longer long RBR 13433 1890 10 a a DT 13433 1890 11 theological theological JJ 13433 1890 12 question question NN 13433 1890 13 , , , 13433 1890 14 and and CC 13433 1890 15 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 1890 16 patents patent NNS 13433 1890 17 of of IN 13433 1890 18 truth truth NN 13433 1890 19 and and CC 13433 1890 20 uprightness uprightness NN 13433 1890 21 have have VBP 13433 1890 22 finally finally RB 13433 1890 23 expired expire VBN 13433 1890 24 . . . 13433 1891 1 Morality Morality NNP 13433 1891 2 , , , 13433 1891 3 which which WDT 13433 1891 4 has have VBZ 13433 1891 5 ever ever RB 13433 1891 6 changed change VBN 13433 1891 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1891 8 complexion complexion NN 13433 1891 9 and and CC 13433 1891 10 modified modify VBD 13433 1891 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1891 12 injunctions injunction NNS 13433 1891 13 according accord VBG 13433 1891 14 to to IN 13433 1891 15 social social JJ 13433 1891 16 requirements requirement NNS 13433 1891 17 , , , 13433 1891 18 will will MD 13433 1891 19 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 1891 20 be be VB 13433 1891 21 enforced enforce VBN 13433 1891 22 as as IN 13433 1891 23 part part NN 13433 1891 24 of of IN 13433 1891 25 human human JJ 13433 1891 26 evolution evolution NN 13433 1891 27 , , , 13433 1891 28 and and CC 13433 1891 29 is be VBZ 13433 1891 30 not not RB 13433 1891 31 dependent dependent JJ 13433 1891 32 on on IN 13433 1891 33 religious religious JJ 13433 1891 34 terrorism terrorism NN 13433 1891 35 or or CC 13433 1891 36 superstitious superstitious JJ 13433 1891 37 persuasion persuasion NN 13433 1891 38 . . . 13433 1892 1 If if IN 13433 1892 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1892 3 are be VBP 13433 1892 4 disposed disposed JJ 13433 1892 5 to to TO 13433 1892 6 say say VB 13433 1892 7 : : : 13433 1892 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1892 9 Cui Cui NNP 13433 1892 10 bono bono FW 13433 1892 11 ? ? . 13433 1892 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1892 13 and and CC 13433 1892 14 only only RB 13433 1892 15 practise practise VB 13433 1892 16 morality morality NN 13433 1892 17 , , , 13433 1892 18 or or CC 13433 1892 19 be be VB 13433 1892 20 ruled rule VBN 13433 1892 21 by by IN 13433 1892 22 right right JJ 13433 1892 23 principles principle NNS 13433 1892 24 , , , 13433 1892 25 to to TO 13433 1892 26 gain gain VB 13433 1892 27 a a DT 13433 1892 28 heaven heaven NN 13433 1892 29 or or CC 13433 1892 30 escape escape VB 13433 1892 31 a a DT 13433 1892 32 hell hell NN 13433 1892 33 , , , 13433 1892 34 there there EX 13433 1892 35 is be VBZ 13433 1892 36 nothing nothing NN 13433 1892 37 lost lose VBN 13433 1892 38 , , , 13433 1892 39 for for IN 13433 1892 40 such such JJ 13433 1892 41 grudging grudging JJ 13433 1892 42 and and CC 13433 1892 43 calculated calculated JJ 13433 1892 44 morality morality NN 13433 1892 45 is be VBZ 13433 1892 46 merely merely RB 13433 1892 47 a a DT 13433 1892 48 spurious spurious JJ 13433 1892 49 imitation imitation NN 13433 1892 50 which which WDT 13433 1892 51 can can MD 13433 1892 52 as as RB 13433 1892 53 well well RB 13433 1892 54 be be VB 13433 1892 55 produced produce VBN 13433 1892 56 by by IN 13433 1892 57 social social JJ 13433 1892 58 compulsion compulsion NN 13433 1892 59 . . . 13433 1893 1 But but CC 13433 1893 2 if if IN 13433 1893 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1893 4 have have VBP 13433 1893 5 ever ever RB 13433 1893 6 been be VBN 13433 1893 7 really really RB 13433 1893 8 penetrated penetrate VBN 13433 1893 9 by by IN 13433 1893 10 the the DT 13433 1893 11 pure pure JJ 13433 1893 12 spirit spirit NN 13433 1893 13 of of IN 13433 1893 14 morality morality NN 13433 1893 15 , , , 13433 1893 16 if if IN 13433 1893 17 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1893 18 have have VBP 13433 1893 19 in in IN 13433 1893 20 any any DT 13433 1893 21 degree degree NN 13433 1893 22 attained attain VBD 13433 1893 23 that that DT 13433 1893 24 elevation elevation NN 13433 1893 25 of of IN 13433 1893 26 mind mind NN 13433 1893 27 which which WDT 13433 1893 28 instinctively instinctively RB 13433 1893 29 turns turn VBZ 13433 1893 30 to to IN 13433 1893 31 the the DT 13433 1893 32 true true JJ 13433 1893 33 and and CC 13433 1893 34 noble noble JJ 13433 1893 35 and and CC 13433 1893 36 shrinks shrink NNS 13433 1893 37 from from IN 13433 1893 38 the the DT 13433 1893 39 baser baser NN 13433 1893 40 level level NN 13433 1893 41 of of IN 13433 1893 42 thought thought NN 13433 1893 43 and and CC 13433 1893 44 action action NN 13433 1893 45 , , , 13433 1893 46 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1893 47 shall shall MD 13433 1893 48 feel feel VB 13433 1893 49 no no DT 13433 1893 50 need need NN 13433 1893 51 of of IN 13433 1893 52 the the DT 13433 1893 53 stimulus stimulus NN 13433 1893 54 of of IN 13433 1893 55 a a DT 13433 1893 56 system system NN 13433 1893 57 of of IN 13433 1893 58 rewards reward NNS 13433 1893 59 and and CC 13433 1893 60 punishments punishment NNS 13433 1893 61 in in IN 13433 1893 62 a a DT 13433 1893 63 future future JJ 13433 1893 64 state state NN 13433 1893 65 which which WDT 13433 1893 66 has have VBZ 13433 1893 67 for for IN 13433 1893 68 so so RB 13433 1893 69 long long RB 13433 1893 70 been be VBN 13433 1893 71 represented represent VBN 13433 1893 72 as as IN 13433 1893 73 essential essential JJ 13433 1893 74 to to IN 13433 1893 75 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1893 76 . . . 13433 1894 1 As as IN 13433 1894 2 to to IN 13433 1894 3 the the DT 13433 1894 4 other other JJ 13433 1894 5 reproach reproach NN 13433 1894 6 , , , 13433 1894 7 let let VB 13433 1894 8 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1894 9 ask ask VB 13433 1894 10 what what WP 13433 1894 11 has have VBZ 13433 1894 12 actually actually RB 13433 1894 13 been be VBN 13433 1894 14 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 1894 15 by by IN 13433 1894 16 such such PDT 13433 1894 17 an an DT 13433 1894 18 enquiry enquiry NN 13433 1894 19 pressed press VBN 13433 1894 20 to to IN 13433 1894 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1894 22 logical logical JJ 13433 1894 23 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 1894 24 . . . 13433 1895 1 Can Can MD 13433 1895 2 Truth truth NN 13433 1895 3 by by IN 13433 1895 4 any any DT 13433 1895 5 means mean NNS 13433 1895 6 be be VB 13433 1895 7 made make VBN 13433 1895 8 less less RBR 13433 1895 9 true true JJ 13433 1895 10 ? ? . 13433 1896 1 Can Can MD 13433 1896 2 reality reality NN 13433 1896 3 be be VB 13433 1896 4 melted melt VBN 13433 1896 5 into into IN 13433 1896 6 thin thin JJ 13433 1896 7 air air NN 13433 1896 8 ? ? . 13433 1897 1 The the DT 13433 1897 2 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1897 3 not not RB 13433 1897 4 being be VBG 13433 1897 5 a a DT 13433 1897 6 reality reality NN 13433 1897 7 , , , 13433 1897 8 that that WDT 13433 1897 9 which which WDT 13433 1897 10 has have VBZ 13433 1897 11 been be VBN 13433 1897 12 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 1897 13 is be VBZ 13433 1897 14 only only RB 13433 1897 15 an an DT 13433 1897 16 illusion illusion NN 13433 1897 17 , , , 13433 1897 18 and and CC 13433 1897 19 that that IN 13433 1897 20 which which WDT 13433 1897 21 is be VBZ 13433 1897 22 left leave VBN 13433 1897 23 is be VBZ 13433 1897 24 the the DT 13433 1897 25 Truth truth NN 13433 1897 26 . . . 13433 1898 1 Losing lose VBG 13433 1898 2 belief belief NN 13433 1898 3 in in IN 13433 1898 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1898 5 and and CC 13433 1898 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1898 7 contents content NNS 13433 1898 8 , , , 13433 1898 9 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1898 10 have have VBP 13433 1898 11 lost lose VBN 13433 1898 12 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1898 13 nothing nothing NN 13433 1898 14 but but IN 13433 1898 15 that that IN 13433 1898 16 which which WDT 13433 1898 17 the the DT 13433 1898 18 traveller traveller NN 13433 1898 19 loses lose VBZ 13433 1898 20 when when WRB 13433 1898 21 the the DT 13433 1898 22 mirage mirage NN 13433 1898 23 , , , 13433 1898 24 which which WDT 13433 1898 25 has have VBZ 13433 1898 26 displayed display VBN 13433 1898 27 cool cool JJ 13433 1898 28 waters water NNS 13433 1898 29 and and CC 13433 1898 30 green green JJ 13433 1898 31 shades shade NNS 13433 1898 32 before before IN 13433 1898 33 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1898 34 , , , 13433 1898 35 melts melt NNS 13433 1898 36 swiftly swiftly RB 13433 1898 37 away away RB 13433 1898 38 . . . 13433 1899 1 There there EX 13433 1899 2 were be VBD 13433 1899 3 no no DT 13433 1899 4 cool cool JJ 13433 1899 5 fountains fountain NNS 13433 1899 6 really really RB 13433 1899 7 there there RB 13433 1899 8 to to TO 13433 1899 9 allay allay VB 13433 1899 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1899 11 thirst thirst NN 13433 1899 12 , , , 13433 1899 13 no no DT 13433 1899 14 flowery flowery JJ 13433 1899 15 meadows meadow VBZ 13433 1899 16 for for IN 13433 1899 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1899 18 wearied weary VBN 13433 1899 19 limbs limb NNS 13433 1899 20 ; ; : 13433 1899 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1899 22 pleasure pleasure NN 13433 1899 23 was be VBD 13433 1899 24 delusion delusion NN 13433 1899 25 , , , 13433 1899 26 and and CC 13433 1899 27 the the DT 13433 1899 28 wilderness wilderness NN 13433 1899 29 is be VBZ 13433 1899 30 blank blank JJ 13433 1899 31 . . . 13433 1900 1 Rather rather RB 13433 1900 2 the the DT 13433 1900 3 mirage mirage NN 13433 1900 4 with with IN 13433 1900 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1900 6 pleasant pleasant JJ 13433 1900 7 illusion illusion NN 13433 1900 8 , , , 13433 1900 9 is be VBZ 13433 1900 10 the the DT 13433 1900 11 human human JJ 13433 1900 12 cry cry NN 13433 1900 13 , , , 13433 1900 14 than than IN 13433 1900 15 the the DT 13433 1900 16 desert desert NN 13433 1900 17 with with IN 13433 1900 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1900 19 barrenness barrenness NN 13433 1900 20 . . . 13433 1901 1 Not not RB 13433 1901 2 so so RB 13433 1901 3 , , , 13433 1901 4 is be VBZ 13433 1901 5 the the DT 13433 1901 6 friendly friendly JJ 13433 1901 7 warning warning NN 13433 1901 8 ; ; : 13433 1901 9 seek seek VB 13433 1901 10 not not RB 13433 1901 11 vainly vainly RB 13433 1901 12 in in IN 13433 1901 13 the the DT 13433 1901 14 desert desert NN 13433 1901 15 that that WDT 13433 1901 16 which which WDT 13433 1901 17 is be VBZ 13433 1901 18 not not RB 13433 1901 19 there there RB 13433 1901 20 , , , 13433 1901 21 but but CC 13433 1901 22 turn turn VB 13433 1901 23 rather rather RB 13433 1901 24 to to IN 13433 1901 25 other other JJ 13433 1901 26 horizons horizon NNS 13433 1901 27 and and CC 13433 1901 28 to to IN 13433 1901 29 surer surer VB 13433 1901 30 hopes hope NNS 13433 1901 31 . . . 13433 1902 1 Do do VB 13433 1902 2 not not RB 13433 1902 3 waste waste VB 13433 1902 4 life life NN 13433 1902 5 clinging cling VBG 13433 1902 6 to to IN 13433 1902 7 ecclesiastical ecclesiastical JJ 13433 1902 8 dogmas dogma NNS 13433 1902 9 which which WDT 13433 1902 10 represent represent VBP 13433 1902 11 no no DT 13433 1902 12 eternal eternal JJ 13433 1902 13 verities verity NNS 13433 1902 14 , , , 13433 1902 15 but but CC 13433 1902 16 search search VB 13433 1902 17 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 1902 18 for for IN 13433 1902 19 truth truth NN 13433 1902 20 which which WDT 13433 1902 21 may may MD 13433 1902 22 haply haply RB 13433 1902 23 be be VB 13433 1902 24 found find VBN 13433 1902 25 . . . 13433 1903 1 What what WP 13433 1903 2 should should MD 13433 1903 3 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1903 4 think think VB 13433 1903 5 of of IN 13433 1903 6 the the DT 13433 1903 7 man man NN 13433 1903 8 who who WP 13433 1903 9 persistently persistently RB 13433 1903 10 repulsed repulse VBD 13433 1903 11 the the DT 13433 1903 12 persuasion persuasion NN 13433 1903 13 that that IN 13433 1903 14 two two CD 13433 1903 15 and and CC 13433 1903 16 two two CD 13433 1903 17 make make VBP 13433 1903 18 four four CD 13433 1903 19 from from IN 13433 1903 20 the the DT 13433 1903 21 ardent ardent JJ 13433 1903 22 desire desire NN 13433 1903 23 to to TO 13433 1903 24 believe believe VB 13433 1903 25 that that IN 13433 1903 26 two two CD 13433 1903 27 and and CC 13433 1903 28 two two CD 13433 1903 29 make make VBP 13433 1903 30 five five CD 13433 1903 31 ? ? . 13433 1904 1 Whose whose WP$ 13433 1904 2 fault fault NN 13433 1904 3 is be VBZ 13433 1904 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1904 5 that that WDT 13433 1904 6 two two CD 13433 1904 7 and and CC 13433 1904 8 two two CD 13433 1904 9 do do VBP 13433 1904 10 make make VB 13433 1904 11 four four CD 13433 1904 12 and and CC 13433 1904 13 not not RB 13433 1904 14 five five CD 13433 1904 15 ? ? . 13433 1905 1 Whose whose WP$ 13433 1905 2 folly folly NN 13433 1905 3 is be VBZ 13433 1905 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1905 5 that that IN 13433 1905 6 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1905 7 should should MD 13433 1905 8 be be VB 13433 1905 9 more more RBR 13433 1905 10 agreeable agreeable JJ 13433 1905 11 to to TO 13433 1905 12 think think VB 13433 1905 13 that that IN 13433 1905 14 two two CD 13433 1905 15 and and CC 13433 1905 16 two two CD 13433 1905 17 make make VBP 13433 1905 18 five five CD 13433 1905 19 than than IN 13433 1905 20 to to TO 13433 1905 21 know know VB 13433 1905 22 that that IN 13433 1905 23 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1905 24 only only RB 13433 1905 25 make make VBP 13433 1905 26 four four CD 13433 1905 27 ? ? . 13433 1906 1 This this DT 13433 1906 2 folly folly NN 13433 1906 3 is be VBZ 13433 1906 4 theirs -PRON- PRP 13433 1906 5 who who WP 13433 1906 6 represent represent VBP 13433 1906 7 the the DT 13433 1906 8 value value NN 13433 1906 9 of of IN 13433 1906 10 life life NN 13433 1906 11 as as IN 13433 1906 12 dependent dependent JJ 13433 1906 13 on on IN 13433 1906 14 the the DT 13433 1906 15 reality reality NN 13433 1906 16 of of IN 13433 1906 17 special special JJ 13433 1906 18 illusions illusion NNS 13433 1906 19 , , , 13433 1906 20 which which WDT 13433 1906 21 they -PRON- PRP 13433 1906 22 have have VBP 13433 1906 23 religiously religiously RB 13433 1906 24 adopted adopt VBN 13433 1906 25 . . . 13433 1907 1 To to TO 13433 1907 2 discover discover VB 13433 1907 3 that that IN 13433 1907 4 a a DT 13433 1907 5 former former JJ 13433 1907 6 belief belief NN 13433 1907 7 is be VBZ 13433 1907 8 unfounded unfounded JJ 13433 1907 9 is be VBZ 13433 1907 10 to to TO 13433 1907 11 change change VB 13433 1907 12 nothing nothing NN 13433 1907 13 of of IN 13433 1907 14 the the DT 13433 1907 15 realities reality NNS 13433 1907 16 of of IN 13433 1907 17 existence existence NN 13433 1907 18 . . . 13433 1908 1 The the DT 13433 1908 2 sun sun NN 13433 1908 3 will will MD 13433 1908 4 descend descend VB 13433 1908 5 as as IN 13433 1908 6 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1908 7 passes pass VBZ 13433 1908 8 the the DT 13433 1908 9 meridian meridian NN 13433 1908 10 whether whether IN 13433 1908 11 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1908 12 believe believe VBP 13433 1908 13 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1908 14 to to TO 13433 1908 15 be be VB 13433 1908 16 noon noon NN 13433 1908 17 or or CC 13433 1908 18 not not RB 13433 1908 19 . . . 13433 1909 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1909 2 is be VBZ 13433 1909 3 idle idle JJ 13433 1909 4 and and CC 13433 1909 5 foolish foolish JJ 13433 1909 6 , , , 13433 1909 7 if if IN 13433 1909 8 human human NN 13433 1909 9 , , , 13433 1909 10 to to TO 13433 1909 11 repine repine VB 13433 1909 12 because because IN 13433 1909 13 the the DT 13433 1909 14 truth truth NN 13433 1909 15 is be VBZ 13433 1909 16 not not RB 13433 1909 17 precisely precisely RB 13433 1909 18 what what WP 13433 1909 19 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1909 20 thought think VBD 13433 1909 21 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1909 22 , , , 13433 1909 23 and and CC 13433 1909 24 at at IN 13433 1909 25 least least JJS 13433 1909 26 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1909 27 shall shall MD 13433 1909 28 not not RB 13433 1909 29 change change VB 13433 1909 30 reality reality NN 13433 1909 31 by by IN 13433 1909 32 childishly childishly RB 13433 1909 33 clinging cling VBG 13433 1909 34 to to IN 13433 1909 35 a a DT 13433 1909 36 dream dream NN 13433 1909 37 . . . 13433 1910 1 The the DT 13433 1910 2 argument argument NN 13433 1910 3 so so RB 13433 1910 4 often often RB 13433 1910 5 employed employ VBN 13433 1910 6 by by IN 13433 1910 7 theologians theologian NNS 13433 1910 8 that that IN 13433 1910 9 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1910 10 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1910 11 is be VBZ 13433 1910 12 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1910 13 for for IN 13433 1910 14 man man NN 13433 1910 15 , , , 13433 1910 16 and and CC 13433 1910 17 that that IN 13433 1910 18 certain certain JJ 13433 1910 19 views view NNS 13433 1910 20 contained contain VBN 13433 1910 21 in in IN 13433 1910 22 that that IN 13433 1910 23 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1910 24 are be VBP 13433 1910 25 required require VBN 13433 1910 26 by by IN 13433 1910 27 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1910 28 moral moral JJ 13433 1910 29 consciousness consciousness NN 13433 1910 30 , , , 13433 1910 31 is be VBZ 13433 1910 32 purely purely RB 13433 1910 33 imaginary imaginary JJ 13433 1910 34 and and CC 13433 1910 35 derived derive VBN 13433 1910 36 from from IN 13433 1910 37 the the DT 13433 1910 38 Revelation revelation NN 13433 1910 39 which which WDT 13433 1910 40 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1910 41 seeks seek VBZ 13433 1910 42 to to TO 13433 1910 43 maintain maintain VB 13433 1910 44 . . . 13433 1911 1 The the DT 13433 1911 2 only only JJ 13433 1911 3 thing thing NN 13433 1911 4 absolutely absolutely RB 13433 1911 5 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1911 6 for for IN 13433 1911 7 man man NN 13433 1911 8 is be VBZ 13433 1911 9 Truth truth NN 13433 1911 10 ; ; : 13433 1911 11 and and CC 13433 1911 12 to to IN 13433 1911 13 that that DT 13433 1911 14 , , , 13433 1911 15 and and CC 13433 1911 16 that that IN 13433 1911 17 alone alone RB 13433 1911 18 , , , 13433 1911 19 must must MD 13433 1911 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1911 21 moral moral JJ 13433 1911 22 consciousness consciousness NN 13433 1911 23 adapt adapt VB 13433 1911 24 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1911 25 . . . 13433 1912 1 Reason reason NN 13433 1912 2 and and CC 13433 1912 3 experience experience NN 13433 1912 4 forbid forbid VBP 13433 1912 5 the the DT 13433 1912 6 expectation expectation NN 13433 1912 7 that that IN 13433 1912 8 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1912 9 can can MD 13433 1912 10 acquire acquire VB 13433 1912 11 any any DT 13433 1912 12 knowledge knowledge NN 13433 1912 13 otherwise otherwise RB 13433 1912 14 than than IN 13433 1912 15 through through IN 13433 1912 16 natural natural JJ 13433 1912 17 channels channel NNS 13433 1912 18 . . . 13433 1913 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1913 2 might may MD 13433 1913 3 as as RB 13433 1913 4 well well RB 13433 1913 5 expect expect VB 13433 1913 6 to to TO 13433 1913 7 be be VB 13433 1913 8 supernaturally supernaturally RB 13433 1913 9 nourished nourish VBN 13433 1913 10 as as IN 13433 1913 11 supernaturally supernaturally RB 13433 1913 12 informed inform VBN 13433 1913 13 . . . 13433 1914 1 To to TO 13433 1914 2 complain complain VB 13433 1914 3 that that IN 13433 1914 4 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1914 5 do do VBP 13433 1914 6 not not RB 13433 1914 7 know know VB 13433 1914 8 all all DT 13433 1914 9 that that WDT 13433 1914 10 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1914 11 desire desire VBP 13433 1914 12 to to TO 13433 1914 13 know know VB 13433 1914 14 is be VBZ 13433 1914 15 foolish foolish JJ 13433 1914 16 and and CC 13433 1914 17 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 13433 1914 18 . . . 13433 1915 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1915 2 is be VBZ 13433 1915 3 tantamount tantamount JJ 13433 1915 4 to to IN 13433 1915 5 complaining complain VBG 13433 1915 6 that that IN 13433 1915 7 the the DT 13433 1915 8 mind mind NN 13433 1915 9 of of IN 13433 1915 10 man man NN 13433 1915 11 is be VBZ 13433 1915 12 not not RB 13433 1915 13 differently differently RB 13433 1915 14 constituted constituted JJ 13433 1915 15 . . . 13433 1916 1 To to TO 13433 1916 2 attain attain VB 13433 1916 3 the the DT 13433 1916 4 full full JJ 13433 1916 5 altitude altitude NN 13433 1916 6 of of IN 13433 1916 7 the the DT 13433 1916 8 Knowable Knowable NNP 13433 1916 9 , , , 13433 1916 10 whatever whatever WDT 13433 1916 11 that that DT 13433 1916 12 may may MD 13433 1916 13 be be VB 13433 1916 14 , , , 13433 1916 15 should should MD 13433 1916 16 be be VB 13433 1916 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1916 18 earnest earnest JJ 13433 1916 19 aim aim NN 13433 1916 20 , , , 13433 1916 21 and and CC 13433 1916 22 more more JJR 13433 1916 23 than than IN 13433 1916 24 this this DT 13433 1916 25 is be VBZ 13433 1916 26 not not RB 13433 1916 27 for for IN 13433 1916 28 humanity humanity NN 13433 1916 29 . . . 13433 1917 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1917 2 may may MD 13433 1917 3 be be VB 13433 1917 4 certain certain JJ 13433 1917 5 that that IN 13433 1917 6 information information NN 13433 1917 7 which which WDT 13433 1917 8 is be VBZ 13433 1917 9 beyond beyond IN 13433 1917 10 the the DT 13433 1917 11 ultimate ultimate JJ 13433 1917 12 reach reach NN 13433 1917 13 of of IN 13433 1917 14 Reason reason NN 13433 1917 15 is be VBZ 13433 1917 16 as as RB 13433 1917 17 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 13433 1917 18 as as IN 13433 1917 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1917 20 is be VBZ 13433 1917 21 inaccessible inaccessible JJ 13433 1917 22 . . . 13433 1918 1 Man man NN 13433 1918 2 may may MD 13433 1918 3 know know VB 13433 1918 4 all all PDT 13433 1918 5 that that DT 13433 1918 6 man man NN 13433 1918 7 requires require VBZ 13433 1918 8 to to TO 13433 1918 9 know know VB 13433 1918 10 . . . 13433 1919 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1919 2 gain gain VBP 13433 1919 3 more more JJR 13433 1919 4 than than IN 13433 1919 5 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1919 6 lose lose VBP 13433 1919 7 by by IN 13433 1919 8 awaking awake VBG 13433 1919 9 to to TO 13433 1919 10 find find VB 13433 1919 11 that that IN 13433 1919 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1919 13 Theology Theology NNP 13433 1919 14 is be VBZ 13433 1919 15 human human JJ 13433 1919 16 invention invention NN 13433 1919 17 and and CC 13433 1919 18 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1919 19 eschatology eschatology NN 13433 1919 20 an an DT 13433 1919 21 unhealthy unhealthy JJ 13433 1919 22 dream dream NN 13433 1919 23 . . . 13433 1920 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1920 2 are be VBP 13433 1920 3 freed free VBN 13433 1920 4 from from IN 13433 1920 5 the the DT 13433 1920 6 incubus incubus NN 13433 1920 7 of of IN 13433 1920 8 base base NN 13433 1920 9 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 1920 10 mythology mythology NN 13433 1920 11 , , , 13433 1920 12 and and CC 13433 1920 13 from from IN 13433 1920 14 doctrines doctrine NNS 13433 1920 15 of of IN 13433 1920 16 Divine divine JJ 13433 1920 17 government government NN 13433 1920 18 which which WDT 13433 1920 19 outrage outrage VBP 13433 1920 20 morality morality NN 13433 1920 21 and and CC 13433 1920 22 set set NN 13433 1920 23 cruelty cruelty NN 13433 1920 24 and and CC 13433 1920 25 injustice injustice NN 13433 1920 26 in in IN 13433 1920 27 the the DT 13433 1920 28 place place NN 13433 1920 29 of of IN 13433 1920 30 holiness holiness NN 13433 1920 31 . . . 13433 1921 1 If if IN 13433 1921 2 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1921 3 have have VBP 13433 1921 4 to to TO 13433 1921 5 abandon abandon VB 13433 1921 6 cherished cherish VBN 13433 1921 7 anthropomorphic anthropomorphic JJ 13433 1921 8 visions vision NNS 13433 1921 9 of of IN 13433 1921 10 future future JJ 13433 1921 11 Blessedness Blessedness NNP 13433 1921 12 , , , 13433 1921 13 the the DT 13433 1921 14 details detail NNS 13433 1921 15 of of IN 13433 1921 16 which which WDT 13433 1921 17 are be VBP 13433 1921 18 either either DT 13433 1921 19 of of IN 13433 1921 20 unseizable unseizable JJ 13433 1921 21 dimness dimness NN 13433 1921 22 or or CC 13433 1921 23 of of IN 13433 1921 24 questionable questionable JJ 13433 1921 25 joy joy NN 13433 1921 26 , , , 13433 1921 27 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1921 28 are be VBP 13433 1921 29 at at IN 13433 1921 30 least least RBS 13433 1921 31 delivered deliver VBN 13433 1921 32 from from IN 13433 1921 33 quibbling quibble VBG 13433 1921 34 discussions discussion NNS 13433 1921 35 of of IN 13433 1921 36 the the DT 13433 1921 37 meaning meaning NN 13433 1921 38 of of IN 13433 1921 39 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1921 40 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1921 41 : : : 13433 1921 42 aiônios aiônio NNS 13433 1921 43 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1921 44 , , , 13433 1921 45 and and CC 13433 1921 46 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1921 47 eternal eternal JJ 13433 1921 48 hope hope NN 13433 1921 49 is be VBZ 13433 1921 50 unclouded unclouded JJ 13433 1921 51 by by IN 13433 1921 52 the the DT 13433 1921 53 doubt doubt NN 13433 1921 54 whether whether IN 13433 1921 55 mankind mankind NN 13433 1921 56 is be VBZ 13433 1921 57 to to TO 13433 1921 58 be be VB 13433 1921 59 tortured torture VBN 13433 1921 60 in in IN 13433 1921 61 hell hell NN 13433 1921 62 for for IN 13433 1921 63 ever ever RB 13433 1921 64 and and CC 13433 1921 65 a a DT 13433 1921 66 day day NN 13433 1921 67 , , , 13433 1921 68 or or CC 13433 1921 69 for for IN 13433 1921 70 a a DT 13433 1921 71 day day NN 13433 1921 72 without without IN 13433 1921 73 the the DT 13433 1921 74 ever ever RB 13433 1921 75 . . . 13433 1922 1 At at IN 13433 1922 2 the the DT 13433 1922 3 end end NN 13433 1922 4 of of IN 13433 1922 5 life life NN 13433 1922 6 there there EX 13433 1922 7 may may MD 13433 1922 8 be be VB 13433 1922 9 no no DT 13433 1922 10 definite definite JJ 13433 1922 11 vista vista NN 13433 1922 12 of of IN 13433 1922 13 a a DT 13433 1922 14 Heaven Heaven NNP 13433 1922 15 glowing glow VBG 13433 1922 16 with with IN 13433 1922 17 the the DT 13433 1922 18 light light NN 13433 1922 19 of of IN 13433 1922 20 apocalyptic apocalyptic JJ 13433 1922 21 imagination imagination NN 13433 1922 22 , , , 13433 1922 23 but but CC 13433 1922 24 neither neither DT 13433 1922 25 will will MD 13433 1922 26 there there EX 13433 1922 27 be be VB 13433 1922 28 the the DT 13433 1922 29 unutterable unutterable JJ 13433 1922 30 horror horror NN 13433 1922 31 of of IN 13433 1922 32 a a DT 13433 1922 33 Purgatory Purgatory NNP 13433 1922 34 or or CC 13433 1922 35 a a DT 13433 1922 36 Hell Hell NNP 13433 1922 37 lurid lurid NN 13433 1922 38 with with IN 13433 1922 39 flames flame NNS 13433 1922 40 for for IN 13433 1922 41 the the DT 13433 1922 42 helpless helpless JJ 13433 1922 43 victims victim NNS 13433 1922 44 of of IN 13433 1922 45 an an DT 13433 1922 46 unjust unjust JJ 13433 1922 47 but but CC 13433 1922 48 omnipotent omnipotent JJ 13433 1922 49 Creator creator NN 13433 1922 50 . . . 13433 1923 1 To to TO 13433 1923 2 entertain entertain VB 13433 1923 3 such such JJ 13433 1923 4 libellous libellous JJ 13433 1923 5 representations representation NNS 13433 1923 6 at at RB 13433 1923 7 all all RB 13433 1923 8 as as IN 13433 1923 9 part part NN 13433 1923 10 of of IN 13433 1923 11 the the DT 13433 1923 12 contents content NNS 13433 1923 13 of of IN 13433 1923 14 " " `` 13433 1923 15 Divine Divine NNP 13433 1923 16 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1923 17 , , , 13433 1923 18 " " '' 13433 1923 19 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1923 20 was be VBD 13433 1923 21 necessary necessary JJ 13433 1923 22 to to TO 13433 1923 23 assert assert VB 13433 1923 24 that that DT 13433 1923 25 man man NN 13433 1923 26 was be VBD 13433 1923 27 incompetent incompetent JJ 13433 1923 28 to to TO 13433 1923 29 judge judge VB 13433 1923 30 of of IN 13433 1923 31 the the DT 13433 1923 32 ways way NNS 13433 1923 33 of of IN 13433 1923 34 the the DT 13433 1923 35 God God NNP 13433 1923 36 of of IN 13433 1923 37 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 1923 38 , , , 13433 1923 39 and and CC 13433 1923 40 must must MD 13433 1923 41 not not RB 13433 1923 42 suppose suppose VB 13433 1923 43 him -PRON- PRP 13433 1923 44 endowed endow VBN 13433 1923 45 with with IN 13433 1923 46 the the DT 13433 1923 47 perfection perfection NN 13433 1923 48 of of IN 13433 1923 49 human human JJ 13433 1923 50 conceptions conception NNS 13433 1923 51 of of IN 13433 1923 52 justice justice NN 13433 1923 53 and and CC 13433 1923 54 mercy mercy NN 13433 1923 55 , , , 13433 1923 56 but but CC 13433 1923 57 submit submit VB 13433 1923 58 to to TO 13433 1923 59 call call VB 13433 1923 60 wrong wrong JJ 13433 1923 61 right right NN 13433 1923 62 and and CC 13433 1923 63 right right RB 13433 1923 64 wrong wrong NN 13433 1923 65 at at IN 13433 1923 66 the the DT 13433 1923 67 foot foot NN 13433 1923 68 of of IN 13433 1923 69 an an DT 13433 1923 70 almighty almighty JJ 13433 1923 71 Despot Despot NNP 13433 1923 72 . . . 13433 1924 1 But but CC 13433 1924 2 now now RB 13433 1924 3 the the DT 13433 1924 4 reproach reproach NN 13433 1924 5 of of IN 13433 1924 6 such such JJ 13433 1924 7 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 1924 8 is be VBZ 13433 1924 9 shaken shake VBN 13433 1924 10 from from IN 13433 1924 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1924 12 shoulders shoulder NNS 13433 1924 13 , , , 13433 1924 14 and and CC 13433 1924 15 returns return NNS 13433 1924 16 to to IN 13433 1924 17 the the DT 13433 1924 18 Jewish jewish JJ 13433 1924 19 superstition superstition NN 13433 1924 20 from from IN 13433 1924 21 which which WDT 13433 1924 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1924 23 sprang spring VBD 13433 1924 24 . . . 13433 1925 1 As as IN 13433 1925 2 myths myth NNS 13433 1925 3 lose lose VBP 13433 1925 4 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1925 5 might might NN 13433 1925 6 and and CC 13433 1925 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1925 8 influence influence NN 13433 1925 9 when when WRB 13433 1925 10 discovered discover VBD 13433 1925 11 to to TO 13433 1925 12 be be VB 13433 1925 13 baseless baseless JJ 13433 1925 14 , , , 13433 1925 15 the the DT 13433 1925 16 power power NN 13433 1925 17 of of IN 13433 1925 18 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 1925 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 1925 20 will will MD 13433 1925 21 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 1925 22 pass pass VB 13433 1925 23 away away RB 13433 1925 24 , , , 13433 1925 25 but but CC 13433 1925 26 the the DT 13433 1925 27 effect effect NN 13433 1925 28 of of IN 13433 1925 29 the the DT 13433 1925 30 revolution revolution NN 13433 1925 31 must must MD 13433 1925 32 not not RB 13433 1925 33 be be VB 13433 1925 34 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 13433 1925 35 , , , 13433 1925 36 although although IN 13433 1925 37 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1925 38 can can MD 13433 1925 39 not not RB 13433 1925 40 here here RB 13433 1925 41 be be VB 13433 1925 42 fully fully RB 13433 1925 43 discussed discuss VBN 13433 1925 44 . . . 13433 1926 1 If if IN 13433 1926 2 the the DT 13433 1926 3 pictures picture NNS 13433 1926 4 which which WDT 13433 1926 5 have have VBP 13433 1926 6 filled fill VBN 13433 1926 7 for for IN 13433 1926 8 so so RB 13433 1926 9 long long RB 13433 1926 10 the the DT 13433 1926 11 horizon horizon NN 13433 1926 12 of of IN 13433 1926 13 the the DT 13433 1926 14 Future Future NNP 13433 1926 15 must must MD 13433 1926 16 vanish vanish VB 13433 1926 17 , , , 13433 1926 18 no no DT 13433 1926 19 hideous hideous JJ 13433 1926 20 blank blank NN 13433 1926 21 can can MD 13433 1926 22 rightly rightly RB 13433 1926 23 be be VB 13433 1926 24 maintained maintain VBN 13433 1926 25 in in IN 13433 1926 26 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1926 27 place place NN 13433 1926 28 . . . 13433 1927 1 We -PRON- PRP 13433 1927 2 should should MD 13433 1927 3 clearly clearly RB 13433 1927 4 distinguish distinguish VB 13433 1927 5 between between IN 13433 1927 6 what what WP 13433 1927 7 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1927 8 know know VBP 13433 1927 9 and and CC 13433 1927 10 know know VBP 13433 1927 11 not not RB 13433 1927 12 , , , 13433 1927 13 but but CC 13433 1927 14 as as IN 13433 1927 15 carefully carefully RB 13433 1927 16 abstain abstain VB 13433 1927 17 from from IN 13433 1927 18 characterising characterise VBG 13433 1927 19 that that IN 13433 1927 20 which which WDT 13433 1927 21 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1927 22 know know VBP 13433 1927 23 not not RB 13433 1927 24 as as IN 13433 1927 25 if if IN 13433 1927 26 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1927 27 were be VBD 13433 1927 28 really really RB 13433 1927 29 known known JJ 13433 1927 30 to to IN 13433 1927 31 us -PRON- PRP 13433 1927 32 . . . 13433 1928 1 That that DT 13433 1928 2 mysterious mysterious JJ 13433 1928 3 Unknown unknown JJ 13433 1928 4 or or CC 13433 1928 5 Unknowable Unknowable NNP 13433 1928 6 is be VBZ 13433 1928 7 no no DT 13433 1928 8 cruel cruel JJ 13433 1928 9 darkness darkness NN 13433 1928 10 , , , 13433 1928 11 but but CC 13433 1928 12 simply simply RB 13433 1928 13 an an DT 13433 1928 14 impenetrable impenetrable JJ 13433 1928 15 distance distance NN 13433 1928 16 into into IN 13433 1928 17 which which WDT 13433 1928 18 we -PRON- PRP 13433 1928 19 are be VBP 13433 1928 20 impotent impotent JJ 13433 1928 21 to to TO 13433 1928 22 glance glance VB 13433 1928 23 , , , 13433 1928 24 but but CC 13433 1928 25 which which WDT 13433 1928 26 excludes exclude VBZ 13433 1928 27 no no DT 13433 1928 28 legitimate legitimate JJ 13433 1928 29 speculation speculation NN 13433 1928 30 and and CC 13433 1928 31 forbids forbid NNS 13433 1928 32 no no DT 13433 1928 33 reasonable reasonable JJ 13433 1928 34 hope hope NN 13433 1928 35 . . . 13433 1929 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1929 2 ENDNOTES endnotes NN 13433 1929 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1929 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1929 5 1:1 1:1 CD 13433 1929 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1929 7 Originally originally RB 13433 1929 8 published publish VBN 13433 1929 9 in in IN 13433 1929 10 the the DT 13433 1929 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1929 12 Fortnightly Fortnightly NNP 13433 1929 13 Review Review NNP 13433 1929 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1929 15 , , , 13433 1929 16 January January NNP 13433 1929 17 1 1 CD 13433 1929 18 , , , 13433 1929 19 1875 1875 CD 13433 1929 20 . . . 13433 1930 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1930 2 4:1 4:1 LS 13433 1930 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1930 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1930 5 On On NNP 13433 1930 6 the the DT 13433 1930 7 Canon Canon NNP 13433 1930 8 _ _ NNP 13433 1930 9 , , , 13433 1930 10 p. p. NN 13433 1930 11 65 65 CD 13433 1930 12 . . . 13433 1931 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1931 2 4:2 4:2 CD 13433 1931 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1931 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1931 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1931 6 . . . 13433 1931 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1931 8 p. p. NN 13433 1931 9 61 61 CD 13433 1931 10 , , , 13433 1931 11 note note VBP 13433 1931 12 2 2 CD 13433 1931 13 . . . 13433 1932 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1932 2 4:3 4:3 CD 13433 1932 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1932 4 At at IN 13433 1932 5 the the DT 13433 1932 6 end end NN 13433 1932 7 of of IN 13433 1932 8 this this DT 13433 1932 9 note note NN 13433 1932 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1932 11 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 1932 12 adds add VBZ 13433 1932 13 , , , 13433 1932 14 " " `` 13433 1932 15 Indeed indeed RB 13433 1932 16 , , , 13433 1932 17 from from IN 13433 1932 18 the the DT 13433 1932 19 similar similar JJ 13433 1932 20 mode mode NN 13433 1932 21 of of IN 13433 1932 22 introducing introduce VBG 13433 1932 23 the the DT 13433 1932 24 story story NN 13433 1932 25 of of IN 13433 1932 26 the the DT 13433 1932 27 vine vine NN 13433 1932 28 , , , 13433 1932 29 which which WDT 13433 1932 30 is be VBZ 13433 1932 31 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 1932 32 referred refer VBN 13433 1932 33 to to IN 13433 1932 34 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1932 35 , , , 13433 1932 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1932 37 is be VBZ 13433 1932 38 reasonable reasonable JJ 13433 1932 39 to to TO 13433 1932 40 conjecture conjecture VB 13433 1932 41 that that IN 13433 1932 42 this this DT 13433 1932 43 interpretation interpretation NN 13433 1932 44 is be VBZ 13433 1932 45 one one CD 13433 1932 46 from from IN 13433 1932 47 Papias Papias NNP 13433 1932 48 ' ' POS 13433 1932 49 _ _ NNP 13433 1932 50 Exposition Exposition NNP 13433 1932 51 _ _ NNP 13433 1932 52 . . . 13433 1932 53 " " '' 13433 1933 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1933 2 4:4 4:4 CD 13433 1933 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1933 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1933 5 Reliq Reliq NNP 13433 1933 6 . . . 13433 1934 1 Sacrae Sacrae NNP 13433 1934 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1934 3 , , , 13433 1934 4 i. i. NNP 13433 1934 5 p. p. NN 13433 1934 6 10 10 CD 13433 1934 7 f. f. NNP 13433 1934 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1934 9 4:5 4:5 CD 13433 1934 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1934 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1934 12 Lehre Lehre NNP 13433 1934 13 Pers Pers NNP 13433 1934 14 . . . 13433 1935 1 Christ Christ NNP 13433 1935 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1935 3 , , , 13433 1935 4 i. i. NNP 13433 1935 5 p. p. NN 13433 1935 6 217 217 CD 13433 1935 7 f. f. NNS 13433 1935 8 , , , 13433 1935 9 Anm Anm NNP 13433 1935 10 . . . 13433 1936 1 56 56 CD 13433 1936 2 , , , 13433 1936 3 p. p. NN 13433 1936 4 218 218 CD 13433 1936 5 , , , 13433 1936 6 Anm Anm NNP 13433 1936 7 , , , 13433 1936 8 62 62 CD 13433 1936 9 . . . 13433 1937 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1937 2 5:1 5:1 CD 13433 1937 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1937 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1937 5 Theol Theol NNP 13433 1937 6 . . . 13433 1938 1 Jahrb Jahrb NNP 13433 1938 2 . . . 13433 1939 1 _ _ NNP 13433 1939 2 1845 1845 CD 13433 1939 3 , , , 13433 1939 4 p. p. NN 13433 1939 5 593 593 CD 13433 1939 6 , , , 13433 1939 7 Anm anm NN 13433 1939 8 . . . 13433 1940 1 2 2 LS 13433 1940 2 ; ; : 13433 1940 3 cf cf NN 13433 1940 4 . . . 13433 1941 1 1847 1847 CD 13433 1941 2 , , , 13433 1941 3 p. p. NN 13433 1941 4 160 160 CD 13433 1941 5 , , , 13433 1941 6 Anm anm NN 13433 1941 7 . . . 13433 1942 1 1 1 LS 13433 1942 2 . . . 13433 1943 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1943 2 5:2 5:2 LS 13433 1943 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1943 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1943 5 Synops Synops NNPS 13433 1943 6 . . . 13433 1944 1 Evang Evang NNP 13433 1944 2 . . . 13433 1944 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1944 4 , , , 13433 1944 5 Proleg Proleg NNP 13433 1944 6 . . . 13433 1945 1 xxxi xxxi NNP 13433 1945 2 . . . 13433 1946 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1946 2 5:3 5:3 NN 13433 1946 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1946 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1946 5 Komm Komm NNP 13433 1946 6 . . . 13433 1947 1 Ev Ev NNP 13433 1947 2 . . . 13433 1948 1 des des NNP 13433 1948 2 Johannes Johannes NNP 13433 1948 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1948 4 , , , 13433 1948 5 p. p. NN 13433 1948 6 6 6 CD 13433 1948 7 f. f. NNP 13433 1948 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1948 9 5:4 5:4 CD 13433 1948 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1948 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1948 12 Die Die NNP 13433 1948 13 Zeugn Zeugn NNP 13433 1948 14 . . . 13433 1949 1 Ev Ev NNP 13433 1949 2 . . . 13433 1950 1 Joh Joh NNP 13433 1950 2 . . NNP 13433 1950 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1950 4 p. p. NN 13433 1950 5 116 116 CD 13433 1950 6 f. f. NNP 13433 1950 7 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1950 8 5:5 5:5 CD 13433 1950 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1950 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1950 11 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 1950 12 _ _ NNP 13433 1950 13 , , , 13433 1950 14 p. p. NN 13433 1950 15 110 110 CD 13433 1950 16 f. f. NNS 13433 1950 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1950 18 5:6 5:6 NNP 13433 1950 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1950 20 _ _ NNP 13433 1950 21 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 1950 22 . . . 13433 1951 1 für für NNP 13433 1951 2 wiss wiss NNP 13433 1951 3 . . . 13433 1952 1 Theol Theol NNP 13433 1952 2 . . . 13433 1952 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1952 4 1867 1867 CD 13433 1952 5 , , , 13433 1952 6 p. p. NN 13433 1952 7 186 186 CD 13433 1952 8 , , , 13433 1952 9 Anm anm CC 13433 1952 10 . . . 13433 1953 1 1 1 CD 13433 1953 2 , , , 13433 1953 3 1868 1868 CD 13433 1953 4 , , , 13433 1953 5 p. p. NN 13433 1953 6 219 219 CD 13433 1953 7 , , , 13433 1953 8 Anm anm CC 13433 1953 9 . . . 13433 1954 1 4 4 LS 13433 1954 2 ; ; : 13433 1954 3 cf cf NN 13433 1954 4 . . . 13433 1955 1 1865 1865 CD 13433 1955 2 , , , 13433 1955 3 p. p. NN 13433 1955 4 334 334 CD 13433 1955 5 f. f. NN 13433 1955 6 , , , 13433 1955 7 " " '' 13433 1955 8 Die Die NNP 13433 1955 9 Evangelien Evangelien NNP 13433 1955 10 , , , 13433 1955 11 " " '' 13433 1955 12 p. p. NN 13433 1955 13 339 339 CD 13433 1955 14 , , , 13433 1955 15 Anm anm CC 13433 1955 16 . . . 13433 1956 1 4 4 LS 13433 1956 2 . . . 13433 1957 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1957 2 6:1 6:1 CD 13433 1957 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1957 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1957 5 Der Der NNP 13433 1957 6 Johann Johann NNP 13433 1957 7 . . . 13433 1958 1 Ursprung ursprung JJ 13433 1958 2 des des NNP 13433 1958 3 viert viert NN 13433 1958 4 . . . 13433 1959 1 Evang Evang NNP 13433 1959 2 . . . 13433 1959 3 _ _ NNP 13433 1959 4 1874 1874 CD 13433 1959 5 , , , 13433 1959 6 p. p. NN 13433 1959 7 72 72 CD 13433 1959 8 . . . 13433 1960 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1960 2 6:2 6:2 CD 13433 1960 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1960 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1960 5 Th Th NNP 13433 1960 6 . . . 13433 1961 1 Stud Stud NNP 13433 1961 2 . . . 13433 1962 1 u. u. NNP 13433 1962 2 Krit Krit NNP 13433 1962 3 . . . 13433 1962 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1962 5 1866 1866 CD 13433 1962 6 , , , 13433 1962 7 p. p. NN 13433 1962 8 674 674 CD 13433 1962 9 . . . 13433 1963 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1963 2 6:3 6:3 CD 13433 1963 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1963 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1963 5 Intro Intro NNP 13433 1963 6 . . . 13433 1964 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1964 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1964 3 ii ii NNP 13433 1964 4 . . . 13433 1965 1 p. p. NN 13433 1965 2 424 424 CD 13433 1965 3 f. f. NNP 13433 1965 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1965 5 6:4 6:4 CD 13433 1965 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1965 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1965 8 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 1965 9 . . . 13433 1965 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1965 11 ii ii NNP 13433 1965 12 . . . 13433 1966 1 p. p. NN 13433 1966 2 372 372 CD 13433 1966 3 . . . 13433 1967 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1967 2 8:1 8:1 LS 13433 1967 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1967 4 The the DT 13433 1967 5 work work NN 13433 1967 6 was be VBD 13433 1967 7 all all RB 13433 1967 8 printed print VBN 13433 1967 9 , , , 13433 1967 10 and and CC 13433 1967 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1967 12 could could MD 13433 1967 13 only only RB 13433 1967 14 reprint reprint VB 13433 1967 15 the the DT 13433 1967 16 sheet sheet NN 13433 1967 17 with with IN 13433 1967 18 such such JJ 13433 1967 19 alterations alteration NNS 13433 1967 20 as as IN 13433 1967 21 could could MD 13433 1967 22 be be VB 13433 1967 23 made make VBN 13433 1967 24 by by IN 13433 1967 25 omissions omission NNS 13433 1967 26 and and CC 13433 1967 27 changes change NNS 13433 1967 28 at at IN 13433 1967 29 the the DT 13433 1967 30 part part NN 13433 1967 31 itself -PRON- PRP 13433 1967 32 . . . 13433 1968 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1968 2 8:2 8:2 CD 13433 1968 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1968 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1968 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1968 6 makes make VBZ 13433 1968 7 use use NN 13433 1968 8 of of IN 13433 1968 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1968 10 second second JJ 13433 1968 11 edition edition NN 13433 1968 12 . . . 13433 1969 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1969 2 9:1 9:1 CD 13433 1969 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1969 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1969 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 1969 6 Review Review NNP 13433 1969 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1969 8 , , , 13433 1969 9 December December NNP 13433 1969 10 , , , 13433 1969 11 p. p. NN 13433 1969 12 4 4 CD 13433 1969 13 , , , 13433 1969 14 n. n. NNP 13433 1969 15 1 1 CD 13433 1969 16 ; ; : 13433 1969 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1969 18 Essays Essays NNP 13433 1969 19 on on IN 13433 1969 20 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1969 21 _ _ NNP 13433 1969 22 p. p. NN 13433 1969 23 4 4 CD 13433 1969 24 , , , 13433 1969 25 n. n. NNP 13433 1969 26 4 4 CD 13433 1969 27 . . . 13433 1970 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1970 2 9:2 9:2 CD 13433 1970 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1970 4 Professor Professor NNP 13433 1970 5 Hofstede Hofstede NNP 13433 1970 6 de de NNP 13433 1970 7 Groot Groot NNP 13433 1970 8 , , , 13433 1970 9 in in IN 13433 1970 10 advancing advance VBG 13433 1970 11 this this DT 13433 1970 12 passage passage NN 13433 1970 13 after after IN 13433 1970 14 the the DT 13433 1970 15 example example NN 13433 1970 16 of of IN 13433 1970 17 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 1970 18 , , , 13433 1970 19 carefully carefully RB 13433 1970 20 distinguishes distinguish VBZ 13433 1970 21 the the DT 13433 1970 22 words word NNS 13433 1970 23 which which WDT 13433 1970 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1970 25 introduces introduce VBZ 13433 1970 26 , , , 13433 1970 27 referring refer VBG 13433 1970 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 1970 29 to to IN 13433 1970 30 the the DT 13433 1970 31 presbyters presbyter NNS 13433 1970 32 , , , 13433 1970 33 by by IN 13433 1970 34 placing place VBG 13433 1970 35 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1970 36 within within IN 13433 1970 37 brackets bracket NNS 13433 1970 38 . . . 13433 1971 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1971 2 10:1 10:1 CD 13433 1971 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1971 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1971 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1971 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1971 7 ii ii NNP 13433 1971 8 . . . 13433 1972 1 p. p. NN 13433 1972 2 231 231 CD 13433 1972 3 f. f. NNS 13433 1972 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1972 5 10:2 10:2 CD 13433 1972 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1972 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1972 8 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 1972 9 Review Review NNP 13433 1972 10 _ _ NNP 13433 1972 11 , , , 13433 1972 12 December December NNP 13433 1972 13 , , , 13433 1972 14 p. p. NN 13433 1972 15 5 5 CD 13433 1972 16 f. f. NNS 13433 1972 17 ; ; : 13433 1972 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1972 19 Essays Essays NNP 13433 1972 20 on on IN 13433 1972 21 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1972 22 _ _ NNP 13433 1972 23 p. p. NN 13433 1972 24 7 7 CD 13433 1972 25 . . . 13433 1973 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1973 2 10:3 10:3 CD 13433 1973 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1973 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1973 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1973 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1973 7 ii ii NNP 13433 1973 8 . . . 13433 1974 1 228 228 CD 13433 1974 2 ff ff NNS 13433 1974 3 . . . 13433 1975 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1975 2 11:1 11:1 CD 13433 1975 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1975 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1975 5 Wann Wann NNP 13433 1975 6 wurden wurden VBD 13433 1975 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1975 8 , , , 13433 1975 9 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 1975 10 . . NNP 13433 1975 11 , , , 13433 1975 12 p. p. NN 13433 1975 13 73 73 CD 13433 1975 14 f. f. NNS 13433 1975 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1975 16 11:2 11:2 CD 13433 1975 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1975 18 The the DT 13433 1975 19 translation translation NN 13433 1975 20 in in IN 13433 1975 21 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1975 22 's 's POS 13433 1975 23 work work NN 13433 1975 24 is be VBZ 13433 1975 25 substantially substantially RB 13433 1975 26 the the DT 13433 1975 27 same same JJ 13433 1975 28 as as IN 13433 1975 29 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 1975 30 's 's POS 13433 1975 31 , , , 13433 1975 32 except except IN 13433 1975 33 that that IN 13433 1975 34 he -PRON- PRP 13433 1975 35 has have VBZ 13433 1975 36 " " `` 13433 1975 37 promises promise NNS 13433 1975 38 " " '' 13433 1975 39 for for IN 13433 1975 40 " " `` 13433 1975 41 has have VBZ 13433 1975 42 promised promise VBN 13433 1975 43 , , , 13433 1975 44 " " '' 13433 1975 45 which which WDT 13433 1975 46 is be VBZ 13433 1975 47 of of IN 13433 1975 48 no no DT 13433 1975 49 importance importance NN 13433 1975 50 . . . 13433 1976 1 Upon upon IN 13433 1976 2 this this DT 13433 1976 3 , , , 13433 1976 4 however however RB 13433 1976 5 , , , 13433 1976 6 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 1976 7 argues argue VBZ 13433 1976 8 that that IN 13433 1976 9 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 1976 10 is be VBZ 13433 1976 11 treated treat VBN 13433 1976 12 as as IN 13433 1976 13 a a DT 13433 1976 14 contemporary contemporary NN 13433 1976 15 . . . 13433 1977 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1977 2 12:1 12:1 CD 13433 1977 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1977 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1977 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1977 6 _ _ NNP 13433 1977 7 ii ii NNP 13433 1977 8 . . . 13433 1978 1 p. p. NN 13433 1978 2 229 229 CD 13433 1978 3 ff ff NN 13433 1978 4 . . . 13433 1979 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1979 2 13:1 13:1 CD 13433 1979 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1979 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1979 5 may may MD 13433 1979 6 here here RB 13433 1979 7 briefly briefly RB 13433 1979 8 refer refer VB 13433 1979 9 to to IN 13433 1979 10 one one CD 13433 1979 11 or or CC 13433 1979 12 two two CD 13433 1979 13 instances instance NNS 13433 1979 14 of of IN 13433 1979 15 translation translation NN 13433 1979 16 attacked attack VBN 13433 1979 17 by by IN 13433 1979 18 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1979 19 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1979 20 . . . 13433 1980 1 He -PRON- PRP 13433 1980 2 sneers sneer VBZ 13433 1980 3 at at IN 13433 1980 4 such such PDT 13433 1980 5 a a DT 13433 1980 6 rendering rendering NN 13433 1980 7 as as IN 13433 1980 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1980 9 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1980 10 : : : 13433 1980 11 ho ho XX 13433 1980 12 logos logos NNP 13433 1980 13 edêlou edêlou NNP 13433 1980 14 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1980 15 , , , 13433 1980 16 " " `` 13433 1980 17 Scripture scripture NN 13433 1980 18 declares declare VBZ 13433 1980 19 , , , 13433 1980 20 " " `` 13433 1980 21 introducing introduce VBG 13433 1980 22 an an DT 13433 1980 23 isolated isolated JJ 13433 1980 24 phrase phrase NN 13433 1980 25 from from IN 13433 1980 26 Justin Justin NNP 13433 1980 27 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 1980 28 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1980 29 ii ii UH 13433 1980 30 . . . 13433 1981 1 296 296 CD 13433 1981 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1981 3 . . . 13433 1982 1 The the DT 13433 1982 2 slight slight JJ 13433 1982 3 liberty liberty NN 13433 1982 4 taken take VBN 13433 1982 5 with with IN 13433 1982 6 the the DT 13433 1982 7 tense tense NN 13433 1982 8 is be VBZ 13433 1982 9 surely surely RB 13433 1982 10 excusable excusable JJ 13433 1982 11 in in IN 13433 1982 12 such such PDT 13433 1982 13 a a DT 13433 1982 14 case case NN 13433 1982 15 , , , 13433 1982 16 and and CC 13433 1982 17 for for IN 13433 1982 18 the the DT 13433 1982 19 rest rest NN 13433 1982 20 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1982 21 may may MD 13433 1982 22 point point VB 13433 1982 23 out out RP 13433 1982 24 that that IN 13433 1982 25 Prudentius Prudentius NNP 13433 1982 26 Maranus Maranus NNP 13433 1982 27 renders render VBZ 13433 1982 28 the the DT 13433 1982 29 words word NNS 13433 1982 30 " " `` 13433 1982 31 ... ... : 13433 1982 32 scripturam scripturam NNP 13433 1982 33 declarare declarare NNP 13433 1982 34 , , , 13433 1982 35 " " '' 13433 1982 36 and and CC 13433 1982 37 Otto Otto NNP 13433 1982 38 " " '' 13433 1982 39 ... ... : 13433 1982 40 effatum effatum NNP 13433 1982 41 declarare declarare NN 13433 1982 42 . . . 13433 1982 43 " " '' 13433 1983 1 They -PRON- PRP 13433 1983 2 occur occur VBP 13433 1983 3 in in IN 13433 1983 4 reference reference NN 13433 1983 5 to to IN 13433 1983 6 passages passage NNS 13433 1983 7 from from IN 13433 1983 8 the the DT 13433 1983 9 Old Old NNP 13433 1983 10 Testament Testament NNP 13433 1983 11 quoted quote VBD 13433 1983 12 in in IN 13433 1983 13 controversy controversy NN 13433 1983 14 with with IN 13433 1983 15 a a DT 13433 1983 16 Jew Jew NNP 13433 1983 17 . . . 13433 1984 1 The the DT 13433 1984 2 next next JJ 13433 1984 3 passage passage NN 13433 1984 4 is be VBZ 13433 1984 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1984 6 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1984 7 : : : 13433 1984 8 kata kata NNP 13433 1984 9 korrhês korrhês NNP 13433 1984 10 propêlakizein propêlakizein NNP 13433 1984 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1984 12 , , , 13433 1984 13 which which WDT 13433 1984 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1984 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1984 16 says say VBZ 13433 1984 17 is be VBZ 13433 1984 18 rendered render VBN 13433 1984 19 " " `` 13433 1984 20 to to TO 13433 1984 21 inflict inflict VB 13433 1984 22 a a DT 13433 1984 23 blow blow NN 13433 1984 24 on on IN 13433 1984 25 one one CD 13433 1984 26 side side NN 13433 1984 27 , , , 13433 1984 28 " " '' 13433 1984 29 but but CC 13433 1984 30 this this DT 13433 1984 31 is be VBZ 13433 1984 32 not not RB 13433 1984 33 the the DT 13433 1984 34 case case NN 13433 1984 35 . . . 13433 1985 1 The the DT 13433 1985 2 phrase phrase NN 13433 1985 3 occurs occur VBZ 13433 1985 4 in in IN 13433 1985 5 contrasting contrast VBG 13433 1985 6 the the DT 13433 1985 7 words word NNS 13433 1985 8 of of IN 13433 1985 9 Matt Matt NNP 13433 1985 10 . . . 13433 1986 1 v. v. CC 13433 1986 2 39 39 CD 13433 1986 3 , , , 13433 1986 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1986 5 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1986 6 : : : 13433 1986 7 all all DT 13433 1986 8 ' ' '' 13433 1986 9 hostis hostis VB 13433 1986 10 se se NNP 13433 1986 11 rhapisei rhapisei NNP 13433 1986 12 epi epi NNP 13433 1986 13 tên tên NNP 13433 1986 14 dexian dexian NNP 13433 1986 15 sou sou NNP 13433 1986 16 siagona siagona NNP 13433 1986 17 , , , 13433 1986 18 strepson strepson NNP 13433 1986 19 autô autô NNP 13433 1986 20 kai kai NNP 13433 1986 21 tên tên NNP 13433 1986 22 allên allên NNP 13433 1986 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1986 24 , , , 13433 1986 25 with with IN 13433 1986 26 a a DT 13433 1986 27 passage passage NN 13433 1986 28 in in IN 13433 1986 29 Athenagoras Athenagoras NNP 13433 1986 30 , , , 13433 1986 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1986 32 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1986 33 : : : 13433 1986 34 alla alla NN 13433 1986 35 tois tois NNP 13433 1986 36 men man NNS 13433 1986 37 kan kan NNP 13433 1986 38 kata kata NNP 13433 1986 39 korrhês korrhês NNP 13433 1986 40 prospêlakizosi prospêlakizosi NNP 13433 1986 41 , , , 13433 1986 42 kai kai NNP 13433 1986 43 to to IN 13433 1986 44 eteron eteron NNP 13433 1986 45 paiein paiein NNP 13433 1986 46 parechein parechein NNP 13433 1986 47 tês tês NNP 13433 1986 48 kephalês kephalês NNP 13433 1986 49 meros meros NNP 13433 1986 50 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1986 51 . . . 13433 1987 1 In in IN 13433 1987 2 endeavouring endeavour VBG 13433 1987 3 to to TO 13433 1987 4 convey convey VB 13433 1987 5 to to IN 13433 1987 6 the the DT 13433 1987 7 English english JJ 13433 1987 8 reader reader NN 13433 1987 9 some some DT 13433 1987 10 idea idea NN 13433 1987 11 of of IN 13433 1987 12 the the DT 13433 1987 13 linguistic linguistic JJ 13433 1987 14 difference difference NN 13433 1987 15 , , , 13433 1987 16 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1987 17 rendered render VBD 13433 1987 18 the the DT 13433 1987 19 latter latter JJ 13433 1987 20 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1987 21 ii ii UH 13433 1987 22 . . . 13433 1988 1 193 193 CD 13433 1988 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1988 3 , , , 13433 1988 4 " " '' 13433 1988 5 but but CC 13433 1988 6 to to IN 13433 1988 7 those those DT 13433 1988 8 who who WP 13433 1988 9 inflict inflict VBP 13433 1988 10 a a DT 13433 1988 11 blow blow NN 13433 1988 12 on on IN 13433 1988 13 the the DT 13433 1988 14 one one CD 13433 1988 15 side side NN 13433 1988 16 , , , 13433 1988 17 also also RB 13433 1988 18 to to TO 13433 1988 19 present present VB 13433 1988 20 the the DT 13433 1988 21 other other JJ 13433 1988 22 side side NN 13433 1988 23 , , , 13433 1988 24 _ _ NNP 13433 1988 25 of of IN 13433 1988 26 the the DT 13433 1988 27 head head NN 13433 1988 28 _ _ NNP 13433 1988 29 , , , 13433 1988 30 " " '' 13433 1988 31 & & CC 13433 1988 32 c. c. NNP 13433 1988 33 , , , 13433 1988 34 inserting insert VBG 13433 1988 35 the the DT 13433 1988 36 three three CD 13433 1988 37 Greek greek JJ 13433 1988 38 words word NNS 13433 1988 39 after after IN 13433 1988 40 " " `` 13433 1988 41 side side NN 13433 1988 42 , , , 13433 1988 43 " " '' 13433 1988 44 to to TO 13433 1988 45 explain explain VB 13433 1988 46 the the DT 13433 1988 47 suspension suspension NN 13433 1988 48 of of IN 13433 1988 49 sense sense NN 13433 1988 50 , , , 13433 1988 51 and and CC 13433 1988 52 the the DT 13433 1988 53 merging merging NN 13433 1988 54 , , , 13433 1988 55 for for IN 13433 1988 56 the the DT 13433 1988 57 sake sake NN 13433 1988 58 of of IN 13433 1988 59 brevity brevity NN 13433 1988 60 , , , 13433 1988 61 the the DT 13433 1988 62 double double JJ 13433 1988 63 expression expression NN 13433 1988 64 in in IN 13433 1988 65 the the DT 13433 1988 66 words word NNS 13433 1988 67 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1988 68 have have VBP 13433 1988 69 italicised italicise VBN 13433 1988 70 . . . 13433 1989 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1989 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1989 3 represents represent VBZ 13433 1989 4 the the DT 13433 1989 5 phrase phrase NN 13433 1989 6 as as IN 13433 1989 7 ending end VBG 13433 1989 8 at at IN 13433 1989 9 " " `` 13433 1989 10 side side NN 13433 1989 11 . . . 13433 1989 12 " " '' 13433 1990 1 The the DT 13433 1990 2 passage passage NN 13433 1990 3 from from IN 13433 1990 4 Tertullian Tertullian NNP 13433 1990 5 was be VBD 13433 1990 6 quoted quote VBN 13433 1990 7 almost almost RB 13433 1990 8 solely solely RB 13433 1990 9 for for IN 13433 1990 10 the the DT 13433 1990 11 purpose purpose NN 13433 1990 12 of of IN 13433 1990 13 showing show VBG 13433 1990 14 the the DT 13433 1990 15 uncertainty uncertainty NN 13433 1990 16 , , , 13433 1990 17 in in IN 13433 1990 18 so so RB 13433 1990 19 bold bold JJ 13433 1990 20 a a DT 13433 1990 21 writer writer NN 13433 1990 22 , , , 13433 1990 23 of of IN 13433 1990 24 the the DT 13433 1990 25 expression expression NN 13433 1990 26 " " `` 13433 1990 27 videtur videtur NNP 13433 1990 28 , , , 13433 1990 29 " " '' 13433 1990 30 for for IN 13433 1990 31 which which WDT 13433 1990 32 reason reason NN 13433 1990 33 , , , 13433 1990 34 although although IN 13433 1990 35 the the DT 13433 1990 36 Latin Latin NNP 13433 1990 37 is be VBZ 13433 1990 38 given give VBN 13433 1990 39 below below RB 13433 1990 40 , , , 13433 1990 41 the the DT 13433 1990 42 word word NN 13433 1990 43 was be VBD 13433 1990 44 introduced introduce VBN 13433 1990 45 into into IN 13433 1990 46 the the DT 13433 1990 47 text text NN 13433 1990 48 . . . 13433 1991 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 1991 2 was be VBD 13433 1991 3 impossible impossible JJ 13433 1991 4 for for IN 13433 1991 5 anyone anyone NN 13433 1991 6 to to IN 13433 1991 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1991 8 mistake mistake NN 13433 1991 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1991 10 the the DT 13433 1991 11 tense tense NN 13433 1991 12 and and CC 13433 1991 13 meaning meaning NN 13433 1991 14 of of IN 13433 1991 15 " " `` 13433 1991 16 quem quem NNP 13433 1991 17 caederet caederet NNP 13433 1991 18 , , , 13433 1991 19 " " '' 13433 1991 20 but but CC 13433 1991 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1991 22 ventured venture VBD 13433 1991 23 to to TO 13433 1991 24 paraphrase paraphrase VB 13433 1991 25 the the DT 13433 1991 26 words word NNS 13433 1991 27 and and CC 13433 1991 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1991 29 context context NN 13433 1991 30 , , , 13433 1991 31 instead instead RB 13433 1991 32 of of IN 13433 1991 33 translating translate VBG 13433 1991 34 them -PRON- PRP 13433 1991 35 . . . 13433 1992 1 In in IN 13433 1992 2 this this DT 13433 1992 3 sentence sentence NN 13433 1992 4 , , , 13433 1992 5 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1992 6 may may MD 13433 1992 7 say say VB 13433 1992 8 , , , 13433 1992 9 the the DT 13433 1992 10 " " `` 13433 1992 11 mutilation mutilation NN 13433 1992 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN 13433 1992 13 " " '' 13433 1992 14 is be VBZ 13433 1992 15 introduced introduce VBN 13433 1992 16 , , , 13433 1992 17 and and CC 13433 1992 18 thereafter thereafter RB 13433 1992 19 Tertullian tertullian JJ 13433 1992 20 proceeds proceed VBZ 13433 1992 21 to to IN 13433 1992 22 press press NN 13433 1992 23 against against IN 13433 1992 24 Marcion Marcion NNP 13433 1992 25 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1992 26 charge charge NN 13433 1992 27 of of IN 13433 1992 28 mutilating mutilate VBG 13433 1992 29 the the DT 13433 1992 30 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 1992 31 of of IN 13433 1992 32 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1992 33 , , , 13433 1992 34 and and CC 13433 1992 35 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1992 36 desired desire VBD 13433 1992 37 to to TO 13433 1992 38 contrast contrast VB 13433 1992 39 the the DT 13433 1992 40 doubt doubt NN 13433 1992 41 of of IN 13433 1992 42 the the DT 13433 1992 43 " " `` 13433 1992 44 videtur videtur NNP 13433 1992 45 " " '' 13433 1992 46 with with IN 13433 1992 47 the the DT 13433 1992 48 assurance assurance NN 13433 1992 49 of of IN 13433 1992 50 the the DT 13433 1992 51 subsequent subsequent JJ 13433 1992 52 charge charge NN 13433 1992 53 . . . 13433 1993 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1993 2 had have VBD 13433 1993 3 imagined imagine VBN 13433 1993 4 that that IN 13433 1993 5 no no DT 13433 1993 6 one one PRP 13433 1993 7 could could MD 13433 1993 8 have have VB 13433 1993 9 doubted doubt VBN 13433 1993 10 that that IN 13433 1993 11 Luke Luke NNP 13433 1993 12 is be VBZ 13433 1993 13 represented represent VBN 13433 1993 14 as as IN 13433 1993 15 one one CD 13433 1993 16 of of IN 13433 1993 17 the the DT 13433 1993 18 " " `` 13433 1993 19 Commentatores Commentatores NNPS 13433 1993 20 . . . 13433 1993 21 " " '' 13433 1994 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1994 2 14:1 14:1 CD 13433 1994 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1994 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1994 5 altered alter VBD 13433 1994 6 " " `` 13433 1994 7 certainly certainly RB 13433 1994 8 " " '' 13433 1994 9 to to TO 13433 1994 10 " " `` 13433 1994 11 probably probably RB 13433 1994 12 " " '' 13433 1994 13 in in IN 13433 1994 14 the the DT 13433 1994 15 second second JJ 13433 1994 16 edition edition NN 13433 1994 17 , , , 13433 1994 18 as as IN 13433 1994 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1994 20 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1994 21 points point VBZ 13433 1994 22 out out RP 13433 1994 23 , , , 13433 1994 24 in in IN 13433 1994 25 order order NN 13433 1994 26 to to TO 13433 1994 27 avoid avoid VB 13433 1994 28 the the DT 13433 1994 29 possibility possibility NN 13433 1994 30 of of IN 13433 1994 31 exaggeration exaggeration NN 13433 1994 32 ; ; : 13433 1994 33 but but CC 13433 1994 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1994 35 mind mind NN 13433 1994 36 was be VBD 13433 1994 37 so so RB 13433 1994 38 impressed impressed JJ 13433 1994 39 with with IN 13433 1994 40 the the DT 13433 1994 41 certainty certainty NN 13433 1994 42 that that WDT 13433 1994 43 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1994 44 had have VBD 13433 1994 45 clearly clearly RB 13433 1994 46 shown show VBN 13433 1994 47 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1994 48 was be VBD 13433 1994 49 merely merely RB 13433 1994 50 , , , 13433 1994 51 for for IN 13433 1994 52 the the DT 13433 1994 53 sake sake NN 13433 1994 54 of of IN 13433 1994 55 fairness fairness NN 13433 1994 56 , , , 13433 1994 57 reporting report VBG 13433 1994 58 the the DT 13433 1994 59 critical critical JJ 13433 1994 60 judgment judgment NN 13433 1994 61 of of IN 13433 1994 62 others other NNS 13433 1994 63 , , , 13433 1994 64 that that IN 13433 1994 65 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1994 66 did do VBD 13433 1994 67 not not RB 13433 1994 68 perceive perceive VB 13433 1994 69 the the DT 13433 1994 70 absence absence NN 13433 1994 71 of of IN 13433 1994 72 the the DT 13433 1994 73 words word NNS 13433 1994 74 given give VBN 13433 1994 75 above above RB 13433 1994 76 . . . 13433 1995 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1995 2 15:1 15:1 CD 13433 1995 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1995 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 1995 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 1995 6 is be VBZ 13433 1995 7 mistaken mistaken JJ 13433 1995 8 in in IN 13433 1995 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1995 10 ingenious ingenious JJ 13433 1995 11 conjecture conjecture NN 13433 1995 12 of of IN 13433 1995 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 1995 14 having have VBG 13433 1995 15 been be VBN 13433 1995 16 misled mislead VBN 13433 1995 17 by by IN 13433 1995 18 the the DT 13433 1995 19 " " `` 13433 1995 20 nur nur NN 13433 1995 21 " " '' 13433 1995 22 of of IN 13433 1995 23 Credner Credner NNP 13433 1995 24 ; ; : 13433 1995 25 but but CC 13433 1995 26 so so RB 13433 1995 27 scrupulous scrupulous JJ 13433 1995 28 a a DT 13433 1995 29 critic critic NN 13433 1995 30 might may MD 13433 1995 31 have have VB 13433 1995 32 mentioned mention VBN 13433 1995 33 that that IN 13433 1995 34 I -PRON- PRP 13433 1995 35 not not RB 13433 1995 36 only only RB 13433 1995 37 refer refer VBP 13433 1995 38 to to IN 13433 1995 39 Credner Credner NNP 13433 1995 40 for for IN 13433 1995 41 this this DT 13433 1995 42 argument argument NN 13433 1995 43 , , , 13433 1995 44 but but CC 13433 1995 45 also also RB 13433 1995 46 to to IN 13433 1995 47 _ _ NNP 13433 1995 48 De De NNP 13433 1995 49 Wette Wette NNP 13433 1995 50 _ _ NNP 13433 1995 51 , , , 13433 1995 52 who who WP 13433 1995 53 has have VBZ 13433 1995 54 " " `` 13433 1995 55 ... ... NFP 13433 1995 56 dass dass NNP 13433 1995 57 er er NNP 13433 1995 58 _ _ NNP 13433 1995 59 nie nie NNP 13433 1995 60 _ _ NNP 13433 1995 61 Joh Joh NNP 13433 1995 62 . . . 13433 1996 1 dem dem NNP 13433 1996 2 Taüfer Taüfer NNP 13433 1996 3 wie wie NNP 13433 1996 4 der der IN 13433 1996 5 Synoptiker Synoptiker NNP 13433 1996 6 den den NN 13433 1996 7 Beinamen Beinamen NNP 13433 1996 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1996 9 Greek Greek NNP 13433 1996 10 : : : 13433 1996 11 ho ho NNP 13433 1996 12 Baptistês Baptistês NNP 13433 1996 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1996 14 giebt giebt NN 13433 1996 15 " " '' 13433 1996 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1996 17 _ _ NNP 13433 1996 18 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1996 19 . . . 13433 1997 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1997 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 3 p. p. NN 13433 1997 4 230 230 CD 13433 1997 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1997 6 , , , 13433 1997 7 and and CC 13433 1997 8 to to IN 13433 1997 9 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 10 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 1997 11 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 12 , , , 13433 1997 13 who who WP 13433 1997 14 says say VBZ 13433 1997 15 , , , 13433 1997 16 " " `` 13433 1997 17 nicht nicht NNP 13433 1997 18 ein ein NNP 13433 1997 19 einziges einzige VBZ 13433 1997 20 Mal Mal NNP 13433 1997 21 " " '' 13433 1997 22 ( ( -LRB- 13433 1997 23 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 24 Beiträge Beiträge NNP 13433 1997 25 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 26 , , , 13433 1997 27 p. p. NN 13433 1997 28 178 178 CD 13433 1997 29 , , , 13433 1997 30 and and CC 13433 1997 31 _ _ NNP 13433 1997 32 Einl Einl NNP 13433 1997 33 . . . 13433 1998 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 1998 2 _ _ NNP 13433 1998 3 p. p. NN 13433 1998 4 150 150 CD 13433 1998 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 1998 6 , , , 13433 1998 7 which which WDT 13433 1998 8 could could MD 13433 1998 9 not not RB 13433 1998 10 be be VB 13433 1998 11 misread misread JJ 13433 1998 12 . . . 13433 1999 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1999 2 16:1 16:1 CD 13433 1999 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1999 4 _ _ NNP 13433 1999 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 1999 6 Review Review NNP 13433 1999 7 _ _ NNP 13433 1999 8 , , , 13433 1999 9 December December NNP 13433 1999 10 , , , 13433 1999 11 p. p. NN 13433 1999 12 15 15 CD 13433 1999 13 ; ; : 13433 1999 14 _ _ NNP 13433 1999 15 Essays Essays NNP 13433 1999 16 on on IN 13433 1999 17 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 1999 18 _ _ NNP 13433 1999 19 p. p. NN 13433 1999 20 21 21 CD 13433 1999 21 f. f. NNS 13433 1999 22 [ [ -LRB- 13433 1999 23 16:2 16:2 CD 13433 1999 24 ] ] -RRB- 13433 1999 25 Clem Clem NNP 13433 1999 26 . . . 13433 2000 1 Alex Alex NNP 13433 2000 2 . . . 13433 2001 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2001 2 Strom Strom NNP 13433 2001 3 . . . 13433 2001 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2001 5 vii vii NN 13433 2001 6 . . . 13433 2002 1 17 17 CD 13433 2002 2 - - SYM 13433 2002 3 106 106 CD 13433 2002 4 . . . 13433 2003 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2003 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2003 3 gives give VBZ 13433 2003 4 the the DT 13433 2003 5 above above JJ 13433 2003 6 reference reference NN 13433 2003 7 , , , 13433 2003 8 but but CC 13433 2003 9 does do VBZ 13433 2003 10 not not RB 13433 2003 11 quote quote VB 13433 2003 12 the the DT 13433 2003 13 passage passage NN 13433 2003 14 . . . 13433 2004 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2004 2 16:3 16:3 CD 13433 2004 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2004 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2004 5 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2004 6 quotes quote VBZ 13433 2004 7 the the DT 13433 2004 8 passage passage NN 13433 2004 9 relative relative JJ 13433 2004 10 to to IN 13433 2004 11 Matthias Matthias NNP 13433 2004 12 . . . 13433 2005 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2005 2 17:1 17:1 CD 13433 2005 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2005 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2005 5 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2005 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2005 7 , , , 13433 2005 8 p. p. NN 13433 2005 9 255 255 CD 13433 2005 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2005 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2005 12 17:2 17:2 CD 13433 2005 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2005 14 The the DT 13433 2005 15 same same JJ 13433 2005 16 remarks remark NNS 13433 2005 17 apply apply VBP 13433 2005 18 to to IN 13433 2005 19 the the DT 13433 2005 20 two two CD 13433 2005 21 passages passage NNS 13433 2005 22 , , , 13433 2005 23 pointed point VBD 13433 2005 24 out out RP 13433 2005 25 by by IN 13433 2005 26 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 2005 27 , , , 13433 2005 28 from from IN 13433 2005 29 Clement Clement NNP 13433 2005 30 of of IN 13433 2005 31 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 2005 32 and and CC 13433 2005 33 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 13433 2005 34 . . . 13433 2006 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2006 2 18:1 18:1 CD 13433 2006 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2006 4 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 2006 5 , , , 13433 2006 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2006 7 Der Der NNP 13433 2006 8 Johann Johann NNP 13433 2006 9 . . . 13433 2007 1 Ursprung ursprung JJ 13433 2007 2 des des NNP 13433 2007 3 viert viert NN 13433 2007 4 . . . 13433 2008 1 Evang Evang NNP 13433 2008 2 . . . 13433 2008 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2008 4 1874 1874 CD 13433 2008 5 , , , 13433 2008 6 p. p. NN 13433 2008 7 85 85 CD 13433 2008 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2008 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2008 10 19:1 19:1 CD 13433 2008 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2008 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2008 13 Strom Strom NNP 13433 2008 14 . . . 13433 2008 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2008 16 vii vii NN 13433 2008 17 . . . 13433 2009 1 17 17 CD 13433 2009 2 , , , 13433 2009 3 § § CD 13433 2009 4 106 106 CD 13433 2009 5 . . . 13433 2010 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2010 2 19:2 19:2 CD 13433 2010 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2010 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2010 5 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2010 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2010 7 , , , 13433 2010 8 p. p. NN 13433 2010 9 255 255 CD 13433 2010 10 . . . 13433 2011 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2011 2 19:3 19:3 CD 13433 2011 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2011 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2011 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2011 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2011 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2011 8 , , , 13433 2011 9 December December NNP 13433 2011 10 , , , 13433 2011 11 p. p. NN 13433 2011 12 16 16 CD 13433 2011 13 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2011 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2011 15 Essays Essays NNP 13433 2011 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2011 17 , , , 13433 2011 18 p. p. NN 13433 2011 19 22 22 CD 13433 2011 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2011 21 . . . 13433 2012 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2012 2 20:1 20:1 CD 13433 2012 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2012 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2012 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2012 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2012 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2012 8 , , , 13433 2012 9 December December NNP 13433 2012 10 , , , 13433 2012 11 p. p. NN 13433 2012 12 8 8 CD 13433 2012 13 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2012 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2012 15 ibid ibid NN 13433 2012 16 . . . 13433 2012 17 _ _ NNP 13433 2012 18 p. p. NN 13433 2012 19 11 11 CD 13433 2012 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2012 21 . . . 13433 2013 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2013 2 21:1 21:1 CD 13433 2013 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2013 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2013 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2013 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2013 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2013 8 , , , 13433 2013 9 p. p. NN 13433 2013 10 8 8 CD 13433 2013 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2013 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2013 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2013 14 . . . 13433 2013 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2013 16 p. p. NN 13433 2013 17 11 11 CD 13433 2013 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2013 19 . . . 13433 2014 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2014 2 21:2 21:2 CD 13433 2014 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2014 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2014 5 A A NNP 13433 2014 6 Crit Crit NNP 13433 2014 7 . . . 13433 2015 1 History history NN 13433 2015 2 of of IN 13433 2015 3 Chr Chr NNP 13433 2015 4 . . . 13433 2016 1 Lit Lit NNP 13433 2016 2 . . . 13433 2017 1 and and CC 13433 2017 2 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 2017 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2017 4 , , , 13433 2017 5 i. i. NNP 13433 2018 1 184 184 CD 13433 2018 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2018 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2018 4 do do VBP 13433 2018 5 not not RB 13433 2018 6 refer refer VB 13433 2018 7 to to IN 13433 2018 8 the the DT 13433 2018 9 numerous numerous JJ 13433 2018 10 authors author NNS 13433 2018 11 who who WP 13433 2018 12 enforce enforce VBP 13433 2018 13 this this DT 13433 2018 14 view view NN 13433 2018 15 . . . 13433 2019 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2019 2 22:1 22:1 CD 13433 2019 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2019 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2019 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2019 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 8 , , , 13433 2019 9 p. p. NN 13433 2019 10 8 8 CD 13433 2019 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2019 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2019 14 . . . 13433 2019 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 16 p. p. NN 13433 2019 17 11 11 CD 13433 2019 18 f. f. NNP 13433 2019 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2019 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2019 21 23:1 23:1 CD 13433 2019 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2019 23 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 24 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2019 25 Review Review NNP 13433 2019 26 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 27 , , , 13433 2019 28 p. p. NN 13433 2019 29 8 8 CD 13433 2019 30 f. f. NNS 13433 2019 31 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2019 32 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 33 ibid ibid NN 13433 2019 34 . . . 13433 2019 35 _ _ NNP 13433 2019 36 p. p. NN 13433 2019 37 11 11 CD 13433 2019 38 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2019 39 . . . 13433 2020 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2020 2 23:2 23:2 CD 13433 2020 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2020 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2020 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2020 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2020 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2020 8 p. p. NN 13433 2020 9 441 441 CD 13433 2020 10 . . . 13433 2021 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2021 2 24:1 24:1 CD 13433 2021 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2021 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2021 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2021 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 8 , , , 13433 2021 9 p. p. NN 13433 2021 10 8 8 CD 13433 2021 11 f. f. NNS 13433 2021 12 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2021 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 14 ibid ibid NN 13433 2021 15 . . . 13433 2021 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 17 p. p. NN 13433 2021 18 12 12 CD 13433 2021 19 f. f. NN 13433 2021 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2021 21 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2021 22 24:2 24:2 CD 13433 2021 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2021 24 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 25 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2021 26 _ _ NNP 13433 2021 27 i. i. NNP 13433 2021 28 p. p. NN 13433 2021 29 387 387 CD 13433 2021 30 ff ff NN 13433 2021 31 . . . 13433 2022 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2022 2 24:3 24:3 CD 13433 2022 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2022 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 5 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2022 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 7 , , , 13433 2022 8 p. p. NN 13433 2022 9 112 112 CD 13433 2022 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2022 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2022 12 24:4 24:4 CD 13433 2022 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2022 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 15 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2022 16 Review Review NNP 13433 2022 17 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 18 , , , 13433 2022 19 p. p. NN 13433 2022 20 9 9 CD 13433 2022 21 , , , 13433 2022 22 note note VBP 13433 2022 23 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2022 24 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 25 ibid ibid NN 13433 2022 26 . . . 13433 2022 27 _ _ NNP 13433 2022 28 p. p. NN 13433 2022 29 12 12 CD 13433 2022 30 , , , 13433 2022 31 n. n. NNP 13433 2022 32 4 4 CD 13433 2022 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2022 34 . . . 13433 2023 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2023 2 24:5 24:5 CD 13433 2023 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2023 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2023 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2023 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2023 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2023 8 p. p. NN 13433 2023 9 360 360 CD 13433 2023 10 , , , 13433 2023 11 note note VBP 13433 2023 12 1 1 CD 13433 2023 13 . . . 13433 2024 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2024 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2024 3 , , , 13433 2024 4 of of IN 13433 2024 5 course course NN 13433 2024 6 , , , 13433 2024 7 " " '' 13433 2024 8 can can MD 13433 2024 9 hardly hardly RB 13433 2024 10 suppose suppose VB 13433 2024 11 " " '' 13433 2024 12 that that IN 13433 2024 13 " " `` 13433 2024 14 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2024 15 had have VBD 13433 2024 16 read read VBN 13433 2024 17 the the DT 13433 2024 18 passage passage NN 13433 2024 19 to to IN 13433 2024 20 which which WDT 13433 2024 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2024 22 refer refer VBP 13433 2024 23 . . . 13433 2024 24 " " '' 13433 2025 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2025 2 25:1 25:1 CD 13433 2025 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2025 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2025 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2025 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2025 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2025 8 , , , 13433 2025 9 p. p. NN 13433 2025 10 9 9 CD 13433 2025 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2025 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2025 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2025 14 . . . 13433 2025 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2025 16 p. p. NN 13433 2025 17 13 13 CD 13433 2025 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2025 19 . . . 13433 2026 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2026 2 26:1 26:1 CD 13433 2026 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2026 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2026 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2026 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2026 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2026 8 , , , 13433 2026 9 p. p. NN 13433 2026 10 9 9 CD 13433 2026 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2026 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2026 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2026 14 . . . 13433 2026 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2026 16 p. p. NN 13433 2026 17 13 13 CD 13433 2026 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2026 19 . . . 13433 2027 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2027 2 26:2 26:2 CD 13433 2027 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2027 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2027 5 can can MD 13433 2027 6 not not RB 13433 2027 7 go go VB 13433 2027 8 through through IN 13433 2027 9 every every DT 13433 2027 10 instance instance NN 13433 2027 11 , , , 13433 2027 12 but but CC 13433 2027 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2027 14 may may MD 13433 2027 15 briefly briefly RB 13433 2027 16 say say VB 13433 2027 17 that that IN 13433 2027 18 such such PDT 13433 2027 19 a a DT 13433 2027 20 passage passage NN 13433 2027 21 as as IN 13433 2027 22 " " `` 13433 2027 23 Ye Ye NNP 13433 2027 24 are be VBP 13433 2027 25 of of IN 13433 2027 26 your -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2027 27 father father NN 13433 2027 28 the the DT 13433 2027 29 devil devil NN 13433 2027 30 " " '' 13433 2027 31 and and CC 13433 2027 32 the the DT 13433 2027 33 passage passage NN 13433 2027 34 Matt Matt NNP 13433 2027 35 . . . 13433 2028 1 xi xi NNP 13433 2028 2 . . . 13433 2029 1 27 27 CD 13433 2029 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2029 3 seq seq NN 13433 2029 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2029 5 . . . 13433 2030 1 are be VBP 13433 2030 2 no no DT 13433 2030 3 refutation refutation NN 13433 2030 4 whatever whatever WDT 13433 2030 5 of of IN 13433 2030 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2030 7 statement statement NN 13433 2030 8 of of IN 13433 2030 9 the the DT 13433 2030 10 contrast contrast NN 13433 2030 11 between between IN 13433 2030 12 the the DT 13433 2030 13 fourth fourth JJ 13433 2030 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2030 15 and and CC 13433 2030 16 the the DT 13433 2030 17 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 2030 18 ; ; : 13433 2030 19 and and CC 13433 2030 20 that that IN 13433 2030 21 the the DT 13433 2030 22 allusion allusion NN 13433 2030 23 to to IN 13433 2030 24 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2030 25 's 's POS 13433 2030 26 teaching teaching NN 13433 2030 27 in in IN 13433 2030 28 the the DT 13433 2030 29 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2030 30 is be VBZ 13433 2030 31 in in IN 13433 2030 32 no no DT 13433 2030 33 way way NN 13433 2030 34 excluded exclude VBN 13433 2030 35 even even RB 13433 2030 36 by by IN 13433 2030 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2030 38 death death NN 13433 2030 39 . . . 13433 2031 1 Regarding regard VBG 13433 2031 2 the the DT 13433 2031 3 relations relation NNS 13433 2031 4 between between IN 13433 2031 5 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2031 6 and and CC 13433 2031 7 the the DT 13433 2031 8 " " `` 13433 2031 9 pillar pillar NN 13433 2031 10 " " '' 13433 2031 11 Apostles apostle NNS 13433 2031 12 , , , 13433 2031 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2031 14 hope hope VBP 13433 2031 15 to to TO 13433 2031 16 speak speak VB 13433 2031 17 hereafter hereafter RB 13433 2031 18 . . . 13433 2032 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2032 2 must must MD 13433 2032 3 maintain maintain VB 13433 2032 4 that that IN 13433 2032 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2032 6 argument argument NN 13433 2032 7 regarding regard VBG 13433 2032 8 the the DT 13433 2032 9 identification identification NN 13433 2032 10 of of IN 13433 2032 11 an an DT 13433 2032 12 eye eye NN 13433 2032 13 - - HYPH 13433 2032 14 witness witness NN 13433 2032 15 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2032 16 ii ii NNP 13433 2032 17 . . . 13433 2033 1 p. p. NN 13433 2033 2 444 444 CD 13433 2033 3 ff ff NN 13433 2033 4 . . . 13433 2033 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2034 1 sufficiently sufficiently RB 13433 2034 2 meets meet VBZ 13433 2034 3 the the DT 13433 2034 4 reasoning reasoning NN 13433 2034 5 to to TO 13433 2034 6 which which WDT 13433 2034 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2034 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2034 9 refers refer VBZ 13433 2034 10 . . . 13433 2035 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2035 2 27:1 27:1 CD 13433 2035 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2035 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2035 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2035 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2035 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2035 8 , , , 13433 2035 9 p. p. NN 13433 2035 10 11 11 CD 13433 2035 11 f. f. NNP 13433 2035 12 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2035 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2035 14 ibid ibid NN 13433 2035 15 . . . 13433 2035 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2035 17 p. p. NN 13433 2035 18 16 16 CD 13433 2035 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2035 20 . . . 13433 2036 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2036 2 27:2 27:2 CD 13433 2036 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2036 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2036 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2036 6 . . . 13433 2036 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2036 8 p. p. NN 13433 2036 9 10 10 CD 13433 2036 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2036 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2036 12 ibid ibid NN 13433 2036 13 . . . 13433 2036 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2036 15 p. p. NN 13433 2036 16 14 14 CD 13433 2036 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2036 18 . . . 13433 2037 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2037 2 28:1 28:1 CD 13433 2037 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2037 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2037 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2037 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2037 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2037 8 . . . 13433 2038 1 p. p. NN 13433 2038 2 402 402 CD 13433 2038 3 . . . 13433 2039 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2039 2 28:2 28:2 CD 13433 2039 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2039 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2039 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2039 6 . . . 13433 2039 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2039 8 ii ii NNP 13433 2039 9 . . . 13433 2040 1 p. p. NN 13433 2040 2 406 406 CD 13433 2040 3 . . . 13433 2041 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2041 2 28:3 28:3 CD 13433 2041 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2041 4 See see VB 13433 2041 5 Acts act NNS 13433 2041 6 iv iv IN 13433 2041 7 . . . 13433 2042 1 13 13 CD 13433 2042 2 . . . 13433 2043 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2043 2 28:4 28:4 CD 13433 2043 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2043 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2043 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2043 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2043 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2043 8 . . . 13433 2044 1 p. p. NN 13433 2044 2 410 410 CD 13433 2044 3 . . . 13433 2045 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2045 2 28:5 28:5 CD 13433 2045 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2045 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2045 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2045 6 . . . 13433 2045 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2045 8 ii ii NNP 13433 2045 9 , , , 13433 2045 10 p. p. NN 13433 2045 11 413 413 CD 13433 2045 12 . . . 13433 2046 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2046 2 29:1 29:1 CD 13433 2046 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2046 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2046 5 Der Der NNP 13433 2046 6 Johann Johann NNP 13433 2046 7 . . . 13433 2047 1 Ursp Ursp NNP 13433 2047 2 . . . 13433 2048 1 des des NNP 13433 2048 2 viert viert NNP 13433 2048 3 . . . 13433 2049 1 Evang Evang NNP 13433 2049 2 . . . 13433 2049 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2049 4 1874 1874 CD 13433 2049 5 , , , 13433 2049 6 pp pp NNP 13433 2049 7 . . . 13433 2050 1 204 204 CD 13433 2050 2 - - SYM 13433 2050 3 7 7 CD 13433 2050 4 . . . 13433 2051 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2051 2 29:2 29:2 CD 13433 2051 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2051 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2051 5 Einl Einl NNP 13433 2051 6 . . . 13433 2052 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2052 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2052 3 p. p. NN 13433 2052 4 625 625 CD 13433 2052 5 . . . 13433 2053 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2053 2 30:1 30:1 CD 13433 2053 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2053 4 In in IN 13433 2053 5 regard regard NN 13433 2053 6 to to IN 13433 2053 7 one one CD 13433 2053 8 other other JJ 13433 2053 9 point point NN 13433 2053 10 , , , 13433 2053 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2053 12 may may MD 13433 2053 13 say say VB 13433 2053 14 that that DT 13433 2053 15 , , , 13433 2053 16 so so RB 13433 2053 17 far far RB 13433 2053 18 from from IN 13433 2053 19 being be VBG 13433 2053 20 silent silent JJ 13433 2053 21 about about IN 13433 2053 22 the the DT 13433 2053 23 presence presence NN 13433 2053 24 of of IN 13433 2053 25 a a DT 13433 2053 26 form form NN 13433 2053 27 of of IN 13433 2053 28 the the DT 13433 2053 29 Logos Logos NNP 13433 2053 30 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 2053 31 in in IN 13433 2053 32 the the DT 13433 2053 33 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2053 34 with with IN 13433 2053 35 which which WDT 13433 2053 36 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2053 37 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2053 38 reproaches reproach VBZ 13433 2053 39 me -PRON- PRP 13433 2053 40 , , , 13433 2053 41 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2053 42 repeatedly repeatedly RB 13433 2053 43 point point VBP 13433 2053 44 out out RP 13433 2053 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2053 46 existence existence NN 13433 2053 47 , , , 13433 2053 48 as as IN 13433 2053 49 , , , 13433 2053 50 for for IN 13433 2053 51 instance instance NN 13433 2053 52 , , , 13433 2053 53 _ _ NNP 13433 2053 54 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2053 55 _ _ NNP 13433 2053 56 ii ii NNP 13433 2053 57 . . . 13433 2054 1 pp pp NNP 13433 2054 2 . . . 13433 2055 1 255 255 CD 13433 2055 2 , , , 13433 2055 3 273 273 CD 13433 2055 4 , , , 13433 2055 5 278 278 CD 13433 2055 6 , , , 13433 2055 7 & & CC 13433 2055 8 c. c. NNP 13433 2055 9 , , , 13433 2055 10 and and CC 13433 2055 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2055 12 also also RB 13433 2055 13 show show VBP 13433 2055 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2055 15 presence presence NN 13433 2055 16 elsewhere elsewhere RB 13433 2055 17 , , , 13433 2055 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2055 19 argument argument NN 13433 2055 20 being be VBG 13433 2055 21 that that IN 13433 2055 22 the the DT 13433 2055 23 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 2055 24 not not RB 13433 2055 25 only only RB 13433 2055 26 was be VBD 13433 2055 27 not not RB 13433 2055 28 originated originate VBN 13433 2055 29 by by IN 13433 2055 30 the the DT 13433 2055 31 fourth fourth JJ 13433 2055 32 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2055 33 , , , 13433 2055 34 but but CC 13433 2055 35 that that IN 13433 2055 36 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2055 37 had have VBD 13433 2055 38 already already RB 13433 2055 39 been be VBN 13433 2055 40 applied apply VBN 13433 2055 41 to to IN 13433 2055 42 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2055 43 in in IN 13433 2055 44 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2056 1 writings writing NNS 13433 2056 2 before before IN 13433 2056 3 the the DT 13433 2056 4 composition composition NN 13433 2056 5 of of IN 13433 2056 6 that that DT 13433 2056 7 work work NN 13433 2056 8 . . . 13433 2057 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2057 2 30:2 30:2 CD 13433 2057 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2057 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2057 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2057 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2057 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2057 8 . . . 13433 2058 1 421 421 CD 13433 2058 2 . . . 13433 2059 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2059 2 30:3 30:3 CD 13433 2059 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2059 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2059 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2059 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2059 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2059 8 , , , 13433 2059 9 12 12 CD 13433 2059 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2059 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2059 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2059 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2059 14 . . . 13433 2059 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2059 16 p. p. NN 13433 2059 17 17 17 CD 13433 2059 18 f. f. NN 13433 2059 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2059 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2059 21 31:1 31:1 CD 13433 2059 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2059 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2059 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2059 25 will will MD 13433 2059 26 find find VB 13433 2059 27 the the DT 13433 2059 28 passage passage NN 13433 2059 29 to to IN 13433 2059 30 which which WDT 13433 2059 31 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2059 32 refer refer VBP 13433 2059 33 , , , 13433 2059 34 more more RBR 13433 2059 35 especially especially RB 13433 2059 36 p. p. NN 13433 2059 37 241 241 CD 13433 2059 38 , , , 13433 2059 39 line line NN 13433 2059 40 4 4 CD 13433 2059 41 , , , 13433 2059 42 commencing commence VBG 13433 2059 43 with with IN 13433 2059 44 the the DT 13433 2059 45 words word NNS 13433 2059 46 , , , 13433 2059 47 " " `` 13433 2059 48 Nur Nur NNP 13433 2059 49 zwei zwei NN 13433 2059 50 neuere neuere NNP 13433 2059 51 Ausleger Ausleger NNP 13433 2059 52 ahnen ahnen NN 13433 2059 53 die die NNP 13433 2059 54 einfache einfache NNP 13433 2059 55 Wahrheit Wahrheit NNP 13433 2059 56 . . . 13433 2059 57 " " '' 13433 2060 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2060 2 31:2 31:2 CD 13433 2060 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2060 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2060 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2060 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2060 7 421 421 CD 13433 2060 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2060 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2060 10 32:1 32:1 CD 13433 2060 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2060 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2060 13 Works Works NNP 13433 2060 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2060 15 , , , 13433 2060 16 ed ed NNP 13433 2060 17 . . . 13433 2061 1 Pitman Pitman NNP 13433 2061 2 , , , 13433 2061 3 x. x. NNP 13433 2062 1 339 339 CD 13433 2062 2 f. f. NNS 13433 2062 3 ; ; : 13433 2062 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2062 5 Horae Horae NNP 13433 2062 6 et et NNP 13433 2062 7 Talm Talm NNP 13433 2062 8 . . . 13433 2062 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2062 10 p. p. NN 13433 2062 11 938 938 CD 13433 2062 12 . . . 13433 2063 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2063 2 32:2 32:2 CD 13433 2063 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2063 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2063 5 Chron Chron NNP 13433 2063 6 . . . 13433 2064 1 Synopse Synopse NNP 13433 2064 2 d. d. NNP 13433 2064 3 vier vier NNP 13433 2064 4 . . . 13433 2065 1 Evv evv UH 13433 2065 2 . . . 13433 2065 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2065 4 p. p. NN 13433 2065 5 256 256 CD 13433 2065 6 , , , 13433 2065 7 Anm anm NN 13433 2065 8 . . . 13433 2066 1 1 1 LS 13433 2066 2 . . . 13433 2067 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2067 2 32:3 32:3 CD 13433 2067 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2067 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2067 5 Bibl Bibl NNP 13433 2067 6 . . . 13433 2068 1 Comm Comm NNP 13433 2068 2 . . NNP 13433 2068 3 , , , 13433 2068 4 Das Das NNP 13433 2068 5 . . . 13433 2069 1 Ev Ev NNP 13433 2069 2 . . . 13433 2070 1 n. n. NNP 13433 2070 2 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2070 3 . . . 13433 2070 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2070 5 , , , 13433 2070 6 umgearb umgearb NNP 13433 2070 7 . . . 13433 2071 1 Ebrard Ebrard NNP 13433 2071 2 ii ii NNP 13433 2071 3 . . . 13433 2072 1 1 1 CD 13433 2072 2 , , , 13433 2072 3 p. p. NN 13433 2072 4 122 122 CD 13433 2072 5 f. f. NNP 13433 2072 6 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2072 7 32:4 32:4 CD 13433 2072 8 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2072 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2072 10 Kurzgef Kurzgef NNP 13433 2072 11 . . . 13433 2073 1 ex ex NNP 13433 2073 2 . . . 13433 2074 1 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 13433 2074 2 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2074 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2074 4 i. i. NN 13433 2075 1 3 3 CD 13433 2075 2 , , , 13433 2075 3 p. p. NN 13433 2075 4 84 84 CD 13433 2075 5 . . . 13433 2076 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2076 2 32:5 32:5 CD 13433 2076 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2076 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2076 5 Einl Einl NNP 13433 2076 6 . . . 13433 2077 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2077 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2077 3 ii ii NNP 13433 2077 4 . . . 13433 2078 1 194 194 CD 13433 2078 2 f. f. NNS 13433 2078 3 Hug Hug NNP 13433 2078 4 more more RBR 13433 2078 5 strictly strictly RB 13433 2078 6 applies apply VBZ 13433 2078 7 the the DT 13433 2078 8 name name NN 13433 2078 9 to to IN 13433 2078 10 the the DT 13433 2078 11 sepulchre sepulchre NN 13433 2078 12 where where WRB 13433 2078 13 the the DT 13433 2078 14 bones bone NNS 13433 2078 15 of of IN 13433 2078 16 Joseph Joseph NNP 13433 2078 17 were be VBD 13433 2078 18 laid lay VBN 13433 2078 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2078 20 Josh Josh NNP 13433 2078 21 . . . 13433 2079 1 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 2079 2 . . . 13433 2080 1 32 32 CD 13433 2080 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2080 3 . . . 13433 2081 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2081 2 32:6 32:6 CD 13433 2081 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2081 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2081 5 Bibelwerk Bibelwerk NNP 13433 2081 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2081 7 , , , 13433 2081 8 iv iv NNP 13433 2081 9 . . . 13433 2082 1 219 219 CD 13433 2082 2 . . . 13433 2083 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2083 2 32:7 32:7 CD 13433 2083 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2083 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2083 5 Die Die NNP 13433 2083 6 Zeugnisse Zeugnisse NNP 13433 2083 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2083 8 , , , 13433 2083 9 p. p. NN 13433 2083 10 21 21 CD 13433 2083 11 . . . 13433 2084 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2084 2 32:8 32:8 CD 13433 2084 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2084 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2084 5 Comm Comm NNP 13433 2084 6 . . . 13433 2085 1 sur sur NNP 13433 2085 2 l'Ev l'Ev NNP 13433 2085 3 . . . 13433 2086 1 de de NNP 13433 2086 2 St. St. NNP 13433 2086 3 Jean Jean NNP 13433 2086 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2086 5 , , , 13433 2086 6 i. i. NNP 13433 2086 7 p. p. NN 13433 2086 8 475 475 CD 13433 2086 9 f. f. NNP 13433 2086 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2086 11 32:9 32:9 CD 13433 2086 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2086 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2086 14 Einl Einl NNP 13433 2086 15 . . . 13433 2087 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2087 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2087 3 p. p. NN 13433 2087 4 211 211 CD 13433 2087 5 . . . 13433 2088 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2088 2 32:10 32:10 CD 13433 2088 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2088 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2088 5 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 2088 6 . . . 13433 2089 1 gesammt gesammt NN 13433 2089 2 . . . 13433 2090 1 Luth Luth NNP 13433 2090 2 . . . 13433 2091 1 Theol Theol NNP 13433 2091 2 . . . 13433 2092 1 u. u. NNP 13433 2092 2 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 2092 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2092 4 , , , 13433 2092 5 1856 1856 CD 13433 2092 6 , , , 13433 2092 7 p. p. NN 13433 2092 8 240 240 CD 13433 2092 9 ff ff NNP 13433 2092 10 . . . 13433 2093 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2093 2 32:11 32:11 CD 13433 2093 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2093 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2093 5 Die Die NNP 13433 2093 6 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2093 7 . . . 13433 2094 1 Schriften Schriften NNP 13433 2094 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2094 3 , , , 13433 2094 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2094 5 p. p. NN 13433 2094 6 181 181 CD 13433 2094 7 , , , 13433 2094 8 Anm anm NN 13433 2094 9 . . . 13433 2095 1 1 1 LS 13433 2095 2 ; ; : 13433 2095 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2095 4 Jahrb Jahrb NNP 13433 2095 5 . . . 13433 2096 1 bibl bibl NNP 13433 2096 2 . . . 13433 2097 1 Wiss Wiss NNP 13433 2097 2 . . . 13433 2097 3 _ _ IN 13433 2097 4 viii viii NN 13433 2097 5 . . . 13433 2098 1 p. p. NN 13433 2098 2 255 255 CD 13433 2098 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2098 4 ; ; : 13433 2098 5 cf cf NNP 13433 2098 6 . . . 13433 2099 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2099 2 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 2099 3 . . . 13433 2100 1 v. v. CC 13433 2100 2 Isr Isr NNP 13433 2100 3 . . . 13433 2100 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2100 5 v. v. IN 13433 2100 6 p. p. NN 13433 2100 7 348 348 CD 13433 2100 8 , , , 13433 2100 9 Anm anm CC 13433 2100 10 . . . 13433 2101 1 1 1 LS 13433 2101 2 . . . 13433 2102 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2102 2 32:12 32:12 CD 13433 2102 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2102 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2102 5 Das Das NNP 13433 2102 6 Ev Ev NNP 13433 2102 7 . . . 13433 2103 1 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2103 2 . . NNP 13433 2103 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2103 4 p. p. NN 13433 2103 5 107 107 CD 13433 2103 6 . . . 13433 2104 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2104 2 32:13 32:13 CD 13433 2104 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2104 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2104 5 Comm Comm NNP 13433 2104 6 . . . 13433 2105 1 Ev Ev NNP 13433 2105 2 . . . 13433 2106 1 n. n. NNP 13433 2106 2 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2106 3 . . . 13433 2106 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2106 5 p. p. NN 13433 2106 6 188 188 CD 13433 2106 7 f. f. NNP 13433 2106 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2106 9 33:1 33:1 CD 13433 2106 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2106 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2106 12 Comm Comm NNP 13433 2106 13 . . . 13433 2107 1 Ev Ev NNP 13433 2107 2 . . . 13433 2108 1 des des NNP 13433 2108 2 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2108 3 . . . 13433 2108 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2108 5 i. i. NNP 13433 2108 6 p. p. NN 13433 2108 7 577 577 CD 13433 2108 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2108 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2108 10 33:2 33:2 NNP 13433 2108 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2108 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2108 13 Jahrb Jahrb NNP 13433 2108 14 . . . 13433 2109 1 bibl bibl NNP 13433 2109 2 . . . 13433 2110 1 Wiss Wiss NNP 13433 2110 2 . . . 13433 2110 3 _ _ IN 13433 2110 4 viii viii NN 13433 2110 5 . . . 13433 2111 1 p. p. NN 13433 2111 2 255 255 CD 13433 2111 3 f. f. NNS 13433 2111 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2111 5 33:3 33:3 CD 13433 2111 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2111 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2111 8 Die Die NNP 13433 2111 9 Joh Joh NNP 13433 2111 10 . . . 13433 2112 1 Schr Schr NNP 13433 2112 2 . . . 13433 2112 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2112 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2112 5 p. p. NN 13433 2112 6 181 181 CD 13433 2112 7 , , , 13433 2112 8 Anm anm NN 13433 2112 9 . . . 13433 2113 1 1 1 LS 13433 2113 2 . . . 13433 2114 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2114 2 33:4 33:4 CD 13433 2114 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2114 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2114 5 Authorship Authorship NNP 13433 2114 6 and and CC 13433 2114 7 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2114 8 . . . 13433 2115 1 Char Char NNP 13433 2115 2 . . . 13433 2116 1 of of IN 13433 2116 2 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2116 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2116 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2116 5 , , , 13433 2116 6 1872 1872 CD 13433 2116 7 , , , 13433 2116 8 p. p. NN 13433 2116 9 92 92 CD 13433 2116 10 . . . 13433 2117 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2117 2 33:5 33:5 CD 13433 2117 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2117 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 13433 2117 5 Sanday Sanday NNP 13433 2117 6 adds add VBZ 13433 2117 7 in in IN 13433 2117 8 a a DT 13433 2117 9 note note NN 13433 2117 10 here here RB 13433 2117 11 : : : 13433 2117 12 " " `` 13433 2117 13 This this DT 13433 2117 14 may may MD 13433 2117 15 perhaps perhaps RB 13433 2117 16 be be VB 13433 2117 17 called call VBN 13433 2117 18 the the DT 13433 2117 19 current current JJ 13433 2117 20 explanation explanation NN 13433 2117 21 of of IN 13433 2117 22 the the DT 13433 2117 23 name name NN 13433 2117 24 . . . 13433 2118 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 2118 2 is be VBZ 13433 2118 3 accepted accept VBN 13433 2118 4 as as RB 13433 2118 5 well well RB 13433 2118 6 by by IN 13433 2118 7 those those DT 13433 2118 8 who who WP 13433 2118 9 deny deny VBP 13433 2118 10 the the DT 13433 2118 11 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 2118 12 of of IN 13433 2118 13 the the DT 13433 2118 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2118 15 as as IN 13433 2118 16 by by IN 13433 2118 17 those those DT 13433 2118 18 who who WP 13433 2118 19 maintain maintain VBP 13433 2118 20 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2118 21 . . . 13433 2119 1 Cf cf NN 13433 2119 2 . . . 13433 2120 1 Keim Keim NNP 13433 2120 2 , , , 13433 2120 3 i. i. NNP 13433 2121 1 133 133 LS 13433 2121 2 . . . 13433 2122 1 But but CC 13433 2122 2 there there EX 13433 2122 3 is be VBZ 13433 2122 4 much much JJ 13433 2122 5 to to TO 13433 2122 6 be be VB 13433 2122 7 said say VBN 13433 2122 8 for for IN 13433 2122 9 the the DT 13433 2122 10 identification identification NN 13433 2122 11 with with IN 13433 2122 12 El El NNP 13433 2122 13 Askar Askar NNP 13433 2122 14 , , , 13433 2122 15 & & CC 13433 2122 16 c. c. NNP 13433 2122 17 " " `` 13433 2122 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2122 19 Authorship Authorship NNP 13433 2122 20 and and CC 13433 2122 21 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2122 22 . . . 13433 2123 1 Char Char NNP 13433 2123 2 . . . 13433 2124 1 of of IN 13433 2124 2 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2124 3 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2124 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2124 5 , , , 13433 2124 6 p. p. NN 13433 2124 7 93 93 CD 13433 2124 8 , , , 13433 2124 9 note note VB 13433 2124 10 1 1 CD 13433 2124 11 . . . 13433 2125 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2125 2 34:1 34:1 CD 13433 2125 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2125 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2125 5 Life Life NNP 13433 2125 6 of of IN 13433 2125 7 Christ Christ NNP 13433 2125 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2125 9 , , , 13433 2125 10 i. i. NNP 13433 2125 11 p. p. NN 13433 2125 12 206 206 CD 13433 2125 13 , , , 13433 2125 14 note note VBP 13433 2125 15 1 1 CD 13433 2125 16 . . . 13433 2126 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2126 2 34:2 34:2 CD 13433 2126 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2126 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2126 5 La La NNP 13433 2126 6 Géographie Géographie NNP 13433 2126 7 du du NNP 13433 2126 8 Tulmud Tulmud NNP 13433 2126 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2126 10 , , , 13433 2126 11 p. p. NN 13433 2126 12 170 170 CD 13433 2126 13 . . . 13433 2127 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2127 2 34:3 34:3 CD 13433 2127 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2127 4 Smith Smith NNP 13433 2127 5 's 's POS 13433 2127 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2127 7 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 13433 2127 8 of of IN 13433 2127 9 the the DT 13433 2127 10 Bible Bible NNP 13433 2127 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2127 12 , , , 13433 2127 13 iii iii NNP 13433 2127 14 . . . 13433 2128 1 p. p. NN 13433 2128 2 1395 1395 CD 13433 2128 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2128 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2128 5 36:1 36:1 CD 13433 2128 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2128 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2128 8 Bampton Bampton NNP 13433 2128 9 Lect Lect NNP 13433 2128 10 . . . 13433 2128 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2128 12 1865 1865 CD 13433 2128 13 , , , 13433 2128 14 2nd 2nd JJ 13433 2128 15 edit edit NN 13433 2128 16 . . . 13433 2129 1 p. p. NN 13433 2129 2 4 4 CD 13433 2129 3 . . . 13433 2130 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2130 2 36:2 36:2 CD 13433 2130 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2130 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2130 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2130 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2130 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2130 8 p. p. NN 13433 2130 9 61 61 CD 13433 2130 10 ff ff NN 13433 2130 11 . . . 13433 2131 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2131 2 37:1 37:1 CD 13433 2131 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2131 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2131 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2131 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 8 , , , 13433 2131 9 p. p. NN 13433 2131 10 19 19 CD 13433 2131 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2131 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2131 14 . . . 13433 2131 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 16 p. p. NN 13433 2131 17 26 26 CD 13433 2131 18 f. f. NN 13433 2131 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2131 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2131 21 37:2 37:2 CD 13433 2131 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2131 23 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 24 Three Three NNP 13433 2131 25 Essays Essays NNPS 13433 2131 26 on on IN 13433 2131 27 Religion Religion NNP 13433 2131 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 29 , , , 13433 2131 30 p. p. NN 13433 2131 31 216 216 CD 13433 2131 32 f. f. NNS 13433 2131 33 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2131 34 38:1 38:1 CD 13433 2131 35 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2131 36 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 37 Three Three NNP 13433 2131 38 Essays Essays NNPS 13433 2131 39 on on IN 13433 2131 40 Religion Religion NNP 13433 2131 41 _ _ NNP 13433 2131 42 , , , 13433 2131 43 p. p. NN 13433 2131 44 234 234 CD 13433 2131 45 . . . 13433 2132 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2132 2 38:2 38:2 CD 13433 2132 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2132 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2132 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2132 6 . . . 13433 2132 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2132 8 p. p. NN 13433 2132 9 219 219 CD 13433 2132 10 . . . 13433 2133 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2133 2 39:1 39:1 CD 13433 2133 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2133 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2133 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2133 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2133 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2133 8 . . . 13433 2134 1 p. p. NN 13433 2134 2 477 477 CD 13433 2134 3 . . . 13433 2135 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2135 2 40:1 40:1 CD 13433 2135 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2135 4 This this DT 13433 2135 5 appeared appear VBD 13433 2135 6 as as IN 13433 2135 7 the the DT 13433 2135 8 Preface Preface NNP 13433 2135 9 to to IN 13433 2135 10 the the DT 13433 2135 11 6th 6th JJ 13433 2135 12 edition edition NN 13433 2135 13 . . . 13433 2136 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2136 2 45:1 45:1 CD 13433 2136 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2136 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2136 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2136 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2136 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2136 8 , , , 13433 2136 9 January January NNP 13433 2136 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2136 11 , , , 13433 2136 12 p. p. NN 13433 2136 13 1 1 CD 13433 2136 14 ff ff NN 13433 2136 15 . . . 13433 2137 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2137 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2137 3 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2137 4 . . . 13433 2137 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2137 6 p. p. NN 13433 2137 7 32 32 CD 13433 2137 8 ff ff NNP 13433 2137 9 . . . 13433 2137 10 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2138 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2138 2 45:2 45:2 CD 13433 2138 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2138 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2138 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2138 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2138 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2138 8 p. p. NN 13433 2138 9 212 212 CD 13433 2138 10 . . . 13433 2139 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2139 2 46:1 46:1 CD 13433 2139 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2139 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2139 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2139 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2139 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2139 8 , , , 13433 2139 9 January January NNP 13433 2139 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2139 11 , , , 13433 2139 12 p. p. NN 13433 2139 13 172 172 CD 13433 2139 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2139 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2139 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2139 17 . . . 13433 2139 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2139 19 p. p. NN 13433 2139 20 36 36 CD 13433 2139 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2139 22 . . . 13433 2140 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2140 2 46:2 46:2 CD 13433 2140 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2140 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2140 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2140 6 . . . 13433 2140 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2140 8 p. p. NN 13433 2140 9 183 183 CD 13433 2140 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2140 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2140 12 ibid ibid NN 13433 2140 13 . . . 13433 2140 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2140 15 p. p. NN 13433 2140 16 51 51 CD 13433 2140 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2140 18 . . . 13433 2141 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2141 2 48:1 48:1 CD 13433 2141 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2141 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2141 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2141 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2141 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2141 8 , , , 13433 2141 9 January January NNP 13433 2141 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2141 11 , , , 13433 2141 12 p. p. NN 13433 2141 13 173 173 CD 13433 2141 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2141 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2141 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2141 17 . . . 13433 2141 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2141 19 p. p. NN 13433 2141 20 38 38 CD 13433 2141 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2141 22 . . . 13433 2142 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2142 2 49:1 49:1 CD 13433 2142 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2142 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2142 5 regret regret VBP 13433 2142 6 very very RB 13433 2142 7 much much RB 13433 2142 8 that that IN 13433 2142 9 some some DT 13433 2142 10 ambiguity ambiguity NN 13433 2142 11 in in IN 13433 2142 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2142 13 language language NN 13433 2142 14 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2142 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2142 16 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2142 17 _ _ NNP 13433 2142 18 i. i. NNP 13433 2142 19 p. p. NN 13433 2142 20 483 483 CD 13433 2142 21 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2142 22 should should MD 13433 2142 23 have have VB 13433 2142 24 misled mislead VBN 13433 2142 25 , , , 13433 2142 26 and and CC 13433 2142 27 given give VBN 13433 2142 28 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2142 29 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2142 30 much much JJ 13433 2142 31 trouble trouble NN 13433 2142 32 . . . 13433 2143 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2143 2 used use VBD 13433 2143 3 the the DT 13433 2143 4 word word NN 13433 2143 5 " " `` 13433 2143 6 quotation quotation NN 13433 2143 7 " " '' 13433 2143 8 in in IN 13433 2143 9 the the DT 13433 2143 10 sense sense NN 13433 2143 11 of of IN 13433 2143 12 a a DT 13433 2143 13 use use NN 13433 2143 14 of of IN 13433 2143 15 the the DT 13433 2143 16 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2143 17 of of IN 13433 2143 18 Peter Peter NNP 13433 2143 19 , , , 13433 2143 20 and and CC 13433 2143 21 not not RB 13433 2143 22 in in IN 13433 2143 23 reference reference NN 13433 2143 24 to to IN 13433 2143 25 any any DT 13433 2143 26 one one CD 13433 2143 27 sentence sentence NN 13433 2143 28 in in IN 13433 2143 29 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2143 30 . . . 13433 2144 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2144 2 trust trust VBP 13433 2144 3 that that IN 13433 2144 4 in in IN 13433 2144 5 this this DT 13433 2144 6 edition edition NN 13433 2144 7 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2144 8 have have VBP 13433 2144 9 made make VBN 13433 2144 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2144 11 meaning meaning NN 13433 2144 12 clear clear JJ 13433 2144 13 . . . 13433 2145 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2145 2 50:1 50:1 CD 13433 2145 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2145 4 Cf cf NN 13433 2145 5 . . . 13433 2146 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2146 2 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2146 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2146 4 iii iii NNP 13433 2146 5 . . . 13433 2147 1 3 3 CD 13433 2147 2 , , , 13433 2147 3 4 4 CD 13433 2147 4 , , , 13433 2147 5 18 18 CD 13433 2147 6 , , , 13433 2147 7 24 24 CD 13433 2147 8 , , , 13433 2147 9 25 25 CD 13433 2147 10 , , , 13433 2147 11 & & CC 13433 2147 12 c. c. NNP 13433 2147 13 & & CC 13433 2147 14 c. c. NNP 13433 2147 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2147 16 50:2 50:2 CD 13433 2147 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2147 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2147 19 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2147 20 . . . 13433 2147 21 _ _ NNP 13433 2147 22 ii ii NNP 13433 2147 23 . . . 13433 2148 1 15 15 CD 13433 2148 2 , , , 13433 2148 3 vi vi NNP 13433 2148 4 . . . 13433 2149 1 14 14 CD 13433 2149 2 . . . 13433 2150 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2150 2 50:3 50:3 CD 13433 2150 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2150 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2150 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2150 6 . . . 13433 2150 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2150 8 v. v. IN 13433 2150 9 8 8 CD 13433 2150 10 . . . 13433 2151 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2151 2 50:4 50:4 CD 13433 2151 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2151 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2151 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2151 6 . . . 13433 2151 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2151 8 vi vi NNP 13433 2151 9 . . . 13433 2152 1 25 25 CD 13433 2152 2 . . . 13433 2153 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2153 2 51:1 51:1 CD 13433 2153 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2153 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2153 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2153 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2153 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2153 8 , , , 13433 2153 9 January January NNP 13433 2153 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2153 11 , , , 13433 2153 12 p. p. NN 13433 2153 13 181 181 CD 13433 2153 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2153 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2153 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2153 17 . . . 13433 2153 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2153 19 p. p. NN 13433 2153 20 48 48 CD 13433 2153 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2153 22 . . . 13433 2154 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2154 2 51:2 51:2 CD 13433 2154 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2154 4 By by IN 13433 2154 5 a a DT 13433 2154 6 slip slip NN 13433 2154 7 of of IN 13433 2154 8 the the DT 13433 2154 9 pen pen NN 13433 2154 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2154 11 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2154 12 refers refer VBZ 13433 2154 13 to to IN 13433 2154 14 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2154 15 , , , 13433 2154 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2154 17 Adv Adv NNP 13433 2154 18 . . . 13433 2155 1 Haer Haer NNP 13433 2155 2 . . . 13433 2155 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2155 4 iii iii NNP 13433 2155 5 . . . 13433 2156 1 3 3 CD 13433 2156 2 , , , 13433 2156 3 4 4 CD 13433 2156 4 . . . 13433 2157 1 It -PRON- PRP 13433 2157 2 should should MD 13433 2157 3 be be VB 13433 2157 4 ii ii PRP 13433 2157 5 . . . 13433 2158 1 22 22 CD 13433 2158 2 , , , 13433 2158 3 5 5 CD 13433 2158 4 . . . 13433 2159 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2159 2 51:3 51:3 CD 13433 2159 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2159 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2159 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2159 6 . . . 13433 2159 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2159 8 p. p. NN 13433 2159 9 181 181 CD 13433 2159 10 . . . 13433 2160 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2160 2 51:4 51:4 CD 13433 2160 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2160 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2160 5 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2160 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2160 7 iii iii NNP 13433 2160 8 , , , 13433 2160 9 24 24 CD 13433 2160 10 . . . 13433 2161 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2161 2 52:1 52:1 CD 13433 2161 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2161 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2161 5 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2161 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2161 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2161 8 . . . 13433 2162 1 23 23 CD 13433 2162 2 . . . 13433 2163 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2163 2 52:2 52:2 CD 13433 2163 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2163 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2163 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2163 6 . . . 13433 2163 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2163 8 iii iii NNP 13433 2163 9 . . . 13433 2164 1 11 11 CD 13433 2164 2 . . . 13433 2165 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2165 2 52:3 52:3 CD 13433 2165 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2165 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2165 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2165 6 . . . 13433 2165 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2165 8 16 16 CD 13433 2165 9 . . . 13433 2166 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2166 2 52:4 52:4 CD 13433 2166 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2166 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2166 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2166 6 . . . 13433 2166 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2166 8 19 19 CD 13433 2166 9 , , , 13433 2166 10 20 20 CD 13433 2166 11 . . . 13433 2167 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2167 2 52:5 52:5 CD 13433 2167 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2167 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2167 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2167 6 . . . 13433 2167 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2167 8 32 32 CD 13433 2167 9 . . . 13433 2168 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2168 2 52:6 52:6 CD 13433 2168 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2168 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2168 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2168 6 . . . 13433 2168 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2168 8 iv iv NNP 13433 2168 9 . . . 13433 2169 1 8 8 LS 13433 2169 2 . . . 13433 2170 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2170 2 52:7 52:7 CD 13433 2170 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2170 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2170 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2170 6 . . . 13433 2170 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2170 8 11 11 CD 13433 2170 9 . . . 13433 2171 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2171 2 52:8 52:8 CD 13433 2171 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2171 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2171 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2171 6 . . . 13433 2171 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2171 8 iv iv NNP 13433 2171 9 . . . 13433 2172 1 22 22 CD 13433 2172 2 . . . 13433 2173 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2173 2 53:1 53:1 CD 13433 2173 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2173 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2173 5 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2173 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2173 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2173 8 . . . 13433 2174 1 15 15 CD 13433 2174 2 . . . 13433 2175 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2175 2 53:2 53:2 CD 13433 2175 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2175 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2175 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2175 6 . . . 13433 2175 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2175 8 vii vii NN 13433 2175 9 . . . 13433 2176 1 25 25 CD 13433 2176 2 . . . 13433 2177 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2177 2 54:1 54:1 CD 13433 2177 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2177 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2177 5 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2177 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2177 7 iii iii NNP 13433 2177 8 . . . 13433 2178 1 18 18 CD 13433 2178 2 . . . 13433 2179 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2179 2 54:2 54:2 CD 13433 2179 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2179 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2179 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2179 6 . . . 13433 2179 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2179 8 19 19 CD 13433 2179 9 , , , 13433 2179 10 20 20 CD 13433 2179 11 . . . 13433 2180 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2180 2 54:3 54:3 CD 13433 2180 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2180 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2180 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2180 6 . . . 13433 2180 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2180 8 20 20 CD 13433 2180 9 . . . 13433 2181 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2181 2 54:4 54:4 CD 13433 2181 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2181 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2181 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2181 6 . . . 13433 2181 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2181 8 20 20 CD 13433 2181 9 . . . 13433 2182 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2182 2 54:5 54:5 CD 13433 2182 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2182 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2182 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2182 6 . . . 13433 2182 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2182 8 23 23 CD 13433 2182 9 . . . 13433 2183 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2183 2 54:6 54:6 CD 13433 2183 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2183 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2183 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2183 6 . . . 13433 2183 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2183 8 24 24 CD 13433 2183 9 . . . 13433 2184 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2184 2 55:1 55:1 CD 13433 2184 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2184 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2184 5 am be VBP 13433 2184 6 much much RB 13433 2184 7 obliged oblige VBN 13433 2184 8 to to IN 13433 2184 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2184 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2184 11 for for IN 13433 2184 12 calling call VBG 13433 2184 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2184 14 attention attention NN 13433 2184 15 to to IN 13433 2184 16 the the DT 13433 2184 17 accidental accidental JJ 13433 2184 18 insertion insertion NN 13433 2184 19 of of IN 13433 2184 20 the the DT 13433 2184 21 words word NNS 13433 2184 22 " " '' 13433 2184 23 and and CC 13433 2184 24 the the DT 13433 2184 25 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2184 26 " " '' 13433 2184 27 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2184 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2184 29 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2184 30 _ _ NNP 13433 2184 31 i. i. NNP 13433 2184 32 p. p. NN 13433 2184 33 433 433 CD 13433 2184 34 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2184 35 . . . 13433 2185 1 This this DT 13433 2185 2 was be VBD 13433 2185 3 a a DT 13433 2185 4 mere mere JJ 13433 2185 5 slip slip NN 13433 2185 6 of of IN 13433 2185 7 the the DT 13433 2185 8 pen pen NN 13433 2185 9 , , , 13433 2185 10 of of IN 13433 2185 11 which which WDT 13433 2185 12 no no DT 13433 2185 13 use use NN 13433 2185 14 is be VBZ 13433 2185 15 made make VBN 13433 2185 16 , , , 13433 2185 17 and and CC 13433 2185 18 the the DT 13433 2185 19 error error NN 13433 2185 20 is be VBZ 13433 2185 21 effectually effectually RB 13433 2185 22 corrected correct VBN 13433 2185 23 by by IN 13433 2185 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2185 25 own own JJ 13433 2185 26 distinct distinct JJ 13433 2185 27 statements statement NNS 13433 2185 28 . . . 13433 2186 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2186 2 55:2 55:2 CD 13433 2186 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2186 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2186 5 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2186 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2186 7 iii iii NNP 13433 2186 8 . . . 13433 2187 1 39 39 CD 13433 2187 2 . . . 13433 2188 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2188 2 56:1 56:1 CD 13433 2188 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2188 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2188 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2188 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2188 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2188 8 , , , 13433 2188 9 January January NNP 13433 2188 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2188 11 , , , 13433 2188 12 p. p. NN 13433 2188 13 183 183 CD 13433 2188 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2188 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2188 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2188 17 . . . 13433 2188 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2188 19 p. p. NN 13433 2188 20 51 51 CD 13433 2188 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2188 22 . . . 13433 2189 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2189 2 57:1 57:1 CD 13433 2189 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2189 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2189 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2189 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2189 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2189 8 , , , 13433 2189 9 February February NNP 13433 2189 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2189 11 , , , 13433 2189 12 p. p. NN 13433 2189 13 337 337 CD 13433 2189 14 ff ff NN 13433 2189 15 . . . 13433 2190 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2190 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2190 3 ibid ibid NN 13433 2190 4 . . . 13433 2190 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2190 6 p. p. NN 13433 2190 7 59 59 CD 13433 2190 8 ff ff NNP 13433 2190 9 . . . 13433 2190 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2191 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2191 2 58:1 58:1 CD 13433 2191 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2191 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2191 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2191 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2191 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2191 8 , , , 13433 2191 9 February February NNP 13433 2191 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2191 11 , , , 13433 2191 12 p. p. NN 13433 2191 13 339 339 CD 13433 2191 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2191 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2191 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2191 17 . . . 13433 2191 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2191 19 p. p. NN 13433 2191 20 62 62 CD 13433 2191 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2191 22 . . . 13433 2192 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2192 2 59:1 59:1 CD 13433 2192 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2192 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2192 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2192 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2192 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2192 8 , , , 13433 2192 9 February February NNP 13433 2192 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2192 11 , , , 13433 2192 12 p. p. NN 13433 2192 13 340 340 CD 13433 2192 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2192 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2192 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2192 17 . . . 13433 2192 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2192 19 p. p. NN 13433 2192 20 63 63 CD 13433 2192 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2192 22 . . . 13433 2193 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2193 2 59:2 59:2 CD 13433 2193 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2193 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2193 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2193 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2193 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2193 8 p. p. NN 13433 2193 9 263 263 CD 13433 2193 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2193 11 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2193 12 have have VBP 13433 2193 13 introduced introduce VBN 13433 2193 14 numbers number NNS 13433 2193 15 for for IN 13433 2193 16 facility facility NN 13433 2193 17 of of IN 13433 2193 18 reference reference NN 13433 2193 19 . . . 13433 2194 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2194 2 60:1 60:1 CD 13433 2194 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2194 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2194 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2194 6 says say VBZ 13433 2194 7 in in IN 13433 2194 8 this this DT 13433 2194 9 volume volume NN 13433 2194 10 : : : 13433 2194 11 " " `` 13433 2194 12 The the DT 13433 2194 13 reading reading NN 13433 2194 14 ' ' `` 13433 2194 15 most most JJS 13433 2194 16 ' ' '' 13433 2194 17 is be VBZ 13433 2194 18 explained explain VBN 13433 2194 19 in in IN 13433 2194 20 the the DT 13433 2194 21 preface preface NN 13433 2194 22 to to IN 13433 2194 23 that that DT 13433 2194 24 edition edition NN 13433 2194 25 as as IN 13433 2194 26 a a DT 13433 2194 27 misprint misprint NN 13433 2194 28 " " '' 13433 2194 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2194 30 p. p. NN 13433 2194 31 63 63 CD 13433 2194 32 , , , 13433 2194 33 n. n. NNP 13433 2194 34 2 2 CD 13433 2194 35 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2194 36 . . . 13433 2195 1 Not not RB 13433 2195 2 so so RB 13433 2195 3 at at RB 13433 2195 4 all all RB 13433 2195 5 . . . 13433 2196 1 " " `` 13433 2196 2 A a DT 13433 2196 3 slip slip NN 13433 2196 4 of of IN 13433 2196 5 the the DT 13433 2196 6 pen pen NN 13433 2196 7 " " `` 13433 2196 8 is be VBZ 13433 2196 9 a a DT 13433 2196 10 very very RB 13433 2196 11 different different JJ 13433 2196 12 thing thing NN 13433 2196 13 . . . 13433 2197 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2197 2 60:2 60:2 CD 13433 2197 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2197 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2197 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2197 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2197 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2197 8 , , , 13433 2197 9 February February NNP 13433 2197 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2197 11 , , , 13433 2197 12 p. p. NN 13433 2197 13 341 341 CD 13433 2197 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2197 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2197 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2197 17 . . . 13433 2197 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2197 19 p. p. NN 13433 2197 20 64 64 CD 13433 2197 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2197 22 . . . 13433 2198 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2198 2 61:1 61:1 CD 13433 2198 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2198 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2198 5 Ueber Ueber NNP 13433 2198 6 d. d. NN 13433 2198 7 Urspr Urspr NNP 13433 2198 8 . . . 13433 2199 1 u.s.w u.s.w JJ 13433 2199 2 . . . 13433 2200 1 des des FW 13433 2200 2 Christennamens Christennamens NNP 13433 2200 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2200 4 , , , 13433 2200 5 p. p. NN 13433 2200 6 7 7 CD 13433 2200 7 , , , 13433 2200 8 Anm anm NN 13433 2200 9 . . . 13433 2201 1 1 1 LS 13433 2201 2 . . . 13433 2202 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2202 2 61:2 61:2 CD 13433 2202 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2202 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2202 5 Zeitschr Zeitschr NNP 13433 2202 6 . . . 13433 2203 1 wiss wiss NNP 13433 2203 2 . . . 13433 2204 1 Theol Theol NNP 13433 2204 2 . . . 13433 2204 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2204 4 1874 1874 CD 13433 2204 5 , , , 13433 2204 6 p. p. NN 13433 2204 7 211 211 CD 13433 2204 8 , , , 13433 2204 9 Anm anm CC 13433 2204 10 . . . 13433 2205 1 1 1 LS 13433 2205 2 . . . 13433 2206 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2206 2 should should MD 13433 2206 3 have have VB 13433 2206 4 added add VBN 13433 2206 5 that that IN 13433 2206 6 the the DT 13433 2206 7 priority priority NN 13433 2206 8 which which WDT 13433 2206 9 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 2206 10 still still RB 13433 2206 11 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 2206 12 is be VBZ 13433 2206 13 that that DT 13433 2206 14 of of IN 13433 2206 15 the the DT 13433 2206 16 text text NN 13433 2206 17 , , , 13433 2206 18 as as IN 13433 2206 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2206 20 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2206 21 points point VBZ 13433 2206 22 out out RP 13433 2206 23 in in IN 13433 2206 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2206 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2206 26 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 2206 27 Fathers Fathers NNP 13433 2206 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2206 29 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2206 30 part part NNP 13433 2206 31 ii ii NNP 13433 2206 32 . . . 13433 2207 1 vol vol NNP 13433 2207 2 . . . 13433 2208 1 i. i. NNP 13433 2209 1 1885 1885 CD 13433 2209 2 , , , 13433 2209 3 p. p. NN 13433 2209 4 273 273 CD 13433 2209 5 , , , 13433 2209 6 n. n. NNP 13433 2209 7 1 1 CD 13433 2209 8 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2209 9 , , , 13433 2209 10 and and CC 13433 2209 11 not not RB 13433 2209 12 of of IN 13433 2209 13 absolute absolute JJ 13433 2209 14 origin origin NN 13433 2209 15 ; ; : 13433 2209 16 but but CC 13433 2209 17 this this DT 13433 2209 18 appears appear VBZ 13433 2209 19 clearly clearly RB 13433 2209 20 enough enough RB 13433 2209 21 in in IN 13433 2209 22 the the DT 13433 2209 23 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2209 24 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2209 25 have have VBP 13433 2209 26 made make VBN 13433 2209 27 . . . 13433 2210 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2210 2 61:3 61:3 CD 13433 2210 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2210 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2210 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2210 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2210 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2210 8 , , , 13433 2210 9 February February NNP 13433 2210 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2210 11 , , , 13433 2210 12 p. p. NN 13433 2210 13 841 841 CD 13433 2210 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2210 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2210 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2210 17 . . . 13433 2210 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2210 19 p. p. NN 13433 2210 20 65 65 CD 13433 2210 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2210 22 . . . 13433 2211 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2211 2 62:1 62:1 CD 13433 2211 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2211 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2211 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2211 8 p. p. NN 13433 2211 9 259 259 CD 13433 2211 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2211 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2211 12 62:2 62:2 CD 13433 2211 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2211 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 15 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2211 16 Review Review NNP 13433 2211 17 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 18 , , , 13433 2211 19 February February NNP 13433 2211 20 1875 1875 CD 13433 2211 21 , , , 13433 2211 22 p. p. NN 13433 2211 23 342 342 CD 13433 2211 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2211 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 26 ibid ibid NN 13433 2211 27 . . . 13433 2211 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 29 p p NNP 13433 2211 30 , , , 13433 2211 31 65 65 CD 13433 2211 32 f. f. NN 13433 2211 33 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2211 34 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2211 35 62:3 62:3 CD 13433 2211 36 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2211 37 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 38 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2211 39 _ _ NNP 13433 2211 40 i. i. NNP 13433 2211 41 p. p. NN 13433 2211 42 259 259 CD 13433 2211 43 . . . 13433 2212 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2212 2 63:1 63:1 CD 13433 2212 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2212 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2212 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2212 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2212 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2212 8 , , , 13433 2212 9 February February NNP 13433 2212 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2212 11 , , , 13433 2212 12 p. p. NN 13433 2212 13 342 342 CD 13433 2212 14 . . . 13433 2213 1 In in IN 13433 2213 2 a a DT 13433 2213 3 note note NN 13433 2213 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2213 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2213 6 states state VBZ 13433 2213 7 that that IN 13433 2213 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2213 9 references reference NNS 13433 2213 10 to to IN 13433 2213 11 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 2213 12 are be VBP 13433 2213 13 to to IN 13433 2213 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2213 15 earlier early JJR 13433 2213 16 works work NNS 13433 2213 17 , , , 13433 2213 18 where where WRB 13433 2213 19 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2213 20 still still RB 13433 2213 21 maintains maintain VBZ 13433 2213 22 the the DT 13433 2213 23 priority priority NN 13433 2213 24 and and CC 13433 2213 25 genuineness genuineness NN 13433 2213 26 of of IN 13433 2213 27 the the DT 13433 2213 28 Curetonian Curetonian NNP 13433 2213 29 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2213 30 . . . 13433 2214 1 Certainly certainly RB 13433 2214 2 they -PRON- PRP 13433 2214 3 are be VBP 13433 2214 4 so so RB 13433 2214 5 : : : 13433 2214 6 but but CC 13433 2214 7 in in IN 13433 2214 8 the the DT 13433 2214 9 right right JJ 13433 2214 10 place place NN 13433 2214 11 , , , 13433 2214 12 two two CD 13433 2214 13 pages page NNS 13433 2214 14 further further RB 13433 2214 15 on on RB 13433 2214 16 , , , 13433 2214 17 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2214 18 refer refer VBP 13433 2214 19 to to IN 13433 2214 20 the the DT 13433 2214 21 writings writing NNS 13433 2214 22 in in IN 13433 2214 23 which which WDT 13433 2214 24 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2214 25 rejects reject VBZ 13433 2214 26 the the DT 13433 2214 27 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 2214 28 , , , 13433 2214 29 whilst whilst IN 13433 2214 30 still still RB 13433 2214 31 maintaining maintain VBG 13433 2214 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2214 33 previous previous JJ 13433 2214 34 view view NN 13433 2214 35 of of IN 13433 2214 36 the the DT 13433 2214 37 priority priority NN 13433 2214 38 of of IN 13433 2214 39 these these DT 13433 2214 40 letters letter NNS 13433 2214 41 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2214 42 _ _ NNP 13433 2214 43 ibid ibid NN 13433 2214 44 . . . 13433 2214 45 _ _ NNP 13433 2214 46 p. p. NN 13433 2214 47 66 66 CD 13433 2214 48 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2214 49 . . . 13433 2215 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2215 2 64:1 64:1 CD 13433 2215 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2215 4 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 2215 5 's 's POS 13433 2215 6 expressions expression NNS 13433 2215 7 are be VBP 13433 2215 8 : : : 13433 2215 9 " " `` 13433 2215 10 Nihil Nihil NNP 13433 2215 11 naeniis naeniis NN 13433 2215 12 illis illis NNP 13433 2215 13 , , , 13433 2215 14 quae quae RB 13433 2215 15 sub sub VB 13433 2215 16 Ignatii Ignatii NNP 13433 2215 17 nomine nomine NN 13433 2215 18 editae editae NNP 13433 2215 19 sunt sunt NNP 13433 2215 20 , , , 13433 2215 21 putidius putidius NNP 13433 2215 22 . . . 13433 2216 1 Quo quo VB 13433 2216 2 minus minus CC 13433 2216 3 tolerabilis tolerabili VBZ 13433 2216 4 est est NNP 13433 2216 5 eorum eorum NNP 13433 2216 6 impudentia impudentia NN 13433 2216 7 , , , 13433 2216 8 qui qui NNP 13433 2216 9 talibus talibus NNP 13433 2216 10 larvis larvis NNP 13433 2216 11 ad ad NNP 13433 2216 12 fallendum fallendum NN 13433 2216 13 se se FW 13433 2216 14 instruunt instruunt NNP 13433 2216 15 " " '' 13433 2216 16 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2216 17 _ _ NNP 13433 2216 18 Inst Inst NNP 13433 2216 19 . . . 13433 2217 1 Chr Chr NNP 13433 2217 2 . . . 13433 2218 1 Rel Rel NNP 13433 2218 2 . . NNP 13433 2218 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2218 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2219 1 13 13 CD 13433 2219 2 , , , 13433 2219 3 § § CD 13433 2219 4 39 39 CD 13433 2219 5 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2219 6 . . . 13433 2220 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2220 2 64:2 64:2 CD 13433 2220 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2220 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2220 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2220 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2220 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2220 8 , , , 13433 2220 9 February February NNP 13433 2220 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2220 11 , , , 13433 2220 12 p. p. NN 13433 2220 13 342 342 CD 13433 2220 14 . . . 13433 2221 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2221 2 64:3 64:3 CD 13433 2221 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2221 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2221 5 Op Op NNP 13433 2221 6 . . . 13433 2222 1 Theolog Theolog NNP 13433 2222 2 . . . 13433 2222 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2222 4 1652 1652 CD 13433 2222 5 , , , 13433 2222 6 11 11 CD 13433 2222 7 , , , 13433 2222 8 p. p. NN 13433 2222 9 1085 1085 CD 13433 2222 10 . . . 13433 2223 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2223 2 64:4 64:4 CD 13433 2223 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2223 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2223 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2223 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2223 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2223 8 , , , 13433 2223 9 February February NNP 13433 2223 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2223 11 , , , 13433 2223 12 p. p. NN 13433 2223 13 342 342 CD 13433 2223 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2223 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2223 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2223 17 . . . 13433 2223 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2223 19 p. p. NN 13433 2223 20 66 66 CD 13433 2223 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2223 22 . . . 13433 2224 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2224 2 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2224 3 refers refer VBZ 13433 2224 4 to to IN 13433 2224 5 Pearson Pearson NNP 13433 2224 6 's 's POS 13433 2224 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2224 8 Vindiciae Vindiciae NNP 13433 2224 9 Ignat Ignat NNP 13433 2224 10 . . . 13433 2224 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2224 12 p. p. NN 13433 2224 13 28 28 CD 13433 2224 14 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2224 15 ed ed NN 13433 2224 16 . . . 13433 2225 1 Churton Churton NNP 13433 2225 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2225 3 . . . 13433 2226 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2226 2 65:1 65:1 CD 13433 2226 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2226 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2226 5 Exam Exam NNP 13433 2226 6 . . . 13433 2227 1 Concilii Concilii NNP 13433 2227 2 Tridentim Tridentim NNP 13433 2227 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2227 4 , , , 13433 2227 5 1614 1614 CD 13433 2227 6 , , , 13433 2227 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2227 8 p. p. NN 13433 2227 9 85 85 CD 13433 2227 10 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2227 11 misprinted misprint VBN 13433 2227 12 89 89 CD 13433 2227 13 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2227 14 . . . 13433 2228 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2228 2 65:2 65:2 CD 13433 2228 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2228 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2228 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2228 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2228 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2228 8 , , , 13433 2228 9 February February NNP 13433 2228 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2228 11 , , , 13433 2228 12 p. p. NN 13433 2228 13 343 343 CD 13433 2228 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2228 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2228 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2228 17 . . . 13433 2228 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2228 19 p. p. NN 13433 2228 20 67 67 CD 13433 2228 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2228 22 . . . 13433 2229 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2229 2 67:1 67:1 CD 13433 2229 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2229 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2229 5 Critici Critici NNP 13433 2229 6 Sacri Sacri NNP 13433 2229 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2229 8 , , , 13433 2229 9 lib lib NNP 13433 2229 10 . . . 13433 2230 1 ii ii NNP 13433 2230 2 cap cap NNP 13433 2230 3 . . . 13433 2231 1 1 1 LS 13433 2231 2 ; ; : 13433 2231 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2231 4 Op Op NNP 13433 2231 5 . . . 13433 2232 1 Theolog Theolog NNP 13433 2232 2 . . . 13433 2232 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2232 4 1652 1652 CD 13433 2232 5 , , , 13433 2232 6 ii ii NNP 13433 2232 7 . . . 13433 2233 1 p. p. NN 13433 2233 2 1086 1086 CD 13433 2233 3 . . . 13433 2234 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2234 2 67:2 67:2 CD 13433 2234 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2234 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2234 5 Vind Vind NNP 13433 2234 6 . . . 13433 2235 1 Ignat ignat JJ 13433 2235 2 . . . 13433 2235 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2235 4 1672 1672 CD 13433 2235 5 , , , 13433 2235 6 p. p. NN 13433 2235 7 14 14 CD 13433 2235 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2235 9 ; ; : 13433 2235 10 Jacobson Jacobson NNP 13433 2235 11 , , , 13433 2235 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2235 13 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2235 14 . . . 13433 2236 1 Apost Apost NNP 13433 2236 2 . . . 13433 2236 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2236 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2236 5 p. p. NNP 13433 2236 6 xxxviii xxxviii NNP 13433 2236 7 . . . 13433 2237 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2237 2 67:3 67:3 CD 13433 2237 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2237 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2237 5 Op Op NNP 13433 2237 6 de de FW 13433 2237 7 Theolog Theolog NNP 13433 2237 8 . . . 13433 2238 1 Dogmat Dogmat NNP 13433 2238 2 . . . 13433 2238 3 , , , 13433 2238 4 De De NNP 13433 2238 5 Eccles Eccles NNP 13433 2238 6 . . . 13433 2239 1 Hierarch Hierarch NNP 13433 2239 2 . . . 13433 2239 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2239 4 v. v. IN 13433 2239 5 8 8 CD 13433 2239 6 § § CD 13433 2239 7 1 1 CD 13433 2239 8 , , , 13433 2239 9 edit edit NN 13433 2239 10 . . . 13433 2240 1 Venetiis Venetiis NNP 13433 2240 2 , , , 13433 2240 3 1757 1757 CD 13433 2240 4 , , , 13433 2240 5 vol vol NNP 13433 2240 6 . . . 13433 2241 1 vii vii NN 13433 2241 2 . . . 13433 2242 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2242 2 68:1 68:1 CD 13433 2242 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2242 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2242 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2242 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2242 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2242 8 , , , 13433 2242 9 February February NNP 13433 2242 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2242 11 , , , 13433 2242 12 p. p. NN 13433 2242 13 343 343 CD 13433 2242 14 f. f. NNP 13433 2242 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2242 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2242 17 ibid ibid NN 13433 2242 18 . . . 13433 2242 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2242 20 p. p. NN 13433 2242 21 67 67 CD 13433 2242 22 f. f. NN 13433 2242 23 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2242 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2242 25 70:1 70:1 CD 13433 2242 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2242 27 _ _ NNP 13433 2242 28 Die Die NNP 13433 2242 29 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 2242 30 i -PRON- PRP 13433 2242 31 m be VBP 13433 2242 32 ap ap NNP 13433 2242 33 . . . 13433 2243 1 Zeit Zeit NNP 13433 2243 2 . . . 13433 2243 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2243 4 p. p. NN 13433 2243 5 322 322 CD 13433 2243 6 . . . 13433 2244 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2244 2 70:2 70:2 CD 13433 2244 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2244 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2244 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2244 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2244 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2244 8 , , , 13433 2244 9 February February NNP 13433 2244 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2244 11 , , , 13433 2244 12 p. p. NN 13433 2244 13 344 344 CD 13433 2244 14 f. f. NNS 13433 2244 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2244 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2244 17 ibid ibid NN 13433 2244 18 . . . 13433 2244 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2244 20 p. p. NN 13433 2245 1 69 69 CD 13433 2245 2 . . . 13433 2245 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2246 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2246 2 72:1 72:1 CD 13433 2246 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2246 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2246 5 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 2246 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2246 7 1842 1842 CD 13433 2246 8 , , , 13433 2246 9 1 1 CD 13433 2246 10 . . . 13433 2246 11 p. p. NN 13433 2246 12 327 327 CD 13433 2246 13 , , , 13433 2246 14 Anm anm CC 13433 2246 15 . . . 13433 2247 1 1 1 LS 13433 2247 2 . . . 13433 2248 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2248 2 73:1 73:1 CD 13433 2248 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2248 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2248 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2248 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2248 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2248 8 , , , 13433 2248 9 February February NNP 13433 2248 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2248 11 , , , 13433 2248 12 p. p. NN 13433 2248 13 345 345 CD 13433 2248 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2248 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2248 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2248 17 . . . 13433 2248 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2248 19 p. p. NN 13433 2248 20 69 69 CD 13433 2248 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2248 22 . . . 13433 2249 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2249 2 75:1 75:1 CD 13433 2249 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2249 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2249 5 Einl Einl NNP 13433 2249 6 . . . 13433 2250 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2250 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2250 3 pp pp NNP 13433 2250 4 . . . 13433 2251 1 144 144 CD 13433 2251 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2251 3 , , , 13433 2251 4 233 233 CD 13433 2251 5 . . . 13433 2252 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2252 2 78:1 78:1 CD 13433 2252 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2252 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2252 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2252 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2252 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2252 8 , , , 13433 2252 9 January January NNP 13433 2252 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2252 11 , , , 13433 2252 12 p. p. NN 13433 2252 13 183 183 CD 13433 2252 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2252 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2252 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2252 17 . . . 13433 2252 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2252 19 p. p. NN 13433 2252 20 51 51 CD 13433 2252 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2252 22 . . . 13433 2253 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2253 2 78:2 78:2 CD 13433 2253 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2253 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2253 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2253 6 . . . 13433 2253 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2253 8 , , , 13433 2253 9 February February NNP 13433 2253 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2253 11 , , , 13433 2253 12 p. p. NN 13433 2253 13 346 346 CD 13433 2253 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2253 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2253 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2253 17 . . . 13433 2253 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2253 19 p. p. NN 13433 2253 20 71 71 CD 13433 2253 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2253 22 . . . 13433 2254 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2254 2 79:1 79:1 CD 13433 2254 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2254 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2254 5 Theolog Theolog NNP 13433 2254 6 . . . 13433 2255 1 Quartalschrift Quartalschrift NNP 13433 2255 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2255 3 , , , 13433 2255 4 1851 1851 CD 13433 2255 5 , , , 13433 2255 6 p. p. NN 13433 2255 7 389 389 CD 13433 2255 8 ff ff NNS 13433 2255 9 . . . 13433 2256 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2256 2 79:2 79:2 CD 13433 2256 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2256 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2256 5 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 2256 6 and and CC 13433 2256 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2256 8 Age Age NNP 13433 2256 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2256 10 , , , 13433 2256 11 1852 1852 CD 13433 2256 12 , , , 13433 2256 13 i. i. NNP 13433 2256 14 p. p. NNP 13433 2256 15 60 60 CD 13433 2256 16 , , , 13433 2256 17 note note VBP 13433 2256 18 , , , 13433 2256 19 iv iv LS 13433 2256 20 . . . 13433 2257 1 p. p. NN 13433 2257 2 vi vi NNP 13433 2257 3 ff ff NNP 13433 2257 4 . . . 13433 2258 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2258 2 79:3 79:3 CD 13433 2258 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2258 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2258 5 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 2258 6 . . . 13433 2259 1 d. d. NNP 13433 2259 2 V. V. NNP 13433 2259 3 Isr Isr NNP 13433 2259 4 . . . 13433 2259 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2259 6 vii vii NN 13433 2259 7 . . . 13433 2260 1 p. p. NN 13433 2260 2 321 321 CD 13433 2260 3 , , , 13433 2260 4 Anm anm CC 13433 2260 5 . . . 13433 2261 1 1 1 LS 13433 2261 2 . . . 13433 2262 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2262 2 80:1 80:1 CD 13433 2262 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2262 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2262 5 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2262 6 . . . 13433 2263 1 Apost apost UH 13433 2263 2 . . . 13433 2264 1 Proleg Proleg NNP 13433 2264 2 . . . 13433 2264 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2264 4 1863 1863 CD 13433 2264 5 , , , 13433 2264 6 p. p. NNP 13433 2264 7 xxx xxx NNP 13433 2264 8 . . . 13433 2265 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2265 2 80:2 80:2 CD 13433 2265 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2265 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2265 5 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2265 6 . . . 13433 2266 1 Apost Apost NNP 13433 2266 2 . . . 13433 2266 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2266 4 ed ed NNP 13433 2266 5 . . . 13433 2267 1 4th 4th NNP 13433 2267 2 , , , 13433 2267 3 1855 1855 CD 13433 2267 4 . . . 13433 2268 1 In in IN 13433 2268 2 a a DT 13433 2268 3 review review NN 13433 2268 4 of of IN 13433 2268 5 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 13433 2268 6 's 's POS 13433 2268 7 work work NN 13433 2268 8 in in IN 13433 2268 9 the the DT 13433 2268 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2268 11 Theolog Theolog NNP 13433 2268 12 . . . 13433 2269 1 Quartalschrift Quartalschrift NNP 13433 2269 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2269 3 , , , 13433 2269 4 1849 1849 CD 13433 2269 5 , , , 13433 2269 6 p. p. NN 13433 2269 7 683 683 CD 13433 2269 8 ff ff NNP 13433 2269 9 . . NNP 13433 2269 10 , , , 13433 2269 11 Hefele Hefele NNP 13433 2269 12 devotes devote VBZ 13433 2269 13 eight eight CD 13433 2269 14 lines line NNS 13433 2269 15 to to IN 13433 2269 16 the the DT 13433 2269 17 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2269 18 version version NN 13433 2269 19 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2269 20 p. p. NN 13433 2269 21 685 685 CD 13433 2269 22 f. f. NN 13433 2269 23 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2269 24 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2269 25 80:3 80:3 CD 13433 2269 26 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2269 27 _ _ NNP 13433 2269 28 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 2269 29 _ _ NNP 13433 2269 30 , , , 13433 2269 31 1852 1852 CD 13433 2269 32 , , , 13433 2269 33 i. i. NNP 13433 2269 34 p. p. NNP 13433 2269 35 60 60 CD 13433 2269 36 , , , 13433 2269 37 note note NN 13433 2269 38 . . . 13433 2270 1 Cf cf NN 13433 2270 2 . . . 13433 2271 1 iv iv XX 13433 2271 2 . . . 13433 2272 1 p. p. NN 13433 2272 2 vi vi NNP 13433 2272 3 ff ff NNP 13433 2272 4 . . . 13433 2273 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2273 2 81:1 81:1 CD 13433 2273 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2273 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2273 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2273 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2273 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2273 8 p. p. NN 13433 2273 9 264 264 CD 13433 2273 10 . . . 13433 2274 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2274 2 81:2 81:2 CD 13433 2274 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2274 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2274 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2274 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2274 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2274 8 , , , 13433 2274 9 February February NNP 13433 2274 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2274 11 , , , 13433 2274 12 p. p. NN 13433 2274 13 347 347 CD 13433 2274 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2274 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2274 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2274 17 . . . 13433 2274 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2274 19 p. p. NN 13433 2274 20 72 72 CD 13433 2274 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2274 22 . . . 13433 2275 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2275 2 82:1 82:1 CD 13433 2275 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2275 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2275 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2275 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2275 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2275 8 , , , 13433 2275 9 February February NNP 13433 2275 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2275 11 , , , 13433 2275 12 p. p. NN 13433 2275 13 348 348 CD 13433 2275 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2275 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2275 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2275 17 . . . 13433 2275 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2275 19 p. p. NN 13433 2275 20 74 74 CD 13433 2275 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2275 22 . . . 13433 2276 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2276 2 82:2 82:2 CD 13433 2276 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2276 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2276 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2276 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2276 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2276 8 p. p. NN 13433 2276 9 265 265 CD 13433 2276 10 . . . 13433 2277 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2277 2 83:1 83:1 CD 13433 2277 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2277 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2277 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2277 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2277 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2277 8 , , , 13433 2277 9 February February NNP 13433 2277 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2277 11 , , , 13433 2277 12 p. p. NN 13433 2277 13 347 347 CD 13433 2277 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2277 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2277 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2277 17 . . . 13433 2277 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2277 19 p. p. NN 13433 2277 20 72 72 CD 13433 2277 21 f. f. NNP 13433 2277 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2277 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2277 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2277 25 makes make VBZ 13433 2277 26 the the DT 13433 2277 27 following follow VBG 13433 2277 28 important important JJ 13433 2277 29 admission admission NN 13433 2277 30 in in IN 13433 2277 31 a a DT 13433 2277 32 note note NN 13433 2277 33 : : : 13433 2277 34 " " `` 13433 2277 35 The the DT 13433 2277 36 Roman Roman NNP 13433 2277 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2277 38 indeed indeed RB 13433 2277 39 has have VBZ 13433 2277 40 been be VBN 13433 2277 41 separated separate VBN 13433 2277 42 from from IN 13433 2277 43 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2277 44 companions companion NNS 13433 2277 45 , , , 13433 2277 46 and and CC 13433 2277 47 is be VBZ 13433 2277 48 embedded embed VBN 13433 2277 49 in in IN 13433 2277 50 the the DT 13433 2277 51 Martyrology Martyrology NNP 13433 2277 52 which which WDT 13433 2277 53 stands stand VBZ 13433 2277 54 at at IN 13433 2277 55 the the DT 13433 2277 56 end end NN 13433 2277 57 of of IN 13433 2277 58 this this DT 13433 2277 59 collection collection NN 13433 2277 60 in in IN 13433 2277 61 the the DT 13433 2277 62 Latin Latin NNP 13433 2277 63 Version Version NNP 13433 2277 64 , , , 13433 2277 65 where where WRB 13433 2277 66 doubtless doubtless RB 13433 2277 67 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2277 68 stood stand VBD 13433 2277 69 also also RB 13433 2277 70 in in IN 13433 2277 71 the the DT 13433 2277 72 Greek Greek NNP 13433 2277 73 , , , 13433 2277 74 before before IN 13433 2277 75 the the DT 13433 2277 76 MS MS NNP 13433 2277 77 . . NNP 13433 2277 78 of of IN 13433 2277 79 this this DT 13433 2277 80 latter latter NN 13433 2277 81 was be VBD 13433 2277 82 mutilated mutilate VBN 13433 2277 83 . . . 13433 2278 1 Otherwise otherwise RB 13433 2278 2 the the DT 13433 2278 3 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 2278 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2278 5 come come VB 13433 2278 6 together together RB 13433 2278 7 , , , 13433 2278 8 and and CC 13433 2278 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2278 10 are be VBP 13433 2278 11 followed follow VBN 13433 2278 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2278 13 by by IN 13433 2278 14 the the DT 13433 2278 15 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 2278 16 spurious spurious JJ 13433 2278 17 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2278 18 in in IN 13433 2278 19 the the DT 13433 2278 20 Greek Greek NNP 13433 2278 21 and and CC 13433 2278 22 Latin Latin NNP 13433 2278 23 MSS MSS NNP 13433 2278 24 . . . 13433 2279 1 In in IN 13433 2279 2 the the DT 13433 2279 3 Armenian armenian NN 13433 2279 4 all all PDT 13433 2279 5 the the DT 13433 2279 6 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 2279 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2279 8 are be VBP 13433 2279 9 together together RB 13433 2279 10 , , , 13433 2279 11 and and CC 13433 2279 12 the the DT 13433 2279 13 confessedly confessedly RB 13433 2279 14 spurious spurious JJ 13433 2279 15 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2279 16 follow follow VBP 13433 2279 17 . . . 13433 2280 1 See See NNP 13433 2280 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2280 3 , , , 13433 2280 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2280 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2280 6 von von NNP 13433 2280 7 Antiochien Antiochien NNP 13433 2280 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2280 9 , , , 13433 2280 10 p. p. NN 13433 2281 1 111 111 CD 13433 2281 2 . . . 13433 2281 3 " " '' 13433 2282 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2282 2 83:2 83:2 CD 13433 2282 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2282 4 Note note VB 13433 2282 5 to to IN 13433 2282 6 Horne Horne NNP 13433 2282 7 's 's POS 13433 2282 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2282 9 Int Int NNP 13433 2282 10 . . . 13433 2283 1 to to IN 13433 2283 2 the the DT 13433 2283 3 Holy Holy NNP 13433 2283 4 Scriptures Scriptures NNPS 13433 2283 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2283 6 , , , 13433 2283 7 12th 12th JJ 13433 2283 8 ed ed NN 13433 2283 9 . . . 13433 2284 1 1869 1869 CD 13433 2284 2 , , , 13433 2284 3 iv iv NNP 13433 2284 4 . . . 13433 2285 1 p. p. NN 13433 2285 2 332 332 CD 13433 2285 3 , , , 13433 2285 4 note note VB 13433 2285 5 1 1 CD 13433 2285 6 . . . 13433 2286 1 The the DT 13433 2286 2 italics italic NNS 13433 2286 3 are be VBP 13433 2286 4 in in IN 13433 2286 5 the the DT 13433 2286 6 original original NN 13433 2286 7 . . . 13433 2287 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2287 2 83:3 83:3 CD 13433 2287 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2287 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2287 5 The the DT 13433 2287 6 Ancient Ancient NNP 13433 2287 7 Syrian Syrian NNP 13433 2287 8 Version Version NNP 13433 2287 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2287 10 , , , 13433 2287 11 & & CC 13433 2287 12 c. c. NNP 13433 2287 13 1845 1845 CD 13433 2287 14 , , , 13433 2287 15 p. p. NNP 13433 2287 16 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 2287 17 f. f. NNP 13433 2287 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2287 19 84:1 84:1 CD 13433 2287 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2287 21 _ _ NNP 13433 2287 22 Corpus Corpus NNP 13433 2287 23 Ignat Ignat NNP 13433 2287 24 . . . 13433 2287 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2287 26 p. p. NN 13433 2287 27 338 338 CD 13433 2287 28 . . . 13433 2288 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2288 2 84:2 84:2 CD 13433 2288 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2288 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2288 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2288 6 . . . 13433 2288 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2288 8 p. p. NNP 13433 2288 9 ii ii NNP 13433 2288 10 . . . 13433 2289 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2289 2 84:3 84:3 CD 13433 2289 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2289 4 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 2289 5 , , , 13433 2289 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2289 7 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2289 8 . . . 13433 2290 1 Ap Ap NNP 13433 2290 2 . . NNP 13433 2290 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2290 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2290 5 lvi lvi NNP 13433 2290 6 . . . 13433 2291 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2291 2 84:4 84:4 CD 13433 2291 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2291 4 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 2291 5 , , , 13433 2291 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2291 7 Corp. Corp. NNP 13433 2292 1 Ign Ign NNP 13433 2292 2 . . . 13433 2292 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2292 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2292 5 iii iii NNP 13433 2292 6 . . . 13433 2293 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2293 2 84:5 84:5 CD 13433 2293 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2293 4 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 2293 5 , , , 13433 2293 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2293 7 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2293 8 . . . 13433 2294 1 Ap Ap NNP 13433 2294 2 . . NNP 13433 2294 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2294 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2294 5 lvii lvii NNP 13433 2294 6 f. f. . 13433 2294 7 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2294 8 84:6 84:6 CD 13433 2294 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2294 10 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 2294 11 , , , 13433 2294 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2294 13 Corp. Corp. NNP 13433 2295 1 Ignat ignat JJ 13433 2295 2 . . . 13433 2295 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2295 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2295 5 vii vii NNP 13433 2295 6 f. f. NNP 13433 2295 7 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2295 8 84:7 84:7 CD 13433 2295 9 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2295 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2295 11 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2295 12 . . . 13433 2295 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2295 14 p. p. NN 13433 2295 15 xi xi NNP 13433 2295 16 ; ; : 13433 2295 17 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 2295 18 , , , 13433 2295 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2295 20 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2295 21 . . . 13433 2296 1 Ap Ap NNP 13433 2296 2 . . NNP 13433 2296 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2296 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2296 5 xxxi xxxi NNP 13433 2296 6 ; ; : 13433 2296 7 cf cf NNP 13433 2296 8 . . . 13433 2297 1 p. p. NN 13433 2297 2 lxii lxii NNP 13433 2297 3 ; ; : 13433 2297 4 Jacobson Jacobson NNP 13433 2297 5 , , , 13433 2297 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2297 7 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2297 8 . . . 13433 2298 1 Ap Ap NNP 13433 2298 2 . . NNP 13433 2298 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2298 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2298 5 p. p. NNP 13433 2298 6 lxxiii lxxiii NN 13433 2298 7 ; ; : 13433 2298 8 Vossius Vossius NNP 13433 2298 9 , , , 13433 2298 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2298 11 Ep Ep NNP 13433 2298 12 . . . 13433 2299 1 gen gen NNP 13433 2299 2 . . NNP 13433 2299 3 S. S. NNP 13433 2299 4 Ign Ign NNP 13433 2299 5 . . . 13433 2300 1 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2300 2 . . . 13433 2300 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2300 4 , , , 13433 2300 5 Amstel Amstel NNP 13433 2300 6 . . . 13433 2301 1 1646 1646 CD 13433 2301 2 . . . 13433 2302 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2302 2 84:8 84:8 CD 13433 2302 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2302 4 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 2302 5 , , , 13433 2302 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2302 7 Patr Patr NNP 13433 2302 8 . . . 13433 2303 1 Ap Ap NNP 13433 2303 2 . . NNP 13433 2303 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2303 4 p. p. NNP 13433 2303 5 lxi lxi NNP 13433 2303 6 . . . 13433 2304 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2304 2 86:1 86:1 NN 13433 2304 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2304 4 " " `` 13433 2304 5 A a DT 13433 2304 6 Few few JJ 13433 2304 7 Words word NNS 13433 2304 8 on on IN 13433 2304 9 ' ' `` 13433 2304 10 Supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 2304 11 Religion religion NN 13433 2304 12 , , , 13433 2304 13 ' ' '' 13433 2304 14 " " `` 13433 2304 15 pref pref NN 13433 2304 16 . . . 13433 2305 1 to to IN 13433 2305 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2305 3 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2305 4 . . . 13433 2306 1 of of IN 13433 2306 2 the the DT 13433 2306 3 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2306 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2306 5 , , , 13433 2306 6 4th 4th JJ 13433 2306 7 ed ed NN 13433 2306 8 . . . 13433 2307 1 1874 1874 CD 13433 2307 2 , , , 13433 2307 3 p. p. NN 13433 2307 4 xix xix NNP 13433 2307 5 . . . 13433 2308 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2308 2 87:1 87:1 CD 13433 2308 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2308 4 " " `` 13433 2308 5 A a DT 13433 2308 6 Few few JJ 13433 2308 7 Words word NNS 13433 2308 8 on on IN 13433 2308 9 ' ' `` 13433 2308 10 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2308 11 , , , 13433 2308 12 ' ' '' 13433 2308 13 " " `` 13433 2308 14 preface preface NN 13433 2308 15 to to IN 13433 2308 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2308 17 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2308 18 . . . 13433 2309 1 of of IN 13433 2309 2 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2309 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2309 4 , , , 13433 2309 5 4th 4th JJ 13433 2309 6 ed ed NN 13433 2309 7 . . . 13433 2310 1 p. p. NNP 13433 2310 2 xix xix NNP 13433 2310 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2310 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2310 5 87:2 87:2 CD 13433 2310 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2310 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2310 8 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2310 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2310 10 i. i. NNP 13433 2310 11 p. p. NN 13433 2310 12 268 268 CD 13433 2310 13 . . . 13433 2311 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2311 2 88:1 88:1 CD 13433 2311 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2311 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2311 5 On on IN 13433 2311 6 the the DT 13433 2311 7 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2311 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2311 9 , , , 13433 2311 10 Preface Preface NNP 13433 2311 11 , , , 13433 2311 12 4th 4th JJ 13433 2311 13 ed ed NN 13433 2311 14 . . . 13433 2312 1 p. p. NN 13433 2312 2 xx xx NNP 13433 2312 3 . . . 13433 2313 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2313 2 89:1 89:1 CD 13433 2313 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2313 4 These these DT 13433 2313 5 consist consist VBP 13433 2313 6 only only RB 13433 2313 7 of of IN 13433 2313 8 an an DT 13433 2313 9 additional additional JJ 13433 2313 10 page page NN 13433 2313 11 of of IN 13433 2313 12 Baur Baur NNP 13433 2313 13 's 's POS 13433 2313 14 work work NN 13433 2313 15 first first RB 13433 2313 16 quoted quote VBD 13433 2313 17 , , , 13433 2313 18 and and CC 13433 2313 19 a a DT 13433 2313 20 reference reference NN 13433 2313 21 to to IN 13433 2313 22 another another DT 13433 2313 23 of of IN 13433 2313 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2313 25 works work NNS 13433 2313 26 quoted quote VBN 13433 2313 27 in in IN 13433 2313 28 the the DT 13433 2313 29 second second JJ 13433 2313 30 note note NN 13433 2313 31 , , , 13433 2313 32 but but CC 13433 2313 33 accidentally accidentally RB 13433 2313 34 left leave VBD 13433 2313 35 out out IN 13433 2313 36 of of IN 13433 2313 37 note note NN 13433 2313 38 3 3 CD 13433 2313 39 . . . 13433 2314 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2314 2 90:1 90:1 NN 13433 2314 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2314 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2314 5 take take VBP 13433 2314 6 the the DT 13433 2314 7 liberty liberty NN 13433 2314 8 of of IN 13433 2314 9 putting put VBG 13433 2314 10 these these DT 13433 2314 11 words word NNS 13433 2314 12 in in IN 13433 2314 13 italics italic NNS 13433 2314 14 to to TO 13433 2314 15 call call VB 13433 2314 16 attention attention NN 13433 2314 17 to to IN 13433 2314 18 the the DT 13433 2314 19 assertion assertion NN 13433 2314 20 opposed oppose VBN 13433 2314 21 to to IN 13433 2314 22 what what WP 13433 2314 23 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2314 24 find find VBP 13433 2314 25 in in IN 13433 2314 26 the the DT 13433 2314 27 note note NN 13433 2314 28 . . . 13433 2315 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2315 2 91:1 91:1 CD 13433 2315 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2315 4 It -PRON- PRP 13433 2315 5 is be VBZ 13433 2315 6 the the DT 13433 2315 7 same same JJ 13433 2315 8 work work NN 13433 2315 9 , , , 13433 2315 10 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2315 11 believe believe VBP 13433 2315 12 , , , 13433 2315 13 subsequently subsequently RB 13433 2315 14 published publish VBN 13433 2315 15 in in IN 13433 2315 16 an an DT 13433 2315 17 extended extended JJ 13433 2315 18 form form NN 13433 2315 19 . . . 13433 2316 1 The the DT 13433 2316 2 work work NN 13433 2316 3 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2316 4 quote quote VBP 13433 2316 5 is be VBZ 13433 2316 6 entitled entitle VBN 13433 2316 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2316 8 Kirchengeschichte Kirchengeschichte NNP 13433 2316 9 der der RB 13433 2316 10 ersten ersten VBN 13433 2316 11 sechs sechs NN 13433 2316 12 Jahrhunderte Jahrhunderte NNP 13433 2316 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2316 14 , , , 13433 2316 15 dritte dritte NN 13433 2316 16 , , , 13433 2316 17 umgearbeitete umgearbeitete JJ 13433 2316 18 Auflage Auflage NNP 13433 2316 19 , , , 13433 2316 20 1869 1869 CD 13433 2316 21 , , , 13433 2316 22 and and CC 13433 2316 23 is be VBZ 13433 2316 24 part part NN 13433 2316 25 of of IN 13433 2316 26 a a DT 13433 2316 27 course course NN 13433 2316 28 of of IN 13433 2316 29 lectures lecture NNS 13433 2316 30 carrying carry VBG 13433 2316 31 the the DT 13433 2316 32 history history NN 13433 2316 33 to to IN 13433 2316 34 the the DT 13433 2316 35 nineteenth nineteenth JJ 13433 2316 36 century century NN 13433 2316 37 . . . 13433 2317 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2317 2 92:1 92:1 CD 13433 2317 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2317 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2317 5 do do VBP 13433 2317 6 not not RB 13433 2317 7 know know VB 13433 2317 8 why why WRB 13433 2317 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2317 10 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2317 11 adds add VBZ 13433 2317 12 the the DT 13433 2317 13 ' ' `` 13433 2317 14 ff ff NN 13433 2317 15 ' ' '' 13433 2317 16 to to IN 13433 2317 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2317 18 reference reference NN 13433 2317 19 , , , 13433 2317 20 but but CC 13433 2317 21 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2317 22 presume presume VBP 13433 2317 23 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2317 24 is be VBZ 13433 2317 25 taken take VBN 13433 2317 26 from from IN 13433 2317 27 note note NN 13433 2317 28 4 4 CD 13433 2317 29 , , , 13433 2317 30 where where WRB 13433 2317 31 the the DT 13433 2317 32 reference reference NN 13433 2317 33 is be VBZ 13433 2317 34 given give VBN 13433 2317 35 to to IN 13433 2317 36 ' ' '' 13433 2317 37 p. p. NN 13433 2318 1 52 52 CD 13433 2318 2 ff ff NN 13433 2318 3 . . . 13433 2318 4 ' ' '' 13433 2319 1 This this DT 13433 2319 2 shows show VBZ 13433 2319 3 how how WRB 13433 2319 4 completely completely RB 13433 2319 5 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2319 6 has have VBZ 13433 2319 7 failed fail VBN 13433 2319 8 to to TO 13433 2319 9 see see VB 13433 2319 10 the the DT 13433 2319 11 different different JJ 13433 2319 12 object object NN 13433 2319 13 of of IN 13433 2319 14 the the DT 13433 2319 15 two two CD 13433 2319 16 notes note NNS 13433 2319 17 . . . 13433 2320 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2320 2 93:1 93:1 CD 13433 2320 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2320 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2320 5 On on IN 13433 2320 6 the the DT 13433 2320 7 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2320 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2320 9 , , , 13433 2320 10 Pref Pref NNP 13433 2320 11 . . . 13433 2321 1 4th 4th NNP 13433 2321 2 ed ed NNP 13433 2321 3 . . . 13433 2322 1 p. p. NN 13433 2322 2 xxi xxi NNP 13433 2322 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2322 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2322 5 97:1 97:1 CD 13433 2322 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2322 7 P. P. NNP 13433 2322 8 213 213 CD 13433 2322 9 . . . 13433 2323 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2323 2 98:1 98:1 CD 13433 2323 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2323 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2323 5 On on IN 13433 2323 6 the the DT 13433 2323 7 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2323 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2323 9 , , , 13433 2323 10 Preface Preface NNP 13433 2323 11 , , , 13433 2323 12 4th 4th JJ 13433 2323 13 ed ed NN 13433 2323 14 . . . 13433 2324 1 p. p. NNP 13433 2324 2 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 2324 3 . . . 13433 2325 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2325 2 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2325 3 adds add VBZ 13433 2325 4 , , , 13433 2325 5 in in IN 13433 2325 6 a a DT 13433 2325 7 note note NN 13433 2325 8 , , , 13433 2325 9 " " `` 13433 2325 10 It -PRON- PRP 13433 2325 11 may may MD 13433 2325 12 be be VB 13433 2325 13 worth worth JJ 13433 2325 14 while while IN 13433 2325 15 to to TO 13433 2325 16 add add VB 13433 2325 17 that that IN 13433 2325 18 in in IN 13433 2325 19 spite spite NN 13433 2325 20 of of IN 13433 2325 21 the the DT 13433 2325 22 profuse profuse NN 13433 2325 23 display display NN 13433 2325 24 of of IN 13433 2325 25 learning learn VBG 13433 2325 26 in in IN 13433 2325 27 connection connection NN 13433 2325 28 with with IN 13433 2325 29 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2325 30 , , , 13433 2325 31 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2325 32 do do VBP 13433 2325 33 not not RB 13433 2325 34 see see VB 13433 2325 35 even even RB 13433 2325 36 in in IN 13433 2325 37 the the DT 13433 2325 38 second second JJ 13433 2325 39 edition edition NN 13433 2325 40 any any DT 13433 2325 41 reference reference NN 13433 2325 42 to to IN 13433 2325 43 the the DT 13433 2325 44 full full JJ 13433 2325 45 and and CC 13433 2325 46 elaborate elaborate JJ 13433 2325 47 work work NN 13433 2325 48 of of IN 13433 2325 49 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2325 50 . . . 13433 2325 51 " " '' 13433 2326 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2326 2 might may MD 13433 2326 3 reply reply VB 13433 2326 4 to to IN 13433 2326 5 this this DT 13433 2326 6 that that IN 13433 2326 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2326 8 MS MS NNP 13433 2326 9 . . NNP 13433 2326 10 had have VBD 13433 2326 11 left leave VBN 13433 2326 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2326 13 hands hand NNS 13433 2326 14 before before IN 13433 2326 15 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2326 16 's 's POS 13433 2326 17 work work NN 13433 2326 18 had have VBD 13433 2326 19 reached reach VBN 13433 2326 20 England England NNP 13433 2326 21 , , , 13433 2326 22 but but CC 13433 2326 23 , , , 13433 2326 24 moreover moreover RB 13433 2326 25 , , , 13433 2326 26 the the DT 13433 2326 27 work work NN 13433 2326 28 contains contain VBZ 13433 2326 29 nothing nothing NN 13433 2326 30 new new JJ 13433 2326 31 to to TO 13433 2326 32 which which WDT 13433 2326 33 reference reference NN 13433 2326 34 was be VBD 13433 2326 35 necessary necessary JJ 13433 2326 36 . . . 13433 2327 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2327 2 99:1 99:1 CD 13433 2327 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2327 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2327 5 On On NNP 13433 2327 6 the the DT 13433 2327 7 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2327 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2327 9 , , , 13433 2327 10 Preface Preface NNP 13433 2327 11 , , , 13433 2327 12 4th 4th JJ 13433 2327 13 ed ed NN 13433 2327 14 . . . 13433 2328 1 p p NNP 13433 2328 2 xxv xxv NNP 13433 2328 3 . . . 13433 2329 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2329 2 100:1 100:1 LS 13433 2329 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2329 4 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 13433 2329 5 , , , 13433 2329 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2329 7 Acta Acta NNP 13433 2329 8 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2329 9 . . . 13433 2329 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2329 11 p. p. NN 13433 2329 12 137 137 CD 13433 2329 13 ff ff NN 13433 2329 14 . . . 13433 2330 1 ; ; : 13433 2330 2 cf cf NN 13433 2330 3 . . . 13433 2331 1 Baronius Baronius NNP 13433 2331 2 , , , 13433 2331 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2331 4 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2331 5 . . . 13433 2332 1 Rom Rom NNP 13433 2332 2 . . . 13433 2332 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2332 4 1631 1631 CD 13433 2332 5 , , , 13433 2332 6 p. p. NN 13433 2332 7 152 152 CD 13433 2332 8 . . . 13433 2333 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2333 2 100:2 100:2 LS 13433 2333 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2333 4 Cf cf NN 13433 2333 5 . . . 13433 2334 1 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 2334 2 , , , 13433 2334 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2334 4 Credibility Credibility NNP 13433 2334 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2334 6 , , , 13433 2334 7 & & CC 13433 2334 8 c. c. NNP 13433 2334 9 , , , 13433 2334 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2334 11 Works Works NNP 13433 2334 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2334 13 , , , 13433 2334 14 iii iii NNP 13433 2334 15 . . . 13433 2335 1 p. p. NN 13433 2335 2 3 3 CD 13433 2335 3 . . . 13433 2336 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2336 2 101:1 101:1 CD 13433 2336 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2336 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2336 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2336 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2336 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2336 8 , , , 13433 2336 9 February February NNP 13433 2336 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2336 11 , , , 13433 2336 12 p. p. NN 13433 2336 13 349 349 CD 13433 2336 14 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2336 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2336 16 ibid ibid NN 13433 2336 17 . . . 13433 2336 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2336 19 p. p. NN 13433 2336 20 75 75 CD 13433 2336 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2336 22 . . . 13433 2337 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2337 2 101:2 101:2 CD 13433 2337 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2337 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2337 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2337 6 . . . 13433 2337 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2337 8 p. p. NN 13433 2337 9 350 350 CD 13433 2337 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2337 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2337 12 ibid ibid NN 13433 2337 13 . . . 13433 2337 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2337 15 p. p. NN 13433 2337 16 76 76 CD 13433 2337 17 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2337 18 . . . 13433 2338 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2338 2 102:1 102:1 CD 13433 2338 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2338 4 There there EX 13433 2338 5 are be VBP 13433 2338 6 grave grave JJ 13433 2338 7 reasons reason NNS 13433 2338 8 for for IN 13433 2338 9 considering consider VBG 13433 2338 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2338 11 altogether altogether RB 13433 2338 12 inauthentic inauthentic JJ 13433 2338 13 . . . 13433 2339 1 Cf cf NN 13433 2339 2 . . . 13433 2340 1 Cotterill Cotterill NNP 13433 2340 2 , , , 13433 2340 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2340 4 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 2340 5 Proteus Proteus NNP 13433 2340 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2340 7 , , , 13433 2340 8 1879 1879 CD 13433 2340 9 . . . 13433 2341 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2341 2 102:2 102:2 CD 13433 2341 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2341 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2341 5 De De NNP 13433 2341 6 Morte Morte NNP 13433 2341 7 Peregr Peregr NNP 13433 2341 8 . . . 13433 2341 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2341 10 11 11 CD 13433 2341 11 . . . 13433 2342 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2342 2 102:3 102:3 CD 13433 2342 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2342 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2342 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2342 6 . . . 13433 2342 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2342 8 14 14 CD 13433 2342 9 . . . 13433 2343 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2343 2 102:4 102:4 CD 13433 2343 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2343 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2343 5 Gesch Gesch NNP 13433 2343 6 . . . 13433 2344 1 chr chr NNP 13433 2344 2 . . . 13433 2345 1 Kirche Kirche NNP 13433 2345 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2345 3 , , , 13433 2345 4 i. i. NNP 13433 2345 5 p. p. NNP 13433 2345 6 410 410 CD 13433 2345 7 f. f. NNS 13433 2345 8 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2345 9 103:1 103:1 CD 13433 2345 10 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2345 11 See see VB 13433 2345 12 , , , 13433 2345 13 for for IN 13433 2345 14 instance instance NN 13433 2345 15 , , , 13433 2345 16 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 13433 2345 17 , , , 13433 2345 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2345 19 Ueber Ueber NNP 13433 2345 20 die die VBP 13433 2345 21 Aechtheit Aechtheit NNP 13433 2345 22 d. d. NNP 13433 2345 23 bish bish NNP 13433 2345 24 . . . 13433 2346 1 Textes texte NNS 13433 2346 2 d. d. NNP 13433 2346 3 Ignat Ignat NNP 13433 2346 4 . . . 13433 2347 1 Briefe Briefe NNP 13433 2347 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2347 3 , , , 13433 2347 4 1849 1849 CD 13433 2347 5 , , , 13433 2347 6 p. p. NN 13433 2347 7 87 87 CD 13433 2347 8 ff ff NN 13433 2347 9 . . . 13433 2348 1 ; ; : 13433 2348 2 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2348 3 , , , 13433 2348 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2348 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2348 6 v. v. IN 13433 2348 7 Ant Ant NNP 13433 2348 8 . . . 13433 2348 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2348 10 , , , 13433 2348 11 1873 1873 CD 13433 2348 12 , , , 13433 2348 13 p. p. NN 13433 2348 14 517 517 CD 13433 2348 15 ff ff NNS 13433 2348 16 . . . 13433 2349 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2349 2 103:2 103:2 CD 13433 2349 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2349 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2349 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2349 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2349 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2349 8 , , , 13433 2349 9 February February NNP 13433 2349 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2349 11 , , , 13433 2349 12 p. p. NN 13433 2349 13 350 350 CD 13433 2349 14 f. f. NNS 13433 2349 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2349 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2349 17 ibid ibid NN 13433 2349 18 . . . 13433 2349 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2349 20 p. p. NN 13433 2349 21 77 77 CD 13433 2349 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2349 23 . . . 13433 2350 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2350 2 104:1 104:1 LS 13433 2350 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2350 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2350 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2350 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2350 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2350 8 p. p. NN 13433 2350 9 268 268 CD 13433 2350 10 , , , 13433 2350 11 note note VBP 13433 2350 12 4 4 CD 13433 2350 13 . . . 13433 2351 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2351 2 105:1 105:1 LS 13433 2351 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2351 4 Dean Dean NNP 13433 2351 5 Milman Milman NNP 13433 2351 6 says say VBZ 13433 2351 7 : : : 13433 2351 8 " " `` 13433 2351 9 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 2351 10 , , , 13433 2351 11 indeed indeed RB 13433 2351 12 , , , 13433 2351 13 is be VBZ 13433 2351 14 absolved absolve VBN 13433 2351 15 , , , 13433 2351 16 at at IN 13433 2351 17 least least JJS 13433 2351 18 by by IN 13433 2351 19 the the DT 13433 2351 20 almost almost RB 13433 2351 21 general general JJ 13433 2351 22 voice voice NN 13433 2351 23 of of IN 13433 2351 24 antiquity antiquity NN 13433 2351 25 , , , 13433 2351 26 from from IN 13433 2351 27 the the DT 13433 2351 28 crime crime NN 13433 2351 29 of of IN 13433 2351 30 persecuting persecute VBG 13433 2351 31 the the DT 13433 2351 32 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 2351 33 . . . 13433 2351 34 " " '' 13433 2352 1 In in IN 13433 2352 2 a a DT 13433 2352 3 note note NN 13433 2352 4 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2352 5 adds add VBZ 13433 2352 6 : : : 13433 2352 7 " " `` 13433 2352 8 Excepting Excepting NNP 13433 2352 9 of of IN 13433 2352 10 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2352 11 , , , 13433 2352 12 probably probably RB 13433 2352 13 of of IN 13433 2352 14 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 2352 15 of of IN 13433 2352 16 Jerusalem Jerusalem NNP 13433 2352 17 , , , 13433 2352 18 there there EX 13433 2352 19 is be VBZ 13433 2352 20 no no DT 13433 2352 21 authentic authentic JJ 13433 2352 22 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2352 23 in in IN 13433 2352 24 the the DT 13433 2352 25 reign reign NN 13433 2352 26 of of IN 13433 2352 27 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 2352 28 . . . 13433 2352 29 "--_Hist "--_Hist '' 13433 2352 30 . . . 13433 2353 1 of of IN 13433 2353 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2353 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2353 4 , , , 13433 2353 5 1867 1867 CD 13433 2353 6 , , , 13433 2353 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2353 8 . . . 13433 2354 1 p. p. NN 13433 2354 2 103 103 CD 13433 2354 3 . . . 13433 2355 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2355 2 106:1 106:1 CD 13433 2355 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2355 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2355 5 K.G. K.G. NNP 13433 2355 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2355 7 1842 1842 CD 13433 2355 8 , , , 13433 2355 9 i. i. NNP 13433 2355 10 p. p. NN 13433 2355 11 171 171 CD 13433 2355 12 . . . 13433 2356 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2356 2 106:2 106:2 CD 13433 2356 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2356 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2356 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2356 6 . . . 13433 2356 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2356 8 i. i. NNP 13433 2356 9 p. p. NN 13433 2356 10 172 172 CD 13433 2356 11 , , , 13433 2356 12 Anm Anm NNP 13433 2356 13 . . . 13433 2357 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2357 2 108:1 108:1 CD 13433 2357 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2357 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2357 5 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2357 6 . . . 13433 2358 1 of of IN 13433 2358 2 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2358 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2358 4 , , , 13433 2358 5 ii ii NNP 13433 2358 6 . . . 13433 2359 1 p. p. NN 13433 2359 2 101 101 CD 13433 2359 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2359 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2359 5 109:1 109:1 CD 13433 2359 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2359 7 P. P. NNP 13433 2359 8 276 276 CD 13433 2359 9 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2359 10 ed ed NN 13433 2359 11 . . . 13433 2360 1 Bonn Bonn NNP 13433 2360 2 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2360 3 . . . 13433 2361 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2361 2 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2361 3 Review Review NNP 13433 2361 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2361 5 , , , 13433 2361 6 February February NNP 13433 2361 7 1875 1875 CD 13433 2361 8 , , , 13433 2361 9 p. p. NN 13433 2361 10 352 352 CD 13433 2361 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2361 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2361 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2361 14 . . . 13433 2361 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2361 16 p. p. NN 13433 2361 17 79 79 CD 13433 2361 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2361 19 . . . 13433 2362 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2362 2 109:2 109:2 CD 13433 2362 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2362 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2362 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2362 6 . . . 13433 2362 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2362 8 p. p. NN 13433 2362 9 353 353 CD 13433 2362 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2362 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2362 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2362 13 ibid ibid NN 13433 2362 14 . . . 13433 2362 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2362 16 p. p. NN 13433 2362 17 80 80 CD 13433 2362 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2362 19 . . . 13433 2363 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2363 2 109:3 109:3 LS 13433 2363 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2363 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2363 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2363 6 . . . 13433 2363 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2363 8 p. p. NN 13433 2363 9 352 352 CD 13433 2363 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2363 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2363 12 ibid ibid NN 13433 2363 13 . . . 13433 2363 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2363 15 p. p. NN 13433 2363 16 79 79 CD 13433 2363 17 f. f. NNP 13433 2363 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2363 19 . . . 13433 2364 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2364 2 110:1 110:1 CD 13433 2364 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2364 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2364 5 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2364 6 Review Review NNP 13433 2364 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2364 8 , , , 13433 2364 9 February February NNP 13433 2364 10 1875 1875 CD 13433 2364 11 , , , 13433 2364 12 p. p. NN 13433 2364 13 353 353 CD 13433 2364 14 f. f. NNP 13433 2364 15 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2364 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2364 17 ibid ibid NN 13433 2364 18 . . . 13433 2364 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2364 20 p. p. NN 13433 2364 21 81 81 CD 13433 2364 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2364 23 . . . 13433 2365 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2365 2 110:2 110:2 LS 13433 2365 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2365 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2365 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2365 6 v. v. IN 13433 2365 7 Ant Ant NNP 13433 2365 8 . . . 13433 2365 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2365 10 p. p. NN 13433 2365 11 66 66 CD 13433 2365 12 , , , 13433 2365 13 Anm anm NN 13433 2365 14 . . . 13433 2366 1 3 3 LS 13433 2366 2 . . . 13433 2367 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2367 2 111:1 111:1 LS 13433 2367 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2367 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2367 5 need need VBP 13433 2367 6 not not RB 13433 2367 7 refer refer VB 13433 2367 8 to to IN 13433 2367 9 the the DT 13433 2367 10 statement statement NN 13433 2367 11 of of IN 13433 2367 12 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 13433 2367 13 that that IN 13433 2367 14 these these DT 13433 2367 15 relics relic NNS 13433 2367 16 were be VBD 13433 2367 17 first first RB 13433 2367 18 brought bring VBN 13433 2367 19 from from IN 13433 2367 20 Rome Rome NNP 13433 2367 21 to to IN 13433 2367 22 Constantinople Constantinople NNP 13433 2367 23 and and CC 13433 2367 24 afterwards afterwards RB 13433 2367 25 translated translate VBN 13433 2367 26 to to IN 13433 2367 27 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 2367 28 . . . 13433 2368 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2368 2 112:1 112:1 CD 13433 2368 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2368 4 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 13433 2368 5 , , , 13433 2368 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2368 7 Acta Acta NNP 13433 2368 8 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2368 9 . . . 13433 2368 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2368 11 pp pp NNP 13433 2368 12 . . . 13433 2369 1 59 59 CD 13433 2369 2 , , , 13433 2369 3 69 69 CD 13433 2369 4 . . . 13433 2370 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2370 2 112:2 112:2 CD 13433 2370 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2370 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2370 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2370 6 v. v. IN 13433 2370 7 Ant Ant NNP 13433 2370 8 . . . 13433 2370 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2370 10 p p NNP 13433 2370 11 , , , 13433 2370 12 68 68 CD 13433 2370 13 . . . 13433 2371 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2371 2 112:3 112:3 LS 13433 2371 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2371 4 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 13433 2371 5 , , , 13433 2371 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2371 7 Acta Acta NNP 13433 2371 8 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2371 9 . . . 13433 2371 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2371 11 p. p. NN 13433 2371 12 56 56 CD 13433 2371 13 . . . 13433 2372 1 Baronius Baronius NNP 13433 2372 2 makes make VBZ 13433 2372 3 the the DT 13433 2372 4 anniversary anniversary NN 13433 2372 5 of of IN 13433 2372 6 the the DT 13433 2372 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2372 8 1st 1st JJ 13433 2372 9 February February NNP 13433 2372 10 , , , 13433 2372 11 and and CC 13433 2372 12 that that DT 13433 2372 13 of of IN 13433 2372 14 the the DT 13433 2372 15 translation translation NN 13433 2372 16 17th 17th NN 13433 2372 17 December December NNP 13433 2372 18 . . . 13433 2373 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2373 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2373 3 Mart Mart NNP 13433 2373 4 . . . 13433 2374 1 Rom Rom NNP 13433 2374 2 . . . 13433 2374 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2374 4 pp pp NNP 13433 2374 5 . . . 13433 2375 1 87 87 CD 13433 2375 2 , , , 13433 2375 3 766 766 CD 13433 2375 4 ff ff NN 13433 2375 5 . . . 13433 2375 6 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2376 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2376 2 112:4 112:4 CD 13433 2376 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2376 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2376 5 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2376 6 v. v. IN 13433 2376 7 Ant Ant NNP 13433 2376 8 . . . 13433 2376 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2376 10 p. p. NN 13433 2376 11 27 27 CD 13433 2376 12 , , , 13433 2376 13 p. p. NN 13433 2376 14 68 68 CD 13433 2376 15 , , , 13433 2376 16 Anm anm NN 13433 2376 17 . . . 13433 2377 1 2 2 LS 13433 2377 2 . . . 13433 2378 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2378 2 112:5 112:5 LS 13433 2378 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2378 4 There there EX 13433 2378 5 is be VBZ 13433 2378 6 no no DT 13433 2378 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 13433 2378 8 evidence evidence NN 13433 2378 9 for for IN 13433 2378 10 the the DT 13433 2378 11 statement statement NN 13433 2378 12 that that IN 13433 2378 13 , , , 13433 2378 14 in in IN 13433 2378 15 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 2378 16 's 's POS 13433 2378 17 time time NN 13433 2378 18 , , , 13433 2378 19 the the DT 13433 2378 20 day day NN 13433 2378 21 dedicated dedicate VBN 13433 2378 22 to to IN 13433 2378 23 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2378 24 was be VBD 13433 2378 25 in in IN 13433 2378 26 June June NNP 13433 2378 27 . . . 13433 2379 1 The the DT 13433 2379 2 mere mere JJ 13433 2379 3 allusion allusion NN 13433 2379 4 , , , 13433 2379 5 in in IN 13433 2379 6 a a DT 13433 2379 7 Homily Homily NNP 13433 2379 8 delivered deliver VBN 13433 2379 9 in in IN 13433 2379 10 honour honour NN 13433 2379 11 of of IN 13433 2379 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2379 13 , , , 13433 2379 14 that that IN 13433 2379 15 " " `` 13433 2379 16 recently recently RB 13433 2379 17 " " `` 13433 2379 18 the the DT 13433 2379 19 feast feast NN 13433 2379 20 of of IN 13433 2379 21 St. St. NNP 13433 2379 22 Pelagia Pelagia NNP 13433 2379 23 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2379 24 in in IN 13433 2379 25 the the DT 13433 2379 26 Latin Latin NNP 13433 2379 27 Calendar Calendar NNP 13433 2379 28 9th 9th NN 13433 2379 29 June June NNP 13433 2379 30 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2379 31 had have VBD 13433 2379 32 been be VBN 13433 2379 33 celebrated celebrate VBN 13433 2379 34 , , , 13433 2379 35 by by IN 13433 2379 36 no no DT 13433 2379 37 means means NN 13433 2379 38 justifies justifie NNS 13433 2379 39 such such PDT 13433 2379 40 a a DT 13433 2379 41 conclusion conclusion NN 13433 2379 42 , , , 13433 2379 43 and and CC 13433 2379 44 there there EX 13433 2379 45 is be VBZ 13433 2379 46 nothing nothing NN 13433 2379 47 else else RB 13433 2379 48 to to TO 13433 2379 49 establish establish VB 13433 2379 50 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2379 51 . . . 13433 2380 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2380 2 114:1 114:1 LS 13433 2380 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2380 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2380 5 St. St. NNP 13433 2381 1 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2381 2 's 's POS 13433 2381 3 Ep Ep NNP 13433 2381 4 . . . 13433 2382 1 to to IN 13433 2382 2 the the DT 13433 2382 3 Philippians Philippians NNP 13433 2382 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2382 5 , , , 13433 2382 6 3rd 3rd NNP 13433 2382 7 ed ed NNP 13433 2382 8 . . . 13433 2383 1 1873 1873 CD 13433 2383 2 , , , 13433 2383 3 p. p. NN 13433 2383 4 232 232 CD 13433 2383 5 , , , 13433 2383 6 note note NN 13433 2383 7 . . . 13433 2384 1 Cf cf NN 13433 2384 2 . . . 13433 2385 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2385 2 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2385 3 Review Review NNP 13433 2385 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2385 5 , , , 13433 2385 6 February February NNP 13433 2385 7 1875 1875 CD 13433 2385 8 , , , 13433 2385 9 p. p. NN 13433 2385 10 358 358 CD 13433 2385 11 f. f. NNS 13433 2385 12 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2385 13 _ _ NNP 13433 2385 14 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2385 15 . . . 13433 2385 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2385 17 p. p. NN 13433 2385 18 88 88 CD 13433 2385 19 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2385 20 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2385 21 116:1 116:1 LS 13433 2385 22 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2385 23 Complete complete JJ 13433 2385 24 ed ed NN 13433 2385 25 . . . 13433 2386 1 i. i. NNP 13433 2386 2 p. p. NNP 13433 2386 3 277 277 CD 13433 2386 4 f. f. NNS 13433 2386 5 All all PDT 13433 2386 6 the the DT 13433 2386 7 references reference NNS 13433 2386 8 which which WDT 13433 2386 9 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2386 10 give give VBP 13433 2386 11 in in IN 13433 2386 12 these these DT 13433 2386 13 essays essay NNS 13433 2386 14 must must MD 13433 2386 15 be be VB 13433 2386 16 understood understand VBN 13433 2386 17 as as IN 13433 2386 18 being be VBG 13433 2386 19 to to IN 13433 2386 20 the the DT 13433 2386 21 complete complete JJ 13433 2386 22 edition edition NN 13433 2386 23 . . . 13433 2387 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2387 2 117:1 117:1 LS 13433 2387 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2387 4 i. i. NN 13433 2387 5 p. p. NN 13433 2387 6 443 443 CD 13433 2387 7 ff ff NN 13433 2387 8 . . . 13433 2388 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2388 2 117:2 117:2 CD 13433 2388 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2388 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2388 5 PG PG NNP 13433 2388 6 Transcriber Transcriber NNP 13433 2388 7 's 's POS 13433 2388 8 note note NN 13433 2388 9 : : : 13433 2388 10 probably probably RB 13433 2388 11 a a DT 13433 2388 12 misprint misprint NN 13433 2388 13 for for IN 13433 2388 14 " " `` 13433 2388 15 lost lose VBN 13433 2388 16 work work NN 13433 2388 17 " " '' 13433 2388 18 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2388 19 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2388 20 118:1 118:1 CD 13433 2388 21 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2388 22 This this DT 13433 2388 23 rendering rendering NN 13433 2388 24 is be VBZ 13433 2388 25 quoted quote VBN 13433 2388 26 from from IN 13433 2388 27 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2388 28 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2388 29 's 's POS 13433 2388 30 _ _ NNP 13433 2388 31 Essays Essays NNP 13433 2388 32 _ _ NNP 13433 2388 33 , , , 13433 2388 34 p. p. NN 13433 2388 35 163 163 CD 13433 2388 36 . . . 13433 2389 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2389 2 119:1 119:1 CD 13433 2389 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2389 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2389 5 Essays Essays NNP 13433 2389 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2389 7 , , , 13433 2389 8 p. p. NN 13433 2389 9 167 167 CD 13433 2389 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2389 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2389 12 120:1 120:1 CD 13433 2389 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2389 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2389 15 Essays Essays NNP 13433 2389 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2389 17 , , , 13433 2389 18 p. p. NN 13433 2389 19 170 170 CD 13433 2389 20 . . . 13433 2390 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2390 2 121:1 121:1 CD 13433 2390 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2390 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2390 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2390 6 . . . 13433 2390 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2390 8 p. p. NN 13433 2390 9 169 169 CD 13433 2390 10 . . . 13433 2391 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2391 2 122:1 122:1 CD 13433 2391 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2391 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2391 5 Essays Essays NNP 13433 2391 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2391 7 , , , 13433 2391 8 p. p. NN 13433 2391 9 170 170 CD 13433 2391 10 . . . 13433 2392 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2392 2 122:2 122:2 CD 13433 2392 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2392 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2392 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2392 6 . . . 13433 2392 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2392 8 p. p. NN 13433 2392 9 170 170 CD 13433 2392 10 . . . 13433 2393 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2393 2 122:3 122:3 CD 13433 2393 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2393 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2393 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2393 6 . . . 13433 2393 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2393 8 p. p. NN 13433 2393 9 170 170 CD 13433 2393 10 . . . 13433 2394 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2394 2 123:1 123:1 CD 13433 2394 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2394 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2394 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2394 6 . . . 13433 2394 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2394 8 p. p. NN 13433 2394 9 152 152 CD 13433 2394 10 . . . 13433 2395 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2395 2 124:1 124:1 LS 13433 2395 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2395 4 Vol Vol NNP 13433 2395 5 . . . 13433 2396 1 i. i. NNP 13433 2396 2 p. p. NN 13433 2396 3 463 463 CD 13433 2396 4 f. f. NNS 13433 2396 5 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2396 6 124:2 124:2 CD 13433 2396 7 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2396 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2396 9 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2396 10 . . . 13433 2396 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2396 12 p. p. NN 13433 2396 13 171 171 CD 13433 2396 14 . . . 13433 2397 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2397 2 124:3 124:3 LS 13433 2397 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2397 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2397 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2397 6 . . . 13433 2397 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2397 8 p. p. NN 13433 2397 9 172 172 CD 13433 2397 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2397 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2397 12 124:4 124:4 CD 13433 2397 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2397 14 i. i. NNP 13433 2397 15 p. p. NN 13433 2397 16 463 463 CD 13433 2397 17 f. f. NNS 13433 2397 18 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2397 19 125:1 125:1 CD 13433 2397 20 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2397 21 _ _ NNP 13433 2397 22 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2397 23 . . . 13433 2397 24 _ _ NNP 13433 2397 25 p. p. NN 13433 2397 26 173 173 CD 13433 2397 27 . . . 13433 2398 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2398 2 125:2 125:2 LS 13433 2398 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2398 4 i. i. NN 13433 2399 1 236 236 CD 13433 2399 2 ff ff NN 13433 2399 3 . . . 13433 2400 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2400 2 125:3 125:3 LS 13433 2400 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2400 4 Note note VB 13433 2400 5 . . . 13433 2401 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2401 2 125:4 125:4 LS 13433 2401 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2401 4 Note note VB 13433 2401 5 . . . 13433 2402 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2402 2 126:1 126:1 CD 13433 2402 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2402 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2402 5 Clem Clem NNP 13433 2402 6 . . . 13433 2403 1 Rom Rom NNP 13433 2403 2 . . . 13433 2403 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2403 4 § § CD 13433 2403 5 53 53 CD 13433 2403 6 , , , 13433 2403 7 § § CD 13433 2403 8 45 45 CD 13433 2403 9 ; ; : 13433 2403 10 ibid ibid RB 13433 2403 11 . . . 13433 2404 1 173 173 CD 13433 2404 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2404 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2404 4 130:1 130:1 LS 13433 2404 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2404 6 I. I. NNP 13433 2404 7 p. p. NN 13433 2404 8 210 210 CD 13433 2404 9 f. f. NNS 13433 2404 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2404 11 132:1 132:1 LS 13433 2404 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2404 13 I. i. NN 13433 2404 14 p. p. NN 13433 2404 15 213 213 CD 13433 2404 16 ff ff NN 13433 2404 17 . . . 13433 2405 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2405 2 have have VBP 13433 2405 3 italicised italicise VBN 13433 2405 4 a a DT 13433 2405 5 few few JJ 13433 2405 6 phrases phrase NNS 13433 2405 7 . . . 13433 2406 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2406 2 133:1 133:1 LS 13433 2406 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2406 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2406 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2406 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2406 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2407 1 259 259 CD 13433 2407 2 ff ff NN 13433 2407 3 . . . 13433 2408 1 See see VB 13433 2408 2 further further JJ 13433 2408 3 illustrations illustration NNS 13433 2408 4 here here RB 13433 2408 5 . . . 13433 2409 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2409 2 134:1 134:1 CD 13433 2409 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2409 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2409 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2409 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2409 7 i. i. NNP 13433 2409 8 p. p. NN 13433 2409 9 363 363 CD 13433 2409 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2409 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2409 12 135:1 135:1 CD 13433 2409 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2409 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2409 15 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2409 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2409 17 ii ii NNP 13433 2409 18 . . . 13433 2410 1 p. p. NN 13433 2410 2 221 221 CD 13433 2410 3 , , , 13433 2410 4 n. n. NNP 13433 2410 5 7 7 CD 13433 2410 6 . . . 13433 2411 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2411 2 135:2 135:2 LS 13433 2411 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2411 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2411 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2411 6 . . . 13433 2411 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2411 8 p. p. NN 13433 2411 9 220 220 CD 13433 2411 10 . . . 13433 2412 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2412 2 135:3 135:3 LS 13433 2412 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2412 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2412 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2412 6 . . . 13433 2412 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2412 8 ii ii NNP 13433 2412 9 . . . 13433 2413 1 p. p. NN 13433 2413 2 169 169 CD 13433 2413 3 f. f. NNS 13433 2413 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2413 5 136:1 136:1 CD 13433 2413 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2413 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2413 8 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2413 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2413 10 ii ii NNP 13433 2413 11 . . . 13433 2414 1 p. p. NN 13433 2414 2 226 226 CD 13433 2414 3 . . . 13433 2415 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2415 2 136:2 136:2 LS 13433 2415 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2415 4 In in IN 13433 2415 5 discussing discuss VBG 13433 2415 6 the the DT 13433 2415 7 authenticity authenticity NN 13433 2415 8 of of IN 13433 2415 9 fragments fragment NNS 13433 2415 10 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 2415 11 to to IN 13433 2415 12 Melito Melito NNP 13433 2415 13 , , , 13433 2415 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2415 15 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2415 16 quoted quote VBD 13433 2415 17 , , , 13433 2415 18 as as IN 13433 2415 19 an an DT 13433 2415 20 argument argument NN 13433 2415 21 from from IN 13433 2415 22 _ _ NNP 13433 2415 23 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 2415 24 Religion Religion NNP 13433 2415 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2415 26 the the DT 13433 2415 27 following follow VBG 13433 2415 28 words word NNS 13433 2415 29 : : : 13433 2415 30 " " `` 13433 2415 31 They -PRON- PRP 13433 2415 32 have have VBP 13433 2415 33 , , , 13433 2415 34 in in IN 13433 2415 35 fact fact NN 13433 2415 36 , , , 13433 2415 37 no no DT 13433 2415 38 attestation attestation NN 13433 2415 39 whatever whatever WDT 13433 2415 40 except except IN 13433 2415 41 that that DT 13433 2415 42 of of IN 13433 2415 43 the the DT 13433 2415 44 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 2415 45 translation translation NN 13433 2415 46 , , , 13433 2415 47 which which WDT 13433 2415 48 is be VBZ 13433 2415 49 unknown unknown JJ 13433 2415 50 and and CC 13433 2415 51 which which WDT 13433 2415 52 , , , 13433 2415 53 therefore therefore RB 13433 2415 54 , , , 13433 2415 55 is be VBZ 13433 2415 56 worthless worthless JJ 13433 2415 57 . . . 13433 2415 58 " " '' 13433 2416 1 The the DT 13433 2416 2 passage passage NN 13433 2416 3 appeared appear VBD 13433 2416 4 thus thus RB 13433 2416 5 in in IN 13433 2416 6 the the DT 13433 2416 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2416 8 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 13433 2416 9 Review Review NNP 13433 2416 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2416 11 , , , 13433 2416 12 and and CC 13433 2416 13 now now RB 13433 2416 14 is be VBZ 13433 2416 15 again again RB 13433 2416 16 given give VBN 13433 2416 17 in in IN 13433 2416 18 the the DT 13433 2416 19 same same JJ 13433 2416 20 form form NN 13433 2416 21 in in IN 13433 2416 22 the the DT 13433 2416 23 present present JJ 13433 2416 24 volume volume NN 13433 2416 25 . . . 13433 2417 1 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2417 2 presume presume VBP 13433 2417 3 that that IN 13433 2417 4 the the DT 13433 2417 5 passage passage NN 13433 2417 6 which which WDT 13433 2417 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2417 8 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2417 9 intends intend VBZ 13433 2417 10 to to TO 13433 2417 11 quote quote VB 13433 2417 12 is be VBZ 13433 2417 13 : : : 13433 2417 14 " " `` 13433 2417 15 They -PRON- PRP 13433 2417 16 have have VBP 13433 2417 17 no no DT 13433 2417 18 attestation attestation NN 13433 2417 19 whatever whatever WDT 13433 2417 20 , , , 13433 2417 21 except except IN 13433 2417 22 that that DT 13433 2417 23 of of IN 13433 2417 24 the the DT 13433 2417 25 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 2417 26 translator translator NN 13433 2417 27 , , , 13433 2417 28 who who WP 13433 2417 29 is be VBZ 13433 2417 30 unknown unknown JJ 13433 2417 31 , , , 13433 2417 32 and and CC 13433 2417 33 which which WDT 13433 2417 34 is be VBZ 13433 2417 35 , , , 13433 2417 36 therefore therefore RB 13433 2417 37 , , , 13433 2417 38 worthless worthless JJ 13433 2417 39 " " '' 13433 2417 40 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2417 41 _ _ NNP 13433 2417 42 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2417 43 _ _ NNP 13433 2417 44 ii ii NNP 13433 2417 45 . . . 13433 2418 1 p. p. NN 13433 2418 2 181 181 CD 13433 2418 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2418 4 . . . 13433 2419 1 If if IN 13433 2419 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2419 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2419 4 , , , 13433 2419 5 who who WP 13433 2419 6 has have VBZ 13433 2419 7 so so RB 13433 2419 8 much much JJ 13433 2419 9 assistance assistance NN 13433 2419 10 in in IN 13433 2419 11 preparing prepare VBG 13433 2419 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2419 13 works work NNS 13433 2419 14 for for IN 13433 2419 15 the the DT 13433 2419 16 press press NN 13433 2419 17 , , , 13433 2419 18 can can MD 13433 2419 19 commit commit VB 13433 2419 20 such such JJ 13433 2419 21 mistakes mistake NNS 13433 2419 22 , , , 13433 2419 23 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2419 24 ought ought MD 13433 2419 25 to to TO 13433 2419 26 be be VB 13433 2419 27 a a DT 13433 2419 28 little little RB 13433 2419 29 more more RBR 13433 2419 30 charitable charitable JJ 13433 2419 31 to to IN 13433 2419 32 those those DT 13433 2419 33 who who WP 13433 2419 34 have have VBP 13433 2419 35 none none NN 13433 2419 36 . . . 13433 2420 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2420 2 137:1 137:1 LS 13433 2420 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2420 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2420 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2420 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2420 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2420 8 . . . 13433 2421 1 p. p. NN 13433 2421 2 182 182 CD 13433 2421 3 ff ff NN 13433 2421 4 . . . 13433 2422 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2422 2 137:2 137:2 CD 13433 2422 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2422 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2422 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2422 6 . . . 13433 2422 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2422 8 p. p. NN 13433 2422 9 239 239 CD 13433 2422 10 . . . 13433 2423 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2423 2 137:3 137:3 CD 13433 2423 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2423 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2423 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2423 6 . . . 13433 2423 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2423 8 p. p. NN 13433 2423 9 248 248 CD 13433 2423 10 . . . 13433 2424 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2424 2 140:1 140:1 LS 13433 2424 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2424 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2424 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2424 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2424 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2424 8 . . . 13433 2425 1 p. p. NN 13433 2425 2 198 198 CD 13433 2425 3 ff ff NNP 13433 2425 4 . . NNP 13433 2425 5 , , , 13433 2425 6 iii iii NNP 13433 2425 7 . . . 13433 2426 1 24 24 CD 13433 2426 2 ff ff NN 13433 2426 3 . . . 13433 2427 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2427 2 140:2 140:2 CD 13433 2427 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2427 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2427 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2427 6 . . . 13433 2427 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2427 8 255 255 CD 13433 2427 9 . . . 13433 2428 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2428 2 141:1 141:1 LS 13433 2428 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2428 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2428 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2428 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2428 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2428 8 . . . 13433 2429 1 p. p. NN 13433 2429 2 200 200 CD 13433 2429 3 . . . 13433 2430 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2430 2 142:1 142:1 CD 13433 2430 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2430 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2430 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2430 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2430 7 ii ii NNP 13433 2430 8 . . . 13433 2431 1 p. p. NN 13433 2431 2 200 200 CD 13433 2431 3 f. f. NNP 13433 2431 4 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2431 5 143:1 143:1 CD 13433 2431 6 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2431 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2431 8 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2431 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2431 10 iii iii NNP 13433 2431 11 . . . 13433 2432 1 p. p. NN 13433 2432 2 257 257 CD 13433 2432 3 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2432 4 143:2 143:2 CD 13433 2432 5 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2432 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2432 7 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2432 8 . . . 13433 2432 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2432 10 p. p. NN 13433 2432 11 25 25 CD 13433 2432 12 f. f. NNS 13433 2432 13 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2432 14 144:1 144:1 CD 13433 2432 15 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2432 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2432 17 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2432 18 . . . 13433 2432 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2432 20 , , , 13433 2432 21 p. p. NN 13433 2432 22 259 259 CD 13433 2432 23 . . . 13433 2433 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2433 2 145:1 145:1 LS 13433 2433 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2433 4 II II NNP 13433 2433 5 . . . 13433 2434 1 pp pp NNP 13433 2434 2 . . . 13433 2435 1 144 144 CD 13433 2435 2 ff ff NNP 13433 2435 3 . . NNP 13433 2435 4 , , , 13433 2435 5 372 372 CD 13433 2435 6 ff ff NN 13433 2435 7 . . . 13433 2436 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2436 2 146:1 146:1 CD 13433 2436 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2436 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 13433 2436 5 . . . 13433 2437 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2437 2 H.E. H.E. NNP 13433 2437 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2437 4 iv iv NNP 13433 2437 5 . . . 13433 2438 1 29 29 CD 13433 2438 2 . . . 13433 2439 1 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2439 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2439 3 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2439 4 . . . 13433 2439 5 _ _ NNP 13433 2439 6 p. p. NN 13433 2439 7 227 227 CD 13433 2439 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2439 9 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2439 10 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2439 11 146:2 146:2 CD 13433 2439 12 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2439 13 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2439 14 need need VBP 13433 2439 15 not not RB 13433 2439 16 quote quote VB 13433 2439 17 the the DT 13433 2439 18 references reference NNS 13433 2439 19 which which WDT 13433 2439 20 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2439 21 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2439 22 gives give VBZ 13433 2439 23 in in IN 13433 2439 24 a a DT 13433 2439 25 note note NN 13433 2439 26 . . . 13433 2440 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2440 2 146:3 146:3 LS 13433 2440 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2440 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2440 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2440 6 . . . 13433 2440 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2440 8 p. p. NN 13433 2440 9 278 278 CD 13433 2440 10 . . . 13433 2441 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2441 2 147:1 147:1 CD 13433 2441 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2441 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2441 5 Unters Unters NNP 13433 2441 6 . . . 13433 2442 1 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2443 1 Kanons Kanons NNP 13433 2443 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2443 3 , , , 13433 2443 4 1881 1881 CD 13433 2443 5 , , , 13433 2443 6 p. p. NN 13433 2443 7 15 15 CD 13433 2443 8 f. f. NNP 13433 2443 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2443 10 147:2 147:2 CD 13433 2443 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2443 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2443 13 On On NNP 13433 2443 14 the the DT 13433 2443 15 Canon Canon NNP 13433 2443 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2443 17 , , , 13433 2443 18 1875 1875 CD 13433 2443 19 , , , 13433 2443 20 p. p. NN 13433 2443 21 318 318 CD 13433 2443 22 , , , 13433 2443 23 n. n. NNP 13433 2443 24 3 3 CD 13433 2443 25 . . . 13433 2444 1 Cf cf NN 13433 2444 2 . . . 13433 2445 1 1881 1881 CD 13433 2445 2 , , , 13433 2445 3 p. p. NN 13433 2445 4 322 322 CD 13433 2445 5 , , , 13433 2445 6 n. n. NNP 13433 2445 7 3 3 CD 13433 2445 8 . . . 13433 2446 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2446 2 147:3 147:3 CD 13433 2446 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2446 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2446 5 The the DT 13433 2446 6 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2446 7 of of IN 13433 2446 8 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2446 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2446 10 , , , 13433 2446 11 1888 1888 CD 13433 2446 12 , , , 13433 2446 13 p. p. NN 13433 2446 14 xiv xiv NNP 13433 2446 15 . . . 13433 2447 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2447 2 147:4 147:4 LS 13433 2447 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2447 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2447 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2447 6 . . . 13433 2447 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2447 8 p. p. NN 13433 2447 9 279 279 CD 13433 2447 10 . . . 13433 2448 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2448 2 148:1 148:1 CD 13433 2448 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2448 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2448 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2448 6 's 's POS 13433 2448 7 rendering rendering NN 13433 2448 8 , , , 13433 2448 9 p p NNP 13433 2448 10 , , , 13433 2448 11 280 280 CD 13433 2448 12 . . . 13433 2449 1 Assem assem NN 13433 2449 2 . . . 13433 2450 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2450 2 Bibl Bibl NNP 13433 2450 3 . . . 13433 2451 1 Orient Orient NNP 13433 2451 2 . . . 13433 2451 3 _ _ NNP 13433 2451 4 ii ii NNP 13433 2451 5 . . . 13433 2452 1 p. p. NN 13433 2452 2 159 159 CD 13433 2452 3 sq sq NN 13433 2452 4 . . . 13433 2453 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2453 2 148:2 148:2 LS 13433 2453 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2453 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2453 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2453 6 . . . 13433 2453 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2453 8 p. p. NN 13433 2453 9 280 280 CD 13433 2453 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2453 11 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2453 12 149:1 149:1 CD 13433 2453 13 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2453 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2453 15 The the DT 13433 2453 16 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2453 17 of of IN 13433 2453 18 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2453 19 _ _ NNP 13433 2453 20 , , , 13433 2453 21 p. p. NNP 13433 2453 22 xxx xxx NNP 13433 2453 23 . . . 13433 2454 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2454 2 149:2 149:2 LS 13433 2454 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2454 4 Euseb Euseb NNP 13433 2454 5 . . . 13433 2455 1 _ _ NNP 13433 2455 2 Op Op NNP 13433 2455 3 . . . 13433 2455 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2455 5 iv iv NNP 13433 2455 6 . . . 13433 2456 1 p. p. NN 13433 2456 2 1276 1276 CD 13433 2456 3 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2456 4 ed ed NN 13433 2456 5 . . . 13433 2457 1 Migne Migne NNP 13433 2457 2 . . . 13433 2457 3 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2458 1 The the DT 13433 2458 2 translation translation NN 13433 2458 3 is be VBZ 13433 2458 4 by by IN 13433 2458 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2458 6 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2458 7 ( ( -LRB- 13433 2458 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2458 9 l.c l.c NNP 13433 2458 10 . . NNP 13433 2458 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2458 12 p. p. NN 13433 2458 13 281 281 CD 13433 2458 14 , , , 13433 2458 15 n. n. NNP 13433 2458 16 1 1 CD 13433 2458 17 ) ) -RRB- 13433 2458 18 . . . 13433 2459 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2459 2 150:1 150:1 LS 13433 2459 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2459 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2459 5 , , , 13433 2459 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2459 7 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2459 8 's 's POS 13433 2459 9 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2459 10 _ _ NNP 13433 2459 11 , , , 13433 2459 12 1881 1881 CD 13433 2459 13 , , , 13433 2459 14 p. p. NN 13433 2459 15 70 70 CD 13433 2459 16 f. f. NNS 13433 2459 17 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2459 18 150:2 150:2 CD 13433 2459 19 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2459 20 _ _ NNP 13433 2459 21 Hist Hist NNP 13433 2459 22 . . . 13433 2460 1 Chr Chr NNP 13433 2460 2 . . . 13433 2461 1 Lit Lit NNP 13433 2461 2 . . . 13433 2462 1 and and CC 13433 2462 2 Doctr Doctr NNP 13433 2462 3 . . . 13433 2462 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2462 5 iii iii NNP 13433 2462 6 . . . 13433 2463 1 p. p. NN 13433 2463 2 26 26 CD 13433 2463 3 . . . 13433 2464 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2464 2 150:3 150:3 LS 13433 2464 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2464 4 Moesinger Moesinger NNP 13433 2464 5 , , , 13433 2464 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2464 7 Evang Evang NNP 13433 2464 8 . . . 13433 2465 1 Concor Concor NNP 13433 2465 2 . . . 13433 2466 1 Expositio Expositio NNP 13433 2466 2 _ _ NNP 13433 2466 3 , , , 13433 2466 4 1876 1876 CD 13433 2466 5 , , , 13433 2466 6 p. p. NN 13433 2466 7 x x NNP 13433 2466 8 f. f. NNP 13433 2466 9 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2466 10 150:4 150:4 CD 13433 2466 11 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2466 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2466 13 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2466 14 . . . 13433 2466 15 _ _ NNP 13433 2466 16 p. p. NN 13433 2466 17 xi xi NNP 13433 2466 18 . . . 13433 2467 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2467 2 152:1 152:1 LS 13433 2467 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2467 4 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2467 5 , , , 13433 2467 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2467 7 l.c l.c NNP 13433 2467 8 . . NNP 13433 2467 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2467 10 p. p. NN 13433 2467 11 38 38 CD 13433 2467 12 . . . 13433 2468 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2468 2 153:1 153:1 CD 13433 2468 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2468 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2468 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2468 6 . . . 13433 2468 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2468 8 p. p. NN 13433 2468 9 286 286 CD 13433 2468 10 . . . 13433 2469 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2469 2 153:2 153:2 CD 13433 2469 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2469 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2469 5 Ibid Ibid NNP 13433 2469 6 . . . 13433 2469 7 _ _ NNP 13433 2469 8 p. p. NN 13433 2469 9 288 288 CD 13433 2469 10 . . . 13433 2470 1 The the DT 13433 2470 2 italics italic NNS 13433 2470 3 are be VBP 13433 2470 4 mine -PRON- PRP 13433 2470 5 . . . 13433 2471 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2471 2 153:3 153:3 LS 13433 2471 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2471 4 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 2471 5 , , , 13433 2471 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2471 7 The the DT 13433 2471 8 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2471 9 of of IN 13433 2471 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2471 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2471 12 , , , 13433 2471 13 p. p. NN 13433 2471 14 xxiv xxiv NNP 13433 2471 15 . . . 13433 2472 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2472 2 154:1 154:1 LS 13433 2472 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2472 4 I -PRON- PRP 13433 2472 5 have have VBP 13433 2472 6 already already RB 13433 2472 7 referred refer VBN 13433 2472 8 to to IN 13433 2472 9 this this DT 13433 2472 10 document document NN 13433 2472 11 further far RBR 13433 2472 12 back back RB 13433 2472 13 , , , 13433 2472 14 p. p. NN 13433 2472 15 136 136 CD 13433 2472 16 . . . 13433 2473 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2473 2 156:1 156:1 LS 13433 2473 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2473 4 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2473 5 , , , 13433 2473 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2473 7 Apostolic Apostolic NNP 13433 2473 8 Fathers Fathers NNP 13433 2473 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2473 10 , , , 13433 2473 11 part part NN 13433 2473 12 ii ii NNP 13433 2473 13 . . . 13433 2474 1 1885 1885 CD 13433 2474 2 , , , 13433 2474 3 p. p. NN 13433 2474 4 598 598 CD 13433 2474 5 ff ff NNS 13433 2474 6 . . . 13433 2475 1 [ [ -LRB- 13433 2475 2 168:1 168:1 CD 13433 2475 3 ] ] -RRB- 13433 2475 4 By by IN 13433 2475 5 recent recent JJ 13433 2475 6 returns return NNS 13433 2475 7 the the DT 13433 2475 8 number number NN 13433 2475 9 of of IN 13433 2475 10 the the DT 13433 2475 11 professors professor NNS 13433 2475 12 of of IN 13433 2475 13 different different JJ 13433 2475 14 religions religion NNS 13433 2475 15 is be VBZ 13433 2475 16 estimated estimate VBN 13433 2475 17 as as IN 13433 2475 18 follows follow VBZ 13433 2475 19 : : : 13433 2475 20 Parsees parse VBN 13433 2475 21 150,000 150,000 CD 13433 2475 22 Sikhs sikh VBN 13433 2475 23 1,200,000 1,200,000 CD 13433 2475 24 Jews Jews NNPS 13433 2475 25 7,000,000 7,000,000 CD 13433 2475 26 , , , 13433 2475 27 being be VBG 13433 2475 28 about about IN 13433 2475 29 ½ ½ JJ 13433 2475 30 per per IN 13433 2475 31 cent cent NN 13433 2475 32 . . . 13433 2476 1 of of IN 13433 2476 2 the the DT 13433 2476 3 whole whole NN 13433 2476 4 . . . 13433 2477 1 Greek Greek NNP 13433 2477 2 Catholics Catholics NNP 13433 2477 3 75,000,000 75,000,000 CD 13433 2477 4 " " `` 13433 2477 5 6 6 CD 13433 2477 6 " " '' 13433 2477 7 " " `` 13433 2477 8 Roman Roman NNP 13433 2477 9 Catholics Catholics NNP 13433 2477 10 152,000,000 152,000,000 CD 13433 2477 11 " " `` 13433 2477 12 12 12 CD 13433 2477 13 " " '' 13433 2477 14 " " `` 13433 2477 15 Other other JJ 13433 2477 16 Christians Christians NNPS 13433 2477 17 100,000,000 100,000,000 CD 13433 2477 18 " " `` 13433 2477 19 8 8 CD 13433 2477 20 " " '' 13433 2477 21 " " `` 13433 2477 22 Hindus Hindus NNP 13433 2477 23 160,000,000 160,000,000 CD 13433 2477 24 " " `` 13433 2477 25 13 13 CD 13433 2477 26 " " '' 13433 2477 27 " " `` 13433 2477 28 Muhammedans muhammedan NNS 13433 2477 29 155,000,000 155,000,000 CD 13433 2477 30 " " `` 13433 2477 31 12½ 12½ CD 13433 2477 32 " " '' 13433 2477 33 " " `` 13433 2477 34 Buddhists buddhist NNS 13433 2477 35 500,000,000 500,000,000 CD 13433 2477 36 " " `` 13433 2477 37 40 40 CD 13433 2477 38 " " '' 13433 2477 39 " " `` 13433 2477 40 Not not RB 13433 2477 41 included include VBN 13433 2477 42 in in IN 13433 2477 43 the the DT 13433 2477 44 above above JJ 13433 2477 45 100,000,000 100,000,000 CD 13433 2477 46 " " `` 13433 2477 47 8 8 CD 13433 2477 48 " " '' 13433 2477 49 " " '' 13433 2477 50 ----------- ----------- NFP 13433 2477 51 1,250,350,000 1,250,350,000 NNS 13433 2477 52 We -PRON- PRP 13433 2477 53 have have VBP 13433 2477 54 taken take VBN 13433 2477 55 these these DT 13433 2477 56 statistics statistic NNS 13433 2477 57 , , , 13433 2477 58 which which WDT 13433 2477 59 are be VBP 13433 2477 60 approximately approximately RB 13433 2477 61 correct correct JJ 13433 2477 62 , , , 13433 2477 63 from from IN 13433 2477 64 an an DT 13433 2477 65 excellent excellent JJ 13433 2477 66 little little JJ 13433 2477 67 work work NN 13433 2477 68 recently recently RB 13433 2477 69 published publish VBN 13433 2477 70 by by IN 13433 2477 71 the the DT 13433 2477 72 Society Society NNP 13433 2477 73 for for IN 13433 2477 74 the the DT 13433 2477 75 Propagation propagation NN 13433 2477 76 of of IN 13433 2477 77 Christian christian JJ 13433 2477 78 Knowledge--_Buddhism knowledge--_buddhism NN 13433 2477 79 _ _ NNP 13433 2477 80 , , , 13433 2477 81 by by IN 13433 2477 82 T.W. T.W. NNP 13433 2478 1 Rhys Rhys NNP 13433 2478 2 Davids Davids NNP 13433 2478 3 , , , 13433 2478 4 p. p. NN 13433 2478 5 6 6 CD 13433 2478 6 . . . 13433 2479 1 INDEX index NN 13433 2479 2 . . . 13433 2480 1 Acts act NNS 13433 2480 2 of of IN 13433 2480 3 the the DT 13433 2480 4 Apostles Apostles NNPS 13433 2480 5 , , , 13433 2480 6 evidence evidence NN 13433 2480 7 for for IN 13433 2480 8 , , , 13433 2480 9 142 142 CD 13433 2480 10 f. f. NN 13433 2480 11 , , , 13433 2480 12 164 164 CD 13433 2480 13 Addai Addai NNP 13433 2480 14 , , , 13433 2480 15 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 2480 16 of of IN 13433 2480 17 , , , 13433 2480 18 147 147 CD 13433 2480 19 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 2480 20 , , , 13433 2480 21 _ _ NNP 13433 2480 22 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2480 23 _ _ NNP 13433 2480 24 of of IN 13433 2480 25 , , , 13433 2480 26 148 148 CD 13433 2480 27 Anger Anger NNP 13433 2480 28 , , , 13433 2480 29 5 5 CD 13433 2480 30 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 2480 31 , , , 13433 2480 32 earthquake earthquake NN 13433 2480 33 at at IN 13433 2480 34 , , , 13433 2480 35 in in IN 13433 2480 36 A.D. A.D. NNP 13433 2480 37 115 115 CD 13433 2480 38 , , , 13433 2480 39 107 107 CD 13433 2480 40 f. f. NNP 13433 2480 41 Aphthonius Aphthonius NNP 13433 2480 42 ; ; : 13433 2480 43 see see VB 13433 2480 44 Elias elia NNS 13433 2480 45 of of IN 13433 2480 46 Salamia Salamia NNP 13433 2480 47 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2480 48 , , , 13433 2480 49 allusion allusion NN 13433 2480 50 to to IN 13433 2480 51 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2480 52 in in IN 13433 2480 53 , , , 13433 2480 54 26 26 CD 13433 2480 55 , , , 13433 2480 56 n. n. NNP 13433 2480 57 2 2 CD 13433 2480 58 ; ; : 13433 2480 59 language language NN 13433 2480 60 of of IN 13433 2480 61 , , , 13433 2480 62 27 27 CD 13433 2480 63 ff ff NNS 13433 2480 64 . . . 13433 2481 1 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 2481 2 , , , 13433 2481 3 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 2481 4 ; ; : 13433 2481 5 date date NN 13433 2481 6 , , , 13433 2481 7 137 137 CD 13433 2481 8 ; ; : 13433 2481 9 evidence evidence NN 13433 2481 10 for for IN 13433 2481 11 Gospels Gospels NNP 13433 2481 12 , , , 13433 2481 13 137 137 CD 13433 2481 14 Aristion Aristion NNP 13433 2481 15 , , , 13433 2481 16 55 55 CD 13433 2481 17 Ascension ascension NN 13433 2481 18 , , , 13433 2481 19 evidence evidence NN 13433 2481 20 for for IN 13433 2481 21 , , , 13433 2481 22 165 165 CD 13433 2481 23 Aubertin Aubertin NNP 13433 2481 24 , , , 13433 2481 25 65 65 CD 13433 2481 26 , , , 13433 2481 27 66 66 CD 13433 2481 28 Aucher Aucher NNP 13433 2481 29 , , , 13433 2481 30 145 145 CD 13433 2481 31 Baronius Baronius NNP 13433 2481 32 , , , 13433 2481 33 112 112 CD 13433 2481 34 n. n. NN 13433 2481 35 3 3 CD 13433 2481 36 Bar Bar NNP 13433 2481 37 - - HYPH 13433 2481 38 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 2481 39 , , , 13433 2481 40 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 2481 41 , , , 13433 2481 42 147 147 CD 13433 2481 43 f. f. NN 13433 2481 44 Basnage Basnage NNP 13433 2481 45 , , , 13433 2481 46 65 65 CD 13433 2481 47 , , , 13433 2481 48 66 66 CD 13433 2481 49 Baumgarten Baumgarten NNP 13433 2481 50 - - HYPH 13433 2481 51 Crusius Crusius NNP 13433 2481 52 , , , 13433 2481 53 70 70 CD 13433 2481 54 , , , 13433 2481 55 72 72 CD 13433 2481 56 Baur Baur NNP 13433 2481 57 , , , 13433 2481 58 does do VBZ 13433 2481 59 not not RB 13433 2481 60 allude allude VB 13433 2481 61 to to IN 13433 2481 62 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2481 63 version version NN 13433 2481 64 of of IN 13433 2481 65 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2481 66 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2481 67 , , , 13433 2481 68 79 79 CD 13433 2481 69 ; ; : 13433 2481 70 date date NN 13433 2481 71 of of IN 13433 2481 72 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2481 73 of of IN 13433 2481 74 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2481 75 , , , 13433 2481 76 89 89 CD 13433 2481 77 f. f. NNS 13433 2481 78 ; ; : 13433 2481 79 place place NN 13433 2481 80 of of IN 13433 2481 81 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2481 82 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2481 83 , , , 13433 2481 84 95 95 CD 13433 2481 85 ff ff NN 13433 2481 86 . . . 13433 2482 1 ; ; : 13433 2482 2 on on IN 13433 2482 3 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 2482 4 Proteus Proteus NNP 13433 2482 5 , , , 13433 2482 6 102 102 CD 13433 2482 7 Beausobre Beausobre NNP 13433 2482 8 , , , 13433 2482 9 70 70 CD 13433 2482 10 , , , 13433 2482 11 71 71 CD 13433 2482 12 Bleek Bleek NNP 13433 2482 13 , , , 13433 2482 14 7 7 CD 13433 2482 15 , , , 13433 2482 16 32 32 CD 13433 2482 17 , , , 13433 2482 18 60 60 CD 13433 2482 19 , , , 13433 2482 20 62 62 CD 13433 2482 21 , , , 13433 2482 22 68 68 CD 13433 2482 23 , , , 13433 2482 24 74 74 CD 13433 2482 25 , , , 13433 2482 26 80 80 CD 13433 2482 27 , , , 13433 2482 28 90 90 CD 13433 2482 29 , , , 13433 2482 30 93 93 CD 13433 2482 31 Blondel Blondel NNP 13433 2482 32 , , , 13433 2482 33 65 65 CD 13433 2482 34 , , , 13433 2482 35 66 66 CD 13433 2482 36 Bochart Bochart NNP 13433 2482 37 , , , 13433 2482 38 65 65 CD 13433 2482 39 , , , 13433 2482 40 66 66 CD 13433 2482 41 Böhringer Böhringer NNP 13433 2482 42 , , , 13433 2482 43 59 59 CD 13433 2482 44 , , , 13433 2482 45 62 62 CD 13433 2482 46 , , , 13433 2482 47 63 63 CD 13433 2482 48 , , , 13433 2482 49 80 80 CD 13433 2482 50 Bunsen Bunsen NNP 13433 2482 51 , , , 13433 2482 52 32 32 CD 13433 2482 53 , , , 13433 2482 54 62 62 CD 13433 2482 55 , , , 13433 2482 56 63 63 CD 13433 2482 57 , , , 13433 2482 58 79 79 CD 13433 2482 59 Calvin Calvin NNP 13433 2482 60 , , , 13433 2482 61 64 64 CD 13433 2482 62 Campianus Campianus NNP 13433 2482 63 , , , 13433 2482 64 64 64 CD 13433 2482 65 Casaubon Casaubon NNP 13433 2482 66 , , , 13433 2482 67 65 65 CD 13433 2482 68 , , , 13433 2482 69 67 67 CD 13433 2482 70 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 2482 71 , , , 13433 2482 72 Origen Origen NNP 13433 2482 73 on on IN 13433 2482 74 , , , 13433 2482 75 10 10 CD 13433 2482 76 ff ff NN 13433 2482 77 . . NNP 13433 2482 78 , , , 13433 2482 79 146 146 CD 13433 2482 80 Centuriators Centuriators NNPS 13433 2482 81 , , , 13433 2482 82 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 13433 2482 83 , , , 13433 2482 84 64 64 CD 13433 2482 85 Chemnitz Chemnitz NNP 13433 2482 86 , , , 13433 2482 87 62 62 CD 13433 2482 88 , , , 13433 2482 89 64 64 CD 13433 2482 90 , , , 13433 2482 91 65 65 CD 13433 2482 92 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2482 93 , , , 13433 2482 94 claim claim NN 13433 2482 95 to to TO 13433 2482 96 be be VB 13433 2482 97 Divine Divine NNP 13433 2482 98 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 2482 99 , , , 13433 2482 100 not not RB 13433 2482 101 original original JJ 13433 2482 102 , , , 13433 2482 103 166 166 CD 13433 2482 104 f. f. NNS 13433 2482 105 ; ; : 13433 2482 106 history history NN 13433 2482 107 and and CC 13433 2482 108 achievements achievement NNS 13433 2482 109 opposed oppose VBN 13433 2482 110 to to IN 13433 2482 111 this this DT 13433 2482 112 claim claim NN 13433 2482 113 , , , 13433 2482 114 167 167 CD 13433 2482 115 f. f. NN 13433 2482 116 ; ; : 13433 2482 117 census census NN 13433 2482 118 of of IN 13433 2482 119 religions religion NNS 13433 2482 120 , , , 13433 2482 121 168 168 CD 13433 2482 122 n. n. NN 13433 2482 123 1 1 CD 13433 2482 124 ; ; : 13433 2482 125 transformation transformation NN 13433 2482 126 of of IN 13433 2482 127 , , , 13433 2482 128 169 169 CD 13433 2482 129 f. f. NNS 13433 2482 130 Chrysostom Chrysostom NNP 13433 2482 131 , , , 13433 2482 132 108 108 CD 13433 2482 133 , , , 13433 2482 134 110 110 CD 13433 2482 135 , , , 13433 2482 136 111 111 CD 13433 2482 137 f. f. NNP 13433 2482 138 Ciasca Ciasca NNP 13433 2482 139 , , , 13433 2482 140 alleged allege VBN 13433 2482 141 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 2482 142 version version NN 13433 2482 143 of of IN 13433 2482 144 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2482 145 's 's POS 13433 2482 146 _ _ NNP 13433 2482 147 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2482 148 _ _ NNP 13433 2482 149 , , , 13433 2482 150 145 145 CD 13433 2482 151 , , , 13433 2482 152 150 150 CD 13433 2482 153 f. f. NN 13433 2482 154 Clement Clement NNP 13433 2482 155 of of IN 13433 2482 156 Alexandria Alexandria NNP 13433 2482 157 , , , 13433 2482 158 on on IN 13433 2482 159 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 2482 160 , , , 13433 2482 161 18 18 CD 13433 2482 162 f. f. NN 13433 2482 163 Cleophas Cleophas NNP 13433 2482 164 , , , 13433 2482 165 52 52 CD 13433 2482 166 Cook Cook NNP 13433 2482 167 , , , 13433 2482 168 65 65 CD 13433 2482 169 , , , 13433 2482 170 66 66 CD 13433 2482 171 Criticism criticism NN 13433 2482 172 , , , 13433 2482 173 attitude attitude NN 13433 2482 174 towards towards IN 13433 2482 175 , , , 13433 2482 176 1 1 CD 13433 2482 177 Cureton Cureton NNP 13433 2482 178 , , , 13433 2482 179 62 62 CD 13433 2482 180 , , , 13433 2482 181 63 63 CD 13433 2482 182 , , , 13433 2482 183 65 65 CD 13433 2482 184 , , , 13433 2482 185 68 68 CD 13433 2482 186 ff ff NN 13433 2482 187 . . NNP 13433 2482 188 , , , 13433 2482 189 79 79 CD 13433 2482 190 , , , 13433 2482 191 83 83 CD 13433 2482 192 f. f. NNP 13433 2482 193 Curetonian curetonian JJ 13433 2482 194 version version NN 13433 2482 195 of of IN 13433 2482 196 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2482 197 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2482 198 , , , 13433 2482 199 59 59 CD 13433 2482 200 ff ff NNP 13433 2482 201 . . NNP 13433 2482 202 , , , 13433 2482 203 67 67 CD 13433 2482 204 ff ff NNP 13433 2482 205 . . NNP 13433 2482 206 , , , 13433 2482 207 74 74 CD 13433 2482 208 ff ff NNP 13433 2482 209 . . NNP 13433 2482 210 , , , 13433 2482 211 80 80 CD 13433 2482 212 f. f. NN 13433 2482 213 Dallaeus Dallaeus NNP 13433 2482 214 , , , 13433 2482 215 62 62 CD 13433 2482 216 Davidson Davidson NNP 13433 2482 217 , , , 13433 2482 218 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2482 219 , , , 13433 2482 220 on on IN 13433 2482 221 passage passage NN 13433 2482 222 of of IN 13433 2482 223 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2482 224 , , , 13433 2482 225 6 6 CD 13433 2482 226 ; ; : 13433 2482 227 date date NN 13433 2482 228 of of IN 13433 2482 229 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2482 230 of of IN 13433 2482 231 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2482 232 , , , 13433 2482 233 91 91 CD 13433 2482 234 ; ; : 13433 2482 235 place place NN 13433 2482 236 of of IN 13433 2482 237 the the DT 13433 2482 238 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2482 239 , , , 13433 2482 240 96 96 CD 13433 2482 241 Delitzsch Delitzsch NNP 13433 2482 242 , , , 13433 2482 243 30 30 CD 13433 2482 244 , , , 13433 2482 245 31 31 CD 13433 2482 246 , , , 13433 2482 247 32 32 CD 13433 2482 248 Denzinger Denzinger NNP 13433 2482 249 , , , 13433 2482 250 78 78 CD 13433 2482 251 , , , 13433 2482 252 79 79 CD 13433 2482 253 , , , 13433 2482 254 80 80 CD 13433 2482 255 n. n. NN 13433 2482 256 2 2 CD 13433 2482 257 , , , 13433 2482 258 103 103 CD 13433 2482 259 n. n. NN 13433 2482 260 1 1 CD 13433 2482 261 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2482 262 of of IN 13433 2482 263 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 2482 264 , , , 13433 2482 265 148 148 CD 13433 2482 266 ff ff NNP 13433 2482 267 . . NNP 13433 2482 268 , , , 13433 2482 269 152 152 CD 13433 2482 270 ff ff NNS 13433 2482 271 . . . 13433 2483 1 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2483 2 of of IN 13433 2483 3 Elias Elias NNP 13433 2483 4 of of IN 13433 2483 5 Salamia Salamia NNP 13433 2483 6 , , , 13433 2483 7 148 148 CD 13433 2483 8 ff ff NN 13433 2483 9 . . . 13433 2484 1 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2484 2 of of IN 13433 2484 3 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2484 4 , , , 13433 2484 5 145 145 CD 13433 2484 6 ff ff NNS 13433 2484 7 . . . 13433 2485 1 ; ; : 13433 2485 2 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2485 3 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2485 4 version version NN 13433 2485 5 of of IN 13433 2485 6 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 2485 7 's 's POS 13433 2485 8 commentary commentary NN 13433 2485 9 on on IN 13433 2485 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2485 11 , , , 13433 2485 12 145 145 CD 13433 2485 13 f. f. NNS 13433 2485 14 ; ; : 13433 2485 15 Latin latin JJ 13433 2485 16 translation translation NN 13433 2485 17 by by IN 13433 2485 18 Aucher Aucher NNP 13433 2485 19 and and CC 13433 2485 20 Moesinger Moesinger NNP 13433 2485 21 , , , 13433 2485 22 145 145 CD 13433 2485 23 f. f. NNS 13433 2485 24 ; ; : 13433 2485 25 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 2485 26 version version NN 13433 2485 27 of of IN 13433 2485 28 , , , 13433 2485 29 translated translate VBN 13433 2485 30 by by IN 13433 2485 31 Ciasca Ciasca NNP 13433 2485 32 , , , 13433 2485 33 145 145 CD 13433 2485 34 f. f. NNS 13433 2485 35 ; ; : 13433 2485 36 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2485 37 on on IN 13433 2485 38 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2485 39 , , , 13433 2485 40 146 146 CD 13433 2485 41 f. f. NN 13433 2485 42 ; ; : 13433 2485 43 did do VBD 13433 2485 44 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2485 45 directly directly RB 13433 2485 46 know know VB 13433 2485 47 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2485 48 ? ? . 13433 2486 1 146 146 CD 13433 2486 2 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 3 ; ; : 13433 2486 4 Bar Bar NNP 13433 2486 5 - - HYPH 13433 2486 6 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 2486 7 on on IN 13433 2486 8 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 9 , , , 13433 2486 10 147 147 CD 13433 2486 11 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 12 ; ; : 13433 2486 13 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 2486 14 suppresses suppress VBZ 13433 2486 15 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 16 , , , 13433 2486 17 149 149 CD 13433 2486 18 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 19 ; ; : 13433 2486 20 the the DT 13433 2486 21 genealogies genealogy NNS 13433 2486 22 of of IN 13433 2486 23 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 2486 24 said say VBD 13433 2486 25 to to TO 13433 2486 26 be be VB 13433 2486 27 excised excise VBN 13433 2486 28 , , , 13433 2486 29 149 149 CD 13433 2486 30 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 31 ; ; : 13433 2486 32 not not RB 13433 2486 33 all all DT 13433 2486 34 suppressed suppress VBN 13433 2486 35 in in IN 13433 2486 36 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2486 37 and and CC 13433 2486 38 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 2486 39 works work NNS 13433 2486 40 , , , 13433 2486 41 150 150 CD 13433 2486 42 ; ; : 13433 2486 43 called call VBD 13433 2486 44 ' ' '' 13433 2486 45 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2486 46 according accord VBG 13433 2486 47 to to IN 13433 2486 48 the the DT 13433 2486 49 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 2486 50 , , , 13433 2486 51 ' ' '' 13433 2486 52 150 150 CD 13433 2486 53 ; ; : 13433 2486 54 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 13433 2486 55 had have VBD 13433 2486 56 not not RB 13433 2486 57 seen see VBN 13433 2486 58 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 59 , , , 13433 2486 60 150 150 CD 13433 2486 61 ; ; : 13433 2486 62 we -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 63 could could MD 13433 2486 64 not not RB 13433 2486 65 identify identify VB 13433 2486 66 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 67 , , , 13433 2486 68 150 150 CD 13433 2486 69 ; ; : 13433 2486 70 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 2486 71 version version NN 13433 2486 72 of of IN 13433 2486 73 Ciasca Ciasca NNP 13433 2486 74 , , , 13433 2486 75 150 150 CD 13433 2486 76 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 77 ; ; , 13433 2486 78 said say VBD 13433 2486 79 to to TO 13433 2486 80 be be VB 13433 2486 81 translated translate VBN 13433 2486 82 from from IN 13433 2486 83 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 2486 84 , , , 13433 2486 85 151 151 CD 13433 2486 86 ; ; : 13433 2486 87 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2486 88 date date NN 13433 2486 89 , , , 13433 2486 90 151 151 CD 13433 2486 91 ; ; : 13433 2486 92 ascribed ascribe VBN 13433 2486 93 in in IN 13433 2486 94 notes note NNS 13433 2486 95 to to IN 13433 2486 96 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2486 97 , , , 13433 2486 98 151 151 CD 13433 2486 99 ; ; : 13433 2486 100 original original JJ 13433 2486 101 language language NN 13433 2486 102 of of IN 13433 2486 103 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2486 104 's 's POS 13433 2486 105 _ _ NNP 13433 2486 106 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2486 107 _ _ NNP 13433 2486 108 , , , 13433 2486 109 151 151 CD 13433 2486 110 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 111 ; ; : 13433 2486 112 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2486 113 texts text VBZ 13433 2486 114 in in IN 13433 2486 115 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2486 116 versions version NNS 13433 2486 117 affected affect VBN 13433 2486 118 by by IN 13433 2486 119 repeated repeat VBN 13433 2486 120 translation translation NN 13433 2486 121 , , , 13433 2486 122 151 151 CD 13433 2486 123 f. f. NNS 13433 2486 124 ; ; : 13433 2486 125 name name NN 13433 2486 126 of of IN 13433 2486 127 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2486 128 not not RB 13433 2486 129 on on IN 13433 2486 130 original original JJ 13433 2486 131 work work NN 13433 2486 132 , , , 13433 2486 133 152 152 CD 13433 2486 134 ; ; : 13433 2486 135 could could MD 13433 2486 136 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2486 137 be be VB 13433 2486 138 identified identify VBN 13433 2486 139 ? ? . 13433 2487 1 152 152 CD 13433 2487 2 ff ff NNS 13433 2487 3 . . . 13433 2488 1 ; ; : 13433 2488 2 case case NN 13433 2488 3 of of IN 13433 2488 4 Victor Victor NNP 13433 2488 5 of of IN 13433 2488 6 Capua Capua NNP 13433 2488 7 , , , 13433 2488 8 152 152 CD 13433 2488 9 ff ff NNS 13433 2488 10 . . . 13433 2489 1 ; ; : 13433 2489 2 was be VBD 13433 2489 3 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2489 4 mistaken mistaken JJ 13433 2489 5 ? ? . 13433 2490 1 153 153 CD 13433 2490 2 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 3 ; ; : 13433 2490 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2490 5 Wace Wace NNP 13433 2490 6 says say VBZ 13433 2490 7 : : : 13433 2490 8 No no UH 13433 2490 9 , , , 13433 2490 10 153 153 CD 13433 2490 11 ; ; : 13433 2490 12 value value NN 13433 2490 13 of of IN 13433 2490 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 2490 15 if if IN 13433 2490 16 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2490 17 versions version NNS 13433 2490 18 be be VB 13433 2490 19 genuine genuine JJ 13433 2490 20 , , , 13433 2490 21 154 154 CD 13433 2490 22 Dionysius dionysius NN 13433 2490 23 of of IN 13433 2490 24 Corinth Corinth NNP 13433 2490 25 , , , 13433 2490 26 56 56 CD 13433 2490 27 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 2490 28 of of IN 13433 2490 29 Addai Addai NNP 13433 2490 30 , , , 13433 2490 31 147 147 CD 13433 2490 32 Donaldson Donaldson NNP 13433 2490 33 , , , 13433 2490 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2490 35 , , , 13433 2490 36 on on IN 13433 2490 37 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2490 38 of of IN 13433 2490 39 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2490 40 , , , 13433 2490 41 21 21 CD 13433 2490 42 ; ; : 13433 2490 43 on on IN 13433 2490 44 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2490 45 's 's POS 13433 2490 46 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 47 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2490 48 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 49 , , , 13433 2490 50 150 150 CD 13433 2490 51 Dorner Dorner NNP 13433 2490 52 , , , 13433 2490 53 4 4 CD 13433 2490 54 Dressel Dressel NNP 13433 2490 55 , , , 13433 2490 56 79 79 CD 13433 2490 57 Ebrard Ebrard NNP 13433 2490 58 , , , 13433 2490 59 7 7 CD 13433 2490 60 Elias elia NNS 13433 2490 61 of of IN 13433 2490 62 Salamia Salamia NNP 13433 2490 63 , , , 13433 2490 64 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2490 65 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 66 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2490 67 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 68 , , , 13433 2490 69 147 147 CD 13433 2490 70 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 71 ; ; : 13433 2490 72 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2490 73 finds find VBZ 13433 2490 74 fault fault NN 13433 2490 75 with with IN 13433 2490 76 Canons Canons NNPS 13433 2490 77 of of IN 13433 2490 78 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2490 79 , , , 13433 2490 80 148 148 CD 13433 2490 81 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 2490 82 Syrus Syrus NNP 13433 2490 83 , , , 13433 2490 84 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2490 85 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 2490 86 on on IN 13433 2490 87 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2490 88 's 's POS 13433 2490 89 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 90 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2490 91 _ _ NNP 13433 2490 92 , , , 13433 2490 93 147 147 CD 13433 2490 94 f. f. NN 13433 2490 95 ; ; : 13433 2490 96 date date NN 13433 2490 97 , , , 13433 2490 98 148 148 CD 13433 2490 99 ; ; , 13433 2490 100 alleged allege VBN 13433 2490 101 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2490 102 version version NN 13433 2490 103 of of IN 13433 2490 104 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2490 105 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 2490 106 , , , 13433 2490 107 145 145 CD 13433 2490 108 ; ; : 13433 2490 109 date date NN 13433 2490 110 of of IN 13433 2490 111 the the DT 13433 2490 112 MS MS NNP 13433 2490 113 . . NNP 13433 2490 114 , , , 13433 2490 115 150 150 CD 13433 2490 116 ; ; : 13433 2490 117 translated translate VBD 13433 2490 118 from from IN 13433 2490 119 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 2490 120 , , , 13433 2490 121 150 150 CD 13433 2490 122 ; ; : 13433 2490 123 evidence evidence NN 13433 2490 124 , , , 13433 2490 125 150 150 CD 13433 2490 126 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 127 ; ; : 13433 2490 128 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2490 129 's 's POS 13433 2490 130 name name NN 13433 2490 131 not not RB 13433 2490 132 mentioned mention VBN 13433 2490 133 , , , 13433 2490 134 150 150 CD 13433 2490 135 ; ; : 13433 2490 136 value value NN 13433 2490 137 as as IN 13433 2490 138 evidence evidence NN 13433 2490 139 if if IN 13433 2490 140 genuine genuine JJ 13433 2490 141 , , , 13433 2490 142 154 154 CD 13433 2490 143 Epiphanius Epiphanius NNP 13433 2490 144 , , , 13433 2490 145 150 150 CD 13433 2490 146 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2490 147 , , , 13433 2490 148 on on IN 13433 2490 149 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2490 150 , , , 13433 2490 151 7 7 CD 13433 2490 152 ; ; : 13433 2490 153 silence silence NN 13433 2490 154 of of IN 13433 2490 155 , , , 13433 2490 156 45 45 CD 13433 2490 157 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 158 ; ; : 13433 2490 159 my -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2490 160 only only JJ 13433 2490 161 inference inference NN 13433 2490 162 from from IN 13433 2490 163 silence silence NN 13433 2490 164 of of IN 13433 2490 165 , , , 13433 2490 166 50 50 CD 13433 2490 167 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 168 ; ; : 13433 2490 169 procedure procedure NN 13433 2490 170 of of IN 13433 2490 171 , , , 13433 2490 172 50 50 CD 13433 2490 173 f. f. NNS 13433 2490 174 ; ; : 13433 2490 175 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2490 176 references reference NNS 13433 2490 177 to to IN 13433 2490 178 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 2490 179 , , , 13433 2490 180 52 52 CD 13433 2490 181 ff ff NN 13433 2490 182 . . . 13433 2491 1 ; ; : 13433 2491 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2491 3 references reference NNS 13433 2491 4 to to IN 13433 2491 5 John John NNP 13433 2491 6 , , , 13433 2491 7 53 53 CD 13433 2491 8 ff ff NNS 13433 2491 9 . . . 13433 2492 1 ; ; : 13433 2492 2 on on IN 13433 2492 3 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 2492 4 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 2492 5 , , , 13433 2492 6 137 137 CD 13433 2492 7 ; ; : 13433 2492 8 on on IN 13433 2492 9 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 13433 2492 10 of of IN 13433 2492 11 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 2492 12 , , , 13433 2492 13 137 137 CD 13433 2492 14 ; ; : 13433 2492 15 on on IN 13433 2492 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2492 17 's 's POS 13433 2492 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2492 19 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2492 20 _ _ NNP 13433 2492 21 , , , 13433 2492 22 146 146 CD 13433 2492 23 f. f. NN 13433 2492 24 ; ; : 13433 2492 25 on on IN 13433 2492 26 _ _ NNP 13433 2492 27 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2492 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2492 29 of of IN 13433 2492 30 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 2492 31 , , , 13433 2492 32 148 148 CD 13433 2492 33 f. f. NNS 13433 2492 34 ; ; : 13433 2492 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2492 36 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2492 37 to to IN 13433 2492 38 Carpianus Carpianus NNP 13433 2492 39 , , , 13433 2492 40 148 148 CD 13433 2492 41 f. f. NN 13433 2492 42 , , , 13433 2492 43 152 152 CD 13433 2492 44 Ewald Ewald NNP 13433 2492 45 , , , 13433 2492 46 32 32 CD 13433 2492 47 , , , 13433 2492 48 33 33 CD 13433 2492 49 , , , 13433 2492 50 62 62 CD 13433 2492 51 , , , 13433 2492 52 63 63 CD 13433 2492 53 , , , 13433 2492 54 79 79 CD 13433 2492 55 , , , 13433 2492 56 141 141 CD 13433 2492 57 Farrar Farrar NNP 13433 2492 58 , , , 13433 2492 59 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2492 60 , , , 13433 2492 61 34 34 CD 13433 2492 62 Francke Francke NNP 13433 2492 63 , , , 13433 2492 64 97 97 CD 13433 2492 65 Gfrörer gfrörer NN 13433 2492 66 , , , 13433 2492 67 7 7 CD 13433 2492 68 , , , 13433 2492 69 75 75 CD 13433 2492 70 Glaucias Glaucias NNP 13433 2492 71 , , , 13433 2492 72 15 15 CD 13433 2492 73 , , , 13433 2492 74 18 18 CD 13433 2492 75 , , , 13433 2492 76 19 19 CD 13433 2492 77 , , , 13433 2492 78 Gobarus Gobarus NNP 13433 2492 79 , , , 13433 2492 80 Stephanus Stephanus NNP 13433 2492 81 , , , 13433 2492 82 23 23 CD 13433 2492 83 Godet Godet NNP 13433 2492 84 , , , 13433 2492 85 32 32 CD 13433 2492 86 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2492 87 , , , 13433 2492 88 the the DT 13433 2492 89 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2492 90 , , , 13433 2492 91 contrast contrast NN 13433 2492 92 with with IN 13433 2492 93 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 2492 94 , , , 13433 2492 95 26 26 CD 13433 2492 96 f. f. NN 13433 2492 97 , , , 13433 2492 98 26 26 CD 13433 2492 99 n. n. NN 13433 2492 100 2 2 CD 13433 2492 101 ; ; : 13433 2492 102 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 2492 103 character character NN 13433 2492 104 of of IN 13433 2492 105 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2492 106 language language NN 13433 2492 107 , , , 13433 2492 108 27 27 CD 13433 2492 109 ff ff NN 13433 2492 110 . . . 13433 2493 1 ; ; : 13433 2493 2 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2493 3 regarding regard VBG 13433 2493 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2493 5 , , , 13433 2493 6 49 49 CD 13433 2493 7 , , , 13433 2493 8 51 51 CD 13433 2493 9 , , , 13433 2493 10 53 53 CD 13433 2493 11 f. f. NNS 13433 2493 12 , , , 13433 2493 13 55 55 CD 13433 2493 14 ff ff NN 13433 2493 15 . . . 13433 2494 1 ; ; : 13433 2494 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 2494 3 to to IN 13433 2494 4 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2494 5 of of IN 13433 2494 6 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 2494 7 of of IN 13433 2494 8 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2494 9 , , , 13433 2494 10 135 135 CD 13433 2494 11 ; ; , 13433 2494 12 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2494 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 2494 14 of of IN 13433 2494 15 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 2494 16 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 2494 17 , , , 13433 2494 18 137 137 CD 13433 2494 19 ; ; : 13433 2494 20 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2494 21 evidence evidence NN 13433 2494 22 of of IN 13433 2494 23 Polycrates Polycrates NNP 13433 2494 24 137 137 CD 13433 2494 25 ; ; , 13433 2494 26 supposed suppose VBN 13433 2494 27 reference reference NN 13433 2494 28 to to IN 13433 2494 29 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2494 30 in in IN 13433 2494 31 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2494 32 of of IN 13433 2494 33 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2494 34 and and CC 13433 2494 35 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2494 36 , , , 13433 2494 37 144 144 CD 13433 2494 38 ; ; : 13433 2494 39 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2494 40 's 's POS 13433 2494 41 _ _ NNP 13433 2494 42 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2494 43 _ _ NNP 13433 2494 44 said say VBD 13433 2494 45 to to TO 13433 2494 46 begin begin VB 13433 2494 47 with with IN 13433 2494 48 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2494 49 , , , 13433 2494 50 147 147 CD 13433 2494 51 f. f. NNS 13433 2494 52 ; ; : 13433 2494 53 insufficiency insufficiency NN 13433 2494 54 of of IN 13433 2494 55 evidence evidence NN 13433 2494 56 for for IN 13433 2494 57 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2494 58 , , , 13433 2494 59 162 162 CD 13433 2494 60 ff ff NN 13433 2494 61 . . . 13433 2495 1 ; ; : 13433 2495 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2495 3 contents content NNS 13433 2495 4 can can MD 13433 2495 5 not not RB 13433 2495 6 be be VB 13433 2495 7 reconciled reconcile VBN 13433 2495 8 with with IN 13433 2495 9 Synoptics Synoptics NNPS 13433 2495 10 , , , 13433 2495 11 163 163 CD 13433 2495 12 f. f. NNP 13433 2495 13 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 2495 14 , , , 13433 2495 15 Justin Justin NNP 13433 2495 16 's 's POS 13433 2495 17 use use NN 13433 2495 18 of of IN 13433 2495 19 , , , 13433 2495 20 24 24 CD 13433 2495 21 f. f. NN 13433 2495 22 ; ; : 13433 2495 23 evidence evidence NN 13433 2495 24 of of IN 13433 2495 25 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2495 26 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2495 27 , , , 13433 2495 28 24 24 CD 13433 2495 29 f. f. NNS 13433 2495 30 ; ; : 13433 2495 31 object object NN 13433 2495 32 in in IN 13433 2495 33 examining examine VBG 13433 2495 34 evidence evidence NN 13433 2495 35 for for IN 13433 2495 36 , , , 13433 2495 37 37 37 CD 13433 2495 38 ff ff NNP 13433 2495 39 . . NNP 13433 2495 40 , , , 13433 2495 41 41 41 CD 13433 2495 42 ff ff NN 13433 2495 43 . . . 13433 2496 1 ; ; : 13433 2496 2 numerous numerous JJ 13433 2496 3 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 2496 4 circulating circulate VBG 13433 2496 5 in in IN 13433 2496 6 early early JJ 13433 2496 7 Church Church NNP 13433 2496 8 , , , 13433 2496 9 131 131 CD 13433 2496 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2496 11 ; ; , 13433 2496 12 anonymous anonymous JJ 13433 2496 13 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2496 14 not not RB 13433 2496 15 necessarily necessarily RB 13433 2496 16 from from IN 13433 2496 17 canonical canonical JJ 13433 2496 18 , , , 13433 2496 19 131 131 CD 13433 2496 20 ff ff NN 13433 2496 21 . . . 13433 2497 1 ; ; : 13433 2497 2 illustrations illustration NNS 13433 2497 3 of of IN 13433 2497 4 this this DT 13433 2497 5 , , , 13433 2497 6 132 132 CD 13433 2497 7 ff ff NN 13433 2497 8 . . . 13433 2498 1 ; ; : 13433 2498 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 2498 3 of of IN 13433 2498 4 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 2498 5 of of IN 13433 2498 6 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2498 7 , , , 13433 2498 8 135 135 CD 13433 2498 9 ; ; : 13433 2498 10 evidence evidence NN 13433 2498 11 of of IN 13433 2498 12 Melito Melito NNP 13433 2498 13 of of IN 13433 2498 14 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 2498 15 , , , 13433 2498 16 135 135 CD 13433 2498 17 f. f. NN 13433 2498 18 ; ; : 13433 2498 19 evidence evidence NN 13433 2498 20 of of IN 13433 2498 21 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 2498 22 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 2498 23 , , , 13433 2498 24 137 137 CD 13433 2498 25 ; ; : 13433 2498 26 evidence evidence NN 13433 2498 27 of of IN 13433 2498 28 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2498 29 of of IN 13433 2498 30 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2498 31 and and CC 13433 2498 32 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2498 33 , , , 13433 2498 34 141 141 CD 13433 2498 35 ff ff NN 13433 2498 36 . . . 13433 2499 1 ; ; : 13433 2499 2 principles principle NNS 13433 2499 3 on on IN 13433 2499 4 which which WDT 13433 2499 5 evidence evidence NN 13433 2499 6 is be VBZ 13433 2499 7 examined examine VBN 13433 2499 8 , , , 13433 2499 9 162 162 CD 13433 2499 10 ; ; : 13433 2499 11 insufficiency insufficiency NN 13433 2499 12 of of IN 13433 2499 13 evidence evidence NN 13433 2499 14 for for IN 13433 2499 15 , , , 13433 2499 16 162 162 CD 13433 2499 17 ff ff NN 13433 2499 18 . . . 13433 2500 1 Greet Greet NNP 13433 2500 2 , , , 13433 2500 3 Hofstede Hofstede NNP 13433 2500 4 de de NNP 13433 2500 5 , , , 13433 2500 6 5 5 CD 13433 2500 7 , , , 13433 2500 8 9 9 CD 13433 2500 9 n. n. NN 13433 2500 10 2 2 CD 13433 2500 11 Grove Grove NNP 13433 2500 12 , , , 13433 2500 13 34 34 CD 13433 2500 14 Guericke Guericke NNP 13433 2500 15 , , , 13433 2500 16 7 7 CD 13433 2500 17 , , , 13433 2500 18 90 90 CD 13433 2500 19 f. f. NN 13433 2500 20 , , , 13433 2500 21 93 93 CD 13433 2500 22 Hadrian Hadrian NNP 13433 2500 23 , , , 13433 2500 24 12 12 CD 13433 2500 25 Hagenbach Hagenbach NNP 13433 2500 26 , , , 13433 2500 27 91 91 CD 13433 2500 28 , , , 13433 2500 29 93 93 CD 13433 2500 30 Harless harless NN 13433 2500 31 , , , 13433 2500 32 75 75 CD 13433 2500 33 Hase Hase NNP 13433 2500 34 , , , 13433 2500 35 76 76 CD 13433 2500 36 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 2500 37 , , , 13433 2500 38 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2500 39 according accord VBG 13433 2500 40 to to IN 13433 2500 41 the the DT 13433 2500 42 , , , 13433 2500 43 122 122 CD 13433 2500 44 f. f. NN 13433 2500 45 , , , 13433 2500 46 123 123 CD 13433 2500 47 , , , 13433 2500 48 150 150 CD 13433 2500 49 Hefele Hefele NNP 13433 2500 50 , , , 13433 2500 51 80 80 CD 13433 2500 52 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 2500 53 , , , 13433 2500 54 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2500 55 attitude attitude NN 13433 2500 56 to to IN 13433 2500 57 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2500 58 , , , 13433 2500 59 23 23 CD 13433 2500 60 ; ; : 13433 2500 61 references reference NNS 13433 2500 62 to to IN 13433 2500 63 him -PRON- PRP 13433 2500 64 by by IN 13433 2500 65 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2500 66 , , , 13433 2500 67 52 52 CD 13433 2500 68 ff ff NN 13433 2500 69 . . . 13433 2501 1 ; ; : 13433 2501 2 on on IN 13433 2501 3 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 2501 4 , , , 13433 2501 5 52 52 CD 13433 2501 6 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 2501 7 , , , 13433 2501 8 Professor Professor NNP 13433 2501 9 , , , 13433 2501 10 did do VBD 13433 2501 11 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2501 12 directly directly RB 13433 2501 13 know know VB 13433 2501 14 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2501 15 's 's POS 13433 2501 16 _ _ NNP 13433 2501 17 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2501 18 _ _ NNP 13433 2501 19 ? ? . 13433 2502 1 146 146 CD 13433 2502 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2502 3 ; ; : 13433 2502 4 on on IN 13433 2502 5 Arabic Arabic NNP 13433 2502 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2502 7 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2502 8 _ _ NNP 13433 2502 9 , , , 13433 2502 10 149 149 CD 13433 2502 11 ; ; : 13433 2502 12 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2502 13 takes take VBZ 13433 2502 14 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2502 15 as as IN 13433 2502 16 basis basis NN 13433 2502 17 , , , 13433 2502 18 149 149 CD 13433 2502 19 ; ; : 13433 2502 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2502 21 substantial substantial JJ 13433 2502 22 identity identity NN 13433 2502 23 with with IN 13433 2502 24 Victor Victor NNP 13433 2502 25 's 's POS 13433 2502 26 _ _ NNP 13433 2502 27 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2502 28 _ _ NNP 13433 2502 29 , , , 13433 2502 30 153 153 CD 13433 2502 31 Hengstenberg Hengstenberg NNP 13433 2502 32 , , , 13433 2502 33 31 31 CD 13433 2502 34 Hilgenfeld Hilgenfeld NNP 13433 2502 35 , , , 13433 2502 36 on on IN 13433 2502 37 passage passage NN 13433 2502 38 of of IN 13433 2502 39 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2502 40 , , , 13433 2502 41 5 5 CD 13433 2502 42 f. f. NN 13433 2502 43 ; ; : 13433 2502 44 on on IN 13433 2502 45 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2502 46 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2502 47 , , , 13433 2502 48 78 78 CD 13433 2502 49 , , , 13433 2502 50 79 79 CD 13433 2502 51 ; ; : 13433 2502 52 place place NN 13433 2502 53 and and CC 13433 2502 54 date date NN 13433 2502 55 of of IN 13433 2502 56 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2502 57 of of IN 13433 2502 58 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2502 59 , , , 13433 2502 60 97 97 CD 13433 2502 61 ff ff NN 13433 2502 62 . . . 13433 2503 1 ; ; : 13433 2503 2 on on IN 13433 2503 3 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2503 4 and and CC 13433 2503 5 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2503 6 's 's POS 13433 2503 7 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 2503 8 " " `` 13433 2503 9 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 2503 10 , , , 13433 2503 11 " " '' 13433 2503 12 122 122 CD 13433 2503 13 ; ; : 13433 2503 14 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 13433 2503 15 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 13433 2503 16 , , , 13433 2503 17 142 142 CD 13433 2503 18 ; ; : 13433 2503 19 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2503 20 on on IN 13433 2503 21 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2503 22 's 's POS 13433 2503 23 _ _ NNP 13433 2503 24 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2503 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2503 26 , , , 13433 2503 27 146 146 CD 13433 2503 28 f. f. NNP 13433 2503 29 Hippolytus Hippolytus NNP 13433 2503 30 , , , 13433 2503 31 17 17 CD 13433 2503 32 f. f. NN 13433 2503 33 Holtzmann Holtzmann NNP 13433 2503 34 , , , 13433 2503 35 135 135 CD 13433 2503 36 , , , 13433 2503 37 147 147 CD 13433 2503 38 Hug Hug NNP 13433 2503 39 , , , 13433 2503 40 32 32 CD 13433 2503 41 Humfrey Humfrey NNP 13433 2503 42 , , , 13433 2503 43 66 66 CD 13433 2503 44 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2503 45 , , , 13433 2503 46 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2503 47 of of IN 13433 2503 48 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2503 49 regarding regard VBG 13433 2503 50 him -PRON- PRP 13433 2503 51 , , , 13433 2503 52 20 20 CD 13433 2503 53 ff ff NNS 13433 2503 54 . . . 13433 2504 1 ; ; : 13433 2504 2 date date NN 13433 2504 3 and and CC 13433 2504 4 place place NN 13433 2504 5 of of IN 13433 2504 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2504 7 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2504 8 , , , 13433 2504 9 87 87 CD 13433 2504 10 , , , 13433 2504 11 94 94 CD 13433 2504 12 ff ff NN 13433 2504 13 . . . 13433 2505 1 ; ; : 13433 2505 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2505 3 alleged allege VBN 13433 2505 4 martyr martyr NN 13433 2505 5 - - HYPH 13433 2505 6 journey journey NN 13433 2505 7 , , , 13433 2505 8 94 94 CD 13433 2505 9 ff ff NN 13433 2505 10 . . . 13433 2506 1 ; ; : 13433 2506 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2506 3 treatment treatment NN 13433 2506 4 during during IN 13433 2506 5 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2506 6 , , , 13433 2506 7 99 99 CD 13433 2506 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2506 9 ; ; , 13433 2506 10 compared compare VBN 13433 2506 11 with with IN 13433 2506 12 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2506 13 's 's POS 13433 2506 14 journey journey NN 13433 2506 15 , , , 13433 2506 16 100 100 CD 13433 2506 17 f. f. NNS 13433 2506 18 ; ; , 13433 2506 19 compared compare VBN 13433 2506 20 with with IN 13433 2506 21 case case NN 13433 2506 22 of of IN 13433 2506 23 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 2506 24 , , , 13433 2506 25 101 101 CD 13433 2506 26 ff ff NN 13433 2506 27 . . . 13433 2507 1 ; ; : 13433 2507 2 reasons reason NNS 13433 2507 3 opposed oppose VBN 13433 2507 4 to to IN 13433 2507 5 martyr martyr NN 13433 2507 6 - - HYPH 13433 2507 7 journey journey NN 13433 2507 8 to to IN 13433 2507 9 Rome Rome NNP 13433 2507 10 , , , 13433 2507 11 and and CC 13433 2507 12 for for IN 13433 2507 13 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2507 14 in in IN 13433 2507 15 Antioch Antioch NNP 13433 2507 16 , , , 13433 2507 17 104 104 CD 13433 2507 18 ff ff NN 13433 2507 19 . . . 13433 2508 1 ; ; : 13433 2508 2 remains remain NNS 13433 2508 3 of of IN 13433 2508 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2508 5 , , , 13433 2508 6 111 111 CD 13433 2508 7 ff ff NNS 13433 2508 8 . . . 13433 2509 1 ; ; : 13433 2509 2 martyrologies martyrologie NNS 13433 2509 3 , , , 13433 2509 4 112 112 CD 13433 2509 5 f. f. NN 13433 2509 6 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2509 7 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2509 8 , , , 13433 2509 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2509 10 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2509 11 on on RP 13433 2509 12 , , , 13433 2509 13 57 57 CD 13433 2509 14 ff ff NN 13433 2509 15 . . . 13433 2510 1 ; ; : 13433 2510 2 critics critic NNS 13433 2510 3 on on IN 13433 2510 4 priority priority NN 13433 2510 5 of of IN 13433 2510 6 Syriac Syriac NNP 13433 2510 7 version version NN 13433 2510 8 , , , 13433 2510 9 59 59 CD 13433 2510 10 ff ff NNP 13433 2510 11 . . NNP 13433 2510 12 , , , 13433 2510 13 long long JJ 13433 2510 14 recension recension NN 13433 2510 15 , , , 13433 2510 16 64 64 CD 13433 2510 17 ff ff NNS 13433 2510 18 . . . 13433 2511 1 ; ; : 13433 2511 2 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 2511 3 Epistles Epistles NNP 13433 2511 4 , , , 13433 2511 5 67 67 CD 13433 2511 6 ff ff NN 13433 2511 7 . . . 13433 2512 1 ; ; : 13433 2512 2 version version NN 13433 2512 3 of of IN 13433 2512 4 Ussher Ussher NNP 13433 2512 5 , , , 13433 2512 6 67 67 CD 13433 2512 7 ; ; : 13433 2512 8 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2512 9 version version NN 13433 2512 10 , , , 13433 2512 11 78 78 CD 13433 2512 12 ff ff NN 13433 2512 13 . . . 13433 2513 1 ; ; : 13433 2513 2 Eusebian Eusebian NNP 13433 2513 3 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2513 4 , , , 13433 2513 5 80 80 CD 13433 2513 6 ff ff NN 13433 2513 7 . . . 13433 2514 1 ; ; : 13433 2514 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2514 3 order order NN 13433 2514 4 in in IN 13433 2514 5 MSS MSS NNP 13433 2514 6 . . . 13433 2514 7 , , , 13433 2514 8 82 82 CD 13433 2514 9 ff ff NN 13433 2514 10 . . . 13433 2515 1 ; ; : 13433 2515 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2515 3 value value NN 13433 2515 4 as as IN 13433 2515 5 evidence evidence NN 13433 2515 6 , , , 13433 2515 7 113 113 CD 13433 2515 8 f. f. NN 13433 2515 9 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2515 10 , , , 13433 2515 11 3 3 CD 13433 2515 12 ff ff NN 13433 2515 13 . . . 13433 2516 1 Jacobson Jacobson NNP 13433 2516 2 , , , 13433 2516 3 65 65 CD 13433 2516 4 Jerome Jerome NNP 13433 2516 5 , , , 13433 2516 6 110 110 CD 13433 2516 7 f. f. NN 13433 2516 8 John John NNP 13433 2516 9 , , , 13433 2516 10 references reference NNS 13433 2516 11 of of IN 13433 2516 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2516 13 , , , 13433 2516 14 53 53 CD 13433 2516 15 ff ff NNS 13433 2516 16 . . . 13433 2517 1 ; ; : 13433 2517 2 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2517 3 and and CC 13433 2517 4 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 2517 5 on on RB 13433 2517 6 , , , 13433 2517 7 55 55 CD 13433 2517 8 f. f. NN 13433 2517 9 ; ; : 13433 2517 10 double double JJ 13433 2517 11 use use NN 13433 2517 12 of of IN 13433 2517 13 name name NN 13433 2517 14 , , , 13433 2517 15 55 55 CD 13433 2517 16 f. f. NN 13433 2517 17 Justin Justin NNP 13433 2517 18 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 2517 19 , , , 13433 2517 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2517 21 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2517 22 , , , 13433 2517 23 28 28 CD 13433 2517 24 ff ff NN 13433 2517 25 . . . 13433 2518 1 Keim Keim NNP 13433 2518 2 , , , 13433 2518 3 135 135 CD 13433 2518 4 Kestner Kestner NNP 13433 2518 5 , , , 13433 2518 6 70 70 CD 13433 2518 7 , , , 13433 2518 8 71 71 CD 13433 2518 9 Kirchhofer Kirchhofer NNP 13433 2518 10 , , , 13433 2518 11 7 7 CD 13433 2518 12 Lange Lange NNP 13433 2518 13 , , , 13433 2518 14 32 32 CD 13433 2518 15 Lardner Lardner NNP 13433 2518 16 , , , 13433 2518 17 70 70 CD 13433 2518 18 , , , 13433 2518 19 136 136 CD 13433 2518 20 Lechler Lechler NNP 13433 2518 21 , , , 13433 2518 22 76 76 CD 13433 2518 23 f. f. NN 13433 2518 24 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2518 25 , , , 13433 2518 26 32 32 CD 13433 2518 27 , , , 13433 2518 28 33 33 CD 13433 2518 29 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2518 30 , , , 13433 2518 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2518 32 , , , 13433 2518 33 objectionable objectionable JJ 13433 2518 34 style style NN 13433 2518 35 of of IN 13433 2518 36 criticism criticism NN 13433 2518 37 , , , 13433 2518 38 1 1 CD 13433 2518 39 f. f. NNP 13433 2518 40 , , , 13433 2518 41 3 3 CD 13433 2518 42 , , , 13433 2518 43 7 7 CD 13433 2518 44 f. f. NN 13433 2518 45 , , , 13433 2518 46 13 13 CD 13433 2518 47 n. n. NN 13433 2518 48 1 1 CD 13433 2518 49 , , , 13433 2518 50 14 14 CD 13433 2518 51 f. f. NNP 13433 2518 52 , , , 13433 2518 53 15 15 CD 13433 2518 54 n. n. NNP 13433 2518 55 1 1 CD 13433 2518 56 , , , 13433 2518 57 20 20 CD 13433 2518 58 , , , 13433 2518 59 21 21 CD 13433 2518 60 , , , 13433 2518 61 23 23 CD 13433 2518 62 f. f. NNS 13433 2518 63 , , , 13433 2518 64 24 24 CD 13433 2518 65 n. n. NN 13433 2518 66 5 5 CD 13433 2518 67 , , , 13433 2518 68 25 25 CD 13433 2518 69 f. f. NNS 13433 2518 70 , , , 13433 2518 71 27 27 CD 13433 2518 72 , , , 13433 2518 73 30 30 CD 13433 2518 74 f. f. NN 13433 2518 75 , , , 13433 2518 76 36 36 CD 13433 2518 77 , , , 13433 2518 78 44 44 CD 13433 2518 79 f. f. NNS 13433 2518 80 , , , 13433 2518 81 46 46 CD 13433 2518 82 f. f. NNS 13433 2518 83 , , , 13433 2518 84 57 57 CD 13433 2518 85 ff ff NNP 13433 2518 86 . . NNP 13433 2518 87 , , , 13433 2518 88 68 68 CD 13433 2518 89 ff ff NN 13433 2518 90 . . . 13433 2519 1 ; ; : 13433 2519 2 73 73 CD 13433 2519 3 ff ff NNP 13433 2519 4 . . NNP 13433 2519 5 , , , 13433 2519 6 144 144 CD 13433 2519 7 ; ; : 13433 2519 8 on on IN 13433 2519 9 a a DT 13433 2519 10 passage passage NN 13433 2519 11 of of IN 13433 2519 12 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2519 13 , , , 13433 2519 14 3 3 CD 13433 2519 15 ff ff NN 13433 2519 16 . . . 13433 2520 1 ; ; : 13433 2520 2 discussion discussion NN 13433 2520 3 of of IN 13433 2520 4 date date NN 13433 2520 5 of of IN 13433 2520 6 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 2520 7 , , , 13433 2520 8 9 9 CD 13433 2520 9 ff ff NN 13433 2520 10 . . . 13433 2521 1 ; ; : 13433 2521 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2521 3 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2521 4 on on IN 13433 2521 5 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 2521 6 , , , 13433 2521 7 15 15 CD 13433 2521 8 ff ff NN 13433 2521 9 . . . 13433 2522 1 ; ; : 13433 2522 2 weightier weighty JJR 13433 2522 3 arguments argument NNS 13433 2522 4 of of IN 13433 2522 5 apologists apologist NNS 13433 2522 6 , , , 13433 2522 7 20 20 CD 13433 2522 8 ff ff NNS 13433 2522 9 . . . 13433 2523 1 ; ; : 13433 2523 2 on on IN 13433 2523 3 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2523 4 of of IN 13433 2523 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2523 6 , , , 13433 2523 7 20 20 CD 13433 2523 8 f. f. NN 13433 2523 9 , , , 13433 2523 10 object object NN 13433 2523 11 of of IN 13433 2523 12 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2523 13 ' ' POS 13433 2523 14 work work NN 13433 2523 15 , , , 13433 2523 16 22 22 CD 13433 2523 17 ; ; : 13433 2523 18 on on IN 13433 2523 19 Hegesippus Hegesippus NNP 13433 2523 20 and and CC 13433 2523 21 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 2523 22 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2523 23 , , , 13433 2523 24 22 22 CD 13433 2523 25 f. f. NN 13433 2523 26 ; ; : 13433 2523 27 on on IN 13433 2523 28 Justin Justin NNP 13433 2523 29 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 2523 30 's 's POS 13433 2523 31 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2523 32 , , , 13433 2523 33 23 23 CD 13433 2523 34 ff ff NNS 13433 2523 35 . . . 13433 2524 1 ; ; : 13433 2524 2 on on IN 13433 2524 3 duration duration NN 13433 2524 4 of of IN 13433 2524 5 ministry ministry NN 13433 2524 6 of of IN 13433 2524 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 2524 8 , , , 13433 2524 9 26 26 CD 13433 2524 10 f. f. NN 13433 2524 11 ; ; : 13433 2524 12 on on IN 13433 2524 13 Hebraic Hebraic NNP 13433 2524 14 character character NN 13433 2524 15 of of IN 13433 2524 16 language language NN 13433 2524 17 of of IN 13433 2524 18 the the DT 13433 2524 19 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2524 20 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2524 21 , , , 13433 2524 22 27 27 CD 13433 2524 23 ff ff NN 13433 2524 24 . . . 13433 2525 1 ; ; : 13433 2525 2 identification identification NN 13433 2525 3 of of IN 13433 2525 4 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 2525 5 , , , 13433 2525 6 30 30 CD 13433 2525 7 ff ff NN 13433 2525 8 . . . 13433 2526 1 ; ; : 13433 2526 2 on on IN 13433 2526 3 argument argument NN 13433 2526 4 of of IN 13433 2526 5 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2526 6 , , , 13433 2526 7 36 36 CD 13433 2526 8 ff ff NN 13433 2526 9 . . . 13433 2527 1 ; ; : 13433 2527 2 on on IN 13433 2527 3 silence silence NN 13433 2527 4 of of IN 13433 2527 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2527 6 , , , 13433 2527 7 45 45 CD 13433 2527 8 ff ff NNS 13433 2527 9 . . . 13433 2528 1 ; ; : 13433 2528 2 the the DT 13433 2528 3 intention intention NN 13433 2528 4 of of IN 13433 2528 5 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2528 6 , , , 13433 2528 7 44 44 CD 13433 2528 8 f. f. NN 13433 2528 9 ; ; : 13433 2528 10 procedure procedure NN 13433 2528 11 of of IN 13433 2528 12 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2528 13 , , , 13433 2528 14 50 50 CD 13433 2528 15 f. f. NNS 13433 2528 16 ; ; : 13433 2528 17 silence silence NN 13433 2528 18 of of IN 13433 2528 19 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2528 20 as as IN 13433 2528 21 evidence evidence NN 13433 2528 22 for for IN 13433 2528 23 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2528 24 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2528 25 , , , 13433 2528 26 56 56 CD 13433 2528 27 f. f. NN 13433 2528 28 ; ; : 13433 2528 29 on on IN 13433 2528 30 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2528 31 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2528 32 , , , 13433 2528 33 57 57 CD 13433 2528 34 ff ff NN 13433 2528 35 . . . 13433 2529 1 ; ; : 13433 2529 2 on on IN 13433 2529 3 view view NN 13433 2529 4 of of IN 13433 2529 5 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 2529 6 , , , 13433 2529 7 60 60 CD 13433 2529 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2529 9 ; ; : 13433 2529 10 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 2529 11 regarding regard VBG 13433 2529 12 references reference NNS 13433 2529 13 in in IN 13433 2529 14 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2529 15 , , , 13433 2529 16 61 61 CD 13433 2529 17 ff ff NN 13433 2529 18 . . . 13433 2530 1 ; ; : 13433 2530 2 differentiation differentiation NN 13433 2530 3 of of IN 13433 2530 4 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2530 5 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2530 6 , , , 13433 2530 7 80 80 CD 13433 2530 8 ff ff NN 13433 2530 9 . . . 13433 2531 1 ; ; : 13433 2531 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2531 3 position position NN 13433 2531 4 in in IN 13433 2531 5 MSS MSS NNP 13433 2531 6 . . . 13433 2531 7 , , , 13433 2531 8 82 82 CD 13433 2531 9 ff ff NN 13433 2531 10 . . . 13433 2532 1 ; ; : 13433 2532 2 on on IN 13433 2532 3 martyr martyr NN 13433 2532 4 - - HYPH 13433 2532 5 journey journey NN 13433 2532 6 and and CC 13433 2532 7 treatment treatment NN 13433 2532 8 of of IN 13433 2532 9 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2532 10 , , , 13433 2532 11 99 99 CD 13433 2532 12 f. f. NNS 13433 2532 13 ; ; , 13433 2532 14 compared compare VBN 13433 2532 15 with with IN 13433 2532 16 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 2532 17 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2532 18 's 's POS 13433 2532 19 , , , 13433 2532 20 100 100 CD 13433 2532 21 f. f. NNS 13433 2532 22 ; ; , 13433 2532 23 compared compare VBN 13433 2532 24 with with IN 13433 2532 25 case case NN 13433 2532 26 of of IN 13433 2532 27 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 2532 28 Proteus Proteus NNP 13433 2532 29 , , , 13433 2532 30 101 101 CD 13433 2532 31 ff ff NN 13433 2532 32 . . . 13433 2533 1 ; ; : 13433 2533 2 on on IN 13433 2533 3 John John NNP 13433 2533 4 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 2533 5 , , , 13433 2533 6 108 108 CD 13433 2533 7 ff ff NNS 13433 2533 8 . . . 13433 2534 1 ; ; : 13433 2534 2 on on IN 13433 2534 3 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2534 4 of of IN 13433 2534 5 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 13433 2534 6 , , , 13433 2534 7 115 115 CD 13433 2534 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2534 9 ; ; : 13433 2534 10 date date NN 13433 2534 11 of of IN 13433 2534 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2534 13 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2534 14 , , , 13433 2534 15 115 115 CD 13433 2534 16 ; ; : 13433 2534 17 does do VBZ 13433 2534 18 not not RB 13433 2534 19 examine examine VB 13433 2534 20 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2534 21 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2534 22 of of IN 13433 2534 23 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 2534 24 , , , 13433 2534 25 116 116 CD 13433 2534 26 ; ; : 13433 2534 27 on on IN 13433 2534 28 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2534 29 of of IN 13433 2534 30 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 13433 2534 31 , , , 13433 2534 32 117 117 CD 13433 2534 33 ff ff NN 13433 2534 34 . . . 13433 2535 1 ; ; : 13433 2535 2 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2535 3 on on IN 13433 2535 4 Mark Mark NNP 13433 2535 5 , , , 13433 2535 6 117 117 CD 13433 2535 7 f. f. NNS 13433 2535 8 ; ; : 13433 2535 9 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2535 10 on on IN 13433 2535 11 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2535 12 , , , 13433 2535 13 119 119 CD 13433 2535 14 ff ff NN 13433 2535 15 . . . 13433 2536 1 ; ; : 13433 2536 2 on on IN 13433 2536 3 accuracy accuracy NN 13433 2536 4 of of IN 13433 2536 5 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2536 6 , , , 13433 2536 7 120 120 CD 13433 2536 8 ff ff NN 13433 2536 9 . . . 13433 2537 1 ; ; : 13433 2537 2 translation translation NN 13433 2537 3 of of IN 13433 2537 4 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 2537 5 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 2537 6 of of IN 13433 2537 7 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2537 8 , , , 13433 2537 9 121 121 CD 13433 2537 10 f. f. NNS 13433 2537 11 ; ; : 13433 2537 12 on on IN 13433 2537 13 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2537 14 according accord VBG 13433 2537 15 to to IN 13433 2537 16 the the DT 13433 2537 17 Hebrews Hebrews NNPS 13433 2537 18 , , , 13433 2537 19 122 122 CD 13433 2537 20 f. f. NN 13433 2537 21 ; ; : 13433 2537 22 on on IN 13433 2537 23 nature nature NN 13433 2537 24 of of IN 13433 2537 25 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 2537 26 of of IN 13433 2537 27 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2537 28 , , , 13433 2537 29 124 124 CD 13433 2537 30 ff ff NN 13433 2537 31 . . . 13433 2538 1 ; ; : 13433 2538 2 can can MD 13433 2538 3 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 2538 4 include include VB 13433 2538 5 narrative narrative NN 13433 2538 6 ? ? . 13433 2539 1 125 125 CD 13433 2539 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2539 3 ; ; : 13433 2539 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2539 5 misapprehension misapprehension NN 13433 2539 6 of of IN 13433 2539 7 argument argument NN 13433 2539 8 of of IN 13433 2539 9 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2539 10 , , , 13433 2539 11 129 129 CD 13433 2539 12 ff ff NNS 13433 2539 13 . . . 13433 2540 1 ; ; : 13433 2540 2 on on IN 13433 2540 3 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 2540 4 of of IN 13433 2540 5 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2540 6 , , , 13433 2540 7 135 135 CD 13433 2540 8 ; ; : 13433 2540 9 on on IN 13433 2540 10 Melito Melito NNP 13433 2540 11 of of IN 13433 2540 12 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 2540 13 , , , 13433 2540 14 135 135 CD 13433 2540 15 f. f. NNS 13433 2540 16 ; ; : 13433 2540 17 erroneous erroneous JJ 13433 2540 18 quotation quotation NN 13433 2540 19 from from IN 13433 2540 20 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2540 21 , , , 13433 2540 22 136 136 CD 13433 2540 23 , , , 13433 2540 24 n. n. NNP 13433 2540 25 2 2 CD 13433 2540 26 ; ; , 13433 2540 27 on on IN 13433 2540 28 Claudius Claudius NNP 13433 2540 29 Apollinaris Apollinaris NNP 13433 2540 30 , , , 13433 2540 31 137 137 CD 13433 2540 32 f. f. NNS 13433 2540 33 ; ; : 13433 2540 34 on on IN 13433 2540 35 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 13433 2540 36 of of IN 13433 2540 37 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 2540 38 , , , 13433 2540 39 137 137 CD 13433 2540 40 ; ; : 13433 2540 41 on on IN 13433 2540 42 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2540 43 of of IN 13433 2540 44 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2540 45 and and CC 13433 2540 46 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2540 47 , , , 13433 2540 48 139 139 CD 13433 2540 49 ff ff NN 13433 2540 50 . . . 13433 2541 1 ; ; : 13433 2541 2 on on IN 13433 2541 3 the the DT 13433 2541 4 " " `` 13433 2541 5 testimony testimony NN 13433 2541 6 of of IN 13433 2541 7 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 2541 8 , , , 13433 2541 9 " " `` 13433 2541 10 140 140 CD 13433 2541 11 ff ff NN 13433 2541 12 . . . 13433 2542 1 ; ; : 13433 2542 2 alleged allege VBN 13433 2542 3 reference reference NN 13433 2542 4 to to IN 13433 2542 5 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 2542 6 , , , 13433 2542 7 142 142 CD 13433 2542 8 f. f. NNS 13433 2542 9 ; ; , 13433 2542 10 alleged allege VBN 13433 2542 11 reference reference NN 13433 2542 12 to to IN 13433 2542 13 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2542 14 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2542 15 , , , 13433 2542 16 144 144 CD 13433 2542 17 ; ; : 13433 2542 18 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2542 19 's 's POS 13433 2542 20 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2542 21 , , , 13433 2542 22 145 145 CD 13433 2542 23 f. f. NNS 13433 2542 24 ; ; : 13433 2542 25 on on IN 13433 2542 26 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2542 27 's 's POS 13433 2542 28 mention mention NN 13433 2542 29 of of IN 13433 2542 30 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2542 31 , , , 13433 2542 32 146 146 CD 13433 2542 33 f. f. NN 13433 2542 34 ; ; : 13433 2542 35 did do VBD 13433 2542 36 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2542 37 directly directly RB 13433 2542 38 know know VB 13433 2542 39 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2542 40 ? ? . 13433 2543 1 146 146 CD 13433 2543 2 ; ; : 13433 2543 3 on on IN 13433 2543 4 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 13433 2543 5 of of IN 13433 2543 6 Addai Addai NNP 13433 2543 7 , , , 13433 2543 8 147 147 CD 13433 2543 9 ; ; : 13433 2543 10 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2543 11 mentions mention VBZ 13433 2543 12 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2543 13 's 's POS 13433 2543 14 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2543 15 , , , 13433 2543 16 147 147 CD 13433 2543 17 ; ; : 13433 2543 18 Dionysius Dionysius NNP 13433 2543 19 Bar Bar NNP 13433 2543 20 - - HYPH 13433 2543 21 Salibi Salibi NNP 13433 2543 22 on on IN 13433 2543 23 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2543 24 's 's POS 13433 2543 25 _ _ NNP 13433 2543 26 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2543 27 _ _ NNP 13433 2543 28 , , , 13433 2543 29 147 147 CD 13433 2543 30 f. f. NNS 13433 2543 31 ; ; : 13433 2543 32 on on IN 13433 2543 33 _ _ NNP 13433 2543 34 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2543 35 _ _ NNP 13433 2543 36 of of IN 13433 2543 37 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 2543 38 , , , 13433 2543 39 148 148 CD 13433 2543 40 ; ; : 13433 2543 41 quite quite RB 13433 2543 42 different different JJ 13433 2543 43 from from IN 13433 2543 44 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2543 45 's 's POS 13433 2543 46 work work NN 13433 2543 47 , , , 13433 2543 48 148 148 CD 13433 2543 49 f. f. NN 13433 2543 50 ; ; : 13433 2543 51 similarity similarity NN 13433 2543 52 to to IN 13433 2543 53 Arabic arabic JJ 13433 2543 54 version version NN 13433 2543 55 asserted assert VBN 13433 2543 56 by by IN 13433 2543 57 Hemphill Hemphill NNP 13433 2543 58 , , , 13433 2543 59 149 149 CD 13433 2543 60 ; ; : 13433 2543 61 case case NN 13433 2543 62 of of IN 13433 2543 63 Victor Victor NNP 13433 2543 64 of of IN 13433 2543 65 Capua Capua NNP 13433 2543 66 , , , 13433 2543 67 152 152 CD 13433 2543 68 f. f. NNS 13433 2543 69 ; ; : 13433 2543 70 Victor Victor NNP 13433 2543 71 must must MD 13433 2543 72 have have VB 13433 2543 73 been be VBN 13433 2543 74 mistaken mistaken JJ 13433 2543 75 , , , 13433 2543 76 153 153 CD 13433 2543 77 f. f. NNS 13433 2543 78 ; ; : 13433 2543 79 Victor Victor NNP 13433 2543 80 not not RB 13433 2543 81 mistaken mistake VBN 13433 2543 82 after after RB 13433 2543 83 all all RB 13433 2543 84 , , , 13433 2543 85 153 153 CD 13433 2543 86 ; ; : 13433 2543 87 on on IN 13433 2543 88 Letter Letter NNP 13433 2543 89 of of IN 13433 2543 90 the the DT 13433 2543 91 Smyrnaens Smyrnaens NNP 13433 2543 92 , , , 13433 2543 93 154 154 CD 13433 2543 94 ff ff NNS 13433 2543 95 . . . 13433 2544 1 ; ; : 13433 2544 2 a a DT 13433 2544 3 short short JJ 13433 2544 4 way way NN 13433 2544 5 with with IN 13433 2544 6 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2544 7 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 2544 8 elements element NNS 13433 2544 9 , , , 13433 2544 10 154 154 CD 13433 2544 11 f. f. NNS 13433 2544 12 ; ; : 13433 2544 13 practically practically RB 13433 2544 14 justifies justify VBZ 13433 2544 15 procedure procedure NN 13433 2544 16 of of IN 13433 2544 17 " " `` 13433 2544 18 Supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 2544 19 Religion religion NN 13433 2544 20 , , , 13433 2544 21 " " '' 13433 2544 22 156 156 CD 13433 2544 23 Lipsius Lipsius NNP 13433 2544 24 , , , 13433 2544 25 on on IN 13433 2544 26 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2544 27 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2544 28 , , , 13433 2544 29 60 60 CD 13433 2544 30 f. f. NN 13433 2544 31 , , , 13433 2544 32 63 63 CD 13433 2544 33 , , , 13433 2544 34 78 78 CD 13433 2544 35 , , , 13433 2544 36 79 79 CD 13433 2544 37 ; ; : 13433 2544 38 on on IN 13433 2544 39 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 2544 40 of of IN 13433 2544 41 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2544 42 , , , 13433 2544 43 135 135 CD 13433 2544 44 Logia logia NN 13433 2544 45 , , , 13433 2544 46 meaning meaning NN 13433 2544 47 of of IN 13433 2544 48 , , , 13433 2544 49 in in IN 13433 2544 50 N.T. N.T. NNP 13433 2544 51 , , , 13433 2544 52 124 124 CD 13433 2544 53 ff ff NN 13433 2544 54 . . . 13433 2545 1 Logos logo NNS 13433 2545 2 doctrine doctrine NN 13433 2545 3 in in IN 13433 2545 4 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2545 5 , , , 13433 2545 6 30 30 CD 13433 2545 7 n. n. NN 13433 2545 8 1 1 CD 13433 2545 9 Lucian Lucian NNP 13433 2545 10 , , , 13433 2545 11 12 12 CD 13433 2545 12 , , , 13433 2545 13 101 101 CD 13433 2545 14 f. f. NNP 13433 2545 15 Luke Luke NNP 13433 2545 16 , , , 13433 2545 17 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2545 18 according accord VBG 13433 2545 19 to to IN 13433 2545 20 , , , 13433 2545 21 supposed suppose VBN 13433 2545 22 reference reference NN 13433 2545 23 to to IN 13433 2545 24 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2545 25 in in IN 13433 2545 26 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2545 27 of of IN 13433 2545 28 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2545 29 and and CC 13433 2545 30 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2545 31 , , , 13433 2545 32 141 141 CD 13433 2545 33 f. f. NNS 13433 2545 34 ; ; : 13433 2545 35 its -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2545 36 use use NN 13433 2545 37 in in IN 13433 2545 38 _ _ NNP 13433 2545 39 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2545 40 _ _ NNP 13433 2545 41 , , , 13433 2545 42 149 149 CD 13433 2545 43 , , , 13433 2545 44 153 153 CD 13433 2545 45 Luthardt Luthardt NNP 13433 2545 46 , , , 13433 2545 47 on on IN 13433 2545 48 passage passage NN 13433 2545 49 of of IN 13433 2545 50 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2545 51 , , , 13433 2545 52 6 6 CD 13433 2545 53 ; ; : 13433 2545 54 on on IN 13433 2545 55 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 2545 56 , , , 13433 2545 57 18 18 CD 13433 2545 58 ; ; : 13433 2545 59 on on IN 13433 2545 60 language language NN 13433 2545 61 of of IN 13433 2545 62 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2545 63 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2545 64 and and CC 13433 2545 65 Apocalypse Apocalypse NNP 13433 2545 66 , , , 13433 2545 67 28 28 CD 13433 2545 68 ff ff NN 13433 2545 69 . . . 13433 2546 1 Magdeburg Magdeburg NNP 13433 2546 2 Centuriators Centuriators NNP 13433 2546 3 , , , 13433 2546 4 64 64 CD 13433 2546 5 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 2546 6 , , , 13433 2546 7 John John NNP 13433 2546 8 , , , 13433 2546 9 on on IN 13433 2546 10 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2546 11 of of IN 13433 2546 12 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2546 13 , , , 13433 2546 14 108 108 CD 13433 2546 15 ff ff NNS 13433 2546 16 . . . 13433 2547 1 Marcus Marcus NNP 13433 2547 2 Aurelius Aurelius NNP 13433 2547 3 , , , 13433 2547 4 105 105 CD 13433 2547 5 f. f. NN 13433 2547 6 Mark Mark NNP 13433 2547 7 , , , 13433 2547 8 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 2547 9 and and CC 13433 2547 10 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2547 11 on on RB 13433 2547 12 , , , 13433 2547 13 117 117 CD 13433 2547 14 f. f. NNS 13433 2547 15 ; ; : 13433 2547 16 not not RB 13433 2547 17 eye eye NN 13433 2547 18 - - HYPH 13433 2547 19 witness witness NN 13433 2547 20 but but CC 13433 2547 21 interpreter interpreter NN 13433 2547 22 of of IN 13433 2547 23 Peter Peter NNP 13433 2547 24 , , , 13433 2547 25 118 118 CD 13433 2547 26 f. f. NNS 13433 2547 27 ; ; : 13433 2547 28 value value NN 13433 2547 29 of of IN 13433 2547 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2547 31 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2547 32 as as IN 13433 2547 33 evidence evidence NN 13433 2547 34 , , , 13433 2547 35 118 118 CD 13433 2547 36 f. f. NNS 13433 2547 37 ; ; : 13433 2547 38 use use NN 13433 2547 39 in in IN 13433 2547 40 _ _ NNP 13433 2547 41 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2547 42 _ _ NNP 13433 2547 43 , , , 13433 2547 44 149 149 CD 13433 2547 45 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2547 46 , , , 13433 2547 47 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 2547 48 and and CC 13433 2547 49 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2547 50 on on RB 13433 2547 51 , , , 13433 2547 52 55 55 CD 13433 2547 53 f. f. NNS 13433 2547 54 , , , 13433 2547 55 119 119 CD 13433 2547 56 ff ff NN 13433 2547 57 . . . 13433 2548 1 ; ; : 13433 2548 2 wrote write VBD 13433 2548 3 oracles oracle NNS 13433 2548 4 in in IN 13433 2548 5 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 2548 6 , , , 13433 2548 7 119 119 CD 13433 2548 8 ff ff NN 13433 2548 9 . . . 13433 2549 1 ; ; : 13433 2549 2 when when WRB 13433 2549 3 translated translate VBN 13433 2549 4 , , , 13433 2549 5 121 121 CD 13433 2549 6 ff ff NN 13433 2549 7 . . . 13433 2550 1 ; ; : 13433 2550 2 use use NN 13433 2550 3 in in IN 13433 2550 4 _ _ NNP 13433 2550 5 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2550 6 _ _ NNP 13433 2550 7 of of IN 13433 2550 8 Ammonius Ammonius NNP 13433 2550 9 , , , 13433 2550 10 148 148 CD 13433 2550 11 ; ; : 13433 2550 12 also also RB 13433 2550 13 in in IN 13433 2550 14 that that DT 13433 2550 15 of of IN 13433 2550 16 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2550 17 , , , 13433 2550 18 149 149 CD 13433 2550 19 f. f. NNP 13433 2550 20 Matthias Matthias NNP 13433 2550 21 , , , 13433 2550 22 16 16 CD 13433 2550 23 , , , 13433 2550 24 18 18 CD 13433 2550 25 Mayerhoff Mayerhoff NNP 13433 2550 26 , , , 13433 2550 27 91 91 CD 13433 2550 28 , , , 13433 2550 29 93 93 CD 13433 2550 30 Melito Melito NNP 13433 2550 31 of of IN 13433 2550 32 Sardis Sardis NNP 13433 2550 33 , , , 13433 2550 34 135 135 CD 13433 2550 35 f. f. NNS 13433 2550 36 Merx Merx NNP 13433 2550 37 , , , 13433 2550 38 78 78 CD 13433 2550 39 , , , 13433 2550 40 79 79 CD 13433 2550 41 Meyer Meyer NNP 13433 2550 42 , , , 13433 2550 43 on on IN 13433 2550 44 passage passage NN 13433 2550 45 of of IN 13433 2550 46 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2550 47 , , , 13433 2550 48 5 5 CD 13433 2550 49 , , , 13433 2550 50 82 82 CD 13433 2550 51 Mill Mill NNP 13433 2550 52 , , , 13433 2550 53 on on IN 13433 2550 54 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2550 55 , , , 13433 2550 56 36 36 CD 13433 2550 57 ff ff NN 13433 2550 58 . . . 13433 2551 1 Milman Milman NNP 13433 2551 2 , , , 13433 2551 3 59 59 CD 13433 2551 4 , , , 13433 2551 5 62 62 CD 13433 2551 6 , , , 13433 2551 7 63 63 CD 13433 2551 8 , , , 13433 2551 9 105 105 CD 13433 2551 10 n. n. NN 13433 2551 11 1 1 CD 13433 2551 12 , , , 13433 2551 13 107 107 CD 13433 2551 14 f. f. NN 13433 2551 15 Moesinger Moesinger NNP 13433 2551 16 , , , 13433 2551 17 Ephraem Ephraem NNP 13433 2551 18 's 's POS 13433 2551 19 Commentary Commentary NNP 13433 2551 20 , , , 13433 2551 21 145 145 CD 13433 2551 22 f. f. NNS 13433 2551 23 , , , 13433 2551 24 150 150 CD 13433 2551 25 Mozley Mozley NNP 13433 2551 26 , , , 13433 2551 27 on on IN 13433 2551 28 belief belief NN 13433 2551 29 , , , 13433 2551 30 35 35 CD 13433 2551 31 f. f. NN 13433 2551 32 Neander Neander NNP 13433 2551 33 , , , 13433 2551 34 70 70 CD 13433 2551 35 , , , 13433 2551 36 71 71 CD 13433 2551 37 f. f. NN 13433 2551 38 , , , 13433 2551 39 105 105 CD 13433 2551 40 f. f. NNS 13433 2551 41 Neubauer Neubauer NNP 13433 2551 42 , , , 13433 2551 43 30 30 CD 13433 2551 44 , , , 13433 2551 45 34 34 CD 13433 2551 46 Nicephorus Nicephorus NNP 13433 2551 47 , , , 13433 2551 48 111 111 CD 13433 2551 49 n. n. NN 13433 2551 50 1 1 CD 13433 2551 51 Olshausen Olshausen NNP 13433 2551 52 , , , 13433 2551 53 7 7 CD 13433 2551 54 , , , 13433 2551 55 32 32 CD 13433 2551 56 " " `` 13433 2551 57 Oracles Oracles NNPS 13433 2551 58 , , , 13433 2551 59 " " '' 13433 2551 60 meaning meaning NN 13433 2551 61 of of IN 13433 2551 62 , , , 13433 2551 63 124 124 CD 13433 2551 64 ff ff NNS 13433 2551 65 . . . 13433 2552 1 Origen Origen NNP 13433 2552 2 , , , 13433 2552 3 on on IN 13433 2552 4 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 2552 5 , , , 13433 2552 6 10 10 CD 13433 2552 7 f. f. NN 13433 2552 8 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2552 9 of of IN 13433 2552 10 Hierapolis Hierapolis NNP 13433 2552 11 , , , 13433 2552 12 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2552 13 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2552 14 from from IN 13433 2552 15 him -PRON- PRP 13433 2552 16 , , , 13433 2552 17 3 3 CD 13433 2552 18 ff ff NN 13433 2552 19 . . . 13433 2553 1 ; ; : 13433 2553 2 object object NN 13433 2553 3 of of IN 13433 2553 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2553 5 work work NN 13433 2553 6 , , , 13433 2553 7 22 22 CD 13433 2553 8 ; ; : 13433 2553 9 references reference NNS 13433 2553 10 of of IN 13433 2553 11 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2553 12 to to IN 13433 2553 13 him -PRON- PRP 13433 2553 14 , , , 13433 2553 15 54 54 CD 13433 2553 16 ff ff NNS 13433 2553 17 . . . 13433 2554 1 ; ; : 13433 2554 2 words word NNS 13433 2554 3 of of IN 13433 2554 4 the the DT 13433 2554 5 Presbyters Presbyters NNPS 13433 2554 6 , , , 13433 2554 7 55 55 CD 13433 2554 8 f. f. NN 13433 2554 9 ; ; : 13433 2554 10 double double JJ 13433 2554 11 reference reference NN 13433 2554 12 to to IN 13433 2554 13 " " `` 13433 2554 14 John John NNP 13433 2554 15 , , , 13433 2554 16 " " '' 13433 2554 17 55 55 CD 13433 2554 18 f. f. NNS 13433 2554 19 ; ; : 13433 2554 20 he -PRON- PRP 13433 2554 21 had have VBD 13433 2554 22 nothing nothing NN 13433 2554 23 to to TO 13433 2554 24 tell tell VB 13433 2554 25 of of IN 13433 2554 26 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2554 27 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2554 28 , , , 13433 2554 29 55 55 CD 13433 2554 30 ff ff NN 13433 2554 31 . . . 13433 2555 1 ; ; : 13433 2555 2 on on IN 13433 2555 3 Mark Mark NNP 13433 2555 4 's 's POS 13433 2555 5 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2555 6 , , , 13433 2555 7 117 117 CD 13433 2555 8 ff ff NN 13433 2555 9 . . . 13433 2556 1 ; ; : 13433 2556 2 on on IN 13433 2556 3 Matthew Matthew NNP 13433 2556 4 's 's POS 13433 2556 5 Hebrew Hebrew NNP 13433 2556 6 Oracles Oracles NNP 13433 2556 7 , , , 13433 2556 8 119 119 CD 13433 2556 9 f. f. NNS 13433 2556 10 ; ; : 13433 2556 11 value value NN 13433 2556 12 of of IN 13433 2556 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2556 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 2556 15 for for IN 13433 2556 16 the the DT 13433 2556 17 Gospels Gospels NNPS 13433 2556 18 , , , 13433 2556 19 127 127 CD 13433 2556 20 f. f. NN 13433 2556 21 Parker Parker NNP 13433 2556 22 , , , 13433 2556 23 65 65 CD 13433 2556 24 , , , 13433 2556 25 66 66 CD 13433 2556 26 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2556 27 , , , 13433 2556 28 Apostle Apostle NNP 13433 2556 29 , , , 13433 2556 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2556 31 treatment treatment NN 13433 2556 32 as as IN 13433 2556 33 prisoner prisoner NN 13433 2556 34 compared compare VBN 13433 2556 35 to to IN 13433 2556 36 that that DT 13433 2556 37 of of IN 13433 2556 38 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2556 39 , , , 13433 2556 40 100 100 CD 13433 2556 41 f. f. NN 13433 2556 42 ; ; : 13433 2556 43 unconscious unconscious JJ 13433 2556 44 testimony testimony NN 13433 2556 45 regarding regard VBG 13433 2556 46 the the DT 13433 2556 47 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 2556 48 , , , 13433 2556 49 165 165 CD 13433 2556 50 ; ; : 13433 2556 51 his -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2556 52 testimony testimony NN 13433 2556 53 for for IN 13433 2556 54 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 2556 55 and and CC 13433 2556 56 Ascension Ascension NNP 13433 2556 57 , , , 13433 2556 58 165 165 CD 13433 2556 59 f. f. NN 13433 2556 60 Pearson Pearson NNP 13433 2556 61 , , , 13433 2556 62 67 67 CD 13433 2556 63 Peregrinus Peregrinus NNP 13433 2556 64 Proteus Proteus NNP 13433 2556 65 , , , 13433 2556 66 102 102 CD 13433 2556 67 ff ff NN 13433 2556 68 . . . 13433 2557 1 Perpetua Perpetua NNP 13433 2557 2 , , , 13433 2557 3 Saturus Saturus NNP 13433 2557 4 and and CC 13433 2557 5 , , , 13433 2557 6 100 100 CD 13433 2557 7 Petau Petau NNP 13433 2557 8 , , , 13433 2557 9 65 65 CD 13433 2557 10 , , , 13433 2557 11 67 67 CD 13433 2557 12 Petermann Petermann NNP 13433 2557 13 , , , 13433 2557 14 78 78 CD 13433 2557 15 ff ff NN 13433 2557 16 . . . 13433 2558 1 Phillips Phillips NNP 13433 2558 2 , , , 13433 2558 3 147 147 CD 13433 2558 4 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2558 5 of of IN 13433 2558 6 Smyrna Smyrna NNP 13433 2558 7 , , , 13433 2558 8 115 115 CD 13433 2558 9 f. f. NNS 13433 2558 10 ; ; : 13433 2558 11 date date NN 13433 2558 12 of of IN 13433 2558 13 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2558 14 , , , 13433 2558 15 115 115 CD 13433 2558 16 Polycarp Polycarp NNP 13433 2558 17 , , , 13433 2558 18 Martyrdom Martyrdom NNP 13433 2558 19 of of IN 13433 2558 20 , , , 13433 2558 21 135 135 CD 13433 2558 22 , , , 13433 2558 23 154 154 CD 13433 2558 24 ff ff NNS 13433 2558 25 . . . 13433 2559 1 ; ; : 13433 2559 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2559 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2559 4 's 's POS 13433 2559 5 short short JJ 13433 2559 6 way way NN 13433 2559 7 with with IN 13433 2559 8 the the DT 13433 2559 9 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 2559 10 elements element NNS 13433 2559 11 , , , 13433 2559 12 154 154 CD 13433 2559 13 f. f. JJ 13433 2559 14 Polycrates Polycrates NNPS 13433 2559 15 of of IN 13433 2559 16 Ephesus Ephesus NNP 13433 2559 17 , , , 13433 2559 18 date date NN 13433 2559 19 , , , 13433 2559 20 137 137 CD 13433 2559 21 ; ; : 13433 2559 22 evidence evidence NN 13433 2559 23 for for IN 13433 2559 24 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2559 25 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2559 26 , , , 13433 2559 27 137 137 CD 13433 2559 28 Pressensé Pressensé NNPS 13433 2559 29 , , , 13433 2559 30 de de NNP 13433 2559 31 , , , 13433 2559 32 60 60 CD 13433 2559 33 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 13433 2559 34 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 13433 2559 35 , , , 13433 2559 36 142 142 CD 13433 2559 37 Quadratus Quadratus NNP 13433 2559 38 , , , 13433 2559 39 Statius Statius NNP 13433 2559 40 , , , 13433 2559 41 date date NN 13433 2559 42 of of IN 13433 2559 43 proconsulship proconsulship NN 13433 2559 44 , , , 13433 2559 45 115 115 CD 13433 2559 46 " " `` 13433 2559 47 Religion Religion NNP 13433 2559 48 , , , 13433 2559 49 Supernatural Supernatural NNP 13433 2559 50 , , , 13433 2559 51 " " '' 13433 2559 52 argument argument NN 13433 2559 53 of of IN 13433 2559 54 , , , 13433 2559 55 36 36 CD 13433 2559 56 ff ff NNP 13433 2559 57 . . NNP 13433 2559 58 , , , 13433 2559 59 40 40 CD 13433 2559 60 ff ff NN 13433 2559 61 . . NNP 13433 2559 62 , , , 13433 2559 63 129 129 CD 13433 2559 64 ff ff NN 13433 2559 65 . . . 13433 2560 1 ; ; : 13433 2560 2 canons canon NNS 13433 2560 3 of of IN 13433 2560 4 criticism criticism NN 13433 2560 5 , , , 13433 2560 6 130 130 CD 13433 2560 7 ff ff NN 13433 2560 8 . . . 13433 2561 1 ; ; : 13433 2561 2 the the DT 13433 2561 3 " " `` 13433 2561 4 testimony testimony NN 13433 2561 5 of of IN 13433 2561 6 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 2561 7 , , , 13433 2561 8 " " `` 13433 2561 9 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2561 10 of of IN 13433 2561 11 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2561 12 and and CC 13433 2561 13 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2561 14 , , , 13433 2561 15 140 140 CD 13433 2561 16 ff ff NN 13433 2561 17 . . . 13433 2562 1 ; ; : 13433 2562 2 was be VBD 13433 2562 3 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2562 4 directly directly RB 13433 2562 5 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 2562 6 with with IN 13433 2562 7 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2562 8 's 's POS 13433 2562 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2562 10 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2562 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2562 12 ? ? . 13433 2563 1 146 146 CD 13433 2563 2 f. f. NNP 13433 2563 3 ; ; : 13433 2563 4 argument argument NN 13433 2563 5 of of IN 13433 2563 6 S.R. S.R. NNP 13433 2564 1 practically practically RB 13433 2564 2 justified justify VBN 13433 2564 3 by by IN 13433 2564 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2564 5 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2564 6 , , , 13433 2564 7 154 154 CD 13433 2564 8 ff ff NNS 13433 2564 9 . . . 13433 2565 1 ; ; : 13433 2565 2 conclusions conclusion NNS 13433 2565 3 of of IN 13433 2565 4 , , , 13433 2565 5 157 157 CD 13433 2565 6 ff ff NNS 13433 2565 7 . . . 13433 2566 1 ; ; : 13433 2566 2 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 3 of of IN 13433 2566 4 Divine Divine NNP 13433 2566 5 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 2566 6 which which WDT 13433 2566 7 is be VBZ 13433 2566 8 necessary necessary JJ 13433 2566 9 , , , 13433 2566 10 157 157 CD 13433 2566 11 ; ; : 13433 2566 12 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2566 13 as as IN 13433 2566 14 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 15 destroyed destroy VBN 13433 2566 16 by by IN 13433 2566 17 doubtful doubtful JJ 13433 2566 18 source source NN 13433 2566 19 , , , 13433 2566 20 157 157 CD 13433 2566 21 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 22 ; ; : 13433 2566 23 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 2566 24 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 25 not not RB 13433 2566 26 original original JJ 13433 2566 27 , , , 13433 2566 28 158 158 CD 13433 2566 29 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 30 , , , 13433 2566 31 stream stream NN 13433 2566 32 of of IN 13433 2566 33 miraculous miraculous JJ 13433 2566 34 pretension pretension NN 13433 2566 35 , , , 13433 2566 36 158 158 CD 13433 2566 37 ; ; : 13433 2566 38 true true JJ 13433 2566 39 character character NN 13433 2566 40 of of IN 13433 2566 41 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2566 42 betrayed betray VBN 13433 2566 43 , , , 13433 2566 44 158 158 CD 13433 2566 45 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 46 ; ; : 13433 2566 47 origin origin NN 13433 2566 48 of of IN 13433 2566 49 belief belief NN 13433 2566 50 in in IN 13433 2566 51 supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 2566 52 interference interference NN 13433 2566 53 , , , 13433 2566 54 159 159 CD 13433 2566 55 ; ; : 13433 2566 56 assumptions assumption NNS 13433 2566 57 to to TO 13433 2566 58 justify justify VB 13433 2566 59 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2566 60 , , , 13433 2566 61 159 159 CD 13433 2566 62 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 63 ; ; : 13433 2566 64 an an DT 13433 2566 65 Infinite Infinite NNP 13433 2566 66 Personal Personal NNP 13433 2566 67 God God NNP 13433 2566 68 , , , 13433 2566 69 159 159 CD 13433 2566 70 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 71 ; ; : 13433 2566 72 Divine divine JJ 13433 2566 73 design design NN 13433 2566 74 of of IN 13433 2566 75 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 2566 76 , , , 13433 2566 77 160 160 CD 13433 2566 78 ; ; : 13433 2566 79 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2566 80 antecedently antecedently RB 13433 2566 81 incredible incredible JJ 13433 2566 82 , , , 13433 2566 83 160 160 CD 13433 2566 84 f. f. NN 13433 2566 85 ; ; : 13433 2566 86 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 87 for for IN 13433 2566 88 the the DT 13433 2566 89 Christian christian JJ 13433 2566 90 miracles miracle NNS 13433 2566 91 , , , 13433 2566 92 161 161 CD 13433 2566 93 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 94 ; ; : 13433 2566 95 principles principle NNS 13433 2566 96 upon upon IN 13433 2566 97 which which WDT 13433 2566 98 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 99 examined examine VBD 13433 2566 100 , , , 13433 2566 101 162 162 CD 13433 2566 102 ; ; : 13433 2566 103 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 104 for for IN 13433 2566 105 Gospels Gospels NNP 13433 2566 106 , , , 13433 2566 107 162 162 CD 13433 2566 108 f. f. NN 13433 2566 109 ; ; : 13433 2566 110 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 111 for for IN 13433 2566 112 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 2566 113 , , , 13433 2566 114 164 164 CD 13433 2566 115 ; ; : 13433 2566 116 the the DT 13433 2566 117 remaining remain VBG 13433 2566 118 books book NNS 13433 2566 119 of of IN 13433 2566 120 New New NNP 13433 2566 121 Testament Testament NNP 13433 2566 122 , , , 13433 2566 123 164 164 CD 13433 2566 124 f. f. NN 13433 2566 125 ; ; : 13433 2566 126 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 127 of of IN 13433 2566 128 Paul Paul NNP 13433 2566 129 , , , 13433 2566 130 165 165 CD 13433 2566 131 ; ; : 13433 2566 132 evidence evidence NN 13433 2566 133 for for IN 13433 2566 134 Resurrection Resurrection NNP 13433 2566 135 and and CC 13433 2566 136 Ascension Ascension NNP 13433 2566 137 , , , 13433 2566 138 165 165 CD 13433 2566 139 f. f. NNS 13433 2566 140 ; ; : 13433 2566 141 results result NNS 13433 2566 142 tested test VBN 13433 2566 143 by by IN 13433 2566 144 general general JJ 13433 2566 145 considerations consideration NNS 13433 2566 146 , , , 13433 2566 147 166 166 CD 13433 2566 148 ff ff NNS 13433 2566 149 . . . 13433 2567 1 ; ; : 13433 2567 2 claim claim NN 13433 2567 3 of of IN 13433 2567 4 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2567 5 to to TO 13433 2567 6 be be VB 13433 2567 7 Divinely divinely RB 13433 2567 8 revealed reveal VBN 13433 2567 9 not not RB 13433 2567 10 original original JJ 13433 2567 11 , , , 13433 2567 12 166 166 CD 13433 2567 13 f. f. NNS 13433 2567 14 ; ; : 13433 2567 15 history history NN 13433 2567 16 and and CC 13433 2567 17 achievements achievement NNS 13433 2567 18 of of IN 13433 2567 19 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2567 20 opposed oppose VBD 13433 2567 21 to to IN 13433 2567 22 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2567 23 , , , 13433 2567 24 167 167 CD 13433 2567 25 f. f. NN 13433 2567 26 ; ; : 13433 2567 27 census census NN 13433 2567 28 of of IN 13433 2567 29 religions religion NNS 13433 2567 30 , , , 13433 2567 31 168 168 CD 13433 2567 32 n. n. NN 13433 2567 33 1 1 CD 13433 2567 34 ; ; : 13433 2567 35 how how WRB 13433 2567 36 far far RB 13433 2567 37 the the DT 13433 2567 38 Great Great NNP 13433 2567 39 Teacher Teacher NNP 13433 2567 40 was be VBD 13433 2567 41 misunderstood misunderstood NN 13433 2567 42 , , , 13433 2567 43 168 168 CD 13433 2567 44 f. f. NNS 13433 2567 45 ; ; : 13433 2567 46 transformation transformation NN 13433 2567 47 of of IN 13433 2567 48 Christianity Christianity NNP 13433 2567 49 , , , 13433 2567 50 169 169 CD 13433 2567 51 f. f. NNS 13433 2567 52 ; ; , 13433 2567 53 alleged allege VBD 13433 2567 54 objections objection NNS 13433 2567 55 to to IN 13433 2567 56 disturbing disturbing JJ 13433 2567 57 belief belief NN 13433 2567 58 , , , 13433 2567 59 169 169 CD 13433 2567 60 f. f. NNS 13433 2567 61 ; ; : 13433 2567 62 objections objection NNS 13433 2567 63 not not RB 13433 2567 64 valid valid JJ 13433 2567 65 , , , 13433 2567 66 170 170 CD 13433 2567 67 f. f. NN 13433 2567 68 ; ; : 13433 2567 69 argument argument NN 13433 2567 70 that that IN 13433 2567 71 Divine Divine NNP 13433 2567 72 Revelation Revelation NNP 13433 2567 73 is be VBZ 13433 2567 74 necessary necessary JJ 13433 2567 75 to to TO 13433 2567 76 man man NN 13433 2567 77 , , , 13433 2567 78 172 172 CD 13433 2567 79 f. f. NNS 13433 2567 80 ; ; : 13433 2567 81 we -PRON- PRP 13433 2567 82 gain gain VBP 13433 2567 83 more more JJR 13433 2567 84 than than IN 13433 2567 85 we -PRON- PRP 13433 2567 86 lose lose VBP 13433 2567 87 by by IN 13433 2567 88 finding find VBG 13433 2567 89 our -PRON- PRP$ 13433 2567 90 theology theology NN 13433 2567 91 to to TO 13433 2567 92 be be VB 13433 2567 93 mere mere JJ 13433 2567 94 human human JJ 13433 2567 95 inventions invention NNS 13433 2567 96 , , , 13433 2567 97 173 173 CD 13433 2567 98 f. f. NNP 13433 2567 99 Resurrection resurrection NN 13433 2567 100 , , , 13433 2567 101 evidence evidence NN 13433 2567 102 for for IN 13433 2567 103 , , , 13433 2567 104 165 165 CD 13433 2567 105 f. f. NNP 13433 2567 106 Reuss Reuss NNP 13433 2567 107 , , , 13433 2567 108 147 147 CD 13433 2567 109 Riggenbach Riggenbach NNP 13433 2567 110 , , , 13433 2567 111 on on IN 13433 2567 112 passage passage NN 13433 2567 113 of of IN 13433 2567 114 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2567 115 , , , 13433 2567 116 5 5 CD 13433 2567 117 ; ; : 13433 2567 118 on on IN 13433 2567 119 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 2567 120 , , , 13433 2567 121 32 32 CD 13433 2567 122 Ritschl Ritschl NNP 13433 2567 123 , , , 13433 2567 124 62 62 CD 13433 2567 125 , , , 13433 2567 126 63 63 CD 13433 2567 127 Rivet Rivet NNS 13433 2567 128 , , , 13433 2567 129 64 64 CD 13433 2567 130 , , , 13433 2567 131 65 65 CD 13433 2567 132 , , , 13433 2567 133 67 67 CD 13433 2567 134 Routh Routh NNPS 13433 2567 135 , , , 13433 2567 136 on on IN 13433 2567 137 passage passage NN 13433 2567 138 of of IN 13433 2567 139 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2567 140 , , , 13433 2567 141 4 4 CD 13433 2567 142 Ruinart Ruinart NNP 13433 2567 143 , , , 13433 2567 144 anniversary anniversary NN 13433 2567 145 of of IN 13433 2567 146 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2567 147 , , , 13433 2567 148 112 112 CD 13433 2567 149 Rumpf Rumpf NNP 13433 2567 150 , , , 13433 2567 151 60 60 CD 13433 2567 152 Sanday Sanday NNP 13433 2567 153 , , , 13433 2567 154 33 33 CD 13433 2567 155 Saumaise Saumaise NNP 13433 2567 156 , , , 13433 2567 157 65 65 CD 13433 2567 158 , , , 13433 2567 159 66 66 CD 13433 2567 160 Schleimann Schleimann NNP 13433 2567 161 , , , 13433 2567 162 75 75 CD 13433 2567 163 f. f. NNP 13433 2567 164 Scholten Scholten NNP 13433 2567 165 , , , 13433 2567 166 11 11 CD 13433 2567 167 n. n. NN 13433 2567 168 2 2 CD 13433 2567 169 , , , 13433 2567 170 80 80 CD 13433 2567 171 , , , 13433 2567 172 91 91 CD 13433 2567 173 f. f. NN 13433 2567 174 , , , 13433 2567 175 96 96 CD 13433 2567 176 f. f. NN 13433 2567 177 , , , 13433 2567 178 147 147 CD 13433 2567 179 Schroeckh Schroeckh NNP 13433 2567 180 , , , 13433 2567 181 70 70 CD 13433 2567 182 , , , 13433 2567 183 71 71 CD 13433 2567 184 Schürer Schürer NNP 13433 2567 185 , , , 13433 2567 186 135 135 CD 13433 2567 187 Shechem Shechem NNP 13433 2567 188 , , , 13433 2567 189 30 30 CD 13433 2567 190 ff ff NN 13433 2567 191 . . . 13433 2568 1 Simeon Simeon NNP 13433 2568 2 , , , 13433 2568 3 52 52 CD 13433 2568 4 , , , 13433 2568 5 105 105 CD 13433 2568 6 f. f. NNS 13433 2568 7 Smyrnaens Smyrnaens NNP 13433 2568 8 , , , 13433 2568 9 Letter Letter NNP 13433 2568 10 of of IN 13433 2568 11 , , , 13433 2568 12 154 154 CD 13433 2568 13 ff ff NNS 13433 2568 14 . . . 13433 2569 1 ; ; : 13433 2569 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2569 3 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2569 4 as as IN 13433 2569 5 a a DT 13433 2569 6 sceptical sceptical JJ 13433 2569 7 critic critic NN 13433 2569 8 , , , 13433 2569 9 154 154 CD 13433 2569 10 f. f. NNP 13433 2569 11 Socinus Socinus NNP 13433 2569 12 , , , 13433 2569 13 65 65 CD 13433 2569 14 Stephen Stephen NNP 13433 2569 15 , , , 13433 2569 16 142 142 CD 13433 2569 17 f. f. NN 13433 2569 18 Sychar Sychar NNP 13433 2569 19 , , , 13433 2569 20 30 30 CD 13433 2569 21 ff ff NN 13433 2569 22 . . . 13433 2570 1 Synoptics synoptic NNS 13433 2570 2 , , , 13433 2570 3 contrasted contrast VBN 13433 2570 4 with with IN 13433 2570 5 Fourth Fourth NNP 13433 2570 6 Gospel Gospel NNP 13433 2570 7 , , , 13433 2570 8 26 26 CD 13433 2570 9 f. f. NN 13433 2570 10 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2570 11 's 's POS 13433 2570 12 _ _ NNP 13433 2570 13 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2570 14 _ _ NNP 13433 2570 15 : : : 13433 2570 16 see see VB 13433 2570 17 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2570 18 Theodoret Theodoret NNP 13433 2570 19 , , , 13433 2570 20 the the DT 13433 2570 21 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2570 22 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2570 23 , , , 13433 2570 24 81 81 CD 13433 2570 25 Thiersch Thiersch NNP 13433 2570 26 , , , 13433 2570 27 7 7 CD 13433 2570 28 , , , 13433 2570 29 70 70 CD 13433 2570 30 Tholuck Tholuck NNP 13433 2570 31 , , , 13433 2570 32 7 7 CD 13433 2570 33 Tischendorf Tischendorf NNP 13433 2570 34 , , , 13433 2570 35 on on IN 13433 2570 36 passage passage NN 13433 2570 37 of of IN 13433 2570 38 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2570 39 , , , 13433 2570 40 3 3 CD 13433 2570 41 ff ff NN 13433 2570 42 . . . 13433 2571 1 ; ; : 13433 2571 2 passage passage NN 13433 2571 3 of of IN 13433 2571 4 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 2571 5 , , , 13433 2571 6 11 11 CD 13433 2571 7 ff ff NN 13433 2571 8 . . . 13433 2572 1 ; ; : 13433 2572 2 does do VBZ 13433 2572 3 not not RB 13433 2572 4 notice notice VB 13433 2572 5 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2572 6 version version NN 13433 2572 7 of of IN 13433 2572 8 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2572 9 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2572 10 , , , 13433 2572 11 80 80 CD 13433 2572 12 ; ; : 13433 2572 13 " " `` 13433 2572 14 testimony testimony NN 13433 2572 15 of of IN 13433 2572 16 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 2572 17 , , , 13433 2572 18 " " '' 13433 2572 19 in in IN 13433 2572 20 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2572 21 of of IN 13433 2572 22 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2572 23 and and CC 13433 2572 24 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2572 25 , , , 13433 2572 26 142 142 CD 13433 2572 27 ; ; : 13433 2572 28 it -PRON- PRP 13433 2572 29 is be VBZ 13433 2572 30 a a DT 13433 2572 31 reference reference NN 13433 2572 32 to to IN 13433 2572 33 the the DT 13433 2572 34 Protevangelium Protevangelium NNP 13433 2572 35 Jacobi Jacobi NNP 13433 2572 36 , , , 13433 2572 37 142 142 CD 13433 2572 38 Trajan Trajan NNP 13433 2572 39 , , , 13433 2572 40 in in IN 13433 2572 41 connection connection NN 13433 2572 42 with with IN 13433 2572 43 the the DT 13433 2572 44 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2572 45 of of IN 13433 2572 46 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2572 47 , , , 13433 2572 48 89 89 CD 13433 2572 49 ff ff NN 13433 2572 50 . . NNP 13433 2572 51 , , , 13433 2572 52 105 105 CD 13433 2572 53 ff ff NN 13433 2572 54 . . . 13433 2573 1 Tregelles tregelle NNS 13433 2573 2 , , , 13433 2573 3 60 60 CD 13433 2573 4 , , , 13433 2573 5 82 82 CD 13433 2573 6 f. f. NN 13433 2573 7 Uhlhorn Uhlhorn NNP 13433 2573 8 , , , 13433 2573 9 78 78 CD 13433 2573 10 , , , 13433 2573 11 79 79 CD 13433 2573 12 Ussher Ussher NNP 13433 2573 13 , , , 13433 2573 14 67 67 CD 13433 2573 15 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2573 16 and and CC 13433 2573 17 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2573 18 , , , 13433 2573 19 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2573 20 of of IN 13433 2573 21 , , , 13433 2573 22 139 139 CD 13433 2573 23 ff ff NN 13433 2573 24 . . . 13433 2574 1 ; ; : 13433 2574 2 date date NN 13433 2574 3 , , , 13433 2574 4 139 139 CD 13433 2574 5 ; ; : 13433 2574 6 the the DT 13433 2574 7 " " `` 13433 2574 8 testimony testimony NN 13433 2574 9 of of IN 13433 2574 10 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 2574 11 , , , 13433 2574 12 " " '' 13433 2574 13 140 140 CD 13433 2574 14 f. f. NNS 13433 2574 15 ; ; , 13433 2574 16 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2574 17 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2574 18 of of IN 13433 2574 19 Acts Acts NNPS 13433 2574 20 , , , 13433 2574 21 142 142 CD 13433 2574 22 ff ff NN 13433 2574 23 . . . 13433 2575 1 ; ; : 13433 2575 2 value value NN 13433 2575 3 of of IN 13433 2575 4 evidence evidence NN 13433 2575 5 , , , 13433 2575 6 143 143 CD 13433 2575 7 ; ; : 13433 2575 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2575 9 Lightfoot Lightfoot NNP 13433 2575 10 on on IN 13433 2575 11 fragrance fragrance NN 13433 2575 12 of of IN 13433 2575 13 the the DT 13433 2575 14 martyrs martyr NNS 13433 2575 15 , , , 13433 2575 16 155 155 CD 13433 2575 17 Volkmar Volkmar NNP 13433 2575 18 , , , 13433 2575 19 on on IN 13433 2575 20 Celsus Celsus NNP 13433 2575 21 , , , 13433 2575 22 10 10 CD 13433 2575 23 ff ff NNS 13433 2575 24 . . . 13433 2576 1 ; ; : 13433 2576 2 on on IN 13433 2576 3 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2576 4 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2576 5 , , , 13433 2576 6 60 60 CD 13433 2576 7 ; ; : 13433 2576 8 does do VBZ 13433 2576 9 not not RB 13433 2576 10 notice notice VB 13433 2576 11 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2576 12 version version NN 13433 2576 13 , , , 13433 2576 14 80 80 CD 13433 2576 15 ; ; : 13433 2576 16 date date NN 13433 2576 17 of of IN 13433 2576 18 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2576 19 of of IN 13433 2576 20 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2576 21 , , , 13433 2576 22 92 92 CD 13433 2576 23 f. f. NN 13433 2576 24 ; ; : 13433 2576 25 place place NN 13433 2576 26 of of IN 13433 2576 27 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2576 28 , , , 13433 2576 29 94 94 CD 13433 2576 30 ff ff NN 13433 2576 31 . . . 13433 2577 1 Vossian Vossian NNP 13433 2577 2 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2577 3 of of IN 13433 2577 4 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2577 5 , , , 13433 2577 6 67 67 CD 13433 2577 7 f. f. NNP 13433 2577 8 Wace Wace NNP 13433 2577 9 , , , 13433 2577 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2577 11 , , , 13433 2577 12 153 153 CD 13433 2577 13 Waddington Waddington NNP 13433 2577 14 , , , 13433 2577 15 115 115 CD 13433 2577 16 Weiss Weiss NNP 13433 2577 17 , , , 13433 2577 18 62 62 CD 13433 2577 19 , , , 13433 2577 20 63 63 CD 13433 2577 21 , , , 13433 2577 22 78 78 CD 13433 2577 23 , , , 13433 2577 24 79 79 CD 13433 2577 25 Weissmann Weissmann NNP 13433 2577 26 , , , 13433 2577 27 69 69 CD 13433 2577 28 f. f. NN 13433 2577 29 Westcott Westcott NNP 13433 2577 30 , , , 13433 2577 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 13433 2577 32 , , , 13433 2577 33 criticisms criticism VBZ 13433 2577 34 on on RP 13433 2577 35 , , , 13433 2577 36 3 3 CD 13433 2577 37 f. f. NN 13433 2577 38 ; ; : 13433 2577 39 on on IN 13433 2577 40 Papias Papias NNP 13433 2577 41 , , , 13433 2577 42 4 4 CD 13433 2577 43 ; ; : 13433 2577 44 on on IN 13433 2577 45 Basilides Basilides NNP 13433 2577 46 , , , 13433 2577 47 15 15 CD 13433 2577 48 ff ff NN 13433 2577 49 . . . 13433 2578 1 ; ; : 13433 2578 2 on on IN 13433 2578 3 Justin Justin NNP 13433 2578 4 Martyr Martyr NNP 13433 2578 5 's 's POS 13433 2578 6 quotations quotation NNS 13433 2578 7 , , , 13433 2578 8 23 23 CD 13433 2578 9 ff ff NNS 13433 2578 10 . . . 13433 2579 1 ; ; : 13433 2579 2 on on IN 13433 2579 3 " " `` 13433 2579 4 Supernatural supernatural JJ 13433 2579 5 Religion religion NN 13433 2579 6 , , , 13433 2579 7 " " '' 13433 2579 8 44 44 CD 13433 2579 9 f. f. NNS 13433 2579 10 ; ; : 13433 2579 11 misstatements misstatement NNS 13433 2579 12 regarding regard VBG 13433 2579 13 notes note NNS 13433 2579 14 , , , 13433 2579 15 85 85 CD 13433 2579 16 ff ff NN 13433 2579 17 . . . 13433 2580 1 ; ; : 13433 2580 2 was be VBD 13433 2580 3 Eusebius eusebius NN 13433 2580 4 directly directly RB 13433 2580 5 acquainted acquaint VBN 13433 2580 6 with with IN 13433 2580 7 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2580 8 's 's POS 13433 2580 9 _ _ NNP 13433 2580 10 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2580 11 _ _ NNP 13433 2580 12 ? ? . 13433 2581 1 147 147 CD 13433 2581 2 Wette Wette NNP 13433 2581 3 , , , 13433 2581 4 de de NNP 13433 2581 5 , , , 13433 2581 6 7 7 CD 13433 2581 7 , , , 13433 2581 8 15 15 CD 13433 2581 9 n. n. NN 13433 2581 10 1 1 CD 13433 2581 11 , , , 13433 2581 12 32 32 CD 13433 2581 13 Wieseler Wieseler NNP 13433 2581 14 , , , 13433 2581 15 31 31 CD 13433 2581 16 , , , 13433 2581 17 32 32 CD 13433 2581 18 Wotton Wotton NNP 13433 2581 19 , , , 13433 2581 20 68 68 CD 13433 2581 21 , , , 13433 2581 22 69 69 CD 13433 2581 23 Zacharias Zacharias NNP 13433 2581 24 , , , 13433 2581 25 the the DT 13433 2581 26 testimony testimony NN 13433 2581 27 of of IN 13433 2581 28 , , , 13433 2581 29 Epistle Epistle NNP 13433 2581 30 of of IN 13433 2581 31 Vienne Vienne NNP 13433 2581 32 and and CC 13433 2581 33 Lyons Lyons NNP 13433 2581 34 , , , 13433 2581 35 140 140 CD 13433 2581 36 ff ff NN 13433 2581 37 . . . 13433 2582 1 Zahn Zahn NNP 13433 2582 2 , , , 13433 2582 3 on on IN 13433 2582 4 passage passage NN 13433 2582 5 of of IN 13433 2582 6 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2582 7 , , , 13433 2582 8 6 6 CD 13433 2582 9 ; ; : 13433 2582 10 on on IN 13433 2582 11 Ignatian Ignatian NNP 13433 2582 12 Epistles Epistles NNPS 13433 2582 13 , , , 13433 2582 14 78 78 CD 13433 2582 15 , , , 13433 2582 16 79 79 CD 13433 2582 17 , , , 13433 2582 18 99 99 CD 13433 2582 19 n. n. NN 13433 2582 20 1 1 CD 13433 2582 21 , , , 13433 2582 22 101 101 CD 13433 2582 23 ; ; : 13433 2582 24 on on IN 13433 2582 25 John John NNP 13433 2582 26 Malalas Malalas NNP 13433 2582 27 , , , 13433 2582 28 110 110 CD 13433 2582 29 , , , 13433 2582 30 date date NN 13433 2582 31 of of IN 13433 2582 32 martyrdom martyrdom NN 13433 2582 33 of of IN 13433 2582 34 Ignatius Ignatius NNP 13433 2582 35 , , , 13433 2582 36 112 112 CD 13433 2582 37 ; ; : 13433 2582 38 did do VBD 13433 2582 39 Eusebius Eusebius NNP 13433 2582 40 directly directly RB 13433 2582 41 know know VB 13433 2582 42 Tatian Tatian NNP 13433 2582 43 's 's POS 13433 2582 44 _ _ NNP 13433 2582 45 Diatessaron Diatessaron NNP 13433 2582 46 _ _ NNP 13433 2582 47 ? ? . 13433 2583 1 147 147 CD 13433 2583 2 ; ; : 13433 2583 3 passages passage NNS 13433 2583 4 regarding regard VBG 13433 2583 5 descent descent NN 13433 2583 6 of of IN 13433 2583 7 Jesus Jesus NNP 13433 2583 8 from from IN 13433 2583 9 David David NNP 13433 2583 10 not not RB 13433 2583 11 all all DT 13433 2583 12 excised excise VBD 13433 2583 13 from from IN 13433 2583 14 alleged alleged JJ 13433 2583 15 Armenian armenian JJ 13433 2583 16 version version NN 13433 2583 17 , , , 13433 2583 18 150 150 CD 13433 2583 19 Zeller Zeller NNP 13433 2583 20 , , , 13433 2583 21 on on IN 13433 2583 22 passage passage NN 13433 2583 23 of of IN 13433 2583 24 Irenaeus Irenaeus NNP 13433 2583 25 , , , 13433 2583 26 5 5 CD