id sid tid token lemma pos 31417 1 1 PSYCHIC PSYCHIC NNP 31417 1 2 PHENOMENA PHENOMENA NNP 31417 1 3 A a DT 31417 1 4 BRIEF BRIEF NNP 31417 1 5 ACCOUNT account NN 31417 1 6 OF of IN 31417 1 7 THE the DT 31417 1 8 PHYSICAL physical NN 31417 1 9 MANIFESTATIONS manifestation NNS 31417 1 10 OBSERVED observe VBN 31417 1 11 IN in IN 31417 1 12 PSYCHICAL PSYCHICAL NNP 31417 1 13 RESEARCH research NN 31417 1 14 WITH with IN 31417 1 15 FACSIMILE FACSIMILE VBN 31417 1 16 ILLUSTRATIONS illustration NNS 31417 1 17 OF of IN 31417 1 18 THOUGHT thought NN 31417 1 19 - - HYPH 31417 1 20 TRANSFERENCE transference NN 31417 1 21 DRAWINGS drawing NNS 31417 1 22 AND and CC 31417 1 23 AUTOMATIC automatic NN 31417 1 24 WRITING write VBG 31417 1 25 BY by IN 31417 1 26 EDWARD EDWARD NNP 31417 1 27 T. T. NNP 31417 1 28 BENNETT BENNETT NNP 31417 1 29 ASSISTANT ASSISTANT NNP 31417 1 30 - - HYPH 31417 1 31 SECRETARY SECRETARY NNP 31417 1 32 TO to IN 31417 1 33 THE the DT 31417 1 34 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31417 1 35 OF of IN 31417 1 36 PSYCHICAL PSYCHICAL NNP 31417 1 37 RESEARCH research NN 31417 1 38 , , , 31417 1 39 1882 1882 CD 31417 1 40 - - SYM 31417 1 41 1902 1902 CD 31417 1 42 WITH with IN 31417 1 43 A a DT 31417 1 44 FOREWORD foreword NN 31417 1 45 BY by IN 31417 1 46 SIR SIR NNP 31417 1 47 OLIVER OLIVER NNP 31417 1 48 LODGE LODGE NNP 31417 1 49 NEW NEW NNP 31417 1 50 YORK YORK NNP 31417 1 51 BRENTANO BRENTANO NNP 31417 1 52 'S 's POS 31417 1 53 MCMIX mcmix NN 31417 1 54 NOTE note NN 31417 1 55 The the DT 31417 1 56 writer writer NN 31417 1 57 desires desire NNS 31417 1 58 to to TO 31417 1 59 express express VB 31417 1 60 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1 61 sincere sincere JJ 31417 1 62 thanks thank NNS 31417 1 63 to to IN 31417 1 64 the the DT 31417 1 65 Council Council NNP 31417 1 66 of of IN 31417 1 67 the the DT 31417 1 68 Society Society NNP 31417 1 69 for for IN 31417 1 70 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1 71 Research Research NNP 31417 1 72 for for IN 31417 1 73 the the DT 31417 1 74 permission permission NN 31417 1 75 given give VBN 31417 1 76 to to TO 31417 1 77 make make VB 31417 1 78 extracts extract NNS 31417 1 79 from from IN 31417 1 80 the the DT 31417 1 81 _ _ NNP 31417 1 82 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1 83 _ _ NNP 31417 1 84 of of IN 31417 1 85 the the DT 31417 1 86 Society Society NNP 31417 1 87 , , , 31417 1 88 from from IN 31417 1 89 the the DT 31417 1 90 privately privately RB 31417 1 91 printed print VBN 31417 1 92 _ _ NNP 31417 1 93 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1 94 _ _ NNP 31417 1 95 , , , 31417 1 96 and and CC 31417 1 97 from from IN 31417 1 98 " " `` 31417 1 99 Phantasms Phantasms NNPS 31417 1 100 of of IN 31417 1 101 the the DT 31417 1 102 Living living NN 31417 1 103 " " '' 31417 1 104 ; ; , 31417 1 105 and and CC 31417 1 106 for for IN 31417 1 107 allowing allow VBG 31417 1 108 the the DT 31417 1 109 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1 110 of of IN 31417 1 111 a a DT 31417 1 112 series series NN 31417 1 113 of of IN 31417 1 114 THOUGHT THOUGHT NNP 31417 1 115 - - HYPH 31417 1 116 TRANSFERENCE TRANSFERENCE NNP 31417 1 117 DRAWINGS DRAWINGS NNP 31417 1 118 . . . 31417 2 1 Also also RB 31417 2 2 best good JJS 31417 2 3 thanks thank NNS 31417 2 4 are be VBP 31417 2 5 due due JJ 31417 2 6 to to IN 31417 2 7 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 2 8 Myers Myers NNP 31417 2 9 , , , 31417 2 10 and and CC 31417 2 11 to to IN 31417 2 12 Messrs. Messrs. NNPS 31417 2 13 Longmans Longmans NNPS 31417 2 14 , , , 31417 2 15 Green Green NNP 31417 2 16 & & CC 31417 2 17 Co. Co. NNP 31417 2 18 , , , 31417 2 19 for for IN 31417 2 20 permission permission NN 31417 2 21 to to TO 31417 2 22 make make VB 31417 2 23 quotations quotation NNS 31417 2 24 from from IN 31417 2 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 2 26 F. F. NNP 31417 2 27 W. W. NNP 31417 2 28 H. H. NNP 31417 2 29 Myers Myers NNP 31417 2 30 ' ' POS 31417 2 31 great great JJ 31417 2 32 work work NN 31417 2 33 , , , 31417 2 34 " " '' 31417 2 35 Human Human NNP 31417 2 36 Personality Personality NNP 31417 2 37 and and CC 31417 2 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 2 39 Survival Survival NNP 31417 2 40 of of IN 31417 2 41 Bodily Bodily NNP 31417 2 42 Death Death NNP 31417 2 43 . . . 31417 2 44 " " '' 31417 3 1 Also also RB 31417 3 2 to to IN 31417 3 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 3 4 J. J. NNP 31417 3 5 Burns Burns NNP 31417 3 6 and and CC 31417 3 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 3 8 brother brother NN 31417 3 9 , , , 31417 3 10 for for IN 31417 3 11 freely freely RB 31417 3 12 granting grant VBG 31417 3 13 permission permission NN 31417 3 14 for for IN 31417 3 15 any any DT 31417 3 16 use use NN 31417 3 17 to to TO 31417 3 18 be be VB 31417 3 19 made make VBN 31417 3 20 of of IN 31417 3 21 the the DT 31417 3 22 James James NNP 31417 3 23 Burns Burns NNP 31417 3 24 1873 1873 CD 31417 3 25 Edition Edition NNP 31417 3 26 of of IN 31417 3 27 the the DT 31417 3 28 " " `` 31417 3 29 Report Report NNP 31417 3 30 of of IN 31417 3 31 the the DT 31417 3 32 Committee Committee NNP 31417 3 33 of of IN 31417 3 34 the the DT 31417 3 35 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 3 36 Society Society NNP 31417 3 37 . . . 31417 3 38 " " '' 31417 4 1 E. E. NNP 31417 4 2 T. T. NNP 31417 4 3 B. B. NNP 31417 5 1 CONTENTS content NNS 31417 5 2 CHAP chap VBP 31417 5 3 . . . 31417 6 1 PAGE PAGE NNP 31417 6 2 I. i. NN 31417 7 1 INTRODUCTORY INTRODUCTORY NNP 31417 7 2 11 11 CD 31417 7 3 II ii CD 31417 7 4 . . . 31417 8 1 THE the DT 31417 8 2 MOVEMENT MOVEMENT NNP 31417 8 3 OF of IN 31417 8 4 OBJECTS OBJECTS NNP 31417 8 5 WITHOUT without IN 31417 8 6 ANY any DT 31417 8 7 APPARENT APPARENT NNP 31417 8 8 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 8 9 CAUSE cause IN 31417 8 10 16 16 CD 31417 8 11 III iii CD 31417 8 12 . . . 31417 9 1 THE the DT 31417 9 2 PRODUCTION production NN 31417 9 3 OF of IN 31417 9 4 SOUND SOUND NNP 31417 9 5 WITHOUT without IN 31417 9 6 ANY any DT 31417 9 7 APPARENT APPARENT NNP 31417 9 8 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 9 9 CAUSE cause IN 31417 9 10 31 31 CD 31417 9 11 IV IV NNP 31417 9 12 . . . 31417 10 1 THE the DT 31417 10 2 APPEARANCE APPEARANCE NNP 31417 10 3 OF of IN 31417 10 4 LIGHT LIGHT NNP 31417 10 5 WITHOUT without IN 31417 10 6 ANY any DT 31417 10 7 APPARENT apparent NN 31417 10 8 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 10 9 CAUSE cause IN 31417 10 10 35 35 CD 31417 10 11 V. v. NN 31417 10 12 PHYSICAL physical NN 31417 10 13 PHENOMENA PHENOMENA NNP 31417 10 14 IN in IN 31417 10 15 THE the DT 31417 10 16 PRESENCE PRESENCE NNP 31417 10 17 OF of IN 31417 10 18 DANIEL DANIEL NNP 31417 10 19 DUNGLAS DUNGLAS NNP 31417 10 20 HOME HOME NNP 31417 10 21 41 41 CD 31417 10 22 VI VI NNP 31417 10 23 . . . 31417 11 1 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNP 31417 11 2 PHENOMENA PHENOMENA NNP 31417 11 3 IN in IN 31417 11 4 THE the DT 31417 11 5 PRESENCE PRESENCE NNP 31417 11 6 OF of IN 31417 11 7 W. W. NNP 31417 11 8 STAINTON STAINTON NNP 31417 11 9 MOSES MOSES NNP 31417 11 10 58 58 CD 31417 11 11 VII vii NN 31417 11 12 . . . 31417 12 1 THE the DT 31417 12 2 DIVINING DIVINING NNP 31417 12 3 ROD ROD VBZ 31417 12 4 76 76 CD 31417 12 5 VIII viii NN 31417 12 6 . . . 31417 13 1 THOUGHT THOUGHT NNP 31417 13 2 - - HYPH 31417 13 3 TRANSFERENCE transference NN 31417 13 4 DRAWINGS DRAWINGS NNP 31417 13 5 89 89 CD 31417 13 6 IX ix NN 31417 13 7 . . . 31417 14 1 MATERIALISATIONS materialisations NN 31417 14 2 109 109 CD 31417 14 3 X. x. NN 31417 15 1 " " `` 31417 15 2 SPIRIT SPIRIT NNP 31417 15 3 PHOTOGRAPHY PHOTOGRAPHY NNP 31417 15 4 " " '' 31417 15 5 113 113 CD 31417 15 6 XI XI NNP 31417 15 7 . . . 31417 16 1 THE the DT 31417 16 2 SUMMING sum VBG 31417 16 3 UP up RP 31417 16 4 OF of IN 31417 16 5 THE the DT 31417 16 6 WHOLE whole NN 31417 16 7 MATTER matter NN 31417 16 8 121 121 CD 31417 16 9 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 31417 16 10 BY by IN 31417 16 11 SIR SIR NNP 31417 16 12 OLIVER OLIVER NNP 31417 16 13 LODGE LODGE NNP 31417 16 14 Consulted consult VBN 31417 16 15 by by IN 31417 16 16 the the DT 31417 16 17 publishers publisher NNS 31417 16 18 as as IN 31417 16 19 to to IN 31417 16 20 the the DT 31417 16 21 production production NN 31417 16 22 of of IN 31417 16 23 a a DT 31417 16 24 small small JJ 31417 16 25 popular popular JJ 31417 16 26 text text NN 31417 16 27 - - HYPH 31417 16 28 book book NN 31417 16 29 , , , 31417 16 30 which which WDT 31417 16 31 should should MD 31417 16 32 constitute constitute VB 31417 16 33 a a DT 31417 16 34 summary summary NN 31417 16 35 indication indication NN 31417 16 36 of of IN 31417 16 37 the the DT 31417 16 38 nature nature NN 31417 16 39 of of IN 31417 16 40 the the DT 31417 16 41 evidence evidence NN 31417 16 42 for for IN 31417 16 43 ultra ultra JJ 31417 16 44 - - JJ 31417 16 45 normal normal JJ 31417 16 46 physical physical JJ 31417 16 47 or or CC 31417 16 48 meta meta JJ 31417 16 49 - - HYPH 31417 16 50 psychical psychical JJ 31417 16 51 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 16 52 , , , 31417 16 53 I -PRON- PRP 31417 16 54 suggested suggest VBD 31417 16 55 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 16 56 E. E. NNP 31417 16 57 T. T. NNP 31417 16 58 Bennett Bennett NNP 31417 16 59 as as IN 31417 16 60 the the DT 31417 16 61 right right JJ 31417 16 62 man man NN 31417 16 63 for for IN 31417 16 64 the the DT 31417 16 65 task task NN 31417 16 66 . . . 31417 17 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 17 2 have have VBP 31417 17 3 now now RB 31417 17 4 seen see VBN 31417 17 5 the the DT 31417 17 6 proof proof NN 31417 17 7 sheets sheet NNS 31417 17 8 , , , 31417 17 9 and and CC 31417 17 10 -- -- : 31417 17 11 without without IN 31417 17 12 making make VBG 31417 17 13 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 17 14 in in IN 31417 17 15 any any DT 31417 17 16 way way NN 31417 17 17 responsible responsible JJ 31417 17 18 for for IN 31417 17 19 details detail NNS 31417 17 20 -- -- : 31417 17 21 perceive perceive VBP 31417 17 22 that that IN 31417 17 23 he -PRON- PRP 31417 17 24 has have VBZ 31417 17 25 done do VBN 31417 17 26 the the DT 31417 17 27 work work NN 31417 17 28 well well RB 31417 17 29 , , , 31417 17 30 and and CC 31417 17 31 has have VBZ 31417 17 32 presented present VBN 31417 17 33 a a DT 31417 17 34 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 31417 17 35 outline outline NN 31417 17 36 of of IN 31417 17 37 the the DT 31417 17 38 testimony testimony NN 31417 17 39 for for IN 31417 17 40 whatever whatever WDT 31417 17 41 it -PRON- PRP 31417 17 42 may may MD 31417 17 43 be be VB 31417 17 44 worth worth JJ 31417 17 45 . . . 31417 18 1 Concerning concern VBG 31417 18 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 18 3 value value NN 31417 18 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 18 5 will will MD 31417 18 6 only only RB 31417 18 7 say say VB 31417 18 8 that that DT 31417 18 9 to to IN 31417 18 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 18 11 mind mind NN 31417 18 12 there there EX 31417 18 13 comes come VBZ 31417 18 14 a a DT 31417 18 15 stage stage NN 31417 18 16 at at IN 31417 18 17 which which WDT 31417 18 18 belief belief NN 31417 18 19 in in IN 31417 18 20 gratuitous gratuitous JJ 31417 18 21 invention invention NN 31417 18 22 and and CC 31417 18 23 false false JJ 31417 18 24 statement statement NN 31417 18 25 becomes become VBZ 31417 18 26 forced forced JJ 31417 18 27 and and CC 31417 18 28 irrational irrational JJ 31417 18 29 . . . 31417 19 1 With with IN 31417 19 2 most most JJS 31417 19 3 of of IN 31417 19 4 the the DT 31417 19 5 evidence evidence NN 31417 19 6 here here RB 31417 19 7 adduced adduce VBD 31417 19 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 19 9 have have VBP 31417 19 10 of of IN 31417 19 11 course course NN 31417 19 12 been be VBN 31417 19 13 familiar familiar JJ 31417 19 14 for for IN 31417 19 15 years year NNS 31417 19 16 , , , 31417 19 17 in in IN 31417 19 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 19 19 original original JJ 31417 19 20 sources source NNS 31417 19 21 , , , 31417 19 22 and and CC 31417 19 23 am be VBP 31417 19 24 well well RB 31417 19 25 aware aware JJ 31417 19 26 of of IN 31417 19 27 the the DT 31417 19 28 extreme extreme JJ 31417 19 29 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 19 30 or or CC 31417 19 31 impossibility impossibility NN 31417 19 32 of of IN 31417 19 33 understanding understand VBG 31417 19 34 some some DT 31417 19 35 of of IN 31417 19 36 the the DT 31417 19 37 alleged allege VBN 31417 19 38 facts fact NNS 31417 19 39 in in IN 31417 19 40 any any DT 31417 19 41 physical physical JJ 31417 19 42 or or CC 31417 19 43 physiological physiological JJ 31417 19 44 sense sense NN 31417 19 45 ; ; : 31417 19 46 nevertheless nevertheless RB 31417 19 47 if if IN 31417 19 48 I -PRON- PRP 31417 19 49 am be VBP 31417 19 50 asked ask VBN 31417 19 51 whether whether IN 31417 19 52 such such JJ 31417 19 53 impressions impression NNS 31417 19 54 can can MD 31417 19 55 be be VB 31417 19 56 actually actually RB 31417 19 57 received receive VBN 31417 19 58 and and CC 31417 19 59 honestly honestly RB 31417 19 60 recorded record VBN 31417 19 61 by by IN 31417 19 62 sane sane JJ 31417 19 63 people people NNS 31417 19 64 , , , 31417 19 65 and and CC 31417 19 66 whether whether IN 31417 19 67 I -PRON- PRP 31417 19 68 recommend recommend VBP 31417 19 69 experiment experiment NN 31417 19 70 by by IN 31417 19 71 careful careful JJ 31417 19 72 and and CC 31417 19 73 competent competent JJ 31417 19 74 and and CC 31417 19 75 unsuperstitious unsuperstitious JJ 31417 19 76 observers observer NNS 31417 19 77 as as IN 31417 19 78 if if IN 31417 19 79 a a DT 31417 19 80 _ _ NNP 31417 19 81 primâ primâ NN 31417 19 82 facie facie NN 31417 19 83 _ _ NNP 31417 19 84 case case NN 31417 19 85 had have VBD 31417 19 86 been be VBN 31417 19 87 made make VBN 31417 19 88 out out RP 31417 19 89 -- -- : 31417 19 90 that that DT 31417 19 91 is be VBZ 31417 19 92 to to TO 31417 19 93 say say VB 31417 19 94 , , , 31417 19 95 as as IN 31417 19 96 if if IN 31417 19 97 some some DT 31417 19 98 of of IN 31417 19 99 these these DT 31417 19 100 unusual unusual JJ 31417 19 101 and and CC 31417 19 102 hitherto hitherto JJ 31417 19 103 quite quite RB 31417 19 104 unexplained unexplained JJ 31417 19 105 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 19 106 might may MD 31417 19 107 possibly possibly RB 31417 19 108 turn turn VB 31417 19 109 out out RP 31417 19 110 to to TO 31417 19 111 be be VB 31417 19 112 true true JJ 31417 19 113 -- -- : 31417 19 114 having have VBG 31417 19 115 laws law NNS 31417 19 116 of of IN 31417 19 117 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 19 118 own own JJ 31417 19 119 and and CC 31417 19 120 constituting constitute VBG 31417 19 121 an an DT 31417 19 122 unopened unopened JJ 31417 19 123 chapter chapter NN 31417 19 124 of of IN 31417 19 125 science science NN 31417 19 126 , , , 31417 19 127 or or CC 31417 19 128 rather rather RB 31417 19 129 a a DT 31417 19 130 new new JJ 31417 19 131 science science NN 31417 19 132 , , , 31417 19 133 uniting unite VBG 31417 19 134 characteristics characteristic NNS 31417 19 135 from from IN 31417 19 136 physical physical JJ 31417 19 137 , , , 31417 19 138 chemical chemical JJ 31417 19 139 , , , 31417 19 140 physiological physiological JJ 31417 19 141 , , , 31417 19 142 and and CC 31417 19 143 psychological psychological JJ 31417 19 144 sciences science NNS 31417 19 145 , , , 31417 19 146 and and CC 31417 19 147 throwing throw VBG 31417 19 148 new new JJ 31417 19 149 light light NN 31417 19 150 on on IN 31417 19 151 the the DT 31417 19 152 connection connection NN 31417 19 153 between between IN 31417 19 154 mind mind NN 31417 19 155 and and CC 31417 19 156 matter matter NN 31417 19 157 -- -- : 31417 19 158 then then RB 31417 19 159 , , , 31417 19 160 though though IN 31417 19 161 doubtless doubtless RB 31417 19 162 the the DT 31417 19 163 answer answer NN 31417 19 164 will will MD 31417 19 165 be be VB 31417 19 166 received receive VBN 31417 19 167 with with IN 31417 19 168 scorn scorn JJ 31417 19 169 , , , 31417 19 170 I -PRON- PRP 31417 19 171 answer answer VBP 31417 19 172 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 31417 19 173 yes yes UH 31417 19 174 . . . 31417 20 1 SPIRITUALISM SPIRITUALISM NNP 31417 20 2 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 20 3 I -PRON- PRP 31417 20 4 INTRODUCTORY introductory VBP 31417 20 5 A a DT 31417 20 6 short short JJ 31417 20 7 title title NN 31417 20 8 to to IN 31417 20 9 a a DT 31417 20 10 book book NN 31417 20 11 has have VBZ 31417 20 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 20 13 advantages advantage NNS 31417 20 14 . . . 31417 21 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 21 2 has have VBZ 31417 21 3 also also RB 31417 21 4 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 21 5 disadvantages disadvantage NNS 31417 21 6 . . . 31417 22 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 22 2 is be VBZ 31417 22 3 almost almost RB 31417 22 4 inevitable inevitable JJ 31417 22 5 that that IN 31417 22 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 22 7 should should MD 31417 22 8 , , , 31417 22 9 on on IN 31417 22 10 the the DT 31417 22 11 one one CD 31417 22 12 hand hand NN 31417 22 13 , , , 31417 22 14 seem seem VBP 31417 22 15 to to TO 31417 22 16 include include VB 31417 22 17 much much RB 31417 22 18 more more JJR 31417 22 19 than than IN 31417 22 20 is be VBZ 31417 22 21 intended intend VBN 31417 22 22 , , , 31417 22 23 and and CC 31417 22 24 , , , 31417 22 25 on on IN 31417 22 26 the the DT 31417 22 27 other other JJ 31417 22 28 hand hand NN 31417 22 29 , , , 31417 22 30 fail fail VBP 31417 22 31 to to TO 31417 22 32 convey convey VB 31417 22 33 the the DT 31417 22 34 purpose purpose NN 31417 22 35 of of IN 31417 22 36 the the DT 31417 22 37 author author NN 31417 22 38 . . . 31417 23 1 " " `` 31417 23 2 Geology geology NN 31417 23 3 " " '' 31417 23 4 would would MD 31417 23 5 be be VB 31417 23 6 a a DT 31417 23 7 tolerably tolerably RB 31417 23 8 large large JJ 31417 23 9 subject subject NN 31417 23 10 . . . 31417 24 1 " " `` 31417 24 2 Astronomy Astronomy NNP 31417 24 3 " " '' 31417 24 4 would would MD 31417 24 5 be be VB 31417 24 6 vastly vastly RB 31417 24 7 larger large JJR 31417 24 8 . . . 31417 25 1 But but CC 31417 25 2 " " `` 31417 25 3 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 25 4 " " '' 31417 25 5 is be VBZ 31417 25 6 an an DT 31417 25 7 infinite infinite JJ 31417 25 8 subject subject NN 31417 25 9 compared compare VBN 31417 25 10 with with IN 31417 25 11 either either DT 31417 25 12 , , , 31417 25 13 and and CC 31417 25 14 to to TO 31417 25 15 suggest suggest VB 31417 25 16 that that IN 31417 25 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 25 18 claims claim NNS 31417 25 19 to to IN 31417 25 20 scientific scientific JJ 31417 25 21 study study NN 31417 25 22 be be VB 31417 25 23 considered consider VBN 31417 25 24 within within IN 31417 25 25 the the DT 31417 25 26 compass compass NN 31417 25 27 of of IN 31417 25 28 a a DT 31417 25 29 small small JJ 31417 25 30 volume volume NN 31417 25 31 of of IN 31417 25 32 not not RB 31417 25 33 much much RB 31417 25 34 over over IN 31417 25 35 a a DT 31417 25 36 hundred hundred CD 31417 25 37 pages page NNS 31417 25 38 seems seem VBZ 31417 25 39 the the DT 31417 25 40 height height NN 31417 25 41 of of IN 31417 25 42 presumption presumption NN 31417 25 43 ! ! . 31417 26 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 26 2 will will MD 31417 26 3 therefore therefore RB 31417 26 4 be be VB 31417 26 5 well well JJ 31417 26 6 at at IN 31417 26 7 the the DT 31417 26 8 outset outset NN 31417 26 9 to to TO 31417 26 10 indicate indicate VB 31417 26 11 exactly exactly RB 31417 26 12 what what WP 31417 26 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 26 14 is be VBZ 31417 26 15 proposed propose VBN 31417 26 16 to to TO 31417 26 17 include include VB 31417 26 18 in in IN 31417 26 19 the the DT 31417 26 20 present present JJ 31417 26 21 investigation investigation NN 31417 26 22 into into IN 31417 26 23 " " `` 31417 26 24 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 26 25 . . . 31417 26 26 " " '' 31417 27 1 The the DT 31417 27 2 alleged alleged JJ 31417 27 3 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 27 4 of of IN 31417 27 5 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 27 6 may may MD 31417 27 7 be be VB 31417 27 8 roughly roughly RB 31417 27 9 divided divide VBN 31417 27 10 into into IN 31417 27 11 two two CD 31417 27 12 classes class NNS 31417 27 13 -- -- : 31417 27 14 physical physical JJ 31417 27 15 and and CC 31417 27 16 mental mental JJ 31417 27 17 . . . 31417 28 1 Those those DT 31417 28 2 which which WDT 31417 28 3 belong belong VBP 31417 28 4 entirely entirely RB 31417 28 5 to to IN 31417 28 6 the the DT 31417 28 7 latter latter JJ 31417 28 8 class class NN 31417 28 9 are be VBP 31417 28 10 outside outside IN 31417 28 11 the the DT 31417 28 12 scope scope NN 31417 28 13 of of IN 31417 28 14 this this DT 31417 28 15 book book NN 31417 28 16 . . . 31417 29 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 29 2 is be VBZ 31417 29 3 proposed propose VBN 31417 29 4 to to TO 31417 29 5 examine examine VB 31417 29 6 those those DT 31417 29 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 29 8 of of IN 31417 29 9 the the DT 31417 29 10 former former JJ 31417 29 11 class class NN 31417 29 12 , , , 31417 29 13 the the DT 31417 29 14 reality reality NN 31417 29 15 of of IN 31417 29 16 which which WDT 31417 29 17 may may MD 31417 29 18 fairly fairly RB 31417 29 19 be be VB 31417 29 20 assumed assume VBN 31417 29 21 to to TO 31417 29 22 be be VB 31417 29 23 proved prove VBN 31417 29 24 by by IN 31417 29 25 scientific scientific JJ 31417 29 26 evidence evidence NN 31417 29 27 . . . 31417 30 1 The the DT 31417 30 2 scope scope NN 31417 30 3 of of IN 31417 30 4 the the DT 31417 30 5 work work NN 31417 30 6 is be VBZ 31417 30 7 thus thus RB 31417 30 8 reduced reduce VBN 31417 30 9 to to IN 31417 30 10 reasonable reasonable JJ 31417 30 11 proportions proportion NNS 31417 30 12 . . . 31417 31 1 There there EX 31417 31 2 are be VBP 31417 31 3 several several JJ 31417 31 4 groups group NNS 31417 31 5 of of IN 31417 31 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 31 7 which which WDT 31417 31 8 appear appear VBP 31417 31 9 to to TO 31417 31 10 violate violate VB 31417 31 11 , , , 31417 31 12 or or CC 31417 31 13 at at IN 31417 31 14 least least JJS 31417 31 15 to to TO 31417 31 16 extend extend VB 31417 31 17 in in IN 31417 31 18 a a DT 31417 31 19 striking striking JJ 31417 31 20 manner manner NN 31417 31 21 , , , 31417 31 22 laws law NNS 31417 31 23 recognised recognise VBN 31417 31 24 by by IN 31417 31 25 Physical Physical NNP 31417 31 26 Science Science NNP 31417 31 27 . . . 31417 32 1 The the DT 31417 32 2 evidence evidence NN 31417 32 3 to to TO 31417 32 4 be be VB 31417 32 5 relied rely VBN 31417 32 6 on on IN 31417 32 7 will will MD 31417 32 8 be be VB 31417 32 9 that that DT 31417 32 10 of of IN 31417 32 11 scientific scientific JJ 31417 32 12 men man NNS 31417 32 13 of of IN 31417 32 14 high high JJ 31417 32 15 standing standing NN 31417 32 16 , , , 31417 32 17 and and CC 31417 32 18 of of IN 31417 32 19 other other JJ 31417 32 20 persons person NNS 31417 32 21 of of IN 31417 32 22 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 31417 32 23 literary literary JJ 31417 32 24 and and CC 31417 32 25 social social JJ 31417 32 26 position position NN 31417 32 27 . . . 31417 33 1 There there EX 31417 33 2 is be VBZ 31417 33 3 , , , 31417 33 4 however however RB 31417 33 5 , , , 31417 33 6 an an DT 31417 33 7 important important JJ 31417 33 8 respect respect NN 31417 33 9 , , , 31417 33 10 in in IN 31417 33 11 regard regard NN 31417 33 12 to to IN 31417 33 13 which which WDT 31417 33 14 this this DT 31417 33 15 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 33 16 is be VBZ 31417 33 17 placed place VBN 31417 33 18 in in IN 31417 33 19 an an DT 31417 33 20 entirely entirely RB 31417 33 21 different different JJ 31417 33 22 position position NN 31417 33 23 to to IN 31417 33 24 any any DT 31417 33 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 33 26 scientific scientific JJ 31417 33 27 investigation investigation NN 31417 33 28 , , , 31417 33 29 and and CC 31417 33 30 one one CD 31417 33 31 which which WDT 31417 33 32 adds add VBZ 31417 33 33 greatly greatly RB 31417 33 34 to to IN 31417 33 35 the the DT 31417 33 36 difficulties difficulty NNS 31417 33 37 of of IN 31417 33 38 the the DT 31417 33 39 student student NN 31417 33 40 . . . 31417 34 1 Ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 34 2 experiments experiment NNS 31417 34 3 conducted conduct VBN 31417 34 4 in in IN 31417 34 5 a a DT 31417 34 6 physical physical JJ 31417 34 7 laboratory laboratory NN 31417 34 8 can can MD 31417 34 9 be be VB 31417 34 10 repeated repeat VBN 31417 34 11 again again RB 31417 34 12 and and CC 31417 34 13 again again RB 31417 34 14 under under IN 31417 34 15 similar similar JJ 31417 34 16 conditions condition NNS 31417 34 17 , , , 31417 34 18 and and CC 31417 34 19 similar similar JJ 31417 34 20 results result NNS 31417 34 21 will will MD 31417 34 22 follow follow VB 31417 34 23 . . . 31417 35 1 If if IN 31417 35 2 attempts attempt NNS 31417 35 3 are be VBP 31417 35 4 made make VBN 31417 35 5 to to TO 31417 35 6 reproduce reproduce VB 31417 35 7 the the DT 31417 35 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 35 9 of of IN 31417 35 10 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 35 11 , , , 31417 35 12 under under IN 31417 35 13 what what WP 31417 35 14 appear appear VBP 31417 35 15 to to TO 31417 35 16 be be VB 31417 35 17 precisely precisely RB 31417 35 18 similar similar JJ 31417 35 19 conditions condition NNS 31417 35 20 , , , 31417 35 21 by by IN 31417 35 22 means mean NNS 31417 35 23 which which WDT 31417 35 24 have have VBP 31417 35 25 previously previously RB 31417 35 26 been be VBN 31417 35 27 successful successful JJ 31417 35 28 , , , 31417 35 29 failure failure NN 31417 35 30 to to TO 31417 35 31 obtain obtain VB 31417 35 32 the the DT 31417 35 33 wished wish VBN 31417 35 34 - - HYPH 31417 35 35 for for IN 31417 35 36 results result NNS 31417 35 37 may may MD 31417 35 38 very very RB 31417 35 39 probably probably RB 31417 35 40 follow follow VB 31417 35 41 . . . 31417 36 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 36 2 is be VBZ 31417 36 3 no no DT 31417 36 4 use use NN 31417 36 5 to to TO 31417 36 6 rebel rebel VB 31417 36 7 and and CC 31417 36 8 to to TO 31417 36 9 feel feel VB 31417 36 10 inclined inclined JJ 31417 36 11 to to TO 31417 36 12 abandon abandon VB 31417 36 13 the the DT 31417 36 14 pursuit pursuit NN 31417 36 15 as as IN 31417 36 16 useless useless JJ 31417 36 17 ! ! . 31417 37 1 That that DT 31417 37 2 would would MD 31417 37 3 be be VB 31417 37 4 most most RBS 31417 37 5 unscientific unscientific JJ 31417 37 6 ! ! . 31417 38 1 The the DT 31417 38 2 inquirer inquirer NN 31417 38 3 finds find VBZ 31417 38 4 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 38 5 in in IN 31417 38 6 the the DT 31417 38 7 presence presence NN 31417 38 8 of of IN 31417 38 9 a a DT 31417 38 10 subtle subtle JJ 31417 38 11 elusive elusive JJ 31417 38 12 influence influence NN 31417 38 13 , , , 31417 38 14 which which WDT 31417 38 15 he -PRON- PRP 31417 38 16 seems seem VBZ 31417 38 17 unable unable JJ 31417 38 18 to to TO 31417 38 19 control control VB 31417 38 20 , , , 31417 38 21 and and CC 31417 38 22 which which WDT 31417 38 23 refuses refuse VBZ 31417 38 24 to to TO 31417 38 25 submit submit VB 31417 38 26 to to IN 31417 38 27 the the DT 31417 38 28 laws law NNS 31417 38 29 which which WDT 31417 38 30 govern govern VBP 31417 38 31 physical physical JJ 31417 38 32 experiments experiment NNS 31417 38 33 . . . 31417 39 1 On on IN 31417 39 2 the the DT 31417 39 3 other other JJ 31417 39 4 hand hand NN 31417 39 5 , , , 31417 39 6 perseverance perseverance NN 31417 39 7 may may MD 31417 39 8 be be VB 31417 39 9 richly richly RB 31417 39 10 rewarded reward VBN 31417 39 11 . . . 31417 40 1 An an DT 31417 40 2 unexplored unexplored JJ 31417 40 3 field field NN 31417 40 4 of of IN 31417 40 5 scientific scientific JJ 31417 40 6 research research NN 31417 40 7 of of IN 31417 40 8 unlimited unlimited JJ 31417 40 9 extent extent NN 31417 40 10 may may MD 31417 40 11 open open VB 31417 40 12 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 40 13 to to TO 31417 40 14 view view VB 31417 40 15 . . . 31417 41 1 Something something NN 31417 41 2 of of IN 31417 41 3 that that DT 31417 41 4 joy joy NN 31417 41 5 may may MD 31417 41 6 be be VB 31417 41 7 experienced experience VBN 31417 41 8 which which WDT 31417 41 9 the the DT 31417 41 10 search search NN 31417 41 11 into into IN 31417 41 12 the the DT 31417 41 13 unknown unknown NN 31417 41 14 alone alone RB 31417 41 15 can can MD 31417 41 16 give give VB 31417 41 17 . . . 31417 42 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 42 2 Arthur Arthur NNP 31417 42 3 James James NNP 31417 42 4 Balfour Balfour NNP 31417 42 5 , , , 31417 42 6 in in IN 31417 42 7 an an DT 31417 42 8 address address NN 31417 42 9 on on IN 31417 42 10 the the DT 31417 42 11 occasion occasion NN 31417 42 12 of of IN 31417 42 13 the the DT 31417 42 14 annual annual JJ 31417 42 15 dinner dinner NN 31417 42 16 of of IN 31417 42 17 the the DT 31417 42 18 Royal Royal NNP 31417 42 19 Literary Literary NNP 31417 42 20 Fund Fund NNP 31417 42 21 , , , 31417 42 22 in in IN 31417 42 23 1893 1893 CD 31417 42 24 , , , 31417 42 25 said:-- said:-- ADD 31417 42 26 " " `` 31417 42 27 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 42 28 friend friend NN 31417 42 29 , , , 31417 42 30 Lord Lord NNP 31417 42 31 Kelvin Kelvin NNP 31417 42 32 , , , 31417 42 33 has have VBZ 31417 42 34 often often RB 31417 42 35 talked talk VBN 31417 42 36 to to IN 31417 42 37 me -PRON- PRP 31417 42 38 of of IN 31417 42 39 the the DT 31417 42 40 future future NN 31417 42 41 of of IN 31417 42 42 science science NN 31417 42 43 , , , 31417 42 44 and and CC 31417 42 45 he -PRON- PRP 31417 42 46 has have VBZ 31417 42 47 said say VBN 31417 42 48 words word NNS 31417 42 49 to to IN 31417 42 50 me -PRON- PRP 31417 42 51 about about IN 31417 42 52 the the DT 31417 42 53 future future NN 31417 42 54 of of IN 31417 42 55 science science NN 31417 42 56 which which WDT 31417 42 57 are be VBP 31417 42 58 parallel parallel JJ 31417 42 59 with with IN 31417 42 60 the the DT 31417 42 61 words word NNS 31417 42 62 I -PRON- PRP 31417 42 63 have have VBP 31417 42 64 quoted quote VBN 31417 42 65 to to IN 31417 42 66 you -PRON- PRP 31417 42 67 about about IN 31417 42 68 the the DT 31417 42 69 future future NN 31417 42 70 of of IN 31417 42 71 art art NN 31417 42 72 , , , 31417 42 73 and and CC 31417 42 74 with with IN 31417 42 75 the the DT 31417 42 76 hope hope NN 31417 42 77 which which WDT 31417 42 78 I -PRON- PRP 31417 42 79 have have VBP 31417 42 80 expressed express VBN 31417 42 81 to to IN 31417 42 82 you -PRON- PRP 31417 42 83 with with IN 31417 42 84 respect respect NN 31417 42 85 to to IN 31417 42 86 literature literature NN 31417 42 87 . . . 31417 43 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 43 2 has have VBZ 31417 43 3 told tell VBD 31417 43 4 me -PRON- PRP 31417 43 5 that that DT 31417 43 6 to to IN 31417 43 7 the the DT 31417 43 8 men man NNS 31417 43 9 of of IN 31417 43 10 science science NN 31417 43 11 of of IN 31417 43 12 to to IN 31417 43 13 - - HYPH 31417 43 14 day day NN 31417 43 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 43 16 appears appear VBZ 31417 43 17 as as IN 31417 43 18 if if IN 31417 43 19 we -PRON- PRP 31417 43 20 were be VBD 31417 43 21 trembling tremble VBG 31417 43 22 on on IN 31417 43 23 the the DT 31417 43 24 brink brink NN 31417 43 25 of of IN 31417 43 26 some some DT 31417 43 27 great great JJ 31417 43 28 scientific scientific JJ 31417 43 29 discovery discovery NN 31417 43 30 which which WDT 31417 43 31 should should MD 31417 43 32 give give VB 31417 43 33 to to IN 31417 43 34 us -PRON- PRP 31417 43 35 a a DT 31417 43 36 new new JJ 31417 43 37 view view NN 31417 43 38 of of IN 31417 43 39 the the DT 31417 43 40 great great JJ 31417 43 41 forces force NNS 31417 43 42 of of IN 31417 43 43 Nature Nature NNP 31417 43 44 , , , 31417 43 45 among among IN 31417 43 46 which which WDT 31417 43 47 and and CC 31417 43 48 in in IN 31417 43 49 the the DT 31417 43 50 midst midst NN 31417 43 51 of of IN 31417 43 52 which which WDT 31417 43 53 we -PRON- PRP 31417 43 54 move move VBP 31417 43 55 . . . 31417 44 1 If if IN 31417 44 2 this this DT 31417 44 3 prophecy prophecy NN 31417 44 4 be be VB 31417 44 5 right right JJ 31417 44 6 , , , 31417 44 7 and and CC 31417 44 8 if if IN 31417 44 9 the the DT 31417 44 10 other other JJ 31417 44 11 forecasts forecast NNS 31417 44 12 to to TO 31417 44 13 which which WDT 31417 44 14 I -PRON- PRP 31417 44 15 have have VBP 31417 44 16 alluded allude VBN 31417 44 17 be be VB 31417 44 18 right right JJ 31417 44 19 , , , 31417 44 20 then then RB 31417 44 21 indeed indeed RB 31417 44 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 44 23 is be VBZ 31417 44 24 true true JJ 31417 44 25 that that IN 31417 44 26 we -PRON- PRP 31417 44 27 live live VBP 31417 44 28 in in IN 31417 44 29 an an DT 31417 44 30 interesting interesting JJ 31417 44 31 age age NN 31417 44 32 ; ; : 31417 44 33 then then RB 31417 44 34 indeed indeed RB 31417 44 35 it -PRON- PRP 31417 44 36 is be VBZ 31417 44 37 true true JJ 31417 44 38 that that IN 31417 44 39 we -PRON- PRP 31417 44 40 may may MD 31417 44 41 look look VB 31417 44 42 forward forward RB 31417 44 43 to to IN 31417 44 44 a a DT 31417 44 45 time time NN 31417 44 46 full full JJ 31417 44 47 of of IN 31417 44 48 fruit fruit NN 31417 44 49 for for IN 31417 44 50 the the DT 31417 44 51 human human JJ 31417 44 52 race race NN 31417 44 53 -- -- : 31417 44 54 to to IN 31417 44 55 an an DT 31417 44 56 age age NN 31417 44 57 which which WDT 31417 44 58 can can MD 31417 44 59 not not RB 31417 44 60 be be VB 31417 44 61 sterilised sterilise VBN 31417 44 62 or or CC 31417 44 63 rendered render VBN 31417 44 64 barren barren JJ 31417 44 65 even even RB 31417 44 66 by by IN 31417 44 67 politics politic NNS 31417 44 68 . . . 31417 44 69 " " '' 31417 45 1 There there EX 31417 45 2 are be VBP 31417 45 3 some some DT 31417 45 4 advantages advantage NNS 31417 45 5 which which WDT 31417 45 6 the the DT 31417 45 7 study study NN 31417 45 8 of of IN 31417 45 9 this this DT 31417 45 10 subject subject JJ 31417 45 11 possesses possess VBZ 31417 45 12 over over IN 31417 45 13 most most JJS 31417 45 14 branches branch NNS 31417 45 15 of of IN 31417 45 16 scientific scientific JJ 31417 45 17 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 45 18 . . . 31417 46 1 In in IN 31417 46 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 46 3 present present JJ 31417 46 4 early early JJ 31417 46 5 and and CC 31417 46 6 incomplete incomplete JJ 31417 46 7 stage stage NN 31417 46 8 the the DT 31417 46 9 most most RBS 31417 46 10 important important JJ 31417 46 11 thing thing NN 31417 46 12 is be VBZ 31417 46 13 the the DT 31417 46 14 accumulation accumulation NN 31417 46 15 of of IN 31417 46 16 carefully carefully RB 31417 46 17 observed observe VBN 31417 46 18 and and CC 31417 46 19 recorded record VBN 31417 46 20 facts fact NNS 31417 46 21 . . . 31417 47 1 Even even RB 31417 47 2 as as IN 31417 47 3 regards regard VBZ 31417 47 4 Thought Thought NNP 31417 47 5 - - HYPH 31417 47 6 Transference Transference NNP 31417 47 7 , , , 31417 47 8 in in IN 31417 47 9 which which WDT 31417 47 10 the the DT 31417 47 11 number number NN 31417 47 12 of of IN 31417 47 13 careful careful JJ 31417 47 14 experiments experiment NNS 31417 47 15 that that WDT 31417 47 16 have have VBP 31417 47 17 been be VBN 31417 47 18 made make VBN 31417 47 19 is be VBZ 31417 47 20 far far RB 31417 47 21 greater great JJR 31417 47 22 than than IN 31417 47 23 in in IN 31417 47 24 any any DT 31417 47 25 other other JJ 31417 47 26 class class NN 31417 47 27 of of IN 31417 47 28 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 47 29 , , , 31417 47 30 it -PRON- PRP 31417 47 31 is be VBZ 31417 47 32 still still RB 31417 47 33 most most RBS 31417 47 34 important important JJ 31417 47 35 to to TO 31417 47 36 multiply multiply VB 31417 47 37 the the DT 31417 47 38 quantity quantity NN 31417 47 39 of of IN 31417 47 40 the the DT 31417 47 41 evidence evidence NN 31417 47 42 . . . 31417 48 1 In in IN 31417 48 2 most most JJS 31417 48 3 of of IN 31417 48 4 the the DT 31417 48 5 branches branch NNS 31417 48 6 of of IN 31417 48 7 the the DT 31417 48 8 subject subject JJ 31417 48 9 no no DT 31417 48 10 expensive expensive JJ 31417 48 11 apparatus apparatus NN 31417 48 12 is be VBZ 31417 48 13 required require VBN 31417 48 14 , , , 31417 48 15 and and CC 31417 48 16 no no DT 31417 48 17 special special JJ 31417 48 18 scientific scientific JJ 31417 48 19 or or CC 31417 48 20 intellectual intellectual JJ 31417 48 21 training training NN 31417 48 22 . . . 31417 49 1 Accurate accurate JJ 31417 49 2 observation observation NN 31417 49 3 and and CC 31417 49 4 careful careful JJ 31417 49 5 recording recording NN 31417 49 6 , , , 31417 49 7 at at IN 31417 49 8 the the DT 31417 49 9 time time NN 31417 49 10 , , , 31417 49 11 of of IN 31417 49 12 all all DT 31417 49 13 that that WDT 31417 49 14 occurs occur VBZ 31417 49 15 , , , 31417 49 16 without without IN 31417 49 17 prejudice prejudice NN 31417 49 18 , , , 31417 49 19 and and CC 31417 49 20 without without IN 31417 49 21 discouragement discouragement NN 31417 49 22 at at IN 31417 49 23 apparent apparent JJ 31417 49 24 failure failure NN 31417 49 25 , , , 31417 49 26 are be VBP 31417 49 27 the the DT 31417 49 28 chief chief JJ 31417 49 29 requisites requisite NNS 31417 49 30 . . . 31417 50 1 Any any DT 31417 50 2 person person NN 31417 50 3 , , , 31417 50 4 or or CC 31417 50 5 small small JJ 31417 50 6 group group NN 31417 50 7 of of IN 31417 50 8 persons person NNS 31417 50 9 of of IN 31417 50 10 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 50 11 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 50 12 , , , 31417 50 13 can can MD 31417 50 14 train train VB 31417 50 15 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 50 16 to to TO 31417 50 17 be be VB 31417 50 18 equal equal JJ 31417 50 19 to to IN 31417 50 20 this this DT 31417 50 21 . . . 31417 51 1 A a DT 31417 51 2 very very RB 31417 51 3 simple simple JJ 31417 51 4 instance instance NN 31417 51 5 occurred occur VBD 31417 51 6 in in IN 31417 51 7 the the DT 31417 51 8 earliest early JJS 31417 51 9 experiences experience NNS 31417 51 10 of of IN 31417 51 11 the the DT 31417 51 12 writer writer NN 31417 51 13 . . . 31417 52 1 After after IN 31417 52 2 three three CD 31417 52 3 or or CC 31417 52 4 four four CD 31417 52 5 sittings sitting NNS 31417 52 6 round round IN 31417 52 7 a a DT 31417 52 8 small small JJ 31417 52 9 table table NN 31417 52 10 with with IN 31417 52 11 two two CD 31417 52 12 friends friend NNS 31417 52 13 , , , 31417 52 14 at at IN 31417 52 15 which which WDT 31417 52 16 there there EX 31417 52 17 was be VBD 31417 52 18 meaningless meaningless JJ 31417 52 19 tipping tipping NN 31417 52 20 , , , 31417 52 21 and and CC 31417 52 22 nothing nothing NN 31417 52 23 better well JJR 31417 52 24 than than IN 31417 52 25 commonplace commonplace JJ 31417 52 26 sentences sentence NNS 31417 52 27 , , , 31417 52 28 the the DT 31417 52 29 following follow VBG 31417 52 30 was be VBD 31417 52 31 tipped tip VBN 31417 52 32 out out RP 31417 52 33 : : : 31417 52 34 " " `` 31417 52 35 Try try VB 31417 52 36 no no RB 31417 52 37 more more JJR 31417 52 38 to to IN 31417 52 39 move"--then move"--then NNP 31417 52 40 this this DT 31417 52 41 succession succession NN 31417 52 42 of of IN 31417 52 43 letters--"a letters--"a NNP 31417 52 44 t t NNP 31417 52 45 a a DT 31417 52 46 t t NN 31417 52 47 a. a. NN 31417 52 48 " " '' 31417 53 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 53 2 seemed seem VBD 31417 53 3 useless useless JJ 31417 53 4 to to TO 31417 53 5 go go VB 31417 53 6 on on RP 31417 53 7 with with IN 31417 53 8 nonsense nonsense NN 31417 53 9 , , , 31417 53 10 but but CC 31417 53 11 one one CD 31417 53 12 of of IN 31417 53 13 the the DT 31417 53 14 party party NN 31417 53 15 suggested suggest VBD 31417 53 16 perseverance perseverance NN 31417 53 17 ; ; : 31417 53 18 when when WRB 31417 53 19 the the DT 31417 53 20 following follow VBG 31417 53 21 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 53 22 converted convert VBD 31417 53 23 seeming seeming JJ 31417 53 24 nonsense nonsense NN 31417 53 25 into into IN 31417 53 26 sense sense NN 31417 53 27 : : : 31417 53 28 " " `` 31417 53 29 b b NNP 31417 53 30 l l NNP 31417 53 31 e e NN 31417 53 32 take take VB 31417 53 33 a a DT 31417 53 34 pencil pencil NN 31417 53 35 and and CC 31417 53 36 write write VB 31417 53 37 . . . 31417 53 38 " " '' 31417 54 1 The the DT 31417 54 2 result result NN 31417 54 3 was be VBD 31417 54 4 that that IN 31417 54 5 one one CD 31417 54 6 of of IN 31417 54 7 the the DT 31417 54 8 party party NN 31417 54 9 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 54 10 developed develop VBD 31417 54 11 into into IN 31417 54 12 an an DT 31417 54 13 interesting interesting JJ 31417 54 14 automatic automatic JJ 31417 54 15 writer writer NN 31417 54 16 . . . 31417 55 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 55 2 is be VBZ 31417 55 3 quite quite RB 31417 55 4 impossible impossible JJ 31417 55 5 to to TO 31417 55 6 foretell foretell VB 31417 55 7 the the DT 31417 55 8 extent extent NN 31417 55 9 of of IN 31417 55 10 the the DT 31417 55 11 aid aid NN 31417 55 12 that that WDT 31417 55 13 may may MD 31417 55 14 not not RB 31417 55 15 be be VB 31417 55 16 given give VBN 31417 55 17 , , , 31417 55 18 in in IN 31417 55 19 the the DT 31417 55 20 explanation explanation NN 31417 55 21 of of IN 31417 55 22 some some DT 31417 55 23 of of IN 31417 55 24 these these DT 31417 55 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 55 26 , , , 31417 55 27 by by IN 31417 55 28 the the DT 31417 55 29 persevering persevere VBG 31417 55 30 experiments experiment NNS 31417 55 31 of of IN 31417 55 32 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 55 33 inquirers inquirer NNS 31417 55 34 . . . 31417 56 1 In in IN 31417 56 2 the the DT 31417 56 3 following following JJ 31417 56 4 chapters chapter NNS 31417 56 5 facts fact NNS 31417 56 6 relating relate VBG 31417 56 7 to to IN 31417 56 8 several several JJ 31417 56 9 different different JJ 31417 56 10 kinds kind NNS 31417 56 11 of of IN 31417 56 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 56 13 are be VBP 31417 56 14 put put VBN 31417 56 15 before before IN 31417 56 16 the the DT 31417 56 17 reader reader NN 31417 56 18 , , , 31417 56 19 as as IN 31417 56 20 to to IN 31417 56 21 which which WDT 31417 56 22 the the DT 31417 56 23 guarantee guarantee NN 31417 56 24 of of IN 31417 56 25 authenticity authenticity NN 31417 56 26 and and CC 31417 56 27 the the DT 31417 56 28 quality quality NN 31417 56 29 of of IN 31417 56 30 the the DT 31417 56 31 evidence evidence NN 31417 56 32 are be VBP 31417 56 33 both both RB 31417 56 34 unimpeachable unimpeachable JJ 31417 56 35 . . . 31417 57 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 57 2 is be VBZ 31417 57 3 not not RB 31417 57 4 proposed propose VBN 31417 57 5 to to TO 31417 57 6 travel travel VB 31417 57 7 all all RB 31417 57 8 over over IN 31417 57 9 the the DT 31417 57 10 world world NN 31417 57 11 in in IN 31417 57 12 search search NN 31417 57 13 of of IN 31417 57 14 evidence evidence NN 31417 57 15 ; ; : 31417 57 16 the the DT 31417 57 17 illustrations illustration NNS 31417 57 18 will will MD 31417 57 19 be be VB 31417 57 20 drawn draw VBN 31417 57 21 almost almost RB 31417 57 22 entirely entirely RB 31417 57 23 from from IN 31417 57 24 home home NN 31417 57 25 sources source NNS 31417 57 26 . . . 31417 58 1 With with IN 31417 58 2 all all DT 31417 58 3 due due JJ 31417 58 4 respect respect NN 31417 58 5 to to IN 31417 58 6 friends friend NNS 31417 58 7 in in IN 31417 58 8 distant distant JJ 31417 58 9 parts part NNS 31417 58 10 , , , 31417 58 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 58 12 will will MD 31417 58 13 doubtless doubtless RB 31417 58 14 be be VB 31417 58 15 a a DT 31417 58 16 satisfaction satisfaction NN 31417 58 17 to to IN 31417 58 18 some some DT 31417 58 19 readers reader NNS 31417 58 20 to to TO 31417 58 21 know know VB 31417 58 22 that that IN 31417 58 23 in in IN 31417 58 24 these these DT 31417 58 25 pages page NNS 31417 58 26 they -PRON- PRP 31417 58 27 will will MD 31417 58 28 not not RB 31417 58 29 meet meet VB 31417 58 30 with with IN 31417 58 31 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 58 32 Piper Piper NNP 31417 58 33 on on IN 31417 58 34 the the DT 31417 58 35 one one CD 31417 58 36 hand hand NN 31417 58 37 , , , 31417 58 38 nor nor CC 31417 58 39 with with IN 31417 58 40 Eusapia Eusapia NNP 31417 58 41 Paladino Paladino NNP 31417 58 42 on on IN 31417 58 43 the the DT 31417 58 44 other other JJ 31417 58 45 . . . 31417 59 1 With with IN 31417 59 2 these these DT 31417 59 3 few few JJ 31417 59 4 introductory introductory JJ 31417 59 5 remarks remark NNS 31417 59 6 a a DT 31417 59 7 calm calm JJ 31417 59 8 and and CC 31417 59 9 dispassionate dispassionate JJ 31417 59 10 consideration consideration NN 31417 59 11 of of IN 31417 59 12 the the DT 31417 59 13 evidence evidence NN 31417 59 14 presented present VBN 31417 59 15 is be VBZ 31417 59 16 invited invite VBN 31417 59 17 . . . 31417 60 1 First first RB 31417 60 2 of of IN 31417 60 3 all all DT 31417 60 4 , , , 31417 60 5 three three CD 31417 60 6 classes class NNS 31417 60 7 of of IN 31417 60 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 60 9 will will MD 31417 60 10 be be VB 31417 60 11 taken take VBN 31417 60 12 up up RP 31417 60 13 in in IN 31417 60 14 the the DT 31417 60 15 following following NN 31417 60 16 order:-- order:-- '' 31417 60 17 ( ( -LRB- 31417 60 18 1 1 LS 31417 60 19 ) ) -RRB- 31417 60 20 The the DT 31417 60 21 Movement Movement NNP 31417 60 22 of of IN 31417 60 23 Objects Objects NNPS 31417 60 24 without without IN 31417 60 25 any any DT 31417 60 26 apparent apparent JJ 31417 60 27 Physical Physical NNP 31417 60 28 Cause Cause NNP 31417 60 29 . . . 31417 61 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 61 2 2 2 LS 31417 61 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 61 4 The the DT 31417 61 5 Production Production NNP 31417 61 6 of of IN 31417 61 7 Sound Sound NNP 31417 61 8 without without IN 31417 61 9 any any DT 31417 61 10 apparent apparent JJ 31417 61 11 Physical Physical NNP 31417 61 12 Cause Cause NNP 31417 61 13 . . . 31417 62 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 62 2 3 3 LS 31417 62 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 62 4 The the DT 31417 62 5 Production Production NNP 31417 62 6 of of IN 31417 62 7 Light Light NNP 31417 62 8 without without IN 31417 62 9 any any DT 31417 62 10 apparent apparent JJ 31417 62 11 Physical Physical NNP 31417 62 12 Cause Cause NNP 31417 62 13 . . . 31417 63 1 Two two CD 31417 63 2 chapters chapter NNS 31417 63 3 will will MD 31417 63 4 then then RB 31417 63 5 be be VB 31417 63 6 devoted devoted JJ 31417 63 7 to to IN 31417 63 8 a a DT 31417 63 9 study study NN 31417 63 10 of of IN 31417 63 11 the the DT 31417 63 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 63 13 exhibited exhibit VBN 31417 63 14 in in IN 31417 63 15 the the DT 31417 63 16 lives life NNS 31417 63 17 of of IN 31417 63 18 two two CD 31417 63 19 of of IN 31417 63 20 the the DT 31417 63 21 most most RBS 31417 63 22 noted noted JJ 31417 63 23 " " `` 31417 63 24 mediums medium NNS 31417 63 25 " " '' 31417 63 26 of of IN 31417 63 27 modern modern JJ 31417 63 28 times time NNS 31417 63 29 -- -- : 31417 63 30 Daniel Daniel NNP 31417 63 31 Dunglas Dunglas NNP 31417 63 32 Home Home NNP 31417 63 33 and and CC 31417 63 34 William William NNP 31417 63 35 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 63 36 Moses Moses NNP 31417 63 37 . . . 31417 64 1 Both both DT 31417 64 2 present present JJ 31417 64 3 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 64 4 of of IN 31417 64 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 64 6 belonging belong VBG 31417 64 7 to to IN 31417 64 8 the the DT 31417 64 9 three three CD 31417 64 10 classes class NNS 31417 64 11 above above RB 31417 64 12 - - HYPH 31417 64 13 named name VBN 31417 64 14 , , , 31417 64 15 as as RB 31417 64 16 well well RB 31417 64 17 as as IN 31417 64 18 striking strike VBG 31417 64 19 examples example NNS 31417 64 20 of of IN 31417 64 21 other other JJ 31417 64 22 kinds kind NNS 31417 64 23 . . . 31417 65 1 A a DT 31417 65 2 chapter chapter NN 31417 65 3 on on IN 31417 65 4 the the DT 31417 65 5 " " `` 31417 65 6 Divining Divining NNP 31417 65 7 Rod Rod NNP 31417 65 8 " " '' 31417 65 9 will will MD 31417 65 10 follow follow VB 31417 65 11 . . . 31417 66 1 Then then RB 31417 66 2 a a DT 31417 66 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 66 4 on on IN 31417 66 5 one one CD 31417 66 6 of of IN 31417 66 7 the the DT 31417 66 8 forms form NNS 31417 66 9 of of IN 31417 66 10 Thought Thought NNP 31417 66 11 - - HYPH 31417 66 12 Transference Transference NNP 31417 66 13 , , , 31417 66 14 one one CD 31417 66 15 which which WDT 31417 66 16 allows allow VBZ 31417 66 17 of of IN 31417 66 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 66 19 being be VBG 31417 66 20 included include VBN 31417 66 21 among among IN 31417 66 22 physical physical JJ 31417 66 23 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 66 24 . . . 31417 67 1 Two two CD 31417 67 2 brief brief JJ 31417 67 3 chapters chapter NNS 31417 67 4 will will MD 31417 67 5 come come VB 31417 67 6 next next RB 31417 67 7 on on IN 31417 67 8 " " `` 31417 67 9 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 67 10 Photography Photography NNP 31417 67 11 " " '' 31417 67 12 and and CC 31417 67 13 on on IN 31417 67 14 " " `` 31417 67 15 Materialisations materialisation NNS 31417 67 16 . . . 31417 67 17 " " '' 31417 68 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 68 2 is be VBZ 31417 68 3 explained explain VBN 31417 68 4 that that IN 31417 68 5 these these DT 31417 68 6 are be VBP 31417 68 7 included include VBN 31417 68 8 , , , 31417 68 9 not not RB 31417 68 10 because because IN 31417 68 11 of of IN 31417 68 12 any any DT 31417 68 13 scientific scientific JJ 31417 68 14 evidence evidence NN 31417 68 15 in in IN 31417 68 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 68 17 favour favour NN 31417 68 18 which which WDT 31417 68 19 can can MD 31417 68 20 be be VB 31417 68 21 quoted quote VBN 31417 68 22 , , , 31417 68 23 but but CC 31417 68 24 because because IN 31417 68 25 of of IN 31417 68 26 the the DT 31417 68 27 extreme extreme JJ 31417 68 28 interest interest NN 31417 68 29 and and CC 31417 68 30 importance importance NN 31417 68 31 of of IN 31417 68 32 the the DT 31417 68 33 subjects subject NNS 31417 68 34 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 68 35 , , , 31417 68 36 and and CC 31417 68 37 also also RB 31417 68 38 because because IN 31417 68 39 the the DT 31417 68 40 strong strong JJ 31417 68 41 testimony testimony NN 31417 68 42 and and CC 31417 68 43 moral moral JJ 31417 68 44 evidence evidence NN 31417 68 45 in in IN 31417 68 46 support support NN 31417 68 47 of of IN 31417 68 48 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 68 49 reality reality NN 31417 68 50 seem seem VBP 31417 68 51 to to TO 31417 68 52 promise promise VB 31417 68 53 a a DT 31417 68 54 tempting tempting JJ 31417 68 55 field field NN 31417 68 56 for for IN 31417 68 57 the the DT 31417 68 58 scientific scientific JJ 31417 68 59 explorer explorer NN 31417 68 60 , , , 31417 68 61 and and CC 31417 68 62 to to TO 31417 68 63 warrant warrant VB 31417 68 64 a a DT 31417 68 65 confident confident JJ 31417 68 66 belief belief NN 31417 68 67 that that IN 31417 68 68 the the DT 31417 68 69 evidence evidence NN 31417 68 70 he -PRON- PRP 31417 68 71 desires desire VBZ 31417 68 72 will will MD 31417 68 73 be be VB 31417 68 74 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 31417 68 75 . . . 31417 69 1 In in IN 31417 69 2 a a DT 31417 69 3 final final JJ 31417 69 4 chapter chapter NN 31417 69 5 an an DT 31417 69 6 endeavour endeavour NN 31417 69 7 is be VBZ 31417 69 8 made make VBN 31417 69 9 to to TO 31417 69 10 sum sum VB 31417 69 11 up up RP 31417 69 12 results result NNS 31417 69 13 and and CC 31417 69 14 conclusions conclusion NNS 31417 69 15 . . . 31417 70 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 70 2 II II NNP 31417 70 3 THE the DT 31417 70 4 MOVEMENT MOVEMENT NNP 31417 70 5 OF of IN 31417 70 6 OBJECTS OBJECTS NNP 31417 70 7 WITHOUT without IN 31417 70 8 ANY any DT 31417 70 9 APPARENT APPARENT NNP 31417 70 10 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 70 11 CAUSE CAUSE VBD 31417 70 12 THE the DT 31417 70 13 COMMITTEE COMMITTEE NNP 31417 70 14 OF of IN 31417 70 15 THE the DT 31417 70 16 DIALECTICAL DIALECTICAL NNP 31417 70 17 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31417 70 18 So so RB 31417 70 19 far far RB 31417 70 20 as as IN 31417 70 21 I -PRON- PRP 31417 70 22 am be VBP 31417 70 23 aware aware JJ 31417 70 24 , , , 31417 70 25 the the DT 31417 70 26 first first JJ 31417 70 27 systematic systematic JJ 31417 70 28 or or CC 31417 70 29 scientific scientific JJ 31417 70 30 attempt attempt NN 31417 70 31 to to TO 31417 70 32 investigate investigate VB 31417 70 33 the the DT 31417 70 34 alleged allege VBN 31417 70 35 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 70 36 of of IN 31417 70 37 the the DT 31417 70 38 movement movement NN 31417 70 39 of of IN 31417 70 40 objects object NNS 31417 70 41 without without IN 31417 70 42 any any DT 31417 70 43 apparent apparent JJ 31417 70 44 physical physical JJ 31417 70 45 cause cause NN 31417 70 46 was be VBD 31417 70 47 made make VBN 31417 70 48 by by IN 31417 70 49 the the DT 31417 70 50 London London NNP 31417 70 51 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 70 52 Society Society NNP 31417 70 53 in in IN 31417 70 54 the the DT 31417 70 55 year year NN 31417 70 56 1869 1869 CD 31417 70 57 . . . 31417 71 1 On on IN 31417 71 2 the the DT 31417 71 3 motion motion NN 31417 71 4 of of IN 31417 71 5 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 71 6 James James NNP 31417 71 7 Edmunds Edmunds NNP 31417 71 8 , , , 31417 71 9 a a DT 31417 71 10 Committee Committee NNP 31417 71 11 was be VBD 31417 71 12 appointed appoint VBN 31417 71 13 " " `` 31417 71 14 to to TO 31417 71 15 investigate investigate VB 31417 71 16 the the DT 31417 71 17 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 71 18 alleged allege VBN 31417 71 19 to to TO 31417 71 20 be be VB 31417 71 21 Spiritual Spiritual NNP 31417 71 22 Manifestations Manifestations NNPS 31417 71 23 , , , 31417 71 24 and and CC 31417 71 25 to to TO 31417 71 26 report report VB 31417 71 27 thereon thereon NN 31417 71 28 . . . 31417 71 29 " " '' 31417 72 1 The the DT 31417 72 2 names name NNS 31417 72 3 of of IN 31417 72 4 twenty twenty CD 31417 72 5 - - HYPH 31417 72 6 eight eight CD 31417 72 7 members member NNS 31417 72 8 were be VBD 31417 72 9 proposed propose VBN 31417 72 10 . . . 31417 73 1 Three three CD 31417 73 2 of of IN 31417 73 3 these these DT 31417 73 4 declined decline VBD 31417 73 5 to to TO 31417 73 6 act act VB 31417 73 7 . . . 31417 74 1 Eight eight CD 31417 74 2 more more JJR 31417 74 3 names name NNS 31417 74 4 were be VBD 31417 74 5 added add VBN 31417 74 6 , , , 31417 74 7 so so IN 31417 74 8 that that IN 31417 74 9 the the DT 31417 74 10 Committee Committee NNP 31417 74 11 , , , 31417 74 12 as as IN 31417 74 13 finally finally RB 31417 74 14 constituted constitute VBN 31417 74 15 , , , 31417 74 16 consisted consist VBD 31417 74 17 of of IN 31417 74 18 thirty thirty CD 31417 74 19 - - HYPH 31417 74 20 three three CD 31417 74 21 , , , 31417 74 22 three three CD 31417 74 23 of of IN 31417 74 24 whom whom WP 31417 74 25 were be VBD 31417 74 26 ladies lady NNS 31417 74 27 . . . 31417 75 1 Among among IN 31417 75 2 the the DT 31417 75 3 best well RBS 31417 75 4 - - HYPH 31417 75 5 known know VBN 31417 75 6 names name NNS 31417 75 7 were be VBD 31417 75 8 H. H. NNP 31417 75 9 G. G. NNP 31417 75 10 Atkinson Atkinson NNP 31417 75 11 , , , 31417 75 12 F.G.S. F.G.S. NNP 31417 76 1 ; ; : 31417 76 2 Charles Charles NNP 31417 76 3 Bradlaugh Bradlaugh NNP 31417 76 4 ; ; : 31417 76 5 E. E. NNP 31417 76 6 W. W. NNP 31417 76 7 Cox Cox NNP 31417 76 8 , , , 31417 76 9 serjeant serjeant NN 31417 76 10 - - HYPH 31417 76 11 at at IN 31417 76 12 - - HYPH 31417 76 13 law law NN 31417 76 14 ; ; : 31417 76 15 Rev. Rev. NNP 31417 77 1 C. C. NNP 31417 77 2 Maurice Maurice NNP 31417 77 3 Davies Davies NNP 31417 77 4 , , , 31417 77 5 D.D. D.D. NNP 31417 78 1 ; ; : 31417 78 2 Charles Charles NNP 31417 78 3 R. R. NNP 31417 78 4 Drysdale Drysdale NNP 31417 78 5 , , , 31417 78 6 M.D. M.D. NNP 31417 79 1 ; ; : 31417 79 2 James James NNP 31417 79 3 Edmunds Edmunds NNP 31417 79 4 , , , 31417 79 5 M.D. M.D. NNP 31417 80 1 ; ; : 31417 80 2 Robert Robert NNP 31417 80 3 Hannah Hannah NNP 31417 80 4 ; ; : 31417 80 5 H. H. NNP 31417 80 6 D. D. NNP 31417 80 7 Jencken Jencken NNP 31417 80 8 , , , 31417 80 9 barrister barrister NN 31417 80 10 - - HYPH 31417 80 11 at at IN 31417 80 12 - - HYPH 31417 80 13 law law NN 31417 80 14 ; ; : 31417 80 15 William William NNP 31417 80 16 Volckman Volckman NNP 31417 80 17 ; ; : 31417 80 18 and and CC 31417 80 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 80 20 Alfred Alfred NNP 31417 80 21 Russel Russel NNP 31417 80 22 Wallace Wallace NNP 31417 80 23 , , , 31417 80 24 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 81 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 81 2 is be VBZ 31417 81 3 believed believe VBN 31417 81 4 that that IN 31417 81 5 Robert Robert NNP 31417 81 6 Hannah Hannah NNP 31417 81 7 and and CC 31417 81 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 81 9 Alfred Alfred NNP 31417 81 10 Russel Russel NNP 31417 81 11 Wallace Wallace NNP 31417 81 12 are be VBP 31417 81 13 the the DT 31417 81 14 only only JJ 31417 81 15 survivors survivor NNS 31417 81 16 . . . 31417 82 1 In in IN 31417 82 2 order order NN 31417 82 3 to to TO 31417 82 4 investigate investigate VB 31417 82 5 the the DT 31417 82 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 82 7 in in IN 31417 82 8 question question NN 31417 82 9 by by IN 31417 82 10 personal personal JJ 31417 82 11 experiment experiment NN 31417 82 12 and and CC 31417 82 13 test test NN 31417 82 14 , , , 31417 82 15 the the DT 31417 82 16 Committee Committee NNP 31417 82 17 resolved resolve VBD 31417 82 18 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 82 19 into into IN 31417 82 20 six six CD 31417 82 21 Sub Sub NNP 31417 82 22 - - HYPH 31417 82 23 Committees Committees NNPS 31417 82 24 . . . 31417 83 1 In in IN 31417 83 2 May May NNP 31417 83 3 1870 1870 CD 31417 83 4 the the DT 31417 83 5 Committee Committee NNP 31417 83 6 appointed appoint VBD 31417 83 7 an an DT 31417 83 8 Editing Editing NNP 31417 83 9 Committee Committee NNP 31417 83 10 to to TO 31417 83 11 prepare prepare VB 31417 83 12 a a DT 31417 83 13 joint joint JJ 31417 83 14 report report NN 31417 83 15 , , , 31417 83 16 based base VBN 31417 83 17 solely solely RB 31417 83 18 on on IN 31417 83 19 the the DT 31417 83 20 evidence evidence NN 31417 83 21 that that WDT 31417 83 22 had have VBD 31417 83 23 been be VBN 31417 83 24 before before IN 31417 83 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 83 26 . . . 31417 84 1 A a DT 31417 84 2 month month NN 31417 84 3 later later RBR 31417 84 4 the the DT 31417 84 5 Editing Editing NNP 31417 84 6 Committee Committee NNP 31417 84 7 presented present VBD 31417 84 8 a a DT 31417 84 9 draft draft NN 31417 84 10 report report NN 31417 84 11 , , , 31417 84 12 which which WDT 31417 84 13 with with IN 31417 84 14 some some DT 31417 84 15 trifling trifle VBG 31417 84 16 verbal verbal JJ 31417 84 17 alterations alteration NNS 31417 84 18 was be VBD 31417 84 19 adopted adopt VBN 31417 84 20 _ _ NNP 31417 84 21 nem nem NNP 31417 84 22 dis dis FW 31417 84 23 _ _ NNP 31417 84 24 . . . 31417 85 1 A a DT 31417 85 2 resolution resolution NN 31417 85 3 was be VBD 31417 85 4 then then RB 31417 85 5 carried carry VBN 31417 85 6 that that IN 31417 85 7 a a DT 31417 85 8 copy copy NN 31417 85 9 be be VB 31417 85 10 forwarded forward VBN 31417 85 11 to to IN 31417 85 12 the the DT 31417 85 13 Council Council NNP 31417 85 14 of of IN 31417 85 15 the the DT 31417 85 16 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 85 17 Society Society NNP 31417 85 18 , , , 31417 85 19 with with IN 31417 85 20 a a DT 31417 85 21 recommendation recommendation NN 31417 85 22 that that IN 31417 85 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 85 24 be be VB 31417 85 25 printed print VBN 31417 85 26 and and CC 31417 85 27 published publish VBN 31417 85 28 . . . 31417 86 1 This this DT 31417 86 2 the the DT 31417 86 3 Council Council NNP 31417 86 4 declined decline VBD 31417 86 5 to to TO 31417 86 6 do do VB 31417 86 7 . . . 31417 87 1 Upon upon IN 31417 87 2 this this DT 31417 87 3 the the DT 31417 87 4 Committee Committee NNP 31417 87 5 met meet VBD 31417 87 6 and and CC 31417 87 7 passed pass VBD 31417 87 8 the the DT 31417 87 9 following following JJ 31417 87 10 resolution:-- resolution:-- NNP 31417 87 11 " " `` 31417 87 12 That that IN 31417 87 13 the the DT 31417 87 14 Report Report NNP 31417 87 15 be be VB 31417 87 16 referred refer VBN 31417 87 17 to to IN 31417 87 18 the the DT 31417 87 19 Editing Editing NNP 31417 87 20 Committee Committee NNP 31417 87 21 , , , 31417 87 22 and and CC 31417 87 23 that that IN 31417 87 24 they -PRON- PRP 31417 87 25 be be VBP 31417 87 26 requested request VBN 31417 87 27 to to TO 31417 87 28 prepare prepare VB 31417 87 29 it -PRON- PRP 31417 87 30 for for IN 31417 87 31 publication publication NN 31417 87 32 , , , 31417 87 33 together together RB 31417 87 34 with with IN 31417 87 35 any any DT 31417 87 36 supplementary supplementary JJ 31417 87 37 or or CC 31417 87 38 counter counter JJ 31417 87 39 reports report NNS 31417 87 40 that that WDT 31417 87 41 may may MD 31417 87 42 be be VB 31417 87 43 received receive VBN 31417 87 44 from from IN 31417 87 45 members member NNS 31417 87 46 of of IN 31417 87 47 the the DT 31417 87 48 Committee Committee NNP 31417 87 49 , , , 31417 87 50 and and CC 31417 87 51 appending append VBG 31417 87 52 thereto thereto NN 31417 87 53 the the DT 31417 87 54 reports report NNS 31417 87 55 of of IN 31417 87 56 the the DT 31417 87 57 Sub Sub NNP 31417 87 58 - - HYPH 31417 87 59 Committees Committees NNPS 31417 87 60 , , , 31417 87 61 and and CC 31417 87 62 the the DT 31417 87 63 evidence evidence NN 31417 87 64 , , , 31417 87 65 oral oral JJ 31417 87 66 and and CC 31417 87 67 verbal verbal JJ 31417 87 68 , , , 31417 87 69 that that WDT 31417 87 70 has have VBZ 31417 87 71 been be VBN 31417 87 72 collected collect VBN 31417 87 73 ; ; : 31417 87 74 the the DT 31417 87 75 entire entire JJ 31417 87 76 work work NN 31417 87 77 , , , 31417 87 78 when when WRB 31417 87 79 ready ready JJ 31417 87 80 for for IN 31417 87 81 publication publication NN 31417 87 82 , , , 31417 87 83 to to TO 31417 87 84 be be VB 31417 87 85 submitted submit VBN 31417 87 86 for for IN 31417 87 87 approval approval NN 31417 87 88 to to IN 31417 87 89 the the DT 31417 87 90 Committee Committee NNP 31417 87 91 . . . 31417 88 1 " " `` 31417 88 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 88 3 1 1 CD 31417 88 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 88 5 Such such JJ 31417 88 6 is be VBZ 31417 88 7 the the DT 31417 88 8 origin origin NN 31417 88 9 of of IN 31417 88 10 the the DT 31417 88 11 volume volume NN 31417 88 12 from from IN 31417 88 13 which which WDT 31417 88 14 the the DT 31417 88 15 following follow VBG 31417 88 16 extracts extract NNS 31417 88 17 are be VBP 31417 88 18 made make VBN 31417 88 19 . . . 31417 89 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 89 2 2 2 LS 31417 89 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 89 4 Considerations consideration NNS 31417 89 5 of of IN 31417 89 6 space space NN 31417 89 7 necessitate necessitate NN 31417 89 8 dealing deal VBG 31417 89 9 with with IN 31417 89 10 the the DT 31417 89 11 work work NN 31417 89 12 of of IN 31417 89 13 one one CD 31417 89 14 Sub Sub NNP 31417 89 15 - - HYPH 31417 89 16 Committee Committee NNP 31417 89 17 only only RB 31417 89 18 . . . 31417 90 1 The the DT 31417 90 2 essential essential JJ 31417 90 3 part part NN 31417 90 4 of of IN 31417 90 5 the the DT 31417 90 6 REPORT REPORT NNP 31417 90 7 OF of IN 31417 90 8 SUB SUB NNP 31417 90 9 - - HYPH 31417 90 10 COMMITTEE COMMITTEE NNP 31417 90 11 NO no NN 31417 90 12 . . . 31417 91 1 1 1 CD 31417 91 2 is be VBZ 31417 91 3 as as IN 31417 91 4 follows:-- follows:-- '' 31417 91 5 " " `` 31417 91 6 Since since IN 31417 91 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 91 8 appointment appointment NN 31417 91 9 on on IN 31417 91 10 the the DT 31417 91 11 16th 16th NN 31417 91 12 of of IN 31417 91 13 February February NNP 31417 91 14 1869 1869 CD 31417 91 15 , , , 31417 91 16 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 91 17 Sub Sub NNP 31417 91 18 - - NNP 31417 91 19 Committee Committee NNP 31417 91 20 have have VBP 31417 91 21 held hold VBN 31417 91 22 forty forty CD 31417 91 23 meetings meeting NNS 31417 91 24 for for IN 31417 91 25 the the DT 31417 91 26 purpose purpose NN 31417 91 27 of of IN 31417 91 28 experiment experiment NN 31417 91 29 and and CC 31417 91 30 test test NN 31417 91 31 . . . 31417 92 1 " " `` 31417 92 2 All all DT 31417 92 3 of of IN 31417 92 4 these these DT 31417 92 5 meetings meeting NNS 31417 92 6 were be VBD 31417 92 7 held hold VBN 31417 92 8 at at IN 31417 92 9 the the DT 31417 92 10 private private JJ 31417 92 11 residences residence NNS 31417 92 12 of of IN 31417 92 13 members member NNS 31417 92 14 of of IN 31417 92 15 the the DT 31417 92 16 Committee Committee NNP 31417 92 17 , , , 31417 92 18 purposely purposely RB 31417 92 19 to to TO 31417 92 20 preclude preclude VB 31417 92 21 the the DT 31417 92 22 possibility possibility NN 31417 92 23 of of IN 31417 92 24 pre pre JJ 31417 92 25 - - JJ 31417 92 26 arranged arranged JJ 31417 92 27 mechanism mechanism NN 31417 92 28 or or CC 31417 92 29 contrivance contrivance NN 31417 92 30 . . . 31417 93 1 " " `` 31417 93 2 The the DT 31417 93 3 furniture furniture NN 31417 93 4 of of IN 31417 93 5 the the DT 31417 93 6 room room NN 31417 93 7 in in IN 31417 93 8 which which WDT 31417 93 9 the the DT 31417 93 10 experiments experiment NNS 31417 93 11 were be VBD 31417 93 12 conducted conduct VBN 31417 93 13 was be VBD 31417 93 14 on on IN 31417 93 15 every every DT 31417 93 16 occasion occasion NN 31417 93 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 93 18 accustomed accustomed JJ 31417 93 19 furniture furniture NN 31417 93 20 . . . 31417 94 1 " " `` 31417 94 2 The the DT 31417 94 3 tables table NNS 31417 94 4 were be VBD 31417 94 5 in in IN 31417 94 6 all all DT 31417 94 7 cases case NNS 31417 94 8 heavy heavy JJ 31417 94 9 dining dining NN 31417 94 10 - - HYPH 31417 94 11 tables table NNS 31417 94 12 , , , 31417 94 13 requiring require VBG 31417 94 14 a a DT 31417 94 15 strong strong JJ 31417 94 16 effort effort NN 31417 94 17 to to TO 31417 94 18 move move VB 31417 94 19 them -PRON- PRP 31417 94 20 . . . 31417 95 1 The the DT 31417 95 2 smallest small JJS 31417 95 3 of of IN 31417 95 4 them -PRON- PRP 31417 95 5 was be VBD 31417 95 6 5 5 CD 31417 95 7 feet foot NNS 31417 95 8 9 9 CD 31417 95 9 inches inch NNS 31417 95 10 long long RB 31417 95 11 by by IN 31417 95 12 4 4 CD 31417 95 13 feet foot NNS 31417 95 14 wide wide JJ 31417 95 15 ... ... : 31417 95 16 and and CC 31417 95 17 of of IN 31417 95 18 proportionate proportionate NN 31417 95 19 weight weight NN 31417 95 20 . . . 31417 96 1 " " `` 31417 96 2 The the DT 31417 96 3 rooms room NNS 31417 96 4 , , , 31417 96 5 tables table NNS 31417 96 6 , , , 31417 96 7 and and CC 31417 96 8 furniture furniture NN 31417 96 9 generally generally RB 31417 96 10 were be VBD 31417 96 11 repeatedly repeatedly RB 31417 96 12 subjected subject VBN 31417 96 13 to to IN 31417 96 14 careful careful JJ 31417 96 15 examination examination NN 31417 96 16 before before IN 31417 96 17 , , , 31417 96 18 during during IN 31417 96 19 , , , 31417 96 20 and and CC 31417 96 21 after after IN 31417 96 22 the the DT 31417 96 23 experiments experiment NNS 31417 96 24 , , , 31417 96 25 to to TO 31417 96 26 ascertain ascertain VB 31417 96 27 that that IN 31417 96 28 no no DT 31417 96 29 concealed conceal VBN 31417 96 30 machinery machinery NN 31417 96 31 , , , 31417 96 32 instrument instrument NN 31417 96 33 , , , 31417 96 34 or or CC 31417 96 35 other other JJ 31417 96 36 contrivance contrivance NN 31417 96 37 existed exist VBN 31417 96 38 by by IN 31417 96 39 means mean NNS 31417 96 40 of of IN 31417 96 41 which which WDT 31417 96 42 the the DT 31417 96 43 sounds sound NNS 31417 96 44 or or CC 31417 96 45 movements movement NNS 31417 96 46 hereinafter hereinafter NN 31417 96 47 mentioned mention VBN 31417 96 48 could could MD 31417 96 49 be be VB 31417 96 50 caused cause VBN 31417 96 51 . . . 31417 97 1 " " `` 31417 97 2 The the DT 31417 97 3 experiments experiment NNS 31417 97 4 were be VBD 31417 97 5 conducted conduct VBN 31417 97 6 in in IN 31417 97 7 the the DT 31417 97 8 light light NN 31417 97 9 of of IN 31417 97 10 gas gas NN 31417 97 11 , , , 31417 97 12 except except IN 31417 97 13 on on IN 31417 97 14 the the DT 31417 97 15 few few JJ 31417 97 16 occasions occasion NNS 31417 97 17 specially specially RB 31417 97 18 noted note VBN 31417 97 19 in in IN 31417 97 20 the the DT 31417 97 21 minutes minute NNS 31417 97 22 . . . 31417 98 1 " " `` 31417 98 2 Your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 98 3 Committee Committee NNP 31417 98 4 have have VBP 31417 98 5 avoided avoid VBN 31417 98 6 the the DT 31417 98 7 employment employment NN 31417 98 8 of of IN 31417 98 9 professional professional JJ 31417 98 10 or or CC 31417 98 11 paid pay VBN 31417 98 12 mediums medium NNS 31417 98 13 , , , 31417 98 14 the the DT 31417 98 15 mediumship mediumship NN 31417 98 16 being be VBG 31417 98 17 that that DT 31417 98 18 of of IN 31417 98 19 members member NNS 31417 98 20 of of IN 31417 98 21 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 98 22 Sub Sub NNP 31417 98 23 - - NNP 31417 98 24 Committee Committee NNP 31417 98 25 , , , 31417 98 26 persons person NNS 31417 98 27 of of IN 31417 98 28 good good JJ 31417 98 29 social social JJ 31417 98 30 position position NN 31417 98 31 and and CC 31417 98 32 of of IN 31417 98 33 unimpeachable unimpeachable JJ 31417 98 34 integrity integrity NN 31417 98 35 , , , 31417 98 36 having have VBG 31417 98 37 no no DT 31417 98 38 pecuniary pecuniary JJ 31417 98 39 object object NN 31417 98 40 to to TO 31417 98 41 serve serve VB 31417 98 42 , , , 31417 98 43 and and CC 31417 98 44 nothing nothing NN 31417 98 45 to to TO 31417 98 46 gain gain VB 31417 98 47 by by IN 31417 98 48 deception deception NN 31417 98 49 . . . 31417 99 1 * * NFP 31417 99 2 * * NFP 31417 99 3 * * NFP 31417 99 4 * * NFP 31417 99 5 * * NFP 31417 99 6 " " `` 31417 99 7 Your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 99 8 Committee Committee NNP 31417 99 9 have have VBP 31417 99 10 confined confine VBN 31417 99 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 99 12 Report Report NNP 31417 99 13 to to IN 31417 99 14 _ _ NNP 31417 99 15 facts fact NNS 31417 99 16 _ _ NNP 31417 99 17 witnessed witness VBN 31417 99 18 by by IN 31417 99 19 them -PRON- PRP 31417 99 20 in in IN 31417 99 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 99 22 collective collective JJ 31417 99 23 capacity capacity NN 31417 99 24 , , , 31417 99 25 which which WDT 31417 99 26 facts fact NNS 31417 99 27 were be VBD 31417 99 28 _ _ NNP 31417 99 29 palpable palpable JJ 31417 99 30 to to IN 31417 99 31 the the DT 31417 99 32 senses sense NNS 31417 99 33 , , , 31417 99 34 and and CC 31417 99 35 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 99 36 reality reality NN 31417 99 37 capable capable JJ 31417 99 38 of of IN 31417 99 39 demonstrative demonstrative JJ 31417 99 40 proof proof NN 31417 99 41 _ _ NNP 31417 99 42 . . . 31417 100 1 * * NFP 31417 100 2 * * NFP 31417 100 3 * * NFP 31417 100 4 * * NFP 31417 100 5 * * NFP 31417 100 6 " " `` 31417 100 7 The the DT 31417 100 8 result result NN 31417 100 9 of of IN 31417 100 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 100 11 long long RB 31417 100 12 - - HYPH 31417 100 13 continued continued JJ 31417 100 14 and and CC 31417 100 15 carefully carefully RB 31417 100 16 - - HYPH 31417 100 17 conducted conduct VBN 31417 100 18 experiments experiment NNS 31417 100 19 , , , 31417 100 20 after after IN 31417 100 21 trial trial NN 31417 100 22 by by IN 31417 100 23 every every DT 31417 100 24 detective detective JJ 31417 100 25 test test NN 31417 100 26 they -PRON- PRP 31417 100 27 could could MD 31417 100 28 devise devise VB 31417 100 29 , , , 31417 100 30 has have VBZ 31417 100 31 been be VBN 31417 100 32 to to TO 31417 100 33 establish establish VB 31417 100 34 conclusively:-- conclusively:-- PRP 31417 100 35 " " `` 31417 100 36 First first RB 31417 100 37 : : : 31417 100 38 That that IN 31417 100 39 under under IN 31417 100 40 certain certain JJ 31417 100 41 bodily bodily JJ 31417 100 42 or or CC 31417 100 43 mental mental JJ 31417 100 44 conditions condition NNS 31417 100 45 of of IN 31417 100 46 one one CD 31417 100 47 or or CC 31417 100 48 more more JJR 31417 100 49 of of IN 31417 100 50 the the DT 31417 100 51 persons person NNS 31417 100 52 present present JJ 31417 100 53 , , , 31417 100 54 a a DT 31417 100 55 force force NN 31417 100 56 is be VBZ 31417 100 57 exhibited exhibit VBN 31417 100 58 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 100 59 to to TO 31417 100 60 set set VB 31417 100 61 in in IN 31417 100 62 motion motion NN 31417 100 63 heavy heavy JJ 31417 100 64 substances substance NNS 31417 100 65 , , , 31417 100 66 without without IN 31417 100 67 the the DT 31417 100 68 employment employment NN 31417 100 69 of of IN 31417 100 70 any any DT 31417 100 71 muscular muscular JJ 31417 100 72 force force NN 31417 100 73 , , , 31417 100 74 without without IN 31417 100 75 contact contact NN 31417 100 76 or or CC 31417 100 77 material material NN 31417 100 78 connection connection NN 31417 100 79 of of IN 31417 100 80 any any DT 31417 100 81 kind kind NN 31417 100 82 between between IN 31417 100 83 such such JJ 31417 100 84 substances substance NNS 31417 100 85 and and CC 31417 100 86 the the DT 31417 100 87 body body NN 31417 100 88 of of IN 31417 100 89 any any DT 31417 100 90 person person NN 31417 100 91 present present JJ 31417 100 92 . . . 31417 101 1 " " `` 31417 101 2 Second second NN 31417 101 3 : : : 31417 101 4 That that IN 31417 101 5 this this DT 31417 101 6 force force NN 31417 101 7 can can MD 31417 101 8 cause cause VB 31417 101 9 sounds sound NNS 31417 101 10 to to TO 31417 101 11 proceed proceed VB 31417 101 12 , , , 31417 101 13 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 101 14 audible audible JJ 31417 101 15 to to IN 31417 101 16 all all RB 31417 101 17 present present JJ 31417 101 18 , , , 31417 101 19 from from IN 31417 101 20 solid solid JJ 31417 101 21 substances substance NNS 31417 101 22 not not RB 31417 101 23 in in IN 31417 101 24 contact contact NN 31417 101 25 with with IN 31417 101 26 , , , 31417 101 27 nor nor CC 31417 101 28 having have VBG 31417 101 29 any any DT 31417 101 30 visible visible JJ 31417 101 31 or or CC 31417 101 32 material material JJ 31417 101 33 connection connection NN 31417 101 34 with with IN 31417 101 35 , , , 31417 101 36 the the DT 31417 101 37 body body NN 31417 101 38 of of IN 31417 101 39 any any DT 31417 101 40 person person NN 31417 101 41 present present JJ 31417 101 42 , , , 31417 101 43 and and CC 31417 101 44 which which WDT 31417 101 45 sounds sound NNS 31417 101 46 are be VBP 31417 101 47 proved prove VBN 31417 101 48 to to TO 31417 101 49 proceed proceed VB 31417 101 50 from from IN 31417 101 51 such such JJ 31417 101 52 substances substance NNS 31417 101 53 by by IN 31417 101 54 the the DT 31417 101 55 vibrations vibration NNS 31417 101 56 which which WDT 31417 101 57 are be VBP 31417 101 58 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 101 59 felt feel VBN 31417 101 60 when when WRB 31417 101 61 they -PRON- PRP 31417 101 62 are be VBP 31417 101 63 touched touch VBN 31417 101 64 . . . 31417 102 1 " " `` 31417 102 2 Third third RB 31417 102 3 : : : 31417 102 4 That that IN 31417 102 5 this this DT 31417 102 6 force force NN 31417 102 7 is be VBZ 31417 102 8 frequently frequently RB 31417 102 9 directed direct VBN 31417 102 10 by by IN 31417 102 11 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 102 12 . . . 31417 103 1 " " `` 31417 103 2 At at IN 31417 103 3 thirty thirty CD 31417 103 4 - - HYPH 31417 103 5 four four CD 31417 103 6 out out IN 31417 103 7 of of IN 31417 103 8 the the DT 31417 103 9 forty forty CD 31417 103 10 meetings meeting NNS 31417 103 11 of of IN 31417 103 12 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 103 13 Committee Committee NNP 31417 103 14 some some DT 31417 103 15 of of IN 31417 103 16 these these DT 31417 103 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 103 18 occurred occur VBD 31417 103 19 . . . 31417 104 1 * * NFP 31417 104 2 * * NFP 31417 104 3 * * NFP 31417 104 4 * * NFP 31417 104 5 * * NFP 31417 104 6 " " `` 31417 104 7 In in IN 31417 104 8 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 104 9 , , , 31417 104 10 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 104 11 Committee Committee NNP 31417 104 12 express express VBP 31417 104 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 104 14 unanimous unanimous JJ 31417 104 15 opinion opinion NN 31417 104 16 that that IN 31417 104 17 the the DT 31417 104 18 one one CD 31417 104 19 important important JJ 31417 104 20 physical physical JJ 31417 104 21 fact fact NN 31417 104 22 thus thus RB 31417 104 23 proved prove VBD 31417 104 24 to to TO 31417 104 25 exist exist VB 31417 104 26 , , , 31417 104 27 that that IN 31417 104 28 _ _ NNP 31417 104 29 motion motion NN 31417 104 30 may may MD 31417 104 31 be be VB 31417 104 32 produced produce VBN 31417 104 33 in in IN 31417 104 34 solid solid JJ 31417 104 35 bodies body NNS 31417 104 36 without without IN 31417 104 37 material material JJ 31417 104 38 contact contact NN 31417 104 39 , , , 31417 104 40 by by IN 31417 104 41 some some DT 31417 104 42 hitherto hitherto NNP 31417 104 43 unrecognised unrecognised JJ 31417 104 44 force force NN 31417 104 45 operating operate VBG 31417 104 46 within within IN 31417 104 47 an an DT 31417 104 48 undefined undefined JJ 31417 104 49 distance distance NN 31417 104 50 from from IN 31417 104 51 the the DT 31417 104 52 human human JJ 31417 104 53 organism organism NN 31417 104 54 , , , 31417 104 55 and and CC 31417 104 56 beyond beyond IN 31417 104 57 the the DT 31417 104 58 range range NN 31417 104 59 of of IN 31417 104 60 muscular muscular JJ 31417 104 61 action action NN 31417 104 62 _ _ NNP 31417 104 63 , , , 31417 104 64 should should MD 31417 104 65 be be VB 31417 104 66 subjected subject VBN 31417 104 67 to to IN 31417 104 68 further further JJ 31417 104 69 scientific scientific JJ 31417 104 70 examination examination NN 31417 104 71 , , , 31417 104 72 with with IN 31417 104 73 a a DT 31417 104 74 view view NN 31417 104 75 to to IN 31417 104 76 ascertaining ascertain VBG 31417 104 77 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 104 78 true true JJ 31417 104 79 source source NN 31417 104 80 , , , 31417 104 81 nature nature NN 31417 104 82 , , , 31417 104 83 and and CC 31417 104 84 power power NN 31417 104 85 . . . 31417 105 1 " " `` 31417 105 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 105 3 3 3 CD 31417 105 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 105 5 One one CD 31417 105 6 selection selection NN 31417 105 7 is be VBZ 31417 105 8 now now RB 31417 105 9 given give VBN 31417 105 10 from from IN 31417 105 11 the the DT 31417 105 12 Minutes Minutes NNPS 31417 105 13 of of IN 31417 105 14 this this DT 31417 105 15 Sub Sub NNP 31417 105 16 - - NNP 31417 105 17 Committee Committee NNP 31417 105 18 , , , 31417 105 19 illustrating illustrate VBG 31417 105 20 the the DT 31417 105 21 nature nature NN 31417 105 22 of of IN 31417 105 23 the the DT 31417 105 24 Evidence Evidence NNP 31417 105 25 that that WDT 31417 105 26 came come VBD 31417 105 27 before before RB 31417 105 28 them:-- them:-- PRP 31417 105 29 " " `` 31417 105 30 EXPERIMENT experiment NN 31417 105 31 XXXVIII xxxviii NN 31417 105 32 . . . 31417 105 33 , , , 31417 105 34 Dec. December NNP 31417 105 35 28th 28th NN 31417 105 36 [ [ -LRB- 31417 105 37 1869].--Eight 1869].--eight CD 31417 105 38 members member NNS 31417 105 39 present present JJ 31417 105 40 . . . 31417 106 1 _ _ NNP 31417 106 2 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 106 3 _ _ NNP 31417 106 4 : : : 31417 106 5 Rapping Rapping NNP 31417 106 6 sounds sound VBZ 31417 106 7 from from IN 31417 106 8 the the DT 31417 106 9 table table NN 31417 106 10 and and CC 31417 106 11 floor floor NN 31417 106 12 , , , 31417 106 13 and and CC 31417 106 14 movements movement NNS 31417 106 15 of of IN 31417 106 16 the the DT 31417 106 17 table table NN 31417 106 18 , , , 31417 106 19 with with IN 31417 106 20 and and CC 31417 106 21 without without IN 31417 106 22 contact contact NN 31417 106 23 . . . 31417 107 1 The the DT 31417 107 2 alphabet alphabet NN 31417 107 3 was be VBD 31417 107 4 repeated repeat VBN 31417 107 5 , , , 31417 107 6 and and CC 31417 107 7 the the DT 31417 107 8 following follow VBG 31417 107 9 letters letter NNS 31417 107 10 were be VBD 31417 107 11 rapped rap VBN 31417 107 12 : : : 31417 107 13 ' ' '' 31417 107 14 A a DT 31417 107 15 bad bad JJ 31417 107 16 circle circle NN 31417 107 17 -- -- : 31417 107 18 want want NN 31417 107 19 of of IN 31417 107 20 harmony harmony NN 31417 107 21 . . . 31417 107 22 ' ' '' 31417 108 1 At at IN 31417 108 2 the the DT 31417 108 3 letter letter NN 31417 108 4 f f NNP 31417 108 5 , , , 31417 108 6 the the DT 31417 108 7 table table NN 31417 108 8 tilted tilt VBD 31417 108 9 three three CD 31417 108 10 times time NNS 31417 108 11 , , , 31417 108 12 and and CC 31417 108 13 at at IN 31417 108 14 the the DT 31417 108 15 letters letter NNS 31417 108 16 a a DT 31417 108 17 , , , 31417 108 18 r r NN 31417 108 19 , , , 31417 108 20 gave give VBD 31417 108 21 several several JJ 31417 108 22 forcible forcible JJ 31417 108 23 horizontal horizontal JJ 31417 108 24 movements movement NNS 31417 108 25 , , , 31417 108 26 tilting tilt VBG 31417 108 27 at at IN 31417 108 28 either either DT 31417 108 29 end end NN 31417 108 30 . . . 31417 109 1 " " `` 31417 109 2 Raps rap NNS 31417 109 3 , , , 31417 109 4 with with IN 31417 109 5 slight slight JJ 31417 109 6 tiltings tilting NNS 31417 109 7 of of IN 31417 109 8 the the DT 31417 109 9 table table NN 31417 109 10 , , , 31417 109 11 beating beat VBG 31417 109 12 time time NN 31417 109 13 to to IN 31417 109 14 the the DT 31417 109 15 measure measure NN 31417 109 16 of of IN 31417 109 17 a a DT 31417 109 18 song song NN 31417 109 19 . . . 31417 110 1 Two two CD 31417 110 2 or or CC 31417 110 3 three three CD 31417 110 4 poems poem NNS 31417 110 5 were be VBD 31417 110 6 recited recite VBN 31417 110 7 , , , 31417 110 8 to to IN 31417 110 9 the the DT 31417 110 10 measure measure NN 31417 110 11 of of IN 31417 110 12 which which WDT 31417 110 13 there there EX 31417 110 14 were be VBD 31417 110 15 loud loud JJ 31417 110 16 raps rap NNS 31417 110 17 from from IN 31417 110 18 the the DT 31417 110 19 table table NN 31417 110 20 and and CC 31417 110 21 floor floor NN 31417 110 22 , , , 31417 110 23 and and CC 31417 110 24 the the DT 31417 110 25 table table NN 31417 110 26 also also RB 31417 110 27 marked mark VBD 31417 110 28 the the DT 31417 110 29 metre metre NN 31417 110 30 by by IN 31417 110 31 various various JJ 31417 110 32 horizontal horizontal JJ 31417 110 33 movements movement NNS 31417 110 34 and and CC 31417 110 35 tiltings tilting NNS 31417 110 36 . . . 31417 111 1 " " `` 31417 111 2 Hood Hood NNP 31417 111 3 's 's POS 31417 111 4 Anatomy Anatomy NNP 31417 111 5 Song Song NNP 31417 111 6 being be VBG 31417 111 7 repeated repeat VBN 31417 111 8 by by IN 31417 111 9 one one CD 31417 111 10 of of IN 31417 111 11 the the DT 31417 111 12 members member NNS 31417 111 13 , , , 31417 111 14 the the DT 31417 111 15 knocking knocking NN 31417 111 16 , , , 31417 111 17 rapping rapping NNP 31417 111 18 , , , 31417 111 19 and and CC 31417 111 20 tilting tilting NN 31417 111 21 sounds sound VBZ 31417 111 22 , , , 31417 111 23 with with IN 31417 111 24 various various JJ 31417 111 25 horizontal horizontal JJ 31417 111 26 , , , 31417 111 27 trembling tremble VBG 31417 111 28 , , , 31417 111 29 and and CC 31417 111 30 vibratory vibratory JJ 31417 111 31 movements movement NNS 31417 111 32 of of IN 31417 111 33 the the DT 31417 111 34 table table NN 31417 111 35 , , , 31417 111 36 accompanied accompany VBD 31417 111 37 it -PRON- PRP 31417 111 38 , , , 31417 111 39 in in IN 31417 111 40 exact exact JJ 31417 111 41 harmony harmony NN 31417 111 42 with with IN 31417 111 43 the the DT 31417 111 44 measure measure NN 31417 111 45 , , , 31417 111 46 added add VBD 31417 111 47 to to TO 31417 111 48 which which WDT 31417 111 49 were be VBD 31417 111 50 strange strange JJ 31417 111 51 movements movement NNS 31417 111 52 , , , 31417 111 53 in in IN 31417 111 54 accordance accordance NN 31417 111 55 with with IN 31417 111 56 the the DT 31417 111 57 character character NN 31417 111 58 of of IN 31417 111 59 the the DT 31417 111 60 verses verse NNS 31417 111 61 . . . 31417 112 1 In in IN 31417 112 2 one one CD 31417 112 3 instance instance NN 31417 112 4 the the DT 31417 112 5 table table NN 31417 112 6 shifted shift VBD 31417 112 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 112 8 position position NN 31417 112 9 several several JJ 31417 112 10 feet foot NNS 31417 112 11 , , , 31417 112 12 the the DT 31417 112 13 tips tip NNS 31417 112 14 of of IN 31417 112 15 the the DT 31417 112 16 fingers finger NNS 31417 112 17 only only RB 31417 112 18 being be VBG 31417 112 19 in in IN 31417 112 20 contact contact NN 31417 112 21 with with IN 31417 112 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 112 23 . . . 31417 113 1 " " `` 31417 113 2 MOVEMENTS movements NN 31417 113 3 WITHOUT without IN 31417 113 4 CONTACT.--Question contact.--question NN 31417 113 5 : : : 31417 113 6 ' ' '' 31417 113 7 Would Would MD 31417 113 8 the the DT 31417 113 9 table table NN 31417 113 10 now now RB 31417 113 11 be be VB 31417 113 12 moved move VBN 31417 113 13 without without IN 31417 113 14 contact contact NN 31417 113 15 ? ? . 31417 113 16 ' ' '' 31417 114 1 Answer answer VB 31417 114 2 : : : 31417 114 3 ' ' '' 31417 114 4 Yes yes UH 31417 114 5 ; ; : 31417 114 6 ' ' '' 31417 114 7 by by IN 31417 114 8 three three CD 31417 114 9 raps rap NNS 31417 114 10 on on IN 31417 114 11 the the DT 31417 114 12 table table NN 31417 114 13 . . . 31417 115 1 All all DT 31417 115 2 chairs chair NNS 31417 115 3 were be VBD 31417 115 4 then then RB 31417 115 5 turned turn VBN 31417 115 6 with with IN 31417 115 7 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 115 8 backs back NNS 31417 115 9 to to IN 31417 115 10 the the DT 31417 115 11 table table NN 31417 115 12 , , , 31417 115 13 and and CC 31417 115 14 nine nine CD 31417 115 15 inches inch NNS 31417 115 16 away away RB 31417 115 17 from from IN 31417 115 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 115 19 ; ; : 31417 115 20 and and CC 31417 115 21 all all DT 31417 115 22 present present JJ 31417 115 23 knelt knelt NN 31417 115 24 on on IN 31417 115 25 the the DT 31417 115 26 chairs chair NNS 31417 115 27 , , , 31417 115 28 with with IN 31417 115 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 115 30 wrists wrist NNS 31417 115 31 resting rest VBG 31417 115 32 on on IN 31417 115 33 the the DT 31417 115 34 backs back NNS 31417 115 35 , , , 31417 115 36 and and CC 31417 115 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 115 38 hands hand NNS 31417 115 39 a a DT 31417 115 40 few few JJ 31417 115 41 inches inch NNS 31417 115 42 above above IN 31417 115 43 the the DT 31417 115 44 table table NN 31417 115 45 . . . 31417 116 1 " " `` 31417 116 2 Under under IN 31417 116 3 these these DT 31417 116 4 conditions condition NNS 31417 116 5 , , , 31417 116 6 the the DT 31417 116 7 table table NN 31417 116 8 ( ( -LRB- 31417 116 9 the the DT 31417 116 10 heavy heavy JJ 31417 116 11 dining dining NN 31417 116 12 - - HYPH 31417 116 13 room room NN 31417 116 14 table table NN 31417 116 15 previously previously RB 31417 116 16 described describe VBN 31417 116 17 ) ) -RRB- 31417 116 18 moved move VBD 31417 116 19 four four CD 31417 116 20 times time NNS 31417 116 21 , , , 31417 116 22 each each DT 31417 116 23 time time NN 31417 116 24 from from IN 31417 116 25 four four CD 31417 116 26 to to TO 31417 116 27 six six CD 31417 116 28 inches inch NNS 31417 116 29 , , , 31417 116 30 and and CC 31417 116 31 the the DT 31417 116 32 second second JJ 31417 116 33 time time NN 31417 116 34 nearly nearly RB 31417 116 35 twelve twelve CD 31417 116 36 inches inch NNS 31417 116 37 . . . 31417 117 1 " " `` 31417 117 2 Then then RB 31417 117 3 all all DT 31417 117 4 hands hand NNS 31417 117 5 were be VBD 31417 117 6 placed place VBN 31417 117 7 on on IN 31417 117 8 the the DT 31417 117 9 backs back NNS 31417 117 10 of of IN 31417 117 11 the the DT 31417 117 12 chairs chair NNS 31417 117 13 , , , 31417 117 14 and and CC 31417 117 15 nearly nearly RB 31417 117 16 a a DT 31417 117 17 foot foot NN 31417 117 18 from from IN 31417 117 19 the the DT 31417 117 20 table table NN 31417 117 21 , , , 31417 117 22 when when WRB 31417 117 23 four four CD 31417 117 24 movements movement NNS 31417 117 25 occurred occur VBD 31417 117 26 , , , 31417 117 27 one one CD 31417 117 28 slow slow JJ 31417 117 29 and and CC 31417 117 30 continuous continuous JJ 31417 117 31 for for IN 31417 117 32 nearly nearly RB 31417 117 33 a a DT 31417 117 34 minute minute NN 31417 117 35 . . . 31417 118 1 " " `` 31417 118 2 Then then RB 31417 118 3 all all DT 31417 118 4 present present JJ 31417 118 5 placed place VBD 31417 118 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 118 7 hands hand NNS 31417 118 8 behind behind IN 31417 118 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 118 10 backs back NNS 31417 118 11 , , , 31417 118 12 kneeling kneel VBG 31417 118 13 erect erect NN 31417 118 14 on on IN 31417 118 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 118 16 chairs chair NNS 31417 118 17 , , , 31417 118 18 which which WDT 31417 118 19 were be VBD 31417 118 20 removed remove VBN 31417 118 21 a a DT 31417 118 22 foot foot NN 31417 118 23 clear clear JJ 31417 118 24 away away RB 31417 118 25 from from IN 31417 118 26 the the DT 31417 118 27 table table NN 31417 118 28 . . . 31417 119 1 The the DT 31417 119 2 gas gas NN 31417 119 3 also also RB 31417 119 4 was be VBD 31417 119 5 turned turn VBN 31417 119 6 up up RP 31417 119 7 higher higher RBR 31417 119 8 , , , 31417 119 9 so so IN 31417 119 10 as as IN 31417 119 11 to to TO 31417 119 12 give give VB 31417 119 13 abundance abundance NN 31417 119 14 of of IN 31417 119 15 light light NN 31417 119 16 ; ; : 31417 119 17 and and CC 31417 119 18 under under IN 31417 119 19 these these DT 31417 119 20 test test NN 31417 119 21 conditions condition NNS 31417 119 22 , , , 31417 119 23 distinct distinct JJ 31417 119 24 movements movement NNS 31417 119 25 occurred occur VBD 31417 119 26 , , , 31417 119 27 to to IN 31417 119 28 the the DT 31417 119 29 extent extent NN 31417 119 30 of of IN 31417 119 31 several several JJ 31417 119 32 inches inch NNS 31417 119 33 each each DT 31417 119 34 time time NN 31417 119 35 , , , 31417 119 36 and and CC 31417 119 37 visible visible JJ 31417 119 38 to to IN 31417 119 39 every every DT 31417 119 40 one one CD 31417 119 41 present present NN 31417 119 42 . . . 31417 120 1 " " `` 31417 120 2 The the DT 31417 120 3 motions motion NNS 31417 120 4 were be VBD 31417 120 5 in in IN 31417 120 6 various various JJ 31417 120 7 directions direction NNS 31417 120 8 , , , 31417 120 9 towards towards IN 31417 120 10 all all DT 31417 120 11 parts part NNS 31417 120 12 of of IN 31417 120 13 the the DT 31417 120 14 room room NN 31417 120 15 -- -- : 31417 120 16 some some DT 31417 120 17 were be VBD 31417 120 18 abrupt abrupt JJ 31417 120 19 , , , 31417 120 20 others other NNS 31417 120 21 steady steady JJ 31417 120 22 . . . 31417 121 1 At at IN 31417 121 2 the the DT 31417 121 3 same same JJ 31417 121 4 time time NN 31417 121 5 , , , 31417 121 6 and and CC 31417 121 7 under under IN 31417 121 8 the the DT 31417 121 9 same same JJ 31417 121 10 conditions condition NNS 31417 121 11 , , , 31417 121 12 distinct distinct JJ 31417 121 13 raps rap NNS 31417 121 14 occurred occur VBD 31417 121 15 , , , 31417 121 16 apparently apparently RB 31417 121 17 both both DT 31417 121 18 on on IN 31417 121 19 the the DT 31417 121 20 floor floor NN 31417 121 21 and and CC 31417 121 22 on on IN 31417 121 23 the the DT 31417 121 24 table table NN 31417 121 25 , , , 31417 121 26 in in IN 31417 121 27 answer answer NN 31417 121 28 to to IN 31417 121 29 requests request NNS 31417 121 30 for for IN 31417 121 31 them -PRON- PRP 31417 121 32 . . . 31417 122 1 " " `` 31417 122 2 The the DT 31417 122 3 above above RB 31417 122 4 - - HYPH 31417 122 5 described describe VBN 31417 122 6 movements movement NNS 31417 122 7 were be VBD 31417 122 8 so so RB 31417 122 9 unmistakable unmistakable JJ 31417 122 10 , , , 31417 122 11 that that IN 31417 122 12 all all DT 31417 122 13 present present VBP 31417 122 14 unhesitatingly unhesitatingly RB 31417 122 15 declared declare VBD 31417 122 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 122 17 conviction conviction NN 31417 122 18 , , , 31417 122 19 that that IN 31417 122 20 no no DT 31417 122 21 physical physical JJ 31417 122 22 force force NN 31417 122 23 , , , 31417 122 24 exerted exert VBN 31417 122 25 by by IN 31417 122 26 any any DT 31417 122 27 one one CD 31417 122 28 present present NN 31417 122 29 , , , 31417 122 30 could could MD 31417 122 31 possibly possibly RB 31417 122 32 have have VB 31417 122 33 produced produce VBN 31417 122 34 them -PRON- PRP 31417 122 35 ; ; : 31417 122 36 and and CC 31417 122 37 they -PRON- PRP 31417 122 38 declared declare VBD 31417 122 39 further far RBR 31417 122 40 , , , 31417 122 41 in in IN 31417 122 42 writing writing NN 31417 122 43 , , , 31417 122 44 that that IN 31417 122 45 a a DT 31417 122 46 rigid rigid JJ 31417 122 47 examination examination NN 31417 122 48 of of IN 31417 122 49 the the DT 31417 122 50 table table NN 31417 122 51 showed show VBD 31417 122 52 it -PRON- PRP 31417 122 53 to to TO 31417 122 54 be be VB 31417 122 55 an an DT 31417 122 56 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 122 57 dining dining NN 31417 122 58 - - HYPH 31417 122 59 table table NN 31417 122 60 , , , 31417 122 61 with with IN 31417 122 62 no no DT 31417 122 63 machinery machinery NN 31417 122 64 or or CC 31417 122 65 apparatus apparatus NN 31417 122 66 of of IN 31417 122 67 any any DT 31417 122 68 kind kind NN 31417 122 69 connected connect VBN 31417 122 70 with with IN 31417 122 71 it -PRON- PRP 31417 122 72 . . . 31417 123 1 The the DT 31417 123 2 table table NN 31417 123 3 was be VBD 31417 123 4 laid lay VBN 31417 123 5 on on IN 31417 123 6 the the DT 31417 123 7 floor floor NN 31417 123 8 with with IN 31417 123 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 123 10 legs leg NNS 31417 123 11 up up RB 31417 123 12 , , , 31417 123 13 and and CC 31417 123 14 taken take VBN 31417 123 15 to to IN 31417 123 16 pieces piece NNS 31417 123 17 so so RB 31417 123 18 far far RB 31417 123 19 as as IN 31417 123 20 practicable practicable JJ 31417 123 21 . . . 31417 124 1 " " `` 31417 124 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 124 3 4 4 LS 31417 124 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 124 5 TESTIMONY TESTIMONY NNP 31417 124 6 OF of IN 31417 124 7 W. W. NNP 31417 124 8 F. F. NNP 31417 124 9 BARRETT BARRETT NNP 31417 124 10 , , , 31417 124 11 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 124 12 , , , 31417 124 13 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNP 31417 124 14 OF of IN 31417 124 15 PHYSICS PHYSICS NNP 31417 124 16 IN in IN 31417 124 17 THE the DT 31417 124 18 ROYAL royal JJ 31417 124 19 COLLEGE COLLEGE NNP 31417 124 20 OF of IN 31417 124 21 SCIENCE SCIENCE NNP 31417 124 22 FOR for IN 31417 124 23 IRELAND IRELAND NNP 31417 124 24 . . . 31417 125 1 No no DT 31417 125 2 endeavour endeavour NN 31417 125 3 appears appear VBZ 31417 125 4 to to TO 31417 125 5 have have VB 31417 125 6 been be VBN 31417 125 7 made make VBN 31417 125 8 by by IN 31417 125 9 any any DT 31417 125 10 of of IN 31417 125 11 the the DT 31417 125 12 members member NNS 31417 125 13 of of IN 31417 125 14 the the DT 31417 125 15 Committee Committee NNP 31417 125 16 of of IN 31417 125 17 the the DT 31417 125 18 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 125 19 Society Society NNP 31417 125 20 to to TO 31417 125 21 follow follow VB 31417 125 22 up up RP 31417 125 23 the the DT 31417 125 24 results result NNS 31417 125 25 which which WDT 31417 125 26 they -PRON- PRP 31417 125 27 had have VBD 31417 125 28 obtained obtain VBN 31417 125 29 . . . 31417 126 1 The the DT 31417 126 2 individual individual JJ 31417 126 3 members member NNS 31417 126 4 who who WP 31417 126 5 had have VBD 31417 126 6 previously previously RB 31417 126 7 been be VBN 31417 126 8 active active JJ 31417 126 9 in in IN 31417 126 10 such such JJ 31417 126 11 matters matter NNS 31417 126 12 continued continue VBD 31417 126 13 to to TO 31417 126 14 take take VB 31417 126 15 an an DT 31417 126 16 interest interest NN 31417 126 17 in in IN 31417 126 18 them -PRON- PRP 31417 126 19 , , , 31417 126 20 but but CC 31417 126 21 there there EX 31417 126 22 is be VBZ 31417 126 23 no no DT 31417 126 24 evidence evidence NN 31417 126 25 that that IN 31417 126 26 a a DT 31417 126 27 single single JJ 31417 126 28 new new JJ 31417 126 29 inquirer inquirer NN 31417 126 30 was be VBD 31417 126 31 gained gain VBN 31417 126 32 . . . 31417 127 1 The the DT 31417 127 2 next next JJ 31417 127 3 event event NN 31417 127 4 of of IN 31417 127 5 any any DT 31417 127 6 importance importance NN 31417 127 7 , , , 31417 127 8 in in IN 31417 127 9 the the DT 31417 127 10 direction direction NN 31417 127 11 of of IN 31417 127 12 scientific scientific JJ 31417 127 13 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 127 14 into into IN 31417 127 15 the the DT 31417 127 16 subject subject NN 31417 127 17 , , , 31417 127 18 was be VBD 31417 127 19 the the DT 31417 127 20 reading reading NN 31417 127 21 by by IN 31417 127 22 Professor Professor NNP 31417 127 23 W. W. NNP 31417 127 24 F. F. NNP 31417 127 25 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 127 26 of of IN 31417 127 27 a a DT 31417 127 28 paper paper NN 31417 127 29 before before IN 31417 127 30 the the DT 31417 127 31 meeting meeting NN 31417 127 32 of of IN 31417 127 33 the the DT 31417 127 34 British British NNP 31417 127 35 Association Association NNP 31417 127 36 at at IN 31417 127 37 Glasgow Glasgow NNP 31417 127 38 in in IN 31417 127 39 1876 1876 CD 31417 127 40 . . . 31417 128 1 This this DT 31417 128 2 paper paper NN 31417 128 3 was be VBD 31417 128 4 entitled entitle VBN 31417 128 5 " " `` 31417 128 6 On on IN 31417 128 7 Some some DT 31417 128 8 Phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 128 9 Associated associate VBN 31417 128 10 with with IN 31417 128 11 Abnormal Abnormal NNP 31417 128 12 Conditions Conditions NNPS 31417 128 13 of of IN 31417 128 14 Mind mind NN 31417 128 15 , , , 31417 128 16 " " '' 31417 128 17 and and CC 31417 128 18 dealt deal VBD 31417 128 19 mainly mainly RB 31417 128 20 with with IN 31417 128 21 what what WP 31417 128 22 was be VBD 31417 128 23 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 128 24 designated designate VBN 31417 128 25 " " `` 31417 128 26 Thought Thought NNP 31417 128 27 - - HYPH 31417 128 28 Transference transference NN 31417 128 29 . . . 31417 128 30 " " '' 31417 129 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 129 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 129 3 also also RB 31417 129 4 referred refer VBD 31417 129 5 to to IN 31417 129 6 some some DT 31417 129 7 " " `` 31417 129 8 physical physical JJ 31417 129 9 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 129 10 " " '' 31417 129 11 which which WDT 31417 129 12 had have VBD 31417 129 13 come come VBN 31417 129 14 under under IN 31417 129 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 129 16 notice notice NN 31417 129 17 . . . 31417 130 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 130 2 says say VBZ 31417 130 3 : : : 31417 130 4 " " `` 31417 130 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 130 6 am be VBP 31417 130 7 bound bind VBN 31417 130 8 to to TO 31417 130 9 mention mention VB 31417 130 10 a a DT 31417 130 11 case case NN 31417 130 12 that that WDT 31417 130 13 came come VBD 31417 130 14 under under IN 31417 130 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 130 16 own own JJ 31417 130 17 repeated repeated JJ 31417 130 18 observation observation NN 31417 130 19 , , , 31417 130 20 wherein wherein WRB 31417 130 21 certain certain JJ 31417 130 22 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 31417 130 23 physical physical JJ 31417 130 24 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 130 25 occurred occur VBD 31417 130 26 in in IN 31417 130 27 broad broad JJ 31417 130 28 daylight daylight NN 31417 130 29 , , , 31417 130 30 and and CC 31417 130 31 for for IN 31417 130 32 which which WDT 31417 130 33 I -PRON- PRP 31417 130 34 could could MD 31417 130 35 find find VB 31417 130 36 no no DT 31417 130 37 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 31417 130 38 solution solution NN 31417 130 39 either either CC 31417 130 40 on on IN 31417 130 41 the the DT 31417 130 42 ground ground NN 31417 130 43 of of IN 31417 130 44 hallucination hallucination NN 31417 130 45 or or CC 31417 130 46 fraud fraud NN 31417 130 47 . . . 31417 131 1 " " `` 31417 131 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 131 3 5 5 CD 31417 131 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 131 5 In in IN 31417 131 6 a a DT 31417 131 7 paper paper NN 31417 131 8 read read NN 31417 131 9 before before IN 31417 131 10 the the DT 31417 131 11 Society Society NNP 31417 131 12 for for IN 31417 131 13 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 131 14 Research Research NNP 31417 131 15 in in IN 31417 131 16 1886 1886 CD 31417 131 17 , , , 31417 131 18 entitled entitle VBN 31417 131 19 " " `` 31417 131 20 On on IN 31417 131 21 Some some DT 31417 131 22 Physical physical JJ 31417 131 23 Phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 131 24 commonly commonly RB 31417 131 25 termed term VBN 31417 131 26 Spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 131 27 , , , 31417 131 28 witnessed witness VBN 31417 131 29 by by IN 31417 131 30 the the DT 31417 131 31 Author author NN 31417 131 32 , , , 31417 131 33 " " '' 31417 131 34 Professor Professor NNP 31417 131 35 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 131 36 describes describe VBZ 31417 131 37 in in IN 31417 131 38 detail detail NN 31417 131 39 the the DT 31417 131 40 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 131 41 he -PRON- PRP 31417 131 42 referred refer VBD 31417 131 43 to to IN 31417 131 44 in in IN 31417 131 45 the the DT 31417 131 46 paper paper NN 31417 131 47 read read VBD 31417 131 48 ten ten CD 31417 131 49 years year NNS 31417 131 50 previously previously RB 31417 131 51 at at IN 31417 131 52 the the DT 31417 131 53 British British NNP 31417 131 54 Association Association NNP 31417 131 55 , , , 31417 131 56 and and CC 31417 131 57 the the DT 31417 131 58 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 131 59 under under IN 31417 131 60 which which WDT 31417 131 61 they -PRON- PRP 31417 131 62 occurred occur VBD 31417 131 63 . . . 31417 132 1 The the DT 31417 132 2 following follow VBG 31417 132 3 paragraphs paragraph NNS 31417 132 4 give give VBP 31417 132 5 the the DT 31417 132 6 important important JJ 31417 132 7 features:[6]-- features:[6]-- NNP 31417 132 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 132 9 C. C. NNP 31417 132 10 , , , 31417 132 11 a a DT 31417 132 12 solicitor solicitor NN 31417 132 13 , , , 31417 132 14 with with IN 31417 132 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 132 16 wife wife NN 31417 132 17 and and CC 31417 132 18 family family NN 31417 132 19 , , , 31417 132 20 had have VBD 31417 132 21 come come VBN 31417 132 22 to to TO 31417 132 23 reside reside VB 31417 132 24 for for IN 31417 132 25 the the DT 31417 132 26 season season NN 31417 132 27 in in IN 31417 132 28 the the DT 31417 132 29 suburban suburban JJ 31417 132 30 house house NN 31417 132 31 of of IN 31417 132 32 a a DT 31417 132 33 friend friend NN 31417 132 34 and and CC 31417 132 35 neighbour neighbour NN 31417 132 36 of of IN 31417 132 37 Professor Professor NNP 31417 132 38 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 132 39 's 's POS 31417 132 40 . . . 31417 133 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 133 2 was be VBD 31417 133 3 an an DT 31417 133 4 Irish irish JJ 31417 133 5 country country NN 31417 133 6 gentleman gentleman NN 31417 133 7 who who WP 31417 133 8 had have VBD 31417 133 9 an an DT 31417 133 10 utter utter JJ 31417 133 11 disbelief disbelief NN 31417 133 12 in in IN 31417 133 13 spiritualism spiritualism NN 31417 133 14 . . . 31417 134 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 134 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 134 3 was be VBD 31417 134 4 therefore therefore RB 31417 134 5 not not RB 31417 134 6 a a DT 31417 134 7 little little JJ 31417 134 8 amused amused JJ 31417 134 9 on on IN 31417 134 10 making make VBG 31417 134 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 134 12 C. C. NNP 31417 134 13 's 's POS 31417 134 14 acquaintance acquaintance NN 31417 134 15 , , , 31417 134 16 to to TO 31417 134 17 find find VB 31417 134 18 that that IN 31417 134 19 he -PRON- PRP 31417 134 20 had have VBD 31417 134 21 in in IN 31417 134 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 134 23 own own JJ 31417 134 24 family family NN 31417 134 25 what what WP 31417 134 26 appeared appear VBD 31417 134 27 to to TO 31417 134 28 be be VB 31417 134 29 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 134 30 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 134 31 then then RB 31417 134 32 and and CC 31417 134 33 there there RB 31417 134 34 going go VBG 31417 134 35 on on RP 31417 134 36 . . . 31417 135 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 135 2 C. C. NNP 31417 135 3 gave give VBD 31417 135 4 Professor Professor NNP 31417 135 5 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 135 6 every every DT 31417 135 7 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 135 8 of of IN 31417 135 9 close close JJ 31417 135 10 and and CC 31417 135 11 frequent frequent JJ 31417 135 12 investigation investigation NN 31417 135 13 . . . 31417 136 1 The the DT 31417 136 2 sittings sitting NNS 31417 136 3 extended extend VBD 31417 136 4 through through IN 31417 136 5 the the DT 31417 136 6 months month NNS 31417 136 7 of of IN 31417 136 8 August August NNP 31417 136 9 and and CC 31417 136 10 September September NNP 31417 136 11 1875 1875 CD 31417 136 12 . . . 31417 137 1 There there EX 31417 137 2 were be VBD 31417 137 3 present present JJ 31417 137 4 besides besides IN 31417 137 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 137 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 137 7 , , , 31417 137 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 137 9 and and CC 31417 137 10 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 137 11 C. C. NNP 31417 137 12 , , , 31417 137 13 and and CC 31417 137 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 137 15 young young JJ 31417 137 16 daughter daughter NN 31417 137 17 Florrie Florrie NNP 31417 137 18 , , , 31417 137 19 a a DT 31417 137 20 bright bright JJ 31417 137 21 , , , 31417 137 22 frank frank JJ 31417 137 23 , , , 31417 137 24 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 137 25 child child NN 31417 137 26 , , , 31417 137 27 then then RB 31417 137 28 about about IN 31417 137 29 ten ten CD 31417 137 30 years year NNS 31417 137 31 old old JJ 31417 137 32 . . . 31417 138 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 138 2 sat sit VBD 31417 138 3 at at IN 31417 138 4 a a DT 31417 138 5 large large JJ 31417 138 6 dining dining NN 31417 138 7 - - HYPH 31417 138 8 room room NN 31417 138 9 table table NN 31417 138 10 , , , 31417 138 11 facing face VBG 31417 138 12 French french JJ 31417 138 13 windows window NNS 31417 138 14 , , , 31417 138 15 which which WDT 31417 138 16 let let VBD 31417 138 17 in in RP 31417 138 18 a a DT 31417 138 19 flood flood NN 31417 138 20 of of IN 31417 138 21 sunlight sunlight NN 31417 138 22 . . . 31417 139 1 Shortly shortly RB 31417 139 2 , , , 31417 139 3 scraping scrape VBG 31417 139 4 sounds sound NNS 31417 139 5 , , , 31417 139 6 raps rap NNS 31417 139 7 , , , 31417 139 8 and and CC 31417 139 9 noises noise NNS 31417 139 10 resembling resemble VBG 31417 139 11 the the DT 31417 139 12 hammering hammering NN 31417 139 13 of of IN 31417 139 14 small small JJ 31417 139 15 nails nail NNS 31417 139 16 , , , 31417 139 17 were be VBD 31417 139 18 heard hear VBN 31417 139 19 . . . 31417 140 1 Florrie Florrie NNP 31417 140 2 's 's POS 31417 140 3 hands hand NNS 31417 140 4 and and CC 31417 140 5 feet foot NNS 31417 140 6 were be VBD 31417 140 7 closely closely RB 31417 140 8 watched watch VBN 31417 140 9 , , , 31417 140 10 and and CC 31417 140 11 were be VBD 31417 140 12 observed observe VBN 31417 140 13 to to TO 31417 140 14 be be VB 31417 140 15 absolutely absolutely RB 31417 140 16 motionless motionless JJ 31417 140 17 when when WRB 31417 140 18 the the DT 31417 140 19 sounds sound NNS 31417 140 20 were be VBD 31417 140 21 heard hear VBN 31417 140 22 . . . 31417 141 1 Besides besides IN 31417 141 2 knocks knock NNS 31417 141 3 , , , 31417 141 4 there there EX 31417 141 5 were be VBD 31417 141 6 occasional occasional JJ 31417 141 7 movements movement NNS 31417 141 8 of of IN 31417 141 9 the the DT 31417 141 10 furniture furniture NN 31417 141 11 . . . 31417 142 1 Seated seat VBN 31417 142 2 one one CD 31417 142 3 day day NN 31417 142 4 at at IN 31417 142 5 a a DT 31417 142 6 large large JJ 31417 142 7 dining dining NN 31417 142 8 - - HYPH 31417 142 9 room room NN 31417 142 10 table table NN 31417 142 11 in in IN 31417 142 12 full full JJ 31417 142 13 sunlight sunlight NN 31417 142 14 , , , 31417 142 15 Florrie Florrie NNP 31417 142 16 , , , 31417 142 17 and and CC 31417 142 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 142 19 and and CC 31417 142 20 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 142 21 C. C. NNP 31417 142 22 , , , 31417 142 23 and and CC 31417 142 24 Professor Professor NNP 31417 142 25 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 142 26 being be VBG 31417 142 27 the the DT 31417 142 28 persons person NNS 31417 142 29 present present JJ 31417 142 30 , , , 31417 142 31 all all DT 31417 142 32 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 142 33 fingers finger NNS 31417 142 34 visibly visibly RB 31417 142 35 resting rest VBG 31417 142 36 on on IN 31417 142 37 the the DT 31417 142 38 surface surface NN 31417 142 39 of of IN 31417 142 40 the the DT 31417 142 41 table table NN 31417 142 42 , , , 31417 142 43 three three CD 31417 142 44 legs leg NNS 31417 142 45 of of IN 31417 142 46 the the DT 31417 142 47 table table NN 31417 142 48 rose rise VBD 31417 142 49 off off IN 31417 142 50 the the DT 31417 142 51 ground ground NN 31417 142 52 to to IN 31417 142 53 a a DT 31417 142 54 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 142 55 height height NN 31417 142 56 to to TO 31417 142 57 allow allow VB 31417 142 58 Professor Professor NNP 31417 142 59 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 142 60 to to TO 31417 142 61 put put VB 31417 142 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 142 63 foot foot NN 31417 142 64 easily easily RB 31417 142 65 beneath beneath IN 31417 142 66 the the DT 31417 142 67 castor castor NN 31417 142 68 nearest nearest VBD 31417 142 69 him -PRON- PRP 31417 142 70 . . . 31417 143 1 The the DT 31417 143 2 importance importance NN 31417 143 3 of of IN 31417 143 4 the the DT 31417 143 5 comparatively comparatively RB 31417 143 6 small small JJ 31417 143 7 amount amount NN 31417 143 8 of of IN 31417 143 9 " " `` 31417 143 10 movement movement NN 31417 143 11 " " '' 31417 143 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 143 13 in in IN 31417 143 14 this this DT 31417 143 15 case case NN 31417 143 16 is be VBZ 31417 143 17 increased increase VBN 31417 143 18 by by IN 31417 143 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 143 20 association association NN 31417 143 21 with with IN 31417 143 22 " " `` 31417 143 23 sound sound JJ 31417 143 24 " " '' 31417 143 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 143 26 of of IN 31417 143 27 great great JJ 31417 143 28 variety variety NN 31417 143 29 and and CC 31417 143 30 frequency frequency NN 31417 143 31 . . . 31417 144 1 These these DT 31417 144 2 will will MD 31417 144 3 be be VB 31417 144 4 fully fully RB 31417 144 5 described describe VBN 31417 144 6 in in IN 31417 144 7 the the DT 31417 144 8 next next JJ 31417 144 9 chapter chapter NN 31417 144 10 . . . 31417 145 1 Another another DT 31417 145 2 case case NN 31417 145 3 which which WDT 31417 145 4 Professor Professor NNP 31417 145 5 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 145 6 cites cite VBZ 31417 145 7 in in IN 31417 145 8 the the DT 31417 145 9 same same JJ 31417 145 10 paper paper NN 31417 145 11 may may MD 31417 145 12 be be VB 31417 145 13 thus thus RB 31417 145 14 summarised summarise VBN 31417 145 15 as as RB 31417 145 16 far far RB 31417 145 17 as as IN 31417 145 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 145 19 of of IN 31417 145 20 movement movement NN 31417 145 21 are be VBP 31417 145 22 concerned:[7]-- concerned:[7]-- JJ 31417 145 23 The the DT 31417 145 24 sitters sitter NNS 31417 145 25 were be VBD 31417 145 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 145 27 L. L. NNP 31417 145 28 , , , 31417 145 29 a a DT 31417 145 30 well well RB 31417 145 31 - - HYPH 31417 145 32 known know VBN 31417 145 33 photographer photographer NN 31417 145 34 in in IN 31417 145 35 Dublin Dublin NNP 31417 145 36 , , , 31417 145 37 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 145 38 niece niece NN 31417 145 39 , , , 31417 145 40 Miss Miss NNP 31417 145 41 I. I. NNP 31417 145 42 , , , 31417 145 43 and and CC 31417 145 44 Professor Professor NNP 31417 145 45 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 145 46 . . . 31417 146 1 While while IN 31417 146 2 noticing notice VBG 31417 146 3 the the DT 31417 146 4 raps rap NNS 31417 146 5 and and CC 31417 146 6 knocks knock NNS 31417 146 7 , , , 31417 146 8 Professor Professor NNP 31417 146 9 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 146 10 observed observe VBD 31417 146 11 a a DT 31417 146 12 frequent frequent JJ 31417 146 13 uneasy uneasy JJ 31417 146 14 movement movement NN 31417 146 15 of of IN 31417 146 16 the the DT 31417 146 17 entire entire JJ 31417 146 18 table table NN 31417 146 19 , , , 31417 146 20 which which WDT 31417 146 21 was be VBD 31417 146 22 a a DT 31417 146 23 moderately moderately RB 31417 146 24 large large JJ 31417 146 25 and and CC 31417 146 26 heavy heavy JJ 31417 146 27 one one CD 31417 146 28 , , , 31417 146 29 four four CD 31417 146 30 feet foot NNS 31417 146 31 square square JJ 31417 146 32 . . . 31417 147 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 147 2 sidled sidle VBD 31417 147 3 about about IN 31417 147 4 in in IN 31417 147 5 a a DT 31417 147 6 most most RBS 31417 147 7 surprising surprising JJ 31417 147 8 manner manner NN 31417 147 9 . . . 31417 148 1 Lifting lift VBG 31417 148 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 148 3 hands hand NNS 31417 148 4 completely completely RB 31417 148 5 off off IN 31417 148 6 the the DT 31417 148 7 table table NN 31417 148 8 , , , 31417 148 9 the the DT 31417 148 10 sitters sitter NNS 31417 148 11 placed place VBD 31417 148 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 148 13 back back RB 31417 148 14 in in IN 31417 148 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 148 16 chairs chair NNS 31417 148 17 , , , 31417 148 18 with with IN 31417 148 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 148 20 hands hand NNS 31417 148 21 folded fold VBN 31417 148 22 across across IN 31417 148 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 148 24 chests chest NNS 31417 148 25 . . . 31417 149 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 149 2 feet foot NNS 31417 149 3 were be VBD 31417 149 4 in in IN 31417 149 5 full full JJ 31417 149 6 view view NN 31417 149 7 . . . 31417 150 1 Under under IN 31417 150 2 these these DT 31417 150 3 conditions condition NNS 31417 150 4 , , , 31417 150 5 and and CC 31417 150 6 in in IN 31417 150 7 obedience obedience NN 31417 150 8 to to IN 31417 150 9 Professor Professor NNP 31417 150 10 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 150 11 's 's POS 31417 150 12 request request NN 31417 150 13 , , , 31417 150 14 the the DT 31417 150 15 table table NN 31417 150 16 raised raise VBD 31417 150 17 the the DT 31417 150 18 two two CD 31417 150 19 legs leg NNS 31417 150 20 nearest near JJS 31417 150 21 to to IN 31417 150 22 him -PRON- PRP 31417 150 23 off off IN 31417 150 24 the the DT 31417 150 25 ground ground NN 31417 150 26 eight eight CD 31417 150 27 or or CC 31417 150 28 ten ten CD 31417 150 29 inches inch NNS 31417 150 30 , , , 31417 150 31 and and CC 31417 150 32 then then RB 31417 150 33 suspended suspend VBD 31417 150 34 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 150 35 for for IN 31417 150 36 a a DT 31417 150 37 few few JJ 31417 150 38 moments moment NNS 31417 150 39 . . . 31417 151 1 A a DT 31417 151 2 similar similar JJ 31417 151 3 act act NN 31417 151 4 was be VBD 31417 151 5 performed perform VBN 31417 151 6 on on IN 31417 151 7 the the DT 31417 151 8 other other JJ 31417 151 9 side side NN 31417 151 10 . . . 31417 152 1 Then then RB 31417 152 2 a a DT 31417 152 3 very very RB 31417 152 4 unexpected unexpected JJ 31417 152 5 occurrence occurrence NN 31417 152 6 happened happen VBD 31417 152 7 . . . 31417 153 1 To to TO 31417 153 2 quote quote VB 31417 153 3 Professor Professor NNP 31417 153 4 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 153 5 's 's POS 31417 153 6 own own JJ 31417 153 7 words:-- words:-- NN 31417 153 8 " " `` 31417 153 9 Whilst whilst IN 31417 153 10 absolutely absolutely RB 31417 153 11 free free JJ 31417 153 12 from from IN 31417 153 13 the the DT 31417 153 14 contact contact NN 31417 153 15 of of IN 31417 153 16 any any DT 31417 153 17 person person NN 31417 153 18 , , , 31417 153 19 the the DT 31417 153 20 table table NN 31417 153 21 wriggled wriggle VBD 31417 153 22 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 153 23 backward backward RB 31417 153 24 and and CC 31417 153 25 forward forward RB 31417 153 26 , , , 31417 153 27 advancing advance VBG 31417 153 28 towards towards IN 31417 153 29 the the DT 31417 153 30 armchair armchair NN 31417 153 31 in in IN 31417 153 32 which which WDT 31417 153 33 I -PRON- PRP 31417 153 34 sat sit VBD 31417 153 35 , , , 31417 153 36 and and CC 31417 153 37 ultimately ultimately RB 31417 153 38 completely completely RB 31417 153 39 imprisoning imprison VBG 31417 153 40 me -PRON- PRP 31417 153 41 in in IN 31417 153 42 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 153 43 seat seat NN 31417 153 44 . . . 31417 154 1 During during IN 31417 154 2 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 154 3 progress progress NN 31417 154 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 154 5 was be VBD 31417 154 6 followed follow VBN 31417 154 7 by by IN 31417 154 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 154 9 L. L. NNP 31417 154 10 and and CC 31417 154 11 Miss Miss NNP 31417 154 12 I. I. NNP 31417 154 13 , , , 31417 154 14 but but CC 31417 154 15 they -PRON- PRP 31417 154 16 were be VBD 31417 154 17 at at IN 31417 154 18 no no DT 31417 154 19 time time NN 31417 154 20 touching touch VBG 31417 154 21 it -PRON- PRP 31417 154 22 , , , 31417 154 23 and and CC 31417 154 24 occasionally occasionally RB 31417 154 25 were be VBD 31417 154 26 so so RB 31417 154 27 distant distant JJ 31417 154 28 that that IN 31417 154 29 I -PRON- PRP 31417 154 30 could could MD 31417 154 31 perceive perceive VB 31417 154 32 a a DT 31417 154 33 free free JJ 31417 154 34 space space NN 31417 154 35 all all RB 31417 154 36 round round VBP 31417 154 37 the the DT 31417 154 38 table table NN 31417 154 39 whilst whilst IN 31417 154 40 it -PRON- PRP 31417 154 41 was be VBD 31417 154 42 still still RB 31417 154 43 in in IN 31417 154 44 motion motion NN 31417 154 45 . . . 31417 155 1 When when WRB 31417 155 2 thus thus RB 31417 155 3 under under IN 31417 155 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 155 5 very very JJ 31417 155 6 nose nose NN 31417 155 7 , , , 31417 155 8 the the DT 31417 155 9 table table NN 31417 155 10 rose rise VBD 31417 155 11 repeatedly repeatedly RB 31417 155 12 , , , 31417 155 13 and and CC 31417 155 14 enabled enable VBD 31417 155 15 me -PRON- PRP 31417 155 16 to to TO 31417 155 17 be be VB 31417 155 18 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 155 19 sure sure JJ 31417 155 20 , , , 31417 155 21 by by IN 31417 155 22 the the DT 31417 155 23 evidence evidence NN 31417 155 24 of of IN 31417 155 25 touch touch NN 31417 155 26 , , , 31417 155 27 that that IN 31417 155 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 155 29 was be VBD 31417 155 30 off off IN 31417 155 31 the the DT 31417 155 32 ground ground NN 31417 155 33 , , , 31417 155 34 and and CC 31417 155 35 further far RBR 31417 155 36 , , , 31417 155 37 that that IN 31417 155 38 no no DT 31417 155 39 human human NN 31417 155 40 being being NN 31417 155 41 , , , 31417 155 42 consciously consciously RB 31417 155 43 or or CC 31417 155 44 unconsciously unconsciously RB 31417 155 45 , , , 31417 155 46 had have VBD 31417 155 47 any any DT 31417 155 48 part part NN 31417 155 49 in in IN 31417 155 50 this this DT 31417 155 51 movement movement NN 31417 155 52 . . . 31417 155 53 " " '' 31417 156 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 156 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 156 3 , , , 31417 156 4 with with IN 31417 156 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 156 6 accustomed accustomed JJ 31417 156 7 caution caution NN 31417 156 8 , , , 31417 156 9 comments comment VBZ 31417 156 10 thus:-- thus:-- '' 31417 156 11 " " `` 31417 156 12 The the DT 31417 156 13 results result NNS 31417 156 14 , , , 31417 156 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 156 16 is be VBZ 31417 156 17 true true JJ 31417 156 18 , , , 31417 156 19 were be VBD 31417 156 20 very very RB 31417 156 21 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 156 22 and and CC 31417 156 23 unaccountable unaccountable JJ 31417 156 24 ; ; : 31417 156 25 but but CC 31417 156 26 though though IN 31417 156 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 156 28 had have VBD 31417 156 29 not not RB 31417 156 30 the the DT 31417 156 31 slightest slight JJS 31417 156 32 doubt doubt NN 31417 156 33 of of IN 31417 156 34 the the DT 31417 156 35 good good JJ 31417 156 36 faith faith NN 31417 156 37 of of IN 31417 156 38 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 156 39 L. L. NNP 31417 156 40 and and CC 31417 156 41 Miss Miss NNP 31417 156 42 I. I. NNP 31417 156 43 , , , 31417 156 44 yet yet CC 31417 156 45 I -PRON- PRP 31417 156 46 do do VBP 31417 156 47 not not RB 31417 156 48 adduce adduce VB 31417 156 49 this this DT 31417 156 50 evidence evidence NN 31417 156 51 as as IN 31417 156 52 unexceptionable unexceptionable JJ 31417 156 53 . . . 31417 157 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 157 2 should should MD 31417 157 3 have have VB 31417 157 4 preferred prefer VBN 31417 157 5 to to TO 31417 157 6 have have VB 31417 157 7 taken take VBN 31417 157 8 precautions precaution NNS 31417 157 9 which which WDT 31417 157 10 were be VBD 31417 157 11 not not RB 31417 157 12 so so RB 31417 157 13 easy easy JJ 31417 157 14 to to TO 31417 157 15 impose impose VB 31417 157 16 on on IN 31417 157 17 a a DT 31417 157 18 lady lady NN 31417 157 19 , , , 31417 157 20 and and CC 31417 157 21 I -PRON- PRP 31417 157 22 should should MD 31417 157 23 also also RB 31417 157 24 have have VB 31417 157 25 preferred prefer VBN 31417 157 26 to to TO 31417 157 27 have have VB 31417 157 28 had have VBN 31417 157 29 the the DT 31417 157 30 seance seance NN 31417 157 31 at at IN 31417 157 32 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 157 33 own own JJ 31417 157 34 house house NN 31417 157 35 . . . 31417 157 36 " " '' 31417 158 1 This this DT 31417 158 2 latter latter JJ 31417 158 3 objection objection NN 31417 158 4 was be VBD 31417 158 5 met meet VBN 31417 158 6 by by IN 31417 158 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 158 8 L. L. NNP 31417 158 9 and and CC 31417 158 10 Miss Miss NNP 31417 158 11 I. I. NNP 31417 158 12 going go VBG 31417 158 13 to to IN 31417 158 14 Professor Professor NNP 31417 158 15 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 158 16 's 's POS 31417 158 17 house house NN 31417 158 18 shortly shortly RB 31417 158 19 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 158 20 , , , 31417 158 21 no no DT 31417 158 22 one one NN 31417 158 23 else else RB 31417 158 24 besides besides IN 31417 158 25 Professor Professor NNP 31417 158 26 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 158 27 being be VBG 31417 158 28 present present JJ 31417 158 29 . . . 31417 159 1 Some some DT 31417 159 2 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 159 3 sounds sound NNS 31417 159 4 were be VBD 31417 159 5 again again RB 31417 159 6 heard hear VBN 31417 159 7 . . . 31417 160 1 Then then RB 31417 160 2 , , , 31417 160 3 this this DT 31417 160 4 happened happen VBD 31417 160 5 -- -- : 31417 160 6 again again RB 31417 160 7 quoting quote VBG 31417 160 8 Professor Professor NNP 31417 160 9 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 160 10 's 's POS 31417 160 11 own own JJ 31417 160 12 words:-- words:-- NN 31417 160 13 " " '' 31417 160 14 Suddenly suddenly RB 31417 160 15 , , , 31417 160 16 only only RB 31417 160 17 the the DT 31417 160 18 tips tip NNS 31417 160 19 of of IN 31417 160 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 160 21 fingers finger NNS 31417 160 22 being be VBG 31417 160 23 on on IN 31417 160 24 the the DT 31417 160 25 table table NN 31417 160 26 , , , 31417 160 27 the the DT 31417 160 28 heavy heavy JJ 31417 160 29 loo loo NN 31417 160 30 - - HYPH 31417 160 31 table table NN 31417 160 32 at at IN 31417 160 33 which which WDT 31417 160 34 we -PRON- PRP 31417 160 35 were be VBD 31417 160 36 sitting sit VBG 31417 160 37 made make VBN 31417 160 38 a a DT 31417 160 39 series series NN 31417 160 40 of of IN 31417 160 41 very very RB 31417 160 42 violent violent JJ 31417 160 43 prancing prance VBG 31417 160 44 movements movement NNS 31417 160 45 ( ( -LRB- 31417 160 46 which which WDT 31417 160 47 I -PRON- PRP 31417 160 48 could could MD 31417 160 49 not not RB 31417 160 50 imitate imitate VB 31417 160 51 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 160 52 except except IN 31417 160 53 by by IN 31417 160 54 using use VBG 31417 160 55 both both DT 31417 160 56 hands hand NNS 31417 160 57 and and CC 31417 160 58 all all DT 31417 160 59 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 160 60 strength strength NN 31417 160 61 ) ) -RRB- 31417 160 62 ; ; : 31417 160 63 the the DT 31417 160 64 blows blow NNS 31417 160 65 were be VBD 31417 160 66 so so RB 31417 160 67 heavy heavy JJ 31417 160 68 that that IN 31417 160 69 I -PRON- PRP 31417 160 70 hurriedly hurriedly RB 31417 160 71 stopped stop VBD 31417 160 72 the the DT 31417 160 73 performance performance NN 31417 160 74 , , , 31417 160 75 fearing fear VBG 31417 160 76 for for IN 31417 160 77 the the DT 31417 160 78 safety safety NN 31417 160 79 of of IN 31417 160 80 the the DT 31417 160 81 gas gas NN 31417 160 82 chandelier chandelier NN 31417 160 83 in in IN 31417 160 84 the the DT 31417 160 85 room room NN 31417 160 86 below below RB 31417 160 87 . . . 31417 161 1 Here here RB 31417 161 2 , , , 31417 161 3 too too RB 31417 161 4 , , , 31417 161 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 161 6 can can MD 31417 161 7 not not RB 31417 161 8 avoid avoid VB 31417 161 9 the the DT 31417 161 10 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 161 11 that that IN 31417 161 12 the the DT 31417 161 13 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 161 14 described describe VBN 31417 161 15 are be VBP 31417 161 16 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 31417 161 17 on on IN 31417 161 18 any any DT 31417 161 19 known know VBN 31417 161 20 hypothesis hypothesis NN 31417 161 21 . . . 31417 161 22 " " '' 31417 162 1 After after IN 31417 162 2 discounting discount VBG 31417 162 3 the the DT 31417 162 4 " " `` 31417 162 5 pious pious JJ 31417 162 6 platitudes platitude NNS 31417 162 7 " " '' 31417 162 8 spelt spelt NNS 31417 162 9 out out RP 31417 162 10 by by IN 31417 162 11 the the DT 31417 162 12 tilts tilt NNS 31417 162 13 of of IN 31417 162 14 the the DT 31417 162 15 table table NN 31417 162 16 , , , 31417 162 17 and and CC 31417 162 18 the the DT 31417 162 19 possibility possibility NN 31417 162 20 , , , 31417 162 21 and and CC 31417 162 22 even even RB 31417 162 23 probability probability NN 31417 162 24 , , , 31417 162 25 that that IN 31417 162 26 " " `` 31417 162 27 unintentional unintentional JJ 31417 162 28 muscular muscular JJ 31417 162 29 movements movement NNS 31417 162 30 " " '' 31417 162 31 were be VBD 31417 162 32 the the DT 31417 162 33 cause cause NN 31417 162 34 of of IN 31417 162 35 these these DT 31417 162 36 , , , 31417 162 37 and and CC 31417 162 38 after after IN 31417 162 39 recognising recognise VBG 31417 162 40 the the DT 31417 162 41 impossibility impossibility NN 31417 162 42 of of IN 31417 162 43 keeping keep VBG 31417 162 44 up up RP 31417 162 45 a a DT 31417 162 46 continuous continuous JJ 31417 162 47 vigilant vigilant JJ 31417 162 48 watch watch NN 31417 162 49 on on IN 31417 162 50 the the DT 31417 162 51 hands hand NNS 31417 162 52 and and CC 31417 162 53 feet foot NNS 31417 162 54 of of IN 31417 162 55 any any DT 31417 162 56 person person NN 31417 162 57 , , , 31417 162 58 and and CC 31417 162 59 after after IN 31417 162 60 supposing suppose VBG 31417 162 61 that that IN 31417 162 62 Miss Miss NNP 31417 162 63 I. I. NNP 31417 162 64 had have VBD 31417 162 65 some some DT 31417 162 66 ingenious ingenious JJ 31417 162 67 mechanism mechanism NN 31417 162 68 concealed conceal VBD 31417 162 69 about about IN 31417 162 70 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 162 71 person person NN 31417 162 72 , , , 31417 162 73 whereby whereby WRB 31417 162 74 she -PRON- PRP 31417 162 75 could could MD 31417 162 76 produce produce VB 31417 162 77 the the DT 31417 162 78 sounds sound NNS 31417 162 79 that that WDT 31417 162 80 were be VBD 31417 162 81 heard hear VBN 31417 162 82 , , , 31417 162 83 Professor Professor NNP 31417 162 84 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 162 85 says say VBZ 31417 162 86 : : : 31417 162 87 " " `` 31417 162 88 This this DT 31417 162 89 would would MD 31417 162 90 fail fail VB 31417 162 91 to to TO 31417 162 92 account account VB 31417 162 93 for for IN 31417 162 94 the the DT 31417 162 95 undoubted undoubted JJ 31417 162 96 motion motion NN 31417 162 97 of of IN 31417 162 98 a a DT 31417 162 99 heavy heavy JJ 31417 162 100 table table NN 31417 162 101 , , , 31417 162 102 free free JJ 31417 162 103 from from IN 31417 162 104 the the DT 31417 162 105 contact contact NN 31417 162 106 of of IN 31417 162 107 all all DT 31417 162 108 present present JJ 31417 162 109 . . . 31417 163 1 After after IN 31417 163 2 giving give VBG 31417 163 3 due due JJ 31417 163 4 weight weight NN 31417 163 5 to to IN 31417 163 6 every every DT 31417 163 7 known know VBN 31417 163 8 explanation explanation NN 31417 163 9 , , , 31417 163 10 the the DT 31417 163 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 163 12 remain remain VBP 31417 163 13 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 31417 163 14 to to IN 31417 163 15 me -PRON- PRP 31417 163 16 . . . 31417 163 17 " " '' 31417 164 1 TESTIMONY TESTIMONY NNP 31417 164 2 COLLECTED collect VBD 31417 164 3 BY by IN 31417 164 4 FREDERIC FREDERIC NNP 31417 164 5 W. W. NNP 31417 164 6 H. H. NNP 31417 164 7 MYERS MYERS NNP 31417 164 8 . . . 31417 165 1 Next next RB 31417 165 2 in in IN 31417 165 3 order order NN 31417 165 4 of of IN 31417 165 5 time time NN 31417 165 6 come come VB 31417 165 7 two two CD 31417 165 8 papers paper NNS 31417 165 9 by by IN 31417 165 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 165 11 F. F. NNP 31417 165 12 W. W. NNP 31417 165 13 H. H. NNP 31417 165 14 Myers Myers NNP 31417 165 15 , , , 31417 165 16 under under IN 31417 165 17 the the DT 31417 165 18 title title NN 31417 165 19 of of IN 31417 165 20 " " `` 31417 165 21 Alleged alleged JJ 31417 165 22 Movements movement NNS 31417 165 23 of of IN 31417 165 24 Objects object NNS 31417 165 25 without without IN 31417 165 26 Contact Contact NNP 31417 165 27 , , , 31417 165 28 occurring occur VBG 31417 165 29 not not RB 31417 165 30 in in IN 31417 165 31 the the DT 31417 165 32 Presence Presence NNP 31417 165 33 of of IN 31417 165 34 a a DT 31417 165 35 Paid Paid NNP 31417 165 36 Medium Medium NNP 31417 165 37 . . . 31417 165 38 " " '' 31417 166 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 166 2 are be VBP 31417 166 3 published publish VBN 31417 166 4 in in IN 31417 166 5 vol vol NNP 31417 166 6 . . . 31417 167 1 vii vii NN 31417 167 2 . . . 31417 168 1 of of IN 31417 168 2 the the DT 31417 168 3 _ _ NNP 31417 168 4 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 168 5 _ _ NNP 31417 168 6 of of IN 31417 168 7 the the DT 31417 168 8 Society Society NNP 31417 168 9 for for IN 31417 168 10 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 168 11 Research Research NNP 31417 168 12 . . . 31417 169 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 169 2 8 8 LS 31417 169 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 169 4 The the DT 31417 169 5 first first JJ 31417 169 6 article article NN 31417 169 7 goes go VBZ 31417 169 8 over over IN 31417 169 9 most most JJS 31417 169 10 of of IN 31417 169 11 the the DT 31417 169 12 ground ground NN 31417 169 13 traversed traverse VBN 31417 169 14 in in IN 31417 169 15 the the DT 31417 169 16 earlier early JJR 31417 169 17 part part NN 31417 169 18 of of IN 31417 169 19 this this DT 31417 169 20 chapter chapter NN 31417 169 21 , , , 31417 169 22 but but CC 31417 169 23 devotes devote VBZ 31417 169 24 twenty twenty CD 31417 169 25 lines line NNS 31417 169 26 only only RB 31417 169 27 to to IN 31417 169 28 the the DT 31417 169 29 Report Report NNP 31417 169 30 of of IN 31417 169 31 the the DT 31417 169 32 Committee Committee NNP 31417 169 33 of of IN 31417 169 34 the the DT 31417 169 35 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 169 36 Society Society NNP 31417 169 37 , , , 31417 169 38 and and CC 31417 169 39 refers refer VBZ 31417 169 40 only only RB 31417 169 41 to to IN 31417 169 42 Professor Professor NNP 31417 169 43 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 169 44 's 's POS 31417 169 45 cases case NNS 31417 169 46 as as IN 31417 169 47 having have VBG 31417 169 48 been be VBN 31417 169 49 already already RB 31417 169 50 published publish VBN 31417 169 51 . . . 31417 170 1 A a DT 31417 170 2 number number NN 31417 170 3 of of IN 31417 170 4 other other JJ 31417 170 5 cases case NNS 31417 170 6 are be VBP 31417 170 7 , , , 31417 170 8 however however RB 31417 170 9 , , , 31417 170 10 described describe VBN 31417 170 11 in in IN 31417 170 12 detail detail NN 31417 170 13 . . . 31417 171 1 The the DT 31417 171 2 evidence evidence NN 31417 171 3 in in IN 31417 171 4 these these DT 31417 171 5 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 171 6 comes come VBZ 31417 171 7 up up RP 31417 171 8 to to IN 31417 171 9 the the DT 31417 171 10 level level NN 31417 171 11 of of IN 31417 171 12 scientific scientific JJ 31417 171 13 , , , 31417 171 14 and and CC 31417 171 15 unless unless IN 31417 171 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 171 17 had have VBD 31417 171 18 been be VBN 31417 171 19 sifted sift VBN 31417 171 20 by by IN 31417 171 21 so so RB 31417 171 22 careful careful JJ 31417 171 23 a a DT 31417 171 24 critic critic NN 31417 171 25 as as IN 31417 171 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 171 27 Myers Myers NNP 31417 171 28 , , , 31417 171 29 who who WP 31417 171 30 convinced convince VBD 31417 171 31 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 171 32 of of IN 31417 171 33 the the DT 31417 171 34 reality reality NN 31417 171 35 of of IN 31417 171 36 the the DT 31417 171 37 facts fact NNS 31417 171 38 , , , 31417 171 39 could could MD 31417 171 40 hardly hardly RB 31417 171 41 be be VB 31417 171 42 considered consider VBN 31417 171 43 of of IN 31417 171 44 much much JJ 31417 171 45 value value NN 31417 171 46 . . . 31417 172 1 The the DT 31417 172 2 two two CD 31417 172 3 following follow VBG 31417 172 4 cases case NNS 31417 172 5 in in IN 31417 172 6 the the DT 31417 172 7 first first JJ 31417 172 8 article article NN 31417 172 9 present present NN 31417 172 10 the the DT 31417 172 11 strongest strong JJS 31417 172 12 evidence evidence NN 31417 172 13 . . . 31417 173 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 173 2 1 1 LS 31417 173 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 173 4 THE the DT 31417 173 5 ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG NNP 31417 173 6 CASE.--Mr CASE.--Mr NNP 31417 173 7 . . . 31417 174 1 George George NNP 31417 174 2 Allman Allman NNP 31417 174 3 Armstrong Armstrong NNP 31417 174 4 , , , 31417 174 5 of of IN 31417 174 6 8 8 CD 31417 174 7 Leeson Leeson NNP 31417 174 8 Place Place NNP 31417 174 9 , , , 31417 174 10 Dublin Dublin NNP 31417 174 11 , , , 31417 174 12 and and CC 31417 174 13 Ardnacarrig Ardnacarrig NNP 31417 174 14 , , , 31417 174 15 Bandon Bandon NNP 31417 174 16 , , , 31417 174 17 writes write VBZ 31417 174 18 an an DT 31417 174 19 account account NN 31417 174 20 dated date VBN 31417 174 21 13th 13th NN 31417 174 22 June June NNP 31417 174 23 1887 1887 CD 31417 174 24 . . . 31417 175 1 After after IN 31417 175 2 vouching vouch VBG 31417 175 3 for for IN 31417 175 4 the the DT 31417 175 5 perfect perfect JJ 31417 175 6 good good JJ 31417 175 7 faith faith NN 31417 175 8 of of IN 31417 175 9 the the DT 31417 175 10 small small JJ 31417 175 11 group group NN 31417 175 12 of of IN 31417 175 13 experimenters experimenter NNS 31417 175 14 , , , 31417 175 15 he -PRON- PRP 31417 175 16 describes describe VBZ 31417 175 17 in in IN 31417 175 18 detail detail NN 31417 175 19 the the DT 31417 175 20 movements movement NNS 31417 175 21 of of IN 31417 175 22 a a DT 31417 175 23 table table NN 31417 175 24 . . . 31417 176 1 The the DT 31417 176 2 " " `` 31417 176 3 rising rise VBG 31417 176 4 " " '' 31417 176 5 was be VBD 31417 176 6 generally generally RB 31417 176 7 preceded precede VBN 31417 176 8 by by IN 31417 176 9 a a DT 31417 176 10 continuous continuous JJ 31417 176 11 fusillade fusillade NN 31417 176 12 of of IN 31417 176 13 " " `` 31417 176 14 knocks knock NNS 31417 176 15 " " '' 31417 176 16 in in IN 31417 176 17 the the DT 31417 176 18 substance substance NN 31417 176 19 of of IN 31417 176 20 the the DT 31417 176 21 table table NN 31417 176 22 . . . 31417 177 1 When when WRB 31417 177 2 the the DT 31417 177 3 knocks knock NNS 31417 177 4 had have VBD 31417 177 5 , , , 31417 177 6 as as IN 31417 177 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 177 8 were be VBD 31417 177 9 , , , 31417 177 10 reached reach VBN 31417 177 11 a a DT 31417 177 12 climax climax NN 31417 177 13 , , , 31417 177 14 the the DT 31417 177 15 table table NN 31417 177 16 slowly slowly RB 31417 177 17 swayed sway VBD 31417 177 18 from from IN 31417 177 19 side side NN 31417 177 20 to to TO 31417 177 21 side side VB 31417 177 22 like like IN 31417 177 23 a a DT 31417 177 24 pendulum pendulum NN 31417 177 25 . . . 31417 178 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 178 2 would would MD 31417 178 3 stop stop VB 31417 178 4 completely completely RB 31417 178 5 , , , 31417 178 6 and and CC 31417 178 7 then then RB 31417 178 8 , , , 31417 178 9 as as IN 31417 178 10 if if IN 31417 178 11 imbued imbue VBN 31417 178 12 with with IN 31417 178 13 life life NN 31417 178 14 , , , 31417 178 15 and and CC 31417 178 16 quite quite RB 31417 178 17 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 178 18 , , , 31417 178 19 would would MD 31417 178 20 rise rise VB 31417 178 21 completely completely RB 31417 178 22 off off IN 31417 178 23 the the DT 31417 178 24 floor floor NN 31417 178 25 to to IN 31417 178 26 a a DT 31417 178 27 height height NN 31417 178 28 of of IN 31417 178 29 twelve twelve CD 31417 178 30 or or CC 31417 178 31 fourteen fourteen CD 31417 178 32 inches inch NNS 31417 178 33 at at IN 31417 178 34 least least JJS 31417 178 35 . . . 31417 179 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 179 2 nearly nearly RB 31417 179 3 always always RB 31417 179 4 came come VBD 31417 179 5 down down RP 31417 179 6 with with IN 31417 179 7 immense immense JJ 31417 179 8 force force NN 31417 179 9 , , , 31417 179 10 and and CC 31417 179 11 on on IN 31417 179 12 several several JJ 31417 179 13 occasions occasion NNS 31417 179 14 proved prove VBD 31417 179 15 destructive destructive JJ 31417 179 16 to to IN 31417 179 17 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 179 18 , , , 31417 179 19 as as IN 31417 179 20 the the DT 31417 179 21 broken break VBN 31417 179 22 limbs limb NNS 31417 179 23 of of IN 31417 179 24 the the DT 31417 179 25 table table NN 31417 179 26 used use VBN 31417 179 27 at at IN 31417 179 28 Kinsale Kinsale NNP 31417 179 29 could could MD 31417 179 30 testify testify VB 31417 179 31 . . . 31417 180 1 The the DT 31417 180 2 table table NN 31417 180 3 was be VBD 31417 180 4 a a DT 31417 180 5 round round NN 31417 180 6 , , , 31417 180 7 rather rather RB 31417 180 8 heavy heavy JJ 31417 180 9 walnut walnut NNP 31417 180 10 one one CD 31417 180 11 , , , 31417 180 12 with with IN 31417 180 13 a a DT 31417 180 14 central central JJ 31417 180 15 column column NN 31417 180 16 standing stand VBG 31417 180 17 on on IN 31417 180 18 three three CD 31417 180 19 claw claw JJ 31417 180 20 legs leg NNS 31417 180 21 . . . 31417 181 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 181 2 Armstrong Armstrong NNP 31417 181 3 says say VBZ 31417 181 4 that that IN 31417 181 5 on on IN 31417 181 6 several several JJ 31417 181 7 occasions occasion NNS 31417 181 8 he -PRON- PRP 31417 181 9 succeeded succeed VBD 31417 181 10 in in IN 31417 181 11 raising raise VBG 31417 181 12 the the DT 31417 181 13 table table NN 31417 181 14 without without IN 31417 181 15 contact contact NN 31417 181 16 . . . 31417 182 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 182 2 rose rise VBD 31417 182 3 to to IN 31417 182 4 the the DT 31417 182 5 fingers finger NNS 31417 182 6 held hold VBN 31417 182 7 over over IN 31417 182 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 182 9 at at IN 31417 182 10 a a DT 31417 182 11 height height NN 31417 182 12 of of IN 31417 182 13 several several JJ 31417 182 14 inches inch NNS 31417 182 15 , , , 31417 182 16 like like IN 31417 182 17 the the DT 31417 182 18 keeper keeper NN 31417 182 19 of of IN 31417 182 20 a a DT 31417 182 21 strong strong JJ 31417 182 22 electro electro JJ 31417 182 23 - - HYPH 31417 182 24 magnet magnet NN 31417 182 25 . . . 31417 183 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 183 2 9 9 CD 31417 183 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 183 4 ( ( -LRB- 31417 183 5 2 2 LS 31417 183 6 ) ) -RRB- 31417 183 7 A a DT 31417 183 8 BELL BELL NNP 31417 183 9 - - HYPH 31417 183 10 RINGING RINGING NNP 31417 183 11 CASE.--Mr CASE.--Mr NNP 31417 183 12 . . . 31417 184 1 Myers Myers NNP 31417 184 2 , , , 31417 184 3 in in IN 31417 184 4 introducing introduce VBG 31417 184 5 this this DT 31417 184 6 case case NN 31417 184 7 , , , 31417 184 8 says say VBZ 31417 184 9 : : : 31417 184 10 " " `` 31417 184 11 The the DT 31417 184 12 usual usual JJ 31417 184 13 hypotheses hypothesis NNS 31417 184 14 of of IN 31417 184 15 fraud fraud NN 31417 184 16 , , , 31417 184 17 rats rat NNS 31417 184 18 , , , 31417 184 19 hitched hitch VBD 31417 184 20 wires wire NNS 31417 184 21 , , , 31417 184 22 & & CC 31417 184 23 c. c. NNP 31417 184 24 , , , 31417 184 25 seem seem VB 31417 184 26 hard hard JJ 31417 184 27 to to TO 31417 184 28 apply apply VB 31417 184 29 . . . 31417 185 1 The the DT 31417 185 2 care care NN 31417 185 3 and and CC 31417 185 4 fulness fulness NN 31417 185 5 with with IN 31417 185 6 which which WDT 31417 185 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 185 8 has have VBZ 31417 185 9 been be VBN 31417 185 10 recorded record VBN 31417 185 11 will will MD 31417 185 12 enable enable VB 31417 185 13 the the DT 31417 185 14 reader reader NN 31417 185 15 to to TO 31417 185 16 judge judge VB 31417 185 17 for for IN 31417 185 18 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 185 19 more more RBR 31417 185 20 easily easily RB 31417 185 21 than than IN 31417 185 22 in in IN 31417 185 23 most most JJS 31417 185 24 narratives narrative NNS 31417 185 25 of of IN 31417 185 26 this this DT 31417 185 27 type type NN 31417 185 28 . . . 31417 186 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 186 2 informant informant NN 31417 186 3 is be VBZ 31417 186 4 a a DT 31417 186 5 gentleman gentleman NN 31417 186 6 [ [ -LRB- 31417 186 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 186 8 D. D. NNP 31417 186 9 ] ] -RRB- 31417 186 10 , , , 31417 186 11 occupying occupy VBG 31417 186 12 a a DT 31417 186 13 responsible responsible JJ 31417 186 14 position position NN 31417 186 15 ; ; : 31417 186 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 186 17 name name NN 31417 186 18 may may MD 31417 186 19 be be VB 31417 186 20 given give VBN 31417 186 21 to to IN 31417 186 22 inquirers inquirer NNS 31417 186 23 . . . 31417 187 1 " " `` 31417 187 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 187 3 10 10 CD 31417 187 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 187 5 The the DT 31417 187 6 detailed detailed JJ 31417 187 7 report report NN 31417 187 8 of of IN 31417 187 9 the the DT 31417 187 10 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 187 11 occupies occupy VBZ 31417 187 12 no no RB 31417 187 13 less less JJR 31417 187 14 than than IN 31417 187 15 twelve twelve CD 31417 187 16 pages page NNS 31417 187 17 , , , 31417 187 18 the the DT 31417 187 19 greater great JJR 31417 187 20 part part NN 31417 187 21 of of IN 31417 187 22 which which WDT 31417 187 23 consists consist VBZ 31417 187 24 of of IN 31417 187 25 a a DT 31417 187 26 long long JJ 31417 187 27 letter letter NN 31417 187 28 addressed address VBN 31417 187 29 by by IN 31417 187 30 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 187 31 D. D. NNP 31417 187 32 to to IN 31417 187 33 the the DT 31417 187 34 Society Society NNP 31417 187 35 for for IN 31417 187 36 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 187 37 Research Research NNP 31417 187 38 . . . 31417 188 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 188 2 explains explain VBZ 31417 188 3 that that IN 31417 188 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 188 5 is be VBZ 31417 188 6 writing write VBG 31417 188 7 in in IN 31417 188 8 the the DT 31417 188 9 main main JJ 31417 188 10 from from IN 31417 188 11 notes note NNS 31417 188 12 taken take VBN 31417 188 13 at at IN 31417 188 14 the the DT 31417 188 15 time time NN 31417 188 16 and and CC 31417 188 17 not not RB 31417 188 18 from from IN 31417 188 19 memory memory NN 31417 188 20 . . . 31417 189 1 The the DT 31417 189 2 following follow VBG 31417 189 3 is be VBZ 31417 189 4 an an DT 31417 189 5 abstract:-- abstract:-- NN 31417 189 6 On on IN 31417 189 7 Friday Friday NNP 31417 189 8 , , , 31417 189 9 23rd 23rd NN 31417 189 10 September September NNP 31417 189 11 1887 1887 CD 31417 189 12 , , , 31417 189 13 he -PRON- PRP 31417 189 14 took take VBD 31417 189 15 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 189 16 four four CD 31417 189 17 pupils pupil NNS 31417 189 18 to to IN 31417 189 19 a a DT 31417 189 20 circus circus NN 31417 189 21 , , , 31417 189 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 189 23 lady lady NN 31417 189 24 housekeeper housekeeper NN 31417 189 25 also also RB 31417 189 26 going go VBG 31417 189 27 , , , 31417 189 28 leaving leave VBG 31417 189 29 two two CD 31417 189 30 servants servant NNS 31417 189 31 at at IN 31417 189 32 home home NN 31417 189 33 . . . 31417 190 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 190 2 left leave VBD 31417 190 3 at at IN 31417 190 4 about about RB 31417 190 5 2 2 CD 31417 190 6 P.M. P.M. NNP 31417 190 7 All all DT 31417 190 8 but but CC 31417 190 9 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 190 10 returned return VBD 31417 190 11 about about RB 31417 190 12 5.30 5.30 CD 31417 190 13 P.M. P.M. NNP 31417 191 1 The the DT 31417 191 2 two two CD 31417 191 3 servants servant NNS 31417 191 4 were be VBD 31417 191 5 on on IN 31417 191 6 the the DT 31417 191 7 doorstep doorstep NN 31417 191 8 , , , 31417 191 9 telling tell VBG 31417 191 10 the the DT 31417 191 11 boys boy NNS 31417 191 12 not not RB 31417 191 13 to to TO 31417 191 14 go go VB 31417 191 15 in in RP 31417 191 16 by by IN 31417 191 17 the the DT 31417 191 18 area area NN 31417 191 19 door door NN 31417 191 20 -- -- : 31417 191 21 the the DT 31417 191 22 kitchens kitchen NNS 31417 191 23 being be VBG 31417 191 24 below below IN 31417 191 25 ground ground NN 31417 191 26 -- -- : 31417 191 27 and and CC 31417 191 28 explaining explain VBG 31417 191 29 that that IN 31417 191 30 all all PDT 31417 191 31 the the DT 31417 191 32 bells bell NNS 31417 191 33 were be VBD 31417 191 34 ringing ring VBG 31417 191 35 violently violently RB 31417 191 36 , , , 31417 191 37 no no DT 31417 191 38 one one NN 31417 191 39 touching touch VBG 31417 191 40 them -PRON- PRP 31417 191 41 , , , 31417 191 42 and and CC 31417 191 43 that that IN 31417 191 44 they -PRON- PRP 31417 191 45 had have VBD 31417 191 46 been be VBN 31417 191 47 doing do VBG 31417 191 48 so so RB 31417 191 49 almost almost RB 31417 191 50 ever ever RB 31417 191 51 since since IN 31417 191 52 half half JJ 31417 191 53 - - HYPH 31417 191 54 past past JJ 31417 191 55 two two CD 31417 191 56 . . . 31417 192 1 When when WRB 31417 192 2 the the DT 31417 192 3 master master NN 31417 192 4 of of IN 31417 192 5 the the DT 31417 192 6 house house NN 31417 192 7 came come VBD 31417 192 8 home home RB 31417 192 9 , , , 31417 192 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 192 11 found find VBD 31417 192 12 the the DT 31417 192 13 same same JJ 31417 192 14 state state NN 31417 192 15 of of IN 31417 192 16 things thing NNS 31417 192 17 , , , 31417 192 18 the the DT 31417 192 19 servants servant NNS 31417 192 20 almost almost RB 31417 192 21 in in IN 31417 192 22 hysterics hysteric NNS 31417 192 23 and and CC 31417 192 24 the the DT 31417 192 25 bells bell NNS 31417 192 26 ringing ring VBG 31417 192 27 . . . 31417 193 1 Nine nine CD 31417 193 2 bells bell NNS 31417 193 3 hung hang VBD 31417 193 4 in in IN 31417 193 5 a a DT 31417 193 6 row row NN 31417 193 7 just just RB 31417 193 8 inside inside IN 31417 193 9 the the DT 31417 193 10 area area NN 31417 193 11 door door NN 31417 193 12 , , , 31417 193 13 opposite opposite IN 31417 193 14 the the DT 31417 193 15 kitchen kitchen NN 31417 193 16 door door NN 31417 193 17 , , , 31417 193 18 and and CC 31417 193 19 there there EX 31417 193 20 was be VBD 31417 193 21 one one CD 31417 193 22 bell bell NN 31417 193 23 -- -- : 31417 193 24 a a DT 31417 193 25 call call NN 31417 193 26 bell bell NN 31417 193 27 -- -- : 31417 193 28 on on IN 31417 193 29 the the DT 31417 193 30 landing landing NN 31417 193 31 at at IN 31417 193 32 the the DT 31417 193 33 top top NN 31417 193 34 of of IN 31417 193 35 the the DT 31417 193 36 house house NN 31417 193 37 . . . 31417 194 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 194 2 D. D. NNP 31417 194 3 frequently frequently RB 31417 194 4 saw see VBD 31417 194 5 several several JJ 31417 194 6 of of IN 31417 194 7 these these DT 31417 194 8 bells bell NNS 31417 194 9 ringing ring VBG 31417 194 10 at at IN 31417 194 11 once once RB 31417 194 12 , , , 31417 194 13 the the DT 31417 194 14 ringing ringing NN 31417 194 15 being be VBG 31417 194 16 sudden sudden JJ 31417 194 17 and and CC 31417 194 18 very very RB 31417 194 19 violent violent JJ 31417 194 20 , , , 31417 194 21 louder loud JJR 31417 194 22 , , , 31417 194 23 he -PRON- PRP 31417 194 24 believed believe VBD 31417 194 25 , , , 31417 194 26 than than IN 31417 194 27 they -PRON- PRP 31417 194 28 could could MD 31417 194 29 be be VB 31417 194 30 rung ring VBN 31417 194 31 by by IN 31417 194 32 pulling pull VBG 31417 194 33 the the DT 31417 194 34 handles handle NNS 31417 194 35 . . . 31417 195 1 One one CD 31417 195 2 bell bell NN 31417 195 3 was be VBD 31417 195 4 more more JJR 31417 195 5 than than IN 31417 195 6 once once RB 31417 195 7 pulled pull VBN 31417 195 8 over over RP 31417 195 9 , , , 31417 195 10 so so IN 31417 195 11 that that IN 31417 195 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 195 13 could could MD 31417 195 14 not not RB 31417 195 15 return return VB 31417 195 16 to to IN 31417 195 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 195 18 normal normal JJ 31417 195 19 position position NN 31417 195 20 . . . 31417 196 1 Several several JJ 31417 196 2 of of IN 31417 196 3 the the DT 31417 196 4 upstairs upstairs NN 31417 196 5 bells bell NNS 31417 196 6 had have VBD 31417 196 7 no no DT 31417 196 8 bell bell NN 31417 196 9 - - HYPH 31417 196 10 pulls pull NNS 31417 196 11 . . . 31417 197 1 The the DT 31417 197 2 bellhanger bellhanger NN 31417 197 3 was be VBD 31417 197 4 several several JJ 31417 197 5 times time NNS 31417 197 6 summoned summon VBN 31417 197 7 to to IN 31417 197 8 the the DT 31417 197 9 premises premise NNS 31417 197 10 . . . 31417 198 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 198 2 showed show VBD 31417 198 3 that that IN 31417 198 4 the the DT 31417 198 5 wires wire NNS 31417 198 6 could could MD 31417 198 7 not not RB 31417 198 8 have have VB 31417 198 9 been be VBN 31417 198 10 entangled entangle VBN 31417 198 11 , , , 31417 198 12 and and CC 31417 198 13 entirely entirely RB 31417 198 14 agreed agree VBD 31417 198 15 that that IN 31417 198 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 198 17 would would MD 31417 198 18 be be VB 31417 198 19 an an DT 31417 198 20 utter utter JJ 31417 198 21 impossibility impossibility NN 31417 198 22 for for IN 31417 198 23 any any DT 31417 198 24 animals animal NNS 31417 198 25 , , , 31417 198 26 such such JJ 31417 198 27 as as IN 31417 198 28 cats cat NNS 31417 198 29 or or CC 31417 198 30 rats rat NNS 31417 198 31 , , , 31417 198 32 to to TO 31417 198 33 ring ring VB 31417 198 34 the the DT 31417 198 35 bells bell NNS 31417 198 36 as as IN 31417 198 37 they -PRON- PRP 31417 198 38 were be VBD 31417 198 39 rung rung JJ 31417 198 40 . . . 31417 199 1 The the DT 31417 199 2 house house NN 31417 199 3 was be VBD 31417 199 4 quite quite PDT 31417 199 5 a a DT 31417 199 6 new new JJ 31417 199 7 one one NN 31417 199 8 , , , 31417 199 9 standing stand VBG 31417 199 10 alone alone RB 31417 199 11 , , , 31417 199 12 surrounded surround VBN 31417 199 13 by by IN 31417 199 14 unoccupied unoccupied JJ 31417 199 15 plots plot NNS 31417 199 16 of of IN 31417 199 17 building build VBG 31417 199 18 land land NN 31417 199 19 . . . 31417 200 1 As as IN 31417 200 2 to to IN 31417 200 3 the the DT 31417 200 4 question question NN 31417 200 5 of of IN 31417 200 6 trickery trickery NN 31417 200 7 . . . 31417 201 1 There there EX 31417 201 2 seemed seem VBD 31417 201 3 no no DT 31417 201 4 possibility possibility NN 31417 201 5 of of IN 31417 201 6 that that DT 31417 201 7 being be VBG 31417 201 8 the the DT 31417 201 9 explanation explanation NN 31417 201 10 . . . 31417 202 1 The the DT 31417 202 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 202 3 occurred occur VBD 31417 202 4 when when WRB 31417 202 5 the the DT 31417 202 6 housekeeper housekeeper NN 31417 202 7 and and CC 31417 202 8 pupils pupil NNS 31417 202 9 were be VBD 31417 202 10 all all RB 31417 202 11 away away RB 31417 202 12 ; ; : 31417 202 13 also also RB 31417 202 14 when when WRB 31417 202 15 the the DT 31417 202 16 cook cook NN 31417 202 17 was be VBD 31417 202 18 away away RB 31417 202 19 ; ; : 31417 202 20 also also RB 31417 202 21 when when WRB 31417 202 22 only only RB 31417 202 23 the the DT 31417 202 24 two two CD 31417 202 25 servants servant NNS 31417 202 26 and and CC 31417 202 27 the the DT 31417 202 28 master master NN 31417 202 29 were be VBD 31417 202 30 in in IN 31417 202 31 the the DT 31417 202 32 house house NN 31417 202 33 , , , 31417 202 34 and and CC 31417 202 35 both both DT 31417 202 36 of of IN 31417 202 37 them -PRON- PRP 31417 202 38 in in IN 31417 202 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 202 40 sight sight NN 31417 202 41 . . . 31417 203 1 For for IN 31417 203 2 instance instance NN 31417 203 3 , , , 31417 203 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 203 5 says say VBZ 31417 203 6 he -PRON- PRP 31417 203 7 stood stand VBD 31417 203 8 in in IN 31417 203 9 the the DT 31417 203 10 passage passage NN 31417 203 11 in in IN 31417 203 12 front front NN 31417 203 13 of of IN 31417 203 14 the the DT 31417 203 15 nine nine CD 31417 203 16 bells bell NNS 31417 203 17 watching watch VBG 31417 203 18 them -PRON- PRP 31417 203 19 ring re VBG 31417 203 20 , , , 31417 203 21 with with IN 31417 203 22 both both CC 31417 203 23 the the DT 31417 203 24 servants servant NNS 31417 203 25 close close RB 31417 203 26 by by RB 31417 203 27 . . . 31417 204 1 Once once RB 31417 204 2 in in IN 31417 204 3 particular particular JJ 31417 204 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 204 5 watched watch VBD 31417 204 6 the the DT 31417 204 7 housemaid housemaid NNS 31417 204 8 on on IN 31417 204 9 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 204 10 knees knee NNS 31417 204 11 in in IN 31417 204 12 the the DT 31417 204 13 middle middle NN 31417 204 14 of of IN 31417 204 15 the the DT 31417 204 16 wash wash NN 31417 204 17 - - HYPH 31417 204 18 house house NNP 31417 204 19 scrubbing scrub VBG 31417 204 20 the the DT 31417 204 21 tiles tile NNS 31417 204 22 , , , 31417 204 23 while while IN 31417 204 24 the the DT 31417 204 25 front front JJ 31417 204 26 door door NNP 31417 204 27 , , , 31417 204 28 area area NN 31417 204 29 door door NN 31417 204 30 , , , 31417 204 31 and and CC 31417 204 32 bath bath NN 31417 204 33 - - HYPH 31417 204 34 room room NN 31417 204 35 bells bell NNS 31417 204 36 were be VBD 31417 204 37 pealing peal VBG 31417 204 38 violently violently RB 31417 204 39 . . . 31417 205 1 The the DT 31417 205 2 ringing ringing NN 31417 205 3 was be VBD 31417 205 4 also also RB 31417 205 5 heard hear VBN 31417 205 6 by by IN 31417 205 7 tradesmen tradesman NNS 31417 205 8 , , , 31417 205 9 and and CC 31417 205 10 by by IN 31417 205 11 men man NNS 31417 205 12 working work VBG 31417 205 13 in in IN 31417 205 14 the the DT 31417 205 15 gardens garden NNS 31417 205 16 near near RB 31417 205 17 . . . 31417 206 1 The the DT 31417 206 2 wires wire NNS 31417 206 3 of of IN 31417 206 4 the the DT 31417 206 5 bells bell NNS 31417 206 6 were be VBD 31417 206 7 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 206 8 moved move VBN 31417 206 9 , , , 31417 206 10 not not RB 31417 206 11 only only RB 31417 206 12 the the DT 31417 206 13 bells bell NNS 31417 206 14 and and CC 31417 206 15 the the DT 31417 206 16 clappers clapper NNS 31417 206 17 . . . 31417 207 1 The the DT 31417 207 2 bell bell NN 31417 207 3 - - HYPH 31417 207 4 handles handles NNP 31417 207 5 were be VBD 31417 207 6 never never RB 31417 207 7 observed observe VBN 31417 207 8 to to TO 31417 207 9 be be VB 31417 207 10 moved move VBN 31417 207 11 . . . 31417 208 1 The the DT 31417 208 2 ringing ringing NN 31417 208 3 lasted last VBD 31417 208 4 between between IN 31417 208 5 three three CD 31417 208 6 and and CC 31417 208 7 four four CD 31417 208 8 weeks week NNS 31417 208 9 , , , 31417 208 10 and and CC 31417 208 11 then then RB 31417 208 12 ceased cease VBD 31417 208 13 . . . 31417 209 1 Knockings knocking NNS 31417 209 2 in in IN 31417 209 3 considerable considerable JJ 31417 209 4 variety variety NN 31417 209 5 were be VBD 31417 209 6 also also RB 31417 209 7 heard hear VBN 31417 209 8 , , , 31417 209 9 and and CC 31417 209 10 a a DT 31417 209 11 few few JJ 31417 209 12 cases case NNS 31417 209 13 of of IN 31417 209 14 the the DT 31417 209 15 movement movement NN 31417 209 16 of of IN 31417 209 17 chairs chair NNS 31417 209 18 and and CC 31417 209 19 small small JJ 31417 209 20 articles article NNS 31417 209 21 , , , 31417 209 22 without without IN 31417 209 23 any any DT 31417 209 24 contact contact NN 31417 209 25 , , , 31417 209 26 also also RB 31417 209 27 occurred occur VBD 31417 209 28 . . . 31417 210 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 210 2 D. D. NNP 31417 210 3 was be VBD 31417 210 4 at at IN 31417 210 5 one one CD 31417 210 6 time time NN 31417 210 7 disposed dispose VBN 31417 210 8 to to TO 31417 210 9 think think VB 31417 210 10 that that IN 31417 210 11 the the DT 31417 210 12 housemaid housemaid NNP 31417 210 13 was be VBD 31417 210 14 in in IN 31417 210 15 some some DT 31417 210 16 way way NN 31417 210 17 connected connect VBN 31417 210 18 with with IN 31417 210 19 the the DT 31417 210 20 disturbances disturbance NNS 31417 210 21 , , , 31417 210 22 but but CC 31417 210 23 he -PRON- PRP 31417 210 24 could could MD 31417 210 25 trace trace VB 31417 210 26 no no DT 31417 210 27 evidence evidence NN 31417 210 28 . . . 31417 211 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 211 2 was be VBD 31417 211 3 a a DT 31417 211 4 young young JJ 31417 211 5 girl girl NN 31417 211 6 who who WP 31417 211 7 had have VBD 31417 211 8 not not RB 31417 211 9 been be VBN 31417 211 10 out out RP 31417 211 11 to to IN 31417 211 12 service service NN 31417 211 13 before before RB 31417 211 14 . . . 31417 212 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 212 2 got get VBD 31417 212 3 into into IN 31417 212 4 such such PDT 31417 212 5 a a DT 31417 212 6 state state NN 31417 212 7 of of IN 31417 212 8 nervous nervous JJ 31417 212 9 excitement excitement NN 31417 212 10 about about IN 31417 212 11 the the DT 31417 212 12 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 212 13 , , , 31417 212 14 that that IN 31417 212 15 brain brain NN 31417 212 16 fever fever NN 31417 212 17 or or CC 31417 212 18 something something NN 31417 212 19 serious serious JJ 31417 212 20 was be VBD 31417 212 21 feared fear VBN 31417 212 22 . . . 31417 213 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 213 2 had have VBD 31417 213 3 only only RB 31417 213 4 been be VBN 31417 213 5 in in IN 31417 213 6 the the DT 31417 213 7 house house NN 31417 213 8 a a DT 31417 213 9 few few JJ 31417 213 10 weeks week NNS 31417 213 11 previous previous JJ 31417 213 12 to to IN 31417 213 13 the the DT 31417 213 14 commencement commencement NN 31417 213 15 of of IN 31417 213 16 the the DT 31417 213 17 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 213 18 , , , 31417 213 19 and and CC 31417 213 20 nothing nothing NN 31417 213 21 occurred occur VBD 31417 213 22 after after IN 31417 213 23 she -PRON- PRP 31417 213 24 left leave VBD 31417 213 25 . . . 31417 214 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 214 2 D. D. NNP 31417 214 3 was be VBD 31417 214 4 , , , 31417 214 5 however however RB 31417 214 6 , , , 31417 214 7 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 214 8 convinced convince VBD 31417 214 9 that that IN 31417 214 10 she -PRON- PRP 31417 214 11 had have VBD 31417 214 12 nothing nothing NN 31417 214 13 to to TO 31417 214 14 do do VB 31417 214 15 voluntarily voluntarily RB 31417 214 16 with with IN 31417 214 17 the the DT 31417 214 18 bell bell NN 31417 214 19 - - HYPH 31417 214 20 ringing ringing NN 31417 214 21 . . . 31417 215 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 215 2 11 11 CD 31417 215 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 215 4 The the DT 31417 215 5 second second JJ 31417 215 6 paper paper NN 31417 215 7 by by IN 31417 215 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 215 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 215 10 is be VBZ 31417 215 11 devoted devote VBN 31417 215 12 exclusively exclusively RB 31417 215 13 to to IN 31417 215 14 some some DT 31417 215 15 " " `` 31417 215 16 strange strange JJ 31417 215 17 experiences experience NNS 31417 215 18 " " '' 31417 215 19 which which WDT 31417 215 20 occurred occur VBD 31417 215 21 several several JJ 31417 215 22 years year NNS 31417 215 23 previous previous JJ 31417 215 24 to to IN 31417 215 25 1891 1891 CD 31417 215 26 , , , 31417 215 27 at at IN 31417 215 28 the the DT 31417 215 29 village village NN 31417 215 30 of of IN 31417 215 31 Swanland Swanland NNP 31417 215 32 , , , 31417 215 33 a a DT 31417 215 34 few few JJ 31417 215 35 miles mile NNS 31417 215 36 from from IN 31417 215 37 Hull Hull NNP 31417 215 38 , , , 31417 215 39 in in IN 31417 215 40 the the DT 31417 215 41 East East NNP 31417 215 42 Riding Riding NNP 31417 215 43 of of IN 31417 215 44 Yorkshire Yorkshire NNP 31417 215 45 . . . 31417 216 1 The the DT 31417 216 2 evidence evidence NN 31417 216 3 is be VBZ 31417 216 4 that that DT 31417 216 5 of of IN 31417 216 6 John John NNP 31417 216 7 Bristow Bristow NNP 31417 216 8 , , , 31417 216 9 who who WP 31417 216 10 states state VBZ 31417 216 11 he -PRON- PRP 31417 216 12 was be VBD 31417 216 13 an an DT 31417 216 14 eye eye NN 31417 216 15 - - HYPH 31417 216 16 witness witness NN 31417 216 17 . . . 31417 217 1 There there EX 31417 217 2 were be VBD 31417 217 3 no no DT 31417 217 4 intellectual intellectual JJ 31417 217 5 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 217 6 , , , 31417 217 7 nothing nothing NN 31417 217 8 but but IN 31417 217 9 the the DT 31417 217 10 apparently apparently RB 31417 217 11 meaningless meaningless JJ 31417 217 12 throwing throw VBG 31417 217 13 about about IN 31417 217 14 of of IN 31417 217 15 pieces piece NNS 31417 217 16 of of IN 31417 217 17 wood wood NN 31417 217 18 -- -- : 31417 217 19 directed direct VBN 31417 217 20 , , , 31417 217 21 however however RB 31417 217 22 , , , 31417 217 23 by by IN 31417 217 24 some some DT 31417 217 25 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 217 26 , , , 31417 217 27 so so IN 31417 217 28 as as IN 31417 217 29 to to TO 31417 217 30 attract attract VB 31417 217 31 attention attention NN 31417 217 32 without without IN 31417 217 33 doing do VBG 31417 217 34 harm harm NN 31417 217 35 . . . 31417 218 1 Here here RB 31417 218 2 again again RB 31417 218 3 what what WDT 31417 218 4 value value NN 31417 218 5 the the DT 31417 218 6 case case NN 31417 218 7 has have VBZ 31417 218 8 rests rest NNS 31417 218 9 almost almost RB 31417 218 10 solely solely RB 31417 218 11 on on IN 31417 218 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 218 13 having have VBG 31417 218 14 received receive VBN 31417 218 15 the the DT 31417 218 16 critical critical JJ 31417 218 17 study study NN 31417 218 18 of of IN 31417 218 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 219 1 Myers myer NNS 31417 219 2 . . . 31417 220 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 220 2 12 12 CD 31417 220 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 220 4 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 220 5 : : : 31417 220 6 [ [ -LRB- 31417 220 7 1 1 CD 31417 220 8 ] ] -RRB- 31417 220 9 Report Report NNP 31417 220 10 of of IN 31417 220 11 the the DT 31417 220 12 Committee Committee NNP 31417 220 13 of of IN 31417 220 14 the the DT 31417 220 15 London London NNP 31417 220 16 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 220 17 Society Society NNP 31417 220 18 , , , 31417 220 19 p. p. NN 31417 220 20 228 228 CD 31417 220 21 . . . 31417 221 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 221 2 2 2 LS 31417 221 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 221 4 Report Report NNP 31417 221 5 on on IN 31417 221 6 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 221 7 of of IN 31417 221 8 the the DT 31417 221 9 Committee Committee NNP 31417 221 10 of of IN 31417 221 11 the the DT 31417 221 12 London London NNP 31417 221 13 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 221 14 Society Society NNP 31417 221 15 , , , 31417 221 16 together together RB 31417 221 17 with with IN 31417 221 18 the the DT 31417 221 19 Evidence evidence NN 31417 221 20 , , , 31417 221 21 Oral Oral NNP 31417 221 22 and and CC 31417 221 23 Written Written NNP 31417 221 24 , , , 31417 221 25 and and CC 31417 221 26 a a DT 31417 221 27 Selection Selection NNP 31417 221 28 from from IN 31417 221 29 the the DT 31417 221 30 Correspondence Correspondence NNP 31417 221 31 . . . 31417 222 1 Two two CD 31417 222 2 editions edition NNS 31417 222 3 have have VBP 31417 222 4 been be VBN 31417 222 5 published publish VBN 31417 222 6 . . . 31417 223 1 Both both DT 31417 223 2 are be VBP 31417 223 3 out out IN 31417 223 4 of of IN 31417 223 5 print print NN 31417 223 6 . . . 31417 224 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 224 2 3 3 LS 31417 224 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 224 4 Report Report NNP 31417 224 5 , , , 31417 224 6 & & CC 31417 224 7 c. c. NNP 31417 224 8 , , , 31417 224 9 pp pp NNP 31417 224 10 . . . 31417 225 1 7 7 CD 31417 225 2 - - SYM 31417 225 3 13 13 CD 31417 225 4 . . . 31417 226 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 226 2 4 4 CD 31417 226 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 226 4 Report Report NNP 31417 226 5 , , , 31417 226 6 & & CC 31417 226 7 c. c. NNP 31417 226 8 , , , 31417 226 9 pp pp NNP 31417 226 10 . . . 31417 227 1 390 390 CD 31417 227 2 - - SYM 31417 227 3 391 391 CD 31417 227 4 . . . 31417 228 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 228 2 5 5 CD 31417 228 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 228 4 _ _ NNP 31417 228 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 228 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 228 7 _ _ NNP 31417 228 8 , , , 31417 228 9 vol vol NNP 31417 228 10 . . . 31417 229 1 i. i. NNP 31417 229 2 p. p. NN 31417 229 3 240 240 CD 31417 229 4 [ [ -LRB- 31417 229 5 6 6 CD 31417 229 6 ] ] -RRB- 31417 229 7 See See NNP 31417 229 8 _ _ NNP 31417 229 9 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 229 10 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 229 11 _ _ NNP 31417 229 12 , , , 31417 229 13 vol vol NNP 31417 229 14 . . . 31417 230 1 iv iv XX 31417 230 2 . . . 31417 231 1 pp pp NNP 31417 231 2 . . . 31417 232 1 29 29 CD 31417 232 2 - - SYM 31417 232 3 33 33 CD 31417 232 4 . . . 31417 233 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 233 2 7 7 LS 31417 233 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 233 4 See See NNP 31417 233 5 _ _ NNP 31417 233 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 233 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 233 8 _ _ NNP 31417 233 9 , , , 31417 233 10 vol vol NNP 31417 233 11 . . . 31417 234 1 iv iv XX 31417 234 2 . . . 31417 235 1 pp pp NNP 31417 235 2 . . . 31417 236 1 33 33 CD 31417 236 2 - - SYM 31417 236 3 35 35 CD 31417 236 4 . . . 31417 237 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 237 2 8 8 CD 31417 237 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 237 4 Vol Vol NNP 31417 237 5 . . . 31417 238 1 vii vii NN 31417 238 2 . . . 31417 239 1 pp pp NNP 31417 239 2 . . . 31417 240 1 146 146 CD 31417 240 2 - - SYM 31417 240 3 198 198 CD 31417 240 4 and and CC 31417 240 5 pp pp NNP 31417 240 6 . . . 31417 241 1 383 383 CD 31417 241 2 - - SYM 31417 241 3 394 394 CD 31417 241 4 . . . 31417 242 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 242 2 9 9 CD 31417 242 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 242 4 For for IN 31417 242 5 full full JJ 31417 242 6 account account NN 31417 242 7 see see VBP 31417 242 8 _ _ NNP 31417 242 9 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 242 10 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 242 11 _ _ NNP 31417 242 12 , , , 31417 242 13 vol vol NNP 31417 242 14 . . . 31417 243 1 vii vii NN 31417 243 2 . . . 31417 244 1 pp pp NNP 31417 244 2 . . . 31417 245 1 159 159 CD 31417 245 2 - - SYM 31417 245 3 160 160 CD 31417 245 4 . . . 31417 246 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 246 2 10 10 CD 31417 246 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 246 4 _ _ NNP 31417 246 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 246 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 246 7 _ _ NNP 31417 246 8 , , , 31417 246 9 vol vol NNP 31417 246 10 . . . 31417 247 1 vii vii NN 31417 247 2 . . . 31417 248 1 p. p. NN 31417 248 2 160 160 CD 31417 248 3 . . . 31417 249 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 249 2 11 11 CD 31417 249 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 249 4 See see VB 31417 249 5 the the DT 31417 249 6 full full JJ 31417 249 7 account account NN 31417 249 8 in in IN 31417 249 9 Part Part NNP 31417 249 10 XIX XIX NNP 31417 249 11 . . . 31417 250 1 of of IN 31417 250 2 the the DT 31417 250 3 _ _ NNP 31417 250 4 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 250 5 of of IN 31417 250 6 the the DT 31417 250 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 250 8 _ _ NNP 31417 250 9 , , , 31417 250 10 which which WDT 31417 250 11 part part NN 31417 250 12 is be VBZ 31417 250 13 included include VBN 31417 250 14 in in IN 31417 250 15 vol vol NNP 31417 250 16 . . . 31417 251 1 vii vii NNP 31417 251 2 . . . 31417 251 3 , , , 31417 251 4 and and CC 31417 251 5 may may MD 31417 251 6 be be VB 31417 251 7 obtained obtain VBN 31417 251 8 separately separately RB 31417 251 9 for for IN 31417 251 10 2s 2s CD 31417 251 11 . . . 31417 252 1 6d 6d NNP 31417 252 2 . . . 31417 253 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 253 2 12 12 CD 31417 253 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 253 4 See See NNP 31417 253 5 _ _ NNP 31417 253 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 253 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 253 8 _ _ NNP 31417 253 9 , , , 31417 253 10 vol vol NNP 31417 253 11 . . . 31417 254 1 vii vii NN 31417 254 2 . . . 31417 255 1 pp pp NNP 31417 255 2 . . . 31417 256 1 383 383 CD 31417 256 2 - - SYM 31417 256 3 394 394 CD 31417 256 4 . . . 31417 257 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 257 2 III III NNP 31417 257 3 THE the DT 31417 257 4 PRODUCTION production NN 31417 257 5 OF of IN 31417 257 6 SOUND SOUND NNP 31417 257 7 WITHOUT without IN 31417 257 8 ANY any DT 31417 257 9 APPARENT apparent NN 31417 257 10 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 257 11 CAUSE CAUSE VBD 31417 257 12 If if IN 31417 257 13 the the DT 31417 257 14 tipping tipping NN 31417 257 15 of of IN 31417 257 16 small small JJ 31417 257 17 tables table NNS 31417 257 18 when when WRB 31417 257 19 the the DT 31417 257 20 hands hand NNS 31417 257 21 of of IN 31417 257 22 the the DT 31417 257 23 sitters sitter NNS 31417 257 24 are be VBP 31417 257 25 in in IN 31417 257 26 contact contact NN 31417 257 27 is be VBZ 31417 257 28 excepted except VBN 31417 257 29 -- -- : 31417 257 30 under under IN 31417 257 31 which which WDT 31417 257 32 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 257 33 it -PRON- PRP 31417 257 34 is be VBZ 31417 257 35 generally generally RB 31417 257 36 impossible impossible JJ 31417 257 37 to to TO 31417 257 38 determine determine VB 31417 257 39 whether whether IN 31417 257 40 the the DT 31417 257 41 result result NN 31417 257 42 is be VBZ 31417 257 43 psychical psychical JJ 31417 257 44 , , , 31417 257 45 or or CC 31417 257 46 due due JJ 31417 257 47 merely merely RB 31417 257 48 to to IN 31417 257 49 muscular muscular JJ 31417 257 50 action action NN 31417 257 51 unconsciously unconsciously RB 31417 257 52 exercised exercise VBN 31417 257 53 -- -- : 31417 257 54 the the DT 31417 257 55 production production NN 31417 257 56 of of IN 31417 257 57 raps rap NNS 31417 257 58 and and CC 31417 257 59 other other JJ 31417 257 60 sounds sound NNS 31417 257 61 is be VBZ 31417 257 62 the the DT 31417 257 63 most most RBS 31417 257 64 frequent frequent JJ 31417 257 65 of of IN 31417 257 66 the the DT 31417 257 67 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 257 68 under under IN 31417 257 69 consideration consideration NN 31417 257 70 . . . 31417 258 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 258 2 are be VBP 31417 258 3 , , , 31417 258 4 however however RB 31417 258 5 , , , 31417 258 6 generally generally RB 31417 258 7 so so RB 31417 258 8 intermixed intermixed JJ 31417 258 9 with with IN 31417 258 10 other other JJ 31417 258 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 258 12 that that IN 31417 258 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 258 14 is be VBZ 31417 258 15 difficult difficult JJ 31417 258 16 to to TO 31417 258 17 treat treat VB 31417 258 18 them -PRON- PRP 31417 258 19 separately separately RB 31417 258 20 . . . 31417 259 1 THE the DT 31417 259 2 DIALECTICAL DIALECTICAL NNP 31417 259 3 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31417 259 4 . . . 31417 260 1 In in IN 31417 260 2 the the DT 31417 260 3 extracts extract NNS 31417 260 4 from from IN 31417 260 5 the the DT 31417 260 6 Report Report NNP 31417 260 7 of of IN 31417 260 8 the the DT 31417 260 9 Committee Committee NNP 31417 260 10 of of IN 31417 260 11 the the DT 31417 260 12 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 260 13 Society Society NNP 31417 260 14 given give VBN 31417 260 15 in in IN 31417 260 16 the the DT 31417 260 17 preceding precede VBG 31417 260 18 chapter chapter NN 31417 260 19 , , , 31417 260 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 260 21 will will MD 31417 260 22 be be VB 31417 260 23 remembered remember VBN 31417 260 24 that that IN 31417 260 25 raps rap NNS 31417 260 26 and and CC 31417 260 27 other other JJ 31417 260 28 noises noise NNS 31417 260 29 are be VBP 31417 260 30 referred refer VBN 31417 260 31 to to IN 31417 260 32 as as IN 31417 260 33 being be VBG 31417 260 34 frequently frequently RB 31417 260 35 heard hear VBN 31417 260 36 , , , 31417 260 37 and and CC 31417 260 38 also also RB 31417 260 39 as as IN 31417 260 40 apparently apparently RB 31417 260 41 produced produce VBN 31417 260 42 by by IN 31417 260 43 an an DT 31417 260 44 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 260 45 agency agency NN 31417 260 46 . . . 31417 261 1 TESTIMONY testimony NN 31417 261 2 OF of IN 31417 261 3 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNP 31417 261 4 W. W. NNP 31417 261 5 F. F. NNP 31417 261 6 BARRETT BARRETT NNP 31417 261 7 , , , 31417 261 8 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 262 1 The the DT 31417 262 2 reader reader NN 31417 262 3 is be VBZ 31417 262 4 asked ask VBN 31417 262 5 to to TO 31417 262 6 refer refer VB 31417 262 7 to to IN 31417 262 8 the the DT 31417 262 9 general general JJ 31417 262 10 conditions condition NNS 31417 262 11 of of IN 31417 262 12 the the DT 31417 262 13 case case NN 31417 262 14 of of IN 31417 262 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 262 16 C. C. NNP 31417 262 17 testified testify VBD 31417 262 18 to to IN 31417 262 19 by by IN 31417 262 20 Professor Professor NNP 31417 262 21 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 262 22 in in IN 31417 262 23 the the DT 31417 262 24 previous previous JJ 31417 262 25 chapter chapter NN 31417 262 26 . . . 31417 263 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 263 2 says:-- says:-- : 31417 263 3 " " `` 31417 263 4 They -PRON- PRP 31417 263 5 ( ( -LRB- 31417 263 6 the the DT 31417 263 7 sounds sound NNS 31417 263 8 ) ) -RRB- 31417 263 9 came come VBD 31417 263 10 more more RBR 31417 263 11 readily readily RB 31417 263 12 and and CC 31417 263 13 more more RBR 31417 263 14 loudly loudly RB 31417 263 15 when when WRB 31417 263 16 music music NN 31417 263 17 was be VBD 31417 263 18 played play VBN 31417 263 19 , , , 31417 263 20 or or CC 31417 263 21 a a DT 31417 263 22 merry merry NN 31417 263 23 song song NN 31417 263 24 struck strike VBD 31417 263 25 up up RP 31417 263 26 . . . 31417 264 1 Usually usually RB 31417 264 2 they -PRON- PRP 31417 264 3 kept keep VBD 31417 264 4 time time NN 31417 264 5 with with IN 31417 264 6 the the DT 31417 264 7 music music NN 31417 264 8 , , , 31417 264 9 and and CC 31417 264 10 altogether altogether RB 31417 264 11 displayed display VBD 31417 264 12 a a DT 31417 264 13 singular singular JJ 31417 264 14 degree degree NN 31417 264 15 of of IN 31417 264 16 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 264 17 . . . 31417 265 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 31417 265 2 a a DT 31417 265 3 loud loud JJ 31417 265 4 rhythmic rhythmic JJ 31417 265 5 scraping scraping NN 31417 265 6 , , , 31417 265 7 as as IN 31417 265 8 of of IN 31417 265 9 a a DT 31417 265 10 violoncello violoncello NN 31417 265 11 bow bow NN 31417 265 12 on on IN 31417 265 13 a a DT 31417 265 14 piece piece NN 31417 265 15 of of IN 31417 265 16 wood wood NN 31417 265 17 , , , 31417 265 18 would would MD 31417 265 19 accompany accompany VB 31417 265 20 the the DT 31417 265 21 music music NN 31417 265 22 . . . 31417 266 1 Again again RB 31417 266 2 and and CC 31417 266 3 again again RB 31417 266 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 266 5 placed place VBD 31417 266 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 266 7 ear ear NN 31417 266 8 on on IN 31417 266 9 the the DT 31417 266 10 very very JJ 31417 266 11 spot spot NN 31417 266 12 on on IN 31417 266 13 the the DT 31417 266 14 table table NN 31417 266 15 whence whence NN 31417 266 16 this this DT 31417 266 17 rough rough JJ 31417 266 18 fiddling fiddling NN 31417 266 19 appeared appear VBD 31417 266 20 to to TO 31417 266 21 proceed proceed VB 31417 266 22 , , , 31417 266 23 and and CC 31417 266 24 felt feel VBD 31417 266 25 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 266 26 the the DT 31417 266 27 rhythmic rhythmic JJ 31417 266 28 vibration vibration NN 31417 266 29 of of IN 31417 266 30 the the DT 31417 266 31 table table NN 31417 266 32 , , , 31417 266 33 but but CC 31417 266 34 no no DT 31417 266 35 tangible tangible JJ 31417 266 36 cause cause NN 31417 266 37 was be VBD 31417 266 38 visible visible JJ 31417 266 39 either either CC 31417 266 40 above above IN 31417 266 41 or or CC 31417 266 42 below below IN 31417 266 43 the the DT 31417 266 44 table table NN 31417 266 45 .... .... . 31417 266 46 On on IN 31417 266 47 one one CD 31417 266 48 occasion occasion NN 31417 266 49 , , , 31417 266 50 when when WRB 31417 266 51 no no DT 31417 266 52 one one NN 31417 266 53 else else RB 31417 266 54 was be VBD 31417 266 55 in in IN 31417 266 56 the the DT 31417 266 57 room room NN 31417 266 58 , , , 31417 266 59 ... ... : 31417 267 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 267 2 asked ask VBD 31417 267 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 267 4 young young JJ 31417 267 5 friend friend NN 31417 267 6 the the DT 31417 267 7 medium medium NN 31417 267 8 to to TO 31417 267 9 put put VB 31417 267 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 267 11 hands hand NNS 31417 267 12 against against IN 31417 267 13 the the DT 31417 267 14 wall wall NN 31417 267 15 , , , 31417 267 16 and and CC 31417 267 17 see see VB 31417 267 18 how how WRB 31417 267 19 far far RB 31417 267 20 she -PRON- PRP 31417 267 21 could could MD 31417 267 22 stretch stretch VB 31417 267 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 267 24 feet foot NNS 31417 267 25 back back RB 31417 267 26 from from IN 31417 267 27 the the DT 31417 267 28 wall wall NN 31417 267 29 without without IN 31417 267 30 tumbling tumble VBG 31417 267 31 down down RP 31417 267 32 . . . 31417 268 1 This this DT 31417 268 2 she -PRON- PRP 31417 268 3 did do VBD 31417 268 4 , , , 31417 268 5 and and CC 31417 268 6 whilst whilst VB 31417 268 7 in in IN 31417 268 8 this this DT 31417 268 9 constrained constrained JJ 31417 268 10 position position NN 31417 268 11 -- -- : 31417 268 12 with with IN 31417 268 13 the the DT 31417 268 14 muscles muscle NNS 31417 268 15 of of IN 31417 268 16 arms arm NNS 31417 268 17 and and CC 31417 268 18 legs leg NNS 31417 268 19 all all DT 31417 268 20 in in IN 31417 268 21 tension tension NN 31417 268 22 -- -- : 31417 268 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 268 24 asked ask VBD 31417 268 25 for for IN 31417 268 26 the the DT 31417 268 27 knocks knock NNS 31417 268 28 to to TO 31417 268 29 come come VB 31417 268 30 . . . 31417 269 1 Immediately immediately RB 31417 269 2 a a DT 31417 269 3 brisk brisk JJ 31417 269 4 pattering pattering NN 31417 269 5 of of IN 31417 269 6 raps rap NNS 31417 269 7 followed follow VBD 31417 269 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 269 9 request request NN 31417 269 10 . . . 31417 270 1 All all PDT 31417 270 2 the the DT 31417 270 3 while while IN 31417 270 4 the the DT 31417 270 5 child child NN 31417 270 6 remained remain VBD 31417 270 7 quite quite RB 31417 270 8 motionless motionless JJ 31417 270 9 . . . 31417 271 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 271 2 reason reason NN 31417 271 3 in in IN 31417 271 4 making make VBG 31417 271 5 this this DT 31417 271 6 experiment experiment NN 31417 271 7 , , , 31417 271 8 was be VBD 31417 271 9 to to TO 31417 271 10 test test VB 31417 271 11 the the DT 31417 271 12 late late JJ 31417 271 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 271 14 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 271 15 's 's POS 31417 271 16 muscular muscular JJ 31417 271 17 theory theory NN 31417 271 18 of of IN 31417 271 19 the the DT 31417 271 20 cause cause NN 31417 271 21 of of IN 31417 271 22 the the DT 31417 271 23 sounds sound NNS 31417 271 24 . . . 31417 272 1 Had have VBD 31417 272 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 272 3 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 272 4 been be VBN 31417 272 5 present present JJ 31417 272 6 , , , 31417 272 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 272 8 feel feel VBP 31417 272 9 sure sure JJ 31417 272 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 272 11 would would MD 31417 272 12 have have VB 31417 272 13 admitted admit VBN 31417 272 14 that that IN 31417 272 15 here here RB 31417 272 16 at at IN 31417 272 17 any any DT 31417 272 18 rate rate NN 31417 272 19 that that WDT 31417 272 20 theory theory NN 31417 272 21 fell fall VBD 31417 272 22 through through RB 31417 272 23 . . . 31417 273 1 " " `` 31417 273 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 273 3 13 13 CD 31417 273 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 273 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 273 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 273 7 sums sum VBZ 31417 273 8 up up RP 31417 273 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 273 10 conclusions conclusion NNS 31417 273 11 on on IN 31417 273 12 this this DT 31417 273 13 case case NN 31417 273 14 thus:-- thus:-- : 31417 273 15 " " `` 31417 273 16 A a DT 31417 273 17 long long JJ 31417 273 18 and and CC 31417 273 19 careful careful JJ 31417 273 20 examination examination NN 31417 273 21 convinced convince VBD 31417 273 22 me -PRON- PRP 31417 273 23 that that DT 31417 273 24 trickery trickery NN 31417 273 25 on on IN 31417 273 26 the the DT 31417 273 27 part part NN 31417 273 28 of of IN 31417 273 29 the the DT 31417 273 30 child child NN 31417 273 31 was be VBD 31417 273 32 a a DT 31417 273 33 more more RBR 31417 273 34 improbable improbable JJ 31417 273 35 hypothesis hypothesis NN 31417 273 36 than than IN 31417 273 37 that that IN 31417 273 38 the the DT 31417 273 39 sounds sound NNS 31417 273 40 proceeded proceed VBN 31417 273 41 from from IN 31417 273 42 some some DT 31417 273 43 unknown unknown JJ 31417 273 44 agency agency NN 31417 273 45 . . . 31417 274 1 Nor nor CC 31417 274 2 could could MD 31417 274 3 the the DT 31417 274 4 sounds sound NNS 31417 274 5 be be VB 31417 274 6 accounted account VBN 31417 274 7 for for IN 31417 274 8 by by IN 31417 274 9 trickery trickery NN 31417 274 10 on on IN 31417 274 11 the the DT 31417 274 12 part part NN 31417 274 13 of of IN 31417 274 14 the the DT 31417 274 15 servants servant NNS 31417 274 16 in in IN 31417 274 17 the the DT 31417 274 18 house house NN 31417 274 19 , , , 31417 274 20 for for IN 31417 274 21 in in IN 31417 274 22 addition addition NN 31417 274 23 to to IN 31417 274 24 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 274 25 careful careful JJ 31417 274 26 inquiries inquiry NNS 31417 274 27 on on IN 31417 274 28 this this DT 31417 274 29 point point NN 31417 274 30 , , , 31417 274 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 274 32 C. C. NNP 31417 274 33 informed inform VBD 31417 274 34 me -PRON- PRP 31417 274 35 that that IN 31417 274 36 he -PRON- PRP 31417 274 37 had have VBD 31417 274 38 obtained obtain VBN 31417 274 39 the the DT 31417 274 40 raps rap NNS 31417 274 41 on on IN 31417 274 42 the the DT 31417 274 43 handle handle NN 31417 274 44 of of IN 31417 274 45 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 274 46 umbrella umbrella NN 31417 274 47 out out IN 31417 274 48 of of IN 31417 274 49 doors door NNS 31417 274 50 , , , 31417 274 51 when when WRB 31417 274 52 the the DT 31417 274 53 child child NN 31417 274 54 was be VBD 31417 274 55 by by IN 31417 274 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 274 57 side side NN 31417 274 58 ; ; : 31417 274 59 and and CC 31417 274 60 that that IN 31417 274 61 the the DT 31417 274 62 music music NN 31417 274 63 - - HYPH 31417 274 64 master master NN 31417 274 65 complained complain VBD 31417 274 66 of of IN 31417 274 67 raps rap NNS 31417 274 68 proceeding proceed VBG 31417 274 69 from from IN 31417 274 70 inside inside IN 31417 274 71 the the DT 31417 274 72 piano piano NN 31417 274 73 whenever whenever WRB 31417 274 74 the the DT 31417 274 75 child child NN 31417 274 76 was be VBD 31417 274 77 listless listless JJ 31417 274 78 or or CC 31417 274 79 inattentive inattentive JJ 31417 274 80 at at IN 31417 274 81 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 274 82 music music NN 31417 274 83 lesson lesson NN 31417 274 84 . . . 31417 275 1 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 275 2 C. C. NNP 31417 275 3 told tell VBD 31417 275 4 me -PRON- PRP 31417 275 5 that that IN 31417 275 6 almost almost RB 31417 275 7 every every DT 31417 275 8 night night NN 31417 275 9 she -PRON- PRP 31417 275 10 heard hear VBD 31417 275 11 the the DT 31417 275 12 raps rap NNS 31417 275 13 by by IN 31417 275 14 the the DT 31417 275 15 bedside bedside NN 31417 275 16 of of IN 31417 275 17 the the DT 31417 275 18 child child NN 31417 275 19 when when WRB 31417 275 20 she -PRON- PRP 31417 275 21 went go VBD 31417 275 22 to to TO 31417 275 23 bid bid VB 31417 275 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 275 25 good good JJ 31417 275 26 - - HYPH 31417 275 27 night night NN 31417 275 28 ; ; : 31417 275 29 and and CC 31417 275 30 that that IN 31417 275 31 after after IN 31417 275 32 she -PRON- PRP 31417 275 33 had have VBD 31417 275 34 left leave VBN 31417 275 35 the the DT 31417 275 36 room room NN 31417 275 37 and and CC 31417 275 38 partially partially RB 31417 275 39 closed close VBD 31417 275 40 the the DT 31417 275 41 door door NN 31417 275 42 , , , 31417 275 43 she -PRON- PRP 31417 275 44 would would MD 31417 275 45 hear hear VB 31417 275 46 quite quite PDT 31417 275 47 an an DT 31417 275 48 animated animate VBN 31417 275 49 conversation conversation NN 31417 275 50 going go VBG 31417 275 51 on on RP 31417 275 52 between between IN 31417 275 53 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 275 54 daughter daughter NN 31417 275 55 and and CC 31417 275 56 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 275 57 invisible invisible JJ 31417 275 58 companion companion NN 31417 275 59 , , , 31417 275 60 the the DT 31417 275 61 child child NN 31417 275 62 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 275 63 spelling spell VBG 31417 275 64 over over IN 31417 275 65 the the DT 31417 275 66 alphabet alphabet NN 31417 275 67 , , , 31417 275 68 and and CC 31417 275 69 the the DT 31417 275 70 raps rap NNS 31417 275 71 occurring occur VBG 31417 275 72 at at IN 31417 275 73 the the DT 31417 275 74 right right JJ 31417 275 75 letters letter NNS 31417 275 76 , , , 31417 275 77 and and CC 31417 275 78 the the DT 31417 275 79 child child NN 31417 275 80 thus thus RB 31417 275 81 obtaining obtain VBG 31417 275 82 with with IN 31417 275 83 surprising surprising JJ 31417 275 84 rapidity rapidity NN 31417 275 85 a a DT 31417 275 86 clue clue NN 31417 275 87 to to IN 31417 275 88 the the DT 31417 275 89 words word NNS 31417 275 90 spelt spell VBN 31417 275 91 out out RP 31417 275 92 . . . 31417 276 1 " " `` 31417 276 2 Still still RB 31417 276 3 more more RBR 31417 276 4 violently violently RB 31417 276 5 improbable improbable JJ 31417 276 6 is be VBZ 31417 276 7 the the DT 31417 276 8 supposition supposition NN 31417 276 9 that that IN 31417 276 10 the the DT 31417 276 11 parents parent NNS 31417 276 12 of of IN 31417 276 13 the the DT 31417 276 14 child child NN 31417 276 15 were be VBD 31417 276 16 at at IN 31417 276 17 the the DT 31417 276 18 bottom bottom NN 31417 276 19 of of IN 31417 276 20 the the DT 31417 276 21 mystery mystery NN 31417 276 22 , , , 31417 276 23 stimulated stimulate VBN 31417 276 24 by by IN 31417 276 25 a a DT 31417 276 26 desire desire NN 31417 276 27 to to TO 31417 276 28 impress impress VB 31417 276 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 276 30 friends friend NNS 31417 276 31 with with IN 31417 276 32 the the DT 31417 276 33 wonderful wonderful JJ 31417 276 34 but but CC 31417 276 35 imaginary imaginary JJ 31417 276 36 gifts gift NNS 31417 276 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 276 38 child child NN 31417 276 39 possessed possess VBD 31417 276 40 . . . 31417 277 1 The the DT 31417 277 2 presence presence NN 31417 277 3 of of IN 31417 277 4 the the DT 31417 277 5 parents parent NNS 31417 277 6 was be VBD 31417 277 7 not not RB 31417 277 8 necessary necessary JJ 31417 277 9 for for IN 31417 277 10 the the DT 31417 277 11 occurrence occurrence NN 31417 277 12 of of IN 31417 277 13 the the DT 31417 277 14 sounds sound NNS 31417 277 15 , , , 31417 277 16 which which WDT 31417 277 17 , , , 31417 277 18 as as IN 31417 277 19 I -PRON- PRP 31417 277 20 have have VBP 31417 277 21 said say VBD 31417 277 22 , , , 31417 277 23 often often RB 31417 277 24 took take VBD 31417 277 25 place place NN 31417 277 26 when when WRB 31417 277 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 277 28 was be VBD 31417 277 29 the the DT 31417 277 30 only only JJ 31417 277 31 person person NN 31417 277 32 in in IN 31417 277 33 the the DT 31417 277 34 room room NN 31417 277 35 besides besides IN 31417 277 36 the the DT 31417 277 37 child child NN 31417 277 38 . . . 31417 278 1 " " `` 31417 278 2 Hallucination Hallucination NNP 31417 278 3 was be VBD 31417 278 4 the the DT 31417 278 5 explanation explanation NN 31417 278 6 which which WDT 31417 278 7 suggested suggest VBD 31417 278 8 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 278 9 to to IN 31417 278 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 278 11 own own JJ 31417 278 12 mind mind NN 31417 278 13 when when WRB 31417 278 14 first first RB 31417 278 15 I -PRON- PRP 31417 278 16 heard hear VBD 31417 278 17 of of IN 31417 278 18 the the DT 31417 278 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 278 20 , , , 31417 278 21 but but CC 31417 278 22 was be VBD 31417 278 23 dismissed dismiss VBN 31417 278 24 as as IN 31417 278 25 wholly wholly RB 31417 278 26 inapplicable inapplicable JJ 31417 278 27 after after IN 31417 278 28 the the DT 31417 278 29 first first JJ 31417 278 30 day day NN 31417 278 31 's 's POS 31417 278 32 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 278 33 ; ; : 31417 278 34 nor nor CC 31417 278 35 do do VBP 31417 278 36 I -PRON- PRP 31417 278 37 think think VB 31417 278 38 that that IN 31417 278 39 any any DT 31417 278 40 one one PRP 31417 278 41 could could MD 31417 278 42 maintain maintain VB 31417 278 43 that that IN 31417 278 44 different different JJ 31417 278 45 people people NNS 31417 278 46 , , , 31417 278 47 individually individually RB 31417 278 48 and and CC 31417 278 49 collectively collectively RB 31417 278 50 , , , 31417 278 51 for for IN 31417 278 52 some some DT 31417 278 53 weeks week NNS 31417 278 54 , , , 31417 278 55 thought think VBD 31417 278 56 they -PRON- PRP 31417 278 57 heard hear VBD 31417 278 58 and and CC 31417 278 59 saw see VBD 31417 278 60 a a DT 31417 278 61 series series NN 31417 278 62 of of IN 31417 278 63 sounds sound NNS 31417 278 64 and and CC 31417 278 65 motions motion NNS 31417 278 66 which which WDT 31417 278 67 had have VBD 31417 278 68 no no DT 31417 278 69 objective objective JJ 31417 278 70 existence existence NN 31417 278 71 . . . 31417 279 1 " " `` 31417 279 2 No no UH 31417 279 3 ! ! . 31417 280 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 280 2 was be VBD 31417 280 3 then then RB 31417 280 4 , , , 31417 280 5 and and CC 31417 280 6 am be VBP 31417 280 7 still still RB 31417 280 8 , , , 31417 280 9 morally morally RB 31417 280 10 certain certain JJ 31417 280 11 that that IN 31417 280 12 the the DT 31417 280 13 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 280 14 had have VBD 31417 280 15 a a DT 31417 280 16 real real JJ 31417 280 17 existence existence NN 31417 280 18 outside outside IN 31417 280 19 oneself oneself PRP 31417 280 20 , , , 31417 280 21 and and CC 31417 280 22 that that IN 31417 280 23 they -PRON- PRP 31417 280 24 were be VBD 31417 280 25 not not RB 31417 280 26 produced produce VBN 31417 280 27 by by IN 31417 280 28 trickery trickery NN 31417 280 29 or or CC 31417 280 30 by by IN 31417 280 31 known know VBN 31417 280 32 causes cause NNS 31417 280 33 . . . 31417 281 1 Hence hence RB 31417 281 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 281 3 could could MD 31417 281 4 come come VB 31417 281 5 to to IN 31417 281 6 no no DT 31417 281 7 other other JJ 31417 281 8 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 281 9 than than IN 31417 281 10 that that IN 31417 281 11 we -PRON- PRP 31417 281 12 had have VBD 31417 281 13 here here RB 31417 281 14 a a DT 31417 281 15 class class NN 31417 281 16 of of IN 31417 281 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 281 18 wholly wholly RB 31417 281 19 new new JJ 31417 281 20 to to IN 31417 281 21 science science NN 31417 281 22 . . . 31417 282 1 " " `` 31417 282 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 282 3 14 14 CD 31417 282 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 282 5 After after IN 31417 282 6 some some DT 31417 282 7 three three CD 31417 282 8 months month NNS 31417 282 9 the the DT 31417 282 10 sounds sound NNS 31417 282 11 ceased cease VBD 31417 282 12 as as RB 31417 282 13 unexpectedly unexpectedly RB 31417 282 14 as as IN 31417 282 15 they -PRON- PRP 31417 282 16 had have VBD 31417 282 17 commenced commence VBN 31417 282 18 . . . 31417 283 1 There there EX 31417 283 2 is be VBZ 31417 283 3 one one CD 31417 283 4 form form NN 31417 283 5 of of IN 31417 283 6 sound sound JJ 31417 283 7 manifestation manifestation NN 31417 283 8 to to TO 31417 283 9 which which WDT 31417 283 10 no no DT 31417 283 11 allusion allusion NN 31417 283 12 has have VBZ 31417 283 13 been be VBN 31417 283 14 made make VBN 31417 283 15 -- -- : 31417 283 16 what what WP 31417 283 17 is be VBZ 31417 283 18 called call VBN 31417 283 19 the the DT 31417 283 20 " " `` 31417 283 21 Direct Direct NNP 31417 283 22 Voice Voice NNP 31417 283 23 . . . 31417 283 24 " " '' 31417 284 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 284 2 is be VBZ 31417 284 3 alleged allege VBN 31417 284 4 to to TO 31417 284 5 be be VB 31417 284 6 of of IN 31417 284 7 frequent frequent JJ 31417 284 8 occurrence occurrence NN 31417 284 9 in in IN 31417 284 10 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 284 11 circles circle NNS 31417 284 12 . . . 31417 285 1 Articulate articulate JJ 31417 285 2 words word NNS 31417 285 3 are be VBP 31417 285 4 , , , 31417 285 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 285 6 is be VBZ 31417 285 7 stated state VBN 31417 285 8 , , , 31417 285 9 spoken speak VBN 31417 285 10 " " `` 31417 285 11 direct direct JJ 31417 285 12 , , , 31417 285 13 " " '' 31417 285 14 not not RB 31417 285 15 through through IN 31417 285 16 the the DT 31417 285 17 voice voice NN 31417 285 18 organs organ NNS 31417 285 19 of of IN 31417 285 20 any any DT 31417 285 21 person person NN 31417 285 22 present present JJ 31417 285 23 . . . 31417 286 1 The the DT 31417 286 2 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 286 3 , , , 31417 286 4 so so RB 31417 286 5 far far RB 31417 286 6 as as IN 31417 286 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 286 8 have have VBP 31417 286 9 heard hear VBN 31417 286 10 , , , 31417 286 11 occurs occur VBZ 31417 286 12 only only RB 31417 286 13 in in IN 31417 286 14 darkness darkness NN 31417 286 15 -- -- : 31417 286 16 and and CC 31417 286 17 is be VBZ 31417 286 18 an an DT 31417 286 19 objective objective JJ 31417 286 20 voice voice NN 31417 286 21 audible audible JJ 31417 286 22 alike alike RB 31417 286 23 to to IN 31417 286 24 every every DT 31417 286 25 one one CD 31417 286 26 present present NN 31417 286 27 . . . 31417 287 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 287 2 corresponds correspond VBZ 31417 287 3 to to IN 31417 287 4 the the DT 31417 287 5 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 287 6 of of IN 31417 287 7 " " `` 31417 287 8 direct direct JJ 31417 287 9 writing writing NN 31417 287 10 . . . 31417 287 11 " " '' 31417 288 1 But but CC 31417 288 2 no no DT 31417 288 3 attempt attempt NN 31417 288 4 that that IN 31417 288 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 288 6 am be VBP 31417 288 7 aware aware JJ 31417 288 8 of of IN 31417 288 9 has have VBZ 31417 288 10 been be VBN 31417 288 11 made make VBN 31417 288 12 to to TO 31417 288 13 treat treat VB 31417 288 14 the the DT 31417 288 15 matter matter NN 31417 288 16 scientifically scientifically RB 31417 288 17 . . . 31417 289 1 One one CD 31417 289 2 of of IN 31417 289 3 the the DT 31417 289 4 earliest early JJS 31417 289 5 alleged allege VBN 31417 289 6 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 289 7 of of IN 31417 289 8 this this DT 31417 289 9 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 289 10 took take VBD 31417 289 11 place place NN 31417 289 12 in in IN 31417 289 13 London London NNP 31417 289 14 , , , 31417 289 15 at at IN 31417 289 16 a a DT 31417 289 17 private private JJ 31417 289 18 seance seance NN 31417 289 19 at at IN 31417 289 20 which which WDT 31417 289 21 I -PRON- PRP 31417 289 22 was be VBD 31417 289 23 present present JJ 31417 289 24 at at IN 31417 289 25 the the DT 31417 289 26 house house NN 31417 289 27 of of IN 31417 289 28 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 289 29 Thos Thos NNP 31417 289 30 . . . 31417 290 1 Everitt Everitt NNP 31417 290 2 , , , 31417 290 3 who who WP 31417 290 4 departed depart VBD 31417 290 5 this this DT 31417 290 6 life life NN 31417 290 7 in in IN 31417 290 8 August August NNP 31417 290 9 of of IN 31417 290 10 last last JJ 31417 290 11 year year NN 31417 290 12 , , , 31417 290 13 and and CC 31417 290 14 who who WP 31417 290 15 was be VBD 31417 290 16 one one CD 31417 290 17 of of IN 31417 290 18 the the DT 31417 290 19 most most RBS 31417 290 20 prominent prominent JJ 31417 290 21 London London NNP 31417 290 22 spiritualists spiritualist NNS 31417 290 23 , , , 31417 290 24 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 290 25 Everitt Everitt NNP 31417 290 26 being be VBG 31417 290 27 the the DT 31417 290 28 medium medium NN 31417 290 29 . . . 31417 291 1 Some some DT 31417 291 2 little little JJ 31417 291 3 time time NN 31417 291 4 later later RB 31417 291 5 , , , 31417 291 6 at at IN 31417 291 7 a a DT 31417 291 8 similar similar JJ 31417 291 9 seance seance NN 31417 291 10 at at IN 31417 291 11 the the DT 31417 291 12 same same JJ 31417 291 13 house house NN 31417 291 14 , , , 31417 291 15 the the DT 31417 291 16 sitting sitting NN 31417 291 17 was be VBD 31417 291 18 terminated terminate VBN 31417 291 19 by by IN 31417 291 20 the the DT 31417 291 21 singing singing NN 31417 291 22 of of IN 31417 291 23 a a DT 31417 291 24 hymn hymn NN 31417 291 25 by by IN 31417 291 26 three three CD 31417 291 27 or or CC 31417 291 28 four four CD 31417 291 29 soft soft JJ 31417 291 30 , , , 31417 291 31 gentle gentle JJ 31417 291 32 voices voice NNS 31417 291 33 , , , 31417 291 34 purporting purport VBG 31417 291 35 to to TO 31417 291 36 be be VB 31417 291 37 " " `` 31417 291 38 direct direct JJ 31417 291 39 " " '' 31417 291 40 voices voice NNS 31417 291 41 , , , 31417 291 42 which which WDT 31417 291 43 sounded sound VBD 31417 291 44 as as IN 31417 291 45 if if IN 31417 291 46 they -PRON- PRP 31417 291 47 proceeded proceed VBD 31417 291 48 from from IN 31417 291 49 the the DT 31417 291 50 top top NN 31417 291 51 of of IN 31417 291 52 the the DT 31417 291 53 room room NN 31417 291 54 close close RB 31417 291 55 to to IN 31417 291 56 the the DT 31417 291 57 ceiling ceiling NN 31417 291 58 . . . 31417 292 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 292 2 were be VBD 31417 292 3 certainly certainly RB 31417 292 4 not not RB 31417 292 5 the the DT 31417 292 6 voices voice NNS 31417 292 7 of of IN 31417 292 8 any any DT 31417 292 9 of of IN 31417 292 10 the the DT 31417 292 11 company company NN 31417 292 12 present present JJ 31417 292 13 . . . 31417 293 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 293 2 was be VBD 31417 293 3 one one CD 31417 293 4 of of IN 31417 293 5 the the DT 31417 293 6 most most RBS 31417 293 7 beautiful beautiful JJ 31417 293 8 and and CC 31417 293 9 touching touching JJ 31417 293 10 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 293 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 293 12 ever ever RB 31417 293 13 experienced experience VBD 31417 293 14 . . . 31417 294 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 294 2 can can MD 31417 294 3 only only RB 31417 294 4 compare compare VB 31417 294 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 294 6 to to IN 31417 294 7 the the DT 31417 294 8 singing singing NN 31417 294 9 of of IN 31417 294 10 a a DT 31417 294 11 choir choir NN 31417 294 12 of of IN 31417 294 13 boys boy NNS 31417 294 14 ' ' POS 31417 294 15 voices voice NNS 31417 294 16 , , , 31417 294 17 high high RB 31417 294 18 up up RP 31417 294 19 out out IN 31417 294 20 of of IN 31417 294 21 sight sight NN 31417 294 22 in in IN 31417 294 23 Truro Truro NNP 31417 294 24 Cathedral Cathedral NNP 31417 294 25 , , , 31417 294 26 which which WDT 31417 294 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 294 28 had have VBD 31417 294 29 heard hear VBN 31417 294 30 many many JJ 31417 294 31 years year NNS 31417 294 32 before before RB 31417 294 33 . . . 31417 295 1 The the DT 31417 295 2 seances seance NNS 31417 295 3 at at IN 31417 295 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 295 5 Everitt Everitt NNP 31417 295 6 's 's POS 31417 295 7 were be VBD 31417 295 8 conducted conduct VBN 31417 295 9 in in IN 31417 295 10 an an DT 31417 295 11 exclusively exclusively RB 31417 295 12 religious religious JJ 31417 295 13 tone tone NN 31417 295 14 , , , 31417 295 15 and and CC 31417 295 16 afforded afford VBD 31417 295 17 no no DT 31417 295 18 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 295 19 for for IN 31417 295 20 obtaining obtain VBG 31417 295 21 scientific scientific JJ 31417 295 22 evidence evidence NN 31417 295 23 . . . 31417 296 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 296 2 is be VBZ 31417 296 3 much much JJ 31417 296 4 to to TO 31417 296 5 be be VB 31417 296 6 desired desire VBN 31417 296 7 that that IN 31417 296 8 a a DT 31417 296 9 careful careful JJ 31417 296 10 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 296 11 should should MD 31417 296 12 be be VB 31417 296 13 made make VBN 31417 296 14 into into IN 31417 296 15 the the DT 31417 296 16 reality reality NN 31417 296 17 of of IN 31417 296 18 so so RB 31417 296 19 interesting interesting JJ 31417 296 20 a a DT 31417 296 21 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 296 22 . . . 31417 297 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 297 2 : : : 31417 297 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 297 4 13 13 CD 31417 297 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 297 6 _ _ NNP 31417 297 7 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 297 8 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 297 9 _ _ NNP 31417 297 10 , , , 31417 297 11 vol vol NNP 31417 297 12 . . . 31417 298 1 iv iv XX 31417 298 2 . . . 31417 299 1 pp pp NNP 31417 299 2 . . . 31417 300 1 29 29 CD 31417 300 2 - - SYM 31417 300 3 30 30 CD 31417 300 4 . . . 31417 301 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 301 2 14 14 CD 31417 301 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 301 4 _ _ NNP 31417 301 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 301 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 301 7 _ _ NNP 31417 301 8 , , , 31417 301 9 vol vol NNP 31417 301 10 . . . 31417 302 1 iv iv XX 31417 302 2 . . . 31417 303 1 p. p. NN 31417 303 2 31 31 CD 31417 303 3 . . . 31417 304 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 304 2 IV IV NNP 31417 304 3 THE the DT 31417 304 4 APPEARANCE APPEARANCE NNP 31417 304 5 OF of IN 31417 304 6 LIGHT LIGHT NNP 31417 304 7 WITHOUT without IN 31417 304 8 ANY any DT 31417 304 9 APPARENT apparent NN 31417 304 10 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 304 11 CAUSE CAUSE VBD 31417 304 12 The the DT 31417 304 13 appearance appearance NN 31417 304 14 of of IN 31417 304 15 Lights Lights NNPS 31417 304 16 at at IN 31417 304 17 Spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 304 18 circles circle NNS 31417 304 19 , , , 31417 304 20 apparently apparently RB 31417 304 21 not not RB 31417 304 22 due due JJ 31417 304 23 to to IN 31417 304 24 any any DT 31417 304 25 physical physical JJ 31417 304 26 cause cause NN 31417 304 27 , , , 31417 304 28 is be VBZ 31417 304 29 very very RB 31417 304 30 widely widely RB 31417 304 31 asserted assert VBN 31417 304 32 . . . 31417 305 1 The the DT 31417 305 2 character character NN 31417 305 3 of of IN 31417 305 4 the the DT 31417 305 5 Lights Lights NNPS 31417 305 6 is be VBZ 31417 305 7 as as RB 31417 305 8 varied varied JJ 31417 305 9 as as IN 31417 305 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 305 11 is be VBZ 31417 305 12 possible possible JJ 31417 305 13 to to TO 31417 305 14 imagine imagine VB 31417 305 15 . . . 31417 306 1 Faint faint JJ 31417 306 2 , , , 31417 306 3 cloudy cloudy JJ 31417 306 4 , , , 31417 306 5 indefinite indefinite JJ 31417 306 6 luminous luminous JJ 31417 306 7 appearances appearance NNS 31417 306 8 -- -- : 31417 306 9 brilliant brilliant JJ 31417 306 10 stars star NNS 31417 306 11 which which WDT 31417 306 12 move move VBP 31417 306 13 or or CC 31417 306 14 hover hover VB 31417 306 15 among among IN 31417 306 16 the the DT 31417 306 17 sitters sitter NNS 31417 306 18 -- -- : 31417 306 19 globes globe NNS 31417 306 20 or or CC 31417 306 21 balls ball NNS 31417 306 22 of of IN 31417 306 23 light light NN 31417 306 24 , , , 31417 306 25 like like IN 31417 306 26 illuminated illuminate VBN 31417 306 27 ostrich ostrich NN 31417 306 28 eggs egg NNS 31417 306 29 , , , 31417 306 30 or or CC 31417 306 31 spheres sphere NNS 31417 306 32 of of IN 31417 306 33 mother mother NN 31417 306 34 - - HYPH 31417 306 35 of of IN 31417 306 36 - - HYPH 31417 306 37 pearl pearl NN 31417 306 38 lit light VBN 31417 306 39 up up RP 31417 306 40 from from IN 31417 306 41 within within IN 31417 306 42 -- -- : 31417 306 43 pillars pillar NNS 31417 306 44 of of IN 31417 306 45 light light NN 31417 306 46 -- -- : 31417 306 47 are be VBP 31417 306 48 some some DT 31417 306 49 of of IN 31417 306 50 the the DT 31417 306 51 many many JJ 31417 306 52 forms form NNS 31417 306 53 which which WDT 31417 306 54 this this DT 31417 306 55 manifestation manifestation NN 31417 306 56 takes take VBZ 31417 306 57 . . . 31417 307 1 But but CC 31417 307 2 anything anything NN 31417 307 3 approaching approach VBG 31417 307 4 to to IN 31417 307 5 scientific scientific JJ 31417 307 6 evidence evidence NN 31417 307 7 of of IN 31417 307 8 the the DT 31417 307 9 reality reality NN 31417 307 10 of of IN 31417 307 11 the the DT 31417 307 12 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 307 13 is be VBZ 31417 307 14 singularly singularly RB 31417 307 15 scarce scarce JJ 31417 307 16 . . . 31417 308 1 And and CC 31417 308 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 308 3 am be VBP 31417 308 4 not not RB 31417 308 5 aware aware JJ 31417 308 6 that that IN 31417 308 7 anything anything NN 31417 308 8 has have VBZ 31417 308 9 ever ever RB 31417 308 10 been be VBN 31417 308 11 done do VBN 31417 308 12 towards towards IN 31417 308 13 testing testing NN 31417 308 14 or or CC 31417 308 15 endeavouring endeavour VBG 31417 308 16 to to TO 31417 308 17 ascertain ascertain VB 31417 308 18 the the DT 31417 308 19 nature nature NN 31417 308 20 of of IN 31417 308 21 the the DT 31417 308 22 light light NN 31417 308 23 . . . 31417 309 1 One one CD 31417 309 2 reason reason NN 31417 309 3 for for IN 31417 309 4 this this DT 31417 309 5 is be VBZ 31417 309 6 , , , 31417 309 7 no no RB 31417 309 8 doubt doubt RB 31417 309 9 , , , 31417 309 10 that that DT 31417 309 11 to to TO 31417 309 12 investigate investigate VB 31417 309 13 light light JJ 31417 309 14 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 309 15 , , , 31417 309 16 the the DT 31417 309 17 exclusion exclusion NN 31417 309 18 of of IN 31417 309 19 other other JJ 31417 309 20 light light NN 31417 309 21 is be VBZ 31417 309 22 obviously obviously RB 31417 309 23 requisite requisite JJ 31417 309 24 . . . 31417 310 1 Hence hence RB 31417 310 2 the the DT 31417 310 3 necessity necessity NN 31417 310 4 for for IN 31417 310 5 dark dark JJ 31417 310 6 seances seance NNS 31417 310 7 . . . 31417 311 1 The the DT 31417 311 2 objection objection NN 31417 311 3 to to IN 31417 311 4 a a DT 31417 311 5 dark dark JJ 31417 311 6 seance seance NN 31417 311 7 in in IN 31417 311 8 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 311 9 can can MD 31417 311 10 of of IN 31417 311 11 course course NN 31417 311 12 have have VB 31417 311 13 no no DT 31417 311 14 scientific scientific JJ 31417 311 15 basis basis NN 31417 311 16 . . . 31417 312 1 But but CC 31417 312 2 a a DT 31417 312 3 strong strong JJ 31417 312 4 feeling feeling NN 31417 312 5 against against IN 31417 312 6 dark dark JJ 31417 312 7 seances seance NNS 31417 312 8 has have VBZ 31417 312 9 arisen arise VBN 31417 312 10 from from IN 31417 312 11 the the DT 31417 312 12 abuses abuse NNS 31417 312 13 to to TO 31417 312 14 which which WDT 31417 312 15 they -PRON- PRP 31417 312 16 have have VBP 31417 312 17 led lead VBN 31417 312 18 . . . 31417 313 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 313 2 is be VBZ 31417 313 3 possible possible JJ 31417 313 4 that that IN 31417 313 5 the the DT 31417 313 6 extent extent NN 31417 313 7 of of IN 31417 313 8 the the DT 31417 313 9 evil evil NN 31417 313 10 has have VBZ 31417 313 11 been be VBN 31417 313 12 exaggerated exaggerate VBN 31417 313 13 , , , 31417 313 14 and and CC 31417 313 15 has have VBZ 31417 313 16 thus thus RB 31417 313 17 produced produce VBN 31417 313 18 an an DT 31417 313 19 exaggerated exaggerated JJ 31417 313 20 prejudice prejudice NN 31417 313 21 against against IN 31417 313 22 darkness darkness NN 31417 313 23 as as IN 31417 313 24 a a DT 31417 313 25 condition condition NN 31417 313 26 . . . 31417 314 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 314 2 is be VBZ 31417 314 3 , , , 31417 314 4 however however RB 31417 314 5 , , , 31417 314 6 safe safe JJ 31417 314 7 to to TO 31417 314 8 say say VB 31417 314 9 , , , 31417 314 10 that that IN 31417 314 11 , , , 31417 314 12 even even RB 31417 314 13 if if IN 31417 314 14 promiscuous promiscuous JJ 31417 314 15 seances seance NNS 31417 314 16 are be VBP 31417 314 17 ever ever RB 31417 314 18 useful useful JJ 31417 314 19 or or CC 31417 314 20 wise wise JJ 31417 314 21 , , , 31417 314 22 a a DT 31417 314 23 promiscuous promiscuous JJ 31417 314 24 dark dark JJ 31417 314 25 seance seance NN 31417 314 26 should should MD 31417 314 27 never never RB 31417 314 28 be be VB 31417 314 29 sanctioned sanction VBN 31417 314 30 by by IN 31417 314 31 an an DT 31417 314 32 earnest earnest JJ 31417 314 33 inquirer inquirer NN 31417 314 34 . . . 31417 315 1 Orthodox orthodox JJ 31417 315 2 science science NN 31417 315 3 has have VBZ 31417 315 4 not not RB 31417 315 5 yet yet RB 31417 315 6 condescended condescend VBN 31417 315 7 to to TO 31417 315 8 bestow bestow VB 31417 315 9 any any DT 31417 315 10 attention attention NN 31417 315 11 on on IN 31417 315 12 " " `` 31417 315 13 spirit spirit NN 31417 315 14 lights light NNS 31417 315 15 . . . 31417 315 16 " " '' 31417 316 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 316 2 had have VBD 31417 316 3 the the DT 31417 316 4 privilege privilege NN 31417 316 5 of of IN 31417 316 6 private private JJ 31417 316 7 acquaintance acquaintance NN 31417 316 8 with with IN 31417 316 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 316 10 Tyndall Tyndall NNP 31417 316 11 , , , 31417 316 12 and and CC 31417 316 13 once once RB 31417 316 14 acted act VBD 31417 316 15 as as IN 31417 316 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 316 17 assistant assistant NN 31417 316 18 at at IN 31417 316 19 some some DT 31417 316 20 lectures lecture NNS 31417 316 21 he -PRON- PRP 31417 316 22 gave give VBD 31417 316 23 in in IN 31417 316 24 a a DT 31417 316 25 country country NN 31417 316 26 place place NN 31417 316 27 . . . 31417 317 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 317 2 remember remember VBP 31417 317 3 sending send VBG 31417 317 4 him -PRON- PRP 31417 317 5 a a DT 31417 317 6 report report NN 31417 317 7 of of IN 31417 317 8 some some DT 31417 317 9 rather rather RB 31417 317 10 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 317 11 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 317 12 of of IN 31417 317 13 light light NN 31417 317 14 witnessed witness VBN 31417 317 15 at at IN 31417 317 16 a a DT 31417 317 17 private private JJ 31417 317 18 seance seance NN 31417 317 19 in in IN 31417 317 20 London London NNP 31417 317 21 , , , 31417 317 22 under under IN 31417 317 23 fairly fairly RB 31417 317 24 good good JJ 31417 317 25 test test NN 31417 317 26 - - HYPH 31417 317 27 conditions condition NNS 31417 317 28 . . . 31417 318 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 318 2 Tyndall Tyndall NNP 31417 318 3 was be VBD 31417 318 4 at at IN 31417 318 5 the the DT 31417 318 6 time time NN 31417 318 7 engaged engage VBN 31417 318 8 in in IN 31417 318 9 some some DT 31417 318 10 special special JJ 31417 318 11 optical optical JJ 31417 318 12 investigations investigation NNS 31417 318 13 , , , 31417 318 14 and and CC 31417 318 15 I -PRON- PRP 31417 318 16 asked ask VBD 31417 318 17 him -PRON- PRP 31417 318 18 to to TO 31417 318 19 spend spend VB 31417 318 20 five five CD 31417 318 21 minutes minute NNS 31417 318 22 in in IN 31417 318 23 reading read VBG 31417 318 24 the the DT 31417 318 25 notes note NNS 31417 318 26 enclosed enclose VBD 31417 318 27 . . . 31417 319 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 319 2 Tyndall Tyndall NNP 31417 319 3 's 's POS 31417 319 4 reply reply NN 31417 319 5 , , , 31417 319 6 in in IN 31417 319 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 319 8 laconic laconic JJ 31417 319 9 , , , 31417 319 10 jocular jocular JJ 31417 319 11 style style NN 31417 319 12 , , , 31417 319 13 was be VBD 31417 319 14 to to IN 31417 319 15 this this DT 31417 319 16 effect--"I effect--"I NNP 31417 319 17 have have VBP 31417 319 18 spent spend VBN 31417 319 19 five five CD 31417 319 20 minutes minute NNS 31417 319 21 as as IN 31417 319 22 you -PRON- PRP 31417 319 23 desired desire VBD 31417 319 24 , , , 31417 319 25 and and CC 31417 319 26 it -PRON- PRP 31417 319 27 is be VBZ 31417 319 28 a a DT 31417 319 29 long long JJ 31417 319 30 time time NN 31417 319 31 since since IN 31417 319 32 I -PRON- PRP 31417 319 33 spent spend VBD 31417 319 34 five five CD 31417 319 35 minutes minute NNS 31417 319 36 so so RB 31417 319 37 badly badly RB 31417 319 38 ! ! . 31417 319 39 " " '' 31417 320 1 The the DT 31417 320 2 best good JJS 31417 320 3 series series NN 31417 320 4 of of IN 31417 320 5 " " `` 31417 320 6 light light JJ 31417 320 7 " " '' 31417 320 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 320 9 , , , 31417 320 10 both both CC 31417 320 11 as as IN 31417 320 12 regards regard VBZ 31417 320 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 320 14 varied varied JJ 31417 320 15 character character NN 31417 320 16 , , , 31417 320 17 and and CC 31417 320 18 as as IN 31417 320 19 regards regard VBZ 31417 320 20 the the DT 31417 320 21 observers observer NNS 31417 320 22 , , , 31417 320 23 and and CC 31417 320 24 the the DT 31417 320 25 care care NN 31417 320 26 with with IN 31417 320 27 which which WDT 31417 320 28 records record NNS 31417 320 29 at at IN 31417 320 30 the the DT 31417 320 31 time time NN 31417 320 32 were be VBD 31417 320 33 made make VBN 31417 320 34 , , , 31417 320 35 occurred occur VBD 31417 320 36 in in IN 31417 320 37 the the DT 31417 320 38 presence presence NN 31417 320 39 of of IN 31417 320 40 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 320 41 W. W. NNP 31417 320 42 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 320 43 Moses Moses NNP 31417 320 44 . . . 31417 321 1 A a DT 31417 321 2 special special JJ 31417 321 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 321 4 is be VBZ 31417 321 5 devoted devoted JJ 31417 321 6 to to IN 31417 321 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 321 8 general general JJ 31417 321 9 experiences experience NNS 31417 321 10 later later RB 31417 321 11 on on RB 31417 321 12 , , , 31417 321 13 but but CC 31417 321 14 I -PRON- PRP 31417 321 15 will will MD 31417 321 16 deal deal VB 31417 321 17 with with IN 31417 321 18 the the DT 31417 321 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 321 20 of of IN 31417 321 21 lights light NNS 31417 321 22 here here RB 31417 321 23 , , , 31417 321 24 and and CC 31417 321 25 make make VB 31417 321 26 this this DT 31417 321 27 the the DT 31417 321 28 only only JJ 31417 321 29 illustration illustration NN 31417 321 30 of of IN 31417 321 31 this this DT 31417 321 32 branch branch NN 31417 321 33 of of IN 31417 321 34 the the DT 31417 321 35 subject subject NN 31417 321 36 . . . 31417 322 1 For for IN 31417 322 2 the the DT 31417 322 3 general general JJ 31417 322 4 credibility credibility NN 31417 322 5 of of IN 31417 322 6 the the DT 31417 322 7 W. W. NNP 31417 322 8 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 322 9 Moses Moses NNP 31417 322 10 phenomena phenomena VBZ 31417 322 11 the the DT 31417 322 12 reader reader NN 31417 322 13 is be VBZ 31417 322 14 referred refer VBN 31417 322 15 to to IN 31417 322 16 the the DT 31417 322 17 opening open VBG 31417 322 18 paragraph paragraph NN 31417 322 19 of of IN 31417 322 20 Chapter Chapter NNP 31417 322 21 VI VI NNP 31417 322 22 . . . 31417 323 1 The the DT 31417 323 2 following follow VBG 31417 323 3 pages page NNS 31417 323 4 are be VBP 31417 323 5 taken take VBN 31417 323 6 , , , 31417 323 7 by by IN 31417 323 8 way way NN 31417 323 9 of of IN 31417 323 10 either either DT 31417 323 11 extract extract NN 31417 323 12 or or CC 31417 323 13 abstract abstract JJ 31417 323 14 , , , 31417 323 15 from from IN 31417 323 16 two two CD 31417 323 17 articles article NNS 31417 323 18 on on IN 31417 323 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 323 20 W. W. NNP 31417 323 21 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 323 22 Moses Moses NNP 31417 323 23 by by IN 31417 323 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 323 25 F. F. NNP 31417 323 26 W. W. NNP 31417 323 27 H. H. NNP 31417 323 28 Myers Myers NNP 31417 323 29 . . . 31417 324 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 324 2 thus thus RB 31417 324 3 have have VBP 31417 324 4 the the DT 31417 324 5 advantage advantage NN 31417 324 6 of of IN 31417 324 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 324 8 Myers Myers NNP 31417 324 9 ' ' POS 31417 324 10 moral moral JJ 31417 324 11 certificate certificate NN 31417 324 12 , , , 31417 324 13 so so RB 31417 324 14 to to TO 31417 324 15 speak speak VB 31417 324 16 , , , 31417 324 17 as as IN 31417 324 18 to to IN 31417 324 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 324 20 value value NN 31417 324 21 . . . 31417 325 1 The the DT 31417 325 2 articles article NNS 31417 325 3 were be VBD 31417 325 4 published publish VBN 31417 325 5 in in IN 31417 325 6 the the DT 31417 325 7 _ _ NNP 31417 325 8 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 325 9 _ _ NNP 31417 325 10 of of IN 31417 325 11 the the DT 31417 325 12 Society Society NNP 31417 325 13 for for IN 31417 325 14 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 325 15 Research Research NNP 31417 325 16 . . . 31417 326 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 326 2 15 15 CD 31417 326 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 326 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 326 5 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 326 6 Moses Moses NNP 31417 326 7 says say VBZ 31417 326 8 that that IN 31417 326 9 the the DT 31417 326 10 first first JJ 31417 326 11 occasion occasion NN 31417 326 12 on on IN 31417 326 13 which which WDT 31417 326 14 large large JJ 31417 326 15 luminous luminous JJ 31417 326 16 appearances appearance NNS 31417 326 17 were be VBD 31417 326 18 seen see VBN 31417 326 19 at at IN 31417 326 20 the the DT 31417 326 21 circle circle NN 31417 326 22 consisting consist VBG 31417 326 23 of of IN 31417 326 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 326 25 and and CC 31417 326 26 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 326 27 Speer Speer NNP 31417 326 28 and and CC 31417 326 29 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 326 30 was be VBD 31417 326 31 on on IN 31417 326 32 7th 7th JJ 31417 326 33 June June NNP 31417 326 34 1873 1873 CD 31417 326 35 . . . 31417 327 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 327 2 had have VBD 31417 327 3 become become VBN 31417 327 4 familiar familiar JJ 31417 327 5 with with IN 31417 327 6 floating float VBG 31417 327 7 masses masse NNS 31417 327 8 of of IN 31417 327 9 luminous luminous JJ 31417 327 10 vapour vapour NN 31417 327 11 ; ; : 31417 327 12 and and CC 31417 327 13 on on IN 31417 327 14 several several JJ 31417 327 15 occasions occasion NNS 31417 327 16 , , , 31417 327 17 the the DT 31417 327 18 masses masse NNS 31417 327 19 condensed condense VBD 31417 327 20 , , , 31417 327 21 so so RB 31417 327 22 to to TO 31417 327 23 speak speak VB 31417 327 24 , , , 31417 327 25 until until IN 31417 327 26 a a DT 31417 327 27 distinct distinct JJ 31417 327 28 objective objective JJ 31417 327 29 light light NN 31417 327 30 was be VBD 31417 327 31 formed form VBN 31417 327 32 . . . 31417 328 1 On on IN 31417 328 2 that that DT 31417 328 3 evening evening NN 31417 328 4 , , , 31417 328 5 however however RB 31417 328 6 , , , 31417 328 7 a a DT 31417 328 8 number number NN 31417 328 9 of of IN 31417 328 10 cones cone NNS 31417 328 11 of of IN 31417 328 12 soft soft JJ 31417 328 13 light light NN 31417 328 14 similar similar JJ 31417 328 15 to to IN 31417 328 16 moonlight moonlight NN 31417 328 17 appeared appear VBD 31417 328 18 in in IN 31417 328 19 succession succession NN 31417 328 20 . . . 31417 329 1 There there EX 31417 329 2 was be VBD 31417 329 3 a a DT 31417 329 4 nucleus nucleus NN 31417 329 5 of of IN 31417 329 6 soft soft JJ 31417 329 7 yellow yellow JJ 31417 329 8 light light NN 31417 329 9 surrounded surround VBN 31417 329 10 by by IN 31417 329 11 a a DT 31417 329 12 haze haze NN 31417 329 13 . . . 31417 330 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 330 2 sailed sail VBD 31417 330 3 up up RP 31417 330 4 from from IN 31417 330 5 a a DT 31417 330 6 corner corner NN 31417 330 7 of of IN 31417 330 8 the the DT 31417 330 9 room room NN 31417 330 10 and and CC 31417 330 11 gradually gradually RB 31417 330 12 died die VBD 31417 330 13 out out RP 31417 330 14 . . . 31417 331 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 331 2 seem seem VBP 31417 331 3 to to TO 31417 331 4 have have VB 31417 331 5 been be VBN 31417 331 6 carried carry VBN 31417 331 7 in in IN 31417 331 8 a a DT 31417 331 9 materialised materialised JJ 31417 331 10 hand hand NN 31417 331 11 , , , 31417 331 12 a a DT 31417 331 13 finger finger NN 31417 331 14 of of IN 31417 331 15 which which WDT 31417 331 16 was be VBD 31417 331 17 shown show VBN 31417 331 18 at at IN 31417 331 19 request request NN 31417 331 20 , , , 31417 331 21 by by IN 31417 331 22 placing place VBG 31417 331 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 331 24 in in IN 31417 331 25 front front NN 31417 331 26 of of IN 31417 331 27 the the DT 31417 331 28 nucleus nucleus NN 31417 331 29 of of IN 31417 331 30 light light NN 31417 331 31 . . . 31417 332 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 332 2 16 16 CD 31417 332 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 332 4 Subsequently subsequently RB 31417 332 5 they -PRON- PRP 31417 332 6 saw see VBD 31417 332 7 another another DT 31417 332 8 kind kind NN 31417 332 9 of of IN 31417 332 10 light light NN 31417 332 11 altogether altogether RB 31417 332 12 . . . 31417 333 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 333 2 was be VBD 31417 333 3 apparently apparently RB 31417 333 4 a a DT 31417 333 5 little little JJ 31417 333 6 round round JJ 31417 333 7 disc disc NN 31417 333 8 of of IN 31417 333 9 light light NN 31417 333 10 which which WDT 31417 333 11 twinkled twinkle VBD 31417 333 12 like like IN 31417 333 13 a a DT 31417 333 14 star star NN 31417 333 15 . . . 31417 334 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 334 2 flashed flash VBD 31417 334 3 with with IN 31417 334 4 great great JJ 31417 334 5 rapidity rapidity NN 31417 334 6 , , , 31417 334 7 and and CC 31417 334 8 answered answer VBN 31417 334 9 questions question NNS 31417 334 10 by by IN 31417 334 11 the the DT 31417 334 12 usual usual JJ 31417 334 13 code code NN 31417 334 14 of of IN 31417 334 15 signals signal NNS 31417 334 16 . . . 31417 335 1 On on IN 31417 335 2 about about IN 31417 335 3 half half PDT 31417 335 4 - - HYPH 31417 335 5 a a DT 31417 335 6 - - HYPH 31417 335 7 dozen dozen NN 31417 335 8 occasions occasion NNS 31417 335 9 a a DT 31417 335 10 bright bright JJ 31417 335 11 scintillating scintillating NN 31417 335 12 light light NN 31417 335 13 apparently apparently RB 31417 335 14 resting rest VBG 31417 335 15 on on IN 31417 335 16 the the DT 31417 335 17 mantelshelf mantelshelf NN 31417 335 18 was be VBD 31417 335 19 seen see VBN 31417 335 20 . . . 31417 336 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 336 2 was be VBD 31417 336 3 about about IN 31417 336 4 the the DT 31417 336 5 size size NN 31417 336 6 of of IN 31417 336 7 a a DT 31417 336 8 pigeon pigeon NN 31417 336 9 's 's POS 31417 336 10 egg egg NN 31417 336 11 , , , 31417 336 12 and and CC 31417 336 13 looked look VBD 31417 336 14 like like IN 31417 336 15 a a DT 31417 336 16 large large JJ 31417 336 17 diamond diamond NN 31417 336 18 lit light VBN 31417 336 19 up up RP 31417 336 20 with with IN 31417 336 21 strong strong JJ 31417 336 22 light light NN 31417 336 23 . . . 31417 337 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 337 2 17 17 CD 31417 337 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 337 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 337 5 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 337 6 Moses Moses NNP 31417 337 7 gives give VBZ 31417 337 8 a a DT 31417 337 9 description description NN 31417 337 10 of of IN 31417 337 11 " " `` 31417 337 12 a a DT 31417 337 13 most most RBS 31417 337 14 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 337 15 light light NN 31417 337 16 , , , 31417 337 17 of of IN 31417 337 18 quite quite PDT 31417 337 19 a a DT 31417 337 20 different different JJ 31417 337 21 kind kind NN 31417 337 22 from from IN 31417 337 23 any any DT 31417 337 24 that that IN 31417 337 25 he -PRON- PRP 31417 337 26 had have VBD 31417 337 27 ever ever RB 31417 337 28 heard hear VBN 31417 337 29 or or CC 31417 337 30 read read VB 31417 337 31 of of IN 31417 337 32 . . . 31417 337 33 " " '' 31417 338 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 338 2 appeared appear VBD 31417 338 3 six six CD 31417 338 4 times time NNS 31417 338 5 , , , 31417 338 6 diminishing diminish VBG 31417 338 7 in in IN 31417 338 8 brilliancy brilliancy NN 31417 338 9 on on IN 31417 338 10 each each DT 31417 338 11 occasion occasion NN 31417 338 12 . . . 31417 339 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 339 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 339 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 339 4 says say VBZ 31417 339 5 : : : 31417 339 6 " " `` 31417 339 7 The the DT 31417 339 8 light light NN 31417 339 9 was be VBD 31417 339 10 first first RB 31417 339 11 observed observe VBN 31417 339 12 directly directly RB 31417 339 13 behind behind IN 31417 339 14 us -PRON- PRP 31417 339 15 -- -- : 31417 339 16 a a DT 31417 339 17 tall tall JJ 31417 339 18 column column NN 31417 339 19 about about RB 31417 339 20 half half PDT 31417 339 21 an an DT 31417 339 22 inch inch NN 31417 339 23 or or CC 31417 339 24 rather rather RB 31417 339 25 more more JJR 31417 339 26 in in IN 31417 339 27 width width NN 31417 339 28 , , , 31417 339 29 and and CC 31417 339 30 six six CD 31417 339 31 or or CC 31417 339 32 seven seven CD 31417 339 33 feet foot NNS 31417 339 34 high high JJ 31417 339 35 . . . 31417 340 1 The the DT 31417 340 2 light light NN 31417 340 3 was be VBD 31417 340 4 of of IN 31417 340 5 a a DT 31417 340 6 bright bright JJ 31417 340 7 golden golden JJ 31417 340 8 hue hue NN 31417 340 9 , , , 31417 340 10 and and CC 31417 340 11 did do VBD 31417 340 12 not not RB 31417 340 13 illuminate illuminate VB 31417 340 14 objects object NNS 31417 340 15 in in IN 31417 340 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 340 17 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 31417 340 18 . . . 31417 341 1 For for IN 31417 341 2 a a DT 31417 341 3 minute minute NN 31417 341 4 a a DT 31417 341 5 cross cross NN 31417 341 6 developed develop VBN 31417 341 7 at at IN 31417 341 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 341 9 top top NN 31417 341 10 , , , 31417 341 11 and and CC 31417 341 12 rays ray NNS 31417 341 13 seemed seem VBD 31417 341 14 to to TO 31417 341 15 dart dart VB 31417 341 16 from from IN 31417 341 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 341 18 . . . 31417 341 19 " " '' 31417 342 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 342 2 Speer Speer NNP 31417 342 3 , , , 31417 342 4 who who WP 31417 342 5 had have VBD 31417 342 6 been be VBN 31417 342 7 watching watch VBG 31417 342 8 the the DT 31417 342 9 strange strange JJ 31417 342 10 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 342 11 with with IN 31417 342 12 absorbing absorb VBG 31417 342 13 interest interest NN 31417 342 14 , , , 31417 342 15 asked ask VBD 31417 342 16 permission permission NN 31417 342 17 to to TO 31417 342 18 examine examine VB 31417 342 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 342 20 more more RBR 31417 342 21 closely closely RB 31417 342 22 . . . 31417 343 1 Leave leave VB 31417 343 2 being be VBG 31417 343 3 given give VBN 31417 343 4 , , , 31417 343 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 343 6 went go VBD 31417 343 7 to to IN 31417 343 8 the the DT 31417 343 9 light light NN 31417 343 10 , , , 31417 343 11 put put VB 31417 343 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 343 13 face face NN 31417 343 14 close close RB 31417 343 15 to to IN 31417 343 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 343 17 , , , 31417 343 18 and and CC 31417 343 19 passed pass VBD 31417 343 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 343 21 hand hand NN 31417 343 22 through through IN 31417 343 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 343 24 . . . 31417 344 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 344 2 detected detect VBD 31417 344 3 no no DT 31417 344 4 odour odour NN 31417 344 5 , , , 31417 344 6 and and CC 31417 344 7 the the DT 31417 344 8 light light NN 31417 344 9 did do VBD 31417 344 10 not not RB 31417 344 11 disappear disappear VB 31417 344 12 . . . 31417 345 1 No no DT 31417 345 2 warmth warmth NN 31417 345 3 came come VBD 31417 345 4 from from IN 31417 345 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 345 6 , , , 31417 345 7 nor nor CC 31417 345 8 did do VBD 31417 345 9 it -PRON- PRP 31417 345 10 perceptibly perceptibly RB 31417 345 11 light light VB 31417 345 12 up up RP 31417 345 13 the the DT 31417 345 14 room room NN 31417 345 15 . . . 31417 346 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 346 2 remained remain VBD 31417 346 3 visible visible JJ 31417 346 4 until until IN 31417 346 5 the the DT 31417 346 6 seance seance NN 31417 346 7 was be VBD 31417 346 8 concluded conclude VBN 31417 346 9 . . . 31417 347 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 347 2 18 18 CD 31417 347 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 347 4 The the DT 31417 347 5 following follow VBG 31417 347 6 graphic graphic JJ 31417 347 7 description description NN 31417 347 8 shall shall MD 31417 347 9 be be VB 31417 347 10 given give VBN 31417 347 11 in in IN 31417 347 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 347 13 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 347 14 Moses Moses NNP 31417 347 15 ' ' POS 31417 347 16 own own JJ 31417 347 17 words:-- words:-- NN 31417 347 18 " " '' 31417 347 19 The the DT 31417 347 20 room room NN 31417 347 21 , , , 31417 347 22 which which WDT 31417 347 23 had have VBD 31417 347 24 been be VBN 31417 347 25 filled fill VBN 31417 347 26 ( ( -LRB- 31417 347 27 especially especially RB 31417 347 28 round round VB 31417 347 29 me -PRON- PRP 31417 347 30 ) ) -RRB- 31417 347 31 with with IN 31417 347 32 floating float VBG 31417 347 33 clouds cloud NNS 31417 347 34 of of IN 31417 347 35 light light NN 31417 347 36 , , , 31417 347 37 grew grow VBD 31417 347 38 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 347 39 dark dark JJ 31417 347 40 , , , 31417 347 41 and and CC 31417 347 42 absolute absolute JJ 31417 347 43 stillness stillness NN 31417 347 44 took take VBD 31417 347 45 the the DT 31417 347 46 place place NN 31417 347 47 of of IN 31417 347 48 the the DT 31417 347 49 previous previous JJ 31417 347 50 loud loud JJ 31417 347 51 knockings knocking NNS 31417 347 52 . . . 31417 348 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 348 2 would would MD 31417 348 3 have have VB 31417 348 4 been be VBN 31417 348 5 a a DT 31417 348 6 strange strange JJ 31417 348 7 scene scene NN 31417 348 8 for for IN 31417 348 9 an an DT 31417 348 10 ear ear NN 31417 348 11 - - HYPH 31417 348 12 witness witness NN 31417 348 13 . . . 31417 349 1 The the DT 31417 349 2 table table NN 31417 349 3 , , , 31417 349 4 isolated isolate VBN 31417 349 5 , , , 31417 349 6 with with IN 31417 349 7 no no DT 31417 349 8 human human JJ 31417 349 9 hand hand NN 31417 349 10 touching touch VBG 31417 349 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 349 12 , , , 31417 349 13 giving give VBG 31417 349 14 forth forth RP 31417 349 15 a a DT 31417 349 16 series series NN 31417 349 17 of of IN 31417 349 18 mysterious mysterious JJ 31417 349 19 thuds thud NNS 31417 349 20 of of IN 31417 349 21 varying vary VBG 31417 349 22 intensity intensity NN 31417 349 23 , , , 31417 349 24 some some DT 31417 349 25 of of IN 31417 349 26 which which WDT 31417 349 27 might may MD 31417 349 28 have have VB 31417 349 29 been be VBN 31417 349 30 made make VBN 31417 349 31 with with IN 31417 349 32 a a DT 31417 349 33 muffled muffled JJ 31417 349 34 sledge sledge NN 31417 349 35 - - HYPH 31417 349 36 hammer hammer NNP 31417 349 37 , , , 31417 349 38 all all DT 31417 349 39 indicating indicate VBG 31417 349 40 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 349 41 -- -- : 31417 349 42 an an DT 31417 349 43 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 349 44 that that WDT 31417 349 45 showed show VBD 31417 349 46 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 349 47 by by IN 31417 349 48 deliberation deliberation NN 31417 349 49 , , , 31417 349 50 or or CC 31417 349 51 eagerness eagerness NN 31417 349 52 , , , 31417 349 53 or or CC 31417 349 54 stately stately JJ 31417 349 55 solemnity solemnity NN 31417 349 56 according accord VBG 31417 349 57 to to IN 31417 349 58 the the DT 31417 349 59 nature nature NN 31417 349 60 of of IN 31417 349 61 the the DT 31417 349 62 communication communication NN 31417 349 63 . . . 31417 350 1 Around around IN 31417 350 2 the the DT 31417 350 3 table table NN 31417 350 4 three three CD 31417 350 5 persons person NNS 31417 350 6 sitting sit VBG 31417 350 7 with with IN 31417 350 8 a a DT 31417 350 9 hush hush NN 31417 350 10 of of IN 31417 350 11 expectation expectation NN 31417 350 12 , , , 31417 350 13 and and CC 31417 350 14 faces face VBZ 31417 350 15 ( ( -LRB- 31417 350 16 if if IN 31417 350 17 they -PRON- PRP 31417 350 18 could could MD 31417 350 19 have have VB 31417 350 20 been be VBN 31417 350 21 seen see VBN 31417 350 22 ) ) -RRB- 31417 350 23 of of IN 31417 350 24 awe awe NN 31417 350 25 - - HYPH 31417 350 26 stricken stricken VBN 31417 350 27 earnestness earnestness NN 31417 350 28 .... .... . 31417 351 1 The the DT 31417 351 2 room room NN 31417 351 3 shrouded shroud VBN 31417 351 4 in in IN 31417 351 5 darkness darkness NN 31417 351 6 , , , 31417 351 7 except except IN 31417 351 8 at at IN 31417 351 9 one one CD 31417 351 10 end end NN 31417 351 11 , , , 31417 351 12 where where WRB 31417 351 13 shifting shift VBG 31417 351 14 masses masse NNS 31417 351 15 of of IN 31417 351 16 luminous luminous JJ 31417 351 17 vapour vapour NN 31417 351 18 now now RB 31417 351 19 and and CC 31417 351 20 again again RB 31417 351 21 gathered gather VBD 31417 351 22 into into IN 31417 351 23 a a DT 31417 351 24 pillar pillar NN 31417 351 25 which which WDT 31417 351 26 dimly dimly RB 31417 351 27 outlined outline VBD 31417 351 28 a a DT 31417 351 29 form form NN 31417 351 30 , , , 31417 351 31 and and CC 31417 351 32 again again RB 31417 351 33 dispersed disperse VBN 31417 351 34 , , , 31417 351 35 and and CC 31417 351 36 flitted flit VBN 31417 351 37 round round IN 31417 351 38 the the DT 31417 351 39 head head NN 31417 351 40 of of IN 31417 351 41 one one CD 31417 351 42 of of IN 31417 351 43 the the DT 31417 351 44 sitters sitter NNS 31417 351 45 . . . 31417 352 1 No no DT 31417 352 2 scene scene NN 31417 352 3 could could MD 31417 352 4 be be VB 31417 352 5 imagined imagine VBN 31417 352 6 more more RBR 31417 352 7 calculated calculated JJ 31417 352 8 to to TO 31417 352 9 strike strike VB 31417 352 10 a a DT 31417 352 11 novice novice NN 31417 352 12 with with IN 31417 352 13 awe awe NN 31417 352 14 , , , 31417 352 15 none none NN 31417 352 16 more more RBR 31417 352 17 solemn solemn JJ 31417 352 18 and and CC 31417 352 19 impressive impressive JJ 31417 352 20 for for IN 31417 352 21 those those DT 31417 352 22 who who WP 31417 352 23 participated participate VBD 31417 352 24 in in IN 31417 352 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 352 26 . . . 31417 353 1 " " `` 31417 353 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 353 3 19 19 CD 31417 353 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 353 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 353 6 W. W. NNP 31417 353 7 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 353 8 Moses Moses NNP 31417 353 9 thus thus RB 31417 353 10 describes describe VBZ 31417 353 11 the the DT 31417 353 12 formation formation NN 31417 353 13 of of IN 31417 353 14 the the DT 31417 353 15 lights light NNS 31417 353 16 at at IN 31417 353 17 a a DT 31417 353 18 sitting sitting NN 31417 353 19 on on IN 31417 353 20 9th 9th JJ 31417 353 21 August August NNP 31417 353 22 1873:-- 1873:-- NNP 31417 353 23 " " '' 31417 353 24 I -PRON- PRP 31417 353 25 witnessed witness VBD 31417 353 26 the the DT 31417 353 27 formation formation NN 31417 353 28 of of IN 31417 353 29 some some DT 31417 353 30 eight eight CD 31417 353 31 or or CC 31417 353 32 nine nine CD 31417 353 33 very very RB 31417 353 34 beautiful beautiful JJ 31417 353 35 spirit spirit NN 31417 353 36 lights light NNS 31417 353 37 . . . 31417 354 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 354 2 formed form VBD 31417 354 3 quite quite RB 31417 354 4 close close RB 31417 354 5 to to IN 31417 354 6 me -PRON- PRP 31417 354 7 , , , 31417 354 8 and and CC 31417 354 9 near near IN 31417 354 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 354 11 left left JJ 31417 354 12 hand hand NN 31417 354 13 , , , 31417 354 14 about about RB 31417 354 15 a a DT 31417 354 16 foot foot NN 31417 354 17 from from IN 31417 354 18 the the DT 31417 354 19 floor floor NN 31417 354 20 , , , 31417 354 21 floating float VBG 31417 354 22 upwards upwards RB 31417 354 23 till till IN 31417 354 24 they -PRON- PRP 31417 354 25 reached reach VBD 31417 354 26 the the DT 31417 354 27 level level NN 31417 354 28 of of IN 31417 354 29 the the DT 31417 354 30 table table NN 31417 354 31 and and CC 31417 354 32 became become VBD 31417 354 33 visible visible JJ 31417 354 34 to to IN 31417 354 35 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 354 36 Speer Speer NNP 31417 354 37 . . . 31417 355 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 355 2 were be VBD 31417 355 3 expressly expressly RB 31417 355 4 made make VBN 31417 355 5 at at IN 31417 355 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 355 7 side side NN 31417 355 8 , , , 31417 355 9 instead instead RB 31417 355 10 of of IN 31417 355 11 , , , 31417 355 12 as as IN 31417 355 13 usual usual JJ 31417 355 14 , , , 31417 355 15 at at IN 31417 355 16 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 355 17 back back NN 31417 355 18 , , , 31417 355 19 so so IN 31417 355 20 that that IN 31417 355 21 I -PRON- PRP 31417 355 22 might may MD 31417 355 23 see see VB 31417 355 24 them -PRON- PRP 31417 355 25 . . . 31417 356 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 356 2 seemed seem VBD 31417 356 3 to to TO 31417 356 4 develop develop VB 31417 356 5 from from IN 31417 356 6 a a DT 31417 356 7 very very RB 31417 356 8 bright bright JJ 31417 356 9 speck speck NN 31417 356 10 , , , 31417 356 11 about about IN 31417 356 12 the the DT 31417 356 13 size size NN 31417 356 14 of of IN 31417 356 15 a a DT 31417 356 16 pea pea NN 31417 356 17 , , , 31417 356 18 until until IN 31417 356 19 they -PRON- PRP 31417 356 20 attained attain VBD 31417 356 21 the the DT 31417 356 22 size size NN 31417 356 23 of of IN 31417 356 24 a a DT 31417 356 25 soda soda NN 31417 356 26 - - HYPH 31417 356 27 water water NN 31417 356 28 tumbler tumbler NN 31417 356 29 , , , 31417 356 30 and and CC 31417 356 31 showed show VBD 31417 356 32 a a DT 31417 356 33 soft soft JJ 31417 356 34 luminosity luminosity NN 31417 356 35 like like IN 31417 356 36 pale pale JJ 31417 356 37 moonlight moonlight NN 31417 356 38 . . . 31417 357 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 357 2 seemed seem VBD 31417 357 3 to to TO 31417 357 4 be be VB 31417 357 5 covered cover VBN 31417 357 6 with with IN 31417 357 7 drapery drapery NN 31417 357 8 and and CC 31417 357 9 to to TO 31417 357 10 be be VB 31417 357 11 held hold VBN 31417 357 12 by by IN 31417 357 13 a a DT 31417 357 14 hand hand NN 31417 357 15 . . . 31417 358 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 358 2 faded fade VBD 31417 358 3 slowly slowly RB 31417 358 4 out out RP 31417 358 5 , , , 31417 358 6 remaining remain VBG 31417 358 7 visible visible JJ 31417 358 8 about about RB 31417 358 9 thirty thirty CD 31417 358 10 or or CC 31417 358 11 forty forty CD 31417 358 12 seconds second NNS 31417 358 13 , , , 31417 358 14 or or CC 31417 358 15 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 358 16 a a DT 31417 358 17 minute minute NN 31417 358 18 . . . 31417 359 1 The the DT 31417 359 2 largest large JJS 31417 359 3 would would MD 31417 359 4 be be VB 31417 359 5 about about RB 31417 359 6 eight eight CD 31417 359 7 inches inch NNS 31417 359 8 long long JJ 31417 359 9 . . . 31417 360 1 " " `` 31417 360 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 360 3 20 20 CD 31417 360 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 360 5 On on IN 31417 360 6 14th 14th JJ 31417 360 7 April April NNP 31417 360 8 1874 1874 CD 31417 360 9 , , , 31417 360 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 360 11 Speer Speer NNP 31417 360 12 and and CC 31417 360 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 360 14 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 360 15 Moses Moses NNP 31417 360 16 held hold VBD 31417 360 17 a a DT 31417 360 18 sitting sitting NN 31417 360 19 by by IN 31417 360 20 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 360 21 . . . 31417 361 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 361 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 361 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 361 4 thus thus RB 31417 361 5 describes describe VBZ 31417 361 6 what what WP 31417 361 7 happened:-- happened:-- VBZ 31417 361 8 " " `` 31417 361 9 To to IN 31417 361 10 - - HYPH 31417 361 11 night night NN 31417 361 12 lights light NNS 31417 361 13 commenced commence VBD 31417 361 14 again again RB 31417 361 15 , , , 31417 361 16 but but CC 31417 361 17 of of IN 31417 361 18 a a DT 31417 361 19 quite quite RB 31417 361 20 different different JJ 31417 361 21 character character NN 31417 361 22 to to IN 31417 361 23 any any DT 31417 361 24 we -PRON- PRP 31417 361 25 had have VBD 31417 361 26 seen see VBN 31417 361 27 before before RB 31417 361 28 . . . 31417 362 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 362 2 darted dart VBD 31417 362 3 about about IN 31417 362 4 like like UH 31417 362 5 a a DT 31417 362 6 comet comet NN 31417 362 7 , , , 31417 362 8 coming come VBG 31417 362 9 from from IN 31417 362 10 the the DT 31417 362 11 side side NN 31417 362 12 by by IN 31417 362 13 the the DT 31417 362 14 harmonium harmonium NN 31417 362 15 , , , 31417 362 16 or or CC 31417 362 17 near near IN 31417 362 18 the the DT 31417 362 19 fireplace fireplace NN 31417 362 20 . . . 31417 363 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 363 2 were be VBD 31417 363 3 evanescent evanescent JJ 31417 363 4 , , , 31417 363 5 and and CC 31417 363 6 apparently apparently RB 31417 363 7 of of IN 31417 363 8 diffuse diffuse NN 31417 363 9 luminosity luminosity NN 31417 363 10 , , , 31417 363 11 within within IN 31417 363 12 which which WDT 31417 363 13 was be VBD 31417 363 14 a a DT 31417 363 15 nucleus nucleus NN 31417 363 16 of of IN 31417 363 17 light light NN 31417 363 18 , , , 31417 363 19 not not RB 31417 363 20 , , , 31417 363 21 however however RB 31417 363 22 , , , 31417 363 23 visible visible JJ 31417 363 24 to to IN 31417 363 25 me -PRON- PRP 31417 363 26 . . . 31417 364 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 364 2 had have VBD 31417 364 3 some some DT 31417 364 4 ten ten CD 31417 364 5 or or CC 31417 364 6 twelve twelve CD 31417 364 7 of of IN 31417 364 8 these these DT 31417 364 9 , , , 31417 364 10 some some DT 31417 364 11 more more RBR 31417 364 12 brilliant brilliant JJ 31417 364 13 than than IN 31417 364 14 others other NNS 31417 364 15 , , , 31417 364 16 some some DT 31417 364 17 visible visible JJ 31417 364 18 both both CC 31417 364 19 in in IN 31417 364 20 the the DT 31417 364 21 looking looking JJ 31417 364 22 - - HYPH 31417 364 23 glass glass NN 31417 364 24 and and CC 31417 364 25 in in IN 31417 364 26 the the DT 31417 364 27 glass glass NN 31417 364 28 of of IN 31417 364 29 the the DT 31417 364 30 book book NN 31417 364 31 - - HYPH 31417 364 32 case case NN 31417 364 33 , , , 31417 364 34 and and CC 31417 364 35 they -PRON- PRP 31417 364 36 were be VBD 31417 364 37 showing show VBG 31417 364 38 a a DT 31417 364 39 trail trail NN 31417 364 40 of of IN 31417 364 41 reflected reflect VBN 31417 364 42 light light NN 31417 364 43 on on IN 31417 364 44 the the DT 31417 364 45 table table NN 31417 364 46 , , , 31417 364 47 when when WRB 31417 364 48 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 364 49 there there RB 31417 364 50 arose arise VBD 31417 364 51 from from IN 31417 364 52 below below IN 31417 364 53 me -PRON- PRP 31417 364 54 , , , 31417 364 55 apparently apparently RB 31417 364 56 under under IN 31417 364 57 the the DT 31417 364 58 table table NN 31417 364 59 , , , 31417 364 60 or or CC 31417 364 61 near near IN 31417 364 62 the the DT 31417 364 63 floor floor NN 31417 364 64 , , , 31417 364 65 right right RB 31417 364 66 under under IN 31417 364 67 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 364 68 nose nose NN 31417 364 69 , , , 31417 364 70 a a DT 31417 364 71 cloud cloud NN 31417 364 72 of of IN 31417 364 73 luminous luminous JJ 31417 364 74 smoke smoke NN 31417 364 75 , , , 31417 364 76 just just RB 31417 364 77 like like IN 31417 364 78 phosphorus phosphorus NN 31417 364 79 . . . 31417 365 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 365 2 fumed fume VBD 31417 365 3 up up RP 31417 365 4 in in IN 31417 365 5 great great JJ 31417 365 6 clouds cloud NNS 31417 365 7 , , , 31417 365 8 until until IN 31417 365 9 I -PRON- PRP 31417 365 10 seemed seem VBD 31417 365 11 to to TO 31417 365 12 be be VB 31417 365 13 on on IN 31417 365 14 fire fire NN 31417 365 15 , , , 31417 365 16 and and CC 31417 365 17 rushed rush VBD 31417 365 18 from from IN 31417 365 19 the the DT 31417 365 20 room room NN 31417 365 21 in in IN 31417 365 22 a a DT 31417 365 23 panic panic NN 31417 365 24 . . . 31417 366 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 366 2 was be VBD 31417 366 3 fairly fairly RB 31417 366 4 frightened frightened JJ 31417 366 5 , , , 31417 366 6 and and CC 31417 366 7 could could MD 31417 366 8 not not RB 31417 366 9 tell tell VB 31417 366 10 what what WP 31417 366 11 was be VBD 31417 366 12 happening happen VBG 31417 366 13 . . . 31417 367 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 367 2 rushed rush VBD 31417 367 3 to to IN 31417 367 4 the the DT 31417 367 5 door door NN 31417 367 6 and and CC 31417 367 7 opened open VBD 31417 367 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 367 9 , , , 31417 367 10 and and CC 31417 367 11 so so RB 31417 367 12 to to IN 31417 367 13 the the DT 31417 367 14 front front JJ 31417 367 15 door door NN 31417 367 16 . . . 31417 368 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 368 2 hands hand NNS 31417 368 3 seemed seem VBD 31417 368 4 to to TO 31417 368 5 be be VB 31417 368 6 ablaze ablaze JJ 31417 368 7 , , , 31417 368 8 and and CC 31417 368 9 left leave VBD 31417 368 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 368 11 impress impress NN 31417 368 12 on on IN 31417 368 13 the the DT 31417 368 14 doors door NNS 31417 368 15 and and CC 31417 368 16 handles handle NNS 31417 368 17 . . . 31417 369 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 369 2 blazed blaze VBD 31417 369 3 for for IN 31417 369 4 a a DT 31417 369 5 while while NN 31417 369 6 after after IN 31417 369 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 369 8 had have VBD 31417 369 9 touched touch VBN 31417 369 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 369 11 , , , 31417 369 12 but but CC 31417 369 13 soon soon RB 31417 369 14 went go VBD 31417 369 15 out out RP 31417 369 16 , , , 31417 369 17 and and CC 31417 369 18 no no DT 31417 369 19 smell smell NN 31417 369 20 or or CC 31417 369 21 trace trace NN 31417 369 22 remained remain VBD 31417 369 23 . . . 31417 370 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 370 2 have have VBP 31417 370 3 seen see VBN 31417 370 4 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 370 5 own own JJ 31417 370 6 hands hand NNS 31417 370 7 covered cover VBN 31417 370 8 with with IN 31417 370 9 a a DT 31417 370 10 lambent lambent JJ 31417 370 11 flame flame NN 31417 370 12 ; ; : 31417 370 13 but but CC 31417 370 14 nothing nothing NN 31417 370 15 like like IN 31417 370 16 this this DT 31417 370 17 I -PRON- PRP 31417 370 18 ever ever RB 31417 370 19 saw see VBD 31417 370 20 .... .... . 31417 371 1 The the DT 31417 371 2 lights light NNS 31417 371 3 were be VBD 31417 371 4 preceded precede VBN 31417 371 5 by by IN 31417 371 6 very very RB 31417 371 7 sharp sharp JJ 31417 371 8 detonations detonation NNS 31417 371 9 on on IN 31417 371 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 371 11 chair chair NN 31417 371 12 , , , 31417 371 13 so so IN 31417 371 14 that that IN 31417 371 15 we -PRON- PRP 31417 371 16 could could MD 31417 371 17 watch watch VB 31417 371 18 for for IN 31417 371 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 371 20 coming come VBG 31417 371 21 by by IN 31417 371 22 hearing hear VBG 31417 371 23 the the DT 31417 371 24 noise noise NN 31417 371 25 . . . 31417 372 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 372 2 shot shoot VBD 31417 372 3 up up RP 31417 372 4 very very RB 31417 372 5 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 372 6 from from IN 31417 372 7 the the DT 31417 372 8 floor floor NN 31417 372 9 . . . 31417 373 1 " " `` 31417 373 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 373 3 21 21 CD 31417 373 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 373 5 This this DT 31417 373 6 sensational sensational JJ 31417 373 7 experience experience NN 31417 373 8 must must MD 31417 373 9 conclude conclude VB 31417 373 10 the the DT 31417 373 11 evidence evidence NN 31417 373 12 respecting respect VBG 31417 373 13 the the DT 31417 373 14 lights light NNS 31417 373 15 , , , 31417 373 16 for for IN 31417 373 17 the the DT 31417 373 18 present present NN 31417 373 19 . . . 31417 374 1 One one CD 31417 374 2 more more JJR 31417 374 3 selection selection NN 31417 374 4 has have VBZ 31417 374 5 , , , 31417 374 6 however however RB 31417 374 7 , , , 31417 374 8 been be VBN 31417 374 9 made make VBN 31417 374 10 , , , 31417 374 11 which which WDT 31417 374 12 is be VBZ 31417 374 13 deferred defer VBN 31417 374 14 to to IN 31417 374 15 the the DT 31417 374 16 special special JJ 31417 374 17 chapter chapter NN 31417 374 18 on on IN 31417 374 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 374 20 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 374 21 Moses Moses NNP 31417 374 22 ' ' POS 31417 374 23 experiences experience NNS 31417 374 24 as as IN 31417 374 25 a a DT 31417 374 26 whole whole NN 31417 374 27 . . . 31417 375 1 The the DT 31417 375 2 present present JJ 31417 375 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 375 4 must must MD 31417 375 5 be be VB 31417 375 6 read read VBN 31417 375 7 in in IN 31417 375 8 connection connection NN 31417 375 9 with with IN 31417 375 10 that that DT 31417 375 11 chapter chapter NN 31417 375 12 . . . 31417 376 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 376 2 is be VBZ 31417 376 3 admitted admit VBN 31417 376 4 that that IN 31417 376 5 the the DT 31417 376 6 testimony testimony NN 31417 376 7 quoted quote VBD 31417 376 8 with with IN 31417 376 9 regard regard NN 31417 376 10 to to IN 31417 376 11 the the DT 31417 376 12 Lights Lights NNPS 31417 376 13 does do VBZ 31417 376 14 not not RB 31417 376 15 reach reach VB 31417 376 16 the the DT 31417 376 17 level level NN 31417 376 18 of of IN 31417 376 19 scientific scientific JJ 31417 376 20 evidence evidence NN 31417 376 21 . . . 31417 377 1 At at IN 31417 377 2 the the DT 31417 377 3 same same JJ 31417 377 4 time time NN 31417 377 5 , , , 31417 377 6 when when WRB 31417 377 7 due due JJ 31417 377 8 consideration consideration NN 31417 377 9 is be VBZ 31417 377 10 given give VBN 31417 377 11 to to IN 31417 377 12 the the DT 31417 377 13 existing exist VBG 31417 377 14 contemporary contemporary JJ 31417 377 15 records record NNS 31417 377 16 , , , 31417 377 17 and and CC 31417 377 18 to to IN 31417 377 19 the the DT 31417 377 20 careful careful JJ 31417 377 21 way way NN 31417 377 22 in in IN 31417 377 23 which which WDT 31417 377 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 377 25 Myers Myers NNP 31417 377 26 examined examine VBD 31417 377 27 the the DT 31417 377 28 whole whole JJ 31417 377 29 case case NN 31417 377 30 , , , 31417 377 31 it -PRON- PRP 31417 377 32 is be VBZ 31417 377 33 difficult difficult JJ 31417 377 34 to to TO 31417 377 35 avoid avoid VB 31417 377 36 the the DT 31417 377 37 conviction conviction NN 31417 377 38 that that IN 31417 377 39 the the DT 31417 377 40 Lights Lights NNPS 31417 377 41 were be VBD 31417 377 42 objective objective JJ 31417 377 43 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 377 44 , , , 31417 377 45 not not RB 31417 377 46 produced produce VBN 31417 377 47 by by IN 31417 377 48 any any DT 31417 377 49 known know VBN 31417 377 50 physical physical JJ 31417 377 51 cause cause NN 31417 377 52 . . . 31417 378 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 378 2 is be VBZ 31417 378 3 much much JJ 31417 378 4 to to TO 31417 378 5 be be VB 31417 378 6 regretted regret VBN 31417 378 7 that that IN 31417 378 8 efforts effort NNS 31417 378 9 were be VBD 31417 378 10 not not RB 31417 378 11 made make VBN 31417 378 12 to to TO 31417 378 13 secure secure VB 31417 378 14 a a DT 31417 378 15 critical critical JJ 31417 378 16 study study NN 31417 378 17 of of IN 31417 378 18 the the DT 31417 378 19 Lights Lights NNPS 31417 378 20 by by IN 31417 378 21 a a DT 31417 378 22 competent competent JJ 31417 378 23 scientific scientific JJ 31417 378 24 man man NN 31417 378 25 . . . 31417 379 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 379 2 : : : 31417 379 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 379 4 15 15 CD 31417 379 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 379 6 Vol Vol NNP 31417 379 7 . . . 31417 380 1 ix ix IN 31417 380 2 . . . 31417 381 1 pp pp NNP 31417 381 2 . . . 31417 382 1 245 245 CD 31417 382 2 - - SYM 31417 382 3 352 352 CD 31417 382 4 , , , 31417 382 5 and and CC 31417 382 6 vol vol NNP 31417 382 7 . . . 31417 383 1 xi xi NNP 31417 383 2 . . . 31417 384 1 pp pp NNP 31417 384 2 . . . 31417 385 1 24 24 CD 31417 385 2 - - SYM 31417 385 3 113 113 CD 31417 385 4 . . . 31417 386 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 386 2 16 16 CD 31417 386 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 386 4 See see VB 31417 386 5 ibid ibid NN 31417 386 6 . . . 31417 386 7 , , , 31417 386 8 vol vol NNP 31417 386 9 . . . 31417 387 1 ix ix IN 31417 387 2 . . . 31417 388 1 pp pp NNP 31417 388 2 . . . 31417 389 1 273 273 CD 31417 389 2 - - SYM 31417 389 3 274 274 CD 31417 389 4 . . . 31417 390 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 390 2 17 17 CD 31417 390 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 390 4 See See NNP 31417 390 5 _ _ NNP 31417 390 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 390 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 390 8 _ _ NNP 31417 390 9 , , , 31417 390 10 vol vol NNP 31417 390 11 . . . 31417 391 1 ix ix IN 31417 391 2 . . . 31417 392 1 p. p. NN 31417 392 2 276 276 CD 31417 392 3 . . . 31417 393 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 393 2 18 18 CD 31417 393 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 393 4 See see VB 31417 393 5 ibid ibid NN 31417 393 6 . . . 31417 393 7 , , , 31417 393 8 pp pp NNP 31417 393 9 . . . 31417 394 1 276 276 CD 31417 394 2 - - SYM 31417 394 3 277 277 CD 31417 394 4 . . . 31417 395 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 395 2 19 19 CD 31417 395 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 395 4 _ _ NNP 31417 395 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 395 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 395 7 _ _ NNP 31417 395 8 , , , 31417 395 9 vol vol NNP 31417 395 10 . . . 31417 396 1 ix ix IN 31417 396 2 . . . 31417 397 1 p. p. NN 31417 397 2 290 290 CD 31417 397 3 . . . 31417 398 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 398 2 20 20 CD 31417 398 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 398 4 _ _ NNP 31417 398 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 398 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 398 7 _ _ NNP 31417 398 8 , , , 31417 398 9 vol vol NNP 31417 398 10 . . . 31417 399 1 ix ix IN 31417 399 2 . . . 31417 400 1 p. p. NN 31417 400 2 319 319 CD 31417 400 3 . . . 31417 401 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 401 2 21 21 CD 31417 401 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 401 4 _ _ NNP 31417 401 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 401 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 401 7 _ _ NNP 31417 401 8 , , , 31417 401 9 vol vol NNP 31417 401 10 . . . 31417 402 1 xi xi NNP 31417 402 2 . . . 31417 403 1 pp pp NNP 31417 403 2 . . . 31417 404 1 44 44 CD 31417 404 2 - - SYM 31417 404 3 45 45 CD 31417 404 4 . . . 31417 405 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 405 2 V V NNP 31417 405 3 PHYSICAL physical NN 31417 405 4 PHENOMENA phenomena NN 31417 405 5 ALLEGED allege VBN 31417 405 6 TO to IN 31417 405 7 HAVE have VB 31417 405 8 OCCURRED occur VBN 31417 405 9 IN in IN 31417 405 10 THE the DT 31417 405 11 PRESENCE presence NN 31417 405 12 OF of IN 31417 405 13 DANIEL DANIEL NNP 31417 405 14 DUNGLAS DUNGLAS NNP 31417 405 15 HOME HOME NNP 31417 405 16 Scientific scientific JJ 31417 405 17 evidence evidence NN 31417 405 18 of of IN 31417 405 19 the the DT 31417 405 20 reality reality NN 31417 405 21 of of IN 31417 405 22 the the DT 31417 405 23 Physical Physical NNP 31417 405 24 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 405 25 alleged allege VBD 31417 405 26 to to TO 31417 405 27 have have VB 31417 405 28 occurred occur VBN 31417 405 29 in in IN 31417 405 30 the the DT 31417 405 31 presence presence NN 31417 405 32 of of IN 31417 405 33 D. D. NNP 31417 405 34 D. D. NNP 31417 405 35 Home Home NNP 31417 405 36 is be VBZ 31417 405 37 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 405 38 to to TO 31417 405 39 be be VB 31417 405 40 looked look VBN 31417 405 41 for for IN 31417 405 42 in in IN 31417 405 43 the the DT 31417 405 44 two two CD 31417 405 45 volumes volume NNS 31417 405 46 written write VBN 31417 405 47 by by IN 31417 405 48 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 405 49 , , , 31417 405 50 nor nor CC 31417 405 51 even even RB 31417 405 52 in in IN 31417 405 53 the the DT 31417 405 54 two two CD 31417 405 55 volumes volume NNS 31417 405 56 published publish VBN 31417 405 57 after after IN 31417 405 58 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 405 59 death death NN 31417 405 60 by by IN 31417 405 61 Madame Madame NNP 31417 405 62 Home Home NNP 31417 405 63 . . . 31417 406 1 The the DT 31417 406 2 alleged alleged JJ 31417 406 3 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 406 4 failed fail VBD 31417 406 5 to to TO 31417 406 6 attract attract VB 31417 406 7 the the DT 31417 406 8 attention attention NN 31417 406 9 of of IN 31417 406 10 more more JJR 31417 406 11 than than IN 31417 406 12 a a DT 31417 406 13 very very RB 31417 406 14 few few JJ 31417 406 15 men man NNS 31417 406 16 of of IN 31417 406 17 science science NN 31417 406 18 during during IN 31417 406 19 Home home NN 31417 406 20 's 's POS 31417 406 21 lifetime lifetime NN 31417 406 22 . . . 31417 407 1 Of of IN 31417 407 2 these these DT 31417 407 3 the the DT 31417 407 4 most most RBS 31417 407 5 eminent eminent JJ 31417 407 6 is be VBZ 31417 407 7 Sir Sir NNP 31417 407 8 William William NNP 31417 407 9 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 407 10 , , , 31417 407 11 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 408 1 With with IN 31417 408 2 regard regard NN 31417 408 3 to to IN 31417 408 4 Sir Sir NNP 31417 408 5 William William NNP 31417 408 6 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 408 7 ' ' POS 31417 408 8 evidence evidence NN 31417 408 9 the the DT 31417 408 10 reader reader NN 31417 408 11 is be VBZ 31417 408 12 referred refer VBN 31417 408 13 to to IN 31417 408 14 two two CD 31417 408 15 paragraphs paragraph NNS 31417 408 16 on on IN 31417 408 17 page page NN 31417 408 18 124 124 CD 31417 408 19 . . . 31417 409 1 THE the DT 31417 409 2 REPORT REPORT NNP 31417 409 3 OF of IN 31417 409 4 THE the DT 31417 409 5 COMMITTEE COMMITTEE NNP 31417 409 6 OF of IN 31417 409 7 THE the DT 31417 409 8 DIALECTICAL DIALECTICAL NNP 31417 409 9 SOCIETY SOCIETY NNP 31417 409 10 . . . 31417 410 1 Again again RB 31417 410 2 , , , 31417 410 3 the the DT 31417 410 4 Report Report NNP 31417 410 5 of of IN 31417 410 6 the the DT 31417 410 7 Committee Committee NNP 31417 410 8 of of IN 31417 410 9 the the DT 31417 410 10 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 410 11 Society Society NNP 31417 410 12 , , , 31417 410 13 or or CC 31417 410 14 rather rather RB 31417 410 15 the the DT 31417 410 16 documents document NNS 31417 410 17 which which WDT 31417 410 18 accompany accompany VBP 31417 410 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 410 20 , , , 31417 410 21 supplies supply VBZ 31417 410 22 some some DT 31417 410 23 good good JJ 31417 410 24 evidence evidence NN 31417 410 25 . . . 31417 411 1 Home Home NNP 31417 411 2 had have VBD 31417 411 3 four four CD 31417 411 4 sittings sitting NNS 31417 411 5 with with IN 31417 411 6 one one CD 31417 411 7 of of IN 31417 411 8 the the DT 31417 411 9 Sub Sub NNP 31417 411 10 - - HYPH 31417 411 11 Committees Committees NNPS 31417 411 12 , , , 31417 411 13 but but CC 31417 411 14 the the DT 31417 411 15 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 411 16 were be VBD 31417 411 17 of of IN 31417 411 18 a a DT 31417 411 19 trifling trifling NN 31417 411 20 and and CC 31417 411 21 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 31417 411 22 character character NN 31417 411 23 . . . 31417 412 1 This this DT 31417 412 2 was be VBD 31417 412 3 attributed attribute VBN 31417 412 4 to to IN 31417 412 5 the the DT 31417 412 6 state state NN 31417 412 7 of of IN 31417 412 8 Home Home NNP 31417 412 9 's 's POS 31417 412 10 bodily bodily JJ 31417 412 11 health health NN 31417 412 12 . . . 31417 413 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 413 2 was be VBD 31417 413 3 on on IN 31417 413 4 the the DT 31417 413 5 eve eve NN 31417 413 6 of of IN 31417 413 7 a a DT 31417 413 8 severe severe JJ 31417 413 9 illness illness NN 31417 413 10 . . . 31417 414 1 Several several JJ 31417 414 2 persons person NNS 31417 414 3 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 414 4 sent send VBN 31417 414 5 to to IN 31417 414 6 the the DT 31417 414 7 Committee Committee NNP 31417 414 8 statements statement NNS 31417 414 9 of of IN 31417 414 10 what what WP 31417 414 11 they -PRON- PRP 31417 414 12 had have VBD 31417 414 13 seen see VBN 31417 414 14 and and CC 31417 414 15 heard hear VBN 31417 414 16 in in IN 31417 414 17 Home home NN 31417 414 18 's 's POS 31417 414 19 presence presence NN 31417 414 20 . . . 31417 415 1 The the DT 31417 415 2 only only JJ 31417 415 3 one one CD 31417 415 4 of of IN 31417 415 5 these these DT 31417 415 6 which which WDT 31417 415 7 can can MD 31417 415 8 be be VB 31417 415 9 said say VBN 31417 415 10 to to TO 31417 415 11 possess possess VB 31417 415 12 scientific scientific JJ 31417 415 13 value value NN 31417 415 14 is be VBZ 31417 415 15 a a DT 31417 415 16 report report NN 31417 415 17 of of IN 31417 415 18 a a DT 31417 415 19 seance seance NN 31417 415 20 held hold VBN 31417 415 21 with with IN 31417 415 22 Lord Lord NNP 31417 415 23 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 415 24 -- -- : 31417 415 25 now now RB 31417 415 26 the the DT 31417 415 27 Earl Earl NNP 31417 415 28 of of IN 31417 415 29 Crawford Crawford NNP 31417 415 30 and and CC 31417 415 31 Balcarres Balcarres NNP 31417 415 32 -- -- : 31417 415 33 and and CC 31417 415 34 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 415 35 Honywood Honywood NNP 31417 415 36 , , , 31417 415 37 and and CC 31417 415 38 two two CD 31417 415 39 other other JJ 31417 415 40 persons person NNS 31417 415 41 . . . 31417 416 1 The the DT 31417 416 2 report report NN 31417 416 3 is be VBZ 31417 416 4 as as IN 31417 416 5 follows follow VBZ 31417 416 6 . . . 31417 417 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 417 2 is be VBZ 31417 417 3 written write VBN 31417 417 4 by by IN 31417 417 5 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 417 6 Honywood Honywood NNP 31417 417 7 , , , 31417 417 8 and and CC 31417 417 9 Lord Lord NNP 31417 417 10 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 417 11 adds add VBZ 31417 417 12 a a DT 31417 417 13 few few JJ 31417 417 14 words word NNS 31417 417 15 , , , 31417 417 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 417 17 own own JJ 31417 417 18 personal personal JJ 31417 417 19 testimony testimony NN 31417 417 20 . . . 31417 418 1 " " `` 31417 418 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 418 3 met meet VBD 31417 418 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 418 5 Home Home NNP 31417 418 6 at at IN 31417 418 7 the the DT 31417 418 8 house house NN 31417 418 9 of of IN 31417 418 10 a a DT 31417 418 11 friend friend NN 31417 418 12 on on IN 31417 418 13 the the DT 31417 418 14 17th 17th JJ 31417 418 15 March March NNP 31417 418 16 1869 1869 CD 31417 418 17 . . . 31417 419 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 419 2 sat sit VBD 31417 419 3 down down RP 31417 419 4 , , , 31417 419 5 five five CD 31417 419 6 in in IN 31417 419 7 number number NN 31417 419 8 , , , 31417 419 9 at at IN 31417 419 10 a a DT 31417 419 11 round round JJ 31417 419 12 table table NN 31417 419 13 in in IN 31417 419 14 the the DT 31417 419 15 back back JJ 31417 419 16 drawing drawing NN 31417 419 17 - - HYPH 31417 419 18 room room NN 31417 419 19 . . . 31417 420 1 There there EX 31417 420 2 was be VBD 31417 420 3 an an DT 31417 420 4 oil oil NN 31417 420 5 lamp lamp NN 31417 420 6 on on IN 31417 420 7 a a DT 31417 420 8 table table NN 31417 420 9 in in IN 31417 420 10 the the DT 31417 420 11 front front JJ 31417 420 12 drawing drawing NN 31417 420 13 - - HYPH 31417 420 14 room room NN 31417 420 15 , , , 31417 420 16 and and CC 31417 420 17 fires fire NNS 31417 420 18 in in IN 31417 420 19 both both DT 31417 420 20 grates grate NNS 31417 420 21 . . . 31417 421 1 After after IN 31417 421 2 a a DT 31417 421 3 while while NN 31417 421 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 421 5 Home Home NNP 31417 421 6 became become VBD 31417 421 7 entranced entrance VBN 31417 421 8 , , , 31417 421 9 walked walk VBD 31417 421 10 into into IN 31417 421 11 the the DT 31417 421 12 front front JJ 31417 421 13 room room NN 31417 421 14 , , , 31417 421 15 and and CC 31417 421 16 stood stand VBD 31417 421 17 on on IN 31417 421 18 the the DT 31417 421 19 hearth hearth JJ 31417 421 20 - - HYPH 31417 421 21 rug rug NN 31417 421 22 . . . 31417 422 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 422 2 began begin VBD 31417 422 3 to to TO 31417 422 4 dance dance VB 31417 422 5 slowly slowly RB 31417 422 6 , , , 31417 422 7 raising raise VBG 31417 422 8 first first RB 31417 422 9 the the DT 31417 422 10 one one CD 31417 422 11 foot foot NN 31417 422 12 and and CC 31417 422 13 then then RB 31417 422 14 the the DT 31417 422 15 other other JJ 31417 422 16 , , , 31417 422 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 422 18 hands hand NNS 31417 422 19 hanging hang VBG 31417 422 20 loosely loosely RB 31417 422 21 as as IN 31417 422 22 I -PRON- PRP 31417 422 23 have have VBP 31417 422 24 read read VBN 31417 422 25 of of IN 31417 422 26 Easterns Easterns NNPS 31417 422 27 and and CC 31417 422 28 Indians Indians NNPS 31417 422 29 , , , 31417 422 30 moving move VBG 31417 422 31 in in IN 31417 422 32 time time NN 31417 422 33 to to IN 31417 422 34 music music NN 31417 422 35 . . . 31417 423 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 423 2 then then RB 31417 423 3 knelt kneel VBD 31417 423 4 down down RP 31417 423 5 , , , 31417 423 6 rubbing rub VBG 31417 423 7 and and CC 31417 423 8 clasping clasp VBG 31417 423 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 423 10 hands hand NNS 31417 423 11 together together RB 31417 423 12 in in IN 31417 423 13 front front NN 31417 423 14 of of IN 31417 423 15 the the DT 31417 423 16 fire fire NN 31417 423 17 . . . 31417 424 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 424 2 asked ask VBD 31417 424 3 , , , 31417 424 4 ' ' '' 31417 424 5 Are be VBP 31417 424 6 you -PRON- PRP 31417 424 7 a a DT 31417 424 8 fire fire NN 31417 424 9 worshipper worshipper NN 31417 424 10 ? ? . 31417 424 11 ' ' '' 31417 425 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 425 2 nodded nod VBD 31417 425 3 and and CC 31417 425 4 looked look VBD 31417 425 5 pleased pleased JJ 31417 425 6 . . . 31417 426 1 ' ' `` 31417 426 2 Are be VBP 31417 426 3 you -PRON- PRP 31417 426 4 a a DT 31417 426 5 Persian Persian NNP 31417 426 6 ? ? . 31417 426 7 ' ' '' 31417 427 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 427 2 smiled smile VBD 31417 427 3 and and CC 31417 427 4 nodded nod VBN 31417 427 5 assent assent NN 31417 427 6 , , , 31417 427 7 after after IN 31417 427 8 which which WDT 31417 427 9 he -PRON- PRP 31417 427 10 rose rise VBD 31417 427 11 and and CC 31417 427 12 placed place VBD 31417 427 13 four four CD 31417 427 14 chairs chair NNS 31417 427 15 in in IN 31417 427 16 a a DT 31417 427 17 row row NN 31417 427 18 near near IN 31417 427 19 the the DT 31417 427 20 folding fold VBG 31417 427 21 doors door NNS 31417 427 22 , , , 31417 427 23 signing sign VBG 31417 427 24 to to IN 31417 427 25 us -PRON- PRP 31417 427 26 to to TO 31417 427 27 sit sit VB 31417 427 28 there there RB 31417 427 29 . . . 31417 428 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 428 2 now now RB 31417 428 3 went go VBD 31417 428 4 to to IN 31417 428 5 the the DT 31417 428 6 table table NN 31417 428 7 on on IN 31417 428 8 which which WDT 31417 428 9 stood stand VBD 31417 428 10 the the DT 31417 428 11 moderator moderator NN 31417 428 12 lamp lamp NN 31417 428 13 ; ; : 31417 428 14 taking take VBG 31417 428 15 off off RP 31417 428 16 the the DT 31417 428 17 globe globe NN 31417 428 18 , , , 31417 428 19 he -PRON- PRP 31417 428 20 placed place VBD 31417 428 21 it -PRON- PRP 31417 428 22 on on IN 31417 428 23 the the DT 31417 428 24 table table NN 31417 428 25 , , , 31417 428 26 and and CC 31417 428 27 deliberately deliberately RB 31417 428 28 grasped grasp VBD 31417 428 29 the the DT 31417 428 30 chimney chimney NN 31417 428 31 of of IN 31417 428 32 the the DT 31417 428 33 lamp lamp NN 31417 428 34 with with IN 31417 428 35 both both DT 31417 428 36 hands hand NNS 31417 428 37 ; ; : 31417 428 38 then then RB 31417 428 39 , , , 31417 428 40 advancing advance VBG 31417 428 41 to to IN 31417 428 42 the the DT 31417 428 43 lady lady NN 31417 428 44 of of IN 31417 428 45 the the DT 31417 428 46 house house NN 31417 428 47 , , , 31417 428 48 he -PRON- PRP 31417 428 49 asked ask VBD 31417 428 50 her -PRON- PRP 31417 428 51 to to TO 31417 428 52 touch touch VB 31417 428 53 it -PRON- PRP 31417 428 54 , , , 31417 428 55 but but CC 31417 428 56 she -PRON- PRP 31417 428 57 refused refuse VBD 31417 428 58 , , , 31417 428 59 knowing know VBG 31417 428 60 it -PRON- PRP 31417 428 61 was be VBD 31417 428 62 hot hot JJ 31417 428 63 . . . 31417 429 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 429 2 Home Home NNP 31417 429 3 said say VBD 31417 429 4 , , , 31417 429 5 ' ' `` 31417 429 6 Have have VBP 31417 429 7 you -PRON- PRP 31417 429 8 no no DT 31417 429 9 faith faith NN 31417 429 10 ? ? . 31417 430 1 Will Will MD 31417 430 2 you -PRON- PRP 31417 430 3 not not RB 31417 430 4 trust trust VB 31417 430 5 in in IN 31417 430 6 Dan Dan NNP 31417 430 7 if if IN 31417 430 8 he -PRON- PRP 31417 430 9 says say VBZ 31417 430 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 430 11 is be VBZ 31417 430 12 cool cool JJ 31417 430 13 ? ? . 31417 430 14 ' ' '' 31417 431 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 431 2 replied reply VBD 31417 431 3 , , , 31417 431 4 ' ' '' 31417 431 5 Certainly certainly RB 31417 431 6 , , , 31417 431 7 ' ' '' 31417 431 8 and and CC 31417 431 9 placed place VBD 31417 431 10 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 431 11 finger finger NN 31417 431 12 on on IN 31417 431 13 the the DT 31417 431 14 glass glass NN 31417 431 15 , , , 31417 431 16 exclaiming exclaim VBG 31417 431 17 , , , 31417 431 18 ' ' '' 31417 431 19 Oh oh UH 31417 431 20 , , , 31417 431 21 it -PRON- PRP 31417 431 22 is be VBZ 31417 431 23 not not RB 31417 431 24 at at RB 31417 431 25 all all RB 31417 431 26 hot hot JJ 31417 431 27 ! ! . 31417 431 28 ' ' '' 31417 432 1 This this DT 31417 432 2 was be VBD 31417 432 3 corroborated corroborate VBN 31417 432 4 by by IN 31417 432 5 Lord Lord NNP 31417 432 6 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 432 7 and and CC 31417 432 8 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 432 9 , , , 31417 432 10 who who WP 31417 432 11 in in IN 31417 432 12 turn turn NN 31417 432 13 both both DT 31417 432 14 laid lay VBD 31417 432 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 432 16 finger finger NN 31417 432 17 on on IN 31417 432 18 the the DT 31417 432 19 glass glass NN 31417 432 20 several several JJ 31417 432 21 times time NNS 31417 432 22 to to TO 31417 432 23 test test VB 31417 432 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 432 25 . . . 31417 433 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 433 2 Home Home NNP 31417 433 3 laughed laugh VBD 31417 433 4 and and CC 31417 433 5 said say VBD 31417 433 6 , , , 31417 433 7 ' ' '' 31417 433 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 433 9 will will MD 31417 433 10 make make VB 31417 433 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 433 12 hot hot JJ 31417 433 13 for for IN 31417 433 14 you -PRON- PRP 31417 433 15 , , , 31417 433 16 old old JJ 31417 433 17 fellow fellow NN 31417 433 18 , , , 31417 433 19 ' ' '' 31417 433 20 and and CC 31417 433 21 holding hold VBG 31417 433 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 433 23 towards towards IN 31417 433 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 433 25 ---- ---- NNP 31417 433 26 , , , 31417 433 27 he -PRON- PRP 31417 433 28 turned turn VBD 31417 433 29 , , , 31417 433 30 apparently apparently RB 31417 433 31 addressing address VBG 31417 433 32 some some DT 31417 433 33 one one NN 31417 433 34 , , , 31417 433 35 and and CC 31417 433 36 said say VBD 31417 433 37 , , , 31417 433 38 in in IN 31417 433 39 a a DT 31417 433 40 sad sad JJ 31417 433 41 tone tone NN 31417 433 42 of of IN 31417 433 43 voice voice NN 31417 433 44 , , , 31417 433 45 ' ' '' 31417 433 46 It -PRON- PRP 31417 433 47 is be VBZ 31417 433 48 necessary necessary JJ 31417 433 49 to to TO 31417 433 50 confirm confirm VB 31417 433 51 the the DT 31417 433 52 faith faith NN 31417 433 53 of of IN 31417 433 54 others other NNS 31417 433 55 that that IN 31417 433 56 the the DT 31417 433 57 glass glass NN 31417 433 58 should should MD 31417 433 59 be be VB 31417 433 60 made make VBN 31417 433 61 hot hot JJ 31417 433 62 for for IN 31417 433 63 him -PRON- PRP 31417 433 64 . . . 31417 433 65 ' ' '' 31417 434 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 434 2 ---- ---- NNP 31417 434 3 now now RB 31417 434 4 touched touch VBD 31417 434 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 434 6 , , , 31417 434 7 and and CC 31417 434 8 exclaimed exclaim VBD 31417 434 9 , , , 31417 434 10 ' ' '' 31417 434 11 You -PRON- PRP 31417 434 12 have have VBP 31417 434 13 indeed indeed RB 31417 434 14 , , , 31417 434 15 ' ' '' 31417 434 16 shaking shake VBG 31417 434 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 434 18 hand hand NN 31417 434 19 and and CC 31417 434 20 showing show VBG 31417 434 21 me -PRON- PRP 31417 434 22 a a DT 31417 434 23 red red JJ 31417 434 24 mark mark NN 31417 434 25 . . . 31417 435 1 So so RB 31417 435 2 hot hot JJ 31417 435 3 was be VBD 31417 435 4 the the DT 31417 435 5 glass glass NN 31417 435 6 when when WRB 31417 435 7 a a DT 31417 435 8 fourth fourth JJ 31417 435 9 person person NN 31417 435 10 touched touch VBD 31417 435 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 435 12 , , , 31417 435 13 that that IN 31417 435 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 435 15 raised raise VBD 31417 435 16 a a DT 31417 435 17 blister blister NN 31417 435 18 , , , 31417 435 19 which which WDT 31417 435 20 I -PRON- PRP 31417 435 21 saw see VBD 31417 435 22 some some DT 31417 435 23 days day NNS 31417 435 24 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 435 25 , , , 31417 435 26 peeling peel VBG 31417 435 27 . . . 31417 436 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 436 2 leave leave VBP 31417 436 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 436 4 for for IN 31417 436 5 the the DT 31417 436 6 scientific scientific JJ 31417 436 7 to to TO 31417 436 8 determine determine VB 31417 436 9 how how WRB 31417 436 10 the the DT 31417 436 11 heat heat NN 31417 436 12 was be VBD 31417 436 13 re re VBN 31417 436 14 - - VBN 31417 436 15 imparted impart VBN 31417 436 16 to to IN 31417 436 17 the the DT 31417 436 18 glass glass NN 31417 436 19 , , , 31417 436 20 after after IN 31417 436 21 being be VBG 31417 436 22 withdrawn withdraw VBN 31417 436 23 . . . 31417 437 1 " " `` 31417 437 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 437 3 Home Home NNP 31417 437 4 now now RB 31417 437 5 returned return VBD 31417 437 6 to to IN 31417 437 7 the the DT 31417 437 8 fireplace fireplace NN 31417 437 9 , , , 31417 437 10 and and CC 31417 437 11 thrust thrust VBD 31417 437 12 the the DT 31417 437 13 chimney chimney NN 31417 437 14 into into IN 31417 437 15 the the DT 31417 437 16 red red JJ 31417 437 17 - - HYPH 31417 437 18 hot hot JJ 31417 437 19 coals coal NNS 31417 437 20 , , , 31417 437 21 resting rest VBG 31417 437 22 the the DT 31417 437 23 end end NN 31417 437 24 on on IN 31417 437 25 the the DT 31417 437 26 top top JJ 31417 437 27 bar bar NN 31417 437 28 ; ; : 31417 437 29 he -PRON- PRP 31417 437 30 left leave VBD 31417 437 31 it -PRON- PRP 31417 437 32 there there RB 31417 437 33 about about IN 31417 437 34 four four CD 31417 437 35 or or CC 31417 437 36 five five CD 31417 437 37 minutes minute NNS 31417 437 38 , , , 31417 437 39 then then RB 31417 437 40 , , , 31417 437 41 lifting lift VBG 31417 437 42 it -PRON- PRP 31417 437 43 , , , 31417 437 44 he -PRON- PRP 31417 437 45 clasped clasp VBD 31417 437 46 it -PRON- PRP 31417 437 47 in in IN 31417 437 48 both both DT 31417 437 49 hands hand NNS 31417 437 50 , , , 31417 437 51 went go VBD 31417 437 52 to to IN 31417 437 53 the the DT 31417 437 54 table table NN 31417 437 55 , , , 31417 437 56 took take VBD 31417 437 57 a a DT 31417 437 58 lucifer lucifer NN 31417 437 59 match match NN 31417 437 60 from from IN 31417 437 61 a a DT 31417 437 62 box box NN 31417 437 63 , , , 31417 437 64 and and CC 31417 437 65 handing hand VBG 31417 437 66 it -PRON- PRP 31417 437 67 to to IN 31417 437 68 the the DT 31417 437 69 lady lady NN 31417 437 70 of of IN 31417 437 71 the the DT 31417 437 72 house house NN 31417 437 73 , , , 31417 437 74 desired desire VBD 31417 437 75 her -PRON- PRP 31417 437 76 to to TO 31417 437 77 touch touch VB 31417 437 78 the the DT 31417 437 79 glass glass NN 31417 437 80 -- -- : 31417 437 81 the the DT 31417 437 82 match match NN 31417 437 83 instantly instantly RB 31417 437 84 ignited ignite VBD 31417 437 85 ; ; : 31417 437 86 and and CC 31417 437 87 having have VBG 31417 437 88 called call VBN 31417 437 89 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 437 90 attention attention NN 31417 437 91 to to IN 31417 437 92 this this DT 31417 437 93 fact fact NN 31417 437 94 , , , 31417 437 95 he -PRON- PRP 31417 437 96 observed observe VBD 31417 437 97 , , , 31417 437 98 ' ' '' 31417 437 99 The the DT 31417 437 100 tongue tongue NN 31417 437 101 and and CC 31417 437 102 lips lip NNS 31417 437 103 are be VBP 31417 437 104 the the DT 31417 437 105 most most RBS 31417 437 106 sensitive sensitive JJ 31417 437 107 parts part NNS 31417 437 108 of of IN 31417 437 109 the the DT 31417 437 110 body body NN 31417 437 111 , , , 31417 437 112 ' ' '' 31417 437 113 and and CC 31417 437 114 thrust thrust VBD 31417 437 115 the the DT 31417 437 116 heated heated JJ 31417 437 117 glass glass NN 31417 437 118 into into IN 31417 437 119 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 437 120 mouth mouth NN 31417 437 121 , , , 31417 437 122 applying apply VBG 31417 437 123 , , , 31417 437 124 especially especially RB 31417 437 125 , , , 31417 437 126 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 437 127 tongue tongue NN 31417 437 128 to to IN 31417 437 129 it -PRON- PRP 31417 437 130 . . . 31417 438 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 438 2 once once RB 31417 438 3 more more RBR 31417 438 4 returned return VBD 31417 438 5 to to IN 31417 438 6 the the DT 31417 438 7 fire fire NN 31417 438 8 , , , 31417 438 9 and and CC 31417 438 10 again again RB 31417 438 11 placed place VBD 31417 438 12 the the DT 31417 438 13 chimney chimney NN 31417 438 14 on on IN 31417 438 15 the the DT 31417 438 16 upper upper JJ 31417 438 17 bar bar NN 31417 438 18 , , , 31417 438 19 the the DT 31417 438 20 end end NN 31417 438 21 of of IN 31417 438 22 the the DT 31417 438 23 glass glass NN 31417 438 24 resting rest VBG 31417 438 25 amidst amidst IN 31417 438 26 the the DT 31417 438 27 red red JJ 31417 438 28 coals coal NNS 31417 438 29 . . . 31417 439 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 439 2 left leave VBD 31417 439 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 439 4 there there RB 31417 439 5 and and CC 31417 439 6 walked walk VBD 31417 439 7 about about IN 31417 439 8 the the DT 31417 439 9 room room NN 31417 439 10 , , , 31417 439 11 selected select VBD 31417 439 12 a a DT 31417 439 13 small small JJ 31417 439 14 fern fern JJ 31417 439 15 - - HYPH 31417 439 16 leaf leaf NN 31417 439 17 from from IN 31417 439 18 a a DT 31417 439 19 vase vase NN 31417 439 20 of of IN 31417 439 21 flowers flower NNS 31417 439 22 , , , 31417 439 23 and and CC 31417 439 24 raising raise VBG 31417 439 25 the the DT 31417 439 26 chimney chimney NN 31417 439 27 , , , 31417 439 28 placed place VBD 31417 439 29 it -PRON- PRP 31417 439 30 within within IN 31417 439 31 , , , 31417 439 32 and and CC 31417 439 33 replaced replace VBD 31417 439 34 the the DT 31417 439 35 chimney chimney NN 31417 439 36 among among IN 31417 439 37 the the DT 31417 439 38 coals coal NNS 31417 439 39 . . . 31417 440 1 After after IN 31417 440 2 a a DT 31417 440 3 few few JJ 31417 440 4 moments moment NNS 31417 440 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 440 6 told tell VBD 31417 440 7 us -PRON- PRP 31417 440 8 to to TO 31417 440 9 observe observe VB 31417 440 10 very very RB 31417 440 11 carefully carefully RB 31417 440 12 , , , 31417 440 13 as as IN 31417 440 14 the the DT 31417 440 15 experiment experiment NN 31417 440 16 would would MD 31417 440 17 be be VB 31417 440 18 very very RB 31417 440 19 pretty pretty JJ 31417 440 20 . . . 31417 441 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 441 2 Home Home NNP 31417 441 3 now now RB 31417 441 4 held hold VBD 31417 441 5 up up RP 31417 441 6 the the DT 31417 441 7 glass glass NN 31417 441 8 , , , 31417 441 9 and and CC 31417 441 10 we -PRON- PRP 31417 441 11 perceived perceive VBD 31417 441 12 the the DT 31417 441 13 fern fern JJ 31417 441 14 - - HYPH 31417 441 15 leaf leaf NN 31417 441 16 within within IN 31417 441 17 apparently apparently RB 31417 441 18 on on IN 31417 441 19 fire fire NN 31417 441 20 . . . 31417 442 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 442 2 replaced replace VBD 31417 442 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 442 4 after after IN 31417 442 5 a a DT 31417 442 6 few few JJ 31417 442 7 seconds second NNS 31417 442 8 , , , 31417 442 9 and and CC 31417 442 10 holding hold VBG 31417 442 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 442 12 up up RP 31417 442 13 again again RB 31417 442 14 , , , 31417 442 15 exclaimed exclaimed NNP 31417 442 16 , , , 31417 442 17 ' ' '' 31417 442 18 Is be VBZ 31417 442 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 442 20 not not RB 31417 442 21 pretty pretty JJ 31417 442 22 ? ? . 31417 442 23 ' ' '' 31417 443 1 The the DT 31417 443 2 fern fern NN 31417 443 3 appeared appear VBD 31417 443 4 red red JJ 31417 443 5 - - HYPH 31417 443 6 hot hot JJ 31417 443 7 ; ; : 31417 443 8 each each DT 31417 443 9 little little JJ 31417 443 10 leaf leaf NN 31417 443 11 edged edge VBD 31417 443 12 with with IN 31417 443 13 gold gold NN 31417 443 14 , , , 31417 443 15 yet yet CC 31417 443 16 flameless flameless JJ 31417 443 17 , , , 31417 443 18 like like IN 31417 443 19 clouds cloud NNS 31417 443 20 at at IN 31417 443 21 sunset sunset NN 31417 443 22 -- -- : 31417 443 23 rich rich JJ 31417 443 24 glowing glow VBG 31417 443 25 crimson crimson NN 31417 443 26 tinged tinge VBD 31417 443 27 with with IN 31417 443 28 molten molten JJ 31417 443 29 gold gold NN 31417 443 30 . . . 31417 444 1 After after IN 31417 444 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 444 3 had have VBD 31417 444 4 all all DT 31417 444 5 looked look VBN 31417 444 6 at at IN 31417 444 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 444 8 and and CC 31417 444 9 admired admire VBD 31417 444 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 444 11 , , , 31417 444 12 he -PRON- PRP 31417 444 13 advanced advance VBD 31417 444 14 to to IN 31417 444 15 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 444 16 ---- ---- NFP 31417 444 17 , , , 31417 444 18 and and CC 31417 444 19 laughingly laughingly RB 31417 444 20 shook shake VBD 31417 444 21 it -PRON- PRP 31417 444 22 out out RP 31417 444 23 on on IN 31417 444 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 444 25 muslin muslin NN 31417 444 26 dress dress NN 31417 444 27 . . . 31417 445 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 445 2 expected expect VBD 31417 445 3 to to TO 31417 445 4 see see VB 31417 445 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 445 6 crumble crumble VB 31417 445 7 away away RB 31417 445 8 ; ; : 31417 445 9 but but CC 31417 445 10 no no UH 31417 445 11 , , , 31417 445 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 445 13 was be VBD 31417 445 14 still still RB 31417 445 15 green green JJ 31417 445 16 , , , 31417 445 17 though though IN 31417 445 18 dry dry JJ 31417 445 19 and and CC 31417 445 20 withered withered JJ 31417 445 21 . . . 31417 446 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 31417 446 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 446 3 was be VBD 31417 446 4 not not RB 31417 446 5 preserved preserve VBN 31417 446 6 . . . 31417 447 1 " " `` 31417 447 2 Again again RB 31417 447 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 447 4 Home Home NNP 31417 447 5 returned return VBD 31417 447 6 to to IN 31417 447 7 the the DT 31417 447 8 fire fire NN 31417 447 9 , , , 31417 447 10 and and CC 31417 447 11 once once RB 31417 447 12 more more RBR 31417 447 13 placed place VBD 31417 447 14 the the DT 31417 447 15 glass glass NN 31417 447 16 on on IN 31417 447 17 the the DT 31417 447 18 coals coal NNS 31417 447 19 , , , 31417 447 20 where where WRB 31417 447 21 he -PRON- PRP 31417 447 22 left leave VBD 31417 447 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 447 24 , , , 31417 447 25 and and CC 31417 447 26 walked walk VBD 31417 447 27 about about IN 31417 447 28 the the DT 31417 447 29 room room NN 31417 447 30 ; ; : 31417 447 31 going go VBG 31417 447 32 to to IN 31417 447 33 the the DT 31417 447 34 lamp lamp NN 31417 447 35 , , , 31417 447 36 he -PRON- PRP 31417 447 37 passed pass VBD 31417 447 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 447 39 hand hand NN 31417 447 40 slowly slowly RB 31417 447 41 backwards backwards RB 31417 447 42 and and CC 31417 447 43 forwards forwards RB 31417 447 44 through through IN 31417 447 45 the the DT 31417 447 46 flame flame NN 31417 447 47 , , , 31417 447 48 not not RB 31417 447 49 an an DT 31417 447 50 inch inch NN 31417 447 51 from from IN 31417 447 52 the the DT 31417 447 53 wick wick NN 31417 447 54 ; ; : 31417 447 55 returning return VBG 31417 447 56 to to IN 31417 447 57 the the DT 31417 447 58 fireplace fireplace NN 31417 447 59 , , , 31417 447 60 he -PRON- PRP 31417 447 61 lifted lift VBD 31417 447 62 the the DT 31417 447 63 chimney chimney NN 31417 447 64 , , , 31417 447 65 and and CC 31417 447 66 moving move VBG 31417 447 67 the the DT 31417 447 68 coals coal NNS 31417 447 69 about about IN 31417 447 70 with with IN 31417 447 71 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 447 72 hand hand NN 31417 447 73 , , , 31417 447 74 selected select VBD 31417 447 75 a a DT 31417 447 76 small small JJ 31417 447 77 flat flat JJ 31417 447 78 red red JJ 31417 447 79 - - HYPH 31417 447 80 hot hot JJ 31417 447 81 coal coal NN 31417 447 82 , , , 31417 447 83 and and CC 31417 447 84 placed place VBD 31417 447 85 it -PRON- PRP 31417 447 86 in in IN 31417 447 87 the the DT 31417 447 88 chimney chimney NN 31417 447 89 -- -- : 31417 447 90 shook shake VBD 31417 447 91 it -PRON- PRP 31417 447 92 up up RP 31417 447 93 and and CC 31417 447 94 down down RB 31417 447 95 , , , 31417 447 96 and and CC 31417 447 97 advancing advance VBG 31417 447 98 to to IN 31417 447 99 us -PRON- PRP 31417 447 100 , , , 31417 447 101 playfully playfully RB 31417 447 102 said say VBD 31417 447 103 , , , 31417 447 104 ' ' '' 31417 447 105 H---- H---- NNP 31417 447 106 , , , 31417 447 107 here here RB 31417 447 108 is be VBZ 31417 447 109 a a DT 31417 447 110 present present NN 31417 447 111 for for IN 31417 447 112 you -PRON- PRP 31417 447 113 , , , 31417 447 114 ' ' '' 31417 447 115 and and CC 31417 447 116 threw throw VBD 31417 447 117 out out RP 31417 447 118 the the DT 31417 447 119 coal coal NN 31417 447 120 on on IN 31417 447 121 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 447 122 muslin muslin NN 31417 447 123 dress dress NN 31417 447 124 . . . 31417 448 1 Catching catch VBG 31417 448 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 448 3 up up RP 31417 448 4 in in IN 31417 448 5 dismay dismay NN 31417 448 6 , , , 31417 448 7 she -PRON- PRP 31417 448 8 tossed toss VBD 31417 448 9 it -PRON- PRP 31417 448 10 to to IN 31417 448 11 Lord Lord NNP 31417 448 12 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 448 13 , , , 31417 448 14 who who WP 31417 448 15 , , , 31417 448 16 unable unable JJ 31417 448 17 to to TO 31417 448 18 retain retain VB 31417 448 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 448 20 in in IN 31417 448 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 448 22 hand hand NN 31417 448 23 , , , 31417 448 24 threw throw VBD 31417 448 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 448 26 from from IN 31417 448 27 palm palm NN 31417 448 28 to to TO 31417 448 29 palm palm NN 31417 448 30 till till IN 31417 448 31 he -PRON- PRP 31417 448 32 reached reach VBD 31417 448 33 , , , 31417 448 34 the the DT 31417 448 35 grate grate NN 31417 448 36 and and CC 31417 448 37 flung fling VBD 31417 448 38 it -PRON- PRP 31417 448 39 in in RP 31417 448 40 . . . 31417 449 1 While while IN 31417 449 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 449 3 were be VBD 31417 449 4 all all RB 31417 449 5 looking look VBG 31417 449 6 at at IN 31417 449 7 the the DT 31417 449 8 muslin muslin NNP 31417 449 9 dress dress NN 31417 449 10 and and CC 31417 449 11 wondering wonder VBG 31417 449 12 that that IN 31417 449 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 449 14 was be VBD 31417 449 15 neither neither CC 31417 449 16 soiled soil VBN 31417 449 17 nor nor CC 31417 449 18 singed singe VBN 31417 449 19 , , , 31417 449 20 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 449 21 Home Home NNP 31417 449 22 approached approach VBD 31417 449 23 , , , 31417 449 24 and and CC 31417 449 25 in in IN 31417 449 26 a a DT 31417 449 27 hurt hurt JJ 31417 449 28 tone tone NN 31417 449 29 of of IN 31417 449 30 voice voice NN 31417 449 31 said say VBD 31417 449 32 , , , 31417 449 33 ' ' '' 31417 449 34 No no UH 31417 449 35 , , , 31417 449 36 no no UH 31417 449 37 , , , 31417 449 38 you -PRON- PRP 31417 449 39 will will MD 31417 449 40 not not RB 31417 449 41 find find VB 31417 449 42 a a DT 31417 449 43 mark mark NN 31417 449 44 ; ; , 31417 449 45 did do VBD 31417 449 46 you -PRON- PRP 31417 449 47 think think VB 31417 449 48 that that IN 31417 449 49 we -PRON- PRP 31417 449 50 would would MD 31417 449 51 hurt hurt VB 31417 449 52 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 449 53 dress dress NN 31417 449 54 . . . 31417 449 55 ' ' '' 31417 450 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 450 2 Home Home NNP 31417 450 3 then then RB 31417 450 4 selected select VBD 31417 450 5 a a DT 31417 450 6 small small JJ 31417 450 7 spray spray NN 31417 450 8 of of IN 31417 450 9 white white JJ 31417 450 10 flower flower NN 31417 450 11 , , , 31417 450 12 and and CC 31417 450 13 going go VBG 31417 450 14 to to IN 31417 450 15 the the DT 31417 450 16 lamp lamp NN 31417 450 17 , , , 31417 450 18 he -PRON- PRP 31417 450 19 passed pass VBD 31417 450 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 450 21 two two CD 31417 450 22 or or CC 31417 450 23 three three CD 31417 450 24 times time NNS 31417 450 25 through through IN 31417 450 26 the the DT 31417 450 27 flame flame NN 31417 450 28 , , , 31417 450 29 then then RB 31417 450 30 carried carry VBD 31417 450 31 it -PRON- PRP 31417 450 32 to to IN 31417 450 33 the the DT 31417 450 34 grate grate NN 31417 450 35 , , , 31417 450 36 and and CC 31417 450 37 held hold VBD 31417 450 38 it -PRON- PRP 31417 450 39 first first RB 31417 450 40 in in IN 31417 450 41 the the DT 31417 450 42 flame flame NN 31417 450 43 and and CC 31417 450 44 then then RB 31417 450 45 in in IN 31417 450 46 the the DT 31417 450 47 smoke smoke NN 31417 450 48 above above IN 31417 450 49 the the DT 31417 450 50 coals coal NNS 31417 450 51 , , , 31417 450 52 moving move VBG 31417 450 53 it -PRON- PRP 31417 450 54 gently gently RB 31417 450 55 about about IN 31417 450 56 . . . 31417 451 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 451 2 now now RB 31417 451 3 brought bring VBD 31417 451 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 451 5 back back RB 31417 451 6 to to IN 31417 451 7 us -PRON- PRP 31417 451 8 , , , 31417 451 9 asking ask VBG 31417 451 10 us -PRON- PRP 31417 451 11 to to TO 31417 451 12 look look VB 31417 451 13 at at IN 31417 451 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 451 15 and and CC 31417 451 16 smell smell VB 31417 451 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 451 18 , , , 31417 451 19 calling call VBG 31417 451 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 451 21 attention attention NN 31417 451 22 to to IN 31417 451 23 the the DT 31417 451 24 fact fact NN 31417 451 25 that that IN 31417 451 26 the the DT 31417 451 27 flower flower NN 31417 451 28 did do VBD 31417 451 29 not not RB 31417 451 30 smell smell VB 31417 451 31 of of IN 31417 451 32 smoke smoke NN 31417 451 33 , , , 31417 451 34 and and CC 31417 451 35 that that IN 31417 451 36 it -PRON- PRP 31417 451 37 was be VBD 31417 451 38 unchanged unchanged JJ 31417 451 39 by by IN 31417 451 40 the the DT 31417 451 41 heat heat NN 31417 451 42 and and CC 31417 451 43 flame flame NN 31417 451 44 of of IN 31417 451 45 lamp lamp NN 31417 451 46 and and CC 31417 451 47 fire fire NN 31417 451 48 . . . 31417 452 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 452 2 then then RB 31417 452 3 bid bid VBD 31417 452 4 us -PRON- PRP 31417 452 5 notice notice VB 31417 452 6 that that IN 31417 452 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 452 8 hand hand NN 31417 452 9 which which WDT 31417 452 10 held hold VBD 31417 452 11 the the DT 31417 452 12 flower flower NN 31417 452 13 smelt smelt NNS 31417 452 14 of of IN 31417 452 15 smoke smoke NN 31417 452 16 , , , 31417 452 17 while while IN 31417 452 18 the the DT 31417 452 19 flower flower NN 31417 452 20 remained remain VBD 31417 452 21 uninjured uninjured JJ 31417 452 22 . . . 31417 453 1 Then then RB 31417 453 2 addressing address VBG 31417 453 3 us -PRON- PRP 31417 453 4 , , , 31417 453 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 453 6 said say VBD 31417 453 7 , , , 31417 453 8 ' ' '' 31417 453 9 The the DT 31417 453 10 spirit spirit NN 31417 453 11 now now RB 31417 453 12 speaking speak VBG 31417 453 13 through through IN 31417 453 14 Dan Dan NNP 31417 453 15 , , , 31417 453 16 and and CC 31417 453 17 that that DT 31417 453 18 has have VBZ 31417 453 19 enabled enable VBN 31417 453 20 him -PRON- PRP 31417 453 21 to to TO 31417 453 22 show show VB 31417 453 23 you -PRON- PRP 31417 453 24 these these DT 31417 453 25 curious curious JJ 31417 453 26 fire fire NN 31417 453 27 - - HYPH 31417 453 28 tests test NNS 31417 453 29 , , , 31417 453 30 in in IN 31417 453 31 which which WDT 31417 453 32 he -PRON- PRP 31417 453 33 hopes hope VBZ 31417 453 34 you -PRON- PRP 31417 453 35 have have VBP 31417 453 36 all all RB 31417 453 37 felt feel VBN 31417 453 38 interested interested JJ 31417 453 39 , , , 31417 453 40 is be VBZ 31417 453 41 the the DT 31417 453 42 spirit spirit NN 31417 453 43 of of IN 31417 453 44 an an DT 31417 453 45 Asiatic asiatic JJ 31417 453 46 fire fire NN 31417 453 47 - - HYPH 31417 453 48 worshipper worshipper NN 31417 453 49 , , , 31417 453 50 who who WP 31417 453 51 was be VBD 31417 453 52 anxious anxious JJ 31417 453 53 to to TO 31417 453 54 come come VB 31417 453 55 here here RB 31417 453 56 to to IN 31417 453 57 - - HYPH 31417 453 58 night night NN 31417 453 59 , , , 31417 453 60 as as IN 31417 453 61 he -PRON- PRP 31417 453 62 had have VBD 31417 453 63 heard hear VBN 31417 453 64 of of IN 31417 453 65 seances seance NNS 31417 453 66 held hold VBN 31417 453 67 here here RB 31417 453 68 . . . 31417 454 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 454 2 now now RB 31417 454 3 bids bid VBZ 31417 454 4 you -PRON- PRP 31417 454 5 farewell farewell VBP 31417 454 6 , , , 31417 454 7 as as IN 31417 454 8 he -PRON- PRP 31417 454 9 will will MD 31417 454 10 return return VB 31417 454 11 no no DT 31417 454 12 more more JJR 31417 454 13 . . . 31417 454 14 ' ' '' 31417 455 1 " " `` 31417 455 2 After after IN 31417 455 3 this this DT 31417 455 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 455 5 Home Home NNP 31417 455 6 awoke awoke NN 31417 455 7 . . . 31417 456 1 " " `` 31417 456 2 BARBARA BARBARA NNP 31417 456 3 HONYWOOD HONYWOOD NNP 31417 456 4 . . . 31417 456 5 " " '' 31417 457 1 " " `` 31417 457 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 457 3 was be VBD 31417 457 4 present present JJ 31417 457 5 at at IN 31417 457 6 this this DT 31417 457 7 seance seance NN 31417 457 8 , , , 31417 457 9 and and CC 31417 457 10 can can MD 31417 457 11 corroborate corroborate VB 31417 457 12 the the DT 31417 457 13 truth truth NN 31417 457 14 of of IN 31417 457 15 the the DT 31417 457 16 above above JJ 31417 457 17 statement statement NN 31417 457 18 . . . 31417 458 1 " " `` 31417 458 2 LINDSAY LINDSAY NNP 31417 458 3 . . . 31417 459 1 " " `` 31417 459 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 459 3 22 22 CD 31417 459 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 459 5 [ [ -LRB- 31417 459 6 NOW now RB 31417 459 7 EARL EARL NNP 31417 459 8 OF of IN 31417 459 9 CRAWFORD CRAWFORD NNP 31417 459 10 AND and CC 31417 459 11 BALCARRES BALCARRES NNP 31417 459 12 . . . 31417 459 13 ] ] -RRB- 31417 460 1 TESTIMONY testimony NN 31417 460 2 OF of IN 31417 460 3 THE the DT 31417 460 4 EARL EARL NNP 31417 460 5 OF of IN 31417 460 6 DUNRAVEN DUNRAVEN NNP 31417 460 7 . . . 31417 461 1 Lord Lord NNP 31417 461 2 Dunraven Dunraven NNP 31417 461 3 -- -- : 31417 461 4 then then RB 31417 461 5 Lord Lord NNP 31417 461 6 Adare Adare NNP 31417 461 7 -- -- : 31417 461 8 had have VBD 31417 461 9 a a DT 31417 461 10 number number NN 31417 461 11 of of IN 31417 461 12 sittings sitting NNS 31417 461 13 with with IN 31417 461 14 Home home NN 31417 461 15 . . . 31417 462 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 462 2 printed print VBD 31417 462 3 a a DT 31417 462 4 small small JJ 31417 462 5 volume volume NN 31417 462 6 -- -- : 31417 462 7 for for IN 31417 462 8 private private JJ 31417 462 9 circulation circulation NN 31417 462 10 only only RB 31417 462 11 -- -- : 31417 462 12 under under IN 31417 462 13 the the DT 31417 462 14 title title NN 31417 462 15 of of IN 31417 462 16 " " `` 31417 462 17 Experiences experience NNS 31417 462 18 in in IN 31417 462 19 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 462 20 with with IN 31417 462 21 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 462 22 D. D. NNP 31417 462 23 D. D. NNP 31417 463 1 Home home NN 31417 463 2 . . . 31417 463 3 " " '' 31417 464 1 This this DT 31417 464 2 volume volume NN 31417 464 3 is be VBZ 31417 464 4 exceedingly exceedingly RB 31417 464 5 scarce scarce JJ 31417 464 6 . . . 31417 465 1 AN an DT 31417 465 2 INQUIRY INQUIRY NNP 31417 465 3 BY by IN 31417 465 4 PROFESSOR PROFESSOR NNP 31417 465 5 W. W. NNP 31417 465 6 F. F. NNP 31417 465 7 BARRETT BARRETT NNP 31417 465 8 , , , 31417 465 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 465 10 , , , 31417 465 11 AND and CC 31417 465 12 MR MR NNP 31417 465 13 . . . 31417 465 14 F. F. NNP 31417 465 15 W. W. NNP 31417 465 16 H. H. NNP 31417 465 17 MYERS MYERS NNP 31417 465 18 . . . 31417 466 1 In in IN 31417 466 2 the the DT 31417 466 3 year year NN 31417 466 4 1889 1889 CD 31417 466 5 , , , 31417 466 6 Professor Professor NNP 31417 466 7 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 466 8 and and CC 31417 466 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 466 10 Myers Myers NNP 31417 466 11 undertook undertake VBD 31417 466 12 an an DT 31417 466 13 " " `` 31417 466 14 Inquiry inquiry NN 31417 466 15 into into IN 31417 466 16 the the DT 31417 466 17 Evidence evidence NN 31417 466 18 for for IN 31417 466 19 the the DT 31417 466 20 Mediumship Mediumship NNP 31417 466 21 of of IN 31417 466 22 D. D. NNP 31417 466 23 D. D. NNP 31417 467 1 Home home NN 31417 467 2 . . . 31417 467 3 " " '' 31417 468 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 468 2 collected collect VBD 31417 468 3 the the DT 31417 468 4 testimony testimony NN 31417 468 5 of of IN 31417 468 6 a a DT 31417 468 7 large large JJ 31417 468 8 number number NN 31417 468 9 of of IN 31417 468 10 persons person NNS 31417 468 11 who who WP 31417 468 12 were be VBD 31417 468 13 witnesses witness NNS 31417 468 14 of of IN 31417 468 15 the the DT 31417 468 16 Home home NN 31417 468 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 468 18 , , , 31417 468 19 carefully carefully RB 31417 468 20 examined examine VBD 31417 468 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 468 22 evidential evidential JJ 31417 468 23 value value NN 31417 468 24 , , , 31417 468 25 and and CC 31417 468 26 summarised summarise VBD 31417 468 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 468 28 in in IN 31417 468 29 a a DT 31417 468 30 Joint Joint NNP 31417 468 31 Report Report NNP 31417 468 32 . . . 31417 469 1 This this DT 31417 469 2 was be VBD 31417 469 3 printed print VBN 31417 469 4 in in IN 31417 469 5 the the DT 31417 469 6 _ _ NNP 31417 469 7 Journal Journal NNP 31417 469 8 _ _ NNP 31417 469 9 of of IN 31417 469 10 the the DT 31417 469 11 Society Society NNP 31417 469 12 for for IN 31417 469 13 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 469 14 Research Research NNP 31417 469 15 for for IN 31417 469 16 July July NNP 31417 469 17 1889 1889 CD 31417 469 18 . . . 31417 470 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 470 2 23 23 CD 31417 470 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 470 4 It -PRON- PRP 31417 470 5 is be VBZ 31417 470 6 to to TO 31417 470 7 be be VB 31417 470 8 regretted regret VBN 31417 470 9 that that IN 31417 470 10 the the DT 31417 470 11 Society Society NNP 31417 470 12 has have VBZ 31417 470 13 not not RB 31417 470 14 seen see VBN 31417 470 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 470 16 way way NN 31417 470 17 to to TO 31417 470 18 publish publish VB 31417 470 19 this this DT 31417 470 20 Report Report NNP 31417 470 21 in in IN 31417 470 22 a a DT 31417 470 23 form form NN 31417 470 24 accessible accessible JJ 31417 470 25 to to IN 31417 470 26 the the DT 31417 470 27 general general JJ 31417 470 28 public public NN 31417 470 29 . . . 31417 471 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 471 2 is be VBZ 31417 471 3 true true JJ 31417 471 4 that that IN 31417 471 5 in in IN 31417 471 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 471 7 great great JJ 31417 471 8 work work NN 31417 471 9 , , , 31417 471 10 " " '' 31417 471 11 Human Human NNP 31417 471 12 Personality Personality NNP 31417 471 13 , , , 31417 471 14 and and CC 31417 471 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 471 16 Survival Survival NNP 31417 471 17 of of IN 31417 471 18 Bodily Bodily NNP 31417 471 19 Death Death NNP 31417 471 20 , , , 31417 471 21 " " '' 31417 471 22 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 471 23 Myers Myers NNP 31417 471 24 gives give VBZ 31417 471 25 a a DT 31417 471 26 brief brief JJ 31417 471 27 summary summary NN 31417 471 28 of of IN 31417 471 29 the the DT 31417 471 30 Report Report NNP 31417 471 31 ; ; : 31417 471 32 but but CC 31417 471 33 he -PRON- PRP 31417 471 34 condenses condense VBZ 31417 471 35 the the DT 31417 471 36 thirty thirty CD 31417 471 37 - - HYPH 31417 471 38 six six CD 31417 471 39 pages page NNS 31417 471 40 of of IN 31417 471 41 the the DT 31417 471 42 original original JJ 31417 471 43 Report Report NNP 31417 471 44 and and CC 31417 471 45 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 471 46 appendices appendix NNS 31417 471 47 into into IN 31417 471 48 four four CD 31417 471 49 pages page NNS 31417 471 50 of of IN 31417 471 51 " " `` 31417 471 52 Human Human NNP 31417 471 53 Personality Personality NNP 31417 471 54 , , , 31417 471 55 " " '' 31417 471 56 which which WDT 31417 471 57 are be VBP 31417 471 58 quite quite RB 31417 471 59 insufficient insufficient JJ 31417 471 60 to to TO 31417 471 61 convey convey VB 31417 471 62 an an DT 31417 471 63 adequate adequate JJ 31417 471 64 idea idea NN 31417 471 65 of of IN 31417 471 66 the the DT 31417 471 67 Report Report NNP 31417 471 68 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 471 69 . . . 31417 472 1 Also also RB 31417 472 2 , , , 31417 472 3 the the DT 31417 472 4 cost cost NN 31417 472 5 of of IN 31417 472 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 472 7 Myers Myers NNP 31417 472 8 ' ' POS 31417 472 9 book book NN 31417 472 10 debars debar VBZ 31417 472 11 from from IN 31417 472 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 472 13 the the DT 31417 472 14 mass mass NN 31417 472 15 of of IN 31417 472 16 readers reader NNS 31417 472 17 . . . 31417 473 1 This this DT 31417 473 2 Report report NN 31417 473 3 was be VBD 31417 473 4 followed follow VBN 31417 473 5 up up RP 31417 473 6 a a DT 31417 473 7 little little JJ 31417 473 8 later later RB 31417 473 9 by by IN 31417 473 10 a a DT 31417 473 11 brief brief JJ 31417 473 12 article article NN 31417 473 13 by by IN 31417 473 14 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 473 15 Myers Myers NNP 31417 473 16 , , , 31417 473 17 forming form VBG 31417 473 18 an an DT 31417 473 19 important important JJ 31417 473 20 supplement supplement NN 31417 473 21 . . . 31417 474 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 474 2 24 24 CD 31417 474 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 474 4 In in IN 31417 474 5 the the DT 31417 474 6 Report Report NNP 31417 474 7 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 474 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 474 9 joint joint JJ 31417 474 10 authors author NNS 31417 474 11 say say VBP 31417 474 12 : : : 31417 474 13 " " `` 31417 474 14 We -PRON- PRP 31417 474 15 propose propose VBP 31417 474 16 the the DT 31417 474 17 question question NN 31417 474 18 -- -- : 31417 474 19 Have have VB 31417 474 20 Home Home NNP 31417 474 21 's 's POS 31417 474 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 474 23 ever ever RB 31417 474 24 been be VBN 31417 474 25 plausibly plausibly RB 31417 474 26 explained explain VBN 31417 474 27 as as IN 31417 474 28 conjuring conjure VBG 31417 474 29 tricks trick NNS 31417 474 30 , , , 31417 474 31 or or CC 31417 474 32 in in IN 31417 474 33 accordance accordance NN 31417 474 34 with with IN 31417 474 35 known known JJ 31417 474 36 laws law NNS 31417 474 37 of of IN 31417 474 38 nature nature NN 31417 474 39 ? ? . 31417 475 1 And and CC 31417 475 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 475 3 answer answer VBP 31417 475 4 -- -- : 31417 475 5 No no UH 31417 475 6 ; ; : 31417 475 7 they -PRON- PRP 31417 475 8 have have VBP 31417 475 9 not not RB 31417 475 10 been be VBN 31417 475 11 so so RB 31417 475 12 explained explain VBN 31417 475 13 , , , 31417 475 14 nor nor CC 31417 475 15 can can MD 31417 475 16 we -PRON- PRP 31417 475 17 so so RB 31417 475 18 explain explain VB 31417 475 19 them -PRON- PRP 31417 475 20 . . . 31417 476 1 " " `` 31417 476 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 476 3 25 25 CD 31417 476 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 476 5 In in IN 31417 476 6 commenting comment VBG 31417 476 7 on on IN 31417 476 8 the the DT 31417 476 9 Joint Joint NNP 31417 476 10 Report Report NNP 31417 476 11 , , , 31417 476 12 by by IN 31417 476 13 Professor Professor NNP 31417 476 14 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 476 15 and and CC 31417 476 16 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 476 17 , , , 31417 476 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 476 19 Myers Myers NNP 31417 476 20 puts put VBZ 31417 476 21 the the DT 31417 476 22 problem problem NN 31417 476 23 as as IN 31417 476 24 to to IN 31417 476 25 Home home NN 31417 476 26 in in IN 31417 476 27 this this DT 31417 476 28 form form NN 31417 476 29 : : : 31417 476 30 " " `` 31417 476 31 There there EX 31417 476 32 is be VBZ 31417 476 33 thus thus RB 31417 476 34 a a DT 31417 476 35 considerable considerable JJ 31417 476 36 body body NN 31417 476 37 of of IN 31417 476 38 evidence evidence NN 31417 476 39 as as IN 31417 476 40 to to IN 31417 476 41 Home Home NNP 31417 476 42 , , , 31417 476 43 which which WDT 31417 476 44 enables enable VBZ 31417 476 45 us -PRON- PRP 31417 476 46 to to TO 31417 476 47 discuss discuss VB 31417 476 48 the the DT 31417 476 49 three three CD 31417 476 50 questions question NNS 31417 476 51 : : : 31417 476 52 ( ( -LRB- 31417 476 53 1 1 LS 31417 476 54 ) ) -RRB- 31417 476 55 Was be VBD 31417 476 56 he -PRON- PRP 31417 476 57 ever ever RB 31417 476 58 convicted convict VBN 31417 476 59 of of IN 31417 476 60 fraud fraud NN 31417 476 61 ? ? . 31417 477 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 477 2 2 2 LS 31417 477 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 477 4 Did do VBD 31417 477 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 477 6 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 477 7 any any DT 31417 477 8 trained train VBN 31417 477 9 observer observer NN 31417 477 10 in in IN 31417 477 11 a a DT 31417 477 12 series series NN 31417 477 13 of of IN 31417 477 14 experiments experiment NNS 31417 477 15 selected select VBN 31417 477 16 by by IN 31417 477 17 the the DT 31417 477 18 observer observer NN 31417 477 19 and and CC 31417 477 20 not not RB 31417 477 21 by by IN 31417 477 22 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 477 23 ? ? . 31417 478 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 478 2 3 3 LS 31417 478 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 478 4 Were be VBD 31417 478 5 the the DT 31417 478 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 478 7 entirely entirely RB 31417 478 8 beyond beyond IN 31417 478 9 the the DT 31417 478 10 scope scope NN 31417 478 11 of of IN 31417 478 12 the the DT 31417 478 13 conjurer conjurer NN 31417 478 14 's 's POS 31417 478 15 art art NN 31417 478 16 ? ? . 31417 479 1 " " `` 31417 479 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 479 3 26 26 CD 31417 479 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 479 5 In in IN 31417 479 6 the the DT 31417 479 7 Joint Joint NNP 31417 479 8 Report Report NNP 31417 479 9 the the DT 31417 479 10 writers writer NNS 31417 479 11 say--(1 say--(1 NN 31417 479 12 ) ) -RRB- 31417 479 13 As as IN 31417 479 14 to to IN 31417 479 15 fraud fraud NN 31417 479 16 : : : 31417 479 17 " " `` 31417 479 18 We -PRON- PRP 31417 479 19 have have VBP 31417 479 20 found find VBN 31417 479 21 no no DT 31417 479 22 allegations allegation NNS 31417 479 23 of of IN 31417 479 24 fraud fraud NN 31417 479 25 on on IN 31417 479 26 which which WDT 31417 479 27 we -PRON- PRP 31417 479 28 should should MD 31417 479 29 be be VB 31417 479 30 justified justify VBN 31417 479 31 in in IN 31417 479 32 laying lay VBG 31417 479 33 much much JJ 31417 479 34 stress stress NN 31417 479 35 . . . 31417 480 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 480 2 Robert Robert NNP 31417 480 3 Browning Browning NNP 31417 480 4 has have VBZ 31417 480 5 told tell VBN 31417 480 6 to to IN 31417 480 7 one one CD 31417 480 8 of of IN 31417 480 9 us -PRON- PRP 31417 480 10 the the DT 31417 480 11 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 480 12 which which WDT 31417 480 13 mainly mainly RB 31417 480 14 led lead VBD 31417 480 15 to to IN 31417 480 16 that that DT 31417 480 17 opinion opinion NN 31417 480 18 of of IN 31417 480 19 Home Home NNP 31417 480 20 which which WDT 31417 480 21 was be VBD 31417 480 22 expressed express VBN 31417 480 23 in in IN 31417 480 24 ' ' '' 31417 480 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 481 1 Sludge Sludge NNP 31417 481 2 , , , 31417 481 3 the the DT 31417 481 4 Medium Medium NNP 31417 481 5 , , , 31417 481 6 ' ' '' 31417 481 7 It -PRON- PRP 31417 481 8 appears appear VBZ 31417 481 9 that that IN 31417 481 10 a a DT 31417 481 11 lady lady NN 31417 481 12 ( ( -LRB- 31417 481 13 since since IN 31417 481 14 dead dead JJ 31417 481 15 ) ) -RRB- 31417 481 16 repeated repeat VBD 31417 481 17 to to IN 31417 481 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 481 19 Browning Browning NNP 31417 481 20 a a DT 31417 481 21 statement statement NN 31417 481 22 made make VBN 31417 481 23 to to IN 31417 481 24 her -PRON- PRP 31417 481 25 by by IN 31417 481 26 a a DT 31417 481 27 lady lady NN 31417 481 28 and and CC 31417 481 29 gentleman gentleman NNP 31417 481 30 ( ( -LRB- 31417 481 31 since since IN 31417 481 32 dead dead JJ 31417 481 33 ) ) -RRB- 31417 481 34 , , , 31417 481 35 as as IN 31417 481 36 to to IN 31417 481 37 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 481 38 finding finding NN 31417 481 39 Home Home NNP 31417 481 40 in in IN 31417 481 41 the the DT 31417 481 42 act act NN 31417 481 43 of of IN 31417 481 44 experimenting experiment VBG 31417 481 45 with with IN 31417 481 46 phosphorus phosphorus NN 31417 481 47 on on IN 31417 481 48 the the DT 31417 481 49 production production NN 31417 481 50 of of IN 31417 481 51 ' ' `` 31417 481 52 spirit spirit NN 31417 481 53 lights light NNS 31417 481 54 , , , 31417 481 55 ' ' '' 31417 481 56 which which WDT 31417 481 57 , , , 31417 481 58 so so RB 31417 481 59 far far RB 31417 481 60 as as IN 31417 481 61 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 481 62 Browning Browning NNP 31417 481 63 remembers remember NNS 31417 481 64 , , , 31417 481 65 were be VBD 31417 481 66 to to TO 31417 481 67 be be VB 31417 481 68 rubbed rub VBN 31417 481 69 round round IN 31417 481 70 the the DT 31417 481 71 walls wall NNS 31417 481 72 of of IN 31417 481 73 the the DT 31417 481 74 room room NN 31417 481 75 , , , 31417 481 76 near near IN 31417 481 77 the the DT 31417 481 78 ceiling ceiling NN 31417 481 79 , , , 31417 481 80 so so IN 31417 481 81 as as IN 31417 481 82 to to TO 31417 481 83 appear appear VB 31417 481 84 when when WRB 31417 481 85 the the DT 31417 481 86 room room NN 31417 481 87 was be VBD 31417 481 88 darkened darken VBN 31417 481 89 . . . 31417 482 1 This this DT 31417 482 2 piece piece NN 31417 482 3 of of IN 31417 482 4 evidence evidence NN 31417 482 5 powerfully powerfully RB 31417 482 6 impressed impress VBD 31417 482 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 482 8 Browning Browning NNP 31417 482 9 ; ; : 31417 482 10 but but CC 31417 482 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 482 12 comes come VBZ 31417 482 13 to to IN 31417 482 14 us -PRON- PRP 31417 482 15 at at IN 31417 482 16 third third JJ 31417 482 17 - - HYPH 31417 482 18 hand hand NN 31417 482 19 , , , 31417 482 20 without without IN 31417 482 21 written write VBN 31417 482 22 record record NN 31417 482 23 , , , 31417 482 24 and and CC 31417 482 25 at at IN 31417 482 26 a a DT 31417 482 27 distance distance NN 31417 482 28 of of IN 31417 482 29 nearly nearly RB 31417 482 30 forty forty CD 31417 482 31 years year NNS 31417 482 32 . . . 31417 483 1 " " `` 31417 483 2 We -PRON- PRP 31417 483 3 have have VBP 31417 483 4 received receive VBN 31417 483 5 one one CD 31417 483 6 other other JJ 31417 483 7 account account NN 31417 483 8 from from IN 31417 483 9 a a DT 31417 483 10 gentleman gentleman NN 31417 483 11 of of IN 31417 483 12 character character NN 31417 483 13 and and CC 31417 483 14 ability ability NN 31417 483 15 , , , 31417 483 16 of of IN 31417 483 17 a a DT 31417 483 18 seance seance NN 31417 483 19 in in IN 31417 483 20 very very RB 31417 483 21 poor poor JJ 31417 483 22 light light NN 31417 483 23 , , , 31417 483 24 when when WRB 31417 483 25 the the DT 31417 483 26 ' ' `` 31417 483 27 spirit spirit NN 31417 483 28 - - HYPH 31417 483 29 hand hand NN 31417 483 30 ' ' '' 31417 483 31 moved move VBD 31417 483 32 in in IN 31417 483 33 such such PDT 31417 483 34 a a DT 31417 483 35 way way NN 31417 483 36 as as IN 31417 483 37 to to TO 31417 483 38 seem seem VB 31417 483 39 dependent dependent JJ 31417 483 40 on on IN 31417 483 41 the the DT 31417 483 42 action action NN 31417 483 43 of of IN 31417 483 44 Home Home NNP 31417 483 45 's 's POS 31417 483 46 arms arm NNS 31417 483 47 and and CC 31417 483 48 legs leg NNS 31417 483 49 . . . 31417 484 1 This this DT 31417 484 2 account account NN 31417 484 3 is be VBZ 31417 484 4 subjoined subjoin VBN 31417 484 5 [ [ -LRB- 31417 484 6 in in IN 31417 484 7 the the DT 31417 484 8 Report report NN 31417 484 9 ] ] -RRB- 31417 484 10 as as IN 31417 484 11 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 484 12 D. D. NNP 31417 484 13 We -PRON- PRP 31417 484 14 may may MD 31417 484 15 add add VB 31417 484 16 that that DT 31417 484 17 few few JJ 31417 484 18 , , , 31417 484 19 if if IN 31417 484 20 any any DT 31417 484 21 , , , 31417 484 22 of of IN 31417 484 23 the the DT 31417 484 24 lights light NNS 31417 484 25 seen see VBN 31417 484 26 at at IN 31417 484 27 Home home NN 31417 484 28 's 's POS 31417 484 29 seances seance NNS 31417 484 30 could could MD 31417 484 31 ( ( -LRB- 31417 484 32 as as IN 31417 484 33 they -PRON- PRP 31417 484 34 are be VBP 31417 484 35 described describe VBN 31417 484 36 to to IN 31417 484 37 us -PRON- PRP 31417 484 38 ) ) -RRB- 31417 484 39 have have VBP 31417 484 40 been be VBN 31417 484 41 contrived contrive VBN 31417 484 42 by by IN 31417 484 43 the the DT 31417 484 44 aid aid NN 31417 484 45 of of IN 31417 484 46 phosphorus phosphorus NN 31417 484 47 . . . 31417 485 1 " " `` 31417 485 2 There there EX 31417 485 3 is be VBZ 31417 485 4 also also RB 31417 485 5 a a DT 31417 485 6 frequently frequently RB 31417 485 7 repeated repeat VBN 31417 485 8 story story NN 31417 485 9 that that WDT 31417 485 10 Home home NN 31417 485 11 was be VBD 31417 485 12 found find VBN 31417 485 13 at at IN 31417 485 14 the the DT 31417 485 15 Tuilleries Tuilleries NNPS 31417 485 16 ( ( -LRB- 31417 485 17 or or CC 31417 485 18 at at IN 31417 485 19 Compiègne Compiègne NNP 31417 485 20 , , , 31417 485 21 or or CC 31417 485 22 at at IN 31417 485 23 Biarritz Biarritz NNP 31417 485 24 ) ) -RRB- 31417 485 25 to to TO 31417 485 26 be be VB 31417 485 27 using use VBG 31417 485 28 a a DT 31417 485 29 stuffed stuff VBN 31417 485 30 hand hand NN 31417 485 31 , , , 31417 485 32 and and CC 31417 485 33 was be VBD 31417 485 34 consequently consequently RB 31417 485 35 forbidden forbid VBN 31417 485 36 the the DT 31417 485 37 Imperial Imperial NNP 31417 485 38 Court Court NNP 31417 485 39 . . . 31417 486 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 486 2 have have VBP 31417 486 3 tried try VBN 31417 486 4 in in IN 31417 486 5 France France NNP 31417 486 6 to to TO 31417 486 7 get get VB 31417 486 8 at at IN 31417 486 9 the the DT 31417 486 10 fountain fountain NN 31417 486 11 - - HYPH 31417 486 12 head head NN 31417 486 13 of of IN 31417 486 14 this this DT 31417 486 15 story story NN 31417 486 16 , , , 31417 486 17 but but CC 31417 486 18 without without IN 31417 486 19 success success NN 31417 486 20 . . . 31417 487 1 " " `` 31417 487 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 487 3 27 27 CD 31417 487 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 487 5 ( ( -LRB- 31417 487 6 2 2 LS 31417 487 7 ) ) -RRB- 31417 487 8 " " '' 31417 487 9 With with IN 31417 487 10 regard regard NN 31417 487 11 to to IN 31417 487 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 487 13 second second JJ 31417 487 14 question question NN 31417 487 15 -- -- : 31417 487 16 whether whether IN 31417 487 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 487 18 powers power NNS 31417 487 19 were be VBD 31417 487 20 tested test VBN 31417 487 21 by by IN 31417 487 22 competent competent JJ 31417 487 23 observers"--Mr observers"--Mr NNP 31417 487 24 . . . 31417 487 25 Myers Myers NNP 31417 487 26 says say VBZ 31417 487 27 : : : 31417 487 28 " " `` 31417 487 29 Home home NN 31417 487 30 in in IN 31417 487 31 this this DT 31417 487 32 respect respect NN 31417 487 33 stands stand VBZ 31417 487 34 pre pre JJ 31417 487 35 - - JJ 31417 487 36 eminent eminent JJ 31417 487 37 ; ; : 31417 487 38 since since IN 31417 487 39 we -PRON- PRP 31417 487 40 have have VBP 31417 487 41 the the DT 31417 487 42 evidence evidence NN 31417 487 43 of of IN 31417 487 44 Sir Sir NNP 31417 487 45 William William NNP 31417 487 46 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 487 47 , , , 31417 487 48 corroborated corroborate VBN 31417 487 49 by by IN 31417 487 50 the the DT 31417 487 51 testimony testimony NN 31417 487 52 of of IN 31417 487 53 the the DT 31417 487 54 Master Master NNP 31417 487 55 of of IN 31417 487 56 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 487 57 ( ( -LRB- 31417 487 58 now now RB 31417 487 59 Earl Earl NNP 31417 487 60 of of IN 31417 487 61 Crawford Crawford NNP 31417 487 62 and and CC 31417 487 63 Balcarres Balcarres NNP 31417 487 64 ) ) -RRB- 31417 487 65 , , , 31417 487 66 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 487 67 a a DT 31417 487 68 _ _ NNP 31417 487 69 savant savant JJ 31417 487 70 _ _ NNP 31417 487 71 of of IN 31417 487 72 some some DT 31417 487 73 distinction distinction NN 31417 487 74 , , , 31417 487 75 and and CC 31417 487 76 the the DT 31417 487 77 privately privately RB 31417 487 78 printed print VBN 31417 487 79 series series NN 31417 487 80 of of IN 31417 487 81 careful careful JJ 31417 487 82 observations observation NNS 31417 487 83 by by IN 31417 487 84 the the DT 31417 487 85 present present NN 31417 487 86 and and CC 31417 487 87 the the DT 31417 487 88 late late JJ 31417 487 89 Lords Lords NNP 31417 487 90 Dunraven Dunraven NNP 31417 487 91 . . . 31417 488 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 488 2 28 28 CD 31417 488 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 488 4 ( ( -LRB- 31417 488 5 3 3 LS 31417 488 6 ) ) -RRB- 31417 488 7 " " `` 31417 488 8 As as IN 31417 488 9 to to IN 31417 488 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 488 11 third third JJ 31417 488 12 question question NN 31417 488 13 -- -- : 31417 488 14 whether whether IN 31417 488 15 the the DT 31417 488 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 488 17 could could MD 31417 488 18 have have VB 31417 488 19 been be VBN 31417 488 20 produced produce VBN 31417 488 21 by by IN 31417 488 22 conjuring"--Mr conjuring"--Mr NNP 31417 488 23 . . . 31417 488 24 Myers Myers NNP 31417 488 25 says say VBZ 31417 488 26 : : : 31417 488 27 " " `` 31417 488 28 Many many JJ 31417 488 29 of of IN 31417 488 30 them -PRON- PRP 31417 488 31 , , , 31417 488 32 especially especially RB 31417 488 33 the the DT 31417 488 34 fire fire NN 31417 488 35 - - HYPH 31417 488 36 tests test NNS 31417 488 37 , , , 31417 488 38 and and CC 31417 488 39 the the DT 31417 488 40 movements movement NNS 31417 488 41 of of IN 31417 488 42 large large JJ 31417 488 43 untouched untouched JJ 31417 488 44 objects object NNS 31417 488 45 in in IN 31417 488 46 good good JJ 31417 488 47 light light NN 31417 488 48 , , , 31417 488 49 seem seem VB 31417 488 50 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 31417 488 51 by by IN 31417 488 52 this this DT 31417 488 53 supposition supposition NN 31417 488 54 . . . 31417 489 1 The the DT 31417 489 2 hypothesis hypothesis NN 31417 489 3 of of IN 31417 489 4 collective collective JJ 31417 489 5 hallucination hallucination NN 31417 489 6 on on IN 31417 489 7 the the DT 31417 489 8 part part NN 31417 489 9 of of IN 31417 489 10 the the DT 31417 489 11 sitters sitter NNS 31417 489 12 seems seem VBZ 31417 489 13 very very RB 31417 489 14 improbable improbable JJ 31417 489 15 , , , 31417 489 16 because because IN 31417 489 17 , , , 31417 489 18 in in IN 31417 489 19 most most JJS 31417 489 20 cases case NNS 31417 489 21 , , , 31417 489 22 all all PDT 31417 489 23 those those DT 31417 489 24 present present JJ 31417 489 25 saw see VBD 31417 489 26 the the DT 31417 489 27 same same JJ 31417 489 28 thing thing NN 31417 489 29 ; ; : 31417 489 30 and and CC 31417 489 31 often often RB 31417 489 32 without without IN 31417 489 33 receiving receive VBG 31417 489 34 from from IN 31417 489 35 Home home NN 31417 489 36 any any DT 31417 489 37 audible audible JJ 31417 489 38 suggestion suggestion NN 31417 489 39 as as IN 31417 489 40 to to IN 31417 489 41 what what WP 31417 489 42 was be VBD 31417 489 43 about about JJ 31417 489 44 to to TO 31417 489 45 happen happen VB 31417 489 46 . . . 31417 490 1 " " `` 31417 490 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 490 3 29 29 CD 31417 490 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 490 5 In in IN 31417 490 6 the the DT 31417 490 7 Joint Joint NNP 31417 490 8 Report Report NNP 31417 490 9 by by IN 31417 490 10 Professor Professor NNP 31417 490 11 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 490 12 and and CC 31417 490 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 490 14 Myers Myers NNP 31417 490 15 , , , 31417 490 16 a a DT 31417 490 17 considerable considerable JJ 31417 490 18 space space NN 31417 490 19 is be VBZ 31417 490 20 devoted devoted JJ 31417 490 21 to to IN 31417 490 22 a a DT 31417 490 23 discussion discussion NN 31417 490 24 as as IN 31417 490 25 to to IN 31417 490 26 conjuring conjure VBG 31417 490 27 being be VBG 31417 490 28 the the DT 31417 490 29 explanation explanation NN 31417 490 30 of of IN 31417 490 31 the the DT 31417 490 32 Home Home NNP 31417 490 33 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 490 34 . . . 31417 491 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 491 2 is be VBZ 31417 491 3 dismissed dismiss VBN 31417 491 4 as as IN 31417 491 5 utterly utterly RB 31417 491 6 inadequate inadequate JJ 31417 491 7 . . . 31417 492 1 In in IN 31417 492 2 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 492 3 , , , 31417 492 4 the the DT 31417 492 5 authors author NNS 31417 492 6 of of IN 31417 492 7 the the DT 31417 492 8 Report Report NNP 31417 492 9 say say VBP 31417 492 10 : : : 31417 492 11 " " `` 31417 492 12 And and CC 31417 492 13 we -PRON- PRP 31417 492 14 find find VBP 31417 492 15 that that IN 31417 492 16 experts expert NNS 31417 492 17 in in IN 31417 492 18 conjuring conjure VBG 31417 492 19 ( ( -LRB- 31417 492 20 several several JJ 31417 492 21 of of IN 31417 492 22 whom whom WP 31417 492 23 we -PRON- PRP 31417 492 24 have have VBP 31417 492 25 consulted consult VBN 31417 492 26 ) ) -RRB- 31417 492 27 , , , 31417 492 28 however however RB 31417 492 29 little little JJ 31417 492 30 they -PRON- PRP 31417 492 31 may may MD 31417 492 32 believe believe VB 31417 492 33 in in IN 31417 492 34 Home Home NNP 31417 492 35 's 's POS 31417 492 36 pretensions pretension NNS 31417 492 37 , , , 31417 492 38 are be VBP 31417 492 39 disposed dispose VBN 31417 492 40 rather rather RB 31417 492 41 to to TO 31417 492 42 reject reject VB 31417 492 43 wholesale wholesale JJ 31417 492 44 than than IN 31417 492 45 to to TO 31417 492 46 explain explain VB 31417 492 47 in in IN 31417 492 48 detail detail NN 31417 492 49 the the DT 31417 492 50 more more RBR 31417 492 51 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 492 52 records record NNS 31417 492 53 . . . 31417 493 1 " " `` 31417 493 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 493 3 30 30 CD 31417 493 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 493 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 493 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 493 7 and and CC 31417 493 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 493 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 493 10 proceed proceed VBP 31417 493 11 to to TO 31417 493 12 quote quote VB 31417 493 13 thirty thirty CD 31417 493 14 - - HYPH 31417 493 15 five five CD 31417 493 16 cases case NNS 31417 493 17 of of IN 31417 493 18 the the DT 31417 493 19 identification identification NN 31417 493 20 of of IN 31417 493 21 alleged allege VBN 31417 493 22 communicating communicate VBG 31417 493 23 spirits spirit NNS 31417 493 24 from from IN 31417 493 25 Madame Madame NNP 31417 493 26 Home Home NNP 31417 493 27 's 's POS 31417 493 28 book book NN 31417 493 29 , , , 31417 493 30 entitled entitle VBN 31417 493 31 " " `` 31417 493 32 D. D. NNP 31417 493 33 D. D. NNP 31417 493 34 Home Home NNP 31417 493 35 , , , 31417 493 36 His -PRON- PRP$ 31417 493 37 Life Life NNP 31417 493 38 and and CC 31417 493 39 Mission Mission NNP 31417 493 40 . . . 31417 493 41 " " '' 31417 494 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 494 2 remark remark VBP 31417 494 3 , , , 31417 494 4 " " `` 31417 494 5 This this DT 31417 494 6 list list NN 31417 494 7 of of IN 31417 494 8 identifications identification NNS 31417 494 9 is be VBZ 31417 494 10 a a DT 31417 494 11 long long JJ 31417 494 12 one one CD 31417 494 13 , , , 31417 494 14 and and CC 31417 494 15 quite quite RB 31417 494 16 unique unique JJ 31417 494 17 in in IN 31417 494 18 the the DT 31417 494 19 history history NN 31417 494 20 of of IN 31417 494 21 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 494 22 . . . 31417 495 1 " " `` 31417 495 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 495 3 31 31 CD 31417 495 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 495 5 After after IN 31417 495 6 analysing analyse VBG 31417 495 7 this this DT 31417 495 8 list list NN 31417 495 9 of of IN 31417 495 10 cases case NNS 31417 495 11 , , , 31417 495 12 they -PRON- PRP 31417 495 13 say say VBP 31417 495 14 near near IN 31417 495 15 the the DT 31417 495 16 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 495 17 of of IN 31417 495 18 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 495 19 Report Report NNP 31417 495 20 , , , 31417 495 21 as as IN 31417 495 22 implying imply VBG 31417 495 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 495 24 final final JJ 31417 495 25 verdict verdict NN 31417 495 26 : : : 31417 495 27 " " `` 31417 495 28 If if IN 31417 495 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 495 30 readers reader NNS 31417 495 31 ask ask VBP 31417 495 32 us--'Do us--'Do NNP 31417 495 33 you -PRON- PRP 31417 495 34 advise advise VBP 31417 495 35 us -PRON- PRP 31417 495 36 to to TO 31417 495 37 go go VB 31417 495 38 on on RP 31417 495 39 experimenting experiment VBG 31417 495 40 in in IN 31417 495 41 these these DT 31417 495 42 matters matter NNS 31417 495 43 as as IN 31417 495 44 though though IN 31417 495 45 Home Home NNP 31417 495 46 's 's POS 31417 495 47 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 495 48 were be VBD 31417 495 49 genuine genuine JJ 31417 495 50 ? ? . 31417 495 51 ' ' '' 31417 496 1 --we --we : 31417 496 2 answer answer VB 31417 496 3 , , , 31417 496 4 ' ' '' 31417 496 5 Yes yes UH 31417 496 6 . . . 31417 497 1 ' ' `` 31417 497 2 " " '' 31417 497 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 497 4 32 32 CD 31417 497 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 497 6 In in IN 31417 497 7 the the DT 31417 497 8 supplementary supplementary JJ 31417 497 9 article article NN 31417 497 10 above above IN 31417 497 11 referred refer VBD 31417 497 12 to to IN 31417 497 13 sixteen sixteen CD 31417 497 14 more more JJR 31417 497 15 cases case NNS 31417 497 16 of of IN 31417 497 17 identification identification NN 31417 497 18 are be VBP 31417 497 19 added add VBN 31417 497 20 to to IN 31417 497 21 the the DT 31417 497 22 thirty thirty CD 31417 497 23 - - HYPH 31417 497 24 five five CD 31417 497 25 . . . 31417 498 1 In in IN 31417 498 2 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 498 3 E E NNP 31417 498 4 to to IN 31417 498 5 the the DT 31417 498 6 Report Report NNP 31417 498 7 is be VBZ 31417 498 8 given give VBN 31417 498 9 some some DT 31417 498 10 striking striking JJ 31417 498 11 testimony testimony NN 31417 498 12 to to IN 31417 498 13 the the DT 31417 498 14 reality reality NN 31417 498 15 of of IN 31417 498 16 the the DT 31417 498 17 " " `` 31417 498 18 fire fire NN 31417 498 19 - - HYPH 31417 498 20 test test NN 31417 498 21 . . . 31417 498 22 " " '' 31417 499 1 The the DT 31417 499 2 following following JJ 31417 499 3 letter letter NN 31417 499 4 from from IN 31417 499 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 499 6 W. W. NNP 31417 499 7 M. M. NNP 31417 499 8 Wilkinson Wilkinson NNP 31417 499 9 , , , 31417 499 10 the the DT 31417 499 11 well well RB 31417 499 12 - - HYPH 31417 499 13 known know VBN 31417 499 14 solicitor solicitor NN 31417 499 15 , , , 31417 499 16 is be VBZ 31417 499 17 included:-- included:-- JJ 31417 499 18 " " `` 31417 499 19 As as IN 31417 499 20 you -PRON- PRP 31417 499 21 ask ask VBP 31417 499 22 me -PRON- PRP 31417 499 23 to to TO 31417 499 24 write write VB 31417 499 25 to to IN 31417 499 26 you -PRON- PRP 31417 499 27 of of IN 31417 499 28 what what WP 31417 499 29 occurred occur VBD 31417 499 30 at at IN 31417 499 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 499 32 house house NN 31417 499 33 at at IN 31417 499 34 Kilburn Kilburn NNP 31417 499 35 , , , 31417 499 36 where where WRB 31417 499 37 we -PRON- PRP 31417 499 38 were be VBD 31417 499 39 living live VBG 31417 499 40 in in IN 31417 499 41 1869 1869 CD 31417 499 42 , , , 31417 499 43 with with IN 31417 499 44 reference reference NN 31417 499 45 to to IN 31417 499 46 the the DT 31417 499 47 handling handling NN 31417 499 48 of of IN 31417 499 49 red red JJ 31417 499 50 - - HYPH 31417 499 51 hot hot JJ 31417 499 52 coal coal NN 31417 499 53 , , , 31417 499 54 I -PRON- PRP 31417 499 55 will will MD 31417 499 56 merely merely RB 31417 499 57 say say VB 31417 499 58 that that IN 31417 499 59 one one CD 31417 499 60 Sunday Sunday NNP 31417 499 61 evening evening NN 31417 499 62 in in IN 31417 499 63 the the DT 31417 499 64 winter winter NN 31417 499 65 of of IN 31417 499 66 that that DT 31417 499 67 year year NN 31417 499 68 , , , 31417 499 69 I -PRON- PRP 31417 499 70 saw see VBD 31417 499 71 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 499 72 Home Home NNP 31417 499 73 take take VB 31417 499 74 out out IN 31417 499 75 of of IN 31417 499 76 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 499 77 drawing drawing NN 31417 499 78 - - HYPH 31417 499 79 room room NN 31417 499 80 fire fire NN 31417 499 81 a a DT 31417 499 82 red red JJ 31417 499 83 - - HYPH 31417 499 84 hot hot JJ 31417 499 85 coal coal NN 31417 499 86 a a DT 31417 499 87 little little JJ 31417 499 88 less less RBR 31417 499 89 in in IN 31417 499 90 size size NN 31417 499 91 than than IN 31417 499 92 a a DT 31417 499 93 cricket cricket NN 31417 499 94 ball ball NN 31417 499 95 , , , 31417 499 96 and and CC 31417 499 97 carry carry VB 31417 499 98 it -PRON- PRP 31417 499 99 up up RP 31417 499 100 and and CC 31417 499 101 down down IN 31417 499 102 the the DT 31417 499 103 drawing drawing NN 31417 499 104 - - HYPH 31417 499 105 room room NN 31417 499 106 . . . 31417 500 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 500 2 said say VBD 31417 500 3 to to IN 31417 500 4 Lord Lord NNP 31417 500 5 Adare Adare NNP 31417 500 6 , , , 31417 500 7 now now RB 31417 500 8 Lord Lord NNP 31417 500 9 Dunraven Dunraven NNP 31417 500 10 , , , 31417 500 11 who who WP 31417 500 12 was be VBD 31417 500 13 present present JJ 31417 500 14 , , , 31417 500 15 ' ' '' 31417 500 16 Will Will MD 31417 500 17 you -PRON- PRP 31417 500 18 take take VB 31417 500 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 500 20 from from IN 31417 500 21 me -PRON- PRP 31417 500 22 ? ? . 31417 501 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 501 2 will will MD 31417 501 3 not not RB 31417 501 4 hurt hurt VB 31417 501 5 you -PRON- PRP 31417 501 6 . . . 31417 501 7 ' ' '' 31417 502 1 Lord Lord NNP 31417 502 2 Adare Adare NNP 31417 502 3 took take VBD 31417 502 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 502 5 from from IN 31417 502 6 him -PRON- PRP 31417 502 7 , , , 31417 502 8 and and CC 31417 502 9 held hold VBD 31417 502 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 502 11 in in IN 31417 502 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 502 13 hand hand NN 31417 502 14 for for IN 31417 502 15 about about IN 31417 502 16 half half PDT 31417 502 17 a a DT 31417 502 18 minute minute NN 31417 502 19 , , , 31417 502 20 and and CC 31417 502 21 before before IN 31417 502 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 502 23 threw throw VBD 31417 502 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 502 25 back back RB 31417 502 26 in in IN 31417 502 27 the the DT 31417 502 28 fire fire NN 31417 502 29 I -PRON- PRP 31417 502 30 put put VBD 31417 502 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 502 32 hand hand NN 31417 502 33 pretty pretty RB 31417 502 34 close close RB 31417 502 35 to to IN 31417 502 36 it -PRON- PRP 31417 502 37 , , , 31417 502 38 and and CC 31417 502 39 felt feel VBD 31417 502 40 the the DT 31417 502 41 heat heat NN 31417 502 42 to to TO 31417 502 43 be be VB 31417 502 44 like like IN 31417 502 45 that that DT 31417 502 46 of of IN 31417 502 47 a a DT 31417 502 48 live live JJ 31417 502 49 coal.--Yours coal.--yours NN 31417 502 50 very very RB 31417 502 51 truly truly RB 31417 502 52 , , , 31417 502 53 W. W. NNP 31417 502 54 M. M. NNP 31417 503 1 WILKINSON WILKINSON NNP 31417 503 2 . . . 31417 504 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 504 2 33 33 CD 31417 504 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 504 4 44 44 CD 31417 504 5 LINCOLN LINCOLN NNP 31417 504 6 'S 's POS 31417 504 7 INN INN NNP 31417 504 8 FIELDS FIELDS NNP 31417 504 9 , , , 31417 504 10 LONDON LONDON NNP 31417 504 11 , , , 31417 504 12 W.C. W.C. NNP 31417 504 13 , , , 31417 504 14 _ _ NNP 31417 504 15 February February NNP 31417 504 16 _ _ NNP 31417 504 17 7 7 CD 31417 504 18 , , , 31417 504 19 1869 1869 CD 31417 504 20 . . . 31417 504 21 " " '' 31417 505 1 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 505 2 M M NNP 31417 505 3 to to IN 31417 505 4 the the DT 31417 505 5 Report Report NNP 31417 505 6 consists consist VBZ 31417 505 7 of of IN 31417 505 8 some some DT 31417 505 9 particulars particular NNS 31417 505 10 verbally verbally RB 31417 505 11 given give VBN 31417 505 12 to to IN 31417 505 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 505 14 Myers Myers NNP 31417 505 15 by by IN 31417 505 16 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 505 17 Honywood Honywood NNP 31417 505 18 , , , 31417 505 19 of of IN 31417 505 20 52 52 CD 31417 505 21 Warwick Warwick NNP 31417 505 22 Square Square NNP 31417 505 23 , , , 31417 505 24 London London NNP 31417 505 25 , , , 31417 505 26 in in IN 31417 505 27 further further JJ 31417 505 28 explanation explanation NN 31417 505 29 of of IN 31417 505 30 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 505 31 printed print VBN 31417 505 32 testimony testimony NN 31417 505 33 to to IN 31417 505 34 phenomena phenomena NNP 31417 505 35 she -PRON- PRP 31417 505 36 had have VBD 31417 505 37 witnessed witness VBN 31417 505 38 in in IN 31417 505 39 Home home NN 31417 505 40 's 's POS 31417 505 41 presence presence NN 31417 505 42 . . . 31417 506 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 506 2 was be VBD 31417 506 3 well well RB 31417 506 4 acquainted acquaint VBN 31417 506 5 with with IN 31417 506 6 him -PRON- PRP 31417 506 7 for for IN 31417 506 8 twenty twenty CD 31417 506 9 - - HYPH 31417 506 10 five five CD 31417 506 11 years year NNS 31417 506 12 , , , 31417 506 13 attended attend VBD 31417 506 14 many many JJ 31417 506 15 seances seance NNS 31417 506 16 , , , 31417 506 17 and and CC 31417 506 18 took take VBD 31417 506 19 notes note NNS 31417 506 20 of of IN 31417 506 21 them -PRON- PRP 31417 506 22 at at IN 31417 506 23 the the DT 31417 506 24 time time NN 31417 506 25 . . . 31417 507 1 In in IN 31417 507 2 the the DT 31417 507 3 early early JJ 31417 507 4 part part NN 31417 507 5 of of IN 31417 507 6 this this DT 31417 507 7 chapter chapter NN 31417 507 8 , , , 31417 507 9 a a DT 31417 507 10 statement statement NN 31417 507 11 she -PRON- PRP 31417 507 12 sent send VBD 31417 507 13 to to IN 31417 507 14 the the DT 31417 507 15 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 507 16 Society Society NNP 31417 507 17 has have VBZ 31417 507 18 already already RB 31417 507 19 been be VBN 31417 507 20 quoted quote VBN 31417 507 21 . . . 31417 508 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 508 2 told tell VBD 31417 508 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 508 4 Myers Myers NNP 31417 508 5 that that IN 31417 508 6 most most JJS 31417 508 7 of of IN 31417 508 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 508 9 friends friend NNS 31417 508 10 were be VBD 31417 508 11 complete complete JJ 31417 508 12 disbelievers disbeliever NNS 31417 508 13 in in IN 31417 508 14 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 508 15 , , , 31417 508 16 and and CC 31417 508 17 that that IN 31417 508 18 they -PRON- PRP 31417 508 19 frequently frequently RB 31417 508 20 repeated repeat VBD 31417 508 21 to to IN 31417 508 22 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 508 23 rumours rumour NNS 31417 508 24 to to IN 31417 508 25 the the DT 31417 508 26 discredit discredit NN 31417 508 27 of of IN 31417 508 28 Home Home NNP 31417 508 29 . . . 31417 509 1 But but CC 31417 509 2 she -PRON- PRP 31417 509 3 never never RB 31417 509 4 heard hear VBD 31417 509 5 any any DT 31417 509 6 first first JJ 31417 509 7 - - HYPH 31417 509 8 hand hand NN 31417 509 9 account account NN 31417 509 10 of of IN 31417 509 11 any any DT 31417 509 12 kind kind NN 31417 509 13 of of IN 31417 509 14 trickery trickery NN 31417 509 15 on on IN 31417 509 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 509 17 part part NN 31417 509 18 . . . 31417 510 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 510 2 considered consider VBD 31417 510 3 him -PRON- PRP 31417 510 4 a a DT 31417 510 5 man man NN 31417 510 6 of of IN 31417 510 7 open open JJ 31417 510 8 childlike childlike NN 31417 510 9 nature nature NN 31417 510 10 , , , 31417 510 11 thoroughly thoroughly RB 31417 510 12 honest honest JJ 31417 510 13 and and CC 31417 510 14 truthful truthful JJ 31417 510 15 , , , 31417 510 16 and and CC 31417 510 17 that that IN 31417 510 18 in in IN 31417 510 19 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 510 20 opinion opinion NN 31417 510 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 510 22 utterances utterance NNS 31417 510 23 in in IN 31417 510 24 the the DT 31417 510 25 trance trance NN 31417 510 26 state state NN 31417 510 27 were be VBD 31417 510 28 much much RB 31417 510 29 superior superior JJ 31417 510 30 in in IN 31417 510 31 thought thought NN 31417 510 32 and and CC 31417 510 33 diction diction NN 31417 510 34 to to IN 31417 510 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 510 36 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 510 37 talk talk NN 31417 510 38 . . . 31417 511 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 511 2 said say VBD 31417 511 3 she -PRON- PRP 31417 511 4 should should MD 31417 511 5 like like VB 31417 511 6 to to TO 31417 511 7 give give VB 31417 511 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 511 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 511 10 a a DT 31417 511 11 few few JJ 31417 511 12 additional additional JJ 31417 511 13 details detail NNS 31417 511 14 with with IN 31417 511 15 regard regard NN 31417 511 16 to to IN 31417 511 17 the the DT 31417 511 18 fire fire NN 31417 511 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 511 20 reported report VBN 31417 511 21 in in IN 31417 511 22 Madame Madame NNP 31417 511 23 Home Home NNP 31417 511 24 's 's POS 31417 511 25 book book NN 31417 511 26 , , , 31417 511 27 " " '' 31417 511 28 D. D. NNP 31417 511 29 D. D. NNP 31417 511 30 Home Home NNP 31417 511 31 , , , 31417 511 32 His -PRON- PRP$ 31417 511 33 Life Life NNP 31417 511 34 and and CC 31417 511 35 Mission Mission NNP 31417 511 36 , , , 31417 511 37 " " '' 31417 511 38 on on IN 31417 511 39 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 511 40 authority authority NN 31417 511 41 . . . 31417 512 1 Madame Madame NNP 31417 512 2 Home Home NNP 31417 512 3 's 's POS 31417 512 4 secretary secretary NN 31417 512 5 , , , 31417 512 6 she -PRON- PRP 31417 512 7 said say VBD 31417 512 8 , , , 31417 512 9 had have VBD 31417 512 10 slightly slightly RB 31417 512 11 abbreviated abbreviate VBN 31417 512 12 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 512 13 words word NNS 31417 512 14 in in IN 31417 512 15 a a DT 31417 512 16 way way NN 31417 512 17 which which WDT 31417 512 18 made make VBD 31417 512 19 the the DT 31417 512 20 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 512 21 seem seem VB 31417 512 22 rather rather RB 31417 512 23 less less RBR 31417 512 24 wonderful wonderful JJ 31417 512 25 than than IN 31417 512 26 they -PRON- PRP 31417 512 27 actually actually RB 31417 512 28 were be VBD 31417 512 29 . . . 31417 513 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 513 2 Myers Myers NNP 31417 513 3 gives give VBZ 31417 513 4 the the DT 31417 513 5 following following NN 31417 513 6 , , , 31417 513 7 as as IN 31417 513 8 having have VBG 31417 513 9 been be VBN 31417 513 10 signed sign VBN 31417 513 11 " " `` 31417 513 12 BARBARA BARBARA NNP 31417 513 13 HONYWOOD HONYWOOD NNP 31417 513 14 , , , 31417 513 15 June June NNP 31417 513 16 1889 1889 CD 31417 513 17 . . . 31417 513 18 " " '' 31417 514 1 " " `` 31417 514 2 As as IN 31417 514 3 to to IN 31417 514 4 the the DT 31417 514 5 burning burn VBG 31417 514 6 coal coal NN 31417 514 7 placed place VBN 31417 514 8 in in IN 31417 514 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 514 10 hand hand NN 31417 514 11 . . . 31417 515 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 515 2 saw see VBD 31417 515 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 515 4 Home Home NNP 31417 515 5 take take VB 31417 515 6 this this DT 31417 515 7 coal coal NN 31417 515 8 from from IN 31417 515 9 the the DT 31417 515 10 fire fire NN 31417 515 11 , , , 31417 515 12 moving move VBG 31417 515 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 515 14 hands hand NNS 31417 515 15 freely freely RB 31417 515 16 among among IN 31417 515 17 the the DT 31417 515 18 coals coal NNS 31417 515 19 . . . 31417 516 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 516 2 was be VBD 31417 516 3 about about IN 31417 516 4 the the DT 31417 516 5 size size NN 31417 516 6 of of IN 31417 516 7 a a DT 31417 516 8 coffee coffee NN 31417 516 9 cup cup NN 31417 516 10 , , , 31417 516 11 blazing blaze VBG 31417 516 12 at at IN 31417 516 13 the the DT 31417 516 14 top top NN 31417 516 15 , , , 31417 516 16 and and CC 31417 516 17 red red JJ 31417 516 18 - - HYPH 31417 516 19 hot hot JJ 31417 516 20 at at IN 31417 516 21 the the DT 31417 516 22 bottom bottom NN 31417 516 23 . . . 31417 517 1 While while IN 31417 517 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 517 3 held hold VBD 31417 517 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 517 5 in in IN 31417 517 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 517 7 hand hand NN 31417 517 8 the the DT 31417 517 9 actual actual JJ 31417 517 10 flame flame NN 31417 517 11 died die VBD 31417 517 12 down down RB 31417 517 13 , , , 31417 517 14 but but CC 31417 517 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 517 16 continued continue VBD 31417 517 17 to to TO 31417 517 18 crackle crackle VB 31417 517 19 , , , 31417 517 20 and and CC 31417 517 21 to to TO 31417 517 22 be be VB 31417 517 23 partially partially RB 31417 517 24 red red JJ 31417 517 25 - - HYPH 31417 517 26 hot hot JJ 31417 517 27 . . . 31417 518 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 518 2 felt feel VBD 31417 518 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 518 4 like like IN 31417 518 5 an an DT 31417 518 6 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 518 7 stone stone NN 31417 518 8 , , , 31417 518 9 neither neither CC 31417 518 10 hot hot JJ 31417 518 11 nor nor CC 31417 518 12 cold cold JJ 31417 518 13 . . . 31417 519 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 519 2 Home Home NNP 31417 519 3 then then RB 31417 519 4 pushed push VBD 31417 519 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 519 6 off off IN 31417 519 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 519 8 hand hand NN 31417 519 9 with with IN 31417 519 10 one one CD 31417 519 11 finger finger NN 31417 519 12 on on IN 31417 519 13 to to IN 31417 519 14 a a DT 31417 519 15 double double JJ 31417 519 16 sheet sheet NN 31417 519 17 of of IN 31417 519 18 cartridge cartridge NN 31417 519 19 paper paper NN 31417 519 20 , , , 31417 519 21 which which WDT 31417 519 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 519 23 at at IN 31417 519 24 once once RB 31417 519 25 set set VBN 31417 519 26 on on IN 31417 519 27 fire fire NN 31417 519 28 . . . 31417 520 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 520 2 am be VBP 31417 520 3 quite quite RB 31417 520 4 certain certain JJ 31417 520 5 that that IN 31417 520 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 520 7 was be VBD 31417 520 8 in in IN 31417 520 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 520 10 usual usual JJ 31417 520 11 condition condition NN 31417 520 12 at at IN 31417 520 13 the the DT 31417 520 14 time time NN 31417 520 15 .... .... . 31417 520 16 " " '' 31417 520 17 As as IN 31417 520 18 to to IN 31417 520 19 the the DT 31417 520 20 hot hot JJ 31417 520 21 lamp lamp NN 31417 520 22 - - HYPH 31417 520 23 chimney chimney NN 31417 520 24 which which WDT 31417 520 25 I -PRON- PRP 31417 520 26 touched touch VBD 31417 520 27 . . . 31417 521 1 There there EX 31417 521 2 was be VBD 31417 521 3 a a DT 31417 521 4 row row NN 31417 521 5 of of IN 31417 521 6 four four CD 31417 521 7 or or CC 31417 521 8 five five CD 31417 521 9 persons person NNS 31417 521 10 sitting sit VBG 31417 521 11 side side NN 31417 521 12 by by IN 31417 521 13 side side NN 31417 521 14 , , , 31417 521 15 and and CC 31417 521 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 521 17 Home Home NNP 31417 521 18 asked ask VBD 31417 521 19 us -PRON- PRP 31417 521 20 each each DT 31417 521 21 in in IN 31417 521 22 turn turn NN 31417 521 23 to to TO 31417 521 24 touch touch VB 31417 521 25 the the DT 31417 521 26 glass glass NN 31417 521 27 . . . 31417 522 1 When when WRB 31417 522 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 522 3 touched touch VBD 31417 522 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 522 5 , , , 31417 522 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 522 7 felt feel VBD 31417 522 8 as as IN 31417 522 9 though though IN 31417 522 10 a a DT 31417 522 11 wave wave NN 31417 522 12 of of IN 31417 522 13 heat heat NN 31417 522 14 were be VBD 31417 522 15 receding recede VBG 31417 522 16 before before IN 31417 522 17 me -PRON- PRP 31417 522 18 .... .... . 31417 522 19 " " `` 31417 522 20 I -PRON- PRP 31417 522 21 have have VBP 31417 522 22 repeatedly repeatedly RB 31417 522 23 taken take VBN 31417 522 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 522 25 Home Home NNP 31417 522 26 in in IN 31417 522 27 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 522 28 own own JJ 31417 522 29 carriage carriage NN 31417 522 30 to to IN 31417 522 31 the the DT 31417 522 32 houses house NNS 31417 522 33 of of IN 31417 522 34 friends friend NNS 31417 522 35 of of IN 31417 522 36 mine mine NN 31417 522 37 who who WP 31417 522 38 were be VBD 31417 522 39 strangers stranger NNS 31417 522 40 to to IN 31417 522 41 him -PRON- PRP 31417 522 42 , , , 31417 522 43 and and CC 31417 522 44 have have VBP 31417 522 45 there there EX 31417 522 46 seen see VBN 31417 522 47 the the DT 31417 522 48 furniture furniture NN 31417 522 49 at at IN 31417 522 50 once once RB 31417 522 51 violently violently RB 31417 522 52 moved move VBN 31417 522 53 in in IN 31417 522 54 rooms room NNS 31417 522 55 which which WDT 31417 522 56 I -PRON- PRP 31417 522 57 knew know VBD 31417 522 58 that that IN 31417 522 59 he -PRON- PRP 31417 522 60 had have VBD 31417 522 61 never never RB 31417 522 62 entered enter VBN 31417 522 63 till till IN 31417 522 64 that that DT 31417 522 65 moment moment NN 31417 522 66 . . . 31417 523 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 523 2 have have VBP 31417 523 3 seen see VBN 31417 523 4 heavy heavy JJ 31417 523 5 furniture furniture NN 31417 523 6 moved move VBN 31417 523 7 ; ; : 31417 523 8 for for IN 31417 523 9 instance instance NN 31417 523 10 , , , 31417 523 11 a a DT 31417 523 12 heavy heavy JJ 31417 523 13 sofa sofa NN 31417 523 14 in in IN 31417 523 15 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 523 16 own own JJ 31417 523 17 drawing drawing NN 31417 523 18 - - HYPH 31417 523 19 room room NN 31417 523 20 , , , 31417 523 21 with with IN 31417 523 22 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 523 23 upon upon IN 31417 523 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 523 25 , , , 31417 523 26 and and CC 31417 523 27 a a DT 31417 523 28 heavy heavy JJ 31417 523 29 centre centre NN 31417 523 30 table table NN 31417 523 31 , , , 31417 523 32 moved move VBD 31417 523 33 several several JJ 31417 523 34 feet foot NNS 31417 523 35 away away RB 31417 523 36 from from IN 31417 523 37 Home home NN 31417 523 38 , , , 31417 523 39 and and CC 31417 523 40 then then RB 31417 523 41 back back RB 31417 523 42 again again RB 31417 523 43 , , , 31417 523 44 in in IN 31417 523 45 the the DT 31417 523 46 light light NN 31417 523 47 , , , 31417 523 48 while while IN 31417 523 49 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 523 50 hands hand NNS 31417 523 51 and and CC 31417 523 52 feet foot NNS 31417 523 53 were be VBD 31417 523 54 visible visible JJ 31417 523 55 . . . 31417 524 1 Not not RB 31417 524 2 horse horse NN 31417 524 3 - - HYPH 31417 524 4 hairs hair NNS 31417 524 5 , , , 31417 524 6 but but CC 31417 524 7 ropes rope NNS 31417 524 8 , , , 31417 524 9 would would MD 31417 524 10 often often RB 31417 524 11 have have VB 31417 524 12 been be VBN 31417 524 13 necessary necessary JJ 31417 524 14 to to TO 31417 524 15 pull pull VB 31417 524 16 the the DT 31417 524 17 furniture furniture NN 31417 524 18 about about IN 31417 524 19 as as IN 31417 524 20 I -PRON- PRP 31417 524 21 have have VBP 31417 524 22 seen see VBN 31417 524 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 524 24 pulled pull VBN 31417 524 25 . . . 31417 525 1 " " `` 31417 525 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 525 3 34 34 CD 31417 525 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 525 5 A a DT 31417 525 6 brief brief JJ 31417 525 7 reference reference NN 31417 525 8 must must MD 31417 525 9 now now RB 31417 525 10 be be VB 31417 525 11 made make VBN 31417 525 12 to to IN 31417 525 13 what what WP 31417 525 14 is be VBZ 31417 525 15 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 525 16 the the DT 31417 525 17 most most RBS 31417 525 18 sensational sensational JJ 31417 525 19 alleged alleged JJ 31417 525 20 event event NN 31417 525 21 in in IN 31417 525 22 Home Home NNP 31417 525 23 's 's POS 31417 525 24 mediumistic mediumistic JJ 31417 525 25 career career NN 31417 525 26 , , , 31417 525 27 the the DT 31417 525 28 one one NN 31417 525 29 which which WDT 31417 525 30 is be VBZ 31417 525 31 most most RBS 31417 525 32 frequently frequently RB 31417 525 33 spoken speak VBN 31417 525 34 of of IN 31417 525 35 by by IN 31417 525 36 the the DT 31417 525 37 general general JJ 31417 525 38 public public NN 31417 525 39 , , , 31417 525 40 with with IN 31417 525 41 more more JJR 31417 525 42 or or CC 31417 525 43 less less JJR 31417 525 44 forcible forcible JJ 31417 525 45 expressions expression NNS 31417 525 46 of of IN 31417 525 47 scornful scornful JJ 31417 525 48 incredulity incredulity NN 31417 525 49 ; ; : 31417 525 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 525 51 " " `` 31417 525 52 levitation levitation NN 31417 525 53 " " '' 31417 525 54 out out IN 31417 525 55 of of IN 31417 525 56 the the DT 31417 525 57 window window NN 31417 525 58 of of IN 31417 525 59 a a DT 31417 525 60 room room NN 31417 525 61 at at IN 31417 525 62 a a DT 31417 525 63 great great JJ 31417 525 64 height height NN 31417 525 65 from from IN 31417 525 66 the the DT 31417 525 67 ground ground NN 31417 525 68 , , , 31417 525 69 and and CC 31417 525 70 in in IN 31417 525 71 at at IN 31417 525 72 a a DT 31417 525 73 window window NN 31417 525 74 of of IN 31417 525 75 the the DT 31417 525 76 next next JJ 31417 525 77 room room NN 31417 525 78 on on IN 31417 525 79 the the DT 31417 525 80 same same JJ 31417 525 81 story story NN 31417 525 82 . . . 31417 526 1 In in IN 31417 526 2 the the DT 31417 526 3 Report Report NNP 31417 526 4 by by IN 31417 526 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 526 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 526 7 and and CC 31417 526 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 526 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 526 10 , , , 31417 526 11 no no DT 31417 526 12 detailed detailed JJ 31417 526 13 account account NN 31417 526 14 of of IN 31417 526 15 this this DT 31417 526 16 is be VBZ 31417 526 17 given give VBN 31417 526 18 . . . 31417 527 1 The the DT 31417 527 2 Report Report NNP 31417 527 3 says say VBZ 31417 527 4 : : : 31417 527 5 " " `` 31417 527 6 Lords Lords NNPS 31417 527 7 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 527 8 and and CC 31417 527 9 Adare Adare NNP 31417 527 10 had have VBD 31417 527 11 printed print VBN 31417 527 12 a a DT 31417 527 13 statement statement NN 31417 527 14 that that IN 31417 527 15 Home Home NNP 31417 527 16 floated float VBD 31417 527 17 out out IN 31417 527 18 of of IN 31417 527 19 the the DT 31417 527 20 window window NN 31417 527 21 and and CC 31417 527 22 in in RB 31417 527 23 at at IN 31417 527 24 another another DT 31417 527 25 in in IN 31417 527 26 Ashley Ashley NNP 31417 527 27 Place Place NNP 31417 527 28 ( ( -LRB- 31417 527 29 Victoria Victoria NNP 31417 527 30 Street Street NNP 31417 527 31 ) ) -RRB- 31417 527 32 , , , 31417 527 33 S.W. S.W. NNP 31417 527 34 , , , 31417 527 35 16th 16th JJ 31417 527 36 December December NNP 31417 527 37 1868 1868 CD 31417 527 38 . . . 31417 528 1 " " `` 31417 528 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 528 3 35 35 CD 31417 528 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 528 5 At at IN 31417 528 6 a a DT 31417 528 7 meeting meeting NN 31417 528 8 of of IN 31417 528 9 the the DT 31417 528 10 Committee Committee NNP 31417 528 11 of of IN 31417 528 12 the the DT 31417 528 13 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 528 14 Society Society NNP 31417 528 15 , , , 31417 528 16 held hold VBN 31417 528 17 on on IN 31417 528 18 6th 6th JJ 31417 528 19 July July NNP 31417 528 20 1869 1869 CD 31417 528 21 , , , 31417 528 22 a a DT 31417 528 23 paper paper NN 31417 528 24 was be VBD 31417 528 25 read read VBN 31417 528 26 from from IN 31417 528 27 Lord Lord NNP 31417 528 28 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 528 29 , , , 31417 528 30 describing describe VBG 31417 528 31 some some DT 31417 528 32 of of IN 31417 528 33 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 528 34 personal personal JJ 31417 528 35 experiences experience NNS 31417 528 36 with with IN 31417 528 37 Home home NN 31417 528 38 . . . 31417 529 1 This this DT 31417 529 2 paper paper NN 31417 529 3 makes make VBZ 31417 529 4 no no DT 31417 529 5 reference reference NN 31417 529 6 to to IN 31417 529 7 the the DT 31417 529 8 above above JJ 31417 529 9 case case NN 31417 529 10 of of IN 31417 529 11 levitation levitation NN 31417 529 12 . . . 31417 530 1 But but CC 31417 530 2 at at IN 31417 530 3 the the DT 31417 530 4 same same JJ 31417 530 5 meeting meeting NN 31417 530 6 of of IN 31417 530 7 the the DT 31417 530 8 Committee Committee NNP 31417 530 9 , , , 31417 530 10 Lord Lord NNP 31417 530 11 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 530 12 and and CC 31417 530 13 others other NNS 31417 530 14 gave give VBD 31417 530 15 evidence evidence NN 31417 530 16 as as IN 31417 530 17 witnesses witness NNS 31417 530 18 , , , 31417 530 19 and and CC 31417 530 20 Lord Lord NNP 31417 530 21 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 530 22 thus thus RB 31417 530 23 described describe VBD 31417 530 24 this this DT 31417 530 25 particular particular JJ 31417 530 26 case:-- case:-- -RRB- 31417 530 27 " " `` 31417 530 28 I -PRON- PRP 31417 530 29 saw see VBD 31417 530 30 the the DT 31417 530 31 levitations levitation NNS 31417 530 32 in in IN 31417 530 33 Victoria Victoria NNP 31417 530 34 Street Street NNP 31417 530 35 , , , 31417 530 36 when when WRB 31417 530 37 Home Home NNP 31417 530 38 floated float VBD 31417 530 39 out out IN 31417 530 40 of of IN 31417 530 41 the the DT 31417 530 42 window window NN 31417 530 43 ; ; : 31417 530 44 he -PRON- PRP 31417 530 45 first first RB 31417 530 46 went go VBD 31417 530 47 into into IN 31417 530 48 a a DT 31417 530 49 trance trance NN 31417 530 50 , , , 31417 530 51 and and CC 31417 530 52 walked walk VBD 31417 530 53 about about IN 31417 530 54 uneasily uneasily RB 31417 530 55 ; ; : 31417 530 56 he -PRON- PRP 31417 530 57 then then RB 31417 530 58 went go VBD 31417 530 59 into into IN 31417 530 60 the the DT 31417 530 61 hall hall NN 31417 530 62 ; ; : 31417 530 63 while while IN 31417 530 64 he -PRON- PRP 31417 530 65 was be VBD 31417 530 66 away away RB 31417 530 67 , , , 31417 530 68 I -PRON- PRP 31417 530 69 heard hear VBD 31417 530 70 a a DT 31417 530 71 voice voice NN 31417 530 72 whisper whisper NN 31417 530 73 in in IN 31417 530 74 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 530 75 ear ear NN 31417 530 76 , , , 31417 530 77 ' ' '' 31417 530 78 He -PRON- PRP 31417 530 79 will will MD 31417 530 80 go go VB 31417 530 81 out out IN 31417 530 82 of of IN 31417 530 83 one one CD 31417 530 84 window window NN 31417 530 85 and and CC 31417 530 86 in in RB 31417 530 87 at at IN 31417 530 88 another another DT 31417 530 89 . . . 31417 530 90 ' ' '' 31417 531 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 531 2 was be VBD 31417 531 3 alarmed alarm VBN 31417 531 4 and and CC 31417 531 5 shocked shock VBN 31417 531 6 at at IN 31417 531 7 the the DT 31417 531 8 idea idea NN 31417 531 9 of of IN 31417 531 10 so so RB 31417 531 11 dangerous dangerous JJ 31417 531 12 an an DT 31417 531 13 experiment experiment NN 31417 531 14 . . . 31417 532 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 532 2 told tell VBD 31417 532 3 the the DT 31417 532 4 company company NN 31417 532 5 what what WP 31417 532 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 532 7 had have VBD 31417 532 8 heard hear VBN 31417 532 9 , , , 31417 532 10 and and CC 31417 532 11 we -PRON- PRP 31417 532 12 then then RB 31417 532 13 waited wait VBD 31417 532 14 for for IN 31417 532 15 Home Home NNP 31417 532 16 's 's POS 31417 532 17 return return NN 31417 532 18 . . . 31417 533 1 Shortly shortly RB 31417 533 2 after after IN 31417 533 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 533 4 entered enter VBD 31417 533 5 the the DT 31417 533 6 room room NN 31417 533 7 , , , 31417 533 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 533 9 heard hear VBD 31417 533 10 the the DT 31417 533 11 window window NN 31417 533 12 go go VB 31417 533 13 up up RP 31417 533 14 , , , 31417 533 15 but but CC 31417 533 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 533 17 could could MD 31417 533 18 not not RB 31417 533 19 see see VB 31417 533 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 533 21 , , , 31417 533 22 for for IN 31417 533 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 533 24 sat sit VBD 31417 533 25 with with IN 31417 533 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 533 27 back back NN 31417 533 28 to to IN 31417 533 29 it -PRON- PRP 31417 533 30 . . . 31417 534 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 534 2 , , , 31417 534 3 however however RB 31417 534 4 , , , 31417 534 5 saw see VBD 31417 534 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 534 7 shadow shadow NN 31417 534 8 on on IN 31417 534 9 the the DT 31417 534 10 opposite opposite JJ 31417 534 11 wall wall NN 31417 534 12 ; ; : 31417 534 13 he -PRON- PRP 31417 534 14 went go VBD 31417 534 15 out out IN 31417 534 16 of of IN 31417 534 17 the the DT 31417 534 18 window window NN 31417 534 19 in in IN 31417 534 20 a a DT 31417 534 21 horizontal horizontal JJ 31417 534 22 position position NN 31417 534 23 , , , 31417 534 24 and and CC 31417 534 25 I -PRON- PRP 31417 534 26 saw see VBD 31417 534 27 him -PRON- PRP 31417 534 28 outside outside IN 31417 534 29 the the DT 31417 534 30 other other JJ 31417 534 31 window window NN 31417 534 32 ( ( -LRB- 31417 534 33 that that IN 31417 534 34 in in IN 31417 534 35 the the DT 31417 534 36 next next JJ 31417 534 37 room room NN 31417 534 38 ) ) -RRB- 31417 534 39 floating float VBG 31417 534 40 in in IN 31417 534 41 the the DT 31417 534 42 air air NN 31417 534 43 . . . 31417 535 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 535 2 was be VBD 31417 535 3 eighty eighty CD 31417 535 4 - - HYPH 31417 535 5 five five CD 31417 535 6 feet foot NNS 31417 535 7 from from IN 31417 535 8 the the DT 31417 535 9 ground ground NN 31417 535 10 . . . 31417 536 1 There there EX 31417 536 2 was be VBD 31417 536 3 no no DT 31417 536 4 balcony balcony NN 31417 536 5 along along IN 31417 536 6 the the DT 31417 536 7 windows window NNS 31417 536 8 , , , 31417 536 9 merely merely RB 31417 536 10 a a DT 31417 536 11 strong strong JJ 31417 536 12 course course NN 31417 536 13 an an DT 31417 536 14 inch inch NN 31417 536 15 and and CC 31417 536 16 a a DT 31417 536 17 half half NN 31417 536 18 wide wide RB 31417 536 19 ; ; : 31417 536 20 each each DT 31417 536 21 window window NN 31417 536 22 had have VBD 31417 536 23 a a DT 31417 536 24 small small JJ 31417 536 25 plant plant NN 31417 536 26 stand stand NN 31417 536 27 , , , 31417 536 28 but but CC 31417 536 29 there there EX 31417 536 30 was be VBD 31417 536 31 no no DT 31417 536 32 connection connection NN 31417 536 33 between between IN 31417 536 34 them -PRON- PRP 31417 536 35 . . . 31417 537 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 537 2 have have VBP 31417 537 3 no no DT 31417 537 4 theory theory NN 31417 537 5 to to TO 31417 537 6 explain explain VB 31417 537 7 these these DT 31417 537 8 things thing NNS 31417 537 9 . . . 31417 538 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 538 2 have have VBP 31417 538 3 tried try VBN 31417 538 4 to to TO 31417 538 5 find find VB 31417 538 6 out out RP 31417 538 7 how how WRB 31417 538 8 they -PRON- PRP 31417 538 9 are be VBP 31417 538 10 done do VBN 31417 538 11 , , , 31417 538 12 but but CC 31417 538 13 the the DT 31417 538 14 more more RBR 31417 538 15 I -PRON- PRP 31417 538 16 studied study VBD 31417 538 17 them -PRON- PRP 31417 538 18 , , , 31417 538 19 the the DT 31417 538 20 more more RBR 31417 538 21 satisfied satisfied JJ 31417 538 22 was be VBD 31417 538 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 538 24 that that WDT 31417 538 25 they -PRON- PRP 31417 538 26 could could MD 31417 538 27 not not RB 31417 538 28 be be VB 31417 538 29 explained explain VBN 31417 538 30 by by IN 31417 538 31 mere mere JJ 31417 538 32 mechanical mechanical JJ 31417 538 33 trick trick NN 31417 538 34 . . . 31417 539 1 " " `` 31417 539 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 539 3 36 36 CD 31417 539 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 539 5 There there EX 31417 539 6 is be VBZ 31417 539 7 one one CD 31417 539 8 episode episode NN 31417 539 9 in in IN 31417 539 10 the the DT 31417 539 11 career career NN 31417 539 12 of of IN 31417 539 13 D. D. NNP 31417 539 14 D. D. NNP 31417 539 15 Home Home NNP 31417 539 16 which which WDT 31417 539 17 , , , 31417 539 18 although although IN 31417 539 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 539 20 does do VBZ 31417 539 21 not not RB 31417 539 22 affect affect VB 31417 539 23 the the DT 31417 539 24 reality reality NN 31417 539 25 of of IN 31417 539 26 the the DT 31417 539 27 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 539 28 alleged allege VBN 31417 539 29 to to TO 31417 539 30 have have VB 31417 539 31 taken take VBN 31417 539 32 place place NN 31417 539 33 in in IN 31417 539 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 539 35 presence presence NN 31417 539 36 , , , 31417 539 37 claims claim VBZ 31417 539 38 a a DT 31417 539 39 brief brief JJ 31417 539 40 mention mention NN 31417 539 41 . . . 31417 540 1 The the DT 31417 540 2 gift gift NN 31417 540 3 to to IN 31417 540 4 Home Home NNP 31417 540 5 by by IN 31417 540 6 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 540 7 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 540 8 of of IN 31417 540 9 a a DT 31417 540 10 large large JJ 31417 540 11 sum sum NN 31417 540 12 of of IN 31417 540 13 money money NN 31417 540 14 , , , 31417 540 15 the the DT 31417 540 16 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 540 17 lawsuit lawsuit NN 31417 540 18 , , , 31417 540 19 and and CC 31417 540 20 the the DT 31417 540 21 judgment judgment NN 31417 540 22 in in IN 31417 540 23 accordance accordance NN 31417 540 24 with with IN 31417 540 25 which which WDT 31417 540 26 the the DT 31417 540 27 money money NN 31417 540 28 was be VBD 31417 540 29 returned return VBN 31417 540 30 to to IN 31417 540 31 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 540 32 original original JJ 31417 540 33 owner owner NN 31417 540 34 , , , 31417 540 35 excited excite VBD 31417 540 36 much much JJ 31417 540 37 attention attention NN 31417 540 38 at at IN 31417 540 39 the the DT 31417 540 40 time time NN 31417 540 41 . . . 31417 541 1 Public public JJ 31417 541 2 opinion opinion NN 31417 541 3 frequently frequently RB 31417 541 4 takes take VBZ 31417 541 5 up up RP 31417 541 6 sensational sensational JJ 31417 541 7 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 541 8 in in IN 31417 541 9 a a DT 31417 541 10 most most RBS 31417 541 11 illogical illogical JJ 31417 541 12 and and CC 31417 541 13 unscientific unscientific JJ 31417 541 14 manner manner NN 31417 541 15 . . . 31417 542 1 But but CC 31417 542 2 a a DT 31417 542 3 permanent permanent JJ 31417 542 4 effect effect NN 31417 542 5 may may MD 31417 542 6 thus thus RB 31417 542 7 be be VB 31417 542 8 produced produce VBN 31417 542 9 , , , 31417 542 10 which which WDT 31417 542 11 is be VBZ 31417 542 12 extremely extremely RB 31417 542 13 difficult difficult JJ 31417 542 14 to to TO 31417 542 15 eradicate eradicate VB 31417 542 16 , , , 31417 542 17 even even RB 31417 542 18 if if IN 31417 542 19 shown show VBN 31417 542 20 to to TO 31417 542 21 be be VB 31417 542 22 unjustifiable unjustifiable JJ 31417 542 23 . . . 31417 543 1 This this DT 31417 543 2 episode episode NN 31417 543 3 with with IN 31417 543 4 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 543 5 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 543 6 has have VBZ 31417 543 7 probably probably RB 31417 543 8 had have VBN 31417 543 9 more more JJR 31417 543 10 effect effect NN 31417 543 11 than than IN 31417 543 12 any any DT 31417 543 13 other other JJ 31417 543 14 circumstance circumstance NN 31417 543 15 in in IN 31417 543 16 causing cause VBG 31417 543 17 the the DT 31417 543 18 feeling feeling NN 31417 543 19 of of IN 31417 543 20 aversion aversion NN 31417 543 21 with with IN 31417 543 22 which which WDT 31417 543 23 large large JJ 31417 543 24 numbers number NNS 31417 543 25 of of IN 31417 543 26 people people NNS 31417 543 27 regard regard VBP 31417 543 28 Home home RB 31417 543 29 and and CC 31417 543 30 all all PDT 31417 543 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 543 32 doings doing NNS 31417 543 33 . . . 31417 544 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 544 2 is be VBZ 31417 544 3 looked look VBN 31417 544 4 upon upon IN 31417 544 5 , , , 31417 544 6 and and CC 31417 544 7 spoken speak VBN 31417 544 8 of of IN 31417 544 9 , , , 31417 544 10 as as IN 31417 544 11 if if IN 31417 544 12 he -PRON- PRP 31417 544 13 were be VBD 31417 544 14 an an DT 31417 544 15 unprincipled unprincipled JJ 31417 544 16 adventurer adventurer NN 31417 544 17 , , , 31417 544 18 convicted convict VBN 31417 544 19 of of IN 31417 544 20 fraud fraud NN 31417 544 21 , , , 31417 544 22 and and CC 31417 544 23 of of IN 31417 544 24 obtaining obtain VBG 31417 544 25 money money NN 31417 544 26 under under IN 31417 544 27 false false JJ 31417 544 28 pretences pretence NNS 31417 544 29 . . . 31417 545 1 The the DT 31417 545 2 remarks remark NNS 31417 545 3 at at IN 31417 545 4 the the DT 31417 545 5 end end NN 31417 545 6 of of IN 31417 545 7 this this DT 31417 545 8 chapter chapter NN 31417 545 9 are be VBP 31417 545 10 based base VBN 31417 545 11 mainly mainly RB 31417 545 12 upon upon IN 31417 545 13 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 545 14 III III NNP 31417 545 15 . . . 31417 546 1 to to IN 31417 546 2 the the DT 31417 546 3 Report Report NNP 31417 546 4 by by IN 31417 546 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 546 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 546 7 and and CC 31417 546 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 546 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 546 10 , , , 31417 546 11 and and CC 31417 546 12 which which WDT 31417 546 13 deals deal VBZ 31417 546 14 with with IN 31417 546 15 the the DT 31417 546 16 case case NN 31417 546 17 of of IN 31417 546 18 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 546 19 _ _ NNP 31417 546 20 v. v. IN 31417 546 21 _ _ NNP 31417 546 22 Home Home NNP 31417 546 23 . . . 31417 547 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 547 2 37 37 CD 31417 547 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 547 4 The the DT 31417 547 5 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 547 6 commences commence NNS 31417 547 7 thus thus RB 31417 547 8 : : : 31417 547 9 " " `` 31417 547 10 Our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 547 11 colleague colleague NN 31417 547 12 , , , 31417 547 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 547 14 H. H. NNP 31417 547 15 Arthur Arthur NNP 31417 547 16 Smith Smith NNP 31417 547 17 [ [ -LRB- 31417 547 18 barrister barrister NN 31417 547 19 - - HYPH 31417 547 20 at at IN 31417 547 21 - - HYPH 31417 547 22 law law NN 31417 547 23 ] ] -RRB- 31417 547 24 , , , 31417 547 25 author author NN 31417 547 26 of of IN 31417 547 27 ' ' '' 31417 547 28 Principles Principles NNPS 31417 547 29 of of IN 31417 547 30 Equity equity NN 31417 547 31 , , , 31417 547 32 ' ' '' 31417 547 33 has have VBZ 31417 547 34 kindly kindly RB 31417 547 35 furnished furnish VBN 31417 547 36 us -PRON- PRP 31417 547 37 with with IN 31417 547 38 the the DT 31417 547 39 following follow VBG 31417 547 40 review review NN 31417 547 41 of of IN 31417 547 42 the the DT 31417 547 43 case case NN 31417 547 44 of of IN 31417 547 45 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 547 46 _ _ NNP 31417 547 47 v. v. IN 31417 547 48 _ _ NNP 31417 547 49 Home Home NNP 31417 547 50 . . . 31417 547 51 " " '' 31417 548 1 The the DT 31417 548 2 following follow VBG 31417 548 3 are be VBP 31417 548 4 a a DT 31417 548 5 few few JJ 31417 548 6 extracts extract NNS 31417 548 7 from from IN 31417 548 8 this this DT 31417 548 9 review:-- review:-- NN 31417 548 10 " " `` 31417 548 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 548 12 have have VBP 31417 548 13 looked look VBN 31417 548 14 carefully carefully RB 31417 548 15 into into IN 31417 548 16 the the DT 31417 548 17 case case NN 31417 548 18 of of IN 31417 548 19 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 548 20 _ _ NNP 31417 548 21 v. v. IN 31417 548 22 _ _ NNP 31417 548 23 Home Home NNP 31417 548 24 as as IN 31417 548 25 reported report VBN 31417 548 26 in in IN 31417 548 27 the the DT 31417 548 28 Law Law NNP 31417 548 29 Reports Reports NNPS 31417 548 30 ( ( -LRB- 31417 548 31 6 6 CD 31417 548 32 Equity Equity NNP 31417 548 33 , , , 31417 548 34 655 655 CD 31417 548 35 ) ) -RRB- 31417 548 36 , , , 31417 548 37 ... ... : 31417 548 38 and and CC 31417 548 39 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 548 40 the the DT 31417 548 41 following follow VBG 31417 548 42 comments comment NNS 31417 548 43 may may MD 31417 548 44 be be VB 31417 548 45 useful useful JJ 31417 548 46 to to IN 31417 548 47 you -PRON- PRP 31417 548 48 . . . 31417 549 1 " " `` 31417 549 2 It -PRON- PRP 31417 549 3 is be VBZ 31417 549 4 certainly certainly RB 31417 549 5 the the DT 31417 549 6 fact fact NN 31417 549 7 that that IN 31417 549 8 the the DT 31417 549 9 judge judge NN 31417 549 10 discredited discredit VBD 31417 549 11 the the DT 31417 549 12 evidence evidence NN 31417 549 13 of of IN 31417 549 14 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 549 15 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 549 16 . . . 31417 550 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 550 2 said say VBD 31417 550 3 : : : 31417 550 4 ' ' `` 31417 550 5 Reliance reliance NN 31417 550 6 can can MD 31417 550 7 not not RB 31417 550 8 be be VB 31417 550 9 placed place VBN 31417 550 10 on on IN 31417 550 11 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 550 12 testimony testimony NN 31417 550 13 .... .... . 31417 551 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 551 2 would would MD 31417 551 3 be be VB 31417 551 4 unjust unjust JJ 31417 551 5 to to TO 31417 551 6 found find VBN 31417 551 7 on on IN 31417 551 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 551 9 a a DT 31417 551 10 decree decree NN 31417 551 11 against against IN 31417 551 12 any any DT 31417 551 13 man man NN 31417 551 14 , , , 31417 551 15 save save VB 31417 551 16 in in IN 31417 551 17 so so RB 31417 551 18 far far RB 31417 551 19 as as IN 31417 551 20 what what WP 31417 551 21 she -PRON- PRP 31417 551 22 has have VBZ 31417 551 23 sworn swear VBN 31417 551 24 to to TO 31417 551 25 may may MD 31417 551 26 be be VB 31417 551 27 corroborated corroborate VBN 31417 551 28 by by IN 31417 551 29 written write VBN 31417 551 30 documents document NNS 31417 551 31 , , , 31417 551 32 or or CC 31417 551 33 unimpeached unimpeached JJ 31417 551 34 witnesses witness NNS 31417 551 35 , , , 31417 551 36 or or CC 31417 551 37 incontrovertible incontrovertible JJ 31417 551 38 facts fact NNS 31417 551 39 . . . 31417 551 40 ' ' '' 31417 552 1 " " `` 31417 552 2 Having have VBG 31417 552 3 , , , 31417 552 4 then then RB 31417 552 5 , , , 31417 552 6 eventually eventually RB 31417 552 7 decided decide VBD 31417 552 8 against against IN 31417 552 9 Home home NN 31417 552 10 , , , 31417 552 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 552 12 follows follow VBZ 31417 552 13 that that IN 31417 552 14 the the DT 31417 552 15 judge judge NN 31417 552 16 must must MD 31417 552 17 have have VB 31417 552 18 considered consider VBN 31417 552 19 that that IN 31417 552 20 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 552 21 evidence evidence NN 31417 552 22 was be VBD 31417 552 23 corroborated corroborate VBN 31417 552 24 in in IN 31417 552 25 some some DT 31417 552 26 or or CC 31417 552 27 other other JJ 31417 552 28 of of IN 31417 552 29 the the DT 31417 552 30 ways way NNS 31417 552 31 mentioned mention VBN 31417 552 32 . . . 31417 552 33 " " '' 31417 553 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 553 2 H. H. NNP 31417 553 3 Arthur Arthur NNP 31417 553 4 Smith Smith NNP 31417 553 5 further further RB 31417 553 6 says say VBZ 31417 553 7 : : : 31417 553 8 " " `` 31417 553 9 There there EX 31417 553 10 was be VBD 31417 553 11 also also RB 31417 553 12 an an DT 31417 553 13 admitted admit VBN 31417 553 14 letter letter NN 31417 553 15 from from IN 31417 553 16 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 553 17 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 553 18 to to IN 31417 553 19 Home Home NNP 31417 553 20 , , , 31417 553 21 in in IN 31417 553 22 which which WDT 31417 553 23 she -PRON- PRP 31417 553 24 stated state VBD 31417 553 25 that that IN 31417 553 26 she -PRON- PRP 31417 553 27 presented present VBD 31417 553 28 him -PRON- PRP 31417 553 29 with with IN 31417 553 30 the the DT 31417 553 31 £ £ $ 31417 553 32 24,000 24,000 CD 31417 553 33 as as IN 31417 553 34 an an DT 31417 553 35 ' ' `` 31417 553 36 _ _ NNP 31417 553 37 entirely entirely RB 31417 553 38 free free JJ 31417 553 39 gift gift NN 31417 553 40 _ _ NNP 31417 553 41 . . . 31417 553 42 ' ' '' 31417 554 1 This this DT 31417 554 2 , , , 31417 554 3 she -PRON- PRP 31417 554 4 said say VBD 31417 554 5 , , , 31417 554 6 was be VBD 31417 554 7 written write VBN 31417 554 8 by by IN 31417 554 9 her -PRON- PRP 31417 554 10 at at IN 31417 554 11 Home home NN 31417 554 12 's 's POS 31417 554 13 dictation dictation NN 31417 554 14 , , , 31417 554 15 under under IN 31417 554 16 magnetic magnetic JJ 31417 554 17 influence influence NN 31417 554 18 . . . 31417 554 19 " " '' 31417 555 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 555 2 H. H. NNP 31417 555 3 Arthur Arthur NNP 31417 555 4 Smith Smith NNP 31417 555 5 proceeds proceed VBZ 31417 555 6 to to TO 31417 555 7 discuss discuss VB 31417 555 8 the the DT 31417 555 9 " " `` 31417 555 10 corroborative corroborative JJ 31417 555 11 evidence evidence NN 31417 555 12 which which WDT 31417 555 13 led lead VBD 31417 555 14 to to IN 31417 555 15 the the DT 31417 555 16 judge judge NN 31417 555 17 's 's POS 31417 555 18 final final JJ 31417 555 19 opinion opinion NN 31417 555 20 . . . 31417 555 21 " " '' 31417 556 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 556 2 then then RB 31417 556 3 remarks:-- remarks:-- VBZ 31417 556 4 " " `` 31417 556 5 Now now RB 31417 556 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 556 7 must must MD 31417 556 8 , , , 31417 556 9 I -PRON- PRP 31417 556 10 think think VBP 31417 556 11 , , , 31417 556 12 be be VB 31417 556 13 admitted admit VBN 31417 556 14 that that IN 31417 556 15 considering consider VBG 31417 556 16 the the DT 31417 556 17 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 31417 556 18 character character NN 31417 556 19 of of IN 31417 556 20 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 556 21 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 556 22 's 's POS 31417 556 23 conduct conduct NN 31417 556 24 , , , 31417 556 25 and and CC 31417 556 26 the the DT 31417 556 27 swiftness swiftness NN 31417 556 28 with with IN 31417 556 29 which which WDT 31417 556 30 she -PRON- PRP 31417 556 31 reached reach VBD 31417 556 32 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 556 33 decision decision NN 31417 556 34 to to TO 31417 556 35 transfer transfer VB 31417 556 36 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 556 37 property property NN 31417 556 38 to to IN 31417 556 39 Home home NN 31417 556 40 , , , 31417 556 41 such such JJ 31417 556 42 evidence evidence NN 31417 556 43 as as IN 31417 556 44 the the DT 31417 556 45 above above RB 31417 556 46 may may MD 31417 556 47 reasonably reasonably RB 31417 556 48 be be VB 31417 556 49 deemed deem VBN 31417 556 50 corroborative corroborative JJ 31417 556 51 of of IN 31417 556 52 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 556 53 assertion assertion NN 31417 556 54 that that IN 31417 556 55 she -PRON- PRP 31417 556 56 was be VBD 31417 556 57 induced induce VBN 31417 556 58 to to TO 31417 556 59 act act VB 31417 556 60 as as IN 31417 556 61 she -PRON- PRP 31417 556 62 did do VBD 31417 556 63 by by IN 31417 556 64 the the DT 31417 556 65 effects effect NNS 31417 556 66 of of IN 31417 556 67 Home Home NNP 31417 556 68 's 's POS 31417 556 69 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 556 70 pretensions pretension NNS 31417 556 71 .... .... . 31417 557 1 There there EX 31417 557 2 was be VBD 31417 557 3 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 557 4 ... ... : 31417 557 5 in in IN 31417 557 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 557 7 opinion opinion NN 31417 557 8 , , , 31417 557 9 to to TO 31417 557 10 establish establish VB 31417 557 11 the the DT 31417 557 12 plaintiff plaintiff NN 31417 557 13 's 's POS 31417 557 14 case case NN 31417 557 15 . . . 31417 558 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 558 2 is be VBZ 31417 558 3 not not RB 31417 558 4 then then RB 31417 558 5 true true JJ 31417 558 6 that that IN 31417 558 7 ' ' `` 31417 558 8 Home home NN 31417 558 9 was be VBD 31417 558 10 made make VBN 31417 558 11 to to TO 31417 558 12 restore restore VB 31417 558 13 the the DT 31417 558 14 money money NN 31417 558 15 , , , 31417 558 16 because because IN 31417 558 17 , , , 31417 558 18 being be VBG 31417 558 19 a a DT 31417 558 20 professed profess VBN 31417 558 21 medium medium NN 31417 558 22 , , , 31417 558 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 558 24 was be VBD 31417 558 25 likely likely JJ 31417 558 26 that that IN 31417 558 27 he -PRON- PRP 31417 558 28 should should MD 31417 558 29 have have VB 31417 558 30 induced induce VBN 31417 558 31 her -PRON- PRP 31417 558 32 in in IN 31417 558 33 the the DT 31417 558 34 way way NN 31417 558 35 he -PRON- PRP 31417 558 36 did do VBD 31417 558 37 . . . 31417 558 38 ' ' '' 31417 559 1 The the DT 31417 559 2 Court Court NNP 31417 559 3 held hold VBD 31417 559 4 the the DT 31417 559 5 law law NN 31417 559 6 to to TO 31417 559 7 be be VB 31417 559 8 that that IN 31417 559 9 such such JJ 31417 559 10 transactions transaction NNS 31417 559 11 as as IN 31417 559 12 those those DT 31417 559 13 in in IN 31417 559 14 question question NN 31417 559 15 can can MD 31417 559 16 not not RB 31417 559 17 be be VB 31417 559 18 upheld uphold VBN 31417 559 19 , , , 31417 559 20 ' ' '' 31417 559 21 unless unless IN 31417 559 22 the the DT 31417 559 23 Court Court NNP 31417 559 24 is be VBZ 31417 559 25 quite quite RB 31417 559 26 satisfied satisfied JJ 31417 559 27 that that IN 31417 559 28 they -PRON- PRP 31417 559 29 are be VBP 31417 559 30 acts act NNS 31417 559 31 of of IN 31417 559 32 pure pure JJ 31417 559 33 volition volition NN 31417 559 34 uninfluenced uninfluenced JJ 31417 559 35 . . . 31417 559 36 ' ' '' 31417 560 1 ... ... NFP 31417 561 1 There there EX 31417 561 2 was be VBD 31417 561 3 evidence evidence NN 31417 561 4 of of IN 31417 561 5 considerable considerable JJ 31417 561 6 weight weight NN 31417 561 7 , , , 31417 561 8 that that IN 31417 561 9 as as IN 31417 561 10 a a DT 31417 561 11 matter matter NN 31417 561 12 of of IN 31417 561 13 fact fact NN 31417 561 14 ... ... : 31417 561 15 Home home NN 31417 561 16 did do VBD 31417 561 17 work work NN 31417 561 18 on on IN 31417 561 19 the the DT 31417 561 20 mind mind NN 31417 561 21 of of IN 31417 561 22 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 561 23 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 561 24 by by IN 31417 561 25 means mean NNS 31417 561 26 of of IN 31417 561 27 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 561 28 devices device NNS 31417 561 29 , , , 31417 561 30 and and CC 31417 561 31 further far RBR 31417 561 32 that that IN 31417 561 33 he -PRON- PRP 31417 561 34 did do VBD 31417 561 35 so so RB 31417 561 36 by by IN 31417 561 37 suggesting suggest VBG 31417 561 38 communications communication NNS 31417 561 39 from from IN 31417 561 40 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 561 41 deceased deceased JJ 31417 561 42 husband husband NN 31417 561 43 . . . 31417 562 1 Whether whether IN 31417 562 2 this this DT 31417 562 3 is be VBZ 31417 562 4 to to IN 31417 562 5 Home Home NNP 31417 562 6 's 's POS 31417 562 7 discredit discredit NN 31417 562 8 or or CC 31417 562 9 not not RB 31417 562 10 of of IN 31417 562 11 course course NN 31417 562 12 will will MD 31417 562 13 be be VB 31417 562 14 decided decide VBN 31417 562 15 according accord VBG 31417 562 16 to to IN 31417 562 17 one one PRP 31417 562 18 's 's POS 31417 562 19 belief belief NN 31417 562 20 in in IN 31417 562 21 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 562 22 and and CC 31417 562 23 the the DT 31417 562 24 reality reality NN 31417 562 25 of of IN 31417 562 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 562 27 husband husband NN 31417 562 28 's 's POS 31417 562 29 interference interference NN 31417 562 30 .... .... . 31417 562 31 H. H. NNP 31417 562 32 ARTHUR ARTHUR NNP 31417 562 33 SMITH SMITH NNP 31417 562 34 . . . 31417 563 1 1 1 CD 31417 563 2 NEW NEW NNP 31417 563 3 SQUARE SQUARE NNP 31417 563 4 , , , 31417 563 5 LINCOLN LINCOLN NNP 31417 563 6 'S 's POS 31417 563 7 INN INN NNP 31417 563 8 , , , 31417 563 9 _ _ NNP 31417 563 10 October October NNP 31417 563 11 _ _ NNP 31417 563 12 19 19 CD 31417 563 13 , , , 31417 563 14 1888 1888 CD 31417 563 15 . . . 31417 563 16 " " '' 31417 564 1 In in IN 31417 564 2 order order NN 31417 564 3 that that IN 31417 564 4 this this DT 31417 564 5 episode episode NN 31417 564 6 should should MD 31417 564 7 have have VB 31417 564 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 564 9 rightful rightful JJ 31417 564 10 effect effect NN 31417 564 11 , , , 31417 564 12 and and CC 31417 564 13 no no RB 31417 564 14 more more JJR 31417 564 15 , , , 31417 564 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 564 17 is be VBZ 31417 564 18 needful needful JJ 31417 564 19 that that IN 31417 564 20 several several JJ 31417 564 21 things thing NNS 31417 564 22 should should MD 31417 564 23 be be VB 31417 564 24 borne bear VBN 31417 564 25 in in IN 31417 564 26 mind mind NN 31417 564 27 . . . 31417 565 1 In in IN 31417 565 2 the the DT 31417 565 3 first first JJ 31417 565 4 place place NN 31417 565 5 , , , 31417 565 6 the the DT 31417 565 7 action action NN 31417 565 8 was be VBD 31417 565 9 in in IN 31417 565 10 a a DT 31417 565 11 Court Court NNP 31417 565 12 of of IN 31417 565 13 Equity Equity NNP 31417 565 14 . . . 31417 566 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 566 2 was be VBD 31417 566 3 not not RB 31417 566 4 a a DT 31417 566 5 prosecution prosecution NN 31417 566 6 in in IN 31417 566 7 a a DT 31417 566 8 Criminal Criminal NNP 31417 566 9 Court Court NNP 31417 566 10 . . . 31417 567 1 The the DT 31417 567 2 decision decision NN 31417 567 3 of of IN 31417 567 4 the the DT 31417 567 5 Court Court NNP 31417 567 6 was be VBD 31417 567 7 not not RB 31417 567 8 a a DT 31417 567 9 verdict verdict NN 31417 567 10 of of IN 31417 567 11 guilty guilty JJ 31417 567 12 against against IN 31417 567 13 a a DT 31417 567 14 prisoner prisoner NN 31417 567 15 , , , 31417 567 16 to to TO 31417 567 17 be be VB 31417 567 18 followed follow VBN 31417 567 19 by by IN 31417 567 20 punishment punishment NN 31417 567 21 for for IN 31417 567 22 wrong wrong NN 31417 567 23 - - HYPH 31417 567 24 doing doing NN 31417 567 25 , , , 31417 567 26 but but CC 31417 567 27 an an DT 31417 567 28 order order NN 31417 567 29 to to TO 31417 567 30 refund refund VB 31417 567 31 certain certain JJ 31417 567 32 money money NN 31417 567 33 . . . 31417 568 1 In in IN 31417 568 2 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 568 3 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 568 4 a a DT 31417 568 5 judgment judgment NN 31417 568 6 of of IN 31417 568 7 this this DT 31417 568 8 kind kind NN 31417 568 9 does do VBZ 31417 568 10 not not RB 31417 568 11 brand brand VB 31417 568 12 a a DT 31417 568 13 man man NN 31417 568 14 with with IN 31417 568 15 infamy infamy NN 31417 568 16 , , , 31417 568 17 nor nor CC 31417 568 18 affect affect VB 31417 568 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 568 20 character character NN 31417 568 21 and and CC 31417 568 22 position position NN 31417 568 23 in in IN 31417 568 24 the the DT 31417 568 25 eyes eye NNS 31417 568 26 of of IN 31417 568 27 society society NN 31417 568 28 . . . 31417 569 1 Again again RB 31417 569 2 , , , 31417 569 3 after after IN 31417 569 4 the the DT 31417 569 5 judgment judgment NN 31417 569 6 of of IN 31417 569 7 the the DT 31417 569 8 Court Court NNP 31417 569 9 , , , 31417 569 10 Home Home NNP 31417 569 11 promptly promptly RB 31417 569 12 repaid repay VBD 31417 569 13 the the DT 31417 569 14 money money NN 31417 569 15 . . . 31417 570 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 570 2 had have VBD 31417 570 3 not not RB 31417 570 4 appropriated appropriate VBN 31417 570 5 or or CC 31417 570 6 expended expend VBD 31417 570 7 any any DT 31417 570 8 part part NN 31417 570 9 of of IN 31417 570 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 570 11 . . . 31417 571 1 What what WP 31417 571 2 more more JJR 31417 571 3 could could MD 31417 571 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 571 5 have have VB 31417 571 6 done do VBN 31417 571 7 ? ? . 31417 572 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 572 2 Myers Myers NNP 31417 572 3 ' ' POS 31417 572 4 remark remark NN 31417 572 5 in in IN 31417 572 6 " " `` 31417 572 7 Human Human NNP 31417 572 8 Personality"--"The Personality"--"The NNP 31417 572 9 most most RBS 31417 572 10 serious serious JJ 31417 572 11 blot blot NN 31417 572 12 on on IN 31417 572 13 Home Home NNP 31417 572 14 's 's POS 31417 572 15 character character NN 31417 572 16 was be VBD 31417 572 17 that that DT 31417 572 18 revealed reveal VBN 31417 572 19 by by IN 31417 572 20 the the DT 31417 572 21 Lyon Lyon NNP 31417 572 22 case"[38]--seems case"[38]--seems NNPS 31417 572 23 , , , 31417 572 24 therefore therefore RB 31417 572 25 , , , 31417 572 26 rather rather RB 31417 572 27 severe severe JJ 31417 572 28 under under IN 31417 572 29 the the DT 31417 572 30 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 572 31 . . . 31417 573 1 Especially especially RB 31417 573 2 as as IN 31417 573 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 573 4 Myers Myers NNP 31417 573 5 has have VBZ 31417 573 6 expressed express VBN 31417 573 7 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 573 8 so so RB 31417 573 9 strongly strongly RB 31417 573 10 in in IN 31417 573 11 favour favour NN 31417 573 12 of of IN 31417 573 13 the the DT 31417 573 14 reality reality NN 31417 573 15 of of IN 31417 573 16 the the DT 31417 573 17 Home home NN 31417 573 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 573 19 , , , 31417 573 20 and and CC 31417 573 21 has have VBZ 31417 573 22 said say VBN 31417 573 23 , , , 31417 573 24 in in IN 31417 573 25 conjunction conjunction NN 31417 573 26 with with IN 31417 573 27 Professor Professor NNP 31417 573 28 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 573 29 , , , 31417 573 30 that that IN 31417 573 31 they -PRON- PRP 31417 573 32 found find VBD 31417 573 33 no no DT 31417 573 34 allegations allegation NNS 31417 573 35 of of IN 31417 573 36 fraud fraud NN 31417 573 37 on on IN 31417 573 38 which which WDT 31417 573 39 they -PRON- PRP 31417 573 40 were be VBD 31417 573 41 justified justify VBN 31417 573 42 in in IN 31417 573 43 laying lay VBG 31417 573 44 much much JJ 31417 573 45 stress stress NN 31417 573 46 . . . 31417 574 1 Much much RB 31417 574 2 more more JJR 31417 574 3 to to IN 31417 574 4 the the DT 31417 574 5 purpose purpose NN 31417 574 6 is be VBZ 31417 574 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 574 8 H. H. NNP 31417 574 9 Arthur Arthur NNP 31417 574 10 Smith Smith NNP 31417 574 11 's 's POS 31417 574 12 comment comment NN 31417 574 13 : : : 31417 574 14 " " `` 31417 574 15 Whether whether IN 31417 574 16 this this DT 31417 574 17 is be VBZ 31417 574 18 to to IN 31417 574 19 Home Home NNP 31417 574 20 's 's POS 31417 574 21 discredit discredit NN 31417 574 22 or or CC 31417 574 23 not not RB 31417 574 24 of of IN 31417 574 25 course course NN 31417 574 26 will will MD 31417 574 27 be be VB 31417 574 28 decided decide VBN 31417 574 29 according accord VBG 31417 574 30 to to IN 31417 574 31 one one PRP 31417 574 32 's 's POS 31417 574 33 belief belief NN 31417 574 34 in in IN 31417 574 35 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 574 36 and and CC 31417 574 37 the the DT 31417 574 38 reality reality NN 31417 574 39 of of IN 31417 574 40 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 574 41 husband husband NN 31417 574 42 's 's POS 31417 574 43 interference interference NN 31417 574 44 . . . 31417 574 45 " " '' 31417 575 1 Had have VBD 31417 575 2 this this DT 31417 575 3 Report Report NNP 31417 575 4 of of IN 31417 575 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 575 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 575 7 's 's POS 31417 575 8 and and CC 31417 575 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 575 10 Myers Myers NNP 31417 575 11 ' ' POS 31417 575 12 , , , 31417 575 13 with with IN 31417 575 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 575 15 Appendices appendix NNS 31417 575 16 , , , 31417 575 17 been be VBN 31417 575 18 placed place VBN 31417 575 19 before before IN 31417 575 20 the the DT 31417 575 21 public public NN 31417 575 22 , , , 31417 575 23 it -PRON- PRP 31417 575 24 might may MD 31417 575 25 have have VB 31417 575 26 mitigated mitigate VBN 31417 575 27 the the DT 31417 575 28 prejudice prejudice NN 31417 575 29 which which WDT 31417 575 30 hangs hang VBZ 31417 575 31 about about IN 31417 575 32 the the DT 31417 575 33 name name NN 31417 575 34 of of IN 31417 575 35 D. D. NNP 31417 575 36 D. D. NNP 31417 575 37 Home Home NNP 31417 575 38 in in IN 31417 575 39 the the DT 31417 575 40 minds mind NNS 31417 575 41 of of IN 31417 575 42 so so RB 31417 575 43 many many JJ 31417 575 44 . . . 31417 576 1 The the DT 31417 576 2 unique unique JJ 31417 576 3 position position NN 31417 576 4 which which WDT 31417 576 5 Home home NN 31417 576 6 occupies occupie NNS 31417 576 7 in in IN 31417 576 8 regard regard NN 31417 576 9 to to IN 31417 576 10 the the DT 31417 576 11 Physical Physical NNP 31417 576 12 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 576 13 of of IN 31417 576 14 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 576 15 seems seem VBZ 31417 576 16 a a DT 31417 576 17 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 576 18 reason reason NN 31417 576 19 for for IN 31417 576 20 dwelling dwell VBG 31417 576 21 somewhat somewhat RB 31417 576 22 fully fully RB 31417 576 23 on on IN 31417 576 24 this this DT 31417 576 25 episode episode NN 31417 576 26 as as IN 31417 576 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 576 28 affects affect VBZ 31417 576 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 576 30 character character NN 31417 576 31 as as IN 31417 576 32 a a DT 31417 576 33 man man NN 31417 576 34 . . . 31417 577 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 577 2 : : : 31417 577 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 577 4 22 22 CD 31417 577 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 577 6 Report Report NNP 31417 577 7 of of IN 31417 577 8 the the DT 31417 577 9 Committee Committee NNP 31417 577 10 of of IN 31417 577 11 the the DT 31417 577 12 London London NNP 31417 577 13 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 577 14 Society Society NNP 31417 577 15 , , , 31417 577 16 pp pp NNP 31417 577 17 . . . 31417 578 1 360 360 CD 31417 578 2 - - SYM 31417 578 3 363 363 CD 31417 578 4 . . . 31417 579 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 579 2 23 23 CD 31417 579 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 579 4 Vol Vol NNP 31417 579 5 . . . 31417 580 1 iv iv XX 31417 580 2 . . . 31417 581 1 pp pp NNP 31417 581 2 . . . 31417 582 1 101 101 CD 31417 582 2 - - SYM 31417 582 3 136 136 CD 31417 582 4 . . . 31417 583 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 583 2 24 24 CD 31417 583 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 583 4 _ _ NNP 31417 583 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 583 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 583 7 _ _ NNP 31417 583 8 , , , 31417 583 9 vol vol NNP 31417 583 10 . . . 31417 584 1 iv iv XX 31417 584 2 . . . 31417 585 1 pp pp NNP 31417 585 2 . . . 31417 586 1 249 249 CD 31417 586 2 - - SYM 31417 586 3 252 252 CD 31417 586 4 . . . 31417 587 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 587 2 25 25 CD 31417 587 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 587 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 587 5 . . . 31417 587 6 , , , 31417 587 7 p. p. NN 31417 587 8 115 115 CD 31417 587 9 . . . 31417 588 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 588 2 26 26 CD 31417 588 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 588 4 " " `` 31417 588 5 Human Human NNP 31417 588 6 Personality personality NN 31417 588 7 , , , 31417 588 8 " " '' 31417 588 9 vol vol NNP 31417 588 10 . . . 31417 589 1 ii ii LS 31417 589 2 . . . 31417 590 1 p. p. NN 31417 590 2 579 579 CD 31417 590 3 . . . 31417 591 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 591 2 27 27 CD 31417 591 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 591 4 _ _ NNP 31417 591 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 591 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 591 7 _ _ NNP 31417 591 8 , , , 31417 591 9 vol vol NNP 31417 591 10 . . . 31417 592 1 iv iv XX 31417 592 2 . . . 31417 593 1 p. p. NN 31417 593 2 102 102 CD 31417 593 3 . . . 31417 594 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 594 2 28 28 CD 31417 594 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 594 4 " " `` 31417 594 5 Human Human NNP 31417 594 6 Personality personality NN 31417 594 7 , , , 31417 594 8 " " '' 31417 594 9 vol vol NNP 31417 594 10 . . . 31417 595 1 ii ii LS 31417 595 2 . . . 31417 596 1 pp pp NNP 31417 596 2 . . . 31417 597 1 580 580 CD 31417 597 2 - - SYM 31417 597 3 581 581 CD 31417 597 4 . . . 31417 598 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 598 2 29 29 CD 31417 598 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 598 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 598 5 . . . 31417 598 6 , , , 31417 598 7 p. p. NN 31417 598 8 581 581 CD 31417 598 9 . . . 31417 599 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 599 2 30 30 CD 31417 599 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 599 4 _ _ NNP 31417 599 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 599 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 599 7 _ _ NNP 31417 599 8 , , , 31417 599 9 vol vol NNP 31417 599 10 . . . 31417 600 1 iv iv XX 31417 600 2 . . . 31417 601 1 p. p. NN 31417 601 2 107 107 CD 31417 601 3 . . . 31417 602 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 602 2 31 31 CD 31417 602 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 602 4 _ _ NNP 31417 602 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 602 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 602 7 _ _ NNP 31417 602 8 , , , 31417 602 9 vol vol NNP 31417 602 10 . . . 31417 603 1 iv iv XX 31417 603 2 . . . 31417 604 1 p. p. NN 31417 604 2 114 114 CD 31417 604 3 . . . 31417 605 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 605 2 32 32 CD 31417 605 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 605 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 605 5 . . . 31417 605 6 , , , 31417 605 7 p. p. NN 31417 605 8 115 115 CD 31417 605 9 . . . 31417 606 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 606 2 33 33 CD 31417 606 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 606 4 _ _ NNP 31417 606 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 606 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 606 7 _ _ NNP 31417 606 8 , , , 31417 606 9 vol vol NNP 31417 606 10 . . . 31417 607 1 iv iv XX 31417 607 2 . . . 31417 608 1 p. p. NN 31417 608 2 122 122 CD 31417 608 3 . . . 31417 609 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 609 2 34 34 CD 31417 609 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 609 4 _ _ NNP 31417 609 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 609 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 609 7 _ _ NNP 31417 609 8 , , , 31417 609 9 vol vol NNP 31417 609 10 . . . 31417 610 1 iv iv XX 31417 610 2 . . . 31417 611 1 pp pp NNP 31417 611 2 . . . 31417 612 1 135 135 CD 31417 612 2 - - SYM 31417 612 3 136 136 CD 31417 612 4 . . . 31417 613 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 613 2 35 35 CD 31417 613 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 613 4 _ _ NNP 31417 613 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 613 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 613 7 _ _ NNP 31417 613 8 , , , 31417 613 9 vol vol NNP 31417 613 10 . . . 31417 614 1 iv iv XX 31417 614 2 . . . 31417 615 1 p. p. NN 31417 615 2 108 108 CD 31417 615 3 . . . 31417 616 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 616 2 36 36 CD 31417 616 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 616 4 Report Report NNP 31417 616 5 of of IN 31417 616 6 the the DT 31417 616 7 Committee Committee NNP 31417 616 8 of of IN 31417 616 9 the the DT 31417 616 10 Dialectical Dialectical NNP 31417 616 11 Society Society NNP 31417 616 12 , , , 31417 616 13 p. p. NN 31417 616 14 214 214 CD 31417 616 15 . . . 31417 617 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 617 2 37 37 CD 31417 617 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 617 4 _ _ NNP 31417 617 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 617 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 617 7 _ _ NNP 31417 617 8 , , , 31417 617 9 vol vol NNP 31417 617 10 . . . 31417 618 1 iv iv XX 31417 618 2 . . . 31417 619 1 pp pp NNP 31417 619 2 . . . 31417 620 1 117 117 CD 31417 620 2 - - SYM 31417 620 3 119 119 CD 31417 620 4 . . . 31417 621 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 621 2 38 38 CD 31417 621 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 621 4 " " `` 31417 621 5 Human Human NNP 31417 621 6 Personality personality NN 31417 621 7 , , , 31417 621 8 " " '' 31417 621 9 vol vol NNP 31417 621 10 . . . 31417 622 1 ii ii LS 31417 622 2 . . . 31417 623 1 p. p. NN 31417 623 2 580 580 CD 31417 623 3 . . . 31417 624 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 624 2 VI VI NNP 31417 624 3 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNP 31417 624 4 PHENOMENA PHENOMENA NNP 31417 624 5 ALLEGED allege VBN 31417 624 6 TO to IN 31417 624 7 HAVE have VB 31417 624 8 OCCURRED occur VBN 31417 624 9 IN in IN 31417 624 10 THE the DT 31417 624 11 PRESENCE presence NN 31417 624 12 OF of IN 31417 624 13 WILLIAM WILLIAM NNS 31417 624 14 STAINTON STAINTON VBD 31417 624 15 MOSES MOSES NNP 31417 624 16 It -PRON- PRP 31417 624 17 is be VBZ 31417 624 18 mainly mainly RB 31417 624 19 due due JJ 31417 624 20 to to IN 31417 624 21 the the DT 31417 624 22 labours labour NNS 31417 624 23 of of IN 31417 624 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 624 25 F. F. NNP 31417 624 26 W. W. NNP 31417 624 27 H. H. NNP 31417 624 28 Myers Myers NNP 31417 624 29 , , , 31417 624 30 after after IN 31417 624 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 624 32 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 624 33 Moses Moses NNP 31417 624 34 ' ' POS 31417 624 35 death death NN 31417 624 36 , , , 31417 624 37 that that IN 31417 624 38 the the DT 31417 624 39 Physical Physical NNP 31417 624 40 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 624 41 alleged allege VBD 31417 624 42 to to TO 31417 624 43 have have VB 31417 624 44 occurred occur VBN 31417 624 45 in in IN 31417 624 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 624 47 presence presence NN 31417 624 48 can can MD 31417 624 49 be be VB 31417 624 50 included include VBN 31417 624 51 among among IN 31417 624 52 those those DT 31417 624 53 for for IN 31417 624 54 which which WDT 31417 624 55 evidence evidence NN 31417 624 56 of of IN 31417 624 57 a a DT 31417 624 58 scientific scientific JJ 31417 624 59 character character NN 31417 624 60 is be VBZ 31417 624 61 claimed claim VBN 31417 624 62 . . . 31417 625 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 625 2 is be VBZ 31417 625 3 much much JJ 31417 625 4 to to TO 31417 625 5 be be VB 31417 625 6 regretted regret VBN 31417 625 7 that that IN 31417 625 8 , , , 31417 625 9 during during IN 31417 625 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 625 11 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 625 12 Moses Moses NNP 31417 625 13 ' ' POS 31417 625 14 lifetime lifetime NN 31417 625 15 , , , 31417 625 16 although although IN 31417 625 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 625 18 of of IN 31417 625 19 a a DT 31417 625 20 very very RB 31417 625 21 varied varied JJ 31417 625 22 character character NN 31417 625 23 were be VBD 31417 625 24 alleged allege VBN 31417 625 25 to to TO 31417 625 26 have have VB 31417 625 27 occurred occur VBN 31417 625 28 with with IN 31417 625 29 great great JJ 31417 625 30 frequency frequency NN 31417 625 31 during during IN 31417 625 32 many many JJ 31417 625 33 years year NNS 31417 625 34 , , , 31417 625 35 no no DT 31417 625 36 scientific scientific JJ 31417 625 37 man man NN 31417 625 38 of of IN 31417 625 39 eminence eminence NN 31417 625 40 appears appear VBZ 31417 625 41 to to TO 31417 625 42 have have VB 31417 625 43 joined join VBN 31417 625 44 in in IN 31417 625 45 the the DT 31417 625 46 seances seance NNS 31417 625 47 , , , 31417 625 48 except except IN 31417 625 49 on on IN 31417 625 50 one one CD 31417 625 51 or or CC 31417 625 52 two two CD 31417 625 53 occasions occasion NNS 31417 625 54 . . . 31417 626 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 31417 626 2 the the DT 31417 626 3 primary primary JJ 31417 626 4 reason reason NN 31417 626 5 for for IN 31417 626 6 this this DT 31417 626 7 was be VBD 31417 626 8 that that IN 31417 626 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 626 10 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 626 11 Moses Moses NNP 31417 626 12 ' ' POS 31417 626 13 own own JJ 31417 626 14 attitude attitude NN 31417 626 15 of of IN 31417 626 16 mind mind NN 31417 626 17 towards towards IN 31417 626 18 the the DT 31417 626 19 subject subject NN 31417 626 20 did do VBD 31417 626 21 not not RB 31417 626 22 court court NN 31417 626 23 critical critical JJ 31417 626 24 and and CC 31417 626 25 scientific scientific JJ 31417 626 26 investigation investigation NN 31417 626 27 of of IN 31417 626 28 the the DT 31417 626 29 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 626 30 . . . 31417 627 1 But but CC 31417 627 2 even even RB 31417 627 3 during during IN 31417 627 4 the the DT 31417 627 5 last last JJ 31417 627 6 ten ten CD 31417 627 7 years year NNS 31417 627 8 of of IN 31417 627 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 627 10 life life NN 31417 627 11 , , , 31417 627 12 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 627 13 to to IN 31417 627 14 the the DT 31417 627 15 formation formation NN 31417 627 16 of of IN 31417 627 17 the the DT 31417 627 18 Society Society NNP 31417 627 19 for for IN 31417 627 20 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 627 21 Research Research NNP 31417 627 22 , , , 31417 627 23 of of IN 31417 627 24 which which WDT 31417 627 25 he -PRON- PRP 31417 627 26 was be VBD 31417 627 27 an an DT 31417 627 28 original original JJ 31417 627 29 member member NN 31417 627 30 , , , 31417 627 31 and and CC 31417 627 32 not not RB 31417 627 33 only only RB 31417 627 34 that that DT 31417 627 35 , , , 31417 627 36 but but CC 31417 627 37 for for IN 31417 627 38 nearly nearly RB 31417 627 39 five five CD 31417 627 40 years year NNS 31417 627 41 a a DT 31417 627 42 Vice Vice NNP 31417 627 43 - - HYPH 31417 627 44 President President NNP 31417 627 45 and and CC 31417 627 46 a a DT 31417 627 47 member member NN 31417 627 48 of of IN 31417 627 49 the the DT 31417 627 50 Council Council NNP 31417 627 51 , , , 31417 627 52 so so RB 31417 627 53 far far RB 31417 627 54 as as IN 31417 627 55 I -PRON- PRP 31417 627 56 know know VBP 31417 627 57 , , , 31417 627 58 no no DT 31417 627 59 sittings sitting NNS 31417 627 60 were be VBD 31417 627 61 held hold VBN 31417 627 62 with with IN 31417 627 63 him -PRON- PRP 31417 627 64 on on IN 31417 627 65 behalf behalf NN 31417 627 66 of of IN 31417 627 67 the the DT 31417 627 68 Society Society NNP 31417 627 69 , , , 31417 627 70 and and CC 31417 627 71 no no DT 31417 627 72 first first JJ 31417 627 73 - - HYPH 31417 627 74 hand hand NN 31417 627 75 authentic authentic JJ 31417 627 76 records record NNS 31417 627 77 of of IN 31417 627 78 the the DT 31417 627 79 alleged allege VBN 31417 627 80 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 627 81 in in IN 31417 627 82 earlier early JJR 31417 627 83 years year NNS 31417 627 84 were be VBD 31417 627 85 placed place VBN 31417 627 86 before before IN 31417 627 87 it -PRON- PRP 31417 627 88 . . . 31417 628 1 One one CD 31417 628 2 reason reason NN 31417 628 3 for for IN 31417 628 4 this this DT 31417 628 5 probably probably RB 31417 628 6 was be VBD 31417 628 7 that that IN 31417 628 8 the the DT 31417 628 9 Council Council NNP 31417 628 10 of of IN 31417 628 11 the the DT 31417 628 12 Society Society NNP 31417 628 13 informally informally RB 31417 628 14 adopted adopt VBD 31417 628 15 a a DT 31417 628 16 sort sort NN 31417 628 17 of of IN 31417 628 18 understanding understanding NN 31417 628 19 that that IN 31417 628 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 628 21 earlier early JJR 31417 628 22 investigations investigation NNS 31417 628 23 should should MD 31417 628 24 not not RB 31417 628 25 be be VB 31417 628 26 directed direct VBN 31417 628 27 towards towards IN 31417 628 28 " " `` 31417 628 29 Spiritualism spiritualism NN 31417 628 30 , , , 31417 628 31 " " '' 31417 628 32 but but CC 31417 628 33 mainly mainly RB 31417 628 34 towards towards IN 31417 628 35 those those DT 31417 628 36 branches branch NNS 31417 628 37 of of IN 31417 628 38 the the DT 31417 628 39 great great JJ 31417 628 40 subject subject NN 31417 628 41 which which WDT 31417 628 42 were be VBD 31417 628 43 , , , 31417 628 44 so so RB 31417 628 45 to to TO 31417 628 46 speak speak VB 31417 628 47 , , , 31417 628 48 just just RB 31417 628 49 outside outside IN 31417 628 50 the the DT 31417 628 51 field field NN 31417 628 52 of of IN 31417 628 53 recognised recognise VBN 31417 628 54 scientific scientific JJ 31417 628 55 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 628 56 -- -- : 31417 628 57 such such JJ 31417 628 58 , , , 31417 628 59 for for IN 31417 628 60 instance instance NN 31417 628 61 , , , 31417 628 62 as as IN 31417 628 63 Thought Thought NNP 31417 628 64 - - HYPH 31417 628 65 Transference Transference NNP 31417 628 66 and and CC 31417 628 67 Hypnotism Hypnotism NNP 31417 628 68 . . . 31417 629 1 In in IN 31417 629 2 this this DT 31417 629 3 course course NN 31417 629 4 there there EX 31417 629 5 was be VBD 31417 629 6 doubtless doubtless RB 31417 629 7 a a DT 31417 629 8 certain certain JJ 31417 629 9 amount amount NN 31417 629 10 of of IN 31417 629 11 wisdom wisdom NN 31417 629 12 , , , 31417 629 13 but but CC 31417 629 14 to to IN 31417 629 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 629 16 was be VBD 31417 629 17 due due JJ 31417 629 18 the the DT 31417 629 19 apathy apathy NN 31417 629 20 and and CC 31417 629 21 the the DT 31417 629 22 ultimate ultimate JJ 31417 629 23 secession secession NN 31417 629 24 of of IN 31417 629 25 a a DT 31417 629 26 few few JJ 31417 629 27 members member NNS 31417 629 28 who who WP 31417 629 29 took take VBD 31417 629 30 great great JJ 31417 629 31 interest interest NN 31417 629 32 in in IN 31417 629 33 the the DT 31417 629 34 formation formation NN 31417 629 35 of of IN 31417 629 36 the the DT 31417 629 37 Society Society NNP 31417 629 38 . . . 31417 630 1 Chief chief NN 31417 630 2 among among IN 31417 630 3 these these DT 31417 630 4 was be VBD 31417 630 5 W. W. NNP 31417 630 6 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 630 7 Moses Moses NNP 31417 630 8 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 630 9 . . . 31417 631 1 In in IN 31417 631 2 November November NNP 31417 631 3 1886 1886 CD 31417 631 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 631 5 withdrew withdraw VBD 31417 631 6 from from IN 31417 631 7 the the DT 31417 631 8 Society Society NNP 31417 631 9 , , , 31417 631 10 considering consider VBG 31417 631 11 that that IN 31417 631 12 the the DT 31417 631 13 evidence evidence NN 31417 631 14 of of IN 31417 631 15 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 631 16 of of IN 31417 631 17 the the DT 31417 631 18 genuine genuine JJ 31417 631 19 character character NN 31417 631 20 of of IN 31417 631 21 which which WDT 31417 631 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 631 23 had have VBD 31417 631 24 satisfied satisfy VBN 31417 631 25 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 631 26 beyond beyond IN 31417 631 27 doubt doubt NN 31417 631 28 , , , 31417 631 29 was be VBD 31417 631 30 not not RB 31417 631 31 being be VBG 31417 631 32 properly properly RB 31417 631 33 entertained entertain VBN 31417 631 34 or or CC 31417 631 35 fairly fairly RB 31417 631 36 treated treat VBN 31417 631 37 . . . 31417 632 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 632 2 W. W. NNP 31417 632 3 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 632 4 Moses Moses NNP 31417 632 5 entrusted entrust VBD 31417 632 6 by by IN 31417 632 7 will will MD 31417 632 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 632 9 unpublished unpublished JJ 31417 632 10 MSS MSS NNP 31417 632 11 . . . 31417 633 1 to to IN 31417 633 2 two two CD 31417 633 3 friends friend NNS 31417 633 4 as as IN 31417 633 5 literary literary JJ 31417 633 6 executors executor NNS 31417 633 7 , , , 31417 633 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 633 9 Charles Charles NNP 31417 633 10 C. C. NNP 31417 633 11 Massey Massey NNP 31417 633 12 and and CC 31417 633 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 633 14 Alaric Alaric NNP 31417 633 15 A. A. NNP 31417 633 16 Watts Watts NNP 31417 633 17 . . . 31417 634 1 At at IN 31417 634 2 the the DT 31417 634 3 earnest earnest JJ 31417 634 4 request request NN 31417 634 5 of of IN 31417 634 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 634 7 Myers Myers NNP 31417 634 8 , , , 31417 634 9 these these DT 31417 634 10 gentlemen gentleman NNS 31417 634 11 permitted permit VBD 31417 634 12 him -PRON- PRP 31417 634 13 to to TO 31417 634 14 see see VB 31417 634 15 a a DT 31417 634 16 large large JJ 31417 634 17 number number NN 31417 634 18 of of IN 31417 634 19 them -PRON- PRP 31417 634 20 . . . 31417 635 1 Thirty thirty CD 31417 635 2 - - HYPH 31417 635 3 one one CD 31417 635 4 note note NN 31417 635 5 - - HYPH 31417 635 6 books book NNS 31417 635 7 were be VBD 31417 635 8 placed place VBN 31417 635 9 in in IN 31417 635 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 635 11 hands hand NNS 31417 635 12 . . . 31417 636 1 Permission permission NN 31417 636 2 was be VBD 31417 636 3 further further RB 31417 636 4 given give VBN 31417 636 5 to to IN 31417 636 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 636 7 Myers Myers NNP 31417 636 8 to to TO 31417 636 9 make make VB 31417 636 10 selections selection NNS 31417 636 11 from from IN 31417 636 12 these these DT 31417 636 13 note note NN 31417 636 14 - - HYPH 31417 636 15 books book NNS 31417 636 16 for for IN 31417 636 17 publication publication NN 31417 636 18 in in IN 31417 636 19 the the DT 31417 636 20 _ _ NNP 31417 636 21 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 636 22 _ _ NNP 31417 636 23 of of IN 31417 636 24 the the DT 31417 636 25 Society Society NNP 31417 636 26 . . . 31417 637 1 These these DT 31417 637 2 selections selection NNS 31417 637 3 form form VBP 31417 637 4 the the DT 31417 637 5 substance substance NN 31417 637 6 of of IN 31417 637 7 two two CD 31417 637 8 long long JJ 31417 637 9 articles article NNS 31417 637 10 . . . 31417 638 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 638 2 39 39 CD 31417 638 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 638 4 The the DT 31417 638 5 thirty thirty CD 31417 638 6 - - HYPH 31417 638 7 one one CD 31417 638 8 books book NNS 31417 638 9 comprise comprise VBP 31417 638 10 twenty twenty CD 31417 638 11 - - HYPH 31417 638 12 four four CD 31417 638 13 of of IN 31417 638 14 Automatic Automatic NNP 31417 638 15 Writing Writing NNP 31417 638 16 , , , 31417 638 17 four four CD 31417 638 18 Records Records NNPS 31417 638 19 of of IN 31417 638 20 Physical Physical NNP 31417 638 21 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 638 22 , , , 31417 638 23 and and CC 31417 638 24 three three CD 31417 638 25 of of IN 31417 638 26 retrospect retrospect NN 31417 638 27 and and CC 31417 638 28 summary summary NN 31417 638 29 . . . 31417 639 1 Two two CD 31417 639 2 of of IN 31417 639 3 these these DT 31417 639 4 recapitulate recapitulate JJ 31417 639 5 physical physical JJ 31417 639 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 639 7 , , , 31417 639 8 with with IN 31417 639 9 reflections reflection NNS 31417 639 10 . . . 31417 640 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 640 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 640 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 640 4 ' ' POS 31417 640 5 most most RBS 31417 640 6 intimate intimate JJ 31417 640 7 friends friend NNS 31417 640 8 were be VBD 31417 640 9 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 640 10 and and CC 31417 640 11 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 640 12 Stanhope Stanhope NNP 31417 640 13 T. T. NNP 31417 640 14 Speer Speer NNP 31417 640 15 . . . 31417 641 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 641 2 , , , 31417 641 3 with with IN 31417 641 4 the the DT 31417 641 5 occasional occasional JJ 31417 641 6 attendance attendance NN 31417 641 7 of of IN 31417 641 8 another another DT 31417 641 9 intimate intimate JJ 31417 641 10 friend friend NN 31417 641 11 , , , 31417 641 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 641 13 F. F. NNP 31417 641 14 W. W. NNP 31417 641 15 Percival Percival NNP 31417 641 16 , , , 31417 641 17 barrister barrister NN 31417 641 18 - - HYPH 31417 641 19 at at IN 31417 641 20 - - HYPH 31417 641 21 law law NN 31417 641 22 , , , 31417 641 23 and and CC 31417 641 24 Examiner Examiner NNP 31417 641 25 in in IN 31417 641 26 the the DT 31417 641 27 Education Education NNP 31417 641 28 Department Department NNP 31417 641 29 , , , 31417 641 30 were be VBD 31417 641 31 generally generally RB 31417 641 32 the the DT 31417 641 33 only only JJ 31417 641 34 members member NNS 31417 641 35 of of IN 31417 641 36 the the DT 31417 641 37 small small JJ 31417 641 38 group group NN 31417 641 39 who who WP 31417 641 40 witnessed witness VBD 31417 641 41 the the DT 31417 641 42 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 641 43 . . . 31417 642 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 642 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 642 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 642 4 ' ' POS 31417 642 5 note note NN 31417 642 6 - - HYPH 31417 642 7 books book NNS 31417 642 8 had have VBD 31417 642 9 been be VBN 31417 642 10 kept keep VBN 31417 642 11 extremely extremely RB 31417 642 12 private private JJ 31417 642 13 . . . 31417 643 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 643 2 seems seem VBZ 31417 643 3 probable probable JJ 31417 643 4 that that IN 31417 643 5 no no DT 31417 643 6 one one NN 31417 643 7 had have VBD 31417 643 8 seen see VBN 31417 643 9 them -PRON- PRP 31417 643 10 until until IN 31417 643 11 they -PRON- PRP 31417 643 12 were be VBD 31417 643 13 placed place VBN 31417 643 14 in in IN 31417 643 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 643 16 Myers Myers NNP 31417 643 17 ' ' POS 31417 643 18 hands hand NNS 31417 643 19 . . . 31417 644 1 Two two CD 31417 644 2 note note NN 31417 644 3 - - HYPH 31417 644 4 books book NNS 31417 644 5 and and CC 31417 644 6 other other JJ 31417 644 7 MSS MSS NNP 31417 644 8 . . . 31417 645 1 by by IN 31417 645 2 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 645 3 Speer Speer NNP 31417 645 4 were be VBD 31417 645 5 also also RB 31417 645 6 handed hand VBN 31417 645 7 to to IN 31417 645 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 645 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 645 10 , , , 31417 645 11 which which WDT 31417 645 12 he -PRON- PRP 31417 645 13 says say VBZ 31417 645 14 contained contain VBD 31417 645 15 independent independent JJ 31417 645 16 contemporary contemporary JJ 31417 645 17 records record NNS 31417 645 18 of of IN 31417 645 19 much much JJ 31417 645 20 evidential evidential JJ 31417 645 21 value value NN 31417 645 22 . . . 31417 646 1 With with IN 31417 646 2 regard regard NN 31417 646 3 to to IN 31417 646 4 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 646 5 and and CC 31417 646 6 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 646 7 Speer Speer NNP 31417 646 8 , , , 31417 646 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 646 10 Myers Myers NNP 31417 646 11 says say VBZ 31417 646 12 : : : 31417 646 13 " " `` 31417 646 14 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 646 15 importance importance NN 31417 646 16 as as IN 31417 646 17 witnesses witness NNS 31417 646 18 of of IN 31417 646 19 the the DT 31417 646 20 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 646 21 is be VBZ 31417 646 22 so so RB 31417 646 23 great great JJ 31417 646 24 , , , 31417 646 25 that that IN 31417 646 26 I -PRON- PRP 31417 646 27 must must MD 31417 646 28 be be VB 31417 646 29 pardoned pardon VBN 31417 646 30 for for IN 31417 646 31 inserting insert VBG 31417 646 32 a a DT 31417 646 33 ' ' `` 31417 646 34 testimonial testimonial NN 31417 646 35 ' ' '' 31417 646 36 to to IN 31417 646 37 the the DT 31417 646 38 late late JJ 31417 646 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 646 40 Speer Speer NNP 31417 646 41 ( ( -LRB- 31417 646 42 M.D. M.D. NNP 31417 646 43 , , , 31417 646 44 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 31417 646 45 ) ) -RRB- 31417 646 46 , , , 31417 646 47 which which WDT 31417 646 48 shall shall MD 31417 646 49 not not RB 31417 646 50 , , , 31417 646 51 however however RB 31417 646 52 , , , 31417 646 53 be be VB 31417 646 54 in in IN 31417 646 55 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 646 56 own own JJ 31417 646 57 words word NNS 31417 646 58 , , , 31417 646 59 but but CC 31417 646 60 in in IN 31417 646 61 those those DT 31417 646 62 of of IN 31417 646 63 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 646 64 Marshall Marshall NNP 31417 646 65 Hall Hall NNP 31417 646 66 , , , 31417 646 67 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 646 68 , , , 31417 646 69 one one CD 31417 646 70 of of IN 31417 646 71 the the DT 31417 646 72 best well RBS 31417 646 73 - - HYPH 31417 646 74 known know VBN 31417 646 75 physicians physician NNS 31417 646 76 of of IN 31417 646 77 the the DT 31417 646 78 middle middle NN 31417 646 79 of of IN 31417 646 80 this this DT 31417 646 81 century century NN 31417 646 82 . . . 31417 647 1 Writing write VBG 31417 647 2 on on IN 31417 647 3 18th 18th JJ 31417 647 4 March March NNP 31417 647 5 1849 1849 CD 31417 647 6 , , , 31417 647 7 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 647 8 Marshall Marshall NNP 31417 647 9 Hall Hall NNP 31417 647 10 says say VBZ 31417 647 11 ( ( -LRB- 31417 647 12 in in IN 31417 647 13 a a DT 31417 647 14 printed print VBN 31417 647 15 collection collection NN 31417 647 16 of of IN 31417 647 17 similar similar JJ 31417 647 18 testimonials testimonial NNS 31417 647 19 now now RB 31417 647 20 before before IN 31417 647 21 me -PRON- PRP 31417 647 22 ) ) -RRB- 31417 647 23 : : : 31417 647 24 ' ' `` 31417 647 25 I -PRON- PRP 31417 647 26 have have VBP 31417 647 27 great great JJ 31417 647 28 satisfaction satisfaction NN 31417 647 29 in in IN 31417 647 30 bearing bear VBG 31417 647 31 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 647 32 testimony testimony NN 31417 647 33 to to IN 31417 647 34 the the DT 31417 647 35 talents talent NNS 31417 647 36 and and CC 31417 647 37 acquirements acquirement NNS 31417 647 38 of of IN 31417 647 39 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 647 40 Stanhope Stanhope NNP 31417 647 41 Templeman Templeman NNP 31417 647 42 Speer Speer NNP 31417 647 43 . . . 31417 648 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 648 2 Speer Speer NNP 31417 648 3 has have VBZ 31417 648 4 had have VBN 31417 648 5 unusual unusual JJ 31417 648 6 advantages advantage NNS 31417 648 7 in in IN 31417 648 8 having have VBG 31417 648 9 been be VBN 31417 648 10 at at IN 31417 648 11 the the DT 31417 648 12 medical medical JJ 31417 648 13 schools school NNS 31417 648 14 , , , 31417 648 15 not not RB 31417 648 16 only only RB 31417 648 17 of of IN 31417 648 18 London London NNP 31417 648 19 and and CC 31417 648 20 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 31417 648 21 , , , 31417 648 22 but but CC 31417 648 23 of of IN 31417 648 24 Paris Paris NNP 31417 648 25 and and CC 31417 648 26 Montpellier Montpellier NNP 31417 648 27 , , , 31417 648 28 and and CC 31417 648 29 he -PRON- PRP 31417 648 30 has have VBZ 31417 648 31 availed avail VBN 31417 648 32 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 648 33 of of IN 31417 648 34 these these DT 31417 648 35 advantages advantage NNS 31417 648 36 with with IN 31417 648 37 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 31417 648 38 diligence diligence NN 31417 648 39 and and CC 31417 648 40 talent talent NN 31417 648 41 . . . 31417 649 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 649 2 ranks rank VBZ 31417 649 3 among among IN 31417 649 4 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 649 5 most most RBS 31417 649 6 distinguished distinguished JJ 31417 649 7 rising rise VBG 31417 649 8 physicians,'"[40 physicians,'"[40 '' 31417 649 9 ] ] -RRB- 31417 649 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 649 11 Speer Speer NNP 31417 649 12 practised practise VBD 31417 649 13 as as IN 31417 649 14 a a DT 31417 649 15 physician physician NN 31417 649 16 at at IN 31417 649 17 Cheltenham Cheltenham NNP 31417 649 18 and and CC 31417 649 19 in in IN 31417 649 20 London London NNP 31417 649 21 , , , 31417 649 22 and and CC 31417 649 23 at at IN 31417 649 24 different different JJ 31417 649 25 times time NNS 31417 649 26 held hold VBD 31417 649 27 various various JJ 31417 649 28 important important JJ 31417 649 29 hospital hospital NN 31417 649 30 posts post NNS 31417 649 31 . . . 31417 650 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 650 2 had have VBD 31417 650 3 scientific scientific JJ 31417 650 4 and and CC 31417 650 5 artistic artistic JJ 31417 650 6 tastes taste NNS 31417 650 7 , , , 31417 650 8 and and CC 31417 650 9 being be VBG 31417 650 10 possessed possess VBN 31417 650 11 of of IN 31417 650 12 private private JJ 31417 650 13 means mean NNS 31417 650 14 , , , 31417 650 15 he -PRON- PRP 31417 650 16 quitted quit VBD 31417 650 17 professional professional JJ 31417 650 18 work work NN 31417 650 19 at at IN 31417 650 20 the the DT 31417 650 21 age age NN 31417 650 22 of of IN 31417 650 23 thirty thirty CD 31417 650 24 - - HYPH 31417 650 25 four four CD 31417 650 26 , , , 31417 650 27 and and CC 31417 650 28 spent spend VBD 31417 650 29 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 650 30 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 650 31 life life NN 31417 650 32 in in IN 31417 650 33 studious studious JJ 31417 650 34 retirement retirement NN 31417 650 35 . . . 31417 651 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 651 2 Myers Myers NNP 31417 651 3 says say VBZ 31417 651 4 that that IN 31417 651 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 651 6 " " `` 31417 651 7 cast cast NN 31417 651 8 of of IN 31417 651 9 mind mind NN 31417 651 10 was be VBD 31417 651 11 strongly strongly RB 31417 651 12 materialistic materialistic JJ 31417 651 13 , , , 31417 651 14 and and CC 31417 651 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 651 16 is be VBZ 31417 651 17 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 651 18 that that IN 31417 651 19 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 651 20 interest interest NN 31417 651 21 in in IN 31417 651 22 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 651 23 Moses Moses NNP 31417 651 24 ' ' POS 31417 651 25 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 651 26 was be VBD 31417 651 27 from from IN 31417 651 28 first first RB 31417 651 29 to to IN 31417 651 30 last last JJ 31417 651 31 of of IN 31417 651 32 a a DT 31417 651 33 purely purely RB 31417 651 34 scientific scientific JJ 31417 651 35 , , , 31417 651 36 as as IN 31417 651 37 contrasted contrast VBN 31417 651 38 with with IN 31417 651 39 an an DT 31417 651 40 emotional emotional JJ 31417 651 41 or or CC 31417 651 42 religious religious JJ 31417 651 43 nature nature NN 31417 651 44 . . . 31417 652 1 " " `` 31417 652 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 652 3 41 41 CD 31417 652 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 652 5 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 652 6 Stanhope Stanhope NNP 31417 652 7 Speer Speer NNP 31417 652 8 also also RB 31417 652 9 kept keep VBD 31417 652 10 careful careful JJ 31417 652 11 records record NNS 31417 652 12 of of IN 31417 652 13 the the DT 31417 652 14 sittings sitting NNS 31417 652 15 . . . 31417 653 1 Over over IN 31417 653 2 sixty sixty CD 31417 653 3 instalments instalment NNS 31417 653 4 were be VBD 31417 653 5 published publish VBN 31417 653 6 in in IN 31417 653 7 the the DT 31417 653 8 weekly weekly JJ 31417 653 9 journal journal NN 31417 653 10 , , , 31417 653 11 _ _ NNP 31417 653 12 Light Light NNP 31417 653 13 _ _ NNP 31417 653 14 , , , 31417 653 15 under under IN 31417 653 16 the the DT 31417 653 17 title title NN 31417 653 18 of of IN 31417 653 19 " " `` 31417 653 20 Records Records NNPS 31417 653 21 of of IN 31417 653 22 Private Private NNP 31417 653 23 Seances Seances NNPS 31417 653 24 , , , 31417 653 25 from from IN 31417 653 26 Notes note NNS 31417 653 27 taken take VBN 31417 653 28 at at IN 31417 653 29 the the DT 31417 653 30 time time NN 31417 653 31 of of IN 31417 653 32 each each DT 31417 653 33 Sitting Sitting NNP 31417 653 34 . . . 31417 653 35 " " '' 31417 654 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 654 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 654 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 654 4 was be VBD 31417 654 5 born bear VBN 31417 654 6 in in IN 31417 654 7 Lincolnshire Lincolnshire NNP 31417 654 8 in in IN 31417 654 9 1839 1839 CD 31417 654 10 . . . 31417 655 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 655 2 studied study VBD 31417 655 3 at at IN 31417 655 4 Oxford Oxford NNP 31417 655 5 , , , 31417 655 6 and and CC 31417 655 7 was be VBD 31417 655 8 ordained ordain VBN 31417 655 9 as as IN 31417 655 10 a a DT 31417 655 11 clergyman clergyman NN 31417 655 12 of of IN 31417 655 13 the the DT 31417 655 14 Church Church NNP 31417 655 15 of of IN 31417 655 16 England England NNP 31417 655 17 . . . 31417 656 1 After after IN 31417 656 2 a a DT 31417 656 3 few few JJ 31417 656 4 years year NNS 31417 656 5 of of IN 31417 656 6 active active JJ 31417 656 7 life life NN 31417 656 8 as as IN 31417 656 9 a a DT 31417 656 10 parish parish JJ 31417 656 11 clergyman clergyman NN 31417 656 12 , , , 31417 656 13 he -PRON- PRP 31417 656 14 was be VBD 31417 656 15 offered offer VBN 31417 656 16 a a DT 31417 656 17 Mastership Mastership NNP 31417 656 18 in in IN 31417 656 19 University University NNP 31417 656 20 College College NNP 31417 656 21 School School NNP 31417 656 22 , , , 31417 656 23 London London NNP 31417 656 24 , , , 31417 656 25 which which WDT 31417 656 26 post post VBP 31417 656 27 he -PRON- PRP 31417 656 28 held hold VBD 31417 656 29 until until IN 31417 656 30 about about IN 31417 656 31 three three CD 31417 656 32 years year NNS 31417 656 33 before before IN 31417 656 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 656 35 death death NN 31417 656 36 , , , 31417 656 37 which which WDT 31417 656 38 took take VBD 31417 656 39 place place NN 31417 656 40 in in IN 31417 656 41 1892 1892 CD 31417 656 42 . . . 31417 657 1 As as IN 31417 657 2 to to IN 31417 657 3 the the DT 31417 657 4 " " `` 31417 657 5 fundamental fundamental JJ 31417 657 6 questions question NNS 31417 657 7 of of IN 31417 657 8 sanity sanity NN 31417 657 9 and and CC 31417 657 10 probity probity NN 31417 657 11 , , , 31417 657 12 " " '' 31417 657 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 657 14 Myers Myers NNP 31417 657 15 says say VBZ 31417 657 16 : : : 31417 657 17 " " `` 31417 657 18 Neither neither CC 31417 657 19 I -PRON- PRP 31417 657 20 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 657 21 , , , 31417 657 22 nor nor CC 31417 657 23 , , , 31417 657 24 so so RB 31417 657 25 far far RB 31417 657 26 as as IN 31417 657 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 657 28 know know VBP 31417 657 29 , , , 31417 657 30 any any DT 31417 657 31 person person NN 31417 657 32 acquainted acquaint VBN 31417 657 33 with with IN 31417 657 34 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 657 35 Moses Moses NNP 31417 657 36 , , , 31417 657 37 has have VBZ 31417 657 38 ever ever RB 31417 657 39 entertained entertain VBN 31417 657 40 any any DT 31417 657 41 doubt doubt NN 31417 657 42 . . . 31417 658 1 " " `` 31417 658 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 658 3 42 42 CD 31417 658 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 658 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 658 6 Charles Charles NNP 31417 658 7 C. C. NNP 31417 658 8 Massey Massey NNP 31417 658 9 says say VBZ 31417 658 10 : : : 31417 658 11 " " `` 31417 658 12 However however RB 31417 658 13 perplexed perplex VBN 31417 658 14 for for IN 31417 658 15 an an DT 31417 658 16 explanation explanation NN 31417 658 17 , , , 31417 658 18 the the DT 31417 658 19 crassest crass JJS 31417 658 20 prejudice prejudice NN 31417 658 21 has have VBZ 31417 658 22 recoiled recoil VBN 31417 658 23 from from IN 31417 658 24 ever ever RB 31417 658 25 suggesting suggest VBG 31417 658 26 a a DT 31417 658 27 doubt doubt NN 31417 658 28 of of IN 31417 658 29 the the DT 31417 658 30 truth truth NN 31417 658 31 and and CC 31417 658 32 honesty honesty NN 31417 658 33 of of IN 31417 658 34 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 658 35 Moses Moses NNP 31417 658 36 . . . 31417 659 1 " " `` 31417 659 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 659 3 43 43 CD 31417 659 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 659 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 659 6 H. H. NNP 31417 659 7 J. J. NNP 31417 660 1 Hood Hood NNP 31417 660 2 , , , 31417 660 3 barrister barrister NN 31417 660 4 - - HYPH 31417 660 5 at at IN 31417 660 6 - - HYPH 31417 660 7 law law NN 31417 660 8 , , , 31417 660 9 who who WP 31417 660 10 knew know VBD 31417 660 11 him -PRON- PRP 31417 660 12 for for IN 31417 660 13 many many JJ 31417 660 14 years year NNS 31417 660 15 , , , 31417 660 16 writes write VBZ 31417 660 17 : : : 31417 660 18 " " `` 31417 660 19 I -PRON- PRP 31417 660 20 believe believe VBP 31417 660 21 that that IN 31417 660 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 660 23 was be VBD 31417 660 24 wholly wholly RB 31417 660 25 incapable incapable JJ 31417 660 26 of of IN 31417 660 27 deceit deceit NN 31417 660 28 . . . 31417 661 1 " " `` 31417 661 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 661 3 44 44 CD 31417 661 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 661 5 The the DT 31417 661 6 principal principal NN 31417 661 7 published publish VBD 31417 661 8 works work NNS 31417 661 9 of of IN 31417 661 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 661 11 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 661 12 Moses Moses NNP 31417 661 13 are--"Researches are--"Researches NNP 31417 661 14 in in IN 31417 661 15 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 661 16 , , , 31417 661 17 " " '' 31417 661 18 issued issue VBN 31417 661 19 in in IN 31417 661 20 _ _ NNP 31417 661 21 Human Human NNP 31417 661 22 Nature Nature NNP 31417 661 23 _ _ NNP 31417 661 24 , , , 31417 661 25 a a DT 31417 661 26 periodical periodical NN 31417 661 27 now now RB 31417 661 28 extinct extinct JJ 31417 661 29 ; ; : 31417 661 30 " " `` 31417 661 31 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 661 32 Identity Identity NNP 31417 661 33 " " '' 31417 661 34 ( ( -LRB- 31417 661 35 1879 1879 CD 31417 661 36 ) ) -RRB- 31417 661 37 , , , 31417 661 38 recently recently RB 31417 661 39 republished republish VBD 31417 661 40 ; ; : 31417 661 41 " " `` 31417 661 42 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 661 43 Teachings Teachings NNP 31417 661 44 " " '' 31417 661 45 ( ( -LRB- 31417 661 46 1883 1883 CD 31417 661 47 ) ) -RRB- 31417 661 48 , , , 31417 661 49 of of IN 31417 661 50 which which WDT 31417 661 51 a a DT 31417 661 52 new new JJ 31417 661 53 edition edition NN 31417 661 54 has have VBZ 31417 661 55 lately lately RB 31417 661 56 appeared appear VBN 31417 661 57 with with IN 31417 661 58 a a DT 31417 661 59 biography biography NN 31417 661 60 by by IN 31417 661 61 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 661 62 Charles Charles NNP 31417 661 63 Speer Speer NNP 31417 661 64 ( ( -LRB- 31417 661 65 son son NN 31417 661 66 of of IN 31417 661 67 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 661 68 S. S. NNP 31417 661 69 T. T. NNP 31417 661 70 Speer Speer NNP 31417 661 71 ) ) -RRB- 31417 661 72 . . . 31417 662 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 662 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 662 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 662 4 was be VBD 31417 662 5 also also RB 31417 662 6 Editor Editor NNP 31417 662 7 of of IN 31417 662 8 _ _ NNP 31417 662 9 Light Light NNP 31417 662 10 _ _ NNP 31417 662 11 during during IN 31417 662 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 662 13 earlier early JJR 31417 662 14 years year NNS 31417 662 15 . . . 31417 663 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 663 2 has have VBZ 31417 663 3 seemed seem VBN 31417 663 4 important important JJ 31417 663 5 , , , 31417 663 6 in in IN 31417 663 7 view view NN 31417 663 8 of of IN 31417 663 9 what what WP 31417 663 10 is be VBZ 31417 663 11 to to TO 31417 663 12 follow follow VB 31417 663 13 , , , 31417 663 14 that that IN 31417 663 15 the the DT 31417 663 16 reader reader NN 31417 663 17 should should MD 31417 663 18 be be VB 31417 663 19 in in IN 31417 663 20 possession possession NN 31417 663 21 of of IN 31417 663 22 this this DT 31417 663 23 somewhat somewhat RB 31417 663 24 explicit explicit JJ 31417 663 25 account account NN 31417 663 26 of of IN 31417 663 27 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 663 28 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 663 29 Moses Moses NNP 31417 663 30 , , , 31417 663 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 663 32 life life NN 31417 663 33 , , , 31417 663 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 663 35 work work NN 31417 663 36 , , , 31417 663 37 and and CC 31417 663 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 663 39 intimate intimate JJ 31417 663 40 friends friend NNS 31417 663 41 . . . 31417 664 1 Having have VBG 31417 664 2 briefly briefly RB 31417 664 3 treated treat VBN 31417 664 4 of of IN 31417 664 5 these these DT 31417 664 6 external external JJ 31417 664 7 matters matter NNS 31417 664 8 in in IN 31417 664 9 the the DT 31417 664 10 first first JJ 31417 664 11 of of IN 31417 664 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 664 13 two two CD 31417 664 14 articles article NNS 31417 664 15 in in IN 31417 664 16 the the DT 31417 664 17 _ _ NNP 31417 664 18 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 664 19 of of IN 31417 664 20 the the DT 31417 664 21 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 664 22 _ _ NNP 31417 664 23 , , , 31417 664 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 664 25 Myers Myers NNP 31417 664 26 goes go VBZ 31417 664 27 on on RP 31417 664 28 to to IN 31417 664 29 say:-- say:-- NNP 31417 664 30 " " '' 31417 664 31 But but CC 31417 664 32 now now RB 31417 664 33 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 664 34 narrative narrative NN 31417 664 35 must must MD 31417 664 36 pass pass VB 31417 664 37 at at IN 31417 664 38 a a DT 31417 664 39 bound bound NN 31417 664 40 from from IN 31417 664 41 the the DT 31417 664 42 commonplace commonplace NN 31417 664 43 and and CC 31417 664 44 the the DT 31417 664 45 credible credible JJ 31417 664 46 to to IN 31417 664 47 bewildering bewildering JJ 31417 664 48 and and CC 31417 664 49 inconceivable inconceivable JJ 31417 664 50 things thing NNS 31417 664 51 . . . 31417 665 1 With with IN 31417 665 2 the the DT 31417 665 3 even even JJ 31417 665 4 tenour tenour NN 31417 665 5 of of IN 31417 665 6 this this DT 31417 665 7 straightforward straightforward JJ 31417 665 8 and and CC 31417 665 9 reputable reputable JJ 31417 665 10 life life NN 31417 665 11 was be VBD 31417 665 12 inwoven inwoven RB 31417 665 13 a a DT 31417 665 14 chain chain NN 31417 665 15 of of IN 31417 665 16 mysteries mystery NNS 31417 665 17 which which WDT 31417 665 18 , , , 31417 665 19 as as IN 31417 665 20 I -PRON- PRP 31417 665 21 have have VBP 31417 665 22 before before RB 31417 665 23 said say VBN 31417 665 24 , , , 31417 665 25 in in IN 31417 665 26 whatever whatever WDT 31417 665 27 way way NN 31417 665 28 soever soever NN 31417 665 29 they -PRON- PRP 31417 665 30 be be VBP 31417 665 31 explained explain VBN 31417 665 32 , , , 31417 665 33 make make VB 31417 665 34 that that DT 31417 665 35 life life NN 31417 665 36 one one CD 31417 665 37 of of IN 31417 665 38 the the DT 31417 665 39 most most RBS 31417 665 40 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 31417 665 41 which which WDT 31417 665 42 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 665 43 century century NN 31417 665 44 has have VBZ 31417 665 45 seen see VBN 31417 665 46 . . . 31417 666 1 For for IN 31417 666 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 666 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 666 4 ' ' POS 31417 666 5 true true JJ 31417 666 6 history history NN 31417 666 7 lies lie NNS 31417 666 8 , , , 31417 666 9 not not RB 31417 666 10 in in IN 31417 666 11 the the DT 31417 666 12 everyday everyday JJ 31417 666 13 events event NNS 31417 666 14 thus thus RB 31417 666 15 far far RB 31417 666 16 recorded record VBN 31417 666 17 , , , 31417 666 18 but but CC 31417 666 19 in in IN 31417 666 20 that that DT 31417 666 21 series series NN 31417 666 22 of of IN 31417 666 23 physical physical JJ 31417 666 24 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 666 25 which which WDT 31417 666 26 began begin VBD 31417 666 27 in in IN 31417 666 28 1872 1872 CD 31417 666 29 , , , 31417 666 30 and and CC 31417 666 31 lasted last VBD 31417 666 32 for for IN 31417 666 33 some some DT 31417 666 34 eight eight CD 31417 666 35 years year NNS 31417 666 36 , , , 31417 666 37 and and CC 31417 666 38 that that IN 31417 666 39 series series NN 31417 666 40 of of IN 31417 666 41 automatic automatic JJ 31417 666 42 writings writing NNS 31417 666 43 and and CC 31417 666 44 trance trance NN 31417 666 45 - - HYPH 31417 666 46 utterances utterance NNS 31417 666 47 which which WDT 31417 666 48 began begin VBD 31417 666 49 in in IN 31417 666 50 1873 1873 CD 31417 666 51 , , , 31417 666 52 received receive VBD 31417 666 53 a a DT 31417 666 54 record record NN 31417 666 55 for for IN 31417 666 56 some some DT 31417 666 57 ten ten CD 31417 666 58 years year NNS 31417 666 59 , , , 31417 666 60 and and CC 31417 666 61 did do VBD 31417 666 62 not not RB 31417 666 63 , , , 31417 666 64 as as IN 31417 666 65 is be VBZ 31417 666 66 believed believe VBN 31417 666 67 , , , 31417 666 68 cease cease VB 31417 666 69 altogether altogether RB 31417 666 70 until until IN 31417 666 71 the the DT 31417 666 72 earthly earthly JJ 31417 666 73 end end NN 31417 666 74 was be VBD 31417 666 75 near near RB 31417 666 76 . . . 31417 667 1 " " `` 31417 667 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 667 3 45 45 CD 31417 667 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 667 5 THE the DT 31417 667 6 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNP 31417 667 7 PHENOMENA PHENOMENA NNP 31417 667 8 . . . 31417 668 1 This this DT 31417 668 2 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 668 3 concerns concern VBZ 31417 668 4 physical physical JJ 31417 668 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 668 6 only only RB 31417 668 7 . . . 31417 669 1 The the DT 31417 669 2 wealth wealth NN 31417 669 3 of of IN 31417 669 4 material material NN 31417 669 5 to to TO 31417 669 6 select select VB 31417 669 7 from from IN 31417 669 8 is be VBZ 31417 669 9 enormous enormous JJ 31417 669 10 . . . 31417 670 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 670 2 is be VBZ 31417 670 3 proposed propose VBN 31417 670 4 to to TO 31417 670 5 give give VB 31417 670 6 one one CD 31417 670 7 or or CC 31417 670 8 two two CD 31417 670 9 examples example NNS 31417 670 10 of of IN 31417 670 11 each each DT 31417 670 12 of of IN 31417 670 13 the the DT 31417 670 14 important important JJ 31417 670 15 classes class NNS 31417 670 16 of of IN 31417 670 17 physical physical JJ 31417 670 18 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 670 19 . . . 31417 671 1 In in IN 31417 671 2 doing do VBG 31417 671 3 so so RB 31417 671 4 such such JJ 31417 671 5 examples example NNS 31417 671 6 only only RB 31417 671 7 will will MD 31417 671 8 be be VB 31417 671 9 quoted quote VBN 31417 671 10 as as IN 31417 671 11 have have VBP 31417 671 12 been be VBN 31417 671 13 selected select VBN 31417 671 14 by by IN 31417 671 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 671 16 Myers Myers NNP 31417 671 17 to to TO 31417 671 18 include include VB 31417 671 19 in in IN 31417 671 20 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 671 21 articles article NNS 31417 671 22 in in IN 31417 671 23 the the DT 31417 671 24 _ _ NNP 31417 671 25 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 671 26 of of IN 31417 671 27 the the DT 31417 671 28 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNS 31417 671 29 _ _ NNP 31417 671 30 The the DT 31417 671 31 reader reader NN 31417 671 32 will will MD 31417 671 33 therefore therefore RB 31417 671 34 know know VB 31417 671 35 that that IN 31417 671 36 the the DT 31417 671 37 following follow VBG 31417 671 38 records record NNS 31417 671 39 have have VBP 31417 671 40 been be VBN 31417 671 41 under under IN 31417 671 42 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 671 43 Myers Myers NNP 31417 671 44 ' ' POS 31417 671 45 scrutiny scrutiny NN 31417 671 46 , , , 31417 671 47 and and CC 31417 671 48 have have VBP 31417 671 49 been be VBN 31417 671 50 considered consider VBN 31417 671 51 by by IN 31417 671 52 him -PRON- PRP 31417 671 53 as as IN 31417 671 54 of of IN 31417 671 55 evidential evidential JJ 31417 671 56 value value NN 31417 671 57 . . . 31417 672 1 This this DT 31417 672 2 will will MD 31417 672 3 also also RB 31417 672 4 simplify simplify VB 31417 672 5 references reference NNS 31417 672 6 , , , 31417 672 7 as as IN 31417 672 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 672 9 will will MD 31417 672 10 be be VB 31417 672 11 needful needful JJ 31417 672 12 to to TO 31417 672 13 refer refer VB 31417 672 14 only only RB 31417 672 15 to to IN 31417 672 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 672 17 Myers Myers NNP 31417 672 18 ' ' POS 31417 672 19 articles article NNS 31417 672 20 which which WDT 31417 672 21 are be VBP 31417 672 22 easily easily RB 31417 672 23 accessible accessible JJ 31417 672 24 , , , 31417 672 25 and and CC 31417 672 26 not not RB 31417 672 27 to to IN 31417 672 28 the the DT 31417 672 29 original original JJ 31417 672 30 sources source NNS 31417 672 31 . . . 31417 673 1 MOVEMENTS movements NN 31417 673 2 WITHOUT without IN 31417 673 3 CONTACT CONTACT NNS 31417 673 4 . . . 31417 674 1 After after IN 31417 674 2 recording record VBG 31417 674 3 some some DT 31417 674 4 movements movement NNS 31417 674 5 of of IN 31417 674 6 a a DT 31417 674 7 table table NN 31417 674 8 , , , 31417 674 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 674 10 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 674 11 Moses Moses NNP 31417 674 12 says say VBZ 31417 674 13 : : : 31417 674 14 " " `` 31417 674 15 All all DT 31417 674 16 that that WDT 31417 674 17 I -PRON- PRP 31417 674 18 have have VBP 31417 674 19 described describe VBN 31417 674 20 occurs occur VBZ 31417 674 21 readily readily RB 31417 674 22 when when WRB 31417 674 23 the the DT 31417 674 24 table table NN 31417 674 25 is be VBZ 31417 674 26 untouched untouched JJ 31417 674 27 . . . 31417 675 1 Indeed indeed RB 31417 675 2 , , , 31417 675 3 when when WRB 31417 675 4 the the DT 31417 675 5 force force NN 31417 675 6 is be VBZ 31417 675 7 developed develop VBN 31417 675 8 , , , 31417 675 9 we -PRON- PRP 31417 675 10 have have VBP 31417 675 11 found find VBN 31417 675 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 675 13 better well JJR 31417 675 14 to to TO 31417 675 15 remove remove VB 31417 675 16 the the DT 31417 675 17 hands hand NNS 31417 675 18 and and CC 31417 675 19 leave leave VB 31417 675 20 the the DT 31417 675 21 table table NN 31417 675 22 to to IN 31417 675 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 675 24 own own JJ 31417 675 25 devices device NNS 31417 675 26 . . . 31417 676 1 The the DT 31417 676 2 tilting tilting NN 31417 676 3 above above RB 31417 676 4 noticed notice VBD 31417 676 5 has have VBZ 31417 676 6 been be VBN 31417 676 7 even even RB 31417 676 8 more more RBR 31417 676 9 marked marked JJ 31417 676 10 when when WRB 31417 676 11 the the DT 31417 676 12 sitters sitter NNS 31417 676 13 have have VBP 31417 676 14 been be VBN 31417 676 15 removed remove VBN 31417 676 16 from from IN 31417 676 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 676 18 to to IN 31417 676 19 a a DT 31417 676 20 distance distance NN 31417 676 21 of of IN 31417 676 22 about about RB 31417 676 23 two two CD 31417 676 24 feet foot NNS 31417 676 25 . . . 31417 677 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 677 2 has have VBZ 31417 677 3 rapped rap VBN 31417 677 4 on on IN 31417 677 5 the the DT 31417 677 6 chair chair NN 31417 677 7 and and CC 31417 677 8 on on IN 31417 677 9 the the DT 31417 677 10 floor floor NN 31417 677 11 , , , 31417 677 12 inclined incline VBN 31417 677 13 so so IN 31417 677 14 as as IN 31417 677 15 to to TO 31417 677 16 play play VB 31417 677 17 into into IN 31417 677 18 a a DT 31417 677 19 hand hand NN 31417 677 20 placed place VBN 31417 677 21 on on IN 31417 677 22 the the DT 31417 677 23 carpet carpet NN 31417 677 24 , , , 31417 677 25 and and CC 31417 677 26 has have VBZ 31417 677 27 been be VBN 31417 677 28 restored restore VBN 31417 677 29 to to IN 31417 677 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 677 31 normal normal JJ 31417 677 32 position position NN 31417 677 33 when when WRB 31417 677 34 no no DT 31417 677 35 hand hand NN 31417 677 36 has have VBZ 31417 677 37 touched touch VBN 31417 677 38 it -PRON- PRP 31417 677 39 . . . 31417 678 1 The the DT 31417 678 2 actual actual JJ 31417 678 3 force force NN 31417 678 4 required require VBN 31417 678 5 to to TO 31417 678 6 perform perform VB 31417 678 7 this this DT 31417 678 8 would would MD 31417 678 9 be be VB 31417 678 10 represented represent VBN 31417 678 11 by by IN 31417 678 12 very very RB 31417 678 13 considerable considerable JJ 31417 678 14 muscular muscular JJ 31417 678 15 exertion exertion NN 31417 678 16 in in IN 31417 678 17 a a DT 31417 678 18 man man NN 31417 678 19 of of IN 31417 678 20 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 678 21 strength strength NN 31417 678 22 . . . 31417 679 1 " " `` 31417 679 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 679 3 46 46 CD 31417 679 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 679 5 The the DT 31417 679 6 following follow VBG 31417 679 7 account account NN 31417 679 8 , , , 31417 679 9 besides besides IN 31417 679 10 being be VBG 31417 679 11 a a DT 31417 679 12 record record NN 31417 679 13 of of IN 31417 679 14 physical physical JJ 31417 679 15 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 679 16 , , , 31417 679 17 is be VBZ 31417 679 18 a a DT 31417 679 19 curious curious JJ 31417 679 20 illustration illustration NN 31417 679 21 of of IN 31417 679 22 the the DT 31417 679 23 result result NN 31417 679 24 of of IN 31417 679 25 not not RB 31417 679 26 following follow VBG 31417 679 27 alleged alleged JJ 31417 679 28 instructions instruction NNS 31417 679 29 . . . 31417 680 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 680 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 680 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 680 4 writes:-- writes:-- : 31417 680 5 " " `` 31417 680 6 We -PRON- PRP 31417 680 7 had have VBD 31417 680 8 ventured venture VBN 31417 680 9 on on IN 31417 680 10 one one CD 31417 680 11 occasion occasion NN 31417 680 12 , , , 31417 680 13 contrary contrary JJ 31417 680 14 to to IN 31417 680 15 direction direction NN 31417 680 16 , , , 31417 680 17 to to TO 31417 680 18 add add VB 31417 680 19 to to IN 31417 680 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 680 21 circle circle NN 31417 680 22 a a DT 31417 680 23 strange strange JJ 31417 680 24 member member NN 31417 680 25 . . . 31417 681 1 Some some DT 31417 681 2 trivial trivial JJ 31417 681 3 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 681 4 occurred occur VBD 31417 681 5 , , , 31417 681 6 but but CC 31417 681 7 the the DT 31417 681 8 usual usual JJ 31417 681 9 controlling controlling NN 31417 681 10 spirit spirit NN 31417 681 11 did do VBD 31417 681 12 not not RB 31417 681 13 appear appear VB 31417 681 14 . . . 31417 682 1 When when WRB 31417 682 2 next next RB 31417 682 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 682 4 sat sit VBD 31417 682 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 682 6 came come VBD 31417 682 7 ; ; , 31417 682 8 and and CC 31417 682 9 probably probably RB 31417 682 10 none none NN 31417 682 11 of of IN 31417 682 12 us -PRON- PRP 31417 682 13 will will MD 31417 682 14 easily easily RB 31417 682 15 forget forget VB 31417 682 16 the the DT 31417 682 17 sledge sledge NN 31417 682 18 - - HYPH 31417 682 19 hammer hammer NN 31417 682 20 blows blow NNS 31417 682 21 with with IN 31417 682 22 which which WDT 31417 682 23 he -PRON- PRP 31417 682 24 smote smite VBD 31417 682 25 the the DT 31417 682 26 table table NN 31417 682 27 . . . 31417 683 1 The the DT 31417 683 2 noise noise NN 31417 683 3 was be VBD 31417 683 4 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 683 5 audible audible JJ 31417 683 6 in in IN 31417 683 7 the the DT 31417 683 8 room room NN 31417 683 9 below below RB 31417 683 10 , , , 31417 683 11 and and CC 31417 683 12 gave give VBD 31417 683 13 one one CD 31417 683 14 the the DT 31417 683 15 idea idea NN 31417 683 16 that that IN 31417 683 17 the the DT 31417 683 18 table table NN 31417 683 19 would would MD 31417 683 20 be be VB 31417 683 21 broken break VBN 31417 683 22 to to IN 31417 683 23 pieces piece NNS 31417 683 24 . . . 31417 684 1 In in IN 31417 684 2 vain vain JJ 31417 684 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 684 4 withdrew withdraw VBD 31417 684 5 from from IN 31417 684 6 the the DT 31417 684 7 table table NN 31417 684 8 , , , 31417 684 9 hoping hope VBG 31417 684 10 to to TO 31417 684 11 diminish diminish VB 31417 684 12 the the DT 31417 684 13 power power NN 31417 684 14 . . . 31417 685 1 The the DT 31417 685 2 heavy heavy JJ 31417 685 3 blows blow NNS 31417 685 4 increased increase VBD 31417 685 5 in in IN 31417 685 6 intensity intensity NN 31417 685 7 , , , 31417 685 8 and and CC 31417 685 9 the the DT 31417 685 10 whole whole JJ 31417 685 11 room room NN 31417 685 12 shook shake VBD 31417 685 13 with with IN 31417 685 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 685 15 force force NN 31417 685 16 . . . 31417 686 1 The the DT 31417 686 2 direst dire JJS 31417 686 3 penalties penalty NNS 31417 686 4 were be VBD 31417 686 5 threatened threaten VBN 31417 686 6 if if IN 31417 686 7 we -PRON- PRP 31417 686 8 again again RB 31417 686 9 interfered interfere VBD 31417 686 10 with with IN 31417 686 11 the the DT 31417 686 12 development development NN 31417 686 13 by by IN 31417 686 14 bringing bring VBG 31417 686 15 in in RP 31417 686 16 new new JJ 31417 686 17 sitters sitter NNS 31417 686 18 . . . 31417 687 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 687 2 have have VBP 31417 687 3 not not RB 31417 687 4 ventured venture VBN 31417 687 5 to to TO 31417 687 6 do do VB 31417 687 7 so so RB 31417 687 8 again again RB 31417 687 9 ; ; : 31417 687 10 and and CC 31417 687 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 687 12 do do VBP 31417 687 13 not not RB 31417 687 14 think think VB 31417 687 15 we -PRON- PRP 31417 687 16 shall shall MD 31417 687 17 easily easily RB 31417 687 18 be be VB 31417 687 19 persuaded persuade VBN 31417 687 20 to to TO 31417 687 21 risk risk VB 31417 687 22 another another DT 31417 687 23 similar similar JJ 31417 687 24 objurgation objurgation NN 31417 687 25 . . . 31417 688 1 " " `` 31417 688 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 688 3 47 47 CD 31417 688 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 688 5 The the DT 31417 688 6 following follow VBG 31417 688 7 account account NN 31417 688 8 of of IN 31417 688 9 some some DT 31417 688 10 impromptu impromptu JJ 31417 688 11 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 688 12 is be VBZ 31417 688 13 written write VBN 31417 688 14 by by IN 31417 688 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 688 16 Serjeant Serjeant NNP 31417 688 17 Cox Cox NNP 31417 688 18 , , , 31417 688 19 and and CC 31417 688 20 is be VBZ 31417 688 21 quoted quote VBN 31417 688 22 by by IN 31417 688 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 688 24 Myers Myers NNP 31417 688 25 from from IN 31417 688 26 the the DT 31417 688 27 second second JJ 31417 688 28 volume volume NN 31417 688 29 of of IN 31417 688 30 Serjeant Serjeant NNP 31417 688 31 Cox Cox NNP 31417 688 32 's 's POS 31417 688 33 work work NN 31417 688 34 , , , 31417 688 35 " " `` 31417 688 36 What what WP 31417 688 37 am be VBP 31417 688 38 I -PRON- PRP 31417 688 39 ? ? . 31417 688 40 " " '' 31417 689 1 The the DT 31417 689 2 scene scene NN 31417 689 3 was be VBD 31417 689 4 also also RB 31417 689 5 orally orally RB 31417 689 6 described describe VBN 31417 689 7 to to IN 31417 689 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 689 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 689 10 by by IN 31417 689 11 Serjeant Serjeant NNP 31417 689 12 Cox Cox NNP 31417 689 13 , , , 31417 689 14 who who WP 31417 689 15 , , , 31417 689 16 as as IN 31417 689 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 689 18 Myers Myers NNP 31417 689 19 remarks remark VBZ 31417 689 20 , , , 31417 689 21 was be VBD 31417 689 22 not not RB 31417 689 23 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 689 24 a a DT 31417 689 25 " " `` 31417 689 26 Spiritualist Spiritualist NNP 31417 689 27 , , , 31417 689 28 " " '' 31417 689 29 but but CC 31417 689 30 ascribed ascribe VBD 31417 689 31 these these DT 31417 689 32 and and CC 31417 689 33 similar similar JJ 31417 689 34 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 689 35 to to IN 31417 689 36 a a DT 31417 689 37 power power NN 31417 689 38 innate innate VBP 31417 689 39 in in IN 31417 689 40 the the DT 31417 689 41 medium medium NN 31417 689 42 's 's POS 31417 689 43 own own JJ 31417 689 44 being being NN 31417 689 45 . . . 31417 690 1 " " `` 31417 690 2 On on IN 31417 690 3 Tuesday Tuesday NNP 31417 690 4 , , , 31417 690 5 2nd 2nd JJ 31417 690 6 June June NNP 31417 690 7 1873 1873 CD 31417 690 8 , , , 31417 690 9 a a DT 31417 690 10 personal personal JJ 31417 690 11 friend friend NN 31417 690 12 [ [ -LRB- 31417 690 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 690 14 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 690 15 Moses Moses NNP 31417 690 16 ] ] -RRB- 31417 690 17 came come VBD 31417 690 18 to to IN 31417 690 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 690 20 residence residence NN 31417 690 21 in in IN 31417 690 22 Russell Russell NNP 31417 690 23 Square Square NNP 31417 690 24 to to TO 31417 690 25 dress dress VB 31417 690 26 for for IN 31417 690 27 a a DT 31417 690 28 dinner dinner NN 31417 690 29 party party NN 31417 690 30 to to TO 31417 690 31 which which WDT 31417 690 32 we -PRON- PRP 31417 690 33 were be VBD 31417 690 34 invited invite VBN 31417 690 35 . . . 31417 691 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 691 2 had have VBD 31417 691 3 previously previously RB 31417 691 4 exhibited exhibit VBN 31417 691 5 considerable considerable JJ 31417 691 6 power power NN 31417 691 7 as as IN 31417 691 8 a a DT 31417 691 9 Psychic Psychic NNP 31417 691 10 . . . 31417 692 1 Having have VBG 31417 692 2 half half PDT 31417 692 3 an an DT 31417 692 4 hour hour NN 31417 692 5 to to TO 31417 692 6 spare spare VB 31417 692 7 , , , 31417 692 8 we -PRON- PRP 31417 692 9 went go VBD 31417 692 10 into into IN 31417 692 11 the the DT 31417 692 12 dining dining NN 31417 692 13 - - HYPH 31417 692 14 room room NN 31417 692 15 . . . 31417 693 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 693 2 was be VBD 31417 693 3 just just RB 31417 693 4 six six CD 31417 693 5 o'clock o'clock NN 31417 693 6 , , , 31417 693 7 and and CC 31417 693 8 of of IN 31417 693 9 course course NN 31417 693 10 broad broad JJ 31417 693 11 daylight daylight NN 31417 693 12 . . . 31417 694 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 694 2 was be VBD 31417 694 3 opening open VBG 31417 694 4 letters letter NNS 31417 694 5 ; ; : 31417 694 6 he -PRON- PRP 31417 694 7 was be VBD 31417 694 8 reading read VBG 31417 694 9 the the DT 31417 694 10 _ _ NNP 31417 694 11 Times Times NNP 31417 694 12 _ _ NNP 31417 694 13 . . . 31417 695 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 695 2 dining dining NN 31417 695 3 - - HYPH 31417 695 4 table table NN 31417 695 5 is be VBZ 31417 695 6 of of IN 31417 695 7 mahogany mahogany NN 31417 695 8 , , , 31417 695 9 very very RB 31417 695 10 heavy heavy JJ 31417 695 11 , , , 31417 695 12 old old JJ 31417 695 13 - - HYPH 31417 695 14 fashioned fashioned JJ 31417 695 15 , , , 31417 695 16 six six CD 31417 695 17 feet foot NNS 31417 695 18 wide wide JJ 31417 695 19 , , , 31417 695 20 nine nine CD 31417 695 21 feet foot NNS 31417 695 22 long long JJ 31417 695 23 . . . 31417 696 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 696 2 stands stand VBZ 31417 696 3 on on IN 31417 696 4 a a DT 31417 696 5 Turkey Turkey NNP 31417 696 6 carpet carpet NN 31417 696 7 , , , 31417 696 8 which which WDT 31417 696 9 much much JJ 31417 696 10 increases increase VBZ 31417 696 11 the the DT 31417 696 12 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 696 13 of of IN 31417 696 14 moving move VBG 31417 696 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 696 16 . . . 31417 697 1 A a DT 31417 697 2 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 697 3 trial trial NN 31417 697 4 showed show VBD 31417 697 5 that that IN 31417 697 6 the the DT 31417 697 7 united united NNP 31417 697 8 efforts effort NNS 31417 697 9 of of IN 31417 697 10 two two CD 31417 697 11 strong strong JJ 31417 697 12 men man NNS 31417 697 13 standing stand VBG 31417 697 14 were be VBD 31417 697 15 required require VBN 31417 697 16 to to TO 31417 697 17 move move VB 31417 697 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 697 19 one one CD 31417 697 20 inch inch NN 31417 697 21 . . . 31417 698 1 There there EX 31417 698 2 was be VBD 31417 698 3 no no DT 31417 698 4 cloth cloth NN 31417 698 5 upon upon IN 31417 698 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 698 7 , , , 31417 698 8 and and CC 31417 698 9 the the DT 31417 698 10 light light NN 31417 698 11 fell fall VBD 31417 698 12 full full JJ 31417 698 13 under under IN 31417 698 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 698 15 . . . 31417 699 1 No no DT 31417 699 2 person person NN 31417 699 3 was be VBD 31417 699 4 in in IN 31417 699 5 the the DT 31417 699 6 room room NN 31417 699 7 but but CC 31417 699 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 699 9 friend friend NN 31417 699 10 and and CC 31417 699 11 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 699 12 . . . 31417 700 1 Suddenly suddenly RB 31417 700 2 , , , 31417 700 3 as as IN 31417 700 4 we -PRON- PRP 31417 700 5 were be VBD 31417 700 6 sitting sit VBG 31417 700 7 thus thus RB 31417 700 8 , , , 31417 700 9 frequent frequent JJ 31417 700 10 and and CC 31417 700 11 loud loud JJ 31417 700 12 rappings rapping NNS 31417 700 13 came come VBD 31417 700 14 upon upon IN 31417 700 15 the the DT 31417 700 16 table table NN 31417 700 17 . . . 31417 701 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 701 2 friend friend NN 31417 701 3 was be VBD 31417 701 4 then then RB 31417 701 5 sitting sit VBG 31417 701 6 holding hold VBG 31417 701 7 the the DT 31417 701 8 newspaper newspaper NN 31417 701 9 with with IN 31417 701 10 both both DT 31417 701 11 hands hand NNS 31417 701 12 , , , 31417 701 13 one one CD 31417 701 14 arm arm NN 31417 701 15 resting rest VBG 31417 701 16 on on IN 31417 701 17 the the DT 31417 701 18 table table NN 31417 701 19 , , , 31417 701 20 the the DT 31417 701 21 other other JJ 31417 701 22 on on IN 31417 701 23 the the DT 31417 701 24 back back NN 31417 701 25 of of IN 31417 701 26 a a DT 31417 701 27 chair chair NN 31417 701 28 , , , 31417 701 29 and and CC 31417 701 30 turned turn VBD 31417 701 31 sideways sideways RB 31417 701 32 from from IN 31417 701 33 the the DT 31417 701 34 table table NN 31417 701 35 , , , 31417 701 36 so so IN 31417 701 37 that that IN 31417 701 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 701 39 legs leg NNS 31417 701 40 and and CC 31417 701 41 feet foot NNS 31417 701 42 were be VBD 31417 701 43 not not RB 31417 701 44 under under IN 31417 701 45 the the DT 31417 701 46 table table NN 31417 701 47 , , , 31417 701 48 but but CC 31417 701 49 at at IN 31417 701 50 the the DT 31417 701 51 side side NN 31417 701 52 of of IN 31417 701 53 it -PRON- PRP 31417 701 54 . . . 31417 702 1 Presently presently RB 31417 702 2 the the DT 31417 702 3 solid solid JJ 31417 702 4 table table NN 31417 702 5 quivered quiver VBN 31417 702 6 as as IN 31417 702 7 with with IN 31417 702 8 an an DT 31417 702 9 ague ague NN 31417 702 10 fit fit NN 31417 702 11 . . . 31417 703 1 Then then RB 31417 703 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 703 3 swayed sway VBD 31417 703 4 to to IN 31417 703 5 and and CC 31417 703 6 fro fro NNP 31417 703 7 so so RB 31417 703 8 violently violently RB 31417 703 9 as as IN 31417 703 10 almost almost RB 31417 703 11 to to TO 31417 703 12 dislocate dislocate VB 31417 703 13 the the DT 31417 703 14 big big JJ 31417 703 15 pillar pillar NN 31417 703 16 - - HYPH 31417 703 17 like like JJ 31417 703 18 legs leg NNS 31417 703 19 , , , 31417 703 20 of of IN 31417 703 21 which which WDT 31417 703 22 there there EX 31417 703 23 are be VBP 31417 703 24 eight eight CD 31417 703 25 . . . 31417 704 1 Then then RB 31417 704 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 704 3 moved move VBD 31417 704 4 forward forward RB 31417 704 5 about about RB 31417 704 6 three three CD 31417 704 7 inches inch NNS 31417 704 8 . . . 31417 705 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 705 2 looked look VBD 31417 705 3 under under IN 31417 705 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 705 5 to to TO 31417 705 6 be be VB 31417 705 7 sure sure JJ 31417 705 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 705 9 was be VBD 31417 705 10 not not RB 31417 705 11 touched touch VBN 31417 705 12 ; ; : 31417 705 13 but but CC 31417 705 14 still still RB 31417 705 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 705 16 moved move VBD 31417 705 17 , , , 31417 705 18 and and CC 31417 705 19 still still RB 31417 705 20 the the DT 31417 705 21 blows blow NNS 31417 705 22 were be VBD 31417 705 23 loud loud JJ 31417 705 24 upon upon IN 31417 705 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 705 26 . . . 31417 706 1 " " `` 31417 706 2 This this DT 31417 706 3 sudden sudden JJ 31417 706 4 access access NN 31417 706 5 of of IN 31417 706 6 the the DT 31417 706 7 Force Force NNP 31417 706 8 at at IN 31417 706 9 such such PDT 31417 706 10 a a DT 31417 706 11 time time NN 31417 706 12 , , , 31417 706 13 and and CC 31417 706 14 in in IN 31417 706 15 such such PDT 31417 706 16 a a DT 31417 706 17 place place NN 31417 706 18 , , , 31417 706 19 with with IN 31417 706 20 none none NN 31417 706 21 present present JJ 31417 706 22 but but CC 31417 706 23 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 706 24 and and CC 31417 706 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 706 26 friend friend NN 31417 706 27 , , , 31417 706 28 and and CC 31417 706 29 with with IN 31417 706 30 no no DT 31417 706 31 thought thought NN 31417 706 32 then then RB 31417 706 33 of of IN 31417 706 34 invoking invoke VBG 31417 706 35 it -PRON- PRP 31417 706 36 , , , 31417 706 37 caused cause VBD 31417 706 38 the the DT 31417 706 39 utmost utmost JJ 31417 706 40 astonishment astonishment NN 31417 706 41 in in IN 31417 706 42 both both DT 31417 706 43 of of IN 31417 706 44 us -PRON- PRP 31417 706 45 . . . 31417 707 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 707 2 friend friend NN 31417 707 3 said say VBD 31417 707 4 that that IN 31417 707 5 nothing nothing NN 31417 707 6 like like IN 31417 707 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 707 8 had have VBD 31417 707 9 ever ever RB 31417 707 10 before before RB 31417 707 11 occurred occur VBD 31417 707 12 to to IN 31417 707 13 him -PRON- PRP 31417 707 14 . . . 31417 708 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 708 2 then then RB 31417 708 3 suggested suggest VBD 31417 708 4 that that IN 31417 708 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 708 6 would would MD 31417 708 7 be be VB 31417 708 8 an an DT 31417 708 9 invaluable invaluable JJ 31417 708 10 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 708 11 , , , 31417 708 12 with with IN 31417 708 13 so so RB 31417 708 14 great great JJ 31417 708 15 a a DT 31417 708 16 power power NN 31417 708 17 in in IN 31417 708 18 action action NN 31417 708 19 , , , 31417 708 20 to to TO 31417 708 21 make make VB 31417 708 22 trial trial NN 31417 708 23 of of IN 31417 708 24 _ _ NNP 31417 708 25 motion motion NN 31417 708 26 without without IN 31417 708 27 contact contact NN 31417 708 28 _ _ NNP 31417 708 29 , , , 31417 708 30 the the DT 31417 708 31 presence presence NN 31417 708 32 of of IN 31417 708 33 two two CD 31417 708 34 persons person NNS 31417 708 35 only only RB 31417 708 36 , , , 31417 708 37 the the DT 31417 708 38 daylight daylight NN 31417 708 39 , , , 31417 708 40 the the DT 31417 708 41 place place NN 31417 708 42 , , , 31417 708 43 the the DT 31417 708 44 size size NN 31417 708 45 and and CC 31417 708 46 weight weight NN 31417 708 47 of of IN 31417 708 48 the the DT 31417 708 49 table table NN 31417 708 50 , , , 31417 708 51 making make VBG 31417 708 52 the the DT 31417 708 53 experiment experiment NN 31417 708 54 a a DT 31417 708 55 crucial crucial JJ 31417 708 56 one one NN 31417 708 57 . . . 31417 709 1 Accordingly accordingly RB 31417 709 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 709 3 stood stand VBD 31417 709 4 upright upright RB 31417 709 5 , , , 31417 709 6 he -PRON- PRP 31417 709 7 on on IN 31417 709 8 one one CD 31417 709 9 side side NN 31417 709 10 of of IN 31417 709 11 the the DT 31417 709 12 table table NN 31417 709 13 , , , 31417 709 14 I -PRON- PRP 31417 709 15 on on IN 31417 709 16 the the DT 31417 709 17 other other JJ 31417 709 18 side side NN 31417 709 19 of of IN 31417 709 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 709 21 . . . 31417 710 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 710 2 stood stand VBD 31417 710 3 two two CD 31417 710 4 feet foot NNS 31417 710 5 from from IN 31417 710 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 710 7 , , , 31417 710 8 and and CC 31417 710 9 held hold VBD 31417 710 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 710 11 hands hand NNS 31417 710 12 eight eight CD 31417 710 13 inches inch NNS 31417 710 14 above above IN 31417 710 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 710 16 . . . 31417 711 1 In in IN 31417 711 2 one one CD 31417 711 3 minute minute NN 31417 711 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 711 5 rocked rock VBD 31417 711 6 violently violently RB 31417 711 7 . . . 31417 712 1 Then then RB 31417 712 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 712 3 moved move VBD 31417 712 4 over over IN 31417 712 5 the the DT 31417 712 6 carpet carpet NN 31417 712 7 a a DT 31417 712 8 distance distance NN 31417 712 9 of of IN 31417 712 10 seven seven CD 31417 712 11 inches inch NNS 31417 712 12 . . . 31417 713 1 Then then RB 31417 713 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 713 3 rose rise VBD 31417 713 4 three three CD 31417 713 5 inches inch NNS 31417 713 6 from from IN 31417 713 7 the the DT 31417 713 8 floor floor NN 31417 713 9 on on IN 31417 713 10 the the DT 31417 713 11 side side NN 31417 713 12 on on IN 31417 713 13 which which WDT 31417 713 14 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 713 15 friend friend NN 31417 713 16 was be VBD 31417 713 17 standing stand VBG 31417 713 18 . . . 31417 714 1 Then then RB 31417 714 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 714 3 rose rise VBD 31417 714 4 equally equally RB 31417 714 5 on on IN 31417 714 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 714 7 side side NN 31417 714 8 . . . 31417 715 1 Finally finally RB 31417 715 2 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 715 3 friend friend NN 31417 715 4 held hold VBD 31417 715 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 715 6 hands hand NNS 31417 715 7 four four CD 31417 715 8 inches inch NNS 31417 715 9 over over IN 31417 715 10 the the DT 31417 715 11 end end NN 31417 715 12 of of IN 31417 715 13 the the DT 31417 715 14 table table NN 31417 715 15 , , , 31417 715 16 and and CC 31417 715 17 asked ask VBD 31417 715 18 that that IN 31417 715 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 715 20 would would MD 31417 715 21 rise rise VB 31417 715 22 and and CC 31417 715 23 touch touch VB 31417 715 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 715 25 hand hand NN 31417 715 26 three three CD 31417 715 27 times time NNS 31417 715 28 . . . 31417 716 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 716 2 did do VBD 31417 716 3 so so RB 31417 716 4 ; ; : 31417 716 5 and and CC 31417 716 6 then then RB 31417 716 7 in in IN 31417 716 8 accordance accordance NN 31417 716 9 with with IN 31417 716 10 the the DT 31417 716 11 like like JJ 31417 716 12 request request NN 31417 716 13 , , , 31417 716 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 716 15 rose rise VBD 31417 716 16 to to IN 31417 716 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 716 18 hand hand NN 31417 716 19 held hold VBN 31417 716 20 at at IN 31417 716 21 the the DT 31417 716 22 other other JJ 31417 716 23 end end NN 31417 716 24 to to IN 31417 716 25 the the DT 31417 716 26 same same JJ 31417 716 27 height height NN 31417 716 28 above above IN 31417 716 29 it -PRON- PRP 31417 716 30 and and CC 31417 716 31 in in IN 31417 716 32 the the DT 31417 716 33 same same JJ 31417 716 34 manner manner NN 31417 716 35 . . . 31417 717 1 " " `` 31417 717 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 717 3 48 48 CD 31417 717 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 717 5 LEVITATION.--The LEVITATION.--The . 31417 717 6 wonderful wonderful JJ 31417 717 7 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 717 8 of of IN 31417 717 9 levitation levitation NN 31417 717 10 must must MD 31417 717 11 be be VB 31417 717 12 included include VBN 31417 717 13 in in IN 31417 717 14 the the DT 31417 717 15 category category NN 31417 717 16 of of IN 31417 717 17 " " `` 31417 717 18 movements movement NNS 31417 717 19 without without IN 31417 717 20 contact contact NN 31417 717 21 " " '' 31417 717 22 ! ! . 31417 718 1 Some some DT 31417 718 2 of of IN 31417 718 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 718 4 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 718 5 Moses Moses NNP 31417 718 6 ' ' POS 31417 718 7 experiences experience NNS 31417 718 8 of of IN 31417 718 9 this this DT 31417 718 10 kind kind NN 31417 718 11 are be VBP 31417 718 12 much much RB 31417 718 13 more more RBR 31417 718 14 explicitly explicitly RB 31417 718 15 and and CC 31417 718 16 circumstantially circumstantially RB 31417 718 17 described describe VBN 31417 718 18 than than IN 31417 718 19 those those DT 31417 718 20 alleged allege VBN 31417 718 21 to to TO 31417 718 22 have have VB 31417 718 23 occurred occur VBN 31417 718 24 with with IN 31417 718 25 D. D. NNP 31417 718 26 D. D. NNP 31417 718 27 Home Home NNP 31417 718 28 . . . 31417 719 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 719 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 719 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 719 4 gives give VBZ 31417 719 5 the the DT 31417 719 6 following follow VBG 31417 719 7 account account NN 31417 719 8 of of IN 31417 719 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 719 10 first first JJ 31417 719 11 personal personal JJ 31417 719 12 experience experience NN 31417 719 13 of of IN 31417 719 14 this this DT 31417 719 15 nature:-- nature:-- NN 31417 719 16 " " `` 31417 719 17 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 719 18 first first JJ 31417 719 19 personal personal JJ 31417 719 20 experience experience NN 31417 719 21 of of IN 31417 719 22 levitation levitation NN 31417 719 23 was be VBD 31417 719 24 about about RB 31417 719 25 five five CD 31417 719 26 months month NNS 31417 719 27 after after IN 31417 719 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 719 29 introduction introduction NN 31417 719 30 to to IN 31417 719 31 spiritualism spiritualism NN 31417 719 32 . . . 31417 720 1 Physical physical JJ 31417 720 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 720 3 of of IN 31417 720 4 a a DT 31417 720 5 very very RB 31417 720 6 powerful powerful JJ 31417 720 7 description description NN 31417 720 8 had have VBD 31417 720 9 been be VBN 31417 720 10 developed develop VBN 31417 720 11 with with IN 31417 720 12 great great JJ 31417 720 13 rapidity rapidity NN 31417 720 14 . . . 31417 721 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 721 2 were be VBD 31417 721 3 new new JJ 31417 721 4 to to IN 31417 721 5 the the DT 31417 721 6 subject subject NN 31417 721 7 , , , 31417 721 8 and and CC 31417 721 9 the the DT 31417 721 10 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 721 11 were be VBD 31417 721 12 most most RBS 31417 721 13 interesting interesting JJ 31417 721 14 .... .... . 31417 721 15 One one CD 31417 721 16 day day NN 31417 721 17 ( ( -LRB- 31417 721 18 30th 30th JJ 31417 721 19 August August NNP 31417 721 20 1872 1872 CD 31417 721 21 ) ) -RRB- 31417 721 22 ... ... . 31417 722 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 722 2 felt feel VBD 31417 722 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 722 4 chair chair NN 31417 722 5 drawn draw VBN 31417 722 6 back back RB 31417 722 7 from from IN 31417 722 8 the the DT 31417 722 9 table table NN 31417 722 10 and and CC 31417 722 11 turned turn VBD 31417 722 12 into into IN 31417 722 13 the the DT 31417 722 14 corner corner NN 31417 722 15 near near IN 31417 722 16 which which WDT 31417 722 17 I -PRON- PRP 31417 722 18 sat sit VBD 31417 722 19 . . . 31417 723 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 723 2 was be VBD 31417 723 3 so so RB 31417 723 4 placed place VBN 31417 723 5 that that IN 31417 723 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 723 7 face face NN 31417 723 8 was be VBD 31417 723 9 turned turn VBN 31417 723 10 away away RB 31417 723 11 from from IN 31417 723 12 the the DT 31417 723 13 circle circle NN 31417 723 14 to to IN 31417 723 15 the the DT 31417 723 16 angle angle NN 31417 723 17 made make VBN 31417 723 18 by by IN 31417 723 19 the the DT 31417 723 20 two two CD 31417 723 21 walls wall NNS 31417 723 22 . . . 31417 724 1 In in IN 31417 724 2 this this DT 31417 724 3 position position NN 31417 724 4 the the DT 31417 724 5 chair chair NN 31417 724 6 was be VBD 31417 724 7 raised raise VBN 31417 724 8 from from IN 31417 724 9 the the DT 31417 724 10 floor floor NN 31417 724 11 to to IN 31417 724 12 a a DT 31417 724 13 distance distance NN 31417 724 14 of of IN 31417 724 15 , , , 31417 724 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 724 17 should should MD 31417 724 18 judge judge VB 31417 724 19 , , , 31417 724 20 twelve twelve CD 31417 724 21 or or CC 31417 724 22 fourteen fourteen CD 31417 724 23 inches inch NNS 31417 724 24 . . . 31417 725 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 725 2 feet foot NNS 31417 725 3 touched touch VBD 31417 725 4 the the DT 31417 725 5 top top NN 31417 725 6 of of IN 31417 725 7 the the DT 31417 725 8 skirting skirting NN 31417 725 9 - - HYPH 31417 725 10 board board NN 31417 725 11 , , , 31417 725 12 which which WDT 31417 725 13 would would MD 31417 725 14 be be VB 31417 725 15 about about RB 31417 725 16 twelve twelve CD 31417 725 17 inches inch NNS 31417 725 18 in in IN 31417 725 19 height height NN 31417 725 20 . . . 31417 726 1 The the DT 31417 726 2 chair chair NN 31417 726 3 remained remain VBD 31417 726 4 suspended suspend VBN 31417 726 5 for for IN 31417 726 6 a a DT 31417 726 7 few few JJ 31417 726 8 moments moment NNS 31417 726 9 , , , 31417 726 10 and and CC 31417 726 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 726 12 then then RB 31417 726 13 felt feel VBD 31417 726 14 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 726 15 going go VBG 31417 726 16 from from IN 31417 726 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 726 18 , , , 31417 726 19 higher high JJR 31417 726 20 and and CC 31417 726 21 higher higher RBR 31417 726 22 , , , 31417 726 23 with with IN 31417 726 24 a a DT 31417 726 25 very very RB 31417 726 26 slow slow JJ 31417 726 27 and and CC 31417 726 28 easy easy JJ 31417 726 29 movement movement NN 31417 726 30 . . . 31417 727 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 727 2 had have VBD 31417 727 3 no no DT 31417 727 4 sense sense NN 31417 727 5 of of IN 31417 727 6 discomfort discomfort NN 31417 727 7 nor nor CC 31417 727 8 of of IN 31417 727 9 apprehension apprehension NN 31417 727 10 . . . 31417 728 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 728 2 was be VBD 31417 728 3 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 728 4 conscious conscious JJ 31417 728 5 of of IN 31417 728 6 what what WP 31417 728 7 was be VBD 31417 728 8 being be VBG 31417 728 9 done do VBN 31417 728 10 , , , 31417 728 11 and and CC 31417 728 12 described describe VBD 31417 728 13 the the DT 31417 728 14 process process NN 31417 728 15 to to IN 31417 728 16 those those DT 31417 728 17 who who WP 31417 728 18 were be VBD 31417 728 19 sitting sit VBG 31417 728 20 at at IN 31417 728 21 the the DT 31417 728 22 table table NN 31417 728 23 . . . 31417 729 1 The the DT 31417 729 2 movement movement NN 31417 729 3 was be VBD 31417 729 4 very very RB 31417 729 5 steady steady JJ 31417 729 6 , , , 31417 729 7 and and CC 31417 729 8 occupied occupy VBD 31417 729 9 what what WP 31417 729 10 seemed seem VBD 31417 729 11 a a DT 31417 729 12 long long JJ 31417 729 13 time time NN 31417 729 14 before before IN 31417 729 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 729 16 was be VBD 31417 729 17 completed complete VBN 31417 729 18 . . . 31417 730 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 730 2 was be VBD 31417 730 3 close close JJ 31417 730 4 to to IN 31417 730 5 the the DT 31417 730 6 wall wall NN 31417 730 7 , , , 31417 730 8 so so RB 31417 730 9 close close RB 31417 730 10 that that IN 31417 730 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 730 12 was be VBD 31417 730 13 able able JJ 31417 730 14 to to TO 31417 730 15 put put VB 31417 730 16 a a DT 31417 730 17 pencil pencil NN 31417 730 18 firmly firmly RB 31417 730 19 against against IN 31417 730 20 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 730 21 chest chest NN 31417 730 22 , , , 31417 730 23 and and CC 31417 730 24 to to TO 31417 730 25 mark mark VB 31417 730 26 the the DT 31417 730 27 spot spot NN 31417 730 28 opposite opposite RB 31417 730 29 to to IN 31417 730 30 me -PRON- PRP 31417 730 31 on on IN 31417 730 32 the the DT 31417 730 33 wall wall NN 31417 730 34 - - HYPH 31417 730 35 paper paper NN 31417 730 36 . . . 31417 731 1 That that DT 31417 731 2 mark mark NN 31417 731 3 when when WRB 31417 731 4 measured measure VBN 31417 731 5 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 731 6 was be VBD 31417 731 7 found find VBN 31417 731 8 to to TO 31417 731 9 be be VB 31417 731 10 rather rather RB 31417 731 11 more more JJR 31417 731 12 than than IN 31417 731 13 six six CD 31417 731 14 feet foot NNS 31417 731 15 from from IN 31417 731 16 the the DT 31417 731 17 floor floor NN 31417 731 18 , , , 31417 731 19 and and CC 31417 731 20 , , , 31417 731 21 from from IN 31417 731 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 731 23 position position NN 31417 731 24 , , , 31417 731 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 731 26 was be VBD 31417 731 27 clear clear JJ 31417 731 28 that that IN 31417 731 29 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 731 30 head head NN 31417 731 31 must must MD 31417 731 32 have have VB 31417 731 33 been be VBN 31417 731 34 in in IN 31417 731 35 the the DT 31417 731 36 very very JJ 31417 731 37 corner corner NN 31417 731 38 of of IN 31417 731 39 the the DT 31417 731 40 room room NN 31417 731 41 , , , 31417 731 42 close close RB 31417 731 43 to to IN 31417 731 44 the the DT 31417 731 45 ceiling ceiling NN 31417 731 46 . . . 31417 732 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 732 2 do do VBP 31417 732 3 not not RB 31417 732 4 think think VB 31417 732 5 that that IN 31417 732 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 732 7 was be VBD 31417 732 8 in in IN 31417 732 9 any any DT 31417 732 10 way way NN 31417 732 11 entranced entrance VBN 31417 732 12 . . . 31417 733 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 733 2 was be VBD 31417 733 3 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 733 4 clear clear JJ 31417 733 5 in in IN 31417 733 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 733 7 mind mind NN 31417 733 8 , , , 31417 733 9 quite quite RB 31417 733 10 alive alive JJ 31417 733 11 to to IN 31417 733 12 what what WP 31417 733 13 was be VBD 31417 733 14 being be VBG 31417 733 15 done do VBN 31417 733 16 , , , 31417 733 17 and and CC 31417 733 18 fully fully RB 31417 733 19 conscious conscious JJ 31417 733 20 of of IN 31417 733 21 the the DT 31417 733 22 curious curious JJ 31417 733 23 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 733 24 . . . 31417 734 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 734 2 felt feel VBD 31417 734 3 no no DT 31417 734 4 pressure pressure NN 31417 734 5 on on IN 31417 734 6 any any DT 31417 734 7 part part NN 31417 734 8 of of IN 31417 734 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 734 10 body body NN 31417 734 11 , , , 31417 734 12 only only RB 31417 734 13 a a DT 31417 734 14 sensation sensation NN 31417 734 15 as as IN 31417 734 16 of of IN 31417 734 17 being be VBG 31417 734 18 in in IN 31417 734 19 a a DT 31417 734 20 lift lift NN 31417 734 21 , , , 31417 734 22 whilst whilst IN 31417 734 23 objects object NNS 31417 734 24 seemed seem VBD 31417 734 25 to to TO 31417 734 26 be be VB 31417 734 27 passing pass VBG 31417 734 28 away away RB 31417 734 29 from from IN 31417 734 30 below below IN 31417 734 31 me -PRON- PRP 31417 734 32 . . . 31417 735 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 735 2 remember remember VBP 31417 735 3 a a DT 31417 735 4 slight slight JJ 31417 735 5 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 735 6 in in IN 31417 735 7 breathing breathing NN 31417 735 8 , , , 31417 735 9 and and CC 31417 735 10 a a DT 31417 735 11 sensation sensation NN 31417 735 12 of of IN 31417 735 13 fulness fulness NN 31417 735 14 in in IN 31417 735 15 the the DT 31417 735 16 chest chest NN 31417 735 17 , , , 31417 735 18 with with IN 31417 735 19 a a DT 31417 735 20 general general JJ 31417 735 21 feeling feeling NN 31417 735 22 of of IN 31417 735 23 being be VBG 31417 735 24 lighter light JJR 31417 735 25 than than IN 31417 735 26 the the DT 31417 735 27 atmosphere atmosphere NN 31417 735 28 . . . 31417 736 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 736 2 was be VBD 31417 736 3 lowered lower VBN 31417 736 4 down down RP 31417 736 5 quite quite RB 31417 736 6 gently gently RB 31417 736 7 , , , 31417 736 8 and and CC 31417 736 9 placed place VBN 31417 736 10 in in IN 31417 736 11 the the DT 31417 736 12 chair chair NN 31417 736 13 , , , 31417 736 14 which which WDT 31417 736 15 had have VBD 31417 736 16 settled settle VBN 31417 736 17 in in IN 31417 736 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 736 19 old old JJ 31417 736 20 position position NN 31417 736 21 . . . 31417 737 1 The the DT 31417 737 2 measurements measurement NNS 31417 737 3 and and CC 31417 737 4 observations observation NNS 31417 737 5 were be VBD 31417 737 6 taken take VBN 31417 737 7 immediately immediately RB 31417 737 8 , , , 31417 737 9 and and CC 31417 737 10 the the DT 31417 737 11 marks mark NNS 31417 737 12 which which WDT 31417 737 13 I -PRON- PRP 31417 737 14 had have VBD 31417 737 15 made make VBN 31417 737 16 with with IN 31417 737 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 737 18 pencil pencil NN 31417 737 19 were be VBD 31417 737 20 noted note VBN 31417 737 21 . . . 31417 738 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 738 2 voice voice NN 31417 738 3 was be VBD 31417 738 4 said say VBN 31417 738 5 at at IN 31417 738 6 the the DT 31417 738 7 time time NN 31417 738 8 to to TO 31417 738 9 sound sound VB 31417 738 10 as as IN 31417 738 11 if if IN 31417 738 12 from from IN 31417 738 13 the the DT 31417 738 14 corner corner NN 31417 738 15 of of IN 31417 738 16 the the DT 31417 738 17 room room NN 31417 738 18 , , , 31417 738 19 close close RB 31417 738 20 to to IN 31417 738 21 the the DT 31417 738 22 ceiling ceiling NN 31417 738 23 . . . 31417 739 1 " " `` 31417 739 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 739 3 49 49 CD 31417 739 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 739 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 739 6 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 739 7 Moses Moses NNP 31417 739 8 says say VBZ 31417 739 9 that that IN 31417 739 10 this this DT 31417 739 11 experience experience NN 31417 739 12 was be VBD 31417 739 13 repeated repeat VBN 31417 739 14 , , , 31417 739 15 with with IN 31417 739 16 variations variation NNS 31417 739 17 , , , 31417 739 18 on on IN 31417 739 19 nine nine CD 31417 739 20 other other JJ 31417 739 21 occasions occasion NNS 31417 739 22 . . . 31417 740 1 Once once IN 31417 740 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 740 3 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 740 4 found find VBD 31417 740 5 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 740 6 on on IN 31417 740 7 the the DT 31417 740 8 table table NN 31417 740 9 -- -- : 31417 740 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 740 11 chair chair NN 31417 740 12 being be VBG 31417 740 13 unmoved unmoved JJ 31417 740 14 . . . 31417 741 1 This this DT 31417 741 2 , , , 31417 741 3 " " `` 31417 741 4 under under IN 31417 741 5 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 741 6 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 741 7 , , , 31417 741 8 " " '' 31417 741 9 he -PRON- PRP 31417 741 10 says say VBZ 31417 741 11 , , , 31417 741 12 " " `` 31417 741 13 is be VBZ 31417 741 14 what what WP 31417 741 15 we -PRON- PRP 31417 741 16 call call VBP 31417 741 17 impossible impossible JJ 31417 741 18 . . . 31417 741 19 " " '' 31417 742 1 On on IN 31417 742 2 another another DT 31417 742 3 occasion occasion NN 31417 742 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 742 5 was be VBD 31417 742 6 placed place VBN 31417 742 7 on on IN 31417 742 8 the the DT 31417 742 9 table table NN 31417 742 10 standing standing NN 31417 742 11 . . . 31417 743 1 But but CC 31417 743 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 743 3 discouraged discourage VBD 31417 743 4 these these DT 31417 743 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 743 6 of of IN 31417 743 7 levitation levitation NN 31417 743 8 as as RB 31417 743 9 much much RB 31417 743 10 as as IN 31417 743 11 possible possible JJ 31417 743 12 , , , 31417 743 13 from from IN 31417 743 14 a a DT 31417 743 15 dislike dislike NN 31417 743 16 to to IN 31417 743 17 violent violent JJ 31417 743 18 physical physical JJ 31417 743 19 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 743 20 . . . 31417 744 1 MOVEMENT MOVEMENT NNP 31417 744 2 OF of IN 31417 744 3 OBJECTS OBJECTS NNP 31417 744 4 IN in IN 31417 744 5 A a DT 31417 744 6 CLOSED closed NN 31417 744 7 ROOM room NN 31417 744 8 , , , 31417 744 9 NO no DT 31417 744 10 ONE one NN 31417 744 11 BEING be VBG 31417 744 12 PRESENT.--I present.--i CD 31417 744 13 am be VBP 31417 744 14 not not RB 31417 744 15 aware aware JJ 31417 744 16 of of IN 31417 744 17 any any DT 31417 744 18 other other JJ 31417 744 19 well well RB 31417 744 20 - - HYPH 31417 744 21 attested attest VBN 31417 744 22 instances instance NNS 31417 744 23 of of IN 31417 744 24 a a DT 31417 744 25 curious curious JJ 31417 744 26 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 744 27 stated state VBN 31417 744 28 to to TO 31417 744 29 have have VB 31417 744 30 occurred occur VBN 31417 744 31 when when WRB 31417 744 32 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 744 33 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 744 34 Moses Moses NNP 31417 744 35 was be VBD 31417 744 36 near near RB 31417 744 37 but but CC 31417 744 38 not not RB 31417 744 39 present present JJ 31417 744 40 . . . 31417 745 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 745 2 thus thus RB 31417 745 3 describes describe VBZ 31417 745 4 the the DT 31417 745 5 " " `` 31417 745 6 first first JJ 31417 745 7 startling startling JJ 31417 745 8 manifestation manifestation NN 31417 745 9 " " '' 31417 745 10 of of IN 31417 745 11 this this DT 31417 745 12 kind kind NN 31417 745 13 . . . 31417 746 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 746 2 was be VBD 31417 746 3 on on IN 31417 746 4 Sunday Sunday NNP 31417 746 5 , , , 31417 746 6 18th 18th JJ 31417 746 7 August August NNP 31417 746 8 1872 1872 CD 31417 746 9 . . . 31417 747 1 Simple simple JJ 31417 747 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 747 3 of of IN 31417 747 4 raps rap NNS 31417 747 5 and and CC 31417 747 6 movements movement NNS 31417 747 7 of of IN 31417 747 8 the the DT 31417 747 9 table table NN 31417 747 10 commenced commence VBN 31417 747 11 at at IN 31417 747 12 breakfast breakfast NN 31417 747 13 - - HYPH 31417 747 14 time time NN 31417 747 15 . . . 31417 748 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 748 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 748 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 748 4 went go VBD 31417 748 5 to to IN 31417 748 6 church church NN 31417 748 7 with with IN 31417 748 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 748 9 friend friend NN 31417 748 10 . . . 31417 749 1 On on IN 31417 749 2 entering enter VBG 31417 749 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 749 4 bedroom bedroom NN 31417 749 5 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 749 6 , , , 31417 749 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 749 8 attention attention NN 31417 749 9 was be VBD 31417 749 10 drawn draw VBN 31417 749 11 by by IN 31417 749 12 loud loud JJ 31417 749 13 rappings rapping NNS 31417 749 14 which which WDT 31417 749 15 followed follow VBD 31417 749 16 him -PRON- PRP 31417 749 17 round round IN 31417 749 18 the the DT 31417 749 19 room room NN 31417 749 20 , , , 31417 749 21 to to IN 31417 749 22 three three CD 31417 749 23 articles article NNS 31417 749 24 so so RB 31417 749 25 placed place VBN 31417 749 26 on on IN 31417 749 27 the the DT 31417 749 28 bed bed NN 31417 749 29 as as IN 31417 749 30 to to TO 31417 749 31 form form VB 31417 749 32 an an DT 31417 749 33 imperfect imperfect JJ 31417 749 34 cross cross NN 31417 749 35 . . . 31417 750 1 While while IN 31417 750 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 750 3 was be VBD 31417 750 4 in in IN 31417 750 5 the the DT 31417 750 6 room room NN 31417 750 7 another another DT 31417 750 8 article article NN 31417 750 9 was be VBD 31417 750 10 added add VBN 31417 750 11 . . . 31417 751 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 751 2 called call VBD 31417 751 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 751 4 friend friend NN 31417 751 5 whose whose WP$ 31417 751 6 guest guest NN 31417 751 7 he -PRON- PRP 31417 751 8 was be VBD 31417 751 9 . . . 31417 752 1 To to TO 31417 752 2 avoid avoid VB 31417 752 3 the the DT 31417 752 4 possibility possibility NN 31417 752 5 of of IN 31417 752 6 children child NNS 31417 752 7 or or CC 31417 752 8 servants servant NNS 31417 752 9 playing play VBG 31417 752 10 tricks trick NNS 31417 752 11 , , , 31417 752 12 in in IN 31417 752 13 case case NN 31417 752 14 anything anything NN 31417 752 15 more more RBR 31417 752 16 happened happen VBD 31417 752 17 , , , 31417 752 18 they -PRON- PRP 31417 752 19 well well RB 31417 752 20 searched search VBD 31417 752 21 the the DT 31417 752 22 room room NN 31417 752 23 -- -- : 31417 752 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 752 25 contained contain VBD 31417 752 26 no no DT 31417 752 27 cupboard cupboard NN 31417 752 28 -- -- : 31417 752 29 bolted bolt VBD 31417 752 30 the the DT 31417 752 31 window window NN 31417 752 32 , , , 31417 752 33 locked lock VBD 31417 752 34 the the DT 31417 752 35 door door NN 31417 752 36 on on IN 31417 752 37 leaving leave VBG 31417 752 38 , , , 31417 752 39 and and CC 31417 752 40 the the DT 31417 752 41 host host NN 31417 752 42 put put VBD 31417 752 43 the the DT 31417 752 44 key key NN 31417 752 45 in in IN 31417 752 46 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 752 47 pocket pocket NN 31417 752 48 . . . 31417 753 1 After after IN 31417 753 2 lunch lunch NN 31417 753 3 two two CD 31417 753 4 more more JJR 31417 753 5 articles article NNS 31417 753 6 were be VBD 31417 753 7 found find VBN 31417 753 8 to to TO 31417 753 9 be be VB 31417 753 10 added add VBN 31417 753 11 . . . 31417 754 1 Another another DT 31417 754 2 visit visit NN 31417 754 3 discovered discover VBD 31417 754 4 other other JJ 31417 754 5 additions addition NNS 31417 754 6 . . . 31417 755 1 This this DT 31417 755 2 went go VBD 31417 755 3 on on RP 31417 755 4 till till IN 31417 755 5 5 5 CD 31417 755 6 P.M. P.M. NNP 31417 755 7 , , , 31417 755 8 " " `` 31417 755 9 when when WRB 31417 755 10 a a DT 31417 755 11 complete complete JJ 31417 755 12 cross cross NN 31417 755 13 extending extend VBG 31417 755 14 the the DT 31417 755 15 whole whole JJ 31417 755 16 length length NN 31417 755 17 of of IN 31417 755 18 the the DT 31417 755 19 bed bed NN 31417 755 20 was be VBD 31417 755 21 made make VBN 31417 755 22 entirely entirely RB 31417 755 23 of of IN 31417 755 24 little little JJ 31417 755 25 articles article NNS 31417 755 26 from from IN 31417 755 27 the the DT 31417 755 28 toilet toilet NN 31417 755 29 - - HYPH 31417 755 30 table table NN 31417 755 31 . . . 31417 755 32 " " '' 31417 756 1 The the DT 31417 756 2 position position NN 31417 756 3 of of IN 31417 756 4 the the DT 31417 756 5 room room NN 31417 756 6 , , , 31417 756 7 and and CC 31417 756 8 the the DT 31417 756 9 whole whole JJ 31417 756 10 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 756 11 , , , 31417 756 12 convinced convince VBD 31417 756 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 756 14 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 756 15 Moses Moses NNP 31417 756 16 and and CC 31417 756 17 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 756 18 and and CC 31417 756 19 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 756 20 Speer Speer NNP 31417 756 21 , , , 31417 756 22 with with IN 31417 756 23 whom whom WP 31417 756 24 he -PRON- PRP 31417 756 25 was be VBD 31417 756 26 staying stay VBG 31417 756 27 , , , 31417 756 28 beyond beyond IN 31417 756 29 any any DT 31417 756 30 doubt doubt NN 31417 756 31 that that IN 31417 756 32 human human JJ 31417 756 33 intervention intervention NN 31417 756 34 was be VBD 31417 756 35 impossible impossible JJ 31417 756 36 . . . 31417 757 1 A a DT 31417 757 2 very very RB 31417 757 3 detailed detailed JJ 31417 757 4 account account NN 31417 757 5 of of IN 31417 757 6 this this DT 31417 757 7 incident incident NN 31417 757 8 exists exist VBZ 31417 757 9 in in IN 31417 757 10 the the DT 31417 757 11 handwriting handwriting NN 31417 757 12 of of IN 31417 757 13 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 758 1 Speer Speer NNP 31417 758 2 . . . 31417 759 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 759 2 50 50 CD 31417 759 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 759 4 THE the DT 31417 759 5 CARRYING carrying NN 31417 759 6 OF of IN 31417 759 7 OBJECTS object NNS 31417 759 8 INTO into VBP 31417 759 9 A a DT 31417 759 10 LOCKED locked JJ 31417 759 11 ROOM room NN 31417 759 12 , , , 31417 759 13 AND and CC 31417 759 14 THE the DT 31417 759 15 PASSAGE passage NN 31417 759 16 OF of IN 31417 759 17 SOLID solid JJ 31417 759 18 OBJECTS object NNS 31417 759 19 THROUGH through NN 31417 759 20 MATERIAL MATERIAL NNS 31417 759 21 OBSTACLES.--During obstacles.--dure VBG 31417 759 22 the the DT 31417 759 23 two two CD 31417 759 24 or or CC 31417 759 25 three three CD 31417 759 26 weeks week NNS 31417 759 27 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 759 28 to to IN 31417 759 29 the the DT 31417 759 30 above above JJ 31417 759 31 , , , 31417 759 32 over over IN 31417 759 33 fifty fifty CD 31417 759 34 instances instance NNS 31417 759 35 occurred occur VBD 31417 759 36 in in IN 31417 759 37 which which WDT 31417 759 38 objects object NNS 31417 759 39 from from IN 31417 759 40 different different JJ 31417 759 41 parts part NNS 31417 759 42 of of IN 31417 759 43 the the DT 31417 759 44 house house NN 31417 759 45 were be VBD 31417 759 46 placed place VBN 31417 759 47 upon upon IN 31417 759 48 the the DT 31417 759 49 table table NN 31417 759 50 round round NN 31417 759 51 which which WDT 31417 759 52 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 759 53 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 759 54 Moses Moses NNP 31417 759 55 and and CC 31417 759 56 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 759 57 and and CC 31417 759 58 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 759 59 Speer Speer NNP 31417 759 60 were be VBD 31417 759 61 sitting sit VBG 31417 759 62 in in IN 31417 759 63 a a DT 31417 759 64 locked lock VBN 31417 759 65 dark dark JJ 31417 759 66 room room NN 31417 759 67 . . . 31417 760 1 The the DT 31417 760 2 gas gas NN 31417 760 3 was be VBD 31417 760 4 always always RB 31417 760 5 left leave VBN 31417 760 6 burning burn VBG 31417 760 7 brightly brightly RB 31417 760 8 in in IN 31417 760 9 the the DT 31417 760 10 adjoining adjoining JJ 31417 760 11 dining dining NN 31417 760 12 - - HYPH 31417 760 13 room room NN 31417 760 14 , , , 31417 760 15 and and CC 31417 760 16 in in IN 31417 760 17 the the DT 31417 760 18 hall hall NN 31417 760 19 outside outside RB 31417 760 20 , , , 31417 760 21 so so IN 31417 760 22 that that IN 31417 760 23 if if IN 31417 760 24 either either DT 31417 760 25 of of IN 31417 760 26 the the DT 31417 760 27 doors door NNS 31417 760 28 had have VBD 31417 760 29 been be VBN 31417 760 30 opened open VBN 31417 760 31 , , , 31417 760 32 even even RB 31417 760 33 for for IN 31417 760 34 a a DT 31417 760 35 moment moment NN 31417 760 36 , , , 31417 760 37 a a DT 31417 760 38 blaze blaze NN 31417 760 39 of of IN 31417 760 40 light light NN 31417 760 41 would would MD 31417 760 42 have have VB 31417 760 43 been be VBN 31417 760 44 let let VBN 31417 760 45 into into IN 31417 760 46 the the DT 31417 760 47 room room NN 31417 760 48 in in IN 31417 760 49 which which WDT 31417 760 50 they -PRON- PRP 31417 760 51 sat sit VBD 31417 760 52 . . . 31417 761 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 761 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 761 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 761 4 remarks--"As remarks--"As NNP 31417 761 5 this this DT 31417 761 6 never never RB 31417 761 7 happened happen VBD 31417 761 8 , , , 31417 761 9 we -PRON- PRP 31417 761 10 have have VBP 31417 761 11 full full JJ 31417 761 12 assurance assurance NN 31417 761 13 from from IN 31417 761 14 what what WP 31417 761 15 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 761 16 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 761 17 considers consider VBZ 31417 761 18 the the DT 31417 761 19 best good JJS 31417 761 20 authority authority NN 31417 761 21 , , , 31417 761 22 common common JJ 31417 761 23 sense sense NN 31417 761 24 , , , 31417 761 25 that that IN 31417 761 26 the the DT 31417 761 27 doors door NNS 31417 761 28 remained remain VBD 31417 761 29 closed closed JJ 31417 761 30 . . . 31417 761 31 " " '' 31417 762 1 On on IN 31417 762 2 one one CD 31417 762 3 occasion occasion NN 31417 762 4 a a DT 31417 762 5 small small JJ 31417 762 6 edition edition NN 31417 762 7 of of IN 31417 762 8 " " `` 31417 762 9 Paradise Paradise NNP 31417 762 10 Lost Lost NNP 31417 762 11 " " '' 31417 762 12 was be VBD 31417 762 13 placed place VBN 31417 762 14 on on IN 31417 762 15 the the DT 31417 762 16 table table NN 31417 762 17 , , , 31417 762 18 and and CC 31417 762 19 at at IN 31417 762 20 the the DT 31417 762 21 same same JJ 31417 762 22 time time NN 31417 762 23 the the DT 31417 762 24 words word NNS 31417 762 25 " " `` 31417 762 26 to to TO 31417 762 27 convince convince VB 31417 762 28 " " '' 31417 762 29 were be VBD 31417 762 30 spelt spelt NNS 31417 762 31 out out RP 31417 762 32 by by IN 31417 762 33 raps rap NNS 31417 762 34 . . . 31417 763 1 This this DT 31417 763 2 little little JJ 31417 763 3 book book NN 31417 763 4 had have VBD 31417 763 5 been be VBN 31417 763 6 in in IN 31417 763 7 the the DT 31417 763 8 hands hand NNS 31417 763 9 of of IN 31417 763 10 all all DT 31417 763 11 of of IN 31417 763 12 them -PRON- PRP 31417 763 13 during during IN 31417 763 14 the the DT 31417 763 15 evening evening NN 31417 763 16 , , , 31417 763 17 and and CC 31417 763 18 they -PRON- PRP 31417 763 19 could could MD 31417 763 20 testify testify VB 31417 763 21 to to IN 31417 763 22 the the DT 31417 763 23 position position NN 31417 763 24 on on IN 31417 763 25 a a DT 31417 763 26 bookshelf bookshelf PRP 31417 763 27 where where WRB 31417 763 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 763 29 had have VBD 31417 763 30 been be VBN 31417 763 31 left leave VBN 31417 763 32 . . . 31417 764 1 One one CD 31417 764 2 evening evening NN 31417 764 3 seven seven CD 31417 764 4 objects object NNS 31417 764 5 in in IN 31417 764 6 different different JJ 31417 764 7 rooms room NNS 31417 764 8 were be VBD 31417 764 9 brought bring VBN 31417 764 10 in in RP 31417 764 11 ; ; , 31417 764 12 among among IN 31417 764 13 them -PRON- PRP 31417 764 14 a a DT 31417 764 15 little little JJ 31417 764 16 bell bell NN 31417 764 17 from from IN 31417 764 18 the the DT 31417 764 19 dining dining NN 31417 764 20 - - HYPH 31417 764 21 room room NN 31417 764 22 . . . 31417 765 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 765 2 heard hear VBD 31417 765 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 765 4 begin begin VB 31417 765 5 to to TO 31417 765 6 ring ring VB 31417 765 7 , , , 31417 765 8 the the DT 31417 765 9 sound sound NN 31417 765 10 approached approach VBD 31417 765 11 the the DT 31417 765 12 door door NN 31417 765 13 , , , 31417 765 14 they -PRON- PRP 31417 765 15 were be VBD 31417 765 16 astonished astonish VBN 31417 765 17 soon soon RB 31417 765 18 to to TO 31417 765 19 hear hear VB 31417 765 20 the the DT 31417 765 21 sound sound NN 31417 765 22 in in IN 31417 765 23 the the DT 31417 765 24 room room NN 31417 765 25 where where WRB 31417 765 26 they -PRON- PRP 31417 765 27 sat sit VBD 31417 765 28 , , , 31417 765 29 round round IN 31417 765 30 which which WDT 31417 765 31 the the DT 31417 765 32 bell bell NN 31417 765 33 was be VBD 31417 765 34 carried carry VBN 31417 765 35 , , , 31417 765 36 close close RB 31417 765 37 to to IN 31417 765 38 the the DT 31417 765 39 faces face NNS 31417 765 40 of of IN 31417 765 41 all all DT 31417 765 42 , , , 31417 765 43 and and CC 31417 765 44 finally finally RB 31417 765 45 placed place VBN 31417 765 46 on on IN 31417 765 47 the the DT 31417 765 48 table table NN 31417 765 49 , , , 31417 765 50 having have VBG 31417 765 51 been be VBN 31417 765 52 ringing ring VBG 31417 765 53 loudly loudly RB 31417 765 54 all all PDT 31417 765 55 the the DT 31417 765 56 time time NN 31417 765 57 . . . 31417 766 1 A a DT 31417 766 2 curious curious JJ 31417 766 3 incident incident NN 31417 766 4 occurred occur VBD 31417 766 5 at at IN 31417 766 6 a a DT 31417 766 7 later later JJ 31417 766 8 date date NN 31417 766 9 , , , 31417 766 10 the the DT 31417 766 11 circle circle NN 31417 766 12 of of IN 31417 766 13 three three CD 31417 766 14 sitting sit VBG 31417 766 15 alone alone RB 31417 766 16 . . . 31417 767 1 A a DT 31417 767 2 small small JJ 31417 767 3 Parian parian JJ 31417 767 4 statuette statuette NN 31417 767 5 from from IN 31417 767 6 an an DT 31417 767 7 upper upper JJ 31417 767 8 room room NN 31417 767 9 was be VBD 31417 767 10 placed place VBN 31417 767 11 upon upon IN 31417 767 12 the the DT 31417 767 13 table table NN 31417 767 14 . . . 31417 768 1 One one CD 31417 768 2 of of IN 31417 768 3 the the DT 31417 768 4 party party NN 31417 768 5 requested request VBD 31417 768 6 that that IN 31417 768 7 a a DT 31417 768 8 friend friend NN 31417 768 9 who who WP 31417 768 10 usually usually RB 31417 768 11 communicates communicate VBZ 31417 768 12 might may MD 31417 768 13 be be VB 31417 768 14 fetched fetch VBN 31417 768 15 . . . 31417 769 1 " " `` 31417 769 2 We -PRON- PRP 31417 769 3 are be VBP 31417 769 4 doing do VBG 31417 769 5 so so RB 31417 769 6 " " '' 31417 769 7 was be VBD 31417 769 8 spelt spell VBN 31417 769 9 out out RP 31417 769 10 by by IN 31417 769 11 raps rap NNS 31417 769 12 . . . 31417 770 1 This this DT 31417 770 2 was be VBD 31417 770 3 taken take VBN 31417 770 4 to to TO 31417 770 5 be be VB 31417 770 6 the the DT 31417 770 7 complete complete JJ 31417 770 8 answer answer NN 31417 770 9 , , , 31417 770 10 and and CC 31417 770 11 they -PRON- PRP 31417 770 12 ceased cease VBD 31417 770 13 to to TO 31417 770 14 call call VB 31417 770 15 over over IN 31417 770 16 the the DT 31417 770 17 alphabet alphabet NN 31417 770 18 . . . 31417 771 1 However however RB 31417 771 2 , , , 31417 771 3 the the DT 31417 771 4 alphabet alphabet NN 31417 771 5 was be VBD 31417 771 6 called call VBN 31417 771 7 for for IN 31417 771 8 again again RB 31417 771 9 , , , 31417 771 10 and and CC 31417 771 11 " " `` 31417 771 12 mething methe VBG 31417 771 13 else else RB 31417 771 14 " " '' 31417 771 15 was be VBD 31417 771 16 spelt spell VBN 31417 771 17 out out RP 31417 771 18 . . . 31417 772 1 No no DT 31417 772 2 idea idea NN 31417 772 3 could could MD 31417 772 4 be be VB 31417 772 5 formed form VBN 31417 772 6 as as IN 31417 772 7 to to IN 31417 772 8 the the DT 31417 772 9 meaning meaning NN 31417 772 10 of of IN 31417 772 11 this this DT 31417 772 12 . . . 31417 773 1 At at IN 31417 773 2 request request NN 31417 773 3 it -PRON- PRP 31417 773 4 was be VBD 31417 773 5 exactly exactly RB 31417 773 6 repeated repeat VBN 31417 773 7 . . . 31417 774 1 After after IN 31417 774 2 much much JJ 31417 774 3 puzzling puzzle VBG 31417 774 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 774 5 occurred occur VBD 31417 774 6 to to IN 31417 774 7 one one CD 31417 774 8 of of IN 31417 774 9 the the DT 31417 774 10 party party NN 31417 774 11 to to TO 31417 774 12 join join VB 31417 774 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 774 14 on on RP 31417 774 15 to to IN 31417 774 16 the the DT 31417 774 17 previous previous JJ 31417 774 18 message message NN 31417 774 19 -- -- : 31417 774 20 when when WRB 31417 774 21 the the DT 31417 774 22 meaning meaning NN 31417 774 23 became become VBD 31417 774 24 apparent apparent JJ 31417 774 25 . . . 31417 775 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 775 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 775 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 775 4 sarcastically sarcastically RB 31417 775 5 remarks--"What remarks--"what DT 31417 775 6 a a DT 31417 775 7 clear clear JJ 31417 775 8 case case NN 31417 775 9 of of IN 31417 775 10 ' ' `` 31417 775 11 unconscious unconscious JJ 31417 775 12 cerebration cerebration NN 31417 775 13 ' ' '' 31417 775 14 " " '' 31417 775 15 ! ! . 31417 776 1 " " `` 31417 776 2 Very very RB 31417 776 3 soon soon RB 31417 776 4 an an DT 31417 776 5 odour odour NN 31417 776 6 like like IN 31417 776 7 Tonquin Tonquin NNP 31417 776 8 bean bean NN 31417 776 9 was be VBD 31417 776 10 apparent apparent JJ 31417 776 11 to to IN 31417 776 12 all all DT 31417 776 13 of of IN 31417 776 14 us -PRON- PRP 31417 776 15 . . . 31417 777 1 Something something NN 31417 777 2 fell fall VBD 31417 777 3 on on IN 31417 777 4 the the DT 31417 777 5 table table NN 31417 777 6 , , , 31417 777 7 and and CC 31417 777 8 light light NN 31417 777 9 showed show VBD 31417 777 10 that that IN 31417 777 11 a a DT 31417 777 12 snuff snuff NN 31417 777 13 - - HYPH 31417 777 14 box box NN 31417 777 15 which which WDT 31417 777 16 had have VBD 31417 777 17 contained contain VBN 31417 777 18 Tonquin Tonquin NNP 31417 777 19 bean bean NN 31417 777 20 had have VBD 31417 777 21 been be VBN 31417 777 22 brought bring VBN 31417 777 23 from from IN 31417 777 24 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 777 25 Speer Speer NNP 31417 777 26 's 's POS 31417 777 27 dressing dressing NN 31417 777 28 - - HYPH 31417 777 29 room room NN 31417 777 30 . . . 31417 778 1 The the DT 31417 778 2 box box NN 31417 778 3 was be VBD 31417 778 4 closed closed JJ 31417 778 5 , , , 31417 778 6 and and CC 31417 778 7 the the DT 31417 778 8 odour odour NN 31417 778 9 was be VBD 31417 778 10 remarked remark VBN 31417 778 11 before before IN 31417 778 12 any any DT 31417 778 13 of of IN 31417 778 14 us -PRON- PRP 31417 778 15 had have VBD 31417 778 16 the the DT 31417 778 17 remotest remote JJS 31417 778 18 idea idea NN 31417 778 19 that that IN 31417 778 20 the the DT 31417 778 21 box box NN 31417 778 22 was be VBD 31417 778 23 in in IN 31417 778 24 the the DT 31417 778 25 room room NN 31417 778 26 . . . 31417 779 1 " " `` 31417 779 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 779 3 51 51 CD 31417 779 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 779 5 PERFUMES perfumes NN 31417 779 6 AND and CC 31417 779 7 WAVES WAVES NNP 31417 779 8 OF of IN 31417 779 9 SCENT SCENT NNP 31417 779 10 - - HYPH 31417 779 11 LADEN LADEN NNP 31417 779 12 AIR AIR NNP 31417 779 13 . . . 31417 780 1 This this DT 31417 780 2 phase phase NN 31417 780 3 of of IN 31417 780 4 the the DT 31417 780 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 780 6 must must MD 31417 780 7 be be VB 31417 780 8 passed pass VBN 31417 780 9 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 780 10 over over RB 31417 780 11 , , , 31417 780 12 though though IN 31417 780 13 manifested manifest VBN 31417 780 14 to to IN 31417 780 15 a a DT 31417 780 16 much much RB 31417 780 17 greater great JJR 31417 780 18 extent extent NN 31417 780 19 and and CC 31417 780 20 in in IN 31417 780 21 greater great JJR 31417 780 22 variety variety NN 31417 780 23 in in IN 31417 780 24 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 780 25 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 780 26 Moses Moses NNP 31417 780 27 ' ' POS 31417 780 28 case case NN 31417 780 29 than than IN 31417 780 30 in in IN 31417 780 31 any any DT 31417 780 32 other other JJ 31417 780 33 with with IN 31417 780 34 which which WDT 31417 780 35 I -PRON- PRP 31417 780 36 am be VBP 31417 780 37 acquainted acquaint VBN 31417 780 38 . . . 31417 781 1 In in IN 31417 781 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 781 3 circle circle NN 31417 781 4 music music NN 31417 781 5 and and CC 31417 781 6 singing singing NN 31417 781 7 were be VBD 31417 781 8 never never RB 31417 781 9 introduced introduce VBN 31417 781 10 as as IN 31417 781 11 a a DT 31417 781 12 means means NN 31417 781 13 of of IN 31417 781 14 harmonising harmonise VBG 31417 781 15 the the DT 31417 781 16 conditions condition NNS 31417 781 17 . . . 31417 782 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 782 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 782 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 782 4 says say VBZ 31417 782 5 : : : 31417 782 6 " " `` 31417 782 7 In in IN 31417 782 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 782 9 circle circle NN 31417 782 10 this this DT 31417 782 11 harmonising harmonising NN 31417 782 12 is be VBZ 31417 782 13 effected effect VBN 31417 782 14 by by IN 31417 782 15 means mean NNS 31417 782 16 of of IN 31417 782 17 perfumes perfume NNS 31417 782 18 and and CC 31417 782 19 waves wave NNS 31417 782 20 of of IN 31417 782 21 cool cool JJ 31417 782 22 - - HYPH 31417 782 23 scented scented JJ 31417 782 24 air air NN 31417 782 25 . . . 31417 782 26 " " '' 31417 783 1 " " `` 31417 783 2 If if IN 31417 783 3 a a DT 31417 783 4 new new JJ 31417 783 5 sitter sitter NN 31417 783 6 is be VBZ 31417 783 7 present present JJ 31417 783 8 , , , 31417 783 9 he -PRON- PRP 31417 783 10 or or CC 31417 783 11 she -PRON- PRP 31417 783 12 is be VBZ 31417 783 13 censed cense VBN 31417 783 14 ( ( -LRB- 31417 783 15 if if IN 31417 783 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 783 17 may may MD 31417 783 18 adopt adopt VB 31417 783 19 the the DT 31417 783 20 expression expression NN 31417 783 21 ) ) -RRB- 31417 783 22 , , , 31417 783 23 and and CC 31417 783 24 so so RB 31417 783 25 initiated initiated JJ 31417 783 26 . . . 31417 783 27 " " '' 31417 784 1 " " `` 31417 784 2 If if IN 31417 784 3 a a DT 31417 784 4 new new JJ 31417 784 5 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 784 6 is be VBZ 31417 784 7 to to TO 31417 784 8 communicate communicate VB 31417 784 9 , , , 31417 784 10 or or CC 31417 784 11 special special JJ 31417 784 12 honour honour NN 31417 784 13 to to TO 31417 784 14 be be VB 31417 784 15 paid pay VBN 31417 784 16 to to IN 31417 784 17 a a DT 31417 784 18 chief chief NN 31417 784 19 , , , 31417 784 20 the the DT 31417 784 21 room room NN 31417 784 22 is be VBZ 31417 784 23 pervaded pervade VBN 31417 784 24 by by IN 31417 784 25 perfumes perfume NNS 31417 784 26 which which WDT 31417 784 27 grow grow VBP 31417 784 28 stronger strong JJR 31417 784 29 as as IN 31417 784 30 the the DT 31417 784 31 spirit spirit NNP 31417 784 32 enters enter VBZ 31417 784 33 . . . 31417 784 34 " " '' 31417 785 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 31417 785 2 the the DT 31417 785 3 scent scent NN 31417 785 4 was be VBD 31417 785 5 in in IN 31417 785 6 a a DT 31417 785 7 liquid liquid JJ 31417 785 8 form form NN 31417 785 9 , , , 31417 785 10 and and CC 31417 785 11 apparently apparently RB 31417 785 12 sprinkled sprinkle VBN 31417 785 13 down down RP 31417 785 14 from from IN 31417 785 15 the the DT 31417 785 16 ceiling ceiling NN 31417 785 17 . . . 31417 786 1 Sometimes sometimes RB 31417 786 2 dry dry JJ 31417 786 3 musk musk NN 31417 786 4 was be VBD 31417 786 5 thrown throw VBN 31417 786 6 about about IN 31417 786 7 in in IN 31417 786 8 considerable considerable JJ 31417 786 9 quantities quantity NNS 31417 786 10 . . . 31417 787 1 A a DT 31417 787 2 striking striking JJ 31417 787 3 instance instance NN 31417 787 4 is be VBZ 31417 787 5 given give VBN 31417 787 6 in in IN 31417 787 7 the the DT 31417 787 8 form form NN 31417 787 9 of of IN 31417 787 10 a a DT 31417 787 11 statement statement NN 31417 787 12 from from IN 31417 787 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 787 14 F. F. NNP 31417 787 15 W. W. NNP 31417 787 16 Percival Percival NNP 31417 787 17 , , , 31417 787 18 mentioned mention VBD 31417 787 19 at at IN 31417 787 20 the the DT 31417 787 21 commencement commencement NN 31417 787 22 of of IN 31417 787 23 this this DT 31417 787 24 article article NN 31417 787 25 -- -- : 31417 787 26 a a DT 31417 787 27 very very RB 31417 787 28 occasional occasional JJ 31417 787 29 sitter sitter NN 31417 787 30 . . . 31417 788 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 788 2 says say VBZ 31417 788 3 : : : 31417 788 4 " " `` 31417 788 5 In in IN 31417 788 6 compliance compliance NN 31417 788 7 with with IN 31417 788 8 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 788 9 request request NN 31417 788 10 , , , 31417 788 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 788 12 will will MD 31417 788 13 describe describe VB 31417 788 14 as as RB 31417 788 15 briefly briefly RB 31417 788 16 as as IN 31417 788 17 possible possible JJ 31417 788 18 what what WP 31417 788 19 occurred occur VBD 31417 788 20 at at IN 31417 788 21 the the DT 31417 788 22 dark dark JJ 31417 788 23 seance seance NN 31417 788 24 held hold VBN 31417 788 25 on on IN 31417 788 26 the the DT 31417 788 27 evening evening NN 31417 788 28 of of IN 31417 788 29 18th 18th JJ 31417 788 30 March March NNP 31417 788 31 1874 1874 CD 31417 788 32 , , , 31417 788 33 when when WRB 31417 788 34 scent scent NNP 31417 788 35 was be VBD 31417 788 36 produced produce VBN 31417 788 37 so so RB 31417 788 38 abundantly abundantly RB 31417 788 39 in in IN 31417 788 40 the the DT 31417 788 41 presence presence NN 31417 788 42 of of IN 31417 788 43 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 788 44 Speer Speer NNP 31417 788 45 and and CC 31417 788 46 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 788 47 , , , 31417 788 48 while while IN 31417 788 49 you -PRON- PRP 31417 788 50 [ [ -LRB- 31417 788 51 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 788 52 S. S. NNP 31417 788 53 M. M. NNP 31417 788 54 ] ] -RRB- 31417 788 55 were be VBD 31417 788 56 in in IN 31417 788 57 a a DT 31417 788 58 state state NN 31417 788 59 of of IN 31417 788 60 trance trance NN 31417 788 61 . . . 31417 789 1 The the DT 31417 789 2 controlling control VBG 31417 789 3 spirit spirit NN 31417 789 4 began begin VBD 31417 789 5 by by IN 31417 789 6 speaking speak VBG 31417 789 7 through through IN 31417 789 8 you -PRON- PRP 31417 789 9 at at IN 31417 789 10 some some DT 31417 789 11 length length NN 31417 789 12 , , , 31417 789 13 and and CC 31417 789 14 we -PRON- PRP 31417 789 15 were be VBD 31417 789 16 told tell VBN 31417 789 17 to to TO 31417 789 18 expect expect VB 31417 789 19 unusual unusual JJ 31417 789 20 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 789 21 . . . 31417 790 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 790 2 commenced commence VBD 31417 790 3 with with IN 31417 790 4 a a DT 31417 790 5 strongly strongly RB 31417 790 6 scented scented JJ 31417 790 7 breeze breeze NN 31417 790 8 , , , 31417 790 9 which which WDT 31417 790 10 passed pass VBD 31417 790 11 softly softly RB 31417 790 12 round round IN 31417 790 13 the the DT 31417 790 14 circle circle NN 31417 790 15 , , , 31417 790 16 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 790 17 course course NN 31417 790 18 being be VBG 31417 790 19 marked mark VBN 31417 790 20 by by IN 31417 790 21 a a DT 31417 790 22 pale pale JJ 31417 790 23 light light NN 31417 790 24 . . . 31417 791 1 In in IN 31417 791 2 a a DT 31417 791 3 few few JJ 31417 791 4 minutes minute NNS 31417 791 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 791 6 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 791 7 changed change VBD 31417 791 8 , , , 31417 791 9 and and CC 31417 791 10 blew blow VBD 31417 791 11 upon upon IN 31417 791 12 us -PRON- PRP 31417 791 13 with with IN 31417 791 14 considerable considerable JJ 31417 791 15 force force NN 31417 791 16 , , , 31417 791 17 as as IN 31417 791 18 if if IN 31417 791 19 a a DT 31417 791 20 pair pair NN 31417 791 21 of of IN 31417 791 22 bellows bellow NNS 31417 791 23 had have VBD 31417 791 24 been be VBN 31417 791 25 employed employ VBN 31417 791 26 , , , 31417 791 27 and and CC 31417 791 28 the the DT 31417 791 29 temperature temperature NN 31417 791 30 of of IN 31417 791 31 the the DT 31417 791 32 room room NN 31417 791 33 was be VBD 31417 791 34 perceptibly perceptibly RB 31417 791 35 lowered lower VBN 31417 791 36 . . . 31417 792 1 After after IN 31417 792 2 this this DT 31417 792 3 liquid liquid JJ 31417 792 4 scent scent NN 31417 792 5 was be VBD 31417 792 6 sprinkled sprinkle VBN 31417 792 7 upon upon IN 31417 792 8 us -PRON- PRP 31417 792 9 several several JJ 31417 792 10 times time NNS 31417 792 11 ; ; : 31417 792 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 792 13 appeared appear VBD 31417 792 14 to to TO 31417 792 15 come come VB 31417 792 16 from from IN 31417 792 17 the the DT 31417 792 18 top top NN 31417 792 19 of of IN 31417 792 20 the the DT 31417 792 21 room room NN 31417 792 22 , , , 31417 792 23 and and CC 31417 792 24 fell fall VBD 31417 792 25 upon upon IN 31417 792 26 us -PRON- PRP 31417 792 27 in in IN 31417 792 28 small small JJ 31417 792 29 drops drop NNS 31417 792 30 . . . 31417 793 1 Finally finally RB 31417 793 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 793 3 were be VBD 31417 793 4 told tell VBN 31417 793 5 that that IN 31417 793 6 a a DT 31417 793 7 new new JJ 31417 793 8 manifestation manifestation NN 31417 793 9 would would MD 31417 793 10 be be VB 31417 793 11 attempted attempt VBN 31417 793 12 , , , 31417 793 13 and and CC 31417 793 14 that that IN 31417 793 15 we -PRON- PRP 31417 793 16 were be VBD 31417 793 17 to to TO 31417 793 18 prepare prepare VB 31417 793 19 for for IN 31417 793 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 793 21 by by IN 31417 793 22 joining join VBG 31417 793 23 hands hand NNS 31417 793 24 and and CC 31417 793 25 holding hold VBG 31417 793 26 the the DT 31417 793 27 palms palm NNS 31417 793 28 upwards upwards RB 31417 793 29 . . . 31417 794 1 In in IN 31417 794 2 this this DT 31417 794 3 position position NN 31417 794 4 we -PRON- PRP 31417 794 5 waited wait VBD 31417 794 6 for for IN 31417 794 7 two two CD 31417 794 8 or or CC 31417 794 9 three three CD 31417 794 10 minutes minute NNS 31417 794 11 , , , 31417 794 12 and and CC 31417 794 13 then then RB 31417 794 14 I -PRON- PRP 31417 794 15 felt feel VBD 31417 794 16 a a DT 31417 794 17 stream stream NN 31417 794 18 of of IN 31417 794 19 liquid liquid JJ 31417 794 20 scent scent NN 31417 794 21 poured pour VBD 31417 794 22 out out RP 31417 794 23 , , , 31417 794 24 as as IN 31417 794 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 794 26 were be VBD 31417 794 27 from from IN 31417 794 28 the the DT 31417 794 29 spout spout NN 31417 794 30 of of IN 31417 794 31 a a DT 31417 794 32 teapot teapot NN 31417 794 33 , , , 31417 794 34 which which WDT 31417 794 35 fell fall VBD 31417 794 36 on on IN 31417 794 37 one one CD 31417 794 38 side side NN 31417 794 39 of of IN 31417 794 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 794 41 left left JJ 31417 794 42 hand hand NN 31417 794 43 , , , 31417 794 44 and and CC 31417 794 45 ran run VBD 31417 794 46 down down RP 31417 794 47 upon upon IN 31417 794 48 the the DT 31417 794 49 table table NN 31417 794 50 . . . 31417 795 1 The the DT 31417 795 2 same same JJ 31417 795 3 was be VBD 31417 795 4 done do VBN 31417 795 5 for for IN 31417 795 6 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 795 7 Speer Speer NNP 31417 795 8 ; ; : 31417 795 9 and and CC 31417 795 10 to to TO 31417 795 11 judge judge VB 31417 795 12 from from IN 31417 795 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 795 14 impressions impression NNS 31417 795 15 at at IN 31417 795 16 the the DT 31417 795 17 time time NN 31417 795 18 , , , 31417 795 19 and and CC 31417 795 20 from from IN 31417 795 21 the the DT 31417 795 22 stains stain NNS 31417 795 23 on on IN 31417 795 24 the the DT 31417 795 25 table table NN 31417 795 26 , , , 31417 795 27 a a DT 31417 795 28 very very RB 31417 795 29 considerable considerable JJ 31417 795 30 quantity quantity NN 31417 795 31 must must MD 31417 795 32 have have VB 31417 795 33 been be VBN 31417 795 34 produced produce VBN 31417 795 35 . . . 31417 796 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 796 2 may may MD 31417 796 3 remark remark VB 31417 796 4 in in IN 31417 796 5 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 796 6 that that IN 31417 796 7 there there EX 31417 796 8 was be VBD 31417 796 9 no no DT 31417 796 10 scent scent NN 31417 796 11 in in IN 31417 796 12 the the DT 31417 796 13 room room NN 31417 796 14 before before IN 31417 796 15 the the DT 31417 796 16 seance seance NN 31417 796 17 , , , 31417 796 18 and and CC 31417 796 19 that that IN 31417 796 20 we -PRON- PRP 31417 796 21 could could MD 31417 796 22 distinguish distinguish VB 31417 796 23 several several JJ 31417 796 24 different different JJ 31417 796 25 perfumes perfume NNS 31417 796 26 which which WDT 31417 796 27 made make VBD 31417 796 28 the the DT 31417 796 29 atmosphere atmosphere NN 31417 796 30 so so RB 31417 796 31 oppressive oppressive JJ 31417 796 32 that that IN 31417 796 33 we -PRON- PRP 31417 796 34 were be VBD 31417 796 35 glad glad JJ 31417 796 36 to to TO 31417 796 37 seek seek VB 31417 796 38 a a DT 31417 796 39 purer purer NN 31417 796 40 air air NN 31417 796 41 so so RB 31417 796 42 soon soon RB 31417 796 43 as as IN 31417 796 44 the the DT 31417 796 45 seance seance NN 31417 796 46 came come VBD 31417 796 47 to to IN 31417 796 48 an an DT 31417 796 49 end end NN 31417 796 50 . . . 31417 797 1 " " `` 31417 797 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 797 3 52 52 CD 31417 797 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 797 5 LIGHTS LIGHTS NNP 31417 797 6 WITHOUT without IN 31417 797 7 APPARENT APPARENT NNP 31417 797 8 PHYSICAL PHYSICAL NNS 31417 797 9 CAUSE cause NN 31417 797 10 . . . 31417 798 1 The the DT 31417 798 2 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 798 3 of of IN 31417 798 4 Light Light NNP 31417 798 5 without without IN 31417 798 6 any any DT 31417 798 7 apparent apparent JJ 31417 798 8 physical physical JJ 31417 798 9 cause cause NN 31417 798 10 was be VBD 31417 798 11 a a DT 31417 798 12 frequent frequent JJ 31417 798 13 one one NN 31417 798 14 with with IN 31417 798 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 798 16 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 798 17 Moses Moses NNP 31417 798 18 , , , 31417 798 19 and and CC 31417 798 20 the the DT 31417 798 21 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 798 22 were be VBD 31417 798 23 of of IN 31417 798 24 a a DT 31417 798 25 very very RB 31417 798 26 varied varied JJ 31417 798 27 character character NN 31417 798 28 . . . 31417 799 1 Several several JJ 31417 799 2 of of IN 31417 799 3 these these DT 31417 799 4 were be VBD 31417 799 5 described describe VBN 31417 799 6 in in IN 31417 799 7 Chapter Chapter NNP 31417 799 8 IV IV NNP 31417 799 9 . . . 31417 800 1 An an DT 31417 800 2 account account NN 31417 800 3 is be VBZ 31417 800 4 now now RB 31417 800 5 given give VBN 31417 800 6 of of IN 31417 800 7 some some DT 31417 800 8 remarkable remarkable JJ 31417 800 9 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 800 10 which which WDT 31417 800 11 occurred occur VBD 31417 800 12 at at IN 31417 800 13 four four CD 31417 800 14 consecutive consecutive JJ 31417 800 15 seances seance NNS 31417 800 16 on on IN 31417 800 17 the the DT 31417 800 18 9th 9th JJ 31417 800 19 , , , 31417 800 20 10th 10th JJ 31417 800 21 , , , 31417 800 22 11th 11th JJ 31417 800 23 , , , 31417 800 24 and and CC 31417 800 25 12th 12th NN 31417 800 26 of of IN 31417 800 27 August August NNP 31417 800 28 1873 1873 CD 31417 800 29 . . . 31417 801 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 801 2 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 801 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 801 4 was be VBD 31417 801 5 on on IN 31417 801 6 a a DT 31417 801 7 holiday holiday NN 31417 801 8 excursion excursion NN 31417 801 9 with with IN 31417 801 10 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 801 11 and and CC 31417 801 12 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 801 13 Speer Speer NNP 31417 801 14 in in IN 31417 801 15 the the DT 31417 801 16 North North NNP 31417 801 17 of of IN 31417 801 18 Ireland Ireland NNP 31417 801 19 . . . 31417 802 1 The the DT 31417 802 2 days day NNS 31417 802 3 were be VBD 31417 802 4 spent spend VBN 31417 802 5 in in IN 31417 802 6 orthodox orthodox NNP 31417 802 7 holiday holiday NN 31417 802 8 fashion fashion NN 31417 802 9 . . . 31417 803 1 The the DT 31417 803 2 following follow VBG 31417 803 3 is be VBZ 31417 803 4 condensed condense VBN 31417 803 5 from from IN 31417 803 6 notes note NNS 31417 803 7 written write VBN 31417 803 8 in in IN 31417 803 9 detail detail NN 31417 803 10 at at IN 31417 803 11 the the DT 31417 803 12 time time NN 31417 803 13 by by IN 31417 803 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 803 15 Speer:-- Speer:-- NNP 31417 803 16 On on IN 31417 803 17 the the DT 31417 803 18 10th 10th NN 31417 803 19 of of IN 31417 803 20 August August NNP 31417 803 21 , , , 31417 803 22 after after IN 31417 803 23 some some DT 31417 803 24 other other JJ 31417 803 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 803 26 had have VBD 31417 803 27 occurred occur VBN 31417 803 28 , , , 31417 803 29 a a DT 31417 803 30 large large JJ 31417 803 31 globe globe NN 31417 803 32 of of IN 31417 803 33 light light NN 31417 803 34 rose rise VBD 31417 803 35 opposite opposite RB 31417 803 36 to to IN 31417 803 37 me -PRON- PRP 31417 803 38 , , , 31417 803 39 sailed sail VBD 31417 803 40 up up RP 31417 803 41 to to IN 31417 803 42 the the DT 31417 803 43 level level NN 31417 803 44 of of IN 31417 803 45 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 803 46 faces face NNS 31417 803 47 , , , 31417 803 48 and and CC 31417 803 49 then then RB 31417 803 50 vanished vanish VBD 31417 803 51 . . . 31417 804 1 Several several JJ 31417 804 2 more more RBR 31417 804 3 followed followed JJ 31417 804 4 . . . 31417 805 1 By by IN 31417 805 2 request request NN 31417 805 3 one one CD 31417 805 4 was be VBD 31417 805 5 placed place VBN 31417 805 6 in in IN 31417 805 7 the the DT 31417 805 8 centre centre NN 31417 805 9 of of IN 31417 805 10 the the DT 31417 805 11 table table NN 31417 805 12 . . . 31417 806 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 806 2 was be VBD 31417 806 3 surrounded surround VBN 31417 806 4 with with IN 31417 806 5 drapery drapery NN 31417 806 6 . . . 31417 807 1 A a DT 31417 807 2 light light NN 31417 807 3 came come VBD 31417 807 4 and and CC 31417 807 5 stood stand VBD 31417 807 6 on on IN 31417 807 7 the the DT 31417 807 8 table table NN 31417 807 9 close close JJ 31417 807 10 to to IN 31417 807 11 me -PRON- PRP 31417 807 12 . . . 31417 808 1 " " `` 31417 808 2 Now now RB 31417 808 3 I -PRON- PRP 31417 808 4 will will MD 31417 808 5 show show VB 31417 808 6 you -PRON- PRP 31417 808 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 808 8 hand hand NN 31417 808 9 " " '' 31417 808 10 was be VBD 31417 808 11 rapped rap VBN 31417 808 12 out out RP 31417 808 13 . . . 31417 809 1 A a DT 31417 809 2 large large JJ 31417 809 3 very very RB 31417 809 4 bright bright JJ 31417 809 5 light light NN 31417 809 6 then then RB 31417 809 7 came come VBD 31417 809 8 up up RP 31417 809 9 , , , 31417 809 10 and and CC 31417 809 11 inside inside RB 31417 809 12 of of IN 31417 809 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 809 14 appeared appear VBD 31417 809 15 the the DT 31417 809 16 materialised materialised JJ 31417 809 17 hand hand NN 31417 809 18 of of IN 31417 809 19 the the DT 31417 809 20 spirit spirit NNP 31417 809 21 . . . 31417 810 1 The the DT 31417 810 2 fingers finger NNS 31417 810 3 moved move VBD 31417 810 4 about about RB 31417 810 5 close close RB 31417 810 6 to to IN 31417 810 7 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 810 8 face face NN 31417 810 9 ; ; : 31417 810 10 the the DT 31417 810 11 appearance appearance NN 31417 810 12 was be VBD 31417 810 13 as as RB 31417 810 14 distinct distinct JJ 31417 810 15 as as IN 31417 810 16 can can MD 31417 810 17 be be VB 31417 810 18 conceived conceive VBN 31417 810 19 . . . 31417 811 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 811 2 was be VBD 31417 811 3 told tell VBN 31417 811 4 to to TO 31417 811 5 write write VB 31417 811 6 an an DT 31417 811 7 exact exact JJ 31417 811 8 account account NN 31417 811 9 of of IN 31417 811 10 what what WP 31417 811 11 had have VBD 31417 811 12 been be VBN 31417 811 13 done do VBN 31417 811 14 . . . 31417 812 1 The the DT 31417 812 2 next next JJ 31417 812 3 evening evening NN 31417 812 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 812 5 placed place VBD 31417 812 6 the the DT 31417 812 7 account account NN 31417 812 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 812 9 had have VBD 31417 812 10 written write VBN 31417 812 11 and and CC 31417 812 12 a a DT 31417 812 13 pencil pencil NN 31417 812 14 on on IN 31417 812 15 the the DT 31417 812 16 table table NN 31417 812 17 , , , 31417 812 18 and and CC 31417 812 19 asked ask VBD 31417 812 20 that that IN 31417 812 21 the the DT 31417 812 22 light light NN 31417 812 23 might may MD 31417 812 24 be be VB 31417 812 25 brought bring VBN 31417 812 26 down down RP 31417 812 27 upon upon IN 31417 812 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 812 29 . . . 31417 813 1 This this DT 31417 813 2 was be VBD 31417 813 3 done do VBN 31417 813 4 . . . 31417 814 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 814 2 then then RB 31417 814 3 asked ask VBD 31417 814 4 that that IN 31417 814 5 if if IN 31417 814 6 possible possible JJ 31417 814 7 the the DT 31417 814 8 spirit spirit NNP 31417 814 9 would would MD 31417 814 10 append append VB 31417 814 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 814 12 signature signature NN 31417 814 13 . . . 31417 815 1 The the DT 31417 815 2 spirit spirit NN 31417 815 3 said say VBD 31417 815 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 815 5 would would MD 31417 815 6 try try VB 31417 815 7 . . . 31417 816 1 After after IN 31417 816 2 other other JJ 31417 816 3 lights light NNS 31417 816 4 had have VBD 31417 816 5 been be VBN 31417 816 6 produced produce VBN 31417 816 7 , , , 31417 816 8 the the DT 31417 816 9 hand hand NN 31417 816 10 appeared appear VBD 31417 816 11 outside outside IN 31417 816 12 the the DT 31417 816 13 drapery drapery NN 31417 816 14 , , , 31417 816 15 I -PRON- PRP 31417 816 16 heard hear VBD 31417 816 17 the the DT 31417 816 18 pencil pencil NN 31417 816 19 moving move VBG 31417 816 20 , , , 31417 816 21 and and CC 31417 816 22 repeating repeat VBG 31417 816 23 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 816 24 instruction instruction NN 31417 816 25 of of IN 31417 816 26 the the DT 31417 816 27 previous previous JJ 31417 816 28 evening evening NN 31417 816 29 , , , 31417 816 30 he -PRON- PRP 31417 816 31 departed depart VBD 31417 816 32 , , , 31417 816 33 leaving leave VBG 31417 816 34 on on IN 31417 816 35 the the DT 31417 816 36 paper paper NN 31417 816 37 a a DT 31417 816 38 specimen speciman NNS 31417 816 39 of of IN 31417 816 40 direct direct JJ 31417 816 41 spirit spirit NN 31417 816 42 caligraphy caligraphy NN 31417 816 43 . . . 31417 817 1 On on IN 31417 817 2 these these DT 31417 817 3 two two CD 31417 817 4 evenings evening NNS 31417 817 5 no no DT 31417 817 6 other other JJ 31417 817 7 sitter sitter NN 31417 817 8 was be VBD 31417 817 9 present present JJ 31417 817 10 but but CC 31417 817 11 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 817 12 . . . 31417 818 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 818 2 53 53 CD 31417 818 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 818 4 DIRECT DIRECT NNP 31417 818 5 WRITING writing NN 31417 818 6 . . . 31417 819 1 As as IN 31417 819 2 has have VBZ 31417 819 3 already already RB 31417 819 4 been be VBN 31417 819 5 remarked remark VBN 31417 819 6 , , , 31417 819 7 the the DT 31417 819 8 wealth wealth NN 31417 819 9 of of IN 31417 819 10 material material NN 31417 819 11 is be VBZ 31417 819 12 so so RB 31417 819 13 great great JJ 31417 819 14 that that IN 31417 819 15 selection selection NN 31417 819 16 is be VBZ 31417 819 17 a a DT 31417 819 18 matter matter NN 31417 819 19 of of IN 31417 819 20 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 819 21 . . . 31417 820 1 There there EX 31417 820 2 is be VBZ 31417 820 3 much much RB 31417 820 4 more more JJR 31417 820 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 820 6 should should MD 31417 820 7 like like VB 31417 820 8 to to TO 31417 820 9 have have VB 31417 820 10 included include VBN 31417 820 11 in in IN 31417 820 12 this this DT 31417 820 13 chapter chapter NN 31417 820 14 , , , 31417 820 15 but but CC 31417 820 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 820 17 must must MD 31417 820 18 be be VB 31417 820 19 drawn draw VBN 31417 820 20 to to IN 31417 820 21 a a DT 31417 820 22 close close NN 31417 820 23 with with IN 31417 820 24 a a DT 31417 820 25 brief brief JJ 31417 820 26 detailed detailed JJ 31417 820 27 account account NN 31417 820 28 of of IN 31417 820 29 a a DT 31417 820 30 case case NN 31417 820 31 of of IN 31417 820 32 " " `` 31417 820 33 Direct Direct NNP 31417 820 34 Writing writing NN 31417 820 35 . . . 31417 820 36 " " '' 31417 821 1 There there EX 31417 821 2 is be VBZ 31417 821 3 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 821 4 no no DT 31417 821 5 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 821 6 more more RBR 31417 821 7 incredible incredible JJ 31417 821 8 to to IN 31417 821 9 the the DT 31417 821 10 " " `` 31417 821 11 beginner beginner NN 31417 821 12 " " '' 31417 821 13 in in IN 31417 821 14 these these DT 31417 821 15 studies study NNS 31417 821 16 , , , 31417 821 17 than than IN 31417 821 18 that that DT 31417 821 19 legible legible JJ 31417 821 20 and and CC 31417 821 21 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 821 22 writing writing NN 31417 821 23 should should MD 31417 821 24 be be VB 31417 821 25 produced produce VBN 31417 821 26 without without IN 31417 821 27 human human JJ 31417 821 28 agency agency NN 31417 821 29 , , , 31417 821 30 and and CC 31417 821 31 yet yet RB 31417 821 32 there there EX 31417 821 33 seems seem VBZ 31417 821 34 no no DT 31417 821 35 other other JJ 31417 821 36 way way NN 31417 821 37 of of IN 31417 821 38 explaining explain VBG 31417 821 39 the the DT 31417 821 40 facts fact NNS 31417 821 41 . . . 31417 822 1 The the DT 31417 822 2 following follow VBG 31417 822 3 is be VBZ 31417 822 4 an an DT 31417 822 5 account account NN 31417 822 6 , , , 31417 822 7 by by IN 31417 822 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 822 9 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 822 10 Moses Moses NNP 31417 822 11 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 822 12 , , , 31417 822 13 of of IN 31417 822 14 a a DT 31417 822 15 seance seance NN 31417 822 16 held hold VBN 31417 822 17 on on IN 31417 822 18 19th 19th JJ 31417 822 19 September September NNP 31417 822 20 1872 1872 CD 31417 822 21 , , , 31417 822 22 the the DT 31417 822 23 last last JJ 31417 822 24 held hold VBN 31417 822 25 before before IN 31417 822 26 a a DT 31417 822 27 break break NN 31417 822 28 in in IN 31417 822 29 the the DT 31417 822 30 series series NN 31417 822 31 during during IN 31417 822 32 the the DT 31417 822 33 autumn autumn NN 31417 822 34 of of IN 31417 822 35 that that DT 31417 822 36 year year NN 31417 822 37 . . . 31417 823 1 " " `` 31417 823 2 Imperator imperator NN 31417 823 3 " " '' 31417 823 4 had have VBD 31417 823 5 recently recently RB 31417 823 6 announced announce VBN 31417 823 7 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 823 8 as as IN 31417 823 9 the the DT 31417 823 10 leading leading JJ 31417 823 11 guide guide NN 31417 823 12 or or CC 31417 823 13 director director NN 31417 823 14 of of IN 31417 823 15 the the DT 31417 823 16 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 823 17 . . . 31417 824 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 824 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 824 3 : : : 31417 824 4 Facsimile Facsimile NNP 31417 824 5 reduced reduce VBN 31417 824 6 from from IN 31417 824 7 original original JJ 31417 824 8 . . . 31417 825 1 The the DT 31417 825 2 paper paper NN 31417 825 3 was be VBD 31417 825 4 blue blue JJ 31417 825 5 , , , 31417 825 6 with with IN 31417 825 7 faint faint JJ 31417 825 8 blue blue JJ 31417 825 9 lines line NNS 31417 825 10 . . . 31417 826 1 The the DT 31417 826 2 corner corner NN 31417 826 3 at at IN 31417 826 4 the the DT 31417 826 5 top top JJ 31417 826 6 right right JJ 31417 826 7 hand hand NN 31417 826 8 was be VBD 31417 826 9 torn tear VBN 31417 826 10 off off RP 31417 826 11 for for IN 31417 826 12 identification identification NN 31417 826 13 of of IN 31417 826 14 the the DT 31417 826 15 paper paper NN 31417 826 16 . . . 31417 826 17 ] ] -RRB- 31417 827 1 " " `` 31417 827 2 We -PRON- PRP 31417 827 3 darkened darken VBD 31417 827 4 the the DT 31417 827 5 seance seance NN 31417 827 6 room room NN 31417 827 7 , , , 31417 827 8 leaving leave VBG 31417 827 9 the the DT 31417 827 10 gas gas NN 31417 827 11 burning burn VBG 31417 827 12 brightly brightly RB 31417 827 13 in in IN 31417 827 14 the the DT 31417 827 15 adjoining adjoining JJ 31417 827 16 dining dining NN 31417 827 17 - - HYPH 31417 827 18 room room NN 31417 827 19 . . . 31417 828 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 828 2 and and CC 31417 828 3 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 828 4 Speer Speer NNP 31417 828 5 and and CC 31417 828 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 828 7 sat sit VBD 31417 828 8 at at IN 31417 828 9 the the DT 31417 828 10 table table NN 31417 828 11 . . . 31417 829 1 On on IN 31417 829 2 the the DT 31417 829 3 floor floor NN 31417 829 4 under under IN 31417 829 5 the the DT 31417 829 6 table table NN 31417 829 7 we -PRON- PRP 31417 829 8 put put VBP 31417 829 9 a a DT 31417 829 10 piece piece NN 31417 829 11 of of IN 31417 829 12 ruled rule VBN 31417 829 13 paper paper NN 31417 829 14 and and CC 31417 829 15 a a DT 31417 829 16 pencil pencil NN 31417 829 17 . . . 31417 830 1 A a DT 31417 830 2 corner corner NN 31417 830 3 of of IN 31417 830 4 the the DT 31417 830 5 paper paper NN 31417 830 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 830 7 tore tear VBD 31417 830 8 off off RP 31417 830 9 , , , 31417 830 10 and and CC 31417 830 11 handed hand VBD 31417 830 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 830 13 to to IN 31417 830 14 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 830 15 Speer Speer NNP 31417 830 16 to to TO 31417 830 17 identify identify VB 31417 830 18 the the DT 31417 830 19 sheet sheet NN 31417 830 20 of of IN 31417 830 21 paper paper NN 31417 830 22 if if IN 31417 830 23 necessary necessary JJ 31417 830 24 . . . 31417 831 1 Various various JJ 31417 831 2 raps rap NNS 31417 831 3 , , , 31417 831 4 some some DT 31417 831 5 objects object NNS 31417 831 6 brought bring VBN 31417 831 7 in in RP 31417 831 8 , , , 31417 831 9 and and CC 31417 831 10 a a DT 31417 831 11 noise noise NN 31417 831 12 rather rather RB 31417 831 13 like like IN 31417 831 14 sawing saw VBG 31417 831 15 wood wood NN 31417 831 16 . . . 31417 832 1 When when WRB 31417 832 2 light light NN 31417 832 3 was be VBD 31417 832 4 called call VBN 31417 832 5 for for IN 31417 832 6 , , , 31417 832 7 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 832 8 Speer Speer NNP 31417 832 9 stooped stoop VBD 31417 832 10 down down RP 31417 832 11 and and CC 31417 832 12 picked pick VBD 31417 832 13 up up RP 31417 832 14 the the DT 31417 832 15 paper paper NN 31417 832 16 . . . 31417 833 1 The the DT 31417 833 2 upper upper JJ 31417 833 3 surface surface NN 31417 833 4 was be VBD 31417 833 5 blank blank JJ 31417 833 6 . . . 31417 834 1 Her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 834 2 endorsement endorsement NN 31417 834 3 on on IN 31417 834 4 the the DT 31417 834 5 back back NN 31417 834 6 of of IN 31417 834 7 the the DT 31417 834 8 paper paper NN 31417 834 9 , , , 31417 834 10 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 834 11 written write VBN 31417 834 12 , , , 31417 834 13 reads read VBZ 31417 834 14 : : : 31417 834 15 ' ' `` 31417 834 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 834 17 took take VBD 31417 834 18 the the DT 31417 834 19 paper paper NN 31417 834 20 from from IN 31417 834 21 under under IN 31417 834 22 the the DT 31417 834 23 table table NN 31417 834 24 with with IN 31417 834 25 the the DT 31417 834 26 writing writing NN 31417 834 27 downwards downwards RB 31417 834 28 , , , 31417 834 29 ' ' '' 31417 834 30 _ _ NNP 31417 834 31 i.e. i.e. FW 31417 834 32 _ _ NNP 31417 834 33 on on IN 31417 834 34 the the DT 31417 834 35 surface surface NN 31417 834 36 touching touch VBG 31417 834 37 the the DT 31417 834 38 carpet carpet NN 31417 834 39 . . . 31417 835 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 835 2 Speer Speer NNP 31417 835 3 and and CC 31417 835 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 835 5 wrote write VBD 31417 835 6 and and CC 31417 835 7 signed sign VBD 31417 835 8 this this DT 31417 835 9 endorsement endorsement NN 31417 835 10 : : : 31417 835 11 ' ' '' 31417 835 12 The the DT 31417 835 13 above above JJ 31417 835 14 corner corner NN 31417 835 15 was be VBD 31417 835 16 torn tear VBN 31417 835 17 by by IN 31417 835 18 me -PRON- PRP 31417 835 19 ( ( -LRB- 31417 835 20 S. S. NNP 31417 835 21 M. M. NNP 31417 835 22 ) ) -RRB- 31417 835 23 before before IN 31417 835 24 the the DT 31417 835 25 light light NN 31417 835 26 was be VBD 31417 835 27 put put VBN 31417 835 28 out out RP 31417 835 29 , , , 31417 835 30 and and CC 31417 835 31 was be VBD 31417 835 32 given give VBN 31417 835 33 to to IN 31417 835 34 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 835 35 S. S. NNP 31417 835 36 ' ' '' 31417 835 37 I -PRON- PRP 31417 835 38 ( ( -LRB- 31417 835 39 S. S. NNP 31417 835 40 M. M. NNP 31417 835 41 ) ) -RRB- 31417 835 42 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 835 43 put put VBD 31417 835 44 the the DT 31417 835 45 two two CD 31417 835 46 pieces piece NNS 31417 835 47 together together RB 31417 835 48 . . . 31417 836 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 836 2 fit fit VBP 31417 836 3 exactly exactly RB 31417 836 4 , , , 31417 836 5 and and CC 31417 836 6 are be VBP 31417 836 7 secured secure VBN 31417 836 8 by by IN 31417 836 9 a a DT 31417 836 10 couple couple NN 31417 836 11 of of IN 31417 836 12 halfpenny halfpenny JJ 31417 836 13 stamps stamp NNS 31417 836 14 , , , 31417 836 15 with with IN 31417 836 16 the the DT 31417 836 17 initials initial NNS 31417 836 18 of of IN 31417 836 19 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 836 20 S. S. NNP 31417 836 21 and and CC 31417 836 22 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 836 23 upon upon IN 31417 836 24 them -PRON- PRP 31417 836 25 . . . 31417 837 1 The the DT 31417 837 2 message message NN 31417 837 3 follows follow VBZ 31417 837 4 the the DT 31417 837 5 rules rule NNS 31417 837 6 exactly exactly RB 31417 837 7 . . . 31417 838 1 A a DT 31417 838 2 facsimile facsimile NN 31417 838 3 is be VBZ 31417 838 4 appended append VBN 31417 838 5 , , , 31417 838 6 omitting omit VBG 31417 838 7 only only RB 31417 838 8 the the DT 31417 838 9 initials initial NNS 31417 838 10 of of IN 31417 838 11 a a DT 31417 838 12 deceased deceased JJ 31417 838 13 friend friend NN 31417 838 14 . . . 31417 839 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 839 2 will will MD 31417 839 3 be be VB 31417 839 4 noticed notice VBN 31417 839 5 that that IN 31417 839 6 the the DT 31417 839 7 writing writing NN 31417 839 8 is be VBZ 31417 839 9 clearly clearly RB 31417 839 10 and and CC 31417 839 11 laboriously laboriously RB 31417 839 12 executed execute VBN 31417 839 13 on on IN 31417 839 14 the the DT 31417 839 15 ruled rule VBN 31417 839 16 lines line NNS 31417 839 17 . . . 31417 840 1 In in IN 31417 840 2 no no DT 31417 840 3 case case NN 31417 840 4 are be VBP 31417 840 5 the the DT 31417 840 6 lines line NNS 31417 840 7 deserted desert VBN 31417 840 8 . . . 31417 841 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 841 2 fancy fancy VBP 31417 841 3 the the DT 31417 841 4 message message NN 31417 841 5 is be VBZ 31417 841 6 written write VBN 31417 841 7 backwards backwards RB 31417 841 8 . . . 31417 842 1 Imperator imperator NN 31417 842 2 's 's POS 31417 842 3 signature signature NN 31417 842 4 is be VBZ 31417 842 5 of of IN 31417 842 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 842 7 usual usual JJ 31417 842 8 decided decide VBN 31417 842 9 type type NN 31417 842 10 , , , 31417 842 11 very very RB 31417 842 12 like like IN 31417 842 13 what what WP 31417 842 14 is be VBZ 31417 842 15 automatically automatically RB 31417 842 16 written write VBN 31417 842 17 by by IN 31417 842 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 842 19 hand hand NN 31417 842 20 . . . 31417 843 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 843 2 suspect suspect VBP 31417 843 3 that that IN 31417 843 4 the the DT 31417 843 5 message message NN 31417 843 6 was be VBD 31417 843 7 written write VBN 31417 843 8 by by IN 31417 843 9 two two CD 31417 843 10 hands hand NNS 31417 843 11 . . . 31417 844 1 " " `` 31417 844 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 844 3 54 54 CD 31417 844 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 844 5 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 844 6 : : : 31417 844 7 [ [ -LRB- 31417 844 8 39 39 CD 31417 844 9 ] ] -RRB- 31417 844 10 _ _ NNP 31417 844 11 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 844 12 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 844 13 _ _ NNP 31417 844 14 , , , 31417 844 15 vol vol NNP 31417 844 16 . . . 31417 845 1 ix ix IN 31417 845 2 . . . 31417 846 1 pp pp NNP 31417 846 2 . . . 31417 847 1 245 245 CD 31417 847 2 - - SYM 31417 847 3 352 352 CD 31417 847 4 , , , 31417 847 5 and and CC 31417 847 6 vol vol NNP 31417 847 7 . . . 31417 848 1 xi xi NNP 31417 848 2 . . . 31417 849 1 pp pp NNP 31417 849 2 . . . 31417 850 1 24 24 CD 31417 850 2 - - SYM 31417 850 3 113 113 CD 31417 850 4 . . . 31417 851 1 Reference reference NN 31417 851 2 should should MD 31417 851 3 also also RB 31417 851 4 be be VB 31417 851 5 made make VBN 31417 851 6 to to IN 31417 851 7 an an DT 31417 851 8 obituary obituary JJ 31417 851 9 notice notice NN 31417 851 10 of of IN 31417 851 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 851 12 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 851 13 Moses Moses NNP 31417 851 14 by by IN 31417 851 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 851 16 Myers Myers NNP 31417 851 17 , , , 31417 851 18 in in IN 31417 851 19 _ _ NNP 31417 851 20 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 851 21 _ _ NNP 31417 851 22 , , , 31417 851 23 vol vol NNP 31417 851 24 . . . 31417 852 1 viii viii RB 31417 852 2 . . . 31417 853 1 pp pp NNP 31417 853 2 . . . 31417 854 1 597 597 CD 31417 854 2 - - SYM 31417 854 3 601 601 CD 31417 854 4 . . . 31417 855 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 855 2 40 40 CD 31417 855 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 855 4 _ _ NNP 31417 855 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 855 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 855 7 _ _ NNP 31417 855 8 , , , 31417 855 9 vol vol NNP 31417 855 10 . . . 31417 856 1 ix ix IN 31417 856 2 . . . 31417 857 1 pp pp NNP 31417 857 2 . . . 31417 858 1 247 247 CD 31417 858 2 - - SYM 31417 858 3 248 248 CD 31417 858 4 . . . 31417 859 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 859 2 41 41 CD 31417 859 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 859 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 859 5 . . . 31417 859 6 , , , 31417 859 7 p. p. NN 31417 859 8 248 248 CD 31417 859 9 . . . 31417 860 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 860 2 42 42 CD 31417 860 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 860 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 860 5 . . . 31417 860 6 , , , 31417 860 7 p. p. NN 31417 860 8 247 247 CD 31417 860 9 . . . 31417 861 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 861 2 43 43 CD 31417 861 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 861 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 861 5 . . . 31417 861 6 , , , 31417 861 7 p. p. NN 31417 861 8 247 247 CD 31417 861 9 . . . 31417 862 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 862 2 44 44 CD 31417 862 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 862 4 _ _ NNP 31417 862 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 862 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 862 7 _ _ NNP 31417 862 8 , , , 31417 862 9 vol vol NNP 31417 862 10 . . . 31417 863 1 ix ix IN 31417 863 2 . . . 31417 864 1 p. p. NN 31417 864 2 247 247 CD 31417 864 3 . . . 31417 865 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 865 2 45 45 CD 31417 865 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 865 4 _ _ NNP 31417 865 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 865 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 865 7 _ _ NNP 31417 865 8 , , , 31417 865 9 vol vol NNP 31417 865 10 . . . 31417 866 1 ix ix IN 31417 866 2 . . . 31417 867 1 p. p. NN 31417 867 2 252 252 CD 31417 867 3 . . . 31417 868 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 868 2 46 46 CD 31417 868 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 868 4 _ _ NNP 31417 868 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 868 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 868 7 _ _ NNP 31417 868 8 , , , 31417 868 9 vol vol NNP 31417 868 10 . . . 31417 869 1 ix ix IN 31417 869 2 . . . 31417 870 1 p. p. NN 31417 870 2 259 259 CD 31417 870 3 . . . 31417 871 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 871 2 47 47 CD 31417 871 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 871 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 871 5 . . . 31417 872 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 872 2 48 48 CD 31417 872 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 872 4 _ _ NNP 31417 872 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 872 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 872 7 _ _ NNP 31417 872 8 , , , 31417 872 9 vol vol NNP 31417 872 10 . . . 31417 873 1 ix ix IN 31417 873 2 . . . 31417 874 1 pp pp NNP 31417 874 2 . . . 31417 875 1 259 259 CD 31417 875 2 - - SYM 31417 875 3 260 260 CD 31417 875 4 . . . 31417 876 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 876 2 49 49 CD 31417 876 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 876 4 _ _ NNP 31417 876 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 876 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 876 7 _ _ NNP 31417 876 8 , , , 31417 876 9 vol vol NNP 31417 876 10 . . . 31417 877 1 ix ix IN 31417 877 2 . . . 31417 878 1 p. p. NN 31417 878 2 261 261 CD 31417 878 3 . . . 31417 879 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 879 2 50 50 CD 31417 879 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 879 4 See See NNP 31417 879 5 _ _ NNP 31417 879 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 879 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 879 8 _ _ NNP 31417 879 9 , , , 31417 879 10 vol vol NNP 31417 879 11 . . . 31417 880 1 ix ix IN 31417 880 2 . . . 31417 881 1 pp pp NNP 31417 881 2 . . . 31417 882 1 263 263 CD 31417 882 2 - - SYM 31417 882 3 266 266 CD 31417 882 4 . . . 31417 883 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 883 2 51 51 CD 31417 883 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 883 4 See See NNP 31417 883 5 _ _ NNP 31417 883 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 883 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 883 8 _ _ NNP 31417 883 9 , , , 31417 883 10 vol vol NNP 31417 883 11 . . . 31417 884 1 ix ix IN 31417 884 2 . . . 31417 885 1 pp pp NNP 31417 885 2 . . . 31417 886 1 266 266 CD 31417 886 2 - - SYM 31417 886 3 267 267 CD 31417 886 4 . . . 31417 887 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 887 2 52 52 CD 31417 887 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 887 4 _ _ NNP 31417 887 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 887 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 887 7 _ _ NNP 31417 887 8 , , , 31417 887 9 vol vol NNP 31417 887 10 . . . 31417 888 1 ix ix IN 31417 888 2 . . . 31417 889 1 pp pp NNP 31417 889 2 . . . 31417 890 1 267 267 CD 31417 890 2 - - SYM 31417 890 3 273 273 CD 31417 890 4 . . . 31417 891 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 891 2 53 53 CD 31417 891 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 891 4 _ _ NNP 31417 891 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 891 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 891 7 _ _ NNP 31417 891 8 , , , 31417 891 9 vol vol NNP 31417 891 10 . . . 31417 892 1 ix ix IN 31417 892 2 . . . 31417 893 1 pp pp NNP 31417 893 2 . . . 31417 894 1 274 274 CD 31417 894 2 - - HYPH 31417 894 3 276 276 CD 31417 894 4 . . . 31417 895 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 895 2 54 54 CD 31417 895 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 895 4 _ _ NNP 31417 895 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 895 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 895 7 _ _ NNP 31417 895 8 , , , 31417 895 9 vol vol NNP 31417 895 10 . . . 31417 896 1 ix ix IN 31417 896 2 . . . 31417 897 1 pp pp NNP 31417 897 2 . . . 31417 898 1 284 284 CD 31417 898 2 - - SYM 31417 898 3 286 286 CD 31417 898 4 . . . 31417 899 1 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 899 2 VII VII NNP 31417 899 3 " " `` 31417 899 4 THE THE NNP 31417 899 5 DIVINING divining NN 31417 899 6 ROD ROD VBZ 31417 899 7 " " `` 31417 899 8 The the DT 31417 899 9 reality reality NN 31417 899 10 or or CC 31417 899 11 otherwise otherwise RB 31417 899 12 of of IN 31417 899 13 the the DT 31417 899 14 pretensions pretension NNS 31417 899 15 of of IN 31417 899 16 the the DT 31417 899 17 " " `` 31417 899 18 Divining Divining NNP 31417 899 19 Rod Rod NNP 31417 899 20 " " '' 31417 899 21 come come VBP 31417 899 22 legitimately legitimately RB 31417 899 23 within within IN 31417 899 24 the the DT 31417 899 25 scope scope NN 31417 899 26 of of IN 31417 899 27 the the DT 31417 899 28 present present JJ 31417 899 29 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 899 30 . . . 31417 900 1 The the DT 31417 900 2 physical physical JJ 31417 900 3 results result NNS 31417 900 4 which which WDT 31417 900 5 , , , 31417 900 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 900 7 is be VBZ 31417 900 8 alleged allege VBN 31417 900 9 , , , 31417 900 10 follow follow VB 31417 900 11 the the DT 31417 900 12 use use NN 31417 900 13 of of IN 31417 900 14 the the DT 31417 900 15 " " `` 31417 900 16 Divining divining NN 31417 900 17 " " '' 31417 900 18 or or CC 31417 900 19 " " `` 31417 900 20 Dowsing dowse VBG 31417 900 21 " " '' 31417 900 22 Rod Rod NNP 31417 900 23 in in IN 31417 900 24 certain certain JJ 31417 900 25 hands hand NNS 31417 900 26 are be VBP 31417 900 27 unexplained unexplained JJ 31417 900 28 by by IN 31417 900 29 recognised recognise VBN 31417 900 30 physical physical JJ 31417 900 31 science science NN 31417 900 32 . . . 31417 901 1 The the DT 31417 901 2 main main JJ 31417 901 3 fact fact NN 31417 901 4 of of IN 31417 901 5 the the DT 31417 901 6 success success NN 31417 901 7 of of IN 31417 901 8 the the DT 31417 901 9 Rod Rod NNP 31417 901 10 , , , 31417 901 11 as as IN 31417 901 12 a a DT 31417 901 13 means means NN 31417 901 14 of of IN 31417 901 15 finding find VBG 31417 901 16 water water NN 31417 901 17 where where WRB 31417 901 18 all all DT 31417 901 19 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 901 20 methods method NNS 31417 901 21 have have VBP 31417 901 22 failed fail VBN 31417 901 23 , , , 31417 901 24 is be VBZ 31417 901 25 , , , 31417 901 26 however however RB 31417 901 27 , , , 31417 901 28 so so RB 31417 901 29 widely widely RB 31417 901 30 acknowledged acknowledge VBN 31417 901 31 among among IN 31417 901 32 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 901 33 persons person NNS 31417 901 34 , , , 31417 901 35 including include VBG 31417 901 36 many many JJ 31417 901 37 business business NN 31417 901 38 men man NNS 31417 901 39 , , , 31417 901 40 that that IN 31417 901 41 it -PRON- PRP 31417 901 42 will will MD 31417 901 43 be be VB 31417 901 44 unnecessary unnecessary JJ 31417 901 45 to to TO 31417 901 46 devote devote VB 31417 901 47 much much JJ 31417 901 48 space space NN 31417 901 49 to to IN 31417 901 50 this this DT 31417 901 51 chapter chapter NN 31417 901 52 . . . 31417 902 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 902 2 shall shall MD 31417 902 3 not not RB 31417 902 4 do do VB 31417 902 5 more more JJR 31417 902 6 than than IN 31417 902 7 briefly briefly RB 31417 902 8 refer refer VB 31417 902 9 to to IN 31417 902 10 the the DT 31417 902 11 scientific scientific JJ 31417 902 12 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 902 13 into into IN 31417 902 14 the the DT 31417 902 15 whole whole JJ 31417 902 16 subject subject NN 31417 902 17 which which WDT 31417 902 18 has have VBZ 31417 902 19 been be VBN 31417 902 20 made make VBN 31417 902 21 in in IN 31417 902 22 recent recent JJ 31417 902 23 years year NNS 31417 902 24 , , , 31417 902 25 and and CC 31417 902 26 quote quote VB 31417 902 27 a a DT 31417 902 28 few few JJ 31417 902 29 cases case NNS 31417 902 30 where where WRB 31417 902 31 success success NN 31417 902 32 has have VBZ 31417 902 33 attended attend VBN 31417 902 34 the the DT 31417 902 35 use use NN 31417 902 36 of of IN 31417 902 37 the the DT 31417 902 38 Rod Rod NNP 31417 902 39 after after IN 31417 902 40 other other JJ 31417 902 41 means mean NNS 31417 902 42 had have VBD 31417 902 43 failed fail VBN 31417 902 44 . . . 31417 903 1 Here here RB 31417 903 2 again again RB 31417 903 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 903 4 are be VBP 31417 903 5 mainly mainly RB 31417 903 6 indebted indebted JJ 31417 903 7 to to IN 31417 903 8 a a DT 31417 903 9 member member NN 31417 903 10 of of IN 31417 903 11 the the DT 31417 903 12 Society Society NNP 31417 903 13 for for IN 31417 903 14 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 903 15 Research Research NNP 31417 903 16 for for IN 31417 903 17 what what WP 31417 903 18 has have VBZ 31417 903 19 been be VBN 31417 903 20 done do VBN 31417 903 21 . . . 31417 904 1 In in IN 31417 904 2 the the DT 31417 904 3 early early JJ 31417 904 4 days day NNS 31417 904 5 of of IN 31417 904 6 the the DT 31417 904 7 Society Society NNP 31417 904 8 , , , 31417 904 9 two two CD 31417 904 10 or or CC 31417 904 11 three three CD 31417 904 12 members member NNS 31417 904 13 , , , 31417 904 14 especially especially RB 31417 904 15 the the DT 31417 904 16 late late JJ 31417 904 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 904 18 E. E. NNP 31417 904 19 Vaughan Vaughan NNP 31417 904 20 Jenkins Jenkins NNP 31417 904 21 , , , 31417 904 22 of of IN 31417 904 23 Oxford Oxford NNP 31417 904 24 , , , 31417 904 25 had have VBD 31417 904 26 assiduously assiduously RB 31417 904 27 collected collect VBN 31417 904 28 the the DT 31417 904 29 best good JJS 31417 904 30 testimony testimony NN 31417 904 31 they -PRON- PRP 31417 904 32 could could MD 31417 904 33 obtain obtain VB 31417 904 34 as as IN 31417 904 35 to to IN 31417 904 36 the the DT 31417 904 37 successful successful JJ 31417 904 38 use use NN 31417 904 39 of of IN 31417 904 40 the the DT 31417 904 41 Rod Rod NNP 31417 904 42 . . . 31417 905 1 This this DT 31417 905 2 was be VBD 31417 905 3 placed place VBN 31417 905 4 at at IN 31417 905 5 the the DT 31417 905 6 disposal disposal NN 31417 905 7 of of IN 31417 905 8 the the DT 31417 905 9 Society Society NNP 31417 905 10 in in IN 31417 905 11 1884 1884 CD 31417 905 12 , , , 31417 905 13 and and CC 31417 905 14 was be VBD 31417 905 15 amply amply RB 31417 905 16 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 905 17 to to TO 31417 905 18 show show VB 31417 905 19 that that IN 31417 905 20 a a DT 31417 905 21 strong strong JJ 31417 905 22 _ _ NNP 31417 905 23 primâ primâ NN 31417 905 24 facie facie NN 31417 905 25 _ _ NNP 31417 905 26 case case NN 31417 905 27 for for IN 31417 905 28 fuller full JJR 31417 905 29 investigation investigation NN 31417 905 30 existed exist VBD 31417 905 31 . . . 31417 906 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 906 2 55 55 CD 31417 906 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 906 4 In in IN 31417 906 5 1891 1891 CD 31417 906 6 , , , 31417 906 7 at at IN 31417 906 8 the the DT 31417 906 9 request request NN 31417 906 10 of of IN 31417 906 11 the the DT 31417 906 12 Council Council NNP 31417 906 13 of of IN 31417 906 14 the the DT 31417 906 15 Society Society NNP 31417 906 16 , , , 31417 906 17 Professor Professor NNP 31417 906 18 W. W. NNP 31417 906 19 F. F. NNP 31417 906 20 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 906 21 , , , 31417 906 22 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 906 23 , , , 31417 906 24 of of IN 31417 906 25 Dublin Dublin NNP 31417 906 26 , , , 31417 906 27 undertook undertake VBD 31417 906 28 to to TO 31417 906 29 submit submit VB 31417 906 30 the the DT 31417 906 31 whole whole JJ 31417 906 32 subject subject NN 31417 906 33 to to IN 31417 906 34 a a DT 31417 906 35 thorough thorough JJ 31417 906 36 scientific scientific JJ 31417 906 37 and and CC 31417 906 38 experimental experimental JJ 31417 906 39 research research NN 31417 906 40 . . . 31417 907 1 The the DT 31417 907 2 results result NNS 31417 907 3 of of IN 31417 907 4 Professor Professor NNP 31417 907 5 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 907 6 's 's POS 31417 907 7 indefatigable indefatigable JJ 31417 907 8 industry industry NN 31417 907 9 over over IN 31417 907 10 a a DT 31417 907 11 number number NN 31417 907 12 of of IN 31417 907 13 years year NNS 31417 907 14 are be VBP 31417 907 15 embodied embody VBN 31417 907 16 in in IN 31417 907 17 two two CD 31417 907 18 lengthy lengthy JJ 31417 907 19 Reports report NNS 31417 907 20 , , , 31417 907 21 published publish VBN 31417 907 22 in in IN 31417 907 23 the the DT 31417 907 24 _ _ NNP 31417 907 25 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 907 26 _ _ NNP 31417 907 27 of of IN 31417 907 28 the the DT 31417 907 29 Society Society NNP 31417 907 30 . . . 31417 908 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 908 2 56 56 LS 31417 908 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 908 4 The the DT 31417 908 5 following follow VBG 31417 908 6 cases case NNS 31417 908 7 are be VBP 31417 908 8 quoted quote VBN 31417 908 9 from from IN 31417 908 10 Professor Professor NNP 31417 908 11 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 908 12 's 's POS 31417 908 13 records record NNS 31417 908 14 as as IN 31417 908 15 examples example NNS 31417 908 16 of of IN 31417 908 17 the the DT 31417 908 18 work work NN 31417 908 19 of of IN 31417 908 20 different different JJ 31417 908 21 professional professional JJ 31417 908 22 " " '' 31417 908 23 dowsers dowser NNS 31417 908 24 . . . 31417 908 25 " " '' 31417 909 1 I. I. NNP 31417 909 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 909 3 B. B. NNP 31417 909 4 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 909 5 , , , 31417 909 6 of of IN 31417 909 7 Pipsmore Pipsmore NNP 31417 909 8 Farm Farm NNP 31417 909 9 , , , 31417 909 10 Chippenham Chippenham NNP 31417 909 11 , , , 31417 909 12 Wilts Wilts NNP 31417 909 13 , , , 31417 909 14 was be VBD 31417 909 15 the the DT 31417 909 16 " " `` 31417 909 17 diviner diviner NN 31417 909 18 " " '' 31417 909 19 in in IN 31417 909 20 this this DT 31417 909 21 case case NN 31417 909 22 . . . 31417 910 1 Prior prior RB 31417 910 2 to to IN 31417 910 3 1890 1890 CD 31417 910 4 , , , 31417 910 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 910 6 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 910 7 was be VBD 31417 910 8 a a DT 31417 910 9 tenant tenant NN 31417 910 10 farmer farmer NN 31417 910 11 . . . 31417 911 1 Having have VBG 31417 911 2 been be VBN 31417 911 3 at at IN 31417 911 4 some some DT 31417 911 5 expense expense NN 31417 911 6 in in IN 31417 911 7 endeavouring endeavour VBG 31417 911 8 to to TO 31417 911 9 obtain obtain VB 31417 911 10 a a DT 31417 911 11 good good JJ 31417 911 12 supply supply NN 31417 911 13 of of IN 31417 911 14 water water NN 31417 911 15 for for IN 31417 911 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 911 17 cattle cattle NNS 31417 911 18 , , , 31417 911 19 without without IN 31417 911 20 success success NN 31417 911 21 , , , 31417 911 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 911 23 sent send VBD 31417 911 24 for for IN 31417 911 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 911 26 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 911 27 , , , 31417 911 28 who who WP 31417 911 29 came come VBD 31417 911 30 and and CC 31417 911 31 found find VBD 31417 911 32 a a DT 31417 911 33 spot spot NN 31417 911 34 where where WRB 31417 911 35 he -PRON- PRP 31417 911 36 said say VBD 31417 911 37 a a DT 31417 911 38 plentiful plentiful JJ 31417 911 39 supply supply NN 31417 911 40 of of IN 31417 911 41 water water NN 31417 911 42 existed exist VBD 31417 911 43 at at IN 31417 911 44 a a DT 31417 911 45 depth depth NN 31417 911 46 of of IN 31417 911 47 less less JJR 31417 911 48 than than IN 31417 911 49 30 30 CD 31417 911 50 feet foot NNS 31417 911 51 . . . 31417 912 1 A a DT 31417 912 2 well well NN 31417 912 3 was be VBD 31417 912 4 sunk sink VBN 31417 912 5 , , , 31417 912 6 and and CC 31417 912 7 at at IN 31417 912 8 15 15 CD 31417 912 9 feet foot NNS 31417 912 10 deep deep JJ 31417 912 11 a a DT 31417 912 12 strong strong JJ 31417 912 13 spring spring NN 31417 912 14 was be VBD 31417 912 15 tapped tap VBN 31417 912 16 which which WDT 31417 912 17 has have VBZ 31417 912 18 yielded yield VBN 31417 912 19 an an DT 31417 912 20 unfailing unfailing JJ 31417 912 21 supply supply NN 31417 912 22 ever ever RB 31417 912 23 since since RB 31417 912 24 . . . 31417 913 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 913 2 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 913 3 finding find VBG 31417 913 4 that that IN 31417 913 5 the the DT 31417 913 6 forked forked JJ 31417 913 7 twig twig NNP 31417 913 8 moved move VBD 31417 913 9 in in IN 31417 913 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 913 11 own own JJ 31417 913 12 hands hand NNS 31417 913 13 , , , 31417 913 14 tried try VBD 31417 913 15 some some DT 31417 913 16 experiments experiment NNS 31417 913 17 on on IN 31417 913 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 913 19 own own JJ 31417 913 20 account account NN 31417 913 21 which which WDT 31417 913 22 proved prove VBD 31417 913 23 successful successful JJ 31417 913 24 . . . 31417 914 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 914 2 was be VBD 31417 914 3 then then RB 31417 914 4 asked ask VBN 31417 914 5 by by IN 31417 914 6 Messrs. Messrs. NNP 31417 914 7 Smith Smith NNP 31417 914 8 and and CC 31417 914 9 Marshall Marshall NNP 31417 914 10 , , , 31417 914 11 of of IN 31417 914 12 Chippenham Chippenham NNP 31417 914 13 , , , 31417 914 14 agents agent NNS 31417 914 15 to to IN 31417 914 16 the the DT 31417 914 17 late late JJ 31417 914 18 Lord Lord NNP 31417 914 19 Methuen Methuen NNP 31417 914 20 , , , 31417 914 21 to to TO 31417 914 22 try try VB 31417 914 23 and and CC 31417 914 24 find find VB 31417 914 25 a a DT 31417 914 26 spring spring NN 31417 914 27 on on IN 31417 914 28 Lord Lord NNP 31417 914 29 Methuen Methuen NNP 31417 914 30 's 's POS 31417 914 31 estate estate NN 31417 914 32 , , , 31417 914 33 as as IN 31417 914 34 a a DT 31417 914 35 well well NN 31417 914 36 already already RB 31417 914 37 sunk sink VBN 31417 914 38 had have VBD 31417 914 39 proved prove VBN 31417 914 40 useless useless JJ 31417 914 41 . . . 31417 915 1 After after IN 31417 915 2 a a DT 31417 915 3 long long JJ 31417 915 4 search search NN 31417 915 5 the the DT 31417 915 6 rod rod NN 31417 915 7 moved move VBD 31417 915 8 at at IN 31417 915 9 a a DT 31417 915 10 certain certain JJ 31417 915 11 spot spot NN 31417 915 12 on on IN 31417 915 13 a a DT 31417 915 14 hillside hillside NN 31417 915 15 where where WRB 31417 915 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 915 17 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 915 18 predicted predict VBD 31417 915 19 a a DT 31417 915 20 good good JJ 31417 915 21 supply supply NN 31417 915 22 of of IN 31417 915 23 water water NN 31417 915 24 would would MD 31417 915 25 be be VB 31417 915 26 found find VBN 31417 915 27 . . . 31417 916 1 Nine nine CD 31417 916 2 feet foot NNS 31417 916 3 of of IN 31417 916 4 solid solid JJ 31417 916 5 rock rock NN 31417 916 6 had have VBD 31417 916 7 to to TO 31417 916 8 be be VB 31417 916 9 blasted blast VBN 31417 916 10 , , , 31417 916 11 but but CC 31417 916 12 at at IN 31417 916 13 18 18 CD 31417 916 14 feet foot NNS 31417 916 15 a a DT 31417 916 16 spring spring NN 31417 916 17 was be VBD 31417 916 18 struck strike VBN 31417 916 19 which which WDT 31417 916 20 rose rise VBD 31417 916 21 9 9 CD 31417 916 22 or or CC 31417 916 23 10 10 CD 31417 916 24 feet foot NNS 31417 916 25 in in IN 31417 916 26 the the DT 31417 916 27 well well NN 31417 916 28 . . . 31417 917 1 Messrs. Messrs. NNP 31417 917 2 Smith Smith NNP 31417 917 3 and and CC 31417 917 4 Marshall Marshall NNP 31417 917 5 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 917 6 wrote write VBD 31417 917 7 thus thus RB 31417 917 8 to to IN 31417 917 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 917 10 Tompkins:-- tompkins:-- NN 31417 917 11 " " `` 31417 917 12 CHIPPENHAM CHIPPENHAM NNP 31417 917 13 , , , 31417 917 14 WILTS WILTS NNP 31417 917 15 , , , 31417 917 16 and and CC 31417 917 17 7 7 CD 31417 917 18 WHITEHALL WHITEHALL NNP 31417 917 19 PLACE PLACE NNP 31417 917 20 , , , 31417 917 21 LONDON LONDON NNP 31417 917 22 , , , 31417 917 23 _ _ NNP 31417 917 24 November November NNP 31417 917 25 _ _ NNP 31417 917 26 24 24 CD 31417 917 27 , , , 31417 917 28 1891 1891 CD 31417 917 29 . . . 31417 918 1 " " `` 31417 918 2 The the DT 31417 918 3 decision decision NN 31417 918 4 you -PRON- PRP 31417 918 5 arrived arrive VBD 31417 918 6 at at IN 31417 918 7 was be VBD 31417 918 8 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 918 9 correct correct JJ 31417 918 10 , , , 31417 918 11 and and CC 31417 918 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 918 13 is be VBZ 31417 918 14 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 918 15 opinion opinion NN 31417 918 16 that that IN 31417 918 17 if if IN 31417 918 18 we -PRON- PRP 31417 918 19 had have VBD 31417 918 20 made make VBN 31417 918 21 the the DT 31417 918 22 well well JJ 31417 918 23 6 6 CD 31417 918 24 feet foot NNS 31417 918 25 either either DT 31417 918 26 way way NN 31417 918 27 to to IN 31417 918 28 the the DT 31417 918 29 right right NN 31417 918 30 or or CC 31417 918 31 left leave VBD 31417 918 32 of of IN 31417 918 33 the the DT 31417 918 34 spot spot NN 31417 918 35 you -PRON- PRP 31417 918 36 marked mark VBD 31417 918 37 , , , 31417 918 38 we -PRON- PRP 31417 918 39 should should MD 31417 918 40 have have VB 31417 918 41 missed miss VBN 31417 918 42 the the DT 31417 918 43 water water NN 31417 918 44 , , , 31417 918 45 which which WDT 31417 918 46 is be VBZ 31417 918 47 now now RB 31417 918 48 abundant abundant JJ 31417 918 49 . . . 31417 919 1 SMITH SMITH NNP 31417 919 2 AND and CC 31417 919 3 MARSHALL MARSHALL NNP 31417 919 4 . . . 31417 919 5 " " '' 31417 920 1 This this DT 31417 920 2 is be VBZ 31417 920 3 by by IN 31417 920 4 way way NN 31417 920 5 of of IN 31417 920 6 introduction introduction NN 31417 920 7 to to TO 31417 920 8 case case VB 31417 920 9 99 99 CD 31417 920 10 in in IN 31417 920 11 Professor Professor NNP 31417 920 12 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 920 13 's 's POS 31417 920 14 Report report NN 31417 920 15 . . . 31417 921 1 " " `` 31417 921 2 No no UH 31417 921 3 . . . 31417 922 1 99 99 CD 31417 922 2 . . . 31417 923 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 923 2 Charles Charles NNP 31417 923 3 Maggs Maggs NNP 31417 923 4 , , , 31417 923 5 who who WP 31417 923 6 is be VBZ 31417 923 7 a a DT 31417 923 8 Wiltshire Wiltshire NNP 31417 923 9 county county NN 31417 923 10 magistrate magistrate NN 31417 923 11 , , , 31417 923 12 and and CC 31417 923 13 proprietor proprietor NN 31417 923 14 of of IN 31417 923 15 the the DT 31417 923 16 Melksham Melksham NNP 31417 923 17 Dairy Dairy NNP 31417 923 18 Company Company NNP 31417 923 19 , , , 31417 923 20 required require VBD 31417 923 21 a a DT 31417 923 22 large large JJ 31417 923 23 supply supply NN 31417 923 24 of of IN 31417 923 25 pure pure JJ 31417 923 26 water water NN 31417 923 27 for for IN 31417 923 28 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 923 29 butter butter NN 31417 923 30 factory factory NN 31417 923 31 , , , 31417 923 32 and and CC 31417 923 33 , , , 31417 923 34 after after IN 31417 923 35 ineffectual ineffectual JJ 31417 923 36 attempts attempt NNS 31417 923 37 to to TO 31417 923 38 obtain obtain VB 31417 923 39 it -PRON- PRP 31417 923 40 , , , 31417 923 41 wrote write VBD 31417 923 42 to to IN 31417 923 43 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 923 44 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 923 45 to to TO 31417 923 46 come come VB 31417 923 47 over over RP 31417 923 48 and and CC 31417 923 49 try try VB 31417 923 50 the the DT 31417 923 51 divining divining NN 31417 923 52 rod rod NN 31417 923 53 . . . 31417 924 1 This this DT 31417 924 2 was be VBD 31417 924 3 done do VBN 31417 924 4 , , , 31417 924 5 and and CC 31417 924 6 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 924 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 924 8 Maggs Maggs NNP 31417 924 9 writes write VBZ 31417 924 10 to to IN 31417 924 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 924 12 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 924 13 as as IN 31417 924 14 follows:-- follows:-- `` 31417 924 15 " " `` 31417 924 16 ' ' '' 31417 924 17 MELKSHAM MELKSHAM NNP 31417 924 18 DAIRY DAIRY NNP 31417 924 19 COMPANY COMPANY NNP 31417 924 20 , , , 31417 924 21 _ _ NNP 31417 924 22 November November NNP 31417 924 23 _ _ NNP 31417 924 24 10 10 CD 31417 924 25 , , , 31417 924 26 1890 1890 CD 31417 924 27 . . . 31417 925 1 " " `` 31417 925 2 ' ' `` 31417 925 3 We -PRON- PRP 31417 925 4 found find VBD 31417 925 5 water water NN 31417 925 6 at at IN 31417 925 7 30 30 CD 31417 925 8 feet foot NNS 31417 925 9 , , , 31417 925 10 as as IN 31417 925 11 stated state VBN 31417 925 12 by by IN 31417 925 13 you -PRON- PRP 31417 925 14 at at IN 31417 925 15 time time NN 31417 925 16 of of IN 31417 925 17 finding find VBG 31417 925 18 the the DT 31417 925 19 spring spring NN 31417 925 20 -- -- : 31417 925 21 a a DT 31417 925 22 very very RB 31417 925 23 strong strong JJ 31417 925 24 spring spring NN 31417 925 25 . . . 31417 926 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 926 2 hopes hope NNS 31417 926 3 had have VBD 31417 926 4 almost almost RB 31417 926 5 gone go VBN 31417 926 6 , , , 31417 926 7 and and CC 31417 926 8 faith faith NN 31417 926 9 was be VBD 31417 926 10 all all DT 31417 926 11 but but CC 31417 926 12 spent spend VBN 31417 926 13 .... .... NFP 31417 926 14 CHARLES CHARLES NNP 31417 926 15 MAGGS MAGGS NNP 31417 926 16 . . . 31417 926 17 ' ' '' 31417 926 18 " " '' 31417 927 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 927 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 927 3 wrote write VBD 31417 927 4 to to IN 31417 927 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 927 6 Maggs Maggs NNP 31417 927 7 , , , 31417 927 8 and and CC 31417 927 9 received receive VBD 31417 927 10 the the DT 31417 927 11 following follow VBG 31417 927 12 interesting interesting JJ 31417 927 13 letter letter NN 31417 927 14 in in IN 31417 927 15 reply:-- reply:-- UH 31417 927 16 " " `` 31417 927 17 BOWERHILL BOWERHILL NNP 31417 927 18 LODGE LODGE NNP 31417 927 19 , , , 31417 927 20 MELKSHAM MELKSHAM NNP 31417 927 21 , , , 31417 927 22 _ _ NNP 31417 927 23 March March NNP 31417 927 24 _ _ NNP 31417 927 25 8 8 CD 31417 927 26 , , , 31417 927 27 1897 1897 CD 31417 927 28 . . . 31417 928 1 " " `` 31417 928 2 Briefly briefly RB 31417 928 3 the the DT 31417 928 4 facts fact NNS 31417 928 5 are:--I are:--i CD 31417 928 6 sunk sink VBD 31417 928 7 a a DT 31417 928 8 well well NN 31417 928 9 to to TO 31417 928 10 find find VB 31417 928 11 water water NN 31417 928 12 for for IN 31417 928 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 928 14 dairy dairy NN 31417 928 15 and and CC 31417 928 16 found find VBD 31417 928 17 none none NN 31417 928 18 . . . 31417 929 1 Then then RB 31417 929 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 929 3 wrote write VBD 31417 929 4 to to IN 31417 929 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 929 6 Tompkins Tompkins NNP 31417 929 7 , , , 31417 929 8 who who WP 31417 929 9 came come VBD 31417 929 10 the the DT 31417 929 11 following follow VBG 31417 929 12 day day NN 31417 929 13 . . . 31417 930 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 930 2 cut cut VBD 31417 930 3 a a DT 31417 930 4 forked forked JJ 31417 930 5 stick stick NN 31417 930 6 out out IN 31417 930 7 of of IN 31417 930 8 the the DT 31417 930 9 hedge hedge NN 31417 930 10 , , , 31417 930 11 and and CC 31417 930 12 having have VBG 31417 930 13 placed place VBN 31417 930 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 930 15 over over IN 31417 930 16 the the DT 31417 930 17 well well NN 31417 930 18 , , , 31417 930 19 said say VBD 31417 930 20 , , , 31417 930 21 ' ' `` 31417 930 22 There there EX 31417 930 23 is be VBZ 31417 930 24 no no DT 31417 930 25 water water NN 31417 930 26 here here RB 31417 930 27 , , , 31417 930 28 ' ' '' 31417 930 29 but but CC 31417 930 30 found find VBD 31417 930 31 a a DT 31417 930 32 slight slight JJ 31417 930 33 spring spring NN 31417 930 34 within within IN 31417 930 35 10 10 CD 31417 930 36 feet foot NNS 31417 930 37 , , , 31417 930 38 too too RB 31417 930 39 small small JJ 31417 930 40 to to TO 31417 930 41 be be VB 31417 930 42 of of IN 31417 930 43 any any DT 31417 930 44 service service NN 31417 930 45 , , , 31417 930 46 he -PRON- PRP 31417 930 47 reported report VBD 31417 930 48 . . . 31417 931 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 931 2 walked walk VBD 31417 931 3 all all RB 31417 931 4 over over IN 31417 931 5 the the DT 31417 931 6 field field NN 31417 931 7 , , , 31417 931 8 and and CC 31417 931 9 said say VBD 31417 931 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 931 11 had have VBD 31417 931 12 not not RB 31417 931 13 come come VBN 31417 931 14 across across IN 31417 931 15 any any DT 31417 931 16 spring spring NN 31417 931 17 at at RB 31417 931 18 all all RB 31417 931 19 . . . 31417 932 1 However however RB 31417 932 2 , , , 31417 932 3 in in IN 31417 932 4 the the DT 31417 932 5 extreme extreme JJ 31417 932 6 corner corner NN 31417 932 7 of of IN 31417 932 8 the the DT 31417 932 9 field field NN 31417 932 10 , , , 31417 932 11 a a DT 31417 932 12 bunch bunch NN 31417 932 13 of of IN 31417 932 14 nettles nettle NNS 31417 932 15 was be VBD 31417 932 16 growing grow VBG 31417 932 17 , , , 31417 932 18 and and CC 31417 932 19 he -PRON- PRP 31417 932 20 entered enter VBD 31417 932 21 this this DT 31417 932 22 , , , 31417 932 23 and and CC 31417 932 24 instantly instantly RB 31417 932 25 exclaimed--'Here exclaimed--'here VB 31417 932 26 it -PRON- PRP 31417 932 27 is be VBZ 31417 932 28 ; ; : 31417 932 29 and and CC 31417 932 30 a a DT 31417 932 31 good good JJ 31417 932 32 head head NN 31417 932 33 of of IN 31417 932 34 water water NN 31417 932 35 , , , 31417 932 36 too too RB 31417 932 37 ! ! . 31417 933 1 Not not RB 31417 933 2 running run VBG 31417 933 3 away away RB 31417 933 4 , , , 31417 933 5 but but CC 31417 933 6 just just RB 31417 933 7 ready ready JJ 31417 933 8 for for IN 31417 933 9 tapping tap VBG 31417 933 10 , , , 31417 933 11 and and CC 31417 933 12 as as RB 31417 933 13 soon soon RB 31417 933 14 as as IN 31417 933 15 you -PRON- PRP 31417 933 16 strike strike VBP 31417 933 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 933 18 , , , 31417 933 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 933 20 will will MD 31417 933 21 come come VB 31417 933 22 surging surge VBG 31417 933 23 up up RP 31417 933 24 . . . 31417 933 25 ' ' '' 31417 934 1 ' ' `` 31417 934 2 How how WRB 31417 934 3 deep deep JJ 31417 934 4 ? ? . 31417 934 5 ' ' '' 31417 935 1 ' ' `` 31417 935 2 Not not RB 31417 935 3 over over IN 31417 935 4 25 25 CD 31417 935 5 feet foot NNS 31417 935 6 . . . 31417 935 7 ' ' '' 31417 936 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 936 2 cut cut VBD 31417 936 3 out out RP 31417 936 4 a a DT 31417 936 5 turf turf NN 31417 936 6 to to TO 31417 936 7 indicate indicate VB 31417 936 8 the the DT 31417 936 9 spot spot NN 31417 936 10 , , , 31417 936 11 and and CC 31417 936 12 we -PRON- PRP 31417 936 13 commenced commence VBD 31417 936 14 sinking sink VBG 31417 936 15 next next JJ 31417 936 16 day day NN 31417 936 17 . . . 31417 937 1 The the DT 31417 937 2 person person NN 31417 937 3 employed employ VBN 31417 937 4 was be VBD 31417 937 5 an an DT 31417 937 6 old old JJ 31417 937 7 well well NN 31417 937 8 - - HYPH 31417 937 9 sinker sinker NN 31417 937 10 , , , 31417 937 11 and and CC 31417 937 12 he -PRON- PRP 31417 937 13 came come VBD 31417 937 14 to to IN 31417 937 15 me -PRON- PRP 31417 937 16 two two CD 31417 937 17 or or CC 31417 937 18 three three CD 31417 937 19 times time NNS 31417 937 20 whilst whilst IN 31417 937 21 engaged engage VBD 31417 937 22 in in IN 31417 937 23 sinking sink VBG 31417 937 24 , , , 31417 937 25 showing show VBG 31417 937 26 specimens specimen NNS 31417 937 27 of of IN 31417 937 28 the the DT 31417 937 29 soil soil NN 31417 937 30 or or CC 31417 937 31 marl marl NNP 31417 937 32 , , , 31417 937 33 assuring assure VBG 31417 937 34 me -PRON- PRP 31417 937 35 there there RB 31417 937 36 never never RB 31417 937 37 was be VBD 31417 937 38 water water NN 31417 937 39 where where WRB 31417 937 40 such such JJ 31417 937 41 existed existed JJ 31417 937 42 , , , 31417 937 43 and and CC 31417 937 44 it -PRON- PRP 31417 937 45 was be VBD 31417 937 46 worse bad JJR 31417 937 47 than than IN 31417 937 48 useless useless JJ 31417 937 49 to to TO 31417 937 50 go go VB 31417 937 51 further further RB 31417 937 52 . . . 31417 938 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 938 2 told tell VBD 31417 938 3 him -PRON- PRP 31417 938 4 to to TO 31417 938 5 go go VB 31417 938 6 on on RP 31417 938 7 if if IN 31417 938 8 he -PRON- PRP 31417 938 9 had have VBD 31417 938 10 to to TO 31417 938 11 get get VB 31417 938 12 to to IN 31417 938 13 New New NNP 31417 938 14 Zealand Zealand NNP 31417 938 15 -- -- : 31417 938 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 938 17 was be VBD 31417 938 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 938 19 money money NN 31417 938 20 , , , 31417 938 21 and and CC 31417 938 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 938 23 need nee MD 31417 938 24 not not RB 31417 938 25 regard regard VB 31417 938 26 me -PRON- PRP 31417 938 27 nor nor CC 31417 938 28 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 938 29 pocket pocket NN 31417 938 30 . . . 31417 939 1 When when WRB 31417 939 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 939 3 had have VBD 31417 939 4 gone go VBN 31417 939 5 about about RB 31417 939 6 22 22 CD 31417 939 7 feet foot NNS 31417 939 8 , , , 31417 939 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 939 10 pickaxe pickaxe NN 31417 939 11 tapped tap VBD 31417 939 12 the the DT 31417 939 13 spring spring NN 31417 939 14 and and CC 31417 939 15 the the DT 31417 939 16 water water NN 31417 939 17 came come VBD 31417 939 18 up up RP 31417 939 19 like like IN 31417 939 20 a a DT 31417 939 21 fountain fountain NN 31417 939 22 , , , 31417 939 23 and and CC 31417 939 24 at at IN 31417 939 25 such such PDT 31417 939 26 a a DT 31417 939 27 rate rate NN 31417 939 28 he -PRON- PRP 31417 939 29 feared fear VBD 31417 939 30 he -PRON- PRP 31417 939 31 should should MD 31417 939 32 be be VB 31417 939 33 drowned drown VBN 31417 939 34 before before IN 31417 939 35 he -PRON- PRP 31417 939 36 could could MD 31417 939 37 get get VB 31417 939 38 pulled pull VBN 31417 939 39 up up RP 31417 939 40 -- -- : 31417 939 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 939 42 mates mate NNS 31417 939 43 being be VBG 31417 939 44 away away RB 31417 939 45 ! ! . 31417 940 1 The the DT 31417 940 2 water water NN 31417 940 3 rose rise VBD 31417 940 4 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 940 5 to to IN 31417 940 6 within within IN 31417 940 7 12 12 CD 31417 940 8 or or CC 31417 940 9 15 15 CD 31417 940 10 inches inch NNS 31417 940 11 of of IN 31417 940 12 the the DT 31417 940 13 surface surface NN 31417 940 14 . . . 31417 941 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 941 2 put put VBP 31417 941 3 in in IN 31417 941 4 pumps pump NNS 31417 941 5 and and CC 31417 941 6 kept keep VBD 31417 941 7 the the DT 31417 941 8 water water NN 31417 941 9 down down RB 31417 941 10 whilst whilst IN 31417 941 11 he -PRON- PRP 31417 941 12 went go VBD 31417 941 13 a a DT 31417 941 14 little little JJ 31417 941 15 deeper deep JJR 31417 941 16 , , , 31417 941 17 but but CC 31417 941 18 the the DT 31417 941 19 rush rush NN 31417 941 20 of of IN 31417 941 21 water water NN 31417 941 22 was be VBD 31417 941 23 such such JJ 31417 941 24 that that IN 31417 941 25 we -PRON- PRP 31417 941 26 had have VBD 31417 941 27 to to TO 31417 941 28 desist desist VB 31417 941 29 going go VBG 31417 941 30 lower lower RBR 31417 941 31 . . . 31417 942 1 Since since IN 31417 942 2 then then RB 31417 942 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 942 4 have have VBP 31417 942 5 had have VBN 31417 942 6 a a DT 31417 942 7 splendid splendid JJ 31417 942 8 supply supply NN 31417 942 9 .... .... . 31417 942 10 CHAS CHAS NNP 31417 942 11 . . . 31417 943 1 MAGGS MAGGS NNP 31417 943 2 . . . 31417 944 1 " " `` 31417 944 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 944 3 57 57 CD 31417 944 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 944 5 II ii CD 31417 944 6 . . . 31417 945 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 945 2 John John NNP 31417 945 3 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 945 4 and and CC 31417 945 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 945 6 H. H. NNP 31417 945 7 W. W. NNP 31417 945 8 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 945 9 , , , 31417 945 10 father father NN 31417 945 11 and and CC 31417 945 12 son son NN 31417 945 13 , , , 31417 945 14 Colerne Colerne NNP 31417 945 15 , , , 31417 945 16 Chippenham Chippenham NNP 31417 945 17 , , , 31417 945 18 Wilts Wilts NNP 31417 945 19 . . . 31417 946 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 946 2 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 946 3 , , , 31417 946 4 sen sen NNP 31417 946 5 . . NNP 31417 946 6 , , , 31417 946 7 who who WP 31417 946 8 died die VBD 31417 946 9 rather rather RB 31417 946 10 more more JJR 31417 946 11 than than IN 31417 946 12 ten ten CD 31417 946 13 years year NNS 31417 946 14 ago ago RB 31417 946 15 , , , 31417 946 16 was be VBD 31417 946 17 for for IN 31417 946 18 thirty thirty CD 31417 946 19 years year NNS 31417 946 20 engaged engage VBN 31417 946 21 all all RB 31417 946 22 over over IN 31417 946 23 Great Great NNP 31417 946 24 Britain Britain NNP 31417 946 25 and and CC 31417 946 26 Ireland Ireland NNP 31417 946 27 in in IN 31417 946 28 finding find VBG 31417 946 29 water water NN 31417 946 30 by by IN 31417 946 31 means mean NNS 31417 946 32 of of IN 31417 946 33 the the DT 31417 946 34 divining divining NN 31417 946 35 rod rod NN 31417 946 36 . . . 31417 947 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 947 2 was be VBD 31417 947 3 a a DT 31417 947 4 professional professional JJ 31417 947 5 well well NN 31417 947 6 - - HYPH 31417 947 7 sinker sinker NN 31417 947 8 . . . 31417 948 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 31417 948 2 sons son NNS 31417 948 3 carry carry VBP 31417 948 4 on on RP 31417 948 5 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 948 6 father father NN 31417 948 7 's 's POS 31417 948 8 business business NN 31417 948 9 . . . 31417 949 1 One one CD 31417 949 2 of of IN 31417 949 3 them -PRON- PRP 31417 949 4 , , , 31417 949 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 949 6 H. H. NNP 31417 949 7 W. W. NNP 31417 949 8 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 949 9 , , , 31417 949 10 inherits inherit VBZ 31417 949 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 949 12 fathers father NNS 31417 949 13 faculty faculty NN 31417 949 14 . . . 31417 950 1 Cases case NNS 31417 950 2 Nos Nos NNP 31417 950 3 . . . 31417 951 1 62 62 CD 31417 951 2 and and CC 31417 951 3 63 63 CD 31417 951 4 in in IN 31417 951 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 951 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 951 7 's 's POS 31417 951 8 Report Report NNP 31417 951 9 illustrate illustrate VBP 31417 951 10 the the DT 31417 951 11 powers power NNS 31417 951 12 of of IN 31417 951 13 both both DT 31417 951 14 father father NNP 31417 951 15 and and CC 31417 951 16 son son NN 31417 951 17 . . . 31417 952 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 952 2 E.G. E.G. NNP 31417 953 1 Allen Allen NNP 31417 953 2 writes:-- writes:-- : 31417 953 3 " " `` 31417 953 4 HIGHFIELD HIGHFIELD NNP 31417 953 5 , , , 31417 953 6 METHERINGHAM METHERINGHAM NNP 31417 953 7 LINCOLN LINCOLN NNP 31417 953 8 , , , 31417 953 9 _ _ NNP 31417 953 10 March March NNP 31417 953 11 _ _ NNP 31417 953 12 25 25 CD 31417 953 13 , , , 31417 953 14 1893 1893 CD 31417 953 15 . . . 31417 954 1 " " `` 31417 954 2 Having have VBG 31417 954 3 frequently frequently RB 31417 954 4 availed avail VBN 31417 954 5 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 954 6 of of IN 31417 954 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 954 8 John John NNP 31417 954 9 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 954 10 ' ' POS 31417 954 11 services service NNS 31417 954 12 during during IN 31417 954 13 the the DT 31417 954 14 last last JJ 31417 954 15 twenty twenty CD 31417 954 16 years year NNS 31417 954 17 , , , 31417 954 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 954 19 can can MD 31417 954 20 say say VB 31417 954 21 I -PRON- PRP 31417 954 22 have have VBP 31417 954 23 never never RB 31417 954 24 known know VBN 31417 954 25 him -PRON- PRP 31417 954 26 to to TO 31417 954 27 fail fail VB 31417 954 28 . . . 31417 955 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 955 2 have have VBP 31417 955 3 sunk sink VBN 31417 955 4 six six CD 31417 955 5 wells well NNS 31417 955 6 , , , 31417 955 7 two two CD 31417 955 8 on on IN 31417 955 9 a a DT 31417 955 10 heath heath NN 31417 955 11 farm farm NN 31417 955 12 about about IN 31417 955 13 30 30 CD 31417 955 14 feet foot NNS 31417 955 15 deep deep JJ 31417 955 16 ( ( -LRB- 31417 955 17 surrounding surround VBG 31417 955 18 wells well NNS 31417 955 19 measuring measure VBG 31417 955 20 about about IN 31417 955 21 70 70 CD 31417 955 22 feet foot NNS 31417 955 23 ) ) -RRB- 31417 955 24 in in IN 31417 955 25 limestone limestone NN 31417 955 26 rock rock NN 31417 955 27 , , , 31417 955 28 thus thus RB 31417 955 29 saving save VBG 31417 955 30 a a DT 31417 955 31 great great JJ 31417 955 32 expense expense NN 31417 955 33 in in IN 31417 955 34 sinking sink VBG 31417 955 35 . . . 31417 956 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 956 2 took take VBD 31417 956 3 him -PRON- PRP 31417 956 4 one one CD 31417 956 5 morning morning NN 31417 956 6 to to IN 31417 956 7 a a DT 31417 956 8 farm farm NN 31417 956 9 which which WDT 31417 956 10 was be VBD 31417 956 11 at at IN 31417 956 12 that that DT 31417 956 13 time time NN 31417 956 14 farmed farm VBN 31417 956 15 by by IN 31417 956 16 the the DT 31417 956 17 owner owner NN 31417 956 18 , , , 31417 956 19 the the DT 31417 956 20 Right Right NNP 31417 956 21 Hon Hon NNP 31417 956 22 . . . 31417 957 1 H. H. NNP 31417 957 2 Chaplin Chaplin NNP 31417 957 3 , , , 31417 957 4 M.P. M.P. NNP 31417 958 1 The the DT 31417 958 2 well well NN 31417 958 3 in in IN 31417 958 4 the the DT 31417 958 5 yard yard NN 31417 958 6 ( ( -LRB- 31417 958 7 nearly nearly RB 31417 958 8 always always RB 31417 958 9 dry dry JJ 31417 958 10 ) ) -RRB- 31417 958 11 was be VBD 31417 958 12 about about RB 31417 958 13 30 30 CD 31417 958 14 feet foot NNS 31417 958 15 deep deep JJ 31417 958 16 . . . 31417 959 1 In in IN 31417 959 2 a a DT 31417 959 3 few few JJ 31417 959 4 minutes minute NNS 31417 959 5 , , , 31417 959 6 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 959 7 , , , 31417 959 8 carrying carry VBG 31417 959 9 in in IN 31417 959 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 959 11 hand hand NN 31417 959 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 959 13 twig twig NN 31417 959 14 , , , 31417 959 15 found find VBD 31417 959 16 a a DT 31417 959 17 good good JJ 31417 959 18 spring spring NN 31417 959 19 a a DT 31417 959 20 very very RB 31417 959 21 short short JJ 31417 959 22 distance distance NN 31417 959 23 from from IN 31417 959 24 the the DT 31417 959 25 old old JJ 31417 959 26 well well NN 31417 959 27 . . . 31417 960 1 A a DT 31417 960 2 new new JJ 31417 960 3 well well NN 31417 960 4 was be VBD 31417 960 5 sunk sink VBN 31417 960 6 , , , 31417 960 7 and and CC 31417 960 8 at at IN 31417 960 9 10 10 CD 31417 960 10 feet foot NNS 31417 960 11 a a DT 31417 960 12 splendid splendid JJ 31417 960 13 supply supply NN 31417 960 14 of of IN 31417 960 15 water water NN 31417 960 16 was be VBD 31417 960 17 found find VBN 31417 960 18 . . . 31417 961 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 961 2 has have VBZ 31417 961 3 never never RB 31417 961 4 failed fail VBN 31417 961 5 , , , 31417 961 6 and and CC 31417 961 7 has have VBZ 31417 961 8 supplied supply VBN 31417 961 9 the the DT 31417 961 10 yards yard NNS 31417 961 11 , , , 31417 961 12 & & CC 31417 961 13 c. c. NNP 31417 961 14 , , , 31417 961 15 with with IN 31417 961 16 water water NN 31417 961 17 ever ever RB 31417 961 18 since since RB 31417 961 19 . . . 31417 962 1 " " `` 31417 962 2 Being be VBG 31417 962 3 in in IN 31417 962 4 want want NN 31417 962 5 of of IN 31417 962 6 water water NN 31417 962 7 for for IN 31417 962 8 a a DT 31417 962 9 large large JJ 31417 962 10 grass grass NN 31417 962 11 field field NN 31417 962 12 , , , 31417 962 13 called call VBN 31417 962 14 ' ' '' 31417 962 15 Catley Catley NNP 31417 962 16 Abbey Abbey NNP 31417 962 17 Field Field NNP 31417 962 18 , , , 31417 962 19 ' ' '' 31417 962 20 I -PRON- PRP 31417 962 21 went go VBD 31417 962 22 with with IN 31417 962 23 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 962 24 , , , 31417 962 25 who who WP 31417 962 26 placed place VBD 31417 962 27 down down RP 31417 962 28 a a DT 31417 962 29 peg peg NN 31417 962 30 to to TO 31417 962 31 denote denote VB 31417 962 32 a a DT 31417 962 33 spring spring NN 31417 962 34 . . . 31417 963 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 963 2 sunk sink VBD 31417 963 3 a a DT 31417 963 4 well well NN 31417 963 5 , , , 31417 963 6 and and CC 31417 963 7 bored bore VBD 31417 963 8 70 70 CD 31417 963 9 feet foot NNS 31417 963 10 obtaining obtain VBG 31417 963 11 a a DT 31417 963 12 good good JJ 31417 963 13 supply supply NN 31417 963 14 of of IN 31417 963 15 water water NN 31417 963 16 . . . 31417 964 1 Being be VBG 31417 964 2 struck strike VBN 31417 964 3 with with IN 31417 964 4 a a DT 31417 964 5 peculiarity peculiarity NN 31417 964 6 in in IN 31417 964 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 964 8 taste taste NN 31417 964 9 , , , 31417 964 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 964 11 was be VBD 31417 964 12 submitted submit VBN 31417 964 13 to to IN 31417 964 14 Professor Professor NNP 31417 964 15 Attfield Attfield NNP 31417 964 16 , , , 31417 964 17 Ph.D. Ph.D. NNP 31417 964 18 , , , 31417 964 19 who who WP 31417 964 20 pronounced pronounce VBD 31417 964 21 it -PRON- PRP 31417 964 22 to to TO 31417 964 23 be be VB 31417 964 24 the the DT 31417 964 25 only only JJ 31417 964 26 natural natural JJ 31417 964 27 seltzer seltzer NN 31417 964 28 spring spring NN 31417 964 29 in in IN 31417 964 30 the the DT 31417 964 31 kingdom kingdom NN 31417 964 32 . . . 31417 965 1 E. E. NNP 31417 965 2 G. G. NNP 31417 966 1 ALLEN ALLEN NNP 31417 966 2 . . . 31417 967 1 " " `` 31417 967 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 967 3 58 58 CD 31417 967 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 967 5 The the DT 31417 967 6 next next JJ 31417 967 7 case case NN 31417 967 8 in in IN 31417 967 9 Professor Professor NNP 31417 967 10 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 967 11 's 's POS 31417 967 12 collection collection NN 31417 967 13 , , , 31417 967 14 No no UH 31417 967 15 . . . 31417 968 1 63 63 CD 31417 968 2 , , , 31417 968 3 forms form VBZ 31417 968 4 an an DT 31417 968 5 interesting interesting JJ 31417 968 6 sequel sequel NN 31417 968 7 to to IN 31417 968 8 the the DT 31417 968 9 above above JJ 31417 968 10 . . . 31417 969 1 The the DT 31417 969 2 following follow VBG 31417 969 3 is be VBZ 31417 969 4 abridged abridge VBN 31417 969 5 from from IN 31417 969 6 a a DT 31417 969 7 long long JJ 31417 969 8 report report NN 31417 969 9 , , , 31417 969 10 in in IN 31417 969 11 the the DT 31417 969 12 _ _ NNP 31417 969 13 Lincolnshire Lincolnshire NNP 31417 969 14 Chronicle Chronicle NNP 31417 969 15 _ _ NNP 31417 969 16 of of IN 31417 969 17 8th 8th JJ 31417 969 18 June June NNP 31417 969 19 1895 1895 CD 31417 969 20 , , , 31417 969 21 of of IN 31417 969 22 a a DT 31417 969 23 visit visit NN 31417 969 24 of of IN 31417 969 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 969 26 H.W. H.W. NNP 31417 970 1 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 970 2 , , , 31417 970 3 son son NN 31417 970 4 of of IN 31417 970 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 970 6 John John NNP 31417 970 7 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 970 8 , , , 31417 970 9 to to IN 31417 970 10 Catley Catley NNP 31417 970 11 Abbey:-- abbey:-- NN 31417 970 12 " " `` 31417 970 13 The the DT 31417 970 14 object object NN 31417 970 15 of of IN 31417 970 16 the the DT 31417 970 17 Catley Catley NNP 31417 970 18 Abbey Abbey NNP 31417 970 19 Company Company NNP 31417 970 20 in in IN 31417 970 21 sending send VBG 31417 970 22 for for IN 31417 970 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 970 24 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 970 25 was be VBD 31417 970 26 to to TO 31417 970 27 secure secure VB 31417 970 28 a a DT 31417 970 29 well well NN 31417 970 30 of of IN 31417 970 31 pure pure JJ 31417 970 32 water water NN 31417 970 33 for for IN 31417 970 34 bottle bottle NN 31417 970 35 - - HYPH 31417 970 36 washing washing NN 31417 970 37 . . . 31417 971 1 A a DT 31417 971 2 well well NN 31417 971 3 on on IN 31417 971 4 the the DT 31417 971 5 adjoining adjoining JJ 31417 971 6 farm farm NN 31417 971 7 of of IN 31417 971 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 971 9 Allen Allen NNP 31417 971 10 had have VBD 31417 971 11 run run VBN 31417 971 12 dry dry JJ 31417 971 13 , , , 31417 971 14 and and CC 31417 971 15 recently recently RB 31417 971 16 the the DT 31417 971 17 seltzer seltzer NN 31417 971 18 water water NN 31417 971 19 had have VBD 31417 971 20 been be VBN 31417 971 21 used use VBN 31417 971 22 for for IN 31417 971 23 the the DT 31417 971 24 purpose purpose NN 31417 971 25 of of IN 31417 971 26 bottle bottle NN 31417 971 27 - - HYPH 31417 971 28 washing washing NN 31417 971 29 . . . 31417 972 1 Eight eight CD 31417 972 2 years year NNS 31417 972 3 ago ago RB 31417 972 4 , , , 31417 972 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 972 6 J. J. NNP 31417 972 7 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 972 8 , , , 31417 972 9 the the DT 31417 972 10 father father NN 31417 972 11 of of IN 31417 972 12 the the DT 31417 972 13 family family NN 31417 972 14 , , , 31417 972 15 located locate VBD 31417 972 16 the the DT 31417 972 17 spot spot NN 31417 972 18 at at IN 31417 972 19 Catley Catley NNP 31417 972 20 , , , 31417 972 21 where where WRB 31417 972 22 now now RB 31417 972 23 stands stand VBZ 31417 972 24 the the DT 31417 972 25 only only JJ 31417 972 26 natural natural JJ 31417 972 27 seltzer seltzer NN 31417 972 28 spring spring NN 31417 972 29 in in IN 31417 972 30 Britain Britain NNP 31417 972 31 .... .... . 31417 973 1 Proceeding proceed VBG 31417 973 2 to to IN 31417 973 3 the the DT 31417 973 4 site site NN 31417 973 5 of of IN 31417 973 6 the the DT 31417 973 7 dried dry VBN 31417 973 8 - - HYPH 31417 973 9 up up RP 31417 973 10 well well RB 31417 973 11 , , , 31417 973 12 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 973 13 took take VBD 31417 973 14 out out RP 31417 973 15 a a DT 31417 973 16 = = SYM 31417 973 17 V=-shaped v=-shaped JJ 31417 973 18 twig twig NN 31417 973 19 , , , 31417 973 20 the the DT 31417 973 21 forks fork NNS 31417 973 22 of of IN 31417 973 23 which which WDT 31417 973 24 were be VBD 31417 973 25 each each DT 31417 973 26 about about IN 31417 973 27 a a DT 31417 973 28 foot foot NN 31417 973 29 long long RB 31417 973 30 , , , 31417 973 31 and and CC 31417 973 32 walked walk VBD 31417 973 33 slowly slowly RB 31417 973 34 along along IN 31417 973 35 the the DT 31417 973 36 ground ground NN 31417 973 37 a a DT 31417 973 38 short short JJ 31417 973 39 distance distance NN 31417 973 40 from from IN 31417 973 41 the the DT 31417 973 42 well well NN 31417 973 43 . . . 31417 974 1 Suddenly suddenly RB 31417 974 2 the the DT 31417 974 3 twig twig NNP 31417 974 4 revolved revolve VBD 31417 974 5 ... ... NFP 31417 974 6 and and CC 31417 974 7 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 974 8 confidently confidently RB 31417 974 9 asserted assert VBD 31417 974 10 that that IN 31417 974 11 he -PRON- PRP 31417 974 12 was be VBD 31417 974 13 standing stand VBG 31417 974 14 over over IN 31417 974 15 a a DT 31417 974 16 subterranean subterranean JJ 31417 974 17 watercourse watercourse NN 31417 974 18 . . . 31417 975 1 Proceeding proceed VBG 31417 975 2 to to IN 31417 975 3 the the DT 31417 975 4 other other JJ 31417 975 5 side side NN 31417 975 6 of of IN 31417 975 7 the the DT 31417 975 8 well well NN 31417 975 9 , , , 31417 975 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 975 11 traced trace VBD 31417 975 12 , , , 31417 975 13 or or CC 31417 975 14 professed profess VBN 31417 975 15 to to TO 31417 975 16 trace trace VB 31417 975 17 , , , 31417 975 18 the the DT 31417 975 19 course course NN 31417 975 20 of of IN 31417 975 21 the the DT 31417 975 22 hidden hidden JJ 31417 975 23 stream stream NN 31417 975 24 , , , 31417 975 25 and and CC 31417 975 26 marked mark VBD 31417 975 27 a a DT 31417 975 28 spot spot NN 31417 975 29 contiguous contiguous JJ 31417 975 30 to to IN 31417 975 31 the the DT 31417 975 32 buildings building NNS 31417 975 33 where where WRB 31417 975 34 he -PRON- PRP 31417 975 35 asserted assert VBD 31417 975 36 a a DT 31417 975 37 good good JJ 31417 975 38 spring spring NN 31417 975 39 would would MD 31417 975 40 be be VB 31417 975 41 tapped tap VBN 31417 975 42 at at IN 31417 975 43 a a DT 31417 975 44 depth depth NN 31417 975 45 of of IN 31417 975 46 from from IN 31417 975 47 120 120 CD 31417 975 48 to to TO 31417 975 49 130 130 CD 31417 975 50 feet foot NNS 31417 975 51 , , , 31417 975 52 and and CC 31417 975 53 he -PRON- PRP 31417 975 54 advised advise VBD 31417 975 55 that that IN 31417 975 56 a a DT 31417 975 57 well well NN 31417 975 58 should should MD 31417 975 59 be be VB 31417 975 60 sunk sink VBN 31417 975 61 there there RB 31417 975 62 . . . 31417 976 1 " " `` 31417 976 2 It -PRON- PRP 31417 976 3 was be VBD 31417 976 4 told tell VBN 31417 976 5 to to IN 31417 976 6 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 976 7 that that IN 31417 976 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 976 9 father father NN 31417 976 10 asserted assert VBD 31417 976 11 the the DT 31417 976 12 seltzer seltzer NN 31417 976 13 spring spring NN 31417 976 14 flowed flow VBN 31417 976 15 under under IN 31417 976 16 a a DT 31417 976 17 hedge hedge NN 31417 976 18 on on IN 31417 976 19 the the DT 31417 976 20 other other JJ 31417 976 21 side side NN 31417 976 22 of of IN 31417 976 23 the the DT 31417 976 24 field field NN 31417 976 25 in in IN 31417 976 26 which which WDT 31417 976 27 we -PRON- PRP 31417 976 28 were be VBD 31417 976 29 then then RB 31417 976 30 standing stand VBG 31417 976 31 , , , 31417 976 32 and and CC 31417 976 33 he -PRON- PRP 31417 976 34 was be VBD 31417 976 35 asked ask VBN 31417 976 36 to to TO 31417 976 37 indicate indicate VB 31417 976 38 the the DT 31417 976 39 place place NN 31417 976 40 . . . 31417 977 1 Starting start VBG 31417 977 2 at at IN 31417 977 3 one one CD 31417 977 4 end end NN 31417 977 5 of of IN 31417 977 6 the the DT 31417 977 7 field field NN 31417 977 8 , , , 31417 977 9 he -PRON- PRP 31417 977 10 walked walk VBD 31417 977 11 close close RB 31417 977 12 by by IN 31417 977 13 the the DT 31417 977 14 hedge hedge NN 31417 977 15 side side NN 31417 977 16 . . . 31417 978 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 978 2 had have VBD 31417 978 3 gone go VBN 31417 978 4 about about RB 31417 978 5 100 100 CD 31417 978 6 yards yard NNS 31417 978 7 when when WRB 31417 978 8 the the DT 31417 978 9 twig twig NN 31417 978 10 began begin VBD 31417 978 11 to to TO 31417 978 12 play play VB 31417 978 13 , , , 31417 978 14 and and CC 31417 978 15 digging dig VBG 31417 978 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 978 17 heel heel NN 31417 978 18 in in IN 31417 978 19 the the DT 31417 978 20 ground ground NN 31417 978 21 , , , 31417 978 22 he -PRON- PRP 31417 978 23 thus thus RB 31417 978 24 marked mark VBD 31417 978 25 the the DT 31417 978 26 spot spot NN 31417 978 27 . . . 31417 979 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 979 2 Allen Allen NNP 31417 979 3 , , , 31417 979 4 who who WP 31417 979 5 was be VBD 31417 979 6 present present JJ 31417 979 7 when when WRB 31417 979 8 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 979 9 , , , 31417 979 10 sen sen NNP 31417 979 11 . . NNP 31417 979 12 , , , 31417 979 13 also also RB 31417 979 14 located locate VBD 31417 979 15 the the DT 31417 979 16 spring spring NN 31417 979 17 , , , 31417 979 18 sent send VBD 31417 979 19 a a DT 31417 979 20 man man NN 31417 979 21 for for IN 31417 979 22 a a DT 31417 979 23 spade spade NN 31417 979 24 , , , 31417 979 25 and and CC 31417 979 26 a a DT 31417 979 27 stake stake NN 31417 979 28 was be VBD 31417 979 29 dug dig VBN 31417 979 30 up up RP 31417 979 31 which which WDT 31417 979 32 eight eight CD 31417 979 33 years year NNS 31417 979 34 ago ago RB 31417 979 35 was be VBD 31417 979 36 driven drive VBN 31417 979 37 in in IN 31417 979 38 by by IN 31417 979 39 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 979 40 Allen Allen NNP 31417 979 41 to to TO 31417 979 42 mark mark VB 31417 979 43 the the DT 31417 979 44 place place NN 31417 979 45 . . . 31417 980 1 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 980 2 , , , 31417 980 3 jun jun NNP 31417 980 4 . . NNP 31417 980 5 , , , 31417 980 6 had have VBD 31417 980 7 touched touch VBN 31417 980 8 the the DT 31417 980 9 spot spot NN 31417 980 10 exactly exactly RB 31417 980 11 . . . 31417 980 12 " " '' 31417 981 1 The the DT 31417 981 2 same same JJ 31417 981 3 newspaper newspaper NN 31417 981 4 of of IN 31417 981 5 23rd 23rd JJ 31417 981 6 August August NNP 31417 981 7 1895 1895 CD 31417 981 8 announces announce VBZ 31417 981 9 the the DT 31417 981 10 result result NN 31417 981 11 of of IN 31417 981 12 digging dig VBG 31417 981 13 in in IN 31417 981 14 the the DT 31417 981 15 spot spot NN 31417 981 16 indicated indicate VBN 31417 981 17 as as IN 31417 981 18 follows:-- follows:-- `` 31417 981 19 " " `` 31417 981 20 Our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 981 21 readers reader NNS 31417 981 22 will will MD 31417 981 23 remember remember VB 31417 981 24 that that IN 31417 981 25 a a DT 31417 981 26 few few JJ 31417 981 27 weeks week NNS 31417 981 28 ago ago IN 31417 981 29 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 981 30 columns column NNS 31417 981 31 contained contain VBD 31417 981 32 an an DT 31417 981 33 article article NN 31417 981 34 relative relative JJ 31417 981 35 to to IN 31417 981 36 the the DT 31417 981 37 finding finding NN 31417 981 38 of of IN 31417 981 39 water water NN 31417 981 40 at at IN 31417 981 41 Catley Catley NNP 31417 981 42 Abbey Abbey NNP 31417 981 43 by by IN 31417 981 44 means mean NNS 31417 981 45 of of IN 31417 981 46 hazel hazel NNP 31417 981 47 twigs twig NNS 31417 981 48 in in IN 31417 981 49 the the DT 31417 981 50 hands hand NNS 31417 981 51 of of IN 31417 981 52 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 981 53 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 981 54 , , , 31417 981 55 the the DT 31417 981 56 eminent eminent JJ 31417 981 57 ' ' POS 31417 981 58 dowser dowser NN 31417 981 59 . . . 31417 981 60 ' ' '' 31417 982 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 982 2 are be VBP 31417 982 3 now now RB 31417 982 4 able able JJ 31417 982 5 to to TO 31417 982 6 state state VB 31417 982 7 that that IN 31417 982 8 a a DT 31417 982 9 well well RB 31417 982 10 having have VBG 31417 982 11 been be VBN 31417 982 12 sunk sink VBN 31417 982 13 in in IN 31417 982 14 the the DT 31417 982 15 position position NN 31417 982 16 indicated indicate VBN 31417 982 17 by by IN 31417 982 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 982 19 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 982 20 , , , 31417 982 21 a a DT 31417 982 22 valuable valuable JJ 31417 982 23 supply supply NN 31417 982 24 of of IN 31417 982 25 water water NN 31417 982 26 has have VBZ 31417 982 27 been be VBN 31417 982 28 obtained obtain VBN 31417 982 29 , , , 31417 982 30 and and CC 31417 982 31 that that IN 31417 982 32 at at IN 31417 982 33 a a DT 31417 982 34 depth depth NN 31417 982 35 of of IN 31417 982 36 about about RB 31417 982 37 5 5 CD 31417 982 38 feet foot NNS 31417 982 39 less less JJR 31417 982 40 than than IN 31417 982 41 that that DT 31417 982 42 mentioned mention VBN 31417 982 43 by by IN 31417 982 44 him -PRON- PRP 31417 982 45 . . . 31417 982 46 " " '' 31417 983 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 983 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 983 3 says say VBZ 31417 983 4 : : : 31417 983 5 " " `` 31417 983 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 983 7 sent send VBD 31417 983 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 983 9 Allen Allen NNP 31417 983 10 the the DT 31417 983 11 foregoing foregoing NN 31417 983 12 account account NN 31417 983 13 , , , 31417 983 14 and and CC 31417 983 15 asked ask VBD 31417 983 16 if if IN 31417 983 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 983 18 were be VBD 31417 983 19 correct correct JJ 31417 983 20 . . . 31417 984 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 984 2 replies reply VBZ 31417 984 3 that that IN 31417 984 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 984 5 is be VBZ 31417 984 6 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 984 7 accurate accurate JJ 31417 984 8 , , , 31417 984 9 the the DT 31417 984 10 facts fact NNS 31417 984 11 being be VBG 31417 984 12 most most RBS 31417 984 13 interesting interesting JJ 31417 984 14 , , , 31417 984 15 and and CC 31417 984 16 occurred occur VBD 31417 984 17 as as IN 31417 984 18 stated state VBN 31417 984 19 in in IN 31417 984 20 the the DT 31417 984 21 letter letter NN 31417 984 22 and and CC 31417 984 23 newspaper newspaper NN 31417 984 24 report report NN 31417 984 25 . . . 31417 985 1 " " `` 31417 985 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 985 3 59 59 CD 31417 985 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 985 5 III iii CD 31417 985 6 . . . 31417 986 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 986 2 Leicester Leicester NNP 31417 986 3 Gataker Gataker NNP 31417 986 4 , , , 31417 986 5 Crescent Crescent NNP 31417 986 6 Gardens Gardens NNPS 31417 986 7 , , , 31417 986 8 Bath Bath NNP 31417 986 9 , , , 31417 986 10 who who WP 31417 986 11 is be VBZ 31417 986 12 a a DT 31417 986 13 gentleman gentleman NN 31417 986 14 by by IN 31417 986 15 birth birth NN 31417 986 16 and and CC 31417 986 17 education education NN 31417 986 18 , , , 31417 986 19 soon soon RB 31417 986 20 after after IN 31417 986 21 leaving leave VBG 31417 986 22 Bath Bath NNP 31417 986 23 College College NNP 31417 986 24 , , , 31417 986 25 discovered discover VBD 31417 986 26 to to IN 31417 986 27 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 986 28 surprise surprise NN 31417 986 29 that that IN 31417 986 30 a a DT 31417 986 31 forked forked JJ 31417 986 32 twig twig NN 31417 986 33 revolved revolve VBD 31417 986 34 in in IN 31417 986 35 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 986 36 hands hand NNS 31417 986 37 in in IN 31417 986 38 the the DT 31417 986 39 same same JJ 31417 986 40 way way NN 31417 986 41 as as IN 31417 986 42 it -PRON- PRP 31417 986 43 did do VBD 31417 986 44 with with IN 31417 986 45 a a DT 31417 986 46 local local JJ 31417 986 47 " " `` 31417 986 48 diviner diviner NN 31417 986 49 . . . 31417 986 50 " " '' 31417 987 1 The the DT 31417 987 2 following follow VBG 31417 987 3 is be VBZ 31417 987 4 Case Case NNP 31417 987 5 123 123 CD 31417 987 6 in in IN 31417 987 7 Professor Professor NNP 31417 987 8 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 987 9 's 's POS 31417 987 10 Report:-- report:-- NN 31417 987 11 " " `` 31417 987 12 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 987 13 Gataker Gataker NNP 31417 987 14 states state VBZ 31417 987 15 that that IN 31417 987 16 , , , 31417 987 17 being be VBG 31417 987 18 engaged engage VBN 31417 987 19 by by IN 31417 987 20 Messrs Messrs NNP 31417 987 21 Ruscombe Ruscombe NNP 31417 987 22 Poole Poole NNP 31417 987 23 & & CC 31417 987 24 Son Son NNP 31417 987 25 , , , 31417 987 26 the the DT 31417 987 27 well well RB 31417 987 28 - - HYPH 31417 987 29 known know VBN 31417 987 30 solicitors solicitor NNS 31417 987 31 of of IN 31417 987 32 Bridgwater Bridgwater NNP 31417 987 33 , , , 31417 987 34 he -PRON- PRP 31417 987 35 found find VBD 31417 987 36 a a DT 31417 987 37 spring spring NN 31417 987 38 less less JJR 31417 987 39 than than IN 31417 987 40 14 14 CD 31417 987 41 feet foot NNS 31417 987 42 deep deep JJ 31417 987 43 , , , 31417 987 44 and and CC 31417 987 45 within within IN 31417 987 46 3 3 CD 31417 987 47 or or CC 31417 987 48 4 4 CD 31417 987 49 yards yard NNS 31417 987 50 of of IN 31417 987 51 a a DT 31417 987 52 useless useless JJ 31417 987 53 well well NN 31417 987 54 , , , 31417 987 55 20 20 CD 31417 987 56 feet foot NNS 31417 987 57 deep deep JJ 31417 987 58 , , , 31417 987 59 sunk sink VBN 31417 987 60 prior prior RB 31417 987 61 to to IN 31417 987 62 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 987 63 visit visit NN 31417 987 64 . . . 31417 988 1 In in IN 31417 988 2 corroboration corroboration NN 31417 988 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 988 4 encloses enclose VBZ 31417 988 5 the the DT 31417 988 6 following follow VBG 31417 988 7 letter:-- letter:-- JJS 31417 988 8 " " `` 31417 988 9 ' ' `` 31417 988 10 BRIDGWATER BRIDGWATER NNP 31417 988 11 , , , 31417 988 12 SOMERSET SOMERSET NNPS 31417 988 13 , , , 31417 988 14 _ _ NNP 31417 988 15 July July NNP 31417 988 16 _ _ NNP 31417 988 17 1896 1896 CD 31417 988 18 . . . 31417 989 1 " " `` 31417 989 2 ' ' `` 31417 989 3 We -PRON- PRP 31417 989 4 have have VBP 31417 989 5 sunk sink VBN 31417 989 6 a a DT 31417 989 7 well well NN 31417 989 8 in in IN 31417 989 9 the the DT 31417 989 10 garden garden NN 31417 989 11 , , , 31417 989 12 and and CC 31417 989 13 a a DT 31417 989 14 copious copious JJ 31417 989 15 spring spring NN 31417 989 16 has have VBZ 31417 989 17 been be VBN 31417 989 18 found find VBN 31417 989 19 at at IN 31417 989 20 13 13 CD 31417 989 21 feet foot NNS 31417 989 22 6 6 CD 31417 989 23 inches inch NNS 31417 989 24 , , , 31417 989 25 which which WDT 31417 989 26 amply amply RB 31417 989 27 verifies verify VBZ 31417 989 28 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 989 29 prediction prediction NN 31417 989 30 . . . 31417 990 1 " " `` 31417 990 2 ' ' `` 31417 990 3 J. J. NNP 31417 991 1 RUSCOMBE RUSCOMBE NNP 31417 991 2 POOLE POOLE NNP 31417 991 3 & & CC 31417 991 4 SON SON NNP 31417 991 5 . . . 31417 991 6 ' ' '' 31417 991 7 " " '' 31417 992 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 992 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 992 3 says say VBZ 31417 992 4 : : : 31417 992 5 " " `` 31417 992 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 992 7 wrote write VBD 31417 992 8 to to IN 31417 992 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 992 10 Ruscombe Ruscombe NNP 31417 992 11 Poole Poole NNP 31417 992 12 , , , 31417 992 13 and and CC 31417 992 14 asked ask VBD 31417 992 15 him -PRON- PRP 31417 992 16 if if IN 31417 992 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 992 18 Gataker Gataker NNP 31417 992 19 's 's POS 31417 992 20 statements statement NNS 31417 992 21 were be VBD 31417 992 22 correct correct JJ 31417 992 23 , , , 31417 992 24 and and CC 31417 992 25 he -PRON- PRP 31417 992 26 replies:-- replies:-- : 31417 992 27 " " `` 31417 992 28 ' ' `` 31417 992 29 BRIDGWATER BRIDGWATER NNP 31417 992 30 , , , 31417 992 31 _ _ NNP 31417 992 32 January January NNP 31417 992 33 _ _ NNP 31417 992 34 15 15 CD 31417 992 35 , , , 31417 992 36 1897 1897 CD 31417 992 37 . . . 31417 993 1 " " `` 31417 993 2 ' ' `` 31417 993 3 We -PRON- PRP 31417 993 4 return return VBP 31417 993 5 the the DT 31417 993 6 paper paper NN 31417 993 7 you -PRON- PRP 31417 993 8 sent send VBD 31417 993 9 us -PRON- PRP 31417 993 10 . . . 31417 994 1 As as IN 31417 994 2 regards regard VBZ 31417 994 3 the the DT 31417 994 4 statement statement NN 31417 994 5 that that IN 31417 994 6 there there EX 31417 994 7 was be VBD 31417 994 8 a a DT 31417 994 9 well well NN 31417 994 10 about about RB 31417 994 11 20 20 CD 31417 994 12 feet foot NNS 31417 994 13 deep deep JJ 31417 994 14 which which WDT 31417 994 15 was be VBD 31417 994 16 useless useless JJ 31417 994 17 , , , 31417 994 18 this this DT 31417 994 19 is be VBZ 31417 994 20 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 994 21 true true JJ 31417 994 22 , , , 31417 994 23 because because IN 31417 994 24 the the DT 31417 994 25 water water NN 31417 994 26 in in IN 31417 994 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 994 28 was be VBD 31417 994 29 foul foul JJ 31417 994 30 and and CC 31417 994 31 smelt smell VBN 31417 994 32 badly badly RB 31417 994 33 . . . 31417 995 1 The the DT 31417 995 2 supply supply NN 31417 995 3 found find VBD 31417 995 4 is be VBZ 31417 995 5 a a DT 31417 995 6 very very RB 31417 995 7 much much RB 31417 995 8 more more RBR 31417 995 9 copious copious JJ 31417 995 10 one one CD 31417 995 11 than than IN 31417 995 12 the the DT 31417 995 13 old old JJ 31417 995 14 well well NN 31417 995 15 , , , 31417 995 16 which which WDT 31417 995 17 contained contain VBD 31417 995 18 very very RB 31417 995 19 little little JJ 31417 995 20 water water NN 31417 995 21 . . . 31417 996 1 ' ' `` 31417 996 2 " " '' 31417 996 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 996 4 60 60 CD 31417 996 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 996 6 The the DT 31417 996 7 Index Index NNP 31417 996 8 to to IN 31417 996 9 Professor Professor NNP 31417 996 10 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 996 11 's 's POS 31417 996 12 Reports report NNS 31417 996 13 enumerates enumerate VBZ 31417 996 14 between between IN 31417 996 15 three three CD 31417 996 16 and and CC 31417 996 17 four four CD 31417 996 18 hundred hundred CD 31417 996 19 persons person NNS 31417 996 20 with with IN 31417 996 21 whom whom WP 31417 996 22 experiments experiment NNS 31417 996 23 with with IN 31417 996 24 the the DT 31417 996 25 Divining Divining NNP 31417 996 26 Rod Rod NNP 31417 996 27 are be VBP 31417 996 28 described describe VBN 31417 996 29 . . . 31417 997 1 A a DT 31417 997 2 list list NN 31417 997 3 of of IN 31417 997 4 the the DT 31417 997 5 names name NNS 31417 997 6 of of IN 31417 997 7 " " `` 31417 997 8 dowsers dowser NNS 31417 997 9 " " '' 31417 997 10 is be VBZ 31417 997 11 also also RB 31417 997 12 given give VBN 31417 997 13 . . . 31417 998 1 This this DT 31417 998 2 list list NN 31417 998 3 includes include VBZ 31417 998 4 the the DT 31417 998 5 names name NNS 31417 998 6 of of IN 31417 998 7 about about RB 31417 998 8 seventy seventy CD 31417 998 9 professional professional JJ 31417 998 10 " " `` 31417 998 11 dowsers dowser NNS 31417 998 12 , , , 31417 998 13 " " '' 31417 998 14 and and CC 31417 998 15 of of IN 31417 998 16 nearly nearly RB 31417 998 17 as as RB 31417 998 18 many many JJ 31417 998 19 amateur amateur NN 31417 998 20 " " `` 31417 998 21 dowsers dowser NNS 31417 998 22 . . . 31417 998 23 " " '' 31417 999 1 These these DT 31417 999 2 figures figure NNS 31417 999 3 show show VBP 31417 999 4 the the DT 31417 999 5 extent extent NN 31417 999 6 to to TO 31417 999 7 which which WDT 31417 999 8 the the DT 31417 999 9 use use NN 31417 999 10 of of IN 31417 999 11 the the DT 31417 999 12 rod rod NN 31417 999 13 prevails prevail VBZ 31417 999 14 , , , 31417 999 15 and and CC 31417 999 16 also also RB 31417 999 17 the the DT 31417 999 18 work work NN 31417 999 19 which which WDT 31417 999 20 the the DT 31417 999 21 preparation preparation NN 31417 999 22 of of IN 31417 999 23 the the DT 31417 999 24 Reports Reports NNPS 31417 999 25 involved involve VBD 31417 999 26 . . . 31417 1000 1 As as IN 31417 1000 2 a a DT 31417 1000 3 specimen speciman NNS 31417 1000 4 of of IN 31417 1000 5 the the DT 31417 1000 6 kind kind NN 31417 1000 7 of of IN 31417 1000 8 evidence evidence NN 31417 1000 9 presented present VBN 31417 1000 10 by by IN 31417 1000 11 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1000 12 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1000 13 from from IN 31417 1000 14 miscellaneous miscellaneous JJ 31417 1000 15 sources source NNS 31417 1000 16 , , , 31417 1000 17 the the DT 31417 1000 18 following follow VBG 31417 1000 19 may may MD 31417 1000 20 be be VB 31417 1000 21 quoted:-- quoted:-- ADD 31417 1000 22 " " `` 31417 1000 23 In in IN 31417 1000 24 the the DT 31417 1000 25 present present JJ 31417 1000 26 Report Report NNP 31417 1000 27 numerous numerous JJ 31417 1000 28 independent independent JJ 31417 1000 29 witnesses witness NNS 31417 1000 30 of of IN 31417 1000 31 unimpeachable unimpeachable JJ 31417 1000 32 integrity integrity NN 31417 1000 33 , , , 31417 1000 34 and and CC 31417 1000 35 some some DT 31417 1000 36 with with IN 31417 1000 37 high high JJ 31417 1000 38 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1000 39 attainments attainment NNS 31417 1000 40 , , , 31417 1000 41 testify testify VB 31417 1000 42 to to IN 31417 1000 43 the the DT 31417 1000 44 same same JJ 31417 1000 45 class class NN 31417 1000 46 of of IN 31417 1000 47 facts fact NNS 31417 1000 48 , , , 31417 1000 49 viz viz NN 31417 1000 50 . . . 31417 1001 1 : : : 31417 1001 2 --(1 --(1 LS 31417 1001 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1001 4 The the DT 31417 1001 5 automatic automatic JJ 31417 1001 6 and and CC 31417 1001 7 apparently apparently RB 31417 1001 8 irresistible irresistible JJ 31417 1001 9 motion motion NN 31417 1001 10 of of IN 31417 1001 11 the the DT 31417 1001 12 twig twig NN 31417 1001 13 in in IN 31417 1001 14 the the DT 31417 1001 15 hands hand NNS 31417 1001 16 often often RB 31417 1001 17 of of IN 31417 1001 18 a a DT 31417 1001 19 complete complete JJ 31417 1001 20 novice novice NN 31417 1001 21 ; ; : 31417 1001 22 and and CC 31417 1001 23 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1001 24 2 2 LS 31417 1001 25 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1001 26 that that IN 31417 1001 27 , , , 31417 1001 28 when when WRB 31417 1001 29 the the DT 31417 1001 30 forked forked JJ 31417 1001 31 twig twig NNP 31417 1001 32 does do VBZ 31417 1001 33 _ _ NNP 31417 1001 34 not not RB 31417 1001 35 _ _ NNP 31417 1001 36 move move NN 31417 1001 37 in in IN 31417 1001 38 a a DT 31417 1001 39 person person NN 31417 1001 40 's 's POS 31417 1001 41 hands hand NNS 31417 1001 42 , , , 31417 1001 43 if if IN 31417 1001 44 the the DT 31417 1001 45 dowser dowser NN 31417 1001 46 takes take VBZ 31417 1001 47 one one CD 31417 1001 48 link link NN 31417 1001 49 of of IN 31417 1001 50 the the DT 31417 1001 51 twig twig NN 31417 1001 52 , , , 31417 1001 53 or or CC 31417 1001 54 even even RB 31417 1001 55 places place VBZ 31417 1001 56 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1001 57 hand hand NN 31417 1001 58 on on IN 31417 1001 59 the the DT 31417 1001 60 wrist wrist NN 31417 1001 61 of of IN 31417 1001 62 the the DT 31417 1001 63 insensitive insensitive JJ 31417 1001 64 person person NN 31417 1001 65 , , , 31417 1001 66 the the DT 31417 1001 67 previously previously RB 31417 1001 68 inert inert JJ 31417 1001 69 twig twig NNP 31417 1001 70 now now RB 31417 1001 71 turns turn VBZ 31417 1001 72 vigorously vigorously RB 31417 1001 73 and and CC 31417 1001 74 often often RB 31417 1001 75 breaks break VBZ 31417 1001 76 in in IN 31417 1001 77 two two CD 31417 1001 78 in in IN 31417 1001 79 the the DT 31417 1001 80 effort effort NN 31417 1001 81 to to TO 31417 1001 82 resist resist VB 31417 1001 83 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1001 84 motion motion NN 31417 1001 85 . . . 31417 1002 1 As as IN 31417 1002 2 regards regard NNS 31417 1002 3 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1002 4 1 1 CD 31417 1002 5 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1002 6 , , , 31417 1002 7 see see VB 31417 1002 8 the the DT 31417 1002 9 letter letter NN 31417 1002 10 from from IN 31417 1002 11 the the DT 31417 1002 12 President President NNP 31417 1002 13 of of IN 31417 1002 14 the the DT 31417 1002 15 Royal Royal NNP 31417 1002 16 Geological Geological NNP 31417 1002 17 Society Society NNP 31417 1002 18 of of IN 31417 1002 19 Cornwall Cornwall NNP 31417 1002 20 on on IN 31417 1002 21 p. p. NNP 31417 1002 22 219,[61 219,[61 NN 31417 1002 23 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1002 24 who who WP 31417 1002 25 states state VBZ 31417 1002 26 that that IN 31417 1002 27 the the DT 31417 1002 28 Clerk Clerk NNP 31417 1002 29 of of IN 31417 1002 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1002 31 Parish Parish NNP 31417 1002 32 Council Council NNP 31417 1002 33 , , , 31417 1002 34 on on IN 31417 1002 35 finding find VBG 31417 1002 36 the the DT 31417 1002 37 rod rod NN 31417 1002 38 suddenly suddenly RB 31417 1002 39 twist twist NN 31417 1002 40 in in IN 31417 1002 41 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1002 42 hands hand NNS 31417 1002 43 , , , 31417 1002 44 called call VBN 31417 1002 45 out--'It out--'It NNP 31417 1002 46 is be VBZ 31417 1002 47 alive alive JJ 31417 1002 48 , , , 31417 1002 49 sir sir NN 31417 1002 50 , , , 31417 1002 51 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1002 52 is be VBZ 31417 1002 53 alive alive JJ 31417 1002 54 ! ! . 31417 1002 55 ' ' '' 31417 1003 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1003 2 Enys Enys NNP 31417 1003 3 adds add VBZ 31417 1003 4 : : : 31417 1003 5 ' ' `` 31417 1003 6 This this DT 31417 1003 7 exactly exactly RB 31417 1003 8 describes describe VBZ 31417 1003 9 the the DT 31417 1003 10 sensation sensation NN 31417 1003 11 when when WRB 31417 1003 12 the the DT 31417 1003 13 rod rod NN 31417 1003 14 moves move VBZ 31417 1003 15 . . . 31417 1003 16 ' ' '' 31417 1004 1 ... ... : 31417 1004 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1004 3 Bennett Bennett NNP 31417 1004 4 , , , 31417 1004 5 of of IN 31417 1004 6 Oxford Oxford NNP 31417 1004 7 , , , 31417 1004 8 on on IN 31417 1004 9 p. p. NN 31417 1004 10 176 176 CD 31417 1004 11 , , , 31417 1004 12 refers refer VBZ 31417 1004 13 to to IN 31417 1004 14 the the DT 31417 1004 15 frantic frantic JJ 31417 1004 16 motion motion NN 31417 1004 17 and and CC 31417 1004 18 the the DT 31417 1004 19 ultimate ultimate JJ 31417 1004 20 breaking breaking NN 31417 1004 21 of of IN 31417 1004 22 the the DT 31417 1004 23 twig twig NNP 31417 1004 24 ' ' '' 31417 1004 25 held hold VBN 31417 1004 26 firmly firmly RB 31417 1004 27 ' ' '' 31417 1004 28 in in IN 31417 1004 29 the the DT 31417 1004 30 dowser dowser NN 31417 1004 31 's 's POS 31417 1004 32 hands hand NNS 31417 1004 33 .... .... . 31417 1004 34 As as IN 31417 1004 35 regards regard NNS 31417 1004 36 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1004 37 2 2 CD 31417 1004 38 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1004 39 , , , 31417 1004 40 see see VB 31417 1004 41 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1004 42 Morton Morton NNP 31417 1004 43 's 's POS 31417 1004 44 letter letter NN 31417 1004 45 to to IN 31417 1004 46 _ _ NNP 31417 1004 47 The the DT 31417 1004 48 Engineer Engineer NNP 31417 1004 49 _ _ NNP 31417 1004 50 , , , 31417 1004 51 given give VBN 31417 1004 52 on on IN 31417 1004 53 p. p. NN 31417 1004 54 172 172 CD 31417 1004 55 ; ; : 31417 1004 56 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1004 57 Morton Morton NNP 31417 1004 58 found find VBD 31417 1004 59 the the DT 31417 1004 60 rod rod NN 31417 1004 61 would would MD 31417 1004 62 not not RB 31417 1004 63 move move VB 31417 1004 64 in in IN 31417 1004 65 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1004 66 hands hand NNS 31417 1004 67 , , , 31417 1004 68 but but CC 31417 1004 69 when when WRB 31417 1004 70 the the DT 31417 1004 71 late late JJ 31417 1004 72 John John NNP 31417 1004 73 Mullins Mullins NNP 31417 1004 74 , , , 31417 1004 75 the the DT 31417 1004 76 dowser dowser NN 31417 1004 77 , , , 31417 1004 78 ' ' '' 31417 1004 79 laid lay VBD 31417 1004 80 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1004 81 hands hand NNS 31417 1004 82 on on IN 31417 1004 83 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1004 84 wrists wrist NNS 31417 1004 85 and and CC 31417 1004 86 grasped grasp VBD 31417 1004 87 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1004 88 firmly firmly RB 31417 1004 89 , , , 31417 1004 90 then then RB 31417 1004 91 the the DT 31417 1004 92 twig twig NNP 31417 1004 93 instantly instantly RB 31417 1004 94 began begin VBD 31417 1004 95 to to TO 31417 1004 96 turn turn VB 31417 1004 97 , , , 31417 1004 98 and and CC 31417 1004 99 continued continue VBD 31417 1004 100 turning turn VBG 31417 1004 101 till till IN 31417 1004 102 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1004 103 removed remove VBD 31417 1004 104 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1004 105 hands hand NNS 31417 1004 106 . . . 31417 1005 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1005 2 never never RB 31417 1005 3 touched touch VBD 31417 1005 4 the the DT 31417 1005 5 twig twig NN 31417 1005 6 while while IN 31417 1005 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1005 8 was be VBD 31417 1005 9 in in IN 31417 1005 10 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1005 11 hands hand NNS 31417 1005 12 . . . 31417 1005 13 ' ' '' 31417 1006 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1006 2 Montague Montague NNP 31417 1006 3 Price Price NNP 31417 1006 4 in in IN 31417 1006 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1006 6 letter letter NN 31417 1006 7 on on IN 31417 1006 8 p. p. NN 31417 1006 9 181 181 CD 31417 1006 10 states state NNS 31417 1006 11 : : : 31417 1006 12 ' ' '' 31417 1006 13 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1006 14 held hold VBD 31417 1006 15 one one CD 31417 1006 16 side side NN 31417 1006 17 of of IN 31417 1006 18 the the DT 31417 1006 19 forked forked JJ 31417 1006 20 rod rod NN 31417 1006 21 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1006 22 and and CC 31417 1006 23 the the DT 31417 1006 24 diviner diviner NN 31417 1006 25 the the DT 31417 1006 26 other other JJ 31417 1006 27 , , , 31417 1006 28 and and CC 31417 1006 29 when when WRB 31417 1006 30 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1006 31 came come VBD 31417 1006 32 to to IN 31417 1006 33 water water NN 31417 1006 34 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1006 35 alleged allege VBN 31417 1006 36 underground underground JJ 31417 1006 37 water water NN 31417 1006 38 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1006 39 the the DT 31417 1006 40 strain strain NN 31417 1006 41 was be VBD 31417 1006 42 so so RB 31417 1006 43 great great JJ 31417 1006 44 on on IN 31417 1006 45 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1006 46 fingers finger NNS 31417 1006 47 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1006 48 was be VBD 31417 1006 49 obliged oblige VBN 31417 1006 50 to to TO 31417 1006 51 ask ask VB 31417 1006 52 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1006 53 to to TO 31417 1006 54 stop stop VB 31417 1006 55 . . . 31417 1007 1 From from IN 31417 1007 2 the the DT 31417 1007 3 position position NN 31417 1007 4 of of IN 31417 1007 5 the the DT 31417 1007 6 rod rod NN 31417 1007 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1007 8 was be VBD 31417 1007 9 almost almost RB 31417 1007 10 impossible impossible JJ 31417 1007 11 for for IN 31417 1007 12 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1007 13 to to TO 31417 1007 14 produce produce VB 31417 1007 15 the the DT 31417 1007 16 pressure pressure NN 31417 1007 17 , , , 31417 1007 18 which which WDT 31417 1007 19 increased increase VBD 31417 1007 20 with with IN 31417 1007 21 the the DT 31417 1007 22 strength strength NN 31417 1007 23 of of IN 31417 1007 24 the the DT 31417 1007 25 stream stream NN 31417 1007 26 . . . 31417 1007 27 ' ' '' 31417 1008 1 ... ... NFP 31417 1008 2 " " `` 31417 1008 3 The the DT 31417 1008 4 usual usual JJ 31417 1008 5 practice practice NN 31417 1008 6 , , , 31417 1008 7 after after IN 31417 1008 8 watching watch VBG 31417 1008 9 a a DT 31417 1008 10 dowser dowser NN 31417 1008 11 at at IN 31417 1008 12 work work NN 31417 1008 13 , , , 31417 1008 14 is be VBZ 31417 1008 15 for for IN 31417 1008 16 some some DT 31417 1008 17 of of IN 31417 1008 18 the the DT 31417 1008 19 onlookers onlooker NNS 31417 1008 20 to to TO 31417 1008 21 try try VB 31417 1008 22 if if IN 31417 1008 23 the the DT 31417 1008 24 forked forked JJ 31417 1008 25 twig twig NN 31417 1008 26 will will MD 31417 1008 27 move move VB 31417 1008 28 in in IN 31417 1008 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1008 30 hands hand NNS 31417 1008 31 . . . 31417 1009 1 Generally generally RB 31417 1009 2 speaking speak VBG 31417 1009 3 , , , 31417 1009 4 one one CD 31417 1009 5 or or CC 31417 1009 6 more more JJR 31417 1009 7 , , , 31417 1009 8 out out IN 31417 1009 9 of of IN 31417 1009 10 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 1009 11 ten ten CD 31417 1009 12 or or CC 31417 1009 13 twelve twelve CD 31417 1009 14 persons person NNS 31417 1009 15 , , , 31417 1009 16 discover discover VBP 31417 1009 17 , , , 31417 1009 18 to to IN 31417 1009 19 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1009 20 astonishment astonishment NN 31417 1009 21 , , , 31417 1009 22 that that IN 31417 1009 23 the the DT 31417 1009 24 twig twig NNP 31417 1009 25 curls curl VBZ 31417 1009 26 up up RP 31417 1009 27 in in IN 31417 1009 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1009 29 hands hand NNS 31417 1009 30 -- -- : 31417 1009 31 at at IN 31417 1009 32 the the DT 31417 1009 33 same same JJ 31417 1009 34 places place NNS 31417 1009 35 at at IN 31417 1009 36 which which WDT 31417 1009 37 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1009 38 did do VBD 31417 1009 39 with with IN 31417 1009 40 the the DT 31417 1009 41 dowser dowser NN 31417 1009 42 . . . 31417 1010 1 Here here RB 31417 1010 2 is be VBZ 31417 1010 3 such such PDT 31417 1010 4 an an DT 31417 1010 5 experience experience NN 31417 1010 6 . . . 31417 1011 1 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1011 2 Hollands Hollands NNP 31417 1011 3 writes write VBZ 31417 1011 4 to to IN 31417 1011 5 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1011 6 as as IN 31417 1011 7 follows:-- follows:-- `` 31417 1011 8 " " `` 31417 1011 9 ' ' `` 31417 1011 10 DENE DENE NNP 31417 1011 11 PARK PARK NNP 31417 1011 12 , , , 31417 1011 13 TONBRIDGE TONBRIDGE NNP 31417 1011 14 , , , 31417 1011 15 _ _ NNP 31417 1011 16 October October NNP 31417 1011 17 _ _ NNP 31417 1011 18 9 9 CD 31417 1011 19 , , , 31417 1011 20 1899 1899 CD 31417 1011 21 . . . 31417 1012 1 " " `` 31417 1012 2 ' ' `` 31417 1012 3 In in IN 31417 1012 4 answer answer NN 31417 1012 5 to to IN 31417 1012 6 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1012 7 note note NN 31417 1012 8 of of IN 31417 1012 9 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1012 10 about about IN 31417 1012 11 the the DT 31417 1012 12 divining divining NN 31417 1012 13 rod rod NN 31417 1012 14 , , , 31417 1012 15 the the DT 31417 1012 16 whole whole JJ 31417 1012 17 thing thing NN 31417 1012 18 is be VBZ 31417 1012 19 rather rather RB 31417 1012 20 a a DT 31417 1012 21 long long JJ 31417 1012 22 story story NN 31417 1012 23 , , , 31417 1012 24 but but CC 31417 1012 25 the the DT 31417 1012 26 practical practical JJ 31417 1012 27 result result NN 31417 1012 28 of of IN 31417 1012 29 the the DT 31417 1012 30 water water NN 31417 1012 31 dowser dowser NN 31417 1012 32 's 's POS 31417 1012 33 visit visit NN 31417 1012 34 was be VBD 31417 1012 35 to to TO 31417 1012 36 find find VB 31417 1012 37 water water NN 31417 1012 38 which which WDT 31417 1012 39 now now RB 31417 1012 40 supplies supply VBZ 31417 1012 41 the the DT 31417 1012 42 house house NN 31417 1012 43 . . . 31417 1013 1 One one CD 31417 1013 2 of of IN 31417 1013 3 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1013 4 daughters daughter NNS 31417 1013 5 found find VBD 31417 1013 6 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1013 7 had have VBD 31417 1013 8 the the DT 31417 1013 9 strange strange JJ 31417 1013 10 power power NN 31417 1013 11 which which WDT 31417 1013 12 moves move VBZ 31417 1013 13 the the DT 31417 1013 14 divining divining NN 31417 1013 15 rod rod NN 31417 1013 16 , , , 31417 1013 17 and and CC 31417 1013 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1013 19 works work VBZ 31417 1013 20 for for IN 31417 1013 21 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1013 22 now now RB 31417 1013 23 quickly quickly RB 31417 1013 24 over over IN 31417 1013 25 any any DT 31417 1013 26 spring spring NN 31417 1013 27 . . . 31417 1014 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 2 is be VBZ 31417 1014 3 most most RBS 31417 1014 4 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1014 5 , , , 31417 1014 6 as as IN 31417 1014 7 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 8 can can MD 31417 1014 9 feel feel VB 31417 1014 10 the the DT 31417 1014 11 rod rod NN 31417 1014 12 move move NN 31417 1014 13 if if IN 31417 1014 14 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 15 take take VBP 31417 1014 16 one one CD 31417 1014 17 side side NN 31417 1014 18 of of IN 31417 1014 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 20 , , , 31417 1014 21 and and CC 31417 1014 22 take take VB 31417 1014 23 one one CD 31417 1014 24 of of IN 31417 1014 25 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1014 26 hands hand NNS 31417 1014 27 , , , 31417 1014 28 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 29 holding hold VBG 31417 1014 30 the the DT 31417 1014 31 other other JJ 31417 1014 32 end end NN 31417 1014 33 of of IN 31417 1014 34 the the DT 31417 1014 35 rod rod NN 31417 1014 36 -- -- : 31417 1014 37 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 38 struggles struggle VBZ 31417 1014 39 up up RP 31417 1014 40 , , , 31417 1014 41 and and CC 31417 1014 42 would would MD 31417 1014 43 break break VB 31417 1014 44 off off RP 31417 1014 45 altogether altogether RB 31417 1014 46 if if IN 31417 1014 47 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 48 did do VBD 31417 1014 49 not not RB 31417 1014 50 allow allow VB 31417 1014 51 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1014 52 to to TO 31417 1014 53 move move VB 31417 1014 54 . . . 31417 1015 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1015 2 daughter daughter NN 31417 1015 3 has have VBZ 31417 1015 4 since since IN 31417 1015 5 found find VBN 31417 1015 6 several several JJ 31417 1015 7 springs spring NNS 31417 1015 8 on on IN 31417 1015 9 the the DT 31417 1015 10 estate estate NN 31417 1015 11 , , , 31417 1015 12 where where WRB 31417 1015 13 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1015 14 have have VBP 31417 1015 15 sunk sink VBN 31417 1015 16 wells well NNS 31417 1015 17 . . . 31417 1016 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1016 2 have have VBP 31417 1016 3 stood stand VBN 31417 1016 4 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1016 5 in in IN 31417 1016 6 very very RB 31417 1016 7 good good JJ 31417 1016 8 stead stead NN 31417 1016 9 these these DT 31417 1016 10 last last JJ 31417 1016 11 dry dry JJ 31417 1016 12 seasons season NNS 31417 1016 13 . . . 31417 1017 1 MINNIE MINNIE NNP 31417 1017 2 HOLLANDS holland NNS 31417 1017 3 . . . 31417 1017 4 ' ' '' 31417 1018 1 " " `` 31417 1018 2 A a DT 31417 1018 3 similar similar JJ 31417 1018 4 experience experience NN 31417 1018 5 is be VBZ 31417 1018 6 given give VBN 31417 1018 7 by by IN 31417 1018 8 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1018 9 M. M. NNP 31417 1018 10 Craigie Craigie NNP 31417 1018 11 Halkett Halkett NNP 31417 1018 12 , , , 31417 1018 13 who who WP 31417 1018 14 published publish VBD 31417 1018 15 some some DT 31417 1018 16 excellent excellent JJ 31417 1018 17 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1018 18 of of IN 31417 1018 19 a a DT 31417 1018 20 dowser dowser NN 31417 1018 21 at at IN 31417 1018 22 work work NN 31417 1018 23 in in IN 31417 1018 24 _ _ NNP 31417 1018 25 Sketch Sketch NNP 31417 1018 26 _ _ NNP 31417 1018 27 for for IN 31417 1018 28 23rd 23rd JJ 31417 1018 29 August August NNP 31417 1018 30 1899 1899 CD 31417 1018 31 . . . 31417 1019 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1019 2 Halkett Halkett NNP 31417 1019 3 writes write VBZ 31417 1019 4 to to IN 31417 1019 5 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1019 6 as as IN 31417 1019 7 follows:-- follows:-- ADD 31417 1019 8 " " `` 31417 1019 9 LAURISTON LAURISTON NNP 31417 1019 10 , , , 31417 1019 11 NEW NEW NNP 31417 1019 12 ELTHAM ELTHAM NNP 31417 1019 13 , , , 31417 1019 14 KENT KENT NNP 31417 1019 15 , , , 31417 1019 16 _ _ NNP 31417 1019 17 September September NNP 31417 1019 18 _ _ NNP 31417 1019 19 8 8 CD 31417 1019 20 , , , 31417 1019 21 1899 1899 CD 31417 1019 22 . . . 31417 1020 1 " " `` 31417 1020 2 The the DT 31417 1020 3 man man NN 31417 1020 4 depicted depict VBD 31417 1020 5 in in IN 31417 1020 6 the the DT 31417 1020 7 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1020 8 is be VBZ 31417 1020 9 not not RB 31417 1020 10 a a DT 31417 1020 11 water water NN 31417 1020 12 - - HYPH 31417 1020 13 finder finder NN 31417 1020 14 by by IN 31417 1020 15 profession profession NN 31417 1020 16 . . . 31417 1021 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1021 2 is be VBZ 31417 1021 3 a a DT 31417 1021 4 tenant tenant NN 31417 1021 5 farmer farmer NN 31417 1021 6 residing reside VBG 31417 1021 7 at at IN 31417 1021 8 Catcolt Catcolt NNP 31417 1021 9 , , , 31417 1021 10 a a DT 31417 1021 11 village village NN 31417 1021 12 near near IN 31417 1021 13 Bridgwater Bridgwater NNP 31417 1021 14 , , , 31417 1021 15 and and CC 31417 1021 16 merely merely RB 31417 1021 17 exercises exercise VBZ 31417 1021 18 the the DT 31417 1021 19 art art NN 31417 1021 20 to to TO 31417 1021 21 oblige oblige VB 31417 1021 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1021 23 neighbours neighbour NNS 31417 1021 24 . . . 31417 1022 1 Several several JJ 31417 1022 2 of of IN 31417 1022 3 the the DT 31417 1022 4 country country NN 31417 1022 5 people people NNS 31417 1022 6 in in IN 31417 1022 7 this this DT 31417 1022 8 neighbourhood neighbourhood NN 31417 1022 9 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1022 10 Somerset Somerset NNP 31417 1022 11 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1022 12 have have VBP 31417 1022 13 the the DT 31417 1022 14 gift gift NN 31417 1022 15 . . . 31417 1023 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1023 2 has have VBZ 31417 1023 3 never never RB 31417 1023 4 been be VBN 31417 1023 5 known know VBN 31417 1023 6 to to TO 31417 1023 7 fail fail VB 31417 1023 8 . . . 31417 1024 1 Personally personally RB 31417 1024 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1024 3 was be VBD 31417 1024 4 rather rather RB 31417 1024 5 sceptical sceptical JJ 31417 1024 6 on on IN 31417 1024 7 the the DT 31417 1024 8 subject subject NN 31417 1024 9 , , , 31417 1024 10 but but CC 31417 1024 11 was be VBD 31417 1024 12 converted convert VBN 31417 1024 13 by by IN 31417 1024 14 the the DT 31417 1024 15 stick stick NN 31417 1024 16 turning turn VBG 31417 1024 17 in in RP 31417 1024 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1024 19 hands hand NNS 31417 1024 20 when when WRB 31417 1024 21 standing stand VBG 31417 1024 22 over over IN 31417 1024 23 a a DT 31417 1024 24 spring spring NN 31417 1024 25 . . . 31417 1025 1 There there EX 31417 1025 2 were be VBD 31417 1025 3 about about RB 31417 1025 4 six six CD 31417 1025 5 persons person NNS 31417 1025 6 present present JJ 31417 1025 7 at at IN 31417 1025 8 the the DT 31417 1025 9 time time NN 31417 1025 10 ; ; : 31417 1025 11 all all DT 31417 1025 12 tried try VBD 31417 1025 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1025 14 , , , 31417 1025 15 but but CC 31417 1025 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1025 17 would would MD 31417 1025 18 turn turn VB 31417 1025 19 for for IN 31417 1025 20 no no DT 31417 1025 21 one one NN 31417 1025 22 excepting except VBG 31417 1025 23 the the DT 31417 1025 24 man man NN 31417 1025 25 in in IN 31417 1025 26 the the DT 31417 1025 27 picture picture NN 31417 1025 28 and and CC 31417 1025 29 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1025 30 . . . 31417 1026 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1026 2 experienced experience VBD 31417 1026 3 a a DT 31417 1026 4 sort sort NN 31417 1026 5 of of IN 31417 1026 6 tingling tingle VBG 31417 1026 7 sensation sensation NN 31417 1026 8 in in IN 31417 1026 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1026 10 arms arm NNS 31417 1026 11 and and CC 31417 1026 12 wrists wrist NNS 31417 1026 13 , , , 31417 1026 14 but but CC 31417 1026 15 otherwise otherwise RB 31417 1026 16 was be VBD 31417 1026 17 quite quite RB 31417 1026 18 unaware unaware JJ 31417 1026 19 when when WRB 31417 1026 20 the the DT 31417 1026 21 forked fork VBN 31417 1026 22 stick stick NN 31417 1026 23 began begin VBD 31417 1026 24 to to TO 31417 1026 25 turn turn VB 31417 1026 26 , , , 31417 1026 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1026 28 seemed seem VBD 31417 1026 29 to to TO 31417 1026 30 go go VB 31417 1026 31 over over RP 31417 1026 32 so so RB 31417 1026 33 quickly quickly RB 31417 1026 34 . . . 31417 1027 1 " " `` 31417 1027 2 ' ' `` 31417 1027 3 MAUDE maude JJ 31417 1027 4 CRAIGIE craigie NN 31417 1027 5 HALKETT halkett NN 31417 1027 6 . . . 31417 1027 7 ' ' '' 31417 1028 1 " " `` 31417 1028 2 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1028 3 Halkett Halkett NNP 31417 1028 4 does do VBZ 31417 1028 5 not not RB 31417 1028 6 say say VB 31417 1028 7 how how WRB 31417 1028 8 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1028 9 knew know VBD 31417 1028 10 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1028 11 was be VBD 31417 1028 12 ' ' `` 31417 1028 13 standing stand VBG 31417 1028 14 over over IN 31417 1028 15 a a DT 31417 1028 16 spring spring NN 31417 1028 17 ' ' '' 31417 1028 18 when when WRB 31417 1028 19 the the DT 31417 1028 20 twig twig NNP 31417 1028 21 turned turn VBD 31417 1028 22 in in RP 31417 1028 23 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1028 24 hands hand NNS 31417 1028 25 ; ; : 31417 1028 26 this this DT 31417 1028 27 statement statement NN 31417 1028 28 is be VBZ 31417 1028 29 very very RB 31417 1028 30 characteristic characteristic JJ 31417 1028 31 of of IN 31417 1028 32 many many JJ 31417 1028 33 others other NNS 31417 1028 34 that that WDT 31417 1028 35 have have VBP 31417 1028 36 reached reach VBN 31417 1028 37 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1028 38 . . . 31417 1029 1 " " `` 31417 1029 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1029 3 62 62 CD 31417 1029 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1029 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1029 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1029 7 's 's POS 31417 1029 8 views view NNS 31417 1029 9 as as IN 31417 1029 10 to to IN 31417 1029 11 the the DT 31417 1029 12 source source NN 31417 1029 13 of of IN 31417 1029 14 the the DT 31417 1029 15 power power NN 31417 1029 16 which which WDT 31417 1029 17 moves move VBZ 31417 1029 18 the the DT 31417 1029 19 rod rod NN 31417 1029 20 are be VBP 31417 1029 21 entitled entitle VBN 31417 1029 22 to to IN 31417 1029 23 more more JJR 31417 1029 24 attention attention NN 31417 1029 25 than than IN 31417 1029 26 those those DT 31417 1029 27 of of IN 31417 1029 28 any any DT 31417 1029 29 one one NN 31417 1029 30 else else RB 31417 1029 31 . . . 31417 1030 1 In in IN 31417 1030 2 a a DT 31417 1030 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 1030 4 on on IN 31417 1030 5 " " `` 31417 1030 6 Theoretical Theoretical NNP 31417 1030 7 Conclusions Conclusions NNPS 31417 1030 8 " " '' 31417 1030 9 in in IN 31417 1030 10 the the DT 31417 1030 11 first first JJ 31417 1030 12 of of IN 31417 1030 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1030 14 two two CD 31417 1030 15 Reports Reports NNPS 31417 1030 16 , , , 31417 1030 17 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1030 18 says say VBZ 31417 1030 19 : : : 31417 1030 20 " " `` 31417 1030 21 Few few JJ 31417 1030 22 will will MD 31417 1030 23 dispute dispute VB 31417 1030 24 the the DT 31417 1030 25 proposition proposition NN 31417 1030 26 that that IN 31417 1030 27 the the DT 31417 1030 28 motion motion NN 31417 1030 29 of of IN 31417 1030 30 the the DT 31417 1030 31 forked forked JJ 31417 1030 32 twig twig NN 31417 1030 33 is be VBZ 31417 1030 34 due due JJ 31417 1030 35 to to IN 31417 1030 36 unconscious unconscious JJ 31417 1030 37 muscular muscular JJ 31417 1030 38 action action NN 31417 1030 39 . . . 31417 1030 40 " " '' 31417 1031 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1031 2 then then RB 31417 1031 3 gives give VBZ 31417 1031 4 a a DT 31417 1031 5 summary summary NN 31417 1031 6 of of IN 31417 1031 7 the the DT 31417 1031 8 causes cause NNS 31417 1031 9 which which WDT 31417 1031 10 , , , 31417 1031 11 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1031 12 believes believe VBZ 31417 1031 13 , , , 31417 1031 14 determine determine VB 31417 1031 15 that that DT 31417 1031 16 action action NN 31417 1031 17 . . . 31417 1032 1 Among among IN 31417 1032 2 these these DT 31417 1032 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1032 4 enumerates enumerate VBZ 31417 1032 5 , , , 31417 1032 6 impressions impression NNS 31417 1032 7 from from IN 31417 1032 8 without without IN 31417 1032 9 unconsciously unconsciously RB 31417 1032 10 made make VBN 31417 1032 11 upon upon IN 31417 1032 12 the the DT 31417 1032 13 dowser dowser NN 31417 1032 14 's 's POS 31417 1032 15 mind mind NN 31417 1032 16 from from IN 31417 1032 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1032 18 own own JJ 31417 1032 19 trained trained JJ 31417 1032 20 observation observation NN 31417 1032 21 and and CC 31417 1032 22 practice practice NN 31417 1032 23 , , , 31417 1032 24 and and CC 31417 1032 25 from from IN 31417 1032 26 bystanders bystander NNS 31417 1032 27 . . . 31417 1033 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1033 2 also also RB 31417 1033 3 believed believe VBD 31417 1033 4 that that IN 31417 1033 5 in in IN 31417 1033 6 some some DT 31417 1033 7 cases case NNS 31417 1033 8 an an DT 31417 1033 9 impression impression NN 31417 1033 10 appears appear VBZ 31417 1033 11 to to TO 31417 1033 12 be be VB 31417 1033 13 gained gain VBN 31417 1033 14 through through IN 31417 1033 15 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1033 16 - - HYPH 31417 1033 17 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1033 18 . . . 31417 1034 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1034 2 did do VBD 31417 1034 3 not not RB 31417 1034 4 , , , 31417 1034 5 however however RB 31417 1034 6 , , , 31417 1034 7 think think VB 31417 1034 8 this this DT 31417 1034 9 covered cover VBD 31417 1034 10 the the DT 31417 1034 11 whole whole JJ 31417 1034 12 ground ground NN 31417 1034 13 . . . 31417 1035 1 A a DT 31417 1035 2 peculiar peculiar JJ 31417 1035 3 pathological pathological JJ 31417 1035 4 effect effect NN 31417 1035 5 is be VBZ 31417 1035 6 produced produce VBN 31417 1035 7 on on IN 31417 1035 8 the the DT 31417 1035 9 dowser dowser NN 31417 1035 10 ; ; : 31417 1035 11 but but CC 31417 1035 12 to to IN 31417 1035 13 what what WP 31417 1035 14 this this DT 31417 1035 15 is be VBZ 31417 1035 16 due due JJ 31417 1035 17 can can MD 31417 1035 18 only only RB 31417 1035 19 be be VB 31417 1035 20 ascertained ascertain VBN 31417 1035 21 by by IN 31417 1035 22 persevering persevere VBG 31417 1035 23 and and CC 31417 1035 24 unbiassed unbiassed JJ 31417 1035 25 investigation investigation NN 31417 1035 26 . . . 31417 1036 1 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1036 2 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1036 3 's 's POS 31417 1036 4 second second JJ 31417 1036 5 Report Report NNP 31417 1036 6 contains contain VBZ 31417 1036 7 a a DT 31417 1036 8 long long JJ 31417 1036 9 and and CC 31417 1036 10 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1036 11 discussion discussion NN 31417 1036 12 of of IN 31417 1036 13 this this DT 31417 1036 14 problem problem NN 31417 1036 15 . . . 31417 1037 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1037 2 views view NNS 31417 1037 3 had have VBD 31417 1037 4 undergone undergo VBN 31417 1037 5 some some DT 31417 1037 6 modification modification NN 31417 1037 7 . . . 31417 1038 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1038 2 adheres adhere VBZ 31417 1038 3 to to IN 31417 1038 4 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1038 5 previous previous JJ 31417 1038 6 view view NN 31417 1038 7 that that IN 31417 1038 8 the the DT 31417 1038 9 " " `` 31417 1038 10 curious curious JJ 31417 1038 11 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1038 12 attending attend VBG 31417 1038 13 the the DT 31417 1038 14 _ _ NNP 31417 1038 15 motion motion NN 31417 1038 16 _ _ NNP 31417 1038 17 of of IN 31417 1038 18 the the DT 31417 1038 19 so so RB 31417 1038 20 - - HYPH 31417 1038 21 called call VBN 31417 1038 22 divining divining NN 31417 1038 23 rod rod NN 31417 1038 24 are be VBP 31417 1038 25 capable capable JJ 31417 1038 26 of of IN 31417 1038 27 explanation explanation NN 31417 1038 28 by by IN 31417 1038 29 causes cause NNS 31417 1038 30 known know VBN 31417 1038 31 to to IN 31417 1038 32 science science NN 31417 1038 33 " " '' 31417 1038 34 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1038 35 _ _ NNP 31417 1038 36 e.g. e.g. NNP 31417 1038 37 _ _ NNP 31417 1038 38 involuntary involuntary JJ 31417 1038 39 muscular muscular JJ 31417 1038 40 action action NN 31417 1038 41 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1038 42 . . . 31417 1039 1 But but CC 31417 1039 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1039 3 has have VBZ 31417 1039 4 become become VBN 31417 1039 5 more more RBR 31417 1039 6 impressed impressed JJ 31417 1039 7 with with IN 31417 1039 8 the the DT 31417 1039 9 view view NN 31417 1039 10 that that IN 31417 1039 11 the the DT 31417 1039 12 suggestion suggestion NN 31417 1039 13 may may MD 31417 1039 14 arise arise VB 31417 1039 15 " " `` 31417 1039 16 from from IN 31417 1039 17 some some DT 31417 1039 18 kind kind NN 31417 1039 19 of of IN 31417 1039 20 transcendental transcendental JJ 31417 1039 21 discernment discernment NN 31417 1039 22 possessed possess VBN 31417 1039 23 by by IN 31417 1039 24 the the DT 31417 1039 25 dowser dowser NN 31417 1039 26 's 's POS 31417 1039 27 subconscious subconscious JJ 31417 1039 28 self self NN 31417 1039 29 . . . 31417 1039 30 " " '' 31417 1040 1 And and CC 31417 1040 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1040 3 further further RB 31417 1040 4 says say VBZ 31417 1040 5 : : : 31417 1040 6 " " `` 31417 1040 7 For for IN 31417 1040 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1040 9 own own JJ 31417 1040 10 part part NN 31417 1040 11 , , , 31417 1040 12 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1040 13 am be VBP 31417 1040 14 disposed disposed JJ 31417 1040 15 to to TO 31417 1040 16 think think VB 31417 1040 17 that that IN 31417 1040 18 this this DT 31417 1040 19 cause cause NN 31417 1040 20 , , , 31417 1040 21 though though IN 31417 1040 22 less less RBR 31417 1040 23 acceptable acceptable JJ 31417 1040 24 to to IN 31417 1040 25 science science NN 31417 1040 26 , , , 31417 1040 27 will will MD 31417 1040 28 be be VB 31417 1040 29 found find VBN 31417 1040 30 to to TO 31417 1040 31 be be VB 31417 1040 32 a a DT 31417 1040 33 truer truer NN 31417 1040 34 explanation explanation NN 31417 1040 35 of of IN 31417 1040 36 the the DT 31417 1040 37 more more RBR 31417 1040 38 striking striking JJ 31417 1040 39 successes success NNS 31417 1040 40 of of IN 31417 1040 41 a a DT 31417 1040 42 good good JJ 31417 1040 43 dowser dowser NN 31417 1040 44 . . . 31417 1040 45 " " '' 31417 1041 1 In in IN 31417 1041 2 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 1041 3 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1041 4 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1041 5 says say VBZ 31417 1041 6 still still RB 31417 1041 7 more more RBR 31417 1041 8 definitely definitely RB 31417 1041 9 : : : 31417 1041 10 " " `` 31417 1041 11 This this DT 31417 1041 12 subconscious subconscious JJ 31417 1041 13 perceptive perceptive JJ 31417 1041 14 power power NN 31417 1041 15 , , , 31417 1041 16 commonly commonly RB 31417 1041 17 called call VBN 31417 1041 18 ' ' '' 31417 1041 19 clairvoyance clairvoyance NN 31417 1041 20 , , , 31417 1041 21 ' ' '' 31417 1041 22 may may MD 31417 1041 23 provisionally provisionally RB 31417 1041 24 be be VB 31417 1041 25 taken take VBN 31417 1041 26 as as IN 31417 1041 27 the the DT 31417 1041 28 explanation explanation NN 31417 1041 29 of of IN 31417 1041 30 those those DT 31417 1041 31 successes success NNS 31417 1041 32 of of IN 31417 1041 33 the the DT 31417 1041 34 dowser dowser NN 31417 1041 35 which which WDT 31417 1041 36 are be VBP 31417 1041 37 inexplicable inexplicable JJ 31417 1041 38 on on IN 31417 1041 39 any any DT 31417 1041 40 grounds ground NNS 31417 1041 41 at at IN 31417 1041 42 present present NN 31417 1041 43 known know VBN 31417 1041 44 to to IN 31417 1041 45 science science NN 31417 1041 46 . . . 31417 1042 1 " " `` 31417 1042 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1042 3 63 63 CD 31417 1042 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1042 5 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 1042 6 : : : 31417 1042 7 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1042 8 55 55 CD 31417 1042 9 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1042 10 _ _ NNP 31417 1042 11 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1042 12 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1042 13 _ _ NNP 31417 1042 14 , , , 31417 1042 15 vol vol NNP 31417 1042 16 . . . 31417 1043 1 ii ii LS 31417 1043 2 . . . 31417 1044 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1044 2 . . . 31417 1045 1 79 79 CD 31417 1045 2 - - SYM 31417 1045 3 107 107 CD 31417 1045 4 . . . 31417 1046 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1046 2 56 56 CD 31417 1046 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1046 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 1046 5 . . . 31417 1046 6 , , , 31417 1046 7 vol vol NNP 31417 1046 8 . . . 31417 1047 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1047 2 . . . 31417 1048 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1048 2 Part part NN 31417 1048 3 XXXII XXXII NNP 31417 1048 4 . . . 31417 1049 1 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1049 2 , , , 31417 1049 3 pp pp NNP 31417 1049 4 . . . 31417 1050 1 2 2 LS 31417 1050 2 - - SYM 31417 1050 3 282 282 CD 31417 1050 4 , , , 31417 1050 5 and and CC 31417 1050 6 vol vol NNP 31417 1050 7 . . . 31417 1051 1 xv xv NNP 31417 1051 2 . . . 31417 1052 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1052 2 Part part NN 31417 1052 3 XXXVI XXXVI NNP 31417 1052 4 . . . 31417 1053 1 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1053 2 , , , 31417 1053 3 pp pp NNP 31417 1053 4 . . . 31417 1054 1 130 130 CD 31417 1054 2 - - SYM 31417 1054 3 383 383 CD 31417 1054 4 . . . 31417 1055 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1055 2 57 57 CD 31417 1055 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1055 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1055 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1055 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1055 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1055 8 , , , 31417 1055 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1055 10 . . . 31417 1056 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1056 2 . . . 31417 1057 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1057 2 . . . 31417 1058 1 145 145 CD 31417 1058 2 - - SYM 31417 1058 3 148 148 CD 31417 1058 4 . . . 31417 1059 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1059 2 58 58 CD 31417 1059 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1059 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1059 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1059 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1059 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1059 8 , , , 31417 1059 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1059 10 . . . 31417 1060 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1060 2 . . . 31417 1061 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1061 2 . . . 31417 1062 1 88 88 CD 31417 1062 2 - - SYM 31417 1062 3 89 89 CD 31417 1062 4 . . . 31417 1063 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1063 2 59 59 CD 31417 1063 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1063 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1063 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1063 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1063 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1063 8 , , , 31417 1063 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1063 10 . . . 31417 1064 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1064 2 . . . 31417 1065 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1065 2 . . . 31417 1066 1 89 89 CD 31417 1066 2 - - SYM 31417 1066 3 90 90 CD 31417 1066 4 . . . 31417 1067 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1067 2 60 60 CD 31417 1067 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1067 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1067 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1067 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1067 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1067 8 , , , 31417 1067 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1067 10 . . . 31417 1068 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1068 2 . . . 31417 1069 1 p. p. NN 31417 1069 2 182 182 CD 31417 1069 3 . . . 31417 1070 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1070 2 61 61 CD 31417 1070 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1070 4 The the DT 31417 1070 5 pages page NNS 31417 1070 6 in in IN 31417 1070 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 8 this this DT 31417 1070 9 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 10 paragraph paragraph NN 31417 1070 11 refer refer NN 31417 1070 12 to to IN 31417 1070 13 the the DT 31417 1070 14 present present JJ 31417 1070 15 Report Report NNP 31417 1070 16 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1070 17 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 18 i.e. i.e. FW 31417 1070 19 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 20 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 21 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1070 22 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1070 23 _ _ NNP 31417 1070 24 , , , 31417 1070 25 vol vol NNP 31417 1070 26 . . . 31417 1071 1 xv xv NNP 31417 1071 2 . . . 31417 1072 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1072 2 . . . 31417 1073 1 130 130 CD 31417 1073 2 - - SYM 31417 1073 3 383 383 CD 31417 1073 4 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1073 5 . . . 31417 1074 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1074 2 62 62 CD 31417 1074 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1074 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1074 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1074 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1074 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1074 8 , , , 31417 1074 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1074 10 . . . 31417 1075 1 xv xv NNP 31417 1075 2 . . . 31417 1076 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1076 2 . . . 31417 1077 1 279 279 CD 31417 1077 2 - - SYM 31417 1077 3 281 281 CD 31417 1077 4 . . . 31417 1078 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1078 2 63 63 CD 31417 1078 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1078 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1078 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1078 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1078 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1078 8 , , , 31417 1078 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1078 10 . . . 31417 1079 1 xv xv NNP 31417 1079 2 . . . 31417 1080 1 p. p. NN 31417 1080 2 314 314 CD 31417 1080 3 . . . 31417 1081 1 See see VB 31417 1081 2 also also RB 31417 1081 3 the the DT 31417 1081 4 whole whole JJ 31417 1081 5 discussion discussion NN 31417 1081 6 of of IN 31417 1081 7 which which WDT 31417 1081 8 this this DT 31417 1081 9 page page NN 31417 1081 10 is be VBZ 31417 1081 11 the the DT 31417 1081 12 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 1081 13 . . . 31417 1082 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 31417 1082 2 VIII viii NN 31417 1082 3 THOUGHT THOUGHT NNP 31417 1082 4 - - HYPH 31417 1082 5 TRANSFERENCE transference NN 31417 1082 6 DRAWINGS DRAWINGS NNP 31417 1082 7 There there EX 31417 1082 8 is be VBZ 31417 1082 9 one one CD 31417 1082 10 , , , 31417 1082 11 and and CC 31417 1082 12 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 1082 13 only only RB 31417 1082 14 one one CD 31417 1082 15 phase phase NN 31417 1082 16 of of IN 31417 1082 17 the the DT 31417 1082 18 great great JJ 31417 1082 19 subject subject NN 31417 1082 20 of of IN 31417 1082 21 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1082 22 - - HYPH 31417 1082 23 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1082 24 or or CC 31417 1082 25 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1082 26 the the DT 31417 1082 27 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 1082 28 of of IN 31417 1082 29 which which WDT 31417 1082 30 can can MD 31417 1082 31 legitimately legitimately RB 31417 1082 32 be be VB 31417 1082 33 included include VBN 31417 1082 34 among among IN 31417 1082 35 physical physical JJ 31417 1082 36 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1082 37 . . . 31417 1083 1 Involuntary involuntary JJ 31417 1083 2 drawing draw VBG 31417 1083 3 or or CC 31417 1083 4 scribbling scribble VBG 31417 1083 5 is be VBZ 31417 1083 6 a a DT 31417 1083 7 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 1083 8 of of IN 31417 1083 9 very very RB 31417 1083 10 common common JJ 31417 1083 11 occurrence occurrence NN 31417 1083 12 . . . 31417 1084 1 But but CC 31417 1084 2 when when WRB 31417 1084 3 such such PDT 31417 1084 4 an an DT 31417 1084 5 involuntary involuntary JJ 31417 1084 6 drawing drawing NN 31417 1084 7 turns turn VBZ 31417 1084 8 out out RP 31417 1084 9 to to TO 31417 1084 10 be be VB 31417 1084 11 a a DT 31417 1084 12 more more RBR 31417 1084 13 or or CC 31417 1084 14 less less RBR 31417 1084 15 exact exact JJ 31417 1084 16 copy copy NN 31417 1084 17 of of IN 31417 1084 18 a a DT 31417 1084 19 drawing drawing NN 31417 1084 20 which which WDT 31417 1084 21 the the DT 31417 1084 22 involuntary involuntary JJ 31417 1084 23 draughtsman draughtsman NNP 31417 1084 24 has have VBZ 31417 1084 25 never never RB 31417 1084 26 seen see VBN 31417 1084 27 ; ; : 31417 1084 28 and and CC 31417 1084 29 still still RB 31417 1084 30 further further RB 31417 1084 31 when when WRB 31417 1084 32 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1084 33 turns turn VBZ 31417 1084 34 out out RP 31417 1084 35 that that IN 31417 1084 36 the the DT 31417 1084 37 original original JJ 31417 1084 38 drawing drawing NN 31417 1084 39 has have VBZ 31417 1084 40 been be VBN 31417 1084 41 drawn draw VBN 31417 1084 42 by by IN 31417 1084 43 another another DT 31417 1084 44 person person NN 31417 1084 45 with with IN 31417 1084 46 the the DT 31417 1084 47 deliberate deliberate JJ 31417 1084 48 purpose purpose NN 31417 1084 49 of of IN 31417 1084 50 impressing impress VBG 31417 1084 51 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1084 52 on on IN 31417 1084 53 the the DT 31417 1084 54 mind mind NN 31417 1084 55 of of IN 31417 1084 56 the the DT 31417 1084 57 involuntary involuntary JJ 31417 1084 58 draughtsman draughtsman NNP 31417 1084 59 , , , 31417 1084 60 the the DT 31417 1084 61 subject subject NN 31417 1084 62 assumes assume VBZ 31417 1084 63 an an DT 31417 1084 64 entirely entirely RB 31417 1084 65 new new JJ 31417 1084 66 interest interest NN 31417 1084 67 . . . 31417 1085 1 This this DT 31417 1085 2 , , , 31417 1085 3 however however RB 31417 1085 4 , , , 31417 1085 5 is be VBZ 31417 1085 6 the the DT 31417 1085 7 history history NN 31417 1085 8 of of IN 31417 1085 9 those those DT 31417 1085 10 series series NN 31417 1085 11 of of IN 31417 1085 12 " " `` 31417 1085 13 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1085 14 - - HYPH 31417 1085 15 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1085 16 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1085 17 " " '' 31417 1085 18 which which WDT 31417 1085 19 have have VBP 31417 1085 20 been be VBN 31417 1085 21 published publish VBN 31417 1085 22 by by IN 31417 1085 23 the the DT 31417 1085 24 Society Society NNP 31417 1085 25 for for IN 31417 1085 26 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1085 27 Research Research NNP 31417 1085 28 . . . 31417 1086 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1086 2 are be VBP 31417 1086 3 scattered scatter VBN 31417 1086 4 through through IN 31417 1086 5 several several JJ 31417 1086 6 volumes volume NNS 31417 1086 7 of of IN 31417 1086 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1086 9 publications publication NNS 31417 1086 10 . . . 31417 1087 1 Through through IN 31417 1087 2 the the DT 31417 1087 3 kindness kindness NN 31417 1087 4 of of IN 31417 1087 5 the the DT 31417 1087 6 Council Council NNP 31417 1087 7 of of IN 31417 1087 8 that that DT 31417 1087 9 Society Society NNP 31417 1087 10 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1087 11 am be VBP 31417 1087 12 able able JJ 31417 1087 13 to to TO 31417 1087 14 put put VB 31417 1087 15 before before IN 31417 1087 16 the the DT 31417 1087 17 reader reader NN 31417 1087 18 the the DT 31417 1087 19 largest large JJS 31417 1087 20 selection selection NN 31417 1087 21 of of IN 31417 1087 22 these these DT 31417 1087 23 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1087 24 which which WDT 31417 1087 25 has have VBZ 31417 1087 26 appeared appear VBN 31417 1087 27 . . . 31417 1088 1 The the DT 31417 1088 2 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1088 3 are be VBP 31417 1088 4 the the DT 31417 1088 5 results result NNS 31417 1088 6 of of IN 31417 1088 7 several several JJ 31417 1088 8 different different JJ 31417 1088 9 groups group NNS 31417 1088 10 of of IN 31417 1088 11 experimenters experimenter NNS 31417 1088 12 in in IN 31417 1088 13 different different JJ 31417 1088 14 parts part NNS 31417 1088 15 of of IN 31417 1088 16 the the DT 31417 1088 17 country country NN 31417 1088 18 ; ; : 31417 1088 19 and and CC 31417 1088 20 the the DT 31417 1088 21 selection selection NN 31417 1088 22 has have VBZ 31417 1088 23 been be VBN 31417 1088 24 made make VBN 31417 1088 25 from from IN 31417 1088 26 as as RB 31417 1088 27 many many JJ 31417 1088 28 groups group NNS 31417 1088 29 as as IN 31417 1088 30 possible possible JJ 31417 1088 31 . . . 31417 1089 1 In in IN 31417 1089 2 all all DT 31417 1089 3 cases case NNS 31417 1089 4 facsimiles facsimile NNS 31417 1089 5 of of IN 31417 1089 6 the the DT 31417 1089 7 original original JJ 31417 1089 8 drawing drawing NN 31417 1089 9 and and CC 31417 1089 10 of of IN 31417 1089 11 the the DT 31417 1089 12 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1089 13 are be VBP 31417 1089 14 given give VBN 31417 1089 15 . . . 31417 1090 1 The the DT 31417 1090 2 earlier early JJR 31417 1090 3 series series NN 31417 1090 4 done do VBN 31417 1090 5 under under IN 31417 1090 6 the the DT 31417 1090 7 auspices auspex NNS 31417 1090 8 of of IN 31417 1090 9 a a DT 31417 1090 10 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1090 11 of of IN 31417 1090 12 the the DT 31417 1090 13 Society Society NNP 31417 1090 14 do do VBP 31417 1090 15 not not RB 31417 1090 16 represent represent VB 31417 1090 17 successes success NNS 31417 1090 18 picked pick VBN 31417 1090 19 out out IN 31417 1090 20 of of IN 31417 1090 21 a a DT 31417 1090 22 large large JJ 31417 1090 23 number number NN 31417 1090 24 of of IN 31417 1090 25 failures failure NNS 31417 1090 26 , , , 31417 1090 27 but but CC 31417 1090 28 include include VBP 31417 1090 29 all all PDT 31417 1090 30 the the DT 31417 1090 31 attempts attempt NNS 31417 1090 32 made make VBN 31417 1090 33 at at IN 31417 1090 34 the the DT 31417 1090 35 time time NN 31417 1090 36 . . . 31417 1091 1 The the DT 31417 1091 2 number number NN 31417 1091 3 that that WDT 31417 1091 4 can can MD 31417 1091 5 be be VB 31417 1091 6 considered consider VBN 31417 1091 7 total total JJ 31417 1091 8 failures failure NNS 31417 1091 9 in in IN 31417 1091 10 any any DT 31417 1091 11 of of IN 31417 1091 12 the the DT 31417 1091 13 trials trial NNS 31417 1091 14 is be VBZ 31417 1091 15 exceedingly exceedingly RB 31417 1091 16 small small JJ 31417 1091 17 . . . 31417 1092 1 Any any DT 31417 1092 2 conceivable conceivable JJ 31417 1092 3 chance chance NN 31417 1092 4 or or CC 31417 1092 5 coincidence coincidence NN 31417 1092 6 is be VBZ 31417 1092 7 entirely entirely RB 31417 1092 8 inadequate inadequate JJ 31417 1092 9 to to TO 31417 1092 10 account account VB 31417 1092 11 for for IN 31417 1092 12 the the DT 31417 1092 13 similarity similarity NN 31417 1092 14 in in IN 31417 1092 15 the the DT 31417 1092 16 great great JJ 31417 1092 17 majority majority NN 31417 1092 18 of of IN 31417 1092 19 cases case NNS 31417 1092 20 . . . 31417 1093 1 The the DT 31417 1093 2 " " `` 31417 1093 3 First First NNP 31417 1093 4 Report Report NNP 31417 1093 5 on on IN 31417 1093 6 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1093 7 - - HYPH 31417 1093 8 Reading reading NN 31417 1093 9 " " '' 31417 1093 10 was be VBD 31417 1093 11 written write VBN 31417 1093 12 by by IN 31417 1093 13 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1093 14 W. W. NNP 31417 1093 15 F. F. NNP 31417 1093 16 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1093 17 , , , 31417 1093 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1093 19 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1093 20 , , , 31417 1093 21 and and CC 31417 1093 22 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1093 23 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1093 24 , , , 31417 1093 25 and and CC 31417 1093 26 was be VBD 31417 1093 27 read read VBN 31417 1093 28 at at IN 31417 1093 29 the the DT 31417 1093 30 first first JJ 31417 1093 31 General General NNP 31417 1093 32 Meeting Meeting NNP 31417 1093 33 of of IN 31417 1093 34 the the DT 31417 1093 35 Society Society NNP 31417 1093 36 on on IN 31417 1093 37 17th 17th JJ 31417 1093 38 July July NNP 31417 1093 39 1882 1882 CD 31417 1093 40 . . . 31417 1094 1 In in IN 31417 1094 2 order order NN 31417 1094 3 to to TO 31417 1094 4 illustrate illustrate VB 31417 1094 5 the the DT 31417 1094 6 then then RB 31417 1094 7 state state NN 31417 1094 8 of of IN 31417 1094 9 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1094 10 opinion opinion NN 31417 1094 11 , , , 31417 1094 12 the the DT 31417 1094 13 writers writer NNS 31417 1094 14 say say VBP 31417 1094 15 : : : 31417 1094 16 " " `` 31417 1094 17 The the DT 31417 1094 18 present present JJ 31417 1094 19 state state NN 31417 1094 20 of of IN 31417 1094 21 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1094 22 opinion opinion NN 31417 1094 23 throughout throughout IN 31417 1094 24 the the DT 31417 1094 25 world world NN 31417 1094 26 is be VBZ 31417 1094 27 not not RB 31417 1094 28 only only RB 31417 1094 29 hostile hostile JJ 31417 1094 30 to to IN 31417 1094 31 any any DT 31417 1094 32 belief belief NN 31417 1094 33 in in IN 31417 1094 34 the the DT 31417 1094 35 possibility possibility NN 31417 1094 36 of of IN 31417 1094 37 transmitting transmit VBG 31417 1094 38 a a DT 31417 1094 39 single single JJ 31417 1094 40 mental mental JJ 31417 1094 41 concept concept NN 31417 1094 42 except except IN 31417 1094 43 through through IN 31417 1094 44 the the DT 31417 1094 45 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1094 46 channels channel NNS 31417 1094 47 of of IN 31417 1094 48 sensations sensation NNS 31417 1094 49 , , , 31417 1094 50 but but CC 31417 1094 51 , , , 31417 1094 52 generally generally RB 31417 1094 53 speaking speak VBG 31417 1094 54 , , , 31417 1094 55 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1094 56 is be VBZ 31417 1094 57 hostile hostile JJ 31417 1094 58 even even RB 31417 1094 59 to to IN 31417 1094 60 any any DT 31417 1094 61 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1094 62 upon upon IN 31417 1094 63 the the DT 31417 1094 64 matter matter NN 31417 1094 65 . . . 31417 1095 1 Every every DT 31417 1095 2 leading lead VBG 31417 1095 3 physiologist physiologist NN 31417 1095 4 and and CC 31417 1095 5 psychologist psychologist VB 31417 1095 6 down down RP 31417 1095 7 to to IN 31417 1095 8 the the DT 31417 1095 9 present present JJ 31417 1095 10 time time NN 31417 1095 11 has have VBZ 31417 1095 12 relegated relegate VBN 31417 1095 13 what what WP 31417 1095 14 , , , 31417 1095 15 for for IN 31417 1095 16 want want NN 31417 1095 17 of of IN 31417 1095 18 a a DT 31417 1095 19 better well JJR 31417 1095 20 term term NN 31417 1095 21 , , , 31417 1095 22 has have VBZ 31417 1095 23 been be VBN 31417 1095 24 called call VBN 31417 1095 25 " " `` 31417 1095 26 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1095 27 - - HYPH 31417 1095 28 Reading reading NN 31417 1095 29 " " '' 31417 1095 30 to to IN 31417 1095 31 the the DT 31417 1095 32 limbo limbo NN 31417 1095 33 of of IN 31417 1095 34 explored explore VBN 31417 1095 35 fallacies fallacy NNS 31417 1095 36 . . . 31417 1096 1 " " `` 31417 1096 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1096 3 64 64 CD 31417 1096 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1096 5 A a DT 31417 1096 6 second second JJ 31417 1096 7 Report report NN 31417 1096 8 by by IN 31417 1096 9 the the DT 31417 1096 10 same same JJ 31417 1096 11 writers writer NNS 31417 1096 12 was be VBD 31417 1096 13 read read VBN 31417 1096 14 at at IN 31417 1096 15 a a DT 31417 1096 16 meeting meeting NN 31417 1096 17 of of IN 31417 1096 18 the the DT 31417 1096 19 Society Society NNP 31417 1096 20 in in IN 31417 1096 21 the the DT 31417 1096 22 same same JJ 31417 1096 23 year year NN 31417 1096 24 . . . 31417 1097 1 In in IN 31417 1097 2 this this DT 31417 1097 3 Report Report NNP 31417 1097 4 the the DT 31417 1097 5 first first JJ 31417 1097 6 series series NN 31417 1097 7 of of IN 31417 1097 8 " " `` 31417 1097 9 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1097 10 - - HYPH 31417 1097 11 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1097 12 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1097 13 " " '' 31417 1097 14 was be VBD 31417 1097 15 described describe VBN 31417 1097 16 . . . 31417 1098 1 The the DT 31417 1098 2 method method NN 31417 1098 3 of of IN 31417 1098 4 proceeding proceeding NN 31417 1098 5 was be VBD 31417 1098 6 as as IN 31417 1098 7 follows:--A. follows:--a. NN 31417 1098 8 makes make VBZ 31417 1098 9 an an DT 31417 1098 10 outline outline JJ 31417 1098 11 sketch sketch NN 31417 1098 12 of of IN 31417 1098 13 a a DT 31417 1098 14 geometrical geometrical JJ 31417 1098 15 figure figure NN 31417 1098 16 , , , 31417 1098 17 or or CC 31417 1098 18 of of IN 31417 1098 19 something something NN 31417 1098 20 a a DT 31417 1098 21 little little RB 31417 1098 22 more more RBR 31417 1098 23 elaborate elaborate JJ 31417 1098 24 . . . 31417 1099 1 B. B. NNP 31417 1099 2 sees see VBZ 31417 1099 3 this this DT 31417 1099 4 sketch sketch NN 31417 1099 5 , , , 31417 1099 6 and and CC 31417 1099 7 carrying carry VBG 31417 1099 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1099 9 in in IN 31417 1099 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1099 11 mind mind NN 31417 1099 12 goes go VBZ 31417 1099 13 and and CC 31417 1099 14 stands stand VBZ 31417 1099 15 behind behind IN 31417 1099 16 C. C. NNP 31417 1099 17 , , , 31417 1099 18 who who WP 31417 1099 19 sits sit VBZ 31417 1099 20 with with IN 31417 1099 21 a a DT 31417 1099 22 pencil pencil NN 31417 1099 23 and and CC 31417 1099 24 paper paper NN 31417 1099 25 before before IN 31417 1099 26 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1099 27 and and CC 31417 1099 28 draws draw VBZ 31417 1099 29 the the DT 31417 1099 30 impression impression NN 31417 1099 31 which which WDT 31417 1099 32 arises arise VBZ 31417 1099 33 in in IN 31417 1099 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1099 35 mind mind NN 31417 1099 36 . . . 31417 1100 1 Precautions precaution NNS 31417 1100 2 are be VBP 31417 1100 3 taken take VBN 31417 1100 4 against against IN 31417 1100 5 the the DT 31417 1100 6 conveyance conveyance NN 31417 1100 7 of of IN 31417 1100 8 information information NN 31417 1100 9 by by IN 31417 1100 10 any any DT 31417 1100 11 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1100 12 means mean NNS 31417 1100 13 . . . 31417 1101 1 Except except IN 31417 1101 2 in in IN 31417 1101 3 a a DT 31417 1101 4 few few JJ 31417 1101 5 of of IN 31417 1101 6 the the DT 31417 1101 7 earliest early JJS 31417 1101 8 trials trial NNS 31417 1101 9 no no DT 31417 1101 10 contact contact NN 31417 1101 11 between between IN 31417 1101 12 any any DT 31417 1101 13 of of IN 31417 1101 14 the the DT 31417 1101 15 parties party NNS 31417 1101 16 was be VBD 31417 1101 17 permitted permit VBN 31417 1101 18 . . . 31417 1102 1 B. B. NNP 31417 1102 2 and and CC 31417 1102 3 C. C. NNP 31417 1102 4 are be VBP 31417 1102 5 called call VBN 31417 1102 6 respectively respectively RB 31417 1102 7 " " `` 31417 1102 8 transmitter transmitter NN 31417 1102 9 " " '' 31417 1102 10 and and CC 31417 1102 11 " " `` 31417 1102 12 receiver receiver FW 31417 1102 13 . . . 31417 1102 14 " " '' 31417 1103 1 In in IN 31417 1103 2 December December NNP 31417 1103 3 1882 1882 CD 31417 1103 4 , , , 31417 1103 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1103 6 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1103 7 and and CC 31417 1103 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1103 9 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1103 10 paid pay VBD 31417 1103 11 a a DT 31417 1103 12 visit visit NN 31417 1103 13 to to IN 31417 1103 14 Brighton Brighton NNP 31417 1103 15 to to TO 31417 1103 16 personally personally RB 31417 1103 17 investigate investigate VB 31417 1103 18 some some DT 31417 1103 19 joint joint JJ 31417 1103 20 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1103 21 of of IN 31417 1103 22 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1103 23 Douglas Douglas NNP 31417 1103 24 Blackburn Blackburn NNP 31417 1103 25 and and CC 31417 1103 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1103 27 G. G. NNP 31417 1103 28 Albert Albert NNP 31417 1103 29 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1103 30 . . . 31417 1104 1 Both both CC 31417 1104 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1104 3 Blackburn Blackburn NNP 31417 1104 4 and and CC 31417 1104 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1104 6 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1104 7 were be VBD 31417 1104 8 then then RB 31417 1104 9 , , , 31417 1104 10 or or CC 31417 1104 11 soon soon RB 31417 1104 12 after after IN 31417 1104 13 became become VBD 31417 1104 14 , , , 31417 1104 15 members member NNS 31417 1104 16 of of IN 31417 1104 17 the the DT 31417 1104 18 Society Society NNP 31417 1104 19 for for IN 31417 1104 20 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1104 21 Research Research NNP 31417 1104 22 . . . 31417 1105 1 The the DT 31417 1105 2 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1105 3 were be VBD 31417 1105 4 made make VBN 31417 1105 5 in in IN 31417 1105 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1105 7 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1105 8 ' ' POS 31417 1105 9 and and CC 31417 1105 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1105 11 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1105 12 's 's POS 31417 1105 13 own own JJ 31417 1105 14 lodgings lodging NNS 31417 1105 15 . . . 31417 1106 1 The the DT 31417 1106 2 following follow VBG 31417 1106 3 plan plan NN 31417 1106 4 , , , 31417 1106 5 arranged arrange VBN 31417 1106 6 in in IN 31417 1106 7 regard regard NN 31417 1106 8 to to IN 31417 1106 9 some some DT 31417 1106 10 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1106 11 made make VBN 31417 1106 12 on on IN 31417 1106 13 4th 4th JJ 31417 1106 14 December December NNP 31417 1106 15 , , , 31417 1106 16 is be VBZ 31417 1106 17 thus thus RB 31417 1106 18 described describe VBN 31417 1106 19 by by IN 31417 1106 20 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1106 21 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1106 22 : : : 31417 1106 23 " " `` 31417 1106 24 One one CD 31417 1106 25 of of IN 31417 1106 26 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1106 27 completely completely RB 31417 1106 28 out out IN 31417 1106 29 of of IN 31417 1106 30 sight sight NN 31417 1106 31 of of IN 31417 1106 32 S. S. NNP 31417 1106 33 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1106 34 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1106 35 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1106 36 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1106 37 drew draw VBD 31417 1106 38 some some DT 31417 1106 39 figure figure NN 31417 1106 40 at at IN 31417 1106 41 random random JJ 31417 1106 42 , , , 31417 1106 43 the the DT 31417 1106 44 figure figure NN 31417 1106 45 being being NN 31417 1106 46 of of IN 31417 1106 47 such such PDT 31417 1106 48 a a DT 31417 1106 49 character character NN 31417 1106 50 that that IN 31417 1106 51 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1106 52 shape shape NN 31417 1106 53 could could MD 31417 1106 54 not not RB 31417 1106 55 be be VB 31417 1106 56 easily easily RB 31417 1106 57 conveyed convey VBN 31417 1106 58 in in IN 31417 1106 59 words word NNS 31417 1106 60 .... .... . 31417 1107 1 The the DT 31417 1107 2 figure figure NN 31417 1107 3 , , , 31417 1107 4 drawn draw VBN 31417 1107 5 by by IN 31417 1107 6 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1107 7 , , , 31417 1107 8 was be VBD 31417 1107 9 then then RB 31417 1107 10 shown show VBN 31417 1107 11 to to IN 31417 1107 12 B. B. NNP 31417 1108 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1108 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1108 3 Blackburn Blackburn NNP 31417 1108 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1108 5 for for IN 31417 1108 6 a a DT 31417 1108 7 few few JJ 31417 1108 8 moments moment NNS 31417 1108 9 , , , 31417 1108 10 S. S. NNP 31417 1108 11 being be VBG 31417 1108 12 seated seat VBN 31417 1108 13 all all PDT 31417 1108 14 the the DT 31417 1108 15 time time NN 31417 1108 16 with with IN 31417 1108 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1108 18 back back NN 31417 1108 19 to to IN 31417 1108 20 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1108 21 , , , 31417 1108 22 and and CC 31417 1108 23 blindfolded blindfold VBD 31417 1108 24 , , , 31417 1108 25 in in IN 31417 1108 26 a a DT 31417 1108 27 distant distant JJ 31417 1108 28 part part NN 31417 1108 29 of of IN 31417 1108 30 the the DT 31417 1108 31 same same JJ 31417 1108 32 room room NN 31417 1108 33 , , , 31417 1108 34 and and CC 31417 1108 35 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 1108 36 in in IN 31417 1108 37 an an DT 31417 1108 38 adjoining adjoining JJ 31417 1108 39 room room NN 31417 1108 40 . . . 31417 1109 1 B. B. NNP 31417 1109 2 looked look VBD 31417 1109 3 at at IN 31417 1109 4 the the DT 31417 1109 5 figure figure NN 31417 1109 6 drawn draw VBN 31417 1109 7 ; ; : 31417 1109 8 then then RB 31417 1109 9 held hold VBD 31417 1109 10 S. S. NNP 31417 1109 11 's 's POS 31417 1109 12 hand hand NN 31417 1109 13 for for IN 31417 1109 14 a a DT 31417 1109 15 while while NN 31417 1109 16 ; ; : 31417 1109 17 then then RB 31417 1109 18 released release VBD 31417 1109 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1109 20 . . . 31417 1110 1 After after IN 31417 1110 2 being be VBG 31417 1110 3 released release VBN 31417 1110 4 , , , 31417 1110 5 S. S. NNP 31417 1110 6 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1110 7 who who WP 31417 1110 8 remained remain VBD 31417 1110 9 blindfolded blindfolded JJ 31417 1110 10 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1110 11 drew draw VBD 31417 1110 12 the the DT 31417 1110 13 impression impression NN 31417 1110 14 of of IN 31417 1110 15 a a DT 31417 1110 16 figure figure NN 31417 1110 17 which which WDT 31417 1110 18 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1110 19 had have VBD 31417 1110 20 received receive VBN 31417 1110 21 .... .... . 31417 1111 1 In in IN 31417 1111 2 no no DT 31417 1111 3 case case NN 31417 1111 4 was be VBD 31417 1111 5 there there RB 31417 1111 6 the the DT 31417 1111 7 smallest small JJS 31417 1111 8 possibility possibility NN 31417 1111 9 that that IN 31417 1111 10 S. S. NNP 31417 1111 11 could could MD 31417 1111 12 have have VB 31417 1111 13 seen see VBN 31417 1111 14 the the DT 31417 1111 15 original original JJ 31417 1111 16 figure figure NN 31417 1111 17 ; ; : 31417 1111 18 and and CC 31417 1111 19 in in IN 31417 1111 20 no no DT 31417 1111 21 case case NN 31417 1111 22 did do VBD 31417 1111 23 B. B. NNP 31417 1111 24 touch touch VB 31417 1111 25 S. S. NNP 31417 1111 26 , , , 31417 1111 27 even even RB 31417 1111 28 in in IN 31417 1111 29 the the DT 31417 1111 30 slightest slight JJS 31417 1111 31 manner manner NN 31417 1111 32 , , , 31417 1111 33 while while IN 31417 1111 34 the the DT 31417 1111 35 figure figure NN 31417 1111 36 was be VBD 31417 1111 37 being be VBG 31417 1111 38 drawn draw VBN 31417 1111 39 . . . 31417 1111 40 " " '' 31417 1112 1 The the DT 31417 1112 2 whole whole JJ 31417 1112 3 series series NN 31417 1112 4 of of IN 31417 1112 5 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1112 6 done do VBN 31417 1112 7 in in IN 31417 1112 8 this this DT 31417 1112 9 way way NN 31417 1112 10 , , , 31417 1112 11 on on IN 31417 1112 12 that that DT 31417 1112 13 occasion occasion NN 31417 1112 14 , , , 31417 1112 15 is be VBZ 31417 1112 16 given give VBN 31417 1112 17 in in IN 31417 1112 18 the the DT 31417 1112 19 Report Report NNP 31417 1112 20 in in IN 31417 1112 21 the the DT 31417 1112 22 _ _ NNP 31417 1112 23 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1113 1 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1113 2 _ _ NNP 31417 1113 3 . . . 31417 1114 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1114 2 were be VBD 31417 1114 3 nine nine CD 31417 1114 4 in in IN 31417 1114 5 number number NN 31417 1114 6 . . . 31417 1115 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1115 2 have have VBP 31417 1115 3 selected select VBN 31417 1115 4 two two CD 31417 1115 5 , , , 31417 1115 6 Nos Nos NNP 31417 1115 7 . . . 31417 1116 1 5 5 CD 31417 1116 2 and and CC 31417 1116 3 9 9 CD 31417 1116 4 . . . 31417 1117 1 No no UH 31417 1117 2 . . . 31417 1118 1 5 5 CD 31417 1118 2 calls call NNS 31417 1118 3 for for IN 31417 1118 4 no no DT 31417 1118 5 special special JJ 31417 1118 6 remark remark NN 31417 1118 7 . . . 31417 1119 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1119 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1119 3 : : : 31417 1119 4 NO no UH 31417 1119 5 . . . 31417 1120 1 5 5 CD 31417 1120 2 . . . 31417 1121 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1121 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1121 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1121 4 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1121 5 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1121 6 : : : 31417 1121 7 NO no UH 31417 1121 8 . . . 31417 1122 1 9 9 CD 31417 1122 2 . . . 31417 1123 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1123 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1123 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1123 4 When when WRB 31417 1123 5 the the DT 31417 1123 6 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1123 7 of of IN 31417 1123 8 No no UH 31417 1123 9 . . . 31417 1124 1 9 9 CD 31417 1124 2 was be VBD 31417 1124 3 drawn draw VBN 31417 1124 4 , , , 31417 1124 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1124 6 S. S. NNP 31417 1124 7 touched touch VBD 31417 1124 8 the the DT 31417 1124 9 spot spot NN 31417 1124 10 to to TO 31417 1124 11 which which WDT 31417 1124 12 the the DT 31417 1124 13 arrow arrow NN 31417 1124 14 points point NNS 31417 1124 15 , , , 31417 1124 16 and and CC 31417 1124 17 said say VBD 31417 1124 18 : : : 31417 1124 19 " " `` 31417 1124 20 There there EX 31417 1124 21 is be VBZ 31417 1124 22 something something NN 31417 1124 23 more more JJR 31417 1124 24 there there RB 31417 1124 25 , , , 31417 1124 26 but but CC 31417 1124 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1124 28 can can MD 31417 1124 29 not not RB 31417 1124 30 tell tell VB 31417 1124 31 what what WP 31417 1124 32 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1124 33 is be VBZ 31417 1124 34 . . . 31417 1124 35 " " '' 31417 1125 1 In in IN 31417 1125 2 the the DT 31417 1125 3 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1125 4 made make VBD 31417 1125 5 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 1125 6 to to IN 31417 1125 7 these these DT 31417 1125 8 , , , 31417 1125 9 the the DT 31417 1125 10 conditions condition NNS 31417 1125 11 were be VBD 31417 1125 12 still still RB 31417 1125 13 more more RBR 31417 1125 14 stringent stringent JJ 31417 1125 15 , , , 31417 1125 16 and and CC 31417 1125 17 no no DT 31417 1125 18 contact contact NN 31417 1125 19 whatever whatever WDT 31417 1125 20 was be VBD 31417 1125 21 allowed allow VBN 31417 1125 22 between between IN 31417 1125 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1125 24 Blackburn Blackburn NNP 31417 1125 25 and and CC 31417 1125 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1125 27 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1125 28 ; ; : 31417 1125 29 and and CC 31417 1125 30 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1125 31 will will MD 31417 1125 32 be be VB 31417 1125 33 seen see VBN 31417 1125 34 that that IN 31417 1125 35 striking striking JJ 31417 1125 36 and and CC 31417 1125 37 successful successful JJ 31417 1125 38 results result NNS 31417 1125 39 were be VBD 31417 1125 40 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1125 41 . . . 31417 1126 1 A a DT 31417 1126 2 few few JJ 31417 1126 3 weeks week NNS 31417 1126 4 later later RB 31417 1126 5 , , , 31417 1126 6 in in IN 31417 1126 7 January January NNP 31417 1126 8 1883 1883 CD 31417 1126 9 , , , 31417 1126 10 at at IN 31417 1126 11 the the DT 31417 1126 12 invitation invitation NN 31417 1126 13 of of IN 31417 1126 14 the the DT 31417 1126 15 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1126 16 of of IN 31417 1126 17 the the DT 31417 1126 18 Society Society NNP 31417 1126 19 for for IN 31417 1126 20 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1126 21 Research Research NNP 31417 1126 22 , , , 31417 1126 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1126 24 Blackburn Blackburn NNP 31417 1126 25 and and CC 31417 1126 26 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1126 27 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1126 28 came come VBD 31417 1126 29 from from IN 31417 1126 30 Brighton Brighton NNP 31417 1126 31 , , , 31417 1126 32 and and CC 31417 1126 33 a a DT 31417 1126 34 series series NN 31417 1126 35 of of IN 31417 1126 36 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1126 37 was be VBD 31417 1126 38 conducted conduct VBN 31417 1126 39 at at IN 31417 1126 40 the the DT 31417 1126 41 Rooms room NNS 31417 1126 42 the the DT 31417 1126 43 Society Society NNP 31417 1126 44 then then RB 31417 1126 45 occupied occupy VBN 31417 1126 46 in in IN 31417 1126 47 Dean Dean NNP 31417 1126 48 's 's POS 31417 1126 49 Yard Yard NNP 31417 1126 50 , , , 31417 1126 51 Westminster Westminster NNP 31417 1126 52 . . . 31417 1127 1 For for IN 31417 1127 2 the the DT 31417 1127 3 Report Report NNP 31417 1127 4 embodying embody VBG 31417 1127 5 the the DT 31417 1127 6 results result NNS 31417 1127 7 of of IN 31417 1127 8 these these DT 31417 1127 9 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1127 10 , , , 31417 1127 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1127 12 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1127 13 , , , 31417 1127 14 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1127 15 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1127 16 , , , 31417 1127 17 and and CC 31417 1127 18 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1127 19 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1127 20 are be VBP 31417 1127 21 specially specially RB 31417 1127 22 responsible responsible JJ 31417 1127 23 . . . 31417 1128 1 Two two CD 31417 1128 2 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1128 3 , , , 31417 1128 4 Nos Nos NNP 31417 1128 5 . . . 31417 1129 1 10 10 CD 31417 1129 2 and and CC 31417 1129 3 11 11 CD 31417 1129 4 , , , 31417 1129 5 are be VBP 31417 1129 6 selected select VBN 31417 1129 7 from from IN 31417 1129 8 a a DT 31417 1129 9 series series NN 31417 1129 10 of of IN 31417 1129 11 twenty twenty CD 31417 1129 12 - - HYPH 31417 1129 13 two two CD 31417 1129 14 made make VBN 31417 1129 15 on on IN 31417 1129 16 this this DT 31417 1129 17 occasion occasion NN 31417 1129 18 . . . 31417 1130 1 As as IN 31417 1130 2 to to IN 31417 1130 3 No no UH 31417 1130 4 . . . 31417 1131 1 10 10 CD 31417 1131 2 , , , 31417 1131 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1131 4 S. S. NNP 31417 1131 5 had have VBD 31417 1131 6 no no DT 31417 1131 7 idea idea NN 31417 1131 8 that that IN 31417 1131 9 the the DT 31417 1131 10 original original NN 31417 1131 11 was be VBD 31417 1131 12 not not RB 31417 1131 13 a a DT 31417 1131 14 geometrical geometrical JJ 31417 1131 15 diagram diagram NN 31417 1131 16 . . . 31417 1132 1 Nor nor CC 31417 1132 2 had have VBD 31417 1132 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1132 4 any any DT 31417 1132 5 clue clue NN 31417 1132 6 given give VBN 31417 1132 7 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1132 8 as as IN 31417 1132 9 to to IN 31417 1132 10 the the DT 31417 1132 11 character character NN 31417 1132 12 of of IN 31417 1132 13 No no UH 31417 1132 14 . . . 31417 1133 1 11 11 CD 31417 1133 2 . . . 31417 1134 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1134 2 added add VBD 31417 1134 3 the the DT 31417 1134 4 line line NN 31417 1134 5 marked mark VBN 31417 1134 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1134 7 b b NNP 31417 1134 8 _ _ NNP 31417 1134 9 some some DT 31417 1134 10 time time NN 31417 1134 11 after after IN 31417 1134 12 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1134 13 had have VBD 31417 1134 14 drawn draw VBN 31417 1134 15 the the DT 31417 1134 16 line line NN 31417 1134 17 marked mark VBN 31417 1134 18 _ _ NNP 31417 1134 19 a a DT 31417 1134 20 _ _ NNP 31417 1134 21 , , , 31417 1134 22 saying say VBG 31417 1134 23 that that IN 31417 1134 24 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1134 25 saw see VBD 31417 1134 26 " " `` 31417 1134 27 a a DT 31417 1134 28 line line NN 31417 1134 29 parallel parallel JJ 31417 1134 30 to to IN 31417 1134 31 another another DT 31417 1134 32 somewhere somewhere RB 31417 1134 33 . . . 31417 1134 34 " " '' 31417 1135 1 The the DT 31417 1135 2 authors author NNS 31417 1135 3 of of IN 31417 1135 4 this this DT 31417 1135 5 Report Report NNP 31417 1135 6 say say VB 31417 1135 7 : : : 31417 1135 8 " " `` 31417 1135 9 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1135 10 is be VBZ 31417 1135 11 almost almost RB 31417 1135 12 needless needless JJ 31417 1135 13 to to TO 31417 1135 14 point point VB 31417 1135 15 out out RP 31417 1135 16 that that IN 31417 1135 17 in in IN 31417 1135 18 these these DT 31417 1135 19 observations observation NNS 31417 1135 20 so so RB 31417 1135 21 foreign foreign JJ 31417 1135 22 to to IN 31417 1135 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1135 24 common common JJ 31417 1135 25 experience experience NN 31417 1135 26 , , , 31417 1135 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1135 28 is be VBZ 31417 1135 29 indispensable indispensable JJ 31417 1135 30 to to TO 31417 1135 31 be be VB 31417 1135 32 minutely minutely RB 31417 1135 33 careful careful JJ 31417 1135 34 and and CC 31417 1135 35 conscientious conscientious JJ 31417 1135 36 in in IN 31417 1135 37 recording record VBG 31417 1135 38 the the DT 31417 1135 39 exact exact JJ 31417 1135 40 conditions condition NNS 31417 1135 41 of of IN 31417 1135 42 each each DT 31417 1135 43 experiment experiment NN 31417 1135 44 . . . 31417 1135 45 " " '' 31417 1136 1 The the DT 31417 1136 2 reader reader NN 31417 1136 3 is be VBZ 31417 1136 4 referred refer VBN 31417 1136 5 to to IN 31417 1136 6 the the DT 31417 1136 7 Report Report NNP 31417 1136 8 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 1136 9 to to TO 31417 1136 10 show show VB 31417 1136 11 how how WRB 31417 1136 12 this this DT 31417 1136 13 was be VBD 31417 1136 14 carried carry VBN 31417 1136 15 out out RP 31417 1136 16 ; ; : 31417 1136 17 and and CC 31417 1136 18 also also RB 31417 1136 19 to to TO 31417 1136 20 show show VB 31417 1136 21 how how WRB 31417 1136 22 exhaustively exhaustively RB 31417 1136 23 every every DT 31417 1136 24 possibility possibility NN 31417 1136 25 was be VBD 31417 1136 26 considered consider VBN 31417 1136 27 by by IN 31417 1136 28 means mean NNS 31417 1136 29 of of IN 31417 1136 30 which which WDT 31417 1136 31 information information NN 31417 1136 32 could could MD 31417 1136 33 be be VB 31417 1136 34 conceived conceive VBN 31417 1136 35 to to TO 31417 1136 36 be be VB 31417 1136 37 conveyed convey VBN 31417 1136 38 through through IN 31417 1136 39 any any DT 31417 1136 40 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1136 41 channel channel NN 31417 1136 42 . . . 31417 1137 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1137 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1137 3 : : : 31417 1137 4 No no UH 31417 1137 5 . . . 31417 1138 1 10 10 CD 31417 1138 2 . . . 31417 1139 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1139 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1139 3 No no NN 31417 1139 4 . . . 31417 1140 1 11 11 CD 31417 1140 2 . . . 31417 1141 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1141 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1141 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1141 4 Smith Smith NNP 31417 1141 5 had have VBD 31417 1141 6 no no DT 31417 1141 7 idea idea NN 31417 1141 8 that that IN 31417 1141 9 the the DT 31417 1141 10 original original NN 31417 1141 11 was be VBD 31417 1141 12 not not RB 31417 1141 13 a a DT 31417 1141 14 geometrical geometrical JJ 31417 1141 15 diagram diagram NN 31417 1141 16 . . . 31417 1142 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1142 2 added add VBD 31417 1142 3 line line NN 31417 1142 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1142 5 b b NNP 31417 1142 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1142 7 some some DT 31417 1142 8 time time NN 31417 1142 9 after after IN 31417 1142 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1142 11 had have VBD 31417 1142 12 drawn draw VBN 31417 1142 13 line line NN 31417 1142 14 _ _ NNP 31417 1142 15 a a DT 31417 1142 16 _ _ NNP 31417 1142 17 , , , 31417 1142 18 " " '' 31417 1142 19 seeing see VBG 31417 1142 20 a a DT 31417 1142 21 line line NN 31417 1142 22 parallel parallel JJ 31417 1142 23 to to IN 31417 1142 24 another another DT 31417 1142 25 somewhere somewhere RB 31417 1142 26 . . . 31417 1142 27 " " '' 31417 1142 28 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1143 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1143 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1143 3 : : : 31417 1143 4 No no UH 31417 1143 5 . . . 31417 1144 1 2 2 LS 31417 1144 2 . . . 31417 1145 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1145 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1145 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1145 4 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1145 5 and and CC 31417 1145 6 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1145 7 E. E. NNP 31417 1145 8 no no DT 31417 1145 9 contact contact NN 31417 1145 10 . . . 31417 1145 11 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1146 1 An an DT 31417 1146 2 entirely entirely RB 31417 1146 3 different different JJ 31417 1146 4 group group NN 31417 1146 5 of of IN 31417 1146 6 experimenters experimenter NNS 31417 1146 7 set set VBN 31417 1146 8 to to TO 31417 1146 9 work work NN 31417 1146 10 in in IN 31417 1146 11 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1146 12 . . . 31417 1147 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1147 2 Malcolm Malcolm NNP 31417 1147 3 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1147 4 , , , 31417 1147 5 J.P. J.P. NNP 31417 1147 6 , , , 31417 1147 7 was be VBD 31417 1147 8 a a DT 31417 1147 9 partner partner NN 31417 1147 10 in in IN 31417 1147 11 one one CD 31417 1147 12 of of IN 31417 1147 13 the the DT 31417 1147 14 large large JJ 31417 1147 15 drapery drapery JJ 31417 1147 16 establishments establishment NNS 31417 1147 17 , , , 31417 1147 18 and and CC 31417 1147 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1147 20 James James NNP 31417 1147 21 Birchall Birchall NNP 31417 1147 22 was be VBD 31417 1147 23 the the DT 31417 1147 24 Hon Hon NNP 31417 1147 25 . . . 31417 1148 1 Secretary Secretary NNP 31417 1148 2 of of IN 31417 1148 3 the the DT 31417 1148 4 Literary Literary NNP 31417 1148 5 and and CC 31417 1148 6 Philosophical Philosophical NNP 31417 1148 7 Society Society NNP 31417 1148 8 of of IN 31417 1148 9 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1148 10 . . . 31417 1149 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1149 2 interest interest NN 31417 1149 3 was be VBD 31417 1149 4 aroused arouse VBN 31417 1149 5 in in IN 31417 1149 6 the the DT 31417 1149 7 subject subject NN 31417 1149 8 of of IN 31417 1149 9 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1149 10 - - HYPH 31417 1149 11 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1149 12 , , , 31417 1149 13 and and CC 31417 1149 14 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1149 15 carried carry VBD 31417 1149 16 out out RP 31417 1149 17 a a DT 31417 1149 18 very very RB 31417 1149 19 large large JJ 31417 1149 20 number number NN 31417 1149 21 of of IN 31417 1149 22 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1149 23 with with IN 31417 1149 24 some some DT 31417 1149 25 of of IN 31417 1149 26 the the DT 31417 1149 27 young young JJ 31417 1149 28 ladies lady NNS 31417 1149 29 employed employ VBN 31417 1149 30 in in IN 31417 1149 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1149 32 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1149 33 's 's POS 31417 1149 34 establishment establishment NN 31417 1149 35 , , , 31417 1149 36 who who WP 31417 1149 37 , , , 31417 1149 38 " " `` 31417 1149 39 amusing amuse VBG 31417 1149 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1149 41 after after IN 31417 1149 42 business business NN 31417 1149 43 hours hour NNS 31417 1149 44 , , , 31417 1149 45 found find VBD 31417 1149 46 that that IN 31417 1149 47 certain certain JJ 31417 1149 48 of of IN 31417 1149 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1149 50 number number NN 31417 1149 51 , , , 31417 1149 52 when when WRB 31417 1149 53 blindfolded blindfold VBN 31417 1149 54 , , , 31417 1149 55 were be VBD 31417 1149 56 able able JJ 31417 1149 57 to to TO 31417 1149 58 name name VB 31417 1149 59 very very RB 31417 1149 60 correctly correctly RB 31417 1149 61 figures figure VBZ 31417 1149 62 selected select VBN 31417 1149 63 from from IN 31417 1149 64 an an DT 31417 1149 65 almanack almanack NN 31417 1149 66 suspended suspend VBN 31417 1149 67 on on IN 31417 1149 68 the the DT 31417 1149 69 wall wall NN 31417 1149 70 of of IN 31417 1149 71 the the DT 31417 1149 72 room room NN 31417 1149 73 , , , 31417 1149 74 when when WRB 31417 1149 75 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1149 76 companions companion NNS 31417 1149 77 having have VBG 31417 1149 78 hold hold NN 31417 1149 79 of of IN 31417 1149 80 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1149 81 hands hand NNS 31417 1149 82 , , , 31417 1149 83 fixed fix VBD 31417 1149 84 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1149 85 attention attention NN 31417 1149 86 on on IN 31417 1149 87 some some DT 31417 1149 88 particular particular JJ 31417 1149 89 day day NN 31417 1149 90 of of IN 31417 1149 91 the the DT 31417 1149 92 month month NN 31417 1149 93 . . . 31417 1149 94 " " '' 31417 1150 1 This this DT 31417 1150 2 led lead VBD 31417 1150 3 to to IN 31417 1150 4 serious serious JJ 31417 1150 5 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1150 6 , , , 31417 1150 7 including include VBG 31417 1150 8 about about IN 31417 1150 9 one one CD 31417 1150 10 hundred hundred CD 31417 1150 11 and and CC 31417 1150 12 fifty fifty CD 31417 1150 13 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1150 14 - - HYPH 31417 1150 15 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1150 16 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1150 17 . . . 31417 1151 1 The the DT 31417 1151 2 conditions condition NNS 31417 1151 3 were be VBD 31417 1151 4 carefully carefully RB 31417 1151 5 guarded guard VBN 31417 1151 6 , , , 31417 1151 7 and and CC 31417 1151 8 in in IN 31417 1151 9 the the DT 31417 1151 10 majority majority NN 31417 1151 11 of of IN 31417 1151 12 cases case NNS 31417 1151 13 no no DT 31417 1151 14 contact contact NN 31417 1151 15 was be VBD 31417 1151 16 permitted permit VBN 31417 1151 17 . . . 31417 1152 1 There there EX 31417 1152 2 were be VBD 31417 1152 3 many many JJ 31417 1152 4 failures failure NNS 31417 1152 5 , , , 31417 1152 6 but but CC 31417 1152 7 a a DT 31417 1152 8 large large JJ 31417 1152 9 number number NN 31417 1152 10 of of IN 31417 1152 11 successes success NNS 31417 1152 12 . . . 31417 1153 1 Assistance assistance NN 31417 1153 2 as as IN 31417 1153 3 " " `` 31417 1153 4 transmitter transmitter NN 31417 1153 5 " " '' 31417 1153 6 was be VBD 31417 1153 7 also also RB 31417 1153 8 given give VBN 31417 1153 9 by by IN 31417 1153 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1153 11 F. F. NNP 31417 1153 12 S. S. NNP 31417 1153 13 Hughes Hughes NNP 31417 1153 14 , , , 31417 1153 15 a a DT 31417 1153 16 member member NN 31417 1153 17 of of IN 31417 1153 18 the the DT 31417 1153 19 Society Society NNP 31417 1153 20 for for IN 31417 1153 21 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1153 22 Research Research NNP 31417 1153 23 . . . 31417 1154 1 In in IN 31417 1154 2 a a DT 31417 1154 3 report report NN 31417 1154 4 by by IN 31417 1154 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1154 6 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1154 7 , , , 31417 1154 8 published publish VBN 31417 1154 9 in in IN 31417 1154 10 the the DT 31417 1154 11 _ _ NNP 31417 1154 12 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1154 13 _ _ NNP 31417 1154 14 of of IN 31417 1154 15 the the DT 31417 1154 16 Society Society NNP 31417 1154 17 , , , 31417 1154 18 sixteen sixteen CD 31417 1154 19 of of IN 31417 1154 20 these these DT 31417 1154 21 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1154 22 are be VBP 31417 1154 23 given give VBN 31417 1154 24 . . . 31417 1155 1 NOS NOS NNP 31417 1155 2 . . . 31417 1156 1 2 2 CD 31417 1156 2 and and CC 31417 1156 3 15 15 CD 31417 1156 4 are be VBP 31417 1156 5 selected select VBN 31417 1156 6 . . . 31417 1157 1 In in IN 31417 1157 2 neither neither DT 31417 1157 3 of of IN 31417 1157 4 these these DT 31417 1157 5 was be VBD 31417 1157 6 any any DT 31417 1157 7 contact contact NN 31417 1157 8 between between IN 31417 1157 9 " " `` 31417 1157 10 transmitter transmitter NN 31417 1157 11 " " '' 31417 1157 12 and and CC 31417 1157 13 " " `` 31417 1157 14 receiver receiver NN 31417 1157 15 " " '' 31417 1157 16 permitted permit VBN 31417 1157 17 . . . 31417 1158 1 In in IN 31417 1158 2 NO NO NNP 31417 1158 3 . . . 31417 1159 1 2 2 CD 31417 1159 2 , , , 31417 1159 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1159 4 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1159 5 was be VBD 31417 1159 6 " " `` 31417 1159 7 transmitter transmitter NN 31417 1159 8 " " '' 31417 1159 9 and and CC 31417 1159 10 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1159 11 Edwards Edwards NNP 31417 1159 12 " " '' 31417 1159 13 receiver receiver NN 31417 1159 14 . . . 31417 1159 15 " " '' 31417 1160 1 In in IN 31417 1160 2 NO NO NNP 31417 1160 3 . . . 31417 1161 1 15 15 CD 31417 1161 2 , , , 31417 1161 3 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1161 4 F. F. NNP 31417 1161 5 S. S. NNP 31417 1161 6 Hughes Hughes NNP 31417 1161 7 was be VBD 31417 1161 8 " " `` 31417 1161 9 transmitter transmitter NN 31417 1161 10 " " '' 31417 1161 11 and and CC 31417 1161 12 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1161 13 Edwards Edwards NNP 31417 1161 14 " " '' 31417 1161 15 receiver receiver NN 31417 1161 16 . . . 31417 1161 17 " " '' 31417 1162 1 With with IN 31417 1162 2 regard regard NN 31417 1162 3 to to IN 31417 1162 4 the the DT 31417 1162 5 second second JJ 31417 1162 6 , , , 31417 1162 7 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1162 8 Edwards Edwards NNP 31417 1162 9 said say VBD 31417 1162 10 , , , 31417 1162 11 " " `` 31417 1162 12 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1162 13 is be VBZ 31417 1162 14 like like IN 31417 1162 15 a a DT 31417 1162 16 mask mask NN 31417 1162 17 at at IN 31417 1162 18 a a DT 31417 1162 19 pantomime pantomime NN 31417 1162 20 , , , 31417 1162 21 " " '' 31417 1162 22 and and CC 31417 1162 23 immediately immediately RB 31417 1162 24 drew draw VBD 31417 1162 25 the the DT 31417 1162 26 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1162 27 . . . 31417 1163 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1163 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1163 3 : : : 31417 1163 4 No no UH 31417 1163 5 . . . 31417 1164 1 15 15 CD 31417 1164 2 . . . 31417 1165 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1165 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1165 3 Hughes Hughes NNP 31417 1165 4 and and CC 31417 1165 5 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1165 6 E. E. NNP 31417 1165 7 no no DT 31417 1165 8 contact contact NN 31417 1165 9 . . . 31417 1166 1 REPRODUCTION REPRODUCTION NNP 31417 1166 2 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1166 3 E. E. NNP 31417 1166 4 said say VBD 31417 1166 5 , , , 31417 1166 6 " " `` 31417 1166 7 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1166 8 is be VBZ 31417 1166 9 like like IN 31417 1166 10 a a DT 31417 1166 11 mask mask NN 31417 1166 12 at at IN 31417 1166 13 a a DT 31417 1166 14 pantomime pantomime NN 31417 1166 15 , , , 31417 1166 16 " " '' 31417 1166 17 and and CC 31417 1166 18 immediately immediately RB 31417 1166 19 drew draw VBD 31417 1166 20 as as IN 31417 1166 21 above above RB 31417 1166 22 . . . 31417 1166 23 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1167 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1167 2 Malcolm Malcolm NNP 31417 1167 3 remarks remark VBZ 31417 1167 4 in in IN 31417 1167 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1167 6 Report report NN 31417 1167 7 : : : 31417 1167 8 " " `` 31417 1167 9 The the DT 31417 1167 10 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1167 11 must must MD 31417 1167 12 speak speak VB 31417 1167 13 for for IN 31417 1167 14 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1167 15 . . . 31417 1168 1 The the DT 31417 1168 2 principal principal JJ 31417 1168 3 facts fact NNS 31417 1168 4 to to TO 31417 1168 5 be be VB 31417 1168 6 borne bear VBN 31417 1168 7 in in IN 31417 1168 8 mind mind NN 31417 1168 9 are be VBP 31417 1168 10 that that IN 31417 1168 11 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1168 12 have have VBP 31417 1168 13 been be VBN 31417 1168 14 executed execute VBN 31417 1168 15 through through IN 31417 1168 16 the the DT 31417 1168 17 instrumentality instrumentality NN 31417 1168 18 as as IN 31417 1168 19 agents agent NNS 31417 1168 20 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1168 21 transmitters transmitter NNS 31417 1168 22 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1168 23 of of IN 31417 1168 24 persons person NNS 31417 1168 25 of of IN 31417 1168 26 unquestioned unquestioned JJ 31417 1168 27 probity probity NN 31417 1168 28 , , , 31417 1168 29 and and CC 31417 1168 30 that that IN 31417 1168 31 the the DT 31417 1168 32 responsibility responsibility NN 31417 1168 33 for for IN 31417 1168 34 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1168 35 is be VBZ 31417 1168 36 spread spread VBN 31417 1168 37 over over IN 31417 1168 38 a a DT 31417 1168 39 considerable considerable JJ 31417 1168 40 group group NN 31417 1168 41 of of IN 31417 1168 42 such such JJ 31417 1168 43 persons person NNS 31417 1168 44 , , , 31417 1168 45 while while IN 31417 1168 46 the the DT 31417 1168 47 conditions condition NNS 31417 1168 48 to to TO 31417 1168 49 be be VB 31417 1168 50 observed observe VBN 31417 1168 51 were be VBD 31417 1168 52 so so RB 31417 1168 53 simple simple JJ 31417 1168 54 -- -- : 31417 1168 55 for for IN 31417 1168 56 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1168 57 amounted amount VBD 31417 1168 58 really really RB 31417 1168 59 to to IN 31417 1168 60 nothing nothing NN 31417 1168 61 more more JJR 31417 1168 62 than than IN 31417 1168 63 taking take VBG 31417 1168 64 care care NN 31417 1168 65 that that IN 31417 1168 66 the the DT 31417 1168 67 original original NN 31417 1168 68 should should MD 31417 1168 69 not not RB 31417 1168 70 be be VB 31417 1168 71 seen see VBN 31417 1168 72 by by IN 31417 1168 73 the the DT 31417 1168 74 subject subject NN 31417 1168 75 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1168 76 receiver]--that receiver]--that IN 31417 1168 77 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1168 78 is be VBZ 31417 1168 79 extremely extremely RB 31417 1168 80 difficult difficult JJ 31417 1168 81 to to TO 31417 1168 82 suppose suppose VB 31417 1168 83 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1168 84 to to TO 31417 1168 85 have have VB 31417 1168 86 been be VBN 31417 1168 87 eluded elude VBN 31417 1168 88 . . . 31417 1168 89 " " '' 31417 1169 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1169 2 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1169 3 , , , 31417 1169 4 having have VBG 31417 1169 5 satisfied satisfy VBN 31417 1169 6 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1169 7 as as IN 31417 1169 8 to to IN 31417 1169 9 the the DT 31417 1169 10 reality reality NN 31417 1169 11 of of IN 31417 1169 12 the the DT 31417 1169 13 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1169 14 of of IN 31417 1169 15 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1169 16 - - HYPH 31417 1169 17 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1169 18 , , , 31417 1169 19 as as IN 31417 1169 20 manifested manifest VBN 31417 1169 21 by by IN 31417 1169 22 the the DT 31417 1169 23 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1169 24 , , , 31417 1169 25 and and CC 31417 1169 26 in in IN 31417 1169 27 other other JJ 31417 1169 28 ways way NNS 31417 1169 29 , , , 31417 1169 30 endeavoured endeavour VBN 31417 1169 31 to to TO 31417 1169 32 interest interest VB 31417 1169 33 the the DT 31417 1169 34 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1169 35 men man NNS 31417 1169 36 of of IN 31417 1169 37 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1169 38 . . . 31417 1170 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1170 2 naturally naturally RB 31417 1170 3 appealed appeal VBD 31417 1170 4 among among IN 31417 1170 5 others other NNS 31417 1170 6 to to IN 31417 1170 7 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1170 8 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1170 9 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1170 10 , , , 31417 1170 11 who who WP 31417 1170 12 was be VBD 31417 1170 13 then then RB 31417 1170 14 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1170 15 of of IN 31417 1170 16 Physics Physics NNP 31417 1170 17 in in IN 31417 1170 18 University University NNP 31417 1170 19 College College NNP 31417 1170 20 , , , 31417 1170 21 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1170 22 . . . 31417 1171 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1171 2 accepted accept VBD 31417 1171 3 the the DT 31417 1171 4 invitation invitation NN 31417 1171 5 , , , 31417 1171 6 and and CC 31417 1171 7 subsequently subsequently RB 31417 1171 8 gave give VBD 31417 1171 9 " " `` 31417 1171 10 An an DT 31417 1171 11 Account Account NNP 31417 1171 12 of of IN 31417 1171 13 Some some DT 31417 1171 14 Experiments Experiments NNPS 31417 1171 15 in in IN 31417 1171 16 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1171 17 - - HYPH 31417 1171 18 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1171 19 " " '' 31417 1171 20 to to IN 31417 1171 21 the the DT 31417 1171 22 Society Society NNP 31417 1171 23 for for IN 31417 1171 24 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1171 25 Research Research NNP 31417 1171 26 , , , 31417 1171 27 of of IN 31417 1171 28 which which WDT 31417 1171 29 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1171 30 was be VBD 31417 1171 31 already already RB 31417 1171 32 an an DT 31417 1171 33 unofficial unofficial JJ 31417 1171 34 member member NN 31417 1171 35 , , , 31417 1171 36 and and CC 31417 1171 37 which which WDT 31417 1171 38 account account NN 31417 1171 39 is be VBZ 31417 1171 40 published publish VBN 31417 1171 41 in in IN 31417 1171 42 the the DT 31417 1171 43 Society Society NNP 31417 1171 44 's 's POS 31417 1171 45 _ _ NNP 31417 1171 46 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1171 47 _ _ NNP 31417 1171 48 . . . 31417 1172 1 The the DT 31417 1172 2 Report Report NNP 31417 1172 3 commences commence VBZ 31417 1172 4 with with IN 31417 1172 5 a a DT 31417 1172 6 tribute tribute NN 31417 1172 7 , , , 31417 1172 8 " " '' 31417 1172 9 since since IN 31417 1172 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1172 11 bears bear VBZ 31417 1172 12 on on IN 31417 1172 13 the the DT 31417 1172 14 questions question NNS 31417 1172 15 of of IN 31417 1172 16 responsibility responsibility NN 31417 1172 17 and and CC 31417 1172 18 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1172 19 , , , 31417 1172 20 " " '' 31417 1172 21 to to IN 31417 1172 22 the the DT 31417 1172 23 important important JJ 31417 1172 24 position position NN 31417 1172 25 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1172 26 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1172 27 held hold VBD 31417 1172 28 in in IN 31417 1172 29 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1172 30 , , , 31417 1172 31 as as IN 31417 1172 32 an an DT 31417 1172 33 active active JJ 31417 1172 34 member member NN 31417 1172 35 of of IN 31417 1172 36 the the DT 31417 1172 37 governing govern VBG 31417 1172 38 bodies body NNS 31417 1172 39 of of IN 31417 1172 40 several several JJ 31417 1172 41 public public JJ 31417 1172 42 institutions institution NNS 31417 1172 43 , , , 31417 1172 44 including include VBG 31417 1172 45 the the DT 31417 1172 46 University University NNP 31417 1172 47 College College NNP 31417 1172 48 . . . 31417 1173 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1173 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1173 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1173 4 then then RB 31417 1173 5 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1173 6 " " `` 31417 1173 7 After after IN 31417 1173 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1173 9 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1173 10 had have VBD 31417 1173 11 laboriously laboriously RB 31417 1173 12 carried carry VBN 31417 1173 13 out out RP 31417 1173 14 a a DT 31417 1173 15 long long JJ 31417 1173 16 series series NN 31417 1173 17 of of IN 31417 1173 18 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1173 19 ... ... : 31417 1173 20 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1173 21 set set VBD 31417 1173 22 about about RP 31417 1173 23 endeavouring endeavour VBG 31417 1173 24 to to TO 31417 1173 25 convince convince VB 31417 1173 26 such such JJ 31417 1173 27 students student NNS 31417 1173 28 of of IN 31417 1173 29 science science NN 31417 1173 30 as as IN 31417 1173 31 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1173 32 could could MD 31417 1173 33 lay lay VB 31417 1173 34 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1173 35 hands hand NNS 31417 1173 36 upon upon IN 31417 1173 37 in in IN 31417 1173 38 Liverpool Liverpool NNP 31417 1173 39 ; ; : 31417 1173 40 and and CC 31417 1173 41 with with IN 31417 1173 42 this this DT 31417 1173 43 object object NN 31417 1173 44 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1173 45 appealed appeal VBD 31417 1173 46 to to IN 31417 1173 47 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1173 48 , , , 31417 1173 49 among among IN 31417 1173 50 others other NNS 31417 1173 51 , , , 31417 1173 52 to to TO 31417 1173 53 come come VB 31417 1173 54 and and CC 31417 1173 55 witness witness VB 31417 1173 56 , , , 31417 1173 57 and and CC 31417 1173 58 within within IN 31417 1173 59 limits limits NNP 31417 1173 60 modify modify NNP 31417 1173 61 , , , 31417 1173 62 the the DT 31417 1173 63 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1173 64 in in IN 31417 1173 65 such such PDT 31417 1173 66 a a DT 31417 1173 67 way way NN 31417 1173 68 as as IN 31417 1173 69 would would MD 31417 1173 70 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1173 71 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1173 72 of of IN 31417 1173 73 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1173 74 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1173 75 and and CC 31417 1173 76 perfect perfect VB 31417 1173 77 good good JJ 31417 1173 78 faith faith NN 31417 1173 79 . . . 31417 1174 1 Yielding yield VBG 31417 1174 2 to to IN 31417 1174 3 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1174 4 entreaty entreaty NN 31417 1174 5 , , , 31417 1174 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1174 7 consented consent VBD 31417 1174 8 , , , 31417 1174 9 and and CC 31417 1174 10 have have VBP 31417 1174 11 been be VBN 31417 1174 12 , , , 31417 1174 13 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1174 14 suppose suppose VBP 31417 1174 15 , , , 31417 1174 16 at at IN 31417 1174 17 some some DT 31417 1174 18 dozen dozen NN 31417 1174 19 sittings sitting NNS 31417 1174 20 , , , 31417 1174 21 at at IN 31417 1174 22 first first RB 31417 1174 23 simply simply RB 31417 1174 24 looking look VBG 31417 1174 25 on on RP 31417 1174 26 so so IN 31417 1174 27 as as IN 31417 1174 28 to to TO 31417 1174 29 grasp grasp VB 31417 1174 30 the the DT 31417 1174 31 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1174 32 , , , 31417 1174 33 but but CC 31417 1174 34 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 1174 35 taking take VBG 31417 1174 36 charge charge NN 31417 1174 37 of of IN 31417 1174 38 the the DT 31417 1174 39 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1174 40 .... .... . 31417 1175 1 In in IN 31417 1175 2 this this DT 31417 1175 3 way way NN 31417 1175 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1175 5 had have VBD 31417 1175 6 every every DT 31417 1175 7 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 1175 8 of of IN 31417 1175 9 examining examine VBG 31417 1175 10 and and CC 31417 1175 11 varying vary VBG 31417 1175 12 the the DT 31417 1175 13 minute minute NN 31417 1175 14 conditions condition NNS 31417 1175 15 of of IN 31417 1175 16 the the DT 31417 1175 17 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1175 18 , , , 31417 1175 19 so so IN 31417 1175 20 as as IN 31417 1175 21 to to TO 31417 1175 22 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1175 23 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1175 24 of of IN 31417 1175 25 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1175 26 genuine genuine JJ 31417 1175 27 and and CC 31417 1175 28 objective objective JJ 31417 1175 29 character character NN 31417 1175 30 , , , 31417 1175 31 in in IN 31417 1175 32 the the DT 31417 1175 33 same same JJ 31417 1175 34 way way NN 31417 1175 35 as as IN 31417 1175 36 one one CD 31417 1175 37 is be VBZ 31417 1175 38 accustomed accustom VBN 31417 1175 39 to to TO 31417 1175 40 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1175 41 oneself oneself PRP 31417 1175 42 as as IN 31417 1175 43 to to IN 31417 1175 44 the the DT 31417 1175 45 truth truth NN 31417 1175 46 and and CC 31417 1175 47 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1175 48 of of IN 31417 1175 49 any any DT 31417 1175 50 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1175 51 physical physical JJ 31417 1175 52 fact fact NN 31417 1175 53 . . . 31417 1176 1 " " `` 31417 1176 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1176 3 did do VBD 31417 1176 4 not not RB 31417 1176 5 feel feel VB 31417 1176 6 at at IN 31417 1176 7 liberty liberty NN 31417 1176 8 to to TO 31417 1176 9 modify modify VB 31417 1176 10 the the DT 31417 1176 11 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1176 12 very very RB 31417 1176 13 largely largely RB 31417 1176 14 , , , 31417 1176 15 in in IN 31417 1176 16 other other JJ 31417 1176 17 words word NNS 31417 1176 18 to to TO 31417 1176 19 try try VB 31417 1176 20 essentially essentially RB 31417 1176 21 new new JJ 31417 1176 22 ones one NNS 31417 1176 23 .... .... . 31417 1177 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1177 2 only only RB 31417 1177 3 regarded regard VBD 31417 1177 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1177 5 as as IN 31417 1177 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1177 7 business business NN 31417 1177 8 to to TO 31417 1177 9 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1177 10 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1177 11 as as IN 31417 1177 12 to to IN 31417 1177 13 the the DT 31417 1177 14 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1177 15 and and CC 31417 1177 16 authenticity authenticity NN 31417 1177 17 of of IN 31417 1177 18 the the DT 31417 1177 19 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1177 20 already already RB 31417 1177 21 described describe VBN 31417 1177 22 by by IN 31417 1177 23 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1177 24 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1177 25 . . . 31417 1178 1 If if IN 31417 1178 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1178 3 had have VBD 31417 1178 4 merely merely RB 31417 1178 5 witnessed witness VBN 31417 1178 6 facts fact NNS 31417 1178 7 as as IN 31417 1178 8 a a DT 31417 1178 9 passive passive JJ 31417 1178 10 spectator spectator NN 31417 1178 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1178 12 should should MD 31417 1178 13 most most RBS 31417 1178 14 certainly certainly RB 31417 1178 15 not not RB 31417 1178 16 publicly publicly RB 31417 1178 17 report report VB 31417 1178 18 upon upon IN 31417 1178 19 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1178 20 . . . 31417 1179 1 So so RB 31417 1179 2 long long RB 31417 1179 3 as as IN 31417 1179 4 one one CD 31417 1179 5 is be VBZ 31417 1179 6 bound bind VBN 31417 1179 7 to to TO 31417 1179 8 accept accept VB 31417 1179 9 imposed impose VBN 31417 1179 10 conditions condition NNS 31417 1179 11 and and CC 31417 1179 12 merely merely RB 31417 1179 13 witness witness VB 31417 1179 14 what what WP 31417 1179 15 goes go VBZ 31417 1179 16 on on RP 31417 1179 17 , , , 31417 1179 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 19 have have VBP 31417 1179 20 no no DT 31417 1179 21 confidence confidence NN 31417 1179 22 in in IN 31417 1179 23 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1179 24 own own JJ 31417 1179 25 penetration penetration NN 31417 1179 26 , , , 31417 1179 27 and and CC 31417 1179 28 am be VBP 31417 1179 29 perfectly perfectly RB 31417 1179 30 sure sure JJ 31417 1179 31 that that IN 31417 1179 32 a a DT 31417 1179 33 conjurer conjurer NN 31417 1179 34 could could MD 31417 1179 35 impose impose VB 31417 1179 36 upon upon IN 31417 1179 37 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 38 , , , 31417 1179 39 possibly possibly RB 31417 1179 40 even even RB 31417 1179 41 to to IN 31417 1179 42 the the DT 31417 1179 43 extent extent NN 31417 1179 44 of of IN 31417 1179 45 making make VBG 31417 1179 46 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 47 think think VB 31417 1179 48 that that IN 31417 1179 49 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 50 was be VBD 31417 1179 51 not not RB 31417 1179 52 imposing impose VBG 31417 1179 53 on on IN 31417 1179 54 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 55 ; ; : 31417 1179 56 but but CC 31417 1179 57 when when WRB 31417 1179 58 one one PRP 31417 1179 59 has have VBZ 31417 1179 60 the the DT 31417 1179 61 control control NN 31417 1179 62 of of IN 31417 1179 63 the the DT 31417 1179 64 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 1179 65 , , , 31417 1179 66 can can MD 31417 1179 67 change change VB 31417 1179 68 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1179 69 at at IN 31417 1179 70 will will NN 31417 1179 71 , , , 31417 1179 72 and and CC 31417 1179 73 arrange arrange VB 31417 1179 74 one one PRP 31417 1179 75 's 's POS 31417 1179 76 own own JJ 31417 1179 77 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1179 78 , , , 31417 1179 79 one one CD 31417 1179 80 gradually gradually RB 31417 1179 81 acquires acquire VBZ 31417 1179 82 a a DT 31417 1179 83 belief belief NN 31417 1179 84 in in IN 31417 1179 85 the the DT 31417 1179 86 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1179 87 observed observe VBD 31417 1179 88 quite quite RB 31417 1179 89 comparable comparable JJ 31417 1179 90 to to IN 31417 1179 91 that that DT 31417 1179 92 induced induce VBN 31417 1179 93 by by IN 31417 1179 94 the the DT 31417 1179 95 repetition repetition NN 31417 1179 96 of of IN 31417 1179 97 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1179 98 physical physical JJ 31417 1179 99 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1179 100 . . . 31417 1179 101 " " '' 31417 1180 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1180 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1180 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1180 4 then then RB 31417 1180 5 describes describe VBZ 31417 1180 6 in in IN 31417 1180 7 detail detail NN 31417 1180 8 the the DT 31417 1180 9 method method NN 31417 1180 10 of of IN 31417 1180 11 procedure procedure NN 31417 1180 12 , , , 31417 1180 13 in in IN 31417 1180 14 the the DT 31417 1180 15 course course NN 31417 1180 16 of of IN 31417 1180 17 which which WDT 31417 1180 18 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1180 19 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1180 20 " " `` 31417 1180 21 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1180 22 have have VBP 31417 1180 23 many many JJ 31417 1180 24 times time NNS 31417 1180 25 succeeded succeed VBN 31417 1180 26 with with IN 31417 1180 27 agents agent NNS 31417 1180 28 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1180 29 ' ' `` 31417 1180 30 transmitters transmitter NNS 31417 1180 31 ' ' POS 31417 1180 32 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1180 33 quite quite RB 31417 1180 34 disconnected disconnected JJ 31417 1180 35 with with IN 31417 1180 36 the the DT 31417 1180 37 percipient percipient NN 31417 1180 38 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1180 39 ' ' `` 31417 1180 40 receiver receiver NN 31417 1180 41 ' ' '' 31417 1180 42 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1180 43 in in IN 31417 1180 44 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1180 45 life life NN 31417 1180 46 and and CC 31417 1180 47 sometimes sometimes RB 31417 1180 48 complete complete JJ 31417 1180 49 strangers stranger NNS 31417 1180 50 to to IN 31417 1180 51 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1180 52 . . . 31417 1181 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1181 2 Birchall Birchall NNP 31417 1181 3 , , , 31417 1181 4 the the DT 31417 1181 5 headmaster headmaster NN 31417 1181 6 of of IN 31417 1181 7 the the DT 31417 1181 8 Birkdale Birkdale NNP 31417 1181 9 Industrial Industrial NNP 31417 1181 10 School School NNP 31417 1181 11 , , , 31417 1181 12 frequently frequently RB 31417 1181 13 acted act VBD 31417 1181 14 ; ; : 31417 1181 15 and and CC 31417 1181 16 the the DT 31417 1181 17 house house NNP 31417 1181 18 physician physician NN 31417 1181 19 at at IN 31417 1181 20 the the DT 31417 1181 21 Eye Eye NNP 31417 1181 22 and and CC 31417 1181 23 Ear Ear NNP 31417 1181 24 Hospital Hospital NNP 31417 1181 25 , , , 31417 1181 26 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1181 27 Shears Shears NNP 31417 1181 28 , , , 31417 1181 29 had have VBD 31417 1181 30 a a DT 31417 1181 31 successful successful JJ 31417 1181 32 experiment experiment NN 31417 1181 33 , , , 31417 1181 34 acting act VBG 31417 1181 35 alone alone RB 31417 1181 36 , , , 31417 1181 37 on on IN 31417 1181 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1181 39 first first JJ 31417 1181 40 and and CC 31417 1181 41 only only JJ 31417 1181 42 visit visit NN 31417 1181 43 . . . 31417 1182 1 All all DT 31417 1182 2 suspicion suspicion NN 31417 1182 3 of of IN 31417 1182 4 a a DT 31417 1182 5 pre pre JJ 31417 1182 6 - - JJ 31417 1182 7 arranged arranged JJ 31417 1182 8 code code NN 31417 1182 9 is be VBZ 31417 1182 10 thus thus RB 31417 1182 11 rendered render VBN 31417 1182 12 impossible impossible JJ 31417 1182 13 even even RB 31417 1182 14 to to IN 31417 1182 15 outsiders outsider NNS 31417 1182 16 who who WP 31417 1182 17 are be VBP 31417 1182 18 unable unable JJ 31417 1182 19 to to TO 31417 1182 20 witness witness VB 31417 1182 21 the the DT 31417 1182 22 obvious obvious JJ 31417 1182 23 fairness fairness NN 31417 1182 24 of of IN 31417 1182 25 all all PDT 31417 1182 26 the the DT 31417 1182 27 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1182 28 . . . 31417 1182 29 " " '' 31417 1183 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1183 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1183 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1183 4 then then RB 31417 1183 5 gives give VBZ 31417 1183 6 the the DT 31417 1183 7 details detail NNS 31417 1183 8 of of IN 31417 1183 9 twenty twenty CD 31417 1183 10 - - HYPH 31417 1183 11 seven seven CD 31417 1183 12 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1183 13 . . . 31417 1184 1 From from IN 31417 1184 2 these these DT 31417 1184 3 four four CD 31417 1184 4 are be VBP 31417 1184 5 selected select VBN 31417 1184 6 . . . 31417 1185 1 Descriptions description NNS 31417 1185 2 , , , 31417 1185 3 in in IN 31417 1185 4 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1185 5 O. O. NNP 31417 1185 6 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1185 7 's 's POS 31417 1185 8 own own JJ 31417 1185 9 words word NNS 31417 1185 10 , , , 31417 1185 11 are be VBP 31417 1185 12 condensed condense VBN 31417 1185 13 . . . 31417 1186 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1186 2 1 1 LS 31417 1186 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1186 4 " " '' 31417 1186 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1186 6 Birchall Birchall NNP 31417 1186 7 , , , 31417 1186 8 agent agent NN 31417 1186 9 -- -- : 31417 1186 10 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1186 11 R R NNP 31417 1186 12 , , , 31417 1186 13 percipient percipient NN 31417 1186 14 , , , 31417 1186 15 holding hold VBG 31417 1186 16 hands hand NNS 31417 1186 17 . . . 31417 1187 1 No no DT 31417 1187 2 one one NN 31417 1187 3 else else RB 31417 1187 4 present present JJ 31417 1187 5 except except IN 31417 1187 6 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1187 7 . . . 31417 1188 1 A a DT 31417 1188 2 drawing drawing NN 31417 1188 3 of of IN 31417 1188 4 a a DT 31417 1188 5 Union Union NNP 31417 1188 6 Jack Jack NNP 31417 1188 7 pattern pattern NN 31417 1188 8 . . . 31417 1189 1 As as IN 31417 1189 2 usual usual JJ 31417 1189 3 in in IN 31417 1189 4 drawing draw VBG 31417 1189 5 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1189 6 , , , 31417 1189 7 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1189 8 R. R. NNP 31417 1189 9 remained remain VBD 31417 1189 10 silent silent JJ 31417 1189 11 for for IN 31417 1189 12 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 1189 13 a a DT 31417 1189 14 minute minute NN 31417 1189 15 ; ; : 31417 1189 16 then then RB 31417 1189 17 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1189 18 said say VBD 31417 1189 19 , , , 31417 1189 20 ' ' `` 31417 1189 21 Now now RB 31417 1189 22 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1189 23 am be VBP 31417 1189 24 ready ready JJ 31417 1189 25 . . . 31417 1189 26 ' ' '' 31417 1190 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1190 2 hid hide VBD 31417 1190 3 the the DT 31417 1190 4 object object NN 31417 1190 5 ; ; : 31417 1190 6 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1190 7 took take VBD 31417 1190 8 off off RP 31417 1190 9 the the DT 31417 1190 10 handkerchief handkerchief NN 31417 1190 11 and and CC 31417 1190 12 proceeded proceed VBD 31417 1190 13 to to TO 31417 1190 14 draw draw VB 31417 1190 15 on on IN 31417 1190 16 paper paper NN 31417 1190 17 placed place VBN 31417 1190 18 ready ready JJ 31417 1190 19 in in IN 31417 1190 20 front front NN 31417 1190 21 of of IN 31417 1190 22 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1190 23 . . . 31417 1191 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1191 2 this this DT 31417 1191 3 time time NN 31417 1191 4 drew draw VBD 31417 1191 5 all all PDT 31417 1191 6 the the DT 31417 1191 7 lines line NNS 31417 1191 8 of of IN 31417 1191 9 the the DT 31417 1191 10 figure figure NN 31417 1191 11 except except IN 31417 1191 12 the the DT 31417 1191 13 horizontal horizontal JJ 31417 1191 14 middle middle JJ 31417 1191 15 one one CD 31417 1191 16 . . . 31417 1192 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1192 2 was be VBD 31417 1192 3 obviously obviously RB 31417 1192 4 much much RB 31417 1192 5 tempted tempt VBN 31417 1192 6 to to TO 31417 1192 7 draw draw VB 31417 1192 8 this this DT 31417 1192 9 , , , 31417 1192 10 and and CC 31417 1192 11 indeed indeed RB 31417 1192 12 began begin VBD 31417 1192 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1192 14 two two CD 31417 1192 15 or or CC 31417 1192 16 three three CD 31417 1192 17 times time NNS 31417 1192 18 faintly faintly RB 31417 1192 19 , , , 31417 1192 20 but but CC 31417 1192 21 ultimately ultimately RB 31417 1192 22 said say VBD 31417 1192 23 , , , 31417 1192 24 ' ' '' 31417 1192 25 No no UH 31417 1192 26 , , , 31417 1192 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1192 28 'm be VBP 31417 1192 29 not not RB 31417 1192 30 sure sure JJ 31417 1192 31 , , , 31417 1192 32 ' ' '' 31417 1192 33 and and CC 31417 1192 34 stopped stop VBD 31417 1192 35 . . . 31417 1192 36 " " '' 31417 1193 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1193 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1193 3 : : : 31417 1193 4 No no UH 31417 1193 5 . . . 31417 1194 1 1 1 LS 31417 1194 2 . . . 31417 1195 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1195 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1195 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1195 4 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1195 5 2 2 LS 31417 1195 6 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1195 7 " " `` 31417 1195 8 Double double JJ 31417 1195 9 object object NN 31417 1195 10 . . . 31417 1196 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1196 2 arranged arrange VBD 31417 1196 3 the the DT 31417 1196 4 double double JJ 31417 1196 5 object object NN 31417 1196 6 between between IN 31417 1196 7 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1196 8 R----d R----d NNP 31417 1196 9 and and CC 31417 1196 10 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1196 11 E. E. NNP 31417 1196 12 , , , 31417 1196 13 who who WP 31417 1196 14 happened happen VBD 31417 1196 15 to to TO 31417 1196 16 be be VB 31417 1196 17 sitting sit VBG 31417 1196 18 nearly nearly RB 31417 1196 19 facing face VBG 31417 1196 20 one one CD 31417 1196 21 another another DT 31417 1196 22 . . . 31417 1197 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1197 2 R----d R----d NNP 31417 1197 3 and and CC 31417 1197 4 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1197 5 E. E. NNP 31417 1197 6 both both DT 31417 1197 7 acting act VBG 31417 1197 8 as as IN 31417 1197 9 agents agent NNS 31417 1197 10 . . . 31417 1198 1 The the DT 31417 1198 2 drawing drawing NN 31417 1198 3 was be VBD 31417 1198 4 a a DT 31417 1198 5 square square NN 31417 1198 6 on on IN 31417 1198 7 one one CD 31417 1198 8 side side NN 31417 1198 9 of of IN 31417 1198 10 the the DT 31417 1198 11 paper paper NN 31417 1198 12 , , , 31417 1198 13 and and CC 31417 1198 14 a a DT 31417 1198 15 cross cross NN 31417 1198 16 on on IN 31417 1198 17 the the DT 31417 1198 18 other other JJ 31417 1198 19 . . . 31417 1199 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1199 2 R----d R----d NNP 31417 1199 3 looked look VBD 31417 1199 4 at at IN 31417 1199 5 the the DT 31417 1199 6 side side NN 31417 1199 7 with with IN 31417 1199 8 the the DT 31417 1199 9 square square NN 31417 1199 10 on on IN 31417 1199 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1199 12 , , , 31417 1199 13 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1199 14 E. E. NNP 31417 1199 15 looked look VBD 31417 1199 16 at at IN 31417 1199 17 the the DT 31417 1199 18 side side NN 31417 1199 19 with with IN 31417 1199 20 the the DT 31417 1199 21 cross cross NN 31417 1199 22 . . . 31417 1200 1 Neither neither CC 31417 1200 2 knew know VBD 31417 1200 3 what what WP 31417 1200 4 the the DT 31417 1200 5 other other JJ 31417 1200 6 was be VBD 31417 1200 7 looking look VBG 31417 1200 8 at at IN 31417 1200 9 -- -- : 31417 1200 10 nor nor CC 31417 1200 11 did do VBD 31417 1200 12 the the DT 31417 1200 13 percipient percipient NN 31417 1200 14 know know VB 31417 1200 15 that that IN 31417 1200 16 anything anything NN 31417 1200 17 unusual unusual JJ 31417 1200 18 was be VBD 31417 1200 19 being be VBG 31417 1200 20 tried try VBN 31417 1200 21 . . . 31417 1201 1 There there EX 31417 1201 2 was be VBD 31417 1201 3 no no DT 31417 1201 4 contact contact NN 31417 1201 5 . . . 31417 1202 1 Very very RB 31417 1202 2 soon soon RB 31417 1202 3 , , , 31417 1202 4 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1202 5 R. R. NNP 31417 1202 6 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1202 7 percipient percipient NN 31417 1202 8 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1202 9 said say VBD 31417 1202 10 , , , 31417 1202 11 ' ' '' 31417 1202 12 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1202 13 see see VBP 31417 1202 14 things thing NNS 31417 1202 15 moving move VBG 31417 1202 16 about about IN 31417 1202 17 .... .... . 31417 1203 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1203 2 seem seem VBP 31417 1203 3 to to TO 31417 1203 4 see see VB 31417 1203 5 two two CD 31417 1203 6 things thing NNS 31417 1203 7 .... .... . 31417 1204 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1204 2 see see VBP 31417 1204 3 first first RB 31417 1204 4 one one CD 31417 1204 5 up up RB 31417 1204 6 there there RB 31417 1204 7 and and CC 31417 1204 8 then then RB 31417 1204 9 one one CD 31417 1204 10 down down RB 31417 1204 11 there there RB 31417 1204 12 .... .... . 31417 1205 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1205 2 ca can MD 31417 1205 3 n't not RB 31417 1205 4 see see VB 31417 1205 5 either either RB 31417 1205 6 distinctly distinctly RB 31417 1205 7 . . . 31417 1205 8 ' ' '' 31417 1206 1 ' ' `` 31417 1206 2 Well well UH 31417 1206 3 , , , 31417 1206 4 anyhow anyhow RB 31417 1206 5 , , , 31417 1206 6 draw draw VB 31417 1206 7 what what WP 31417 1206 8 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1206 9 have have VBP 31417 1206 10 seen see VBN 31417 1206 11 . . . 31417 1206 12 ' ' '' 31417 1207 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 2 took take VBD 31417 1207 3 off off RP 31417 1207 4 the the DT 31417 1207 5 bandage bandage NN 31417 1207 6 and and CC 31417 1207 7 drew draw VBD 31417 1207 8 first first RB 31417 1207 9 a a DT 31417 1207 10 square square NN 31417 1207 11 , , , 31417 1207 12 and and CC 31417 1207 13 then then RB 31417 1207 14 said say VBD 31417 1207 15 , , , 31417 1207 16 ' ' '' 31417 1207 17 Then then RB 31417 1207 18 there there EX 31417 1207 19 was be VBD 31417 1207 20 the the DT 31417 1207 21 other other JJ 31417 1207 22 thing thing NN 31417 1207 23 as as RB 31417 1207 24 well well RB 31417 1207 25 , , , 31417 1207 26 ... ... : 31417 1207 27 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 1207 28 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 29 seemed seem VBD 31417 1207 30 to to TO 31417 1207 31 go go VB 31417 1207 32 into into IN 31417 1207 33 one one CD 31417 1207 34 , , , 31417 1207 35 ' ' '' 31417 1207 36 and and CC 31417 1207 37 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 38 drew draw VBD 31417 1207 39 a a DT 31417 1207 40 cross cross NN 31417 1207 41 inside inside IN 31417 1207 42 the the DT 31417 1207 43 square square NN 31417 1207 44 from from IN 31417 1207 45 corner corner NN 31417 1207 46 to to IN 31417 1207 47 corner corner NN 31417 1207 48 , , , 31417 1207 49 adding add VBG 31417 1207 50 afterwards afterwards RB 31417 1207 51 , , , 31417 1207 52 ' ' '' 31417 1207 53 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 54 do do VBP 31417 1207 55 n't not RB 31417 1207 56 know know VB 31417 1207 57 what what WP 31417 1207 58 made make VBD 31417 1207 59 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 60 put put VB 31417 1207 61 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1207 62 inside inside RB 31417 1207 63 . . . 31417 1207 64 ' ' '' 31417 1207 65 " " '' 31417 1208 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1208 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1208 3 : : : 31417 1208 4 No no UH 31417 1208 5 . . . 31417 1209 1 2 2 LS 31417 1209 2 . . . 31417 1210 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1210 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1210 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1210 4 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1210 5 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1210 6 : : : 31417 1210 7 No no UH 31417 1210 8 . . . 31417 1211 1 3 3 LS 31417 1211 2 . . . 31417 1212 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1212 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1212 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1212 4 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1212 5 3 3 CD 31417 1212 6 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1212 7 " " `` 31417 1212 8 Object object NN 31417 1212 9 -- -- : 31417 1212 10 a a DT 31417 1212 11 drawing drawing NN 31417 1212 12 of of IN 31417 1212 13 the the DT 31417 1212 14 outline outline NN 31417 1212 15 of of IN 31417 1212 16 a a DT 31417 1212 17 flag flag NN 31417 1212 18 . . . 31417 1213 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1213 2 R. R. NNP 31417 1213 3 as as IN 31417 1213 4 percipient percipient NN 31417 1213 5 , , , 31417 1213 6 in in IN 31417 1213 7 contact contact NN 31417 1213 8 with with IN 31417 1213 9 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1213 10 E. E. NNP 31417 1213 11 as as IN 31417 1213 12 agent agent NN 31417 1213 13 . . . 31417 1214 1 Very very RB 31417 1214 2 quickly quickly RB 31417 1214 3 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1214 4 R. R. NNP 31417 1214 5 said say VBD 31417 1214 6 , , , 31417 1214 7 ' ' `` 31417 1214 8 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1214 9 's be VBZ 31417 1214 10 a a DT 31417 1214 11 little little JJ 31417 1214 12 flag flag NN 31417 1214 13 . . . 31417 1214 14 ' ' '' 31417 1215 1 And and CC 31417 1215 2 when when WRB 31417 1215 3 asked ask VBN 31417 1215 4 to to TO 31417 1215 5 draw draw VB 31417 1215 6 , , , 31417 1215 7 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1215 8 drew draw VBD 31417 1215 9 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1215 10 fairly fairly RB 31417 1215 11 well well RB 31417 1215 12 but but CC 31417 1215 13 perverted perverted JJ 31417 1215 14 . . . 31417 1216 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1216 2 showed show VBD 31417 1216 3 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1216 4 the the DT 31417 1216 5 flag flag NN 31417 1216 6 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1216 7 as as IN 31417 1216 8 usual usual JJ 31417 1216 9 after after IN 31417 1216 10 a a DT 31417 1216 11 success success NN 31417 1216 12 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1216 13 , , , 31417 1216 14 and and CC 31417 1216 15 then then RB 31417 1216 16 took take VBD 31417 1216 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1216 18 away away RB 31417 1216 19 to to IN 31417 1216 20 the the DT 31417 1216 21 drawing drawing NN 31417 1216 22 place place NN 31417 1216 23 to to TO 31417 1216 24 fetch fetch VB 31417 1216 25 something something NN 31417 1216 26 else else RB 31417 1216 27 . . . 31417 1217 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1217 2 made make VBD 31417 1217 3 another another DT 31417 1217 4 drawing drawing NN 31417 1217 5 , , , 31417 1217 6 but but CC 31417 1217 7 instead instead RB 31417 1217 8 of of IN 31417 1217 9 bringing bring VBG 31417 1217 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1217 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1217 12 brought bring VBD 31417 1217 13 the the DT 31417 1217 14 flag flag NN 31417 1217 15 back back RB 31417 1217 16 again again RB 31417 1217 17 and and CC 31417 1217 18 set set VBD 31417 1217 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1217 20 up up RP 31417 1217 21 in in IN 31417 1217 22 the the DT 31417 1217 23 same same JJ 31417 1217 24 place place NN 31417 1217 25 as as IN 31417 1217 26 before before RB 31417 1217 27 , , , 31417 1217 28 but but CC 31417 1217 29 inverted invert VBN 31417 1217 30 . . . 31417 1218 1 There there EX 31417 1218 2 was be VBD 31417 1218 3 no no DT 31417 1218 4 contact contact NN 31417 1218 5 this this DT 31417 1218 6 time time NN 31417 1218 7 . . . 31417 1219 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1219 2 R----d R----d NNP 31417 1219 3 and and CC 31417 1219 4 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1219 5 E. E. NNP 31417 1219 6 were be VBD 31417 1219 7 acting act VBG 31417 1219 8 as as IN 31417 1219 9 agents agent NNS 31417 1219 10 . . . 31417 1220 1 After after IN 31417 1220 2 some some DT 31417 1220 3 time time NN 31417 1220 4 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1220 5 R. R. NNP 31417 1220 6 said say VBD 31417 1220 7 , , , 31417 1220 8 ' ' `` 31417 1220 9 No no UH 31417 1220 10 , , , 31417 1220 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1220 12 ca can MD 31417 1220 13 nt not RB 31417 1220 14 see see VB 31417 1220 15 anything anything NN 31417 1220 16 this this DT 31417 1220 17 time time NN 31417 1220 18 . . . 31417 1221 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1221 2 still still RB 31417 1221 3 see see VBP 31417 1221 4 that that DT 31417 1221 5 flag flag NN 31417 1221 6 .... .... . 31417 1222 1 The the DT 31417 1222 2 flag flag NN 31417 1222 3 keeps keep VBZ 31417 1222 4 bothering bother VBG 31417 1222 5 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1222 6 .... .... . 31417 1223 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1223 2 sha shall MD 31417 1223 3 n't not RB 31417 1223 4 do do VB 31417 1223 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1223 6 this this DT 31417 1223 7 time time NN 31417 1223 8 . . . 31417 1223 9 ' ' '' 31417 1224 1 Presently presently RB 31417 1224 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1224 3 said say VBD 31417 1224 4 , , , 31417 1224 5 ' ' '' 31417 1224 6 Well well UH 31417 1224 7 , , , 31417 1224 8 draw draw VB 31417 1224 9 what what WP 31417 1224 10 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1224 11 saw see VBD 31417 1224 12 anyway anyway RB 31417 1224 13 . . . 31417 1224 14 ' ' '' 31417 1225 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1225 2 said say VBD 31417 1225 3 , , , 31417 1225 4 ' ' '' 31417 1225 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1225 6 only only RB 31417 1225 7 saw see VBD 31417 1225 8 the the DT 31417 1225 9 same same JJ 31417 1225 10 flag flag NN 31417 1225 11 , , , 31417 1225 12 but but CC 31417 1225 13 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 1225 14 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1225 15 had have VBD 31417 1225 16 a a DT 31417 1225 17 cross cross NN 31417 1225 18 on on IN 31417 1225 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1225 20 . . . 31417 1225 21 ' ' '' 31417 1226 1 So so RB 31417 1226 2 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1226 3 drew draw VBD 31417 1226 4 a a DT 31417 1226 5 flag flag NN 31417 1226 6 in in IN 31417 1226 7 the the DT 31417 1226 8 same same JJ 31417 1226 9 position position NN 31417 1226 10 as as IN 31417 1226 11 before before RB 31417 1226 12 , , , 31417 1226 13 but but CC 31417 1226 14 added add VBD 31417 1226 15 a a DT 31417 1226 16 cross cross NN 31417 1226 17 to to IN 31417 1226 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1226 19 . . . 31417 1226 20 " " '' 31417 1227 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1227 2 4 4 LS 31417 1227 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1227 4 " " `` 31417 1227 5 Object object NN 31417 1227 6 -- -- : 31417 1227 7 a a DT 31417 1227 8 teapot teapot NN 31417 1227 9 cut cut VBN 31417 1227 10 out out IN 31417 1227 11 of of IN 31417 1227 12 silver silver JJ 31417 1227 13 paper paper NN 31417 1227 14 . . . 31417 1228 1 Present present JJ 31417 1228 2 -- -- : 31417 1228 3 Dr Dr NNP 31417 1228 4 . . NNP 31417 1228 5 Herdman Herdman NNP 31417 1228 6 , , , 31417 1228 7 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1228 8 R----d R----d NNP 31417 1228 9 , , , 31417 1228 10 and and CC 31417 1228 11 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1228 12 R. R. NNP 31417 1228 13 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1228 14 E. E. NNP 31417 1228 15 percipient percipient NN 31417 1228 16 . . . 31417 1229 1 Miss Miss NNP 31417 1229 2 R. R. NNP 31417 1229 3 holding hold VBG 31417 1229 4 percipient percipient NN 31417 1229 5 's 's POS 31417 1229 6 hands hand NNS 31417 1229 7 , , , 31417 1229 8 but but CC 31417 1229 9 all all DT 31417 1229 10 thinking think VBG 31417 1229 11 of of IN 31417 1229 12 the the DT 31417 1229 13 object object NN 31417 1229 14 . . . 31417 1230 1 Told tell VBD 31417 1230 2 nothing nothing NN 31417 1230 3 . . . 31417 1231 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1231 2 said say VBD 31417 1231 3 , , , 31417 1231 4 ' ' `` 31417 1231 5 Something something NN 31417 1231 6 light light JJ 31417 1231 7 .... .... NFP 31417 1231 8 No no DT 31417 1231 9 colour colour NN 31417 1231 10 .... .... . 31417 1231 11 Looks look VBZ 31417 1231 12 like like IN 31417 1231 13 a a DT 31417 1231 14 duck duck NN 31417 1231 15 .... .... NFP 31417 1231 16 Like like IN 31417 1231 17 a a DT 31417 1231 18 silver silver JJ 31417 1231 19 duck duck NN 31417 1231 20 .... .... . 31417 1231 21 Something something NN 31417 1231 22 oval oval NN 31417 1231 23 .... .... . 31417 1231 24 Head head VB 31417 1231 25 at at IN 31417 1231 26 one one CD 31417 1231 27 end end NN 31417 1231 28 and and CC 31417 1231 29 tail tail NN 31417 1231 30 at at IN 31417 1231 31 the the DT 31417 1231 32 other other JJ 31417 1231 33 . . . 31417 1231 34 ' ' '' 31417 1232 1 ... ... NFP 31417 1233 1 The the DT 31417 1233 2 object object NN 31417 1233 3 being be VBG 31417 1233 4 rather rather RB 31417 1233 5 large large JJ 31417 1233 6 , , , 31417 1233 7 was be VBD 31417 1233 8 then then RB 31417 1233 9 moved move VBN 31417 1233 10 further further RB 31417 1233 11 back back RB 31417 1233 12 , , , 31417 1233 13 so so IN 31417 1233 14 that that IN 31417 1233 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1233 16 might may MD 31417 1233 17 be be VB 31417 1233 18 more more RBR 31417 1233 19 easily easily RB 31417 1233 20 grasped grasp VBN 31417 1233 21 by by IN 31417 1233 22 the the DT 31417 1233 23 agents agent NNS 31417 1233 24 as as IN 31417 1233 25 a a DT 31417 1233 26 whole whole NN 31417 1233 27 , , , 31417 1233 28 but but CC 31417 1233 29 percipient percipient NN 31417 1233 30 persisted persist VBD 31417 1233 31 that that IN 31417 1233 32 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1233 33 was be VBD 31417 1233 34 like like IN 31417 1233 35 a a DT 31417 1233 36 duck duck NN 31417 1233 37 . . . 31417 1234 1 On on IN 31417 1234 2 being be VBG 31417 1234 3 told tell VBN 31417 1234 4 to to TO 31417 1234 5 unbandage unbandage VB 31417 1234 6 and and CC 31417 1234 7 draw draw VB 31417 1234 8 , , , 31417 1234 9 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1234 10 drew draw VBD 31417 1234 11 a a DT 31417 1234 12 rude rude JJ 31417 1234 13 and and CC 31417 1234 14 perverted perverted JJ 31417 1234 15 copy copy NN 31417 1234 16 of of IN 31417 1234 17 the the DT 31417 1234 18 teapot teapot NN 31417 1234 19 , , , 31417 1234 20 but but CC 31417 1234 21 did do VBD 31417 1234 22 n't not RB 31417 1234 23 know know VB 31417 1234 24 what what WP 31417 1234 25 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1234 26 was be VBD 31417 1234 27 unless unless IN 31417 1234 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1234 29 was be VBD 31417 1234 30 a a DT 31417 1234 31 duck duck NN 31417 1234 32 . . . 31417 1235 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1235 2 Herdman Herdman NNP 31417 1235 3 then then RB 31417 1235 4 explained explain VBD 31417 1235 5 that that IN 31417 1235 6 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1235 7 had have VBD 31417 1235 8 been be VBN 31417 1235 9 thinking think VBG 31417 1235 10 all all PDT 31417 1235 11 the the DT 31417 1235 12 time time NN 31417 1235 13 how how WRB 31417 1235 14 like like IN 31417 1235 15 a a DT 31417 1235 16 duck duck NN 31417 1235 17 the the DT 31417 1235 18 original original JJ 31417 1235 19 teapot teapot NN 31417 1235 20 was be VBD 31417 1235 21 , , , 31417 1235 22 and and CC 31417 1235 23 in in IN 31417 1235 24 fact fact NN 31417 1235 25 had have VBD 31417 1235 26 been be VBN 31417 1235 27 thinking think VBG 31417 1235 28 more more JJR 31417 1235 29 of of IN 31417 1235 30 ducks duck NNS 31417 1235 31 than than IN 31417 1235 32 teapots teapot NNS 31417 1235 33 . . . 31417 1235 34 " " '' 31417 1236 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1236 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1236 3 : : : 31417 1236 4 No no UH 31417 1236 5 . . . 31417 1237 1 4 4 LS 31417 1237 2 . . . 31417 1238 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1238 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1238 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1238 4 In in IN 31417 1238 5 the the DT 31417 1238 6 autumn autumn NN 31417 1238 7 of of IN 31417 1238 8 1891 1891 CD 31417 1238 9 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1238 10 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1238 11 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1238 12 was be VBD 31417 1238 13 staying stay VBG 31417 1238 14 for for IN 31417 1238 15 a a DT 31417 1238 16 fortnight fortnight NN 31417 1238 17 in in IN 31417 1238 18 the the DT 31417 1238 19 house house NN 31417 1238 20 of of IN 31417 1238 21 Herr Herr NNP 31417 1238 22 von von NNP 31417 1238 23 Lyro Lyro NNP 31417 1238 24 at at IN 31417 1238 25 Portschach Portschach NNP 31417 1238 26 am be VBP 31417 1238 27 See see VB 31417 1238 28 , , , 31417 1238 29 Carinthia Carinthia NNP 31417 1238 30 . . . 31417 1239 1 While while IN 31417 1239 2 there there RB 31417 1239 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1239 4 found find VBD 31417 1239 5 that that IN 31417 1239 6 the the DT 31417 1239 7 two two CD 31417 1239 8 adult adult NN 31417 1239 9 daughters daughter NNS 31417 1239 10 of of IN 31417 1239 11 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1239 12 host host NN 31417 1239 13 were be VBD 31417 1239 14 adepts adept NNS 31417 1239 15 in in IN 31417 1239 16 the the DT 31417 1239 17 so so RB 31417 1239 18 - - HYPH 31417 1239 19 called call VBN 31417 1239 20 " " `` 31417 1239 21 willing willing JJ 31417 1239 22 game game NN 31417 1239 23 . . . 31417 1239 24 " " '' 31417 1240 1 The the DT 31417 1240 2 speed speed NN 31417 1240 3 and and CC 31417 1240 4 accuracy accuracy NN 31417 1240 5 with with IN 31417 1240 6 which which WDT 31417 1240 7 the the DT 31417 1240 8 willed will VBN 31417 1240 9 action action NN 31417 1240 10 was be VBD 31417 1240 11 performed perform VBN 31417 1240 12 left leave VBD 31417 1240 13 little little JJ 31417 1240 14 doubt doubt NN 31417 1240 15 in in IN 31417 1240 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1240 17 mind mind NN 31417 1240 18 that that IN 31417 1240 19 there there EX 31417 1240 20 was be VBD 31417 1240 21 some some DT 31417 1240 22 genuine genuine JJ 31417 1240 23 thought thought NN 31417 1240 24 - - HYPH 31417 1240 25 transference transference NN 31417 1240 26 power power NN 31417 1240 27 . . . 31417 1241 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1241 2 obtained obtain VBD 31417 1241 3 permission permission NN 31417 1241 4 to to TO 31417 1241 5 make make VB 31417 1241 6 a a DT 31417 1241 7 series series NN 31417 1241 8 of of IN 31417 1241 9 test test NN 31417 1241 10 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1241 11 , , , 31417 1241 12 the the DT 31417 1241 13 two two CD 31417 1241 14 sisters sister NNS 31417 1241 15 acting act VBG 31417 1241 16 as as IN 31417 1241 17 agent agent NN 31417 1241 18 and and CC 31417 1241 19 percipient percipient NN 31417 1241 20 alternately alternately RB 31417 1241 21 . . . 31417 1242 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1242 2 hoped hope VBD 31417 1242 3 gradually gradually RB 31417 1242 4 to to TO 31417 1242 5 secure secure VB 31417 1242 6 the the DT 31417 1242 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1242 8 without without IN 31417 1242 9 contact contact NN 31417 1242 10 of of IN 31417 1242 11 any any DT 31417 1242 12 kind kind NN 31417 1242 13 . . . 31417 1243 1 But but CC 31417 1243 2 unfortunately unfortunately RB 31417 1243 3 contact contact NN 31417 1243 4 seemed seem VBD 31417 1243 5 essential essential JJ 31417 1243 6 , , , 31417 1243 7 though though IN 31417 1243 8 of of IN 31417 1243 9 the the DT 31417 1243 10 slightest slight JJS 31417 1243 11 description description NN 31417 1243 12 , , , 31417 1243 13 for for IN 31417 1243 14 instance instance NN 31417 1243 15 through through IN 31417 1243 16 the the DT 31417 1243 17 backs back NNS 31417 1243 18 of of IN 31417 1243 19 the the DT 31417 1243 20 knuckles knuckle NNS 31417 1243 21 . . . 31417 1244 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1244 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1244 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1244 4 says say VBZ 31417 1244 5 : : : 31417 1244 6 " " `` 31417 1244 7 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1244 8 was be VBD 31417 1244 9 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1244 10 and and CC 31417 1244 11 new new JJ 31417 1244 12 to to IN 31417 1244 13 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1244 14 to to TO 31417 1244 15 see see VB 31417 1244 16 how how WRB 31417 1244 17 clearly clearly RB 31417 1244 18 the the DT 31417 1244 19 effect effect NN 31417 1244 20 seemed seem VBD 31417 1244 21 to to TO 31417 1244 22 depend depend VB 31417 1244 23 on on IN 31417 1244 24 contact contact NN 31417 1244 25 , , , 31417 1244 26 and and CC 31417 1244 27 how how WRB 31417 1244 28 abruptly abruptly RB 31417 1244 29 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1244 30 ceased cease VBD 31417 1244 31 when when WRB 31417 1244 32 contact contact NN 31417 1244 33 was be VBD 31417 1244 34 broken break VBN 31417 1244 35 . . . 31417 1245 1 While while IN 31417 1245 2 guessing guess VBG 31417 1245 3 through through IN 31417 1245 4 a a DT 31417 1245 5 pack pack NN 31417 1245 6 of of IN 31417 1245 7 cards card NNS 31417 1245 8 , , , 31417 1245 9 for for IN 31417 1245 10 instance instance NN 31417 1245 11 , , , 31417 1245 12 rapidly rapidly RB 31417 1245 13 and and CC 31417 1245 14 continuously continuously RB 31417 1245 15 , , , 31417 1245 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1245 17 sometimes sometimes RB 31417 1245 18 allowed allow VBD 31417 1245 19 contact contact NN 31417 1245 20 , , , 31417 1245 21 and and CC 31417 1245 22 sometimes sometimes RB 31417 1245 23 stopped stop VBD 31417 1245 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1245 25 ; ; : 31417 1245 26 and and CC 31417 1245 27 the the DT 31417 1245 28 guesses guess NNS 31417 1245 29 changed change VBD 31417 1245 30 , , , 31417 1245 31 from from IN 31417 1245 32 frequently frequently RB 31417 1245 33 correct correct JJ 31417 1245 34 to to IN 31417 1245 35 quite quite RB 31417 1245 36 wild wild JJ 31417 1245 37 , , , 31417 1245 38 directly directly RB 31417 1245 39 the the DT 31417 1245 40 knuckles knuckle NNS 31417 1245 41 or or CC 31417 1245 42 finger finger NN 31417 1245 43 tips tip NNS 31417 1245 44 , , , 31417 1245 45 or or CC 31417 1245 46 any any DT 31417 1245 47 part part NN 31417 1245 48 of of IN 31417 1245 49 the the DT 31417 1245 50 skin skin NN 31417 1245 51 of of IN 31417 1245 52 the the DT 31417 1245 53 two two CD 31417 1245 54 hands hand NNS 31417 1245 55 ceased cease VBD 31417 1245 56 to to TO 31417 1245 57 touch touch VB 31417 1245 58 . . . 31417 1246 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1246 2 was be VBD 31417 1246 3 almost almost RB 31417 1246 4 like like IN 31417 1246 5 breaking break VBG 31417 1246 6 an an DT 31417 1246 7 electric electric JJ 31417 1246 8 circuit circuit NN 31417 1246 9 . . . 31417 1246 10 " " '' 31417 1247 1 As as IN 31417 1247 2 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1247 3 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1247 4 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1247 5 remarks remark VBZ 31417 1247 6 , , , 31417 1247 7 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1247 8 is be VBZ 31417 1247 9 obvious obvious JJ 31417 1247 10 how how WRB 31417 1247 11 strongly strongly RB 31417 1247 12 this this DT 31417 1247 13 suggests suggest VBZ 31417 1247 14 the the DT 31417 1247 15 idea idea NN 31417 1247 16 of of IN 31417 1247 17 a a DT 31417 1247 18 code code NN 31417 1247 19 , , , 31417 1247 20 and and CC 31417 1247 21 that that IN 31417 1247 22 therefore therefore RB 31417 1247 23 this this DT 31417 1247 24 flaw flaw NN 31417 1247 25 prevents prevent VBZ 31417 1247 26 these these DT 31417 1247 27 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1247 28 from from IN 31417 1247 29 having have VBG 31417 1247 30 any any DT 31417 1247 31 value value NN 31417 1247 32 as as IN 31417 1247 33 tests test NNS 31417 1247 34 , , , 31417 1247 35 or or CC 31417 1247 36 as as IN 31417 1247 37 establishing establish VBG 31417 1247 38 _ _ NNP 31417 1247 39 de de NNP 31417 1247 40 novo novo NNP 31417 1247 41 _ _ NNP 31417 1247 42 the the DT 31417 1247 43 existence existence NN 31417 1247 44 of of IN 31417 1247 45 the the DT 31417 1247 46 genuine genuine JJ 31417 1247 47 power power NN 31417 1247 48 . . . 31417 1248 1 But but CC 31417 1248 2 apart apart RB 31417 1248 3 from from IN 31417 1248 4 the the DT 31417 1248 5 moral moral JJ 31417 1248 6 conviction conviction NN 31417 1248 7 that that IN 31417 1248 8 unfair unfair JJ 31417 1248 9 practices practice NNS 31417 1248 10 were be VBD 31417 1248 11 extremely extremely RB 31417 1248 12 unlikely unlikely JJ 31417 1248 13 , , , 31417 1248 14 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1248 15 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1248 16 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1248 17 says say VBZ 31417 1248 18 that that IN 31417 1248 19 there there EX 31417 1248 20 was be VBD 31417 1248 21 a a DT 31417 1248 22 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 1248 23 amount amount NN 31417 1248 24 of of IN 31417 1248 25 internal internal JJ 31417 1248 26 evidence evidence NN 31417 1248 27 derived derive VBN 31417 1248 28 from from IN 31417 1248 29 the the DT 31417 1248 30 facts fact NNS 31417 1248 31 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1248 32 to to TO 31417 1248 33 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1248 34 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1248 35 that that IN 31417 1248 36 no no DT 31417 1248 37 code code NN 31417 1248 38 was be VBD 31417 1248 39 used use VBN 31417 1248 40 . . . 31417 1249 1 As as IN 31417 1249 2 examples example NNS 31417 1249 3 , , , 31417 1249 4 two two CD 31417 1249 5 from from IN 31417 1249 6 a a DT 31417 1249 7 series series NN 31417 1249 8 of of IN 31417 1249 9 twelve twelve CD 31417 1249 10 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1249 11 are be VBP 31417 1249 12 given give VBN 31417 1249 13 . . . 31417 1250 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1250 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1250 3 : : : 31417 1250 4 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1250 5 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1250 6 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1250 7 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1250 8 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1250 9 : : : 31417 1250 10 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1250 11 REPRODUCTIONS reproduction NNS 31417 1250 12 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1250 13 In in IN 31417 1250 14 1894 1894 CD 31417 1250 15 , , , 31417 1250 16 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1250 17 Henry Henry NNP 31417 1250 18 G. G. NNP 31417 1250 19 Rawson Rawson NNP 31417 1250 20 , , , 31417 1250 21 barrister barrister NN 31417 1250 22 - - HYPH 31417 1250 23 at at IN 31417 1250 24 - - HYPH 31417 1250 25 law law NN 31417 1250 26 , , , 31417 1250 27 made make VBD 31417 1250 28 a a DT 31417 1250 29 long long JJ 31417 1250 30 and and CC 31417 1250 31 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1250 32 series series NN 31417 1250 33 of of IN 31417 1250 34 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1250 35 in in IN 31417 1250 36 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1250 37 - - HYPH 31417 1250 38 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1250 39 , , , 31417 1250 40 a a DT 31417 1250 41 Report Report NNP 31417 1250 42 of of IN 31417 1250 43 which which WDT 31417 1250 44 was be VBD 31417 1250 45 published publish VBN 31417 1250 46 in in IN 31417 1250 47 vol vol NNP 31417 1250 48 . . . 31417 1251 1 xi xi NNP 31417 1251 2 . . . 31417 1252 1 of of IN 31417 1252 2 the the DT 31417 1252 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1252 4 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1252 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1252 6 of of IN 31417 1252 7 the the DT 31417 1252 8 Society Society NNP 31417 1252 9 for for IN 31417 1252 10 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1252 11 Research Research NNP 31417 1252 12 . . . 31417 1253 1 The the DT 31417 1253 2 Report Report NNP 31417 1253 3 includes include VBZ 31417 1253 4 fifteen fifteen CD 31417 1253 5 originals original NNS 31417 1253 6 and and CC 31417 1253 7 reproductions reproduction NNS 31417 1253 8 of of IN 31417 1253 9 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1253 10 . . . 31417 1254 1 Two two CD 31417 1254 2 sisters sister NNS 31417 1254 3 , , , 31417 1254 4 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1254 5 L. L. NNP 31417 1254 6 and and CC 31417 1254 7 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1254 8 B. B. NNP 31417 1254 9 , , , 31417 1254 10 were be VBD 31417 1254 11 the the DT 31417 1254 12 operators operator NNS 31417 1254 13 ; ; : 31417 1254 14 and and CC 31417 1254 15 on on IN 31417 1254 16 the the DT 31417 1254 17 two two CD 31417 1254 18 evenings evening NNS 31417 1254 19 when when WRB 31417 1254 20 the the DT 31417 1254 21 two two CD 31417 1254 22 series series NN 31417 1254 23 of of IN 31417 1254 24 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1254 25 were be VBD 31417 1254 26 executed execute VBN 31417 1254 27 , , , 31417 1254 28 from from IN 31417 1254 29 which which WDT 31417 1254 30 the the DT 31417 1254 31 accompanying accompany VBG 31417 1254 32 selections selection NNS 31417 1254 33 are be VBP 31417 1254 34 made make VBN 31417 1254 35 , , , 31417 1254 36 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1254 37 Rawson Rawson NNP 31417 1254 38 was be VBD 31417 1254 39 the the DT 31417 1254 40 only only JJ 31417 1254 41 other other JJ 31417 1254 42 person person NN 31417 1254 43 present present JJ 31417 1254 44 . . . 31417 1255 1 On on IN 31417 1255 2 both both DT 31417 1255 3 occasions occasion NNS 31417 1255 4 , , , 31417 1255 5 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1255 6 L. L. NNP 31417 1255 7 sat sit VBD 31417 1255 8 on on IN 31417 1255 9 a a DT 31417 1255 10 chair chair NN 31417 1255 11 near near IN 31417 1255 12 the the DT 31417 1255 13 fire fire NN 31417 1255 14 , , , 31417 1255 15 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1255 16 R. R. NNP 31417 1255 17 sat sit VBD 31417 1255 18 at at IN 31417 1255 19 a a DT 31417 1255 20 table table NN 31417 1255 21 many many JJ 31417 1255 22 feet foot NNS 31417 1255 23 off off RP 31417 1255 24 , , , 31417 1255 25 with with IN 31417 1255 26 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1255 27 back back RB 31417 1255 28 to to IN 31417 1255 29 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1255 30 L. L. NNP 31417 1255 31 , , , 31417 1255 32 and and CC 31417 1255 33 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1255 34 Rawson Rawson NNP 31417 1255 35 stood stand VBD 31417 1255 36 or or CC 31417 1255 37 sat sit VBD 31417 1255 38 where where WRB 31417 1255 39 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1255 40 could could MD 31417 1255 41 see see VB 31417 1255 42 both both DT 31417 1255 43 ladies lady NNS 31417 1255 44 . . . 31417 1256 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1256 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1256 3 : : : 31417 1256 4 5 5 CD 31417 1256 5 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1256 6 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1256 7 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1256 8 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1256 9 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1256 10 : : : 31417 1256 11 6 6 CD 31417 1256 12 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1256 13 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1256 14 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1256 15 Nos Nos NNP 31417 1256 16 . . . 31417 1257 1 5 5 CD 31417 1257 2 and and CC 31417 1257 3 6 6 CD 31417 1257 4 of of IN 31417 1257 5 the the DT 31417 1257 6 first first JJ 31417 1257 7 series series NN 31417 1257 8 are be VBP 31417 1257 9 here here RB 31417 1257 10 reproduced reproduce VBN 31417 1257 11 . . . 31417 1258 1 The the DT 31417 1258 2 following follow VBG 31417 1258 3 selection selection NN 31417 1258 4 is be VBZ 31417 1258 5 from from IN 31417 1258 6 the the DT 31417 1258 7 second second JJ 31417 1258 8 series series NN 31417 1258 9 . . . 31417 1259 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1259 2 Rawson Rawson NNP 31417 1259 3 says say VBZ 31417 1259 4 respecting respect VBG 31417 1259 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1259 6 : : : 31417 1259 7 " " `` 31417 1259 8 Mrs. Mrs. NNP 31417 1259 9 L. L. NNP 31417 1259 10 began begin VBD 31417 1259 11 drawing draw VBG 31417 1259 12 within within IN 31417 1259 13 ten ten CD 31417 1259 14 to to IN 31417 1259 15 fifteen fifteen CD 31417 1259 16 seconds second NNS 31417 1259 17 , , , 31417 1259 18 and and CC 31417 1259 19 presently presently RB 31417 1259 20 said say VBD 31417 1259 21 , , , 31417 1259 22 ' ' '' 31417 1259 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1259 24 am be VBP 31417 1259 25 drawing draw VBG 31417 1259 26 something something NN 31417 1259 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1259 28 can can MD 31417 1259 29 see see VB 31417 1259 30 . . . 31417 1259 31 ' ' '' 31417 1260 1 The the DT 31417 1260 2 clock clock NN 31417 1260 3 was be VBD 31417 1260 4 in in IN 31417 1260 5 front front NN 31417 1260 6 of of IN 31417 1260 7 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1260 8 on on IN 31417 1260 9 the the DT 31417 1260 10 mantelpiece mantelpiece NN 31417 1260 11 . . . 31417 1260 12 " " '' 31417 1261 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1261 2 would would MD 31417 1261 3 seem seem VB 31417 1261 4 as as IN 31417 1261 5 though though IN 31417 1261 6 the the DT 31417 1261 7 idea idea NN 31417 1261 8 of of IN 31417 1261 9 a a DT 31417 1261 10 clock clock NN 31417 1261 11 was be VBD 31417 1261 12 thought think VBN 31417 1261 13 - - HYPH 31417 1261 14 transferred transfer VBN 31417 1261 15 at at IN 31417 1261 16 once once RB 31417 1261 17 ; ; : 31417 1261 18 but but CC 31417 1261 19 that that IN 31417 1261 20 the the DT 31417 1261 21 working work VBG 31417 1261 22 out out IN 31417 1261 23 of of IN 31417 1261 24 the the DT 31417 1261 25 idea idea NN 31417 1261 26 in in IN 31417 1261 27 the the DT 31417 1261 28 mind mind NN 31417 1261 29 was be VBD 31417 1261 30 modified modify VBN 31417 1261 31 by by IN 31417 1261 32 what what WP 31417 1261 33 the the DT 31417 1261 34 percipient percipient NN 31417 1261 35 happened happen VBD 31417 1261 36 to to TO 31417 1261 37 see see VB 31417 1261 38 before before IN 31417 1261 39 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1261 40 . . . 31417 1262 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1262 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1262 3 : : : 31417 1262 4 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1262 5 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1262 6 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1262 7 A a DT 31417 1262 8 final final JJ 31417 1262 9 selection selection NN 31417 1262 10 of of IN 31417 1262 11 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1262 12 - - HYPH 31417 1262 13 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1262 14 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1262 15 will will MD 31417 1262 16 be be VB 31417 1262 17 taken take VBN 31417 1262 18 from from IN 31417 1262 19 the the DT 31417 1262 20 records record NNS 31417 1262 21 of of IN 31417 1262 22 several several JJ 31417 1262 23 series series NN 31417 1262 24 of of IN 31417 1262 25 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1262 26 of of IN 31417 1262 27 different different JJ 31417 1262 28 kinds kind NNS 31417 1262 29 made make VBN 31417 1262 30 in in IN 31417 1262 31 1897 1897 CD 31417 1262 32 and and CC 31417 1262 33 1898 1898 CD 31417 1262 34 by by IN 31417 1262 35 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1262 36 A. A. NNP 31417 1262 37 P. P. NNP 31417 1262 38 Chattock Chattock NNP 31417 1262 39 , , , 31417 1262 40 of of IN 31417 1262 41 University University NNP 31417 1262 42 College College NNP 31417 1262 43 , , , 31417 1262 44 Bristol Bristol NNP 31417 1262 45 . . . 31417 1263 1 The the DT 31417 1263 2 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1263 3 were be VBD 31417 1263 4 made make VBN 31417 1263 5 with with IN 31417 1263 6 two two CD 31417 1263 7 old old JJ 31417 1263 8 students student NNS 31417 1263 9 of of IN 31417 1263 10 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1263 11 Chattock Chattock NNP 31417 1263 12 's 's POS 31417 1263 13 , , , 31417 1263 14 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1263 15 Wedmore Wedmore NNP 31417 1263 16 and and CC 31417 1263 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1263 18 Clinker Clinker NNP 31417 1263 19 . . . 31417 1264 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1264 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1264 3 : : : 31417 1264 4 No no UH 31417 1264 5 . . . 31417 1265 1 6 6 CD 31417 1265 2 . . . 31417 1266 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1266 2 REPRODUCTION reproduction NN 31417 1266 3 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1266 4 1 1 CD 31417 1266 5 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1266 6 . . . 31417 1266 7 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1267 1 REPRODUCTION REPRODUCTION NNP 31417 1267 2 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1267 3 2 2 CD 31417 1267 4 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1267 5 . . . 31417 1267 6 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1268 1 No no UH 31417 1268 2 . . . 31417 1269 1 6 6 CD 31417 1269 2 of of IN 31417 1269 3 a a DT 31417 1269 4 series series NN 31417 1269 5 done do VBN 31417 1269 6 at at IN 31417 1269 7 Harrow Harrow NNP 31417 1269 8 , , , 31417 1269 9 September September NNP 31417 1269 10 1897 1897 CD 31417 1269 11 . . . 31417 1270 1 Agents Agents NNP 31417 1270 2 , , , 31417 1270 3 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1270 4 Chattock Chattock NNP 31417 1270 5 and and CC 31417 1270 6 R. R. NNP 31417 1270 7 C. C. NNP 31417 1270 8 Clinker Clinker NNP 31417 1270 9 . . . 31417 1271 1 Percipient Percipient NNP 31417 1271 2 , , , 31417 1271 3 E. E. NNP 31417 1271 4 B. B. NNP 31417 1271 5 Wedmore Wedmore NNP 31417 1271 6 . . . 31417 1272 1 E. E. NNP 31417 1272 2 B. B. NNP 31417 1272 3 W. W. NNP 31417 1272 4 about about RB 31417 1272 5 three three CD 31417 1272 6 yards yard NNS 31417 1272 7 from from IN 31417 1272 8 agents agent NNS 31417 1272 9 , , , 31417 1272 10 with with IN 31417 1272 11 lamp lamp NN 31417 1272 12 and and CC 31417 1272 13 table table NN 31417 1272 14 between between IN 31417 1272 15 . . . 31417 1273 1 To to IN 31417 1273 2 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1273 3 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1273 4 1 1 LS 31417 1273 5 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1273 6 these these DT 31417 1273 7 words word NNS 31417 1273 8 are be VBP 31417 1273 9 added add VBN 31417 1273 10 : : : 31417 1273 11 " " `` 31417 1273 12 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1273 13 thought think VBD 31417 1273 14 of of IN 31417 1273 15 these these DT 31417 1273 16 , , , 31417 1273 17 and and CC 31417 1273 18 then then RB 31417 1273 19 suggested suggest VBD 31417 1273 20 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1273 21 should should MD 31417 1273 22 try try VB 31417 1273 23 three three CD 31417 1273 24 musical musical JJ 31417 1273 25 notes note NNS 31417 1273 26 . . . 31417 1273 27 " " '' 31417 1274 1 And and CC 31417 1274 2 to to IN 31417 1274 3 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1274 4 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1274 5 2 2 LS 31417 1274 6 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1274 7 these these DT 31417 1274 8 words word NNS 31417 1274 9 are be VBP 31417 1274 10 added add VBN 31417 1274 11 : : : 31417 1274 12 " " `` 31417 1274 13 Got got VB 31417 1274 14 this this DT 31417 1274 15 result result NN 31417 1274 16 . . . 31417 1274 17 " " '' 31417 1275 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1275 2 Illustration illustration NN 31417 1275 3 : : : 31417 1275 4 No no UH 31417 1275 5 . . . 31417 1276 1 1 1 LS 31417 1276 2 . . . 31417 1277 1 ORIGINAL original JJ 31417 1277 2 Agent Agent NNP 31417 1277 3 , , , 31417 1277 4 E. E. NNP 31417 1277 5 B. B. NNP 31417 1278 1 Wedmore Wedmore NNP 31417 1278 2 . . . 31417 1278 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1279 1 REPRODUCTION REPRODUCTION NNP 31417 1279 2 Percipient Percipient NNP 31417 1279 3 , , , 31417 1279 4 R. R. NNP 31417 1280 1 Wedmore Wedmore NNP 31417 1280 2 . . . 31417 1280 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1281 1 No no UH 31417 1281 2 . . . 31417 1282 1 1 1 CD 31417 1282 2 of of IN 31417 1282 3 a a DT 31417 1282 4 series series NN 31417 1282 5 done do VBN 31417 1282 6 in in IN 31417 1282 7 London London NNP 31417 1282 8 , , , 31417 1282 9 a a DT 31417 1282 10 little little JJ 31417 1282 11 later later RB 31417 1282 12 . . . 31417 1283 1 The the DT 31417 1283 2 reproduction reproduction NN 31417 1283 3 was be VBD 31417 1283 4 drawn draw VBN 31417 1283 5 in in IN 31417 1283 6 about about RB 31417 1283 7 one one CD 31417 1283 8 and and CC 31417 1283 9 a a DT 31417 1283 10 half half NN 31417 1283 11 minutes minute NNS 31417 1283 12 after after IN 31417 1283 13 the the DT 31417 1283 14 sitting sitting NN 31417 1283 15 commenced commence VBD 31417 1283 16 . . . 31417 1284 1 The the DT 31417 1284 2 Report Report NNP 31417 1284 3 of of IN 31417 1284 4 the the DT 31417 1284 5 various various JJ 31417 1284 6 series series NN 31417 1284 7 of of IN 31417 1284 8 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1284 9 is be VBZ 31417 1284 10 printed print VBN 31417 1284 11 in in IN 31417 1284 12 the the DT 31417 1284 13 _ _ NNP 31417 1284 14 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1284 15 _ _ NNP 31417 1284 16 of of IN 31417 1284 17 the the DT 31417 1284 18 Society Society NNP 31417 1284 19 for for IN 31417 1284 20 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1284 21 Research Research NNP 31417 1284 22 for for IN 31417 1284 23 November November NNP 31417 1284 24 1898 1898 CD 31417 1284 25 . . . 31417 1285 1 Instead instead RB 31417 1285 2 of of IN 31417 1285 3 giving give VBG 31417 1285 4 detailed detailed JJ 31417 1285 5 references reference NNS 31417 1285 6 to to IN 31417 1285 7 all all PDT 31417 1285 8 the the DT 31417 1285 9 quotations quotation NNS 31417 1285 10 in in IN 31417 1285 11 the the DT 31417 1285 12 descriptions description NNS 31417 1285 13 of of IN 31417 1285 14 these these DT 31417 1285 15 various various JJ 31417 1285 16 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1285 17 - - HYPH 31417 1285 18 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1285 19 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1285 20 , , , 31417 1285 21 a a DT 31417 1285 22 list list NN 31417 1285 23 of of IN 31417 1285 24 the the DT 31417 1285 25 several several JJ 31417 1285 26 Reports report NNS 31417 1285 27 is be VBZ 31417 1285 28 appended append VBN 31417 1285 29 . . . 31417 1286 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1286 2 can can MD 31417 1286 3 be be VB 31417 1286 4 referred refer VBN 31417 1286 5 to to IN 31417 1286 6 for for IN 31417 1286 7 further further JJ 31417 1286 8 information information NN 31417 1286 9 . . . 31417 1287 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1287 2 65 65 CD 31417 1287 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1287 4 Second Second NNP 31417 1287 5 Report Report NNP 31417 1287 6 of of IN 31417 1287 7 the the DT 31417 1287 8 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNS 31417 1288 1 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1288 2 . . . 31417 1289 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1289 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1289 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1289 4 , , , 31417 1289 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1289 6 . . . 31417 1290 1 i. i. NNP 31417 1290 2 , , , 31417 1290 3 part part NNP 31417 1290 4 ii ii NNP 31417 1290 5 . . NNP 31417 1290 6 , , , 31417 1290 7 1882 1882 CD 31417 1290 8 . . . 31417 1291 1 See see VB 31417 1291 2 p. p. NN 31417 1291 3 92 92 CD 31417 1291 4 . . . 31417 1292 1 Third Third NNP 31417 1292 2 Report Report NNP 31417 1292 3 of of IN 31417 1292 4 the the DT 31417 1292 5 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNS 31417 1293 1 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1293 2 . . . 31417 1294 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1294 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1294 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1294 4 , , , 31417 1294 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1294 6 . . . 31417 1295 1 i. i. NNP 31417 1295 2 , , , 31417 1295 3 part part NNP 31417 1295 4 iii iii NNP 31417 1295 5 . . NNP 31417 1295 6 , , , 31417 1295 7 1883 1883 CD 31417 1295 8 . . . 31417 1296 1 See see VB 31417 1296 2 pp pp NNP 31417 1296 3 . . . 31417 1297 1 94 94 CD 31417 1297 2 , , , 31417 1297 3 95 95 CD 31417 1297 4 . . . 31417 1298 1 Experiments experiment NNS 31417 1298 2 in in IN 31417 1298 3 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1298 4 - - HYPH 31417 1298 5 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1298 6 , , , 31417 1298 7 by by IN 31417 1298 8 Malcolm Malcolm NNP 31417 1298 9 Guthrie Guthrie NNP 31417 1298 10 . . . 31417 1299 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1299 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1299 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1299 4 , , , 31417 1299 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1299 6 . . . 31417 1300 1 ii ii NNP 31417 1300 2 . . NNP 31417 1300 3 , , , 31417 1300 4 part part NN 31417 1300 5 v. v. NNP 31417 1300 6 , , , 31417 1300 7 1884 1884 CD 31417 1300 8 . . . 31417 1301 1 See see VB 31417 1301 2 pp pp NNP 31417 1301 3 . . . 31417 1302 1 96 96 CD 31417 1302 2 , , , 31417 1302 3 97 97 CD 31417 1302 4 . . . 31417 1303 1 Experiments experiment NNS 31417 1303 2 in in IN 31417 1303 3 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1303 4 - - HYPH 31417 1303 5 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1303 6 , , , 31417 1303 7 by by IN 31417 1303 8 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1303 9 J. J. NNP 31417 1303 10 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1303 11 , , , 31417 1303 12 D.Sc D.Sc NNP 31417 1303 13 . . . 31417 1304 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1304 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1304 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1304 4 , , , 31417 1304 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1304 6 . . . 31417 1305 1 ii ii NNP 31417 1305 2 . . NNP 31417 1305 3 , , , 31417 1305 4 part part NN 31417 1305 5 vi vi NNP 31417 1305 6 . . NNP 31417 1305 7 , , , 31417 1305 8 1884 1884 CD 31417 1305 9 . . . 31417 1306 1 See see VB 31417 1306 2 pp pp NNP 31417 1306 3 . . . 31417 1307 1 100 100 CD 31417 1307 2 - - SYM 31417 1307 3 102 102 CD 31417 1307 4 . . . 31417 1308 1 Some some DT 31417 1308 2 Recent recent JJ 31417 1308 3 Thought thought NN 31417 1308 4 - - HYPH 31417 1308 5 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1308 6 Experiments Experiments NNPS 31417 1308 7 , , , 31417 1308 8 by by IN 31417 1308 9 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1308 10 J. J. NNP 31417 1308 11 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1308 12 . . . 31417 1309 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1309 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1309 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1309 4 , , , 31417 1309 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1309 6 . . . 31417 1310 1 vii vii NNP 31417 1310 2 . . . 31417 1310 3 , , , 31417 1310 4 part part NN 31417 1310 5 xx xx NNP 31417 1310 6 . . NNP 31417 1310 7 , , , 31417 1310 8 1891 1891 CD 31417 1310 9 . . . 31417 1311 1 See see VB 31417 1311 2 p. p. NN 31417 1311 3 104 104 CD 31417 1311 4 . . . 31417 1312 1 Experiments experiment NNS 31417 1312 2 in in IN 31417 1312 3 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1312 4 - - HYPH 31417 1312 5 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1312 6 , , , 31417 1312 7 by by IN 31417 1312 8 Henry Henry NNP 31417 1312 9 G. G. NNP 31417 1312 10 Rawson Rawson NNP 31417 1312 11 . . . 31417 1313 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1313 2 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1313 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1313 4 , , , 31417 1313 5 vol vol NNP 31417 1313 6 . . . 31417 1314 1 xi xi NNP 31417 1314 2 . . NNP 31417 1314 3 , , , 31417 1314 4 part part NNP 31417 1314 5 xxvii xxvii NNP 31417 1314 6 . . NNP 31417 1314 7 , , , 31417 1314 8 1894 1894 CD 31417 1314 9 . . . 31417 1315 1 See see VB 31417 1315 2 pp pp NNP 31417 1315 3 . . . 31417 1316 1 105 105 CD 31417 1316 2 , , , 31417 1316 3 106 106 CD 31417 1316 4 . . . 31417 1317 1 Experiments experiment NNS 31417 1317 2 in in IN 31417 1317 3 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1317 4 - - HYPH 31417 1317 5 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1317 6 , , , 31417 1317 7 by by IN 31417 1317 8 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1317 9 A. A. NNP 31417 1317 10 P. P. NNP 31417 1317 11 Chattock Chattock NNP 31417 1317 12 . . . 31417 1318 1 _ _ NNP 31417 1318 2 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1318 3 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1318 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1318 5 , , , 31417 1318 6 vol vol NNP 31417 1318 7 . . . 31417 1319 1 xiii xiii NNP 31417 1319 2 . . NNP 31417 1319 3 , , , 31417 1319 4 No no UH 31417 1319 5 . . . 31417 1320 1 153 153 CD 31417 1320 2 , , , 31417 1320 3 Nov. November NNP 31417 1320 4 1898 1898 CD 31417 1320 5 . . . 31417 1321 1 See see VB 31417 1321 2 p. p. NN 31417 1321 3 107 107 CD 31417 1321 4 . . . 31417 1322 1 During during IN 31417 1322 2 the the DT 31417 1322 3 last last JJ 31417 1322 4 few few JJ 31417 1322 5 years year NNS 31417 1322 6 no no DT 31417 1322 7 important important JJ 31417 1322 8 addition addition NN 31417 1322 9 appears appear VBZ 31417 1322 10 to to TO 31417 1322 11 have have VB 31417 1322 12 been be VBN 31417 1322 13 made make VBN 31417 1322 14 to to IN 31417 1322 15 the the DT 31417 1322 16 series series NN 31417 1322 17 of of IN 31417 1322 18 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1322 19 - - HYPH 31417 1322 20 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1322 21 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1322 22 . . . 31417 1323 1 A a DT 31417 1323 2 revival revival NN 31417 1323 3 of of IN 31417 1323 4 similar similar JJ 31417 1323 5 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1323 6 would would MD 31417 1323 7 be be VB 31417 1323 8 of of IN 31417 1323 9 great great JJ 31417 1323 10 interest interest NN 31417 1323 11 and and CC 31417 1323 12 value value NN 31417 1323 13 . . . 31417 1324 1 The the DT 31417 1324 2 question question NN 31417 1324 3 may may MD 31417 1324 4 fairly fairly RB 31417 1324 5 be be VB 31417 1324 6 asked ask VBN 31417 1324 7 , , , 31417 1324 8 What what WP 31417 1324 9 have have VBP 31417 1324 10 these these DT 31417 1324 11 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1324 12 - - HYPH 31417 1324 13 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1324 14 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1324 15 to to TO 31417 1324 16 do do VB 31417 1324 17 with with IN 31417 1324 18 the the DT 31417 1324 19 Physical physical JJ 31417 1324 20 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 1324 21 of of IN 31417 1324 22 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 1324 23 ? ? . 31417 1325 1 A a DT 31417 1325 2 reply reply NN 31417 1325 3 is be VBZ 31417 1325 4 easily easily RB 31417 1325 5 given give VBN 31417 1325 6 . . . 31417 1326 1 The the DT 31417 1326 2 reader reader NN 31417 1326 3 is be VBZ 31417 1326 4 referred refer VBN 31417 1326 5 to to IN 31417 1326 6 a a DT 31417 1326 7 passage passage NN 31417 1326 8 in in IN 31417 1326 9 the the DT 31417 1326 10 concluding concluding NN 31417 1326 11 chapter chapter NN 31417 1326 12 , , , 31417 1326 13 quoted quote VBN 31417 1326 14 from from IN 31417 1326 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1326 16 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1326 17 , , , 31417 1326 18 in in IN 31417 1326 19 which which WDT 31417 1326 20 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1326 21 claims claim VBZ 31417 1326 22 an an DT 31417 1326 23 exalted exalted JJ 31417 1326 24 position position NN 31417 1326 25 for for IN 31417 1326 26 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1326 27 , , , 31417 1326 28 as as IN 31417 1326 29 almost almost RB 31417 1326 30 the the DT 31417 1326 31 fundamental fundamental JJ 31417 1326 32 doctrine doctrine NN 31417 1326 33 of of IN 31417 1326 34 Spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1326 35 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 31417 1326 36 . . . 31417 1327 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1327 2 speaks speak VBZ 31417 1327 3 of of IN 31417 1327 4 the the DT 31417 1327 5 beginning beginning NN 31417 1327 6 of of IN 31417 1327 7 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1327 8 as as IN 31417 1327 9 a a DT 31417 1327 10 " " `` 31417 1327 11 quasi quasi JJ 31417 1327 12 - - JJ 31417 1327 13 mechanical mechanical JJ 31417 1327 14 transference transference NN 31417 1327 15 of of IN 31417 1327 16 ideas idea NNS 31417 1327 17 and and CC 31417 1327 18 images image NNS 31417 1327 19 from from IN 31417 1327 20 one one CD 31417 1327 21 to to IN 31417 1327 22 another another DT 31417 1327 23 brain brain NN 31417 1327 24 . . . 31417 1327 25 " " '' 31417 1328 1 The the DT 31417 1328 2 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1328 3 - - HYPH 31417 1328 4 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1328 5 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1328 6 constitute constitute VBP 31417 1328 7 the the DT 31417 1328 8 primary primary JJ 31417 1328 9 evidence evidence NN 31417 1328 10 of of IN 31417 1328 11 this this DT 31417 1328 12 . . . 31417 1329 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1329 2 may may MD 31417 1329 3 be be VB 31417 1329 4 looked look VBN 31417 1329 5 upon upon IN 31417 1329 6 as as IN 31417 1329 7 constituting constitute VBG 31417 1329 8 the the DT 31417 1329 9 physical physical JJ 31417 1329 10 basis basis NN 31417 1329 11 of of IN 31417 1329 12 a a DT 31417 1329 13 belief belief NN 31417 1329 14 in in IN 31417 1329 15 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1329 16 - - HYPH 31417 1329 17 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1329 18 , , , 31417 1329 19 and and CC 31417 1329 20 therefore therefore RB 31417 1329 21 as as IN 31417 1329 22 the the DT 31417 1329 23 physical physical JJ 31417 1329 24 basis basis NN 31417 1329 25 of of IN 31417 1329 26 a a DT 31417 1329 27 belief belief NN 31417 1329 28 in in IN 31417 1329 29 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1329 30 , , , 31417 1329 31 the the DT 31417 1329 32 action action NN 31417 1329 33 of of IN 31417 1329 34 which which WDT 31417 1329 35 , , , 31417 1329 36 as as IN 31417 1329 37 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1329 38 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1329 39 says say VBZ 31417 1329 40 , , , 31417 1329 41 " " `` 31417 1329 42 was be VBD 31417 1329 43 traced trace VBN 31417 1329 44 across across IN 31417 1329 45 a a DT 31417 1329 46 gulf gulf NNP 31417 1329 47 greater great JJR 31417 1329 48 than than IN 31417 1329 49 any any DT 31417 1329 50 space space NN 31417 1329 51 of of IN 31417 1329 52 earth earth NN 31417 1329 53 or or CC 31417 1329 54 ocean ocean NN 31417 1329 55 -- -- : 31417 1329 56 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1329 57 bridged bridge VBD 31417 1329 58 the the DT 31417 1329 59 interval interval NN 31417 1329 60 between between IN 31417 1329 61 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1329 62 incarnate incarnate VBP 31417 1329 63 and and CC 31417 1329 64 discarnate discarnate VBP 31417 1329 65 . . . 31417 1329 66 " " '' 31417 1330 1 Thus thus RB 31417 1330 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1330 3 may may MD 31417 1330 4 look look VB 31417 1330 5 upon upon IN 31417 1330 6 these these DT 31417 1330 7 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1330 8 - - HYPH 31417 1330 9 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1330 10 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1330 11 as as IN 31417 1330 12 supplying supply VBG 31417 1330 13 the the DT 31417 1330 14 chief chief NN 31417 1330 15 -- -- : 31417 1330 16 perhaps perhaps RB 31417 1330 17 the the DT 31417 1330 18 only only JJ 31417 1330 19 -- -- : 31417 1330 20 physical physical JJ 31417 1330 21 basis basis NN 31417 1330 22 for for IN 31417 1330 23 a a DT 31417 1330 24 belief belief NN 31417 1330 25 in in IN 31417 1330 26 one one CD 31417 1330 27 of of IN 31417 1330 28 the the DT 31417 1330 29 main main JJ 31417 1330 30 doctrines doctrine NNS 31417 1330 31 of of IN 31417 1330 32 spiritualism spiritualism NN 31417 1330 33 . . . 31417 1331 1 Hence hence RB 31417 1331 2 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1331 3 legitimately legitimately RB 31417 1331 4 find find VBP 31417 1331 5 a a DT 31417 1331 6 place place NN 31417 1331 7 in in IN 31417 1331 8 the the DT 31417 1331 9 present present JJ 31417 1331 10 examination examination NN 31417 1331 11 . . . 31417 1332 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 1332 2 : : : 31417 1332 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1332 4 64 64 CD 31417 1332 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1332 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1332 7 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1332 8 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1332 9 _ _ NNP 31417 1332 10 , , , 31417 1332 11 vol vol NNP 31417 1332 12 . . . 31417 1333 1 i. i. NNP 31417 1333 2 p. p. NNP 31417 1333 3 13 13 CD 31417 1333 4 . . . 31417 1334 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1334 2 65 65 CD 31417 1334 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1334 4 A a DT 31417 1334 5 list list NN 31417 1334 6 of of IN 31417 1334 7 all all PDT 31417 1334 8 the the DT 31417 1334 9 publications publication NNS 31417 1334 10 of of IN 31417 1334 11 the the DT 31417 1334 12 Society Society NNP 31417 1334 13 for for IN 31417 1334 14 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1334 15 Research Research NNP 31417 1334 16 , , , 31417 1334 17 with with IN 31417 1334 18 prices price NNS 31417 1334 19 of of IN 31417 1334 20 the the DT 31417 1334 21 different different JJ 31417 1334 22 volumes volume NNS 31417 1334 23 and and CC 31417 1334 24 parts part NNS 31417 1334 25 , , , 31417 1334 26 can can MD 31417 1334 27 be be VB 31417 1334 28 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1334 29 from from IN 31417 1334 30 the the DT 31417 1334 31 Secretary Secretary NNP 31417 1334 32 , , , 31417 1334 33 at at IN 31417 1334 34 the the DT 31417 1334 35 Society Society NNP 31417 1334 36 's 's POS 31417 1334 37 Rooms room NNS 31417 1334 38 , , , 31417 1334 39 20 20 CD 31417 1334 40 Hanover Hanover NNP 31417 1334 41 Square Square NNP 31417 1334 42 , , , 31417 1334 43 London London NNP 31417 1334 44 , , , 31417 1334 45 W. W. NNP 31417 1334 46 CHAPTER CHAPTER NNP 31417 1334 47 IX IX NNP 31417 1334 48 MATERIALISATIONS MATERIALISATIONS NNP 31417 1334 49 By by IN 31417 1334 50 " " `` 31417 1334 51 materialisation materialisation NN 31417 1334 52 , , , 31417 1334 53 " " '' 31417 1334 54 in in IN 31417 1334 55 this this DT 31417 1334 56 chapter chapter NN 31417 1334 57 , , , 31417 1334 58 is be VBZ 31417 1334 59 not not RB 31417 1334 60 meant mean VBN 31417 1334 61 the the DT 31417 1334 62 production production NN 31417 1334 63 of of IN 31417 1334 64 more more JJR 31417 1334 65 or or CC 31417 1334 66 less less RBR 31417 1334 67 complete complete JJ 31417 1334 68 portions portion NNS 31417 1334 69 of of IN 31417 1334 70 the the DT 31417 1334 71 human human JJ 31417 1334 72 body body NN 31417 1334 73 -- -- : 31417 1334 74 generally generally RB 31417 1334 75 hands hand NNS 31417 1334 76 -- -- : 31417 1334 77 a a DT 31417 1334 78 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 1334 79 alleged allege VBN 31417 1334 80 to to TO 31417 1334 81 be be VB 31417 1334 82 frequent frequent JJ 31417 1334 83 in in IN 31417 1334 84 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1334 85 circles circle NNS 31417 1334 86 . . . 31417 1335 1 A a DT 31417 1335 2 " " `` 31417 1335 3 materialisation materialisation NN 31417 1335 4 " " '' 31417 1335 5 of of IN 31417 1335 6 the the DT 31417 1335 7 whole whole JJ 31417 1335 8 figure figure NN 31417 1335 9 is be VBZ 31417 1335 10 meant mean VBN 31417 1335 11 , , , 31417 1335 12 the the DT 31417 1335 13 production production NN 31417 1335 14 of of IN 31417 1335 15 a a DT 31417 1335 16 figure figure NN 31417 1335 17 which which WDT 31417 1335 18 to to IN 31417 1335 19 the the DT 31417 1335 20 spectator spectator NN 31417 1335 21 appears appear VBZ 31417 1335 22 as as IN 31417 1335 23 a a DT 31417 1335 24 new new JJ 31417 1335 25 human human JJ 31417 1335 26 being being NN 31417 1335 27 , , , 31417 1335 28 so so RB 31417 1335 29 to to TO 31417 1335 30 speak speak VB 31417 1335 31 , , , 31417 1335 32 occasionally occasionally RB 31417 1335 33 exhibiting exhibit VBG 31417 1335 34 signs sign NNS 31417 1335 35 of of IN 31417 1335 36 independent independent JJ 31417 1335 37 organic organic JJ 31417 1335 38 life life NN 31417 1335 39 . . . 31417 1336 1 Such such PDT 31417 1336 2 a a DT 31417 1336 3 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 1336 4 would would MD 31417 1336 5 be be VB 31417 1336 6 the the DT 31417 1336 7 most most RBS 31417 1336 8 astounding astounding JJ 31417 1336 9 that that WDT 31417 1336 10 can can MD 31417 1336 11 well well RB 31417 1336 12 be be VB 31417 1336 13 imagined imagine VBN 31417 1336 14 . . . 31417 1337 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1337 2 am be VBP 31417 1337 3 not not RB 31417 1337 4 in in IN 31417 1337 5 a a DT 31417 1337 6 position position NN 31417 1337 7 to to TO 31417 1337 8 offer offer VB 31417 1337 9 any any DT 31417 1337 10 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1337 11 evidence evidence NN 31417 1337 12 in in IN 31417 1337 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1337 14 support support NN 31417 1337 15 . . . 31417 1338 1 By by IN 31417 1338 2 far far RB 31417 1338 3 the the DT 31417 1338 4 majority majority NN 31417 1338 5 of of IN 31417 1338 6 the the DT 31417 1338 7 accounts account NNS 31417 1338 8 which which WDT 31417 1338 9 have have VBP 31417 1338 10 been be VBN 31417 1338 11 published publish VBN 31417 1338 12 of of IN 31417 1338 13 full full JJ 31417 1338 14 form form NN 31417 1338 15 " " '' 31417 1338 16 materialisations materialisation NNS 31417 1338 17 " " '' 31417 1338 18 are be VBP 31417 1338 19 destitute destitute JJ 31417 1338 20 of of IN 31417 1338 21 any any DT 31417 1338 22 evidential evidential JJ 31417 1338 23 value value NN 31417 1338 24 , , , 31417 1338 25 and and CC 31417 1338 26 in in IN 31417 1338 27 many many JJ 31417 1338 28 cases case NNS 31417 1338 29 the the DT 31417 1338 30 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 31417 1338 31 evidence evidence NN 31417 1338 32 for for IN 31417 1338 33 fraud fraud NN 31417 1338 34 is be VBZ 31417 1338 35 strong strong JJ 31417 1338 36 . . . 31417 1339 1 Were be VBD 31417 1339 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1339 3 not not RB 31417 1339 4 for for IN 31417 1339 5 a a DT 31417 1339 6 small small JJ 31417 1339 7 number number NN 31417 1339 8 of of IN 31417 1339 9 cases case NNS 31417 1339 10 which which WDT 31417 1339 11 present present VBP 31417 1339 12 _ _ NNP 31417 1339 13 primâ primâ NN 31417 1339 14 facie facie NN 31417 1339 15 _ _ NNP 31417 1339 16 evidence evidence NN 31417 1339 17 of of IN 31417 1339 18 a a DT 31417 1339 19 different different JJ 31417 1339 20 character character NN 31417 1339 21 , , , 31417 1339 22 the the DT 31417 1339 23 question question NN 31417 1339 24 of of IN 31417 1339 25 the the DT 31417 1339 26 reality reality NN 31417 1339 27 of of IN 31417 1339 28 this this DT 31417 1339 29 phase phase NN 31417 1339 30 of of IN 31417 1339 31 " " `` 31417 1339 32 mediumship mediumship NN 31417 1339 33 " " '' 31417 1339 34 would would MD 31417 1339 35 be be VB 31417 1339 36 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1339 37 worth worth JJ 31417 1339 38 raising raise VBG 31417 1339 39 . . . 31417 1340 1 But but CC 31417 1340 2 the the DT 31417 1340 3 existence existence NN 31417 1340 4 of of IN 31417 1340 5 even even RB 31417 1340 6 a a DT 31417 1340 7 small small JJ 31417 1340 8 amount amount NN 31417 1340 9 of of IN 31417 1340 10 evidence evidence NN 31417 1340 11 of of IN 31417 1340 12 such such PDT 31417 1340 13 a a DT 31417 1340 14 kind kind NN 31417 1340 15 raises raise VBZ 31417 1340 16 the the DT 31417 1340 17 question question NN 31417 1340 18 into into IN 31417 1340 19 a a DT 31417 1340 20 different different JJ 31417 1340 21 position position NN 31417 1340 22 , , , 31417 1340 23 to to IN 31417 1340 24 one one CD 31417 1340 25 which which WDT 31417 1340 26 reasonably reasonably RB 31417 1340 27 demands demand VBZ 31417 1340 28 the the DT 31417 1340 29 searching search VBG 31417 1340 30 investigation investigation NN 31417 1340 31 of of IN 31417 1340 32 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1340 33 men man NNS 31417 1340 34 . . . 31417 1341 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1341 2 propose propose VBP 31417 1341 3 to to TO 31417 1341 4 give give VB 31417 1341 5 one one CD 31417 1341 6 illustration illustration NN 31417 1341 7 only only RB 31417 1341 8 of of IN 31417 1341 9 this this DT 31417 1341 10 better well JJR 31417 1341 11 class class NN 31417 1341 12 of of IN 31417 1341 13 evidence evidence NN 31417 1341 14 , , , 31417 1341 15 but but CC 31417 1341 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1341 17 is be VBZ 31417 1341 18 one one CD 31417 1341 19 in in IN 31417 1341 20 which which WDT 31417 1341 21 common common JJ 31417 1341 22 - - HYPH 31417 1341 23 sense sense NN 31417 1341 24 precautions precaution NNS 31417 1341 25 against against IN 31417 1341 26 deception deception NN 31417 1341 27 seem seem VBP 31417 1341 28 to to TO 31417 1341 29 have have VB 31417 1341 30 been be VBN 31417 1341 31 carefully carefully RB 31417 1341 32 taken take VBN 31417 1341 33 . . . 31417 1342 1 The the DT 31417 1342 2 following follow VBG 31417 1342 3 extracts extract NNS 31417 1342 4 are be VBP 31417 1342 5 from from IN 31417 1342 6 a a DT 31417 1342 7 report report NN 31417 1342 8 made make VBN 31417 1342 9 by by IN 31417 1342 10 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1342 11 J. J. NNP 31417 1342 12 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1342 13 , , , 31417 1342 14 and and CC 31417 1342 15 published publish VBN 31417 1342 16 in in IN 31417 1342 17 _ _ NNP 31417 1342 18 The the DT 31417 1342 19 Two two CD 31417 1342 20 Worlds Worlds NNPS 31417 1342 21 _ _ NNP 31417 1342 22 of of IN 31417 1342 23 15th 15th JJ 31417 1342 24 February February NNP 31417 1342 25 1895:-- 1895:-- CD 31417 1342 26 " " '' 31417 1342 27 IS be VBZ 31417 1342 28 MATERIALISATION MATERIALISATION NNP 31417 1342 29 A a NN 31417 1342 30 FACT fact NN 31417 1342 31 ? ? . 31417 1343 1 YES yes UH 31417 1343 2 . . . 31417 1344 1 SCIENTIFIC scientific JJ 31417 1344 2 PROOF PROOF NNP 31417 1344 3 . . . 31417 1345 1 " " `` 31417 1345 2 After after IN 31417 1345 3 the the DT 31417 1345 4 recent recent JJ 31417 1345 5 suspicions suspicion NNS 31417 1345 6 and and CC 31417 1345 7 exposures exposure NNS 31417 1345 8 of of IN 31417 1345 9 materialising materialise VBG 31417 1345 10 mediums medium NNS 31417 1345 11 , , , 31417 1345 12 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1345 13 determined determine VBD 31417 1345 14 to to TO 31417 1345 15 take take VB 31417 1345 16 the the DT 31417 1345 17 first first JJ 31417 1345 18 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 1345 19 of of IN 31417 1345 20 applying apply VBG 31417 1345 21 further far RBR 31417 1345 22 and and CC 31417 1345 23 more more RBR 31417 1345 24 stringent stringent JJ 31417 1345 25 tests test NNS 31417 1345 26 , , , 31417 1345 27 which which WDT 31417 1345 28 should should MD 31417 1345 29 absolutely absolutely RB 31417 1345 30 preclude preclude VB 31417 1345 31 the the DT 31417 1345 32 possibility possibility NN 31417 1345 33 of of IN 31417 1345 34 deception deception NN 31417 1345 35 . . . 31417 1346 1 For for IN 31417 1346 2 this this DT 31417 1346 3 purpose purpose NN 31417 1346 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 5 wrote write VBD 31417 1346 6 to to IN 31417 1346 7 the the DT 31417 1346 8 Middlesbro Middlesbro NNP 31417 1346 9 ' ' POS 31417 1346 10 materialising materialise VBG 31417 1346 11 medium medium NN 31417 1346 12 , , , 31417 1346 13 asking ask VBG 31417 1346 14 for for IN 31417 1346 15 a a DT 31417 1346 16 test test NN 31417 1346 17 sitting sit VBG 31417 1346 18 , , , 31417 1346 19 and and CC 31417 1346 20 stating state VBG 31417 1346 21 the the DT 31417 1346 22 conditions condition NNS 31417 1346 23 -- -- : 31417 1346 24 which which WDT 31417 1346 25 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 26 readily readily RB 31417 1346 27 accepted accept VBD 31417 1346 28 .... .... . 31417 1346 29 " " `` 31417 1346 30 The the DT 31417 1346 31 conditions condition NNS 31417 1346 32 were be VBD 31417 1346 33 that that IN 31417 1346 34 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 35 should should MD 31417 1346 36 strip strip VB 31417 1346 37 to to IN 31417 1346 38 the the DT 31417 1346 39 skin skin NN 31417 1346 40 ' ' '' 31417 1346 41 naked naked JJ 31417 1346 42 as as IN 31417 1346 43 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 44 was be VBD 31417 1346 45 born bear VBN 31417 1346 46 , , , 31417 1346 47 ' ' '' 31417 1346 48 and and CC 31417 1346 49 in in IN 31417 1346 50 the the DT 31417 1346 51 presence presence NN 31417 1346 52 of of IN 31417 1346 53 witnesses witness NNS 31417 1346 54 dress dress VB 31417 1346 55 in in IN 31417 1346 56 clothes clothe NNS 31417 1346 57 to to TO 31417 1346 58 be be VB 31417 1346 59 supplied supply VBN 31417 1346 60 by by IN 31417 1346 61 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 62 .... .... . 31417 1346 63 " " `` 31417 1346 64 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 65 made make VBD 31417 1346 66 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 67 understand understand VB 31417 1346 68 that that IN 31417 1346 69 after after IN 31417 1346 70 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 71 had have VBD 31417 1346 72 dressed dress VBN 31417 1346 73 in in IN 31417 1346 74 the the DT 31417 1346 75 clothes clothe NNS 31417 1346 76 supplied supply VBN 31417 1346 77 by by IN 31417 1346 78 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 79 , , , 31417 1346 80 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 81 must must MD 31417 1346 82 consider consider VB 31417 1346 83 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 84 in in IN 31417 1346 85 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1346 86 charge charge NN 31417 1346 87 , , , 31417 1346 88 and and CC 31417 1346 89 must must MD 31417 1346 90 not not RB 31417 1346 91 attempt attempt VB 31417 1346 92 to to TO 31417 1346 93 do do VB 31417 1346 94 or or CC 31417 1346 95 touch touch VB 31417 1346 96 anything anything NN 31417 1346 97 , , , 31417 1346 98 or or CC 31417 1346 99 go go VB 31417 1346 100 anywhere anywhere RB 31417 1346 101 except except IN 31417 1346 102 to to IN 31417 1346 103 the the DT 31417 1346 104 chair chair NN 31417 1346 105 provided provide VBN 31417 1346 106 for for IN 31417 1346 107 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1346 108 . . . 31417 1347 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1347 2 readily readily RB 31417 1347 3 agreed agree VBD 31417 1347 4 to to IN 31417 1347 5 this this DT 31417 1347 6 , , , 31417 1347 7 and and CC 31417 1347 8 imposed impose VBN 31417 1347 9 upon upon IN 31417 1347 10 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1347 11 a a DT 31417 1347 12 still still RB 31417 1347 13 further further JJ 31417 1347 14 test test NN 31417 1347 15 , , , 31417 1347 16 viz viz NN 31417 1347 17 . . . 31417 1348 1 that that IN 31417 1348 2 as as RB 31417 1348 3 soon soon RB 31417 1348 4 as as IN 31417 1348 5 the the DT 31417 1348 6 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 1348 7 had have VBD 31417 1348 8 ceased cease VBN 31417 1348 9 , , , 31417 1348 10 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1348 11 would would MD 31417 1348 12 instantly instantly RB 31417 1348 13 place place VB 31417 1348 14 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1348 15 in in IN 31417 1348 16 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1348 17 charge charge NN 31417 1348 18 , , , 31417 1348 19 to to TO 31417 1348 20 be be VB 31417 1348 21 held hold VBN 31417 1348 22 fast fast RB 31417 1348 23 until until IN 31417 1348 24 the the DT 31417 1348 25 light light NN 31417 1348 26 was be VBD 31417 1348 27 turned turn VBN 31417 1348 28 up up RP 31417 1348 29 , , , 31417 1348 30 and and CC 31417 1348 31 the the DT 31417 1348 32 company company NN 31417 1348 33 had have VBD 31417 1348 34 retired retire VBN 31417 1348 35 to to IN 31417 1348 36 the the DT 31417 1348 37 next next JJ 31417 1348 38 room room NN 31417 1348 39 , , , 31417 1348 40 the the DT 31417 1348 41 same same JJ 31417 1348 42 process process NN 31417 1348 43 of of IN 31417 1348 44 undressing undressing NN 31417 1348 45 being be VBG 31417 1348 46 gone go VBN 31417 1348 47 through through RB 31417 1348 48 . . . 31417 1348 49 " " '' 31417 1349 1 This this DT 31417 1349 2 was be VBD 31417 1349 3 all all DT 31417 1349 4 carried carry VBN 31417 1349 5 out out RP 31417 1349 6 preliminary preliminary JJ 31417 1349 7 to to IN 31417 1349 8 a a DT 31417 1349 9 seance seance NN 31417 1349 10 , , , 31417 1349 11 and and CC 31417 1349 12 a a DT 31417 1349 13 final final JJ 31417 1349 14 examination examination NN 31417 1349 15 of of IN 31417 1349 16 the the DT 31417 1349 17 room room NN 31417 1349 18 was be VBD 31417 1349 19 made make VBN 31417 1349 20 . . . 31417 1350 1 " " `` 31417 1350 2 The the DT 31417 1350 3 light light NN 31417 1350 4 was be VBD 31417 1350 5 then then RB 31417 1350 6 lowered lower VBN 31417 1350 7 so so IN 31417 1350 8 that that IN 31417 1350 9 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1350 10 could could MD 31417 1350 11 just just RB 31417 1350 12 see see VB 31417 1350 13 each each DT 31417 1350 14 other other JJ 31417 1350 15 -- -- : 31417 1350 16 the the DT 31417 1350 17 company company NN 31417 1350 18 sang sing VBD 31417 1350 19 a a DT 31417 1350 20 hymn hymn NN 31417 1350 21 , , , 31417 1350 22 a a DT 31417 1350 23 prayer prayer NN 31417 1350 24 was be VBD 31417 1350 25 offered offer VBN 31417 1350 26 , , , 31417 1350 27 and and CC 31417 1350 28 then then RB 31417 1350 29 came come VBD 31417 1350 30 the the DT 31417 1350 31 crisis crisis NN 31417 1350 32 -- -- : 31417 1350 33 to to TO 31417 1350 34 be be VB 31417 1350 35 or or CC 31417 1350 36 not not RB 31417 1350 37 to to TO 31417 1350 38 be be VB 31417 1350 39 ? ? . 31417 1351 1 In in IN 31417 1351 2 less less JJR 31417 1351 3 than than IN 31417 1351 4 a a DT 31417 1351 5 minute minute NN 31417 1351 6 a a DT 31417 1351 7 form form NN 31417 1351 8 of of IN 31417 1351 9 exceeding exceed VBG 31417 1351 10 whiteness whiteness NN 31417 1351 11 appeared appear VBD 31417 1351 12 at at IN 31417 1351 13 the the DT 31417 1351 14 opening opening NN 31417 1351 15 of of IN 31417 1351 16 the the DT 31417 1351 17 curtain curtain NN 31417 1351 18 ; ; : 31417 1351 19 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1351 20 should should MD 31417 1351 21 judge judge VB 31417 1351 22 the the DT 31417 1351 23 height height NN 31417 1351 24 to to TO 31417 1351 25 be be VB 31417 1351 26 three three CD 31417 1351 27 feet foot NNS 31417 1351 28 six six CD 31417 1351 29 inches inch NNS 31417 1351 30 or or CC 31417 1351 31 a a DT 31417 1351 32 little little JJ 31417 1351 33 more more JJR 31417 1351 34 . . . 31417 1352 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1352 2 could could MD 31417 1352 3 not not RB 31417 1352 4 distinguish distinguish VB 31417 1352 5 the the DT 31417 1352 6 face face NN 31417 1352 7 . . . 31417 1353 1 The the DT 31417 1353 2 form form NN 31417 1353 3 appeared appear VBD 31417 1353 4 twice twice RB 31417 1353 5 . . . 31417 1354 1 Then then RB 31417 1354 2 a a DT 31417 1354 3 child child NN 31417 1354 4 form form NN 31417 1354 5 appeared appear VBD 31417 1354 6 , , , 31417 1354 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1354 8 raiment raiment NN 31417 1354 9 white white JJ 31417 1354 10 , , , 31417 1354 11 luminous luminous JJ 31417 1354 12 and and CC 31417 1354 13 very very RB 31417 1354 14 distinct distinct JJ 31417 1354 15 . . . 31417 1355 1 Then then RB 31417 1355 2 came come VBD 31417 1355 3 the the DT 31417 1355 4 well well RB 31417 1355 5 - - HYPH 31417 1355 6 known know VBN 31417 1355 7 and and CC 31417 1355 8 lively lively JJ 31417 1355 9 black black JJ 31417 1355 10 child child NN 31417 1355 11 , , , 31417 1355 12 opening open VBG 31417 1355 13 the the DT 31417 1355 14 curtain curtain NN 31417 1355 15 with with IN 31417 1355 16 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1355 17 small small JJ 31417 1355 18 arms arm NNS 31417 1355 19 and and CC 31417 1355 20 bowing bow VBG 31417 1355 21 repeatedly repeatedly RB 31417 1355 22 to to IN 31417 1355 23 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1355 24 . . . 31417 1356 1 This this DT 31417 1356 2 child child NN 31417 1356 3 would would MD 31417 1356 4 be be VB 31417 1356 5 about about RB 31417 1356 6 two two CD 31417 1356 7 and and CC 31417 1356 8 a a DT 31417 1356 9 half half NN 31417 1356 10 feet foot NNS 31417 1356 11 in in IN 31417 1356 12 height height NN 31417 1356 13 . . . 31417 1357 1 The the DT 31417 1357 2 folds fold NNS 31417 1357 3 of of IN 31417 1357 4 shining shine VBG 31417 1357 5 drapery drapery NN 31417 1357 6 hung hang VBD 31417 1357 7 from from IN 31417 1357 8 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1357 9 head head NN 31417 1357 10 in in IN 31417 1357 11 gipsy gipsy JJ 31417 1357 12 fashion fashion NN 31417 1357 13 , , , 31417 1357 14 which which WDT 31417 1357 15 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1357 16 opened open VBD 31417 1357 17 for for IN 31417 1357 18 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1357 19 to to TO 31417 1357 20 see see VB 31417 1357 21 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1357 22 round round JJ 31417 1357 23 black black JJ 31417 1357 24 face face NN 31417 1357 25 . . . 31417 1358 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1358 2 was be VBD 31417 1358 3 quite quite RB 31417 1358 4 close close JJ 31417 1358 5 to to IN 31417 1358 6 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1358 7 , , , 31417 1358 8 but but CC 31417 1358 9 did do VBD 31417 1358 10 not not RB 31417 1358 11 pat pat VB 31417 1358 12 her -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1358 13 face face NN 31417 1358 14 and and CC 31417 1358 15 woolly woolly RB 31417 1358 16 head head NN 31417 1358 17 as as IN 31417 1358 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1358 19 have have VBP 31417 1358 20 done do VBN 31417 1358 21 before before RB 31417 1358 22 . . . 31417 1359 1 She -PRON- PRP 31417 1359 2 climbed climb VBD 31417 1359 3 upon upon IN 31417 1359 4 the the DT 31417 1359 5 medium medium NN 31417 1359 6 's 's POS 31417 1359 7 knee knee NN 31417 1359 8 , , , 31417 1359 9 and and CC 31417 1359 10 then then RB 31417 1359 11 came come VBD 31417 1359 12 close close RB 31417 1359 13 to to IN 31417 1359 14 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1359 15 again again RB 31417 1359 16 , , , 31417 1359 17 and and CC 31417 1359 18 then then RB 31417 1359 19 disappeared disappear VBD 31417 1359 20 .... .... . 31417 1359 21 " " '' 31417 1359 22 The the DT 31417 1359 23 meeting meeting NN 31417 1359 24 then then RB 31417 1359 25 concluded conclude VBD 31417 1359 26 with with IN 31417 1359 27 prayer prayer NN 31417 1359 28 and and CC 31417 1359 29 doxology doxology NN 31417 1359 30 . . . 31417 1360 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1360 2 then then RB 31417 1360 3 seized seize VBD 31417 1360 4 hold hold NN 31417 1360 5 of of IN 31417 1360 6 the the DT 31417 1360 7 medium medium NN 31417 1360 8 's 's POS 31417 1360 9 hands hand NNS 31417 1360 10 , , , 31417 1360 11 and and CC 31417 1360 12 held hold VBD 31417 1360 13 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1360 14 until until IN 31417 1360 15 the the DT 31417 1360 16 company company NN 31417 1360 17 retired retire VBD 31417 1360 18 , , , 31417 1360 19 and and CC 31417 1360 20 then then RB 31417 1360 21 went go VBD 31417 1360 22 through through IN 31417 1360 23 the the DT 31417 1360 24 undressing undressing NN 31417 1360 25 and and CC 31417 1360 26 dressing dressing NN 31417 1360 27 process process NN 31417 1360 28 as as IN 31417 1360 29 before before RB 31417 1360 30 , , , 31417 1360 31 every every DT 31417 1360 32 article article NN 31417 1360 33 of of IN 31417 1360 34 clothing clothing NN 31417 1360 35 being be VBG 31417 1360 36 rigidly rigidly RB 31417 1360 37 examined examine VBN 31417 1360 38 as as IN 31417 1360 39 removed remove VBN 31417 1360 40 . . . 31417 1361 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1361 2 then then RB 31417 1361 3 searched search VBD 31417 1361 4 the the DT 31417 1361 5 corner corner NN 31417 1361 6 as as IN 31417 1361 7 before before RB 31417 1361 8 , , , 31417 1361 9 and and CC 31417 1361 10 found find VBD 31417 1361 11 all all DT 31417 1361 12 intact intact JJ 31417 1361 13 , , , 31417 1361 14 and and CC 31417 1361 15 not not RB 31417 1361 16 a a DT 31417 1361 17 sign sign NN 31417 1361 18 anywhere anywhere RB 31417 1361 19 of of IN 31417 1361 20 the the DT 31417 1361 21 abundance abundance NN 31417 1361 22 of of IN 31417 1361 23 drapery drapery NN 31417 1361 24 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1361 25 had have VBD 31417 1361 26 seen see VBN 31417 1361 27 . . . 31417 1361 28 " " '' 31417 1362 1 Sixteen sixteen CD 31417 1362 2 ladies lady NNS 31417 1362 3 and and CC 31417 1362 4 gentlemen gentleman NNS 31417 1362 5 present present JJ 31417 1362 6 at at IN 31417 1362 7 the the DT 31417 1362 8 meeting meeting NN 31417 1362 9 allowed allow VBD 31417 1362 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1362 11 names name NNS 31417 1362 12 to to TO 31417 1362 13 be be VB 31417 1362 14 published publish VBN 31417 1362 15 as as IN 31417 1362 16 a a DT 31417 1362 17 testimony testimony NN 31417 1362 18 to to IN 31417 1362 19 what what WP 31417 1362 20 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1362 21 saw see VBD 31417 1362 22 . . . 31417 1363 1 The the DT 31417 1363 2 evidential evidential JJ 31417 1363 3 value value NN 31417 1363 4 of of IN 31417 1363 5 the the DT 31417 1363 6 seance seance NN 31417 1363 7 depends depend VBZ 31417 1363 8 entirely entirely RB 31417 1363 9 on on IN 31417 1363 10 the the DT 31417 1363 11 honesty honesty NN 31417 1363 12 and and CC 31417 1363 13 truthfulness truthfulness NN 31417 1363 14 of of IN 31417 1363 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1363 16 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1363 17 and and CC 31417 1363 18 of of IN 31417 1363 19 the the DT 31417 1363 20 two two CD 31417 1363 21 friends friend NNS 31417 1363 22 who who WP 31417 1363 23 assisted assist VBD 31417 1363 24 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1363 25 in in IN 31417 1363 26 the the DT 31417 1363 27 carrying carrying NN 31417 1363 28 out out IN 31417 1363 29 of of IN 31417 1363 30 the the DT 31417 1363 31 precautions precaution NNS 31417 1363 32 taken take VBN 31417 1363 33 . . . 31417 1364 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1364 2 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1364 3 had have VBD 31417 1364 4 been be VBN 31417 1364 5 in in IN 31417 1364 6 the the DT 31417 1364 7 York York NNP 31417 1364 8 Post Post NNP 31417 1364 9 Office Office NNP 31417 1364 10 for for IN 31417 1364 11 over over IN 31417 1364 12 thirty thirty CD 31417 1364 13 years year NNS 31417 1364 14 , , , 31417 1364 15 and and CC 31417 1364 16 for for IN 31417 1364 17 nearly nearly RB 31417 1364 18 seven seven CD 31417 1364 19 years year NNS 31417 1364 20 before before IN 31417 1364 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1364 22 death death NN 31417 1364 23 in in IN 31417 1364 24 1902 1902 CD 31417 1364 25 had have VBD 31417 1364 26 occupied occupy VBN 31417 1364 27 the the DT 31417 1364 28 position position NN 31417 1364 29 of of IN 31417 1364 30 superintendent superintendent NN 31417 1364 31 . . . 31417 1365 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1365 2 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1365 3 was be VBD 31417 1365 4 a a DT 31417 1365 5 frequent frequent JJ 31417 1365 6 contributor contributor NN 31417 1365 7 to to IN 31417 1365 8 the the DT 31417 1365 9 newspaper newspaper NN 31417 1365 10 press press NN 31417 1365 11 of of IN 31417 1365 12 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1365 13 own own JJ 31417 1365 14 district district NN 31417 1365 15 , , , 31417 1365 16 and and CC 31417 1365 17 also also RB 31417 1365 18 occasionally occasionally RB 31417 1365 19 to to IN 31417 1365 20 other other JJ 31417 1365 21 periodicals periodical NNS 31417 1365 22 . . . 31417 1366 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1366 2 appears appear VBZ 31417 1366 3 to to TO 31417 1366 4 have have VB 31417 1366 5 been be VBN 31417 1366 6 a a DT 31417 1366 7 man man NN 31417 1366 8 of of IN 31417 1366 9 considerable considerable JJ 31417 1366 10 intelligence intelligence NN 31417 1366 11 and and CC 31417 1366 12 force force NN 31417 1366 13 of of IN 31417 1366 14 character character NN 31417 1366 15 , , , 31417 1366 16 and and CC 31417 1366 17 to to TO 31417 1366 18 have have VB 31417 1366 19 been be VBN 31417 1366 20 widely widely RB 31417 1366 21 respected respect VBN 31417 1366 22 . . . 31417 1367 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1367 2 am be VBP 31417 1367 3 informed inform VBN 31417 1367 4 by by IN 31417 1367 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1367 6 J. J. NNP 31417 1367 7 P. P. NNP 31417 1367 8 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1367 9 , , , 31417 1367 10 a a DT 31417 1367 11 son son NN 31417 1367 12 of of IN 31417 1367 13 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1367 14 J. J. NNP 31417 1367 15 Slater Slater NNP 31417 1367 16 , , , 31417 1367 17 and and CC 31417 1367 18 who who WP 31417 1367 19 is be VBZ 31417 1367 20 in in IN 31417 1367 21 the the DT 31417 1367 22 Post Post NNP 31417 1367 23 Office Office NNP 31417 1367 24 at at IN 31417 1367 25 York York NNP 31417 1367 26 , , , 31417 1367 27 that that IN 31417 1367 28 the the DT 31417 1367 29 name name NN 31417 1367 30 of of IN 31417 1367 31 the the DT 31417 1367 32 " " `` 31417 1367 33 Middlesbro Middlesbro NNP 31417 1367 34 ' ' '' 31417 1367 35 medium medium NN 31417 1367 36 " " '' 31417 1367 37 was be VBD 31417 1367 38 Kenwin Kenwin NNP 31417 1367 39 , , , 31417 1367 40 and and CC 31417 1367 41 that that IN 31417 1367 42 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1367 43 was be VBD 31417 1367 44 an an DT 31417 1367 45 " " `` 31417 1367 46 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1367 47 working working NN 31417 1367 48 man man NN 31417 1367 49 " " '' 31417 1367 50 in in IN 31417 1367 51 some some DT 31417 1367 52 steel steel NN 31417 1367 53 works work NNS 31417 1367 54 . . . 31417 1368 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1368 2 died die VBD 31417 1368 3 six six CD 31417 1368 4 or or CC 31417 1368 5 seven seven CD 31417 1368 6 years year NNS 31417 1368 7 ago ago RB 31417 1368 8 . . . 31417 1369 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 31417 1369 2 X x NN 31417 1369 3 " " `` 31417 1369 4 SPIRIT SPIRIT NNP 31417 1369 5 PHOTOGRAPHY PHOTOGRAPHY NNP 31417 1369 6 " " '' 31417 1369 7 For for IN 31417 1369 8 over over IN 31417 1369 9 thirty thirty CD 31417 1369 10 years year NNS 31417 1369 11 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1369 12 have have VBP 31417 1369 13 been be VBN 31417 1369 14 taken take VBN 31417 1369 15 in in IN 31417 1369 16 London London NNP 31417 1369 17 , , , 31417 1369 18 on on IN 31417 1369 19 which which WDT 31417 1369 20 , , , 31417 1369 21 when when WRB 31417 1369 22 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1369 23 were be VBD 31417 1369 24 developed develop VBN 31417 1369 25 , , , 31417 1369 26 figures figure NNS 31417 1369 27 appeared appear VBD 31417 1369 28 for for IN 31417 1369 29 the the DT 31417 1369 30 presence presence NN 31417 1369 31 of of IN 31417 1369 32 which which WDT 31417 1369 33 there there EX 31417 1369 34 seemed seem VBD 31417 1369 35 to to TO 31417 1369 36 be be VB 31417 1369 37 no no DT 31417 1369 38 physical physical JJ 31417 1369 39 cause cause NN 31417 1369 40 . . . 31417 1370 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1370 2 appeared appear VBD 31417 1370 3 both both DT 31417 1370 4 with with IN 31417 1370 5 professional professional JJ 31417 1370 6 photographers photographer NNS 31417 1370 7 and and CC 31417 1370 8 in in IN 31417 1370 9 private private JJ 31417 1370 10 studios studio NNS 31417 1370 11 . . . 31417 1371 1 Two two CD 31417 1371 2 or or CC 31417 1371 3 three three CD 31417 1371 4 professional professional JJ 31417 1371 5 photographers photographer NNS 31417 1371 6 laid lay VBD 31417 1371 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1371 8 out out RP 31417 1371 9 to to TO 31417 1371 10 encourage encourage VB 31417 1371 11 such such JJ 31417 1371 12 appearances appearance NNS 31417 1371 13 . . . 31417 1372 1 Others other NNS 31417 1372 2 were be VBD 31417 1372 3 annoyed annoy VBN 31417 1372 4 by by IN 31417 1372 5 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1372 6 . . . 31417 1373 1 One one CD 31417 1373 2 in in IN 31417 1373 3 particular particular JJ 31417 1373 4 , , , 31417 1373 5 whom whom WP 31417 1373 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1373 7 knew know VBD 31417 1373 8 personally personally RB 31417 1373 9 , , , 31417 1373 10 was be VBD 31417 1373 11 greatly greatly RB 31417 1373 12 annoyed annoy VBN 31417 1373 13 in in IN 31417 1373 14 this this DT 31417 1373 15 way way NN 31417 1373 16 , , , 31417 1373 17 fearing fear VBG 31417 1373 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1373 19 might may MD 31417 1373 20 injure injure VB 31417 1373 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1373 22 business business NN 31417 1373 23 . . . 31417 1374 1 Naturally naturally RB 31417 1374 2 , , , 31417 1374 3 but but CC 31417 1374 4 unfortunately unfortunately RB 31417 1374 5 , , , 31417 1374 6 the the DT 31417 1374 7 term term NN 31417 1374 8 " " `` 31417 1374 9 spirit spirit NN 31417 1374 10 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1374 11 " " '' 31417 1374 12 was be VBD 31417 1374 13 invented invent VBN 31417 1374 14 . . . 31417 1375 1 Unfortunately unfortunately RB 31417 1375 2 , , , 31417 1375 3 because because IN 31417 1375 4 , , , 31417 1375 5 granting grant VBG 31417 1375 6 the the DT 31417 1375 7 reality reality NN 31417 1375 8 and and CC 31417 1375 9 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1375 10 of of IN 31417 1375 11 some some DT 31417 1375 12 of of IN 31417 1375 13 the the DT 31417 1375 14 results result NNS 31417 1375 15 , , , 31417 1375 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1375 17 by by IN 31417 1375 18 no no DT 31417 1375 19 means means NN 31417 1375 20 follows follow VBZ 31417 1375 21 that that IN 31417 1375 22 a a DT 31417 1375 23 " " `` 31417 1375 24 spirit spirit NN 31417 1375 25 " " '' 31417 1375 26 stood stand VBD 31417 1375 27 or or CC 31417 1375 28 sat sit VBD 31417 1375 29 for for IN 31417 1375 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1375 31 portrait portrait NN 31417 1375 32 , , , 31417 1375 33 as as IN 31417 1375 34 a a DT 31417 1375 35 human human JJ 31417 1375 36 sitter sitter NN 31417 1375 37 does do VBZ 31417 1375 38 . . . 31417 1376 1 Naturally naturally RB 31417 1376 2 also also RB 31417 1376 3 , , , 31417 1376 4 various various JJ 31417 1376 5 explanations explanation NNS 31417 1376 6 were be VBD 31417 1376 7 soon soon RB 31417 1376 8 alleged allege VBN 31417 1376 9 , , , 31417 1376 10 two two CD 31417 1376 11 being being NN 31417 1376 12 , , , 31417 1376 13 either either CC 31417 1376 14 that that IN 31417 1376 15 the the DT 31417 1376 16 plates plate NNS 31417 1376 17 had have VBD 31417 1376 18 been be VBN 31417 1376 19 used use VBN 31417 1376 20 before before RB 31417 1376 21 , , , 31417 1376 22 and and CC 31417 1376 23 had have VBD 31417 1376 24 been be VBN 31417 1376 25 imperfectly imperfectly RB 31417 1376 26 cleaned clean VBN 31417 1376 27 , , , 31417 1376 28 or or CC 31417 1376 29 that that IN 31417 1376 30 the the DT 31417 1376 31 results result NNS 31417 1376 32 were be VBD 31417 1376 33 produced produce VBN 31417 1376 34 by by IN 31417 1376 35 deliberate deliberate JJ 31417 1376 36 artifice artifice NN 31417 1376 37 and and CC 31417 1376 38 fraud fraud NN 31417 1376 39 on on IN 31417 1376 40 the the DT 31417 1376 41 part part NN 31417 1376 42 of of IN 31417 1376 43 the the DT 31417 1376 44 photographer photographer NN 31417 1376 45 . . . 31417 1377 1 There there EX 31417 1377 2 is be VBZ 31417 1377 3 no no DT 31417 1377 4 doubt doubt NN 31417 1377 5 that that IN 31417 1377 6 artificial artificial JJ 31417 1377 7 results result NNS 31417 1377 8 can can MD 31417 1377 9 be be VB 31417 1377 10 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1377 11 in in IN 31417 1377 12 a a DT 31417 1377 13 variety variety NN 31417 1377 14 of of IN 31417 1377 15 ways way NNS 31417 1377 16 , , , 31417 1377 17 which which WDT 31417 1377 18 are be VBP 31417 1377 19 extremely extremely RB 31417 1377 20 difficult difficult JJ 31417 1377 21 , , , 31417 1377 22 if if IN 31417 1377 23 not not RB 31417 1377 24 impossible impossible JJ 31417 1377 25 to to TO 31417 1377 26 distinguish distinguish VB 31417 1377 27 from from IN 31417 1377 28 the the DT 31417 1377 29 professed profess VBN 31417 1377 30 genuine genuine JJ 31417 1377 31 article article NN 31417 1377 32 . . . 31417 1378 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1378 2 may may MD 31417 1378 3 therefore therefore RB 31417 1378 4 be be VB 31417 1378 5 said say VBN 31417 1378 6 that that IN 31417 1378 7 no no DT 31417 1378 8 examination examination NN 31417 1378 9 of of IN 31417 1378 10 a a DT 31417 1378 11 professed professed JJ 31417 1378 12 " " `` 31417 1378 13 spirit spirit NN 31417 1378 14 photograph photograph NN 31417 1378 15 , , , 31417 1378 16 " " '' 31417 1378 17 or or CC 31417 1378 18 as as IN 31417 1378 19 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1378 20 should should MD 31417 1378 21 prefer prefer VB 31417 1378 22 to to TO 31417 1378 23 call call VB 31417 1378 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1378 25 , , , 31417 1378 26 a a DT 31417 1378 27 " " `` 31417 1378 28 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1378 29 photograph photograph NN 31417 1378 30 , , , 31417 1378 31 " " '' 31417 1378 32 is be VBZ 31417 1378 33 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 1378 34 to to TO 31417 1378 35 determine determine VB 31417 1378 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1378 37 nature nature NN 31417 1378 38 and and CC 31417 1378 39 origin origin NN 31417 1378 40 . . . 31417 1379 1 The the DT 31417 1379 2 true true JJ 31417 1379 3 test test NN 31417 1379 4 must must MD 31417 1379 5 be be VB 31417 1379 6 sought seek VBN 31417 1379 7 for for IN 31417 1379 8 in in IN 31417 1379 9 the the DT 31417 1379 10 conditions condition NNS 31417 1379 11 under under IN 31417 1379 12 which which WDT 31417 1379 13 the the DT 31417 1379 14 photograph photograph NN 31417 1379 15 was be VBD 31417 1379 16 taken take VBN 31417 1379 17 . . . 31417 1380 1 Very very RB 31417 1380 2 few few JJ 31417 1380 3 of of IN 31417 1380 4 those those DT 31417 1380 5 who who WP 31417 1380 6 have have VBP 31417 1380 7 had have VBN 31417 1380 8 to to TO 31417 1380 9 do do VB 31417 1380 10 with with IN 31417 1380 11 " " `` 31417 1380 12 spirit spirit NN 31417 1380 13 photography photography NN 31417 1380 14 " " '' 31417 1380 15 have have VBP 31417 1380 16 possessed possess VBN 31417 1380 17 the the DT 31417 1380 18 necessary necessary JJ 31417 1380 19 technical technical JJ 31417 1380 20 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1380 21 , , , 31417 1380 22 and and CC 31417 1380 23 also also RB 31417 1380 24 been be VBN 31417 1380 25 sufficiently sufficiently RB 31417 1380 26 careful careful JJ 31417 1380 27 , , , 31417 1380 28 in in IN 31417 1380 29 the the DT 31417 1380 30 various various JJ 31417 1380 31 stages stage NNS 31417 1380 32 of of IN 31417 1380 33 the the DT 31417 1380 34 process process NN 31417 1380 35 . . . 31417 1381 1 The the DT 31417 1381 2 result result NN 31417 1381 3 is be VBZ 31417 1381 4 that that IN 31417 1381 5 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1381 6 any any DT 31417 1381 7 of of IN 31417 1381 8 the the DT 31417 1381 9 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1381 10 shown show VBN 31417 1381 11 as as IN 31417 1381 12 " " `` 31417 1381 13 spirit spirit NN 31417 1381 14 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1381 15 " " '' 31417 1381 16 possess possess VBP 31417 1381 17 any any DT 31417 1381 18 evidential evidential JJ 31417 1381 19 value value NN 31417 1381 20 . . . 31417 1382 1 In in IN 31417 1382 2 common common JJ 31417 1382 3 with with IN 31417 1382 4 several several JJ 31417 1382 5 other other JJ 31417 1382 6 alleged allege VBN 31417 1382 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1382 8 , , , 31417 1382 9 but but CC 31417 1382 10 little little JJ 31417 1382 11 attention attention NN 31417 1382 12 has have VBZ 31417 1382 13 been be VBN 31417 1382 14 given give VBN 31417 1382 15 to to IN 31417 1382 16 the the DT 31417 1382 17 subject subject NN 31417 1382 18 by by IN 31417 1382 19 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1382 20 men man NNS 31417 1382 21 , , , 31417 1382 22 or or CC 31417 1382 23 by by IN 31417 1382 24 trained train VBN 31417 1382 25 experimenters experimenter NNS 31417 1382 26 . . . 31417 1383 1 The the DT 31417 1383 2 most most RBS 31417 1383 3 notable notable JJ 31417 1383 4 exception exception NN 31417 1383 5 to to IN 31417 1383 6 this this DT 31417 1383 7 which which WDT 31417 1383 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1383 9 am be VBP 31417 1383 10 able able JJ 31417 1383 11 to to TO 31417 1383 12 quote quote VB 31417 1383 13 is be VBZ 31417 1383 14 that that DT 31417 1383 15 of of IN 31417 1383 16 the the DT 31417 1383 17 late late JJ 31417 1383 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1383 19 J. J. NNP 31417 1383 20 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1383 21 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1383 22 , , , 31417 1383 23 who who WP 31417 1383 24 was be VBD 31417 1383 25 for for IN 31417 1383 26 a a DT 31417 1383 27 considerable considerable JJ 31417 1383 28 time time NN 31417 1383 29 the the DT 31417 1383 30 editor editor NN 31417 1383 31 of of IN 31417 1383 32 the the DT 31417 1383 33 _ _ NNP 31417 1383 34 British British NNP 31417 1383 35 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1383 36 of of IN 31417 1383 37 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1383 38 _ _ NNP 31417 1383 39 . . . 31417 1384 1 The the DT 31417 1384 2 following follow VBG 31417 1384 3 quotations quotation NNS 31417 1384 4 are be VBP 31417 1384 5 from from IN 31417 1384 6 a a DT 31417 1384 7 paper paper NN 31417 1384 8 on on IN 31417 1384 9 " " `` 31417 1384 10 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1384 11 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1384 12 " " '' 31417 1384 13 by by IN 31417 1384 14 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1384 15 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1384 16 . . . 31417 1385 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1385 2 was be VBD 31417 1385 3 originally originally RB 31417 1385 4 read read VBN 31417 1385 5 before before IN 31417 1385 6 the the DT 31417 1385 7 London London NNP 31417 1385 8 and and CC 31417 1385 9 Provincial Provincial NNP 31417 1385 10 Photographic Photographic NNP 31417 1385 11 Association Association NNP 31417 1385 12 in in IN 31417 1385 13 March March NNP 31417 1385 14 1893 1893 CD 31417 1385 15 , , , 31417 1385 16 and and CC 31417 1385 17 was be VBD 31417 1385 18 reprinted reprint VBN 31417 1385 19 in in IN 31417 1385 20 the the DT 31417 1385 21 _ _ NNP 31417 1385 22 British British NNP 31417 1385 23 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1385 24 of of IN 31417 1385 25 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1385 26 _ _ NNP 31417 1385 27 for for IN 31417 1385 28 26th 26th JJ 31417 1385 29 May May NNP 31417 1385 30 1904 1904 CD 31417 1385 31 , , , 31417 1385 32 shortly shortly RB 31417 1385 33 after after IN 31417 1385 34 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1385 35 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1385 36 's 's POS 31417 1385 37 death death NN 31417 1385 38 . . . 31417 1386 1 " " `` 31417 1386 2 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1386 3 photography photography NN 31417 1386 4 , , , 31417 1386 5 so so RB 31417 1386 6 called call VBN 31417 1386 7 , , , 31417 1386 8 has have VBZ 31417 1386 9 of of IN 31417 1386 10 late late RB 31417 1386 11 been be VBN 31417 1386 12 asserting assert VBG 31417 1386 13 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1386 14 existence existence NN 31417 1386 15 in in IN 31417 1386 16 such such PDT 31417 1386 17 a a DT 31417 1386 18 manner manner NN 31417 1386 19 and and CC 31417 1386 20 to to IN 31417 1386 21 such such PDT 31417 1386 22 an an DT 31417 1386 23 extent extent NN 31417 1386 24 as as IN 31417 1386 25 to to TO 31417 1386 26 warrant warrant VB 31417 1386 27 competent competent JJ 31417 1386 28 men man NNS 31417 1386 29 in in IN 31417 1386 30 making make VBG 31417 1386 31 an an DT 31417 1386 32 investigation investigation NN 31417 1386 33 , , , 31417 1386 34 conducted conduct VBN 31417 1386 35 under under IN 31417 1386 36 stringent stringent JJ 31417 1386 37 test test NN 31417 1386 38 conditions condition NNS 31417 1386 39 , , , 31417 1386 40 into into IN 31417 1386 41 the the DT 31417 1386 42 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 1386 43 under under IN 31417 1386 44 which which WDT 31417 1386 45 such such JJ 31417 1386 46 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1386 47 are be VBP 31417 1386 48 produced produce VBN 31417 1386 49 , , , 31417 1386 50 and and CC 31417 1386 51 exposing expose VBG 31417 1386 52 the the DT 31417 1386 53 fraud fraud NN 31417 1386 54 should should MD 31417 1386 55 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1386 56 prove prove VB 31417 1386 57 to to TO 31417 1386 58 be be VB 31417 1386 59 such such JJ 31417 1386 60 , , , 31417 1386 61 instead instead RB 31417 1386 62 of of IN 31417 1386 63 pooh pooh NNP 31417 1386 64 - - : 31417 1386 65 poohing poohe VBG 31417 1386 66 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1386 67 as as IN 31417 1386 68 insensate insensate NN 31417 1386 69 because because IN 31417 1386 70 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1386 71 do do VBP 31417 1386 72 not not RB 31417 1386 73 understand understand VB 31417 1386 74 how how WRB 31417 1386 75 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1386 76 can can MD 31417 1386 77 be be VB 31417 1386 78 otherwise otherwise RB 31417 1386 79 -- -- : 31417 1386 80 a a DT 31417 1386 81 position position NN 31417 1386 82 that that WDT 31417 1386 83 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1386 84 commends commend VBZ 31417 1386 85 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 1386 86 as as IN 31417 1386 87 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 1386 88 or or CC 31417 1386 89 philosophical philosophical JJ 31417 1386 90 . . . 31417 1387 1 If if IN 31417 1387 2 , , , 31417 1387 3 in in IN 31417 1387 4 what what WP 31417 1387 5 follows follow VBZ 31417 1387 6 , , , 31417 1387 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1387 8 call call VBP 31417 1387 9 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1387 10 ' ' POS 31417 1387 11 spirit spirit NNP 31417 1387 12 photography photography NN 31417 1387 13 ' ' '' 31417 1387 14 instead instead RB 31417 1387 15 of of IN 31417 1387 16 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1387 17 photography photography NN 31417 1387 18 , , , 31417 1387 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1387 20 is be VBZ 31417 1387 21 only only RB 31417 1387 22 in in IN 31417 1387 23 deference deference NN 31417 1387 24 to to IN 31417 1387 25 a a DT 31417 1387 26 nomenclature nomenclature NN 31417 1387 27 that that WDT 31417 1387 28 extensively extensively RB 31417 1387 29 prevails prevail VBZ 31417 1387 30 .... .... . 31417 1388 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1388 2 approach approach VBP 31417 1388 3 the the DT 31417 1388 4 subject subject NN 31417 1388 5 merely merely RB 31417 1388 6 as as IN 31417 1388 7 a a DT 31417 1388 8 photographer photographer NN 31417 1388 9 . . . 31417 1388 10 " " '' 31417 1389 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1389 2 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1389 3 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1389 4 then then RB 31417 1389 5 gives give VBZ 31417 1389 6 a a DT 31417 1389 7 history history NN 31417 1389 8 of of IN 31417 1389 9 the the DT 31417 1389 10 earlier early JJR 31417 1389 11 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 1389 12 of of IN 31417 1389 13 " " `` 31417 1389 14 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1389 15 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1389 16 , , , 31417 1389 17 " " '' 31417 1389 18 and and CC 31417 1389 19 goes go VBZ 31417 1389 20 on on RP 31417 1389 21 to to TO 31417 1389 22 explain explain VB 31417 1389 23 how how WRB 31417 1389 24 striking striking JJ 31417 1389 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1389 26 in in IN 31417 1389 27 photographing photograph VBG 31417 1389 28 what what WP 31417 1389 29 is be VBZ 31417 1389 30 invisible invisible JJ 31417 1389 31 to to IN 31417 1389 32 the the DT 31417 1389 33 eye eye NN 31417 1389 34 may may MD 31417 1389 35 be be VB 31417 1389 36 produced produce VBN 31417 1389 37 by by IN 31417 1389 38 the the DT 31417 1389 39 agency agency NN 31417 1389 40 of of IN 31417 1389 41 fluorescence fluorescence NNP 31417 1389 42 . . . 31417 1390 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1390 2 quotes quote VBZ 31417 1390 3 the the DT 31417 1390 4 demonstration demonstration NN 31417 1390 5 by by IN 31417 1390 6 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1390 7 Gladstone Gladstone NNP 31417 1390 8 , , , 31417 1390 9 F.R.S. F.R.S. NNP 31417 1390 10 , , , 31417 1390 11 at at IN 31417 1390 12 the the DT 31417 1390 13 Bradford Bradford NNP 31417 1390 14 Meeting Meeting NNP 31417 1390 15 of of IN 31417 1390 16 the the DT 31417 1390 17 British British NNP 31417 1390 18 Association Association NNP 31417 1390 19 in in IN 31417 1390 20 1873 1873 CD 31417 1390 21 , , , 31417 1390 22 showing show VBG 31417 1390 23 that that IN 31417 1390 24 invisible invisible JJ 31417 1390 25 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1390 26 on on IN 31417 1390 27 white white JJ 31417 1390 28 cards card NNS 31417 1390 29 have have VBP 31417 1390 30 produced produce VBN 31417 1390 31 bold bold JJ 31417 1390 32 and and CC 31417 1390 33 clear clear JJ 31417 1390 34 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1390 35 when when WRB 31417 1390 36 no no DT 31417 1390 37 eye eye NN 31417 1390 38 could could MD 31417 1390 39 see see VB 31417 1390 40 the the DT 31417 1390 41 drawings drawing NNS 31417 1390 42 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1390 43 . . . 31417 1391 1 Hence hence RB 31417 1391 2 , , , 31417 1391 3 as as IN 31417 1391 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1391 5 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1391 6 says say VBZ 31417 1391 7 , , , 31417 1391 8 the the DT 31417 1391 9 photographing photographing NN 31417 1391 10 of of IN 31417 1391 11 an an DT 31417 1391 12 invisible invisible JJ 31417 1391 13 image image NN 31417 1391 14 is be VBZ 31417 1391 15 not not RB 31417 1391 16 scientifically scientifically RB 31417 1391 17 impossible impossible JJ 31417 1391 18 . . . 31417 1392 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1392 2 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1392 3 then then RB 31417 1392 4 proceeds proceed VBZ 31417 1392 5 to to TO 31417 1392 6 describe describe VB 31417 1392 7 some some DT 31417 1392 8 personal personal JJ 31417 1392 9 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1392 10 . . . 31417 1393 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1393 2 says say VBZ 31417 1393 3 : : : 31417 1393 4 " " `` 31417 1393 5 For for IN 31417 1393 6 several several JJ 31417 1393 7 years year NNS 31417 1393 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1393 9 have have VBP 31417 1393 10 experienced experience VBN 31417 1393 11 a a DT 31417 1393 12 strong strong JJ 31417 1393 13 desire desire NN 31417 1393 14 to to TO 31417 1393 15 ascertain ascertain VB 31417 1393 16 by by IN 31417 1393 17 personal personal JJ 31417 1393 18 investigation investigation NN 31417 1393 19 the the DT 31417 1393 20 amount amount NN 31417 1393 21 of of IN 31417 1393 22 truth truth NN 31417 1393 23 in in IN 31417 1393 24 the the DT 31417 1393 25 ever ever RB 31417 1393 26 - - HYPH 31417 1393 27 recurring recur VBG 31417 1393 28 allegation allegation NN 31417 1393 29 that that WDT 31417 1393 30 figures figure VBZ 31417 1393 31 other other JJ 31417 1393 32 than than IN 31417 1393 33 those those DT 31417 1393 34 visually visually RB 31417 1393 35 present present JJ 31417 1393 36 in in IN 31417 1393 37 the the DT 31417 1393 38 room room NN 31417 1393 39 appeared appear VBD 31417 1393 40 on on IN 31417 1393 41 a a DT 31417 1393 42 sensitive sensitive JJ 31417 1393 43 plate plate NN 31417 1393 44 .... .... . 31417 1393 45 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1393 46 D. D. NNP 31417 1393 47 , , , 31417 1393 48 of of IN 31417 1393 49 Glasgow Glasgow NNP 31417 1393 50 , , , 31417 1393 51 in in IN 31417 1393 52 whose whose WP$ 31417 1393 53 presence presence NN 31417 1393 54 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1393 55 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1393 56 have have VBP 31417 1393 57 long long RB 31417 1393 58 been be VBN 31417 1393 59 alleged allege VBN 31417 1393 60 to to TO 31417 1393 61 be be VB 31417 1393 62 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1393 63 , , , 31417 1393 64 was be VBD 31417 1393 65 lately lately RB 31417 1393 66 in in IN 31417 1393 67 London London NNP 31417 1393 68 on on IN 31417 1393 69 a a DT 31417 1393 70 visit visit NN 31417 1393 71 , , , 31417 1393 72 and and CC 31417 1393 73 a a DT 31417 1393 74 mutual mutual JJ 31417 1393 75 friend friend NN 31417 1393 76 got get VBD 31417 1393 77 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1393 78 to to TO 31417 1393 79 consent consent VB 31417 1393 80 to to TO 31417 1393 81 extend extend VB 31417 1393 82 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1393 83 stay stay NN 31417 1393 84 in in IN 31417 1393 85 order order NN 31417 1393 86 that that IN 31417 1393 87 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1393 88 might may MD 31417 1393 89 try try VB 31417 1393 90 to to TO 31417 1393 91 get get VB 31417 1393 92 a a DT 31417 1393 93 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1393 94 photograph photograph NN 31417 1393 95 under under IN 31417 1393 96 test test NN 31417 1393 97 conditions condition NNS 31417 1393 98 . . . 31417 1394 1 To to IN 31417 1394 2 this this DT 31417 1394 3 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1394 4 willingly willingly RB 31417 1394 5 agreed agree VBD 31417 1394 6 . . . 31417 1395 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1395 2 conditions condition NNS 31417 1395 3 were be VBD 31417 1395 4 exceedingly exceedingly RB 31417 1395 5 simple simple JJ 31417 1395 6 , , , 31417 1395 7 were be VBD 31417 1395 8 courteously courteously RB 31417 1395 9 expressed express VBN 31417 1395 10 to to IN 31417 1395 11 the the DT 31417 1395 12 host host NN 31417 1395 13 , , , 31417 1395 14 and and CC 31417 1395 15 entirely entirely RB 31417 1395 16 acquiesced acquiesce VBD 31417 1395 17 in in IN 31417 1395 18 . . . 31417 1396 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 2 were be VBD 31417 1396 3 , , , 31417 1396 4 that that IN 31417 1396 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 6 for for IN 31417 1396 7 the the DT 31417 1396 8 nonce nonce NN 31417 1396 9 would would MD 31417 1396 10 assume assume VB 31417 1396 11 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 12 all all DT 31417 1396 13 to to TO 31417 1396 14 be be VB 31417 1396 15 tricksters trickster NNS 31417 1396 16 , , , 31417 1396 17 and and CC 31417 1396 18 to to TO 31417 1396 19 guard guard VB 31417 1396 20 against against IN 31417 1396 21 fraud fraud NN 31417 1396 22 , , , 31417 1396 23 should should MD 31417 1396 24 use use VB 31417 1396 25 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1396 26 own own JJ 31417 1396 27 camera camera NN 31417 1396 28 and and CC 31417 1396 29 unopened unopened JJ 31417 1396 30 packages package NNS 31417 1396 31 of of IN 31417 1396 32 dry dry JJ 31417 1396 33 plates plate NNS 31417 1396 34 purchased purchase VBN 31417 1396 35 from from IN 31417 1396 36 dealers dealer NNS 31417 1396 37 of of IN 31417 1396 38 repute repute NN 31417 1396 39 , , , 31417 1396 40 and and CC 31417 1396 41 that that IN 31417 1396 42 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 43 should should MD 31417 1396 44 be be VB 31417 1396 45 excused excuse VBN 31417 1396 46 from from IN 31417 1396 47 allowing allow VBG 31417 1396 48 a a DT 31417 1396 49 plate plate NN 31417 1396 50 to to TO 31417 1396 51 go go VB 31417 1396 52 out out IN 31417 1396 53 of of IN 31417 1396 54 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1396 55 own own JJ 31417 1396 56 hand hand NN 31417 1396 57 till till IN 31417 1396 58 after after IN 31417 1396 59 development development NN 31417 1396 60 unless unless IN 31417 1396 61 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 62 felt feel VBD 31417 1396 63 otherwise otherwise RB 31417 1396 64 disposed disposed JJ 31417 1396 65 ; ; : 31417 1396 66 but but CC 31417 1396 67 that that IN 31417 1396 68 as as IN 31417 1396 69 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 70 was be VBD 31417 1396 71 to to TO 31417 1396 72 treat treat VB 31417 1396 73 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 74 as as IN 31417 1396 75 under under IN 31417 1396 76 suspicion suspicion NN 31417 1396 77 , , , 31417 1396 78 so so RB 31417 1396 79 must must MD 31417 1396 80 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 81 treat treat VB 31417 1396 82 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 83 , , , 31417 1396 84 and and CC 31417 1396 85 that that IN 31417 1396 86 every every DT 31417 1396 87 act act NN 31417 1396 88 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 89 performed perform VBD 31417 1396 90 must must MD 31417 1396 91 be be VB 31417 1396 92 in in IN 31417 1396 93 the the DT 31417 1396 94 presence presence NN 31417 1396 95 of of IN 31417 1396 96 two two CD 31417 1396 97 witnesses witness NNS 31417 1396 98 ; ; : 31417 1396 99 nay nay NNP 31417 1396 100 , , , 31417 1396 101 that that IN 31417 1396 102 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 103 would would MD 31417 1396 104 set set VB 31417 1396 105 a a DT 31417 1396 106 watch watch NN 31417 1396 107 upon upon IN 31417 1396 108 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1396 109 own own JJ 31417 1396 110 camera camera NN 31417 1396 111 in in IN 31417 1396 112 the the DT 31417 1396 113 guise guise NN 31417 1396 114 of of IN 31417 1396 115 a a DT 31417 1396 116 duplicate duplicate JJ 31417 1396 117 one one CD 31417 1396 118 of of IN 31417 1396 119 the the DT 31417 1396 120 same same JJ 31417 1396 121 focus focus NN 31417 1396 122 -- -- : 31417 1396 123 in in IN 31417 1396 124 other other JJ 31417 1396 125 words word NNS 31417 1396 126 , , , 31417 1396 127 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 128 would would MD 31417 1396 129 use use VB 31417 1396 130 a a DT 31417 1396 131 binocular binocular JJ 31417 1396 132 stereoscopic stereoscopic JJ 31417 1396 133 camera camera NN 31417 1396 134 and and CC 31417 1396 135 dictate dictate VB 31417 1396 136 all all PDT 31417 1396 137 the the DT 31417 1396 138 conditions condition NNS 31417 1396 139 of of IN 31417 1396 140 operation operation NN 31417 1396 141 .... .... . 31417 1396 142 " " '' 31417 1396 143 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1396 144 G. G. NNP 31417 1396 145 was be VBD 31417 1396 146 the the DT 31417 1396 147 first first JJ 31417 1396 148 sitter sitter NN 31417 1396 149 , , , 31417 1396 150 and and CC 31417 1396 151 for for IN 31417 1396 152 a a DT 31417 1396 153 reason reason NN 31417 1396 154 known know VBN 31417 1396 155 to to IN 31417 1396 156 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 157 , , , 31417 1396 158 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1396 159 used use VBD 31417 1396 160 a a DT 31417 1396 161 monocular monocular JJ 31417 1396 162 camera camera NN 31417 1396 163 . . . 31417 1397 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1397 2 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1397 3 took take VBD 31417 1397 4 the the DT 31417 1397 5 plate plate NN 31417 1397 6 out out IN 31417 1397 7 of of IN 31417 1397 8 a a DT 31417 1397 9 packet packet NN 31417 1397 10 just just RB 31417 1397 11 previously previously RB 31417 1397 12 ripped rip VBN 31417 1397 13 up up RP 31417 1397 14 under under IN 31417 1397 15 the the DT 31417 1397 16 surveillance surveillance NN 31417 1397 17 of of IN 31417 1397 18 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1397 19 two two CD 31417 1397 20 detectives detective NNS 31417 1397 21 . . . 31417 1398 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1398 2 placed place VBD 31417 1398 3 the the DT 31417 1398 4 slide slide NN 31417 1398 5 in in IN 31417 1398 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1398 7 pocket pocket NN 31417 1398 8 , , , 31417 1398 9 and and CC 31417 1398 10 exposed expose VBD 31417 1398 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1398 12 by by IN 31417 1398 13 magnesium magnesium NN 31417 1398 14 ribbon ribbon NN 31417 1398 15 which which WDT 31417 1398 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1398 17 held hold VBD 31417 1398 18 in in IN 31417 1398 19 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1398 20 own own JJ 31417 1398 21 hand hand NN 31417 1398 22 , , , 31417 1398 23 keeping keep VBG 31417 1398 24 one one CD 31417 1398 25 eye eye NN 31417 1398 26 , , , 31417 1398 27 as as IN 31417 1398 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1398 29 were be VBD 31417 1398 30 , , , 31417 1398 31 on on IN 31417 1398 32 the the DT 31417 1398 33 sitter sitter NN 31417 1398 34 , , , 31417 1398 35 and and CC 31417 1398 36 the the DT 31417 1398 37 other other JJ 31417 1398 38 on on IN 31417 1398 39 the the DT 31417 1398 40 camera camera NN 31417 1398 41 . . . 31417 1399 1 There there EX 31417 1399 2 was be VBD 31417 1399 3 no no DT 31417 1399 4 background background NN 31417 1399 5 . . . 31417 1400 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1400 2 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1400 3 took take VBD 31417 1400 4 the the DT 31417 1400 5 plate plate NN 31417 1400 6 from from IN 31417 1400 7 the the DT 31417 1400 8 dark dark JJ 31417 1400 9 slide slide NN 31417 1400 10 , , , 31417 1400 11 and and CC 31417 1400 12 , , , 31417 1400 13 under under IN 31417 1400 14 the the DT 31417 1400 15 eyes eye NNS 31417 1400 16 of of IN 31417 1400 17 the the DT 31417 1400 18 two two CD 31417 1400 19 detectives detective NNS 31417 1400 20 , , , 31417 1400 21 placed place VBD 31417 1400 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1400 23 in in IN 31417 1400 24 the the DT 31417 1400 25 developing develop VBG 31417 1400 26 dish dish NN 31417 1400 27 . . . 31417 1401 1 Between between IN 31417 1401 2 the the DT 31417 1401 3 camera camera NN 31417 1401 4 and and CC 31417 1401 5 the the DT 31417 1401 6 sitter sitter NN 31417 1401 7 a a DT 31417 1401 8 female female JJ 31417 1401 9 figure figure NN 31417 1401 10 was be VBD 31417 1401 11 developed develop VBN 31417 1401 12 , , , 31417 1401 13 rather rather RB 31417 1401 14 in in IN 31417 1401 15 a a DT 31417 1401 16 more more RBR 31417 1401 17 pronounced pronounced JJ 31417 1401 18 form form NN 31417 1401 19 than than IN 31417 1401 20 that that DT 31417 1401 21 of of IN 31417 1401 22 the the DT 31417 1401 23 sitter sitter NN 31417 1401 24 .... .... . 31417 1402 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1402 2 submit submit VBP 31417 1402 3 this this DT 31417 1402 4 picture picture NN 31417 1402 5 .... .... . 31417 1403 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1403 2 do do VBP 31417 1403 3 not not RB 31417 1403 4 recognise recognise VB 31417 1403 5 her -PRON- PRP 31417 1403 6 or or CC 31417 1403 7 any any DT 31417 1403 8 of of IN 31417 1403 9 the the DT 31417 1403 10 other other JJ 31417 1403 11 figures figure NNS 31417 1403 12 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1403 13 obtained obtain VBD 31417 1403 14 , , , 31417 1403 15 as as IN 31417 1403 16 like like UH 31417 1403 17 any any DT 31417 1403 18 one one NN 31417 1403 19 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1403 20 know know VBP 31417 1403 21 .... .... NFP 31417 1403 22 " " '' 31417 1403 23 Many many JJ 31417 1403 24 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1403 25 of of IN 31417 1403 26 like like UH 31417 1403 27 nature nature NN 31417 1403 28 followed follow VBN 31417 1403 29 ; ; : 31417 1403 30 on on IN 31417 1403 31 some some DT 31417 1403 32 plates plate NNS 31417 1403 33 were be VBD 31417 1403 34 abnormal abnormal JJ 31417 1403 35 appearances appearance NNS 31417 1403 36 , , , 31417 1403 37 on on IN 31417 1403 38 others other NNS 31417 1403 39 none none NN 31417 1403 40 . . . 31417 1404 1 All all PDT 31417 1404 2 this this DT 31417 1404 3 time time NN 31417 1404 4 , , , 31417 1404 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1404 6 D. D. NNP 31417 1404 7 the the DT 31417 1404 8 medium medium NN 31417 1404 9 , , , 31417 1404 10 during during IN 31417 1404 11 the the DT 31417 1404 12 exposure exposure NN 31417 1404 13 of of IN 31417 1404 14 the the DT 31417 1404 15 plates plate NNS 31417 1404 16 , , , 31417 1404 17 was be VBD 31417 1404 18 quite quite RB 31417 1404 19 inactive inactive JJ 31417 1404 20 .... .... . 31417 1404 21 " " '' 31417 1404 22 The the DT 31417 1404 23 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1404 24 figures figure NNS 31417 1404 25 behaved behave VBN 31417 1404 26 badly badly RB 31417 1404 27 . . . 31417 1405 1 Some some DT 31417 1405 2 were be VBD 31417 1405 3 in in IN 31417 1405 4 focus focus NN 31417 1405 5 . . . 31417 1406 1 Others other NNS 31417 1406 2 not not RB 31417 1406 3 so so RB 31417 1406 4 . . . 31417 1407 1 Some some DT 31417 1407 2 were be VBD 31417 1407 3 lighted light VBN 31417 1407 4 from from IN 31417 1407 5 the the DT 31417 1407 6 right right NN 31417 1407 7 , , , 31417 1407 8 while while IN 31417 1407 9 the the DT 31417 1407 10 sitter sitter NN 31417 1407 11 was be VBD 31417 1407 12 so so RB 31417 1407 13 from from IN 31417 1407 14 the the DT 31417 1407 15 left left NN 31417 1407 16 ; ; : 31417 1407 17 some some DT 31417 1407 18 were be VBD 31417 1407 19 comely comely RB 31417 1407 20 , , , 31417 1407 21 ... ... : 31417 1407 22 others other NNS 31417 1407 23 not not RB 31417 1407 24 so so RB 31417 1407 25 . . . 31417 1408 1 Some some DT 31417 1408 2 monopolised monopolise VBD 31417 1408 3 the the DT 31417 1408 4 major major JJ 31417 1408 5 portion portion NN 31417 1408 6 of of IN 31417 1408 7 the the DT 31417 1408 8 plate plate NN 31417 1408 9 , , , 31417 1408 10 quite quite RB 31417 1408 11 obliterating obliterate VBG 31417 1408 12 the the DT 31417 1408 13 material material NN 31417 1408 14 sitters sitter NNS 31417 1408 15 . . . 31417 1409 1 Others other NNS 31417 1409 2 were be VBD 31417 1409 3 as as IN 31417 1409 4 if if IN 31417 1409 5 an an DT 31417 1409 6 atrociously atrociously RB 31417 1409 7 - - HYPH 31417 1409 8 badly badly RB 31417 1409 9 vignetted vignette VBN 31417 1409 10 portrait portrait NN 31417 1409 11 ... ... : 31417 1409 12 were be VBD 31417 1409 13 held hold VBN 31417 1409 14 up up RP 31417 1409 15 behind behind IN 31417 1409 16 the the DT 31417 1409 17 sitter sitter NN 31417 1409 18 . . . 31417 1410 1 But but CC 31417 1410 2 here here RB 31417 1410 3 is be VBZ 31417 1410 4 the the DT 31417 1410 5 point:--Not point:--not NN 31417 1410 6 one one CD 31417 1410 7 of of IN 31417 1410 8 these these DT 31417 1410 9 figures figure NNS 31417 1410 10 which which WDT 31417 1410 11 came come VBD 31417 1410 12 out out RP 31417 1410 13 so so RB 31417 1410 14 strongly strongly RB 31417 1410 15 in in IN 31417 1410 16 the the DT 31417 1410 17 negative negative JJ 31417 1410 18 , , , 31417 1410 19 was be VBD 31417 1410 20 visible visible JJ 31417 1410 21 in in IN 31417 1410 22 any any DT 31417 1410 23 form form NN 31417 1410 24 or or CC 31417 1410 25 shape shape NN 31417 1410 26 to to IN 31417 1410 27 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1410 28 during during IN 31417 1410 29 the the DT 31417 1410 30 time time NN 31417 1410 31 of of IN 31417 1410 32 exposure exposure NN 31417 1410 33 in in IN 31417 1410 34 the the DT 31417 1410 35 camera camera NN 31417 1410 36 , , , 31417 1410 37 and and CC 31417 1410 38 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1410 39 vouch vouch VBP 31417 1410 40 in in IN 31417 1410 41 the the DT 31417 1410 42 strongest strong JJS 31417 1410 43 manner manner NN 31417 1410 44 for for IN 31417 1410 45 the the DT 31417 1410 46 fact fact NN 31417 1410 47 that that IN 31417 1410 48 no no DT 31417 1410 49 one one NN 31417 1410 50 whatever whatever WDT 31417 1410 51 had have VBD 31417 1410 52 an an DT 31417 1410 53 opportunity opportunity NN 31417 1410 54 of of IN 31417 1410 55 tampering tamper VBG 31417 1410 56 with with IN 31417 1410 57 any any DT 31417 1410 58 plate plate NN 31417 1410 59 anterior anterior NN 31417 1410 60 to to IN 31417 1410 61 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1410 62 being be VBG 31417 1410 63 placed place VBN 31417 1410 64 in in IN 31417 1410 65 the the DT 31417 1410 66 dark dark JJ 31417 1410 67 slide slide NN 31417 1410 68 or or CC 31417 1410 69 immediately immediately RB 31417 1410 70 preceding precede VBG 31417 1410 71 development development NN 31417 1410 72 . . . 31417 1411 1 Pictorially pictorially RB 31417 1411 2 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1411 3 are be VBP 31417 1411 4 vile vile JJ 31417 1411 5 , , , 31417 1411 6 but but CC 31417 1411 7 how how WRB 31417 1411 8 came come VBD 31417 1411 9 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1411 10 there there RB 31417 1411 11 ? ? . 31417 1412 1 " " `` 31417 1412 2 Now now RB 31417 1412 3 all all PDT 31417 1412 4 this this DT 31417 1412 5 time time NN 31417 1412 6 , , , 31417 1412 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1412 8 imagine imagine VBP 31417 1412 9 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1412 10 are be VBP 31417 1412 11 wondering wonder VBG 31417 1412 12 how how WRB 31417 1412 13 the the DT 31417 1412 14 stereoscopic stereoscopic JJ 31417 1412 15 camera camera NN 31417 1412 16 was be VBD 31417 1412 17 behaving behave VBG 31417 1412 18 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 1412 19 as as IN 31417 1412 20 such such JJ 31417 1412 21 . . . 31417 1413 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1413 2 is be VBZ 31417 1413 3 due due JJ 31417 1413 4 to to IN 31417 1413 5 the the DT 31417 1413 6 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1413 7 entities entity NNS 31417 1413 8 to to TO 31417 1413 9 say say VB 31417 1413 10 that that IN 31417 1413 11 whatever whatever WDT 31417 1413 12 was be VBD 31417 1413 13 produced produce VBN 31417 1413 14 on on IN 31417 1413 15 one one CD 31417 1413 16 half half NN 31417 1413 17 of of IN 31417 1413 18 the the DT 31417 1413 19 stereoscopic stereoscopic JJ 31417 1413 20 plates plate NNS 31417 1413 21 was be VBD 31417 1413 22 produced produce VBN 31417 1413 23 on on IN 31417 1413 24 the the DT 31417 1413 25 other other JJ 31417 1413 26 , , , 31417 1413 27 alike alike RB 31417 1413 28 good good JJ 31417 1413 29 or or CC 31417 1413 30 bad bad JJ 31417 1413 31 in in IN 31417 1413 32 definition definition NN 31417 1413 33 . . . 31417 1414 1 But but CC 31417 1414 2 on on IN 31417 1414 3 a a DT 31417 1414 4 careful careful JJ 31417 1414 5 examination examination NN 31417 1414 6 of of IN 31417 1414 7 one one CD 31417 1414 8 which which WDT 31417 1414 9 was be VBD 31417 1414 10 rather rather RB 31417 1414 11 better well JJR 31417 1414 12 than than IN 31417 1414 13 the the DT 31417 1414 14 other other JJ 31417 1414 15 , , , 31417 1414 16 ... ... : 31417 1415 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1415 2 deduce deduce VBP 31417 1415 3 this this DT 31417 1415 4 fact fact NN 31417 1415 5 , , , 31417 1415 6 that that IN 31417 1415 7 the the DT 31417 1415 8 impressing impressing NN 31417 1415 9 of of IN 31417 1415 10 the the DT 31417 1415 11 spirit spirit NNP 31417 1415 12 form form NN 31417 1415 13 was be VBD 31417 1415 14 not not RB 31417 1415 15 consentaneous consentaneous JJ 31417 1415 16 with with IN 31417 1415 17 that that DT 31417 1415 18 of of IN 31417 1415 19 the the DT 31417 1415 20 sitter sitter NN 31417 1415 21 . . . 31417 1416 1 This this DT 31417 1416 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1416 3 consider consider VBP 31417 1416 4 an an DT 31417 1416 5 important important JJ 31417 1416 6 discovery discovery NN 31417 1416 7 . . . 31417 1417 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1417 2 carefully carefully RB 31417 1417 3 examined examine VBD 31417 1417 4 one one CD 31417 1417 5 in in IN 31417 1417 6 the the DT 31417 1417 7 stereoscope stereoscope NN 31417 1417 8 , , , 31417 1417 9 and and CC 31417 1417 10 found find VBD 31417 1417 11 that that IN 31417 1417 12 , , , 31417 1417 13 while while IN 31417 1417 14 the the DT 31417 1417 15 two two CD 31417 1417 16 sitters sitter NNS 31417 1417 17 were be VBD 31417 1417 18 stereoscopic stereoscopic JJ 31417 1417 19 _ _ NNP 31417 1417 20 per per FW 31417 1417 21 se se FW 31417 1417 22 _ _ NNP 31417 1417 23 , , , 31417 1417 24 the the DT 31417 1417 25 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1417 26 figure figure NN 31417 1417 27 was be VBD 31417 1417 28 absolutely absolutely RB 31417 1417 29 flat flat JJ 31417 1417 30 . . . 31417 1418 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1418 2 also also RB 31417 1418 3 found find VBD 31417 1418 4 that that IN 31417 1418 5 the the DT 31417 1418 6 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1418 7 figure figure NN 31417 1418 8 was be VBD 31417 1418 9 at at IN 31417 1418 10 least least JJS 31417 1418 11 a a DT 31417 1418 12 millimetre millimetre NN 31417 1418 13 higher high JJR 31417 1418 14 up up RP 31417 1418 15 in in IN 31417 1418 16 one one CD 31417 1418 17 than than IN 31417 1418 18 the the DT 31417 1418 19 other other JJ 31417 1418 20 . . . 31417 1419 1 Now now RB 31417 1419 2 , , , 31417 1419 3 as as IN 31417 1419 4 both both DT 31417 1419 5 had have VBD 31417 1419 6 been be VBN 31417 1419 7 simultaneously simultaneously RB 31417 1419 8 exposed expose VBN 31417 1419 9 , , , 31417 1419 10 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1419 11 follows follow VBZ 31417 1419 12 to to IN 31417 1419 13 demonstration demonstration NN 31417 1419 14 that that IN 31417 1419 15 , , , 31417 1419 16 although although IN 31417 1419 17 both both DT 31417 1419 18 were be VBD 31417 1419 19 correctly correctly RB 31417 1419 20 placed place VBN 31417 1419 21 vertically vertically RB 31417 1419 22 in in IN 31417 1419 23 relation relation NN 31417 1419 24 to to IN 31417 1419 25 the the DT 31417 1419 26 particular particular JJ 31417 1419 27 sitter sitter NN 31417 1419 28 behind behind IN 31417 1419 29 whom whom WP 31417 1419 30 the the DT 31417 1419 31 figure figure NN 31417 1419 32 appeared appear VBD 31417 1419 33 , , , 31417 1419 34 and and CC 31417 1419 35 not not RB 31417 1419 36 so so RB 31417 1419 37 horizontally horizontally RB 31417 1419 38 , , , 31417 1419 39 this this DT 31417 1419 40 figure figure NN 31417 1419 41 had have VBD 31417 1419 42 not not RB 31417 1419 43 only only RB 31417 1419 44 not not RB 31417 1419 45 been be VBN 31417 1419 46 impressed impressed JJ 31417 1419 47 on on IN 31417 1419 48 the the DT 31417 1419 49 plate plate NN 31417 1419 50 simultaneously simultaneously RB 31417 1419 51 with with IN 31417 1419 52 the the DT 31417 1419 53 two two CD 31417 1419 54 gentlemen gentleman NNS 31417 1419 55 forming form VBG 31417 1419 56 the the DT 31417 1419 57 group group NN 31417 1419 58 , , , 31417 1419 59 but but CC 31417 1419 60 had have VBD 31417 1419 61 not not RB 31417 1419 62 been be VBN 31417 1419 63 formed form VBN 31417 1419 64 by by IN 31417 1419 65 the the DT 31417 1419 66 lens lens NN 31417 1419 67 at at RB 31417 1419 68 all all RB 31417 1419 69 , , , 31417 1419 70 and and CC 31417 1419 71 that that IN 31417 1419 72 therefore therefore RB 31417 1419 73 the the DT 31417 1419 74 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1419 75 image image NN 31417 1419 76 might may MD 31417 1419 77 be be VB 31417 1419 78 produced produce VBN 31417 1419 79 without without IN 31417 1419 80 a a DT 31417 1419 81 camera camera NN 31417 1419 82 . . . 31417 1420 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1420 2 think think VBP 31417 1420 3 this this DT 31417 1420 4 is be VBZ 31417 1420 5 a a DT 31417 1420 6 fair fair JJ 31417 1420 7 deduction deduction NN 31417 1420 8 . . . 31417 1421 1 But but CC 31417 1421 2 still still RB 31417 1421 3 the the DT 31417 1421 4 question question NN 31417 1421 5 obtrudes obtrude VBZ 31417 1421 6 : : : 31417 1421 7 How how WRB 31417 1421 8 came come VBD 31417 1421 9 these these DT 31417 1421 10 figures figure NNS 31417 1421 11 there there RB 31417 1421 12 ? ? . 31417 1422 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1422 2 again again RB 31417 1422 3 assert assert VBP 31417 1422 4 that that IN 31417 1422 5 the the DT 31417 1422 6 plates plate NNS 31417 1422 7 were be VBD 31417 1422 8 not not RB 31417 1422 9 tampered tamper VBN 31417 1422 10 with with IN 31417 1422 11 by by IN 31417 1422 12 either either CC 31417 1422 13 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1422 14 or or CC 31417 1422 15 any any DT 31417 1422 16 one one CD 31417 1422 17 present present NN 31417 1422 18 . . . 31417 1423 1 Are be VBP 31417 1423 2 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1423 3 crystallisations crystallisation NNS 31417 1423 4 of of IN 31417 1423 5 thought thought NN 31417 1423 6 ? ? . 31417 1424 1 Have have VBP 31417 1424 2 lens lens NN 31417 1424 3 and and CC 31417 1424 4 light light NN 31417 1424 5 really really RB 31417 1424 6 nothing nothing NN 31417 1424 7 to to TO 31417 1424 8 do do VB 31417 1424 9 with with IN 31417 1424 10 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1424 11 formation formation NN 31417 1424 12 ? ? . 31417 1425 1 The the DT 31417 1425 2 whole whole JJ 31417 1425 3 subject subject NN 31417 1425 4 was be VBD 31417 1425 5 mysterious mysterious JJ 31417 1425 6 enough enough RB 31417 1425 7 on on IN 31417 1425 8 the the DT 31417 1425 9 hypothesis hypothesis NN 31417 1425 10 of of IN 31417 1425 11 an an DT 31417 1425 12 invisible invisible JJ 31417 1425 13 spirit spirit NN 31417 1425 14 , , , 31417 1425 15 whether whether IN 31417 1425 16 a a DT 31417 1425 17 thought thought NN 31417 1425 18 projection projection NN 31417 1425 19 or or CC 31417 1425 20 an an DT 31417 1425 21 actual actual JJ 31417 1425 22 spirit spirit NN 31417 1425 23 , , , 31417 1425 24 being be VBG 31417 1425 25 really really RB 31417 1425 26 there there RB 31417 1425 27 in in IN 31417 1425 28 the the DT 31417 1425 29 vicinity vicinity NN 31417 1425 30 of of IN 31417 1425 31 the the DT 31417 1425 32 sitter sitter NN 31417 1425 33 , , , 31417 1425 34 but but CC 31417 1425 35 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1425 36 is be VBZ 31417 1425 37 now now RB 31417 1425 38 a a DT 31417 1425 39 thousand thousand CD 31417 1425 40 times time NNS 31417 1425 41 more more RBR 31417 1425 42 so so RB 31417 1425 43 .... .... NFP 31417 1425 44 " " '' 31417 1425 45 In in IN 31417 1425 46 the the DT 31417 1425 47 foregoing foregoing NN 31417 1425 48 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1425 49 have have VBP 31417 1425 50 confined confine VBN 31417 1425 51 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1425 52 as as RB 31417 1425 53 closely closely RB 31417 1425 54 as as IN 31417 1425 55 possible possible JJ 31417 1425 56 to to IN 31417 1425 57 narrating narrate VBG 31417 1425 58 how how WRB 31417 1425 59 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1425 60 conducted conduct VBD 31417 1425 61 a a DT 31417 1425 62 photographic photographic JJ 31417 1425 63 experiment experiment NN 31417 1425 64 open open JJ 31417 1425 65 to to IN 31417 1425 66 every every DT 31417 1425 67 one one NN 31417 1425 68 to to TO 31417 1425 69 make make VB 31417 1425 70 , , , 31417 1425 71 avoiding avoid VBG 31417 1425 72 stating state VBG 31417 1425 73 any any DT 31417 1425 74 hypothesis hypothesis NN 31417 1425 75 or or CC 31417 1425 76 belief belief NN 31417 1425 77 of of IN 31417 1425 78 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1425 79 own own JJ 31417 1425 80 on on IN 31417 1425 81 the the DT 31417 1425 82 subject subject NN 31417 1425 83 . . . 31417 1425 84 " " '' 31417 1426 1 Two two CD 31417 1426 2 years year NNS 31417 1426 3 later later RB 31417 1426 4 , , , 31417 1426 5 in in IN 31417 1426 6 May May NNP 31417 1426 7 1895 1895 CD 31417 1426 8 , , , 31417 1426 9 the the DT 31417 1426 10 spiritualists spiritualist NNS 31417 1426 11 held hold VBD 31417 1426 12 a a DT 31417 1426 13 General General NNP 31417 1426 14 Conference Conference NNP 31417 1426 15 in in IN 31417 1426 16 London London NNP 31417 1426 17 , , , 31417 1426 18 the the DT 31417 1426 19 proceedings proceeding NNS 31417 1426 20 of of IN 31417 1426 21 which which WDT 31417 1426 22 extended extend VBD 31417 1426 23 over over IN 31417 1426 24 several several JJ 31417 1426 25 days day NNS 31417 1426 26 . . . 31417 1427 1 At at IN 31417 1427 2 one one CD 31417 1427 3 of of IN 31417 1427 4 the the DT 31417 1427 5 meetings meeting NNS 31417 1427 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1427 7 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1427 8 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1427 9 read read VBD 31417 1427 10 a a DT 31417 1427 11 paper paper NN 31417 1427 12 under under IN 31417 1427 13 the the DT 31417 1427 14 title--"Are title--"Are NNP 31417 1427 15 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1427 16 Photographs Photographs NNPS 31417 1427 17 necessarily necessarily RB 31417 1427 18 the the DT 31417 1427 19 Photographs Photographs NNPS 31417 1427 20 of of IN 31417 1427 21 Spirits Spirits NNPS 31417 1427 22 ? ? . 31417 1427 23 " " '' 31417 1428 1 An an DT 31417 1428 2 abstract abstract NN 31417 1428 3 of of IN 31417 1428 4 this this DT 31417 1428 5 paper paper NN 31417 1428 6 appears appear VBZ 31417 1428 7 in in IN 31417 1428 8 _ _ NNP 31417 1428 9 Light Light NNP 31417 1428 10 _ _ NNP 31417 1428 11 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1428 12 18th 18th JJ 31417 1428 13 May May NNP 31417 1428 14 1895 1895 CD 31417 1428 15 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1428 16 , , , 31417 1428 17 and and CC 31417 1428 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1428 19 is be VBZ 31417 1428 20 printed print VBN 31417 1428 21 in in IN 31417 1428 22 full full JJ 31417 1428 23 in in IN 31417 1428 24 _ _ NNP 31417 1428 25 Borderland Borderland NNP 31417 1428 26 _ _ NNP 31417 1428 27 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1428 28 July July NNP 31417 1428 29 1895 1895 CD 31417 1428 30 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1428 31 . . . 31417 1429 1 At at IN 31417 1429 2 the the DT 31417 1429 3 commencement commencement NN 31417 1429 4 of of IN 31417 1429 5 the the DT 31417 1429 6 paper paper NN 31417 1429 7 , , , 31417 1429 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1429 9 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1429 10 explained explain VBD 31417 1429 11 that that IN 31417 1429 12 light light NN 31417 1429 13 is be VBZ 31417 1429 14 the the DT 31417 1429 15 agent agent NN 31417 1429 16 in in IN 31417 1429 17 the the DT 31417 1429 18 production production NN 31417 1429 19 of of IN 31417 1429 20 an an DT 31417 1429 21 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1429 22 photograph photograph NN 31417 1429 23 ; ; : 31417 1429 24 but but CC 31417 1429 25 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1429 26 says say VBZ 31417 1429 27 : : : 31417 1429 28 " " `` 31417 1429 29 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1429 30 have have VBP 31417 1429 31 ascertained ascertain VBN 31417 1429 32 , , , 31417 1429 33 to to IN 31417 1429 34 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1429 35 own own JJ 31417 1429 36 satisfaction satisfaction NN 31417 1429 37 at at IN 31417 1429 38 any any DT 31417 1429 39 rate rate NN 31417 1429 40 , , , 31417 1429 41 that that DT 31417 1429 42 light light NN 31417 1429 43 so so RB 31417 1429 44 called call VBD 31417 1429 45 , , , 31417 1429 46 so so RB 31417 1429 47 far far RB 31417 1429 48 as as IN 31417 1429 49 concerns concern NNS 31417 1429 50 the the DT 31417 1429 51 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1429 52 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1429 53 have have VBP 31417 1429 54 made make VBN 31417 1429 55 , , , 31417 1429 56 has have VBZ 31417 1429 57 nothing nothing NN 31417 1429 58 to to TO 31417 1429 59 do do VB 31417 1429 60 with with IN 31417 1429 61 the the DT 31417 1429 62 production production NN 31417 1429 63 of of IN 31417 1429 64 a a DT 31417 1429 65 psychic psychic JJ 31417 1429 66 picture picture NN 31417 1429 67 , , , 31417 1429 68 and and CC 31417 1429 69 that that IN 31417 1429 70 the the DT 31417 1429 71 lens lens NN 31417 1429 72 and and CC 31417 1429 73 camera camera NN 31417 1429 74 of of IN 31417 1429 75 the the DT 31417 1429 76 photographer photographer NN 31417 1429 77 are be VBP 31417 1429 78 consequently consequently RB 31417 1429 79 useless useless JJ 31417 1429 80 incumbrances incumbrance NNS 31417 1429 81 . . . 31417 1429 82 " " '' 31417 1430 1 Following follow VBG 31417 1430 2 this this DT 31417 1430 3 up up RP 31417 1430 4 , , , 31417 1430 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1430 6 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1430 7 says say VBZ 31417 1430 8 : : : 31417 1430 9 " " `` 31417 1430 10 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1430 11 was be VBD 31417 1430 12 the the DT 31417 1430 13 realisation realisation NN 31417 1430 14 of of IN 31417 1430 15 this this DT 31417 1430 16 that that WDT 31417 1430 17 enabled enable VBD 31417 1430 18 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1430 19 at at IN 31417 1430 20 a a DT 31417 1430 21 certain certain JJ 31417 1430 22 seance seance NN 31417 1430 23 recently recently RB 31417 1430 24 held hold VBD 31417 1430 25 , , , 31417 1430 26 at at IN 31417 1430 27 which which WDT 31417 1430 28 many many JJ 31417 1430 29 cameras camera NNS 31417 1430 30 were be VBD 31417 1430 31 in in IN 31417 1430 32 requisition requisition NN 31417 1430 33 , , , 31417 1430 34 to to TO 31417 1430 35 obtain obtain VB 31417 1430 36 certain certain JJ 31417 1430 37 abnormal abnormal JJ 31417 1430 38 figures figure NNS 31417 1430 39 on on IN 31417 1430 40 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1430 41 plates plate NNS 31417 1430 42 when when WRB 31417 1430 43 all all DT 31417 1430 44 others other NNS 31417 1430 45 failed fail VBD 31417 1430 46 to to TO 31417 1430 47 do do VB 31417 1430 48 so so RB 31417 1430 49 . . . 31417 1431 1 After after IN 31417 1431 2 withdrawing withdraw VBG 31417 1431 3 the the DT 31417 1431 4 slide slide NN 31417 1431 5 from from IN 31417 1431 6 the the DT 31417 1431 7 camera camera NN 31417 1431 8 , , , 31417 1431 9 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1431 10 wrapped wrap VBD 31417 1431 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1431 12 up up RP 31417 1431 13 in in IN 31417 1431 14 the the DT 31417 1431 15 velvet velvet NN 31417 1431 16 focussing focusse VBG 31417 1431 17 cloth cloth NN 31417 1431 18 and and CC 31417 1431 19 requested request VBD 31417 1431 20 the the DT 31417 1431 21 medium medium NN 31417 1431 22 to to TO 31417 1431 23 hold hold VB 31417 1431 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1431 25 in in IN 31417 1431 26 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1431 27 hand hand NN 31417 1431 28 , , , 31417 1431 29 giving give VBG 31417 1431 30 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1431 31 no no DT 31417 1431 32 clue clue NN 31417 1431 33 as as IN 31417 1431 34 to to IN 31417 1431 35 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1431 36 reason reason NN 31417 1431 37 for for IN 31417 1431 38 doing do VBG 31417 1431 39 so so RB 31417 1431 40 . . . 31417 1432 1 A a DT 31417 1432 2 general general JJ 31417 1432 3 conversation conversation NN 31417 1432 4 favoured favour VBD 31417 1432 5 the the DT 31417 1432 6 delay delay NN 31417 1432 7 in in IN 31417 1432 8 proceeding proceed VBG 31417 1432 9 to to IN 31417 1432 10 the the DT 31417 1432 11 developing develop VBG 31417 1432 12 room room NN 31417 1432 13 for for IN 31417 1432 14 about about RB 31417 1432 15 five five CD 31417 1432 16 or or CC 31417 1432 17 more more JJR 31417 1432 18 minutes minute NNS 31417 1432 19 , , , 31417 1432 20 during during IN 31417 1432 21 which which WDT 31417 1432 22 the the DT 31417 1432 23 medium medium NN 31417 1432 24 still still RB 31417 1432 25 held hold VBD 31417 1432 26 the the DT 31417 1432 27 wrapped wrap VBN 31417 1432 28 - - HYPH 31417 1432 29 up up RP 31417 1432 30 slide slide NN 31417 1432 31 . . . 31417 1433 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1433 2 then then RB 31417 1433 3 relieved relieve VBD 31417 1433 4 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1433 5 of of IN 31417 1433 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1433 7 , , , 31417 1433 8 and and CC 31417 1433 9 in in IN 31417 1433 10 the the DT 31417 1433 11 presence presence NN 31417 1433 12 of of IN 31417 1433 13 others other NNS 31417 1433 14 applied apply VBD 31417 1433 15 the the DT 31417 1433 16 developer developer NN 31417 1433 17 , , , 31417 1433 18 which which WDT 31417 1433 19 brought bring VBD 31417 1433 20 to to IN 31417 1433 21 view view NN 31417 1433 22 figures figure NNS 31417 1433 23 in in IN 31417 1433 24 addition addition NN 31417 1433 25 to to IN 31417 1433 26 that that DT 31417 1433 27 of of IN 31417 1433 28 the the DT 31417 1433 29 sitter sitter NN 31417 1433 30 . . . 31417 1433 31 " " '' 31417 1434 1 In in IN 31417 1434 2 making make VBG 31417 1434 3 a a DT 31417 1434 4 categorical categorical JJ 31417 1434 5 reply reply NN 31417 1434 6 to to IN 31417 1434 7 the the DT 31417 1434 8 question question NN 31417 1434 9 which which WDT 31417 1434 10 forms form VBZ 31417 1434 11 the the DT 31417 1434 12 title title NN 31417 1434 13 of of IN 31417 1434 14 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1434 15 paper paper NN 31417 1434 16 , , , 31417 1434 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1434 18 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1434 19 replies--"No"--and replies--"no"--and NN 31417 1434 20 gives give VBZ 31417 1434 21 various various JJ 31417 1434 22 " " `` 31417 1434 23 surmises surmise NNS 31417 1434 24 " " '' 31417 1434 25 to to TO 31417 1434 26 account account VB 31417 1434 27 for for IN 31417 1434 28 recognisable recognisable JJ 31417 1434 29 likenesses likeness NNS 31417 1434 30 having have VBG 31417 1434 31 been be VBN 31417 1434 32 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1434 33 . . . 31417 1435 1 At at IN 31417 1435 2 the the DT 31417 1435 3 end end NN 31417 1435 4 of of IN 31417 1435 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1435 6 paper paper NN 31417 1435 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1435 8 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1435 9 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1435 10 " " `` 31417 1435 11 The the DT 31417 1435 12 influence influence NN 31417 1435 13 of of IN 31417 1435 14 the the DT 31417 1435 15 mind mind NN 31417 1435 16 of of IN 31417 1435 17 the the DT 31417 1435 18 medium medium NN 31417 1435 19 in in IN 31417 1435 20 the the DT 31417 1435 21 obtaining obtaining NN 31417 1435 22 of of IN 31417 1435 23 psychographs psychograph NNS 31417 1435 24 might may MD 31417 1435 25 be be VB 31417 1435 26 deduced deduce VBN 31417 1435 27 from from IN 31417 1435 28 the the DT 31417 1435 29 fact fact NN 31417 1435 30 of of IN 31417 1435 31 pictures picture NNS 31417 1435 32 having have VBG 31417 1435 33 been be VBN 31417 1435 34 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1435 35 of of IN 31417 1435 36 angels angel NNS 31417 1435 37 with with IN 31417 1435 38 wings wing NNS 31417 1435 39 , , , 31417 1435 40 a a DT 31417 1435 41 still still RB 31417 1435 42 popular popular JJ 31417 1435 43 belief belief NN 31417 1435 44 of of IN 31417 1435 45 some some DT 31417 1435 46 , , , 31417 1435 47 as as IN 31417 1435 48 ridiculous ridiculous JJ 31417 1435 49 in in IN 31417 1435 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1435 51 conception conception NN 31417 1435 52 as as IN 31417 1435 53 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1435 54 is be VBZ 31417 1435 55 false false JJ 31417 1435 56 in in IN 31417 1435 57 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1435 58 anatomy anatomy NN 31417 1435 59 , , , 31417 1435 60 but but CC 31417 1435 61 still still RB 31417 1435 62 no no RB 31417 1435 63 less less RBR 31417 1435 64 true true JJ 31417 1435 65 in in IN 31417 1435 66 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1435 67 photo photo NN 31417 1435 68 - - HYPH 31417 1435 69 pictorial pictorial JJ 31417 1435 70 outcome outcome NN 31417 1435 71 . . . 31417 1436 1 This this DT 31417 1436 2 does do VBZ 31417 1436 3 not not RB 31417 1436 4 in in IN 31417 1436 5 the the DT 31417 1436 6 slightest slight JJS 31417 1436 7 degree degree NN 31417 1436 8 impair impair VBP 31417 1436 9 the the DT 31417 1436 10 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1436 11 and and CC 31417 1436 12 honesty honesty NN 31417 1436 13 of of IN 31417 1436 14 the the DT 31417 1436 15 medium medium NN 31417 1436 16 , , , 31417 1436 17 but but CC 31417 1436 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1436 19 inspires inspire VBZ 31417 1436 20 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1436 21 , , , 31417 1436 22 a a DT 31417 1436 23 disbeliever disbeliever NN 31417 1436 24 in in IN 31417 1436 25 the the DT 31417 1436 26 wing wing NN 31417 1436 27 notion notion NN 31417 1436 28 , , , 31417 1436 29 with with IN 31417 1436 30 the the DT 31417 1436 31 belief belief NN 31417 1436 32 that that IN 31417 1436 33 spirit spirit NN 31417 1436 34 - - HYPH 31417 1436 35 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1436 36 are be VBP 31417 1436 37 not not RB 31417 1436 38 necessarily necessarily RB 31417 1436 39 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1436 40 of of IN 31417 1436 41 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1436 42 . . . 31417 1437 1 " " `` 31417 1437 2 A a DT 31417 1437 3 concluding conclude VBG 31417 1437 4 word word NN 31417 1437 5 : : : 31417 1437 6 A a DT 31417 1437 7 medium medium NN 31417 1437 8 may may MD 31417 1437 9 , , , 31417 1437 10 on on IN 31417 1437 11 passing pass VBG 31417 1437 12 through through IN 31417 1437 13 a a DT 31417 1437 14 picture picture NN 31417 1437 15 gallery gallery NN 31417 1437 16 , , , 31417 1437 17 become become VBN 31417 1437 18 impressed impressed JJ 31417 1437 19 by by IN 31417 1437 20 some some DT 31417 1437 21 picture picture NN 31417 1437 22 which which WDT 31417 1437 23 , , , 31417 1437 24 although although IN 31417 1437 25 forgotten forget VBN 31417 1437 26 soon soon RB 31417 1437 27 after after RB 31417 1437 28 , , , 31417 1437 29 may may MD 31417 1437 30 yet yet RB 31417 1437 31 make make VB 31417 1437 32 a a DT 31417 1437 33 persistent persistent JJ 31417 1437 34 appearance appearance NN 31417 1437 35 on on IN 31417 1437 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1437 37 negative negative NN 31417 1437 38 on on IN 31417 1437 39 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 1437 40 occasions occasion NNS 31417 1437 41 . . . 31417 1438 1 My -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1438 2 caution caution NN 31417 1438 3 is be VBZ 31417 1438 4 that that IN 31417 1438 5 if if IN 31417 1438 6 such such JJ 31417 1438 7 be be VB 31417 1438 8 published publish VBN 31417 1438 9 as as IN 31417 1438 10 a a DT 31417 1438 11 spirit spirit NNP 31417 1438 12 photograph photograph NN 31417 1438 13 , , , 31417 1438 14 care care NN 31417 1438 15 must must MD 31417 1438 16 be be VB 31417 1438 17 taken take VBN 31417 1438 18 that that IN 31417 1438 19 no no DT 31417 1438 20 copyright copyright NN 31417 1438 21 of of IN 31417 1438 22 such such JJ 31417 1438 23 picture picture NN 31417 1438 24 is be VBZ 31417 1438 25 infringed infringe VBN 31417 1438 26 . . . 31417 1439 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1439 2 have have VBP 31417 1439 3 cases case NNS 31417 1439 4 of of IN 31417 1439 5 this this DT 31417 1439 6 nature nature NN 31417 1439 7 in in IN 31417 1439 8 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1439 9 mind mind NN 31417 1439 10 's 's POS 31417 1439 11 eye eye NN 31417 1439 12 , , , 31417 1439 13 but but CC 31417 1439 14 time time NN 31417 1439 15 does do VBZ 31417 1439 16 not not RB 31417 1439 17 permit permit VB 31417 1439 18 of of IN 31417 1439 19 this this DT 31417 1439 20 being be VBG 31417 1439 21 enlarged enlarge VBN 31417 1439 22 upon upon IN 31417 1439 23 , , , 31417 1439 24 else else RB 31417 1439 25 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1439 26 could could MD 31417 1439 27 have have VB 31417 1439 28 recited recite VBN 31417 1439 29 several several JJ 31417 1439 30 instances instance NNS 31417 1439 31 . . . 31417 1439 32 " " '' 31417 1440 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1440 2 would would MD 31417 1440 3 be be VB 31417 1440 4 extremely extremely RB 31417 1440 5 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1440 6 if if IN 31417 1440 7 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1440 8 could could MD 31417 1440 9 have have VB 31417 1440 10 had have VBN 31417 1440 11 these these DT 31417 1440 12 " " `` 31417 1440 13 several several JJ 31417 1440 14 instances instance NNS 31417 1440 15 " " '' 31417 1440 16 recited recite VBN 31417 1440 17 . . . 31417 1441 1 At at IN 31417 1441 2 all all DT 31417 1441 3 events event NNS 31417 1441 4 , , , 31417 1441 5 what what WP 31417 1441 6 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1441 7 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1441 8 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1441 9 says say VBZ 31417 1441 10 is be VBZ 31417 1441 11 suggestive suggestive JJ 31417 1441 12 , , , 31417 1441 13 and and CC 31417 1441 14 is be VBZ 31417 1441 15 well well RB 31417 1441 16 worth worth JJ 31417 1441 17 being be VBG 31417 1441 18 borne bear VBN 31417 1441 19 in in IN 31417 1441 20 mind mind NN 31417 1441 21 by by IN 31417 1441 22 any any DT 31417 1441 23 one one NN 31417 1441 24 investigating investigate VBG 31417 1441 25 the the DT 31417 1441 26 subject subject NN 31417 1441 27 . . . 31417 1442 1 Some some DT 31417 1442 2 careful careful JJ 31417 1442 3 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1442 4 have have VBP 31417 1442 5 been be VBN 31417 1442 6 made make VBN 31417 1442 7 of of IN 31417 1442 8 late late JJ 31417 1442 9 years year NNS 31417 1442 10 , , , 31417 1442 11 mostly mostly RB 31417 1442 12 , , , 31417 1442 13 so so RB 31417 1442 14 far far RB 31417 1442 15 as as IN 31417 1442 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1442 17 have have VBP 31417 1442 18 heard hear VBN 31417 1442 19 , , , 31417 1442 20 with with IN 31417 1442 21 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 31417 1442 22 , , , 31417 1442 23 or or CC 31417 1442 24 discouraging discouraging JJ 31417 1442 25 results result NNS 31417 1442 26 . . . 31417 1443 1 But but CC 31417 1443 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1443 3 am be VBP 31417 1443 4 not not RB 31417 1443 5 aware aware JJ 31417 1443 6 of of IN 31417 1443 7 any any DT 31417 1443 8 serious serious JJ 31417 1443 9 sustained sustained JJ 31417 1443 10 study study NN 31417 1443 11 of of IN 31417 1443 12 the the DT 31417 1443 13 question question NN 31417 1443 14 by by IN 31417 1443 15 any any DT 31417 1443 16 English english JJ 31417 1443 17 photographer photographer NN 31417 1443 18 since since IN 31417 1443 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1443 20 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1443 21 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1443 22 's 's POS 31417 1443 23 death death NN 31417 1443 24 . . . 31417 1444 1 CHAPTER chapter NN 31417 1444 2 XI XI NNP 31417 1444 3 THE the DT 31417 1444 4 SUMMING sum VBG 31417 1444 5 UP up RP 31417 1444 6 OF of IN 31417 1444 7 THE the DT 31417 1444 8 WHOLE whole JJ 31417 1444 9 MATTER matter NN 31417 1444 10 In in IN 31417 1444 11 the the DT 31417 1444 12 preceding precede VBG 31417 1444 13 chapters chapter NNS 31417 1444 14 the the DT 31417 1444 15 chief chief NN 31417 1444 16 endeavour endeavour NN 31417 1444 17 has have VBZ 31417 1444 18 been be VBN 31417 1444 19 to to TO 31417 1444 20 present present VB 31417 1444 21 the the DT 31417 1444 22 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1444 23 evidence evidence NN 31417 1444 24 in in IN 31417 1444 25 favour favour NN 31417 1444 26 of of IN 31417 1444 27 the the DT 31417 1444 28 reality reality NN 31417 1444 29 of of IN 31417 1444 30 a a DT 31417 1444 31 mass mass NN 31417 1444 32 of of IN 31417 1444 33 alleged alleged JJ 31417 1444 34 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1444 35 , , , 31417 1444 36 so so RB 31417 1444 37 far far RB 31417 1444 38 unrecognised unrecognised JJ 31417 1444 39 by by IN 31417 1444 40 science science NN 31417 1444 41 as as IN 31417 1444 42 facts fact NNS 31417 1444 43 . . . 31417 1445 1 The the DT 31417 1445 2 chief chief JJ 31417 1445 3 object object NN 31417 1445 4 is be VBZ 31417 1445 5 to to TO 31417 1445 6 arouse arouse VB 31417 1445 7 interest interest NN 31417 1445 8 , , , 31417 1445 9 and and CC 31417 1445 10 to to TO 31417 1445 11 excite excite VB 31417 1445 12 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1445 13 and and CC 31417 1445 14 investigation investigation NN 31417 1445 15 . . . 31417 1446 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1446 2 is be VBZ 31417 1446 3 difficult difficult JJ 31417 1446 4 to to TO 31417 1446 5 imagine imagine VB 31417 1446 6 a a DT 31417 1446 7 more more RBR 31417 1446 8 attractive attractive JJ 31417 1446 9 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 31417 1446 10 country country NN 31417 1446 11 than than IN 31417 1446 12 that that DT 31417 1446 13 which which WDT 31417 1446 14 lies lie VBZ 31417 1446 15 just just RB 31417 1446 16 outside outside IN 31417 1446 17 the the DT 31417 1446 18 realm realm NN 31417 1446 19 of of IN 31417 1446 20 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1446 21 science science NN 31417 1446 22 , , , 31417 1446 23 in in IN 31417 1446 24 the the DT 31417 1446 25 direction direction NN 31417 1446 26 of of IN 31417 1446 27 such such JJ 31417 1446 28 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1446 29 as as IN 31417 1446 30 have have VBP 31417 1446 31 been be VBN 31417 1446 32 under under IN 31417 1446 33 consideration consideration NN 31417 1446 34 . . . 31417 1447 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1447 2 is be VBZ 31417 1447 3 a a DT 31417 1447 4 country country NN 31417 1447 5 teeming teem VBG 31417 1447 6 with with IN 31417 1447 7 wonders wonder NNS 31417 1447 8 , , , 31417 1447 9 and and CC 31417 1447 10 with with IN 31417 1447 11 miraculous miraculous JJ 31417 1447 12 occurrences occurrence NNS 31417 1447 13 of of IN 31417 1447 14 endless endless JJ 31417 1447 15 variety variety NN 31417 1447 16 . . . 31417 1448 1 Miraculous miraculous JJ 31417 1448 2 to to IN 31417 1448 3 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1448 4 , , , 31417 1448 5 inasmuch inasmuch JJ 31417 1448 6 as as IN 31417 1448 7 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1448 8 are be VBP 31417 1448 9 not not RB 31417 1448 10 subject subject JJ 31417 1448 11 to to IN 31417 1448 12 any any DT 31417 1448 13 " " `` 31417 1448 14 Laws Laws NNPS 31417 1448 15 of of IN 31417 1448 16 Nature Nature NNP 31417 1448 17 " " '' 31417 1448 18 which which WDT 31417 1448 19 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1448 20 have have VBP 31417 1448 21 discovered discover VBN 31417 1448 22 . . . 31417 1449 1 The the DT 31417 1449 2 marvel marvel NN 31417 1449 3 is be VBZ 31417 1449 4 that that IN 31417 1449 5 there there EX 31417 1449 6 is be VBZ 31417 1449 7 not not RB 31417 1449 8 a a DT 31417 1449 9 rush rush NN 31417 1449 10 of of IN 31417 1449 11 explorers explorer NNS 31417 1449 12 into into IN 31417 1449 13 fields field NNS 31417 1449 14 incomparably incomparably RB 31417 1449 15 more more RBR 31417 1449 16 fascinating fascinating JJ 31417 1449 17 than than IN 31417 1449 18 North North NNP 31417 1449 19 or or CC 31417 1449 20 South South NNP 31417 1449 21 Pole Pole NNP 31417 1449 22 can can MD 31417 1449 23 present present VB 31417 1449 24 , , , 31417 1449 25 and and CC 31417 1449 26 containing contain VBG 31417 1449 27 more more JJR 31417 1449 28 treasure treasure NN 31417 1449 29 than than IN 31417 1449 30 gold gold NN 31417 1449 31 - - HYPH 31417 1449 32 fields field NNS 31417 1449 33 or or CC 31417 1449 34 diamond diamond NN 31417 1449 35 mines mine NNS 31417 1449 36 can can MD 31417 1449 37 ever ever RB 31417 1449 38 yield yield VB 31417 1449 39 . . . 31417 1450 1 The the DT 31417 1450 2 two two CD 31417 1450 3 chapters chapter NNS 31417 1450 4 devoted devote VBN 31417 1450 5 to to IN 31417 1450 6 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1450 7 occurring occur VBG 31417 1450 8 in in IN 31417 1450 9 the the DT 31417 1450 10 presence presence NN 31417 1450 11 of of IN 31417 1450 12 D. D. NNP 31417 1450 13 D. D. NNP 31417 1450 14 Home Home NNP 31417 1450 15 and and CC 31417 1450 16 W. W. NNP 31417 1450 17 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 1450 18 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1450 19 demand demand VBP 31417 1450 20 special special JJ 31417 1450 21 reference reference NN 31417 1450 22 . . . 31417 1451 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1451 2 is be VBZ 31417 1451 3 difficult difficult JJ 31417 1451 4 to to TO 31417 1451 5 imagine imagine VB 31417 1451 6 two two CD 31417 1451 7 men man NNS 31417 1451 8 differing differ VBG 31417 1451 9 more more RBR 31417 1451 10 widely widely RB 31417 1451 11 in in IN 31417 1451 12 almost almost RB 31417 1451 13 every every DT 31417 1451 14 respect respect NN 31417 1451 15 . . . 31417 1452 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1452 2 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1452 3 describes describe VBZ 31417 1452 4 the the DT 31417 1452 5 even even JJ 31417 1452 6 tenour tenour NN 31417 1452 7 of of IN 31417 1452 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1452 9 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 1452 10 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1452 11 ' ' POS 31417 1452 12 " " `` 31417 1452 13 straightforward straightforward JJ 31417 1452 14 and and CC 31417 1452 15 reputable reputable JJ 31417 1452 16 life life NN 31417 1452 17 " " '' 31417 1452 18 as as IN 31417 1452 19 " " `` 31417 1452 20 inwoven inwoven RB 31417 1452 21 with with IN 31417 1452 22 a a DT 31417 1452 23 chain chain NN 31417 1452 24 of of IN 31417 1452 25 mysteries mystery NNS 31417 1452 26 , , , 31417 1452 27 which which WDT 31417 1452 28 ... ... : 31417 1452 29 make make VBP 31417 1452 30 that that DT 31417 1452 31 life life NN 31417 1452 32 one one CD 31417 1452 33 of of IN 31417 1452 34 the the DT 31417 1452 35 most most RBS 31417 1452 36 extraordinary extraordinary JJ 31417 1452 37 which which WDT 31417 1452 38 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1452 39 century century NN 31417 1452 40 has have VBZ 31417 1452 41 seen see VBN 31417 1452 42 . . . 31417 1453 1 " " `` 31417 1453 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1453 3 66 66 CD 31417 1453 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1453 5 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1453 6 was be VBD 31417 1453 7 a a DT 31417 1453 8 scholar scholar NN 31417 1453 9 , , , 31417 1453 10 a a DT 31417 1453 11 literary literary JJ 31417 1453 12 man man NN 31417 1453 13 , , , 31417 1453 14 and and CC 31417 1453 15 a a DT 31417 1453 16 clergyman clergyman NN 31417 1453 17 of of IN 31417 1453 18 the the DT 31417 1453 19 Church Church NNP 31417 1453 20 of of IN 31417 1453 21 England England NNP 31417 1453 22 . . . 31417 1454 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1454 2 had have VBD 31417 1454 3 no no DT 31417 1454 4 worldly worldly RB 31417 1454 5 ambition ambition NN 31417 1454 6 or or CC 31417 1454 7 fondness fondness NN 31417 1454 8 for for IN 31417 1454 9 what what WP 31417 1454 10 is be VBZ 31417 1454 11 called call VBN 31417 1454 12 " " `` 31417 1454 13 Society Society NNP 31417 1454 14 . . . 31417 1454 15 " " '' 31417 1455 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1455 2 D. D. NNP 31417 1455 3 D. D. NNP 31417 1455 4 Home Home NNP 31417 1455 5 , , , 31417 1455 6 on on IN 31417 1455 7 the the DT 31417 1455 8 contrary contrary NN 31417 1455 9 , , , 31417 1455 10 does do VBZ 31417 1455 11 not not RB 31417 1455 12 appear appear VB 31417 1455 13 to to TO 31417 1455 14 have have VB 31417 1455 15 been be VBN 31417 1455 16 a a DT 31417 1455 17 man man NN 31417 1455 18 who who WP 31417 1455 19 could could MD 31417 1455 20 have have VB 31417 1455 21 been be VBN 31417 1455 22 termed term VBN 31417 1455 23 a a DT 31417 1455 24 religious religious JJ 31417 1455 25 character character NN 31417 1455 26 , , , 31417 1455 27 or or CC 31417 1455 28 spiritually spiritually RB 31417 1455 29 - - HYPH 31417 1455 30 minded minded JJ 31417 1455 31 , , , 31417 1455 32 nor nor CC 31417 1455 33 did do VBD 31417 1455 34 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1455 35 give give VB 31417 1455 36 evidence evidence NN 31417 1455 37 of of IN 31417 1455 38 intellectual intellectual JJ 31417 1455 39 talent talent NN 31417 1455 40 . . . 31417 1456 1 But but CC 31417 1456 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1456 3 had have VBD 31417 1456 4 gained gain VBN 31417 1456 5 access access NN 31417 1456 6 to to IN 31417 1456 7 some some DT 31417 1456 8 of of IN 31417 1456 9 the the DT 31417 1456 10 highest high JJS 31417 1456 11 society society NN 31417 1456 12 in in IN 31417 1456 13 Europe Europe NNP 31417 1456 14 . . . 31417 1457 1 And and CC 31417 1457 2 yet yet RB 31417 1457 3 both both DT 31417 1457 4 men man NNS 31417 1457 5 were be VBD 31417 1457 6 " " `` 31417 1457 7 mediums medium NNS 31417 1457 8 " " '' 31417 1457 9 for for IN 31417 1457 10 these these DT 31417 1457 11 curious curious JJ 31417 1457 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1457 13 , , , 31417 1457 14 to to IN 31417 1457 15 a a DT 31417 1457 16 wonderful wonderful JJ 31417 1457 17 extent extent NN 31417 1457 18 , , , 31417 1457 19 both both DT 31417 1457 20 as as IN 31417 1457 21 regards regard VBZ 31417 1457 22 the the DT 31417 1457 23 amount amount NN 31417 1457 24 and and CC 31417 1457 25 the the DT 31417 1457 26 variety variety NN 31417 1457 27 of of IN 31417 1457 28 the the DT 31417 1457 29 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 1457 30 . . . 31417 1458 1 Although although IN 31417 1458 2 the the DT 31417 1458 3 two two CD 31417 1458 4 men man NNS 31417 1458 5 were be VBD 31417 1458 6 so so RB 31417 1458 7 different different JJ 31417 1458 8 , , , 31417 1458 9 there there EX 31417 1458 10 is be VBZ 31417 1458 11 a a DT 31417 1458 12 parallelism parallelism NN 31417 1458 13 in in IN 31417 1458 14 the the DT 31417 1458 15 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1458 16 in in IN 31417 1458 17 so so RB 31417 1458 18 many many JJ 31417 1458 19 respects respect NNS 31417 1458 20 , , , 31417 1458 21 that that IN 31417 1458 22 a a DT 31417 1458 23 similar similar JJ 31417 1458 24 origin origin NN 31417 1458 25 or or CC 31417 1458 26 source source NN 31417 1458 27 seems seem VBZ 31417 1458 28 inevitably inevitably RB 31417 1458 29 suggested suggest VBN 31417 1458 30 . . . 31417 1459 1 There there EX 31417 1459 2 were be VBD 31417 1459 3 peculiarities peculiarity NNS 31417 1459 4 special special JJ 31417 1459 5 to to IN 31417 1459 6 each each DT 31417 1459 7 , , , 31417 1459 8 but but CC 31417 1459 9 untouched untouched JJ 31417 1459 10 movements movement NNS 31417 1459 11 of of IN 31417 1459 12 heavy heavy JJ 31417 1459 13 articles article NNS 31417 1459 14 , , , 31417 1459 15 " " `` 31417 1459 16 levitations levitation NNS 31417 1459 17 , , , 31417 1459 18 " " '' 31417 1459 19 lights light NNS 31417 1459 20 , , , 31417 1459 21 and and CC 31417 1459 22 sounds sound NNS 31417 1459 23 , , , 31417 1459 24 were be VBD 31417 1459 25 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1459 26 common common JJ 31417 1459 27 to to IN 31417 1459 28 both both DT 31417 1459 29 . . . 31417 1460 1 From from IN 31417 1460 2 whence whence NN 31417 1460 3 does do VBZ 31417 1460 4 this this DT 31417 1460 5 " " `` 31417 1460 6 chain chain NN 31417 1460 7 of of IN 31417 1460 8 mysteries mystery NNS 31417 1460 9 " " `` 31417 1460 10 come come VB 31417 1460 11 ? ? . 31417 1461 1 Is be VBZ 31417 1461 2 the the DT 31417 1461 3 source source NN 31417 1461 4 to to TO 31417 1461 5 be be VB 31417 1461 6 sought seek VBN 31417 1461 7 for for IN 31417 1461 8 in in IN 31417 1461 9 undiscovered undiscovered JJ 31417 1461 10 powers power NNS 31417 1461 11 and and CC 31417 1461 12 faculties faculty NNS 31417 1461 13 of of IN 31417 1461 14 the the DT 31417 1461 15 men man NNS 31417 1461 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1461 17 , , , 31417 1461 18 or or CC 31417 1461 19 in in IN 31417 1461 20 the the DT 31417 1461 21 action action NN 31417 1461 22 of of IN 31417 1461 23 other other JJ 31417 1461 24 intelligences intelligence NNS 31417 1461 25 ? ? . 31417 1462 1 That that DT 31417 1462 2 is be VBZ 31417 1462 3 a a DT 31417 1462 4 problem problem NN 31417 1462 5 which which WDT 31417 1462 6 must must MD 31417 1462 7 be be VB 31417 1462 8 left leave VBN 31417 1462 9 . . . 31417 1463 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1463 2 is be VBZ 31417 1463 3 outside outside IN 31417 1463 4 the the DT 31417 1463 5 scope scope NN 31417 1463 6 of of IN 31417 1463 7 this this DT 31417 1463 8 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1463 9 , , , 31417 1463 10 which which WDT 31417 1463 11 deals deal VBZ 31417 1463 12 solely solely RB 31417 1463 13 with with IN 31417 1463 14 the the DT 31417 1463 15 establishment establishment NN 31417 1463 16 of of IN 31417 1463 17 physical physical JJ 31417 1463 18 facts fact NNS 31417 1463 19 . . . 31417 1464 1 But but CC 31417 1464 2 where where WRB 31417 1464 3 can can MD 31417 1464 4 any any DT 31417 1464 5 other other JJ 31417 1464 6 field field NN 31417 1464 7 be be VB 31417 1464 8 found find VBN 31417 1464 9 of of IN 31417 1464 10 equal equal JJ 31417 1464 11 interest interest NN 31417 1464 12 ? ? . 31417 1465 1 Difficulties difficulty NNS 31417 1465 2 and and CC 31417 1465 3 perplexities perplexity NNS 31417 1465 4 meet meet VBP 31417 1465 5 the the DT 31417 1465 6 explorer explorer NN 31417 1465 7 in in IN 31417 1465 8 abundance abundance NN 31417 1465 9 . . . 31417 1466 1 But but CC 31417 1466 2 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1466 3 exist exist VBP 31417 1466 4 in in IN 31417 1466 5 order order NN 31417 1466 6 to to TO 31417 1466 7 be be VB 31417 1466 8 overcome overcome VBN 31417 1466 9 by by IN 31417 1466 10 the the DT 31417 1466 11 same same JJ 31417 1466 12 steady steady JJ 31417 1466 13 persistence persistence NN 31417 1466 14 which which WDT 31417 1466 15 has have VBZ 31417 1466 16 attained attain VBN 31417 1466 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1466 18 reward reward NN 31417 1466 19 in in IN 31417 1466 20 many many JJ 31417 1466 21 another another DT 31417 1466 22 direction direction NN 31417 1466 23 . . . 31417 1467 1 With with IN 31417 1467 2 regard regard NN 31417 1467 3 to to IN 31417 1467 4 two two CD 31417 1467 5 other other JJ 31417 1467 6 chapters chapter NNS 31417 1467 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1467 8 desire desire VBP 31417 1467 9 also also RB 31417 1467 10 to to TO 31417 1467 11 make make VB 31417 1467 12 a a DT 31417 1467 13 special special JJ 31417 1467 14 remark remark NN 31417 1467 15 -- -- : 31417 1467 16 those those DT 31417 1467 17 on on IN 31417 1467 18 " " `` 31417 1467 19 Materialisations materialisation NNS 31417 1467 20 " " '' 31417 1467 21 and and CC 31417 1467 22 " " `` 31417 1467 23 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1467 24 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1467 25 . . . 31417 1467 26 " " '' 31417 1468 1 Both both DT 31417 1468 2 are be VBP 31417 1468 3 physical physical JJ 31417 1468 4 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1468 5 . . . 31417 1469 1 But but CC 31417 1469 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1469 3 desire desire VBP 31417 1469 4 to to TO 31417 1469 5 make make VB 31417 1469 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1469 7 plain plain JJ 31417 1469 8 that that IN 31417 1469 9 no no DT 31417 1469 10 claim claim NN 31417 1469 11 is be VBZ 31417 1469 12 made make VBN 31417 1469 13 of of IN 31417 1469 14 being be VBG 31417 1469 15 able able JJ 31417 1469 16 to to TO 31417 1469 17 present present VB 31417 1469 18 evidence evidence NN 31417 1469 19 with with IN 31417 1469 20 regard regard NN 31417 1469 21 to to IN 31417 1469 22 either either DT 31417 1469 23 of of IN 31417 1469 24 these these DT 31417 1469 25 subjects subject NNS 31417 1469 26 which which WDT 31417 1469 27 should should MD 31417 1469 28 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1469 29 the the DT 31417 1469 30 reasonable reasonable JJ 31417 1469 31 demands demand NNS 31417 1469 32 of of IN 31417 1469 33 science science NN 31417 1469 34 . . . 31417 1470 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1470 2 may may MD 31417 1470 3 be be VB 31417 1470 4 asked ask VBN 31417 1470 5 -- -- : 31417 1470 6 Why why WRB 31417 1470 7 then then RB 31417 1470 8 introduce introduce VB 31417 1470 9 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1470 10 at at RB 31417 1470 11 all all RB 31417 1470 12 ? ? . 31417 1471 1 For for IN 31417 1471 2 two two CD 31417 1471 3 reasons reason NNS 31417 1471 4 : : : 31417 1471 5 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1471 6 1 1 LS 31417 1471 7 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1471 8 Because because IN 31417 1471 9 the the DT 31417 1471 10 evidence evidence NN 31417 1471 11 in in IN 31417 1471 12 favour favour NN 31417 1471 13 of of IN 31417 1471 14 both both DT 31417 1471 15 is be VBZ 31417 1471 16 only only RB 31417 1471 17 just just RB 31417 1471 18 outside outside IN 31417 1471 19 the the DT 31417 1471 20 boundary boundary NN 31417 1471 21 of of IN 31417 1471 22 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1471 23 demonstration demonstration NN 31417 1471 24 . . . 31417 1472 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1472 2 2 2 LS 31417 1472 3 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1472 4 Because because IN 31417 1472 5 of of IN 31417 1472 6 the the DT 31417 1472 7 extreme extreme JJ 31417 1472 8 interest interest NN 31417 1472 9 of of IN 31417 1472 10 the the DT 31417 1472 11 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 1472 12 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1472 13 . . . 31417 1473 1 As as IN 31417 1473 2 to to IN 31417 1473 3 " " `` 31417 1473 4 Materialisations materialisation NNS 31417 1473 5 . . . 31417 1473 6 " " '' 31417 1474 1 Out out IN 31417 1474 2 of of IN 31417 1474 3 an an DT 31417 1474 4 immense immense JJ 31417 1474 5 mass mass NN 31417 1474 6 of of IN 31417 1474 7 testimony testimony NN 31417 1474 8 , , , 31417 1474 9 most most JJS 31417 1474 10 of of IN 31417 1474 11 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1474 12 of of IN 31417 1474 13 no no DT 31417 1474 14 evidential evidential JJ 31417 1474 15 value value NN 31417 1474 16 , , , 31417 1474 17 one one CD 31417 1474 18 case case NN 31417 1474 19 has have VBZ 31417 1474 20 been be VBN 31417 1474 21 selected select VBN 31417 1474 22 where where WRB 31417 1474 23 more more JJR 31417 1474 24 than than IN 31417 1474 25 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1474 26 care care NN 31417 1474 27 seems seem VBZ 31417 1474 28 to to TO 31417 1474 29 have have VB 31417 1474 30 been be VBN 31417 1474 31 taken take VBN 31417 1474 32 . . . 31417 1475 1 But but CC 31417 1475 2 the the DT 31417 1475 3 phenomenon phenomenon NN 31417 1475 4 is be VBZ 31417 1475 5 so so RB 31417 1475 6 marvellous marvellous JJ 31417 1475 7 , , , 31417 1475 8 especially especially RB 31417 1475 9 in in IN 31417 1475 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1475 11 more more RBR 31417 1475 12 perfect perfect JJ 31417 1475 13 alleged allege VBN 31417 1475 14 phases phase NNS 31417 1475 15 , , , 31417 1475 16 when when WRB 31417 1475 17 the the DT 31417 1475 18 " " `` 31417 1475 19 materialised materialised JJ 31417 1475 20 " " '' 31417 1475 21 form form NN 31417 1475 22 is be VBZ 31417 1475 23 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1475 24 distinguishable distinguishable JJ 31417 1475 25 from from IN 31417 1475 26 a a DT 31417 1475 27 living live VBG 31417 1475 28 breathing breathing NN 31417 1475 29 human human JJ 31417 1475 30 being being NN 31417 1475 31 , , , 31417 1475 32 that that IN 31417 1475 33 the the DT 31417 1475 34 inquirer inquirer NN 31417 1475 35 is be VBZ 31417 1475 36 bound bind VBN 31417 1475 37 to to TO 31417 1475 38 hold hold VB 31417 1475 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1475 40 judgment judgment NN 31417 1475 41 in in IN 31417 1475 42 suspense suspense NN 31417 1475 43 until until IN 31417 1475 44 the the DT 31417 1475 45 last last JJ 31417 1475 46 possible possible JJ 31417 1475 47 moment moment NN 31417 1475 48 . . . 31417 1476 1 Again again RB 31417 1476 2 as as IN 31417 1476 3 to to IN 31417 1476 4 " " `` 31417 1476 5 Spirit Spirit NNP 31417 1476 6 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1476 7 . . . 31417 1476 8 " " '' 31417 1477 1 The the DT 31417 1477 2 term term NN 31417 1477 3 " " `` 31417 1477 4 Psychic Psychic NNP 31417 1477 5 Photography Photography NNP 31417 1477 6 " " '' 31417 1477 7 would would MD 31417 1477 8 be be VB 31417 1477 9 far far RB 31417 1477 10 preferable preferable JJ 31417 1477 11 , , , 31417 1477 12 as as IN 31417 1477 13 implying imply VBG 31417 1477 14 no no DT 31417 1477 15 theory theory NN 31417 1477 16 . . . 31417 1478 1 The the DT 31417 1478 2 experiences experience NNS 31417 1478 3 of of IN 31417 1478 4 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1478 5 J. J. NNP 31417 1478 6 Traill Traill NNP 31417 1478 7 Taylor Taylor NNP 31417 1478 8 , , , 31417 1478 9 which which WDT 31417 1478 10 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1478 11 have have VBP 31417 1478 12 selected select VBN 31417 1478 13 as as IN 31417 1478 14 the the DT 31417 1478 15 sole sole JJ 31417 1478 16 illustration illustration NN 31417 1478 17 , , , 31417 1478 18 appear appear VB 31417 1478 19 to to TO 31417 1478 20 leave leave VB 31417 1478 21 no no DT 31417 1478 22 moral moral JJ 31417 1478 23 doubt doubt NN 31417 1478 24 but but CC 31417 1478 25 that that IN 31417 1478 26 under under IN 31417 1478 27 certain certain JJ 31417 1478 28 circumstances circumstance NNS 31417 1478 29 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1478 30 are be VBP 31417 1478 31 produced produce VBN 31417 1478 32 which which WDT 31417 1478 33 known know VBN 31417 1478 34 laws law NNS 31417 1478 35 are be VBP 31417 1478 36 unable unable JJ 31417 1478 37 to to TO 31417 1478 38 explain explain VB 31417 1478 39 . . . 31417 1479 1 Definite definite JJ 31417 1479 2 and and CC 31417 1479 3 recognisable recognisable JJ 31417 1479 4 human human JJ 31417 1479 5 figures figure NNS 31417 1479 6 and and CC 31417 1479 7 faces face NNS 31417 1479 8 are be VBP 31417 1479 9 thus thus RB 31417 1479 10 obtained obtain VBN 31417 1479 11 . . . 31417 1480 1 But but CC 31417 1480 2 this this DT 31417 1480 3 is be VBZ 31417 1480 4 a a DT 31417 1480 5 very very RB 31417 1480 6 long long JJ 31417 1480 7 way way NN 31417 1480 8 from from IN 31417 1480 9 proving prove VBG 31417 1480 10 that that IN 31417 1480 11 " " `` 31417 1480 12 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1480 13 " " '' 31417 1480 14 sit sit VBP 31417 1480 15 or or CC 31417 1480 16 stand stand VB 31417 1480 17 before before IN 31417 1480 18 the the DT 31417 1480 19 camera camera NN 31417 1480 20 for for IN 31417 1480 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1480 22 photographs photograph NNS 31417 1480 23 to to TO 31417 1480 24 be be VB 31417 1480 25 taken take VBN 31417 1480 26 ! ! . 31417 1481 1 If if IN 31417 1481 2 some some DT 31417 1481 3 trained train VBN 31417 1481 4 experimenter experimenter NN 31417 1481 5 in in IN 31417 1481 6 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1481 7 research research NN 31417 1481 8 , , , 31417 1481 9 who who WP 31417 1481 10 possesses possess VBZ 31417 1481 11 an an DT 31417 1481 12 unbiassed unbiassed JJ 31417 1481 13 mind mind NN 31417 1481 14 , , , 31417 1481 15 would would MD 31417 1481 16 devote devote VB 31417 1481 17 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1481 18 for for IN 31417 1481 19 two two CD 31417 1481 20 or or CC 31417 1481 21 three three CD 31417 1481 22 years year NNS 31417 1481 23 to to IN 31417 1481 24 the the DT 31417 1481 25 study study NN 31417 1481 26 of of IN 31417 1481 27 either either DT 31417 1481 28 of of IN 31417 1481 29 these these DT 31417 1481 30 classes class NNS 31417 1481 31 of of IN 31417 1481 32 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1481 33 , , , 31417 1481 34 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1481 35 is be VBZ 31417 1481 36 almost almost RB 31417 1481 37 a a DT 31417 1481 38 certainty certainty NN 31417 1481 39 that that IN 31417 1481 40 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1481 41 would would MD 31417 1481 42 be be VB 31417 1481 43 richly richly RB 31417 1481 44 rewarded reward VBN 31417 1481 45 . . . 31417 1482 1 Is be VBZ 31417 1482 2 there there EX 31417 1482 3 no no DT 31417 1482 4 one one NN 31417 1482 5 who who WP 31417 1482 6 will will MD 31417 1482 7 enter enter VB 31417 1482 8 upon upon IN 31417 1482 9 the the DT 31417 1482 10 task task NN 31417 1482 11 ? ? . 31417 1483 1 There there EX 31417 1483 2 is be VBZ 31417 1483 3 one one CD 31417 1483 4 large large JJ 31417 1483 5 group group NN 31417 1483 6 of of IN 31417 1483 7 evidence evidence NN 31417 1483 8 , , , 31417 1483 9 embracing embrace VBG 31417 1483 10 most most JJS 31417 1483 11 of of IN 31417 1483 12 the the DT 31417 1483 13 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1483 14 which which WDT 31417 1483 15 have have VBP 31417 1483 16 been be VBN 31417 1483 17 under under IN 31417 1483 18 consideration consideration NN 31417 1483 19 , , , 31417 1483 20 from from IN 31417 1483 21 which which WDT 31417 1483 22 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1483 23 had have VBD 31417 1483 24 hoped hope VBN 31417 1483 25 to to TO 31417 1483 26 make make VB 31417 1483 27 copious copious JJ 31417 1483 28 selections selection NNS 31417 1483 29 , , , 31417 1483 30 with with IN 31417 1483 31 pleasure pleasure NN 31417 1483 32 to to IN 31417 1483 33 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1483 34 , , , 31417 1483 35 and and CC 31417 1483 36 with with IN 31417 1483 37 interest interest NN 31417 1483 38 to to IN 31417 1483 39 the the DT 31417 1483 40 reader reader NN 31417 1483 41 . . . 31417 1484 1 No no DT 31417 1484 2 living living NN 31417 1484 3 scientist scientist NN 31417 1484 4 has have VBZ 31417 1484 5 bestowed bestow VBN 31417 1484 6 so so RB 31417 1484 7 large large JJ 31417 1484 8 an an DT 31417 1484 9 amount amount NN 31417 1484 10 of of IN 31417 1484 11 study study NN 31417 1484 12 on on IN 31417 1484 13 " " `` 31417 1484 14 certain certain JJ 31417 1484 15 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1484 16 usually usually RB 31417 1484 17 termed term VBD 31417 1484 18 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1484 19 " " '' 31417 1484 20 as as IN 31417 1484 21 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1484 22 William William NNP 31417 1484 23 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1484 24 . . . 31417 1485 1 As as RB 31417 1485 2 long long RB 31417 1485 3 ago ago RB 31417 1485 4 as as IN 31417 1485 5 the the DT 31417 1485 6 year year NN 31417 1485 7 1874 1874 CD 31417 1485 8 , , , 31417 1485 9 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1485 10 William William NNP 31417 1485 11 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1485 12 gave give VBD 31417 1485 13 permission permission NN 31417 1485 14 for for IN 31417 1485 15 the the DT 31417 1485 16 reprint reprint NN 31417 1485 17 of of IN 31417 1485 18 a a DT 31417 1485 19 limited limited JJ 31417 1485 20 number number NN 31417 1485 21 of of IN 31417 1485 22 copies copy NNS 31417 1485 23 of of IN 31417 1485 24 various various JJ 31417 1485 25 articles article NNS 31417 1485 26 which which WDT 31417 1485 27 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1485 28 had have VBD 31417 1485 29 contributed contribute VBN 31417 1485 30 to to IN 31417 1485 31 the the DT 31417 1485 32 periodical periodical JJ 31417 1485 33 literature literature NN 31417 1485 34 of of IN 31417 1485 35 the the DT 31417 1485 36 day day NN 31417 1485 37 . . . 31417 1486 1 These these DT 31417 1486 2 , , , 31417 1486 3 with with IN 31417 1486 4 some some DT 31417 1486 5 other other JJ 31417 1486 6 original original JJ 31417 1486 7 matter matter NN 31417 1486 8 , , , 31417 1486 9 were be VBD 31417 1486 10 published publish VBN 31417 1486 11 under under IN 31417 1486 12 the the DT 31417 1486 13 title title NN 31417 1486 14 of of IN 31417 1486 15 " " `` 31417 1486 16 Researches Researches NNP 31417 1486 17 in in IN 31417 1486 18 the the DT 31417 1486 19 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 1486 20 of of IN 31417 1486 21 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 1486 22 . . . 31417 1486 23 " " '' 31417 1487 1 That that DT 31417 1487 2 volume volume NN 31417 1487 3 has have VBZ 31417 1487 4 long long RB 31417 1487 5 been be VBN 31417 1487 6 out out IN 31417 1487 7 of of IN 31417 1487 8 print print NN 31417 1487 9 . . . 31417 1488 1 In in IN 31417 1488 2 1890 1890 CD 31417 1488 3 , , , 31417 1488 4 an an DT 31417 1488 5 article article NN 31417 1488 6 by by IN 31417 1488 7 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1488 8 William William NNP 31417 1488 9 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1488 10 , , , 31417 1488 11 under under IN 31417 1488 12 the the DT 31417 1488 13 title title NN 31417 1488 14 of of IN 31417 1488 15 " " `` 31417 1488 16 Notes Notes NNPS 31417 1488 17 of of IN 31417 1488 18 Seances Seances NNPS 31417 1488 19 with with IN 31417 1488 20 D. D. NNP 31417 1488 21 D. D. NNP 31417 1488 22 Home Home NNP 31417 1488 23 , , , 31417 1488 24 " " '' 31417 1488 25 was be VBD 31417 1488 26 published publish VBN 31417 1488 27 in in IN 31417 1488 28 volume volume NN 31417 1488 29 vi vi NNP 31417 1488 30 . . . 31417 1489 1 of of IN 31417 1489 2 the the DT 31417 1489 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1489 4 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1489 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1489 6 of of IN 31417 1489 7 the the DT 31417 1489 8 Society Society NNP 31417 1489 9 for for IN 31417 1489 10 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1489 11 Research Research NNP 31417 1489 12 . . . 31417 1490 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1490 2 also also RB 31417 1490 3 referred refer VBD 31417 1490 4 to to IN 31417 1490 5 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1490 6 experiences experience NNS 31417 1490 7 with with IN 31417 1490 8 D. D. NNP 31417 1490 9 D. D. NNP 31417 1490 10 Home Home NNP 31417 1490 11 , , , 31417 1490 12 in in IN 31417 1490 13 two two CD 31417 1490 14 addresses address NNS 31417 1490 15 delivered deliver VBN 31417 1490 16 at at IN 31417 1490 17 meetings meeting NNS 31417 1490 18 of of IN 31417 1490 19 the the DT 31417 1490 20 Society Society NNP 31417 1490 21 in in IN 31417 1490 22 1894 1894 CD 31417 1490 23 and and CC 31417 1490 24 in in IN 31417 1490 25 1899 1899 CD 31417 1490 26 . . . 31417 1491 1 These these DT 31417 1491 2 are be VBP 31417 1491 3 reported report VBN 31417 1491 4 in in IN 31417 1491 5 the the DT 31417 1491 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1491 7 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1491 8 _ _ NNP 31417 1491 9 of of IN 31417 1491 10 the the DT 31417 1491 11 Society Society NNP 31417 1491 12 . . . 31417 1492 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1492 2 William William NNP 31417 1492 3 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1492 4 also also RB 31417 1492 5 devoted devote VBD 31417 1492 6 a a DT 31417 1492 7 portion portion NN 31417 1492 8 of of IN 31417 1492 9 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1492 10 address address NN 31417 1492 11 , , , 31417 1492 12 as as IN 31417 1492 13 President President NNP 31417 1492 14 of of IN 31417 1492 15 the the DT 31417 1492 16 British British NNP 31417 1492 17 Association Association NNP 31417 1492 18 in in IN 31417 1492 19 1898 1898 CD 31417 1492 20 , , , 31417 1492 21 to to IN 31417 1492 22 a a DT 31417 1492 23 reference reference NN 31417 1492 24 to to IN 31417 1492 25 the the DT 31417 1492 26 part part NN 31417 1492 27 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1492 28 took take VBD 31417 1492 29 many many JJ 31417 1492 30 years year NNS 31417 1492 31 before before RB 31417 1492 32 in in IN 31417 1492 33 psychical psychical JJ 31417 1492 34 research research NN 31417 1492 35 . . . 31417 1493 1 This this DT 31417 1493 2 portion portion NN 31417 1493 3 of of IN 31417 1493 4 the the DT 31417 1493 5 address address NN 31417 1493 6 was be VBD 31417 1493 7 reprinted reprint VBN 31417 1493 8 in in IN 31417 1493 9 volume volume NN 31417 1493 10 xiv xiv NN 31417 1493 11 . . . 31417 1494 1 of of IN 31417 1494 2 the the DT 31417 1494 3 _ _ NNP 31417 1494 4 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1494 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1494 6 of of IN 31417 1494 7 the the DT 31417 1494 8 Society Society NNP 31417 1494 9 . . . 31417 1495 1 Considerations consideration NNS 31417 1495 2 , , , 31417 1495 3 which which WDT 31417 1495 4 can can MD 31417 1495 5 not not RB 31417 1495 6 be be VB 31417 1495 7 entered enter VBN 31417 1495 8 into into IN 31417 1495 9 here here RB 31417 1495 10 , , , 31417 1495 11 compel compel VB 31417 1495 12 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1495 13 , , , 31417 1495 14 however however RB 31417 1495 15 , , , 31417 1495 16 to to TO 31417 1495 17 be be VB 31417 1495 18 content content JJ 31417 1495 19 with with IN 31417 1495 20 referring refer VBG 31417 1495 21 the the DT 31417 1495 22 reader reader NN 31417 1495 23 to to IN 31417 1495 24 the the DT 31417 1495 25 publications publication NNS 31417 1495 26 mentioned mention VBN 31417 1495 27 , , , 31417 1495 28 a a DT 31417 1495 29 study study NN 31417 1495 30 of of IN 31417 1495 31 which which WDT 31417 1495 32 will will MD 31417 1495 33 , , , 31417 1495 34 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1495 35 think think VBP 31417 1495 36 , , , 31417 1495 37 bring bring VBP 31417 1495 38 conviction conviction NN 31417 1495 39 that that IN 31417 1495 40 the the DT 31417 1495 41 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1495 42 evidence evidence NN 31417 1495 43 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1495 44 contain contain VBP 31417 1495 45 would would MD 31417 1495 46 , , , 31417 1495 47 even even RB 31417 1495 48 if if IN 31417 1495 49 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1495 50 stood stand VBD 31417 1495 51 alone alone JJ 31417 1495 52 , , , 31417 1495 53 be be VB 31417 1495 54 amply amply RB 31417 1495 55 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 1495 56 to to TO 31417 1495 57 prove prove VB 31417 1495 58 the the DT 31417 1495 59 reality reality NN 31417 1495 60 of of IN 31417 1495 61 the the DT 31417 1495 62 alleged allege VBN 31417 1495 63 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1495 64 . . . 31417 1496 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1496 2 67 67 CD 31417 1496 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1496 4 * * NFP 31417 1496 5 * * NFP 31417 1496 6 * * NFP 31417 1496 7 * * NFP 31417 1496 8 * * NFP 31417 1496 9 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1496 10 are be VBP 31417 1496 11 now now RB 31417 1496 12 warranted warrant VBN 31417 1496 13 in in IN 31417 1496 14 the the DT 31417 1496 15 assertion assertion NN 31417 1496 16 that that IN 31417 1496 17 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1496 18 have have VBP 31417 1496 19 arrived arrive VBN 31417 1496 20 at at IN 31417 1496 21 this this DT 31417 1496 22 position position NN 31417 1496 23 : : : 31417 1496 24 That that IN 31417 1496 25 the the DT 31417 1496 26 careful careful JJ 31417 1496 27 reader reader NN 31417 1496 28 is be VBZ 31417 1496 29 compelled compel VBN 31417 1496 30 to to TO 31417 1496 31 admit admit VB 31417 1496 32 that that IN 31417 1496 33 the the DT 31417 1496 34 evidence evidence NN 31417 1496 35 in in IN 31417 1496 36 favour favour NN 31417 1496 37 of of IN 31417 1496 38 a a DT 31417 1496 39 variety variety NN 31417 1496 40 of of IN 31417 1496 41 alleged alleged JJ 31417 1496 42 physical physical JJ 31417 1496 43 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1496 44 being be VBG 31417 1496 45 undoubted undoubted JJ 31417 1496 46 facts fact NNS 31417 1496 47 , , , 31417 1496 48 is be VBZ 31417 1496 49 too too RB 31417 1496 50 strong strong JJ 31417 1496 51 to to TO 31417 1496 52 be be VB 31417 1496 53 resisted resist VBN 31417 1496 54 . . . 31417 1497 1 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1497 2 are be VBP 31417 1497 3 accustomed accustomed JJ 31417 1497 4 to to TO 31417 1497 5 say say VB 31417 1497 6 in in IN 31417 1497 7 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1497 8 life life NN 31417 1497 9 , , , 31417 1497 10 the the DT 31417 1497 11 proof proof NN 31417 1497 12 of of IN 31417 1497 13 this this DT 31417 1497 14 or or CC 31417 1497 15 that that DT 31417 1497 16 is be VBZ 31417 1497 17 complete complete JJ 31417 1497 18 . . . 31417 1498 1 The the DT 31417 1498 2 man man NN 31417 1498 3 of of IN 31417 1498 4 science science NN 31417 1498 5 is be VBZ 31417 1498 6 accustomed accustom VBN 31417 1498 7 to to TO 31417 1498 8 say say VB 31417 1498 9 in in IN 31417 1498 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1498 11 own own JJ 31417 1498 12 sphere sphere NN 31417 1498 13 of of IN 31417 1498 14 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1498 15 , , , 31417 1498 16 the the DT 31417 1498 17 proof proof NN 31417 1498 18 of of IN 31417 1498 19 this this DT 31417 1498 20 or or CC 31417 1498 21 that that DT 31417 1498 22 is be VBZ 31417 1498 23 complete complete JJ 31417 1498 24 . . . 31417 1499 1 Applying apply VBG 31417 1499 2 the the DT 31417 1499 3 same same JJ 31417 1499 4 rules rule NNS 31417 1499 5 of of IN 31417 1499 6 evidence evidence NN 31417 1499 7 to to IN 31417 1499 8 physical physical JJ 31417 1499 9 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1499 10 generally generally RB 31417 1499 11 called call VBN 31417 1499 12 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1499 13 , , , 31417 1499 14 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1499 15 are be VBP 31417 1499 16 bound bind VBN 31417 1499 17 to to TO 31417 1499 18 admit admit VB 31417 1499 19 that that IN 31417 1499 20 in in IN 31417 1499 21 regard regard NN 31417 1499 22 to to IN 31417 1499 23 many many JJ 31417 1499 24 of of IN 31417 1499 25 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1499 26 the the DT 31417 1499 27 proof proof NN 31417 1499 28 of of IN 31417 1499 29 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1499 30 reality reality NN 31417 1499 31 is be VBZ 31417 1499 32 complete complete JJ 31417 1499 33 . . . 31417 1500 1 Yet yet CC 31417 1500 2 these these DT 31417 1500 3 facts fact NNS 31417 1500 4 are be VBP 31417 1500 5 not not RB 31417 1500 6 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1500 7 by by IN 31417 1500 8 the the DT 31417 1500 9 world world NN 31417 1500 10 of of IN 31417 1500 11 science science NN 31417 1500 12 , , , 31417 1500 13 and and CC 31417 1500 14 are be VBP 31417 1500 15 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1500 16 deemed deem VBN 31417 1500 17 worthy worthy JJ 31417 1500 18 of of IN 31417 1500 19 any any DT 31417 1500 20 serious serious JJ 31417 1500 21 attention attention NN 31417 1500 22 by by IN 31417 1500 23 the the DT 31417 1500 24 majority majority NN 31417 1500 25 of of IN 31417 1500 26 intelligent intelligent JJ 31417 1500 27 people people NNS 31417 1500 28 . . . 31417 1501 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1501 2 may may MD 31417 1501 3 be be VB 31417 1501 4 worth worth JJ 31417 1501 5 while while IN 31417 1501 6 to to TO 31417 1501 7 consider consider VB 31417 1501 8 for for IN 31417 1501 9 a a DT 31417 1501 10 few few JJ 31417 1501 11 moments moment NNS 31417 1501 12 the the DT 31417 1501 13 mode mode NN 31417 1501 14 in in IN 31417 1501 15 which which WDT 31417 1501 16 new new JJ 31417 1501 17 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1501 18 enters enter VBZ 31417 1501 19 the the DT 31417 1501 20 mind mind NN 31417 1501 21 . . . 31417 1502 1 By by IN 31417 1502 2 new new JJ 31417 1502 3 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1502 4 is be VBZ 31417 1502 5 meant mean VBN 31417 1502 6 not not RB 31417 1502 7 extension extension NN 31417 1502 8 of of IN 31417 1502 9 existing exist VBG 31417 1502 10 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1502 11 , , , 31417 1502 12 but but CC 31417 1502 13 facts fact NNS 31417 1502 14 of of IN 31417 1502 15 a a DT 31417 1502 16 new new JJ 31417 1502 17 order order NN 31417 1502 18 , , , 31417 1502 19 such such JJ 31417 1502 20 , , , 31417 1502 21 for for IN 31417 1502 22 instance instance NN 31417 1502 23 , , , 31417 1502 24 as as IN 31417 1502 25 the the DT 31417 1502 26 rising rise VBG 31417 1502 27 of of IN 31417 1502 28 a a DT 31417 1502 29 heavy heavy JJ 31417 1502 30 dining dining NN 31417 1502 31 table table NN 31417 1502 32 into into IN 31417 1502 33 the the DT 31417 1502 34 air air NN 31417 1502 35 without without IN 31417 1502 36 any any DT 31417 1502 37 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1502 38 physical physical JJ 31417 1502 39 cause cause NN 31417 1502 40 being be VBG 31417 1502 41 apparent apparent JJ 31417 1502 42 . . . 31417 1503 1 The the DT 31417 1503 2 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 1503 3 of of IN 31417 1503 4 admitting admit VBG 31417 1503 5 new new JJ 31417 1503 6 facts fact NNS 31417 1503 7 of of IN 31417 1503 8 this this DT 31417 1503 9 kind kind NN 31417 1503 10 to to IN 31417 1503 11 the the DT 31417 1503 12 mind mind NN 31417 1503 13 is be VBZ 31417 1503 14 not not RB 31417 1503 15 confined confine VBN 31417 1503 16 to to IN 31417 1503 17 any any DT 31417 1503 18 one one CD 31417 1503 19 class class NN 31417 1503 20 of of IN 31417 1503 21 people people NNS 31417 1503 22 . . . 31417 1504 1 Indeed indeed RB 31417 1504 2 the the DT 31417 1504 3 difficulty difficulty NN 31417 1504 4 appears appear VBZ 31417 1504 5 to to TO 31417 1504 6 be be VB 31417 1504 7 greater great JJR 31417 1504 8 in in IN 31417 1504 9 the the DT 31417 1504 10 case case NN 31417 1504 11 of of IN 31417 1504 12 highly highly RB 31417 1504 13 educated educate VBN 31417 1504 14 people people NNS 31417 1504 15 than than IN 31417 1504 16 among among IN 31417 1504 17 the the DT 31417 1504 18 comparatively comparatively RB 31417 1504 19 uninformed uninformed JJ 31417 1504 20 . . . 31417 1505 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1505 2 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1505 3 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1505 4 has have VBZ 31417 1505 5 recently recently RB 31417 1505 6 said say VBN 31417 1505 7 : : : 31417 1505 8 " " `` 31417 1505 9 What what WP 31417 1505 10 does do VBZ 31417 1505 11 a a DT 31417 1505 12 ' ' `` 31417 1505 13 proof proof NN 31417 1505 14 ' ' '' 31417 1505 15 mean mean NN 31417 1505 16 ? ? . 31417 1506 1 A a DT 31417 1506 2 proof proof NN 31417 1506 3 means mean VBZ 31417 1506 4 destroying destroy VBG 31417 1506 5 the the DT 31417 1506 6 isolation isolation NN 31417 1506 7 of of IN 31417 1506 8 an an DT 31417 1506 9 observed observed JJ 31417 1506 10 fact fact NN 31417 1506 11 or or CC 31417 1506 12 experience experience NN 31417 1506 13 by by IN 31417 1506 14 linking link VBG 31417 1506 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1506 16 on on RP 31417 1506 17 with with IN 31417 1506 18 all all DT 31417 1506 19 pre pre JJ 31417 1506 20 - - JJ 31417 1506 21 existent existent JJ 31417 1506 22 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1506 23 ; ; : 31417 1506 24 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1506 25 means mean VBZ 31417 1506 26 the the DT 31417 1506 27 bringing bring VBG 31417 1506 28 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1506 29 into into IN 31417 1506 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1506 31 place place NN 31417 1506 32 in in IN 31417 1506 33 the the DT 31417 1506 34 system system NN 31417 1506 35 of of IN 31417 1506 36 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1506 37 ; ; : 31417 1506 38 and and CC 31417 1506 39 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1506 40 affords afford VBZ 31417 1506 41 the the DT 31417 1506 42 same same JJ 31417 1506 43 sort sort NN 31417 1506 44 of of IN 31417 1506 45 gratification gratification NN 31417 1506 46 as as IN 31417 1506 47 finding find VBG 31417 1506 48 the the DT 31417 1506 49 right right JJ 31417 1506 50 place place NN 31417 1506 51 for for IN 31417 1506 52 a a DT 31417 1506 53 queer queer NN 31417 1506 54 - - HYPH 31417 1506 55 shaped shape VBN 31417 1506 56 piece piece NN 31417 1506 57 in in IN 31417 1506 58 a a DT 31417 1506 59 puzzle puzzle NN 31417 1506 60 - - HYPH 31417 1506 61 map map NN 31417 1506 62 . . . 31417 1507 1 Do do VB 31417 1507 2 not not RB 31417 1507 3 let let VB 31417 1507 4 these these DT 31417 1507 5 puzzle puzzle NN 31417 1507 6 - - HYPH 31417 1507 7 maps map NNS 31417 1507 8 go go VBP 31417 1507 9 out out IN 31417 1507 10 of of IN 31417 1507 11 fashion fashion NN 31417 1507 12 ; ; : 31417 1507 13 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1507 14 afford afford VBP 31417 1507 15 a a DT 31417 1507 16 most most RBS 31417 1507 17 useful useful JJ 31417 1507 18 psychological psychological JJ 31417 1507 19 illustration illustration NN 31417 1507 20 ; ; : 31417 1507 21 the the DT 31417 1507 22 foundation foundation NN 31417 1507 23 of of IN 31417 1507 24 every every DT 31417 1507 25 organised organised JJ 31417 1507 26 system system NN 31417 1507 27 of of IN 31417 1507 28 truth truth NN 31417 1507 29 is be VBZ 31417 1507 30 bound bind VBN 31417 1507 31 up up RP 31417 1507 32 with with IN 31417 1507 33 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1507 34 .... .... . 31417 1508 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1508 2 is be VBZ 31417 1508 3 because because IN 31417 1508 4 a a DT 31417 1508 5 number number NN 31417 1508 6 of of IN 31417 1508 7 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1508 8 , , , 31417 1508 9 such such JJ 31417 1508 10 as as IN 31417 1508 11 clairvoyance clairvoyance NN 31417 1508 12 , , , 31417 1508 13 physical physical JJ 31417 1508 14 movement movement NN 31417 1508 15 without without IN 31417 1508 16 contact contact NN 31417 1508 17 , , , 31417 1508 18 and and CC 31417 1508 19 other other JJ 31417 1508 20 apparent apparent JJ 31417 1508 21 abnormalities abnormality NNS 31417 1508 22 and and CC 31417 1508 23 unusualnesses unusualness NNS 31417 1508 24 , , , 31417 1508 25 can can MD 31417 1508 26 not not RB 31417 1508 27 at at IN 31417 1508 28 present present JJ 31417 1508 29 be be VB 31417 1508 30 linked link VBN 31417 1508 31 on on RP 31417 1508 32 with with IN 31417 1508 33 the the DT 31417 1508 34 rest rest NN 31417 1508 35 of of IN 31417 1508 36 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1508 37 in in IN 31417 1508 38 a a DT 31417 1508 39 coherent coherent JJ 31417 1508 40 stream stream NN 31417 1508 41 -- -- : 31417 1508 42 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1508 43 is be VBZ 31417 1508 44 for for IN 31417 1508 45 that that DT 31417 1508 46 reason reason NN 31417 1508 47 that that IN 31417 1508 48 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1508 49 are be VBP 31417 1508 50 not not RB 31417 1508 51 , , , 31417 1508 52 as as RB 31417 1508 53 yet yet RB 31417 1508 54 , , , 31417 1508 55 generally generally RB 31417 1508 56 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1508 57 as as RB 31417 1508 58 true true JJ 31417 1508 59 ; ; : 31417 1508 60 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1508 61 stand stand VBP 31417 1508 62 at at IN 31417 1508 63 present present JJ 31417 1508 64 outside outside IN 31417 1508 65 the the DT 31417 1508 66 realms realm NNS 31417 1508 67 of of IN 31417 1508 68 science science NN 31417 1508 69 ; ; : 31417 1508 70 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1508 71 will will MD 31417 1508 72 be be VB 31417 1508 73 presently presently RB 31417 1508 74 incorporated incorporate VBN 31417 1508 75 into into IN 31417 1508 76 that that DT 31417 1508 77 kingdom kingdom NN 31417 1508 78 , , , 31417 1508 79 and and CC 31417 1508 80 annexed annex VBN 31417 1508 81 by by IN 31417 1508 82 the the DT 31417 1508 83 progress progress NN 31417 1508 84 of of IN 31417 1508 85 discovery discovery NN 31417 1508 86 . . . 31417 1509 1 " " `` 31417 1509 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1509 3 68 68 CD 31417 1509 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1509 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1509 6 F. F. NNP 31417 1509 7 C. C. NNP 31417 1509 8 S. S. NNP 31417 1509 9 Schiller Schiller NNP 31417 1509 10 , , , 31417 1509 11 in in IN 31417 1509 12 an an DT 31417 1509 13 article article NN 31417 1509 14 in in IN 31417 1509 15 the the DT 31417 1509 16 _ _ NNP 31417 1509 17 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1509 18 _ _ NNP 31417 1509 19 of of IN 31417 1509 20 the the DT 31417 1509 21 Society Society NNP 31417 1509 22 for for IN 31417 1509 23 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1509 24 Research Research NNP 31417 1509 25 , , , 31417 1509 26 expresses express VBZ 31417 1509 27 a a DT 31417 1509 28 similar similar JJ 31417 1509 29 thought thought NN 31417 1509 30 in in IN 31417 1509 31 a a DT 31417 1509 32 different different JJ 31417 1509 33 manner manner NN 31417 1509 34 . . . 31417 1510 1 He -PRON- PRP 31417 1510 2 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1510 3 " " `` 31417 1510 4 A a DT 31417 1510 5 mind mind NN 31417 1510 6 unwilling unwilling JJ 31417 1510 7 to to TO 31417 1510 8 believe believe VB 31417 1510 9 , , , 31417 1510 10 or or CC 31417 1510 11 even even RB 31417 1510 12 undesirous undesirous JJ 31417 1510 13 to to TO 31417 1510 14 be be VB 31417 1510 15 instructed instruct VBN 31417 1510 16 , , , 31417 1510 17 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1510 18 weightiest weighty JJS 31417 1510 19 evidence evidence NN 31417 1510 20 must must MD 31417 1510 21 ever ever RB 31417 1510 22 fail fail VB 31417 1510 23 to to TO 31417 1510 24 impress impress VB 31417 1510 25 . . . 31417 1511 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1511 2 will will MD 31417 1511 3 insist insist VB 31417 1511 4 on on IN 31417 1511 5 taking take VBG 31417 1511 6 that that DT 31417 1511 7 evidence evidence NN 31417 1511 8 in in IN 31417 1511 9 bits bit NNS 31417 1511 10 , , , 31417 1511 11 and and CC 31417 1511 12 rejecting reject VBG 31417 1511 13 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1511 14 item item NN 31417 1511 15 by by IN 31417 1511 16 item item NN 31417 1511 17 . . . 31417 1512 1 The the DT 31417 1512 2 man man NN 31417 1512 3 therefore therefore RB 31417 1512 4 who who WP 31417 1512 5 announces announce VBZ 31417 1512 6 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1512 7 intention intention NN 31417 1512 8 of of IN 31417 1512 9 waiting wait VBG 31417 1512 10 until until IN 31417 1512 11 a a DT 31417 1512 12 single single JJ 31417 1512 13 absolutely absolutely RB 31417 1512 14 conclusive conclusive JJ 31417 1512 15 bit bit NN 31417 1512 16 of of IN 31417 1512 17 evidence evidence NN 31417 1512 18 turns turn VBZ 31417 1512 19 up up RP 31417 1512 20 , , , 31417 1512 21 is be VBZ 31417 1512 22 really really RB 31417 1512 23 a a DT 31417 1512 24 man man NN 31417 1512 25 _ _ NNP 31417 1512 26 not not RB 31417 1512 27 _ _ NNP 31417 1512 28 open open JJ 31417 1512 29 to to IN 31417 1512 30 conviction conviction NN 31417 1512 31 , , , 31417 1512 32 and and CC 31417 1512 33 if if IN 31417 1512 34 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1512 35 is be VBZ 31417 1512 36 a a DT 31417 1512 37 logician logician NN 31417 1512 38 , , , 31417 1512 39 _ _ NNP 31417 1512 40 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1512 41 knows know VBZ 31417 1512 42 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1512 43 _ _ NNP 31417 1512 44 . . . 31417 1513 1 For for IN 31417 1513 2 modern modern JJ 31417 1513 3 logic logic NN 31417 1513 4 has have VBZ 31417 1513 5 made make VBN 31417 1513 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1513 7 plain plain JJ 31417 1513 8 that that IN 31417 1513 9 single single JJ 31417 1513 10 facts fact NNS 31417 1513 11 can can MD 31417 1513 12 never never RB 31417 1513 13 be be VB 31417 1513 14 ' ' `` 31417 1513 15 proved prove VBN 31417 1513 16 , , , 31417 1513 17 ' ' '' 31417 1513 18 except except IN 31417 1513 19 by by IN 31417 1513 20 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1513 21 coherence coherence NN 31417 1513 22 in in IN 31417 1513 23 a a DT 31417 1513 24 system system NN 31417 1513 25 . . . 31417 1514 1 But but CC 31417 1514 2 as as IN 31417 1514 3 all all PDT 31417 1514 4 the the DT 31417 1514 5 facts fact NNS 31417 1514 6 come come VBP 31417 1514 7 singly singly RB 31417 1514 8 , , , 31417 1514 9 any any DT 31417 1514 10 one one NN 31417 1514 11 who who WP 31417 1514 12 dismisses dismiss VBZ 31417 1514 13 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1514 14 one one CD 31417 1514 15 by by IN 31417 1514 16 one one CD 31417 1514 17 , , , 31417 1514 18 is be VBZ 31417 1514 19 destroying destroy VBG 31417 1514 20 the the DT 31417 1514 21 conditions condition NNS 31417 1514 22 under under IN 31417 1514 23 which which WDT 31417 1514 24 the the DT 31417 1514 25 conviction conviction NN 31417 1514 26 of of IN 31417 1514 27 new new JJ 31417 1514 28 truth truth NN 31417 1514 29 could could MD 31417 1514 30 arise arise VB 31417 1514 31 in in IN 31417 1514 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1514 33 mind mind NN 31417 1514 34 . . . 31417 1515 1 " " `` 31417 1515 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1515 3 69 69 CD 31417 1515 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1515 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1515 6 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1515 7 , , , 31417 1515 8 in in IN 31417 1515 9 summing sum VBG 31417 1515 10 up up RP 31417 1515 11 the the DT 31417 1515 12 evidence evidence NN 31417 1515 13 in in IN 31417 1515 14 the the DT 31417 1515 15 case case NN 31417 1515 16 of of IN 31417 1515 17 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1515 18 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 1515 19 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1515 20 , , , 31417 1515 21 dwells dwell VBZ 31417 1515 22 on on IN 31417 1515 23 the the DT 31417 1515 24 importance importance NN 31417 1515 25 of of IN 31417 1515 26 simple simple JJ 31417 1515 27 repetition repetition NN 31417 1515 28 . . . 31417 1516 1 This this DT 31417 1516 2 , , , 31417 1516 3 though though IN 31417 1516 4 practically practically RB 31417 1516 5 effective effective JJ 31417 1516 6 , , , 31417 1516 7 is be VBZ 31417 1516 8 scarcely scarcely RB 31417 1516 9 a a DT 31417 1516 10 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1516 11 consideration consideration NN 31417 1516 12 . . . 31417 1517 1 A a DT 31417 1517 2 fact fact NN 31417 1517 3 is be VBZ 31417 1517 4 none none NN 31417 1517 5 the the DT 31417 1517 6 less less RBR 31417 1517 7 a a DT 31417 1517 8 fact fact NN 31417 1517 9 on on IN 31417 1517 10 account account NN 31417 1517 11 of of IN 31417 1517 12 the the DT 31417 1517 13 rarity rarity NN 31417 1517 14 of of IN 31417 1517 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1517 16 occurrence occurrence NN 31417 1517 17 , , , 31417 1517 18 any any DT 31417 1517 19 more more JJR 31417 1517 20 than than IN 31417 1517 21 the the DT 31417 1517 22 existence existence NN 31417 1517 23 of of IN 31417 1517 24 a a DT 31417 1517 25 rare rare JJ 31417 1517 26 animal animal NN 31417 1517 27 or or CC 31417 1517 28 plant plant NN 31417 1517 29 is be VBZ 31417 1517 30 rendered render VBN 31417 1517 31 questionable questionable JJ 31417 1517 32 by by IN 31417 1517 33 the the DT 31417 1517 34 fewness fewness NN 31417 1517 35 of of IN 31417 1517 36 the the DT 31417 1517 37 number number NN 31417 1517 38 of of IN 31417 1517 39 specimens specimen NNS 31417 1517 40 which which WDT 31417 1517 41 have have VBP 31417 1517 42 been be VBN 31417 1517 43 found find VBN 31417 1517 44 . . . 31417 1518 1 An an DT 31417 1518 2 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1518 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 1518 4 might may MD 31417 1518 5 be be VB 31417 1518 6 written write VBN 31417 1518 7 under under IN 31417 1518 8 the the DT 31417 1518 9 title title NN 31417 1518 10 of of IN 31417 1518 11 " " `` 31417 1518 12 The the DT 31417 1518 13 History history NN 31417 1518 14 of of IN 31417 1518 15 the the DT 31417 1518 16 Growth growth NN 31417 1518 17 in in IN 31417 1518 18 the the DT 31417 1518 19 Belief Belief NNP 31417 1518 20 in in IN 31417 1518 21 Hypnotism Hypnotism NNP 31417 1518 22 during during IN 31417 1518 23 the the DT 31417 1518 24 last last JJ 31417 1518 25 Twenty twenty CD 31417 1518 26 - - HYPH 31417 1518 27 five five CD 31417 1518 28 Years year NNS 31417 1518 29 . . . 31417 1518 30 " " '' 31417 1519 1 One one CD 31417 1519 2 episode episode NN 31417 1519 3 that that WDT 31417 1519 4 would would MD 31417 1519 5 be be VB 31417 1519 6 included include VBN 31417 1519 7 in in IN 31417 1519 8 such such PDT 31417 1519 9 a a DT 31417 1519 10 history history NN 31417 1519 11 may may MD 31417 1519 12 be be VB 31417 1519 13 worth worth JJ 31417 1519 14 quoting quote VBG 31417 1519 15 here here RB 31417 1519 16 as as IN 31417 1519 17 illustrating illustrate VBG 31417 1519 18 the the DT 31417 1519 19 present present JJ 31417 1519 20 subject subject NN 31417 1519 21 . . . 31417 1520 1 As as RB 31417 1520 2 recently recently RB 31417 1520 3 as as IN 31417 1520 4 1891 1891 CD 31417 1520 5 , , , 31417 1520 6 the the DT 31417 1520 7 British British NNP 31417 1520 8 Medical Medical NNP 31417 1520 9 Association Association NNP 31417 1520 10 appointed appoint VBD 31417 1520 11 a a DT 31417 1520 12 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1520 13 , , , 31417 1520 14 consisting consist VBG 31417 1520 15 of of IN 31417 1520 16 eleven eleven CD 31417 1520 17 of of IN 31417 1520 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1520 19 number number NN 31417 1520 20 , , , 31417 1520 21 " " '' 31417 1520 22 to to TO 31417 1520 23 investigate investigate VB 31417 1520 24 the the DT 31417 1520 25 nature nature NN 31417 1520 26 of of IN 31417 1520 27 the the DT 31417 1520 28 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1520 29 of of IN 31417 1520 30 hypnotism hypnotism NN 31417 1520 31 , , , 31417 1520 32 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1520 33 value value NN 31417 1520 34 as as IN 31417 1520 35 a a DT 31417 1520 36 therapeutic therapeutic JJ 31417 1520 37 agent agent NN 31417 1520 38 , , , 31417 1520 39 and and CC 31417 1520 40 the the DT 31417 1520 41 propriety propriety NN 31417 1520 42 of of IN 31417 1520 43 using use VBG 31417 1520 44 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1520 45 . . . 31417 1520 46 " " '' 31417 1521 1 This this DT 31417 1521 2 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1521 3 presented present VBD 31417 1521 4 a a DT 31417 1521 5 Report report NN 31417 1521 6 at at IN 31417 1521 7 the the DT 31417 1521 8 Annual Annual NNP 31417 1521 9 Meeting Meeting NNP 31417 1521 10 in in IN 31417 1521 11 the the DT 31417 1521 12 following following JJ 31417 1521 13 year year NN 31417 1521 14 . . . 31417 1522 1 In in IN 31417 1522 2 the the DT 31417 1522 3 first first JJ 31417 1522 4 paragraph paragraph NN 31417 1522 5 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1522 6 solemnly solemnly RB 31417 1522 7 stated state VBD 31417 1522 8 that that IN 31417 1522 9 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1522 10 " " `` 31417 1522 11 have have VBP 31417 1522 12 satisfied satisfy VBN 31417 1522 13 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1522 14 of of IN 31417 1522 15 the the DT 31417 1522 16 genuineness genuineness NN 31417 1522 17 of of IN 31417 1522 18 the the DT 31417 1522 19 hypnotic hypnotic JJ 31417 1522 20 state state NN 31417 1522 21 " " '' 31417 1522 22 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1522 23 ! ! . 31417 1522 24 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1522 25 . . . 31417 1523 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1523 2 also also RB 31417 1523 3 expressed express VBD 31417 1523 4 the the DT 31417 1523 5 " " `` 31417 1523 6 opinion opinion NN 31417 1523 7 that that IN 31417 1523 8 as as IN 31417 1523 9 a a DT 31417 1523 10 therapeutic therapeutic JJ 31417 1523 11 agent agent NN 31417 1523 12 hypnotism hypnotism NN 31417 1523 13 is be VBZ 31417 1523 14 frequently frequently RB 31417 1523 15 effective effective JJ 31417 1523 16 in in IN 31417 1523 17 relieving relieve VBG 31417 1523 18 pain pain NN 31417 1523 19 , , , 31417 1523 20 procuring procure VBG 31417 1523 21 sleep sleep NN 31417 1523 22 , , , 31417 1523 23 and and CC 31417 1523 24 alleviating alleviate VBG 31417 1523 25 many many JJ 31417 1523 26 functional functional JJ 31417 1523 27 ailments ailment NNS 31417 1523 28 " " '' 31417 1523 29 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1523 30 ! ! . 31417 1523 31 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1523 32 . . . 31417 1524 1 They -PRON- PRP 31417 1524 2 are be VBP 31417 1524 3 also also RB 31417 1524 4 of of IN 31417 1524 5 opinion opinion NN 31417 1524 6 that that IN 31417 1524 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1524 8 " " `` 31417 1524 9 employment employment NN 31417 1524 10 for for IN 31417 1524 11 therapeutic therapeutic JJ 31417 1524 12 purposes purpose NNS 31417 1524 13 should should MD 31417 1524 14 be be VB 31417 1524 15 confined confine VBN 31417 1524 16 to to IN 31417 1524 17 qualified qualified JJ 31417 1524 18 medical medical JJ 31417 1524 19 men man NNS 31417 1524 20 . . . 31417 1524 21 " " '' 31417 1525 1 The the DT 31417 1525 2 Association Association NNP 31417 1525 3 referred refer VBD 31417 1525 4 this this DT 31417 1525 5 unanimous unanimous JJ 31417 1525 6 Report Report NNP 31417 1525 7 of of IN 31417 1525 8 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1525 9 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1525 10 back back RB 31417 1525 11 for for IN 31417 1525 12 further further JJ 31417 1525 13 consideration consideration NN 31417 1525 14 . . . 31417 1526 1 In in IN 31417 1526 2 1893 1893 CD 31417 1526 3 the the DT 31417 1526 4 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1526 5 presented present VBD 31417 1526 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1526 7 again again RB 31417 1526 8 , , , 31417 1526 9 with with IN 31417 1526 10 the the DT 31417 1526 11 addition addition NN 31417 1526 12 of of IN 31417 1526 13 an an DT 31417 1526 14 important important JJ 31417 1526 15 Appendix Appendix NNP 31417 1526 16 , , , 31417 1526 17 consisting consist VBG 31417 1526 18 of of IN 31417 1526 19 " " `` 31417 1526 20 some some DT 31417 1526 21 documentary documentary JJ 31417 1526 22 evidence evidence NN 31417 1526 23 upon upon IN 31417 1526 24 which which WDT 31417 1526 25 the the DT 31417 1526 26 Report Report NNP 31417 1526 27 was be VBD 31417 1526 28 based base VBN 31417 1526 29 . . . 31417 1526 30 " " '' 31417 1527 1 On on IN 31417 1527 2 this this DT 31417 1527 3 occasion occasion NN 31417 1527 4 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1527 5 was be VBD 31417 1527 6 moved move VBN 31417 1527 7 and and CC 31417 1527 8 seconded second VBN 31417 1527 9 , , , 31417 1527 10 that that IN 31417 1527 11 the the DT 31417 1527 12 Report Report NNP 31417 1527 13 should should MD 31417 1527 14 lie lie VB 31417 1527 15 on on IN 31417 1527 16 the the DT 31417 1527 17 table table NN 31417 1527 18 . . . 31417 1528 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1528 2 was be VBD 31417 1528 3 suggested suggest VBN 31417 1528 4 that that IN 31417 1528 5 the the DT 31417 1528 6 amendment amendment NN 31417 1528 7 to to IN 31417 1528 8 this this DT 31417 1528 9 effect effect NN 31417 1528 10 be be VB 31417 1528 11 so so RB 31417 1528 12 altered altered JJ 31417 1528 13 as as IN 31417 1528 14 to to TO 31417 1528 15 read read VB 31417 1528 16 that that IN 31417 1528 17 the the DT 31417 1528 18 Report Report NNP 31417 1528 19 be be VB 31417 1528 20 received receive VBN 31417 1528 21 only only RB 31417 1528 22 , , , 31417 1528 23 and and CC 31417 1528 24 the the DT 31417 1528 25 Committee Committee NNP 31417 1528 26 thanked thank VBD 31417 1528 27 for for IN 31417 1528 28 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1528 29 services service NNS 31417 1528 30 . . . 31417 1529 1 Finally finally RB 31417 1529 2 , , , 31417 1529 3 a a DT 31417 1529 4 resolution resolution NN 31417 1529 5 to to IN 31417 1529 6 this this DT 31417 1529 7 effect effect NN 31417 1529 8 was be VBD 31417 1529 9 carried carry VBN 31417 1529 10 . . . 31417 1530 1 The the DT 31417 1530 2 most most RBS 31417 1530 3 strongly strongly RB 31417 1530 4 worded word VBN 31417 1530 5 recommendation recommendation NN 31417 1530 6 of of IN 31417 1530 7 the the DT 31417 1530 8 Report Report NNP 31417 1530 9 was be VBD 31417 1530 10 that that IN 31417 1530 11 some some DT 31417 1530 12 legal legal JJ 31417 1530 13 restriction restriction NN 31417 1530 14 should should MD 31417 1530 15 be be VB 31417 1530 16 placed place VBN 31417 1530 17 on on IN 31417 1530 18 public public JJ 31417 1530 19 exhibitions exhibition NNS 31417 1530 20 of of IN 31417 1530 21 hypnotic hypnotic JJ 31417 1530 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1530 23 . . . 31417 1531 1 This this DT 31417 1531 2 was be VBD 31417 1531 3 only only RB 31417 1531 4 twelve twelve CD 31417 1531 5 years year NNS 31417 1531 6 ago ago RB 31417 1531 7 , , , 31417 1531 8 and and CC 31417 1531 9 was be VBD 31417 1531 10 five five CD 31417 1531 11 or or CC 31417 1531 12 six six CD 31417 1531 13 years year NNS 31417 1531 14 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 1531 15 to to IN 31417 1531 16 the the DT 31417 1531 17 publication publication NN 31417 1531 18 of of IN 31417 1531 19 some some DT 31417 1531 20 of of IN 31417 1531 21 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1531 22 Edmund Edmund NNP 31417 1531 23 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1531 24 's 's POS 31417 1531 25 most most RBS 31417 1531 26 important important JJ 31417 1531 27 series series NN 31417 1531 28 of of IN 31417 1531 29 experiments experiment NNS 31417 1531 30 in in IN 31417 1531 31 hypnotism hypnotism NN 31417 1531 32 in in IN 31417 1531 33 the the DT 31417 1531 34 _ _ NNP 31417 1531 35 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1531 36 _ _ NNP 31417 1531 37 of of IN 31417 1531 38 the the DT 31417 1531 39 Society Society NNP 31417 1531 40 for for IN 31417 1531 41 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1531 42 Research Research NNP 31417 1531 43 . . . 31417 1532 1 The the DT 31417 1532 2 " " `` 31417 1532 3 reception reception NN 31417 1532 4 only only RB 31417 1532 5 " " '' 31417 1532 6 of of IN 31417 1532 7 the the DT 31417 1532 8 Report Report NNP 31417 1532 9 was be VBD 31417 1532 10 also also RB 31417 1532 11 two two CD 31417 1532 12 or or CC 31417 1532 13 three three CD 31417 1532 14 years year NNS 31417 1532 15 subsequent subsequent JJ 31417 1532 16 to to IN 31417 1532 17 a a DT 31417 1532 18 demonstration demonstration NN 31417 1532 19 of of IN 31417 1532 20 hypnotic hypnotic JJ 31417 1532 21 anæsthesia anæsthesia NN 31417 1532 22 which which WDT 31417 1532 23 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1532 24 J. J. NNP 31417 1532 25 Milne Milne NNP 31417 1532 26 Bramwell Bramwell NNP 31417 1532 27 gave give VBD 31417 1532 28 at at IN 31417 1532 29 Leeds Leeds NNPS 31417 1532 30 to to IN 31417 1532 31 a a DT 31417 1532 32 large large JJ 31417 1532 33 gathering gathering NN 31417 1532 34 of of IN 31417 1532 35 medical medical JJ 31417 1532 36 men man NNS 31417 1532 37 . . . 31417 1533 1 One one CD 31417 1533 2 result result NN 31417 1533 3 of of IN 31417 1533 4 that that DT 31417 1533 5 gathering gathering NN 31417 1533 6 was be VBD 31417 1533 7 that that IN 31417 1533 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1533 9 Bramwell Bramwell NNP 31417 1533 10 decided decide VBD 31417 1533 11 to to TO 31417 1533 12 abandon abandon VB 31417 1533 13 general general JJ 31417 1533 14 practice practice NN 31417 1533 15 and and CC 31417 1533 16 devote devote VB 31417 1533 17 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1533 18 to to IN 31417 1533 19 hypnotic hypnotic JJ 31417 1533 20 work work NN 31417 1533 21 . . . 31417 1534 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1534 2 Bramwell Bramwell NNP 31417 1534 3 says:-- says:-- ADD 31417 1534 4 " " `` 31417 1534 5 As as IN 31417 1534 6 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1534 7 was be VBD 31417 1534 8 well well RB 31417 1534 9 aware aware JJ 31417 1534 10 of of IN 31417 1534 11 the the DT 31417 1534 12 fate fate NN 31417 1534 13 that that WDT 31417 1534 14 had have VBD 31417 1534 15 awaited await VBN 31417 1534 16 earlier early JJR 31417 1534 17 pioneers pioneer NNS 31417 1534 18 in in IN 31417 1534 19 the the DT 31417 1534 20 same same JJ 31417 1534 21 movement movement NN 31417 1534 22 , , , 31417 1534 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1534 24 naturally naturally RB 31417 1534 25 expected expect VBD 31417 1534 26 to to TO 31417 1534 27 meet meet VB 31417 1534 28 with with IN 31417 1534 29 opposition opposition NN 31417 1534 30 and and CC 31417 1534 31 misrepresentation misrepresentation NN 31417 1534 32 . . . 31417 1535 1 These these DT 31417 1535 2 have have VBP 31417 1535 3 been be VBN 31417 1535 4 encountered encounter VBN 31417 1535 5 , , , 31417 1535 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1535 7 is be VBZ 31417 1535 8 true true JJ 31417 1535 9 ; ; : 31417 1535 10 but but CC 31417 1535 11 the the DT 31417 1535 12 friendly friendly JJ 31417 1535 13 help help NN 31417 1535 14 and and CC 31417 1535 15 encouragement encouragement NN 31417 1535 16 received receive VBN 31417 1535 17 have have VBP 31417 1535 18 been be VBN 31417 1535 19 immeasurably immeasurably RB 31417 1535 20 greater great JJR 31417 1535 21 . . . 31417 1536 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1536 2 have have VBP 31417 1536 3 also also RB 31417 1536 4 had have VBN 31417 1536 5 many many JJ 31417 1536 6 opportunities opportunity NNS 31417 1536 7 of of IN 31417 1536 8 placing place VBG 31417 1536 9 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1536 10 views view NNS 31417 1536 11 before before IN 31417 1536 12 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1536 13 professional professional JJ 31417 1536 14 brethren brother NNS 31417 1536 15 , , , 31417 1536 16 both both CC 31417 1536 17 by by IN 31417 1536 18 writing write VBG 31417 1536 19 and and CC 31417 1536 20 speaking speak VBG 31417 1536 21 ; ; : 31417 1536 22 " " `` 31417 1536 23 to to TO 31417 1536 24 which which WDT 31417 1536 25 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1536 26 Bramwell Bramwell NNP 31417 1536 27 somewhat somewhat RB 31417 1536 28 naively naively RB 31417 1536 29 adds--"opportunities adds--"opportunities : 31417 1536 30 all all PDT 31417 1536 31 the the DT 31417 1536 32 more more RBR 31417 1536 33 valued valued JJ 31417 1536 34 , , , 31417 1536 35 because because IN 31417 1536 36 almost almost RB 31417 1536 37 always always RB 31417 1536 38 unsolicited unsolicited JJ 31417 1536 39 . . . 31417 1537 1 " " `` 31417 1537 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1537 3 70 70 CD 31417 1537 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1537 5 An an DT 31417 1537 6 incident incident NN 31417 1537 7 which which WDT 31417 1537 8 occurred occur VBD 31417 1537 9 in in IN 31417 1537 10 connection connection NN 31417 1537 11 with with IN 31417 1537 12 the the DT 31417 1537 13 most most RBS 31417 1537 14 sensational sensational JJ 31417 1537 15 case case NN 31417 1537 16 of of IN 31417 1537 17 " " `` 31417 1537 18 levitation levitation NN 31417 1537 19 " " '' 31417 1537 20 recorded record VBN 31417 1537 21 of of IN 31417 1537 22 D. D. NNP 31417 1537 23 D. D. NNP 31417 1537 24 Home Home NNP 31417 1537 25 , , , 31417 1537 26 is be VBZ 31417 1537 27 very very RB 31417 1537 28 instructive instructive JJ 31417 1537 29 as as IN 31417 1537 30 illustrating illustrate VBG 31417 1537 31 the the DT 31417 1537 32 great great JJ 31417 1537 33 care care NN 31417 1537 34 that that WDT 31417 1537 35 is be VBZ 31417 1537 36 needful needful JJ 31417 1537 37 in in IN 31417 1537 38 estimating estimate VBG 31417 1537 39 the the DT 31417 1537 40 value value NN 31417 1537 41 of of IN 31417 1537 42 testimony testimony NN 31417 1537 43 regarding regard VBG 31417 1537 44 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1537 45 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1537 46 , , , 31417 1537 47 even even RB 31417 1537 48 of of IN 31417 1537 49 statements statement NNS 31417 1537 50 made make VBN 31417 1537 51 by by IN 31417 1537 52 persons person NNS 31417 1537 53 of of IN 31417 1537 54 established establish VBN 31417 1537 55 reputation reputation NN 31417 1537 56 and and CC 31417 1537 57 position position NN 31417 1537 58 . . . 31417 1538 1 The the DT 31417 1538 2 Joint Joint NNP 31417 1538 3 Report Report NNP 31417 1538 4 of of IN 31417 1538 5 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1538 6 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1538 7 and and CC 31417 1538 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1538 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1538 10 , , , 31417 1538 11 from from IN 31417 1538 12 which which WDT 31417 1538 13 extracts extract NNS 31417 1538 14 were be VBD 31417 1538 15 made make VBN 31417 1538 16 in in IN 31417 1538 17 Chapter Chapter NNP 31417 1538 18 V. V. NNP 31417 1538 19 , , , 31417 1538 20 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1538 21 " " '' 31417 1538 22 Lords Lords NNPS 31417 1538 23 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 1538 24 and and CC 31417 1538 25 Adare Adare NNP 31417 1538 26 had have VBD 31417 1538 27 printed print VBN 31417 1538 28 a a DT 31417 1538 29 statement statement NN 31417 1538 30 that that IN 31417 1538 31 Home Home NNP 31417 1538 32 floated float VBD 31417 1538 33 out out IN 31417 1538 34 of of IN 31417 1538 35 the the DT 31417 1538 36 window window NN 31417 1538 37 , , , 31417 1538 38 and and CC 31417 1538 39 in in RB 31417 1538 40 at at IN 31417 1538 41 another another DT 31417 1538 42 , , , 31417 1538 43 in in IN 31417 1538 44 Ashley Ashley NNP 31417 1538 45 Place Place NNP 31417 1538 46 , , , 31417 1538 47 S.W. S.W. NNP 31417 1538 48 , , , 31417 1538 49 16th 16th JJ 31417 1538 50 December December NNP 31417 1538 51 1868 1868 CD 31417 1538 52 . . . 31417 1539 1 A a DT 31417 1539 2 third third JJ 31417 1539 3 person person NN 31417 1539 4 , , , 31417 1539 5 Captain Captain NNP 31417 1539 6 Wynne Wynne NNP 31417 1539 7 , , , 31417 1539 8 was be VBD 31417 1539 9 present present JJ 31417 1539 10 at at IN 31417 1539 11 the the DT 31417 1539 12 time time NN 31417 1539 13 , , , 31417 1539 14 but but CC 31417 1539 15 had have VBD 31417 1539 16 written write VBN 31417 1539 17 no no DT 31417 1539 18 separate separate JJ 31417 1539 19 account account NN 31417 1539 20 . . . 31417 1540 1 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1540 2 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 1540 3 , , , 31417 1540 4 in in IN 31417 1540 5 an an DT 31417 1540 6 article article NN 31417 1540 7 in in IN 31417 1540 8 the the DT 31417 1540 9 _ _ NNP 31417 1540 10 Contemporary Contemporary NNP 31417 1540 11 Review Review NNP 31417 1540 12 _ _ NNP 31417 1540 13 for for IN 31417 1540 14 January January NNP 31417 1540 15 1876 1876 CD 31417 1540 16 , , , 31417 1540 17 thus thus RB 31417 1540 18 commented comment VBN 31417 1540 19 on on IN 31417 1540 20 the the DT 31417 1540 21 incident:-- incident:-- : 31417 1540 22 " " '' 31417 1540 23 ' ' `` 31417 1540 24 The the DT 31417 1540 25 most most RBS 31417 1540 26 diverse diverse JJ 31417 1540 27 accounts account NNS 31417 1540 28 of of IN 31417 1540 29 the the DT 31417 1540 30 _ _ NNP 31417 1540 31 facts fact NNS 31417 1540 32 _ _ NNP 31417 1540 33 of of IN 31417 1540 34 a a DT 31417 1540 35 seance seance NN 31417 1540 36 will will MD 31417 1540 37 be be VB 31417 1540 38 given give VBN 31417 1540 39 by by IN 31417 1540 40 a a DT 31417 1540 41 believer believer NN 31417 1540 42 and and CC 31417 1540 43 a a DT 31417 1540 44 sceptic sceptic NN 31417 1540 45 . . . 31417 1541 1 A a DT 31417 1541 2 whole whole JJ 31417 1541 3 party party NN 31417 1541 4 of of IN 31417 1541 5 believers believer NNS 31417 1541 6 will will MD 31417 1541 7 affirm affirm VB 31417 1541 8 that that IN 31417 1541 9 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1541 10 saw see VBD 31417 1541 11 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1541 12 Home Home NNP 31417 1541 13 float float VB 31417 1541 14 out out IN 31417 1541 15 of of IN 31417 1541 16 one one CD 31417 1541 17 window window NN 31417 1541 18 , , , 31417 1541 19 and and CC 31417 1541 20 in in RB 31417 1541 21 at at IN 31417 1541 22 another another DT 31417 1541 23 , , , 31417 1541 24 while while IN 31417 1541 25 a a DT 31417 1541 26 single single JJ 31417 1541 27 honest honest JJ 31417 1541 28 sceptic sceptic JJ 31417 1541 29 declares declare NNS 31417 1541 30 that that IN 31417 1541 31 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1541 32 Home Home NNP 31417 1541 33 was be VBD 31417 1541 34 sitting sit VBG 31417 1541 35 in in IN 31417 1541 36 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1541 37 chair chair NN 31417 1541 38 all all PDT 31417 1541 39 the the DT 31417 1541 40 time time NN 31417 1541 41 . . . 31417 1542 1 And and CC 31417 1542 2 in in IN 31417 1542 3 this this DT 31417 1542 4 last last JJ 31417 1542 5 case case NN 31417 1542 6 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1542 7 have have VBP 31417 1542 8 an an DT 31417 1542 9 example example NN 31417 1542 10 of of IN 31417 1542 11 a a DT 31417 1542 12 fact fact NN 31417 1542 13 , , , 31417 1542 14 of of IN 31417 1542 15 which which WDT 31417 1542 16 there there EX 31417 1542 17 is be VBZ 31417 1542 18 ample ample JJ 31417 1542 19 illustration illustration NN 31417 1542 20 , , , 31417 1542 21 that that IN 31417 1542 22 during during IN 31417 1542 23 the the DT 31417 1542 24 prevalence prevalence NN 31417 1542 25 of of IN 31417 1542 26 an an DT 31417 1542 27 epidemic epidemic NN 31417 1542 28 delusion delusion NN 31417 1542 29 , , , 31417 1542 30 the the DT 31417 1542 31 honest honest JJ 31417 1542 32 testimony testimony NN 31417 1542 33 of of IN 31417 1542 34 any any DT 31417 1542 35 number number NN 31417 1542 36 of of IN 31417 1542 37 individuals individual NNS 31417 1542 38 on on IN 31417 1542 39 one one CD 31417 1542 40 side side NN 31417 1542 41 , , , 31417 1542 42 if if IN 31417 1542 43 given give VBN 31417 1542 44 under under IN 31417 1542 45 a a DT 31417 1542 46 prepossession prepossession NN 31417 1542 47 , , , 31417 1542 48 is be VBZ 31417 1542 49 of of IN 31417 1542 50 no no DT 31417 1542 51 more more JJR 31417 1542 52 weight weight NN 31417 1542 53 than than IN 31417 1542 54 that that DT 31417 1542 55 of of IN 31417 1542 56 a a DT 31417 1542 57 single single JJ 31417 1542 58 adverse adverse JJ 31417 1542 59 witness witness NN 31417 1542 60 -- -- : 31417 1542 61 if if IN 31417 1542 62 so so RB 31417 1542 63 much much RB 31417 1542 64 . . . 31417 1542 65 ' ' '' 31417 1543 1 " " `` 31417 1543 2 This this DT 31417 1543 3 passage passage NN 31417 1543 4 was be VBD 31417 1543 5 of of IN 31417 1543 6 course course NN 31417 1543 7 quoted quote VBN 31417 1543 8 as as IN 31417 1543 9 implying imply VBG 31417 1543 10 that that IN 31417 1543 11 Captain Captain NNP 31417 1543 12 Wynne Wynne NNP 31417 1543 13 had have VBD 31417 1543 14 somewhere somewhere RB 31417 1543 15 made make VBN 31417 1543 16 a a DT 31417 1543 17 statement statement NN 31417 1543 18 contradicting contradict VBG 31417 1543 19 Lords Lords NNPS 31417 1543 20 Lindsay Lindsay NNP 31417 1543 21 and and CC 31417 1543 22 Adare Adare NNP 31417 1543 23 . . . 31417 1544 1 Home home NN 31417 1544 2 wrote write VBD 31417 1544 3 to to IN 31417 1544 4 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1544 5 to to TO 31417 1544 6 inquire inquire VB 31417 1544 7 ; ; : 31417 1544 8 and and CC 31417 1544 9 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1544 10 replied reply VBD 31417 1544 11 ... ... : 31417 1544 12 in in IN 31417 1544 13 the the DT 31417 1544 14 following follow VBG 31417 1544 15 terms:-- terms:-- '' 31417 1544 16 " " `` 31417 1544 17 ' ' `` 31417 1544 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1544 19 remember remember VBP 31417 1544 20 that that IN 31417 1544 21 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1544 22 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 1544 23 wrote write VBD 31417 1544 24 some some DT 31417 1544 25 nonsense nonsense NN 31417 1544 26 about about IN 31417 1544 27 that that DT 31417 1544 28 trip trip NN 31417 1544 29 of of IN 31417 1544 30 yours -PRON- PRP 31417 1544 31 along along IN 31417 1544 32 the the DT 31417 1544 33 side side NN 31417 1544 34 of of IN 31417 1544 35 the the DT 31417 1544 36 house house NN 31417 1544 37 in in IN 31417 1544 38 Ashley Ashley NNP 31417 1544 39 Place Place NNP 31417 1544 40 . . . 31417 1545 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1545 2 wrote write VBD 31417 1545 3 to to IN 31417 1545 4 the the DT 31417 1545 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1545 6 Medium Medium NNP 31417 1545 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1545 8 to to TO 31417 1545 9 say say VB 31417 1545 10 that that IN 31417 1545 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1545 12 was be VBD 31417 1545 13 present present JJ 31417 1545 14 as as IN 31417 1545 15 a a DT 31417 1545 16 witness witness NN 31417 1545 17 . . . 31417 1546 1 Now now RB 31417 1546 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1546 3 do do VBP 31417 1546 4 n't not RB 31417 1546 5 think think VB 31417 1546 6 that that IN 31417 1546 7 any any DT 31417 1546 8 one one NN 31417 1546 9 who who WP 31417 1546 10 knows know VBZ 31417 1546 11 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1546 12 would would MD 31417 1546 13 for for IN 31417 1546 14 one one CD 31417 1546 15 moment moment NN 31417 1546 16 say say VBP 31417 1546 17 that that IN 31417 1546 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1546 19 was be VBD 31417 1546 20 a a DT 31417 1546 21 victim victim NN 31417 1546 22 to to TO 31417 1546 23 hallucination hallucination NN 31417 1546 24 or or CC 31417 1546 25 any any DT 31417 1546 26 other other JJ 31417 1546 27 humbug humbug NNS 31417 1546 28 of of IN 31417 1546 29 the the DT 31417 1546 30 kind kind NN 31417 1546 31 . . . 31417 1547 1 The the DT 31417 1547 2 fact fact NN 31417 1547 3 of of IN 31417 1547 4 your -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1547 5 having have VBG 31417 1547 6 gone go VBN 31417 1547 7 out out IN 31417 1547 8 of of IN 31417 1547 9 the the DT 31417 1547 10 window window NN 31417 1547 11 and and CC 31417 1547 12 in in RB 31417 1547 13 at at IN 31417 1547 14 the the DT 31417 1547 15 other other JJ 31417 1547 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1547 17 can can MD 31417 1547 18 swear swear VB 31417 1547 19 to to IN 31417 1547 20 . . . 31417 1547 21 ' ' '' 31417 1547 22 " " '' 31417 1548 1 " " `` 31417 1548 2 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1548 3 seems seem VBZ 31417 1548 4 , , , 31417 1548 5 therefore therefore RB 31417 1548 6 , , , 31417 1548 7 that that IN 31417 1548 8 the the DT 31417 1548 9 instance instance NN 31417 1548 10 selected select VBN 31417 1548 11 by by IN 31417 1548 12 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1548 13 Carpenter Carpenter NNP 31417 1548 14 to to TO 31417 1548 15 prove prove VB 31417 1548 16 the the DT 31417 1548 17 existence existence NN 31417 1548 18 of of IN 31417 1548 19 a a DT 31417 1548 20 hallucination hallucination NN 31417 1548 21 -- -- : 31417 1548 22 by by IN 31417 1548 23 the the DT 31417 1548 24 exemption exemption NN 31417 1548 25 of of IN 31417 1548 26 one one CD 31417 1548 27 person person NN 31417 1548 28 present present JJ 31417 1548 29 from from IN 31417 1548 30 the the DT 31417 1548 31 illusion illusion NN 31417 1548 32 -- -- : 31417 1548 33 was be VBD 31417 1548 34 of of IN 31417 1548 35 a a DT 31417 1548 36 very very RB 31417 1548 37 unfortunate unfortunate JJ 31417 1548 38 kind kind NN 31417 1548 39 ; ; : 31417 1548 40 suggesting suggest VBG 31417 1548 41 , , , 31417 1548 42 indeed indeed RB 31417 1548 43 , , , 31417 1548 44 that that IN 31417 1548 45 a a DT 31417 1548 46 controversialist controversialist NN 31417 1548 47 thus thus RB 31417 1548 48 driven drive VBN 31417 1548 49 to to TO 31417 1548 50 draw draw VB 31417 1548 51 on on IN 31417 1548 52 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1548 53 imagination imagination NN 31417 1548 54 for for IN 31417 1548 55 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1548 56 facts fact NNS 31417 1548 57 must must MD 31417 1548 58 have have VB 31417 1548 59 been be VBN 31417 1548 60 conscious conscious JJ 31417 1548 61 of of IN 31417 1548 62 a a DT 31417 1548 63 weak weak JJ 31417 1548 64 case case NN 31417 1548 65 . . . 31417 1549 1 " " `` 31417 1549 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1549 3 71 71 CD 31417 1549 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1549 5 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1549 6 may may MD 31417 1549 7 be be VB 31417 1549 8 interesting interesting JJ 31417 1549 9 , , , 31417 1549 10 in in IN 31417 1549 11 concluding conclude VBG 31417 1549 12 this this DT 31417 1549 13 brief brief JJ 31417 1549 14 examination examination NN 31417 1549 15 into into IN 31417 1549 16 one one CD 31417 1549 17 branch branch NN 31417 1549 18 of of IN 31417 1549 19 the the DT 31417 1549 20 great great JJ 31417 1549 21 subject subject NN 31417 1549 22 of of IN 31417 1549 23 " " `` 31417 1549 24 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 1549 25 , , , 31417 1549 26 " " '' 31417 1549 27 to to TO 31417 1549 28 bring bring VB 31417 1549 29 together together RB 31417 1549 30 a a DT 31417 1549 31 few few JJ 31417 1549 32 of of IN 31417 1549 33 the the DT 31417 1549 34 impressions impression NNS 31417 1549 35 produced produce VBN 31417 1549 36 on on IN 31417 1549 37 the the DT 31417 1549 38 minds mind NNS 31417 1549 39 of of IN 31417 1549 40 some some DT 31417 1549 41 of of IN 31417 1549 42 the the DT 31417 1549 43 leading lead VBG 31417 1549 44 investigators investigator NNS 31417 1549 45 . . . 31417 1550 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1550 2 should should MD 31417 1550 3 not not RB 31417 1550 4 be be VB 31417 1550 5 forgotten forget VBN 31417 1550 6 that that IN 31417 1550 7 the the DT 31417 1550 8 branch branch NN 31417 1550 9 of of IN 31417 1550 10 the the DT 31417 1550 11 subject subject NN 31417 1550 12 which which WDT 31417 1550 13 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1550 14 have have VBP 31417 1550 15 been be VBN 31417 1550 16 studying study VBG 31417 1550 17 may may MD 31417 1550 18 be be VB 31417 1550 19 looked look VBN 31417 1550 20 upon upon IN 31417 1550 21 as as IN 31417 1550 22 representing represent VBG 31417 1550 23 the the DT 31417 1550 24 lowest low JJS 31417 1550 25 steps step NNS 31417 1550 26 only only RB 31417 1550 27 of of IN 31417 1550 28 a a DT 31417 1550 29 great great JJ 31417 1550 30 staircase staircase NN 31417 1550 31 which which WDT 31417 1550 32 ascends ascend VBZ 31417 1550 33 , , , 31417 1550 34 until until IN 31417 1550 35 , , , 31417 1550 36 to to IN 31417 1550 37 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1550 38 gaze gaze NN 31417 1550 39 , , , 31417 1550 40 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1550 41 is be VBZ 31417 1550 42 lost lose VBN 31417 1550 43 in in IN 31417 1550 44 unknown unknown JJ 31417 1550 45 infinite infinite JJ 31417 1550 46 heights height NNS 31417 1550 47 . . . 31417 1551 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1551 2 is be VBZ 31417 1551 3 only only RB 31417 1551 4 the the DT 31417 1551 5 foot foot NN 31417 1551 6 of of IN 31417 1551 7 a a DT 31417 1551 8 ladder ladder NN 31417 1551 9 , , , 31417 1551 10 to to TO 31417 1551 11 use use VB 31417 1551 12 another another DT 31417 1551 13 simile simile NN 31417 1551 14 , , , 31417 1551 15 resting rest VBG 31417 1551 16 on on IN 31417 1551 17 the the DT 31417 1551 18 material material JJ 31417 1551 19 earth earth NN 31417 1551 20 , , , 31417 1551 21 which which WDT 31417 1551 22 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1551 23 have have VBP 31417 1551 24 been be VBN 31417 1551 25 considering consider VBG 31417 1551 26 ; ; : 31417 1551 27 at at IN 31417 1551 28 most most JJS 31417 1551 29 the the DT 31417 1551 30 two two CD 31417 1551 31 or or CC 31417 1551 32 three three CD 31417 1551 33 lowest low JJS 31417 1551 34 rungs rung NNS 31417 1551 35 . . . 31417 1552 1 But but CC 31417 1552 2 to to IN 31417 1552 3 the the DT 31417 1552 4 eyes eye NNS 31417 1552 5 of of IN 31417 1552 6 some some DT 31417 1552 7 , , , 31417 1552 8 even even RB 31417 1552 9 now now RB 31417 1552 10 and and CC 31417 1552 11 here here RB 31417 1552 12 , , , 31417 1552 13 glimpses glimpse NNS 31417 1552 14 of of IN 31417 1552 15 angels angel NNS 31417 1552 16 ascending ascend VBG 31417 1552 17 and and CC 31417 1552 18 descending descend VBG 31417 1552 19 are be VBP 31417 1552 20 visible visible JJ 31417 1552 21 . . . 31417 1553 1 Five five CD 31417 1553 2 names name NNS 31417 1553 3 stand stand VBP 31417 1553 4 out out RP 31417 1553 5 prominently prominently RB 31417 1553 6 before before IN 31417 1553 7 all all DT 31417 1553 8 others other NNS 31417 1553 9 among among IN 31417 1553 10 the the DT 31417 1553 11 earlier early JJR 31417 1553 12 investigators investigator NNS 31417 1553 13 of of IN 31417 1553 14 the the DT 31417 1553 15 last last JJ 31417 1553 16 thirty thirty CD 31417 1553 17 years year NNS 31417 1553 18 -- -- : 31417 1553 19 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1553 20 William William NNP 31417 1553 21 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1553 22 and and CC 31417 1553 23 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1553 24 W. W. NNP 31417 1553 25 F. F. NNP 31417 1553 26 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1553 27 , , , 31417 1553 28 who who WP 31417 1553 29 are be VBP 31417 1553 30 still still RB 31417 1553 31 with with IN 31417 1553 32 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1553 33 ; ; : 31417 1553 34 and and CC 31417 1553 35 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1553 36 Henry Henry NNP 31417 1553 37 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1553 38 , , , 31417 1553 39 Edmund Edmund NNP 31417 1553 40 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1553 41 , , , 31417 1553 42 and and CC 31417 1553 43 F. F. NNP 31417 1553 44 W. W. NNP 31417 1553 45 H. H. NNP 31417 1553 46 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1553 47 , , , 31417 1553 48 who who WP 31417 1553 49 have have VBP 31417 1553 50 gone go VBN 31417 1553 51 . . . 31417 1554 1 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1554 2 William William NNP 31417 1554 3 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1554 4 ' ' POS 31417 1554 5 work work NN 31417 1554 6 in in IN 31417 1554 7 other other JJ 31417 1554 8 directions direction NNS 31417 1554 9 has have VBZ 31417 1554 10 been be VBN 31417 1554 11 all all RB 31417 1554 12 - - HYPH 31417 1554 13 absorbing absorbing JJ 31417 1554 14 , , , 31417 1554 15 so so IN 31417 1554 16 that that IN 31417 1554 17 all all DT 31417 1554 18 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1554 19 has have VBZ 31417 1554 20 been be VBN 31417 1554 21 able able JJ 31417 1554 22 to to TO 31417 1554 23 tell tell VB 31417 1554 24 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1554 25 during during IN 31417 1554 26 the the DT 31417 1554 27 last last JJ 31417 1554 28 few few JJ 31417 1554 29 years year NNS 31417 1554 30 , , , 31417 1554 31 in in IN 31417 1554 32 relation relation NN 31417 1554 33 to to IN 31417 1554 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1554 35 present present JJ 31417 1554 36 subject subject NN 31417 1554 37 , , , 31417 1554 38 is be VBZ 31417 1554 39 that that IN 31417 1554 40 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1554 41 had have VBD 31417 1554 42 nothing nothing NN 31417 1554 43 to to TO 31417 1554 44 add add VB 31417 1554 45 to to IN 31417 1554 46 , , , 31417 1554 47 and and CC 31417 1554 48 nothing nothing NN 31417 1554 49 to to TO 31417 1554 50 retract retract VB 31417 1554 51 from from IN 31417 1554 52 what what WP 31417 1554 53 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1554 54 has have VBZ 31417 1554 55 said say VBN 31417 1554 56 in in IN 31417 1554 57 the the DT 31417 1554 58 past past NN 31417 1554 59 . . . 31417 1555 1 In in IN 31417 1555 2 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1555 3 address address NN 31417 1555 4 as as IN 31417 1555 5 President President NNP 31417 1555 6 of of IN 31417 1555 7 the the DT 31417 1555 8 British British NNP 31417 1555 9 Association Association NNP 31417 1555 10 in in IN 31417 1555 11 1898 1898 CD 31417 1555 12 , , , 31417 1555 13 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1555 14 William William NNP 31417 1555 15 Crookes Crookes NNP 31417 1555 16 said say VBD 31417 1555 17 , , , 31417 1555 18 after after IN 31417 1555 19 referring refer VBG 31417 1555 20 to to IN 31417 1555 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1555 22 work work NN 31417 1555 23 of of IN 31417 1555 24 thirty thirty CD 31417 1555 25 years year NNS 31417 1555 26 ago:-- ago:-- NNP 31417 1555 27 " " `` 31417 1555 28 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1555 29 think think VBP 31417 1555 30 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1555 31 see see VBP 31417 1555 32 a a DT 31417 1555 33 little little JJ 31417 1555 34 further further RB 31417 1555 35 now now RB 31417 1555 36 . . . 31417 1556 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1556 2 have have VBP 31417 1556 3 glimpses glimpse NNS 31417 1556 4 of of IN 31417 1556 5 something something NN 31417 1556 6 like like IN 31417 1556 7 coherence coherence NN 31417 1556 8 among among IN 31417 1556 9 the the DT 31417 1556 10 strange strange JJ 31417 1556 11 elusive elusive JJ 31417 1556 12 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1556 13 , , , 31417 1556 14 of of IN 31417 1556 15 something something NN 31417 1556 16 like like IN 31417 1556 17 continuity continuity NN 31417 1556 18 between between IN 31417 1556 19 those those DT 31417 1556 20 unexplained unexplained JJ 31417 1556 21 forces force NNS 31417 1556 22 , , , 31417 1556 23 and and CC 31417 1556 24 laws law NNS 31417 1556 25 already already RB 31417 1556 26 known know VBN 31417 1556 27 .... .... . 31417 1557 1 Were be VBD 31417 1557 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1557 3 now now RB 31417 1557 4 introducing introduce VBG 31417 1557 5 for for IN 31417 1557 6 the the DT 31417 1557 7 first first JJ 31417 1557 8 time time NN 31417 1557 9 these these DT 31417 1557 10 inquiries inquiry NNS 31417 1557 11 to to IN 31417 1557 12 the the DT 31417 1557 13 world world NN 31417 1557 14 of of IN 31417 1557 15 science science NN 31417 1557 16 , , , 31417 1557 17 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1557 18 should should MD 31417 1557 19 choose choose VB 31417 1557 20 a a DT 31417 1557 21 starting starting NN 31417 1557 22 - - HYPH 31417 1557 23 point point NN 31417 1557 24 different different JJ 31417 1557 25 from from IN 31417 1557 26 that that DT 31417 1557 27 of of IN 31417 1557 28 old old JJ 31417 1557 29 . . . 31417 1558 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1558 2 would would MD 31417 1558 3 be be VB 31417 1558 4 well well JJ 31417 1558 5 to to TO 31417 1558 6 begin begin VB 31417 1558 7 with with IN 31417 1558 8 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1558 9 ; ; : 31417 1558 10 with with IN 31417 1558 11 the the DT 31417 1558 12 fundamental fundamental JJ 31417 1558 13 law law NN 31417 1558 14 , , , 31417 1558 15 as as IN 31417 1558 16 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1558 17 believe believe VBP 31417 1558 18 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1558 19 to to TO 31417 1558 20 be be VB 31417 1558 21 , , , 31417 1558 22 that that IN 31417 1558 23 thoughts thought NNS 31417 1558 24 and and CC 31417 1558 25 images image NNS 31417 1558 26 may may MD 31417 1558 27 be be VB 31417 1558 28 transferred transfer VBN 31417 1558 29 from from IN 31417 1558 30 one one CD 31417 1558 31 mind mind NN 31417 1558 32 to to IN 31417 1558 33 another another DT 31417 1558 34 without without IN 31417 1558 35 the the DT 31417 1558 36 agency agency NN 31417 1558 37 of of IN 31417 1558 38 the the DT 31417 1558 39 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1558 40 organs organ NNS 31417 1558 41 of of IN 31417 1558 42 sense sense NN 31417 1558 43 -- -- : 31417 1558 44 that that IN 31417 1558 45 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1558 46 may may MD 31417 1558 47 enter enter VB 31417 1558 48 the the DT 31417 1558 49 human human JJ 31417 1558 50 mind mind NN 31417 1558 51 without without IN 31417 1558 52 being be VBG 31417 1558 53 communicated communicate VBN 31417 1558 54 in in IN 31417 1558 55 any any DT 31417 1558 56 hitherto hitherto JJ 31417 1558 57 known know VBN 31417 1558 58 or or CC 31417 1558 59 recognised recognise VBN 31417 1558 60 ways way NNS 31417 1558 61 . . . 31417 1559 1 " " `` 31417 1559 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1559 3 72 72 CD 31417 1559 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1559 5 For for IN 31417 1559 6 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1559 7 Barrett Barrett NNP 31417 1559 8 's 's POS 31417 1559 9 present present JJ 31417 1559 10 views view NNS 31417 1559 11 the the DT 31417 1559 12 reader reader NN 31417 1559 13 is be VBZ 31417 1559 14 referred refer VBN 31417 1559 15 to to IN 31417 1559 16 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1559 17 address address NN 31417 1559 18 as as IN 31417 1559 19 President President NNP 31417 1559 20 of of IN 31417 1559 21 the the DT 31417 1559 22 Society Society NNP 31417 1559 23 for for IN 31417 1559 24 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1559 25 Research Research NNP 31417 1559 26 delivered deliver VBN 31417 1559 27 in in IN 31417 1559 28 January January NNP 31417 1559 29 1904 1904 CD 31417 1559 30 . . . 31417 1560 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1560 2 73 73 CD 31417 1560 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1560 4 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1560 5 is be VBZ 31417 1560 6 full full JJ 31417 1560 7 of of IN 31417 1560 8 interest interest NN 31417 1560 9 , , , 31417 1560 10 but but CC 31417 1560 11 is be VBZ 31417 1560 12 not not RB 31417 1560 13 easy easy JJ 31417 1560 14 to to TO 31417 1560 15 quote quote VB 31417 1560 16 from from IN 31417 1560 17 . . . 31417 1561 1 Speaking speak VBG 31417 1561 2 of of IN 31417 1561 3 " " `` 31417 1561 4 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1561 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1561 6 , , , 31417 1561 7 " " '' 31417 1561 8 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1561 9 says say VBZ 31417 1561 10 : : : 31417 1561 11 " " `` 31417 1561 12 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1561 13 must must MD 31417 1561 14 all all RB 31417 1561 15 agree agree VB 31417 1561 16 that that IN 31417 1561 17 indiscriminate indiscriminate VB 31417 1561 18 condemnation condemnation NN 31417 1561 19 on on IN 31417 1561 20 the the DT 31417 1561 21 one one CD 31417 1561 22 hand hand NN 31417 1561 23 , , , 31417 1561 24 and and CC 31417 1561 25 ignorant ignorant JJ 31417 1561 26 credulity credulity NN 31417 1561 27 on on IN 31417 1561 28 the the DT 31417 1561 29 other other JJ 31417 1561 30 , , , 31417 1561 31 are be VBP 31417 1561 32 the the DT 31417 1561 33 two two CD 31417 1561 34 most most RBS 31417 1561 35 mischievous mischievous JJ 31417 1561 36 elements element NNS 31417 1561 37 with with IN 31417 1561 38 which which WDT 31417 1561 39 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1561 40 are be VBP 31417 1561 41 confronted confront VBN 31417 1561 42 in in IN 31417 1561 43 connection connection NN 31417 1561 44 with with IN 31417 1561 45 this this DT 31417 1561 46 subject subject NN 31417 1561 47 . . . 31417 1562 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1562 2 is be VBZ 31417 1562 3 because because IN 31417 1562 4 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1562 5 , , , 31417 1562 6 as as IN 31417 1562 7 a a DT 31417 1562 8 Society Society NNP 31417 1562 9 , , , 31417 1562 10 feel feel VB 31417 1562 11 that that IN 31417 1562 12 in in IN 31417 1562 13 the the DT 31417 1562 14 fearless fearless JJ 31417 1562 15 pursuit pursuit NN 31417 1562 16 of of IN 31417 1562 17 truth truth NN 31417 1562 18 , , , 31417 1562 19 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1562 20 is be VBZ 31417 1562 21 the the DT 31417 1562 22 paramount paramount JJ 31417 1562 23 duty duty NN 31417 1562 24 of of IN 31417 1562 25 science science NN 31417 1562 26 to to TO 31417 1562 27 lead lead VB 31417 1562 28 the the DT 31417 1562 29 way way NN 31417 1562 30 , , , 31417 1562 31 that that IN 31417 1562 32 the the DT 31417 1562 33 scornful scornful JJ 31417 1562 34 attitude attitude NN 31417 1562 35 of of IN 31417 1562 36 the the DT 31417 1562 37 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1562 38 world world NN 31417 1562 39 towards towards IN 31417 1562 40 even even RB 31417 1562 41 the the DT 31417 1562 42 investigation investigation NN 31417 1562 43 of of IN 31417 1562 44 these these DT 31417 1562 45 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1562 46 is be VBZ 31417 1562 47 so so RB 31417 1562 48 much much JJ 31417 1562 49 to to TO 31417 1562 50 be be VB 31417 1562 51 deprecated deprecate VBN 31417 1562 52 .... .... . 31417 1563 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1563 2 suppose suppose VBP 31417 1563 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1563 4 are be VBP 31417 1563 5 all all RB 31417 1563 6 apt apt JJ 31417 1563 7 to to TO 31417 1563 8 fancy fancy VB 31417 1563 9 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1563 10 own own JJ 31417 1563 11 power power NN 31417 1563 12 of of IN 31417 1563 13 discernment discernment NN 31417 1563 14 and and CC 31417 1563 15 of of IN 31417 1563 16 sound sound JJ 31417 1563 17 judgment judgment NN 31417 1563 18 to to TO 31417 1563 19 be be VB 31417 1563 20 somewhat somewhat RB 31417 1563 21 better well JJR 31417 1563 22 than than IN 31417 1563 23 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1563 24 neighbours neighbour NNS 31417 1563 25 . . . 31417 1564 1 But but CC 31417 1564 2 after after RB 31417 1564 3 all all RB 31417 1564 4 , , , 31417 1564 5 is be VBZ 31417 1564 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1564 7 not not RB 31417 1564 8 the the DT 31417 1564 9 common common JJ 31417 1564 10 - - HYPH 31417 1564 11 sense sense NN 31417 1564 12 , , , 31417 1564 13 the the DT 31417 1564 14 care care NN 31417 1564 15 , , , 31417 1564 16 the the DT 31417 1564 17 patience patience NN 31417 1564 18 , , , 31417 1564 19 and and CC 31417 1564 20 the the DT 31417 1564 21 amount amount NN 31417 1564 22 of of IN 31417 1564 23 uninterrupted uninterrupted JJ 31417 1564 24 attention attention NN 31417 1564 25 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1564 26 bestow bestow VBP 31417 1564 27 upon upon IN 31417 1564 28 any any DT 31417 1564 29 psychical psychical JJ 31417 1564 30 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1564 31 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1564 32 are be VBP 31417 1564 33 investigating investigate VBG 31417 1564 34 , , , 31417 1564 35 that that WDT 31417 1564 36 gives give VBZ 31417 1564 37 value value NN 31417 1564 38 to to IN 31417 1564 39 the the DT 31417 1564 40 opinion opinion NN 31417 1564 41 at at IN 31417 1564 42 which which WDT 31417 1564 43 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1564 44 arrive arrive VBP 31417 1564 45 , , , 31417 1564 46 and and CC 31417 1564 47 not not RB 31417 1564 48 the the DT 31417 1564 49 particular particular JJ 31417 1564 50 cleverness cleverness NN 31417 1564 51 or or CC 31417 1564 52 scepticism scepticism NN 31417 1564 53 of of IN 31417 1564 54 the the DT 31417 1564 55 observer observer NN 31417 1564 56 ? ? . 31417 1565 1 The the DT 31417 1565 2 lesson lesson NN 31417 1565 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1565 4 all all DT 31417 1565 5 need need VBP 31417 1565 6 to to TO 31417 1565 7 learn learn VB 31417 1565 8 is be VBZ 31417 1565 9 , , , 31417 1565 10 that that IN 31417 1565 11 what what WP 31417 1565 12 even even RB 31417 1565 13 the the DT 31417 1565 14 humblest humblest NN 31417 1565 15 of of IN 31417 1565 16 men man NNS 31417 1565 17 _ _ NNP 31417 1565 18 affirm affirm NN 31417 1565 19 _ _ NNP 31417 1565 20 , , , 31417 1565 21 from from IN 31417 1565 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1565 23 own own JJ 31417 1565 24 experience experience NN 31417 1565 25 , , , 31417 1565 26 is be VBZ 31417 1565 27 always always RB 31417 1565 28 worth worth JJ 31417 1565 29 listening listen VBG 31417 1565 30 to to TO 31417 1565 31 , , , 31417 1565 32 but but CC 31417 1565 33 what what WP 31417 1565 34 even even RB 31417 1565 35 the the DT 31417 1565 36 cleverest clever JJS 31417 1565 37 of of IN 31417 1565 38 men man NNS 31417 1565 39 , , , 31417 1565 40 in in IN 31417 1565 41 their -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1565 42 ignorance ignorance NN 31417 1565 43 , , , 31417 1565 44 deny deny NN 31417 1565 45 , , , 31417 1565 46 is be VBZ 31417 1565 47 never never RB 31417 1565 48 worth worth JJ 31417 1565 49 a a DT 31417 1565 50 moment moment NN 31417 1565 51 's 's POS 31417 1565 52 attention attention NN 31417 1565 53 . . . 31417 1566 1 " " `` 31417 1566 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1566 3 74 74 CD 31417 1566 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1566 5 As as IN 31417 1566 6 regards regard VBZ 31417 1566 7 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1566 8 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1566 9 , , , 31417 1566 10 the the DT 31417 1566 11 experimental experimental JJ 31417 1566 12 work work NN 31417 1566 13 of of IN 31417 1566 14 the the DT 31417 1566 15 Society Society NNP 31417 1566 16 for for IN 31417 1566 17 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1566 18 Research Research NNP 31417 1566 19 soon soon RB 31417 1566 20 convinced convince VBD 31417 1566 21 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1566 22 that that IN 31417 1566 23 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1566 24 - - HYPH 31417 1566 25 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1566 26 , , , 31417 1566 27 or or CC 31417 1566 28 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1566 29 , , , 31417 1566 30 was be VBD 31417 1566 31 a a DT 31417 1566 32 fact fact NN 31417 1566 33 . . . 31417 1567 1 In in IN 31417 1567 2 an an DT 31417 1567 3 address address NN 31417 1567 4 in in IN 31417 1567 5 1889 1889 CD 31417 1567 6 , , , 31417 1567 7 after after IN 31417 1567 8 speaking speak VBG 31417 1567 9 of of IN 31417 1567 10 the the DT 31417 1567 11 probabilities probability NNS 31417 1567 12 of of IN 31417 1567 13 testimony testimony NN 31417 1567 14 given give VBN 31417 1567 15 being be VBG 31417 1567 16 false false JJ 31417 1567 17 , , , 31417 1567 18 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1567 19 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1567 20 " " `` 31417 1567 21 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1567 22 is be VBZ 31417 1567 23 for for IN 31417 1567 24 this this DT 31417 1567 25 reason reason NN 31417 1567 26 that that WDT 31417 1567 27 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1567 28 feel feel VBP 31417 1567 29 that that IN 31417 1567 30 a a DT 31417 1567 31 part part NN 31417 1567 32 of of IN 31417 1567 33 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1567 34 grounds ground NNS 31417 1567 35 for for IN 31417 1567 36 believing believe VBG 31417 1567 37 in in IN 31417 1567 38 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1567 39 , , , 31417 1567 40 depending depend VBG 31417 1567 41 as as IN 31417 1567 42 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1567 43 does do VBZ 31417 1567 44 on on IN 31417 1567 45 personal personal JJ 31417 1567 46 knowledge knowledge NN 31417 1567 47 , , , 31417 1567 48 can can MD 31417 1567 49 not not RB 31417 1567 50 be be VB 31417 1567 51 communicated communicate VBN 31417 1567 52 except except IN 31417 1567 53 in in IN 31417 1567 54 a a DT 31417 1567 55 weakened weaken VBN 31417 1567 56 form form NN 31417 1567 57 to to IN 31417 1567 58 the the DT 31417 1567 59 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1567 60 reader reader NN 31417 1567 61 of of IN 31417 1567 62 the the DT 31417 1567 63 printed print VBN 31417 1567 64 statements statement NNS 31417 1567 65 which which WDT 31417 1567 66 represent represent VBP 31417 1567 67 the the DT 31417 1567 68 evidence evidence NN 31417 1567 69 that that WDT 31417 1567 70 has have VBZ 31417 1567 71 convinced convince VBN 31417 1567 72 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1567 73 . . . 31417 1568 1 Indeed indeed RB 31417 1568 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 3 feel feel VBP 31417 1568 4 this this DT 31417 1568 5 so so RB 31417 1568 6 strongly strongly RB 31417 1568 7 that that IN 31417 1568 8 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 9 have have VBP 31417 1568 10 always always RB 31417 1568 11 made make VBN 31417 1568 12 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 13 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1568 14 highest high JJS 31417 1568 15 ambition ambition NN 31417 1568 16 as as IN 31417 1568 17 a a DT 31417 1568 18 psychical psychical JJ 31417 1568 19 researcher researcher NN 31417 1568 20 to to TO 31417 1568 21 produce produce VB 31417 1568 22 evidence evidence NN 31417 1568 23 which which WDT 31417 1568 24 will will MD 31417 1568 25 drive drive VB 31417 1568 26 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1568 27 opponents opponent NNS 31417 1568 28 to to TO 31417 1568 29 doubt doubt VB 31417 1568 30 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1568 31 honesty honesty NN 31417 1568 32 or or CC 31417 1568 33 veracity veracity NN 31417 1568 34 ; ; : 31417 1568 35 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 36 think think VBP 31417 1568 37 there there EX 31417 1568 38 are be VBP 31417 1568 39 a a DT 31417 1568 40 very very RB 31417 1568 41 small small JJ 31417 1568 42 minority minority NN 31417 1568 43 who who WP 31417 1568 44 will will MD 31417 1568 45 not not RB 31417 1568 46 doubt doubt VB 31417 1568 47 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 48 , , , 31417 1568 49 and and CC 31417 1568 50 that that IN 31417 1568 51 if if IN 31417 1568 52 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 53 can can MD 31417 1568 54 convince convince VB 31417 1568 55 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 56 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 57 have have VBP 31417 1568 58 done do VBN 31417 1568 59 all all DT 31417 1568 60 that that WDT 31417 1568 61 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 62 can can MD 31417 1568 63 do do VB 31417 1568 64 : : : 31417 1568 65 as as IN 31417 1568 66 regards regard VBZ 31417 1568 67 the the DT 31417 1568 68 majority majority NN 31417 1568 69 of of IN 31417 1568 70 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1568 71 own own JJ 31417 1568 72 acquaintances acquaintance NNS 31417 1568 73 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 74 should should MD 31417 1568 75 claim claim VB 31417 1568 76 no no RB 31417 1568 77 more more JJR 31417 1568 78 than than IN 31417 1568 79 an an DT 31417 1568 80 admission admission NN 31417 1568 81 that that IN 31417 1568 82 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 83 were be VBD 31417 1568 84 considerably considerably RB 31417 1568 85 surprised surprised JJ 31417 1568 86 to to TO 31417 1568 87 find find VB 31417 1568 88 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1568 89 in in IN 31417 1568 90 the the DT 31417 1568 91 trick trick NN 31417 1568 92 . . . 31417 1569 1 " " `` 31417 1569 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1569 3 75 75 CD 31417 1569 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1569 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1569 6 am be VBP 31417 1569 7 not not RB 31417 1569 8 aware aware JJ 31417 1569 9 that that IN 31417 1569 10 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1569 11 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1569 12 ever ever RB 31417 1569 13 expressed express VBD 31417 1569 14 any any DT 31417 1569 15 opinion opinion NN 31417 1569 16 as as IN 31417 1569 17 to to IN 31417 1569 18 the the DT 31417 1569 19 reality reality NN 31417 1569 20 of of IN 31417 1569 21 the the DT 31417 1569 22 ordinary ordinary JJ 31417 1569 23 physical physical JJ 31417 1569 24 spiritualistic spiritualistic JJ 31417 1569 25 manifestations manifestation NNS 31417 1569 26 . . . 31417 1570 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1570 2 is be VBZ 31417 1570 3 clear clear JJ 31417 1570 4 that that IN 31417 1570 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1570 6 believed believe VBD 31417 1570 7 a a DT 31417 1570 8 large large JJ 31417 1570 9 proportion proportion NN 31417 1570 10 to to TO 31417 1570 11 have have VB 31417 1570 12 been be VBN 31417 1570 13 fraudulently fraudulently RB 31417 1570 14 produced produce VBN 31417 1570 15 . . . 31417 1571 1 As as IN 31417 1571 2 to to IN 31417 1571 3 some some DT 31417 1571 4 psychical psychical JJ 31417 1571 5 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1571 6 , , , 31417 1571 7 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1571 8 convictions conviction NNS 31417 1571 9 were be VBD 31417 1571 10 very very RB 31417 1571 11 strong strong JJ 31417 1571 12 . . . 31417 1572 1 For for IN 31417 1572 2 instance instance NN 31417 1572 3 , , , 31417 1572 4 in in IN 31417 1572 5 the the DT 31417 1572 6 final final JJ 31417 1572 7 paragraph paragraph NN 31417 1572 8 of of IN 31417 1572 9 the the DT 31417 1572 10 " " `` 31417 1572 11 Report Report NNP 31417 1572 12 on on IN 31417 1572 13 Hallucinations Hallucinations NNP 31417 1572 14 , , , 31417 1572 15 " " '' 31417 1572 16 which which WDT 31417 1572 17 occupies occupy VBZ 31417 1572 18 the the DT 31417 1572 19 whole whole NN 31417 1572 20 of of IN 31417 1572 21 the the DT 31417 1572 22 tenth tenth JJ 31417 1572 23 volume volume NN 31417 1572 24 of of IN 31417 1572 25 the the DT 31417 1572 26 _ _ NNP 31417 1572 27 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1572 28 _ _ NNP 31417 1572 29 of of IN 31417 1572 30 the the DT 31417 1572 31 Society Society NNP 31417 1572 32 , , , 31417 1572 33 and and CC 31417 1572 34 to to TO 31417 1572 35 which which WDT 31417 1572 36 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1572 37 appended append VBD 31417 1572 38 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1572 39 name name NN 31417 1572 40 , , , 31417 1572 41 these these DT 31417 1572 42 two two CD 31417 1572 43 sentences sentence NNS 31417 1572 44 occur occur VBP 31417 1572 45 : : : 31417 1572 46 " " `` 31417 1572 47 Between between IN 31417 1572 48 deaths death NNS 31417 1572 49 and and CC 31417 1572 50 apparitions apparition NNS 31417 1572 51 of of IN 31417 1572 52 the the DT 31417 1572 53 dying die VBG 31417 1572 54 person person NN 31417 1572 55 a a DT 31417 1572 56 connection connection NN 31417 1572 57 exists exist VBZ 31417 1572 58 which which WDT 31417 1572 59 is be VBZ 31417 1572 60 not not RB 31417 1572 61 due due JJ 31417 1572 62 to to TO 31417 1572 63 chance chance NN 31417 1572 64 alone alone RB 31417 1572 65 . . . 31417 1573 1 This this DT 31417 1573 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1573 3 hold hold VBP 31417 1573 4 as as IN 31417 1573 5 a a DT 31417 1573 6 proved prove VBN 31417 1573 7 fact fact NN 31417 1573 8 . . . 31417 1574 1 " " `` 31417 1574 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1574 3 76 76 CD 31417 1574 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1574 5 And and CC 31417 1574 6 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1574 7 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1574 8 speaks speak VBZ 31417 1574 9 of of IN 31417 1574 10 this this DT 31417 1574 11 as as IN 31417 1574 12 corroborating corroborate VBG 31417 1574 13 the the DT 31417 1574 14 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 1574 15 already already RB 31417 1574 16 drawn draw VBN 31417 1574 17 by by IN 31417 1574 18 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1574 19 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1574 20 nearly nearly RB 31417 1574 21 ten ten CD 31417 1574 22 years year NNS 31417 1574 23 earlier early RBR 31417 1574 24 . . . 31417 1575 1 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1575 2 Edmund Edmund NNP 31417 1575 3 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1575 4 's 's POS 31417 1575 5 name name NN 31417 1575 6 stands stand VBZ 31417 1575 7 next next RB 31417 1575 8 . . . 31417 1576 1 His -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1576 2 earthly earthly JJ 31417 1576 3 work work NN 31417 1576 4 came come VBD 31417 1576 5 to to IN 31417 1576 6 a a DT 31417 1576 7 sudden sudden JJ 31417 1576 8 termination termination NN 31417 1576 9 in in IN 31417 1576 10 1888 1888 CD 31417 1576 11 . . . 31417 1577 1 " " `` 31417 1577 2 Phantasms phantasm NNS 31417 1577 3 of of IN 31417 1577 4 the the DT 31417 1577 5 Living living NN 31417 1577 6 " " '' 31417 1577 7 is be VBZ 31417 1577 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1577 9 enduring enduring JJ 31417 1577 10 memorial memorial NN 31417 1577 11 . . . 31417 1578 1 Although although IN 31417 1578 2 two two CD 31417 1578 3 other other JJ 31417 1578 4 names name NNS 31417 1578 5 are be VBP 31417 1578 6 associated associate VBN 31417 1578 7 with with IN 31417 1578 8 his -PRON- PRP 31417 1578 9 on on IN 31417 1578 10 the the DT 31417 1578 11 title title NN 31417 1578 12 - - HYPH 31417 1578 13 page page NN 31417 1578 14 , , , 31417 1578 15 the the DT 31417 1578 16 greater great JJR 31417 1578 17 part part NN 31417 1578 18 of of IN 31417 1578 19 the the DT 31417 1578 20 two two CD 31417 1578 21 volumes volume NNS 31417 1578 22 was be VBD 31417 1578 23 written write VBN 31417 1578 24 by by IN 31417 1578 25 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1578 26 alone alone JJ 31417 1578 27 . . . 31417 1579 1 For for IN 31417 1579 2 most most JJS 31417 1579 3 of of IN 31417 1579 4 the the DT 31417 1579 5 views view NNS 31417 1579 6 expressed express VBD 31417 1579 7 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1579 8 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1579 9 is be VBZ 31417 1579 10 solely solely RB 31417 1579 11 responsible responsible JJ 31417 1579 12 . . . 31417 1580 1 In in IN 31417 1580 2 a a DT 31417 1580 3 chapter chapter NN 31417 1580 4 devoted devote VBN 31417 1580 5 to to IN 31417 1580 6 " " `` 31417 1580 7 The the DT 31417 1580 8 Theory Theory NNP 31417 1580 9 of of IN 31417 1580 10 Chance Chance NNP 31417 1580 11 - - HYPH 31417 1580 12 Coincidence Coincidence NNP 31417 1580 13 " " '' 31417 1580 14 as as IN 31417 1580 15 an an DT 31417 1580 16 explanation explanation NN 31417 1580 17 of of IN 31417 1580 18 the the DT 31417 1580 19 order order NN 31417 1580 20 of of IN 31417 1580 21 natural natural JJ 31417 1580 22 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1580 23 to to TO 31417 1580 24 which which WDT 31417 1580 25 " " `` 31417 1580 26 Phantasms phantasm NNS 31417 1580 27 of of IN 31417 1580 28 the the DT 31417 1580 29 Living living NN 31417 1580 30 " " '' 31417 1580 31 belong belong VB 31417 1580 32 , , , 31417 1580 33 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1580 34 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1580 35 says:-- says:-- : 31417 1580 36 " " `` 31417 1580 37 Figures figure NNS 31417 1580 38 , , , 31417 1580 39 one one CD 31417 1580 40 is be VBZ 31417 1580 41 sometimes sometimes RB 31417 1580 42 told tell VBN 31417 1580 43 , , , 31417 1580 44 can can MD 31417 1580 45 be be VB 31417 1580 46 made make VBN 31417 1580 47 to to TO 31417 1580 48 prove prove VB 31417 1580 49 anything anything NN 31417 1580 50 ; ; : 31417 1580 51 but but CC 31417 1580 52 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1580 53 confess confess VBP 31417 1580 54 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1580 55 should should MD 31417 1580 56 be be VB 31417 1580 57 curious curious JJ 31417 1580 58 to to TO 31417 1580 59 see see VB 31417 1580 60 the the DT 31417 1580 61 figures figure NNS 31417 1580 62 by by IN 31417 1580 63 which which WDT 31417 1580 64 the the DT 31417 1580 65 theory theory NN 31417 1580 66 of of IN 31417 1580 67 chance chance NN 31417 1580 68 - - HYPH 31417 1580 69 coincidence coincidence NN 31417 1580 70 could could MD 31417 1580 71 here here RB 31417 1580 72 be be VB 31417 1580 73 proved prove VBN 31417 1580 74 adequate adequate JJ 31417 1580 75 to to IN 31417 1580 76 the the DT 31417 1580 77 facts fact NNS 31417 1580 78 . . . 31417 1581 1 Whatever whatever WDT 31417 1581 2 group group NN 31417 1581 3 of of IN 31417 1581 4 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1581 5 be be VB 31417 1581 6 selected select VBN 31417 1581 7 , , , 31417 1581 8 and and CC 31417 1581 9 whatever whatever WDT 31417 1581 10 method method NN 31417 1581 11 of of IN 31417 1581 12 reckoning reckoning NN 31417 1581 13 be be VB 31417 1581 14 adopted adopt VBN 31417 1581 15 , , , 31417 1581 16 probabilities probability NNS 31417 1581 17 are be VBP 31417 1581 18 hopelessly hopelessly RB 31417 1581 19 and and CC 31417 1581 20 even even RB 31417 1581 21 ludicrously ludicrously RB 31417 1581 22 overpassed overpassed JJ 31417 1581 23 . . . 31417 1582 1 " " `` 31417 1582 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1582 3 77 77 CD 31417 1582 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1582 5 This this DT 31417 1582 6 is be VBZ 31417 1582 7 the the DT 31417 1582 8 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 1582 9 referred refer VBD 31417 1582 10 to to IN 31417 1582 11 above above RB 31417 1582 12 by by IN 31417 1582 13 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1582 14 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1582 15 . . . 31417 1583 1 With with IN 31417 1583 2 exclusively exclusively RB 31417 1583 3 physical physical JJ 31417 1583 4 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1583 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1583 6 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1583 7 did do VBD 31417 1583 8 not not RB 31417 1583 9 much much JJ 31417 1583 10 concern concern VB 31417 1583 11 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1583 12 . . . 31417 1584 1 The the DT 31417 1584 2 last last JJ 31417 1584 3 of of IN 31417 1584 4 the the DT 31417 1584 5 five five CD 31417 1584 6 names name NNS 31417 1584 7 mentioned mention VBN 31417 1584 8 is be VBZ 31417 1584 9 that that DT 31417 1584 10 of of IN 31417 1584 11 Mr Mr NNP 31417 1584 12 F. F. NNP 31417 1584 13 W. W. NNP 31417 1584 14 H. H. NNP 31417 1584 15 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1584 16 . . . 31417 1585 1 The the DT 31417 1585 2 written written JJ 31417 1585 3 testimony testimony NN 31417 1585 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1585 5 has have VBZ 31417 1585 6 left leave VBN 31417 1585 7 behind behind RB 31417 1585 8 enables enable VBZ 31417 1585 9 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1585 10 to to TO 31417 1585 11 obtain obtain VB 31417 1585 12 a a DT 31417 1585 13 much much RB 31417 1585 14 clearer clear JJR 31417 1585 15 view view NN 31417 1585 16 of of IN 31417 1585 17 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1585 18 conclusions conclusion NNS 31417 1585 19 as as IN 31417 1585 20 a a DT 31417 1585 21 whole whole NN 31417 1585 22 , , , 31417 1585 23 than than IN 31417 1585 24 is be VBZ 31417 1585 25 attainable attainable JJ 31417 1585 26 in in IN 31417 1585 27 the the DT 31417 1585 28 case case NN 31417 1585 29 of of IN 31417 1585 30 Professor Professor NNP 31417 1585 31 Sidgwick Sidgwick NNP 31417 1585 32 and and CC 31417 1585 33 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1585 34 Gurney Gurney NNP 31417 1585 35 . . . 31417 1586 1 The the DT 31417 1586 2 convictions conviction NNS 31417 1586 3 which which WDT 31417 1586 4 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1586 5 came come VBD 31417 1586 6 to to IN 31417 1586 7 in in IN 31417 1586 8 regard regard NN 31417 1586 9 to to IN 31417 1586 10 the the DT 31417 1586 11 two two CD 31417 1586 12 most most RBS 31417 1586 13 notable notable JJ 31417 1586 14 " " `` 31417 1586 15 mediums medium NNS 31417 1586 16 " " '' 31417 1586 17 in in IN 31417 1586 18 the the DT 31417 1586 19 history history NN 31417 1586 20 of of IN 31417 1586 21 modern modern JJ 31417 1586 22 spiritualism spiritualism NN 31417 1586 23 -- -- : 31417 1586 24 D. D. NNP 31417 1586 25 D. D. NNP 31417 1586 26 Home Home NNP 31417 1586 27 and and CC 31417 1586 28 W. W. NNP 31417 1586 29 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 1586 30 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1586 31 -- -- : 31417 1586 32 are be VBP 31417 1586 33 evidence evidence NN 31417 1586 34 that that IN 31417 1586 35 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1586 36 believed believe VBD 31417 1586 37 in in IN 31417 1586 38 most most JJS 31417 1586 39 of of IN 31417 1586 40 the the DT 31417 1586 41 alleged alleged JJ 31417 1586 42 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1586 43 being be VBG 31417 1586 44 proved prove VBN 31417 1586 45 realities reality NNS 31417 1586 46 . . . 31417 1587 1 These these DT 31417 1587 2 convictions conviction NNS 31417 1587 3 are be VBP 31417 1587 4 so so RB 31417 1587 5 important important JJ 31417 1587 6 from from IN 31417 1587 7 such such PDT 31417 1587 8 a a DT 31417 1587 9 careful careful JJ 31417 1587 10 and and CC 31417 1587 11 competent competent JJ 31417 1587 12 student student NN 31417 1587 13 of of IN 31417 1587 14 the the DT 31417 1587 15 subject subject NN 31417 1587 16 that that IN 31417 1587 17 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1587 18 is be VBZ 31417 1587 19 best good JJS 31417 1587 20 to to TO 31417 1587 21 quote quote VB 31417 1587 22 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1587 23 in in IN 31417 1587 24 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1587 25 own own JJ 31417 1587 26 words word NNS 31417 1587 27 . . . 31417 1588 1 Of of IN 31417 1588 2 D. D. NNP 31417 1588 3 D. D. NNP 31417 1588 4 Home Home NNP 31417 1588 5 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1588 6 said say VBD 31417 1588 7 : : : 31417 1588 8 " " `` 31417 1588 9 If if IN 31417 1588 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1588 11 readers reader NNS 31417 1588 12 ask ask VBP 31417 1588 13 us--'Do us--'Do NNP 31417 1588 14 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1588 15 desire desire VBP 31417 1588 16 us -PRON- PRP 31417 1588 17 to to TO 31417 1588 18 go go VB 31417 1588 19 on on RP 31417 1588 20 experimenting experiment VBG 31417 1588 21 in in IN 31417 1588 22 these these DT 31417 1588 23 matters matter NNS 31417 1588 24 , , , 31417 1588 25 as as IN 31417 1588 26 though though IN 31417 1588 27 Home Home NNP 31417 1588 28 's 's POS 31417 1588 29 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1588 30 were be VBD 31417 1588 31 genuine genuine JJ 31417 1588 32 ? ? . 31417 1588 33 ' ' '' 31417 1589 1 --we --we : 31417 1589 2 answer answer VB 31417 1589 3 ' ' '' 31417 1589 4 Yes yes UH 31417 1589 5 . . . 31417 1590 1 ' ' `` 31417 1590 2 " " `` 31417 1590 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1590 4 78 78 CD 31417 1590 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1590 6 Of of IN 31417 1590 7 the the DT 31417 1590 8 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1590 9 which which WDT 31417 1590 10 occurred occur VBD 31417 1590 11 in in IN 31417 1590 12 the the DT 31417 1590 13 presence presence NN 31417 1590 14 of of IN 31417 1590 15 W. W. NNP 31417 1590 16 Stainton Stainton NNP 31417 1590 17 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1590 18 , , , 31417 1590 19 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1590 20 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1590 21 said say VBD 31417 1590 22 : : : 31417 1590 23 " " `` 31417 1590 24 That that IN 31417 1590 25 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1590 26 were be VBD 31417 1590 27 not not RB 31417 1590 28 produced produce VBN 31417 1590 29 fraudulently fraudulently RB 31417 1590 30 by by IN 31417 1590 31 Dr. Dr. NNP 31417 1590 32 Speer Speer NNP 31417 1590 33 or or CC 31417 1590 34 other other JJ 31417 1590 35 sitters sitter NNS 31417 1590 36 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1590 37 regard regard VBP 31417 1590 38 as as IN 31417 1590 39 proved prove VBN 31417 1590 40 both both CC 31417 1590 41 by by IN 31417 1590 42 moral moral JJ 31417 1590 43 considerations consideration NNS 31417 1590 44 and and CC 31417 1590 45 by by IN 31417 1590 46 the the DT 31417 1590 47 fact fact NN 31417 1590 48 that that IN 31417 1590 49 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1590 50 are be VBP 31417 1590 51 constantly constantly RB 31417 1590 52 reported report VBN 31417 1590 53 as as IN 31417 1590 54 occurring occur VBG 31417 1590 55 when when WRB 31417 1590 56 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1590 57 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1590 58 was be VBD 31417 1590 59 alone alone JJ 31417 1590 60 . . . 31417 1591 1 That that IN 31417 1591 2 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1591 3 Moses Moses NNP 31417 1591 4 should should MD 31417 1591 5 have have VB 31417 1591 6 himself -PRON- PRP 31417 1591 7 fraudulently fraudulently RB 31417 1591 8 produced produce VBN 31417 1591 9 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1591 10 , , , 31417 1591 11 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1591 12 regard regard VBP 31417 1591 13 as as IN 31417 1591 14 both both DT 31417 1591 15 morally morally RB 31417 1591 16 and and CC 31417 1591 17 physically physically RB 31417 1591 18 incredible incredible JJ 31417 1591 19 . . . 31417 1592 1 That that IN 31417 1592 2 he -PRON- PRP 31417 1592 3 should should MD 31417 1592 4 have have VB 31417 1592 5 prepared prepare VBN 31417 1592 6 and and CC 31417 1592 7 produced produce VBN 31417 1592 8 them -PRON- PRP 31417 1592 9 in in IN 31417 1592 10 a a DT 31417 1592 11 state state NN 31417 1592 12 of of IN 31417 1592 13 trance trance NN 31417 1592 14 , , , 31417 1592 15 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1592 16 regard regard VBP 31417 1592 17 both both DT 31417 1592 18 as as IN 31417 1592 19 physically physically RB 31417 1592 20 incredible incredible JJ 31417 1592 21 , , , 31417 1592 22 and and CC 31417 1592 23 also also RB 31417 1592 24 as as IN 31417 1592 25 entirely entirely RB 31417 1592 26 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 31417 1592 27 with with IN 31417 1592 28 the the DT 31417 1592 29 tenour tenour NN 31417 1592 30 both both DT 31417 1592 31 of of IN 31417 1592 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1592 33 own own JJ 31417 1592 34 reports report NNS 31417 1592 35 and and CC 31417 1592 36 of of IN 31417 1592 37 those those DT 31417 1592 38 of of IN 31417 1592 39 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1592 40 friends friend NNS 31417 1592 41 . . . 31417 1593 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1593 2 therefore therefore RB 31417 1593 3 regard regard VBP 31417 1593 4 the the DT 31417 1593 5 reported reported JJ 31417 1593 6 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 1593 7 as as IN 31417 1593 8 having have VBG 31417 1593 9 actually actually RB 31417 1593 10 occurred occur VBN 31417 1593 11 in in IN 31417 1593 12 a a DT 31417 1593 13 genuinely genuinely RB 31417 1593 14 supernormal supernormal JJ 31417 1593 15 manner manner NN 31417 1593 16 . . . 31417 1594 1 " " `` 31417 1594 2 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1594 3 79 79 CD 31417 1594 4 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1594 5 At at IN 31417 1594 6 the the DT 31417 1594 7 same same JJ 31417 1594 8 time time NN 31417 1594 9 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1594 10 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1594 11 believed believe VBD 31417 1594 12 in in IN 31417 1594 13 the the DT 31417 1594 14 existence existence NN 31417 1594 15 of of IN 31417 1594 16 a a DT 31417 1594 17 large large JJ 31417 1594 18 amount amount NN 31417 1594 19 of of IN 31417 1594 20 conscious conscious JJ 31417 1594 21 and and CC 31417 1594 22 wilful wilful JJ 31417 1594 23 fraud fraud NN 31417 1594 24 , , , 31417 1594 25 especially especially RB 31417 1594 26 in in IN 31417 1594 27 professional professional JJ 31417 1594 28 mediumship mediumship NN 31417 1594 29 . . . 31417 1595 1 * * NFP 31417 1595 2 * * NFP 31417 1595 3 * * NFP 31417 1595 4 * * NFP 31417 1595 5 * * NFP 31417 1595 6 There there EX 31417 1595 7 will will MD 31417 1595 8 be be VB 31417 1595 9 no no DT 31417 1595 10 fitter fitter NN 31417 1595 11 conclusion conclusion NN 31417 1595 12 to to IN 31417 1595 13 this this DT 31417 1595 14 volume volume NN 31417 1595 15 than than IN 31417 1595 16 a a DT 31417 1595 17 few few JJ 31417 1595 18 passages passage NNS 31417 1595 19 from from IN 31417 1595 20 the the DT 31417 1595 21 last last JJ 31417 1595 22 chapter chapter NN 31417 1595 23 , , , 31417 1595 24 entitled entitle VBN 31417 1595 25 " " `` 31417 1595 26 Epilogue Epilogue NNP 31417 1595 27 , , , 31417 1595 28 " " '' 31417 1595 29 of of IN 31417 1595 30 " " `` 31417 1595 31 Human Human NNP 31417 1595 32 Personality Personality NNP 31417 1595 33 , , , 31417 1595 34 " " '' 31417 1595 35 by by IN 31417 1595 36 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1595 37 F. F. NNP 31417 1595 38 W. W. NNP 31417 1595 39 H. H. NNP 31417 1595 40 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1595 41 . . . 31417 1596 1 To to IN 31417 1596 2 a a DT 31417 1596 3 large large JJ 31417 1596 4 extent extent NN 31417 1596 5 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1596 6 are be VBP 31417 1596 7 appropriate appropriate JJ 31417 1596 8 to to IN 31417 1596 9 the the DT 31417 1596 10 evidence evidence NN 31417 1596 11 presented present VBN 31417 1596 12 in in IN 31417 1596 13 the the DT 31417 1596 14 preceding precede VBG 31417 1596 15 pages page NNS 31417 1596 16 . . . 31417 1597 1 " " `` 31417 1597 2 The the DT 31417 1597 3 task task NN 31417 1597 4 which which WDT 31417 1597 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1597 6 proposed propose VBD 31417 1597 7 to to IN 31417 1597 8 myself -PRON- PRP 31417 1597 9 at at IN 31417 1597 10 the the DT 31417 1597 11 beginning beginning NN 31417 1597 12 of of IN 31417 1597 13 this this DT 31417 1597 14 work work NN 31417 1597 15 , , , 31417 1597 16 is be VBZ 31417 1597 17 now now RB 31417 1597 18 , , , 31417 1597 19 after after IN 31417 1597 20 a a DT 31417 1597 21 fashion fashion NN 31417 1597 22 , , , 31417 1597 23 accomplished accomplish VBN 31417 1597 24 . . . 31417 1598 1 Following follow VBG 31417 1598 2 the the DT 31417 1598 3 successive successive JJ 31417 1598 4 steps step NNS 31417 1598 5 of of IN 31417 1598 6 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1598 7 programme programme NN 31417 1598 8 , , , 31417 1598 9 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1598 10 have have VBP 31417 1598 11 presented present VBN 31417 1598 12 -- -- : 31417 1598 13 not not RB 31417 1598 14 indeed indeed RB 31417 1598 15 all all PDT 31417 1598 16 the the DT 31417 1598 17 evidence evidence NN 31417 1598 18 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1598 19 possess possess VBP 31417 1598 20 , , , 31417 1598 21 and and CC 31417 1598 22 which which WDT 31417 1598 23 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1598 24 would would MD 31417 1598 25 willingly willingly RB 31417 1598 26 present present VB 31417 1598 27 -- -- : 31417 1598 28 but but CC 31417 1598 29 enough enough JJ 31417 1598 30 at at IN 31417 1598 31 least least RBS 31417 1598 32 to to TO 31417 1598 33 illustrate illustrate VB 31417 1598 34 a a DT 31417 1598 35 continuous continuous JJ 31417 1598 36 exposition exposition NN 31417 1598 37 .... .... . 31417 1599 1 Such such JJ 31417 1599 2 wider wide JJR 31417 1599 3 generalisations generalisation NNS 31417 1599 4 as as IN 31417 1599 5 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1599 6 may may MD 31417 1599 7 now now RB 31417 1599 8 add add VB 31417 1599 9 , , , 31417 1599 10 must must MD 31417 1599 11 needs needs VB 31417 1599 12 be be VB 31417 1599 13 dangerously dangerously RB 31417 1599 14 speculative speculative JJ 31417 1599 15 ; ; : 31417 1599 16 they -PRON- PRP 31417 1599 17 must must MD 31417 1599 18 run run VB 31417 1599 19 the the DT 31417 1599 20 risk risk NN 31417 1599 21 of of IN 31417 1599 22 alienating alienate VBG 31417 1599 23 still still RB 31417 1599 24 further further RB 31417 1599 25 from from IN 31417 1599 26 this this DT 31417 1599 27 research research NN 31417 1599 28 many many JJ 31417 1599 29 of of IN 31417 1599 30 the the DT 31417 1599 31 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1599 32 minds mind NNS 31417 1599 33 which which WDT 31417 1599 34 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1599 35 am be VBP 31417 1599 36 most most RBS 31417 1599 37 anxious anxious JJ 31417 1599 38 to to TO 31417 1599 39 influence influence VB 31417 1599 40 .... .... . 31417 1599 41 " " '' 31417 1599 42 The the DT 31417 1599 43 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1599 44 falls fall VBZ 31417 1599 45 between between IN 31417 1599 46 the the DT 31417 1599 47 two two CD 31417 1599 48 stools stool NNS 31417 1599 49 of of IN 31417 1599 50 religion religion NN 31417 1599 51 and and CC 31417 1599 52 science science NN 31417 1599 53 ; ; : 31417 1599 54 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1599 55 can can MD 31417 1599 56 not not RB 31417 1599 57 claim claim VB 31417 1599 58 support support NN 31417 1599 59 either either CC 31417 1599 60 from from IN 31417 1599 61 the the DT 31417 1599 62 ' ' `` 31417 1599 63 religious religious JJ 31417 1599 64 world world NN 31417 1599 65 ' ' '' 31417 1599 66 or or CC 31417 1599 67 from from IN 31417 1599 68 the the DT 31417 1599 69 Royal Royal NNP 31417 1599 70 Society Society NNP 31417 1599 71 . . . 31417 1600 1 Yet yet RB 31417 1600 2 even even RB 31417 1600 3 apart apart RB 31417 1600 4 from from IN 31417 1600 5 the the DT 31417 1600 6 instinct instinct NN 31417 1600 7 of of IN 31417 1600 8 pure pure JJ 31417 1600 9 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1600 10 curiosity curiosity NN 31417 1600 11 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1600 12 which which WDT 31417 1600 13 surely surely RB 31417 1600 14 has have VBZ 31417 1600 15 seldom seldom RB 31417 1600 16 seen see VBN 31417 1600 17 such such PDT 31417 1600 18 a a DT 31417 1600 19 field field NN 31417 1600 20 opening open VBG 31417 1600 21 before before IN 31417 1600 22 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1600 23 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1600 24 , , , 31417 1600 25 the the DT 31417 1600 26 mighty mighty JJ 31417 1600 27 issues issue NNS 31417 1600 28 depending depend VBG 31417 1600 29 on on IN 31417 1600 30 these these DT 31417 1600 31 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1600 32 ought ought MD 31417 1600 33 , , , 31417 1600 34 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1600 35 think think VBP 31417 1600 36 , , , 31417 1600 37 to to TO 31417 1600 38 constitute constitute VB 31417 1600 39 in in IN 31417 1600 40 themselves -PRON- PRP 31417 1600 41 a a DT 31417 1600 42 strong strong JJ 31417 1600 43 , , , 31417 1600 44 an an DT 31417 1600 45 exceptional exceptional JJ 31417 1600 46 appeal appeal NN 31417 1600 47 . . . 31417 1601 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1601 2 desire desire VBP 31417 1601 3 in in IN 31417 1601 4 this this DT 31417 1601 5 book book NN 31417 1601 6 to to TO 31417 1601 7 emphasise emphasise VB 31417 1601 8 that that DT 31417 1601 9 appeal appeal NN 31417 1601 10 ; ; : 31417 1601 11 not not RB 31417 1601 12 only only RB 31417 1601 13 to to TO 31417 1601 14 produce produce VB 31417 1601 15 conviction conviction NN 31417 1601 16 , , , 31417 1601 17 but but CC 31417 1601 18 also also RB 31417 1601 19 to to TO 31417 1601 20 attract attract VB 31417 1601 21 co co NN 31417 1601 22 - - NN 31417 1601 23 operation operation NN 31417 1601 24 . . . 31417 1602 1 And and CC 31417 1602 2 actual actual JJ 31417 1602 3 converse converse NN 31417 1602 4 with with IN 31417 1602 5 many many JJ 31417 1602 6 persons person NNS 31417 1602 7 has have VBZ 31417 1602 8 led lead VBN 31417 1602 9 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1602 10 to to TO 31417 1602 11 believe believe VB 31417 1602 12 that that IN 31417 1602 13 in in IN 31417 1602 14 order order NN 31417 1602 15 to to TO 31417 1602 16 attract attract VB 31417 1602 17 such such JJ 31417 1602 18 help help NN 31417 1602 19 , , , 31417 1602 20 even even RB 31417 1602 21 from from IN 31417 1602 22 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1602 23 men man NNS 31417 1602 24 , , , 31417 1602 25 some some DT 31417 1602 26 general general JJ 31417 1602 27 view view NN 31417 1602 28 of of IN 31417 1602 29 the the DT 31417 1602 30 moral moral JJ 31417 1602 31 upshot upshot NN 31417 1602 32 of of IN 31417 1602 33 all all PDT 31417 1602 34 the the DT 31417 1602 35 phenomena phenomena NN 31417 1602 36 is be VBZ 31417 1602 37 needed need VBN 31417 1602 38 .... .... . 31417 1603 1 The the DT 31417 1603 2 time time NN 31417 1603 3 is be VBZ 31417 1603 4 ripe ripe JJ 31417 1603 5 for for IN 31417 1603 6 a a DT 31417 1603 7 study study NN 31417 1603 8 of of IN 31417 1603 9 unseen unseen JJ 31417 1603 10 things thing NNS 31417 1603 11 as as IN 31417 1603 12 strenuous strenuous JJ 31417 1603 13 and and CC 31417 1603 14 sincere sincere JJ 31417 1603 15 as as IN 31417 1603 16 that that DT 31417 1603 17 which which WDT 31417 1603 18 Science Science NNP 31417 1603 19 has have VBZ 31417 1603 20 made make VBN 31417 1603 21 familiar familiar JJ 31417 1603 22 for for IN 31417 1603 23 the the DT 31417 1603 24 problems problem NNS 31417 1603 25 of of IN 31417 1603 26 earth earth NN 31417 1603 27 . . . 31417 1603 28 " " '' 31417 1604 1 Coming come VBG 31417 1604 2 now now RB 31417 1604 3 to to IN 31417 1604 4 more more RBR 31417 1604 5 definite definite JJ 31417 1604 6 considerations consideration NNS 31417 1604 7 , , , 31417 1604 8 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1604 9 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1604 10 writes write VBZ 31417 1604 11 thus thus RB 31417 1604 12 of of IN 31417 1604 13 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1604 14 , , , 31417 1604 15 lifting lift VBG 31417 1604 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1604 17 on on RP 31417 1604 18 to to IN 31417 1604 19 an an DT 31417 1604 20 altogether altogether RB 31417 1604 21 higher high JJR 31417 1604 22 plane plane NN 31417 1604 23 : : : 31417 1604 24 " " `` 31417 1604 25 In in IN 31417 1604 26 the the DT 31417 1604 27 infinite infinite JJ 31417 1604 28 Universe Universe NNP 31417 1604 29 man man NN 31417 1604 30 may may MD 31417 1604 31 now now RB 31417 1604 32 feel feel VB 31417 1604 33 , , , 31417 1604 34 for for IN 31417 1604 35 the the DT 31417 1604 36 first first JJ 31417 1604 37 time time NN 31417 1604 38 , , , 31417 1604 39 at at IN 31417 1604 40 home home NN 31417 1604 41 . . . 31417 1605 1 The the DT 31417 1605 2 worst bad JJS 31417 1605 3 fear fear NN 31417 1605 4 is be VBZ 31417 1605 5 over over RB 31417 1605 6 ; ; : 31417 1605 7 the the DT 31417 1605 8 true true JJ 31417 1605 9 security security NN 31417 1605 10 is be VBZ 31417 1605 11 won win VBN 31417 1605 12 . . . 31417 1606 1 The the DT 31417 1606 2 worst bad JJS 31417 1606 3 fear fear NN 31417 1606 4 was be VBD 31417 1606 5 the the DT 31417 1606 6 fear fear NN 31417 1606 7 of of IN 31417 1606 8 spiritual spiritual JJ 31417 1606 9 extinction extinction NN 31417 1606 10 or or CC 31417 1606 11 spiritual spiritual JJ 31417 1606 12 solitude solitude NN 31417 1606 13 . . . 31417 1607 1 The the DT 31417 1607 2 true true JJ 31417 1607 3 security security NN 31417 1607 4 is be VBZ 31417 1607 5 in in IN 31417 1607 6 the the DT 31417 1607 7 telepathic telepathic JJ 31417 1607 8 law law NN 31417 1607 9 . . . 31417 1608 1 Let let VB 31417 1608 2 me -PRON- PRP 31417 1608 3 draw draw VB 31417 1608 4 out out RP 31417 1608 5 my -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1608 6 meaning meaning NN 31417 1608 7 at at IN 31417 1608 8 somewhat somewhat RB 31417 1608 9 greater great JJR 31417 1608 10 length length NN 31417 1608 11 . . . 31417 1609 1 As as IN 31417 1609 2 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1609 3 have have VBP 31417 1609 4 dwelt dwell VBN 31417 1609 5 successively successively RB 31417 1609 6 on on IN 31417 1609 7 various various JJ 31417 1609 8 aspects aspect NNS 31417 1609 9 of of IN 31417 1609 10 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1609 11 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1609 12 have have VBP 31417 1609 13 gradually gradually RB 31417 1609 14 felt feel VBN 31417 1609 15 the the DT 31417 1609 16 conception conception NN 31417 1609 17 enlarge enlarge NN 31417 1609 18 and and CC 31417 1609 19 deepen deepen VB 31417 1609 20 under under IN 31417 1609 21 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1609 22 study study NN 31417 1609 23 . . . 31417 1610 1 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1610 2 began begin VBD 31417 1610 3 as as IN 31417 1610 4 a a DT 31417 1610 5 quasi quasi JJ 31417 1610 6 - - JJ 31417 1610 7 mechanical mechanical JJ 31417 1610 8 transference transference NN 31417 1610 9 of of IN 31417 1610 10 ideas idea NNS 31417 1610 11 and and CC 31417 1610 12 images image NNS 31417 1610 13 from from IN 31417 1610 14 one one CD 31417 1610 15 to to IN 31417 1610 16 another another DT 31417 1610 17 brain brain NN 31417 1610 18 . . . 31417 1610 19 " " '' 31417 1611 1 This this DT 31417 1611 2 is be VBZ 31417 1611 3 illustrated illustrate VBN 31417 1611 4 by by IN 31417 1611 5 the the DT 31417 1611 6 series series NN 31417 1611 7 of of IN 31417 1611 8 Thought Thought NNP 31417 1611 9 - - HYPH 31417 1611 10 Transference Transference NNP 31417 1611 11 Drawings Drawings NNPS 31417 1611 12 ; ; : 31417 1611 13 almost almost RB 31417 1611 14 the the DT 31417 1611 15 only only JJ 31417 1611 16 telepathic telepathic JJ 31417 1611 17 manifestation manifestation NN 31417 1611 18 which which WDT 31417 1611 19 strictly strictly RB 31417 1611 20 comes come VBZ 31417 1611 21 within within IN 31417 1611 22 the the DT 31417 1611 23 scope scope NN 31417 1611 24 of of IN 31417 1611 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1611 26 inquiry inquiry NN 31417 1611 27 into into IN 31417 1611 28 physical physical JJ 31417 1611 29 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1611 30 . . . 31417 1612 1 " " `` 31417 1612 2 Presently presently RB 31417 1612 3 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1612 4 find find VBP 31417 1612 5 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1612 6 assuming assume VBG 31417 1612 7 a a DT 31417 1612 8 more more RBR 31417 1612 9 varied varied JJ 31417 1612 10 and and CC 31417 1612 11 potent potent JJ 31417 1612 12 form form NN 31417 1612 13 , , , 31417 1612 14 as as IN 31417 1612 15 though though IN 31417 1612 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1612 17 were be VBD 31417 1612 18 the the DT 31417 1612 19 veritable veritable JJ 31417 1612 20 influence influence NN 31417 1612 21 or or CC 31417 1612 22 invasion invasion NN 31417 1612 23 of of IN 31417 1612 24 a a DT 31417 1612 25 distant distant JJ 31417 1612 26 mind mind NN 31417 1612 27 . . . 31417 1613 1 Again again RB 31417 1613 2 , , , 31417 1613 3 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1613 4 action action NN 31417 1613 5 was be VBD 31417 1613 6 traced trace VBN 31417 1613 7 across across IN 31417 1613 8 a a DT 31417 1613 9 gulf gulf NNP 31417 1613 10 greater great JJR 31417 1613 11 than than IN 31417 1613 12 any any DT 31417 1613 13 space space NN 31417 1613 14 of of IN 31417 1613 15 earth earth NN 31417 1613 16 or or CC 31417 1613 17 ocean ocean NN 31417 1613 18 , , , 31417 1613 19 and and CC 31417 1613 20 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1613 21 bridged bridge VBD 31417 1613 22 the the DT 31417 1613 23 interval interval NN 31417 1613 24 between between IN 31417 1613 25 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1613 26 incarnate incarnate VBP 31417 1613 27 and and CC 31417 1613 28 discarnate discarnate VBP 31417 1613 29 , , , 31417 1613 30 between between IN 31417 1613 31 the the DT 31417 1613 32 visible visible JJ 31417 1613 33 and and CC 31417 1613 34 the the DT 31417 1613 35 invisible invisible JJ 31417 1613 36 world world NN 31417 1613 37 . . . 31417 1614 1 There there EX 31417 1614 2 seemed seem VBD 31417 1614 3 no no DT 31417 1614 4 limit limit NN 31417 1614 5 to to IN 31417 1614 6 the the DT 31417 1614 7 distance distance NN 31417 1614 8 of of IN 31417 1614 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1614 10 operation operation NN 31417 1614 11 , , , 31417 1614 12 or or CC 31417 1614 13 to to IN 31417 1614 14 the the DT 31417 1614 15 intimacy intimacy NN 31417 1614 16 of of IN 31417 1614 17 its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1614 18 appeal appeal NN 31417 1614 19 .... .... . 31417 1614 20 " " '' 31417 1614 21 Love love NN 31417 1614 22 ... ... : 31417 1614 23 is be VBZ 31417 1614 24 no no DT 31417 1614 25 matter matter NN 31417 1614 26 of of IN 31417 1614 27 carnal carnal JJ 31417 1614 28 impulse impulse NN 31417 1614 29 or or CC 31417 1614 30 of of IN 31417 1614 31 emotional emotional JJ 31417 1614 32 caprice caprice NN 31417 1614 33 .... .... . 31417 1614 34 Love love NN 31417 1614 35 is be VBZ 31417 1614 36 a a DT 31417 1614 37 kind kind NN 31417 1614 38 of of IN 31417 1614 39 exalted exalted JJ 31417 1614 40 but but CC 31417 1614 41 unspecialised unspecialise VBD 31417 1614 42 Telepathy;--the telepathy;--the DT 31417 1614 43 simplest simple JJS 31417 1614 44 and and CC 31417 1614 45 most most RBS 31417 1614 46 universal universal JJ 31417 1614 47 expression expression NN 31417 1614 48 of of IN 31417 1614 49 that that DT 31417 1614 50 mutual mutual JJ 31417 1614 51 gravitation gravitation NN 31417 1614 52 or or CC 31417 1614 53 kinship kinship NN 31417 1614 54 of of IN 31417 1614 55 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1614 56 which which WDT 31417 1614 57 is be VBZ 31417 1614 58 the the DT 31417 1614 59 foundation foundation NN 31417 1614 60 of of IN 31417 1614 61 the the DT 31417 1614 62 telepathic telepathic JJ 31417 1614 63 law law NN 31417 1614 64 . . . 31417 1615 1 This this DT 31417 1615 2 is be VBZ 31417 1615 3 the the DT 31417 1615 4 answer answer NN 31417 1615 5 to to IN 31417 1615 6 the the DT 31417 1615 7 ancient ancient JJ 31417 1615 8 fear fear NN 31417 1615 9 ; ; : 31417 1615 10 the the DT 31417 1615 11 fear fear NN 31417 1615 12 lest l JJS 31417 1615 13 man man NN 31417 1615 14 's 's POS 31417 1615 15 fellowships fellowship NNS 31417 1615 16 be be VB 31417 1615 17 the the DT 31417 1615 18 outward outward NN 31417 1615 19 , , , 31417 1615 20 and and CC 31417 1615 21 his -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1615 22 solitude solitude NN 31417 1615 23 the the DT 31417 1615 24 inward inward JJ 31417 1615 25 thing thing NN 31417 1615 26 .... .... . 31417 1616 1 Such such JJ 31417 1616 2 fears fear NNS 31417 1616 3 vanish vanish VBP 31417 1616 4 when when WRB 31417 1616 5 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1616 6 learn learn VBP 31417 1616 7 that that IN 31417 1616 8 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1616 9 is be VBZ 31417 1616 10 the the DT 31417 1616 11 soul soul NN 31417 1616 12 in in IN 31417 1616 13 man man NN 31417 1616 14 which which WDT 31417 1616 15 links link VBZ 31417 1616 16 him -PRON- PRP 31417 1616 17 with with IN 31417 1616 18 other other JJ 31417 1616 19 souls soul NNS 31417 1616 20 ; ; : 31417 1616 21 the the DT 31417 1616 22 body body NN 31417 1616 23 which which WDT 31417 1616 24 dissevers dissever NNS 31417 1616 25 even even RB 31417 1616 26 while while IN 31417 1616 27 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1616 28 seems seem VBZ 31417 1616 29 to to TO 31417 1616 30 unite unite VB 31417 1616 31 .... .... . 31417 1616 32 Like like IN 31417 1616 33 atoms atom NNS 31417 1616 34 , , , 31417 1616 35 like like IN 31417 1616 36 suns sun NNS 31417 1616 37 , , , 31417 1616 38 like like IN 31417 1616 39 galaxies galaxy NNS 31417 1616 40 , , , 31417 1616 41 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1616 42 spirits spirit NNS 31417 1616 43 are be VBP 31417 1616 44 systems system NNS 31417 1616 45 of of IN 31417 1616 46 forces force NNS 31417 1616 47 which which WDT 31417 1616 48 vibrate vibrate VBP 31417 1616 49 continually continually RB 31417 1616 50 to to IN 31417 1616 51 each each DT 31417 1616 52 other other JJ 31417 1616 53 's 's POS 31417 1616 54 attractive attractive JJ 31417 1616 55 power power NN 31417 1616 56 . . . 31417 1616 57 " " '' 31417 1617 1 For for IN 31417 1617 2 the the DT 31417 1617 3 further further RB 31417 1617 4 working work VBG 31417 1617 5 out out IN 31417 1617 6 of of IN 31417 1617 7 these these DT 31417 1617 8 thoughts thought NNS 31417 1617 9 the the DT 31417 1617 10 reader reader NN 31417 1617 11 must must MD 31417 1617 12 be be VB 31417 1617 13 referred refer VBN 31417 1617 14 to to IN 31417 1617 15 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1617 16 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1617 17 ' ' POS 31417 1617 18 book book NN 31417 1617 19 itself -PRON- PRP 31417 1617 20 . . . 31417 1618 1 After after IN 31417 1618 2 a a DT 31417 1618 3 few few JJ 31417 1618 4 pages page NNS 31417 1618 5 Mr. Mr. NNP 31417 1618 6 Myers Myers NNP 31417 1618 7 proceeds:-- proceeds:-- `` 31417 1618 8 " " `` 31417 1618 9 Our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1618 10 duty duty NN 31417 1618 11 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1618 12 the the DT 31417 1618 13 duty duty NN 31417 1618 14 of of IN 31417 1618 15 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1618 16 Researchers Researchers NNPS 31417 1618 17 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1618 18 is be VBZ 31417 1618 19 not not RB 31417 1618 20 the the DT 31417 1618 21 founding founding NN 31417 1618 22 of of IN 31417 1618 23 a a DT 31417 1618 24 new new JJ 31417 1618 25 sect sect NN 31417 1618 26 , , , 31417 1618 27 nor nor CC 31417 1618 28 even even RB 31417 1618 29 the the DT 31417 1618 30 establishment establishment NN 31417 1618 31 of of IN 31417 1618 32 a a DT 31417 1618 33 new new JJ 31417 1618 34 science science NN 31417 1618 35 , , , 31417 1618 36 but but CC 31417 1618 37 is be VBZ 31417 1618 38 rather rather RB 31417 1618 39 the the DT 31417 1618 40 expansion expansion NN 31417 1618 41 of of IN 31417 1618 42 Science Science NNP 31417 1618 43 herself -PRON- PRP 31417 1618 44 until until IN 31417 1618 45 she -PRON- PRP 31417 1618 46 can can MD 31417 1618 47 satisfy satisfy VB 31417 1618 48 those those DT 31417 1618 49 questions question NNS 31417 1618 50 , , , 31417 1618 51 which which WDT 31417 1618 52 the the DT 31417 1618 53 human human JJ 31417 1618 54 heart heart NN 31417 1618 55 will will MD 31417 1618 56 rightly rightly RB 31417 1618 57 ask ask VB 31417 1618 58 , , , 31417 1618 59 but but CC 31417 1618 60 to to TO 31417 1618 61 which which WDT 31417 1618 62 Religion religion NN 31417 1618 63 alone alone RB 31417 1618 64 has have VBZ 31417 1618 65 thus thus RB 31417 1618 66 far far RB 31417 1618 67 attempted attempt VBN 31417 1618 68 an an DT 31417 1618 69 answer answer NN 31417 1618 70 .... .... . 31417 1619 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1619 2 see see VBP 31417 1619 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1619 4 original original JJ 31417 1619 5 programme programme NN 31417 1619 6 completely completely RB 31417 1619 7 justified justify VBN 31417 1619 8 .... .... . 31417 1620 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1620 2 see see VBP 31417 1620 3 all all DT 31417 1620 4 things thing NNS 31417 1620 5 coming come VBG 31417 1620 6 to to TO 31417 1620 7 pass pass VB 31417 1620 8 as as IN 31417 1620 9 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1620 10 foresaw foresaw VBP 31417 1620 11 . . . 31417 1621 1 What what WP 31417 1621 2 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1621 3 do do VBP 31417 1621 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1621 5 not not RB 31417 1621 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1621 7 see see VB 31417 1621 8 , , , 31417 1621 9 alas alas UH 31417 1621 10 ! ! . 31417 1622 1 is be VBZ 31417 1622 2 an an DT 31417 1622 3 energy energy NN 31417 1622 4 and and CC 31417 1622 5 capacity capacity NN 31417 1622 6 of of IN 31417 1622 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1622 8 own own JJ 31417 1622 9 , , , 31417 1622 10 sufficient sufficient JJ 31417 1622 11 for for IN 31417 1622 12 our -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1622 13 widening widen VBG 31417 1622 14 duty duty NN 31417 1622 15 .... .... . 31417 1622 16 We -PRON- PRP 31417 1622 17 invite invite VBP 31417 1622 18 workers worker NNS 31417 1622 19 from from IN 31417 1622 20 each each DT 31417 1622 21 department department NN 31417 1622 22 of of IN 31417 1622 23 science science NNP 31417 1622 24 , , , 31417 1622 25 from from IN 31417 1622 26 every every DT 31417 1622 27 school school NN 31417 1622 28 of of IN 31417 1622 29 thought thought NN 31417 1622 30 . . . 31417 1623 1 With with IN 31417 1623 2 equal equal JJ 31417 1623 3 confidence confidence NN 31417 1623 4 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1623 5 appeal appeal VBP 31417 1623 6 for for IN 31417 1623 7 co co NN 31417 1623 8 - - NN 31417 1623 9 operation operation NN 31417 1623 10 to to IN 31417 1623 11 _ _ NNP 31417 1623 12 savant savant JJ 31417 1623 13 _ _ NNP 31417 1623 14 and and CC 31417 1623 15 to to IN 31417 1623 16 saint saint VB 31417 1623 17 . . . 31417 1624 1 " " `` 31417 1624 2 To to IN 31417 1624 3 the the DT 31417 1624 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1624 5 savant savant JJ 31417 1624 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1624 7 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1624 8 point point VBP 31417 1624 9 out out RP 31417 1624 10 that that IN 31417 1624 11 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1624 12 are be VBP 31417 1624 13 not not RB 31417 1624 14 trying try VBG 31417 1624 15 to to TO 31417 1624 16 pick pick VB 31417 1624 17 holes hole NNS 31417 1624 18 in in IN 31417 1624 19 the the DT 31417 1624 20 order order NN 31417 1624 21 of of IN 31417 1624 22 Nature nature NN 31417 1624 23 , , , 31417 1624 24 but but CC 31417 1624 25 rather rather RB 31417 1624 26 by by IN 31417 1624 27 the the DT 31417 1624 28 scrutiny scrutiny NN 31417 1624 29 of of IN 31417 1624 30 residual residual JJ 31417 1624 31 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1624 32 , , , 31417 1624 33 to to TO 31417 1624 34 get get VB 31417 1624 35 nearer nearer RB 31417 1624 36 to to IN 31417 1624 37 the the DT 31417 1624 38 origin origin NN 31417 1624 39 and and CC 31417 1624 40 operation operation NN 31417 1624 41 of of IN 31417 1624 42 Nature Nature NNP 31417 1624 43 's 's POS 31417 1624 44 central central JJ 31417 1624 45 mystery mystery NN 31417 1624 46 of of IN 31417 1624 47 Life Life NNP 31417 1624 48 . . . 31417 1625 1 Men man NNS 31417 1625 2 who who WP 31417 1625 3 realise realise VBP 31417 1625 4 that that IN 31417 1625 5 the the DT 31417 1625 6 ethereal ethereal JJ 31417 1625 7 environment environment NN 31417 1625 8 was be VBD 31417 1625 9 discovered discover VBN 31417 1625 10 yesterday yesterday NN 31417 1625 11 , , , 31417 1625 12 need nee MD 31417 1625 13 not not RB 31417 1625 14 deem deem VB 31417 1625 15 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1625 16 impossible impossible JJ 31417 1625 17 that that IN 31417 1625 18 a a DT 31417 1625 19 metethereal metethereal NN 31417 1625 20 environment environment NN 31417 1625 21 -- -- : 31417 1625 22 yet yet RB 31417 1625 23 another another DT 31417 1625 24 omnipresent omnipresent JJ 31417 1625 25 system system NN 31417 1625 26 of of IN 31417 1625 27 cosmic cosmic JJ 31417 1625 28 law law NN 31417 1625 29 -- -- : 31417 1625 30 should should MD 31417 1625 31 be be VB 31417 1625 32 discovered discover VBN 31417 1625 33 to to IN 31417 1625 34 - - HYPH 31417 1625 35 morrow morrow NNP 31417 1625 36 . . . 31417 1626 1 The the DT 31417 1626 2 only only JJ 31417 1626 3 valid valid JJ 31417 1626 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1626 5 a a DT 31417 1626 6 priori priori FW 31417 1626 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1626 8 presumption presumption NN 31417 1626 9 in in IN 31417 1626 10 the the DT 31417 1626 11 matter matter NN 31417 1626 12 , , , 31417 1626 13 is be VBZ 31417 1626 14 the the DT 31417 1626 15 presumption presumption NN 31417 1626 16 that that IN 31417 1626 17 the the DT 31417 1626 18 Universe Universe NNP 31417 1626 19 is be VBZ 31417 1626 20 infinite infinite JJ 31417 1626 21 in in IN 31417 1626 22 an an DT 31417 1626 23 infinite infinite JJ 31417 1626 24 number number NN 31417 1626 25 of of IN 31417 1626 26 ways way NNS 31417 1626 27 . . . 31417 1627 1 " " `` 31417 1627 2 To to IN 31417 1627 3 the the DT 31417 1627 4 Christian Christian NNP 31417 1627 5 we -PRON- PRP 31417 1627 6 can can MD 31417 1627 7 speak speak VB 31417 1627 8 with with IN 31417 1627 9 a a DT 31417 1627 10 still still RB 31417 1627 11 more more RBR 31417 1627 12 direct direct JJ 31417 1627 13 appeal appeal NN 31417 1627 14 . . . 31417 1628 1 You -PRON- PRP 31417 1628 2 believe believe VBP 31417 1628 3 -- -- : 31417 1628 4 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1628 5 would would MD 31417 1628 6 say say VB 31417 1628 7 -- -- : 31417 1628 8 that that IN 31417 1628 9 a a DT 31417 1628 10 spiritual spiritual JJ 31417 1628 11 world world NN 31417 1628 12 exists exist VBZ 31417 1628 13 , , , 31417 1628 14 and and CC 31417 1628 15 that that IN 31417 1628 16 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1628 17 acted act VBD 31417 1628 18 on on IN 31417 1628 19 the the DT 31417 1628 20 material material NN 31417 1628 21 world world NN 31417 1628 22 two two CD 31417 1628 23 thousand thousand CD 31417 1628 24 years year NNS 31417 1628 25 ago ago RB 31417 1628 26 . . . 31417 1629 1 Surely surely RB 31417 1629 2 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1629 3 is be VBZ 31417 1629 4 so so RB 31417 1629 5 acting act VBG 31417 1629 6 still still RB 31417 1629 7 . . . 31417 1630 1 Nay nay UH 31417 1630 2 , , , 31417 1630 3 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1630 4 believe believe VBP 31417 1630 5 that that IN 31417 1630 6 it -PRON- PRP 31417 1630 7 is be VBZ 31417 1630 8 so so RB 31417 1630 9 acting act VBG 31417 1630 10 still still RB 31417 1630 11 , , , 31417 1630 12 for for IN 31417 1630 13 you -PRON- PRP 31417 1630 14 believe believe VBP 31417 1630 15 that that DT 31417 1630 16 prayer prayer NN 31417 1630 17 is be VBZ 31417 1630 18 heard hear VBN 31417 1630 19 and and CC 31417 1630 20 answered answer VBN 31417 1630 21 . . . 31417 1631 1 To to TO 31417 1631 2 believe believe VB 31417 1631 3 that that DT 31417 1631 4 prayer prayer NN 31417 1631 5 is be VBZ 31417 1631 6 heard hear VBN 31417 1631 7 is be VBZ 31417 1631 8 to to TO 31417 1631 9 believe believe VB 31417 1631 10 in in IN 31417 1631 11 Telepathy Telepathy NNP 31417 1631 12 -- -- : 31417 1631 13 in in IN 31417 1631 14 the the DT 31417 1631 15 direct direct JJ 31417 1631 16 influence influence NN 31417 1631 17 of of IN 31417 1631 18 mind mind NN 31417 1631 19 on on IN 31417 1631 20 mind mind NN 31417 1631 21 . . . 31417 1632 1 To to TO 31417 1632 2 believe believe VB 31417 1632 3 that that DT 31417 1632 4 prayer prayer NN 31417 1632 5 is be VBZ 31417 1632 6 answered answer VBN 31417 1632 7 is be VBZ 31417 1632 8 to to TO 31417 1632 9 believe believe VB 31417 1632 10 that that IN 31417 1632 11 unembodied unembodied JJ 31417 1632 12 spirit spirit NN 31417 1632 13 does do VBZ 31417 1632 14 actually actually RB 31417 1632 15 modify modify VB 31417 1632 16 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1632 17 even even RB 31417 1632 18 if if IN 31417 1632 19 not not RB 31417 1632 20 storm storm NN 31417 1632 21 - - HYPH 31417 1632 22 cloud cloud NN 31417 1632 23 or or CC 31417 1632 24 plague plague NN 31417 1632 25 - - HYPH 31417 1632 26 germ germ NN 31417 1632 27 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1632 28 at at IN 31417 1632 29 least least JJS 31417 1632 30 the the DT 31417 1632 31 minds mind NNS 31417 1632 32 , , , 31417 1632 33 and and CC 31417 1632 34 therefore therefore RB 31417 1632 35 the the DT 31417 1632 36 brains brain NNS 31417 1632 37 , , , 31417 1632 38 of of IN 31417 1632 39 living living NN 31417 1632 40 men man NNS 31417 1632 41 . . . 31417 1633 1 From from IN 31417 1633 2 that that DT 31417 1633 3 belief belief NN 31417 1633 4 the the DT 31417 1633 5 most most RBS 31417 1633 6 advanced advanced JJ 31417 1633 7 ' ' `` 31417 1633 8 psychical psychical JJ 31417 1633 9 ' ' '' 31417 1633 10 theories theory NNS 31417 1633 11 are be VBP 31417 1633 12 easy easy JJ 31417 1633 13 corollaries corollary NNS 31417 1633 14 . . . 31417 1633 15 " " '' 31417 1634 1 A a DT 31417 1634 2 few few JJ 31417 1634 3 more more JJR 31417 1634 4 lines line NNS 31417 1634 5 in in IN 31417 1634 6 conclusion:-- conclusion:-- NN 31417 1634 7 " " `` 31417 1634 8 It -PRON- PRP 31417 1634 9 may may MD 31417 1634 10 be be VB 31417 1634 11 that that IN 31417 1634 12 for for IN 31417 1634 13 some some DT 31417 1634 14 generations generation NNS 31417 1634 15 to to TO 31417 1634 16 come come VB 31417 1634 17 the the DT 31417 1634 18 truest true JJS 31417 1634 19 faith faith NN 31417 1634 20 will will MD 31417 1634 21 lie lie VB 31417 1634 22 in in IN 31417 1634 23 the the DT 31417 1634 24 patient patient JJ 31417 1634 25 attempt attempt NN 31417 1634 26 to to TO 31417 1634 27 unravel unravel VB 31417 1634 28 from from IN 31417 1634 29 confused confused JJ 31417 1634 30 phenomena phenomenon NNS 31417 1634 31 some some DT 31417 1634 32 trace trace NN 31417 1634 33 of of IN 31417 1634 34 the the DT 31417 1634 35 supernal supernal JJ 31417 1634 36 world;--to world;--to NNP 31417 1634 37 find find VBP 31417 1634 38 thus thus RB 31417 1634 39 at at IN 31417 1634 40 last last JJ 31417 1634 41 ' ' '' 31417 1634 42 the the DT 31417 1634 43 substance substance NN 31417 1634 44 of of IN 31417 1634 45 things thing NNS 31417 1634 46 hoped hope VBN 31417 1634 47 for for IN 31417 1634 48 , , , 31417 1634 49 the the DT 31417 1634 50 evidence evidence NN 31417 1634 51 of of IN 31417 1634 52 things thing NNS 31417 1634 53 not not RB 31417 1634 54 seen see VBN 31417 1634 55 . . . 31417 1634 56 ' ' '' 31417 1635 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1635 2 confess confess VBP 31417 1635 3 , , , 31417 1635 4 indeed indeed RB 31417 1635 5 , , , 31417 1635 6 that that IN 31417 1635 7 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1635 8 have have VBP 31417 1635 9 often often RB 31417 1635 10 felt feel VBN 31417 1635 11 as as IN 31417 1635 12 though though IN 31417 1635 13 this this DT 31417 1635 14 present present JJ 31417 1635 15 age age NN 31417 1635 16 were be VBD 31417 1635 17 even even RB 31417 1635 18 unduly unduly JJ 31417 1635 19 favoured;--as favoured;--as NN 31417 1635 20 though though IN 31417 1635 21 no no DT 31417 1635 22 future future JJ 31417 1635 23 revelation revelation NN 31417 1635 24 and and CC 31417 1635 25 calm calm NN 31417 1635 26 could could MD 31417 1635 27 equal equal VB 31417 1635 28 the the DT 31417 1635 29 joy joy NN 31417 1635 30 of of IN 31417 1635 31 this this DT 31417 1635 32 great great JJ 31417 1635 33 struggle struggle NN 31417 1635 34 from from IN 31417 1635 35 doubt doubt NN 31417 1635 36 into into IN 31417 1635 37 certainty;--from certainty;--from NN 31417 1635 38 the the DT 31417 1635 39 materialism materialism NN 31417 1635 40 or or CC 31417 1635 41 agnosticism agnosticism NN 31417 1635 42 which which WDT 31417 1635 43 accompany accompany VBP 31417 1635 44 the the DT 31417 1635 45 first first JJ 31417 1635 46 advance advance NN 31417 1635 47 of of IN 31417 1635 48 Science Science NNP 31417 1635 49 into into IN 31417 1635 50 the the DT 31417 1635 51 deeper deep JJR 31417 1635 52 scientific scientific JJ 31417 1635 53 conviction conviction NN 31417 1635 54 that that IN 31417 1635 55 there there EX 31417 1635 56 is be VBZ 31417 1635 57 a a DT 31417 1635 58 deathless deathless JJ 31417 1635 59 soul soul NN 31417 1635 60 in in IN 31417 1635 61 man man NN 31417 1635 62 . . . 31417 1636 1 I -PRON- PRP 31417 1636 2 can can MD 31417 1636 3 imagine imagine VB 31417 1636 4 no no DT 31417 1636 5 other other JJ 31417 1636 6 crisis crisis NN 31417 1636 7 of of IN 31417 1636 8 such such JJ 31417 1636 9 deep deep JJ 31417 1636 10 delight delight NN 31417 1636 11 . . . 31417 1636 12 " " '' 31417 1637 1 FOOTNOTES footnote NNS 31417 1637 2 : : : 31417 1637 3 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1637 4 66 66 CD 31417 1637 5 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1637 6 _ _ NNP 31417 1637 7 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1637 8 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1637 9 _ _ NNP 31417 1637 10 , , , 31417 1637 11 vol vol NNP 31417 1637 12 . . . 31417 1638 1 ix ix IN 31417 1638 2 . . . 31417 1639 1 p. p. NN 31417 1639 2 252 252 CD 31417 1639 3 . . . 31417 1640 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1640 2 67 67 CD 31417 1640 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1640 4 The the DT 31417 1640 5 references reference NNS 31417 1640 6 to to IN 31417 1640 7 these these DT 31417 1640 8 contributions contribution NNS 31417 1640 9 are be VBP 31417 1640 10 : : : 31417 1640 11 _ _ NNP 31417 1640 12 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1640 13 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1640 14 _ _ NNP 31417 1640 15 , , , 31417 1640 16 vol vol NNP 31417 1640 17 . . . 31417 1641 1 vi vi NNP 31417 1641 2 . . . 31417 1642 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1642 2 . . . 31417 1643 1 98 98 CD 31417 1643 2 - - SYM 31417 1643 3 127 127 CD 31417 1643 4 ; ; : 31417 1643 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1643 6 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1643 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1643 8 _ _ NNP 31417 1643 9 , , , 31417 1643 10 vol vol NNP 31417 1643 11 . . . 31417 1644 1 vi vi NNP 31417 1644 2 . . . 31417 1645 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1645 2 . . . 31417 1646 1 341 341 CD 31417 1646 2 - - SYM 31417 1646 3 345 345 CD 31417 1646 4 , , , 31417 1646 5 and and CC 31417 1646 6 vol vol NNP 31417 1646 7 . . . 31417 1647 1 ix ix IN 31417 1647 2 . . . 31417 1648 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1648 2 . . . 31417 1649 1 147 147 CD 31417 1649 2 - - SYM 31417 1649 3 148 148 CD 31417 1649 4 ; ; : 31417 1649 5 _ _ NNP 31417 1649 6 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1649 7 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1649 8 _ _ NNP 31417 1649 9 , , , 31417 1649 10 vol vol NNP 31417 1649 11 . . . 31417 1650 1 xiv xiv NNP 31417 1650 2 . . . 31417 1651 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1651 2 . . . 31417 1652 1 2 2 CD 31417 1652 2 - - SYM 31417 1652 3 5 5 CD 31417 1652 4 . . . 31417 1653 1 " " `` 31417 1653 2 Researches research NNS 31417 1653 3 in in IN 31417 1653 4 the the DT 31417 1653 5 Phenomena Phenomena NNP 31417 1653 6 of of IN 31417 1653 7 Spiritualism Spiritualism NNP 31417 1653 8 " " '' 31417 1653 9 will will MD 31417 1653 10 be be VB 31417 1653 11 found find VBN 31417 1653 12 in in IN 31417 1653 13 the the DT 31417 1653 14 Libraries library NNS 31417 1653 15 of of IN 31417 1653 16 the the DT 31417 1653 17 Society Society NNP 31417 1653 18 for for IN 31417 1653 19 Psychical Psychical NNP 31417 1653 20 Research Research NNP 31417 1653 21 , , , 31417 1653 22 and and CC 31417 1653 23 of of IN 31417 1653 24 the the DT 31417 1653 25 London London NNP 31417 1653 26 Spiritualist Spiritualist NNP 31417 1653 27 Alliance Alliance NNP 31417 1653 28 . . . 31417 1654 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1654 2 68 68 CD 31417 1654 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1654 4 " " `` 31417 1654 5 School School NNP 31417 1654 6 Teaching Teaching NNP 31417 1654 7 and and CC 31417 1654 8 School School NNP 31417 1654 9 Reform Reform NNP 31417 1654 10 , , , 31417 1654 11 " " '' 31417 1654 12 by by IN 31417 1654 13 Sir Sir NNP 31417 1654 14 Oliver Oliver NNP 31417 1654 15 Lodge Lodge NNP 31417 1654 16 , , , 31417 1654 17 pp pp NNP 31417 1654 18 . . . 31417 1655 1 89 89 CD 31417 1655 2 , , , 31417 1655 3 90 90 CD 31417 1655 4 . . . 31417 1656 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1656 2 69 69 CD 31417 1656 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1656 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1656 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1656 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1656 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1656 8 , , , 31417 1656 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1656 10 . . . 31417 1657 1 xviii xviii NNP 31417 1657 2 . . . 31417 1658 1 p. p. NN 31417 1658 2 419 419 CD 31417 1658 3 . . . 31417 1659 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1659 2 70 70 CD 31417 1659 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1659 4 See see VB 31417 1659 5 " " '' 31417 1659 6 Hypnotism hypnotism NN 31417 1659 7 : : : 31417 1659 8 Its -PRON- PRP$ 31417 1659 9 History history NN 31417 1659 10 , , , 31417 1659 11 Practice Practice NNP 31417 1659 12 , , , 31417 1659 13 and and CC 31417 1659 14 Theory theory NN 31417 1659 15 , , , 31417 1659 16 " " '' 31417 1659 17 by by IN 31417 1659 18 J. J. NNP 31417 1659 19 Milne Milne NNP 31417 1659 20 Bramwell Bramwell NNP 31417 1659 21 , , , 31417 1659 22 M.B. M.B. NNP 31417 1659 23 , , , 31417 1659 24 C.M. C.M. NNP 31417 1659 25 , , , 31417 1659 26 1903 1903 CD 31417 1659 27 , , , 31417 1659 28 pp pp NNP 31417 1659 29 . . . 31417 1660 1 36 36 CD 31417 1660 2 - - SYM 31417 1660 3 39 39 CD 31417 1660 4 . . . 31417 1661 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1661 2 71 71 CD 31417 1661 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1661 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1661 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1661 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1661 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1661 8 , , , 31417 1661 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1661 10 . . . 31417 1662 1 iv iv XX 31417 1662 2 . . . 31417 1663 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1663 2 . . . 31417 1664 1 108 108 CD 31417 1664 2 - - SYM 31417 1664 3 109 109 CD 31417 1664 4 . . . 31417 1665 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1665 2 72 72 CD 31417 1665 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1665 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1665 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1665 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1665 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1665 8 , , , 31417 1665 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1665 10 . . . 31417 1666 1 xiv xiv NNP 31417 1666 2 . . . 31417 1667 1 p. p. NN 31417 1667 2 3 3 CD 31417 1667 3 . . . 31417 1668 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1668 2 73 73 CD 31417 1668 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1668 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 1668 5 . . . 31417 1668 6 , , , 31417 1668 7 Part Part NNP 31417 1668 8 XLVIII XLVIII NNP 31417 1668 9 . . . 31417 1668 10 , , , 31417 1668 11 1s 1 NNS 31417 1668 12 . . . 31417 1669 1 ( ( -LRB- 31417 1669 2 included include VBN 31417 1669 3 in in IN 31417 1669 4 vol vol NNP 31417 1669 5 . . . 31417 1670 1 xviii xviii NNP 31417 1670 2 . . . 31417 1671 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1671 2 . . . 31417 1672 1 323 323 CD 31417 1672 2 - - SYM 31417 1672 3 351 351 CD 31417 1672 4 ) ) -RRB- 31417 1672 5 . . . 31417 1673 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1673 2 74 74 CD 31417 1673 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1673 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1673 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1673 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1673 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1673 8 , , , 31417 1673 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1673 10 . . . 31417 1674 1 xviii xviii NNP 31417 1674 2 . . . 31417 1675 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1675 2 . . . 31417 1676 1 340 340 CD 31417 1676 2 - - SYM 31417 1676 3 341 341 CD 31417 1676 4 . . . 31417 1677 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1677 2 75 75 CD 31417 1677 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1677 4 Ibid Ibid NNP 31417 1677 5 . . . 31417 1677 6 , , , 31417 1677 7 vol vol NNP 31417 1677 8 . . . 31417 1678 1 vi vi NNP 31417 1678 2 . . . 31417 1679 1 p. p. NN 31417 1679 2 5 5 CD 31417 1679 3 . . . 31417 1680 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1680 2 76 76 CD 31417 1680 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1680 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1680 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1680 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1680 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1680 8 , , , 31417 1680 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1680 10 . . . 31417 1681 1 x. x. NNP 31417 1681 2 p. p. NN 31417 1681 3 394 394 CD 31417 1681 4 . . . 31417 1682 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1682 2 77 77 CD 31417 1682 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1682 4 " " `` 31417 1682 5 Phantasms Phantasms NNPS 31417 1682 6 of of IN 31417 1682 7 the the DT 31417 1682 8 Living living NN 31417 1682 9 , , , 31417 1682 10 " " '' 31417 1682 11 vol vol NNP 31417 1682 12 . . . 31417 1683 1 ii ii LS 31417 1683 2 . . . 31417 1684 1 p. p. NN 31417 1684 2 21 21 CD 31417 1684 3 . . . 31417 1685 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1685 2 78 78 CD 31417 1685 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1685 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1685 5 Journal Journal NNP 31417 1685 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1685 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1685 8 , , , 31417 1685 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1685 10 . . . 31417 1686 1 iv iv XX 31417 1686 2 . . . 31417 1687 1 p. p. NN 31417 1687 2 115 115 CD 31417 1687 3 . . . 31417 1688 1 [ [ -LRB- 31417 1688 2 79 79 CD 31417 1688 3 ] ] -RRB- 31417 1688 4 _ _ NNP 31417 1688 5 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 31417 1688 6 S.P.R. S.P.R. NNP 31417 1688 7 _ _ NNP 31417 1688 8 , , , 31417 1688 9 vol vol NNP 31417 1688 10 . . . 31417 1689 1 xi xi NNP 31417 1689 2 . . . 31417 1690 1 pp pp NNP 31417 1690 2 . . . 31417 1691 1 24 24 CD 31417 1691 2 - - SYM 31417 1691 3 25 25 CD 31417 1691 4 . . . 31417 1692 1 THE the DT 31417 1692 2 END END NNP 31417 1692 3 Printed print VBN 31417 1692 4 by by IN 31417 1692 5 BALLANTYNE BALLANTYNE NNP 31417 1692 6 , , , 31417 1692 7 HANSON HANSON NNP 31417 1692 8 , , , 31417 1692 9 & & CC 31417 1692 10 CO CO NNP 31417 1692 11 . . . 31417 1692 12 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 31417 1692 13 & & CC 31417 1692 14 London London NNP