id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
38430	1	1	THE	the	DT
38430	1	2	PHILOSOPHY	PHILOSOPHY	NNP
38430	1	3	OF	of	IN
38430	1	4	MR	MR	NNP
38430	1	5	.	.	.
38430	1	6	B*RTR*ND	B*RTR*ND	NNP
38430	1	7	R*SS*LL	r*ss*ll	VB
38430	1	8	WITH	with	IN
38430	1	9	AN	an	DT
38430	1	10	APPENDIX	APPENDIX	NNP
38430	1	11	OF	of	IN
38430	1	12	LEADING	lead	VBG
38430	1	13	PASSAGES	passages	NN
38430	1	14	FROM	from	IN
38430	1	15	CERTAIN	certain	JJ
38430	1	16	OTHER	other	JJ
38430	1	17	WORKS	works	NN
38430	1	18	EDITED	edit	VBN
38430	1	19	BY	by	IN
38430	1	20	PHILIP	PHILIP	NNP
38430	1	21	E.	E.	NNP
38430	1	22	B.	B.	NNP
38430	1	23	JOURDAIN	JOURDAIN	NNP
38430	1	24	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1	25	Illustration	illustration	NN
38430	1	26	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1	27	LONDON	LONDON	NNP
38430	1	28	:	:	:
38430	1	29	GEORGE	GEORGE	NNP
38430	1	30	ALLEN	ALLEN	NNP
38430	1	31	&	&	CC
38430	1	32	UNWIN	UNWIN	NNP
38430	1	33	LTD	LTD	NNP
38430	1	34	.	.	.
38430	1	35	RUSKIN	RUSKIN	NNP
38430	1	36	HOUSE	HOUSE	NNP
38430	1	37	40	40	CD
38430	1	38	MUSEUM	MUSEUM	NNP
38430	1	39	STREET	STREET	NNP
38430	1	40	,	,	,
38430	1	41	W.C.	W.C.	NNP
38430	1	42	1	1	CD
38430	1	43	CHICAGO	CHICAGO	NNP
38430	1	44	:	:	:
38430	1	45	THE	the	DT
38430	1	46	OPEN	open	JJ
38430	1	47	COURT	COURT	NNP
38430	1	48	PUBLISHING	PUBLISHING	NNP
38430	1	49	CO	CO	NNP
38430	1	50	.	.	NNP
38430	1	51	_	_	NNP
38430	1	52	First	First	NNP
38430	1	53	published	publish	VBN
38430	1	54	in	in	IN
38430	1	55	1918	1918	CD
38430	1	56	_	_	NNP
38430	1	57	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1	58	_	_	NNP
38430	1	59	All	all	DT
38430	1	60	rights	right	NNS
38430	1	61	reserved	reserve	VBN
38430	1	62	_	_	NNP
38430	1	63	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1	64	EDITOR	EDITOR	NNP
38430	1	65	'S	's	POS
38430	1	66	NOTE	note	NN
38430	1	67	When	when	WRB
38430	1	68	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1	69	B*rtr*nd	B*rtr*nd	NNP
38430	1	70	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	1	71	,	,	,
38430	1	72	following	follow	VBG
38430	1	73	the	the	DT
38430	1	74	advice	advice	NN
38430	1	75	of	of	IN
38430	1	76	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1	77	W*ll**m	W*ll**m	NNP
38430	1	78	J*m*s	J*m*s	NNP
38430	1	79	,	,	,
38430	1	80	again	again	RB
38430	1	81	"	"	``
38430	1	82	got	get	VBN
38430	1	83	into	into	IN
38430	1	84	touch	touch	NN
38430	1	85	with	with	IN
38430	1	86	reality	reality	NN
38430	1	87	"	"	''
38430	1	88	and	and	CC
38430	1	89	in	in	IN
38430	1	90	July	July	NNP
38430	1	91	1911	1911	CD
38430	1	92	was	be	VBD
38430	1	93	torn	tear	VBN
38430	1	94	to	to	IN
38430	1	95	pieces	piece	NNS
38430	1	96	by	by	IN
38430	1	97	Anti	Anti	NNP
38430	1	98	-	-	NNP
38430	1	99	Suffragists	Suffragists	NNPS
38430	1	100	,	,	,
38430	1	101	many	many	DT
38430	1	102	of	of	IN
38430	1	103	whom	whom	WP
38430	1	104	were	be	VBD
38430	1	105	political	political	JJ
38430	1	106	opponents	opponent	NNS
38430	1	107	of	of	IN
38430	1	108	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1	109	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	1	110	and	and	CC
38430	1	111	held	hold	VBD
38430	1	112	strong	strong	JJ
38430	1	113	views	view	NNS
38430	1	114	on	on	IN
38430	1	115	the	the	DT
38430	1	116	Necessity	Necessity	NNP
38430	1	117	of	of	IN
38430	1	118	Protection	Protection	NNP
38430	1	119	of	of	IN
38430	1	120	Trade	Trade	NNP
38430	1	121	and	and	CC
38430	1	122	person	person	NN
38430	1	123	,	,	,
38430	1	124	a	a	DT
38430	1	125	manuscript	manuscript	NN
38430	1	126	which	which	WDT
38430	1	127	was	be	VBD
38430	1	128	almost	almost	RB
38430	1	129	ready	ready	JJ
38430	1	130	for	for	IN
38430	1	131	the	the	DT
38430	1	132	press	press	NN
38430	1	133	was	be	VBD
38430	1	134	fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	1	135	saved	save	VBN
38430	1	136	from	from	IN
38430	1	137	the	the	DT
38430	1	138	flames	flame	NNS
38430	1	139	on	on	IN
38430	1	140	the	the	DT
38430	1	141	occasion	occasion	NN
38430	1	142	when	when	WRB
38430	1	143	a	a	DT
38430	1	144	body	body	NN
38430	1	145	of	of	IN
38430	1	146	eager	eager	JJ
38430	1	147	champions	champion	NNS
38430	1	148	of	of	IN
38430	1	149	the	the	DT
38430	1	150	Sacredness	sacredness	NN
38430	1	151	of	of	IN
38430	1	152	Personal	Personal	NNP
38430	1	153	Property	Property	NNP
38430	1	154	burnt	burn	VBD
38430	1	155	the	the	DT
38430	1	156	late	late	JJ
38430	1	157	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1	158	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	1	159	's	's	POS
38430	1	160	house	house	NN
38430	1	161	.	.	.
38430	2	1	This	this	DT
38430	2	2	manuscript	manuscript	NN
38430	2	3	,	,	,
38430	2	4	together	together	RB
38430	2	5	with	with	IN
38430	2	6	some	some	DT
38430	2	7	further	further	JJ
38430	2	8	fragments	fragment	NNS
38430	2	9	found	find	VBN
38430	2	10	in	in	IN
38430	2	11	the	the	DT
38430	2	12	late	late	JJ
38430	2	13	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	2	14	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	2	15	's	's	POS
38430	2	16	own	own	JJ
38430	2	17	interleaved	interleaved	JJ
38430	2	18	copy	copy	NN
38430	2	19	of	of	IN
38430	2	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	2	21	_	_	NNP
38430	2	22	Prayer	Prayer	NNP
38430	2	23	-	-	HYPH
38430	2	24	Book	Book	NNP
38430	2	25	of	of	IN
38430	2	26	Free	Free	NNP
38430	2	27	Man	Man	NNP
38430	2	28	's	's	POS
38430	2	29	Worship	Worship	NNP
38430	2	30	_	_	NNP
38430	2	31	,	,	,
38430	2	32	which	which	WDT
38430	2	33	was	be	VBD
38430	2	34	fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	2	35	rescued	rescue	VBN
38430	2	36	with	with	IN
38430	2	37	a	a	DT
38430	2	38	few	few	JJ
38430	2	39	of	of	IN
38430	2	40	the	the	DT
38430	2	41	great	great	JJ
38430	2	42	author	author	NN
38430	2	43	's	's	POS
38430	2	44	other	other	JJ
38430	2	45	belongings	belonging	NNS
38430	2	46	,	,	,
38430	2	47	was	be	VBD
38430	2	48	first	first	RB
38430	2	49	given	give	VBN
38430	2	50	to	to	IN
38430	2	51	the	the	DT
38430	2	52	world	world	NN
38430	2	53	in	in	IN
38430	2	54	the	the	DT
38430	2	55	_	_	NNP
38430	2	56	Monist	Monist	NNP
38430	2	57	_	_	NNP
38430	2	58	for	for	IN
38430	2	59	October	October	NNP
38430	2	60	1911	1911	CD
38430	2	61	and	and	CC
38430	2	62	January	January	NNP
38430	2	63	1916	1916	CD
38430	2	64	,	,	,
38430	2	65	and	and	CC
38430	2	66	has	have	VBZ
38430	2	67	here	here	RB
38430	2	68	been	be	VBN
38430	2	69	arranged	arrange	VBN
38430	2	70	and	and	CC
38430	2	71	completed	complete	VBN
38430	2	72	by	by	IN
38430	2	73	some	some	DT
38430	2	74	other	other	JJ
38430	2	75	hitherto	hitherto	JJ
38430	2	76	undecipherable	undecipherable	JJ
38430	2	77	manuscripts	manuscript	NNS
38430	2	78	.	.	.
38430	3	1	The	the	DT
38430	3	2	title	title	NN
38430	3	3	of	of	IN
38430	3	4	the	the	DT
38430	3	5	above	above	RB
38430	3	6	-	-	HYPH
38430	3	7	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	3	8	_	_	NNP
38430	3	9	Prayer	Prayer	NNP
38430	3	10	-	-	HYPH
38430	3	11	Book	Book	NNP
38430	3	12	_	_	NNP
38430	3	13	,	,	,
38430	3	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	3	15	may	may	MD
38430	3	16	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	3	17	be	be	VB
38430	3	18	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	3	19	,	,	,
38430	3	20	was	be	VBD
38430	3	21	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	3	22	suggested	suggest	VBN
38430	3	23	to	to	IN
38430	3	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	3	25	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	3	26	by	by	IN
38430	3	27	that	that	DT
38430	3	28	of	of	IN
38430	3	29	the	the	DT
38430	3	30	Essay	Essay	NNP
38430	3	31	on	on	IN
38430	3	32	"	"	``
38430	3	33	The	the	DT
38430	3	34	Free	Free	NNP
38430	3	35	Man	Man	NNP
38430	3	36	's	's	POS
38430	3	37	Worship	Worship	NNP
38430	3	38	"	"	''
38430	3	39	in	in	IN
38430	3	40	the	the	DT
38430	3	41	_	_	NNP
38430	3	42	Philosophical	Philosophical	NNP
38430	3	43	Essays	Essays	NNPS
38430	3	44	_	_	NNP
38430	3	45	(	(	-LRB-
38430	3	46	London	London	NNP
38430	3	47	,	,	,
38430	3	48	1910	1910	CD
38430	3	49	,	,	,
38430	3	50	pp	pp	NNP
38430	3	51	.	.	.
38430	4	1	59	59	CD
38430	4	2	-	-	SYM
38430	4	3	70[1	70[1	CD
38430	4	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	4	5	)	)	-RRB-
38430	4	6	of	of	IN
38430	4	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	4	8	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	4	9	's	's	POS
38430	4	10	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
38430	4	11	contemporary	contemporary	NN
38430	4	12	,	,	,
38430	4	13	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	4	14	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	4	15	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	4	16	,	,	,
38430	4	17	from	from	IN
38430	4	18	whom	whom	WP
38430	4	19	much	much	JJ
38430	4	20	of	of	IN
38430	4	21	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	4	22	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	4	23	's	's	POS
38430	4	24	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	4	25	was	be	VBD
38430	4	26	derived	derive	VBN
38430	4	27	.	.	.
38430	5	1	And	and	CC
38430	5	2	,	,	,
38430	5	3	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	5	4	,	,	,
38430	5	5	the	the	DT
38430	5	6	influence	influence	NN
38430	5	7	of	of	IN
38430	5	8	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	5	9	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	5	10	extended	extend	VBD
38430	5	11	even	even	RB
38430	5	12	beyond	beyond	IN
38430	5	13	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	5	14	views	view	NNS
38430	5	15	to	to	IN
38430	5	16	arrangement	arrangement	VB
38430	5	17	and	and	CC
38430	5	18	literary	literary	JJ
38430	5	19	style	style	NN
38430	5	20	.	.	.
38430	6	1	The	the	DT
38430	6	2	method	method	NN
38430	6	3	of	of	IN
38430	6	4	arrangement	arrangement	NN
38430	6	5	of	of	IN
38430	6	6	the	the	DT
38430	6	7	present	present	JJ
38430	6	8	work	work	NN
38430	6	9	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	6	10	to	to	TO
38430	6	11	have	have	VB
38430	6	12	been	be	VBN
38430	6	13	borrowed	borrow	VBN
38430	6	14	from	from	IN
38430	6	15	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	6	16	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	6	17	's	's	POS
38430	6	18	_	_	NNP
38430	6	19	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	6	20	of	of	IN
38430	6	21	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	6	22	_	_	NNP
38430	6	23	of	of	IN
38430	6	24	1900	1900	CD
38430	6	25	;	;	:
38430	6	26	in	in	IN
38430	6	27	the	the	DT
38430	6	28	selection	selection	NN
38430	6	29	of	of	IN
38430	6	30	subjects	subject	NNS
38430	6	31	dealt	deal	VBN
38430	6	32	with	with	IN
38430	6	33	,	,	,
38430	6	34	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	6	35	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	6	36	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	6	37	to	to	TO
38430	6	38	have	have	VB
38430	6	39	been	be	VBN
38430	6	40	guided	guide	VBN
38430	6	41	by	by	IN
38430	6	42	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	6	43	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	6	44	's	's	POS
38430	6	45	_	_	NNP
38430	6	46	Principles	Principles	NNPS
38430	6	47	of	of	IN
38430	6	48	Mathematics	Mathematics	NNP
38430	6	49	_	_	NNP
38430	6	50	of	of	IN
38430	6	51	1903	1903	CD
38430	6	52	;	;	:
38430	6	53	while	while	IN
38430	6	54	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	6	55	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	6	56	's	's	POS
38430	6	57	literary	literary	JJ
38430	6	58	style	style	NN
38430	6	59	fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	6	60	reminds	remind	VBZ
38430	6	61	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	6	62	more	more	JJR
38430	6	63	of	of	IN
38430	6	64	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	6	65	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	6	66	's	's	POS
38430	6	67	later	later	RB
38430	6	68	clear	clear	JJ
38430	6	69	and	and	CC
38430	6	70	charming	charming	JJ
38430	6	71	subtleties	subtlety	NNS
38430	6	72	than	than	IN
38430	6	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	6	74	earlier	early	RBR
38430	6	75	brilliant	brilliant	JJ
38430	6	76	and	and	CC
38430	6	77	no	no	DT
38430	6	78	less	less	RBR
38430	6	79	subtle	subtle	JJ
38430	6	80	obscurities	obscurity	NNS
38430	6	81	.	.	.
38430	7	1	But	but	CC
38430	7	2	,	,	,
38430	7	3	on	on	IN
38430	7	4	the	the	DT
38430	7	5	other	other	JJ
38430	7	6	hand	hand	NN
38430	7	7	,	,	,
38430	7	8	some	some	DT
38430	7	9	important	important	JJ
38430	7	10	points	point	NNS
38430	7	11	of	of	IN
38430	7	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	7	13	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	7	14	's	's	POS
38430	7	15	doctrine	doctrine	NN
38430	7	16	,	,	,
38430	7	17	which	which	WDT
38430	7	18	first	first	RB
38430	7	19	appeared	appear	VBD
38430	7	20	in	in	IN
38430	7	21	books	book	NNS
38430	7	22	published	publish	VBN
38430	7	23	after	after	IN
38430	7	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	7	25	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	7	26	's	's	POS
38430	7	27	death	death	NN
38430	7	28	,	,	,
38430	7	29	were	be	VBD
38430	7	30	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
38430	7	31	in	in	IN
38430	7	32	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	7	33	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	7	34	's	's	POS
38430	7	35	notes	note	NNS
38430	7	36	,	,	,
38430	7	37	and	and	CC
38430	7	38	these	these	DT
38430	7	39	anticipations	anticipation	NNS
38430	7	40	,	,	,
38430	7	41	so	so	RB
38430	7	42	interesting	interesting	JJ
38430	7	43	for	for	IN
38430	7	44	future	future	JJ
38430	7	45	historians	historian	NNS
38430	7	46	of	of	IN
38430	7	47	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	7	48	,	,	,
38430	7	49	have	have	VBP
38430	7	50	been	be	VBN
38430	7	51	provided	provide	VBN
38430	7	52	by	by	IN
38430	7	53	the	the	DT
38430	7	54	editor	editor	NN
38430	7	55	with	with	IN
38430	7	56	references	reference	NNS
38430	7	57	to	to	IN
38430	7	58	the	the	DT
38430	7	59	later	later	JJ
38430	7	60	works	work	NNS
38430	7	61	of	of	IN
38430	7	62	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	7	63	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	7	64	.	.	.
38430	8	1	All	all	DT
38430	8	2	editorial	editorial	JJ
38430	8	3	notes	note	NNS
38430	8	4	are	be	VBP
38430	8	5	enclosed	enclose	VBN
38430	8	6	in	in	IN
38430	8	7	square	square	JJ
38430	8	8	brackets	bracket	NNS
38430	8	9	,	,	,
38430	8	10	to	to	TO
38430	8	11	indicate	indicate	VB
38430	8	12	that	that	IN
38430	8	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	8	14	were	be	VBD
38430	8	15	not	not	RB
38430	8	16	written	write	VBN
38430	8	17	by	by	IN
38430	8	18	the	the	DT
38430	8	19	late	late	JJ
38430	8	20	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	8	21	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	8	22	.	.	.
38430	9	1	At	at	IN
38430	9	2	the	the	DT
38430	9	3	present	present	JJ
38430	9	4	time	time	NN
38430	9	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	9	6	have	have	VBP
38430	9	7	come	come	VBN
38430	9	8	to	to	TO
38430	9	9	take	take	VB
38430	9	10	a	a	DT
38430	9	11	calm	calm	JJ
38430	9	12	view	view	NN
38430	9	13	of	of	IN
38430	9	14	the	the	DT
38430	9	15	question	question	NN
38430	9	16	so	so	RB
38430	9	17	much	much	RB
38430	9	18	debated	debate	VBN
38430	9	19	seven	seven	CD
38430	9	20	years	year	NNS
38430	9	21	ago	ago	RB
38430	9	22	as	as	IN
38430	9	23	to	to	IN
38430	9	24	the	the	DT
38430	9	25	legitimacy	legitimacy	NN
38430	9	26	of	of	IN
38430	9	27	logical	logical	JJ
38430	9	28	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	9	29	in	in	IN
38430	9	30	political	political	JJ
38430	9	31	discussions	discussion	NNS
38430	9	32	.	.	.
38430	10	1	No	no	RB
38430	10	2	longer	long	RBR
38430	10	3	,	,	,
38430	10	4	fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	10	5	,	,	,
38430	10	6	can	can	MD
38430	10	7	that	that	DT
38430	10	8	intense	intense	JJ
38430	10	9	feeling	feeling	NN
38430	10	10	be	be	VB
38430	10	11	roused	rouse	VBN
38430	10	12	which	which	WDT
38430	10	13	then	then	RB
38430	10	14	found	find	VBD
38430	10	15	expression	expression	NN
38430	10	16	in	in	IN
38430	10	17	the	the	DT
38430	10	18	famous	famous	JJ
38430	10	19	cry	cry	NN
38430	10	20	,	,	,
38430	10	21	"	"	''
38430	10	22	Justice	justice	NN
38430	10	23	--	--	:
38430	10	24	right	right	JJ
38430	10	25	or	or	CC
38430	10	26	wrong	wrong	JJ
38430	10	27	,	,	,
38430	10	28	"	"	''
38430	10	29	and	and	CC
38430	10	30	which	which	WDT
38430	10	31	played	play	VBD
38430	10	32	such	such	PDT
38430	10	33	a	a	DT
38430	10	34	large	large	JJ
38430	10	35	part	part	NN
38430	10	36	in	in	IN
38430	10	37	the	the	DT
38430	10	38	politics	politic	NNS
38430	10	39	of	of	IN
38430	10	40	that	that	DT
38430	10	41	time	time	NN
38430	10	42	.	.	.
38430	11	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	11	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	11	3	will	will	MD
38430	11	4	not	not	RB
38430	11	5	be	be	VB
38430	11	6	out	out	IN
38430	11	7	of	of	IN
38430	11	8	place	place	NN
38430	11	9	in	in	IN
38430	11	10	this	this	DT
38430	11	11	unimpassioned	unimpassioned	JJ
38430	11	12	record	record	NN
38430	11	13	of	of	IN
38430	11	14	some	some	DT
38430	11	15	of	of	IN
38430	11	16	the	the	DT
38430	11	17	truths	truth	NNS
38430	11	18	and	and	CC
38430	11	19	errors	error	NNS
38430	11	20	in	in	IN
38430	11	21	the	the	DT
38430	11	22	world	world	NN
38430	11	23	to	to	TO
38430	11	24	refer	refer	VB
38430	11	25	briefly	briefly	RB
38430	11	26	to	to	IN
38430	11	27	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	11	28	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	11	29	's	's	POS
38430	11	30	short	short	JJ
38430	11	31	and	and	CC
38430	11	32	stormy	stormy	JJ
38430	11	33	career	career	NN
38430	11	34	.	.	.
38430	12	1	Before	before	IN
38430	12	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	12	3	was	be	VBD
38430	12	4	torn	tear	VBN
38430	12	5	to	to	IN
38430	12	6	pieces	piece	NNS
38430	12	7	,	,	,
38430	12	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	12	9	had	have	VBD
38430	12	10	been	be	VBN
38430	12	11	forbidden	forbid	VBN
38430	12	12	to	to	TO
38430	12	13	lecture	lecture	VB
38430	12	14	on	on	IN
38430	12	15	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	12	16	or	or	CC
38430	12	17	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	12	18	by	by	IN
38430	12	19	some	some	DT
38430	12	20	well	well	RB
38430	12	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	12	22	intentioned	intentione	VBN
38430	12	23	advocates	advocate	NNS
38430	12	24	of	of	IN
38430	12	25	freedom	freedom	NN
38430	12	26	in	in	IN
38430	12	27	speech	speech	NN
38430	12	28	who	who	WP
38430	12	29	thought	think	VBD
38430	12	30	that	that	IN
38430	12	31	the	the	DT
38430	12	32	cause	cause	NN
38430	12	33	of	of	IN
38430	12	34	freedom	freedom	NN
38430	12	35	might	may	MD
38430	12	36	be	be	VB
38430	12	37	endangered	endanger	VBN
38430	12	38	by	by	IN
38430	12	39	allowing	allow	VBG
38430	12	40	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	12	41	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	12	42	to	to	TO
38430	12	43	speak	speak	VB
38430	12	44	freely	freely	RB
38430	12	45	on	on	IN
38430	12	46	points	point	NNS
38430	12	47	of	of	IN
38430	12	48	logic	logic	NN
38430	12	49	,	,	,
38430	12	50	on	on	IN
38430	12	51	the	the	DT
38430	12	52	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	12	53	,	,	,
38430	12	54	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	12	55	,	,	,
38430	12	56	that	that	IN
38430	12	57	logic	logic	NN
38430	12	58	is	be	VBZ
38430	12	59	both	both	CC
38430	12	60	harmful	harmful	JJ
38430	12	61	and	and	CC
38430	12	62	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
38430	12	63	and	and	CC
38430	12	64	might	may	MD
38430	12	65	be	be	VB
38430	12	66	applied	apply	VBN
38430	12	67	to	to	IN
38430	12	68	politics	politic	NNS
38430	12	69	unless	unless	IN
38430	12	70	strong	strong	JJ
38430	12	71	measures	measure	NNS
38430	12	72	were	be	VBD
38430	12	73	taken	take	VBN
38430	12	74	for	for	IN
38430	12	75	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	12	76	suppression	suppression	NN
38430	12	77	.	.	.
38430	13	1	On	on	IN
38430	13	2	much	much	RB
38430	13	3	the	the	DT
38430	13	4	same	same	JJ
38430	13	5	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	13	6	,	,	,
38430	13	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	13	8	liberty	liberty	NN
38430	13	9	was	be	VBD
38430	13	10	taken	take	VBN
38430	13	11	from	from	IN
38430	13	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	13	13	by	by	IN
38430	13	14	those	those	DT
38430	13	15	who	who	WP
38430	13	16	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	13	17	that	that	IN
38430	13	18	,	,	,
38430	13	19	if	if	IN
38430	13	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	13	21	,	,	,
38430	13	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	13	23	would	would	MD
38430	13	24	die	die	VB
38430	13	25	in	in	IN
38430	13	26	defence	defence	NN
38430	13	27	of	of	IN
38430	13	28	the	the	DT
38430	13	29	sacred	sacred	JJ
38430	13	30	principle	principle	NN
38430	13	31	of	of	IN
38430	13	32	liberty	liberty	NN
38430	13	33	;	;	:
38430	13	34	and	and	CC
38430	13	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	13	36	was	be	VBD
38430	13	37	in	in	IN
38430	13	38	prison	prison	NN
38430	13	39	that	that	IN
38430	13	40	the	the	DT
38430	13	41	greater	great	JJR
38430	13	42	part	part	NN
38430	13	43	of	of	IN
38430	13	44	the	the	DT
38430	13	45	present	present	JJ
38430	13	46	work	work	NN
38430	13	47	was	be	VBD
38430	13	48	written	write	VBN
38430	13	49	.	.	.
38430	14	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
38430	14	2	after	after	IN
38430	14	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	14	4	liberation	liberation	NN
38430	14	5	,	,	,
38430	14	6	which	which	WDT
38430	14	7	,	,	,
38430	14	8	like	like	IN
38430	14	9	all	all	DT
38430	14	10	actions	action	NNS
38430	14	11	of	of	IN
38430	14	12	public	public	JJ
38430	14	13	bodies	body	NNS
38430	14	14	,	,	,
38430	14	15	was	be	VBD
38430	14	16	brought	bring	VBN
38430	14	17	about	about	RP
38430	14	18	by	by	IN
38430	14	19	the	the	DT
38430	14	20	combined	combine	VBN
38430	14	21	honour	honour	NN
38430	14	22	and	and	CC
38430	14	23	interests	interest	NNS
38430	14	24	of	of	IN
38430	14	25	those	those	DT
38430	14	26	in	in	IN
38430	14	27	authority	authority	NN
38430	14	28	,	,	,
38430	14	29	occurred	occur	VBD
38430	14	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	14	31	lamentable	lamentable	JJ
38430	14	32	death	death	NN
38430	14	33	to	to	TO
38430	14	34	which	which	WDT
38430	14	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	14	36	have	have	VBP
38430	14	37	referred	refer	VBN
38430	14	38	above	above	RB
38430	14	39	.	.	.
38430	15	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	15	2	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	15	3	maintained	maintain	VBD
38430	15	4	that	that	IN
38430	15	5	the	the	DT
38430	15	6	chief	chief	JJ
38430	15	7	use	use	NN
38430	15	8	of	of	IN
38430	15	9	"	"	``
38430	15	10	implication	implication	NN
38430	15	11	"	"	''
38430	15	12	in	in	IN
38430	15	13	politics	politics	NN
38430	15	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	15	15	to	to	TO
38430	15	16	draw	draw	VB
38430	15	17	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	15	18	,	,	,
38430	15	19	which	which	WDT
38430	15	20	are	be	VBP
38430	15	21	thought	think	VBN
38430	15	22	to	to	TO
38430	15	23	be	be	VB
38430	15	24	true	true	JJ
38430	15	25	,	,	,
38430	15	26	and	and	CC
38430	15	27	which	which	WDT
38430	15	28	are	be	VBP
38430	15	29	consequently	consequently	RB
38430	15	30	false	false	JJ
38430	15	31	,	,	,
38430	15	32	from	from	IN
38430	15	33	identical	identical	JJ
38430	15	34	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	15	35	,	,	,
38430	15	36	and	and	CC
38430	15	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	15	38	can	can	MD
38430	15	39	see	see	VB
38430	15	40	these	these	DT
38430	15	41	views	view	NNS
38430	15	42	expressed	express	VBN
38430	15	43	in	in	IN
38430	15	44	Chapters	Chapters	NNP
38430	15	45	III	III	NNP
38430	15	46	and	and	CC
38430	15	47	XIX	XIX	NNP
38430	15	48	of	of	IN
38430	15	49	the	the	DT
38430	15	50	present	present	JJ
38430	15	51	work	work	NN
38430	15	52	.	.	.
38430	16	1	These	these	DT
38430	16	2	chapters	chapter	NNS
38430	16	3	were	be	VBD
38430	16	4	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	16	5	written	write	VBN
38430	16	6	before	before	IN
38430	16	7	the	the	DT
38430	16	8	Government	Government	NNP
38430	16	9	,	,	,
38430	16	10	in	in	IN
38430	16	11	the	the	DT
38430	16	12	spring	spring	NN
38430	16	13	of	of	IN
38430	16	14	1910	1910	CD
38430	16	15	,	,	,
38430	16	16	arrived	arrive	VBD
38430	16	17	at	at	IN
38430	16	18	the	the	DT
38430	16	19	famous	famous	JJ
38430	16	20	secret	secret	JJ
38430	16	21	decision	decision	NN
38430	16	22	that	that	WDT
38430	16	23	only	only	RB
38430	16	24	"	"	``
38430	16	25	certain	certain	JJ
38430	16	26	implications	implication	NNS
38430	16	27	"	"	''
38430	16	28	are	be	VBP
38430	16	29	permitted	permit	VBN
38430	16	30	in	in	IN
38430	16	31	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	16	32	.	.	.
38430	17	1	Naturally	naturally	RB
38430	17	2	the	the	DT
38430	17	3	secret	secret	JJ
38430	17	4	decision	decision	NN
38430	17	5	gave	give	VBD
38430	17	6	rise	rise	NN
38430	17	7	to	to	IN
38430	17	8	much	much	JJ
38430	17	9	speculation	speculation	NN
38430	17	10	among	among	IN
38430	17	11	logicians	logicians	NNPS
38430	17	12	as	as	IN
38430	17	13	to	to	IN
38430	17	14	which	which	WDT
38430	17	15	kinds	kind	NNS
38430	17	16	of	of	IN
38430	17	17	implication	implication	NN
38430	17	18	were	be	VBD
38430	17	19	barred	bar	VBN
38430	17	20	,	,	,
38430	17	21	and	and	CC
38430	17	22	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	17	23	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	17	24	and	and	CC
38430	17	25	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	17	26	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	17	27	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	17	28	had	have	VBD
38430	17	29	many	many	JJ
38430	17	30	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	17	31	on	on	IN
38430	17	32	the	the	DT
38430	17	33	subject	subject	NN
38430	17	34	,	,	,
38430	17	35	which	which	WDT
38430	17	36	naturally	naturally	RB
38430	17	37	could	could	MD
38430	17	38	not	not	RB
38430	17	39	be	be	VB
38430	17	40	published	publish	VBN
38430	17	41	at	at	IN
38430	17	42	the	the	DT
38430	17	43	time	time	NN
38430	17	44	.	.	.
38430	18	1	However	however	RB
38430	18	2	,	,	,
38430	18	3	after	after	IN
38430	18	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	18	5	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	18	6	's	's	POS
38430	18	7	death	death	NN
38430	18	8	,	,	,
38430	18	9	successive	successive	JJ
38430	18	10	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
38430	18	11	which	which	WDT
38430	18	12	were	be	VBD
38430	18	13	made	make	VBN
38430	18	14	by	by	IN
38430	18	15	the	the	DT
38430	18	16	Government	Government	NNP
38430	18	17	at	at	IN
38430	18	18	last	last	RB
38430	18	19	made	make	VBD
38430	18	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	18	21	quite	quite	RB
38430	18	22	clear	clear	JJ
38430	18	23	that	that	IN
38430	18	24	the	the	DT
38430	18	25	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	18	26	held	hold	VBN
38430	18	27	by	by	IN
38430	18	28	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	18	29	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	18	30	was	be	VBD
38430	18	31	the	the	DT
38430	18	32	correct	correct	JJ
38430	18	33	one	one	NN
38430	18	34	.	.	.
38430	19	1	There	there	EX
38430	19	2	had	have	VBD
38430	19	3	been	be	VBN
38430	19	4	numerous	numerous	JJ
38430	19	5	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
38430	19	6	of	of	IN
38430	19	7	people	people	NNS
38430	19	8	who	who	WP
38430	19	9	,	,	,
38430	19	10	from	from	IN
38430	19	11	true	true	JJ
38430	19	12	but	but	CC
38430	19	13	not	not	RB
38430	19	14	identical	identical	JJ
38430	19	15	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	19	16	,	,	,
38430	19	17	had	have	VBD
38430	19	18	deduced	deduce	VBN
38430	19	19	true	true	JJ
38430	19	20	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	19	21	,	,	,
38430	19	22	so	so	IN
38430	19	23	that	that	IN
38430	19	24	the	the	DT
38430	19	25	possible	possible	JJ
38430	19	26	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	19	27	forms	form	NNS
38430	19	28	of	of	IN
38430	19	29	"	"	``
38430	19	30	implication	implication	NN
38430	19	31	"	"	''
38430	19	32	were	be	VBD
38430	19	33	reduced	reduce	VBN
38430	19	34	.	.	.
38430	20	1	Further	further	RB
38430	20	2	,	,	,
38430	20	3	the	the	DT
38430	20	4	other	other	JJ
38430	20	5	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	20	6	cases	case	NNS
38430	20	7	were	be	VBD
38430	20	8	cleared	clear	VBN
38430	20	9	up	up	RP
38430	20	10	in	in	IN
38430	20	11	course	course	NN
38430	20	12	of	of	IN
38430	20	13	time	time	NN
38430	20	14	by	by	IN
38430	20	15	the	the	DT
38430	20	16	prosecution	prosecution	NN
38430	20	17	of	of	IN
38430	20	18	(	(	-LRB-
38430	20	19	1	1	CD
38430	20	20	)	)	-RRB-
38430	20	21	members	member	NNS
38430	20	22	of	of	IN
38430	20	23	the	the	DT
38430	20	24	Aristotelian	Aristotelian	NNP
38430	20	25	Society	Society	NNP
38430	20	26	for	for	IN
38430	20	27	deducing	deduce	VBG
38430	20	28	true	true	JJ
38430	20	29	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	20	30	from	from	IN
38430	20	31	false	false	JJ
38430	20	32	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	20	33	;	;	:
38430	20	34	(	(	-LRB-
38430	20	35	2	2	LS
38430	20	36	)	)	-RRB-
38430	20	37	members	member	NNS
38430	20	38	of	of	IN
38430	20	39	the	the	DT
38430	20	40	_	_	NNP
38430	20	41	Mind	Mind	NNP
38430	20	42	_	_	NNP
38430	20	43	Association	Association	NNP
38430	20	44	for	for	IN
38430	20	45	deducing	deduce	VBG
38430	20	46	false	false	JJ
38430	20	47	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	20	48	from	from	IN
38430	20	49	false	false	JJ
38430	20	50	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	20	51	;	;	:
38430	20	52	and	and	CC
38430	20	53	also	also	RB
38430	20	54	by	by	IN
38430	20	55	the	the	DT
38430	20	56	attempted	attempt	VBN
38430	20	57	prosecution	prosecution	NN
38430	20	58	of	of	IN
38430	20	59	an	an	DT
38430	20	60	eminent	eminent	JJ
38430	20	61	lady	lady	NN
38430	20	62	for	for	IN
38430	20	63	deducing	deduce	VBG
38430	20	64	true	true	JJ
38430	20	65	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	20	66	from	from	IN
38430	20	67	identities	identity	NNS
38430	20	68	.	.	.
38430	21	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	21	2	this	this	DT
38430	21	3	lady	lady	NN
38430	21	4	was	be	VBD
38430	21	5	able	able	JJ
38430	21	6	to	to	TO
38430	21	7	defend	defend	VB
38430	21	8	herself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	21	9	successfully	successfully	RB
38430	21	10	by	by	IN
38430	21	11	pleading	plead	VBG
38430	21	12	that	that	IN
38430	21	13	one	one	CD
38430	21	14	eminent	eminent	JJ
38430	21	15	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	21	16	believed	believe	VBD
38430	21	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	21	18	to	to	TO
38430	21	19	be	be	VB
38430	21	20	true	true	JJ
38430	21	21	--	--	:
38430	21	22	which	which	WDT
38430	21	23	,	,	,
38430	21	24	of	of	IN
38430	21	25	course	course	NN
38430	21	26	,	,	,
38430	21	27	means	mean	VBZ
38430	21	28	that	that	IN
38430	21	29	the	the	DT
38430	21	30	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	21	31	are	be	VBP
38430	21	32	false	false	JJ
38430	21	33	.	.	.
38430	22	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	22	2	appeared	appear	VBD
38430	22	3	the	the	DT
38430	22	4	true	true	JJ
38430	22	5	nature	nature	NN
38430	22	6	of	of	IN
38430	22	7	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	22	8	political	political	JJ
38430	22	9	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	22	10	.	.	.
38430	23	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	23	2	:	:	:
38430	23	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	23	4	1	1	CD
38430	23	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	23	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	23	7	This	this	DT
38430	23	8	Essay	Essay	NNP
38430	23	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	23	10	also	also	RB
38430	23	11	reprinted	reprint	VBN
38430	23	12	in	in	IN
38430	23	13	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	23	14	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	23	15	's	's	POS
38430	23	16	_	_	NNP
38430	23	17	Mysticism	Mysticism	NNP
38430	23	18	and	and	CC
38430	23	19	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	23	20	_	_	NNP
38430	23	21	,	,	,
38430	23	22	London	London	NNP
38430	23	23	and	and	CC
38430	23	24	New	New	NNP
38430	23	25	York	York	NNP
38430	23	26	,	,	,
38430	23	27	1918	1918	CD
38430	23	28	,	,	,
38430	23	29	pp	pp	NNP
38430	23	30	.	.	.
38430	24	1	46	46	CD
38430	24	2	-	-	HYPH
38430	24	3	57.--ED	57.--ed	CD
38430	24	4	.	.	.
38430	24	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	25	1	"	"	``
38430	25	2	Even	even	RB
38430	25	3	a	a	DT
38430	25	4	joke	joke	NN
38430	25	5	should	should	MD
38430	25	6	have	have	VB
38430	25	7	some	some	DT
38430	25	8	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	25	9	....	....	NFP
38430	25	10	"	"	''
38430	25	11	(	(	-LRB-
38430	25	12	The	the	DT
38430	25	13	Red	Red	NNP
38430	25	14	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	25	15	,	,	,
38430	25	16	_	_	NNP
38430	25	17	T.	T.	NNP
38430	26	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	26	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	26	3	_	_	NNP
38430	26	4	,	,	,
38430	26	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	26	6	105	105	CD
38430	26	7	)	)	-RRB-
38430	26	8	.	.	.
38430	27	1	CONTENTS	content	NNS
38430	27	2	PAGE	PAGE	NNP
38430	27	3	EDITOR	EDITOR	NNP
38430	27	4	'S	's	POS
38430	27	5	NOTE	note	NN
38430	27	6	3	3	CD
38430	27	7	ABBREVIATIONS	abbreviations	NN
38430	27	8	9	9	CD
38430	27	9	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	27	10	I.	i.	NN
38430	28	1	THE	the	DT
38430	28	2	INDEFINABLES	indefinable	NNS
38430	28	3	OF	of	IN
38430	28	4	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	28	5	11	11	CD
38430	28	6	II	ii	CD
38430	28	7	.	.	.
38430	29	1	OBJECTIVE	objective	JJ
38430	29	2	VALIDITY	validity	NN
38430	29	3	OF	of	IN
38430	29	4	THE	the	DT
38430	29	5	"	"	``
38430	29	6	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
38430	29	7	OF	of	IN
38430	29	8	THOUGHT	THOUGHT	NNP
38430	29	9	"	"	''
38430	29	10	15	15	CD
38430	29	11	III	iii	CD
38430	29	12	.	.	.
38430	30	1	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	30	2	16	16	CD
38430	30	3	IV	iv	NN
38430	30	4	.	.	.
38430	31	1	IDENTITY	identity	NN
38430	31	2	OF	of	IN
38430	31	3	CLASSES	classes	NN
38430	31	4	18	18	CD
38430	31	5	V.	v.	NN
38430	31	6	ETHICAL	ethical	NN
38430	31	7	APPLICATIONS	application	NNS
38430	31	8	OF	of	IN
38430	31	9	THE	the	DT
38430	31	10	LAW	law	NN
38430	31	11	OF	of	IN
38430	31	12	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	31	13	19	19	CD
38430	31	14	VI	VI	NNP
38430	31	15	.	.	.
38430	32	1	THE	the	DT
38430	32	2	LAW	law	NN
38430	32	3	OF	of	IN
38430	32	4	CONTRADICTION	CONTRADICTION	VBN
38430	32	5	IN	in	IN
38430	32	6	MODERN	MODERN	NNP
38430	32	7	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	32	8	21	21	CD
38430	32	9	VII	vii	NN
38430	32	10	.	.	.
38430	33	1	SYMBOLISM	SYMBOLISM	NNP
38430	33	2	AND	and	CC
38430	33	3	MEANING	meaning	NN
38430	33	4	22	22	CD
38430	33	5	VIII	viii	NN
38430	33	6	.	.	.
38430	34	1	NOMINALISM	NOMINALISM	NNP
38430	34	2	24	24	CD
38430	34	3	IX	ix	NN
38430	34	4	.	.	.
38430	35	1	AMBIGUITY	AMBIGUITY	NNP
38430	35	2	AND	and	CC
38430	35	3	SYMBOLIC	symbolic	NN
38430	35	4	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	35	5	26	26	CD
38430	35	6	X.	x.	NN
38430	36	1	LOGICAL	LOGICAL	NNP
38430	36	2	ADDITION	ADDITION	NNP
38430	36	3	AND	and	CC
38430	36	4	THE	the	DT
38430	36	5	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
38430	36	6	OF	of	IN
38430	36	7	SYMBOLISM	SYMBOLISM	NNP
38430	36	8	27	27	CD
38430	36	9	XI	XI	NNP
38430	36	10	.	.	.
38430	37	1	CRITICISM	CRITICISM	NNP
38430	37	2	29	29	CD
38430	37	3	XII	xii	NN
38430	37	4	.	.	.
38430	38	1	HISTORICAL	HISTORICAL	NNP
38430	38	2	CRITICISM	CRITICISM	NNP
38430	38	3	30	30	CD
38430	38	4	XIII	xiii	NN
38430	38	5	.	.	.
38430	39	1	IS	be	VBZ
38430	39	2	THE	the	DT
38430	39	3	MIND	mind	NN
38430	39	4	IN	in	IN
38430	39	5	THE	the	DT
38430	39	6	HEAD	HEAD	NNP
38430	39	7	?	?	.
38430	40	1	31	31	CD
38430	40	2	XIV	xiv	NN
38430	40	3	.	.	.
38430	41	1	THE	the	DT
38430	41	2	PRAGMATIST	PRAGMATIST	NNP
38430	41	3	THEORY	THEORY	NNP
38430	41	4	OF	of	IN
38430	41	5	TRUTH	truth	NN
38430	41	6	32	32	CD
38430	41	7	XV	XV	NNP
38430	41	8	.	.	.
38430	42	1	ASSERTION	assertion	NN
38430	42	2	34	34	CD
38430	42	3	XVI	XVI	NNS
38430	42	4	.	.	.
38430	43	1	THE	the	DT
38430	43	2	COMMUTATIVE	COMMUTATIVE	NNP
38430	43	3	LAW	law	NN
38430	43	4	35	35	CD
38430	43	5	XVII	XVII	NNP
38430	43	6	.	.	.
38430	44	1	UNIVERSAL	UNIVERSAL	NNP
38430	44	2	AND	and	CC
38430	44	3	PARTICULAR	PARTICULAR	NNP
38430	44	4	PROPOSITIONS	proposition	VBZ
38430	44	5	36	36	CD
38430	44	6	XVIII	xviii	NN
38430	44	7	.	.	.
38430	45	1	DENIAL	denial	NN
38430	45	2	OF	of	IN
38430	45	3	GENERALITY	GENERALITY	NNP
38430	45	4	AND	and	CC
38430	45	5	GENERALITY	generality	NN
38430	45	6	OF	of	IN
38430	45	7	DENIAL	denial	NN
38430	45	8	37	37	CD
38430	45	9	XIX	xix	NN
38430	45	10	.	.	.
38430	46	1	IMPLICATION	IMPLICATION	NNP
38430	46	2	39	39	CD
38430	46	3	XX	XX	NNS
38430	46	4	.	.	.
38430	47	1	DIGNITY	dignity	NN
38430	47	2	43	43	CD
38430	47	3	XXI	xxi	NN
38430	47	4	.	.	.
38430	48	1	THE	the	DT
38430	48	2	SYNTHETIC	synthetic	NN
38430	48	3	NATURE	NATURE	NNS
38430	48	4	OF	of	IN
38430	48	5	DEDUCTION	deduction	NN
38430	48	6	45	45	CD
38430	48	7	XXII	XXII	NNS
38430	48	8	.	.	.
38430	49	1	THE	the	DT
38430	49	2	MORTALITY	MORTALITY	NNP
38430	49	3	OF	of	IN
38430	49	4	SOCRATES	SOCRATES	NNP
38430	49	5	48	48	CD
38430	49	6	XXIII	xxiii	NN
38430	49	7	.	.	.
38430	50	1	DENOTING	DENOTING	NNP
38430	50	2	53	53	CD
38430	50	3	XXIV	xxiv	NN
38430	50	4	.	.	.
38430	51	1	THE	the	DT
38430	51	2	54	54	CD
38430	51	3	XXV	XXV	NNP
38430	51	4	.	.	.
38430	52	1	NON	non	LS
38430	52	2	-	-	NNP
38430	52	3	ENTITY	ENTITY	NNP
38430	52	4	56	56	CD
38430	52	5	XXVI	XXVI	NNS
38430	52	6	.	.	.
38430	53	1	IS	be	VBZ
38430	53	2	58	58	CD
38430	53	3	XXVII	xxvii	NN
38430	53	4	.	.	.
38430	54	1	AND	and	CC
38430	54	2	AND	and	CC
38430	54	3	OR	or	CC
38430	54	4	59	59	CD
38430	54	5	XXVIII	XXVIII	NNS
38430	54	6	.	.	.
38430	55	1	THE	the	DT
38430	55	2	CONVERSION	CONVERSION	NNP
38430	55	3	OF	of	IN
38430	55	4	RELATIONS	RELATIONS	NNP
38430	55	5	60	60	CD
38430	55	6	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
38430	55	7	.	.	.
38430	56	1	PREVIOUS	previous	JJ
38430	56	2	PHILOSOPHICAL	philosophical	NN
38430	56	3	THEORIES	theory	NNS
38430	56	4	OF	of	IN
38430	56	5	MATHEMATICS	MATHEMATICS	NNP
38430	56	6	61	61	CD
38430	56	7	XXX	XXX	NNP
38430	56	8	.	.	.
38430	57	1	FINITE	FINITE	NNS
38430	57	2	AND	and	CC
38430	57	3	INFINITE	INFINITE	NNP
38430	57	4	63	63	CD
38430	57	5	XXXI	xxxi	NN
38430	57	6	.	.	.
38430	58	1	THE	the	DT
38430	58	2	MATHEMATICAL	mathematical	NN
38430	58	3	ATTAINMENTS	attainment	VBZ
38430	58	4	OF	of	IN
38430	58	5	TRISTRAM	TRISTRAM	NNP
38430	58	6	SHANDY	shandy	VBP
38430	58	7	64	64	CD
38430	58	8	XXXII	XXXII	NNS
38430	58	9	.	.	.
38430	59	1	THE	the	DT
38430	59	2	HARDSHIPS	hardship	NNS
38430	59	3	OF	of	IN
38430	59	4	A	a	DT
38430	59	5	MAN	man	NN
38430	59	6	WITH	with	IN
38430	59	7	AN	an	DT
38430	59	8	UNLIMITED	UNLIMITED	NNP
38430	59	9	INCOME	INCOME	NNP
38430	59	10	66	66	CD
38430	59	11	XXXIII	xxxiii	NN
38430	59	12	.	.	.
38430	60	1	THE	the	DT
38430	60	2	RELATIONS	relations	NN
38430	60	3	OF	of	IN
38430	60	4	MAGNITUDE	MAGNITUDE	NNP
38430	60	5	OF	of	IN
38430	60	6	CARDINAL	CARDINAL	NNP
38430	60	7	NUMBERS	number	NNS
38430	60	8	69	69	CD
38430	60	9	XXXIV	xxxiv	NN
38430	60	10	.	.	.
38430	61	1	THE	the	DT
38430	61	2	UNKNOWABLE	UNKNOWABLE	NNP
38430	61	3	70	70	CD
38430	61	4	XXXV	XXXV	NNP
38430	61	5	.	.	.
38430	62	1	MR	MR	NNP
38430	62	2	.	.	.
38430	62	3	SPENCER	SPENCER	NNP
38430	62	4	,	,	,
38430	62	5	THE	the	DT
38430	62	6	ATHANASIAN	ATHANASIAN	NNP
38430	62	7	CREED	CREED	NNP
38430	62	8	,	,	,
38430	62	9	AND	and	CC
38430	62	10	THE	the	DT
38430	62	11	ARTICLES	ARTICLES	NNP
38430	62	12	73	73	CD
38430	62	13	XXXVI	XXXVI	NNP
38430	62	14	.	.	.
38430	63	1	THE	the	DT
38430	63	2	HUMOUR	humour	NN
38430	63	3	OF	of	IN
38430	63	4	MATHEMATICIANS	MATHEMATICIANS	NNP
38430	63	5	74	74	CD
38430	63	6	XXXVII	xxxvii	NN
38430	63	7	.	.	.
38430	64	1	THE	the	DT
38430	64	2	PARADOXES	PARADOXES	NNP
38430	64	3	OF	of	IN
38430	64	4	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	64	5	75	75	CD
38430	64	6	XXXVIII	xxxviii	NN
38430	64	7	.	.	.
38430	65	1	MODERN	MODERN	NNS
38430	65	2	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	65	3	AND	and	CC
38430	65	4	SOME	some	NN
38430	65	5	PHILOSOPHICAL	philosophical	NN
38430	65	6	ARGUMENTS	argument	NNS
38430	65	7	79	79	CD
38430	65	8	XXXIX	xxxix	NN
38430	65	9	.	.	.
38430	66	1	THE	the	DT
38430	66	2	HIERARCHY	HIERARCHY	NNS
38430	66	3	OF	of	IN
38430	66	4	JOKES	JOKES	NNP
38430	66	5	81	81	CD
38430	66	6	XL	XL	NNP
38430	66	7	.	.	.
38430	67	1	THE	the	DT
38430	67	2	EVIDENCE	evidence	NN
38430	67	3	OF	of	IN
38430	67	4	GEOMETRICAL	GEOMETRICAL	NNP
38430	67	5	PROPOSITIONS	PROPOSITIONS	NNP
38430	67	6	83	83	CD
38430	67	7	XLI	XLI	NNS
38430	67	8	.	.	.
38430	68	1	ABSOLUTE	ABSOLUTE	NNP
38430	68	2	AND	and	CC
38430	68	3	RELATIVE	relative	NN
38430	68	4	POSITION	position	NN
38430	68	5	84	84	CD
38430	68	6	XLII	xlii	NN
38430	68	7	.	.	.
38430	69	1	LAUGHTER	laughter	NN
38430	69	2	86	86	CD
38430	69	3	XLIII	XLIII	NNS
38430	69	4	.	.	.
38430	70	1	"	"	``
38430	70	2	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	NNP
38430	70	3	"	"	''
38430	70	4	AND	and	CC
38430	70	5	EVOLUTIONARY	EVOLUTIONARY	NNP
38430	70	6	ETHICS	ethic	NNS
38430	70	7	88	88	CD
38430	70	8	APPENDIXES	appendix	NNS
38430	70	9	89	89	CD
38430	70	10	ABBREVIATIONS	abbreviation	NNS
38430	70	11	_	_	NNP
38430	70	12	A.	a.	NN
38430	71	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	71	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	71	3	_	_	NNP
38430	71	4	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	71	5	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	71	6	:	:	:
38430	71	7	_	_	NNP
38430	71	8	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	71	9	's	's	POS
38430	71	10	Adventures	adventure	NNS
38430	71	11	in	in	IN
38430	71	12	Wonderland	Wonderland	NNP
38430	71	13	_	_	NNP
38430	71	14	,	,	,
38430	71	15	London	London	NNP
38430	71	16	,	,	,
38430	71	17	1908	1908	CD
38430	71	18	.	.	.
38430	72	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	72	2	This	this	DT
38430	72	3	book	book	NN
38430	72	4	was	be	VBD
38430	72	5	first	first	RB
38430	72	6	published	publish	VBN
38430	72	7	much	much	RB
38430	72	8	earlier	early	RBR
38430	72	9	,	,	,
38430	72	10	but	but	CC
38430	72	11	this	this	DT
38430	72	12	was	be	VBD
38430	72	13	the	the	DT
38430	72	14	edition	edition	NN
38430	72	15	used	use	VBN
38430	72	16	by	by	IN
38430	72	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	72	18	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	72	19	.	.	.
38430	73	1	The	the	DT
38430	73	2	same	same	JJ
38430	73	3	applies	apply	VBZ
38430	73	4	to	to	IN
38430	73	5	_	_	NNP
38430	73	6	H.	H.	NNP
38430	74	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	74	2	_	_	NNP
38430	74	3	and	and	CC
38430	74	4	_	_	NNP
38430	74	5	T.	T.	NNP
38430	75	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	75	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	75	3	_	_	NNP
38430	75	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	75	5	_	_	NNP
38430	75	6	A.	a.	NN
38430	76	1	C.	C.	NNP
38430	76	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	76	3	_	_	NNP
38430	76	4	John	John	NNP
38430	76	5	Henry	Henry	NNP
38430	76	6	Blunt	Blunt	NNP
38430	76	7	(	(	-LRB-
38430	76	8	ed	ed	NNP
38430	76	9	.	.	.
38430	77	1	by	by	IN
38430	77	2	)	)	-RRB-
38430	77	3	:	:	:
38430	77	4	_	_	NNP
38430	77	5	The	the	DT
38430	77	6	Annotated	Annotated	NNP
38430	77	7	Book	Book	NNP
38430	77	8	of	of	IN
38430	77	9	Common	Common	NNP
38430	77	10	Prayer	Prayer	NNP
38430	77	11	_	_	NNP
38430	77	12	,	,	,
38430	77	13	London	London	NNP
38430	77	14	,	,	,
38430	77	15	new	new	JJ
38430	77	16	edition	edition	NN
38430	77	17	,	,	,
38430	77	18	1888	1888	CD
38430	77	19	.	.	.
38430	78	1	_	_	NNP
38430	78	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	79	1	d.	d.	NNP
38430	79	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	79	3	_	_	NNP
38430	79	4	Ernst	Ernst	NNP
38430	79	5	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	79	6	:	:	:
38430	79	7	_	_	NNP
38430	79	8	Vorlesungen	Vorlesungen	NNP
38430	79	9	über	über	NN
38430	79	10	die	die	VBP
38430	79	11	Algebra	Algebra	NNP
38430	79	12	der	der	IN
38430	79	13	Logik	Logik	NNP
38430	79	14	,	,	,
38430	79	15	Leipzig	Leipzig	NNP
38430	79	16	_	_	NNP
38430	79	17	,	,	,
38430	79	18	vol	vol	NNP
38430	79	19	.	.	.
38430	80	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	80	2	,	,	,
38430	80	3	1890	1890	CD
38430	80	4	;	;	:
38430	80	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	80	6	.	.	.
38430	81	1	ii	ii	LS
38430	81	2	.	.	.
38430	82	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	82	2	two	two	CD
38430	82	3	parts	part	NNS
38430	82	4	)	)	-RRB-
38430	82	5	,	,	,
38430	82	6	1891	1891	CD
38430	82	7	and	and	CC
38430	82	8	1905	1905	CD
38430	82	9	;	;	:
38430	82	10	vol	vol	NNP
38430	82	11	.	.	.
38430	83	1	iii	iii	NNP
38430	83	2	.	.	.
38430	84	1	:	:	:
38430	84	2	_	_	NNP
38430	84	3	Algebra	Algebra	NNP
38430	84	4	und	und	JJ
38430	84	5	Logik	Logik	NNP
38430	84	6	der	der	NNP
38430	84	7	Relative	Relative	NNP
38430	84	8	_	_	NNP
38430	84	9	,	,	,
38430	84	10	1895	1895	CD
38430	84	11	.	.	.
38430	85	1	_	_	NNP
38430	85	2	E.	E.	NNP
38430	86	1	N.	N.	NNP
38430	86	2	_	_	NNP
38430	86	3	Richard	Richard	NNP
38430	86	4	Dedekind	Dedekind	NNP
38430	86	5	:	:	:
38430	86	6	_	_	NNP
38430	86	7	Essays	Essays	NNP
38430	86	8	on	on	IN
38430	86	9	the	the	DT
38430	86	10	Theory	Theory	NNP
38430	86	11	of	of	IN
38430	86	12	Numbers	Numbers	NNPS
38430	86	13	_	_	NNP
38430	86	14	,	,	,
38430	86	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
38430	86	16	and	and	CC
38430	86	17	London	London	NNP
38430	86	18	,	,	,
38430	86	19	1901	1901	CD
38430	86	20	.	.	.
38430	87	1	_	_	NNP
38430	87	2	E.	E.	NNP
38430	88	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	88	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	88	3	_	_	NNP
38430	88	4	William	William	NNP
38430	88	5	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
38430	88	6	Jevons	Jevons	NNPS
38430	88	7	:	:	:
38430	88	8	_	_	NNP
38430	88	9	Elementary	Elementary	NNP
38430	88	10	Lessons	Lessons	NNP
38430	88	11	in	in	IN
38430	88	12	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	88	13	,	,	,
38430	88	14	Deductive	Deductive	NNP
38430	88	15	and	and	CC
38430	88	16	Inductive	Inductive	NNP
38430	88	17	.	.	.
38430	89	1	With	with	IN
38430	89	2	copious	copious	JJ
38430	89	3	Questions	Questions	NNPS
38430	89	4	and	and	CC
38430	89	5	Examples	Examples	NNPS
38430	89	6	,	,	,
38430	89	7	and	and	CC
38430	89	8	a	a	DT
38430	89	9	Vocabulary	Vocabulary	NNP
38430	89	10	of	of	IN
38430	89	11	Logical	Logical	NNP
38430	89	12	Terms	Terms	NNPS
38430	89	13	_	_	NNP
38430	89	14	,	,	,
38430	89	15	London	London	NNP
38430	89	16	,	,	,
38430	89	17	24th	24th	JJ
38430	89	18	ed	ed	NNP
38430	89	19	.	.	NNP
38430	89	20	,	,	,
38430	89	21	1907	1907	CD
38430	89	22	[	[	-LRB-
38430	89	23	first	first	RB
38430	89	24	published	publish	VBN
38430	89	25	in	in	IN
38430	89	26	1870	1870	CD
38430	89	27	]	]	-RRB-
38430	89	28	.	.	.
38430	90	1	_	_	NNP
38430	90	2	E.	E.	NNP
38430	91	1	u.	u.	NNP
38430	91	2	I.	I.	NNP
38430	91	3	_	_	NNP
38430	91	4	Ernst	Ernst	NNP
38430	91	5	Mach	Mach	NNP
38430	91	6	:	:	:
38430	91	7	_	_	NNP
38430	91	8	Erkenntnis	Erkenntnis	NNP
38430	91	9	und	und	VBP
38430	91	10	Irrtum	Irrtum	NNP
38430	91	11	:	:	:
38430	91	12	Skizzen	Skizzen	NNP
38430	91	13	zur	zur	NNP
38430	91	14	Psychologie	Psychologie	NNP
38430	91	15	der	der	VBP
38430	91	16	Forschung	Forschung	NNP
38430	91	17	_	_	NNP
38430	91	18	,	,	,
38430	91	19	Leipzig	Leipzig	NNP
38430	91	20	,	,	,
38430	91	21	1906	1906	CD
38430	91	22	.	.	.
38430	92	1	_	_	NNP
38430	92	2	F.	F.	NNP
38430	93	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	93	2	_	_	NNP
38430	93	3	Augustus	Augustus	NNP
38430	93	4	De	De	NNP
38430	93	5	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	93	6	:	:	:
38430	93	7	_	_	NNP
38430	93	8	Formal	Formal	NNP
38430	93	9	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	93	10	:	:	:
38430	93	11	or	or	CC
38430	93	12	The	the	DT
38430	93	13	Calculus	calculus	NN
38430	93	14	of	of	IN
38430	93	15	Inference	Inference	NNP
38430	93	16	,	,	,
38430	93	17	Necessary	Necessary	NNP
38430	93	18	and	and	CC
38430	93	19	Probable	probable	JJ
38430	93	20	_	_	NNP
38430	93	21	,	,	,
38430	93	22	London	London	NNP
38430	93	23	,	,	,
38430	93	24	1847	1847	CD
38430	93	25	.	.	.
38430	94	1	_	_	NNP
38430	94	2	Fm	Fm	NNP
38430	94	3	.	.	.
38430	95	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	95	2	_	_	NNP
38430	95	3	John	John	NNP
38430	95	4	Neville	Neville	NNP
38430	95	5	Keynes	Keynes	NNP
38430	95	6	:	:	:
38430	95	7	_	_	NNP
38430	95	8	Studies	Studies	NNPS
38430	95	9	and	and	CC
38430	95	10	Exercises	Exercises	NNPS
38430	95	11	in	in	IN
38430	95	12	Formal	Formal	NNP
38430	95	13	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	95	14	_	_	NNP
38430	95	15	,	,	,
38430	95	16	4th	4th	JJ
38430	95	17	ed	ed	NNP
38430	95	18	.	.	NNP
38430	95	19	,	,	,
38430	95	20	London	London	NNP
38430	95	21	,	,	,
38430	95	22	1906	1906	CD
38430	95	23	.	.	.
38430	96	1	_	_	NNP
38430	96	2	Gg	Gg	NNP
38430	96	3	.	.	.
38430	96	4	_	_	NNP
38430	96	5	Gottlob	Gottlob	NNP
38430	96	6	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	96	7	:	:	:
38430	96	8	_	_	NNP
38430	96	9	Grundgesetze	Grundgesetze	NNP
38430	96	10	der	der	VBP
38430	96	11	Arithmetik	Arithmetik	NNP
38430	96	12	begriffschriftlich	begriffschriftlich	NN
38430	96	13	abgeleitet	abgeleitet	NN
38430	96	14	_	_	NNP
38430	96	15	,	,	,
38430	96	16	Jena	Jena	NNP
38430	96	17	,	,	,
38430	96	18	vol	vol	NNP
38430	96	19	.	.	.
38430	97	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	97	2	,	,	,
38430	97	3	1893	1893	CD
38430	97	4	;	;	:
38430	97	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	97	6	.	.	.
38430	98	1	ii	ii	NNP
38430	98	2	.	.	NNP
38430	98	3	,	,	,
38430	98	4	1903	1903	CD
38430	98	5	.	.	.
38430	99	1	_	_	NNP
38430	99	2	Gl	Gl	NNP
38430	99	3	.	.	.
38430	99	4	_	_	NNP
38430	99	5	Gottlob	Gottlob	NNP
38430	99	6	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	99	7	:	:	:
38430	99	8	_	_	NNP
38430	99	9	Die	Die	NNP
38430	99	10	Grundlagen	Grundlagen	NNP
38430	99	11	der	der	NN
38430	99	12	Arithmetik	Arithmetik	NNP
38430	99	13	:	:	:
38430	99	14	eine	eine	NNP
38430	99	15	logisch	logisch	JJ
38430	99	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	99	17	mathematische	mathematische	NNP
38430	99	18	Untersuchung	untersuchung	JJ
38430	99	19	über	über	NN
38430	99	20	den	den	NN
38430	99	21	Begriff	Begriff	NNP
38430	99	22	der	der	IN
38430	99	23	Zahl	Zahl	NNP
38430	99	24	_	_	NNP
38430	99	25	,	,	,
38430	99	26	Breslau	Breslau	NNP
38430	99	27	,	,	,
38430	99	28	1884	1884	CD
38430	99	29	.	.	.
38430	100	1	_	_	NNP
38430	100	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	101	1	u.	u.	NNP
38430	101	2	E.	E.	NNP
38430	101	3	_	_	NNP
38430	101	4	G.	G.	NNP
38430	101	5	Heymans	Heymans	NNPS
38430	101	6	:	:	:
38430	101	7	_	_	NNP
38430	101	8	Die	Die	NNP
38430	101	9	Gesetze	Gesetze	NNP
38430	101	10	und	und	NN
38430	101	11	Elemente	Elemente	NNP
38430	101	12	des	des	FW
38430	101	13	wisenschaftlichen	wisenschaftlichen	NN
38430	101	14	Denkens	Denkens	NNP
38430	101	15	_	_	NNP
38430	101	16	,	,	,
38430	101	17	Leiden	Leiden	NNP
38430	101	18	,	,	,
38430	101	19	vol	vol	NNP
38430	101	20	.	.	.
38430	102	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	102	2	,	,	,
38430	102	3	1890	1890	CD
38430	102	4	;	;	:
38430	102	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	102	6	.	.	.
38430	103	1	ii	ii	NNP
38430	103	2	.	.	NNP
38430	103	3	,	,	,
38430	103	4	1894	1894	CD
38430	103	5	.	.	.
38430	104	1	_	_	NNP
38430	104	2	H.	H.	NNP
38430	105	1	J.	J.	NNP
38430	105	2	_	_	NNP
38430	105	3	_	_	NNP
38430	105	4	The	the	DT
38430	105	5	Hibbert	Hibbert	NNP
38430	105	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
38430	105	7	:	:	:
38430	105	8	a	a	DT
38430	105	9	Quarterly	Quarterly	NNP
38430	105	10	Review	Review	NNP
38430	105	11	of	of	IN
38430	105	12	Religion	Religion	NNP
38430	105	13	,	,	,
38430	105	14	Theology	Theology	NNP
38430	105	15	and	and	CC
38430	105	16	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	105	17	_	_	NNP
38430	105	18	,	,	,
38430	105	19	London	London	NNP
38430	105	20	and	and	CC
38430	105	21	New	New	NNP
38430	105	22	York	York	NNP
38430	105	23	.	.	.
38430	106	1	_	_	NNP
38430	106	2	H.	H.	NNP
38430	107	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	107	2	_	_	NNP
38430	107	3	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	107	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	107	5	:	:	:
38430	107	6	_	_	NNP
38430	107	7	The	the	DT
38430	107	8	Hunting	Hunting	NNP
38430	107	9	of	of	IN
38430	107	10	the	the	DT
38430	107	11	Snark	snark	NN
38430	107	12	:	:	:
38430	107	13	an	an	DT
38430	107	14	Agony	Agony	NNP
38430	107	15	in	in	IN
38430	107	16	Eight	Eight	NNP
38430	107	17	Fits	Fits	NNPS
38430	107	18	_	_	NNP
38430	107	19	,	,	,
38430	107	20	London	London	NNP
38430	107	21	,	,	,
38430	107	22	1911	1911	CD
38430	107	23	.	.	.
38430	108	1	_	_	NNP
38430	108	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	108	3	_	_	NNP
38430	108	4	_	_	NNP
38430	108	5	The	the	DT
38430	108	6	Monist	Monist	NNP
38430	108	7	:	:	:
38430	108	8	a	a	DT
38430	108	9	Quarterly	Quarterly	NNP
38430	108	10	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
38430	108	11	Devoted	devote	VBN
38430	108	12	to	to	IN
38430	108	13	Science	Science	NNP
38430	108	14	and	and	CC
38430	108	15	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	108	16	_	_	NNP
38430	108	17	,	,	,
38430	108	18	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
38430	108	19	and	and	CC
38430	108	20	London	London	NNP
38430	108	21	.	.	.
38430	109	1	_	_	NNP
38430	109	2	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	109	3	_	_	NNP
38430	109	4	_	_	NNP
38430	109	5	Mind	Mind	NNP
38430	109	6	:	:	:
38430	109	7	a	a	DT
38430	109	8	Quarterly	Quarterly	NNP
38430	109	9	Review	Review	NNP
38430	109	10	of	of	IN
38430	109	11	Psychology	Psychology	NNP
38430	109	12	and	and	CC
38430	109	13	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	109	14	_	_	NNP
38430	109	15	,	,	,
38430	109	16	London	London	NNP
38430	109	17	and	and	CC
38430	109	18	New	New	NNP
38430	109	19	York	York	NNP
38430	109	20	.	.	.
38430	110	1	_	_	NNP
38430	110	2	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
38430	111	1	Ma	Ma	NNP
38430	111	2	.	.	NNP
38430	111	3	_	_	NNP
38430	111	4	Alfred	Alfred	NNP
38430	111	5	North	North	NNP
38430	111	6	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
38430	111	7	and	and	CC
38430	111	8	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	111	9	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	111	10	:	:	:
38430	111	11	_	_	NNP
38430	111	12	Principia	Principia	NNP
38430	111	13	Mathematica	Mathematica	NNP
38430	111	14	_	_	NNP
38430	111	15	,	,	,
38430	111	16	vol	vol	NNP
38430	111	17	.	.	.
38430	112	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	112	2	,	,	,
38430	112	3	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	112	4	,	,	,
38430	112	5	1910	1910	CD
38430	112	6	.	.	.
38430	113	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	113	2	Other	other	JJ
38430	113	3	volumes	volume	NNS
38430	113	4	were	be	VBD
38430	113	5	published	publish	VBN
38430	113	6	in	in	IN
38430	113	7	1912	1912	CD
38430	113	8	and	and	CC
38430	113	9	1913	1913	CD
38430	113	10	.	.	.
38430	113	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	114	1	_	_	NNP
38430	114	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	115	1	E.	E.	NNP
38430	115	2	_	_	NNP
38430	115	3	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	115	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	115	5	:	:	:
38430	115	6	_	_	NNP
38430	115	7	Philosophical	Philosophical	NNP
38430	115	8	Essays	Essays	NNPS
38430	115	9	_	_	NNP
38430	115	10	,	,	,
38430	115	11	London	London	NNP
38430	115	12	and	and	CC
38430	115	13	New	New	NNP
38430	115	14	York	York	NNP
38430	115	15	,	,	,
38430	115	16	1910	1910	CD
38430	115	17	.	.	.
38430	116	1	_	_	NNP
38430	116	2	Ph	Ph	NNP
38430	116	3	.	.	.
38430	117	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	117	2	_	_	NNP
38430	117	3	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	117	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	117	5	:	:	:
38430	117	6	_	_	NNP
38430	117	7	A	a	DT
38430	117	8	Critical	Critical	NNP
38430	117	9	Exposition	Exposition	NNP
38430	117	10	of	of	IN
38430	117	11	the	the	DT
38430	117	12	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	117	13	of	of	IN
38430	117	14	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	117	15	,	,	,
38430	117	16	with	with	IN
38430	117	17	an	an	DT
38430	117	18	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	117	19	of	of	IN
38430	117	20	Leading	Leading	NNP
38430	117	21	Passages	Passages	NNPS
38430	117	22	_	_	NNP
38430	117	23	,	,	,
38430	117	24	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	117	25	,	,	,
38430	117	26	1900	1900	CD
38430	117	27	.	.	.
38430	118	1	_	_	NNP
38430	118	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	119	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	119	2	_	_	NNP
38430	119	3	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	119	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	119	5	:	:	:
38430	119	6	_	_	NNP
38430	119	7	The	the	DT
38430	119	8	Principles	Principles	NNPS
38430	119	9	of	of	IN
38430	119	10	Mathematics	Mathematics	NNP
38430	119	11	_	_	NNP
38430	119	12	,	,	,
38430	119	13	vol	vol	NNP
38430	119	14	.	.	.
38430	120	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	120	2	,	,	,
38430	120	3	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	120	4	,	,	,
38430	120	5	1903	1903	CD
38430	120	6	.	.	.
38430	121	1	_	_	NNP
38430	121	2	R.	R.	NNP
38430	122	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	122	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	122	3	_	_	NNP
38430	122	4	_	_	NNP
38430	122	5	Revue	Revue	NNP
38430	122	6	de	de	NNP
38430	122	7	Métaphysique	Métaphysique	NNP
38430	122	8	et	et	FW
38430	122	9	de	de	FW
38430	122	10	Morale	Morale	NNP
38430	122	11	_	_	NNP
38430	122	12	,	,	,
38430	122	13	Paris	Paris	NNP
38430	122	14	.	.	.
38430	123	1	_	_	NNP
38430	123	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	124	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	124	2	_	_	NNP
38430	124	3	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	124	4	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	124	5	:	:	:
38430	124	6	_	_	NNP
38430	124	7	Sylvie	Sylvie	NNP
38430	124	8	and	and	CC
38430	124	9	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
38430	124	10	_	_	NNP
38430	124	11	,	,	,
38430	124	12	London	London	NNP
38430	124	13	,	,	,
38430	124	14	1889	1889	CD
38430	124	15	.	.	.
38430	125	1	_	_	NNP
38430	125	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	126	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	126	2	_	_	NNP
38430	126	3	John	John	NNP
38430	126	4	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	126	5	:	:	:
38430	126	6	_	_	NNP
38430	126	7	Symbolic	Symbolic	NNP
38430	126	8	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	126	9	_	_	NNP
38430	126	10	,	,	,
38430	126	11	London	London	NNP
38430	126	12	,	,	,
38430	126	13	1881	1881	CD
38430	126	14	;	;	:
38430	126	15	2nd	2nd	NNP
38430	126	16	ed	ed	NNP
38430	126	17	.	.	NNP
38430	126	18	,	,	,
38430	126	19	1894	1894	CD
38430	126	20	.	.	.
38430	127	1	_	_	NNP
38430	127	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	128	1	o.	o.	NNP
38430	128	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	128	3	_	_	NNP
38430	128	4	William	William	NNP
38430	128	5	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
38430	128	6	Jevons	Jevons	NNPS
38430	128	7	:	:	:
38430	128	8	_	_	NNP
38430	128	9	The	the	DT
38430	128	10	Substitution	Substitution	NNP
38430	128	11	of	of	IN
38430	128	12	Similars	Similars	NNPS
38430	128	13	,	,	,
38430	128	14	the	the	DT
38430	128	15	True	True	NNP
38430	128	16	Principle	Principle	NNP
38430	128	17	of	of	IN
38430	128	18	Reasoning	Reasoning	NNP
38430	128	19	derived	derive	VBN
38430	128	20	from	from	IN
38430	128	21	a	a	DT
38430	128	22	Modification	Modification	NNP
38430	128	23	of	of	IN
38430	128	24	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
38430	128	25	's	's	POS
38430	128	26	Dictum	Dictum	NNP
38430	128	27	_	_	NNP
38430	128	28	,	,	,
38430	128	29	London	London	NNP
38430	128	30	,	,	,
38430	128	31	1869	1869	CD
38430	128	32	.	.	.
38430	129	1	_	_	NNP
38430	129	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	130	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	130	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	130	3	_	_	NNP
38430	130	4	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	130	5	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	130	6	:	:	:
38430	130	7	_	_	NNP
38430	130	8	Through	through	IN
38430	130	9	the	the	DT
38430	130	10	Looking	Looking	NNP
38430	130	11	-	-	HYPH
38430	130	12	Glass	Glass	NNP
38430	130	13	,	,	,
38430	130	14	and	and	CC
38430	130	15	what	what	WP
38430	130	16	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	130	17	found	find	VBD
38430	130	18	there	there	RB
38430	130	19	_	_	NNP
38430	130	20	,	,	,
38430	130	21	London	London	NNP
38430	130	22	,	,	,
38430	130	23	1911	1911	CD
38430	130	24	.	.	.
38430	131	1	_	_	NNP
38430	131	2	Z.	Z.	NNP
38430	132	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	132	2	_	_	NNP
38430	132	3	Gottlob	Gottlob	NNP
38430	132	4	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	132	5	:	:	:
38430	132	6	_	_	NNP
38430	132	7	Ueber	Ueber	NNP
38430	132	8	die	die	VBP
38430	132	9	Zahlen	Zahlen	NNP
38430	132	10	des	des	NNP
38430	132	11	Herrn	Herrn	NNP
38430	132	12	H.	H.	NNP
38430	132	13	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
38430	132	14	_	_	NNP
38430	132	15	,	,	,
38430	132	16	Jena	Jena	NNP
38430	132	17	,	,	,
38430	132	18	1899	1899	CD
38430	132	19	.	.	.
38430	133	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	133	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	133	3	THE	the	DT
38430	133	4	INDEFINABLES	indefinable	NNS
38430	133	5	OF	of	IN
38430	133	6	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	133	7	The	the	DT
38430	133	8	view	view	NN
38430	133	9	that	that	IN
38430	133	10	the	the	DT
38430	133	11	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
38430	133	12	principles	principle	NNS
38430	133	13	of	of	IN
38430	133	14	logic	logic	NN
38430	133	15	consist	consist	VBP
38430	133	16	solely	solely	RB
38430	133	17	of	of	IN
38430	133	18	the	the	DT
38430	133	19	law	law	NN
38430	133	20	of	of	IN
38430	133	21	identity	identity	NN
38430	133	22	was	be	VBD
38430	133	23	held	hold	VBN
38430	133	24	by	by	IN
38430	133	25	Leibniz,[2	Leibniz,[2	NNP
38430	133	26	]	]	-RRB-
38430	133	27	Drobisch	Drobisch	NNP
38430	133	28	,	,	,
38430	133	29	Uberweg,[3	Uberweg,[3	NNP
38430	133	30	]	]	-RRB-
38430	133	31	and	and	CC
38430	133	32	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	133	33	.	.	.
38430	134	1	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	134	2	,	,	,
38430	134	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	134	4	may	may	MD
38430	134	5	be	be	VB
38430	134	6	remembered,[4	remembered,[4	LS
38430	134	7	]	]	-RRB-
38430	134	8	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	134	9	that	that	IN
38430	134	10	certain	certain	JJ
38430	134	11	identities	identity	NNS
38430	134	12	"	"	``
38430	134	13	are	be	VBP
38430	134	14	"	"	``
38430	134	15	logic	logic	NN
38430	134	16	.	.	.
38430	135	1	Now	now	RB
38430	135	2	,	,	,
38430	135	3	there	there	EX
38430	135	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	135	5	some	some	DT
38430	135	6	doubt	doubt	NN
38430	135	7	as	as	IN
38430	135	8	to	to	IN
38430	135	9	whether	whether	IN
38430	135	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	135	11	,	,	,
38430	135	12	like	like	IN
38430	135	13	Jevons,[5	Jevons,[5	NNP
38430	135	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	135	15	understood	understand	VBD
38430	135	16	"	"	``
38430	135	17	are	be	VBP
38430	135	18	"	"	``
38430	135	19	to	to	TO
38430	135	20	mean	mean	VB
38430	135	21	what	what	WP
38430	135	22	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	135	23	mean	mean	VBP
38430	135	24	by	by	IN
38430	135	25	"	"	``
38430	135	26	=	=	NNS
38430	135	27	,	,	,
38430	135	28	"	"	''
38430	135	29	or	or	CC
38430	135	30	,	,	,
38430	135	31	like	like	IN
38430	135	32	Schröder[6	Schröder[6	NNP
38430	135	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	135	34	and	and	CC
38430	135	35	most	most	JJS
38430	135	36	logicians	logicians	NNPS
38430	135	37	,	,	,
38430	135	38	to	to	TO
38430	135	39	have	have	VB
38430	135	40	the	the	DT
38430	135	41	same	same	JJ
38430	135	42	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	135	43	as	as	IN
38430	135	44	the	the	DT
38430	135	45	relation	relation	NN
38430	135	46	of	of	IN
38430	135	47	subsumption	subsumption	NN
38430	135	48	.	.	.
38430	136	1	The	the	DT
38430	136	2	first	first	JJ
38430	136	3	alternative	alternative	NN
38430	136	4	alone	alone	RB
38430	136	5	would	would	MD
38430	136	6	justify	justify	VB
38430	136	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	136	8	contention	contention	NN
38430	136	9	;	;	:
38430	136	10	and	and	CC
38430	136	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	136	12	may	may	MD
38430	136	13	,	,	,
38430	136	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	136	15	think	think	VBP
38430	136	16	,	,	,
38430	136	17	conclude	conclude	VBP
38430	136	18	from	from	IN
38430	136	19	an	an	DT
38430	136	20	opposition	opposition	NN
38430	136	21	to	to	IN
38430	136	22	authority	authority	NN
38430	136	23	that	that	WDT
38430	136	24	may	may	MD
38430	136	25	have	have	VB
38430	136	26	been	be	VBN
38430	136	27	indicated	indicate	VBN
38430	136	28	by	by	IN
38430	136	29	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	136	30	's	's	POS
38430	136	31	frequent	frequent	JJ
38430	136	32	use	use	NN
38430	136	33	of	of	IN
38430	136	34	the	the	DT
38430	136	35	word	word	NN
38430	136	36	"	"	``
38430	136	37	contrariwise	contrariwise	NN
38430	136	38	"	"	''
38430	136	39	that	that	IN
38430	136	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	136	41	did	do	VBD
38430	136	42	not	not	RB
38430	136	43	follow	follow	VB
38430	136	44	the	the	DT
38430	136	45	majority	majority	NN
38430	136	46	of	of	IN
38430	136	47	logicians	logicians	NNPS
38430	136	48	,	,	,
38430	136	49	but	but	CC
38430	136	50	held	hold	VBD
38430	136	51	,	,	,
38430	136	52	like	like	IN
38430	136	53	Jevons,[7	Jevons,[7	NNP
38430	136	54	]	]	-RRB-
38430	136	55	the	the	DT
38430	136	56	mistaken[8	mistaken[8	NNPS
38430	136	57	]	]	-RRB-
38430	136	58	view	view	NN
38430	136	59	that	that	IN
38430	136	60	the	the	DT
38430	136	61	quantification	quantification	NN
38430	136	62	of	of	IN
38430	136	63	the	the	DT
38430	136	64	predicate	predicate	NN
38430	136	65	is	be	VBZ
38430	136	66	relevant	relevant	JJ
38430	136	67	to	to	IN
38430	136	68	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
38430	136	69	logic	logic	NN
38430	136	70	.	.	.
38430	137	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	137	2	may	may	MD
38430	137	3	be	be	VB
38430	137	4	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	137	5	,	,	,
38430	137	6	by	by	IN
38430	137	7	the	the	DT
38430	137	8	way	way	NN
38430	137	9	,	,	,
38430	137	10	that	that	IN
38430	137	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	137	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	137	13	probable	probable	JJ
38430	137	14	that	that	IN
38430	137	15	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	137	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	137	17	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	137	18	's	's	POS
38430	137	19	"	"	``
38430	137	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	137	21	"	"	``
38430	137	22	is	be	VBZ
38430	137	23	the	the	DT
38430	137	24	"	"	``
38430	137	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	137	26	"	"	''
38430	137	27	of	of	IN
38430	137	28	identity	identity	NN
38430	137	29	.	.	.
38430	138	1	In	in	IN
38430	138	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	138	3	,	,	,
38430	138	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	138	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	138	6	not	not	RB
38430	138	7	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
38430	138	8	that	that	IN
38430	138	9	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	138	10	-	-	HYPH
38430	138	11	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	138	12	was	be	VBD
38430	138	13	a	a	DT
38430	138	14	Hegelian	Hegelian	NNP
38430	138	15	;	;	:
38430	138	16	for	for	IN
38430	138	17	,	,	,
38430	138	18	although	although	IN
38430	138	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	138	20	ability	ability	NN
38430	138	21	for	for	IN
38430	138	22	clear	clear	JJ
38430	138	23	explanation	explanation	NN
38430	138	24	may	may	MD
38430	138	25	seem	seem	VB
38430	138	26	to	to	TO
38430	138	27	militate	militate	VB
38430	138	28	against	against	IN
38430	138	29	this	this	DT
38430	138	30	,	,	,
38430	138	31	yet	yet	CC
38430	138	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	138	33	inability	inability	NN
38430	138	34	to	to	TO
38430	138	35	understand	understand	VB
38430	138	36	mathematics,[9	mathematics,[9	NNP
38430	138	37	]	]	-RRB-
38430	138	38	together	together	RB
38430	138	39	with	with	IN
38430	138	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	138	41	synthesis	synthesis	NN
38430	138	42	of	of	IN
38430	138	43	a	a	DT
38430	138	44	cravat	cravat	NN
38430	138	45	and	and	CC
38430	138	46	a	a	DT
38430	138	47	belt	belt	NN
38430	138	48	,	,	,
38430	138	49	which	which	WDT
38430	138	50	usually	usually	RB
38430	138	51	serve	serve	VBP
38430	138	52	different	different	JJ
38430	138	53	purposes,[10	purposes,[10	CD
38430	138	54	]	]	-RRB-
38430	138	55	and	and	CC
38430	138	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	138	57	proclivity	proclivity	NN
38430	138	58	towards	towards	IN
38430	138	59	riddles	riddle	NNS
38430	138	60	seem	seem	VBP
38430	138	61	to	to	TO
38430	138	62	make	make	VB
38430	138	63	out	out	RP
38430	138	64	a	a	DT
38430	138	65	good	good	JJ
38430	138	66	case	case	NN
38430	138	67	for	for	IN
38430	138	68	those	those	DT
38430	138	69	who	who	WP
38430	138	70	hold	hold	VBP
38430	138	71	that	that	IN
38430	138	72	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	138	73	was	be	VBD
38430	138	74	in	in	IN
38430	138	75	fact	fact	NN
38430	138	76	a	a	DT
38430	138	77	Hegelian	Hegelian	NNP
38430	138	78	.	.	.
38430	139	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
38430	139	2	,	,	,
38430	139	3	riddles	riddle	NNS
38430	139	4	are	be	VBP
38430	139	5	very	very	RB
38430	139	6	closely	closely	RB
38430	139	7	allied	ally	VBN
38430	139	8	to	to	IN
38430	139	9	puns	pun	NNS
38430	139	10	,	,	,
38430	139	11	and	and	CC
38430	139	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	139	13	was	be	VBD
38430	139	14	upon	upon	IN
38430	139	15	a	a	DT
38430	139	16	pun	pun	NN
38430	139	17	,	,	,
38430	139	18	consisting	consist	VBG
38430	139	19	of	of	IN
38430	139	20	the	the	DT
38430	139	21	confusion	confusion	NN
38430	139	22	of	of	IN
38430	139	23	the	the	DT
38430	139	24	"	"	``
38430	139	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	139	26	"	"	``
38430	139	27	of	of	IN
38430	139	28	predication	predication	NN
38430	139	29	with	with	IN
38430	139	30	the	the	DT
38430	139	31	"	"	``
38430	139	32	is	be	VBZ
38430	139	33	"	"	''
38430	139	34	of	of	IN
38430	139	35	identity	identity	NN
38430	139	36	--	--	:
38430	139	37	so	so	IN
38430	139	38	that	that	IN
38430	139	39	,	,	,
38430	139	40	for	for	IN
38430	139	41	example	example	NN
38430	139	42	,	,	,
38430	139	43	"	"	``
38430	139	44	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	139	45	"	"	''
38430	139	46	was	be	VBD
38430	139	47	identified	identify	VBN
38430	139	48	with	with	IN
38430	139	49	"	"	``
38430	139	50	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	139	51	"	"	''
38430	139	52	and	and	CC
38430	139	53	more	more	RBR
38430	139	54	generally	generally	RB
38430	139	55	the	the	DT
38430	139	56	particular	particular	JJ
38430	139	57	with	with	IN
38430	139	58	the	the	DT
38430	139	59	universal	universal	NN
38430	139	60	--	--	:
38430	139	61	that	that	IN
38430	139	62	Hegel	Hegel	NNP
38430	139	63	's	's	POS
38430	139	64	system	system	NN
38430	139	65	of	of	IN
38430	139	66	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	139	67	was	be	VBD
38430	139	68	founded	found	VBN
38430	139	69	.	.	.
38430	140	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	140	2	11	11	CD
38430	140	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	140	4	But	but	CC
38430	140	5	the	the	DT
38430	140	6	question	question	NN
38430	140	7	of	of	IN
38430	140	8	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	140	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	140	10	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	140	11	's	's	POS
38430	140	12	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	140	13	opinions	opinion	NNS
38430	140	14	must	must	MD
38430	140	15	be	be	VB
38430	140	16	left	leave	VBN
38430	140	17	for	for	IN
38430	140	18	final	final	JJ
38430	140	19	verification	verification	NN
38430	140	20	to	to	IN
38430	140	21	the	the	DT
38430	140	22	historians	historian	NNS
38430	140	23	of	of	IN
38430	140	24	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	140	25	:	:	:
38430	140	26	here	here	RB
38430	140	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	140	28	am	be	VBP
38430	140	29	only	only	RB
38430	140	30	concerned	concern	VBN
38430	140	31	with	with	IN
38430	140	32	an	an	DT
38430	140	33	_	_	NNP
38430	140	34	a	a	DT
38430	140	35	priori	priori	FW
38430	140	36	_	_	NNP
38430	140	37	logical	logical	JJ
38430	140	38	construction	construction	NN
38430	140	39	of	of	IN
38430	140	40	what	what	WP
38430	140	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	140	42	views	view	NNS
38430	140	43	might	may	MD
38430	140	44	have	have	VB
38430	140	45	been	be	VBN
38430	140	46	if	if	IN
38430	140	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	140	48	formed	form	VBD
38430	140	49	a	a	DT
38430	140	50	consistent	consistent	JJ
38430	140	51	whole	whole	NN
38430	140	52	.	.	.
38430	141	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	141	2	12	12	CD
38430	141	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	141	4	If	if	IN
38430	141	5	the	the	DT
38430	141	6	principle	principle	NN
38430	141	7	of	of	IN
38430	141	8	identity	identity	NN
38430	141	9	were	be	VBD
38430	141	10	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	141	11	the	the	DT
38430	141	12	sole	sole	JJ
38430	141	13	principle	principle	NN
38430	141	14	of	of	IN
38430	141	15	logic	logic	NN
38430	141	16	,	,	,
38430	141	17	the	the	DT
38430	141	18	principles	principle	NNS
38430	141	19	of	of	IN
38430	141	20	logic	logic	NN
38430	141	21	could	could	MD
38430	141	22	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	141	23	be	be	VB
38430	141	24	said	say	VBN
38430	141	25	to	to	TO
38430	141	26	be	be	VB
38430	141	27	,	,	,
38430	141	28	as	as	IN
38430	141	29	in	in	IN
38430	141	30	fact	fact	NN
38430	141	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	141	32	are	be	VBP
38430	141	33	,	,	,
38430	141	34	a	a	DT
38430	141	35	body	body	NN
38430	141	36	of	of	IN
38430	141	37	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	141	38	whose	whose	WP$
38430	141	39	consistency	consistency	NN
38430	141	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	141	41	is	be	VBZ
38430	141	42	impossible	impossible	JJ
38430	141	43	to	to	TO
38430	141	44	prove	prove	VB
38430	141	45	.	.	.
38430	142	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	142	2	13	13	CD
38430	142	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	142	4	This	this	DT
38430	142	5	characteristic	characteristic	NN
38430	142	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	142	7	important	important	JJ
38430	142	8	and	and	CC
38430	142	9	one	one	CD
38430	142	10	of	of	IN
38430	142	11	the	the	DT
38430	142	12	marks	mark	NNS
38430	142	13	of	of	IN
38430	142	14	the	the	DT
38430	142	15	greatest	great	JJS
38430	142	16	possible	possible	JJ
38430	142	17	security	security	NN
38430	142	18	.	.	.
38430	143	1	For	for	IN
38430	143	2	example	example	NN
38430	143	3	,	,	,
38430	143	4	while	while	IN
38430	143	5	a	a	DT
38430	143	6	great	great	JJ
38430	143	7	achievement	achievement	NN
38430	143	8	of	of	IN
38430	143	9	late	late	JJ
38430	143	10	years	year	NNS
38430	143	11	has	have	VBZ
38430	143	12	been	be	VBN
38430	143	13	to	to	TO
38430	143	14	prove	prove	VB
38430	143	15	the	the	DT
38430	143	16	consistency	consistency	NN
38430	143	17	of	of	IN
38430	143	18	the	the	DT
38430	143	19	principles	principle	NNS
38430	143	20	of	of	IN
38430	143	21	arithmetic	arithmetic	JJ
38430	143	22	,	,	,
38430	143	23	a	a	DT
38430	143	24	science	science	NN
38430	143	25	which	which	WDT
38430	143	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	143	27	unreservedly	unreservedly	RB
38430	143	28	accepted	accept	VBN
38430	143	29	except	except	IN
38430	143	30	by	by	IN
38430	143	31	some	some	DT
38430	143	32	empiricists,[14	empiricists,[14	CD
38430	143	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	143	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	143	35	can	can	MD
38430	143	36	be	be	VB
38430	143	37	proved	prove	VBN
38430	143	38	formally	formally	RB
38430	143	39	that	that	IN
38430	143	40	one	one	CD
38430	143	41	foundation	foundation	NN
38430	143	42	of	of	IN
38430	143	43	arithmetic	arithmetic	JJ
38430	143	44	is	be	VBZ
38430	143	45	shattered	shatter	VBN
38430	143	46	.	.	.
38430	144	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	144	2	15	15	CD
38430	144	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	144	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	144	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	144	6	true	true	JJ
38430	144	7	that	that	IN
38430	144	8	,	,	,
38430	144	9	quite	quite	RB
38430	144	10	lately	lately	RB
38430	144	11	,	,	,
38430	144	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	144	13	has	have	VBZ
38430	144	14	been	be	VBN
38430	144	15	shown	show	VBN
38430	144	16	that	that	IN
38430	144	17	this	this	DT
38430	144	18	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	144	19	may	may	MD
38430	144	20	be	be	VB
38430	144	21	avoided	avoid	VBN
38430	144	22	,	,	,
38430	144	23	and	and	CC
38430	144	24	,	,	,
38430	144	25	by	by	IN
38430	144	26	a	a	DT
38430	144	27	re	re	NN
38430	144	28	-	-	NN
38430	144	29	moulding	moulding	NN
38430	144	30	of	of	IN
38430	144	31	logic	logic	NN
38430	144	32	,	,	,
38430	144	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	144	34	can	can	MD
38430	144	35	draw	draw	VB
38430	144	36	instead	instead	RB
38430	144	37	the	the	DT
38430	144	38	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	144	39	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	144	40	that	that	IN
38430	144	41	the	the	DT
38430	144	42	opinions	opinion	NNS
38430	144	43	held	hold	VBN
38430	144	44	by	by	IN
38430	144	45	common	common	JJ
38430	144	46	-	-	HYPH
38430	144	47	sense	sense	NN
38430	144	48	for	for	IN
38430	144	49	so	so	RB
38430	144	50	many	many	JJ
38430	144	51	years	year	NNS
38430	144	52	are	be	VBP
38430	144	53	,	,	,
38430	144	54	in	in	IN
38430	144	55	part	part	NN
38430	144	56	,	,	,
38430	144	57	justified	justify	VBN
38430	144	58	.	.	.
38430	145	1	But	but	CC
38430	145	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	145	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	145	4	quite	quite	RB
38430	145	5	certain	certain	JJ
38430	145	6	that	that	IN
38430	145	7	,	,	,
38430	145	8	with	with	IN
38430	145	9	the	the	DT
38430	145	10	principles	principle	NNS
38430	145	11	of	of	IN
38430	145	12	logic	logic	NN
38430	145	13	,	,	,
38430	145	14	no	no	DT
38430	145	15	such	such	JJ
38430	145	16	proof	proof	NN
38430	145	17	of	of	IN
38430	145	18	consistency	consistency	NN
38430	145	19	,	,	,
38430	145	20	and	and	CC
38430	145	21	no	no	DT
38430	145	22	such	such	JJ
38430	145	23	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	145	24	result	result	NN
38430	145	25	of	of	IN
38430	145	26	further	further	JJ
38430	145	27	investigations	investigation	NNS
38430	145	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	145	29	to	to	TO
38430	145	30	be	be	VB
38430	145	31	feared	fear	VBN
38430	145	32	.	.	.
38430	146	1	Still	still	RB
38430	146	2	,	,	,
38430	146	3	this	this	DT
38430	146	4	re	re	NN
38430	146	5	-	-	NN
38430	146	6	moulding	moulding	NN
38430	146	7	has	have	VBZ
38430	146	8	had	have	VBN
38430	146	9	the	the	DT
38430	146	10	result	result	NN
38430	146	11	of	of	IN
38430	146	12	bringing	bring	VBG
38430	146	13	logic	logic	NN
38430	146	14	into	into	IN
38430	146	15	a	a	DT
38430	146	16	fuller	full	JJR
38430	146	17	agreement	agreement	NN
38430	146	18	with	with	IN
38430	146	19	common	common	JJ
38430	146	20	-	-	HYPH
38430	146	21	sense	sense	NN
38430	146	22	than	than	IN
38430	146	23	might	may	MD
38430	146	24	be	be	VB
38430	146	25	expected	expect	VBN
38430	146	26	.	.	.
38430	147	1	There	there	EX
38430	147	2	were	be	VBD
38430	147	3	only	only	RB
38430	147	4	two	two	CD
38430	147	5	alternatives	alternative	NNS
38430	147	6	:	:	:
38430	147	7	if	if	IN
38430	147	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	147	9	chose	choose	VBD
38430	147	10	principles	principle	NNS
38430	147	11	in	in	IN
38430	147	12	accordance	accordance	NN
38430	147	13	with	with	IN
38430	147	14	common	common	JJ
38430	147	15	-	-	HYPH
38430	147	16	sense	sense	NN
38430	147	17	,	,	,
38430	147	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	147	19	arrived	arrive	VBD
38430	147	20	at	at	IN
38430	147	21	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	147	22	which	which	WDT
38430	147	23	shocked	shock	VBD
38430	147	24	common	common	JJ
38430	147	25	-	-	HYPH
38430	147	26	sense	sense	NN
38430	147	27	;	;	:
38430	147	28	by	by	IN
38430	147	29	starting	start	VBG
38430	147	30	with	with	IN
38430	147	31	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	147	32	principles	principle	NNS
38430	147	33	,	,	,
38430	147	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	147	35	arrived	arrive	VBD
38430	147	36	at	at	IN
38430	147	37	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	147	38	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	147	39	.	.	.
38430	148	1	Like	like	IN
38430	148	2	the	the	DT
38430	148	3	White	White	NNP
38430	148	4	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	148	5	,	,	,
38430	148	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	148	7	have	have	VBP
38430	148	8	dyed	dye	VBN
38430	148	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	148	10	whiskers	whisker	NNS
38430	148	11	an	an	DT
38430	148	12	unusual	unusual	JJ
38430	148	13	colour	colour	NN
38430	148	14	and	and	CC
38430	148	15	then	then	RB
38430	148	16	hidden	hide	VBD
38430	148	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	148	18	.	.	.
38430	149	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	149	2	16	16	CD
38430	149	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	149	4	The	the	DT
38430	149	5	quaint	quaint	NN
38430	149	6	name	name	NN
38430	149	7	of	of	IN
38430	149	8	"	"	``
38430	149	9	Laws	Laws	NNPS
38430	149	10	of	of	IN
38430	149	11	Thought	Thought	NNP
38430	149	12	,	,	,
38430	149	13	"	"	''
38430	149	14	which	which	WDT
38430	149	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	149	16	often	often	RB
38430	149	17	applied	apply	VBN
38430	149	18	to	to	IN
38430	149	19	the	the	DT
38430	149	20	principles	principle	NNS
38430	149	21	of	of	IN
38430	149	22	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	149	23	,	,	,
38430	149	24	has	have	VBZ
38430	149	25	given	give	VBN
38430	149	26	rise	rise	NN
38430	149	27	to	to	IN
38430	149	28	confusion	confusion	NN
38430	149	29	in	in	IN
38430	149	30	two	two	CD
38430	149	31	ways	way	NNS
38430	149	32	:	:	:
38430	149	33	in	in	IN
38430	149	34	the	the	DT
38430	149	35	first	first	JJ
38430	149	36	place	place	NN
38430	149	37	,	,	,
38430	149	38	the	the	DT
38430	149	39	"	"	``
38430	149	40	Laws	Laws	NNPS
38430	149	41	,	,	,
38430	149	42	"	"	''
38430	149	43	unlike	unlike	IN
38430	149	44	other	other	JJ
38430	149	45	laws	law	NNS
38430	149	46	,	,	,
38430	149	47	can	can	MD
38430	149	48	not	not	RB
38430	149	49	be	be	VB
38430	149	50	broken	break	VBN
38430	149	51	,	,	,
38430	149	52	even	even	RB
38430	149	53	in	in	IN
38430	149	54	thought	thought	NN
38430	149	55	;	;	:
38430	149	56	and	and	CC
38430	149	57	,	,	,
38430	149	58	in	in	IN
38430	149	59	the	the	DT
38430	149	60	second	second	JJ
38430	149	61	place	place	NN
38430	149	62	,	,	,
38430	149	63	people	people	NNS
38430	149	64	think	think	VBP
38430	149	65	that	that	IN
38430	149	66	the	the	DT
38430	149	67	"	"	``
38430	149	68	Laws	Laws	NNPS
38430	149	69	"	"	''
38430	149	70	have	have	VBP
38430	149	71	something	something	NN
38430	149	72	to	to	TO
38430	149	73	do	do	VB
38430	149	74	with	with	IN
38430	149	75	holding	hold	VBG
38430	149	76	for	for	IN
38430	149	77	the	the	DT
38430	149	78	operations	operation	NNS
38430	149	79	of	of	IN
38430	149	80	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	149	81	minds	mind	NNS
38430	149	82	,	,	,
38430	149	83	just	just	RB
38430	149	84	as	as	IN
38430	149	85	laws	law	NNS
38430	149	86	of	of	IN
38430	149	87	nature	nature	NN
38430	149	88	hold	hold	VBP
38430	149	89	for	for	IN
38430	149	90	events	event	NNS
38430	149	91	in	in	IN
38430	149	92	the	the	DT
38430	149	93	world	world	NN
38430	149	94	around	around	IN
38430	149	95	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	149	96	.	.	.
38430	150	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	150	2	17	17	CD
38430	150	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	150	4	But	but	CC
38430	150	5	that	that	IN
38430	150	6	the	the	DT
38430	150	7	laws	law	NNS
38430	150	8	are	be	VBP
38430	150	9	not	not	RB
38430	150	10	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	150	11	laws	law	NNS
38430	150	12	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	150	13	from	from	IN
38430	150	14	the	the	DT
38430	150	15	facts	fact	NNS
38430	150	16	that	that	WDT
38430	150	17	a	a	DT
38430	150	18	thing	thing	NN
38430	150	19	may	may	MD
38430	150	20	be	be	VB
38430	150	21	true	true	JJ
38430	150	22	even	even	RB
38430	150	23	if	if	IN
38430	150	24	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	150	25	believes	believe	VBZ
38430	150	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	150	27	,	,	,
38430	150	28	and	and	CC
38430	150	29	something	something	NN
38430	150	30	else	else	RB
38430	150	31	may	may	MD
38430	150	32	be	be	VB
38430	150	33	false	false	JJ
38430	150	34	if	if	IN
38430	150	35	everybody	everybody	NN
38430	150	36	believes	believe	VBZ
38430	150	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	150	38	.	.	.
38430	151	1	Such	such	JJ
38430	151	2	,	,	,
38430	151	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	151	4	may	may	MD
38430	151	5	be	be	VB
38430	151	6	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	151	7	,	,	,
38430	151	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	151	9	usually	usually	RB
38430	151	10	the	the	DT
38430	151	11	case	case	NN
38430	151	12	.	.	.
38430	152	1	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	152	2	the	the	DT
38430	152	3	most	most	RBS
38430	152	4	frequent	frequent	JJ
38430	152	5	instance	instance	NN
38430	152	6	of	of	IN
38430	152	7	the	the	DT
38430	152	8	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	152	9	that	that	IN
38430	152	10	the	the	DT
38430	152	11	laws	law	NNS
38430	152	12	of	of	IN
38430	152	13	logic	logic	NN
38430	152	14	are	be	VBP
38430	152	15	mental	mental	JJ
38430	152	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	152	17	the	the	DT
38430	152	18	treatment	treatment	NN
38430	152	19	of	of	IN
38430	152	20	an	an	DT
38430	152	21	identity	identity	NN
38430	152	22	as	as	IN
38430	152	23	if	if	IN
38430	152	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	152	25	validity	validity	NN
38430	152	26	were	be	VBD
38430	152	27	an	an	DT
38430	152	28	affair	affair	NN
38430	152	29	of	of	IN
38430	152	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	152	31	permission	permission	NN
38430	152	32	.	.	.
38430	153	1	Some	some	DT
38430	153	2	people	people	NNS
38430	153	3	suggest	suggest	VBP
38430	153	4	to	to	IN
38430	153	5	others	other	NNS
38430	153	6	that	that	IN
38430	153	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	153	8	should	should	MD
38430	153	9	"	"	``
38430	153	10	let	let	VB
38430	153	11	bygones	bygone	NNS
38430	153	12	be	be	VB
38430	153	13	bygones	bygone	NNS
38430	153	14	.	.	.
38430	153	15	"	"	''
38430	154	1	Another	another	DT
38430	154	2	important	important	JJ
38430	154	3	piece	piece	NN
38430	154	4	of	of	IN
38430	154	5	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	154	6	that	that	IN
38430	154	7	the	the	DT
38430	154	8	truth	truth	NN
38430	154	9	of	of	IN
38430	154	10	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	154	11	has	have	VBZ
38430	154	12	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	154	13	to	to	TO
38430	154	14	do	do	VB
38430	154	15	with	with	IN
38430	154	16	mind	mind	NN
38430	154	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	154	18	given	give	VBN
38430	154	19	by	by	IN
38430	154	20	the	the	DT
38430	154	21	phrase	phrase	NN
38430	154	22	"	"	``
38430	154	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	154	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	154	25	morally	morally	RB
38430	154	26	certain	certain	JJ
38430	154	27	that	that	IN
38430	154	28	such	such	JJ
38430	154	29	-	-	HYPH
38430	154	30	and	and	CC
38430	154	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	154	32	such	such	PDT
38430	154	33	a	a	DT
38430	154	34	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	154	35	is	be	VBZ
38430	154	36	true	true	JJ
38430	154	37	.	.	.
38430	154	38	"	"	''
38430	155	1	Now	now	RB
38430	155	2	,	,	,
38430	155	3	in	in	IN
38430	155	4	the	the	DT
38430	155	5	first	first	JJ
38430	155	6	place	place	NN
38430	155	7	,	,	,
38430	155	8	morality	morality	NN
38430	155	9	,	,	,
38430	155	10	curiously	curiously	RB
38430	155	11	enough	enough	RB
38430	155	12	,	,	,
38430	155	13	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	155	14	to	to	TO
38430	155	15	be	be	VB
38430	155	16	closely	closely	RB
38430	155	17	associated	associate	VBN
38430	155	18	with	with	IN
38430	155	19	mental	mental	JJ
38430	155	20	acts	act	NNS
38430	155	21	:	:	:
38430	155	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	155	23	have	have	VBP
38430	155	24	professorships	professorship	NNS
38430	155	25	and	and	CC
38430	155	26	lectureships	lectureship	NNS
38430	155	27	of	of	IN
38430	155	28	,	,	,
38430	155	29	and	and	CC
38430	155	30	examinations	examination	NNS
38430	155	31	in	in	IN
38430	155	32	,	,	,
38430	155	33	"	"	``
38430	155	34	mental	mental	JJ
38430	155	35	and	and	CC
38430	155	36	moral	moral	JJ
38430	155	37	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	155	38	.	.	.
38430	155	39	"	"	''
38430	156	1	In	in	IN
38430	156	2	the	the	DT
38430	156	3	second	second	JJ
38430	156	4	place	place	NN
38430	156	5	,	,	,
38430	156	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	156	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	156	8	plain	plain	JJ
38430	156	9	that	that	IN
38430	156	10	a	a	DT
38430	156	11	"	"	``
38430	156	12	morally	morally	RB
38430	156	13	certain	certain	JJ
38430	156	14	"	"	``
38430	156	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	156	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	156	17	a	a	DT
38430	156	18	highly	highly	RB
38430	156	19	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	156	20	one	one	CD
38430	156	21	.	.	.
38430	157	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	157	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	157	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	157	4	as	as	RB
38430	157	5	vain	vain	JJ
38430	157	6	to	to	TO
38430	157	7	expect	expect	VB
38430	157	8	any	any	DT
38430	157	9	information	information	NN
38430	157	10	about	about	IN
38430	157	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	157	12	minds	mind	NNS
38430	157	13	from	from	IN
38430	157	14	a	a	DT
38430	157	15	study	study	NN
38430	157	16	of	of	IN
38430	157	17	the	the	DT
38430	157	18	"	"	``
38430	157	19	Laws	Laws	NNPS
38430	157	20	of	of	IN
38430	157	21	Thought	Thought	NNP
38430	157	22	"	"	''
38430	157	23	as	as	IN
38430	157	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	157	25	would	would	MD
38430	157	26	be	be	VB
38430	157	27	to	to	TO
38430	157	28	expect	expect	VB
38430	157	29	a	a	DT
38430	157	30	description	description	NN
38430	157	31	of	of	IN
38430	157	32	a	a	DT
38430	157	33	certain	certain	JJ
38430	157	34	social	social	JJ
38430	157	35	event	event	NN
38430	157	36	from	from	IN
38430	157	37	Miss	Miss	NNP
38430	157	38	E.	E.	NNP
38430	157	39	E.	E.	NNP
38430	157	40	C.	C.	NNP
38430	157	41	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	157	42	's	's	POS
38430	157	43	book	book	NN
38430	157	44	_	_	NNP
38430	157	45	An	an	DT
38430	157	46	Introduction	introduction	NN
38430	157	47	to	to	IN
38430	157	48	General	General	NNP
38430	157	49	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	157	50	_	_	NNP
38430	157	51	.	.	.
38430	158	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	158	2	,	,	,
38430	158	3	the	the	DT
38430	158	4	principles	principle	NNS
38430	158	5	or	or	CC
38430	158	6	laws	law	NNS
38430	158	7	of	of	IN
38430	158	8	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	158	9	are	be	VBP
38430	158	10	not	not	RB
38430	158	11	a	a	DT
38430	158	12	matter	matter	NN
38430	158	13	of	of	IN
38430	158	14	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	158	15	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	158	16	.	.	.
38430	159	1	Idealists	idealist	NNS
38430	159	2	like	like	IN
38430	159	3	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	159	4	and	and	CC
38430	159	5	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	159	6	,	,	,
38430	159	7	and	and	CC
38430	159	8	even	even	RB
38430	159	9	practical	practical	JJ
38430	159	10	idealists	idealist	NNS
38430	159	11	like	like	IN
38430	159	12	the	the	DT
38430	159	13	White	White	NNP
38430	159	14	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	159	15	,	,	,
38430	159	16	explicitly	explicitly	RB
38430	159	17	accept	accept	VB
38430	159	18	laws	law	NNS
38430	159	19	like	like	IN
38430	159	20	the	the	DT
38430	159	21	law	law	NN
38430	159	22	of	of	IN
38430	159	23	identity	identity	NN
38430	159	24	and	and	CC
38430	159	25	the	the	DT
38430	159	26	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	159	27	middle	middle	NN
38430	159	28	.	.	.
38430	160	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	160	2	18	18	CD
38430	160	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	160	4	In	in	IN
38430	160	5	fact	fact	NN
38430	160	6	,	,	,
38430	160	7	throughout	throughout	IN
38430	160	8	all	all	DT
38430	160	9	logic	logic	NN
38430	160	10	and	and	CC
38430	160	11	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	160	12	,	,	,
38430	160	13	the	the	DT
38430	160	14	existence	existence	NN
38430	160	15	of	of	IN
38430	160	16	the	the	DT
38430	160	17	human	human	NN
38430	160	18	or	or	CC
38430	160	19	any	any	DT
38430	160	20	other	other	JJ
38430	160	21	mind	mind	NN
38430	160	22	is	be	VBZ
38430	160	23	totally	totally	RB
38430	160	24	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
38430	160	25	;	;	:
38430	160	26	mental	mental	JJ
38430	160	27	processes	process	NNS
38430	160	28	are	be	VBP
38430	160	29	studied	study	VBN
38430	160	30	by	by	IN
38430	160	31	means	mean	NNS
38430	160	32	of	of	IN
38430	160	33	logic	logic	NN
38430	160	34	,	,	,
38430	160	35	but	but	CC
38430	160	36	the	the	DT
38430	160	37	subject	subject	JJ
38430	160	38	-	-	HYPH
38430	160	39	matter	matter	NN
38430	160	40	of	of	IN
38430	160	41	logic	logic	NN
38430	160	42	does	do	VBZ
38430	160	43	not	not	RB
38430	160	44	presuppose	presuppose	VB
38430	160	45	mental	mental	JJ
38430	160	46	processes	process	NNS
38430	160	47	,	,	,
38430	160	48	and	and	CC
38430	160	49	would	would	MD
38430	160	50	be	be	VB
38430	160	51	equally	equally	RB
38430	160	52	true	true	JJ
38430	160	53	if	if	IN
38430	160	54	there	there	EX
38430	160	55	were	be	VBD
38430	160	56	no	no	DT
38430	160	57	mental	mental	JJ
38430	160	58	processes	process	NNS
38430	160	59	.	.	.
38430	161	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	161	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	161	3	true	true	JJ
38430	161	4	that	that	IN
38430	161	5	,	,	,
38430	161	6	in	in	IN
38430	161	7	that	that	DT
38430	161	8	case	case	NN
38430	161	9	,	,	,
38430	161	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	161	11	should	should	MD
38430	161	12	not	not	RB
38430	161	13	know	know	VB
38430	161	14	logic	logic	NN
38430	161	15	;	;	:
38430	161	16	but	but	CC
38430	161	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	161	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	161	19	must	must	MD
38430	161	20	not	not	RB
38430	161	21	be	be	VB
38430	161	22	confounded	confound	VBN
38430	161	23	with	with	IN
38430	161	24	the	the	DT
38430	161	25	truths	truth	NNS
38430	161	26	which	which	WDT
38430	161	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	161	28	know	know	VBP
38430	161	29	.	.	.
38430	162	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	162	2	19	19	CD
38430	162	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	162	4	An	an	DT
38430	162	5	apple	apple	NN
38430	162	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	162	7	not	not	RB
38430	162	8	confused	confused	JJ
38430	162	9	with	with	IN
38430	162	10	the	the	DT
38430	162	11	eating	eating	NN
38430	162	12	of	of	IN
38430	162	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	162	14	except	except	IN
38430	162	15	by	by	IN
38430	162	16	savages	savage	NNS
38430	162	17	,	,	,
38430	162	18	idealists	idealist	NNS
38430	162	19	,	,	,
38430	162	20	and	and	CC
38430	162	21	people	people	NNS
38430	162	22	who	who	WP
38430	162	23	are	be	VBP
38430	162	24	too	too	RB
38430	162	25	hungry	hungry	JJ
38430	162	26	to	to	TO
38430	162	27	think	think	VB
38430	162	28	.	.	.
38430	163	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	163	2	:	:	:
38430	163	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	163	4	2	2	LS
38430	163	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	163	6	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	163	7	,	,	,
38430	163	8	_	_	NNP
38430	163	9	Ph	Ph	NNP
38430	163	10	.	.	.
38430	164	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	164	2	_	_	NNP
38430	164	3	,	,	,
38430	164	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	164	5	.	.	.
38430	165	1	17	17	CD
38430	165	2	,	,	,
38430	165	3	19	19	CD
38430	165	4	,	,	,
38430	165	5	207	207	CD
38430	165	6	-	-	SYM
38430	165	7	8	8	CD
38430	165	8	.	.	.
38430	166	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	166	2	3	3	CD
38430	166	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	166	4	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	166	5	,	,	,
38430	166	6	_	_	NNP
38430	166	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	167	1	d.	d.	NNP
38430	167	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	167	3	_	_	NNP
38430	167	4	,	,	,
38430	167	5	i.	i.	NNP
38430	167	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	167	7	4	4	CD
38430	167	8	.	.	.
38430	168	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	168	2	4	4	LS
38430	168	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	168	4	See	See	NNP
38430	168	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	168	6	A.	a.	NN
38430	169	1	This	this	DT
38430	169	2	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	169	3	also	also	RB
38430	169	4	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
38430	169	5	the	the	DT
38430	169	6	importance	importance	NN
38430	169	7	attached	attach	VBN
38430	169	8	to	to	IN
38430	169	9	the	the	DT
38430	169	10	Principle	Principle	NNP
38430	169	11	of	of	IN
38430	169	12	Identity	Identity	NNP
38430	169	13	by	by	IN
38430	169	14	the	the	DT
38430	169	15	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	169	16	and	and	CC
38430	169	17	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
38430	169	18	.	.	.
38430	170	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	170	2	5	5	CD
38430	170	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	170	4	_	_	NNP
38430	170	5	S.	S.	NNP
38430	171	1	o.	o.	NNP
38430	171	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	171	3	_	_	NNP
38430	171	4	,	,	,
38430	171	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	171	6	.	.	.
38430	172	1	9	9	CD
38430	172	2	-	-	SYM
38430	172	3	15	15	CD
38430	172	4	.	.	.
38430	173	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	173	2	6	6	CD
38430	173	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	173	4	_	_	NNP
38430	173	5	A.	a.	NN
38430	174	1	d.	d.	NNP
38430	174	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	174	3	_	_	NNP
38430	174	4	,	,	,
38430	174	5	i.	i.	NNP
38430	174	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	174	7	132	132	CD
38430	174	8	.	.	.
38430	175	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	175	2	7	7	CD
38430	175	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	175	4	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	175	5	.	.	NNP
38430	175	6	,	,	,
38430	175	7	besides	besides	IN
38430	175	8	the	the	DT
38430	175	9	reference	reference	NN
38430	175	10	in	in	IN
38430	175	11	the	the	DT
38430	175	12	last	last	JJ
38430	175	13	note	note	NN
38430	175	14	but	but	CC
38430	175	15	one	one	CD
38430	175	16	,	,	,
38430	175	17	_	_	NNP
38430	175	18	E.	E.	NNP
38430	176	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	176	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	176	3	_	_	NNP
38430	176	4	,	,	,
38430	176	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	176	6	.	.	.
38430	177	1	183	183	CD
38430	177	2	,	,	,
38430	177	3	191	191	CD
38430	177	4	.	.	.
38430	178	1	"	"	``
38430	178	2	Contrariwise	contrariwise	NN
38430	178	3	,	,	,
38430	178	4	"	"	''
38430	178	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	178	6	may	may	MD
38430	178	7	be	be	VB
38430	178	8	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	178	9	,	,	,
38430	178	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	178	11	not	not	RB
38430	178	12	a	a	DT
38430	178	13	term	term	NN
38430	178	14	used	use	VBN
38430	178	15	in	in	IN
38430	178	16	traditional	traditional	JJ
38430	178	17	logic	logic	NN
38430	178	18	.	.	.
38430	179	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	179	2	8	8	CD
38430	179	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	179	4	_	_	NNP
38430	179	5	S.	S.	NNP
38430	180	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	180	2	_	_	NNP
38430	180	3	,	,	,
38430	180	4	1881	1881	CD
38430	180	5	,	,	,
38430	180	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	180	7	.	.	.
38430	181	1	173	173	CD
38430	181	2	-	-	SYM
38430	181	3	5	5	CD
38430	181	4	,	,	,
38430	181	5	324	324	CD
38430	181	6	-	-	SYM
38430	181	7	5	5	CD
38430	181	8	;	;	,
38430	181	9	1894	1894	CD
38430	181	10	,	,	,
38430	181	11	pp	pp	NNP
38430	181	12	.	.	.
38430	182	1	194	194	CD
38430	182	2	-	-	SYM
38430	182	3	6	6	CD
38430	182	4	.	.	.
38430	183	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	183	2	9	9	CD
38430	183	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	183	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	183	5	.	.	.
38430	184	1	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	184	2	C	C	NNP
38430	184	3	,	,	,
38430	184	4	and	and	CC
38430	184	5	William	William	NNP
38430	184	6	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
38430	184	7	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	184	8	,	,	,
38430	184	9	"	"	``
38430	184	10	Hegel	Hegel	NNP
38430	184	11	and	and	CC
38430	184	12	the	the	DT
38430	184	13	Metaphysics	Metaphysics	NNPS
38430	184	14	of	of	IN
38430	184	15	the	the	DT
38430	184	16	Fluxional	Fluxional	NNP
38430	184	17	Calculus	Calculus	NNP
38430	184	18	,	,	,
38430	184	19	"	"	''
38430	184	20	_	_	NNP
38430	184	21	Trans	Trans	NNP
38430	184	22	.	.	.
38430	185	1	Roy	Roy	NNP
38430	185	2	.	.	.
38430	186	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
38430	186	2	.	.	NNP
38430	186	3	,	,	,
38430	186	4	Edinb	Edinb	NNP
38430	186	5	.	.	.
38430	186	6	_	_	NNP
38430	186	7	,	,	,
38430	186	8	vol	vol	NNP
38430	186	9	.	.	.
38430	187	1	xxv	xxv	NNP
38430	187	2	.	.	NNP
38430	187	3	,	,	,
38430	187	4	1869	1869	CD
38430	187	5	,	,	,
38430	187	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	187	7	.	.	.
38430	188	1	491	491	CD
38430	188	2	-	-	SYM
38430	188	3	511	511	CD
38430	188	4	.	.	.
38430	189	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	189	2	10	10	CD
38430	189	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	189	4	See	see	VB
38430	189	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	189	6	B.	B.	NNP
38430	190	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	190	2	11	11	CD
38430	190	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	190	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	190	5	This	this	DT
38430	190	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	190	7	a	a	DT
38430	190	8	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
38430	190	9	anticipation	anticipation	NN
38430	190	10	of	of	IN
38430	190	11	the	the	DT
38430	190	12	note	note	NN
38430	190	13	on	on	IN
38430	190	14	pp	pp	NNP
38430	190	15	.	.	.
38430	191	1	39	39	CD
38430	191	2	-	-	SYM
38430	191	3	40	40	CD
38430	191	4	of	of	IN
38430	191	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	191	6	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	191	7	's	's	POS
38430	191	8	book	book	NN
38430	191	9	,	,	,
38430	191	10	published	publish	VBN
38430	191	11	about	about	RB
38430	191	12	three	three	CD
38430	191	13	years	year	NNS
38430	191	14	after	after	IN
38430	191	15	the	the	DT
38430	191	16	death	death	NN
38430	191	17	of	of	IN
38430	191	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	191	19	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	191	20	,	,	,
38430	191	21	and	and	CC
38430	191	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
38430	191	23	_	_	NNP
38430	191	24	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	191	25	Knowledge	Knowledge	NNP
38430	191	26	of	of	IN
38430	191	27	the	the	DT
38430	191	28	External	External	NNP
38430	191	29	World	World	NNP
38430	191	30	as	as	IN
38430	191	31	a	a	DT
38430	191	32	Field	field	NN
38430	191	33	for	for	IN
38430	191	34	Scientific	scientific	JJ
38430	191	35	Method	Method	NNP
38430	191	36	in	in	IN
38430	191	37	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	191	38	_	_	NNP
38430	191	39	,	,	,
38430	191	40	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
38430	191	41	and	and	CC
38430	191	42	London	London	NNP
38430	191	43	,	,	,
38430	191	44	1914.--ED	1914.--ed	CD
38430	191	45	.	.	.
38430	191	46	]	]	-RRB-
38430	192	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	192	2	12	12	CD
38430	192	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	192	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	192	5	.	.	.
38430	193	1	_	_	NNP
38430	193	2	Ph	Ph	NNP
38430	193	3	.	.	.
38430	194	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	194	2	_	_	NNP
38430	194	3	,	,	,
38430	194	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	194	5	.	.	.
38430	195	1	v.-vi	v.-vi	ADD
38430	195	2	.	.	.
38430	196	1	3	3	LS
38430	196	2	.	.	.
38430	197	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	197	2	13	13	CD
38430	197	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	197	4	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	197	5	.	.	.
38430	198	1	Pieri	Pieri	NNP
38430	198	2	,	,	,
38430	198	3	_	_	NNP
38430	198	4	R.	R.	NNP
38430	199	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	199	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	199	3	_	_	NNP
38430	199	4	,	,	,
38430	199	5	March	March	NNP
38430	199	6	1906	1906	CD
38430	199	7	,	,	,
38430	199	8	p.	p.	NN
38430	199	9	199	199	CD
38430	199	10	.	.	.
38430	200	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	200	2	14	14	CD
38430	200	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	200	4	As	as	IN
38430	200	5	a	a	DT
38430	200	6	type	type	NN
38430	200	7	of	of	IN
38430	200	8	these	these	DT
38430	200	9	,	,	,
38430	200	10	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	200	11	-	-	HYPH
38430	200	12	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	200	13	,	,	,
38430	200	14	with	with	IN
38430	200	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	200	16	inability	inability	NN
38430	200	17	to	to	TO
38430	200	18	admit	admit	VB
38430	200	19	anything	anything	NN
38430	200	20	not	not	RB
38430	200	21	empirically	empirically	RB
38430	200	22	given	give	VBN
38430	200	23	and	and	CC
38430	200	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	200	25	lack	lack	NN
38430	200	26	of	of	IN
38430	200	27	comprehension	comprehension	NN
38430	200	28	of	of	IN
38430	200	29	pure	pure	JJ
38430	200	30	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	200	31	,	,	,
38430	200	32	may	may	MD
38430	200	33	be	be	VB
38430	200	34	taken	take	VBN
38430	200	35	(	(	-LRB-
38430	200	36	see	see	VB
38430	200	37	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	200	38	C	C	NNP
38430	200	39	)	)	-RRB-
38430	200	40	.	.	.
38430	201	1	In	in	IN
38430	201	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	201	3	(	(	-LRB-
38430	201	4	correct	correct	JJ
38430	201	5	)	)	-RRB-
38430	201	6	thesis	thesis	NN
38430	201	7	that	that	IN
38430	201	8	definitions	definition	NNS
38430	201	9	are	be	VBP
38430	201	10	nominal	nominal	JJ
38430	201	11	,	,	,
38430	201	12	too	too	RB
38430	201	13	,	,	,
38430	201	14	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	201	15	-	-	HYPH
38430	201	16	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	201	17	reminds	remind	VBZ
38430	201	18	one	one	CD
38430	201	19	of	of	IN
38430	201	20	J.	J.	NNP
38430	201	21	S.	S.	NNP
38430	201	22	Mill	Mill	NNP
38430	201	23	(	(	-LRB-
38430	201	24	see	see	VB
38430	201	25	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	201	26	D	D	NNP
38430	201	27	)	)	-RRB-
38430	201	28	.	.	.
38430	202	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	202	2	15	15	CD
38430	202	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	202	4	See	See	NNP
38430	202	5	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	202	6	,	,	,
38430	202	7	_	_	NNP
38430	202	8	Gg	Gg	NNP
38430	202	9	.	.	.
38430	202	10	_	_	NNP
38430	202	11	,	,	,
38430	202	12	ii	ii	NNP
38430	202	13	.	.	.
38430	203	1	p.	p.	NN
38430	203	2	253	253	CD
38430	203	3	.	.	.
38430	204	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	204	2	16	16	CD
38430	204	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	204	4	See	see	VB
38430	204	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	204	6	E.	E.	NNP
38430	204	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	204	8	17	17	CD
38430	204	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	204	10	See	See	NNP
38430	204	11	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	204	12	,	,	,
38430	204	13	_	_	NNP
38430	204	14	Gg	Gg	NNP
38430	204	15	.	.	.
38430	204	16	_	_	NNP
38430	204	17	,	,	,
38430	204	18	i.	i.	NNP
38430	204	19	p.	p.	NNP
38430	204	20	15	15	CD
38430	204	21	.	.	.
38430	205	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	205	2	18	18	CD
38430	205	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	205	4	See	see	VB
38430	205	5	the	the	DT
38430	205	6	above	above	JJ
38430	205	7	references	reference	NNS
38430	205	8	and	and	CC
38430	205	9	also	also	RB
38430	205	10	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	205	11	F.	F.	NNP
38430	205	12	[	[	-LRB-
38430	205	13	19	19	CD
38430	205	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	205	15	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	205	16	.	.	.
38430	206	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	206	2	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	206	3	,	,	,
38430	206	4	_	_	NNP
38430	206	5	H.	H.	NNP
38430	207	1	J.	J.	NNP
38430	207	2	_	_	NNP
38430	207	3	,	,	,
38430	207	4	July	July	NNP
38430	207	5	1904	1904	CD
38430	207	6	,	,	,
38430	207	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	207	8	812	812	CD
38430	207	9	.	.	.
38430	208	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	208	2	II	ii	CD
38430	208	3	OBJECTIVE	objective	NN
38430	208	4	VALIDITY	validity	NN
38430	208	5	OF	of	IN
38430	208	6	THE	the	DT
38430	208	7	"	"	``
38430	208	8	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
38430	208	9	OF	of	IN
38430	208	10	THOUGHT	THOUGHT	NNP
38430	208	11	"	"	''
38430	208	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	208	13	once	once	RB
38430	208	14	inquired	inquire	VBD
38430	208	15	of	of	IN
38430	208	16	a	a	DT
38430	208	17	maid	maid	NN
38430	208	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	208	19	servant	servant	NN
38430	208	20	whether	whether	IN
38430	208	21	her	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	208	22	mistress	mistress	NN
38430	208	23	was	be	VBD
38430	208	24	at	at	IN
38430	208	25	home	home	NN
38430	208	26	.	.	.
38430	209	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	209	2	replied	reply	VBD
38430	209	3	,	,	,
38430	209	4	in	in	IN
38430	209	5	a	a	DT
38430	209	6	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	209	7	fashion	fashion	NN
38430	209	8	,	,	,
38430	209	9	that	that	IN
38430	209	10	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	209	11	_	_	NNP
38430	209	12	thought	think	VBD
38430	209	13	_	_	NNP
38430	209	14	that	that	IN
38430	209	15	her	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	209	16	mistress	mistress	NN
38430	209	17	was	be	VBD
38430	209	18	in	in	IN
38430	209	19	unless	unless	IN
38430	209	20	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	209	21	was	be	VBD
38430	209	22	out	out	RB
38430	209	23	.	.	.
38430	210	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	210	2	concluded	conclude	VBD
38430	210	3	that	that	IN
38430	210	4	the	the	DT
38430	210	5	maid	maid	NN
38430	210	6	was	be	VBD
38430	210	7	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
38430	210	8	as	as	IN
38430	210	9	to	to	IN
38430	210	10	the	the	DT
38430	210	11	objective	objective	JJ
38430	210	12	validity	validity	NN
38430	210	13	of	of	IN
38430	210	14	the	the	DT
38430	210	15	law	law	NN
38430	210	16	of	of	IN
38430	210	17	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	210	18	middle	middle	NN
38430	210	19	,	,	,
38430	210	20	and	and	CC
38430	210	21	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	210	22	that	that	DT
38430	210	23	to	to	IN
38430	210	24	her	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	210	25	mistress	mistress	NN
38430	210	26	.	.	.
38430	211	1	But	but	CC
38430	211	2	since	since	IN
38430	211	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	211	4	used	use	VBD
38430	211	5	the	the	DT
38430	211	6	phrase	phrase	NN
38430	211	7	"	"	``
38430	211	8	laws	law	NNS
38430	211	9	of	of	IN
38430	211	10	thought	thought	NN
38430	211	11	,	,	,
38430	211	12	"	"	''
38430	211	13	the	the	DT
38430	211	14	mistress	mistress	NN
38430	211	15	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	211	16	supposed	suppose	VBD
38430	211	17	that	that	IN
38430	211	18	a	a	DT
38430	211	19	"	"	``
38430	211	20	law	law	NN
38430	211	21	of	of	IN
38430	211	22	thought	thought	NN
38430	211	23	"	"	''
38430	211	24	has	have	VBZ
38430	211	25	something	something	NN
38430	211	26	to	to	TO
38430	211	27	do	do	VB
38430	211	28	with	with	IN
38430	211	29	thinking	thinking	NN
38430	211	30	and	and	CC
38430	211	31	seemed	seem	VBD
38430	211	32	to	to	TO
38430	211	33	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	211	34	that	that	IN
38430	211	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	211	36	wished	wish	VBD
38430	211	37	to	to	TO
38430	211	38	impute	impute	VB
38430	211	39	to	to	IN
38430	211	40	the	the	DT
38430	211	41	maid	maid	NN
38430	211	42	some	some	DT
38430	211	43	moral	moral	JJ
38430	211	44	defect	defect	NN
38430	211	45	of	of	IN
38430	211	46	an	an	DT
38430	211	47	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
38430	211	48	nature	nature	NN
38430	211	49	.	.	.
38430	212	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	212	2	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	212	3	remonstrated	remonstrate	VBD
38430	212	4	with	with	IN
38430	212	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	212	6	in	in	IN
38430	212	7	an	an	DT
38430	212	8	amused	amused	JJ
38430	212	9	way	way	NN
38430	212	10	,	,	,
38430	212	11	since	since	IN
38430	212	12	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	212	13	probably	probably	RB
38430	212	14	imagined	imagine	VBD
38430	212	15	that	that	IN
38430	212	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	212	17	meant	mean	VBD
38430	212	18	to	to	TO
38430	212	19	find	find	VB
38430	212	20	fault	fault	NN
38430	212	21	with	with	IN
38430	212	22	the	the	DT
38430	212	23	maid	maid	NN
38430	212	24	's	's	POS
38430	212	25	capacity	capacity	NN
38430	212	26	for	for	IN
38430	212	27	thinking	thinking	NN
38430	212	28	.	.	.
38430	213	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	213	2	III	iii	CD
38430	213	3	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	213	4	In	in	IN
38430	213	5	the	the	DT
38430	213	6	first	first	JJ
38430	213	7	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	213	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	213	9	have	have	VBP
38430	213	10	noticed	notice	VBN
38430	213	11	the	the	DT
38430	213	12	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	213	13	that	that	IN
38430	213	14	identities	identity	NNS
38430	213	15	are	be	VBP
38430	213	16	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
38430	213	17	to	to	IN
38430	213	18	all	all	DT
38430	213	19	logic	logic	NN
38430	213	20	.	.	.
38430	214	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	214	2	will	will	MD
38430	214	3	now	now	RB
38430	214	4	consider	consider	VB
38430	214	5	some	some	DT
38430	214	6	other	other	JJ
38430	214	7	views	view	NNS
38430	214	8	of	of	IN
38430	214	9	the	the	DT
38430	214	10	value	value	NN
38430	214	11	of	of	IN
38430	214	12	identities	identity	NNS
38430	214	13	.	.	.
38430	215	1	Identities	identity	NNS
38430	215	2	are	be	VBP
38430	215	3	frequently	frequently	RB
38430	215	4	used	use	VBN
38430	215	5	in	in	IN
38430	215	6	common	common	JJ
38430	215	7	life	life	NN
38430	215	8	by	by	IN
38430	215	9	people	people	NNS
38430	215	10	who	who	WP
38430	215	11	seem	seem	VBP
38430	215	12	to	to	TO
38430	215	13	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	215	14	that	that	IN
38430	215	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	215	16	can	can	MD
38430	215	17	draw	draw	VB
38430	215	18	important	important	JJ
38430	215	19	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	215	20	respecting	respect	VBG
38430	215	21	conduct	conduct	NN
38430	215	22	or	or	CC
38430	215	23	matters	matter	NNS
38430	215	24	of	of	IN
38430	215	25	fact	fact	NN
38430	215	26	from	from	IN
38430	215	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	215	28	.	.	.
38430	216	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	216	2	have	have	VBP
38430	216	3	heard	hear	VBN
38430	216	4	of	of	IN
38430	216	5	a	a	DT
38430	216	6	man	man	NN
38430	216	7	who	who	WP
38430	216	8	gained	gain	VBD
38430	216	9	the	the	DT
38430	216	10	double	double	JJ
38430	216	11	reputation	reputation	NN
38430	216	12	of	of	IN
38430	216	13	being	be	VBG
38430	216	14	a	a	DT
38430	216	15	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	216	16	and	and	CC
38430	216	17	a	a	DT
38430	216	18	fatalist	fatalist	NN
38430	216	19	by	by	IN
38430	216	20	the	the	DT
38430	216	21	repeated	repeat	VBN
38430	216	22	enunciation	enunciation	NN
38430	216	23	of	of	IN
38430	216	24	the	the	DT
38430	216	25	identity	identity	NN
38430	216	26	"	"	``
38430	216	27	Whatever	whatever	WDT
38430	216	28	will	will	MD
38430	216	29	be	be	VB
38430	216	30	,	,	,
38430	216	31	will	will	MD
38430	216	32	be	be	VB
38430	216	33	"	"	``
38430	216	34	;	;	:
38430	216	35	and	and	CC
38430	216	36	the	the	DT
38430	216	37	Italian	italian	JJ
38430	216	38	equivalent	equivalent	NN
38430	216	39	of	of	IN
38430	216	40	this	this	DT
38430	216	41	makes	make	VBZ
38430	216	42	up	up	RP
38430	216	43	an	an	DT
38430	216	44	appreciable	appreciable	JJ
38430	216	45	part	part	NN
38430	216	46	of	of	IN
38430	216	47	one	one	CD
38430	216	48	of	of	IN
38430	216	49	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	216	50	Robert	Robert	NNP
38430	216	51	Hichens	Hichens	NNP
38430	216	52	'	'	POS
38430	216	53	novels	novel	NNS
38430	216	54	.	.	.
38430	217	1	Further	further	RB
38430	217	2	,	,	,
38430	217	3	the	the	DT
38430	217	4	identity	identity	NN
38430	217	5	"	"	``
38430	217	6	Life	life	NN
38430	217	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	217	8	Life	Life	NNP
38430	217	9	"	"	''
38430	217	10	has	have	VBZ
38430	217	11	not	not	RB
38430	217	12	only	only	RB
38430	217	13	been	be	VBN
38430	217	14	often	often	RB
38430	217	15	accepted	accept	VBN
38430	217	16	as	as	IN
38430	217	17	an	an	DT
38430	217	18	explanation	explanation	NN
38430	217	19	for	for	IN
38430	217	20	a	a	DT
38430	217	21	particular	particular	JJ
38430	217	22	way	way	NN
38430	217	23	of	of	IN
38430	217	24	living	living	NN
38430	217	25	but	but	CC
38430	217	26	has	have	VBZ
38430	217	27	even	even	RB
38430	217	28	been	be	VBN
38430	217	29	considered	consider	VBN
38430	217	30	by	by	IN
38430	217	31	an	an	DT
38430	217	32	authoress	authoress	NN
38430	217	33	who	who	WP
38430	217	34	calls	call	VBZ
38430	217	35	herself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	217	36	"	"	``
38430	217	37	Zack	Zack	NNP
38430	217	38	"	"	''
38430	217	39	to	to	TO
38430	217	40	be	be	VB
38430	217	41	an	an	DT
38430	217	42	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
38430	217	43	title	title	NN
38430	217	44	for	for	IN
38430	217	45	a	a	DT
38430	217	46	novel	novel	NN
38430	217	47	;	;	:
38430	217	48	while	while	IN
38430	217	49	"	"	``
38430	217	50	Business	business	NN
38430	217	51	is	be	VBZ
38430	217	52	Business	business	NN
38430	217	53	"	"	``
38430	217	54	is	be	VBZ
38430	217	55	frequently	frequently	RB
38430	217	56	thought	think	VBN
38430	217	57	to	to	TO
38430	217	58	provide	provide	VB
38430	217	59	an	an	DT
38430	217	60	excuse	excuse	NN
38430	217	61	for	for	IN
38430	217	62	dishonesty	dishonesty	NN
38430	217	63	in	in	IN
38430	217	64	trading	trading	NN
38430	217	65	,	,	,
38430	217	66	for	for	IN
38430	217	67	which	which	WDT
38430	217	68	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	217	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	217	70	is	be	VBZ
38430	217	71	plainly	plainly	RB
38430	217	72	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
38430	217	73	.	.	.
38430	218	1	Another	another	DT
38430	218	2	example	example	NN
38430	218	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	218	4	given	give	VBN
38430	218	5	by	by	IN
38430	218	6	a	a	DT
38430	218	7	poem	poem	NN
38430	218	8	of	of	IN
38430	218	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	218	10	Kipling	Kipling	NNP
38430	218	11	,	,	,
38430	218	12	where	where	WRB
38430	218	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	218	14	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	218	15	to	to	TO
38430	218	16	assert	assert	VB
38430	218	17	that	that	IN
38430	218	18	"	"	``
38430	218	19	East	East	NNP
38430	218	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	218	21	East	East	NNP
38430	218	22	"	"	''
38430	218	23	and	and	CC
38430	218	24	"	"	``
38430	218	25	West	West	NNP
38430	218	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	218	27	West	West	NNP
38430	218	28	"	"	''
38430	218	29	imply	imply	VB
38430	218	30	that	that	IN
38430	218	31	"	"	``
38430	218	32	never	never	RB
38430	218	33	the	the	DT
38430	218	34	twain	twain	NN
38430	218	35	shall	shall	MD
38430	218	36	meet	meet	VB
38430	218	37	.	.	.
38430	218	38	"	"	''
38430	219	1	The	the	DT
38430	219	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	219	3	,	,	,
38430	219	4	now	now	RB
38430	219	5	,	,	,
38430	219	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	219	7	false	false	JJ
38430	219	8	;	;	:
38430	219	9	for	for	IN
38430	219	10	,	,	,
38430	219	11	since	since	IN
38430	219	12	the	the	DT
38430	219	13	world	world	NN
38430	219	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	219	15	round	round	JJ
38430	219	16	--	--	:
38430	219	17	as	as	IN
38430	219	18	geography	geography	NN
38430	219	19	books	book	NNS
38430	219	20	still	still	RB
38430	219	21	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	219	22	by	by	IN
38430	219	23	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	219	24	which	which	WDT
38430	219	25	strike	strike	VBP
38430	219	26	every	every	DT
38430	219	27	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
38430	219	28	child	child	NN
38430	219	29	as	as	IN
38430	219	30	invalid[20]--what	invalid[20]--what	NNP
38430	219	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	219	32	called	call	VBN
38430	219	33	the	the	DT
38430	219	34	"	"	``
38430	219	35	West	West	NNP
38430	219	36	"	"	''
38430	219	37	does	do	VBZ
38430	219	38	,	,	,
38430	219	39	in	in	IN
38430	219	40	fact	fact	NN
38430	219	41	,	,	,
38430	219	42	merge	merge	VB
38430	219	43	into	into	IN
38430	219	44	the	the	DT
38430	219	45	"	"	``
38430	219	46	East	East	NNP
38430	219	47	.	.	.
38430	219	48	"	"	''
38430	220	1	Even	even	RB
38430	220	2	if	if	IN
38430	220	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	220	4	are	be	VBP
38430	220	5	to	to	TO
38430	220	6	take	take	VB
38430	220	7	the	the	DT
38430	220	8	statement	statement	NN
38430	220	9	metaphorically	metaphorically	RB
38430	220	10	,	,	,
38430	220	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	220	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	220	13	still	still	RB
38430	220	14	untrue	untrue	JJ
38430	220	15	,	,	,
38430	220	16	as	as	IN
38430	220	17	the	the	DT
38430	220	18	Japanese	japanese	JJ
38430	220	19	nation	nation	NN
38430	220	20	has	have	VBZ
38430	220	21	shown	show	VBN
38430	220	22	.	.	.
38430	221	1	The	the	DT
38430	221	2	law	law	NN
38430	221	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	221	4	courts	court	NNS
38430	221	5	are	be	VBP
38430	221	6	often	often	RB
38430	221	7	rightly	rightly	RB
38430	221	8	blamed	blame	VBN
38430	221	9	for	for	IN
38430	221	10	being	be	VBG
38430	221	11	strenuous	strenuous	JJ
38430	221	12	opponents	opponent	NNS
38430	221	13	of	of	IN
38430	221	14	the	the	DT
38430	221	15	spread	spread	NN
38430	221	16	of	of	IN
38430	221	17	modern	modern	JJ
38430	221	18	logic	logic	NN
38430	221	19	:	:	:
38430	221	20	the	the	DT
38430	221	21	frequent	frequent	JJ
38430	221	22	misuse	misuse	NN
38430	221	23	of	of	IN
38430	221	24	_	_	NNP
38430	221	25	and	and	CC
38430	221	26	_	_	NNP
38430	221	27	,	,	,
38430	221	28	_	_	NNP
38430	221	29	or	or	CC
38430	221	30	_	_	NNP
38430	221	31	,	,	,
38430	221	32	_	_	NNP
38430	221	33	the	the	DT
38430	221	34	_	_	NNP
38430	221	35	,	,	,
38430	221	36	and	and	CC
38430	221	37	_	_	NNP
38430	221	38	provided	provide	VBD
38430	221	39	that	that	IN
38430	221	40	_	_	NNP
38430	221	41	in	in	IN
38430	221	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	221	43	is	be	VBZ
38430	221	44	notorious	notorious	JJ
38430	221	45	.	.	.
38430	222	1	But	but	CC
38430	222	2	the	the	DT
38430	222	3	fault	fault	NN
38430	222	4	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	222	5	partly	partly	RB
38430	222	6	to	to	TO
38430	222	7	lie	lie	VB
38430	222	8	in	in	IN
38430	222	9	the	the	DT
38430	222	10	uncomplicated	uncomplicated	JJ
38430	222	11	nature	nature	NN
38430	222	12	of	of	IN
38430	222	13	the	the	DT
38430	222	14	logical	logical	JJ
38430	222	15	problems	problem	NNS
38430	222	16	which	which	WDT
38430	222	17	are	be	VBP
38430	222	18	dealt	deal	VBN
38430	222	19	with	with	IN
38430	222	20	in	in	IN
38430	222	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	222	22	.	.	.
38430	223	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	223	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	223	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	223	4	no	no	DT
38430	223	5	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
38430	223	6	thing	thing	NN
38430	223	7	for	for	IN
38430	223	8	somebody	somebody	NN
38430	223	9	to	to	TO
38430	223	10	appear	appear	VB
38430	223	11	there	there	EX
38430	223	12	who	who	WP
38430	223	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	223	14	unable	unable	JJ
38430	223	15	to	to	TO
38430	223	16	establish	establish	VB
38430	223	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	223	18	own	own	JJ
38430	223	19	identity	identity	NN
38430	223	20	,	,	,
38430	223	21	or	or	CC
38430	223	22	for	for	IN
38430	223	23	A	A	NNP
38430	223	24	to	to	TO
38430	223	25	assert	assert	VB
38430	223	26	that	that	DT
38430	223	27	B	b	NN
38430	223	28	was	be	VBD
38430	223	29	"	"	``
38430	223	30	not	not	RB
38430	223	31	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	223	32	"	"	''
38430	223	33	when	when	WRB
38430	223	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	223	35	made	make	VBD
38430	223	36	a	a	DT
38430	223	37	will	will	NN
38430	223	38	leaving	leave	VBG
38430	223	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	223	40	money	money	NN
38430	223	41	to	to	IN
38430	223	42	C.	C.	NNP
38430	223	43	The	the	DT
38430	223	44	chief	chief	JJ
38430	223	45	use	use	NN
38430	223	46	of	of	IN
38430	223	47	identities	identity	NNS
38430	223	48	is	be	VBZ
38430	223	49	in	in	IN
38430	223	50	implication	implication	NN
38430	223	51	.	.	.
38430	224	1	Since	since	IN
38430	224	2	,	,	,
38430	224	3	in	in	IN
38430	224	4	logic	logic	NN
38430	224	5	,	,	,
38430	224	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	224	7	so	so	RB
38430	224	8	understand	understand	VBP
38430	224	9	_	_	NNP
38430	224	10	implication_[21	implication_[21	NNP
38430	224	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	224	12	that	that	IN
38430	224	13	any	any	DT
38430	224	14	true	true	JJ
38430	224	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	224	16	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	224	17	and	and	CC
38430	224	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	224	19	implied	imply	VBN
38430	224	20	by	by	IN
38430	224	21	any	any	DT
38430	224	22	other	other	JJ
38430	224	23	true	true	JJ
38430	224	24	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	224	25	;	;	:
38430	224	26	if	if	IN
38430	224	27	one	one	CD
38430	224	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	224	29	convinced	convince	VBN
38430	224	30	of	of	IN
38430	224	31	the	the	DT
38430	224	32	truth	truth	NN
38430	224	33	of	of	IN
38430	224	34	the	the	DT
38430	224	35	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	224	36	Q	q	NN
38430	224	37	,	,	,
38430	224	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	224	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	224	40	advisable	advisable	JJ
38430	224	41	to	to	TO
38430	224	42	choose	choose	VB
38430	224	43	one	one	CD
38430	224	44	or	or	CC
38430	224	45	more	more	JJR
38430	224	46	identities	identity	NNS
38430	224	47	P	P	NNP
38430	224	48	,	,	,
38430	224	49	whose	whose	WP$
38430	224	50	truth	truth	NN
38430	224	51	is	be	VBZ
38430	224	52	undoubted	undoubted	JJ
38430	224	53	,	,	,
38430	224	54	and	and	CC
38430	224	55	say	say	VB
38430	224	56	that	that	IN
38430	224	57	P	p	NN
38430	224	58	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	224	59	Q.	Q.	NNP
38430	225	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	225	2	,	,	,
38430	225	3	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	225	4	Austen	Austen	NNP
38430	225	5	Chamberlain	Chamberlain	NNP
38430	225	6	,	,	,
38430	225	7	according	accord	VBG
38430	225	8	to	to	IN
38430	225	9	_	_	NNP
38430	225	10	The	the	DT
38430	225	11	Times	Times	NNP
38430	225	12	_	_	NNP
38430	225	13	of	of	IN
38430	225	14	March	March	NNP
38430	225	15	27	27	CD
38430	225	16	,	,	,
38430	225	17	1909	1909	CD
38430	225	18	,	,	,
38430	225	19	professed	profess	VBD
38430	225	20	to	to	TO
38430	225	21	deduce	deduce	VB
38430	225	22	the	the	DT
38430	225	23	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	225	24	that	that	IN
38430	225	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	225	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	225	27	not	not	RB
38430	225	28	right	right	JJ
38430	225	29	that	that	IN
38430	225	30	women	woman	NNS
38430	225	31	should	should	MD
38430	225	32	have	have	VB
38430	225	33	votes	vote	NNS
38430	225	34	from	from	IN
38430	225	35	the	the	DT
38430	225	36	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	225	37	that	that	WDT
38430	225	38	"	"	``
38430	225	39	man	man	NN
38430	225	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	225	41	man	man	NN
38430	225	42	"	"	''
38430	225	43	and	and	CC
38430	225	44	"	"	``
38430	225	45	woman	woman	NN
38430	225	46	is	be	VBZ
38430	225	47	woman	woman	NN
38430	225	48	.	.	.
38430	225	49	"	"	''
38430	226	1	This	this	DT
38430	226	2	method	method	NN
38430	226	3	requires	require	VBZ
38430	226	4	that	that	IN
38430	226	5	one	one	PRP
38430	226	6	should	should	MD
38430	226	7	have	have	VB
38430	226	8	made	make	VBN
38430	226	9	up	up	RP
38430	226	10	one	one	NN
38430	226	11	's	's	POS
38430	226	12	mind	mind	NN
38430	226	13	about	about	IN
38430	226	14	the	the	DT
38430	226	15	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	226	16	before	before	IN
38430	226	17	discovering	discover	VBG
38430	226	18	the	the	DT
38430	226	19	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	226	20	--	--	:
38430	226	21	by	by	IN
38430	226	22	what	what	WP
38430	226	23	,	,	,
38430	226	24	no	no	RB
38430	226	25	doubt	doubt	RB
38430	226	26	,	,	,
38430	226	27	Jevons	Jevons	NNP
38430	226	28	would	would	MD
38430	226	29	call	call	VB
38430	226	30	an	an	DT
38430	226	31	"	"	``
38430	226	32	inverse	inverse	NN
38430	226	33	or	or	CC
38430	226	34	inductive	inductive	JJ
38430	226	35	method	method	NN
38430	226	36	.	.	.
38430	226	37	"	"	''
38430	227	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	227	2	the	the	DT
38430	227	3	method	method	NN
38430	227	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	227	5	of	of	IN
38430	227	6	use	use	NN
38430	227	7	only	only	RB
38430	227	8	in	in	IN
38430	227	9	speeches	speech	NNS
38430	227	10	and	and	CC
38430	227	11	in	in	IN
38430	227	12	giving	give	VBG
38430	227	13	good	good	JJ
38430	227	14	advice	advice	NN
38430	227	15	.	.	.
38430	228	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	228	2	Austen	Austen	NNP
38430	228	3	Chamberlain	Chamberlain	NNP
38430	228	4	afterwards	afterwards	RB
38430	228	5	rather	rather	RB
38430	228	6	destroyed	destroy	VBD
38430	228	7	one	one	NN
38430	228	8	's	's	POS
38430	228	9	belief	belief	NN
38430	228	10	in	in	IN
38430	228	11	the	the	DT
38430	228	12	truth	truth	NN
38430	228	13	of	of	IN
38430	228	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	228	15	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	228	16	by	by	IN
38430	228	17	putting	put	VBG
38430	228	18	limits	limit	NNS
38430	228	19	to	to	IN
38430	228	20	the	the	DT
38430	228	21	validity	validity	NN
38430	228	22	of	of	IN
38430	228	23	the	the	DT
38430	228	24	principle	principle	NN
38430	228	25	of	of	IN
38430	228	26	identity	identity	NN
38430	228	27	.	.	.
38430	229	1	In	in	IN
38430	229	2	the	the	DT
38430	229	3	course	course	NN
38430	229	4	of	of	IN
38430	229	5	the	the	DT
38430	229	6	Debate	debate	NN
38430	229	7	on	on	IN
38430	229	8	the	the	DT
38430	229	9	Budget	Budget	NNP
38430	229	10	of	of	IN
38430	229	11	1909	1909	CD
38430	229	12	,	,	,
38430	229	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	229	14	maintained	maintain	VBD
38430	229	15	,	,	,
38430	229	16	against	against	IN
38430	229	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	229	18	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
38430	229	19	George	George	NNP
38430	229	20	,	,	,
38430	229	21	that	that	IN
38430	229	22	a	a	DT
38430	229	23	joke	joke	NN
38430	229	24	was	be	VBD
38430	229	25	a	a	DT
38430	229	26	joke	joke	NN
38430	229	27	except	except	IN
38430	229	28	when	when	WRB
38430	229	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	229	30	was	be	VBD
38430	229	31	an	an	DT
38430	229	32	untruth	untruth	NN
38430	229	33	:	:	:
38430	229	34	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	229	35	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
38430	229	36	George	George	NNP
38430	229	37	,	,	,
38430	229	38	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	229	39	,	,	,
38430	229	40	being	be	VBG
38430	229	41	of	of	IN
38430	229	42	the	the	DT
38430	229	43	plausible	plausible	JJ
38430	229	44	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	229	45	that	that	IN
38430	229	46	a	a	DT
38430	229	47	joke	joke	NN
38430	229	48	is	be	VBZ
38430	229	49	a	a	DT
38430	229	50	joke	joke	NN
38430	229	51	under	under	IN
38430	229	52	all	all	DT
38430	229	53	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
38430	229	54	.	.	.
38430	230	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	230	2	:	:	:
38430	230	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	230	4	20	20	CD
38430	230	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	230	6	The	the	DT
38430	230	7	argument	argument	NN
38430	230	8	about	about	IN
38430	230	9	the	the	DT
38430	230	10	hull	hull	NN
38430	230	11	of	of	IN
38430	230	12	a	a	DT
38430	230	13	ship	ship	NN
38430	230	14	disappearing	disappear	VBG
38430	230	15	first	first	RB
38430	230	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	230	17	not	not	RB
38430	230	18	convincing	convincing	JJ
38430	230	19	,	,	,
38430	230	20	since	since	IN
38430	230	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	230	22	would	would	MD
38430	230	23	equally	equally	RB
38430	230	24	well	well	RB
38430	230	25	prove	prove	VB
38430	230	26	that	that	IN
38430	230	27	the	the	DT
38430	230	28	surface	surface	NN
38430	230	29	of	of	IN
38430	230	30	the	the	DT
38430	230	31	earth	earth	NN
38430	230	32	was	be	VBD
38430	230	33	,	,	,
38430	230	34	for	for	IN
38430	230	35	example	example	NN
38430	230	36	,	,	,
38430	230	37	corrugated	corrugate	VBN
38430	230	38	on	on	IN
38430	230	39	a	a	DT
38430	230	40	large	large	JJ
38430	230	41	scale	scale	NN
38430	230	42	.	.	.
38430	231	1	If	if	IN
38430	231	2	the	the	DT
38430	231	3	common	common	JJ
38430	231	4	-	-	HYPH
38430	231	5	sense	sense	NN
38430	231	6	of	of	IN
38430	231	7	the	the	DT
38430	231	8	reader	reader	NN
38430	231	9	were	be	VBD
38430	231	10	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	231	11	to	to	TO
38430	231	12	dismiss	dismiss	VB
38430	231	13	the	the	DT
38430	231	14	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	231	15	of	of	IN
38430	231	16	water	water	NN
38430	231	17	clinging	cling	VBG
38430	231	18	to	to	IN
38430	231	19	such	such	JJ
38430	231	20	corrugations	corrugation	NNS
38430	231	21	,	,	,
38430	231	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	231	23	might	may	MD
38430	231	24	equally	equally	RB
38430	231	25	be	be	VB
38430	231	26	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	231	27	to	to	TO
38430	231	28	dismiss	dismiss	VB
38430	231	29	the	the	DT
38430	231	30	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	231	31	of	of	IN
38430	231	32	water	water	NN
38430	231	33	clinging	cling	VBG
38430	231	34	to	to	IN
38430	231	35	a	a	DT
38430	231	36	spherical	spherical	JJ
38430	231	37	earth	earth	NN
38430	231	38	.	.	.
38430	232	1	Traditional	traditional	JJ
38430	232	2	geography	geography	NN
38430	232	3	books	book	NNS
38430	232	4	,	,	,
38430	232	5	no	no	RB
38430	232	6	doubt	doubt	RB
38430	232	7	,	,	,
38430	232	8	gave	give	VBD
38430	232	9	rise	rise	NN
38430	232	10	to	to	IN
38430	232	11	the	the	DT
38430	232	12	opinions	opinion	NNS
38430	232	13	held	hold	VBN
38430	232	14	by	by	IN
38430	232	15	Lady	Lady	NNP
38430	232	16	Blount	Blount	NNP
38430	232	17	and	and	CC
38430	232	18	the	the	DT
38430	232	19	Zetetic	Zetetic	NNP
38430	232	20	Society	Society	NNP
38430	232	21	.	.	.
38430	233	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	233	2	21	21	LS
38430	233	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	233	4	The	the	DT
38430	233	5	subject	subject	NN
38430	233	6	of	of	IN
38430	233	7	Implication	implication	NN
38430	233	8	will	will	MD
38430	233	9	be	be	VB
38430	233	10	further	further	RB
38430	233	11	considered	consider	VBN
38430	233	12	in	in	IN
38430	233	13	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	233	14	XIX	XIX	NNP
38430	233	15	.	.	.
38430	234	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	234	2	IV	IV	NNP
38430	234	3	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	234	4	OF	of	IN
38430	234	5	CLASSES	class	NNS
38430	234	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	234	7	once	once	RB
38430	234	8	heard	hear	VBD
38430	234	9	of	of	IN
38430	234	10	a	a	DT
38430	234	11	meritorious	meritorious	JJ
38430	234	12	lady	lady	NN
38430	234	13	who	who	WP
38430	234	14	was	be	VBD
38430	234	15	extremely	extremely	RB
38430	234	16	conventional	conventional	JJ
38430	234	17	;	;	:
38430	234	18	on	on	IN
38430	234	19	the	the	DT
38430	234	20	slender	slender	NN
38430	234	21	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	234	22	of	of	IN
38430	234	23	carefully	carefully	RB
38430	234	24	acquired	acquire	VBN
38430	234	25	habits	habit	NNS
38430	234	26	of	of	IN
38430	234	27	preferring	prefer	VBG
38430	234	28	the	the	DT
38430	234	29	word	word	NN
38430	234	30	"	"	``
38430	234	31	woman	woman	NN
38430	234	32	"	"	''
38430	234	33	to	to	IN
38430	234	34	the	the	DT
38430	234	35	word	word	NN
38430	234	36	"	"	``
38430	234	37	lady	lady	NN
38430	234	38	"	"	''
38430	234	39	and	and	CC
38430	234	40	of	of	IN
38430	234	41	going	go	VBG
38430	234	42	to	to	IN
38430	234	43	the	the	DT
38430	234	44	post	post	JJ
38430	234	45	-	-	JJ
38430	234	46	office	office	NN
38430	234	47	without	without	IN
38430	234	48	a	a	DT
38430	234	49	hat	hat	NN
38430	234	50	,	,	,
38430	234	51	imagined	imagine	VBD
38430	234	52	that	that	IN
38430	234	53	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	234	54	was	be	VBD
38430	234	55	unconventional	unconventional	JJ
38430	234	56	and	and	CC
38430	234	57	altogether	altogether	RB
38430	234	58	a	a	DT
38430	234	59	remarkable	remarkable	JJ
38430	234	60	person	person	NN
38430	234	61	;	;	:
38430	234	62	and	and	CC
38430	234	63	who	who	WP
38430	234	64	once	once	RB
38430	234	65	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	234	66	with	with	IN
38430	234	67	great	great	JJ
38430	234	68	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
38430	234	69	that	that	IN
38430	234	70	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	234	71	was	be	VBD
38430	234	72	a	a	DT
38430	234	73	"	"	``
38430	234	74	very	very	RB
38430	234	75	queer	queer	NN
38430	234	76	person	person	NN
38430	234	77	,	,	,
38430	234	78	"	"	''
38430	234	79	and	and	CC
38430	234	80	that	that	IN
38430	234	81	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	234	82	shocked	shock	VBD
38430	234	83	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	234	84	"	"	``
38430	234	85	except	except	IN
38430	234	86	,	,	,
38430	234	87	of	of	IN
38430	234	88	course	course	NN
38430	234	89	,	,	,
38430	234	90	bad	bad	JJ
38430	234	91	form	form	NN
38430	234	92	.	.	.
38430	234	93	"	"	''
38430	235	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	235	2	,	,	,
38430	235	3	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	4	asserted	assert	VBD
38430	235	5	that	that	IN
38430	235	6	all	all	PDT
38430	235	7	the	the	DT
38430	235	8	things	thing	NNS
38430	235	9	which	which	WDT
38430	235	10	shocked	shock	VBD
38430	235	11	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	12	were	be	VBD
38430	235	13	actions	action	NNS
38430	235	14	in	in	IN
38430	235	15	bad	bad	JJ
38430	235	16	form	form	NN
38430	235	17	;	;	:
38430	235	18	and	and	CC
38430	235	19	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	20	would	would	MD
38430	235	21	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
38430	235	22	agree	agree	VB
38430	235	23	,	,	,
38430	235	24	though	though	IN
38430	235	25	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	26	did	do	VBD
38430	235	27	not	not	RB
38430	235	28	actually	actually	RB
38430	235	29	state	state	VB
38430	235	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	31	,	,	,
38430	235	32	that	that	IN
38430	235	33	all	all	PDT
38430	235	34	the	the	DT
38430	235	35	things	thing	NNS
38430	235	36	which	which	WDT
38430	235	37	were	be	VBD
38430	235	38	done	do	VBN
38430	235	39	in	in	IN
38430	235	40	bad	bad	JJ
38430	235	41	form	form	NN
38430	235	42	would	would	MD
38430	235	43	shock	shock	VB
38430	235	44	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	235	45	.	.	.
38430	236	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
38430	236	2	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	236	3	asserted	assert	VBD
38430	236	4	that	that	IN
38430	236	5	the	the	DT
38430	236	6	class	class	NN
38430	236	7	of	of	IN
38430	236	8	things	thing	NNS
38430	236	9	which	which	WDT
38430	236	10	shocked	shock	VBD
38430	236	11	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	236	12	was	be	VBD
38430	236	13	the	the	DT
38430	236	14	class	class	NN
38430	236	15	of	of	IN
38430	236	16	actions	action	NNS
38430	236	17	in	in	IN
38430	236	18	bad	bad	JJ
38430	236	19	form	form	NN
38430	236	20	.	.	.
38430	237	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
38430	237	2	the	the	DT
38430	237	3	statement	statement	NN
38430	237	4	of	of	IN
38430	237	5	this	this	DT
38430	237	6	lady	lady	NN
38430	237	7	that	that	IN
38430	237	8	some	some	DT
38430	237	9	or	or	CC
38430	237	10	all	all	DT
38430	237	11	of	of	IN
38430	237	12	the	the	DT
38430	237	13	actions	action	NNS
38430	237	14	done	do	VBN
38430	237	15	in	in	IN
38430	237	16	bad	bad	JJ
38430	237	17	form	form	NN
38430	237	18	shocked	shock	VBD
38430	237	19	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	237	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	237	21	an	an	DT
38430	237	22	identical	identical	JJ
38430	237	23	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	237	24	of	of	IN
38430	237	25	the	the	DT
38430	237	26	form	form	NN
38430	237	27	"	"	``
38430	237	28	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	237	29	shocks	shock	VBZ
38430	237	30	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	237	31	,	,	,
38430	237	32	except	except	IN
38430	237	33	,	,	,
38430	237	34	of	of	IN
38430	237	35	course	course	NN
38430	237	36	,	,	,
38430	237	37	the	the	DT
38430	237	38	things	thing	NNS
38430	237	39	which	which	WDT
38430	237	40	do	do	VBP
38430	237	41	,	,	,
38430	237	42	in	in	IN
38430	237	43	fact	fact	NN
38430	237	44	,	,	,
38430	237	45	shock	shock	VB
38430	237	46	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	237	47	"	"	''
38430	237	48	;	;	:
38430	237	49	and	and	CC
38430	237	50	this	this	DT
38430	237	51	statement	statement	NN
38430	237	52	the	the	DT
38430	237	53	lady	lady	NN
38430	237	54	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	237	55	did	do	VBD
38430	237	56	not	not	RB
38430	237	57	intend	intend	VB
38430	237	58	to	to	TO
38430	237	59	make	make	VB
38430	237	60	.	.	.
38430	238	1	This	this	DT
38430	238	2	excellent	excellent	JJ
38430	238	3	lady	lady	NN
38430	238	4	,	,	,
38430	238	5	had	have	VBD
38430	238	6	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	238	7	but	but	CC
38430	238	8	known	know	VBD
38430	238	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	238	10	,	,	,
38430	238	11	was	be	VBD
38430	238	12	logically	logically	RB
38430	238	13	justified	justify	VBN
38430	238	14	in	in	IN
38430	238	15	making	make	VBG
38430	238	16	any	any	DT
38430	238	17	statement	statement	NN
38430	238	18	whatever	whatever	WDT
38430	238	19	about	about	IN
38430	238	20	her	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	238	21	unconventionality	unconventionality	NN
38430	238	22	.	.	.
38430	239	1	For	for	IN
38430	239	2	the	the	DT
38430	239	3	class	class	NN
38430	239	4	of	of	IN
38430	239	5	her	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	239	6	unconventional	unconventional	JJ
38430	239	7	actions	action	NNS
38430	239	8	was	be	VBD
38430	239	9	the	the	DT
38430	239	10	null	null	JJ
38430	239	11	class	class	NN
38430	239	12	.	.	.
38430	240	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	240	2	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	240	3	might	may	MD
38430	240	4	logically	logically	RB
38430	240	5	have	have	VB
38430	240	6	made	make	VBN
38430	240	7	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
38430	240	8	statements	statement	NNS
38430	240	9	about	about	IN
38430	240	10	this	this	DT
38430	240	11	class	class	NN
38430	240	12	of	of	IN
38430	240	13	actions	action	NNS
38430	240	14	.	.	.
38430	241	1	As	as	IN
38430	241	2	a	a	DT
38430	241	3	matter	matter	NN
38430	241	4	of	of	IN
38430	241	5	fact	fact	NN
38430	241	6	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	241	7	did	do	VBD
38430	241	8	make	make	VB
38430	241	9	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
38430	241	10	statements	statement	NNS
38430	241	11	,	,	,
38430	241	12	but	but	CC
38430	241	13	unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
38430	241	14	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	241	15	justified	justify	VBD
38430	241	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	241	17	by	by	IN
38430	241	18	stating	state	VBG
38430	241	19	that	that	IN
38430	241	20	,	,	,
38430	241	21	"	"	``
38430	241	22	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	241	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	241	24	the	the	DT
38430	241	25	privilege	privilege	NN
38430	241	26	of	of	IN
38430	241	27	woman	woman	NN
38430	241	28	to	to	TO
38430	241	29	be	be	VB
38430	241	30	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
38430	241	31	.	.	.
38430	241	32	"	"	''
38430	242	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	242	2	was	be	VBD
38430	242	3	one	one	CD
38430	242	4	of	of	IN
38430	242	5	those	those	DT
38430	242	6	persons	person	NNS
38430	242	7	who	who	WP
38430	242	8	say	say	VBP
38430	242	9	things	thing	NNS
38430	242	10	like	like	IN
38430	242	11	that	that	DT
38430	242	12	.	.	.
38430	243	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	243	2	V	V	NNP
38430	243	3	ETHICAL	ethical	NN
38430	243	4	APPLICATIONS	application	NNS
38430	243	5	OF	of	IN
38430	243	6	THE	the	DT
38430	243	7	LAW	law	NN
38430	243	8	OF	of	IN
38430	243	9	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	243	10	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	243	11	may	may	MD
38430	243	12	be	be	VB
38430	243	13	remembered	remember	VBN
38430	243	14	that	that	IN
38430	243	15	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	243	16	Podsnap	Podsnap	NNP
38430	243	17	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	243	18	,	,	,
38430	243	19	with	with	IN
38430	243	20	sadness	sadness	NN
38430	243	21	tempered	temper	VBN
38430	243	22	by	by	IN
38430	243	23	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
38430	243	24	,	,	,
38430	243	25	that	that	IN
38430	243	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	243	27	regretted	regret	VBD
38430	243	28	to	to	TO
38430	243	29	say	say	VB
38430	243	30	that	that	IN
38430	243	31	"	"	``
38430	243	32	Foreign	foreign	JJ
38430	243	33	nations	nation	NNS
38430	243	34	do	do	VBP
38430	243	35	as	as	IN
38430	243	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	243	37	do	do	VBP
38430	243	38	do	do	VB
38430	243	39	.	.	.
38430	243	40	"	"	''
38430	244	1	Besides	besides	IN
38430	244	2	aiding	aid	VBG
38430	244	3	the	the	DT
38430	244	4	comforting	comfort	VBG
38430	244	5	expression	expression	NN
38430	244	6	of	of	IN
38430	244	7	moral	moral	JJ
38430	244	8	disapproval	disapproval	NN
38430	244	9	,	,	,
38430	244	10	the	the	DT
38430	244	11	law	law	NN
38430	244	12	of	of	IN
38430	244	13	identity	identity	NN
38430	244	14	has	have	VBZ
38430	244	15	yet	yet	RB
38430	244	16	another	another	DT
38430	244	17	useful	useful	JJ
38430	244	18	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	244	19	in	in	IN
38430	244	20	practical	practical	JJ
38430	244	21	ethics	ethic	NNS
38430	244	22	:	:	:
38430	244	23	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	244	24	serves	serve	VBZ
38430	244	25	the	the	DT
38430	244	26	welcome	welcome	JJ
38430	244	27	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	244	28	of	of	IN
38430	244	29	providing	provide	VBG
38430	244	30	an	an	DT
38430	244	31	excuse	excuse	NN
38430	244	32	for	for	IN
38430	244	33	infractions	infraction	NNS
38430	244	34	of	of	IN
38430	244	35	the	the	DT
38430	244	36	moral	moral	JJ
38430	244	37	law	law	NN
38430	244	38	.	.	.
38430	245	1	There	there	EX
38430	245	2	was	be	VBD
38430	245	3	once	once	RB
38430	245	4	a	a	DT
38430	245	5	man	man	NN
38430	245	6	who	who	WP
38430	245	7	treated	treat	VBD
38430	245	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	245	9	wife	wife	NN
38430	245	10	badly	badly	RB
38430	245	11	,	,	,
38430	245	12	was	be	VBD
38430	245	13	unfaithful	unfaithful	JJ
38430	245	14	to	to	IN
38430	245	15	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	245	16	,	,	,
38430	245	17	was	be	VBD
38430	245	18	dishonest	dishonest	JJ
38430	245	19	in	in	IN
38430	245	20	business	business	NN
38430	245	21	,	,	,
38430	245	22	and	and	CC
38430	245	23	was	be	VBD
38430	245	24	not	not	RB
38430	245	25	particular	particular	JJ
38430	245	26	in	in	IN
38430	245	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	245	28	use	use	NN
38430	245	29	of	of	IN
38430	245	30	language	language	NN
38430	245	31	;	;	:
38430	245	32	and	and	CC
38430	245	33	yet	yet	RB
38430	245	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	245	35	life	life	NN
38430	245	36	on	on	IN
38430	245	37	earth	earth	NN
38430	245	38	was	be	VBD
38430	245	39	described	describe	VBN
38430	245	40	in	in	IN
38430	245	41	the	the	DT
38430	245	42	lines	line	NNS
38430	245	43	:	:	:
38430	245	44	This	this	DT
38430	245	45	man	man	NN
38430	245	46	maintained	maintain	VBD
38430	245	47	a	a	DT
38430	245	48	wife	wife	NN
38430	245	49	's	's	POS
38430	245	50	a	a	DT
38430	245	51	wife	wife	NN
38430	245	52	,	,	,
38430	245	53	Men	man	NNS
38430	245	54	are	be	VBP
38430	245	55	as	as	IN
38430	245	56	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	245	57	are	be	VBP
38430	245	58	made	make	VBN
38430	245	59	,	,	,
38430	245	60	Business	Business	NNP
38430	245	61	is	be	VBZ
38430	245	62	business	business	NN
38430	245	63	,	,	,
38430	245	64	life	life	NN
38430	245	65	is	be	VBZ
38430	245	66	life	life	NN
38430	245	67	;	;	,
38430	245	68	And	and	CC
38430	245	69	called	call	VBD
38430	245	70	a	a	DT
38430	245	71	spade	spade	NN
38430	245	72	a	a	DT
38430	245	73	spade	spade	NN
38430	245	74	.	.	.
38430	246	1	One	one	CD
38430	246	2	of	of	IN
38430	246	3	the	the	DT
38430	246	4	objects	object	NNS
38430	246	5	of	of	IN
38430	246	6	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	246	7	G.	G.	NNP
38430	246	8	E.	E.	NNP
38430	246	9	Moore	Moore	NNP
38430	246	10	's	's	POS
38430	246	11	_	_	NNP
38430	246	12	Principia	Principia	NNP
38430	246	13	Ethica_[22	Ethica_[22	NNP
38430	246	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	246	15	was	be	VBD
38430	246	16	to	to	TO
38430	246	17	argue	argue	VB
38430	246	18	that	that	IN
38430	246	19	the	the	DT
38430	246	20	word	word	NN
38430	246	21	"	"	``
38430	246	22	good	good	JJ
38430	246	23	"	"	''
38430	246	24	means	mean	VBZ
38430	246	25	simply	simply	RB
38430	246	26	good	good	JJ
38430	246	27	,	,	,
38430	246	28	and	and	CC
38430	246	29	not	not	RB
38430	246	30	pleasant	pleasant	JJ
38430	246	31	or	or	CC
38430	246	32	anything	anything	NN
38430	246	33	else	else	RB
38430	246	34	.	.	.
38430	247	1	Appropriately	appropriately	RB
38430	247	2	enough	enough	RB
38430	247	3	,	,	,
38430	247	4	this	this	DT
38430	247	5	book	book	NN
38430	247	6	bore	bear	VBD
38430	247	7	on	on	IN
38430	247	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	247	9	title	title	NN
38430	247	10	-	-	HYPH
38430	247	11	page	page	NN
38430	247	12	the	the	DT
38430	247	13	quotation	quotation	NN
38430	247	14	from	from	IN
38430	247	15	the	the	DT
38430	247	16	preface	preface	NN
38430	247	17	to	to	IN
38430	247	18	the	the	DT
38430	247	19	_	_	NNP
38430	247	20	Sermons	Sermons	NNPS
38430	247	21	_	_	NNP
38430	247	22	,	,	,
38430	247	23	published	publish	VBN
38430	247	24	in	in	IN
38430	247	25	1726	1726	CD
38430	247	26	,	,	,
38430	247	27	of	of	IN
38430	247	28	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
38430	247	29	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
38430	247	30	Butler	Butler	NNP
38430	247	31	,	,	,
38430	247	32	the	the	DT
38430	247	33	author	author	NN
38430	247	34	of	of	IN
38430	247	35	the	the	DT
38430	247	36	_	_	NNP
38430	247	37	Analogy	Analogy	NNP
38430	247	38	_	_	NNP
38430	247	39	:	:	:
38430	247	40	"	"	``
38430	247	41	Everything	everything	NN
38430	247	42	is	be	VBZ
38430	247	43	what	what	WP
38430	247	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	247	45	is	be	VBZ
38430	247	46	and	and	CC
38430	247	47	not	not	RB
38430	247	48	another	another	DT
38430	247	49	thing	thing	NN
38430	247	50	.	.	.
38430	247	51	"	"	''
38430	248	1	But	but	CC
38430	248	2	another	another	DT
38430	248	3	famous	famous	JJ
38430	248	4	Butler	butler	NN
38430	248	5	--	--	.
38430	248	6	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
38430	248	7	Butler	Butler	NNP
38430	248	8	,	,	,
38430	248	9	the	the	DT
38430	248	10	author	author	NN
38430	248	11	of	of	IN
38430	248	12	_	_	NNP
38430	248	13	Hudibras_--went	Hudibras_--went	NNS
38430	248	14	farther	far	RBR
38430	248	15	than	than	IN
38430	248	16	this	this	DT
38430	248	17	,	,	,
38430	248	18	and	and	CC
38430	248	19	maintained	maintain	VBD
38430	248	20	that	that	IN
38430	248	21	identities	identity	NNS
38430	248	22	were	be	VBD
38430	248	23	the	the	DT
38430	248	24	highest	high	JJS
38430	248	25	attainment	attainment	JJ
38430	248	26	of	of	IN
38430	248	27	metaphysics	metaphysic	NNS
38430	248	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	248	29	.	.	.
38430	249	1	At	at	IN
38430	249	2	the	the	DT
38430	249	3	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	249	4	of	of	IN
38430	249	5	the	the	DT
38430	249	6	first	first	JJ
38430	249	7	Canto	Canto	NNP
38430	249	8	of	of	IN
38430	249	9	_	_	NNP
38430	249	10	Hudibras	Hudibras	NNP
38430	249	11	_	_	NNP
38430	249	12	,	,	,
38430	249	13	in	in	IN
38430	249	14	the	the	DT
38430	249	15	description	description	NN
38430	249	16	of	of	IN
38430	249	17	Hudibras	Hudibras	NNP
38430	249	18	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	249	19	,	,	,
38430	249	20	Butler	Butler	NNP
38430	249	21	wrote	write	VBD
38430	249	22	:	:	:
38430	249	23	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	249	24	knew	know	VBD
38430	249	25	what	what	WP
38430	249	26	's	be	VBZ
38430	249	27	what	what	WP
38430	249	28	,	,	,
38430	249	29	and	and	CC
38430	249	30	that	that	DT
38430	249	31	's	be	VBZ
38430	249	32	as	as	RB
38430	249	33	high	high	JJ
38430	249	34	As	as	IN
38430	249	35	metaphysic	metaphysic	JJ
38430	249	36	wit	wit	NN
38430	249	37	can	can	MD
38430	249	38	fly	fly	VB
38430	249	39	.	.	.
38430	250	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	250	2	once	once	RB
38430	250	3	conducted	conduct	VBD
38430	250	4	what	what	WP
38430	250	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	250	6	imagined	imagine	VBD
38430	250	7	to	to	TO
38430	250	8	be	be	VB
38430	250	9	an	an	DT
38430	250	10	æsthetic	æsthetic	JJ
38430	250	11	investigation	investigation	NN
38430	250	12	for	for	IN
38430	250	13	the	the	DT
38430	250	14	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	250	15	of	of	IN
38430	250	16	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	250	17	,	,	,
38430	250	18	by	by	IN
38430	250	19	the	the	DT
38430	250	20	continual	continual	JJ
38430	250	21	use	use	NN
38430	250	22	of	of	IN
38430	250	23	the	the	DT
38430	250	24	word	word	NN
38430	250	25	"	"	``
38430	250	26	Why	why	WRB
38430	250	27	?	?	.
38430	251	1	"	"	``
38430	251	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	251	3	23	23	CD
38430	251	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	251	5	the	the	DT
38430	251	6	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	251	7	upon	upon	IN
38430	251	8	which	which	WDT
38430	251	9	certain	certain	JJ
38430	251	10	people	people	NNS
38430	251	11	choose	choose	VBP
38430	251	12	to	to	TO
38430	251	13	put	put	VB
38430	251	14	milk	milk	NN
38430	251	15	into	into	IN
38430	251	16	a	a	DT
38430	251	17	tea	tea	NN
38430	251	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	251	19	cup	cup	NN
38430	251	20	before	before	IN
38430	251	21	the	the	DT
38430	251	22	tea	tea	NN
38430	251	23	.	.	.
38430	252	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	252	2	was	be	VBD
38430	252	3	surprised	surprised	JJ
38430	252	4	to	to	TO
38430	252	5	discover	discover	VB
38430	252	6	that	that	IN
38430	252	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	252	8	was	be	VBD
38430	252	9	an	an	DT
38430	252	10	ethical	ethical	JJ
38430	252	11	,	,	,
38430	252	12	and	and	CC
38430	252	13	not	not	RB
38430	252	14	an	an	DT
38430	252	15	æsthetic	æsthetic	JJ
38430	252	16	problem	problem	NN
38430	252	17	;	;	:
38430	252	18	for	for	CC
38430	252	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	252	20	soon	soon	RB
38430	252	21	elicited	elicit	VBD
38430	252	22	the	the	DT
38430	252	23	fact	fact	NN
38430	252	24	that	that	IN
38430	252	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	252	26	was	be	VBD
38430	252	27	done	do	VBN
38430	252	28	because	because	IN
38430	252	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	252	30	was	be	VBD
38430	252	31	"	"	``
38430	252	32	right	right	JJ
38430	252	33	.	.	.
38430	252	34	"	"	''
38430	253	1	A	a	DT
38430	253	2	continuance	continuance	NN
38430	253	3	of	of	IN
38430	253	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	253	5	patient	patient	NN
38430	253	6	questioning	questioning	NN
38430	253	7	elicited	elicit	VBD
38430	253	8	further	further	JJ
38430	253	9	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	253	10	of	of	IN
38430	253	11	the	the	DT
38430	253	12	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
38430	253	13	character	character	NN
38430	253	14	of	of	IN
38430	253	15	the	the	DT
38430	253	16	principle	principle	NN
38430	253	17	of	of	IN
38430	253	18	identity	identity	NN
38430	253	19	in	in	IN
38430	253	20	ethics	ethic	NNS
38430	253	21	;	;	:
38430	253	22	for	for	IN
38430	253	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	253	24	was	be	VBD
38430	253	25	right	right	JJ
38430	253	26	,	,	,
38430	253	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	253	28	learned	learn	VBD
38430	253	29	,	,	,
38430	253	30	because	because	IN
38430	253	31	"	"	``
38430	253	32	right	right	JJ
38430	253	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	253	34	right	right	JJ
38430	253	35	.	.	.
38430	253	36	"	"	''
38430	254	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	254	2	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	254	3	that	that	IN
38430	254	4	some	some	DT
38430	254	5	people	people	NNS
38430	254	6	unconsciously	unconsciously	RB
38430	254	7	think	think	VBP
38430	254	8	that	that	IN
38430	254	9	the	the	DT
38430	254	10	principle	principle	NN
38430	254	11	of	of	IN
38430	254	12	identity	identity	NN
38430	254	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	254	14	the	the	DT
38430	254	15	foundation	foundation	NN
38430	254	16	,	,	,
38430	254	17	in	in	IN
38430	254	18	certain	certain	JJ
38430	254	19	religions	religion	NNS
38430	254	20	,	,	,
38430	254	21	of	of	IN
38430	254	22	the	the	DT
38430	254	23	reasons	reason	NNS
38430	254	24	which	which	WDT
38430	254	25	can	can	MD
38430	254	26	be	be	VB
38430	254	27	alleged	allege	VBN
38430	254	28	for	for	IN
38430	254	29	moral	moral	JJ
38430	254	30	conduct	conduct	NN
38430	254	31	,	,	,
38430	254	32	and	and	CC
38430	254	33	are	be	VBP
38430	254	34	surprised	surprised	JJ
38430	254	35	when	when	WRB
38430	254	36	this	this	DT
38430	254	37	fact	fact	NN
38430	254	38	is	be	VBZ
38430	254	39	pointed	point	VBN
38430	254	40	out	out	RP
38430	254	41	to	to	IN
38430	254	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	254	43	.	.	.
38430	255	1	The	the	DT
38430	255	2	late	late	JJ
38430	255	3	Sir	Sir	NNP
38430	255	4	Leslie	Leslie	NNP
38430	255	5	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
38430	255	6	,	,	,
38430	255	7	when	when	WRB
38430	255	8	travelling	travel	VBG
38430	255	9	by	by	IN
38430	255	10	railway	railway	NN
38430	255	11	,	,	,
38430	255	12	fell	fall	VBD
38430	255	13	into	into	IN
38430	255	14	conversation	conversation	NN
38430	255	15	with	with	IN
38430	255	16	an	an	DT
38430	255	17	officer	officer	NN
38430	255	18	of	of	IN
38430	255	19	the	the	DT
38430	255	20	Salvation	Salvation	NNP
38430	255	21	Army	Army	NNP
38430	255	22	,	,	,
38430	255	23	who	who	WP
38430	255	24	tried	try	VBD
38430	255	25	hard	hard	RB
38430	255	26	to	to	TO
38430	255	27	convert	convert	VB
38430	255	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	255	29	.	.	.
38430	256	1	Failing	fail	VBG
38430	256	2	in	in	IN
38430	256	3	this	this	DT
38430	256	4	laudable	laudable	JJ
38430	256	5	endeavour	endeavour	NN
38430	256	6	,	,	,
38430	256	7	the	the	DT
38430	256	8	Salvationist	Salvationist	NNP
38430	256	9	at	at	IN
38430	256	10	last	last	JJ
38430	256	11	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	256	12	:	:	:
38430	256	13	"	"	``
38430	256	14	But	but	CC
38430	256	15	if	if	IN
38430	256	16	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	256	17	are	be	VBP
38430	256	18	n't	not	RB
38430	256	19	saved	save	VBN
38430	256	20	,	,	,
38430	256	21	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	256	22	ca	can	MD
38430	256	23	n't	not	RB
38430	256	24	go	go	VB
38430	256	25	to	to	IN
38430	256	26	heaven	heaven	NNP
38430	256	27	!	!	.
38430	256	28	"	"	''
38430	257	1	"	"	``
38430	257	2	That	that	IN
38430	257	3	,	,	,
38430	257	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	257	5	friend	friend	NN
38430	257	6	,	,	,
38430	257	7	"	"	''
38430	257	8	replied	reply	VBD
38430	257	9	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
38430	257	10	,	,	,
38430	257	11	"	"	''
38430	257	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	257	13	an	an	DT
38430	257	14	identical	identical	JJ
38430	257	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	257	16	.	.	.
38430	257	17	"	"	''
38430	258	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	258	2	:	:	:
38430	258	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	258	4	22	22	CD
38430	258	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	258	6	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	258	7	,	,	,
38430	258	8	1903	1903	CD
38430	258	9	.	.	.
38430	259	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	259	2	23	23	CD
38430	259	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	259	4	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	259	5	.	.	.
38430	260	1	_	_	NNP
38430	260	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	261	1	E.	E.	NNP
38430	261	2	_	_	NNP
38430	261	3	,	,	,
38430	261	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	261	5	2	2	CD
38430	261	6	.	.	.
38430	262	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	262	2	VI	VI	NNP
38430	262	3	THE	the	DT
38430	262	4	LAW	law	NN
38430	262	5	OF	of	IN
38430	262	6	CONTRADICTION	CONTRADICTION	VBN
38430	262	7	IN	in	IN
38430	262	8	MODERN	MODERN	NNP
38430	262	9	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	262	10	Considering	consider	VBG
38430	262	11	the	the	DT
38430	262	12	important	important	JJ
38430	262	13	place	place	NN
38430	262	14	assigned	assign	VBN
38430	262	15	by	by	IN
38430	262	16	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
38430	262	17	and	and	CC
38430	262	18	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	262	19	to	to	IN
38430	262	20	the	the	DT
38430	262	21	law	law	NN
38430	262	22	of	of	IN
38430	262	23	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	262	24	,	,	,
38430	262	25	the	the	DT
38430	262	26	remark	remark	NN
38430	262	27	will	will	MD
38430	262	28	naturally	naturally	RB
38430	262	29	be	be	VB
38430	262	30	resented	resent	VBN
38430	262	31	by	by	IN
38430	262	32	many	many	JJ
38430	262	33	of	of	IN
38430	262	34	the	the	DT
38430	262	35	older	old	JJR
38430	262	36	schools	school	NNS
38430	262	37	of	of	IN
38430	262	38	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	262	39	,	,	,
38430	262	40	and	and	CC
38430	262	41	especially	especially	RB
38430	262	42	by	by	IN
38430	262	43	Kantians	Kantians	NNPS
38430	262	44	,	,	,
38430	262	45	that	that	IN
38430	262	46	"	"	``
38430	262	47	in	in	IN
38430	262	48	spite	spite	NN
38430	262	49	of	of	IN
38430	262	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	262	51	fame	fame	NN
38430	262	52	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	262	53	have	have	VBP
38430	262	54	found	find	VBN
38430	262	55	few	few	JJ
38430	262	56	occasions	occasion	NNS
38430	262	57	for	for	IN
38430	262	58	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	262	59	use	use	NN
38430	262	60	.	.	.
38430	263	1	"	"	``
38430	263	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	263	3	24	24	CD
38430	263	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	263	5	Also	also	RB
38430	263	6	in	in	IN
38430	263	7	modern	modern	JJ
38430	263	8	times	time	NNS
38430	263	9	,	,	,
38430	263	10	Benedetto	Benedetto	NNP
38430	263	11	Croce	Croce	NNP
38430	263	12	,	,	,
38430	263	13	an	an	DT
38430	263	14	opponent	opponent	NN
38430	263	15	of	of	IN
38430	263	16	both	both	CC
38430	263	17	traditional	traditional	JJ
38430	263	18	logic	logic	NN
38430	263	19	and	and	CC
38430	263	20	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	263	21	logic	logic	NN
38430	263	22	,	,	,
38430	263	23	began	begin	VBD
38430	263	24	the	the	DT
38430	263	25	preface	preface	NN
38430	263	26	of	of	IN
38430	263	27	the	the	DT
38430	263	28	book	book	NN
38430	263	29	of	of	IN
38430	263	30	1908	1908	CD
38430	263	31	on	on	IN
38430	263	32	Logic[25	logic[25	CD
38430	263	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	263	34	by	by	IN
38430	263	35	saying	say	VBG
38430	263	36	that	that	IN
38430	263	37	that	that	DT
38430	263	38	volume	volume	NN
38430	263	39	"	"	``
38430	263	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	263	41	and	and	CC
38430	263	42	is	be	VBZ
38430	263	43	not	not	RB
38430	263	44	"	"	``
38430	263	45	a	a	DT
38430	263	46	certain	certain	JJ
38430	263	47	memoir	memoir	NN
38430	263	48	of	of	IN
38430	263	49	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	263	50	which	which	WDT
38430	263	51	had	have	VBD
38430	263	52	been	be	VBN
38430	263	53	published	publish	VBN
38430	263	54	in	in	IN
38430	263	55	1905	1905	CD
38430	263	56	.	.	.
38430	264	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	264	2	:	:	:
38430	264	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	264	4	24	24	CD
38430	264	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	264	6	_	_	NNP
38430	264	7	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
38430	265	1	Ma	Ma	NNP
38430	265	2	.	.	.
38430	265	3	_	_	NNP
38430	265	4	,	,	,
38430	265	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	265	6	116	116	CD
38430	265	7	.	.	.
38430	266	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	266	2	25	25	CD
38430	266	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	266	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	266	5	English	english	JJ
38430	266	6	translation	translation	NN
38430	266	7	of	of	IN
38430	266	8	the	the	DT
38430	266	9	third	third	JJ
38430	266	10	Italian	italian	JJ
38430	266	11	edition	edition	NN
38430	266	12	by	by	IN
38430	266	13	Douglas	Douglas	NNP
38430	266	14	Ainslie	Ainslie	NNP
38430	266	15	,	,	,
38430	266	16	under	under	IN
38430	266	17	the	the	DT
38430	266	18	title	title	NN
38430	266	19	:	:	:
38430	266	20	_	_	NNP
38430	266	21	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	266	22	as	as	IN
38430	266	23	the	the	DT
38430	266	24	Science	Science	NNP
38430	266	25	of	of	IN
38430	266	26	the	the	DT
38430	266	27	Pure	Pure	NNP
38430	266	28	Concept	Concept	NNP
38430	266	29	_	_	NNP
38430	266	30	,	,	,
38430	266	31	London	London	NNP
38430	266	32	1917.--ED	1917.--ed	CD
38430	266	33	.	.	.
38430	266	34	]	]	-RRB-
38430	267	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	267	2	VII	vii	NN
38430	267	3	SYMBOLISM	SYMBOLISM	NNP
38430	267	4	AND	and	CC
38430	267	5	MEANING	MEANING	NNP
38430	267	6	When	when	WRB
38430	267	7	people	people	NNS
38430	267	8	write	write	VBP
38430	267	9	down	down	RP
38430	267	10	any	any	DT
38430	267	11	statement	statement	NN
38430	267	12	such	such	JJ
38430	267	13	as	as	IN
38430	267	14	"	"	``
38430	267	15	The	the	DT
38430	267	16	curfew	curfew	NN
38430	267	17	tolls	toll	VBZ
38430	267	18	the	the	DT
38430	267	19	knell	knell	NN
38430	267	20	of	of	IN
38430	267	21	parting	part	VBG
38430	267	22	day,"[26	day,"[26	UH
38430	267	23	]	]	-RRB-
38430	267	24	which	which	WDT
38430	267	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	267	26	will	will	MD
38430	267	27	call	call	VB
38430	267	28	"	"	``
38430	267	29	C	c	NN
38430	267	30	"	"	''
38430	267	31	for	for	IN
38430	267	32	shortness	shortness	JJ
38430	267	33	,	,	,
38430	267	34	what	what	WP
38430	267	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	267	36	mean	mean	VBP
38430	267	37	is	be	VBZ
38430	267	38	not	not	RB
38430	267	39	"	"	``
38430	267	40	C	c	NN
38430	267	41	"	"	''
38430	267	42	but	but	CC
38430	267	43	the	the	DT
38430	267	44	_	_	NNP
38430	267	45	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	267	46	_	_	NNP
38430	267	47	of	of	IN
38430	267	48	"	"	``
38430	267	49	C	C	NNP
38430	267	50	"	"	''
38430	267	51	;	;	:
38430	267	52	and	and	CC
38430	267	53	not	not	RB
38430	267	54	"	"	``
38430	267	55	the	the	DT
38430	267	56	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	267	57	of	of	IN
38430	267	58	'	'	``
38430	267	59	C	C	NNP
38430	267	60	'	'	''
38430	267	61	"	"	''
38430	267	62	but	but	CC
38430	267	63	the	the	DT
38430	267	64	_	_	NNP
38430	267	65	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	267	66	_	_	NNP
38430	267	67	of	of	IN
38430	267	68	"	"	``
38430	267	69	the	the	DT
38430	267	70	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	267	71	of	of	IN
38430	267	72	'	'	``
38430	267	73	C	C	NNP
38430	267	74	'	'	''
38430	267	75	.	.	.
38430	267	76	"	"	''
38430	268	1	And	and	CC
38430	268	2	so	so	RB
38430	268	3	on	on	RB
38430	268	4	,	,	,
38430	268	5	_	_	NNP
38430	268	6	ad	ad	NN
38430	268	7	infinitum	infinitum	IN
38430	268	8	_	_	NNP
38430	268	9	.	.	.
38430	269	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	269	2	,	,	,
38430	269	3	in	in	IN
38430	269	4	writing	writing	NN
38430	269	5	or	or	CC
38430	269	6	in	in	IN
38430	269	7	speech	speech	NN
38430	269	8	,	,	,
38430	269	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	269	10	always	always	RB
38430	269	11	fail	fail	VBP
38430	269	12	to	to	TO
38430	269	13	state	state	VB
38430	269	14	the	the	DT
38430	269	15	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	269	16	of	of	IN
38430	269	17	any	any	DT
38430	269	18	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	269	19	whatever	whatever	WDT
38430	269	20	.	.	.
38430	270	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	270	2	,	,	,
38430	270	3	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	270	4	,	,	,
38430	270	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	270	6	succeed	succeed	VBP
38430	270	7	in	in	IN
38430	270	8	_	_	NNP
38430	270	9	conveying	convey	VBG
38430	270	10	_	_	IN
38430	270	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	270	12	;	;	:
38430	270	13	but	but	CC
38430	270	14	there	there	EX
38430	270	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	270	16	danger	danger	NN
38430	270	17	in	in	IN
38430	270	18	too	too	RB
38430	270	19	great	great	JJ
38430	270	20	a	a	DT
38430	270	21	disregard	disregard	NN
38430	270	22	of	of	IN
38430	270	23	statement	statement	NN
38430	270	24	and	and	CC
38430	270	25	preoccupation	preoccupation	NN
38430	270	26	with	with	IN
38430	270	27	conveyance	conveyance	NN
38430	270	28	of	of	IN
38430	270	29	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	270	30	.	.	.
38430	271	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	271	2	many	many	JJ
38430	271	3	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	271	4	have	have	VBP
38430	271	5	been	be	VBN
38430	271	6	so	so	RB
38430	271	7	anxious	anxious	JJ
38430	271	8	to	to	TO
38430	271	9	convey	convey	VB
38430	271	10	to	to	IN
38430	271	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	12	a	a	DT
38430	271	13	perfectly	perfectly	RB
38430	271	14	distinct	distinct	JJ
38430	271	15	and	and	CC
38430	271	16	unmetaphysical	unmetaphysical	JJ
38430	271	17	concept	concept	NN
38430	271	18	of	of	IN
38430	271	19	number	number	NN
38430	271	20	that	that	WDT
38430	271	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	22	have	have	VBP
38430	271	23	stripped	strip	VBN
38430	271	24	away	away	RB
38430	271	25	from	from	IN
38430	271	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	27	everything	everything	NN
38430	271	28	that	that	WDT
38430	271	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	30	considered	consider	VBD
38430	271	31	unessential	unessential	RB
38430	271	32	(	(	-LRB-
38430	271	33	like	like	IN
38430	271	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	271	35	logical	logical	JJ
38430	271	36	nature	nature	NN
38430	271	37	)	)	-RRB-
38430	271	38	and	and	CC
38430	271	39	have	have	VBP
38430	271	40	finally	finally	RB
38430	271	41	delivered	deliver	VBN
38430	271	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	43	to	to	IN
38430	271	44	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	271	45	as	as	IN
38430	271	46	a	a	DT
38430	271	47	mere	mere	JJ
38430	271	48	_	_	NNP
38430	271	49	sign	sign	NN
38430	271	50	_	_	NNP
38430	271	51	.	.	.
38430	272	1	By	by	IN
38430	272	2	the	the	DT
38430	272	3	labours	labour	NNS
38430	272	4	of	of	IN
38430	272	5	Helmholtz	Helmholtz	NNP
38430	272	6	,	,	,
38430	272	7	Kronecker	Kronecker	NNP
38430	272	8	,	,	,
38430	272	9	Heine	Heine	NNP
38430	272	10	,	,	,
38430	272	11	Stolz	Stolz	NNP
38430	272	12	,	,	,
38430	272	13	Thomae	Thomae	NNP
38430	272	14	,	,	,
38430	272	15	Pringsheim	Pringsheim	NNP
38430	272	16	,	,	,
38430	272	17	and	and	CC
38430	272	18	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
38430	272	19	,	,	,
38430	272	20	many	many	JJ
38430	272	21	people	people	NNS
38430	272	22	were	be	VBD
38430	272	23	persuaded	persuade	VBN
38430	272	24	that	that	IN
38430	272	25	,	,	,
38430	272	26	when	when	WRB
38430	272	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	272	28	said	say	VBD
38430	272	29	"	"	``
38430	272	30	'	'	``
38430	272	31	2	2	CD
38430	272	32	'	'	''
38430	272	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	272	34	a	a	DT
38430	272	35	number	number	NN
38430	272	36	"	"	``
38430	272	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	272	38	were	be	VBD
38430	272	39	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	272	40	the	the	DT
38430	272	41	truth	truth	NN
38430	272	42	,	,	,
38430	272	43	and	and	CC
38430	272	44	hold	hold	VB
38430	272	45	that	that	IN
38430	272	46	"	"	``
38430	272	47	Paris	Paris	NNP
38430	272	48	"	"	''
38430	272	49	is	be	VBZ
38430	272	50	a	a	DT
38430	272	51	town	town	NN
38430	272	52	containing	contain	VBG
38430	272	53	the	the	DT
38430	272	54	letter	letter	NN
38430	272	55	"	"	``
38430	272	56	P.	P.	NNP
38430	272	57	"	"	''
38430	272	58	When	when	WRB
38430	272	59	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	272	60	pointed	point	VBD
38430	272	61	out[27	out[27	JJ
38430	272	62	]	]	-RRB-
38430	272	63	this	this	DT
38430	272	64	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	272	65	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	272	66	was	be	VBD
38430	272	67	almost	almost	RB
38430	272	68	universally	universally	RB
38430	272	69	denounced	denounce	VBN
38430	272	70	in	in	IN
38430	272	71	Germany	Germany	NNP
38430	272	72	as	as	IN
38430	272	73	"	"	``
38430	272	74	_	_	NNP
38430	272	75	spitzfindig	spitzfindig	NN
38430	272	76	_	_	NNP
38430	272	77	.	.	.
38430	272	78	"	"	''
38430	273	1	In	in	IN
38430	273	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	273	3	,	,	,
38430	273	4	Germans	Germans	NNPS
38430	273	5	seem	seem	VBP
38430	273	6	to	to	TO
38430	273	7	have	have	VB
38430	273	8	been	be	VBN
38430	273	9	influenced	influence	VBN
38430	273	10	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	273	11	by	by	IN
38430	273	12	that	that	DT
38430	273	13	great	great	JJ
38430	273	14	contemner	contemner	NN
38430	273	15	of	of	IN
38430	273	16	"	"	``
38430	273	17	_	_	NNP
38430	273	18	Spitzfindigkeit	Spitzfindigkeit	NNP
38430	273	19	_	_	NNP
38430	273	20	,	,	,
38430	273	21	"	"	``
38430	273	22	Kant	Kant	NNP
38430	273	23	,	,	,
38430	273	24	to	to	TO
38430	273	25	reject	reject	VB
38430	273	26	the	the	DT
38430	273	27	White	White	NNP
38430	273	28	Knight's[28	Knight's[28	NNP
38430	273	29	]	]	-RRB-
38430	273	30	distinctions	distinction	NNS
38430	273	31	between	between	IN
38430	273	32	words	word	NNS
38430	273	33	and	and	CC
38430	273	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	273	35	denotations	denotation	NNS
38430	273	36	and	and	CC
38430	273	37	to	to	TO
38430	273	38	regard	regard	VB
38430	273	39	subtlety	subtlety	NN
38430	273	40	with	with	IN
38430	273	41	disfavour	disfavour	NN
38430	273	42	to	to	IN
38430	273	43	such	such	PDT
38430	273	44	a	a	DT
38430	273	45	degree	degree	NN
38430	273	46	that	that	IN
38430	273	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	273	48	only	only	JJ
38430	273	49	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	273	50	logician	logician	NN
38430	273	51	except	except	IN
38430	273	52	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	273	53	,	,	,
38430	273	54	namely	namely	RB
38430	273	55	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	273	56	--	--	:
38430	273	57	the	the	DT
38430	273	58	least	least	JJS
38430	273	59	subtle	subtle	JJ
38430	273	60	of	of	IN
38430	273	61	mortals	mortal	NNS
38430	273	62	,	,	,
38430	273	63	by	by	IN
38430	273	64	the	the	DT
38430	273	65	way	way	NN
38430	273	66	--	--	:
38430	273	67	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	273	68	to	to	TO
38430	273	69	have	have	VB
38430	273	70	been	be	VBN
38430	273	71	filled	fill	VBN
38430	273	72	with	with	IN
38430	273	73	such	such	JJ
38430	273	74	fear	fear	NN
38430	273	75	of	of	IN
38430	273	76	being	be	VBG
38430	273	77	thought	think	VBN
38430	273	78	subtle	subtle	NN
38430	273	79	,	,	,
38430	273	80	that	that	IN
38430	273	81	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	273	82	made	make	VBD
38430	273	83	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	273	84	books	book	NNS
38430	273	85	so	so	RB
38430	273	86	prolix	prolix	JJ
38430	273	87	that	that	IN
38430	273	88	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	273	89	has	have	VBZ
38430	273	90	read	read	VBN
38430	273	91	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	273	92	.	.	.
38430	274	1	Another	another	DT
38430	274	2	term	term	NN
38430	274	3	which	which	WDT
38430	274	4	,	,	,
38430	274	5	as	as	IN
38430	274	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	274	7	shall	shall	MD
38430	274	8	see	see	VB
38430	274	9	when	when	WRB
38430	274	10	discussing	discuss	VBG
38430	274	11	the	the	DT
38430	274	12	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	274	13	of	of	IN
38430	274	14	logic	logic	NN
38430	274	15	,	,	,
38430	274	16	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	274	17	are	be	VBP
38430	274	18	accustomed	accustom	VBN
38430	274	19	to	to	TO
38430	274	20	apply	apply	VB
38430	274	21	to	to	IN
38430	274	22	thought	thought	NN
38430	274	23	which	which	WDT
38430	274	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	274	25	more	more	RBR
38430	274	26	exact	exact	JJ
38430	274	27	than	than	IN
38430	274	28	any	any	DT
38430	274	29	to	to	IN
38430	274	30	which	which	WDT
38430	274	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	274	32	are	be	VBP
38430	274	33	accustomed	accustomed	JJ
38430	274	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	274	35	"	"	``
38430	274	36	scholastic	scholastic	JJ
38430	274	37	.	.	.
38430	275	1	"	"	``
38430	275	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	275	3	29	29	CD
38430	275	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	275	5	By	by	IN
38430	275	6	this	this	DT
38430	275	7	,	,	,
38430	275	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	275	9	suppose	suppose	VBP
38430	275	10	,	,	,
38430	275	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	275	12	mean	mean	VBP
38430	275	13	that	that	IN
38430	275	14	the	the	DT
38430	275	15	pursuits	pursuit	NNS
38430	275	16	of	of	IN
38430	275	17	certain	certain	JJ
38430	275	18	acute	acute	JJ
38430	275	19	people	people	NNS
38430	275	20	of	of	IN
38430	275	21	the	the	DT
38430	275	22	Middle	Middle	NNP
38430	275	23	Ages	Ages	NNPS
38430	275	24	are	be	VBP
38430	275	25	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
38430	275	26	in	in	IN
38430	275	27	contrast	contrast	NN
38430	275	28	with	with	IN
38430	275	29	the	the	DT
38430	275	30	great	great	JJ
38430	275	31	achievements	achievement	NNS
38430	275	32	of	of	IN
38430	275	33	modern	modern	JJ
38430	275	34	thought	thought	NN
38430	275	35	,	,	,
38430	275	36	as	as	IN
38430	275	37	exemplified	exemplify	VBN
38430	275	38	by	by	IN
38430	275	39	a	a	DT
38430	275	40	method	method	NN
38430	275	41	of	of	IN
38430	275	42	making	make	VBG
38430	275	43	plausible	plausible	JJ
38430	275	44	guesses	guess	NNS
38430	275	45	known	know	VBN
38430	275	46	as	as	IN
38430	275	47	induction,[30	induction,[30	LS
38430	275	48	]	]	-RRB-
38430	275	49	the	the	DT
38430	275	50	bicycle	bicycle	NN
38430	275	51	,	,	,
38430	275	52	and	and	CC
38430	275	53	the	the	DT
38430	275	54	gramophone	gramophone	NN
38430	275	55	--	--	:
38430	275	56	all	all	DT
38430	275	57	of	of	IN
38430	275	58	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	275	59	instruments	instrument	NNS
38430	275	60	of	of	IN
38430	275	61	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	275	62	merit	merit	NN
38430	275	63	.	.	.
38430	276	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	276	2	:	:	:
38430	276	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	276	4	26	26	CD
38430	276	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	276	6	Cf	cf	NN
38430	276	7	.	.	.
38430	277	1	_	_	NNP
38430	277	2	Md	Md	NNP
38430	277	3	_	_	NNP
38430	277	4	,	,	,
38430	277	5	N.	N.	NNP
38430	277	6	S.	S.	NNP
38430	277	7	,	,	,
38430	277	8	vol	vol	NNP
38430	277	9	.	.	.
38430	278	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	278	2	.	.	NNP
38430	278	3	,	,	,
38430	278	4	October	October	NNP
38430	278	5	1905	1905	CD
38430	278	6	,	,	,
38430	278	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	278	8	486	486	CD
38430	278	9	.	.	.
38430	279	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	279	2	27	27	CD
38430	279	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	279	4	In	in	IN
38430	279	5	_	_	NNP
38430	279	6	Z.	Z.	NNP
38430	280	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	280	2	_	_	NNP
38430	280	3	,	,	,
38430	280	4	for	for	IN
38430	280	5	example	example	NN
38430	280	6	.	.	.
38430	281	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	281	2	28	28	CD
38430	281	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	281	4	See	see	VB
38430	281	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	281	6	G.	G.	NNP
38430	281	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	281	8	29	29	CD
38430	281	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	281	10	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	281	11	.	.	.
38430	282	1	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	282	2	XXXVII	xxxvii	NN
38430	282	3	below	below	RB
38430	282	4	.	.	.
38430	283	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	283	2	30	30	CD
38430	283	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	283	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	283	5	.	.	.
38430	284	1	_	_	NNP
38430	284	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	285	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	285	2	_	_	NNP
38430	285	3	,	,	,
38430	285	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	285	5	11	11	CD
38430	285	6	,	,	,
38430	285	7	note	note	VBP
38430	285	8	.	.	.
38430	286	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	286	2	VIII	viii	NN
38430	286	3	NOMINALISM	NOMINALISM	NNP
38430	286	4	De	De	NNP
38430	286	5	Morgan[31	Morgan[31	NNP
38430	286	6	]	]	-RRB-
38430	286	7	said	say	VBD
38430	286	8	that	that	IN
38430	286	9	,	,	,
38430	286	10	"	"	``
38430	286	11	if	if	IN
38430	286	12	all	all	DT
38430	286	13	mankind	mankind	NN
38430	286	14	had	have	VBD
38430	286	15	spoken	speak	VBN
38430	286	16	one	one	CD
38430	286	17	language	language	NN
38430	286	18	,	,	,
38430	286	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	286	20	can	can	MD
38430	286	21	not	not	RB
38430	286	22	doubt	doubt	VB
38430	286	23	that	that	IN
38430	286	24	there	there	EX
38430	286	25	would	would	MD
38430	286	26	have	have	VB
38430	286	27	been	be	VBN
38430	286	28	a	a	DT
38430	286	29	powerful	powerful	JJ
38430	286	30	,	,	,
38430	286	31	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	286	32	universal	universal	JJ
38430	286	33	,	,	,
38430	286	34	school	school	NN
38430	286	35	of	of	IN
38430	286	36	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
38430	286	37	who	who	WP
38430	286	38	would	would	MD
38430	286	39	have	have	VB
38430	286	40	believed	believe	VBN
38430	286	41	in	in	IN
38430	286	42	the	the	DT
38430	286	43	inherent	inherent	JJ
38430	286	44	connexion	connexion	NN
38430	286	45	between	between	IN
38430	286	46	names	name	NNS
38430	286	47	and	and	CC
38430	286	48	things	thing	NNS
38430	286	49	;	;	:
38430	286	50	who	who	WP
38430	286	51	would	would	MD
38430	286	52	have	have	VB
38430	286	53	taken	take	VBN
38430	286	54	the	the	DT
38430	286	55	sound	sound	NN
38430	286	56	_	_	NNP
38430	286	57	man	man	NN
38430	286	58	_	_	NNP
38430	286	59	to	to	TO
38430	286	60	be	be	VB
38430	286	61	the	the	DT
38430	286	62	mode	mode	NN
38430	286	63	of	of	IN
38430	286	64	agitating	agitate	VBG
38430	286	65	the	the	DT
38430	286	66	air	air	NN
38430	286	67	which	which	WDT
38430	286	68	is	be	VBZ
38430	286	69	essentially	essentially	RB
38430	286	70	communicative	communicative	JJ
38430	286	71	of	of	IN
38430	286	72	the	the	DT
38430	286	73	ideas	idea	NNS
38430	286	74	of	of	IN
38430	286	75	reason	reason	NN
38430	286	76	,	,	,
38430	286	77	cookery	cookery	NN
38430	286	78	,	,	,
38430	286	79	bipedality	bipedality	NN
38430	286	80	,	,	,
38430	286	81	etc	etc	FW
38430	286	82	....	....	NFP
38430	286	83	'	'	''
38430	286	84	The	the	DT
38430	286	85	French	French	NNP
38430	286	86	,	,	,
38430	286	87	'	'	''
38430	286	88	said	say	VBD
38430	286	89	the	the	DT
38430	286	90	sailor	sailor	NN
38430	286	91	,	,	,
38430	286	92	'	'	''
38430	286	93	call	call	VB
38430	286	94	a	a	DT
38430	286	95	cabbage	cabbage	NN
38430	286	96	a	a	DT
38430	286	97	_	_	NNP
38430	286	98	shoe	shoe	NN
38430	286	99	_	_	NNP
38430	286	100	;	;	:
38430	286	101	the	the	DT
38430	286	102	fools	fool	NNS
38430	286	103	!	!	.
38430	287	1	Why	why	WRB
38430	287	2	ca	can	MD
38430	287	3	n't	not	RB
38430	287	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	287	5	call	call	VB
38430	287	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	287	7	a	a	DT
38430	287	8	cabbage	cabbage	NN
38430	287	9	,	,	,
38430	287	10	when	when	WRB
38430	287	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	287	12	must	must	MD
38430	287	13	know	know	VB
38430	287	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	287	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	287	16	one	one	CD
38430	287	17	?	?	.
38430	287	18	'	'	''
38430	287	19	"	"	''
38430	288	1	One	one	CD
38430	288	2	of	of	IN
38430	288	3	the	the	DT
38430	288	4	chief	chief	JJ
38430	288	5	differences	difference	NNS
38430	288	6	between	between	IN
38430	288	7	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	288	8	and	and	CC
38430	288	9	men	man	NNS
38430	288	10	of	of	IN
38430	288	11	letters	letter	NNS
38430	288	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	288	13	that	that	IN
38430	288	14	the	the	DT
38430	288	15	latter	latter	JJ
38430	288	16	mean	mean	VBP
38430	288	17	many	many	JJ
38430	288	18	different	different	JJ
38430	288	19	things	thing	NNS
38430	288	20	by	by	IN
38430	288	21	one	one	CD
38430	288	22	word	word	NN
38430	288	23	,	,	,
38430	288	24	whereas	whereas	IN
38430	288	25	the	the	DT
38430	288	26	former	former	JJ
38430	288	27	do	do	VBP
38430	288	28	not	not	RB
38430	288	29	--	--	:
38430	288	30	at	at	IN
38430	288	31	least	least	JJS
38430	288	32	nowadays	nowadays	RB
38430	288	33	.	.	.
38430	289	1	Most	Most	JJS
38430	289	2	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	289	3	belong	belong	VBP
38430	289	4	to	to	IN
38430	289	5	the	the	DT
38430	289	6	class	class	NN
38430	289	7	of	of	IN
38430	289	8	men	man	NNS
38430	289	9	of	of	IN
38430	289	10	letters	letter	NNS
38430	289	11	.	.	.
38430	290	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	290	2	once	once	RB
38430	290	3	had	have	VBD
38430	290	4	a	a	DT
38430	290	5	manservant	manservant	NN
38430	290	6	who	who	WP
38430	290	7	told	tell	VBD
38430	290	8	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	290	9	on	on	IN
38430	290	10	a	a	DT
38430	290	11	certain	certain	JJ
38430	290	12	occasion	occasion	NN
38430	290	13	that	that	IN
38430	290	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	290	15	"	"	``
38430	290	16	never	never	RB
38430	290	17	thought	think	VBD
38430	290	18	a	a	DT
38430	290	19	word	word	NN
38430	290	20	about	about	IN
38430	290	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	290	22	.	.	.
38430	290	23	"	"	''
38430	291	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	291	2	was	be	VBD
38430	291	3	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	291	4	whether	whether	IN
38430	291	5	to	to	TO
38430	291	6	class	class	VB
38430	291	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	291	8	with	with	IN
38430	291	9	such	such	JJ
38430	291	10	eminent	eminent	JJ
38430	291	11	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	291	12	as	as	IN
38430	291	13	are	be	VBP
38430	291	14	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	291	15	in	in	IN
38430	291	16	the	the	DT
38430	291	17	last	last	JJ
38430	291	18	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	291	19	,	,	,
38430	291	20	or	or	CC
38430	291	21	as	as	IN
38430	291	22	a	a	DT
38430	291	23	supporter	supporter	NN
38430	291	24	of	of	IN
38430	291	25	Max	Max	NNP
38430	291	26	Müller	Müller	NNP
38430	291	27	's	's	POS
38430	291	28	theory	theory	NN
38430	291	29	of	of	IN
38430	291	30	the	the	DT
38430	291	31	identity	identity	NN
38430	291	32	of	of	IN
38430	291	33	thought	thought	NN
38430	291	34	and	and	CC
38430	291	35	language	language	NN
38430	291	36	.	.	.
38430	292	1	However	however	RB
38430	292	2	,	,	,
38430	292	3	since	since	IN
38430	292	4	the	the	DT
38430	292	5	man	man	NN
38430	292	6	was	be	VBD
38430	292	7	very	very	RB
38430	292	8	untruthful	untruthful	JJ
38430	292	9	,	,	,
38430	292	10	and	and	CC
38430	292	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	12	told	tell	VBD
38430	292	13	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	14	that	that	IN
38430	292	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	16	meant	mean	VBD
38430	292	17	what	what	WP
38430	292	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	19	said	say	VBD
38430	292	20	and	and	CC
38430	292	21	said	say	VBD
38430	292	22	what	what	WP
38430	292	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	24	meant,[32	meant,[32	CD
38430	292	25	]	]	-RRB-
38430	292	26	the	the	DT
38430	292	27	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	292	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	292	29	probably	probably	RB
38430	292	30	correct	correct	JJ
38430	292	31	that	that	IN
38430	292	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	33	really	really	RB
38430	292	34	believed	believe	VBD
38430	292	35	that	that	IN
38430	292	36	the	the	DT
38430	292	37	meanings	meaning	NNS
38430	292	38	of	of	IN
38430	292	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	292	40	words	word	NNS
38430	292	41	were	be	VBD
38430	292	42	not	not	RB
38430	292	43	the	the	DT
38430	292	44	words	word	NNS
38430	292	45	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	292	46	.	.	.
38430	293	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	293	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	293	3	think	think	VBP
38430	293	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	293	5	most	most	RBS
38430	293	6	probable	probable	JJ
38430	293	7	that	that	IN
38430	293	8	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	293	9	manservant	manservant	NN
38430	293	10	had	have	VBD
38430	293	11	been	be	VBN
38430	293	12	a	a	DT
38430	293	13	mathematician	mathematician	NN
38430	293	14	but	but	CC
38430	293	15	had	have	VBD
38430	293	16	escaped	escape	VBN
38430	293	17	by	by	IN
38430	293	18	the	the	DT
38430	293	19	aid	aid	NN
38430	293	20	of	of	IN
38430	293	21	logic	logic	NN
38430	293	22	.	.	.
38430	294	1	As	as	IN
38430	294	2	regards	regard	VBZ
38430	294	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	294	4	remark	remark	NN
38430	294	5	that	that	IN
38430	294	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	7	meant	mean	VBD
38430	294	8	what	what	WP
38430	294	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	10	said	say	VBD
38430	294	11	and	and	CC
38430	294	12	said	say	VBD
38430	294	13	what	what	WP
38430	294	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	15	meant	mean	VBD
38430	294	16	,	,	,
38430	294	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	18	plainly	plainly	RB
38430	294	19	wished	wish	VBD
38430	294	20	to	to	TO
38430	294	21	pride	pride	VB
38430	294	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	23	on	on	IN
38430	294	24	certain	certain	JJ
38430	294	25	virtues	virtue	NNS
38430	294	26	which	which	WDT
38430	294	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	294	28	did	do	VBD
38430	294	29	not	not	RB
38430	294	30	possess	possess	VB
38430	294	31	,	,	,
38430	294	32	and	and	CC
38430	294	33	was	be	VBD
38430	294	34	not	not	RB
38430	294	35	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
38430	294	36	to	to	TO
38430	294	37	applause	applause	VB
38430	294	38	,	,	,
38430	294	39	which	which	WDT
38430	294	40	,	,	,
38430	294	41	however	however	RB
38430	294	42	,	,	,
38430	294	43	was	be	VBD
38430	294	44	never	never	RB
38430	294	45	evoked	evoke	VBN
38430	294	46	.	.	.
38430	295	1	The	the	DT
38430	295	2	virtues	virtue	NNS
38430	295	3	,	,	,
38430	295	4	if	if	IN
38430	295	5	so	so	RB
38430	295	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	295	7	be	be	VBP
38430	295	8	,	,	,
38430	295	9	and	and	CC
38430	295	10	the	the	DT
38430	295	11	applause	applause	NN
38430	295	12	were	be	VBD
38430	295	13	withheld	withhold	VBN
38430	295	14	for	for	IN
38430	295	15	other	other	JJ
38430	295	16	reasons	reason	NNS
38430	295	17	than	than	IN
38430	295	18	that	that	IN
38430	295	19	the	the	DT
38430	295	20	above	above	JJ
38430	295	21	statements	statement	NNS
38430	295	22	are	be	VBP
38430	295	23	either	either	CC
38430	295	24	nonsensical	nonsensical	JJ
38430	295	25	or	or	CC
38430	295	26	false	false	JJ
38430	295	27	.	.	.
38430	296	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
38430	296	2	that	that	IN
38430	296	3	"	"	``
38430	296	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	296	5	say	say	VBP
38430	296	6	what	what	WP
38430	296	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	296	8	mean	mean	VBP
38430	296	9	"	"	``
38430	296	10	expresses	express	VBZ
38430	296	11	a	a	DT
38430	296	12	truth	truth	NN
38430	296	13	.	.	.
38430	297	1	What	what	WP
38430	297	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	297	3	say	say	VBP
38430	297	4	(	(	-LRB-
38430	297	5	or	or	CC
38430	297	6	write	write	VBP
38430	297	7	)	)	-RRB-
38430	297	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	297	9	always	always	RB
38430	297	10	a	a	DT
38430	297	11	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	297	12	--	--	:
38430	297	13	words	word	NNS
38430	297	14	(	(	-LRB-
38430	297	15	or	or	CC
38430	297	16	marks	mark	NNS
38430	297	17	)	)	-RRB-
38430	297	18	;	;	:
38430	297	19	and	and	CC
38430	297	20	what	what	WP
38430	297	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	297	22	mean	mean	VBP
38430	297	23	by	by	IN
38430	297	24	the	the	DT
38430	297	25	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	297	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	297	27	the	the	DT
38430	297	28	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	297	29	of	of	IN
38430	297	30	the	the	DT
38430	297	31	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	297	32	and	and	CC
38430	297	33	not	not	RB
38430	297	34	the	the	DT
38430	297	35	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	297	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	297	37	.	.	.
38430	298	1	So	so	IN
38430	298	2	the	the	DT
38430	298	3	remark	remark	NN
38430	298	4	can	can	MD
38430	298	5	not	not	RB
38430	298	6	express	express	VB
38430	298	7	a	a	DT
38430	298	8	truth	truth	NN
38430	298	9	,	,	,
38430	298	10	any	any	DT
38430	298	11	more	more	RBR
38430	298	12	than	than	IN
38430	298	13	the	the	DT
38430	298	14	name	name	NN
38430	298	15	"	"	``
38430	298	16	Wellington	Wellington	NNP
38430	298	17	"	"	''
38430	298	18	won	win	VBD
38430	298	19	the	the	DT
38430	298	20	battle	battle	NN
38430	298	21	of	of	IN
38430	298	22	Waterloo	Waterloo	NNP
38430	298	23	.	.	.
38430	299	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	299	2	:	:	:
38430	299	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	299	4	31	31	CD
38430	299	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	299	6	_	_	NNP
38430	299	7	F.	F.	NNP
38430	300	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	300	2	_	_	NNP
38430	300	3	,	,	,
38430	300	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	300	5	.	.	.
38430	301	1	246	246	CD
38430	301	2	-	-	SYM
38430	301	3	7	7	CD
38430	301	4	.	.	.
38430	302	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	302	2	32	32	CD
38430	302	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	302	4	The	the	DT
38430	302	5	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	302	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	302	7	see	see	VB
38430	302	8	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	302	9	H	H	NNP
38430	302	10	)	)	-RRB-
38430	302	11	pointed	point	VBD
38430	302	12	out	out	RP
38430	302	13	that	that	IN
38430	302	14	there	there	EX
38430	302	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	302	16	a	a	DT
38430	302	17	difference	difference	NN
38430	302	18	between	between	IN
38430	302	19	these	these	DT
38430	302	20	two	two	CD
38430	302	21	assertions	assertion	NNS
38430	302	22	.	.	.
38430	303	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	303	2	,	,	,
38430	303	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	303	4	clearly	clearly	RB
38430	303	5	showed	show	VBD
38430	303	6	that	that	IN
38430	303	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	303	8	was	be	VBD
38430	303	9	a	a	DT
38430	303	10	nominalist	nominalist	NN
38430	303	11	,	,	,
38430	303	12	and	and	CC
38430	303	13	philosophically	philosophically	RB
38430	303	14	opposed	oppose	VBN
38430	303	15	to	to	IN
38430	303	16	the	the	DT
38430	303	17	March	March	NNP
38430	303	18	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	303	19	who	who	WP
38430	303	20	had	have	VBD
38430	303	21	recommended	recommend	VBN
38430	303	22	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	303	23	to	to	TO
38430	303	24	say	say	VB
38430	303	25	what	what	WP
38430	303	26	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	303	27	meant	mean	VBD
38430	303	28	.	.	.
38430	304	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	304	2	IX	IX	NNP
38430	304	3	AMBIGUITY	AMBIGUITY	NNS
38430	304	4	AND	and	CC
38430	304	5	SYMBOLIC	symbolic	NN
38430	304	6	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	304	7	The	the	DT
38430	304	8	universal	universal	JJ
38430	304	9	use	use	NN
38430	304	10	of	of	IN
38430	304	11	some	some	DT
38430	304	12	system	system	NN
38430	304	13	of	of	IN
38430	304	14	Symbolic	Symbolic	NNP
38430	304	15	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	304	16	would	would	MD
38430	304	17	not	not	RB
38430	304	18	only	only	RB
38430	304	19	enable	enable	VB
38430	304	20	everybody	everybody	NN
38430	304	21	easily	easily	RB
38430	304	22	to	to	TO
38430	304	23	deal	deal	VB
38430	304	24	with	with	IN
38430	304	25	exceedingly	exceedingly	RB
38430	304	26	complicated	complicated	JJ
38430	304	27	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	304	28	,	,	,
38430	304	29	but	but	CC
38430	304	30	would	would	MD
38430	304	31	prevent	prevent	VB
38430	304	32	ambiguous	ambiguous	JJ
38430	304	33	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	304	34	.	.	.
38430	305	1	In	in	IN
38430	305	2	denying	deny	VBG
38430	305	3	the	the	DT
38430	305	4	indispensability	indispensability	NN
38430	305	5	of	of	IN
38430	305	6	Symbolic	Symbolic	NNP
38430	305	7	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	305	8	in	in	IN
38430	305	9	the	the	DT
38430	305	10	former	former	JJ
38430	305	11	state	state	NN
38430	305	12	of	of	IN
38430	305	13	things	thing	NNS
38430	305	14	,	,	,
38430	305	15	Keynes[33	keynes[33	ADD
38430	305	16	]	]	-RRB-
38430	305	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	305	18	probably	probably	RB
38430	305	19	alone	alone	JJ
38430	305	20	,	,	,
38430	305	21	against	against	IN
38430	305	22	the	the	DT
38430	305	23	need	need	NN
38430	305	24	strongly	strongly	RB
38430	305	25	felt	feel	VBN
38430	305	26	by	by	IN
38430	305	27	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	305	28	when	when	WRB
38430	305	29	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	305	30	to	to	IN
38430	305	31	the	the	DT
38430	305	32	Duchess,[34	Duchess,[34	NNP
38430	305	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	305	34	and	and	CC
38430	305	35	most	most	JJS
38430	305	36	modern	modern	JJ
38430	305	37	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	305	38	.	.	.
38430	306	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	306	2	may	may	MD
38430	306	3	be	be	VB
38430	306	4	noticed	notice	VBN
38430	306	5	that	that	IN
38430	306	6	the	the	DT
38430	306	7	Duchess	Duchess	NNP
38430	306	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	306	9	more	more	RBR
38430	306	10	consistent	consistent	JJ
38430	306	11	than	than	IN
38430	306	12	Keynes	Keynes	NNP
38430	306	13	,	,	,
38430	306	14	for	for	IN
38430	306	15	Keynes	Keynes	NNP
38430	306	16	really	really	RB
38430	306	17	uses	use	VBZ
38430	306	18	the	the	DT
38430	306	19	signs	sign	NNS
38430	306	20	for	for	IN
38430	306	21	logical	logical	JJ
38430	306	22	multiplication	multiplication	NN
38430	306	23	and	and	CC
38430	306	24	addition	addition	NN
38430	306	25	of	of	IN
38430	306	26	Boole	Boole	NNP
38430	306	27	and	and	CC
38430	306	28	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	306	29	under	under	IN
38430	306	30	the	the	DT
38430	306	31	different	different	JJ
38430	306	32	shapes	shape	NNS
38430	306	33	of	of	IN
38430	306	34	the	the	DT
38430	306	35	words	word	NNS
38430	306	36	"	"	''
38430	306	37	and	and	CC
38430	306	38	"	"	``
38430	306	39	and	and	CC
38430	306	40	"	"	''
38430	306	41	or	or	CC
38430	306	42	.	.	.
38430	306	43	"	"	''
38430	307	1	As	as	IN
38430	307	2	regards	regard	VBZ
38430	307	3	ambiguity	ambiguity	NN
38430	307	4	,	,	,
38430	307	5	a	a	DT
38430	307	6	translation	translation	NN
38430	307	7	of	of	IN
38430	307	8	_	_	NNP
38430	307	9	Hymns	Hymns	NNP
38430	307	10	Ancient	Ancient	NNP
38430	307	11	and	and	CC
38430	307	12	Modern	Modern	NNP
38430	307	13	_	_	NNP
38430	307	14	into	into	IN
38430	307	15	,	,	,
38430	307	16	say	say	UH
38430	307	17	,	,	,
38430	307	18	Peanesque	Peanesque	NNP
38430	307	19	,	,	,
38430	307	20	would	would	MD
38430	307	21	prevent	prevent	VB
38430	307	22	the	the	DT
38430	307	23	puzzle	puzzle	NN
38430	307	24	of	of	IN
38430	307	25	childhood	childhood	NN
38430	307	26	as	as	IN
38430	307	27	to	to	IN
38430	307	28	whether	whether	IN
38430	307	29	the	the	DT
38430	307	30	"	"	``
38430	307	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	307	32	"	"	''
38430	307	33	in	in	IN
38430	307	34	And	and	CC
38430	307	35	Satan	Satan	NNP
38430	307	36	trembles	tremble	VBZ
38430	307	37	when	when	WRB
38430	307	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	307	39	sees	see	VBZ
38430	307	40	The	the	DT
38430	307	41	weakest	weak	JJS
38430	307	42	saint	saint	NN
38430	307	43	upon	upon	IN
38430	307	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	307	45	knees	knee	NNS
38430	307	46	refers	refer	VBZ
38430	307	47	to	to	IN
38430	307	48	the	the	DT
38430	307	49	saint	saint	NN
38430	307	50	's	's	POS
38430	307	51	knees	knee	NNS
38430	307	52	or	or	CC
38430	307	53	Satan	Satan	NNP
38430	307	54	's	's	POS
38430	307	55	.	.	.
38430	308	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	308	2	:	:	:
38430	308	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	308	4	33	33	CD
38430	308	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	308	6	In	in	IN
38430	308	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	308	8	_	_	NNP
38430	308	9	Fm	Fm	NNP
38430	308	10	.	.	.
38430	309	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	309	2	_	_	NNP
38430	309	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	309	4	34	34	CD
38430	309	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	309	6	See	see	VB
38430	309	7	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	309	8	I.	i.	NN
38430	310	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	310	2	X	X	NNP
38430	310	3	LOGICAL	LOGICAL	NNP
38430	310	4	ADDITION	addition	NN
38430	310	5	AND	and	CC
38430	310	6	THE	the	DT
38430	310	7	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
38430	310	8	OF	of	IN
38430	310	9	SYMBOLISM	SYMBOLISM	NNP
38430	310	10	Frequently	frequently	RB
38430	310	11	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	310	12	language	language	NN
38430	310	13	contains	contain	VBZ
38430	310	14	subtle	subtle	JJ
38430	310	15	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	310	16	implications	implication	NNS
38430	310	17	which	which	WDT
38430	310	18	can	can	MD
38430	310	19	not	not	RB
38430	310	20	be	be	VB
38430	310	21	translated	translate	VBN
38430	310	22	into	into	IN
38430	310	23	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
38430	310	24	logic	logic	NN
38430	310	25	except	except	IN
38430	310	26	at	at	IN
38430	310	27	great	great	JJ
38430	310	28	length	length	NN
38430	310	29	.	.	.
38430	311	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	311	2	if	if	IN
38430	311	3	a	a	DT
38430	311	4	man	man	NN
38430	311	5	(	(	-LRB-
38430	311	6	say	say	VB
38430	311	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	311	8	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	311	9	)	)	-RRB-
38430	311	10	wishes	wish	VBZ
38430	311	11	to	to	TO
38430	311	12	speak	speak	VB
38430	311	13	collectively	collectively	RB
38430	311	14	of	of	IN
38430	311	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	311	16	and	and	CC
38430	311	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	311	18	wife	wife	NN
38430	311	19	,	,	,
38430	311	20	the	the	DT
38430	311	21	order	order	NN
38430	311	22	of	of	IN
38430	311	23	mentioning	mention	VBG
38430	311	24	the	the	DT
38430	311	25	terms	term	NNS
38430	311	26	in	in	IN
38430	311	27	the	the	DT
38430	311	28	class	class	NN
38430	311	29	considered	consider	VBN
38430	311	30	and	and	CC
38430	311	31	the	the	DT
38430	311	32	names	name	NNS
38430	311	33	applied	apply	VBD
38430	311	34	to	to	IN
38430	311	35	these	these	DT
38430	311	36	terms	term	NNS
38430	311	37	are	be	VBP
38430	311	38	,	,	,
38430	311	39	logically	logically	RB
38430	311	40	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	311	41	,	,	,
38430	311	42	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
38430	311	43	.	.	.
38430	312	1	And	and	CC
38430	312	2	yet	yet	RB
38430	312	3	more	more	RBR
38430	312	4	or	or	CC
38430	312	5	less	less	RBR
38430	312	6	definite	definite	JJ
38430	312	7	information	information	NN
38430	312	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	312	9	given	give	VBN
38430	312	10	about	about	IN
38430	312	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	312	12	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	312	13	according	accord	VBG
38430	312	14	as	as	IN
38430	312	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	16	talks	talk	VBZ
38430	312	17	to	to	IN
38430	312	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	312	19	friends	friend	NNS
38430	312	20	of	of	IN
38430	312	21	:	:	:
38430	312	22	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	23	1	1	LS
38430	312	24	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	25	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	312	26	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	312	27	and	and	CC
38430	312	28	I	I	NNP
38430	312	29	,	,	,
38430	312	30	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	31	2	2	LS
38430	312	32	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	33	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	34	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	35	or	or	CC
38430	312	36	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	37	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	38	and	and	CC
38430	312	39	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	312	40	wife	wife	NN
38430	312	41	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	42	or	or	CC
38430	312	43	missus	missus	NNP
38430	312	44	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	45	,	,	,
38430	312	46	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	47	3	3	LS
38430	312	48	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	49	My	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	312	50	wife	wife	NN
38430	312	51	and	and	CC
38430	312	52	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	53	,	,	,
38430	312	54	or	or	CC
38430	312	55	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	56	4	4	LS
38430	312	57	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	58	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	59	(	(	-LRB-
38430	312	60	or	or	CC
38430	312	61	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	312	62	)	)	-RRB-
38430	312	63	and	and	CC
38430	312	64	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	312	65	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	312	66	.	.	.
38430	313	1	In	in	IN
38430	313	2	case	case	NN
38430	313	3	(	(	-LRB-
38430	313	4	1	1	CD
38430	313	5	)	)	-RRB-
38430	313	6	one	one	CD
38430	313	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	313	8	probably	probably	RB
38430	313	9	correct	correct	JJ
38430	313	10	in	in	IN
38430	313	11	placing	place	VBG
38430	313	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	313	13	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	313	14	among	among	IN
38430	313	15	the	the	DT
38430	313	16	clergy	clergy	NN
38430	313	17	or	or	CC
38430	313	18	the	the	DT
38430	313	19	small	small	JJ
38430	313	20	professional	professional	JJ
38430	313	21	men	man	NNS
38430	313	22	who	who	WP
38430	313	23	make	make	VBP
38430	313	24	up	up	RP
38430	313	25	the	the	DT
38430	313	26	bulk	bulk	NN
38430	313	27	of	of	IN
38430	313	28	the	the	DT
38430	313	29	middle	middle	JJ
38430	313	30	-	-	HYPH
38430	313	31	class	class	NN
38430	313	32	;	;	:
38430	313	33	in	in	IN
38430	313	34	case	case	NN
38430	313	35	(	(	-LRB-
38430	313	36	2	2	CD
38430	313	37	)	)	-RRB-
38430	313	38	one	one	PRP
38430	313	39	would	would	MD
38430	313	40	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	313	41	that	that	IN
38430	313	42	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	313	43	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	313	44	belonged	belong	VBD
38430	313	45	to	to	IN
38430	313	46	the	the	DT
38430	313	47	lower	low	JJR
38430	313	48	middle	middle	JJ
38430	313	49	-	-	HYPH
38430	313	50	class	class	NN
38430	313	51	;	;	:
38430	313	52	the	the	DT
38430	313	53	form	form	NN
38430	313	54	(	(	-LRB-
38430	313	55	3	3	CD
38430	313	56	)	)	-RRB-
38430	313	57	would	would	MD
38430	313	58	be	be	VB
38430	313	59	used	use	VBN
38430	313	60	by	by	IN
38430	313	61	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	313	62	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	313	63	if	if	IN
38430	313	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	313	65	were	be	VBD
38430	313	66	a	a	DT
38430	313	67	member	member	NN
38430	313	68	of	of	IN
38430	313	69	the	the	DT
38430	313	70	upper	upper	JJ
38430	313	71	,	,	,
38430	313	72	upper	upper	JJ
38430	313	73	middle	middle	NN
38430	313	74	,	,	,
38430	313	75	or	or	CC
38430	313	76	lower	low	JJR
38430	313	77	class	class	NN
38430	313	78	;	;	:
38430	313	79	while	while	IN
38430	313	80	form	form	NN
38430	313	81	(	(	-LRB-
38430	313	82	4	4	CD
38430	313	83	)	)	-RRB-
38430	313	84	is	be	VBZ
38430	313	85	only	only	RB
38430	313	86	used	use	VBN
38430	313	87	by	by	IN
38430	313	88	retired	retired	JJ
38430	313	89	shopkeepers	shopkeeper	NNS
38430	313	90	of	of	IN
38430	313	91	the	the	DT
38430	313	92	lower	low	JJR
38430	313	93	middle	middle	JJ
38430	313	94	-	-	HYPH
38430	313	95	class	class	NN
38430	313	96	,	,	,
38430	313	97	of	of	IN
38430	313	98	which	which	WDT
38430	313	99	a	a	DT
38430	313	100	male	male	JJ
38430	313	101	member	member	NN
38430	313	102	usually	usually	RB
38430	313	103	combines	combine	VBZ
38430	313	104	belief	belief	NN
38430	313	105	in	in	IN
38430	313	106	the	the	DT
38430	313	107	supremacy	supremacy	NN
38430	313	108	of	of	IN
38430	313	109	man	man	NN
38430	313	110	with	with	IN
38430	313	111	belief	belief	NN
38430	313	112	in	in	IN
38430	313	113	the	the	DT
38430	313	114	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	313	115	of	of	IN
38430	313	116	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	313	117	wife	wife	NN
38430	313	118	as	as	RB
38430	313	119	well	well	RB
38430	313	120	as	as	IN
38430	313	121	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	313	122	.	.	.
38430	314	1	A	a	DT
38430	314	2	further	further	JJ
38430	314	3	complication	complication	NN
38430	314	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	314	5	introduced	introduce	VBN
38430	314	6	if	if	IN
38430	314	7	a	a	DT
38430	314	8	wife	wife	NN
38430	314	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	314	10	referred	refer	VBN
38430	314	11	to	to	IN
38430	314	12	as	as	IN
38430	314	13	"	"	``
38430	314	14	the	the	DT
38430	314	15	wife	wife	NN
38430	314	16	.	.	.
38430	315	1	"	"	``
38430	315	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	315	3	35	35	CD
38430	315	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	315	5	Cases	case	NNS
38430	315	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	315	7	2	2	CD
38430	315	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	315	9	and	and	CC
38430	315	10	(	(	-LRB-
38430	315	11	3	3	LS
38430	315	12	)	)	-RRB-
38430	315	13	then	then	RB
38430	315	14	each	each	DT
38430	315	15	give	give	VBP
38430	315	16	rise	rise	NN
38430	315	17	to	to	IN
38430	315	18	one	one	CD
38430	315	19	more	more	JJR
38430	315	20	case	case	NN
38430	315	21	.	.	.
38430	316	1	Cases	case	NNS
38430	316	2	(	(	-LRB-
38430	316	3	1	1	CD
38430	316	4	)	)	-RRB-
38430	316	5	and	and	CC
38430	316	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	316	7	4	4	LS
38430	316	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	316	9	do	do	VBP
38430	316	10	not	not	RB
38430	316	11	,	,	,
38430	316	12	since	since	IN
38430	316	13	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	316	14	has	have	VBZ
38430	316	15	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
38430	316	16	referred	refer	VBN
38430	316	17	to	to	IN
38430	316	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	316	19	wife	wife	NN
38430	316	20	as	as	IN
38430	316	21	"	"	``
38430	316	22	the	the	DT
38430	316	23	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	316	24	Jones"--at	Jones"--at	NNP
38430	316	25	least	least	JJS
38430	316	26	without	without	IN
38430	316	27	a	a	DT
38430	316	28	qualifying	qualifying	NN
38430	316	29	adjective	adjective	NN
38430	316	30	before	before	IN
38430	316	31	the	the	DT
38430	316	32	"	"	``
38430	316	33	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	316	34	"	"	''
38430	316	35	On	on	IN
38430	316	36	the	the	DT
38430	316	37	other	other	JJ
38430	316	38	hand	hand	NN
38430	316	39	,	,	,
38430	316	40	certain	certain	JJ
38430	316	41	descriptive	descriptive	JJ
38430	316	42	phrases	phrase	NNS
38430	316	43	and	and	CC
38430	316	44	certain	certain	JJ
38430	316	45	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	316	46	can	can	MD
38430	316	47	be	be	VB
38430	316	48	expressed	express	VBN
38430	316	49	more	more	RBR
38430	316	50	shortly	shortly	RB
38430	316	51	and	and	CC
38430	316	52	more	more	RBR
38430	316	53	accurately	accurately	RB
38430	316	54	by	by	IN
38430	316	55	means	mean	NNS
38430	316	56	of	of	IN
38430	316	57	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
38430	316	58	logic	logic	NN
38430	316	59	.	.	.
38430	317	1	Let	let	VB
38430	317	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	317	3	consider	consider	VB
38430	317	4	the	the	DT
38430	317	5	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	317	6	"	"	``
38430	317	7	No	no	DT
38430	317	8	man	man	NN
38430	317	9	marries	marry	VBZ
38430	317	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	317	11	deceased	deceased	JJ
38430	317	12	wife	wife	NN
38430	317	13	's	's	POS
38430	317	14	sister	sister	NN
38430	317	15	.	.	.
38430	317	16	"	"	''
38430	318	1	If	if	IN
38430	318	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	318	3	assume	assume	VBP
38430	318	4	,	,	,
38430	318	5	as	as	IN
38430	318	6	a	a	DT
38430	318	7	first	first	JJ
38430	318	8	approximation	approximation	NN
38430	318	9	,	,	,
38430	318	10	that	that	IN
38430	318	11	all	all	DT
38430	318	12	marriages	marriage	NNS
38430	318	13	are	be	VBP
38430	318	14	fertile	fertile	JJ
38430	318	15	and	and	CC
38430	318	16	that	that	IN
38430	318	17	all	all	DT
38430	318	18	children	child	NNS
38430	318	19	are	be	VBP
38430	318	20	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	318	21	,	,	,
38430	318	22	then	then	RB
38430	318	23	,	,	,
38430	318	24	with	with	IN
38430	318	25	only	only	RB
38430	318	26	four	four	CD
38430	318	27	primitive	primitive	JJ
38430	318	28	ideas	idea	NNS
38430	318	29	:	:	:
38430	318	30	the	the	DT
38430	318	31	relation	relation	NN
38430	318	32	of	of	IN
38430	318	33	parent	parent	NN
38430	318	34	to	to	TO
38430	318	35	child	child	NN
38430	318	36	(	(	-LRB-
38430	318	37	P	p	NN
38430	318	38	)	)	-RRB-
38430	318	39	and	and	CC
38430	318	40	the	the	DT
38430	318	41	three	three	CD
38430	318	42	classes	class	NNS
38430	318	43	of	of	IN
38430	318	44	males	male	NNS
38430	318	45	,	,	,
38430	318	46	females	female	NNS
38430	318	47	,	,	,
38430	318	48	and	and	CC
38430	318	49	dead	dead	JJ
38430	318	50	people	people	NNS
38430	318	51	,	,	,
38430	318	52	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	318	53	can	can	MD
38430	318	54	define	define	VB
38430	318	55	"	"	``
38430	318	56	wife	wife	NN
38430	318	57	"	"	''
38430	318	58	(	(	-LRB-
38430	318	59	a	a	DT
38430	318	60	female	female	NN
38430	318	61	who	who	WP
38430	318	62	has	have	VBZ
38430	318	63	the	the	DT
38430	318	64	relation	relation	NN
38430	318	65	formed	form	VBN
38430	318	66	by	by	IN
38430	318	67	taking	take	VBG
38430	318	68	the	the	DT
38430	318	69	relative	relative	JJ
38430	318	70	product	product	NN
38430	318	71	of	of	IN
38430	318	72	P	p	NN
38430	318	73	and	and	CC
38430	318	74	[	[	-LRB-
38430	318	75	vP][36	vp][36	NN
38430	318	76	]	]	-RRB-
38430	318	77	to	to	IN
38430	318	78	a	a	DT
38430	318	79	male	male	NN
38430	318	80	)	)	-RRB-
38430	318	81	,	,	,
38430	318	82	"	"	''
38430	318	83	sister	sister	NN
38430	318	84	,	,	,
38430	318	85	"	"	''
38430	318	86	"	"	``
38430	318	87	deceased	deceased	JJ
38430	318	88	wife	wife	NN
38430	318	89	,	,	,
38430	318	90	"	"	''
38430	318	91	and	and	CC
38430	318	92	"	"	``
38430	318	93	deceased	deceased	JJ
38430	318	94	wife	wife	NN
38430	318	95	's	's	POS
38430	318	96	sister	sister	NN
38430	318	97	"	"	''
38430	318	98	in	in	IN
38430	318	99	terms	term	NNS
38430	318	100	of	of	IN
38430	318	101	these	these	DT
38430	318	102	ideas	idea	NNS
38430	318	103	and	and	CC
38430	318	104	of	of	IN
38430	318	105	the	the	DT
38430	318	106	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
38430	318	107	notions	notion	NNS
38430	318	108	of	of	IN
38430	318	109	logic	logic	NN
38430	318	110	.	.	.
38430	319	1	Then	then	RB
38430	319	2	the	the	DT
38430	319	3	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	319	4	"	"	``
38430	319	5	No	no	DT
38430	319	6	man	man	NN
38430	319	7	marries	marry	VBZ
38430	319	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	319	9	deceased	deceased	JJ
38430	319	10	wife	wife	NN
38430	319	11	's	's	POS
38430	319	12	sister	sister	NN
38430	319	13	"	"	''
38430	319	14	can	can	MD
38430	319	15	be	be	VB
38430	319	16	expressed	express	VBN
38430	319	17	unambiguously	unambiguously	RB
38430	319	18	by	by	IN
38430	319	19	about	about	RB
38430	319	20	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	319	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	319	22	nine	nine	CD
38430	319	23	simple	simple	JJ
38430	319	24	signs	sign	NNS
38430	319	25	on	on	IN
38430	319	26	paper	paper	NN
38430	319	27	,	,	,
38430	319	28	whereas	whereas	IN
38430	319	29	,	,	,
38430	319	30	in	in	IN
38430	319	31	words	word	NNS
38430	319	32	,	,	,
38430	319	33	the	the	DT
38430	319	34	unasserted	unasserted	JJ
38430	319	35	statement	statement	NN
38430	319	36	consists	consist	VBZ
38430	319	37	of	of	IN
38430	319	38	no	no	DT
38430	319	39	less	less	JJR
38430	319	40	than	than	IN
38430	319	41	thirty	thirty	CD
38430	319	42	-	-	HYPH
38430	319	43	four	four	CD
38430	319	44	letters	letter	NNS
38430	319	45	.	.	.
38430	320	1	Although	although	IN
38430	320	2	,	,	,
38430	320	3	legally	legally	RB
38430	320	4	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	320	5	,	,	,
38430	320	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	320	7	should	should	MD
38430	320	8	have	have	VB
38430	320	9	to	to	TO
38430	320	10	adopt	adopt	VB
38430	320	11	somewhat	somewhat	RB
38430	320	12	different	different	JJ
38430	320	13	definitions	definition	NNS
38430	320	14	and	and	CC
38430	320	15	possibly	possibly	RB
38430	320	16	increase	increase	VB
38430	320	17	the	the	DT
38430	320	18	complications	complication	NNS
38430	320	19	of	of	IN
38430	320	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	320	21	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	320	22	,	,	,
38430	320	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	320	24	must	must	MD
38430	320	25	be	be	VB
38430	320	26	remembered	remember	VBN
38430	320	27	that	that	IN
38430	320	28	,	,	,
38430	320	29	on	on	IN
38430	320	30	the	the	DT
38430	320	31	other	other	JJ
38430	320	32	hand	hand	NN
38430	320	33	,	,	,
38430	320	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	320	35	always	always	RB
38430	320	36	reduce	reduce	VBP
38430	320	37	the	the	DT
38430	320	38	number	number	NN
38430	320	39	of	of	IN
38430	320	40	symbols	symbol	NNS
38430	320	41	in	in	IN
38430	320	42	any	any	DT
38430	320	43	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	320	44	by	by	IN
38430	320	45	increasing	increase	VBG
38430	320	46	the	the	DT
38430	320	47	number	number	NN
38430	320	48	of	of	IN
38430	320	49	definitions	definition	NNS
38430	320	50	in	in	IN
38430	320	51	the	the	DT
38430	320	52	preliminaries	preliminary	NNS
38430	320	53	to	to	IN
38430	320	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	320	55	.	.	.
38430	321	1	But	but	CC
38430	321	2	the	the	DT
38430	321	3	utility	utility	NN
38430	321	4	of	of	IN
38430	321	5	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
38430	321	6	logic	logic	NN
38430	321	7	should	should	MD
38430	321	8	not	not	RB
38430	321	9	be	be	VB
38430	321	10	estimated	estimate	VBN
38430	321	11	by	by	IN
38430	321	12	the	the	DT
38430	321	13	brevity	brevity	NN
38430	321	14	with	with	IN
38430	321	15	which	which	WDT
38430	321	16	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	321	17	may	may	MD
38430	321	18	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	321	19	be	be	VB
38430	321	20	expressed	express	VBN
38430	321	21	by	by	IN
38430	321	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	321	23	means	mean	NNS
38430	321	24	.	.	.
38430	322	1	Logical	logical	JJ
38430	322	2	simplicity	simplicity	NN
38430	322	3	,	,	,
38430	322	4	in	in	IN
38430	322	5	fact	fact	NN
38430	322	6	,	,	,
38430	322	7	can	can	MD
38430	322	8	very	very	RB
38430	322	9	often	often	RB
38430	322	10	only	only	RB
38430	322	11	be	be	VB
38430	322	12	obtained	obtain	VBN
38430	322	13	by	by	IN
38430	322	14	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	322	15	complicated	complicated	JJ
38430	322	16	statements	statement	NNS
38430	322	17	.	.	.
38430	323	1	For	for	IN
38430	323	2	example	example	NN
38430	323	3	,	,	,
38430	323	4	the	the	DT
38430	323	5	logical	logical	JJ
38430	323	6	interpretation	interpretation	NN
38430	323	7	of	of	IN
38430	323	8	"	"	``
38430	323	9	The	the	DT
38430	323	10	father	father	NN
38430	323	11	of	of	IN
38430	323	12	Charles	Charles	NNP
38430	323	13	II	II	NNP
38430	323	14	was	be	VBD
38430	323	15	executed	execute	VBN
38430	323	16	"	"	``
38430	323	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	323	18	,	,	,
38430	323	19	"	"	``
38430	323	20	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	323	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	323	22	not	not	RB
38430	323	23	always	always	RB
38430	323	24	false	false	JJ
38430	323	25	of	of	IN
38430	323	26	_	_	NNP
38430	323	27	x	x	NNP
38430	323	28	_	_	NNP
38430	323	29	that	that	IN
38430	323	30	_	_	NNP
38430	323	31	x	x	NNP
38430	323	32	_	_	NNP
38430	323	33	begat	beget	VBZ
38430	323	34	Charles	Charles	NNP
38430	323	35	II	II	NNP
38430	323	36	,	,	,
38430	323	37	and	and	CC
38430	323	38	that	that	IN
38430	323	39	_	_	NNP
38430	323	40	x	x	SYM
38430	323	41	_	_	NNP
38430	323	42	was	be	VBD
38430	323	43	executed	execute	VBN
38430	323	44	and	and	CC
38430	323	45	that	that	IN
38430	323	46	'	'	''
38430	323	47	if	if	IN
38430	323	48	_	_	NNP
38430	323	49	y	y	NNP
38430	323	50	_	_	NNP
38430	323	51	begat	beget	VBZ
38430	323	52	Charles	Charles	NNP
38430	323	53	II	II	NNP
38430	323	54	,	,	,
38430	323	55	_	_	NNP
38430	323	56	y	y	NNP
38430	323	57	_	_	NNP
38430	323	58	is	be	VBZ
38430	323	59	identical	identical	JJ
38430	323	60	with	with	IN
38430	323	61	_	_	NNP
38430	323	62	x	x	NNP
38430	323	63	_	_	NNP
38430	323	64	'	'	''
38430	323	65	is	be	VBZ
38430	323	66	always	always	RB
38430	323	67	true	true	JJ
38430	323	68	of	of	IN
38430	323	69	_	_	NNP
38430	323	70	y	y	NNP
38430	323	71	_	_	NNP
38430	323	72	.	.	.
38430	324	1	"	"	``
38430	324	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	324	3	37	37	CD
38430	324	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	324	5	From	from	IN
38430	324	6	the	the	DT
38430	324	7	point	point	NN
38430	324	8	of	of	IN
38430	324	9	view	view	NN
38430	324	10	of	of	IN
38430	324	11	logic	logic	NN
38430	324	12	,	,	,
38430	324	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	324	14	may	may	MD
38430	324	15	say	say	VB
38430	324	16	that	that	IN
38430	324	17	the	the	DT
38430	324	18	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	324	19	simple	simple	NN
38430	324	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	324	21	most	most	RBS
38430	324	22	often	often	RB
38430	324	23	very	very	RB
38430	324	24	complicated	complicated	JJ
38430	324	25	,	,	,
38430	324	26	and	and	CC
38430	324	27	,	,	,
38430	324	28	even	even	RB
38430	324	29	if	if	IN
38430	324	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	324	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	324	32	not	not	RB
38430	324	33	so	so	RB
38430	324	34	,	,	,
38430	324	35	symbolism	symbolism	NN
38430	324	36	will	will	MD
38430	324	37	make	make	VB
38430	324	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	324	39	seem	seem	VB
38430	324	40	so,[38	so,[38	-LRB-
38430	324	41	]	]	-RRB-
38430	324	42	and	and	CC
38430	324	43	thus	thus	RB
38430	324	44	draw	draw	VB
38430	324	45	attention	attention	NN
38430	324	46	to	to	IN
38430	324	47	what	what	WP
38430	324	48	might	may	MD
38430	324	49	otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	324	50	easily	easily	RB
38430	324	51	be	be	VB
38430	324	52	overlooked	overlook	VBN
38430	324	53	.	.	.
38430	325	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	325	2	:	:	:
38430	325	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	325	4	35	35	CD
38430	325	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	325	6	Cf	cf	NN
38430	325	7	.	.	.
38430	326	1	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	326	2	XXIV	XXIV	NNP
38430	326	3	below	below	RB
38430	326	4	.	.	.
38430	327	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	327	2	36	36	CD
38430	327	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	327	4	C.	C.	NNP
38430	327	5	S.	S.	NNP
38430	327	6	Peirce	Peirce	NNP
38430	327	7	's	's	POS
38430	327	8	notation	notation	NN
38430	327	9	for	for	IN
38430	327	10	the	the	DT
38430	327	11	relation	relation	NN
38430	327	12	"	"	``
38430	327	13	converse	converse	NN
38430	327	14	of	of	IN
38430	327	15	P.	p.	NN
38430	327	16	"	"	''
38430	327	17	[	[	-LRB-
38430	327	18	37	37	CD
38430	327	19	]	]	-RRB-
38430	327	20	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	327	21	,	,	,
38430	327	22	_	_	NNP
38430	327	23	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	327	24	_	_	NNP
38430	327	25	,	,	,
38430	327	26	N.	N.	NNP
38430	327	27	S.	S.	NNP
38430	327	28	,	,	,
38430	327	29	vol	vol	NNP
38430	327	30	.	.	.
38430	328	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	328	2	.	.	NNP
38430	328	3	,	,	,
38430	328	4	October	October	NNP
38430	328	5	1905	1905	CD
38430	328	6	,	,	,
38430	328	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	328	8	482	482	CD
38430	328	9	.	.	.
38430	329	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	329	2	38	38	CD
38430	329	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	329	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	329	5	,	,	,
38430	329	6	_	_	NNP
38430	329	7	International	International	NNP
38430	329	8	Monthly	Monthly	NNP
38430	329	9	_	_	NNP
38430	329	10	,	,	,
38430	329	11	vol	vol	NNP
38430	329	12	.	.	.
38430	330	1	iv	iv	NNP
38430	330	2	.	.	NNP
38430	330	3	,	,	,
38430	330	4	1901	1901	CD
38430	330	5	,	,	,
38430	330	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	330	7	.	.	.
38430	331	1	85	85	CD
38430	331	2	-	-	SYM
38430	331	3	6	6	CD
38430	331	4	;	;	:
38430	331	5	cf	cf	NN
38430	331	6	.	.	.
38430	332	1	_	_	NNP
38430	332	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	332	3	_	_	NNP
38430	332	4	,	,	,
38430	332	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	332	6	.	.	.
38430	333	1	xxii	xxii	NNP
38430	333	2	.	.	NNP
38430	333	3	,	,	,
38430	333	4	1912	1912	CD
38430	333	5	,	,	,
38430	333	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	333	7	153	153	CD
38430	333	8	.	.	.
38430	334	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	334	2	This	this	DT
38430	334	3	essay	essay	NN
38430	334	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	334	5	reprinted	reprint	VBN
38430	334	6	in	in	IN
38430	334	7	_	_	NNP
38430	334	8	Mysticism	Mysticism	NNP
38430	334	9	and	and	CC
38430	334	10	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	334	11	_	_	NNP
38430	334	12	,	,	,
38430	334	13	London	London	NNP
38430	334	14	and	and	CC
38430	334	15	New	New	NNP
38430	334	16	York	York	NNP
38430	334	17	,	,	,
38430	334	18	1918	1918	CD
38430	334	19	,	,	,
38430	334	20	pp	pp	NNP
38430	334	21	.	.	.
38430	335	1	74	74	CD
38430	335	2	-	-	HYPH
38430	335	3	96.--ED	96.--ed	CD
38430	335	4	.	.	.
38430	335	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	336	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	336	2	XI	XI	NNP
38430	336	3	CRITICISM	criticism	XX
38430	336	4	Those	those	DT
38430	336	5	people	people	NNS
38430	336	6	who	who	WP
38430	336	7	think	think	VBP
38430	336	8	that	that	IN
38430	336	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	336	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	336	11	more	more	RBR
38430	336	12	godlike	godlike	JJ
38430	336	13	to	to	TO
38430	336	14	seem	seem	VB
38430	336	15	to	to	TO
38430	336	16	turn	turn	VB
38430	336	17	water	water	NN
38430	336	18	into	into	IN
38430	336	19	wine	wine	NN
38430	336	20	than	than	IN
38430	336	21	to	to	TO
38430	336	22	seem	seem	VB
38430	336	23	to	to	TO
38430	336	24	turn	turn	VB
38430	336	25	wine	wine	NN
38430	336	26	into	into	IN
38430	336	27	water	water	NN
38430	336	28	surprise	surprise	VB
38430	336	29	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	336	30	.	.	.
38430	337	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	337	2	can	can	MD
38430	337	3	not	not	RB
38430	337	4	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	337	5	an	an	DT
38430	337	6	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
38430	337	7	critic	critic	NN
38430	337	8	.	.	.
38430	338	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	338	2	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	338	3	to	to	IN
38430	338	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	338	5	that	that	DT
38430	338	6	,	,	,
38430	338	7	if	if	IN
38430	338	8	A	a	DT
38430	338	9	resents	resent	NNS
38430	338	10	B	B	NNP
38430	338	11	's	's	POS
38430	338	12	criticism	criticism	NN
38430	338	13	in	in	IN
38430	338	14	trying	try	VBG
38430	338	15	to	to	TO
38430	338	16	put	put	VB
38430	338	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	338	18	(	(	-LRB-
38430	338	19	A	A	NNP
38430	338	20	's	's	POS
38430	338	21	)	)	-RRB-
38430	338	22	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	338	23	in	in	IN
38430	338	24	the	the	DT
38430	338	25	right	right	NN
38430	338	26	or	or	CC
38430	338	27	wrong	wrong	JJ
38430	338	28	place	place	NN
38430	338	29	,	,	,
38430	338	30	A	a	DT
38430	338	31	acts	act	NNS
38430	338	32	as	as	IN
38430	338	33	if	if	IN
38430	338	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	338	35	thought	think	VBD
38430	338	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	338	37	had	have	VBD
38430	338	38	some	some	DT
38430	338	39	private	private	JJ
38430	338	40	property	property	NN
38430	338	41	in	in	IN
38430	338	42	truth	truth	NN
38430	338	43	.	.	.
38430	339	1	The	the	DT
38430	339	2	White	White	NNP
38430	339	3	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	339	4	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	339	5	to	to	TO
38430	339	6	have	have	VB
38430	339	7	shared	share	VBN
38430	339	8	the	the	DT
38430	339	9	popular	popular	JJ
38430	339	10	misconception	misconception	NN
38430	339	11	as	as	IN
38430	339	12	to	to	IN
38430	339	13	the	the	DT
38430	339	14	nature	nature	NN
38430	339	15	of	of	IN
38430	339	16	criticism	criticism	NN
38430	339	17	.	.	.
38430	340	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	340	2	39	39	CD
38430	340	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	340	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	340	5	:	:	:
38430	340	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	340	7	39	39	CD
38430	340	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	340	9	See	see	VB
38430	340	10	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	340	11	J.	J.	NNP
38430	341	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	341	2	XII	XII	NNP
38430	341	3	HISTORICAL	HISTORICAL	NNP
38430	341	4	CRITICISM	criticism	NN
38430	341	5	From	from	IN
38430	341	6	a	a	DT
38430	341	7	problem	problem	NN
38430	341	8	in	in	IN
38430	341	9	Diophantus	Diophantus	NNP
38430	341	10	's	's	POS
38430	341	11	_	_	NNP
38430	341	12	Arithmetic	Arithmetic	NNP
38430	341	13	_	_	NNP
38430	341	14	about	about	IN
38430	341	15	the	the	DT
38430	341	16	price	price	NN
38430	341	17	of	of	IN
38430	341	18	some	some	DT
38430	341	19	wine	wine	NN
38430	341	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	341	21	would	would	MD
38430	341	22	seem	seem	VB
38430	341	23	that	that	IN
38430	341	24	the	the	DT
38430	341	25	wine	wine	NN
38430	341	26	was	be	VBD
38430	341	27	of	of	IN
38430	341	28	poor	poor	JJ
38430	341	29	quality	quality	NN
38430	341	30	,	,	,
38430	341	31	and	and	CC
38430	341	32	Paul	Paul	NNP
38430	341	33	Tannery	Tannery	NNP
38430	341	34	has	have	VBZ
38430	341	35	suggested	suggest	VBN
38430	341	36	that	that	IN
38430	341	37	the	the	DT
38430	341	38	prices	price	NNS
38430	341	39	mentioned	mention	VBD
38430	341	40	for	for	IN
38430	341	41	such	such	PDT
38430	341	42	a	a	DT
38430	341	43	wine	wine	NN
38430	341	44	are	be	VBP
38430	341	45	higher	high	JJR
38430	341	46	than	than	IN
38430	341	47	were	be	VBD
38430	341	48	usual	usual	JJ
38430	341	49	until	until	IN
38430	341	50	after	after	IN
38430	341	51	the	the	DT
38430	341	52	end	end	NN
38430	341	53	of	of	IN
38430	341	54	the	the	DT
38430	341	55	second	second	JJ
38430	341	56	century	century	NN
38430	341	57	.	.	.
38430	342	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	342	2	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	342	3	rejected	reject	VBD
38430	342	4	the	the	DT
38430	342	5	view	view	NN
38430	342	6	which	which	WDT
38430	342	7	was	be	VBD
38430	342	8	formerly	formerly	RB
38430	342	9	held	hold	VBN
38430	342	10	that	that	IN
38430	342	11	Diophantus	Diophantus	NNP
38430	342	12	lived	live	VBD
38430	342	13	in	in	IN
38430	342	14	that	that	DT
38430	342	15	century	century	NN
38430	342	16	.	.	.
38430	343	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	343	2	40	40	CD
38430	343	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	343	4	The	the	DT
38430	343	5	same	same	JJ
38430	343	6	method	method	NN
38430	343	7	applied	apply	VBD
38430	343	8	to	to	IN
38430	343	9	a	a	DT
38430	343	10	problem	problem	NN
38430	343	11	given	give	VBN
38430	343	12	by	by	IN
38430	343	13	the	the	DT
38430	343	14	ancient	ancient	JJ
38430	343	15	Hindu	Hindu	NNP
38430	343	16	algebraist	algebraist	NN
38430	343	17	Brahmagupta	Brahmagupta	NNP
38430	343	18	,	,	,
38430	343	19	who	who	WP
38430	343	20	lived	live	VBD
38430	343	21	in	in	IN
38430	343	22	the	the	DT
38430	343	23	seventh	seventh	JJ
38430	343	24	century	century	NN
38430	343	25	after	after	IN
38430	343	26	Christ	Christ	NNP
38430	343	27	,	,	,
38430	343	28	might	may	MD
38430	343	29	result	result	VB
38430	343	30	in	in	IN
38430	343	31	placing	place	VBG
38430	343	32	Brahmagupta	Brahmagupta	NNP
38430	343	33	in	in	IN
38430	343	34	prehistoric	prehistoric	JJ
38430	343	35	times	time	NNS
38430	343	36	.	.	.
38430	344	1	This	this	DT
38430	344	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	344	3	the	the	DT
38430	344	4	problem:[41	problem:[41	NNP
38430	344	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	344	6	"	"	``
38430	344	7	Two	two	CD
38430	344	8	apes	ape	NNS
38430	344	9	lived	live	VBD
38430	344	10	at	at	IN
38430	344	11	the	the	DT
38430	344	12	top	top	NN
38430	344	13	of	of	IN
38430	344	14	a	a	DT
38430	344	15	cliff	cliff	NN
38430	344	16	of	of	IN
38430	344	17	height	height	NN
38430	344	18	_	_	NNP
38430	344	19	h	h	NNP
38430	344	20	_	_	NNP
38430	344	21	,	,	,
38430	344	22	whose	whose	WP$
38430	344	23	base	base	NN
38430	344	24	was	be	VBD
38430	344	25	distant	distant	JJ
38430	344	26	_	_	NNP
38430	344	27	mh	mh	VB
38430	344	28	_	_	NNP
38430	344	29	from	from	IN
38430	344	30	a	a	DT
38430	344	31	neighbouring	neighbouring	NN
38430	344	32	village	village	NN
38430	344	33	.	.	.
38430	345	1	One	one	CD
38430	345	2	descended	descend	VBD
38430	345	3	the	the	DT
38430	345	4	cliff	cliff	NN
38430	345	5	and	and	CC
38430	345	6	walked	walk	VBD
38430	345	7	to	to	IN
38430	345	8	the	the	DT
38430	345	9	village	village	NN
38430	345	10	,	,	,
38430	345	11	the	the	DT
38430	345	12	other	other	JJ
38430	345	13	flew	fly	VBD
38430	345	14	up	up	RB
38430	345	15	a	a	DT
38430	345	16	height	height	NN
38430	345	17	_	_	NNP
38430	345	18	x	x	NNP
38430	345	19	_	_	NNP
38430	345	20	and	and	CC
38430	345	21	then	then	RB
38430	345	22	flew	fly	VBD
38430	345	23	in	in	IN
38430	345	24	a	a	DT
38430	345	25	straight	straight	JJ
38430	345	26	line	line	NN
38430	345	27	to	to	IN
38430	345	28	the	the	DT
38430	345	29	village	village	NN
38430	345	30	.	.	.
38430	346	1	The	the	DT
38430	346	2	distance	distance	NN
38430	346	3	traversed	traverse	VBN
38430	346	4	by	by	IN
38430	346	5	each	each	DT
38430	346	6	was	be	VBD
38430	346	7	the	the	DT
38430	346	8	same	same	JJ
38430	346	9	.	.	.
38430	347	1	Find	find	VB
38430	347	2	_	_	NNP
38430	347	3	x	x	NNP
38430	347	4	_	_	NNP
38430	347	5	.	.	.
38430	347	6	"	"	''
38430	348	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	348	2	:	:	:
38430	348	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	348	4	40	40	CD
38430	348	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	348	6	W.	W.	NNP
38430	348	7	W.	W.	NNP
38430	348	8	Rouse	Rouse	NNP
38430	348	9	Ball	Ball	NNP
38430	348	10	,	,	,
38430	348	11	_	_	NNP
38430	348	12	A	A	NNP
38430	348	13	Short	Short	NNP
38430	348	14	Account	Account	NNP
38430	348	15	of	of	IN
38430	348	16	the	the	DT
38430	348	17	History	History	NNP
38430	348	18	of	of	IN
38430	348	19	Mathematics	Mathematics	NNP
38430	348	20	_	_	NNP
38430	348	21	,	,	,
38430	348	22	4th	4th	JJ
38430	348	23	edition	edition	NN
38430	348	24	,	,	,
38430	348	25	London	London	NNP
38430	348	26	,	,	,
38430	348	27	1908	1908	CD
38430	348	28	,	,	,
38430	348	29	p.	p.	NN
38430	348	30	109	109	CD
38430	348	31	.	.	.
38430	349	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	349	2	41	41	CD
38430	349	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	349	4	_	_	NNP
38430	349	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	349	6	.	.	.
38430	349	7	_	_	NNP
38430	349	8	,	,	,
38430	349	9	pp	pp	NNP
38430	349	10	.	.	.
38430	350	1	148	148	CD
38430	350	2	-	-	SYM
38430	350	3	9	9	CD
38430	350	4	.	.	.
38430	351	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	351	2	XIII	XIII	NNP
38430	351	3	IS	be	VBZ
38430	351	4	THE	the	DT
38430	351	5	MIND	mind	NN
38430	351	6	IN	in	IN
38430	351	7	THE	the	DT
38430	351	8	HEAD	HEAD	NNP
38430	351	9	?	?	.
38430	352	1	The	the	DT
38430	352	2	contrary	contrary	JJ
38430	352	3	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	352	4	has	have	VBZ
38430	352	5	been	be	VBN
38430	352	6	maintained	maintain	VBN
38430	352	7	by	by	IN
38430	352	8	idealists	idealist	NNS
38430	352	9	and	and	CC
38430	352	10	a	a	DT
38430	352	11	certain	certain	JJ
38430	352	12	election	election	NN
38430	352	13	agent	agent	NN
38430	352	14	with	with	IN
38430	352	15	whom	whom	WP
38430	352	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	352	17	once	once	RB
38430	352	18	had	have	VBD
38430	352	19	to	to	TO
38430	352	20	deal	deal	VB
38430	352	21	and	and	CC
38430	352	22	who	who	WP
38430	352	23	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	352	24	that	that	IN
38430	352	25	something	something	NN
38430	352	26	slipped	slip	VBD
38430	352	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	352	28	mind	mind	NN
38430	352	29	and	and	CC
38430	352	30	then	then	RB
38430	352	31	went	go	VBD
38430	352	32	out	out	IN
38430	352	33	of	of	IN
38430	352	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	352	35	head	head	NN
38430	352	36	altogether	altogether	RB
38430	352	37	.	.	.
38430	353	1	At	at	IN
38430	353	2	some	some	DT
38430	353	3	period	period	NN
38430	353	4	,	,	,
38430	353	5	then	then	RB
38430	353	6	,	,	,
38430	353	7	a	a	DT
38430	353	8	remembrance	remembrance	NN
38430	353	9	was	be	VBD
38430	353	10	in	in	IN
38430	353	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	353	12	head	head	NN
38430	353	13	and	and	CC
38430	353	14	out	out	IN
38430	353	15	of	of	IN
38430	353	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	353	17	mind	mind	NN
38430	353	18	;	;	:
38430	353	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	353	20	mind	mind	NN
38430	353	21	was	be	VBD
38430	353	22	not	not	RB
38430	353	23	,	,	,
38430	353	24	then	then	RB
38430	353	25	,	,	,
38430	353	26	wholly	wholly	RB
38430	353	27	within	within	IN
38430	353	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	353	29	head	head	NN
38430	353	30	.	.	.
38430	354	1	Also	also	RB
38430	354	2	,	,	,
38430	354	3	one	one	NN
38430	354	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	354	5	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	354	6	assured	assure	VBN
38430	354	7	that	that	IN
38430	354	8	with	with	IN
38430	354	9	certain	certain	JJ
38430	354	10	people	people	NNS
38430	354	11	"	"	''
38430	354	12	out	out	IN
38430	354	13	of	of	IN
38430	354	14	sight	sight	NN
38430	354	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	354	16	out	out	IN
38430	354	17	of	of	IN
38430	354	18	mind	mind	NN
38430	354	19	.	.	.
38430	354	20	"	"	''
38430	355	1	What	what	WP
38430	355	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	355	3	in	in	IN
38430	355	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	355	5	minds	mind	NNS
38430	355	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	355	7	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	355	8	in	in	IN
38430	355	9	sight	sight	NN
38430	355	10	,	,	,
38430	355	11	and	and	CC
38430	355	12	can	can	MD
38430	355	13	not	not	RB
38430	355	14	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	355	15	be	be	VB
38430	355	16	inside	inside	IN
38430	355	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	355	18	heads	head	NNS
38430	355	19	.	.	.
38430	356	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	356	2	XIV	XIV	NNP
38430	356	3	THE	the	DT
38430	356	4	PRAGMATIST	PRAGMATIST	NNP
38430	356	5	THEORY	THEORY	NNP
38430	356	6	OF	of	IN
38430	356	7	TRUTH	truth	NN
38430	356	8	The	the	DT
38430	356	9	pragmatist	pragmatist	JJ
38430	356	10	theory	theory	NN
38430	356	11	that	that	IN
38430	356	12	"	"	``
38430	356	13	truth	truth	NN
38430	356	14	"	"	''
38430	356	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	356	16	a	a	DT
38430	356	17	belief	belief	NN
38430	356	18	which	which	WDT
38430	356	19	works	work	VBZ
38430	356	20	well	well	RB
38430	356	21	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	356	22	conflicts	conflict	VBZ
38430	356	23	with	with	IN
38430	356	24	common	common	JJ
38430	356	25	-	-	HYPH
38430	356	26	sense	sense	NN
38430	356	27	and	and	CC
38430	356	28	not	not	RB
38430	356	29	with	with	IN
38430	356	30	logic	logic	NN
38430	356	31	.	.	.
38430	357	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	357	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	357	3	commonly	commonly	RB
38430	357	4	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	357	5	that	that	IN
38430	357	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	357	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	357	8	always	always	RB
38430	357	9	better	well	JJR
38430	357	10	to	to	TO
38430	357	11	be	be	VB
38430	357	12	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	357	13	right	right	JJ
38430	357	14	than	than	IN
38430	357	15	to	to	TO
38430	357	16	be	be	VB
38430	357	17	never	never	RB
38430	357	18	right	right	JJ
38430	357	19	.	.	.
38430	358	1	But	but	CC
38430	358	2	this	this	DT
38430	358	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	358	4	by	by	IN
38430	358	5	no	no	DT
38430	358	6	means	means	NN
38430	358	7	true	true	JJ
38430	358	8	.	.	.
38430	359	1	For	for	IN
38430	359	2	example	example	NN
38430	359	3	,	,	,
38430	359	4	consider	consider	VB
38430	359	5	the	the	DT
38430	359	6	case	case	NN
38430	359	7	of	of	IN
38430	359	8	a	a	DT
38430	359	9	watch	watch	NN
38430	359	10	which	which	WDT
38430	359	11	has	have	VBZ
38430	359	12	stopped	stop	VBN
38430	359	13	;	;	:
38430	359	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	359	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	359	16	exactly	exactly	RB
38430	359	17	right	right	JJ
38430	359	18	twice	twice	RB
38430	359	19	every	every	DT
38430	359	20	day	day	NN
38430	359	21	.	.	.
38430	360	1	A	a	DT
38430	360	2	watch	watch	NN
38430	360	3	,	,	,
38430	360	4	on	on	IN
38430	360	5	the	the	DT
38430	360	6	other	other	JJ
38430	360	7	hand	hand	NN
38430	360	8	,	,	,
38430	360	9	which	which	WDT
38430	360	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	360	11	always	always	RB
38430	360	12	five	five	CD
38430	360	13	minutes	minute	NNS
38430	360	14	slow	slow	JJ
38430	360	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	360	16	never	never	RB
38430	360	17	exactly	exactly	RB
38430	360	18	right	right	JJ
38430	360	19	.	.	.
38430	361	1	And	and	CC
38430	361	2	yet	yet	RB
38430	361	3	there	there	EX
38430	361	4	can	can	MD
38430	361	5	be	be	VB
38430	361	6	no	no	DT
38430	361	7	question	question	NN
38430	361	8	but	but	CC
38430	361	9	that	that	IN
38430	361	10	a	a	DT
38430	361	11	belief	belief	NN
38430	361	12	in	in	IN
38430	361	13	the	the	DT
38430	361	14	accuracy	accuracy	NN
38430	361	15	of	of	IN
38430	361	16	the	the	DT
38430	361	17	watch	watch	NN
38430	361	18	which	which	WDT
38430	361	19	was	be	VBD
38430	361	20	never	never	RB
38430	361	21	right	right	JJ
38430	361	22	would	would	MD
38430	361	23	,	,	,
38430	361	24	on	on	IN
38430	361	25	the	the	DT
38430	361	26	whole	whole	JJ
38430	361	27	,	,	,
38430	361	28	produce	produce	VB
38430	361	29	better	well	JJR
38430	361	30	results	result	NNS
38430	361	31	than	than	IN
38430	361	32	such	such	PDT
38430	361	33	a	a	DT
38430	361	34	belief	belief	NN
38430	361	35	in	in	IN
38430	361	36	the	the	DT
38430	361	37	one	one	NN
38430	361	38	which	which	WDT
38430	361	39	had	have	VBD
38430	361	40	altogether	altogether	RB
38430	361	41	stopped	stop	VBN
38430	361	42	.	.	.
38430	362	1	The	the	DT
38430	362	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
38430	362	3	would	would	MD
38430	362	4	,	,	,
38430	362	5	then	then	RB
38430	362	6	,	,	,
38430	362	7	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	362	8	that	that	IN
38430	362	9	the	the	DT
38430	362	10	watch	watch	NN
38430	362	11	which	which	WDT
38430	362	12	was	be	VBD
38430	362	13	always	always	RB
38430	362	14	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
38430	362	15	gave	give	VBD
38430	362	16	truer	truer	NN
38430	362	17	results	result	NNS
38430	362	18	than	than	IN
38430	362	19	the	the	DT
38430	362	20	one	one	NN
38430	362	21	which	which	WDT
38430	362	22	was	be	VBD
38430	362	23	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	362	24	accurate	accurate	JJ
38430	362	25	.	.	.
38430	363	1	In	in	IN
38430	363	2	this	this	DT
38430	363	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	363	4	the	the	DT
38430	363	5	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
38430	363	6	would	would	MD
38430	363	7	seem	seem	VB
38430	363	8	to	to	TO
38430	363	9	be	be	VB
38430	363	10	correct	correct	JJ
38430	363	11	,	,	,
38430	363	12	and	and	CC
38430	363	13	this	this	DT
38430	363	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	363	15	an	an	DT
38430	363	16	instance	instance	NN
38430	363	17	of	of	IN
38430	363	18	how	how	WRB
38430	363	19	the	the	DT
38430	363	20	false	false	JJ
38430	363	21	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	363	22	of	of	IN
38430	363	23	pragmatism	pragmatism	NN
38430	363	24	may	may	MD
38430	363	25	give	give	VB
38430	363	26	rise	rise	NN
38430	363	27	to	to	IN
38430	363	28	true	true	JJ
38430	363	29	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	363	30	.	.	.
38430	364	1	From	from	IN
38430	364	2	the	the	DT
38430	364	3	text	text	NN
38430	364	4	written	write	VBN
38430	364	5	above	above	IN
38430	364	6	the	the	DT
38430	364	7	church	church	NN
38430	364	8	clock	clock	NN
38430	364	9	in	in	IN
38430	364	10	a	a	DT
38430	364	11	certain	certain	JJ
38430	364	12	English	english	JJ
38430	364	13	village	village	NN
38430	364	14	,	,	,
38430	364	15	"	"	''
38430	364	16	Be	be	VB
38430	364	17	ye	ye	PRP
38430	364	18	ready	ready	JJ
38430	364	19	,	,	,
38430	364	20	for	for	IN
38430	364	21	ye	ye	NNP
38430	364	22	know	know	VBP
38430	364	23	not	not	RB
38430	364	24	the	the	DT
38430	364	25	time	time	NN
38430	364	26	,	,	,
38430	364	27	"	"	``
38430	364	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	364	29	would	would	MD
38430	364	30	be	be	VB
38430	364	31	concluded	conclude	VBN
38430	364	32	that	that	IN
38430	364	33	the	the	DT
38430	364	34	clock	clock	NN
38430	364	35	never	never	RB
38430	364	36	stopped	stop	VBD
38430	364	37	for	for	IN
38430	364	38	a	a	DT
38430	364	39	period	period	NN
38430	364	40	as	as	RB
38430	364	41	long	long	RB
38430	364	42	as	as	IN
38430	364	43	twelve	twelve	CD
38430	364	44	hours	hour	NNS
38430	364	45	.	.	.
38430	365	1	For	for	IN
38430	365	2	the	the	DT
38430	365	3	text	text	NN
38430	365	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	365	5	rather	rather	RB
38430	365	6	a	a	DT
38430	365	7	vague	vague	JJ
38430	365	8	symbolical	symbolical	JJ
38430	365	9	expression	expression	NN
38430	365	10	of	of	IN
38430	365	11	a	a	DT
38430	365	12	propositional	propositional	JJ
38430	365	13	function	function	NN
38430	365	14	which	which	WDT
38430	365	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	365	16	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	365	17	to	to	TO
38430	365	18	be	be	VB
38430	365	19	true	true	JJ
38430	365	20	at	at	IN
38430	365	21	all	all	DT
38430	365	22	instants	instant	NNS
38430	365	23	.	.	.
38430	366	1	The	the	DT
38430	366	2	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	366	3	that	that	WDT
38430	366	4	a	a	DT
38430	366	5	presumably	presumably	RB
38430	366	6	not	not	RB
38430	366	7	illiterate	illiterate	JJ
38430	366	8	and	and	CC
38430	366	9	credulous	credulous	JJ
38430	366	10	observer	observer	NN
38430	366	11	of	of	IN
38430	366	12	the	the	DT
38430	366	13	clock	clock	NN
38430	366	14	at	at	IN
38430	366	15	any	any	DT
38430	366	16	definite	definite	JJ
38430	366	17	instant	instant	NN
38430	366	18	does	do	VBZ
38430	366	19	not	not	RB
38430	366	20	know	know	VB
38430	366	21	the	the	DT
38430	366	22	time	time	NN
38430	366	23	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	366	24	,	,	,
38430	366	25	then	then	RB
38430	366	26	,	,	,
38430	366	27	that	that	IN
38430	366	28	the	the	DT
38430	366	29	clock	clock	NN
38430	366	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	366	31	always	always	RB
38430	366	32	wrong	wrong	JJ
38430	366	33	.	.	.
38430	367	1	Now	now	RB
38430	367	2	,	,	,
38430	367	3	if	if	IN
38430	367	4	the	the	DT
38430	367	5	clock	clock	NN
38430	367	6	stopped	stop	VBD
38430	367	7	for	for	IN
38430	367	8	twelve	twelve	CD
38430	367	9	hours	hour	NNS
38430	367	10	,	,	,
38430	367	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	367	12	would	would	MD
38430	367	13	be	be	VB
38430	367	14	absolutely	absolutely	RB
38430	367	15	right	right	RB
38430	367	16	at	at	IN
38430	367	17	least	least	JJS
38430	367	18	once	once	RB
38430	367	19	.	.	.
38430	368	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	368	2	must	must	MD
38430	368	3	be	be	VB
38430	368	4	right	right	RB
38430	368	5	twice	twice	RB
38430	368	6	if	if	IN
38430	368	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	368	8	were	be	VBD
38430	368	9	right	right	JJ
38430	368	10	at	at	IN
38430	368	11	the	the	DT
38430	368	12	first	first	JJ
38430	368	13	instant	instant	NN
38430	368	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	368	15	stopped	stop	VBD
38430	368	16	or	or	CC
38430	368	17	the	the	DT
38430	368	18	last	last	JJ
38430	368	19	instant	instant	NN
38430	368	20	at	at	IN
38430	368	21	which	which	WDT
38430	368	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	368	23	went;[42	went;[42	NNP
38430	368	24	]	]	-RRB-
38430	368	25	but	but	CC
38430	368	26	the	the	DT
38430	368	27	second	second	JJ
38430	368	28	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	368	29	is	be	VBZ
38430	368	30	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	368	31	by	by	IN
38430	368	32	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
38430	368	33	,	,	,
38430	368	34	and	and	CC
38430	368	35	the	the	DT
38430	368	36	occurrence	occurrence	NN
38430	368	37	of	of	IN
38430	368	38	the	the	DT
38430	368	39	first	first	JJ
38430	368	40	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	368	41	--	--	:
38430	368	42	or	or	CC
38430	368	43	of	of	IN
38430	368	44	the	the	DT
38430	368	45	analogous	analogous	JJ
38430	368	46	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	368	47	of	of	IN
38430	368	48	the	the	DT
38430	368	49	stopped	stop	VBN
38430	368	50	clock	clock	NN
38430	368	51	being	be	VBG
38430	368	52	right	right	JJ
38430	368	53	three	three	CD
38430	368	54	times	time	NNS
38430	368	55	in	in	IN
38430	368	56	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	368	57	-	-	HYPH
38430	368	58	four	four	CD
38430	368	59	hours	hour	NNS
38430	368	60	--	--	:
38430	368	61	does	do	VBZ
38430	368	62	not	not	RB
38430	368	63	affect	affect	VB
38430	368	64	the	the	DT
38430	368	65	present	present	JJ
38430	368	66	question	question	NN
38430	368	67	.	.	.
38430	369	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	369	2	the	the	DT
38430	369	3	clock	clock	NN
38430	369	4	can	can	MD
38430	369	5	never	never	RB
38430	369	6	stop	stop	VB
38430	369	7	for	for	IN
38430	369	8	twelve	twelve	CD
38430	369	9	hours	hour	NNS
38430	369	10	.	.	.
38430	370	1	The	the	DT
38430	370	2	pragmatist	pragmatist	NN
38430	370	3	's	's	POS
38430	370	4	criterion	criterion	NN
38430	370	5	of	of	IN
38430	370	6	truth	truth	NN
38430	370	7	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	370	8	to	to	TO
38430	370	9	be	be	VB
38430	370	10	far	far	RB
38430	370	11	more	more	RBR
38430	370	12	difficult	difficult	JJ
38430	370	13	to	to	TO
38430	370	14	apply	apply	VB
38430	370	15	than	than	IN
38430	370	16	the	the	DT
38430	370	17	Bellman's,[43	Bellman's,[43	NNP
38430	370	18	]	]	-RRB-
38430	370	19	that	that	IN
38430	370	20	what	what	WP
38430	370	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	370	22	said	say	VBD
38430	370	23	three	three	CD
38430	370	24	times	time	NNS
38430	370	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	370	26	true	true	JJ
38430	370	27	,	,	,
38430	370	28	and	and	CC
38430	370	29	to	to	TO
38430	370	30	give	give	VB
38430	370	31	results	result	NNS
38430	370	32	just	just	RB
38430	370	33	as	as	IN
38430	370	34	insecure	insecure	JJ
38430	370	35	.	.	.
38430	371	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	371	2	:	:	:
38430	371	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	371	4	42	42	CD
38430	371	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	371	6	Both	both	DT
38430	371	7	cases	case	NNS
38430	371	8	can	can	MD
38430	371	9	not	not	RB
38430	371	10	occur	occur	VB
38430	371	11	;	;	:
38430	371	12	the	the	DT
38430	371	13	question	question	NN
38430	371	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	371	15	similar	similar	JJ
38430	371	16	to	to	IN
38430	371	17	that	that	DT
38430	371	18	arising	arise	VBG
38430	371	19	in	in	IN
38430	371	20	the	the	DT
38430	371	21	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	371	22	of	of	IN
38430	371	23	the	the	DT
38430	371	24	mortality	mortality	NN
38430	371	25	of	of	IN
38430	371	26	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	371	27	(	(	-LRB-
38430	371	28	see	see	VB
38430	371	29	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	371	30	XXII	XXII	NNP
38430	371	31	)	)	-RRB-
38430	371	32	.	.	.
38430	372	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	372	2	43	43	CD
38430	372	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	372	4	See	see	VB
38430	372	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	372	6	K.	K.	NNP
38430	372	7	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	372	8	XV	XV	NNP
38430	372	9	ASSERTION	assertion	VBP
38430	372	10	The	the	DT
38430	372	11	subject	subject	NN
38430	372	12	of	of	IN
38430	372	13	the	the	DT
38430	372	14	present	present	JJ
38430	372	15	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	372	16	must	must	MD
38430	372	17	not	not	RB
38430	372	18	be	be	VB
38430	372	19	confused	confuse	VBN
38430	372	20	with	with	IN
38430	372	21	the	the	DT
38430	372	22	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	372	23	of	of	IN
38430	372	24	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	372	25	life	life	NN
38430	372	26	.	.	.
38430	373	1	Commonly	commonly	RB
38430	373	2	,	,	,
38430	373	3	an	an	DT
38430	373	4	unasserted	unasserted	JJ
38430	373	5	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	373	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	373	7	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
38430	373	8	with	with	IN
38430	373	9	a	a	DT
38430	373	10	probably	probably	RB
38430	373	11	false	false	JJ
38430	373	12	statement	statement	NN
38430	373	13	,	,	,
38430	373	14	while	while	IN
38430	373	15	an	an	DT
38430	373	16	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	373	17	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	373	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	373	19	synonymous	synonymous	JJ
38430	373	20	with	with	IN
38430	373	21	one	one	NN
38430	373	22	that	that	WDT
38430	373	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	373	24	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	373	25	false	false	JJ
38430	373	26	.	.	.
38430	374	1	But	but	CC
38430	374	2	in	in	IN
38430	374	3	logic	logic	NN
38430	374	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	374	5	apply	apply	VBP
38430	374	6	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	374	7	also	also	RB
38430	374	8	to	to	IN
38430	374	9	true	true	JJ
38430	374	10	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	374	11	,	,	,
38430	374	12	and	and	CC
38430	374	13	,	,	,
38430	374	14	as	as	IN
38430	374	15	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	374	16	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	374	17	showed	show	VBD
38430	374	18	in	in	IN
38430	374	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	374	20	version	version	NN
38430	374	21	of	of	IN
38430	374	22	"	"	``
38430	374	23	What	what	WP
38430	374	24	the	the	DT
38430	374	25	Tortoise	Tortoise	NNP
38430	374	26	said	say	VBD
38430	374	27	to	to	IN
38430	374	28	Achilles,"[44	Achilles,"[44	NNP
38430	374	29	]	]	-RRB-
38430	374	30	usually	usually	RB
38430	374	31	pass	pass	VBP
38430	374	32	over	over	RP
38430	374	33	unconsciously	unconsciously	RB
38430	374	34	an	an	DT
38430	374	35	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	374	36	series	series	NN
38430	374	37	of	of	IN
38430	374	38	implications	implication	NNS
38430	374	39	in	in	IN
38430	374	40	so	so	RB
38430	374	41	doing	do	VBG
38430	374	42	.	.	.
38430	375	1	If	if	IN
38430	375	2	_	_	NNP
38430	375	3	p	p	NNP
38430	375	4	_	_	NNP
38430	375	5	and	and	CC
38430	375	6	_	_	NNP
38430	375	7	q	q	NNP
38430	375	8	_	_	NNP
38430	375	9	are	be	VBP
38430	375	10	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	375	11	,	,	,
38430	375	12	_	_	NNP
38430	375	13	p	p	NNP
38430	375	14	_	_	NNP
38430	375	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	375	16	true	true	JJ
38430	375	17	,	,	,
38430	375	18	and	and	CC
38430	375	19	_	_	NNP
38430	375	20	p	p	NNP
38430	375	21	_	_	NNP
38430	375	22	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	375	23	_	_	NNP
38430	375	24	q	q	NNP
38430	375	25	_	_	NNP
38430	375	26	,	,	,
38430	375	27	then	then	RB
38430	375	28	,	,	,
38430	375	29	at	at	IN
38430	375	30	first	first	JJ
38430	375	31	sight	sight	NN
38430	375	32	,	,	,
38430	375	33	one	one	PRP
38430	375	34	would	would	MD
38430	375	35	think	think	VB
38430	375	36	that	that	IN
38430	375	37	one	one	PRP
38430	375	38	might	may	MD
38430	375	39	assert	assert	VB
38430	375	40	_	_	NNP
38430	375	41	q	q	NNP
38430	375	42	_	_	NNP
38430	375	43	.	.	.
38430	376	1	But	but	CC
38430	376	2	,	,	,
38430	376	3	from	from	IN
38430	376	4	(	(	-LRB-
38430	376	5	A	a	NN
38430	376	6	)	)	-RRB-
38430	376	7	_	_	NNP
38430	376	8	p	p	NNP
38430	376	9	_	_	NNP
38430	376	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	376	11	true	true	JJ
38430	376	12	,	,	,
38430	376	13	and	and	CC
38430	376	14	(	(	-LRB-
38430	376	15	B	b	NN
38430	376	16	)	)	-RRB-
38430	376	17	_	_	NNP
38430	376	18	p	p	NNP
38430	376	19	_	_	NNP
38430	376	20	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	376	21	_	_	NNP
38430	376	22	q	q	NNP
38430	376	23	_	_	NNP
38430	376	24	,	,	,
38430	376	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	376	26	must	must	MD
38430	376	27	,	,	,
38430	376	28	in	in	IN
38430	376	29	order	order	NN
38430	376	30	to	to	TO
38430	376	31	deduce	deduce	VB
38430	376	32	(	(	-LRB-
38430	376	33	Z	Z	NNP
38430	376	34	)	)	-RRB-
38430	376	35	_	_	NNP
38430	376	36	q	q	NNP
38430	376	37	_	_	NNP
38430	376	38	is	be	VBZ
38430	376	39	true	true	JJ
38430	376	40	,	,	,
38430	376	41	accept	accept	VB
38430	376	42	the	the	DT
38430	376	43	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
38430	376	44	:	:	:
38430	376	45	(	(	-LRB-
38430	376	46	C	c	NN
38430	376	47	)	)	-RRB-
38430	376	48	If	if	IN
38430	376	49	A	a	NN
38430	376	50	and	and	CC
38430	376	51	B	b	NN
38430	376	52	are	be	VBP
38430	376	53	true	true	JJ
38430	376	54	,	,	,
38430	376	55	Z	z	JJ
38430	376	56	must	must	MD
38430	376	57	be	be	VB
38430	376	58	true	true	JJ
38430	376	59	.	.	.
38430	377	1	And	and	CC
38430	377	2	then	then	RB
38430	377	3	,	,	,
38430	377	4	in	in	IN
38430	377	5	order	order	NN
38430	377	6	to	to	TO
38430	377	7	deduce	deduce	VB
38430	377	8	Z	z	NN
38430	377	9	from	from	IN
38430	377	10	A	a	NN
38430	377	11	,	,	,
38430	377	12	B	b	NN
38430	377	13	,	,	,
38430	377	14	and	and	CC
38430	377	15	C	C	NNP
38430	377	16	,	,	,
38430	377	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	377	18	must	must	MD
38430	377	19	accept	accept	VB
38430	377	20	another	another	DT
38430	377	21	hypothetical	hypothetical	NN
38430	377	22	:	:	:
38430	377	23	(	(	-LRB-
38430	377	24	D	d	NN
38430	377	25	)	)	-RRB-
38430	377	26	If	if	IN
38430	377	27	A	a	NN
38430	377	28	,	,	,
38430	377	29	B	b	NN
38430	377	30	,	,	,
38430	377	31	and	and	CC
38430	377	32	C	C	NNP
38430	377	33	are	be	VBP
38430	377	34	true	true	JJ
38430	377	35	,	,	,
38430	377	36	Z	z	JJ
38430	377	37	must	must	MD
38430	377	38	be	be	VB
38430	377	39	true	true	JJ
38430	377	40	;	;	:
38430	377	41	and	and	CC
38430	377	42	so	so	RB
38430	377	43	on	on	IN
38430	377	44	_	_	NNP
38430	377	45	ad	ad	NN
38430	377	46	infinitum	infinitum	IN
38430	377	47	_	_	NNP
38430	377	48	.	.	.
38430	378	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	378	2	,	,	,
38430	378	3	in	in	IN
38430	378	4	deducing	deduce	VBG
38430	378	5	Z	z	NN
38430	378	6	,	,	,
38430	378	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	378	8	pass	pass	VBP
38430	378	9	over	over	RP
38430	378	10	an	an	DT
38430	378	11	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	378	12	series	series	NN
38430	378	13	of	of	IN
38430	378	14	hypotheticals	hypothetical	NNS
38430	378	15	which	which	WDT
38430	378	16	increase	increase	VBP
38430	378	17	in	in	IN
38430	378	18	complexity	complexity	NN
38430	378	19	.	.	.
38430	379	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	379	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	379	3	need	need	VBP
38430	379	4	a	a	DT
38430	379	5	new	new	JJ
38430	379	6	principle	principle	NN
38430	379	7	to	to	TO
38430	379	8	be	be	VB
38430	379	9	able	able	JJ
38430	379	10	to	to	TO
38430	379	11	assert	assert	VB
38430	379	12	_	_	NNP
38430	379	13	q	q	NNP
38430	379	14	_	_	NNP
38430	379	15	.	.	.
38430	380	1	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	380	2	was	be	VBD
38430	380	3	the	the	DT
38430	380	4	first	first	JJ
38430	380	5	logician	logician	NNP
38430	380	6	sharply	sharply	RB
38430	380	7	to	to	TO
38430	380	8	distinguish	distinguish	VB
38430	380	9	between	between	IN
38430	380	10	an	an	DT
38430	380	11	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	380	12	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	380	13	,	,	,
38430	380	14	like	like	IN
38430	380	15	"	"	``
38430	380	16	A	a	NN
38430	380	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	380	18	greater	great	JJR
38430	380	19	than	than	IN
38430	380	20	B	b	NN
38430	380	21	,	,	,
38430	380	22	"	"	''
38430	380	23	and	and	CC
38430	380	24	one	one	CD
38430	380	25	which	which	WDT
38430	380	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	380	27	merely	merely	RB
38430	380	28	considered	consider	VBN
38430	380	29	,	,	,
38430	380	30	like	like	IN
38430	380	31	"	"	``
38430	380	32	A	A	NNP
38430	380	33	's	's	POS
38430	380	34	being	be	VBG
38430	380	35	greater	great	JJR
38430	380	36	than	than	IN
38430	380	37	B	b	NN
38430	380	38	,	,	,
38430	380	39	"	"	''
38430	380	40	although	although	IN
38430	380	41	an	an	DT
38430	380	42	analogous	analogous	JJ
38430	380	43	distinction	distinction	NN
38430	380	44	had	have	VBD
38430	380	45	been	be	VBN
38430	380	46	made	make	VBN
38430	380	47	in	in	IN
38430	380	48	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	380	49	common	common	JJ
38430	380	50	discourse	discourse	NN
38430	380	51	on	on	IN
38430	380	52	certain	certain	JJ
38430	380	53	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	380	54	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	380	55	,	,	,
38430	380	56	for	for	IN
38430	380	57	long	long	RB
38430	380	58	previously	previously	RB
38430	380	59	.	.	.
38430	381	1	In	in	IN
38430	381	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	381	3	,	,	,
38430	381	4	soon	soon	RB
38430	381	5	after	after	IN
38430	381	6	the	the	DT
38430	381	7	invention	invention	NN
38430	381	8	of	of	IN
38430	381	9	speech	speech	NN
38430	381	10	,	,	,
38430	381	11	the	the	DT
38430	381	12	necessity	necessity	NN
38430	381	13	of	of	IN
38430	381	14	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
38430	381	15	between	between	IN
38430	381	16	a	a	DT
38430	381	17	considered	consider	VBN
38430	381	18	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	381	19	and	and	CC
38430	381	20	an	an	DT
38430	381	21	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	381	22	one	one	CD
38430	381	23	became	become	VBD
38430	381	24	evident	evident	JJ
38430	381	25	,	,	,
38430	381	26	on	on	IN
38430	381	27	account	account	NN
38430	381	28	of	of	IN
38430	381	29	the	the	DT
38430	381	30	state	state	NN
38430	381	31	of	of	IN
38430	381	32	things	thing	NNS
38430	381	33	referred	refer	VBN
38430	381	34	to	to	IN
38430	381	35	at	at	IN
38430	381	36	the	the	DT
38430	381	37	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	381	38	of	of	IN
38430	381	39	this	this	DT
38430	381	40	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	381	41	.	.	.
38430	382	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	382	2	:	:	:
38430	382	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	382	4	44	44	CD
38430	382	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	382	6	_	_	NNP
38430	382	7	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	382	8	_	_	NNP
38430	382	9	N.	N.	NNP
38430	382	10	S.	S.	NNP
38430	382	11	,	,	,
38430	382	12	vol	vol	NNP
38430	382	13	.	.	.
38430	383	1	iv	iv	NNP
38430	383	2	.	.	NNP
38430	383	3	,	,	,
38430	383	4	1895	1895	CD
38430	383	5	,	,	,
38430	383	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	383	7	.	.	.
38430	384	1	278	278	CD
38430	384	2	-	-	SYM
38430	384	3	80	80	CD
38430	384	4	.	.	.
38430	385	1	Cf	cf	NN
38430	385	2	.	.	.
38430	386	1	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	386	2	,	,	,
38430	386	3	_	_	NNP
38430	386	4	P.	P.	NNP
38430	387	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	387	2	_	_	NNP
38430	387	3	,	,	,
38430	387	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	387	5	35	35	CD
38430	387	6	.	.	.
38430	388	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	388	2	XVI	XVI	NNP
38430	388	3	THE	the	DT
38430	388	4	COMMUTATIVE	COMMUTATIVE	NNP
38430	388	5	LAW	law	NN
38430	388	6	Often	often	RB
38430	388	7	the	the	DT
38430	388	8	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	388	9	of	of	IN
38430	388	10	a	a	DT
38430	388	11	sentence	sentence	NN
38430	388	12	tacitly	tacitly	RB
38430	388	13	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	388	14	that	that	IN
38430	388	15	the	the	DT
38430	388	16	commutative	commutative	JJ
38430	388	17	law	law	NN
38430	388	18	does	do	VBZ
38430	388	19	not	not	RB
38430	388	20	hold	hold	VB
38430	388	21	.	.	.
38430	389	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	389	2	are	be	VBP
38430	389	3	all	all	RB
38430	389	4	familiar	familiar	JJ
38430	389	5	with	with	IN
38430	389	6	the	the	DT
38430	389	7	passage	passage	NN
38430	389	8	in	in	IN
38430	389	9	which	which	WDT
38430	389	10	Macaulay	Macaulay	NNP
38430	389	11	pointed	point	VBD
38430	389	12	out	out	RP
38430	389	13	that	that	IN
38430	389	14	,	,	,
38430	389	15	by	by	IN
38430	389	16	using	use	VBG
38430	389	17	the	the	DT
38430	389	18	commutative	commutative	JJ
38430	389	19	law	law	NN
38430	389	20	because	because	IN
38430	389	21	of	of	IN
38430	389	22	exigencies	exigency	NNS
38430	389	23	of	of	IN
38430	389	24	metre	metre	NNP
38430	389	25	,	,	,
38430	389	26	Robert	Robert	NNP
38430	389	27	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
38430	389	28	unintentionally	unintentionally	RB
38430	389	29	made	make	VBD
38430	389	30	Creation	creation	NN
38430	389	31	tremble	tremble	NN
38430	389	32	at	at	IN
38430	389	33	the	the	DT
38430	389	34	Atheist	Atheist	NNP
38430	389	35	's	's	POS
38430	389	36	nod	nod	NN
38430	389	37	instead	instead	RB
38430	389	38	of	of	IN
38430	389	39	the	the	DT
38430	389	40	Almighty	Almighty	NNP
38430	389	41	's	's	POS
38430	389	42	.	.	.
38430	390	1	This	this	DT
38430	390	2	use	use	NN
38430	390	3	of	of	IN
38430	390	4	the	the	DT
38430	390	5	commutative	commutative	JJ
38430	390	6	law	law	NN
38430	390	7	by	by	IN
38430	390	8	writers	writer	NNS
38430	390	9	of	of	IN
38430	390	10	verse	verse	NN
38430	390	11	renders	render	NNS
38430	390	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	390	13	doubtful	doubtful	VBD
38430	390	14	whether	whether	IN
38430	390	15	,	,	,
38430	390	16	in	in	IN
38430	390	17	the	the	DT
38430	390	18	hymn	hymn	NN
38430	390	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	390	20	line	line	NN
38430	390	21	:	:	:
38430	390	22	The	the	DT
38430	390	23	humble	humble	JJ
38430	390	24	poor	poor	JJ
38430	390	25	believe	believe	VBP
38430	390	26	,	,	,
38430	390	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	390	28	are	be	VBP
38430	390	29	to	to	TO
38430	390	30	understand	understand	VB
38430	390	31	a	a	DT
38430	390	32	statement	statement	NN
38430	390	33	about	about	IN
38430	390	34	the	the	DT
38430	390	35	humble	humble	JJ
38430	390	36	poor	poor	JJ
38430	390	37	,	,	,
38430	390	38	or	or	CC
38430	390	39	a	a	DT
38430	390	40	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	390	41	maxim	maxim	NN
38430	390	42	as	as	IN
38430	390	43	to	to	IN
38430	390	44	the	the	DT
38430	390	45	attitude	attitude	NN
38430	390	46	of	of	IN
38430	390	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	390	48	minds	mind	NNS
38430	390	49	to	to	IN
38430	390	50	statements	statement	NNS
38430	390	51	made	make	VBN
38430	390	52	by	by	IN
38430	390	53	the	the	DT
38430	390	54	humble	humble	JJ
38430	390	55	poor	poor	JJ
38430	390	56	.	.	.
38430	391	1	The	the	DT
38430	391	2	non	non	JJ
38430	391	3	-	-	NN
38430	391	4	commutativity	commutativity	NN
38430	391	5	of	of	IN
38430	391	6	English	english	JJ
38430	391	7	titles	title	NNS
38430	391	8	offers	offer	VBZ
38430	391	9	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	391	10	to	to	IN
38430	391	11	some	some	DT
38430	391	12	novelists	novelist	NNS
38430	391	13	and	and	CC
38430	391	14	Americans	Americans	NNPS
38430	391	15	who	who	WP
38430	391	16	refer	refer	VBP
38430	391	17	to	to	IN
38430	391	18	Mary	Mary	NNP
38430	391	19	Lady	Lady	NNP
38430	391	20	So	So	NNP
38430	391	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	391	22	and	and	CC
38430	391	23	-	-	HYPH
38430	391	24	So	so	RB
38430	391	25	as	as	IN
38430	391	26	Lady	Lady	NNP
38430	391	27	Mary	Mary	NNP
38430	391	28	So	So	NNP
38430	391	29	-	-	HYPH
38430	391	30	and	and	CC
38430	391	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	391	32	So	so	RB
38430	391	33	,	,	,
38430	391	34	and	and	CC
38430	391	35	_	_	NNP
38430	391	36	vice	vice	NN
38430	391	37	versa	versa	NNP
38430	391	38	_	_	NNP
38430	391	39	.	.	.
38430	392	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	392	2	XVII	XVII	NNP
38430	392	3	UNIVERSAL	UNIVERSAL	NNP
38430	392	4	AND	and	CC
38430	392	5	PARTICULAR	PARTICULAR	NNP
38430	392	6	PROPOSITIONS	PROPOSITIONS	NNP
38430	392	7	People	People	NNS
38430	392	8	who	who	WP
38430	392	9	are	be	VBP
38430	392	10	cynical	cynical	JJ
38430	392	11	as	as	IN
38430	392	12	to	to	IN
38430	392	13	the	the	DT
38430	392	14	morality	morality	NN
38430	392	15	of	of	IN
38430	392	16	the	the	DT
38430	392	17	English	English	NNP
38430	392	18	are	be	VBP
38430	392	19	often	often	RB
38430	392	20	unpleasantly	unpleasantly	RB
38430	392	21	surprised	surprised	JJ
38430	392	22	to	to	TO
38430	392	23	learn	learn	VB
38430	392	24	that	that	IN
38430	392	25	"	"	``
38430	392	26	All	all	DT
38430	392	27	trespassers	trespasser	NNS
38430	392	28	will	will	MD
38430	392	29	be	be	VB
38430	392	30	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
38430	392	31	"	"	``
38430	392	32	does	do	VBZ
38430	392	33	not	not	RB
38430	392	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
38430	392	35	imply	imply	VB
38430	392	36	that	that	IN
38430	392	37	"	"	``
38430	392	38	some	some	DT
38430	392	39	trespassers	trespasser	NNS
38430	392	40	will	will	MD
38430	392	41	be	be	VB
38430	392	42	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
38430	392	43	.	.	.
38430	392	44	"	"	''
38430	393	1	The	the	DT
38430	393	2	view	view	NN
38430	393	3	that	that	IN
38430	393	4	universal	universal	JJ
38430	393	5	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	393	6	are	be	VBP
38430	393	7	non	non	JJ
38430	393	8	-	-	JJ
38430	393	9	existential	existential	JJ
38430	393	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	393	11	now	now	RB
38430	393	12	generally	generally	RB
38430	393	13	held	hold	VBN
38430	393	14	:	:	:
38430	393	15	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
38430	393	16	and	and	CC
38430	393	17	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	393	18	seem	seem	VBP
38430	393	19	to	to	TO
38430	393	20	have	have	VB
38430	393	21	been	be	VBN
38430	393	22	the	the	DT
38430	393	23	first	first	JJ
38430	393	24	to	to	TO
38430	393	25	hold	hold	VB
38430	393	26	this	this	DT
38430	393	27	,	,	,
38430	393	28	while	while	IN
38430	393	29	older	old	JJR
38430	393	30	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	393	31	,	,	,
38430	393	32	such	such	JJ
38430	393	33	as	as	IN
38430	393	34	De	De	NNP
38430	393	35	Morgan,[45	Morgan,[45	NNP
38430	393	36	]	]	-RRB-
38430	393	37	considered	consider	VBD
38430	393	38	universal	universal	JJ
38430	393	39	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	393	40	to	to	TO
38430	393	41	be	be	VB
38430	393	42	existential	existential	JJ
38430	393	43	,	,	,
38430	393	44	like	like	IN
38430	393	45	particular	particular	JJ
38430	393	46	ones	one	NNS
38430	393	47	.	.	.
38430	394	1	If	if	IN
38430	394	2	the	the	DT
38430	394	3	Gnat[46	Gnat[46	NNP
38430	394	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	394	5	had	have	VBD
38430	394	6	been	be	VBN
38430	394	7	content	content	JJ
38430	394	8	to	to	TO
38430	394	9	affirm	affirm	VB
38430	394	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	394	11	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	394	12	about	about	IN
38430	394	13	the	the	DT
38430	394	14	means	mean	NNS
38430	394	15	of	of	IN
38430	394	16	subsistence	subsistence	NN
38430	394	17	of	of	IN
38430	394	18	Bread	bread	NN
38430	394	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	394	20	and	and	CC
38430	394	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	394	22	Butter	butter	NN
38430	394	23	flies	fly	NNS
38430	394	24	,	,	,
38430	394	25	in	in	IN
38430	394	26	consequence	consequence	NN
38430	394	27	of	of	IN
38430	394	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	394	29	lack	lack	NN
38430	394	30	of	of	IN
38430	394	31	which	which	WDT
38430	394	32	such	such	JJ
38430	394	33	flies	fly	NNS
38430	394	34	always	always	RB
38430	394	35	die	die	VBP
38430	394	36	,	,	,
38430	394	37	without	without	IN
38430	394	38	pointing	point	VBG
38430	394	39	out	out	RP
38430	394	40	such	such	PDT
38430	394	41	an	an	DT
38430	394	42	insect	insect	NN
38430	394	43	and	and	CC
38430	394	44	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	394	45	proving	prove	VBG
38430	394	46	that	that	IN
38430	394	47	the	the	DT
38430	394	48	class	class	NN
38430	394	49	of	of	IN
38430	394	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	394	51	is	be	VBZ
38430	394	52	not	not	RB
38430	394	53	null	null	JJ
38430	394	54	,	,	,
38430	394	55	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	394	56	's	's	POS
38430	394	57	doubt	doubt	NN
38430	394	58	as	as	IN
38430	394	59	to	to	IN
38430	394	60	the	the	DT
38430	394	61	existence	existence	NN
38430	394	62	of	of	IN
38430	394	63	the	the	DT
38430	394	64	class	class	NN
38430	394	65	in	in	IN
38430	394	66	question	question	NN
38430	394	67	,	,	,
38430	394	68	even	even	RB
38430	394	69	if	if	IN
38430	394	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	394	71	were	be	VBD
38430	394	72	proved	prove	VBN
38430	394	73	to	to	TO
38430	394	74	be	be	VB
38430	394	75	well	well	RB
38430	394	76	founded	found	VBN
38430	394	77	,	,	,
38430	394	78	would	would	MD
38430	394	79	not	not	RB
38430	394	80	have	have	VB
38430	394	81	affected	affect	VBN
38430	394	82	the	the	DT
38430	394	83	validity	validity	NN
38430	394	84	of	of	IN
38430	394	85	the	the	DT
38430	394	86	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	394	87	.	.	.
38430	395	1	This	this	DT
38430	395	2	brings	bring	VBZ
38430	395	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	395	4	to	to	IN
38430	395	5	a	a	DT
38430	395	6	great	great	JJ
38430	395	7	convenience	convenience	NN
38430	395	8	in	in	IN
38430	395	9	treating	treat	VBG
38430	395	10	universal	universal	JJ
38430	395	11	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	395	12	as	as	IN
38430	395	13	non	non	JJ
38430	395	14	-	-	JJ
38430	395	15	existential	existential	JJ
38430	395	16	:	:	:
38430	395	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	395	18	can	can	MD
38430	395	19	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	395	20	that	that	IN
38430	395	21	all	all	DT
38430	395	22	_	_	NNP
38430	395	23	x	x	NNP
38430	395	24	_	_	NNP
38430	395	25	's	's	POS
38430	395	26	are	be	VBP
38430	395	27	_	_	NNP
38430	395	28	y	y	NNP
38430	395	29	_	_	NNP
38430	395	30	's	's	POS
38430	395	31	at	at	IN
38430	395	32	the	the	DT
38430	395	33	same	same	JJ
38430	395	34	time	time	NN
38430	395	35	as	as	IN
38430	395	36	that	that	DT
38430	395	37	no	no	DT
38430	395	38	_	_	NNP
38430	395	39	x	x	NNP
38430	395	40	_	_	NNP
38430	395	41	's	's	POS
38430	395	42	are	be	VBP
38430	395	43	_	_	NNP
38430	395	44	y	y	NNP
38430	395	45	_	_	NNP
38430	395	46	's	's	POS
38430	395	47	,	,	,
38430	395	48	if	if	IN
38430	395	49	only	only	RB
38430	395	50	_	_	NNP
38430	395	51	x	x	NNP
38430	395	52	_	_	NNP
38430	395	53	is	be	VBZ
38430	395	54	the	the	DT
38430	395	55	null	null	JJ
38430	395	56	-	-	HYPH
38430	395	57	class	class	NN
38430	395	58	.	.	.
38430	396	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	396	2	,	,	,
38430	396	3	when	when	WRB
38430	396	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	396	5	MacColl[47	MacColl[47	NNP
38430	396	6	]	]	-RRB-
38430	396	7	objected	object	VBD
38430	396	8	to	to	IN
38430	396	9	other	other	JJ
38430	396	10	symbolic	symbolic	JJ
38430	396	11	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	396	12	that	that	IN
38430	396	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	396	14	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	396	15	imply	imply	VBP
38430	396	16	that	that	IN
38430	396	17	all	all	DT
38430	396	18	Centaurs	centaur	NNS
38430	396	19	are	be	VBP
38430	396	20	flower	flower	NN
38430	396	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	396	22	pots	pot	NNS
38430	396	23	,	,	,
38430	396	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	396	25	could	could	MD
38430	396	26	reply	reply	VB
38430	396	27	that	that	IN
38430	396	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	396	29	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	396	30	also	also	RB
38430	396	31	imply	imply	VBP
38430	396	32	the	the	DT
38430	396	33	more	more	RBR
38430	396	34	usual	usual	JJ
38430	396	35	view	view	NN
38430	396	36	that	that	IN
38430	396	37	Centaurs	centaur	NNS
38430	396	38	are	be	VBP
38430	396	39	not	not	RB
38430	396	40	flower	flower	NN
38430	396	41	-	-	HYPH
38430	396	42	pots	pot	NNS
38430	396	43	.	.	.
38430	397	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	397	2	:	:	:
38430	397	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	397	4	45	45	CD
38430	397	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	397	6	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	397	7	.	.	NNP
38430	397	8	,	,	,
38430	397	9	e.g.	e.g.	NNP
38430	397	10	,	,	,
38430	397	11	_	_	NNP
38430	397	12	F.	F.	NNP
38430	398	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	398	2	_	_	NNP
38430	398	3	,	,	,
38430	398	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	398	5	4	4	CD
38430	398	6	.	.	.
38430	399	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	399	2	46	46	CD
38430	399	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	399	4	See	see	VB
38430	399	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	399	6	L.	L.	NNP
38430	399	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	399	8	47	47	CD
38430	399	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	399	10	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	399	11	.	.	NNP
38430	399	12	,	,	,
38430	399	13	e.g.	e.g.	NNP
38430	399	14	,	,	,
38430	399	15	_	_	NNP
38430	399	16	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	399	17	_	_	NNP
38430	399	18	,	,	,
38430	399	19	N.	N.	NNP
38430	399	20	S.	S.	NNP
38430	399	21	,	,	,
38430	399	22	vol	vol	NNP
38430	399	23	.	.	.
38430	400	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	400	2	.	.	NNP
38430	400	3	,	,	,
38430	400	4	July	July	NNP
38430	400	5	,	,	,
38430	400	6	1905	1905	CD
38430	400	7	,	,	,
38430	400	8	pp	pp	NNP
38430	400	9	.	.	.
38430	401	1	399	399	CD
38430	401	2	-	-	SYM
38430	401	3	400	400	CD
38430	401	4	.	.	.
38430	402	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	402	2	XVIII	xviii	NN
38430	402	3	DENIAL	DENIAL	NNS
38430	402	4	OF	of	IN
38430	402	5	GENERALITY	GENERALITY	NNS
38430	402	6	AND	and	CC
38430	402	7	GENERALITY	generality	NN
38430	402	8	OF	of	IN
38430	402	9	DENIAL	denial	NN
38430	402	10	The	the	DT
38430	402	11	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	402	12	of	of	IN
38430	402	13	a	a	DT
38430	402	14	certain	certain	JJ
38430	402	15	song[48	song[48	NNP
38430	402	16	]	]	-RRB-
38430	402	17	about	about	RB
38430	402	18	a	a	DT
38430	402	19	young	young	JJ
38430	402	20	man	man	NN
38430	402	21	who	who	WP
38430	402	22	poisoned	poison	VBD
38430	402	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	402	24	sweetheart	sweetheart	NN
38430	402	25	with	with	IN
38430	402	26	sheep's	sheep's	NN
38430	402	27	-	-	HYPH
38430	402	28	head	head	NN
38430	402	29	broth	broth	NN
38430	402	30	,	,	,
38430	402	31	and	and	CC
38430	402	32	was	be	VBD
38430	402	33	frightened	frighten	VBN
38430	402	34	to	to	IN
38430	402	35	death	death	NN
38430	402	36	by	by	IN
38430	402	37	a	a	DT
38430	402	38	voice	voice	NN
38430	402	39	exclaiming	exclaim	VBG
38430	402	40	:	:	:
38430	402	41	"	"	``
38430	402	42	Where	where	WRB
38430	402	43	's	be	VBZ
38430	402	44	that	that	DT
38430	402	45	young	young	JJ
38430	402	46	maid	maid	VBD
38430	402	47	What	what	WP
38430	402	48	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	402	49	did	do	VBD
38430	402	50	poison	poison	NN
38430	402	51	with	with	IN
38430	402	52	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	402	53	head	head	NN
38430	402	54	?	?	.
38430	402	55	"	"	''
38430	403	1	at	at	IN
38430	403	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	403	3	bedside	bedside	NN
38430	403	4	,	,	,
38430	403	5	gives	give	VBZ
38430	403	6	rise	rise	NN
38430	403	7	to	to	IN
38430	403	8	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	403	9	which	which	WDT
38430	403	10	are	be	VBP
38430	403	11	readily	readily	RB
38430	403	12	solved	solve	VBN
38430	403	13	by	by	IN
38430	403	14	a	a	DT
38430	403	15	symbolism	symbolism	NN
38430	403	16	that	that	WDT
38430	403	17	brings	bring	VBZ
38430	403	18	into	into	IN
38430	403	19	relief	relief	NN
38430	403	20	the	the	DT
38430	403	21	principle	principle	NN
38430	403	22	that	that	IN
38430	403	23	the	the	DT
38430	403	24	denial	denial	NN
38430	403	25	of	of	IN
38430	403	26	a	a	DT
38430	403	27	universal	universal	JJ
38430	403	28	and	and	CC
38430	403	29	non	non	JJ
38430	403	30	-	-	JJ
38430	403	31	existential	existential	JJ
38430	403	32	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	403	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	403	34	a	a	DT
38430	403	35	particular	particular	JJ
38430	403	36	and	and	CC
38430	403	37	existential	existential	JJ
38430	403	38	one	one	CD
38430	403	39	.	.	.
38430	404	1	The	the	DT
38430	404	2	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	404	3	of	of	IN
38430	404	4	the	the	DT
38430	404	5	song	song	NN
38430	404	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	404	7	:	:	:
38430	404	8	Now	now	RB
38430	404	9	all	all	DT
38430	404	10	young	young	JJ
38430	404	11	men	man	NNS
38430	404	12	,	,	,
38430	404	13	both	both	CC
38430	404	14	high	high	JJ
38430	404	15	and	and	CC
38430	404	16	low	low	JJ
38430	404	17	,	,	,
38430	404	18	Take	take	VB
38430	404	19	warning	warning	NN
38430	404	20	by	by	IN
38430	404	21	this	this	DT
38430	404	22	dismal	dismal	JJ
38430	404	23	go	go	VB
38430	404	24	!	!	.
38430	405	1	For	for	IN
38430	405	2	if	if	IN
38430	405	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	405	4	'd	have	VBD
38430	405	5	never	never	RB
38430	405	6	done	do	VBN
38430	405	7	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	405	8	no	no	DT
38430	405	9	wrong	wrong	RB
38430	405	10	,	,	,
38430	405	11	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	405	12	might	may	MD
38430	405	13	have	have	VB
38430	405	14	been	be	VBN
38430	405	15	here	here	RB
38430	405	16	to	to	TO
38430	405	17	have	have	VB
38430	405	18	heard	hear	VBN
38430	405	19	this	this	DT
38430	405	20	song	song	NN
38430	405	21	.	.	.
38430	406	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	406	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	406	3	an	an	DT
38430	406	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	406	5	error	error	NN
38430	406	6	,	,	,
38430	406	7	say	say	VBP
38430	406	8	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
38430	406	9	and	and	CC
38430	406	10	Russell,[49	Russell,[49	NNP
38430	406	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	406	12	though	though	IN
38430	406	13	one	one	CD
38430	406	14	easy	easy	JJ
38430	406	15	to	to	TO
38430	406	16	commit	commit	VB
38430	406	17	,	,	,
38430	406	18	to	to	TO
38430	406	19	assume	assume	VB
38430	406	20	that	that	IN
38430	406	21	the	the	DT
38430	406	22	cases	case	NNS
38430	406	23	:	:	:
38430	406	24	(	(	-LRB-
38430	406	25	1	1	LS
38430	406	26	)	)	-RRB-
38430	406	27	all	all	PDT
38430	406	28	the	the	DT
38430	406	29	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	406	30	of	of	IN
38430	406	31	a	a	DT
38430	406	32	certain	certain	JJ
38430	406	33	class	class	NN
38430	406	34	are	be	VBP
38430	406	35	true	true	JJ
38430	406	36	;	;	:
38430	406	37	and	and	CC
38430	406	38	(	(	-LRB-
38430	406	39	2	2	LS
38430	406	40	)	)	-RRB-
38430	406	41	no	no	DT
38430	406	42	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	406	43	of	of	IN
38430	406	44	the	the	DT
38430	406	45	class	class	NN
38430	406	46	is	be	VBZ
38430	406	47	true	true	JJ
38430	406	48	;	;	:
38430	406	49	are	be	VBP
38430	406	50	each	each	DT
38430	406	51	other	other	JJ
38430	406	52	's	's	POS
38430	406	53	contradictories	contradictory	NNS
38430	406	54	.	.	.
38430	407	1	However	however	RB
38430	407	2	,	,	,
38430	407	3	in	in	IN
38430	407	4	the	the	DT
38430	407	5	modification[50	modification[50	NN
38430	407	6	]	]	-RRB-
38430	407	7	of	of	IN
38430	407	8	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	407	9	's	's	POS
38430	407	10	symbolism	symbolism	NN
38430	407	11	which	which	WDT
38430	407	12	was	be	VBD
38430	407	13	used	use	VBN
38430	407	14	by	by	IN
38430	407	15	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	407	16	(	(	-LRB-
38430	407	17	1	1	CD
38430	407	18	)	)	-RRB-
38430	407	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	407	20	(	(	-LRB-
38430	407	21	_	_	NNP
38430	407	22	x	x	NNP
38430	407	23	_	_	NNP
38430	407	24	)	)	-RRB-
38430	407	25	.	.	.
38430	408	1	_	_	NNP
38430	408	2	x	x	NNP
38430	408	3	_	_	NNP
38430	408	4	,	,	,
38430	408	5	and	and	CC
38430	408	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	408	7	2	2	LS
38430	408	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	408	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	408	10	(	(	-LRB-
38430	408	11	_	_	NNP
38430	408	12	x	x	NNP
38430	408	13	_	_	NNP
38430	408	14	)	)	-RRB-
38430	408	15	.	.	.
38430	409	1	not	not	RB
38430	409	2	_	_	NNP
38430	409	3	x	x	NNP
38430	409	4	_	_	NNP
38430	409	5	;	;	:
38430	409	6	while	while	IN
38430	409	7	the	the	DT
38430	409	8	contradictory	contradictory	NN
38430	409	9	of	of	IN
38430	409	10	(	(	-LRB-
38430	409	11	1	1	CD
38430	409	12	)	)	-RRB-
38430	409	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	409	14	:	:	:
38430	409	15	not	not	RB
38430	409	16	(	(	-LRB-
38430	409	17	_	_	NNP
38430	409	18	x	x	NNP
38430	409	19	_	_	NNP
38430	409	20	)	)	-RRB-
38430	409	21	.	.	.
38430	410	1	_	_	NNP
38430	410	2	x	x	NNP
38430	410	3	_	_	NNP
38430	410	4	.	.	.
38430	411	1	The	the	DT
38430	411	2	last	last	JJ
38430	411	3	line	line	NN
38430	411	4	but	but	CC
38430	411	5	one	one	CD
38430	411	6	of	of	IN
38430	411	7	the	the	DT
38430	411	8	above	above	JJ
38430	411	9	verse	verse	NN
38430	411	10	may	may	MD
38430	411	11	,	,	,
38430	411	12	then	then	RB
38430	411	13	,	,	,
38430	411	14	be	be	VB
38430	411	15	written	write	VBN
38430	411	16	:	:	:
38430	411	17	(	(	-LRB-
38430	411	18	_	_	NNP
38430	411	19	t	t	NNP
38430	411	20	_	_	NNP
38430	411	21	)	)	-RRB-
38430	411	22	.	.	.
38430	412	1	not	not	RB
38430	412	2	(	(	-LRB-
38430	412	3	_	_	NNP
38430	412	4	x	x	NNP
38430	412	5	_	_	NNP
38430	412	6	)	)	-RRB-
38430	412	7	.	.	.
38430	413	1	not	not	RB
38430	413	2	not	not	RB
38430	413	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	413	4	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	413	5	:	:	:
38430	413	6	ph	ph	LS
38430	413	7	]	]	-RRB-
38430	413	8	(	(	-LRB-
38430	413	9	_	_	NNP
38430	413	10	x	x	NNP
38430	413	11	_	_	NNP
38430	413	12	,	,	,
38430	413	13	_	_	NNP
38430	413	14	t	t	NNP
38430	413	15	_	_	NNP
38430	413	16	)	)	-RRB-
38430	413	17	,	,	,
38430	413	18	where	where	WRB
38430	413	19	"	"	``
38430	413	20	[	[	-LRB-
38430	413	21	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	413	22	:	:	:
38430	413	23	ph	ph	LS
38430	413	24	]	]	-RRB-
38430	413	25	(	(	-LRB-
38430	413	26	_	_	NNP
38430	413	27	x	x	NNP
38430	413	28	_	_	NNP
38430	413	29	,	,	,
38430	413	30	_	_	NNP
38430	413	31	t	t	NNP
38430	413	32	_	_	NNP
38430	413	33	)	)	-RRB-
38430	413	34	"	"	``
38430	413	35	denotes	denote	VBZ
38430	413	36	the	the	DT
38430	413	37	unasserted	unasserted	JJ
38430	413	38	propositional	propositional	JJ
38430	413	39	function	function	NN
38430	413	40	"	"	''
38430	413	41	the	the	DT
38430	413	42	doing	do	VBG
38430	413	43	wrong	wrong	NN
38430	413	44	to	to	IN
38430	413	45	the	the	DT
38430	413	46	person	person	NN
38430	413	47	_	_	NNP
38430	413	48	x	x	NNP
38430	413	49	_	_	NNP
38430	413	50	at	at	IN
38430	413	51	the	the	DT
38430	413	52	instant	instant	NN
38430	413	53	_	_	NNP
38430	413	54	t	t	NNP
38430	413	55	_	_	NNP
38430	413	56	.	.	.
38430	413	57	"	"	''
38430	414	1	By	by	IN
38430	414	2	means	mean	NNS
38430	414	3	of	of	IN
38430	414	4	the	the	DT
38430	414	5	principle	principle	NN
38430	414	6	of	of	IN
38430	414	7	double	double	JJ
38430	414	8	negation	negation	NN
38430	414	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	414	10	can	can	MD
38430	414	11	at	at	IN
38430	414	12	once	once	RB
38430	414	13	simplify	simplify	VB
38430	414	14	the	the	DT
38430	414	15	above	above	JJ
38430	414	16	expression	expression	NN
38430	414	17	into	into	IN
38430	414	18	:	:	:
38430	414	19	(	(	-LRB-
38430	414	20	_	_	NNP
38430	414	21	t	t	NNP
38430	414	22	_	_	NNP
38430	414	23	)	)	-RRB-
38430	414	24	.	.	.
38430	415	1	not	not	RB
38430	415	2	(	(	-LRB-
38430	415	3	_	_	NNP
38430	415	4	x	x	NNP
38430	415	5	_	_	NNP
38430	415	6	)	)	-RRB-
38430	415	7	.	.	.
38430	416	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	416	2	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	416	3	:	:	:
38430	416	4	ph	ph	LS
38430	416	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	416	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	416	7	_	_	NNP
38430	416	8	x	x	NNP
38430	416	9	_	_	NNP
38430	416	10	,	,	,
38430	416	11	_	_	NNP
38430	416	12	t	t	NNP
38430	416	13	_	_	NNP
38430	416	14	)	)	-RRB-
38430	416	15	;	;	:
38430	416	16	which	which	WDT
38430	416	17	can	can	MD
38430	416	18	be	be	VB
38430	416	19	thus	thus	RB
38430	416	20	read	read	VBN
38430	416	21	:	:	:
38430	416	22	"	"	``
38430	416	23	If	if	IN
38430	416	24	at	at	IN
38430	416	25	every	every	DT
38430	416	26	instant	instant	NN
38430	416	27	of	of	IN
38430	416	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	416	29	life	life	NN
38430	416	30	there	there	EX
38430	416	31	was	be	VBD
38430	416	32	at	at	RB
38430	416	33	least	least	RBS
38430	416	34	one	one	CD
38430	416	35	person	person	NN
38430	416	36	_	_	NNP
38430	416	37	x	x	NNP
38430	416	38	_	_	NNP
38430	416	39	to	to	IN
38430	416	40	whom	whom	WP
38430	416	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	416	42	did	do	VBD
38430	416	43	no	no	DT
38430	416	44	wrong	wrong	NN
38430	416	45	(	(	-LRB-
38430	416	46	at	at	IN
38430	416	47	that	that	DT
38430	416	48	instant	instant	NN
38430	416	49	)	)	-RRB-
38430	416	50	.	.	.
38430	416	51	"	"	''
38430	417	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	417	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	417	3	difficult	difficult	JJ
38430	417	4	to	to	TO
38430	417	5	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	417	6	any	any	DT
38430	417	7	one	one	NN
38430	417	8	so	so	RB
38430	417	9	sunk	sink	VBN
38430	417	10	in	in	IN
38430	417	11	iniquity	iniquity	NN
38430	417	12	that	that	IN
38430	417	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	417	14	would	would	MD
38430	417	15	not	not	RB
38430	417	16	satisfy	satisfy	VB
38430	417	17	this	this	DT
38430	417	18	hypothesis	hypothesis	NN
38430	417	19	.	.	.
38430	418	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	418	2	are	be	VBP
38430	418	3	forced	force	VBN
38430	418	4	,	,	,
38430	418	5	then	then	RB
38430	418	6	,	,	,
38430	418	7	unless	unless	IN
38430	418	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	418	9	imagination	imagination	NN
38430	418	10	for	for	IN
38430	418	11	evil	evil	NN
38430	418	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	418	13	to	to	TO
38430	418	14	be	be	VB
38430	418	15	distrusted	distrust	VBN
38430	418	16	,	,	,
38430	418	17	to	to	TO
38430	418	18	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	418	19	that	that	IN
38430	418	20	any	any	DT
38430	418	21	one	one	NN
38430	418	22	might	may	MD
38430	418	23	have	have	VB
38430	418	24	been	be	VBN
38430	418	25	there	there	RB
38430	418	26	to	to	TO
38430	418	27	have	have	VB
38430	418	28	heard	hear	VBN
38430	418	29	that	that	DT
38430	418	30	song	song	NN
38430	418	31	.	.	.
38430	419	1	Now	now	RB
38430	419	2	this	this	DT
38430	419	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	419	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	419	5	plainly	plainly	RB
38430	419	6	false	false	JJ
38430	419	7	,	,	,
38430	419	8	possibly	possibly	RB
38430	419	9	on	on	IN
38430	419	10	physical	physical	JJ
38430	419	11	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	419	12	,	,	,
38430	419	13	and	and	CC
38430	419	14	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	419	15	on	on	IN
38430	419	16	æsthetic	æsthetic	JJ
38430	419	17	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	419	18	.	.	.
38430	420	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	420	2	may	may	MD
38430	420	3	be	be	VB
38430	420	4	added	add	VBN
38430	420	5	,	,	,
38430	420	6	by	by	IN
38430	420	7	the	the	DT
38430	420	8	way	way	NN
38430	420	9	,	,	,
38430	420	10	that	that	IN
38430	420	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	420	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	420	13	quite	quite	RB
38430	420	14	possible	possible	JJ
38430	420	15	that	that	IN
38430	420	16	De	De	NNP
38430	420	17	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	420	18	was	be	VBD
38430	420	19	mistaken	mistake	VBN
38430	420	20	in	in	IN
38430	420	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	420	22	interpretation	interpretation	NN
38430	420	23	of	of	IN
38430	420	24	the	the	DT
38430	420	25	above	above	JJ
38430	420	26	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	420	27	owing	owe	VBG
38430	420	28	to	to	IN
38430	420	29	the	the	DT
38430	420	30	fact	fact	NN
38430	420	31	that	that	IN
38430	420	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	420	33	was	be	VBD
38430	420	34	unacquainted	unacquainte	VBN
38430	420	35	with	with	IN
38430	420	36	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	420	37	's	's	POS
38430	420	38	work	work	NN
38430	420	39	.	.	.
38430	421	1	In	in	IN
38430	421	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	421	3	,	,	,
38430	421	4	if	if	IN
38430	421	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	421	6	had	have	VBD
38430	421	7	not	not	RB
38430	421	8	noticed	notice	VBN
38430	421	9	the	the	DT
38430	421	10	fact	fact	NN
38430	421	11	that	that	IN
38430	421	12	_	_	NNP
38430	421	13	any	any	DT
38430	421	14	_	_	NNP
38430	421	15	two	two	CD
38430	421	16	of	of	IN
38430	421	17	the	the	DT
38430	421	18	"	"	``
38430	421	19	not	not	RB
38430	421	20	's	be	VBZ
38430	421	21	"	"	``
38430	421	22	can	can	MD
38430	421	23	not	not	RB
38430	421	24	be	be	VB
38430	421	25	cancelled	cancel	VBN
38430	421	26	against	against	IN
38430	421	27	one	one	CD
38430	421	28	another	another	DT
38430	421	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	421	30	would	would	MD
38430	421	31	have	have	VB
38430	421	32	concluded	conclude	VBN
38430	421	33	that	that	IN
38430	421	34	the	the	DT
38430	421	35	interpretation	interpretation	NN
38430	421	36	was	be	VBD
38430	421	37	:	:	:
38430	421	38	"	"	``
38430	421	39	If	if	IN
38430	421	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	421	41	had	have	VBD
38430	421	42	never	never	RB
38430	421	43	done	do	VBN
38430	421	44	any	any	DT
38430	421	45	wrong	wrong	NN
38430	421	46	to	to	IN
38430	421	47	anybody	anybody	NN
38430	421	48	.	.	.
38430	421	49	"	"	''
38430	422	1	According	accord	VBG
38430	422	2	as	as	IN
38430	422	3	the	the	DT
38430	422	4	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	422	5	for	for	IN
38430	422	6	"	"	``
38430	422	7	not	not	RB
38430	422	8	"	"	''
38430	422	9	comes	come	VBZ
38430	422	10	before	before	IN
38430	422	11	the	the	DT
38430	422	12	(	(	-LRB-
38430	422	13	_	_	NNP
38430	422	14	x	x	NNP
38430	422	15	_	_	NNP
38430	422	16	)	)	-RRB-
38430	422	17	or	or	CC
38430	422	18	between	between	IN
38430	422	19	the	the	DT
38430	422	20	(	(	-LRB-
38430	422	21	_	_	NNP
38430	422	22	x	x	NNP
38430	422	23	_	_	NNP
38430	422	24	)	)	-RRB-
38430	422	25	and	and	CC
38430	422	26	the	the	DT
38430	422	27	[	[	-LRB-
38430	422	28	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	422	29	:	:	:
38430	422	30	ph	ph	NN
38430	422	31	]	]	-RRB-
38430	422	32	,	,	,
38430	422	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	422	34	have	have	VBP
38430	422	35	an	an	DT
38430	422	36	expression	expression	NN
38430	422	37	of	of	IN
38430	422	38	what	what	WP
38430	422	39	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	422	40	called	call	VBD
38430	422	41	respectively	respectively	RB
38430	422	42	the	the	DT
38430	422	43	denial	denial	NN
38430	422	44	of	of	IN
38430	422	45	generality	generality	NN
38430	422	46	,	,	,
38430	422	47	and	and	CC
38430	422	48	the	the	DT
38430	422	49	generality	generality	NN
38430	422	50	of	of	IN
38430	422	51	denial	denial	NN
38430	422	52	.	.	.
38430	423	1	The	the	DT
38430	423	2	denial	denial	NN
38430	423	3	of	of	IN
38430	423	4	the	the	DT
38430	423	5	generality	generality	NN
38430	423	6	of	of	IN
38430	423	7	a	a	DT
38430	423	8	denial	denial	NN
38430	423	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	423	10	the	the	DT
38430	423	11	form	form	NN
38430	423	12	of	of	IN
38430	423	13	all	all	DT
38430	423	14	existential	existential	JJ
38430	423	15	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	423	16	,	,	,
38430	423	17	while	while	IN
38430	423	18	the	the	DT
38430	423	19	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	423	20	of	of	IN
38430	423	21	or	or	CC
38430	423	22	denial	denial	NN
38430	423	23	of	of	IN
38430	423	24	generality	generality	NN
38430	423	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	423	26	the	the	DT
38430	423	27	general	general	JJ
38430	423	28	form	form	NN
38430	423	29	of	of	IN
38430	423	30	all	all	DT
38430	423	31	non	non	JJ
38430	423	32	-	-	JJ
38430	423	33	existential	existential	JJ
38430	423	34	or	or	CC
38430	423	35	universal	universal	JJ
38430	423	36	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	423	37	.	.	.
38430	424	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	424	2	:	:	:
38430	424	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	424	4	48	48	CD
38430	424	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	424	6	To	to	TO
38430	424	7	which	which	WDT
38430	424	8	De	De	NNP
38430	424	9	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	424	10	drew	draw	VBD
38430	424	11	attention	attention	NN
38430	424	12	in	in	IN
38430	424	13	a	a	DT
38430	424	14	letter	letter	NN
38430	424	15	;	;	:
38430	424	16	see	see	VB
38430	424	17	(	(	-LRB-
38430	424	18	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	424	19	)	)	-RRB-
38430	424	20	S.	S.	NNP
38430	424	21	E.	E.	NNP
38430	424	22	De	De	NNP
38430	424	23	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	424	24	,	,	,
38430	424	25	_	_	NNP
38430	424	26	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
38430	424	27	of	of	IN
38430	424	28	Augustus	Augustus	NNP
38430	424	29	De	De	NNP
38430	424	30	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	424	31	_	_	NNP
38430	424	32	,	,	,
38430	424	33	London	London	NNP
38430	424	34	,	,	,
38430	424	35	1882	1882	CD
38430	424	36	,	,	,
38430	424	37	p.	p.	NN
38430	424	38	324	324	CD
38430	424	39	.	.	.
38430	425	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	425	2	49	49	CD
38430	425	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	425	4	_	_	NNP
38430	425	5	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
38430	426	1	Ma	Ma	NNP
38430	426	2	.	.	.
38430	426	3	_	_	NNP
38430	426	4	,	,	,
38430	426	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	426	6	16	16	CD
38430	426	7	.	.	.
38430	427	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	427	2	50	50	CD
38430	427	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	427	4	However	however	RB
38430	427	5	,	,	,
38430	427	6	here	here	RB
38430	427	7	,	,	,
38430	427	8	for	for	IN
38430	427	9	the	the	DT
38430	427	10	printer	printer	NN
38430	427	11	's	's	POS
38430	427	12	convenience	convenience	NN
38430	427	13	,	,	,
38430	427	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	427	15	depart	depart	VBP
38430	427	16	from	from	IN
38430	427	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	427	18	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	427	19	's	's	POS
38430	427	20	usage	usage	NN
38430	427	21	so	so	RB
38430	427	22	far	far	RB
38430	427	23	as	as	IN
38430	427	24	to	to	TO
38430	427	25	write	write	VB
38430	427	26	"	"	``
38430	427	27	not	not	RB
38430	427	28	"	"	''
38430	427	29	for	for	IN
38430	427	30	a	a	DT
38430	427	31	curly	curly	RB
38430	427	32	minus	minu	VBN
38430	427	33	sign	sign	NN
38430	427	34	.	.	.
38430	428	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	428	2	XIX	XIX	NNP
38430	428	3	IMPLICATION	IMPLICATION	VBD
38430	428	4	A	a	DT
38430	428	5	good	good	JJ
38430	428	6	illustration	illustration	NN
38430	428	7	of	of	IN
38430	428	8	the	the	DT
38430	428	9	fact	fact	NN
38430	428	10	that	that	IN
38430	428	11	what	what	WP
38430	428	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	428	13	called	call	VBN
38430	428	14	"	"	``
38430	428	15	implication	implication	NN
38430	428	16	"	"	''
38430	428	17	in	in	IN
38430	428	18	logic	logic	NN
38430	428	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	428	20	such	such	JJ
38430	428	21	that	that	IN
38430	428	22	a	a	DT
38430	428	23	false	false	JJ
38430	428	24	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	428	25	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	428	26	any	any	DT
38430	428	27	other	other	JJ
38430	428	28	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	428	29	,	,	,
38430	428	30	true	true	JJ
38430	428	31	or	or	CC
38430	428	32	false	false	JJ
38430	428	33	,	,	,
38430	428	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	428	35	given	give	VBN
38430	428	36	by	by	IN
38430	428	37	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	428	38	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	428	39	's	's	POS
38430	428	40	puzzle	puzzle	NN
38430	428	41	of	of	IN
38430	428	42	the	the	DT
38430	428	43	three	three	CD
38430	428	44	barbers	barber	NNS
38430	428	45	.	.	.
38430	429	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	429	2	51	51	CD
38430	429	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	429	4	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	429	5	,	,	,
38430	429	6	Brown	Brown	NNP
38430	429	7	,	,	,
38430	429	8	and	and	CC
38430	429	9	Carr	Carr	NNP
38430	429	10	keep	keep	VBP
38430	429	11	a	a	DT
38430	429	12	barber	barber	NN
38430	429	13	's	's	POS
38430	429	14	shop	shop	NN
38430	429	15	together	together	RB
38430	429	16	;	;	:
38430	429	17	so	so	IN
38430	429	18	that	that	IN
38430	429	19	one	one	CD
38430	429	20	of	of	IN
38430	429	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	429	22	must	must	MD
38430	429	23	be	be	VB
38430	429	24	in	in	IN
38430	429	25	during	during	IN
38430	429	26	working	working	NN
38430	429	27	hours	hour	NNS
38430	429	28	.	.	.
38430	430	1	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	430	2	has	have	VBZ
38430	430	3	lately	lately	RB
38430	430	4	had	have	VBN
38430	430	5	an	an	DT
38430	430	6	illness	illness	NN
38430	430	7	of	of	IN
38430	430	8	such	such	PDT
38430	430	9	a	a	DT
38430	430	10	nature	nature	NN
38430	430	11	that	that	WDT
38430	430	12	,	,	,
38430	430	13	if	if	IN
38430	430	14	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	430	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	430	16	out	out	RB
38430	430	17	,	,	,
38430	430	18	Brown	Brown	NNP
38430	430	19	must	must	MD
38430	430	20	be	be	VB
38430	430	21	accompanying	accompany	VBG
38430	430	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	430	23	.	.	.
38430	431	1	Further	further	RB
38430	431	2	,	,	,
38430	431	3	if	if	IN
38430	431	4	Carr	Carr	NNP
38430	431	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	431	6	out	out	RB
38430	431	7	,	,	,
38430	431	8	then	then	RB
38430	431	9	,	,	,
38430	431	10	if	if	IN
38430	431	11	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	431	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	431	13	out	out	RB
38430	431	14	,	,	,
38430	431	15	Brown	Brown	NNP
38430	431	16	must	must	MD
38430	431	17	be	be	VB
38430	431	18	in	in	IN
38430	431	19	for	for	IN
38430	431	20	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	431	21	business	business	NN
38430	431	22	reasons	reason	NNS
38430	431	23	.	.	.
38430	432	1	The	the	DT
38430	432	2	problem	problem	NN
38430	432	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	432	4	,	,	,
38430	432	5	may	may	MD
38430	432	6	Carr	Carr	NNP
38430	432	7	ever	ever	RB
38430	432	8	go	go	VB
38430	432	9	out	out	RP
38430	432	10	?	?	.
38430	433	1	Putting	put	VBG
38430	433	2	_	_	NNP
38430	433	3	p	p	NNP
38430	433	4	_	_	NNP
38430	433	5	for	for	IN
38430	433	6	"	"	``
38430	433	7	Carr	Carr	NNP
38430	433	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	433	9	out	out	RB
38430	433	10	,	,	,
38430	433	11	"	"	''
38430	433	12	_	_	NNP
38430	433	13	q	q	NNP
38430	433	14	_	_	NNP
38430	433	15	for	for	IN
38430	433	16	"	"	``
38430	433	17	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	433	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	433	19	out	out	RB
38430	433	20	"	"	''
38430	433	21	and	and	CC
38430	433	22	_	_	NNP
38430	433	23	r	r	NNP
38430	433	24	_	_	NNP
38430	433	25	for	for	IN
38430	433	26	"	"	``
38430	433	27	Brown	Brown	NNP
38430	433	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	433	29	out	out	RB
38430	433	30	,	,	,
38430	433	31	"	"	``
38430	433	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	433	33	have	have	VBP
38430	433	34	:	:	:
38430	433	35	(	(	-LRB-
38430	433	36	1	1	LS
38430	433	37	)	)	-RRB-
38430	433	38	_	_	NNP
38430	433	39	q	q	NNP
38430	433	40	_	_	NNP
38430	433	41	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	433	42	_	_	NNP
38430	433	43	r	r	NNP
38430	433	44	_	_	NNP
38430	433	45	,	,	,
38430	433	46	(	(	-LRB-
38430	433	47	2	2	LS
38430	433	48	)	)	-RRB-
38430	433	49	_	_	NNP
38430	433	50	p	p	NNP
38430	433	51	_	_	NNP
38430	433	52	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	433	53	that	that	IN
38430	433	54	_	_	NNP
38430	433	55	q	q	NNP
38430	433	56	_	_	NNP
38430	433	57	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	433	58	not-_r	not-_r	NNP
38430	433	59	_	_	NNP
38430	433	60	.	.	.
38430	434	1	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
38430	434	2	Carroll	Carroll	NNP
38430	434	3	supposed	suppose	VBD
38430	434	4	that	that	IN
38430	434	5	"	"	``
38430	434	6	_	_	NNP
38430	434	7	q	q	NNP
38430	434	8	_	_	NNP
38430	434	9	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	434	10	_	_	NNP
38430	434	11	r	r	NNP
38430	434	12	_	_	NNP
38430	434	13	"	"	''
38430	434	14	and	and	CC
38430	434	15	"	"	``
38430	434	16	_	_	NNP
38430	434	17	q	q	NNP
38430	434	18	_	_	NNP
38430	434	19	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	434	20	not-_r	not-_r	NNP
38430	434	21	_	_	NNP
38430	434	22	"	"	``
38430	434	23	are	be	VBP
38430	434	24	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
38430	434	25	,	,	,
38430	434	26	and	and	CC
38430	434	27	hence	hence	RB
38430	434	28	that	that	IN
38430	434	29	_	_	NNP
38430	434	30	p	p	NNP
38430	434	31	_	_	NNP
38430	434	32	must	must	MD
38430	434	33	be	be	VB
38430	434	34	false	false	JJ
38430	434	35	.	.	.
38430	435	1	But	but	CC
38430	435	2	these	these	DT
38430	435	3	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	435	4	are	be	VBP
38430	435	5	not	not	RB
38430	435	6	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
38430	435	7	,	,	,
38430	435	8	and	and	CC
38430	435	9	are	be	VBP
38430	435	10	,	,	,
38430	435	11	in	in	IN
38430	435	12	fact	fact	NN
38430	435	13	,	,	,
38430	435	14	both	both	CC
38430	435	15	true	true	JJ
38430	435	16	if	if	IN
38430	435	17	_	_	NNP
38430	435	18	q	q	NNP
38430	435	19	_	_	NNP
38430	435	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	435	21	false	false	JJ
38430	435	22	.	.	.
38430	436	1	The	the	DT
38430	436	2	contradictory	contradictory	NN
38430	436	3	of	of	IN
38430	436	4	"	"	``
38430	436	5	_	_	NNP
38430	436	6	q	q	NNP
38430	436	7	_	_	NNP
38430	436	8	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	436	9	_	_	NNP
38430	436	10	r	r	NNP
38430	436	11	_	_	NNP
38430	436	12	"	"	``
38430	436	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	436	14	"	"	``
38430	436	15	_	_	NNP
38430	436	16	q	q	NNP
38430	436	17	_	_	NNP
38430	436	18	does	do	VBZ
38430	436	19	not	not	RB
38430	436	20	imply	imply	VB
38430	436	21	_	_	NNP
38430	436	22	r	r	NNP
38430	436	23	_	_	NNP
38430	436	24	"	"	''
38430	436	25	which	which	WDT
38430	436	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	436	27	not	not	RB
38430	436	28	a	a	DT
38430	436	29	consequence	consequence	NN
38430	436	30	of	of	IN
38430	436	31	"	"	``
38430	436	32	_	_	NNP
38430	436	33	q	q	NNP
38430	436	34	_	_	NNP
38430	436	35	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	436	36	not-_r	not-_r	NNP
38430	436	37	_	_	NNP
38430	436	38	.	.	.
38430	436	39	"	"	''
38430	437	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	437	2	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	437	3	to	to	TO
38430	437	4	be	be	VB
38430	437	5	true	true	JJ
38430	437	6	theoretically	theoretically	RB
38430	437	7	that	that	IN
38430	437	8	,	,	,
38430	437	9	if	if	IN
38430	437	10	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	437	11	X	X	NNP
38430	437	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	437	13	a	a	DT
38430	437	14	Christian	Christian	NNP
38430	437	15	,	,	,
38430	437	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	437	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	437	18	not	not	RB
38430	437	19	an	an	DT
38430	437	20	Atheist	Atheist	NNP
38430	437	21	,	,	,
38430	437	22	but	but	CC
38430	437	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	437	24	can	can	MD
38430	437	25	not	not	RB
38430	437	26	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	437	27	from	from	IN
38430	437	28	this	this	DT
38430	437	29	alone	alone	JJ
38430	437	30	that	that	IN
38430	437	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	437	32	being	be	VBG
38430	437	33	a	a	DT
38430	437	34	Christian	Christian	NNP
38430	437	35	does	do	VBZ
38430	437	36	not	not	RB
38430	437	37	imply	imply	VB
38430	437	38	that	that	IN
38430	437	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	437	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	437	41	an	an	DT
38430	437	42	Atheist	Atheist	NNP
38430	437	43	,	,	,
38430	437	44	unless	unless	IN
38430	437	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	437	46	assume	assume	VBP
38430	437	47	that	that	IN
38430	437	48	the	the	DT
38430	437	49	class	class	NN
38430	437	50	of	of	IN
38430	437	51	Christians	Christians	NNPS
38430	437	52	is	be	VBZ
38430	437	53	not	not	RB
38430	437	54	null	null	JJ
38430	437	55	.	.	.
38430	438	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	438	2	,	,	,
38430	438	3	if	if	IN
38430	438	4	_	_	NNP
38430	438	5	p	p	NNP
38430	438	6	_	_	NNP
38430	438	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	438	8	true	true	JJ
38430	438	9	,	,	,
38430	438	10	_	_	NNP
38430	438	11	q	q	NNP
38430	438	12	_	_	NNP
38430	438	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	438	14	false	false	JJ
38430	438	15	;	;	,
38430	438	16	or	or	CC
38430	438	17	,	,	,
38430	438	18	if	if	IN
38430	438	19	Carr	Carr	NNP
38430	438	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	438	21	out	out	RB
38430	438	22	,	,	,
38430	438	23	Allen	Allen	NNP
38430	438	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	438	25	in	in	IN
38430	438	26	.	.	.
38430	439	1	The	the	DT
38430	439	2	odd	odd	JJ
38430	439	3	part	part	NN
38430	439	4	of	of	IN
38430	439	5	this	this	DT
38430	439	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	439	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	439	8	that	that	IN
38430	439	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	439	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	439	11	the	the	DT
38430	439	12	one	one	CD
38430	439	13	which	which	WDT
38430	439	14	common	common	JJ
38430	439	15	-	-	HYPH
38430	439	16	sense	sense	NN
38430	439	17	would	would	MD
38430	439	18	have	have	VB
38430	439	19	drawn	draw	VBN
38430	439	20	in	in	IN
38430	439	21	that	that	DT
38430	439	22	particular	particular	JJ
38430	439	23	case	case	NN
38430	439	24	.	.	.
38430	440	1	A	a	DT
38430	440	2	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
38430	440	3	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	440	4	(	(	-LRB-
38430	440	5	M	m	NN
38430	440	6	)	)	-RRB-
38430	440	7	once	once	RB
38430	440	8	thought	think	VBD
38430	440	9	that	that	IN
38430	440	10	the	the	DT
38430	440	11	logical	logical	JJ
38430	440	12	use	use	NN
38430	440	13	of	of	IN
38430	440	14	the	the	DT
38430	440	15	word	word	NN
38430	440	16	"	"	``
38430	440	17	implication"--any	implication"--any	NNP
38430	440	18	false	false	JJ
38430	440	19	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	440	20	being	be	VBG
38430	440	21	said	say	VBN
38430	440	22	to	to	TO
38430	440	23	"	"	``
38430	440	24	imply	imply	VB
38430	440	25	"	"	''
38430	440	26	any	any	DT
38430	440	27	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	440	28	true	true	JJ
38430	440	29	or	or	CC
38430	440	30	false	false	JJ
38430	440	31	--	--	:
38430	440	32	is	be	VBZ
38430	440	33	absurd	absurd	JJ
38430	440	34	,	,	,
38430	440	35	on	on	IN
38430	440	36	the	the	DT
38430	440	37	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	440	38	that	that	IN
38430	440	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	440	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	440	41	ridiculous	ridiculous	JJ
38430	440	42	to	to	TO
38430	440	43	suppose	suppose	VB
38430	440	44	that	that	IN
38430	440	45	the	the	DT
38430	440	46	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	440	47	"	"	``
38430	440	48	2	2	CD
38430	440	49	and	and	CC
38430	440	50	2	2	CD
38430	440	51	make	make	VBP
38430	440	52	5	5	CD
38430	440	53	"	"	''
38430	440	54	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	440	55	the	the	DT
38430	440	56	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	440	57	"	"	``
38430	440	58	M	M	NNP
38430	440	59	is	be	VBZ
38430	440	60	the	the	DT
38430	440	61	Pope	Pope	NNP
38430	440	62	.	.	.
38430	440	63	"	"	''
38430	441	1	This	this	DT
38430	441	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	441	3	a	a	DT
38430	441	4	most	most	RBS
38430	441	5	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
38430	441	6	instance	instance	NN
38430	441	7	,	,	,
38430	441	8	because	because	IN
38430	441	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	441	10	so	so	RB
38430	441	11	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	441	12	that	that	IN
38430	441	13	the	the	DT
38430	441	14	false	false	JJ
38430	441	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	441	16	that	that	WDT
38430	441	17	2	2	CD
38430	441	18	and	and	CC
38430	441	19	2	2	CD
38430	441	20	make	make	VBP
38430	441	21	5	5	CD
38430	441	22	can	can	MD
38430	441	23	rigorously	rigorously	RB
38430	441	24	be	be	VB
38430	441	25	proved	prove	VBN
38430	441	26	to	to	TO
38430	441	27	imply	imply	VB
38430	441	28	that	that	IN
38430	441	29	M	M	NNP
38430	441	30	,	,	,
38430	441	31	or	or	CC
38430	441	32	anybody	anybody	NN
38430	441	33	else	else	RB
38430	441	34	other	other	JJ
38430	441	35	than	than	IN
38430	441	36	the	the	DT
38430	441	37	Pope	Pope	NNP
38430	441	38	,	,	,
38430	441	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	441	40	the	the	DT
38430	441	41	Pope	Pope	NNP
38430	441	42	.	.	.
38430	442	1	For	for	IN
38430	442	2	if	if	IN
38430	442	3	2	2	CD
38430	442	4	and	and	CC
38430	442	5	2	2	CD
38430	442	6	make	make	VBP
38430	442	7	5	5	CD
38430	442	8	,	,	,
38430	442	9	since	since	IN
38430	442	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	442	11	also	also	RB
38430	442	12	make	make	VBP
38430	442	13	4	4	CD
38430	442	14	,	,	,
38430	442	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	442	16	would	would	MD
38430	442	17	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	442	18	that	that	IN
38430	442	19	5	5	CD
38430	442	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	442	21	equal	equal	JJ
38430	442	22	to	to	IN
38430	442	23	4	4	CD
38430	442	24	.	.	.
38430	443	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
38430	443	2	,	,	,
38430	443	3	subtracting	subtract	VBG
38430	443	4	3	3	CD
38430	443	5	from	from	IN
38430	443	6	both	both	DT
38430	443	7	sides	side	NNS
38430	443	8	,	,	,
38430	443	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	443	10	conclude	conclude	VBP
38430	443	11	that	that	IN
38430	443	12	2	2	CD
38430	443	13	would	would	MD
38430	443	14	be	be	VB
38430	443	15	equal	equal	JJ
38430	443	16	to	to	IN
38430	443	17	1	1	CD
38430	443	18	.	.	.
38430	444	1	But	but	CC
38430	444	2	if	if	IN
38430	444	3	this	this	DT
38430	444	4	were	be	VBD
38430	444	5	true	true	JJ
38430	444	6	,	,	,
38430	444	7	since	since	IN
38430	444	8	M	M	NNP
38430	444	9	and	and	CC
38430	444	10	the	the	DT
38430	444	11	Pope	Pope	NNP
38430	444	12	are	be	VBP
38430	444	13	two	two	CD
38430	444	14	,	,	,
38430	444	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	444	16	would	would	MD
38430	444	17	be	be	VB
38430	444	18	one	one	CD
38430	444	19	,	,	,
38430	444	20	and	and	CC
38430	444	21	obviously	obviously	RB
38430	444	22	then	then	RB
38430	444	23	M	M	NNP
38430	444	24	would	would	MD
38430	444	25	be	be	VB
38430	444	26	the	the	DT
38430	444	27	Pope	Pope	NNP
38430	444	28	.	.	.
38430	445	1	The	the	DT
38430	445	2	principle	principle	NN
38430	445	3	that	that	IN
38430	445	4	the	the	DT
38430	445	5	false	false	JJ
38430	445	6	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	445	7	the	the	DT
38430	445	8	true	true	JJ
38430	445	9	has	have	VBZ
38430	445	10	very	very	RB
38430	445	11	important	important	JJ
38430	445	12	applications	application	NNS
38430	445	13	in	in	IN
38430	445	14	political	political	JJ
38430	445	15	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	445	16	.	.	.
38430	446	1	In	in	IN
38430	446	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	446	3	,	,	,
38430	446	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	446	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	446	6	hard	hard	JJ
38430	446	7	to	to	TO
38430	446	8	find	find	VB
38430	446	9	a	a	DT
38430	446	10	single	single	JJ
38430	446	11	principle	principle	NN
38430	446	12	of	of	IN
38430	446	13	politics	politic	NNS
38430	446	14	of	of	IN
38430	446	15	which	which	WDT
38430	446	16	false	false	JJ
38430	446	17	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	446	18	are	be	VBP
38430	446	19	not	not	RB
38430	446	20	the	the	DT
38430	446	21	main	main	JJ
38430	446	22	support	support	NN
38430	446	23	.	.	.
38430	447	1	If	if	IN
38430	447	2	_	_	NNP
38430	447	3	p	p	NNP
38430	447	4	_	_	NNP
38430	447	5	and	and	CC
38430	447	6	_	_	NNP
38430	447	7	q	q	NNP
38430	447	8	_	_	NNP
38430	447	9	are	be	VBP
38430	447	10	two	two	CD
38430	447	11	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	447	12	,	,	,
38430	447	13	and	and	CC
38430	447	14	_	_	NNP
38430	447	15	p	p	NNP
38430	447	16	_	_	NNP
38430	447	17	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	447	18	_	_	NNP
38430	447	19	q	q	NNP
38430	447	20	_	_	NNP
38430	447	21	;	;	:
38430	447	22	then	then	RB
38430	447	23	,	,	,
38430	447	24	if	if	IN
38430	447	25	,	,	,
38430	447	26	and	and	CC
38430	447	27	only	only	RB
38430	447	28	if	if	IN
38430	447	29	,	,	,
38430	447	30	_	_	NNP
38430	447	31	q	q	NNP
38430	447	32	_	_	NNP
38430	447	33	and	and	CC
38430	447	34	_	_	NNP
38430	447	35	p	p	NNP
38430	447	36	_	_	NNP
38430	447	37	are	be	VBP
38430	447	38	both	both	DT
38430	447	39	false	false	JJ
38430	447	40	or	or	CC
38430	447	41	both	both	CC
38430	447	42	true	true	JJ
38430	447	43	,	,	,
38430	447	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	447	45	also	also	RB
38430	447	46	have	have	VBP
38430	447	47	:	:	:
38430	447	48	_	_	NNP
38430	447	49	q	q	NNP
38430	447	50	_	_	NNP
38430	447	51	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	447	52	_	_	NNP
38430	447	53	p	p	NNP
38430	447	54	_	_	NNP
38430	447	55	.	.	.
38430	448	1	The	the	DT
38430	448	2	most	most	RBS
38430	448	3	important	important	JJ
38430	448	4	applications	application	NNS
38430	448	5	of	of	IN
38430	448	6	this	this	DT
38430	448	7	invertibility	invertibility	NN
38430	448	8	were	be	VBD
38430	448	9	made	make	VBN
38430	448	10	by	by	IN
38430	448	11	the	the	DT
38430	448	12	late	late	JJ
38430	448	13	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
38430	448	14	Butler[52	butler[52	ADD
38430	448	15	]	]	-RRB-
38430	448	16	and	and	CC
38430	448	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	448	18	G.	G.	NNP
38430	448	19	B.	B.	NNP
38430	448	20	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
38430	448	21	.	.	.
38430	449	1	A	a	DT
38430	449	2	political	political	JJ
38430	449	3	application	application	NN
38430	449	4	may	may	MD
38430	449	5	be	be	VB
38430	449	6	made	make	VBN
38430	449	7	as	as	IN
38430	449	8	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	449	9	:	:	:
38430	449	10	In	in	IN
38430	449	11	a	a	DT
38430	449	12	country	country	NN
38430	449	13	where	where	WRB
38430	449	14	only	only	RB
38430	449	15	those	those	DT
38430	449	16	with	with	IN
38430	449	17	middling	middling	NN
38430	449	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	449	19	sized	sized	JJ
38430	449	20	incomes	income	NNS
38430	449	21	are	be	VBP
38430	449	22	taxed	tax	VBN
38430	449	23	,	,	,
38430	449	24	conservative	conservative	JJ
38430	449	25	and	and	CC
38430	449	26	_	_	NNP
38430	449	27	bourgeois	bourgeois	NN
38430	449	28	_	_	NNP
38430	449	29	politicians	politician	NNS
38430	449	30	would	would	MD
38430	449	31	still	still	RB
38430	449	32	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	449	33	that	that	IN
38430	449	34	the	the	DT
38430	449	35	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	449	36	"	"	``
38430	449	37	the	the	DT
38430	449	38	rich	rich	JJ
38430	449	39	are	be	VBP
38430	449	40	taxed	tax	VBN
38430	449	41	"	"	``
38430	449	42	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	449	43	the	the	DT
38430	449	44	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	449	45	"	"	``
38430	449	46	the	the	DT
38430	449	47	poor	poor	JJ
38430	449	48	are	be	VBP
38430	449	49	taxed	tax	VBN
38430	449	50	,	,	,
38430	449	51	"	"	''
38430	449	52	and	and	CC
38430	449	53	this	this	DT
38430	449	54	implication	implication	NN
38430	449	55	,	,	,
38430	449	56	which	which	WDT
38430	449	57	is	be	VBZ
38430	449	58	true	true	JJ
38430	449	59	because	because	IN
38430	449	60	both	both	CC
38430	449	61	premiss	premiss	VBP
38430	449	62	and	and	CC
38430	449	63	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	449	64	are	be	VBP
38430	449	65	false	false	JJ
38430	449	66	,	,	,
38430	449	67	would	would	MD
38430	449	68	be	be	VB
38430	449	69	quite	quite	RB
38430	449	70	unnecessarily	unnecessarily	RB
38430	449	71	supported	support	VBN
38430	449	72	by	by	IN
38430	449	73	many	many	JJ
38430	449	74	false	false	JJ
38430	449	75	practical	practical	JJ
38430	449	76	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	449	77	.	.	.
38430	450	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	450	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	450	3	equally	equally	RB
38430	450	4	true	true	JJ
38430	450	5	that	that	IN
38430	450	6	"	"	``
38430	450	7	the	the	DT
38430	450	8	poor	poor	JJ
38430	450	9	are	be	VBP
38430	450	10	taxed	tax	VBN
38430	450	11	"	"	``
38430	450	12	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	450	13	that	that	IN
38430	450	14	"	"	``
38430	450	15	the	the	DT
38430	450	16	rich	rich	JJ
38430	450	17	are	be	VBP
38430	450	18	taxed	tax	VBN
38430	450	19	.	.	.
38430	450	20	"	"	''
38430	451	1	And	and	CC
38430	451	2	this	this	DT
38430	451	3	can	can	MD
38430	451	4	be	be	VB
38430	451	5	proved	prove	VBN
38430	451	6	,	,	,
38430	451	7	in	in	IN
38430	451	8	certain	certain	JJ
38430	451	9	cases	case	NNS
38430	451	10	,	,	,
38430	451	11	on	on	IN
38430	451	12	other	other	JJ
38430	451	13	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	451	14	.	.	.
38430	452	1	For	for	IN
38430	452	2	the	the	DT
38430	452	3	taxation	taxation	NN
38430	452	4	of	of	IN
38430	452	5	the	the	DT
38430	452	6	poor	poor	JJ
38430	452	7	would	would	MD
38430	452	8	imply	imply	VB
38430	452	9	,	,	,
38430	452	10	ultimately	ultimately	RB
38430	452	11	,	,	,
38430	452	12	that	that	IN
38430	452	13	the	the	DT
38430	452	14	poor	poor	JJ
38430	452	15	could	could	MD
38430	452	16	not	not	RB
38430	452	17	afford	afford	VB
38430	452	18	to	to	TO
38430	452	19	pay	pay	VB
38430	452	20	a	a	DT
38430	452	21	little	little	JJ
38430	452	22	more	more	JJR
38430	452	23	for	for	IN
38430	452	24	the	the	DT
38430	452	25	necessities	necessity	NNS
38430	452	26	of	of	IN
38430	452	27	life	life	NN
38430	452	28	than	than	IN
38430	452	29	,	,	,
38430	452	30	in	in	IN
38430	452	31	strict	strict	JJ
38430	452	32	justice	justice	NN
38430	452	33	,	,	,
38430	452	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	452	35	ought	ought	MD
38430	452	36	;	;	:
38430	452	37	and	and	CC
38430	452	38	this	this	DT
38430	452	39	would	would	MD
38430	452	40	mean	mean	VB
38430	452	41	the	the	DT
38430	452	42	cessation	cessation	NN
38430	452	43	of	of	IN
38430	452	44	one	one	CD
38430	452	45	of	of	IN
38430	452	46	the	the	DT
38430	452	47	chief	chief	JJ
38430	452	48	means	mean	NNS
38430	452	49	of	of	IN
38430	452	50	production	production	NN
38430	452	51	of	of	IN
38430	452	52	individual	individual	JJ
38430	452	53	wealth	wealth	NN
38430	452	54	.	.	.
38430	453	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	453	2	also	also	RB
38430	453	3	see	see	VBP
38430	453	4	why	why	WRB
38430	453	5	a	a	DT
38430	453	6	valuable	valuable	JJ
38430	453	7	means	mean	NNS
38430	453	8	for	for	IN
38430	453	9	the	the	DT
38430	453	10	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	453	11	of	of	IN
38430	453	12	truth	truth	NN
38430	453	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	453	14	given	give	VBN
38430	453	15	by	by	IN
38430	453	16	the	the	DT
38430	453	17	inversion	inversion	NN
38430	453	18	of	of	IN
38430	453	19	platitudinous	platitudinous	JJ
38430	453	20	implications	implication	NNS
38430	453	21	.	.	.
38430	454	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	454	2	may	may	MD
38430	454	3	happen	happen	VB
38430	454	4	that	that	IN
38430	454	5	another	another	DT
38430	454	6	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	454	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	454	8	the	the	DT
38430	454	9	result	result	NN
38430	454	10	of	of	IN
38430	454	11	inversion	inversion	NN
38430	454	12	;	;	:
38430	454	13	but	but	CC
38430	454	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	454	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	454	16	the	the	DT
38430	454	17	fate	fate	NN
38430	454	18	of	of	IN
38430	454	19	any	any	DT
38430	454	20	true	true	JJ
38430	454	21	remark	remark	NN
38430	454	22	,	,	,
38430	454	23	especially	especially	RB
38430	454	24	if	if	IN
38430	454	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	454	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	454	27	easy	easy	JJ
38430	454	28	to	to	TO
38430	454	29	remember	remember	VB
38430	454	30	by	by	IN
38430	454	31	reason	reason	NN
38430	454	32	of	of	IN
38430	454	33	a	a	DT
38430	454	34	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	454	35	form	form	NN
38430	454	36	,	,	,
38430	454	37	to	to	TO
38430	454	38	become	become	VB
38430	454	39	a	a	DT
38430	454	40	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	454	41	in	in	IN
38430	454	42	course	course	NN
38430	454	43	of	of	IN
38430	454	44	time	time	NN
38430	454	45	.	.	.
38430	455	1	There	there	EX
38430	455	2	are	be	VBP
38430	455	3	rare	rare	JJ
38430	455	4	cases	case	NNS
38430	455	5	of	of	IN
38430	455	6	a	a	DT
38430	455	7	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	455	8	remaining	remain	VBG
38430	455	9	unrepeated	unrepeate	VBN
38430	455	10	for	for	IN
38430	455	11	so	so	RB
38430	455	12	long	long	RB
38430	455	13	that	that	IN
38430	455	14	,	,	,
38430	455	15	by	by	IN
38430	455	16	a	a	DT
38430	455	17	converse	converse	NN
38430	455	18	process	process	NN
38430	455	19	,	,	,
38430	455	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	455	21	has	have	VBZ
38430	455	22	become	become	VBN
38430	455	23	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	455	24	.	.	.
38430	456	1	Such	such	JJ
38430	456	2	,	,	,
38430	456	3	for	for	IN
38430	456	4	example	example	NN
38430	456	5	,	,	,
38430	456	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	456	7	Plato	Plato	NNP
38430	456	8	's	's	POS
38430	456	9	remark	remark	NN
38430	456	10	that	that	IN
38430	456	11	a	a	DT
38430	456	12	lie	lie	NN
38430	456	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	456	14	less	less	RBR
38430	456	15	important	important	JJ
38430	456	16	than	than	IN
38430	456	17	an	an	DT
38430	456	18	error	error	NN
38430	456	19	in	in	IN
38430	456	20	thought	thought	NN
38430	456	21	.	.	.
38430	457	1	Of	of	IN
38430	457	2	late	late	JJ
38430	457	3	years	year	NNS
38430	457	4	,	,	,
38430	457	5	a	a	DT
38430	457	6	method	method	NN
38430	457	7	of	of	IN
38430	457	8	disguising	disguising	NN
38430	457	9	platitudes	platitude	NNS
38430	457	10	as	as	IN
38430	457	11	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	457	12	has	have	VBZ
38430	457	13	been	be	VBN
38430	457	14	too	too	RB
38430	457	15	extensively	extensively	RB
38430	457	16	used	use	VBN
38430	457	17	by	by	IN
38430	457	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	457	19	G.	G.	NNP
38430	457	20	K.	K.	NNP
38430	457	21	Chesterton	Chesterton	NNP
38430	457	22	.	.	.
38430	458	1	The	the	DT
38430	458	2	method	method	NN
38430	458	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	458	4	as	as	IN
38430	458	5	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	458	6	.	.	.
38430	459	1	Take	take	VB
38430	459	2	any	any	DT
38430	459	3	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	459	4	_	_	NNP
38430	459	5	p	p	NNP
38430	459	6	_	_	NNP
38430	459	7	which	which	WDT
38430	459	8	holds	hold	VBZ
38430	459	9	of	of	IN
38430	459	10	an	an	DT
38430	459	11	entity	entity	NN
38430	459	12	_	_	NNP
38430	459	13	a	a	DT
38430	459	14	_	_	NN
38430	459	15	;	;	:
38430	459	16	choose	choose	VB
38430	459	17	_	_	NNP
38430	459	18	p	p	NNP
38430	459	19	_	_	NNP
38430	459	20	so	so	IN
38430	459	21	that	that	IN
38430	459	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	459	23	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	459	24	plausible	plausible	JJ
38430	459	25	that	that	IN
38430	459	26	_	_	NNP
38430	459	27	p	p	NNP
38430	459	28	_	_	NNP
38430	459	29	also	also	RB
38430	459	30	holds	hold	VBZ
38430	459	31	of	of	IN
38430	459	32	at	at	RB
38430	459	33	least	least	RBS
38430	459	34	two	two	CD
38430	459	35	other	other	JJ
38430	459	36	entities	entity	NNS
38430	459	37	_	_	NNP
38430	459	38	b	b	NNP
38430	459	39	_	_	NNP
38430	459	40	and	and	CC
38430	459	41	_	_	NNP
38430	459	42	c	c	NNP
38430	459	43	_	_	NNP
38430	459	44	;	;	:
38430	459	45	call	call	NN
38430	459	46	_	_	NNP
38430	459	47	a	a	DT
38430	459	48	_	_	NNP
38430	459	49	,	,	,
38430	459	50	_	_	NNP
38430	459	51	b	b	NNP
38430	459	52	_	_	NNP
38430	459	53	,	,	,
38430	459	54	_	_	NNP
38430	459	55	c	c	NNP
38430	459	56	_	_	NNP
38430	459	57	,	,	,
38430	459	58	and	and	CC
38430	459	59	any	any	DT
38430	459	60	others	other	NNS
38430	459	61	for	for	IN
38430	459	62	which	which	WDT
38430	459	63	_	_	NNP
38430	459	64	p	p	NNP
38430	459	65	_	_	NNP
38430	459	66	holds	hold	VBZ
38430	459	67	or	or	CC
38430	459	68	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	459	69	to	to	TO
38430	459	70	hold	hold	VB
38430	459	71	,	,	,
38430	459	72	the	the	DT
38430	459	73	class	class	NN
38430	459	74	A	a	NN
38430	459	75	,	,	,
38430	459	76	and	and	CC
38430	459	77	_	_	NNP
38430	459	78	p	p	NNP
38430	459	79	_	_	NNP
38430	459	80	the	the	DT
38430	459	81	"	"	``
38430	459	82	A	a	NN
38430	459	83	-	-	HYPH
38430	459	84	ness	ness	NN
38430	459	85	"	"	''
38430	459	86	or	or	CC
38430	459	87	"	"	``
38430	459	88	A	A	NNP
38430	459	89	-	-	HYPH
38430	459	90	ity	ity	NN
38430	459	91	"	"	''
38430	459	92	of	of	IN
38430	459	93	A	a	DT
38430	459	94	;	;	:
38430	459	95	let	let	VB
38430	459	96	_	_	NNP
38430	459	97	d	d	NNP
38430	459	98	_	_	NNP
38430	459	99	be	be	VB
38430	459	100	an	an	DT
38430	459	101	entity	entity	NN
38430	459	102	for	for	IN
38430	459	103	which	which	WDT
38430	459	104	_	_	NNP
38430	459	105	p	p	NNP
38430	459	106	_	_	NNP
38430	459	107	does	do	VBZ
38430	459	108	not	not	RB
38430	459	109	hold	hold	VB
38430	459	110	;	;	:
38430	459	111	and	and	CC
38430	459	112	put	put	VBD
38430	459	113	_	_	NNP
38430	459	114	d	d	NNP
38430	459	115	_	_	NNP
38430	459	116	among	among	IN
38430	459	117	the	the	DT
38430	459	118	A	A	NNP
38430	459	119	's	's	NN
38430	459	120	when	when	WRB
38430	459	121	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	459	122	think	think	VBP
38430	459	123	that	that	IN
38430	459	124	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	459	125	is	be	VBZ
38430	459	126	looking	look	VBG
38430	459	127	.	.	.
38430	460	1	Then	then	RB
38430	460	2	state	state	VB
38430	460	3	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	460	4	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	460	5	:	:	:
38430	460	6	"	"	``
38430	460	7	Some	some	DT
38430	460	8	A	A	NNP
38430	460	9	's	's	POS
38430	460	10	do	do	VBP
38430	460	11	not	not	RB
38430	460	12	have	have	VB
38430	460	13	A	a	NN
38430	460	14	-	-	HYPH
38430	460	15	ness	ness	NN
38430	460	16	.	.	.
38430	460	17	"	"	''
38430	461	1	By	by	IN
38430	461	2	further	further	JJ
38430	461	3	manipulation	manipulation	NN
38430	461	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	461	5	can	can	MD
38430	461	6	get	get	VB
38430	461	7	the	the	DT
38430	461	8	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	461	9	"	"	``
38430	461	10	No	No	NNP
38430	461	11	A	A	NNP
38430	461	12	's	's	POS
38430	461	13	have	have	VBP
38430	461	14	A	a	NN
38430	461	15	-	-	HYPH
38430	461	16	ness	ness	NN
38430	461	17	.	.	.
38430	461	18	"	"	''
38430	462	1	But	but	CC
38430	462	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	462	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	462	4	possible	possible	JJ
38430	462	5	to	to	TO
38430	462	6	make	make	VB
38430	462	7	a	a	DT
38430	462	8	very	very	RB
38430	462	9	successful	successful	JJ
38430	462	10	_	_	NNP
38430	462	11	coup	coup	NN
38430	462	12	_	_	XX
38430	462	13	if	if	IN
38430	462	14	A	a	DT
38430	462	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	462	16	the	the	DT
38430	462	17	null	null	JJ
38430	462	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	462	19	class	class	NN
38430	462	20	,	,	,
38430	462	21	which	which	WDT
38430	462	22	has	have	VBZ
38430	462	23	the	the	DT
38430	462	24	advantage	advantage	NN
38430	462	25	that	that	IN
38430	462	26	manipulation	manipulation	NN
38430	462	27	is	be	VBZ
38430	462	28	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
38430	462	29	.	.	.
38430	463	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	463	2	,	,	,
38430	463	3	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	463	4	Chesterton	Chesterton	NNP
38430	463	5	,	,	,
38430	463	6	in	in	IN
38430	463	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	463	8	_	_	NNP
38430	463	9	Orthodoxy	Orthodoxy	NNP
38430	463	10	_	_	NNP
38430	463	11	put	put	VBD
38430	463	12	A	a	NN
38430	463	13	for	for	IN
38430	463	14	the	the	DT
38430	463	15	class	class	NN
38430	463	16	of	of	IN
38430	463	17	doubters	doubter	NNS
38430	463	18	who	who	WP
38430	463	19	doubt	doubt	VBP
38430	463	20	the	the	DT
38430	463	21	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	463	22	of	of	IN
38430	463	23	logic	logic	NN
38430	463	24	,	,	,
38430	463	25	and	and	CC
38430	463	26	proved	prove	VBD
38430	463	27	that	that	IN
38430	463	28	such	such	JJ
38430	463	29	agnostics	agnostic	NNS
38430	463	30	refuted	refute	VBD
38430	463	31	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	463	32	--	--	:
38430	463	33	a	a	DT
38430	463	34	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	463	35	which	which	WDT
38430	463	36	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	463	37	to	to	TO
38430	463	38	have	have	VB
38430	463	39	pleased	please	VBN
38430	463	40	many	many	JJ
38430	463	41	clergymen	clergyman	NNS
38430	463	42	.	.	.
38430	464	1	In	in	IN
38430	464	2	this	this	DT
38430	464	3	way	way	NN
38430	464	4	,	,	,
38430	464	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	464	6	Chesterton	Chesterton	NNP
38430	464	7	has	have	VBZ
38430	464	8	been	be	VBN
38430	464	9	enabled	enable	VBN
38430	464	10	readily	readily	RB
38430	464	11	to	to	TO
38430	464	12	write	write	VB
38430	464	13	many	many	JJ
38430	464	14	books	book	NNS
38430	464	15	and	and	CC
38430	464	16	to	to	TO
38430	464	17	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	464	18	,	,	,
38430	464	19	on	on	IN
38430	464	20	almost	almost	RB
38430	464	21	every	every	DT
38430	464	22	page	page	NN
38430	464	23	,	,	,
38430	464	24	such	such	PDT
38430	464	25	these	these	DT
38430	464	26	s	s	XX
38430	464	27	as	as	IN
38430	464	28	that	that	DT
38430	464	29	simplicity	simplicity	NN
38430	464	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	464	31	not	not	RB
38430	464	32	simple	simple	JJ
38430	464	33	,	,	,
38430	464	34	heterodoxy	heterodoxy	JJ
38430	464	35	is	be	VBZ
38430	464	36	not	not	RB
38430	464	37	heterodox	heterodox	JJ
38430	464	38	,	,	,
38430	464	39	poets	poet	NNS
38430	464	40	are	be	VBP
38430	464	41	not	not	RB
38430	464	42	poetical	poetical	JJ
38430	464	43	,	,	,
38430	464	44	and	and	CC
38430	464	45	so	so	RB
38430	464	46	on	on	RB
38430	464	47	;	;	:
38430	464	48	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	464	49	building	build	VBG
38430	464	50	up	up	RP
38430	464	51	the	the	DT
38430	464	52	gigantic	gigantic	JJ
38430	464	53	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	464	54	that	that	IN
38430	464	55	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	464	56	Chesterton	Chesterton	NNP
38430	464	57	is	be	VBZ
38430	464	58	Chestertonian	Chestertonian	NNP
38430	464	59	.	.	.
38430	465	1	In	in	IN
38430	465	2	the	the	DT
38430	465	3	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	465	4	on	on	IN
38430	465	5	Identity	Identity	NNP
38430	465	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	465	7	have	have	VBP
38430	465	8	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
38430	465	9	the	the	DT
38430	465	10	use	use	NN
38430	465	11	of	of	IN
38430	465	12	a	a	DT
38430	465	13	case	case	NN
38430	465	14	of	of	IN
38430	465	15	the	the	DT
38430	465	16	principle	principle	NN
38430	465	17	that	that	IN
38430	465	18	any	any	DT
38430	465	19	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	465	20	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	465	21	any	any	DT
38430	465	22	true	true	JJ
38430	465	23	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	465	24	.	.	.
38430	466	1	This	this	DT
38430	466	2	important	important	JJ
38430	466	3	principle	principle	NN
38430	466	4	may	may	MD
38430	466	5	be	be	VB
38430	466	6	called	call	VBN
38430	466	7	_	_	NNP
38430	466	8	the	the	DT
38430	466	9	principle	principle	NN
38430	466	10	of	of	IN
38430	466	11	the	the	DT
38430	466	12	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
38430	466	13	premiss_;[53	premiss_;[53	.
38430	466	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	466	15	and	and	CC
38430	466	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	466	17	of	of	IN
38430	466	18	great	great	JJ
38430	466	19	service	service	NN
38430	466	20	in	in	IN
38430	466	21	oratory	oratory	JJ
38430	466	22	,	,	,
38430	466	23	because	because	IN
38430	466	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	466	25	does	do	VBZ
38430	466	26	not	not	RB
38430	466	27	matter	matter	VB
38430	466	28	what	what	WP
38430	466	29	the	the	DT
38430	466	30	premiss	premiss	NNP
38430	466	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	466	32	,	,	,
38430	466	33	true	true	JJ
38430	466	34	or	or	CC
38430	466	35	false	false	JJ
38430	466	36	.	.	.
38430	467	1	There	there	EX
38430	467	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	467	3	a	a	DT
38430	467	4	_	_	NNP
38430	467	5	principle	principle	NN
38430	467	6	of	of	IN
38430	467	7	the	the	DT
38430	467	8	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
38430	467	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	467	10	_	_	NNP
38430	467	11	,	,	,
38430	467	12	but	but	CC
38430	467	13	,	,	,
38430	467	14	except	except	IN
38430	467	15	in	in	IN
38430	467	16	law	law	NN
38430	467	17	-	-	HYPH
38430	467	18	courts	court	NNS
38430	467	19	,	,	,
38430	467	20	interruptions	interruption	NNS
38430	467	21	of	of	IN
38430	467	22	meetings	meeting	NNS
38430	467	23	,	,	,
38430	467	24	and	and	CC
38430	467	25	family	family	NN
38430	467	26	life	life	NN
38430	467	27	,	,	,
38430	467	28	this	this	DT
38430	467	29	is	be	VBZ
38430	467	30	seldom	seldom	RB
38430	467	31	used	use	VBN
38430	467	32	,	,	,
38430	467	33	partly	partly	RB
38430	467	34	because	because	IN
38430	467	35	of	of	IN
38430	467	36	the	the	DT
38430	467	37	limitation	limitation	NN
38430	467	38	involved	involve	VBN
38430	467	39	in	in	IN
38430	467	40	the	the	DT
38430	467	41	logical	logical	JJ
38430	467	42	impossibility	impossibility	NN
38430	467	43	for	for	IN
38430	467	44	the	the	DT
38430	467	45	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	467	46	to	to	TO
38430	467	47	be	be	VB
38430	467	48	false	false	JJ
38430	467	49	if	if	IN
38430	467	50	the	the	DT
38430	467	51	premiss	premis	NNS
38430	467	52	be	be	VB
38430	467	53	true	true	JJ
38430	467	54	,	,	,
38430	467	55	but	but	CC
38430	467	56	chiefly	chiefly	RB
38430	467	57	because	because	IN
38430	467	58	the	the	DT
38430	467	59	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	467	60	is	be	VBZ
38430	467	61	more	more	RBR
38430	467	62	important	important	JJ
38430	467	63	than	than	IN
38430	467	64	the	the	DT
38430	467	65	premiss	premiss	NNP
38430	467	66	,	,	,
38430	467	67	being	be	VBG
38430	467	68	usually	usually	RB
38430	467	69	a	a	DT
38430	467	70	matter	matter	NN
38430	467	71	of	of	IN
38430	467	72	prejudice	prejudice	NN
38430	467	73	.	.	.
38430	468	1	Certain	certain	JJ
38430	468	2	modern	modern	JJ
38430	468	3	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	468	4	,	,	,
38430	468	5	such	such	JJ
38430	468	6	as	as	IN
38430	468	7	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	468	8	,	,	,
38430	468	9	have	have	VBP
38430	468	10	found	find	VBN
38430	468	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	468	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	468	13	so	so	RB
38430	468	14	to	to	TO
38430	468	15	extend	extend	VB
38430	468	16	the	the	DT
38430	468	17	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	468	18	of	of	IN
38430	468	19	implication	implication	NN
38430	468	20	of	of	IN
38430	468	21	_	_	NNP
38430	468	22	q	q	NNP
38430	468	23	_	_	NNP
38430	468	24	by	by	IN
38430	468	25	_	_	NNP
38430	468	26	p	p	NNP
38430	468	27	_	_	NNP
38430	468	28	that	that	IN
38430	468	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	468	30	holds	hold	VBZ
38430	468	31	when	when	WRB
38430	468	32	_	_	NNP
38430	468	33	p	p	NNP
38430	468	34	_	_	NNP
38430	468	35	is	be	VBZ
38430	468	36	not	not	RB
38430	468	37	a	a	DT
38430	468	38	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	468	39	at	at	RB
38430	468	40	all	all	RB
38430	468	41	.	.	.
38430	469	1	Hitherto	Hitherto	NNP
38430	469	2	,	,	,
38430	469	3	politicians	politician	NNS
38430	469	4	,	,	,
38430	469	5	finding	find	VBG
38430	469	6	that	that	IN
38430	469	7	either	either	CC
38430	469	8	identical	identical	JJ
38430	469	9	or	or	CC
38430	469	10	false	false	JJ
38430	469	11	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	469	12	are	be	VBP
38430	469	13	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
38430	469	14	for	for	IN
38430	469	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	469	16	needs	need	NNS
38430	469	17	,	,	,
38430	469	18	have	have	VBP
38430	469	19	made	make	VBN
38430	469	20	no	no	DT
38430	469	21	use	use	NN
38430	469	22	of	of	IN
38430	469	23	this	this	DT
38430	469	24	principle	principle	NN
38430	469	25	;	;	:
38430	469	26	but	but	CC
38430	469	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	469	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	469	29	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	469	30	that	that	IN
38430	469	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	469	32	stock	stock	NN
38430	469	33	of	of	IN
38430	469	34	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	469	35	would	would	MD
38430	469	36	be	be	VB
38430	469	37	vastly	vastly	RB
38430	469	38	increased	increase	VBN
38430	469	39	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	469	40	.	.	.
38430	470	1	Logical	logical	JJ
38430	470	2	implication	implication	NN
38430	470	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	470	4	often	often	RB
38430	470	5	an	an	DT
38430	470	6	enemy	enemy	NN
38430	470	7	of	of	IN
38430	470	8	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	470	9	and	and	CC
38430	470	10	eloquence	eloquence	NN
38430	470	11	.	.	.
38430	471	1	De	De	NNP
38430	471	2	Morgan[54	Morgan[54	NNP
38430	471	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	471	4	relates	relate	VBZ
38430	471	5	"	"	``
38430	471	6	a	a	DT
38430	471	7	tradition	tradition	NN
38430	471	8	of	of	IN
38430	471	9	a	a	DT
38430	471	10	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	471	11	professor	professor	NN
38430	471	12	who	who	WP
38430	471	13	was	be	VBD
38430	471	14	once	once	RB
38430	471	15	asked	ask	VBN
38430	471	16	in	in	IN
38430	471	17	a	a	DT
38430	471	18	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	471	19	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	471	20	,	,	,
38430	471	21	'	'	''
38430	471	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	471	23	suppose	suppose	VBP
38430	471	24	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	471	25	will	will	MD
38430	471	26	admit	admit	VB
38430	471	27	that	that	IN
38430	471	28	the	the	DT
38430	471	29	whole	whole	NN
38430	471	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	471	31	greater	great	JJR
38430	471	32	than	than	IN
38430	471	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	471	34	part	part	NN
38430	471	35	?	?	.
38430	471	36	'	'	''
38430	472	1	and	and	CC
38430	472	2	who	who	WP
38430	472	3	answered	answer	VBD
38430	472	4	,	,	,
38430	472	5	'	'	''
38430	472	6	Not	not	RB
38430	472	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	472	8	,	,	,
38430	472	9	until	until	IN
38430	472	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	472	11	see	see	VBP
38430	472	12	what	what	WP
38430	472	13	use	use	NN
38430	472	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	472	15	are	be	VBP
38430	472	16	going	go	VBG
38430	472	17	to	to	TO
38430	472	18	make	make	VB
38430	472	19	of	of	IN
38430	472	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	472	21	.	.	.
38430	472	22	'	'	''
38430	472	23	"	"	''
38430	473	1	And	and	CC
38430	473	2	the	the	DT
38430	473	3	care	care	NN
38430	473	4	displayed	display	VBN
38430	473	5	by	by	IN
38430	473	6	cautious	cautious	JJ
38430	473	7	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	473	8	like	like	IN
38430	473	9	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	473	10	,	,	,
38430	473	11	Schoenflies	Schoenflies	NNPS
38430	473	12	,	,	,
38430	473	13	Borel	Borel	NNP
38430	473	14	,	,	,
38430	473	15	Hobson	Hobson	NNP
38430	473	16	,	,	,
38430	473	17	and	and	CC
38430	473	18	Baire	Baire	NNP
38430	473	19	in	in	IN
38430	473	20	abstaining	abstain	VBG
38430	473	21	from	from	IN
38430	473	22	pushing	push	VBG
38430	473	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	473	24	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	473	25	to	to	IN
38430	473	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	473	27	logical	logical	JJ
38430	473	28	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	473	29	is	be	VBZ
38430	473	30	probably	probably	RB
38430	473	31	founded	found	VBN
38430	473	32	on	on	IN
38430	473	33	the	the	DT
38430	473	34	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
38430	473	35	--	--	:
38430	473	36	but	but	CC
38430	473	37	no	no	DT
38430	473	38	less	less	RBR
38430	473	39	well	well	RB
38430	473	40	-	-	HYPH
38430	473	41	grounded	ground	VBN
38430	473	42	--	--	:
38430	473	43	fear	fear	NN
38430	473	44	of	of	IN
38430	473	45	appearing	appear	VBG
38430	473	46	ridiculous	ridiculous	JJ
38430	473	47	if	if	IN
38430	473	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	473	49	dealt	deal	VBD
38430	473	50	with	with	IN
38430	473	51	such	such	JJ
38430	473	52	extreme	extreme	JJ
38430	473	53	cases	case	NNS
38430	473	54	as	as	IN
38430	473	55	"	"	``
38430	473	56	the	the	DT
38430	473	57	series	series	NN
38430	473	58	of	of	IN
38430	473	59	all	all	DT
38430	473	60	ordinal	ordinal	JJ
38430	473	61	numbers	number	NNS
38430	473	62	.	.	.
38430	474	1	"	"	``
38430	474	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	474	3	55	55	CD
38430	474	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	474	5	They	-PRON-	PRP
38430	474	6	are	be	VBP
38430	474	7	,	,	,
38430	474	8	probably	probably	RB
38430	474	9	,	,	,
38430	474	10	as	as	IN
38430	474	11	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
38430	474	12	of	of	IN
38430	474	13	implication	implication	NN
38430	474	14	as	as	IN
38430	474	15	Gibbon	Gibbon	NNP
38430	474	16	,	,	,
38430	474	17	when	when	WRB
38430	474	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	474	19	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	474	20	that	that	IN
38430	474	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	474	22	always	always	RB
38430	474	23	had	have	VBD
38430	474	24	a	a	DT
38430	474	25	copy	copy	NN
38430	474	26	of	of	IN
38430	474	27	Horace	Horace	NNP
38430	474	28	in	in	IN
38430	474	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	474	30	pocket	pocket	NN
38430	474	31	,	,	,
38430	474	32	and	and	CC
38430	474	33	often	often	RB
38430	474	34	in	in	IN
38430	474	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	474	36	hand	hand	NN
38430	474	37	,	,	,
38430	474	38	was	be	VBD
38430	474	39	of	of	IN
38430	474	40	the	the	DT
38430	474	41	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	474	42	implication	implication	NN
38430	474	43	of	of	IN
38430	474	44	these	these	DT
38430	474	45	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	474	46	that	that	WDT
38430	474	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	474	48	hand	hand	NN
38430	474	49	was	be	VBD
38430	474	50	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	474	51	in	in	IN
38430	474	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	474	53	pocket	pocket	NN
38430	474	54	.	.	.
38430	475	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	475	2	:	:	:
38430	475	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	475	4	51	51	CD
38430	475	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	475	6	_	_	NNP
38430	475	7	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	475	8	_	_	NNP
38430	475	9	,	,	,
38430	475	10	N.	N.	NNP
38430	475	11	S.	S.	NNP
38430	475	12	,	,	,
38430	475	13	vol	vol	NNP
38430	475	14	.	.	.
38430	476	1	iii	iii	NNP
38430	476	2	.	.	NNP
38430	476	3	,	,	,
38430	476	4	1894	1894	CD
38430	476	5	,	,	,
38430	476	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	476	7	.	.	.
38430	477	1	436	436	CD
38430	477	2	-	-	SYM
38430	477	3	8	8	CD
38430	477	4	.	.	.
38430	478	1	Cf	cf	NN
38430	478	2	.	.	.
38430	479	1	the	the	DT
38430	479	2	discussions	discussion	NNS
38430	479	3	by	by	IN
38430	479	4	W.	W.	NNP
38430	479	5	E.	E.	NNP
38430	479	6	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
38430	479	7	(	(	-LRB-
38430	479	8	_	_	NNP
38430	479	9	ibid	ibid	NN
38430	479	10	.	.	.
38430	479	11	_	_	NNP
38430	479	12	,	,	,
38430	479	13	p.	p.	NN
38430	479	14	583	583	CD
38430	479	15	)	)	-RRB-
38430	479	16	and	and	CC
38430	479	17	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	479	18	(	(	-LRB-
38430	479	19	_	_	NNP
38430	479	20	P.	P.	NNP
38430	480	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	480	2	_	_	NNP
38430	480	3	,	,	,
38430	480	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	480	5	18	18	CD
38430	480	6	,	,	,
38430	480	7	note	note	VBP
38430	480	8	,	,	,
38430	480	9	and	and	CC
38430	480	10	_	_	NNP
38430	480	11	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	480	12	_	_	NNP
38430	480	13	,	,	,
38430	480	14	N.	N.	NNP
38430	480	15	S.	S.	NNP
38430	480	16	,	,	,
38430	480	17	vol	vol	NNP
38430	480	18	.	.	.
38430	481	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	481	2	.	.	NNP
38430	481	3	,	,	,
38430	481	4	1905	1905	CD
38430	481	5	,	,	,
38430	481	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	481	7	.	.	.
38430	482	1	400	400	CD
38430	482	2	-	-	SYM
38430	482	3	1	1	CD
38430	482	4	)	)	-RRB-
38430	482	5	.	.	.
38430	483	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	483	2	52	52	CD
38430	483	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	483	4	The	the	DT
38430	483	5	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
38430	483	6	of	of	IN
38430	483	7	"	"	``
38430	483	8	Erewhon	Erewhon	NNP
38430	483	9	"	"	''
38430	483	10	punished	punish	VBD
38430	483	11	invalids	invalid	NNS
38430	483	12	more	more	RBR
38430	483	13	severely	severely	RB
38430	483	14	than	than	IN
38430	483	15	criminals	criminal	NNS
38430	483	16	.	.	.
38430	484	1	In	in	IN
38430	484	2	modern	modern	JJ
38430	484	3	times	time	NNS
38430	484	4	,	,	,
38430	484	5	one	one	CD
38430	484	6	frequently	frequently	RB
38430	484	7	hears	hear	VBZ
38430	484	8	the	the	DT
38430	484	9	statement	statement	NN
38430	484	10	that	that	IN
38430	484	11	crime	crime	NN
38430	484	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	484	13	a	a	DT
38430	484	14	disease	disease	NN
38430	484	15	;	;	:
38430	484	16	and	and	CC
38430	484	17	if	if	IN
38430	484	18	so	so	RB
38430	484	19	,	,	,
38430	484	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	484	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	484	22	surely	surely	RB
38430	484	23	false	false	JJ
38430	484	24	that	that	IN
38430	484	25	criminals	criminal	NNS
38430	484	26	ought	ought	MD
38430	484	27	to	to	TO
38430	484	28	be	be	VB
38430	484	29	punished	punish	VBN
38430	484	30	.	.	.
38430	485	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	485	2	53	53	CD
38430	485	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	485	4	_	_	NNP
38430	485	5	Irrelevant	Irrelevant	NNP
38430	485	6	_	_	NNP
38430	485	7	in	in	IN
38430	485	8	a	a	DT
38430	485	9	popular	popular	JJ
38430	485	10	sense	sense	NN
38430	485	11	;	;	:
38430	485	12	one	one	PRP
38430	485	13	would	would	MD
38430	485	14	not	not	RB
38430	485	15	say	say	VB
38430	485	16	,	,	,
38430	485	17	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	485	18	loosely	loosely	RB
38430	485	19	,	,	,
38430	485	20	that	that	IN
38430	485	21	the	the	DT
38430	485	22	fact	fact	NN
38430	485	23	that	that	IN
38430	485	24	Brutus	Brutus	NNP
38430	485	25	killed	kill	VBD
38430	485	26	Cæsar	Cæsar	NNP
38430	485	27	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	485	28	that	that	IN
38430	485	29	the	the	DT
38430	485	30	sea	sea	NN
38430	485	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	485	32	salt	salt	NN
38430	485	33	;	;	:
38430	485	34	and	and	CC
38430	485	35	yet	yet	RB
38430	485	36	this	this	DT
38430	485	37	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	485	38	is	be	VBZ
38430	485	39	implied	imply	VBN
38430	485	40	both	both	CC
38430	485	41	by	by	IN
38430	485	42	the	the	DT
38430	485	43	above	above	JJ
38430	485	44	premiss	premiss	NNP
38430	485	45	,	,	,
38430	485	46	and	and	CC
38430	485	47	the	the	DT
38430	485	48	premiss	premiss	VBP
38430	485	49	that	that	IN
38430	485	50	Cæsar	Cæsar	NNP
38430	485	51	killed	kill	VBD
38430	485	52	Brutus	Brutus	NNP
38430	485	53	.	.	.
38430	486	1	Cf	cf	NN
38430	486	2	.	.	.
38430	487	1	on	on	IN
38430	487	2	such	such	JJ
38430	487	3	questions	question	NNS
38430	487	4	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	487	5	,	,	,
38430	487	6	_	_	NNP
38430	487	7	S.	S.	NNP
38430	488	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	488	2	_	_	NNP
38430	488	3	,	,	,
38430	488	4	2nd	2nd	NNP
38430	488	5	ed	ed	NNP
38430	488	6	.	.	NNP
38430	488	7	,	,	,
38430	488	8	pp	pp	NNP
38430	488	9	.	.	.
38430	489	1	240	240	CD
38430	489	2	-	-	SYM
38430	489	3	4	4	CD
38430	489	4	.	.	.
38430	490	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	490	2	54	54	CD
38430	490	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	490	4	_	_	NNP
38430	490	5	F.	F.	NNP
38430	491	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	491	2	_	_	NNP
38430	491	3	,	,	,
38430	491	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	491	5	264	264	CD
38430	491	6	.	.	.
38430	492	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	492	2	55	55	CD
38430	492	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	492	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	492	5	.	.	.
38430	493	1	Chapters	chapter	NNS
38430	493	2	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
38430	493	3	and	and	CC
38430	493	4	XXXVII	xxxvii	NN
38430	493	5	.	.	.
38430	494	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	494	2	XX	XX	NNP
38430	494	3	DIGNITY	dignity	NN
38430	494	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	494	5	have	have	VBP
38430	494	6	seen	see	VBN
38430	494	7	,	,	,
38430	494	8	at	at	IN
38430	494	9	the	the	DT
38430	494	10	end	end	NN
38430	494	11	of	of	IN
38430	494	12	the	the	DT
38430	494	13	preceding	precede	VBG
38430	494	14	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	494	15	,	,	,
38430	494	16	that	that	DT
38430	494	17	logical	logical	JJ
38430	494	18	implication	implication	NN
38430	494	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	494	20	often	often	RB
38430	494	21	an	an	DT
38430	494	22	enemy	enemy	NN
38430	494	23	of	of	IN
38430	494	24	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	494	25	.	.	.
38430	495	1	The	the	DT
38430	495	2	subject	subject	NN
38430	495	3	of	of	IN
38430	495	4	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	495	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	495	6	not	not	RB
38430	495	7	usually	usually	RB
38430	495	8	considered	consider	VBN
38430	495	9	in	in	IN
38430	495	10	treatises	treatise	NNS
38430	495	11	on	on	IN
38430	495	12	logic	logic	NN
38430	495	13	,	,	,
38430	495	14	but	but	CC
38430	495	15	,	,	,
38430	495	16	as	as	IN
38430	495	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	495	18	have	have	VBP
38430	495	19	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	495	20	,	,	,
38430	495	21	many	many	JJ
38430	495	22	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	495	23	implicitly	implicitly	RB
38430	495	24	or	or	CC
38430	495	25	explicitly	explicitly	RB
38430	495	26	seem	seem	VBP
38430	495	27	to	to	TO
38430	495	28	fear	fear	VB
38430	495	29	either	either	CC
38430	495	30	that	that	IN
38430	495	31	the	the	DT
38430	495	32	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	495	33	of	of	IN
38430	495	34	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	495	35	will	will	MD
38430	495	36	be	be	VB
38430	495	37	impaired	impair	VBN
38430	495	38	if	if	IN
38430	495	39	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	495	40	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	495	41	out	out	RP
38430	495	42	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	495	43	logically	logically	RB
38430	495	44	,	,	,
38430	495	45	or	or	CC
38430	495	46	that	that	IN
38430	495	47	only	only	RB
38430	495	48	an	an	DT
38430	495	49	act	act	NN
38430	495	50	of	of	IN
38430	495	51	faith	faith	NN
38430	495	52	can	can	MD
38430	495	53	save	save	VB
38430	495	54	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	495	55	from	from	IN
38430	495	56	the	the	DT
38430	495	57	belief	belief	NN
38430	495	58	that	that	IN
38430	495	59	,	,	,
38430	495	60	if	if	IN
38430	495	61	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	495	62	followed	follow	VBD
38430	495	63	out	out	RP
38430	495	64	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	495	65	logically	logically	RB
38430	495	66	,	,	,
38430	495	67	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	495	68	should	should	MD
38430	495	69	find	find	VB
38430	495	70	out	out	RP
38430	495	71	something	something	NN
38430	495	72	alarming	alarm	VBG
38430	495	73	about	about	IN
38430	495	74	the	the	DT
38430	495	75	past	past	NN
38430	495	76	,	,	,
38430	495	77	present	present	JJ
38430	495	78	,	,	,
38430	495	79	or	or	CC
38430	495	80	future	future	NN
38430	495	81	of	of	IN
38430	495	82	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	495	83	.	.	.
38430	496	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	496	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	496	3	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	496	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	496	5	to	to	TO
38430	496	6	inquire	inquire	VB
38430	496	7	rather	rather	RB
38430	496	8	more	more	RBR
38430	496	9	closely	closely	RB
38430	496	10	into	into	IN
38430	496	11	the	the	DT
38430	496	12	nature	nature	NN
38430	496	13	of	of	IN
38430	496	14	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	496	15	,	,	,
38430	496	16	with	with	IN
38430	496	17	a	a	DT
38430	496	18	view	view	NN
38430	496	19	to	to	IN
38430	496	20	the	the	DT
38430	496	21	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	496	22	of	of	IN
38430	496	23	whether	whether	IN
38430	496	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	496	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	496	26	,	,	,
38430	496	27	as	as	IN
38430	496	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	496	29	commonly	commonly	RB
38430	496	30	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	496	31	,	,	,
38430	496	32	a	a	DT
38430	496	33	merit	merit	NN
38430	496	34	in	in	IN
38430	496	35	life	life	NN
38430	496	36	and	and	CC
38430	496	37	logic	logic	NN
38430	496	38	.	.	.
38430	497	1	The	the	DT
38430	497	2	chief	chief	JJ
38430	497	3	use	use	NN
38430	497	4	of	of	IN
38430	497	5	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	497	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	497	7	to	to	TO
38430	497	8	veil	veil	VB
38430	497	9	ignorance	ignorance	NN
38430	497	10	.	.	.
38430	498	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	498	2	,	,	,
38430	498	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	498	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	498	5	well	well	RB
38430	498	6	known	know	VBN
38430	498	7	that	that	IN
38430	498	8	the	the	DT
38430	498	9	most	most	RBS
38430	498	10	dignified	dignified	JJ
38430	498	11	people	people	NNS
38430	498	12	,	,	,
38430	498	13	as	as	IN
38430	498	14	a	a	DT
38430	498	15	rule	rule	NN
38430	498	16	,	,	,
38430	498	17	are	be	VBP
38430	498	18	schoolmasters	schoolmaster	NNS
38430	498	19	,	,	,
38430	498	20	and	and	CC
38430	498	21	schoolmasters	schoolmaster	NNS
38430	498	22	are	be	VBP
38430	498	23	usually	usually	RB
38430	498	24	so	so	RB
38430	498	25	occupied	occupied	JJ
38430	498	26	with	with	IN
38430	498	27	teaching	teaching	NN
38430	498	28	that	that	IN
38430	498	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	498	30	have	have	VBP
38430	498	31	no	no	DT
38430	498	32	time	time	NN
38430	498	33	to	to	TO
38430	498	34	learn	learn	VB
38430	498	35	anything	anything	NN
38430	498	36	.	.	.
38430	499	1	And	and	CC
38430	499	2	because	because	IN
38430	499	3	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	499	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	499	5	used	use	VBN
38430	499	6	to	to	TO
38430	499	7	hide	hide	VB
38430	499	8	ignorance	ignorance	NN
38430	499	9	,	,	,
38430	499	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	499	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	499	12	plain	plain	JJ
38430	499	13	that	that	IN
38430	499	14	impudence	impudence	NN
38430	499	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	499	16	not	not	RB
38430	499	17	always	always	RB
38430	499	18	the	the	DT
38430	499	19	opposite	opposite	NN
38430	499	20	of	of	IN
38430	499	21	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	499	22	,	,	,
38430	499	23	but	but	CC
38430	499	24	that	that	DT
38430	499	25	dignity	dignity	NN
38430	499	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	499	27	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	499	28	impudence	impudence	NN
38430	499	29	.	.	.
38430	500	1	Dignity	dignity	NN
38430	500	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	500	3	said	say	VBN
38430	500	4	to	to	TO
38430	500	5	inspire	inspire	VB
38430	500	6	respect	respect	NN
38430	500	7	;	;	:
38430	500	8	and	and	CC
38430	500	9	this	this	DT
38430	500	10	may	may	MD
38430	500	11	be	be	VB
38430	500	12	in	in	IN
38430	500	13	part	part	NN
38430	500	14	why	why	WRB
38430	500	15	respect	respect	NN
38430	500	16	for	for	IN
38430	500	17	others	other	NNS
38430	500	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	500	19	an	an	DT
38430	500	20	error	error	NN
38430	500	21	of	of	IN
38430	500	22	judgment	judgment	NN
38430	500	23	and	and	CC
38430	500	24	self	self	NN
38430	500	25	-	-	HYPH
38430	500	26	respect	respect	NN
38430	500	27	is	be	VBZ
38430	500	28	ridiculous	ridiculous	JJ
38430	500	29	.	.	.
38430	501	1	Self	self	NN
38430	501	2	-	-	HYPH
38430	501	3	respect	respect	NN
38430	501	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	501	5	,	,	,
38430	501	6	of	of	IN
38430	501	7	course	course	NN
38430	501	8	,	,	,
38430	501	9	self	self	NN
38430	501	10	-	-	HYPH
38430	501	11	esteem	esteem	NN
38430	501	12	.	.	.
38430	502	1	William	William	NNP
38430	502	2	James	James	NNP
38430	502	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	502	4	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	502	5	that	that	IN
38430	502	6	self	self	NN
38430	502	7	-	-	HYPH
38430	502	8	esteem	esteem	NN
38430	502	9	depends	depend	VBZ
38430	502	10	,	,	,
38430	502	11	not	not	RB
38430	502	12	simply	simply	RB
38430	502	13	upon	upon	IN
38430	502	14	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	502	15	success	success	NN
38430	502	16	,	,	,
38430	502	17	but	but	CC
38430	502	18	upon	upon	IN
38430	502	19	the	the	DT
38430	502	20	ratio	ratio	NN
38430	502	21	of	of	IN
38430	502	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	502	23	success	success	NN
38430	502	24	to	to	IN
38430	502	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	502	26	pretensions	pretension	NNS
38430	502	27	,	,	,
38430	502	28	and	and	CC
38430	502	29	can	can	MD
38430	502	30	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	502	31	be	be	VB
38430	502	32	increased	increase	VBN
38430	502	33	by	by	IN
38430	502	34	diminishing	diminish	VBG
38430	502	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	502	36	pretensions	pretension	NNS
38430	502	37	.	.	.
38430	503	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	503	2	if	if	IN
38430	503	3	a	a	DT
38430	503	4	man	man	NN
38430	503	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	503	6	successful	successful	JJ
38430	503	7	,	,	,
38430	503	8	but	but	CC
38430	503	9	only	only	RB
38430	503	10	then	then	RB
38430	503	11	,	,	,
38430	503	12	can	can	MD
38430	503	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	503	14	be	be	VB
38430	503	15	both	both	CC
38430	503	16	ambitious	ambitious	JJ
38430	503	17	and	and	CC
38430	503	18	dignified	dignified	JJ
38430	503	19	.	.	.
38430	504	1	James	James	NNP
38430	504	2	also	also	RB
38430	504	3	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	504	4	that	that	IN
38430	504	5	happiness	happiness	NN
38430	504	6	increases	increase	VBZ
38430	504	7	with	with	IN
38430	504	8	self	self	NN
38430	504	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	504	10	esteem	esteem	NN
38430	504	11	.	.	.
38430	505	1	Likeness	likeness	NN
38430	505	2	of	of	IN
38430	505	3	thought	thought	NN
38430	505	4	with	with	IN
38430	505	5	one	one	PRP
38430	505	6	's	's	POS
38430	505	7	friends	friend	NNS
38430	505	8	,	,	,
38430	505	9	then	then	RB
38430	505	10	,	,	,
38430	505	11	does	do	VBZ
38430	505	12	not	not	RB
38430	505	13	make	make	VB
38430	505	14	one	one	CD
38430	505	15	happy	happy	JJ
38430	505	16	,	,	,
38430	505	17	for	for	IN
38430	505	18	otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	505	19	a	a	DT
38430	505	20	man	man	NN
38430	505	21	who	who	WP
38430	505	22	esteemed	esteem	VBD
38430	505	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	505	24	little	little	JJ
38430	505	25	would	would	MD
38430	505	26	be	be	VB
38430	505	27	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	505	28	happy	happy	JJ
38430	505	29	.	.	.
38430	506	1	Also	also	RB
38430	506	2	if	if	IN
38430	506	3	a	a	DT
38430	506	4	man	man	NN
38430	506	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	506	6	unhappy	unhappy	JJ
38430	506	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	506	8	could	could	MD
38430	506	9	not	not	RB
38430	506	10	,	,	,
38430	506	11	from	from	IN
38430	506	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	506	13	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	506	14	,	,	,
38430	506	15	by	by	IN
38430	506	16	the	the	DT
38430	506	17	principles	principle	NNS
38430	506	18	of	of	IN
38430	506	19	the	the	DT
38430	506	20	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	506	21	and	and	CC
38430	506	22	of	of	IN
38430	506	23	contraposition	contraposition	NN
38430	506	24	,	,	,
38430	506	25	be	be	VB
38430	506	26	dignified	dignify	VBN
38430	506	27	--	--	:
38430	506	28	a	a	DT
38430	506	29	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	506	30	which	which	WDT
38430	506	31	should	should	MD
38430	506	32	be	be	VB
38430	506	33	fatal	fatal	JJ
38430	506	34	to	to	IN
38430	506	35	many	many	JJ
38430	506	36	novelists	novelist	NNS
38430	506	37	'	'	POS
38430	506	38	heroes	hero	NNS
38430	506	39	.	.	.
38430	507	1	A	a	DT
38430	507	2	reflection	reflection	NN
38430	507	3	on	on	IN
38430	507	4	pessimism	pessimism	NN
38430	507	5	to	to	TO
38430	507	6	which	which	WDT
38430	507	7	this	this	DT
38430	507	8	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	507	9	gives	give	VBZ
38430	507	10	rise	rise	NN
38430	507	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	507	12	the	the	DT
38430	507	13	following	follow	VBG
38430	507	14	:	:	:
38430	507	15	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	507	16	would	would	MD
38430	507	17	appear	appear	VB
38430	507	18	that	that	IN
38430	507	19	a	a	DT
38430	507	20	man	man	NN
38430	507	21	's	's	POS
38430	507	22	self	self	NN
38430	507	23	-	-	HYPH
38430	507	24	esteem	esteem	NN
38430	507	25	would	would	MD
38430	507	26	be	be	VB
38430	507	27	increased	increase	VBN
38430	507	28	by	by	IN
38430	507	29	a	a	DT
38430	507	30	conviction	conviction	NN
38430	507	31	of	of	IN
38430	507	32	the	the	DT
38430	507	33	unworthiness	unworthiness	NN
38430	507	34	of	of	IN
38430	507	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	507	36	neighbours	neighbour	NNS
38430	507	37	.	.	.
38430	508	1	A	a	DT
38430	508	2	man	man	NN
38430	508	3	,	,	,
38430	508	4	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	508	5	,	,	,
38430	508	6	who	who	WP
38430	508	7	thinks	think	VBZ
38430	508	8	that	that	IN
38430	508	9	the	the	DT
38430	508	10	world	world	NN
38430	508	11	and	and	CC
38430	508	12	all	all	PDT
38430	508	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	508	14	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
38430	508	15	,	,	,
38430	508	16	except	except	IN
38430	508	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	508	18	,	,	,
38430	508	19	are	be	VBP
38430	508	20	very	very	RB
38430	508	21	bad	bad	JJ
38430	508	22	,	,	,
38430	508	23	should	should	MD
38430	508	24	be	be	VB
38430	508	25	extremely	extremely	RB
38430	508	26	happy	happy	JJ
38430	508	27	.	.	.
38430	509	1	In	in	IN
38430	509	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	509	3	,	,	,
38430	509	4	the	the	DT
38430	509	5	effects	effect	NNS
38430	509	6	would	would	MD
38430	509	7	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	509	8	be	be	VB
38430	509	9	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
38430	509	10	from	from	IN
38430	509	11	those	those	DT
38430	509	12	of	of	IN
38430	509	13	optimism	optimism	NN
38430	509	14	.	.	.
38430	510	1	And	and	CC
38430	510	2	optimism	optimism	NN
38430	510	3	,	,	,
38430	510	4	as	as	IN
38430	510	5	everybody	everybody	NN
38430	510	6	knows	know	VBZ
38430	510	7	,	,	,
38430	510	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	510	9	a	a	DT
38430	510	10	state	state	NN
38430	510	11	of	of	IN
38430	510	12	mind	mind	NN
38430	510	13	induced	induce	VBN
38430	510	14	by	by	IN
38430	510	15	stupidity	stupidity	NN
38430	510	16	.	.	.
38430	511	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	511	2	XXI	xxi	VBP
38430	511	3	THE	the	DT
38430	511	4	SYNTHETIC	synthetic	NN
38430	511	5	NATURE	NATURE	NNS
38430	511	6	OF	of	IN
38430	511	7	DEDUCTION	DEDUCTION	NNP
38430	511	8	Doubt	Doubt	NNP
38430	511	9	has	have	VBZ
38430	511	10	often	often	RB
38430	511	11	been	be	VBN
38430	511	12	expressed	express	VBN
38430	511	13	as	as	IN
38430	511	14	to	to	IN
38430	511	15	whether	whether	IN
38430	511	16	a	a	DT
38430	511	17	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	511	18	can	can	MD
38430	511	19	add	add	VB
38430	511	20	to	to	IN
38430	511	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	511	22	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	511	23	in	in	IN
38430	511	24	any	any	DT
38430	511	25	way	way	NN
38430	511	26	.	.	.
38430	512	1	John	John	NNP
38430	512	2	Stuart	Stuart	NNP
38430	512	3	Mill	Mill	NNP
38430	512	4	and	and	CC
38430	512	5	Henri	Henri	NNP
38430	512	6	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	512	7	,	,	,
38430	512	8	in	in	IN
38430	512	9	particular	particular	JJ
38430	512	10	,	,	,
38430	512	11	held	hold	VBD
38430	512	12	the	the	DT
38430	512	13	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	512	14	that	that	IN
38430	512	15	the	the	DT
38430	512	16	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	512	17	of	of	IN
38430	512	18	a	a	DT
38430	512	19	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	512	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	512	21	an	an	DT
38430	512	22	"	"	``
38430	512	23	analytic	analytic	JJ
38430	512	24	"	"	''
38430	512	25	judgment	judgment	NN
38430	512	26	in	in	IN
38430	512	27	the	the	DT
38430	512	28	sense	sense	NN
38430	512	29	of	of	IN
38430	512	30	Kant	Kant	NNP
38430	512	31	,	,	,
38430	512	32	and	and	CC
38430	512	33	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	512	34	could	could	MD
38430	512	35	be	be	VB
38430	512	36	obtained	obtain	VBN
38430	512	37	by	by	IN
38430	512	38	the	the	DT
38430	512	39	mere	mere	JJ
38430	512	40	dissection	dissection	NN
38430	512	41	of	of	IN
38430	512	42	the	the	DT
38430	512	43	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	512	44	.	.	.
38430	513	1	Any	any	DT
38430	513	2	one	one	CD
38430	513	3	,	,	,
38430	513	4	then	then	RB
38430	513	5	,	,	,
38430	513	6	who	who	WP
38430	513	7	maintains	maintain	VBZ
38430	513	8	that	that	IN
38430	513	9	mathematics	mathematics	NN
38430	513	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	513	11	founded	found	VBN
38430	513	12	solely	solely	RB
38430	513	13	on	on	IN
38430	513	14	logical	logical	JJ
38430	513	15	principles	principle	NNS
38430	513	16	would	would	MD
38430	513	17	appear	appear	VB
38430	513	18	to	to	TO
38430	513	19	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	513	20	that	that	IN
38430	513	21	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	513	22	,	,	,
38430	513	23	in	in	IN
38430	513	24	the	the	DT
38430	513	25	last	last	JJ
38430	513	26	instance	instance	NN
38430	513	27	,	,	,
38430	513	28	reduces	reduce	VBZ
38430	513	29	to	to	IN
38430	513	30	a	a	DT
38430	513	31	huge	huge	JJ
38430	513	32	tautology	tautology	NN
38430	513	33	.	.	.
38430	514	1	Mill	Mill	NNP
38430	514	2	,	,	,
38430	514	3	in	in	IN
38430	514	4	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	514	5	III	III	NNP
38430	514	6	of	of	IN
38430	514	7	Book	Book	NNP
38430	514	8	II	II	NNP
38430	514	9	of	of	IN
38430	514	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	514	11	_	_	NNP
38430	514	12	System	System	NNP
38430	514	13	of	of	IN
38430	514	14	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	514	15	_	_	NNP
38430	514	16	,	,	,
38430	514	17	said	say	VBD
38430	514	18	that	that	IN
38430	514	19	"	"	``
38430	514	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	514	21	must	must	MD
38430	514	22	be	be	VB
38430	514	23	granted	grant	VBN
38430	514	24	that	that	IN
38430	514	25	in	in	IN
38430	514	26	every	every	DT
38430	514	27	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	514	28	,	,	,
38430	514	29	considered	consider	VBN
38430	514	30	as	as	IN
38430	514	31	an	an	DT
38430	514	32	argument	argument	NN
38430	514	33	to	to	TO
38430	514	34	prove	prove	VB
38430	514	35	the	the	DT
38430	514	36	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	514	37	,	,	,
38430	514	38	there	there	EX
38430	514	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	514	40	a	a	DT
38430	514	41	_	_	NNP
38430	514	42	petitio	petitio	NNP
38430	514	43	principii	principii	NN
38430	514	44	_	_	NNP
38430	514	45	.	.	.
38430	515	1	When	when	WRB
38430	515	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	3	say	say	VBP
38430	515	4	All	all	DT
38430	515	5	men	man	NNS
38430	515	6	are	be	VBP
38430	515	7	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	8	,	,	,
38430	515	9	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	515	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	11	a	a	DT
38430	515	12	man	man	NN
38430	515	13	,	,	,
38430	515	14	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	515	15	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	515	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	17	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	18	,	,	,
38430	515	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	21	unanswerably	unanswerably	RB
38430	515	22	urged	urge	VBN
38430	515	23	by	by	IN
38430	515	24	the	the	DT
38430	515	25	adversaries	adversary	NNS
38430	515	26	of	of	IN
38430	515	27	the	the	DT
38430	515	28	syllogistic	syllogistic	JJ
38430	515	29	theory	theory	NN
38430	515	30	,	,	,
38430	515	31	that	that	IN
38430	515	32	the	the	DT
38430	515	33	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	515	34	,	,	,
38430	515	35	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	515	36	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	37	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	38	,	,	,
38430	515	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	40	presupposed	presuppose	VBN
38430	515	41	in	in	IN
38430	515	42	the	the	DT
38430	515	43	more	more	RBR
38430	515	44	general	general	JJ
38430	515	45	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	515	46	,	,	,
38430	515	47	All	all	DT
38430	515	48	men	man	NNS
38430	515	49	are	be	VBP
38430	515	50	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	51	;	;	:
38430	515	52	that	that	IN
38430	515	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	54	can	can	MD
38430	515	55	not	not	RB
38430	515	56	be	be	VB
38430	515	57	assured	assure	VBN
38430	515	58	of	of	IN
38430	515	59	the	the	DT
38430	515	60	mortality	mortality	NN
38430	515	61	of	of	IN
38430	515	62	all	all	DT
38430	515	63	men	man	NNS
38430	515	64	unless	unless	IN
38430	515	65	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	66	are	be	VBP
38430	515	67	already	already	RB
38430	515	68	certain	certain	JJ
38430	515	69	of	of	IN
38430	515	70	the	the	DT
38430	515	71	mortality	mortality	NN
38430	515	72	of	of	IN
38430	515	73	every	every	DT
38430	515	74	individual	individual	JJ
38430	515	75	man	man	NN
38430	515	76	;	;	:
38430	515	77	that	that	IN
38430	515	78	if	if	IN
38430	515	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	80	be	be	VBP
38430	515	81	still	still	RB
38430	515	82	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	515	83	whether	whether	IN
38430	515	84	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	515	85	,	,	,
38430	515	86	or	or	CC
38430	515	87	any	any	DT
38430	515	88	other	other	JJ
38430	515	89	individual	individual	NN
38430	515	90	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	91	choose	choose	VBP
38430	515	92	to	to	TO
38430	515	93	name	name	VB
38430	515	94	,	,	,
38430	515	95	be	be	VB
38430	515	96	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	97	or	or	CC
38430	515	98	not	not	RB
38430	515	99	,	,	,
38430	515	100	the	the	DT
38430	515	101	same	same	JJ
38430	515	102	degree	degree	NN
38430	515	103	of	of	IN
38430	515	104	uncertainty	uncertainty	NN
38430	515	105	must	must	MD
38430	515	106	hang	hang	VB
38430	515	107	over	over	IN
38430	515	108	the	the	DT
38430	515	109	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	515	110	,	,	,
38430	515	111	All	all	DT
38430	515	112	men	man	NNS
38430	515	113	are	be	VBP
38430	515	114	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	515	115	;	;	:
38430	515	116	that	that	IN
38430	515	117	the	the	DT
38430	515	118	general	general	JJ
38430	515	119	principle	principle	NN
38430	515	120	,	,	,
38430	515	121	instead	instead	RB
38430	515	122	of	of	IN
38430	515	123	being	be	VBG
38430	515	124	given	give	VBN
38430	515	125	as	as	IN
38430	515	126	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	515	127	of	of	IN
38430	515	128	the	the	DT
38430	515	129	particular	particular	JJ
38430	515	130	case	case	NN
38430	515	131	,	,	,
38430	515	132	can	can	MD
38430	515	133	not	not	RB
38430	515	134	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	135	be	be	VB
38430	515	136	taken	take	VBN
38430	515	137	for	for	IN
38430	515	138	true	true	JJ
38430	515	139	without	without	IN
38430	515	140	exception	exception	NN
38430	515	141	until	until	IN
38430	515	142	every	every	DT
38430	515	143	shadow	shadow	NN
38430	515	144	of	of	IN
38430	515	145	doubt	doubt	NN
38430	515	146	which	which	WDT
38430	515	147	could	could	MD
38430	515	148	affect	affect	VB
38430	515	149	any	any	DT
38430	515	150	case	case	NN
38430	515	151	comprised	comprise	VBN
38430	515	152	with	with	IN
38430	515	153	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	515	154	is	be	VBZ
38430	515	155	dispelled	dispel	VBN
38430	515	156	by	by	IN
38430	515	157	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	515	158	_	_	NNP
38430	515	159	aliunde	aliunde	NNP
38430	515	160	_	_	NNP
38430	515	161	;	;	:
38430	515	162	and	and	CC
38430	515	163	then	then	RB
38430	515	164	what	what	WP
38430	515	165	remains	remain	VBZ
38430	515	166	for	for	IN
38430	515	167	the	the	DT
38430	515	168	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	515	169	to	to	TO
38430	515	170	prove	prove	VB
38430	515	171	?	?	.
38430	516	1	That	that	IN
38430	516	2	,	,	,
38430	516	3	in	in	IN
38430	516	4	short	short	JJ
38430	516	5	,	,	,
38430	516	6	no	no	DT
38430	516	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
38430	516	8	from	from	IN
38430	516	9	general	general	JJ
38430	516	10	to	to	IN
38430	516	11	particular	particular	JJ
38430	516	12	can	can	MD
38430	516	13	,	,	,
38430	516	14	as	as	IN
38430	516	15	such	such	JJ
38430	516	16	,	,	,
38430	516	17	prove	prove	VB
38430	516	18	anything	anything	NN
38430	516	19	,	,	,
38430	516	20	since	since	IN
38430	516	21	from	from	IN
38430	516	22	a	a	DT
38430	516	23	general	general	JJ
38430	516	24	principle	principle	NN
38430	516	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	516	26	can	can	MD
38430	516	27	not	not	RB
38430	516	28	infer	infer	VB
38430	516	29	any	any	DT
38430	516	30	particulars	particular	NNS
38430	516	31	but	but	CC
38430	516	32	those	those	DT
38430	516	33	which	which	WDT
38430	516	34	the	the	DT
38430	516	35	principle	principle	NN
38430	516	36	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	516	37	assumes	assume	VBZ
38430	516	38	as	as	RB
38430	516	39	known	know	VBN
38430	516	40	.	.	.
38430	517	1	This	this	DT
38430	517	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
38430	517	3	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	517	4	to	to	IN
38430	517	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	517	6	irrefragable	irrefragable	JJ
38430	517	7	....	....	.
38430	517	8	"	"	''
38430	517	9	But	but	CC
38430	517	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	517	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	517	12	not	not	RB
38430	517	13	difficult	difficult	JJ
38430	517	14	to	to	TO
38430	517	15	see	see	VB
38430	517	16	that	that	IN
38430	517	17	in	in	IN
38430	517	18	certain	certain	JJ
38430	517	19	cases	case	NNS
38430	517	20	at	at	IN
38430	517	21	least	least	JJS
38430	517	22	deduction	deduction	NN
38430	517	23	gives	give	VBZ
38430	517	24	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	517	25	_	_	NNP
38430	517	26	new	new	JJ
38430	517	27	_	_	NNP
38430	517	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	517	29	.	.	.
38430	518	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	518	2	56	56	CD
38430	518	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	518	4	If	if	IN
38430	518	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	518	6	already	already	RB
38430	518	7	know	know	VBP
38430	518	8	that	that	IN
38430	518	9	two	two	CD
38430	518	10	and	and	CC
38430	518	11	two	two	CD
38430	518	12	always	always	RB
38430	518	13	make	make	VB
38430	518	14	four	four	CD
38430	518	15	,	,	,
38430	518	16	and	and	CC
38430	518	17	that	that	IN
38430	518	18	Asquith	Asquith	NNP
38430	518	19	and	and	CC
38430	518	20	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
38430	518	21	George	George	NNP
38430	518	22	are	be	VBP
38430	518	23	two	two	CD
38430	518	24	and	and	CC
38430	518	25	so	so	RB
38430	518	26	are	be	VBP
38430	518	27	the	the	DT
38430	518	28	German	German	NNP
38430	518	29	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	518	30	and	and	CC
38430	518	31	the	the	DT
38430	518	32	Crown	Crown	NNP
38430	518	33	Prince	Prince	NNP
38430	518	34	,	,	,
38430	518	35	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	518	36	can	can	MD
38430	518	37	deduce	deduce	VB
38430	518	38	that	that	IN
38430	518	39	Asquith	Asquith	NNP
38430	518	40	and	and	CC
38430	518	41	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
38430	518	42	George	George	NNP
38430	518	43	and	and	CC
38430	518	44	the	the	DT
38430	518	45	German	German	NNP
38430	518	46	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	518	47	and	and	CC
38430	518	48	the	the	DT
38430	518	49	Crown	Crown	NNP
38430	518	50	Prince	Prince	NNP
38430	518	51	are	be	VBP
38430	518	52	four	four	CD
38430	518	53	.	.	.
38430	519	1	This	this	DT
38430	519	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	519	3	new	new	JJ
38430	519	4	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	519	5	,	,	,
38430	519	6	not	not	RB
38430	519	7	contained	contain	VBN
38430	519	8	in	in	IN
38430	519	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	519	10	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	519	11	,	,	,
38430	519	12	because	because	IN
38430	519	13	the	the	DT
38430	519	14	general	general	JJ
38430	519	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	519	16	,	,	,
38430	519	17	"	"	''
38430	519	18	two	two	CD
38430	519	19	and	and	CC
38430	519	20	two	two	CD
38430	519	21	are	be	VBP
38430	519	22	four	four	CD
38430	519	23	,	,	,
38430	519	24	"	"	''
38430	519	25	never	never	RB
38430	519	26	told	tell	VBD
38430	519	27	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	519	28	there	there	EX
38430	519	29	were	be	VBD
38430	519	30	such	such	JJ
38430	519	31	people	people	NNS
38430	519	32	as	as	IN
38430	519	33	Asquith	Asquith	NNP
38430	519	34	and	and	CC
38430	519	35	Lloyd	Lloyd	NNP
38430	519	36	George	George	NNP
38430	519	37	and	and	CC
38430	519	38	the	the	DT
38430	519	39	German	German	NNP
38430	519	40	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	519	41	and	and	CC
38430	519	42	the	the	DT
38430	519	43	Crown	Crown	NNP
38430	519	44	Prince	Prince	NNP
38430	519	45	,	,	,
38430	519	46	and	and	CC
38430	519	47	the	the	DT
38430	519	48	particular	particular	JJ
38430	519	49	premisses	premiss	NNS
38430	519	50	did	do	VBD
38430	519	51	not	not	RB
38430	519	52	tell	tell	VB
38430	519	53	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	519	54	that	that	IN
38430	519	55	there	there	EX
38430	519	56	were	be	VBD
38430	519	57	four	four	CD
38430	519	58	of	of	IN
38430	519	59	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	519	60	,	,	,
38430	519	61	whereas	whereas	IN
38430	519	62	the	the	DT
38430	519	63	particular	particular	JJ
38430	519	64	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	519	65	deduced	deduce	VBN
38430	519	66	does	do	VBZ
38430	519	67	tell	tell	VB
38430	519	68	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	519	69	both	both	PDT
38430	519	70	these	these	DT
38430	519	71	things	thing	NNS
38430	519	72	.	.	.
38430	520	1	But	but	CC
38430	520	2	the	the	DT
38430	520	3	newness	newness	NN
38430	520	4	of	of	IN
38430	520	5	the	the	DT
38430	520	6	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	520	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	520	8	much	much	RB
38430	520	9	less	less	RBR
38430	520	10	certain	certain	JJ
38430	520	11	if	if	IN
38430	520	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	520	13	take	take	VBP
38430	520	14	the	the	DT
38430	520	15	stock	stock	NN
38430	520	16	instance	instance	NN
38430	520	17	of	of	IN
38430	520	18	deduction	deduction	NN
38430	520	19	that	that	WDT
38430	520	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	520	21	always	always	RB
38430	520	22	given	give	VBN
38430	520	23	in	in	IN
38430	520	24	books	book	NNS
38430	520	25	on	on	IN
38430	520	26	logic	logic	NN
38430	520	27	,	,	,
38430	520	28	namely	namely	RB
38430	520	29	"	"	``
38430	520	30	All	all	DT
38430	520	31	men	man	NNS
38430	520	32	are	be	VBP
38430	520	33	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	520	34	;	;	:
38430	520	35	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	520	36	is	be	VBZ
38430	520	37	a	a	DT
38430	520	38	man	man	NN
38430	520	39	,	,	,
38430	520	40	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	520	41	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	520	42	is	be	VBZ
38430	520	43	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	520	44	.	.	.
38430	520	45	"	"	''
38430	521	1	In	in	IN
38430	521	2	this	this	DT
38430	521	3	case	case	NN
38430	521	4	what	what	WP
38430	521	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	521	6	really	really	RB
38430	521	7	know	know	VBP
38430	521	8	beyond	beyond	IN
38430	521	9	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
38430	521	10	doubt	doubt	NN
38430	521	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	521	12	that	that	IN
38430	521	13	certain	certain	JJ
38430	521	14	men	man	NNS
38430	521	15	,	,	,
38430	521	16	A	a	NN
38430	521	17	,	,	,
38430	521	18	B	B	NNP
38430	521	19	,	,	,
38430	521	20	C	C	NNP
38430	521	21	,	,	,
38430	521	22	were	be	VBD
38430	521	23	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	521	24	,	,	,
38430	521	25	since	since	IN
38430	521	26	,	,	,
38430	521	27	in	in	IN
38430	521	28	fact	fact	NN
38430	521	29	,	,	,
38430	521	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	521	31	have	have	VBP
38430	521	32	died	die	VBN
38430	521	33	.	.	.
38430	522	1	If	if	IN
38430	522	2	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	522	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	522	4	one	one	CD
38430	522	5	of	of	IN
38430	522	6	these	these	DT
38430	522	7	men	man	NNS
38430	522	8	,	,	,
38430	522	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	522	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	522	11	foolish	foolish	JJ
38430	522	12	to	to	TO
38430	522	13	go	go	VB
38430	522	14	the	the	DT
38430	522	15	roundabout	roundabout	NN
38430	522	16	way	way	NN
38430	522	17	through	through	IN
38430	522	18	"	"	``
38430	522	19	all	all	DT
38430	522	20	men	man	NNS
38430	522	21	are	be	VBP
38430	522	22	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	522	23	"	"	''
38430	522	24	to	to	TO
38430	522	25	arrive	arrive	VB
38430	522	26	at	at	IN
38430	522	27	the	the	DT
38430	522	28	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	522	29	that	that	WDT
38430	522	30	_	_	NNP
38430	522	31	probably	probably	RB
38430	522	32	_	_	NNP
38430	522	33	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	522	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	522	35	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	522	36	.	.	.
38430	523	1	If	if	IN
38430	523	2	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	523	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	523	4	not	not	RB
38430	523	5	one	one	CD
38430	523	6	of	of	IN
38430	523	7	the	the	DT
38430	523	8	men	man	NNS
38430	523	9	on	on	IN
38430	523	10	whom	whom	WP
38430	523	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	523	12	induction	induction	NN
38430	523	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	523	14	based	base	VBN
38430	523	15	,	,	,
38430	523	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	523	17	shall	shall	MD
38430	523	18	still	still	RB
38430	523	19	do	do	VB
38430	523	20	better	well	JJR
38430	523	21	to	to	TO
38430	523	22	argue	argue	VB
38430	523	23	straight	straight	RB
38430	523	24	from	from	IN
38430	523	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	523	26	A	a	NN
38430	523	27	,	,	,
38430	523	28	B	b	NN
38430	523	29	,	,	,
38430	523	30	C	C	NNP
38430	523	31	,	,	,
38430	523	32	to	to	IN
38430	523	33	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	523	34	,	,	,
38430	523	35	than	than	IN
38430	523	36	to	to	TO
38430	523	37	go	go	VB
38430	523	38	round	round	RB
38430	523	39	by	by	IN
38430	523	40	the	the	DT
38430	523	41	general	general	JJ
38430	523	42	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	523	43	,	,	,
38430	523	44	"	"	''
38430	523	45	all	all	DT
38430	523	46	men	man	NNS
38430	523	47	are	be	VBP
38430	523	48	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	523	49	.	.	.
38430	523	50	"	"	''
38430	524	1	For	for	IN
38430	524	2	the	the	DT
38430	524	3	probability	probability	NN
38430	524	4	that	that	WDT
38430	524	5	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	524	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	524	7	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	524	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	524	9	greater	great	JJR
38430	524	10	,	,	,
38430	524	11	on	on	IN
38430	524	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	524	13	data	datum	NNS
38430	524	14	,	,	,
38430	524	15	than	than	IN
38430	524	16	the	the	DT
38430	524	17	probability	probability	NN
38430	524	18	that	that	WDT
38430	524	19	all	all	DT
38430	524	20	men	man	NNS
38430	524	21	are	be	VBP
38430	524	22	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	524	23	.	.	.
38430	525	1	This	this	DT
38430	525	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	525	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	525	4	,	,	,
38430	525	5	because	because	IN
38430	525	6	if	if	IN
38430	525	7	all	all	DT
38430	525	8	men	man	NNS
38430	525	9	are	be	VBP
38430	525	10	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	525	11	,	,	,
38430	525	12	so	so	RB
38430	525	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	525	14	Socrates	Socrates	NNPS
38430	525	15	;	;	:
38430	525	16	but	but	CC
38430	525	17	if	if	IN
38430	525	18	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	525	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	525	20	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	525	21	,	,	,
38430	525	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	525	23	does	do	VBZ
38430	525	24	not	not	RB
38430	525	25	follow	follow	VB
38430	525	26	that	that	IN
38430	525	27	all	all	DT
38430	525	28	men	man	NNS
38430	525	29	are	be	VBP
38430	525	30	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	525	31	.	.	.
38430	526	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	526	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	526	3	shall	shall	MD
38430	526	4	reach	reach	VB
38430	526	5	the	the	DT
38430	526	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	526	7	that	that	IN
38430	526	8	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	526	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	526	10	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	526	11	,	,	,
38430	526	12	with	with	IN
38430	526	13	a	a	DT
38430	526	14	greater	great	JJR
38430	526	15	approach	approach	NN
38430	526	16	to	to	TO
38430	526	17	certainty	certainty	VB
38430	526	18	if	if	IN
38430	526	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	526	20	make	make	VBP
38430	526	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	526	22	argument	argument	NN
38430	526	23	purely	purely	RB
38430	526	24	inductive	inductive	JJ
38430	526	25	than	than	IN
38430	526	26	if	if	IN
38430	526	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	526	28	go	go	VBP
38430	526	29	by	by	IN
38430	526	30	way	way	NN
38430	526	31	of	of	IN
38430	526	32	"	"	``
38430	526	33	all	all	DT
38430	526	34	men	man	NNS
38430	526	35	are	be	VBP
38430	526	36	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	526	37	"	"	''
38430	526	38	and	and	CC
38430	526	39	then	then	RB
38430	526	40	use	use	VBP
38430	526	41	deduction	deduction	NN
38430	526	42	.	.	.
38430	527	1	Many	many	JJ
38430	527	2	years	year	NNS
38430	527	3	ago	ago	RB
38430	527	4	there	there	EX
38430	527	5	appeared	appear	VBD
38430	527	6	,	,	,
38430	527	7	principally	principally	RB
38430	527	8	owing	owe	VBG
38430	527	9	to	to	IN
38430	527	10	the	the	DT
38430	527	11	initiative	initiative	NN
38430	527	12	of	of	IN
38430	527	13	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	527	14	F.	F.	NNP
38430	527	15	C.	C.	NNP
38430	527	16	S.	S.	NNP
38430	527	17	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
38430	527	18	of	of	IN
38430	527	19	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	527	20	,	,	,
38430	527	21	a	a	DT
38430	527	22	comic	comic	JJ
38430	527	23	number	number	NN
38430	527	24	of	of	IN
38430	527	25	_	_	NNP
38430	527	26	Mind	Mind	NNP
38430	527	27	_	_	NNP
38430	527	28	.	.	.
38430	528	1	The	the	DT
38430	528	2	idea	idea	NN
38430	528	3	was	be	VBD
38430	528	4	extraordinarily	extraordinarily	RB
38430	528	5	good	good	JJ
38430	528	6	,	,	,
38430	528	7	not	not	RB
38430	528	8	so	so	RB
38430	528	9	the	the	DT
38430	528	10	execution	execution	NN
38430	528	11	.	.	.
38430	529	1	A	a	DT
38430	529	2	German	german	JJ
38430	529	3	friend	friend	NN
38430	529	4	of	of	IN
38430	529	5	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	529	6	Schiller	Schiller	NNP
38430	529	7	was	be	VBD
38430	529	8	puzzled	puzzle	VBN
38430	529	9	by	by	IN
38430	529	10	the	the	DT
38430	529	11	appearance	appearance	NN
38430	529	12	of	of	IN
38430	529	13	the	the	DT
38430	529	14	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
38430	529	15	,	,	,
38430	529	16	which	which	WDT
38430	529	17	were	be	VBD
38430	529	18	doubtfully	doubtfully	RB
38430	529	19	humorous	humorous	JJ
38430	529	20	.	.	.
38430	530	1	However	however	RB
38430	530	2	,	,	,
38430	530	3	by	by	IN
38430	530	4	a	a	DT
38430	530	5	syllogistic	syllogistic	JJ
38430	530	6	process	process	NN
38430	530	7	,	,	,
38430	530	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	530	9	acquired	acquire	VBD
38430	530	10	information	information	NN
38430	530	11	which	which	WDT
38430	530	12	was	be	VBD
38430	530	13	new	new	JJ
38430	530	14	and	and	CC
38430	530	15	useful	useful	JJ
38430	530	16	to	to	IN
38430	530	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	530	18	,	,	,
38430	530	19	and	and	CC
38430	530	20	thus	thus	RB
38430	530	21	incidentally	incidentally	RB
38430	530	22	refuted	refute	VBN
38430	530	23	Mill	Mill	NNP
38430	530	24	.	.	.
38430	531	1	Presumably	presumably	RB
38430	531	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	531	3	started	start	VBD
38430	531	4	from	from	IN
38430	531	5	the	the	DT
38430	531	6	title	title	NN
38430	531	7	of	of	IN
38430	531	8	the	the	DT
38430	531	9	magazine	magazine	NN
38430	531	10	(	(	-LRB-
38430	531	11	_	_	NNP
38430	531	12	Mind	Mind	NNP
38430	531	13	!	!	.
38430	531	14	_	_	NNP
38430	531	15	)	)	-RRB-
38430	531	16	,	,	,
38430	531	17	for	for	IN
38430	531	18	a	a	DT
38430	531	19	mark	mark	NN
38430	531	20	of	of	IN
38430	531	21	exclamation	exclamation	NN
38430	531	22	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	531	23	nearly	nearly	RB
38430	531	24	always	always	RB
38430	531	25	in	in	IN
38430	531	26	German	German	NNP
38430	531	27	to	to	TO
38430	531	28	be	be	VB
38430	531	29	a	a	DT
38430	531	30	sign	sign	NN
38430	531	31	of	of	IN
38430	531	32	an	an	DT
38430	531	33	intended	intended	JJ
38430	531	34	joke	joke	NN
38430	531	35	(	(	-LRB-
38430	531	36	including	include	VBG
38430	531	37	of	of	IN
38430	531	38	course	course	NN
38430	531	39	the	the	DT
38430	531	40	mark	mark	NN
38430	531	41	after	after	IN
38430	531	42	the	the	DT
38430	531	43	politeness	politeness	NN
38430	531	44	expressed	express	VBN
38430	531	45	in	in	IN
38430	531	46	the	the	DT
38430	531	47	first	first	JJ
38430	531	48	sentence	sentence	NN
38430	531	49	of	of	IN
38430	531	50	a	a	DT
38430	531	51	private	private	JJ
38430	531	52	letter	letter	NN
38430	531	53	or	or	CC
38430	531	54	a	a	DT
38430	531	55	public	public	JJ
38430	531	56	address	address	NN
38430	531	57	)	)	-RRB-
38430	531	58	.	.	.
38430	532	1	There	there	EX
38430	532	2	would	would	MD
38430	532	3	be	be	VB
38430	532	4	,	,	,
38430	532	5	then	then	RB
38430	532	6	,	,	,
38430	532	7	the	the	DT
38430	532	8	following	following	JJ
38430	532	9	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	532	10	:	:	:
38430	532	11	This	this	DT
38430	532	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	532	13	a	a	DT
38430	532	14	book	book	NN
38430	532	15	of	of	IN
38430	532	16	would	would	MD
38430	532	17	-	-	HYPH
38430	532	18	be	be	VB
38430	532	19	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	532	20	(	(	-LRB-
38430	532	21	i.e.	i.e.	FW
38430	533	1	everything	everything	NN
38430	533	2	in	in	IN
38430	533	3	this	this	DT
38430	533	4	book	book	NN
38430	533	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	533	6	a	a	DT
38430	533	7	would	would	MD
38430	533	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	533	9	be	be	VB
38430	533	10	joke	joke	NN
38430	533	11	)	)	-RRB-
38430	533	12	;	;	:
38430	533	13	This	this	DT
38430	533	14	advertisement	advertisement	NN
38430	533	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	533	16	in	in	IN
38430	533	17	this	this	DT
38430	533	18	book	book	NN
38430	533	19	;	;	:
38430	533	20	Therefore	therefore	RB
38430	533	21	,	,	,
38430	533	22	this	this	DT
38430	533	23	advertisement	advertisement	NN
38430	533	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	533	25	a	a	DT
38430	533	26	would	would	MD
38430	533	27	-	-	HYPH
38430	533	28	be	be	VB
38430	533	29	joke	joke	NN
38430	533	30	.	.	.
38430	534	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	534	2	the	the	DT
38430	534	3	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	534	4	may	may	MD
38430	534	5	be	be	VB
38430	534	6	almost	almost	RB
38430	534	7	as	as	RB
38430	534	8	powerful	powerful	JJ
38430	534	9	an	an	DT
38430	534	10	agent	agent	NN
38430	534	11	in	in	IN
38430	534	12	the	the	DT
38430	534	13	detection	detection	NN
38430	534	14	of	of	IN
38430	534	15	humour	humour	NN
38430	534	16	as	as	IN
38430	534	17	M.	M.	NNP
38430	534	18	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	534	19	's	's	POS
38430	534	20	criterion	criterion	NN
38430	534	21	,	,	,
38430	534	22	to	to	TO
38430	534	23	be	be	VB
38430	534	24	described	describe	VBN
38430	534	25	in	in	IN
38430	534	26	a	a	DT
38430	534	27	future	future	JJ
38430	534	28	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	534	29	.	.	.
38430	535	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	535	2	57	57	CD
38430	535	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	535	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	535	5	:	:	:
38430	535	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	535	7	56	56	CD
38430	535	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	535	9	[	[	-LRB-
38430	535	10	The	the	DT
38430	535	11	following	follow	VBG
38430	535	12	passage	passage	NN
38430	535	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	535	14	almost	almost	RB
38430	535	15	word	word	NN
38430	535	16	for	for	IN
38430	535	17	word	word	NN
38430	535	18	the	the	DT
38430	535	19	same	same	JJ
38430	535	20	as	as	IN
38430	535	21	a	a	DT
38430	535	22	passage	passage	NN
38430	535	23	on	on	IN
38430	535	24	pp	pp	NNP
38430	535	25	.	.	.
38430	536	1	123	123	CD
38430	536	2	-	-	SYM
38430	536	3	5	5	CD
38430	536	4	of	of	IN
38430	536	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	536	6	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	536	7	's	's	POS
38430	536	8	_	_	NNP
38430	536	9	Problems	Problems	NNPS
38430	536	10	of	of	IN
38430	536	11	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	536	12	_	_	NNP
38430	536	13	,	,	,
38430	536	14	first	first	RB
38430	536	15	published	publish	VBN
38430	536	16	in	in	IN
38430	536	17	1912	1912	CD
38430	536	18	,	,	,
38430	536	19	a	a	DT
38430	536	20	year	year	NN
38430	536	21	after	after	IN
38430	536	22	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	536	23	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	536	24	's	's	POS
38430	536	25	death	death	NN
38430	536	26	.	.	.
38430	537	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	537	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	537	3	easy	easy	JJ
38430	537	4	hastily	hastily	RB
38430	537	5	to	to	TO
38430	537	6	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	537	7	that	that	IN
38430	537	8	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	537	9	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	537	10	was	be	VBD
38430	537	11	indebted	indebte	VBN
38430	537	12	to	to	IN
38430	537	13	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	537	14	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	537	15	to	to	IN
38430	537	16	a	a	DT
38430	537	17	greater	great	JJR
38430	537	18	degree	degree	NN
38430	537	19	than	than	IN
38430	537	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	537	21	usually	usually	RB
38430	537	22	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	537	23	.	.	.
38430	538	1	But	but	CC
38430	538	2	an	an	DT
38430	538	3	examination	examination	NN
38430	538	4	of	of	IN
38430	538	5	the	the	DT
38430	538	6	internal	internal	JJ
38430	538	7	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	538	8	leads	lead	VBZ
38430	538	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	538	10	to	to	IN
38430	538	11	another	another	DT
38430	538	12	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	538	13	.	.	.
38430	539	1	The	the	DT
38430	539	2	two	two	CD
38430	539	3	texts	text	NNS
38430	539	4	,	,	,
38430	539	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	539	6	will	will	MD
38430	539	7	be	be	VB
38430	539	8	found	find	VBN
38430	539	9	,	,	,
38430	539	10	differ	differ	VB
38430	539	11	only	only	RB
38430	539	12	in	in	IN
38430	539	13	the	the	DT
38430	539	14	names	name	NNS
38430	539	15	of	of	IN
38430	539	16	the	the	DT
38430	539	17	German	German	NNP
38430	539	18	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	539	19	,	,	,
38430	539	20	the	the	DT
38430	539	21	Crown	Crown	NNP
38430	539	22	Prince	Prince	NNP
38430	539	23	and	and	CC
38430	539	24	the	the	DT
38430	539	25	other	other	JJ
38430	539	26	personages	personage	NNS
38430	539	27	being	be	VBG
38430	539	28	replaced	replace	VBN
38430	539	29	,	,	,
38430	539	30	in	in	IN
38430	539	31	the	the	DT
38430	539	32	book	book	NN
38430	539	33	of	of	IN
38430	539	34	1912	1912	CD
38430	539	35	,	,	,
38430	539	36	by	by	IN
38430	539	37	those	those	DT
38430	539	38	of	of	IN
38430	539	39	Messrs.	Messrs.	NNP
38430	539	40	Brown	Brown	NNP
38430	539	41	,	,	,
38430	539	42	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	539	43	,	,	,
38430	539	44	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	539	45	,	,	,
38430	539	46	and	and	CC
38430	539	47	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
38430	539	48	.	.	.
38430	540	1	Now	now	RB
38430	540	2	,	,	,
38430	540	3	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	540	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	540	5	,	,	,
38430	540	6	in	in	IN
38430	540	7	a	a	DT
38430	540	8	new	new	JJ
38430	540	9	edition	edition	NN
38430	540	10	of	of	IN
38430	540	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	540	12	_	_	NNP
38430	540	13	Problems	Problems	NNPS
38430	540	14	_	_	NNP
38430	540	15	issued	issue	VBD
38430	540	16	near	near	IN
38430	540	17	the	the	DT
38430	540	18	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	540	19	of	of	IN
38430	540	20	the	the	DT
38430	540	21	European	european	JJ
38430	540	22	war	war	NN
38430	540	23	and	and	CC
38430	540	24	before	before	IN
38430	540	25	the	the	DT
38430	540	26	Russian	russian	JJ
38430	540	27	revolution	revolution	NN
38430	540	28	,	,	,
38430	540	29	substituted	substitute	VBD
38430	540	30	"	"	``
38430	540	31	the	the	DT
38430	540	32	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	540	33	of	of	IN
38430	540	34	Russia	Russia	NNP
38430	540	35	"	"	''
38430	540	36	for	for	IN
38430	540	37	"	"	``
38430	540	38	the	the	DT
38430	540	39	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
38430	540	40	of	of	IN
38430	540	41	China	China	NNP
38430	540	42	"	"	''
38430	540	43	of	of	IN
38430	540	44	the	the	DT
38430	540	45	first	first	JJ
38430	540	46	edition	edition	NN
38430	540	47	.	.	.
38430	541	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	541	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	541	3	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	541	4	quite	quite	RB
38430	541	5	likely	likely	JJ
38430	541	6	that	that	IN
38430	541	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	541	8	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	541	9	,	,	,
38430	541	10	who	who	WP
38430	541	11	has	have	VBZ
38430	541	12	always	always	RB
38430	541	13	shown	show	VBN
38430	541	14	a	a	DT
38430	541	15	tendency	tendency	NN
38430	541	16	to	to	TO
38430	541	17	substitute	substitute	VB
38430	541	18	existents	existent	NNS
38430	541	19	for	for	IN
38430	541	20	nonentities	nonentity	NNS
38430	541	21	,	,	,
38430	541	22	wrote	write	VBD
38430	541	23	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	541	24	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	541	25	's	's	POS
38430	541	26	notes.--<sc	notes.--<sc	CD
38430	541	27	>	>	NN
38430	541	28	Ed.</sc	ed.</sc	JJ
38430	541	29	>	>	XX
38430	541	30	]	]	-RRB-
38430	541	31	[	[	-LRB-
38430	541	32	57	57	CD
38430	541	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	541	34	[	[	-LRB-
38430	541	35	See	see	VB
38430	541	36	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	541	37	XLII.--ED	xlii.--ed	NN
38430	541	38	.	.	.
38430	541	39	]	]	-RRB-
38430	542	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	542	2	XXII	xxii	NN
38430	542	3	THE	the	DT
38430	542	4	MORTALITY	mortality	NN
38430	542	5	OF	of	IN
38430	542	6	SOCRATES	socrates	NN
38430	542	7	The	the	DT
38430	542	8	mortality	mortality	NN
38430	542	9	of	of	IN
38430	542	10	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	542	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	542	12	so	so	RB
38430	542	13	often	often	RB
38430	542	14	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	542	15	in	in	IN
38430	542	16	books	book	NNS
38430	542	17	on	on	IN
38430	542	18	logic	logic	NN
38430	542	19	that	that	IN
38430	542	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	542	21	may	may	MD
38430	542	22	be	be	VB
38430	542	23	as	as	RB
38430	542	24	well	well	RB
38430	542	25	briefly	briefly	NN
38430	542	26	to	to	TO
38430	542	27	consider	consider	VB
38430	542	28	what	what	WP
38430	542	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	542	30	means	mean	VBZ
38430	542	31	.	.	.
38430	543	1	The	the	DT
38430	543	2	phrase	phrase	NN
38430	543	3	"	"	``
38430	543	4	Socrates	socrates	NN
38430	543	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	543	6	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	543	7	"	"	``
38430	543	8	may	may	MD
38430	543	9	be	be	VB
38430	543	10	thus	thus	RB
38430	543	11	defined	define	VBN
38430	543	12	:	:	:
38430	543	13	"	"	``
38430	543	14	There	there	EX
38430	543	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	543	16	at	at	RB
38430	543	17	least	least	RBS
38430	543	18	one	one	CD
38430	543	19	instant	instant	NN
38430	543	20	_	_	NNP
38430	543	21	t	t	NNP
38430	543	22	_	_	NNP
38430	543	23	such	such	JJ
38430	543	24	that	that	IN
38430	543	25	_	_	NNP
38430	543	26	t	t	NNP
38430	543	27	_	_	NNP
38430	543	28	has	have	VBZ
38430	543	29	not	not	RB
38430	543	30	to	to	TO
38430	543	31	Socrates	socrates	VB
38430	543	32	the	the	DT
38430	543	33	one	one	CD
38430	543	34	-	-	HYPH
38430	543	35	many	many	JJ
38430	543	36	relation	relation	NN
38430	543	37	R	r	NN
38430	543	38	which	which	WDT
38430	543	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	543	40	the	the	DT
38430	543	41	converse	converse	NN
38430	543	42	of	of	IN
38430	543	43	the	the	DT
38430	543	44	relation	relation	NN
38430	543	45	'	'	''
38430	543	46	exists	exist	VBZ
38430	543	47	at	at	IN
38430	543	48	,	,	,
38430	543	49	'	'	''
38430	543	50	and	and	CC
38430	543	51	all	all	DT
38430	543	52	instants	instant	NNS
38430	543	53	following	follow	VBG
38430	543	54	_	_	NNP
38430	543	55	t	t	NNP
38430	543	56	_	_	NNP
38430	543	57	have	have	VBP
38430	543	58	not	not	RB
38430	543	59	the	the	DT
38430	543	60	relation	relation	NN
38430	543	61	R	r	NN
38430	543	62	to	to	IN
38430	543	63	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	543	64	,	,	,
38430	543	65	and	and	CC
38430	543	66	there	there	EX
38430	543	67	is	be	VBZ
38430	543	68	at	at	RB
38430	543	69	least	least	RBS
38430	543	70	one	one	CD
38430	543	71	instant	instant	NN
38430	543	72	_	_	NNP
38430	543	73	t	t	NNP
38430	543	74	´	´	NNP
38430	543	75	_	_	NNP
38430	543	76	such	such	JJ
38430	543	77	that	that	IN
38430	543	78	neither	neither	CC
38430	543	79	_	_	NNP
38430	543	80	t	t	NNP
38430	543	81	´	´	CD
38430	543	82	_	_	NNP
38430	543	83	nor	nor	CC
38430	543	84	any	any	DT
38430	543	85	instant	instant	NN
38430	543	86	preceding	precede	VBG
38430	543	87	_	_	NNP
38430	543	88	t	t	NNP
38430	543	89	´	´	NNP
38430	543	90	_	_	NNP
38430	543	91	has	have	VBZ
38430	543	92	the	the	DT
38430	543	93	relation	relation	NN
38430	543	94	R	r	NN
38430	543	95	to	to	IN
38430	543	96	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	543	97	.	.	.
38430	543	98	"	"	''
38430	544	1	This	this	DT
38430	544	2	definition	definition	NN
38430	544	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	544	4	many	many	JJ
38430	544	5	merits	merit	NNS
38430	544	6	.	.	.
38430	545	1	In	in	IN
38430	545	2	the	the	DT
38430	545	3	first	first	JJ
38430	545	4	place	place	NN
38430	545	5	,	,	,
38430	545	6	no	no	DT
38430	545	7	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	545	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	545	9	made	make	VBN
38430	545	10	that	that	IN
38430	545	11	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	545	12	ever	ever	RB
38430	545	13	lived	live	VBD
38430	545	14	at	at	RB
38430	545	15	all	all	RB
38430	545	16	.	.	.
38430	546	1	In	in	IN
38430	546	2	the	the	DT
38430	546	3	second	second	JJ
38430	546	4	place	place	NN
38430	546	5	,	,	,
38430	546	6	no	no	DT
38430	546	7	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	546	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	546	9	made	make	VBN
38430	546	10	that	that	IN
38430	546	11	the	the	DT
38430	546	12	instants	instant	NNS
38430	546	13	of	of	IN
38430	546	14	time	time	NN
38430	546	15	form	form	VB
38430	546	16	a	a	DT
38430	546	17	continuous	continuous	JJ
38430	546	18	series	series	NN
38430	546	19	.	.	.
38430	547	1	In	in	IN
38430	547	2	the	the	DT
38430	547	3	third	third	JJ
38430	547	4	place	place	NN
38430	547	5	,	,	,
38430	547	6	no	no	DT
38430	547	7	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	547	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	547	9	made	make	VBN
38430	547	10	as	as	IN
38430	547	11	to	to	IN
38430	547	12	whether	whether	IN
38430	547	13	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	547	14	had	have	VBD
38430	547	15	a	a	DT
38430	547	16	first	first	JJ
38430	547	17	or	or	CC
38430	547	18	last	last	JJ
38430	547	19	moment	moment	NN
38430	547	20	of	of	IN
38430	547	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	547	22	existence	existence	NN
38430	547	23	.	.	.
38430	548	1	If	if	IN
38430	548	2	time	time	NN
38430	548	3	be	be	VBP
38430	548	4	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	548	5	a	a	DT
38430	548	6	continuous	continuous	JJ
38430	548	7	series	series	NN
38430	548	8	,	,	,
38430	548	9	then	then	RB
38430	548	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	548	11	can	can	MD
38430	548	12	easily	easily	RB
38430	548	13	deduce[58	deduce[58	LS
38430	548	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	548	15	that	that	IN
38430	548	16	there	there	EX
38430	548	17	must	must	MD
38430	548	18	have	have	VB
38430	548	19	been	be	VBN
38430	548	20	_	_	NNP
38430	548	21	either	either	CC
38430	548	22	_	_	NNP
38430	548	23	a	a	DT
38430	548	24	first	first	JJ
38430	548	25	moment	moment	NN
38430	548	26	of	of	IN
38430	548	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	548	28	non	non	JJ
38430	548	29	-	-	JJ
38430	548	30	existence	existence	NN
38430	548	31	_	_	NNP
38430	548	32	or	or	CC
38430	548	33	_	_	NNP
38430	548	34	a	a	DT
38430	548	35	last	last	JJ
38430	548	36	one	one	NN
38430	548	37	of	of	IN
38430	548	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	548	39	existence	existence	NN
38430	548	40	,	,	,
38430	548	41	but	but	CC
38430	548	42	not	not	RB
38430	548	43	both	both	DT
38430	548	44	;	;	:
38430	548	45	just	just	RB
38430	548	46	as	as	IN
38430	548	47	there	there	EX
38430	548	48	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	548	49	to	to	TO
38430	548	50	be	be	VB
38430	548	51	either	either	CC
38430	548	52	a	a	DT
38430	548	53	greatest	great	JJS
38430	548	54	weight	weight	NN
38430	548	55	that	that	WDT
38430	548	56	a	a	DT
38430	548	57	man	man	NN
38430	548	58	can	can	MD
38430	548	59	lift	lift	VB
38430	548	60	or	or	CC
38430	548	61	a	a	DT
38430	548	62	least	least	JJS
38430	548	63	weight	weight	NN
38430	548	64	that	that	IN
38430	548	65	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	548	66	can	can	MD
38430	548	67	not	not	RB
38430	548	68	lift	lift	VB
38430	548	69	,	,	,
38430	548	70	but	but	CC
38430	548	71	not	not	RB
38430	548	72	both	both	DT
38430	548	73	.	.	.
38430	549	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	549	2	59	59	CD
38430	549	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	549	4	This	this	DT
38430	549	5	may	may	MD
38430	549	6	be	be	VB
38430	549	7	set	set	VBN
38430	549	8	forth	forth	RP
38430	549	9	as	as	IN
38430	549	10	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	549	11	:	:	:
38430	549	12	for	for	IN
38430	549	13	the	the	DT
38430	549	14	present	present	NN
38430	549	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	549	16	will	will	MD
38430	549	17	not	not	RB
38430	549	18	concern	concern	VB
38430	549	19	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	549	20	with	with	IN
38430	549	21	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	549	22	for	for	IN
38430	549	23	or	or	CC
38430	549	24	against	against	IN
38430	549	25	human	human	JJ
38430	549	26	immortality	immortality	NN
38430	549	27	;	;	:
38430	549	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	549	29	will	will	MD
38430	549	30	merely	merely	RB
38430	549	31	try	try	VB
38430	549	32	to	to	TO
38430	549	33	present	present	VB
38430	549	34	some	some	DT
38430	549	35	logical	logical	JJ
38430	549	36	questions	question	NNS
38430	549	37	which	which	WDT
38430	549	38	persistently	persistently	RB
38430	549	39	arise	arise	VBP
38430	549	40	whenever	whenever	WRB
38430	549	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	549	42	think	think	VBP
38430	549	43	of	of	IN
38430	549	44	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	549	45	life	life	NN
38430	549	46	.	.	.
38430	550	1	One	one	CD
38430	550	2	of	of	IN
38430	550	3	the	the	DT
38430	550	4	greatest	great	JJS
38430	550	5	merits	merit	NNS
38430	550	6	of	of	IN
38430	550	7	modern	modern	JJ
38430	550	8	logic	logic	NN
38430	550	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	550	10	that	that	IN
38430	550	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	550	12	has	have	VBZ
38430	550	13	allowed	allow	VBN
38430	550	14	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	550	15	to	to	TO
38430	550	16	give	give	VB
38430	550	17	precision	precision	NN
38430	550	18	to	to	IN
38430	550	19	such	such	JJ
38430	550	20	problems	problem	NNS
38430	550	21	,	,	,
38430	550	22	while	while	IN
38430	550	23	definitely	definitely	RB
38430	550	24	abandoning	abandon	VBG
38430	550	25	any	any	DT
38430	550	26	pretensions	pretension	NNS
38430	550	27	of	of	IN
38430	550	28	solving	solve	VBG
38430	550	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	550	30	;	;	:
38430	550	31	and	and	CC
38430	550	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	550	33	will	will	MD
38430	550	34	now	now	RB
38430	550	35	apply	apply	VB
38430	550	36	the	the	DT
38430	550	37	logico	logico	JJ
38430	550	38	-	-	HYPH
38430	550	39	analytical	analytical	JJ
38430	550	40	method	method	NN
38430	550	41	to	to	IN
38430	550	42	one	one	CD
38430	550	43	of	of	IN
38430	550	44	the	the	DT
38430	550	45	problems	problem	NNS
38430	550	46	of	of	IN
38430	550	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	550	48	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	550	49	of	of	IN
38430	550	50	the	the	DT
38430	550	51	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	550	52	world	world	NN
38430	550	53	.	.	.
38430	551	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	551	2	60	60	CD
38430	551	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	551	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	551	5	will	will	MD
38430	551	6	start	start	VB
38430	551	7	from	from	IN
38430	551	8	the	the	DT
38430	551	9	generally	generally	RB
38430	551	10	accepted	accept	VBN
38430	551	11	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	551	12	that	that	IN
38430	551	13	all	all	DT
38430	551	14	men	man	NNS
38430	551	15	are	be	VBP
38430	551	16	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	551	17	.	.	.
38430	552	1	Clearly	clearly	RB
38430	552	2	,	,	,
38430	552	3	if	if	IN
38430	552	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	552	5	could	could	MD
38430	552	6	know	know	VB
38430	552	7	each	each	DT
38430	552	8	individual	individual	JJ
38430	552	9	man	man	NN
38430	552	10	,	,	,
38430	552	11	and	and	CC
38430	552	12	know	know	VB
38430	552	13	that	that	IN
38430	552	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	552	15	was	be	VBD
38430	552	16	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	552	17	,	,	,
38430	552	18	that	that	WDT
38430	552	19	would	would	MD
38430	552	20	not	not	RB
38430	552	21	enable	enable	VB
38430	552	22	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	552	23	to	to	TO
38430	552	24	know	know	VB
38430	552	25	that	that	IN
38430	552	26	all	all	DT
38430	552	27	men	man	NNS
38430	552	28	are	be	VBP
38430	552	29	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	552	30	,	,	,
38430	552	31	unless	unless	IN
38430	552	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	552	33	knew	know	VBD
38430	552	34	,	,	,
38430	552	35	in	in	IN
38430	552	36	addition	addition	NN
38430	552	37	,	,	,
38430	552	38	that	that	IN
38430	552	39	those	those	DT
38430	552	40	were	be	VBD
38430	552	41	all	all	PDT
38430	552	42	the	the	DT
38430	552	43	men	man	NNS
38430	552	44	there	there	EX
38430	552	45	are	be	VBP
38430	552	46	.	.	.
38430	553	1	But	but	CC
38430	553	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	553	3	need	need	VBP
38430	553	4	not	not	RB
38430	553	5	here	here	RB
38430	553	6	assume	assume	VB
38430	553	7	any	any	DT
38430	553	8	such	such	JJ
38430	553	9	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	553	10	of	of	IN
38430	553	11	general	general	JJ
38430	553	12	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	553	13	;	;	:
38430	553	14	and	and	CC
38430	553	15	,	,	,
38430	553	16	though	though	IN
38430	553	17	most	most	JJS
38430	553	18	of	of	IN
38430	553	19	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	553	20	will	will	MD
38430	553	21	admit	admit	VB
38430	553	22	that	that	IN
38430	553	23	the	the	DT
38430	553	24	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	553	25	in	in	IN
38430	553	26	question	question	NN
38430	553	27	has	have	VBZ
38430	553	28	great	great	JJ
38430	553	29	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
38430	553	30	plausibility	plausibility	NN
38430	553	31	,	,	,
38430	553	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	553	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	553	34	not	not	RB
38430	553	35	strictly	strictly	RB
38430	553	36	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	553	37	for	for	IN
38430	553	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	553	39	present	present	JJ
38430	553	40	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	553	41	to	to	TO
38430	553	42	assume	assume	VB
38430	553	43	anything	anything	NN
38430	553	44	more	more	JJR
38430	553	45	than	than	IN
38430	553	46	the	the	DT
38430	553	47	still	still	RB
38430	553	48	more	more	RBR
38430	553	49	probable	probable	JJ
38430	553	50	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	553	51	"	"	''
38430	553	52	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	553	53	is	be	VBZ
38430	553	54	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	553	55	.	.	.
38430	553	56	"	"	''
38430	554	1	This	this	DT
38430	554	2	last	last	JJ
38430	554	3	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	554	4	,	,	,
38430	554	5	quite	quite	RB
38430	554	6	apart	apart	RB
38430	554	7	from	from	IN
38430	554	8	the	the	DT
38430	554	9	fact	fact	NN
38430	554	10	that	that	IN
38430	554	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	554	12	have	have	VBP
38430	554	13	a	a	DT
38430	554	14	large	large	JJ
38430	554	15	amount	amount	NN
38430	554	16	of	of	IN
38430	554	17	historical	historical	JJ
38430	554	18	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	554	19	for	for	IN
38430	554	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	554	21	truth	truth	NN
38430	554	22	,	,	,
38430	554	23	has	have	VBZ
38430	554	24	been	be	VBN
38430	554	25	repeated	repeat	VBN
38430	554	26	so	so	RB
38430	554	27	often	often	RB
38430	554	28	in	in	IN
38430	554	29	books	book	NNS
38430	554	30	on	on	IN
38430	554	31	logic	logic	NN
38430	554	32	that	that	IN
38430	554	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	554	34	has	have	VBZ
38430	554	35	taken	take	VBN
38430	554	36	on	on	IN
38430	554	37	the	the	DT
38430	554	38	respectable	respectable	JJ
38430	554	39	air	air	NN
38430	554	40	of	of	IN
38430	554	41	a	a	DT
38430	554	42	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	554	43	while	while	IN
38430	554	44	preserving	preserve	VBG
38430	554	45	the	the	DT
38430	554	46	character	character	NN
38430	554	47	of	of	IN
38430	554	48	an	an	DT
38430	554	49	exceedingly	exceedingly	RB
38430	554	50	probable	probable	JJ
38430	554	51	truth	truth	NN
38430	554	52	.	.	.
38430	555	1	The	the	DT
38430	555	2	truth	truth	NN
38430	555	3	also	also	RB
38430	555	4	results	result	VBZ
38430	555	5	from	from	IN
38430	555	6	the	the	DT
38430	555	7	fact	fact	NN
38430	555	8	that	that	IN
38430	555	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	555	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	555	11	used	use	VBN
38430	555	12	as	as	IN
38430	555	13	the	the	DT
38430	555	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	555	15	of	of	IN
38430	555	16	a	a	DT
38430	555	17	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	555	18	.	.	.
38430	556	1	For	for	IN
38430	556	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	556	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	556	4	a	a	DT
38430	556	5	well	well	RB
38430	556	6	-	-	HYPH
38430	556	7	known	know	VBN
38430	556	8	fact	fact	NN
38430	556	9	that	that	IN
38430	556	10	syllogisms	syllogism	NNS
38430	556	11	can	can	MD
38430	556	12	only	only	RB
38430	556	13	be	be	VB
38430	556	14	regarded	regard	VBN
38430	556	15	as	as	IN
38430	556	16	forming	form	VBG
38430	556	17	part	part	NN
38430	556	18	of	of	IN
38430	556	19	a	a	DT
38430	556	20	sound	sound	JJ
38430	556	21	education	education	NN
38430	556	22	if	if	IN
38430	556	23	the	the	DT
38430	556	24	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	556	25	are	be	VBP
38430	556	26	obviously	obviously	RB
38430	556	27	true	true	JJ
38430	556	28	.	.	.
38430	557	1	The	the	DT
38430	557	2	use	use	NN
38430	557	3	of	of	IN
38430	557	4	a	a	DT
38430	557	5	syllogism	syllogism	NN
38430	557	6	of	of	IN
38430	557	7	the	the	DT
38430	557	8	form	form	NN
38430	557	9	"	"	``
38430	557	10	All	all	DT
38430	557	11	cats	cat	NNS
38430	557	12	are	be	VBP
38430	557	13	ducks	duck	NNS
38430	557	14	and	and	CC
38430	557	15	all	all	DT
38430	557	16	ducks	duck	NNS
38430	557	17	are	be	VBP
38430	557	18	mice	mouse	NNS
38430	557	19	,	,	,
38430	557	20	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	557	21	all	all	DT
38430	557	22	cats	cat	NNS
38430	557	23	are	be	VBP
38430	557	24	mice	mouse	NNS
38430	557	25	,	,	,
38430	557	26	"	"	''
38430	557	27	would	would	MD
38430	557	28	introduce	introduce	VB
38430	557	29	grave	grave	JJ
38430	557	30	doubts	doubt	NNS
38430	557	31	into	into	IN
38430	557	32	the	the	DT
38430	557	33	University	University	NNP
38430	557	34	of	of	IN
38430	557	35	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	557	36	as	as	IN
38430	557	37	to	to	IN
38430	557	38	whether	whether	IN
38430	557	39	logic	logic	NN
38430	557	40	could	could	MD
38430	557	41	any	any	DT
38430	557	42	longer	longer	RB
38430	557	43	be	be	VB
38430	557	44	considered	consider	VBN
38430	557	45	as	as	IN
38430	557	46	a	a	DT
38430	557	47	valuable	valuable	JJ
38430	557	48	mental	mental	JJ
38430	557	49	training	training	NN
38430	557	50	for	for	IN
38430	557	51	what	what	WP
38430	557	52	are	be	VBP
38430	557	53	amusingly	amusingly	RB
38430	557	54	called	call	VBN
38430	557	55	the	the	DT
38430	557	56	"	"	``
38430	557	57	learned	learn	VBN
38430	557	58	professions	profession	NNS
38430	557	59	.	.	.
38430	557	60	"	"	''
38430	558	1	If	if	IN
38430	558	2	,	,	,
38430	558	3	then	then	RB
38430	558	4	,	,	,
38430	558	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	558	6	divide	divide	VBP
38430	558	7	all	all	PDT
38430	558	8	the	the	DT
38430	558	9	instants	instant	NNS
38430	558	10	of	of	IN
38430	558	11	time	time	NN
38430	558	12	,	,	,
38430	558	13	whether	whether	IN
38430	558	14	past	past	JJ
38430	558	15	,	,	,
38430	558	16	present	present	JJ
38430	558	17	,	,	,
38430	558	18	or	or	CC
38430	558	19	future	future	NN
38430	558	20	,	,	,
38430	558	21	into	into	IN
38430	558	22	two	two	CD
38430	558	23	series	series	NN
38430	558	24	--	--	:
38430	558	25	those	those	DT
38430	558	26	instants	instant	NNS
38430	558	27	at	at	IN
38430	558	28	which	which	WDT
38430	558	29	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	558	30	was	be	VBD
38430	558	31	alive	alive	JJ
38430	558	32	,	,	,
38430	558	33	and	and	CC
38430	558	34	those	those	DT
38430	558	35	instants	instant	NNS
38430	558	36	at	at	IN
38430	558	37	which	which	WDT
38430	558	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	558	39	was	be	VBD
38430	558	40	not	not	RB
38430	558	41	alive	alive	JJ
38430	558	42	--	--	:
38430	558	43	and	and	CC
38430	558	44	leave	leave	VB
38430	558	45	out	out	IN
38430	558	46	of	of	IN
38430	558	47	consideration	consideration	NN
38430	558	48	,	,	,
38430	558	49	for	for	IN
38430	558	50	the	the	DT
38430	558	51	sake	sake	NN
38430	558	52	of	of	IN
38430	558	53	greater	great	JJR
38430	558	54	simplicity	simplicity	NN
38430	558	55	,	,	,
38430	558	56	all	all	PDT
38430	558	57	those	those	DT
38430	558	58	instants	instant	NNS
38430	558	59	before	before	IN
38430	558	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	558	61	lived	live	VBD
38430	558	62	,	,	,
38430	558	63	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	558	64	see	see	VBP
38430	558	65	at	at	IN
38430	558	66	once	once	RB
38430	558	67	,	,	,
38430	558	68	by	by	IN
38430	558	69	the	the	DT
38430	558	70	simple	simple	JJ
38430	558	71	application	application	NN
38430	558	72	of	of	IN
38430	558	73	Dedekind	Dedekind	NNP
38430	558	74	's	's	POS
38430	558	75	Axiom	Axiom	NNP
38430	558	76	,	,	,
38430	558	77	that	that	IN
38430	558	78	,	,	,
38430	558	79	if	if	IN
38430	558	80	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	558	81	entered	enter	VBD
38430	558	82	into	into	IN
38430	558	83	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	558	84	life	life	NN
38430	558	85	after	after	IN
38430	558	86	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	558	87	death	death	NN
38430	558	88	,	,	,
38430	558	89	there	there	EX
38430	558	90	must	must	MD
38430	558	91	have	have	VB
38430	558	92	been	be	VBN
38430	558	93	either	either	CC
38430	558	94	a	a	DT
38430	558	95	last	last	JJ
38430	558	96	moment	moment	NN
38430	558	97	of	of	IN
38430	558	98	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	558	99	earthly	earthly	JJ
38430	558	100	life	life	NN
38430	558	101	_	_	NNP
38430	558	102	or	or	CC
38430	558	103	_	_	NNP
38430	558	104	a	a	DT
38430	558	105	first	first	JJ
38430	558	106	moment	moment	NN
38430	558	107	of	of	IN
38430	558	108	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	558	109	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	558	110	life	life	NN
38430	558	111	,	,	,
38430	558	112	but	but	CC
38430	558	113	not	not	RB
38430	558	114	both	both	DT
38430	558	115	.	.	.
38430	559	1	Logic	logic	NN
38430	559	2	alone	alone	RB
38430	559	3	can	can	MD
38430	559	4	give	give	VB
38430	559	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	559	6	no	no	DT
38430	559	7	information	information	NN
38430	559	8	as	as	IN
38430	559	9	to	to	IN
38430	559	10	which	which	WDT
38430	559	11	of	of	IN
38430	559	12	these	these	DT
38430	559	13	cases	case	NNS
38430	559	14	actually	actually	RB
38430	559	15	occurred	occur	VBD
38430	559	16	,	,	,
38430	559	17	and	and	CC
38430	559	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	559	19	are	be	VBP
38430	559	20	thrown	throw	VBN
38430	559	21	back	back	RB
38430	559	22	on	on	RB
38430	559	23	to	to	IN
38430	559	24	a	a	DT
38430	559	25	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	559	26	of	of	IN
38430	559	27	empirical	empirical	JJ
38430	559	28	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	559	29	.	.	.
38430	560	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	560	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	560	3	no	no	DT
38430	560	4	unusual	unusual	JJ
38430	560	5	thing	thing	NN
38430	560	6	to	to	TO
38430	560	7	read	read	VB
38430	560	8	of	of	IN
38430	560	9	people	people	NNS
38430	560	10	who	who	WP
38430	560	11	thought	think	VBD
38430	560	12	"	"	``
38430	560	13	that	that	IN
38430	560	14	every	every	DT
38430	560	15	moment	moment	NN
38430	560	16	would	would	MD
38430	560	17	be	be	VB
38430	560	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	560	19	last	last	JJ
38430	560	20	.	.	.
38430	560	21	"	"	''
38430	561	1	In	in	IN
38430	561	2	this	this	DT
38430	561	3	case	case	NN
38430	561	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	561	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	561	6	quite	quite	RB
38430	561	7	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	561	8	that	that	IN
38430	561	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	561	10	consequently	consequently	RB
38430	561	11	thought	think	VBD
38430	561	12	that	that	IN
38430	561	13	eternity	eternity	NN
38430	561	14	would	would	MD
38430	561	15	have	have	VB
38430	561	16	no	no	DT
38430	561	17	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	561	18	.	.	.
38430	562	1	Now	now	RB
38430	562	2	here	here	RB
38430	562	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	4	must	must	MD
38430	562	5	consider	consider	VB
38430	562	6	two	two	CD
38430	562	7	things	thing	NNS
38430	562	8	:	:	:
38430	562	9	(	(	-LRB-
38430	562	10	1	1	LS
38430	562	11	)	)	-RRB-
38430	562	12	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	562	14	plainly	plainly	RB
38430	562	15	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
38430	562	16	to	to	TO
38430	562	17	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	562	18	from	from	IN
38430	562	19	what	what	WP
38430	562	20	people	people	NNS
38430	562	21	think	think	VBP
38430	562	22	will	will	MD
38430	562	23	happen	happen	VB
38430	562	24	to	to	IN
38430	562	25	what	what	WP
38430	562	26	will	will	MD
38430	562	27	happen	happen	VB
38430	562	28	;	;	:
38430	562	29	(	(	-LRB-
38430	562	30	2	2	LS
38430	562	31	)	)	-RRB-
38430	562	32	even	even	RB
38430	562	33	if	if	IN
38430	562	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	35	could	could	MD
38430	562	36	so	so	RB
38430	562	37	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	562	38	,	,	,
38430	562	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	40	would	would	MD
38430	562	41	be	be	VB
38430	562	42	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
38430	562	43	to	to	TO
38430	562	44	deduce	deduce	VB
38430	562	45	that	that	IN
38430	562	46	there	there	EX
38430	562	47	was	be	VBD
38430	562	48	a	a	DT
38430	562	49	last	last	JJ
38430	562	50	moment	moment	NN
38430	562	51	in	in	IN
38430	562	52	the	the	DT
38430	562	53	life	life	NN
38430	562	54	of	of	IN
38430	562	55	Socrates	Socrates	NNPS
38430	562	56	:	:	:
38430	562	57	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	58	could	could	MD
38430	562	59	only	only	RB
38430	562	60	make	make	VB
38430	562	61	the	the	DT
38430	562	62	guess	guess	NN
38430	562	63	plausible	plausible	JJ
38430	562	64	,	,	,
38430	562	65	as	as	IN
38430	562	66	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	562	67	should	should	MD
38430	562	68	be	be	VB
38430	562	69	using	use	VBG
38430	562	70	the	the	DT
38430	562	71	inductive	inductive	JJ
38430	562	72	method	method	NN
38430	562	73	.	.	.
38430	563	1	There	there	EX
38430	563	2	are	be	VBP
38430	563	3	two	two	CD
38430	563	4	other	other	JJ
38430	563	5	pieces	piece	NNS
38430	563	6	of	of	IN
38430	563	7	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	563	8	that	that	IN
38430	563	9	there	there	EX
38430	563	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	563	11	a	a	DT
38430	563	12	last	last	JJ
38430	563	13	moment	moment	NN
38430	563	14	of	of	IN
38430	563	15	any	any	DT
38430	563	16	earthly	earthly	JJ
38430	563	17	existence	existence	NN
38430	563	18	,	,	,
38430	563	19	which	which	WDT
38430	563	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	563	21	may	may	MD
38430	563	22	now	now	RB
38430	563	23	briefly	briefly	RB
38430	563	24	consider	consider	VB
38430	563	25	.	.	.
38430	564	1	That	that	IN
38430	564	2	this	this	DT
38430	564	3	was	be	VBD
38430	564	4	so	so	RB
38430	564	5	was	be	VBD
38430	564	6	held	hold	VBN
38430	564	7	by	by	IN
38430	564	8	Carlo	Carlo	NNP
38430	564	9	Michaelstaedter	Michaelstaedter	NNP
38430	564	10	;	;	:
38430	564	11	but	but	CC
38430	564	12	since	since	IN
38430	564	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	564	14	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	564	15	only	only	RB
38430	564	16	believed	believe	VBD
38430	564	17	this	this	DT
38430	564	18	because	because	IN
38430	564	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	564	20	wanted	want	VBD
38430	564	21	,	,	,
38430	564	22	by	by	IN
38430	564	23	attributing	attribute	VBG
38430	564	24	a	a	DT
38430	564	25	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	564	26	ethical	ethical	JJ
38430	564	27	value	value	NN
38430	564	28	to	to	IN
38430	564	29	that	that	DT
38430	564	30	moment	moment	NN
38430	564	31	,	,	,
38430	564	32	to	to	TO
38430	564	33	give	give	VB
38430	564	34	support	support	NN
38430	564	35	to	to	IN
38430	564	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	564	37	theory	theory	NN
38430	564	38	of	of	IN
38430	564	39	suicide	suicide	NN
38430	564	40	,	,	,
38430	564	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	564	42	ought	ought	MD
38430	564	43	not	not	RB
38430	564	44	to	to	TO
38430	564	45	give	give	VB
38430	564	46	great	great	JJ
38430	564	47	weight	weight	NN
38430	564	48	to	to	IN
38430	564	49	this	this	DT
38430	564	50	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	564	51	.	.	.
38430	565	1	Secondly	secondly	RB
38430	565	2	,	,	,
38430	565	3	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
38430	565	4	Hobbes	Hobbes	NNP
38430	565	5	objected	object	VBD
38430	565	6	to	to	IN
38430	565	7	the	the	DT
38430	565	8	principle	principle	NN
38430	565	9	"	"	''
38430	565	10	that	that	IN
38430	565	11	a	a	DT
38430	565	12	quantity	quantity	NN
38430	565	13	may	may	MD
38430	565	14	grow	grow	VB
38430	565	15	less	less	RBR
38430	565	16	and	and	CC
38430	565	17	less	less	RBR
38430	565	18	eternally	eternally	RB
38430	565	19	,	,	,
38430	565	20	so	so	RB
38430	565	21	as	as	IN
38430	565	22	at	at	IN
38430	565	23	last	last	JJ
38430	565	24	to	to	TO
38430	565	25	be	be	VB
38430	565	26	equal	equal	JJ
38430	565	27	to	to	IN
38430	565	28	another	another	DT
38430	565	29	quantity	quantity	NN
38430	565	30	;	;	:
38430	565	31	or	or	CC
38430	565	32	,	,	,
38430	565	33	which	which	WDT
38430	565	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	565	35	all	all	DT
38430	565	36	one	one	CD
38430	565	37	,	,	,
38430	565	38	that	that	IN
38430	565	39	there	there	EX
38430	565	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	565	41	a	a	DT
38430	565	42	last	last	JJ
38430	565	43	in	in	IN
38430	565	44	eternity	eternity	NN
38430	565	45	"	"	''
38430	565	46	as	as	IN
38430	565	47	"	"	``
38430	565	48	void	void	NN
38430	565	49	of	of	IN
38430	565	50	sense	sense	NN
38430	565	51	.	.	.
38430	565	52	"	"	''
38430	566	1	Now	now	RB
38430	566	2	,	,	,
38430	566	3	the	the	DT
38430	566	4	principle	principle	NN
38430	566	5	meant	mean	VBD
38430	566	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	566	7	true	true	JJ
38430	566	8	,	,	,
38430	566	9	so	so	IN
38430	566	10	that	that	IN
38430	566	11	,	,	,
38430	566	12	although	although	IN
38430	566	13	the	the	DT
38430	566	14	other	other	JJ
38430	566	15	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	566	16	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	566	17	by	by	IN
38430	566	18	Hobbes	hobbe	NNS
38430	566	19	does	do	VBZ
38430	566	20	not	not	RB
38430	566	21	follow	follow	VB
38430	566	22	logically	logically	RB
38430	566	23	from	from	IN
38430	566	24	the	the	DT
38430	566	25	first	first	JJ
38430	566	26	,	,	,
38430	566	27	there	there	EX
38430	566	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	566	29	some	some	DT
38430	566	30	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	566	31	that	that	IN
38430	566	32	this	this	DT
38430	566	33	other	other	JJ
38430	566	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	566	35	true	true	JJ
38430	566	36	.	.	.
38430	567	1	In	in	IN
38430	567	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	567	3	,	,	,
38430	567	4	that	that	DT
38430	567	5	Hobbes	hobbe	VBZ
38430	567	6	thought	think	VBD
38430	567	7	that	that	IN
38430	567	8	such	such	JJ
38430	567	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	567	10	and	and	CC
38430	567	11	-	-	HYPH
38430	567	12	such	such	PDT
38430	567	13	a	a	DT
38430	567	14	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	567	15	followed	follow	VBN
38430	567	16	from	from	IN
38430	567	17	another	another	DT
38430	567	18	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	567	19	which	which	WDT
38430	567	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	567	21	wrongly	wrongly	RB
38430	567	22	believed	believe	VBD
38430	567	23	to	to	TO
38430	567	24	be	be	VB
38430	567	25	false	false	JJ
38430	567	26	,	,	,
38430	567	27	is	be	VBZ
38430	567	28	far	far	RB
38430	567	29	better	well	JJR
38430	567	30	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	567	31	for	for	IN
38430	567	32	the	the	DT
38430	567	33	truth	truth	NN
38430	567	34	of	of	IN
38430	567	35	such	such	JJ
38430	567	36	-	-	HYPH
38430	567	37	and	and	CC
38430	567	38	-	-	HYPH
38430	567	39	such	such	PDT
38430	567	40	a	a	DT
38430	567	41	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	567	42	than	than	IN
38430	567	43	any	any	DT
38430	567	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	567	45	have	have	VBP
38430	567	46	for	for	IN
38430	567	47	the	the	DT
38430	567	48	truth	truth	NN
38430	567	49	of	of	IN
38430	567	50	most	most	JJS
38430	567	51	of	of	IN
38430	567	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	567	53	most	most	RBS
38430	567	54	cherished	cherished	JJ
38430	567	55	beliefs	belief	NNS
38430	567	56	.	.	.
38430	568	1	Thirdly	thirdly	RB
38430	568	2	,	,	,
38430	568	3	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	568	4	,	,	,
38430	568	5	in	in	IN
38430	568	6	a	a	DT
38430	568	7	dialogue[61	dialogue[61	NN
38430	568	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	568	9	written	write	VBN
38430	568	10	on	on	IN
38430	568	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	568	12	journey	journey	NN
38430	568	13	of	of	IN
38430	568	14	1676	1676	CD
38430	568	15	to	to	TO
38430	568	16	visit	visit	VB
38430	568	17	Spinoza	Spinoza	NNP
38430	568	18	,	,	,
38430	568	19	raised	raise	VBD
38430	568	20	the	the	DT
38430	568	21	question	question	NN
38430	568	22	whether	whether	IN
38430	568	23	the	the	DT
38430	568	24	moment	moment	NN
38430	568	25	at	at	IN
38430	568	26	which	which	WDT
38430	568	27	a	a	DT
38430	568	28	man	man	NN
38430	568	29	dies	die	VBZ
38430	568	30	may	may	MD
38430	568	31	be	be	VB
38430	568	32	regarded	regard	VBN
38430	568	33	as	as	IN
38430	568	34	both	both	CC
38430	568	35	the	the	DT
38430	568	36	last	last	JJ
38430	568	37	moment	moment	NN
38430	568	38	at	at	IN
38430	568	39	which	which	WDT
38430	568	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	568	41	is	be	VBZ
38430	568	42	alive	alive	JJ
38430	568	43	and	and	CC
38430	568	44	the	the	DT
38430	568	45	first	first	JJ
38430	568	46	at	at	IN
38430	568	47	which	which	WDT
38430	568	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	568	49	is	be	VBZ
38430	568	50	dead	dead	JJ
38430	568	51	,	,	,
38430	568	52	as	as	IN
38430	568	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	568	54	must	must	MD
38430	568	55	be	be	VB
38430	568	56	by	by	IN
38430	568	57	Aristotle	Aristotle	NNP
38430	568	58	's	's	POS
38430	568	59	theory	theory	NN
38430	568	60	of	of	IN
38430	568	61	continuity	continuity	NN
38430	568	62	.	.	.
38430	569	1	Agreement	agreement	NN
38430	569	2	with	with	IN
38430	569	3	this	this	DT
38430	569	4	view	view	NN
38430	569	5	violates	violate	VBZ
38430	569	6	the	the	DT
38430	569	7	law	law	NN
38430	569	8	of	of	IN
38430	569	9	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	569	10	;	;	,
38430	569	11	denial	denial	NN
38430	569	12	of	of	IN
38430	569	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	569	14	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	569	15	that	that	IN
38430	569	16	two	two	CD
38430	569	17	moments	moment	NNS
38430	569	18	can	can	MD
38430	569	19	be	be	VB
38430	569	20	immediately	immediately	RB
38430	569	21	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
38430	569	22	.	.	.
38430	570	1	By	by	IN
38430	570	2	the	the	DT
38430	570	3	denial	denial	NN
38430	570	4	,	,	,
38430	570	5	then	then	RB
38430	570	6	,	,	,
38430	570	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	570	8	are	be	VBP
38430	570	9	led	lead	VBN
38430	570	10	to	to	TO
38430	570	11	regard	regard	VB
38430	570	12	space	space	NN
38430	570	13	and	and	CC
38430	570	14	time	time	NN
38430	570	15	as	as	IN
38430	570	16	made	make	VBN
38430	570	17	up	up	RP
38430	570	18	of	of	IN
38430	570	19	indivisible	indivisible	JJ
38430	570	20	points	point	NNS
38430	570	21	and	and	CC
38430	570	22	moments	moment	NNS
38430	570	23	,	,	,
38430	570	24	and	and	CC
38430	570	25	thus	thus	RB
38430	570	26	,	,	,
38430	570	27	since	since	IN
38430	570	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	570	29	can	can	MD
38430	570	30	draw	draw	VB
38430	570	31	one	one	CD
38430	570	32	and	and	CC
38430	570	33	only	only	RB
38430	570	34	one	one	CD
38430	570	35	parallel	parallel	NN
38430	570	36	from	from	IN
38430	570	37	any	any	DT
38430	570	38	point	point	NN
38430	570	39	in	in	IN
38430	570	40	the	the	DT
38430	570	41	diagonal	diagonal	NN
38430	570	42	of	of	IN
38430	570	43	a	a	DT
38430	570	44	square	square	NN
38430	570	45	to	to	IN
38430	570	46	a	a	DT
38430	570	47	given	give	VBN
38430	570	48	side	side	NN
38430	570	49	,	,	,
38430	570	50	the	the	DT
38430	570	51	diagonal	diagonal	JJ
38430	570	52	will	will	MD
38430	570	53	contain	contain	VB
38430	570	54	the	the	DT
38430	570	55	same	same	JJ
38430	570	56	(	(	-LRB-
38430	570	57	infinite	infinite	NN
38430	570	58	)	)	-RRB-
38430	570	59	number	number	NN
38430	570	60	of	of	IN
38430	570	61	points	point	NNS
38430	570	62	as	as	IN
38430	570	63	that	that	DT
38430	570	64	side	side	NN
38430	570	65	,	,	,
38430	570	66	and	and	CC
38430	570	67	will	will	MD
38430	570	68	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	570	69	be	be	VB
38430	570	70	equal	equal	JJ
38430	570	71	to	to	IN
38430	570	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	570	73	.	.	.
38430	571	1	In	in	IN
38430	571	2	this	this	DT
38430	571	3	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	571	4	repeated	repeat	VBD
38430	571	5	an	an	DT
38430	571	6	argument	argument	NN
38430	571	7	used	use	VBN
38430	571	8	by	by	IN
38430	571	9	the	the	DT
38430	571	10	ancient	ancient	JJ
38430	571	11	Arabs	Arabs	NNPS
38430	571	12	,	,	,
38430	571	13	Roger	Roger	NNP
38430	571	14	Bacon	Bacon	NNP
38430	571	15	,	,	,
38430	571	16	and	and	CC
38430	571	17	William	William	NNP
38430	571	18	of	of	IN
38430	571	19	Occam	Occam	NNP
38430	571	20	.	.	.
38430	572	1	This	this	DT
38430	572	2	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	572	3	considered	consider	VBD
38430	572	4	to	to	TO
38430	572	5	be	be	VB
38430	572	6	a	a	DT
38430	572	7	proof	proof	NN
38430	572	8	that	that	IN
38430	572	9	a	a	DT
38430	572	10	line	line	NN
38430	572	11	can	can	MD
38430	572	12	not	not	RB
38430	572	13	be	be	VB
38430	572	14	an	an	DT
38430	572	15	aggregate	aggregate	NN
38430	572	16	of	of	IN
38430	572	17	points	point	NNS
38430	572	18	.	.	.
38430	573	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
38430	573	2	,	,	,
38430	573	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	573	4	number	number	NN
38430	573	5	would	would	MD
38430	573	6	be	be	VB
38430	573	7	"	"	``
38430	573	8	the	the	DT
38430	573	9	number	number	NN
38430	573	10	of	of	IN
38430	573	11	all	all	DT
38430	573	12	numbers	number	NNS
38430	573	13	"	"	''
38430	573	14	of	of	IN
38430	573	15	the	the	DT
38430	573	16	greatest	great	JJS
38430	573	17	possible	possible	JJ
38430	573	18	integer	integer	NN
38430	573	19	,	,	,
38430	573	20	which	which	WDT
38430	573	21	_	_	NNP
38430	573	22	is	be	VBZ
38430	573	23	_	_	NNP
38430	573	24	not	not	RB
38430	573	25	.	.	.
38430	574	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	574	2	does	do	VBZ
38430	574	3	not	not	RB
38430	574	4	seem	seem	VB
38430	574	5	,	,	,
38430	574	6	further	further	RB
38430	574	7	,	,	,
38430	574	8	that	that	IN
38430	574	9	any	any	DT
38430	574	10	light	light	NN
38430	574	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	574	12	thrown	throw	VBN
38430	574	13	on	on	IN
38430	574	14	the	the	DT
38430	574	15	logical	logical	JJ
38430	574	16	question	question	NN
38430	574	17	of	of	IN
38430	574	18	human	human	JJ
38430	574	19	mortality	mortality	NN
38430	574	20	or	or	CC
38430	574	21	immortality	immortality	NN
38430	574	22	by	by	IN
38430	574	23	legal	legal	JJ
38430	574	24	decisions	decision	NNS
38430	574	25	.	.	.
38430	575	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	575	2	would	would	MD
38430	575	3	appear	appear	VB
38430	575	4	that	that	IN
38430	575	5	one	one	PRP
38430	575	6	can	can	MD
38430	575	7	,	,	,
38430	575	8	legally	legally	RB
38430	575	9	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	575	10	,	,	,
38430	575	11	be	be	VB
38430	575	12	alive	alive	JJ
38430	575	13	for	for	IN
38430	575	14	any	any	DT
38430	575	15	period	period	NN
38430	575	16	less	less	JJR
38430	575	17	than	than	IN
38430	575	18	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	575	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	575	20	four	four	CD
38430	575	21	hours	hour	NNS
38430	575	22	after	after	IN
38430	575	23	one	one	CD
38430	575	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	575	25	dead	dead	JJ
38430	575	26	and	and	CC
38430	575	27	be	be	VB
38430	575	28	dead	dead	JJ
38430	575	29	for	for	IN
38430	575	30	any	any	DT
38430	575	31	period	period	NN
38430	575	32	less	less	JJR
38430	575	33	than	than	IN
38430	575	34	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	575	35	-	-	HYPH
38430	575	36	four	four	CD
38430	575	37	hours	hour	NNS
38430	575	38	before	before	IN
38430	575	39	one	one	CD
38430	575	40	's	's	POS
38430	575	41	death	death	NN
38430	575	42	.	.	.
38430	576	1	At	at	RB
38430	576	2	least	least	JJS
38430	576	3	,	,	,
38430	576	4	according	accord	VBG
38430	576	5	to	to	IN
38430	576	6	_	_	NNP
38430	576	7	Salkeld	Salkeld	NNP
38430	576	8	_	_	NNP
38430	576	9	,	,	,
38430	576	10	i.	i.	NNP
38430	577	1	44	44	CD
38430	577	2	,	,	,
38430	577	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	577	4	was	be	VBD
38430	577	5	"	"	``
38430	577	6	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
38430	577	7	that	that	IN
38430	577	8	if	if	IN
38430	577	9	one	one	CD
38430	577	10	be	be	VB
38430	577	11	born	bear	VBN
38430	577	12	the	the	DT
38430	577	13	first	first	JJ
38430	577	14	of	of	IN
38430	577	15	February	February	NNP
38430	577	16	at	at	IN
38430	577	17	eleven	eleven	CD
38430	577	18	at	at	IN
38430	577	19	night	night	NN
38430	577	20	,	,	,
38430	577	21	and	and	CC
38430	577	22	the	the	DT
38430	577	23	last	last	JJ
38430	577	24	of	of	IN
38430	577	25	January	January	NNP
38430	577	26	in	in	IN
38430	577	27	the	the	DT
38430	577	28	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	577	29	-	-	HYPH
38430	577	30	first	first	JJ
38430	577	31	year	year	NN
38430	577	32	of	of	IN
38430	577	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	577	34	age	age	NN
38430	577	35	,	,	,
38430	577	36	at	at	IN
38430	577	37	one	one	CD
38430	577	38	of	of	IN
38430	577	39	the	the	DT
38430	577	40	clock	clock	NN
38430	577	41	in	in	IN
38430	577	42	the	the	DT
38430	577	43	morning	morning	NN
38430	577	44	,	,	,
38430	577	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	577	46	makes	make	VBZ
38430	577	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	577	48	will	will	NN
38430	577	49	of	of	IN
38430	577	50	lands	land	NNS
38430	577	51	,	,	,
38430	577	52	and	and	CC
38430	577	53	dies	die	VBZ
38430	577	54	,	,	,
38430	577	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	577	56	is	be	VBZ
38430	577	57	a	a	DT
38430	577	58	good	good	JJ
38430	577	59	will	will	NN
38430	577	60	,	,	,
38430	577	61	for	for	IN
38430	577	62	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	577	63	was	be	VBD
38430	577	64	then	then	RB
38430	577	65	of	of	IN
38430	577	66	age	age	NN
38430	577	67	.	.	.
38430	577	68	"	"	''
38430	578	1	In	in	IN
38430	578	2	Sir	Sir	NNP
38430	578	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
38430	578	4	Howard	Howard	NNP
38430	578	5	's	's	POS
38430	578	6	case	case	NN
38430	578	7	(	(	-LRB-
38430	578	8	_	_	NNP
38430	578	9	ibid	ibid	NN
38430	578	10	.	.	.
38430	578	11	_	_	NNP
38430	578	12	,	,	,
38430	578	13	ii	ii	NNP
38430	578	14	.	.	.
38430	579	1	625	625	LS
38430	579	2	)	)	-RRB-
38430	579	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	579	4	was	be	VBD
38430	579	5	held	hold	VBN
38430	579	6	by	by	IN
38430	579	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
38430	579	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
38430	579	9	Holt	Holt	NNP
38430	579	10	that	that	IN
38430	579	11	"	"	``
38430	579	12	if	if	IN
38430	579	13	A	a	DT
38430	579	14	be	be	VB
38430	579	15	born	bear	VBN
38430	579	16	on	on	IN
38430	579	17	the	the	DT
38430	579	18	third	third	JJ
38430	579	19	day	day	NN
38430	579	20	of	of	IN
38430	579	21	September	September	NNP
38430	579	22	;	;	:
38430	579	23	and	and	CC
38430	579	24	on	on	IN
38430	579	25	the	the	DT
38430	579	26	second	second	JJ
38430	579	27	day	day	NN
38430	579	28	of	of	IN
38430	579	29	September	September	NNP
38430	579	30	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	579	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	579	32	one	one	CD
38430	579	33	years	year	NNS
38430	579	34	afterwards	afterwards	RB
38430	579	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	579	36	make	make	VBP
38430	579	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	579	38	will	will	NN
38430	579	39	,	,	,
38430	579	40	this	this	DT
38430	579	41	is	be	VBZ
38430	579	42	a	a	DT
38430	579	43	good	good	JJ
38430	579	44	will	will	NN
38430	579	45	;	;	:
38430	579	46	for	for	IN
38430	579	47	the	the	DT
38430	579	48	law	law	NN
38430	579	49	will	will	MD
38430	579	50	make	make	VB
38430	579	51	no	no	DT
38430	579	52	fraction	fraction	NN
38430	579	53	of	of	IN
38430	579	54	a	a	DT
38430	579	55	day	day	NN
38430	579	56	,	,	,
38430	579	57	and	and	CC
38430	579	58	by	by	IN
38430	579	59	consequence	consequence	NNP
38430	579	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	579	61	was	be	VBD
38430	579	62	of	of	IN
38430	579	63	age	age	NN
38430	579	64	.	.	.
38430	579	65	"	"	''
38430	580	1	But	but	CC
38430	580	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	580	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	580	4	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	580	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	580	6	to	to	TO
38430	580	7	remark	remark	VB
38430	580	8	that	that	IN
38430	580	9	in	in	IN
38430	580	10	this	this	DT
38430	580	11	way	way	NN
38430	580	12	the	the	DT
38430	580	13	problem	problem	NN
38430	580	14	with	with	IN
38430	580	15	which	which	WDT
38430	580	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	580	17	are	be	VBP
38430	580	18	concerned	concerned	JJ
38430	580	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	580	20	merely	merely	RB
38430	580	21	shifted	shift	VBN
38430	580	22	and	and	CC
38430	580	23	not	not	RB
38430	580	24	solved	solve	VBN
38430	580	25	.	.	.
38430	581	1	For	for	IN
38430	581	2	the	the	DT
38430	581	3	question	question	NN
38430	581	4	as	as	IN
38430	581	5	to	to	IN
38430	581	6	whether	whether	IN
38430	581	7	there	there	EX
38430	581	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	581	9	or	or	CC
38430	581	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	581	11	not	not	RB
38430	581	12	a	a	DT
38430	581	13	last	last	JJ
38430	581	14	moment	moment	NN
38430	581	15	of	of	IN
38430	581	16	a	a	DT
38430	581	17	man	man	NN
38430	581	18	's	's	POS
38430	581	19	life	life	NN
38430	581	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	581	21	not	not	RB
38430	581	22	answered	answer	VBN
38430	581	23	by	by	IN
38430	581	24	the	the	DT
38430	581	25	decision	decision	NN
38430	581	26	that	that	IN
38430	581	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	581	28	dies	die	VBZ
38430	581	29	legally	legally	RB
38430	581	30	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	581	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	581	32	four	four	CD
38430	581	33	hours	hour	NNS
38430	581	34	before	before	RB
38430	581	35	or	or	CC
38430	581	36	after	after	IN
38430	581	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	581	38	dies	die	VBZ
38430	581	39	in	in	IN
38430	581	40	the	the	DT
38430	581	41	usual	usual	JJ
38430	581	42	sense	sense	NN
38430	581	43	of	of	IN
38430	581	44	the	the	DT
38430	581	45	word	word	NN
38430	581	46	,	,	,
38430	581	47	and	and	CC
38430	581	48	the	the	DT
38430	581	49	problem	problem	NN
38430	581	50	arises	arise	VBZ
38430	581	51	as	as	IN
38430	581	52	to	to	IN
38430	581	53	whether	whether	IN
38430	581	54	there	there	EX
38430	581	55	is	be	VBZ
38430	581	56	or	or	CC
38430	581	57	is	be	VBZ
38430	581	58	not	not	RB
38430	581	59	a	a	DT
38430	581	60	last	last	JJ
38430	581	61	moment	moment	NN
38430	581	62	of	of	IN
38430	581	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	581	64	legal	legal	JJ
38430	581	65	age	age	NN
38430	581	66	.	.	.
38430	582	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	582	2	62	62	CD
38430	582	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	582	4	So	so	RB
38430	582	5	assuming	assume	VBG
38430	582	6	that	that	IN
38430	582	7	there	there	EX
38430	582	8	was	be	VBD
38430	582	9	a	a	DT
38430	582	10	last	last	JJ
38430	582	11	moment	moment	NN
38430	582	12	of	of	IN
38430	582	13	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	582	14	's	's	POS
38430	582	15	earthly	earthly	JJ
38430	582	16	life	life	NN
38430	582	17	,	,	,
38430	582	18	and	and	CC
38430	582	19	consequently	consequently	RB
38430	582	20	no	no	DT
38430	582	21	first	first	JJ
38430	582	22	moment	moment	NN
38430	582	23	of	of	IN
38430	582	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	582	25	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	582	26	life	life	NN
38430	582	27	,	,	,
38430	582	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	582	29	see	see	VBP
38430	582	30	,	,	,
38430	582	31	further	further	RB
38430	582	32	,	,	,
38430	582	33	that	that	IN
38430	582	34	,	,	,
38430	582	35	unless	unless	IN
38430	582	36	the	the	DT
38430	582	37	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	582	38	of	of	IN
38430	582	39	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	582	40	numbers	number	NNS
38430	582	41	is	be	VBZ
38430	582	42	granted	grant	VBN
38430	582	43	,	,	,
38430	582	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	582	45	would	would	MD
38430	582	46	be	be	VB
38430	582	47	quite	quite	RB
38430	582	48	possible	possible	JJ
38430	582	49	for	for	IN
38430	582	50	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	582	51	logically	logically	RB
38430	582	52	to	to	TO
38430	582	53	doubt	doubt	VB
38430	582	54	the	the	DT
38430	582	55	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	582	56	of	of	IN
38430	582	57	an	an	DT
38430	582	58	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	582	59	life	life	NN
38430	582	60	for	for	IN
38430	582	61	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	582	62	on	on	IN
38430	582	63	the	the	DT
38430	582	64	same	same	JJ
38430	582	65	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	582	66	as	as	IN
38430	582	67	those	those	DT
38430	582	68	which	which	WDT
38430	582	69	led	lead	VBD
38430	582	70	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
38430	582	71	to	to	TO
38430	582	72	assert	assert	VB
38430	582	73	that	that	DT
38430	582	74	motion	motion	NN
38430	582	75	was	be	VBD
38430	582	76	impossible	impossible	JJ
38430	582	77	and	and	CC
38430	582	78	that	that	IN
38430	582	79	Achilles	Achilles	NNP
38430	582	80	could	could	MD
38430	582	81	never	never	RB
38430	582	82	overtake	overtake	VB
38430	582	83	the	the	DT
38430	582	84	Tortoise	Tortoise	NNP
38430	582	85	.	.	.
38430	583	1	If	if	IN
38430	583	2	,	,	,
38430	583	3	on	on	IN
38430	583	4	the	the	DT
38430	583	5	other	other	JJ
38430	583	6	hand	hand	NN
38430	583	7	,	,	,
38430	583	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	583	9	be	be	VB
38430	583	10	admitted	admit	VBN
38430	583	11	that	that	IN
38430	583	12	eternity	eternity	NN
38430	583	13	,	,	,
38430	583	14	at	at	IN
38430	583	15	least	least	JJS
38430	583	16	in	in	IN
38430	583	17	the	the	DT
38430	583	18	case	case	NN
38430	583	19	of	of	IN
38430	583	20	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	583	21	,	,	,
38430	583	22	had	have	VBD
38430	583	23	a	a	DT
38430	583	24	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	583	25	,	,	,
38430	583	26	these	these	DT
38430	583	27	same	same	JJ
38430	583	28	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	583	29	of	of	IN
38430	583	30	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
38430	583	31	would	would	MD
38430	583	32	lead	lead	VB
38430	583	33	any	any	DT
38430	583	34	one	one	NN
38430	583	35	who	who	WP
38430	583	36	denies	deny	VBZ
38430	583	37	the	the	DT
38430	583	38	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	583	39	of	of	IN
38430	583	40	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	583	41	number	number	NN
38430	583	42	to	to	TO
38430	583	43	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	583	44	that	that	IN
38430	583	45	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	583	46	,	,	,
38430	583	47	like	like	IN
38430	583	48	the	the	DT
38430	583	49	worm	worm	NN
38430	583	50	,	,	,
38430	583	51	can	can	MD
38430	583	52	never	never	RB
38430	583	53	die	die	VB
38430	583	54	.	.	.
38430	584	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	584	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	584	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	584	4	quite	quite	RB
38430	584	5	plain	plain	JJ
38430	584	6	that	that	IN
38430	584	7	the	the	DT
38430	584	8	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	584	9	about	about	IN
38430	584	10	immortality	immortality	NN
38430	584	11	which	which	WDT
38430	584	12	meet	meet	VBP
38430	584	13	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	584	14	at	at	IN
38430	584	15	the	the	DT
38430	584	16	very	very	JJ
38430	584	17	outset	outset	NN
38430	584	18	of	of	IN
38430	584	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	584	20	inquiry	inquiry	NN
38430	584	21	can	can	MD
38430	584	22	partly	partly	RB
38430	584	23	be	be	VB
38430	584	24	solved	solve	VBN
38430	584	25	only	only	RB
38430	584	26	by	by	IN
38430	584	27	the	the	DT
38430	584	28	help	help	NN
38430	584	29	of	of	IN
38430	584	30	the	the	DT
38430	584	31	theory	theory	NN
38430	584	32	of	of	IN
38430	584	33	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	584	34	numbers	number	NNS
38430	584	35	and	and	CC
38430	584	36	partly	partly	RB
38430	584	37	,	,	,
38430	584	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	584	39	would	would	MD
38430	584	40	seem	seem	VB
38430	584	41	,	,	,
38430	584	42	not	not	RB
38430	584	43	at	at	RB
38430	584	44	all	all	RB
38430	584	45	.	.	.
38430	585	1	There	there	EX
38430	585	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	585	3	another	another	DT
38430	585	4	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	585	5	about	about	IN
38430	585	6	immortality	immortality	NN
38430	585	7	which	which	WDT
38430	585	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	585	9	quite	quite	RB
38430	585	10	distinct	distinct	JJ
38430	585	11	from	from	IN
38430	585	12	this	this	DT
38430	585	13	and	and	CC
38430	585	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	585	15	analogous	analogous	JJ
38430	585	16	to	to	IN
38430	585	17	another	another	DT
38430	585	18	argument	argument	NN
38430	585	19	of	of	IN
38430	585	20	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
38430	585	21	.	.	.
38430	586	1	If	if	IN
38430	586	2	,	,	,
38430	586	3	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	586	4	,	,	,
38430	586	5	all	all	PDT
38430	586	6	the	the	DT
38430	586	7	instants	instant	NNS
38430	586	8	of	of	IN
38430	586	9	time	time	NN
38430	586	10	be	be	VB
38430	586	11	divided	divide	VBN
38430	586	12	,	,	,
38430	586	13	as	as	IN
38430	586	14	before	before	RB
38430	586	15	,	,	,
38430	586	16	into	into	IN
38430	586	17	the	the	DT
38430	586	18	two	two	CD
38430	586	19	series	series	NN
38430	586	20	of	of	IN
38430	586	21	instants	instant	NNS
38430	586	22	at	at	IN
38430	586	23	which	which	WDT
38430	586	24	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	586	25	was	be	VBD
38430	586	26	alive	alive	JJ
38430	586	27	and	and	CC
38430	586	28	instants	instant	NNS
38430	586	29	at	at	IN
38430	586	30	which	which	WDT
38430	586	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	586	32	was	be	VBD
38430	586	33	not	not	RB
38430	586	34	alive	alive	JJ
38430	586	35	,	,	,
38430	586	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	586	37	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	586	38	at	at	IN
38430	586	39	once	once	RB
38430	586	40	that	that	IN
38430	586	41	no	no	DT
38430	586	42	instant	instant	NN
38430	586	43	of	of	IN
38430	586	44	time	time	NN
38430	586	45	is	be	VBZ
38430	586	46	not	not	RB
38430	586	47	accounted	account	VBN
38430	586	48	for	for	IN
38430	586	49	.	.	.
38430	587	1	At	at	IN
38430	587	2	none	none	NN
38430	587	3	of	of	IN
38430	587	4	these	these	DT
38430	587	5	instants	instant	NNS
38430	587	6	,	,	,
38430	587	7	however	however	RB
38430	587	8	,	,	,
38430	587	9	does	do	VBZ
38430	587	10	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	587	11	die	die	VB
38430	587	12	;	;	:
38430	587	13	obviously	obviously	RB
38430	587	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	587	15	can	can	MD
38430	587	16	not	not	RB
38430	587	17	die	die	VB
38430	587	18	either	either	RB
38430	587	19	when	when	WRB
38430	587	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	587	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	587	22	alive	alive	JJ
38430	587	23	or	or	CC
38430	587	24	when	when	WRB
38430	587	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	587	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	587	27	dead	dead	JJ
38430	587	28	.	.	.
38430	588	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	588	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	588	3	would	would	MD
38430	588	4	appear	appear	VB
38430	588	5	that	that	IN
38430	588	6	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	588	7	never	never	RB
38430	588	8	died	die	VBD
38430	588	9	,	,	,
38430	588	10	and	and	CC
38430	588	11	that	that	IN
38430	588	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	588	13	ought	ought	MD
38430	588	14	to	to	TO
38430	588	15	re	re	VB
38430	588	16	-	-	VB
38430	588	17	define	define	VB
38430	588	18	the	the	DT
38430	588	19	term	term	NN
38430	588	20	"	"	``
38430	588	21	mortal	mortal	NN
38430	588	22	"	"	''
38430	588	23	to	to	TO
38430	588	24	mean	mean	VB
38430	588	25	"	"	``
38430	588	26	a	a	DT
38430	588	27	human	human	JJ
38430	588	28	being	being	NN
38430	588	29	who	who	WP
38430	588	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	588	31	alive	alive	JJ
38430	588	32	at	at	IN
38430	588	33	some	some	DT
38430	588	34	moments	moment	NNS
38430	588	35	and	and	CC
38430	588	36	dead	dead	JJ
38430	588	37	at	at	IN
38430	588	38	some	some	DT
38430	588	39	.	.	.
38430	588	40	"	"	''
38430	589	1	Consequently	consequently	RB
38430	589	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	589	3	must	must	MD
38430	589	4	avoid	avoid	VB
38430	589	5	the	the	DT
38430	589	6	very	very	RB
38430	589	7	tempting	tempting	JJ
38430	589	8	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	589	9	that	that	IN
38430	589	10	,	,	,
38430	589	11	because	because	IN
38430	589	12	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	589	13	never	never	RB
38430	589	14	died	die	VBD
38430	589	15	,	,	,
38430	589	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	589	17	was	be	VBD
38430	589	18	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	589	19	immortal	immortal	JJ
38430	589	20	.	.	.
38430	590	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	590	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	590	3	very	very	RB
38430	590	4	important	important	JJ
38430	590	5	carefully	carefully	RB
38430	590	6	to	to	TO
38430	590	7	distinguish	distinguish	VB
38430	590	8	between	between	IN
38430	590	9	the	the	DT
38430	590	10	two	two	CD
38430	590	11	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	590	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	590	13	have	have	VBP
38430	590	14	just	just	RB
38430	590	15	set	set	VBN
38430	590	16	forth	forth	RB
38430	590	17	.	.	.
38430	591	1	The	the	DT
38430	591	2	second	second	JJ
38430	591	3	argument	argument	NN
38430	591	4	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	591	5	quite	quite	RB
38430	591	6	rigidly	rigidly	RB
38430	591	7	that	that	IN
38430	591	8	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	591	9	and	and	CC
38430	591	10	,	,	,
38430	591	11	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	591	12	,	,	,
38430	591	13	anybody	anybody	NN
38430	591	14	else	else	RB
38430	591	15	,	,	,
38430	591	16	never	never	RB
38430	591	17	dies	die	VBZ
38430	591	18	,	,	,
38430	591	19	whether	whether	IN
38430	591	20	there	there	EX
38430	591	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	591	22	or	or	CC
38430	591	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	591	24	not	not	RB
38430	591	25	a	a	DT
38430	591	26	last	last	JJ
38430	591	27	moment	moment	NN
38430	591	28	of	of	IN
38430	591	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	591	30	life	life	NN
38430	591	31	on	on	IN
38430	591	32	earth	earth	NN
38430	591	33	.	.	.
38430	592	1	The	the	DT
38430	592	2	first	first	JJ
38430	592	3	argument	argument	NN
38430	592	4	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	592	5	that	that	IN
38430	592	6	,	,	,
38430	592	7	if	if	IN
38430	592	8	there	there	EX
38430	592	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	592	10	a	a	DT
38430	592	11	first	first	JJ
38430	592	12	moment	moment	NN
38430	592	13	of	of	IN
38430	592	14	Socrates	Socrates	NNP
38430	592	15	's	's	POS
38430	592	16	eternal	eternal	JJ
38430	592	17	life	life	NN
38430	592	18	,	,	,
38430	592	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	592	20	life	life	NN
38430	592	21	on	on	IN
38430	592	22	earth	earth	NN
38430	592	23	never	never	RB
38430	592	24	ends	end	VBZ
38430	592	25	.	.	.
38430	593	1	But	but	CC
38430	593	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	593	3	have	have	VBP
38430	593	4	seen	see	VBN
38430	593	5	that	that	IN
38430	593	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	593	7	can	can	MD
38430	593	8	not	not	RB
38430	593	9	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	593	10	that	that	IN
38430	593	11	this	this	DT
38430	593	12	unending	unending	JJ
38430	593	13	life	life	NN
38430	593	14	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	593	15	that	that	IN
38430	593	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	593	17	never	never	RB
38430	593	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	593	19	or	or	CC
38430	593	20	will	will	MD
38430	593	21	be	be	VB
38430	593	22	in	in	IN
38430	593	23	a	a	DT
38430	593	24	state	state	NN
38430	593	25	of	of	IN
38430	593	26	eternity	eternity	NN
38430	593	27	.	.	.
38430	594	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	594	2	:	:	:
38430	594	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	594	4	58	58	CD
38430	594	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	594	6	By	by	IN
38430	594	7	"	"	``
38430	594	8	Dedekind	Dedekind	NNP
38430	594	9	's	's	POS
38430	594	10	Axiom	Axiom	NNP
38430	594	11	,	,	,
38430	594	12	"	"	``
38430	594	13	_	_	NNP
38430	594	14	E.	E.	NNP
38430	595	1	N.	N.	NNP
38430	595	2	_	_	NNP
38430	595	3	,	,	,
38430	595	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	595	5	11	11	CD
38430	595	6	.	.	.
38430	596	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	596	2	59	59	CD
38430	596	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	596	4	_	_	NNP
38430	596	5	M.	M.	NNP
38430	596	6	_	_	NNP
38430	596	7	,	,	,
38430	596	8	vol	vol	NNP
38430	596	9	.	.	.
38430	597	1	xx	xx	NNP
38430	597	2	.	.	NNP
38430	597	3	,	,	,
38430	597	4	1910	1910	CD
38430	597	5	,	,	,
38430	597	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	597	7	.	.	.
38430	598	1	134	134	CD
38430	598	2	-	-	SYM
38430	598	3	5	5	CD
38430	598	4	.	.	.
38430	599	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	599	2	60	60	CD
38430	599	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	599	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	599	5	Here	here	RB
38430	599	6	,	,	,
38430	599	7	again	again	RB
38430	599	8	,	,	,
38430	599	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	599	10	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	599	11	's	's	POS
38430	599	12	work	work	NN
38430	599	13	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	599	14	to	to	TO
38430	599	15	anticipate	anticipate	VB
38430	599	16	some	some	DT
38430	599	17	of	of	IN
38430	599	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	599	19	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	599	20	's	's	POS
38430	599	21	later	later	JJ
38430	599	22	work	work	NN
38430	599	23	,	,	,
38430	599	24	e.g.	e.g.	RB
38430	600	1	in	in	IN
38430	600	2	_	_	NNP
38430	600	3	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	600	4	Knowledge	Knowledge	NNP
38430	600	5	of	of	IN
38430	600	6	the	the	DT
38430	600	7	External	External	NNP
38430	600	8	World	World	NNP
38430	600	9	as	as	IN
38430	600	10	a	a	DT
38430	600	11	Field	field	NN
38430	600	12	for	for	IN
38430	600	13	Scientific	scientific	JJ
38430	600	14	Method	Method	NNP
38430	600	15	in	in	IN
38430	600	16	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	600	17	_	_	NNP
38430	600	18	,	,	,
38430	600	19	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
38430	600	20	and	and	CC
38430	600	21	London	London	NNP
38430	600	22	,	,	,
38430	600	23	1914	1914	CD
38430	600	24	,	,	,
38430	600	25	pp	pp	NNP
38430	600	26	.	.	.
38430	601	1	3	3	CD
38430	601	2	-	-	SYM
38430	601	3	4	4	CD
38430	601	4	,	,	,
38430	601	5	55	55	CD
38430	601	6	-	-	SYM
38430	601	7	6	6	CD
38430	601	8	,	,	,
38430	601	9	_	_	NNP
38430	601	10	et	et	NNP
38430	601	11	passim._--ED	passim._--ed	FW
38430	601	12	.	.	.
38430	601	13	]	]	-RRB-
38430	602	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	602	2	61	61	CD
38430	602	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	602	4	"	"	``
38430	602	5	Pacidius	Pacidius	NNP
38430	602	6	Philalethi	Philalethi	NNP
38430	602	7	"	"	''
38430	602	8	in	in	IN
38430	602	9	Louis	Louis	NNP
38430	602	10	Couturat	Couturat	NNP
38430	602	11	,	,	,
38430	602	12	_	_	NNP
38430	602	13	Opuscules	Opuscules	NNP
38430	602	14	et	et	NNP
38430	602	15	Fragments	Fragments	NNPS
38430	602	16	inédits	inédit	VBZ
38430	602	17	de	de	NNP
38430	602	18	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	602	19	_	_	NNP
38430	602	20	,	,	,
38430	602	21	Paris	Paris	NNP
38430	602	22	,	,	,
38430	602	23	1903	1903	CD
38430	602	24	,	,	,
38430	602	25	pp	pp	NNP
38430	602	26	.	.	.
38430	603	1	594	594	CD
38430	603	2	-	-	SYM
38430	603	3	627	627	CD
38430	603	4	,	,	,
38430	603	5	especially	especially	RB
38430	603	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	603	7	.	.	.
38430	604	1	599	599	CD
38430	604	2	,	,	,
38430	604	3	601	601	CD
38430	604	4	,	,	,
38430	604	5	608	608	CD
38430	604	6	,	,	,
38430	604	7	611	611	CD
38430	604	8	.	.	.
38430	605	1	Cf	cf	NN
38430	605	2	.	.	.
38430	606	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	606	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	606	3	E.	E.	NNP
38430	606	4	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
38430	606	5	,	,	,
38430	606	6	Hastings	Hastings	NNP
38430	606	7	'	'	POS
38430	606	8	_	_	NNP
38430	606	9	Encyclopædia	Encyclopædia	NNP
38430	606	10	of	of	IN
38430	606	11	Religion	Religion	NNP
38430	606	12	and	and	CC
38430	606	13	Ethics	Ethics	NNP
38430	606	14	_	_	NNP
38430	606	15	,	,	,
38430	606	16	vol	vol	NNP
38430	606	17	.	.	.
38430	607	1	iv	iv	NNP
38430	607	2	.	.	NNP
38430	607	3	,	,	,
38430	607	4	Part	Part	NNP
38430	607	5	2	2	CD
38430	607	6	,	,	,
38430	607	7	Edinburgh	Edinburgh	NNP
38430	607	8	,	,	,
38430	607	9	1912	1912	CD
38430	607	10	,	,	,
38430	607	11	p.	p.	NN
38430	608	1	96.--ED	96.--ed	CD
38430	608	2	.	.	.
38430	609	1	]	]	-RRB-
38430	609	2	;	;	:
38430	609	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
38430	609	4	Latta	Latta	NNP
38430	609	5	,	,	,
38430	609	6	_	_	NNP
38430	609	7	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	609	8	:	:	:
38430	609	9	The	the	DT
38430	609	10	Monadology	Monadology	NNP
38430	609	11	and	and	CC
38430	609	12	other	other	JJ
38430	609	13	Philosophical	Philosophical	NNP
38430	609	14	Writings	Writings	NNPS
38430	609	15	_	_	NNP
38430	609	16	,	,	,
38430	609	17	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	609	18	,	,	,
38430	609	19	1898	1898	CD
38430	609	20	,	,	,
38430	609	21	pp	pp	NNP
38430	609	22	.	.	.
38430	610	1	21	21	CD
38430	610	2	ff	ff	NN
38430	610	3	,	,	,
38430	610	4	29	29	CD
38430	610	5	(	(	-LRB-
38430	610	6	note	note	NN
38430	610	7	)	)	-RRB-
38430	610	8	;	;	:
38430	610	9	Couturat	Couturat	NNP
38430	610	10	,	,	,
38430	610	11	_	_	NNP
38430	610	12	La	La	NNP
38430	610	13	Logique	Logique	NNP
38430	610	14	de	de	NNP
38430	610	15	Leibniz	Leibniz	NNP
38430	610	16	d'après	d'après	NNP
38430	610	17	des	des	NNP
38430	610	18	documents	document	NNS
38430	610	19	inédits	inédit	NNS
38430	610	20	_	_	NNP
38430	610	21	,	,	,
38430	610	22	Paris	Paris	NNP
38430	610	23	,	,	,
38430	610	24	1901	1901	CD
38430	610	25	,	,	,
38430	610	26	pp	pp	NNP
38430	610	27	.	.	.
38430	611	1	130	130	CD
38430	611	2	,	,	,
38430	611	3	132	132	CD
38430	611	4	;	;	:
38430	611	5	and	and	CC
38430	611	6	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	611	7	,	,	,
38430	611	8	_	_	NNP
38430	611	9	Ph	Ph	NNP
38430	611	10	.	.	.
38430	612	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	612	2	_	_	NNP
38430	612	3	,	,	,
38430	612	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	612	5	.	.	.
38430	613	1	108	108	CD
38430	613	2	-	-	SYM
38430	613	3	16	16	CD
38430	613	4	,	,	,
38430	613	5	243	243	CD
38430	613	6	-	-	SYM
38430	613	7	9	9	CD
38430	613	8	.	.	.
38430	614	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	614	2	62	62	CD
38430	614	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	614	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	614	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	614	6	may	may	MD
38430	614	7	be	be	VB
38430	614	8	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	614	9	that	that	IN
38430	614	10	,	,	,
38430	614	11	according	accord	VBG
38430	614	12	to	to	IN
38430	614	13	_	_	NNP
38430	614	14	The	the	DT
38430	614	15	Times	Times	NNP
38430	614	16	_	_	NNP
38430	614	17	of	of	IN
38430	614	18	December	December	NNP
38430	614	19	20	20	CD
38430	614	20	,	,	,
38430	614	21	1917	1917	CD
38430	614	22	,	,	,
38430	614	23	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	614	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
38430	614	25	Sargant	Sargant	NNP
38430	614	26	,	,	,
38430	614	27	in	in	IN
38430	614	28	the	the	DT
38430	614	29	Chancery	Chancery	NNP
38430	614	30	Division	Division	NNP
38430	614	31	,	,	,
38430	614	32	also	also	RB
38430	614	33	held	hold	VBD
38430	614	34	that	that	IN
38430	614	35	"	"	``
38430	614	36	the	the	DT
38430	614	37	law	law	NN
38430	614	38	did	do	VBD
38430	614	39	not	not	RB
38430	614	40	recognize	recognize	VB
38430	614	41	fractions	fraction	NNS
38430	614	42	of	of	IN
38430	614	43	a	a	DT
38430	614	44	day	day	NN
38430	614	45	,	,	,
38430	614	46	"	"	''
38430	614	47	and	and	CC
38430	614	48	that	that	IN
38430	614	49	Lord	Lord	NNP
38430	614	50	Blackburn	Blackburn	NNP
38430	614	51	,	,	,
38430	614	52	in	in	IN
38430	614	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	614	54	decision	decision	NN
38430	614	55	(	(	-LRB-
38430	614	56	9	9	CD
38430	614	57	_	_	NNP
38430	614	58	App	App	NNP
38430	614	59	.	.	.
38430	615	1	Cas	Cas	NNP
38430	615	2	.	.	.
38430	615	3	_	_	NNP
38430	615	4	,	,	,
38430	615	5	371	371	CD
38430	615	6	,	,	,
38430	615	7	373	373	CD
38430	615	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	615	9	that	that	WDT
38430	615	10	a	a	DT
38430	615	11	man	man	NN
38430	615	12	born	bear	VBN
38430	615	13	on	on	IN
38430	615	14	the	the	DT
38430	615	15	thirteenth	thirteenth	NN
38430	615	16	of	of	IN
38430	615	17	May	May	NNP
38430	615	18	1853	1853	CD
38430	615	19	attained	attain	VBD
38430	615	20	the	the	DT
38430	615	21	age	age	NN
38430	615	22	of	of	IN
38430	615	23	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	615	24	-	-	HYPH
38430	615	25	one	one	CD
38430	615	26	on	on	IN
38430	615	27	the	the	DT
38430	615	28	thirteenth	thirteenth	NN
38430	615	29	of	of	IN
38430	615	30	May	May	NNP
38430	615	31	1874	1874	CD
38430	615	32	"	"	''
38430	615	33	was	be	VBD
38430	615	34	not	not	RB
38430	615	35	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	615	36	strictly	strictly	RB
38430	615	37	.	.	.
38430	615	38	"--ED	"--ED	''
38430	615	39	.	.	.
38430	615	40	]	]	-RRB-
38430	616	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	616	2	XXIII	xxiii	NN
38430	616	3	DENOTING	denote	VBZ
38430	616	4	A	a	DT
38430	616	5	concept	concept	NN
38430	616	6	_	_	NNP
38430	616	7	denotes	denote	NNS
38430	616	8	_	_	NNP
38430	616	9	when	when	WRB
38430	616	10	,	,	,
38430	616	11	if	if	IN
38430	616	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	616	13	occurs	occur	VBZ
38430	616	14	in	in	IN
38430	616	15	a	a	DT
38430	616	16	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	616	17	,	,	,
38430	616	18	the	the	DT
38430	616	19	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	616	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	616	21	not	not	RB
38430	616	22	about	about	IN
38430	616	23	the	the	DT
38430	616	24	concept	concept	NN
38430	616	25	,	,	,
38430	616	26	but	but	CC
38430	616	27	_	_	NNP
38430	616	28	about	about	IN
38430	616	29	_	_	NNP
38430	616	30	a	a	DT
38430	616	31	term	term	NN
38430	616	32	connected	connect	VBN
38430	616	33	in	in	IN
38430	616	34	a	a	DT
38430	616	35	certain	certain	JJ
38430	616	36	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
38430	616	37	way	way	NN
38430	616	38	with	with	IN
38430	616	39	the	the	DT
38430	616	40	concept	concept	NN
38430	616	41	.	.	.
38430	617	1	Some	some	DT
38430	617	2	people	people	NNS
38430	617	3	often	often	RB
38430	617	4	assert	assert	VBP
38430	617	5	that	that	DT
38430	617	6	man	man	NN
38430	617	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	617	8	mortal	mortal	JJ
38430	617	9	,	,	,
38430	617	10	and	and	CC
38430	617	11	yet	yet	RB
38430	617	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	617	13	never	never	RB
38430	617	14	see	see	VBP
38430	617	15	announced	announce	VBN
38430	617	16	in	in	IN
38430	617	17	_	_	NNP
38430	617	18	The	the	DT
38430	617	19	Times	Times	NNP
38430	617	20	_	_	NNP
38430	617	21	that	that	DT
38430	617	22	Man	Man	NNP
38430	617	23	died	die	VBD
38430	617	24	on	on	IN
38430	617	25	a	a	DT
38430	617	26	certain	certain	JJ
38430	617	27	day	day	NN
38430	617	28	at	at	IN
38430	617	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	617	30	villa	villa	NN
38430	617	31	residence	residence	NN
38430	617	32	"	"	``
38430	617	33	Camelot	Camelot	NNP
38430	617	34	"	"	''
38430	617	35	at	at	IN
38430	617	36	Upper	Upper	NNP
38430	617	37	Tooting,[63	tooting,[63	NN
38430	617	38	]	]	-RRB-
38430	617	39	nor	nor	CC
38430	617	40	do	do	VBP
38430	617	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	617	42	hear	hear	VB
38430	617	43	that	that	IN
38430	617	44	Procrastination	procrastination	NN
38430	617	45	was	be	VBD
38430	617	46	again	again	RB
38430	617	47	the	the	DT
38430	617	48	butt	butt	NN
38430	617	49	of	of	IN
38430	617	50	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	617	51	Plowden	Plowden	NNP
38430	617	52	's	's	POS
38430	617	53	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	617	54	at	at	IN
38430	617	55	Marylebone	Marylebone	NNP
38430	617	56	Police	Police	NNP
38430	617	57	Court	Court	NNP
38430	617	58	last	last	JJ
38430	617	59	week	week	NN
38430	617	60	.	.	.
38430	618	1	That	that	IN
38430	618	2	two	two	CD
38430	618	3	phrases	phrase	NNS
38430	618	4	may	may	MD
38430	618	5	have	have	VB
38430	618	6	different	different	JJ
38430	618	7	_	_	NNP
38430	618	8	meanings	meaning	NNS
38430	618	9	_	_	NNP
38430	618	10	and	and	CC
38430	618	11	the	the	DT
38430	618	12	same	same	JJ
38430	618	13	_	_	NNP
38430	618	14	denotation	denotation	NN
38430	618	15	_	_	NNP
38430	618	16	was	be	VBD
38430	618	17	discovered	discover	VBN
38430	618	18	by	by	IN
38430	618	19	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	618	20	and	and	CC
38430	618	21	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	618	22	.	.	.
38430	619	1	Alice[64	Alice[64	NFP
38430	619	2	]	]	-RRB-
38430	619	3	observed	observe	VBD
38430	619	4	that	that	IN
38430	619	5	the	the	DT
38430	619	6	road	road	NN
38430	619	7	which	which	WDT
38430	619	8	led	lead	VBD
38430	619	9	to	to	IN
38430	619	10	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	619	11	's	's	POS
38430	619	12	house	house	NN
38430	619	13	was	be	VBD
38430	619	14	that	that	DT
38430	619	15	which	which	WDT
38430	619	16	led	lead	VBD
38430	619	17	to	to	IN
38430	619	18	the	the	DT
38430	619	19	house	house	NN
38430	619	20	of	of	IN
38430	619	21	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	619	22	;	;	:
38430	619	23	and	and	CC
38430	619	24	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	619	25	pointed	point	VBD
38430	619	26	out	out	RP
38430	619	27	that	that	IN
38430	619	28	the	the	DT
38430	619	29	phrases	phrase	NNS
38430	619	30	"	"	``
38430	619	31	the	the	DT
38430	619	32	house	house	NN
38430	619	33	to	to	TO
38430	619	34	which	which	WDT
38430	619	35	the	the	DT
38430	619	36	road	road	NN
38430	619	37	that	that	WDT
38430	619	38	leads	lead	VBZ
38430	619	39	to	to	IN
38430	619	40	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	619	41	's	's	POS
38430	619	42	house	house	NN
38430	619	43	leads	lead	VBZ
38430	619	44	"	"	''
38430	619	45	and	and	CC
38430	619	46	"	"	``
38430	619	47	the	the	DT
38430	619	48	house	house	NN
38430	619	49	to	to	TO
38430	619	50	which	which	WDT
38430	619	51	the	the	DT
38430	619	52	road	road	NN
38430	619	53	that	that	WDT
38430	619	54	leads	lead	VBZ
38430	619	55	to	to	IN
38430	619	56	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	619	57	's	's	POS
38430	619	58	house	house	NN
38430	619	59	leads	lead	VBZ
38430	619	60	"	"	``
38430	619	61	have	have	VBP
38430	619	62	different	different	JJ
38430	619	63	_	_	NNP
38430	619	64	Sinn	Sinn	NNP
38430	619	65	_	_	NNP
38430	619	66	,	,	,
38430	619	67	but	but	CC
38430	619	68	the	the	DT
38430	619	69	same	same	JJ
38430	619	70	_	_	NNP
38430	619	71	Bedeutung	Bedeutung	NNP
38430	619	72	_	_	NNP
38430	619	73	.	.	.
38430	620	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	620	2	:	:	:
38430	620	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	620	4	63	63	CD
38430	620	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	620	6	Cf	cf	NN
38430	620	7	.	.	.
38430	621	1	_	_	NNP
38430	621	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	622	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	622	2	_	_	NNP
38430	622	3	,	,	,
38430	622	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	622	5	.	.	.
38430	623	1	53	53	CD
38430	623	2	-	-	SYM
38430	623	3	4	4	CD
38430	623	4	.	.	.
38430	624	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	624	2	64	64	CD
38430	624	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	624	4	See	see	VB
38430	624	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	624	6	M.	M.	NNP
38430	624	7	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	624	8	XXIV	XXIV	NNP
38430	624	9	THE	the	DT
38430	624	10	The	the	DT
38430	624	11	word	word	NN
38430	624	12	"	"	``
38430	624	13	the	the	DT
38430	624	14	"	"	''
38430	624	15	implies	imply	VBZ
38430	624	16	existence	existence	NN
38430	624	17	and	and	CC
38430	624	18	uniqueness	uniqueness	NN
38430	624	19	;	;	:
38430	624	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	624	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	624	22	a	a	DT
38430	624	23	mistake	mistake	NN
38430	624	24	to	to	TO
38430	624	25	talk	talk	VB
38430	624	26	of	of	IN
38430	624	27	"	"	``
38430	624	28	the	the	DT
38430	624	29	son	son	NN
38430	624	30	of	of	IN
38430	624	31	So	So	NNP
38430	624	32	-	-	HYPH
38430	624	33	and	and	CC
38430	624	34	-	-	HYPH
38430	624	35	So	so	RB
38430	624	36	"	"	''
38430	624	37	if	if	IN
38430	624	38	So	so	RB
38430	624	39	-	-	HYPH
38430	624	40	and	and	CC
38430	624	41	-	-	HYPH
38430	624	42	So	so	RB
38430	624	43	has	have	VBZ
38430	624	44	a	a	DT
38430	624	45	fine	fine	JJ
38430	624	46	family	family	NN
38430	624	47	of	of	IN
38430	624	48	ten	ten	CD
38430	624	49	sons	son	NNS
38430	624	50	.	.	.
38430	625	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	625	2	65	65	CD
38430	625	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	625	4	People	People	NNS
38430	625	5	who	who	WP
38430	625	6	refer	refer	VBP
38430	625	7	to	to	IN
38430	625	8	"	"	``
38430	625	9	the	the	DT
38430	625	10	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	625	11	Movement	Movement	NNP
38430	625	12	"	"	''
38430	625	13	imply	imply	VBP
38430	625	14	that	that	IN
38430	625	15	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	625	16	only	only	RB
38430	625	17	moved	move	VBD
38430	625	18	once	once	RB
38430	625	19	;	;	:
38430	625	20	and	and	CC
38430	625	21	those	those	DT
38430	625	22	quaint	quaint	NN
38430	625	23	people	people	NNS
38430	625	24	who	who	WP
38430	625	25	say	say	VBP
38430	625	26	that	that	IN
38430	625	27	"	"	``
38430	625	28	A	a	DT
38430	625	29	is	be	VBZ
38430	625	30	quite	quite	PDT
38430	625	31	the	the	DT
38430	625	32	gentleman	gentleman	NN
38430	625	33	"	"	``
38430	625	34	imply	imply	VB
38430	625	35	both	both	CC
38430	625	36	the	the	DT
38430	625	37	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	625	38	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	625	39	that	that	IN
38430	625	40	there	there	EX
38430	625	41	is	be	VBZ
38430	625	42	only	only	RB
38430	625	43	one	one	CD
38430	625	44	gentleman	gentleman	NN
38430	625	45	in	in	IN
38430	625	46	the	the	DT
38430	625	47	world	world	NN
38430	625	48	,	,	,
38430	625	49	and	and	CC
38430	625	50	the	the	DT
38430	625	51	indubitably	indubitably	RB
38430	625	52	false	false	JJ
38430	625	53	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	625	54	that	that	IN
38430	625	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	625	56	is	be	VBZ
38430	625	57	that	that	DT
38430	625	58	man	man	NN
38430	625	59	.	.	.
38430	626	1	Probably	probably	RB
38430	626	2	A	a	DT
38430	626	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	626	4	one	one	CD
38430	626	5	of	of	IN
38430	626	6	those	those	DT
38430	626	7	persons	person	NNS
38430	626	8	who	who	WP
38430	626	9	add	add	VBP
38430	626	10	to	to	IN
38430	626	11	the	the	DT
38430	626	12	confusion	confusion	NN
38430	626	13	in	in	IN
38430	626	14	the	the	DT
38430	626	15	use	use	NN
38430	626	16	of	of	IN
38430	626	17	the	the	DT
38430	626	18	definite	definite	JJ
38430	626	19	article	article	NN
38430	626	20	by	by	IN
38430	626	21	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	626	22	of	of	IN
38430	626	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	626	24	wife	wife	NN
38430	626	25	as	as	IN
38430	626	26	"	"	``
38430	626	27	the	the	DT
38430	626	28	wife	wife	NN
38430	626	29	.	.	.
38430	626	30	"	"	''
38430	627	1	In	in	IN
38430	627	2	a	a	DT
38430	627	3	certain	certain	JJ
38430	627	4	Children	Children	NNP
38430	627	5	's	's	POS
38430	627	6	Hymn	Hymn	NNP
38430	627	7	Book	Book	NNP
38430	627	8	one	one	CD
38430	627	9	reads	read	VBZ
38430	627	10	:	:	:
38430	627	11	The	the	DT
38430	627	12	river	river	NN
38430	627	13	vast	vast	JJ
38430	627	14	and	and	CC
38430	627	15	small	small	JJ
38430	627	16	.	.	.
38430	628	1	Few	few	JJ
38430	628	2	would	would	MD
38430	628	3	deny	deny	VB
38430	628	4	that	that	IN
38430	628	5	there	there	EX
38430	628	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	628	7	not	not	RB
38430	628	8	more	more	JJR
38430	628	9	than	than	IN
38430	628	10	one	one	CD
38430	628	11	such	such	JJ
38430	628	12	river	river	NN
38430	628	13	,	,	,
38430	628	14	but	but	CC
38430	628	15	unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
38430	628	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	628	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	628	18	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	628	19	if	if	IN
38430	628	20	there	there	EX
38430	628	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	628	22	such	such	PDT
38430	628	23	a	a	DT
38430	628	24	river	river	NN
38430	628	25	at	at	RB
38430	628	26	all	all	RB
38430	628	27	.	.	.
38430	629	1	The	the	DT
38430	629	2	case	case	NN
38430	629	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	629	4	exactly	exactly	RB
38430	629	5	the	the	DT
38430	629	6	same	same	JJ
38430	629	7	with	with	IN
38430	629	8	the	the	DT
38430	629	9	ontological	ontological	JJ
38430	629	10	proof	proof	NN
38430	629	11	of	of	IN
38430	629	12	the	the	DT
38430	629	13	existence	existence	NN
38430	629	14	of	of	IN
38430	629	15	the	the	DT
38430	629	16	most	most	RBS
38430	629	17	perfect	perfect	JJ
38430	629	18	being	being	NN
38430	629	19	.	.	.
38430	630	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	630	2	66	66	CD
38430	630	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	630	4	According	accord	VBG
38430	630	5	to	to	IN
38430	630	6	the	the	DT
38430	630	7	_	_	NNP
38430	630	8	Daily	Daily	NNP
38430	630	9	Mail	Mail	NNP
38430	630	10	_	_	NNP
38430	630	11	of	of	IN
38430	630	12	October	October	NNP
38430	630	13	9	9	CD
38430	630	14	,	,	,
38430	630	15	1906	1906	CD
38430	630	16	,	,	,
38430	630	17	Judge	Judge	NNP
38430	630	18	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	630	19	decided	decide	VBD
38430	630	20	against	against	IN
38430	630	21	a	a	DT
38430	630	22	claim	claim	NN
38430	630	23	brought	bring	VBN
38430	630	24	by	by	IN
38430	630	25	an	an	DT
38430	630	26	agent	agent	NN
38430	630	27	against	against	IN
38430	630	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	630	29	company	company	NN
38430	630	30	for	for	IN
38430	630	31	appointing	appoint	VBG
38430	630	32	another	another	DT
38430	630	33	agent	agent	NN
38430	630	34	,	,	,
38430	630	35	the	the	DT
38430	630	36	claim	claim	NN
38430	630	37	being	be	VBG
38430	630	38	on	on	IN
38430	630	39	the	the	DT
38430	630	40	ground	ground	NN
38430	630	41	that	that	IN
38430	630	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	630	43	was	be	VBD
38430	630	44	appointed	appoint	VBN
38430	630	45	as	as	IN
38430	630	46	"	"	``
38430	630	47	the	the	DT
38430	630	48	"	"	``
38430	630	49	agent	agent	NN
38430	630	50	.	.	.
38430	631	1	Most	Most	JJS
38430	631	2	people	people	NNS
38430	631	3	admit	admit	VBP
38430	631	4	that	that	IN
38430	631	5	the	the	DT
38430	631	6	number	number	NN
38430	631	7	2	2	CD
38430	631	8	can	can	MD
38430	631	9	be	be	VB
38430	631	10	added	add	VBN
38430	631	11	to	to	IN
38430	631	12	the	the	DT
38430	631	13	number	number	NN
38430	631	14	2	2	CD
38430	631	15	to	to	TO
38430	631	16	give	give	VB
38430	631	17	the	the	DT
38430	631	18	number	number	NN
38430	631	19	4	4	CD
38430	631	20	,	,	,
38430	631	21	but	but	CC
38430	631	22	this	this	DT
38430	631	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	631	24	a	a	DT
38430	631	25	mistake	mistake	NN
38430	631	26	.	.	.
38430	632	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	2	concede	concede	VBP
38430	632	3	,	,	,
38430	632	4	when	when	WRB
38430	632	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	6	use	use	VBP
38430	632	7	_	_	NNP
38430	632	8	the	the	DT
38430	632	9	_	_	NNP
38430	632	10	,	,	,
38430	632	11	that	that	IN
38430	632	12	there	there	EX
38430	632	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	632	14	only	only	RB
38430	632	15	one	one	CD
38430	632	16	number	number	NN
38430	632	17	2	2	CD
38430	632	18	,	,	,
38430	632	19	and	and	CC
38430	632	20	yet	yet	RB
38430	632	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	22	imagine	imagine	VBP
38430	632	23	that	that	IN
38430	632	24	,	,	,
38430	632	25	when	when	WRB
38430	632	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	27	consider	consider	VBP
38430	632	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	29	apart	apart	RB
38430	632	30	as	as	IN
38430	632	31	the	the	DT
38430	632	32	first	first	JJ
38430	632	33	term	term	NN
38430	632	34	of	of	IN
38430	632	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	632	36	above	above	JJ
38430	632	37	sum	sum	NN
38430	632	38	,	,	,
38430	632	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	40	can	can	MD
38430	632	41	find	find	VB
38430	632	42	another	another	DT
38430	632	43	to	to	TO
38430	632	44	add	add	VB
38430	632	45	to	to	IN
38430	632	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	632	47	,	,	,
38430	632	48	and	and	CC
38430	632	49	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	632	50	form	form	VB
38430	632	51	the	the	DT
38430	632	52	third	third	JJ
38430	632	53	term	term	NN
38430	632	54	.	.	.
38430	633	1	The	the	DT
38430	633	2	truth	truth	NN
38430	633	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	633	4	that	that	IN
38430	633	5	"	"	``
38430	633	6	2	2	CD
38430	633	7	+	+	SYM
38430	633	8	2	2	CD
38430	633	9	=	=	SYM
38430	633	10	4	4	CD
38430	633	11	"	"	''
38430	633	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	633	13	a	a	DT
38430	633	14	very	very	RB
38430	633	15	misleading	misleading	JJ
38430	633	16	equation	equation	NN
38430	633	17	,	,	,
38430	633	18	and	and	CC
38430	633	19	what	what	WP
38430	633	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	633	21	really	really	RB
38430	633	22	mean	mean	VBP
38430	633	23	by	by	IN
38430	633	24	that	that	DT
38430	633	25	faultily	faultily	RB
38430	633	26	abbreviated	abbreviate	VBN
38430	633	27	statement	statement	NN
38430	633	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	633	29	more	more	RBR
38430	633	30	precisely	precisely	RB
38430	633	31	:	:	:
38430	633	32	If	if	IN
38430	633	33	_	_	NNP
38430	633	34	x	x	NNP
38430	633	35	_	_	NNP
38430	633	36	and	and	CC
38430	633	37	_	_	NNP
38430	633	38	y	y	NNP
38430	633	39	_	_	NNP
38430	633	40	denote	denote	NN
38430	633	41	any	any	DT
38430	633	42	things	thing	NNS
38430	633	43	which	which	WDT
38430	633	44	form	form	VBP
38430	633	45	a	a	DT
38430	633	46	class	class	NN
38430	633	47	B	b	NN
38430	633	48	,	,	,
38430	633	49	and	and	CC
38430	633	50	_	_	NNP
38430	633	51	x	x	SYM
38430	633	52	´	´	CD
38430	633	53	_	_	NNP
38430	633	54	and	and	CC
38430	633	55	_	_	NNP
38430	633	56	y	y	NNP
38430	633	57	´	´	CD
38430	633	58	_	_	NNP
38430	633	59	any	any	DT
38430	633	60	other	other	JJ
38430	633	61	things	thing	NNS
38430	633	62	that	that	WDT
38430	633	63	form	form	VBP
38430	633	64	a	a	DT
38430	633	65	class	class	NN
38430	633	66	(	(	-LRB-
38430	633	67	A	a	NN
38430	633	68	)	)	-RRB-
38430	633	69	which	which	WDT
38430	633	70	,	,	,
38430	633	71	like	like	IN
38430	633	72	that	that	DT
38430	633	73	of	of	IN
38430	633	74	_	_	NNP
38430	633	75	x	x	NNP
38430	633	76	_	_	NNP
38430	633	77	and	and	CC
38430	633	78	_	_	NNP
38430	633	79	y	y	NNP
38430	633	80	_	_	NNP
38430	633	81	,	,	,
38430	633	82	is	be	VBZ
38430	633	83	a	a	DT
38430	633	84	member	member	NN
38430	633	85	of	of	IN
38430	633	86	the	the	DT
38430	633	87	class	class	NN
38430	633	88	(	(	-LRB-
38430	633	89	which	which	WDT
38430	633	90	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	633	91	call	call	VBP
38430	633	92	"	"	``
38430	633	93	2	2	CD
38430	633	94	"	"	''
38430	633	95	)	)	-RRB-
38430	633	96	of	of	IN
38430	633	97	those	those	DT
38430	633	98	classes	class	NNS
38430	633	99	which	which	WDT
38430	633	100	have	have	VBP
38430	633	101	a	a	DT
38430	633	102	one	one	CD
38430	633	103	-	-	HYPH
38430	633	104	one	one	CD
38430	633	105	correspondence	correspondence	NN
38430	633	106	with	with	IN
38430	633	107	B	b	NN
38430	633	108	(	(	-LRB-
38430	633	109	so	so	IN
38430	633	110	that	that	IN
38430	633	111	any	any	DT
38430	633	112	member	member	NN
38430	633	113	of	of	IN
38430	633	114	A	a	DT
38430	633	115	corresponds	correspond	NNS
38430	633	116	to	to	IN
38430	633	117	one	one	CD
38430	633	118	,	,	,
38430	633	119	and	and	CC
38430	633	120	only	only	RB
38430	633	121	one	one	CD
38430	633	122	,	,	,
38430	633	123	member	member	NN
38430	633	124	of	of	IN
38430	633	125	B	B	NNP
38430	633	126	,	,	,
38430	633	127	and	and	CC
38430	633	128	conversely	conversely	RB
38430	633	129	)	)	-RRB-
38430	633	130	,	,	,
38430	633	131	the	the	DT
38430	633	132	class	class	NN
38430	633	133	of	of	IN
38430	633	134	all	all	PDT
38430	633	135	the	the	DT
38430	633	136	terms	term	NNS
38430	633	137	of	of	IN
38430	633	138	A	a	NN
38430	633	139	and	and	CC
38430	633	140	B	b	NN
38430	633	141	together	together	RB
38430	633	142	is	be	VBZ
38430	633	143	a	a	DT
38430	633	144	member	member	NN
38430	633	145	of	of	IN
38430	633	146	that	that	DT
38430	633	147	class	class	NN
38430	633	148	of	of	IN
38430	633	149	classes	class	NNS
38430	633	150	which	which	WDT
38430	633	151	,	,	,
38430	633	152	analogously	analogously	RB
38430	633	153	,	,	,
38430	633	154	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	633	155	call	call	VBP
38430	633	156	"	"	``
38430	633	157	4	4	CD
38430	633	158	.	.	.
38430	633	159	"	"	''
38430	634	1	In	in	IN
38430	634	2	this	this	DT
38430	634	3	,	,	,
38430	634	4	for	for	IN
38430	634	5	the	the	DT
38430	634	6	sake	sake	NN
38430	634	7	of	of	IN
38430	634	8	shortness	shortness	NN
38430	634	9	,	,	,
38430	634	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	634	11	have	have	VBP
38430	634	12	introduced	introduce	VBN
38430	634	13	abbreviations	abbreviation	NNS
38430	634	14	which	which	WDT
38430	634	15	should	should	MD
38430	634	16	not	not	RB
38430	634	17	be	be	VB
38430	634	18	used	use	VBN
38430	634	19	in	in	IN
38430	634	20	a	a	DT
38430	634	21	rigorous	rigorous	JJ
38430	634	22	logical	logical	JJ
38430	634	23	statement	statement	NN
38430	634	24	.	.	.
38430	635	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	635	2	:	:	:
38430	635	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	635	4	65	65	CD
38430	635	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	635	6	Cf	cf	NN
38430	635	7	.	.	.
38430	636	1	_	_	NNP
38430	636	2	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	636	3	_	_	NNP
38430	636	4	,	,	,
38430	636	5	N.	N.	NNP
38430	636	6	S.	S.	NNP
38430	636	7	,	,	,
38430	636	8	vol	vol	NNP
38430	636	9	.	.	.
38430	637	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	637	2	.	.	NNP
38430	637	3	,	,	,
38430	637	4	1905	1905	CD
38430	637	5	,	,	,
38430	637	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	637	7	.	.	.
38430	638	1	481	481	CD
38430	638	2	,	,	,
38430	638	3	484	484	CD
38430	638	4	.	.	.
38430	639	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	639	2	66	66	CD
38430	639	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	639	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	639	5	.	.	.
38430	640	1	_	_	NNP
38430	640	2	ibid	ibid	NN
38430	640	3	.	.	.
38430	640	4	_	_	NNP
38430	640	5	,	,	,
38430	640	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	640	7	491	491	CD
38430	640	8	,	,	,
38430	640	9	note	note	NN
38430	640	10	.	.	.
38430	641	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	641	2	XXV	XXV	NNP
38430	641	3	NON	NON	NNP
38430	641	4	-	-	NNP
38430	641	5	ENTITY	entity	NN
38430	641	6	When	when	WRB
38430	641	7	people	people	NNS
38430	641	8	say	say	VBP
38430	641	9	that	that	IN
38430	641	10	such	such	JJ
38430	641	11	-	-	HYPH
38430	641	12	and	and	CC
38430	641	13	-	-	HYPH
38430	641	14	such	such	PDT
38430	641	15	a	a	DT
38430	641	16	thing	thing	NN
38430	641	17	"	"	``
38430	641	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	641	19	non	non	JJ
38430	641	20	-	-	JJ
38430	641	21	existent	existent	JJ
38430	641	22	"	"	''
38430	641	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	641	24	usually	usually	RB
38430	641	25	mean	mean	VBP
38430	641	26	that	that	IN
38430	641	27	there	there	EX
38430	641	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	641	29	not	not	RB
38430	641	30	any	any	DT
38430	641	31	"	"	``
38430	641	32	thing	thing	NN
38430	641	33	"	"	''
38430	641	34	of	of	IN
38430	641	35	the	the	DT
38430	641	36	kind	kind	NN
38430	641	37	spoken	speak	VBN
38430	641	38	of	of	IN
38430	641	39	.	.	.
38430	642	1	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	642	2	meant	mean	VBD
38430	642	3	this	this	DT
38430	642	4	when	when	WRB
38430	642	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	642	6	described[67	described[67	VBZ
38430	642	7	]	]	-RRB-
38430	642	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	642	9	encounter	encounter	NN
38430	642	10	with	with	IN
38430	642	11	what	what	WP
38430	642	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	642	13	imagined	imagine	VBD
38430	642	14	to	to	TO
38430	642	15	be	be	VB
38430	642	16	a	a	DT
38430	642	17	very	very	RB
38430	642	18	ingenious	ingenious	JJ
38430	642	19	tradesman	tradesman	NN
38430	642	20	:	:	:
38430	642	21	"	"	``
38430	642	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	642	23	once	once	RB
38430	642	24	had	have	VBD
38430	642	25	some	some	DT
38430	642	26	strawberry	strawberry	JJ
38430	642	27	plants	plant	NNS
38430	642	28	furnished	furnish	VBD
38430	642	29	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	642	30	which	which	WDT
38430	642	31	the	the	DT
38430	642	32	vendor	vendor	NN
38430	642	33	admitted	admit	VBD
38430	642	34	would	would	MD
38430	642	35	not	not	RB
38430	642	36	bear	bear	VB
38430	642	37	many	many	JJ
38430	642	38	berries	berry	NNS
38430	642	39	.	.	.
38430	643	1	But	but	CC
38430	643	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	643	3	assured	assure	VBD
38430	643	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	643	5	that	that	IN
38430	643	6	this	this	DT
38430	643	7	did	do	VBD
38430	643	8	not	not	RB
38430	643	9	matter	matter	VB
38430	643	10	,	,	,
38430	643	11	since	since	IN
38430	643	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	643	13	made	make	VBD
38430	643	14	up	up	RP
38430	643	15	in	in	IN
38430	643	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	643	17	size	size	NN
38430	643	18	what	what	WP
38430	643	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	643	20	lost	lose	VBD
38430	643	21	in	in	IN
38430	643	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	643	23	number	number	NN
38430	643	24	.	.	.
38430	644	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	644	2	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	644	3	gave	give	VBD
38430	644	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	644	5	,	,	,
38430	644	6	in	in	IN
38430	644	7	fact	fact	NN
38430	644	8	,	,	,
38430	644	9	the	the	DT
38430	644	10	hyperbolic	hyperbolic	JJ
38430	644	11	formula	formula	NN
38430	644	12	,	,	,
38430	644	13	_	_	NNP
38430	644	14	xy	xy	NNP
38430	644	15	=	=	SYM
38430	644	16	c	c	NNP
38430	644	17	_	_	NNP
38430	644	18	,	,	,
38430	644	19	to	to	TO
38430	644	20	connect	connect	VB
38430	644	21	the	the	DT
38430	644	22	number	number	NN
38430	644	23	and	and	CC
38430	644	24	magnitude	magnitude	NN
38430	644	25	.	.	.
38430	644	26	)	)	-RRB-
38430	645	1	When	when	WRB
38430	645	2	summer	summer	NN
38430	645	3	came	come	VBD
38430	645	4	,	,	,
38430	645	5	_	_	NNP
38430	645	6	no	no	DT
38430	645	7	_	_	NNP
38430	645	8	fruit	fruit	NN
38430	645	9	whatever	whatever	WDT
38430	645	10	appeared	appear	VBD
38430	645	11	.	.	.
38430	646	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	646	2	saw	see	VBD
38430	646	3	that	that	IN
38430	646	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	646	5	would	would	MD
38430	646	6	be	be	VB
38430	646	7	no	no	DT
38430	646	8	use	use	NN
38430	646	9	to	to	TO
38430	646	10	complain	complain	VB
38430	646	11	,	,	,
38430	646	12	because	because	IN
38430	646	13	the	the	DT
38430	646	14	man	man	NN
38430	646	15	would	would	MD
38430	646	16	urge	urge	VB
38430	646	17	that	that	IN
38430	646	18	the	the	DT
38430	646	19	size	size	NN
38430	646	20	of	of	IN
38430	646	21	the	the	DT
38430	646	22	non	non	JJ
38430	646	23	-	-	JJ
38430	646	24	existent	existent	JJ
38430	646	25	berry	berry	NN
38430	646	26	was	be	VBD
38430	646	27	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	646	28	,	,	,
38430	646	29	which	which	WDT
38430	646	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	646	31	could	could	MD
38430	646	32	not	not	RB
38430	646	33	see	see	VB
38430	646	34	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	646	35	way	way	NN
38430	646	36	to	to	TO
38430	646	37	disprove	disprove	VB
38430	646	38	.	.	.
38430	647	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	647	2	had	have	VBD
38430	647	3	forgotten	forget	VBN
38430	647	4	to	to	TO
38430	647	5	bar	bar	NN
38430	647	6	zero	zero	CD
38430	647	7	values	value	NNS
38430	647	8	of	of	IN
38430	647	9	either	either	DT
38430	647	10	variable	variable	NN
38430	647	11	.	.	.
38430	647	12	"	"	''
38430	648	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	648	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	648	3	to	to	TO
38430	648	4	be	be	VB
38430	648	5	regretted	regret	VBN
38430	648	6	that	that	IN
38430	648	7	this	this	DT
38430	648	8	useful	useful	JJ
38430	648	9	note	note	NN
38430	648	10	was	be	VBD
38430	648	11	omitted	omit	VBN
38430	648	12	in	in	IN
38430	648	13	the	the	DT
38430	648	14	second	second	JJ
38430	648	15	edition	edition	NN
38430	648	16	of	of	IN
38430	648	17	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	648	18	's	's	POS
38430	648	19	book	book	NN
38430	648	20	;	;	:
38430	648	21	one	one	PRP
38430	648	22	can	can	MD
38430	648	23	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	648	24	that	that	IN
38430	648	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	648	26	might	may	MD
38430	648	27	have	have	VB
38430	648	28	protected	protect	VBN
38430	648	29	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	648	30	MacColl	MacColl	NNP
38430	648	31	and	and	CC
38430	648	32	Herr	Herr	NNP
38430	648	33	Meinong	Meinong	NNP
38430	648	34	(	(	-LRB-
38430	648	35	who	who	WP
38430	648	36	believed	believe	VBD
38430	648	37	,	,	,
38430	648	38	unlike	unlike	IN
38430	648	39	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	648	40	in	in	IN
38430	648	41	what	what	WP
38430	648	42	may	may	MD
38430	648	43	be	be	VB
38430	648	44	called	call	VBN
38430	648	45	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	648	46	first	first	JJ
38430	648	47	theory,[68	theory,[68	NNP
38430	648	48	]	]	-RRB-
38430	648	49	in	in	IN
38430	648	50	round	round	JJ
38430	648	51	squares	square	NNS
38430	648	52	and	and	CC
38430	648	53	fabulous	fabulous	JJ
38430	648	54	monsters	monster	NNS
38430	648	55	)	)	-RRB-
38430	648	56	against	against	IN
38430	648	57	the	the	DT
38430	648	58	dishonest	dishonest	JJ
38430	648	59	practices	practice	NNS
38430	648	60	of	of	IN
38430	648	61	traders	trader	NNS
38430	648	62	who	who	WP
38430	648	63	were	be	VBD
38430	648	64	too	too	RB
38430	648	65	ready	ready	JJ
38430	648	66	with	with	IN
38430	648	67	promises	promise	NNS
38430	648	68	.	.	.
38430	649	1	For	for	IN
38430	649	2	the	the	DT
38430	649	3	death	death	NN
38430	649	4	-	-	HYPH
38430	649	5	blow	blow	NN
38430	649	6	to	to	IN
38430	649	7	this	this	DT
38430	649	8	kind	kind	NN
38430	649	9	of	of	IN
38430	649	10	trade	trade	NN
38430	649	11	was	be	VBD
38430	649	12	not	not	RB
38430	649	13	given	give	VBN
38430	649	14	until	until	IN
38430	649	15	1905	1905	CD
38430	649	16	,	,	,
38430	649	17	when	when	WRB
38430	649	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	649	19	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	649	20	published	publish	VBD
38430	649	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	649	22	article	article	NN
38430	649	23	"	"	``
38430	649	24	On	on	IN
38430	649	25	Denoting,"[69	Denoting,"[69	NNP
38430	649	26	]	]	-RRB-
38430	649	27	and	and	CC
38430	649	28	took	take	VBD
38430	649	29	up	up	RP
38430	649	30	the	the	DT
38430	649	31	position	position	NN
38430	649	32	of	of	IN
38430	649	33	the	the	DT
38430	649	34	White	White	NNP
38430	649	35	King	King	NNP
38430	649	36	in	in	IN
38430	649	37	opposition	opposition	NN
38430	649	38	to	to	IN
38430	649	39	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	649	40	's	's	POS
38430	649	41	later	later	JJ
38430	649	42	assertions	assertion	NNS
38430	649	43	.	.	.
38430	650	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	650	2	70	70	CD
38430	650	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	650	4	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	650	5	's	's	POS
38430	650	6	experience	experience	NN
38430	650	7	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
38430	650	8	another	another	DT
38430	650	9	characteristic	characteristic	NN
38430	650	10	of	of	IN
38430	650	11	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	650	12	logic	logic	NN
38430	650	13	.	.	.
38430	651	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	651	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	651	3	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	651	4	,	,	,
38430	651	5	in	in	IN
38430	651	6	order	order	NN
38430	651	7	to	to	TO
38430	651	8	make	make	VB
38430	651	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	651	10	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	651	11	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
38430	651	12	,	,	,
38430	651	13	to	to	TO
38430	651	14	devote	devote	VB
38430	651	15	great	great	JJ
38430	651	16	care	care	NN
38430	651	17	to	to	IN
38430	651	18	the	the	DT
38430	651	19	elimination	elimination	NN
38430	651	20	of	of	IN
38430	651	21	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	651	22	which	which	WDT
38430	651	23	rarely	rarely	RB
38430	651	24	occur	occur	VBP
38430	651	25	.	.	.
38430	652	1	The	the	DT
38430	652	2	White	White	NNP
38430	652	3	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	652	4	--	--	:
38430	652	5	who	who	WP
38430	652	6	was	be	VBD
38430	652	7	like	like	IN
38430	652	8	Boole	Boole	NNP
38430	652	9	in	in	IN
38430	652	10	being	be	VBG
38430	652	11	a	a	DT
38430	652	12	pioneer	pioneer	NN
38430	652	13	of	of	IN
38430	652	14	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	652	15	logic	logic	NN
38430	652	16	in	in	IN
38430	652	17	this	this	DT
38430	652	18	way	way	NN
38430	652	19	,	,	,
38430	652	20	and	and	CC
38430	652	21	yet	yet	RB
38430	652	22	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	652	23	to	to	TO
38430	652	24	have	have	VB
38430	652	25	held	hold	VBN
38430	652	26	,	,	,
38430	652	27	like	like	IN
38430	652	28	Boole	Boole	NNP
38430	652	29	,	,	,
38430	652	30	those	those	DT
38430	652	31	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	652	32	opinions	opinion	NNS
38430	652	33	which	which	WDT
38430	652	34	would	would	MD
38430	652	35	base	base	VB
38430	652	36	logic	logic	NN
38430	652	37	on	on	IN
38430	652	38	psychology	psychology	NN
38430	652	39	--	--	:
38430	652	40	recognized	recognize	VBD
38430	652	41	the	the	DT
38430	652	42	necessity	necessity	NN
38430	652	43	of	of	IN
38430	652	44	taking	take	VBG
38430	652	45	precautions	precaution	NNS
38430	652	46	against	against	IN
38430	652	47	any	any	DT
38430	652	48	unusual	unusual	JJ
38430	652	49	appearance	appearance	NN
38430	652	50	of	of	IN
38430	652	51	mice	mouse	NNS
38430	652	52	on	on	IN
38430	652	53	a	a	DT
38430	652	54	horse	horse	NN
38430	652	55	's	's	POS
38430	652	56	back	back	NN
38430	652	57	.	.	.
38430	653	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	653	2	71	71	CD
38430	653	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	653	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	653	5	:	:	:
38430	653	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	653	7	67	67	CD
38430	653	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	653	9	_	_	NNP
38430	653	10	S.	S.	NNP
38430	654	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	654	2	_	_	NNP
38430	654	3	,	,	,
38430	654	4	1881	1881	CD
38430	654	5	,	,	,
38430	654	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	654	7	339	339	CD
38430	654	8	,	,	,
38430	654	9	note	note	NN
38430	654	10	.	.	.
38430	655	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	655	2	68	68	CD
38430	655	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	655	4	See	see	VB
38430	655	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	655	6	N.	N.	NNP
38430	655	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	655	8	69	69	CD
38430	655	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	655	10	_	_	NNP
38430	655	11	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	655	12	_	_	NNP
38430	655	13	,	,	,
38430	655	14	N.	N.	NNP
38430	655	15	S.	S.	NNP
38430	655	16	,	,	,
38430	655	17	vol	vol	NNP
38430	655	18	.	.	.
38430	656	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	656	2	.	.	NNP
38430	656	3	,	,	,
38430	656	4	October	October	NNP
38430	656	5	1905	1905	CD
38430	656	6	,	,	,
38430	656	7	pp	pp	NNP
38430	656	8	.	.	.
38430	657	1	479	479	CD
38430	657	2	-	-	SYM
38430	657	3	93	93	CD
38430	657	4	.	.	.
38430	658	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	658	2	70	70	CD
38430	658	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	658	4	See	see	VB
38430	658	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	658	6	N.	N.	NNP
38430	658	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	658	8	71	71	CD
38430	658	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	658	10	See	See	NNP
38430	658	11	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	658	12	O.	O.	NNP
38430	659	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	659	2	XXVI	XXVI	NNP
38430	659	3	IS	be	VBZ
38430	659	4	_	_	NNP
38430	659	5	Is	be	VBZ
38430	659	6	_	_	NNP
38430	659	7	has	have	VBZ
38430	659	8	four	four	CD
38430	659	9	perfectly	perfectly	RB
38430	659	10	distinct	distinct	JJ
38430	659	11	meanings	meaning	NNS
38430	659	12	in	in	IN
38430	659	13	English	English	NNP
38430	659	14	,	,	,
38430	659	15	besides	besides	IN
38430	659	16	misuses	misuse	NNS
38430	659	17	of	of	IN
38430	659	18	the	the	DT
38430	659	19	word	word	NN
38430	659	20	.	.	.
38430	660	1	Among	among	IN
38430	660	2	the	the	DT
38430	660	3	misuses	misuse	NNS
38430	660	4	,	,	,
38430	660	5	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	660	6	the	the	DT
38430	660	7	most	most	RBS
38430	660	8	important	important	JJ
38430	660	9	are	be	VBP
38430	660	10	those	those	DT
38430	660	11	referred	refer	VBN
38430	660	12	to	to	IN
38430	660	13	by	by	IN
38430	660	14	De	De	NNP
38430	660	15	Morgan:[72	Morgan:[72	NNP
38430	660	16	]	]	-RRB-
38430	660	17	"	"	``
38430	660	18	...	...	.
38430	660	19	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	660	20	say	say	VBP
38430	660	21	'	'	''
38430	660	22	murder	murder	NN
38430	660	23	_	_	NNP
38430	660	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	660	25	_	_	NNP
38430	660	26	death	death	NN
38430	660	27	to	to	IN
38430	660	28	the	the	DT
38430	660	29	perpetrator	perpetrator	NN
38430	660	30	'	'	''
38430	660	31	where	where	WRB
38430	660	32	the	the	DT
38430	660	33	copula	copula	NN
38430	660	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	660	35	_	_	NNP
38430	660	36	brings	bring	VBZ
38430	660	37	_	_	NNP
38430	660	38	;	;	:
38430	660	39	'	'	''
38430	660	40	two	two	CD
38430	660	41	and	and	CC
38430	660	42	two	two	CD
38430	660	43	_	_	NNP
38430	660	44	are	be	VBP
38430	660	45	_	_	NNP
38430	660	46	four	four	CD
38430	660	47	,	,	,
38430	660	48	'	'	''
38430	660	49	the	the	DT
38430	660	50	copula	copula	NNP
38430	660	51	being	being	NN
38430	660	52	'	'	''
38430	660	53	have	have	VB
38430	660	54	the	the	DT
38430	660	55	value	value	NN
38430	660	56	of	of	IN
38430	660	57	,	,	,
38430	660	58	'	'	''
38430	660	59	etc	etc	FW
38430	660	60	.	.	.
38430	660	61	"	"	''
38430	661	1	Schröder[73	schröder[73	ADD
38430	661	2	]	]	-RRB-
38430	661	3	quite	quite	RB
38430	661	4	satisfactorily	satisfactorily	RB
38430	661	5	pointed	point	VBD
38430	661	6	out	out	RP
38430	661	7	the	the	DT
38430	661	8	well	well	RB
38430	661	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	661	10	known	know	VBN
38430	661	11	distinction	distinction	NN
38430	661	12	between	between	IN
38430	661	13	an	an	DT
38430	661	14	_	_	NNP
38430	661	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	661	16	_	_	NNP
38430	661	17	where	where	WRB
38430	661	18	subject	subject	JJ
38430	661	19	and	and	CC
38430	661	20	predicate	predicate	NN
38430	661	21	can	can	MD
38430	661	22	be	be	VB
38430	661	23	interchanged	interchange	VBN
38430	661	24	(	(	-LRB-
38430	661	25	such	such	JJ
38430	661	26	as	as	IN
38430	661	27	:	:	:
38430	661	28	"	"	``
38430	661	29	the	the	DT
38430	661	30	class	class	NN
38430	661	31	whose	whose	WP$
38430	661	32	members	member	NNS
38430	661	33	are	be	VBP
38430	661	34	Shem	Shem	NNP
38430	661	35	,	,	,
38430	661	36	Ham	Ham	NNP
38430	661	37	and	and	CC
38430	661	38	Japhet	Japhet	NNP
38430	661	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	661	40	the	the	DT
38430	661	41	class	class	NN
38430	661	42	of	of	IN
38430	661	43	the	the	DT
38430	661	44	sons	son	NNS
38430	661	45	of	of	IN
38430	661	46	Noah	Noah	NNP
38430	661	47	"	"	''
38430	661	48	)	)	-RRB-
38430	661	49	and	and	CC
38430	661	50	an	an	DT
38430	661	51	_	_	NNP
38430	661	52	is	be	VBZ
38430	661	53	_	_	NNP
38430	661	54	or	or	CC
38430	661	55	_	_	NNP
38430	661	56	are	be	VBP
38430	661	57	_	_	NNP
38430	661	58	where	where	WRB
38430	661	59	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	661	60	can	can	MD
38430	661	61	not	not	RB
38430	661	62	(	(	-LRB-
38430	661	63	such	such	JJ
38430	661	64	as	as	IN
38430	661	65	:	:	:
38430	661	66	Englishmen	englishman	NNS
38430	661	67	are	be	VBP
38430	661	68	Britons	briton	NNS
38430	661	69	)	)	-RRB-
38430	661	70	,	,	,
38430	661	71	but	but	CC
38430	661	72	failed	fail	VBD
38430	661	73	to	to	TO
38430	661	74	see[74	see[74	VB
38430	661	75	]	]	-RRB-
38430	661	76	the	the	DT
38430	661	77	more	more	RBR
38430	661	78	important	important	JJ
38430	661	79	distinction	distinction	NN
38430	661	80	(	(	-LRB-
38430	661	81	made	make	VBN
38430	661	82	by	by	IN
38430	661	83	Peano	Peano	NNP
38430	661	84	)	)	-RRB-
38430	661	85	of	of	IN
38430	661	86	is	be	VBZ
38430	661	87	in	in	IN
38430	661	88	the	the	DT
38430	661	89	sense	sense	NN
38430	661	90	of	of	IN
38430	661	91	"	"	``
38430	661	92	is	be	VBZ
38430	661	93	a	a	DT
38430	661	94	member	member	NN
38430	661	95	of	of	IN
38430	661	96	.	.	.
38430	661	97	"	"	''
38430	662	1	If	if	IN
38430	662	2	Englishmen	englishman	NNS
38430	662	3	are	be	VBP
38430	662	4	Britons	briton	NNS
38430	662	5	,	,	,
38430	662	6	and	and	CC
38430	662	7	Britons	briton	NNS
38430	662	8	are	be	VBP
38430	662	9	civilized	civilized	JJ
38430	662	10	people	people	NNS
38430	662	11	,	,	,
38430	662	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	662	13	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	662	14	that	that	IN
38430	662	15	Englishmen	englishman	NNS
38430	662	16	are	be	VBP
38430	662	17	civilized	civilized	JJ
38430	662	18	people	people	NNS
38430	662	19	;	;	:
38430	662	20	but	but	CC
38430	662	21	,	,	,
38430	662	22	though	though	IN
38430	662	23	the	the	DT
38430	662	24	_	_	NNP
38430	662	25	Harmsworth	Harmsworth	NNP
38430	662	26	Encyclopædia	Encyclopædia	NNP
38430	662	27	_	_	NNP
38430	662	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	29	a	a	DT
38430	662	30	member	member	NN
38430	662	31	of	of	IN
38430	662	32	the	the	DT
38430	662	33	class	class	NN
38430	662	34	Book	Book	NNP
38430	662	35	(	(	-LRB-
38430	662	36	of	of	IN
38430	662	37	one	one	CD
38430	662	38	or	or	CC
38430	662	39	more	more	JJR
38430	662	40	volumes	volume	NNS
38430	662	41	)	)	-RRB-
38430	662	42	,	,	,
38430	662	43	and	and	CC
38430	662	44	this	this	DT
38430	662	45	class	class	NN
38430	662	46	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	47	the	the	DT
38430	662	48	member	member	NN
38430	662	49	of	of	IN
38430	662	50	a	a	DT
38430	662	51	class	class	NN
38430	662	52	A	a	NN
38430	662	53	of	of	IN
38430	662	54	which	which	WDT
38430	662	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	662	56	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	57	the	the	DT
38430	662	58	only	only	JJ
38430	662	59	member	member	NN
38430	662	60	,	,	,
38430	662	61	yet	yet	CC
38430	662	62	the	the	DT
38430	662	63	_	_	NNP
38430	662	64	Harmsworth	Harmsworth	NNP
38430	662	65	Encyclopædia	Encyclopædia	NNP
38430	662	66	_	_	NNP
38430	662	67	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	68	not	not	RB
38430	662	69	a	a	DT
38430	662	70	member	member	NN
38430	662	71	of	of	IN
38430	662	72	A	A	NNP
38430	662	73	,	,	,
38430	662	74	for	for	IN
38430	662	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	662	76	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	77	not	not	RB
38430	662	78	true	true	JJ
38430	662	79	that	that	IN
38430	662	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	662	81	is	be	VBZ
38430	662	82	the	the	DT
38430	662	83	whole	whole	JJ
38430	662	84	class	class	NN
38430	662	85	of	of	IN
38430	662	86	books	book	NNS
38430	662	87	;	;	:
38430	662	88	and	and	CC
38430	662	89	such	such	PDT
38430	662	90	a	a	DT
38430	662	91	statement	statement	NN
38430	662	92	would	would	MD
38430	662	93	not	not	RB
38430	662	94	even	even	RB
38430	662	95	be	be	VB
38430	662	96	made	make	VBN
38430	662	97	except	except	IN
38430	662	98	possibly	possibly	RB
38430	662	99	in	in	IN
38430	662	100	the	the	DT
38430	662	101	form	form	NN
38430	662	102	of	of	IN
38430	662	103	an	an	DT
38430	662	104	advertisement	advertisement	NN
38430	662	105	.	.	.
38430	663	1	The	the	DT
38430	663	2	fourth	fourth	JJ
38430	663	3	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	663	4	of	of	IN
38430	663	5	_	_	NNP
38430	663	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	663	7	_	_	NNP
38430	663	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	663	9	_	_	NNP
38430	663	10	exists	exist	VBZ
38430	663	11	_	_	NNP
38430	663	12	;	;	:
38430	663	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	663	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	663	15	in	in	IN
38430	663	16	certain	certain	JJ
38430	663	17	rare	rare	JJ
38430	663	18	moods	mood	NNS
38430	663	19	a	a	DT
38430	663	20	matter	matter	NN
38430	663	21	for	for	IN
38430	663	22	regret	regret	NN
38430	663	23	that	that	IN
38430	663	24	there	there	EX
38430	663	25	are	be	VBP
38430	663	26	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	663	27	in	in	IN
38430	663	28	the	the	DT
38430	663	29	way	way	NN
38430	663	30	of	of	IN
38430	663	31	using	use	VBG
38430	663	32	one	one	CD
38430	663	33	word	word	NN
38430	663	34	to	to	TO
38430	663	35	denote	denote	VB
38430	663	36	four	four	CD
38430	663	37	different	different	JJ
38430	663	38	things	thing	NNS
38430	663	39	.	.	.
38430	664	1	For	for	IN
38430	664	2	,	,	,
38430	664	3	if	if	IN
38430	664	4	there	there	EX
38430	664	5	were	be	VBD
38430	664	6	not	not	RB
38430	664	7	,	,	,
38430	664	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	664	9	might	may	MD
38430	664	10	prove	prove	VB
38430	664	11	the	the	DT
38430	664	12	existence	existence	NN
38430	664	13	of	of	IN
38430	664	14	any	any	DT
38430	664	15	thing	thing	NN
38430	664	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	664	17	please	please	VBP
38430	664	18	by	by	IN
38430	664	19	making	make	VBG
38430	664	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	664	21	the	the	DT
38430	664	22	subject	subject	NN
38430	664	23	of	of	IN
38430	664	24	a	a	DT
38430	664	25	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	664	26	,	,	,
38430	664	27	and	and	CC
38430	664	28	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	664	29	earn	earn	VB
38430	664	30	the	the	DT
38430	664	31	gratitude	gratitude	NN
38430	664	32	of	of	IN
38430	664	33	theologians	theologian	NNS
38430	664	34	.	.	.
38430	665	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	665	2	:	:	:
38430	665	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	665	4	72	72	CD
38430	665	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	665	6	_	_	NNP
38430	665	7	F.	F.	NNP
38430	666	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	666	2	_	_	NNP
38430	666	3	,	,	,
38430	666	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	666	5	268	268	CD
38430	666	6	.	.	.
38430	667	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	667	2	73	73	CD
38430	667	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	667	4	_	_	NNP
38430	667	5	A.	a.	NN
38430	668	1	d.	d.	NNP
38430	668	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	668	3	_	_	NNP
38430	668	4	,	,	,
38430	668	5	i.	i.	NNP
38430	668	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	668	7	.	.	.
38430	669	1	127	127	CD
38430	669	2	sqq	sqq	NN
38430	669	3	.	.	.
38430	670	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	670	2	74	74	CD
38430	670	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	670	4	_	_	NNP
38430	670	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	670	6	.	.	.
38430	670	7	_	_	NNP
38430	670	8	,	,	,
38430	670	9	vol	vol	NNP
38430	670	10	.	.	.
38430	671	1	ii	ii	LS
38430	671	2	.	.	.
38430	672	1	pp	pp	NNP
38430	672	2	.	.	.
38430	673	1	461	461	CD
38430	673	2	,	,	,
38430	673	3	597	597	CD
38430	673	4	.	.	.
38430	674	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	674	2	XXVII	XXVII	NNP
38430	674	3	_	_	NNP
38430	674	4	AND	and	CC
38430	674	5	_	_	NNP
38430	674	6	AND	and	CC
38430	674	7	_	_	NNP
38430	674	8	OR	or	CC
38430	674	9	_	_	NNP
38430	674	10	When	when	WRB
38430	674	11	,	,	,
38430	674	12	with	with	IN
38430	674	13	Boole	Boole	NNP
38430	674	14	,	,	,
38430	674	15	alternatives	alternative	NNS
38430	674	16	(	(	-LRB-
38430	674	17	A	a	NN
38430	674	18	,	,	,
38430	674	19	B	b	NN
38430	674	20	)	)	-RRB-
38430	674	21	are	be	VBP
38430	674	22	considered	consider	VBN
38430	674	23	as	as	IN
38430	674	24	mutually	mutually	RB
38430	674	25	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
38430	674	26	,	,	,
38430	674	27	logical	logical	JJ
38430	674	28	addition	addition	NN
38430	674	29	may	may	MD
38430	674	30	be	be	VB
38430	674	31	described	describe	VBN
38430	674	32	as	as	IN
38430	674	33	the	the	DT
38430	674	34	process	process	NN
38430	674	35	of	of	IN
38430	674	36	taking	take	VBG
38430	674	37	A	a	DT
38430	674	38	_	_	NNP
38430	674	39	and	and	CC
38430	674	40	_	_	NNP
38430	674	41	B	B	NNP
38430	674	42	or	or	CC
38430	674	43	A	a	DT
38430	674	44	_	_	NNP
38430	674	45	or	or	CC
38430	674	46	_	_	NNP
38430	674	47	B.	B.	NNP
38430	675	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	675	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	675	3	a	a	DT
38430	675	4	great	great	JJ
38430	675	5	and	and	CC
38430	675	6	rare	rare	JJ
38430	675	7	convenience	convenience	NN
38430	675	8	to	to	TO
38430	675	9	have	have	VB
38430	675	10	two	two	CD
38430	675	11	terms	term	NNS
38430	675	12	for	for	IN
38430	675	13	denoting	denote	VBG
38430	675	14	the	the	DT
38430	675	15	same	same	JJ
38430	675	16	thing	thing	NN
38430	675	17	:	:	:
38430	675	18	commonly	commonly	RB
38430	675	19	,	,	,
38430	675	20	people	people	NNS
38430	675	21	denote	denote	VBP
38430	675	22	several	several	JJ
38430	675	23	things	thing	NNS
38430	675	24	by	by	IN
38430	675	25	the	the	DT
38430	675	26	same	same	JJ
38430	675	27	term	term	NN
38430	675	28	,	,	,
38430	675	29	and	and	CC
38430	675	30	only	only	RB
38430	675	31	the	the	DT
38430	675	32	Germans	Germans	NNPS
38430	675	33	have	have	VBP
38430	675	34	the	the	DT
38430	675	35	privilege	privilege	NN
38430	675	36	of	of	IN
38430	675	37	referring	refer	VBG
38430	675	38	to	to	IN
38430	675	39	,	,	,
38430	675	40	say	say	VB
38430	675	41	,	,	,
38430	675	42	_	_	NNP
38430	675	43	continuity	continuity	NN
38430	675	44	_	_	NNP
38430	675	45	as	as	IN
38430	675	46	_	_	NNP
38430	675	47	Stetigkeit	Stetigkeit	NNP
38430	675	48	_	_	NNP
38430	675	49	or	or	CC
38430	675	50	_	_	NNP
38430	675	51	Kontinuierlichkeit	Kontinuierlichkeit	NNP
38430	675	52	_	_	NNP
38430	675	53	.	.	.
38430	676	1	But	but	CC
38430	676	2	Jevons[75	jevons[75	ADD
38430	676	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	676	4	quoted	quote	VBN
38430	676	5	Milton	Milton	NNP
38430	676	6	,	,	,
38430	676	7	Shakespeare	Shakespeare	NNP
38430	676	8	,	,	,
38430	676	9	and	and	CC
38430	676	10	Darwin	Darwin	NNP
38430	676	11	to	to	TO
38430	676	12	prove	prove	VB
38430	676	13	that	that	IN
38430	676	14	alternatives	alternative	NNS
38430	676	15	are	be	VBP
38430	676	16	not	not	RB
38430	676	17	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
38430	676	18	,	,	,
38430	676	19	and	and	CC
38430	676	20	so	so	RB
38430	676	21	attained	attain	VBN
38430	676	22	first	first	RB
38430	676	23	to	to	TO
38430	676	24	recognized	recognize	VBN
38430	676	25	views	view	NNS
38430	676	26	by	by	IN
38430	676	27	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	676	28	which	which	WDT
38430	676	29	were	be	VBD
38430	676	30	plainly	plainly	RB
38430	676	31	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
38430	676	32	.	.	.
38430	677	1	Of	of	RB
38430	677	2	course	course	RB
38430	677	3	,	,	,
38430	677	4	_	_	NNP
38430	677	5	and	and	CC
38430	677	6	_	_	NNP
38430	677	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	677	8	often	often	RB
38430	677	9	used	use	VBN
38430	677	10	as	as	IN
38430	677	11	the	the	DT
38430	677	12	sign	sign	NN
38430	677	13	of	of	IN
38430	677	14	logical	logical	JJ
38430	677	15	addition	addition	NN
38430	677	16	:	:	:
38430	677	17	thus	thus	RB
38430	677	18	one	one	PRP
38430	677	19	may	may	MD
38430	677	20	speak	speak	VB
38430	677	21	of	of	IN
38430	677	22	one	one	NN
38430	677	23	's	's	POS
38430	677	24	brothers	brother	NNS
38430	677	25	_	_	NNP
38430	677	26	and	and	CC
38430	677	27	_	_	NNP
38430	677	28	sisters	sister	NNS
38430	677	29	,	,	,
38430	677	30	without	without	IN
38430	677	31	being	be	VBG
38430	677	32	understood	understand	VBN
38430	677	33	to	to	TO
38430	677	34	mean	mean	VB
38430	677	35	the	the	DT
38430	677	36	null	null	JJ
38430	677	37	-	-	HYPH
38430	677	38	class	class	NN
38430	677	39	(	(	-LRB-
38430	677	40	as	as	IN
38430	677	41	should	should	MD
38430	677	42	be	be	VB
38430	677	43	the	the	DT
38430	677	44	case	case	NN
38430	677	45	)	)	-RRB-
38430	677	46	,	,	,
38430	677	47	or	or	CC
38430	677	48	pray	pray	VB
38430	677	49	for	for	IN
38430	677	50	one	one	NN
38430	677	51	's	's	POS
38430	677	52	"	"	``
38430	677	53	relations	relation	NNS
38430	677	54	and	and	CC
38430	677	55	friends	friend	NNS
38430	677	56	,	,	,
38430	677	57	"	"	``
38430	677	58	without	without	IN
38430	677	59	being	be	VBG
38430	677	60	sure	sure	JJ
38430	677	61	that	that	IN
38430	677	62	one	one	NN
38430	677	63	's	's	POS
38430	677	64	prayer	prayer	NN
38430	677	65	would	would	MD
38430	677	66	be	be	VB
38430	677	67	answered,--as	answered,--as	JJ
38430	677	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	677	69	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	677	70	would	would	MD
38430	677	71	if	if	IN
38430	677	72	one	one	CD
38430	677	73	meant	mean	VBD
38430	677	74	to	to	TO
38430	677	75	pray	pray	VB
38430	677	76	for	for	IN
38430	677	77	the	the	DT
38430	677	78	null	null	JJ
38430	677	79	-	-	HYPH
38430	677	80	class	class	NN
38430	677	81	,	,	,
38430	677	82	this	this	DT
38430	677	83	being	be	VBG
38430	677	84	the	the	DT
38430	677	85	class	class	NN
38430	677	86	indicated	indicate	VBN
38430	677	87	.	.	.
38430	678	1	And	and	CC
38430	678	2	a	a	DT
38430	678	3	word	word	NN
38430	678	4	like	like	IN
38430	678	5	_	_	NNP
38430	678	6	while	while	IN
38430	678	7	_	_	NNP
38430	678	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	678	9	often	often	RB
38430	678	10	used	use	VBN
38430	678	11	for	for	IN
38430	678	12	a	a	DT
38430	678	13	logical	logical	JJ
38430	678	14	addition	addition	NN
38430	678	15	,	,	,
38430	678	16	when	when	WRB
38430	678	17	exclusiveness	exclusiveness	NN
38430	678	18	of	of	IN
38430	678	19	the	the	DT
38430	678	20	alternatives	alternative	NNS
38430	678	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	678	22	almost	almost	RB
38430	678	23	implied	implied	JJ
38430	678	24	.	.	.
38430	679	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	679	2	,	,	,
38430	679	3	a	a	DT
38430	679	4	reviewer	reviewer	NN
38430	679	5	in	in	IN
38430	679	6	_	_	NNP
38430	679	7	Mind_,[76	Mind_,[76	NNP
38430	679	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	679	9	noticing	notice	VBG
38430	679	10	the	the	DT
38430	679	11	translation	translation	NN
38430	679	12	of	of	IN
38430	679	13	Mach	Mach	NNP
38430	679	14	's	's	POS
38430	679	15	_	_	NNP
38430	679	16	Popular	Popular	NNP
38430	679	17	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
38430	679	18	Lectures	Lectures	NNPS
38430	679	19	_	_	NNP
38430	679	20	into	into	IN
38430	679	21	American	American	NNP
38430	679	22	,	,	,
38430	679	23	said	say	VBD
38430	679	24	of	of	IN
38430	679	25	the	the	DT
38430	679	26	lectures	lecture	NNS
38430	679	27	that	that	WDT
38430	679	28	:	:	:
38430	679	29	"	"	``
38430	679	30	Most	Most	JJS
38430	679	31	of	of	IN
38430	679	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	679	33	will	will	MD
38430	679	34	be	be	VB
38430	679	35	familiar	familiar	JJ
38430	679	36	...	...	NFP
38430	679	37	to	to	IN
38430	679	38	epistemologists	epistemologist	NNS
38430	679	39	and	and	CC
38430	679	40	experimental	experimental	JJ
38430	679	41	psychologists	psychologist	NNS
38430	679	42	:	:	:
38430	679	43	while	while	IN
38430	679	44	the	the	DT
38430	679	45	remainder	remainder	NN
38430	679	46	,	,	,
38430	679	47	which	which	WDT
38430	679	48	deal	deal	VBP
38430	679	49	with	with	IN
38430	679	50	physical	physical	JJ
38430	679	51	questions	question	NNS
38430	679	52	,	,	,
38430	679	53	are	be	VBP
38430	679	54	well	well	RB
38430	679	55	worth	worth	JJ
38430	679	56	reading	read	VBG
38430	679	57	.	.	.
38430	679	58	"	"	''
38430	680	1	The	the	DT
38430	680	2	reader	reader	NN
38430	680	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	680	4	the	the	DT
38430	680	5	impression	impression	NN
38430	680	6	,	,	,
38430	680	7	probably	probably	RB
38430	680	8	given	give	VBN
38430	680	9	unintentionally	unintentionally	RB
38430	680	10	,	,	,
38430	680	11	that	that	IN
38430	680	12	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	680	13	Mach	Mach	NNP
38430	680	14	's	's	POS
38430	680	15	epistemological	epistemological	JJ
38430	680	16	and	and	CC
38430	680	17	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	680	18	lectures	lecture	NNS
38430	680	19	are	be	VBP
38430	680	20	not	not	RB
38430	680	21	,	,	,
38430	680	22	in	in	IN
38430	680	23	the	the	DT
38430	680	24	reviewer	reviewer	NN
38430	680	25	's	's	POS
38430	680	26	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	680	27	,	,	,
38430	680	28	worth	worth	JJ
38430	680	29	reading	read	VBG
38430	680	30	.	.	.
38430	681	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	681	2	:	:	:
38430	681	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	681	4	75	75	CD
38430	681	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	681	6	_	_	NNP
38430	681	7	Pure	Pure	NNP
38430	681	8	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	681	9	_	_	NNP
38430	681	10	...	...	:
38430	681	11	,	,	,
38430	681	12	London	London	NNP
38430	681	13	,	,	,
38430	681	14	1864	1864	CD
38430	681	15	,	,	,
38430	681	16	pp	pp	NNP
38430	681	17	.	.	.
38430	682	1	76	76	CD
38430	682	2	-	-	SYM
38430	682	3	9	9	CD
38430	682	4	.	.	.
38430	683	1	Cf	cf	NN
38430	683	2	.	.	.
38430	684	1	Venn	Venn	NNP
38430	684	2	,	,	,
38430	684	3	_	_	NNP
38430	684	4	S.	S.	NNP
38430	685	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	685	2	_	_	NNP
38430	685	3	,	,	,
38430	685	4	2nd	2nd	NNP
38430	685	5	ed	ed	NNP
38430	685	6	.	.	NNP
38430	685	7	,	,	,
38430	685	8	pp	pp	NNP
38430	685	9	.	.	.
38430	686	1	40	40	CD
38430	686	2	-	-	SYM
38430	686	3	8	8	CD
38430	686	4	.	.	.
38430	687	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	687	2	76	76	CD
38430	687	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	687	4	N.	N.	NNP
38430	687	5	S.	S.	NNP
38430	687	6	,	,	,
38430	687	7	vol	vol	NNP
38430	687	8	.	.	.
38430	688	1	iv	iv	XX
38430	688	2	.	.	.
38430	689	1	p.	p.	NN
38430	689	2	261	261	CD
38430	689	3	.	.	.
38430	690	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	690	2	XXVIII	XXVIII	NNP
38430	690	3	THE	the	DT
38430	690	4	CONVERSION	CONVERSION	NNP
38430	690	5	OF	of	IN
38430	690	6	RELATIONS	relations	NN
38430	690	7	The	the	DT
38430	690	8	"	"	``
38430	690	9	Conversion	Conversion	NNP
38430	690	10	of	of	IN
38430	690	11	Relations	Relations	NNPS
38430	690	12	"	"	''
38430	690	13	does	do	VBZ
38430	690	14	not	not	RB
38430	690	15	mean	mean	VB
38430	690	16	what	what	WP
38430	690	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	690	18	might	may	MD
38430	690	19	be	be	VB
38430	690	20	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	690	21	to	to	TO
38430	690	22	mean	mean	VB
38430	690	23	;	;	:
38430	690	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	690	25	has	have	VBZ
38430	690	26	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	690	27	to	to	TO
38430	690	28	do	do	VB
38430	690	29	with	with	IN
38430	690	30	what	what	WP
38430	690	31	Kant	Kant	NNP
38430	690	32	called	call	VBD
38430	690	33	"	"	``
38430	690	34	the	the	DT
38430	690	35	wholesome	wholesome	JJ
38430	690	36	art	art	NN
38430	690	37	of	of	IN
38430	690	38	persuasion	persuasion	NN
38430	690	39	.	.	.
38430	690	40	"	"	''
38430	691	1	What	what	WP
38430	691	2	concerns	concern	VBZ
38430	691	3	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	691	4	here	here	RB
38430	691	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	691	6	the	the	DT
38430	691	7	convertibility	convertibility	NN
38430	691	8	of	of	IN
38430	691	9	a	a	DT
38430	691	10	logical	logical	JJ
38430	691	11	relation	relation	NN
38430	691	12	.	.	.
38430	692	1	If	if	IN
38430	692	2	A	a	DT
38430	692	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	692	4	a	a	DT
38430	692	5	certain	certain	JJ
38430	692	6	relation	relation	NN
38430	692	7	R	r	NN
38430	692	8	to	to	IN
38430	692	9	B	b	NN
38430	692	10	,	,	,
38430	692	11	the	the	DT
38430	692	12	relation	relation	NN
38430	692	13	of	of	IN
38430	692	14	B	b	NN
38430	692	15	to	to	IN
38430	692	16	A	a	NN
38430	692	17	,	,	,
38430	692	18	which	which	WDT
38430	692	19	may	may	MD
38430	692	20	be	be	VB
38430	692	21	denoted	denote	VBN
38430	692	22	by	by	IN
38430	692	23	[	[	-LRB-
38430	692	24	vR	vR	NNP
38430	692	25	]	]	-RRB-
38430	692	26	,	,	,
38430	692	27	is	be	VBZ
38430	692	28	called	call	VBN
38430	692	29	the	the	DT
38430	692	30	_	_	NNP
38430	692	31	converse	converse	NN
38430	692	32	_	_	NNP
38430	692	33	of	of	IN
38430	692	34	R.	R.	NNP
38430	692	35	As	As	NNP
38430	692	36	De	De	NNP
38430	692	37	Morgan[77	Morgan[77	NNP
38430	692	38	]	]	-RRB-
38430	692	39	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	692	40	,	,	,
38430	692	41	this	this	DT
38430	692	42	conversion	conversion	NN
38430	692	43	may	may	MD
38430	692	44	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	692	45	present	present	VB
38430	692	46	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	692	47	.	.	.
38430	693	1	The	the	DT
38430	693	2	following	follow	VBG
38430	693	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	693	4	De	De	NNP
38430	693	5	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	693	6	's	's	POS
38430	693	7	example	example	NN
38430	693	8	:	:	:
38430	693	9	"	"	``
38430	693	10	Teacher	teacher	NN
38430	693	11	:	:	:
38430	693	12	'	'	''
38430	693	13	Now	now	RB
38430	693	14	,	,	,
38430	693	15	boys	boy	NNS
38430	693	16	,	,	,
38430	693	17	Shem	Shem	NNP
38430	693	18	,	,	,
38430	693	19	Ham	Ham	NNP
38430	693	20	and	and	CC
38430	693	21	Japheth	Japheth	NNP
38430	693	22	were	be	VBD
38430	693	23	Noah	Noah	NNP
38430	693	24	's	's	POS
38430	693	25	sons	son	NNS
38430	693	26	;	;	:
38430	693	27	who	who	WP
38430	693	28	was	be	VBD
38430	693	29	the	the	DT
38430	693	30	father	father	NN
38430	693	31	of	of	IN
38430	693	32	Shem	Shem	NNP
38430	693	33	,	,	,
38430	693	34	Ham	Ham	NNP
38430	693	35	and	and	CC
38430	693	36	Japheth	Japheth	NNP
38430	693	37	?	?	.
38430	693	38	'	'	''
38430	694	1	No	no	DT
38430	694	2	answer	answer	NN
38430	694	3	.	.	.
38430	695	1	"	"	``
38430	695	2	Teacher	teacher	NN
38430	695	3	:	:	:
38430	695	4	'	'	''
38430	695	5	Boys	boy	NNS
38430	695	6	,	,	,
38430	695	7	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	695	8	know	know	VBP
38430	695	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	695	10	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	695	11	,	,	,
38430	695	12	the	the	DT
38430	695	13	carpenter	carpenter	NN
38430	695	14	,	,	,
38430	695	15	opposite	opposite	JJ
38430	695	16	;	;	:
38430	695	17	has	have	VBZ
38430	695	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	695	19	any	any	DT
38430	695	20	sons	son	NNS
38430	695	21	?	?	.
38430	695	22	'	'	''
38430	696	1	"	"	``
38430	696	2	Boys	boy	NNS
38430	696	3	:	:	:
38430	696	4	'	'	''
38430	696	5	Oh	oh	UH
38430	696	6	!	!	.
38430	697	1	yes	yes	UH
38430	697	2	,	,	,
38430	697	3	sir	sir	NN
38430	697	4	!	!	.
38430	698	1	there	there	EX
38430	698	2	's	be	VBZ
38430	698	3	Bill	Bill	NNP
38430	698	4	and	and	CC
38430	698	5	Ben	Ben	NNP
38430	698	6	.	.	.
38430	698	7	'	'	''
38430	699	1	"	"	``
38430	699	2	Teacher	teacher	NN
38430	699	3	:	:	:
38430	699	4	'	'	''
38430	699	5	And	and	CC
38430	699	6	who	who	WP
38430	699	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	699	8	the	the	DT
38430	699	9	father	father	NN
38430	699	10	of	of	IN
38430	699	11	Bill	Bill	NNP
38430	699	12	and	and	CC
38430	699	13	Ben	Ben	NNP
38430	699	14	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	699	15	?	?	.
38430	699	16	'	'	''
38430	700	1	"	"	``
38430	700	2	Boys	boy	NNS
38430	700	3	:	:	:
38430	700	4	'	'	''
38430	700	5	Why	why	WRB
38430	700	6	,	,	,
38430	700	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	700	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	700	9	,	,	,
38430	700	10	to	to	TO
38430	700	11	be	be	VB
38430	700	12	sure	sure	JJ
38430	700	13	.	.	.
38430	700	14	'	'	''
38430	701	1	"	"	``
38430	701	2	Teacher	teacher	NN
38430	701	3	:	:	:
38430	701	4	'	'	''
38430	701	5	Well	well	UH
38430	701	6	,	,	,
38430	701	7	then	then	RB
38430	701	8	,	,	,
38430	701	9	once	once	RB
38430	701	10	more	more	JJR
38430	701	11	,	,	,
38430	701	12	Shem	Shem	NNP
38430	701	13	,	,	,
38430	701	14	Ham	Ham	NNP
38430	701	15	and	and	CC
38430	701	16	Japheth	Japheth	NNP
38430	701	17	were	be	VBD
38430	701	18	_	_	NNP
38430	701	19	Noah	Noah	NNP
38430	701	20	's	's	POS
38430	701	21	_	_	NNP
38430	701	22	sons	son	NNS
38430	701	23	;	;	:
38430	701	24	who	who	WP
38430	701	25	was	be	VBD
38430	701	26	the	the	DT
38430	701	27	father	father	NN
38430	701	28	of	of	IN
38430	701	29	Shem	Shem	NNP
38430	701	30	,	,	,
38430	701	31	Ham	Ham	NNP
38430	701	32	and	and	CC
38430	701	33	Japheth	Japheth	NNP
38430	701	34	?	?	.
38430	701	35	'	'	''
38430	702	1	"	"	``
38430	702	2	A	a	DT
38430	702	3	long	long	JJ
38430	702	4	pause	pause	NN
38430	702	5	;	;	:
38430	702	6	at	at	IN
38430	702	7	last	last	JJ
38430	702	8	a	a	DT
38430	702	9	boy	boy	NN
38430	702	10	,	,	,
38430	702	11	indignant	indignant	JJ
38430	702	12	at	at	IN
38430	702	13	what	what	WP
38430	702	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	702	15	thought	think	VBD
38430	702	16	the	the	DT
38430	702	17	attempted	attempt	VBN
38430	702	18	trick	trick	NN
38430	702	19	,	,	,
38430	702	20	cried	cry	VBD
38430	702	21	out	out	RP
38430	702	22	:	:	:
38430	702	23	'	'	''
38430	702	24	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	702	25	_	_	NNP
38430	702	26	could	could	MD
38430	702	27	n't	not	RB
38430	702	28	_	_	NNP
38430	702	29	have	have	VB
38430	702	30	been	be	VBN
38430	702	31	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	703	1	Smith	Smith	NNP
38430	703	2	.	.	.
38430	703	3	'	'	''
38430	704	1	These	these	DT
38430	704	2	boys	boy	NNS
38430	704	3	had	have	VBD
38430	704	4	never	never	RB
38430	704	5	converted	convert	VBN
38430	704	6	the	the	DT
38430	704	7	relation	relation	NN
38430	704	8	of	of	IN
38430	704	9	father	father	NNP
38430	704	10	and	and	CC
38430	704	11	son	son	NN
38430	704	12	....	....	NFP
38430	704	13	"	"	''
38430	704	14	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	704	15	:	:	:
38430	704	16	[	[	-LRB-
38430	704	17	77	77	CD
38430	704	18	]	]	-RRB-
38430	704	19	_	_	NNP
38430	704	20	Trans	Trans	NNP
38430	704	21	.	.	.
38430	705	1	Camb	camb	NN
38430	705	2	.	.	.
38430	706	1	Phil	Phil	NNP
38430	706	2	.	.	.
38430	707	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
38430	707	2	.	.	.
38430	707	3	_	_	NNP
38430	707	4	,	,	,
38430	707	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	707	6	.	.	.
38430	708	1	x.	x.	NNP
38430	708	2	,	,	,
38430	708	3	1864	1864	CD
38430	708	4	,	,	,
38430	708	5	part	part	NNP
38430	708	6	ii	ii	NNP
38430	708	7	.	.	NNP
38430	708	8	,	,	,
38430	708	9	note	note	VB
38430	708	10	on	on	IN
38430	708	11	page	page	NN
38430	708	12	334	334	CD
38430	708	13	.	.	.
38430	709	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	709	2	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
38430	709	3	PREVIOUS	previou	NNS
38430	709	4	PHILOSOPHICAL	philosophical	NN
38430	709	5	THEORIES	theory	NNS
38430	709	6	OF	of	IN
38430	709	7	MATHEMATICS	mathematic	NNS
38430	709	8	Mathematicians	Mathematicians	NNPS
38430	709	9	usually	usually	RB
38430	709	10	try	try	VBP
38430	709	11	to	to	TO
38430	709	12	found	found	VB
38430	709	13	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	709	14	on	on	IN
38430	709	15	two	two	CD
38430	709	16	principles:[78	principles:[78	NNP
38430	709	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	709	18	one	one	CD
38430	709	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	709	20	the	the	DT
38430	709	21	principle	principle	NN
38430	709	22	of	of	IN
38430	709	23	confusion	confusion	NN
38430	709	24	between	between	IN
38430	709	25	the	the	DT
38430	709	26	sign	sign	NN
38430	709	27	and	and	CC
38430	709	28	the	the	DT
38430	709	29	thing	thing	NN
38430	709	30	signified	signify	VBN
38430	709	31	(	(	-LRB-
38430	709	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	709	33	call	call	VBP
38430	709	34	this	this	DT
38430	709	35	principle	principle	NN
38430	709	36	the	the	DT
38430	709	37	foundation	foundation	NN
38430	709	38	-	-	HYPH
38430	709	39	stone	stone	NN
38430	709	40	of	of	IN
38430	709	41	the	the	DT
38430	709	42	formal	formal	JJ
38430	709	43	theory	theory	NN
38430	709	44	)	)	-RRB-
38430	709	45	,	,	,
38430	709	46	and	and	CC
38430	709	47	the	the	DT
38430	709	48	other	other	JJ
38430	709	49	is	be	VBZ
38430	709	50	the	the	DT
38430	709	51	Principle	Principle	NNP
38430	709	52	of	of	IN
38430	709	53	the	the	DT
38430	709	54	Identity	Identity	NNP
38430	709	55	of	of	IN
38430	709	56	Discernibles	Discernibles	NNP
38430	709	57	(	(	-LRB-
38430	709	58	which	which	WDT
38430	709	59	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	709	60	call	call	VBP
38430	709	61	the	the	DT
38430	709	62	principle	principle	NN
38430	709	63	of	of	IN
38430	709	64	the	the	DT
38430	709	65	permanence	permanence	NN
38430	709	66	of	of	IN
38430	709	67	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
38430	709	68	forms	form	NNS
38430	709	69	)	)	-RRB-
38430	709	70	.	.	.
38430	710	1	But	but	CC
38430	710	2	the	the	DT
38430	710	3	truth	truth	NN
38430	710	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	710	5	that	that	IN
38430	710	6	if	if	IN
38430	710	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	8	set	set	VBP
38430	710	9	sail	sail	NN
38430	710	10	on	on	IN
38430	710	11	a	a	DT
38430	710	12	voyage	voyage	NN
38430	710	13	of	of	IN
38430	710	14	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	710	15	with	with	IN
38430	710	16	Logic	Logic	NNP
38430	710	17	alone	alone	RB
38430	710	18	at	at	IN
38430	710	19	the	the	DT
38430	710	20	helm	helm	NN
38430	710	21	,	,	,
38430	710	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	23	must	must	MD
38430	710	24	either	either	CC
38430	710	25	throw	throw	VB
38430	710	26	such	such	JJ
38430	710	27	principles	principle	NNS
38430	710	28	as	as	IN
38430	710	29	"	"	``
38430	710	30	the	the	DT
38430	710	31	identity	identity	NN
38430	710	32	of	of	IN
38430	710	33	those	those	DT
38430	710	34	conceptions	conception	NNS
38430	710	35	which	which	WDT
38430	710	36	have	have	VBP
38430	710	37	in	in	IN
38430	710	38	common	common	JJ
38430	710	39	the	the	DT
38430	710	40	properties	property	NNS
38430	710	41	that	that	WDT
38430	710	42	interest	interest	VBP
38430	710	43	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	44	"	"	''
38430	710	45	and	and	CC
38430	710	46	"	"	``
38430	710	47	the	the	DT
38430	710	48	principle	principle	NN
38430	710	49	of	of	IN
38430	710	50	permanence	permanence	NN
38430	710	51	"	"	''
38430	710	52	overboard	overboard	RB
38430	710	53	,	,	,
38430	710	54	or	or	CC
38430	710	55	,	,	,
38430	710	56	if	if	IN
38430	710	57	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	58	do	do	VBP
38430	710	59	not	not	RB
38430	710	60	like	like	VB
38430	710	61	to	to	TO
38430	710	62	act	act	VB
38430	710	63	in	in	IN
38430	710	64	such	such	PDT
38430	710	65	a	a	DT
38430	710	66	way	way	NN
38430	710	67	to	to	IN
38430	710	68	old	old	JJ
38430	710	69	companions	companion	NNS
38430	710	70	with	with	IN
38430	710	71	whom	whom	WP
38430	710	72	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	73	are	be	VBP
38430	710	74	so	so	RB
38430	710	75	familiar	familiar	JJ
38430	710	76	that	that	IN
38430	710	77	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	78	can	can	MD
38430	710	79	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	710	80	feel	feel	VB
38430	710	81	contempt	contempt	NN
38430	710	82	for	for	IN
38430	710	83	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	84	,	,	,
38430	710	85	at	at	IN
38430	710	86	least	least	JJS
38430	710	87	recognize	recognize	VB
38430	710	88	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	89	clearly	clearly	RB
38430	710	90	as	as	IN
38430	710	91	having	have	VBG
38430	710	92	no	no	DT
38430	710	93	logical	logical	JJ
38430	710	94	validity	validity	NN
38430	710	95	and	and	CC
38430	710	96	merely	merely	RB
38430	710	97	as	as	IN
38430	710	98	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	710	99	principles	principle	NNS
38430	710	100	,	,	,
38430	710	101	and	and	CC
38430	710	102	reduce	reduce	VB
38430	710	103	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	710	104	to	to	IN
38430	710	105	the	the	DT
38430	710	106	humble	humble	JJ
38430	710	107	rank	rank	NN
38430	710	108	of	of	IN
38430	710	109	stewards	steward	NNS
38430	710	110	,	,	,
38430	710	111	to	to	TO
38430	710	112	minister	minister	VB
38430	710	113	to	to	IN
38430	710	114	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	710	115	human	human	JJ
38430	710	116	weaknesses	weakness	NNS
38430	710	117	on	on	IN
38430	710	118	the	the	DT
38430	710	119	voyage	voyage	NN
38430	710	120	.	.	.
38430	711	1	And	and	CC
38430	711	2	then	then	RB
38430	711	3	,	,	,
38430	711	4	if	if	IN
38430	711	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	711	6	adopt	adopt	VBP
38430	711	7	the	the	DT
38430	711	8	wise	wise	JJ
38430	711	9	policy	policy	NN
38430	711	10	of	of	IN
38430	711	11	keeping	keep	VBG
38430	711	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	711	13	axioms	axiom	NNS
38430	711	14	down	down	RP
38430	711	15	to	to	IN
38430	711	16	the	the	DT
38430	711	17	minimum	minimum	JJ
38430	711	18	number	number	NN
38430	711	19	,	,	,
38430	711	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	711	21	must	must	MD
38430	711	22	refrain	refrain	VB
38430	711	23	from	from	IN
38430	711	24	creating	create	VBG
38430	711	25	or	or	CC
38430	711	26	thinking	think	VBG
38430	711	27	that	that	IN
38430	711	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	711	29	are	be	VBP
38430	711	30	creating	create	VBG
38430	711	31	new	new	JJ
38430	711	32	numbers	number	NNS
38430	711	33	to	to	TO
38430	711	34	fill	fill	VB
38430	711	35	up	up	RP
38430	711	36	gaps	gap	NNS
38430	711	37	among	among	IN
38430	711	38	the	the	DT
38430	711	39	older	old	JJR
38430	711	40	ones	one	NNS
38430	711	41	,	,	,
38430	711	42	and	and	CC
38430	711	43	thence	thence	NN
38430	711	44	recognize	recognize	VB
38430	711	45	that	that	IN
38430	711	46	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	711	47	rational	rational	JJ
38430	711	48	numbers	number	NNS
38430	711	49	are	be	VBP
38430	711	50	not	not	RB
38430	711	51	particular	particular	JJ
38430	711	52	cases	case	NNS
38430	711	53	of	of	IN
38430	711	54	"	"	``
38430	711	55	real	real	JJ
38430	711	56	"	"	''
38430	711	57	numbers	number	NNS
38430	711	58	,	,	,
38430	711	59	and	and	CC
38430	711	60	so	so	RB
38430	711	61	on	on	RB
38430	711	62	.	.	.
38430	712	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	712	2	thus	thus	RB
38430	712	3	get	get	VBP
38430	712	4	a	a	DT
38430	712	5	world	world	NN
38430	712	6	of	of	IN
38430	712	7	conceptions	conception	NNS
38430	712	8	which	which	WDT
38430	712	9	looks	look	VBZ
38430	712	10	,	,	,
38430	712	11	and	and	CC
38430	712	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	712	13	,	,	,
38430	712	14	very	very	RB
38430	712	15	different	different	JJ
38430	712	16	from	from	IN
38430	712	17	that	that	DT
38430	712	18	which	which	WDT
38430	712	19	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	712	20	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	712	21	think	think	VBP
38430	712	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	712	23	see	see	VBP
38430	712	24	;	;	:
38430	712	25	and	and	CC
38430	712	26	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	712	27	this	this	DT
38430	712	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	712	29	the	the	DT
38430	712	30	reason	reason	NN
38430	712	31	why	why	WRB
38430	712	32	some	some	DT
38430	712	33	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	712	34	of	of	IN
38430	712	35	great	great	JJ
38430	712	36	eminence	eminence	NN
38430	712	37	,	,	,
38430	712	38	such	such	JJ
38430	712	39	as	as	IN
38430	712	40	Hilbert	Hilbert	NNP
38430	712	41	and	and	CC
38430	712	42	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	712	43	,	,	,
38430	712	44	have	have	VBP
38430	712	45	produced	produce	VBN
38430	712	46	such	such	JJ
38430	712	47	absurd	absurd	JJ
38430	712	48	discussions	discussion	NNS
38430	712	49	on	on	IN
38430	712	50	the	the	DT
38430	712	51	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
38430	712	52	principles	principle	NNS
38430	712	53	of	of	IN
38430	712	54	mathematics,[79	mathematics,[79	CD
38430	712	55	]	]	-RRB-
38430	712	56	showing	show	VBG
38430	712	57	once	once	RB
38430	712	58	more	more	JJR
38430	712	59	the	the	DT
38430	712	60	truth	truth	NN
38430	712	61	of	of	IN
38430	712	62	the	the	DT
38430	712	63	not	not	RB
38430	712	64	quite	quite	RB
38430	712	65	original	original	JJ
38430	712	66	remark	remark	NN
38430	712	67	of	of	IN
38430	712	68	Aunt	Aunt	NNP
38430	712	69	Jane	Jane	NNP
38430	712	70	,	,	,
38430	712	71	who	who	WP
38430	712	72	...	...	NFP
38430	712	73	observed	observe	VBN
38430	712	74	,	,	,
38430	712	75	the	the	DT
38430	712	76	second	second	JJ
38430	712	77	time	time	NN
38430	712	78	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	712	79	tumbled	tumble	VBD
38430	712	80	off	off	RP
38430	712	81	a	a	DT
38430	712	82	'	'	``
38430	712	83	bus	bus	NN
38430	712	84	:	:	:
38430	712	85	"	"	``
38430	712	86	The	the	DT
38430	712	87	step	step	NN
38430	712	88	is	be	VBZ
38430	712	89	short	short	JJ
38430	712	90	from	from	IN
38430	712	91	the	the	DT
38430	712	92	sublime	sublime	NN
38430	712	93	To	to	IN
38430	712	94	the	the	DT
38430	712	95	ridiculous	ridiculous	JJ
38430	712	96	.	.	.
38430	712	97	"	"	''
38430	713	1	In	in	IN
38430	713	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	713	3	readiness	readiness	NN
38430	713	4	to	to	TO
38430	713	5	consider	consider	VB
38430	713	6	many	many	JJ
38430	713	7	different	different	JJ
38430	713	8	things	thing	NNS
38430	713	9	as	as	IN
38430	713	10	one	one	CD
38430	713	11	thing	thing	NN
38430	713	12	--	--	:
38430	713	13	to	to	TO
38430	713	14	consider	consider	VB
38430	713	15	,	,	,
38430	713	16	for	for	IN
38430	713	17	example	example	NN
38430	713	18	,	,	,
38430	713	19	the	the	DT
38430	713	20	ratio	ratio	NN
38430	713	21	2:1	2:1	CD
38430	713	22	as	as	IN
38430	713	23	the	the	DT
38430	713	24	same	same	JJ
38430	713	25	thing	thing	NN
38430	713	26	as	as	IN
38430	713	27	the	the	DT
38430	713	28	cardinal	cardinal	JJ
38430	713	29	number	number	NN
38430	713	30	2	2	CD
38430	713	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	713	32	-such	-such	JJ
38430	713	33	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	713	34	as	as	IN
38430	713	35	Peacock	Peacock	NNP
38430	713	36	,	,	,
38430	713	37	Hankel	Hankel	NNP
38430	713	38	,	,	,
38430	713	39	and	and	CC
38430	713	40	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
38430	713	41	were	be	VBD
38430	713	42	forestalled	forestall	VBN
38430	713	43	by	by	IN
38430	713	44	the	the	DT
38430	713	45	Pigeon	Pigeon	NNP
38430	713	46	,	,	,
38430	713	47	who	who	WP
38430	713	48	thought	think	VBD
38430	713	49	that	that	IN
38430	713	50	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	713	51	and	and	CC
38430	713	52	the	the	DT
38430	713	53	Serpent	Serpent	NNP
38430	713	54	were	be	VBD
38430	713	55	the	the	DT
38430	713	56	same	same	JJ
38430	713	57	creature	creature	NN
38430	713	58	,	,	,
38430	713	59	because	because	IN
38430	713	60	both	both	DT
38430	713	61	had	have	VBD
38430	713	62	long	long	JJ
38430	713	63	necks	neck	NNS
38430	713	64	and	and	CC
38430	713	65	ate	eat	VBD
38430	713	66	eggs	egg	NNS
38430	713	67	.	.	.
38430	714	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	714	2	80	80	CD
38430	714	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	714	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	714	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	714	6	,	,	,
38430	714	7	however	however	RB
38430	714	8	,	,	,
38430	714	9	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	714	10	whether	whether	IN
38430	714	11	the	the	DT
38430	714	12	Pigeon	Pigeon	NNP
38430	714	13	would	would	MD
38430	714	14	have	have	VB
38430	714	15	followed	follow	VBN
38430	714	16	the	the	DT
38430	714	17	example	example	NN
38430	714	18	of	of	IN
38430	714	19	the	the	DT
38430	714	20	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	714	21	just	just	RB
38430	714	22	mentioned	mention	VBD
38430	714	23	so	so	RB
38430	714	24	far	far	RB
38430	714	25	as	as	IN
38430	714	26	to	to	TO
38430	714	27	embrace	embrace	VB
38430	714	28	the	the	DT
38430	714	29	creed	creed	NN
38430	714	30	of	of	IN
38430	714	31	nominalism	nominalism	NN
38430	714	32	and	and	CC
38430	714	33	so	so	RB
38430	714	34	to	to	TO
38430	714	35	feel	feel	VB
38430	714	36	no	no	DT
38430	714	37	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	714	38	in	in	IN
38430	714	39	subtracting	subtract	VBG
38430	714	40	from	from	IN
38430	714	41	zero	zero	CD
38430	714	42	--	--	:
38430	714	43	a	a	DT
38430	714	44	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	714	45	which	which	WDT
38430	714	46	was	be	VBD
38430	714	47	pointed	point	VBN
38430	714	48	out	out	RP
38430	714	49	with	with	IN
38430	714	50	great	great	JJ
38430	714	51	acuteness	acuteness	NN
38430	714	52	by	by	IN
38430	714	53	the	the	DT
38430	714	54	Hatter[81	hatter[81	ADD
38430	714	55	]	]	-RRB-
38430	714	56	and	and	CC
38430	714	57	modern	modern	JJ
38430	714	58	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	714	59	logicians	logician	NNS
38430	714	60	.	.	.
38430	715	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	715	2	:	:	:
38430	715	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	715	4	78	78	CD
38430	715	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	715	6	These	these	DT
38430	715	7	principles	principle	NNS
38430	715	8	,	,	,
38430	715	9	after	after	IN
38430	715	10	many	many	JJ
38430	715	11	attempts	attempt	NNS
38430	715	12	to	to	TO
38430	715	13	state	state	VB
38430	715	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	715	15	by	by	IN
38430	715	16	Peacock	Peacock	NNP
38430	715	17	,	,	,
38430	715	18	the	the	DT
38430	715	19	Red	Red	NNP
38430	715	20	and	and	CC
38430	715	21	the	the	DT
38430	715	22	White	White	NNP
38430	715	23	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	715	24	(	(	-LRB-
38430	715	25	see	see	VB
38430	715	26	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	715	27	P	P	NNP
38430	715	28	)	)	-RRB-
38430	715	29	,	,	,
38430	715	30	Hankel	Hankel	NNP
38430	715	31	,	,	,
38430	715	32	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	715	33	,	,	,
38430	715	34	and	and	CC
38430	715	35	Schubert	Schubert	NNP
38430	715	36	had	have	VBD
38430	715	37	been	be	VBN
38430	715	38	made	make	VBN
38430	715	39	,	,	,
38430	715	40	were	be	VBD
38430	715	41	first	first	RB
38430	715	42	precisely	precisely	RB
38430	715	43	formulated	formulate	VBN
38430	715	44	by	by	IN
38430	715	45	Frege	Frege	NNP
38430	715	46	in	in	IN
38430	715	47	_	_	NNP
38430	715	48	Z.	Z.	NNP
38430	716	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	716	2	_	_	NNP
38430	716	3	;	;	:
38430	716	4	cf	cf	NN
38430	716	5	.	.	.
38430	717	1	also	also	RB
38430	717	2	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
38430	717	3	VII	VII	NNP
38430	717	4	.	.	.
38430	718	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	718	2	79	79	CD
38430	718	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	718	4	See	See	NNP
38430	718	5	Couturat	Couturat	NNP
38430	718	6	,	,	,
38430	718	7	_	_	NNP
38430	718	8	R.	R.	NNP
38430	719	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	719	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	719	3	_	_	NNP
38430	719	4	,	,	,
38430	719	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	719	6	.	.	.
38430	720	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	720	2	.	.	NNP
38430	720	3	,	,	,
38430	720	4	March	March	NNP
38430	720	5	,	,	,
38430	720	6	1906	1906	CD
38430	720	7	,	,	,
38430	720	8	pp	pp	NNP
38430	720	9	.	.	.
38430	721	1	208	208	CD
38430	721	2	-	-	SYM
38430	721	3	50	50	CD
38430	721	4	,	,	,
38430	721	5	and	and	CC
38430	721	6	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	721	7	,	,	,
38430	721	8	_	_	NNP
38430	721	9	ibid	ibid	NN
38430	721	10	.	.	.
38430	721	11	_	_	NNP
38430	721	12	,	,	,
38430	721	13	September	September	NNP
38430	721	14	,	,	,
38430	721	15	1906	1906	CD
38430	721	16	,	,	,
38430	721	17	pp	pp	NNP
38430	721	18	.	.	.
38430	722	1	627	627	CD
38430	722	2	-	-	SYM
38430	722	3	34	34	CD
38430	722	4	.	.	.
38430	723	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	723	2	80	80	CD
38430	723	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	723	4	See	see	VB
38430	723	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	723	6	P.	P.	NNP
38430	723	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	723	8	81	81	CD
38430	723	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	723	10	See	see	VB
38430	723	11	_	_	NNP
38430	723	12	ibid	ibid	NN
38430	723	13	.	.	.
38430	723	14	_	_	NNP
38430	723	15	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	723	16	XXX	XXX	NNP
38430	723	17	FINITE	FINITE	NNP
38430	723	18	AND	and	CC
38430	723	19	INFINITE	INFINITE	NNP
38430	723	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	723	21	was	be	VBD
38430	723	22	once	once	RB
38430	723	23	shown	show	VBN
38430	723	24	a	a	DT
38430	723	25	statement	statement	NN
38430	723	26	made	make	VBN
38430	723	27	by	by	IN
38430	723	28	an	an	DT
38430	723	29	eminent	eminent	JJ
38430	723	30	mathematician	mathematician	NN
38430	723	31	of	of	IN
38430	723	32	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	723	33	from	from	IN
38430	723	34	which	which	WDT
38430	723	35	one	one	PRP
38430	723	36	would	would	MD
38430	723	37	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	723	38	that	that	IN
38430	723	39	this	this	DT
38430	723	40	mathematician	mathematician	NN
38430	723	41	thought	think	VBD
38430	723	42	that	that	IN
38430	723	43	finite	finite	JJ
38430	723	44	distances	distance	NNS
38430	723	45	became	become	VBD
38430	723	46	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	723	47	when	when	WRB
38430	723	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	723	49	were	be	VBD
38430	723	50	great	great	JJ
38430	723	51	enough	enough	RB
38430	723	52	.	.	.
38430	724	1	In	in	IN
38430	724	2	one	one	CD
38430	724	3	of	of	IN
38430	724	4	those	those	DT
38430	724	5	splendidly	splendidly	RB
38430	724	6	printed	print	VBN
38430	724	7	books	book	NNS
38430	724	8	,	,	,
38430	724	9	bound	bind	VBN
38430	724	10	in	in	IN
38430	724	11	blue	blue	NNP
38430	724	12	,	,	,
38430	724	13	published	publish	VBN
38430	724	14	by	by	IN
38430	724	15	the	the	DT
38430	724	16	University	University	NNP
38430	724	17	Press	Press	NNP
38430	724	18	,	,	,
38430	724	19	and	and	CC
38430	724	20	sold	sell	VBD
38430	724	21	at	at	IN
38430	724	22	about	about	RB
38430	724	23	a	a	DT
38430	724	24	guinea	guinea	NN
38430	724	25	as	as	IN
38430	724	26	a	a	DT
38430	724	27	guide	guide	NN
38430	724	28	to	to	IN
38430	724	29	some	some	DT
38430	724	30	advanced	advanced	JJ
38430	724	31	branch	branch	NN
38430	724	32	of	of	IN
38430	724	33	pure	pure	JJ
38430	724	34	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	724	35	,	,	,
38430	724	36	one	one	PRP
38430	724	37	may	may	MD
38430	724	38	read	read	VB
38430	724	39	,	,	,
38430	724	40	even	even	RB
38430	724	41	in	in	IN
38430	724	42	the	the	DT
38430	724	43	second	second	JJ
38430	724	44	edition	edition	NN
38430	724	45	published	publish	VBN
38430	724	46	in	in	IN
38430	724	47	1900	1900	CD
38430	724	48	,	,	,
38430	724	49	the	the	DT
38430	724	50	words	word	NNS
38430	724	51	:	:	:
38430	724	52	"	"	``
38430	724	53	Representation	representation	NN
38430	724	54	[	[	-LRB-
38430	724	55	of	of	IN
38430	724	56	a	a	DT
38430	724	57	complex	complex	JJ
38430	724	58	variable	variable	NN
38430	724	59	]	]	-RRB-
38430	724	60	on	on	IN
38430	724	61	a	a	DT
38430	724	62	plane	plane	NN
38430	724	63	is	be	VBZ
38430	724	64	obviously	obviously	RB
38430	724	65	more	more	RBR
38430	724	66	effective	effective	JJ
38430	724	67	for	for	IN
38430	724	68	points	point	NNS
38430	724	69	at	at	IN
38430	724	70	a	a	DT
38430	724	71	finite	finite	JJ
38430	724	72	distance	distance	NN
38430	724	73	from	from	IN
38430	724	74	the	the	DT
38430	724	75	origin	origin	NN
38430	724	76	than	than	IN
38430	724	77	for	for	IN
38430	724	78	points	point	NNS
38430	724	79	at	at	IN
38430	724	80	a	a	DT
38430	724	81	very	very	RB
38430	724	82	great	great	JJ
38430	724	83	distance	distance	NN
38430	724	84	.	.	.
38430	724	85	"	"	''
38430	725	1	Plainly	plainly	RB
38430	725	2	some	some	DT
38430	725	3	of	of	IN
38430	725	4	the	the	DT
38430	725	5	points	point	NNS
38430	725	6	at	at	IN
38430	725	7	a	a	DT
38430	725	8	very	very	RB
38430	725	9	great	great	JJ
38430	725	10	distance	distance	NN
38430	725	11	are	be	VBP
38430	725	12	at	at	IN
38430	725	13	a	a	DT
38430	725	14	_	_	NNP
38430	725	15	finite	finite	JJ
38430	725	16	_	_	NNP
38430	725	17	distance	distance	NN
38430	725	18	,	,	,
38430	725	19	for	for	IN
38430	725	20	the	the	DT
38430	725	21	same	same	JJ
38430	725	22	author	author	NN
38430	725	23	mentions	mention	VBZ
38430	725	24	that	that	IN
38430	725	25	Neumann	Neumann	NNP
38430	725	26	's	's	POS
38430	725	27	sphere	sphere	NN
38430	725	28	for	for	IN
38430	725	29	representing	represent	VBG
38430	725	30	the	the	DT
38430	725	31	positions	position	NNS
38430	725	32	of	of	IN
38430	725	33	points	point	NNS
38430	725	34	on	on	IN
38430	725	35	a	a	DT
38430	725	36	plane	plane	NN
38430	725	37	"	"	``
38430	725	38	has	have	VBZ
38430	725	39	the	the	DT
38430	725	40	advantage	advantage	NN
38430	725	41	...	...	:
38430	725	42	of	of	IN
38430	725	43	exhibiting	exhibit	VBG
38430	725	44	the	the	DT
38430	725	45	uniqueness	uniqueness	NN
38430	725	46	of	of	IN
38430	725	47	_	_	NNP
38430	725	48	z	z	NNP
38430	725	49	_	_	NNP
38430	725	50	=	=	NFP
38430	725	51	[	[	-LRB-
38430	725	52	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	725	53	symbol	symbol	NN
38430	725	54	]	]	-RRB-
38430	725	55	as	as	IN
38430	725	56	a	a	DT
38430	725	57	value	value	NN
38430	725	58	of	of	IN
38430	725	59	the	the	DT
38430	725	60	variable	variable	NN
38430	725	61	.	.	.
38430	725	62	"	"	''
38430	726	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	726	2	XXXI	XXXI	NNP
38430	726	3	THE	the	DT
38430	726	4	MATHEMATICAL	mathematical	NN
38430	726	5	ATTAINMENTS	attainment	VBZ
38430	726	6	OF	of	IN
38430	726	7	TRISTRAM	TRISTRAM	NNP
38430	726	8	SHANDY	shandy	VBP
38430	726	9	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	726	10	Shandy[82	Shandy[82	NNP
38430	726	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	726	12	said	say	VBD
38430	726	13	that	that	IN
38430	726	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	726	15	father	father	NN
38430	726	16	was	be	VBD
38430	726	17	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	726	18	a	a	DT
38430	726	19	gainer	gainer	NN
38430	726	20	by	by	IN
38430	726	21	misfortune	misfortune	NN
38430	726	22	;	;	:
38430	726	23	for	for	IN
38430	726	24	if	if	IN
38430	726	25	the	the	DT
38430	726	26	pleasure	pleasure	NN
38430	726	27	of	of	IN
38430	726	28	haranguing	harangue	VBG
38430	726	29	about	about	IN
38430	726	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	726	31	was	be	VBD
38430	726	32	as	as	RB
38430	726	33	ten	ten	CD
38430	726	34	,	,	,
38430	726	35	and	and	CC
38430	726	36	the	the	DT
38430	726	37	misfortune	misfortune	NN
38430	726	38	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	726	39	only	only	RB
38430	726	40	as	as	IN
38430	726	41	five	five	CD
38430	726	42	,	,	,
38430	726	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	726	44	gained	gain	VBD
38430	726	45	"	"	``
38430	726	46	half	half	NN
38430	726	47	in	in	IN
38430	726	48	half	half	NN
38430	726	49	,	,	,
38430	726	50	"	"	''
38430	726	51	and	and	CC
38430	726	52	was	be	VBD
38430	726	53	well	well	RB
38430	726	54	off	off	RB
38430	726	55	again	again	RB
38430	726	56	as	as	IN
38430	726	57	if	if	IN
38430	726	58	the	the	DT
38430	726	59	misfortune	misfortune	NN
38430	726	60	had	have	VBD
38430	726	61	never	never	RB
38430	726	62	happened	happen	VBN
38430	726	63	.	.	.
38430	727	1	Suppose	suppose	VB
38430	727	2	that	that	IN
38430	727	3	the	the	DT
38430	727	4	unit	unit	NN
38430	727	5	(	(	-LRB-
38430	727	6	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
38430	727	7	)	)	-RRB-
38430	727	8	of	of	IN
38430	727	9	pleasure	pleasure	NN
38430	727	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	727	11	denoted	denote	VBN
38430	727	12	by	by	IN
38430	727	13	A	a	DT
38430	727	14	,	,	,
38430	727	15	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	727	16	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	727	17	,	,	,
38430	727	18	by	by	IN
38430	727	19	neglecting	neglect	VBG
38430	727	20	,	,	,
38430	727	21	in	in	IN
38430	727	22	this	this	DT
38430	727	23	ethical	ethical	JJ
38430	727	24	discussion	discussion	NN
38430	727	25	,	,	,
38430	727	26	to	to	TO
38430	727	27	introduce	introduce	VB
38430	727	28	negative	negative	JJ
38430	727	29	quantities	quantity	NNS
38430	727	30	(	(	-LRB-
38430	727	31	Kant	Kant	NNP
38430	727	32	's	's	POS
38430	727	33	pamphlet	pamphlet	NN
38430	727	34	advocating	advocate	VBG
38430	727	35	this	this	DT
38430	727	36	introduction	introduction	NN
38430	727	37	into	into	IN
38430	727	38	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	727	39	was	be	VBD
38430	727	40	made	make	VBN
38430	727	41	subsequently[83	subsequently[83	NNP
38430	727	42	]	]	-RRB-
38430	727	43	)	)	-RRB-
38430	727	44	,	,	,
38430	727	45	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	727	46	made	make	VBD
38430	727	47	15A	15a	CD
38430	727	48	to	to	TO
38430	727	49	result	result	VB
38430	727	50	,	,	,
38430	727	51	and	and	CC
38430	727	52	this	this	DT
38430	727	53	can	can	MD
38430	727	54	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	727	55	be	be	VB
38430	727	56	maintained	maintain	VBN
38430	727	57	to	to	TO
38430	727	58	be	be	VB
38430	727	59	the	the	DT
38430	727	60	half	half	NN
38430	727	61	of	of	IN
38430	727	62	10A.	10a.	CD
38430	728	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	728	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	728	3	possible	possible	JJ
38430	728	4	,	,	,
38430	728	5	however	however	RB
38430	728	6	,	,	,
38430	728	7	that	that	IN
38430	728	8	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	728	9	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	728	10	succeeded	succeed	VBD
38430	728	11	in	in	IN
38430	728	12	proving	prove	VBG
38430	728	13	the	the	DT
38430	728	14	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	728	15	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	728	16	equation	equation	NN
38430	728	17	15A	15a	CD
38430	728	18	=	=	SYM
38430	728	19	5A	5a	NN
38430	728	20	by	by	IN
38430	728	21	remarking	remark	VBG
38430	728	22	that	that	IN
38430	728	23	the	the	DT
38430	728	24	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	728	25	"	"	``
38430	728	26	the	the	DT
38430	728	27	whole	whole	NN
38430	728	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	728	29	greater	great	JJR
38430	728	30	than	than	IN
38430	728	31	the	the	DT
38430	728	32	part	part	NN
38430	728	33	"	"	``
38430	728	34	does	do	VBZ
38430	728	35	not	not	RB
38430	728	36	always	always	RB
38430	728	37	hold	hold	VB
38430	728	38	.	.	.
38430	729	1	This	this	DT
38430	729	2	remark	remark	NN
38430	729	3	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	729	4	at	at	IN
38430	729	5	once	once	RB
38430	729	6	from	from	IN
38430	729	7	what	what	WP
38430	729	8	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	729	9	Russell[84	Russell[84	NNP
38430	729	10	]	]	-RRB-
38430	729	11	has	have	VBZ
38430	729	12	called	call	VBN
38430	729	13	"	"	``
38430	729	14	The	the	DT
38430	729	15	Paradox	Paradox	NNP
38430	729	16	of	of	IN
38430	729	17	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	729	18	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	729	19	.	.	.
38430	729	20	"	"	''
38430	730	1	This	this	DT
38430	730	2	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	730	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	730	4	described	describe	VBN
38430	730	5	by	by	IN
38430	730	6	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	730	7	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	730	8	as	as	IN
38430	730	9	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	730	10	:	:	:
38430	730	11	"	"	``
38430	730	12	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	730	13	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	730	14	,	,	,
38430	730	15	as	as	IN
38430	730	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	730	17	know	know	VBP
38430	730	18	,	,	,
38430	730	19	took	take	VBD
38430	730	20	two	two	CD
38430	730	21	years	year	NNS
38430	730	22	writing	write	VBG
38430	730	23	the	the	DT
38430	730	24	history	history	NN
38430	730	25	of	of	IN
38430	730	26	the	the	DT
38430	730	27	first	first	JJ
38430	730	28	two	two	CD
38430	730	29	days	day	NNS
38430	730	30	of	of	IN
38430	730	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	730	32	life	life	NN
38430	730	33	,	,	,
38430	730	34	and	and	CC
38430	730	35	lamented	lament	VBD
38430	730	36	that	that	IN
38430	730	37	,	,	,
38430	730	38	at	at	IN
38430	730	39	this	this	DT
38430	730	40	rate	rate	NN
38430	730	41	,	,	,
38430	730	42	material	material	NN
38430	730	43	would	would	MD
38430	730	44	accumulate	accumulate	VB
38430	730	45	faster	fast	RBR
38430	730	46	than	than	IN
38430	730	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	730	48	could	could	MD
38430	730	49	deal	deal	VB
38430	730	50	with	with	IN
38430	730	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	730	52	,	,	,
38430	730	53	so	so	IN
38430	730	54	that	that	IN
38430	730	55	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	730	56	could	could	MD
38430	730	57	never	never	RB
38430	730	58	come	come	VB
38430	730	59	to	to	IN
38430	730	60	an	an	DT
38430	730	61	end	end	NN
38430	730	62	.	.	.
38430	731	1	Now	now	RB
38430	731	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	731	3	maintain	maintain	VBP
38430	731	4	that	that	IN
38430	731	5	,	,	,
38430	731	6	if	if	IN
38430	731	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	731	8	had	have	VBD
38430	731	9	lived	live	VBN
38430	731	10	for	for	IN
38430	731	11	ever	ever	RB
38430	731	12	,	,	,
38430	731	13	and	and	CC
38430	731	14	not	not	RB
38430	731	15	wearied	wearied	JJ
38430	731	16	of	of	IN
38430	731	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	731	18	task	task	NN
38430	731	19	,	,	,
38430	731	20	then	then	RB
38430	731	21	,	,	,
38430	731	22	even	even	RB
38430	731	23	if	if	IN
38430	731	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	731	25	life	life	NN
38430	731	26	had	have	VBD
38430	731	27	continued	continue	VBN
38430	731	28	as	as	RB
38430	731	29	eventfully	eventfully	RB
38430	731	30	as	as	IN
38430	731	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	731	32	began	begin	VBD
38430	731	33	,	,	,
38430	731	34	no	no	DT
38430	731	35	part	part	NN
38430	731	36	of	of	IN
38430	731	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	731	38	biography	biography	NN
38430	731	39	would	would	MD
38430	731	40	have	have	VB
38430	731	41	remained	remain	VBN
38430	731	42	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
38430	731	43	.	.	.
38430	731	44	"	"	''
38430	732	1	This	this	DT
38430	732	2	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	732	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	732	4	strictly	strictly	RB
38430	732	5	correlative	correlative	JJ
38430	732	6	to	to	IN
38430	732	7	the	the	DT
38430	732	8	well	well	RB
38430	732	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	732	10	known	know	VBN
38430	732	11	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	732	12	of	of	IN
38430	732	13	Zeno	Zeno	NNP
38430	732	14	about	about	IN
38430	732	15	Achilles	Achilles	NNP
38430	732	16	and	and	CC
38430	732	17	the	the	DT
38430	732	18	Tortoise	Tortoise	NNP
38430	732	19	.	.	.
38430	733	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	733	2	85	85	CD
38430	733	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	733	4	"	"	``
38430	733	5	The	the	DT
38430	733	6	Achilles	Achilles	NNP
38430	733	7	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	733	8	that	that	IN
38430	733	9	two	two	CD
38430	733	10	variables	variable	NNS
38430	733	11	in	in	IN
38430	733	12	a	a	DT
38430	733	13	continuous	continuous	JJ
38430	733	14	series	series	NN
38430	733	15	,	,	,
38430	733	16	which	which	WDT
38430	733	17	approach	approach	VBP
38430	733	18	equality	equality	NN
38430	733	19	from	from	IN
38430	733	20	the	the	DT
38430	733	21	same	same	JJ
38430	733	22	side	side	NN
38430	733	23	,	,	,
38430	733	24	can	can	MD
38430	733	25	not	not	RB
38430	733	26	ever	ever	RB
38430	733	27	have	have	VB
38430	733	28	a	a	DT
38430	733	29	common	common	JJ
38430	733	30	limit	limit	NN
38430	733	31	:	:	:
38430	733	32	the	the	DT
38430	733	33	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	733	34	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	733	35	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	733	36	that	that	IN
38430	733	37	two	two	CD
38430	733	38	variables	variable	NNS
38430	733	39	which	which	WDT
38430	733	40	start	start	VBP
38430	733	41	from	from	IN
38430	733	42	a	a	DT
38430	733	43	common	common	JJ
38430	733	44	term	term	NN
38430	733	45	,	,	,
38430	733	46	and	and	CC
38430	733	47	proceed	proceed	VB
38430	733	48	in	in	IN
38430	733	49	the	the	DT
38430	733	50	same	same	JJ
38430	733	51	direction	direction	NN
38430	733	52	,	,	,
38430	733	53	but	but	CC
38430	733	54	diverge	diverge	NN
38430	733	55	more	more	JJR
38430	733	56	and	and	CC
38430	733	57	more	more	RBR
38430	733	58	,	,	,
38430	733	59	may	may	MD
38430	733	60	yet	yet	RB
38430	733	61	determine	determine	VB
38430	733	62	the	the	DT
38430	733	63	same	same	JJ
38430	733	64	limiting	limit	VBG
38430	733	65	class	class	NN
38430	733	66	(	(	-LRB-
38430	733	67	which	which	WDT
38430	733	68	,	,	,
38430	733	69	however	however	RB
38430	733	70	,	,	,
38430	733	71	is	be	VBZ
38430	733	72	not	not	RB
38430	733	73	necessarily	necessarily	RB
38430	733	74	a	a	DT
38430	733	75	segment	segment	NN
38430	733	76	,	,	,
38430	733	77	because	because	IN
38430	733	78	segments	segment	NNS
38430	733	79	were	be	VBD
38430	733	80	defined	define	VBN
38430	733	81	as	as	IN
38430	733	82	having	have	VBG
38430	733	83	terms	term	NNS
38430	733	84	beyond	beyond	IN
38430	733	85	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	733	86	)	)	-RRB-
38430	733	87	.	.	.
38430	734	1	The	the	DT
38430	734	2	Achilles	Achilles	NNPS
38430	734	3	assumes	assume	VBZ
38430	734	4	that	that	IN
38430	734	5	whole	whole	NN
38430	734	6	and	and	CC
38430	734	7	part	part	NN
38430	734	8	can	can	MD
38430	734	9	not	not	RB
38430	734	10	be	be	VB
38430	734	11	similar	similar	JJ
38430	734	12	,	,	,
38430	734	13	and	and	CC
38430	734	14	deduces	deduce	VBZ
38430	734	15	a	a	DT
38430	734	16	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	734	17	;	;	:
38430	734	18	the	the	DT
38430	734	19	other	other	JJ
38430	734	20	,	,	,
38430	734	21	starting	start	VBG
38430	734	22	from	from	IN
38430	734	23	a	a	DT
38430	734	24	platitude	platitude	NN
38430	734	25	,	,	,
38430	734	26	deduces	deduce	VBZ
38430	734	27	that	that	WDT
38430	734	28	whole	whole	JJ
38430	734	29	and	and	CC
38430	734	30	part	part	NN
38430	734	31	may	may	MD
38430	734	32	be	be	VB
38430	734	33	similar	similar	JJ
38430	734	34	.	.	.
38430	735	1	For	for	IN
38430	735	2	common	common	JJ
38430	735	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	735	4	sense	sense	NN
38430	735	5	,	,	,
38430	735	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	735	7	must	must	MD
38430	735	8	be	be	VB
38430	735	9	confessed	confess	VBN
38430	735	10	that	that	IN
38430	735	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	735	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	735	13	a	a	DT
38430	735	14	most	most	RBS
38430	735	15	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
38430	735	16	state	state	NN
38430	735	17	of	of	IN
38430	735	18	things	thing	NNS
38430	735	19	.	.	.
38430	735	20	"	"	''
38430	736	1	And	and	CC
38430	736	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	736	3	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	736	4	considers	consider	VBZ
38430	736	5	that	that	IN
38430	736	6	,	,	,
38430	736	7	in	in	IN
38430	736	8	the	the	DT
38430	736	9	face	face	NN
38430	736	10	of	of	IN
38430	736	11	proofs	proofs	NNP
38430	736	12	,	,	,
38430	736	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	736	14	ought	ought	MD
38430	736	15	to	to	TO
38430	736	16	commit	commit	VB
38430	736	17	suicide	suicide	NN
38430	736	18	in	in	IN
38430	736	19	despair	despair	NN
38430	736	20	.	.	.
38430	737	1	Now	now	RB
38430	737	2	,	,	,
38430	737	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	737	4	suggest	suggest	VBP
38430	737	5	the	the	DT
38430	737	6	extremely	extremely	RB
38430	737	7	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
38430	737	8	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	737	9	that	that	IN
38430	737	10	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	737	11	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	737	12	,	,	,
38430	737	13	by	by	IN
38430	737	14	reflection	reflection	NN
38430	737	15	on	on	IN
38430	737	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	737	17	own	own	JJ
38430	737	18	life	life	NN
38430	737	19	and	and	CC
38430	737	20	literary	literary	JJ
38430	737	21	labours	labour	NNS
38430	737	22	,	,	,
38430	737	23	was	be	VBD
38430	737	24	led	lead	VBN
38430	737	25	to	to	IN
38430	737	26	the	the	DT
38430	737	27	correct	correct	JJ
38430	737	28	course	course	NN
38430	737	29	of	of	IN
38430	737	30	accepting	accept	VBG
38430	737	31	the	the	DT
38430	737	32	paradox	paradox	NN
38430	737	33	which	which	WDT
38430	737	34	resulted	result	VBD
38430	737	35	from	from	IN
38430	737	36	this	this	DT
38430	737	37	reflection	reflection	NN
38430	737	38	and	and	CC
38430	737	39	rejecting	reject	VBG
38430	737	40	the	the	DT
38430	737	41	Achilles	Achilles	NNPS
38430	737	42	.	.	.
38430	738	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	738	2	,	,	,
38430	738	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	738	4	concluded	conclude	VBD
38430	738	5	that	that	IN
38430	738	6	an	an	DT
38430	738	7	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	738	8	whole	whole	NN
38430	738	9	may	may	MD
38430	738	10	be	be	VB
38430	738	11	similar	similar	JJ
38430	738	12	(	(	-LRB-
38430	738	13	or	or	CC
38430	738	14	,	,	,
38430	738	15	in	in	IN
38430	738	16	Cantor	Cantor	NNP
38430	738	17	's	's	POS
38430	738	18	terminology	terminology	NN
38430	738	19	,	,	,
38430	738	20	"	"	``
38430	738	21	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
38430	738	22	"	"	''
38430	738	23	)	)	-RRB-
38430	738	24	to	to	IN
38430	738	25	a	a	DT
38430	738	26	proper	proper	JJ
38430	738	27	part	part	NN
38430	738	28	of	of	IN
38430	738	29	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	738	30	,	,	,
38430	738	31	and	and	CC
38430	738	32	hence	hence	RB
38430	738	33	,	,	,
38430	738	34	by	by	IN
38430	738	35	a	a	DT
38430	738	36	confusion	confusion	NN
38430	738	37	of	of	IN
38430	738	38	similarity	similarity	NN
38430	738	39	with	with	IN
38430	738	40	identity	identity	NN
38430	738	41	(	(	-LRB-
38430	738	42	or	or	CC
38430	738	43	equivalence	equivalence	NN
38430	738	44	with	with	IN
38430	738	45	equality	equality	NN
38430	738	46	)	)	-RRB-
38430	738	47	which	which	WDT
38430	738	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	738	49	shares	share	VBZ
38430	738	50	with	with	IN
38430	738	51	some	some	DT
38430	738	52	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
38430	738	53	philosophers,[86	philosophers,[86	CD
38430	738	54	]	]	-RRB-
38430	738	55	that	that	IN
38430	738	56	a	a	DT
38430	738	57	whole	whole	NN
38430	738	58	may	may	MD
38430	738	59	be	be	VB
38430	738	60	equal	equal	JJ
38430	738	61	to	to	IN
38430	738	62	a	a	DT
38430	738	63	proper	proper	JJ
38430	738	64	part	part	NN
38430	738	65	of	of	IN
38430	738	66	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	738	67	.	.	.
38430	739	1	If	if	IN
38430	739	2	A	a	NN
38430	739	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	739	4	an	an	DT
38430	739	5	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	739	6	class	class	NN
38430	739	7	,	,	,
38430	739	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	739	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	739	10	not	not	RB
38430	739	11	difficult	difficult	JJ
38430	739	12	to	to	TO
38430	739	13	see	see	VB
38430	739	14	that	that	IN
38430	739	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	739	16	can	can	MD
38430	739	17	have	have	VB
38430	739	18	10A	10A	NNP
38430	739	19	=	=	SYM
38430	739	20	5A.	5a.	XX
38430	740	1	In	in	IN
38430	740	2	this	this	DT
38430	740	3	way	way	NN
38430	740	4	many	many	JJ
38430	740	5	have	have	VBP
38430	740	6	avoided	avoid	VBN
38430	740	7	an	an	DT
38430	740	8	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	740	9	which	which	WDT
38430	740	10	rests	rest	VBZ
38430	740	11	on	on	IN
38430	740	12	no	no	DT
38430	740	13	better	well	JJR
38430	740	14	foundation	foundation	NN
38430	740	15	than	than	IN
38430	740	16	that	that	DT
38430	740	17	formerly	formerly	RB
38430	740	18	entertained	entertain	VBN
38430	740	19	by	by	IN
38430	740	20	the	the	DT
38430	740	21	inductive	inductive	JJ
38430	740	22	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
38430	740	23	of	of	IN
38430	740	24	Central	Central	NNP
38430	740	25	Africa	Africa	NNP
38430	740	26	,	,	,
38430	740	27	that	that	IN
38430	740	28	all	all	DT
38430	740	29	men	man	NNS
38430	740	30	are	be	VBP
38430	740	31	black	black	JJ
38430	740	32	.	.	.
38430	741	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	741	2	87	87	CD
38430	741	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	741	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	741	5	:	:	:
38430	741	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	741	7	82	82	CD
38430	741	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	741	9	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	741	10	.	.	.
38430	742	1	a	a	DT
38430	742	2	letter	letter	NN
38430	742	3	of	of	IN
38430	742	4	De	De	NNP
38430	742	5	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	742	6	in	in	IN
38430	742	7	Mrs.	Mrs.	NNP
38430	742	8	De	De	NNP
38430	742	9	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	742	10	's	's	POS
38430	742	11	_	_	NNP
38430	742	12	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
38430	742	13	of	of	IN
38430	742	14	Augustus	Augustus	NNP
38430	742	15	De	De	NNP
38430	742	16	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	742	17	_	_	NNP
38430	742	18	,	,	,
38430	742	19	p.	p.	NN
38430	742	20	324	324	CD
38430	742	21	.	.	.
38430	743	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	743	2	83	83	CD
38430	743	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	743	4	Kant	Kant	NNP
38430	743	5	's	's	POS
38430	743	6	tract	tract	NN
38430	743	7	was	be	VBD
38430	743	8	published	publish	VBN
38430	743	9	in	in	IN
38430	743	10	1763	1763	CD
38430	743	11	,	,	,
38430	743	12	while	while	IN
38430	743	13	_	_	NNP
38430	743	14	Tristram	Tristram	NNP
38430	743	15	Shandy	Shandy	NNP
38430	743	16	_	_	NNP
38430	743	17	was	be	VBD
38430	743	18	published	publish	VBN
38430	743	19	in	in	IN
38430	743	20	1760	1760	CD
38430	743	21	.	.	.
38430	744	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	744	2	84	84	CD
38430	744	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	744	4	_	_	NNP
38430	744	5	P.	P.	NNP
38430	745	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	745	2	_	_	NNP
38430	745	3	,	,	,
38430	745	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	745	5	.	.	.
38430	746	1	358	358	CD
38430	746	2	-	-	SYM
38430	746	3	9	9	CD
38430	746	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	746	5	Cf	cf	NN
38430	746	6	.	.	.
38430	747	1	_	_	NNP
38430	747	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	747	3	_	_	NNP
38430	747	4	,	,	,
38430	747	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	747	6	.	.	.
38430	748	1	xxii	xxii	NNP
38430	748	2	.	.	NNP
38430	748	3	,	,	,
38430	748	4	January	January	NNP
38430	748	5	1912	1912	CD
38430	748	6	,	,	,
38430	748	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	749	1	187.--ED	187.--ed	CD
38430	749	2	.	.	.
38430	749	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	750	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	750	2	85	85	CD
38430	750	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	750	4	Cf	cf	NN
38430	750	5	.	.	.
38430	751	1	_	_	NNP
38430	751	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	752	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	752	2	_	_	NNP
38430	752	3	,	,	,
38430	752	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	752	5	.	.	.
38430	753	1	350	350	CD
38430	753	2	,	,	,
38430	753	3	358	358	CD
38430	753	4	-	-	SYM
38430	753	5	9	9	CD
38430	753	6	;	;	:
38430	753	7	_	_	NNP
38430	753	8	M.	M.	NNP
38430	753	9	_	_	NNP
38430	753	10	,	,	,
38430	753	11	vol	vol	NNP
38430	753	12	.	.	.
38430	754	1	xxii	xxii	NNP
38430	754	2	.	.	NNP
38430	754	3	,	,	,
38430	754	4	1912	1912	CD
38430	754	5	,	,	,
38430	754	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	754	7	157	157	CD
38430	754	8	.	.	.
38430	755	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	755	2	86	86	CD
38430	755	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	755	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	755	5	Cf	cf	NN
38430	755	6	.	.	.
38430	756	1	for	for	IN
38430	756	2	example	example	NN
38430	756	3	,	,	,
38430	756	4	Cosmo	Cosmo	NNP
38430	756	5	Guastella	Guastella	NNP
38430	756	6	,	,	,
38430	756	7	_	_	NNP
38430	756	8	Dell	Dell	NNP
38430	756	9	'	'	POS
38430	756	10	infinito	infinito	NNP
38430	756	11	_	_	NNP
38430	756	12	,	,	,
38430	756	13	Palermo	Palermo	NNP
38430	756	14	,	,	,
38430	756	15	1912.--ED	1912.--ed	CD
38430	756	16	.	.	.
38430	756	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	757	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	757	2	87	87	CD
38430	757	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	757	4	Cf	Cf	NNP
38430	757	5	.	.	.
38430	758	1	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	758	2	,	,	,
38430	758	3	_	_	NNP
38430	758	4	P.	P.	NNP
38430	759	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	759	2	_	_	NNP
38430	759	3	,	,	,
38430	759	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	759	5	360	360	CD
38430	759	6	.	.	.
38430	760	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	760	2	XXXII	XXXII	NNP
38430	760	3	THE	the	DT
38430	760	4	HARDSHIPS	hardship	NNS
38430	760	5	OF	of	IN
38430	760	6	A	a	DT
38430	760	7	MAN	man	NN
38430	760	8	WITH	with	IN
38430	760	9	AN	an	DT
38430	760	10	UNLIMITED	unlimited	JJ
38430	760	11	INCOME	income	NN
38430	760	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	760	13	once	once	RB
38430	760	14	heard	hear	VBD
38430	760	15	a	a	DT
38430	760	16	man	man	NN
38430	760	17	refer	refer	VB
38430	760	18	to	to	IN
38430	760	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	760	20	income	income	NN
38430	760	21	as	as	IN
38430	760	22	limited	limit	VBN
38430	760	23	,	,	,
38430	760	24	in	in	IN
38430	760	25	order	order	NN
38430	760	26	to	to	TO
38430	760	27	illustrate	illustrate	VB
38430	760	28	the	the	DT
38430	760	29	hardship	hardship	NN
38430	760	30	of	of	IN
38430	760	31	a	a	DT
38430	760	32	class	class	NN
38430	760	33	of	of	IN
38430	760	34	men	man	NNS
38430	760	35	,	,	,
38430	760	36	of	of	IN
38430	760	37	which	which	WDT
38430	760	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	760	39	of	of	IN
38430	760	40	course	course	NN
38430	760	41	was	be	VBD
38430	760	42	one	one	CD
38430	760	43	,	,	,
38430	760	44	in	in	IN
38430	760	45	having	have	VBG
38430	760	46	to	to	TO
38430	760	47	pay	pay	VB
38430	760	48	a	a	DT
38430	760	49	somewhat	somewhat	RB
38430	760	50	high	high	JJ
38430	760	51	income	income	NN
38430	760	52	-	-	HYPH
38430	760	53	tax	tax	NN
38430	760	54	.	.	.
38430	761	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	761	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	761	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
38430	761	4	that	that	IN
38430	761	5	this	this	DT
38430	761	6	man	man	NN
38430	761	7	spoke	speak	VBD
38430	761	8	enviously	enviously	RB
38430	761	9	,	,	,
38430	761	10	and	and	CC
38430	761	11	consequently	consequently	RB
38430	761	12	admitted	admit	VBD
38430	761	13	the	the	DT
38430	761	14	existence	existence	NN
38430	761	15	of	of	IN
38430	761	16	more	more	RBR
38430	761	17	fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	761	18	placed	place	VBN
38430	761	19	individuals	individual	NNS
38430	761	20	who	who	WP
38430	761	21	had	have	VBD
38430	761	22	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
38430	761	23	incomes	income	NNS
38430	761	24	.	.	.
38430	762	1	A	a	DT
38430	762	2	little	little	JJ
38430	762	3	reflection	reflection	NN
38430	762	4	would	would	MD
38430	762	5	have	have	VB
38430	762	6	shown	show	VBN
38430	762	7	the	the	DT
38430	762	8	man	man	NN
38430	762	9	that	that	IN
38430	762	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	762	11	was	be	VBD
38430	762	12	not	not	RB
38430	762	13	taking	take	VBG
38430	762	14	up	up	RP
38430	762	15	a	a	DT
38430	762	16	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	762	17	attitude	attitude	NN
38430	762	18	.	.	.
38430	763	1	A	a	DT
38430	763	2	"	"	``
38430	763	3	paradoxical	paradoxical	JJ
38430	763	4	attitude	attitude	NN
38430	763	5	"	"	''
38430	763	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	763	7	of	of	IN
38430	763	8	course	course	NN
38430	763	9	the	the	DT
38430	763	10	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	763	11	of	of	IN
38430	763	12	one	one	CD
38430	763	13	or	or	CC
38430	763	14	more	more	JJR
38430	763	15	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	763	16	of	of	IN
38430	763	17	which	which	WDT
38430	763	18	the	the	DT
38430	763	19	truth	truth	NN
38430	763	20	can	can	MD
38430	763	21	not	not	RB
38430	763	22	be	be	VB
38430	763	23	perceived	perceive	VBN
38430	763	24	by	by	IN
38430	763	25	a	a	DT
38430	763	26	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	763	27	--	--	:
38430	763	28	and	and	CC
38430	763	29	particularly	particularly	RB
38430	763	30	an	an	DT
38430	763	31	idealist	idealist	NN
38430	763	32	--	--	:
38430	763	33	and	and	CC
38430	763	34	can	can	MD
38430	763	35	be	be	VB
38430	763	36	perceived	perceive	VBN
38430	763	37	by	by	IN
38430	763	38	a	a	DT
38430	763	39	logician	logician	JJ
38430	763	40	and	and	CC
38430	763	41	occasionally	occasionally	RB
38430	763	42	,	,	,
38430	763	43	but	but	CC
38430	763	44	not	not	RB
38430	763	45	always	always	RB
38430	763	46	,	,	,
38430	763	47	by	by	IN
38430	763	48	a	a	DT
38430	763	49	man	man	NN
38430	763	50	of	of	IN
38430	763	51	common	common	JJ
38430	763	52	-	-	HYPH
38430	763	53	sense	sense	NN
38430	763	54	.	.	.
38430	764	1	Such	such	JJ
38430	764	2	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	764	3	are	be	VBP
38430	764	4	:	:	:
38430	764	5	"	"	``
38430	764	6	The	the	DT
38430	764	7	cat	cat	NN
38430	764	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	764	9	hungry	hungry	JJ
38430	764	10	,	,	,
38430	764	11	"	"	''
38430	764	12	"	"	``
38430	764	13	Columbus	Columbus	NNP
38430	764	14	discovered	discover	VBD
38430	764	15	America	America	NNP
38430	764	16	,	,	,
38430	764	17	"	"	''
38430	764	18	and	and	CC
38430	764	19	"	"	``
38430	764	20	A	a	DT
38430	764	21	thing	thing	NN
38430	764	22	which	which	WDT
38430	764	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	764	24	always	always	RB
38430	764	25	at	at	IN
38430	764	26	rest	rest	NN
38430	764	27	may	may	MD
38430	764	28	move	move	VB
38430	764	29	from	from	IN
38430	764	30	the	the	DT
38430	764	31	position	position	NN
38430	764	32	A	a	NN
38430	764	33	to	to	IN
38430	764	34	the	the	DT
38430	764	35	different	different	JJ
38430	764	36	position	position	NN
38430	764	37	B.	B.	NNP
38430	764	38	"	"	''
38430	765	1	Now	now	RB
38430	765	2	,	,	,
38430	765	3	if	if	IN
38430	765	4	a	a	DT
38430	765	5	man	man	NN
38430	765	6	had	have	VBD
38430	765	7	an	an	DT
38430	765	8	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
38430	765	9	income	income	NN
38430	765	10	,	,	,
38430	765	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	765	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	765	13	an	an	DT
38430	765	14	immediate	immediate	JJ
38430	765	15	inference	inference	NN
38430	765	16	that	that	IN
38430	765	17	,	,	,
38430	765	18	however	however	RB
38430	765	19	low	low	JJ
38430	765	20	income	income	NN
38430	765	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	765	22	tax	tax	NN
38430	765	23	might	may	MD
38430	765	24	be	be	VB
38430	765	25	,	,	,
38430	765	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	765	27	would	would	MD
38430	765	28	have	have	VB
38430	765	29	to	to	TO
38430	765	30	pay	pay	VB
38430	765	31	annually	annually	RB
38430	765	32	to	to	IN
38430	765	33	the	the	DT
38430	765	34	Exchequer	Exchequer	NNP
38430	765	35	of	of	IN
38430	765	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	765	37	nation	nation	NN
38430	765	38	a	a	DT
38430	765	39	sum	sum	NN
38430	765	40	equal	equal	JJ
38430	765	41	in	in	IN
38430	765	42	value	value	NN
38430	765	43	to	to	IN
38430	765	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	765	45	whole	whole	JJ
38430	765	46	income	income	NN
38430	765	47	.	.	.
38430	766	1	Further	further	RB
38430	766	2	,	,	,
38430	766	3	if	if	IN
38430	766	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	766	5	income	income	NN
38430	766	6	was	be	VBD
38430	766	7	derived	derive	VBN
38430	766	8	from	from	IN
38430	766	9	a	a	DT
38430	766	10	capital	capital	NN
38430	766	11	invested	invest	VBN
38430	766	12	at	at	IN
38430	766	13	a	a	DT
38430	766	14	finite	finite	JJ
38430	766	15	rate	rate	NN
38430	766	16	of	of	IN
38430	766	17	interest	interest	NN
38430	766	18	(	(	-LRB-
38430	766	19	as	as	IN
38430	766	20	is	be	VBZ
38430	766	21	usual	usual	JJ
38430	766	22	)	)	-RRB-
38430	766	23	,	,	,
38430	766	24	the	the	DT
38430	766	25	annual	annual	JJ
38430	766	26	payments	payment	NNS
38430	766	27	of	of	IN
38430	766	28	income	income	NN
38430	766	29	-	-	HYPH
38430	766	30	tax	tax	NN
38430	766	31	would	would	MD
38430	766	32	each	each	DT
38430	766	33	be	be	VB
38430	766	34	equal	equal	JJ
38430	766	35	in	in	IN
38430	766	36	value	value	NN
38430	766	37	to	to	IN
38430	766	38	the	the	DT
38430	766	39	man	man	NN
38430	766	40	's	's	POS
38430	766	41	whole	whole	JJ
38430	766	42	capital	capital	NN
38430	766	43	.	.	.
38430	767	1	If	if	IN
38430	767	2	,	,	,
38430	767	3	then	then	RB
38430	767	4	,	,	,
38430	767	5	the	the	DT
38430	767	6	man	man	NN
38430	767	7	with	with	IN
38430	767	8	an	an	DT
38430	767	9	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
38430	767	10	income	income	NN
38430	767	11	chose	choose	VBD
38430	767	12	to	to	TO
38430	767	13	be	be	VB
38430	767	14	discontented	discontent	VBN
38430	767	15	,	,	,
38430	767	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	767	17	would	would	MD
38430	767	18	be	be	VB
38430	767	19	sure	sure	JJ
38430	767	20	of	of	IN
38430	767	21	a	a	DT
38430	767	22	sympathetic	sympathetic	JJ
38430	767	23	audience	audience	NN
38430	767	24	among	among	IN
38430	767	25	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
38430	767	26	and	and	CC
38430	767	27	business	business	NN
38430	767	28	acquaintances	acquaintance	NNS
38430	767	29	;	;	:
38430	767	30	but	but	CC
38430	767	31	discontent	discontent	NN
38430	767	32	could	could	MD
38430	767	33	not	not	RB
38430	767	34	last	last	VB
38430	767	35	long	long	RB
38430	767	36	,	,	,
38430	767	37	for	for	IN
38430	767	38	the	the	DT
38430	767	39	thought	thought	NN
38430	767	40	of	of	IN
38430	767	41	the	the	DT
38430	767	42	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	767	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	767	44	was	be	VBD
38430	767	45	putting	put	VBG
38430	767	46	in	in	RP
38430	767	47	the	the	DT
38430	767	48	way	way	NN
38430	767	49	of	of	IN
38430	767	50	the	the	DT
38430	767	51	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
38430	767	52	of	of	IN
38430	767	53	the	the	DT
38430	767	54	Exchequer	Exchequer	NNP
38430	767	55	,	,	,
38430	767	56	who	who	WP
38430	767	57	would	would	MD
38430	767	58	find	find	VB
38430	767	59	the	the	DT
38430	767	60	drawing	drawing	NN
38430	767	61	up	up	RP
38430	767	62	of	of	IN
38430	767	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	767	64	budget	budget	NN
38430	767	65	most	most	RBS
38430	767	66	puzzling	puzzling	JJ
38430	767	67	,	,	,
38430	767	68	would	would	MD
38430	767	69	be	be	VB
38430	767	70	amusing	amusing	JJ
38430	767	71	.	.	.
38430	768	1	Again	again	RB
38430	768	2	,	,	,
38430	768	3	the	the	DT
38430	768	4	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	768	5	that	that	IN
38430	768	6	,	,	,
38430	768	7	after	after	IN
38430	768	8	paying	pay	VBG
38430	768	9	an	an	DT
38430	768	10	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	768	11	income	income	NN
38430	768	12	-	-	HYPH
38430	768	13	tax	tax	NN
38430	768	14	,	,	,
38430	768	15	the	the	DT
38430	768	16	income	income	NN
38430	768	17	would	would	MD
38430	768	18	be	be	VB
38430	768	19	quite	quite	RB
38430	768	20	undiminished	undiminished	JJ
38430	768	21	,	,	,
38430	768	22	would	would	MD
38430	768	23	obviously	obviously	RB
38430	768	24	afford	afford	VB
38430	768	25	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
38430	768	26	,	,	,
38430	768	27	though	though	IN
38430	768	28	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	768	29	the	the	DT
38430	768	30	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
38430	768	31	might	may	MD
38430	768	32	be	be	VB
38430	768	33	mixed	mix	VBN
38430	768	34	with	with	IN
38430	768	35	a	a	DT
38430	768	36	slight	slight	JJ
38430	768	37	uneasiness	uneasiness	NN
38430	768	38	as	as	IN
38430	768	39	to	to	IN
38430	768	40	any	any	DT
38430	768	41	action	action	NN
38430	768	42	the	the	DT
38430	768	43	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
38430	768	44	of	of	IN
38430	768	45	Income	Income	NNP
38430	768	46	-	-	HYPH
38430	768	47	Tax	Tax	NNP
38430	768	48	might	may	MD
38430	768	49	take	take	VB
38430	768	50	in	in	IN
38430	768	51	view	view	NN
38430	768	52	of	of	IN
38430	768	53	this	this	DT
38430	768	54	fact	fact	NN
38430	768	55	.	.	.
38430	769	1	A	a	DT
38430	769	2	problem	problem	NN
38430	769	3	of	of	IN
38430	769	4	a	a	DT
38430	769	5	wholly	wholly	RB
38430	769	6	different	different	JJ
38430	769	7	nature	nature	NN
38430	769	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	769	9	connected	connect	VBN
38430	769	10	with	with	IN
38430	769	11	the	the	DT
38430	769	12	possible	possible	JJ
38430	769	13	purchase	purchase	NN
38430	769	14	by	by	IN
38430	769	15	the	the	DT
38430	769	16	man	man	NN
38430	769	17	with	with	IN
38430	769	18	an	an	DT
38430	769	19	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
38430	769	20	income	income	NN
38430	769	21	of	of	IN
38430	769	22	an	an	DT
38430	769	23	enumerable	enumerable	JJ
38430	769	24	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	769	25	of	of	IN
38430	769	26	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	769	27	of	of	IN
38430	769	28	boots	boot	NNS
38430	769	29	.	.	.
38430	770	1	If	if	IN
38430	770	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	3	wished	wish	VBD
38430	770	4	to	to	TO
38430	770	5	prove	prove	VB
38430	770	6	that	that	IN
38430	770	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	8	had	have	VBD
38430	770	9	an	an	DT
38430	770	10	even	even	JJ
38430	770	11	number	number	NN
38430	770	12	of	of	IN
38430	770	13	boots	boot	NNS
38430	770	14	,	,	,
38430	770	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	16	would	would	MD
38430	770	17	be	be	VB
38430	770	18	easy	easy	JJ
38430	770	19	if	if	IN
38430	770	20	right	right	JJ
38430	770	21	boots	boot	NNS
38430	770	22	were	be	VBD
38430	770	23	distinguishable	distinguishable	JJ
38430	770	24	from	from	IN
38430	770	25	left	left	JJ
38430	770	26	ones	one	NNS
38430	770	27	,	,	,
38430	770	28	but	but	CC
38430	770	29	if	if	IN
38430	770	30	the	the	DT
38430	770	31	man	man	NN
38430	770	32	were	be	VBD
38430	770	33	a	a	DT
38430	770	34	faddist	faddist	NN
38430	770	35	of	of	IN
38430	770	36	such	such	PDT
38430	770	37	a	a	DT
38430	770	38	kind	kind	NN
38430	770	39	that	that	WDT
38430	770	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	41	insisted	insist	VBD
38430	770	42	that	that	IN
38430	770	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	770	44	left	left	JJ
38430	770	45	boots	boot	NNS
38430	770	46	should	should	MD
38430	770	47	not	not	RB
38430	770	48	be	be	VB
38430	770	49	made	make	VBN
38430	770	50	in	in	IN
38430	770	51	any	any	DT
38430	770	52	way	way	NN
38430	770	53	differently	differently	RB
38430	770	54	from	from	IN
38430	770	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	770	56	right	right	JJ
38430	770	57	ones	one	NNS
38430	770	58	,	,	,
38430	770	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	60	would	would	MD
38430	770	61	not	not	RB
38430	770	62	be	be	VB
38430	770	63	possible	possible	JJ
38430	770	64	for	for	IN
38430	770	65	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	66	to	to	TO
38430	770	67	prove	prove	VB
38430	770	68	the	the	DT
38430	770	69	theorem	theorem	NN
38430	770	70	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	770	71	unless	unless	IN
38430	770	72	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	770	73	assumed	assume	VBD
38430	770	74	what	what	WP
38430	770	75	is	be	VBZ
38430	770	76	known	know	VBN
38430	770	77	as	as	IN
38430	770	78	"	"	``
38430	770	79	the	the	DT
38430	770	80	multiplicative	multiplicative	JJ
38430	770	81	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	770	82	.	.	.
38430	770	83	"	"	''
38430	771	1	In	in	IN
38430	771	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	771	3	this	this	DT
38430	771	4	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	771	5	shows	show	VBZ
38430	771	6	that	that	IN
38430	771	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	771	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	771	9	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	771	10	to	to	TO
38430	771	11	pick	pick	VB
38430	771	12	out	out	RP
38430	771	13	an	an	DT
38430	771	14	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	771	15	succession	succession	NN
38430	771	16	of	of	IN
38430	771	17	members	member	NNS
38430	771	18	of	of	IN
38430	771	19	an	an	DT
38430	771	20	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	771	21	class	class	NN
38430	771	22	in	in	IN
38430	771	23	an	an	DT
38430	771	24	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
38430	771	25	way	way	NN
38430	771	26	.	.	.
38430	772	1	In	in	IN
38430	772	2	the	the	DT
38430	772	3	case	case	NN
38430	772	4	of	of	IN
38430	772	5	the	the	DT
38430	772	6	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	772	7	of	of	IN
38430	772	8	boots	boot	NNS
38430	772	9	,	,	,
38430	772	10	each	each	DT
38430	772	11	pair	pair	NN
38430	772	12	contains	contain	VBZ
38430	772	13	two	two	CD
38430	772	14	members	member	NNS
38430	772	15	,	,	,
38430	772	16	and	and	CC
38430	772	17	if	if	IN
38430	772	18	there	there	EX
38430	772	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	772	20	no	no	DT
38430	772	21	means	means	NN
38430	772	22	of	of	IN
38430	772	23	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
38430	772	24	between	between	IN
38430	772	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	26	,	,	,
38430	772	27	when	when	WRB
38430	772	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	29	wish	wish	VBP
38430	772	30	to	to	TO
38430	772	31	pick	pick	VB
38430	772	32	out	out	RP
38430	772	33	one	one	CD
38430	772	34	of	of	IN
38430	772	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	36	for	for	IN
38430	772	37	each	each	DT
38430	772	38	of	of	IN
38430	772	39	the	the	DT
38430	772	40	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	772	41	of	of	IN
38430	772	42	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	772	43	,	,	,
38430	772	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	45	can	can	MD
38430	772	46	not	not	RB
38430	772	47	say	say	VB
38430	772	48	which	which	WDT
38430	772	49	ones	one	NNS
38430	772	50	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	51	mean	mean	VBP
38430	772	52	to	to	TO
38430	772	53	pick	pick	VB
38430	772	54	out	out	RP
38430	772	55	unless	unless	IN
38430	772	56	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	57	assume	assume	VBP
38430	772	58	,	,	,
38430	772	59	by	by	IN
38430	772	60	means	mean	NNS
38430	772	61	of	of	IN
38430	772	62	the	the	DT
38430	772	63	above	above	JJ
38430	772	64	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	772	65	,	,	,
38430	772	66	that	that	IN
38430	772	67	a	a	DT
38430	772	68	particularized	particularize	VBN
38430	772	69	member	member	NN
38430	772	70	can	can	MD
38430	772	71	always	always	RB
38430	772	72	be	be	VB
38430	772	73	found	find	VBN
38430	772	74	even	even	RB
38430	772	75	with	with	IN
38430	772	76	things	thing	NNS
38430	772	77	of	of	IN
38430	772	78	each	each	DT
38430	772	79	of	of	IN
38430	772	80	which	which	WDT
38430	772	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	82	can	can	MD
38430	772	83	be	be	VB
38430	772	84	said	say	VBN
38430	772	85	that	that	IN
38430	772	86	,	,	,
38430	772	87	like	like	IN
38430	772	88	Private	Private	NNP
38430	772	89	James	James	NNP
38430	772	90	in	in	IN
38430	772	91	the	the	DT
38430	772	92	_	_	NNP
38430	772	93	Bab	Bab	NNP
38430	772	94	Ballads	Ballads	NNP
38430	772	95	_	_	NNP
38430	772	96	,	,	,
38430	772	97	No	no	DT
38430	772	98	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
38430	772	99	trait	trait	NN
38430	772	100	had	have	VBD
38430	772	101	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	772	102	Of	of	IN
38430	772	103	any	any	DT
38430	772	104	distinctive	distinctive	JJ
38430	772	105	kind	kind	NN
38430	772	106	.	.	.
38430	773	1	However	however	RB
38430	773	2	,	,	,
38430	773	3	a	a	DT
38430	773	4	solution	solution	NN
38430	773	5	of	of	IN
38430	773	6	the	the	DT
38430	773	7	puzzle	puzzle	NN
38430	773	8	was	be	VBD
38430	773	9	given	give	VBN
38430	773	10	by	by	IN
38430	773	11	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	773	12	Dénes	Dénes	NNP
38430	773	13	König	König	NNP
38430	773	14	of	of	IN
38430	773	15	Budapest	Budapest	NNP
38430	773	16	.	.	.
38430	774	1	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	774	2	first	first	RB
38430	774	3	prove	prove	VBP
38430	774	4	that	that	IN
38430	774	5	there	there	EX
38430	774	6	are	be	VBP
38430	774	7	points	point	NNS
38430	774	8	in	in	IN
38430	774	9	space	space	NN
38430	774	10	such	such	JJ
38430	774	11	that	that	IN
38430	774	12	,	,	,
38430	774	13	if	if	IN
38430	774	14	P	p	NN
38430	774	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	774	16	one	one	CD
38430	774	17	of	of	IN
38430	774	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	774	19	,	,	,
38430	774	20	not	not	RB
38430	774	21	more	more	JJR
38430	774	22	than	than	IN
38430	774	23	a	a	DT
38430	774	24	finite	finite	JJ
38430	774	25	number	number	NN
38430	774	26	of	of	IN
38430	774	27	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	774	28	of	of	IN
38430	774	29	boots	boot	NNS
38430	774	30	are	be	VBP
38430	774	31	such	such	JJ
38430	774	32	that	that	IN
38430	774	33	each	each	DT
38430	774	34	centre	centre	NN
38430	774	35	of	of	IN
38430	774	36	mass	mass	NN
38430	774	37	of	of	IN
38430	774	38	the	the	DT
38430	774	39	two	two	CD
38430	774	40	members	member	NNS
38430	774	41	of	of	IN
38430	774	42	a	a	DT
38430	774	43	pair	pair	NN
38430	774	44	is	be	VBZ
38430	774	45	equidistant	equidistant	JJ
38430	774	46	from	from	IN
38430	774	47	P.	P.	NNP
38430	774	48	Taking	take	VBG
38430	774	49	a	a	DT
38430	774	50	point	point	NN
38430	774	51	P	p	NN
38430	774	52	of	of	IN
38430	774	53	this	this	DT
38430	774	54	sort	sort	NN
38430	774	55	,	,	,
38430	774	56	select	select	JJ
38430	774	57	from	from	IN
38430	774	58	each	each	DT
38430	774	59	pair	pair	NN
38430	774	60	the	the	DT
38430	774	61	boot	boot	NN
38430	774	62	whose	whose	WP$
38430	774	63	centre	centre	NN
38430	774	64	of	of	IN
38430	774	65	mass	mass	NNP
38430	774	66	is	be	VBZ
38430	774	67	nearest	near	JJS
38430	774	68	P.	P.	NNP
38430	774	69	(	(	-LRB-
38430	774	70	There	there	EX
38430	774	71	may	may	MD
38430	774	72	be	be	VB
38430	774	73	a	a	DT
38430	774	74	finite	finite	JJ
38430	774	75	number	number	NN
38430	774	76	of	of	IN
38430	774	77	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	774	78	left	leave	VBN
38430	774	79	over	over	RP
38430	774	80	,	,	,
38430	774	81	but	but	CC
38430	774	82	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	774	83	can	can	MD
38430	774	84	be	be	VB
38430	774	85	dealt	deal	VBN
38430	774	86	with	with	IN
38430	774	87	arbitrarily	arbitrarily	NNP
38430	774	88	.	.	.
38430	774	89	)	)	-RRB-
38430	775	1	Another	another	DT
38430	775	2	form	form	NN
38430	775	3	of	of	IN
38430	775	4	the	the	DT
38430	775	5	problem	problem	NN
38430	775	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	775	7	as	as	IN
38430	775	8	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	775	9	.	.	.
38430	776	1	Every	every	DT
38430	776	2	time	time	NN
38430	776	3	the	the	DT
38430	776	4	man	man	NN
38430	776	5	bought	buy	VBD
38430	776	6	a	a	DT
38430	776	7	pair	pair	NN
38430	776	8	of	of	IN
38430	776	9	boots	boot	NNS
38430	776	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	776	11	also	also	RB
38430	776	12	bought	buy	VBD
38430	776	13	a	a	DT
38430	776	14	pair	pair	NN
38430	776	15	of	of	IN
38430	776	16	socks	sock	NNS
38430	776	17	to	to	TO
38430	776	18	go	go	VB
38430	776	19	with	with	IN
38430	776	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	776	21	;	;	:
38430	776	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	776	23	had	have	VBD
38430	776	24	an	an	DT
38430	776	25	enumerable	enumerable	JJ
38430	776	26	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	776	27	of	of	IN
38430	776	28	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	776	29	of	of	IN
38430	776	30	each	each	DT
38430	776	31	,	,	,
38430	776	32	and	and	CC
38430	776	33	the	the	DT
38430	776	34	problem	problem	NN
38430	776	35	is	be	VBZ
38430	776	36	to	to	TO
38430	776	37	prove	prove	VB
38430	776	38	that	that	IN
38430	776	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	776	40	had	have	VBD
38430	776	41	as	as	RB
38430	776	42	many	many	JJ
38430	776	43	boots	boot	NNS
38430	776	44	as	as	IN
38430	776	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	776	46	had	have	VBD
38430	776	47	socks	sock	NNS
38430	776	48	.	.	.
38430	777	1	In	in	IN
38430	777	2	this	this	DT
38430	777	3	case	case	NN
38430	777	4	the	the	DT
38430	777	5	boots	boot	NNS
38430	777	6	,	,	,
38430	777	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	777	8	will	will	MD
38430	777	9	suppose	suppose	VB
38430	777	10	,	,	,
38430	777	11	can	can	MD
38430	777	12	be	be	VB
38430	777	13	divided	divide	VBN
38430	777	14	into	into	IN
38430	777	15	right	right	NN
38430	777	16	and	and	CC
38430	777	17	left	leave	VBD
38430	777	18	,	,	,
38430	777	19	but	but	CC
38430	777	20	the	the	DT
38430	777	21	socks	sock	NNS
38430	777	22	can	can	MD
38430	777	23	not	not	RB
38430	777	24	.	.	.
38430	778	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	778	2	there	there	EX
38430	778	3	are	be	VBP
38430	778	4	an	an	DT
38430	778	5	enumerable	enumerable	JJ
38430	778	6	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	778	7	of	of	IN
38430	778	8	boots	boot	NNS
38430	778	9	,	,	,
38430	778	10	but	but	CC
38430	778	11	the	the	DT
38430	778	12	number	number	NN
38430	778	13	of	of	IN
38430	778	14	the	the	DT
38430	778	15	socks	sock	NNS
38430	778	16	can	can	MD
38430	778	17	not	not	RB
38430	778	18	be	be	VB
38430	778	19	determined	determine	VBN
38430	778	20	without	without	IN
38430	778	21	admitting	admit	VBG
38430	778	22	the	the	DT
38430	778	23	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	778	24	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	778	25	above	above	RB
38430	778	26	.	.	.
38430	779	1	A	a	DT
38430	779	2	further	further	JJ
38430	779	3	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	779	4	might	may	MD
38430	779	5	arise	arise	VB
38430	779	6	if	if	IN
38430	779	7	the	the	DT
38430	779	8	owner	owner	NN
38430	779	9	of	of	IN
38430	779	10	the	the	DT
38430	779	11	boots	boot	NNS
38430	779	12	and	and	CC
38430	779	13	socks	sock	NNS
38430	779	14	lost	lose	VBD
38430	779	15	one	one	CD
38430	779	16	leg	leg	NN
38430	779	17	in	in	IN
38430	779	18	some	some	DT
38430	779	19	accident	accident	NN
38430	779	20	,	,	,
38430	779	21	and	and	CC
38430	779	22	told	tell	VBD
38430	779	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	779	24	butler	butler	NN
38430	779	25	to	to	TO
38430	779	26	give	give	VB
38430	779	27	away	away	RP
38430	779	28	half	half	PDT
38430	779	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	779	30	socks	sock	NNS
38430	779	31	.	.	.
38430	780	1	Naturally	naturally	RB
38430	780	2	the	the	DT
38430	780	3	butler	butler	NN
38430	780	4	would	would	MD
38430	780	5	find	find	VB
38430	780	6	great	great	JJ
38430	780	7	logical	logical	JJ
38430	780	8	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	780	9	in	in	IN
38430	780	10	so	so	RB
38430	780	11	doing	do	VBG
38430	780	12	,	,	,
38430	780	13	and	and	CC
38430	780	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	780	15	would	would	MD
38430	780	16	seem	seem	VB
38430	780	17	to	to	TO
38430	780	18	be	be	VB
38430	780	19	an	an	DT
38430	780	20	interesting	interesting	JJ
38430	780	21	ethical	ethical	JJ
38430	780	22	problem	problem	NN
38430	780	23	whether	whether	IN
38430	780	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	780	25	should	should	MD
38430	780	26	be	be	VB
38430	780	27	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
38430	780	28	from	from	IN
38430	780	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	780	30	situation	situation	NN
38430	780	31	for	for	IN
38430	780	32	failing	fail	VBG
38430	780	33	to	to	TO
38430	780	34	prove	prove	VB
38430	780	35	the	the	DT
38430	780	36	multiplicative	multiplicative	JJ
38430	780	37	axiom	axiom	NN
38430	780	38	.	.	.
38430	781	1	Again	again	RB
38430	781	2	,	,	,
38430	781	3	if	if	IN
38430	781	4	the	the	DT
38430	781	5	butler	butler	NN
38430	781	6	stole	steal	VBD
38430	781	7	a	a	DT
38430	781	8	pair	pair	NN
38430	781	9	of	of	IN
38430	781	10	boots	boot	NNS
38430	781	11	,	,	,
38430	781	12	the	the	DT
38430	781	13	millionaire	millionaire	NN
38430	781	14	would	would	MD
38430	781	15	have	have	VB
38430	781	16	as	as	RB
38430	781	17	many	many	JJ
38430	781	18	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	781	19	as	as	IN
38430	781	20	before	before	RB
38430	781	21	,	,	,
38430	781	22	but	but	CC
38430	781	23	might	may	MD
38430	781	24	have	have	VB
38430	781	25	fewer	few	JJR
38430	781	26	boots	boot	NNS
38430	781	27	.	.	.
38430	782	1	There	there	EX
38430	782	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	782	3	as	as	RB
38430	782	4	yet	yet	RB
38430	782	5	no	no	DT
38430	782	6	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	782	7	that	that	IN
38430	782	8	the	the	DT
38430	782	9	number	number	NN
38430	782	10	of	of	IN
38430	782	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	782	12	boots	boot	NNS
38430	782	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	782	14	equal	equal	JJ
38430	782	15	to	to	IN
38430	782	16	or	or	CC
38430	782	17	greater	great	JJR
38430	782	18	than	than	IN
38430	782	19	the	the	DT
38430	782	20	number	number	NN
38430	782	21	of	of	IN
38430	782	22	pairs	pair	NNS
38430	782	23	.	.	.
38430	783	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	783	2	XXXIII	XXXIII	NNP
38430	783	3	THE	the	DT
38430	783	4	RELATIONS	relations	NN
38430	783	5	OF	of	IN
38430	783	6	MAGNITUDE	MAGNITUDE	NNP
38430	783	7	OF	of	IN
38430	783	8	CARDINAL	CARDINAL	NNP
38430	783	9	NUMBERS	number	NNS
38430	783	10	The	the	DT
38430	783	11	theorems	theorem	NNS
38430	783	12	of	of	IN
38430	783	13	cardinal	cardinal	JJ
38430	783	14	arithmetic	arithmetic	NNP
38430	783	15	are	be	VBP
38430	783	16	frequently	frequently	RB
38430	783	17	used	use	VBN
38430	783	18	in	in	IN
38430	783	19	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	783	20	conversation	conversation	NN
38430	783	21	.	.	.
38430	784	1	What	what	WP
38430	784	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	784	3	known	know	VBN
38430	784	4	as	as	IN
38430	784	5	the	the	DT
38430	784	6	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	784	7	-	-	HYPH
38430	784	8	Bernstein	Bernstein	NNP
38430	784	9	theorem	theorem	NN
38430	784	10	was	be	VBD
38430	784	11	used	use	VBN
38430	784	12	,	,	,
38430	784	13	long	long	RB
38430	784	14	before	before	IN
38430	784	15	Bernstein	Bernstein	NNP
38430	784	16	or	or	CC
38430	784	17	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	784	18	,	,	,
38430	784	19	by	by	IN
38430	784	20	Edward	Edward	NNP
38430	784	21	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
38430	784	22	,	,	,
38430	784	23	afterward	afterward	RB
38430	784	24	the	the	DT
38430	784	25	law	law	NN
38430	784	26	-	-	HYPH
38430	784	27	lord	lord	JJ
38430	784	28	Lord	Lord	NNP
38430	784	29	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
38430	784	30	,	,	,
38430	784	31	when	when	WRB
38430	784	32	an	an	DT
38430	784	33	undergraduate	undergraduate	NN
38430	784	34	of	of	IN
38430	784	35	Caius	Caius	NNP
38430	784	36	College	College	NNP
38430	784	37	,	,	,
38430	784	38	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	784	39	.	.	.
38430	785	1	Thurlow	thurlow	NN
38430	785	2	was	be	VBD
38430	785	3	rebuked	rebuke	VBN
38430	785	4	for	for	IN
38430	785	5	idleness	idleness	JJ
38430	785	6	by	by	IN
38430	785	7	the	the	DT
38430	785	8	Master	Master	NNP
38430	785	9	,	,	,
38430	785	10	who	who	WP
38430	785	11	said	say	VBD
38430	785	12	to	to	IN
38430	785	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	785	14	:	:	:
38430	785	15	"	"	``
38430	785	16	Whenever	whenever	WRB
38430	785	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	785	18	look	look	VBP
38430	785	19	out	out	IN
38430	785	20	of	of	IN
38430	785	21	the	the	DT
38430	785	22	window	window	NN
38430	785	23	,	,	,
38430	785	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	785	25	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
38430	785	26	,	,	,
38430	785	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	785	28	see	see	VBP
38430	785	29	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	785	30	crossing	cross	VBG
38430	785	31	the	the	DT
38430	785	32	Court	Court	NNP
38430	785	33	.	.	.
38430	785	34	"	"	''
38430	786	1	The	the	DT
38430	786	2	provost	provost	NN
38430	786	3	thus	thus	RB
38430	786	4	asserted	assert	VBD
38430	786	5	a	a	DT
38430	786	6	one	one	CD
38430	786	7	-	-	HYPH
38430	786	8	one	one	CD
38430	786	9	correspondence	correspondence	NN
38430	786	10	between	between	IN
38430	786	11	the	the	DT
38430	786	12	class	class	NN
38430	786	13	A	a	NN
38430	786	14	of	of	IN
38430	786	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	786	16	acts	act	NNS
38430	786	17	of	of	IN
38430	786	18	looking	look	VBG
38430	786	19	out	out	IN
38430	786	20	of	of	IN
38430	786	21	the	the	DT
38430	786	22	window	window	NN
38430	786	23	and	and	CC
38430	786	24	a	a	DT
38430	786	25	part	part	NN
38430	786	26	of	of	IN
38430	786	27	the	the	DT
38430	786	28	class	class	NN
38430	786	29	B	b	NN
38430	786	30	of	of	IN
38430	786	31	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
38430	786	32	's	's	POS
38430	786	33	acts	act	NNS
38430	786	34	of	of	IN
38430	786	35	crossing	cross	VBG
38430	786	36	the	the	DT
38430	786	37	Court	Court	NNP
38430	786	38	.	.	.
38430	787	1	Thurlow	thurlow	NN
38430	787	2	asserted	assert	VBD
38430	787	3	in	in	IN
38430	787	4	reply	reply	NN
38430	787	5	a	a	DT
38430	787	6	one	one	CD
38430	787	7	-	-	HYPH
38430	787	8	one	one	CD
38430	787	9	correspondence	correspondence	NN
38430	787	10	between	between	IN
38430	787	11	B	b	NN
38430	787	12	and	and	CC
38430	787	13	a	a	DT
38430	787	14	part	part	NN
38430	787	15	of	of	IN
38430	787	16	A	a	NN
38430	787	17	:	:	:
38430	787	18	"	"	``
38430	787	19	Whenever	whenever	WRB
38430	787	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	787	21	cross	cross	VBP
38430	787	22	the	the	DT
38430	787	23	Court	Court	NNP
38430	787	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	787	25	see	see	VBP
38430	787	26	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	787	27	looking	look	VBG
38430	787	28	out	out	IN
38430	787	29	of	of	IN
38430	787	30	the	the	DT
38430	787	31	window	window	NN
38430	787	32	.	.	.
38430	787	33	"	"	''
38430	788	1	The	the	DT
38430	788	2	Schröder	Schröder	NNP
38430	788	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	788	4	Bernstein	Bernstein	NNP
38430	788	5	theorem	theorem	NN
38430	788	6	,	,	,
38430	788	7	then	then	RB
38430	788	8	,	,	,
38430	788	9	allows	allow	VBZ
38430	788	10	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	788	11	to	to	TO
38430	788	12	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	788	13	that	that	IN
38430	788	14	there	there	EX
38430	788	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	788	16	a	a	DT
38430	788	17	one	one	CD
38430	788	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	788	19	one	one	CD
38430	788	20	correspondence	correspondence	NN
38430	788	21	between	between	IN
38430	788	22	the	the	DT
38430	788	23	classes	class	NNS
38430	788	24	A	A	NNP
38430	788	25	and	and	CC
38430	788	26	B.	B.	NNP
38430	789	1	That	that	IN
38430	789	2	A	a	NN
38430	789	3	and	and	CC
38430	789	4	B	b	NN
38430	789	5	were	be	VBD
38430	789	6	finite	finite	JJ
38430	789	7	classes	class	NNS
38430	789	8	is	be	VBZ
38430	789	9	not	not	RB
38430	789	10	the	the	DT
38430	789	11	fault	fault	NN
38430	789	12	of	of	IN
38430	789	13	the	the	DT
38430	789	14	Master	Master	NNP
38430	789	15	or	or	CC
38430	789	16	Thurlow	Thurlow	NNP
38430	789	17	;	;	:
38430	789	18	nor	nor	CC
38430	789	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	789	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	789	21	relevant	relevant	JJ
38430	789	22	logically	logically	RB
38430	789	23	.	.	.
38430	790	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	790	2	XXXIV	xxxiv	NN
38430	790	3	THE	the	DT
38430	790	4	UNKNOWABLE	UNKNOWABLE	NNP
38430	790	5	According	accord	VBG
38430	790	6	to	to	IN
38430	790	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	790	8	S.	S.	NNP
38430	790	9	N.	N.	NNP
38430	790	10	Gupta,[88	Gupta,[88	NNP
38430	790	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	790	12	the	the	DT
38430	790	13	first	first	JJ
38430	790	14	thing	thing	NN
38430	790	15	that	that	WDT
38430	790	16	every	every	DT
38430	790	17	student	student	NN
38430	790	18	of	of	IN
38430	790	19	Hindu	Hindu	NNP
38430	790	20	logic	logic	NN
38430	790	21	has	have	VBZ
38430	790	22	to	to	TO
38430	790	23	learn	learn	VB
38430	790	24	when	when	WRB
38430	790	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	790	26	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	27	said	say	VBN
38430	790	28	to	to	TO
38430	790	29	begin	begin	VB
38430	790	30	the	the	DT
38430	790	31	study	study	NN
38430	790	32	of	of	IN
38430	790	33	inference	inference	NN
38430	790	34	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	35	that	that	IN
38430	790	36	"	"	``
38430	790	37	all	all	DT
38430	790	38	H	h	NN
38430	790	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	40	S	s	NN
38430	790	41	"	"	''
38430	790	42	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	43	not	not	RB
38430	790	44	always	always	RB
38430	790	45	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
38430	790	46	to	to	IN
38430	790	47	"	"	``
38430	790	48	No	no	DT
38430	790	49	H	h	NN
38430	790	50	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	51	not	not	RB
38430	790	52	S.	s.	NN
38430	790	53	"	"	''
38430	790	54	"	"	``
38430	790	55	The	the	DT
38430	790	56	latter	latter	JJ
38430	790	57	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	790	58	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	59	an	an	DT
38430	790	60	absurdity	absurdity	NN
38430	790	61	when	when	WRB
38430	790	62	S	S	NNP
38430	790	63	is	be	VBZ
38430	790	64	_	_	NNP
38430	790	65	Kebalánvayi	Kebalánvayi	NNP
38430	790	66	_	_	NNP
38430	790	67	,	,	,
38430	790	68	i.e.	i.e.	FW
38430	791	1	covers	cover	VBZ
38430	791	2	the	the	DT
38430	791	3	whole	whole	JJ
38430	791	4	sphere	sphere	NN
38430	791	5	of	of	IN
38430	791	6	thought	thought	NN
38430	791	7	and	and	CC
38430	791	8	existence	existence	NN
38430	791	9	....	....	NFP
38430	791	10	'	'	''
38430	791	11	Knowable	knowable	JJ
38430	791	12	'	'	''
38430	791	13	and	and	CC
38430	791	14	'	'	``
38430	791	15	Nameable	nameable	JJ
38430	791	16	'	'	''
38430	791	17	are	be	VBP
38430	791	18	among	among	IN
38430	791	19	the	the	DT
38430	791	20	examples	example	NNS
38430	791	21	of	of	IN
38430	791	22	_	_	NNP
38430	791	23	Kebalánvayi	Kebalánvayi	NNP
38430	791	24	_	_	NNP
38430	791	25	terms	term	NNS
38430	791	26	.	.	.
38430	792	1	If	if	IN
38430	792	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	792	3	say	say	VBP
38430	792	4	there	there	EX
38430	792	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	792	6	a	a	DT
38430	792	7	thing	thing	NN
38430	792	8	not	not	RB
38430	792	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	792	10	knowable	knowable	JJ
38430	792	11	,	,	,
38430	792	12	how	how	WRB
38430	792	13	do	do	VBP
38430	792	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	792	15	know	know	VB
38430	792	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	792	17	?	?	.
38430	793	1	If	if	IN
38430	793	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	793	3	say	say	VBP
38430	793	4	there	there	EX
38430	793	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	793	6	a	a	DT
38430	793	7	thing	thing	NN
38430	793	8	not	not	RB
38430	793	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	793	10	nameable	nameable	JJ
38430	793	11	,	,	,
38430	793	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	793	13	must	must	MD
38430	793	14	point	point	VB
38430	793	15	that	that	DT
38430	793	16	out	out	RP
38430	793	17	,	,	,
38430	793	18	i.e.	i.e.	FW
38430	794	1	somehow	somehow	RB
38430	794	2	name	name	VB
38430	794	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	794	4	.	.	.
38430	795	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	795	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	795	3	contradict	contradict	VBP
38430	795	4	yourself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	795	5	.	.	.
38430	795	6	"	"	''
38430	796	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	796	2	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
38430	796	3	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
38430	796	4	's	's	POS
38430	796	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
38430	796	6	of	of	IN
38430	796	7	the	the	DT
38430	796	8	"	"	``
38430	796	9	Unknowable	Unknowable	NNP
38430	796	10	"	"	''
38430	796	11	gives	give	VBZ
38430	796	12	rise	rise	NN
38430	796	13	to	to	IN
38430	796	14	some	some	DT
38430	796	15	amusing	amusing	JJ
38430	796	16	thoughts	thought	NNS
38430	796	17	.	.	.
38430	797	1	To	to	TO
38430	797	2	state	state	VB
38430	797	3	that	that	IN
38430	797	4	all	all	DT
38430	797	5	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	797	6	of	of	IN
38430	797	7	such	such	JJ
38430	797	8	and	and	CC
38430	797	9	such	such	PDT
38430	797	10	a	a	DT
38430	797	11	thing	thing	NN
38430	797	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	797	13	above	above	IN
38430	797	14	a	a	DT
38430	797	15	certain	certain	JJ
38430	797	16	person	person	NN
38430	797	17	's	's	POS
38430	797	18	intelligence	intelligence	NN
38430	797	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	797	20	not	not	RB
38430	797	21	self	self	NN
38430	797	22	-	-	HYPH
38430	797	23	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
38430	797	24	,	,	,
38430	797	25	but	but	CC
38430	797	26	merely	merely	RB
38430	797	27	rude	rude	JJ
38430	797	28	:	:	:
38430	797	29	to	to	TO
38430	797	30	state	state	VB
38430	797	31	that	that	IN
38430	797	32	all	all	DT
38430	797	33	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	797	34	of	of	IN
38430	797	35	a	a	DT
38430	797	36	certain	certain	JJ
38430	797	37	thing	thing	NN
38430	797	38	is	be	VBZ
38430	797	39	above	above	IN
38430	797	40	all	all	DT
38430	797	41	possible	possible	JJ
38430	797	42	human	human	JJ
38430	797	43	intelligence	intelligence	NN
38430	797	44	is	be	VBZ
38430	797	45	nonsense	nonsense	NN
38430	797	46	,	,	,
38430	797	47	in	in	IN
38430	797	48	spite	spite	NN
38430	797	49	of	of	IN
38430	797	50	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	797	51	modest	modest	JJ
38430	797	52	,	,	,
38430	797	53	platitudinous	platitudinous	JJ
38430	797	54	appearance	appearance	NN
38430	797	55	.	.	.
38430	798	1	For	for	IN
38430	798	2	the	the	DT
38430	798	3	statement	statement	NN
38430	798	4	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	798	5	to	to	TO
38430	798	6	show	show	VB
38430	798	7	that	that	IN
38430	798	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	798	9	do	do	VBP
38430	798	10	know	know	VB
38430	798	11	something	something	NN
38430	798	12	of	of	IN
38430	798	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	798	14	,	,	,
38430	798	15	viz	viz	NN
38430	798	16	.	.	.
38430	799	1	that	that	IN
38430	799	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	799	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	799	4	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
38430	799	5	.	.	.
38430	800	1	To	to	IN
38430	800	2	the	the	DT
38430	800	3	last	last	JJ
38430	800	4	(	(	-LRB-
38430	800	5	1900	1900	CD
38430	800	6	)	)	-RRB-
38430	800	7	edition	edition	NN
38430	800	8	of	of	IN
38430	800	9	_	_	NNP
38430	800	10	First	First	NNP
38430	800	11	Principles	Principles	NNPS
38430	800	12	_	_	NNP
38430	800	13	was	be	VBD
38430	800	14	added	add	VBN
38430	800	15	a	a	DT
38430	800	16	"	"	``
38430	800	17	Postscript	postscript	NN
38430	800	18	to	to	IN
38430	800	19	Part	Part	NNP
38430	800	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	800	21	,	,	,
38430	800	22	"	"	''
38430	800	23	in	in	IN
38430	800	24	which	which	WDT
38430	800	25	the	the	DT
38430	800	26	justice	justice	NN
38430	800	27	of	of	IN
38430	800	28	this	this	DT
38430	800	29	simple	simple	JJ
38430	800	30	and	and	CC
38430	800	31	well	well	RB
38430	800	32	-	-	HYPH
38430	800	33	known	know	VBN
38430	800	34	criticism	criticism	NN
38430	800	35	as	as	IN
38430	800	36	to	to	IN
38430	800	37	the	the	DT
38430	800	38	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	800	39	involved	involve	VBN
38430	800	40	in	in	IN
38430	800	41	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	800	42	of	of	IN
38430	800	43	an	an	DT
38430	800	44	"	"	``
38430	800	45	Unknowable	unknowable	JJ
38430	800	46	,	,	,
38430	800	47	"	"	''
38430	800	48	which	which	WDT
38430	800	49	had	have	VBD
38430	800	50	been	be	VBN
38430	800	51	often	often	RB
38430	800	52	made	make	VBN
38430	800	53	during	during	IN
38430	800	54	the	the	DT
38430	800	55	forty	forty	CD
38430	800	56	odd	odd	JJ
38430	800	57	years	year	NNS
38430	800	58	in	in	IN
38430	800	59	which	which	WDT
38430	800	60	the	the	DT
38430	800	61	various	various	JJ
38430	800	62	editions	edition	NNS
38430	800	63	had	have	VBD
38430	800	64	been	be	VBN
38430	800	65	on	on	IN
38430	800	66	the	the	DT
38430	800	67	market	market	NN
38430	800	68	,	,	,
38430	800	69	was	be	VBD
38430	800	70	grudgingly	grudgingly	RB
38430	800	71	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
38430	800	72	as	as	IN
38430	800	73	follows:[89	follows:[89	NNP
38430	800	74	]	]	-RRB-
38430	800	75	"	"	``
38430	800	76	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	800	77	is	be	VBZ
38430	800	78	doubtless	doubtless	RB
38430	800	79	true	true	JJ
38430	800	80	that	that	IN
38430	800	81	saying	say	VBG
38430	800	82	what	what	WP
38430	800	83	a	a	DT
38430	800	84	thing	thing	NN
38430	800	85	is	be	VBZ
38430	800	86	not	not	RB
38430	800	87	,	,	,
38430	800	88	is	be	VBZ
38430	800	89	,	,	,
38430	800	90	in	in	IN
38430	800	91	some	some	DT
38430	800	92	measure	measure	NN
38430	800	93	,	,	,
38430	800	94	saying	say	VBG
38430	800	95	what	what	WP
38430	800	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	800	97	is	be	VBZ
38430	800	98	;	;	:
38430	800	99	...	...	.
38430	801	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	801	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	801	3	can	can	MD
38430	801	4	not	not	RB
38430	801	5	be	be	VB
38430	801	6	denied	deny	VBN
38430	801	7	that	that	IN
38430	801	8	to	to	TO
38430	801	9	affirm	affirm	VB
38430	801	10	of	of	IN
38430	801	11	the	the	DT
38430	801	12	Ultimate	Ultimate	NNP
38430	801	13	Reality	Reality	NNP
38430	801	14	that	that	IN
38430	801	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	801	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	801	17	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
38430	801	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	801	19	,	,	,
38430	801	20	in	in	IN
38430	801	21	a	a	DT
38430	801	22	remote	remote	JJ
38430	801	23	way	way	NN
38430	801	24	,	,	,
38430	801	25	to	to	TO
38430	801	26	assert	assert	VB
38430	801	27	some	some	DT
38430	801	28	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	801	29	of	of	IN
38430	801	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	801	31	,	,	,
38430	801	32	and	and	CC
38430	801	33	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	801	34	involves	involve	VBZ
38430	801	35	a	a	DT
38430	801	36	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	801	37	.	.	.
38430	801	38	"	"	''
38430	802	1	The	the	DT
38430	802	2	"	"	``
38430	802	3	Postscript	Postscript	NNP
38430	802	4	"	"	''
38430	802	5	reminds	remind	VBZ
38430	802	6	one	one	CD
38430	802	7	of	of	IN
38430	802	8	the	the	DT
38430	802	9	postscript	postscript	NN
38430	802	10	to	to	IN
38430	802	11	a	a	DT
38430	802	12	certain	certain	JJ
38430	802	13	Irishman	Irishman	NNP
38430	802	14	's	's	POS
38430	802	15	letter	letter	NN
38430	802	16	.	.	.
38430	803	1	This	this	DT
38430	803	2	Irishman	Irishman	NNP
38430	803	3	,	,	,
38430	803	4	missing	miss	VBG
38430	803	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	803	6	razors	razor	NNS
38430	803	7	after	after	IN
38430	803	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	803	9	return	return	NN
38430	803	10	from	from	IN
38430	803	11	a	a	DT
38430	803	12	visit	visit	NN
38430	803	13	to	to	IN
38430	803	14	a	a	DT
38430	803	15	friend	friend	NN
38430	803	16	,	,	,
38430	803	17	wrote	write	VBD
38430	803	18	to	to	IN
38430	803	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	803	20	friend	friend	NN
38430	803	21	,	,	,
38430	803	22	giving	give	VBG
38430	803	23	precise	precise	JJ
38430	803	24	directions	direction	NNS
38430	803	25	where	where	WRB
38430	803	26	to	to	TO
38430	803	27	look	look	VB
38430	803	28	for	for	IN
38430	803	29	the	the	DT
38430	803	30	missing	miss	VBG
38430	803	31	razors	razor	NNS
38430	803	32	;	;	:
38430	803	33	but	but	CC
38430	803	34	,	,	,
38430	803	35	before	before	IN
38430	803	36	posting	post	VBG
38430	803	37	the	the	DT
38430	803	38	letter	letter	NN
38430	803	39	,	,	,
38430	803	40	added	add	VBD
38430	803	41	a	a	DT
38430	803	42	postscript	postscript	NN
38430	803	43	to	to	IN
38430	803	44	the	the	DT
38430	803	45	effect	effect	NN
38430	803	46	that	that	WDT
38430	803	47	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	803	48	had	have	VBD
38430	803	49	found	find	VBN
38430	803	50	the	the	DT
38430	803	51	razors	razor	NNS
38430	803	52	.	.	.
38430	804	1	One	one	CD
38430	804	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	804	3	tempted	tempt	VBN
38430	804	4	to	to	TO
38430	804	5	inquire	inquire	VB
38430	804	6	,	,	,
38430	804	7	analogously	analogously	RB
38430	804	8	,	,	,
38430	804	9	what	what	WP
38430	804	10	might	may	MD
38430	804	11	be	be	VB
38430	804	12	,	,	,
38430	804	13	in	in	IN
38430	804	14	view	view	NN
38430	804	15	of	of	IN
38430	804	16	the	the	DT
38430	804	17	Postscript	Postscript	NNP
38430	804	18	,	,	,
38430	804	19	the	the	DT
38430	804	20	point	point	NN
38430	804	21	of	of	IN
38430	804	22	much	much	JJ
38430	804	23	of	of	IN
38430	804	24	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
38430	804	25	's	's	POS
38430	804	26	Part	Part	NNP
38430	804	27	I.	i.	NN
38430	805	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	805	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	805	3	,	,	,
38430	805	4	to	to	TO
38430	805	5	use	use	VB
38430	805	6	De	De	NNP
38430	805	7	Morgan's[90	Morgan's[90	NNP
38430	805	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	805	9	description	description	NN
38430	805	10	of	of	IN
38430	805	11	the	the	DT
38430	805	12	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	805	13	of	of	IN
38430	805	14	some	some	DT
38430	805	15	who	who	WP
38430	805	16	maintain	maintain	VBP
38430	805	17	that	that	IN
38430	805	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	805	19	can	can	MD
38430	805	20	know	know	VB
38430	805	21	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	805	22	about	about	IN
38430	805	23	infinity	infinity	NN
38430	805	24	,	,	,
38430	805	25	of	of	IN
38430	805	26	the	the	DT
38430	805	27	same	same	JJ
38430	805	28	force	force	NN
38430	805	29	as	as	IN
38430	805	30	that	that	DT
38430	805	31	of	of	IN
38430	805	32	the	the	DT
38430	805	33	man	man	NN
38430	805	34	who	who	WP
38430	805	35	answered	answer	VBD
38430	805	36	the	the	DT
38430	805	37	question	question	NN
38430	805	38	how	how	WRB
38430	805	39	long	long	RB
38430	805	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	805	41	had	have	VBD
38430	805	42	been	be	VBN
38430	805	43	deaf	deaf	JJ
38430	805	44	and	and	CC
38430	805	45	dumb	dumb	JJ
38430	805	46	.	.	.
38430	806	1	But	but	CC
38430	806	2	the	the	DT
38430	806	3	best	good	JJS
38430	806	4	part	part	NN
38430	806	5	of	of	IN
38430	806	6	the	the	DT
38430	806	7	joke	joke	NN
38430	806	8	against	against	IN
38430	806	9	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	806	10	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
38430	806	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	806	12	that	that	IN
38430	806	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	806	14	,	,	,
38430	806	15	as	as	IN
38430	806	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	806	17	shall	shall	MD
38430	806	18	see	see	VB
38430	806	19	in	in	IN
38430	806	20	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	806	21	XXXVIII	xxxviii	NN
38430	806	22	,	,	,
38430	806	23	was	be	VBD
38430	806	24	refuted	refute	VBN
38430	806	25	by	by	IN
38430	806	26	a	a	DT
38430	806	27	fallacious	fallacious	JJ
38430	806	28	argument	argument	NN
38430	806	29	,	,	,
38430	806	30	and	and	CC
38430	806	31	thus	thus	RB
38430	806	32	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
38430	806	33	asserted	assert	VBD
38430	806	34	the	the	DT
38430	806	35	validity	validity	NN
38430	806	36	of	of	IN
38430	806	37	the	the	DT
38430	806	38	refutation	refutation	NN
38430	806	39	of	of	IN
38430	806	40	remarks	remark	NNS
38430	806	41	which	which	WDT
38430	806	42	happen	happen	VBP
38430	806	43	to	to	TO
38430	806	44	be	be	VB
38430	806	45	unsound	unsound	JJ
38430	806	46	.	.	.
38430	807	1	The	the	DT
38430	807	2	analogy	analogy	NN
38430	807	3	of	of	IN
38430	807	4	the	the	DT
38430	807	5	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	807	6	of	of	IN
38430	807	7	Burali	Burali	NNP
38430	807	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	807	9	Forti	Forti	NNP
38430	807	10	with	with	IN
38430	807	11	the	the	DT
38430	807	12	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	807	13	involved	involve	VBN
38430	807	14	in	in	IN
38430	807	15	the	the	DT
38430	807	16	notion	notion	NN
38430	807	17	of	of	IN
38430	807	18	an	an	DT
38430	807	19	"	"	``
38430	807	20	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
38430	807	21	"	"	''
38430	807	22	may	may	MD
38430	807	23	be	be	VB
38430	807	24	set	set	VBN
38430	807	25	forth	forth	RP
38430	807	26	as	as	IN
38430	807	27	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	807	28	.	.	.
38430	808	1	If	if	IN
38430	808	2	A	a	DT
38430	808	3	should	should	MD
38430	808	4	say	say	VB
38430	808	5	to	to	IN
38430	808	6	B	b	NN
38430	808	7	:	:	:
38430	808	8	"	"	``
38430	808	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	808	10	know	know	VBP
38430	808	11	things	thing	NNS
38430	808	12	which	which	WDT
38430	808	13	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	808	14	never	never	RB
38430	808	15	by	by	IN
38430	808	16	any	any	DT
38430	808	17	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	808	18	can	can	MD
38430	808	19	know	know	VB
38430	808	20	,	,	,
38430	808	21	"	"	''
38430	808	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	808	23	may	may	MD
38430	808	24	be	be	VB
38430	808	25	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	808	26	the	the	DT
38430	808	27	truth	truth	NN
38430	808	28	.	.	.
38430	809	1	In	in	IN
38430	809	2	the	the	DT
38430	809	3	same	same	JJ
38430	809	4	way	way	NN
38430	809	5	,	,	,
38430	809	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	809	7	Greek	greek	NN
38430	809	8	:	:	:
38430	809	9	ô	ô	LS
38430	809	10	]	]	-RRB-
38430	809	11	may	may	MD
38430	809	12	be	be	VB
38430	809	13	said	say	VBN
38430	809	14	,	,	,
38430	809	15	without	without	IN
38430	809	16	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	809	17	,	,	,
38430	809	18	to	to	TO
38430	809	19	transcend	transcend	VB
38430	809	20	all	all	PDT
38430	809	21	the	the	DT
38430	809	22	_	_	NNP
38430	809	23	finite	finite	NN
38430	809	24	_	_	NNP
38430	809	25	integers	integer	NNS
38430	809	26	.	.	.
38430	810	1	But	but	CC
38430	810	2	if	if	IN
38430	810	3	some	some	DT
38430	810	4	one	one	NN
38430	810	5	else	else	RB
38430	810	6	,	,	,
38430	810	7	C	C	NNP
38430	810	8	,	,	,
38430	810	9	should	should	MD
38430	810	10	say	say	VB
38430	810	11	:	:	:
38430	810	12	"	"	``
38430	810	13	There	there	EX
38430	810	14	are	be	VBP
38430	810	15	some	some	DT
38430	810	16	things	thing	NNS
38430	810	17	which	which	WDT
38430	810	18	no	no	DT
38430	810	19	human	human	NN
38430	810	20	being	being	NN
38430	810	21	can	can	MD
38430	810	22	ever	ever	RB
38430	810	23	know	know	VB
38430	810	24	anything	anything	NN
38430	810	25	about	about	IN
38430	810	26	,	,	,
38430	810	27	"	"	''
38430	810	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	810	29	is	be	VBZ
38430	810	30	talking	talk	VBG
38430	810	31	nonsense	nonsense	NN
38430	810	32	.	.	.
38430	811	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	811	2	91	91	CD
38430	811	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	811	4	And	and	CC
38430	811	5	in	in	IN
38430	811	6	the	the	DT
38430	811	7	same	same	JJ
38430	811	8	way	way	NN
38430	811	9	if	if	IN
38430	811	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	811	11	succeeded	succeed	VBD
38430	811	12	in	in	IN
38430	811	13	imagining	imagine	VBG
38430	811	14	a	a	DT
38430	811	15	number	number	NN
38430	811	16	which	which	WDT
38430	811	17	transcends	transcend	VBZ
38430	811	18	_	_	NNP
38430	811	19	all	all	DT
38430	811	20	_	_	NNP
38430	811	21	numbers	number	NNS
38430	811	22	,	,	,
38430	811	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	811	24	have	have	VBP
38430	811	25	succeeded	succeed	VBN
38430	811	26	in	in	IN
38430	811	27	imagining	imagine	VBG
38430	811	28	the	the	DT
38430	811	29	absurdity	absurdity	NN
38430	811	30	of	of	IN
38430	811	31	a	a	DT
38430	811	32	number	number	NN
38430	811	33	which	which	WDT
38430	811	34	transcends	transcend	VBZ
38430	811	35	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	811	36	.	.	.
38430	812	1	All	all	PDT
38430	812	2	the	the	DT
38430	812	3	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	812	4	of	of	IN
38430	812	5	logic	logic	NN
38430	812	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	812	7	or	or	CC
38430	812	8	"	"	``
38430	812	9	the	the	DT
38430	812	10	theory	theory	NN
38430	812	11	of	of	IN
38430	812	12	aggregates	aggregate	NNS
38430	812	13	"	"	''
38430	812	14	)	)	-RRB-
38430	812	15	are	be	VBP
38430	812	16	analogous	analogous	JJ
38430	812	17	to	to	IN
38430	812	18	the	the	DT
38430	812	19	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	812	20	arising	arise	VBG
38430	812	21	from	from	IN
38430	812	22	a	a	DT
38430	812	23	man	man	NN
38430	812	24	's	's	POS
38430	812	25	statement	statement	NN
38430	812	26	:	:	:
38430	812	27	"	"	``
38430	812	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	812	29	am	be	VBP
38430	812	30	lying	lie	VBG
38430	812	31	.	.	.
38430	813	1	"	"	``
38430	813	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	813	3	92	92	CD
38430	813	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	813	5	In	in	IN
38430	813	6	fact	fact	NN
38430	813	7	,	,	,
38430	813	8	if	if	IN
38430	813	9	this	this	DT
38430	813	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	813	11	true	true	JJ
38430	813	12	,	,	,
38430	813	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	813	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	813	15	false	false	JJ
38430	813	16	,	,	,
38430	813	17	and	and	CC
38430	813	18	_	_	NNP
38430	813	19	vice	vice	NN
38430	813	20	versa	versa	NNP
38430	813	21	_	_	NNP
38430	813	22	.	.	.
38430	814	1	If	if	IN
38430	814	2	such	such	PDT
38430	814	3	a	a	DT
38430	814	4	statement	statement	NN
38430	814	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	814	6	spread	spread	VBN
38430	814	7	out	out	RP
38430	814	8	a	a	DT
38430	814	9	little	little	JJ
38430	814	10	,	,	,
38430	814	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	814	12	becomes	become	VBZ
38430	814	13	an	an	DT
38430	814	14	amusing	amusing	JJ
38430	814	15	hoax	hoax	NN
38430	814	16	or	or	CC
38430	814	17	an	an	DT
38430	814	18	epigram	epigram	NN
38430	814	19	.	.	.
38430	815	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	815	2	,	,	,
38430	815	3	one	one	PRP
38430	815	4	may	may	MD
38430	815	5	present	present	VB
38430	815	6	to	to	IN
38430	815	7	a	a	DT
38430	815	8	friend	friend	NN
38430	815	9	a	a	DT
38430	815	10	card	card	NN
38430	815	11	bearing	bear	VBG
38430	815	12	on	on	IN
38430	815	13	both	both	DT
38430	815	14	sides	side	NNS
38430	815	15	the	the	DT
38430	815	16	words	word	NNS
38430	815	17	:	:	:
38430	815	18	"	"	``
38430	815	19	The	the	DT
38430	815	20	statement	statement	NN
38430	815	21	on	on	IN
38430	815	22	the	the	DT
38430	815	23	other	other	JJ
38430	815	24	side	side	NN
38430	815	25	of	of	IN
38430	815	26	this	this	DT
38430	815	27	card	card	NN
38430	815	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	815	29	false	false	JJ
38430	815	30	"	"	''
38430	815	31	;	;	:
38430	815	32	while	while	IN
38430	815	33	the	the	DT
38430	815	34	first	first	JJ
38430	815	35	of	of	IN
38430	815	36	the	the	DT
38430	815	37	epigrams	epigram	NNS
38430	815	38	derived	derive	VBN
38430	815	39	from	from	IN
38430	815	40	this	this	DT
38430	815	41	principle	principle	NN
38430	815	42	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	815	43	to	to	TO
38430	815	44	have	have	VB
38430	815	45	been	be	VBN
38430	815	46	written	write	VBN
38430	815	47	by	by	IN
38430	815	48	a	a	DT
38430	815	49	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	815	50	satirist:[93	satirist:[93	NN
38430	815	51	]	]	-RRB-
38430	815	52	Lerians	Lerians	NNPS
38430	815	53	are	be	VBP
38430	815	54	bad	bad	JJ
38430	815	55	;	;	:
38430	815	56	not	not	RB
38430	815	57	_	_	NNP
38430	815	58	some	some	DT
38430	815	59	_	_	NNP
38430	815	60	bad	bad	JJ
38430	815	61	and	and	CC
38430	815	62	some	some	DT
38430	815	63	_	_	NNP
38430	815	64	not	not	RB
38430	815	65	_	_	NNP
38430	815	66	;	;	:
38430	815	67	But	but	CC
38430	815	68	all	all	DT
38430	815	69	;	;	:
38430	815	70	there	there	EX
38430	815	71	's	be	VBZ
38430	815	72	not	not	RB
38430	815	73	a	a	DT
38430	815	74	Lerian	Lerian	NNP
38430	815	75	in	in	IN
38430	815	76	the	the	DT
38430	815	77	lot	lot	NN
38430	815	78	,	,	,
38430	815	79	Save	Save	NNP
38430	815	80	Procles	Procles	NNPS
38430	815	81	,	,	,
38430	815	82	that	that	IN
38430	815	83	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	815	84	could	could	MD
38430	815	85	a	a	DT
38430	815	86	good	good	JJ
38430	815	87	man	man	NN
38430	815	88	call;--	call;--	NNS
38430	815	89	And	and	CC
38430	815	90	Procles	Procles	NNPS
38430	815	91	--	--	:
38430	815	92	is	be	VBZ
38430	815	93	a	a	DT
38430	815	94	Lerian	Lerian	NNP
38430	815	95	after	after	RB
38430	815	96	all	all	RB
38430	815	97	.	.	.
38430	816	1	This	this	DT
38430	816	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	816	3	the	the	DT
38430	816	4	original	original	NN
38430	816	5	of	of	IN
38430	816	6	a	a	DT
38430	816	7	well	well	RB
38430	816	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	816	9	known	know	VBN
38430	816	10	epigram	epigram	NN
38430	816	11	by	by	IN
38430	816	12	Porson	Porson	NNP
38430	816	13	,	,	,
38430	816	14	who	who	WP
38430	816	15	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	816	16	that	that	IN
38430	816	17	all	all	DT
38430	816	18	Germans	Germans	NNPS
38430	816	19	are	be	VBP
38430	816	20	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
38430	816	21	of	of	IN
38430	816	22	Greek	greek	JJ
38430	816	23	metres	metre	NNS
38430	816	24	,	,	,
38430	816	25	All	all	RB
38430	816	26	,	,	,
38430	816	27	save	save	VB
38430	816	28	only	only	JJ
38430	816	29	Hermann;--	hermann;--	NN
38430	816	30	And	and	CC
38430	816	31	Hermann	Hermann	NNP
38430	816	32	's	's	POS
38430	816	33	a	a	DT
38430	816	34	German	German	NNP
38430	816	35	.	.	.
38430	817	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	817	2	:	:	:
38430	817	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	817	4	88	88	CD
38430	817	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	817	6	_	_	NNP
38430	817	7	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	817	8	_	_	NNP
38430	817	9	,	,	,
38430	817	10	N.	N.	NNP
38430	817	11	S.	S.	NNP
38430	817	12	,	,	,
38430	817	13	vol	vol	NNP
38430	817	14	.	.	.
38430	818	1	iv	iv	NNP
38430	818	2	.	.	NNP
38430	818	3	,	,	,
38430	818	4	1895	1895	CD
38430	818	5	,	,	,
38430	818	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	818	7	168	168	CD
38430	818	8	.	.	.
38430	819	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	819	2	89	89	CD
38430	819	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	819	4	_	_	NNP
38430	819	5	First	First	NNP
38430	819	6	Principles	Principles	NNPS
38430	819	7	_	_	NNP
38430	819	8	,	,	,
38430	819	9	6th	6th	JJ
38430	819	10	ed	ed	NNP
38430	819	11	.	.	NNP
38430	819	12	,	,	,
38430	819	13	1900	1900	CD
38430	819	14	,	,	,
38430	819	15	pp	pp	NNP
38430	819	16	.	.	.
38430	820	1	107	107	CD
38430	820	2	-	-	SYM
38430	820	3	10	10	CD
38430	820	4	.	.	.
38430	821	1	The	the	DT
38430	821	2	first	first	JJ
38430	821	3	edition	edition	NN
38430	821	4	was	be	VBD
38430	821	5	published	publish	VBN
38430	821	6	in	in	IN
38430	821	7	1862	1862	CD
38430	821	8	.	.	.
38430	822	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	822	2	90	90	CD
38430	822	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	822	4	Note	note	VB
38430	822	5	on	on	IN
38430	822	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	822	7	6	6	CD
38430	822	8	of	of	IN
38430	822	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	822	10	paper	paper	NN
38430	822	11	:	:	:
38430	822	12	"	"	``
38430	822	13	On	on	IN
38430	822	14	Infinity	Infinity	NNP
38430	822	15	;	;	:
38430	822	16	and	and	CC
38430	822	17	on	on	IN
38430	822	18	the	the	DT
38430	822	19	Sign	Sign	NNP
38430	822	20	of	of	IN
38430	822	21	Equality	equality	NN
38430	822	22	,	,	,
38430	822	23	"	"	''
38430	822	24	_	_	NNP
38430	822	25	Trans	Trans	NNP
38430	822	26	.	.	.
38430	823	1	Camb	camb	NN
38430	823	2	.	.	.
38430	824	1	Phil	Phil	NNP
38430	824	2	.	.	.
38430	825	1	Soc	Soc	NNP
38430	825	2	.	.	.
38430	825	3	_	_	NNP
38430	825	4	,	,	,
38430	825	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	825	6	.	.	.
38430	826	1	xi	xi	NNP
38430	826	2	.	.	NNP
38430	826	3	,	,	,
38430	826	4	part	part	NNP
38430	826	5	i.	i.	NNP
38430	826	6	,	,	,
38430	826	7	pp	pp	NNP
38430	826	8	.	.	.
38430	827	1	1	1	CD
38430	827	2	-	-	SYM
38430	827	3	45	45	CD
38430	827	4	(	(	-LRB-
38430	827	5	read	read	VBN
38430	827	6	May	May	NNP
38430	827	7	16	16	CD
38430	827	8	,	,	,
38430	827	9	1864	1864	CD
38430	827	10	)	)	-RRB-
38430	827	11	.	.	.
38430	828	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	828	2	91	91	CD
38430	828	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	828	4	The	the	DT
38430	828	5	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	828	6	of	of	IN
38430	828	7	the	the	DT
38430	828	8	finitude	finitude	NN
38430	828	9	of	of	IN
38430	828	10	a	a	DT
38430	828	11	man	man	NN
38430	828	12	's	's	POS
38430	828	13	mind	mind	NN
38430	828	14	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	828	15	to	to	TO
38430	828	16	be	be	VB
38430	828	17	nonsense	nonsense	NN
38430	828	18	;	;	:
38430	828	19	both	both	DT
38430	828	20	because	because	IN
38430	828	21	,	,	,
38430	828	22	if	if	IN
38430	828	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	828	24	say	say	VBP
38430	828	25	that	that	IN
38430	828	26	the	the	DT
38430	828	27	mind	mind	NN
38430	828	28	of	of	IN
38430	828	29	man	man	NN
38430	828	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	828	31	limited	limit	VBN
38430	828	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	828	33	tacitly	tacitly	RB
38430	828	34	postulate	postulate	VBP
38430	828	35	an	an	DT
38430	828	36	"	"	``
38430	828	37	unknowable	unknowable	JJ
38430	828	38	,	,	,
38430	828	39	"	"	''
38430	828	40	and	and	CC
38430	828	41	because	because	IN
38430	828	42	,	,	,
38430	828	43	even	even	RB
38430	828	44	if	if	IN
38430	828	45	the	the	DT
38430	828	46	human	human	JJ
38430	828	47	mind	mind	NN
38430	828	48	were	be	VBD
38430	828	49	finite	finite	JJ
38430	828	50	,	,	,
38430	828	51	there	there	EX
38430	828	52	is	be	VBZ
38430	828	53	no	no	DT
38430	828	54	more	more	JJR
38430	828	55	reason	reason	NN
38430	828	56	against	against	IN
38430	828	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	828	58	conceiving	conceiving	NN
38430	828	59	the	the	DT
38430	828	60	infinite	infinite	NN
38430	828	61	than	than	IN
38430	828	62	there	there	EX
38430	828	63	is	be	VBZ
38430	828	64	for	for	IN
38430	828	65	a	a	DT
38430	828	66	mind	mind	NN
38430	828	67	to	to	TO
38430	828	68	be	be	VB
38430	828	69	blue	blue	JJ
38430	828	70	in	in	IN
38430	828	71	order	order	NN
38430	828	72	to	to	TO
38430	828	73	conceive	conceive	VB
38430	828	74	a	a	DT
38430	828	75	pair	pair	NN
38430	828	76	of	of	IN
38430	828	77	blue	blue	JJ
38430	828	78	eyes	eye	NNS
38430	828	79	(	(	-LRB-
38430	828	80	cf	cf	NN
38430	828	81	.	.	.
38430	829	1	De	De	NNP
38430	829	2	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
38430	829	3	,	,	,
38430	829	4	_	_	NNP
38430	829	5	loc	loc	NNP
38430	829	6	.	.	.
38430	830	1	cit	cit	NNP
38430	830	2	.	.	.
38430	830	3	_	_	NNP
38430	830	4	)	)	-RRB-
38430	830	5	.	.	.
38430	831	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	831	2	92	92	CD
38430	831	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	831	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	831	5	,	,	,
38430	831	6	_	_	NNP
38430	831	7	R.	R.	NNP
38430	832	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	832	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	832	3	_	_	NNP
38430	832	4	,	,	,
38430	832	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	832	6	.	.	.
38430	833	1	xiv	xiv	NNP
38430	833	2	.	.	NNP
38430	833	3	,	,	,
38430	833	4	September	September	NNP
38430	833	5	1906	1906	CD
38430	833	6	,	,	,
38430	833	7	pp	pp	NNP
38430	833	8	.	.	.
38430	834	1	632	632	CD
38430	834	2	-	-	SYM
38430	834	3	3	3	CD
38430	834	4	,	,	,
38430	834	5	640	640	CD
38430	834	6	-	-	SYM
38430	834	7	4	4	CD
38430	834	8	.	.	.
38430	835	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	835	2	93	93	CD
38430	835	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	835	4	_	_	NNP
38430	835	5	The	the	DT
38430	835	6	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	835	7	Anthology	Anthology	NNP
38430	835	8	_	_	NNP
38430	835	9	,	,	,
38430	835	10	by	by	IN
38430	835	11	Lord	Lord	NNP
38430	835	12	Neaves	Neaves	NNPS
38430	835	13	(	(	-LRB-
38430	835	14	Ancient	Ancient	NNP
38430	835	15	Classics	Classics	NNPS
38430	835	16	for	for	IN
38430	835	17	English	English	NNP
38430	835	18	Readers	Readers	NNPS
38430	835	19	)	)	-RRB-
38430	835	20	,	,	,
38430	835	21	Edinburgh	Edinburgh	NNP
38430	835	22	and	and	CC
38430	835	23	London	London	NNP
38430	835	24	,	,	,
38430	835	25	1897	1897	CD
38430	835	26	,	,	,
38430	835	27	p.	p.	NN
38430	835	28	194	194	CD
38430	835	29	.	.	.
38430	836	1	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	836	2	XXXV	XXXV	NNP
38430	836	3	MR	MR	NNP
38430	836	4	.	.	.
38430	836	5	SPENCER	SPENCER	NNP
38430	836	6	,	,	,
38430	836	7	THE	the	DT
38430	836	8	ATHANASIAN	ATHANASIAN	NNP
38430	836	9	CREED	CREED	NNP
38430	836	10	AND	and	CC
38430	836	11	THE	the	DT
38430	836	12	ARTICLES	ARTICLES	NNP
38430	836	13	When	when	WRB
38430	836	14	,	,	,
38430	836	15	in	in	IN
38430	836	16	what	what	WP
38430	836	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	836	18	believe	believe	VBP
38430	836	19	is	be	VBZ
38430	836	20	misleadingly	misleadingly	RB
38430	836	21	known	know	VBN
38430	836	22	as	as	IN
38430	836	23	"	"	``
38430	836	24	The	the	DT
38430	836	25	Athanasian	Athanasian	NNP
38430	836	26	Creed	Creed	NNP
38430	836	27	,	,	,
38430	836	28	"	"	``
38430	836	29	people	people	NNS
38430	836	30	say	say	VBP
38430	836	31	"	"	``
38430	836	32	The	the	DT
38430	836	33	Father	Father	NNP
38430	836	34	incomprehensible	incomprehensible	NN
38430	836	35	,	,	,
38430	836	36	"	"	''
38430	836	37	and	and	CC
38430	836	38	so	so	RB
38430	836	39	on	on	RB
38430	836	40	,	,	,
38430	836	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	836	42	are	be	VBP
38430	836	43	not	not	RB
38430	836	44	falling	fall	VBG
38430	836	45	into	into	IN
38430	836	46	the	the	DT
38430	836	47	same	same	JJ
38430	836	48	error	error	NN
38430	836	49	as	as	IN
38430	836	50	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	836	51	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
38430	836	52	,	,	,
38430	836	53	for	for	IN
38430	836	54	the	the	DT
38430	836	55	Latin	Latin	NNP
38430	836	56	equivalent	equivalent	NN
38430	836	57	for	for	IN
38430	836	58	"	"	``
38430	836	59	incomprehensible	incomprehensible	JJ
38430	836	60	"	"	''
38430	836	61	is	be	VBZ
38430	836	62	merely	merely	RB
38430	836	63	"	"	``
38430	836	64	_	_	NNP
38430	836	65	immensus	immensus	NN
38430	836	66	_	_	NNP
38430	836	67	,	,	,
38430	836	68	"	"	''
38430	836	69	and	and	CC
38430	836	70	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
38430	836	71	Hilsey	Hilsey	NNP
38430	836	72	translated	translate	VBD
38430	836	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	836	74	more	more	RBR
38430	836	75	correctly	correctly	RB
38430	836	76	as	as	IN
38430	836	77	"	"	``
38430	836	78	immeasurable	immeasurable	JJ
38430	836	79	.	.	.
38430	837	1	"	"	``
38430	837	2	[	[	-LRB-
38430	837	3	94	94	CD
38430	837	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	837	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	837	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	837	7	a	a	DT
38430	837	8	regrettable	regrettable	JJ
38430	837	9	fact	fact	NN
38430	837	10	that	that	IN
38430	837	11	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	837	12	Blunt,[95	Blunt,[95	NNP
38430	837	13	]	]	-RRB-
38430	837	14	in	in	IN
38430	837	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	837	16	mistaken	mistaken	JJ
38430	837	17	modesty	modesty	NN
38430	837	18	,	,	,
38430	837	19	has	have	VBZ
38430	837	20	added	add	VBN
38430	837	21	a	a	DT
38430	837	22	note	note	NN
38430	837	23	to	to	IN
38430	837	24	this	this	DT
38430	837	25	passage	passage	NN
38430	837	26	that	that	DT
38430	837	27	:	:	:
38430	837	28	"	"	``
38430	837	29	Yet	yet	CC
38430	837	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	837	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	837	32	true	true	JJ
38430	837	33	that	that	IN
38430	837	34	a	a	DT
38430	837	35	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	837	36	not	not	RB
38430	837	37	intended	intend	VBN
38430	837	38	in	in	IN
38430	837	39	the	the	DT
38430	837	40	Creed	Creed	NNP
38430	837	41	has	have	VBZ
38430	837	42	developed	develop	VBN
38430	837	43	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	837	44	through	through	IN
38430	837	45	this	this	DT
38430	837	46	change	change	NN
38430	837	47	of	of	IN
38430	837	48	language	language	NN
38430	837	49	,	,	,
38430	837	50	for	for	IN
38430	837	51	the	the	DT
38430	837	52	Nature	Nature	NNP
38430	837	53	of	of	IN
38430	837	54	God	God	NNP
38430	837	55	is	be	VBZ
38430	837	56	as	as	RB
38430	837	57	far	far	RB
38430	837	58	beyond	beyond	IN
38430	837	59	the	the	DT
38430	837	60	grasp	grasp	NN
38430	837	61	of	of	IN
38430	837	62	the	the	DT
38430	837	63	mind	mind	NN
38430	837	64	as	as	IN
38430	837	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	837	66	is	be	VBZ
38430	837	67	beyond	beyond	IN
38430	837	68	the	the	DT
38430	837	69	possibility	possibility	NN
38430	837	70	of	of	IN
38430	837	71	being	be	VBG
38430	837	72	contained	contain	VBN
38430	837	73	within	within	IN
38430	837	74	local	local	JJ
38430	837	75	bounds	bound	NNS
38430	837	76	.	.	.
38430	837	77	"	"	''
38430	838	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	838	2	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
38430	838	3	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	838	4	no	no	RB
38430	838	5	happier	happy	JJR
38430	838	6	when	when	WRB
38430	838	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	838	8	compare	compare	VBP
38430	838	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	838	10	statements	statement	NNS
38430	838	11	with	with	IN
38430	838	12	those	those	DT
38430	838	13	in	in	IN
38430	838	14	the	the	DT
38430	838	15	Anglican	anglican	JJ
38430	838	16	Articles	Articles	NNPS
38430	838	17	of	of	IN
38430	838	18	Religion	religion	NN
38430	838	19	.	.	.
38430	839	1	There	there	EX
38430	839	2	God	God	NNP
38430	839	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	839	4	never	never	RB
38430	839	5	referred	refer	VBN
38430	839	6	to	to	IN
38430	839	7	as	as	RB
38430	839	8	infinite	infinite	JJ
38430	839	9	.	.	.
38430	840	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	840	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	840	3	true	true	JJ
38430	840	4	that	that	IN
38430	840	5	His	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	840	6	power	power	NN
38430	840	7	and	and	CC
38430	840	8	goodness	goodness	NN
38430	840	9	are	be	VBP
38430	840	10	so	so	RB
38430	840	11	referred	refer	VBN
38430	840	12	to	to	IN
38430	840	13	;	;	:
38430	840	14	but	but	CC
38430	840	15	this	this	DT
38430	840	16	deficiency	deficiency	NN
38430	840	17	was	be	VBD
38430	840	18	presumably	presumably	RB
38430	840	19	brought	bring	VBN
38430	840	20	about	about	RP
38430	840	21	intentionally	intentionally	RB
38430	840	22	,	,	,
38430	840	23	so	so	IN
38430	840	24	that	that	DT
38430	840	25	faith	faith	NN
38430	840	26	might	may	MD
38430	840	27	gain	gain	VB
38430	840	28	in	in	IN
38430	840	29	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	840	30	as	as	IN
38430	840	31	time	time	NN
38430	840	32	went	go	VBD
38430	840	33	on	on	RP
38430	840	34	.	.	.
38430	841	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	841	2	:	:	:
38430	841	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	841	4	94	94	CD
38430	841	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	841	6	_	_	NNP
38430	841	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	842	1	C.	C.	NNP
38430	842	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	842	3	_	_	NNP
38430	842	4	,	,	,
38430	842	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	842	6	217	217	CD
38430	842	7	.	.	.
38430	843	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	843	2	95	95	CD
38430	843	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	843	4	_	_	NNP
38430	843	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	843	6	.	.	.
38430	843	7	_	_	NNP
38430	843	8	,	,	,
38430	843	9	p.	p.	NN
38430	843	10	218	218	CD
38430	843	11	.	.	.
38430	844	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	844	2	XXXVI	xxxvi	NN
38430	844	3	THE	the	DT
38430	844	4	HUMOUR	humour	NN
38430	844	5	OF	of	IN
38430	844	6	MATHEMATICIANS	MATHEMATICIANS	NNP
38430	844	7	Brahmagupta	Brahmagupta	NNP
38430	844	8	's	's	POS
38430	844	9	problem[96	problem[96	NN
38430	844	10	]	]	-RRB-
38430	844	11	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	844	12	to	to	TO
38430	844	13	be	be	VB
38430	844	14	the	the	DT
38430	844	15	earliest	early	JJS
38430	844	16	instance	instance	NN
38430	844	17	of	of	IN
38430	844	18	a	a	DT
38430	844	19	kind	kind	NN
38430	844	20	of	of	IN
38430	844	21	joke	joke	NN
38430	844	22	which	which	WDT
38430	844	23	has	have	VBZ
38430	844	24	been	be	VBN
38430	844	25	much	much	RB
38430	844	26	used	use	VBN
38430	844	27	by	by	IN
38430	844	28	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	844	29	.	.	.
38430	845	1	For	for	IN
38430	845	2	the	the	DT
38430	845	3	sake	sake	NN
38430	845	4	of	of	IN
38430	845	5	giving	give	VBG
38430	845	6	a	a	DT
38430	845	7	certain	certain	JJ
38430	845	8	picturesqueness	picturesqueness	NN
38430	845	9	to	to	IN
38430	845	10	the	the	DT
38430	845	11	data	datum	NNS
38430	845	12	of	of	IN
38430	845	13	problems	problem	NNS
38430	845	14	,	,	,
38430	845	15	and	and	CC
38430	845	16	so	so	RB
38430	845	17	to	to	TO
38430	845	18	excite	excite	VB
38430	845	19	that	that	DT
38430	845	20	sort	sort	NN
38430	845	21	of	of	IN
38430	845	22	interest	interest	NN
38430	845	23	which	which	WDT
38430	845	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	845	25	partly	partly	RB
38430	845	26	expressed	express	VBN
38430	845	27	by	by	IN
38430	845	28	a	a	DT
38430	845	29	smile	smile	NN
38430	845	30	,	,	,
38430	845	31	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	845	32	have	have	VBP
38430	845	33	got	get	VBN
38430	845	34	into	into	IN
38430	845	35	the	the	DT
38430	845	36	habit	habit	NN
38430	845	37	of	of	IN
38430	845	38	talking	talking	NN
38430	845	39	,	,	,
38430	845	40	for	for	IN
38430	845	41	example	example	NN
38430	845	42	,	,	,
38430	845	43	of	of	IN
38430	845	44	monkeys	monkey	NNS
38430	845	45	in	in	IN
38430	845	46	the	the	DT
38430	845	47	form	form	NN
38430	845	48	of	of	IN
38430	845	49	geometrical	geometrical	JJ
38430	845	50	points	point	NNS
38430	845	51	climbing	climb	VBG
38430	845	52	up	up	RP
38430	845	53	massless	massless	JJ
38430	845	54	ropes	rope	NNS
38430	845	55	.	.	.
38430	846	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	846	2	P.	P.	NNP
38430	846	3	Stäckel[97	Stäckel[97	NNP
38430	846	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	846	5	truly	truly	RB
38430	846	6	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	846	7	that	that	IN
38430	846	8	physiological	physiological	JJ
38430	846	9	mechanics	mechanic	NNS
38430	846	10	--	--	:
38430	846	11	the	the	DT
38430	846	12	mechanics	mechanic	NNS
38430	846	13	of	of	IN
38430	846	14	bones	bone	NNS
38430	846	15	,	,	,
38430	846	16	muscles	muscle	NNS
38430	846	17	,	,	,
38430	846	18	and	and	CC
38430	846	19	so	so	RB
38430	846	20	on	on	RB
38430	846	21	--	--	:
38430	846	22	is	be	VBZ
38430	846	23	wholly	wholly	RB
38430	846	24	different	different	JJ
38430	846	25	from	from	IN
38430	846	26	this	this	DT
38430	846	27	.	.	.
38430	847	1	There	there	EX
38430	847	2	was	be	VBD
38430	847	3	once	once	RB
38430	847	4	a	a	DT
38430	847	5	lecturer	lecturer	NN
38430	847	6	on	on	IN
38430	847	7	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	847	8	at	at	IN
38430	847	9	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	847	10	who	who	WP
38430	847	11	used	use	VBD
38430	847	12	yearly	yearly	RB
38430	847	13	to	to	TO
38430	847	14	propound	propound	VB
38430	847	15	to	to	IN
38430	847	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	847	17	pupils	pupil	NNS
38430	847	18	a	a	DT
38430	847	19	problem	problem	NN
38430	847	20	in	in	IN
38430	847	21	rigid	rigid	JJ
38430	847	22	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
38430	847	23	which	which	WDT
38430	847	24	related	relate	VBD
38430	847	25	to	to	IN
38430	847	26	the	the	DT
38430	847	27	motion	motion	NN
38430	847	28	of	of	IN
38430	847	29	a	a	DT
38430	847	30	garden	garden	NN
38430	847	31	roller	roller	NN
38430	847	32	supposed	suppose	VBN
38430	847	33	to	to	TO
38430	847	34	be	be	VB
38430	847	35	without	without	IN
38430	847	36	mass	mass	NN
38430	847	37	or	or	CC
38430	847	38	friction	friction	NN
38430	847	39	,	,	,
38430	847	40	when	when	WRB
38430	847	41	a	a	DT
38430	847	42	heavy	heavy	JJ
38430	847	43	and	and	CC
38430	847	44	perfectly	perfectly	RB
38430	847	45	rough	rough	JJ
38430	847	46	insect	insect	NN
38430	847	47	walked	walk	VBD
38430	847	48	round	round	IN
38430	847	49	the	the	DT
38430	847	50	interior	interior	NN
38430	847	51	of	of	IN
38430	847	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	847	53	in	in	IN
38430	847	54	the	the	DT
38430	847	55	direction	direction	NN
38430	847	56	of	of	IN
38430	847	57	normal	normal	JJ
38430	847	58	rolling	rolling	NN
38430	847	59	.	.	.
38430	848	1	Hitherto	Hitherto	NNP
38430	848	2	this	this	DT
38430	848	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	848	4	been	be	VBN
38430	848	5	the	the	DT
38430	848	6	only	only	JJ
38430	848	7	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	848	8	outlet	outlet	NN
38430	848	9	for	for	IN
38430	848	10	the	the	DT
38430	848	11	humour	humour	NN
38430	848	12	of	of	IN
38430	848	13	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	848	14	;	;	:
38430	848	15	and	and	CC
38430	848	16	those	those	DT
38430	848	17	who	who	WP
38430	848	18	really	really	RB
38430	848	19	had	have	VBD
38430	848	20	the	the	DT
38430	848	21	interests	interest	NNS
38430	848	22	of	of	IN
38430	848	23	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	848	24	at	at	IN
38430	848	25	heart	heart	NN
38430	848	26	saw	see	VBD
38430	848	27	with	with	IN
38430	848	28	alarm	alarm	NN
38430	848	29	the	the	DT
38430	848	30	growing	grow	VBG
38430	848	31	tendency	tendency	NN
38430	848	32	towards	towards	IN
38430	848	33	scholasticism	scholasticism	NN
38430	848	34	in	in	IN
38430	848	35	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	848	36	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	848	37	.	.	.
38430	849	1	Fortunately	fortunately	RB
38430	849	2	the	the	DT
38430	849	3	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	849	4	of	of	IN
38430	849	5	logic	logic	NN
38430	849	6	by	by	IN
38430	849	7	some	some	DT
38430	849	8	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	849	9	has	have	VBZ
38430	849	10	removed	remove	VBN
38430	849	11	this	this	DT
38430	849	12	danger	danger	NN
38430	849	13	.	.	.
38430	850	1	Still	still	RB
38430	850	2	to	to	IN
38430	850	3	many	many	JJ
38430	850	4	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	850	5	logic	logic	NN
38430	850	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	850	7	still	still	RB
38430	850	8	unknown	unknown	JJ
38430	850	9	,	,	,
38430	850	10	and	and	CC
38430	850	11	to	to	IN
38430	850	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	850	13	--	--	:
38430	850	14	to	to	IN
38430	850	15	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	850	16	A.	A.	NNP
38430	850	17	Schoenflies	Schoenflies	NNP
38430	850	18	for	for	IN
38430	850	19	example	example	NN
38430	850	20	--	--	:
38430	850	21	modern	modern	JJ
38430	850	22	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	850	23	,	,	,
38430	850	24	owing	owe	VBG
38430	850	25	to	to	IN
38430	850	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	850	27	alliance	alliance	NN
38430	850	28	with	with	IN
38430	850	29	logic	logic	NN
38430	850	30	,	,	,
38430	850	31	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	850	32	to	to	TO
38430	850	33	be	be	VB
38430	850	34	sinking	sink	VBG
38430	850	35	into	into	IN
38430	850	36	scholasticism	scholasticism	NN
38430	850	37	.	.	.
38430	851	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	851	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	851	3	true	true	JJ
38430	851	4	that	that	IN
38430	851	5	the	the	DT
38430	851	6	word	word	NN
38430	851	7	"	"	``
38430	851	8	scholasticism	scholasticism	NN
38430	851	9	"	"	''
38430	851	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	851	11	not	not	RB
38430	851	12	used	use	VBN
38430	851	13	by	by	IN
38430	851	14	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	851	15	Schoenflies	Schoenflies	NNP
38430	851	16	in	in	IN
38430	851	17	any	any	DT
38430	851	18	intentionally	intentionally	RB
38430	851	19	precise	precise	JJ
38430	851	20	signification	signification	NN
38430	851	21	,	,	,
38430	851	22	but	but	CC
38430	851	23	merely	merely	RB
38430	851	24	as	as	IN
38430	851	25	a	a	DT
38430	851	26	vague	vague	JJ
38430	851	27	epithet	epithet	NN
38430	851	28	of	of	IN
38430	851	29	disapproval	disapproval	NN
38430	851	30	,	,	,
38430	851	31	as	as	IN
38430	851	32	the	the	DT
38430	851	33	word	word	NN
38430	851	34	"	"	``
38430	851	35	socialism	socialism	NN
38430	851	36	"	"	''
38430	851	37	is	be	VBZ
38430	851	38	used	use	VBN
38430	851	39	by	by	IN
38430	851	40	the	the	DT
38430	851	41	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	851	42	philistine	philistine	NN
38430	851	43	,	,	,
38430	851	44	and	and	CC
38430	851	45	this	this	DT
38430	851	46	would	would	MD
38430	851	47	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	851	48	serve	serve	VB
38430	851	49	as	as	IN
38430	851	50	a	a	DT
38430	851	51	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
38430	851	52	excuse	excuse	NN
38430	851	53	.	.	.
38430	852	1	But	but	CC
38430	852	2	no	no	DT
38430	852	3	excuse	excuse	NN
38430	852	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	852	5	needed	need	VBN
38430	852	6	:	:	:
38430	852	7	these	these	DT
38430	852	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
38430	852	9	are	be	VBP
38430	852	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	852	11	a	a	DT
38430	852	12	source	source	NN
38430	852	13	of	of	IN
38430	852	14	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	852	15	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	852	16	.	.	.
38430	853	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	853	2	:	:	:
38430	853	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	853	4	96	96	CD
38430	853	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	853	6	See	see	VB
38430	853	7	Chapter	chapter	NN
38430	853	8	XII	XII	NNP
38430	853	9	.	.	.
38430	854	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	854	2	97	97	CD
38430	854	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	854	4	_	_	NNP
38430	854	5	Encykl	Encykl	NNP
38430	854	6	.	.	.
38430	855	1	der	der	IN
38430	855	2	math	math	NN
38430	855	3	.	.	.
38430	856	1	Wiss	Wiss	NNP
38430	856	2	.	.	.
38430	856	3	_	_	NNP
38430	856	4	,	,	,
38430	856	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	856	6	.	.	.
38430	857	1	iv	iv	NNP
38430	857	2	.	.	NNP
38430	857	3	,	,	,
38430	857	4	part	part	NNP
38430	857	5	i.	i.	NNP
38430	857	6	,	,	,
38430	857	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	857	8	474	474	CD
38430	857	9	.	.	.
38430	858	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	858	2	XXXVII	xxxvii	NN
38430	858	3	THE	the	DT
38430	858	4	PARADOXES	paradoxes	NN
38430	858	5	OF	of	IN
38430	858	6	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	858	7	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	858	8	have	have	VBP
38430	858	9	already[98	already[98	NN
38430	858	10	]	]	-RRB-
38430	858	11	referred	refer	VBN
38430	858	12	to	to	IN
38430	858	13	the	the	DT
38430	858	14	contempt	contempt	NN
38430	858	15	shown	show	VBN
38430	858	16	by	by	IN
38430	858	17	some	some	DT
38430	858	18	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	858	19	for	for	IN
38430	858	20	exact	exact	JJ
38430	858	21	thought	thought	NN
38430	858	22	,	,	,
38430	858	23	which	which	WDT
38430	858	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	858	25	condemn	condemn	VBD
38430	858	26	under	under	IN
38430	858	27	the	the	DT
38430	858	28	name	name	NN
38430	858	29	of	of	IN
38430	858	30	"	"	``
38430	858	31	scholasticism	scholasticism	NN
38430	858	32	.	.	.
38430	858	33	"	"	''
38430	859	1	An	an	DT
38430	859	2	example	example	NN
38430	859	3	of	of	IN
38430	859	4	this	this	DT
38430	859	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	859	6	given	give	VBN
38430	859	7	by	by	IN
38430	859	8	Schoenflies	schoenflie	NNS
38430	859	9	in	in	IN
38430	859	10	the	the	DT
38430	859	11	second	second	JJ
38430	859	12	part	part	NN
38430	859	13	of	of	IN
38430	859	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	859	15	publication	publication	NN
38430	859	16	usually	usually	RB
38430	859	17	known	know	VBN
38430	859	18	as	as	IN
38430	859	19	the	the	DT
38430	859	20	_	_	NNP
38430	859	21	Bericht	Bericht	NNP
38430	859	22	über	über	NN
38430	859	23	Mengenlehre	Mengenlehre	NNP
38430	859	24	_	_	NNP
38430	859	25	.	.	.
38430	860	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	860	2	99	99	CD
38430	860	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	860	4	Here[100	here[100	CD
38430	860	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	860	6	a	a	DT
38430	860	7	battle	battle	NN
38430	860	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	860	9	cry	cry	NN
38430	860	10	in	in	IN
38430	860	11	italics--	italics--	NNP
38430	860	12	"	"	``
38430	860	13	_	_	NNP
38430	860	14	Against	Against	NNP
38430	860	15	all	all	DT
38430	860	16	resignation	resignation	NN
38430	860	17	,	,	,
38430	860	18	but	but	CC
38430	860	19	also	also	RB
38430	860	20	against	against	IN
38430	860	21	all	all	RB
38430	860	22	scholasticism!_"--	scholasticism!_"--	$
38430	860	23	found	find	VBN
38430	860	24	utterance	utterance	NN
38430	860	25	.	.	.
38430	861	1	Later	later	RB
38430	861	2	on	on	RB
38430	861	3	,	,	,
38430	861	4	Schoenflies[101	schoenflies[101	CD
38430	861	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	861	6	became	become	VBD
38430	861	7	bolder	bold	JJR
38430	861	8	and	and	CC
38430	861	9	adopted	adopt	VBD
38430	861	10	a	a	DT
38430	861	11	more	more	RBR
38430	861	12	personal	personal	JJ
38430	861	13	battle	battle	NN
38430	861	14	-	-	:
38430	861	15	cry	cry	NN
38430	861	16	,	,	,
38430	861	17	also	also	RB
38430	861	18	in	in	IN
38430	861	19	italics	italic	NNS
38430	861	20	,	,	,
38430	861	21	and	and	CC
38430	861	22	with	with	IN
38430	861	23	a	a	DT
38430	861	24	whole	whole	JJ
38430	861	25	line	line	NN
38430	861	26	to	to	IN
38430	861	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	861	28	:	:	:
38430	861	29	"	"	``
38430	861	30	_	_	NNP
38430	861	31	For	for	IN
38430	861	32	Cantorism	Cantorism	NNP
38430	861	33	but	but	CC
38430	861	34	against	against	IN
38430	861	35	Russellism	Russellism	NNP
38430	861	36	!	!	.
38430	861	37	_	_	NNP
38430	861	38	"	"	''
38430	861	39	"	"	``
38430	861	40	Cantorism	Cantorism	NNP
38430	861	41	"	"	''
38430	861	42	means	mean	VBZ
38430	861	43	the	the	DT
38430	861	44	theory	theory	NN
38430	861	45	of	of	IN
38430	861	46	transfinite	transfinite	JJ
38430	861	47	aggregates	aggregate	NNS
38430	861	48	and	and	CC
38430	861	49	numbers	number	NNS
38430	861	50	erected	erect	VBN
38430	861	51	for	for	IN
38430	861	52	the	the	DT
38430	861	53	most	most	JJS
38430	861	54	part	part	NN
38430	861	55	by	by	IN
38430	861	56	Georg	Georg	NNP
38430	861	57	Cantor	Cantor	NNP
38430	861	58	.	.	.
38430	862	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
38430	862	2	speaking	speak	VBG
38430	862	3	,	,	,
38430	862	4	the	the	DT
38430	862	5	great	great	JJ
38430	862	6	sin	sin	NN
38430	862	7	of	of	IN
38430	862	8	"	"	``
38430	862	9	Russellism	Russellism	NNP
38430	862	10	"	"	''
38430	862	11	is	be	VBZ
38430	862	12	to	to	TO
38430	862	13	have	have	VB
38430	862	14	gone	go	VBN
38430	862	15	too	too	RB
38430	862	16	far	far	RB
38430	862	17	in	in	IN
38430	862	18	the	the	DT
38430	862	19	chain	chain	NN
38430	862	20	of	of	IN
38430	862	21	logical	logical	JJ
38430	862	22	deduction	deduction	NN
38430	862	23	for	for	IN
38430	862	24	many	many	JJ
38430	862	25	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	862	26	,	,	,
38430	862	27	who	who	WP
38430	862	28	were	be	VBD
38430	862	29	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	862	30	,	,	,
38430	862	31	like	like	UH
38430	862	32	Schoenflies,[102	schoenflies,[102	CD
38430	862	33	]	]	-RRB-
38430	862	34	blinded	blind	VBN
38430	862	35	by	by	IN
38430	862	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	862	37	rather	rather	RB
38430	862	38	uncritical	uncritical	JJ
38430	862	39	love	love	NN
38430	862	40	of	of	IN
38430	862	41	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	862	42	.	.	.
38430	863	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	863	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	863	3	comes	come	VBZ
38430	863	4	about	about	IN
38430	863	5	that	that	DT
38430	863	6	Schoenflies[103	Schoenflies[103	NNP
38430	863	7	]	]	-RRB-
38430	863	8	denounces	denounce	VBZ
38430	863	9	Russellism	Russellism	NNP
38430	863	10	as	as	IN
38430	863	11	"	"	``
38430	863	12	scholastic	scholastic	JJ
38430	863	13	and	and	CC
38430	863	14	unhealthy	unhealthy	JJ
38430	863	15	.	.	.
38430	863	16	"	"	''
38430	864	1	This	this	DT
38430	864	2	queer	queer	NN
38430	864	3	blend	blend	NN
38430	864	4	of	of	IN
38430	864	5	qualities	quality	NNS
38430	864	6	would	would	MD
38430	864	7	surely	surely	RB
38430	864	8	arouse	arouse	VB
38430	864	9	the	the	DT
38430	864	10	curiosity	curiosity	NN
38430	864	11	of	of	IN
38430	864	12	the	the	DT
38430	864	13	most	most	JJS
38430	864	14	_	_	NNP
38430	864	15	blasé	blasé	NN
38430	864	16	_	_	NNP
38430	864	17	as	as	IN
38430	864	18	to	to	IN
38430	864	19	what	what	WP
38430	864	20	strange	strange	JJ
38430	864	21	thing	thing	NN
38430	864	22	Russellism	Russellism	NNP
38430	864	23	must	must	MD
38430	864	24	be	be	VB
38430	864	25	.	.	.
38430	865	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	865	2	104	104	CD
38430	865	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	865	4	Schoenflies[105	schoenflies[105	NN
38430	865	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	865	6	said	say	VBD
38430	865	7	that	that	IN
38430	865	8	some	some	DT
38430	865	9	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	865	10	attributed	attribute	VBD
38430	865	11	to	to	IN
38430	865	12	the	the	DT
38430	865	13	logical	logical	JJ
38430	865	14	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	865	15	which	which	WDT
38430	865	16	have	have	VBP
38430	865	17	given	give	VBN
38430	865	18	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	865	19	so	so	RB
38430	865	20	much	much	JJ
38430	865	21	trouble	trouble	NN
38430	865	22	to	to	TO
38430	865	23	clear	clear	VB
38430	865	24	up	up	RP
38430	865	25	,	,	,
38430	865	26	"	"	''
38430	865	27	especially	especially	RB
38430	865	28	to	to	IN
38430	865	29	those	those	DT
38430	865	30	that	that	WDT
38430	865	31	are	be	VBP
38430	865	32	artificially	artificially	RB
38430	865	33	constructed	construct	VBN
38430	865	34	,	,	,
38430	865	35	a	a	DT
38430	865	36	significance	significance	NN
38430	865	37	that	that	IN
38430	865	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	865	39	do	do	VBP
38430	865	40	not	not	RB
38430	865	41	have	have	VB
38430	865	42	.	.	.
38430	865	43	"	"	''
38430	866	1	Yet	yet	CC
38430	866	2	no	no	DT
38430	866	3	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	866	4	were	be	VBD
38430	866	5	given	give	VBN
38430	866	6	for	for	IN
38430	866	7	this	this	DT
38430	866	8	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	866	9	,	,	,
38430	866	10	from	from	IN
38430	866	11	which	which	WDT
38430	866	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	866	13	might	may	MD
38430	866	14	be	be	VB
38430	866	15	concluded	conclude	VBN
38430	866	16	that	that	IN
38430	866	17	the	the	DT
38430	866	18	rigid	rigid	JJ
38430	866	19	examination	examination	NN
38430	866	20	of	of	IN
38430	866	21	any	any	DT
38430	866	22	concept	concept	NN
38430	866	23	was	be	VBD
38430	866	24	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
38430	866	25	.	.	.
38430	867	1	The	the	DT
38430	867	2	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	867	3	are	be	VBP
38430	867	4	simply	simply	RB
38430	867	5	the	the	DT
38430	867	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	867	7	results	result	NNS
38430	867	8	of	of	IN
38430	867	9	certain	certain	JJ
38430	867	10	logical	logical	JJ
38430	867	11	views	view	NNS
38430	867	12	which	which	WDT
38430	867	13	are	be	VBP
38430	867	14	currently	currently	RB
38430	867	15	held	hold	VBN
38430	867	16	,	,	,
38430	867	17	which	which	WDT
38430	867	18	views	view	NNS
38430	867	19	do	do	VBP
38430	867	20	not	not	RB
38430	867	21	,	,	,
38430	867	22	except	except	IN
38430	867	23	when	when	WRB
38430	867	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	867	25	are	be	VBP
38430	867	26	examined	examine	VBN
38430	867	27	rather	rather	RB
38430	867	28	closely	closely	RB
38430	867	29	,	,	,
38430	867	30	appear	appear	VB
38430	867	31	to	to	TO
38430	867	32	contain	contain	VB
38430	867	33	any	any	DT
38430	867	34	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	867	35	.	.	.
38430	868	1	The	the	DT
38430	868	2	contradiction	contradiction	NN
38430	868	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	868	4	not	not	RB
38430	868	5	felt	feel	VBN
38430	868	6	,	,	,
38430	868	7	as	as	IN
38430	868	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	868	9	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	868	10	,	,	,
38430	868	11	by	by	IN
38430	868	12	people	people	NNS
38430	868	13	who	who	WP
38430	868	14	confine	confine	VBP
38430	868	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	868	16	attention	attention	NN
38430	868	17	to	to	IN
38430	868	18	the	the	DT
38430	868	19	first	first	JJ
38430	868	20	few	few	JJ
38430	868	21	number	number	NN
38430	868	22	-	-	HYPH
38430	868	23	classes	class	NNS
38430	868	24	of	of	IN
38430	868	25	Cantor	Cantor	NNP
38430	868	26	,	,	,
38430	868	27	and	and	CC
38430	868	28	this	this	DT
38430	868	29	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	868	30	to	to	TO
38430	868	31	have	have	VB
38430	868	32	given	give	VBN
38430	868	33	rise	rise	NN
38430	868	34	to	to	IN
38430	868	35	the	the	DT
38430	868	36	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	868	37	,	,	,
38430	868	38	which	which	WDT
38430	868	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	868	40	is	be	VBZ
38430	868	41	a	a	DT
38430	868	42	little	little	RB
38430	868	43	surprising	surprising	JJ
38430	868	44	to	to	TO
38430	868	45	find	find	VB
38430	868	46	that	that	IN
38430	868	47	some	some	DT
38430	868	48	still	still	RB
38430	868	49	hold	hold	VBP
38430	868	50	,	,	,
38430	868	51	that	that	IN
38430	868	52	cases	case	NNS
38430	868	53	not	not	RB
38430	868	54	usually	usually	RB
38430	868	55	met	meet	VBN
38430	868	56	with	with	IN
38430	868	57	,	,	,
38430	868	58	though	though	IN
38430	868	59	falling	fall	VBG
38430	868	60	under	under	IN
38430	868	61	the	the	DT
38430	868	62	same	same	JJ
38430	868	63	concept	concept	NN
38430	868	64	as	as	IN
38430	868	65	those	those	DT
38430	868	66	usually	usually	RB
38430	868	67	met	meet	VBD
38430	868	68	with	with	IN
38430	868	69	,	,	,
38430	868	70	are	be	VBP
38430	868	71	of	of	IN
38430	868	72	little	little	JJ
38430	868	73	importance	importance	NN
38430	868	74	.	.	.
38430	869	1	One	one	NN
38430	869	2	might	may	MD
38430	869	3	just	just	RB
38430	869	4	as	as	RB
38430	869	5	well	well	RB
38430	869	6	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	869	7	that	that	RB
38430	869	8	continuous	continuous	JJ
38430	869	9	but	but	CC
38430	869	10	not	not	RB
38430	869	11	differentiable	differentiable	JJ
38430	869	12	functions	function	NNS
38430	869	13	are	be	VBP
38430	869	14	unimportant	unimportant	JJ
38430	869	15	because	because	IN
38430	869	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	869	17	are	be	VBP
38430	869	18	artificially	artificially	RB
38430	869	19	constructed	construct	VBN
38430	869	20	--	--	:
38430	869	21	a	a	DT
38430	869	22	term	term	NN
38430	869	23	which	which	WDT
38430	869	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	869	25	suppose	suppose	VBP
38430	869	26	means	mean	VBZ
38430	869	27	that	that	IN
38430	869	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	869	29	do	do	VBP
38430	869	30	not	not	RB
38430	869	31	present	present	VB
38430	869	32	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	869	33	when	when	WRB
38430	869	34	unasked	unasked	JJ
38430	869	35	for	for	IN
38430	869	36	.	.	.
38430	870	1	Rather	rather	RB
38430	870	2	should	should	MD
38430	870	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	870	4	say	say	VB
38430	870	5	that	that	IN
38430	870	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	870	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	870	8	by	by	IN
38430	870	9	the	the	DT
38430	870	10	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	870	11	and	and	CC
38430	870	12	investigation	investigation	NN
38430	870	13	of	of	IN
38430	870	14	such	such	JJ
38430	870	15	cases	case	NNS
38430	870	16	that	that	WDT
38430	870	17	the	the	DT
38430	870	18	concept	concept	NN
38430	870	19	in	in	IN
38430	870	20	question	question	NN
38430	870	21	can	can	MD
38430	870	22	alone	alone	RB
38430	870	23	be	be	VB
38430	870	24	judged	judge	VBN
38430	870	25	,	,	,
38430	870	26	and	and	CC
38430	870	27	the	the	DT
38430	870	28	validity	validity	NN
38430	870	29	of	of	IN
38430	870	30	certain	certain	JJ
38430	870	31	theorems	theorem	NNS
38430	870	32	--	--	:
38430	870	33	if	if	IN
38430	870	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	870	35	are	be	VBP
38430	870	36	valid	valid	JJ
38430	870	37	--	--	:
38430	870	38	conclusively	conclusively	RB
38430	870	39	proved	prove	VBN
38430	870	40	.	.	.
38430	871	1	That	that	IN
38430	871	2	this	this	DT
38430	871	3	has	have	VBZ
38430	871	4	been	be	VBN
38430	871	5	done	do	VBN
38430	871	6	,	,	,
38430	871	7	chiefly	chiefly	RB
38430	871	8	by	by	IN
38430	871	9	the	the	DT
38430	871	10	work	work	NN
38430	871	11	of	of	IN
38430	871	12	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	871	13	,	,	,
38430	871	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	871	15	simply	simply	RB
38430	871	16	a	a	DT
38430	871	17	fact	fact	NN
38430	871	18	;	;	:
38430	871	19	that	that	IN
38430	871	20	this	this	DT
38430	871	21	work	work	NN
38430	871	22	has	have	VBZ
38430	871	23	been	be	VBN
38430	871	24	and	and	CC
38430	871	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	871	26	misunderstood	misunderstand	VBN
38430	871	27	by	by	IN
38430	871	28	many[106	many[106	NNP
38430	871	29	]	]	-RRB-
38430	871	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	871	31	regrettable	regrettable	JJ
38430	871	32	for	for	IN
38430	871	33	this	this	DT
38430	871	34	reason	reason	NN
38430	871	35	,	,	,
38430	871	36	among	among	IN
38430	871	37	others	other	NNS
38430	871	38	,	,	,
38430	871	39	that	that	IN
38430	871	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	871	41	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	871	42	that	that	IN
38430	871	43	,	,	,
38430	871	44	at	at	IN
38430	871	45	the	the	DT
38430	871	46	present	present	JJ
38430	871	47	time	time	NN
38430	871	48	,	,	,
38430	871	49	as	as	IN
38430	871	50	in	in	IN
38430	871	51	the	the	DT
38430	871	52	days	day	NNS
38430	871	53	in	in	IN
38430	871	54	which	which	WDT
38430	871	55	_	_	NNP
38430	871	56	Gulliver	Gulliver	NNP
38430	871	57	's	's	POS
38430	871	58	Travels	Travels	NNPS
38430	871	59	_	_	NNP
38430	871	60	were	be	VBD
38430	871	61	written	write	VBN
38430	871	62	,	,	,
38430	871	63	some	some	DT
38430	871	64	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	871	65	are	be	VBP
38430	871	66	bad	bad	JJ
38430	871	67	reasoners	reasoner	NNS
38430	871	68	.	.	.
38430	872	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	872	2	107	107	CD
38430	872	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	872	4	Nearly	nearly	RB
38430	872	5	all	all	DT
38430	872	6	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	872	7	agreed	agree	VBD
38430	872	8	that	that	IN
38430	872	9	the	the	DT
38430	872	10	way	way	NN
38430	872	11	to	to	TO
38430	872	12	solve	solve	VB
38430	872	13	these	these	DT
38430	872	14	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	872	15	was	be	VBD
38430	872	16	simply	simply	RB
38430	872	17	not	not	RB
38430	872	18	to	to	TO
38430	872	19	mention	mention	VB
38430	872	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	872	21	;	;	:
38430	872	22	but	but	CC
38430	872	23	there	there	EX
38430	872	24	was	be	VBD
38430	872	25	some	some	DT
38430	872	26	divergence	divergence	NN
38430	872	27	of	of	IN
38430	872	28	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	872	29	as	as	IN
38430	872	30	to	to	IN
38430	872	31	how	how	WRB
38430	872	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	872	33	were	be	VBD
38430	872	34	to	to	TO
38430	872	35	be	be	VB
38430	872	36	unmentioned	unmentione	VBN
38430	872	37	.	.	.
38430	873	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	873	2	was	be	VBD
38430	873	3	clearly	clearly	RB
38430	873	4	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
38430	873	5	merely	merely	RB
38430	873	6	not	not	RB
38430	873	7	to	to	TO
38430	873	8	mention	mention	VB
38430	873	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	873	10	.	.	.
38430	874	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	874	2	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	874	3	was	be	VBD
38430	874	4	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	874	5	of	of	IN
38430	874	6	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	874	7	that	that	IN
38430	874	8	the	the	DT
38430	874	9	best	good	JJS
38430	874	10	way	way	NN
38430	874	11	of	of	IN
38430	874	12	avoiding	avoid	VBG
38430	874	13	such	such	JJ
38430	874	14	awkward	awkward	JJ
38430	874	15	subjects	subject	NNS
38430	874	16	was	be	VBD
38430	874	17	to	to	TO
38430	874	18	mention	mention	VB
38430	874	19	that	that	IN
38430	874	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	874	21	were	be	VBD
38430	874	22	not	not	RB
38430	874	23	to	to	TO
38430	874	24	be	be	VB
38430	874	25	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	874	26	.	.	.
38430	875	1	But[108	But[108	``
38430	875	2	]	]	-RRB-
38430	875	3	"	"	``
38430	875	4	one	one	PRP
38430	875	5	might	may	MD
38430	875	6	as	as	RB
38430	875	7	well	well	RB
38430	875	8	,	,	,
38430	875	9	in	in	IN
38430	875	10	talking	talk	VBG
38430	875	11	to	to	IN
38430	875	12	a	a	DT
38430	875	13	man	man	NN
38430	875	14	with	with	IN
38430	875	15	a	a	DT
38430	875	16	long	long	JJ
38430	875	17	nose	nose	NN
38430	875	18	,	,	,
38430	875	19	say	say	VBP
38430	875	20	:	:	:
38430	875	21	'	'	``
38430	875	22	When	when	WRB
38430	875	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	875	24	speak	speak	VBP
38430	875	25	of	of	IN
38430	875	26	noses	nose	NNS
38430	875	27	,	,	,
38430	875	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	875	29	except	except	IN
38430	875	30	such	such	JJ
38430	875	31	as	as	IN
38430	875	32	are	be	VBP
38430	875	33	inordinately	inordinately	RB
38430	875	34	long	long	JJ
38430	875	35	,	,	,
38430	875	36	'	'	''
38430	875	37	which	which	WDT
38430	875	38	would	would	MD
38430	875	39	not	not	RB
38430	875	40	be	be	VB
38430	875	41	a	a	DT
38430	875	42	very	very	RB
38430	875	43	successful	successful	JJ
38430	875	44	effort	effort	NN
38430	875	45	to	to	TO
38430	875	46	avoid	avoid	VB
38430	875	47	a	a	DT
38430	875	48	painful	painful	JJ
38430	875	49	topic	topic	NN
38430	875	50	.	.	.
38430	875	51	"	"	''
38430	876	1	Schoenflies	schoenflie	NNS
38430	876	2	,	,	,
38430	876	3	in	in	IN
38430	876	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	876	5	paper	paper	NN
38430	876	6	of	of	IN
38430	876	7	1911	1911	CD
38430	876	8	mentioned	mention	VBN
38430	876	9	above	above	RB
38430	876	10	,	,	,
38430	876	11	adopted	adopt	VBD
38430	876	12	the	the	DT
38430	876	13	convenient	convenient	JJ
38430	876	14	plan	plan	NN
38430	876	15	of	of	IN
38430	876	16	referring	refer	VBG
38430	876	17	these	these	DT
38430	876	18	logical	logical	JJ
38430	876	19	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	876	20	at	at	IN
38430	876	21	the	the	DT
38430	876	22	root	root	NN
38430	876	23	of	of	IN
38430	876	24	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	876	25	to	to	IN
38430	876	26	a	a	DT
38430	876	27	department	department	NN
38430	876	28	of	of	IN
38430	876	29	knowledge	knowledge	NN
38430	876	30	which	which	WDT
38430	876	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	876	32	called	call	VBD
38430	876	33	"	"	``
38430	876	34	philosophy	philosophy	NN
38430	876	35	.	.	.
38430	876	36	"	"	''
38430	877	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	877	2	said[109	said[109	NN
38430	877	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	877	4	of	of	IN
38430	877	5	the	the	DT
38430	877	6	theory	theory	NN
38430	877	7	of	of	IN
38430	877	8	aggregates	aggregate	NNS
38430	877	9	that	that	WDT
38430	877	10	though	though	IN
38430	877	11	"	"	``
38430	877	12	born	bear	VBN
38430	877	13	of	of	IN
38430	877	14	the	the	DT
38430	877	15	acuteness	acuteness	NN
38430	877	16	of	of	IN
38430	877	17	the	the	DT
38430	877	18	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	877	19	spirit	spirit	NN
38430	877	20	,	,	,
38430	877	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	877	22	has	have	VBZ
38430	877	23	gradually	gradually	RB
38430	877	24	fallen	fall	VBN
38430	877	25	into	into	IN
38430	877	26	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	877	27	ways	way	NNS
38430	877	28	,	,	,
38430	877	29	and	and	CC
38430	877	30	has	have	VBZ
38430	877	31	lost	lose	VBN
38430	877	32	to	to	IN
38430	877	33	some	some	DT
38430	877	34	extent	extent	NN
38430	877	35	the	the	DT
38430	877	36	compelling	compelling	JJ
38430	877	37	force	force	NN
38430	877	38	which	which	WDT
38430	877	39	dwells	dwell	VBZ
38430	877	40	in	in	IN
38430	877	41	the	the	DT
38430	877	42	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	877	43	process	process	NN
38430	877	44	of	of	IN
38430	877	45	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	877	46	.	.	.
38430	877	47	"	"	''
38430	878	1	The	the	DT
38430	878	2	majority	majority	NN
38430	878	3	of	of	IN
38430	878	4	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	878	5	have	have	VBP
38430	878	6	followed	follow	VBN
38430	878	7	Schoenflies	Schoenflies	NNPS
38430	878	8	rather	rather	RB
38430	878	9	than	than	IN
38430	878	10	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	878	11	,	,	,
38430	878	12	and	and	CC
38430	878	13	have	have	VBP
38430	878	14	thus	thus	RB
38430	878	15	adopted	adopt	VBN
38430	878	16	tactics	tactic	NNS
38430	878	17	rather	rather	RB
38430	878	18	like	like	IN
38430	878	19	those	those	DT
38430	878	20	of	of	IN
38430	878	21	the	the	DT
38430	878	22	March	March	NNP
38430	878	23	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	878	24	and	and	CC
38430	878	25	the	the	DT
38430	878	26	Gryphon,[110	gryphon,[110	LS
38430	878	27	]	]	-RRB-
38430	878	28	who	who	WP
38430	878	29	promptly	promptly	RB
38430	878	30	changed	change	VBD
38430	878	31	the	the	DT
38430	878	32	subject	subject	NN
38430	878	33	when	when	WRB
38430	878	34	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	878	35	raised	raise	VBD
38430	878	36	awkward	awkward	JJ
38430	878	37	questions	question	NNS
38430	878	38	.	.	.
38430	879	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
38430	879	2	,	,	,
38430	879	3	the	the	DT
38430	879	4	process	process	NN
38430	879	5	of	of	IN
38430	879	6	the	the	DT
38430	879	7	first	first	JJ
38430	879	8	of	of	IN
38430	879	9	these	these	DT
38430	879	10	creatures	creature	NNS
38430	879	11	of	of	IN
38430	879	12	a	a	DT
38430	879	13	child	child	NN
38430	879	14	's	's	POS
38430	879	15	dream	dream	NN
38430	879	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	879	17	rather	rather	RB
38430	879	18	preferable	preferable	JJ
38430	879	19	to	to	IN
38430	879	20	that	that	DT
38430	879	21	of	of	IN
38430	879	22	Schoenflies	schoenflie	NNS
38430	879	23	.	.	.
38430	880	1	The	the	DT
38430	880	2	March	March	NNP
38430	880	3	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	880	4	refused	refuse	VBD
38430	880	5	to	to	TO
38430	880	6	discuss	discuss	VB
38430	880	7	the	the	DT
38430	880	8	subject	subject	NN
38430	880	9	because	because	IN
38430	880	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	880	11	was	be	VBD
38430	880	12	bored	bore	VBN
38430	880	13	when	when	WRB
38430	880	14	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
38430	880	15	arose	arise	VBD
38430	880	16	.	.	.
38430	881	1	Schoenflies	schoenflie	NNS
38430	881	2	would	would	MD
38430	881	3	not	not	RB
38430	881	4	say	say	VB
38430	881	5	that	that	IN
38430	881	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	881	7	was	be	VBD
38430	881	8	bored	bore	VBN
38430	881	9	--	--	:
38430	881	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	881	11	professed	profess	VBD
38430	881	12	interest	interest	NN
38430	881	13	in	in	IN
38430	881	14	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	881	15	matters	matter	NNS
38430	881	16	,	,	,
38430	881	17	but	but	CC
38430	881	18	simply	simply	RB
38430	881	19	called	call	VBD
38430	881	20	the	the	DT
38430	881	21	logical	logical	JJ
38430	881	22	continuation	continuation	NN
38430	881	23	of	of	IN
38430	881	24	a	a	DT
38430	881	25	subject	subject	NN
38430	881	26	by	by	IN
38430	881	27	another	another	DT
38430	881	28	name	name	NN
38430	881	29	when	when	WRB
38430	881	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	881	31	did	do	VBD
38430	881	32	not	not	RB
38430	881	33	wish	wish	VB
38430	881	34	to	to	TO
38430	881	35	discuss	discuss	VB
38430	881	36	the	the	DT
38430	881	37	continuation	continuation	NN
38430	881	38	,	,	,
38430	881	39	and	and	CC
38430	881	40	thus	thus	RB
38430	881	41	implied	imply	VBD
38430	881	42	that	that	IN
38430	881	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	881	44	had	have	VBD
38430	881	45	discussed	discuss	VBN
38430	881	46	the	the	DT
38430	881	47	whole	whole	JJ
38430	881	48	subject	subject	NN
38430	881	49	.	.	.
38430	882	1	Further	further	RB
38430	882	2	,	,	,
38430	882	3	Schoenflies	schoenflie	NNS
38430	882	4	would	would	MD
38430	882	5	not	not	RB
38430	882	6	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	882	7	admit	admit	VB
38430	882	8	that	that	IN
38430	882	9	the	the	DT
38430	882	10	one	one	CD
38430	882	11	method	method	NN
38430	882	12	of	of	IN
38430	882	13	logic	logic	NN
38430	882	14	could	could	MD
38430	882	15	be	be	VB
38430	882	16	applied	apply	VBN
38430	882	17	to	to	IN
38430	882	18	the	the	DT
38430	882	19	solution	solution	NN
38430	882	20	of	of	IN
38430	882	21	both	both	CC
38430	882	22	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	882	23	and	and	CC
38430	882	24	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	882	25	problems	problem	NNS
38430	882	26	,	,	,
38430	882	27	in	in	IN
38430	882	28	so	so	RB
38430	882	29	far	far	RB
38430	882	30	as	as	IN
38430	882	31	these	these	DT
38430	882	32	problems	problem	NNS
38430	882	33	are	be	VBP
38430	882	34	soluble	soluble	JJ
38430	882	35	at	at	RB
38430	882	36	all	all	RB
38430	882	37	;	;	:
38430	882	38	but	but	CC
38430	882	39	the	the	DT
38430	882	40	March	March	NNP
38430	882	41	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	882	42	,	,	,
38430	882	43	shortly	shortly	RB
38430	882	44	before	before	IN
38430	882	45	the	the	DT
38430	882	46	remark	remark	NN
38430	882	47	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	882	48	have	have	VBP
38430	882	49	just	just	RB
38430	882	50	quoted	quote	VBN
38430	882	51	,	,	,
38430	882	52	rightly	rightly	RB
38430	882	53	showed	show	VBD
38430	882	54	great	great	JJ
38430	882	55	astonishment	astonishment	NN
38430	882	56	that	that	IN
38430	882	57	butter	butter	NN
38430	882	58	did	do	VBD
38430	882	59	not	not	RB
38430	882	60	help	help	VB
38430	882	61	to	to	TO
38430	882	62	cure	cure	VB
38430	882	63	both	both	DT
38430	882	64	hunger	hunger	NN
38430	882	65	and	and	CC
38430	882	66	watches	watch	NNS
38430	882	67	that	that	WDT
38430	882	68	would	would	MD
38430	882	69	not	not	RB
38430	882	70	go	go	VB
38430	882	71	.	.	.
38430	883	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	883	2	111	111	CD
38430	883	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	883	4	The	the	DT
38430	883	5	judgment	judgment	NN
38430	883	6	of	of	IN
38430	883	7	Schoenflies	Schoenflies	NNPS
38430	883	8	by	by	IN
38430	883	9	which	which	WDT
38430	883	10	certain	certain	JJ
38430	883	11	apparently	apparently	RB
38430	883	12	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	883	13	questions	question	NNS
38430	883	14	were	be	VBD
38430	883	15	condemned	condemn	VBN
38430	883	16	as	as	IN
38430	883	17	"	"	``
38430	883	18	philosophical	philosophical	JJ
38430	883	19	,	,	,
38430	883	20	"	"	''
38430	883	21	rested	rest	VBN
38430	883	22	on	on	IN
38430	883	23	grounds	ground	NNS
38430	883	24	as	as	RB
38430	883	25	flimsy	flimsy	JJ
38430	883	26	as	as	IN
38430	883	27	those	those	DT
38430	883	28	in	in	IN
38430	883	29	the	the	DT
38430	883	30	Dreyfus	Dreyfus	NNP
38430	883	31	Case	Case	NNP
38430	883	32	,	,	,
38430	883	33	or	or	CC
38430	883	34	the	the	DT
38430	883	35	Trial	Trial	NNP
38430	883	36	in	in	IN
38430	883	37	_	_	NNP
38430	883	38	Wonderland	Wonderland	NNP
38430	883	39	_	_	NNP
38430	883	40	.	.	.
38430	884	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	884	2	112	112	CD
38430	884	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	884	4	FOOTNOTES	FOOTNOTES	NNP
38430	884	5	:	:	:
38430	884	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	884	7	98	98	CD
38430	884	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	884	9	Chapters	Chapters	NNPS
38430	884	10	VII	VII	NNP
38430	884	11	and	and	CC
38430	884	12	XXXVI	XXXVI	NNP
38430	884	13	.	.	.
38430	885	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	885	2	99	99	CD
38430	885	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	885	4	_	_	NNP
38430	885	5	Die	Die	NNP
38430	885	6	Entwickelung	Entwickelung	NNP
38430	885	7	der	der	NN
38430	885	8	Lehre	Lehre	NNP
38430	885	9	von	von	NNP
38430	885	10	den	den	NN
38430	885	11	Punktmannigfaltigkeiten	Punktmannigfaltigkeiten	NNP
38430	885	12	.	.	.
38430	885	13	_	_	NNP
38430	885	14	Bericht	Bericht	NNP
38430	885	15	,	,	,
38430	885	16	erstattet	erstattet	NN
38430	885	17	der	der	XX
38430	885	18	deutschen	deutschen	NNP
38430	885	19	Mathematiker	Mathematiker	NNP
38430	885	20	-	-	HYPH
38430	885	21	Vereinigung	Vereinigung	NNP
38430	885	22	,	,	,
38430	885	23	Leipzig	Leipzig	NNP
38430	885	24	,	,	,
38430	885	25	1908	1908	CD
38430	885	26	.	.	.
38430	886	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	886	2	100	100	CD
38430	886	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	886	4	_	_	NNP
38430	886	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	886	6	.	.	.
38430	886	7	_	_	NNP
38430	886	8	,	,	,
38430	886	9	p.	p.	NN
38430	886	10	7	7	CD
38430	886	11	.	.	.
38430	887	1	The	the	DT
38430	887	2	battle	battle	NN
38430	887	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	887	4	cry	cry	NN
38430	887	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	887	6	:	:	:
38430	887	7	"	"	``
38430	887	8	_	_	NNP
38430	887	9	Gegen	Gegen	NNP
38430	887	10	jede	jede	NNP
38430	887	11	Resignation	Resignation	NNP
38430	887	12	,	,	,
38430	887	13	aber	aber	NN
38430	887	14	auch	auch	NN
38430	887	15	gegen	gegen	NNP
38430	887	16	jede	jede	NNP
38430	887	17	Scholastik	Scholastik	NNP
38430	887	18	!	!	.
38430	887	19	_	_	NNP
38430	887	20	"	"	''
38430	887	21	[	[	-LRB-
38430	887	22	101	101	CD
38430	887	23	]	]	-RRB-
38430	887	24	"	"	``
38430	887	25	Ueber	Ueber	NNP
38430	887	26	die	die	VBP
38430	887	27	Stellung	Stellung	NNP
38430	887	28	der	der	IN
38430	887	29	Definition	definition	NN
38430	887	30	in	in	IN
38430	887	31	der	der	NN
38430	887	32	Axiomatik	Axiomatik	NNP
38430	887	33	,	,	,
38430	887	34	"	"	''
38430	887	35	_	_	NNP
38430	887	36	Jahresber	Jahresber	NNP
38430	887	37	,	,	,
38430	887	38	der	der	NNP
38430	887	39	deutsch	deutsch	NNP
38430	887	40	.	.	.
38430	888	1	Math.-Ver	Math.-Ver	NNP
38430	888	2	.	.	.
38430	888	3	_	_	NNP
38430	888	4	,	,	,
38430	888	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	888	6	.	.	.
38430	889	1	xx	xx	NNP
38430	889	2	.	.	NNP
38430	889	3	,	,	,
38430	889	4	1911	1911	CD
38430	889	5	,	,	,
38430	889	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	889	7	.	.	.
38430	890	1	222	222	CD
38430	890	2	-	-	SYM
38430	890	3	5	5	CD
38430	890	4	.	.	.
38430	891	1	The	the	DT
38430	891	2	battle	battle	NN
38430	891	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	891	4	cry	cry	NN
38430	891	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	891	6	on	on	IN
38430	891	7	p.	p.	NN
38430	891	8	256	256	CD
38430	891	9	and	and	CC
38430	891	10	is	be	VBZ
38430	891	11	:	:	:
38430	891	12	"	"	``
38430	891	13	Für	Für	NNP
38430	891	14	den	den	NN
38430	891	15	Cantorismus	Cantorismus	NNP
38430	891	16	aber	aber	NN
38430	891	17	gegen	gegen	NNP
38430	891	18	den	den	NNP
38430	891	19	Russellismus	Russellismus	NNP
38430	891	20	!	!	.
38430	891	21	"	"	''
38430	892	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	892	2	102	102	CD
38430	892	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	892	4	_	_	NNP
38430	892	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	892	6	.	.	.
38430	892	7	_	_	NNP
38430	892	8	,	,	,
38430	892	9	p.	p.	NN
38430	892	10	251	251	CD
38430	892	11	.	.	.
38430	893	1	"	"	``
38430	893	2	Es	es	NN
38430	893	3	ist	ist	NN
38430	893	4	also	also	RB
38430	893	5	,	,	,
38430	893	6	"	"	''
38430	893	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	893	8	exclaims	exclaim	VBZ
38430	893	9	with	with	IN
38430	893	10	the	the	DT
38430	893	11	eloquence	eloquence	NN
38430	893	12	of	of	IN
38430	893	13	emotion	emotion	NN
38430	893	14	and	and	CC
38430	893	15	the	the	DT
38430	893	16	emotion	emotion	NN
38430	893	17	of	of	IN
38430	893	18	eloquence	eloquence	NN
38430	893	19	,	,	,
38430	893	20	"	"	''
38430	893	21	nicht	nicht	NN
38430	893	22	die	die	VBP
38430	893	23	Geringschätzung	Geringschätzung	NNP
38430	893	24	der	der	IN
38430	893	25	Philosophie	Philosophie	NNP
38430	893	26	,	,	,
38430	893	27	die	die	VBP
38430	893	28	mich	mich	NNP
38430	893	29	dabei	dabei	NNP
38430	893	30	treibt	treibt	NNP
38430	893	31	,	,	,
38430	893	32	sondern	sondern	NNP
38430	893	33	die	die	VBP
38430	893	34	Liebe	Liebe	NNP
38430	893	35	zur	zur	NNP
38430	893	36	Mathematik	Mathematik	NNP
38430	893	37	;	;	:
38430	893	38	...	...	:
38430	893	39	"	"	''
38430	893	40	[	[	-LRB-
38430	893	41	103	103	CD
38430	893	42	]	]	-RRB-
38430	893	43	"	"	``
38430	893	44	Ueber	Ueber	NNP
38430	893	45	die	die	VBP
38430	893	46	Stellung	Stellung	NNP
38430	893	47	der	der	IN
38430	893	48	Definition	definition	NN
38430	893	49	in	in	IN
38430	893	50	der	der	NN
38430	893	51	Axiomatik	Axiomatik	NNP
38430	893	52	,	,	,
38430	893	53	"	"	''
38430	893	54	_	_	NNP
38430	893	55	Jahresber	Jahresber	NNP
38430	893	56	,	,	,
38430	893	57	der	der	NNP
38430	893	58	deutsch	deutsch	NNP
38430	893	59	.	.	.
38430	894	1	Math.-Ver	Math.-Ver	NNP
38430	894	2	.	.	.
38430	894	3	_	_	NNP
38430	894	4	,	,	,
38430	894	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	894	6	.	.	.
38430	895	1	xx	xx	NNP
38430	895	2	.	.	NNP
38430	895	3	,	,	,
38430	895	4	1911	1911	CD
38430	895	5	,	,	,
38430	895	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	895	7	251	251	CD
38430	895	8	.	.	.
38430	896	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	896	2	104	104	CD
38430	896	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	896	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	896	5	Cf	cf	NN
38430	896	6	.	.	.
38430	897	1	for	for	IN
38430	897	2	this	this	DT
38430	897	3	,	,	,
38430	897	4	_	_	NNP
38430	897	5	M.	M.	NNP
38430	897	6	_	_	NNP
38430	897	7	,	,	,
38430	897	8	vol	vol	NNP
38430	897	9	.	.	.
38430	898	1	xxii	xxii	NNP
38430	898	2	.	.	NNP
38430	898	3	,	,	,
38430	898	4	January	January	NNP
38430	898	5	1912	1912	CD
38430	898	6	,	,	,
38430	898	7	pp	pp	NNP
38430	898	8	.	.	.
38430	899	1	149	149	CD
38430	899	2	-	-	HYPH
38430	899	3	58.--ED	58.--ed	CD
38430	899	4	.	.	.
38430	899	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	900	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	900	2	105	105	CD
38430	900	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	900	4	_	_	NNP
38430	900	5	Bericht	Bericht	NNP
38430	900	6	_	_	NNP
38430	900	7	,	,	,
38430	900	8	1908	1908	CD
38430	900	9	,	,	,
38430	900	10	p.	p.	NN
38430	900	11	76	76	CD
38430	900	12	,	,	,
38430	900	13	note	note	VBP
38430	900	14	;	;	:
38430	900	15	cf	cf	NN
38430	900	16	.	.	.
38430	901	1	p.	p.	NN
38430	901	2	72	72	CD
38430	901	3	.	.	.
38430	902	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	902	2	106	106	CD
38430	902	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	902	4	E.g.	e.g.	CD
38430	903	1	in	in	IN
38430	903	2	F.	F.	NNP
38430	903	3	Hausdorff	Hausdorff	NNP
38430	903	4	's	's	POS
38430	903	5	review	review	NN
38430	903	6	of	of	IN
38430	903	7	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	903	8	's	's	POS
38430	903	9	_	_	NNP
38430	903	10	Principles	Principles	NNPS
38430	903	11	_	_	NNP
38430	903	12	of	of	IN
38430	903	13	1903	1903	CD
38430	903	14	in	in	IN
38430	903	15	the	the	DT
38430	903	16	_	_	NNP
38430	903	17	Vierteljahrsschr	Vierteljahrsschr	NNP
38430	903	18	.	.	.
38430	904	1	für	für	NNP
38430	904	2	wiss	wiss	NNP
38430	904	3	.	.	.
38430	905	1	Philos	Philos	NNP
38430	905	2	.	.	.
38430	906	1	und	und	JJ
38430	906	2	Soziologie	Soziologie	NNP
38430	906	3	_	_	NNP
38430	906	4	.	.	.
38430	907	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	907	2	107	107	CD
38430	907	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	907	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	907	5	Cf	cf	NN
38430	907	6	.	.	.
38430	908	1	_	_	NNP
38430	908	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	908	3	_	_	NNP
38430	908	4	,	,	,
38430	908	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	908	6	.	.	.
38430	909	1	xxv	xxv	NNP
38430	909	2	.	.	NNP
38430	909	3	,	,	,
38430	909	4	1915	1915	CD
38430	909	5	,	,	,
38430	909	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	909	7	.	.	.
38430	910	1	333	333	CD
38430	910	2	-	-	HYPH
38430	910	3	8.--ED	8.--ed	CD
38430	910	4	.	.	.
38430	910	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	911	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	911	2	108	108	CD
38430	911	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	911	4	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	911	5	,	,	,
38430	911	6	_	_	NNP
38430	911	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	912	1	J.	J.	NNP
38430	912	2	M.	M.	NNP
38430	912	3	_	_	NNP
38430	912	4	,	,	,
38430	912	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	912	6	.	.	.
38430	913	1	xxx	xxx	NNP
38430	913	2	.	.	NNP
38430	913	3	,	,	,
38430	913	4	1908	1908	CD
38430	913	5	,	,	,
38430	913	6	p.	p.	NN
38430	913	7	226	226	CD
38430	913	8	.	.	.
38430	914	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	914	2	109	109	CD
38430	914	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	914	4	_	_	NNP
38430	914	5	Loc	Loc	NNP
38430	914	6	.	.	.
38430	915	1	cit	cit	NNP
38430	915	2	.	.	.
38430	915	3	_	_	NNP
38430	915	4	,	,	,
38430	915	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	915	6	222	222	CD
38430	915	7	.	.	.
38430	916	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	916	2	110	110	CD
38430	916	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	916	4	See	see	VB
38430	916	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	916	6	Q.	Q.	NNP
38430	917	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	917	2	111	111	CD
38430	917	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	917	4	See	see	VB
38430	917	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	917	6	R.	R.	NNP
38430	917	7	[	[	-LRB-
38430	917	8	112	112	CD
38430	917	9	]	]	-RRB-
38430	917	10	See	see	VB
38430	917	11	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	917	12	S.	S.	NNP
38430	917	13	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
38430	917	14	XXXVIII	XXXVIII	VBD
38430	917	15	MODERN	MODERN	NNS
38430	917	16	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	917	17	AND	and	CC
38430	917	18	SOME	some	NN
38430	917	19	PHILOSOPHICAL	philosophical	NN
38430	917	20	ARGUMENTS	argument	NNS
38430	917	21	The	the	DT
38430	917	22	most	most	RBS
38430	917	23	noteworthy	noteworthy	JJ
38430	917	24	reformation	reformation	NN
38430	917	25	of	of	IN
38430	917	26	recent	recent	JJ
38430	917	27	years	year	NNS
38430	917	28	in	in	IN
38430	917	29	logic	logic	NN
38430	917	30	is	be	VBZ
38430	917	31	the	the	DT
38430	917	32	discovery	discovery	NN
38430	917	33	and	and	CC
38430	917	34	development	development	NN
38430	917	35	by	by	IN
38430	917	36	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	917	37	Bertrand	Bertrand	NNP
38430	917	38	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	917	39	of	of	IN
38430	917	40	the	the	DT
38430	917	41	fact	fact	NN
38430	917	42	that	that	IN
38430	917	43	the	the	DT
38430	917	44	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	917	45	--	--	:
38430	917	46	of	of	IN
38430	917	47	Burali	Burali	NNP
38430	917	48	-	-	HYPH
38430	917	49	Forti	Forti	NNP
38430	917	50	,	,	,
38430	917	51	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	917	52	,	,	,
38430	917	53	König	König	NNP
38430	917	54	,	,	,
38430	917	55	Richard	Richard	NNP
38430	917	56	,	,	,
38430	917	57	and	and	CC
38430	917	58	others	other	NNS
38430	917	59	--	--	:
38430	917	60	which	which	WDT
38430	917	61	have	have	VBP
38430	917	62	appeared	appear	VBN
38430	917	63	of	of	IN
38430	917	64	late	late	JJ
38430	917	65	years	year	NNS
38430	917	66	in	in	IN
38430	917	67	the	the	DT
38430	917	68	mathematical	mathematical	JJ
38430	917	69	theory	theory	NN
38430	917	70	of	of	IN
38430	917	71	aggregates	aggregate	NNS
38430	917	72	and	and	CC
38430	917	73	have	have	VBP
38430	917	74	just	just	RB
38430	917	75	been	be	VBN
38430	917	76	referred	refer	VBN
38430	917	77	to	to	IN
38430	917	78	,	,	,
38430	917	79	are	be	VBP
38430	917	80	of	of	IN
38430	917	81	an	an	DT
38430	917	82	entirely	entirely	RB
38430	917	83	_	_	NNP
38430	917	84	logical	logical	JJ
38430	917	85	_	_	NNP
38430	917	86	nature	nature	NN
38430	917	87	,	,	,
38430	917	88	and	and	CC
38430	917	89	that	that	IN
38430	917	90	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	917	91	avoidance	avoidance	NN
38430	917	92	requires	require	VBZ
38430	917	93	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	917	94	to	to	TO
38430	917	95	take	take	VB
38430	917	96	account	account	NN
38430	917	97	of	of	IN
38430	917	98	a	a	DT
38430	917	99	principle	principle	NN
38430	917	100	which	which	WDT
38430	917	101	has	have	VBZ
38430	917	102	been	be	VBN
38430	917	103	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
38430	917	104	unrecognized	unrecognized	JJ
38430	917	105	,	,	,
38430	917	106	and	and	CC
38430	917	107	which	which	WDT
38430	917	108	renders	render	VBZ
38430	917	109	invalid	invalid	RB
38430	917	110	several	several	JJ
38430	917	111	well	well	RB
38430	917	112	-	-	HYPH
38430	917	113	known	know	VBN
38430	917	114	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	917	115	in	in	IN
38430	917	116	refutation	refutation	NN
38430	917	117	of	of	IN
38430	917	118	scepticism	scepticism	NN
38430	917	119	,	,	,
38430	917	120	agnosticism	agnosticism	NN
38430	917	121	,	,	,
38430	917	122	and	and	CC
38430	917	123	the	the	DT
38430	917	124	statement	statement	NN
38430	917	125	of	of	IN
38430	917	126	a	a	DT
38430	917	127	man	man	NN
38430	917	128	that	that	WDT
38430	917	129	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	917	130	asserts	assert	VBZ
38430	917	131	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	917	132	.	.	.
38430	918	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	918	2	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
38430	918	3	and	and	CC
38430	918	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	918	5	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	918	6	say:[113	say:[113	NNP
38430	918	7	]	]	-RRB-
38430	918	8	"	"	``
38430	918	9	The	the	DT
38430	918	10	principle	principle	NN
38430	918	11	which	which	WDT
38430	918	12	enables	enable	VBZ
38430	918	13	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	918	14	to	to	TO
38430	918	15	avoid	avoid	VB
38430	918	16	illegitimate	illegitimate	JJ
38430	918	17	totalities	totality	NNS
38430	918	18	may	may	MD
38430	918	19	be	be	VB
38430	918	20	stated	state	VBN
38430	918	21	as	as	IN
38430	918	22	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	918	23	:	:	:
38430	918	24	'	'	''
38430	918	25	Whatever	whatever	WDT
38430	918	26	involves	involve	VBZ
38430	918	27	_	_	NNP
38430	918	28	all	all	DT
38430	918	29	_	_	NNP
38430	918	30	of	of	IN
38430	918	31	a	a	DT
38430	918	32	collection	collection	NN
38430	918	33	must	must	MD
38430	918	34	not	not	RB
38430	918	35	be	be	VB
38430	918	36	one	one	CD
38430	918	37	of	of	IN
38430	918	38	the	the	DT
38430	918	39	collection	collection	NN
38430	918	40	,	,	,
38430	918	41	'	'	''
38430	918	42	or	or	CC
38430	918	43	conversely	conversely	RB
38430	918	44	:	:	:
38430	918	45	'	'	''
38430	918	46	If	if	IN
38430	918	47	,	,	,
38430	918	48	provided	provide	VBD
38430	918	49	a	a	DT
38430	918	50	certain	certain	JJ
38430	918	51	collection	collection	NN
38430	918	52	had	have	VBD
38430	918	53	a	a	DT
38430	918	54	total	total	NN
38430	918	55	,	,	,
38430	918	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	918	57	would	would	MD
38430	918	58	have	have	VB
38430	918	59	members	member	NNS
38430	918	60	only	only	RB
38430	918	61	definable	definable	JJ
38430	918	62	in	in	IN
38430	918	63	terms	term	NNS
38430	918	64	of	of	IN
38430	918	65	that	that	DT
38430	918	66	total	total	NN
38430	918	67	,	,	,
38430	918	68	then	then	RB
38430	918	69	the	the	DT
38430	918	70	said	say	VBD
38430	918	71	collection	collection	NN
38430	918	72	has	have	VBZ
38430	918	73	no	no	DT
38430	918	74	total	total	NN
38430	918	75	.	.	.
38430	918	76	'	'	''
38430	919	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	919	2	shall	shall	MD
38430	919	3	call	call	VB
38430	919	4	this	this	DT
38430	919	5	the	the	DT
38430	919	6	'	'	``
38430	919	7	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	919	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	919	9	circle	circle	NN
38430	919	10	principle	principle	NN
38430	919	11	,	,	,
38430	919	12	'	'	''
38430	919	13	because	because	IN
38430	919	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	919	15	enables	enable	VBZ
38430	919	16	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	919	17	to	to	TO
38430	919	18	avoid	avoid	VB
38430	919	19	the	the	DT
38430	919	20	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	919	21	circles	circle	NNS
38430	919	22	involved	involve	VBN
38430	919	23	in	in	IN
38430	919	24	the	the	DT
38430	919	25	assumption	assumption	NN
38430	919	26	of	of	IN
38430	919	27	illegitimate	illegitimate	JJ
38430	919	28	totalities	totality	NNS
38430	919	29	.	.	.
38430	920	1	Arguments	argument	NNS
38430	920	2	which	which	WDT
38430	920	3	are	be	VBP
38430	920	4	condemned	condemn	VBN
38430	920	5	by	by	IN
38430	920	6	the	the	DT
38430	920	7	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	920	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	920	9	circle	circle	NN
38430	920	10	principle	principle	NN
38430	920	11	will	will	MD
38430	920	12	be	be	VB
38430	920	13	called	call	VBN
38430	920	14	'	'	``
38430	920	15	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	920	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	920	17	circle	circle	NN
38430	920	18	fallacies	fallacy	NNS
38430	920	19	.	.	.
38430	920	20	'	'	''
38430	921	1	Such	such	JJ
38430	921	2	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	921	3	,	,	,
38430	921	4	in	in	IN
38430	921	5	certain	certain	JJ
38430	921	6	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
38430	921	7	,	,	,
38430	921	8	may	may	MD
38430	921	9	lead	lead	VB
38430	921	10	to	to	IN
38430	921	11	contradictions	contradiction	NNS
38430	921	12	,	,	,
38430	921	13	but	but	CC
38430	921	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	921	15	often	often	RB
38430	921	16	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	921	17	that	that	IN
38430	921	18	the	the	DT
38430	921	19	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
38430	921	20	to	to	TO
38430	921	21	which	which	WDT
38430	921	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	921	23	lead	lead	VBP
38430	921	24	are	be	VBP
38430	921	25	in	in	IN
38430	921	26	fact	fact	NN
38430	921	27	true	true	JJ
38430	921	28	,	,	,
38430	921	29	though	though	IN
38430	921	30	the	the	DT
38430	921	31	arguments	argument	NNS
38430	921	32	are	be	VBP
38430	921	33	fallacious	fallacious	JJ
38430	921	34	.	.	.
38430	922	1	Take	take	VB
38430	922	2	,	,	,
38430	922	3	for	for	IN
38430	922	4	example	example	NN
38430	922	5	,	,	,
38430	922	6	the	the	DT
38430	922	7	law	law	NN
38430	922	8	of	of	IN
38430	922	9	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	922	10	middle	middle	NN
38430	922	11	in	in	IN
38430	922	12	the	the	DT
38430	922	13	form	form	NN
38430	922	14	'	'	''
38430	922	15	all	all	DT
38430	922	16	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	922	17	are	be	VBP
38430	922	18	true	true	JJ
38430	922	19	or	or	CC
38430	922	20	false	false	JJ
38430	922	21	.	.	.
38430	922	22	'	'	''
38430	923	1	If	if	IN
38430	923	2	from	from	IN
38430	923	3	this	this	DT
38430	923	4	law	law	NN
38430	923	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	923	6	argue	argue	VBP
38430	923	7	that	that	IN
38430	923	8	,	,	,
38430	923	9	because	because	IN
38430	923	10	the	the	DT
38430	923	11	law	law	NN
38430	923	12	of	of	IN
38430	923	13	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	923	14	middle	middle	NN
38430	923	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	923	16	a	a	DT
38430	923	17	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	923	18	,	,	,
38430	923	19	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	923	20	the	the	DT
38430	923	21	law	law	NN
38430	923	22	of	of	IN
38430	923	23	excluded	exclude	VBN
38430	923	24	middle	middle	NN
38430	923	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	923	26	true	true	JJ
38430	923	27	or	or	CC
38430	923	28	false	false	JJ
38430	923	29	,	,	,
38430	923	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	923	31	incur	incur	VBP
38430	923	32	a	a	DT
38430	923	33	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	923	34	-	-	HYPH
38430	923	35	circle	circle	NN
38430	923	36	fallacy	fallacy	NN
38430	923	37	.	.	.
38430	924	1	'	'	``
38430	924	2	All	all	DT
38430	924	3	propositions	proposition	NNS
38430	924	4	'	'	''
38430	924	5	must	must	MD
38430	924	6	be	be	VB
38430	924	7	in	in	IN
38430	924	8	some	some	DT
38430	924	9	way	way	NN
38430	924	10	limited	limit	VBN
38430	924	11	before	before	IN
38430	924	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	924	13	becomes	become	VBZ
38430	924	14	a	a	DT
38430	924	15	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	924	16	totality	totality	NN
38430	924	17	,	,	,
38430	924	18	and	and	CC
38430	924	19	any	any	DT
38430	924	20	limitation	limitation	NN
38430	924	21	which	which	WDT
38430	924	22	makes	make	VBZ
38430	924	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	924	24	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
38430	924	25	must	must	MD
38430	924	26	make	make	VB
38430	924	27	any	any	DT
38430	924	28	statement	statement	NN
38430	924	29	about	about	IN
38430	924	30	the	the	DT
38430	924	31	totality	totality	NN
38430	924	32	fall	fall	NN
38430	924	33	outside	outside	IN
38430	924	34	the	the	DT
38430	924	35	totality	totality	NN
38430	924	36	.	.	.
38430	925	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
38430	925	2	the	the	DT
38430	925	3	imaginary	imaginary	JJ
38430	925	4	sceptic	sceptic	NN
38430	925	5	who	who	WP
38430	925	6	asserts	assert	VBZ
38430	925	7	that	that	IN
38430	925	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	925	9	knows	know	VBZ
38430	925	10	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	925	11	and	and	CC
38430	925	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	925	13	refuted	refute	VBN
38430	925	14	by	by	IN
38430	925	15	being	be	VBG
38430	925	16	asked	ask	VBN
38430	925	17	if	if	IN
38430	925	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	925	19	knows	know	VBZ
38430	925	20	that	that	IN
38430	925	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	925	22	knows	know	VBZ
38430	925	23	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	925	24	,	,	,
38430	925	25	has	have	VBZ
38430	925	26	asserted	assert	VBN
38430	925	27	nonsense	nonsense	NN
38430	925	28	,	,	,
38430	925	29	and	and	CC
38430	925	30	has	have	VBZ
38430	925	31	been	be	VBN
38430	925	32	fallaciously	fallaciously	RB
38430	925	33	refuted	refute	VBN
38430	925	34	by	by	IN
38430	925	35	an	an	DT
38430	925	36	argument	argument	NN
38430	925	37	which	which	WDT
38430	925	38	involves	involve	VBZ
38430	925	39	a	a	DT
38430	925	40	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	925	41	-	-	HYPH
38430	925	42	circle	circle	NN
38430	925	43	fallacy	fallacy	NN
38430	925	44	.	.	.
38430	926	1	In	in	IN
38430	926	2	order	order	NN
38430	926	3	that	that	IN
38430	926	4	the	the	DT
38430	926	5	sceptic	sceptic	NN
38430	926	6	's	's	POS
38430	926	7	assertion	assertion	NN
38430	926	8	may	may	MD
38430	926	9	become	become	VB
38430	926	10	significant	significant	JJ
38430	926	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	926	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	926	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
38430	926	14	to	to	TO
38430	926	15	place	place	VB
38430	926	16	some	some	DT
38430	926	17	limitation	limitation	NN
38430	926	18	upon	upon	IN
38430	926	19	the	the	DT
38430	926	20	things	thing	NNS
38430	926	21	of	of	IN
38430	926	22	which	which	WDT
38430	926	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	926	24	is	be	VBZ
38430	926	25	asserting	assert	VBG
38430	926	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	926	27	ignorance	ignorance	NN
38430	926	28	;	;	:
38430	926	29	the	the	DT
38430	926	30	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	926	31	that	that	IN
38430	926	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	926	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	926	34	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
38430	926	35	of	of	IN
38430	926	36	every	every	DT
38430	926	37	member	member	NN
38430	926	38	of	of	IN
38430	926	39	this	this	DT
38430	926	40	collection	collection	NN
38430	926	41	must	must	MD
38430	926	42	not	not	RB
38430	926	43	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	926	44	be	be	VB
38430	926	45	one	one	CD
38430	926	46	of	of	IN
38430	926	47	the	the	DT
38430	926	48	collection	collection	NN
38430	926	49	.	.	.
38430	927	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	927	2	any	any	DT
38430	927	3	significant	significant	JJ
38430	927	4	scepticism	scepticism	NN
38430	927	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	927	6	not	not	RB
38430	927	7	open	open	JJ
38430	927	8	to	to	IN
38430	927	9	the	the	DT
38430	927	10	above	above	JJ
38430	927	11	form	form	NN
38430	927	12	of	of	IN
38430	927	13	refutation	refutation	NN
38430	927	14	.	.	.
38430	927	15	"	"	''
38430	928	1	In	in	IN
38430	928	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	928	3	,	,	,
38430	928	4	the	the	DT
38430	928	5	world	world	NN
38430	928	6	of	of	IN
38430	928	7	things	thing	NNS
38430	928	8	falls	fall	VBZ
38430	928	9	into	into	IN
38430	928	10	various	various	JJ
38430	928	11	sets	set	NNS
38430	928	12	of	of	IN
38430	928	13	things	thing	NNS
38430	928	14	of	of	IN
38430	928	15	the	the	DT
38430	928	16	same	same	JJ
38430	928	17	"	"	``
38430	928	18	type	type	NN
38430	928	19	.	.	.
38430	928	20	"	"	''
38430	929	1	For	for	IN
38430	929	2	every	every	DT
38430	929	3	propositional	propositional	JJ
38430	929	4	function	function	NN
38430	929	5	[	[	-LRB-
38430	929	6	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	929	7	:	:	:
38430	929	8	ph](_x	ph](_x	NNP
38430	929	9	_	_	NNP
38430	929	10	)	)	-RRB-
38430	929	11	there	there	EX
38430	929	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	929	13	a	a	DT
38430	929	14	range	range	NN
38430	929	15	of	of	IN
38430	929	16	values	value	NNS
38430	929	17	of	of	IN
38430	929	18	_	_	NNP
38430	929	19	x	x	NNP
38430	929	20	_	_	NNP
38430	929	21	for	for	IN
38430	929	22	which	which	WDT
38430	929	23	[	[	-LRB-
38430	929	24	Greek	Greek	NNP
38430	929	25	:	:	:
38430	929	26	ph](_x	ph](_x	NNP
38430	929	27	_	_	NNP
38430	929	28	)	)	-RRB-
38430	929	29	has	have	VBZ
38430	929	30	a	a	DT
38430	929	31	signification	signification	NN
38430	929	32	as	as	IN
38430	929	33	a	a	DT
38430	929	34	true	true	JJ
38430	929	35	or	or	CC
38430	929	36	a	a	DT
38430	929	37	false	false	JJ
38430	929	38	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	929	39	.	.	.
38430	930	1	Until	until	IN
38430	930	2	this	this	DT
38430	930	3	theory	theory	NN
38430	930	4	was	be	VBD
38430	930	5	brought	bring	VBN
38430	930	6	forward	forward	RB
38430	930	7	,	,	,
38430	930	8	there	there	EX
38430	930	9	were	be	VBD
38430	930	10	occasionally	occasionally	RB
38430	930	11	discussions	discussion	NNS
38430	930	12	as	as	IN
38430	930	13	to	to	IN
38430	930	14	whether	whether	IN
38430	930	15	an	an	DT
38430	930	16	object	object	NN
38430	930	17	which	which	WDT
38430	930	18	did	do	VBD
38430	930	19	not	not	RB
38430	930	20	belong	belong	VB
38430	930	21	to	to	IN
38430	930	22	the	the	DT
38430	930	23	range	range	NN
38430	930	24	of	of	IN
38430	930	25	a	a	DT
38430	930	26	certain	certain	JJ
38430	930	27	propositional	propositional	JJ
38430	930	28	function	function	NN
38430	930	29	possessed	possess	VBD
38430	930	30	the	the	DT
38430	930	31	corresponding	correspond	VBG
38430	930	32	property	property	NN
38430	930	33	or	or	CC
38430	930	34	not	not	RB
38430	930	35	.	.	.
38430	931	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	931	2	,	,	,
38430	931	3	Jevons	Jevons	NNP
38430	931	4	,	,	,
38430	931	5	in	in	IN
38430	931	6	early	early	JJ
38430	931	7	days,[114	days,[114	NNP
38430	931	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	931	9	was	be	VBD
38430	931	10	of	of	IN
38430	931	11	opinion	opinion	NN
38430	931	12	that	that	DT
38430	931	13	virtue	virtue	NN
38430	931	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	931	15	neither	neither	DT
38430	931	16	black	black	JJ
38430	931	17	nor	nor	CC
38430	931	18	not	not	RB
38430	931	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	931	20	black	black	JJ
38430	931	21	because	because	IN
38430	931	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	931	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	931	24	not	not	RB
38430	931	25	coloured	colour	VBN
38430	931	26	,	,	,
38430	931	27	but	but	CC
38430	931	28	rather	rather	RB
38430	931	29	later[115	later[115	LS
38430	931	30	]	]	-RRB-
38430	931	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	931	32	admitted	admit	VBD
38430	931	33	that	that	DT
38430	931	34	virtue	virtue	NN
38430	931	35	is	be	VBZ
38430	931	36	not	not	RB
38430	931	37	triangular	triangular	JJ
38430	931	38	.	.	.
38430	932	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	932	2	116	116	CD
38430	932	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	932	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	932	5	:	:	:
38430	932	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	932	7	113	113	CD
38430	932	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	932	9	_	_	NNP
38430	932	10	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
38430	933	1	Ma	Ma	NNP
38430	933	2	.	.	.
38430	933	3	_	_	NNP
38430	933	4	,	,	,
38430	933	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	933	6	40	40	CD
38430	933	7	.	.	.
38430	934	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	934	2	114	114	CD
38430	934	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	934	4	_	_	NNP
38430	934	5	S.	S.	NNP
38430	935	1	o.	o.	NNP
38430	935	2	S.	S.	NNP
38430	935	3	_	_	NNP
38430	935	4	pp	pp	NNP
38430	935	5	.	.	.
38430	936	1	36	36	CD
38430	936	2	-	-	SYM
38430	936	3	7	7	CD
38430	936	4	.	.	.
38430	937	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	937	2	115	115	CD
38430	937	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	937	4	_	_	NNP
38430	937	5	E.	E.	NNP
38430	938	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	938	2	L.	L.	NNP
38430	938	3	_	_	NNP
38430	938	4	,	,	,
38430	938	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	938	6	.	.	.
38430	939	1	120	120	CD
38430	939	2	-	-	SYM
38430	939	3	1	1	CD
38430	939	4	.	.	.
38430	940	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	940	2	116	116	CD
38430	940	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	940	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	940	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	940	6	may	may	MD
38430	940	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	940	8	be	be	VB
38430	940	9	added	add	VBN
38430	940	10	that	that	IN
38430	940	11	,	,	,
38430	940	12	some	some	DT
38430	940	13	years	year	NNS
38430	940	14	after	after	IN
38430	940	15	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	940	16	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	940	17	's	's	POS
38430	940	18	death	death	NN
38430	940	19	,	,	,
38430	940	20	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
38430	940	21	Whitehead	Whitehead	NNP
38430	940	22	stated	state	VBD
38430	940	23	,	,	,
38430	940	24	in	in	IN
38430	940	25	an	an	DT
38430	940	26	address	address	NN
38430	940	27	delivered	deliver	VBN
38430	940	28	in	in	IN
38430	940	29	1916	1916	CD
38430	940	30	and	and	CC
38430	940	31	reprinted	reprint	VBN
38430	940	32	in	in	IN
38430	940	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	940	34	book	book	NN
38430	940	35	on	on	IN
38430	940	36	_	_	NNP
38430	940	37	The	the	DT
38430	940	38	Organisation	Organisation	NNP
38430	940	39	of	of	IN
38430	940	40	Thought	Thought	NNP
38430	940	41	_	_	NNP
38430	940	42	(	(	-LRB-
38430	940	43	London	London	NNP
38430	940	44	,	,	,
38430	940	45	1917	1917	CD
38430	940	46	,	,	,
38430	940	47	p.	p.	NN
38430	940	48	120	120	CD
38430	940	49	)	)	-RRB-
38430	940	50	,	,	,
38430	940	51	that	that	IN
38430	940	52	"	"	``
38430	940	53	the	the	DT
38430	940	54	specific	specific	JJ
38430	940	55	heat	heat	NN
38430	940	56	of	of	IN
38430	940	57	virtue	virtue	NN
38430	940	58	is	be	VBZ
38430	940	59	0.003	0.003	CD
38430	940	60	is	be	VBZ
38430	940	61	,	,	,
38430	940	62	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	940	63	should	should	MD
38430	940	64	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	940	65	,	,	,
38430	940	66	not	not	RB
38430	940	67	a	a	DT
38430	940	68	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	940	69	at	at	RB
38430	940	70	all	all	RB
38430	940	71	,	,	,
38430	940	72	so	so	IN
38430	940	73	that	that	IN
38430	940	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	940	75	is	be	VBZ
38430	940	76	neither	neither	CC
38430	940	77	true	true	JJ
38430	940	78	nor	nor	CC
38430	940	79	false	false	JJ
38430	940	80	....	....	NFP
38430	940	81	"--ED	"--ED	''
38430	940	82	.	.	.
38430	940	83	]	]	-RRB-
38430	941	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	941	2	XXXIX	xxxix	VBP
38430	941	3	THE	the	DT
38430	941	4	HIERARCHY	HIERARCHY	NNS
38430	941	5	OF	of	IN
38430	941	6	JOKES	JOKES	NNP
38430	941	7	Jokes	joke	NNS
38430	941	8	may	may	MD
38430	941	9	be	be	VB
38430	941	10	divided	divide	VBN
38430	941	11	into	into	IN
38430	941	12	various	various	JJ
38430	941	13	types	type	NNS
38430	941	14	.	.	.
38430	942	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	942	2	a	a	DT
38430	942	3	joke	joke	NN
38430	942	4	or	or	CC
38430	942	5	class	class	NN
38430	942	6	of	of	IN
38430	942	7	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	942	8	can	can	MD
38430	942	9	only	only	RB
38430	942	10	be	be	VB
38430	942	11	the	the	DT
38430	942	12	subject	subject	NN
38430	942	13	of	of	IN
38430	942	14	a	a	DT
38430	942	15	joke	joke	NN
38430	942	16	of	of	IN
38430	942	17	higher	high	JJR
38430	942	18	order	order	NN
38430	942	19	.	.	.
38430	943	1	Otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	943	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	943	3	would	would	MD
38430	943	4	get	get	VB
38430	943	5	the	the	DT
38430	943	6	same	same	JJ
38430	943	7	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	943	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	943	9	circle	circle	NN
38430	943	10	fallacy	fallacy	NN
38430	943	11	which	which	WDT
38430	943	12	gives	give	VBZ
38430	943	13	rise	rise	NN
38430	943	14	to	to	IN
38430	943	15	so	so	RB
38430	943	16	many	many	JJ
38430	943	17	paradoxes	paradox	NNS
38430	943	18	in	in	IN
38430	943	19	logic	logic	NN
38430	943	20	and	and	CC
38430	943	21	mathematics	mathematic	NNS
38430	943	22	.	.	.
38430	944	1	A	a	DT
38430	944	2	certain	certain	JJ
38430	944	3	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
38430	944	4	scholar	scholar	NN
38430	944	5	succeeded	succeed	VBD
38430	944	6	,	,	,
38430	944	7	to	to	IN
38430	944	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	944	9	own	own	JJ
38430	944	10	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
38430	944	11	,	,	,
38430	944	12	in	in	IN
38430	944	13	reducing	reduce	VBG
38430	944	14	all	all	DT
38430	944	15	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	944	16	to	to	IN
38430	944	17	primitive	primitive	JJ
38430	944	18	types	type	NNS
38430	944	19	,	,	,
38430	944	20	consisting	consist	VBG
38430	944	21	of	of	IN
38430	944	22	thirty	thirty	CD
38430	944	23	-	-	HYPH
38430	944	24	seven	seven	CD
38430	944	25	proto	proto	RB
38430	944	26	-	-	:
38430	944	27	Aryan	aryan	JJ
38430	944	28	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	944	29	.	.	.
38430	945	1	When	when	WRB
38430	945	2	any	any	DT
38430	945	3	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	945	4	was	be	VBD
38430	945	5	propounded	propound	VBN
38430	945	6	to	to	IN
38430	945	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	945	8	,	,	,
38430	945	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	945	10	would	would	MD
38430	945	11	reflect	reflect	VB
38430	945	12	and	and	CC
38430	945	13	afterwards	afterwards	RB
38430	945	14	pronounce	pronounce	NN
38430	945	15	on	on	IN
38430	945	16	the	the	DT
38430	945	17	question	question	NN
38430	945	18	as	as	IN
38430	945	19	to	to	IN
38430	945	20	whether	whether	IN
38430	945	21	the	the	DT
38430	945	22	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	945	23	was	be	VBD
38430	945	24	a	a	DT
38430	945	25	joke	joke	NN
38430	945	26	or	or	CC
38430	945	27	not	not	RB
38430	945	28	.	.	.
38430	946	1	If	if	IN
38430	946	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	946	3	decided	decide	VBD
38430	946	4	,	,	,
38430	946	5	by	by	IN
38430	946	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	946	7	theory	theory	NN
38430	946	8	,	,	,
38430	946	9	that	that	IN
38430	946	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	946	11	was	be	VBD
38430	946	12	a	a	DT
38430	946	13	joke	joke	NN
38430	946	14	,	,	,
38430	946	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	946	16	would	would	MD
38430	946	17	solemnly	solemnly	RB
38430	946	18	say	say	VB
38430	946	19	:	:	:
38430	946	20	"	"	``
38430	946	21	There	there	RB
38430	946	22	_	_	NNP
38430	946	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	946	24	_	_	NNP
38430	946	25	that	that	DT
38430	946	26	joke	joke	NN
38430	946	27	.	.	.
38430	946	28	"	"	''
38430	947	1	If	if	IN
38430	947	2	this	this	DT
38430	947	3	narration	narration	NN
38430	947	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	947	5	accepted	accept	VBN
38430	947	6	as	as	IN
38430	947	7	a	a	DT
38430	947	8	joke	joke	NN
38430	947	9	,	,	,
38430	947	10	since	since	IN
38430	947	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	947	12	can	can	MD
38430	947	13	not	not	RB
38430	947	14	be	be	VB
38430	947	15	reduced	reduce	VBN
38430	947	16	to	to	IN
38430	947	17	one	one	CD
38430	947	18	of	of	IN
38430	947	19	the	the	DT
38430	947	20	proto	proto	RB
38430	947	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	947	22	Aryan	aryan	JJ
38430	947	23	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	947	24	under	under	IN
38430	947	25	pain	pain	NN
38430	947	26	of	of	IN
38430	947	27	leading	lead	VBG
38430	947	28	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	947	29	to	to	TO
38430	947	30	commit	commit	VB
38430	947	31	a	a	DT
38430	947	32	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	947	33	-	-	HYPH
38430	947	34	circle	circle	NN
38430	947	35	fallacy	fallacy	NN
38430	947	36	,	,	,
38430	947	37	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	947	38	must	must	MD
38430	947	39	conclude	conclude	VB
38430	947	40	that	that	IN
38430	947	41	there	there	EX
38430	947	42	is	be	VBZ
38430	947	43	at	at	RB
38430	947	44	least	least	RBS
38430	947	45	one	one	CD
38430	947	46	joke	joke	NN
38430	947	47	which	which	WDT
38430	947	48	is	be	VBZ
38430	947	49	not	not	RB
38430	947	50	proto	proto	JJ
38430	947	51	-	-	:
38430	947	52	Aryan	Aryan	NNP
38430	947	53	;	;	:
38430	947	54	and	and	CC
38430	947	55	,	,	,
38430	947	56	in	in	IN
38430	947	57	fact	fact	NN
38430	947	58	,	,	,
38430	947	59	is	be	VBZ
38430	947	60	of	of	IN
38430	947	61	a	a	DT
38430	947	62	higher	high	JJR
38430	947	63	type	type	NN
38430	947	64	.	.	.
38430	948	1	There	there	EX
38430	948	2	is	be	VBZ
38430	948	3	no	no	DT
38430	948	4	great	great	JJ
38430	948	5	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	948	6	in	in	IN
38430	948	7	forming	form	VBG
38430	948	8	a	a	DT
38430	948	9	hierarchy	hierarchy	NN
38430	948	10	of	of	IN
38430	948	11	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	948	12	of	of	IN
38430	948	13	various	various	JJ
38430	948	14	types	type	NNS
38430	948	15	.	.	.
38430	949	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	949	2	a	a	DT
38430	949	3	joke	joke	NN
38430	949	4	of	of	IN
38430	949	5	the	the	DT
38430	949	6	fourth	fourth	JJ
38430	949	7	type	type	NN
38430	949	8	(	(	-LRB-
38430	949	9	or	or	CC
38430	949	10	order	order	NN
38430	949	11	)	)	-RRB-
38430	949	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	949	13	as	as	IN
38430	949	14	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	949	15	:	:	:
38430	949	16	A	a	DT
38430	949	17	joke	joke	NN
38430	949	18	of	of	IN
38430	949	19	the	the	DT
38430	949	20	first	first	JJ
38430	949	21	order	order	NN
38430	949	22	was	be	VBD
38430	949	23	told	tell	VBN
38430	949	24	to	to	IN
38430	949	25	a	a	DT
38430	949	26	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	949	27	,	,	,
38430	949	28	who	who	WP
38430	949	29	,	,	,
38430	949	30	as	as	IN
38430	949	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	949	32	would	would	MD
38430	949	33	expect	expect	VB
38430	949	34	,	,	,
38430	949	35	was	be	VBD
38430	949	36	unable	unable	JJ
38430	949	37	to	to	TO
38430	949	38	see	see	VB
38430	949	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	949	40	.	.	.
38430	950	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	950	2	117	117	CD
38430	950	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	950	4	The	the	DT
38430	950	5	person	person	NN
38430	950	6	(	(	-LRB-
38430	950	7	A	a	NN
38430	950	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	950	9	who	who	WP
38430	950	10	told	tell	VBD
38430	950	11	this	this	DT
38430	950	12	joke	joke	NN
38430	950	13	told	tell	VBD
38430	950	14	the	the	DT
38430	950	15	story	story	NN
38430	950	16	of	of	IN
38430	950	17	how	how	WRB
38430	950	18	the	the	DT
38430	950	19	joke	joke	NN
38430	950	20	was	be	VBD
38430	950	21	received	receive	VBN
38430	950	22	to	to	IN
38430	950	23	another	another	DT
38430	950	24	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	950	25	thereby	thereby	RB
38430	950	26	making	make	VBG
38430	950	27	a	a	DT
38430	950	28	joke	joke	NN
38430	950	29	about	about	IN
38430	950	30	a	a	DT
38430	950	31	joke	joke	NN
38430	950	32	of	of	IN
38430	950	33	the	the	DT
38430	950	34	first	first	JJ
38430	950	35	order	order	NN
38430	950	36	,	,	,
38430	950	37	and	and	CC
38430	950	38	thus	thus	RB
38430	950	39	making	make	VBG
38430	950	40	a	a	DT
38430	950	41	joke	joke	NN
38430	950	42	of	of	IN
38430	950	43	the	the	DT
38430	950	44	second	second	JJ
38430	950	45	order	order	NN
38430	950	46	.	.	.
38430	951	1	A	a	DT
38430	951	2	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	951	3	on	on	IN
38430	951	4	this	this	DT
38430	951	5	joke	joke	NN
38430	951	6	that	that	IN
38430	951	7	no	no	DT
38430	951	8	joke	joke	NN
38430	951	9	could	could	MD
38430	951	10	penetrate	penetrate	VB
38430	951	11	the	the	DT
38430	951	12	head	head	NN
38430	951	13	of	of	IN
38430	951	14	the	the	DT
38430	951	15	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	951	16	to	to	TO
38430	951	17	whom	whom	WP
38430	951	18	the	the	DT
38430	951	19	joke	joke	NN
38430	951	20	of	of	IN
38430	951	21	the	the	DT
38430	951	22	first	first	JJ
38430	951	23	order	order	NN
38430	951	24	was	be	VBD
38430	951	25	told	tell	VBN
38430	951	26	,	,	,
38430	951	27	even	even	RB
38430	951	28	if	if	IN
38430	951	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	951	30	were	be	VBD
38430	951	31	fired	fire	VBN
38430	951	32	into	into	IN
38430	951	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	951	34	head	head	NN
38430	951	35	with	with	IN
38430	951	36	a	a	DT
38430	951	37	gun	gun	NN
38430	951	38	.	.	.
38430	952	1	The	the	DT
38430	952	2	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	952	3	,	,	,
38430	952	4	after	after	IN
38430	952	5	severe	severe	JJ
38430	952	6	thought	thought	NN
38430	952	7	,	,	,
38430	952	8	replied	reply	VBD
38430	952	9	:	:	:
38430	952	10	"	"	``
38430	952	11	But	but	CC
38430	952	12	ye	ye	PRP
38430	952	13	could	could	MD
38430	952	14	n't	not	RB
38430	952	15	do	do	VB
38430	952	16	that	that	DT
38430	952	17	,	,	,
38430	952	18	ye	ye	NNP
38430	952	19	know	know	VBP
38430	952	20	!	!	.
38430	952	21	"	"	''
38430	953	1	A	a	DT
38430	953	2	repeated	repeat	VBD
38430	953	3	the	the	DT
38430	953	4	whole	whole	JJ
38430	953	5	story	story	NN
38430	953	6	,	,	,
38430	953	7	which	which	WDT
38430	953	8	constituted	constitute	VBD
38430	953	9	a	a	DT
38430	953	10	joke	joke	NN
38430	953	11	of	of	IN
38430	953	12	the	the	DT
38430	953	13	third	third	JJ
38430	953	14	order	order	NN
38430	953	15	,	,	,
38430	953	16	to	to	IN
38430	953	17	a	a	DT
38430	953	18	third	third	JJ
38430	953	19	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	953	20	.	.	.
38430	954	1	This	this	DT
38430	954	2	last	last	JJ
38430	954	3	Scotchman	Scotchman	NNP
38430	954	4	again	again	RB
38430	954	5	,	,	,
38430	954	6	after	after	IN
38430	954	7	prolonged	prolonged	JJ
38430	954	8	thought	thought	NN
38430	954	9	,	,	,
38430	954	10	replied	reply	VBD
38430	954	11	:	:	:
38430	954	12	"	"	``
38430	954	13	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	954	14	had	have	VBD
38430	954	15	ye	ye	PRP
38430	954	16	there	there	RB
38430	954	17	!	!	.
38430	954	18	"	"	''
38430	955	1	This	this	DT
38430	955	2	whole	whole	JJ
38430	955	3	story	story	NN
38430	955	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	955	5	a	a	DT
38430	955	6	joke	joke	NN
38430	955	7	of	of	IN
38430	955	8	the	the	DT
38430	955	9	fourth	fourth	JJ
38430	955	10	order	order	NN
38430	955	11	.	.	.
38430	956	1	Most	Most	JJS
38430	956	2	known	known	JJ
38430	956	3	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	956	4	are	be	VBP
38430	956	5	of	of	IN
38430	956	6	the	the	DT
38430	956	7	first	first	JJ
38430	956	8	order	order	NN
38430	956	9	,	,	,
38430	956	10	for	for	IN
38430	956	11	the	the	DT
38430	956	12	simple	simple	JJ
38430	956	13	reason	reason	NN
38430	956	14	that	that	IN
38430	956	15	the	the	DT
38430	956	16	majority	majority	NN
38430	956	17	of	of	IN
38430	956	18	people	people	NNS
38430	956	19	find	find	VBP
38430	956	20	that	that	IN
38430	956	21	the	the	DT
38430	956	22	slightest	slight	JJS
38430	956	23	mental	mental	JJ
38430	956	24	effort	effort	NN
38430	956	25	effectually	effectually	RB
38430	956	26	destroys	destroy	VBZ
38430	956	27	any	any	DT
38430	956	28	perception	perception	NN
38430	956	29	of	of	IN
38430	956	30	humour	humour	NN
38430	956	31	.	.	.
38430	957	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	957	2	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	957	3	to	to	IN
38430	957	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	957	5	that	that	IN
38430	957	6	a	a	DT
38430	957	7	joke	joke	NN
38430	957	8	becomes	become	VBZ
38430	957	9	more	more	RBR
38430	957	10	pleasurable	pleasurable	JJ
38430	957	11	in	in	IN
38430	957	12	proportion	proportion	NN
38430	957	13	as	as	IN
38430	957	14	logical	logical	JJ
38430	957	15	faculties	faculty	NNS
38430	957	16	are	be	VBP
38430	957	17	brought	bring	VBN
38430	957	18	into	into	IN
38430	957	19	play	play	NN
38430	957	20	by	by	IN
38430	957	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	957	22	;	;	:
38430	957	23	and	and	CC
38430	957	24	hence	hence	RB
38430	957	25	that	that	DT
38430	957	26	logical	logical	JJ
38430	957	27	power	power	NN
38430	957	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	957	29	allied	ally	VBN
38430	957	30	,	,	,
38430	957	31	or	or	CC
38430	957	32	possibly	possibly	RB
38430	957	33	identical	identical	JJ
38430	957	34	,	,	,
38430	957	35	with	with	IN
38430	957	36	the	the	DT
38430	957	37	power	power	NN
38430	957	38	of	of	IN
38430	957	39	grasping	grasp	VBG
38430	957	40	more	more	JJR
38430	957	41	subtle	subtle	JJ
38430	957	42	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	957	43	.	.	.
38430	958	1	The	the	DT
38430	958	2	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	958	3	which	which	WDT
38430	958	4	amuse	amuse	VBP
38430	958	5	the	the	DT
38430	958	6	frequenters	frequenter	NNS
38430	958	7	of	of	IN
38430	958	8	music	music	NN
38430	958	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	958	10	halls	hall	NNS
38430	958	11	,	,	,
38430	958	12	Conservatives	Conservatives	NNPS
38430	958	13	,	,	,
38430	958	14	and	and	CC
38430	958	15	M.	M.	NNP
38430	958	16	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	958	17	--	--	:
38430	958	18	and	and	CC
38430	958	19	which	which	WDT
38430	958	20	usually	usually	RB
38430	958	21	deal	deal	VBP
38430	958	22	with	with	IN
38430	958	23	accidents	accident	NNS
38430	958	24	,	,	,
38430	958	25	physical	physical	JJ
38430	958	26	defects	defect	NNS
38430	958	27	,	,	,
38430	958	28	mothers	mother	NNS
38430	958	29	-	-	HYPH
38430	958	30	in	in	IN
38430	958	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	958	32	law	law	NN
38430	958	33	,	,	,
38430	958	34	foreigners	foreigner	NNS
38430	958	35	,	,	,
38430	958	36	or	or	CC
38430	958	37	over	over	IN
38430	958	38	-	-	HYPH
38430	958	39	ripe	ripe	JJ
38430	958	40	cheese	cheese	NN
38430	958	41	--	--	:
38430	958	42	are	be	VBP
38430	958	43	usually	usually	RB
38430	958	44	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	958	45	of	of	IN
38430	958	46	the	the	DT
38430	958	47	first	first	JJ
38430	958	48	order	order	NN
38430	958	49	.	.	.
38430	959	1	Jokes	joke	NNS
38430	959	2	of	of	IN
38430	959	3	the	the	DT
38430	959	4	second	second	JJ
38430	959	5	,	,	,
38430	959	6	and	and	CC
38430	959	7	even	even	RB
38430	959	8	of	of	IN
38430	959	9	the	the	DT
38430	959	10	third	third	JJ
38430	959	11	,	,	,
38430	959	12	order	order	NN
38430	959	13	appeal	appeal	NN
38430	959	14	to	to	IN
38430	959	15	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
38430	959	16	well	well	RB
38430	959	17	-	-	HYPH
38430	959	18	educated	educate	VBN
38430	959	19	people	people	NNS
38430	959	20	;	;	:
38430	959	21	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	959	22	of	of	IN
38430	959	23	higher	high	JJR
38430	959	24	order	order	NN
38430	959	25	require	require	VBP
38430	959	26	either	either	CC
38430	959	27	special	special	JJ
38430	959	28	ability	ability	NN
38430	959	29	or	or	CC
38430	959	30	a	a	DT
38430	959	31	sound	sound	JJ
38430	959	32	logical	logical	JJ
38430	959	33	training	training	NN
38430	959	34	on	on	IN
38430	959	35	the	the	DT
38430	959	36	part	part	NN
38430	959	37	of	of	IN
38430	959	38	the	the	DT
38430	959	39	hearer	hearer	NNP
38430	959	40	if	if	IN
38430	959	41	the	the	DT
38430	959	42	joke	joke	NN
38430	959	43	is	be	VBZ
38430	959	44	to	to	TO
38430	959	45	be	be	VB
38430	959	46	appreciated	appreciate	VBN
38430	959	47	;	;	:
38430	959	48	while	while	IN
38430	959	49	jokes	joke	NNS
38430	959	50	of	of	IN
38430	959	51	transfinite	transfinite	JJ
38430	959	52	order	order	NN
38430	959	53	presumably	presumably	RB
38430	959	54	only	only	RB
38430	959	55	excite	excite	VBP
38430	959	56	the	the	DT
38430	959	57	inaudible	inaudible	JJ
38430	959	58	laughter	laughter	NN
38430	959	59	of	of	IN
38430	959	60	the	the	DT
38430	959	61	gods	god	NNS
38430	959	62	.	.	.
38430	960	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	960	2	:	:	:
38430	960	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	960	4	117	117	CD
38430	960	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	960	6	[	[	-LRB-
38430	960	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	960	8	may	may	MD
38430	960	9	be	be	VB
38430	960	10	that	that	DT
38430	960	11	,	,	,
38430	960	12	like	like	IN
38430	960	13	certain	certain	JJ
38430	960	14	remarks	remark	NNS
38430	960	15	about	about	IN
38430	960	16	cheese	cheese	NN
38430	960	17	and	and	CC
38430	960	18	mothers	mother	NNS
38430	960	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	960	20	in	in	IN
38430	960	21	-	-	HYPH
38430	960	22	law	law	NN
38430	960	23	(	(	-LRB-
38430	960	24	see	see	VB
38430	960	25	below	below	RB
38430	960	26	)	)	-RRB-
38430	960	27	,	,	,
38430	960	28	the	the	DT
38430	960	29	statement	statement	NN
38430	960	30	that	that	IN
38430	960	31	Scotchmen	Scotchmen	NNP
38430	960	32	can	can	MD
38430	960	33	not	not	RB
38430	960	34	see	see	VB
38430	960	35	jokes	jokes	NNP
38430	960	36	is	be	VBZ
38430	960	37	a	a	DT
38430	960	38	joke	joke	NN
38430	960	39	of	of	IN
38430	960	40	the	the	DT
38430	960	41	first	first	JJ
38430	960	42	order.--ED	order.--ed	NN
38430	960	43	.	.	.
38430	960	44	]	]	-RRB-
38430	961	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	961	2	XL	XL	NNP
38430	961	3	THE	the	DT
38430	961	4	EVIDENCE	evidence	NN
38430	961	5	OF	of	IN
38430	961	6	GEOMETRICAL	GEOMETRICAL	NNP
38430	961	7	PROPOSITIONS	proposition	NNS
38430	961	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	961	9	has	have	VBZ
38430	961	10	often	often	RB
38430	961	11	been	be	VBN
38430	961	12	maintained	maintain	VBN
38430	961	13	that	that	IN
38430	961	14	the	the	DT
38430	961	15	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
38430	961	16	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	961	17	of	of	IN
38430	961	18	the	the	DT
38430	961	19	first	first	JJ
38430	961	20	book	book	NN
38430	961	21	of	of	IN
38430	961	22	Euclid	Euclid	NNP
38430	961	23	--	--	:
38430	961	24	that	that	IN
38430	961	25	two	two	CD
38430	961	26	sides	side	NNS
38430	961	27	of	of	IN
38430	961	28	a	a	DT
38430	961	29	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	961	30	are	be	VBP
38430	961	31	together	together	RB
38430	961	32	greater	great	JJR
38430	961	33	than	than	IN
38430	961	34	the	the	DT
38430	961	35	third	third	JJ
38430	961	36	side	side	NN
38430	961	37	--	--	:
38430	961	38	is	be	VBZ
38430	961	39	evident	evident	JJ
38430	961	40	even	even	RB
38430	961	41	to	to	IN
38430	961	42	asses	ass	NNS
38430	961	43	.	.	.
38430	962	1	This	this	DT
38430	962	2	does	do	VBZ
38430	962	3	not	not	RB
38430	962	4	,	,	,
38430	962	5	however	however	RB
38430	962	6	,	,	,
38430	962	7	seem	seem	VBP
38430	962	8	to	to	IN
38430	962	9	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	962	10	generally	generally	RB
38430	962	11	true	true	JJ
38430	962	12	.	.	.
38430	963	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	963	2	once	once	RB
38430	963	3	asked	ask	VBD
38430	963	4	a	a	DT
38430	963	5	coastguardsman	coastguardsman	NN
38430	963	6	the	the	DT
38430	963	7	distance	distance	NN
38430	963	8	from	from	IN
38430	963	9	A	a	NN
38430	963	10	to	to	IN
38430	963	11	B	b	NN
38430	963	12	;	;	:
38430	963	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	963	14	replied	reply	VBD
38430	963	15	:	:	:
38430	963	16	"	"	``
38430	963	17	Eight	eight	CD
38430	963	18	miles	mile	NNS
38430	963	19	.	.	.
38430	963	20	"	"	''
38430	964	1	On	on	IN
38430	964	2	further	further	JJ
38430	964	3	inquiry	inquiry	NN
38430	964	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	964	5	elicited	elicit	VBD
38430	964	6	the	the	DT
38430	964	7	fact	fact	NN
38430	964	8	that	that	IN
38430	964	9	the	the	DT
38430	964	10	distance	distance	NN
38430	964	11	from	from	IN
38430	964	12	A	A	NNP
38430	964	13	to	to	IN
38430	964	14	C	C	NNP
38430	964	15	was	be	VBD
38430	964	16	two	two	CD
38430	964	17	miles	mile	NNS
38430	964	18	and	and	CC
38430	964	19	the	the	DT
38430	964	20	distance	distance	NN
38430	964	21	from	from	IN
38430	964	22	C	C	NNP
38430	964	23	to	to	IN
38430	964	24	B	b	NN
38430	964	25	was	be	VBD
38430	964	26	twenty	twenty	CD
38430	964	27	-	-	HYPH
38430	964	28	two	two	CD
38430	964	29	miles	mile	NNS
38430	964	30	.	.	.
38430	965	1	Now	now	RB
38430	965	2	the	the	DT
38430	965	3	paths	path	NNS
38430	965	4	from	from	IN
38430	965	5	A	a	NN
38430	965	6	to	to	IN
38430	965	7	B	b	NN
38430	965	8	and	and	CC
38430	965	9	from	from	IN
38430	965	10	C	c	NN
38430	965	11	to	to	IN
38430	965	12	B	b	NN
38430	965	13	were	be	VBD
38430	965	14	by	by	IN
38430	965	15	sea	sea	NN
38430	965	16	;	;	:
38430	965	17	while	while	IN
38430	965	18	the	the	DT
38430	965	19	path	path	NN
38430	965	20	from	from	IN
38430	965	21	A	a	NN
38430	965	22	to	to	IN
38430	965	23	C	C	NNP
38430	965	24	was	be	VBD
38430	965	25	by	by	IN
38430	965	26	land	land	NN
38430	965	27	.	.	.
38430	966	1	Hence	hence	RB
38430	966	2	if	if	IN
38430	966	3	the	the	DT
38430	966	4	path	path	NN
38430	966	5	by	by	IN
38430	966	6	land	land	NN
38430	966	7	was	be	VBD
38430	966	8	rugged	rugge	VBN
38430	966	9	and	and	CC
38430	966	10	the	the	DT
38430	966	11	distance	distance	NN
38430	966	12	along	along	IN
38430	966	13	the	the	DT
38430	966	14	road	road	NN
38430	966	15	was	be	VBD
38430	966	16	two	two	CD
38430	966	17	miles	mile	NNS
38430	966	18	,	,	,
38430	966	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	966	20	would	would	MD
38430	966	21	appear	appear	VB
38430	966	22	that	that	IN
38430	966	23	the	the	DT
38430	966	24	coastguardsman	coastguardsman	NN
38430	966	25	believed	believe	VBD
38430	966	26	that	that	IN
38430	966	27	not	not	RB
38430	966	28	only	only	RB
38430	966	29	could	could	MD
38430	966	30	one	one	CD
38430	966	31	side	side	NN
38430	966	32	of	of	IN
38430	966	33	a	a	DT
38430	966	34	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	966	35	be	be	VB
38430	966	36	greater	great	JJR
38430	966	37	than	than	IN
38430	966	38	the	the	DT
38430	966	39	other	other	JJ
38430	966	40	two	two	CD
38430	966	41	,	,	,
38430	966	42	but	but	CC
38430	966	43	that	that	IN
38430	966	44	one	one	CD
38430	966	45	straight	straight	JJ
38430	966	46	side	side	NN
38430	966	47	of	of	IN
38430	966	48	a	a	DT
38430	966	49	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	966	50	might	may	MD
38430	966	51	be	be	VB
38430	966	52	greater	great	JJR
38430	966	53	than	than	IN
38430	966	54	one	one	CD
38430	966	55	straight	straight	JJ
38430	966	56	side	side	NN
38430	966	57	and	and	CC
38430	966	58	any	any	DT
38430	966	59	curvilinear	curvilinear	NN
38430	966	60	side	side	NN
38430	966	61	of	of	IN
38430	966	62	the	the	DT
38430	966	63	same	same	JJ
38430	966	64	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	966	65	.	.	.
38430	967	1	The	the	DT
38430	967	2	only	only	JJ
38430	967	3	escape	escape	NN
38430	967	4	from	from	IN
38430	967	5	part	part	NN
38430	967	6	of	of	IN
38430	967	7	this	this	DT
38430	967	8	astonishing	astonishing	JJ
38430	967	9	creed	creed	NN
38430	967	10	would	would	MD
38430	967	11	be	be	VB
38430	967	12	by	by	IN
38430	967	13	assuming	assume	VBG
38430	967	14	that	that	IN
38430	967	15	the	the	DT
38430	967	16	distance	distance	NN
38430	967	17	of	of	IN
38430	967	18	two	two	CD
38430	967	19	miles	mile	NNS
38430	967	20	from	from	IN
38430	967	21	A	a	NN
38430	967	22	to	to	IN
38430	967	23	C	C	NNP
38430	967	24	was	be	VBD
38430	967	25	measured	measure	VBN
38430	967	26	"	"	''
38430	967	27	as	as	IN
38430	967	28	the	the	DT
38430	967	29	crow	crow	NN
38430	967	30	flies	fly	VBZ
38430	967	31	,	,	,
38430	967	32	"	"	``
38430	967	33	while	while	IN
38430	967	34	the	the	DT
38430	967	35	road	road	NN
38430	967	36	A	A	NNP
38430	967	37	to	to	IN
38430	967	38	C	C	NNP
38430	967	39	was	be	VBD
38430	967	40	so	so	RB
38430	967	41	hilly	hilly	RB
38430	967	42	that	that	IN
38430	967	43	a	a	DT
38430	967	44	pedestrian	pedestrian	NN
38430	967	45	would	would	MD
38430	967	46	traverse	traverse	VB
38430	967	47	more	more	JJR
38430	967	48	than	than	IN
38430	967	49	fourteen	fourteen	CD
38430	967	50	miles	mile	NNS
38430	967	51	when	when	WRB
38430	967	52	proceeding	proceed	VBG
38430	967	53	from	from	IN
38430	967	54	A	a	DT
38430	967	55	to	to	IN
38430	967	56	C.	C.	NNP
38430	967	57	Then	then	RB
38430	967	58	indeed	indeed	RB
38430	967	59	the	the	DT
38430	967	60	coastguardsman	coastguardsman	NN
38430	967	61	could	could	MD
38430	967	62	maintain	maintain	VB
38430	967	63	the	the	DT
38430	967	64	true	true	JJ
38430	967	65	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	967	66	that	that	IN
38430	967	67	there	there	EX
38430	967	68	is	be	VBZ
38430	967	69	at	at	RB
38430	967	70	least	least	RBS
38430	967	71	one	one	CD
38430	967	72	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	967	73	ABC	ABC	NNP
38430	967	74	,	,	,
38430	967	75	with	with	IN
38430	967	76	the	the	DT
38430	967	77	side	side	NN
38430	967	78	AC	AC	NNP
38430	967	79	curvilinear	curvilinear	NN
38430	967	80	,	,	,
38430	967	81	such	such	JJ
38430	967	82	that	that	IN
38430	967	83	the	the	DT
38430	967	84	sum	sum	NN
38430	967	85	of	of	IN
38430	967	86	the	the	DT
38430	967	87	lengths	length	NNS
38430	967	88	of	of	IN
38430	967	89	AB	AB	NNP
38430	967	90	and	and	CC
38430	967	91	AC	AC	NNP
38430	967	92	is	be	VBZ
38430	967	93	greater	great	JJR
38430	967	94	than	than	IN
38430	967	95	the	the	DT
38430	967	96	length	length	NN
38430	967	97	of	of	IN
38430	967	98	BC	BC	NNP
38430	967	99	,	,	,
38430	967	100	and	and	CC
38430	967	101	only	only	RB
38430	967	102	deny	deny	VB
38430	967	103	the	the	DT
38430	967	104	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
38430	967	105	proposition	proposition	NN
38430	967	106	of	of	IN
38430	967	107	the	the	DT
38430	967	108	first	first	JJ
38430	967	109	book	book	NN
38430	967	110	of	of	IN
38430	967	111	Euclid	Euclid	NNP
38430	967	112	.	.	.
38430	968	1	Reasoning	reason	VBG
38430	968	2	with	with	IN
38430	968	3	the	the	DT
38430	968	4	coastguardsman	coastguardsman	NN
38430	968	5	only	only	RB
38430	968	6	had	have	VBD
38430	968	7	the	the	DT
38430	968	8	effect	effect	NN
38430	968	9	of	of	IN
38430	968	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	968	11	adducing	adduce	VBG
38430	968	12	the	the	DT
38430	968	13	authority	authority	NN
38430	968	14	of	of	IN
38430	968	15	one	one	CD
38430	968	16	Captain	Captain	NNP
38430	968	17	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	968	18	in	in	IN
38430	968	19	support	support	NN
38430	968	20	of	of	IN
38430	968	21	the	the	DT
38430	968	22	accuracy	accuracy	NN
38430	968	23	of	of	IN
38430	968	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	968	25	data	datum	NNS
38430	968	26	.	.	.
38430	969	1	Possibly	possibly	RB
38430	969	2	Captain	Captain	NNP
38430	969	3	Jones	Jones	NNP
38430	969	4	held	hold	VBD
38430	969	5	strange	strange	JJ
38430	969	6	views	view	NNS
38430	969	7	as	as	IN
38430	969	8	to	to	IN
38430	969	9	the	the	DT
38430	969	10	influence	influence	NN
38430	969	11	of	of	IN
38430	969	12	temperature	temperature	NN
38430	969	13	or	or	CC
38430	969	14	other	other	JJ
38430	969	15	physical	physical	JJ
38430	969	16	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
38430	969	17	,	,	,
38430	969	18	or	or	CC
38430	969	19	even	even	RB
38430	969	20	the	the	DT
38430	969	21	nature	nature	NN
38430	969	22	of	of	IN
38430	969	23	space	space	NN
38430	969	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	969	25	,	,	,
38430	969	26	on	on	IN
38430	969	27	the	the	DT
38430	969	28	lengths	length	NNS
38430	969	29	of	of	IN
38430	969	30	lines	line	NNS
38430	969	31	in	in	IN
38430	969	32	the	the	DT
38430	969	33	neighbourhood	neighbourhood	NN
38430	969	34	of	of	IN
38430	969	35	the	the	DT
38430	969	36	triangle	triangle	NN
38430	969	37	ABC	ABC	NNP
38430	969	38	.	.	.
38430	970	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	970	2	XLI	XLI	NNP
38430	970	3	ABSOLUTE	ABSOLUTE	NNP
38430	970	4	AND	and	CC
38430	970	5	RELATIVE	RELATIVE	VBD
38430	970	6	POSITION	POSITION	VBD
38430	970	7	Some	some	DT
38430	970	8	people	people	NNS
38430	970	9	maintain	maintain	VBP
38430	970	10	that	that	DT
38430	970	11	position	position	NN
38430	970	12	in	in	IN
38430	970	13	space	space	NN
38430	970	14	or	or	CC
38430	970	15	time	time	NN
38430	970	16	must	must	MD
38430	970	17	be	be	VB
38430	970	18	relative	relative	JJ
38430	970	19	because	because	IN
38430	970	20	,	,	,
38430	970	21	if	if	IN
38430	970	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	970	23	try	try	VBP
38430	970	24	to	to	TO
38430	970	25	determine	determine	VB
38430	970	26	the	the	DT
38430	970	27	position	position	NN
38430	970	28	of	of	IN
38430	970	29	a	a	DT
38430	970	30	body	body	NN
38430	970	31	A	a	NN
38430	970	32	,	,	,
38430	970	33	if	if	IN
38430	970	34	bodies	body	NNS
38430	970	35	B	B	NNP
38430	970	36	,	,	,
38430	970	37	C	C	NNP
38430	970	38	,	,	,
38430	970	39	D	d	NN
38430	970	40	with	with	IN
38430	970	41	respect	respect	NN
38430	970	42	to	to	TO
38430	970	43	which	which	WDT
38430	970	44	the	the	DT
38430	970	45	position	position	NN
38430	970	46	of	of	IN
38430	970	47	A	a	DT
38430	970	48	could	could	MD
38430	970	49	be	be	VB
38430	970	50	determined	determine	VBN
38430	970	51	were	be	VBD
38430	970	52	not	not	RB
38430	970	53	present	present	JJ
38430	970	54	,	,	,
38430	970	55	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	970	56	should	should	MD
38430	970	57	be	be	VB
38430	970	58	trying	try	VBG
38430	970	59	to	to	TO
38430	970	60	determine	determine	VB
38430	970	61	something	something	NN
38430	970	62	about	about	IN
38430	970	63	A	a	DT
38430	970	64	without	without	IN
38430	970	65	having	have	VBG
38430	970	66	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	970	67	senses	sense	NNS
38430	970	68	affected	affect	VBN
38430	970	69	by	by	IN
38430	970	70	other	other	JJ
38430	970	71	things	thing	NNS
38430	970	72	.	.	.
38430	971	1	These	these	DT
38430	971	2	people	people	NNS
38430	971	3	seem	seem	VBP
38430	971	4	to	to	IN
38430	971	5	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	971	6	to	to	TO
38430	971	7	be	be	VB
38430	971	8	like	like	IN
38430	971	9	the	the	DT
38430	971	10	cautious	cautious	JJ
38430	971	11	guest	guest	NN
38430	971	12	who	who	WP
38430	971	13	refused	refuse	VBD
38430	971	14	to	to	TO
38430	971	15	say	say	VB
38430	971	16	anything	anything	NN
38430	971	17	about	about	IN
38430	971	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	971	19	host	host	NN
38430	971	20	's	's	POS
38430	971	21	port	port	NN
38430	971	22	-	-	HYPH
38430	971	23	wine	wine	NN
38430	971	24	until	until	IN
38430	971	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	971	26	had	have	VBD
38430	971	27	tasted	taste	VBN
38430	971	28	red	red	JJ
38430	971	29	ink	ink	NN
38430	971	30	.	.	.
38430	972	1	"	"	``
38430	972	2	Wherein	Wherein	NNP
38430	972	3	,	,	,
38430	972	4	then	then	RB
38430	972	5	,	,	,
38430	972	6	"	"	''
38430	972	7	says	say	VBZ
38430	972	8	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	972	9	Russell,[118	Russell,[118	NNP
38430	972	10	]	]	-RRB-
38430	972	11	"	"	``
38430	972	12	lies	lie	VBZ
38430	972	13	the	the	DT
38430	972	14	plausibility	plausibility	NN
38430	972	15	of	of	IN
38430	972	16	the	the	DT
38430	972	17	notion	notion	NN
38430	972	18	that	that	IN
38430	972	19	all	all	DT
38430	972	20	points	point	NNS
38430	972	21	are	be	VBP
38430	972	22	exactly	exactly	RB
38430	972	23	alike	alike	JJ
38430	972	24	?	?	.
38430	973	1	This	this	DT
38430	973	2	notion	notion	NN
38430	973	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	973	4	,	,	,
38430	973	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	973	6	believe	believe	VBP
38430	973	7	,	,	,
38430	973	8	a	a	DT
38430	973	9	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	973	10	illusion	illusion	NN
38430	973	11	,	,	,
38430	973	12	due	due	IN
38430	973	13	to	to	IN
38430	973	14	the	the	DT
38430	973	15	fact	fact	NN
38430	973	16	that	that	IN
38430	973	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	973	18	can	can	MD
38430	973	19	not	not	RB
38430	973	20	remember	remember	VB
38430	973	21	a	a	DT
38430	973	22	point	point	NN
38430	973	23	so	so	IN
38430	973	24	as	as	IN
38430	973	25	to	to	TO
38430	973	26	know	know	VB
38430	973	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	973	28	when	when	WRB
38430	973	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	973	30	meet	meet	VBP
38430	973	31	again	again	RB
38430	973	32	.	.	.
38430	974	1	Among	among	IN
38430	974	2	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
38430	974	3	presented	present	VBN
38430	974	4	points	point	NNS
38430	974	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	974	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	974	7	easy	easy	JJ
38430	974	8	to	to	TO
38430	974	9	distinguish	distinguish	VB
38430	974	10	;	;	:
38430	974	11	but	but	CC
38430	974	12	though	though	IN
38430	974	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	974	14	are	be	VBP
38430	974	15	perpetually	perpetually	RB
38430	974	16	moving	move	VBG
38430	974	17	,	,	,
38430	974	18	and	and	CC
38430	974	19	thus	thus	RB
38430	974	20	being	be	VBG
38430	974	21	brought	bring	VBN
38430	974	22	among	among	IN
38430	974	23	new	new	JJ
38430	974	24	points	point	NNS
38430	974	25	,	,	,
38430	974	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	974	27	are	be	VBP
38430	974	28	quite	quite	RB
38430	974	29	unable	unable	JJ
38430	974	30	to	to	TO
38430	974	31	detect	detect	VB
38430	974	32	this	this	DT
38430	974	33	fact	fact	NN
38430	974	34	by	by	IN
38430	974	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	974	36	senses	sense	NNS
38430	974	37	,	,	,
38430	974	38	and	and	CC
38430	974	39	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	974	40	recognize	recognize	VBP
38430	974	41	places	place	NNS
38430	974	42	only	only	RB
38430	974	43	by	by	IN
38430	974	44	the	the	DT
38430	974	45	objects	object	NNS
38430	974	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	974	47	contain	contain	VBP
38430	974	48	.	.	.
38430	975	1	But	but	CC
38430	975	2	this	this	DT
38430	975	3	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	975	4	to	to	TO
38430	975	5	be	be	VB
38430	975	6	a	a	DT
38430	975	7	mere	mere	JJ
38430	975	8	blindness	blindness	NN
38430	975	9	on	on	IN
38430	975	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	975	11	part	part	NN
38430	975	12	--	--	:
38430	975	13	there	there	EX
38430	975	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	975	15	no	no	DT
38430	975	16	difficulty	difficulty	NN
38430	975	17	,	,	,
38430	975	18	so	so	RB
38430	975	19	far	far	RB
38430	975	20	as	as	IN
38430	975	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	975	22	can	can	MD
38430	975	23	see	see	VB
38430	975	24	,	,	,
38430	975	25	in	in	IN
38430	975	26	supposing	suppose	VBG
38430	975	27	an	an	DT
38430	975	28	immediate	immediate	JJ
38430	975	29	difference	difference	NN
38430	975	30	between	between	IN
38430	975	31	points	point	NNS
38430	975	32	,	,	,
38430	975	33	as	as	IN
38430	975	34	between	between	IN
38430	975	35	colours	colour	NNS
38430	975	36	,	,	,
38430	975	37	but	but	CC
38430	975	38	a	a	DT
38430	975	39	difference	difference	NN
38430	975	40	which	which	WDT
38430	975	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	975	42	senses	sense	NNS
38430	975	43	are	be	VBP
38430	975	44	not	not	RB
38430	975	45	constructed	construct	VBN
38430	975	46	to	to	TO
38430	975	47	be	be	VB
38430	975	48	aware	aware	JJ
38430	975	49	of	of	IN
38430	975	50	.	.	.
38430	976	1	Let	let	VB
38430	976	2	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	976	3	take	take	VB
38430	976	4	an	an	DT
38430	976	5	analogy	analogy	NN
38430	976	6	:	:	:
38430	976	7	Suppose	suppose	VB
38430	976	8	a	a	DT
38430	976	9	man	man	NN
38430	976	10	with	with	IN
38430	976	11	a	a	DT
38430	976	12	very	very	RB
38430	976	13	bad	bad	JJ
38430	976	14	memory	memory	NN
38430	976	15	for	for	IN
38430	976	16	faces	face	NNS
38430	976	17	;	;	:
38430	976	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	976	19	would	would	MD
38430	976	20	be	be	VB
38430	976	21	able	able	JJ
38430	976	22	to	to	TO
38430	976	23	know	know	VB
38430	976	24	,	,	,
38430	976	25	at	at	IN
38430	976	26	any	any	DT
38430	976	27	moment	moment	NN
38430	976	28	,	,	,
38430	976	29	whether	whether	IN
38430	976	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	976	31	saw	see	VBD
38430	976	32	one	one	CD
38430	976	33	face	face	NN
38430	976	34	or	or	CC
38430	976	35	many	many	JJ
38430	976	36	,	,	,
38430	976	37	but	but	CC
38430	976	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	976	39	would	would	MD
38430	976	40	not	not	RB
38430	976	41	be	be	VB
38430	976	42	aware	aware	JJ
38430	976	43	whether	whether	IN
38430	976	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	976	45	had	have	VBD
38430	976	46	seen	see	VBN
38430	976	47	any	any	DT
38430	976	48	of	of	IN
38430	976	49	the	the	DT
38430	976	50	faces	face	NNS
38430	976	51	before	before	RB
38430	976	52	.	.	.
38430	977	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	977	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	977	3	might	may	MD
38430	977	4	be	be	VB
38430	977	5	led	lead	VBN
38430	977	6	to	to	TO
38430	977	7	define	define	VB
38430	977	8	people	people	NNS
38430	977	9	by	by	IN
38430	977	10	the	the	DT
38430	977	11	rooms	room	NNS
38430	977	12	in	in	IN
38430	977	13	which	which	WDT
38430	977	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	977	15	saw	see	VBD
38430	977	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	977	17	,	,	,
38430	977	18	and	and	CC
38430	977	19	to	to	TO
38430	977	20	suppose	suppose	VB
38430	977	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	977	22	self	self	NN
38430	977	23	-	-	HYPH
38430	977	24	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
38430	977	25	that	that	IN
38430	977	26	new	new	JJ
38430	977	27	people	people	NNS
38430	977	28	should	should	MD
38430	977	29	come	come	VB
38430	977	30	to	to	IN
38430	977	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	977	32	lectures	lecture	NNS
38430	977	33	,	,	,
38430	977	34	or	or	CC
38430	977	35	that	that	IN
38430	977	36	old	old	JJ
38430	977	37	people	people	NNS
38430	977	38	should	should	MD
38430	977	39	cease	cease	VB
38430	977	40	to	to	TO
38430	977	41	do	do	VB
38430	977	42	so	so	RB
38430	977	43	.	.	.
38430	978	1	In	in	IN
38430	978	2	the	the	DT
38430	978	3	latter	latter	JJ
38430	978	4	point	point	NN
38430	978	5	at	at	IN
38430	978	6	least	least	JJS
38430	978	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	978	8	will	will	MD
38430	978	9	be	be	VB
38430	978	10	admitted	admit	VBN
38430	978	11	by	by	IN
38430	978	12	lecturers	lecturer	NNS
38430	978	13	that	that	IN
38430	978	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	978	15	would	would	MD
38430	978	16	be	be	VB
38430	978	17	mistaken	mistaken	JJ
38430	978	18	.	.	.
38430	979	1	And	and	CC
38430	979	2	as	as	IN
38430	979	3	with	with	IN
38430	979	4	faces	face	NNS
38430	979	5	,	,	,
38430	979	6	so	so	CC
38430	979	7	with	with	IN
38430	979	8	points	point	NNS
38430	979	9	--	--	:
38430	979	10	inability	inability	NN
38430	979	11	to	to	TO
38430	979	12	recognize	recognize	VB
38430	979	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	979	14	must	must	MD
38430	979	15	be	be	VB
38430	979	16	attributed	attribute	VBN
38430	979	17	,	,	,
38430	979	18	not	not	RB
38430	979	19	to	to	IN
38430	979	20	the	the	DT
38430	979	21	absence	absence	NN
38430	979	22	of	of	IN
38430	979	23	individuality	individuality	NN
38430	979	24	,	,	,
38430	979	25	but	but	CC
38430	979	26	merely	merely	RB
38430	979	27	to	to	IN
38430	979	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	979	29	incapacity	incapacity	NN
38430	979	30	.	.	.
38430	979	31	"	"	''
38430	980	1	Another	another	DT
38430	980	2	form	form	NN
38430	980	3	of	of	IN
38430	980	4	this	this	DT
38430	980	5	tendency	tendency	NN
38430	980	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	980	7	shown	show	VBN
38430	980	8	by	by	IN
38430	980	9	Kronecker	Kronecker	NNP
38430	980	10	,	,	,
38430	980	11	Borel	Borel	NNP
38430	980	12	,	,	,
38430	980	13	Poincaré	Poincaré	NNP
38430	980	14	,	,	,
38430	980	15	and	and	CC
38430	980	16	many	many	JJ
38430	980	17	other	other	JJ
38430	980	18	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	980	19	,	,	,
38430	980	20	who	who	WP
38430	980	21	refuse	refuse	VBP
38430	980	22	mere	mere	JJ
38430	980	23	logical	logical	JJ
38430	980	24	determination	determination	NN
38430	980	25	of	of	IN
38430	980	26	a	a	DT
38430	980	27	conception	conception	NN
38430	980	28	and	and	CC
38430	980	29	require	require	VBP
38430	980	30	that	that	IN
38430	980	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	980	32	be	be	VB
38430	980	33	actually	actually	RB
38430	980	34	described	describe	VBN
38430	980	35	in	in	IN
38430	980	36	a	a	DT
38430	980	37	finite	finite	JJ
38430	980	38	number	number	NN
38430	980	39	of	of	IN
38430	980	40	terms	term	NNS
38430	980	41	.	.	.
38430	981	1	These	these	DT
38430	981	2	eminent	eminent	JJ
38430	981	3	mathematicians	mathematician	NNS
38430	981	4	were	be	VBD
38430	981	5	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
38430	981	6	by	by	IN
38430	981	7	the	the	DT
38430	981	8	empirical	empirical	JJ
38430	981	9	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	981	10	who	who	WP
38430	981	11	would	would	MD
38430	981	12	not	not	RB
38430	981	13	pronounce	pronounce	VB
38430	981	14	that	that	IN
38430	981	15	the	the	DT
38430	981	16	"	"	``
38430	981	17	law	law	NN
38430	981	18	of	of	IN
38430	981	19	thought	thought	NN
38430	981	20	"	"	''
38430	981	21	that	that	IN
38430	981	22	A	A	NNP
38430	981	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	981	24	either	either	CC
38430	981	25	in	in	IN
38430	981	26	the	the	DT
38430	981	27	place	place	NN
38430	981	28	B	b	NN
38430	981	29	or	or	CC
38430	981	30	not	not	RB
38430	981	31	is	be	VBZ
38430	981	32	true	true	JJ
38430	981	33	until	until	IN
38430	981	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	981	35	had	have	VBD
38430	981	36	looked	look	VBN
38430	981	37	to	to	TO
38430	981	38	make	make	VB
38430	981	39	sure	sure	JJ
38430	981	40	.	.	.
38430	982	1	This	this	DT
38430	982	2	philosopher	philosopher	NN
38430	982	3	was	be	VBD
38430	982	4	of	of	IN
38430	982	5	the	the	DT
38430	982	6	same	same	JJ
38430	982	7	school	school	NN
38430	982	8	as	as	IN
38430	982	9	J.	J.	NNP
38430	982	10	S.	S.	NNP
38430	982	11	Mill	Mill	NNP
38430	982	12	and	and	CC
38430	982	13	Buckle	Buckle	NNP
38430	982	14	,	,	,
38430	982	15	who	who	WP
38430	982	16	seem	seem	VBP
38430	982	17	to	to	TO
38430	982	18	have	have	VB
38430	982	19	maintained	maintain	VBN
38430	982	20	implicitly	implicitly	RB
38430	982	21	not	not	RB
38430	982	22	only	only	RB
38430	982	23	that	that	DT
38430	982	24	,	,	,
38430	982	25	in	in	IN
38430	982	26	view	view	NN
38430	982	27	of	of	IN
38430	982	28	the	the	DT
38430	982	29	fact	fact	NN
38430	982	30	that	that	IN
38430	982	31	the	the	DT
38430	982	32	breadth	breadth	NN
38430	982	33	of	of	IN
38430	982	34	a	a	DT
38430	982	35	geometrical	geometrical	JJ
38430	982	36	line	line	NN
38430	982	37	depends	depend	VBZ
38430	982	38	upon	upon	IN
38430	982	39	the	the	DT
38430	982	40	material	material	NN
38430	982	41	out	out	IN
38430	982	42	of	of	IN
38430	982	43	which	which	WDT
38430	982	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	982	45	is	be	VBZ
38430	982	46	constructed	construct	VBN
38430	982	47	,	,	,
38430	982	48	or	or	CC
38430	982	49	upon	upon	IN
38430	982	50	which	which	WDT
38430	982	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	982	52	is	be	VBZ
38430	982	53	drawn	draw	VBN
38430	982	54	,	,	,
38430	982	55	that	that	IN
38430	982	56	there	there	EX
38430	982	57	ought	ought	MD
38430	982	58	to	to	TO
38430	982	59	be	be	VB
38430	982	60	a	a	DT
38430	982	61	paste	paste	NN
38430	982	62	-	-	HYPH
38430	982	63	board	board	NN
38430	982	64	geometry	geometry	NN
38430	982	65	,	,	,
38430	982	66	a	a	DT
38430	982	67	stone	stone	NN
38430	982	68	geometry	geometry	NN
38430	982	69	,	,	,
38430	982	70	and	and	CC
38430	982	71	so	so	RB
38430	982	72	on;[119	on;[119	JJ
38430	982	73	]	]	-RRB-
38430	982	74	but	but	CC
38430	982	75	also	also	RB
38430	982	76	that	that	IN
38430	982	77	the	the	DT
38430	982	78	foundations	foundation	NNS
38430	982	79	of	of	IN
38430	982	80	logic	logic	NN
38430	982	81	are	be	VBP
38430	982	82	inductive	inductive	JJ
38430	982	83	in	in	IN
38430	982	84	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	982	85	nature	nature	NN
38430	982	86	.	.	.
38430	983	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	983	2	120	120	CD
38430	983	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	983	4	"	"	``
38430	983	5	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	983	6	can	can	MD
38430	983	7	not	not	RB
38430	983	8	,	,	,
38430	983	9	"	"	''
38430	983	10	says	say	VBZ
38430	983	11	Mill,[121	Mill,[121	NNP
38430	983	12	]	]	-RRB-
38430	983	13	"	"	``
38430	983	14	conceive	conceive	VB
38430	983	15	a	a	DT
38430	983	16	round	round	JJ
38430	983	17	square	square	NN
38430	983	18	,	,	,
38430	983	19	not	not	RB
38430	983	20	merely	merely	RB
38430	983	21	because	because	IN
38430	983	22	no	no	DT
38430	983	23	such	such	JJ
38430	983	24	object	object	NN
38430	983	25	has	have	VBZ
38430	983	26	ever	ever	RB
38430	983	27	presented	present	VBN
38430	983	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	983	29	in	in	IN
38430	983	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	983	31	experience	experience	NN
38430	983	32	,	,	,
38430	983	33	for	for	IN
38430	983	34	that	that	DT
38430	983	35	would	would	MD
38430	983	36	not	not	RB
38430	983	37	be	be	VB
38430	983	38	enough	enough	RB
38430	983	39	.	.	.
38430	984	1	Neither	neither	DT
38430	984	2	,	,	,
38430	984	3	for	for	IN
38430	984	4	anything	anything	NN
38430	984	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	984	6	know	know	VBP
38430	984	7	,	,	,
38430	984	8	are	be	VBP
38430	984	9	the	the	DT
38430	984	10	two	two	CD
38430	984	11	ideas	idea	NNS
38430	984	12	in	in	IN
38430	984	13	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	984	14	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
38430	984	15	.	.	.
38430	985	1	To	to	TO
38430	985	2	conceive	conceive	VB
38430	985	3	a	a	DT
38430	985	4	body	body	NN
38430	985	5	all	all	DT
38430	985	6	black	black	JJ
38430	985	7	and	and	CC
38430	985	8	yet	yet	RB
38430	985	9	white	white	JJ
38430	985	10	would	would	MD
38430	985	11	only	only	RB
38430	985	12	be	be	VB
38430	985	13	to	to	TO
38430	985	14	conceive	conceive	VB
38430	985	15	two	two	CD
38430	985	16	different	different	JJ
38430	985	17	sensations	sensation	NNS
38430	985	18	as	as	IN
38430	985	19	produced	produce	VBN
38430	985	20	in	in	IN
38430	985	21	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	985	22	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
38430	985	23	by	by	IN
38430	985	24	the	the	DT
38430	985	25	same	same	JJ
38430	985	26	object	object	NN
38430	985	27	--	--	:
38430	985	28	a	a	DT
38430	985	29	conception	conception	NN
38430	985	30	familiar	familiar	JJ
38430	985	31	to	to	IN
38430	985	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	985	33	experience	experience	NN
38430	985	34	--	--	:
38430	985	35	and	and	CC
38430	985	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	985	37	should	should	MD
38430	985	38	probably	probably	RB
38430	985	39	be	be	VB
38430	985	40	as	as	RB
38430	985	41	well	well	RB
38430	985	42	able	able	JJ
38430	985	43	to	to	TO
38430	985	44	conceive	conceive	VB
38430	985	45	a	a	DT
38430	985	46	round	round	JJ
38430	985	47	square	square	NN
38430	985	48	as	as	IN
38430	985	49	a	a	DT
38430	985	50	hard	hard	JJ
38430	985	51	square	square	NN
38430	985	52	,	,	,
38430	985	53	or	or	CC
38430	985	54	a	a	DT
38430	985	55	heavy	heavy	JJ
38430	985	56	square	square	NN
38430	985	57	,	,	,
38430	985	58	if	if	IN
38430	985	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	985	60	were	be	VBD
38430	985	61	not	not	RB
38430	985	62	that	that	DT
38430	985	63	in	in	IN
38430	985	64	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	985	65	uniform	uniform	JJ
38430	985	66	experience	experience	NN
38430	985	67	,	,	,
38430	985	68	at	at	IN
38430	985	69	the	the	DT
38430	985	70	instant	instant	NN
38430	985	71	when	when	WRB
38430	985	72	a	a	DT
38430	985	73	thing	thing	NN
38430	985	74	begins	begin	VBZ
38430	985	75	to	to	TO
38430	985	76	be	be	VB
38430	985	77	round	round	JJ
38430	985	78	,	,	,
38430	985	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	985	80	ceases	cease	VBZ
38430	985	81	to	to	TO
38430	985	82	be	be	VB
38430	985	83	square	square	JJ
38430	985	84	,	,	,
38430	985	85	so	so	IN
38430	985	86	that	that	IN
38430	985	87	the	the	DT
38430	985	88	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	985	89	of	of	IN
38430	985	90	the	the	DT
38430	985	91	one	one	CD
38430	985	92	impression	impression	NN
38430	985	93	is	be	VBZ
38430	985	94	inseparably	inseparably	RB
38430	985	95	associated	associate	VBN
38430	985	96	with	with	IN
38430	985	97	the	the	DT
38430	985	98	departure	departure	NN
38430	985	99	or	or	CC
38430	985	100	cessation	cessation	NN
38430	985	101	of	of	IN
38430	985	102	the	the	DT
38430	985	103	other	other	JJ
38430	985	104	.	.	.
38430	986	1	Thus	thus	RB
38430	986	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	986	3	inability	inability	NN
38430	986	4	to	to	TO
38430	986	5	form	form	VB
38430	986	6	a	a	DT
38430	986	7	conception	conception	NN
38430	986	8	always	always	RB
38430	986	9	arises	arise	VBZ
38430	986	10	from	from	IN
38430	986	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	986	12	being	be	VBG
38430	986	13	compelled	compel	VBN
38430	986	14	to	to	TO
38430	986	15	form	form	VB
38430	986	16	another	another	DT
38430	986	17	contradictory	contradictory	JJ
38430	986	18	to	to	IN
38430	986	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	986	20	.	.	.
38430	986	21	"	"	''
38430	987	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	987	2	:	:	:
38430	987	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	987	4	118	118	CD
38430	987	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	987	6	_	_	NNP
38430	987	7	Md.	Md.	NNP
38430	987	8	_	_	NNP
38430	987	9	,	,	,
38430	987	10	N.	N.	NNP
38430	987	11	S.	S.	NNP
38430	987	12	,	,	,
38430	987	13	vol	vol	NNP
38430	987	14	.	.	.
38430	988	1	x.	x.	NNP
38430	988	2	,	,	,
38430	988	3	July	July	NNP
38430	988	4	,	,	,
38430	988	5	1901	1901	CD
38430	988	6	,	,	,
38430	988	7	pp	pp	NNP
38430	988	8	.	.	.
38430	989	1	313	313	CD
38430	989	2	-	-	SYM
38430	989	3	14	14	CD
38430	989	4	.	.	.
38430	990	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	990	2	119	119	CD
38430	990	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	990	4	J.	J.	NNP
38430	991	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	991	2	Stallo	Stallo	NNP
38430	991	3	,	,	,
38430	991	4	_	_	NNP
38430	991	5	The	the	DT
38430	991	6	Concepts	Concepts	NNPS
38430	991	7	and	and	CC
38430	991	8	Theories	Theories	NNPS
38430	991	9	of	of	IN
38430	991	10	Modern	Modern	NNP
38430	991	11	Physics	Physics	NNP
38430	991	12	_	_	NNP
38430	991	13	,	,	,
38430	991	14	4th	4th	JJ
38430	991	15	ed	ed	NNP
38430	991	16	.	.	NNP
38430	991	17	,	,	,
38430	991	18	London	London	NNP
38430	991	19	,	,	,
38430	991	20	1900	1900	CD
38430	991	21	,	,	,
38430	991	22	pp	pp	NNP
38430	991	23	.	.	.
38430	992	1	217	217	CD
38430	992	2	-	-	SYM
38430	992	3	27	27	CD
38430	992	4	.	.	.
38430	993	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	993	2	120	120	CD
38430	993	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	993	4	_	_	NNP
38430	993	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
38430	993	6	.	.	.
38430	993	7	_	_	NNP
38430	993	8	,	,	,
38430	993	9	pp	pp	NNP
38430	993	10	.	.	.
38430	994	1	140	140	CD
38430	994	2	-	-	SYM
38430	994	3	4	4	CD
38430	994	4	.	.	.
38430	995	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	995	2	121	121	CD
38430	995	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	995	4	_	_	NNP
38430	995	5	Examination	Examination	NNP
38430	995	6	of	of	IN
38430	995	7	the	the	DT
38430	995	8	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
38430	995	9	of	of	IN
38430	995	10	Sir	Sir	NNP
38430	995	11	William	William	NNP
38430	995	12	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
38430	995	13	_	_	NNP
38430	995	14	,	,	,
38430	995	15	vol	vol	NNP
38430	995	16	.	.	.
38430	996	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	996	2	p.	p.	NNP
38430	996	3	88	88	CD
38430	996	4	,	,	,
38430	996	5	Amer	Amer	NNP
38430	996	6	.	.	.
38430	997	1	ed	ed	NNP
38430	997	2	.	.	.
38430	998	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	998	2	XLII	xlii	NN
38430	998	3	LAUGHTER	laughter	NN
38430	998	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	998	5	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	998	6	seemed	seem	VBD
38430	998	7	advisable	advisable	JJ
38430	998	8	to	to	TO
38430	998	9	give	give	VB
38430	998	10	here[122	here[122	.
38430	998	11	]	]	-RRB-
38430	998	12	some	some	DT
38430	998	13	views	view	NNS
38430	998	14	on	on	IN
38430	998	15	laughter	laughter	NN
38430	998	16	,	,	,
38430	998	17	most	most	JJS
38430	998	18	of	of	IN
38430	998	19	which	which	WDT
38430	998	20	were	be	VBD
38430	998	21	also	also	RB
38430	998	22	held	hold	VBN
38430	998	23	by	by	IN
38430	998	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	998	25	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	998	26	,	,	,
38430	998	27	though	though	IN
38430	998	28	no	no	DT
38430	998	29	written	write	VBN
38430	998	30	expression	expression	NN
38430	998	31	of	of	IN
38430	998	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	998	33	views	view	NNS
38430	998	34	has	have	VBZ
38430	998	35	yet	yet	RB
38430	998	36	been	be	VBN
38430	998	37	found	find	VBN
38430	998	38	.	.	.
38430	999	1	In	in	IN
38430	999	2	a	a	DT
38430	999	3	review[123	review[123	NN
38430	999	4	]	]	-RRB-
38430	999	5	of	of	IN
38430	999	6	M.	M.	NNP
38430	999	7	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	999	8	's	's	POS
38430	999	9	book	book	NN
38430	999	10	on	on	IN
38430	999	11	_	_	NNP
38430	999	12	Laughter_,[124	Laughter_,[124	NNP
38430	999	13	]	]	-RRB-
38430	999	14	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	999	15	Russell	Russell	NNP
38430	999	16	has	have	VBZ
38430	999	17	remarked	remark	VBN
38430	999	18	:	:	:
38430	999	19	"	"	``
38430	999	20	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	999	21	has	have	VBZ
38430	999	22	long	long	RB
38430	999	23	been	be	VBN
38430	999	24	recognized	recognize	VBN
38430	999	25	by	by	IN
38430	999	26	publishers	publisher	NNS
38430	999	27	that	that	IN
38430	999	28	everybody	everybody	NN
38430	999	29	desires	desire	VBZ
38430	999	30	to	to	TO
38430	999	31	be	be	VB
38430	999	32	a	a	DT
38430	999	33	perfect	perfect	JJ
38430	999	34	lady	lady	NN
38430	999	35	or	or	CC
38430	999	36	gentleman	gentleman	NNP
38430	999	37	(	(	-LRB-
38430	999	38	as	as	IN
38430	999	39	the	the	DT
38430	999	40	case	case	NN
38430	999	41	may	may	MD
38430	999	42	be	be	VB
38430	999	43	)	)	-RRB-
38430	999	44	;	;	:
38430	999	45	to	to	IN
38430	999	46	this	this	DT
38430	999	47	fact	fact	NN
38430	999	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	999	49	owe	owe	VBP
38430	999	50	the	the	DT
38430	999	51	constant	constant	JJ
38430	999	52	stream	stream	NN
38430	999	53	of	of	IN
38430	999	54	etiquette	etiquette	NN
38430	999	55	-	-	HYPH
38430	999	56	books	book	NNS
38430	999	57	.	.	.
38430	1000	1	But	but	CC
38430	1000	2	if	if	IN
38430	1000	3	there	there	EX
38430	1000	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	1000	5	one	one	CD
38430	1000	6	thing	thing	NN
38430	1000	7	which	which	WDT
38430	1000	8	people	people	NNS
38430	1000	9	desire	desire	VBP
38430	1000	10	even	even	RB
38430	1000	11	more	more	RBR
38430	1000	12	,	,	,
38430	1000	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1000	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	1000	15	to	to	TO
38430	1000	16	have	have	VB
38430	1000	17	a	a	DT
38430	1000	18	faultless	faultless	JJ
38430	1000	19	sense	sense	NN
38430	1000	20	of	of	IN
38430	1000	21	humour	humour	NN
38430	1000	22	.	.	.
38430	1001	1	Yet	yet	RB
38430	1001	2	so	so	RB
38430	1001	3	far	far	RB
38430	1001	4	as	as	IN
38430	1001	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1001	6	know	know	VBP
38430	1001	7	,	,	,
38430	1001	8	there	there	EX
38430	1001	9	is	be	VBZ
38430	1001	10	no	no	DT
38430	1001	11	book	book	NN
38430	1001	12	called	call	VBN
38430	1001	13	'	'	''
38430	1001	14	Jokes	joke	NNS
38430	1001	15	without	without	IN
38430	1001	16	Tears	tear	NNS
38430	1001	17	,	,	,
38430	1001	18	by	by	IN
38430	1001	19	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1002	1	McQuedy	McQuedy	NNP
38430	1002	2	.	.	.
38430	1002	3	'	'	''
38430	1003	1	This	this	DT
38430	1003	2	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
38430	1003	3	lacuna	lacuna	NN
38430	1003	4	has	have	VBZ
38430	1003	5	now	now	RB
38430	1003	6	been	be	VBN
38430	1003	7	filled	fill	VBN
38430	1003	8	.	.	.
38430	1004	1	Those	those	DT
38430	1004	2	to	to	IN
38430	1004	3	whom	whom	WP
38430	1004	4	laughter	laughter	NN
38430	1004	5	has	have	VBZ
38430	1004	6	hitherto	hitherto	VBN
38430	1004	7	been	be	VBN
38430	1004	8	an	an	DT
38430	1004	9	unintelligible	unintelligible	JJ
38430	1004	10	vagary	vagary	NN
38430	1004	11	,	,	,
38430	1004	12	in	in	IN
38430	1004	13	which	which	WDT
38430	1004	14	one	one	PRP
38430	1004	15	must	must	MD
38430	1004	16	join	join	VB
38430	1004	17	,	,	,
38430	1004	18	though	though	IN
38430	1004	19	one	one	PRP
38430	1004	20	could	could	MD
38430	1004	21	never	never	RB
38430	1004	22	tell	tell	VB
38430	1004	23	when	when	WRB
38430	1004	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1004	25	would	would	MD
38430	1004	26	break	break	VB
38430	1004	27	out	out	RP
38430	1004	28	,	,	,
38430	1004	29	need	need	VB
38430	1004	30	only	only	RB
38430	1004	31	study	study	VB
38430	1004	32	M.	M.	NNP
38430	1004	33	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	1004	34	's	's	POS
38430	1004	35	book	book	NN
38430	1004	36	to	to	TO
38430	1004	37	acquire	acquire	VB
38430	1004	38	the	the	DT
38430	1004	39	finest	fine	JJS
38430	1004	40	flower	flower	NN
38430	1004	41	of	of	IN
38430	1004	42	Parisian	parisian	JJ
38430	1004	43	wit	wit	NN
38430	1004	44	.	.	.
38430	1005	1	By	by	IN
38430	1005	2	observing	observe	VBG
38430	1005	3	a	a	DT
38430	1005	4	very	very	RB
38430	1005	5	simple	simple	JJ
38430	1005	6	formula	formula	NN
38430	1005	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1005	8	will	will	MD
38430	1005	9	know	know	VB
38430	1005	10	infallibly	infallibly	RB
38430	1005	11	what	what	WP
38430	1005	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	1005	13	funny	funny	JJ
38430	1005	14	and	and	CC
38430	1005	15	what	what	WP
38430	1005	16	is	be	VBZ
38430	1005	17	not	not	RB
38430	1005	18	;	;	:
38430	1005	19	if	if	IN
38430	1005	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1005	21	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	1005	22	surprise	surprise	VBP
38430	1005	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1005	24	unlearned	unlearned	JJ
38430	1005	25	friends	friend	NNS
38430	1005	26	,	,	,
38430	1005	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1005	28	have	have	VBP
38430	1005	29	only	only	RB
38430	1005	30	to	to	TO
38430	1005	31	mention	mention	VB
38430	1005	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1005	33	authority	authority	NN
38430	1005	34	in	in	IN
38430	1005	35	order	order	NN
38430	1005	36	to	to	TO
38430	1005	37	silence	silence	VB
38430	1005	38	doubt	doubt	NN
38430	1005	39	.	.	.
38430	1006	1	'	'	``
38430	1006	2	The	the	DT
38430	1006	3	attitudes	attitude	NNS
38430	1006	4	,	,	,
38430	1006	5	gestures	gesture	NNS
38430	1006	6	and	and	CC
38430	1006	7	movements	movement	NNS
38430	1006	8	of	of	IN
38430	1006	9	the	the	DT
38430	1006	10	human	human	JJ
38430	1006	11	body	body	NN
38430	1006	12	,	,	,
38430	1006	13	'	'	''
38430	1006	14	says	say	VBZ
38430	1006	15	M.	M.	NNP
38430	1006	16	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	1006	17	,	,	,
38430	1006	18	'	'	``
38430	1006	19	are	be	VBP
38430	1006	20	laughable	laughable	JJ
38430	1006	21	in	in	IN
38430	1006	22	exact	exact	JJ
38430	1006	23	proportion	proportion	NN
38430	1006	24	as	as	IN
38430	1006	25	that	that	DT
38430	1006	26	body	body	NN
38430	1006	27	reminds	remind	VBZ
38430	1006	28	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1006	29	of	of	IN
38430	1006	30	a	a	DT
38430	1006	31	mere	mere	JJ
38430	1006	32	machine	machine	NN
38430	1006	33	.	.	.
38430	1006	34	'	'	''
38430	1007	1	When	when	WRB
38430	1007	2	an	an	DT
38430	1007	3	elderly	elderly	JJ
38430	1007	4	gentleman	gentleman	NN
38430	1007	5	slips	slip	VBZ
38430	1007	6	on	on	IN
38430	1007	7	a	a	DT
38430	1007	8	piece	piece	NN
38430	1007	9	of	of	IN
38430	1007	10	orange	orange	NN
38430	1007	11	-	-	HYPH
38430	1007	12	peel	peel	NN
38430	1007	13	and	and	CC
38430	1007	14	falls	fall	VBZ
38430	1007	15	,	,	,
38430	1007	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1007	17	laugh	laugh	VBP
38430	1007	18	,	,	,
38430	1007	19	because	because	IN
38430	1007	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1007	21	body	body	NN
38430	1007	22	follows	follow	VBZ
38430	1007	23	the	the	DT
38430	1007	24	laws	law	NNS
38430	1007	25	of	of	IN
38430	1007	26	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
38430	1007	27	instead	instead	RB
38430	1007	28	of	of	IN
38430	1007	29	a	a	DT
38430	1007	30	human	human	JJ
38430	1007	31	purpose	purpose	NN
38430	1007	32	.	.	.
38430	1008	1	When	when	WRB
38430	1008	2	a	a	DT
38430	1008	3	man	man	NN
38430	1008	4	falls	fall	VBZ
38430	1008	5	from	from	IN
38430	1008	6	a	a	DT
38430	1008	7	scaffolding	scaffolding	NN
38430	1008	8	and	and	CC
38430	1008	9	breaks	break	VBZ
38430	1008	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1008	11	neck	neck	NN
38430	1008	12	on	on	IN
38430	1008	13	the	the	DT
38430	1008	14	pavement	pavement	NN
38430	1008	15	,	,	,
38430	1008	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1008	17	presumably	presumably	RB
38430	1008	18	laugh	laugh	VBP
38430	1008	19	even	even	RB
38430	1008	20	more	more	RBR
38430	1008	21	,	,	,
38430	1008	22	since	since	IN
38430	1008	23	the	the	DT
38430	1008	24	movement	movement	NN
38430	1008	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	1008	26	even	even	RB
38430	1008	27	more	more	RBR
38430	1008	28	completely	completely	RB
38430	1008	29	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
38430	1008	30	.	.	.
38430	1009	1	When	when	WRB
38430	1009	2	the	the	DT
38430	1009	3	clown	clown	NN
38430	1009	4	makes	make	VBZ
38430	1009	5	a	a	DT
38430	1009	6	bad	bad	JJ
38430	1009	7	joke	joke	NN
38430	1009	8	for	for	IN
38430	1009	9	the	the	DT
38430	1009	10	first	first	JJ
38430	1009	11	time	time	NN
38430	1009	12	,	,	,
38430	1009	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1009	14	keep	keep	VBP
38430	1009	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1009	16	countenance	countenance	NN
38430	1009	17	,	,	,
38430	1009	18	but	but	CC
38430	1009	19	at	at	IN
38430	1009	20	the	the	DT
38430	1009	21	fifth	fifth	JJ
38430	1009	22	repetition	repetition	NN
38430	1009	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1009	24	smile	smile	VBP
38430	1009	25	,	,	,
38430	1009	26	and	and	CC
38430	1009	27	at	at	IN
38430	1009	28	the	the	DT
38430	1009	29	tenth	tenth	NN
38430	1009	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1009	31	roar	roar	VBP
38430	1009	32	with	with	IN
38430	1009	33	laughter	laughter	NN
38430	1009	34	,	,	,
38430	1009	35	because	because	IN
38430	1009	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1009	37	begin	begin	VBP
38430	1009	38	to	to	TO
38430	1009	39	feel	feel	VB
38430	1009	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1009	41	a	a	DT
38430	1009	42	mere	mere	JJ
38430	1009	43	automaton	automaton	NN
38430	1009	44	.	.	.
38430	1010	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1010	2	laugh	laugh	VBP
38430	1010	3	at	at	IN
38430	1010	4	Molière	Molière	NNP
38430	1010	5	's	's	POS
38430	1010	6	misers	miser	NNS
38430	1010	7	,	,	,
38430	1010	8	misanthropists	misanthropist	NNS
38430	1010	9	and	and	CC
38430	1010	10	hypocrites	hypocrite	NNS
38430	1010	11	,	,	,
38430	1010	12	because	because	IN
38430	1010	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1010	14	are	be	VBP
38430	1010	15	mere	mere	JJ
38430	1010	16	types	type	NNS
38430	1010	17	mechanically	mechanically	RB
38430	1010	18	dominated	dominate	VBN
38430	1010	19	by	by	IN
38430	1010	20	a	a	DT
38430	1010	21	master	master	NN
38430	1010	22	impulse	impulse	NN
38430	1010	23	.	.	.
38430	1011	1	Presumably	presumably	RB
38430	1011	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1011	3	laugh	laugh	VBP
38430	1011	4	at	at	IN
38430	1011	5	Balzac	Balzac	NNP
38430	1011	6	's	's	POS
38430	1011	7	characters	character	NNS
38430	1011	8	for	for	IN
38430	1011	9	the	the	DT
38430	1011	10	same	same	JJ
38430	1011	11	reason	reason	NN
38430	1011	12	;	;	:
38430	1011	13	and	and	CC
38430	1011	14	presumably	presumably	RB
38430	1011	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1011	16	never	never	RB
38430	1011	17	smile	smile	VBP
38430	1011	18	at	at	IN
38430	1011	19	Falstaff	Falstaff	NNP
38430	1011	20	,	,	,
38430	1011	21	because	because	IN
38430	1011	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1011	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	1011	24	individual	individual	JJ
38430	1011	25	throughout	throughout	IN
38430	1011	26	.	.	.
38430	1011	27	"	"	''
38430	1012	1	The	the	DT
38430	1012	2	review	review	NN
38430	1012	3	concludes	conclude	VBZ
38430	1012	4	with	with	IN
38430	1012	5	the	the	DT
38430	1012	6	reflection	reflection	NN
38430	1012	7	that	that	IN
38430	1012	8	"	"	``
38430	1012	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1012	10	would	would	MD
38430	1012	11	seem	seem	VB
38430	1012	12	to	to	TO
38430	1012	13	be	be	VB
38430	1012	14	impossible	impossible	JJ
38430	1012	15	to	to	TO
38430	1012	16	find	find	VB
38430	1012	17	any	any	DT
38430	1012	18	such	such	JJ
38430	1012	19	formula	formula	NN
38430	1012	20	as	as	IN
38430	1012	21	M.	M.	NNP
38430	1012	22	Bergson	Bergson	NNP
38430	1012	23	seeks	seek	VBZ
38430	1012	24	.	.	.
38430	1013	1	Every	every	DT
38430	1013	2	formula	formula	NN
38430	1013	3	treats	treat	VBZ
38430	1013	4	what	what	WP
38430	1013	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1013	6	living	live	VBG
38430	1013	7	as	as	IN
38430	1013	8	if	if	IN
38430	1013	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1013	10	were	be	VBD
38430	1013	11	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
38430	1013	12	,	,	,
38430	1013	13	and	and	CC
38430	1013	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	1013	15	therefore	therefore	RB
38430	1013	16	by	by	IN
38430	1013	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1013	18	own	own	JJ
38430	1013	19	rule	rule	NN
38430	1013	20	a	a	DT
38430	1013	21	fitting	fitting	JJ
38430	1013	22	object	object	NN
38430	1013	23	of	of	IN
38430	1013	24	laughter	laughter	NN
38430	1013	25	.	.	.
38430	1013	26	"	"	''
38430	1014	1	Now	now	RB
38430	1014	2	,	,	,
38430	1014	3	this	this	DT
38430	1014	4	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	JJ
38430	1014	5	true	true	JJ
38430	1014	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
38430	1014	7	has	have	VBZ
38430	1014	8	been	be	VBN
38430	1014	9	obtained	obtain	VBN
38430	1014	10	,	,	,
38430	1014	11	as	as	IN
38430	1014	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	1014	13	readily	readily	RB
38430	1014	14	seen	see	VBN
38430	1014	15	,	,	,
38430	1014	16	by	by	IN
38430	1014	17	a	a	DT
38430	1014	18	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	1014	19	-	-	HYPH
38430	1014	20	circle	circle	NN
38430	1014	21	fallacy	fallacy	NN
38430	1014	22	which	which	WDT
38430	1014	23	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1014	24	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	1014	25	would	would	MD
38430	1014	26	hardly	hardly	RB
38430	1014	27	have	have	VB
38430	1014	28	committed.--ED	committed.--ED	NNP
38430	1014	29	.	.	.
38430	1014	30	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1015	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	1015	2	:	:	:
38430	1015	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1015	4	122	122	CD
38430	1015	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1015	6	From	from	IN
38430	1015	7	a	a	DT
38430	1015	8	remark	remark	NN
38430	1015	9	on	on	IN
38430	1015	10	p.	p.	NN
38430	1015	11	47	47	CD
38430	1015	12	above	above	RB
38430	1015	13	,	,	,
38430	1015	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1015	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	1015	16	evident	evident	JJ
38430	1015	17	that	that	IN
38430	1015	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
38430	1015	19	R*ss*ll	R*ss*ll	NNP
38430	1015	20	intended	intend	VBD
38430	1015	21	to	to	TO
38430	1015	22	write	write	VB
38430	1015	23	some	some	DT
38430	1015	24	such	such	JJ
38430	1015	25	chapter	chapter	NN
38430	1015	26	as	as	IN
38430	1015	27	this	this	DT
38430	1015	28	.	.	.
38430	1016	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1016	2	123	123	CD
38430	1016	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1016	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1016	5	The	the	DT
38430	1016	6	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	1016	7	's	's	POS
38430	1016	8	Guide	Guide	NNP
38430	1016	9	to	to	IN
38430	1016	10	Laughter	Laughter	NNP
38430	1016	11	,	,	,
38430	1016	12	The	the	DT
38430	1016	13	Cambridge	Cambridge	NNP
38430	1016	14	Review	Review	NNP
38430	1016	15	_	_	NNP
38430	1016	16	,	,	,
38430	1016	17	vol	vol	NNP
38430	1016	18	.	.	.
38430	1017	1	xxxii	xxxii	NNP
38430	1017	2	.	.	NNP
38430	1017	3	,	,	,
38430	1017	4	1912	1912	CD
38430	1017	5	,	,	,
38430	1017	6	pp	pp	NNP
38430	1017	7	.	.	.
38430	1018	1	193	193	CD
38430	1018	2	-	-	SYM
38430	1018	3	4	4	CD
38430	1018	4	.	.	.
38430	1019	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1019	2	124	124	CD
38430	1019	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1019	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1019	5	Laughter	Laughter	NNP
38430	1019	6	,	,	,
38430	1019	7	an	an	DT
38430	1019	8	Essay	Essay	NNP
38430	1019	9	on	on	IN
38430	1019	10	the	the	DT
38430	1019	11	Meaning	Meaning	NNP
38430	1019	12	of	of	IN
38430	1019	13	the	the	DT
38430	1019	14	Comic	Comic	NNP
38430	1019	15	_	_	NNP
38430	1019	16	,	,	,
38430	1019	17	English	english	JJ
38430	1019	18	translation	translation	NN
38430	1019	19	by	by	IN
38430	1019	20	C.	C.	NNP
38430	1019	21	Brereton	Brereton	NNP
38430	1019	22	and	and	CC
38430	1019	23	F.	F.	NNP
38430	1019	24	Rothwell	Rothwell	NNP
38430	1019	25	,	,	,
38430	1019	26	London	London	NNP
38430	1019	27	,	,	,
38430	1019	28	1911	1911	CD
38430	1019	29	.	.	.
38430	1020	1	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
38430	1020	2	XLIII	xliii	NN
38430	1020	3	"	"	``
38430	1020	4	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	NNP
38430	1020	5	"	"	''
38430	1020	6	AND	and	CC
38430	1020	7	EVOLUTIONARY	EVOLUTIONARY	NNP
38430	1020	8	ETHICS	ethics	VBP
38430	1020	9	The	the	DT
38430	1020	10	"	"	``
38430	1020	11	Gedankenexperimente	Gedankenexperimente	NNP
38430	1020	12	,	,	,
38430	1020	13	"	"	''
38430	1020	14	upon	upon	IN
38430	1020	15	which	which	WDT
38430	1020	16	so	so	RB
38430	1020	17	much	much	JJ
38430	1020	18	weight	weight	NN
38430	1020	19	has	have	VBZ
38430	1020	20	been	be	VBN
38430	1020	21	laid	lay	VBN
38430	1020	22	by	by	IN
38430	1020	23	Mach[125	mach[125	CD
38430	1020	24	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1020	25	and	and	CC
38430	1020	26	Heymans,[126	heymans,[126	NN
38430	1020	27	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1020	28	had	have	VBD
38430	1020	29	already	already	RB
38430	1020	30	been	be	VBN
38430	1020	31	investigated	investigate	VBN
38430	1020	32	by	by	IN
38430	1020	33	the	the	DT
38430	1020	34	White	White	NNP
38430	1020	35	Queen,[127	Queen,[127	NNP
38430	1020	36	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1020	37	who	who	WP
38430	1020	38	,	,	,
38430	1020	39	however	however	RB
38430	1020	40	,	,	,
38430	1020	41	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	1020	42	to	to	TO
38430	1020	43	have	have	VB
38430	1020	44	perceived	perceive	VBN
38430	1020	45	that	that	IN
38430	1020	46	the	the	DT
38430	1020	47	results	result	NNS
38430	1020	48	of	of	IN
38430	1020	49	such	such	JJ
38430	1020	50	experiments	experiment	NNS
38430	1020	51	are	be	VBP
38430	1020	52	not	not	RB
38430	1020	53	always	always	RB
38430	1020	54	logically	logically	RB
38430	1020	55	valid	valid	JJ
38430	1020	56	.	.	.
38430	1021	1	The	the	DT
38430	1021	2	psychological	psychological	JJ
38430	1021	3	founding	founding	NN
38430	1021	4	of	of	IN
38430	1021	5	logic	logic	NN
38430	1021	6	appears	appear	VBZ
38430	1021	7	to	to	TO
38430	1021	8	be	be	VB
38430	1021	9	not	not	RB
38430	1021	10	without	without	IN
38430	1021	11	analogy	analogy	NN
38430	1021	12	with	with	IN
38430	1021	13	the	the	DT
38430	1021	14	surprising	surprising	JJ
38430	1021	15	method	method	NN
38430	1021	16	of	of	IN
38430	1021	17	advocates	advocate	NNS
38430	1021	18	of	of	IN
38430	1021	19	evolutionary	evolutionary	JJ
38430	1021	20	ethics	ethic	NNS
38430	1021	21	,	,	,
38430	1021	22	who	who	WP
38430	1021	23	expect	expect	VBP
38430	1021	24	to	to	TO
38430	1021	25	discover	discover	VB
38430	1021	26	what	what	WP
38430	1021	27	_	_	NNP
38430	1021	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	1021	29	_	_	NNP
38430	1021	30	good	good	JJ
38430	1021	31	by	by	IN
38430	1021	32	inquiring	inquire	VBG
38430	1021	33	what	what	WP
38430	1021	34	cannibals	cannibal	NNS
38430	1021	35	have	have	VBP
38430	1021	36	_	_	NNP
38430	1021	37	thought	think	VBN
38430	1021	38	_	_	NNP
38430	1021	39	good	good	NN
38430	1021	40	.	.	.
38430	1022	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1022	2	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	1022	3	feel	feel	VBP
38430	1022	4	inclined	inclined	JJ
38430	1022	5	to	to	TO
38430	1022	6	apply	apply	VB
38430	1022	7	the	the	DT
38430	1022	8	historical	historical	JJ
38430	1022	9	method	method	NN
38430	1022	10	to	to	IN
38430	1022	11	the	the	DT
38430	1022	12	multiplication	multiplication	NN
38430	1022	13	table	table	NN
38430	1022	14	.	.	.
38430	1023	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1023	2	should	should	MD
38430	1023	3	make	make	VB
38430	1023	4	a	a	DT
38430	1023	5	statistical	statistical	JJ
38430	1023	6	inquiry	inquiry	NN
38430	1023	7	among	among	IN
38430	1023	8	school	school	NN
38430	1023	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	1023	10	children	child	NNS
38430	1023	11	,	,	,
38430	1023	12	before	before	IN
38430	1023	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1023	14	pristine	pristine	JJ
38430	1023	15	wisdom	wisdom	NN
38430	1023	16	had	have	VBD
38430	1023	17	been	be	VBN
38430	1023	18	biassed	bias	VBN
38430	1023	19	by	by	IN
38430	1023	20	teachers	teacher	NNS
38430	1023	21	.	.	.
38430	1024	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1024	2	should	should	MD
38430	1024	3	put	put	VB
38430	1024	4	down	down	RP
38430	1024	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1024	6	answers	answer	NNS
38430	1024	7	as	as	IN
38430	1024	8	to	to	IN
38430	1024	9	what	what	WP
38430	1024	10	6	6	CD
38430	1024	11	times	time	NNS
38430	1024	12	9	9	CD
38430	1024	13	amounts	amount	NNS
38430	1024	14	to	to	IN
38430	1024	15	,	,	,
38430	1024	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1024	17	should	should	MD
38430	1024	18	work	work	VB
38430	1024	19	out	out	RP
38430	1024	20	the	the	DT
38430	1024	21	average	average	NN
38430	1024	22	of	of	IN
38430	1024	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1024	24	answers	answer	NNS
38430	1024	25	to	to	IN
38430	1024	26	six	six	CD
38430	1024	27	places	place	NNS
38430	1024	28	of	of	IN
38430	1024	29	decimals	decimal	NNS
38430	1024	30	,	,	,
38430	1024	31	and	and	CC
38430	1024	32	should	should	MD
38430	1024	33	then	then	RB
38430	1024	34	decide	decide	VB
38430	1024	35	that	that	DT
38430	1024	36	,	,	,
38430	1024	37	at	at	IN
38430	1024	38	the	the	DT
38430	1024	39	present	present	JJ
38430	1024	40	stage	stage	NN
38430	1024	41	of	of	IN
38430	1024	42	human	human	JJ
38430	1024	43	development	development	NN
38430	1024	44	,	,	,
38430	1024	45	this	this	DT
38430	1024	46	average	average	NN
38430	1024	47	is	be	VBZ
38430	1024	48	the	the	DT
38430	1024	49	value	value	NN
38430	1024	50	of	of	IN
38430	1024	51	6	6	CD
38430	1024	52	times	time	NNS
38430	1024	53	9	9	CD
38430	1024	54	.	.	.
38430	1025	1	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
38430	1025	2	:	:	:
38430	1025	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1025	4	125	125	CD
38430	1025	5	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1025	6	See	see	VB
38430	1025	7	,	,	,
38430	1025	8	e.g.	e.g.	RB
38430	1025	9	,	,	,
38430	1025	10	_	_	NNP
38430	1025	11	E.	E.	NNP
38430	1026	1	u.	u.	NNP
38430	1026	2	I.	I.	NNP
38430	1026	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1026	4	,	,	,
38430	1026	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	1026	6	.	.	.
38430	1027	1	183	183	CD
38430	1027	2	-	-	SYM
38430	1027	3	200	200	CD
38430	1027	4	.	.	.
38430	1028	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1028	2	126	126	CD
38430	1028	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1028	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1028	5	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1029	1	u.	u.	NNP
38430	1029	2	E.	E.	NNP
38430	1029	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1029	4	,	,	,
38430	1029	5	vol	vol	NNP
38430	1029	6	.	.	.
38430	1030	1	i.	i.	NNP
38430	1031	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1031	2	127	127	CD
38430	1031	3	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1031	4	See	See	NNP
38430	1031	5	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
38430	1031	6	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1031	7	APPENDIXES	APPENDIXES	NNP
38430	1031	8	A.	a.	NN
38430	1032	1	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1032	2	AND	and	CC
38430	1032	3	THE	the	DT
38430	1032	4	PRINCIPLE	PRINCIPLE	NNP
38430	1032	5	OF	of	IN
38430	1032	6	IDENTITY	IDENTITY	NNP
38430	1032	7	.	.	.
38430	1033	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1033	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1034	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1034	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1034	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1034	4	,	,	,
38430	1034	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1034	6	45	45	CD
38430	1034	7	:	:	:
38430	1034	8	"	"	``
38430	1034	9	'	'	``
38430	1034	10	Contrariwise	contrariwise	NN
38430	1034	11	,	,	,
38430	1034	12	"	"	''
38430	1034	13	continued	continue	VBN
38430	1034	14	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	1034	15	,	,	,
38430	1034	16	"	"	''
38430	1034	17	if	if	IN
38430	1034	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	19	was	be	VBD
38430	1034	20	so	so	RB
38430	1034	21	,	,	,
38430	1034	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	23	might	may	MD
38430	1034	24	be	be	VB
38430	1034	25	;	;	:
38430	1034	26	and	and	CC
38430	1034	27	if	if	IN
38430	1034	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	29	were	be	VBD
38430	1034	30	so	so	RB
38430	1034	31	,	,	,
38430	1034	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	33	would	would	MD
38430	1034	34	be	be	VB
38430	1034	35	:	:	:
38430	1034	36	but	but	CC
38430	1034	37	as	as	IN
38430	1034	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	39	is	be	VBZ
38430	1034	40	n't	not	RB
38430	1034	41	,	,	,
38430	1034	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1034	43	ai	be	VBP
38430	1034	44	n't	not	RB
38430	1034	45	.	.	.
38430	1035	1	That	that	DT
38430	1035	2	's	be	VBZ
38430	1035	3	logic	logic	NN
38430	1035	4	.	.	.
38430	1035	5	"	"	''
38430	1036	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1036	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1036	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1036	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1036	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1036	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1036	7	S.	S.	NNP
38430	1037	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	1037	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1037	3	,	,	,
38430	1037	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	1037	5	159	159	CD
38430	1037	6	:	:	:
38430	1037	7	The	the	DT
38430	1037	8	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	1037	9	said	say	VBD
38430	1037	10	:	:	:
38430	1037	11	"	"	``
38430	1037	12	The	the	DT
38430	1037	13	day	day	NN
38430	1037	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	1037	15	the	the	DT
38430	1037	16	same	same	JJ
38430	1037	17	length	length	NN
38430	1037	18	as	as	IN
38430	1037	19	anything	anything	NN
38430	1037	20	that	that	WDT
38430	1037	21	is	be	VBZ
38430	1037	22	the	the	DT
38430	1037	23	same	same	JJ
38430	1037	24	length	length	NN
38430	1037	25	as	as	IN
38430	1037	26	_	_	NNP
38430	1037	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1037	28	_	_	NNP
38430	1037	29	.	.	.
38430	1037	30	"	"	''
38430	1038	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1038	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1038	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1038	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1038	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1038	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1038	7	S.	S.	NNP
38430	1039	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	1039	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1039	3	,	,	,
38430	1039	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	1039	5	161	161	CD
38430	1039	6	:	:	:
38430	1039	7	Bruno	Bruno	NNP
38430	1039	8	observed	observe	VBD
38430	1039	9	that	that	IN
38430	1039	10	,	,	,
38430	1039	11	when	when	WRB
38430	1039	12	the	the	DT
38430	1039	13	Other	Other	NNP
38430	1039	14	Professor	Professor	NNP
38430	1039	15	lost	lose	VBD
38430	1039	16	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1039	17	,	,	,
38430	1039	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1039	19	should	should	MD
38430	1039	20	shout	shout	VB
38430	1039	21	:	:	:
38430	1039	22	"	"	``
38430	1039	23	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1039	24	'd	'd	MD
38430	1039	25	be	be	VB
38430	1039	26	sure	sure	JJ
38430	1039	27	to	to	TO
38430	1039	28	hear	hear	VB
38430	1039	29	hisself	hisself	PRP
38430	1039	30	,	,	,
38430	1039	31	'cause	because	IN
38430	1039	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1039	33	could	could	MD
38430	1039	34	n't	not	RB
38430	1039	35	be	be	VB
38430	1039	36	far	far	RB
38430	1039	37	off	off	RB
38430	1039	38	.	.	.
38430	1039	39	"	"	''
38430	1040	1	B.	B.	NNP
38430	1040	2	SYNTHESIS	SYNTHESIS	NNP
38430	1040	3	OF	of	IN
38430	1040	4	CONTRADICTORIES	contradictory	NNS
38430	1040	5	.	.	.
38430	1041	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1041	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1042	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1042	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1042	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1042	4	,	,	,
38430	1042	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1042	6	71	71	CD
38430	1042	7	:	:	:
38430	1042	8	"	"	``
38430	1042	9	'	'	``
38430	1042	10	What	what	WP
38430	1042	11	a	a	DT
38430	1042	12	beautiful	beautiful	JJ
38430	1042	13	belt	belt	NN
38430	1042	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1042	15	've	have	VB
38430	1042	16	got	get	VBN
38430	1042	17	on	on	RP
38430	1042	18	!	!	.
38430	1042	19	'	'	''
38430	1043	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1043	2	suddenly	suddenly	RB
38430	1043	3	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	1043	4	....	....	.
38430	1043	5	'	'	''
38430	1043	6	At	at	IN
38430	1043	7	least	least	JJS
38430	1043	8	,	,	,
38430	1043	9	'	'	''
38430	1043	10	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1043	11	corrected	correct	VBD
38430	1043	12	herself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1043	13	on	on	IN
38430	1043	14	second	second	JJ
38430	1043	15	thoughts	thought	NNS
38430	1043	16	,	,	,
38430	1043	17	'	'	''
38430	1043	18	a	a	DT
38430	1043	19	beautiful	beautiful	JJ
38430	1043	20	cravat	cravat	NN
38430	1043	21	,	,	,
38430	1043	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1043	23	should	should	MD
38430	1043	24	have	have	VB
38430	1043	25	said	say	VBD
38430	1043	26	--	--	:
38430	1043	27	no	no	UH
38430	1043	28	,	,	,
38430	1043	29	a	a	DT
38430	1043	30	belt	belt	NN
38430	1043	31	,	,	,
38430	1043	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1043	33	mean	mean	VBP
38430	1043	34	--	--	:
38430	1043	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1043	36	beg	beg	VBP
38430	1043	37	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1043	38	pardon	pardon	NN
38430	1043	39	!	!	.
38430	1043	40	'	'	''
38430	1044	1	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1044	2	added	add	VBD
38430	1044	3	in	in	IN
38430	1044	4	dismay	dismay	NN
38430	1044	5	,	,	,
38430	1044	6	for	for	IN
38430	1044	7	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	1044	8	-	-	HYPH
38430	1044	9	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	1044	10	looked	look	VBD
38430	1044	11	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
38430	1044	12	offended	offend	VBN
38430	1044	13	,	,	,
38430	1044	14	and	and	CC
38430	1044	15	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1044	16	began	begin	VBD
38430	1044	17	to	to	TO
38430	1044	18	wish	wish	VB
38430	1044	19	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1044	20	had	have	VBD
38430	1044	21	n't	not	RB
38430	1044	22	chosen	choose	VBN
38430	1044	23	that	that	DT
38430	1044	24	subject	subject	NN
38430	1044	25	.	.	.
38430	1045	1	'	'	``
38430	1045	2	If	if	IN
38430	1045	3	only	only	RB
38430	1045	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1045	5	knew	know	VBD
38430	1045	6	,	,	,
38430	1045	7	'	'	''
38430	1045	8	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1045	9	thought	think	VBD
38430	1045	10	to	to	IN
38430	1045	11	herself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1045	12	,	,	,
38430	1045	13	'	'	''
38430	1045	14	which	which	WDT
38430	1045	15	was	be	VBD
38430	1045	16	neck	neck	NN
38430	1045	17	and	and	CC
38430	1045	18	which	which	WDT
38430	1045	19	was	be	VBD
38430	1045	20	waist	waist	JJ
38430	1045	21	!	!	.
38430	1045	22	'	'	''
38430	1045	23	"	"	''
38430	1046	1	C.	C.	NNP
38430	1046	2	EMPIRICAL	EMPIRICAL	NNP
38430	1046	3	PHILOSOPHERS	philosopher	NNS
38430	1046	4	AND	and	CC
38430	1046	5	MATHEMATICS	mathematic	NNS
38430	1046	6	.	.	.
38430	1047	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1047	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1048	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1048	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1048	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1048	4	,	,	,
38430	1048	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1048	6	79	79	CD
38430	1048	7	:	:	:
38430	1048	8	"	"	``
38430	1048	9	'	'	''
38430	1048	10	...	...	.
38430	1048	11	Now	now	UH
38430	1048	12	if	if	IN
38430	1048	13	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1048	14	had	have	VBD
38430	1048	15	the	the	DT
38430	1048	16	two	two	CD
38430	1048	17	eyes	eye	NNS
38430	1048	18	on	on	IN
38430	1048	19	the	the	DT
38430	1048	20	same	same	JJ
38430	1048	21	side	side	NN
38430	1048	22	of	of	IN
38430	1048	23	the	the	DT
38430	1048	24	nose	nose	NN
38430	1048	25	,	,	,
38430	1048	26	for	for	IN
38430	1048	27	instance	instance	NN
38430	1048	28	--	--	:
38430	1048	29	or	or	CC
38430	1048	30	the	the	DT
38430	1048	31	mouth	mouth	NN
38430	1048	32	at	at	IN
38430	1048	33	the	the	DT
38430	1048	34	top	top	NN
38430	1048	35	--	--	:
38430	1048	36	that	that	DT
38430	1048	37	would	would	MD
38430	1048	38	be	be	VB
38430	1048	39	_	_	NNP
38430	1048	40	some	some	DT
38430	1048	41	_	_	NNP
38430	1048	42	help	help	NN
38430	1048	43	.	.	.
38430	1048	44	'	'	''
38430	1049	1	"	"	``
38430	1049	2	'	'	``
38430	1049	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1049	4	would	would	MD
38430	1049	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1049	6	look	look	VB
38430	1049	7	nice	nice	JJ
38430	1049	8	,	,	,
38430	1049	9	'	'	''
38430	1049	10	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1049	11	objected	object	VBD
38430	1049	12	.	.	.
38430	1050	1	But	but	CC
38430	1050	2	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	1050	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	1050	4	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	1050	5	only	only	RB
38430	1050	6	shut	shut	VBD
38430	1050	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1050	8	eyes	eye	NNS
38430	1050	9	and	and	CC
38430	1050	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1050	11	:	:	:
38430	1050	12	'	'	''
38430	1050	13	Wait	wait	VB
38430	1050	14	till	till	IN
38430	1050	15	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1050	16	've	have	VB
38430	1050	17	tried	try	VBN
38430	1050	18	.	.	.
38430	1050	19	'	'	''
38430	1050	20	"	"	''
38430	1051	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1051	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1051	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1051	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1051	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1051	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1051	7	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1052	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1052	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1052	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1052	4	,	,	,
38430	1052	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1052	6	72	72	CD
38430	1052	7	:	:	:
38430	1052	8	"	"	``
38430	1052	9	'	'	``
38430	1052	10	And	and	CC
38430	1052	11	if	if	IN
38430	1052	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1052	13	take	take	VBP
38430	1052	14	one	one	CD
38430	1052	15	from	from	IN
38430	1052	16	three	three	CD
38430	1052	17	hundred	hundred	CD
38430	1052	18	and	and	CC
38430	1052	19	sixty	sixty	CD
38430	1052	20	-	-	HYPH
38430	1052	21	five	five	CD
38430	1052	22	,	,	,
38430	1052	23	what	what	WP
38430	1052	24	remains	remain	VBZ
38430	1052	25	?	?	.
38430	1052	26	'	'	''
38430	1053	1	"	"	``
38430	1053	2	'	'	``
38430	1053	3	Three	three	CD
38430	1053	4	hundred	hundred	CD
38430	1053	5	and	and	CC
38430	1053	6	sixty	sixty	CD
38430	1053	7	-	-	HYPH
38430	1053	8	four	four	CD
38430	1053	9	,	,	,
38430	1053	10	of	of	IN
38430	1053	11	course	course	NN
38430	1053	12	.	.	.
38430	1053	13	'	'	''
38430	1054	1	"	"	``
38430	1054	2	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	1054	3	-	-	HYPH
38430	1054	4	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	1054	5	looked	look	VBD
38430	1054	6	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
38430	1054	7	.	.	.
38430	1055	1	'	'	``
38430	1055	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1055	3	'd	'd	MD
38430	1055	4	rather	rather	RB
38430	1055	5	see	see	VB
38430	1055	6	that	that	DT
38430	1055	7	done	do	VBN
38430	1055	8	on	on	IN
38430	1055	9	paper	paper	NN
38430	1055	10	,	,	,
38430	1055	11	'	'	''
38430	1055	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1055	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1055	14	.	.	.
38430	1055	15	"	"	''
38430	1056	1	D.	D.	NNP
38430	1056	2	NOMINAL	NOMINAL	NNP
38430	1056	3	DEFINITION	DEFINITION	NNP
38430	1056	4	.	.	.
38430	1057	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1057	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1058	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1058	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1058	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1058	4	,	,	,
38430	1058	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1058	6	73	73	CD
38430	1058	7	:	:	:
38430	1058	8	"	"	``
38430	1058	9	'	'	``
38430	1058	10	When	when	WRB
38430	1058	11	_	_	NNP
38430	1058	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1058	13	_	_	NNP
38430	1058	14	used	use	VBD
38430	1058	15	a	a	DT
38430	1058	16	word	word	NN
38430	1058	17	,	,	,
38430	1058	18	'	'	''
38430	1058	19	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	1058	20	-	-	HYPH
38430	1058	21	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	1058	22	said	say	VBD
38430	1058	23	in	in	IN
38430	1058	24	rather	rather	RB
38430	1058	25	a	a	DT
38430	1058	26	scornful	scornful	JJ
38430	1058	27	tone	tone	NN
38430	1058	28	,	,	,
38430	1058	29	'	'	''
38430	1058	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1058	31	means	mean	VBZ
38430	1058	32	just	just	RB
38430	1058	33	what	what	WP
38430	1058	34	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1058	35	choose	choose	VBP
38430	1058	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1058	37	to	to	TO
38430	1058	38	mean	mean	VB
38430	1058	39	--	--	:
38430	1058	40	neither	neither	CC
38430	1058	41	more	more	RBR
38430	1058	42	nor	nor	CC
38430	1058	43	less	less	JJR
38430	1058	44	.	.	.
38430	1058	45	'	'	''
38430	1059	1	"	"	``
38430	1059	2	'	'	``
38430	1059	3	The	the	DT
38430	1059	4	question	question	NN
38430	1059	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1059	6	,	,	,
38430	1059	7	'	'	''
38430	1059	8	said	say	VBD
38430	1059	9	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1059	10	,	,	,
38430	1059	11	'	'	''
38430	1059	12	whether	whether	IN
38430	1059	13	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1059	14	_	_	NNP
38430	1059	15	can	can	MD
38430	1059	16	_	_	NNP
38430	1059	17	make	make	VB
38430	1059	18	words	word	NNS
38430	1059	19	mean	mean	VB
38430	1059	20	different	different	JJ
38430	1059	21	things	thing	NNS
38430	1059	22	.	.	.
38430	1059	23	'	'	''
38430	1060	1	"	"	``
38430	1060	2	'	'	``
38430	1060	3	The	the	DT
38430	1060	4	question	question	NN
38430	1060	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1060	6	,	,	,
38430	1060	7	'	'	''
38430	1060	8	said	say	VBD
38430	1060	9	Humpty	Humpty	NNP
38430	1060	10	-	-	HYPH
38430	1060	11	Dumpty	Dumpty	NNP
38430	1060	12	,	,	,
38430	1060	13	'	'	''
38430	1060	14	which	which	WDT
38430	1060	15	is	be	VBZ
38430	1060	16	to	to	TO
38430	1060	17	be	be	VB
38430	1060	18	master	master	NN
38430	1060	19	--	--	:
38430	1060	20	that	that	DT
38430	1060	21	's	be	VBZ
38430	1060	22	all	all	DT
38430	1060	23	.	.	.
38430	1060	24	'	'	''
38430	1060	25	"	"	''
38430	1061	1	E.	E.	NNP
38430	1061	2	CONFORMITY	CONFORMITY	NNP
38430	1061	3	OF	of	IN
38430	1061	4	A	a	DT
38430	1061	5	PARADOXICAL	paradoxical	NN
38430	1061	6	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1061	7	WITH	with	IN
38430	1061	8	COMMON	common	NN
38430	1061	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	1061	10	SENSE	SENSE	NNP
38430	1061	11	.	.	.
38430	1062	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1062	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1063	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1063	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1063	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1063	4	,	,	,
38430	1063	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1063	6	100	100	CD
38430	1063	7	:	:	:
38430	1063	8	"	"	``
38430	1063	9	But	but	CC
38430	1063	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1063	11	was	be	VBD
38430	1063	12	thinking	think	VBG
38430	1063	13	of	of	IN
38430	1063	14	a	a	DT
38430	1063	15	plan	plan	NN
38430	1063	16	To	to	TO
38430	1063	17	dye	dye	VB
38430	1063	18	one	one	PRP
38430	1063	19	's	's	POS
38430	1063	20	whiskers	whisker	NNS
38430	1063	21	green	green	JJ
38430	1063	22	,	,	,
38430	1063	23	And	and	CC
38430	1063	24	always	always	RB
38430	1063	25	use	use	VBP
38430	1063	26	so	so	RB
38430	1063	27	large	large	JJ
38430	1063	28	a	a	DT
38430	1063	29	fan	fan	NN
38430	1063	30	That	that	WDT
38430	1063	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1063	32	could	could	MD
38430	1063	33	not	not	RB
38430	1063	34	be	be	VB
38430	1063	35	seen	see	VBN
38430	1063	36	.	.	.
38430	1063	37	"	"	''
38430	1064	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1064	2	Verse	verse	NN
38430	1064	3	from	from	IN
38430	1064	4	White	White	NNP
38430	1064	5	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1064	6	's	's	POS
38430	1064	7	song	song	NN
38430	1064	8	.	.	.
38430	1064	9	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1065	1	F.	F.	NNP
38430	1065	2	IDEALISTS	IDEALISTS	NNP
38430	1065	3	AND	and	CC
38430	1065	4	THE	the	DT
38430	1065	5	LAWS	LAWS	NNP
38430	1065	6	OF	of	IN
38430	1065	7	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1065	8	.	.	.
38430	1066	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1066	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1067	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1067	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1067	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1067	4	,	,	,
38430	1067	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1067	6	52	52	CD
38430	1067	7	-	-	SYM
38430	1067	8	3	3	CD
38430	1067	9	:	:	:
38430	1067	10	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	1067	11	exclaimed	exclaimed	JJ
38430	1067	12	:	:	:
38430	1067	13	"	"	``
38430	1067	14	'	'	``
38430	1067	15	...	...	:
38430	1067	16	if	if	IN
38430	1067	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1067	18	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1067	19	the	the	DT
38430	1067	20	Red	Red	NNP
38430	1067	21	King	King	NNP
38430	1067	22	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1067	23	left	leave	VBD
38430	1067	24	off	off	RP
38430	1067	25	dreaming	dream	VBG
38430	1067	26	about	about	IN
38430	1067	27	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1067	28	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1067	29	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1067	30	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1067	31	,	,	,
38430	1067	32	where	where	WRB
38430	1067	33	do	do	VBP
38430	1067	34	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1067	35	suppose	suppose	VB
38430	1067	36	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1067	37	'd	'd	MD
38430	1067	38	be	be	VB
38430	1067	39	?	?	.
38430	1067	40	'	'	''
38430	1068	1	"	"	``
38430	1068	2	'	'	``
38430	1068	3	Where	where	WRB
38430	1068	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1068	5	am	be	VBP
38430	1068	6	now	now	RB
38430	1068	7	,	,	,
38430	1068	8	of	of	IN
38430	1068	9	course	course	NN
38430	1068	10	,	,	,
38430	1068	11	'	'	''
38430	1068	12	said	say	VBD
38430	1068	13	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1068	14	.	.	.
38430	1069	1	"	"	``
38430	1069	2	'	'	``
38430	1069	3	Not	not	RB
38430	1069	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1069	5	!	!	.
38430	1069	6	'	'	''
38430	1070	1	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	1070	2	retorted	retort	VBD
38430	1070	3	contemptuously	contemptuously	RB
38430	1070	4	.	.	.
38430	1071	1	'	'	``
38430	1071	2	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1071	3	'd	'd	MD
38430	1071	4	be	be	VB
38430	1071	5	nowhere	nowhere	RB
38430	1071	6	.	.	.
38430	1072	1	Why	why	WRB
38430	1072	2	,	,	,
38430	1072	3	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1072	4	're	be	VBP
38430	1072	5	only	only	RB
38430	1072	6	a	a	DT
38430	1072	7	sort	sort	NN
38430	1072	8	of	of	IN
38430	1072	9	thing	thing	NN
38430	1072	10	in	in	IN
38430	1072	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1072	12	dream	dream	NN
38430	1072	13	!	!	.
38430	1072	14	'	'	''
38430	1073	1	"	"	``
38430	1073	2	'	'	``
38430	1073	3	If	if	IN
38430	1073	4	that	that	IN
38430	1073	5	there	there	RB
38430	1073	6	King	King	NNP
38430	1073	7	was	be	VBD
38430	1073	8	to	to	TO
38430	1073	9	wake	wake	VB
38430	1073	10	,	,	,
38430	1073	11	'	'	''
38430	1073	12	added	add	VBN
38430	1073	13	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	1073	14	,	,	,
38430	1073	15	'	'	''
38430	1073	16	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1073	17	'd	'd	MD
38430	1073	18	go	go	VB
38430	1073	19	out	out	RP
38430	1073	20	--	--	:
38430	1073	21	bang!--just	bang!--just	NNP
38430	1073	22	like	like	IN
38430	1073	23	a	a	DT
38430	1073	24	candle	candle	NN
38430	1073	25	!	!	.
38430	1073	26	'	'	''
38430	1074	1	"	"	``
38430	1074	2	'	'	``
38430	1074	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1074	4	should	should	MD
38430	1074	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1074	6	!	!	.
38430	1074	7	'	'	''
38430	1075	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1075	2	exclaimed	exclaim	VBD
38430	1075	3	indignantly	indignantly	RB
38430	1075	4	.	.	.
38430	1076	1	'	'	``
38430	1076	2	Besides	besides	RB
38430	1076	3	,	,	,
38430	1076	4	if	if	IN
38430	1076	5	_	_	NNP
38430	1076	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1076	7	'm	be	VBP
38430	1076	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1076	9	only	only	RB
38430	1076	10	a	a	DT
38430	1076	11	sort	sort	NN
38430	1076	12	of	of	IN
38430	1076	13	thing	thing	NN
38430	1076	14	in	in	IN
38430	1076	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1076	16	dream	dream	NN
38430	1076	17	,	,	,
38430	1076	18	what	what	WP
38430	1076	19	are	be	VBP
38430	1076	20	_	_	NNP
38430	1076	21	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1076	22	_	_	NNP
38430	1076	23	,	,	,
38430	1076	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1076	25	should	should	MD
38430	1076	26	like	like	VB
38430	1076	27	to	to	TO
38430	1076	28	know	know	VB
38430	1076	29	?	?	.
38430	1076	30	'	'	''
38430	1077	1	"	"	``
38430	1077	2	'	'	``
38430	1077	3	Ditto	ditto	NN
38430	1077	4	,	,	,
38430	1077	5	'	'	''
38430	1077	6	said	say	VBD
38430	1077	7	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	1077	8	...	...	NFP
38430	1077	9	;	;	:
38430	1077	10	'	'	''
38430	1077	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1077	12	know	know	VBP
38430	1077	13	very	very	RB
38430	1077	14	well	well	RB
38430	1077	15	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1077	16	're	be	VBP
38430	1077	17	not	not	RB
38430	1077	18	real	real	JJ
38430	1077	19	.	.	.
38430	1077	20	'	'	''
38430	1078	1	"	"	``
38430	1078	2	'	'	``
38430	1078	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1078	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1078	5	am	be	VBP
38430	1078	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1078	7	real	real	JJ
38430	1078	8	!	!	.
38430	1078	9	'	'	''
38430	1079	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1079	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1079	3	,	,	,
38430	1079	4	and	and	CC
38430	1079	5	began	begin	VBD
38430	1079	6	to	to	TO
38430	1079	7	cry	cry	VB
38430	1079	8	.	.	.
38430	1079	9	"	"	''
38430	1080	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1080	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1080	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1080	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1080	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1080	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1080	7	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1081	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1081	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1081	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1081	4	,	,	,
38430	1081	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1081	6	97	97	CD
38430	1081	7	:	:	:
38430	1081	8	"	"	``
38430	1081	9	'	'	``
38430	1081	10	How	how	WRB
38430	1081	11	_	_	NNP
38430	1081	12	can	can	MD
38430	1081	13	_	_	VB
38430	1081	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1081	15	go	go	VB
38430	1081	16	on	on	RP
38430	1081	17	talking	talk	VBG
38430	1081	18	so	so	RB
38430	1081	19	quietly	quietly	RB
38430	1081	20	,	,	,
38430	1081	21	head	head	VBP
38430	1081	22	downwards	downwards	RB
38430	1081	23	?	?	.
38430	1081	24	'	'	''
38430	1082	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1082	2	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1082	3	,	,	,
38430	1082	4	as	as	IN
38430	1082	5	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1082	6	dragged	drag	VBD
38430	1082	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1082	8	out	out	RP
38430	1082	9	by	by	IN
38430	1082	10	the	the	DT
38430	1082	11	feet	foot	NNS
38430	1082	12	,	,	,
38430	1082	13	and	and	CC
38430	1082	14	laid	lay	VBD
38430	1082	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1082	16	in	in	IN
38430	1082	17	a	a	DT
38430	1082	18	heap	heap	NN
38430	1082	19	on	on	IN
38430	1082	20	the	the	DT
38430	1082	21	bank	bank	NN
38430	1082	22	.	.	.
38430	1083	1	"	"	``
38430	1083	2	The	the	DT
38430	1083	3	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1083	4	looked	look	VBD
38430	1083	5	surprised	surprised	JJ
38430	1083	6	at	at	IN
38430	1083	7	the	the	DT
38430	1083	8	question	question	NN
38430	1083	9	.	.	.
38430	1084	1	'	'	``
38430	1084	2	What	what	WP
38430	1084	3	does	do	VBZ
38430	1084	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1084	5	matter	matter	VB
38430	1084	6	where	where	WRB
38430	1084	7	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1084	8	body	body	NN
38430	1084	9	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	1084	10	to	to	TO
38430	1084	11	be	be	VB
38430	1084	12	?	?	.
38430	1084	13	'	'	''
38430	1085	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1085	2	said	say	VBD
38430	1085	3	.	.	.
38430	1086	1	'	'	``
38430	1086	2	My	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1086	3	mind	mind	NN
38430	1086	4	goes	go	VBZ
38430	1086	5	on	on	IN
38430	1086	6	working	work	VBG
38430	1086	7	all	all	PDT
38430	1086	8	the	the	DT
38430	1086	9	same	same	JJ
38430	1086	10	.	.	.
38430	1087	1	In	in	IN
38430	1087	2	fact	fact	NN
38430	1087	3	,	,	,
38430	1087	4	the	the	DT
38430	1087	5	more	more	JJR
38430	1087	6	head	head	NN
38430	1087	7	downwards	downwards	RB
38430	1087	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1087	9	am	be	VBP
38430	1087	10	,	,	,
38430	1087	11	the	the	DT
38430	1087	12	more	more	RBR
38430	1087	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1087	14	keep	keep	VBP
38430	1087	15	inventing	invent	VBG
38430	1087	16	new	new	JJ
38430	1087	17	things	thing	NNS
38430	1087	18	.	.	.
38430	1087	19	'	'	''
38430	1087	20	"	"	''
38430	1088	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1088	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1088	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1088	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1088	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1088	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1088	7	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1089	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1089	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1089	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1089	4	,	,	,
38430	1089	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1089	6	98	98	CD
38430	1089	7	:	:	:
38430	1089	8	"	"	``
38430	1089	9	'	'	''
38430	1089	10	...	...	:
38430	1089	11	Everybody	everybody	NN
38430	1089	12	that	that	WDT
38430	1089	13	hears	hear	VBZ
38430	1089	14	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1089	15	sing	sing	VB
38430	1089	16	--	--	:
38430	1089	17	either	either	CC
38430	1089	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1089	19	brings	bring	VBZ
38430	1089	20	the	the	DT
38430	1089	21	_	_	NNP
38430	1089	22	tears	tear	NNS
38430	1089	23	_	_	XX
38430	1089	24	into	into	IN
38430	1089	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1089	26	eyes	eye	NNS
38430	1089	27	,	,	,
38430	1089	28	or	or	CC
38430	1089	29	else----	else----	NNP
38430	1089	30	'	'	''
38430	1089	31	"	"	''
38430	1089	32	'	'	''
38430	1089	33	Or	or	CC
38430	1089	34	else	else	RB
38430	1089	35	what	what	WP
38430	1089	36	?	?	.
38430	1089	37	'	'	''
38430	1090	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1090	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1090	3	,	,	,
38430	1090	4	for	for	IN
38430	1090	5	the	the	DT
38430	1090	6	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1090	7	had	have	VBD
38430	1090	8	made	make	VBN
38430	1090	9	a	a	DT
38430	1090	10	sudden	sudden	JJ
38430	1090	11	pause	pause	NN
38430	1090	12	.	.	.
38430	1091	1	"	"	``
38430	1091	2	'	'	``
38430	1091	3	Or	or	CC
38430	1091	4	else	else	RB
38430	1091	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1091	6	does	do	VBZ
38430	1091	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1091	8	,	,	,
38430	1091	9	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1091	10	know	know	VBP
38430	1091	11	.	.	.
38430	1091	12	'	'	''
38430	1091	13	"	"	''
38430	1092	1	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1092	2	DISTINCTION	distinction	NN
38430	1092	3	BETWEEN	between	IN
38430	1092	4	SIGN	SIGN	NNP
38430	1092	5	AND	and	CC
38430	1092	6	SIGNIFICATION	SIGNIFICATION	NNP
38430	1092	7	.	.	.
38430	1093	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1093	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1094	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1094	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1094	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1094	4	,	,	,
38430	1094	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	1094	6	.	.	.
38430	1095	1	98	98	CD
38430	1095	2	-	-	SYM
38430	1095	3	9	9	CD
38430	1095	4	:	:	:
38430	1095	5	"	"	``
38430	1095	6	'	'	``
38430	1095	7	The	the	DT
38430	1095	8	name	name	NN
38430	1095	9	of	of	IN
38430	1095	10	the	the	DT
38430	1095	11	song	song	NN
38430	1095	12	is	be	VBZ
38430	1095	13	called	call	VBN
38430	1095	14	"	"	``
38430	1095	15	_	_	NNP
38430	1095	16	Haddocks	Haddocks	NNPS
38430	1095	17	'	'	POS
38430	1095	18	Eyes	eye	NNS
38430	1095	19	_	_	NNP
38430	1095	20	.	.	.
38430	1095	21	"	"	''
38430	1095	22	'	'	''
38430	1096	1	"	"	``
38430	1096	2	'	'	``
38430	1096	3	Oh	oh	UH
38430	1096	4	,	,	,
38430	1096	5	that	that	DT
38430	1096	6	's	be	VBZ
38430	1096	7	the	the	DT
38430	1096	8	name	name	NN
38430	1096	9	of	of	IN
38430	1096	10	the	the	DT
38430	1096	11	song	song	NN
38430	1096	12	,	,	,
38430	1096	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	1096	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1096	15	?	?	.
38430	1096	16	'	'	''
38430	1097	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1097	2	said	say	VBD
38430	1097	3	,	,	,
38430	1097	4	trying	try	VBG
38430	1097	5	to	to	TO
38430	1097	6	feel	feel	VB
38430	1097	7	interested	interested	JJ
38430	1097	8	.	.	.
38430	1098	1	"	"	``
38430	1098	2	'	'	``
38430	1098	3	No	no	UH
38430	1098	4	,	,	,
38430	1098	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1098	6	do	do	VBP
38430	1098	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1098	8	understand	understand	VB
38430	1098	9	,	,	,
38430	1098	10	'	'	''
38430	1098	11	the	the	DT
38430	1098	12	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1098	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1098	14	looking	look	VBG
38430	1098	15	a	a	DT
38430	1098	16	little	little	JJ
38430	1098	17	vexed	vexed	NN
38430	1098	18	.	.	.
38430	1099	1	'	'	``
38430	1099	2	That	that	DT
38430	1099	3	's	be	VBZ
38430	1099	4	what	what	WP
38430	1099	5	the	the	DT
38430	1099	6	name	name	NN
38430	1099	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	1099	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1099	9	called	call	VBN
38430	1099	10	_	_	NNP
38430	1099	11	.	.	.
38430	1100	1	The	the	DT
38430	1100	2	name	name	NN
38430	1100	3	really	really	RB
38430	1100	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1100	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1100	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1100	7	"	"	``
38430	1100	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1100	9	The	the	DT
38430	1100	10	Aged	Aged	NNP
38430	1100	11	Aged	Aged	NNP
38430	1100	12	Man	Man	NNP
38430	1100	13	_	_	NNP
38430	1100	14	.	.	.
38430	1100	15	"	"	''
38430	1100	16	'	'	''
38430	1101	1	"	"	``
38430	1101	2	'	'	``
38430	1101	3	Then	then	RB
38430	1101	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1101	5	ought	ought	MD
38430	1101	6	to	to	TO
38430	1101	7	have	have	VB
38430	1101	8	said	say	VBN
38430	1101	9	"	"	``
38430	1101	10	That	that	DT
38430	1101	11	's	be	VBZ
38430	1101	12	what	what	WP
38430	1101	13	the	the	DT
38430	1101	14	_	_	NNP
38430	1101	15	song	song	NN
38430	1101	16	_	_	NNP
38430	1101	17	is	be	VBZ
38430	1101	18	called	call	VBN
38430	1101	19	"	"	``
38430	1101	20	?	?	.
38430	1101	21	'	'	''
38430	1102	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1102	2	corrected	correct	VBD
38430	1102	3	herself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1102	4	.	.	.
38430	1103	1	"	"	``
38430	1103	2	'	'	``
38430	1103	3	No	no	UH
38430	1103	4	,	,	,
38430	1103	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1103	6	ought	ought	MD
38430	1103	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1103	8	:	:	:
38430	1103	9	that	that	DT
38430	1103	10	's	be	VBZ
38430	1103	11	another	another	DT
38430	1103	12	thing	thing	NN
38430	1103	13	.	.	.
38430	1104	1	The	the	DT
38430	1104	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	3	song	song	NN
38430	1104	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1104	6	called	call	VBN
38430	1104	7	"	"	``
38430	1104	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	9	Ways	Ways	NNPS
38430	1104	10	and	and	CC
38430	1104	11	Means	Means	NNPS
38430	1104	12	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	13	"	"	''
38430	1104	14	:	:	:
38430	1104	15	but	but	CC
38430	1104	16	that	that	DT
38430	1104	17	's	be	VBZ
38430	1104	18	only	only	RB
38430	1104	19	what	what	WP
38430	1104	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1104	21	's	be	VBZ
38430	1104	22	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	23	called	call	VBN
38430	1104	24	_	_	NNP
38430	1104	25	,	,	,
38430	1104	26	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1104	27	know	know	VBP
38430	1104	28	!	!	.
38430	1104	29	'	'	''
38430	1105	1	"	"	``
38430	1105	2	'	'	``
38430	1105	3	Well	well	UH
38430	1105	4	,	,	,
38430	1105	5	what	what	WP
38430	1105	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1105	7	is	be	VBZ
38430	1105	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1105	9	the	the	DT
38430	1105	10	song	song	NN
38430	1105	11	,	,	,
38430	1105	12	then	then	RB
38430	1105	13	?	?	.
38430	1105	14	'	'	''
38430	1106	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1106	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1106	3	,	,	,
38430	1106	4	who	who	WP
38430	1106	5	was	be	VBD
38430	1106	6	by	by	IN
38430	1106	7	this	this	DT
38430	1106	8	time	time	NN
38430	1106	9	completely	completely	RB
38430	1106	10	bewildered	bewilder	VBN
38430	1106	11	.	.	.
38430	1107	1	"	"	``
38430	1107	2	'	'	``
38430	1107	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1107	4	was	be	VBD
38430	1107	5	coming	come	VBG
38430	1107	6	to	to	IN
38430	1107	7	that	that	DT
38430	1107	8	,	,	,
38430	1107	9	'	'	''
38430	1107	10	the	the	DT
38430	1107	11	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1107	12	said	say	VBD
38430	1107	13	.	.	.
38430	1108	1	'	'	``
38430	1108	2	The	the	DT
38430	1108	3	song	song	NN
38430	1108	4	really	really	RB
38430	1108	5	_	_	NNP
38430	1108	6	is	be	VBZ
38430	1108	7	"	"	``
38430	1108	8	A	a	NN
38430	1108	9	-	-	HYPH
38430	1108	10	sitting	sit	VBG
38430	1108	11	on	on	IN
38430	1108	12	a	a	DT
38430	1108	13	Gate	Gate	NNP
38430	1108	14	_	_	NNP
38430	1108	15	"	"	''
38430	1108	16	....	....	.
38430	1108	17	'	'	''
38430	1108	18	"	"	''
38430	1108	19	H.	H.	NNP
38430	1108	20	NOMINALISM	NOMINALISM	NNP
38430	1108	21	.	.	.
38430	1109	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1109	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1110	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1110	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1110	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1110	4	,	,	,
38430	1110	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1110	6	70	70	CD
38430	1110	7	:	:	:
38430	1110	8	"	"	``
38430	1110	9	'	'	``
38430	1110	10	Then	then	RB
38430	1110	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1110	12	should	should	MD
38430	1110	13	say	say	VB
38430	1110	14	what	what	WP
38430	1110	15	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1110	16	mean	mean	VBP
38430	1110	17	,	,	,
38430	1110	18	'	'	''
38430	1110	19	the	the	DT
38430	1110	20	March	March	NNP
38430	1110	21	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1110	22	went	go	VBD
38430	1110	23	on	on	RP
38430	1110	24	.	.	.
38430	1111	1	"	"	``
38430	1111	2	'	'	``
38430	1111	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1111	4	do	do	VBP
38430	1111	5	,	,	,
38430	1111	6	'	'	''
38430	1111	7	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1111	8	hastily	hastily	RB
38430	1111	9	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1111	10	;	;	:
38430	1111	11	'	'	''
38430	1111	12	at	at	IN
38430	1111	13	least	least	JJS
38430	1111	14	--	--	:
38430	1111	15	at	at	RB
38430	1111	16	least	least	JJS
38430	1111	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1111	18	mean	mean	VBP
38430	1111	19	what	what	WP
38430	1111	20	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1111	21	say	say	VBP
38430	1111	22	--	--	:
38430	1111	23	that	that	DT
38430	1111	24	's	be	VBZ
38430	1111	25	the	the	DT
38430	1111	26	same	same	JJ
38430	1111	27	thing	thing	NN
38430	1111	28	,	,	,
38430	1111	29	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1111	30	know	know	VBP
38430	1111	31	.	.	.
38430	1111	32	'	'	''
38430	1112	1	"	"	``
38430	1112	2	'	'	``
38430	1112	3	Not	not	RB
38430	1112	4	the	the	DT
38430	1112	5	same	same	JJ
38430	1112	6	thing	thing	NN
38430	1112	7	a	a	DT
38430	1112	8	bit	bit	NN
38430	1112	9	!	!	.
38430	1112	10	'	'	''
38430	1113	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1113	2	the	the	DT
38430	1113	3	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1113	4	.	.	.
38430	1114	1	'	'	``
38430	1114	2	Why	why	WRB
38430	1114	3	,	,	,
38430	1114	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1114	5	might	may	MD
38430	1114	6	just	just	RB
38430	1114	7	as	as	RB
38430	1114	8	well	well	RB
38430	1114	9	say	say	VB
38430	1114	10	that	that	IN
38430	1114	11	"	"	``
38430	1114	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1114	13	see	see	VBP
38430	1114	14	what	what	WP
38430	1114	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1114	16	eat	eat	VBP
38430	1114	17	"	"	''
38430	1114	18	is	be	VBZ
38430	1114	19	the	the	DT
38430	1114	20	same	same	JJ
38430	1114	21	thing	thing	NN
38430	1114	22	as	as	IN
38430	1114	23	"	"	``
38430	1114	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1114	25	eat	eat	VBP
38430	1114	26	what	what	WP
38430	1114	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1114	28	see	see	VBP
38430	1114	29	.	.	.
38430	1114	30	"	"	''
38430	1114	31	'	'	''
38430	1115	1	"	"	``
38430	1115	2	'	'	``
38430	1115	3	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1115	4	might	may	MD
38430	1115	5	just	just	RB
38430	1115	6	as	as	RB
38430	1115	7	well	well	RB
38430	1115	8	say	say	VB
38430	1115	9	,	,	,
38430	1115	10	'	'	''
38430	1115	11	added	add	VBD
38430	1115	12	the	the	DT
38430	1115	13	March	March	NNP
38430	1115	14	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1115	15	,	,	,
38430	1115	16	'	'	''
38430	1115	17	that	that	IN
38430	1115	18	"	"	``
38430	1115	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1115	20	like	like	VBP
38430	1115	21	what	what	WP
38430	1115	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1115	23	get	get	VBP
38430	1115	24	"	"	''
38430	1115	25	is	be	VBZ
38430	1115	26	the	the	DT
38430	1115	27	same	same	JJ
38430	1115	28	thing	thing	NN
38430	1115	29	as	as	IN
38430	1115	30	"	"	``
38430	1115	31	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1115	32	get	get	VBP
38430	1115	33	what	what	WP
38430	1115	34	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1115	35	like	like	VBP
38430	1115	36	"	"	''
38430	1115	37	!	!	.
38430	1115	38	'	'	''
38430	1116	1	"	"	``
38430	1116	2	'	'	``
38430	1116	3	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1116	4	might	may	MD
38430	1116	5	just	just	RB
38430	1116	6	as	as	RB
38430	1116	7	well	well	RB
38430	1116	8	say	say	VB
38430	1116	9	,	,	,
38430	1116	10	'	'	''
38430	1116	11	added	add	VBD
38430	1116	12	the	the	DT
38430	1116	13	Dormouse	Dormouse	NNP
38430	1116	14	,	,	,
38430	1116	15	which	which	WDT
38430	1116	16	seemed	seem	VBD
38430	1116	17	to	to	TO
38430	1116	18	be	be	VB
38430	1116	19	talking	talk	VBG
38430	1116	20	in	in	IN
38430	1116	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1116	22	sleep	sleep	NN
38430	1116	23	,	,	,
38430	1116	24	'	'	''
38430	1116	25	that	that	IN
38430	1116	26	"	"	``
38430	1116	27	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1116	28	breathe	breathe	VBP
38430	1116	29	when	when	WRB
38430	1116	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1116	31	sleep	sleep	VBP
38430	1116	32	"	"	''
38430	1116	33	is	be	VBZ
38430	1116	34	the	the	DT
38430	1116	35	same	same	JJ
38430	1116	36	as	as	IN
38430	1116	37	"	"	``
38430	1116	38	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1116	39	sleep	sleep	VBP
38430	1116	40	when	when	WRB
38430	1116	41	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1116	42	breathe	breathe	VBP
38430	1116	43	"	"	``
38430	1116	44	!	!	.
38430	1116	45	'	'	''
38430	1117	1	"	"	``
38430	1117	2	'	'	``
38430	1117	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1117	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1117	5	is	be	VBZ
38430	1117	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1117	7	the	the	DT
38430	1117	8	same	same	JJ
38430	1117	9	thing	thing	NN
38430	1117	10	with	with	IN
38430	1117	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1117	12	,	,	,
38430	1117	13	'	'	''
38430	1117	14	said	say	VBD
38430	1117	15	the	the	DT
38430	1117	16	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1117	17	;	;	:
38430	1117	18	and	and	CC
38430	1117	19	here	here	RB
38430	1117	20	the	the	DT
38430	1117	21	conversation	conversation	NN
38430	1117	22	dropped	drop	VBD
38430	1117	23	,	,	,
38430	1117	24	...	...	:
38430	1117	25	"	"	``
38430	1117	26	I.	i.	NN
38430	1118	1	UTILITY	UTILITY	NNP
38430	1118	2	OF	of	IN
38430	1118	3	SYMBOLIC	symbolic	NN
38430	1118	4	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1118	5	.	.	.
38430	1119	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1119	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1120	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1120	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1120	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1120	4	,	,	,
38430	1120	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1120	6	92	92	CD
38430	1120	7	:	:	:
38430	1120	8	"	"	``
38430	1120	9	'	'	``
38430	1120	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	11	quite	quite	RB
38430	1120	12	agree	agree	VBP
38430	1120	13	with	with	IN
38430	1120	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	15	,	,	,
38430	1120	16	'	'	''
38430	1120	17	said	say	VBD
38430	1120	18	the	the	DT
38430	1120	19	Duchess	Duchess	NNP
38430	1120	20	,	,	,
38430	1120	21	'	'	''
38430	1120	22	and	and	CC
38430	1120	23	the	the	DT
38430	1120	24	moral	moral	NN
38430	1120	25	of	of	IN
38430	1120	26	that	that	DT
38430	1120	27	is--"Be	is--"Be	NFP
38430	1120	28	what	what	WP
38430	1120	29	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	30	would	would	MD
38430	1120	31	seem	seem	VB
38430	1120	32	to	to	IN
38430	1120	33	be"--or	be"--or	PRP
38430	1120	34	if	if	IN
38430	1120	35	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	36	'd	'd	MD
38430	1120	37	like	like	VB
38430	1120	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	39	put	put	VBD
38430	1120	40	more	more	RBR
38430	1120	41	simply--"Never	simply--"never	JJ
38430	1120	42	imagine	imagine	VB
38430	1120	43	yourself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	44	not	not	RB
38430	1120	45	to	to	TO
38430	1120	46	be	be	VB
38430	1120	47	otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	1120	48	than	than	IN
38430	1120	49	what	what	WP
38430	1120	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	51	might	may	MD
38430	1120	52	appear	appear	VB
38430	1120	53	to	to	IN
38430	1120	54	others	other	NNS
38430	1120	55	that	that	IN
38430	1120	56	what	what	WP
38430	1120	57	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	58	were	be	VBD
38430	1120	59	or	or	CC
38430	1120	60	might	may	MD
38430	1120	61	have	have	VB
38430	1120	62	been	be	VBN
38430	1120	63	was	be	VBD
38430	1120	64	not	not	RB
38430	1120	65	otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	1120	66	than	than	IN
38430	1120	67	what	what	WP
38430	1120	68	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	69	had	have	VBD
38430	1120	70	been	be	VBN
38430	1120	71	would	would	MD
38430	1120	72	have	have	VB
38430	1120	73	appeared	appear	VBN
38430	1120	74	to	to	IN
38430	1120	75	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1120	76	to	to	TO
38430	1120	77	be	be	VB
38430	1120	78	otherwise	otherwise	RB
38430	1120	79	.	.	.
38430	1120	80	"	"	''
38430	1120	81	'	'	''
38430	1121	1	"	"	``
38430	1121	2	'	'	``
38430	1121	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	4	think	think	VBP
38430	1121	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	6	should	should	MD
38430	1121	7	understand	understand	VB
38430	1121	8	that	that	IN
38430	1121	9	better	well	JJR
38430	1121	10	,	,	,
38430	1121	11	'	'	''
38430	1121	12	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1121	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1121	14	very	very	RB
38430	1121	15	politely	politely	RB
38430	1121	16	,	,	,
38430	1121	17	'	'	''
38430	1121	18	if	if	IN
38430	1121	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	20	had	have	VBD
38430	1121	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	22	written	write	VBN
38430	1121	23	down	down	RP
38430	1121	24	:	:	:
38430	1121	25	but	but	CC
38430	1121	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	27	ca	can	MD
38430	1121	28	n't	not	RB
38430	1121	29	quite	quite	RB
38430	1121	30	follow	follow	VB
38430	1121	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	32	as	as	IN
38430	1121	33	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	34	say	say	VBP
38430	1121	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1121	36	.	.	.
38430	1121	37	'	'	''
38430	1122	1	"	"	``
38430	1122	2	'	'	``
38430	1122	3	That	that	DT
38430	1122	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1122	5	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1122	6	to	to	IN
38430	1122	7	what	what	WP
38430	1122	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1122	9	could	could	MD
38430	1122	10	say	say	VB
38430	1122	11	if	if	IN
38430	1122	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1122	13	chose	choose	VBD
38430	1122	14	,	,	,
38430	1122	15	'	'	''
38430	1122	16	the	the	DT
38430	1122	17	Duchess	Duchess	NNP
38430	1122	18	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1122	19	,	,	,
38430	1122	20	in	in	IN
38430	1122	21	a	a	DT
38430	1122	22	pleased	pleased	JJ
38430	1122	23	tone	tone	NN
38430	1122	24	.	.	.
38430	1122	25	"	"	''
38430	1123	1	J.	J.	NNP
38430	1124	1	MISTAKE	MISTAKE	NNP
38430	1124	2	AS	as	IN
38430	1124	3	TO	to	IN
38430	1124	4	THE	the	DT
38430	1124	5	NATURE	NATURE	NNP
38430	1124	6	OF	of	IN
38430	1124	7	CRITICISM	CRITICISM	NNP
38430	1124	8	.	.	.
38430	1125	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1125	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1126	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1126	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1126	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1126	4	,	,	,
38430	1126	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1126	6	105	105	CD
38430	1126	7	:	:	:
38430	1126	8	"	"	``
38430	1126	9	'	'	``
38430	1126	10	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1126	11	's	be	VBZ
38430	1126	12	in	in	IN
38430	1126	13	that	that	DT
38430	1126	14	state	state	NN
38430	1126	15	of	of	IN
38430	1126	16	mind	mind	NN
38430	1126	17	,	,	,
38430	1126	18	'	'	''
38430	1126	19	said	say	VBD
38430	1126	20	the	the	DT
38430	1126	21	White	White	NNP
38430	1126	22	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1126	23	,	,	,
38430	1126	24	'	'	''
38430	1126	25	that	that	IN
38430	1126	26	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1126	27	wants	want	VBZ
38430	1126	28	to	to	TO
38430	1126	29	deny	deny	VB
38430	1126	30	_	_	NNP
38430	1126	31	something_--only	something_--only	RB
38430	1126	32	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1126	33	does	do	VBZ
38430	1126	34	n't	not	RB
38430	1126	35	know	know	VB
38430	1126	36	what	what	WP
38430	1126	37	to	to	TO
38430	1126	38	deny	deny	VB
38430	1126	39	.	.	.
38430	1126	40	'	'	''
38430	1127	1	"	"	``
38430	1127	2	'	'	``
38430	1127	3	A	a	DT
38430	1127	4	nasty	nasty	JJ
38430	1127	5	,	,	,
38430	1127	6	vicious	vicious	JJ
38430	1127	7	temper	temper	NN
38430	1127	8	,	,	,
38430	1127	9	'	'	''
38430	1127	10	the	the	DT
38430	1127	11	White	White	NNP
38430	1127	12	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1127	13	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	1127	14	;	;	:
38430	1127	15	and	and	CC
38430	1127	16	then	then	RB
38430	1127	17	there	there	EX
38430	1127	18	was	be	VBD
38430	1127	19	an	an	DT
38430	1127	20	uncomfortable	uncomfortable	JJ
38430	1127	21	silence	silence	NN
38430	1127	22	for	for	IN
38430	1127	23	a	a	DT
38430	1127	24	minute	minute	NN
38430	1127	25	or	or	CC
38430	1127	26	two	two	CD
38430	1127	27	.	.	.
38430	1127	28	"	"	''
38430	1128	1	K.	K.	NNP
38430	1128	2	A	A	NNP
38430	1128	3	CRITERION	criterion	NN
38430	1128	4	OF	of	IN
38430	1128	5	TRUTH	truth	NN
38430	1128	6	.	.	.
38430	1129	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1129	2	H.	H.	NNP
38430	1130	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	1130	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1130	3	,	,	,
38430	1130	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	1130	5	3	3	CD
38430	1130	6	:	:	:
38430	1130	7	"	"	``
38430	1130	8	Just	just	RB
38430	1130	9	the	the	DT
38430	1130	10	place	place	NN
38430	1130	11	for	for	IN
38430	1130	12	a	a	DT
38430	1130	13	Snark	snark	NN
38430	1130	14	!	!	.
38430	1131	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1131	2	have	have	VBP
38430	1131	3	said	say	VBN
38430	1131	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1131	5	twice	twice	RB
38430	1131	6	:	:	:
38430	1131	7	That	that	IN
38430	1131	8	alone	alone	RB
38430	1131	9	should	should	MD
38430	1131	10	encourage	encourage	VB
38430	1131	11	the	the	DT
38430	1131	12	crew	crew	NN
38430	1131	13	.	.	.
38430	1132	1	Just	just	RB
38430	1132	2	the	the	DT
38430	1132	3	place	place	NN
38430	1132	4	for	for	IN
38430	1132	5	a	a	DT
38430	1132	6	Snark	snark	NN
38430	1132	7	!	!	.
38430	1133	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1133	2	have	have	VBP
38430	1133	3	said	say	VBN
38430	1133	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1133	5	thrice	thrice	NN
38430	1133	6	:	:	:
38430	1133	7	What	what	WP
38430	1133	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1133	9	tell	tell	VBP
38430	1133	10	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1133	11	three	three	CD
38430	1133	12	times	time	NNS
38430	1133	13	is	be	VBZ
38430	1133	14	true	true	JJ
38430	1133	15	.	.	.
38430	1133	16	"	"	''
38430	1134	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1134	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1134	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1134	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1134	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1134	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1134	7	H.	H.	NNP
38430	1135	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	1135	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1135	3	,	,	,
38430	1135	4	p.	p.	NN
38430	1135	5	50	50	CD
38430	1135	6	:	:	:
38430	1135	7	"	"	``
38430	1135	8	'	'	``
38430	1135	9	Tis	Tis	NNP
38430	1135	10	the	the	DT
38430	1135	11	note	note	NN
38430	1135	12	of	of	IN
38430	1135	13	the	the	DT
38430	1135	14	Jubjub	Jubjub	NNP
38430	1135	15	!	!	.
38430	1136	1	Keep	keep	VB
38430	1136	2	count	count	NN
38430	1136	3	.	.	.
38430	1137	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1137	2	entreat	entreat	VBP
38430	1137	3	;	;	:
38430	1137	4	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1137	5	will	will	MD
38430	1137	6	find	find	VB
38430	1137	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1137	8	have	have	VBP
38430	1137	9	told	tell	VBN
38430	1137	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1137	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1137	12	twice	twice	RB
38430	1137	13	.	.	.
38430	1138	1	'	'	``
38430	1138	2	Tis	Tis	NNP
38430	1138	3	the	the	DT
38430	1138	4	song	song	NN
38430	1138	5	of	of	IN
38430	1138	6	the	the	DT
38430	1138	7	Jubjub	Jubjub	NNP
38430	1138	8	!	!	.
38430	1139	1	The	the	DT
38430	1139	2	proof	proof	NN
38430	1139	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	1139	4	complete	complete	JJ
38430	1139	5	,	,	,
38430	1139	6	If	if	IN
38430	1139	7	only	only	RB
38430	1139	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1139	9	've	have	VB
38430	1139	10	stated	state	VBN
38430	1139	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1139	12	thrice	thrice	NN
38430	1139	13	.	.	.
38430	1139	14	"	"	''
38430	1140	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1140	2	UNIVERSAL	UNIVERSAL	NNP
38430	1140	3	AND	and	CC
38430	1140	4	PARTICULAR	PARTICULAR	NNP
38430	1140	5	PROPOSITIONS	PROPOSITIONS	NNP
38430	1140	6	.	.	.
38430	1141	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1141	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1142	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1142	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1142	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1142	4	,	,	,
38430	1142	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1142	6	40	40	CD
38430	1142	7	:	:	:
38430	1142	8	The	the	DT
38430	1142	9	Gnat	Gnat	NNP
38430	1142	10	had	have	VBD
38430	1142	11	told	tell	VBN
38430	1142	12	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1142	13	that	that	IN
38430	1142	14	the	the	DT
38430	1142	15	Bread	Bread	NNP
38430	1142	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	1142	17	and	and	CC
38430	1142	18	-	-	HYPH
38430	1142	19	butterfly	butterfly	NN
38430	1142	20	lives	live	VBZ
38430	1142	21	on	on	IN
38430	1142	22	weak	weak	JJ
38430	1142	23	tea	tea	NN
38430	1142	24	with	with	IN
38430	1142	25	cream	cream	NN
38430	1142	26	in	in	IN
38430	1142	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1142	28	;	;	:
38430	1142	29	so	so	RB
38430	1142	30	:	:	:
38430	1142	31	"	"	``
38430	1142	32	'	'	``
38430	1142	33	Supposing	suppose	VBG
38430	1142	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1142	35	could	could	MD
38430	1142	36	n't	not	RB
38430	1142	37	find	find	VB
38430	1142	38	any	any	DT
38430	1142	39	?	?	.
38430	1142	40	'	'	''
38430	1143	1	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1143	2	suggested	suggest	VBD
38430	1143	3	.	.	.
38430	1144	1	"	"	``
38430	1144	2	'	'	``
38430	1144	3	Then	then	RB
38430	1144	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1144	5	would	would	MD
38430	1144	6	die	die	VB
38430	1144	7	,	,	,
38430	1144	8	of	of	IN
38430	1144	9	course	course	NN
38430	1144	10	.	.	.
38430	1144	11	'	'	''
38430	1145	1	"	"	``
38430	1145	2	'	'	``
38430	1145	3	But	but	CC
38430	1145	4	that	that	DT
38430	1145	5	must	must	MD
38430	1145	6	happen	happen	VB
38430	1145	7	very	very	RB
38430	1145	8	often	often	RB
38430	1145	9	,	,	,
38430	1145	10	'	'	''
38430	1145	11	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1145	12	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	1145	13	thoughtfully	thoughtfully	RB
38430	1145	14	.	.	.
38430	1146	1	"	"	``
38430	1146	2	'	'	``
38430	1146	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1146	4	always	always	RB
38430	1146	5	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	1146	6	,	,	,
38430	1146	7	'	'	''
38430	1146	8	said	say	VBD
38430	1146	9	the	the	DT
38430	1146	10	Gnat	Gnat	NNP
38430	1146	11	.	.	.
38430	1146	12	"	"	''
38430	1147	1	M.	M.	NNP
38430	1147	2	DENOTING	DENOTING	NNP
38430	1147	3	.	.	.
38430	1148	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1148	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1149	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1149	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1149	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1149	4	,	,	,
38430	1149	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1149	6	43	43	CD
38430	1149	7	:	:	:
38430	1149	8	Tweedledum	Tweedledum	NNP
38430	1149	9	and	and	CC
38430	1149	10	Tweedledee	Tweedledee	NNP
38430	1149	11	were	be	VBD
38430	1149	12	,	,	,
38430	1149	13	in	in	IN
38430	1149	14	many	many	JJ
38430	1149	15	respects	respect	NNS
38430	1149	16	,	,	,
38430	1149	17	indistinguishable	indistinguishable	JJ
38430	1149	18	,	,	,
38430	1149	19	and	and	CC
38430	1149	20	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1149	21	,	,	,
38430	1149	22	walking	walk	VBG
38430	1149	23	along	along	IN
38430	1149	24	the	the	DT
38430	1149	25	road	road	NN
38430	1149	26	,	,	,
38430	1149	27	noticed	notice	VBD
38430	1149	28	that	that	IN
38430	1149	29	"	"	``
38430	1149	30	whenever	whenever	WRB
38430	1149	31	the	the	DT
38430	1149	32	road	road	NN
38430	1149	33	divided	divide	VBN
38430	1149	34	there	there	EX
38430	1149	35	were	be	VBD
38430	1149	36	sure	sure	JJ
38430	1149	37	to	to	TO
38430	1149	38	be	be	VB
38430	1149	39	two	two	CD
38430	1149	40	finger	finger	NN
38430	1149	41	-	-	HYPH
38430	1149	42	posts	post	NNS
38430	1149	43	pointing	point	VBG
38430	1149	44	the	the	DT
38430	1149	45	same	same	JJ
38430	1149	46	way	way	NN
38430	1149	47	,	,	,
38430	1149	48	one	one	CD
38430	1149	49	marked	mark	VBD
38430	1149	50	'	'	''
38430	1149	51	TO	to	IN
38430	1149	52	TWEEDLEDUM	TWEEDLEDUM	NNP
38430	1149	53	'S	's	POS
38430	1149	54	HOUSE	HOUSE	NNP
38430	1149	55	'	'	''
38430	1149	56	and	and	CC
38430	1149	57	the	the	DT
38430	1149	58	other	other	JJ
38430	1149	59	'	'	''
38430	1149	60	TO	to	IN
38430	1149	61	THE	the	DT
38430	1149	62	HOUSE	HOUSE	NNP
38430	1149	63	OF	of	IN
38430	1149	64	TWEEDLEDEE	TWEEDLEDEE	NNP
38430	1149	65	.	.	.
38430	1149	66	'	'	''
38430	1150	1	"	"	``
38430	1150	2	'	'	``
38430	1150	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1150	4	do	do	VBP
38430	1150	5	believe	believe	VB
38430	1150	6	,	,	,
38430	1150	7	'	'	''
38430	1150	8	said	say	VBD
38430	1150	9	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1150	10	at	at	IN
38430	1150	11	last	last	JJ
38430	1150	12	,	,	,
38430	1150	13	'	'	''
38430	1150	14	that	that	IN
38430	1150	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1150	16	live	live	VBP
38430	1150	17	in	in	IN
38430	1150	18	the	the	DT
38430	1150	19	same	same	JJ
38430	1150	20	house	house	NN
38430	1150	21	!	!	.
38430	1150	22	...	...	:
38430	1150	23	'	'	''
38430	1150	24	"	"	''
38430	1151	1	N.	N.	NNP
38430	1151	2	NON	NON	NNP
38430	1151	3	-	-	NNP
38430	1151	4	ENTITY	ENTITY	NNP
38430	1151	5	.	.	.
38430	1152	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1152	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1153	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1153	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1153	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1153	4	,	,	,
38430	1153	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1153	6	87	87	CD
38430	1153	7	:	:	:
38430	1153	8	"	"	``
38430	1153	9	'	'	``
38430	1153	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1153	11	always	always	RB
38430	1153	12	thought	think	VBD
38430	1153	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1153	14	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1153	15	human	human	JJ
38430	1153	16	children	child	NNS
38430	1153	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1153	18	were	be	VBD
38430	1153	19	fabulous	fabulous	JJ
38430	1153	20	monsters	monster	NNS
38430	1153	21	!	!	.
38430	1153	22	'	'	''
38430	1154	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1154	2	the	the	DT
38430	1154	3	Unicorn	Unicorn	NNP
38430	1154	4	....	....	.
38430	1154	5	"	"	''
38430	1154	6	'	'	``
38430	1154	7	Do	do	VBP
38430	1154	8	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1154	9	know	know	VB
38430	1154	10	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1154	11	said	say	VBD
38430	1154	12	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1154	13	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1154	14	,	,	,
38430	1154	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1154	16	always	always	RB
38430	1154	17	thought	think	VBD
38430	1154	18	Unicorns	Unicorns	NNP
38430	1154	19	were	be	VBD
38430	1154	20	fabulous	fabulous	JJ
38430	1154	21	monsters	monster	NNS
38430	1154	22	,	,	,
38430	1154	23	too	too	RB
38430	1154	24	!	!	.
38430	1155	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1155	2	never	never	RB
38430	1155	3	saw	see	VBD
38430	1155	4	one	one	CD
38430	1155	5	alive	alive	JJ
38430	1155	6	before	before	RB
38430	1155	7	!	!	.
38430	1155	8	'	'	''
38430	1156	1	"	"	``
38430	1156	2	'	'	``
38430	1156	3	Well	well	UH
38430	1156	4	,	,	,
38430	1156	5	now	now	RB
38430	1156	6	that	that	IN
38430	1156	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1156	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1156	9	have	have	VBP
38430	1156	10	_	_	NNP
38430	1156	11	seen	see	VBN
38430	1156	12	each	each	DT
38430	1156	13	other	other	JJ
38430	1156	14	,	,	,
38430	1156	15	'	'	''
38430	1156	16	said	say	VBD
38430	1156	17	the	the	DT
38430	1156	18	Unicorn	Unicorn	NNP
38430	1156	19	,	,	,
38430	1156	20	'	'	''
38430	1156	21	if	if	IN
38430	1156	22	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1156	23	'll	will	MD
38430	1156	24	believe	believe	VB
38430	1156	25	in	in	IN
38430	1156	26	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1156	27	,	,	,
38430	1156	28	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1156	29	'll	will	MD
38430	1156	30	believe	believe	VB
38430	1156	31	in	in	IN
38430	1156	32	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1156	33	.	.	.
38430	1157	1	Is	be	VBZ
38430	1157	2	that	that	DT
38430	1157	3	a	a	DT
38430	1157	4	bargain	bargain	NN
38430	1157	5	?	?	.
38430	1157	6	'	'	''
38430	1157	7	"	"	''
38430	1158	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1158	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1158	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1158	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1158	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1158	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1158	7	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1159	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1159	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1159	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1159	4	,	,	,
38430	1159	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	1159	6	.	.	.
38430	1160	1	80	80	CD
38430	1160	2	-	-	SYM
38430	1160	3	1	1	CD
38430	1160	4	:	:	:
38430	1160	5	"	"	``
38430	1160	6	'	'	``
38430	1160	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1160	8	see	see	VBP
38430	1160	9	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	1160	10	on	on	IN
38430	1160	11	the	the	DT
38430	1160	12	road	road	NN
38430	1160	13	,	,	,
38430	1160	14	'	'	''
38430	1160	15	said	say	VBD
38430	1160	16	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1160	17	.	.	.
38430	1161	1	"	"	``
38430	1161	2	'	'	``
38430	1161	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1161	4	only	only	RB
38430	1161	5	wish	wish	VBP
38430	1161	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1161	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1161	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1161	9	had	have	VBD
38430	1161	10	such	such	JJ
38430	1161	11	eyes	eye	NNS
38430	1161	12	,	,	,
38430	1161	13	'	'	''
38430	1161	14	the	the	DT
38430	1161	15	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1161	16	White	White	NNP
38430	1161	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1161	18	King	King	NNP
38430	1161	19	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	1161	20	in	in	IN
38430	1161	21	a	a	DT
38430	1161	22	fretful	fretful	JJ
38430	1161	23	tone	tone	NN
38430	1161	24	.	.	.
38430	1162	1	'	'	``
38430	1162	2	To	to	TO
38430	1162	3	be	be	VB
38430	1162	4	able	able	JJ
38430	1162	5	to	to	TO
38430	1162	6	see	see	VB
38430	1162	7	Nobody	nobody	NN
38430	1162	8	!	!	.
38430	1163	1	And	and	CC
38430	1163	2	at	at	IN
38430	1163	3	that	that	DT
38430	1163	4	distance	distance	NN
38430	1163	5	,	,	,
38430	1163	6	too	too	RB
38430	1163	7	!	!	.
38430	1164	1	Why	why	WRB
38430	1164	2	,	,	,
38430	1164	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1164	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1164	5	as	as	RB
38430	1164	6	much	much	JJ
38430	1164	7	as	as	IN
38430	1164	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1164	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1164	10	_	_	NNP
38430	1164	11	can	can	MD
38430	1164	12	do	do	VB
38430	1164	13	to	to	TO
38430	1164	14	see	see	VB
38430	1164	15	real	real	JJ
38430	1164	16	people	people	NNS
38430	1164	17	by	by	IN
38430	1164	18	this	this	DT
38430	1164	19	light	light	NN
38430	1164	20	!	!	.
38430	1164	21	'	'	''
38430	1164	22	"	"	''
38430	1165	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1165	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1165	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1165	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1165	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1165	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1165	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	1166	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1166	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1166	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1166	4	,	,	,
38430	1166	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1166	6	17	17	CD
38430	1166	7	:	:	:
38430	1166	8	"	"	``
38430	1166	9	And	and	CC
38430	1166	10	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1166	11	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1166	12	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1166	13	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1166	14	tried	try	VBD
38430	1166	15	to	to	TO
38430	1166	16	fancy	fancy	VB
38430	1166	17	what	what	WP
38430	1166	18	the	the	DT
38430	1166	19	flame	flame	NN
38430	1166	20	of	of	IN
38430	1166	21	a	a	DT
38430	1166	22	candle	candle	NN
38430	1166	23	looks	look	VBZ
38430	1166	24	like	like	IN
38430	1166	25	after	after	IN
38430	1166	26	the	the	DT
38430	1166	27	candle	candle	NN
38430	1166	28	is	be	VBZ
38430	1166	29	blown	blow	VBN
38430	1166	30	out	out	RP
38430	1166	31	,	,	,
38430	1166	32	for	for	IN
38430	1166	33	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1166	34	could	could	MD
38430	1166	35	not	not	RB
38430	1166	36	remember	remember	VB
38430	1166	37	ever	ever	RB
38430	1166	38	having	have	VBG
38430	1166	39	seen	see	VBN
38430	1166	40	such	such	PDT
38430	1166	41	a	a	DT
38430	1166	42	thing	thing	NN
38430	1166	43	.	.	.
38430	1166	44	"	"	''
38430	1167	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1167	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1167	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1167	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1167	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1167	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1167	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	1168	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1168	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1168	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1168	4	,	,	,
38430	1168	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1168	6	68	68	CD
38430	1168	7	:	:	:
38430	1168	8	"	"	``
38430	1168	9	...	...	.
38430	1169	1	This	this	DT
38430	1169	2	time	time	NN
38430	1169	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1169	4	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1169	5	the	the	DT
38430	1169	6	Cheshire	Cheshire	NNP
38430	1169	7	Cat	Cat	NNP
38430	1169	8	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1169	9	vanished	vanish	VBD
38430	1169	10	quite	quite	RB
38430	1169	11	slowly	slowly	RB
38430	1169	12	,	,	,
38430	1169	13	beginning	begin	VBG
38430	1169	14	with	with	IN
38430	1169	15	the	the	DT
38430	1169	16	end	end	NN
38430	1169	17	of	of	IN
38430	1169	18	the	the	DT
38430	1169	19	tail	tail	NN
38430	1169	20	,	,	,
38430	1169	21	and	and	CC
38430	1169	22	ending	end	VBG
38430	1169	23	with	with	IN
38430	1169	24	the	the	DT
38430	1169	25	grin	grin	NN
38430	1169	26	,	,	,
38430	1169	27	which	which	WDT
38430	1169	28	remained	remain	VBD
38430	1169	29	some	some	DT
38430	1169	30	time	time	NN
38430	1169	31	after	after	IN
38430	1169	32	the	the	DT
38430	1169	33	rest	rest	NN
38430	1169	34	of	of	IN
38430	1169	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1169	36	had	have	VBD
38430	1169	37	gone	go	VBN
38430	1169	38	.	.	.
38430	1170	1	"	"	``
38430	1170	2	'	'	``
38430	1170	3	Well	well	UH
38430	1170	4	!	!	.
38430	1171	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1171	2	've	have	VB
38430	1171	3	often	often	RB
38430	1171	4	seen	see	VBN
38430	1171	5	a	a	DT
38430	1171	6	cat	cat	NN
38430	1171	7	without	without	IN
38430	1171	8	a	a	DT
38430	1171	9	grin	grin	NN
38430	1171	10	,	,	,
38430	1171	11	'	'	''
38430	1171	12	thought	think	VBD
38430	1171	13	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1171	14	;	;	:
38430	1171	15	'	'	''
38430	1171	16	but	but	CC
38430	1171	17	a	a	DT
38430	1171	18	grin	grin	NN
38430	1171	19	without	without	IN
38430	1171	20	a	a	DT
38430	1171	21	cat	cat	NN
38430	1171	22	!	!	.
38430	1172	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1172	2	's	be	VBZ
38430	1172	3	the	the	DT
38430	1172	4	most	most	RBS
38430	1172	5	curious	curious	JJ
38430	1172	6	thing	thing	NN
38430	1172	7	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1172	8	ever	ever	RB
38430	1172	9	saw	see	VBD
38430	1172	10	in	in	IN
38430	1172	11	all	all	DT
38430	1172	12	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1172	13	life	life	NN
38430	1172	14	!	!	.
38430	1172	15	'	'	''
38430	1172	16	"	"	''
38430	1173	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1173	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1173	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1173	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1173	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1173	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1173	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	1174	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1174	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1174	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1174	4	,	,	,
38430	1174	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1174	6	77	77	CD
38430	1174	7	:	:	:
38430	1174	8	"	"	``
38430	1174	9	...	...	.
38430	1175	1	The	the	DT
38430	1175	2	Dormouse	Dormouse	NNP
38430	1175	3	went	go	VBD
38430	1175	4	on	on	RP
38430	1175	5	,	,	,
38430	1175	6	...	...	NFP
38430	1175	7	;	;	:
38430	1175	8	'	'	''
38430	1175	9	and	and	CC
38430	1175	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1175	11	drew	draw	VBD
38430	1175	12	all	all	DT
38430	1175	13	manner	manner	NN
38430	1175	14	of	of	IN
38430	1175	15	things	thing	NNS
38430	1175	16	--	--	:
38430	1175	17	everything	everything	NN
38430	1175	18	that	that	WDT
38430	1175	19	begins	begin	VBZ
38430	1175	20	with	with	IN
38430	1175	21	an	an	DT
38430	1175	22	M.	M.	NNP
38430	1175	23	'	'	''
38430	1175	24	"	"	''
38430	1175	25	'	'	``
38430	1175	26	Why	why	WRB
38430	1175	27	with	with	IN
38430	1175	28	an	an	DT
38430	1175	29	M	m	NN
38430	1175	30	?	?	.
38430	1175	31	'	'	''
38430	1176	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1176	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1176	3	.	.	.
38430	1177	1	"	"	``
38430	1177	2	'	'	``
38430	1177	3	Why	why	WRB
38430	1177	4	not	not	RB
38430	1177	5	?	?	.
38430	1177	6	'	'	''
38430	1178	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1178	2	the	the	DT
38430	1178	3	March	March	NNP
38430	1178	4	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1178	5	.	.	.
38430	1179	1	"	"	``
38430	1179	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1179	3	was	be	VBD
38430	1179	4	silent	silent	JJ
38430	1179	5	.	.	.
38430	1180	1	"	"	``
38430	1180	2	...	...	NFP
38430	1180	3	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1180	4	The	the	DT
38430	1180	5	Dormouse	Dormouse	NNP
38430	1180	6	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1180	7	went	go	VBD
38430	1180	8	on	on	RB
38430	1180	9	:	:	:
38430	1180	10	'	'	''
38430	1180	11	--that	--that	NN
38430	1180	12	begins	begin	VBZ
38430	1180	13	with	with	IN
38430	1180	14	an	an	DT
38430	1180	15	M	M	NNP
38430	1180	16	,	,	,
38430	1180	17	such	such	JJ
38430	1180	18	as	as	IN
38430	1180	19	mouse	mouse	NN
38430	1180	20	-	-	HYPH
38430	1180	21	traps	trap	NNS
38430	1180	22	,	,	,
38430	1180	23	and	and	CC
38430	1180	24	the	the	DT
38430	1180	25	moon	moon	NN
38430	1180	26	,	,	,
38430	1180	27	and	and	CC
38430	1180	28	memory	memory	NN
38430	1180	29	,	,	,
38430	1180	30	and	and	CC
38430	1180	31	muchness	muchness	NN
38430	1180	32	,	,	,
38430	1180	33	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1180	34	know	know	VBP
38430	1180	35	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1180	36	say	say	VBP
38430	1180	37	things	thing	NNS
38430	1180	38	are	be	VBP
38430	1180	39	"	"	``
38430	1180	40	much	much	JJ
38430	1180	41	of	of	IN
38430	1180	42	a	a	DT
38430	1180	43	muchness"--did	muchness"--did	NN
38430	1180	44	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1180	45	ever	ever	RB
38430	1180	46	see	see	VBP
38430	1180	47	such	such	PDT
38430	1180	48	a	a	DT
38430	1180	49	thing	thing	NN
38430	1180	50	as	as	IN
38430	1180	51	a	a	DT
38430	1180	52	drawing	drawing	NN
38430	1180	53	of	of	IN
38430	1180	54	a	a	DT
38430	1180	55	muchness	muchness	NN
38430	1180	56	?	?	.
38430	1180	57	'	'	''
38430	1181	1	"	"	``
38430	1181	2	'	'	``
38430	1181	3	Really	really	RB
38430	1181	4	,	,	,
38430	1181	5	now	now	RB
38430	1181	6	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1181	7	ask	ask	VBP
38430	1181	8	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1181	9	,	,	,
38430	1181	10	'	'	''
38430	1181	11	said	say	VBD
38430	1181	12	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1181	13	,	,	,
38430	1181	14	very	very	RB
38430	1181	15	much	much	RB
38430	1181	16	confused	confused	JJ
38430	1181	17	,	,	,
38430	1181	18	'	'	''
38430	1181	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1181	20	do	do	VBP
38430	1181	21	n't	not	RB
38430	1181	22	think----	think----	VB
38430	1181	23	'	'	``
38430	1181	24	"	"	''
38430	1181	25	'	'	''
38430	1181	26	Then	then	RB
38430	1181	27	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1181	28	should	should	MD
38430	1181	29	n't	not	RB
38430	1181	30	talk	talk	VB
38430	1181	31	,	,	,
38430	1181	32	'	'	''
38430	1181	33	said	say	VBD
38430	1181	34	the	the	DT
38430	1181	35	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1181	36	.	.	.
38430	1181	37	"	"	''
38430	1182	1	O.	O.	NNP
38430	1183	1	OBJECTS	OBJECTS	NNP
38430	1183	2	OF	of	IN
38430	1183	3	MATHEMATICAL	MATHEMATICAL	NNP
38430	1183	4	LOGIC	LOGIC	NNP
38430	1183	5	.	.	.
38430	1184	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1184	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1185	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1185	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1185	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1185	4	,	,	,
38430	1185	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1185	6	93	93	CD
38430	1185	7	:	:	:
38430	1185	8	"	"	``
38430	1185	9	'	'	``
38430	1185	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1185	11	was	be	VBD
38430	1185	12	wondering	wonder	VBG
38430	1185	13	what	what	WP
38430	1185	14	the	the	DT
38430	1185	15	mouse	mouse	NN
38430	1185	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	1185	17	trap	trap	NN
38430	1185	18	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1185	19	fastened	fasten	VBN
38430	1185	20	to	to	IN
38430	1185	21	the	the	DT
38430	1185	22	White	White	NNP
38430	1185	23	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1185	24	's	's	POS
38430	1185	25	saddle	saddle	NN
38430	1185	26	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1185	27	was	be	VBD
38430	1185	28	for	for	IN
38430	1185	29	,	,	,
38430	1185	30	'	'	''
38430	1185	31	said	say	VBD
38430	1185	32	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1185	33	.	.	.
38430	1186	1	'	'	``
38430	1186	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1186	3	is	be	VBZ
38430	1186	4	n't	not	RB
38430	1186	5	very	very	RB
38430	1186	6	likely	likely	JJ
38430	1186	7	there	there	EX
38430	1186	8	would	would	MD
38430	1186	9	be	be	VB
38430	1186	10	any	any	DT
38430	1186	11	mice	mouse	NNS
38430	1186	12	on	on	IN
38430	1186	13	the	the	DT
38430	1186	14	horse	horse	NN
38430	1186	15	's	be	VBZ
38430	1186	16	back	back	NN
38430	1186	17	.	.	.
38430	1186	18	'	'	''
38430	1187	1	"	"	``
38430	1187	2	'	'	``
38430	1187	3	Not	not	RB
38430	1187	4	very	very	RB
38430	1187	5	likely	likely	JJ
38430	1187	6	,	,	,
38430	1187	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
38430	1187	8	,	,	,
38430	1187	9	'	'	''
38430	1187	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1187	11	the	the	DT
38430	1187	12	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1187	13	,	,	,
38430	1187	14	'	'	''
38430	1187	15	but	but	CC
38430	1187	16	,	,	,
38430	1187	17	if	if	IN
38430	1187	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1187	19	_	_	NNP
38430	1187	20	do	do	VBP
38430	1187	21	_	_	NNP
38430	1187	22	come	come	VB
38430	1187	23	,	,	,
38430	1187	24	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1187	25	do	do	VBP
38430	1187	26	n't	not	RB
38430	1187	27	choose	choose	VB
38430	1187	28	to	to	TO
38430	1187	29	have	have	VB
38430	1187	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1187	31	running	run	VBG
38430	1187	32	all	all	RB
38430	1187	33	about	about	IN
38430	1187	34	.	.	.
38430	1187	35	'	'	''
38430	1188	1	"	"	``
38430	1188	2	'	'	``
38430	1188	3	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1188	4	see	see	VBP
38430	1188	5	,	,	,
38430	1188	6	'	'	''
38430	1188	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1188	8	went	go	VBD
38430	1188	9	on	on	RP
38430	1188	10	after	after	IN
38430	1188	11	a	a	DT
38430	1188	12	pause	pause	NN
38430	1188	13	,	,	,
38430	1188	14	'	'	''
38430	1188	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1188	16	's	be	VBZ
38430	1188	17	as	as	RB
38430	1188	18	well	well	RB
38430	1188	19	to	to	TO
38430	1188	20	be	be	VB
38430	1188	21	provided	provide	VBN
38430	1188	22	for	for	IN
38430	1188	23	_	_	NNP
38430	1188	24	everything	everything	NN
38430	1188	25	_	_	NNP
38430	1188	26	.	.	.
38430	1189	1	That	that	DT
38430	1189	2	's	be	VBZ
38430	1189	3	the	the	DT
38430	1189	4	reason	reason	NN
38430	1189	5	the	the	DT
38430	1189	6	horse	horse	NN
38430	1189	7	has	have	VBZ
38430	1189	8	all	all	PDT
38430	1189	9	these	these	DT
38430	1189	10	anklets	anklet	NNS
38430	1189	11	round	round	IN
38430	1189	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1189	13	feet	foot	NNS
38430	1189	14	.	.	.
38430	1189	15	'	'	''
38430	1190	1	"	"	``
38430	1190	2	'	'	``
38430	1190	3	But	but	CC
38430	1190	4	what	what	WP
38430	1190	5	are	be	VBP
38430	1190	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1190	7	for	for	IN
38430	1190	8	?	?	.
38430	1190	9	'	'	''
38430	1191	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1191	2	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1191	3	in	in	IN
38430	1191	4	a	a	DT
38430	1191	5	tone	tone	NN
38430	1191	6	of	of	IN
38430	1191	7	great	great	JJ
38430	1191	8	curiosity	curiosity	NN
38430	1191	9	.	.	.
38430	1192	1	"	"	``
38430	1192	2	'	'	``
38430	1192	3	To	to	TO
38430	1192	4	guard	guard	VB
38430	1192	5	against	against	IN
38430	1192	6	the	the	DT
38430	1192	7	bites	bite	NNS
38430	1192	8	of	of	IN
38430	1192	9	sharks	shark	NNS
38430	1192	10	,	,	,
38430	1192	11	'	'	''
38430	1192	12	the	the	DT
38430	1192	13	Knight	Knight	NNP
38430	1192	14	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1192	15	.	.	.
38430	1192	16	"	"	''
38430	1193	1	P.	P.	NNP
38430	1193	2	THE	the	DT
38430	1193	3	PRINCIPLE	PRINCIPLE	NNP
38430	1193	4	OF	of	IN
38430	1193	5	PERMANENCE	PERMANENCE	NNP
38430	1193	6	.	.	.
38430	1194	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1194	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1195	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1195	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1195	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1195	4	,	,	,
38430	1195	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1195	6	106	106	CD
38430	1195	7	:	:	:
38430	1195	8	"	"	``
38430	1195	9	'	'	``
38430	1195	10	Can	Can	MD
38430	1195	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1195	12	do	do	VB
38430	1195	13	Subtraction	subtraction	NN
38430	1195	14	?	?	.
38430	1196	1	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1196	2	said	say	VBD
38430	1196	3	the	the	DT
38430	1196	4	Red	Red	NNP
38430	1196	5	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1196	6	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1196	7	Take	take	VB
38430	1196	8	nine	nine	CD
38430	1196	9	from	from	IN
38430	1196	10	eight	eight	CD
38430	1196	11	.	.	.
38430	1196	12	'	'	''
38430	1197	1	"	"	``
38430	1197	2	'	'	``
38430	1197	3	Nine	nine	CD
38430	1197	4	from	from	IN
38430	1197	5	eight	eight	CD
38430	1197	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1197	7	ca	can	MD
38430	1197	8	n't	not	RB
38430	1197	9	,	,	,
38430	1197	10	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1197	11	know	know	VBP
38430	1197	12	,	,	,
38430	1197	13	'	'	''
38430	1197	14	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1197	15	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1197	16	very	very	RB
38430	1197	17	readily	readily	RB
38430	1197	18	'	'	``
38430	1197	19	but--	but--	NNP
38430	1197	20	'	'	''
38430	1197	21	"	"	''
38430	1197	22	'	'	``
38430	1197	23	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1197	24	ca	can	MD
38430	1197	25	n't	not	RB
38430	1197	26	do	do	VB
38430	1197	27	Substraction	substraction	NN
38430	1197	28	,	,	,
38430	1197	29	'	'	''
38430	1197	30	said	say	VBD
38430	1197	31	the	the	DT
38430	1197	32	White	White	NNP
38430	1197	33	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1197	34	.	.	.
38430	1197	35	"	"	''
38430	1198	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1198	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1198	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1198	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1198	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1198	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1198	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	1199	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1199	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1199	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1199	4	,	,	,
38430	1199	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1199	6	56	56	CD
38430	1199	7	:	:	:
38430	1199	8	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1199	9	Said	say	VBD
38430	1199	10	the	the	DT
38430	1199	11	Pigeon	Pigeon	NNP
38430	1199	12	to	to	IN
38430	1199	13	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1199	14	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1199	15	:	:	:
38430	1199	16	"	"	``
38430	1199	17	'	'	``
38430	1199	18	...	...	.
38430	1199	19	No	no	UH
38430	1199	20	,	,	,
38430	1199	21	no	no	UH
38430	1199	22	!	!	.
38430	1200	1	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1200	2	're	be	VBP
38430	1200	3	a	a	DT
38430	1200	4	serpent	serpent	NN
38430	1200	5	;	;	:
38430	1200	6	and	and	CC
38430	1200	7	there	there	EX
38430	1200	8	's	be	VBZ
38430	1200	9	no	no	DT
38430	1200	10	use	use	NN
38430	1200	11	denying	deny	VBG
38430	1200	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1200	13	.	.	.
38430	1201	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1201	2	suppose	suppose	VBP
38430	1201	3	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1201	4	'll	will	MD
38430	1201	5	be	be	VB
38430	1201	6	telling	tell	VBG
38430	1201	7	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1201	8	next	next	IN
38430	1201	9	that	that	IN
38430	1201	10	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1201	11	never	never	RB
38430	1201	12	tasted	taste	VBD
38430	1201	13	an	an	DT
38430	1201	14	egg	egg	NN
38430	1201	15	!	!	.
38430	1201	16	'	'	''
38430	1202	1	"	"	``
38430	1202	2	'	'	``
38430	1202	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1202	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1202	5	have	have	VBP
38430	1202	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1202	7	tasted	taste	VBN
38430	1202	8	eggs	egg	NNS
38430	1202	9	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	1202	10	,	,	,
38430	1202	11	'	'	''
38430	1202	12	said	say	VBD
38430	1202	13	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1202	14	,	,	,
38430	1202	15	who	who	WP
38430	1202	16	was	be	VBD
38430	1202	17	a	a	DT
38430	1202	18	very	very	RB
38430	1202	19	truthful	truthful	JJ
38430	1202	20	child	child	NN
38430	1202	21	;	;	:
38430	1202	22	'	'	''
38430	1202	23	but	but	CC
38430	1202	24	little	little	JJ
38430	1202	25	girls	girl	NNS
38430	1202	26	eat	eat	VBP
38430	1202	27	eggs	egg	NNS
38430	1202	28	quite	quite	RB
38430	1202	29	as	as	RB
38430	1202	30	much	much	RB
38430	1202	31	as	as	IN
38430	1202	32	serpents	serpent	NNS
38430	1202	33	do	do	VBP
38430	1202	34	,	,	,
38430	1202	35	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1202	36	know	know	VBP
38430	1202	37	.	.	.
38430	1202	38	'	'	''
38430	1203	1	"	"	``
38430	1203	2	'	'	``
38430	1203	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1203	4	do	do	VBP
38430	1203	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1203	6	believe	believe	VB
38430	1203	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1203	8	,	,	,
38430	1203	9	'	'	''
38430	1203	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1203	11	the	the	DT
38430	1203	12	Pigeon	Pigeon	NNP
38430	1203	13	;	;	:
38430	1203	14	'	'	''
38430	1203	15	but	but	CC
38430	1203	16	if	if	IN
38430	1203	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1203	18	do	do	VBP
38430	1203	19	,	,	,
38430	1203	20	why	why	WRB
38430	1203	21	then	then	RB
38430	1203	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1203	23	're	be	VBP
38430	1203	24	a	a	DT
38430	1203	25	kind	kind	NN
38430	1203	26	of	of	IN
38430	1203	27	serpent	serpent	NN
38430	1203	28	,	,	,
38430	1203	29	that	that	DT
38430	1203	30	's	be	VBZ
38430	1203	31	all	all	DT
38430	1203	32	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1203	33	can	can	MD
38430	1203	34	say	say	VB
38430	1203	35	.	.	.
38430	1203	36	'	'	''
38430	1204	1	"	"	``
38430	1204	2	This	this	DT
38430	1204	3	was	be	VBD
38430	1204	4	such	such	PDT
38430	1204	5	a	a	DT
38430	1204	6	new	new	JJ
38430	1204	7	idea	idea	NN
38430	1204	8	to	to	IN
38430	1204	9	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1204	10	,	,	,
38430	1204	11	that	that	IN
38430	1204	12	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	13	was	be	VBD
38430	1204	14	quite	quite	RB
38430	1204	15	silent	silent	JJ
38430	1204	16	for	for	IN
38430	1204	17	a	a	DT
38430	1204	18	minute	minute	NN
38430	1204	19	or	or	CC
38430	1204	20	two	two	CD
38430	1204	21	,	,	,
38430	1204	22	which	which	WDT
38430	1204	23	gave	give	VBD
38430	1204	24	the	the	DT
38430	1204	25	Pigeon	Pigeon	NNP
38430	1204	26	the	the	DT
38430	1204	27	opportunity	opportunity	NN
38430	1204	28	of	of	IN
38430	1204	29	adding	add	VBG
38430	1204	30	,	,	,
38430	1204	31	'	'	''
38430	1204	32	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	33	're	be	VBP
38430	1204	34	looking	look	VBG
38430	1204	35	for	for	IN
38430	1204	36	eggs	egg	NNS
38430	1204	37	,	,	,
38430	1204	38	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	39	know	know	VBP
38430	1204	40	_	_	NNP
38430	1204	41	that	that	DT
38430	1204	42	_	_	NNP
38430	1204	43	well	well	RB
38430	1204	44	enough	enough	RB
38430	1204	45	;	;	:
38430	1204	46	and	and	CC
38430	1204	47	what	what	WP
38430	1204	48	does	do	VBZ
38430	1204	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	50	matter	matter	VB
38430	1204	51	to	to	IN
38430	1204	52	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	53	whether	whether	IN
38430	1204	54	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1204	55	're	be	VBP
38430	1204	56	a	a	DT
38430	1204	57	little	little	JJ
38430	1204	58	girl	girl	NN
38430	1204	59	or	or	CC
38430	1204	60	a	a	DT
38430	1204	61	serpent	serpent	NN
38430	1204	62	?	?	.
38430	1204	63	'	'	''
38430	1205	1	"	"	``
38430	1205	2	'	'	``
38430	1205	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1205	4	matters	matter	VBZ
38430	1205	5	a	a	DT
38430	1205	6	good	good	JJ
38430	1205	7	deal	deal	NN
38430	1205	8	to	to	IN
38430	1205	9	_	_	NNP
38430	1205	10	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1205	11	_	_	NNP
38430	1205	12	,	,	,
38430	1205	13	'	'	''
38430	1205	14	said	say	VBD
38430	1205	15	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1205	16	hastily	hastily	RB
38430	1205	17	;	;	:
38430	1205	18	...	...	:
38430	1205	19	"	"	``
38430	1205	20	*	*	NFP
38430	1205	21	*	*	NFP
38430	1205	22	*	*	NFP
38430	1205	23	*	*	NFP
38430	1205	24	*	*	NFP
38430	1205	25	_	_	NNP
38430	1205	26	A.	a.	NN
38430	1206	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1206	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1206	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1206	4	,	,	,
38430	1206	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1206	6	75	75	CD
38430	1206	7	:	:	:
38430	1206	8	"	"	``
38430	1206	9	'	'	``
38430	1206	10	But	but	CC
38430	1206	11	why	why	WRB
38430	1206	12	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1206	13	asked	ask	VBN
38430	1206	14	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1206	15	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1206	16	did	do	VBD
38430	1206	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1206	18	live	live	VB
38430	1206	19	at	at	IN
38430	1206	20	the	the	DT
38430	1206	21	bottom	bottom	NN
38430	1206	22	of	of	IN
38430	1206	23	a	a	DT
38430	1206	24	well	well	NN
38430	1206	25	?	?	.
38430	1206	26	'	'	''
38430	1207	1	"	"	``
38430	1207	2	'	'	``
38430	1207	3	Take	take	VB
38430	1207	4	some	some	DT
38430	1207	5	more	more	JJR
38430	1207	6	tea	tea	NN
38430	1207	7	,	,	,
38430	1207	8	'	'	''
38430	1207	9	the	the	DT
38430	1207	10	March	March	NNP
38430	1207	11	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1207	12	said	say	VBD
38430	1207	13	to	to	IN
38430	1207	14	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1207	15	,	,	,
38430	1207	16	very	very	RB
38430	1207	17	earnestly	earnestly	RB
38430	1207	18	.	.	.
38430	1208	1	"	"	``
38430	1208	2	'	'	``
38430	1208	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1208	4	've	have	VB
38430	1208	5	had	have	VBD
38430	1208	6	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1208	7	yet	yet	RB
38430	1208	8	,	,	,
38430	1208	9	'	'	''
38430	1208	10	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1208	11	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1208	12	in	in	IN
38430	1208	13	an	an	DT
38430	1208	14	offended	offend	VBN
38430	1208	15	tone	tone	NN
38430	1208	16	,	,	,
38430	1208	17	'	'	''
38430	1208	18	so	so	RB
38430	1208	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1208	20	ca	can	MD
38430	1208	21	n't	not	RB
38430	1208	22	take	take	VB
38430	1208	23	more	more	JJR
38430	1208	24	.	.	.
38430	1208	25	'	'	''
38430	1209	1	"	"	``
38430	1209	2	'	'	``
38430	1209	3	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1209	4	mean	mean	VBP
38430	1209	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1209	6	ca	can	MD
38430	1209	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1209	8	take	take	VB
38430	1209	9	_	_	NNP
38430	1209	10	less	less	RBR
38430	1209	11	_	_	NNP
38430	1209	12	,	,	,
38430	1209	13	'	'	''
38430	1209	14	said	say	VBD
38430	1209	15	the	the	DT
38430	1209	16	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1209	17	:	:	:
38430	1209	18	'	'	``
38430	1209	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1209	20	's	be	VBZ
38430	1209	21	very	very	RB
38430	1209	22	easy	easy	JJ
38430	1209	23	to	to	TO
38430	1209	24	take	take	VB
38430	1209	25	_	_	NNP
38430	1209	26	more	more	RBR
38430	1209	27	_	_	NNP
38430	1209	28	than	than	IN
38430	1209	29	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1209	30	.	.	.
38430	1209	31	'	'	''
38430	1209	32	"	"	''
38430	1210	1	Q.	Q.	NNP
38430	1210	2	MATHEMATICIANS	MATHEMATICIANS	NNP
38430	1210	3	'	'	POS
38430	1210	4	TREATMENT	treatment	NN
38430	1210	5	OF	of	IN
38430	1210	6	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1210	7	.	.	.
38430	1211	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1211	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1212	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1212	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1212	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1212	4	,	,	,
38430	1212	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1212	6	74	74	CD
38430	1212	7	:	:	:
38430	1212	8	The	the	DT
38430	1212	9	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1212	10	had	have	VBD
38430	1212	11	told	tell	VBN
38430	1212	12	of	of	IN
38430	1212	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1212	14	quarrel	quarrel	NN
38430	1212	15	with	with	IN
38430	1212	16	Time	Time	NNP
38430	1212	17	,	,	,
38430	1212	18	and	and	CC
38430	1212	19	of	of	IN
38430	1212	20	Time	Time	NNP
38430	1212	21	's	's	POS
38430	1212	22	refusal	refusal	NN
38430	1212	23	now	now	RB
38430	1212	24	to	to	TO
38430	1212	25	do	do	VB
38430	1212	26	anything	anything	NN
38430	1212	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1212	28	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1212	29	:	:	:
38430	1212	30	"	"	``
38430	1212	31	'	'	''
38430	1212	32	...	...	.
38430	1213	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1213	2	's	be	VBZ
38430	1213	3	always	always	RB
38430	1213	4	six	six	CD
38430	1213	5	o'clock	o'clock	NN
38430	1213	6	now	now	RB
38430	1213	7	!	!	.
38430	1213	8	'	'	''
38430	1214	1	"	"	``
38430	1214	2	A	a	DT
38430	1214	3	bright	bright	JJ
38430	1214	4	idea	idea	NN
38430	1214	5	came	come	VBD
38430	1214	6	into	into	IN
38430	1214	7	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1214	8	's	's	POS
38430	1214	9	head	head	NN
38430	1214	10	.	.	.
38430	1215	1	'	'	``
38430	1215	2	Is	be	VBZ
38430	1215	3	that	that	IN
38430	1215	4	the	the	DT
38430	1215	5	reason	reason	NN
38430	1215	6	so	so	RB
38430	1215	7	many	many	JJ
38430	1215	8	tea	tea	NN
38430	1215	9	things	thing	NNS
38430	1215	10	are	be	VBP
38430	1215	11	put	put	VBN
38430	1215	12	out	out	RP
38430	1215	13	here	here	RB
38430	1215	14	?	?	.
38430	1215	15	'	'	''
38430	1216	1	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1216	2	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1216	3	.	.	.
38430	1217	1	"	"	``
38430	1217	2	'	'	``
38430	1217	3	Yes	yes	UH
38430	1217	4	,	,	,
38430	1217	5	that	that	DT
38430	1217	6	's	be	VBZ
38430	1217	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1217	8	,	,	,
38430	1217	9	'	'	''
38430	1217	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1217	11	the	the	DT
38430	1217	12	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1217	13	,	,	,
38430	1217	14	with	with	IN
38430	1217	15	a	a	DT
38430	1217	16	sigh	sigh	NN
38430	1217	17	:	:	:
38430	1217	18	'	'	``
38430	1217	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1217	20	's	be	VBZ
38430	1217	21	always	always	RB
38430	1217	22	tea	tea	NN
38430	1217	23	time	time	NN
38430	1217	24	,	,	,
38430	1217	25	and	and	CC
38430	1217	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1217	27	've	have	VB
38430	1217	28	no	no	DT
38430	1217	29	time	time	NN
38430	1217	30	to	to	TO
38430	1217	31	wash	wash	VB
38430	1217	32	the	the	DT
38430	1217	33	things	thing	NNS
38430	1217	34	between	between	IN
38430	1217	35	whiles	while	NNS
38430	1217	36	.	.	.
38430	1217	37	'	'	''
38430	1218	1	"	"	``
38430	1218	2	'	'	``
38430	1218	3	Then	then	RB
38430	1218	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1218	5	keep	keep	VBP
38430	1218	6	moving	move	VBG
38430	1218	7	round	round	RB
38430	1218	8	,	,	,
38430	1218	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1218	10	suppose	suppose	VBP
38430	1218	11	?	?	.
38430	1218	12	'	'	''
38430	1219	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1219	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1219	3	.	.	.
38430	1220	1	"	"	``
38430	1220	2	'	'	``
38430	1220	3	Exactly	exactly	RB
38430	1220	4	so	so	RB
38430	1220	5	,	,	,
38430	1220	6	'	'	''
38430	1220	7	said	say	VBD
38430	1220	8	the	the	DT
38430	1220	9	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1220	10	:	:	:
38430	1220	11	'	'	''
38430	1220	12	as	as	IN
38430	1220	13	the	the	DT
38430	1220	14	things	thing	NNS
38430	1220	15	get	get	VBP
38430	1220	16	used	use	VBN
38430	1220	17	up	up	RP
38430	1220	18	.	.	.
38430	1220	19	'	'	''
38430	1221	1	"	"	``
38430	1221	2	'	'	``
38430	1221	3	But	but	CC
38430	1221	4	what	what	WP
38430	1221	5	happens	happen	VBZ
38430	1221	6	when	when	WRB
38430	1221	7	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1221	8	come	come	VBP
38430	1221	9	to	to	IN
38430	1221	10	the	the	DT
38430	1221	11	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	1221	12	again	again	RB
38430	1221	13	?	?	.
38430	1221	14	'	'	''
38430	1222	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1222	2	ventured	venture	VBD
38430	1222	3	to	to	TO
38430	1222	4	ask	ask	VB
38430	1222	5	.	.	.
38430	1223	1	"	"	``
38430	1223	2	'	'	``
38430	1223	3	Suppose	suppose	VB
38430	1223	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1223	5	change	change	VBP
38430	1223	6	the	the	DT
38430	1223	7	subject	subject	NN
38430	1223	8	,	,	,
38430	1223	9	'	'	''
38430	1223	10	the	the	DT
38430	1223	11	March	March	NNP
38430	1223	12	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1223	13	interrupted	interrupt	VBD
38430	1223	14	,	,	,
38430	1223	15	yawning	yawning	NN
38430	1223	16	.	.	.
38430	1224	1	'	'	``
38430	1224	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1224	3	'm	be	VBP
38430	1224	4	getting	get	VBG
38430	1224	5	tired	tired	JJ
38430	1224	6	of	of	IN
38430	1224	7	this	this	DT
38430	1224	8	.	.	.
38430	1224	9	'	'	''
38430	1224	10	"	"	''
38430	1225	1	*	*	NFP
38430	1225	2	*	*	NFP
38430	1225	3	*	*	NFP
38430	1225	4	*	*	NFP
38430	1225	5	*	*	NFP
38430	1225	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1225	7	A.	a.	NN
38430	1226	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1226	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1226	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1226	4	,	,	,
38430	1226	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1226	6	99	99	CD
38430	1226	7	:	:	:
38430	1226	8	"	"	``
38430	1226	9	'	'	``
38430	1226	10	And	and	CC
38430	1226	11	how	how	WRB
38430	1226	12	many	many	JJ
38430	1226	13	hours	hour	NNS
38430	1226	14	a	a	DT
38430	1226	15	day	day	NN
38430	1226	16	did	do	VBD
38430	1226	17	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1226	18	do	do	VB
38430	1226	19	lessons	lesson	NNS
38430	1226	20	?	?	.
38430	1226	21	'	'	''
38430	1227	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1227	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1227	3	,	,	,
38430	1227	4	in	in	IN
38430	1227	5	a	a	DT
38430	1227	6	hurry	hurry	NN
38430	1227	7	to	to	TO
38430	1227	8	change	change	VB
38430	1227	9	the	the	DT
38430	1227	10	subject	subject	NN
38430	1227	11	.	.	.
38430	1228	1	"	"	``
38430	1228	2	'	'	``
38430	1228	3	Ten	ten	CD
38430	1228	4	hours	hour	NNS
38430	1228	5	the	the	DT
38430	1228	6	first	first	JJ
38430	1228	7	day	day	NN
38430	1228	8	,	,	,
38430	1228	9	'	'	''
38430	1228	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1228	11	the	the	DT
38430	1228	12	Mock	Mock	NNP
38430	1228	13	Turtle	Turtle	NNP
38430	1228	14	,	,	,
38430	1228	15	'	'	''
38430	1228	16	nine	nine	CD
38430	1228	17	the	the	DT
38430	1228	18	next	next	JJ
38430	1228	19	,	,	,
38430	1228	20	and	and	CC
38430	1228	21	so	so	RB
38430	1228	22	on	on	RB
38430	1228	23	.	.	.
38430	1228	24	'	'	''
38430	1229	1	"	"	``
38430	1229	2	'	'	``
38430	1229	3	What	what	WP
38430	1229	4	a	a	DT
38430	1229	5	curious	curious	JJ
38430	1229	6	plan	plan	NN
38430	1229	7	!	!	.
38430	1229	8	'	'	''
38430	1230	1	exclaimed	exclaimed	NNP
38430	1230	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1230	3	.	.	.
38430	1231	1	"	"	``
38430	1231	2	'	'	``
38430	1231	3	That	that	DT
38430	1231	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1231	5	the	the	DT
38430	1231	6	reason	reason	NN
38430	1231	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1231	8	're	be	VBP
38430	1231	9	called	call	VBN
38430	1231	10	lessons	lesson	NNS
38430	1231	11	,	,	,
38430	1231	12	'	'	''
38430	1231	13	the	the	DT
38430	1231	14	Gryphon	Gryphon	NNP
38430	1231	15	remarked	remark	VBD
38430	1231	16	,	,	,
38430	1231	17	'	'	''
38430	1231	18	because	because	IN
38430	1231	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1231	20	lessen	lessen	VBD
38430	1231	21	from	from	IN
38430	1231	22	day	day	NN
38430	1231	23	to	to	IN
38430	1231	24	day	day	NN
38430	1231	25	.	.	.
38430	1231	26	'	'	''
38430	1232	1	"	"	``
38430	1232	2	This	this	DT
38430	1232	3	was	be	VBD
38430	1232	4	quite	quite	PDT
38430	1232	5	a	a	DT
38430	1232	6	new	new	JJ
38430	1232	7	idea	idea	NN
38430	1232	8	to	to	IN
38430	1232	9	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1232	10	,	,	,
38430	1232	11	and	and	CC
38430	1232	12	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1232	13	thought	think	VBD
38430	1232	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1232	15	over	over	IN
38430	1232	16	a	a	DT
38430	1232	17	little	little	JJ
38430	1232	18	before	before	IN
38430	1232	19	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1232	20	made	make	VBD
38430	1232	21	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1232	22	next	next	JJ
38430	1232	23	remark	remark	NN
38430	1232	24	.	.	.
38430	1233	1	'	'	``
38430	1233	2	Then	then	RB
38430	1233	3	the	the	DT
38430	1233	4	eleventh	eleventh	JJ
38430	1233	5	day	day	NN
38430	1233	6	must	must	MD
38430	1233	7	have	have	VB
38430	1233	8	been	be	VBN
38430	1233	9	a	a	DT
38430	1233	10	holiday	holiday	NN
38430	1233	11	.	.	.
38430	1233	12	'	'	''
38430	1234	1	"	"	``
38430	1234	2	'	'	``
38430	1234	3	Of	of	RB
38430	1234	4	course	course	RB
38430	1234	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1234	6	was	be	VBD
38430	1234	7	,	,	,
38430	1234	8	'	'	''
38430	1234	9	said	say	VBD
38430	1234	10	the	the	DT
38430	1234	11	Mock	Mock	NNP
38430	1234	12	Turtle	Turtle	NNP
38430	1234	13	.	.	.
38430	1235	1	"	"	``
38430	1235	2	'	'	``
38430	1235	3	And	and	CC
38430	1235	4	how	how	WRB
38430	1235	5	did	do	VBD
38430	1235	6	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1235	7	manage	manage	VB
38430	1235	8	on	on	IN
38430	1235	9	the	the	DT
38430	1235	10	twelfth	twelfth	NN
38430	1235	11	?	?	.
38430	1235	12	'	'	''
38430	1236	1	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1236	2	went	go	VBD
38430	1236	3	on	on	RB
38430	1236	4	eagerly	eagerly	RB
38430	1236	5	.	.	.
38430	1237	1	"	"	``
38430	1237	2	'	'	``
38430	1237	3	That	that	DT
38430	1237	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1237	5	enough	enough	JJ
38430	1237	6	about	about	IN
38430	1237	7	lessons	lesson	NNS
38430	1237	8	,	,	,
38430	1237	9	'	'	''
38430	1237	10	the	the	DT
38430	1237	11	Gryphon	Gryphon	NNP
38430	1237	12	interrupted	interrupt	VBD
38430	1237	13	in	in	IN
38430	1237	14	a	a	DT
38430	1237	15	very	very	RB
38430	1237	16	decided	decide	VBN
38430	1237	17	tone	tone	NN
38430	1237	18	....	....	NFP
38430	1237	19	"	"	''
38430	1237	20	R.	R.	NNP
38430	1237	21	METHOD	METHOD	NNP
38430	1237	22	IN	in	IN
38430	1237	23	MATHEMATICS	MATHEMATICS	NNP
38430	1237	24	AND	and	CC
38430	1237	25	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1237	26	.	.	.
38430	1238	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1238	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1239	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1239	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1239	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1239	4	,	,	,
38430	1239	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1239	6	71	71	CD
38430	1239	7	:	:	:
38430	1239	8	"	"	``
38430	1239	9	'	'	``
38430	1239	10	Two	two	CD
38430	1239	11	days	day	NNS
38430	1239	12	wrong	wrong	JJ
38430	1239	13	!	!	.
38430	1239	14	'	'	''
38430	1240	1	sighed	sigh	VBD
38430	1240	2	the	the	DT
38430	1240	3	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1240	4	.	.	.
38430	1241	1	'	'	``
38430	1241	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1241	3	told	tell	VBD
38430	1241	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1241	5	butter	butter	NN
38430	1241	6	would	would	MD
38430	1241	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1241	8	suit	suit	VB
38430	1241	9	the	the	DT
38430	1241	10	works	work	NNS
38430	1241	11	!	!	.
38430	1241	12	'	'	''
38430	1242	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1242	2	added	add	VBD
38430	1242	3	,	,	,
38430	1242	4	looking	look	VBG
38430	1242	5	angrily	angrily	RB
38430	1242	6	at	at	IN
38430	1242	7	the	the	DT
38430	1242	8	March	March	NNP
38430	1242	9	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1242	10	.	.	.
38430	1243	1	"	"	``
38430	1243	2	'	'	``
38430	1243	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1243	4	was	be	VBD
38430	1243	5	the	the	DT
38430	1243	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1243	7	best	good	JJS
38430	1243	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1243	9	butter	butter	NN
38430	1243	10	,	,	,
38430	1243	11	'	'	''
38430	1243	12	the	the	DT
38430	1243	13	March	March	NNP
38430	1243	14	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1243	15	meekly	meekly	RB
38430	1243	16	replied	reply	VBD
38430	1243	17	.	.	.
38430	1244	1	"	"	``
38430	1244	2	'	'	``
38430	1244	3	Yes	yes	UH
38430	1244	4	,	,	,
38430	1244	5	but	but	CC
38430	1244	6	some	some	DT
38430	1244	7	crumbs	crumb	NNS
38430	1244	8	must	must	MD
38430	1244	9	have	have	VB
38430	1244	10	got	get	VBN
38430	1244	11	in	in	RP
38430	1244	12	as	as	RB
38430	1244	13	well	well	RB
38430	1244	14	,	,	,
38430	1244	15	'	'	''
38430	1244	16	the	the	DT
38430	1244	17	Hatter	Hatter	NNP
38430	1244	18	grumbled	grumble	VBD
38430	1244	19	;	;	:
38430	1244	20	'	'	''
38430	1244	21	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1244	22	should	should	MD
38430	1244	23	n't	not	RB
38430	1244	24	have	have	VB
38430	1244	25	put	put	VBN
38430	1244	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1244	27	in	in	RP
38430	1244	28	with	with	IN
38430	1244	29	the	the	DT
38430	1244	30	bread	bread	NN
38430	1244	31	-	-	HYPH
38430	1244	32	knife	knife	NN
38430	1244	33	.	.	.
38430	1244	34	'	'	''
38430	1245	1	"	"	``
38430	1245	2	The	the	DT
38430	1245	3	March	March	NNP
38430	1245	4	Hare	Hare	NNP
38430	1245	5	took	take	VBD
38430	1245	6	the	the	DT
38430	1245	7	watch	watch	NN
38430	1245	8	and	and	CC
38430	1245	9	looked	look	VBD
38430	1245	10	at	at	IN
38430	1245	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	12	gloomily	gloomily	RB
38430	1245	13	:	:	:
38430	1245	14	then	then	RB
38430	1245	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	16	dipped	dip	VBD
38430	1245	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	18	into	into	IN
38430	1245	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1245	20	cup	cup	NN
38430	1245	21	of	of	IN
38430	1245	22	tea	tea	NN
38430	1245	23	,	,	,
38430	1245	24	and	and	CC
38430	1245	25	looked	look	VBD
38430	1245	26	at	at	IN
38430	1245	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	28	again	again	RB
38430	1245	29	:	:	:
38430	1245	30	but	but	CC
38430	1245	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	32	could	could	MD
38430	1245	33	think	think	VB
38430	1245	34	of	of	IN
38430	1245	35	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1245	36	better	well	JJR
38430	1245	37	to	to	TO
38430	1245	38	say	say	VB
38430	1245	39	than	than	IN
38430	1245	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1245	41	first	first	JJ
38430	1245	42	remark	remark	NN
38430	1245	43	,	,	,
38430	1245	44	'	'	''
38430	1245	45	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	46	was	be	VBD
38430	1245	47	the	the	DT
38430	1245	48	_	_	NNP
38430	1245	49	best	good	JJS
38430	1245	50	_	_	NNP
38430	1245	51	butter	butter	NN
38430	1245	52	,	,	,
38430	1245	53	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1245	54	know	know	VBP
38430	1245	55	.	.	.
38430	1245	56	'	'	''
38430	1245	57	"	"	''
38430	1246	1	S.	S.	NNP
38430	1246	2	VERDICT	verdict	NN
38430	1246	3	THAT	that	DT
38430	1246	4	LOGIC	logic	NN
38430	1246	5	IS	be	VBZ
38430	1246	6	PHILOSOPHY	PHILOSOPHY	NNS
38430	1246	7	.	.	.
38430	1247	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1247	2	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1248	1	A.	A.	NNP
38430	1248	2	W.	W.	NNP
38430	1248	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1248	4	,	,	,
38430	1248	5	pp	pp	NNP
38430	1248	6	.	.	.
38430	1249	1	119	119	CD
38430	1249	2	-	-	SYM
38430	1249	3	23	23	CD
38430	1249	4	:	:	:
38430	1249	5	"	"	``
38430	1249	6	...	...	:
38430	1249	7	'	'	''
38430	1249	8	Consider	consider	VB
38430	1249	9	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1249	10	verdict	verdict	NN
38430	1249	11	,	,	,
38430	1249	12	'	'	''
38430	1249	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1249	14	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1249	15	the	the	DT
38430	1249	16	King	King	NNP
38430	1249	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1249	18	said	say	VBD
38430	1249	19	to	to	IN
38430	1249	20	the	the	DT
38430	1249	21	jury	jury	NN
38430	1249	22	,	,	,
38430	1249	23	in	in	IN
38430	1249	24	a	a	DT
38430	1249	25	low	low	JJ
38430	1249	26	trembling	trembling	NN
38430	1249	27	voice	voice	NN
38430	1249	28	.	.	.
38430	1250	1	"	"	``
38430	1250	2	'	'	``
38430	1250	3	There	there	EX
38430	1250	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1250	5	more	more	JJR
38430	1250	6	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	1250	7	to	to	TO
38430	1250	8	come	come	VB
38430	1250	9	yet	yet	RB
38430	1250	10	,	,	,
38430	1250	11	please	please	VB
38430	1250	12	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1250	13	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
38430	1250	14	,	,	,
38430	1250	15	'	'	''
38430	1250	16	said	say	VBD
38430	1250	17	the	the	DT
38430	1250	18	White	White	NNP
38430	1250	19	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1250	20	,	,	,
38430	1250	21	jumping	jump	VBG
38430	1250	22	up	up	RP
38430	1250	23	in	in	IN
38430	1250	24	a	a	DT
38430	1250	25	great	great	JJ
38430	1250	26	hurry	hurry	NN
38430	1250	27	:	:	:
38430	1250	28	'	'	''
38430	1250	29	this	this	DT
38430	1250	30	paper	paper	NN
38430	1250	31	has	have	VBZ
38430	1250	32	just	just	RB
38430	1250	33	been	be	VBN
38430	1250	34	picked	pick	VBN
38430	1250	35	up	up	RP
38430	1250	36	.	.	.
38430	1250	37	'	'	''
38430	1251	1	"	"	``
38430	1251	2	'	'	``
38430	1251	3	What	what	WP
38430	1251	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1251	5	in	in	IN
38430	1251	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1251	7	?	?	.
38430	1251	8	'	'	''
38430	1252	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1252	2	the	the	DT
38430	1252	3	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1252	4	.	.	.
38430	1253	1	"	"	``
38430	1253	2	'	'	``
38430	1253	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1253	4	have	have	VBP
38430	1253	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1253	6	opened	open	VBN
38430	1253	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1253	8	yet	yet	RB
38430	1253	9	,	,	,
38430	1253	10	'	'	''
38430	1253	11	said	say	VBD
38430	1253	12	the	the	DT
38430	1253	13	White	White	NNP
38430	1253	14	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1253	15	,	,	,
38430	1253	16	'	'	''
38430	1253	17	but	but	CC
38430	1253	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1253	19	seems	seem	VBZ
38430	1253	20	to	to	TO
38430	1253	21	be	be	VB
38430	1253	22	a	a	DT
38430	1253	23	letter	letter	NN
38430	1253	24	written	write	VBN
38430	1253	25	by	by	IN
38430	1253	26	the	the	DT
38430	1253	27	prisoner	prisoner	NN
38430	1253	28	to	to	IN
38430	1253	29	--	--	:
38430	1253	30	to	to	IN
38430	1253	31	somebody	somebody	NN
38430	1253	32	.	.	.
38430	1253	33	'	'	''
38430	1254	1	"	"	``
38430	1254	2	'	'	``
38430	1254	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1254	4	must	must	MD
38430	1254	5	have	have	VB
38430	1254	6	been	be	VBN
38430	1254	7	that	that	DT
38430	1254	8	,	,	,
38430	1254	9	'	'	''
38430	1254	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1254	11	the	the	DT
38430	1254	12	King	King	NNP
38430	1254	13	,	,	,
38430	1254	14	'	'	''
38430	1254	15	unless	unless	IN
38430	1254	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1254	17	was	be	VBD
38430	1254	18	written	write	VBN
38430	1254	19	to	to	IN
38430	1254	20	nobody	nobody	NN
38430	1254	21	,	,	,
38430	1254	22	which	which	WDT
38430	1254	23	is	be	VBZ
38430	1254	24	n't	not	RB
38430	1254	25	usual	usual	JJ
38430	1254	26	,	,	,
38430	1254	27	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1254	28	know	know	VBP
38430	1254	29	.	.	.
38430	1254	30	'	'	''
38430	1255	1	"	"	``
38430	1255	2	'	'	``
38430	1255	3	Who	who	WP
38430	1255	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	1255	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1255	6	directed	direct	VBN
38430	1255	7	to	to	IN
38430	1255	8	?	?	.
38430	1255	9	'	'	''
38430	1256	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1256	2	one	one	CD
38430	1256	3	of	of	IN
38430	1256	4	the	the	DT
38430	1256	5	jurymen	juryman	NNS
38430	1256	6	.	.	.
38430	1257	1	"	"	``
38430	1257	2	'	'	``
38430	1257	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1257	4	is	be	VBZ
38430	1257	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1257	6	directed	direct	VBN
38430	1257	7	at	at	RB
38430	1257	8	all	all	RB
38430	1257	9	,	,	,
38430	1257	10	'	'	''
38430	1257	11	said	say	VBD
38430	1257	12	the	the	DT
38430	1257	13	White	White	NNP
38430	1257	14	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1257	15	,	,	,
38430	1257	16	'	'	''
38430	1257	17	in	in	IN
38430	1257	18	fact	fact	NN
38430	1257	19	there	there	EX
38430	1257	20	's	be	VBZ
38430	1257	21	nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1257	22	written	write	VBN
38430	1257	23	on	on	IN
38430	1257	24	the	the	DT
38430	1257	25	_	_	NNP
38430	1257	26	outside	outside	IN
38430	1257	27	_	_	NNP
38430	1257	28	.	.	.
38430	1257	29	'	'	''
38430	1258	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1258	2	unfolded	unfold	VBD
38430	1258	3	the	the	DT
38430	1258	4	paper	paper	NN
38430	1258	5	as	as	IN
38430	1258	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1258	7	spoke	speak	VBD
38430	1258	8	,	,	,
38430	1258	9	and	and	CC
38430	1258	10	added	add	VBD
38430	1258	11	,	,	,
38430	1258	12	'	'	''
38430	1258	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1258	14	is	be	VBZ
38430	1258	15	n't	not	RB
38430	1258	16	a	a	DT
38430	1258	17	letter	letter	NN
38430	1258	18	,	,	,
38430	1258	19	after	after	RB
38430	1258	20	all	all	RB
38430	1258	21	:	:	:
38430	1258	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1258	23	's	be	VBZ
38430	1258	24	a	a	DT
38430	1258	25	set	set	NN
38430	1258	26	of	of	IN
38430	1258	27	verses	verse	NNS
38430	1258	28	.	.	.
38430	1258	29	'	'	''
38430	1259	1	"	"	``
38430	1259	2	'	'	``
38430	1259	3	Are	be	VBP
38430	1259	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1259	5	in	in	IN
38430	1259	6	the	the	DT
38430	1259	7	prisoner	prisoner	NN
38430	1259	8	's	's	POS
38430	1259	9	handwriting	handwriting	NN
38430	1259	10	?	?	.
38430	1259	11	'	'	''
38430	1260	1	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1260	2	another	another	DT
38430	1260	3	of	of	IN
38430	1260	4	the	the	DT
38430	1260	5	jurymen	juryman	NNS
38430	1260	6	.	.	.
38430	1261	1	"	"	``
38430	1261	2	'	'	``
38430	1261	3	No	no	UH
38430	1261	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1261	5	're	be	VBP
38430	1261	6	not	not	RB
38430	1261	7	,	,	,
38430	1261	8	'	'	''
38430	1261	9	said	say	VBD
38430	1261	10	the	the	DT
38430	1261	11	White	White	NNP
38430	1261	12	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1261	13	,	,	,
38430	1261	14	'	'	''
38430	1261	15	and	and	CC
38430	1261	16	that	that	DT
38430	1261	17	's	be	VBZ
38430	1261	18	the	the	DT
38430	1261	19	queerest	queer	JJS
38430	1261	20	thing	thing	NN
38430	1261	21	about	about	IN
38430	1261	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1261	23	.	.	.
38430	1261	24	'	'	''
38430	1262	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1262	2	The	the	DT
38430	1262	3	jury	jury	NN
38430	1262	4	all	all	DT
38430	1262	5	looked	look	VBD
38430	1262	6	puzzled	puzzled	JJ
38430	1262	7	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1262	8	.	.	.
38430	1263	1	"	"	``
38430	1263	2	'	'	``
38430	1263	3	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1263	4	must	must	MD
38430	1263	5	have	have	VB
38430	1263	6	imitated	imitate	VBN
38430	1263	7	somebody	somebody	NN
38430	1263	8	else	else	RB
38430	1263	9	's	's	POS
38430	1263	10	hand	hand	NN
38430	1263	11	,	,	,
38430	1263	12	'	'	''
38430	1263	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1263	14	the	the	DT
38430	1263	15	King	King	NNP
38430	1263	16	.	.	.
38430	1264	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1264	2	The	the	DT
38430	1264	3	jury	jury	NN
38430	1264	4	brightened	brighten	VBD
38430	1264	5	up	up	RP
38430	1264	6	again	again	RB
38430	1264	7	.	.	.
38430	1264	8	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1265	1	"	"	``
38430	1265	2	'	'	``
38430	1265	3	Please	please	UH
38430	1265	4	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1265	5	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
38430	1265	6	,	,	,
38430	1265	7	'	'	''
38430	1265	8	said	say	VBD
38430	1265	9	the	the	DT
38430	1265	10	Knave	Knave	NNP
38430	1265	11	,	,	,
38430	1265	12	'	'	''
38430	1265	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1265	14	did	do	VBD
38430	1265	15	n't	not	RB
38430	1265	16	write	write	VB
38430	1265	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1265	18	,	,	,
38430	1265	19	and	and	CC
38430	1265	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1265	21	ca	can	MD
38430	1265	22	n't	not	RB
38430	1265	23	prove	prove	VB
38430	1265	24	that	that	IN
38430	1265	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1265	26	did	do	VBD
38430	1265	27	:	:	:
38430	1265	28	there	there	EX
38430	1265	29	's	be	VBZ
38430	1265	30	no	no	DT
38430	1265	31	name	name	NN
38430	1265	32	signed	sign	VBN
38430	1265	33	at	at	IN
38430	1265	34	the	the	DT
38430	1265	35	end	end	NN
38430	1265	36	.	.	.
38430	1265	37	'	'	''
38430	1266	1	"	"	``
38430	1266	2	'	'	``
38430	1266	3	If	if	IN
38430	1266	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1266	5	did	do	VBD
38430	1266	6	n't	not	RB
38430	1266	7	sign	sign	VB
38430	1266	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1266	9	,	,	,
38430	1266	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1266	11	the	the	DT
38430	1266	12	King	King	NNP
38430	1266	13	,	,	,
38430	1266	14	that	that	IN
38430	1266	15	only	only	RB
38430	1266	16	makes	make	VBZ
38430	1266	17	the	the	DT
38430	1266	18	matter	matter	NN
38430	1266	19	worse	bad	JJR
38430	1266	20	.	.	.
38430	1267	1	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1267	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1267	3	must	must	MD
38430	1267	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1267	5	have	have	VB
38430	1267	6	meant	mean	VBN
38430	1267	7	some	some	DT
38430	1267	8	mischief	mischief	NN
38430	1267	9	,	,	,
38430	1267	10	or	or	CC
38430	1267	11	else	else	RB
38430	1267	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1267	13	'd	'd	MD
38430	1267	14	have	have	VB
38430	1267	15	signed	sign	VBN
38430	1267	16	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1267	17	name	name	NN
38430	1267	18	like	like	IN
38430	1267	19	an	an	DT
38430	1267	20	honest	honest	JJ
38430	1267	21	man	man	NN
38430	1267	22	.	.	.
38430	1267	23	'	'	''
38430	1268	1	"	"	``
38430	1268	2	There	there	EX
38430	1268	3	was	be	VBD
38430	1268	4	a	a	DT
38430	1268	5	general	general	JJ
38430	1268	6	clapping	clapping	NN
38430	1268	7	of	of	IN
38430	1268	8	hands	hand	NNS
38430	1268	9	at	at	IN
38430	1268	10	this	this	DT
38430	1268	11	:	:	:
38430	1268	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1268	13	was	be	VBD
38430	1268	14	the	the	DT
38430	1268	15	first	first	JJ
38430	1268	16	really	really	RB
38430	1268	17	clever	clever	JJ
38430	1268	18	thing	thing	NN
38430	1268	19	the	the	DT
38430	1268	20	King	King	NNP
38430	1268	21	had	have	VBD
38430	1268	22	said	say	VBN
38430	1268	23	that	that	DT
38430	1268	24	day	day	NN
38430	1268	25	.	.	.
38430	1269	1	"	"	``
38430	1269	2	'	'	``
38430	1269	3	That	that	IN
38430	1269	4	_	_	NNP
38430	1269	5	proves	prove	VBZ
38430	1269	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1269	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1269	8	guilt	guilt	NN
38430	1269	9	,	,	,
38430	1269	10	of	of	IN
38430	1269	11	course	course	NN
38430	1269	12	,	,	,
38430	1269	13	'	'	''
38430	1269	14	said	say	VBD
38430	1269	15	the	the	DT
38430	1269	16	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1269	17	,	,	,
38430	1269	18	'	'	''
38430	1269	19	so	so	RB
38430	1269	20	,	,	,
38430	1269	21	off	off	RP
38430	1269	22	with----	with----	VBZ
38430	1269	23	'	'	''
38430	1269	24	"	"	''
38430	1269	25	'	'	''
38430	1269	26	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1269	27	does	do	VBZ
38430	1269	28	n't	not	RB
38430	1269	29	prove	prove	VB
38430	1269	30	anything	anything	NN
38430	1269	31	of	of	IN
38430	1269	32	the	the	DT
38430	1269	33	sort	sort	NN
38430	1269	34	!	!	.
38430	1269	35	'	'	''
38430	1270	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1270	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1270	3	.	.	.
38430	1271	1	'	'	``
38430	1271	2	Why	why	WRB
38430	1271	3	,	,	,
38430	1271	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1271	5	do	do	VBP
38430	1271	6	n't	not	RB
38430	1271	7	even	even	RB
38430	1271	8	know	know	VB
38430	1271	9	what	what	WP
38430	1271	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1271	11	're	be	VBP
38430	1271	12	about	about	IN
38430	1271	13	!	!	.
38430	1271	14	'	'	''
38430	1272	1	"	"	``
38430	1272	2	'	'	``
38430	1272	3	Read	read	VB
38430	1272	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1272	5	,	,	,
38430	1272	6	'	'	''
38430	1272	7	said	say	VBD
38430	1272	8	the	the	DT
38430	1272	9	King	King	NNP
38430	1272	10	.	.	.
38430	1273	1	"	"	``
38430	1273	2	The	the	DT
38430	1273	3	White	White	NNP
38430	1273	4	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1273	5	put	put	VBD
38430	1273	6	on	on	IN
38430	1273	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1273	8	spectacles	spectacle	NNS
38430	1273	9	.	.	.
38430	1274	1	'	'	``
38430	1274	2	Where	where	WRB
38430	1274	3	shall	shall	MD
38430	1274	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1274	5	begin	begin	VB
38430	1274	6	,	,	,
38430	1274	7	please	please	VB
38430	1274	8	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1274	9	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
38430	1274	10	?	?	.
38430	1274	11	'	'	''
38430	1275	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1275	2	asked	ask	VBD
38430	1275	3	.	.	.
38430	1276	1	"	"	``
38430	1276	2	'	'	``
38430	1276	3	Begin	begin	VB
38430	1276	4	at	at	IN
38430	1276	5	the	the	DT
38430	1276	6	beginning	beginning	NN
38430	1276	7	,	,	,
38430	1276	8	'	'	''
38430	1276	9	the	the	DT
38430	1276	10	King	King	NNP
38430	1276	11	said	say	VBD
38430	1276	12	very	very	RB
38430	1276	13	gravely	gravely	RB
38430	1276	14	,	,	,
38430	1276	15	'	'	''
38430	1276	16	and	and	CC
38430	1276	17	go	go	VB
38430	1276	18	on	on	RP
38430	1276	19	till	till	IN
38430	1276	20	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1276	21	come	come	VBP
38430	1276	22	to	to	IN
38430	1276	23	the	the	DT
38430	1276	24	end	end	NN
38430	1276	25	:	:	:
38430	1276	26	then	then	RB
38430	1276	27	stop	stop	VB
38430	1276	28	.	.	.
38430	1276	29	'	'	''
38430	1277	1	"	"	``
38430	1277	2	There	there	EX
38430	1277	3	was	be	VBD
38430	1277	4	dead	dead	JJ
38430	1277	5	silence	silence	NN
38430	1277	6	in	in	IN
38430	1277	7	the	the	DT
38430	1277	8	court	court	NN
38430	1277	9	,	,	,
38430	1277	10	whilst	whilst	IN
38430	1277	11	the	the	DT
38430	1277	12	White	White	NNP
38430	1277	13	Rabbit	Rabbit	NNP
38430	1277	14	read	read	VBD
38430	1277	15	out	out	RP
38430	1277	16	these	these	DT
38430	1277	17	verses	verse	NNS
38430	1277	18	:	:	:
38430	1277	19	"	"	``
38430	1277	20	'	'	``
38430	1277	21	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	22	They	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	23	told	tell	VBD
38430	1277	24	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	25	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	26	had	have	VBD
38430	1277	27	been	be	VBN
38430	1277	28	to	to	IN
38430	1277	29	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	30	,	,	,
38430	1277	31	And	and	CC
38430	1277	32	mentioned	mention	VBD
38430	1277	33	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	34	to	to	IN
38430	1277	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	36	;	;	:
38430	1277	37	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	38	gave	give	VBD
38430	1277	39	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	40	a	a	DT
38430	1277	41	good	good	JJ
38430	1277	42	character	character	NN
38430	1277	43	,	,	,
38430	1277	44	But	but	CC
38430	1277	45	said	say	VBD
38430	1277	46	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	47	could	could	MD
38430	1277	48	not	not	RB
38430	1277	49	swim	swim	VB
38430	1277	50	.	.	.
38430	1277	51	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	52	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	53	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	54	sent	send	VBD
38430	1277	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	56	word	word	NN
38430	1277	57	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	58	had	have	VBD
38430	1277	59	not	not	RB
38430	1277	60	gone	go	VBN
38430	1277	61	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1277	62	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	63	know	know	VBP
38430	1277	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	65	to	to	TO
38430	1277	66	be	be	VB
38430	1277	67	true	true	JJ
38430	1277	68	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1277	69	:	:	:
38430	1277	70	If	if	IN
38430	1277	71	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	72	should	should	MD
38430	1277	73	push	push	VB
38430	1277	74	the	the	DT
38430	1277	75	matter	matter	NN
38430	1277	76	on	on	RP
38430	1277	77	,	,	,
38430	1277	78	What	what	WP
38430	1277	79	would	would	MD
38430	1277	80	become	become	VB
38430	1277	81	of	of	IN
38430	1277	82	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	83	?	?	.
38430	1277	84	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	85	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	86	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	87	gave	give	VBD
38430	1277	88	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	89	one	one	NN
38430	1277	90	,	,	,
38430	1277	91	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	92	gave	give	VBD
38430	1277	93	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	94	two	two	CD
38430	1277	95	,	,	,
38430	1277	96	You	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	97	gave	give	VBD
38430	1277	98	us	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	99	three	three	CD
38430	1277	100	or	or	CC
38430	1277	101	more	more	JJR
38430	1277	102	;	;	:
38430	1277	103	They	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	104	all	all	DT
38430	1277	105	returned	return	VBD
38430	1277	106	from	from	IN
38430	1277	107	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	108	to	to	IN
38430	1277	109	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	110	,	,	,
38430	1277	111	Though	though	IN
38430	1277	112	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	113	were	be	VBD
38430	1277	114	mine	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	115	before	before	RB
38430	1277	116	.	.	.
38430	1277	117	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	118	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	119	If	if	IN
38430	1277	120	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	121	or	or	CC
38430	1277	122	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	123	should	should	MD
38430	1277	124	chance	chance	VB
38430	1277	125	to	to	TO
38430	1277	126	be	be	VB
38430	1277	127	Involved	involve	VBN
38430	1277	128	in	in	IN
38430	1277	129	this	this	DT
38430	1277	130	affair	affair	NN
38430	1277	131	,	,	,
38430	1277	132	He	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	133	trusts	trust	VBZ
38430	1277	134	to	to	IN
38430	1277	135	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	136	to	to	TO
38430	1277	137	set	set	VB
38430	1277	138	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	139	free	free	JJ
38430	1277	140	Exactly	exactly	RB
38430	1277	141	as	as	IN
38430	1277	142	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	143	were	be	VBD
38430	1277	144	.	.	.
38430	1277	145	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	146	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	147	My	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1277	148	notion	notion	NN
38430	1277	149	was	be	VBD
38430	1277	150	that	that	IN
38430	1277	151	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	152	had	have	VBD
38430	1277	153	been	be	VBN
38430	1277	154	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1277	155	Before	before	IN
38430	1277	156	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	157	had	have	VBD
38430	1277	158	this	this	DT
38430	1277	159	fit	fit	NN
38430	1277	160	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1277	161	An	an	DT
38430	1277	162	obstacle	obstacle	NN
38430	1277	163	that	that	WDT
38430	1277	164	came	come	VBD
38430	1277	165	between	between	IN
38430	1277	166	Him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	167	,	,	,
38430	1277	168	and	and	CC
38430	1277	169	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	170	,	,	,
38430	1277	171	and	and	CC
38430	1277	172	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	173	.	.	.
38430	1277	174	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	175	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	176	Do	do	VBP
38430	1277	177	n't	not	RB
38430	1277	178	let	let	VB
38430	1277	179	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	180	know	know	VB
38430	1277	181	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	182	liked	like	VBD
38430	1277	183	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	184	best	well	RBS
38430	1277	185	,	,	,
38430	1277	186	For	for	IN
38430	1277	187	this	this	DT
38430	1277	188	must	must	MD
38430	1277	189	ever	ever	RB
38430	1277	190	be	be	VB
38430	1277	191	A	a	DT
38430	1277	192	secret	secret	NN
38430	1277	193	kept	keep	VBN
38430	1277	194	from	from	IN
38430	1277	195	all	all	PDT
38430	1277	196	the	the	DT
38430	1277	197	rest	rest	NN
38430	1277	198	,	,	,
38430	1277	199	Between	between	IN
38430	1277	200	yourself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	201	and	and	CC
38430	1277	202	me	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	203	.	.	.
38430	1277	204	_	_	NNP
38430	1277	205	'	'	``
38430	1277	206	"	"	``
38430	1277	207	'	'	``
38430	1277	208	That	that	DT
38430	1277	209	's	be	VBZ
38430	1277	210	the	the	DT
38430	1277	211	most	most	RBS
38430	1277	212	important	important	JJ
38430	1277	213	piece	piece	NN
38430	1277	214	of	of	IN
38430	1277	215	evidence	evidence	NN
38430	1277	216	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	217	've	have	VB
38430	1277	218	heard	hear	VBN
38430	1277	219	yet	yet	RB
38430	1277	220	,	,	,
38430	1277	221	'	'	''
38430	1277	222	said	say	VBD
38430	1277	223	the	the	DT
38430	1277	224	King	King	NNP
38430	1277	225	,	,	,
38430	1277	226	rubbing	rub	VBG
38430	1277	227	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1277	228	hands	hand	NNS
38430	1277	229	,	,	,
38430	1277	230	'	'	''
38430	1277	231	so	so	RB
38430	1277	232	now	now	RB
38430	1277	233	let	let	VB
38430	1277	234	the	the	DT
38430	1277	235	jury----	jury----	NNP
38430	1277	236	'	'	POS
38430	1277	237	"	"	''
38430	1277	238	'	'	``
38430	1277	239	If	if	IN
38430	1277	240	any	any	DT
38430	1277	241	one	one	CD
38430	1277	242	of	of	IN
38430	1277	243	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	244	can	can	MD
38430	1277	245	explain	explain	VB
38430	1277	246	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	247	,	,	,
38430	1277	248	'	'	''
38430	1277	249	said	say	VBD
38430	1277	250	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1277	251	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1277	252	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	253	had	have	VBD
38430	1277	254	grown	grow	VBN
38430	1277	255	so	so	RB
38430	1277	256	large	large	JJ
38430	1277	257	in	in	IN
38430	1277	258	the	the	DT
38430	1277	259	last	last	JJ
38430	1277	260	few	few	JJ
38430	1277	261	minutes	minute	NNS
38430	1277	262	that	that	IN
38430	1277	263	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	264	was	be	VBD
38430	1277	265	n't	not	RB
38430	1277	266	a	a	DT
38430	1277	267	bit	bit	NN
38430	1277	268	afraid	afraid	JJ
38430	1277	269	of	of	IN
38430	1277	270	interrupting	interrupt	VBG
38430	1277	271	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	272	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1277	273	,	,	,
38430	1277	274	'	'	''
38430	1277	275	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	276	'll	will	MD
38430	1277	277	give	give	VB
38430	1277	278	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1277	279	sixpence	sixpence	NN
38430	1277	280	.	.	.
38430	1278	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1278	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1278	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1278	4	do	do	VBP
38430	1278	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1278	6	believe	believe	VB
38430	1278	7	there	there	EX
38430	1278	8	's	be	VBZ
38430	1278	9	an	an	DT
38430	1278	10	atom	atom	NN
38430	1278	11	of	of	IN
38430	1278	12	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	1278	13	in	in	IN
38430	1278	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1278	15	.	.	.
38430	1278	16	'	'	''
38430	1279	1	"	"	``
38430	1279	2	The	the	DT
38430	1279	3	jury	jury	NN
38430	1279	4	all	all	DT
38430	1279	5	wrote	write	VBD
38430	1279	6	down	down	RP
38430	1279	7	on	on	IN
38430	1279	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1279	9	slates	slate	NNS
38430	1279	10	,	,	,
38430	1279	11	'	'	''
38430	1279	12	She	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1279	13	does	do	VBZ
38430	1279	14	n't	not	RB
38430	1279	15	believe	believe	VB
38430	1279	16	there	there	EX
38430	1279	17	's	be	VBZ
38430	1279	18	an	an	DT
38430	1279	19	atom	atom	NN
38430	1279	20	of	of	IN
38430	1279	21	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	1279	22	in	in	IN
38430	1279	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1279	24	,	,	,
38430	1279	25	'	'	''
38430	1279	26	but	but	CC
38430	1279	27	none	none	NN
38430	1279	28	of	of	IN
38430	1279	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1279	30	attempted	attempt	VBD
38430	1279	31	to	to	TO
38430	1279	32	explain	explain	VB
38430	1279	33	the	the	DT
38430	1279	34	paper	paper	NN
38430	1279	35	.	.	.
38430	1280	1	"	"	``
38430	1280	2	'	'	``
38430	1280	3	If	if	IN
38430	1280	4	there	there	EX
38430	1280	5	's	be	VBZ
38430	1280	6	no	no	DT
38430	1280	7	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	1280	8	in	in	IN
38430	1280	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1280	10	,	,	,
38430	1280	11	'	'	''
38430	1280	12	said	say	VBD
38430	1280	13	the	the	DT
38430	1280	14	King	King	NNP
38430	1280	15	,	,	,
38430	1280	16	'	'	''
38430	1280	17	that	that	DT
38430	1280	18	saves	save	VBZ
38430	1280	19	a	a	DT
38430	1280	20	world	world	NN
38430	1280	21	of	of	IN
38430	1280	22	trouble	trouble	NN
38430	1280	23	,	,	,
38430	1280	24	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1280	25	know	know	VBP
38430	1280	26	,	,	,
38430	1280	27	as	as	IN
38430	1280	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1280	29	need	need	VBP
38430	1280	30	n't	not	RB
38430	1280	31	try	try	VB
38430	1280	32	to	to	TO
38430	1280	33	find	find	VB
38430	1280	34	any	any	DT
38430	1280	35	.	.	.
38430	1281	1	And	and	CC
38430	1281	2	yet	yet	RB
38430	1281	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1281	4	do	do	VBP
38430	1281	5	n't	not	RB
38430	1281	6	know	know	VB
38430	1281	7	,	,	,
38430	1281	8	'	'	''
38430	1281	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1281	10	went	go	VBD
38430	1281	11	on	on	RP
38430	1281	12	,	,	,
38430	1281	13	spreading	spread	VBG
38430	1281	14	out	out	RP
38430	1281	15	the	the	DT
38430	1281	16	verses	verse	NNS
38430	1281	17	on	on	IN
38430	1281	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1281	19	knee	knee	NN
38430	1281	20	and	and	CC
38430	1281	21	looking	look	VBG
38430	1281	22	at	at	IN
38430	1281	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1281	24	with	with	IN
38430	1281	25	one	one	CD
38430	1281	26	eye	eye	NN
38430	1281	27	;	;	:
38430	1281	28	'	'	''
38430	1281	29	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1281	30	seem	seem	VBP
38430	1281	31	to	to	TO
38430	1281	32	see	see	VB
38430	1281	33	some	some	DT
38430	1281	34	meaning	meaning	NN
38430	1281	35	in	in	IN
38430	1281	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1281	37	after	after	RB
38430	1281	38	all	all	RB
38430	1281	39	.	.	.
38430	1282	1	"	"	``
38430	1282	2	_	_	NNP
38430	1282	3	--	--	:
38430	1282	4	said	say	VBD
38430	1282	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1282	6	could	could	MD
38430	1282	7	not	not	RB
38430	1282	8	swim	swim	VB
38430	1282	9	_	_	NNP
38430	1282	10	"	"	''
38430	1282	11	;	;	:
38430	1282	12	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1282	13	ca	can	MD
38430	1282	14	n't	not	RB
38430	1282	15	swim	swim	VB
38430	1282	16	,	,	,
38430	1282	17	can	can	MD
38430	1282	18	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1282	19	?	?	.
38430	1282	20	'	'	''
38430	1283	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1283	2	added	add	VBD
38430	1283	3	,	,	,
38430	1283	4	turning	turn	VBG
38430	1283	5	to	to	IN
38430	1283	6	the	the	DT
38430	1283	7	Knave	Knave	NNP
38430	1283	8	.	.	.
38430	1284	1	"	"	``
38430	1284	2	The	the	DT
38430	1284	3	Knave	Knave	NNP
38430	1284	4	shook	shake	VBD
38430	1284	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1284	6	head	head	NN
38430	1284	7	sadly	sadly	RB
38430	1284	8	.	.	.
38430	1285	1	'	'	``
38430	1285	2	Do	do	VBP
38430	1285	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1285	4	look	look	VB
38430	1285	5	like	like	IN
38430	1285	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1285	7	?	?	.
38430	1285	8	'	'	''
38430	1286	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1286	2	said	say	VBD
38430	1286	3	.	.	.
38430	1287	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1287	2	Which	which	WDT
38430	1287	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1287	4	certainly	certainly	RB
38430	1287	5	did	do	VBD
38430	1287	6	_	_	NNP
38430	1287	7	not	not	RB
38430	1287	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1287	9	,	,	,
38430	1287	10	being	be	VBG
38430	1287	11	made	make	VBN
38430	1287	12	entirely	entirely	RB
38430	1287	13	of	of	IN
38430	1287	14	cardboard	cardboard	NN
38430	1287	15	.	.	.
38430	1287	16	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1288	1	"	"	``
38430	1288	2	'	'	``
38430	1288	3	All	all	RB
38430	1288	4	right	right	RB
38430	1288	5	,	,	,
38430	1288	6	so	so	RB
38430	1288	7	far	far	RB
38430	1288	8	,	,	,
38430	1288	9	'	'	''
38430	1288	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1288	11	the	the	DT
38430	1288	12	King	King	NNP
38430	1288	13	;	;	:
38430	1288	14	and	and	CC
38430	1288	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	16	went	go	VBD
38430	1288	17	on	on	IN
38430	1288	18	muttering	mutter	VBG
38430	1288	19	over	over	IN
38430	1288	20	the	the	DT
38430	1288	21	verses	verse	NNS
38430	1288	22	to	to	IN
38430	1288	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	24	:	:	:
38430	1288	25	'	'	''
38430	1288	26	'	'	``
38430	1288	27	_	_	RB
38430	1288	28	We	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	29	know	know	VBP
38430	1288	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	31	to	to	TO
38430	1288	32	be	be	VB
38430	1288	33	true_'--that	true_'--that	NNP
38430	1288	34	's	be	VBZ
38430	1288	35	the	the	DT
38430	1288	36	jury	jury	NN
38430	1288	37	,	,	,
38430	1288	38	of	of	IN
38430	1288	39	course--'_If	course--'_if	NN
38430	1288	40	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	41	should	should	MD
38430	1288	42	push	push	VB
38430	1288	43	the	the	DT
38430	1288	44	matter	matter	NN
38430	1288	45	on_'--that	on_'--that	RB
38430	1288	46	must	must	MD
38430	1288	47	be	be	VB
38430	1288	48	the	the	DT
38430	1288	49	Queen--'_What	queen--'_what	NN
38430	1288	50	would	would	MD
38430	1288	51	become	become	VB
38430	1288	52	of	of	IN
38430	1288	53	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	54	?	?	.
38430	1288	55	_	_	NNP
38430	1288	56	'	'	''
38430	1288	57	What	what	WP
38430	1288	58	indeed!--'_I	indeed!--'_I	NNP
38430	1288	59	gave	give	VBD
38430	1288	60	her	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	61	one	one	NN
38430	1288	62	,	,	,
38430	1288	63	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	64	gave	give	VBD
38430	1288	65	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	66	two	two	CD
38430	1288	67	!	!	.
38430	1288	68	_	_	NNP
38430	1288	69	'	'	''
38430	1288	70	why	why	WRB
38430	1288	71	,	,	,
38430	1288	72	that	that	DT
38430	1288	73	must	must	MD
38430	1288	74	be	be	VB
38430	1288	75	what	what	WP
38430	1288	76	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	77	did	do	VBD
38430	1288	78	with	with	IN
38430	1288	79	the	the	DT
38430	1288	80	tarts	tart	NNS
38430	1288	81	,	,	,
38430	1288	82	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	83	know----	know----	VBP
38430	1288	84	'	'	''
38430	1288	85	"	"	''
38430	1288	86	'	'	''
38430	1288	87	But	but	CC
38430	1288	88	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	89	goes	go	VBZ
38430	1288	90	on	on	RP
38430	1288	91	,	,	,
38430	1288	92	'	'	''
38430	1288	93	_	_	IN
38430	1288	94	They	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	95	all	all	DT
38430	1288	96	returned	return	VBD
38430	1288	97	from	from	IN
38430	1288	98	him	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	99	to	to	IN
38430	1288	100	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1288	101	_	_	NNP
38430	1288	102	,	,	,
38430	1288	103	'	'	''
38430	1288	104	'	'	''
38430	1288	105	said	say	VBD
38430	1288	106	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1288	107	.	.	.
38430	1289	1	"	"	``
38430	1289	2	'	'	``
38430	1289	3	Why	why	WRB
38430	1289	4	,	,	,
38430	1289	5	there	there	RB
38430	1289	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1289	7	are	be	VBP
38430	1289	8	!	!	.
38430	1289	9	'	'	''
38430	1290	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1290	2	the	the	DT
38430	1290	3	King	King	NNP
38430	1290	4	,	,	,
38430	1290	5	triumphantly	triumphantly	RB
38430	1290	6	pointing	point	VBG
38430	1290	7	to	to	IN
38430	1290	8	the	the	DT
38430	1290	9	tarts	tart	NNS
38430	1290	10	on	on	IN
38430	1290	11	the	the	DT
38430	1290	12	table	table	NN
38430	1290	13	.	.	.
38430	1291	1	'	'	``
38430	1291	2	Nothing	nothing	NN
38430	1291	3	can	can	MD
38430	1291	4	be	be	VB
38430	1291	5	clearer	clear	JJR
38430	1291	6	than	than	IN
38430	1291	7	that	that	DT
38430	1291	8	.	.	.
38430	1292	1	Then	then	RB
38430	1292	2	again--'_Before	again--'_Before	-LRB-
38430	1292	3	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1292	4	had	have	VBD
38430	1292	5	this	this	DT
38430	1292	6	fit_'--you	fit_'--you	WP
38430	1292	7	never	never	RB
38430	1292	8	had	have	VBD
38430	1292	9	fits	fit	NNS
38430	1292	10	,	,	,
38430	1292	11	my	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1292	12	dear	dear	NN
38430	1292	13	,	,	,
38430	1292	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1292	15	think	think	VBP
38430	1292	16	?	?	.
38430	1292	17	'	'	''
38430	1293	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1293	2	said	say	VBD
38430	1293	3	to	to	IN
38430	1293	4	the	the	DT
38430	1293	5	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1293	6	.	.	.
38430	1294	1	"	"	``
38430	1294	2	'	'	``
38430	1294	3	Never	never	RB
38430	1294	4	!	!	.
38430	1294	5	'	'	''
38430	1295	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1295	2	the	the	DT
38430	1295	3	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1295	4	furiously	furiously	RB
38430	1295	5	,	,	,
38430	1295	6	throwing	throw	VBG
38430	1295	7	an	an	DT
38430	1295	8	inkstand	inkstand	NN
38430	1295	9	at	at	IN
38430	1295	10	the	the	DT
38430	1295	11	Lizard	Lizard	NNP
38430	1295	12	as	as	IN
38430	1295	13	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1295	14	spoke	speak	VBD
38430	1295	15	.	.	.
38430	1296	1	(	(	-LRB-
38430	1296	2	The	the	DT
38430	1296	3	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
38430	1296	4	little	little	JJ
38430	1296	5	Bill	Bill	NNP
38430	1296	6	had	have	VBD
38430	1296	7	left	leave	VBN
38430	1296	8	off	off	RP
38430	1296	9	writing	write	VBG
38430	1296	10	on	on	IN
38430	1296	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1296	12	slate	slate	NN
38430	1296	13	with	with	IN
38430	1296	14	one	one	CD
38430	1296	15	finger	finger	NN
38430	1296	16	,	,	,
38430	1296	17	as	as	IN
38430	1296	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1296	19	found	find	VBD
38430	1296	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1296	21	made	make	VBD
38430	1296	22	no	no	DT
38430	1296	23	mark	mark	NN
38430	1296	24	;	;	:
38430	1296	25	but	but	CC
38430	1296	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1296	27	now	now	RB
38430	1296	28	hastily	hastily	RB
38430	1296	29	began	begin	VBD
38430	1296	30	again	again	RB
38430	1296	31	,	,	,
38430	1296	32	using	use	VBG
38430	1296	33	the	the	DT
38430	1296	34	ink	ink	NN
38430	1296	35	that	that	WDT
38430	1296	36	was	be	VBD
38430	1296	37	trickling	trickle	VBG
38430	1296	38	down	down	RP
38430	1296	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1296	40	face	face	NN
38430	1296	41	,	,	,
38430	1296	42	as	as	RB
38430	1296	43	long	long	RB
38430	1296	44	as	as	IN
38430	1296	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1296	46	lasted	last	VBD
38430	1296	47	.	.	.
38430	1296	48	)	)	-RRB-
38430	1297	1	"	"	``
38430	1297	2	'	'	``
38430	1297	3	Then	then	RB
38430	1297	4	the	the	DT
38430	1297	5	words	word	NNS
38430	1297	6	do	do	VBP
38430	1297	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1297	8	_	_	NNP
38430	1297	9	fit	fit	JJ
38430	1297	10	_	_	NNP
38430	1297	11	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1297	12	,	,	,
38430	1297	13	'	'	''
38430	1297	14	said	say	VBD
38430	1297	15	the	the	DT
38430	1297	16	King	King	NNP
38430	1297	17	,	,	,
38430	1297	18	looking	look	VBG
38430	1297	19	round	round	IN
38430	1297	20	the	the	DT
38430	1297	21	court	court	NN
38430	1297	22	with	with	IN
38430	1297	23	a	a	DT
38430	1297	24	smile	smile	NN
38430	1297	25	.	.	.
38430	1298	1	There	there	EX
38430	1298	2	was	be	VBD
38430	1298	3	a	a	DT
38430	1298	4	dead	dead	JJ
38430	1298	5	silence	silence	NN
38430	1298	6	.	.	.
38430	1299	1	"	"	``
38430	1299	2	'	'	``
38430	1299	3	It	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1299	4	's	be	VBZ
38430	1299	5	a	a	DT
38430	1299	6	pun	pun	NN
38430	1299	7	!	!	.
38430	1299	8	'	'	''
38430	1300	1	the	the	DT
38430	1300	2	King	King	NNP
38430	1300	3	added	add	VBD
38430	1300	4	in	in	IN
38430	1300	5	an	an	DT
38430	1300	6	angry	angry	JJ
38430	1300	7	tone	tone	NN
38430	1300	8	,	,	,
38430	1300	9	and	and	CC
38430	1300	10	everybody	everybody	NN
38430	1300	11	laughed	laugh	VBD
38430	1300	12	.	.	.
38430	1301	1	"	"	``
38430	1301	2	'	'	``
38430	1301	3	Let	let	VB
38430	1301	4	the	the	DT
38430	1301	5	jury	jury	NN
38430	1301	6	consider	consider	VB
38430	1301	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1301	8	verdict	verdict	NN
38430	1301	9	,	,	,
38430	1301	10	'	'	''
38430	1301	11	the	the	DT
38430	1301	12	King	King	NNP
38430	1301	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1301	14	,	,	,
38430	1301	15	for	for	IN
38430	1301	16	about	about	RB
38430	1301	17	the	the	DT
38430	1301	18	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
38430	1301	19	time	time	NN
38430	1301	20	that	that	DT
38430	1301	21	day	day	NN
38430	1301	22	.	.	.
38430	1302	1	"	"	``
38430	1302	2	'	'	``
38430	1302	3	No	no	UH
38430	1302	4	,	,	,
38430	1302	5	no	no	UH
38430	1302	6	!	!	.
38430	1302	7	'	'	''
38430	1303	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1303	2	the	the	DT
38430	1303	3	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1303	4	.	.	.
38430	1304	1	'	'	``
38430	1304	2	Sentence	sentence	NN
38430	1304	3	first	first	RB
38430	1304	4	--	--	:
38430	1304	5	verdict	verdict	NN
38430	1304	6	afterwards	afterwards	RB
38430	1304	7	.	.	.
38430	1304	8	'	'	''
38430	1305	1	"	"	``
38430	1305	2	'	'	``
38430	1305	3	Stuff	stuff	NN
38430	1305	4	and	and	CC
38430	1305	5	nonsense	nonsense	NN
38430	1305	6	!	!	.
38430	1305	7	'	'	''
38430	1306	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1306	2	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1306	3	loudly	loudly	RB
38430	1306	4	.	.	.
38430	1307	1	'	'	``
38430	1307	2	The	the	DT
38430	1307	3	idea	idea	NN
38430	1307	4	of	of	IN
38430	1307	5	having	have	VBG
38430	1307	6	the	the	DT
38430	1307	7	sentence	sentence	NN
38430	1307	8	first	first	RB
38430	1307	9	!	!	.
38430	1307	10	'	'	''
38430	1308	1	"	"	``
38430	1308	2	'	'	``
38430	1308	3	Hold	hold	VB
38430	1308	4	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1308	5	tongue	tongue	NN
38430	1308	6	!	!	.
38430	1308	7	'	'	''
38430	1309	1	said	say	VBD
38430	1309	2	the	the	DT
38430	1309	3	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1309	4	,	,	,
38430	1309	5	turning	turn	VBG
38430	1309	6	purple	purple	NN
38430	1309	7	....	....	.
38430	1309	8	"	"	''
38430	1309	9	T.	t.	NN
38430	1310	1	"	"	``
38430	1310	2	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	GEDANKENEXPERIMENTE	NNP
38430	1310	3	.	.	.
38430	1310	4	"	"	''
38430	1311	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1311	2	T.	T.	NNP
38430	1312	1	L.	L.	NNP
38430	1312	2	G.	G.	NNP
38430	1312	3	_	_	NNP
38430	1312	4	,	,	,
38430	1312	5	p.	p.	NN
38430	1312	6	61	61	CD
38430	1312	7	:	:	:
38430	1312	8	"	"	``
38430	1312	9	Alice	Alice	NNP
38430	1312	10	laughed	laugh	VBD
38430	1312	11	.	.	.
38430	1313	1	'	'	``
38430	1313	2	There	there	EX
38430	1313	3	's	be	VBZ
38430	1313	4	no	no	DT
38430	1313	5	use	use	NN
38430	1313	6	trying	try	VBG
38430	1313	7	,	,	,
38430	1313	8	'	'	''
38430	1313	9	she	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1313	10	said	say	VBD
38430	1313	11	:	:	:
38430	1313	12	'	'	``
38430	1313	13	one	one	CD
38430	1313	14	_	_	NNP
38430	1313	15	ca	can	MD
38430	1313	16	n't	not	RB
38430	1313	17	_	_	NNP
38430	1313	18	believe	believe	VB
38430	1313	19	impossible	impossible	JJ
38430	1313	20	things	thing	NNS
38430	1313	21	.	.	.
38430	1313	22	'	'	''
38430	1314	1	"	"	``
38430	1314	2	'	'	``
38430	1314	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1314	4	daresay	daresay	VBP
38430	1314	5	you	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1314	6	have	have	VBP
38430	1314	7	n't	not	RB
38430	1314	8	had	have	VBN
38430	1314	9	much	much	JJ
38430	1314	10	practice	practice	NN
38430	1314	11	,	,	,
38430	1314	12	'	'	''
38430	1314	13	said	say	VBD
38430	1314	14	the	the	DT
38430	1314	15	[	[	-LRB-
38430	1314	16	White	White	NNP
38430	1314	17	]	]	-RRB-
38430	1314	18	Queen	Queen	NNP
38430	1314	19	.	.	.
38430	1315	1	'	'	``
38430	1315	2	When	when	WRB
38430	1315	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1315	4	was	be	VBD
38430	1315	5	your	-PRON-	PRP$
38430	1315	6	age	age	NN
38430	1315	7	,	,	,
38430	1315	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1315	9	always	always	RB
38430	1315	10	did	do	VBD
38430	1315	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1315	12	for	for	IN
38430	1315	13	half	half	PDT
38430	1315	14	-	-	HYPH
38430	1315	15	an	an	DT
38430	1315	16	-	-	HYPH
38430	1315	17	hour	hour	NN
38430	1315	18	a	a	DT
38430	1315	19	day	day	NN
38430	1315	20	.	.	.
38430	1316	1	Why	why	WRB
38430	1316	2	,	,	,
38430	1316	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
38430	1316	4	I	-PRON-	PRP
38430	1316	5	've	have	VB
38430	1316	6	believed	believe	VBN
38430	1316	7	as	as	RB
38430	1316	8	many	many	JJ
38430	1316	9	as	as	IN
38430	1316	10	six	six	CD
38430	1316	11	impossible	impossible	JJ
38430	1316	12	things	thing	NNS
38430	1316	13	before	before	IN
38430	1316	14	breakfast	breakfast	NN
38430	1316	15	.	.	.
38430	1316	16	'	'	''
38430	1316	17	"	"	''
38430	1317	1	_	_	NNP
38430	1317	2	Printed	Printed	NNP
38430	1317	3	in	in	IN
38430	1317	4	Great	Great	NNP
38430	1317	5	Britain	Britain	NNP
38430	1317	6	by	by	IN
38430	1317	7	_	_	NNP
38430	1317	8	UNWIN	UNWIN	NNP
38430	1317	9	BROTHERS	BROTHERS	NNPS
38430	1317	10	,	,	,
38430	1317	11	LIMITED	LIMITED	NNP
38430	1317	12	,	,	,
38430	1317	13	THE	the	DT
38430	1317	14	GRESHAM	GRESHAM	NNP
38430	1317	15	PRESS	PRESS	NNP
38430	1317	16	,	,	,
38430	1317	17	WOKING	WOKING	NNP
38430	1317	18	AND	and	CC
38430	1317	19	LONDON	LONDON	NNP