id sid tid token lemma pos WOS-000476239500001 1 1 objective objective ADJ WOS-000476239500001 1 2 we we PRON WOS-000476239500001 1 3 compare compare VERB WOS-000476239500001 1 4 academic academic ADJ WOS-000476239500001 1 5 achievement achievement NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 6 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 7 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 8 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 9 versus versus ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 10 two two NUM WOS-000476239500001 1 11 types type NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 12 of of ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 13 traditional traditional ADJ WOS-000476239500001 1 14 public public ADJ WOS-000476239500001 1 15 school school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 16 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 17 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 1 18 state state NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 19 of of ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 20 michigan michigan PROPN WOS-000476239500001 1 21 over over ADP WOS-000476239500001 1 22 a a DET WOS-000476239500001 1 23 10 10 NUM WOS-000476239500001 1 24 - - PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 1 25 year year NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 26 period period NOUN WOS-000476239500001 1 27 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 2 1 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 2 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 3 serve serve VERB WOS-000476239500001 2 4 as as ADP WOS-000476239500001 2 5 a a DET WOS-000476239500001 2 6 reform reform NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 7 measure measure NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 8 for for ADP WOS-000476239500001 2 9 failing fail VERB WOS-000476239500001 2 10 public public ADJ WOS-000476239500001 2 11 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 12 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 2 13 so so SCONJ WOS-000476239500001 2 14 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 2 15 natural natural ADJ WOS-000476239500001 2 16 research research NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 17 question question NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 18 is be AUX WOS-000476239500001 2 19 : : PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 2 20 do do AUX WOS-000476239500001 2 21 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 22 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 23 generate generate VERB WOS-000476239500001 2 24 higher high ADJ WOS-000476239500001 2 25 achievement achievement NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 26 levels level NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 27 than than ADP WOS-000476239500001 2 28 observationally observationally ADV WOS-000476239500001 2 29 comparable comparable ADJ WOS-000476239500001 2 30 public public ADJ WOS-000476239500001 2 31 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 2 32 ? ? PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 3 1 methods method NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 2 we we PRON WOS-000476239500001 3 3 have have AUX WOS-000476239500001 3 4 assembled assemble VERB WOS-000476239500001 3 5 a a DET WOS-000476239500001 3 6 longitudinal longitudinal ADJ WOS-000476239500001 3 7 data datum NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 8 set set VERB WOS-000476239500001 3 9 spanning span VERB WOS-000476239500001 3 10 academic academic ADJ WOS-000476239500001 3 11 years year NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 12 2002/2003 2002/2003 NUM WOS-000476239500001 3 13 - - SYM WOS-000476239500001 3 14 2011/2012 2011/2012 NUM WOS-000476239500001 3 15 containing contain VERB WOS-000476239500001 3 16 proficiency proficiency NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 17 rates rate NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 18 on on ADP WOS-000476239500001 3 19 standardized standardized ADJ WOS-000476239500001 3 20 math math NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 21 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 3 22 reading read VERB WOS-000476239500001 3 23 tests test NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 24 for for ADP WOS-000476239500001 3 25 grades grade NOUN WOS-000476239500001 3 26 4 4 NUM WOS-000476239500001 3 27 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 3 28 7 7 NUM WOS-000476239500001 3 29 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 3 30 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 3 31 11 11 NUM WOS-000476239500001 3 32 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 4 1 our our PRON WOS-000476239500001 4 2 set set NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 3 of of ADP WOS-000476239500001 4 4 control control NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 5 variables variable NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 6 includes include VERB WOS-000476239500001 4 7 demographic demographic ADJ WOS-000476239500001 4 8 measures measure NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 9 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 4 10 free free ADJ WOS-000476239500001 4 11 lunch lunch NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 12 eligibility eligibility NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 13 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 4 14 school school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 15 characteristics characteristic NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 16 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 4 17 funding funding NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 18 per per ADP WOS-000476239500001 4 19 student student NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 20 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 4 21 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 4 22 locational locational ADJ WOS-000476239500001 4 23 measures measure NOUN WOS-000476239500001 4 24 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 5 1 we we PRON WOS-000476239500001 5 2 model model VERB WOS-000476239500001 5 3 unobserved unobserved ADJ WOS-000476239500001 5 4 heterogeneity heterogeneity NOUN WOS-000476239500001 5 5 using use VERB WOS-000476239500001 5 6 random random ADJ WOS-000476239500001 5 7 effects effect NOUN WOS-000476239500001 5 8 estimation estimation NOUN WOS-000476239500001 5 9 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 6 1 results result NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 2 we we PRON WOS-000476239500001 6 3 find find VERB WOS-000476239500001 6 4 that that SCONJ WOS-000476239500001 6 5 michigan michigan PROPN WOS-000476239500001 6 6 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 7 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 8 significantly significantly ADV WOS-000476239500001 6 9 underperform underperform VERB WOS-000476239500001 6 10 traditional traditional ADJ WOS-000476239500001 6 11 public public ADJ WOS-000476239500001 6 12 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 13 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 6 14 both both DET WOS-000476239500001 6 15 subjects subject NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 16 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 6 17 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 6 18 all all DET WOS-000476239500001 6 19 three three NUM WOS-000476239500001 6 20 grade grade NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 21 levels level NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 22 early early ADV WOS-000476239500001 6 23 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 6 24 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 6 25 study study NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 26 period period NOUN WOS-000476239500001 6 27 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 7 1 these these DET WOS-000476239500001 7 2 gaps gap NOUN WOS-000476239500001 7 3 narrow narrow ADJ WOS-000476239500001 7 4 considerably considerably ADV WOS-000476239500001 7 5 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 7 6 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 7 7 in in ADP WOS-000476239500001 7 8 some some DET WOS-000476239500001 7 9 cases case NOUN WOS-000476239500001 7 10 disappear disappear VERB WOS-000476239500001 7 11 , , PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 7 12 by by ADP WOS-000476239500001 7 13 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 7 14 end end NOUN WOS-000476239500001 7 15 of of ADP WOS-000476239500001 7 16 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 7 17 period period NOUN WOS-000476239500001 7 18 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 8 1 conclusion conclusion NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 2 michigan michigan PROPN WOS-000476239500001 8 3 is be AUX WOS-000476239500001 8 4 noteworthy noteworthy ADJ WOS-000476239500001 8 5 among among ADP WOS-000476239500001 8 6 states state NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 7 with with ADP WOS-000476239500001 8 8 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 9 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 10 for for ADP WOS-000476239500001 8 11 its its PRON WOS-000476239500001 8 12 deregulated deregulated ADJ WOS-000476239500001 8 13 and and CCONJ WOS-000476239500001 8 14 competitive competitive ADJ WOS-000476239500001 8 15 charter charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 16 environment environment NOUN WOS-000476239500001 8 17 . . PUNCT WOS-000476239500001 9 1 our our PRON WOS-000476239500001 9 2 results result NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 3 suggest suggest VERB WOS-000476239500001 9 4 that that SCONJ WOS-000476239500001 9 5 michigan michigan PROPN WOS-000476239500001 9 6 charters charter NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 7 nevertheless nevertheless ADV WOS-000476239500001 9 8 were be AUX WOS-000476239500001 9 9 doing do VERB WOS-000476239500001 9 10 about about ADP WOS-000476239500001 9 11 as as ADV WOS-000476239500001 9 12 well well ADV WOS-000476239500001 9 13 on on ADP WOS-000476239500001 9 14 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 9 15 state state NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 16 's 's PART WOS-000476239500001 9 17 academic academic ADJ WOS-000476239500001 9 18 achievement achievement NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 19 tests test VERB WOS-000476239500001 9 20 as as ADP WOS-000476239500001 9 21 observationally observationally ADV WOS-000476239500001 9 22 comparable comparable ADJ WOS-000476239500001 9 23 public public ADJ WOS-000476239500001 9 24 schools school NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 25 by by ADP WOS-000476239500001 9 26 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 9 27 end end NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 28 of of ADP WOS-000476239500001 9 29 the the DET WOS-000476239500001 9 30 period period NOUN WOS-000476239500001 9 31 . . PUNCT