id sid tid token lemma pos WOS-000234792900004 1 1 over over ADP WOS-000234792900004 1 2 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 1 3 past past ADJ WOS-000234792900004 1 4 fifteen fifteen NUM WOS-000234792900004 1 5 years year NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 6 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 1 7 public public ADJ WOS-000234792900004 1 8 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 9 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 10 have have AUX WOS-000234792900004 1 11 emerged emerge VERB WOS-000234792900004 1 12 as as ADP WOS-000234792900004 1 13 an an DET WOS-000234792900004 1 14 influential influential ADJ WOS-000234792900004 1 15 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 1 16 if if SCONJ WOS-000234792900004 1 17 controversial controversial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 1 18 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 1 19 school school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 20 choice choice NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 21 model model NOUN WOS-000234792900004 1 22 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 2 1 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 2 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 3 seek seek VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 4 to to PART WOS-000234792900004 2 5 reform reform VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 6 america america PROPN WOS-000234792900004 2 7 's 's PART WOS-000234792900004 2 8 underperforming underperform VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 9 public public ADJ WOS-000234792900004 2 10 education education NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 11 system system NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 12 by by ADP WOS-000234792900004 2 13 stimulating stimulate VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 14 curricular curricular ADJ WOS-000234792900004 2 15 innovation innovation NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 16 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 2 17 increasing increase VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 18 parental parental ADJ WOS-000234792900004 2 19 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 2 20 community community NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 21 involvement involvement NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 22 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 2 23 education education NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 24 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 2 25 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 2 26 competing compete VERB WOS-000234792900004 2 27 with with ADP WOS-000234792900004 2 28 traditional traditional ADJ WOS-000234792900004 2 29 public public ADJ WOS-000234792900004 2 30 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 2 31 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 3 1 however however ADV WOS-000234792900004 3 2 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 3 3 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 4 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 5 experience experience VERB WOS-000234792900004 3 6 intense intense ADJ WOS-000234792900004 3 7 levels level NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 8 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 3 9 segregation segregation NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 10 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 3 11 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 3 12 isolation isolation NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 13 that that PRON WOS-000234792900004 3 14 exceed exceed VERB WOS-000234792900004 3 15 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 3 16 already already ADV WOS-000234792900004 3 17 troubling troubling ADJ WOS-000234792900004 3 18 levels level NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 19 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 3 20 traditional traditional ADJ WOS-000234792900004 3 21 public public ADJ WOS-000234792900004 3 22 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 3 23 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 4 1 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 4 2 response response NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 3 to to ADP WOS-000234792900004 4 4 this this DET WOS-000234792900004 4 5 trend trend NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 6 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 4 7 eleven eleven NUM WOS-000234792900004 4 8 states state NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 9 have have AUX WOS-000234792900004 4 10 enacted enact VERB WOS-000234792900004 4 11 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 4 12 balancing balance VERB WOS-000234792900004 4 13 statutes statute NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 14 that that PRON WOS-000234792900004 4 15 require require VERB WOS-000234792900004 4 16 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 17 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 18 to to PART WOS-000234792900004 4 19 use use VERB WOS-000234792900004 4 20 race race NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 21 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 4 22 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 4 23 classifications classification NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 24 to to PART WOS-000234792900004 4 25 achieve achieve VERB WOS-000234792900004 4 26 racially racially ADV WOS-000234792900004 4 27 diverse diverse ADJ WOS-000234792900004 4 28 student student NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 29 bodies body NOUN WOS-000234792900004 4 30 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 5 1 this this DET WOS-000234792900004 5 2 note note NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 3 appraises appraise VERB WOS-000234792900004 5 4 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 5 5 constitutionality constitutionality NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 6 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 7 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 8 school school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 9 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 5 10 balancing balancing NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 11 laws law NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 12 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 13 light light NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 14 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 15 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 5 16 supreme supreme PROPN WOS-000234792900004 5 17 court court PROPN WOS-000234792900004 5 18 's 's PART WOS-000234792900004 5 19 holding holding NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 20 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 21 grutter grutter PROPN WOS-000234792900004 5 22 v. v. ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 23 bollinger bollinger PROPN WOS-000234792900004 5 24 that that SCONJ WOS-000234792900004 5 25 diversity diversity NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 26 is be AUX WOS-000234792900004 5 27 a a DET WOS-000234792900004 5 28 compelling compelling ADJ WOS-000234792900004 5 29 interest interest NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 30 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 5 31 higher high ADJ WOS-000234792900004 5 32 education education NOUN WOS-000234792900004 5 33 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 1 careful careful ADJ WOS-000234792900004 6 2 examination examination NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 3 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 6 4 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 5 school school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 6 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 6 7 balancing balancing NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 8 provisions provision NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 9 reveals reveal VERB WOS-000234792900004 6 10 that that SCONJ WOS-000234792900004 6 11 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 12 on on ADP WOS-000234792900004 6 13 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 6 14 basis basis NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 15 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 6 16 their their PRON WOS-000234792900004 6 17 characteristics characteristic NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 18 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 19 these these DET WOS-000234792900004 6 20 laws law NOUN WOS-000234792900004 6 21 are be AUX WOS-000234792900004 6 22 either either CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 6 23 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 24 strong strong ADJ WOS-000234792900004 6 25 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 26 or or CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 6 27 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 28 weak weak ADJ WOS-000234792900004 6 29 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 6 30 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 7 1 although although SCONJ WOS-000234792900004 7 2 all all DET WOS-000234792900004 7 3 eleven eleven NUM WOS-000234792900004 7 4 states state NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 5 that that PRON WOS-000234792900004 7 6 mandate mandate VERB WOS-000234792900004 7 7 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 7 8 balancing balancing NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 9 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 7 10 charter charter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 11 schools school NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 12 possess possess VERB WOS-000234792900004 7 13 a a DET WOS-000234792900004 7 14 constitutionally constitutionally ADV WOS-000234792900004 7 15 compelling compelling ADJ WOS-000234792900004 7 16 interest interest NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 17 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 7 18 diversity diversity NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 19 as as SCONJ WOS-000234792900004 7 20 articulated articulate VERB WOS-000234792900004 7 21 in in ADP WOS-000234792900004 7 22 grutter grutter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 23 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 7 24 only only ADV WOS-000234792900004 7 25 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 7 26 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 7 27 weak weak ADJ WOS-000234792900004 7 28 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 7 29 provisions provision NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 30 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 7 31 nine nine NUM WOS-000234792900004 7 32 states state NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 33 are be AUX WOS-000234792900004 7 34 sufficiently sufficiently ADV WOS-000234792900004 7 35 narrowly narrowly ADV WOS-000234792900004 7 36 tailored tailor VERB WOS-000234792900004 7 37 to to PART WOS-000234792900004 7 38 survive survive VERB WOS-000234792900004 7 39 strict strict ADJ WOS-000234792900004 7 40 scrutiny scrutiny NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 41 equal equal ADJ WOS-000234792900004 7 42 protection protection NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 43 analysis analysis NOUN WOS-000234792900004 7 44 . . PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 1 consequently consequently ADV WOS-000234792900004 8 2 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 3 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 8 4 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 5 strong",racial strong",racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 6 balancing balancing NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 7 provisions provision NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 8 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 8 9 nevada nevada PROPN WOS-000234792900004 8 10 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 8 11 south south PROPN WOS-000234792900004 8 12 carolina carolina PROPN WOS-000234792900004 8 13 should should AUX WOS-000234792900004 8 14 be be AUX WOS-000234792900004 8 15 rejected reject VERB WOS-000234792900004 8 16 as as ADP WOS-000234792900004 8 17 unconstitutional unconstitutional ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 18 , , PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 19 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 8 20 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 8 21 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 22 weak weak ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 23 " " PUNCT WOS-000234792900004 8 24 racial racial ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 25 balancing balance VERB WOS-000234792900004 8 26 provisions provision NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 27 of of ADP WOS-000234792900004 8 28 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 8 29 remaining remain VERB WOS-000234792900004 8 30 nine nine NUM WOS-000234792900004 8 31 states state NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 32 should should AUX WOS-000234792900004 8 33 be be AUX WOS-000234792900004 8 34 affirmed affirm VERB WOS-000234792900004 8 35 as as ADP WOS-000234792900004 8 36 constitutional constitutional ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 37 under under ADP WOS-000234792900004 8 38 grutter grutter NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 39 and and CCONJ WOS-000234792900004 8 40 the the DET WOS-000234792900004 8 41 fourteenth fourteenth ADJ WOS-000234792900004 8 42 amendment amendment NOUN WOS-000234792900004 8 43 . . PUNCT